In Camera Affidavit of Eugene F. Yeates, CAUS v. NSA, Civil Action No. 80-1562 (9 October 1980) Eugene F. Yeates, Chief, Office of Policy, National Security Agency, 1980 US Government work — public domain. Declassified TOP SECRET affidavit (released 2009) justifying NSA’s withholding of 156 COMINT UFO reports. 21 pages; still-redacted portions noted in text. Transcription source: governmentattic.org (National Security Agency MDR release) ================================================================ NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY CENTRAL SECURITY SERVICE FORT GEORGE G. MEADE, MARYLAND 20755-6000 Serial: MDR-4 7423 07 April 2009 This responds to your request and subsequent appeal to the Interagency Security Classification Appeals Panel (ISCAP) to have one document entitled: • In Camera Mfidavit of Eugene F. Yeates, Civil Action No. 8-1562, 9 Oct 80, U. S. District Court for the District of Columbia in the Case of Citizens Against Unidentified Flying Objects Secrecy vs. NSA reviewed for declassification. The document has been reviewed under the Mandatory Declassification Review (MDR) requirements of Executive Order (E.O.) 12958, as amended. The document listed above has been reviewed and is enclosed. The IS CAP has determined that some of the information in the document is properly classified in accordance with E.O. 12958, as amended. The information denied meets the criteria for classification as set forth in Section 3.3 subparagraphs (b)(l) and (b)(3)and remains classified TOP SECRET as provided in Section 1.2 of E.O. 12958, as amended. Sincerely, KEMLYN K. BRAZDA Acting Chief Declassification Services Encl: als / DECLASSIFIED UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE INTERAGENCY SECURITY CLASSIFICATION APPEALS PANEL, E.O.1Z958, AS AMENDED, SECTION 5.3(b)(3) DOC:ID: 2768909 ISCAP NO. 7-0 0 6 - 0 I ( ,....--- ,--, ,-- Ui\~8RA .. .,.--,.- '- ,- UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CITIZENS AGAINST UNIDENTIFIED FLYING OBJECTS SECRECY, Plaintiff, v. Civil Action No. 80-1562 NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY, Defendant. IN CAMERA AFFIDAVIT OF EUGENE F. YEATES county of Anne Arundel ) . ) ss:. State of Maryland· ) Eugene F. Yeates, being duly sworn, deposes and says: 1. (U) I am the Chief, Office of Policy, of the National Se,curity Agency (NSA). As Chief, Office of Policy, J: am responsiQle for processing all initial requests made pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) forNSA records.. The statements herein are based upon pe,:,sonal knowledge, up.on my personal review of information available to me in my official .capaci ty, and upon conclusions reached in accordance therewi th. 2. (0) This afH'davit supplements my unclassified affidavit executed on September 30, 1980 regarding' all documents which have been located by NSA pursuant to plain~iff's FOIA request but Which have been withheld wholly ot in part by NSA. .1 submit this affidavit in camera for the purpose of stating facts, which cannot be publicly disclosed, that are the basis for exempting· the records from release to the plaintiff. 3. fS eee) At the beginning of each parag.raph of this affidavit, the let~er or letters within parentheses designate(s) the degree of sensitivity of information the paragraph contains. DOCID: 2798909 The letters "0", "c", MS· and "TS" indicate respectively that the information is .unclassified or is classified CONFIDENTIAL, SECRET or TOP SECRET. The symbols "(SC)" and "(TSel" stand for "SECRET CODEWORD" and "TOP SECRET CODEWORD", respectively. "CODEWORD" re~ers to one of the distinctive five-letter words used to identify the source of the information as communications intelligence (COMINT), to distinguish between COMINT categories and ·sub-categories, and to facilitate the application of regula- tions for the dissemination and use of COM.INT. The codeword "UKE\RA- appearing in .conjunction with the TOP SECRET classifica- tion at the top and bottom of each page of this affidavit, 15 the codeword applicable to Category III (the highest category) COHINT~Documents revealing sens{tive details abo!,1t the pro':" . ductioD of COHINT must bear the" classification and codeword. appropriate to the highest category or sub-category of COMINT to whIch they relate, even though they may nQt contain ·COMINT as such. The symbol "ceo·, which stands for the caveat -HANJ;>LE . . . ·VIA COMINT CHANNELS ONLY·, is used to designate information related to COMINT or COMINT activities, which, although it does not require codeword protection, must be kept .within COMINT . channels. i.e., dt"sclosed only to persons eligible to receive COMINT itself. THE RELEVANT DOCUMENTS 4. ~ In processing the plaintiff's FOIA request, a total of two hundred ana thirty-nine documents were located in NSA files. Seventy-nine of these documents originated with other government agencies and have been referred. by NSA to those agencies for their direct response to the plaintiff. One document, which I. addressed in paragraph 20c of my public· affidavit, was erroneously treated as part of the subject matter of plaintiff's FOIA request. It is an account by a person 2 DOCID: 2768909 assigned to -NSA of his attenda.nce at a UFO symposium and it cannot fairly be said to be a record of the kind sought by the plaintiff. Another document, discussed in paragraph 20d of my public affidavit, was recently declassified and released to plaintiff. Two additional non-COHINT records have been released to the plaintiff with the exempted material de.leted. The deletions in these documents are explained below:_ a. A document entitled UFO HYEothesis and Survival Qy~sti0M was released to the plaintiff wi th the deletion on- page seven.of the name of the employee who prepared the draft and a dele-tion of a reference_ to his NSA component. As '[ explained in paragraph. 20, sub-paragraph a, of my open affidavi t .. information a.bout NSA' s organization or emploYees is protected from disclosure by Public Law 86-36 and, therefore, exempt pursuant to 5 U.S.C. S552(b}(3). . - bo_ ,.he second non-COHINT document is a three page undated .. -unofficial draft of· a -monograph with a- four page appendix by the same agency employee who authored the draft referenced in sub-paragraph a, above.. This document was discussed in paragraph.20b of my public affidavit. It is entitled tlFO'S ana the Ipt.elligence C~.m!!!unitYBlind sPOt_to Surprise or De.ceptive Q!'!!!. In this document, the author discusses what he considers to be a serious shortcoming In the - . Agency's .COHINT interception and reporting procedures -- the iriability to respond correctly to surprising information or deliberately deceptive data. He uses the-OFO phenomena to illustrate his belief that the inability of the U.S. intelli- gence community to process this type of unusual data adversely affects u.s. intelligence gathering capabilities. Deletions in· this document were made as follows: (I) All of th~ title after UFO, which addresses the perceived Shortcoming, and all of paragraph one, which discusses the employee's perception of the negative implications. DOC:rD: 2768909 of the handling of OFO pllenomena as it demonstrates what he believes is tile less than optimulll ability of the intelligence cOllllllunity to process and evaluate highly unusual data. As I stated in my public affidavit:. (paragraph 20,b)! the type of candor that is reflected in this record must be, encouraged especially in an intelligence Agency where the most meaningful ~~9gestions regarding ways to promote the efficiency of the, critical Agency mission wIll of necessity ,come from within. Public 'disclosure of such information, especially,when ft, advances a novel theory, could have the effect of stifling such candor by the risk of diminution of professional' standing the emplo~ee runs if 'subsequently found wrong.' Thus, this matter was del~ted pursuant to 5 U.S.C. §5S2(b)(Sl. (2) Paragraph three of this document uses a signals intelligence oper,atton against 'the Soviet Onion to illustrate the author's point. This paragraph contains information about SIGINT activities that is currently and properly classified and, thus, is exempt from disclosure pursuafit tG 5 U.S.C. 5SS2tb)(I)~ Tne material in this parag,r'aph also concerns the organization and operational' activities and ,function's of NSA directed against:. the Soviet Union'. This material is exempt from disclosure under ,5 U.S.,C. 5552(b)'(3) which exempts from rel.ease under the FOIA matters specifically exempted fr'om disclosure by another 'statute. As noted in paragraph 20, sub-paragraph b of my pub,lic affidavit, Public Law 86-36 provides that nq law shall be construed to require disclosure of the organization or a~y function of the NSA or any information with respect to activities thereof. (3) Paragraph four of the memorandum states the conclusions and recommendations of the author. While it talks of the ability of the Agency employees to deal with unusual phenomena it is not responsive to the plaintiff's ,request 4 I OOCID: 2768909 :TOP SECRET UMBRA regarding UFO or UFO phenomena. In any event, as I stated in my public affidavit (paragraph 20b), the subject matter of that paragraph Is exempt from disclosure because it contains the employee's specific recommendations for addressing the probl~ o·f responding to surprise material. For the reasons stated In sub-paragraph (1) ahove, these reoommendations ·are exempt from disclosure pursuant to 5 U.S.C. S552(b)(5). ORe specific recom- mendation suggests an operational approach to solving the plioblem which reveals NSA.activitles and is, therefore, exempt from disclosure pursuant to~5 U.S.C. S552(b) (3) as explained above. (4) Tbe final deletion is in appendix A, paragraph 10 Of this report. Thi.~ section talks about deceptive c01Din~nicatlons tactics ulied by tbe Vietnamese ag'ainst q. S. forces and does riot include any refer'ence to UFO or OFO phenomena and, Is, therefore, not respons'ive to plaintiff's request. Nqnetheless tbe subjecft matter of sub-paragraph lOis currently and properly'classified. Thus, even i f it were deellledto be, wi thin the scope of plaintiff's request, it is exempt from disclosure pursuant to 5 U.S.C. SSS2 (b)(l). COMINT REPORTS s. ('1'BErl)' The remaining one hundred and fifty-six records being withheld are· communlqaU'ons intelligence (COHINT) reports which were produced between 1958 and 1979. For purposes of my discussion here, these records are organized into three groups based upon the source of the report. a. One hundred and fifteen of these reports' were produced by the signals intelligence organizations of foreign governments. These COMINT reports are provided to NSA under 5 ~ " - . , -:' DOCID: 2768909 various arrangements for sharing COMIN1' information. The counte teB who collaborate with NSA in SIGINT activitles are . designated either second. parey' Or third party so~rces -- depending on the natur~ Gf ,the relationsh'ip. '(l.j TWo of the records ,at issue here were produced by second party sources (Dnited Kingdom and Austral ia).' .The United states has extremely close intelliqence ties ~ithboth these nations d.aUng back to, World W~r II. 'l'he report from the Dni,ted K~n9dOlll. wail provided to NSA under it formal agreement governing collaboration in COKIN1' b'etween the U. S. and the D. K. ~ the Qnited Klngdom-United Sta te~ cbmmunieations Intelligence . . ; Agreement of .~ March 1946 (UKUSA Agreement)~Under t.he OKUSA' Agreement, the, relationship of 'NSA and 'GOvernment Co~unicat1ons , Headquarters' . . (ecHQ -- the U.K.·S . . counterpart to .' NSA)- is virtually a full partnershiJ;!_ Mutua11y 4gree'a upon rules governing the security protection a(for'd,ed, to COMINr are appiied un:J.formly by, our two governments. The relationsMp between NSA and the Australian SIGIN1' organization is also, '., very close ,one which i's governed by a,s1milar~geeement. (2) One hundred ana thirteen, r.eports were prov1ded ' E.O. 12958, as amended , Section 3.3(b)(1) and (b)(3) b. TWo of these COMINT reports, originated from SIGINT operations which were conducted jointly by the United States and a fore,ign government., Unaersucb an arrangell!~nt: the 6 DOCID: 2768909 in exchange for the ,sharing of technology and COMIN'l' information. c. 'l'heremaining thirty-nine COMINT documents were produced by NSA or, ,relate to NSA SIGINT operations. That is, " tbese'reports originated at NSA itself ori~ field sites, ~nder ' tbe operational and technical' control of NSA. 6.. (U) All of the COMINT "uports are in ,dther message Qr slimmary forllat.' A report in lIess~ge fOrmat contains a ,sing~e , " . und~rlyin9 communicaUonpresen.ted in a classic cable format, I.e .. the verbatim ~ext of the particular transmission, preceded and followed by -ell;ter'nals· consisti~gO.f: data about th,e sender, ,and the recipient;, the dates' and, times of transmission, and . E.O. 12958, as amended . . .- other technical info·tmatlon. A sum.mary~ as the. label sllggests, Section 3.3(b)(1) and (b)(3) provides!n summary 'form the contents' of a single ,message or" I ofa .small number of re'lated ,intercepted communicat'ions, often . l "acco,!,~nied bY' some t.ePhnic~1 'dat~~ 7. ~'One hundred ~ndfift~':"four of' the one' hund'~!i!d anc! fift.y-six, COMINT 'reports ar~, based, wholly' UpOI) intercepted cOlQlunicaUons of fO'reign government~ transmitted on non-public . . -government net- communications'links oray.tems. Of the two ' reports not inCluded in t.hls' total, one 'report'is the text of: a decrypted communication tr'ansmitted by an International ,communications common carrier., I have described the distinction between theEle two kinds of cOirununlcation's facilities hi my public affid'avit at paragraph ,lO..'l'be other record which is not based on intercepted communications from -g.overnment net- facilities, 7 DOCID: 2768909 n .. c -r...,r T.' a. E..... C~~~.,;-~ . . '. :3C'Q». ·.·i•. ~7~. ~""~~4 _ U:~~·RA· is a description of an incident purported to have been learned from U.S.-interception and analysis of communications; 8. f'lI8ei. The"COHINl' reports originated by. can be further described in terms of sources and intelligence targets as follows: l:ar~et. c munications format, was produced by communications between two ground. 'contrOlle~ in April . E.O. 12958, as amended III ·phenomena- . Section 3.3(b)(1) and (b)(3) repOrts are summaries' ofdecrypt.ed .messages in~ercepted from _ cOllllllun·icatio~s~. The messages .were. transmitted f.rom· ground radar operators t~ a' central. e~:m'trol station. In these Emc'oded , . mess·ages,. , ·the. operator.s.repo~t everything tbat appears on the'ir radar screi!ns. When th.ey cannot identify a particular object, tbey report: it as an unidentifiable object:. ;I:n translating these messages, the O.S. cryptolinguist uses "unidentified flying object- as the' equivalent of the text. _ . o n e huridr~d and nine documents.insummary format report on intercepted· communications between _ground radar operators and a' central control point. These .summar.ies aie Similar to the reports deSCribed in sub-paragraph a above and, .••. /.. ',-..;:)4.$ '--' ~ ,M.~J... __- ........ h . ......... , ..... DOcrD: 2768909 \.;'~!, ... ". ,~ ,".'., ,. again, contain decrypted information pert~ining to the radar: operator's report of obj'ects on his radar screen which he cannot identify. summar,Y of intercepted messages prepared in 1976 which repo,rt radar tracking information from a ground radar station to a ce'ntral control point. It is similar to the reports described . .tnsub-paragraphs ta) and (b) above,,'· was Prepared .It con tiline a' .' summary of intercepted communications which were transmitted ,between ': the cOllimander and the .. ' air commandetregarding a' yellOW object that' • r" . . . was reported to have fall.en into, the, sea. 'l.'Qese messages' , . were tranSlllitted along"' a -government net- facility. " produced £rom a field site whicb is jointly operated by the v.s. and it col1abo~a·,t1J:lg foreign ·government. The reports; werep~epared' In' 1966" and' contain summaries oftbe communica- tions transmitted by ground 'radar operators as discussed in "sub-paragraph b, above.' on.e of the t.wo reports is a follow-up re~rt to the other. mil~s northeast" of Facility. _by The relevant"activit.y reported deals with" the tracking,of an obj,ctapprox.1mately50nautiqal A,S with the mes~ages the' described above, these COMINT report.s are summaries of the decrypted messages. 9 DOCID: 2768909 9. (iI.se) NSA-originated reports - Thirty-:-eight documents' are the direct pr,od'uct of NSA SIGINT operations and one document describes classified SIGINT act:.iv1ties. These documents can be further described as follows: a. The document deli\cribing SIGINT operations repor an alleged interce~t of communications. The . factual oircwnst.ances of theincidel')t. 'reported io' this reoord were reoeived by NSA trom an FOIA ,requester other than the plaioti'ff and are considered to be fictitious bY,NSA analysts. However,' ~he report d,oes contain details about existing. SIGI.NT 'activit.ies, a9!linst the E.O. 12958, as amended Section 3.3(b)(1) and (b)(3) 10 - . ~. ~ , ", .DOC:tD:" 2768909 c. ,Twelve NSA-origlnated COMINT r'eports target the communications links and systems o,t Two documen'ts, in sUmmary format, report the decrypted text: of military communications. TWo of the, records are in 'message , , , format and report the decrypted texts of cOUlmun ica,- tions which relate that an unIdentified flying object was, sighted in the air by a it. 'One report contains a summary of _ activity based' upon e~mmuni~a- , " tions in reaction' to an unidentified flying obj'ect along' the Two documents, report on eommunica't,i,ons , transmitted between and • • , _ wh,o ,~~port' vi~ual observ~tionsof luminous SPhe~;~. ~e four'documents in this group 9f twelve wereinterceptea from other, non-,military communications tar;gets. '~e 'document is based on the intercept-ed tJ:ansrclissio;n of III , " , ,reporting a bright liqht.' 'lbe, ,second recoc'd is based on th4i intercept of 'a transmission of an to a_ ~tatlon seeking a l1epOrt on ,any shining phenomena o'r falling meteorites observed on sPecified date,S. The third and . . ".. fourth ,reports are, a slllDlllaries Qf on-going clebates on O'POs among baseCl'on intercepted communications transmitted on· 'nets. d., ~ive of the NSA~originated COMINT reports . target government net communications of All five of these , documents are based on intercepted mil! tary communications between units and commandersrepo,rting observa- tiona of luminous objects in the 'sky. 11 TOP SECRET UMBRA ,DOCID: 2768909,' , OP GE/.... r ',' ~ e. Pour NSA-orig inahd COMIt-IT reports target' communications links dr systems. Three reports are if! summary format and are based on an intercepted message trans- mitted b~tween two reporting an unidentified flying obje~t at a very high altitude; .. .an inter·cepted. me'ssag8 'transmi tted .from an unid,entifie(f flying obj,ect with two facility.by a who reporte,d an unioentifiedflying . report i~' based .uPon ~. message b~tween. , . units re9,ardin~ a O~O sighting. Six teen NSA-od91!l~,ted COH1NT reports target the "government net". eommunicaU~ns systems and 1inks of several different countries. 'ihisgroup contains summaries • B.O, 12958. as amended of lntei:eepted 'transmissions between mllit,ary units " Section 3.3(b)(1) and (b)(3) (two~eportisbased , .' . on.communica- .. ' an' unidentified sender' repOrting . sightings of a UPO)~. (two repor'ts based' on c:ommu~Ucat1on8 by 11111' unit commanders ~.,port1ng ,unident.1 ne