: © oe a6 eo” ss Me nd fl oe oa, a fl oe sn! ih RP Os 5 em foe P i” eee or ee et a or a es ee 7 « - i Pa ~ > ~ Lat Swe é ten fey ee a « tae * fee “ik in Southern PREF... 4 { H i : fi Mii i AM) , 4 J : : os t | THE AMERICAN GRAIN IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN BY WILLIAM CARLOS WILLIAMS NEW YORK ALBERT & CHARLES BONI 1925 Copyright, 1925, by Albert § Charles Boni Printed in the United States of America by J. J. LITTLE AND IVES COMPANY, NEW YORK CONTENTS PAGH PR SNPYSUEREQHE CUE Nat Vets tig eye NUL ges e e J . ° J e oO e 1 Tue Discovery or THE INDINS . .. Christopher Columbus Tue Destruction or TENOCHTITLAN . . . . 2. 6 fe) 24 Cortez and Montezuma Tue Fountain or Erernat Youtu . Juan Ponce de Leon De Soro anp tHE New Worip mrarhe Prime UNO rae ERATION. 5 4 eke le at ee Sek 59 VoyaGcre or ror “MAvFLowEr’. . . . » © «© «© « « 68 Remo POUNDING OF QUmBEC. . 5 «6 6 6 8 eo ew > 6S Samuel de Champlain Tue May-pote at MerryMounT . . . . . 2. « « ew) COB Thomas Morton Corron Marner’s WonprERS oF THE INvisIBLE WoRLD. . . I Enchantments Encountered . . . «© «© «© «© «© 81 II The Trial of Bridget Bishop at Salem. . ... « « 85 The Trial of Susanna Martin . =. «- 0 ‘© © eveo us 92 etemrtnirinikies Sw so OO Sen lene 6 Ce eee MER ROSEBRASTIAN TLASTNG ¢ 5 9550 3 we a po ew we ROS Tur Discovery or KentucKY . . . «+ + « « e« «+ 180 Daniel Boone Peano WASGINGION 5 . 9.) « «v6 8) & ale , 180 ite o tenn se ce Re ge el ae oe gel ot ae Benjamin Franklin : Barrie Between THE Bon Homme RicHarD AND THE Srrapis 158 John Paul Jones a te ie i 8 ie oe Mie igo on Pale US Tuer VIRTUE OF History e ° ° e ° ° e e e e e 188 Aaron Burr Apvent or THE SLAVES. «. + © © © © © © © @ *& 208 Tintin ALtAMYeOP < «8s 6 Fe 8 ot 8 Pe kee KG 3 OReAMee LINCOLN «0 2 4 © we o # ee ee 234 ee = TPs of 1 2 hele he at ee ¥. A ae ee | Sitges Ft 9k.” i Ay IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN RED ERIC by single strength, theirs by the crookedness of their law. But they have marked me—even to myself. Be- cause I am not like them, I am evil. I cannot get my hands on it: I, murderer, outlaw, outcast even from Iceland. Be- cause their way is the just way and my way—the way of the kings and my father—crosses them: weaklings holding to- gether to appear strong. But I am alone, though in Green- land. The worst is that weak, still, somehow, they are strong: they in effect have the power, by hook or by crook. And because I am not like them—not that I am evil, but more in accord with our own blood than they, eager to lead—this very part of me, by their’ trickery must not appear, unless in their jacket. Eric was Greenland: I call it Greenland, that men will go there to colonize it. I, then, must open a way for them into the ice that they - follow me even here—their servant, in spite of myself. Yet they must follow. It was so from the beginning. They drove me from Jaederen, my father and me. Who was this Christ, that he should come to bother me in my own country? His bishops that lie and falsify the records, make me out to be what I am not—for their own ends—because we killed a man. Was he the first man that was ever killed, that they must sour over it? That he was important to their schemes, that he meant much to them—granted: one of their own color, we 1 R iy sxe the ice than their way: to take what is mine 2 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN who altered him must be driven from Norway. ‘Their courts and soft ways. Not that we killed him. One or the other of us had to die, under the natural circumstance. He or we. But that if we had been killed, would he then have been driven from his country? They would have made him Archbishop. To Iceland, then. Forget Norway. What there? My father dead. Land to the north cleared. A poor homestead. Manslaughter had driven me there. Then I married 'Thor- hild, removed from the north and cleared land at Haukadal. Must I-be meek because of that? If my slaves cause a land- slide on Valthioff’s farm and Valthioff’s kinsman slays them, shall I not kill him? Is it proper for me to stand and to be made small before my slaves? I am not a man to shake and sweat like a thief when the time comes. Rather say I killed two men instead of the one. They tried me among themselves and drove me out once more. To the north, then. Iceland wilderness. There Thorgest comes to me and asks if I will lend him my outer dais-boards: ready to take me at a loss. Why else? For Eric the Red is a marked man, beyond the law, so it would seem: from that man one steals at will—being many in the act against his one. Thorgest keeps the decorated woodpieces. I go to his house and remove my property. He gives chase and two of his sons are killed in the encounter. This time they have done the thing. They search for us among the islands—me and my people. This is the way of it, Thorhall, this has always been the way with me from the first. Eric loves his friends, loves bed, loves food, loves the hunt, loves his sons. He is a man that can throw a spear, take a girl, steer a ship, till the soil, plant, care for the cattle, skin a fox, sing, dance, run, wrestle, climb, swim like a seal. A man to plan an expedition and pay for it, kill an enemy, take his way through a fog, a snowstorm, read a reckoning by the stars, live in a stench, drink foul water, withstand the fierce cold, the black of winter and come to a new country with a hundred men and found them there. RED ERIC 3 But they have branded me. They have separated murder _ into two parts and fastened the worse on me. It rides in the air around me. What is it to be killed? They have had their fling at me. Is it worse, so much worse, than to be hunted about the islands, chased from Norway to Iceland, from south to north, from Iceland to Greenland, because—I am I, and remain so. Outlaws have no friends. Murderers are run down like rabbits among the stones. Yet my ship was built, fitted, manned, given safe conduct beyond the reefs. To Thorbiorn I owe much. And so to Greenland—after bitter days fighting the ice and rough seas. Pestilence struck us. The cattle sickened. Weeks passed. The summer nearly ended before we struck land. This is my portion. I do not call it not to my liking. Hardship lives in me. What I suffer is myself that outraces the water or the wind. But that it only should be mine, cuts deep. It is the half only. And it takes it out of my taste that the choice is theirs. I have the rough of it not because I will it, but because it is all that is left, a rem- nant from their coatcloth. This is the gall on the meat. Let the hail beat me. It is a kind of joy I feel in such things. Greenland then. So be it. Start over again. It turns out always the one way. A wife, her two sons and a daughter. So my life was split up. The logic of it also. This is my proof. We lived at our homestead, well rid of the world. Traders visited us. ‘Then Lief, Eric’s son, sails to Norway, a thousand miles, in one carry. But on his return, Lief the Lucky, he is driven westward upon a new country, news of which he brings to Brattahlid. At the same stroke he brings me back pride and joy-in-his-deed, my deed, Eric moving up, and poison: an edict from Olaf—from my son’s mouth— solid as an axe to cut me, half healed, into pieces again. Not that it was new. Only that here in Greenland I had begun to feel that I had left the curse behind. Here through the winters, far to the west, I had begun to look toward sum- mer when I should be whole again. My people at work, my 4 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN wife beside me, the boys free from my smear, growing in strength and knowledge of the sea. Here was an answer to them all: Thorstein and Lief Erickson, sons of Red Eric, murderer! Myself in the teeth of the world. So they chopped me up. The Pope wins Olaf. Lief at court—Olaf commissions him to carry the thing back to Greenland. It grows like fire. Why not? Promise the weak strength and have the strength of a thousand weak at your bidding. Thorhild bars me, godless, from her bed. Both sons she wins to it. Lief and Thorstein both Christians. And this is what they say: Eric, son of evil, come and be forgiven.— Let her build a church and sleep in it. e+ * # With the years there began to be much talk at Brattahlid of Vinland the Good that Lief had first seen, that it should be explored. And so Karlsefni and Snorri fitted out a ship. Eric, too old to go with them, watches the ship depart. But Eric is in the ship, with the men, Eric the bedless, the sonless. Fate has pulled him out at the holes of his eyes and flung him again to sea as the ship steers southward. Now the glass — darkens as the sea takes them to the New World. . They found wild rice, they built booths and palisades. First they traded with the Skrellings, whose cheekbones were high, whose eyes wide, then fought them. Whereas Karlsefni and his men had shown white shields before, now they took red shields and displayed them. The Skrellings sprang from their canoes and they fought together. Karlsefni and Snorri were beaten. ‘They fell back. Then it was that Freydis, Eric’s natural daughter, came out from her cabin. Seeing — that the men were fleeing, she cried: Why do you flee from these wretches, when ye should slaughter them like cattle? Had I a weapon I would fight better than any of you. Lagging behind the rest as they ran, because of her belly, she being with child, she found a dead man in front of her. It was Snorri’s son, with his head cleft by a stone, his naked RED ERIC 5 sword beside him. This she took up and prepared to defend herself. The Skrellings then approached her, whereupon she stripped down her shirt and slapped her breast with her bare sword. At this the Skrellings were terrified and ran down to their boats. So, thinning out, more and more dark, it ran: Eric in Freydis’ bones: Freydis now, mistress of her own ship, per- suades two brothers, Helgi and Finnbogi, to sail with her again to Vinland: all to share equally the good things that might there be obtained. Lief to lend her his house there. Two ships, each to have thirty able-bodied men besides the women, but at the start Freydis violated the compact by con- cealing five men more. Karlsefni feared her. Now they put out to sea, the brothers in one ship and Freydis and Karlsefni in the other, having agreed that they would sail in company. But although they were not far apart from each other the brothers arrived somewhat in advance and carried their belongings up to Lief’s house. Freydis comes and does the same. The brothers withdraw and build a new house nearby. Within a month, the two houses are at odds and winter comes on. Spring. Freydis, one night, after long thinking, arose early from her bed and dressed herself, but did not put on shoes and stockings. A heavy dew had fallen. She took up her husband’s cloak, wrapped it about her and walked in the dark to the brothers’ house and up to the door, which had been only partly closed by one of the men, who had gone out only a short time earlier. She pushed open the door and. stood silently in the doorway for a moment. Finnbogi was awake and said: What dost thou wish here, Freydis? She answered: I wish thee to arise and go with me for I would speak with thee. They walked to a tree which lay close by the wall of the house and seated themselves upon it. How art thou pleased here, she said. He answered that he was well pleased with the place, except for the quarrel which had come up between them. They talked. 6 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN It was the brothers’ boat—it seemed—she wanted, larger than her own. Finnbogi slow, thickheaded, or asleep, con- sents to let her have it. Freydis, split with anger or bad blood, returns home and Finnbogi to his bed. The woman climbed into bed and awakened her husband with her cold feet. Why so cold and wet? I have been to the brothers to buy their ship, but they refused and beat me! Thorvard roused his men. ‘They went to the brothers’ house, took them and all their people, and slaughtered them one by one as they were brought from within. Only the women were left. These no man would kill. What? said Freydis. Hand me an axe! This done, she fell upon the five women and left them dead. . In Greenland, Lief, now head of the family, has no heart to punish his sister as she deserves: But this I predict of them, that there is little prosperity in store for their offspring. Hence it came to pass that no one from that time forward thought them worthy of aught but evil. Eric in his grave. THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES HE New World, existing in those times beyond the sphere of all things known to history, lay in the fifteenth century as the middle of the desert or the sea lies now and must lie forever, marked with its own dark life which goes on to an immaculate fulfillment in which we have no part. But now, with the maritime successes of that period, the western land could not guard its seclusion longer; a predestined and bitter fruit existing, perversely, before the white flower of its birth, it was laid bare by the miraculous first voyage. For it is as the achievement of a flower, pure, white, waxlike and fragrant, that Columbus’ infatuated course must be depicted, especially when compared with the acrid and poisonous apple which was later by him to be proved. No more had Columbus landed, the flower once ravished, than it seemed as if heaven itself had turned upon this man for disturbing its repose. But the initiative taken, the course broached, the story must goon. He left a handful of colonists in the islands while he, himself, returned to Spain with the news and for aid. As the outward journey had been pleasant “like April in Andalucia”—still seas, clear, fine weather and steady winds, so now the return was difficult. Through tempest, assault, trickery among the Portuguese Azores, capture and despair, he fought his way. But as he neared the home coast at last his trials grew worst of all. Everything hung on the point of being lost: * * & . . . daylight until sunset, great trouble with the wind, high and tempestuous seas. Lightning three times to the N.N.E. —sign of a great storm coming from that quarter or its op- posite. We lay to most of the night, afterwards showing a 7 8 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN little sail. In the day the wind moderated a little, but soon increased again and during the night the waves were ter- rible, rising against each other and so shaking and straining the Nifia that she was in danger of being stove in. We car- ried the mainsail very closely reefed, so as just to give her steer- way. Meanwhile the sea and wind increased, and we began to run before it, there being nothing else to do. The caravel Pinta began to run before it at the same time, and Martin Alonzo ran her out of sight, although we kept showing lanterns all night and they answered us. Sunrise the wind blew still harder, and the cross seas were terrific. Continued to show the closely reefed mainsail to en- able her to rise between the waves, or she would otherwise have been swamped. Now I feared that we should perish. I should have borne this misfortune with less distress had my life alone been in peril, but what caused me boundless grief and trouble was the thought that just now when our gainsayers were to be convinced and the discovery of a New World victoriously to be announced, that just now the Divine Will should wish to block it with my destruction. Of this mind I resolved, that even if I should die, the ship be lost, to find a means of not losing a victory already won. I wrote on a parchment, with that brevity which the time de- manded, how I had discovered the lands I had promised to find, describing the route I had followed and how your High- ness had possession of all that had been found by me. This folded and sealed, I had a cask brought, and having wrapped the writing in waxed cloth surrounded by a large cake of wax, I enclosed all in a barrel stoutly hooped, which I threw into the sea. All believed it some act of devotion. Later amid showers and squalls, the wind veered to the west and we sailed before it, in a very confused sea, for five hours. We had taken in the reefed mainsail, for fear that the wind would carry all away. That night at the time of re- peating the Salve, some of the men saw a light to leeward. THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES 9 During the night a terrible storm, expecting to be overwhelmed by the cross seas, while the wind seemed to raise the caravel into the air. In these straits, not knowing whether there was any port for shelter, I set the mainsail... . * * * Forced by the storm into Lisbon harbor, the turn of his destiny quickly multiplied his misfortunes. In Spain, when he finally arrived there, they immediately accused him of play- ing traitor to Castile, of having tried to ere with the Portuguese sovereign. But that passed; there was too much still for him to en- dure for catastrophe to have overtaken him so early; some savage power had him in its care, preserving him for its later pleasure. Now his triumph was acclaimed, his captives were paraded in Madrid, his gold was witnessed, his birds, monkeys and native implements were admired. This over, immediately the urge was on him once more. He must re- turn at once to the New World. Never content would he be for the balance of his whole life, following his fortune, whose flower, unknown to him, was past. | But now he saw before him the illusive bright future of a great empire founded, coupled with a fabulous conquest of heathendom by the only true church. Much had been prom- ised him. He had succeeded in the sternest hazard, the great first step; should not the rest prove easy and natural? It rose before him like a great gilded mountain. Again and again he calls before his mind their agreements: * *+ * . . . that henceforth I should be called Don, and should be Chief Admiral of the Ocean Sea, perpetual Viceroy and Governor of all the islands and continents that I should dis- cover and gain in the Ocean Sea, and that my eldest son should succeed, and so from generation to generation for- ever. 10 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN Item: that of all and every kind of merchandise, whether pearls, precious stones, gold, silver, spices, etc., of whatever kind, name and sort which may be bought, bartered, discov- ered within the said Admiralty, your Highnesses grant from henceforth to the said Don Cristébal, the tenth part of the whole . . . granted, in the town of Santa Fe de la Granada on the 17th day of April, in the year of our Lord Jesus Christ, 1492. I, the King. I, the Queen. * & # Unhappy talk. What power had such ridiculous little promises to stay a man against that terrific downpour on the brink of which they were all floating? How could a king fulfill them? Yet this man, this straw in the play of the elemental giants, must go blindly on. More and more he threw everything he had into the contest, his sons, his brothers, in the hope that his fortunes would be retrieved in the end. How could he have realized that against which he was op- posed? His instinctive enemies, however, were not so back- ward on their part. With malicious accuracy, finding him more and more alone, they sensed everything and turned it to their own advantage, being closer to that curious self-in- terest of natural things than he. Heroically, but pitifully, he strove to fasten to himself that enormous world, that presently crushed him among its multiple small disguises. With its archaic smile, America found Columbus its first victim. This was well, even merciful. As for the others, who shall say?—when riding a gigantic Nature and when through her heat they could arrogate to themselves a pin’s worth of that massive strength, to turn it against another of their own kind to his undoing,—even they are natural and as much a part of the scheme as any other. There is no need to argue Columbus’ special worth. As much as many another more successful, everything that is holy, brave or of whatever worth there is in a man was con- tained in that body. Let it have been as genius that he made THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES 11 his first great voyage, possessed of that streamlike human purity of purpose called by that name—it was still as a man that he would bite the bitter fruit that Nature would offer him. He was poisoned and his fellows turned against him like wild beasts. Bewildered, he continued, voyage after voyage, four times, out of his growing despair; it seemed that finally by sheer physical effort a way must be found—till the realization of it all at last grew firmly upon him: * * * ‘ Seven years passed in discussion and nine in execution, the Indies discovered, wealth and renown for Spain and great increase to God and to his Church. And I have arrived at and am in such condition that there is no one so vile but thinks he may insult me. What have I not endured? ‘Three voyages undertaken and brought to success against all who would gainsay me; islands and a mainland to the south discovered; pearls, gold, and, in spite of all, after a thousand struggles with the world and having withstood them all, neither arms nor counsels availed, it cruelly kept me under water. If I were to steal the Indies or the land which lies beyond them from the altar of St..Peter and give them to the Moors, they could not have greater enmity toward me in Spain. When on my last voyage, having turned homeward, I had left Paria (Brazil) and come again to Espajiola (Porto Rico), I found half the people in revolt; and the Indians on the other side grievously harassed me. It was at this time that Bobadilla came to Santo Domingo. I was at La Vega. He took up his abode in my house and, just as he found it, so he appropriated everything to himself. Well and good; per- haps he was in want of it. On the second day after his ar- rival he created himself Governor. I thought the affair would end like that of Hojeda and the others, but I restrained myself when I learned for certain from the friars that your Highnesses had sent him. I wrote 12 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN to him that his arrival was welcome, that I was prepared to hand it over to him as smooth as my palm. But he gave me no answer. On the contrary, he put himself in a warlike at- titude and compelled all who were there to take an oath to him as Governor. Together with them, he ordered inquisitions concerning me, the like whereof were never known in hell. I was made prisoner and returned to Spain in the condition of which you know. I should have freed myself forever from this affair and undertaken that holy pilgrimage which has long been in my heart had it been honorable to my Queen to do so. But the sup- port of Our Lord and Her Highness made me persevere. I undertook a fresh voyage to the new Heaven and Earth. And if this, the most honorable and profitable of all, is held in small esteem in Spain, it is because it has been looked upon as my work. Up to the period of reaching these shores, I experienced most excellent weather, but the night of my arrival came on with a dreadful tempest, and the same bad weather has con- tinued ever since. On reaching the island of Espajfiola, I despatched a packet of letters, by which I begged as a favor that a ship be supplied me at my own cost in lieu of one of those that I had brought with me, which had become unsea- worthy, and could no longer carry sail. The letters were taken, and your Highnesses will know if a reply has been given them. For my part I was forbidden to go on shore. The tempest was terrible throughout the night, all the ships were separated, and each one driven to the last extremity without hope of anything but death; each of them also looked — upon the loss of the rest as a matter of certainty. What man was ever born, not even excepting Job, who would not have been ready to die of despair at finding himself as I then was, in anxious fear for my own safety, and that of my son, my brother and my friends, and yet refused permission either to land or to put into harbor on the shores which by God’s mercy I had gained for Spain sweating blood? THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES 18 And this is the thing which calls most loudly for redress and remains inexplicable to this moment. The lands in this part of the world, which are now under your Highnesses’ sway, are richer and more extensive than those of any other Christian power, and yet, after that I had, by the Divine Will, placed them under your high and royal sovereignty, and was on the point of bringing your Majesties into receipt of a very great and unexpected revenue; and while I was wait- ing for ships to convey me to safety, and with a heart full of joy, to your royal presence, victoriously to announce the news of the gold that I had discovered, I was arrested and thrown with my two brothers, loaded with irons, into a ship, stripped, and very ill treated without being allowed any appeal to justice. | Who could believe that a poor foreigner would have risen against your Highnesses, in such a place without any motive or argument on his side; without even the assistance of any other Prince upon whom to rely; but on the contrary amongst your own vassals and natural subjects, and with my sons stay- ing at the royal court? I was twenty-eight years old when I came into your Highnesses’ service, and now I have not a hair upon me that is not gray; my body is infirm, and all that was _ left me, as well as to my brothers, has been taken away and sold, even to the frock that I wore. I would implore your Highnesses to forgive my com- plaints. I am indeed in as ruined condition as I have re- lated. With regard to temporal things, I have not even a blanca for an offering; and in spiritual things, I have ceased here in the Indies from observing the prescribed forms of re- limon... But to return to the ships: although the tempest had so completely separated them from me as to leave me single, yet the Lord restored them to me in His good time. The ship for which we had the greatest fear, had put out to sea to escape being blown toward the island. The Gallega lost her boat and a part of her provisions, which latter loss indeed all of the 14 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN ships suffered. With this tempest I struggled on till I reached Jamaica, and there the sea became calm, but there was a strong contrary current which carried me as far as the Queen’s Garden without seeing land. Hence, as opportunity offered, I pushed on for the mainland, in spite of the wind and a fear- ful contrary current, against which I contended for sixty days. All this time I was unable to get into harbor, nor was there any cessation of the tempest, which was one continua- tion of rain, thunder and lightning. I at length reached the Cape of Gracias a Dios, and after that the Lord granted me fair wind and tide; this was on the twelfth of September. Twenty-eight days did this fearful tempest continue, during which I was at sea and saw neither sun nor stars, my ships lay exposed, with sails torn, and anchors, rigging, cables, boats and a great quantity of provisions lost. Other tempests have been experienced, but never of so long a duration as this. I myself had fallen sick, and was many times on the point of death, but from a little cabin that I had caused to be con- structed on deck, I directed our course. My brother was in the ship that was in the worst condition and the most ex- posed to danger; and my grief on this account was the greater that I had brought him with me against his will. Such is my fate, that the twenty years of service through which I have passed with so much toil and danger, have profited me nothing, and at this very day I do not possess a roof in Spain that I can call my own; if I wish to eat or sleep, I have nowhere to go but to the inn or tavern, and most times lack wherewith to pay the bill. I reached the land of Cariay, where I stopped to repair my vessels and take in provisions, as well as to afford relaxation to my men, who had become very weak. There I gained in- formation respecting the gold mines of which I was in search and two Indians conducted me to Carambaru, where the peo- ple, who go naked, wear golden mirrors round their necks, which they will neither sell, give, nor part with for any con- ‘THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES 15 sideration. They named to me many places on the sea-coast where there were both gold and mines. I started with the in- tention of visiting all of them. It was on the eve of St. Simon and St. Jude, which was the day fixed for our departure; but that night there arose so violent a storm, that we were forced to go wherever it drove us. I ran before the wind without power to resist it. Never was the sea seen so high, so terrific and so covered with foam; not only did the wind oppose our proceeding onward, but it also rendered it highly dangerous to run in for any headland, and kept me in that sea, which seemed to me as a sea of blood, seething like a cauldron on a mighty fire. Never did the sky look more fearful; during day and night it burned like a furnace and every instant I looked to see if my masts and my sails were not destroyed. These flashes came with such alarming fury that we all thought the ships must have been destroyed. All this time the waters from heaven never ceased, not to say that it rained, for it was like a repetition of the deluge. Twice had the ships suffered loss in boats, anchors, rigging, and were now lying bare with- out sails . . . still raining. The sea very tempestuous and I was driven backward under bare poles. . . . I anchored at an island, where I lost, at one stroke, three anchors; and at midnight, when the weather was such that the world appeared to be coming to an end, the cables of the other ship broke, and it came down upon my vessel with such force that it was a wonder we were not dashed to pieces; the single anchor that remained to me was our only preservation. _ After six days, when the weather became calm, I resumed my journey, having already lost all my tackle; my ships were pierced with borers more than a honeycomb and the crew en- tirely paralyzed with fear and in despair. There the storm returned to drive me back . . . I continued beating against contrary winds, and with the ships in the worst possible con- dition. With three pumps. and the use of pots and kettles, we could scarcely clear the’ water that came into the ship, there being no remedy but this, against the shipworm, I deter- 16 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN mined on keeping the sea, in spite of the weather, when we miraculously came upon land. Weep for me whoever has charity, truth and justice. I did not come out on this voyage to gain to myself honor and wealth; for at that time all hope of such a thing was dead. I do not lie when I say, that I went to your Highnesses with honest purpose of heart, and sincere zeal in your cause. I humbly beseech your Highnesses, that if it please God to rescue me from this place, you will graciously sanction my pilgrimage to Rome and other holy places. May the holy Trinity protect your Highnesses’ lives, and add pros- perity. ... * *x* * Storms and men; the very worms of the sea were opposed to him. But if, as he instinctively, but for his insane dogged- ness, would have done, he had undertaken that holy pilgrimage of which he had spoken, the flower might again, in that seclusion, often have appeared to him in all its old-time loveli- ness, as when he himself floated with luck and in sunshine on that tropic sea toward adventure and discovery: *% * * . at the third hour of Saturday night it began to blow from the N. E. and I shaped my course to the west. We took in much water over the bows, which retarded our prog- ress and nine leagues were made during the day and night. Sunday we made nineteen leagues, and I decided to reckon less than the number run, for should the voyage prove of long duration, the people would not be so terrified and disheartened. This day we lost sight of land, and many fearful of not seeing it again sighed and shed tears. The sailors steered badly, letting the ships fall off to N. E. and even more, of which I was forced to complain several times. Monday . . . Tuesday we sailed on our course which was west and made twenty leagues or more. We saw a large piece of the mast of a ship of one hundred and twenty tons, but were unable to get it. . THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES 1% Wednesday . . . On this day, Thursday, thirteenth Sep- tember, at the commencement of the night, the needles turned a half point to the north-west, and in the morning still more so. This I took to be due to a movement of the North Star which must have an orbit like the others howbeit less than they. Friday, on the westerly course, day and night, twenty leagues, counting a little less: Here those on the caravel Nifia reported that they had seen a tern, a bird which is never far from land. Saturday, we made twenty-seven leagues on the west course; and in the early part of the night there fell into the sea a marvelous flame of fire, at a distance of about four or five leagues from the ship. Sunday, the sixteenth, day and night, I steered the course west, making thirty-nine leagues but counted only thirty- six. There were some clouds and small rain. From this day and ever afterward very temperate breezes, so that there was - great pleasure in enjoying the mornings, nothing being wanted but the song of nightingales. It was like April in Andalucia. Here we began to see many tufts of grass that were very green and appeared to have been quite recently torn from the land. All this I called to the attention of the men and from this I judged that we were near land, but not the mainland which I make to be more distant. The seventeenth of September, Monday, I proceeded on the west course and made over fifty leagues in the day and night, counting only forty-seven. A favorable current aided us on our way. There was very much fine grass and herbs from rocks, which came from the west, so that it seemed for certain that land must be near. This day the pilots observed the north point and found, for the first time, that the needles turned a full point to the west of north. All this day the mariners were alarmed and dejected and would not give their reason. But I knew that it was because of the needle. At dawn I ordered that the north should be again observed. 18 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN They then found that the needles were true for the cause was that the star makes the movement and not the needles. At dawn we observed much more weed appearing, like herbs from a river, in which one of the men discovered a live crab. This I kept that all might see it and believe on the land. The sea water was found to be less salt than it had been since leaving the Canaries. This I caused many to taste. The breezes were always soft. Every one was pleased and the best sailors went ahead to sight the first land. Many tunnyfish passed on all sides of us and the crew of the Nifia killed one. All these signs came from the west in which direction I trust in that high God in whose hands are all victories that very soon we shall see land. On that morning there appeared a white bird, called boatswainbird, which is not in the habit of sleeping on the sea. Tuesday, we made forty-five leagues, counting only thirty- eight. The sea was like the river of Seville. Martin Alonzo, with the Pinta, which was a fast sailer, did not wait, but said to me from his caravel, that he hoped to see land that night. A great cloud appeared to the north, a sign of the nearness of land. Wednesday, twenty-five leagues, but it was calm, and counted only twenty-two. This day, at ten o’clock, a booby came to the ship and in the afternoon another, these birds not generally going more than twenty leagues from the land. There was also some drizzling rain without wind, which is a sure sign of land. I felt it to be certain that there were islands both to the north and south of our position and that we were passing through them. This I explained to all saying that my desire was to press on to the Indies, the weather being fine, as such it was, and that on the return we should see all. Here the pilots found their position. He of the Nifia made the Canaries four hundred and forty leagues distant, the Pinta four hundred and twenty. But he of my own ship made the distance exactly four hundred leagues, which I gave out to be the true. . THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES 19 Thursday, twentieth of September, the course was W. by N. and-as her head was all round the compass, owing to the calm that prevailed, the ship made only seven or eight leagues. Two boobies came to the ship, and afterwards another, a sign of the proximity of land. One of the men caught a bird with the hand, which was like a tern. But it was a riverbird, not a seabird, the feet being like those of a gull. At dawn two or three land birds came singing to the ship and they disappeared before sunset. Twenty-first of September, most of the day was calm, later a little wind. During the day and night we made only thir- teen leagues. At dawn we saw so much weed that the sea appeared to be covered with it. And it came from the west. A booby was seen. The sea was very smooth, like a river, and the air the best in the world. ‘Toward midday a whale was sighted, which is a sign of land, because they always keep near the shore. Saturday, September eer I shaped my course W. N. W. more or less, her head turning from one to the other point and made thirty leagues. This contrary wind was very necessary to me, because my people had become much ex- cited at the thought that in these seas no wind ever blew in the direction of Spain. In the morning there was no weed but in the afternoon it was very thick. This day, Sunday, the twenty-third of September, I shaped a course N. W. and at times more northerly; some- times getting upon our course, which was west, and made about twenty-two leagues. A dove was seen and also another booby, another riverbird and some white birds. Great quan- tities of weed and crabs in it. The sea being calm and smooth, the crews began to murmur, saying that here there was no great sea and the wind would never blow so that they could return to Spain. Many were in great despair and torment of mind thinking that they would never be able to return. After- ward the sea arose very much and later adverse winds ap- peared. The adverseness of the wind and the high sea were 20 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN very helpful to me since they freed the crew of the idea that there would be no favorable sea and winds for their re- turn. Yet even then some objected, saying that the wind would not last. Monday, on the west course all day and night making four- teen leagues. I counted only twelve. Tuesday, calm and afterwards wind. On the west course till night. This day I signaled that the Pinta should draw near and conversed with Martin Alonzo Pinzon respecting a chart which I had sent to the caravel three days before on which I had depicted certain islands in that sea. Martin Alonzo said that the ships were in the position on which the islands were placed, with which I agreed but added that it might be that we had not fallen in with them due to the cur- rents which had always set the ships to the N. E. and that we had not made so much as the pilots had reported. At my request the chart was sent back on a line. “hereat I plotted our position on it with the aid of the pilot and mariners that they might be reassured. At sunset Martin Alonzo went up on the poop of his ship and with joy called out that he had sighted land. I fell on my knees and gave thanks to the Lord, so heavy had been my burdens these latter days at the despair among the men and the murmurs going among them, that I should have to turn back. And Martin Alonzo said the Gloria im Excelsis with his people. My own crew did the same. Those of the Nifia all went up on the mast and into the rigging and declared that it was land. It seemed distant twenty-five leagues. So it appeared until night. I ordered the course to be altered from west to S. W. in which direction the land had appeared. Four leagues that day on a west course and seventeen S. W. during the night, in all twenty-one, but I told the men that thirteen was the distance made good. The sea was very smooth so that many sailors bathed alongside. We saw many giltheads and other fish. Wednesday, what had been said to be land was only clouds and I continued on the west course till afternoon, then al- THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES a1 tered to S. W. Day and night thirty-one leagues counting twenty-four for the people. The sea was like a river, the air pleasant and mild. The despair of the crew redoubled at this disappointment but I comforted them as best I could, begging them to endure a while longer for all that would be theirs in the end. Thursday, the course west, and distance made good day and night twenty-four leagues, twenty being counted for the people. Many giltheads came. One was killed. A boat- swainbird came. Twenty-eighth September, Friday, the course was west and the distance, owing to calms, only fourteen leagues, count- ing only thirteen. Little weed but more giltheads. Caught one. Saturday, the course was west, twenty-four leagues, count- ing only twenty-one. Calm, not much distance made good during day and night. Today we saw a man-o-war bird, which makes the boobies vomit what they have swallowed, and eats it, maintaining itself on nothing else. It is a seabird but does not sleep on the sea, and does not go more than twenty leagues from land. The sea smooth as a river. Much weed. Sunday, the last day of September, west fourteen leagues, eleven being counted. Four boatswainbirds came to the ship _ which I considered a great sign of land. Monday, first of October, west twenty-five leagues, counted twenty. A heavy shower of rain. At dawn the pilot of our ship made the distance from Hierro five hundred eighty-four leagues to the west. The reduced reckoning which I showed to the crew made it five hundred seventy-eight leagues, but the truth which I kept secret was seven hundred seven. Thus the wisdom of the double reckoning was confirmed. Tuesday, west, day and night thirty-nine leagues, counted for the crew thirty. The weed, many thanks to God, coming from east to west, contrary to the usual course. Many fish seen and one killed. A white bird like a gull. Wednesday, still the west course, and made good forty- 22 | IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN seven leagues, counted forty. Sandpipers appeared, and much weed, some old and some quite fresh and having fruit. No birds. So I gave it out that we had left the islands be- hind that were depicted on the chart. Here many called upon me to turn about and search for the land but I did not wish to keep the ships beating about, although I had certain in- formation of islands in this region. It would not have been — good sense to do this since the weather was favorable and the chief intention was to go in search of the Indies by way of the west. This was what I had promised to the King and Queen, and they had sent me for this purpose. Thursday, west sixty-three leagues, counted forty-six. More than forty sandpipers came to the ship in a flock and two boobies. A shipsboy hit one with astone. There also came a man-o-war bird and a white bird like a gull. The crew here became ever louder in their complaints but I gave as little heed as I was able though many were now openly mutinous and would have done me harm if they dared. Peter Gutierrez: So that, virtually, you have staked your life and the lives of your companions, upon the foundation of a mere speculative opinion. Columbus: So it is: I cannot deny it. But consider a lit-« _ tle. If at present you and I, and all our companions, were’ not in this vessel, in the midst of this sea, in this unknown’ solitude, in a state as uncertain and perilous as you please; in what other condition of life should we pass these days? Per- haps more cheerfully? or should we not rather be in some greater trouble or solicitude, or else full of tedium? I care not to mention the glory and utility we shall carry back, if the enterprise succeeds according to our hope. Should no other fruit come from this navigation, to me it appears most profitable inasmuch as for a time it preserves us free from tedium, makes life dear to us, makes valuable to us many things that otherwise we should not have in consideration. Friday, fifth of October, fifty-seven leagues, but counted forty-five. ‘The sea smooth and quiet. To God be given | j THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES 93 thanks, the air being pleasant and temperate, with no weed, many sandpipers, and flying fish coming on the deck in numbers. | Saturday, continued the west course, forty leagues, thirty- three being counted. Martin Alonzo said that it would be best to steer west by south, that night, for the island’ of Ci- pango which the map showed but I thought it best to go at once to the continent and afterwards to the island. Sunday, seventh October, west twenty-three leagues, count- ing eighteen. This day the Nifia hoisted a flag at the mast- head, and fired a gun, which was the signal I had ordered that land had been sighted. At this time also, I ordered that at sunrise and sunset, all the ships should join me, because at these times things are most proper for seeing the greatest distance, the haze clearing away. No land was seen during the afternoon as reported by the Nifia. But we passed great numbers of birds flying from N. to S. W. This I believed to be due either to the birds going to sleep on land or that they were flying from the winter which might be supposed to be near in the land from which they were coming. And this in some measure consoled the men from their disappointment ‘over the false news from the Nifia since it is known that most of the islands held by the Portuguese were discovered by the flight of birds. For this reason I resolved to give up the west - course and to shape a course W. S. W. for two days. We began the new course an hour before sunset, expecting to see land soon and this served to encourage the crew with renewed hope. fe _ Monday, the course W. S. W. and twelve leagues were’ made during the day and night. Thanks be to God the air is very soft like April at Seville; and it is a pleasure to be here, so balmy are the breezes. The weed this day is very fresh, there are many land birds and one was taken that was flying S. W., terns, ducks and a booby. Tuesday, ninth October, the course S. W. The wind then 24 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN changed and I steered W. by N. four leagues. Throughout the night birds were heard passing. Wednesday, fifty-nine leagues, W. S. W.., but counted no more than forty-four. Here the people cpuld endure no longer. All now complained of the length of the voyage. But I cheered them as best I could, giving them good hopes of the advantages they might gain by it. Roused to madness by their fear, the captains declared they were going back but I told them then, that however much they might complain, — I had to go to the Indies and they along with me, and that I would go on until I found them, with the help of our Lord. And so for a time it passed but now all was in great danger from the men. Thursday, eleventh of October. The course was W. S. W. More sea than there had been during the whole of the voy- age. Sandpipers and a green reed near the ship. And for this I gave thanks to God as it was a sure sign of land. Those of the Pinta saw a cane and a pole, and they took up another small pole which appeared to be worked with iron; also an- other bit of cane, a land plant and a small board. The crew of the caravel Nifia also saw signs of land, and a small plant covered with berries. After sunset I returned to the west course. Up to two hours past midnight we had gone ninety miles, when the Pinta, which was the fastest sailer and had gone ahead, found the land and gave the signals. The land was first seen by Rodrigo de Triana. Though on the night before, at ten o’clock, I saw a light and called Peter Gutierrez and said that there seemed to be a light, and that he should look at it. He did so and saw it. | The same to Rodrigo Sanchez who at first could see nothing but afterward saw the light once or twice like a wax candle rising and falling. When they said the Salve, which all the sailors are accustomed to sing in their way, I admonished the men to keep a good lookout on the forecastle and to watch well for land and to him who should first cry out that he had THE DISCOVERY OF THE INDIES 25 seen land I would give a silk doublet besides the other rewards promised by the Sovereigns which were ten thousand mara- vedis to him who should first see it. Two hours past midnight, the moon having risen at eleven o’clock and then shining brightly in the sky, being in its third quarter and a little behind Rodrigo de Triana, the land was sighted at a distance of about two leagues. At once I ordered them to shorten sail and we lay under the mainsail without the bonnets, hove to waiting for daylight. On Friday, the twelfth of October, we anchored before the land and made ready to go on shore. Presently we saw naked people on the beach. I went ashore in the armed boat and took the royal standard, and Martin Alonzo and Vincent Yariez, his brother, who was captain of the Nif#a. And we saw the trees very green, and much water and fruits of divers kinds. Presently many of the inhabitants assembled. I gave to some red caps and glass beads to put round their necks, and many other things of little value. They came to the ships’ boats afterward, where we were, swimming and bring- ing us parrots, cotton threads in skeins, darts—what they had, with good will. As naked as their mothers bore them, and so the women, though I did not see more than one young girl. All I saw were youtlis, well made with very handsome bodies and very good countenances. Their hair short and coarse, almost like the hairs of a horse’s tail. They paint themselves some black, some white, others red and others of what color they can find. Some paint the faces and others the whole body, some only round the eyes and others only on the nose. They are themselves neither black nor white. ' On Saturday, as dawn broke, many of these people came to the beach, all youths. Their legs are very straight, all in one line and no belly. They came to the ship in canoes, made out of the trunk of a tree, all in one piece, and wonderfully worked, propelled with a paddle like a baker’s shovel, and go at a marvelous speed. Bright green trees, the whole land so green that it is a 26 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN pleasure to look on it. Gardens of the most beautiful trees I ever saw. Later I came upon a man alone in a canoe going from one island to another. He had a little of their bread, about the size of a fist, a calabash of water, a piece of brown earth, powdered then kneaded, and some dried leaves which must be a thing highly valued by them for they bartered with it at San Salvador. He also had with him a native basket. The women wore in front of their bodies a small piece of cotton cloth. I saw many trees very unlike those of our coun- try. Branches growing in different ways and all from one trunk; one twig is one form and another is a different shape and so unlike that it is the greatest wonder in the world to see the diversity; thus one branch has leaves like those of a cane, and others like those of a mastic tree; and on a single tree there are five different kinds. The fish so unlike ours that it is wonderful. Some are the shape of dories and of the finest colors, so bright that there is not a man who would not be astounded, and would not take great delight in seeing them. There are also whales. I saw no beasts on land save parrots and lizards. On shore I sent the people for water, some with arms, and others with casks; and as it was some little distance, I waited two hours for them. During that time I walked among the trees which was the most beautiful thing which I had ever seen. . Be Eia ergo, advocata nostra, illos tuos misericordes oculos ad nos converte. Et J esum, benedictum fructum ventris tut, nobis post hoc exsiliwm ostende. O clemens, o pia, o dulces Maria. THE DESTRUCTION OF TENOCHTITLAN PON the orchidean beauty of the new world the old rushed inevitably to revenge itself after the Italian’s return. Such things occur in secret. Though men may be possessed by beauty while they work that is all they know of it or of their own terrible hands; they do not fathom the forces which carry them. Spain cannot be blamed for the crassness of the discoverers. They moved out across the seas stirred by instincts, ancient beyond thought as the depths they were crossing, which they obeyed under the names of King or Christ or whatever it might be, while they watched the recreative New unfolding itself miraculously before them, before them, deafened and blinded. Steering beyond familiar horizons they were driven to seek perhaps self-justification for victorious wars against Arab and Moor; but these things are the surface only. At the back, as it remains, it was the evil of the whole world; it was the perennial disappointment which follows, like smoke, the bursting of ideas. It was the spirit of malice which underlies men’s lives and against which noth- ing offers resistance. And bitter as the thought may be that Tenochtitlan, the barbaric city, its people, its genius wherever found should have been crushed out because of the awkward names men give their emptiness, yet it was no man’s fault. It was the force of the pack whom the dead drive. Cortez was neither malicious, stupid nor blind, but a conqueror like other conquerors. Courageous almost beyond precedent, tactful, resourceful in misfortune, he was a man of genius superbly suited to his task. What his hand touched went down in spite of him. He was one among the rest. Velasquez, the Cuban Governor who sent him out, traitorously attacked him from the rear a week afterward. His own captains would have 27 28 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN deserted him, so hard was he to follow. But the entire enter- prise lived for many years on the verge of being allowed to languish, ruin to succeed destruction, because of the for- tuitous anger which blossomed so naively, so mysteriously in Fonseca, Bishop of Burgos, President of the Council of the Indies. This the man, Cortez’ most powerful enemy, already so notorious for the spiteful malevolence with which he thwarted the views of Columbus—a logic clearer had there been two Fonsecas instead of the one. After a rough voyage from Cuba, across the gulf, Cortez landed his small force safely before what is now Vera Cruz, near the native city of Cempoal. There, lest his men should desert him in view of the hardships which lay ahead, he had his vessels beached, un- der pretext of their being no longer seaworthy, and destroyed them. Montezuma immediately sent gifts, at the same time beg- ging the Spaniard not to risk coming up into the back coun- try: a gold necklace of seven pieces, set with many gems like small rubies, a hundred and eighty-three emeralds and ten fine pearls, and hung with twenty-seven little bells of gold— Two wheels, one of gold like the sun and the other of silver with the image of the moon upon it, made of plates of those metals, twenty-eight hands in circumference, with figures of animals and other things in bas relief, finished with great skill and ingenuity.—A headpiece of wood and gold, adorned with gems, from which hung twenty-five little bells of gold, and, on it, instead of plume, a green bird with eyes, beak and feet of gold—Several shoes of the skin of deer, sewed with gold thread, the soles of which were made of blue and white stones of a brilliant appearance.—A shield of wood and leather, with little bells hanging to it and covered with plates of gold, in — the middle of which was cut the image of the god of war be- tween four heads of a lion, a tiger, an eagle and an owl rep- resented alive with their hair and feathers.—Twenty-four curi- ous and beautiful shields of gold, of feathers and very small pearls, and four of feathers and silver only.—Four fishes, two DESTRUCTION OF TENOCHTITLAN Qg9 ducks and some other birds of molten gold.—A large mirror adorned with gold, and many small.—Miters and crowns of feathers and gold ornamented with pearls and gems.—Sev- eral large plumes of beautiful feathers, fretted with gold and small pearls.—Several fans of gold and silver mixed together ; others of feathers only, of different forms and sizes.—A va- riety of cotton mantles, some all white, others chequered with white and black, or red, green, yellow and blue; on the out- side rough like shaggy cloth and within destitute of color and nap.—A number of underwaistcoats, handkerchiefs, counter- panes, tapestries and carpets of cotton, the workmanship superior to the materials of which they were composed.—And books made of tablets with a smooth surface for writing, which being joined might be folded together or stretched out to a considerable length, “the characters inscribed thereon resembling nothing so much as Egyptian hieroglyphics.”—But Cortez was unwilling to turn back; rather these things whet- ted his appetite for the adventure. Without more ado he sent letters to his king advising him that having come to these lands to conquer them, in the royal name and that of the true church, he would forthwith proceed to take Montezuma, dead or alive, unless he should accept the faith and acknowledge himself a subject to the Spanish throne. The advance was like any similar military enterprise: it accomplished its purpose. Surmounting every difficulty Cor- tez went his way into the country past the quiet Cempoalan maizefields, past the smoking summit of Popocatepetl, until, after weeks of labor, he arrived upon the great lakes and the small cities in them adjoining Tenochtitlan itself. Mon- tezuma seeing that there was nothing else for it, sent envoys accompanied by three hundred warriors, who met the Spaniard _ advancing on the lake road and there welcomed him to the district with great ceremony and show of friendliness. No- ticeable among them was one young man of magnificent ap- pearance who descended from his litter and walked to meet the Conqueror while his followers ran before him, picking up 30 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN stones and other small obstructions which lay in his path. Cortez now passed over his first causeway into one of the lesser lake cities, built of well-hewn stone sheer from the water. He was overcome with wonder. ‘The houses were so excel- lently put together, so well decorated with cloths and carven wood, so embellished with metalwork and other marks of a beautiful civilization; the people were so gracious; there were such gardens, such trees, such conservatories of flowers that nothing like it had ever been seen or imagined. At the house where the Conqueror was entertained that day and night he especially noted a pool built of stone into the clear waters of which stone steps descended, while round it were paven paths lined with sweet-smelling shrubs and plants and trees of all sorts. Also he noted the well-stocked kitchen garden. The following day at noon he arrived at the end of his journey. There it lay! a city as large as Cordova or Seville, entirely within the lake two miles from the mainland: Tenochtitlan. Four avenues or entrances led to it, all formed of artificial causeways. Along the most easterly of these, constructed of great beams perfectly hewn and fitted together, and measuring two spears-lengths in width, the Christian advanced. Run- ning in at one side of the city and out at the other this avenue constituted at the same time its principal street. As Cortez drew nearer he saw, right and left, magnificent houses and temples, close to the walls of which, each side, moved parallel rows of priests in black robes, and, between them, supported by two attendants, Montezuma, on foot, down the center of the roadway. Cortez stepped forward but the attendants in- terceded. The Emperor then advanced alone and with great simpleness of manner placed a golden chain about the Chris- tian’s neck. Then taking him by the hand, and the whole procession following, he conducted him to the quarters which had been chosen for the visitors, a great building close to the royal palaces in the center of the city. Everything had been prepared in advance: all the material needs together with rich gifts, as before: precious metals, gems, male and female re a pa le + OO ee DESTRUCTION OF TENOCHTITLAN 81 apparel of remarkable elegance, ornamental hangings for bed- chambers, tapestries for halls and temples, counterpanes composed of feathers interwoven with cotton, and many beauti- ful and curious artifices “of so costly and unusual workman- ship that considering their novelty and wonderful beauty no price could be set on them.” Here in this large building whose great hall was to serve the Spaniards for barracks from that time until the end, Montezuma and Cortez found themselves seated at last face to face. Montezuma spoke: ‘They have told you that I possess houses with walls of gold and many other such things and that I am a god or make myself one. The houses you see are of stone and lime and earth.”—'Then opening his robe: “You see that I am composed of flesh and bone like yourselves and that I am mortal and palpable to the touch.”—To this smiling sally, so full of gentleness and amused irony, Cortez could reply nothing save to demand that the man declare himself a subject of the Spanish King forth- with and that, furthermore, he should then and there announce publicly his allegiance to the new power.—Whatever the Aztec may have felt during the weeks of Cortez’ slow advance upon his capital from the seashore, nothing at the present moment _ seemed to disturb his aristocratic reserve. He had thought and he had made up his mind. Without semblance of anger, fear or impatience; without humility or protest but with the force bred of a determination to face at any cost a situation fast going beyond his control, he spoke again. He explained that his people were not the aborigines of the land but that _ they had emigrated there in times past and ended by accepting the Spanish Monarch as his rightful and hereditary master. After due announcements and explanations had been made to the people Cortez became the acknowledged regent, in the name _ of Castile and the true church, for all that country. Streets, public squares, markets, temples, palaces, the city spread its dark life upon the earth of a new world, rooted there, sensitive to its richest beauty, but so completely removed from those foreign contacts which harden and protect, that 32 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN at the very breath of conquest it vanished. The whole world of its unique associations sank back into the ground to be reénkindled, never. Never, at least, save in spirit; a spirit mysterious, constructive, independent, puissant with natural wealth; light, if it may be, as feathers; a spirit lost in that soil. Scarcely an element in the city’s incredible organization but evidenced an intellectual vigor full of resource and delicacy which had given it distinction. Half land and half water the streets were navigated by canoes and bridged at the intersec- tions by structures of great timbers over which ten horses could go abreast. For water supply a masonry pipe, two paces broad and five feet high, ran from the mainland over one of the great causeways, carrying excellent drinking water. There were two such aqueducts, side by side, each to be used alter- nately while the other was cleaning. There were public squares, and one of great size surrounded by porticoes where daily sixty thousand souls engaged in buying and selling under the supervision of twelve central magistrates and numbers of inspectors. Here “everything which the world affords” was offered for purchase, from the personal services of laborers and porters to the last refinements of bijouterie; gold, silver, lead, brass, copper, tin; wrought and unwrought stone, bricks burnt and unburnt, timber hewn and unhewn, of ‘different sorts; game of every variety, fowls, quails, partridges, wild ducks, parrots, pigeons, reed-birds, sparrows, eagles, hawks, owls, likewise the skins of some birds of prey with their feath- ers, head, beak and claws; rabbits, hares, deer and little dogs, which they raised for eating; wood and coals in abundance and brasiers of earthenware for burning coals; mats of various kinds; all kinds of green vegetables, especially onions, leeks, watercresses, nasturtium, sorrel, artichokes and golden thistle; fruits, fish, honey, grain—either whole, in the form of flour or baked into loaves; different kinds of cotton thread of all colors; jars, jugs, pots and an endless variety of vessels, all — made of fine clay, most of them glazed and painted; eggs, cakes, patés of birds and fish; wine from the maguey;; finally ee eee DESTRUCTION OF TENOCHTITLAN 33 everything that could be found throughout the whole country was sold there, each kind of merchandise in a separate street or quarter of the market assigned to it exclusively, and thus the best order was preserved. There was an herb street, there were shops where they shaved and washed the head, and res- taurateurs who furnished food and drink at a price. Large numbers of temples existed throughout the great city, but for grandeur and excellence of architectural detail one far surpassed the rest. Forty towers, lofty and well built, rose from within its sacred precinct, the largest of which, con- structed of hewn stone remarkably hard in texture, had fifty steps leading to its main body. A mass higher than the ca- thedral of Seville. Three halls of wonderful extent and height, adorned with figures sculptured in wood and stone, contained the principal idols. And from these, through very small doors, opened the chapels, to which no light was admitted, nor any person except the priests, and not all of them. Decorated with curious imagery in stone, the woodwork carved in relief and painted with figures of monsters and other things, un- paved, darkened and bloodstained, it was in these chapels that the religious practices which so shocked the Christian were performed. Here it was that the tribe’s deep feeling for a reality that stems back into the permanence of remote origins had its firm hold. It was the earthward thrust of their logic; _ blood and earth; the realization of their primal and continuous identity with the ground itself, where everything is fixed in darkness. The priests in black robes, tribal men, never cutting or combing the hair; the instinctive exclusion of women from all places of worship; the debarring of priests from female society: it was a ceremonial acknowledgment of the deep sex- less urge of life itself, the hungry animal, underlying all other power; the mysterious secret of existence whose cruel beauty they, the living, inherited from the dead. The same for their sculpture. It is the mystery of the past which monsters, gro- tesques, beasts combined with the human, truly signify—gen- tle animal associations distorted by the invasions of night— 34 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN and not a debased instinct whose reliance is necessarily upon oppression and fear. The earth is black and it is there: only art advances. The figures of the idols themselves were of extra-human size and composed, significantly, of a paste of seeds and leguminous plants, commonly used for food, ground and mixed together and kneaded with human blood, the whole when completed being consecrated with a bath of blood from the heart of a living victim. The chief of these idols Cortez precipitated from their pedestals and cast down the temple steps; an act of extraordinary daring; at the same time puri- fying the chapels and setting up in them images of Our Lady and the saints. Such a stroke could not fail to have proved of the most serious consequence to all had not Montezuma again displayed his tact, self-control and remarkable grasp of the changing situation. The new state of affairs was accepted, human sacrifice was abolished and the orderly significance of the events taking place was publicly made evident. In per- son, together with many of the principal citizens, he, Monte- zuma, assisted at the final purification of the chapels. Whether or not this be evidence on the Aztec’s part of weak- ness or the deepest forbearance, surely nothing like it for quiet flexibility of temper and retained dignity has ever been re- corded. Perhaps by a sudden, daring stroke this man might have rid himself of the intestine enemy who was each day, each week, striking deeper at the nation’s life. Perhaps fear had unmanned him. Perhaps what we call forbearance was no more than the timidity which is an overwhelming agony of heart inspired by the sight of a resistless force aimed at our destruction. Still, if this be so, Montezuma has left no trace of cowardice upon the records. But weakling or genius, about the suave personality of this barbaric chieftain the liveliest, most airily expansive moods of the race did flower, just as the black permanence of tribal understanding stood rooted in the priesthood. Perhaps it was a conscious knowledge of this that inspired and moved Montezuma in the present action. Surely no other prince has lived, or will ever live, in such es a. ee a ™ Oe a Ta DESTRUCTION OF TENOCHTITLAN 35 state as did this American cacique. The whole waking aspira- tions of his people, opposed to and completing their religious sense, seemed to come off in him and in him alone: the drive upward, toward the sun and the stars. He was the very per- son of their ornate dreams, so delicate, so prismatically color- ful, so full of tinkling sounds and rhythms, so tireless of in- vention. Never was such a surface lifted above the isolate blackness of such profound savagery. It is delightful to know that Montezuma changed his clothes four times a day, donning four different suits, entirely new, which he never wore again; that at meals he was served in a great clean-swept chamber on mats upon the floor, his food being kept warm in chafing dishes containing live coals; that at meals he sat upon a small cushion “curiously wrought of leather.” But nowhere in his state was the stark power of beauty, the refined and the barbaric, so exquisitely expressed as in his smaller palaces and places of amusement. ‘What can be more wonderful than that a bar- barous monarch, as he is, should have every object in his do- main imitated in gold, silver, precious stones and feathers; the gold and silver being wrought so naturally as not to be sur- passed by any smith in the world; the stonework executed with such perfection that it is difficult to conceive what instru- ments could have been used, and the feather work superior tothe finest production in wax and embroidery.” “There is one palace inferior to the rest, attached to which is a beautiful garden with balconies extending over it supported by marble columns and having a floor formed of jasper elegantly inlaid. Belonging to it are ten pools, in which are kept the different - species of water birds found in the country, all domesticated: for the sea birds there are pools of salt water and for the river birds, fresh water. Each species being supplied with the food natural to it when wild. Over the pools are corridors and galleries, to which Montezuma resorts, and from which~he can look out and amuse himself with the sight of the birds there.” “In an apartment of the same palace there are men, women and children whose faces, bodies, hair, eyebrows and 86 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN eyelashes were white from birth.” “The Emperor has another very beautiful palace, with a large courtyard, paved with handsome flags in the style of a chessboard. ‘There are cages about nine feet in height and six paces square, each of which is half covered with a roof of tiles, and the other half has over it a wooden grate, skilfully made. Every cage contains a bird of prey, of all species.” “In the same palace there are several large halls on the ground floor, filled with im- mense cages built of heavy pieces of timber, well put together, in which are kept lions, wolves, foxes and a great variety of other animals of the cat kind.” “The care of these animals and birds is assigned to three hundred men.” Daily the Em- peror’s wine cellar and larder were open to all who wished to eat and drink. His meals were served by three or four hundred youths who brought on an infinite variety of dishes; mdeed, whenever he dined or supped, the table was loaded with every kind of fish, flesh, fruits and vegetables which the country afforded. Both at the beginning and end of every meal they furnished water for the hands, and the napkins used « on these occasions were never employed a second time. And then the end: Cortez had demanded gold from the first. To satisfy him, small groups of two Spaniards and two Indians, bearing the proper credentials, had been despatched about the Aztec’s domain, to distances in some cases of several hundred miles, that the tribute be collected. On one of these forays the two Christians were killed. Cortez immediately seized the person of Montezuma, together with his daughters and sons, imprisoning them in the garrison-fortress. From that time on, it was merely a matter of detail and of time as to what form the final catastrophe would take. Events shifted back and forth until in May, seven months after the Span- iards’ first entrance to the city, the people laid siege to the intolerable intruders, determined to have done with them. In answer to shouts from outside, Montezuma, a prisoner within, had appeared on the ramparts of the besieged fortress whence he implored his people to give over their attacks. In reply he a : DESTRUCTION OF TENOCHTITLAN 37 was struck on the head by a stone which killed him, Only the horse and the ordnance saved the Christians on that memorable retreat across the great causeway. Fighting madly to escape with some remnant of his forces through the masses of the enemy, and to retain at the same time his prisoners and treas- ure, Cortez lost everything. The children of Montezuma, the gold, everything perished over the sides of the breached and beleaguered avenue across the lake down which the Spaniards retreated, foot by foot, with swarms of Indians flinging them- selves continually upon them. They escaped. Some months later they returned and continued the destruction, this time deliberately and with calculated malintention. Tenochtitlan surrounded, the water supply cut off, the augmented Spanish forces began to burrow forward and after weeks of desperate effort they succeeded in their plans. It was the horses the Indians feared most. At one time they had Cortez in their very hands only to have them cut off at the wrists by his fol- lowers. But nothing could bemuse them now. They knew now what it all meant and they opposed themselves to the intruder inflexibly and without murmur until the end. Neither the overwhelming means used against them, their desertion by friends of the nearby tribes, the lack of water, starvation, nor attempts to inspire them with fear, made the slightest im- pression. ‘To every advance made inviting them to parley they had but the one answer: no! Cortez, dejected, seeing that it would be necessary to exterminate them before.he could succeed in taking the city and dreading the horror of such a course, decided with reluctance, in order to impress them, to burn the noble edifices in the great square which had served Montezuma for aviaries. “It grieved me much but it grieved the enemy more.” Each day he heard mass and returned to the city to renew the attack upon the now nearly starved in- habitants who had retreated to the market quarter and there still held out. At one time during a successful sally the In- - dians had killed two of the Spanish horses and in great spirits had sent the severed heads by messengers in canoes to the sur- 38 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN rounding tribes for them to come to the rescue, but none dared. Most had already joined the Christian in his irresistible pur- pose. But Guatemotzin, the young nephew of Montezuma, would not give in. Women and children reduced to the last extremity by hunger and privation were wandering dazed about the streets when the Spaniards had made their final charge. But Guatemotzin, taken captive from a boat in an effort to get to the mainland, still maintained his pride and integrity of spirit. He had done all that he could and he was beaten. Placing his hand upon the hilt of Cortez’ dagger, he asked the Spaniard to draw it and plunge it into his heart. Cortez refused. Later the Conqueror tried to rebuild the city. Viva quien vence! THE FOUNTAIN OF ETERNAL YOUTH ISTORY, history! We fools, what do we know or care? History begins for us with murder and en- slavement, not with discovery. No, we are not In- dians but we are men of their world. The blood means noth- ing; the spirit, the ghost of the land moves in the blood, moves the blood. It is we who ran to the shore naked, we who cried, “Heavenly Man!” These are the inhabitants of our souls, our murdered souls that lie... agh. Listen! I tell you it was lucky for Spain the first ship put its men ashore where it did. If the Italian had landed in Florida, one twist of the helm north, or among the islands a hair more to the south; among the Yemasses with their sharpened bones and fishspines, or among the Caribs with their poisoned darts—it might have begun differently. When in the later years Ponce found his plantations go- ing under for lack of slaves—no more to be trapped in Puerto Rico, rico! all ruined—he sought and obtained a royal patent to find more in the surrounding islands. He was granted the right to hunt out and to take the Caribs; the Caribs whom The Great Maker had dropped through a hole in the sky among their islands; they whose souls lived in their bodies, many souls in one body; they who fought their enemies, ate them; whose gods lived, Mabouya, in the forest, Oumekon, by the sea—there were other gods— His ship came into Guadeloupe—the great sulphur cone back of the water. He had arrived straight from Spain, hot foot after niggers. Having much soiled linen aboard from the long trip, he ordered his laundresses ashore, with a body of troops to guard them, where a stream could be observed com- ing down to the sea. 39 40 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN It was a paradise. A stream of splashing water, the lux- uriant foliage. A gorge, a veritable tunnel led upstream be- tween cliffwalls covered by thick vines in flower attended by ensanguined hummingbirds which darted about from cup to cup in the green light. But the soul of the Carib was on the alert among the leaves. It was too late. Fierce and implacable we kill them but their souls domi- nate us. Our men, our blood, but their spirit is master. It enters us, it defeats us, it imposes itself. We are moderns— madmen at Paris—all lacking in a ground sense of cleanliness. It is the Caribs leaping out, facing the arquebuses, thinking it thunder, looking up at the sky: No rain! No clouds! Then the second volley. Their comrades bleeding, dead. Kill! Not a Spaniard but they stretched out in the streambed. Hagh, I can hear the laundresses squeal on the shore—run hither and thither. The devils had them safe. Let old Ponce sit up in his hammock on the poop of his ship. Let him send other boats ashore. The Indians have grabbed up the women. Three naked savages shot through the chest from behind be- fore they could gain the forest rolled over and gripped the females they had been carrying by the throat with their teeth. Worth being a laundress to be carried off that way, eh? Nice psychologic study, those women. And the damned blood- hound, Berrescien. Ponce had got his belly full. They out- flanked him in canoes, ridiculed his strategy, took his chain- shot in the chest and came back for more. They drove him off, so much so that they made him forget his dog, the pre- cious Berrescien, of whom he thought more, that and his hidal- gan pride, than—a population. The hound had been left behind in their scared flight. They saw him, they in the re- treating boats, leap from the woods in pursuit of a flying Carib. Listen to this. The Indian swam out, the Spaniards in the boats turned back for the beast. The dog was steadily gaining on his victim. But, O Soul of the New World, the man had his bow and arrow with him as he swam. ‘Tell that to Wilson. He stopped, turned, raised his body half out of FOUNTAIN OF ETERNAL YOUTH 4 the water, treading it, and put a bolt into the damned hound’s throat—whom sharks swallowed. Then to shore, not forget- ting—leaping to safety—to turn and spit back the swallowed _chainshot, a derisive yell at the Christians. They had the women and the dog. They left what they had defeated, to—us. * 8 & If men inherit souls this is the color of mine. We are, too, the others. Think of them! ‘The main islands were thickly populated with a peaceful folk when Christ-over found them. But the orgy of blood which followed, no man has written. We are the slaughterers. It is the tortured soul of our world. Indians have no souls; that was it. That was what they said. But they knew they lied—the blood-smell proof. Ponce had been with the discoverer on his second trip. He became a planter. Sugar cane was imported from the Canaries, maize was adopted from the Indian souls. But revenues dwindled where none would work save in the traffic in girls: nine years old, reads the Italian’s journal. Slaves. The Indians having no souls knew what freedom means. The Spaniards killed their kings, betrayed, raped, murdered their women and children; hounded them into the mountains. Ponce with wife and children in the Casa Blanca was one of the bloodthirstiest. ‘They took them in droves, forced them to labor. It was impossible to them—not having been born to baptism. How maddening it is to the spirit to hear:—Bands of them went into the forests, their forests, and hanged them- selves to the trees. What else? Islands—paradise. Sur- rounded by seas. On all sides “heavenly man” bent on murder. Self-privilege. Two women and one man on a raft had got- ten one hundred and fifty miles out to sea—such seamen were they—then luck again went against the Indian. Captured and back to slavery. Caravels crept along the shore by night. Next morning when women and children came down to the shore to fish—fine figures, straight black hair, high cheek- bones, a language—they caught them, made them walk in 42 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN bands, cut them down if they fainted, slashed off breasts, arms —women, children. Gut souls— * & # Thus the whole free population was brought into slavery or killed off. Aboujoubo, greatest chief in the island of San Ion, retreated in anguish to a rocky height. Ponce, now Gov- ernor, since he dare not economically murder every one, sallies out and is received by a native queen, girls dancing, gives one a gold crucifix, legend says. ‘Two years later finds her under a bush, both hands hacked off. Belly-hurt he digs a shallow grave with his sword for her and shoves the gold sym- bol into his wallet. He exchanges names with a chief, sacred symbol of Indian faith and friendship. Hounds him out later: I am Juan Ponce de Leon! says the savage, standing before his followers—hanged nevertheless. The hound, Berrescien, gone ahead into a rocky place, comes spinning back, tumbling down, knocking against rocks, a gash in his forehead. Ponce defeated, embittered has the dog stretched upon a litter of leaves and branches and carried to the ship. Do these things die? Men who do not know what lives, are themselves dead. In the heart there are living Indians once slaughtered and defrauded—Indians that live also in subtler ways: Ponce at fifty-two was rich, the murderous campaigns of his youth had subjugated the island—allayed his lust of common murder. The island was, in any case, mostly con- quered. An old Indian woman among his slaves, began to tell him of an island, Bimini, a paradise of fragrant groves, of all fruits. And in the center of it a fountain of clearest water of virtue to make old men young. Think of that! Picture to yourself the significance of that—as revenge, as irony, as the trail of departing loveliness, fata morgana. Yet the real, the thing destroyed turning back with a smile. Think of the Spaniard listening. Gold. Gold. Riches. And figure to yourself the exquisite justice of it: an old woman, loose tongued—loose sword—the book, her soul already half out FOUNTAIN OF ETERNAL YOUTH 48 of her with sorrow: abandoned by a Carib who had fled back to his home having found Borequien greatly overrated. Her children enslaved— The man, fifty-two, listened. Something has escaped him. At that moment rich, idle, he was relieved of his governorship. Vessels, three. He fitted them up at his own cost. Men enough, eager to serve the old master, rushed to his banner. Let the new governor complain that he was taking away too many able soldiers. Ponce smiled. Men whose terms of service had expired do as they please. Por donde va la mar Vayan las arenas— They sailed north. It was March. In the wind, what? Beauty the eternal. White sands and fragrant woods, fruits, riches, truth! The sea, the home of permanence, drew them on into its endless distances. Again the new! Do you feel it? The murderer, the enslaver, the terror striker, the de- stroyer of beauty, drawn on by beauty across the glancing tropical seas—before Drake, before the galleons. The rhythm of the waves, birds, fish, seaweed as on the first voyage. They even put in at Guanahani for water—Columbus’ first land- fall; then populous, inviting ; now desolate, defeated, murdered —unpeopled. March! Spring! to the north. The argosy of the New World! In search of eternal youth. In search of the island of Bimini—an old woman’s tale. The destroyer. Admon- ished that he had done enough, still there floated a third world to discover: no end—away from the beginning—tail chaser. A Carne de lobo Diente de perro he could not halt—no end. Curious that Amino—the boy of Palos who watched Columbus prepare his vessels for the first voyage and went on the second—should be his pilot. Sea scud. ‘The same piloted Cortez to Mexico. 44 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN Let them go. They found nothing but a row of white islands called “The Martyrs,” a catch of turtles, Las Tortugas, a sandy coastline, a devil of a current that shoved them about and devilish Indians who drove them back from the watering places—flamingoes, pelicans, egrets, herons—Rous- seau has it. Thickets with striped leaves, ferns emerging from the dark, palms, the heat, the moon, the stars, the sun in a pool of swampwater. Fish fly. In the water seals—back to Cuba. Old now, heavy at heart over the death of his bloody pet, Ponce retired to his Casa Blanca and sulked for three years. Then came the news of Cortez’ triumph and the wealth of Montezuma. Ponce— de Leon en nombre y podesta —the victor, now defeated, must stir again. Back to Florida thinking to find on the continent, he only then found that he had dis- covered, another Tehuantepec. But this time the Yamasses put an arrow into his thigh at the first landing—and let out his fountain. They flocked to the beach, jeered him as he was lifted to the shoulders of his men and carried away. Dead. ee ae DE SOTO AND THE NEW WORLD HE—Courage is strength—and you are vigilant, saga- cious, firm besides. But I am beautiful—as “a cane box, called petaca, full of unbored pearls.” I am beautiful: a city greater than Cuzco; rocks loaded with gold as a comb with honey. Believe it. You will not dare to cease following me—at Apalchi, at Cutifachiqui, at Mabilla, turning from the sea, facing inland. And in the end you shall receive of me, nothing —save one long caress as of a great river passing forever upon your sweet corse. Balboa lost his eyes on the smile of the Chinese ocean ; Cabeca de Vaca lived hard and saw much; Pizarro, Cortez, Coronado—but you, Hernando de Soto, keeping the lead four years in a savage country, against odds, “without fortress or support of any kind,” you are mine, Black Jasmine, mine.— * * & On Friday, the thirtieth day of May, in the year 1548, the army, fresh from Cuba, landed in Florida, on the west coast, two leagues from the town of an Indian chief named Ucita. The ground was very fenny and encumbered with dense thickets and high trees. From this place, Espiritu Santo, they began their event- ful journey, having first sent a small squadron north to find a base toward which they might travel. And they waited two months for its return “which seemed like a thousand years,” but finally the ships appeared and with good news. De Soto divided his forces, sending a few back to Cuba and leaving some others as a garrison at the place they then occupied. With the rest he set out paralleling the coast toward Anhaica Apalachi where they were to spend the winter that year. The 45 46 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN course was north and west, a march of about a hundred leagues —through obscure and intricate parts: native villages in the swamps, Caliquen, Napateca, Hurripacuxi, Paracoxi, Tocaste, Cale—outlandish names. She—Who will recognize them? None but you. To the rest without definition but to you each a thing in itself, deli- cate, pregnant with sudden meanings. * #* * The way had been difficult: through a great morass, mis- led, ambuscaded at the fords, fighting, swimming, starving for a month at a.time, thankful for a little parched corn, not even ripe, the cob and all being eaten as it was, and the stalk, too, for want of better. * * #& She—It is de Soto! all goes forward somehow. But I am before you. It is my country. Everything is in accordance with my wish. Eight men start from a thicket, naked and tattooed, your lancers rush upon them, but one falls to his knees crying out, “Do not kill me. I am a Christian! It is Juan Ortiz, relic of Narvaez’ forces, whom I have nursed tenderly for you these twelve years, teaching him the wild language. Witness my love. But I shall take him from you when he is most needed.”— * £ @ At Anhaica Apalachi, through the winter, they lived with difficulty on game and other stores, such as they could take from the natives, miserably, as best they were able. On Wednesday, the third of March, 1549, the Governor left his winter quarters at Apalachi to seek Yupaha, of which a young slave had told them: a country toward the rising sun, governed by a woman, where there was gold in quantity. Now the second year was starting. Led by the youth they continued to bear east and north in the hope of finding the country of which he had spoken: days, weeks, a month—with So ee a ee DE SOTO AND THE NEW WORLD 4W small food, such want of meat and salt that oftentimes, in many places, a sick man would say, “Now, if I had but a slice of meat, or only a few lumps of salt, I should not thus die.” But the Indians, skillful with the bow, would get abundance of deer, turkeys, rabbits and other game. Crossing a stream after nine last days of forced marching they came out into a pine grove on the far bank. Here all direction was lost. “He went about for the road and returned to us desperate.” The Governor had brought thirteen sows to Florida, which had increased to three hundred swine; and the maize having failed for three days, he ordered killed daily, for each man, half a pound of pork, on which small allowance, and some boiled herbs, the people with much difficulty lived. From Apalachi in Florida to Cutifachiqui, on the Savanna River, two days march from the sea, where presently after the greatest hardships they arrived, they had traveled northeast it may be four hundred and thirty leagues. At this place, it appeared well to all to make a settlement; but Soto, as it was his object to find another treasure like that of Atabalipa, lord of Peru, would not be content to stay. The natives were asked if they had knowledge of any great lord further on, to which they answered that twelve days’ travel thence was a province called Chiaha, subject to a chief of Coca. The Governor then resolved, having rested his army, to go at once in quest of that country, taking with him a quantity of pearls which the cacique had given him; and being an in- flexible man, and dry of word, who, although he liked to know what the others all thought and had to say, after he had once made up his mind he did not like to be opposed, and as he ever acted as he thought best, all bent to his will. So they turned north and continued forward until the fall, bending about through a quiet country. * * * She—For you I come severally as envoys from the chief men upon the road, bearing baskets of mulberries, a honey comb, marten skins and the hides of deer, and in calabashes 48 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN the oil of walnuts and bear fat, drawn like olive oil, clear and of good taste.— * & * And what? Silences, death, rotting trees; insects “so that the sails were black with them and the men laughed, in spite of their forlorn condition, to see each others’ faces so swollen and out of shape in the morning;” alligators, reptiles, a wild rose “like that of Spain, but with less leaves, because it grew in the woods.” Sun, moon, stars, rain, heat, snow; water to the neck for days; blue-butterflies among the green palmetto leaves; grapes and others that grow on vines along the ground ; plums of two sorts, vermillion and gray, of the form and size of walnuts, having three or four stones in them; wolves, deer, jackals, rabbits,— * & # She—To make you lonesome, ready for my caresses. * & # ‘“Unprepared, we believed ourselves on a footing of peace, so much so that some of us, putting our arms in the luggage, had gone without any.” Then to battle! It is Mabilla, the staked town. x oe # She—lIt is I, in my son, Tuscaloosa; tall of person, muscu- lar, lean and symmetrical. All is you; I, too, am all—one either side. Men, horses, hogs—all goes down in our fury. Now you feel me. Many times I shall drive you back from the palisades. But you come again. What shall I do to govern that lust—which if it break, I am the most defeated? Those in chains having set down their burdens near the fence, my people lift them on their backs and bring them into the town. Thus, to anger you, I have possession of all the bag- gage, the clothes, pearls and whatever else you had besides— lost in the conflagration. I am strong! I shall possess you. Oh, but I lie. I am weak. I fail. I cannot take you. What are they but savages—who know nothing? they wound you, they wound you, and every arrow has upon its barbs a DE SOTO AND THE NEW WORLD 49 kiss from my lips. There is one in your thigh, between the edges of the armor. Thrice you fall before reaching the gate! The fools, madmen. It is into my own flesh, fifty, a hundred times deeper than into yours. And me it kills—but you, though you cannot grip the saddle because of it, you fight standing all day in the stirrups. I divide myself to take you and it is myself that wounds myself, jealous even of your injuries, furious at that sweet touch of your flesh which my tools en- joy but I have—not yet. It is all you. The young Syl- vestre fainting on the back track; Pedro Moron diving from the bridge with a shower of arrows about him—swimming to safety ; Don Carlos, alighting to pull an arrow from his horse’s breast at the stockade, receives one himself, in at the neck, out behind—and falls prostrate. * # 8 After heaviest losses in men, beasts and possessions they prevailed and of the Indians all were killed, two thousand five hundred more or less, all having fought with the utmost bravery and devotion. The Governor now learning that Francisco Maldonado was waiting for him at the port of Ochuse, six days’ travel distant to the southward, he caused Juan Ortiz to keep the news secret, that he might not be interrupted in his purpose; because the pearls he wished to send to Cuba for show, that their fame might raise the desire of coming to Florida, had been lost, and he feared that, hearing of him without seeing _ gold or silver or other thing of value from that land, it would come to have such a reputation that no one would be found willing to go there when men would be wanted; so he deter- mined to send no news of himself until he should discover a rich country. So that to Tuscaloosa must be given credit, in effect, for a great victory. On Sunday, the eighteenth of November, the sick being found to be getting well, the Governor again set out, moving west, to Chicaca, a small town of twenty houses, but well stocked with maize. There he determined to pass the second 50 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN winter. The Indians, at peace, came frequently with turkeys and rabbits and other food—but secretly they were plotting other matters. Suddenly, on a certain night, the air above the straw roofs is filled with flame. Sentries and the enemy arrive in the town together; a terrific confusion, four columns converging upon the same point. Indians moving about freely in the town, because of the peace that existed, had that night brought the fire in little pots, not to be seen. Everything is aflame. Men come out naked from their. beds. The horses strive to free themselves, some succeed. 'The hogs squeal and perish. Soto and one other are all that are able to mount. He drives upon an Indian with his lance and transpierces him. His saddle girth, hastily adjusted, slips and he falls. Who will straighten out the confusion in the night? Who will gather the naked and disarmed soldiers, among the smoke, the flames, the noise? The Governor is up. He directs as best he can. But, by luck, the horses dashing about through the smoke, spread terror to the savages who think it the cavalry forming for an attack. Alarmed they escape from the stockade. * * & She—Naked, armless, acold you draw off, in the morning, to Chicacilla, protecting yourself as best you can—there to retemper the swords and await what will happen. Some are reduced to straw mats for their only cover, lying now this way, now that to the fire, keeping warm as they are able. And for this your people begin to hate you. It is my work. But again I am defeated, your last thought shall be for their safety. Because you have found no gold, only increas- ing hardships; because of your obstinacy, unexplained, in- credible to them—you will be compared meanly with far lesser spirits. It is their revenge, making you solitary—ready for my caresses. ~ And if, to survive, you yourself in the end turned native, this victory is sweetest of all. Bitter the need that at Nilco will cause that horrid slaughter: You already sick, in grave ee a — OY ee DE SOTO AND THE NEW WORLD 51 danger, thinking of the men. Let them talk, my Indian: I will console you. None but you, the wise, the brave, could have answered. * & & At Chicacilla, the balance of the winter over, once more they gathered their strength and again set out to the west- ward, beginning the third summer. There was a town Quiz- quiz. Here, after struggling seven days through a wilder- ness having many pondy places, with thick forests, they came out upon the Great River. He went to look at the river: swift and very deep; the water, flowing turbidly, bringing from above many trees and much timber, driven onward by its force. The next day the chief of that country arrived. . * * #& She—It is I. * * * Two hundred canoes filled with men having weapons. They were painted with ochre, wearing great bunches of white and other plumes of many colors, having feathered shields in their hands, with which they sheltered the oarsmen on either side, the warriors standing erect from bow to stern, holding bows and arrows. The barge in which the chief came had an awning at the poop under which he sat; and there, from under the canopy, where the chief man was, the course was directed and orders issued to the rest. All came down together, and arrived within a stone’s throw of the ravine, whence the chief said to the Governor, who was walking along the river bank, with others who bore him company, that he had come to visit, serve and obey him. The Governor expressed his pleas- ure, and besought him to land, that they might the better con- fer; but the chief gave no reply, ordering three barges to draw near, wherein were great quantity of fish, and loaves like bricks, made of pulp of plums, which Soto receiving, gave him thanks and again entreated him to land. Making the gifts had been a pretext, to discover if any 52 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN harm might be done; but finding the Governor and his people on their guard, the chief began to draw off from the shore, when the crossbowmen, who were in readiness, with loud cries shot at the Indians, and struck down five or six of them. * * # She—Well done, Spaniard! like an Indian. Witness then my answer: * # # They retired with great order, not one leaving the oar, even though the one next to him might have fallen, and cover- ing themselves they withdrew. These were fine lookmg men, very large and well formed; and what with the awnings, the plumes, and the shields, the pennons, and the number of peo- ple in the fleet, it appeared like a famous armada of galleys. During the thirty days that were passed there, four piraguas were built, into three of which one morning, three hours before daybreak, the Governor ordered twelve cavalry to enter, four in each, men in whom he had confidence that they would gain the land notwithstanding the natives and secure passage or die. So soon as they had come ashore the piraguas returned and when the sun was two hours high, the people had all got over. The distance was nearly half a league: a man standing on the shore could not be told whether he were a man or something else, from the far side. * # 8 She—Now you are over, you have straddled me, this is my middle. Left to right, the end is the same. But here in the center I am not defeated. Go wander. Aquixo, Casqui, Pacaha. Take what you will. Clothe your men, yourself you will never clothe save as I clothe you, in my own way. They have suffered, they have gone nearly bare. At Pacaha I have provisioned them in advance. * & Shawls, deer skins, lion and bear skins, and many cat skins were found. Numbers who had been a long time badly DE SOTO AND THE NEW WORLD 33 covered here clothed themselves. Of the shawls they made mantles and cassocks. Of the deer skins were made jerkins, shirts, stockings and shoes; and from the bear skins they made very good cloaks, such as no water could get through. They found shields of raw cowhide out of which armor was made for the horses. * € & She—tLook, then, Soto, upon this transformed army.— Here forty days and at the end I am beside you once more. Where is she now, Dofia Ysobel, your helpmate, years since, in Cuba? * * & The chief of Pacaha bestowed on him two of his sisters telling him that they were tokens of love, for his remembrance, to be his wives. The name of one was Macanoche, that of the other Mochila. They were symmetrical, tall and full; Maca- noche bore a pleasant expression; in her manners and features appeared the lady, the other was robust. She—Ride upon the belly of the waters, building your boats to carry all across. Calculate for the current; the boats move with a force not their own, up and down, sliding upon that female who communicates to them, across all else, herself. And still there is that which you have not sounded, under the boats, under the adventure—giving to all things the current, the wave, the onwash of my passion. So cross and have done with it, you are safe—and I am desolate. But you are mine and I will strip you naked—Jjealous of everything that touches you. Down, down to me—in and un- der and down, unbeaten, the white kernel, the flame—the flame burning under water, that I cannot quench. I will cause it to be known that you are a brute. Now it is no sea-ringed island, now it is no city in a lake: Come, here is room for search and countersearch. Come, black- beard, tireless rider, with an arrow in the thigh. I wait for you—beyond the river, Follow me—if you can. Follow me, 54 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN Sefior, this is your country. I give it to you. Take it. Here are carriers for your burdens; here are girls for your beds; my best men for adversaries. You have beaten them all. My time is coming: you have seen how they defend their palisades for me; they have driven trees into the ground about their villages. They are men, tall, slim, full of strategies; they come against you naked, with their bows and arrows; they die at the paddles but none quivers. It is me they defend. I am for the brave, for the wise, for the victor. Watch yourself at the fords, at the porches of houses. See how I have fled you, dashing into a lake there to freeze all night, coming forth at dawn, half drowned, my brows hidden in lily leaves. At the sight of your boats, at the breath of your name, the villages are left empty. Nothing can in- duce the chief to show himself. All have gone upstream to an island, carrying their goods with them. At the sight of your men in armor, terror strikes them; they plunge into the stream, pushing their possessions on little rafts, that escap- ing in the haste, float downstream. I have fled, a single man, among my own people but your hounds scenting me out have dragged me down. * * 8 Now it begins to change. The third winter past, at Ali- mamu, it is the fourth year. At Alimamu, where they learned to catch rabbits with In- dian snares, Juan Ortiz died, a loss the Governor greatly re- gretted; for, without an interpreter, not knowing whither he was traveling, Soto feared to enter the country, lest he might get lost. The death was so great a hindrance to our going, whether on discovery or out of the country, that to learn of the Indians what would have been rendered in four words, it now became necessary to have the whole day; and oftener than otherwise the very opposite was understood to what was asked; so that many times it happened the road traveled one day, or sometimes two or three days would have to be returned over, wandering up and down, lost in the thickets. DE SOTO AND THE NEW WORLD _ 55 For four days marching was impossible because of the snow. When that ceased to fall, he traveled three days through a desert, a region so low, so full of lakes and bad passages, that at one time, for a whole day, the travel lay through water up to the knees at places, in others to the stirrups; and occasionally, for the distance of a few paces there was swimming. And he came to Tutelpinco, a town un- tenanted and found to be without maize, seated near a lake that flowed into the river with a great current. * * * She—Nearer, nearer. =e ee Cayas, Quigaltam, Guachoya—thither the Governor de- termined to go in a few days to learn if the sea was near. He had not over three hundred efficient men, nor more than forty horses. Some of the beasts were lame, and useful only in making out a show of a troop of cavalry. At Guachoya he sent Juan de Anasco with eight of the cavalry down the river to discover what population might be there and get what knowledge there was of the sea. He was gone eight days and stated, when he got back, that in all that» time he could not travel more than fourteen or fifteen leagues, on account of the great bogs that came out of the river, the canebrakes and thick shrubs that were along the margin, and that he had found no inhabited spot. The river, the river. The Governor sank into a deep despondency at sight of the difficulties that presented themselves to his reaching the sea; and, what was worse, from the way in which the men and horses were diminishing in numbers, he could not sustain himself in the country without succor. Of that reflection he pined. But before he took to his pallet, he sent a message to the eacique of Quigaltam to say that he was the child of the sun, and whence he came all obeyed him, rendering him trib- 56 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN ute; that he besought him to value his friendship, and to come where he was. By the same Indians the chief replied: “As to what you say of your being the child of the sun, if you will cause him to dry up the great river, I will believe you; as to the rest, it is not my custom to visit any one, but rather all, of whom I have ever heard, have come to visit me, to serve and obey me, and pay me tribute, either voluntarily or by force. If you desire to see me, come where I am; if for peace, I will receive you with especial good will; if for war, I will await you in my town; but neither for you nor for any man, will I set back one foot.” When the messenger returned the Governor was already low, being very ill of fevers. He grieved that he was not in a state to cross the river at once to see if he could not abate that pride; though the stream was already flowing very power- fully, was nearly half a league broad, sixteen fathoms deep, rushing by in a furious torrent, and on either shore were many Indians; nor was his power any longer so great that he might disregard advantages, relying on his strength alone. Every day the Indians of Guachoya brought fish, until they came in such plenty that the town was covered with them. Now the Governer feared to repair the palisades that they might not suppose he stood in awe of them; and, lest the Indians rise, he ordered the slaughter at Nilco, to strike dread into the rest. Conscious that the hour approached in which he should depart this life, Soto commanded that all the king’s officers should be called before him, the captains and principal per- sonages, to whom he made a speech. He told them that he was about to go into the presence of God, to give account of all his past life; and since He had been pleased to take him away at such a time, he, His most unworthy servant, rendered Him hearty thanks. He confessed his deep obligations to them all, for their great qualities, their love and loyalty to his person, well tried in suffering of hardship. He begged DE SOTO AND THE NEW WORLD 357 that they would pray for him. He asked that they would relieve him of the charge he had over them as well as of the indebtedness he was under to them all, and to forgive him any wrongs they may have suffered at his hands. To prevent any divisions that might arise, as to who should command, he begged that they elect a principal person to be governor, and _ being chosen, they would swear before him to obey; that this would greatly satisfy him, abate somewhat the pains he suf- fered, and moderate the anxiety of leaving ene in a country, they knew not where. Baltasar de Gallegos responded in behalf of all, consoling him with remarks on the shortness of the life of this world, at- tended as it was by so many toils and afflictions, saying that whom God earliest called away, He showed particular favor; with many other things appropriate to such an occasion; and finally since it pleased the Almighty to take him to Himself, amid the deep sorrow which they not unreasonably felt, it was necessary and becoming in him, as in them, to conform to the Divine Will; that as respected the election of a governor, which he ordered, whomsoever his Excellency should name to the command, him would they obey. Thereupon the Governor nominated Luis Moscosco de Alvarado to be his captain-gen- eral; when by all those present was he straightway chosen and sworn Governor. The next day, the twenty-first of May, departed this life the magnanimous, the virtuous, the intrepid captain, Don Hernando de Soto, Governor of Cuba and Adelantado of Florida. He was advanced by fortune, in the way she is wont to lead others, that he might fall the greater depth; he died in a land, and at a time, that could afford him little com- fort in his illness, when the danger of being no more heard from stared his companions in the face, each one himself hav- ing need of sympathy, which was the cause why they neither gave him companionship nor visited him, as otherwise they would have done. Some were glad. 58 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN It was decided to conceal what had happened, lest the In- dians might venture on an attack when they should learn that he whom they feared was no longer opposed to them. So soon as death had taken place, the body was put secretly in a house, where it remained three days: thence it was taken by night to the gate of the town and buried within. The Indians having seen him ill, finding him no longer, sus- pected the reason; and passing by where he lay, they observed the ground loose and looking about talked among themselves. This coming to the knowledge of Luis de Moscosco he ordered the corpse to be taken up at night, and among the shawls that enshrouded it having cast abundance of sand, it was taken out in a canoe and committed to the middle of the stream. Down, down, this solitary sperm, down into the liquid, the formless, the insatiable belly of sleep; down among the fishes: there was one called bagre, the third part of which was head, with gills from end to end, and along the sides were great spines, like very sharp awls; there were some in the river that weighed from a hundred to a hundred and fifty pounds. There were some in the shape of barbel; another like bream, with the head of a hake, having a color between red and brown. There was likewise a kind called peel-fish, the snout a cubit in length, the upper lip being shaped like a shovel. Others were like a shad. ‘There was one called pereo the Indians sometimes brought, the size of a hog and had rows of teeth above and below. Luis de Moscosco ordered the property of the Governor to be sold at public cry. It consisted of two male and three female slaves, three horses, and seven hundred swine. From that time forward most of the people owned and raised hogs. SIR WALTER RALEIGH F the pursuit of beauty and the husk that remains, per- versions and mistakes, while the true form escapes in the wind, sing O Muse; of Raleigh, beloved by majesty, plunging his lust into the body of a new world—and the deaths, misfortunes, counter coups, which swelled back to certify that ardor with defeat. Sing! and let the rumor of these things make the timid more timid and the brave desperate, careless of monuments which celebrate the subtle conversions of sense and let truth go unrecognized. Sing! and make known Raleigh, who would found colonies; his England become a mouthful of smoke sucked from the embers of a burnt weed. And if the nations, well founded on a million hindrances, taxes, laws and laws to annul laws must have a monument, let it be here im- plied: this undersong, this worm armed to gnaw away lies and to release—Raleigh: if it so please the immortal gods. Sing of his wisdom, O Muse: The truth is that all nations, how remote soever, being all reasonable creatures, and enjoy- ing one and the same imagination and fantasy, have devised, according to their means and materials, the same things. They all have lighted on the invention of bows and ar- rows; all have targets and wooden swords, all have instru- ments to encourage them to fight, all that have corn beat it in mortars and make cakes, baking them upon slate stones; all devised laws without any grounds had from the scriptures or from Aristotle’s Politick, whereby they are governed; all that dwell near their enemies impale their villages, to save them- selves from surprise. Yea, besides the same inventions, all have the same natural impulsions; they follow nature in the choice of many wives; and there are among them which, out of a kind of wolfish ferocity, eat man’s flesh; yea, most of them 59 , 60 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN believe in a second life, and they are all of them idolators in one kind or another.—— These things, still chewing, he chewed out. And as an atheist, with Marlow, they would have burned him. It was his style! To the sea, then! mixed with soundest sense—on sell- ing cannon to one’s enemies. But through all else, O Muse, say that he penetrated to the Queen ! Sing! O Muse and say, he was too mad in love, too clear, too desperate for her to trust upon great councils. He was not England, as she was. She held him, but she was too shrewd a woman not to know she held him as a woman, she, the Queen; which left an element. Say that he was made and cracked by majesty, knew that devotion, tasted that wisdom ‘and became too wise—and she all eyes and wit looking through until her man, her Raleigh became thin, light, a spirit. ~ He was the whetter, the life giver through the Queen—but wounded cruelly. In this desperate condition, willless, inspired, the tool of a woman, flaming, falling, being lifted up, robbed of himself to feed her, caught, dispatched, starting, held again, giving yet seeking round the circle for an outlet: this was, herself; but what, O Muse, of Raleigh, that proud man? Say, first, he was the breath of the Queen—for a few years; say, too, that he had traveled much before he knew her, that he had seen the tropics and explored the Orinoco River for a hundred miles. Then say, O Muse, that now he saw himself afar, that he became—America! that he con- ceived a voyage from perfection to find—an England new again; to found a colony; the outward thrust, to seek. But it turned out to be a voyage on the body of his Queen: Eng- land, Elizabeth—Virginia! He sent out colonists, she would not let him go himself; nothing succeeded. It was a venture in the crook of a lady’s q finger, pointing, then curving in. Virginia? It was the nail upon that finger. O Raleigh! nowhere, everywhere—and noth- 7 ing. Declare, O Muse, impartially, how he had gone with the SIR WALTER RALEIGH 61 English fleet to strike at Spain and how she called him back— Sire, do you not know, you!? These women are my person. What have you dared to do? How have you dared, without my order, to possess yourself of what is mine? Marry this woman! Sing, O Muse, with an easy voice, how she, Elizabeth, she England, she the Queen—deserted him; Raleigh for Leicester, Essex now for Raleigh; she Spencer whom he friended, she “The Faery Queen,” she Guiana, she Virginia, she atheist, she “my dear friend Marlow,” she rents, rewards, honors, influ- ence, reputation, she “the fundamental. laws of human knowl- edge,” she prison, she tobacco, the introduction of potatoes to the Irish soil: It is the body of the Queen stirred by that plough—now all withdrawn. O Muse, in that still pasture where you dwell amid the hardly noticed sounds of water falling and the little cries of crickets and small birds, sing of Virginia floating off: the broken chips of Raleigh: the Queen is dead. O Virginia! who will gather you again as Raleigh had you gathered? science, wisdom, love, despair. O America, the deathplace of his son! It is Raleigh, anti-tropical. It is the cold north, flaring up in ice again. What might he have known, what seen, O Muse?—Shoal water where we smelt so sweet and so strong a smell, as if we had been in the midst of some delicate garden; and keeping good watch and keeping but slack sail—we arrived upon the coast; a land so full of grapes as the very beating and surge of the sea overflow them, such plenty, as well there as in all places else, on the sand and on the green soil on the hills, as well as every little shrub, as also climbing towards the tops of high cedars, that in all the world I think a like abundance is not to be found. And from below the hill such a flock of cranes, mostly white, arose with such a cry as if an army of men had shouted all together.—He might have seen the brother of the king, Granganimo, with copper cap, whose wife, comely and bashful, might have come aboard the ship, her brows bound 62 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN with white coral; or running out to meet them very cheerfully, at Roanoak, plucked off his socks and washed his feet in warm water. A people gentle, loving, faithful, void of all guile and treason. Earthen pots, large, white and sweet and wooden platters of sweet timber. Sing, O Muse and say, there is a spirit that is seeking through America for Raleigh: in the earth, the air, the waters, up and down, for Raleigh, that lost man: seer who failed, planter who never planted, poet whose works are questioned, leader without command, favorite deposed—but one who yet gave title for his Queen, his England, to a coast he never saw but grazed alone with genius. Question him in hell, O Muse, where he has gone, and when there is an answer, sing and make clear the reasons that he gave for that last blow. Why did he send his son into that tropic jungle and not go himself, upon so dangerous an er- rand? And when the boy had died why not die too? Why England again and force the new King to keep his promise and behead him? VOYAGE OF THE MAYFLOWER HE Pilgrims were seed of Tudor England’s lusty blos- soming. The flamboyant force of that zenith, spent, be- came in them hard and little. Among such as they its precarious wealth of petals sank safely within bounds to lie dreaming or floating off while the Restoration throve, a swel- tering seclusion of the hothouse, surrounded by winter’s cold. In those little pips a nadir, sure as the sun, was reached, in which lay the character of beginnings in North America. As particles stripped of wealth, mortifying as they were mor- tified, “predicateurs,” greatly suffering, greatly prepared to suffer, they were the perfect sprout for the savage continent God had driven them to. But Puritans, as they were called, if they were pure it was more since they had nothing in them of fulfillment than because of positive virtues. By their very emptiness they were the fiercest element in the battle to establish a European life on the New World. The first to come as a group, of a desire sprung within themselves, they were the first American democracy—and it was they, in the end, who would succeed in making everything like them- selves. No man led them; there was none. The leaders had _ failed long since for them at home—if there ever had been any —and those still at home were still more removed from them ' than ever. Stripped and little they came resting on no author- ity but the secret warmth of their tight-locked hearts. But, unhappily, never had they themselves nor has any one pene- trated there to see what was contained. The emptiness about them was sufficient terror for them not to look further. The jargon of God, which they used, was their dialect by which they kept themselves surrounded as with a palisade. They 63 64 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN pleaded weakness, they called continually for help (while work- ing shrewdly with their own hands all the while), they asked protection—but the real help had been to make them small, small and several, several and each as a shell for his own “soul.” And the soul? a memory (or a promise), a flower sheared away —nothing. Theirs is the secret of fairy tales, the descent of the “soul” into picturesque smallness: children, dwarfs, elves; the diminu- tive desires of the lowly for—they scarcely know what. ‘The “God” of the Pilgrims is redolent of these mysteries. All their fears, their helplessness, the uncertainty of their force—have the quality of such lore. The pathetic detail of the rough sailor who cursed the poor people and what happened to him is strongly in this mood. It shows also the collective sense of the destiny common to lowly people. i From the outset they had had trouble, then the account goes on:—“These troubles being blowne over, and now all be- ing compacte together in one shipe, they put to sea again with a prosperous winde, which continued diverce days together, which was some incouragement unto them; yet according to ye usuall maner many were afflicted with sea sickness. And I may not omit here a spetial worke of God’s providence. Ther was a proud and very profane younge man, one of ye sea- men, of a lustie body, which made him the more hauty; he _ would allway be contemning ye poore people in their sickness, _ and cursing them dayly with greeous execrations, and did not let to tell them, that he hoped to cast halfe of them over board — before they came to their journey’s end, and to make merry with what they had; and if he were by any gently reproved he ~ would curse and swear most bitterly. But it pleased God be- — fore they came halfe seas over, to smite this yong man with a greeveous disease, of which he dyed in a desperate maner, — and so was himself ye first yt was throwne overboard. Thus — his curses light on his owne head; and it was an astonishment to all his fellows for they noted it to be ye just hand of God upon him.” 4 VOYAGE OF THE MAYFLOWER 65 _ The dreadful and curious thing is that men, despoiled and having nothing, must long most for that which they have not and so, out of the intensity of their emptiness imagining they are full, deceive themselves and all the despoiled of the world into their sorry beliefs. It is the spirit that existing nowhere in them is forced into their dreams. The Pilgrims, they, the seed, instead of growing, looked black at the world and damn- ing its perfections praised a zero in themselves. The inver- sion of a Gothic Calvin. For the Puritans there had been a decline of which it was their miserable fate never to know, while they raised their holy incantations. 'These are not the great flower of the spirit. Purged by hard experience (worn bodies from which a white dove springs), they are not all soul as they and we have imagined. JBodily suffermg was more an alleviation than otherwise, a distraction that kept them mercifully blinded. They were condemned to be without flower, to sow themselves basely that after them others might know the end. Each shrank from an imagination that would sever him from the rest. And so they stressed the “spirit”—for what else could _ they do?—and this spirit és an earthly pride which they, pride- less, referred to heaven and the next world. And for this we praise them, instead of for the one thing in them that was valuable: their tough littleness and weight of many to carry through the cold; not their brokenness but their projection of the great flower of which they were the seed. The Pilgrims were mistaken not in what they did, because they went hard to work with their hands and heads, but in what they imagined for their warmth. It could not have been otherwise. But it is sordid that a rich world should follow apathetically after. Their misfortune has become a mal- feasant ghost that dominates us all. It is they who must have invented the “soul,” but the perversion is for this emptiness, this dream, this pale negative to usurp the place of that which really they were destined to continue. 66 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN This stress of the spirit against the flesh has produced a race incapable of flower. Upon that part of the earth they occupied true spirit dies because of the Puritans, except through vigorous revolt. They are the bane, not the staff. Their religious zeal, mistaken for a thrust up toward the sun, was a stroke in, in, in—not.toward germination but the confinements of a tomb. / Everything attests their despoiled condition: the pitiful care for each one, the talk of the common wealth (common to all alike, so never the proud possession of any one) and the church—that secret inversion of loveliness; their lost posi- tion, itself, in the new land, the cold, disease, starvation—in- explicable, unavoided troubles; their committing themselves not to any plan but floating on the ocean as a seed to God— to the sea and the winds—trustful, in a leaky boat. It is the weakling in us all that finds this beautiful. So with the low condition of their words themselves, the bad spelling of their journal; treated with contempt by the least of those they had to do with, so contemned that no one would lend them money “so they were forst to selle of some provisions to stop this gape”; their continually expressed love of each other, “Be- loved friends, sory we are that there should be occasion of writing at all unto you,” etc. x * & “So they comited them selves to ye will of God and re- ‘solved to proceed. In sundrie of these storms the winds were so feirce and ye seas so high, as they could not beare a knote of saile, but were forced to hull, for diverce days together. And in one of them, as they thus lay at hull in a mighty storm, a lustie young man (called John Howland) coming upon some occasion above ye gratings, was, with a seel of ye shipe thrown into ye sea: but it pleased God yt he caught hold of ye tope- saile halliards, which hung over board, and ran out at great length: yet he held his hould (though he was sundrie fadomes under water) till he was hold up by ye same rope to ye brim of ye water, and then with a boat hooke and other means got VOYAGE OF THE MAYFLOWER 67 into ye shipe again, and his life saved; and though he was something ill with it, yet he lived many years after, and be- came a profitable member both in church and comone wealth.” This passage is perfect: the one man of it, at sea, in the merciful guardianship of God, (washed away, howbeit), rely- ing on his own hands and feet saves himself by force of him- self, is hauled back by others like himself; the minute care for detail, the note of his subsequent illness, and yet, the moral at the end. And this moral? As with the deformed sop, morals are the memory of success that no longer succeeds. But the enjoyment of the lust, the hidden flower, they martyrized as the spirit or the soul, has curious turns. Pri- marily despoiled by providence; clinging with the doggedness of a northern race, cold, close and slow to that; they become unfit, except where there exists the same sort of stress which brought them into being; the hard, repressive pioneer soil of the mind. They must have relied on vigorous hypocrisy to save them—which they did. But this they could not revere. If the “puritan” in them could have ended with their entry into the New World and the subtle changes of growth at once have started, (See Cotton Mather’s “Wonders of the Invisible World,” the prefatory remarks) everything would have been different, but the character of the land was not favorable. They did try to land further south. In fear and without guidance, really lost in the world, it is they alone who would later, at Salem, have strayed so far— morbidly seeking the flame,—that terrifying unknown image - to which, like savages, they too offered sacrifices of human flesh. It is just such emptiness, revulsion, terror in all ages, which in fire—a projection still of the truth—finds that which lost and desperate men have worshiped. And it is still to-day the Puritan who keeps his frightened grip upon the throat of the world lest it should prove him—empty. Such would the New World become. Their strength made it, but why, why the perpetual error of remaining at that low 68 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN point? It is that at which the soul, dying in them, not liber- ated by death, but dead—is sad. The result of that brave setting out of the Pilgrims has been an atavism that thwarts and destroys. The agonized spirit, that has followed like an idiot with undeveloped brain, governs with its great muscles, babbling in a text of the dead years. Here souls perish miserably, or, escaping, are bent into grotesque designs of violence and despair. It is an added strength thrown to a continent already too powerful for men. One had not expected that this seed of England would come to impersonate, and to marry, the very primitive itself; to creep into the very intestines of the settlers and turn them against themselves, to befoul the New World. It has become “the most lawless country in the civilized world,” a panorama of murders, perversions, a terrific un- governed strength, excusable only because of the horrid beauty of its great machines. To-day it is a generation of gross know- nothingism, of blackened churches where hymns groan like chants from stupefied jungles, a generation universally eager to barter permanent values (the hope of an aristocracy) in return for opportunist material advantages, a generation hat- ing those whom it obeys. What prevented the normal growth? Was it England, the northern strain, the soil they landed on? It was, of course, the whole weight of the wild continent that made their condition of mind advantageous, forcing it to reproduce its own like- ness, and no more. THE FOUNDING OF QUEBEC J HY cannot I sit here lovingly, quietly and simply thinking of that most delightful man, Champlain, without offending you? Samuel de Champlain, of Brouage, on the Bay of Biscaye, if you remember. His father was an admiral in the navy of Henry of Navarre. Here was a man. Here és a man after my own heart. Is it merely in a book? So am I then, merely in a book. You see? Here at least I find the thing I love. I mean here is the thing, ac- curately, my own world, the world in which I myself breathe and walk and live—against that which you present. No, no! I insist. We live in different worlds. _ | There is a place among the works of Machiavelli where he says that coming home at evening from the fields dusty and tired out he doffs his outdoor clothes, dresses himself for a new part and entering his study becomes a king. It is not too rare a feeling but at least I understand it. Not that I’m a great reader; I tire of books too easily. Can anything tire like a book? But to me this Champlain is the perfection of what we lack, here. And sometimes, you know, well—it’s a godsend to read a book—about such as he. Parkman says, “Champlain was a man all for the theme and purpose, nothing for himself.” Good Lord, these his- torians! By that I understand the exact opposite of what is written: a man all for himself—but gently, with love, with patience, unwilling to endure the smallest fracture of his way of doing. He knew Champlain and followed Champlain in everything. See if I am not right. At the time of which I speak he had already spent three years in North America, penetrating as far as the location ‘of the city he would found, trading, making maps, charting 69 710 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN the coast and drawing colored pictures of everything. And now, in France, he is ready to make his real essay. To sup- port his project he asks one favor only of the king, a monopoly of the fur trade for three years. Good! He gets Pont Gravé to sponsor him and, all in proper time, sets out with two ves- sels for New France, a country almost invented, one might say, out of his single brain. First the sea. The two ships heading for Cape St. Law- rence had lost track of each other, Pont Gravé’s, as it turned out later, being in the van. Then the northern coast. It is a new world this time sure enough: high mountains with little soil, rocks and sand covered with firs and birches, icy winds, hard currents and treacherous tides. But presently he ar- rived at the harbor of Tadoussac, their rendezvous, outside of which he anchored in a storm. But what has happened? Where is Pont Gravé and the other ship? The New World presses on us all; there seems no end to it—and no beginning. So too with him. They see a ship’s boat coming. So Pont Gravé has gained the harbor. Good. But there’s a stranger in the skiff. A Basque. There’s been trouble. To me there is a world of pleasure in watching just that Frenchman, just Champlain, like no one else about him, watch- ing, keeping the thing whole within him with almost a woman’s tenderness—but such an energy for detail—a love of the ex- act detail—watching that little boat drawing nearer on that icy bay. This is the interest I see. It is this man. This— me; this American; a sort of radio distributor sending out sparks to us all. Well, here’s the boat. What’s happened? Ah, Pont Gravé is here, of course. Well? ‘There was a Basque ship in the bay before him, they refused to stop their trade in furs at the King’s order. A short battle. Pont Gravé wounded. This Basque with us has come to make a truce. Champlain was “oreatly annoyed,” his records say, at such a beginning. Greatly annoyed! , Isn’t that a treasure? THE FOUNDING OF QUEBEC 71 Well, what? What to do? Well, what’s first? To plant the colony this year, this year, you understand. Everything else—aside. To begin with, he must see Pont Gravé. He is hurt but will recover. The Basque is content to temporize. There is a truce. The carpenters are set to work and since the ships are too unwieldy for the river a small barque is soon completed. In this, not waiting for a second one, Champlain, the gentleman, the adventurer, the enthusiast, drawer of col- ored pictures—is ready to go and found the City of Quebec. _ Is that weakness, not to have destroyed the Spaniard on the spot, or to have died himself? Yes. Drake would not have done it, nor would Raleigh. Columbus, yes. Yes, it was a kind of weakness I suppose—a thing priceless, miraculous in that age and in such a place. It is a pride as separate from the ordinary as—Well, these things are costly. See what it entailed. For these things show in a man. And who cares so long as a man leads, leads? I mean here is a fine energy that penetrated Canada, the cold, the isolation, the savages, but the fineness of it is all personal. It is all a fire, a lost—something that the ship, the sailors, the very theme itself does not need. It disturbs, torments, undermines the way, it is a fine difficulty to success. But you shall see. The river ascended, they arrive at the selected place. Here Quebec shall stand. But how carefully he has noted every island, every tree almost upon the way and how his imagina- tion has run west and south and north with the stories of the Indians, surmising peoples, mountains, lakes, some day to be discovered, with the greatest accuracy. And what care he takes, what fastidious pains to establish beyond point of con- troversy the exact place where Jacques Cartier wintered for- merly, that it was not where popular misconception had sup- posed but in another place—beyond the scientific possibility of a doubt. This is Champlain. Do not mistake me though. This was a great adventurer, a tremendous energy, one of the foremost colonizers of our continent. He knew our North Atlantic coast from end to 42 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN end, had been in Boston Harbor, noted the islands and what trees grew on them, had been at Plymouth—or where it should be—fifteen years before the Pilgrims. -And, in addition, had left charts, maps, colored drawings, as I told you, that are priceless now. You remember, he had left Pont Gravé recovering from his wound at Tadoussac and the Basque there with him; one watching the other ; while he himself had gone up in the barque to the place selected for his city. Immediately he set the men to work, some digging a cellar, some sawing logs and making boards of them and some doing the construction. He speaks of their energy and good spirits, saying that with such a fine ensemble the supplies would soon be under cover. But now the second barque comes up the river with its sup- port. What devil is it in this land? What special hell has had this country assigned to it as a province? “T was in a garden that I was having prepared,” he writes. In a garden! that’s wonderful to me. He was in this garden when the pilot of the second barque came to him with a story —for his private ear. Champlain drew the fellow off into a little wood, and there he heard: From the very day of setting out from France, it seems, there had been one at least who’d planned to murder him. That’s how Quebec was planted: from the first day. It is the genius of such men as Cham- - plain to attract such dooms. A locksmith, one Jean de Val, was the chief culprit, but by this time almost the whole com- pany had been subverted, only the unexpected arrival of the second barque having saved the Master from his death that night. One of the company had confessed. Is it not clarity itself? The man absorbed in his work, eager, riding ahead of his plans—and fate dogging him behind. . But now he is awakened, what does he do? What? It is too amusing! Mind you his life is threatened. He gets the pilot, his informer, to send the four chief felons two bottles of wine from the second barque, a gift, we'll say, from their 2 THE FOUNDING OF QUEBEC 78 friends, the Basques, and will they come to dinner at the barque that night? They come, of course, and there he seizes them. What then? But first he has had a session with the man himself who first disclosed the plot. I can sce that puzzled face. Why? Why? Why have they wished to kill him, him Champlain? He’d pardon every one, except those four, if he could learn the motive. Nothing, except that they had imagined that by giving up the place into the hands of the Basques and Spaniards, they might all become rich, and that they did not want to return to France. How’s that for a simple answer? Think what Champlain must have thought at that, he bred on the sea, a Frenchman —probably nowhere so much at home as by himself, out of France, carrying his own head about prying curiously into the wilderness. And now that he had them handcuffed, those four, imagine what comes next. He took them personally down the river in the barque to Tadoussac and called a coun- cil: Pont Gravé, the Captain of the vessel, the surgeon, the mate and other sailors—and himself. Can you beat it? They decided that to kill the one man Jean de Val would be sufficient, and necessary to intimidate the Spanish who were everywhere about. The other three should be returned to France for trial. So they strangled and hanged de Val and stuck his head upon a pike. To me the whole thing’s marvel- | ~ lous—all through. Then he, Champlain, returned up river, carefully took stock of the provisions which the knaves had badly wasted— and goes on with his city. (His friend replies) To hell with all that: collecting pictures for France—or science—or art! What for the New World? No. I know what you mean. A spirit of resignation. Literature. Books —a library. Good night, then. That’s not you. You! It is why France never succeeded here. It is the Latin, 14 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN or Gaelic or Celtic sense of historic continuity. Let it go back, Roman, Greek, Phoenician, Egyptian, Arab—Jew; let it go back with roots in every culture of the world. Chinese. It is the weakness of you French—planting a drop of your precious blood in outlandish veins, in the wilderness and fancy- ing that that addition makes them French—that by this the wilderness is converted! civilized, a new link in the chain. Never. Great as your desire may be. Rebellion, savagery; a force to leap up and wrench you from your hold and force you to be part of it; the place, the absolute new without a law but the basic blood where the savage becomes brother. That is generous. Open. A break through. Champlain couldn’t. The place (that more vulgar men sensed as the strength in their arms) was outraged, that is— if you are right—and I think you are. These men struck at him as an impertinence. He with his maps, for France, for science, for civilization—his gentleness, his swoons. I say, it is marvelous—if you want it, but as against a New World— it is inconceivable. It claims you, you! and you resign the office for the sake of—history. Quite so, you say. The land! don’t you feel it? Doesn’t it make you want to go out and lift dead Indians tenderly from their graves, to steal from them—as if it must be clinging even to their corpses —some authenticity, that which— Here not there. THE MAY-POLE AT MERRY MOUNT read it, is the nearly universal lack of scale. This parochialism is helped by such balanced statement as A. C. Adams’ preface to Thomas Morton’s The New English Canaan—in which the incident of the May-pole at Merry Mount is related. Adams has compared that “vulgar royalist libertine,” Morton, and the Puritans of the Plymouth Colony too closely. He has seen the time too near. He has accepted the mere chance presence of Morton in the neighborhood of Plymouth as the outstanding fact, letting his mind dwell upon that, trying one party against the other, as they quarreled in the flesh—till both are worn, in our eyes, to some unrecog- nizable, indifferent proportion. The description, “a vulgar royalist libertine, thrown by accident into the midst of a Puri- tan Community, an extremely reckless but highly amusing old debauchee and tippler,” is not adequate to describe a man living under the circumstances that surrounded Morton; its tone might do for a London clubman but not a New World pioneer taking his chances in the wilderness. It lacks scale. Adams’ pretty scholar humor can be very annoying. “Had Morton lived in Virginia or even in the vicinity of New York,” he says, “he would not have been noticed.” What of it? He did not live in either Virginia or New York and he was noticed ; so he was brought to write the Canaan, so he has come down to us and so we recognize him. Instead of quarreling with his luck, Adams should have given us a better picture. Not that one expects or should expect, in the preface to a book of slight importance, more than a simple exposition of the facts relating to it. But Thomas Morton was unique in our his- tory and since Adams does attempt an evaluation of his book 75 \ MOST confusing thing in American. History, as we 76 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN it is a pity he did not realize that, in history, to preserve things of “little importance” may be more valuable—as it is more difficult and more the business of a writer—than to champion a winner. It is not so much good history to present Morton with sly amusement in mortal and unmannerly combat with his betters, as it would be to relieve him from that imposition of his time and seriously to show up that lightness, his essential — character, which discloses the Puritans themselves as maimed, to their advantage, for survival, the converse of which—in a crooked way, perhaps, but in a way—Morton presented. No use, merely because he lived that way, to joi Morton with the Puritans; comment upon him and his book should be laid mainly elsewhere, upon the more general scene of the New World, in his relationship with its natives—to which the Puritans so violently objected. And they were dead right in that, Adams convinces us. Such a place as Morton kept at ‘“Ma-re Mount,” the yearly rendezvous of a rough and law- less class of men, selling liquor and firearms to the savages “was a terror unto them, who lived stragglingly, and were of no strength in any place;” and it was unfair of Morton—seeing how the Indians valued guns and liquor—to use them for bar- ter when the other settlers were not permitted to do so. This was the practical side of the desire to rid the colony of this man. But since the whites were armed with guns and had liquor, was it in the eyes of history wrong for Morton to use them for his trade? Another side of Puritan disgust with this brazen fellow was the moral one of his consorting with the Indian girls. It was upon this count, not the first, that they chose finally to attack him. .Lasses in beaver coats come away Ye shall be welcome to us night and day. Some of the earlier writers on the New England Indians — have spoken of the modesty of the women; Wood, in his Pros- pect, for mstance, and Josselyn, in the second of his “Two Voyages.” “Morton however is significantly silent on this MAY-POLE AT MERRY MOUNT (17 point, and the idea of female chastity in the Indian mind, in the rare cases where it existed at all, seems to have been of the vaguest possible description. Morton was not a man likely to be fastidious, and his reference to the ‘lasses in beaver coats,? Is suggestive.” This is as near as Adams ever gets to a full statement of the facts. In Parkman, “Jesuits in North America,” (ch. iv) there is a very graphic account of the missionary Le Jeune’s ex- perience among the Algonquins, in which he describes the in- terior of a wigwam on a winter’s evening. “Heated to suffo- cation, the sorcerer, in the closest possible approach to nudity, lay on his back, with his right knee planted upright and his left leg crossed on it, discoursing volubly to the company, who, on their part, listened in positions scarcely less remote from decency.” Le Jeune says, “Les filles et les jeunes femmes sont a l’exterieur trés honnestement couvertes, mais entre elles leurs discours sont puants, commes des cloaques.” Parkman says that “chastity in women was recognized as a virtue by many tribes.” Of the New England Indians Wil- liams remarks,—“Single fornications they count no sin, but after marriage they count it heinous for either of them to be false.’ Judging by an incident mentioned by Morton, how- ever, adultery does not seem to have been looked upon as a very grave offense among the Indians of the vicinity in which he lived. “The colour of their eies being so generally black made a salvage, that had a young infant whose eies were gray, showed him to us, and said they were English mens eies; I tould the Father that his son was nan weeteo, which is a bastard; hee replied tita cheshetue squaa, which is, he could not tell, his wife might play the whore; and his childe the father desired “might have an English name, because of the liteness of his eies, which his father had in admiration because of the novelty amongst their nation.” Strachey (Historie p. 65) says of the Virginians: “Their young women goe not shadowed (clothed) amongst their own companie, until they be nigh eleven or twelve returns of the 18 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN leafe old, nor are they much ashamed thereof, and therefore would the before remembered Pocahuntas, a well featured, but wanton yong girle, Powhatan’s daughter, sometymes resorting to our fort, of the age of eleven or twelve years, get the boyes forth with her into the market place, and make them wheele, falling on their hands, turning up their heels upwards, whome she would followe, and wheele so her self, naked as she was, all the fort over; but being over twelve years, they put on a kind of semecinctum lethern apron before their bellies, and are very shamefaced to be seen bare. | ‘“‘_wantons before marriage and household drudges after, it is extremely questionable whether they had any conception of it.” (i. e. female chastity.) From conflicting reports from many sources the truth seems to be that the state of affairs with respect to this trait of female chastity was a matter largely of individual inclination. Some would be chaste and others wanton as the blood ruled them or the local fashion of the moment seemed to warrant. Were a wife too flagrantly adulterous no husband would want her; thus, the case would decide itself. And so—“Morton’s inclination to boisterous revelry cul- minated at last inethat proceeding which scandalized the Ply- mouth elders and passed into history.” Book III, Chapter 14, of “The New English Canaan” presents it as follows:-“The Inhabitants of Pasonagessit having translated the name of their habitation from the ancient Salvage name to Ma-re Mount, and being resolved to have the new name confirmed for a memorial to after ages, did devise amongst themselves to have it performed in a solemn maner, with Revels and merri- ment after the old English custome; (they) prepared to sett up a Maypole upon the festivall day of Philip and Jacob (1627), and therefore brewed a barrell of excellent beare and provided a case of bottles, to be spent, with other good cheare, for all commers of that day. And because they would have it in compleat forme, they had prepared a song fitting to the time and present occasion. And upon May day they brought MAY-POLE AT MERRY MOUNT 19 the Maypole to the place appointed, with drumes, gunnes, pis- tols and other fitting instruments, for the purpose; and there erected it with the help of Salvages, that came thether to see the manner of our Revels. A goodly pine tree of 80 foot longe was reared up, with a peare of buckshorns nayled one somewhat neare unto the top of it: where it stood, as a faire sea mark for directions how to finde out the way to mine Hoste of Ma-re Mount.” Bradford’s account was very different—“They also set up a May-pole, drinking and dancing about it many days to- gether, inviting the Indian women, for their consorts, dancing and frisking together, (like so many fairies, or furies rather) and worse practices. As if they had anew revived and cele- brated the feasts of the Roman Goddes Flora, or the beastly practieses of the madd Bacchinalians. Morton likewise (to shew his poetrie) composed sundry rimes and verses, some tending to lasciviousnes, and others to the detraction and scan- dall of some persons, which he affixed to this idle or idoll May- polle.” . This gambol on the green brought matters to a head with a vengeance. Although, as Adams says, it would not have been sufficient in itself to have caused the Puritan Elders to take action had there not been the graver matter of the sale of firearms behind it—yet it was the direct cause of Miles Standish going with eight men to arrest Morton. He was taken, his plantation destroyed, after the good, round for- mula: “to please the Indians”—and he himself put in the stocks, where the Indians came to look at him very much in amazement to know what it was all about. Morton was scandalously maltreated while in the care of his captors and, due to their failure to provide food, he nearly died on the vessel which transported him back to England for trial. But as Adams smilingly remarks, had it been later in our history and on a more westerly frontier, they would just have shot him. In England, an acquaintance of Ben Jonson and others at T'he Mermaid, Morton wrote his book. 80 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN It was no great literary feat. It is, in a great measure, trivial and obscure, but as a piece from American History it has its savor which Adams dulls rather than heightens— which is too bad. It seems impossible for Adams to get clearly in mind what. Morton means when he expostulates—“this harmless mirth by younge men (that lived in hope to have wifes brought over to them, that would save them a laboure to make a voyage to fetch any over) was much distasted by the precise Separatists those moles. .. But marriage and hanging, (they say) comes by destiny and Scogan’s choice, tis better (than) none atall. He that played Proteus (with the help of Priapus) put their noses out of joynt, as the Proverb is—” Or: as Scogan, (famous court buffoon attached to the household of Edward IV) ordered to be hanged, but allowed the privilege of choosing the tree, escaped hanging by being unable to find a tree to his liking—trying many; so Morton and his men, awaiting wives from England, escaped marriage by varying (Proteus) among (Priapus) the Indian girls they took to bed with them. } This in its simplicity the Puritans lacked spirit to explain. But spiritless, thus without grounds on which to rest their judgments of this world, fearing to touch its bounties, a fis- sure takes place for the natural mouth—and everything’s per- verse to them. Forced by Morton’s peccadillo they countered with fantastic violence—and some duplicity—having the trade in beaver skins in view. Then their own true perversions enter in; for “ignorance of the law is no excuse.” As Morton laid his hands, roughly perhaps but lovingly, upon the flesh of his Indian consorts, so the Puritans laid theirs with malice, with envy, msanely, not only upon him, but also—one thing leading to another—upon the unoffending Quakers. Trustless of humane experience, not knowing what t think, they went mad, lost all direction. Mather defends the witchcraft persecutions. | COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS OF THE INVISIBLE WORLD I ENCHANTMENTS ENCOUNTERED 1 T was as long ago, as the year 1637, that a Faithful Minister of the Church of England, whose name was Mr. Edward Symons, did in a Sermon afterwards printed, thus express himself: At New England now the Sun of Com- fort begins to appear, and the glorious Day-Star to show itself ;—Sed Venient Annis Saecule Seris, there will come Times in after Ages, when the Clouds will overshadow and darken the Sky there. Many now promise to themselves nothing but successive Happiness there, which for a time through God’s Mercy they may enjoy; and I pray God, they may a long time; but in this World there is no Happiness perpetual. An Observation, or I had almost said an Inspira- tion, very dismally now verify’d upon us! It has been affirm’d by some who best knew New England, That the World wil! do New England a great piece of Injustice, if it acknowledge not a measure of Religion, Loyalty, Honesty and Industry, in the People there, beyond what is to be found with any other People ior the number of them. When I did a few years ago, _ publish a Book, which mentioned a few memorable Witch- crafts, committed in this Country; the excellent Bazter, graced the second edition of that Book, with a kind Preface, wherein he sees cause to say, If any are scandalized, that New England, a place of as serious Piety, as any I can hear of, under Heaven, should be troubled so much with Witches; I think, ’tis ne wonder; Where will the Devil show most malice, 81 82 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN but where he is hated, and hateth most; and I hope, the Coun- — try will still deserve and answer the Charity so expressed by that Reverend man of God. Whosoever travels over this Wil- derness, will see it richly bespangled with Evangelical Churches, whose Pastors are holy, able, and painful Overseers of their Flocks, lively Preachers, and vertuous Livers; . . We are still so happy, that I suppose there is no Land in the Universe more free from the debauching, and the debasing Vices of Ungodliness. The Body of the People are hitherto so disposed, that Swearing, Sabbath-breaking, Whoring, Drunkenness, and the like, do not make a Gentleman, but a Monster, or a Goblin, in the vulgar Estimation. All this notwithstanding, we must humbly confess to our God, that we are miserably degenerated from the first Love of our Predecessors; however we boast ourselves a_ little, when Men would go to trample upon us, and we venture to say, wheremsoever any is bold (we speak foolishly) we are bold also. The first Planters of these Colonies were a chosen Generation of Men, who were first so pure, as to disrelish many things, which they thought wanted Reformation Else- where; and yet withal so peaceable, that they embraced a voluntary Exile in a squallid, horrid American Des- art, rather than to live in Contentions with their Brethren. Those good Men imagined that they should leave their Pos- terity in a place, where they should never see the Inroads of Profanity, or Superstition: And a famous Person returning hence, could in a Sermon before the Parliament, profess, J have now been seven Years in a Country, where I never saw one Man drunk, or heard one oath sworn, or beheld one Beggar im the Streets all the while. Such great Persons as Budaeus, and others, who mistook Sir Thomas More’s Uroprra, for a Country really existent, and stirr’d up some Divines charitably to undertake a Voyage thither, might now have certainly found a Truth in their Mistake; New England was a true Utopia. But, alas, the Children and Servants of those old Planters must needs afford many, degenerate Plants, COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 33 and there is now risen up a Number of People, otherwise in- clined than our Joshwa’s, and the Elders that out-liv’d them. Those two things our holy Progenitors, and our happy Ad- vantages make Omissions of Duty, and such Spiritual Disor- ders as the whole World abroad is overwhelmed with, to be as provoking in us, as the most flagitious Wickedness committed in other places; and the Ministers of God are accordingly severe in their Testimonies: But in short, those Interests of the Gospel, which were the Errand of our Fathers into these Ends of the Earth, have been too much neglected and post- poned, and the Attainments of an handsome Education, have been too much undervalued, by Multitudes that have not fallen into Exorbitances of wickedness; and some, especially of our young Ones, when they have got abroad from under the Re- straints here laid upon them, have become extravagantly and abominably Vicious. Hence ’tis, that the Happiness of New England has been but for a time, as it was foretold, and not for a long time, as has been desir’d for us. A Variety of Calamity has long follow’d this Plantation; and we have all the Reason imaginable to ascribe it unto the Rebuke of Heaven upon us for our manifold A postasies; we make no right use of our Disasters: If we do not, Remember whence we are fallen, and. repent, and do the first Works. But yet our Afflictions may come under a further Consideration with us: There is a further Cause of our Afflictions, whose due must be given him. 2 ~The New Englanders are a People of God settled in those, ‘which were once the Devil’s Territories; and it may easily be supposed that the Devil was exceedingly disturbed, when he perceived such a People here accomplishing the Promise of old made unto our Blessed Jesus, That He should have the Utomost parts of the earth for his Possession. ‘There was not a greater Uproar among the Ephesians, when the Gospel was first brought among them, than there was among, T'he Powers 84 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN of the Air. (after whom those Ephesians walked) when first the Silver Trwmpets of the Gospel here made the Joyful Sound. The Devil thus Irritated, immediately try’d all sorts of Methods to overturn this poor Plantation: and so much of the Church, as was Fled into this Wilderness, immediately found, The Serpent cast out of his Mouth a Flood for the carrying of it away. I believe, that never were more Satanical Devices used for the Unsetling of any People under the Sun, than what have been Employ’d for the Extirpation of the Vine which God has here Planted, Casting out the Heathen, and preparing a Room before it, and causing tt to take deep root, and fill the Land, so that it sent its Boughs unto the Atlantic Sea Eastward, and its Branches unto the Connecticut River Westward, and the Hills were covered with the shadow thereof. But, All those Attempts of Hell, have hitherto been Abortive, many an Ebenezer has been Erected unto the Praise of God, by his Poor People here; and, Having obtained Help from God, we continue to this Day. Wherefore the Devil is now making one Attempt more upon us; an Attempt more Difficult, more Surprizing, more snarl’d with unintelligible Circum- stances than any that we have Encountered; an Attempt so Critical, that if we get well through, we shall soon Enjoy Halcyon Days with all the Vultures of Hell T'rodden under our Feet. He has wanted his Incarnate Legions to Persecute us, as the People of God have in the other Hemisphere been persecuted: he has therefore drawn forth his more Spiritual ones to make an attacque upon us. We have been advised by some Credible Christians yet alive, that a malefactor, accused of Witchcraft as well as Murder, and Executed in this place more than Forty Years ago, did then give Notice of, An Hor- rible PLOT against the Country by Wrircucrart, and a Foundation of Wircucrart then laid, which if it were not seasonably discovered, would probably Blow wp, and pull down all the Churches in the Country. And we have now with Horror seen the Discovery of such a Witchcraft! An Army of Devils is horribly broke in upon the place which is the Cen- COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 85 ter, and after a sort, the First-born of our English Settle- ments: and the Houses of the Good People there are fill’d with the doleful Shrieks of their Children and Servants, Tormented by Invisible Hands, with Tortures altogether preternatural. II Tue Tri or Briocer Bisnop, Animas Oniver, At Tur Court or OryerR anp TrEerMiner, Hetp at SaLem, June 2, 1692. 1. She was Indicted for Bewitching of several Persons in the Neighbourhood, the Indictment being drawn up, according to the Form in such Cases usual. And pleading, Not Guilty, there were brought in several persons, who had long under- gone many kinds of Miseries, which were preternaturally in- flicted, and generally ascribed unto an horrible Witchcraft. There was little occasion to prove the Witchcraft, it being evident and notorious to all beholders. Now to fix the Witch- craft on the Prisoner at the Bar, the first thing used was the Testimony of the Bewitched; whereof several testifi’d That the Shape of the Prisoner did oftentimes very grievously Pinch them, Choak them, Bite them, and afflict them; urging them to write their Names in a Book, which the said Spectre called Ours. One of them did further testifie, that it was the Shape of this Prisoner, with another, which one day took her from her wheel, and carrying her to the Riverside, threatened there to Drown her, if she did not Sign to the Book mentioned ; which yet she refused. Others of them did also testifie, that the said Shape did in her Threats brag to them that she had been the Death of sundry Persons, then by her named; that she had Ridden a Man then likewise named. Another testifi’d, the Apparition of Ghosts unto the Spectre of Bishop, crying out, You Murdered us! About the Truth whereof there was in the Matter of Fact but too much Suspicion. 86 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN 2, It was testifi’d, That at the Examination of the Prisoner before the Magistrates, the Bewitched were extremely tor- tured. If she did but cast her Eyes on them, they were pres- ently struck down; and this in such a manner as there could be no collusion in the Business. But upon the Touch of her Hand upon them, when they lay in their Swoons, they would immediately Revive; and not upon the Touch of any ones Else. Moreover, upon some Special Actions of her Body, as the shaking of her Head, or the turning of her Eyes, they presently and painfully fell into the like postures. And many of the like Accidents now fell out, while she was at the Bar, One at the same time testifying, That she said, She could not be troubled to see the afflicted thus tormented. 3. There was Testimony likewise brought in, that a Man Striking once at the place, where a bewitched person said, the Shape of this Bishop stood, the bewitched cried out, That he had tore her Coat, in the place then particularly specifi’d ; and the Woman’s Coat was found to be Torn in that very place. 4. One Deliverance Hobbs, who had confessed her being a Witch, was now tormented by the Spectres, for her Confes- sion. And she now testifi’?d, That this Bishop tempted her to Sign the Book again, and to deny what she had confess’d. She affirm’d, That it was the Shape of this Prisoner, which whipped her with Iron Rods, to compel her thereunto. And she af- firmed, that this Bishop was at a General Meeting of the Witches, in a Field at Salem-Village, and there partook of a Diabolical Sacrament in Bread and Wine then administered. 5. To render it further unquestionable, that the Prisoner at the Bar, was the Person truly charged in Tuts Witchcraft there were produced many Evidences of Orner Witchcrafts, by her perpetrated. For Instance, John Cook testifi?d, That about five or six Years ago, one Morning, about Sun-Rise, he was in his Chamber assaulted by the Shape of this Prisoner ; COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 87 which look’d on him, grinn’d at him, and very much hurt him with a Blow on the Side of the Head; and that on the same day, about Noon, the same Shape walked in the Room where he was, and an Apple Strangely flew out of his Hand, into the Lap of his Mother, six or eight Foot from him. 6. Samuel Gray testifi?d, That about fourteen Years ago, he wak’d on a Night, and saw the Room where he lay full of Light; and that he then saw plainly a Woman between the Cradle, and the Bed-side, which look’d upon him. He rose, and it vanished; tho’ he found the Doors all fast. Looking out at the Entry-door, he saw the same Woman in the same Garb again; and said, In God’s Name, what do you come for? He went to Bed, and had the same Woman again assaulting him. The Child in the Cradle gave a great Screech, and the Woman disappeared. It was long before the Child could be quieted; and tho it pined away, and, after divers months, died in a sad condition. He knew not Bishop, nor her Name; but when he saw her after this, he knew by her Countenance, and Apparel, and all Circumstances, that it was the Appari- tion of this Bishop, which had thus troubled him. 7. John Bly and his Wife testifi’d, That he bought a sow of Edward Bishop, the Husband of the Prisoner; and was to pay the Price agreed, unto another person. This Prisoner being angry that she was hindred from figuring the Mony quarrell’d with Bly. Soon after which, the Sow was taken with strange Fits; Jumping, Leaping, and Knocking her Head against the Fence; she seem’d Blind and Deaf, and would neither Eat nor be Suck’d. Whereupon a Neighbor said, she believed the Creature was Over-looked; and sundry other Cir- cumstances concurred, which made the Deponents believe that Bishop had bewitched it. 8. Richard Corvan testifi?d, That Eight Years ago, he lay awake in his Bed, with a Light burning in the Room, he was annoy’d with the Apparition of this Bishop, and of two more 88 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN that were Strangers to him, who came and oppressed him so, that he could neither stir himself, nor wake anyone else, and that he was the Night after, molested again in the like man- ner; the said Bishop, taking him by the Throat, and pulling him almost out of the Bed. His Kinsman offered for this cause to lodge with him; and that Night, as they were awake, discoursing together, this Corvan was once more visited by the Guests which had formerly been so troublesome; his Kins- man being at the same time struck speechless, and unable to move Hand or Foot. He had laid his Sword by him, which these unhappy Spectres did strive much to wrest from him; only he held too fast for them. He then grew able to call the People of his House; but altho’ they heard him, yet they had not power to stir or speak; until at last, one of the People crying out, What’s the matter? The Spectres all vanished. 9. Samuel Shattock testifi?d, That in the Year 1680, this Bridget Bishop, often came to his House upon such frivolous Errands, that they suspected she came indeed with a pur- pose of mischief. Presently, whereupon, his Eldest Child, which was of as promising Health and Sense, as any Child of its Age, began to droop exceedingly; and the oftener that Bishop came to the House, the worse grew the Child. As the Child would be standing at the Door, he would be thrown and bruised against the Stones, by an invisible Hand, and in like sort knock his Face against the sides of the House, and bruise it after a miserable manner. Afterwards this Bishop would bring him things to Dye, whereof he could not imagin any use; and when she paid him a piece of Mony, the Purse and Mony were unaccountably conveyed out of a lock’d Box, and never seen any more. The Child was immediately, here- upon, taken with terrible Fits, whereof his Friends thought he would have dyed; Indeed he did almost nothing but Cry and Sleep for several Months together; and at length his understanding was utterly taken away. Among other Symp- toms of an Inchantment upon him, one was, That there was COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 89 a Board in the Garden, whereon he would walk; and all the Invitations in the World could never fetch him off. About 17 or 18 years after, there came a Stranger to Shatiock’s House, who seeing the Child, said, This poor Child is Be- witched; and you have a Neighbor liwing not far off, who is a Witch. He added, Your Neighbor has had a falling out with your Wife; and she said, in her Heart, your Wife is a proud Woman, and she would bring down her Pride in this Child. He then remembered, that Bishop had parted from his Wife in muttering and menacing Terms, a little before the Child was taken Ill. The abovesaid Stranger would needs carry the bewitched Boy with him, to Bishop’s House, on pretense of buying a pot of Cyder. The Woman entertained him in furious manner; and flew also upon the Boy, scratching his Face till the Blood came; and saying, Thou Rogue, what dost thow bring this Fellow here to plague me? Now it seems the Man said, before he went, That he would fetch Blood for her. Ever after the Boy was follow’d with grievous Fits, which the Doctors themselves generally ascribed unto Witchcraft; and wherein he would be thrown still into the Fire or the Water, if he were not constantly look’d after; and it was verily be- lieved that Bishop was the cause of it. 10. John Louder testify’d, That upon some little Contro- versy with Bishop about her Fowls, going well to Bed, he did awake in the Night by Moonlight, and did see clearly the like- ness of this Woman grievously oppressing him; in which miser- able condition she held him, unable to help himself, till near Day. He told Bishop of this; but she deny’d it, and threatened -him very much. Quickly after this, being at home on a Lord’s day, with the doors shut about him, he saw a black Pig ap- proach him; at which, he going to kick, it vanished away. Im- mediately after, sitting down, he saw a black Thing jump in at the Window, and come to stand before him. The Body was like that of a Monkey, the Feet like a cocks, but the Face much like a Mans. He being so extremely affrighted, that he 90 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN could not speak; this Monster spoke to him, and said, I am a Messenger sent unto you, for I understand that you are in some Trouble of Mind, and if you will be ruled by me, you shall want for nothing in this World. Whereupon he endeay- oured to clap his Hands upon it; but he could feel no sub- stance; and it jumped out of the Window again; but imme- diately came in by the Porch, tho’ the Doors were shut, and said, You had better take my Counsel! He then struck at it with a Stick, but struck only the Ground-sel, and broke the Stick: _The Arm with which he struck was presently Dis- enabled, and it vanished away. He presently went out at the Back-door, and spied this Bishop in her Orchard, going to- ward her House; but he had not power to set one foot forward unto her. Whereupon, returning into the House, he was immediately accosted by the Monster he had seen before; which Goblin was now going to fly at him; whereat he cry’d out, The Whole Armour of God be between me and you! So it sprang back, and flew over the Apple-tree; shaking many Apples off the Tree, in its flying over. At its leap, it flung Dirt with its Feet against the Stomach of the Man; where- on he was then struck Dumb, and so continued for three Days together. Upon the producing of this Testimony, Bishop deny’d that she knew this Deponent: Yet their two Orchards joined; and they had often had their little Quarrels for some years together. 11. William Stacy testify’d, That receiving Mony of this Bishop, for work done by him; he had gone but a matter of three Rods from her, and looking for his Mony, found it un- accountably gone from him. Sometime after, Bishop asked him, whether his Father would grind her Grist for her? He demanded why? She reply’d, Because Folks count me a Witch. He answered, No question but he will grind it for you. Being then gone about six Rods from her, with a small Load in his Cart, suddenly the Off wheel stump’d, and sunk down into an hole, upon plain Ground; so that the Deponent COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 91 was forced to get help for the recovering of the Wheel: But stepping back to look for the hole, which might give him this Disaster, there was none at all to be found. Some time after, he was waked in the Night; but it seem’d as light as day; and he perfectly saw the shape of the Bishop in the Room, trou- bling of him; but upon her going out, all was dark again. He charg’d Bishop afterwards with it, and she deny’d it not; but was very angry. Quickly after, this Deponent having been threatened by Bishop, as he was in a dark Night going to the Barn, he was suddenly taken or lifted from the Ground, and thrown against a Stonewall: After that, he was again hoisted up and thrown down a Bank, at the end of his House. After this again, passing by this Bishop, his Horse with a small Load, striving to draw, all his Gears flew to pieces, and the Cart fell down; and this Deponent going then to lift a Bag of Corn, of about two Bushels, could not budge it with all his Might. Many other Pranks of this Bishop’s this Deponent was ready to testify. He also testify’d, That he verily believ’d the said Bishop was the Instrument of his Daughter Priscilla’s Death; of which suspicion, pregnant Reasons were assigned. 12. To crown all, John Bly and William Bly testify’d, That being employ’d by Bridget Bishop, to help to take down the Cellar-wall of the old House wherein she formerly lived, they did in holes of the said old Wall, find several Poppets, made up of Rags and Hogs-bristles, with headless Pins in them, the Points being outward; whereof she could give no Account unto the Court, that was reasonable or tolerable. 13. One thing that made against the Prisoner was, her be- ing evidently convicted of gross Lying im the Court, several times, while she was making her Plea; but besides this, a Jury of Women found a preternatural Teat upon her Body: But upon a second search, within 3 or 4 hours, there was no such thing to be seen. There was also an Account of other People 92 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN whom this Woman had Afflicted; and there might have been many more, if they had been enquired for; but there was no need of them. 14. There was one very strange thing more, with which the Court was newly entertained. As this Woman was under a Guard, passing by the great and spacious Meeting-house of Salem, she gave a look towards the House: And immediately a Daemon invisibly entring the Meeting-house, tore down a part of it; so that tho’ there was no Person to be seen there, yet the People, at the noise, running in, found a Board, which was strongly fastned with several Nails, transported unto another quarter of the House. * + * Tur Triat or Susanna Martin, At Tue Court or Over AND TERMINER HELD By ADJOURNMENT AT SaLem, JuNE 29, 1692. 1. Susanna Martin, pleading Not Guilty to the Indict- ment of Witchcraft, brought in against her, there were pro- duced the Evidences of many Persons very sensibly and griev- ously Bewitched; who all complained of the Prisoner at the Bar, as the Person whom they believed the cause of their Miseries. And now, as well as in the other Trials, there was an extraordinary Endeavour by Witchcrafts, with Cruel and fre- quent Fits, to hinder the poor Sufferers from giving in their Complaints, which the Court was forced with much Patience to obtain, by much waiting and watching for it. 2. There was now also an account given of what passed at her first Examination before the Magistrates. The Cast of her Eye, then striking the afflicted People to the Ground, whether they saw that Cast or no; there were these among other Passages between Magistrates and the Examinate. Magistrate: Pray, what ails these People? baits COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 93 Martin: I don’t know. Magistrate: But what do you think ails them? Martin: I don’t desire to spend my Judgement upon it. Magistrate: Don’t you think they are bewitch’d? Martin: No, I do not think they are. Magistrate: Tell us your thought about them then. Martin: No, my thoughts are my own, when they are in, but when they are out they are anothers. Their Master Magistrate: Their Master? -Who do you think is their Master? Martin: If they be dealing in = Black Art, you may know as well as I. Magistrate: Well, what have you done towards this? Martin: Nothing at all. Magistrate: Why, ’tis you or your Appearance. Martin: I cannot help it. Magistrate: Is it not your Master? How comes your Appearance to hurt these? Martin: How do I know? He that appeared in the shape of Samuel, a glorified Saint, may appear in any ones Shape. It was then also noted in her, as in others like her, that if the Afflicted went to approach her, they were flung down to the Ground. And, when she was asked the reason of it, she said, I cannot tell; it may be, the Devil bears me more Malice than another. 3. The Court accounted themselves, alarum’d by these Things, to enquire further into the Conversation of the Pris- -oner ; and see what there might occur, to render these Accusa- tions further credible. Whereupon, John Allen of Salisbury, testify’d, That he refusing, because of the weakness of his Oxen, to Cart some Stones at the request of this Martin, she was displeased at it; and said, It had been as good that he had; for his Oxen should never do him much more service. Where- upon, this Deponent said, Dost thow threaten me, thow old 94 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN Witch?. I’l throw thee in the Brook. Which to avoid, she flew over the Bridge, and escaped. But as he was going home, one of his Oxen tired, so that he was forced to Unyoke him, that he might get him home. He then put his Oxen, with many more, upon Salisbury Beach, where Cattle did use to get Flesh. In a few days, all the Oxen upon the Beach were found by their Tracks, to have run unto the Mouth of Merri- mack-River, and not returned; but the next day they were found come ashore upon Plum Island. They that sought them, used all imaginable gentleness, but they would still run away with a violence, that seemed wholly Diabolical, till they came near the Mouth of Merrimack-River; when they ran right into the Sea, swimming as far as they could be seen. One of them swam back again, with a swiftness, amazing to the Be- holders, who stood ready to receive him, and help up his tired Carcass: But the Beast ran furiously up into the Island, and from thence, through the Marshes, up into Newbury Town, and so up into the Woods; and there after a while found near Amesbury.. So that, of fourteen good Oxen, there was only this saved: The rest were all cast up, some in one place, and some in another, Drowned. 4. John Atkinson testifi’d, That he exchanged a Cow with a Son of Susanna Martin’s, whereat she muttered, and was un- willing he should have it. Going to receive this Cow, tho’ he Hamstring’d her, and Halter’d her, she, of a Tame Creature, grew so mad, that they could scarce get her along. She broke all the Ropes that were fastned unto her, and though she were ty’d fast unto a Tree, yet she made her escape, and gave them such further trouble, as they could ascribe to no cause but Witchcraft. 5. Bernard Peache testifi’d, That being in Bed, on the Lord’sday Night, he heard a scrabbling at the Window, where- at he then saw Susanna Martin come in, and jump down upon the Floor. She took hold of this Deponent’s Feet, and drawing COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 95 his Body up into an Heap, she lay upon him near Two Hours, in all which time he could neither speak nor stir. At length, when he could begin to move, he laid hold on her Hand, and pulling it up to his Mouth, he bit three of her Fingers, as he judged, unto the Bone. Whereupon she went from the Chamber, down the Stairs, out at the Door. This Deponent, thereupon called unto the People of the House, to advise them of what passed; and he himself did follow her. The People saw her not; but there being a Bucket at the Left-hand of the Door, there was a drop of Blood found upon it; and several more drops of Blood upon the Snow newly fallen abroad: There was likewise the print of her 2 Feet just without the Threshold; but no more sign of any Footing further off. At another time this Deponent was desired by the Pris- oner, to come unto an Husking of Corn, at her House; and she said, If he did not come, it were better that he did! We went not, but the Night following, Susanna Martin, as he judged, and another came towards him. One of them said, Here he is! but he having a Quarterstaff, made a Blow at them. The Roof of the Barn, broke his Blow; but following them to the Win- dow, he made another Blow at them, and struck them down; yet they got up, and got out, and he saw no more of them. About this time, there was a Rumour about the Town, that Martin had a Broken Head; but the Deponent could say nothing to that. ‘The said Peache also testifi’d, the Bewitching the Cattle to Death, upon Martin’s Discontents. 6. Robert Downer testified, That this Prisoner being some Years ago prosecuted at Court for a Witch, he then said unto her, He believed she was a Witch. Whereat she being dissat- isfied, said, That some She Devil would shortly fetch him away! which words were heard by others as well as himself. The Night following, as he lay in his Bed, there came in at the Window, the likeness of a Cat, which flew upon him, and fast hold of his Throat, lay on him a considerable while, and 96 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN almost killed him. At length he remembered what Susanna Martin had threatened the Day before; and with much striv- ing he cried out, Avoid, thou She-Devil! In the Name of God the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, Avoid! Whereupon it left him, leap’t on the Floor, and flew out at the Window. And there also came in several Testimonies, that before ever Downer spoke a word of this Accident, Susanna Martm _ and her family had related, How this Downer had been handled! ”. John Kembal testified, that Susanna Martm, upon a causeless Disgust, had threatned him, about a certain Cow of his, That she would never do him any more Good: and it came to pass accordingly. For soon after the Cow was found stark dead on the dry Ground, without any Distemper to be dis- cerned upon her. Upon which he was followed with a strange Death upon more of his Catéle, whereof he lost in one Sprmg to, the value of Thirty Pounds. But the said John Kembal had a further Testimony to give in against the Prisoner which was truly abominable. Being desirous to furnish himself with a Dog, he applied himself to buy one of this Martin, who had a Bitch with Whelps in her House. But she was not letting him have his choice, he said, he would supply himself then at one Blezdels. Having mark’d a Puppy, which he lik’d at Blezdel’s, he met George Martin, the Husband of the Prisoner, going by, who asked him, Whether he would not have one of his Wife’s Pup- pies? and he answered, No. The same Day, one Edmond Eliot, being at Martin’s House, heard George Martin relate, where this Kembal had been, and what he had said, where- upon Susanna Martin replied, If I live, Pll give him Puppies enough! Within a few days after, this Kembal, coming out of the Woods, there arose a little Black Cloud in the North West and Kembal immediately felt a force upon him, which made him not able to avoid running upon the stumps of Trees, that were before him, albeit he had ‘a broad, plain Cart-way, ~—— COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 97 before him; but tho’ he had his Az also on his Shoulder, to en- danger him in his Falls, he could not forbear going out of his way to stumble over them. When he came below the Meet- ing House, there appeared unto him, a little thing like a Puppy, of a Darkish Colour; and it shot backwards and for- wards between his Legs. He had the Courage to use all pos- sible Endeavours of Cutting it with his Ax; but he could not Hit it: the Puppy gave a jump from him, and went, as to him it seem’d into the Ground. Going a little further, there ap- peared unto him a Black Puppy, somewhat bigger than the first, but as Black as a Cole. Its Motions were quicker than those of his Ax; it flew at his Belly, and away; then at his Throat; so, over his Shoulder one way, and then over his Shoulder another way. His Heart now began to fail him, and he thought the Dog would have tore his Throat out. But he recovered himself, and called upon God in his Distress; and naming the Name of Jrsus Curist, it vanished away at once. ‘The Deponent spoke not one Word of these Accidents, for fear of affrighting his Wife. But the next Morning, Edmond Eliot, going into Martin’s House, this Woman asked him where Kembal was? He replied, At home a Bed for ought he knew. She returned, They say, he was frighted last Night. Eliot asked, With what? She answered, With Puppies. Eliot asked, Where she heard of it, for he had heard nothing of it? She rejoined, About the Town. Altho? Kem- bal had mentioned the Matter to no Creature living. 8. William Brown, testifi?d, That Heaven having blessed him with a most Pious and Prudent Wife, this Wife of his, one day met with Susanna Martin; but when she approach’d just unto her, Martin vanished out of sight, and left her extremely affrighted. After which time, the said Martin often appear’d unto her, giving her no little trouble; and when she did come, she was visited with Birds, that sorely peck’d and prick’d her; and sometimes, a Bunch, like a Pullet’s Egg, would rise in her Throat, ready to choak her, till she cry’d out, Witch, you 98 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN shan’t choak me! While this good Woman was in this ex- tremity, the Church appointed a Day of Prayer, on her be- half; whereupon her Trouble ceas’d; she saw not Martin as formerly ; and the Church, instead of their Fast, gave Thanks for her Deliverance. But a considerable while after, she being Summoned to give in some Evidence at the Court, against this Martin, quickly thereupon, this Martin came behind her, while she was milking her Cow, and said unto her, For thy defaming her at Court, I'll make thee the miserablest Creature im the World. Soon after which, she fell into a strange kind of dis- temper, became horribly frantick and uncapable of any rea- sonable Action; the Physician declaring, that her Distemper was preternatural, and that some Devil had certainly be- witched her; and in that condition she now remained. 9. Sarah Atkinson testify’d, That Susanna Martm came from Amesbury to their House at Newbury, in an extraordi- nary Season, when it was not fit for any to Travel. She came (as she said, unto Atkinson) all that long way on Foot. She brag’d and shew’d how dry she was; nor could it be perceived that so much as the Soles of her Shoes were wet. Atkinson was amazed at it; and professed, that she should herself have been wet up to the knees, if she had then come so far; but Martin reply’d, She scorn’d to be Drabbled! It was noted, that this Testimony upon her Trial, cast her in a very singular Confusion. 10. John Pressy testify’d, That being one Evening very unaccountably Bewildered, near a Field of Martins, and several times, as one under an Enchantment, returning to the place he had left, at length he saw a marvellous Light, about the bigness of an Half-bushel, near two Rod, out of the way. He went, and struck at it with a Stick, and laid it on with all his might. He gave it near forty blows; and felt it a palpable sub- stance. But going from it, his Heels were struck up, and he was laid with his Back on the Ground, sliding, as he thought, into a Pit; from whence he recover’d by taking hold on the COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 99 Bush; altho’ afterwards he could find \no such Pit in the place. Having, after his Recovery, gone five or six Rod, he saw Susanna Martin standing on his Left-hand, as the Light had done before; but they changed no words with one another. He could scarce find his House in his Return, but at length he got home extremely affrighted. The next day, it was upon En- quiry understood, that Martin was in a miserable condition by pains and hurts that were upon her. It was further testify’d by this Deponent, That after he had given in some Evidence against Susanna Martin, many years ago, she gave him foul words about it; and said He should never prosper more; particularly, That he should never have more than two Cows; that tho’ he was never so likely to have more, yet he should never have them. And that from that very day to this, namely twenty years together, he could never exceed that number; but some strange thing or other still prevented his having any more. 11. Jervis Ring testify’d, That about seven years ago, he was oftentimes and grievously oppressed in the Night, but saw - not who troubled him; until at last he Lying perfectly Awake, plainly saw Susanna Martin approach him. She came to him, and forceably bit him by the Finger; so that the Print of the bite is now, long after, to be seen upon him. 12. But besides all these Evidences, there was a most won- derful Account of one Joseph Ring, produced on this occasion. This Man has been strangely carried about by Daemons, from one Witch-meeting to another, for near two years to- gether; and for one quarter of this time, they have made him, and keep him Dumb, tho’ he is now again able to speak. There was one T'. H. who having, as ’tis judged, a design of engaging this Joseph Ring in a snare of Devillism, contrived a while, to bring this Ring two Shillings in Debt unto him. Afterwards, this poor Man would be visited with unknown shapes, and this T. H. sometimes among them; which would force him away with them, unto unknown Places, where he 100 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN saw Meetings, Feastings, Dancings; and after his return, wherein they hurried him along through the Air, he gave Demonstrations to the Neighbors, that he had indeed been so transported. When he was brought unto these hellish Meet- ings, one of the first Things they still did unto him, was to give him a knock on the Back, whereupon he was ever as if bound with Chains, uncapable of stirring out of the place, till they should release him. He related, that there often came to him a Man, who presented him a Book, whereto he would have him set his Hand; promising to him, that he should then have even what he would; and presenting him with all the delectable Things, Persons, and Places, that he could imagin. But he refusing to subscribe, the business would end with dreadful Shapes, Noises and Screeches, which almost scared him out of his Wits. Once with the Book, there was a Pen offered him, and an Ink-horn with Liquor in it, that seemed like Blood: But he never toucht it. This Man did now affirm, That he saw the Prisoner at sev- eral of those hellish Rendezvouzes. Note, this Woman was one of the most impudent, scur- rilous, wicked Creatures in the World; and she did now throughout her whole Tryal, discover herself to be such an one. Yet when she was asked, what she had to say for her self? Her chief Plea was, That she had lead a most virtuous and holy Life. III Having thus far done the Service imposed upon me; I will further pursue it, by relating a few of those Matchless Curi- osities, with which the Witchcraft now upon us, has enter- tained us. All I shall Report Nothing but with Good Author- ity, and what I would invite all my Readers to examine, while *tis yet Fresh and New, that if there be found any mistake, it may be as willingly Retracted, as it was unwillingly Com- mitted. COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 101 1. Tue First Coriosrrm *Tis very Remarkable to see what an Impious and Impu- dent imitation of Divine Things, is Apishly affected by the Devil, in several of those matters, whereof the Confessions of our Witches, and the Afflictions of our Sufferers have in- formed us. . That Reverend and Excellent Person, Mr. John Higgin- son, in my Conversation with him, Once invited me to this Re- flection ; that the Indians which came from far to settle about Mexico, were in their Progress to that Settlement, under a Conduct of the Devil, very strangely Emulating what the Blessed God gave to Israel in the Wilderness. Acosta, is our Author for it, that the Devil in their Idol ’Vitzlipultzli, governed that mighty Nation. He commanded them to leave their Country, promising to make them Lords over all the Provinces possessed by Sia other Nations of In- dians, and give them a Land abounding with all precious things. They went forth, carrying their Idol with them, in a Coffer of Reeds, supported by Four of their Principal Priests ; with whom he still Discoursed in secret, Revealing to them the Successes, and Accidents of their way. He advised them, when to March, and where to Stay, and without his Commandment they moved not. The first thing they did, © wherever they came, was to Erect a Tabernacle, for their false god; which they set always in the midst of their Camp, and they placed the Ark upon an Alter.. When they, Tired with pains, talked of, proceeding no further in their Journey, than a certain pleasant Stage, whereto they were arrived, this Devil in one Night, horribly kill’d them that had started this Talk, by pulling out their Hearts. And so they passed on till they came to Mezico. The Devil which there thus imitated what was in the Church of the Old Testament, now among Us would Imitate the Affairs of the Church in the New. The Witches do say, that they form themselves much after the manner of Congre- 102 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN gational Churches; and that they have a Baptism and a Sup- per, and Officers among them, abominably Resembling those of our Lord. But there are many more of these Bloody Imitations, if the Confessions of the Witches are to be Received; which I confess, ought to be but with very much Caution. What is their stricking down with a fierce Look? What is their making of the Afflicted Rise, with a touch of their Hand? What is their Transportation thro’ the Air? What is their Travelling in Spirit, while their Body is cast into a Trance? What is their Causing of Cattle to run mad and perish? What is their Entring their Names in a Book? What is their coming together from all parts, at the Sound of a Trumpet? What is their Appearing sometimes Cloathed with Light or Fire upon them? What is their Covering of them- selves and their Instruments with Invisibility? But a Blas- phemous Imitation of certain Things recorded about our Saviour or His Prophets, or the Saints in the Kingdom of God. 2. A Seconp CuRIOSITIE In all the Witchcraft which now Grievously Vexes us, I know not whether anything be more unaccountable, than the Trick which the Witches have to render themselves, and their Tools Invisible. Witchcraft seems to be the Skill of Applying the Plastic Spirit of the World, unto some unlawful pur- poses, by means of a Confederacy with Evil Spirits. Yet one would wonder how the Evil Spirits themselves can do some things; especially at Invisibilizing of the Grossest Bodies. I can tell the Name of an Ancient Author, who pretends to show the way, how a man may come to walk about Invisible, and I can tell the Name of another Ancient Author, who pretends to Explode that way. But I will not speak too plainly Lest I _ should unawares Poison some of my Readers, as the pious Herningius did one of his Pupils, when he only by way of Di- version recited a Spell, which, they had said, would cure Agues. COTTON MATHER’S WONDERS 103 This much I will say; The notion of procuring Invisibility by any Natural Expedient, yet known, is, I Believe, a meer Purnyism; How far it may be obtained by a Magical Sacra- ment, is best known to the Dangerous Knaves that have try’d it. But our Witches do seem to have got the knack; and this is one of the Things, that make me think, Witchcraft will not be fully understood, until the day when there shall not be one Witch in the World. | There are certain people very Dogmatical about these matters; but I’ll give them only three Bones to pick. First, One of our bewitched people, was cruelly assaulted by a Spectre, that, she said, ran at her with a spindle: tho’ no body else in the Room, could see either the Spectre or the spindle. At last, in her miseries, giving a snatch at the S'pectre, she pull’d the spindle away, and it was no sooner got into her hand, but the other people then present, behold, that it was indeed a Real, Proper, Iron spindle, belonging they knew to whom; which when they lock’d up very safe, it was nevertheless by Demons unaccountably stole away, to do fur- ther mischief. ; Secondly, Another of our bewitched people, was haunted with a most abusive spectre, which came to her, she said, with a sheet about her. After she had undergone a deal of Teaze, from the Annoyance of the Spectre, she gave a violent snatch at the sheet, that was upon it; wherefrom she tore a corner, which in her hand immediately became Visible to a Roomful of Spectators; a palpable Corner of a Sheet. Her Father, who was now holding her, catch’d that he might keep what his Daughter had so strangely seized, but the unseen Syectre had like to have pull’d his hand off, by endeavoring to wrest it from him; however he still held it, and I suppose has it, still _ to show; it being but a few hours ago, namely about the be- ginning of this October, that this Accident happened; in the family of one Pitman, at Manchester. Thirdly, A young man, delaying to procure Testimonials for his Parents, who being under confinement on suspicion of 104 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN Witchcraft, required him to do that service for them, was quickly pursued with odd Inconveniences. But once above the Rest, an officer going to put his Brand on the Horns of some Cows, belonging to these people, which tho’ he had seiz’d for some of their debts, yet he was willing to leave in their possession, for the subsistance of the poor Family; this young man help’d in holding the Cows to be thus branded. The three first Cows he held well enough: but when the Brand entered the Cow’s Horn, exactly the like burning Brand was clap’d upon his own Thigh; where he has exposed the lasting marks of it, unto such as asked to see them. Unriddle these Things, . . . Et Eris mihi Magnus A pollo. PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES ICASSO (turning to look back, with a smile), Braque (brown cotton), Gertrude Stein (opening the doors of a cabinet of MSS.), Tzara (grinning), André Ger- main (blocking the door), Van der Pyl (speaking of St. Cloud), Bob Chandler (prodding Marcel), Marcel (shout- ing), Salmon (in a corner) and my good friends Philip and Madam Soupault; the Prince of Dahomi, Clive Bell (dressed), Nancy, Sylvia, Clotilde, Sally, Kitty, Mina and her two lovely daughters; James and Norah Joyce (in a taxi at the Place de Etoile), McAlmon, Antheil, Bryher, H. D. and dear Ezra who took me to talk with Léger; and finally Adrienne Monnier—these were my six weeks in Paris. Adrienne is last since it was she who by her insistence brought me one of my best moments among those days of rushing about and talking and seeing, while my bronzed faculties strove to right them- selves—among the scenes and fashions of this world where all the world comes, from time to time, to shed its nerves—after my brutalizing battle of twenty years to hear myself above the boilermakers in and about New York, where I had em- barked so precariously upon my literary career. I was, during that time, with antenne fully extended, but nothing came of it save an awakened realization within myself of that resistant core of nature upon which I had so long been driven for support. I felt myself with ardors not released but beaten back, in this center of old-world culture where everyone was tearing his own meat, warily conscious of a new- comer, but wholly without inquisitiveness—No wish to know; they were served. I saw exhibitions and sat at a few tables, here and there. “Gaite” told us of her sailor lover whom she 105 1066 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN would marry if she found that he really came from a large city, as he said. Brancusi sat us by his fire, the sheep slept about us while by constant rubbing his fingers carved the neck of his staff. This was a relief but like a fairy tale. It was not easy for me to be drunk; I had only a few weeks dur- ing which to see. I enjoyed the ballets, Dérain— But it was no more than a kind of quickened sullenness. Could I have shouted out in the midst of it, could I have loosed myself to embrace this turning, shouting, rustling, colored thing, my mind would have been relieved. I could not do it. Could I have been Nancy to imagine myself a kitten and fall from a tree. I could not. It infuriated my meanness. Was it not my vanity and impotence? We did this, we did that, we drank at the Ritz bar. What did I presume? ‘These ques- tions made me shy. Marcel knows New York, I said, I shall investigate his drunken leer. Adrienne Monnier pointed to a box at the Cigale. Look, she said, how enheartening. You will see that now in Paris everywhere. Look! there is a member of the Chamber of Deputies, there is a lawyer, there is a man of science, there is Cocteau, a few beautiful women and two or three pederasts. Is it not cheering? It makes me believe again that we are taking hold. H. D. listened. Adrienne Monnier seemed to be inviting my mood. It was she who, during the dark days of the war, had written her invitation to us all to come bor- row and buy books of her; to read. A delicious savor it gave to the dinner she served us to have her lock the kitchen door and remain alone with her secret task of preparing the chicken —a la Adrienne Monnier, in the purest tradition of the Parisian art. To eat, to drink; wines, the delicious flesh, the poets—all good things of the world—these we must learn again to enjoy. Had she not wished to do with books, she would have enjoyed most to be a butcher, to kill a pig, to hear it squeal, eeeeHEEE! Bryher’s eyes snapped darkly. We looked at prints of Brughel; the great fish, cut open, dis- charging from its slit belly other fish and each fish, slit in PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 107 turn, discharging other smaller fish, and so on to the smallest. She laughed with glee. Secretly my heart beat high. Here was invitation. When you come again, she said, I shall take you to le désert. You must talk to Valéry Larbaud, she told me. He wants to see you. Why should I? I insist that you go. 7 Already from the pot of my brain the odors of foods cook- ing had begun to rise. This encouraged me to move. One afternoon I mounted a bus and let it drag me through the rain. Some laborers were taking their overcoats out of a kiosk to put them on; one of the younger of the men had a mirror between his hands which he kept holding before an old fellow who had to laugh, in spite of himself, but shyly, like an embarrassed boy, at his own silly face which he saw there. Who is this man Larbaud who has so little pride that he wishes to talk with me? The lump in my breast hardened and became like the Aztec calendar of stone which the priests buried because they couldn’t smash it easily, but it was dug up intact later. At least, so I prided myself that I felt. But after a few moments, seeing the man himself, I was un- expectedly confused. He is a student, I am a block, I thought. I could see it at once: he knows far more of what is written of my world than I. But he is a student while I am—the brutal thing itself. At the bottom of an alley which opened out into a court, as of a decayed cloister, was the doorway which bore the num- ber upon the card in my hand. It was a small room, nearly filled by a great table. He excused himself a moment to ac- company a lady to the bus. We sat and looked at each other. So it was a pleasure to be sitting in this small room, in this secluded court, with this man whose totem is the hippopotamus —slumped down in his chair, smiling and looking. He knew what I had attempted. Almost at once he began to speak out of my imagination. He presumed too much. I am not a student; presently he will ask me questions I cannot answer! He spoke of Bolivar (he was engaged with a treatise upon the 108 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN great Venezuelan patriot and liberator) bringing four fat volumes from the Spanish history upon the subject, out of his bookcase for me to see, and piling them one upon the other. Frightened I began to heal nevertheless—The English ap- praised the New World too meanly. It was to them a carcass from which to tear pieces for their belly’s sake, a colony, a place to despise a little. They gave to it parsimoniously, in a slender Puritan fashion. But the Spaniard gave magnifi- cently, with a generous sweep, wherever he was able. (This tallies with the bounty of the New World, I said to myself.) They sought to make it in truth a New Spain, to build fine cathedrals, to found universities, to establish great estates. For this I like them, he said. They came as from the King himself to transport nobility, learning, refinement thither in one move.—Valéry Larbaud seemed cultivating my intimate earth with his skillful hands, a gracious gesture (lost perhaps in its own shadows, I thought) ; here is one at least of this world, moving to meet that other which is straming for re- lease under my confining ribs—not wishing so much to under- stand it as to taste, perhaps, its freshness—Its freshness! — if it exist! (John Barrymore’s “Hamlet” wins first night ovation in London.) A herd of proofs moved through my mind like stumbling buffalo: ornaments of woven moosehair! There is the Indian. We are none. Who are we? Degraded whites riding our fears to market where everything is by accident and only one thing sure: the fatter we get the duller we grow; only a simpering disgust (like a chicken with a broken neck, that aims where it cannot peck and pecks only where it cannot aim, which a hog-plenty everywhere prevents from starving to death) reveals any contact with a possible freshness—and that only by inversion. Shall I never bring a look to bear which is not tawdry? Recruits to Pavlova’s corps de ballet, from Montclair and Sacramento, fillers-in. There are—so many things, there’s Edison, there’s—Must I make a choice between to scream like a locomotive or to speak not at all? If it be a day of delirious heat, leave your cool PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 109 retreat, rush about to find a sufferer and carry ice tohim. In the din we die—and rot into the magazines and newspapers— and books by the million—Books. We had mentioned books. We have no books, I said. __ There you are wrong. ‘Two or three are enough, to have shown a beginning. Have you not yourself proven that there is meat Yes (so he had read what I intended !), the early records— to try to find—something, a freshness; if it exist. I said, It is an extraordinary phenomenon that Americans have lost the sense, being made up as we are, that what we are has its origin in what the nation in the past has been; that there is a source iv America for everything we think or do; that morals affect the food and food the bone, and that, in fine, we have no conception at all of what is meant by moral, since we recognize no ground our own—and that this rude- ness rests all upon the unstudied character of our beginnings ; and that if we will not pay heed to our own affairs, we are nothing but an unconscious porkyard and oilhole for those, more able, who will fasten themselves upon us. And that we have no defense, lacking intelligent investigation of the changes worked upon the early comers here, to the New World, the books, the records, no defense save brute isolation, pro- hibitions, walls, ships, fortresses—and all the asininities of ignorant fear that forbids us to protect a doubtful freedom by employing it. That unless everything that is, proclaim a ground on which it stand, it has no worth; and that what has been morally, xsthetically worth while in America has rested upon peculiar and discoverable ground. But they think they get it out of the air or the rivers, or from the Grand Banks or wherever it may be, instead of by word of mouth or from records contained for us in books—and that ssthetically, morally we are deformed unless we read. j You mean such books as the Magnalia of Cotton Mather. What! Startled but thrilling with pleasure, I found that he had read the Magnalia. No. He had read it. I had seen 110 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN the book and brushed through its pages hunting for some- thing I wished to verify. Un grand prédicateur. Tus in Paris. 'Tiresome, I said I had found him. Yes, he assented, but very strong, very real. (My French became inspired, it was like a fountain when it is first turned on in the spring and all the moss and rust and loosened mud and sand are flung up with the water—I could see grotesque shapes of my desire escaping from me—and I laughed to myself in my intense pleasure.) He saw my pleasure and he likewise smiled. Quelle rire omnivore @herbes sousmarins! He had read the India Christi- ana with its two silver trumpets crying, “a joyful sound.” “The American savages were men Satan had whished away (via Asia) at the beginning sound of the two silver trumpets calling from the tabernacle, announcing the advent of the gospel.” It is the Puritan.— By the strength of religion alone, they surmounted all difficulties in which science has degraded us again today; all things they explain, with clarity and distinction. It is firm, it is solid, it holds the understanding in its true position, not beneath the surface of the facts, where it will drown, but up, fearlessly into a clear air, like science at its best, in a cer- tain few minds. For our taste, it is perhaps a little grotesque, this explanation—but firm. There is vigor there—and by that, a beauty. True enough, I said, there is abundant vigor. But to them it was, America, “the seat of them that shall think an evil thought” ; the savages were men lost in the devil’s woods, miser- able in their abandonment and more especially, damned. Fiery particles, the Puritans, I said, acquainting him with my rigid tenet, seeds of Elizabethan vigor, few against the wilder- ness. Their sureness which you praise is of their tight tied littleness which, firm as it was, infuriates me today. It is their littleness that explains their admirable courage, close to the miraculous. It was good when through that first De- PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 111 cember they were going about in small boats in Cape Cod Bay, through rain and cold, under attack, when save for the finding of corn buried in the sand, they might not have had seed for the spring planting. Going about from place to place, seeking a lodgment, drowned, frozen, awaking to the howls of savages, dawn and the attack, rushing to the boat for their arquebuses, arrows in their hanging coats, at the mercy of chance and the wind, they were themselves the corn I speak of. The things they did were of highest order, per- mitted only by lack of full knowledge, things which would have been terrifying to them beyond endurance had they not > been reduced to bear them. Their courage, had they been gifted with a full knowledge of the New World they had hit upon, could not have stood against the mass of the wilderness; it took the form, then, for the mysterious processes of their implantation here, of a doctrinaire religion, a form, that is to say, fixed—but small. For the great task God had destined them to perform, they were clipped in mind, stripped to the physical necessities. They could not afford to allow their senses to wander any more than they could allow a member of their company to wander from the precinct of the church, even from Boston to Casco Bay, ror woritpLy prorir. This their formula con- demned. For that Hannah: Swanton was punished by captivity and TEMPTATION among the Catholics in Quebec.—I mean, that this form, this rorm rrseLF, such a religion upon our lips, though it have an economic, biologic basis in truth, neverthe- _ less it is bred of brutality, inhumanity, cruel amputations and that THis is the sum of its moral effect. You speak of Mather’s books—? Yes, they were the flower of that religion, that unreasonable thing, on which they prided themselves for its purity. That is, its rigid clarity, its inhwman clarity, its steel-like thrust from the heart of each isolate man straight into the tabernacle of Jehovah without embellishment or soft- ening. Its firmness is its beauty, it seems austere but limpid. Its virtue is to make each map stand alone, surrounded by 112 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN a density as of the Lord: a seed in its shell. The Kingdom of God; the Devil at fault fighting for souls; Christ the Divine sacrifice; the Bible the guide; the Church its apostle. ‘There it is, concise, bare, purE: blind to every contingency, mash- ing Indian, child and matron into one safe mold. They must have closed all the world out. It was the enor- mity of their task that enforced it. Having in themselves nothing of curiosity, no wonder, for the New World—that is nothing official—they knew only to keep their eyes blinded, their tongues in orderly manner between their teeth, their ears stopped by the monotony of their hymns and their flesh covered in straight habits. Is there another place than Amer- ica (which inherits this tradition) where a husband, after twenty years, knows of his wife’s body not more than neck and ankles, and four children to attest to his fidelity ; where books are written and read counselling women that upon mar- riage, should they allow themselves for one moment to enjoy their state, they lower themselves to the level of the whore? Such is the persistence of this abortion of the mind, this purity. These were the modes of a people, small in number, beset by dangers and in terror. They dared not think. If frightened by Indians or the supernatural, they shook and committed horrid atrocities in the name of their creed, the cost of empti- ness. All that they saw they lived by but denied. And this is overlooked. There was a book written at that time attacking them: New England Judged by the Spirit of the Lord: it contains a relation of the Quakers in New England, from the time of their first arrival there, in 1656, to the year 1660. Wherein their merciless whippings, chainings, finings, imprisonments, starvings, burnings in the hands, cuttings off of ears and put- ting to death, with other cruelties, inflicted upon the bodies of innocent men and women only for conscience’ sake, are de- scribed. And a further relation of the Quakers’ cruel and bloody suffering in New England, continued from 1660 to 1665, beginning with the sufferings of one William Leddra, PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 118 whom they put to death. There is also an appendix attack- ing Cotton Mather. . Why does one not hear Americans speak more often of these important things? _ Because the fools do not believe that they have sprung from anything: bone, thought and action. They will not see that what they are is growing on these roots. They will not look. They float without question. Their history is to them an enigma. What superb beauty! As with all histories, it begins with giants—cruel, but enormous, who eat flesh. They were giants. — No, no. True they had their magnificent logic but it was microscopic in dimensions—against the flamboyant mass of savagery. This disproportion has no representation in the contemporary Puritan imagination. The Puritan, finding one thing like another in a world destined for blossom only in “Eternity,” all soul, all “emptiness” then here, was precluded from sEEING the Indian. They never realized the Indian in the least save as an unformed Purrran. The immorality of such a concept, the inhumanity, the brutalizing effect upon their own minds, on their sprrrrs—they never suspected. And Mather, a flower in mail, inhuman —a bee that stabs a bear. Blind seeds, I said, filled with the baleful beauty of their religion: an mmmoraL source—— A source at any rate, immoral or moral, religion, a blind- ing fury for the most part. They were seeds, a fiery concen- trate of great virtues—dwarfed; the genus indistinguishable in the egg. It is that hidden, unacknowledged bias (that they were Elizabethans) that IS their strength. It is that violent bias that as with mocking, hellish whips would drive them still to change, to grow. But the direction, the objective has been lost in the mass of the new. Never could they have comprehended that it would be, that it was, black deceit for them to condemn Indian sins, while they cut the ground from under the Indian’s feet without 114 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN acknowledging so much as his existence. The immorality, I say, of such an attitude never becomes apparent to them. Or, yes, up to a certain point it does: they brought their land in- stead of frankly stealing it and set up palisades to mark the two parts from each other; they instituted courts—but in them- selves they were like pebbles. To them it was as nothing to desecrate the chief’s mother’s grave, in the name of sanctity pulling up the stakes, to shock the spirit of native reverence. Yet it cannot be said it was the time. For there was a French- man further north, a Jesuit, of different understanding. There was a maggot in them. It was their beliefs. This rurne and its effects you will detect in Mather, in him a curious blend of learning and intolerance that’s illus- trated when he says, “there are, they say, two hundred thou- sand books in: the library which Ptolemy erected at Alex- andria: but it was the addition of the scriptures which made it a truly LeaRNep library.” The turn of the word “learned” is the image of their sophistry. Puritans, we name them, but they were not so called be- cause of moral qualities. They were not blessed with that name by virtue of a stern but just conception of the world. That is a misconception of the name. They were called Puri- tans from a stripped dogma of four noncorrosive links, they thought, a saving bond in their desolation and abandonment between themselves and God. He smiled and begged me to distinguish in my mind be- tween the rugged English pioneers and a theoretic dogma that clung to them unevenly, doubtful how much any of it was a part of any one of them. But that is it, I answered. That is exactly what I pretend to do, to separate it out, to isolate it. It is an immorality that IS America. Here it began. You see the cause. There was no ground to build on, with a ground all blossoming about them—under their noses. Their thesis is a possession of the incomplete—like senseless winds or waves or the fire itself. I wish to drag this ruine out by itself to annihilate it. He answered, That one cannot PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 115 do. Yes, I insisted, it musr be done, you do not know America. There is a “puritanism’”—of which you hear, of course, but you have never felt it stinking all about you— that has survived to us from the past. It is an atrocious thing, a kind of mermaid with a corpse for tail. Or it remains, a bad breath in the room. This rune, strange, inhuman, powerful, is like a relic of some died out tribe whose practices were revolting. But the relic will be beautiful, he answered, sometimes. I have enjoyed the books. Against his view I continually protested. I cannot separate myself, I said, from this ghostly miasm. It grips me. I cannot merely talk of books, just of Mather as if he were some pearl.—I began to be impatient of my friend’s cultured tolerance, the beauties he saw. I grant you, I said, the stench of their narrowing beliefs has been made to cling too closely to the men of that time, but the more reason then to lift it out, to hold it apart, to sacrifice them if necessary, in order to disentangle this “thing.” Very well, he assented, you are from that place. You are caught by asmell. It is good that you struggle to appreciate it. Proceed. Mather. What a force, still to interest you; it is admirable. But I find your interest “trés théorique.” What! I cried. Wait a bit. These men are not the only ones of these times. It is of books that we were speaking. It is of books that I wish to tell you. Then they live still, those books? I could not assure him that they did, those books of Mather’s. As books, no, I said to him. But what is in them lives and there hides, as in a lair from whence it sallies now _ and then to strike terror through the land. And you would be the St. George? Are they then in such a bad state in America, in such a swamp? I thought As always, I answered him. This fiery breath, as of a dragon, is to us a living thing. Our resistance to the wilder- 116 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN ness has been too strong. It has turned us anti-American, anti-literature. As a violent “puritanism” it breathes still. In these books is its seed. I cannot discuss Mather with you like that! I must grow angry. I must be disturbed. It lies in wait there to defeat a beginning to morality. Cotton Mather’s books, to you an enchanting diversion, a curious study, to me they are a vessel that vomits up a thing that obsesses my quiet, that allows me no tranquillity, a broken, a maimed, a foul thing—that they tell me is sweet, PURE. This interests me greatly because I see you brimming— you, yourself—with those three things of which you speak: a puritanical sense of order, a practical mysticism as of the Jesuits, and the sum all those qualities defeated in the savage men of your country by the first two. These three things I see still battling in your heart. This interests me greatly— and it pleases me still more that you show a taste for books. Does this indicate, I say to myself, a new force.in your coun- try? Are you today presenting me with a new spectacle, a man, no matter what his qualities may be, who has begun to reach a height but who still retains his warmth; that moment when all greatness is conceived. It is no more than a moment, it is the birth of a civilized interest in the world. No, no, no, I cried. I speak only of sources. I wish only to disentangle the obscurities that oppress me, to track them to the root and to uproot them Continue, he said. Adding, with a smile, You wish to up- root history, like those young men of the Sorbonne. No, I seek the support of history but I wish to understand it aright, to make it snow itself. Continue, continue. 7 There was, to the north, another force, equal to the Puri- tans but of opposite character, the French Jesuits; two parties with the Indians between them, two sources opposite. But first, can you enlighten me, he now broke in, what was in the middle? Who were these Indians of whom you PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 17 speak? What sort of men were they? What were their qualities? Good, I said, take Brookfield, then, scene of the famous Massacre, in 1680. The history (which we do not know) says first the whites and natives lived peaceably in this lovely, fertile valley, side by side cultivating and breeding cattle. Only after repeated evidence to the Indian of perfidy on the part of the white man—that he intended “by peaceful methods” to take and hold the land—to supplant the Indian, did he gradwally withdraw, later to strike, in fair battle, for his country. But even so, even granted, as a consequence of all this, that “King Philip” erred—if he did, it was war, open and above board on the Indians’ part and according to their methods, fairly begun, fairly prosecuted—had it not been for white savagery, a determination to exterminate man, woman and child of the disaffected natives—and ended by a proper treaty. Terror killed more of King Philip’s people than Puri- tan bullets. Shocking scenes took place. Indian women found lying naked on the ground, heads cut off and stuck on poles, _a relentless lust for extermination of the “bad” savages— because they fought, believing the whites had, in time of peace, tricked them. It was true. And there is the story of the capture of a group of French Indians under a Sachem Bommaseen who being brought to Boston, prisoners, asked that they might see an English Divine. Questioned as to what the French had taught them, the Indian replied, that the French had taught them that the Lord Jesus Christ was of the French nation; that his mother, the Virgin Mary, was a French lady; that they were the Eng- lish who had murdered him; and that, whereas he rose from the dead, and ascended into heaven, all who would recommend themselves to his favor, must avenge him on the English as far as they could. Told that this was not so, the Indians replied that if what the French taught them was false, what then had the English to offer them that was good in its place? 118 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN The minister knowing their custom to use much similitude in their talk, looked about for some agreeable object. His eye lit upon a tankard of drink which happened to be standing on the table. He said: Christ has given us a good religion which might be compared to the good drink in the cup on the table. If we take that good drink into our hearts it will do us good and preserve us from death. That God’s Book, the Bible, is the cup. The French having the cup of good drink, put poison in it and had made the Indians drink poison liquor, by which they run mad and begin to kill the English. It was plain that the English had not put poison in it for they had set the cup wide open and invited all men, for they had translated the Bible into the Indian language. But the French kept the cup shut fast, the Bible in an unknown tongue, the Latin, and so kept their hands on the eyes of the Indians when they put it to their mouths to drink. At this the Indian asked for him to show-what was the good drink in the cup and what the poison the French put into it. . He then stated to them distinctly the chief articles of the Christian religion, “with all the simplicity and sincerity of a Protestant” ; adding upon each, “This is the good drink in the Lord’s cup of life.’ He further demonstrated to them how the Papists had, “in their idolatrous papery,” in some way or other depraved every one of these articles, with base ingredi- ents of their own invention, adding upon each, This is the poison which the French have put into the cup. You need confess your sins to none but God and none but God can forgive them, said the minister. To confess your sins to a priest and submit to penance enjoined by a priest—there is no need of all this ceremony. It is nothing but French poison, all of it. The Indians, in a rapture of admiration and surprise to find one who had put them in the way of obtaining “pardon for their sins” without paying beaver skins for it, fell on their knees, and, taking the minister’s hand in theirs, began PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 119 to kiss it in an extreme show of affection. But he shook them off with marked dislike of their posture. He would not suffer the contrite Indians to lay their hands upon him, as the Catholic fathers in the north had done, but drew back and told them to address themselves to God alone. Ah, very fine, you say. But it is very ugly—and it is that which has persisted: afraid to touch! But being forced to it every day by passion, by necessity—a devil of duplicity has taken possession of us. You know, I asked him, do you not, how other means being denied them, the Puritans ran madly to orricran sexual excess—during the long winters? It was a common thing for men to have had as many as seven wives. Few had less than three. The women died under the stress of bearing children, they died like flies under the strains and accidents of child- birth prus the rigors of primitive labors: carrying water, wood, etc., lugging brats up and down. Add to this the fury against unofficial sexual indulgence and the plight of the women, at least, is heavily shadowed. It is pleasant to think of the beginning decadence of the cruel régime when some years later at Groton, I think it was—the lady who unearthed the record lives in Chicago—the women had begun to put ribbons in their hitherto plain bonnets. The elders met in solemn conclave and forbade the practice but the women met in another church and as solemnly told the men, in a word, to hush! They continued to wear their ribbons. One young lady, of this time, went to her wedding upon a white horse and in a dress of scarlet satin with a purple velvet shoulder cloak over it, bless her unknown pride. What a beautiful country where all these simple forces have so much weight and vitality—but you were speaking of the Indians. Yes, but I shall tell you more of that along with the story of “those terrible priests” to the north of whom the English were so afraid and whom they accused of all evil while they themselves practiced hypocrisy, bigotry, encroachment, fraud, 120 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN violence and bloodshed. “When we fought we were driven back and when peace returned we multiplied.” There was Pére Rasles, a spirit, rich, blossoming, generous, able to give and to receive, full of taste, a nose, a tongue, a laugh, enduring, self-forgetful in beneficence—a new spirit in the New World. All that will be new in America will be anti-Puritan. It will be of another root. It will be more from the heart of Rasles, in the north. There the French priests, good and bad, had penetrated a border ground, Maine, disputed between the English to the south and the French in Canada. The Indians were caught between the two factions, Catholic and Protestant. The English were at the mouths of the rivers, as in the case of Hannah Swanton at Casco bay. Pére Rasles was in the In- terior, living with his “cher troupeau.” It is from the Lettres Edifiantes that I am speaking. Contrary to the English, Rasles recognized the New World. It stands out in all he says. It is a living flame compared to their dead ash. But the Puritans were infuriated at the progress the Priests were making and cried out against “the true character of Catholic bigotry” about them and “the danger experienced by the first settlers of Maine from this spirit.” Rasles lived thirty-four years, October 13, 1689 to Octeber 12, 1723, with his beloved savages, drawing their sweet like honey, Toucuine them every day. A Catholic, a Jesuit, he was of those by whom the head of logic is beautifully relegated to its place—in heaven. To mystery, rightly reasoned, logic is consigned. Thus we put that all aside. The Church remains. Relieved of dogmatic bitterness, the priest with a fresh mind could open eyes and heart to the New World. Nothing shall be ignored. All shall be included. The world is parcel of the Church so that every leaf, every vein in every leaf, the throbbing’ of the temples is of that mysterious flower. Here is richness, here is color, here is form. Consign- PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 191 ing his creed to a worldly flower in Rome whose perfume should draw all bees, Rasles labored to have them know that garden. Contrasted with the Protestant acts, dry and splitting, those of Pére Rasles were striking in their tenderness, devotion, in- sight and detail of apprehension. This was luscious fruit. The deed was for humanity,—his passion held him a slave to the New World, he strove to sound its mettle. He was a great man. Reading his letters, it is a river that brings sweet water to us. Tuts is a moral source not reck- oned with, peculiarly sensitive and daring in its close embrace | of native things. His sensitive mind. For everything his fine sense, blossoming, thriving, opening, reviving—not shut- ting out—was tuned. He speaks of his struggles with their language, its peculiar beauties, “je ne sais quot d’éner- gique,” he cited its tempo, the form of its genius with gusto, with admiration, with generosity. Already the flower is turn- ing up its petals. It is this to be moral: to be positive, to be peculiar, to be sure, generous, brave—ro marry, to touch —to give because one was, not because one has nothing. And to give to him who nas, who will join, who will make, who will fertilize, who will be like you yourself: to create, to hybridize, to crosspollenize,—not to sterilize, to draw back, to fear, to dry up, to rot. Itis the sun. In Rasles one feels raz INDIAN emerging from within the pod of his isolation from eastern understanding, he is released an INpIan. He exists, he is— it is an AFFIRMATION, it is alive. Pére Rasles, often suffering _ the tortures of the damned as the result of an early accident— fracture of both thighs, badly mended—lived with his village —alone, absorbed in them, Lost in them, swallowed, a hard yeast For his presentation of the Indian point of view toward the raids on the English settlements alone, his letters are in- valuable. If the Puritans feared the savage—his admirable enthusiasm for their high merit as warriors is very beautiful. “The way they make war, these people, renders a handful of their warriors more redoubtable than would be a corps of two 122 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN or three thousand European soldiers.” During the war they carried desolation to all the country inhabited by the English. It is an enthusiasm that possesses him. I care not for the injury. And you want to make Americans see that, you want to make them comprehend this generous spirit, as you call it? Well, come to France and make us understand it.—He laughed. (It is the quality of this impact upon the native phase that is the moral source I speak of, one of the sources that has shaped America and must be recognized.) The Indians in Maine at that time were no more than a few thousand, the Abnaki tribe. Their life was hard. Some- times they had little to eat, often, in certain seasons, nothing. The hardships that Hannah Swanton endured following her captivity, were little more than those of any Indian woman on the march. Speed, speed, or disaster. She must walk or die. So it was with them too. Walk, carry, fight or die. The wild world touched them, always, under their cloaks. She tells of her agony, under a heavy load; she crossed swamps on logs, step- ping for an hour always from one to two feet from the ground. On this trip they had little to eat for days at a time. Once she had part of a turtle they had killed. Once an Indian gave her a piece of moose liver. Once, on an island in the river with her Indian mistress, she had hailed a passing canoe filled with squaws, who, seeing her condition, gave her a roast eel to feed upon. Whortleberries, roots, and acorns were her fare, “or fish if they could catch any.” But this was the life of the savage. It was also his habit, his school. By it he grew round, he grew tough. The wounded were killed. To accept - torture with equanimity was a proof of virtue. Skill and courage were revered. These things Pére Rasles accepted and shared, with diffi- culty in some respects at first but in the end with admiration and enthusiasm. “Ce qui me revolta le plus,” etc. A price sterling was offered by the English for his head; his village—two days march from Portland—was burned and PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 123 the church along with it. He stuck staunchly to his tribe and they to him. ‘Twice he was rescued from assassination by his followers, once there was a false alarm and already the braves were on their way to attack the English fort when the mistake and his safety were discovered. It is a new picture. Vous jugerez sans doute, que c’est de la part de Messieurs les Anglais de notre voisinage, que j’ai le plus & craindre.. Il est vrai que depuis longtemps ils ont conjuré ma porte; mais ni leur mauvaise volonté pour moi, ni la mort dont ils me ménacent ne pourront jamais me séparer de mon cher Trou- peau. Jele récommande & vos saintes Priéres. Once when the English would have captured him two of his young men came to the chapel-tent in the night and whisked him away. It was winter, they had not had time to provide themselves with sufficient provisions. It was several days to the village. The three suffered side by side. They ate the dog that was with them. Then they ate their sacks of loup marims, boiled at a fire, though Rasles had great trouble to swallow his share, tripes des rocher, excréscences de bois. They ate a certain sort of wood that was cooked and so made partly soft in the center,—as Hannah had found and eaten wild - pusley at another season. ‘Crossing a lake that had begun to thaw, their snowshoes became waterlogged. He himself sank up to the knees in the mushy ice. His companion on the right went in to his hips. Going to help each other all managed to - flounder through. He was at their side—— These were his children. He tells of how they laughed at his early attempts at the language. Failing to catch certain gutturals at first, he pronounced but half the words. He speaks of the comparative beauty of the Huron tongue. In the spring the fish come up the river solidly packed, two feet deep—with flesh of a most delicious taste. They gather the fish, eat all they can and dry the rest—that serves them until the corn is ready to harvest. In the spring also, celebrating the Eucharist, Rasles saw the corn planted. In 124 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN August this was ready to be plucked. When that was finished there must be other food. For this it was the habit of the Indians to go to the sea- shore. It was always, says Rasles, the same formula. He knew what was about to happen. They would gather about their spiritual counselor and offer him a speech, saying that the corn was low, that the tribe must have food and that they begged him to come with them to the shore that they might not be deprived of his spiritual comfort while they were gone. Always he answered with the one word,— Kekiberba (1 am listening, my children). When all cried together, 8ri8rie! (We thank you). (Note, the figure 8 is used by Rasles in his alphabet of the Abnaki language to signify the unique guttural sound characteristic of the Indian dialects.) Then they would break camp. Leaving the church he had built, he would take up his altar of a pine board with him and all would set out upon the trail. He complains to his Jesuit brothers that the reason he is not a more constant correspondent is that he never has a mo- ment to himself among his duties to the tribe; not only must he carry on his religious duties but they demand that he com- fort them when they are ill, he must bleed them, advise them, settle their disputes, and he must hear their confessions. In the hallowed, tender light of Rasles’ love for him, the Indian stands out strangely revealed as a child, a passionate friend, a resourceful man and—a genius in attack, another music than the single horror of his war-whoop terrifying the invader. But we are used only to the English attitude bred of the Indian raid. This is rrxep in us without realization of the EFFEcT that such a story, such a tradition, entirely the product of the state of mind that it records, has had upon us and our feeling toward the country. We scarcely know that there can be errects—that anything has a cause. It is of this our moral fiber has been made up in the past—we do not know even that moral fiber nas a quality that is caused by Se a ro ee ee ee ee eee PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 195 something, something almost pure tradition. It is of this our conception of the New World has been fabricated. The English, with an eye upon Maine, did everything to detach Rasles from his children, knowing that he, by keeping them in the Catholic faith, kept them united to France. They offered them everything to kill him or to send him back to Quebec and to take one of their own ministers in his stead. No success. About this time war between France and England was threatening. The English and the Indians being at peace the new Governor of Massachusetts, envoy of the King, sought an interview with the men of Rasles’ tribe. The place appointed was an island a short distance off the coast. The English were there in a barque of war when the Indians, in canoes, arrived and drew their craft up on the beach. Rasles was with them, at their request, to advise. them—though not once throughout the following proceedings did he take part. All this occurred, I wish you to observe, before an act of war on either side. But the English came armed with one of their Ministers, for what purpose Rasles well knew, though upon sight of the Jesuit, the English preacher was kept strictly in the background. As the Indians stepped from their canoes, Rasles was caught in the press and forced up the beach before them, in spite of himself, he says. The English, seeing him, were taken aback; but the Governor, advancing, greeted him and then _ prepared to address the savages. He told them that before long it was expected that Eng- land and France would be at war. He pleaded with the Indians to remain neutral should this war arrive. The Indians listened. Having heard his words, they drew off to talk among themselves before giving a reply—inadvertently leaving Rasles alone, facing the English at the head of the beach. At this the English Governor, speaking to Rasles in pri- vate, asked him, should there be war, if he would send his 126 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN savages against them.—Je lui repondis, says the J esuit, que mon réligion et mon caractére de Prétre, ne m’engageomt a ne leur donner que des conseils de paix.—But suddenly while speaking, he saw himself surrounded by twenty young braves, who feared the English might attempt to do him an injury. — And now the tribe returned with their reply: Know that the Frenchman is my brother, we have the same prayer, he and I, and we live in the same cabin of two fires. If I see you come into the cabin near the fire of my brother, I watch you from my mat. If I see that you carry a hatchet, I would think, what does this Englishman want to do with that hatchet? I get up from my mat to consider what you will do. If he raise the hatchet to strike my brother, I will run to help him. A short time after this, a French, man-of-war came up the river to Quebec announcing that France and England had commenced hostilities. At once the two hundred and fifty of Rasles’ men “killed the dogs” and prepared to take the war path. Kindling the traditional fire, they performed their wild dance and then, next morning, came to him for his blessing and advice. He says: I told them to remember their prayers and to do no cruelty, to kill no one save in the heat of battle and to treat humanely all those taken prisoners.—After that he thinks of them as soldiers. Were England and France at it, what then exceptional that the savages should wish also to indulge themselves in battle? Rasles’? measured pride of them, his unexpected can- dor, is most refreshing. Frontier villages will suffer from an enemy. If the English waste their time blaming the priests for setting the savages upon them, Rasles does not even think of such excuses. Instead he thinks of quatirizs. He speaks with enthusiasm of the Indian as a fighter. He outlines their mode of approach upon a doomed village.—When they have drawn near to the point of attack they say, twenty here, thirty there. To this party that village is given to be eaten! It is their term. (He speaks with appreciation of their term.) What relief here from the reverent duplicity of PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES 197 the English, with their surprise and horror that ever THEY should suffer. And still the Puritans would poke the heads of dead Indian women on poles outside their villages. ‘When we fight we are beaten, at peace we multiply.” At whose expense? Did one expect the Indians not to be fighters? Not Rasles at any rate. The war finished with the peace of Ryswick; the Indians, as soon as they heard of it, ceased to battle. The English sought a new parley and that peace also was concluded. But the English, to appease the savages, sought to rebuild the church at Norridgewock, which they had burned during hos- tilities, in the hope of getting Indians to work in Boston as laborers. Yet in secret, they tried without ceasing to kill the offending Jesuit. He was killed by them at last—at the foot of his rude cross which he had erected in the center of his village—seeking to draw the fire of the enemy upon himself in order that the women and the children might escape—and they mangled him besides, leaving him disfigured and with his bones all crushed within him. What a curious thing it is, this American religion which we have inherited so largely from the Puritans. I find, I said, so many sources traceable today. But Pére Rasles was, of course, a good man. Let it be said that all he did was due to that, as Eliot was a good man on the other side. Let it be acknowledged that much the Puritans complained of in the Jesuits was justified. And let us say that much that Pére Rasles might have said against the Puritan-English was also true. So one thing cancels the other. A good man is a good man. This leaves two things, two flaming doctrines. As con- trasting influences, I said, in shaping the esthetic and the moral fiber of the growing race they must be weighed (not for | themselves) the Catholic and Protestant, the qualities each one has lent in forming our morale.—I think these early battles have a great importance for the student of today. 128 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN They are remote, he answered. One should read the Lettres Edifiantes, I think one would understand better how much we are like the Indians and how nicely Catholicism fits us. What would Mather think today of Catholic Boston? It is inevitable, I said. Tus is America. If the Puritans have damned us with their abstinence, re- moval from the world, denial, slowly we are forced within ourselves upon an emptiness which cannot be supplied,—this IS the soul, according to their tenets. Lost, in this (and its environments) as in a forest, I do believe the average American to be an Indian, but an Indian robbed of his world unless we call machines a forest in themselves. It would be diverting to believe, if it were so, as I think it’s proving, that despite its obvious benefits, such Protestantism, in America, would have Catholicism, as its consequence. ‘This and the accumulation of great staying wealth. From lack of touch, lack of belief. Steadily the individual loses caste, then the local government loses its authority; the head is more and more removed. Finally the center is reached —totally dehumanized, like a Protestant heaven. Everything is Federalized and all laws become prohibitive in essence. Such, the trail of Puritanism, is the direct cause of the great growth of the Catholic Church with us today, this de- humanization. It offers to a headless mob a government, and THAT is its appeal (to take immediately the place of that lost local one that used to touch), a government in opposition to the general evil of our civil one; that is at least humane against the other (morally) that’s merely stupid. Only the negro, with a keen necessity to find an equivalent, for the voodooism, the mystery of his African jungles, where one cannot see far, has been able to make a vital thing of our religion. For the rest of us the influence is degenerative. It is largely a persistence of the stasis of the early beliefs, to- gether with their vigor. If enamored of the gospel, the Puritans in a wild New World by that pure stare into the center of their souls ex- i eS a Be PERE SEBASTIAN RASLES _ 129 cluded terrors each for himself, and so, in effect, blocked all ingress and all egress (in theory) to the tenderer humanities, the frailties in which beauty lives entangled, rendering their lives hard, unproductive of that openness which would have been to them as a flower to the stalk; so the Catholics to the north, equally lost, would achieve the same end of escape by the equivalent of a blow on the head at the start, that relieved them of responsibility. Thus stunned and benumbed to terror, the Church comes at least with gentleness to aid. So that they could approach the Indians who, if they were lost, still had their apt sensual touch which the Puritan occluded. And so America is become the greatest proselytizing ground for the Catholic in the world today—in spite of every- thing. The difficulty, from lack of sensual application, re- moved from without by an authority that represents the mys- tery itself—leaves hands freed for embraces, a field where tenderness may move, love may awaken and (save by the one blocked door) a way is offered. Certain it is that the New World suffered greatly from both Puritans and Catholics; but as Pére Rasles touched it nearer than his southern neighbors, and as the ghost of Puri- tanism still binds us by its horrid walls, so, as a corollary, Catholicism gains in that it offers us aLLEviaTION from the dullness, the lack of touch incident upon the steady with- drawal of our liberty. THE DISCOVERY OF KENTUCKY HERE was, thank God, a great voluptuary born to the American settlements against the niggardliness of the damming puritanical tradition; one who by the single logic of his passion, which he rested on the savage life about him, destroyed at its spring that spiritually withering plague. For this he has remained since buried in a miscolored legend and left for rotten. Far from dead, however, but full of a rich regenerative violence he remains, when his history will be carefully reported, for us who have come after to call upon him. Kentucky, the great wilderness beyond the western edge of the world, “the dark and bloody ground” of coming years, seemed to the colonists along the eastern North-American sea- board as far away, nearly, and as difficult of approach as had that problematical world itself beyond the western ocean to the times prior to Columbus. “A country there was, of this none could doubt who thought at all; but whether land or water, mountain or plain, fertility or barrenness, preponder- ated; whether it was inhabited by men or beasts, or both or neither, they knew not.” But if inhabited by men then it was the savage with whom the settlers had had long since experi- ence sufficient to make them loth to pry further, for the mo- ment, beyond the securing mountain barrier. Clinging narrowly to their new foothold, dependent still on sailing vessels for a contact none too swift or certain with “home,” the colonists looked with fear to the west. They worked hard and for the most part throve, suffering the ma- terial lacks of their exposed condition with intention. But they suffered also privations not even to be estimated, cramp- ing and demeaning for a people used to a world less primi- ‘ 130 THE DISCOVERY OF KENTUCKY 131 tively rigorous. A spirit of insecurity calling upon thrift and self-denial remained their basic mood. Opposed to this lay the forbidden wealth of the Unknown. Into such an atmosphere, more or less varied, more or less changed for better or worse in minds of different understand- ing, was born Daniel Boone, the foremost pioneer and fron- tiersman of his day. A man like none other about him Boone had for the life of his fellow settlers, high or low, no sympa- thy whatever. Was it his ancestry, full of a rural quietness from placid Dorset or the sober Quaker training of his early associations that bred the instinct in him, made him ready to take desperate chances with his mind for pleasure, certainly he was not, as commonly believed, of that riff-raff of hunters and Indian killers among which destiny had thrown him—the man of border foray—a link between the savage and the settler. His character was not this. Mild and simple hearted, steady, not impulsive in courage—bold and determined, but always rather inclined to defend than attack—he stood im- mensely above that wretched class of men who are so often the preliminaries of civilization. Boone deliberately chose the peace of solitude, rather than to mingle in the wild wrang- lings and disputings of the ‘society around him—from whom it was ever his first thought to be escaping—or he would never have penetrated to those secret places where later his name became a talisman. Three years the junior of George Washington, Boone was taken while still a child from his birthplace on the upper waters of the Schuylkill River near Philadelphia to the then comparatively wild country of western Pennsylvania. Here he grew up. Soon a hunter, even as a boy men stepped back to contemplate with more than ordinary wonder the fearlessness with which he faced the fiercer wild beasts that prowled around. It was the early evidence of his genius. At eighteen, with his love of the woods marked for good, and his disposition for solitude, taciturnity and a hunter’s life determined, the family 132 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN moved again this time from the rapidly settling country of Pennsylvania to the wild Yadkin, a river that takes its rise among the mountains that form the western boundary of North Carolina. With his arrival on the Yadkin, Daniel Boone married a neighbor’s daughter, Rebecca Bryan, and together the young couple left the world behind them. Boone at once traversed the Yadkin Valley at a point still more remote from the sea- board and nearer the mountain; here he placed his cabin. It was a true home to him. Its firelight shone in welcome to the rare stranger who found that riverside. But he was not to remain thus solitary! The lands along the Yadkin at- — tracted the notice of other settlers, and Boone, at thirty, found the smoke of his cabin no longer the only one that floated in that air. These accessions of companionship, however con- genial to the greatest part of mankind, did not suit Boone. He soon became conscious that his time on the Yadkin was limited. The fields for adventure lay within his reach. The moun- tains were to be crossed and a new and unexplored country, invested with every beauty, every danger, every incident that could amuse the imagination or quicken action, lay before him, the indefinite world of the future. Along the Clinch River and the Holston River hunting parties pursued their way. As they went, the mysteries of forest life grew more familiar. Boone learned even better than before that neither roof, nor house, nor bed was necessary to existence. There were, of _ course, many things to urge him on in his natural choice. It was the time just preceding the Revolution. The colonial — system of taxation was iniquitous to the last degree; this the pioneer could not fathom and would not endure. Such things Boone solved most according to his nature by leaving them behind. eR = At this point Boone’s life may be said really to begin. Facing his first great adventure Boone was now in his best years. His age was thirty-six. He is described by various - THE DISCOVERY OF KENTUCKY 138 writers as being five feet ten inches high, robust, clean limbed _and athletic, fitted by his habit and temperament, and by his physique, for endurance—a bright eye, and a calm determi- nation in his manner. In 1769, John Finley returned from a hunting trip beyond the mountain. He talked loud and long of the beauty and fertility of the country and Daniel Boone was soon eagerly a listener. It touched the great keynote of his character, and the hour and the man had come. “It was on the first of May, in the year 1769, that I re- signed my domestic happiness for a time and left my family and peaceful habitation on the Yadkin River in North Caro- lina, to wander through the wilderness of America, in quest of the country of Kentucky, in company with John Finley, John Stewart, Joseph Holden, James Monay, and William Cool. We proceeded successfully and after a long and fatigu- ing journey through a mountain wilderness, in a westward di- rection on the seventh day of June following, we found our- selves on Red River, where John Finley had formerly been trading with the Indians, and from the top of an eminence, saw with pleasure the beautiful level of Kentucky.” Thus opens the so-called autobiography, said to have been written down from Boone’s dictation, late in his life by one John Filson. But the silly phrases and total disregard for what must have been the rude words of the old hunter serve only, for the most part, to make it a keen disappointment to the interested reader. But now, from everything that is said, all that Boone is known to have put through and willingly suf- fered during the next two years, there ensued a time of the _ most enchanting adventure for the still young explorer. For a time the party hunted and enjoyed the country, seeing buf- falo “more frequent than I have seen cattle in the settlements, browsing on the leaves of the cane, or cropping the grass on those extensive prairies, . . . abundance of wild beasts of all sorts through this vast forest; and the numbers about the salt springs were amazing.” Here the party practised hunting till the twenty-second day of December following. 134 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN “On this day John Stewart and I had a pleasant ramble; but fortune changed the scene in the close of it. We had passed through a great forest, Nature was here a series of wonders and a fund of delight, and we were diverted with innumerable animals presenting themselves perpetually to our view. In the decline of the day, near the Kentucky River, as we ascended the brow of a small hill, a number of Indians rushed out of a thick canebrake upon us and made us prison- ers.” Escaping later the two returned to their camp to find it plundered and the others of their party gone. But now, by one of those determining chances which occur in all great careers Squire Boone, Daniel’s brother, who with another adventurer had set out to get news of the original party if possible, came accidentally upon his brother’s camp in the forest. It was a meeting of greatest importance and un- bounded joy to Daniel Boone. For a short time there were now four together, but within a month, the man Stewart was killed by Indians while Squire Boone’s companion, who had accompanied him upon his quest, either wandered off and was lost or returned by himself to the Colonies. Daniel and Squire were left alone. ‘We were then in a dangerous and helpless situation, ex- posed daily to perils and death amongst the savages and wild beasts—not a white man in the country but ourselves. Thus situated many hundred miles from our families, in the howling wilderness, I believe few would have equally enjoyed the happi- ness we experienced. We continued not in a state of indolence but hunted every day, and prepared to defend ourselves against the winter’s storms. We remained there undisturbed during the winter. . . . On the first day of May, following, my brother returned home to the settlement by himself, for a new recruit of horses and ammunition, leaving me by myself, without bread, salt or sugar, without company of my fellow creatures, or even a horse or a dog. “I confess I never was under greater necessity of exercis- ing philosophy and fortitude. A few days I passed uncom- THE DISCOVERY OF KENTUCKY 135 fortably: The idea of a beloved wife and family, and their anxiety upon the account of my absence, and exposed situation, made sensible impressions on my heart. A thousand dread- ful apprehensions presented themselves to my view and had undoubtedly disposed me to melancholy if indulged. One day I undertook a tour through the country, and the diversity and beauty of nature I met with in this charming season expelled every gloom and vexatious thought. Not a breeze shook the most tremulous leaf. I had gained the summit of a command- ing ridge, and looking around with astonishing delight, beheld the ample plain, the beauteous tracts below. All things were still; I kindled a fire near a fountain of sweet water and feasted on a loin of a buck which a few hours before I had killed. Night came and the earth seemed to gasp after the hovering moisture. » But only impatience is kindled by the silly language of the asinine chronicler. _ But when Filson goes on to declare Boone’s loneliness “an uninterrupted scene of sylvan pleasures” it is a little too much to bear. Constant exposure to danger and death, a habitation which he states had been discovered by the savages, the neces- sity of such stratagems as the resort to the canebrake rather than to take the risk of being found in his cabin, have nothing of sylvan pleasures in them. Boone had too much strong sense to feel anything but patience amidst the scenes of his solitude. And yet, having sounded the depth of forest life, and having considered and weighed all it had to offer, he felt secure enough to brave the perils of an exploring tour. He saw the Ohio, and unquestionably, from the results of this ex- cursion, strengthened his determination to establish himself in such a land of delight. For three months he was alone. It was an ordeal through which few men could have passed. Certain it is that nothing but a passionate attachment of the most extraordinary inten- _ sity could have induced even him to undergo it. If there were perils there was a pleasure keener, which bade him stay op, even in solitude, while his day was lasting. Surely he 136 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN must have known that it was the great ecstatic moment of his life’s affirmation. By instinct and from the first Boone had run past the difficulties encountered by his fellows in making the New World their own. As ecstasy cannot live without devotion and he who is not given to some earth of basic logic cannot enjoy, so Boone lived to enjoy ecstasy through his single devotion to the wilderness with which he was surrounded. The beauty of a lavish, primitive embrace in savage, wild beast and forest rising above the cramped life about him possessed him wholly. Passionate and thoroughly given he avoided the half logic of stealing from the immense profusion. Some one must have taken the step. He took it. Not that he settled Kentucky or made a path to the west, not that he defended, suffered, hated and fled, but because of a descent to the ground of his desire was Boone’s life important and does it remain still loaded with power,—power to strengthen every form of energy that would be voluptuous, passionate, possessive in that place which he opened. For the problem of the New World was, as every new comer soon found out, an awkward one, on all sides the same: how to replace from the wild land that which, at home, they had scarcely known the Old World meant to them; through difficulty and even brutal hardship to find a ground to take the place of England. They could not do it. They clung, one way or another, to the old, striving the while to pull off pieces to themselves from the fat of the new bounty. | Boone’s genius was to recognize the difficulty as neither ma- terial nor political but one purely moral and esthetic. Filled with the wild beauty of the New World to overbrimming so long as he had what he desired, to bathe in, to explore always more deeply, to see, to feel, to touch—his instincts were con- tented. Sensing a limitless fortune which daring could make his own, he sought only with primal lust to grow close to it, to understand it and to be part of its mysterious movements— like an Indian. And among all the colonists, like an Indian, THE DISCOVERY OF KENTUCKY 187 the ecstasy of complete possession of the new country was his alone. In Kentucky he would stand, a lineal descendant of Columbus on the beach at Santo Domingo, walking up and down with eager eyes while his men were gathering water. With the sense of an Indian, Boone felt the wild beasts about him as a natural offering. Like a savage he knew that for such as he their destined lives were intended. As an In- dian to the wild, without stint or tremor, he offered himself to his world, hunting, killing with a great appetitie, taking the lives of the beasts into his quiet, murderous hands as they or their masters, the savages, might take his own, if they were able, without kindling his resentment; as naturally as his own gentle son, his beloved brother, his nearest companions were taken—without his rancor being lifted. Possessing a body at once powerful, compact and capable of tremendous activity and resistance when roused, a clear eye and a deadly aim, taciturn in his demeanor, symmetrical and instinctive in un- derstanding, Boone stood for his race, the affirmation of that wild logic, which in times past had mastered another wilder- ness and now, renascent, would master this, to prove it potent. There must be a new wedding. But he saw and only he saw the prototype of it all, the native savage. To Boone the Indian was his greatest master. Not for himself surely to be an Indian, though they eagerly sought to adopt him into their tribes, but the reverse: to be himself in a new world, Indian- like. If the land were to be possessed it must be as the Indian possessed it. Boone saw the truth of the Red Man, not an _ aberrant type, treacherous and anti-white to be feared and ex- terminated, but as a natural expression of the place, the In- dian himself as “right,” the flower of his world. Keen then was the defeat he tasted when, having returned safe to the Colonies after his first ecstatic sojourn, and when after long delay having undertaken to lead a party of forty settlers to the new country, his eldest son, among five others of his own age, was brutally murdered by the savages at the very outset. It was a crushing blow. Although Boone and 138 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN others argued against it, the expedition turned back and with his sorrowing wife Boone once more took up his homestead on the Yadkin. And this is the mark of his personality, that even for this cruel stroke he held no illwill against the Red Men. Disappointed in his early hopes and when through subse- quent years of battle against the wild tribes, when through losses and trials of the severest order, he led at last in the establishment of the settlers about the fort and center of Boonesborough, he never wavered for a moment in his clear conception of the Indian as a natural part of a beloved con- dition, the New World, in which all lived together. Captured or escaping, outwitted by or outwitting the savages, he ad- mired and defended them always, as, implacable and remorse- less enemy to the Red Man that he proved, they admired and respected him ‘to the end of his days. You have bought the land, said an old Indian who acted for his tribe in the transaction which now made Kentucky over to the white man, but you will have trouble to settle it. It proved true. An old lady who had been in the forts was describing the scenes she had witnessed in those times of peril and adventure, and, among other things, remarked that-during the first two years of her residence in Kentucky, the most comely sight she beheld, was seeing a young man die in his bed a natural death. She had been familiar with blood, and car- nage, and death, but in all those cases the sufferers were the victims of the Indian tomahawk and scalping knife; and that on an occasion when a young man was taken sick and died, after the usual manner of nature, she and the rest of the women sat up all night, gazing upon him as an object of beauty. ‘It was against his own kind that Boone’s lasting resent- ment was fixed, “those damned Yankees,” who took from him, by the chicanery of the law and in his old age, every last acre of the then prosperous homestead he had at last won for himself after years of battle in the new country. Confirmed in his distrust for his “own kind,” in old age THE DISCOVERY OF KENTUCKY 1839 homeless and quite ruined, he must turn once more to his early loves, the savage and the wild. Once more a wanderer he struck out through Tennessee for “more elbowroom,” de- termined to leave the young nation which he had helped to establish, definitely behind him. He headed for Spanish ter- ritory beyond the Mississippi where the Provincial Governor, having gotten wind of the old hunter’s state of mind, was glad to offer him a large tract of land on which to settle. There he lived and died, past ninety, serving his traps as usual. In the woods he would have an Indian for companion even out of preference to his own sons, and from these men, the Indians, he had the greatest reverence, enjoying always when afield with them the signal honor of disposing them in the order of the hunt. Too late the American Congress did follow him with some slight recognition. But that was by then to him really a small matter. He had already that which he wanted: the woods and native companions whom, in a written statement of great interest, he defends against all detractors and in that defense establishes himself in clear words: the antagonist of those of his own blood whose alien strength he felt and de- tested, while his whole soul, with greatest devotion, was given to the New World which he adored and found, in its every expression, the land of heart’s desire. GEORGE WASHINGTON ASHINGTON was, I think, the typically good man: take it as you please. But, of course, a remarkable one. No doubt at all he, personally, was ninety per- cent of the force which made of the American Revolution a successful issue. Know of what that force consisted, that is, the intimate character of its makeup, that is, Washington himself, and you will know practically all there is to under- stand about the beginnings of the American Republic. You will know, also, why a crown was offered this great hero at the conclusion of hostilities with Great Britain, and with what a hidden gesture he rejected the idea. Therein you have it: it was unthinkable—or he might have taken it. Here was a man of tremendous vitality buried in a mas- sive frame and under a rather stolid and untractable exterior which the ladies somewhat feared, I fancy. He must have looked well to them, from a distance, or say on horseback— but later it proved a little too powerful for comfort. And he wanted them too; violently. One can imagine him curiously alive to the need of dainty waistcoats, lace and kid gloves, in which to cover that dangerous rudeness which he must have felt about himself. His interest in dress at a certain period of his career is notorious. The surveying contract which took him to Duquesne and _ the wilderness thereabouts was, however, the other side of the question. In this he must have breathed a more serious air which cannot but have penetrated to the deepest parts of his nature. ‘The thing is, however, that in his case it did not, as it might have done, win him permanently to that kind of an existence. There was in his nature a profound spirit of resig- nation before life’s rich proposals which disarmed him. As he » 140 GEORGE WASHINGTON 141 expressed it, to him it was always his “vine and figtree,” home _and quiet, for which he longed. Stress he could endure but peace and regularity pleased him better. ‘There must have been within him a great country whose wild paths he alone knew and explored in secret and at his leisure. Patience, horses or a fine carriage, a widow to wive, a sloping lawn with a river at the bottom, a thriving field, an adopted daughter—that was as far as his desire wandered. All the rest he accepted as put upon him by chance. Resistance was, I believe, his code. Encitadeled. A pro- tector of the peace, or at least, keeper of the stillness within himself. He was too strong to want to evade anything. That’s _ his reputation for truthtelling. It was a good scratching to him to take it on and see himself through. He knew he would come through. There was his club life in Alexandria, as a Mason; the ten-mile ride to Church: it warmed him up a little. As for rebellion, I don’t think it entered his mind. I don’t see how it could, except from the rear, subconsciously—that fire was too subdued in him. As commander of the troops he resisted, struck and drew back, struck and doubled on his tracks and struck and struck again, then rested. He couldn’t give in. He couldn’t give in without such a ruffling within himself that he had no choice but to continue. That’s the secret of Valley Forge and the valor and patience of his battle, as great as the other, against an aimless, waver- ing Congress at Philadelphia. He couldn’t give in. I be- lieve he would have gone out and battled it alone if he had felt his army wasted from under him or even left the country. Or else— ; Well, there is the night he wandered off alone near Morris- town, I think, off toward the British lines on horseback, impa- tient of warning—to air himself, so to speak, under the stars. Something angry was stirred there. But seven days in the week it was for him: resist, be pru- dent, be calm—with a mad hell inside that might rise, might 1442 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN one day do something perhaps brilliant, perhaps joyously abandoned—but not to be thought of. Such men suffering thus a political conversion of their emotions are, I suppose, always the noteworthy among us. Battle to them must be the expression of that something in themselves which they fear. Washington’s calmness of de- meanor and characteristics as a military leader were of that cloth. Some girl at Princeton, was it? had some joke with him about a slipper at a dance. He was full of it. And there was the obscene anecdote he told that night in the boat crossing the Delaware. | But apparently the one man who got it full, who saw him really roused was General Lee—the one who wanted to replace him in command. That was all right. Washington could understand that and forgive it in another. He forgave Lee and restored him to his division with full trust after his re- turn from capture by the British. But when, subsequently, Lee, in direct disobedience of orders, forgetting his position and risking his own whim on an important decision before Monmouth, lost the chance for an important victory—that was different. Immediately after, Washington met him by chance at a country cross road and Lee got it. It is said no man, before or after, saw Washington in such a rage. This sort of thing Lee had done, he, Washington, knew from top to bottom. It was the firmly held part of him- self which had broken loose—in another. Should he, Wash- ington, stop that resistance in himself. What would happen? No use to ask that now. Here it was: disaster. To Lee then in a fury, he opened the gates of his soul and Lee saw such hell fire that it was the end of him—retired muttering and half silly to his farm in Virginia where he stayed. The presidency could not have meant anything to Wash- ington. I think he spoke the candid truth about it when he said he neither desired it nor sought it. He merely did his duty. He did it with wisdom since he couldn’t do it any tn — GEORGE WASHINGTON 143 other way. He wasn’t enough interested to be scheming. Re- sist and protect: that was the gist of most that he said. Don’t go looking for trouble. Stay home. In his very face, even, it was said in Congress he had turned monster under the name of prudence: “a sort of a non-describable chameleon-colored thing called prudence.” Alexander Hamilton, a type that needed power, found all this quite to his liking. Washington let him do. He wanted to get back to Mt. Vernon. America has a special destiny for such men, I suppose, great wench lovers—there is the letter from Jefferson attesting it in the case of Washington, if that were needed—terrible leaders they might make if one could release them. It seems a loss not compensated for by the tawdry stuff bred after them—in place of a splendor, too rare. They are a kind of American swan song, each one. > The whole crawling mass gnaws on them—hates them. He was hated, don’t imagine he was not. The minute he had se- cured their dung heap for them—he had to take their dirt in the face. From deep within, you may count upon it, came those final words when, his head in his friend’s lap, he said with difficulty: “Doctor, I am dying, and have been dying for a long time, . ” adding to reassure them, “but I am not afraid to die.” He is the typical sacrifice to the mob—in a great many ways thoroughly disappointing. POOR RICHARD Information to Those Who Would Remove to America: | the writer of this, who is well acquainted with North America, their desire of transporting and establishing themselves in that country, but who appear to have formed, through ignorance, mistaken ideas and expectations of what is to be obtained there, he thinks it may be useful, and prevent inconvenient, expensive, and fruitless removals and voyages of improper persons, if he gives some clearer and truer notions of that part of the world than appear to have hitherto pre- vailed. He finds it is imagined by numbers that the inhabitants of North America are rich, capable of rewarding, and dis- posed to reward, all sorts of ingenuity; that they are at the same time ignorant of all the sciences, and, consequently, that strangers possessing talents in the belles-lettres, fine arts, etc., must be highly esteemed, and so well paid as to become easily rich themselves, that there are also abundance of profitable offices to be disposed of, which the natives are not qualified to fill; and that, having few persons of family among them, strangers of birth must be greatly respected, and of course easily obtain the best of those offices, which will make all their fortunes; that the governments too, to encourage emigration from Europe, not only pay the expense of personal transpor- tation, but give lands gratis to strangers, with negroes to work for them, utensils of husbandry, and stocks of cattle. These are all wild imaginations; and those who go to America with expectations founded upon them will surely find themselves dis- appointed. Mite: persons in Europe having by letters expressed to 144 a ——" ee POOR RICHARD 145 The truth is, that though there are in that country few people so miserable as the poor of Europe, there are also very few that in Europe would be called rich 3 It is rather a general happy mediocrity that prevails. There are few great proprie- tors of the soil, and few tenants; most people cultivate their own lands, or follow some handicraft or merchandise; very few rich enough to live idly upon their rents or incomes, or to pay the highest prices given in Europe for painting, statues, archi- tecture, and the other works of art that are more curious than useful. Hence the natural geniuses that have arisen in Amer- ica with such talents have uniformly quitted that country for Europe, where they can be more suitably rewarded. It is true that letters and mathematical knowledge are in esteem there; but they are at the same time more common than is appre- ciated; there being already existing nine colleges or univer- sities, viz. four in New England, and one in each of the provinces of New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Mary- land, and Virginia, all furnished with learned professors; be- sides a number of smaller academies. These educate many of their youth in the languages, and those sciences that qualify men for the professions of divinity, law or physic. Strangers indeed are by no means excluded from exercising those pro- fessions; and the quick increase of inhabitants everywhere gives them a chance of employ, which they have in common . with the natives. Of civil offices, or employments, there are few; no superfluous ones, as in Europe; and it is a rule estab- lished in some states, that no office shall be so profitable as to make it desirable. The thirty-sixth article of the Constitution of Pennsylvania runs expressly in these words: “As every free- man, to preserve his independence (if he has not a sufficient estate) ought to have some profession, calling, trade or farm, whereby he may honestly subsist, there can be no necessity for, nor use in, establishing offices of profit, the usual effects of which are dependence and servility unbecoming freemen, in the possessors and expectants; faction, contention, corruption, and disorder among the people; Wherefore, whenever an of- 146 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN fice, through increase of fees or otherwise, becomes so profit- able as to occasion many to apply for it, the profits ought to be lessened by the Legislature.” These ideas prevailing more or less in all the United States, it cannot be worth any man’s while, who has a means of living at home, to expatriate himself, in hopes of obtaining a profit- able civil office in America; and as to military offices, they are at an end with the war, the armies being disbanded. Much less is it advisable for a person to go thither who has no other quality to recommend him but his birth. In Europe it has indeed its value; but it is a commodity that cannot be carried to a worse market than that of America; where people do not inquire of a stranger, What is he? but, What can he do? If he has any useful art he is welcome; and if he exer- cises it, and behaves well, he will be respected by all that know him; but a mere man of quality, who, on that account, wants to live upon the public, by some office or salary, will be de- spised and disregarded. ‘The husbandman is in honor there, and even the mechanic; because their employments are useful. The people have a saying, that God Almighty is himself a mechanic, the greatest in the universe; and he is respected and more admired for the variety, ingenuity, and utility of his handiworks, than for the antiquity of his family. They are pleased with the observation of a negro, and frequently men- tion it, that Boccarora (meaning the white man) make de black man workee, make de horse workee, make de ox workee; make ebery ting workee, only the hog. He, de hog, no workee; he eat, he drink, he walk about, he go to sleep when he please, he live like a gempleman. According to these opinions of the Americans one would think himself more obliged to a geneal- ogist, who could prove for him that his ancestors and relations for ten generations had been ploughmen, smiths, carpenters, turners, weavers, tanners, or even shoemakers, and consequently that they were useful members of society, than if he could only prove that they were gentlemen, doing nothing of value, but —— on ee — | ii ae POOR RICHARD 147 living idly on the labor of others, mere fruges conswmere nati,* and otherwise good for nothing, till by their death their es- tates, like the carcass of the negro’s gentleman-hog, come to be cut up. _ With regard to encouragements for strangers from gov- ernment, they are really only what are derived from good laws and liberty. Strangers are welcome, because there is room enough for them all, and therefore the old inhabitants are not jealous of them; the laws protect them sufficiently, so that they have no need of the patronage of great men; and every one will enjoy securely the profits of his industry. But, if he does not bring a fortune with him, he must work and be indus- trious to live. One or two years’ residence gives him all the rights of a citizen; but the government does not, at present, whatever it may have done in former times, hire people to be- come settlers, by paying their passages, giving land, negroes, utensils, stock, or any other kind of emolument whatsoever. In short, America is the land of labor, and by no means _ what the English call Lubberland, and the French Pays de Cocagne, where the streets are said to be paved with half- peck loaves, the houses tiled with pancakes, and where the fouls fly about ready to be roasted, crying, Come eat me! Who then are the kind of persons to whom an emigration to America may be advantageous? And what are the advan- tages they may reasonably expect? Land being cheap in that country, from the vast forests still void of inhabitants, and not likely to be occupied in an age to come, insomuch that the propriety of a hundred acres of fertile soil full of wood may be obtained near the frontiers, in many places, for eight or ten guineas, hearty young labor- ing men, who understand the husbandry of corn and cattle, which is nearly the same in that country as in Europe, may easily establish themselves there. A little money saved of me eve born Merely to eat up the corn.” —Warts, 148 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN the good wages they receive there, while they work for others, enables them to buy the land and begin their plantation, in which they are assisted by the good will of their neighbors, and some credit. Multitudes of poor people from England, Ire- land, Scotland and Germany, have, by this means, in a few years become wealthy farmers, who, in their own countries, where all the lands are fully occupied, and the wages of labor low, could never have emerged from the poor condition wherein they were born. From the salubrity of the air, the healthiness of the cli- mate, and plenty of good provisions, and the encouragement to early marriages by the certainty of subsistence in cultivat- ing the earth, the increase of inhabitants by natural genera- tion is very rapid in America, and becomes still more so by the accession of strangers; hence there is a continual demand for more artisans of all the necessary and useful kinds, to supply those cultivators of the earth with houses, and with furniture and. utensils of the grosser sorts, which cannot so well be brought from Europe. Tolerably good workmen in any of those mechanic arts are sure to find employ, and to be well paid for their work, there being no restraints preventing strangers from exercising any art they understand, nor any permission necessary. If they are poor, they begin first as servants or Journeymen; and if they are sober, industrious, and frugal, they soon become masters, establish themselves in business, marry, raise families, and become respectable citi- zens. Also, persons of moderate fortunes and capitals, who, hav- ing a number of children to provide for, are desirous of bring- ing them up to industry, and to secure estates for their posterity, have opportunities of doing it in America, which Eu- rope does not afford. There they may be taught and practise profitable mechanic arts, without incurring disgrace on that account, but, on the contrary, acquiring respect by such abili- ties. There small capitals laid out in lands, which daily be- come more valuable by the increase of people, afford a solid POOR RICHARD 149 prospect of ample fortunes thereafter for those children. The writer of this has known several instances of large tracts of land, bought, on what was then the frontier of Pennsylvania, for ten pounds per hundred acres, which when the settlements had been extended far beyond them, sold readily, without any improvement made upon them, for three pounds per acre. The acre in America is the same with the English acre, or the acre of Normandy. Those who desire to understand the state of government in America, would do well to read the Constitutions of the sev- eral States, and the Articles of Confederation that bind the whole together for general purposes, under the direction of one assembly, called the Congress. These Constitutions have been printed, by order of Congress, in America; two editions of them have also been printed in London; and a good trans- lation of them into French has lately been published in Paris. Several of the princes of Europe, of late, from an opinion of advantage to arise by producing all commodities and manu- factures within their own dominions, so as to diminish or render useless their importations, have endeavored to entice workmen from other countries by high salaries, privileges, ete. Many persons, pretending to be skilled in various great manufactures, imagining that America must be in want of them, and that the Congress would probably be disposed to imitate the princes above mentioned, have proposed to go over, on condition of having their passage paid, lands given, sala- ries appointed, exclusive privileges for terms of years, etc. Such persons, on reading the Articles of Confederation, will find that the Congress have no power committed to them, nor money put into their hands, for such purposes; and that, if any such encouragement is given, it must be by the govern- _ ment of some separate State. This, however, has rarely been done in America; and when it has been done, it has rarely succeeded, so as to establish a manufacture, which the country ‘was not yet so ripe for as to encourage private persons to set it up; labor being generally too dear there, and hands difficult | 150 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN to be kept together, every one desiring to be a master, and the cheapness of lands inclining many to leave trades for agriculture. Some, indeed, have met with success, and are car- ried on to advantage; but they are generally such as require only a few hands, or wherein great part of the work is per- formed by machines. Goods that are bulky, and of so small value as not well to bear the expense of freight, may often be made cheaper in the country than they can be imported; and the manufacture of such goods will be profitable wherever there isa sufficient demand. The farmers in America produce, indeed, a good deal of wool and flax; and none is exported, it is all worked up; but it is in the way of domestic manufac- ture, for the use of the family. ‘The buying up quantities of wool and flax, with the design to employ spinners, weavers, etc., and form great establishments, producing quantities of linen and woolen goods for sale, has been several times at- tempted in different provinces; but those projects have gen- erally failed, goods of equal value being imported cheaper. And when the governments have been solicited to support such schemes by encouragements in money, or by imposing duties on importation of such goods, it has been generally refused, on this principle, that, if the country is ripe for the manu- facture, it may be carried on by private persons to advan- tage; and if not, it is a folly to think of forcing nature. Great establishments of manufacture require great numbers of poor to do the work for small wages; those poor are to be found in Europe, but will not be found in America till the lands are all taken up and cultivated, and the excess of people, who cannot get land, want employment. The manufacture of silk, they say, is natural in France, as that of cloth in Eng- land, because each country produces in plenty the first ma- terial ; but if England will have a manufacture of silk as well as that of cloth, and France of cloth as well as that of silk, these unnatural operations must be supported by mutual prohibi- tions, or high duties on the importation of each other’s goods; by which means the workmen are enabled to tax the home con- Ye POOR RICHARD 151 sumer by greater prices, while the higher wages they receive makes them neither happier nor richer, since they only drink more and work less. Therefore, the governments in America do nothing to encourage such projects. The people, by this means, are not imposed on, either by the merchant or by the mechanic. If the merchant demands too much profit on im- ported shoes, they buy of the shoemaker; and if he asks too high a price, they take them of the merchant; thus the two professions are checks on each other. The shoemaker, how- ever, has, on the whole, a considerable profit upon his labor in America, beyond what he had in Europe, as he can add to his price a sum nearly equal to all the expenses of freight and commission, risk or insurance, etc., necessarily charged by the merchant. And the case is the same with the workmen in every other mechanic art. Hence it is that artisans generally live better and more easily in America than in Europe; and such as are good economists make a comfortable provision for age, and for their children. Such may, therefore, remove with ad- vantage to America. In the long-settled countries of Europe, all arts, trades, professions, farms, etc., are so full, that it is difficult for a poor man, who has children, to place them where they may gain, or learn to gain a decent livelihood. The artisans, wha _ fear creating future rivals in business, refuse to take appren- tices, but upon conditions of money, maintenance, or the like, which the parents are unable to comply with. Hence the youth are dragged up in ignorance of every gainful art, and obliged to become soldiers, or servants, or thieves, for subsistence. In America, the rapid increase of inhabitants takes away that ‘fear of rivalship, and artisans willingly receive apprentices from the hope of profit by their labor, during the remainder of the time stipulated, after they shall be instructed. Hence it is easy for poor families to get their children instructed; for the artisans are so desirous of apprentices, that many of them will even give money to the parents, to have boys from ten to fifteen years of age bound apprentices to them till the 152 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN age of twenty-one; and many poor parents have, by that means, on their arrival in the country, raised money enough to buy land sufficient to establish themselves, and to subsist the rest of their family by agriculture. ‘These contracts for ap- prentices are made before a magistrate, who regulates the agreement according to reason and justice, and, having in view the formation of a future and useful citizen, obliges the. master to engage by a written indenture, not only that, dur- ing the time of service stipulated, the apprentice shall be duly provided with meat, drink, apparel, washing, and lodging, and, at its expiration, with a complete new suit of clothes, but also that he shall be taught to read and write and cast ac- counts; and that he shall be well instructed in the art or pro- fession of his master, or some other, by which he may gain a livelihood, and be able in his turn to raise a family. A copy of this indenture is given to the apprentice or his friends, and the magistrate keeps a record of it, to which recourse may be had, in case of failure by the master in any point of perform- ance. This desire among the masters, to have more hands employed in working for them, induces them to pay the pas- sages of young persons, of both sexes, who, on their arrival, agree to serve them one, two, three, or four years; those who have already learned a trade agreeing for a shorter term, in proportion to’ their skill and the consequent immediate value of their service; and those who have none agreeing for a longer term, in consideration of being taught an art their poverty would not permit them to acquire in their own country. The almost general mediocrity of fortune that prevails in America obliging its people to follow some business for sub- sistence, those vices that arise usually from idleness are in a great measure prevented. Industry and constant employment are great preservatives of the morals and virtue of a nation. Hence bad examples to youth are more rare in America, which must be a comfortable consideration to parents. To this may be truly added, that serious religion, under its various de- POOR RICHARD 153 nominations, is not only tolerated, but respected and prac- tised. Atheism is unknown there; infidelity rare and secret; so that persons may live to a great age in that country, with- _ out having their piety shocked by meeting with either an atheist or an infidel. And the Divine Being seems to have manifested his approbation of the mutual forbearance and kindness with which the different sects treat each other, by the remarkable prosperity with which He has been pleased to favor the whole country. (B. Franxuin) Notes FoR A CoMMENTARY on F RANKLIN ““He’s sort of proud of his commonness, isn’t he?” He was the balancer full of motion without direction, the gyroscope which by its large spinning kept us, at that early period of our fate, upon an even keel. The greatest winner of his day, he represents a voluptu- ousness of omnivorous energy brought to a dead stop by the rock of New World inopportunity. His energy never at- tained to a penetrant gist; rather it was stopped by and splashed upon the barrier, like a melon. His “good” was scattered about him. This is what is called being “practical.” At such “success” we smile to see Franklin often so puffed up. In the sheer mass of his voluptuous energy lies his chief excuse—a trait he borrowed without recognition from the primitive profusion of his surroundings. Relaxed in a mass of impedimenta he found opportunity for thought. Franklin, along with all the responsible aristocrats of his period, shows the two major characteristics of a bulky, crude energy, something in proportion to the continent, and a colos- sal restraint equalizing it. The result must have been a com- plete cancellation, frustration or descent to a low plane for release, which latter alternative he chose shiningly. He played with lightning and the French court. 154 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN The great force (which was in him the expression of the New World) must have had not only volume but a quality, the determination of which will identify him. It was in Franklin, as shown characteristically in this letter, a scattering to recon- noitre. Poor Richard’s Almanac was as important in founding the nation as Paine’s Age of Reason—he adaged them into a kind of pride in possession. By casting scorn at men merely of birth while stressing the foundation of estates which should be family strongholds he did the service of discouraging aristocracy and creating it— the qualifying condition being that he repelled that which was foreign and supported that which was native—on a lower level roR THE TIME BEING. He sparred for time: he was a diplomat of distinction with positive New World char- acteristics. His mind was att out of the New World. Feeling a strength, a backing which was the New itself, he could afford to be sly with France, England or any nation; since, to live, he had to be sly with the massive strength of that primitive wilderness with whose conditions he had been bred to battle: thus, used to a mass EquaL to them, he could swing them too. So again he asserted his nativity. Strong and New World in innate strength, he is without beauty. The force of the New World is never in these men open; it is sly, covert, almost cringing. It is the mass that forces them into praise of mediocrity to escape its compul- sions: so there is a kind of nastiness in his Toucuine the hand of the Marchioness, in his meddling with the lightning, a resentment against his upstart bumptiousness in 2 London how to light its stupidly ill-lit streets. There has not yet appeared in the New World any one with sufficient strength for the open assertion. So with Frank- lin, the tone is frightened and horribly smug—at his worst; it flames a little in de Soto; it is necessary to Boone to lose himself in the wilds; there,are no women—Houston’s bride is POOR RICHARD 155 frightened off; the New Englanders are the clever bone-men. Nowhere the open, free assertion save in the Indian: this is the quality. Jones has to leave the American navy, we feel, to _ go to Russia, for release. It is necessary in appraising our history to realize that the nation was the offspring of the desire to huddle, to protect— of terror—superadded to a new world of great beauty and ripest blossom that well-nigh no man of distinction saw save Boone. Franklin is the full development of the timidity, the strength that denies itself. Such is his itch to serve science. “Education” represented to these pioneers an obscure knowledge of the great beauty that was denied them, but of the great beauty under their feet no man seems to have been conscious, to appreciable degree; the foundation they must first appraise. Nowhere does the full assertion come through save as a joke, jokingly, that masks the rest. The terrible beauty of the New World attracts men to their ruin. Franklin did not care to be ruined—he only wanted to touch. “I wish he hadn’t gone fooling with lightning; I wish he’d left it alone—the old fool.” Sure enough, he didn’t dare let it go in at the top of his head and out at his toes, that’s it; he had to fool with it. He sensed the power and knew only enough to want to run an engine with it. His fingers itched to be meddling, to do the little concrete thing—the barrier against a flood of lightning that would inundate him. Of ‘course he was the most useful, “the most industrious citizen that Philadelphia or America had ever known.” He was the dike keeper, keeping out the wilderness with his wits. Fear drove his curiosity. Do something, anything, to keep the fingers busy—not to realize—the lightning. Be industrious, let money and com- fort increase; money is like a bell that keeps the dance 156 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN from terrifying, as it would if it were silent and we could hear the grunt,—thud—swish. It is small, hard; it keeps the at- tention fixed so that the eyes shall not see. And such is humor: pennies—that see gold come of copper by adding together, shrewd guesses hidden under the armament of an humble jest. Poor Richard. Don’t offend. His mighty answer to the New World’s offer of a great embrace was THRIFT. Work night and day, build up, penny by penny, a wall against that which is threatening, the terror of life, poverty. Make a fort to be secure in. . The terrific energy of the new breed is its first character; the second is its terror before the NEW. As a boy, he had tentatively loosed himself once to love, to curiosity perhaps, which was the birth of his first son. But the terror of that dare must have frightened the soul out of him. Having dared that once, his heart recoiled; his teaching must have smitten him. But Franklin, shrewd fellow, did not succumb to the benumbing judgment and go branded, repen- tant.or rebellious. He trotted off gaily to Philly and noticed ~ Bettsy in the shop on Arch Street, the first day. He is our wise prophet of chicanery, the great buffoon, the face on the penny stamp. The shock his youth got went into the fibre of the Consti- tution: he joked himself into a rich life—so he joked the coun- try into.a good alliance: to fortify, to buckle up—and reserve a will to be gay, to BE—(on the side). Poor Richard: Save, be rich—and do as you please— might have been his motto, with an addendum: provided your house has strong walls and thick shutters. Prince Richard in the lamb’s skin: with a tongue in the cheek for aristocracy, humbly, arrogantly (that you may wish to imitate me) touching everything. . , To want to touch, not to wish anything to remain clean, aloof—comes always of a kind of timidity, from fear. POOR RICHARD 157 The character they had (our pioneer statesmen, etc.) was that of giving their fine energy, as they must have done, to the smaller, narrower, protective thing and not to the great, New World. Yet they cannot quite leave hands off it but must _ ToucH it, in a “practical” way, that is a joking, shy, nasty Way, using “science” etc., not with the generosity of the say- age or scientist but in a shameful manner. The sweep of the force was too horrible to them; it would have swept them into chaos. They wap to do as they could but it can be no offense that their quality should be named. They could have been inspired by the new auatity about them to yield to loveliness in a fresh spirit. . bite Ios It is the placing of his enthusiasm that characterizes the man. It is not to mark Franklin, but to attempt to appraise the nature of the difficulties that molded him, the characteristic weight of the mass; how nearly all our national heroes have been driven back—and praised by reason of their shrewdness in making walls: not in bursting into flower. To discover the New Wortp: that there is something there: what it has done to us, its quality, its weight, its prophets, its—horrible temper. The niggardliness of our history, our stupidity, sluggish- ness of spirit, the falseness of our historical notes, the com- plete missing of the point. Addressed to the wrong head, the _ tenacity with which the fear still inspires laws, customs,—the suppression of the superb corn dance of the Chippewas, since it symbolizes the generative processes,—as if morals have but one character, and that,—srx: while morals are deformed in the name of Purity; till, in the confusion, almost nothing remains of the great American New World but a memory of the Indian. BATTLE BETWEEN THE BON HOMME RICHARD AND THE SERAPIS N board the ship “Serapis,” at anchor without the Texel, in Holland, October 3d, 1779. His Exce,tuency BenszamMin FRANKLIN. Honored and Dear Sir :—When I had the honor of writing to you on the 11th of August, previous to my departure from the Road of Groaix, I had before me the most flattering pros- pect of rendering essential service to the common cause of France and America. I had a full confidence in the voluntary inclination and ability of every captain under my command to assist and support me in my duty with cheerful emulation; and I was persuaded that every one of them would pursue glory in preference to interest. Whether I was or was not deceived will best appear by a relation of circumstances. The little squadron under my orders, consisting of the Bon homme Richard of 40 guns, the Alliance of 36 guns, the Pallas of 32 guns, the Cerf of 18 guns, and the Vengence of 12 guns, joined by two privateers, the Monsieur and the Gran- ville, sailed from the Road of Groaix at daybreak on the 14th of August. ‘The same day we spoke with a large convoy bound from the southward to Brest. On the 23d we saw Cape Clear and the S.W. part of Ire- land. That afternoon, it being calm, I sent some armed boats to take a brigantine that appeared in the N.W. quarter. Soon after in the evening it became necessary to have a boat ahead of the ship to tow, as the helm could not prevent her from laying across the tide of flood, which would have driven us into a deep and dangerous bay, situated between the rocks “158 THE BATTLE 159 on the south called the Skallocks and on the north called the Blaskets. The ship’s boats being absent, I sent my own barge ahead to tow the ship. The boats took the brigantine. She was called the Fortuned, and bound with a cargo of oil, blub- ber, and staves from Newfoundland for Bristol. This vessel I ordered to proceed immediately for Nantes or St. Malo. Soon after sunset the villains who towed the ship cut the tow rope, and decamped with my barge. Sundry shots were fired to bring them to without effect. In the mean time the master of the Bon homme Richard, without orders, manned one of the ship’s boats, and with four soldiers pursued the barge in order to stop the deserters. The evening was clear and serene, but the zeal of that officer, Mr. Cutting Lunt, induced him to pur- sue too far; and a fog, which came on soon afterward, pre- vented the boats from rejoining the ship, although I caused signal guns to be frequently fired. The fog and calm con- tinued the next day till toward evening. In the afternoon ‘Captain Landais came on board the Bon homme Richard, and behaved towards me with great disrespect, affirming in the most indelicate manner and language that I had lost my boats and people through my imprudence in sending boats to take a prize! He persisted in his reproaches, though he was as- sured by Messrs. de Weibert and de Chamillard that the barge was towing the ship at the time of elopement, and that she had not been in pursuit of the prize. He was affronted be- - cause I would not the day before suffer him to chase without my orders and to approach the dangerous shore I have already mentioned, where he was an entire stranger and when there was not sufficient wind to govern a ship. He told me he was the only American in the squadron, and was determined to follow his own opinion in chasing when and where he thought proper, and in every other matter that concerned the service, and that, if I continued in that situation three days longer, the squadron would be taken, &c. By the advice of Captain de Cottineau, and with the free consent and approbation of M. de Verage, I sent the Cerf in to reconnoitre the coast, and en- 160 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN deavor to take the boats and people the next day, while the squadron stood off and on in the S.W. quarter, in the best possible situation to intercept the enemy’s merchant ships, whether outward or homeward bound. The Cerf had on board a pilot well acquainted with the coast, and was ordered to join me again before night. I approached the shore in the afternoon but the Cerf did not appear. This induced me to stand off again in the night in order to return and be rejoined by the Cerf the next day; but to my great con- cern and disappointment, though I ranged the coast along and hoisted our private signals, neither the boats nor the Cerf joined me. The evening of that day, the 26th, brought with it stormy weather, with an appearance of a severe gale from the S.W., yet I must declare I did not follow my own judgment, but was led by the assertion that had fallen from Captain Landais, when I in the evening made a signal to steer to the northward and leave that station, which I wished to have occu- pied a week longer. The gale increased in the night with thick weather. To prevent separation, I carried a top light, and fired a gun every quarter of an hour. I carried, also, a very moderate sail, and the course had been clearly pointed out by a signal before night; yet, with all this precaution, I found my- self accompanied only by the brigantine Vengence in the morn- ing, the Granville having remained astern with a prize. As I have since understood the tiller of the Pallas broke after mid- night, which disabled her from keeping up, but no apology has yet been made in behalf of the Alliance. On the 3lst we saw the Flamie Islands situated near the Lewis, on the N.W. coast of Scotland; and the next morning, off Cape Wrath, we gave chase to a ship to windward, at the same time two ships appearing in the N.W. quarter, which proved to be the Alliance and a prize ship which she had taken, bound, as I understood, from Liverpool to Jamaica. The ship which I chased brought to at noon. She proved to be the Union letter of marque, bound from London to Quebec, with a cargo of naval stores on account of government, adapted: THE BATTLE 161 for the service of the British armed vessels on the lakes. The public despatches were lost, as the Alliance very imprudently hoisted American colors, though English colors were then flying on board the Bon homme Richard. Captain Landais sent a small boat to ask whether I would man the ship or he should, as in the latter case he would suffer no boat nor per- son from the Bon homme Richard to go near the prize. Ridic- ulous as this appeared to me, I yielded to it for the sake of peace, and received the prisoners on board the Bon homme Richard, while the prize was manned from the Alliance. In the afternoon another sail appeared, and I immediately made the signal for the Alliance to chase; but, instead of obeying, -he wore and laid the ship’s head the other way. The next morning I made signal to speak with the Alliance, to which no attention was shown. I then made sail with the ships in company for the second rendezvous, which was not far distant, and where I fully expected to be joined by the Pallas and the Cerf. The second of September we saw a sail at daybreak, and gave chase. That ship proved to be the Pallas, and had met with no success while separated from the Bon homme Richard. On the 3d the Vengence brought to a small Irish brigantine, bound homeward from Norway. The same evening I sent the Vengence in the N.E. quarter to bring up the two prize ships that appeared to me to be too near the islands of Shet- land. While with the Alliance and Pallas, I endeavored to weather Fair Isle, and to get into my second rendezvous, where I directed the Vengence to join me with the three prizes. The next morning, having weathered Fair Isle, and not seeing the Vengence nor the prizes, I spoke the Alliance, and ordered her to steer to the northward, and bring them up to the rendez- vous. On the morning of the 4th the Alliance appeared again, and had brought to two very small coasting sloops in ballast, but without having attended properly to my orders of yesterday. The Vengence joined me soon after, and informed me that in 162 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN consequence of Captain Landais’ orders to the commanders of the two prize ships they had refused to follow him to the rendez- vous. I am to this moment ignorant of what orders these men received from Captain Landais, nor know I by virtue of what authority he ventured to give his orders to prizes in my presence and without either my knowledge or approbation. Captain Ricot further informed me that he had burnt the prize brigantine because that vessel proved leaky; and I was sorry to understand afterward that, though the vessel was Irish property, the cargo was property of the subjects of Norway. In the evening I sent for all the captains to come on board the Bon homme Richard to consult on future plans of opera- tion. Captains Cottineau and Ricot obeyed me, but Captain Landais obstinately refused, and, after sending me various uncivil messages, wrote me a very extraordinary letter in an- swer to a written order which I had sent him on finding that he had trifled with my verbal orders. The next day a pilot boat came on board from Shetland, by which means I received such advices as induced me to change a plan which I otherwise meant | to have pursued; and, as the Cerf did not appear at my sec- ond rendezvous, I determined to steer towards the third in hopes of meeting her there. In the afternoon a gale of wind came on, which continued four days without intermission. In the second night of that gale the Alliance, with her two little prizes, again separated from the Bon homme Richard. I had now with me only the Pallas and the Vengence, yet I did not abandon the hopes of performing some essential service. The winds continued con- trary, so that we did not see the land till the evening of the 13th, when the hills of Cheviot in the S.E. of Scotland ap- peared. The next day we chased sundry vessels, and took a _ ship and a brigantine, both from the Firth of Edinburgh, laden with coal. Knowing that there lay at anchor in Leith road an armed ship of 20 guns, with two or three fine cutters, I formed an expedition against Leith, which I purposed to lay THE BATTLE 163 under a large contribution, or otherwise to reduce it to ashes. Had I been alone, the wind being favorable, I would have proceeded directly up the Firth, and must have succeeded, as_ they lay there in a state of perfect indolence and security, which would have proved their ruin. Unfortunately for me, the Pallas and Vengence were both at a considerable distance in the offing, they having chased to the southward. This obliged us to steer out of the Firth again to meet them. The captains of the Pallas and Vengence being come on board the Bon homme Richard, I communicated to them my project, to which many difficulties and objections were made by them. At last, however, they appeared to think better of the design after I had assured them that I hoped to raise a contribution of 200,000 pounds sterling on Leith, and that there was no bat- tery of cannon there to oppose our landing. So much time, however, was unavoidably spent in pointed remarks and sage deliberations that night that the wind became contrary in the morning. We continued working to windward up the Firth without being able to reach the road of Leith, till on the morning of the 17th, when being almost within cannon-shot of the town, having everything in readiness for a descent, a very severe gale of wind came on, and being directly contrary, obliged us to bear away, after having in vain endeavored for some time to withstand its violence. The gale was so severe that one of the prizes that had been taken on the 14th sunk to the bottom, the crew being with difficulty saved. As the alarm by this time had reached Leith by means of a cutter that had watched our motions that morning, and as the wind con- tinued contrary (though more moderate in the evening), I thought it impossible to pursue the enterprise with a good pros- pect of success, especially as Edinburgh, where there is al- ways a number of troops, is only a mile distant from Leith, therefore I gave up the project. On the 21st we saw and chased two sail off Flamborough Head, the Pallas in the N.E. quarter, while the Bon homme 164 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN Richard followed by the Vengence in the S.W. The one I chased, a brigantine collier in ballast belonging to Scarbor- ough was soon taken, and sunk immediately afterward, as a fleet then appeared to the southward. It was so late in the day that I could not come up with the fleet before night. At length, however, I got so near one of them as to force her to run ashore between Flamborough Head and the Spurn. Soon after I took another, a brigantine from Holland, belonging to Sunderland; and at daylight the next morning, seeing a fleet steering toward me from the Spurn, I imagined them to be a convoy, bound from London for Leith, which had been for some time expected. One of them had a pendant hoisted, and appeared to be a ship of force. They had not, however, cour- age to come on, but kept back, all except the one which seemed to be armed, and that one also kept to windward very near the land and on the edge of dangerous shoals, where I could not with safety approach. This induced me to make a signal for a pilot, and soon afterward two pilot boats came off. They informed me that the ship that wore a pendant was an armed merchant ship, and that a king’s frigate lay there in sight at anchor within the Humber, waiting to take under convoy a number of merchant ships bound to the northward. The pilots imagined the Bon homme Richard to be an English ship of war, and consequently communicated to me the private signal which they had been required to make. I endeavored _ by this means to decoy the ships out of the port, but the wind then changing, and with the tide becoming unfavorable for them, the deception had not the desired effect, and they wisely put back. The entrance of the Humber is exceedingly diffi- cult and dangerous; and, as the Pallas was not in sight, I thought it not prudent to remain off the entrance. I therefore steered out again to join the Pallas off Flamborough Head. In the night we saw and chased two ships until 3 o’clock in the morning, when, being at a very small distance from them, I made the private signal of recognizance which I had given to each captain before I sailed from Groaix; one-half of the THE BATTLE 165 answer only was returned. In this position both sides lay to till daylight, when the ships proved to be the Alliance and the Pallas. _ On the morning of that day, the 23d, the brig from Hol- land not being in sight, we chased a brigantine that appeared laying to to windward. About noon we saw and chased a large ship that appeared coming around Flamborough Head from the northward, and at the same time I manned and armed one of the pilot boats to sail in pursuit of the brigantine, which now appeared to be the vessel that I had forced ashore. Soon after this a fleet of 41 sail appeared off Flamborough Head, bearing N.N.E. This induced me to abandon the single ship which had then been anchored in Burlington Bay. I also called back the pilot boat, and hoisted a signal for a general chase. When the fleet discovered us bearing down, all the merchant ships crowded sail toward the shore. The two ships of war that protected the fleet at the same time steered from the land, and made the disposition for the battle. In approaching the enemy, I crowded every possible sail, and made the signal for the line of battle, to which the Alliance showed no attention. Earnest as I was for the action, I could not reach the commodore’s ship until seven in the evening. Being then within pistol shot, when he hailed the Bon homme Richard, we answered him by firing a whole broadside. The battle, being thus begun, was continued with unre- mitting fury. Every method was practised on both sides to gain an advantage and rake each other; and I must confess that the enemy’s ship, being much more manageable than the Bon homme Richard, gained thereby several times an advan- tageous situation, in spite of my best efforts to prevent it. As I had to deal with an enemy of greatly superior force, I was under the necessity of closing with him, to prevent the advan- tage which he had over me in point of mancuvre. It was my intention to lay the Bon homme Richard athwart the enemy’s bow, but, as that operation required great dexterity in man- agement of both sail and helm, and some of our braces being 166 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN shot away, it did not exactly succeed to my wishes. ‘The enemy’s bowsprit, however, came over the Bon homme Richard’s poop by the mizzen mast, and I made both ships fast together in that situation which by the action of the wind on the enemy’s sails forced her stern close to the Bon homme Richard’s bow, so that the ships lay square alongside of each other, the yards being all entangled, and the cannon of each ship touch- ~ ing the opponent’s side. When this position took place, it was 8 o’clock, previous to which the Bon homme Richard had _re- ceived sundry eighteen-pound shots below the water, and leaked very much. My battery of 12-pounders, on which I had placed my chief dependence, being commanded by Lieut. Dale and Col. Weibert, and manned principally with American seamen and French volunteers, were entirely silenced and abandoned. As to the six old eighteen-pounders that formed the battery of the lower gun-deck, they did no service whatever. Two out of three of them burst at the first fire, and killed almost all the men who were stationed to manage them. Before this time, too, Col. de Chamillard who commanded a party of 20 soldiers on the poop, had abandoned that station after having lost some of his men. ‘These men deserted their quarters. I had now only two pieces of cannon, nine-pounders, on the quarter deck, that were not silenced; and not one of the heavier cannon was fired during the rest of the action. The purser, Mr. Mease, who commanded the guns on the quarter deck, being dangerously wounded in the head, I was obliged to fill his place, and with great difficulty rallied a few men, and shifted over one of the quarterdeck guns, so that we afterward played three pieces of 9-pounders upon the enemy. The tops alone seconded the fire of this little battery, and held out bravely during the whole of the action, especially the main top, where Lieut. Stack commanded. I directed the fire of one of the — three cannon against the main-mast, with double-headed shot, while the other two were exceedingly well served with grape and canister shot to silence the enemy’s musketry, and clear her decks, which was at last effected. The enemy were, as I have THE BATTLE 167 since understood, on the instant of calling for quarters when the cowardice or treachery of three of my under officers in- duced them to call to the enemy. The English commodore asked me if I demanded quarters; and, I having answered him in the most determined negative, they renewed the battle with double fury. They were unable to stand the deck; but the fire of their cannon, especially the lower battery, which was entirely formed of 18-pounders, was incessant. Both ships were set on fire in various places, and the scene was dreadful beyond the reach of language. To account for the timidity of my three under officers,—I mean the gunner, the carpenter, and the master-at-arms,—I must observe that the two first were slightly wounded; and, as the ship had received various shots under water and one of the pumps being shot away, the carpenter expressed his fear that she would sink, and the other two concluded that she was sinking, which occasioned the gunner to run aft on the poop without my knowledge to strike the colors. Fortunately for me, a cannon ball had done that before by carrying away the ensign staff. He was therefore reduced to the necessity of sinking as he supposed, or of call- ing for quarter; and he preferred the latter. All this time the Bon homme Richard had sustained the action alone, and the enemy, though much superior in force, would have been very glad to have got clear, as appears by their own acknowledgments, and by their having let go an anchor the instant that I laid them on board, by which means they would have escaped, had I not made them well fast to the | Bon homme Richard. At last, at half-past nine o’clock, the Alliance appeared, and I now thought the battle at an end; but, to my utter astonishment, he discharged a broadside full into the stern of the Bon homme Richard. We called to him for God’s sake to forbear firing into the Bon homme Richard; yet he passed along the off side of the ship and continued firing. There was no possibility of his mistaking the enemy’s ship for the _ Bon homme Richard, there being the most essential difference 168 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN in their appearance and construction; besides, it was then full moonlight, and the sides of the Bon homme Richard were all black, while the sides of the prizes were yellow; yet, for the greater security, I showed the signal of our reconnoissance by putting out three lanthorns, one at the head (bow), another at the stern (quarter), and the third in the middle in a horizon- tal line. Every tongue cried that he was firing into the wrong ship, but nothing availed. He passed round, firing into the Bon homme Richard’s head, stern, and broadside; and by one of his volleys killed several of my best men, and mortally wounded a good officer on the forecastle. My situation was really deplorable. The Bon homme Richard received various shot under the water from the Alliance, the leak gained on the pumps, and the fire increased much on both ships. Some of- ficers persuaded me to strike, of whose courage and good sense I have high opinion. My treacherous master-at-arms let loose all my prisoners without my knowledge and my prospect be- came gloomy indeed. I would not, however, give up the point. The enemy’s main-mast began to shake, their firing decreased, ours rather increased, and the British colors were struck at half an hour past 10 o’clock. This prize proved to be the British ship of war the Serapis, a new ship of 44 guns, built on their most approved construc- tion, with two complete batteries, one of them of 18-pounders, and commanded by the brave Commodore Richard Pearson. I had yet two enemies to encounter far more formidable than the Britons,—I mean fire and water. The Serapis was attacked only by the first, but the Bon homme Richard was assailed by both. There were five feet of water in the hold, and though it was moderated from the explosion of so much gunpowder, yet the three pumps that remained could with difficulty only keep the water from gaining. The fire broke out in various parts of the ship, in spite of all the water that could be thrown to quench it, and at length broke out as low as the powder maga- zine, and within a few inches of the powder. In that dilemma I took out the powder upon deck, ready to be thrown over- THE BATTLE 169 board at the last extremity; and it was ten o’clock the next day, the 24th, before the fire was entirely extinguished. With respect to the situation of the Bon homme Richard, the rudder was cut entirely off the stern frame, and the transoms were almost entirely cut away; the timbers, by the lower deck especially, from the main-mast to the stern, being greatly de- cayed with age, were mangled beyond my power of description ; and a person must have been an eye-witness to form a just idea of the tremendous scene of carnage, wreck, and ruin that everywhere appeared. Humanity cannot but recoil from the prospect of such finished horror, and lament that war should produce such fatal consequences. After the carpenters, as well as Capt. de Cottineau, and other men of sense, had well examined and surveyed the ship (which was not finished before five in the evening), I found every person to be convinced that it was impossible to keep the Bon homme Richard afloat so as to reach a port if the wind should increase; it being then only a moderate breeze. I had but little time to remove my wounded, which now became un- avoidable, and which was effected in the course of the night and the next morning. I was determined to keep the Bon homme Richard afloat, and, if possible, to bring her into port. For that purpose the first lieutenant of the Pallas continued on board with a party of men to attend the pumps, with boats In waiting ready to take them on board in case the water should gain on them too fast. The wind augmented in the night and the next day, on the 25th, so that it was impossible to prevent the good old ship from sinking. They did not abandon her till after 9 o’clock. The water was then up to the lower deck, and a little after ten I saw with inexpressible grief the last glimpse of the Bon homme Richard. No lives were lost with the ship, but it was impossible to save the stores of any sort whatsoever. I lost even the best part of my clothes, books, and papers; and several of my officers lost all their clothes and effects, 170 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN Having thus endeavored to give a clear and simple rela- tion of the circumstances and the events that have attended the little armament under my command, I shall freely submit my conduct therein to the censure of my superiors and the im- partial public. I beg leave however, to observe that the force that was put under my command was far from being well composed; and, as the great majority of the actors in it have appeared bent on the pursuit of interest only, I am exceed- inly sorry that they and I have been at all concerned. I am in the highest degree sensible of the singular attentions which I have experienced from the Court of France, which I shall remember with perfect gratitude until the end of my life, and will always endeavor to merit while I can, consistent with my honor, continue in the public service. I must speak plainly. As I have been always honored with the full confidence of Con- gress, and as I also flattered myself with enjoying in some measure the confidence of the Court of France, I could not but be astonished at the conduct of M. de Chaumont, when, in the moment of my departure from Groaix, he produced a paper, a concordat, for me to sign in common with the officers whom I had commissioned but a few days before. Had that paper, or even a less dishonorable one, been proposed to me at the be- ginning, I would have rejected it with just contempt, and the word deplacement among others should have been neces- sary. I cannot, however, even now suppose that he was authorized by the court to make such a bargain with me, nor can I suppose that the minister of the marine meant that M. de Chaumont should consider me merely as a colleague with the commanders of the other ships, and communicate to them not only all he knew, but all he thought, respecting our destina- tion and operations. M. de Chaumont has made me various reproaches on account of the expense of the Bon homme Richard, wherewith I cannot think I have been justly charge- able. M. de Chamillard can attest that the Bon homme Richard was at last far from being well fitted or armed for war. If any person or persons who have been charged with THE BATTLE 171 the expense of that armament have acted wrong, the fault must not be laid to my charge. I had no authority to superintend that armament, and the persons who had authority were so far from giving me what I thought necessary that M. de Chaumont even refused among other things, to allow me irons for securing the prisoners of war. In short, while my life remains, if I have any capacity to render good and acceptable services to the common cause, no man will step forth with greater cheerfulness and alacrity than myself; but I am not to be dishonored, nor can I accept of the half confidence of any man living. Of course, I cannot, con- sistent with my honor and a prospect of success, undertake future expeditions, unless when the object and destination is communicated to me alone, and to no other person in the marine line. In cases where troops are embarked, a like con- fidence is due alone to their commander-in-chief. Qn no other condition will I ever undertake the chief command of a private expedition; and, when I do not command in chief, I have no desire to be in the secret. Captain Cottineau engaged the Countess of Scarborough, and took her after an hour’s action, while the Bon homme Richard engaged the Serapis. The Countess of Scarborough is an armed ship of 20 six-pounders, and was commanded by a king’s officer. In the action the Countess of Scarborough and the Serapis were at a considerable distance asunder; and the Alliance, as I am informed, fired into the Pallas, and killed some men. If it should be asked why the convoy was suffered to escape, I must answer that I was myself in no condition to pursue, and that none of the rest showed any inclination, not even M. Ricot, who had held off at a distance to windward during the whole action, and withheld by force the pilotboat with my lieutenant and 15 men. The Alliance, too, was in a state to pursue the fleet, not having had a single man wounded or a single shot fired at her from the Serapis, and only three that did execution from the Countess of Scarborough, at such 172 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN a distance that one stuck in the side, and the other two just touched and then dropped into the water. The Alliance killed one man only on board the Serapis. As Captain de Cottineau charged himself with manning and securing the prisoners of the Countess of Scarborough, I think the escape of the Baltic fleet cannot so well be charged to his account. I should have mentioned that the main-mast and the mizzen- top-mast of the Serapis fell overboard soon after the captain had come on board the Bon homme Richard. Upon the whole, the captain of the Alliance has behaved so very ill in every respect that I must complain loudly of his conduct. He pretends that he is authorized to act independ- ent of my command. I have been taught to the contrary; but, supposing it to be so, his conduct has been base and un- pardonable. M. de Chamillard will explain the particulars. Either Captain Landais or myself is highly criminal and one or the other must be punished. I forbear to take any steps with him until I have the advice and approbation of your ex- cellency. I have been advised by all the officers of the squad- ron to put M. Landais under arrest; but, as I have postponed it so long, I will bear with him a little longer until the return of my express. We this day anchored here, having since the action been tossed to and fro by contrary winds. I wished to have gained the road of Dunkirk on account of our prisoners, but was overruled by the majority of my colleagues. I shall hasten up to Amsterdam; and there, if I meet with no orders for my government, I will take the advice of the French ambassador. It is my present intention to have the Countess of Scarborough ready to transport the prisoners from hence to Dunkirk, un- less it should be found more expedient to deliver them to the English ambassador, taking his obligation to send to Dunkirk, &c., immediately an equal number of American prisoners. I am under strong apprehensions that our object here will fail, and that through the imprudence of M. de Chaumont, who has communicated everything he knew or thought on the matter THE BATTLE 173 to persons who cannot help talking of it at a full table. This is the way he keeps state secrets, though he never mentioned the affair to me. I am ever, &c., John P. Jones. JACATAQUA ERROR enlarges the object, as does joy. “The whole forest seemed to open,”’ says the hunter of his first tiger, “T don’t know what its exact size may have been; but, to me, it seemed thirty feet high.” So, by emotional grandeur, were the heroes of antiquity conceived; and so, to the joyful eye of the lover seems the object of his delight, bringing such wonder and awe, that each motion—each look—is exagger- ated, filled with power and significance, intensified to a degree that puts colder measurements aside. From this, the lore of romance has grown. In America, the legend of a horror before the war-whoops of the Indians gives some inkling of a great dread the colonists experienced—but there is rarely a countering legend of joy. We believe that life in America is compact of violence and "he shock of immediacy. This is not so. Were it so, there would be a corresponding beauty of the spirit—to bear it witness; a great flowering, simple and ungovernable as the configuration of a rose—that should stand with the gifts of the spirit of other times and other nations as a standard to humanity. There is none. . “The United States, without self-seeking, has given more of material help to Europe and to the world in the last ten years in time of need, than have all other nations of the world put together in the entire history of mankind. It has stamped out yellow fever from the coasts of South America, etc.” It is our need that is crying out, that and our immense wealth, the product of fear,—a torment to the spirit; we sell— but carefully—to seek blessings abroad. And this wealth, all that is not pure accident—is the growth of fear. Ii is this which makes us the flaming terror of the world, “174 OS JACATAQUA 175 a Titan, stupid (as were all the giants), great, to be tricked or tripped (from terror of us) with hatred barking at us by every sea—and by those most to whom we give the most. In the midst of wealth, riches, we have the inevitable Coolidge platform: “poorstateish”—meek. T'uts is his cure before the world: our goodness and industry. Tus will convince the world that we are ricut. It will not. Make a small mouth. It is the acme of shrewdness, of policy. It will work. We shall have more to give. Logical reasoning it is: generous to save and give. It is bred of fear. It is as impossible for a rich nation to convince any one of its generosity as for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle.’ Puritanical; pioneer; “out of the small white farm-house”—the product of delay. The characteristic of American life is that it holds off from embraces, from impacts, gaining, by fear, safety and time in which to fortify its prolific carcass—while the spirit, with tongue hanging out, bites at its bars—its object just out of reach. Wilson grazed heaven by his lewdness; the door stood open till it was slammed close. I relish the back door gossip that made him impossible. Delay, all through youth, halt and cessation, not of effort, but of touch, all through life as it is learned: no end save accumulation, always upon the way to BiccER opportunity; we keep realization from the mind with a purpose till men are trained never to possess fully but just to SEE. This makes scientists and it makes the masochist. Keep it cold and small and under the cold lens. It is bastardization as of astronomy that has no counterpart with us in the aspirations or the con- ceits of the flesh; a passion equal to the straining of a tele- scope. Digressions—The American character is acquisitive, but mediate, like the Morgan interests, Mr. Franklin at the helm, the International Mercantile Marine that owns, as mort- gager, the White Star, the Red Star, the Atlantic Transport lines, ete. American lines but English ships. We own them. But who nas them? A more practical race used to holding India. Crude as iron. 176 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN What would be better to-night than a long hour of music, at ease and away from disturbance, a friend or two of the same humor with a little talk now and again when the musi- cian, since it should be a woman, rested,—the pause before the sexual act, that interruption from desire that piles up a weight of energy behind it like stones do a river. The im- possibility to attain is the source of all good in the world, the real reason for the Puritan. No, not all good, though so it seems to Americans. There is a kind of piling of experience upon experience that is not bound to satiety, but to wisdom, the highest knowledge of all, to Buddha, if one,like, to release, to relief, to the dangerous ground of pleasure: Jenseits des lust princip, Freud sees it, beyond the charmed circle. It is no matter, since it is unknown in the province I am discussing. Here, through terror, there is no direct touch; all is cold, little and discreet:—save just under the hide. There are no American servitors. An American will not serve another man. This is a fear. Nothing is so delightful as to serve another. Instead of that, we have “service,” the thing that Rabindranath Tagore so admired, telling us we did not know we had it: Sending supplies to relieve the cyclone sufferers in Indiana. It is a passion. But to serve another, with a harder personal devotion is foreign to us: a trick for foreigners, a servant’s trick. We are afraid that we couldn’t do it and retain our self-esteem. We couldn’t. Thus we see of what our self-esteem is made. “Don’t let’s have any poor,” is our slogan. And we do not notice that the chief reason for this is that it offends us to believe that there are the essentially poor who are far richer than are we who give. The poor are ostracized. Cults are built to abolish them, as if they were cockroaches, and not human beings who may not want what we have in such abun- dance. THat would be an offense an American could not stomach. So down with them. Let everybody be rich and so ErquaL. What a farce! But what a tragedy! It rests upon false values and fear to discover them. Do not serve another JACATAQUA 1v7 for you might have to roucn him and he might be a Jew or a NiccER. Do you realize the fascination the story of the white woman who had twin nigger babies has for us? They accused the woman of having had intercourse with the apartment’s colored elevator boy. Her husband abandoned her at once, of course,—charming man. But you know Mendel’s law; they discovered there had been a darky in his family six generations before! There’s the dénouement for every good American. Be careful whom you marry! Be careful for you can NEVER know. Watch, wait, study. Deanimated, that’s the word; something the sound of “met- ronome,” a mechanical means; Yankee inventions. Machines were not so much to save time as to save dignity that fears the animate touch. It is miraculous the energy that goes into inventions here. Do you know that it now takes just ten min- utes to put a bushel of wheat on the market from planting to selling, whereas it took three hours in our colonial days? That’s striking. It must have been a tremendous force that would do that. That force is fear that robs the emotions; a mechanism to increase the gap between touch and thing, not to have a contact. America adores violence, yes. It thrills at big fires and explosions. This approaches magnificence! The finest fire- fighters in the world. We live not by having less fires but more, by the excitement of seeing torturing things done well, with light ease even. But we have violence for service, mark it. Battleships for peace. The force of enterprise for bring- ing bananas to the breakfast table. Massive mining opera- tions to transport us—whither? Bathrooms, kitchens, hos- pitals with a maximum of physical convenience and a minimum of waste to spare us—for what? We never ask. It is all a bar to more intimate shocks. Everything is for “generosity” and “honor.” It has to be for us to get away with it. There- fore, we cannot acknowledge, really, downright, thievery in our 178 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN friends. We can’t get to it. Did we do so, we should know many things most disturbing to our peace of mind. Atlanta, Georgia, is far worse than Paris for girls on the streets soliciting, but there is no good in it,—I don’t suppose there has ever been an American woman like Kiki or that delightful Baroness who paraded Fifth Avenue one day with a coal-scuttle for a chapeau. Naturally they arrested her. Naturally. She would have been arrested in any city, but not, I imagine, with quite such a sense of duty as in America. To permit such a thing would cast a very awkward light on us all. The impact of the bare soul upon the very twist of the fact which is our world about us, is un-American. T'hat we shun and rush off to the laboratory, the wheatfield (hiding our indecent passion in meddling, playing) in a spirit of serv- ice—our chemistry is all that—salt away the profits, and boast of our saving, stabilizing Constitution in dread, as of a glass heart, fiercely aligning ourselves in its defense as if it were something else than a mechanical shift. Men weaving women, women spouting men—colleges and streets torturing and annealing the machinery to cure cancer and kill mosquitoes, to carry fish in proper cars and fruit in others, to kill the Aides Egyptus in the domestic water supply of Quito by the use of minnows in the house tanks—Our life is tortuous and grotesque, huge fetishes by which we are ruled in utter darkness—or we fly abroad for sensation: Any- thing to escape—we fear simplicity as the plague. Nurver to allow touch. What are we but poor doomed carcasses, any one of us? Why then all this fury, this multiplicity we push between ourselves and our desires? Twisting and bending; that nervous habit of wanting to be thought pleasant—tor- tuous and grotesque. It is the women above all—there never have been women, save pioneer Katies; not one in flower save some moonflower Poe may have seen, or an unripe child. Poets? Where? They are the test. But a true woman in flower, never. Emily JACATAQUA 179 Dickinson, DIRS of passion in her father’s garden, is the very nearest we have ever been—starving. Never a woman: never a poet. That’s an axiom. Never a poet saw sun here. _ Oh, men have had women, millions of them, of course: good, firm Janes. But one that spouted any comprehensive joy? Never. Dolly Madison was a bright doll. At best they want to be men, sit and be a pal. It’s all right. How could they do anything else with the men brutally beaten by the life— Do you know that the old town-records in Massachusetts show few men without two and many with as many as seven wives? Not at all uncommon to have had five. How? The first ones died shooting children against the wilderness like cannon balls. There’s a reason for traditional cleverness! And we talk about the wilderness with affection. We are blind asses, with our whole history unread before us and helpless if we read it. Nothing noticed. Nothing taught in the academies. You’d think that rHat would force us into some immediacy. Never. We write books deploring the post-war hilarity of our present-day girls. Mr. Hungerford assures me the girls are no different now than they were before the Rebellion. But shh! Ben Franklin, who started black with an illegitimate son, was forced to turn white, poor Richard, to save himself later. He saw the hell and warned us, warned us to save our pennies. So, too, spendthrift Cleveland who became economist. Our life drives us apart and forces us upon science and invention—away from touch. Or if we do touch, our breed knows no better than the coarse fiber of football. Though Bill Bird says that American men are the greatest business men in the world: the only ones who understand the passion of making money: absorbed, enthralled in it. It’s a game. To me, it is because we fear to wake up that we play so well. Imagine stopping money making. Our whole conception of reality would have to be altered. But to keep a just balance between business and another object, is to spoil the intoxica- 180 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN tion, the illusion, the unity even. It’s very hard on the poet who must be something or other in order to live. To live against that stream, Emily Dickinson, about the only woman one can respect for her clarity, lived in her father’s back yard. Our breed knows no better than the coarse fibre of football, the despair we have for touching, the cheek, the breast—drives us to scream in beaten frenzy at the great spectacle of violence —or to applaud coldness and skill. Who is open to injuries? Not Americans. Get hurt; you're a fool. The only hero is he who is not hurt. We have no feeling for the tragic. Let the sucker who fails get his. What’s tragic in that? That’s funny! To hell with him. He didn’t make good, that’s all. It’s a kind of celluloid of gayety (I am speaking of the theaters), a numbing coat that cuts us off from touch. Did you see the expression on Coolidge’s face when Al Jolson did his stuff before him on the White House lawn? embarrassment, shame, fear to seem not to be amused, desire to get away— very bad taste on everybody’s part. But it was really funny to see. That jazz dose and the Puritan: something akin: both removed from simplicity, really, and touch: each his own way, that shaky shimmy and the—shame. What is the result? The result is the thing that results, of course. Anyhow, it’s curious to pick up results, you'll find tail ends of New England families—all burnt out; charming people: an old man marries a girl: male sons aplenty who sew and wash and make pies; embroider, select their mother’s hats and dress fabrics—and paint pictures: long skinny men with emotional wits who have smelt losses. A bastard aris- tocracy. Men who, when their friends disappoint them, grow nervous and cry all night. It is because there are no women. These men are more out of place in pushing young Aer than a Chinaman—or a Tibetan. Women—givers (but they have been, as reservoirs, empty) perhaps they are being filled now, Hard to deal with in busi- JACATAQUA 181 ness, more conservative, closer to earth—the only earth. They are our cattle, cattle of the spirit—not yet come in. None yet has raised benevolence to distinction. Not one to “wield her beauty as a scepter.” It is a brilliant opportunity.—But the esthetic shown by American artists (the test of the women) is discouraging: the New England eunuchs,—“no more sex than a tapeworm”—faint echoes of England, per- haps of France, of Rousseau, as Valéry Larbaud insists,— Rider: no detail in his foregrounds just remote lusts, fiery but “gone,”—Poe: moonlight. It is the annunciation of the spiritual barrenness of the American woman. Violence—the newspapers are full of murder, but it is for the papers: that’s not immediacy but rear. It is the hysteria of cheated folk, similar to the outbreaks of murder and suicide in the Germanic countries after the war—The old man that murdered the woman with a Polish name in Perth Amboy. It is so clear: A man without a woman finds one. She imme- diately starts to torture him. It’s all they can do. “Take it out of the son of a bitch”—he’s put himself in a compro- mising position and deserves to be castrated. Every force is piled against him. So he murders her. But is rat a deed of passion? Surely not. Or the motion picture murders. It’s the shriek of starvation. As Charlot said after his first abor- tive attempt to get a wife: “Such is life in the Great West,” that land of wealth and promise. As Roosevelt said of Roose- velt after this last gubernatorial campaign in New York: “He’s a promising young man.” Yes, it’s a promising coun- try. It’s what the French say of our women in Paris: prom- ising young women. Dr. Gaskins sensed it cynically: The ideal woman should end at the eyebrows and have the rest filled in with hair. It is the practical answer to the immediate American need. Prag- matism. It’s inevitable that men shall go down the scale until they strike what they want—or can get. There was the young medical fellow, a New Englander, in the State Asylum at Worcester, a periodic maniac; his history fascinated me. He 182 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN is a clever physician, and a man of excellent antecedents. Shortly after college (and a medical education takes so long that a man is in his late twenties before he can afford to marry) he married a woman far below his class,—he had to to get her. Shortly realizing his fatal error, he promptly, being a sensitive man, went insane,—and was as promptly di- vorced and committed to the asylum by his wife, proving the soundness of his mind—fundamentally. He has married three times since and has always gone mad: a little like Strindberg. But the reasoning here is truly American. Trained a Puritan, he was bursting for lack of sexual satisfaction. Unwilling - to commit the sin of fornication and being unable to get a wife of his own class, due to poverty, or what not—he mar- ried someone below his scale of esthetic or emotional relief. Thus the greater was sacrificed to the lesser. Now he was overcome with anguish. His life was ruined. He bitterly assailed himself for his folly and lost all control. In the hos- pital, he worked well in the laboratory—but he was truly insane. 'There is no class to absorb this stress. There is a story told of George Moore the last time he was in New York. Meeting at a tea some well shaped Ameri- can woman, who was apparently intent upon showing herself to the world (though the poor thing probably didn’t mean it), Moore asked her to go upstairs and undress for him that he might see her naked. She indignantly refused of course. But I like his gesture. Naturally she didn’t nave to do as he | wanted her to; yet he nailed her. And he nailed us. I think he was sufficiently distinguished for her to have satisfied him. Or, if a girl is—(not generous, bah!) but discerning with her whole body—that’s it, a woman must see with her whole body to be benevolent.—If in the eighth grade she begins to discern the depth of her necessity—she is made to feel that there is something wrong about her, not reckless but finde mentally wrong. In contradistinction, a woman from Adri- anople might be taught not that it is wrong to give herself but that murder will follow it, or that it is a dangerous gift to be ee JACATAQUA : 183 given rarely, but a GIFT. So she is shut up, like a French girl of better family, say; as we do wheat or a case of fine fruit. But the American girl who can run free must be protected in some other way so she is frightened—if possible. She is a low thing (they tell her), she is made to feel that she is vi- cious, evil—It really doesn’t do anything save alter the color of her deed, make it unprofitable, it scrapes off the bloom of the gift—it is puritanical envy. When she gives, it will be probably to the butcher boy—since she has been an apt pupil and believes that she is evil, believes even that her pleasure is evil. | It’s the central lie! but she is sure of it and gives her vir- ginity to the butcher boy instead of having at least a decent romance. As Ken. says: we get (that is, presuming we are poets) the daughters of the butcher. In the boarding school at Burlington, my friend, a teacher, was on the alert. The tension was horrible in this fashionable school. Several of the women were watching at points of vantage—with what feel- ings in their own hearts it would be easy to say. Soon a soft whistle, then the window opened and the conventional knotted sheet ladder dropped out. There was a buggy down the road. Just as the second of the two girls reached the ground, they were both seized. In a wild scramble the young fellows es- caped. Yes, the butcher boy and his pal. Of course, these things cannot be permitted. Our girls have excellent physiques, really superb. I have often watched, as who has not—for they are coming out— some bather in the little stuff they wear to-day with acid passion. And there you are. They are fit only to be seen in shows, or, in the train of a launch, on aquaplanes, six at a time, the swift motion only serving to give the authentic sense of slipperiness, pseudo-naiads without the necessary wildness and the chill—fit only to be seen by the box, like Oregon apples, bright and round but tasteless—wineless, wholesale. Why one of the hottest women that I know, lascivious in what might have been the sense in which I speak of it, but too 184 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN timid, unable to stem the great American tide inimical to women, spent almost the whole war period in Washington. She was a yeomanette but employed her spare time spying on middle-aged men, Majors with wives in Omaha, who were giv- ing the nights to their stenographers—as it was done during the war. This girl’s passion was horrible to behold. It turned slightly later, though she didn’t perhaps perceive it, to other women. She wrote to me from time to time of her experiences. I liked her and enjoyed her letters. In one let- ter, among other things, she said that no one could imagine what it meant to a girl to lose her virginity. But yes, I could imagine it, better than she. It means everything in America. Well, of course, it has meant more than it does today but I am tracing the tendency. It means that she gets such a vio- lent jolt from her past teaching and such a sense of the hatred of the world (as she conceives it must be) against her that she is ready to commit suicide. Or “go to the dogs.” That it might be the opening of wonders, of freedom to “save the nation,” that it might at least be an opportunity for practical use to the half of humanity that needs just that, never occurs to her. She is crushed. Or one imagines she is. As a matter of fact, Wally Gould tells of the two Lewiston girls who were coming home by moonlight from a rendezvous in the woods with two boy friends; one was crying, but the other sighed, and said, “Well, that’s over with”—and next day when the old fool of a neighbor was sending a box of candy to the widow, — she dumped the sweets out and filled the box with horse manure. Intelligent, our girls are, their minds are whip-like, if they don’t rot, as did Martha’s, she who beat the record of all years at Cornell; was secretary to Altman; was graduated as a trained nurse and, what a volcano of energy !—taught Greek in a school till she went mad at the slowness of the pupils— and married that marvelous little lame Irishman, Darby—who has the moods of a rose. What a woman! spending her life now as seryitor to women in the Insane Hospital on Ward’s Island —— _ JACATAQUA 185 —after being an inmate for years there herself—and recover- ing. What an energy wasted there! No place for it in the world save among the insane. Especially no place for it in the United States. Whip-like intelligences, lost after a few years. Perverse, they “deraille,” as Brancusi says, too easily. To them, Paris is bizarre, a “place to spill the nerves,” a bewildering surprise. They cannot carry a weight, as French women do their men; under the release of Paris, they are just useless, often coarse, lewd, drunk. What’s that but unsatisfying. I salute them, because only for American women, have I any deep fellow feeling, or at least they are the only ones that seem to me satisfying. Great experimenters with the emotions, “Paris” appears in so many literatures and there are so many appear- ances that are “‘Paris,” heaven knows whom they are influenc- ing. I wish they could live at home. Imagine fleeing from the world to a woman—and leaving her—strengthened, forti- fied, above all free to GO! That costs money here! Of course men should spend money upon women, especially American men. Of course, our history has been short and comparatively obscure, for the most part. There must be character in out- of-the-way places, naturally, but none has raised the point of which I speak, to distinction. They existed, we know, de- graded and demeaned in the pioneer camps, as in Maine— discredited save in a few bad narrative verses and short stories —oh, any number of stories: drunk and waking up ina whore’s bed, etc. Many men tell of that primitive kindness and savoir faire in the frontier camps, the purse returned with money intact. To that understanding one must bow. But there has been no genius in a woman, to see a man’s talent and coax it up, as did Miss Li, let us say, in the Chinese legend. Never a character to raise into story. The incidents of our lives are too completely surrounded by delays—the violence of our athletic games is mostly a de- lay. Of course, it is fortunate that we are so active and fear- 186 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN less. The youth must be “taken up” somehow. It is taken up completely in a great many cases, though. A good many college athletes are “burnt out” in their three years of com- petition; it is too much. They frequently find it impossible to breed, if that were all. Poets, through their energy, receive such a stamp of the age upon their work, that they are marked, in fact, even in the necessities of their defeat, as having lived well in their time. Poets are defeated but in an essential and total defeat at any time, that time is stamped in character upon their work, they give shape to the formless age as by a curious die,—and so other times recognize them, the positives that created the forms which give character and dignity to the damp mass of the overpowering but characterless resistance. So Jacataqua gave to womanhood in her time, the form which bitterness of pioneer character had denied it. At the left, with the company but not of it, silent in the midst of noise and laughter, one group accorded well with the wooded hill and quiet river, twenty or more Abenaki braves from Swan Island, picturesque in hunting garb. Perhaps none of all the company felt more interest and curiosity than did those dusky warriors, but their stolid faces and occasional guttural ejaculations gave no sign of the fire within. Three paces in front of these silent braves stood their Sachem, Jacataqua, a girl scarce eighteen, in whom showed the best traits of her mixed French and Indian blood. “These Anglese for whom we watch, who are they?” she asked Squire Holworth, near her. “Soldiers who go to fight the English at Quebec under Arnold.” As the transports began to arrive and the eleven hundred disembarked, Captain Howard, commandant of Fort West- ward, came up from the landing with the most notable of the guests. It was upon the reckless, dashing Arnold that all eyes were turned. Jacataqua’s Abenakis stood in the same stolid silence, still a group apart, but the maiden herself, for JACATAQUA 187 once yielding to the wild pulses of her heart, stepped between the sturdy squires to a point of vantage whence she might gaze upon the warrior whom all men seemed to honor. One swift glance she gave the hero, then her black eyes met a pair as dark and flashing as her own, met and were held. She turned to the man at her side. “That, that Anglese! Who?” “Thet? Thet’s young Burr, the one Cushing said got off a sick bed to come.” Startled, she stepped back among her people. Young Burr but waited to gain his genial host’s attention to ask, excitedly: “Who is that beauty?” “Jacataqua, Sachem of the Indians of Swan Island; you passed the wigwams of her people on the way up the river.” In a moment, Burr was standing before the Indian prin- cess, for the first and last time at a loss before a woman. Primitive and direct, it was she who opened the conversation and opened it with a challenge: © “These,” with a wave of her brown hand toward Howard and the group of officers, “these want meat. You hunt with me? I win.” THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY | beasts, so in writing, or better, speaking of Aaron Burr, one could not begin better than by saying, “there is nothing on earth divine beside humanity.” And more especially the female part of it. He was admired by women; yet, even his most violent de- tractors acknowledge him a great soldier; he had men’s ad- miration also. If distrust, jealousy and hatred can be called so, yes. A secret admiration appears often under those names. But you speak there of other things than military reputation. I say, in matters of war, he was widely acknowledged a leader. A pity, then, he did not stick to soldiermg instead of entering politics. That’s the question. I think not. On that his critics are to a man agreed. Then just there one should look closest. Not so. Indeed it is so, for if there is agreement on one point in history, be sure there’s interest there to have it so and that’s not truth. In governments, at least, I shall agree with you—nothing is divine. A S in writing of some men it should be a pageant of wild But history follows governments and never men. It por- trays us in generic patterns, like effigies or the carvings on sarcophagi, which say nothing save, of such and such a man, that he is dead. That’s history. It is concerned only with the one thing: to say everything is dead. Then it fixes up the effigy: there that’s finished. Not at all. History must stay open, it is all humanity. Are lives to be twisted forcibly about events, the mere accidents of geography and climate? 188 THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY 189 It is an obscenity which few escape—save at the hands of the stylist, literature, in which alone humanity is protected against tyrannous designs. __ But how small is the sum of good writing against the mass of poisonous stuff that finds its way into the history books; for the dead can be stifled like the living. That’s metaphysical. Never. That of the dead which exists in our imaginations has as much fact as have we ourselves. The premise that serves to fix us fixes also that part of them which we remember. If history could be that which annihilated all memory of past things from our minds it would be a useful tyranny. But since it lives in us practically day by day we should fear it. But if it is, as it may be, a tyranny over the souls of the dead—and so the imaginations of the living—where lies our greatest well of inspiration, our greatest hope of free- dom (since the future is totally blank, if not black) we should guard it doubly from the interlopers. You mean, tradition. Yes, nothing there is metaphysical. It is the better part of all of us. ‘It is the fountain! But men, never content in the malice with which they surround each living moment, must extend their illwill backward, jealous even of a freedom in the past, to maim and to destroy there too. Better to be a Mexican and take food to the graves on feast days. When a man dies what can remain to us, even from the _ best records, save a few facts—and a mass of prejudice since he, though he were the greatest man in the world, was only one among the others of his time? History that should be a left hand to us, as of a violinist, we bind up with prejudice, warping it to suit our fears as Chinese women do their feet. What can we do? Facts remain but what is the truth? We can begin by saying: No opinion can be trusted; even the facts may be nothing but a printer’s error ; but if a verdict be unanimous, it is sure to be a wrong one, a crude rush of the 190 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN herd which has carried its object before it like a helpless con- doning image. If we cannot make a man live again when he is gone, it is boorish to imprison him dead within some narrow definition, when, were he in his shoes before us, we could not do it. It’s lies, such history, and dangerous. Just there may lie our one hope for the future, beneath that stone of prejudice. Perhaps Burr A prophet? Perhaps Burr carried into politics an element of demo- cratic government, even a major. element, those times were slighting—no matter what, an element so powerful and so rare that he was hated for it, feared—and loved. “‘A dangerous man, one who ought not to be trusted with the reins of government,” said Hamilton. How dangerous, and to whom? ‘To usurpers? Why did the Senate weep so uncontrolledly at his farewell address? Perhaps he had somebody’s number. The hateful deed he spoke of had been done already, and, in their subtler appre- hensions, they wept a vital loss. “As to Burr,” it says, “these things are admitted and in- deed cannot be denied, that he is a man of extreme and irregu- lar ambition,—” He wanted to be President, an ambition both extreme and —to his enemies—irregular. *‘__that he is selfish to a degree which excludes all social affection and that he is decidedly profligate.” Hamilton again. But the man is'a balloon of malice. What has this slatternly talk to do with Burr’s ability in mat- ters of public trust? It is an attempt to maim the man by loose talk of his traits and private life where his reputation cannot be attacked by pat facts marshaled in the open. Not his ability but his reliability is questioned. But where are the facts? His enterprise in Mexico. Not yet. That one thorn on which they did impale him was a later growth. It did not come until the end of years THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY 191 of vicious enmity by Hamilton and might well be called a deed of desperation. It proved the soundness of their logic. They hounded him to it to prove their logic. So for the rest of the denunciation: Burr, seldom talkative in public (a rare point in a politician and one dangerous to an oppo- nent) but a marvelous listener (most disquieting) becomes, out of malice, “selfish to a degree that excludes all social affection,”—but the accusation falls apart itself in the last of it, that Burr was profligate—which hardly goes with one devoid of all social affection. In fact the last is a pure lie, proven fifty times over by the man’s life. Incurably generous he was dearly loved by his friends. No. It is all loose talk. Or rather talk well aimed to do a damage. They feared him. Or he was out of their control; out of their aula most likely. “A brilliant lawyer, ranked by nearly all men of his time,” it says, “only second to their favorite, his friends placed him _at the head. Calm, a persuasive speaker with an unusual power of condensation, he never spoke long but swiftly to the point. He knew no fatigue. As long as an enterprise ap- peared not impossible he was never discouraged but his insu- perable fortitude accomplished what others conceived utterly impracticable.” Is this a man to be thrown lightly into the discard? It looks mightily as if there were something there a government might conserve. “A eon man in little things while he is really small 1 in great ones.’ That’s Jeffersonian rhetoric: a well turned aye but what does it mean? It means that in the things Burr set his hand to they found him great—he had no chance for more, they would not give him way. Would he be Governor of New York? No. Would he be Ambassador in Paris? No, though the committee three times unanimously recommended his ap- pointment. Would he be Brigadier General when in 1798 the 192 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN war with France threatened? Again, no. No, no; they were envious of this courteous, well-bred, able silent man whom no enemy could down and so they sought to do away with him by any means. We should suspect the motives of those who malign him. | | Did they, or did they speak the truth of a relentless enem to law and order? They malign him, I assert, because of something strange in his composition, a weighty element—that in democracies is often called an enemy to law and order. They suspected him. Of what? 'They never can quite say. They say, this man must not be trusted. That is all. And that is ALL. So “history” has recorded him a blackguard. And that women loved him. Royally, yes; especially his daughter, his Theodosia. But that’s a sop, a trick of history— | Wait. Here’s splendid reading. “I contemplate you,” she says, “with such a mixture of humility, admiration, rever- ence, love and pride that very little superstition would be necessary to make me worship you as a superior being.” By all that is divine on earth, by children, women, soldiers, he was loved. An infatuated woman. . And by half the population to boot, since so they voted. There was something there, an element—hated and loved; suppressed; resurgent. What will history reveal? Little, count upon it, save through violent means: an egg, you must smash it to have it. . The shell only you will break. The rigid part.. Come, then, let’s look inside; to most of us, I think, Burr’s life presents a travesty on greatness. We'll take the whole period to begin with. But if we ex- amine it, not as history, that lie! but as a living thing, some- thing moving, undecided, swaying—Which way will it goP— Se eee a THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY 193 something on the brink of the Unknown, as we are today,— shall we not see it (not as history has pictured it)—in no sense a period of revolution—such uprisings are for old states where senility has become ingrained—but as a half-wild colony, young, shooting out green wood? England? A dry skin to be cast off, an itch, that’s all. There was a deeper matter, a yeast in the sap, an untracked force that might lead anywhere; it was springtime in a new world when all things were pos- sible. Freedom of conscience, a new start, and to be quit of Europe. The Revolution came with Washington, the pin about which all hearts revolved. Most were satisfied with the obvi- ous: England the oppressor, from whom freedom must be won. So when the war is over, why—there you are! But where were they? Sooner or later it must have been the same awakening without the Revolution. The war was nothing. It was a war to the death that absorbed all loyal hearts. And nearly all wits. They were at their wits’ ends. But there were some saving minds. I say, compared to the great burst of a reawakened sense of life in the spirit of the New World, the war was nothing. But in those agonies that spirit nearly died! It had been a sense of rebirth, not so much a declaration of independence against little England as an announcement to heaven itself, full of pride and of deep feeling. England must be beaten; but, under that, there was a deeper and a stronger force passing through the moment. There would be few to realize that undersong. ’ England, by chance, stood in the way. But the defeat of England was the obvious false end. And now, a race in the making, America must remember what in its hour of excite- ment it had promised, its declarations, its pronouncements, its Patrick Henry speeches. Were these just expedients of war te spur to battle or was it serious? There will be two opinions; and, if the small attempt to absorb the great— 194 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN Much will be left over... The most perhaps,—two parts, a greater and a less, the lesser biting on the larger. The war won, all fatigued, would not the way be smoothed for the easy deception that—the ob- vious thing—liberty had triumphed? | And so it had. And would there not be a shrewd party, one way or an- other, to step in and profit by the moment to say it had; and still another, opposite, to see a eine liberty not won but lost anew in the mélée? Shea’s rebellion. Shea was an inspired ass. Our fate is in the air wavering which way it will go, a Junto on one side, Burr (maybe) on the other. This is a philosophical division to be admitted if it present the facts. I speak of fiercely contested things, practical in the ex- treme, that tortured the souls of the founders: “the original principle of state vitality, the most important element in our Constitution, and one steadily undermined by Federal en- croachment.” ‘The sense of the individual, the basis on which the war was fought, instantly the war was over began to be debauched. .Randolph sensed it. Burr sensed it. Hamilton was the Federalist champion. Washington, as President, “a monster of prudence,” was the helpless mother. All very well, yet let us recognize that there are those in the world who will throw themselves into any subversive act for sheer love of violence. We are admonished to seek nothing but the good. Seek, yes, but how if you do not find it? I say, unless a land conserve this yeast, it will not raise much bread. Burr was a subversive force. Granted, granted. Then? } He was a subversive force where liberty was waning. THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY 195 They nearly hanged him for it. Hang him? They tried to torture him to death with their small slanders on his private life and would have done so had he not known how to make them fail. So now they laugh and say his genius was to keep himself amused. They could not kill it in him. His vanity they could not. His profound refinement, his sense of the deeper forces working in his world that demanded freedom; things the others were beginning to stamp out, to whittle away, down to the common level. Gutted by their own phrases, Is this the nation that made Washington? It made him a cripple. Protector of liberty. Whose, Hamilton’s?—to harness the whole, young, aspir- ing genius toa treadmill? Paterson he wished to make capital of the country because there was waterpower there which to his time and mind seemed colossal. And so he organized a company to hold the land thereabouts, with dams and sluices, the origin today of the vilest swillhole in christendom, the Passaic River ; impossible to remove the nuisance so tight had he, Hamilton, sewed up his privileges unto kingdomcome, through his holding company, in the State legislature. His company. His United States: Hamiltonia—the land of the company. You violate your own concept of what history should be when you speak so violently. The pendulum must swing. Is it not time that it swung back? ~ But was Burr really better who founded Tammany? Child’s play. So you have raised the point that once the Revolution over the New World instead of being freed slipped into a tyr- anny as bad as or worse than the one it left behind; that, of this tyranny, Hamilton was the agent; and that—perhaps— in Burr reposed the true element, liberty, which a party in a 196 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN power tried to smother. What basis, other than the one adopted under the Constitution, could the new Government have taken firmer? Burr proposed none. 'This is the charge against him: that he proposed nothing yet refused to abide loyally by the established order. | In that man there burned a springtime of the soul, a mounting desire that makes him seem, beside the harness ' animals of that dawning period like a bird in flight. But they, the others, wanting to escape their load, each puts his harness on a lesser nag,—the government on top, after the text, perhaps— Set thy servant to work, and thou shalt find rest: Leave his hands idle, and he will seek liberty. And for an evil servant (that’s Burr) there are racks and tortures. The Colonial Government was not perfect, but can the oyster live without his shell? They did what they were able. Whai did Burr propose? I say that what Burr stood for—and that this is typical of us—is lost sight of in the calumny that surrounds his name, through which the truth is not so easily to be discovered. Let us dig and we shall see what is turned up—and name it if we can. Go on. A new world, that’s what we were. It was a springtime that the colonists, at their most impassioned were attempting. But as it is a winter we are now in, and the more ordered the more wintry—dulled values, stereotyped effects of bygone _adventures—so it began to be after the Revolution; a sense of life killed, systematically, as with school children— Under a cruel eye outworn. But some one must rule, even children know that and ac- cept it with pleasure and relief. What matter who rule? to rule is without sense. There OS a ee THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY 197 can be no rule. Burr saw America in his imagination, free. His spirit leaped to it—and his body followed out of a sick bed. But his spark was not preserved. He saw America, or he had seen America, as a promise of delight and it struck fine earth, that fancy. Now he saw a sombre Washington—with shrewd dog Hamilton at his side—locking the doors, closing the windows, building fences and providing walls. He dreaded this. He saw that they would only lock up themselves, and he rebelled. | Inspired by devil or angel, Burr was a frightful danger to the young state and needed to be curbed. So much the worse for the young state then. But it’s the malice I decry. Burr’s account in history is a distortion. The good which history should have preserved, it tortures. A country is not free, is not what it pretends to be, unless it leave a vantage open (in tradition) for that which Burr pos- sessed in such remarkable degree. This is my theme. But has he not that place? He’s there in history just as you design him. He’s in myself and so I dig through lies to resurrect him. We are deceived by history. America had a great spirit given to freedom but it was a mean, narrow, provincial place; it was NOT the great liberty-loving country, not at all. Its choice spirits died. Ah, my friend, you are an enthusiast, rash guesses and the same loose talk of which you complain. The Federal Government was slipping in its fangs. The banks were being organized. A central power is strength. -“Morals and happiness will always be nearest to per- fection in small communities.” In big ones men are theorists and outlaws. Make it big enough and it becomes a wood where thieves protect each other from the more general evil— Oh balderdash, anarchy, exploded theory— One thing was sure, he used to say, no one would steal his hat, it would fit no one else he had so big a head. 198 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN All very well, but let me hear you tell the story now, how his life, in its detail, supports your roseate view of him. I doubt if you can do it. He had a good beginning. He was a brilliant student while at Princeton—howbeit there were stories of a wild life there. Jonathan Edwards was his grandfather on the moth- er’s side and his father was President of the University. He was wealthy and of a pleasing personal appearance,—though short. After the university an interest in theology took him to Connecticut for private study— Now the mill begins. To the consternation of his friends he did a rightaboutface, _ threw the whole mass of religious dogma from him and declared himself a disbeliever. He was twenty at that time, if I remember. If his world believed in freedom he came out with it. This fits in with my design. Unlike a schemer, he stood from the first in the open. Then, rising from a sickbed, he rushed off with Arnold to Quebec. The thing that offers to the eye is his enthusiasm ; headlong he goes. On that campaign, through direst hardships he returned a brilliant record; he led, he sup- ported, he adventured by himself. When there was difficult work he did it. He carried his commander from the field through snow kneedeep before the British guns. Fearless, he offered himself without stint. He was frail; it weakened him. He paid no heed. When he returned, still nothing but a boy, Washington claimed him for his staff. It was a startling opportunity for him. Burr stayed six weeks. They say that to the personal dislike between the boy and Washington that followed, much of Burr’s later unsuccess is to be traced. In fairness to them both, if there was ever an antithesis between two men, both good in essence, it was here, both fine but one the earth itself, the other—air, Somehow they should have joined. ae THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY 199 It is a fascinating moment, many chapters could be written just upon this meeting. No need of that. There was a plain reason for what took place. Burr could not stomach the restraint and the perfunc- tory nature of his work. Hamilton, himself, had not been able to do it. The General’s aides were merely clerks to him; he himself did all the planning. This was no place for a high- spirited young man demanding action. Washington fell from high hopes into disappointment, and, reading Burr’s impa- tience in his looks, distrusted him. A fixed dislike sprang up between them. 5 I do believe you sometimes when you speak of a natural malice of events; here truly there was no need for such an outcome.. At least the break was clean; there was no flattery, no carping. Burr no doubt found the General slow-witted. He could not see the power in Washington or else resented it. He chaffed at his superior’s dignity and deliberation. It made him restless. But, transferred to Putnam’s staff, he had brilliant service till through ill health he had to quit. A humbler devotion, such as the time required, he could not stomach. He was self-willed, rash in judgment and un- bridled in both speech and deed. Yet how clearly in everything he des his virtues and his faults stand out. Admit that he was rash: Mrs. Washington, he said, knit well; Mrs. Putnam was a wondrous spinner! Well enough; he looked at that, rejected it as passing and looked for more. The simpler manners of the time did not encircle him. He wanted other things of women. But, right or wrong, he must have known such preferences could not bring him popularity. It is evidence of the man’s sincerity and open disregard for the opinion of the world. He was no schemer. Washington, he said, should have retired after the war,—he 200 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN would have made a picturesque figure as a country gentleman. _ As President, Burr did not fancy him. A very shallow judgment. At least it followed his logic candidly. What cause had he to praise the everlasting prudence of the President that negated so much of value in order to conserve that which he, Burr, thought nothing? Three times the committee unani- mously recommended him for the post in Paris and each time Washington vetoed the choice. Three times right then. Well, maybe; but—here’s still a young man, dashing, rich —a proven soldier. The Clintons, the Livingstons, the Van Rensselaers all had eligible daughters. Let young Burr marry one of them. Did he? It would have been a shrewd move if one were the man avid for political ascendency. He married whom? A nobody, a widow of Paramus, New Jersey, older than himself and with two sons; unbeautiful, a scar on her face—but the most refined, courteous, gracious creature he had ever laid his eyes upon. He loved these things, as in all he does, openly—in the teeth of the world. He found her an inspiration, one who opened his eyes to the blessed pages of literature, to the deeper values that he sought—and she gave him his Theodosia. This constant evidence of the man’s clarity and disrespect for the applause of the world is in every- thing he does. Immoral virtues— He loved and straight he went to the mark. It was an impossible plane in that world. That sort of independence was bound to bring him into disrepute with the rulers of the colonies. Never though with the people, whom he knew, lovers of the senses, as was he. Men believed in him. He tied for the presidency in spite of nearly all the upper ten against him. Jefferson succeeded. He hated Burr. Overbearing toward the Vice President he told him—to look in the papers — for the news. The Vice Presidency was never better served, however. And when he ran for Governor of New York, with a ee ¢ ; y : . 4 q THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY 201 every daily paper hounding him, is that like a clever schemer, not to have support?—the lowest gossip was not too low for the New York Post. They poured their venom on him from every side. He was defeated, thanks to this, not a single paper backed him, a very awkward schemer that, and yet he nearly got it. That’s why they hated him: they feared his power. It was the dread and the love of his free spirit. And then the duel— Hamilton had hounded him for years. At length he openly called Burr “politically dangerous.” What did he mean? Burr wrote demanding an explanation. To the party in power, yes, dangerous he may have been, but to the country— How? Hamilton refused to answer. Then let it be pinned down. Either it must be one or the other. Burr was not angry. If any one feared it was not he. His head was clear, he slept well, he was refreshed and went to the place of the duel. Hamilton was fifty-seven. Burr somewhat younger. Hamilton fired first, the bullet clipping a twig above Burr’s head. His hand was trembling. Did he fire wild, as his seconds say he did, on purpose? Burr’s seconds said no, and stuck to it; the bullet came too close to their man’s head to have been anything but a’plain miss due to a shaking hand. Then Burr fired. He shot coolly, seriously and with convic- tion. He killed his man, logically and as he meant to do and knew he must. For a moment, as he saw his adversary fall, he was overcome with compassion, then he turned away. Ham- ilton, before he died, dictated his astonishing testament, in which he says—imagine the flimsy nature of his lifelong enmity _ toward the man—that, regarding Burr, he “might have been misinformed of his intentions.”” Good God, what an answer! Work till you are fifty-seven to ruin a man, insult him, malign him and then say, dying: I may have been misinformed. May it not have been so? It may, but that’s a poor excuse for Hamilton. No, Burr was not tractable; but, the villain they imagine him, he was 202 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN not either. It was his hatred of the Virginia Junto and their success against him that undid him. Did he intend an empire in the west? Sam Houston was later to be called a hero for that, if he did. Perhaps he did dream: a man whose schemes, if they were so, were so poor they never once succeeded. He was a bad scholar of his betters—whose schemes succeeded. His expedi- tion into the west was, in effect, his hatred of the Junto. It was his protest against the major fault of tyranny with which he accused the Federalist Party. If his wild scheme, whatever it may have been, was traitorous, it was no more so than theirs was subtly sinister. He hated them. ‘They knew it. He sought new worlds. The trial— A farce. No one believed in it. It’s most noteworthy inci- dent was John Marshall’s graciousness in permitting the de- fense to subpoena Jefferson, the real accuser, though he was President. Tea was served in the afternoons. Nothing was proved. But now, yes, all hope of power was ended. For twenty-five years he fought that party; in the end, he broke them backing Andrew Jackson whom he ardently admired. But he, himself, was ended. How then did he deport himself? They exiled him to Europe where his journal shows him never much depressed—a lover of his brilliant daughter. After four years he returned to meet the bitterest tragedy experience could deal him, the death of his small grandson whom he loved tenderly; then, on top of that, the death at sea of Theodosia herself. He felt at last “cut off from humanity.” His Theodosia— He had taught her everything he knew, hoping in his last years to enjoy with her a rare companionship. Now even that hope was lost. Did he intend his gross journal for her eyes as it is said? Every word of it. He had told her everything; he had created her into his free world where he lived in unconstraint. — 4 a ee THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY 203 She was as far above the women of her time as he would have had himself above the men. They say he paid to keep ten women. And there were, perhaps, an hundred bastard children—for the legend’s sake. But what I would drag out to the light is this: If they were wrong, those who judged him in his time, the intent was deliberate and malicious—and that this is typ- ical of us. I can see how you would wish to prove that so but not how you will prove it. Knowing in the marrow what they must lose, the self-styled “free and independent,” to become a nation— That is, what they must give up of personal liberty for the general good— What they must sacrifice of hard-won freedom, whittling themselves down—it was dispiriting—they realized with a nostalgic tremor that Burr had KEPT. An unbecoming jeal- ousy sprang up instanter, as with pioneers in a bad country who know that one of them is hoarding up his sugar. Burr would not give in. Let others shift and scheme and draw away, he would not. He proved himself, by ae measure, wanting in good feel- ing for his fellows. Nothing of the sort. By any measure that you choose, what we find good our virtue is to cling to it. The common good he found common—and did not hesitate to show it. The common good he found lacking, in no matter what—but lack- ing. He would not stand for its tyrannical assertions. The rare thing—liberty—he saw disappearing in the dreadful lev- eling, the machinations of a Junto, no matter how well inten- tioned, were seeking to negate for themselves by seizing power. Was he so great a rock of liberty? They knew they must give up much, he refused—and de- manded still a place for himself, whole. They yielding to the crowd, yet felt regret to take its dust. The degradation which they suffered and he refused to suffer brought their hatred 204 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN down on him with double force. It was all in that feeling. He gave it vent. The loss to Jefferson of a glass candlestick, and more later, which he imagined he could sacrifice; Washington retiring disheartened to his farm to breathe the air; Burr carried into politics. At last we have it! A humanity, his own, free and independent, unyielding to the herd, practical, direct. That was his violent party that, based on the rock, could not be moved. Did he present it in that light? What light? Who shall name that thing? It is the hid- den flame, but like all that’s universal it cannot be packed into three common words. They called him frivolous. Because he was serious, because he gave himself wholly where they played and ducked and hedged and took their sorrow off into the parlor or among the cattle. He stood up and was arrogant, unyielding. They strutted pompously— shyly, great liberals; he struck straight for liberty and did not kid himself that he had it, he who believed in himself and his teaching and his blood, when he was smothering it in pretty fancies and high-sounding phrases and dung. Either they had what they were fighting for or they did not have it. England or the mob, it made small difference to him. He WAS serious, they were the triflers—their own dupes. They said he was immoral. He was, safely so, by the flesh. He found safety in that flesh and among its sturdy guardians—women. Were they too idle in recognizing him? They loved him. Frivolous? He was perhaps the only one of the time who saw women, in the flesh, as serious, and they hailed and welcomed with deep gratitude and profound joy his serious knowledge and regard and liberating force—for them. Freedom? 'Then for women also—but such a freedom that the one defense must be—im- moral. He laughed at that and dug in the deeper. He treated them lightly. ee ee ee i. THE VIRTUE OF HISTORY 205 Never. He kept their secrets; no man has a better record. Asked his opinion he could say of women: all seriousness, yet you must speak light nothings to them. The rest were frivo- lous with women. The rest denied them, condoned the female flesh, found them helpmates at the best and at the worst, horses, cattle, provincial accessories, useful workers to make coffee and doughnuts—and to be left to go crazy on the farms for five generations after—that’s New England, or they’d hide the bull behind the barn, so that the women would not think it knew the cows were—Bah, feudal dolls gone wrong, that’s Virginia. Women? necessary but not noble, not the highest, not deliciously a free thing, apart, feminine, a heaven;—afraid to delve in it save like so much dough. Burr found the spirit living there, free and equal, independ- ent, springing with life. Or did he? I say if he did he was before his time. Surely they drank of him like water. Of children he was passionately fond, and they of him. Those little images of freedom, children, fascinated him. They, loving seriousness and openness and all things with light m them—loved him. He adored them, his stepsons among the first, and after them, that little grandson, Theodo- sia’s baby who died—and broke the old man’s heart. He was immoral as a satyr. It is a cry of fear and disappointment—and perverse pleas- ure. The acute delight Americans have always got from de- nying themselves joy and maiming others that they might be “saved” from some obliquity of moral carriage is only lately understood. One step further and it leads to persecutions. The world is made to eat, not leave, that the spirit may be full, not empty. It is every licentious man’s excuse for his excesses. Free- dom is not so easy. There is no tyranny save ignorance and no escape from it save clear and persistent moral achievement, deeply followed. Doubtful of an advance the mere sensualist flaps and flounders. Burr knew what a democracy must liberate. 206 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN What then? Men intact—with all their senses waking. He had, raised to a different level, the directness of “common people” which reformers, that is to say, schemers, commonly neglect, mis- name, misapprehend as if it were anything but to touch, to hear, to see, to smell, to taste. Transcendental theory, my dear countryman. What is ; the delicious sincerity of pioneer people? In Burr this aristocratic strain, straight out of the ground, was seeing its own ground belied. To maintain that truth up through the scale is the hard thing. A while ago, just here, I heard a Polish woman saying to her daughter: “You bust your coat with your fifty sweaters.” What’s that: You bust your coat with your fifty sweaters? Its immediacy, its sensual quality, a pure observation, its lack of irritation, its lack of pretense, its playful exaggera- tion, its repose, its sense of design, its openness, its gayety, its unconstraint. It frees, it creates relief. In the great it is the same, or would be if ever it existed, a delicious sincerity (in greater things of course) not a scheme, nor a system of pro- cedure—but careless truth. A second China you would have. Burr’s life was of that stuff. It is this that is trying to escape in a democracy. Traitors have it, maybe; also the incapable. Yes, they have (maybe); it saves them. And if it has not appeared in the great rulers of the world it is because they lack power of the spirit and it is yet to appear. It is difficult but itis IT, | Not too enlightening, that. What does it matter on this earth about scientists, philoso- phers or saints? Snake charmers. An amusement. Their schemes amount to nothing. But to the men themselves every moment, every detail, the devotion, the clarities are vital—and so we value them, in short, by their style. They must ponder deeply, pass hours of suspense, give themselves wholly, seri- ee ae a — a SS aera — = % THE VIRTURE OF HISTORY 207 ously that they may have the authenticity of a shepherd—or a clown, without which their lives, are so much paper. Well, yes. But how is Burr concerned in this? If politics could be the science of humanity, I think his place was there. He was the essence of the schemes the others made. Granted that the value of all things—and men—is purely spiritual, a devotion in themselves to painstaking truthfulness, with no interfering, yet how will Burr—? Such things have an aspect, on the world’s side, that be- wilders us. That obscene flesh in which we dig for all our good, man and woman alike, Burr knew and trusted. Here he lived, giving and receiving to the full of his instinctive nature. But passion will obscure our sense so that we eat sad stuff and call it nectar. Burr was heavily censured by his time, immoral, traitorous and irregular. What they say of him, I still believe. Believe it if you will but listen to this story: Near the end of his life a lady said to him: “Colonel, I wonder if you were ever the gay Lothario they say you were.” The old man turned his eyes, the lustre still undiminished, toward the lady —and lifting his trembling finger said in his quiet, impressive whisper: “They say, they say, they say. Ah, my child, how long are you going to continue to use those dreadful words? Those two little words have done more harm than all others. Never use them, my dear, never use them.” ADVENT OF THE SLAVES) HE colored men and women whom I know intimately add a quality, that is delightful, to the life about me. There is little use, after all—save in a title—of speaking of the advent of the slaves; these were just men of a certain mettle who came to America in ships, like the rest. 'The minor differences of condition were of no importance—the mere con- dition of their coming is of no importance— The colored men and women whom I have known intimately have a racial character which has impressed me. I have not much bothered to know why, exactly, this has been so— The one thing that never seems to occur to anybody is that the negroes have a quality which they have brought to America. It is not important that it is available or not to us for any special use— Poised against the Mayflower is the slave ship—manned by Yankees and Englishmen—bringing another race to try upon the New World, that will prove its tenacity and ability to thrive by seizing upon the Christian religion—a thing to replace their own elephant-, snake- and gorilla-filled jungles— on which to fasten for stability, blowing into it the soul of their own darkness, where, as were the Aztecs in ‘their bloody chapels, they are founded— They helped to build “a society that was rich and in some ways sumptuous and curiously oriental”. ‘Puritan Massa- chusetts unable to rid itself of the idea of man’s essential wickedness, could not envision this earthly paradise, Geor- gia—’ great gentlemen almost openly kept their concubines; great ladies half dozed through the long summer afternoons on their ; 208 > “In many families every child had his individual slave; 4 ADVENT OF THE SLAVES 209 shaded piazzas mollified by the slow fanning of their black attendants, and by the laving of their feet in water periodically fetched anew from the spring house”—it is a sunken quality, or it is a living quality—it is no matter which. All the rest is to keep from having to say anything more —like a nigger: it is their beauty. When they try to make their race an issue—it is nothing. In a chorus singing T'rova- tore, they are nothing. But saying nothing, dancing nothing, “NOBODY”, it is a quality— Bert Williams, author of a Russian ballet, The Kiss; that’s worse than nothin’. But “Somewhere the sun am shinin’—for ME...” That’s somernin’. Taking his shoes off; that’s SOMETHIN’. . . . dancing, singing with the wild abandon of being close, closer, closest together ; waggin’, wavin’, weavin’, shakin’ ; or alone, in a cabin, at night, in the stillness, in the moonlight —hein’ nothin’—with gravity, with tenderness—they arrive and “walk all over God’s heaven—” There is a solidity, a racial irreducible minimum, which gives them poise in a world where they have no authority— Or a ramshackle “castle”, peaked with doll’s house gables, all awry, by the railroad; where the boys came with their “brides” in those good old. days sust before the war; old shoes and a shambling independence: a tigerish life, lived in defiance over a worthless son, by virtue of fierce courage, a heavy fearless voice and a desperate determination to be let alone—with two reminiscent, shrewd, remembering eyes stamping authenticity upon her words—and long gorilla arms to deal a heavy blow upon man or woman who may threaten her, with a shouted threat of knife-thrust or hatchet stroke if that fails. She was knocked down, bellowing like a buffalo, maltreated—by whom? You wouldn’t get it out of her. But she announced to whoever has ears, in this place or the next, that it wouldn’t happen another time,—and it hasn’t. On a Saturday night shuffling along absorbed, with slow, swinging gait, or staring into odd corners, or settling back on her heels 210 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN with a belligerent scowl if greeted—ready to talk: “Why how are ya?”—anywhere. “Go ahead, kill me, I ain’t afraid of a. I remember with thrilling pleasure and deep satisfaction E. K. Means’ tale, Diada Daughter of Discord, an outstanding story of a wild nigger wench, billeted upon a friend’s family by her owner while he went for a short boat trip without her. Read Diada—cutting cane stalks, sharpening them with light- ning speed and driving them through the attacking hounds. “faces like old Florentine oak. Also the set pieces of your faces stir me— leading citizens— but not in the same way.” Nothin’ makes much difference—to Otie: Butcher knife, butcher knife, Mr. Gould wants you. It’s a quality, the same as “Sweet everlasting voices be still”. Of the colored men and women whom I have known inti- mately, the most loquacious is M.—who can’t eat eggs because it gives him the hives. Language grows in the original from _ his laughing lips, “You know that bloom of youth stuff”, his shy crooked smile, weary, slow, topping his svelt figure, his — straight, slim six feet of willowy grace, drooping from the shoulders, smiling sleepy eyes. ‘White blood and colored blood _ don’t mix,” said he nursing his injury, “Doc, I got a hemor- _ rhage of the riute,” he said. “Cocaine for horses, cocaine — for mules, IN THE TRENCHES!” he yelled as I removed — the bandage. “I’m going to feed this to the ducks,” he said. _ The relief is never ending, never failing. It is water froma ADVENT OF THE SLAVES 211 spring to talk with him—it is a quality. I wish I might write a book of his improvisations in slang. I wish I might write a play in collaboration with him. His old man is a different sort: I once ale several pages of notes upon his conversation—but I lost them; he was an able fisherman along the North Atlantic shore, resistant as an eel. In the hold of the vessel when they were packing porgies, ice and fish filling the hold of the schooner in heavy layers, it was he who could stay down there at work longest— For sheer sordidness we never touch them, the desperate drunkenness, upon foul stuff, in which they nearly die in a heap of rags under the eaves in the attic of some revolting, dis- ease-ridden female’s dump—fly-covered, dazed— For purity of religious devotion, in the simplicity of their manceuvres, they exceed our greatest application. Personal cleanliness becomes them with an oriental grace before which our ablutions pale to insignificance. They wear the pest fabrics that money can buy, man and woman alike. It is nothing, nothing. There was Georgie Anderson whom I remember as some female who walked upon air and light—in her wild girlhood. And there was “Dudu”, gentle as the dew or rain in April, —but I knew she had a temper for those who offended her— And there are many others. Put them on a ship, under any circumstances you may fancy and you have them coming, coming. Why for? Nothin’— As old man Hemby said to me at the door: “I’m here. I come after you yesterday but I couldn’t find yous. Doctor, I’m in a bad fix; I want you to do something for me.’ DESCENT Scotch-Irish, ran away from his brothers of whom he was a charge and joined the Cherokee Indians of West- ern Tennessee. He lived with them until eighteen, then re- ascended to the settlements for school. . . . The primitive destiny of the land is obscure, but it has been obscured further by a field of unrelated culture stuccoed upon it that has made that destmy more difficult than ever to determine. ‘To this latter nearly all the xsthetic adhesions of the present day occur. Through that stratum of obscurity the acute but frail genius of the place must penetrate. The seed is tough but the chances are entirely against a growth. It is possible for every A T fifteen years of age Samuel Houston, born 1793, vestige of virtue from the New World to be lost, like the wood pigeon. Houston was one of the few men of his time suited men- tally, morally, physically for dominant achievement. Gov- ernor of Tennessee, 1829, he married Eliza Allen of a promi- nent family of Sumner County, of that state. After three months she left him. None knows the reason, both remained silent. He wrote, “Eliza stands acquitted by me.” The brief duration of the marriage, the violence and permanence of the separation, the prominence of Houston and the lack of all in- formation forthcoming concerning the incident give it an arresting character. Surmise will suit the fancy: he accused her of a romantic attachment; she accused him of worse; or there was, more likely, a disproportion between them; a man of primitive vigors loosed upon her in private, she was over- borne by him in some manner, or she refused to be overborne. He, swept off his feet by the emotional recoil from the mis- fortune, first pleaded with her father to intercede for him that "212 DESCENT 213 his wife might return; failing in this, he resigned the gover- norship of Tennessee, left everything behind him and took the descent once more, to the ground. He rejoined the Chero- kees, now removed to Arkansas. The state was in an uproar, people spoke badly of him; there was nothing too bad for them to say. His wife divorced him and remarried. For a while he took to drink. . . . He turned back to the Indians, it is the saving gesture—but a gesture of despair. Poe can be under- stood only in a knowledge of his deep roots. The quality of the flower will then be seen to be normal, in all its tortured spirituosity and paleness, a desert gore with roots under _ the sand of his day. Whitman had to come from under. All have to come from under and through a dead layer. But this primitive ordeal, created by a peculiar condition of destiny (the implantation of an already partly cultured race on a wild continent) has a plant in its purpose, in its lusts’ eye, as gorgeous as Montezuma’s gardens of birds, wild beasts and albino natives in wooden cages. But he who will grow from that basis must sink first. If he goes to France, it is not to learn a do re mi fa sol. He goes to see a strange New World. If not definitely a culture new in every part, at least a sat- isfaction. He wants to have the feet of his understanding on the ground, his ground, the ground, the only ground that he knows, that which is under his feet. I speak of esthetic satisfaction. This want, in America, can only be filled by ‘knowledge, a poetic knowledge, of that ground. Since this is difficult, due to the hardships which beset the emergence of a poet: A poet is one related to a basis of material, esthetic, spiritual, hypothetical, abnormal—satisfaction, . . . since this is so, the want goes for the most part unsatisfied in America or is satisfied by a fillgap. The predominant picture of America is a land esthetically satisfied by temporary fill- gaps. But the danger remains: Taste is so debauched in the end that everything of new will be forgotten and— 214 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN In spite of size its genius is shy and wild and frail, the loveliest, to be cherished only by the most keen, courageous and sensitive. It may die. Meanwhile, taste is pandered to somehow. . . . Among the Indians Houston lived, from the time of his separation from his wife, eleven years. He was adopted into the tribe; he, maintaining silence upon the calamity which had overtaken him, preferred to be among those who accepted him for what he was and let no rumor of his past affect them. It was a courtesy he knew how to find as they to proffer. It came from the ground like water. He took an Indian woman for his wife. 7 The instigation to invasion is apparent: ready profit. The excuse also is apparent: progress. The refusal of these things is like feathered darts on armor. We are tyros in what we are glad to believe are the fundamentals of artistic under- standing. We crave filling and eagerly grab for what there is. The next step is, floating upon cash, to wish to be like the others. Now come in the Universities, the conformists of all colors from the arch-English to the Italian peasant and his goats. It is imperative that we sink. But from a low position it is impossible to answer those who know all the Latin and some of the Sanskrit names, much French and perhaps one or two other literatures. Their riposte is: Knownothingism. But we cannot climb every tree in that world of birds. But where foreign values are held to be a desideratum, he who is buried and speaks thickly—ais lost. There is nothing for a man but genius or despair. We cannot answer in the smart language, certainly it would be a bastardization of our own talents to waste time to learn the language they use. I would rather sneak off and die like a sick dog than be a well known literary person in America—and no doubt Til do it in the end. Our betters we may bitterly ad- vise: Know nothing (i.e., the man on the street), make no attempt to know. With a foreign congeries of literary clap- eee i i ee ee ee ee Se a DESCENT 215, trap, come without courtesy to a strange country and make for yourself a smooth track to the pockets of the mob by cater- _ ing to a “refined” taste and soiling that which you do not know how to estimate. Courtesy would at least bid him be informed or keep still. ... Those who come up from under will have a mark on them that invites scorn, like a farmer’s filthy clodhoppers. They will be recognized only from abroad, being so like the mass out of which they come as to be scorned from anear, etc., etc., etc. . . . After the many years with the Cherokees, having settled down thoroughly, this time, Houston rose again: de- feated Santa Ana at San Jacinto and: received the soubri- quet, “Sam Jacinto,” Governor of Texas, U. S. Senator dur- ing a long term, several times mentioned for the presidency, married again, several children, when in deep thought whit- tled pine sticks, tigerskin vest, blanket, sombrero, joined Bap- tist Church, opposed secession of southern states, lived to have Lincoln recognize him by offer of a Major-Generalship, which he refused. However hopeless it may seem, we have no other choice: we must go back to the beginning; it must all be done over; everything that is must be destroyed. EDGAR ALLAN POE I OE was not “a fault of nature”, “a find for French eyes”, _ ripe but unaccountable, as through our woollyheaded- ness we’ve sought to designate him, but a genius inti- mately shaped by his locality and time. It is to save our faces that we’ve given him a crazy reputation, a writer from whose classic accuracies we have not known how else to escape. The false emphasis was helped by his Parisian vogue and tonal influence on Baudelaire, but the French mind was deeper hit than that. Poe’s work strikes by its scrupulous originality, not “originality” in the bastard sense, but in its legitimate sense of solidity which goes back to the ground, a conviction that he can judge within himself. These things the French were ready to perceive and quick to use to their advantage: a new point from which to readjust the trigonometric measure- ments of literary form. It is the New World, or to leave that for the better term, it is anew locality that is in Poe assertive; it is America, the first great burst through to expression of a re-awakened genius of place. Poe gives the sense for the first time in America, that liter- ature is serious, not a matter of courtesy but of truth. (See Maria Lucretia Davidson). The aspect of his critical statements as a whole, from their hundred American titles to the inmost structure of his sen- tences, is that of a single gesture, not avoiding the trivial, to sweep all worthless chaff aside. It is a movement, first and last to clear the crounp. : There is a flavor of provincialism that 1s provincialism in the plainness of his reasoning upon elementary grammatical, syntactical and prosodic grounds which awakened Lowell’s 216 : | i sa als Se — a es. EDGAR ALLAN POE | 217 derision. But insistence upon primary distinctions, that seems coldly academic, was in this case no more than evidence of a strong impulse to begin at the beginning. Poe was unsophis- ticated, when contrasted with the puerile sophistications of a Lowell. It is a beginning he has in mind, a juvenescent local literature. By this he avoids the clownish turn of trying to join, contrary to every reasonable impulsion, a literature (the English) with which he had no actual connection and which might be presumed, long since, to have passed that beginning which to the new condition was requisite. But Mr. Lowell’s comment had to be answered: “Here comes Poe with his Raven, like Barnaby Rudge— Three fifths of him genius, and two fifths sheer fudge; Who talks like a book of iambs and pentameters In a way to make all men of common sense damn meters Who has written some things far the best of their kind; But somehow the heart seems squeezed out by the mind.” It brings a technical retort from Poe upon the grounds that, “We may observe here that profound ignorance on any particular topic is always sure to manifest itself by some allu- sion to ‘common sense’ as an all-sufficient instructor.” Then he tears L.’s versification to pieces, adding, “Mr. L. should not have meddled with the anapestic rhythm: it is exceedingly awkward in the hands of one who knows nothing about it and who will persist in fancying that he can write it by ear.” But, previously, he had nailed the matter in a different vein. Lo- well “could not do a better thing than to take the advice of those who mean him well, and leave prose, with satiric verse, to those who are better able to manage them; while he contents himself with that class of poetry for which, and for which alone, he seems to have an especial vocation—the poetry of sentiment.” But Poe might have added finally, in his own defense, what he says elsewhere, concerning the accusation in L.’s last two lines: “The highest order of the imaginative intel- lect is always preeminently mathematical—” Pry 218 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN The whole passage is noteworthy not only for the brilliance of such a statement as that, but also because of its use of the provincial “we” (Mr. Griswold and the Poets): “That we are not a poetical people has been asserted so often and so roundly, both at home and abroad that the slander, through mere dint of repetition, has come to be received as truth. Yet nothing can be farther removed from it. The mistake is but a portion, or corollary, of the old dogma, that the calculating faculties are at war with the ideal; while, in fact, it may be demonstrated that the two divisions of mental power are never to be found in perfection apart. The highest order of the imaginative in- tellect is always preéminently mathematical ; and the converse.” “The idiosyncrasy of our political position has stimulated into early action whatever practical talent we possessed. Even in our national infancy we evinced a degree of utilitarian abil- ity which put to shame the mature skill of our forefathers, While yet in leading strings we proved ourselves adepts in all the arts and sciences which promoted the comfort of the animal man. But the arena of exertion, and of consequent distinction, into which our first and most obvious wants impelled us, has been regarded as the field of our deliberate choice. Our neces- sities have been taken for our propensities. Having been forced to make railroads, it has been deemed impossible that we should make verse. Because it suited us to construct an engine in the first instance, it has been denied that we could compose an epic in the second. Because we are not all Homers in the beginning, it has been somewhat rashly taken for granted that we shall be all Jeremy Benthams to the end.” “But this is purest insanity . . .” In the critical note upon Francis Marryat, the distinction between “nationality in letters”, which Poe carefully slights, and the preéminent importance, in letters as in all other branches of imaginative creation, of the lecal, which is his con- stant focus of attention, is to be noted. — Poe was Not, it must be repeated, a Macabre genius, essen- EDGAR ALLAN POE © 219 tially lost upon the grotesque and the arabesque. If we have appraised him a morass of “lolling lilies”, that is surface only. The local causes shaping Poe’s genius were two in charac- ter: the necessity for a fresh beginning, backed by a native vigor of extraordinary proportions,—with the corollary, that all “colonial imitation” must be swept aside. This was the conscious force which rose in Poe as innumerable timeless in- sights resulting, by his genius, in firm statements on the char- acter of form, profusely illustrated by his practices; and, second the immediate effect of the locality upon the first, upon his nascent impulses, upon his original thrusts; tormenting the depths into a surface of bizarre designs by which he’s known and which are noé at all the major point in question. Yet Boru influences were determined by the locality, which, in the usual fashion, finds its mind swayed by the results of its stupidity rather than by a self-interest bred of greater wisdom. As with all else in America, the value of Poe’s genius TO OURSELVES must be wncovered from our droppings, or at least uncovered from the “protection” which it must have raised about itself to have survived in any form among us— where everything is quickly trampled. | Poe “saw the end”; unhappily he saw his own despair at the same time, yet he continued to attack, with amazing genius seeking to discover, and discovering, points of firmness by which to stanp and grasp, against the slipping way they had of holding on in his locality. Either the New World must be mine as I will have it, or it is a worthless bog. There can be no concession. His attack was from the center out. Either I exist or I do not exist and no amount of pap which I hap- pen to be lapping can dull me to the loss. It was a doctrine, anti-American. Here everything was makeshift, everything was colossal, in profusion. The frightened hogs or scared birds feeding on the corn— It left, in 1840, the same mood as ever dominant among us. Take what you can get. What you lack, copy. It was a population puffed with braggadocio, whom Poe so beautifully summarizes in many of his prose tales. 200 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN To such men, all of them, the most terrible experience in the world is to be shown up. This Poe did, in his criticisms, with venomous accuracy. It was a gesture to BE cLEAN. It was a wish to HAvE the world or leave it. It was the truest instinct in America demanding to be satisfied, and an end to makeshifts, self deceptions and grotesque excuses. And yet the grotesque inappropriateness of the life about him forced itself in among his words. One is forced on the conception of the New World as a woman. Poe was a new De Soto. The rest might be content with little things, not he. : ‘Rather the ice than their way.” His attack upon the difficulty which faced him was bril- liantly conceived, faultlessly maintained and successful. The best term is perhaps: immaculate. What he wanted was connected with no particular place; — therefore it must be where he was. “We have at length arrived at that epoch when our litera- ture may and must stand on its own merits, or fall through its own defects. We have snapped asunder the leading-strings of our British Grandmama, and, better still, we have survived the first hours of our novel freedom,—the first licentious hours of hobbledehoy braggadocio and swagger. At last, then, we are in a condition to be criticized—even more, to be ne- glected ; What Poe says gains power by his not diminishing his force for the slightness of the object; it is a sense of an inevit- able, impartial tide. “We have no design to be bitter. We notice this book at all, only because it is an unusually large one of its kind, because it is lying here upon our table, and be- cause, whether justly or unjustly, whether for good reason or for none, it has attracted some portion of the attention of the public.” There is no softening for the department of names, old or new, but a sense of the evidence examined, as it lies on the page, by a faultless mechanism which he brings from the rear of his head for the trial. EDGAR ALLAN POE 221 Lowell, Bryant, etc., concerned poetry with literature, Poe concerned it with the soul; hence their differing conceptions of the use of language. With Poe, words were not hung by usage with associations, the pleasing wraiths of former masteries, this is the sentimental trap-door to beginnings. With Poe words were figures; an old language truly, but one from which he carried over only the most elemental qualities to his new purpose; which was, to find a way to tell his soul. Sometimes he used words so playfully his sentences seem to fly away from sense, the destructive! with the conserving abandon, fore- shadowed, of a Gertrude Stein. The particles of language must be clear as sand. (See Diddling.) This was an impossible conception for the gluey imagina- tion of his day. Constantly he labored to detach someTHING from the inchoate mass—That’s it: His concern, the apex of his immaculate attack, was to detach a “method” from the smear of common usage—it is the work of nine tenths of his criticism. He struck to lay low the “niaiseries” of form and content with which his world abounded. It was a machine-gun fire; even in the slaughter of banality he rises to a merciless distinction. (See Rufus Dawes.) He sought by stress upon construction to hold the loose-strung mass off even at-the cost of an icy coldness of ap- pearance; it was the first need of his time, an escape from the formless mass he hated. It is the very sense of a beginning, as it is the impulse which drove him to the character of all his tales; to get from sentiment to form, a backstroke from the swarming “population.” He has a habit, borrowed perhaps from algebra, of balanc- ing his sentences in the middle, or of reversing them in the later clauses, a sense of play, as with objects, or numerals which he has in the original, disassociated, that is, from other literary habit; separate words which he feels and turns about as if he fitted them to his design with some sense of their individual quality: “those who belong properly to books, and to whom books, perhaps, do not quite so properly belong.” 2922 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN The strong sense of a beginning in Poe is in no one else before him. What he says, being thoroughly local in origin, has some chance of being universal in application, a thing they never dared conceive. Made to fit a place it will have that actual quality of things anti-metaphysica | About Poe there is— No supernatural mystery— No extraordinary eccentricity of fate—— He is American, understandable by a simple exercise of reason; a light in the morass—which must appear eerie, even to him- self, by force of terrific contrast, an isolation that would nat- urally lead to drunkenness and death, logically and simply— by despair, as the very final evidence of a too fine seriousness and devotion. It is natural that the French (foreigners, unacquainted with American conditions) should be attracted by the sur- Face of his genius and copy the wrong thing, (but the ex- _ pressive thing), the strange, the bizarre (the recoil) without sensing the actuality, of which that is the complement,—and we get for Poe a REPuTATION for eccentric genius, maimed, the curious, the sick—at least the unexplainable crop-up, unre- lated to his ground—which has become his inheritance. * # * * * * * * * “The fiery serpent that bit the children of Israel when — they wandered through the wilderness was possibly the guinea worm, which enters the body as a water flea, develops, and ultimately, lies coiled under the skin, from one to six feet in length. It formerly was coaxed out by winding it on a stick little by little each day. Then the zoologist found that it seeks — water in which to lay its eggs, and will naively crawl out if — the affected leg or arm is simply submerged in water for a few _ hours. “The mysterious is so simple when revealed by science!” * * * * * * % bd * On him is FOUNDED A LITERATURE—typical; an anger to sweep out the unoriginal, that became ill-tempered, a mono- — q 7 EDGAR ALLAN POE 293 maniacal driving to destroy, to annihilate the copied, the slav- ish, the rauseE literature about him: this is the major impulse in his notes—darkening as he goes, losing the battle, as he feels himself going under—he emerges as the ghoulish, the driven back. It is the crudeness with which he was attacked in his own person, scoffed at— He declares, maintains himself, pre-supposes himself and 1s first rate. First!—madly, valiantly battling for the right to BE first—to hold up his orreinaLiry— “Tf a man—if an Orphicist—or srEER—or whatever else he may choose to call himself, while the rest of the world calls him an ass—if this gentleman have an idea which he does not understand himself, the best thing he can do is to say nothing about it; ... but if he have any idea which is actually intelligi- ble to himself, and if he sincerely wishes to render it intelligible to others, we then hold it as indisputable that he should employ those forms of speech which are the best adapted to further his object. He should speak to the people in that people’s ordi- nary tongue. He should arrange words such as are habitually employed for the preliminary and introductory ideas to be conveyed—he should arrange them in collocations such as those in which we are accustomed to see those words arranged.” “Meantime we earnestly ask if bread-and-butter be the vast IDEA in question—if bread-and-butter be any portion of this vast wea? for we have often observed that when a sEER has to speak of even so usual a thing as bread-and- eee he can never be induced to mention it outright. . a The language of his essays is a peiarieatle HISTORY of the locality he springs from. There is no aroma to his words, rather a luminosity, that comes of a disassociation from anything else than thought and ideals; a coldly nebulous, side to side juxtaposition of the words as the ideas—It seems to fall back continuously to a bare surface exhausted by having reached no perch in tradition. Seldom a long or sensuous sen- tence, but with frequent reduplication upon itself as if holding itself up by itself. 094 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN Thought, thought, mass—and the sense of soMETHING over the heads of the composite particles of the logic, the im- significance of the details, wu1cH HE DID acTUALLY achieve. A “childlike,” simple, deductive reasoning IS his criticism—a sense of BEGINNINc—of originality that presupposes an in- trinsic wortH in the reasoner—a sense of stripped, being clothed, nevertheless. Unwilling to concede the necessity for any prop to his logical constructions, save the locality upon which originality is rested, he is the diametric opposite of Longfellow—to say the least. But Longfellow was the apotheosis of all that had preceded him in America, to this extent, that he brought over — the most from “the other side.” In “Longfellow and Other Plagiarists,” Poe looses himself to the full upon them. But what had they done? No more surely than five hundred archi- tects are constantly practicing. Longfellow did it without genius, perhaps, but he did no more and no less than to bring the tower of the Seville Cathedral to Madison Square. This is the expression of a “good” spirit. It is the desire to have “culture” for America by “finding” it, full blown— — somewhere. But we had wandered too far, suffered too many losses for that. Such a conception could be no more than a pathetic reminiscence. It had noruine of the New World in ~ it. Yet, it was bred of the wish to bring to the locality what it lacked. What it lacked, really, was to be cultivated. So they build an unrelated copy upon it; this, as a sign of intelligence,— vigor. ‘That is, to bring out its qualities, they cover them. Culture is still the effect of cultivation, to work with a thing until it be rare; as a golden dome among the mustard fields. It implies a solidity capable of cultivation. Its effects are marble blocks that lie perfectly fitted and aligned to express — by isolate distinction the rising lusts which threw them off, regulated, in moving through the mass of impedimenta which is the world. a This is culture; in mastering them, to burst through the — EDGAR ALLAN POE 225 peculiarities of an environment. It is nor culture to oppress a novel environment with the stale, if symmetrical, castoffs of another battle. They are nearly right when they say: Destroy the museums! But that is only the reflection, after all, of minds that fear to be slavish. Poe could look at France, Spain, Greece, and nor be impelled to copy. He could do this sr- cause he had the sense within him of a locality of his own, capable of cultivation. Poe’s use of the tags of other cultures than his own man- ages to be novel, interesting, useful, wnaffected, since it suc- ceeds in giving the impression of being not in the least dragged in by rule or pretence but of a fresh purpose such as I have indicated. There is nothing offensively “learned” there, noth- ing contemptuous, even in the witty tricks with bogus Latin which he plays on his illiterate public, which by its power, in turn, permits him an originality, allows him, even when he is satiric, an authenticity since he is not seeking to destroy but to assert, candidly, and to defend his own. He was the first to realize that the hard, sardonic, trucu- lent mass of the New World, hot, angry—was, in fact, not a thing to paint over, to smear, to destroy—for it wouLp not be destroyed, it was too powerful,—it smiled! That it is nor a thing to be slighted by men.’ Difficult, its very difficulty was their strength. It was in the generous bulk of its animal _erudity that their every fineness would be found safely im- bedded. Poe conceived the possibility, the sullen, volcanic inevita- bility of the place. He was willing to go down and wrestle with its conditions, using every tool France, England, Greece could give him,—but to use them to original purpose. This is his anger against Longfellow. The difficulty is in holding the mind down to the point of seeing the beginning difference between Poe and the rest. One cannot expect to see as wide a gap between him and the others as exists between the Greek and the Chinese. It is only in the conception of a possibility that he is most dis- 226 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN tinguished. His greatness is in that he turned his back and faced inland, to originality, with the identical gesture of a Boone. And for that reason he is unrecognized. Americans have never recognized themselves. How can they? It is impos- sible until someone invent the oricrnat terms. As long as we are content to be called by somebody’s else terms, we are incapable of being anything but our own dupes. Thus Poe must suffer by his originality. Invent that which is new, even if it be made of pine from your own yard, and there’s none to know what you have done. It is because there’s no name. This is the cause of Poe’s lack of recogni- tion. He was American. He was the astounding, inconceiy- able growth of his locality. Gape at him they did, and he at them in amazement. Afterward with mutual hatred; he in ~ disgust, they in mistrust. It is only that which is under your nose which seems inexplicable. _ Here Poe emerges—in no sense the bizarre, isolate writer, the curious literary figure. On the contrary, in him Ameri- can literature is anchored, in him alone, on solid ground. J In all he says there is a sense of him surrounded by his time, tearing at it, ever with more rancor, but always at battle, taking hold. | But Poe—differing from pioneers in other literatures, the — great beginners—due to the nature of the people, had first 7 to lift his head through a successful banality. ‘This was a double impost. But he did it, wor by despising, ignoring, slighting the work that preceded him but by attacking it. “Among all the pioneers of American literature, whether prose or poetical, there is not one (Note: In his own estimate even, | he begins.) whose productions have not been much overrated by his countrymen.” ; “But originality, as it is one of the highest, is ee one of the rarest of merits. In America it is especially, and very | remarkably, rare—this through causes sufficiently well un-— derstood.” 7 . EDGAR ALLAN POE Q27 He abhorred the “excessively opportune.”—Of course, he says, to write of the Indians, the forests, the great natural beauty of the New World will be attractive and make a hit— so he counsels writers to avor it, for reasons crystal clear and well chosen. (See Fenimore Cooper.) His whole in- sistence has been upon method, in opposition to a nameless rapture over nature. He admired Claude Lorraine. Instead of to hog-fill the copied style with a gross rural sap, he wanted a lean style, rapid as a hunter and with an aim as sure. One way, in the New World, men must go. Bust gut or acute wit. Find the ground, on your feet or on your belly. It is a fight. He counsels writers to borrow nothing from the scene, but to put all the weight of effort into the writinc. Put aside the GRAND scene and get to work to express yourself. Method, punctuation, grammar— The local condition of literature rorcED Poe’s hand. It is necessary to understand this if his names are to be grasped. By avoiding, of necessity, the fat country itself for its ex- pression; to originate a style that does spring from the local conditions, not of trees and mountains, but of the “soul”— here starved, stricken by loss of liberty, ready to die—he is forced in certain directions for his subjects. But this left him in difficulties. When he had narrowed himself down to a choice of method and subject, when all the meaningless lump of the lush landscape and all that that m- plies had been swept away, THEN, and only then will he begin to search for a subject. A voluntary lopping off of a NATURAL landscape, forced him into a field which he must have searched for, a field of cold logic, of invention, to which his work must still present a natural appearance: into his imaginative prose. His criticism paves the way for what must be his prose— illustrating his favorite theory that the theory includes the practice. No better means of transit from the criticism to the tales could be imagined than his discussion of the merits and de- 228 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN merits of Hawthorne as a proseist. He expresses his delight and surprise at finding Hawthorne’s work of such excellence, but then he finds a fault: | “He has the purest style, the finest taste, the most available scholarship, the most delicate humor, the most touching pathos, the most radiant imagination, the most consummate ingenuity, and with these varied good qualities he has done well as a mystic. But is there any one of these qualities which would prevent his doing doubly as well in a career of honest, up- right, sensible, prehensible, and. comprehensible things? Let him mend his pen, get a bottle of visible ink, come out from the Old Manse, cut Mr. Alcott, hang (if possible) the Editor of The Dial, and throw out of the window to the pigs all his — odd numbers of The North American Review.” Hawthorne has no repugnance for handling what Poe pur- — posely avoids, the contamination of the UNFORMED LUMP, the “monstrum, horrendum, informe, ingens, cui lumen ademp- tum.” And it is precisely here that lies Hawthorne’s lack of — importance to our literature when he is compared with Poe; what Hawthorne loses by his willing closeness to the life of his locality in its vague humors; his lifelike copying of ‘the New England melancholy ; his reposeful closeness to the town — pump—Poe gains by abhorring; flying to the ends of the earth for “original” material— By such a simple, logical twist does Poe succeed in being . the more American, heeding more the local necessities, the harder structural imperatives—by standing off to srr instead — of forcing himself too close. Whereas Hawthorne, in his tales, by doing what everyone else in France, England, Germany was doing for his own milieu, is no more than copying their method with another setting; does not ortcrnaTE; has not a beginning literature at heart that must establish its own rules, — own framework,—Poe has realized by adopting a more clea mien. This feeling in Poe’s tales, that is, the hidden, under, un-— apparent part, gives him the firmness of rnsicHT into the con- — EDGAR ALLAN POE 229 ditions upon which our literature must rest, always the same, a local one, surely, but not of sentiment or mood, as not of trees and Indians, but of original fibre, the normal toughness which fragility of mood presupposes, if it will be expressive of anything— It is the expression of Poe’s clearness of insight into the true difficulty, and his soundness of judgment. % * * * # % * To understand what Poe is driving at in his tales, one should read first nor the popular, perfect—Gold Bug, Mur- ders in the Rue Morgue, etc., which by their brilliancy de- tract from the observation of his deeper intent, but the less striking tales—in fact all, but especially those where his humor is less certain, his mood lighter, less tightly bound by the incident, where numerous illuminating faults are allowed to become expressive, The Business Man, The Man That Was Used Up, Loss of Breath, BonBon, Diddling, The Angel of the Odd—and others of his lesser Tales. It should be noted how often certain things take place— how often there is death but not that only; it is the Pay broken apart, dismembered, as in Loss of Breath— Then, as in Hop Frog, The System of Dr. Tarr and Pro- fessor Fether and the Murders in the Rue Morgue—the re- current image of the ape. Is it his disgust with his immed- iate associates and his own fears, which cause this frequent use of the figure to create the emotion of extreme terror?— “Your majesty cannot conceive of the effect produced, at a masquerade, by eight chained orang-outangs, imagined to be real ones by the most of the company; and rushing in with savage cries, among the crowd of delicately and gorgeously habited men and women. The contrast is inimitable.” Note, in Silence—a Fable: “sorrow and weariness and dis- gust with mankind and a longing for solitude.” Many colloquial words could be detached from Poe’s usage if it were worth while, to show how the language he practices varies from English, but such an exercise would be of little value—hipped, crack, etc.—it does not touch bottom. 230 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN The Tales continue the theories of the criticism, carrying out what they propose: 1. In choice of material, abstract. 2. In method, a logi- cal construction that clips away, in great part, the “scenery” near at hand in order to let the real business of composition show. 3. A primitive awkwardness of diction, lack of polish, colloquialism that is, unexpectedly, especially in the dialogues, much in the vein of Mark Twain. One feels that inthe actual composition of his tales there must have been for him, as they embody it in fact, a fascina- tion other than the topical one. The impulse that made him write them, that made him enjoy writing them—cannot have been the puerile one of amazement, but a deeper, logical en- joyment, in keeping with his own seriousness: it is that of PROVING even the most preposterous of his inventions plausible —that py His METHOD he makes them worx. They go: they prove him potent, they confirm his thought. And by the very extreme of their play, by so much the more do they hold up the actuality of that which he conceives. If there ever had been another American to use his Greek, Sanscrit, Hebrew, Latin, French, German, Italian and Span- ish—in the text—with anything like the unspoiled mastery of Poe, we should have known, long since, what it meant to have a literature of our own. It is to have a basis, a local stanchion, by which to bridge over the gap between present learning and the classical; that asserts the continuity of the common virtues of style; that asserts their aristocratic origin, or their democratic origin, the same, as it has been pointed out recently, since an aristocracy is the flower of a locality and so the full expression of a democracy. Of his method in the Tales, the significance and the secret ' is: authentic particles, a thousand of which spring to the mind for quotation, taken apart and reknit with a view to em- phasize, enforce and make evident, the method. 'Their qual- ity of skill in observation, their heat, local verity, being over- EDGAR ALLAN POE 231 shadowed only by the detached, the abstract, the cold phil- osophy of their joining together ; a method springing so freshly from the local conditions which determine it, by their em- phasis of firm crudity and lack of coordinated structure, as to be worthy of most painstaking study— The whole pe- riod, America 1840, could be rebuilt, psychologically (phreno- logically) from Poe’s “method.” * * * * * * = 2 * It is especially in the poetry where “death looked gigan- tically down” that the horror of the formless resistance which opposed, maddened, destroyed him has forced its character into the air, the wind, the blessed galleries of paradise, above a morose, dead world, peopled by shadows and silence, and despair— It is the compelling force of his isolation. The one earthly island he found where he might live in something akin to the state he imagined, the love of his wife, had to be single and inviolate. Failing of a more compre- hensive passion, which might have possessed him had the place been of favorable omen, only in this narrow cell could he exist at all. Of this the poems are the full effect. He is known as a poet, yet there are but five poems, possibly three. When she died, there was nothing left. In his despair he had nowhere to turn. It is the very apotheosis of the place and the time. He died imploring from those about him a love he could ‘not possess, since his own love, as his poems, had been SO mingled in character with the iron revenge which completely surrounded him that it could not be repeated once its single object had been lost. But here, in his poetry least of all, is there a mystery. It is but the accumulation of all that he has expressed, in the criticism, in the prose tales, but made as if so shaken with desire, that it has come off as a flame, destroying the very vial that contained it—and become, against his will almost it would seem,—himself. 232 IN THE AMERICAN GRAIN It is not by a change in character but by its quickened motion that it has turned from mere heat into light—by its power of penetration that it has been brought to dwell upon love. By its acid power to break down truth that it has been forced upon love— | I mean that though in this his “method” has escaped him, yet his poems remain of the single stuff of his great “theory”: to grasp the meaning, to understand, to reduce all things to method, to control, lifting himself to power— And failing, truth turning to love, as if metamorphosed in his hands as he was about to grasp it—now the full horror of his isolation comes down— In his prose he could still keep a firm hold, he still held the “arrangement” fast and stood above it, but in the poetry he was at the edge—there was nothing Here in poetry, where it is said “we approach the gods,” Poe was caught, instead, in his time. Now, defenseless, the place itself attacked him. Now the thinness of his coat, the terror of his isolation took hold. Had he lived in a world where love throve, his poems might — have grown differently. But living where he did, surrounded as he was by that world of unreality, a formless “population” —drifting and feeding—a huge terror possessed him. His passion for the refrain is like an echo from a hollow. It is his own voice returning— His imagery is of the desperate situation of his mind, thin as a flame to mount unsupported, successful for a moment in the love of—not so much his wife—but in the escape she filled for him with her frail person, herself afflicted as by “ghouls.” Disarmed, in his poetry the place itself comes through. This is the New World. It is this that it does, as if It is in this wraithlike quality of his poems, of his five poems, that Poe is most of the very ground, hard to find, as if we walked upon a cushion of light pressed thin beneath our feet, that insulates, satirises—while we lash ourselves up and down in a fury of impotence. oe ele 2 ek See > \ i a ele oe - en i: “wets be or fl 7 A AA TS ee eR ee hee, A 4 eee r > i . P ery, Ae ‘ [3 ee ss ! fe oe eee ey = Dh eine ’ ae Aen 1 Te) eee HDGAR ALLAN POR 233 e tay : zainst the thin edge, driven to be heard by > bat ring racket about him to a distant screaming—the oe essence of his locality. aes “f The best poem is T'o One in Paradise. ae f - ABRAHAM LINCOLN HE Great Railsplitter’s, “All I am or ever hope to be I owe to my angel mother”; the walking up and down in Springfield on the narrow walk between the two houses, day after day, with a neighbor’s baby, borrowed for the occa- sion, sleeping inside his cape upon his shoulder to give him stability while thinking and composing his coming speeches; and apart from its cowardice, the blinding stupidity of his murderer’s sic semper tyrannis, after he had shot him in the back—in this trinity is reflected the brutalizing desolation of life in America up to that time; yet perversely flowering. Mengelberg, a great broad hipped one, conducts an or- chestra in the same vein. It is a woman. He babies them. He leans over and floods them with his insistences. It is a woman drawing to herself with insatiable passion the myriad points of sound, conferring upon each the dignity of a suc- cessful approach, relieving each of his swelling burden (but particularly, by himself), in the overtowering symphony— It is the balm of command. The violins, surrounded, yet feel _ that they have come alone, in silence and in secret, singly to be heard. It is Lincoln pardoning the fellow who slept on sentry duty. It is the grace of the Bixby letter. The least private would find a woman to caress him, a woman in an old shawl— with a great bearded face and a towering black hat above it, to give unearthly reality. Brancusi should make his statue—of wood—after the man- ner of his Socrates, with the big hole in the enormous mass of the head, save that this would be a woman— The age-old torture reached a disastrous climax in Lin- 234 ABRAHAM LINCOLN 235 coln. Failing of relief or expression, the place tormented it- self into a convulsion of bewilderment and pain—with a woman, born somehow, aching over it, holding all fearfully together. It was the end of THar period. ao =| ms * F Pes ay, 4 Soh oot se he ‘Mates. ‘ '. r S po anes ei k & a ott | ae eC a * § AAS way ee Hite ae .