ROLL NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Microfiln Publication M887 .RECORDS OF THE UNITED STATES NUERNBERG WAR CRIMES TRIALS UNITED STATES OP AMERICA V. KARL BRANDT ET AL. (CASE I) NOVEMBER 21, 1946-AUGUST 20, 1947 Roll 9 Transcript Volumes (English Version) Volumes 22-24 May 22-June 14, 1947 THE NATIONAL ARCHIVES NATIONAL ARCHIVES AND RECORDS SERVICE GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION WASHINGTON: 1974 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS records of the other Nuernberg and Far East (INTTFE) war crimes trials, are part of the National Archives Collection of World War II War Crimes Records, Record Group 238. The Brandt case was 1 of 12 separate proceedings held before several U.S. Military Tribunals at Nuernberg in the U.S. Zone of Occupation in Germany against officials or citizens of the Third Reich, as follows: Case No. United States v. Popular Name No, of Defendants 1 Karl Brandt et al-. 2 Erhard Milch 3 Josef Altstoetter et al. 4 Oswald Pohl et al. 5 Friedrich Flick et al. 6 Carl Krauch et al. 7 Wilhelm List et al 8 Ulrich Greifelt et al. 9 Otto Ohlendorf et al. 10 Alfried Krupp et al. 11 Ernst von Weizsaccker et al. 12 Wilhelm von Leeb et al. Medical Case 23 Milch Case 1 (Luftwaffe) Justice Case 16 Pohl Case (SS) 18 Flick Case 6 (Industrialist) I. G. Farben Case 24 (Industrialist) Hostage Case 12 RuSHA Case (SS) 14 Einsatzgruppen 24 Case (SS) Krupp Case 12 (Industrialist) Ministries Case 21 High Command Case 14 Authority for the proceedings of the International Military Tribunal against the major Nazi war criminals derived from the Declaration on German Atrocities (Moscow Declaration) released November 1, 1943, Executive Order 9547 of May 2, 1945, the London Agreement of August 8, 1945, the Berlin Protocol of October 6, 1945, and the Charter of the International Military Tribunal. Authority for the 12 subsequent cases stemmed mainly from Control Council Law 10 of December 20, 1945, and was reinforced by Executive Order 9679 of January 16, 1946; U.S. Military Govern¬ ment Ordinances Nos. 7 and 11 of October 18, 1946, and February 17, 1947, respectively; and U.S. Forces, European Theater General Order 301 of October 24, 1946. The procedures applied by U.S. Military Tribunals in the subsequent proceedings were patterned after those of the International Military Tribunal and further developed in the 12 cases, which required over 1,200 days of court sessions and generated more than 330,000 transcript pages. 2 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS The crimes charged in the Brandt case consisted largely of medical experiments performed on defenseless concentration camp inmates against their will; "euthanasia" carried out on the mentally defective, the physically sick, the aged, and ethnic and racial groups; and the murder of concentration camp inmates for the express purpose of collecting skulls and skeletons for the Anatomical Institute of the Reich University of Strassburg. The following medical experiments were conducted: 1. High altitude: to investigate effects of low pressure on persons. 2. Freezing: to test human resistance to extemely low temperatures. 3. Malaria: to develop controls over the recurring nature of the disease. 4. Mustard gas: part of a general research program in gas warfare. 5. Sulfanilamide: to test the efficacy of the drug in bone muscle and nerve regeneration and bone transplantation. 6. Seawater: to test methods of rendering seawater potable. 7. Epidemic jaundice: to develop an antitoxin against the disease. 8. Sterilization: to test techniques for preventing further propagation of the mentally and physically defective. 9. Typhus: to investigate the value of various vaccines. 10. Poison: to test the efficacy of certain poisons. 11. Incendiary bomb: to find better treatment for phosphorus bums. The prosecution alleged and the judgment confirmed that these experiments were not isolated acts of individual doctors and scientists on their own responsibility but that they were the result of high-level policy and planning. They were carried out with particular brutality, often disregarding all established medical practice. Consequently, large numbers of the victims died in the course of or as a result of the experiments. The euthanasia program was the direct result of a directive by Hitler of September 1, 1939. It resulted in the secret killing not only of aged, insane, incurably ill, and deformed German citizens in sanatoriums in Germany but also in the clandestine murder of foreign workers. The killing in gas chambers and by injections in the sanatoriums served as a proving ground for these forerunners of much larger installations in the mass extermination camps. In addition to these experiments, over 100 concentration camp inmates were killed for the purpose of obtaining their skeletons. Their ghastly remains were found in Strassburg by Allied troops. 3 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS The transcripts of the Brandt case include the indictments of the following 23 persons all of whoa were physicians except defendants Rudolf Brandt, Viktor Brack, and Wolfram Sievers: Karl Brandt: Personal physician to Adolf Hitler, Gruppen- fuehrer in the SS and Generalleutnant (Major General) in the Waffen SS, Reichskoomissar fuer Sanitaets- und Gesund- heitswesen (Reich Commissioner for Health and Sanitation), and member of the Reichsforschungsrat (Reich Research Council). Kurt Blooe: Deputy [of the) Reichsgesundheitsfuehrer (Reich Health Leader) and Plenipotentiary for Cancer Research in the Reich Research Council. Rudolf Brandt: Standartenfuehrer (Colonel) in the Allgemeine SS, Persoenlicher Referent von Himmler (Personal Admin¬ istrative Officer to Reichsfuehrer SS Himmler), and Min¬ isterial Counselor and Chief of the Ministerial Office in the Reich Ministry of the Interior. Joachim Mrugowsky: Oberfuehrer (Senior Colonel) in the Waffen SS, Oberster Hygieniker, Reichsarzt SS und Polizei (Chief Hygienist of the Reich Physician SS and Police), and Chef des Hygienischen Institutes der Waffen SS (Chief of the Hygienic Institute of the Waffen SS). Helmut Poppendick: Oberfuehrer in the SS and Chef des Persoenlichen Stabes des Reichsarztes SS und Polizei (Chief of the Personal Staff of the Reich Physician SS and Police). Wolfram Sievers: Standartenfuehrer in the SS, Reich Manager of the "Ahnenerbe" Society and Director of its Institut fuer Wehrwissenschaftliche Zweckforschung (Institute for Military Scientific Research), and Deputy Chairman of the Managing Board of Directors of the Reich Research Council. Karl Genzken: Gruppenfuehrer in the SS and Generalleutnant in the Waffen SS and Chef des Sanitaetsamts dcr Waffen SS (Chief of the Medical Department of the Waffen SS). Karl Gebhardt: Gruppenfuehrer in the SS and Generalleutnant in the Waffen SS, personal physician to Reichsfuehrer SS Himmler, Oberster Kliniker, Reichsarzt SS und Polizei (Chief Surgeon of the Staff of the Reich Physician SS and Police), and President of the German Red Cross. Viktor Brack: Oberfuehrer in the SS and Sturmbannfuehrer (Major) in the Waffen SS and Oberdienstleiter, Kanzlei des Fuehrers der NSDAP (Chief Administrative Officer in the Chancellery of the Fuehrer to the NSDAP). NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Waldeaar Hoven: Hauptsturafuehrer (Captain) in the Waffen SS and Chief Physician of the Buchenwald Concentration Camp. Herta Oberheuser: Physician at the Ravensbrueck Concentration Camp and assistant physician to the defendant Gebhardt at the hospital at Hohenlychen. Fritz Fischer: Sturmbannfuehrer in the Waffen SS and assist¬ ant physician to the defendant Gebhardt at the hospital at Hohenlychen. Siegfried Handloser: Generaloberstabsarzt (Lieutenant General, Medical Service), Heeressanitaetsinspekteur (Medical Inspector of the Army), and Chef des Wehr- machtsanitaetswesens (Chief of the Medical Services of the Armed Forces). Paul Rostock: Chief Surgeon of the Surgical Clinic in Berlin, Surgical Adviser to the Army, and Amtschef der Dienststelle Medizinische Wissenschaft und Forschung (Chief of the Office for Medical Science and Research) under the defendant Karl Brandt, Reich Commissioner for Health and Sanitation. Oskar Schroeder: Generaloberstabsarzt; Chef des Stabes, Inspekteur des Luftwaffe-Sanitaetswesens (Chief of Staff of the Inspectorate of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe); and Chef des Sanitaetswescns der Luftwaffe (Chief of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe). Hermann Becker-Freyseng: Stabsarzt in the Luftwaffe (Captain, Medical Service of the Air Force) and Chief of the Department for Aviation Medicine of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe. Georg August Weltz: Oberfeldarzt in the Luftwaffe (Lieu¬ tenant Colonel, Medical Service of the Air Force) and Chief of the Institut fuer Luftfahrtmedizin (Institute for Aviation Medicine) in Munich. Wilhelm Beiglboeck: Consulting physician to tho Luftwaffe. Gerhard Rose: Gcneralarzt of the Luftwaffe (Brigadier General, Medical Service of the Air Force); Vice President, Chief of the Department for Tropical Medicine, and Professor of the Robert Koch Institute; and Hygienic Adviser for Tropical Medicine to the Chief of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe. Siegfried Ruff: Director of the Department for Aviation Medicine at the Deutsche Versuchsanstalt fuer Luftfahrt (German Experimental Institute for Aviation). 5 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Hans Wolfgang Romberg: Physician on the staff of the Depart¬ ment for Aviation Medicine at the German Experimental Institute for Aviation. Konrad Schaefer: Physician on the staff of the Institute for Aviation Medicine in Berlin. Adolf Pokomy: Physician, specialist in skin and venereal diseases. The indictment consisted of four counts. Count one charged participation in a common design or conspiracy to commit war crimes or crimes against humanity. The ruling of the tribunal disregarded this count, hence no defendant was found guilty of the crime charged in count one. Count two was concerned with war crimes and count three, with crimes against humanity. Fifteen defendants were found guilty, and eight were acquitted on these two counts. Ten defendants were charged under count four with membership in a criminal organiza¬ tion and were found guilty. The transcripts also contain the arraignment and plea of each defendant (all pleaded not guilty), opening and closing statements of defense and prosecution, and the judgment and sentences, which acquitted 7 of the 23 defendants (Blome, Pokorny, Romberg, Rostock, Ruff, Schaefer, and Weltz). Death sentences were imposed on defendants Brack, Karl Brandt, Rudolf Brandt, Hoven, Gebhardt, Mrugowsky, and Sievers, and life imprisonment on Fischer, Genzken, Hand loser, Rose, and Schroeder; varying terms of years were given to defendants Becker-Freyscng, Bciglboeck, Oberheuscr, and Poppendick. The English-language transcript volumes are arranged numer¬ ically, 1-30; pagination is continuous, 1-11538. The German- language transcript volumes are numbered la-30a and paginated 1-11756. The letters at the top of each page indicate morning, afternoon, and evening sessions. The letter "C" designates com¬ mission hearings (to save court time and to avoid assembling hundreds of witnesses at Nuernberg, in most of the cases one or more commissions took testimony and received documentary evidence for consideration by the tribunals). Several hundred pages are added to the transcript volumes and given number plus letter designations, such as page number 1044a. Page 1 in volume 1 (English) is preceded by pages numbered 001-039, while the last page of volume 28 (English) is followed by pages numbered 1-48. Of the many documents assembled for possible prosecution use, 570 were chosen for presentation as evidence before the tribunal. These consisted largely of orders, directives, and reports on medical experiments or the euthanasia program; several interrogation reports; affidavits; and excerpts from the Reichegesetzblatt (the official gazette of Reich laws) as well as correspondence. A number 6 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS of the medical reports were accompanied by series of photographs and charts of various experiments. The first item in the arrangement of the prosecution exhibits is usually a certificate listing the document number, a short description of the exhibit, and a statement on the location of the original document of the exhibit. The certificate is followed by the document, the actual prosecution exhibit (most of which are photostats), and a few mimeographed articles with an occasional carbon of the original. In rare cases the exhibits are followed by translations or additional certificates. A few exhibits are original documents, such asj Exhibit No. Doc. No. Exhibit No. Doc. No 301 NO-1314 410 NO-158 307 NO-120 441 NO-1730 309 NO-131 443 NO-890 310 NO-132 451 NO-732 357 1696 PS 462 NO-1424 362 628 PS 507 NO-365 368 NO-817 546 NO-3347 403 616 PS No certificate is attached to several exhibits, including exhibits 433, 435-439, 462, 559, and 561. Following exhibit 570 is a tribunal exhibit containing the interrogation of three citizens of the Netherlands. Number 494 was not assigned, and exhibit 519 is followed by 519a and 519b. Other than affidavits, the defense exhibits consist of newspaper clippings, reports, personnel records, Feiahsgeaetzblatt excerpts, and other items. There are 901 exhibits for the defendants. The defense exhibits arc arranged by name of defendant and thereunder by exhibit number, each followed by a certificate wherever available. The translations in the prosecution document books are preceded by indexes listing prosecution document numbers, biased descriptions, and page numbers of the translation. They arc generally listed in the order in which the prosecution exhibits were introduced into evidence before the tribunal. Pages 81-84 of prosecution document book 1 are missing. Books 12, 16, and 19 arc followed by addenda. The document books consist largely of mimeographed pages. The defense document books are similarly arranged. Each book is preceded by an index giving document numbers, description, and page number for each exhibit. The corresponding exhibit numbers are generally not provided. There are several unindexed supplements to numbered document books. Prosecution and defense briefs are arranged alphabetically by names of defendants; final pleas and defense answers to prosecution briefs follow a similar NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS scheme. Pagination is consecutive, yet there are many pages where an "a" or "b" is added to the numeral. The English-language final pleas, closing briefs, and replies to prosecution briefs of several defendants are missing, as are a few German-language closing briefs and replies to prosecution briefs. . At the beginning of roll 1 are filmed key documents from which Tribunal I derived its jurisdiction: the Moscow Declaration, U.S. Executive Orders 9547 and 9679, the London Agreement, the Berlin Protocol, the Charter of the International Military Tri¬ bunal, Control Council Law 10, U.S. Military Government Ordinances 7 and 11, and U.S. Forces, European Theater General Order 301. Following these documents of authorization is a list of the names and functions of the members of Tribunal I and counsels. These documents are followed by the transcript covers giving such information as name and number of case, volume numbers, language, page numbers, and inclusive dates. They are followed by summaries of the daily proceedings providing an additional finding aid for the transcripts. The exhibits arc listed in an index, which notes type of exhibit, exhibit number and name, corresponding document number and document book and page, a short description of the exhibit, arid the date when it was offered in court. The official court file is indexed in the court docket, which is followed by a list of witnesses. Not filmed were rocords duplicated elsewhere in this micro¬ film publication, such as prosecution and defense document books in the German language that are largely duplications of pros¬ ecution and defense exhibits already microfilmed or opening statements of prosecution and defense, which can be found in the transcripts of the proceedings. The records of the Brandt case are closely related to other microfilmed records in Record Group 238, specifically prosecution exhibits submitted to the International Military Tribunal, T988; NI (Nuernberg Industrialist) Series, T301; NOKW (Nuernberg Armed Forces High Command) Series, T1119; NG (Nuernberg Government) Series, T1139; and records of the Milch case, M888, the List case, M893, the Greifelt case, M894, and the Ohlendorf case, M895. In addition, the record of the International Military Tribunal at Nuernberg has been published in Trial of the Major War Criminate Before the International Military Tribunal (Nuernberg, 1947), 42 vols. Excerpts from the subsequent proceedings have been pub¬ lished as Triale of War Criminate Before the Nuernberg Military Tribunal Under Control Council Law No. 10 (U.S. Government Printing Office: 1950-53), 15 vols. The Audiovisual Archives Division of the National Archives and Records Service holds motion picture records and photographs of all 13 trials and tape re¬ cordings of the International Military Tribunal proceedings. 8 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS John Mendelsohn wrote these introductory remarks and arranged the records for microfilming in collaboration with George Chalou. NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Roll 9 Target 1 Volume 22 May 22-June 2, 1947 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS OFFICIAL RECORD UNITED STATES MILITARY TRIBUNALS NURNBERG CASE No. 1 TRIBUNAL I U.S. vs KARL BRANDT et al VOLUME 22 TRANSCRIPTS (English) 22 May-2 June 1947 pp. 7955-8399 22 May 47--TD-l-l-Fost«r (Int. Eaalor) Court No. 1 Official Transcript of the American Military Tribunal I in the natter of the United States of America against Karl Brandt, et al, dofondants, sitting at Nurnborg, Germany on 22 May 1947, 0930, Justice Beals presiding. THE MARSHAL: Persons in the court roce will please find their scats. The Honorable, the Judges of Military Tribunal I. Military Tribunal I is now in session. God save the Unitod States of Anerica end this Honorable Tribunal. There will be order in the court rooa. THE PRESIDENT: Hr. Marshal, will ycu ascertain that the dofendants are all prosent in court? THE MARSHALt May it please your Honor, all the defendants arc prosont in the court. THE PRESIDENT: The Socrotary-Gonorrl will note for tho record tho presenco of all tho defendants in court. Counsel nay proccod. «. HARDY: U«y it please tho Tribunal, it has boon called to ay attention by dbfenao counsel that next Sunday and Monday aro Gorman holidays, ncaely, ‘.hitsuntido. Tho dofonso counsel dosiroo to hevo tho court adjourn on Ibbd&y that they may observe this holiday. THE PRESIDENT: That, I undorstrjvi, is this cooing Manic.;'? UP.. HARDY: That is tho 26th. THE PRESIDENT: Tho Tribunal would be indinod to head tho re-quest of defense counsel if they dosiro that \ hit sun Mandey bo observed ns a holiday. Tho Tribunal will cooperate with then and hold no sosoion next tonday. / .Do ycu^f/. what the other Tribunals have done in connection with /this nnttor? • «) f “0 , ‘rj \ UR. HARDY: I Uhderstand that Tribunal No. 2 downstairs will hove r» session on^Jfcnd^y as to the decision cf the other Tribunals, I love the - whorein Defendant click is being tried i3 having no session on Monday. 7955 22 May i7-M-ATD-i-2-Foster (Int. Easier) Court Me. 1 THE PRESIDENT: Tribunal will recess tomorrow evening until Tuesday arming in compliance with the request prof erred by defense counsel. Counsel nay proceed. HBUANK 3SCKEH-FREYS2iG - Resumed DIRECT EXAMINATION (Continued) DR. TIFF (Counsel fer the Defendant Bccker-Freyscng): »ir. President, some technical remarks first. i$r colleague. Dr. ilarx, has rotumed today and hc3 recovered sufficiently in ordor to again take over the caso of his client. Dr. 3cckor-Frcyseng. For technical reasons we hrvo decided that I finish the question of typhus end yellow fovtr, and I think that after the morning recess Dr. larx will ccao in and take over the sea¬ water ease. THE j RESIDENT: Any arrangsaent satisfactory to the Defondant Bockor-Prcyscng and his counsel will bo approved by the Tribunal. Dr. Marx may resumo his activo position as defense counsel when it is agrooablo to him and to you. DR. TIFF: Thank ycu, your Honor. BY DR. TIPP: Q Doctor Bockc- when wo condudod yost-rdry wo had arrived at the question of the Chi f o.' the Medical Department of the Rc3oarch Institute who the Prosecution assorts was. I think you have clarlfijd this point sufficiently end shall now pass over to another point upon which wo havo already touched on re on. time. I want to talk about tho natorial which you fourrf in >aur Re \r .t regarding Haagen's work. If I roacabor correctly, you said th t ycu only r-x-aber interim reports from Haegen. In that connection, however, I have to put to you a document from tho Prosecution free which I think they concluded that ycu also had knowlcdgo of Haagen's flnel report. Thi3 is Prosecution document from 3ook 12, on pago S8 in the English copy. It was submitted under Document -.’umber .‘X) 123, rnd bears tho date 9 ’lay, and the Exhibit Nusber >03. It is a letter writton by Dr. Haagon to the Hauptamt SS through Professor Dr. Hirt, Anatomied Institute of the Reich University Strasbourg. The letter 3trrts, and I quote: 7956 22 May i.7-tt“r.I3-l->-Fc at or (Int. Healer) Court lie. 1 "I enclose herewith a carbon copy of a paper on our exp eric wit 9 with a dry typhus vaccine. The paper was s.nt as e manuscript to the Chief of the Luftwaffe Medical Service with the request for permission to publish it." Obviously it is a final report of Heegen's in the form of a scientific publication, which was subsequently submitted to the Chief of the IfcdicH Service of the Luftwaffo. Sinco we aro hero concerned with a research natter, I assume that the Prosecution will chnrgo you with having had knowledge of this report. Did you know of this report or do you remember it? A I do not renenber this final report of Hnagen. However, let mo point to c number of matters in thrt connection. It boconcs cloar in this document presented by the Prosocution whrt 1 have already said about the reports nado by tho rosocrchers who have received resorrch assignments by tho Chief of tho Luftw'^fo Medical Service. X said that the researchers mostly submitted their final reports in tho form of manuscripts or in the foro of reprints. Kaogen says here specifically tho papor naa sent, tho manuscript, for permission to publish it. Professor Hargen was a researcher and c-rteinly wasn't as well familiar with the bureaucratre .ulntions as I, sinco I set at a dook for almost fivo years in a buroaucratic agency. Just as there was no Jauptrmt SS, 3Uch a» is mentionod in this document, the work of nodical officors of the Luftwaffo did not have to be submitted to tho chief for approval,, ' rat at rate was not tru^ in the year of 1944. The agency which 'tried cat. and which hod to carry out ttu censorship of scientific w.ri: 'fore its publication was the Lecture Unit for Science- and . s arch at the I Iodic rl Academy of tho Luftwaffe. This agency, to be sure, 3cnt the purely aviation medical papers to ttio Reforat Aviation Medicine for its information. AH other papers, however, were not s^nt to the Ref era t Aviation Medicine but was handled by tho Locturo Unit for Science and Rcsoarch Hone. 7957 22 Kay-144E-2-1-Narrow (Int. Rssler) Court No# I. Perhaps it ra s sometimes sent to the consulting specialists for their attitude on that work. I say point to what ft*ofessor Rose testified in this witness stand. He said that he had read that paper and that ho assumed a position on it. Furthc-rnore, lot me point to the docu¬ ment of the prosecution, NO-128, Exhibit 307, page 97 of the German ard pa<_e 95 of the English Document Book 12. This is a letter by the Medical Acadoay of the Luftwaffe, which I just mentioned. Lecture Unit for Science and Research, and constitutes the reply to Haagen*s request in order to permit the publication of his paper as it is nontionod in the document before us. Sinco file references seon to play such a considerable part here, I ray also draw your attention to that# This is file rcforenco #5, which concerns all published literature. At no time was the file roferenco •£> handlod by tho Roferat Aviation iedicino# In addition, it becomes ovident from this lottor that tho -.York had boon sent back to Dr. Haagen. Q .itnear., you ore now speaking about tho last document which you just cited? A Yos, I aa speaking about Docunont NO-128, Exhibit 307. It says horo "Annox - one manuscript, two copies". That Haagen sont more than two copies of this manuscript is highly improbable. It is thus very improbable that the Locturo Unit for Science and Research had nont a copy of this manuscript to tho rcsoarch files, for instance; but oven assuming that this rather impossible situation was true, I may add that if Professor Luxemburger, who was tho director of this Lecture Unit, when censoring that work, had not had tho suspicion that it dealt with something inadmissible, I am euro that no such suspicion would have arisen within me. Apart from that, I cortainly would have hardly road any such specialized bacteriological paper frea the beginning to tho end since neither I nor anyone else in the world would have do rived any benefit from that. Q Witness, you were just speaking of the Document KO-129, this letter by the Medical Academy of the Luftwaffe, dated tho 7th of July, 7958 22 Kay-K-Ix- 2 - 2 —Xarrow (Int. Rader) Court Ko. I. ani you acntionod the nane of Dr. luxeaburger. There is no such signa¬ ture in the German docuoent book and since I have not received the photostat copy I don't know whether any such signature is apparent in _ tta English document book. I assume, horevor, that the original docu¬ ment does bear that signature. If then the Tribunal nay have any doubts as to whether this docuaent was actually signed by Dr. Luxen- burgor, I would ask the General Secrotary to sufccit tto photostat copy of the original to the Tribunal. Unfortunately, I was not in a posi¬ tion to obtain the photostat copy in the Information Contor. It had been given out sonowhere and I couldn't ascertain to whom. THE FRZSlDEJiT: If Counsol trill inform tho Secretary General - the Clerk is absont at prosont - that the Tribunal doslres that this docunant, tho original photostat he produced before tho Tribunal, tho Tribunal will bo obliged. BY DR. TIFPi Q Yes, Hr. President. In this connection, Mr. President, lot no offer as tho noxt docuswnt tho Bockor-Frvysong Docusont ,/37 fron Docuaent Book ?3« This car. bo found on Pagos 156 to 153 of tho Docuremt Book and is an affid¬ avit by tho Just mentioned Professor Dr. Luxenburgor, dated tho 2bth of February, 19h7. I shall quote briefly from this docuaont. THE lUSSIDEhiTi tfhat oxhibit number do you assign to this? BY DR. TIFF: Q This rill receive the Exhibit nuebor Bocker-Froysong 23. Professor Luxemburger states, after tho customry introductory formula: "At present I an a nor-/, specialist at 12unich, ana consulting psychiatrist at the Catholic Institute for tho Caro of thi Young/ "Until 19kl I worked at tho Gormn Institute for Psychiatric Research, r -bo Kaiser '>.ilholn Institute attached to the University of ifunich. As I was considered politically unreliable by tho Nazis, 1 had to leave this institute in 191:1. In Jan u ar y , 19Ui, I ras drafted to the 7959 22 Kay-tf-*e-2-3-Karrow (Int. Hosier) Court Ko. I. Gorman Lufttraffc, at first as an Assistant Physician. After having boon with the ifedical Inspectorate of the Goman Luftwaffe in Berlin until 19Ui as a psychiatrist, I became Instruction Group Coocandcr at the Luftwaffe Jtdical Academy in Berlin in the summer of 19 Uj, and at the sane tiro, consulting psychiatrist tndcr the Chief of the Luftwaffe Ifcdical Service, with the rank of Ctocrstorzt." The rest of Dr. Luxemburger's fate during the war doc3 not in¬ terest us in that connection and I shall therefore skip the noxt fow sentences. I shall continue to quote from paragraph 2 on page 2 of that document: ■Each raedical-ecientific work to bo publichod as nodical liter¬ ature had to bo submitted chon roady for printing, to the Instruction Group of tho Luftwaffe liedicol Academy of which I was Chief. The chocking, insofar as it was dono by no, was carried out in the caco of non-poychiatric works only from a military point of view. Spocial ox- ports approved then as to their scientific content. The author of tho work was informed, of tho oxport's criticisn in full or in port, in n lettor of approval or rejection, which I signed. "3. Generally, those manuscripts did not havo to bo submitted to tho Chi of of tho Luftwaffo Medical Service. Only works in tho fiold of aviation medicine were regularly submitted to tho offico of 'Chiof of tho Madlcal Service'. Tho other works cure only checked from tho medical point of view by tho apjxopriate consultants or other experts. "Ji. Proa nono of tho manuscripts 'diich wore over submitted to me in the course of my dutios could I gather or assure that human ex¬ po ri-onts were being carried out on concentration coxsp inmates or, in any coso, on persons who were unwilling to act as subjects. Although my chocking of non-psychiatric manuscripts extended only to military form¬ alities and I could not judgo them as an export, I still think that clear and distinct reports or. experiments which had been carried out forcibly would have struck me." There follows the signature on that document and the certification. 7960 22 Kay-U-E-2-ii»-Ksrro (Int. Rader) Court So. I. Witness, let us non go over to another point. let us turn to the research list which has been so often mentioned here. This is Docu- nent ?10-93b, Prosecution Exhibit 1*53. Tho docurent is not contained in a document book. It was submitted to Professor Schroeder during his cross-oxaainntion. In this research list there arc contained tho re¬ search assignaents by the Chief of the Lcdical Service of tho LuftwrXfo and Peso arch Guidance of the Raich llinistry for Aviation and Supreno Comaandor of tho Luftwaffe. As tho re visor tho Stabsant Dr. Dockor- Froyoong is mentioned. On pago 7 of that document under IV wo find tho title "Hygiene." Under 2 wo find tho assignment to :ir. Hcagcn. Let no quote this short paragraph: "Tho manufacture of typhus vaccine (secret). Hygienic Instit¬ ute, Strasbourg, Oborstabearit frofosror Dr. Haagen." 7/itnoss, you know that tho prosecution naintainod and concludud during tho cross-examination of Profossor Schrooder that since this re¬ search assignment was kept socnet thoro must have boon some valid reason to koop it so, and tho prosooution naturally assumes that tho Jfcdical Inspectorate know that Haagen wns carrying out oxporlmonts on human beings which, thoroforo, had to be kopt secret. I have alror.dy discussed this list with Mr. Ruff on tho 29th of April, 19li7, on ;ogo 6?l6 of tlio German and 6622 of tho English record. Since you aro listed hero as tho expert dealing with that list I must ask you to give us your opinion about it and, in particular, why this ro so .arch given to Dr. Haagen is listed as secret. 22 .-lay (Raccier) Court I • A. Well, lut me say at first that all the documents which have so far been submitted by the prosecution rigir- -*ing Haagen' s research assignment have shown time and again that this assignment was entirely open to the outside world. How, suddeQly we see this research assignment is secret, i cannot roooSb^r that this research assignment was suddenly changed over to a secret one, out perhaps professor Ha igon personally will be able to talk about that when he takes tho witness stand. Q. Lot me interpolate a question in order to clarify this point: since you were the expert in thxt case, did you a dlrectlvo to whoever was compiling this list to insert this assignment a secret or did you previously issue a genoral directive that this assignment be converted from open to secret? A. IT anyone could have done any such thing this could only have been done by my department chief. I could have made a suggestion to that effoot, but tho research aoslgn- mont had boon issued a long time ago, and this would have been a subsequent change in the Summer of 194-1, which I cannot remember. Q. At any rate, you don't know, witness, how this word "secret" was inserted? A. It is remarkable that the next assignment by Haugen, namely the o-mufacture of a yellow fever vaccine, is also designated as ■secret 0 here. The Prosecution itself has aubclttod a document here which wo shall later discuss, that this assignment for the manufacture of a yo low fevdr vaccine was stepped by the medical Inspectorate of the Luft- • waffe in the summer of 19-x^. Q. For purposes of clarification I may say that tho document which was just mentioned by tho witness as tho 79c2 22 Hay 47-K-jft-*-&-Maloy- (Raseler) Court I prosecution Document N0.-297, exhibit -*16, and It can bo found in Document 3ook 12 on page 112 of the Herman and the English text. as you were already saying. Dr. Becker, wo shall revert to this document when discussing the yellow fever experiments. .‘iow, in the document which you have just designated it becomes evident that -his assignment for the production of a yellow fever vaccine vor' clearly vao a ncn-socr.t matter. In addition, not oven the prosecution has .* .sorted that sub¬ sequent to 1942 yellow fever experiments on human beings were carried out. If in the year 1944 this assignment, which had been stopped In 194, Is really designated as seerst, then it either constitutes on error or there were certain reasons for that which certainly cannot indicate the planning or the execution of any experl unto on human beings. But now lot us turn to tho yellow fever vaoclno assignment itself. Unfortunately It Is not knows to me where tho Proaeoutlon rooelved this document fro.. It bears no signature, the person who sent It is not mentioned, no reolplcnt Is men¬ tioned, and It is quite Impossible to conclude from where tills list originated. I remember exactly that In tho course of the summer of 1944 a similar list had oeon compiled, In my Reforat. It was the ordinary list of all research assig¬ nments, which was usually available in tho Reforat and which had merely been brought up to date. Slnco I, in the meantime, had taxan over Dr. Bonzlnger's work in the Research Guidance of the RLM, the medical research'assignments of the Research Guidance of tne RLri were also Included In the list. Tho list, or the supplementation of the old Hat In Its form as It Is before us, was compiled ay y instructing my secretary, who was in the Research Guidance ofx'lce In "erlin. to co:b out to Saalov for a period of 2 or * days, which was about 15 kilom¬ eters outside Berlin, and I gave here all the research files, 7963 22 Kay 47-M- Xt- ’'-Mai oy- (Raami er) Court I the entire material under file reference 55, and on the basis of this material and the old list she carried out the new compilation, bringing the list up to date. Q. If I understood you correctly - to return to the Haagen case - these were all the letter, reports, etc. filed at the -'eferat. I would imagine that all these documents were filed properly in one filed according to date, as it Is cus¬ tomary in every army throughout the world? a. The latter 13 true, but naturally these files wore not Kept In the Roforat, but as la customary everywhere else these were kept in t*w Registration office. I, after all, only had one little office, and I hadn't enougn room there to keep all my files in that offlcu. furthermore, I can remember that this list, in the course of the summer or fall of 1944 was sent upon request to various other agencies. I bolievo I remember that one 3uch copy had been sent to the Rolch Research Counsel, and I think It possible that one copy was also sent to the office of Herr Professor Rootook. It may oe posslblo oven that ono copy was sunt to tie Office of Oeneroloborstabsortt Hundloaer. I am 3uro there were a num¬ ber of other offices too; howevur, I cannot toll you that in detail. When Dr. Ruff was sitting in this witness stand you discussed a number of errors with him contained In that list. In ad dltlon the errors wore dlscueced with Ruff there are, in the allegedly true copy which Is before us here, as well as in the photostat copy, a number of other errors. Q. hay I Interrupt you briefly, witness. Did I unior- otand you to say that even here, when compiling the documents Tor the document boos and when mimeographing this document which 1 s before us, a number of mistakes were made, typogra¬ phical errors, wh ch means that the photostat copy does not quite correspond to the allegedly true copy as it is contain¬ ed in the document book before us? 22 'ay 47^»- ■*- 4_ xaloy- (Rfckholer) dourt I Yes, chat ia Just vfaat I wanted to say. Q. Veil, m that case would you explain these errors to us? <*. Unfortunately, wo only received the photostat cop¬ ies only after you had dlscuaaod this allegedly true copy with Dr. Huff. After only looking at the photostat for once I found out that all tne errors which refer to the research assignments given to Dr. Ruff are not contained In the phot¬ ostat copy, but that these are errors which resulted from Che copying of that photostat copy when thlo "true copy" was uude. Q. If I understand you correctly, Wintaas, those are obviously purd alstakoa in copying? Yes, furthermore even in the photostat copy thero are a number of mistakes caused by negligence, which, how- ovor, are all so striking to anyone who knows the subject as well as I, that upon thd first reading of the document I guarantee that I would have notices them immediately. For Instance, the nano of Harr Professor Velti - 7965 2 2 47-iK ij-4-l-MechEn (Int; Racier) Court No. 1 Q Not., let me ask you> witness, to speak slowly here and always mention where the point can bo found in the document which you happen to be discussing. A For instance, on page 2 of the docunent under 1-10, thero is an assignment given to Professor Welts. This name was copied as Koltze. This is obviously a very simple natter, but had I looked through this list la the year of 1944 I an sure this would have attracted ay attention. Another mistake, which could easily occur in the caso of a Icynan but which I should have noticed, can be found on page 10 of this docunent. Kero, under Will - >, there is a research assignnent .icntionod and I nay quoto: "The significance of individual factors in measuring distances." The institute which obviously rcceivod this assignment is mentioned horo as the institute for Physiological Anthropology of the University of Uarburg/Lnhn. In roality wo ore hero concerned with the Institute for Psychological Anthropology, which is well known to ao. In copying, the difforonco between "physiological" and "psychological" always causue great difficulties, and ko have often had that cxporlcnco when dealing with ono another hero and compiling our document books. ^ * • psychiatric clinic has a collection of autilntions of its nr-ao, and tho word "psychiatric" is very often misspelled, UR. HARDY: I don‘t believe it is nocossnry to toko up tho tino of thu Tribunal on a insignificant setter such as this. If thoro nro some errors in the German document books when it was mimeographed the defendant .cay call then to our attention. These are so insignificant and so minor that the Prosecution dooms tho documents may 3poak for themselves. The prosecution resents some of the remarks of the dofenso. THE PRESIDENT: It appears to tho Tribunal that this matter may bo corrected for the Tribunal by r. conference between the defend end tho Prosecution without taking up the time and covering the records with such matters. IB. TTPF: I am naturally prepor ad to adhere to the wish of tho Tribunal, but I believe that counsel for the Frosecution misunderstood 7966 22 May 47-4r-r.TD-4-2-Ucchan (Int. Rtnlcr) Court So. 1 the oim I have pursued in this matter. I am not concerned rdth proving the t t *.3 copy in the German document book contains mistakes, which are not in the photostat, but I an concerned in showing that in the photo¬ stat copy, in the original, there are already errors. This nay sound somewhat like an argument, but I nust clarify that it is our intention to prove that there are actual mistakes contained in the list, the list which the Defendant 3ccker-Froyseng had had compiled. Furthermore wo want to prevo that this list was not compiled by an oxpert, but only originated, as was already stated by the witness, from an unskilled % • and ncdically untrained typist who Just copied something fren soao documents, rnd for that reason the inaccuracies are contained in tho list. I think this is something that oast be discussed rdth tho witness and cannot be clarified by a more discussion betweon the defense counaol and Prosecution. But, I think, witness, that wo can adhoro to tho Tribunal*c wish, and drop tho nettor. !&. !u\RDY: I au3t point out that it is of no interest hero what tho capabilities of the accrotary of Bcckor-Froyscng wero. If oho made tfeu adstakoa in tho original list, it seems to me that is tho nogli- 9 genco of tho defendant in not checking tho secretary's work. THo PR33IDS?.T: Tho defendant, howover, could show that tho * eccrctary did incorrectly transcribe what he had given hur to copy or what he had dictated to her. DR. TIPP: Ur. President, I on in a fortunate position to givo you thir proof In a minute. Witness, you hoard the Tribunal's decision and you hoard shot I said, but I think that we cro in full agreement. If you have something to say, would you please express yourself briefly. IKS 1T7IESS: In connection with the reprimand by tho Prosocution, I rust say I always was very careful in reading over what ay secretary had written and I am sure that such sill;- and noticeable typing mistakes would have drown cy attention. Thc.ro are a number of other mistakes contained in that list, for instance at one time Haagen's nemo was spelled with one "a" and once with two "A'a." I an sure I would have 7967 22 Jfey 47-ii-..7>-i.->-i&ch£n (Inti R«nler) Court Hoj 1 noticed that. I do not believe that this list is tho sene list which wr.s typed by ay secretary, which I am sure that I read through very carefully. I easumc that we era h3rc concerned with a copy. 5Y DR. TIPP: Q Do you mean that this document, which is before you now, is a copy of the original list, which you ordered to bo coapilcd? A Yes, this aist bo a copy nr.do by one cf tpe offices which rccuiv Jd the original list from us. Furthermore, I oey say that our socrotarios were wall vorsod on the difference between physiology and psychology after they had been with us for sane tine. This orror nay havo occurred with new secretaries during their first fem wochs, but not later. However, enough of that. 3 Lot ua finish then. Ur. President, in this connection lot mo offer - document fren Document Book Buckor-Freyoeng 3. This is Document Bockcr-Freyseng 36 and can bo feund on page 159 to 161 of tho docuaont book. This will recoivo o^hibit Ho. 24. It is an affidavit. Jfi. UHDY: Ua:* it pluisc, Your Honor, this document contains tho onat subject which the defendant has been discussing hero for nearly fiftcon minutes. The prosecution deems it irrelevant and I object to any further introduction of documents .-long thoso lines. THE PRESIDENT: Tho Tribunal has not read the document. tihet is the probitivo v;luc of the material offered in this document, counaul? DR. TIPP: This can bo settled briefly, Ur. President. Ihis i3 the secretary who hed typed and ccopilcd the list by order of Becker- Froysong^ -nd she states how she compilod the list. She says that Bcckcr-Frcy seng gave her ell thw material for that list and that she could not ace anything about experiments on human beings from this list. • She further .x?r- says, it is quito possible that in her hsGtc sho over¬ looked seme errors contained in the list. It i3 not ay intention to quote anything from thst document and I think li-. Hardy is correct in saying that this point has been sufficiently clarified, Witness — 7968 * 22 tfcy 4?-JF-A7D-i.-i.-'.'ccfcaa (Inti Renlcr) Court Ho. 1 THE PRESIDENT: Just e accent, counsel. Dh. TIFF: IS". President, I did not quite understand you. Ur. Frosidont, did you ask a question of no? T}C P T -ESI DE MT: Ho, I Just requested you to wait a few nonents until wc cxrninc the docuncr.t. IR. KaRDT: The ifcolc jist of this scons to no to bo as follows. This docunont !X >-934 contains a list of tho assignnents *hich cano fror. tho office of Beckor-Froyscng. Ho*, B eckcr-Freyac-nt is aeintnining that this list is Just a copy of the list •..hieh originated from his office and that his secretary cade typographic'! errors and ho points out that such errors aro nade like spelling tho nano of Waltz rdth two "E's" instead of one "S", etc. Mow this docunont is introduced to show that the or,try concerning the wortc of Haagen with typhus and after that entry is tho nuihor designating the word “secret 1 *. The prosocution has nado an issue of the -.K>rd "secret" and ho is now attempting to intro¬ duce that she erroneously put down the word "secret." That is the Jint cf this entire affidavit and tho context of this argument. M 7969 1 Court 1 Rcy B&dH-5-l-HD-Cook-Ramleri TRH PRES 102: T: Is there available there in the original photostat of the Exhibit wnlch ccme from the defendant's office? DR. TIP?: Yes, Your Honor, I hove the ori-inal photostat of that list. I--R. rhiRDY: The section In Issue, /our Honor, Is c. ite obvl ualjr-in the photostat as checked In pencil ris. THE ?=S5ID2: T: If this Ho. 93-i which la now . In evidence? DR. TIPF: Yes, Your Honor.. Perhaps I may say In th t connection that the defendant hna not been aeaertin*, that the remark "secret 0 wc.s erroneously transcribed but he says that he does not think that this photostat copy la a car bon oooy of the orlginnl li6t but thinks that It is just c transcrib d copy of the original. He thinks that there are two ooeslbllltloe, one that his secretary, Hiss "Voinor, by mistake Inserted the rem ric, or It crept Into the original In some way; or It Is farther poselble that the erson who Is unknown to ue and who has transcribed tt. c or 1 Inal list n s made th t error. It Is In no way contested that the photostetlo copy submitted here contains t.»e r.-aerk "secret." DR. 32-RIMG: You ore attempting to show that a list '••a* '-c.de b; this defendant's Secretary and under his direction but that the list that was directed to be made b- elm or. the cne hand or teat may actually h ve been made under hie direction, did not list these projects as secret. Is that C..e thin- you are tryln = to establish, that as a mr.tt v of fact tney were open subjects? DR. TIFP: Yes, according to ur knowled a e, lour Honor, Che Heaven assignment wae open. *e have a wealth of I letters Court 1 -ar 2&-24-5-3-KD—Cook-iteEler i b Haagen and directed Co Haager. whlcu was material sub¬ mitted to as by Che Prosecution, which so far as they c noera the Luftwaffe are always open, and now suddenly we nave the remark “secret B from the year 1944, and we d'.n't thins that Haa t er,'s assignment was suddenly converted Into a secret one. I personally have another explanation, which, of course, cannot be proved, but may interest the Tribunal if I any mention it briefly. «t one time we discussed the fact that all reports of cases of typhus h d co -3 ;opt secret throughout the entire Vehricacht. In other >crds, any typhus case which occurred anyvher? lr, • Ov-rmany had for military reasons to be reported as ’•secret". It la quite possible that Mias tegner knew about t la ru ulstlon r>rk could not possibly bo doe l t with by one nan alone, part of the work was to bo takan over •by the Instruction Oroup Scienco and Research. About the end of October 19LL, Dr. Becker Freyseng therefore handed over to no all tho orders for research which had, up to then, boon distributed by tho Chief of the licdical Services of the Luftwaffe, together with tho files, reports, etc, conncctod therewith. The Instruction Oroup Scienco and Research was, fro.: this time on by ordor of' the Chief of 7973 May 22-U-3K-5-1--Cook (Int. .iannlor) Court No. 1 tho Ho.’.iocl Services of the Luftwaffe, to supervise tho • carry in out of those orders, since the consultant, -;r. -ookor-Froyson: could not possibly ncoorr lish this task of su. jrvisior., in view of tho multitude of his other duties and of th~ incroasin ; transportation difficulties. On tho other hand, control had been rendered necessary 'ey tho strict re ;ulations concornin; tie use of nnnpowor nd natorial. "6) .sion th-j files hondod over to r.o wore tho order for roso rch jlvon to the Strassbour z hy ;ienist ^rof. Dr. ^ujon Hoajon. ~s far as I runoaljor, they were ccnoornod with tho .reduction of ty.hus, yellow fovor and influence vaccines. „3 far -s I rorcabar they were dated sor.o years back (about 1910 or 1911), and, ct Ha;on's request, were oxtended ~»-a annually. The order for the product! xi of yollow fovor vaccine was cancelled at tho ond of 19ii 3inoo thoro was no further clonruid for it. "..t the witton request of ..ttornuy Dr. Hens Marx I ox.rossly declare that noithor frar. tho urdor3 frou rosoaroh ~ivcn to i'raf. Ha ;on, which had i>oon hondod to no, nor frot; Ha;on's reports on his activities in connection with theso orders, nor fren any infornntion ;ivon to no either when theso files were handed to tie or on any othor occasion huvo X been led, directly, or indirectly, to ooncludc that Ha jon carried out hunan uxpor inonts in a concentration c . 1 ., which wore conccrnod with artificial infocti n with typhus or with any othor disoaso. "7) Tho .orders for roscarch or 4 reduction ;iven to j-rof. Ua 'on were of a purely bnctoriolojiool nature .end wore therefore actually dealt with by tho appropriate consulting hy ;ionist. Thu *K>forat of ..viation Iloilicino of whioh Dr. liookor-rroyscxv; was a neaber, was not Oh‘ir.;od with tho actual execution of the work in accordance with theso rosoarch orders which did not cono within the scopo of "aviation 7974 - ~".y 22-CI-JK-5-2::-Co (Int. ±tc;-:lor) Court No. 1 no’.icino", but was ccly c ’ncomcfl with the fomnl, adninis- trativo, financial and supply questi >ns connoctoc’ with r~soaroh Rssi :nnont. -.11 rosorxch orders boro tho rile nur.’ or "55" which wr.s r. number a 1 lotto,’. _,uroly for filing - ur - - SJS to the .vofer-t of ..vintion Medici no. This *vcferat had tho roforonco nuaber -hero follows the si -nature and tho certification. Court 1 May 22-K- >- 1- KD-Ka rrow-Ha _ 1 e r. ".tness, in conclusion of this question of typhus I any su:u_:arlza that you have said that ro£ a factual point of viev never had anything to do with dealing with ty.hue qua • Ci -ns. secondly, you said that up to the time you took over the Referat in the yeer of 194-, you had nothing at all co c.o with these research nssl-naents lr. bncterlolo-ical ields, even formally. Thirdly shat from no documents, fr. no converst*-tlons, and fr ; no re orta you received, did u t .ov whether nnd to what extent e^erlaenta on n jeinga were carried out in connection with typhus ixnd yallov fever, or anythin- else. Did I understand you correctly? a. Yea, that ia correct. i. Mr. President, there ere only r few short quoBClons in o-nnootion with yellow fever, of which thu prosecution has a :'.e cn issue. I think th». t 1 can finish that by 11sGC o'clock. I should bo e rateful to the Tribunal if they -emitted ae to conclude that question. THZ PAZSI02ST: 1 think the Tribunal should follow its oust . of taking a reoess at this tine. Counsel any -^rocoed • th the untter at 11:01 o'clock. Thu Tribunal will now bo in recess for a few minutes. (« recces was tnkon) 22 L7-Ii-S2-7-l-Miloy (7ca Schoon) Court So, 1 —■ ‘--HSHXLi The Tribunal is ogain in scsicn. 2?ESIDE:T: Tho clc* rt li rotum this photostat to the counsol. Counsol ray proceed, r >. Dr. Becker, now ro cone to afar :ioro points with which you r^o c.arged, You .-ore accusod ordly vith oxporinonts in influonsn. It was only ccntioncd. I havo not beon able to f ind any dccun*nts referring to influenza, thoreforo, I only ask you did you Imon of ary c:r.xrinonts in tho field cf influonza at my tire any. he re? »♦_ Um JO# 1 m -itness, you arc elm cnargod th participation in oxpar- iaonta in cholera, typhoid, pcra-ty?]»ld and strdlar things. Tlw onli- dccunont *.hich tho Prosecution hrs submitted on this subject _ ay it ploaso tho 7 p ibunal, to stnplify tho issuo tho ftrosooution ‘•'ill at this ti_o rithdrmr charges a-jainst Boc!:or- a n-oysong c once min." yollcw fevor, c.allpox, para-typhus A and B , oholora, an! dipthoria, - not typhus. ?;r. Tho Secretary C, ncral dll note for tho record tho nithdr-ral af these changos, and c unsol ferthe Prosecution v3 11 file '-1th tho Sccrotary General and sorvo upon • ppoaing counsel a •Titten statenont of tho charges d.ich are withdrawn. on * 177: '•’■y 1 " Jk > r. Ha* v, do y •-» also -rithdrenr yellow fovor? ;:.IXY: roller.- fovr, snallpox,para-typhus A 4 B, cholera, dipthoria. DR, ;IPP* Tcllow fever is also uithdrmm? -It. lURDI: In other rorlc, all tho other charges to tho dofondant Pochor-frcyscag, yellow fovor, snail pox, para-typhus A & B, Ofeofera, dipthoria, and 3ulphanilasdc’o r.hich t*c *..lth ror bof.-rc -rill bo rith- rca—, by the FTocccutien, xr-?: ir. President, in vie.. of this statenont I hare no further questions, T hc only p int re; l. ring for discussion is tho change cf sea rater, ad this t. 111 be dealt 1th by Dr. lane, tho 22 lay -7-2-C ialcy(Ycn Schoon) Court :jo. 1 dofoniant counsel for Dr. Bcch.rw roysong. I should liko to givo a brief technical explanation, -ho witness :iaagon isZjcrc. I hovo boon only able to talk to hin briefly. I can say that he Till bo called as a dofenso rdtnossfor Dr. Sc brooder aixi Boclxr-Proysons, after tho oxaaination of this dofeniant. I shall sutait th is in writing to tho Secretary General, 22 - £-3—l-4ioeban (int. Bailor) Court Id. I. rRZSJDELT: Very well, counsel. Counsel for t'>? defendant Beelc&r-rreyscng, Dr. i&rx, aay proceed. 3Z DR. HARX: 5 With tho permission of the Tribunal I shall non; begin the ex¬ amination of the defendant. Dr. Beckor-Freysang, on the question of sea- rat . r. Witness, wo now coco to the final charge against you. You aro charged with special responsibility for and participation in tho sea- >rat:r experiments carried out in the concontration camp Dachau, the ex¬ periments to tost two procodures for asking sea water drinknblo. Wit¬ ness, you woro actually involvod in planning experiments as a Referent; will you please tell the Tribunal how tboso experiments care about? A The proUes of combatting thirst in cases of distress at soa up until 19h2 was not settled either in Gornuny or in any other coun¬ try, at 'eart not with much succo33.* Just as in other countries, thero rtr.a a small supply of water in tlao Goman enorgency equipment, but it wr.o inadequate in most cases. The office responsible for equipping airplanes with or.orgency equipment ras that of tho Technical Offico of tljo Luftwaffe. Lhon German pianos woro usod in tho Mediterranean area and over the Atlantic, tho cases of distress at sea increased and also tho cases of sovoro thirst and complaints from tho crows. In ny previous testimony, I Juive already said that one of ny main duties as Assistant Referent in tho Raferat for Aviation ISedicine ,rs that I had to work on fror. between three hundred to four hundi*od re¬ ports. In tlic reports from the Luftr.rffe doctors in the flying forma¬ tions in l?!il and 19U2 I found an increasing nurber of reports of cases of distress at sea from tho i5editerranear. area free units which flew over the Atlantic. When severe thirst had cose about tho danger for fliers in thoso sub-tropical and solo tires tropical areas was that they "ore not exposed to the cold, like their comrades in the North Sea area and the area around England, but they were exposed for days at a time to the heat of the sun and consequently to thirst. I had personal scientific connections with this field. From 1935 22 Jiy-li-iS-2-«ioban (int. Rosier) Court ::o. i. to 1935 I hod worked on questions of water and salt nyseif, although not -rith this definite a is of couSxatting thirst. Of course, I wondered how this problem could be solved. I discussed ■ ith the Referent Pro¬ fessor Anthony and at ny suggestion, or rather our suggestion, in the spring, perhaps in April of 19U2, Dr. Konrad Schaefer was given tho assignment to see to it that tho thirst problem was dealt with scient¬ ifically. For this purpose, ho was sent to tho Aviation iiidical Re¬ search Institute in 3erlin. Q Hitnoss, do you know that Dr. Schaefer in October of 19l*2 at the Kurnborg conference "Son and Winter Distress" made a lecture on combatting thirst in distress at sea? A Yos, I beard this lecturo. Of course, it was simply a locturo based on his reading, because Dr. Schaefer had not performed any ex¬ periments hlasolf at that tine. 3 Thon, to your knowledge, up to the fall of 191*2, Dr. Schaofor had not iorforrod any exporinords on human beings himsolf? a lioitivr or. human boingc or on animals, as far ns I know. This locturo was siaply a lecture bared on his ronding on tho cubjoct. Q Hew, what happened after this ^eating; how did tho matter de¬ velop? A (ir. tin winter of 1912-1:3 and in 19l3, Dr. Schaofor worked on this problem intensively. First of all, lie undo physiological tosts on how thirst was caused. It is remarkable that a thing uhich Boons so simple and primitive to a layman, thirst, from tho scientific and thcorotical point of view was not settlod at that time and is not com¬ pletely sottlod oven today. Dr. Schaefer performed many animal experi- • □eats and also self experiments on four or five of his technics^ assist¬ ants, who volunteered for this purpose. I should liko to point out that these technical assistants went without water and food completely for four days, at the sace time being able to carry on their full lab¬ oratory work. The second way that Dr. Schaefer took was a purely chemical test /?&) 22 Uay-ii-f5-8-3-M*eban (Lit. Raaler) Ccurt Ko« I. or development. Ho tried to discover a sc ^-distress food as good as possible. Without going into detail, I shall state briefly that most foods fihich wo oat are burned in the bod;.' and bee one carbonic acid -.nd rater. In normal food about 300 cc of rater are created daily in the body. It is possible to compose the food in such a ray as to chango and prepare foods chemically in such a way that this amount of water in the body is* oven irtdrorsod. That was one purpose cf Schaefer's tests and on his suggestion two research assignments v.ero issued to two research workers in Prague. That you ca.nnot find these two aon on the list, which has been discussed at loxv-th, is because this cssicivnont t.'no given in the fall of 19 hi after this list was drawn up. Also Dr. Schaefer devolopod c oathod to make sen water drinkable. Soa rater las about 3* salts, about 2.7? table salt and about 0.2? nagnosiun sulphate, also snail mounts of other salts, which arc not important. 7931 Court So. 1 22 Kay 47-K-S-l-nHh-Cook (Von Scfccen) The table salt Is icportant especially because it is the salt 'hicb causes or can cause thirst, and the nagnesiua sulphate ic ianor- tant because it can cause diarrhea. This diarrhetic effect of cagnesiuo sulphate has a certain significance in this trial. This is causedonly after a certain anount has been take. ?or example, if sea water is taken, diarrhea is caused only if tho individual dose, that is, tho anount taken at one tine, is at least 300 or 4C0 cc. In nurely scien¬ tific collaboration with a research laboratory of tho 1.0. Parbon Indus¬ try Dr. Schaefer worked out a procedure, and for tho first tine In the history of husanity it was possible that sea water could be node drinkable even under the conditions prevailing in a lifeboat. In the meantinu I have becoco acquainted with a procedure developed by an American scientist, but I can still uphold this statoaent which I have Just node bucouso through sy knovlodgc tho procoduro dovolopod by Dr. Schaefer is the only one which at tho oaao tine removes the tablo salt and tho magnesium sulphate. Dr. Schaofer hod finished developing tho procedure in about Sovesbor 1943 and in tho first days of Deccnbor 1943 ho demonstrated it in ny prosonco to a saall group of pconlo, including the Hodical Insrcctor, Professor Kipokfl, and Oborstingonicur Christonoon of the Technical Office, the non responsible for introducing such a pioco of eauipeont into the energency equipaont. Schaefer's procoduro gained general recognition at tho time and Cborstingeniour Christensen proeised the kodical Inspector, Professor h'ippko, that this procedure would be introduced. In December 1943 ho issued a so-callod development assignment to the I.G. Parbcn Industry in order to have the las*, technical details worked cut noro ouickly and preparations made for large-scale production before the beginning of the cuaaer of 1944, if possible. This settled tho whole natter for ne. As this trial shows, it van unfortunately not settled. Q, Bow, witness, how did it happen that the natter was taken up again? A. In January, February, up to the niddle of Aoril, 1944 I had a 7982 Court So. 1 22 Hay 47-K-9-2-DQ(-Coofc (Von Schoen) leave to do sene scientific work, to carry out soso crpericcntal work of my own, and I hardly had any contact during this tine with Professor Anthony. When on the 16th of April 1944 I rerorted back to the office • end took up ny work, I heard to my great astonishment that in the mean¬ time lr. Vienna a second procedure had been developed to make eco water drinkable by an engineer neccd Bcrka, and tkat a forcer Oberstarrt in the Luftwaffo, Dr. Von Serany, had tested this method in experiments on soldiers of the Luftwaffe in a Luftvaffo hospital in Vienna. Professor Anthony hod heard about this story and had Dr. Schaefer go to Vienna and work with this procedure and with Serany's experiments, but unfortunately ho had oinply told the Technical Cffico that thoro was a second nroccdure and had not taken any further interest in the matter. Since betveon the 15th of April and the 15th of Hoy I hod taken over the affairs of the Rofcrat - Anthony was to leave on tho 15th of Hoy - I immediately suggested that tho original records from Kr. Von Serany should be sent for. I saw those records about the end of Aoril. I looked through these records myself ond suggested to ay department chief that thoy should be shewn to Dr. Schoofer and hU opinion on them asked for, ond on Che basis of Schaefer's opinion ond my ovr. opinion vc came to the conclusion that tho Berko aothod was to be rejedted under all condi¬ tions; and so In the first days of Hoy 1944 a vfiry definite rejection van given to the Technical Office. I shall go into the reasons for our rejection lator. On the bade of our rejection almost oroctly threo years ego, or. the 19th or 20th of Kay 1944, the Technical Cffico called a conference on the subject, ar.d =y department chief ordered me to go to it, and also ordered that Dr. Schaefer wot to oarticipate in tho discussion as ar. export in tho field. (*. Witness, I now come to the first docuaont on the subject. I show to you free Document Book 5, cage 10 of tho German, page 9 of the -nglisn. Document £0-164, Prosecution Dxhibit 132. This is a letter from the Technical Office to the Rcichsfuehrer SS, dated 15 Kay 1944. I ask you, witness, did you know that in the oucstion of making sea 7983 Court Sc. 1 22 May 47-K-5-3-iHM-CoGk (Von Scfcoen) water drinkable there had been close contact between the Technical office of the Belch Air Ministry and the r.eiehsfuefcror SS fron the end cf 1942 at the latest? A. So, I knew nothing about such a connection and, of course, I did not know this letter. Cj, Witness, do you have the letter before you? A. Yes, I have it. q. If you look et the letterhead and the signature, can you tell us vhnt office this letter cone* froa? A. Yes, it coses frea the Technical Office end the abbreviation "Gi/co 54" indicates it ccc^s free the office responsible for the dcvclopacnt of •ouipewnt for airplanes. That was the departaent of Otorstlngenicur Christensen. On the copy I hovo here I cannot declphor the signature because there Is no signature given, but sosc tlrao ago I saw tho photostat of this letter and I know tho signature on it. It is that of Korsann, who wac a Generallngenicur and Chriotcnoon'c superior. Q, Sow I coco to tho contents of the letter itself. Witness, the Technical Office writes in the first oarrgrnoh, and I ouoto: "With rcfcrenco to the lntor-office conference between Gbcrct- ingoniour Chrictcnoer. ond Eauptoturafuohrcr lag. Poh;e regarding tho natter it is announced that two croceeses have been worked out by the office to render sea water potable." Eoes this statement not contradict ~hat you have .lust said? A. Yes. but the statenent in this lotter is definitely untrue. Seithor the procedure of Dr. Schaefer nor that of Engineer Bcrka was vxkcd out by the office, neaning the Technical Office, as it says here. Schaefer's process was worked out for the nodical Inspectorate and Bcrka worked first at the Technical College in Vienna without any assigenent. and only when Anthony informed the Technical Office would the Technical Office have been turned ever to Berks. q. Witness, the Technical Office now speaks of Schaefer's 7984 Court Fo. 1 22 - tens of iron were really not an insurmountable obstacle, net even in 1944. The 250 thousand Rdchs- carks which sotting up • plant fer Schaefer's settled would have cost are, cf ccursp, quite r lot cf aonej for a priv.tt citizen, but if one considers that the training cf cnc pilot until he is ready for the front, until he is ready tc be used as r fighter pilot or a beraber pilot r.t the front, costs the state about 50 tc 100 thousand narks — I nay renark thrt this includes costs cf accidents in training end aany other expenses — if :r.e contrasts this sun and considers thrt the first two cr three fliers who rxo saved will reimburse the Luft- waffo for these 250 thousand Roichs.aarks, then one can bolieve that this sun of nen-y is nc valid argument against the introduction cf Schnef-r's uethed. ,.s for th- 2.5 to 3 tons cf pure silver which would allegedly be needed every nenth, this is a gru’t exaggeration, as 1 think I can prove later. These 2.5 to 3 tens cf pure silvu- were the amount of silvor needed fer the sc-called prinery equipment. In the course of future aonths “there would he needed only fer replacements the Toour.t used in cases cf distress at scr or by less of planes. Tho Technical Office acts as if every flier wculd to forced down at oca cnco a menth cr that every piano would crash and be completely destroyed once a r. nth. .*nl new for the last rcos.n, that is, tho difficulty because r filter is needed ir. Schaefer's process, Sven a ncn-cheaist will bo willing U believe thrt tht is a very hairless natter, which can be easily settled and which is nc reasen against introducing such a acthod. q itness, the letter gees cn tc say, I quote: "2. Tho second process which was worked cut is the sc-crllod Serkr. nethed. ..cccrding to this nothed thu salts present in the sea. weter are net precipitated but are so treated that in drinking they -re not disagreeable tc the teste. They pass thro ugh .tho body vdth ut 7986 22 D JG-10*-lS-garrow ( ven Schcn) Ccurt I cvcr-s-.turrting it with salts and without causing undue thirst." In my opinion this is a ncdical Judgment on the 3crkc nethed. Wes the Technical Office in r. position to make such a nodical Jud^aent? i- Me, md for that reason this propaganda for Berkatit is that cf n lejram end is rather dumb. You indicated in your question thr.t it was r. medical statement, which the Technical Office was net cor.ipotont tc make, since it was c.npcsod purely cf engineers. I said before that, at the beginning cf 1fay, 1944, the rejection cf the Berka method, which hrd been very clearly formulated and explained, was sent tc the Tech¬ nical Office. Nevertheless, on the 15th cf Key the Technical Offico wroto this lottor tc the Koichsfuchrcr SS. Q In the next sontuncc, the Technical Office speaks cf the practical aide cf the prccoss, I quoto: "Mo special plants arc necossary for producing preparations needed for this process ncr do the preparations themselves consist cf scarce nctorials." ..ill ycu please cccacnt on this statement cf the Technical Office, witness? The only thing true in this sentence is that no special plants wore necessary fer producing this preparation. That was really an advantago tc this nethed. Berkatit could bo produced in any sugar factor;'. ..s fer the statenont that the preparations woro net scarco materials, I nay point cut that the preparations needed were glucose. It is significant cf the ebstinancy of this Technical Office that 200 tens cf iron they c.nsi.ier ’n unsuracuntsblc obstacle, but glucose* they say is net c scarco aatcrial. I d:n't think I'll bo giving away r.ny secrets if 1 say that, in 1944, glucose, which is aede of corn primarily here, was a very scarce nattrial and that gluccso was used only for feeding sick persons and was available only in very limited quantities. Today, when all the papers arc writing about calorics, I can soy that during cur discussion with the Technical Offico about the introduction cf Berkatit, the Technical Office went to the Supply Office of the 7987 22 Mey-^DiG-lO-3-Karrcn (vcn Schcn) Court I Luftwaffe end demanded the first two tens cf glucose. Fortunately, we learned eb:ut it end were able tc step it. One ten tf glucose con¬ tains four million calorics. If one takes the amount cf two thousand calorics per person per day, which is ideal under present day condi¬ tions, this one t_n of glucose which the Technical Office wanted would bo enough tc feed a feur person family, from the point of view of calorics clone, of course, fer five hundred days, and yet the Technical Office says th.'t is net a scarce material. THE PFlSIDEifi: Counsel, the it.ness has been testifying as tc the various methods that woro suggested. I do not see that it has probative value before the Tribunal, the fact that they s-lectori tne method instead cf another, and that they were even falso with both notheda*. One method was selected end that method was attunptud tc be carried cut. Certainly, tho relative merits cf the twe aethedo are net particularly important. If the higher authorities rejected the bettor method, I dc not see that that wuild be relevant. 9R. ILJOCs Ur. President, tho testimony cf the witness has prebntivo value inasmuch -a ho wants tc prove what difficulties wore raised by the Technical Office and that prejudices existed in tho Technical Office pr.i hew the natter dcvelcpod, so that f_n.ally, from tho point cf view cf the Kcdical Inspectorate, tho experiments becano necessary. For this reason I think thut tho testimony cf the defendant is relevant, but in order tc avoid delaying the trial unnecoocarily, I sh^ll ask only tho mest imp rtent questi ns and I ask yeu, witness, tc be as, brief as possible in answering my questions. Y.u heard what the President ju3t said. 22 fcy-i:-GJ-ll-l-i--.lcy-(vcnSchon)- Court 1 TrE ??-LSIZEfiT: CCunsol, you nay proceed. t:., su-RX: T v c letter of the technical Offic. continues, I quote: "It cm be presumed that this s_thcd, that is the Berk.-, Method will be introduced ir. the Luftwaffe end the Kavy within a snort tine." « I ask you, could the Technical Office cn its own initiative nuko such a decision? /. Yos, the technical Ofi'icc, could dc that. The Technical Office al'ne was competent to decide whether a piece of equipment was to be intriduccd or net. I tasy add that in the organizeti.n cf equipment cus¬ tomary in the Gorman Luftwaffe, such as an iUm for making Sei water drinkable was n t foed—the food Office would be competent to handle that. It was not cedicine:Thc Chief of :rt, yes, b_cause b.fcrc the 20th of toy, fer example, Christensen called up Dr. Schaefer or called him in and t- Id him that h*. prohibited any cement against 5„rkatit. And from work in the Ref-.rnt for rt /iatien -.-decinc I was u3ed to similar prejudices in scientific attituos from the same office, and in other fields, for -xanple in the field nirtht sight, which is of no intorest here.However, I refer to it only because there is an affidavit onwtho subject. DR. ieiRX: At this point I should like to refer to an affidavit of Dr. H .inrich Rose, who is net identical with Professor Gerhard Rose. Dr. Heinrich Rose, was also a doctor. He was a dyo doctor, and ho was 22 ^y-i:-3J-il-2-*-alcy-(vcn Scfcon)- Court 1 called up;n as a consultant frca tine to time. I quota frca the nffida- vf ^ Kcinric h Soso. This is docuacnt 39, on pages 162 to 163, 34 CUE ‘ at hu * 3 * Thls “- 111 ^ Exhibit 26. I quote only one paragraph, that is the -nc under « 1 »). The affidavit of the 2 ? Oeceabcr 191*. I quo¬ ta] ’" rhc ^chnical Department of the Reich Air Hinistry pr.:co-dcd inde¬ pendently also m questions of medical research. F:r instance, the Tech¬ nical Department gave orders tc tost Xip id rctjnalo - a remedy which n3a aupp s-d to improve night sight cn the tre ps without previous con¬ sultation with ether nodical outheritios. n I shall not read the rest of tnis dccunont. Is shall cc=c back tc it later in ay argument. I cff.r ti-is affidavit as Exhibit 26. Q fitness, I ask you, when ycu Went tc th- discussi- ns of 19 .nd 20 cf -*ny ycu did n.t knew that tee technical Office has already decided en Beckatit and nad promised that it would bo introduced soon? i. No, I did net know that. Q T »- u Prosecution has submitted a deconmt which is no doubt the nest important one in the whole prccccution dccucent beck in this con¬ nection; in -ny caco the Prosecution shewed this Dccuae.nt V. ?r fessor Schrotder in cross-examination and drew the ccnclusi.n that the sm-watcr experiments wore criainol. I should therefore like tc discuss this docu- aent rlth you in detail. It is in Docunent Bock 5, page 12, in the Gcr- •* 3c k, page 11 of tho English. This is Decuaont Mo 177, Exhibit 132; -I. you hay, th, photostat? •* Yes, I have it. itr.-ss, h. w did the twe discussi ns of the 19 and 20 cf .-ay cc- U ' b Ut; ,iid 3U£F-st teem? Did yru make the preparations for t:.^? " ld th< “ r lh - -^-dical Services f the Luftwaffe call then, or " These discussions rrcre called by th. Technical Office, and at both —cussi-ns the person who called thma presided at them, that was Oberet-. insqpicur Christensen, the head of this Apartment GL/ce 5. *y 7990 22 i::y->-3J-U -3-Halcy-(ro« Schcn)- Court 1 dcpOrtccnt chief, os I said, scat a_ and Dr. Kcarad Schac-f.r to these tw discussions, and 1 nay add that he did this because according to the inf creation which we n.coi? t d, I think it ras a telcphon. cell to ay department chief, we expected a small discussion attended solely by Rforents, and not a discussion on the scale on which it actually took place. * itness, will you first cocacnt generally on this r_p. rt? A I should sorely like tc rvfcr very briefly to what I said. Above all I should like to go tack to Instrument Ho. lSL, Exhibit 132, according to which, on the 15 Kay 19LL, th. Technical Office vrus already determined tc intrcduc. -erkatit. .e, that is the office cf the chief of Medical Service cf the Luftwaffe, wwxv. asked to at¬ tend two discussions on the 19 and 20, and want tc these discuss! ns convinced that it would b. a purely technical discussion cf this point questicn. Hew, please look at the letterhead and th- heading of this document, which on the 15th of December 19ls6 was submitted by the Prose¬ cution page 525 of the '^rc-.a record; -..hat you h • to tf :t. A The heading, and if I my mention it right new, the signatu¬ re of this .etter shews that it corn free the Technical Offi c „, that is the Office of Cberstingeniour Christensen, and was signed by him per¬ sonally. Abeve the d:consent it says -Minutes”. If the Prosocuticn Uiinks that it is a rec rd transcript I must say that 1 d. n.t knew the exact definition ef these teras in International Law. 1 merely knew new a rec-.rd c-aae ab ut in the Aviatirh Ministry, since I belonged 22 eScv-sWP-U-la-Xolcy (1st. von Schcn) Crart I to -lie office for nl-cos five years, .it a noetic a porson was ajrsoint- cd who either took down the entire wording rc' the ceeting in shorthand or took down tr.c nain points of the ncetisg. A t the cad of the .:octing t-is document w_g shown to those present, Jhey had an opportunity to road it, to approve it and to sign it. 2aec it w_s signed by tho recor¬ der and in taia way such a document oot-ined the character of want uo call a "Protckoll 3 , or if no recorder was appointed tnon at tho end of t.'.o aoot.-ng q brief decision v_s drawn up In a few pregnant ccr.toncoc wlsich were dictated to a secret ary and it was also signed by pll par¬ ticipants at the nooting. Thoro Was a third possibility in very long discussions; tho office w.dch callod tho uootlng, tho roprcscnt.tivo of which Van in charge of the ueoting, drew up a report of tho uootlng, a roiort of tho discussion rather, tho draft of which was sent to tho various rgenclos or porscas t*o had part icipated with the roquoct for signaturo, then one h.d nn opportunity to road it through colaly. Tl:o porsons Justlflod to do so signod it. It was sont back to tho offico whoro it hod cone free, and then aDovo such document it said, "In C'.roa.ont with such and euch agoaclos tho following report in iosuod.'' according to uy rather thorough knowledge of tho procooduro of tho Reich Aviation Ministry those voro tho threo possibilities of how a binding record w .# drawn up. 22 Hay 47 -L-12-l-=kp- Meehan (vcr. Schon) . Court Mo. 1 A. (Cart.) This Bocuaont indicates th t th_r- as a no person appointed or nc=ud here .*o kept the .record end that the participants did r.ot si^r. this document. It is not - shorthand record and it docs not say that it -.its issued in ngroonert with the agencies co.ncemod tixl fir-'Uy ‘bout the entin* cocieo-r.t, there is the word "Hiedorschrift" end not "Protokoll", which neons that the person who drew it up did not think it was a bindi^ record. Therefore, I want to soy th-1 the person rtio drew up this Docunnt, prusu.-v.bly tho JJcfe-rent of Christenson, and Christensen hinself, who signed it, apparently are just putting down thoir impression cf the ewetin* and what they thou; ht should be passed on to othor offices. Q. Mott tho i/ocuav.r.t lists thj poople who wore present. I do net want tcroed this part of the document, hot I want to - si: you frea whrt poin t of view had these people beon chosen? A. I need not read all tho nones, but it iA noteworthy that ihero won. nine people there end that with xm exception, 11 people -xc-pt Dr. Schcofer and ay self were Majors or Colonels nd as I shall -xolrin Later that they wore all pocpL, who did not urderstaod aocic-1 problems .anl wore therefore all the tore in favor of the introduction of D-rkatit. Q. Now, 'id you wonder why so a:ny officers were called to this discussion? A » Y-s, espcclr,lly or. the 20th I noticed what was going on v-ry quickly. It was - typically staged scene, -t which every one except Dr. Schaefer -nd ayself knew his role very well by heart. They were to cut-voto us to sec th t Borkntit should by introduced, Q. : fore I c o cn with the document, witness, I should like to ask: was th- iscussion xi a scientific o-sis or were ther- --ny debates or qunrr-ls? «. I auat say thrt t this discussion I heard xiu of the p-rticipants, th- chi-f of the Traveauandc Government T-stin Station, a Major J-worok, ttack ci personally. He said I was against &rkatit only i-.caus. I was financially intcrest-d in the other octr.od. * - I 7993 22 kay 47 -ir-I2-3-pkp- lfcthan. (van -.ro 480 of the relish trr nacript, the Prosecution s-.i * that thedcfendante Schaefer rn' Schroodor expressed the opinion that tho uxperioonts would cause injuries to the health of the axperiasntrl subjects. Before this nuctirv., id Professor Schrooder knw about the plm for those experiments? n. No, ha uac inforoed only after th. discussion. I hear* this statement of the Prosecution too. I think the nanos were confused: it shoul* have boon “Becker-Freysong and Schaefer," or it rr.y be that since it says Chief of the itedicr.l Service, otc., that ni ht have confusad hin. Tho Pro*, cut ion th-ught that it wc; tha chief of the n-dic-1 service. Dr. Sohroodor, personally. In Ger r.n military t-.rwlo-y it was custxaary to :r.e-k of the office, to fry Chief of tho lidic-1 Service nd Chief of the Intelligence Servic-, etc., nwanii^ the ofifico not the rxrson in charge hims-If. .itr.se, . ill you say whether you ectuaiiy aa :« the statement in this document *nd held the point of view reproduced h-re? o\. x t is true that cr. Lay 19th I made a brief speech »syi«; 7994 22 uej A7 -_-12-3-Meehan (vc« Schon) Court So. 1 roughly wnat wc had said three necks before to the Technical Officer in writing. I said more r less that Dr. ven Scrany's experiments in Vienna did not saec valid to us because they contained a number of mistakes, but I would like to go into a state-sent contained in Schrocdcr's afiicanit, that I said Serany 1 s experiments wero not strict enough. In ay opinion, Scrany's experiments were stricter end aoi*> dangerous than those which wore later carried out under air responsibility. In Scrany's exporirtnts, every subject could drink as nuch as to wanted. This caused diarrhea, which sr.de the thirst much wor» and tUsdcarrhoa was not included in Scrany's rocords cl tho experiments. In ay speech, I said when speaking on sx* definite experiments subject of Dorcny's that if this oxp^ri.*;ntal subject, who drank ecau&tor • for four days, had jorv. -n in t.*v rv-xt few days to drink as nuch Kanator, he would have loot so much water because «f diarrhea that after about six days ttoro would have boon serious cawequonces. 1 unfortunately forced to mko o vorybriof physiological rco rk on this subject in order to ocplain -hat will folios. Tho human b-xly ccnsista to .\ very great percentage f water. Tho body :»/ a n-w bom child io 90* water, this water gradually lessons in a norsr.l adult to .bout 60 % water. Tils water is in p.-rt in the body tissues nd is kept constant as a permanent supply. In addition to this supply of body water, we also have the so-called transport wator, which we take in daily with ur food and which » eliminate daily. This elimination is in part by respirtaion, ir. part through the akin, but the majority is through tho kidneys. In our fo.d, ingest daily a quantity of salt which must be eliminated, also Li nets bo li an a number of products are created which must bo elLiinatod through the kidneys. F r this reason tho kidnies rt-ed a certain amount of water. Ttoy ne_d water because thffy arc -bit to eliminate urine only up to a certain concentration of 3alt. If I now give the body either too much salt or too little vr.tor, then the normal transport will be insufficient for the kidneys tnd they will be forced to use the water supply of tho body itself. 7995 22 Kay LI -1*-12—okp- Me-bin (von Schoa) Court Soj 1 Mow, if the net or in the body tissues has b-en reduced to a cv.rt-.in limit, t a,a feel thirst. At least, that is on« reason for thirst. „ loss of body water up to about 10 % can be s us t tine a without any danger. At 1C£ disruptive syaptcas begin, the tenger increases up to 20 %, arri if tho loss of water of the body reacts about 20 % thon there is a cort'in danger of death. I should like to point out me thing in connection with the cxp.rin-nts under discussion hero. I h?ve r.lruady said in Sorany's experiments diarrhea occurred because Sorany let his experiment subjects drink unlimited quantities if swruater of nhich the unpleasant taste had boon covered by 3*.rk-'tit. It is $o norally kru»n that in diarrhea large quantities of liquid axe lost. That was our preliminary argument ap'inst ajrk.itit. It slight soon that tho Pros-cution is right in saying that I call-d the 3erkntit -xp.rio.nta ^ry dangerous, but that is not tho case. I said that the use of Eirtetit In practico in distress at s-a was- very dangeroxs far tho following reasons. If civ. looks at the reports of cases of distress at oca, and there aro sxa. very good English descriptions, orvo observes generally that shipwrecked pers-ns first try to go withxxt drinking at all for mo or two days. During thisti/no, of course, they lose ur.tor and they become acre rxl aoiv thirsty. Finlly thvy cannot atr. nd tho thirst and under those conditions they drink wh-at they have in unlimited quantities, that is, soawater. In this condition, seawater cm ir.vo v-ry dangerous consequences. Cases havo been described 'here after mly a few hours r. very &>rious conditi n was caused, 'nd evon sx*. times with fatal consequences. THE HtSSIDSi.T: Hitrxss, at this tine ysi will have to suspend tho discussion until after recess. (A r-cess was token until 1330 hours.) 7996 /M] May 22 -..-DK-13-1-Fostor (Int. rfeanlor) Court No. i .jTiuw.;; 3Z3JIUS (The hearing reconvened et 1330 hours, 22 U ay 19*7.) TH-i M.--wrookod person in a oonplotoly diiod out 3tato eftor having suffered thirst for a numbor of days, is drinkinj sv,a viator. -nd I further said that accord in;; to tho njroorxont nado by all exports in this fiold, tho er3or. in this driod out state 3uffcr3 c nsidcrnbly and th.*t his orpnnisn can tltroforo al 3 o bo considerably decayed. Tho danflor of 3orkatit was soon by us in tho following: The borkntit a super like drug whioh has tho capacity to-tic away with tho bitter and 3 nlty taste of soa wator and to convert tho sen water into . drinkable.liquid. Th« person in son enorfconcios with'^tfcAdd of jcrkr.tit will bu able to prepare a certain Y?.\ • anount of drinkable son \v;t-r. oinco, however, Jerkatit does not chai;o the salt content of the soa water, tho Oy / ship wrecked .arson ,-ftor scco tiua will, of course, booono ohir3t^-^nd ajnin with tho aid of his eorketit will try to drink son water. He apein intreduoos a considerable anount 7997 May 22-..-3K-12-2-?ost a r (Inc. Jiamlor) Court No. 1 of salt inco his body which oust ojain bo eliminated fron hi3 body end, since, by and larjc, the wator which is nin.ulod with the salt is not sufficiont, ho will ;ct aoro end noro thirsty as tiao joes on and thereby will be jin to drink increasingly larger amounts of son water mixod "ith dorkatit. ..s soon as ha starts drinking aoro than 300 cubic contir.otcrs r.t one tino diarrhea will or oust onsuo. Not only will ho lc3o water through tho bladder but also as a result of diarrhea. This moans that tho thirst condition oinroasos and at tho so;* tine tho dan .-or of bo in; thirsty. Ono could naturally say that one could prcscribo oxactly how nuoh 3on wator c :n bo drunk oixod with borkatit. Thoro is no nood for a Ion; discussion in stntin ; that a shtp- v/rooked person findin; hiasolf in an ocoan full of son water which he allowedly can nako potable, by tho uso of Jerkatit, can not be credited with a sufficient aiount of 3olf di3ci.line in actually ndhorinj to this do3o as it was officially proscribed. ..t any rate, such cn assumption oan not bo r:ado tho point of do.arturo 0 f any ailitory dir^otivo. This i3 tho bis danger of iiorkatit in tho soa oacrjoncy .;ractico. Entirely different, howvcr, aro tho conditions for tho b^rketit oxpcrir.ont. If I start to spook ceout tho axporiment which we carried out without cuch ado, tho situation wo3 a3 follows: 22 I'ay li7-A-nTD-li.—1-Cook (Int. Raaior) :ourt Kb. 1 ^hiring this experiment tho entire aaount of sea water with or -..it tout berkatit had been deterined baforehand. The mount of the individual dcs&go vras pre-detor.inod in such a saonor that ir. no case could diarrhea result. That was very sinple because only had to keep tho individualcdosage under 300 cubic centimeters. In addition, there was always a physician Present during the oporinent, who was in a position to observe and Judge tho condition of the oxpcrinentr.l subject and could always interrupt at r.ny somont this artificial sea distress condition by sla ly vivin" ar?in nomal water to each exp.riivmtal lubjcct. Thoro is a vary clear .and absolutely logical difforonco for the exp'.rt betwoon the application of Sorkatit durin; tho actual oxpori'inco of soa cttstrosrmhoro tho shipwrecked person is 3'dnrd.ng in his rubber boat senowhoro in tho aiddlo of tho ocoan all alono and tho oxporirvjnt undor poraanont adequate oodical control and cxact pridotorrdrod conditions which tako into consideration all of the Laapors I Just d scribed. During tho conforenco on 1? nd 20 May 19U», in order to rov.rt back to our original docunnt, I had to instruct tho ‘.achniciara and angin^ors, who al30 oro participants in this tooting, about the retter as I Just described it. Vory soon I noticod that I had doscribod it in such a way as to really r.akc it clear to tho engineers it the danger of Borkatit act- .>ant. For vory understandable propaqandistic reasons T tharofor- aaintod i ly black. I told those on-ir. ors that -.*0 radical nen very ••oil kno.: tha extrnoly sorlous consepuonco3 of thirst and tho loss of water. know it fror. . 'fory danjorous sickness, reooly, the cholera. In ord^r to avoid any • labor ri sun dor starving I ray no-- state that naturally th -ro is eon- ; idorablo difference between the consocuoncos of soa wntar and tho* thirst and tho cholera. ' cave this ixanplo, only to rescind these P-oplo of cholera, sinco particularly during this illness continuous liarrhea results, and a groat los3 of water ensues as a result of those iarrhaa attacks, -fhich in turn provokes 3erious disturbances in the cr^anisns ahich ray load to death. I quoted verbatim during this aeeting, 22 'lay U?—A-t-TD—lii—2-Ccok (Int. Gamier) Court So. i what * a kT>ir ‘ abo " t fcfca ioss Of inter in tho ease of cholera as contained in tho text book of internal nedicir.o by Bergnaim. I at that tine *ns in the possession of that book and I had read it through before. I an ovoa new in a position to road to you the sane passages. ; "itness, you just speaking of Bergaann's text book. I sh have it handed to ycu and I say ask ycu to read tho passages to which you have Just referred into tho record. A •'0 are concerned with tho text book for internal nedicino by Asarann, Bachnann and Gustav Von Borgmrm and a nuubor of other rrofoosors, jxiblishod by Julius 3prir*er, Berlin Edition of 19Ji2 — aiTOXi ’4ay it ploaso your Honors, it secras to no that this tochnical argument concerning tho qualitios of tho-8orta Method ia rather oxtonoivo ard it seono to no that tho dofondant can got to tho issues involvod in this case without going through all of this tochnical argu- aor.t and discussion. !io doubt thoro is room fer a considerable amount of this discussion toro. Borovor, ho has covorod quite a bit of ground nor and fcho i3suo in tho caso is -^V-l5-3-K=rrwr(Sa=3or) Court Ko. 1 Then tho litter continuesi °Tho experimental l cries are to cerr?isa tho following:" hoover ra the flutter of that letter, hen could he know on tho I$th, T.*hat the ccrriasicn ~hich tta 3 only bo appointed on tho 20th nuld L :oido on tho 25th. 2 0 yond that, tho author of that 1) ttor r~s not cron a physician* Otherwise ho wouldn't have bocncfcle to entertain -_~j- auoh thoughts* T hiaran wasnoroly a technician who crobabiy never in his lifo hao porforaod a ncdioal o^jcriront. You rcrc, furtioriuro, rsldnc OP such a oocrlssion wao nccopoary ard rriy tho ex.: - inontal conditions couldn't ha vs bcom'ctcroincd already cn the 20th, That had tho following reasons. During tho conf. reive-s on tho 20th of 3’ey besidoa a very young captain ~.t tho Qntal conditions bo determined in tho prosonco of thoir ropro- :er.tativos * 0. itnoGS, in that caso I o an soy that t!»c cenforonco of tho 25th of d-y, Iplili, rouid have boon ontiroly aupcrflucus, ovon sonsolosu, if, on the 19th and tho 20th of -fey, suoh iocioions ab ut tho experimental renditions liad alroaiy been made. In other words, it ”a3 to doj.-ond upon die prcsoncc of Eppingor and a number cf other null 'norm scientists dooidc upon tho final conditions f:r the experiments? Is that ::rroct? i*os, that is correct, V, The conditions for those medical cxp.i-cntscouidonly bo determined y the nodical representatives cf the respective agencies, 'ho was to eoo5 1 22 ~ay 67-A-ST,'—15-6—Xarror (Eadbr) C:urt Ko. 1 bo assigned for that purpeso f ren the different agencies? A. Tint car. be seen on pro 3 the original document eMLOh I haro before no in photostat fom. It says that the cession ras to inolude Professor Eppingor, v icnna; roprocontativos of tho af-onc;.- cf tho Chief of tho ihdical Sorvico; roTosontatives of tho Toohnical Office; and representatives of tho High C axrtld of the Uavy, o.* 3 :. Didn't you discuss oxporinonta at an cn tho 19th of :hy? 8006 22aloy (int. amacr) Ctvrt I — --tur^ly. cxpcrincr.ts vcro discus icd. I told tr.o- in m vox;.* ,c :or .-2 —d understandable wcy for all the lcynon present thoro, end * ith- ut ;ol:.~ into jy physiological or oxporinoatal questions th. t a numbor coyorl~cat.il groups would h_vo to oc act up If tais question could oo colvod oxpcriacntally at nil. I appro xi natoly said vh.-.t vould bo tc ©-Try out such an experiment J aeries. I certainly e id that or.o jroup would h_ve to be treated with the 3exfcatit procedure,. .\sd I corCnin ..uat have mentioned th_t it would oo oayvdient for puroooos of c:upc\rieo.i to leave out ono group entirely, und naturally I also must .V.vo arid taut it vould bo noccss-ry to havo a so-called control group :t *&lch normal drinking viator waa to oo given. What, however, I certainly did not aey v..s th..t u nuuber of e^oriment-1 grape ahould io li ited to six doya at tho moat, and on tno other hand no aporluon- :rl group ahould bo limited to 12 days. iko aim of those o:q>arlzonto, :ftor ell, wot to dotumino tho timo durir,; which 3orkatlt son vator oculd bo consumed. If I must for once assuuo tho credit which \/no .r ntod mo oy tho Prosocution initially to the effect thut they ndmittod I Woe young, but to a certain extent an oaporioncod eoionbiat, I "ill asaumo it nor*. I novor nu . osted any rich experiment..! neneonoo, r/. novor would nuve done ao. If I carry out an ox?ari..ont in ordor to find out tho toloranco of an *rgjerlmunt_l subject towurda a cortaln rag for any particular length of tiuo, it lacks tho moot primitive logic *.9 determine already ..t tno voxy be.tinning how ling this cxjcri-e-.it '.6 to last. If so I could h„vu saved mya-lf the entiro experiment, die timo us to how long thuso experiments could or should bo carried : .rov,li naturally primarily depends upon the -nou.it of aoa water consumed. .3U, this oo-cailed "minutes" of this discussion was laid down by c - Irymm, and only a complcto layman is in a position to derive :eroly tho fact teat one drinks sou water dally. Can derive a dehgor from f-.ct th~t one drinks sea w_ter daily, any such st~taJt.it cin only --vo sense and ro_scn if it is stated how ouch sea w_tcr i6 to bo consumed 3CC7 22 1.,rv?- 16 - 2 -i. -lev (P-oalor) Cctrt I ..-•aria. that tl-o. If, for instance, it vas said hore; *:cnlc c.Mjined 500 cubic centimeters, or 10000 cubic ccntiaotcrs d-ily, cr any other figure, and if there had been stated tfc-t enfor tnis special ccq>cri.icn- »ol condition the expected duration of the exooriuont is so and sc dry*, then this sc .cement would-have the merit of n cort-in amount of sense* It constitutes, of course, a tremendous -mount of diffcrcnco -aether I carry out the experiment witn a sli.^t -mount of so., vat or or cncn.oua amount of ae_ v rt tcr; but do lot ..e point t t.-.o following ir. this docu.-ont; undor I, 'a" it is stated, md I quoto: "Peoplo nourished with 3orfca se- w>tcr -prccoeduro. ■ a little fart nor oelow it nays, "Period of oxtorinont 6 days at tho most". Immediately undorno.-.th it says, “ ooplo to who., soa Water and Jorhatit was introduced," .nd so orth, and thor. it says, "Poriod of the oxoerluoat 12 days." Had I av. cotcd *n oxporiuoct to 1 -st over 12 days then I certainly tnuldr-'t v rixy I should have su gosted the other experiment to l.nt only : d-j-c. hhutevor I could have derived freo the oaQtorlncnt which .-llo odiy should tjco 12 d.ya, would h-vo also includod what w.ld h.v.-c ha^poned in the first six d^rs of this aatiro poriod cf 12 days. For nny physician »*io has only the most primitive ia-glnatica of on ccnoviucnt it lo entirely out of tho question to read any sense out of ..'.is so-called cxnerimontal plan. In conclusion, I ~.y t-y th_t noith^r or. tho occ-sion of tho oon- foronce of tho 20 or 25 of *.ay in the presto of Profosoor al> in\or, n. 1 . ti..o Halts were determined throughout i£;ich tne .jcporL.cr.ts woro tv bw conducted, or when these experiments wore to oo interrupted. eo- C.aisO thes'6 very d-tvs were to bo exceeded experimentally, isn , t th t correct? Yes, th t is true. 0 , Witness, during these nc. otiaticr.a .--id duri.n trio no.otintion Cf the 19th cf koy 1944 w_s there any mention i-ado of tho selection of the experimental subjects; w..s it e-id expressly th-t these were tc bo 22 16-3-b-loy (let. ?„ler) Crrt I ; shod by tie Hcichsfuehrcr SSI a. lit3 proocs.il V -5 not c„dc on tne 19th of Hoy 19^-:, xtf th..t c I stated npproxic.itCI 7 the following, I said tu.t tho osporiuonts i>.:ich hod now once uoro become necessary should naturally bocarriod throu-ii under tho responsibility of the cr.icf of the kedic.,1 Sorviccs for uno.ubitlvoly wo ar. here concerned with a nodical uattor. In Jobrucry or ;,..rch 1944 I had pcrfoiuod cy own experimental worlc in jorlic. To bo sure -t th-t tiuc I didn't work on huena experimental persons, out on cnic_ls, out at th..t ti.:o I v .s „ctivc in ny nodical research institute, _r.d experienced tho cnoxvicut difficulties which conditioned the execution of scientific work un?or the streos of doily rlv attacks on jorlia. I therefore know exactly Just how difficult oar oxccutloa of experiments w^j in tr.c cursor of 1944 and in parti¬ cular L'. her! in. In .Edition it vj cioar to no amroxiuutoly ho\f nsajr persons would havo to oo secured for this e xperimont if it w o to bo c..rrled through. I think that at tfa.t ti«c I ostlu-tod that about 20 or 30 experiuent.a subjects would be noodod. IXirlng tho confornnco of tho 2 - th wo h_vo found out that wo would nood to jroxlu.-.toly 40 xyo;l..out-l subjects for th..t ounooo. In addition it w o clo.\r to ao th .t tho experiment -would h-vu to oo continued for abo t i UOOks vith¬ at any interruption because oof ore tho sou w ater oxppri.-ent prep or .nd aftor tno so., v-tor axporir.ont propor, tho experimental subjects Would h:.vo to undergo a pre or S ter^-bsorv .tion. For th t ro son I considered it my duty to point out to tho ;o irticlpahto in tho ..eoting cn tho 19, 20 and 26 th-t it would probably bo oxtroioly difficult to U tho aoccss-ry experiment.I subjects for such experiments. I'a7 22--.-3K-l7-i-::c-har. (let. jtonnlor « Von Schoon) Court No. 1 >*e did not have tho basical order in the Lurtwaffo to the effect that soldiers wore not to bo used for ox. orixaonts, as it existed in the arcy. Jbctrenoly often we used soldiers for experiments. I booceo increasingly difficult to jot such soldiers for any lonath of tine and I thoujht it to bo out of the question to jot forty soldiers for such an experiment fra: anywhere. The sane was truo in tho oa3o of pationts in hospitals. ..t tho end of 19-13 or bejinninj of 19-14 a nunbor of re ,-ulations had boon issued by tho O.X. .. to tho effect that tho stay in military hospitals of soldiers was to be United to tho similest oxtont and as far as it could bo Justified medically, which meant that not ovon this possibility could bo considered. The Prosecution asked Gonoraloborstnb3arzt Prof. Sohroodor during tho cress examination whothor ho considered it possiblo that in tho year of 1944 - whetiier we could obtain 40 experimental subjects in Berlin, a oity of four and u half million inhabitants. Germany in the year of 19-i-i was aunist total war faro. ..nyono who has not oxporioncod that on hi3 own body con not ;rasp tho situation which then pro vailed. S’ron tho . oint of view of personnel, tho situation ut that tico was such that practically every nan capable to boar arns had boon dr of tod into the ./ohrnacht and all others, ovon wo nun had boon used for some kind of lebor. Sven tho youth3, fiftoon or sixteen years old, were used as either ack-nck assistants or in tho labor sorvlco. Naturally in Berlin, considerin'; the four end ono half nil? I a inhabitants wo could hc.vd raised 40 people on which wo could havo porforasd these ex. orinonts, but who would tftoy hove -eon? ..t tho nost, 'kj could have jotton sorx! women, who wore » ins. irod b y a will to sacrifice themselves, or sonu ill pooplo, or soco younj boys and jirls of a very youthful aje. Thu 3 e •'-re all experimental subjects who in no way could have- 8010 "ay 22 —--3IC-17- 2 -Aeolian (Int. senior i Von Schoon) Court No. 1 conformed to tho conditions, ilxpariuental subjects, who had the corresponding a^e, no one could have found in tho y'szx of 19« and none of then could have received lonvo fer four wooks froc their office or work place. . .'ell, how was the thoujht finally entertained to use prisoners for thoso oxpericcnts? .. On the 19th of clay I pointed out theso difficulties briefly, tho difficulties I have just described and on 19th May this question renoined^ open. Then i/inodintoly after tho discussion ondod, while I wa3 still in Christonson's offloo or in tho corridor, I talked to one or several of tho on^inoers who hed been present and one of us pointed out that at that tine in Jerlin conpanius of prisoners wore usod to cl-ar away dobris of building which had been dostroyed by boubs. That was sonothinG that was faulliar to everyone in Jorlin at that tirso and tho ..risonors, who v/oro scon at that t ino in their striped suits woro tho very pooplo whor. we oould uso for our oxporinonts. Evory Jorllnor saw in tho stroots in those d ay3 thoso youn-j non, twenty, thirty or feurty yor.rs of nee, healthy stron*’ and capable of work. One of us, naybo it was cysolf, I don't rononber, ronarkod that thoso wero tho people free whor. one could cot a few volunteers for such an oXporinent. How, tho referent of Chri3tcn3cn, Stabs-En inocr Schick- ler, referred to this renark in the oeotinc on 20 th of Hoy and asked nu as it is st-tod in this record, since ho had: consulted no about tho nectinj of tho 19th and 3inco he hinsolf sail it ’./as vory difficult to jet ox. orinentcl subjects. Schickl.r 03ked no son3thinc like this: "Dr. bockcr- rreysenc, yesterday we discussed another possibility co ;et out of this difficulty of finding' oxporicontal subjects; would you present your idea to thoso ..resent in this nee tine aj-in?"I said that I considered it pbssiblo. v’-" 22-—3X-17-3-J:cjohon (Inc. Scaalor & Ton Sahoon) ..o. 1 IT -.11 other sources for ex.orir.ental subjects dried u , wo 0 ul'I ix3k the oon-jetent authorities for ;risonors for ox- - -'fir-ont .1 subjects. I said that was u;j to the chief of th: -.’ouical oorvicc, tut wo would try to have the ox;>ori- aonts c.jriud out in our own office with our own *>o;:lw and if that v/es not possible, wo would try to find other subjects. That was assuuin; that the discussion on the 25th of lisy actually onfu, to the exclusion that the ox.oriuonts woro actually to be carried cut. ' ./itnoss, how do you fool about the ox. lanction 'sivon by tho ; orsor. who drew u., this r^. ort for the chart of the laboratory in baohau? - -ou .robably noan tho basis, 3inco tho chief of tho aediocl service ex;* 20 ts certain dnr.a .30 to hoalth and there- * :or ' ;;co:Ie should bo taken free a oonoontration can 4 j. • Yob, that i3 tho basis I noon. 22 ihy hi -wlS-l-pkp- Gross (v_r. ochon) Court Sj, 1 A. Hero the n n-audlC 1 writer of this report has confused two jr -too three thin-s which hcv- nothing to do with one -r.oth-r. First. • • of 11 :u has confused the danger of Sorlr.tit in practise with the -ofl-lat® safety X the saa. drug in cn -xp-ria:r.t. And tfton he confused thiatihoL: cr.ttcr with purely organisational difficulties. Inth& suasor of 19W. in Germany finding forty healthy y-ung men as subject a for an exp-ricont which would last four weeks and besides I think that this am did not rtalito whr.t ho was writing. And, as a Laymen there is o or haps something mm actional in having to do with the subject of human oxperim-nts. C. itnoss, 1 go on in th. document. I skip the next paragraph. It speaks for itself. Thu next two sentenc-s r. page 3 ^f th> documont I shall queto: "In regard to tta. silver problem GL/C - E 5 IV will deteraino whotlvr the n-cessary amount of silver is available. With GL/C-D 5 it is to bo determirv-d .whether the sam. quantities will bo required .as heretofore." '..ill you please caua-nt on that? A. Yes,l cm cament Very briefly bee*us- I have ruforr-d to it before. At tlx, tii. I this meeting I said that the alleged 2.5 to 3 tons of silver required was a @-oss exaggeration and the technical office had to dait that rd promised to check the affair '.gain, Q. Then what con you say in c nclusi n on the point f tho d .cuirwnt? A. Tr» whole document? Yes, I moan this last passage. You h; vo already 3poke ’.bout the re-St if it. A. It is the admission of th, technical office that tho 2.5 to 3 tons of silver is an -xag^eratim. You h ve said already that that would bj necessary only f ivtho first equipment. /». Yes. h. N «, I coo. -o the second p-rt of the doc urn-at dealing with the conforen c-- of the 20 Hay 19AA. The list of participants is on P“gc r>- of the docunmt. I should likuto ask you did you know those 8013 22 ILzy LI Gross (v* Schon) Court 1 :-n who c =v ir--a the Navy? A. No, I teen none f ttese K-vy n-n nd I did not kn« , ns the doea*.nt indicates, that tte technical office S the Luftwaffe- ted previously discussed the some subject with the Navy becausu it is *sun hvrv that Schickl-r reported -.bout the -work eon-, since th. test discussion. Since we ted ted no discussion previously with the technical office it could only be discussions with thv Navy which v.r. orrriod on behind our back. l/itnoss I shell nn quoto t he first paragraph : "At tho orin conference or. 20 May 19U, Captain Xng. (itabsingonicur) Dr. Schicklor reports on work done s ince tho test conference especially regarding tte r-sulta of the pre limin'ry discussion described in part Ka. I." You tero just sold that Hr. Schickler jpico ; t the second meeting. K-v I would like to -sk you - it s-ys here that ho reported on work dorx. since tho last conference especially reg'rdin^/.ho results -f the preliminary d iscussi.r.. Did y.u kn * f *ny conference before the one if 20 lt*.y 19iU,? A. K , I just arid th‘t I ted knsin of no discussion betwocn tho technical iffico *rd the Kavy, Q. No the neat paragraph contains the Navy*s point .f view. It ar*id th-t tho Kavy considered it important to introduce the awthod i.-xiedi tely, ate wants to f ir.d something good for three to five days, h't do yai havo to say 'bout th-t? A. I oust go Vck to p-g* one of th- docurrent briefly. Ute-or nunb-r L thero is a Marine Str.bsarst Dr. Laurens who c-ao fr«n tho ffico of tte C mandor Adair-.1 of Sufco-rinos in Kiel. The Navy hrd planned if possible to g-t all th- drinkinj water supplies for the submarines by :ne f tte new methods developed by the Luftwaffo. • Cir.co r. wtrrrinc is -t a-a for longer than three to five rirys it is ovious th-t this statement were proof that the writer failed to understand the pr blert. Hot only every Navy expert but every»e els- wh- thinks -r.ic n-.tter thr-.utfi carefully will agree with n« no doubt if I say that 8011 22 ~\y 47 -*-13-3- --cp- Gr.ss (va Scbon) Court No. 1 precisely in the Navy there is great interest ir. i lading s uch a process. While the Luftwaffe had nly very snail life b its in its pl'nss, rubber lifo r-fts, tr*i Hivy ard the Submria-s hive life boats which re nuch larger, where. 50, 60 or oren 100 pe.pL> can use then. Or.e rved aiercly open *ny book reporting a ship wreck, one will sec that such lifo boats if the Navy .ire -ft-n 30 ^r 40 days at aor. bof:ro they roach lard. Th. tr^lish who hive been soif.aring oc.pLo for centuries hrvo .vny very clear reo;rts on that subject. If the Luftwaffe wish.s ship wrecks f course within r. certain limitation frnthu Lin:’, biso md have bwjn satisfied with tiree to fiv. d-jrs this limitation of three to five days would hav~ n. sense f r th. Navy it all. I don't kn,w what th- writer w.s thinkirg, at Lnst he didn't write down whit wr.s actually said. Now, lid 0;- Novy c-nsider Sirany's exporin-nts sufticient? A. Th't is given h-re ir. this dwcuomt nd in th. second place, it least, the rwpret ntatives >f the Navy who wore present said they * uld consider Sirany's experiments sufficient. In dditi r. to this St.absrrzt Laurens. Notv )f then w oxv d ctors. I sh-11 explain later th.t certain pc plo in the Navy did n t think these vxperinonts "decjii te tut durin this discussion represent-tives of th- Navy said Sir-ny's experiments Were ad.qu-to. Q. K n, I cxw t; the rv-xt froblon, -nd I quote: "These Series of experiments should be finished and reported n r.»t later then the one' of June. During this period all prepare tins ire to be cr.do for the coanenceOwnt f production according to the Berk: rvthod a t a date not later t*rn July 1st 1944, and Is., if ihj I.G. ncthjd should b- introduced, 1 r th- start f th. construction of th. rveessary mnul'acturing equipo-nt by the I.G." On y u cocrient on this. Wore th-se points diccusm-d in this fore during this conference? A. No, rd if li>_y had been discuss. ' I would have objected so violently trr.t they would probably n t be given in h-re, but a -ybo =015 * 22 lay L? -A-i:--A-pkp- Gr-ss(v;n £ch n) Z art 8}. 1 they w.uld be. On the first July the Berks cuthod is t a be in production. At tho s’ao tine th, bogiming of the construction ,f tho manufacturing equipment is t. bo h-gun for the other sothod. This iniic'tos to a: tho -..-hole prejudice and unpractic -1 spirit f th- p roar. ■ho wroto this. _ The ntet paragraph denis with the oo.ple , r . this c aoissi zi y m have just a.rfclaru*i who were to acct lator -nd determine the series f uxp.rl^nts. Is this list of the Member : f the c.acdsrion here. correct? A. Yes, no ruvaos re new except ?r foss;r Eapingor. It is terdly possible to .t.I® -ny mistakes, th,rofon.. I nsy point -ut tho folljiing: • As rupr«jsontntivc f th. Uodic-1 Service Stabsarzt Dr. 3ccl;.n-Froyseng ispr vi-led. 1 ' That was the pinion r porticps the w ish f this .ffico. In reality ay c'op rtmer.tal chief was To sent ,n the 25th. I wan with hla, that is true. T-.sii'oa after I h->d rto^rted t ay dopartraontal chief when I returned to th. .fficu he erid th*t -we w.uld ask two thor scier.tisto to participate at this nccting. First, the Profossor fo r • Pharanc,1 jgy at tho University ,f Berlin - Prjfoss r Heubner, an*, th.. Profos av for Physiological Chenistry at tho University at Kiol— Professor Kotto. Tien it gives here as r> vesentntivo of the ?Jr.v” Profess.r Oralchowaki. Unf-rtunately tho K'vy inf .mod ?r .fossor Orzichowski se late that h, did n t, attend the noting hinoolf. I nay also point .ut that this s-c.m* iiscussi.n n the 25th was n tho jrdur ef my dopartaBiital chief in Berlin. hile it was originally to t-kc place in Munich because f Pr.fcss r Eppingor who had tj c.e .all tho way fr*a Viannasince cy doparto-ntcl chief wanted t: bo oro3on t at this ate-ting laiaaelf, since Profe3s.r rkmbtr fra Berlin wh: was to bo present anc Profess.* Hctte fr a Kiel, it was n.r. sensible to h w the discussi.n at 3--rlir. - which happened. Q. Km, rdtncss, -chat -b ut the sentence in peronthwsos which aentions a tele an. conrorsati.nwhich yon rr_ supposed to hav. had on tao basis f hich -he pi c_ f the -..tir.r was chrng.d frn iQmich to sorlin, do y:u r.c-U anything abo ut this tclcph^.o canvorsteiao? &016 22 11-7 47 -A-iS-5- pkp Gr ss (v n Schon) C.urt K-. 1 A. S-s, I rocccber this telephone c 11 but it c-uhi h Vv boon at the earliest .r~ day ' ftcr the retire, th-t is ,n the 21 st. And I don't knar ha/ it c ould be put in -n alleged r-cord f what happened ont he 20 th. Then, again ir. y ur >pini n this is -pin or oof h-w light- heartedly this record was drawn up and that it dies n t give the ix al course ;f the thing. • A. 'I -roally that w uld have had to bo r. supplesv-nt to this record. Q. itness, thu report goes on to say. I quote: "Dachau was deternined as tho place f the experiments", ’.Jho determined that and what do y u have to say ab ut it? A. Nibody dutorained it and nobody c tils' d-ternin. it. There was n-t a single representative jf any officer there »h- had -nything to do with concentration c-aps. That would have hod to bo • representative of a high Police Agency of the Reichofuehrer-SS or the Reich Ministry f Interior, It is quit-j possible that that is based n tho f Uo./ing cistckos or the foliating facts: Everyone present realised tlrt experinents with prio-rxrs could n-t be porferrv-d in any pris n .r penitentary and probably -u of the people present wondered how this w.uld be don. technically. Then I no d ubt told him what I know - that 1 knew there were laboratories in Dachau an! that I. c.ulc iaegin- that if uic c-uld obtain prisoners the experlo-nts c uld be purforraed in tho Laboratory rooos of the caap.it Dachau. I know of then because of tho Nurnberg Sea Distress rnd Cold neeting. Q. Hod you over b-en in Dachau y urself? A. N , I have never been in Dachau. Q. N-Wj . itness, the nxt s-ntencc in the d. cunent says that y u did get in tough with Pr jfess.r Eppinger an’ the P.oichefuchrer S3, is* t hat c -rroct? A. It is a fact cnyhaw that Profess-r Lppingvr was informed by our ffice probably by teL.gr-.rn -r telephone to the Vienna Medical' office, 'rr’ I nsauau tr.-t thu writer of this report did not a.an that I did get 6017 22 hr7 47 C-r-.ss (v n Sch r.) -.art . . 1 Jr. toqgh -it.: the Huichsfu«hrer-SS porsjc ll/ b-c?.use I did r. t "r. Killer. Ho jjrobr.bly n^-ns ttet if - ny contact his necessary it » '-Id be wflt blisheC thr.ugh tK, ffice _f th- Chief .f the liccic'l i.rvicu t. ihich I belonged. Did ”-u r. t sry th-t the responsibility f^r the planning nd execution if tho exoeria-nts would hr.v_ ti b- with the Chief if the lledic-l Service' C013 22 ’ny-h-OSS-19-1-r^ rrw (Int. . - Sch >r.) C urt ’■ . 1. ... In view f the oxraria'nts which :tr. v n Sirnn” had carried ut n his -wn initiative, and because f the — ri us ther ex; jr- ionccs with the Technic 1 Cffio? which .iro testified t >y the offi- • it f Dr. Boinrieb sc which tec been . fforod in evi , I said that these ox;or’.rvrts war* a pirely no !ical nr.ttjr nr.d th :rof re vuld, f c urs , fall un'er tho res. nsihility f a nodic -1 ffico. Q. “itness. it is r. w noocssory t discuss tho dist-riluti n list f fin d c*in nt, rioc.sc 1 1 c at it raid tell nc whether th, .ffiooa listed there were -.ctuclly otr.cermd with tho qu--tti na ■’iscussyi ct th"»so n ".tin's, r int< rested ir. then, .t 1 ast? ... First, there are throo Vary ffices ah ut which I kn w n thin-, v ut since the Kevy was raj-resented I qssubo th * theso ffices wore interostod. Tho .0search Instituto of tho *:DL '.nd OBDL w.a the Luftwaffe aponcy e ncornod with tochniccl r sonreh. Siwo I wna n t referent f r research nt the tiro I d n’t kn w vhothor tho referent Dr. Eonsin.’or was into ro stud r not. Lutor, fr ra tho files which 3 t k 'wr, I sow th'.t this ffico had n thin,- to do with the , r blun. Than it lists L. In. 16. That w s tho Insjeet rate f the Luftwaffe, II . 16. It was tho insjoct rato f r -*i stress t sen which was, of C' urso, interostod. . w c'rw th" ffices which wore t rot this »’ eunent f r th ir inf rmti nr K :w nb Luftwaffe nt Lochlir.; and th Institute f r i.vinti n ilodicin.- f th * D.V.L., 3. rlin-.'.dl -rsh. f. I ncod net ,• ir.t that in detail n< w, '-ot I "nr. s v f r certain iVt th:ec three offices novor dealt with ;r *blc:-03 f- oca iistross, anil T i! n't kr. w why they re list ad. I sh ulr! Ilk t-. pint ut riofly th rr.xt cffic Ls L. Ir.. K. Th-t r>:ans tr. ffic. f th* *hi of . ho n n eertni- Then c n a the So ichs fuehrer S* with wh -a tho Tochnicol Of.-ico, nt - w* nt " . led, Exhi* it 132, has ah wn h~u ’-ocn in ernt-'Ot tchir.d ur cck, ‘*:hind tho ’ack f the Chief f the I odic-.l Service, and finally, the Technic-1 .'.endony in Vionm. which want, as *-r. ’’crancy assured, lr fcaa r S.jin-.-or's ffioe, »ajt the ffic . where Borka had cerriod ut hi a ox, orients. '• Thin, what c r.cluai na can y u dr w o’ ut this jJors n wh irow ur tho distri’uti n liat? '*• I c-n nly a ay, Voctuao o nuc'or f a -oneioa ore listed which had n thin* whatever tr with tho j r Mon, ’ut that tho egonov tr which Tr. Schnofer ’-ul .nrcd, the ..Tioti n ?.C8< r.rch Inatituto, ia n» t listed; that . Id nr.r.oa were included sh~wa, at least that this dio- a li3 - *»• r. t irewn u; with tho naeoasory thor u'hncss. ;. ..n ! I my edd, kn rlod « f the subject? oa, Q. "hen witness, I can say that tho 4 cunont which w h vo lust 'iacusao' o ntoina nunur ua ine rroct stntor.cr.ts, -' 1 st rt! r.s, and c seldom? lo nona nao. :.-hcn did you f r tho first tino -,rs rvt all theso incr-rr«ot thin-s? TLirc in Kurnbor- r oorlior? ... That v.a » aVlior. Tho letter wn a si *nod ..n tho 23rd rf Toy, 19;-:. 3ir.ee ur ffico was a cut SO kilenders s uth f S~rlin »nd v;o received ovorvthi nr thr uch tho mil cr'yc urior, I nssuno that we *-t tho letter ■ r. ths 25th cf 26th or 27th. In any enso, : k w that I did net -ct tho letter, booruao it hr.d to .- thr urh ef fie ini channels in cur ffico t e, until nftor tho discuss: n of tho 25th f May, rt ft «r * - nditi' na for tho ox;orir»nt hnd boon settled in tho ; ros« nco f r f rs r ~ :ir..--r and . rT.rs-r Eeubnor and -thor jVJoplo. Tiwn I aur.- sted tr my dojnrtsent chiof that n written onsw.r Should bo sont tc tho fficc which hrd sont cut this rc; ort, pointin’ ut tho mny niatnkos. 8020 22 Jfc»y-A-GSS-19-3-Kar*rw (Van Schoon) G ort r . 1. Pnf Ttunatcly, ay surrcsti- n was r. -t accosted. It was tiid tliat the •lscussi r. n the 25th had sh-wr. h-rr the oxporinents w.ro actually to be corriod cut; I thought that the o-ntents f this d cup»Bt wore * a lcto; end, in the sumor of 1944, there ware r.rro inj-ortnnt thin~s t d< than t waste pepor.- On the next recast n f henovor, I told oithor Christensen, personally, or his ropresontativc, Schicklor, oithor 'y toloihrno r poraon lly, th't : h.d f und n nunhor f aistakes in this d curwnt, and I cskod then if thuy issued an ther such document to Iv.vo it si- nad bef ro h- nd by s no effieo which knew c r-thin,* r.V./ut tho subjoct. Q. hr. .rosidont, in this c niwcti n I wanted to offor an offi- df thoporsoa in choree .f those c.'nferoneos onrt tho si-nor f this d ounont, C or-Bnrinoor Christenson, which :ir. Chrir.tonson avo rw porsoanlly in tho Sn,-lish ooftn f 'kuonrarro. Unf rtumtoly, this in’ortont d current has n t boon tr-.nslatod yot and, thorof r , I nr. urn’ !o t ffor it in ovidonco. 3ut, in view of the fact that this is 1 orhijs tho n st ir.; rt-.nt d cun;nt in ny or.tirj case, ! nsk for ;ur- nissiT. t Bubnit this Christenson affidavit lr.tor in a so. plorwntory decunont l k ns s.on as tho En-lish translation is ovnilaUo. I Bhoild like t- tnko the li’xirty cf ; intiir ut that Christenson filly c nfirrs everything that the witness has just tostifiod, csj-'ioially tho f ot that thi# dccuaont was written dtn by naaory by ?!r. Schicklor at lo-.st throe dn»s nftor tho r>ictin r f tho 20 th of Uov fer tho i-urposos f th- Technical Office, end thet thoro was n sh rthand rcc rd durinr th-, noctin-. I do n t wnnt t soy onythin * olso, but I should like to have purr.issicn t submit tho dccurvmt later. Vcy it plocso four H-*n r, I request that the c emont f c- unsel concerning tho Christenson affidavit be stricken (V a t?fl» ro- e rd until such tiao as the affidavit is prosontod in c«-urt. T!C I RESHEhT: ~h: c .mor.t f coins 1 is imat*,ricl. *h>: document - y 1 • fTarod as s on as th> translrti.-n is ready. If tho d cur^nt J not offered, the ctmunt of counsel will To strickon. 8021 22 ! :•) y-.. -- IS -19-4-?Ic r rnr (7 r. &hoor.) C urt *r. . 1. 22 . I'.JZt I 'Or y-ur nrin, I should li^o to rorark cnc thin,;. It is thro weeks since wo sent tfco d<-cuaoat in for translation. I ccause thf-t the Lnn.-uaro Divisi n is cwor-wrrkod. Thst is the only ex’-lo notion I con think of. I cr. very sorry, but in this natter I certainly don't hear the bkre. ?!»S .ISSUE*'?, (Interrupting): K thin - I said r.-ns noent os i.rty reflect! r. upon ooonsol. Sinvly the fact that a ocaaaat n a d.cicnent t- bo I'fforod in the Aituro is entirely imetorial. I on entirely awaro th-t the Translation Divisi n is behind in its work and it is no foult f c-ur.se 1 ot oil. *22 Hay JC-20-1-! oloy-(Homier) Court I 3- J .. . aHX: ;iay it please the Tribunal, I shall continue vith ay interrogation of the witness. v. witness, what did you do after those two mootings of the 19 and 20 of ::*y 1944? -*• These two meetings took place In Berlin, .ifter the meeting on the 20th I went back to ay office, which is I have said was about 50 kilometers south of Berlin In Saalow. I laaodl -tely reported to ay top chief, Oberstarrt Dr. Htterz, '.bout which aeetlngs he decided that Professor Jpplnger should be informed Immediately, do also decided tnat Professor Heubner and Professor Notto should be asked to attend the conference as experts for the Chief of the Medical Service. He also decided that he hlaself would attend the mooting cn the 25th, and I believe It was on the evening of the 21st of i*ay, possibly as late is the 22nd, That I o illcd up Dr. SchAfor In Berlin and asked him to l.afora Professor Heubner and asked him to attend the meeting on the 25th. That was because I knew that Dr. 3chAf-r knew Heubner personally, and of course I did not Viet to call up Professor Heubner by tjlephon and thought It better if achAfor would go and ask him p«-rson»lly. DH. ; *RX: Your Honor, this Professor Heubner who has Just been mentioned Is a scientist who still enjoys lnter- n .tlonal renown. In order to show th-.t we offer Beckei^- r’reyseng Document Ho. 10, on p ago •* cf Becker Prey song Document Bock This will bo meeker freyser.g Zxhloit 27. It Is an excerpt from the German l.edlcal -'ooKly of 17 January 19*7. I quote: “The Constituent assembly of the Scientific Senate of the German Central .administration for Public Health In the Russian Zone took place In Berlin. The Senate, consisting c: leading German scientist* and medical practitioners, is an autonomous corporation independant of the central ad- 8023 .2 Hay •7-.-.*2-20- 2-kaloy-ivan J. e r COUHT I ministration, with a self elected Board, and has Advisory CIBKS * Professor Heubner was elected chairman and Professor brugsch vice-chairman.■ I offer this excerpt as proof of how thoroughly the ques- :ion of whether these experiments were necessary was examin¬ ed. 'fitne8s, what w..s the essential content of the dis¬ cussion of the 25th of Way? .w My department chief an I hoped that it would result fron this conference that no further experl-onta would be necessary. Consequently, the first question put before tto professors, that la Profeasor Spplnger, Professor Heubner and Professor l.’ette, was whether they would regard new experiments necessary before Berkatit should bo introduced. Q. fitness, did you yourself consider further experiments neouesary? You remember th.t tno Prosocutlon at one time said that this question could hive been oolvod by a chemist In one afternoon? .v. I don't consider the rroblor. so simplo that a chemist could have solved It In one afternoon, but perhaps I may cone bacx to that later. I myself dldnot consider further oxoor- lia^ntB necessary. That can be seen from everything that I have already said on the subject, horoovor I stould like to point out that the representative of the office of the Chief of the . edlcal Service at the meeting of the 25th was not myself, but my Department Chief, who was an Oberstarzt. Q. ./as that Dr. k'aerr? A. Yes, Dr. Maerz. Q. For wheat reasons did you la ter participate In the planning and reparation for the experiments, if you your¬ self did not consider them necessary? That I did not consider these oxper lments necessary 6021 22 Hay 4?-.^«K-20^-HAloy-(Hanaalor) Court I was ay own private scientific opinion, on the basis of ay position I thought it whs ay duty, however, to participate in the planning and preparation of those experiments. Q. Witness, can you explain those official reasons or considerations which you Just mentioned? % A. I shall try to do so briefly. One nuot nako a distinction between nodical roaaons, eoonozic or technical reasons, and military reasons. DR. K.lRX: Kr. President, this explanation will take some tine. I should like to take the liberty of suggesting that wo adjourn now, beoause I personally am still suffer¬ ing a little from pains in my foot md would be vory grateful ii I oould sit down. 1.i£ PRJSIDfiNT: The Tribunal will bo in recess until 9:*0 o'clock tomorrow morning. (Thereupon a roodso was taken until o'clook Hay 2\ 1947.) &025 23 !:7-:«^-l-l-Postcr(7on Gchocn) Co-, rt No. 1 Official Transcript of the -e^ricon Vin ter? Tribunal in the not tor of the .'nited States of .uiorica, against Narl Trandt, et al, defendants, sitting at lumber", lerrrr.y, on 23 lay 0930, Justice Seals presiding# TKS HJSHil: Persons in tie can-t rocr: rill pic os a find their Tho Honorable, tho Judges of Military Tribunal I. lllitary Tribunal I is nor in session. God savo tho United Statos of .Ulrica and this honorablo Tribunal. Thcro trill bo orcLr in to courtroco. T:^ TP2SI3EM?* -lr. liarshal, y.u ascertain if t'.o aofondanta are all present in court. 183 —3EH-L! -lay it pic as o ycur \r.or, all defendants are .rcsor.t in tho court, TIE PTC JS DENT i The Soc rcfcary-C-cndrsl rill noto for tho record t!o prosonco of all the dofjndants in court. Counsol coy proco-d. Dr. Har::, if bocauso of your injury you find it inconvoniont to stand you eay conduct your onaaination aoatod. ..rrsn-jccxnta can bo raado for a . icro;-hono for you. ihoro :rill bo no objection to your oral: in- tho uitnoss fro:; a chair ins toad of standing. DTu ::jc: (Counsel for Bector-Froysons)* lr. President, I thunk you hut it Till bo possiblo for .o to stand. Hith tho remission of tho Tribunal I shall continue *riti; tJx> direct ox&iination of tho v/it:iosu, • Dr. Icckcr-Froysonc* E2C.13—TTTTZJ—S3 — p.osurud ^ SLUHXClU (Continued) DT DP.. HR" for t’le Defendant Doc’.: r-?rcysca~)i •• 1 ~‘-r,:s$ tw;jtopped yesterday rdth the question that you iron your ;»rsona 1 point of vi.r, ycur pa *scnal s cicntific point of N^SQg^o otf / tho opinion that t:»cso c:?crinonts roro not necessary 8026 23 : U7->rS -l-2-?ostcr (Von Schools) Court So. 1 but that on the basis of your office you had to participate in the preparations and plans for theso experiments. PI cos o comont briefly aid toll us what natives you folia red here. ... The lest thine I said yestorday t.*os that there were, first, medical considerations, sac r.d, cccnccicand technical considerations, fimlly, military caasiderations. Tho medical considerations affoot¬ ing no personally, I have alrcadydoscribod. I need not go into then furtlior. In contrast to my opinion, Profossor Eppinpor consid¬ ered furthor oxperinonts noce33ary in order to Cotermino rrhotiior borkatit should bo introduced or rojcctcd. I nood not go into all tho scientific reasons which Profossor "ppinjor ~avo at tho tino. I can only say briofly that Profossor Eppin'.cr had soon Dr. Von 3irony's experiments in Vionna, and in tho mooting on tho 25th of ::ay in Borlin ho pointed out that in “irony's oxrorla-nts ho had observod that cno or sovorai of tho experimental subjoctc 3irony hrd shoro a salt concentration in tho urine which was far abovo what scionco had nor.ally assumed up to that timo. Thoroforo, a number of roaaons of sciontific thoory ho concidorod it possiblo t!v»t with tho aid of borkatit tho body was onablcd to tolerate lar^o quantities of salt such 33 ora contalnod in sea water, without danaro. Sppin'jor indstod on hiapoint of viow and ho peraaadod Profossor Kcubnor, tho second important sciontist present, to join him in his opinion, -. '•itress, you have oxplainod tho nodical point cf view. That about tho technical ono? "• I touched upon that briefly yesterday. I should like to sun it up as foil Otis : if it had boon possiblo to introduco a druy just as ;;ood• as wofatit, that would havo b_on a jrcat advantage. For this reason , of courso, it Tould have to bo tested Spain. f; . :!ovr » please co into the military paint of vionbricfly. -to military point of viewin the sunmer of 19bh was character¬ ised by the fact that the Luffrraf o as --ell as the Navy wore in an 6027 23 ~r ' "-"-S':-l-3-?35tcr (Y-- schgcn) CwrtSTo. 1 uaTavarablo petition, in such a position remedies at see aro noro in xirtanfc Tor nr. air force than rhon it is victorious. On tho ot;-r hand, I havo tho point of vionthat if tho *:r-ng decision is reached tho censoquoncos 5f this rron-- decision rill be carried not bv :r. Chris to neon or tho toclnical o-'iicc or qysolf but tho flyers in distros3 at sea. lor this reason I oonoidcrod it -- absoluto duty to do cv.rythinrj to convince t-Ixc technical offico and Profosocr 7/jpin cr that b_r!:atit could not bo irtroducod. 23 May 47 -it-2-l-p»q>- Karra* (von Schon) Saort So. 1 Q. witness, yea have just said test, on tho basis of Professor Eppingsr's opinion, it was decided that further c-xperincnts were necessary. Did that solve the duties of this conference of the 25th of Hay? a. That solved one point - the question of whether further experiments wore necessary. 7; second question was how these :oc?crir>onts wore actually to to carried out. Q. The final conditions for the .xp-rlmonts tb-n did not agree with those in the letter written by tho Technical Office. Pl^aco describe briefly tho conditions ret down or. the 25th of May, 1944, but please bo as brief as possible so that wo c n get or.. A. First of all, the conditions given ir. this report of the Technical Office could never have been seriously discussed by doctors. Thu conditions decided upon on the 25th of May wore to follows: Tlie ■hole experiment was to bo carried out in varl uc .. ries of .xpcriionts# Every ocpvrinur.tcl group was t o contain sever, or eight •woplo. All the subjects nure to be given r. careful physical oerjainntion before t!>o experiojet. Boforc the expwria^nt proper, there was to be n prullnirnry period of olght to ten *.yc. Ir. this prollolnory period the subjects her- to be kept under crrvful observation and also t.vy ■ere to be fed with the fliers' rrtion necessary urin and blood t-sto w.re to be t- kon ir. ttais prelinin ry puriod. For 111 who were to drink sea wr.tor the tot:l anoint of se*. water was de tormina! and tho cnount :i tho individual doses; that is, the -mount of sea water token 't one tie. Tho first group was to drink 5CC cc if sea ‘.inter p-r dry with 3erkntit. Tk© SeCord group wrs to drink 1,CX» cc rf sea wrter per day. Iso with Berkatit, and there was to bu a control group which *>•.= to get normal drinking water, 1,000 cc pur day. This n;r.r.-l drinking water was Inter produced during the exporl-> nt by treating - a water with of tit, Schaefer's drug. But I want to point out that this Jhs not a test lor i.ofatit bocr.usa no one, not -v.n any 8029 23 1lay 47 -“-2-2-pp- Karrow (vco Schoc) Court No.. 1 representatives of the Technical Office, had any doubt of the ef¬ fectiveness of this drug. It was not necessary to include Wafatit in the experiment. A fourth group was to drink sen water without any ad¬ dition, and a fifth gr«wp was to get nothing at all to e ct a* drink. I oust explain southing about the last two groups. The croup which was to drink only sea water was chosen in order to deurni.-xj what was to bo done if, for technical reasons or reasons of raw material, tta ttofatit could not be introduced and, i„r nodical reasons, Berkr.tit was not taken . The opinions of practicing physicians, as well ra the scientists, as to whether it was better to go without water entirely or to drink anrll quantities of sea water, wore divergont. Sana thought it bettor to go without water entirely. Others thought thoro would bo certain advantage in drinking small quantities of aoa -water. In order to get a decision, these two groups wore- includod in the oxporinent. Q. Now, how a bout food? A. The four first groups hr.d the full fliers' ration*with 3,300 calories a day for ton days before the «.oqaerinont. During the experiment they were giu-n the oowg-ncy rations. These oixrger.cy rations contained 2,474 c- lorioa and consisted >f chocolrto, zwiobr.ck and dextrose. I happened to bo in a position to give the nuabor of calorics of the English sea onurgency rations of 1943 per nan per dry • This was U.8 calories ,xr d-y. r ,. Hew jeny? n. U8 calories a day. Considering this figure, the Goman orxrgency ration, which included 2,274 calories 1 together, v; ulti be equivalent to the English ration for five and ono-half days. In an affidavit submitted by the- prosecution, it was said that during the ‘-xporlmakits tho people got only a little chocol te and soue zwieback, but chocolate and zwieback are very concentrated foras S food. That is be-t shown br.* the ccapositijn f the English emrgcncy rations. Th-. .j .8 calories of the English tzxrgoncy ratirr.s arc composed of or.e ur.ce f biscuit, on- ounce of peraican, ne ounce of talk tablets, r *‘ ne -ur.ee of chocolate. This is not vary ranch in quantity, but 8030 23 Ifey 47 -U-2 -3-pte- Narrow (vor. Sc ben) Court No. 1 it ia very concentrated feed. Q. In this connection, I offer the affidavit of Dr. Henson Ln Doctta#nfc on !*««« 165 t« 167, which will bo Seckor- rreyseng Exhibit «* 28. I should Lite to read excerpts. Dr. Hanson is a unowned physiologist wto, since the 1st of July, 1945, has been working at the Physiological-chemical Institute of the University of Hallo. I road -/ 2* "For cases of distress at sea, the Goman Luftwaffe had the foliating facilities rt their disposal: n. Tho uoorgency ration containers in rubber liveboats. b. Th* sea emergency ration bur-a dropped by piano. Ore urgency ration container in a rubber lifeboat cental! tho foL- lowing itons: ainorcl water, windproof sr.tchca, cigarettes and Pervitin Amy biscuits, chocolate end Doctro-energiters. Total c-lorie content of tho food: 2,474 calorics." Thon I ccr.tinuo -ith "The food supplied to tho flying personnel of tho Luftwaffe in action at the front consisted -f tho goncrr.l basic ration and tho oimen's special, raticr.. The first consisted, in 1943, of 3,700 Q’.lorios p.r day per w, in 1944 ctf 3,5CO calories with 97 grams of protein, ei grams of fat, and 569 grans of carbohydrates." A. Perhaps I nay explain briefly the fact that’tho fifth group, which was to got no water, got n thing to eat either. To a lajBun tlrt ■=* rather cruel. In reality, it's tho other nay round. Yesterday I explained briefly that with -ut food wo tokc in a number of substances, ;r rather that a number f metabolic final products are created ir. tho body, freo tho food, which must bo elimirr ted through the -urine. If 1 dc nut give the body any liquid, p but do give food, tm nc.d for water will bo Increased am that wiU subjuctivoly increase the thirst. It is therefore quite general -mdical ocpcrioncc, fr-n thirst euros, that they are much marc easily tolerated if no food is taken during then. The sa=o experience is i 8031 23'Jny l*7 -:f-2-4-nki>- Karrm (vai Schcn) Court J'd. i reported in '.11 cases of shipwreck and, ns an exeaplo, I should . like to cuote only one source. That is the paper by a Gerana Xavy St abaarzt Dr. Sasr in the Kgaaine The German Uilitary Doctor'- fron July, 1944. It is n report on three shipwrecked persons who wore rescued efter thirty-seven days: I quote: "Ascause of tbo extx\ae]^ sell quantity of wator,after f jut to fivL flays the rejority of the shipwrecked persons could no longer cat th« biscuits sinco they rwr.inod in th. nooth as c dry powdor and it was not possiblo to swall tr.is powder without rny liquid." I boUevo this brief quotation shoes rhy wo decided that this group would rvot bo given any solid food. 8032 23 Stay 47^-SV-3-2-*evh£n(7cn Schon) CourtHo. 1 * - 16M6S * •« acv to the duration of he exnorinent. Were dorinlto tloea «et. vhlch hBd to to Ploooo •* trl.f , Ill( . e you ' keTO rried cut on nrlsoners. I pointed cut that tinder his redecessors, G er.c rrlcbcrctrb- scrct Prcfcssor Eit-oke end Kolzloehncr, such 'experiments hrd been carried out nnd fir-lly I ccintcd out th- t the ser—water errxriaer.ts wore 3C35 23 May 47-M-SV-3-4-Meehaa(V 0 n Sdon) Court So. 1 absolutely hffruleaa, that nothing could kronen to the subJoets ar.i that I vi o convinced that v« vouli find enough TClunteers anong the oriscrxra for theso ejcxrincnts because before and eftcr the cxrerlnonte they would get especially good food. Professor hekroeder ceiced rsa whether ! know any dotsilsenbaut hew Kolrloehner had obteined his subjects. I had to answtr i'r. the negr.tive, I could only a*- that I knew thft richer hed said in tho dumber* oeeting that the chief of the Goman Police had supplied the prisoners. Professor Sohrocder said that he *culd talk to the chief of the aedicnl service of the l, crat Police. "itneos, did you not tell Pressor -chroodcr on thie occasion that they were a rvlonned criminals; crininale scntonced to ooTero penalties? A. *08, I an sure that I said that. 25 -iry-ni-J?-4-2r-Cook (Ir.t. Vo- Schoba) Court I ^ Yocr .vps, I should like to refer _t to is point to tho .hfi ..vit cf tho Caoiander :f t-e 4 .cdic_l -c_da.y cfythc Luftv_f;c which is Schrocdor xxai'oi- Ho. 19 la tho Schrooder document book on p./.o - it Is ftocrsieat 25 oa pohOs 72-73 and h.x .1 ready been accepted .x on otdiibit. This affidavit eaafirus th_t toe rap ori. lent v .a to bo cai-.lod out in the ..edical -Cudaiy :f too Luftv.n'f e aad also the Chi of Physician of too Eoo?it-1 la Brunswick, Conor lurst Harriehausca .ui uafto nn affidavit which le Lr. Btcker Treys oa.. 42 ounces 168-170 of docx’.-cat 3oc::or-~rcysca«; Ho. 3, watch I sh old like t offer la cvidcnco ..a lii-.lMt '.To. 29. I to-11 rc-d the 1 st n .r... .ih oa t»o,; 0 2. I shall aot road -o rent cf tho affidavit. Karri*.-usca writosi "I roc .11 very veil to t I w .a coco -shod x .. other it vo-ild ho •jot oiblc t; carry out control emertocntB with so r-v-tcr, ado drink.-blo by v rious -othods, ca-> .t loots aufforin, frc\: :.iaor cc-..-31-iuto -id tho cli iitly wounded la tho Luftv ffc Hospit 1 la Brunswick vhick ir.'.o under ;:y suporvlsl 'a. bhotoor Prof. Dr. Schrooder or ono of hio ropreBO.it tivoB put t.-.is question to uo, -ad at what oxact tiuo, Z cenhob rcc.. 1 ox-ctly. It could h-vo ocoa lr. Juno 19.4. I h-d to refuse t.io under*, uk in.; cf sue;', oxpcrlnonts, as I h i ctrlct ordoro to ■oad ill patients -ad V adod v...? could oc rolo-cod b..ck to tho troops? tkuo I did act h-vo cxrumd of hoa”>it-l la-.tca suitaole for thoco ornorh.cati,. lurthcr-ore, the hospital v b ovorcrcvded .t tain o-d, therefore, v_s aot c it able for scioatiflc oxiori.-cr.t6. I can _1 bo reC.ll dearly th t, at a 1-tor ti:.c, I a;-in spoke to Prof. Sr. Schroodor ..eoat t.:io •• .tter. -ad t .t a- espressod ais Turret oa t .is occasion that -:csc cr’crL.ants could act be carried out 1 ;. too Luft- waffo Hoc it 1 ia Brunswick which was under ; s - direction." hhls affidavit is si aod -ad certified oy too notary obcrh..qt M*ixa oa tho 9 January 1947. Ibis -ffid-vit v.s to h-ve be or. offered ia too Scare-odor c so but tho abolish tr-nslation was aot yet -v~il-do» I withdraw it ia the Schrooder c-sc and offer it a a Scckcr-Treysor.j 6037 22 ok (ir.t. Ton ichon) Co’trt I Sdiijit. ■‘1*^038, you 8 —Id th..t Brofcsaor Schroedor w s to spe 1 : to tho ,’odlc:JL Chief of tao C-cious Police, tunt 1 * Scichsurst SS ernwit::, do ytr. 2 -u vhothor ho _ctu illy t.Xcod to hi.. -,".d wh it result the dio- cuseica hud? u. Yce, I uaow t;:_t ho did t-lk to bfc. .athru-i: I :>yself v •* »°t preaeat, but ./ter 2 few duy* 14 ' dc?>..rt..ont c.'.ief ordered ue to ncad „ lot-tor to the aoich 1 .‘sister of the Interior -ad the Chief of the Oor-na Pollco, or rather dri/t such 2 lcttor, since in tuo -cuatiuo Conor hLobor 0 1 ubs.ir zt Schrocdcr b.A tjx.:«d to Sr-witz. *-r..witz hud ouid th.t 20 w. a will in to coopor-to tat is order to deal wits tho u.ttor offioi lly nc would ne*d u brief lcttor. ilo a..id the lottor nc-d oixl;* cout.ds tfle nccose ry lafociutioa oiuco Oc--.cr.J.oocrot.i’oo.xst • Schroodyor h.A di«cussod t .10 nutter or lly with .;ru«ltz. VltsooB, I thai chow you docu.e.-.t ‘Jo. 185, Prcc.c- tion ibhioit 13*1, xi.c 16 of tho cr. u. 18 :f the ^ich docui.oat bool: 5, nc.; u. tor o;:>oriuoatc. 2 . 1 c ic t-.o letter to too I.olcn hir.ictor of too I-.tcrlor, Did you draft thi« letter? .w Yea, I uJ.o tr.o first dr ft for tuis lcttor. The dopurtnoat chief and t.;o c..iof of ot.ff ch_v;od - few niaor points ocforc it WM ni-jacd by Schrocdor. Q. -04 tho letter h-s t.;e oi, nature of your roier.it, doeo it? Am Yos, it 8.4-c 65 -ad tho ref or-t 2-7. a.;it ti..o you wore a refur.-at -nda t sa uosist.-nt roforor.t any loader? a, I hud been a roforor.t frx. tho 15th of .%uy on. Tho lottor ia dated tho 7th of Juno. ?. whoa did tao reforest, ProfCBtor .aathesy, lo-vo t..is offico? ^ jsti-.ony loft noout tho 15th of 1 -y • C.. Jew how v_s t.iis salutation for-ulutcd? I ae-s "Highly rca- pcctcd _.c:.ch l.i.lister?" 23 ..1 .-vT—1—3-Cock (Iat. Yu Schoa) Court I j. Ei-3 v..s _t tee spcci -1 request of ^cncTjloberstaJsarrt Sekreodcr. Tour Honor*-, this is - lot-.er of the kcdical Inspectorate for the „oieriacats ad in the ha. lish it Dc uo to refer to too fo:v.or o^?orluents. ;.7, kuHBYj Your acaors, tais is .point of consider .bio La?ort.*aoo. Indo-d for such .. problem .s tois, it's ooin,; discussed should bo dispensed with at well -s _r,.u;ent..tioa c f it before tho a'ribunol rad t. w ori-.iu.l document oh.-uld oo brought into the Court rooo by tho Clerk and turned over to the intorpret .tion den .rtaont to conotruo as to vhothor t .lo English version is correct. She Pros.cution uaii>- tains t. t it is one hundred pc re oat c^rr^ct. ••o have h.d it cnockod* ‘h.lSXTH. I: The Clerk will procuro frou the Soerct .ry Conor, l's office the ori inal cf this document Ho* 185, ad tuc docunout \dll co submitted to the interpreters for a report by thoa to tho Sribuucl, 33* .._Uh hr. President, on tho 3 of ^ay I eubuittod an a'plic:- ticn throujy-i the Sccrot..xy Gcaer.2 -oout tnia trasl .tion out no decision has boon rc.ahcd yet. I h «T«, tnerefere, h A a tr.asl-.ti on propnrod and a;- opinion corresponds to tho wording of the Gen»na ori,\-i- n.l docrtioat. Hey I .;ive this tr.asl .tion t. the iribuaul because in -v opinion it ic vital. Inis firts sentence is the one on which the Prosecution wants to put ,re_t cgih^sis. I sh-ulf like pomissitn to 23 ;;.y-iX?-i-4-C30Jc (lut. Ton Scr.oa) submit this translation which «„s prepared 07 -in -ivvlishuan ..ad tarn tr.o final tr nslation by tie int-rpreters 0*. undo 1-twr out it bocob * c IC i*-i=rtu 3 t tu.-.t t-c TriJUii-l be iven tr.is translation. j._ - Uill counsel for the Ounefit of the record ;ivo too u.-uo and position of the interpreter vao a^do the tr-nsl-tion to v.. cl: c. *_■ sel h-s Just referred? i.d, a*OK» four Honors, I i.i.’^t st .tc _t talc tine th .t the tr aslation division .-.ad the interpretation division of tao Offico of Chief C June el f :r v„r cri cs h_s cert .inly tested all iatcrpr-t^ro and tr nslntor* boforo n person c j\ qualify ..s .-1 interpreter, and it „i'j*.t bo woil th-t this version f ?r. Karx be submitted tc the into- protntion 4 op..rtucnt end th..t they c.a tjec t. is int » consideration when the;' arc interpret In;; tr.o docuacnt, p_siaiL.jj When co -.scl f or defend nt h 41 naswerul ay ques¬ tion I U.vS GOih<: to su est theta i B OLD 23 lay-*'i-DJG-5-l-Gr:ss (Von Schon) C urt 1 £R. .so.- Vx. President, I :n't ra.:w . crsonnlly. !fcr staff tcld at thrfc a translation h?d been prep-red end when I asked whether pre- p.-Xwd by c G^mcr. or an American I r.as tcli by n Englishman l.ith the nccossnry knowledge cf the G«.r=an as veil as the English. THE PRESIDENT: The Tribunal would like tc be ' ivised the nrxw cf the person whe .cede thr.t translation, if thr.t can be furnished for the record. ER. I have Just been inferred thr.t it was a :*r. Dirks. THE 1 RESIDENT: Dees this rcntlesnn who ardc the trr-nslrticn, this Jlr. Dirks, held any official pcsiti.n here with the .xiericen cr 3ritish Gevomaent? DR. ;.S far as I knrw he is r. nomt ~r cf the .jterican Hili- trry Gevernnent and translates fer the General Socr^t-.r;-, but 1 it n't know exactly. I den't knew hia personally at nil. THE rRESXDEKT: ihen the cri.inal dccuaont is presented tc the Tribunal the transition in tho prosessUr. -f counsel fer the 'cfendant niU bo submitted tc tho interpreters together with the crir^nrl dccu- n.nt end the interpreters will then consider the natter rn:‘. report in pen ccurt tc the Tribunal. MR, ILi.DY: Did the Sccretcry General bring in the csdilfcit? The interpreters can take this up during the rc$c3s I think. THE rhZSIDE?iT : The Tribunal has instructed that the crijinol dccuaont be brought into ccurt. ,R. H.J-.DY: I jus net cle-r whether, ycur Hener is givir.,? the translation tc the interpreter at the saao tine. THE ThESIDEtfT: That is wh't I have instructed t be dene, th? t the interpreter should bo furnished this intcrprota.ti r. -ith the docu- =ent. Tho interpreter will then revert in open ceurt to the •Tribunal. The interpreters -ill consider this ar.ttor during the ocrrdn: recess which . ill be called in a few minute. 3Y DR. UdC: Witness, ploaso let us discuss the contents of this docu¬ ment. Thw first sentence reads: "Scrli^r this na-'o it possible. - r r SOUL 23 :fcj—4S-DJG-5-2—Ore ss (Ven Schcr.) Court i the Luftwaffe to settle urgent nodical setters thrcu^i experiments cn huar.n beings," '.hat experiments docs this refer tc? A The experinonts that I knew about, that was Hclzloohnor'a experiments^ 1 New I gc cn to the next sentence: "Today I - ;rin atm-.', before r decision, which, after nun-rcus oc crincnts on hucons and else cn voluntary human subjects, demands final resolution." The Prosecution considers this sentenoo sc important that -n 16 December 19A6 en 530 cf the Gcxnan transcript they said a. about it. I quote* "1 should like tc cell the attention of the Tribunal tc tho words 'voluntary sub¬ jects' . This pr.vos that they (nooning tho defendants) had finished their work cn veluntoors an*! had U have recourse to innrtes cf c n- cvntraticn ccnvs," ' -11 you please cement rn this, witness? A Sir.co this seems tc be th- cest inp- rtmt sentence in the whole question cf sea water, I would like tc £c inte seno iotail. UR. F-hDYx Hay it please ytur Honor, I don't think it nocosscry to go into detail in this quostlcn until wo have tho translation settled. It w uld sorely take up tho time f tho Tribunal unnecessarily, TIC .RISID3.T: I think this rrtter should be delayed until after tho interpreters have reported en tho tr-nsl tien. DR. H.1JC: Very well. IXr. President, vy I suggest that no recess new so that I c-n discuss this point with Dr. Bockcr-Froya-ng since this io .no cf the nest important points fir t'nu c'so, THE .hZSIDS.T: The Tribunal will new be in rocoss. («v recess was token,) EC U2 I 22 -.; -i.-C?-7-l-..cchin (lr.t. Jrown) (hurt I J __ -T. » She tribunal is —-in in soscicn* ZZZ. T.ZSZjj* I: aro tr.c interpreters prep-JOd to rtport to t..c Sribuad c,. t::o translation cf the docu~or.t in question? I. Tour honor, t c original jorz^x of t..i6 x c.o'O raids no follows: “Ich stche acute wieder vor oiner uatscncidun, , die uuCh snhlreichon nor unt* ..cnschcnvorsuche.. sine out£uolti,.e noosun.'; verl-a«it." 2ho version of t..io passage, >ropoe od b - tho Prosecution in diglish in ..s followsi ,, 2odn;•, I -.-in st..nd before - docision, which -ftor nunorous axxo- riuenta on :>iiuds -nd veluat«ry huuoa subjects, da—ids fin-1 colntiou." and thowersion, prenosed by C unscl for Jof-nd.-nt -iocJcor-rroj'ccsir;, io as follows* 0 "2od.;-, I o«; .in st.-nd before - decision, wr.ic . nftor mtiorou^up^.'o- ri .onto on aniuals .aid l.u.-ns da.-nds u solution on volunt-rr export.iattd subjoctu." In tno o lnitn of the i-torprotors, t..o Jordan saitenco io cubi- ,Tuously ,iiir.8-d -.id is open to both the Prosecution's -nd the Dof-nno'o construction* She f..ct w..ich i.^it .../o t:.o Prosccuti n'o lntoxprat.- tioa soaouhnt i.oru liScoly is t..o following: if tno vritor of tho lottor h-d iatuiidod to a.ph..sizt that tho sue sequent cxic.i-onto ver- to oo carried out on volunteers, ~o cculd have i_de :iis uonninort of tho inturorctoro that t o nooning of tho origin -1 letter, u b written in wor..un, is ut lo;8t Uibig”. 0 U 8 . She n-ttor is open for ergu-ient, dso open for further tr ; 8 l .tioa end. further 6 tudy b 7 cupotont tr.-nal ;tors if either sido d«sires to produce tho-. Exo mound, of esurec, carroEsec nq opinion SO/,3 (Int. 3row=) utt this ti-o £3 to the of the letter, tr.^t is e a^ttor for aJjrneat Kirch will oc 1 ,tcr considered* 5Ci.i — r 23 riy-y-^S-S-l-C-- k (Int. Brown ) cwt r . i. DS. v -JJLr !>. President, I have token notice 3 f what th-j Inter- protor said. but I have failed t.- hear the position f ihj Pr.socuti r. wi*h r 'fcroneo t the nsserti n bv the defense t. the offoet that neither th tmr.sldti -n n r the interpreters have tajeor. int? consideration the tx Jtuotinn mrks, which er.nnrt be f und in the Gerner cri c iMl, but Wl.irh have been ins rted int. the English trar.slati . n. Th.t h c hr u,-ht Ct Ut tronsloti n t th« di. to-o ef th.--- defendant, if it was stated th"t thoco tw e. rens were err-no uoly inserted, trs o.uld tbor. discuss the question r.a t whether thv scntor.ei is anbiru us :r n t. First f oil, h rover, itw.uld h \v t bo c* ted th t those tn e nrr.s rgly inserted. They d r. t-rr-r.!» tht Gomm ri-in.i. ~''Z rXSSI!)EK?* It WTiId Scon that tho matter si.-ht Vst bo approached if tho interpreters will rake a vrittor. report end file -no tilth thu Seerotr r- G rur 1, v with th If.-accuti n onl n< with Da- fonso C -ms 1 >nd r.» e py - with th, Tribunal - ’IT., HiJiDIi 1 ur K n rs -- 7I?S i’SSSIOBWt *'r s cutl r. • nd by Jefonsn c ur.sol, '.nd onv evidence.which w - 3d thr : any 11,-ht r. th. subj ot m-.y »r ffored, but th-> nurc or^ur mt up r. th.. r. nrirv- c uld b> n r apprcprlatol- c nductod nr.d r.-.re c nvoniontly by uv rvb. dy by written ■'r^in. nta os t tho neacin.* f the vr rds. • I rd ht odd at this tir. th- * th-' lmnunc 0 division f CCC? V.C. has s n v r.l roferntc ’h'-roin, n. 'f which is th trnnslnti n 'ivlsi n r S'.cti n and - nc f which Is the interpret ti n soctim. "r. F-.ul J s ton, vrh is chief f th trineloti r. sect! r., I an inf-mod h-s r .lrry trio fly new. "• Tfhat Is said here about tho dr.r^or invclv.d ir tho Berks ruth-d rofors only dourly to tho use • f bc.-ki tit in practical use • ir -ng sen onor^oncios. That is said hero about tho feet that tho “ethed must bo useablo for twolvo dn«*s running, the w. rds hero spoak for Mvr.se Ives, nnr.cly tho rractical domnd for a twi lvc lay peri-d c f us * v -is docs net rear, that '-.eh oxpc ri rental sub,} ct would ba treated T M. this borkatit for twelve days, r.nd then ir. th next sentence B046 22 Vny-*!-G5S-5-3-C''ck (3rcwn) court r . 1 . It is stated what I nysolf knew about the possibility of oxrorinonts in. thti oaap Dachou, naooly, that ttoro wore suitable 1 r r.riis th-re. Yju are talking now of the ferty healty cxyorinontal suhjoets wh- nust bo mdo available for four wooVs and thon it goes on, ns it is W «n fr-r. previous oxperio-'Rts that laboratories oxistod ir. tho Can} Dachau, nd thorof ro this orr? would v : suitable, is that what you aro referring to? A. 10S . in the ln-t j ir.t ir. that dccic-cntj '.nd I quota* "Duo to tho en-’nvus inj.ortir.co which a s.luti r. of this • r hl'.rs has fro. Idlers • f the Luftwnffo en 1 *’ vy w>. have boeerw shijwrockod, I w uld bo groatly billed t y u, ay door illniator, if y> u w.uld tooido t c-rr.ply with ny request." Yu are writ in- thon of t!;o « • f the f.llcwing, witness: It c-'uld ’ sai *. th-.t y«u really c uldn’t spook ut that tine f the on err. ua inportanco « f s lvlng this problo* bccauso t is rfas in th surn ir • f 19i-i and it c 1 * be said that the situotl- n % at that tino wns n t such cs t rr.Vo this s luti.« absolutely nooosscry. ■>.'.1 d< y n hevo t soy ;!• ut th"t? A. Lit no r for to what I have already said that in ny oj inlvn such a nothod is f relatively rro“tor injort'.noc f r rn inforlr *ir -m than fV r a superior no. ..n inforicr -.ir force will suffer rrouter e-BM'.ltios and 1 ss-.s and will he n r* s ri'MSly affected by those lee sob thm w uld supori r ir am. 0. * low reached the mA f this ■ cua.nt. ’•hat heppon-jd in this Bitter after tho letter war r :;t r f? i.. First, we waited for the r.nsw- r fr -n the sinister of tho • Interior and Chief of the Co man rd ice end in tho n .antinu ir feasor ; ip lb cock iris t< Id t- report t the office .f tho Chief cf the r.-dical Ir.ep-ct rata. .. Di ycu rue ire . r npt r ; 1 " t this letter aco 3i • v u d - -."•-bin t expedite rrtters? Z5 !'ay-’'-riS-8-4-C Sr to ) C art ,v . 1. i.. ITo waited a 1 n* tiro for the reply -r.d I beliove that finally the answer c; no rly m>r th tolvh'Sjc i -ir or six we l:s -ft.r tho letter was sent .*it. I zysrlf ht-J n- re os r. t expedite or hnston tho rr.tter. Q. *7hnt had happened in the re-.ntisc f Ir-.fosser Sciflb-'eoJc? A. .»t the riddle «:r end f June Boi'lbccele ev.nc t' ur ffiea and ctovud in Berlin f-r tre r' thr.o weeks t study the newest literature r. the pr 'Mens of thirst c ntainad ir. the librr.rios in tho University ir. Berlin, and then at the begiminc *r tho riddle ..f July, when news on no fr n th itoieha ..rzt SS th t the oxporiswr.ta c--.Id he curried thr urh he w nt t Dachau, Q. N<~r dcourvr.t heck 5, jrgo 20, of t>v. En- ish be k, documnt Fr, 179, and TC, sup - ! , xhibih ICC, tho first docu- mmt is o : TJiralor f tho 2?th f Juno 10-;;, the soc mi is a lottor fr Prindt t Grvits, dated th • 8th July 194-1. w < * toll r-, d. yni ka>v those tor latter 8 .nl th ovonta iia-ussed In then. •*. K- , i V tho lottor itself it c-i; be scon el arly th nor.t if ff and t wh a it was u ':rocsod. This is .ur ly an int. r- ffico rr.ttcr within the .* lico and SS -ffico :f tho f'.et th-1 Uinrl.r was rrkir- vaJla'-lo ^ypsi s f r those ox;crlwati, which I found ut thr urh lY-fcss >r Dei •.It'xck • nly after the c nclusi r. of the -(Xpori- ac nta. S lonp oc -rofess r Boiplb ock wr.s in Borlir. he lmc-w n thin- f that doclsi'-n either 23-:-r-X-y-l-rr ss (1st. r r.) C tire :Cu. 1 * Q whtn -id y-ts fir.- 1 cut then that gypsies were- to 'oe uso'. ~s oxperiEKntd subjects? A That they were to be used I never found out. I just sale’ that I found that out cnly after the experiments were cncluded. Q Hot: die natters develop further vith Professor 3c i,lbcock? A First of all I discussod this natter Pith Professor ^oiglbcock and infonxd hin briefly of what it ooncemed. I had cssun-.d that Professor Eppin;-er had already tails. ‘ with hit since he had proposed as director of tlx experirxnts. I asa-rxr that had happenod. Professor Boi lboeck didn't knor anythin, ab ut the natter. I went with hin to *.y 'opart cental chi-f r.introduced hin to General- oborstabsirst Schr odor. Fr those t\ :: superirs ho received tho order tc carry out the oxptlbcec-: receive"' far carry in.- ut the excerir. r.ts wore briefly ns fellows* under n: drcunstarcos were the oxporin_r.es 80A9 - 2>-5K-9-2-Or ss (Lit. Prrwn) Court . 1 to cause serious c-aa~. ; c tc _ health ' t.ic subjects, ar.d :f course there should be n. fatalities. I’-'.t was perfectly clear. Soc:n^lly, t! oxporiamts wen. to be interrupted on the basis of that instruction if they bocrr.o dangerous. Tba oxporirentc should be carried out according to basic scientific practice but, f course, 'hat was clear t both of us anyway. It was also clear to us that the exporisonts r-ra to bo carried cut in such a way art c provide p:rfcctly clc-r results. I also discussed tea question of the voluntary oonsont cf tho experimental subjects with Profess:r Boi .lbr.eck, not for lcral rcas ns but far pur-1. Mdical reasons. fr*ofoss:r Belclboeek is on internist. I als: was a d*ctcr de^lin; With internal ’iseasos and -,o both had had considerable experience with rc.tients rhe had t- b» iven a. special •Hot bee '.iso f purely* theraojttic r s-ns ir. the clinic. .vary dodt.r has had the oxperione- that hurra >Ar K a 'Jjxnd to a rcat extent rndwont t keep n hovin. their evat'-nary :i..t and uvery clinician has tho oxjxrienco that sick p.x*sous t certain foe s arc frrbidden for radical, reasons, sii\i that f rbid -n f rod ir. particular even will pr-curo it i.r ihonsolvos b r«i t:io reason Pr-fsos-r Pci.lbccc;: ashed r- about t'u oxp-riiwntnl G bj .cta intended f r those oxporiaonts. Sh uld precautions bu taken t soc. that they received only tho foed and t. cunts if wr.t.r “v*. sjr. water that •..•ere prescribed for tho experiments? I enswurod that I ii : not think that particular proca.uti-.nary measures should bo taken bee-use these wore vluntecrs rd.r bectiso :f their c ansi lor .ably better f d Which proceeded tiw exjeriaants were interested in tho oxr»rinont3 if it was explained tj those p.c 'la V-f ro tho exjx.ri-'ants what was r._rc concerned I ccui: net '.xli~ve that Ii-fesscr S-i.lbccch vnflil -vut any particular difficulties wit . a - axp rir nt -1 cubj-cts. q nitmss, what did yen su^ as tli- -uamtec that oxporiaants rc-llyw.uld bw c-rrlcd rut r.cccrdir.- t this p licy? A i -ar this uaranto-- -n the. :r»,- har. ir. the p.rs n of Pr fos: rr i IVaccI: and soc ndly, i:- :~rc- r.-cf ?r fuss r levin , r v. had 8050 * '-y 2(l-: -lZ-9- 3-Gr:sr (Int. 3rr a) C-• rt 1 proposed hio chief physician. Q Bid any other office have the ri ht to int.rfor. in nry ray with those exceri:^nts in Dachau? A Kb, either by ny departnontr.l chief :r by », Herr 3ci lbcock was explicitly tele’ that ho had nothin. to Jv. with th-_ rest of tha crunp of Dachau, that ha was, sc to speak, a little Luftvrrffo unit cf his ora, and was subordin-tc only t th Ghicf 'f *Jio Ibdicol Inspectorate of the Luftcrffo. ?h-rv was no such thin- as any subordination to any authority within the conp cf Dachau. 3 „ -itnaas, I pat aoc lv r D.cuttant to you now. It is in Dccunant Book K . 5, F23, KC-132, Inhibit 157. It is a letter frea the Re iohsfuohrer-SS Pers "'1 S»ait to Dr. Grawits f 26 July 19liA. In this letter is a. descrlpti.n .f a conference that took plaoo on too 20 July 19IJ. at Daefc u between D... rr-r.dt and t:ve si;ncr of tills lettor, namely Slovers. Did you know anythin of this discussion? A He, I kr~w nothin of it. It is ’>esnblo that 3ci- .l 'cock told no sene thin atxut tills after ho orste bac!: but-iurin cr before the disc us si r. I knew nothing of it. Q 1»ns it not y'ur duty to jo to D-chau and to ir.spoct or to observe? A IF'.. Porivape one rf ny superiors could have iv.n r t. that ta6k but f irst of oil it had b^er. - rood with the technical cffico that Frofusccr iipplngcr was t sap-rviao the cxpcrlr..-ri.^nt&. Signed: Or. Theodore less©*" Cortificd by n notary. This ifl&hlblt ?30. .Yitnoss, wo must nor discuss a few documents put in by t!v- uroso- cutior. ir. this connection. The first one is in Docuront look 3, p- a 6 of the Sr. lish bcok. This ic Docuraont he. llh, Exhibit 131. This is an affidavit by Dr. lonrad Schaefer. This is in Docxcxnt Book 5, Tour ff-ners, pa^o 5. Ir. this affidavit, thure -ro a low passages that could lead U rdsintorprotetions. .le-.oc say- son; thins .about then. A I believe that Dr. Schaefer, -hoi i*c is in the stand, can best correct thorn mdsintorprot-tisns. I Aould like to point out aijain, Ycur honors.... "p. i-ITjjy (Latorruptin; ): Your Kcncr, It sec-is most unusual that this witness sh ul J correct affidavit of tfk defondant Schaofur. Schaefer will be here in th. witness stand and will be able to correct thot affidavit if h has aifc* corrections to aak_. THE nfijsmail: I understood that the witness nado that a: cstion. I :.-r.»t knew what the witness is oinp to say, but the def ---'.ant Schaefer would certainly be in a better prsiticn t- c,-rruct his cm statement. 802 . 23- - ^-1C—u-Sarrcv (Ini. Brown) C:rt J-. 1 The witness ^ay prcccod. r il D2. I.JGC: ^ r “ - cysel^ ted just requested that Dr. Schaefer clarify those aisinterpretatijns. I bolien that settles the natter. Q Lot rn sirply ask y-.u, witness, to sry sonethin ; . cocut ^7 in .his ttflU avit. He says lu.ro, and I quoto: "It was on ccer. secret in the highest ocdicnl circles that the --r/a jo thee was used or. inaates of concentre tion craps. It was alro known that sea water, processed by the Berko method, was ’ substantially the soao as ooa water and. was, thcr-fore, exceedingly Ion; ere us. I was clwcys of this opinion and personally advised Sehrcodcr, Dacfc.r-?njyscnj, Apttony, Christensen, Berk- .and Schicklor it this, -y opinion." Plocce spy soaothin; about that passage. A First of all, re tc thi* question of the -pen secret is ccr.- cornod. It was neither an spot nor a closed secret. It war, as £ * r "* vc wn concerned, a perfectly irreproachable natter. So far ■■ tl ~ h; nodical circlo? arc c r.cornjd - I !->n«t knenr whether ■>r. Schaefer includes no ir. those circl-sf U never thou .ht tn.-t I c.lon;v' t-- those circles - and Sv far as thA*. xc.edir^ly •'.•n.rua- neos^f tho Berk", -netted we c j scorned, I ern refer tc what I havo -lrca.-y said; namely, that I also hoi the application of thu Berfca r-*hod in practical encr.jency sea etc!ions as dangerous, out 0 1 1 1 ” t ernsi:r it dan; : orous in experiments. Dr. Schaefer is ri .ht in sayint; that I knew of his opinions about Borkatit. “< But, witness, you remenber that the prosecution spoke of tho so- c:ll-d toxicity cf sea water. A Xos, I heard that. I can s~ about that the follarinj. Since t,,c f " aous Tlicophrastus Boabastus von Hohanheia knorn as Ruracclsus, - - iYc - -round 15CO, it lias '-ccr. known in medicine that ary material - a poison. It nl; depends :n tho sc. I c dll P-rr n - h °VJon. I cm oven kill hi with distilled water, but still 8055 :;=y 23r4f-BK-10-5-?tarrcw (lex.. drorm) Crurt Ho. 1 no one is inf to assert that these two substances arc pjiscr.. ROgard- inf, 5 -‘- water, I nay point out that f:r centuries sea vr.ter has been used for therapeutic purposes, oven in lar^e mounts, by doctors. I kaow, -f course, that there is adifferonco between this doctor*s proscription of sea water and our experiments, but I thin, it is impossible to apeak of the toxidity of aos water as such. 6056 2Z May-iA-J -ll-l-I I sc han (Drews) Ccurt 1 * . Your Honors, I put In Eacker-?r jyaoa._ Doca-eat No. "A, r a : os 175 to 181 of locu. jnt bock 3. This will bo exhibit 31. This is o rocont doscrlptisa of t!ia history of tho uso of soa-wetor as a *ri;-kia£ euro. This is ’./rittan by Dr. Hon^an Bruoalni. This iocu- or.t pr^vos that eoa water has lcr,_ bje:: uso; in -odiciao as c. thor- a apouticol ..oaas and if trains loss then 300 cc ycu do not have to ex¬ pect diarrhea and elo- aoa-ustor i3 used for intastlcnal iafoctions puch as typhoid a—', cl; lor a. ?ro.. this ints do y >u of for this doca*jnt? Ia other words, what uo you think it tonda to prove in the c .so, h*» will It bo helpful? DR. :&&£: This document cl^ll prevj first cf all that coa- ujtor la oven uaod a-* a Uirkir, euro an., ti.is proves that it is not la itself her Sul, thou it . ill yrevo in what a ousts sea-wat-r car. bo a: inictorod, that it caucos r.o intesti .al dicordors and tint on tho e .nt^ary soa-wator is -.iso: in troatim iatocticnal infections such as typhoid and cholo a. That can bo coon fra; this dooaant Ho. A, * Szhlbit No. 31. Hr. KTD”: ?!ds is a situation, Your H ’ r, ca.poroblj to ‘■sfess-r R ’so wit: .malaria. St-o of tho vork o :id iith .alario •a f r tho benefit f his ,ai touts, houuvor Pr-forr.r R'-so Z'os not ai.itcin th-t .Gloria i' har Io3s. 8057 2 C 1 -li-l-riacban. (Brcua) Court 1 Your Honor:, I put in Buckor-Yruynoiv. Docu-ont No. 44, pa-os 175 to 181 of locuiant book 3. This will bo o-hibit 31. This is a rocont description of tha history of tha usa of eao-uator as a driJciae euro. This is written by Dr. Eor-^ann Eruonini.. This docu- _.ont proros that soa water has lonp been us ad in medicine as a ther¬ apeutical .'.eons end if usiiv. loss titan 30C cc y.u do not havo to ex¬ pect diarrhea arJ also soe-vetor i3 used for inta&ticnal infoctlona such as typhoid oal ch lor a. ?ra. this d cau; tent, I ..ay - t uoto brief¬ ly. It is ?Q60 1. 7 o hock ie ontltlod: "On tho History of tho Sea Tator Drinkini Curas, "atkoft* and Indications," by Dr V .or Ana GruMdr-L, Diroot->r of .. scatocfc University ChUdrens-Cliaic. VR. '{JOY: I objoet to this Dccu ar.t, It la i:rtetoriol, your Honor. DR. ! JJIZ: Kr. Proaidont, I tollovo I can diepanso with roudlrv tho paoso os fia: tho book, becauso I : ova al-oady sot forth . hat tho orsontlal pointo in thia docu-ont a: o to w blob I wish to draw ycur attention. I ark that this doou ant be occo .ted i:. avl- donoo. TKJ KXDIT: Counsol, on Just w.iat p :r. Prosidout, I should liko to pcir.t cut tho biblio¬ graphy attache*! to this docu. out, which rill ah on you how uxtor.rivo tho literature or t.ilc uhjoct is, all ;_oi.». .0 prove that h ca¬ va Mr is not poisonous or har Xul If used ir. ronaihle, clinic -1 doaa*os. T/itnas-., th Prviocutica cha ..es you with c usir^ the or.- porl.antol subjoct inhu a e poiuo and isory; wiiat do y u have to cay ab'-uf that? jl. i bellevo that first of all it is a qvostlon tc by yut 60 tho oxport who will bj :oa?d on this oarticul r ..otter. for yeaIf, I should like to cay that this in a confuci on tho part cf tho Prococution betwoor. tho eondltione that rovailed In uxror- 1 enta and 00 unions • ich provailod in eottialy j j oncy sea situa¬ tions. The oxporL ants *.orl Ol.t :n ht-self I hove eon. 1 1 :qvo also at -hen with two car throe f 9r. Schaefer* s technical-asulfltj*nte, who stayed wit-’Mut food cad drink for f *ur full 1 -6 a., 2 still continued hair lat^raiory duties. I kr.cw of course t:.at hu.„.or r ud thirst are xiplawact, in fac- that can be bery anploa-a/.t, but I lo not be¬ lieve that it cm; bo c.iloi ia?.i or ln':u an t c rr: ut such ax- oorl-ossto. iloroovar, P -fosaer 3ol*_loock informed th.e ox par l -ontal subjacts proclsaly .j tho ouwl on tc Muld be cc;Uiuctod o’. i in tho expiri. onto the .-elver, in tho pi aval n_ .-f tho x: j- 1 wo did ovorytrdru pccsi lo h avoid any uur.ocaecary uctIo caatnoss. ?or ln- -.taaco, tho thirst ; r-.p bid not receive -> .7 s-li' fool, becouso, as is hr.. ... that si .1.' a. revatos tho - once f :hlvst e:d produces un- -loasaiit syn.pt re. Ci. h'itnorr, i.- not the result! c. ios h wei ' t 0 i to 8058 z: :.ay-::^-ii-3-::oa ar. (sr- r.) Co-ar? 1 these people and i . air: danger to thair health? A• This loss tf ueitht, ’..hick cortoinly 'ccurad duri:... the oxperL-ant: , consists f--, the :aost pert si. .ply in a li/sc of water and lr. tart consists in real loss «tf wi&ht, but In : ca3o did his los3 Of iolt.ht approach the 1Lits of -'rat ca.: ha r.’ereto:'. I .:nov/ that fir i..3ta..co consol on tl 003 objectors in othor c-ur.trlas c rrioi out oxyori ants in. ;/hlch thoy lost as . .uch as 2 ^j of their total voicht. "Tia-tf* .-aixul-’o f 10 Deco her 10do putlisluyi an articlo on this ani in --iliral litorituro t.'.ore are caco; if uch louder faat3 Kith raich _roator l.s .* oi ht. I boliovo tliat it con ha cour. that ouch a loso of voi hi. within o lL*dtod period of ti.o does net con- o'-ltuto an:- oseontial ■>- or to the person's health. V Ur. Pro , : a doouuont haro. Docu o :t Bo. -*.5, Dect : . book 3, pofio 102 to q i 133. This is on trace pt fr .nr. Sohaik . : .tJ D-. Tloyer'a book, o.rtltlod •’Fast". 1 wish to rja-1 nothin-, fr-. thlr rtocu.ont, but wish to refer briefly t.-« what It: aln co.-.to.-.tr aro. Thin hock rojwrtc or. a odlcal oolf oxperi.ant, to tie r 26 days* leain. l-:.3 kilograms. This of 17 of his total body vol&ht can bo toloratod wltl no da.-v.or. Thera lu no raiuct^ - in tho por-rn's ability to roriot dinjaaj, hiit iulto the coatrcr:. The scientific attitude toward fo-tir* -ver brief poriodo of si.-j . lLdtod ..oriodc of fci a» iu Loro -alo cloar. I si ould 1 2co to put this in an exhibit 32 and ask that it bo ailttod. Ill FJDy: Your Honor* I object to tMr ieeu a.:t. I don't think it has any ir-'ative valuo hats cover. —.j-.Irra-ily, the substmeo cf this docur-ont is to tho effect that th. .. ho foots .ill lore oi t. T’ o Tribunal is of the opinion t a. it har no prrbativo val-.o -• atsoovor o»i the objection io susta* . 1 . 3R. JI-: I s all withdraw this lecu nt. ‘.'Itnoss, it -./ill ’ j oecossarr t deal it! re point cn vhlch the P peso cut i n laid roat i ,'rtanco, aawoly, t e juo: il vhOthor - 5059 23::ay-.r: ooha:. (Dram) Ccurt 1 those export arts had zX' sonso or puro'co onj *~-i 5ro ctar:®; with the fact that a clo let ecuId havo ccca to tlo sa j c sr.clusisns that t’a experiments lei to by oxperi-anting f r ono '-alf hour vith viator with a filter in it. !3. Hfcl©T: It 30032 tc -a this quaction is out of order. I object to it. This dofoviant is char u oi *:ith having jarticiyated in oxpori.ar.ts on huan boi.i'3 at Dachau cor.cor.truti a coup, not for par¬ ticipation in soa-'-xtor rosearch. uo dc not oc .tor.t that the rosearch as to the potability sf saa-«atar is unnecessary, it was cortainly •.eco3sary, it :;or d i . .yarici and it *.fas ior.a ho o In Oor any. I don't coo any rJason J.r ccntinuln alcni thoco lines. It hao b on to¬ la'. or. for five bourn uv I think the defoosa counsol car. ond up his cq j uch a: or..r t .an ha as. DR. :yj»Z: ::r. Prosidont, I -luito ualorr-tcnd uhot tho Proso- eutor said a -1 I a. .led tc hoar that tho Proiocutor sold tkono m- ps i or.tn had a pur .o t tho:.. I diotir.ctl;. ra v:bor ho laid they uom soiwoloso and c-hra^uattl:* I had to toko that late consideration i y def or.o, but a on th t ho akos th.ir stataa.nV t tho Tribunal, this in no loa/n necessary, I '.dll acco t t’at. :3. &3DY: Tliat lost state .ant, 1 accopt with.ut projulloo, Yvar Honor. TIL! at&MS’?: Ccxirjol a;- prucoel . v 23- -3X-12-1-C ■'< (Inc. Brown) t n't y.;i 1 Dr.. TiRX: Hr. Resident, I Ar.il try to cti. tc the- conclusion hie presentation rapidly. I ivx; put in cccuiaonfc Boclcor-Troyscn^- fart a ccujnt - 0 .'itnoss, .’id you talk about thv.ee nodical experiments with any other doctors? -* A I felt a. reason not to and did so. Q m ether words, you did not f- .1 that these experiments should » kept secret. “ •*t any rate I sprkc with ccUna^u.8 about this natter, »h I th u;ht would bo interested in it. 1 How I put in, :t. President, Docuxnt h3, page 2C6-9 in c’-r. nt oh This rill bo Deckcr-Fxeysorv Exhibit Wo. 32 . This i- affidavit by Otto Loch .rt, v o had an official roasen for talkin wLtU eh* witnosa about those experiments. The rffidnvit is f t.o 1? January, 19h7 , md I quote fr-r p-fc 2: " ' Jlon Problem woro discusaod - in -.-y presence at lonct - no n -r-.us r own cruel oxpor •. rr woro over dobntod. I ala r ^axdod this as .uiU ii.mciblc in vie: of the oxtrocoly ht*;h : indod and ethically i; maculate fundamental attitude of L!ic *viaticn nodical rose.arch tror’c.rs I kn w." And tfv»n on pa; e 3, about the nidOo* "3 citcr-rroyserv was Vvr. upoot that h_ had espoci-ally to rut a difficult ii.tab.lisa v.xporia.nt in notion for such (obvious nonsenso' but he saw i.j other p.ssibiiity of prevent in. tlv. layaan fron unstinr ccnsi orable qu-ntiti_s of raw material and subsequently distributing t the tr ops a proparaticr. -.;hich was net conplotoly har.aL.-sc, Ho was .all the .are n.xoyod about the oxpcrirmr.t, b-- •t ci so :n -.c-' -ur.t of the strained situati-n n the v xiius fr r.ts, ich, X c urso, effected the tr: y-x t hco_, it .as ver- '*ifficult obtain a sufficiently lar - nu-Xx .-f soldiers f'r ''ays n end a be us:-.' exclusively f r t „ :.tabolica xperL.-nt. 7hv.se ‘iff icul;i. s ar- uli_ainat_- if inmates “ere used -s cxperin.ntal 23-:-3K-I2-2-C - '< (Int. Sr ra) C*urt He. 1 subjects. I had not the faintest icon that the experiients re* re- carried ut until p-mer»ent injuries tc health ‘ccurrcd, ar.d I did a--' at the icproESim that Sector Frcyson* intended anythin; -f this •. y of c-rryir, out vhese expori- nts. ven today ! car. sou in rotrcsp;cti n no '.her p-scibility which could have boon ai v.rtaton with ny likelihood f succosc. I cnor, hcvtvor, that t.x subjects fer th».c« cxpcriner.to roro only volunteers; that tno probln r -ich the o (I r J . .rc:.r.) courti V-4=y -VCR to bear the res : . .asibilit: that falls t- at on the basis r .* f ici.al position at that ti^e. DR. -V JC: !£% President, this c ncludos ay tlrcct oxaninaticn of D-. --jclcer Froyeeng. T'-J FRZ6I3Z;?: The Tribur.'l will nor be in recess until onc- thirty o'clock. 6063 i.ay 47-.r--iY-l"*-l-VOnSohon) COURT I .jraRNOOM session. (Tad hearing reconvened at hours, 2^ :ay 1947.) TH£ .>L»R3K«L: The Tribunal is again In session. MR. H.JOY: May It please the Tribunal, during the noon recess It was called to ay attention by Mr. McHanoy that the cbjoction to Docuaent NO 185 — that Is Prosecut¬ ion Sxhlblt No. l‘*4 — had been raised prior to today and at that tine the prosecution had submitted to the Tribunal, and tc defense counsel, a inoaorandum to whloh I referred to this nornlng. However, If further worh is being prepared which the prosecution nay Intend to do In addition to that raenorondum, if the interpretation departaent has anything to add thereto, we will aubait th.it at a later date. But at this tiao the prosecution wishes to statj that thoy stand flraly upon the translation as It appears In the prosecution document booh, No. 5. THS PR33IDSHT: Did I understand you to say that a written noaorandun on the translation has already boon filed? MR. H.RDY: It already has been filed with the Tribunal and defenso counsel. THS PR2SID3NT: Vhen this supplementary translation Is prepared, a aeaorandum by the Interpreters, see that it Is attached to that and ando cne file. If you please. HR. H«RDY: Yes, sir. THS PR3SIDENT: Has any dofense counsel any questions to* pi'^^md to this witness? k£Tv:«n. v bscxsr-frzyssng- Rosuaod CROSS RX^'.IKATION (By Defense) 0 (For Dr. Sauter, counsel for the Defendant Ruff): £064 2* -'-a: 47-.r-.iZ'-l.’-a-Foster-(/onSchon) COURT I Q- Witness, in your direct examination you said chat thu mobile low pressure chambers had to bo transported by rail in the second half of 1942 at the latest because there was no longer any diesel oil available for long trips. Old I understand you correctly? If I said that, you understood ne correctly. I can't remember ray words at the moment. Q. How can you still remember that that was the case froa the second half of 1942 on? I happened to remember a definite event, the transport of a low pressure chamber fron Berlin to the area of the Gross-Glocknor. A lew pressure chamber wao needed there for nigh-altitude research and a lev pressure chamber was sent there. That was the sane low pressure chamber which at the end of July or the beginning of August 1944 — uxouoo oo, 1942, was taken over by a Luft¬ waffe crew at tho German Research Institute for Aviation, and this must have been the same chamber which according to Dr. Ruff had oorlior been In Dachau. Since at that time I was In the Reforat for Aviation Medicine and was responsible for these chambers, I, myself, was concerned with this transport and I know that we wore unable to get any dio6el oil fer this long trip, and that wo had to move the chamber by rail. 23 17-,-..”>-lW3>Gros9 (Inti von Schor.) Coart *fc. 1 “ In so-o socurwnts which have been submitted, that is in various ictt:r3 fron SS c -ancles an', in a 1 otter fro- :-s. >:ird Saschar, it is su os to d that Rcscher bo assi nod tc the DVL branch ffico Dachau. Althsurh no such offico existed an: no letter f ron ary Luftwaffe aroncy took up this su jostion I should lilao you tc tell no whether it was at all possible t assi n soldiers an', nodical cffleers to the DVL? Di ! you yourself not arran o for .jodical officers workin- for a shorter or lon er tiuo at the Aviation ''odidno Institute to work there a3 -nost3? A I cn at least t-tll infemoi about the s teps connected with this aivi I car. first of all confirm that the Goman Research Institute for ..viation was not a uilitary agoncy, that it certainly had no branch offico in Dachauj and if nodical officors or sol’iers woro to work at the Institute of Dr, Ruff, woro to loarn soaicthin thoro, it was ban Ho l as followsi Thoso sol ’iors or officors waro assi -nod to the noaro3t Luftwaffo unit by tho porscnnol offico an* tho DVL was ask o’, to taka theso sol Hors in as .aiosts an', lot thc;i work in tho instituto. Q Do y u know that tho officors and scl i„rs who worked as .aiosts ir. tho DVL ha 1 for their identification a aiost pass of tho Goman Research Instituto for ..viation an* net tho sano pass that tho rsonbors of the instituto had? A Yos, that is truo, I can confim that fren qy ovm knoiAo.l o becauso at tho borinnin- of 19U3 I nysolf set up a aachino in Dr. 'biffs instituto which I could not sot up elsewhere bocauso of difficulties ith tho current, ..r. , bocauso I was at tho Instituto froqucntly ’.urin -1 that tino, I ha ’ such a uost pass rysclf an I know that other nonbors the Luftwaffe hr.! tho sj.to Icin' of most pass, Q In tho examination of Professor '-eltz tho question of adaptation v. altitu *o playod a certain role. I, thorefor., have a few brief questions 7 on this subject which y u can answer as an export or. the basis of " ir axjjjrinatttal work or fror. your knowlai-e of literature. Does the of feet of a Captation to altitu 'o play an important role in oxporinents " c ‘‘ "3 -o hoar', of ir. Dachau for rescue fr or. hi* altitude? 0066 23 "ay !;7-..-» .rh-2l:-2-Gros3 (lot* von Schon) Court ¥?. i A First of all I shcul I like t: answer a preliminary question. I o acbially consider •^•solf some sert of an expert on these questions. I -rk j for soco tine on adaptation to altitu !c an-’. I aav refer to naabors 21* an * 25 of the list of ny scientific publications offered as Bockor-rToyson • Exhibit 1 . Theso aro papers on altitude adaptation which I r^roto iirir. the yoars 1939 to 191*2, I boliovo. I tb not believe that the quostion of altitude adaptation was important in Dr, Huff and Dr. Roabor, 's experiments, C} can oro compare altitude a daptation ".ainod through cumulative ar.Ion- stays in a lew urossuro chamber with the altitu 'o adaptation acquire! for oxar-plo by nountain dlnbors. It is woll knovm that clinbirs in tho Himalayas havo reached 8,OCO voters by moans of tho nost lifficult physical exertion without artificial scurcos cf oxy.-cn, A I have ha no experience in the Hiraalayns. I porfomod ny wn exporiaonto in Switzorlan* at tho hi h .Jpine Research Station on tho ■m fraujoch at altitu’.as botifjon 3,500 an 1*,000 rioters. :5oroovor, lator, as a referent ux’or tho Chiof of tho ”o’ical Sorcicos of tho Usftwaffo I ha’ to consider tho possibility of altitu !o adaptation by ropor.tod stays in a low pro3suro chamber. As proof of this I nay refer to hocunjnt ’>-931;, Prosocution Exhibit 158, That is tho list of tho 97 research assiptraents. On .a-;o 3 of tho copy, I havo at ny 'ispos.al on ; a e 1*, I bof; your pardon, under in 5 throe research assi. nnonts on this subject are listo V An ’ sinco I know tho results of this research woll, I can answer this question. By ropeatod ascents in tho low pressure chanbar nr actual altitude a Captation can bo achieve.. slight increase in rosistanco to altitude is obsorvo! to be sure in thoxcon’, thirl, a* ■irth ascent with the low prossuro choaber. To extant =f this effect is so nil ht, h'wovar, that in effect it is af no importance,, especially in the experiments which Drs. Ruff .an' Harder.: carried out at altitudes '-vo 12,COD m-tors. 3 Thon I can assume that the sli at 'o~rcc of a Captation which ' cvrr ’ - ir * thj cour3 ° ° r - scries of experiments such as was perfomoi - 8067 23 "~7 *.7-..--.r>li.-3-~r-ss (Xnt. vzn Schon) Court Ifc* 1 at Dachau does not influence tha results of the cxporinents to ary important extent. '^ 3 i this assumption is correct. Q Is it true that as far as possible after a lour series of experiments with the low prossuro charier the experimental subjects aro lift cut for a short tine to do away with even the sliyhtost adaptation which nay exist? Yes, that is true, but I must point out tho following* with the aviation rwiicino oxperto who constantly performed oxcorijwnts or. thon- soivos in thoir institute, wo are ccncorno with ropdoto! ascents over a porlc ’ of nary years. That is of course, somethin • quite .afferent than in series of . xperi-vents ltd to ' to 2, 3 or U months. And, an attempt rill of courso bo an do after conclusion of a sorios of oeperi- .-’.onts las tin- sovoral nonths to insort a certain pause. Q In Dachau about 20 oxperlnont3 noro carried out in the course :f approximately throo months. Is it yceruse, in the institute, I sr.w ..-ny c* 'eta eh hed •indnges cr. their ferenras, rail I wr-s tcld thrt th- jo cere ehc.ic.-l wrrf-rc _nt t-ots. . D: you knew the Zf antnin io lied School c f the OKU is Sc. Jeh-nn? .» Yes, I knc. th t Inst. Lute, 'he Arny buntnia ifcdiocl 5chcol i Zt. J hrain in tix Tyr.l. ■} D- ycu ka w th t oqicri'-cnts core p.rf.rtoi there on volunteer SvIdlers? .. Yos, 1 knc.. that very well. This kncv«l-l."c vc.s the rcr.sen f^r th. su -flticn which I nenticned yesterdry, thrt c sldl r training c -.i such o the -roy h-J in St. Jehnnn should bo set u;; for the Luftweffe ir. th- Vrrinin,; S-cticn in Juctcr 1 ' ;. q 'fir t y u c*i i y stord-y night h-v- been interpreted t nor.n th;.t t‘. ..ny did net pcrf era • v el] aenbers cf the ..ray. Th*t in n-t right? .. *i-t 1 ani'l cr. the subject referred cniy U •ihrt 1 hoerd h-rc ir. this c urt r. 1 bdiovod th t ither ir.fess: r Krodlcr.cr r s.iac- :.e els- hr ' s;jcku; . f - ‘ -sic r'-r free. Keitel th-t nc wc-cri-.jits ? ull 'o . erf croud ,n s.ldi.rs vf the ..rqy hut, cf ccurse, I luiow thrt ir. .tii the x lie-1 ffice*s ir. St. J. h-nn in the Tyr 1 rn’ io’. the :l- ic‘l ,.c“ ' 0 * such oq erlacntc verc xrfemod n v luntcers. . I. oh- list ;f . rrticignnta f the ilurnb-rc i> -tio* - IJ 0 -A 01 — •J'. r Ai, there is Cb rsrzt Dr. enig cf the lfborat. ry trriaAf th. o: . Is it true th t Dr. Ktenig :.rs r. t present? .. Yes, ti.-t is true. Thtt s vi.us in the ri ;iml ’.canent. h-rc t. ^ 1-cturc ,f Dr. Teem.- is printed, there is - fcctnctc -t the it . cf t o , * > ir.eic .tine th*t Dr. Kceni£ ves uhhblo t: ttor/ the 23 ->v- --DJG-15-t-K-rrrw (Vcr. Schch) C urt 1 ncctinr or serially fer reasons connected with the war, and that K conic 13 lecture was rori by Dr. Benzin.-or, at wr.csc institute Keeni ha.', v.rkod. The nose of Keen! ; is listed anenr the participants cnly because his lecture is included. o Thank ycu. I have rte further questions. BY DR. TRIEILLn (Defense Counsel fet tho defendant Rcstcck am. "Iso representing Dr. Sorvrtius, Defense Counsel fer tho defendant Karl Brandt): Q Dr. Bccktr-Frcyscnc, did ycu, free your ferner work, knew tho duties of tho Office f_r Scicnco and Research well? .. I believe I hr>ve alro- *.y aa.de a st'tcaent tc tho effect that 1 did net h/vc any kncwlcdre cf ay cwn abcut the specific duties and position of the office f-r Science end Research. q Then I nay sua up ycur st-tveccnts to the effect th't v.hcn ycu said that Krrl Brandt was perhaps tho hi .hv.st nodical authority in science n 1 research ycu did net say this fren ycur cwn knowledge, but that it was a ccnclusien which was su jested t. ycu? The wer: 1 "perhaps” exprossos th."t I Merit only tho possibility. Q Thon the ccphasis is cn the "perhaps”? A Yes. Q During ycur vork, at that tirw, did y u ever receive any in- stracticr.s fr-o Frefesser hv.st.ck :r any suggest! ns tc carry :ut vany experiments? .. So. q Th^n, Rcstcck did net surest the seft-wator experiments and h-d no ccnnecticn with then? .. Ho. Q Then, in the field cf those ex; erin.nts, there is nc connection which ycu renemher tc lay with the Office f r Science "nd Research? .. I have said that tho sea-water experiments were n:t worked cut thv. ’ cic cf a research assignment riven t. a civilian research rrk.r, ut * re carried ut by juts elves on a purely aUitnr; basis. e073 23 bhy-..-D JG-15 -^Kcttc v (V:r. Sch r.) Court 1 ‘ c '■-id not have t_ .;ive any ix.^ rt tc the Office fer Science and Re¬ search, and no did net do sc. 1 Thank ycu. I have nc further questions. BY jR. rZLCK-iJu.’ (Defense Counsel fer the defendant Schaefer): ' Dr. Bockcr-Frcyscns, you have cr.de detailed stateaents ab.ut Hclzlcchnur 1 s lecture at the .Numbers racotir-c and r.bLut Reseller's concents Dii you talk t; the defendant Schaefer clout H. lzlcohner*s eoc'criiiuits? .. I dc net recall any such ccnvcracticn. 'J i’-u hr.vc discussod the deb .to between yc u end the non of the r Technical Office about the usefulness cf Bortatit. ‘.Alet did Schaefer uaj hasizo during this debate tc sh.v he- dan; ere us Berkatit ires? .. First cf all, I of rood in . rir.clplo with idr. Schaofor that the ra-in dajvvcr cf Berk'tit was that it ccncoals the unpleasant salty bitter taste of sea-water and lee's the p'crs ns in distress at see to drink it, :ut by tho failure tc change the salt content, tho effects ere the sc:o. as th t if untreated water, and that was what Schaufer eephasizo.. 1 .. n if t.o <-o into the physiclcgical considerations, he ,irc- -tly addod th t that would incx-er.so the thirst -«nd the desire tc •rink, end acre end cere hanaful so.a-4»r.tor would be drunk? .. Y es, I bolievo I srl-l the ariac thine yestordny afternoon. B07h 23 -by 47 !r~ M-l-y (v:n Scnon) C-urt No. 1 Q. In yjur cxrviin ti r. s- for you rrvc said that Christenson ir. th- first cliscussi-ns prohibited interference in his job; you also s id s thing -bout a quarrel with a Luftwaffe Officer narx-d Jevi rck at the oeetirg of 19 May. Hon, I ask you whether you ivc-nbcr another quarrel which Schaefer told you about? «. I believe it Has between the two .aoetings .f the 2Cth and the 25th that Schaefer told a- that Lir. Schicklur, the Referent of Oo-rstirgoniour Christ-ns-a, acid th“t h- could expect to bo prosecuted f-r sabotage if ho continued to oppose Berkatit, Q. Is it true that ,n 19 May 't this oie-ting Christensen gave ♦ orders at Alt what the Luftwaffe worv to do rood say at the neetirg -n the 20th? a. I kn.w what y u ae-n. Christeno-n said, asked, or demanded thr.t the differences nit bin the Luftwaffe should bu put in the b-ckgrjurd on the rxxt day and those differonces sh uld. n-t be expressed befer- th- Navy non. And did you or Schaefer -t th- ’.tooting ;n th- 20th act on this r«qu«.3t of Chrisensen, >r wore there quarrels in spite of it? a. I express- ay point of view on the 20th, Just as'i had on the 19th. Thoro ware, f c-urse, debates. 'fho consequence was that Derk-.tit was not introduced as the Technical Office had ordered, but that the decision ms nado to iipond on no; oxperia»jnts. Q. Can x.o say that th-s- quarrols Her- violent? A. At loast the ones _n the 19th twjro very violent, yes. Q. 3ut I am asking -b-ut the nos ;r. the 20th? a. They wore perfectly clear, anyhow. ... Now, the discussion n 25th May you said was carried out uring an -ir raid? A. As. Yxi said that it wa3 cxitinued in the air-raid sh-ltor? a. T-s, an ir-rcII shelter f the Helical Acad-ay to which -ho a starch institute ‘xlorved ~nd in on- r . a f which the discussion ••as ; ( king place. 8075 23 J&y A7 -r^l£r-2-S,v.- Malay (v.n Sch-a) C:urt h>. 1 .. You '.loo said that pert of the participants were soperatod b-cause of circaeswir.co? «. Yos, I roscajor that -/try clearly. Q. 1= it .ossicle, or do you know, whether the Defendant Soha.for rwnr.L-.tu with the gr up which prircrily continued the discussion r whether ho was with one of the groups which was so parr tod free the .win participants in the discussion? A. Ho was certainly n-t in the seas group as I was, which La eluded ny dopart.cx.nt chief and Professor EppLngor end Professor Htubrv-r. Q. Y.u saitl that in th, discuss! ns on 19th 20th Uay no condition f r the ex-xrlsxr.ta wor.- s-ttled? A. Yus, I said that. Then it is no doubt correct that no experiment or sorios of experiaants to test ofatlt was decided upon tore? A. Yes, th t is c.rrect, an'. 1 aay add that that was unnecessary, h/caus- r.> one ever doubted the effectiveness >f Viofotit, n>t ovv.n tho representatives of the Technical Office. Q. If Later a sorios of experiments with .. fat it was introduced without Schrofcr's kr.owlodgo, what was the purpose -f this series f .xperlnunts? .v. I explained th~t this norning. F.r reas-ns f ooperLoontir^ a s.-called control gr up ha, to bu c cducted which was given n xai 1 drinking wator. This couli* havu b eon 'bt-inod fr a any water tap, but since this wepwrioent was being carried ut '.’ofatlt was included and tho nra -1 water was 'rxlucod by xvaoving the salt fr a sea inter erLth ofetit. Q. Can you recall whwthor the- inclusion .f this i./fatit series ws decided upon or at least discussed on 25 May? A. There was no great -mount >f discussion about it, certainly, because it was n>t r. questi n of testing Wofatit. ‘k. On 25 U«~.y y_u w«re with Schaefer at least part of tbs ti-6? 8076 23 - Y 47 -A~l6-3-*p- U=1 7 (vac Schon) C.urt Ut* 1 A. On 25 K-7, yes. H-w Ling was it until you sew hin -g*in after that? .v. A few necks later, perhaps five we..ks. Q. At least yiudi^'t a* hin daily 3 brief intervals? *• Ho, I was narsnlly 50 kilometers south f Berlin; Schaefer ha-: his laboratory in Telt®, I believe, in a different direction fron Berlin, and anyone who kn-ws coitions in Berlin in the suanor of 19V. knows hoi? difficult it was t- get around. If you say you didn't »jw hin, do yxi noan y u didn't talk to hin either by tele phorv., f.r instaraoo? ... I don't rocall - ny c-nvorstti n after the 25th. '*• ’..hen y ai saw oin again after about a month, can yu rcncabor that ho asked you what had been dan. in this natter? ... I saw Schr.ufor for the first tine after the 25th whon Hirnlcr's 'eciaian h-al n t yet beer, received. I n-nenbor that. And what did y-u toll hin ir. answer to his question? a. I told hie nothing had buon decided yet. Did y u ary y u ha 1 heard nothing non. about tho natter, it sou=a to bo dwindling away to nothing? a. If Schaefer rv^r-bers those words it is possible. I don't r-'ojabor that it tho nroent. Q. n*r. when did y.u soc -r talk to Schaefer again after tils c.nvorsotior. ? a. As far as I can recall, it was in th. flak tower at tho ; > which I aonticnod this morning. d. .ok’ whon uas that? a. That was the middls or end _f September 19U, after the «:>crincnts were cao late Q. Dr. Bcckor-Froyseng, y u kn w the 1 cuaents which tho • : r socuti n has subnit ted ir. S cicK-nt 3:ok 5 -gainst y.u rnd Schaefer; r. u tell n-. which 1 .cua-.nts Schaefer w.uld have obtained knowledge * - :r ^ugh fficial channels r whether he would hr.ve seen any of -currents n.r.-*.ily, for instance the nir.utes signed by Christenson £077 23 li-jr L7 -..-16-4- kp- Sfcl.y (v r. Schon) c urt 1 • * •.* 1 ^ * 'r.-d the letter which Schr.edcr a* y« s-na to Hinraler; y_u know k m business was caoductod, n* y .u kr.-w Schaefer’s poaiti n. A. I ccnn-t imagine Setaofor having known f ny of those docuasmts. DR. P3LCX5*NK: Ibank you. DR. FRITZ: Fritz, for Rose. BY DR. FRITZ: In - .ciivnt Bo_k 3, • it ness, f the Prosecuti.n, there is an affidavit jf yours, KO 448. In paragraph 5, which is on pago 7 of the D cux-r.t Book, you cr.y aawig other things: "Profess r Rose nca perhaps the most significant factor in the hygienic service >f the Luftwcffo," rro those y.ur own wores, -r was that formuLation ut into y Air aouth by tho interrogator? ». In ny -'irect uxanimtion I have already acid that the affichvit was put to u in the English language f.r signature; so far as I c'n reoonber today I think that tho :nly w*rd in that ser.tunco that rigirv.to fr a ne is th, word "perhaps" . Q. H never, ' itn-ss, yxi signed this vorai n; would y u -lo“se express this more -rociaoly to tho Tribunal; did y u wish that to no an that Pr feasor Race tad tho a: at to say in tills fluid, in ithor words, that he had tho g rentest powor to issuo orders, r just what did, you rxan to aay? /». H , I did not intend it to be so inter pro tod, buccueo thero is n-thing in this sentence that indicates anything of this sort. I thought I could h-vu signed this sentence having intr duood the won 1 "pertaps" int; it, because-, urely scientific"lly speaking, I emoidtr him - highly ounlifiod bncteriol gist and hygienist. Q. Then a t least you did not want t say in this Sentence that he had -x.cutiv- poirors, or that proposals if h- made thorn ncr_ binding f r tta persons without executive p *or? ... First f all there i3 nothing to that effect in this sentence, "n d 'Ctually s a -cobor A the office of the Chief f the Medical Inspector*te I knew very well that the surge-sti ns cede by the 23 *-y -.7 ---16-5- :o- '-l y Orw.) C-urt Ko. 1 consultant wore in m way binding :n or dop-'rta^r.tal chief, :r in us Q. ’iiw f cnothor sr.ttcr; y-u testified that thu research ~s- sigments Treat ho nutu-n if 19W. on wore r..t worked or. in yjur Eofornt, hut in the Department of Science *n3 Research are! tho Military Ucdi& 1 .'.esdeny? ... Porhepe I any correct y-u right away. Thoynoru taken care of by the training or lecture gr.*ip of thr.t ansb r. cnc’eny. 23 Kay 47-A-SW-17-l-*cehai:(3rcvn) Court Eo. 1 Q» ' ell, eftor thisorgan! ration changed, vfco vorlced on these assign¬ ment e? This is of particular interestin Professor Soee's *sc, beeeuse he «s one of the consulting specialists; O you know whether he concerned hi'-self with these r escerch essisngr.ents. A. “et no printout to you Dr. hens irich Hal hack's affidavit , w kich ves put in yesterdcy as a Seeker--r seehia at a conference or meeting of consulting physicians? I only ttended ono 6uchconference, tho ono in May of 1544 at Kohenlycbec. Q. *0 you kr.ov whether Dr. Beiglboeck ever attended such-a confer¬ ence? a. I noT-.r brnrd anything to that effect, at any rate I did not sec •‘-in in 1944. '-hrt was -^r. ^eiglboeck's rack? A. Sank? •v -'r.zkl 8080 25 «ay 47-A-SV-17-2-Keekan(Brcwn) Court So. 1 A. At the beginning if June, when ve first sew bin, he wee an Obercrzt and I Relieve later he becase a Stahsartt. W. Sow, let us turn to the experiments; did Dr. Beiglbocck attend any of the conferences that ere mentioned in document hook 5? A. SO, ■% ~id he participate in tho setting of the 25th cf hay in particular? A. So. Sov, another Question; you seid that the experiments wore to he supervised by a specialist, neaely ‘V. Epplnger; do you know whether Dr. Epplnger really carried out this sut> rvision, whothor he was In Dachau or not? A, I believe I can recesbor tr certain taht Tr. Bclglboock, after he returned from the oxoerisent* when they wure over at Travisio .said th/t Dr. Zip! Eger had been in Dachau. Sov coac to the oxp.risonte thcssclvcs; you roceivei tho asoignsent to have those oxoorisonts carried out? A, Yoc. Dr. Bolglboeck wr.s at thr.t tise in Italy; what did you do to got tho exoerimonts started; did you tolsohono to Italy to get hla; did you vrito to his or telegraph to his; what did you do? a. If I es to explain that to you in detail, I oust say the follow¬ ings I dlctatcl a short aosorenlus throught our Pirsonnol Cfficor in tho offico — r <. So, I don't vent to slow up the proceedings; how was Bclglboock infers; d? A. Ho received a written communication from the Cffico oftdu Chief cf tho Medical Inspectorate, stating that he should report to the A Office as soon es possible. Q. The cure-se for which he had to report was not told to bin; is that right? a. -o, it vis not. ’. ®cv he r ported to you. sou seid this morning that noithor SCSI 23 ry 4-i-S , J-i7-3-Hcckah(Brovc) Ccufc So. 1. officially nor unofficially br.d you previously known Dr. Beiglhoock; thus Seigltceck did cot know what your political opinions were; you could have teen an informer, he had to te careful ; is that not so? A. Cf course. V Nevertheless, when you explained those experiments to hin. he cold, "I don't vent to 50 to Dachau to carry out experiments there?" A, Yes, I seid that this morning in my direct examination, 0 . ®hen you seid this merning that he proposed that the experiments should not lb carried out in "nchou :ut elsewhere? A. Yes, .1 did. And you refused that? A, You ere exaggerating =y authority, Dr, Stcir. v *uer. Q* No, I aa not doing that. I Just wanted to ascortrln that for another rer.son. rt . ior personal rcroons he vented the locrtion to lb changed. X told Boigltoeck that I would glidly agree, tut I wrs sure ho would not to successful, end I mont lined such and such a ronson. Q• 2r. Bockcr-ircyscng, don't Qisundcrstrnd no, I don't want to incriminate you in ary w„y, tut wont to tring out the truth here. I simply soy that for one reason or another you refused the proposal thrt Boigltceck made that the experiments to trnnefornd clsowhero? A. Yoo, that is 60 . Q» - ; 5v lot me ask you e supplemental oue tion to this; did he not akc another oroposol to you? A, Yes, he mode mother proposal, which unfortunately cent to nothing, told me thrt teforc he had tccone the director of the Internal Department of the Luftwaffe hospital at. Trc/lsitr had had teen S the same in Brunswick, and since the hospital in Brunswick had vory goci laboratories, it should be possible to carry out tho experiments there. v '*;ry good. Now, let =t remind you of something else; did not Dr. *“ --.:lbccck make oven another proposal; did he not spy , " Deferent, I 23 -*jr 47-^-3¥-l7-4-Keehnn(Brown) Court lie. 1 have still eaother suggestion to -aike?" Sow you Just reflect on this— —Beybe I'cen help you a little. Did he not say to you, "I an expend¬ ing the hospital et Trevisio and I have an assistant there vfco could very v 0 ll carry out the sea veter experiaents there?* hasn't that so? A. Tea, he suggested that his representative in !Travislo should carry out the experinents there alsc. ^ AT.i did ycu not say, Dr. 3eckcr-?reyecng, "Unfortunately.^-Tr. 3oiglboeck, that von't work because Eiaaler is ir. the wuy7" n. I told fcia that the proposal did not originate vlth us; it had already teen decicded that Seigltoeck should be usod and this had already teen reverted to Elrvrlor. Ci. Siw, in naaing Eiraler you ueent to say that the proposal vaa lOpOHiitlO. ^ I mated to toy that froa a rllitary point of view the whole situation w» s cettlcl and thwro vrs no purpose In trying to .take n lot of changes tecauso It *ac too late. <<• Bow, v-o won't talk about the experlnonts thor.solvoo as vo have already gone into then a.t great length. Sow, Bolglbocck and Bccker-Frtyaeng ncet; did ho tell you anything etout vha.t things voro like In the concentration caar; what contrcts ho hud th rc; vhnt the S3 vrs liko, etc.7 He told ne two things that rather surprised nc. Birrt , I had trld Bclglboock that ho veuld probably find a very '-ell oauippod laboratory there. I did not know nuch about it in detail, but it vns the g^norcl belief that the S3 coui-acnt vrs good. Vr.cn 3oiglboock returned, ho told ac that ell he had had vrs en e-nty rooa there and ell the ecuicaent, retorts, and vhat not that he needed for tho ft exaeriaent, he hed to provide for hir.sslf, Tho sesnd thing that surprised ae cor-c-rncd is relationship to his colleagues who w.ro present i nd *:o were SS offierrs . This roletionshio v; 3 so coor that reiglbocck ves obliged to eat not in the SS officer's -csshnll, but outside the caap soacvh'.re in the town of Dachau. 8083 23 'ay *7- A-3V-17-5-ti e ehen ( Brown) Court Sc. 1 Sew, after the cxncrirents ve.e concluded, didn't veu toll Belglboeck that you would help bin tc get e Jot. a* a consultant rni he refused to accent that? A, Pr. Wilheln •-•eister, one of the Slovakian rcEi6tcr.cc aoveaent aen, was nurdered and thus his position ws free,. I asked Besglboeck whethor he wuld like ae tc apeak to ay depart cent chief end nek for the position for hin, since It was open. Beiglboeck refused that because ho preferred to reaain es the internal director In his hospltalj u o further auettlon. TrE PHEJILASTs If there ere no further questions by the defense counsel, the frocecutlcn nay crcss-exnaino the witness. 22 'ay-A~G 2 S- 18 - 1 -Ck (Ir.t. Brw.) C urt " . 1. CHCSS EX-dTtt.TION 81 -'3. E..FDxi Q. May it plcaso the Tribunal, Dr. 3cckcr Freys eng ir. th c urse f v tr direct oxnninati* n y u statod ir. regard t y ur ; cvsiti -r. in so far so the experiments or. hunan beings aro c neorned thit y u held throo joints and act forth throo ; -ints which mat bo fulfilled pri r t oxporinentati n n huacn boings. ..a I understand it, point . 1 w>s that the exporirwnt rust bo nucossory, that is, thoro is no rthor e luti-nj point It.. 2 , tho oxj-cricont rust also h-.\v boon woll jro- perod and nil research along t'-eso lines thr ugh onion 1 oxporisiontoti-'n has boon oxhnuetod, and y u had for hoys -..del oxyorinonta and ex; ori¬ ents n tho physician hlnaclf; or.d, Vr. 3, u statod medical oeti ns. " uld y u kindly ex; Lain t nc just wbnt y u cennt by \ int Ho. 3? ... I think ny ;■■•int I! . 3 ns that tho jeporinonts ah.uld be carried ut in strict acc rdonee with regular nodical pr ccduro. i. D.os the olucunt f c naent or the v- luntary nature f tho aubject c ru. into ploy? ... It d es c no ir.t • lay ' nd lot ro_- p< int ut t ■ •• u th 1 1 when rr/ c unael asked no this quest! n he explicitly said that in ny nnawor I sh uld ljnvo tho quest!-n • f tho t luntory c nsont f oxjorinontril subjects oIt-father ut -f rr/ onsw-ir, rnd, thtfrof ro, I did r. t sny anything at that tino regarding tho v lunt-ry nature f tho subjeota. I^tir, h wuvor, I did g int-' the quoeti n f thoir e r.sont and said that I w.s c nvincod th-.t prisoners c uld o Is b usod as v luntary subj ots. Q. Toll thon if I undorwtnnd y-u ocrroetly the othico! c nditi. no under which y u w-ulii ' ct w. uld bci 1 , tint tho oxrorinont must be necessary, that there is n - tfcar soluti'-n; Ho. 2, that it was woll V * j ruperod thr ugh nniml oxyorinontati r., a dol experiments, and salf- xporinents; and H . 3, that it was under the ; -called nodical act!'n roi-.*; and lb . 4, the subjects mst be v lunteors? Th sc ar th c editi r.s under which I c nsidcr the xperi- I " ntati r. justified. 8085 23 !£fty---G£S-18-2-CT k (3r to) C r urt S- . i. Q. do yyj fool nay vrluntoor fr cx:orincnts? A. .^ny-:no in full possess! t. <.f his senses. Q. TToll, dr yu think s.newhat cl^ng the sere linos as ?r fess r B SC, that rorhera r.ly oodicel atudonta r physicians shoild v luntcop f r oxperinentati n? A. N , it scons t pso that any r.ontnlly n«*rnal pers n wh can be t l 4 . what tha nature *f tho oxjcrirwnt is. TTcll thon by that t ken it rust bo necos«ary f r tho physician t warn the exj cpincntnl subj- ct nb ut tho hatnrds f tho ox; opinents, is *hnt true? “• I should like t- sny that it sh uld at least bo explained t*. kin. Q. Thon p-int So. f under Bockor Frey song :% . 1 la that tho rhysioir.n sh 1 uld cdviac the oxporinontal sibjocts? a. Lot =» i int ut that I had nlroa'v included this c mliti n under point 3 of nv provi us principles rr i n answering quuati r.s put no bv Judge Sobring. Q. ~ol! nw th-«t it hsio y nr othical principles clearly in mind, ! v u foi l that o7< r* exportnont which y u instigated in tho post f llorod those j rlnciplos, that ovorv experiment instigated by y u in tho past f Hewed thcco jrinci;lrs? a. Since I instigated nly no, ranoly, th sea mter oxporir.ont, ! an O' nvir.cod that whet was r» by rs Carres; nds t< tho principles Z ,iu*t cot f rth. 'I. D y u fool th t any oxporirvntr 1 plan th^t did n t c r.; ly with the othical principles wmll bo crirdnnl? T u asked whether I believeany * th r x;orinont. 1 plan th: t id n t nL-ot tho principle I sot f rth w uld bo crininal — is that "hit y u asked? *». That is what I asked, y s. ... That I can't say because I kn w n> thing f ny wn knowledge f the lar.s f r the tb-r exj crie.r.ts. '• Toll, * u think it w i id be un thic. 1? 23 ?a»y-A-G3S-18-3-C k (Br wri) C urt y.-. 1. Any cxioriaont which >2 id n t neat tha reguioti -ns os sot f rth by - u hare -n this witn>ss stand? A. I cant rnswor that questi n oith~r bacause t d s I sh el l have t kr.'W nil f the o.ndjti r.s rni ! d n't hr. w the.--* Dr. Beckor Freys ong, ,s I understand it, in 1941 y u -isaunttd this : siti r. ns As cist*, at Roforont in the Ruforr.t f r Aviotl a Hudioino in tho Hedies 1 Soj>ortnont f tho Chief f the lindical Service p «.f the Luftvrr. ffo, is that a rraot? ... Tr. August 1941 I boerr.'. on ..ssistont R. fore at in the liofornt f r .’.Tintii n liedicir.o in the Cfr'ico cf tho Chi f f the Modi'*-.! Inspectorate, y s» n , H w rvmy ..nsisvmt Daforonts ware there? I sold y starrier,' th t nly n fc-.? f tb Roforots hod Assistant Seforonts. I b-liavn thft thcro w ro jarh-.;o hw thor Ro fa rent a -- in thor Reforata, n t in th R-’forr.t f r ..vinti n a Kodioino -- which hid assistant jtoforonts. Q. That wns tho t ts 1 nur.bcr f ; orr nr. • ’ Q. Thorc wrs tho fficc f tho Roferat f r ..victi n lladicino 1 - CO tod? Until August 19-13 it wr.s in n building f tho Ton^olh- f Alr- no ar.d fr r. 1943 n it w-c ir. tho ir.rr oks can. f Snr 1 w near 2 sser., nb ut SC kill noturs fr — Berlin. S0S7 23 1-C k .Int. Br ~ r.) C art y-. 1. ~hcrc was the Office f the Chief f the "udicel Ins poet.'rate f the L-.ftwaffo, nnr.oly. Ei;ykc, and l-.tcr Scfcr odor? That was until 1942 in Berlin in tho sar.c building in the ■■v.jelh f ..irirnc, and fr n 1943 .'n it w.e els. in tho barracks canp 3- .1 w, nca r Z.sscn. '«• Physically h vr far w ro the • fficos -f tho .loforont f r .'.viati n Xodioiuo fr n th. Offioo f thv Chief f tho llcdicol Inspect r a to f tho Luftwaffe? “• In Berlin, HippkV’s ? fico w :s r. tho soc nd fl r and ur ffice was n tho third fl r in tho sano jnrt ef the snra building, end in tho barracks canp ot Sfiolrw the barracks in which tho vori.us fficos woro wero perhaps fifty t citfity noters opart. Q. .'oil n* in Kay 1544 y u boosts tho .tcforor.t ir. tho ftoforat f r ;.vinti. n Jtodicino, is that c rroct? «. Vos. S during thetirw nt issue in this trial wo ht-‘ tw liofo rents fr r. ..urust 1941 n ..nth ny «r.s tho Soforant in tho Itofornt f. r Aviatim "adlcir.o up until J'sy 1944, end nftur that tiro y.u bocano Soforont? ... Vis, tho change t k 1 lnco nb ut tbj IS Hay 1944. Q. “.'ore the duties f the Itoferont in the .toforot f r .‘.viati n '’odicino lir.itod t nor«ly tho ;hcr of a viati n radio in 3 ... I believe I already described that it grout length. I'y rani duties sow United t tho field fevirti n r..-dlcino. Did y u have art;/ thcr fields in which y u w ro active? A. Vestorday I said that fr n July n f 1944, that is, I wfs -Is radical 3c fo rent with tho research I/jo dor ship. f tho ..ir !'inistry, '“ J until tho boginning f 1914 I carried r. research *>f ny vm in !’odical Research Institute. I casn t row 11 -.tny -thor dutios ot *-ho r. nont. 3C33 23 *--7 -7-.-TD-i9-1-Orcs5 (Ir.C. Broun) Court So. 1 3 ./oil new bL 1 n*t, as a sitter of fact, all assiiznssts pass threu- h y:ur cffico when you wero Roferont to Schroodor — ail research assignments? A I ’.oscribod that at -tc t 1 anyth. I sal.’ that the Reforat for ..viation "o'icino, aside freo-its 95? aviation assi -naonts, also '1 ‘ purely foraal work for the rest of tho rasearch assi naonts, oven if not aviation nodical assi rrents cr in other fields. Q V all, than could it bo construed that tho offico you hold was r-.oro r loss a cloarir. h:uso far all rosoarch assi iriants? A C.ul you perhaps ox. lain what you :wan by tho expression cloarir. h:uso? Q \Vr>t no3t of thoso assi rxionts had tc havo allocations, various :r.torials, had to rocolvo subsi.’ios, aonoy, havo ro ulations to bo ftbidod by. IJow, wasyour offico t’.» offico rhoroir. thoso riattors v;oro taken caro of for all rosoarch assi nar.ts ef tha Luftv.r.ffo? A I had thought that I had Uscussoi this so oxhaustivoly alroa 'y that I would not havo to ;x> intj it ayain. Hewovor, ——— 1 TV, Bockor-Preysen;, before you continuo I want to toll you that ny reason for askin y u this is that perhaps in your Iroct examination you './ore t o elaborate, so jlabora to that it bo car. a very oonfusin^ to r.j and I ou trj to straighten xysolf out now. So, if y u .dll bo brief and. nnswor ;y questions briefly perhaps I can un lur- 3van* you noro cloarly. A I shall bo only too happy to try to. A In our offico there wore always rou hly ono hun 'rad currant assi rr.ents at one tiro, 95 of thee* C-ncorr.ir. thj field of .aviation -j 'idno. Thoso .as3i n. or.Vs -..-ora taken caro f by =y Rofcrat formally, far as their contorts w.;ro concorOo *. I t:ck caro of tho formal an! r nizutional aspects of t:*j other 5 assi-pnants of this .auiv’r j You • itione' fur ls necessary. Perhaps I shoul ’ toll you that — ill - .t . t!rt later, Deter, when air.- into chat point, in bri f, all rcsoarc assi nr^nts rale by vho Left.-affo cane 80S 9 23 Ifcy U7->W.Ti>-I^C-C-roS3 (Inc. ~rr.m) Court Ifo. 1 thrnr h tho cffico of R- c!: „n-?r cysor.';, trrospectivo of whether or net they !oalt with aviation o leine? Yos, after I bacano Roforont in 19Ui they all want through ny Roforat, that is ri/'ht. 1 Thank jru. Doctor. 2fow, durin; tha course of Anthony*s tom as Roforont, if I understand you correctly, ha 'i ' not havo tho authority to is3ua oriorsj is thrt corroct? A That is sc. Jfc Roforont ha! tha ri' ht to issuo or:lors. Q 'loll now, -I ', you havo tho authority to issuo ardors vrhon you baca.'o Roforont? A Ik noro than any other Roforont. !Jono ->f tho Roforonts ha l tho authority to issuo triors. Q ’ oil, now, suppooo y-ai woro intorustoin sono particular r os oar eh and in or'.or t. initinto a propra=» y-m raust tavo cr ’ars so that you caul*, hr.vo Hr- or. or any one of your consultants at vari >us universities who v.-orko:’. on a particular problcn comonco thoir work, ■,;h-> would issuo that erdor? A Roso-arch assijnnonts woro iosuod only by tho Chiof of tho deal Inspootorato hi-aolf personally an’ si nod by hin, boforo tho first f January 19Ui by Hippko, after that by Professor Schrodlor. Q Thon, in brief a pain, a Roforont ha', no authority whatsoovor to issuo or.tors, is that corroot? A That*s ri ht. q JJw, you havo statod horo in 'iroct axaiination that 'urin- Ar.thonyts torn 03 Roforont in tho Roforat fer .iviation ‘lo.'icir.o you ••foro rarely an assistant Roforont, that you woro not a ’.oputyj i3 that corroct? A That is correct. "J Thor, you ha * no authority t: issuo instructions to tho or-ply-im in Anthony*3 abs or.ee, is that corroct? A !*ay I ask what aaployoes you aro talkir.7 about? ; "oil, the other tr.ro onployces ir. y-ur cffico? 8090 1 23 :tr.* h7--.-..~-*19-3-Orcss (Ir.t. Brorr.) roixpfc a>. i "'ell* of course, I coul 'ictnta a letter to then or smothinr like that. Q Suppose Anthory Treat on an oxter, led trip, how coul’. you carry or. tho business of the office, would you lock tho door of too office then an t take a vacation? A !f“, above no was ry dapartaer.tal chief who was conpotont for :.y dopartnont and irho pavo no iy as si gnats. I had ry own reon to rhich tho topartoontcl chiof sent :a tho - cuner.ts I was to work on. dut ..nth ny*3 room was really 1 ckod up, that is so. Q "as the ’.opart-cntal chiof an export in tho field of aviation no icino? A !&• two lopcrtcontal chiefs coul be considered specialists in the fiold of aviation nodicino, boonuso tho first was Genoralarzt Dr. dartius, :ho had rovicuoly boon tho iroctin Victor of tho Goman ..viation Sport Association, and consequently ho know about aviation. An! tho aocon’. ono was Oburstarxt Dr. "art, who was hinsolf a ~on J pil t aw! know a good deal moro about flyin tta f ,for oxanplo. Q Assur.o for tho noaent that Anthony was on a trip an’ an - important prablai cono up in the fiol l of Aviation Idodicino v,heroin it was nocossary for or:loro to bo issue ’. To when woul .* you turn? A It is very oasy to answer that question. Such a problcca vr'*ul •0.70 ccno t< tho offico in rrritin in the n rr.al c urso of ovonts, at - -ast lot us assun j so. Thor. thi3 report or this inquiry, boforo it reached tho Roforat, woul l havo boon soon by tho flopartaont chiof. Than tho dspartnor.t chiof nul * olthor have reacha l a loci si or. ircao ’lately \L:salf or ho would havo -asked :.a to find certain ‘ccunents for hin on thi basis of latch ho coul’. r.ako his locision. Or, if this arr.s a field hich the lopartncr.t chiof know was within the special fiol' of Anthony's rdc, then tho ’o. artaant chief — ar.' this ft in In.-pono ’ whan «ntheny • '•* or. trips would havo ordared that efforts bo r.a do to reach Anthony by t 1 pho&: an • to put tho prettier. to hin. These arc tho nair. possibilities. 23 I-fey U7-i-nTI>-i9-ii-Gross (Inti 3rcn.r.) Owt ffc- 1 Q Bairc hypothetical a. air. for a accent, assuno that Anthony "oci dad that it was nocossary to initiate research in the fidd of hirh .altitude, or roscuo fron hi^h altitude an’ he wantod to cc mission 3onzinr;er in his institute at Rechlin, or Ruff in his institute at .. larshof, or 'oltz in hi3 instituto at :*unich, to conduot rosoarch alon,- tliosa linos, who wcul ’ initiato the research or ’.or? Anthory? A Un.’ar no circuits tancos. Q !tow, lector, .to y'u havo Dccunont B'ok No. 12 in front af you? That’s docurtont No. I*>-306 in the typhus experiments Docunont Book, on pa.-o - A I sorely havo a f an /ocumnts fron that ttocunont Book. Q This is pc;;o 7U of tho Sn lish, lour Sonor. It*s locunont !D-3C6 that you 'locus sod y os ter toy. Dr. Pockor-Froyson , whoroin you pointed tc tho last sontonco in tho lottcr. This is a lottor fron Rose to Hao/ on. A I havo that locu: ant hora. Q Y;u pointod to tho last sontonco in this lottor, which stitos cs follows: "It will take oono tL-n until 2-F pro due os its now rosoarch or 'or, as Anthory is on a duty trip for sovaral rooks." An l you in ti- catod t; the Tribunal that this sontonco substantia tod y ur position that ycu woro unablo to act in ..nthony’s abs-jneo and that you woro n"t by this tokon his loputy. Ifcw, isn’t it apparont fron this sentonco that Anthony had the authority to issuo a rosoarch or lor? A Ho, that is not apparont at all. q It certainly is, lector. Road it. A Th- sontonco roar’s aonowhat ’iffarontly ir. t’lo ori inal than fr—. what I Just hoard over the earphones. Tho translation says: "Its now research as si araonts”. H~ovor, in tho copy I havo haro it sryh ‘Until 2-F can pro >ico tho nsr rosoarch ardor." in. RIRDY: I won*t quibblo with y:u about tho translation, bocauso all lay yesterday tho translators translated tho word rosoarch order, huther it b> rosoarch assi nr-ant r research or dor, that is immaterial. 8092 23 "‘7 17---..73-19—5-Gross (Ir.t. 3rem) Co ur t l$c« 1 Tho assl joent or or’or irri.tir.tod tr on Anthony, accor±Lnr tc Hose* Now I want 70 U to boar in nin.l that if you attest tc state P.oso i in't know the inr.or workings of your office, then ycu roust also boor in rrinl that refutes your or^uzaont that ycu wero not a 'eputy to Anthony, if ?.cso .idn*t know what was oin: on in y.ur offico. Isn't it true hero frea this sontoac a, fTcn'roa in; this sor.tenco, that Anthony ha ! tho authority tc issuo a rosoarch assignment or or !or? 8093 t- 25 Key Court : 'Is*., Brcvs; A Chat is not to b< seen in this sentence at all. Hew, let n«. say remrding the translation, tha* it is not a question of the translation "research order" or "research essignnent", hut what you r.ad sc before vos read to =c that "it would he quite a while before 2 -I gave cut its rcsoarch asclgnsent", hut here it says "until 2-1 produces the new research ordor". * That's right. Just what I spld, "producos its new rosonrch order". I'll ash the interpreters kindly to turn to Docuaent Book rl2, rhe Gorsan edition thoreof, and re-*d the last sentence as it ic in the dccuncnt hook which will he an oxa.ct cuotation of what I have Just rend !r. the English. Interpreter reads sentence in C-ernan. A That's Just what I read, end it doesn't correspond exactly to what I heard fros the interpreters before. Si Jfcv, this states that “it -ill take 2 -T soac tiae to produce Its r.tv research ordor", 2-T heir th* Bofornt for Avlntion Modlclnc, a.nd tho chief thereof w«# enc Anthony. Sow, how could Anthony produco a ro- :oarch order? Ee d'.dn't hove that authority. A Tvert is nothin/- here to tho offcct that Anthony win issue thio riooarch ordor, hut only that it will take soae tl-« before the or-'er is '.cosed, because so long as Anthony is r^ny the order can't be worked Mid, consequently, cannot he put tc tho departmental chief, or th* >.itf ' the Medical Inspectorate, for sirnnturo. ^ “hon it is true that all research orderr initiate frea the Scftrcnt'r office ar.d that the signature of Schrocdcr was aerely a. fera¬ 'll*-”, ie that true? Or did "chrotdcr knew the contents cf each t nd research 'rdcr? A I* had to he shewn to bin hy tho derprtaent chief, e-nd I can re.v "‘■"ir., ir. thin connection, *his particular research eeoign-ent surely 'l 1 r.<- * initiate fres the Kefcrat fer Aviation Medicine, hut certainly - the “eftrat fer Hvri«no, '•hieh wag interested in such vaccine ’■' tz. The i *nnont vent through the Beferat for Aviat ion Medicine ir, through Anthony 1 c office only so that tho fornal end 8094 23 Key -i7-^F.'C_2C-2-£*rrcv (fat 3 rcv -' Co-rt I orfr&lcatlonal aspects could of it and prepare it for the signature of the department chief or the chief of the Medical Inspectoral. Both the Heferat for Hygiene and the Heferat for Av.etion Medicine was 0 u- bordinate to the sr=c department chief, so that if Anthony, or later I, submitted a research assignment to hi= that really concerned th. Hygiene 3eferrt then, of course, the Hygiene Heferat had already orientod him ■lout the natter. y the Eefc-rant for Schroedor's signature ? I? that what you're trying to eer.vcy to me 7 A The research assignment, for exarplc, in the field of aviation ne-'icine In 19^ was drawn up, dictated by =c after the scientist in cucstlon had generally cade an application and had told bo exactly Why ha wanted to receive a research assignment. T^is draft of a resoerch assignment I then subaitted to =y depertaent chief. He cither aade changes in it or approved it as it wr-s. Under scat circucstancts, he turned it down lsncdiately. That scaetincs happened. Then wc had it rewritten and it was put to the chief of staff, and if hi wns in rgreonont with it then it went to the Chief of the Xcdicnl Inspectorate for thi fine! decision. H Perhaps I gained an incorrect iaprossicn froa the testineny of Professor Schroeder hero beforo this Tribunal, Dr. Scckcr-Preyocng, I have the lapression froa the testimony of Prefossor Schroodor that you sore or less dealt with Professer Schroodor directly without going through ■ny interaedicrios. Ion't that the impression he created hero? A I don't believe so. I believe that laprcosicn arose beemiso we arc sitting next to each other in the dock hero without the representa¬ tives of the cfflees in between. Without first sneaking to the depart¬ ment chief end the chief of staff I could not go to Schrccdcr personally or dlroctly, ^ Didn't Schroeder say that whenever any of thcoe research assign¬ ment problcas ease up he always turned that over to Pcckcr-Prcyocnr, on pare 3616 cf the trenscript? A It is quite possible that he said that, but I think if you had asked him acre exactly Just how that was done he- would certainly have ?»'.d that if he, for oxasple, received a report that concerned an avic- tion acdicrl research esslgnacnt, the report went first to the chief of staff, who sent it to the depertaent chief, who sent it =e. 23 Mav -'7-A-Jcrk of the heart. D Can ycu tell f ren the study cf the electro car diegraph vhether r net . crSxn in a lc*,; press-ore chamber, utt'ergpin.; an ex crir.ent, 27 ifejwtWJG-5-2-Karrc* (Reader) Ccurt I is ir. danger? .. ub I alroady said before, I never performed any experiments, whore we could observe danger for cur experimental subjects by ncano of tho electrocardiograph. To used ether methods in order to orJee that cbsorvaticn. *fter what I heard hero frea Dr. Rcoborg on tho wit- ncss stand, I knew, or I can confirm, thrt by conns of the electrccnrdic- CTftph cno is in 2 position to carry cut such cn exnalnation. Q Tell, prior to the war — to the end of the war, prrdcn ae, what w«s tho highest altitude that any cf ycur experinents had attained? Did you'go up to 23,000 actors in ycur coqjcrincnts ever, prior to tho end of the war? •' I personally was engaged in ether esepexiaonts and cy highest altitudo was only 15 kilometers. Q Now, Doctor, those low pressure checkers, they wore under tho control cf tho referent, is that correct, for eviction IJedicino? A Yes, aftor thoy wore taken over by us. Q Now, that was in 19U1? The lew pressure chasbors wore trken ever hy ycur office; that is, tho office of .Atheny? .. New, this is net exactly right. That was already earlier. Tho lew pressuro chambers which had been taken ever by the Medical Inspect¬ orate, and that also hold true in peace, were handlod by the refornt for Aviation Kcdicino. 3 Did you havo any further connection or authority over the alloo- '.ticn cf the lew pressuro chamber after you had cnco assigned it to n particular institute? « Mo. ~ Then, in other words, when you assigned a lew prossurc chamber tc, a ay, Ruff 1 3 Institute, tc Institute cltz, or to tho instittrie -t r.ichlin, whor-. Benzingcr was the ccrranding officer, after the rasignaunt then you hr.d nc farther ode with that lew pressure chamber? Ic that it? .t No. <' Suppose Dr. Ruff wanted to scr.d tho lew pressure chan’ er to .-■echlin? 3enzic-er c-llod him on the tclcphcnc and said: "Dr. Ruff, 27 C-5-3-K arrow (RorSlcr) Court I I'd iik>- to use your lc. pressure ch&n'.cr for two r three *..ocka," Could Dr. Huff transfer the lev pressure chrj± -r tc tho Institute at /.echlin without superior criers? .. That is scacthinc diffcicnt ejain. Tho institutes ruvl tho cth.r smaller research stations hed their own lew pressure chral -rs which v;ere finely installed. In Dr. Buffs ease vie nro concerned with r v-ry special type of chamber, notorized .ccbil-. eh —-r. The Ger.um Luftwaffe only bad four of such .labile note riled chambers. Dr, Ruff explained here, in detail, thr.t the lev pressure ch/evbor which was at his disposal fer sc.uo tine h.d been furnished t. hia on the ' *sis cf & very special approval y th .cal Inspector : s r Hippke. It wis n turclly furnished t; hin an:’, tc his institute or.’. hr he, fer instance, wonted tc tr nspert this chrnbcr tc Dr. Bernin^er at ..-chlin h~ Mould he.vc bod tc ask fer pernissien fer that frea Professor Hippke. q ..nS, cf course, Trefesser Hippke would then consult with you ir.-a:uch es ycu were his expert cn lev. pressure cheaburs? .. Yes, ncrurlly that would have tc bo ossuacd, T Vfcll, did h- consult vdth ycu when Ruff asked to transfer the lev pressure chvjber to D-*chr.u? .» He, he didn't do that, q That's r-th-.r unusual, isn't it? .. It wasn't unusual in that case bee-use this chrrv.cr lire! net vet b.jj taken over by tho Medical Inspcctcra.to officially. Dr. ..uff had e^lrine*', and I can only repeat it, th't t!iis cha.nl -r hr 1 ' een sunt to the Gciucn Zxpurloentcl Institute fer ..vi-ti n fr;.. ih~ firn Zeuz^n in order tc ’ c equipped there with their latest cqui. iwit, such as breathing rnd cczxainic&ticu -.qui. ..-nt, rnd 1 -s th- c.vy-etcnt r-ferent for these questions, tack ever this oh oibor the aft of July -r lurin' tfc first dry s cf ..u exist, 19L2, in cell-bar tif n rith a c p* in ‘ the ::-dic-l Corps, Dr. Jmst Kcllcrst nn, • h. ccaiivrvul this i ct thTr h 'n -ffi- vit which _,r. Ruff has Ire ly su’. rdetod. : 'Ml the:, if I undorst s.-X ycu correctly, Doctrr, * il< ressure drearer 't Ruffs institute t Berlin-..dl-rsbw .ra n-t 27 ’.fc^tf-DJG-5-A-Krxrow (Herder) Ccurt 1 under tho supervision of the Ifediccl Inspectcrotc until July, 1942? Is that correct? 4 :.t any rate, not under tho supervision cf the r-ferat Aviation Icdicir.e. .-fter that I heard here, the -iodical Inspector had tc send the approval for tho transfer of theso chanters frea Berlin to Kunich. Q ’.ell now, when did ycu fccccse ~ cn what date — tho day end nrnth — did ycu tccoac ..ssistant Referent in the refernt fer ,.viation k’cdicino? ^ A I believe that was tho 8th cf August, 1941. 3 ..nd ycu then assumed, as one of ycur ncro iaertant tasks, this lew prossur- chasidi^ business, is that right? A I bcliovo I explained it in detail that I cansidcrod one of ray nain tasks tc to tho oedernizntien of the lew pressure chwabors. 3 Then, every low pressure choubcr in thb Luftwaffe was of intorost tc ycu, was it net? .. I bcliovo that one word was lest during tho interpretation and it was the word "ortsfest", ircx’cilc. Q ''Oil then, in ether words, ycu had nothing to do with tho .-.ebile low rrcasuro charabors? :fc Jurisdiction ever theso whatsoever? Court 1 Hay 8?-H-o-l-HD-..a loy-Roal c r. A. In that connection I have to tell you the following: the immobile lev pressure chambers had all been built before Che war, and for that reason were built in correspondence t. the reserrch regulations as they prevailed before the war as t-' their resistance to high altitude. During his insocct- tion in the year 19 1 Dr. Ruff had found out that those old Immobile low pressure chambers no longer sufficed for modern requirements. The modernizing of thlse immobile low pressure chambers b.came my main task. The noblle low pressuro chambers on the other hand were all bjllt during the beginning of the War. For that reason they all complied with :heso requirements I Just mentioned, so that it was no longer necessary to romodol these mobile low prossure chambers. In addition, the low pressure chambers wore all subcrdln-tod to the air fleet, were onnlttcd by the air floot in orucr to examine and instruct the pilots of the various flyln a jnlts. Fr>o the moment when by ordor of the Hodlcal Inspector'-to I took over this low pressure chamber, together with Captain Kolleram'*nn, this low pressuro chamber had als, buen subordinated to an air floot, and after a short stay in the Alps for research purposos was sent for lecture purposes to the Troops. Well, then in summation. Doctor, after nugust 19-il a had Jurisdlctl n ever the permanent low pressure chambers, but did not have -ny authority over tne mobile low pressure chambers and would not have Jurisdiction in any manner whatsoever /or the low pressure ch cber used at Ja.chau until July 1£42, but that prior to tna.t time the Jurisdict¬ ion ever that m/oile chamber was purely in the hands cf Huff and Hippke, is that correct? a. This entails such an enure us amount of individual quostkna that I cannot possibly answer it with Just one answer. 8106 • i Court 1 Hay 27-A-5-2-ED- ha loy-Raml e r. i,. You can answer just one of them; frist of all I vill ask teem individually; after August 1941 you were assigned the task o: remodeling low pressure chambers for the Luftwaffe, is that correct? A. Yes, Chle task was assigned to me. Thut duty assignment did not Include work on mobile low measure chambers'? A. No, not on notorized low pressure clumbers. When was the first time that /ou had anything to do with low pressure chambers, that 16 mobile low pressure chambers? A. Do you mean when I for the first time had anything :c do with mobile lo-’ pressure? 3. At any rate when did you have any Jurisdiction over - when did you h-ve any authority as referent in the ei’eret over tnese mobile low pressure chambers? A. You mean the mobile ones don't y u? «. The mobile? AS far as I roaombor that was approximately at the or.d of July 1942. *hen, in collaboration with the already mentioned Captain Kcllosnann, I took over the low prespuro evnvoy for Dr. Ruff. 5. Alright, then you h~d Jurisdiction over the mobile If. pressure chambers — pardon ce, *'e will qualify It, doctor — y.u had Jurlsdlctl n over the single aobllo low pressure chamber used at Dachau prior t? July 1942? «. I can nly toll y u vivt I maard hero. I heard that -r. ruff obtained the approval for the use of these chambers •r m Professor Hlppke. In other words, at that time he didn't c nslder himself competent en ugh to send this chamber " Daohru on his own Initio live, but obtained Hlppke's "-val for that. Sourt 1 Hay --5-3-HD-Maloy-Rrdor. v- Thor. Huff mi Hlppkc hod Jurisdiction over the low pressure chaaber and consider It In the ease light as an . rpfcan child? A. It me no orphan child. I would designate this circumstance as the birth cf the child. 3. Allright. Ye will go on. Doctor. Ir. connection *>ltk y ur testimony concerning research assignments within the Luftwaffe, whenever n research assignment order was Issued, and at this point I will not quibble with you about the originator of the orders, that is the person with authori¬ ty to give the orders, but vhon a research nsslgnov-nt was Issued, who aumllwd the funds to carry out that assign¬ ment? A. The. funds were auppllud by the Medical Inspectorate f the Luftwaffe, and after the 1st of April 1944 that wa6 d.nu by the Office of the Chief of the Medical Service of che Luftwaffe. i. Didn't your chief have anything to do with the funds at all? A. The Hoferat of «vlntlon Modlclnc had nothing to do •'1th the funds. There was a fteforat 3udget with Its own -dalr.lstrati ,r. stiff, and li was only tho task of the ?creronc for Aviation i-cdlclr.G t> s.lve the question In : porrtl n with tfc*. budget Ref.rent whether there was any- t-.ln -.gainst the reason given for any research work, ana • -o Budget Referent then c. r.f lrmcd his approval by making a el^n n th. origin 1 research assignment to that effect. !* w. Just a jonent. Doctor, It is my understanding - : -11 research cseignaents in the field of aviation ••-diclne had to pass throu B h the Refer^t for «vlation cine Office "fter May 1944, and prior to that time the - ice of Aiith.r.y who approved- ei;s Z -Tt 1 1 k: ; • 27-1—3- 4- I- Ma ioy-fiaml c r. A. Kay I Interrupt you shortly. I think you were say- in- 3fcy 1244, ware you? Ye3. Mow who approved the allocation of funds for Che orrticular research which was .rdered by the Chief of :hc Medical Services or by your office? -•v. In that connection I tiny point out to you that my ?.wferat did not order the furnishing cf these funds, but _r.ly sug_.est-a thorn. The approval for such funds was reserved for the ..odicnl Chief himself. %. V ow, wa r. getting d wn to something. Doctor. ’-'-'.on after it was determined that n research assignment oh.uld ce mr.de in th. field of eviction Medicine, the . novel for the assign nt w uld be made by your office, la Chat correct, because Profossor Shroeder certainly oouldn’t ltudy all these things. Ho was n busy nan. You would have to study the assignment and determine whether or net it was necessary at this time, inasmuch ns you had a lack of nnn- ; ov;or and a war going on; now, tho research assignment must have ‘coon approved lr. the fieferot for Aviation Medlclr.o wasn't it? A. I don’t quite understand what you said. Did you °°y it was ay Cn3k to appro-. . l rose- assignments. '■'ho approved tho research assignment wherein it was necessary to allocate funds to carry It out, who approved the sc? A. Tho appr vrl for any research assignment was reserved : v the Medical Chief and b fore for the Medical Inspector, w-s the task of tho Heforat to furnish the necessary data order to sake that decision. h In other words, the fioferat would suggest what - -isi.r. sh -.-Id be made? How, in y-ur position as Ref era t mter May 1Z44 lid you have tho now or t: pny sums of m.ney 6105 I Court 1 .Icy 27-I*-6-5-HD-MGloy-Hr.alcr. for experimental purposes? A. In my capacity ns Hefcrat with the Chief of Medical Services I did not have such authority. Z. Did your Chief, that is Professor Schroeder, knot* of what y.u were doing, did he have any idea of what your duties were? A. I would assume thrt. Q. Ke tells ne that you had the power of Attorney, nevertheless, to ray sums of coney for experimental purposes? Can you toll ae about the connection in which Professor Schroeder nr.do that statement. I think there mist be an error. Not a single referent could place his signature to a grant of funds. That could only bo done by the Chief of the Medical Services for any annual grants. ; - - f-7-l-..r „fcan (RtufLcr) ' rt I . Then it is your contention that Professor Schrocdor did r. i ns: bio job; is that it, ... I would rather believe that there izist have been so: a; other ndin" durina your conversation *.±th Professor Schroodor. ; v. S’.'i-j that Professor Schroder was v_ry veil versed irith his tas!: .anf a error could have been possible. . oil, nor, in those rcsoarch assignments, Doctor, when did /;v. first roport to Professor Rostock c'-nccrninp research assijrrxnts of tlw lufttraffof ... I rononbor one tira, that was in the sirrcr of 19ldi, vhon wj sent a list of all research assi arar.ts to Professor Rostock* office, cannot ivc you the oxact date, it could cithor have boon in July or c vst 19ldi. Q. *il Xf did you dond report® to Rostock's officoj ... If I r. j.abor correctly, I was ordered to do so by .y nodical cldc.‘rofossor Schrocdcr. I don't bolievo thoro was a roquost tiaclo by Rostock's office, hoaevor, I cam r.o lenyor tell with cortainty, '!• Veil, now, you received an ardor frc:i yoor nodical chiof to ■e.V. re.crts to Rrstcck in 19)ih; Is that correct? ... I pr for.b?;* df r. * <,ot -his rdor -.r-onnUy fron .y nodical aid.of, vt I at it fr » d. ?avt.fcntal chi l, rcrov v, in the final -a-lysis it did oc.v> >e- ).'a. It Did y-»u ua -»-s ’• • •- ' D was : f science an' r^a •..•eh *■? tki Roloh'C'.r ilssrr for ir.-s3.th and •‘•vv’.to i-o andor Dr .ir.an't? I think that 1 Saw: that at that tine. . iir- often did you send reports to Rostock? ... "uch collective reports, as t . r port concerning the 91 ' as. : r. .nts, —is only sent out onco as far as x rcrxcdjcr by f the - 'deal Sorbiccs. Inter on copies of lr . _ research asoin-ats ;:«a. sent to Professor Rostock*:; £111 27 - J-7-2-iehnr. (Ranlor: Court 1 > Then you sont a collective re pert for the first tirx to Rostock in 19hh and thereafter you sent Mr: a copy of each research -ric.-j is that riyht? i*08, he received a copy of these research asslyiaxnts issuod later. There roro only very, very fen, horovor. Did you sond hie a report on the sea-crater exporLnonts? ... I an suro that I did not, because that ras no research assi ruu-nt. i. Did Rostock have any reason to knor about the soa-aator cxpcriirents J A, I knot; of no such reasons. I. * ‘ore you ovor at a aootiny concerning the soa-ratcr oxperi- aonts and at such rxetiny a ropr. oontativw f Rostock vras present? A. It is possible that at the l-st root in that tooJ: place I think at the ond of Soptcuhor 1?U1: at thv Plnlrtum at tlx Coo, t/non rofessor loiylbocck ras spo.alriny a*x>ut the causo and the results of cripsriconts, a representative of IVofosoor Rostock was present. This is ruitc p sriblc• I knot- for cortain, he ovor, that Professor •'.- steel: ras not personally present. .. Do you knor rhothcr >r not ; ur .nx Accessor, Anthony, sent r-ports tv Restock? ... :b, I knor nothin of tliat. .. ou ’.-n't exclude th rssi i* ity, hevover? ... It is id lly i. ps33i :lu bocauso Rostock's off ico crux ' appearance only in the year cf 1 ?Ji!j. . It carx into appe-ranee in Jeneary of 191:3, lidn't it, - :c -or, actively? . I* ras in the curt:*- 2 1 me *. the office of R stock. r i%. lookin- at the ovidonee her , status the office ras dvon in 19l;3? , 8112 27 :iy-iK'aJ-7-.3-:fceh2n (Roller) Court 1 ... Yes, I believe I rcztubcr havin; hoard of here, but it al- • ays takes sons tire be for- any such office starts working. 0. It takes a rrholo year? ... '-ell, I can only say that froa zy point of view and as far as I could see, I only taow of Rostock's office in the year of 19Ui« . Q. ‘.loll, new these research assi^naonts which noro ordered by the chief of the Ocdical service or by tlu. nodical inspectorate, nc- eaaponing th- assi^nnent a certain anount of acnoy ra allocated; what did you direct cr '..-hot did the •‘cdical Inspcfctcrato direct tie re¬ searchers to do in the way of reporting? Did you have soar chock on just what was happenin': to your nonoy, A. Yes, fj. How often did you requost the particular scientist; how often die’, you roquire reports free the particular scientist? A. Arc you now speaking about reports rejardin- the research or rcjnrdinj the uao of the noncy? Q. Recording tho uso of the nonoy. A. Tho accounts regarding tho nonoy wore :r.dc at tho end of tho bud jet y-ar after th- nonoy had boon used. Only such anoint of nonoy was distributed as was expected to bo uood during thu course of cno year. .. How often did you requiro th-i: to report on the results of tiioi? research? ... l^st of the research i>:n wore asked to send half yearly re¬ port:, however this war not done in every case bccaussc considering -x situation at that tine thzro zzay net have beer, anything to report cv-r* half year. Enough confidence -as placed in the various res-arA ■•‘crkcro an- it was assuzszd that they uld r-port any r ay had they - iund anythin- worth . hilc, however, it was stated n the re-sozxch as- -i nexnts that they were requested te s-nd in repeals every half year/ !. Doctor, hen :’dd you first hear f th. hi h altitude oapuri- -r.tc r.t Dachau? 27 iJ-7-h—ooten (Ranlcr) Court 1 .. That was T-hcn Dr. Rasctor and Dr. r.oribor.- shcncd their filn r rather intended to she - their fill.', at General - r iold Marshall Cilch's -ffico. Q. Did you see the filn? ... Jfc, "ore you present? A* No. 0 . Do you knor who wa3 there? ... I knor it nor froa the documents submitted hero. 0. Did you evor talk to Dr. Bcnzin>r about it afterwards? A. Ho. 0. Do you know whother or not he saw the file? ... .’.ccordin tr the report by Dr. Ro.abcr;, rhich was outaittod horo, I ossuno that ho saw it. I cannot say ^ortain. Q. Did you hear any repercussions as a result of tho choiring of that fill? Repercussions, I know of none. Q* "ho infomod you that thox*c was to bo a rxotiny in tho R.L.!'., wherein a notion picture filn m3 to be shorn concerning hi?h altitude research? .. Darin ;y direct oxaninntion I explained that a telephone call tts uado that Jimin;, which I received in tho roforat that aerning to the effect that either Professor I Call -r his assistant Dr. Bruehl were 03kin" *.:hcthor re know any thing about a fill and a lecture re¬ gardin' high altitude experim ents, rhich was tc to shewn in tto Itoichs inistry for aviation. !. Tlicn Professor Kali: infers.' ycu; is that it? — H I have just said rhat Prefos-or Xalk told to .x, he said n - than that because that icopcncd before the fill ras shorn and that tine to of course knew none of the details. I can*t say thothcc it rac Pr-fess-sr Kalk -r Dr. Bru-.J., .. I utoerstand that this fil; in this rcctin- ms sup?.sod ta 8114 27 ^J-7-5-:iciiin (Ranlo*) Court 1 be - secret nutter; rras it not? I know nothinr of that one the only knowledge I hove ccr.es free, tho docuitnts suboitted here. 0. "cro you usually inferart of nil sccrot natters? ... I t depended --bother I hud to knew then or net. Haturally I learned about secret nutters during tho rrur. I ccrtlnly did not le-rn of all sccrot natter*. Did ynu leur of all secret nutters in the field of aviation n-dicinc? Cortainly not, fcccuuso I fetch*, cut about a nuubor _f then aftor tho war, which I did not knot; boforef. 0. Did y u learn cf all otters in tho field cf aviation uoli- cinc ofter the tix you beca.ro roforant f.r aviation aodicino? ... I cannot really answer this question because I don't know vUat secret natters existed. 0. If you did not know, who did? I d n't kn— what socrots there Wv.ro, oxcupt tho things I actually kxr rt -rdln tJxso tilings. I actually don't know : ho lwicw then. 2? Hay 47-M- .,X&-1- Co Ok- (Rannlor & von Schoen) Court 1 Q. Doctor, do you know Dr. xottenh: ff? .i. Xottenhoff, yes I nade his acquaintance In the year 1944. Q. Did he.have any connection with your orgmlzatloB? ... Yes, for a few days in the sunner of 1944 he was fer a few days with the cffico of the Chief of the office cf the C.dof of the Medical Service, but was transferred iamodiatoly thereafter. Q. Did you know hln before that tine? <». No, I did net know hln. Q. When did you first sake the acquaintance cf Dr. Kelts? .u Ky first personal aoaory of Welts dates back to July 1942. That was on the occasion of the aviation aod- lclno O/nference lr. Hamburg. I would assume, however, that I had soon hln before that tine sonovhoro. However, I c-m- qct give you an exact late. Q. Kill you toll no, doctor, a few nore details concern¬ ing your first aootlng with RaGCher, Just when UJ that happen? ... I think that that happened on the occasion f the conference between Klppko and Raschor, which, according to a iocuaent which I have seen here, dates to June 1942. Q. That Is Jur.a 1942? .u Y£s, Juno 1942. Q. Well Wiion did this nee ting - pardon no - where did this aootlng take place? This meeting between General Oborstabsartz Prof¬ essor Hippko and Raschcr took place at the office cf Profess r Hlppke. Q. ..t the office of Professor Hippko, how did you 8116 27 May 4?-x-«:{-8*^Cook-(Royaler k yen sehoen) Court 1 happen to be there? A. I didn't quite understand. Q. How did ycu happen to be there? •w I was ashed to attend the conversation, it was Goneral&rzt Dr. Marius, ay department chief, who ordered no to do sc. + * Q. Who ashed ycu? You say Dr. Marzlus ashed ycu to attend this meeting? a. Yes, Dr. Xarzlus ordered ae by request of the nodical Inspectorate to go there. This .fflco was Ju6t one floor below ay department, that is, under the dopart- □ont of Gonoralarzt Dr. Marzlus, and in this department our referat was located. Q. Do you any Idea why he ashod you to come to this mooting? •u Yes, I hnvo an Idea and I have alroady explained that luring ny llreot examination. Q. Glvo It to uo again? ... I rccolvod an order to gc down to Hlpphe with the files concerning the planned cold meeting In Hurnborg. Originally .jithony was t- go there but since he was nrt present I was to replace him. Q. Did you usu illy represent .wthony when he was not present? I didn't usually ropresent him but only on certain occasions, on occasions when my departmental chief ordered mo to do so. Q. I am ashing you what time, when did you represent o-.thony? a. Tnoro wore occasions, not times. Q. I soo. Now at this meeting between Raschcr and 8117 27 May 47—&-;^-Cook-(Ramnlor & Von Schoen) Court 1 Hippke, Rascher spoxe very clearly, did he not, about the use of concentration camp Inmates fer exporlmontation purposes? I don't remember him raving spoken particularly about concentration camp inmates. He mentioned that ho had received a spoclal commission for particular cases to use condemned criminals as experimental subjects, who could volunteer for those purposes, and to whom a mitigation of thoir sontence would be promised, as a result of such experiments. Q. Now, doctor, this meeting took place in June 1942 and the reason why you wore called to the mooting was tc make arrangements for the cold conference in Nurnborg in Ootcber, is that tho reason? No, I was asked to attend buoauae professor Hippko wanted information on what the individual members of tho Luftwaffe, who wore dealing with tho cold problem, would bo lecturing about. Ho wanted to recommend O no of thoao experts to Professor Rascher so that ho could got in touch with him. 'I. Did you gather from the conversation why Hippko w.nted to make the recommendation to Rascher, for vhnt reason? I assumed that Rascher asked him to name an export for coll problem. 3. Veil what lid R.3Chor want to Know that for? rt t that time I assumed and I still assume that Rascher wonted t, collaborate with a scientlest who had r.is own personal experiences in this field. x. That was the gist of the whole conversation - that Rascher was seeking an expert in the field of cold, from 27 Hay 47-K-.wC-&-4-Cooic-(Racier & Vcn schoen) Court 1 exposure, - shock from exposure to coll, is that it? - At any rata that was tha subject of tha conversation as long as I was present. I was only asked to attend the conference after It had already started and I left Profess-r Hlppke and Haaoher before the end of It. In other words. I was only present for a brief period during the middle of the conversation. Q. Then as near as I can gather there were two things you heard at this ooetlng between Rasoher and Hippke, No. 1. Raschor was seeking the collaboration of an expert in the field of freezing, and No. 2. Rasoher talked about th ° U8 ° 0f inaatoa Cho concentration oanpo for oxporlm- ontal purposos. That was only two things you hoarl at this mooting? A. Yob, those wore the two subjects, wherby I want to emphasize once mere that I don't remember Raooher using the word 'Concentration camp Inmates”. He usod the word “criminal Q- I see. Raschor mentioned the criminals that Himmler w>uli assign tc. him for use in experiments? 'fes, he was mentioning that. 5. Now, I assume you are an Intelligent young man. You have exhibited on the stand superior Intellect, were you not able tc ascertain at this meeting Raschor's Inten- Cions? *». I ion 1 1 know what you understand by Raschor's true intontlons. • Q. Couldn't you put two and two together and make four, namely, criminals on this hand and seeking an expert for 'roezing research on the other hand, and that the two of -non together make experimentation on human beings? 27 May 47-K-dX-8-5-Coolc- (Ranmlor i vor. Schcan) Court 1 -»• Certainly this was discussed very openly In Hlppko' presence and that is what I said during my Uroct examin¬ ation. One needs no particular Intelligence for that. Q.. Then you know in June 1S42 that experiments on human beings, condemned criminals, you say, wore to be performed by Dr. Rasohar and a collaborator? a. Yes, I said that during my llroct examination. Q. With tho approval of Hippko? •w Yes, with the approval of Hippfcc. I had assumed that. Mind you I didn't stay until the end of the conver¬ sation but since Hlppke discussed the matter with Rascher I hal assumed It was with his approval. Whon was tho next tlno you hear! about the freezing experiments? a. The next tlmo was In Nurnberg, at this discussion here about distress at sea and winter distress on tho 26 th and 27 of October 1942. Q. Who arranged tho Nurnborg ccnforonoe? •». Tno preparations for this mooting wore rondo by the referent. That was Profossor .jithony at that tlmo and I had a few duties of an organizational nature, for exam¬ ple, four woe/. 3 bo fore this mooting I was here In Nurnberg for day or two and Investigated hotel possibilities and arranged a row other questions, such as for tho hall for tho meeting and equipment and so forth. Q. Then you wore on tho commltteo for tho arrangements of the meeting In October 1942? a. Tr.ore was not a commltteo. The preparations for tha meeting, not only this meeting, but all of the tvolvo meetings of this nature which tho Luftwaffe held, were always mado by the referent because he was in charge of * i7 May »2C-&-&-Oook-(aanmldr & Von sc ho on) Court Ho. l discussions later and I had organizational taste, Just as later, for oxanple in lSi-i, i assigned such duties to soao one else. ei 21 Court 1 Kay 27-M-9-l-KD~3roes-Von3chon. Yet y - were raking all these ' rrnngc=cnt6 i'or hall n.d for chairs, etc. You didn't know what the meet in.. was .* v? A. I didn't sav thrt I didn't know that. I knew the subject. I knew 3jre~ or less the program of the lectures. k. Did y u know Raaoher was going to lecture? A. No. Th t was not expected. The report on this meeting indicates clearly that Rasoher'e lecture was a so-called discussion remark - it was not a pi. nr.ed lectui'c. Z. I see. Yell, now, doctor, on page 77 in Document 5-ok II. Do you have the Gorman Document 3vok II before y.u? This la Document 343-n-PS - a letter fr->n Erhard Kilck to Wolf and is the "Door Wolffy letter". a. Yes, I have that. Yes, I have the doounont. Q,. Now, in this document 1 note thrt ill 1 oh states lr. the first paragraph about seven lines down from the top "These h^ve been pr^red in immediate agreement with ov'.por offices; Ooorstabsarzt Voltz will bo charged with the exocuti n and Stabarzt Rascher will be mode nvnilnblo until further order in addition to his duties within tho helical Corps of tho Luftwaffe." This is concerning tho institution or the initiate n of the freezing experiments. Car. you tell me rr.d the Tribunal how Kllcn received lnfor- aati n th*t r oltz and nascher w -ula be good non to put on t/.is assignment? Who would advise ftllch in that matter? a. Unfortunately I cannot give y u that information. - car. only refer to what .-rofessor .-ll-pke said as a witness * C:._ Trial n-cp.inst field Marsnal iiilch. I know no more :.'.r\r. t.:at and it Is not quite clear to me ho:* at the end • such n letter could h-ve been written. Up to this :ri 1 I had believed that when Rascher talked to Kl pke '.-use experiments were discussed for the first time, but 8122 Court 1 Ihy 27-K-9-2-HD-Gross-VunScbon. here I see It must have been discussed three L.i. 1 . .-j;— weeks before hand and must have been discussed by various people. ?„ .ire y u certain then of the date that you have _lven us about the meeting between Kippke nr.C Hascher? ::ight it be possible that that sooting took place two or three months before the date y >u have 6ald, Juno 1942 you have said? Might it bo possible the talk took place in /arch, April, or onybe six months before, or oven the summer before, Juno 1941? That might fit into all these plruis. «re y^u certain of that date - June 1942? A. In June 1941 I was not yet an assistant referent in the Medical Inspectorate. I was in Roucnnln at that tine. ... Could it have boon in August 1941? £. That is quite impossible. I roaonber It as much later. I thought that this Rascher-Klppko talk, where I xaa portly pioscnt was in the middle of the summer, perhaps iJly or august of 1942. 5ut According to Document NO-283, Exhibit 80, Raochor's letter to Klmaler, it has the rl 6 ht Jato and fits in with the rest of the documents on£ as far “ i can Judge moans that this mooting was on 12 June 1942, :ocr.uso cn the 15 Juno Hascher writes to Himmler - « fow days Ago I was called to the Inspector of the Luft- liedical Service, etc." and since I was prosor.t at ••ly one conversation between Kippke and Hascher this must tho one he is talking about here. • i. Vail, didn't it seem to you that this meeting : -:v;con Hascher and Hippke, that this was the first time 1: ~ J h-.d discussed this problem, that is what I goth.red :r - your testimony? That had been my impression - that that had boon the Cj • 7 ,-vr 27-j -3-H J- Jrose-V •nScbon. first that Hi- k* t-.lked to Fischer -xb et it. I .lad the ! ..-I'cajl^n that Hip tc baa known Rase her before, but I ,_ht this ■'is the first tine they hed talked possibly. ... Veil, then the testinvny of Veltr was enlightening u when «'eltr t Id us he had discussed the ore bleu wit.: Kippke hineolf in the susner of 1941? a. Yea, X neard that. However you still ar.intain that the date of June 1942 when the teeting between Hi. he and Raacner tooh -laoa? A. Yes. ... Your Honor, I night suggest that wo could have a en oinute recess if it sect* with the a rovnl of the Tribunal. THZ 1RZ3IDENT: Very well, the Tribunal will be In ecesG for - few ainutoa. ei2i 27 4-iy-11-l-GJ-«alqy-(von Schcen)- Ccurt 1 THE MARSHALL: Inc Tribunal is agin in session. THE P RB S TE BMT: Counsel nay proceed. BI -ffi. HARDY (Continued) Q Dr. Scckcr-Freyscng, how often in the course of professional business in the Office of- the nodical Inspector of the Luftwaffe, did Professor Hippko refer to the referent of Aviation Medicine in regard to natters pertaining to that particular field? A I an afraid that is 2 question I can't answer. I could say how often Hippko called no, for instance. Q .ell, he c lied you in; how often? * Not very often. I would estimate that it was five to 10 tines but I wouldn't want to give any definite figure. It was certainly not oft-nor than that. ^ How often did Hippko concern hinsolf with natters in the field of Aviation Ltdicine without referring to the referent? A Very frequently I an sure. I alone of quite a number of nat- tere, where Professor Hippko for uxaaplo, delivered lectures on avia¬ tion Bodicin^. Q How do you know about;then ? A Because I hoard then later. Q He n^v.r reported to you.about then cr told you about then cr asked your advice about then? A These are V o questions, you is/ no first, whether Hippko re¬ ported to r.e, - no. It is r.;t custc&ary for the bo3s to rop^rT'lo his subordinate, and ho v-ry addon asked a. for advice-. The referat was Antr.ony. There is an old German saying that you siK>uld get to the Black¬ smith end not to his apprentice and during Anthony's tin- Anthony tod - i. balcks.aith. Cnly when *nthony w:s not there or when it wassomething v^ry ap.cific that I had worked with th_n f rof-ssor Hippk- called nc. For • -x-xple, at the discussion have Just bo-n talking about. Q h.n I presun- whenev-r Professor Hippko concerned hicsclf 27 Asy—J-GJ-ll-2-4Lo 1 oy-( von Seho.n)- Ccurt 1 ir. in the field of Aviation .iedlcine ohat h_ would consult with Anthony, that was the reason why he hod antheny then.? « I con't quite answer this in the affinaativo, because I know of cases when Professor Hippke dealt with aviation oedepin. questions .viesoil without consulting Anthony. Q How could your office, that is Anthony have efficiently per- feraod his task in the assi^ncaent without have ccapletc knowledge of the activities in his fi-ld. a In ay explanation of the duties of the referent, which is very thorough, I said that the n.fercnt worked on the orders of his superiors " d of course it happ n.d froe tin. to tie*, that these suporiers acted iiidoponiontly on an aviation aridccino question without consulting the referent for aviation acdicine. Q iVoll, now you toll us that it was your understanding in these expurinente that criainals condemned to death Were to bu used, is that correct? a I don't believe I said that. 1 said that convicted crininals r-.re used. I-rco that discussion, between Hippke and Roschur I didn't know of anything ibeut the persons condcnnod to death, and I never said 30 . A ‘hat is your opLiion about the ability of a person incarcera¬ ted to volunteer for an ex? rinent? a I 3i.«uld l:ko le refer again to ry d lives cxnn.lnitlon and repeat briefly that ir .j. rsl pllcc frj . * orta cf c or aaa and foreign werks, I know fa* throughout the wcrld the possibility is rcco- Ini zed for prisoners to volunteer. Q I cc not interested in the possibility throughout the world; 1 tc * tn: " ?^cJa.r-?reyscng's pinion, what do you think -bout the- -s-ioility cf Parser, incarcerated in prison to volunteer for an cx- =*risuat? a l«y -rscnal opinion is that under the conditions on incarcara- - b-rser. v luatcers r.adily for such n experiment whei a special niti- 27, ay-.-.-G J-ll-3-imloy-( vonSchocn)- Court 1 ration of sentence is premised to bin, and even if no such pronise 1 ; ondc, because he can assume that by participating in such an exp^-ri- n-nt ho will put himself in a good light in the ey-s of the parole b; rad, and nest of the -prisoners would K. intcreSt.d in that. , tVcll, nor: yew issued or ordered the sea-water cxixricents, or initiated then, or whatever nomenclature you wish to adopt; you have told us you nove accepted th_ responsibility for the sea-wattr ex- p-rinents, and in the sea-water experiments that used concentration c.rp innattS; those inmat,s were criminals, c nvictcd criminals; did ycu approve of using convicted criminals in those txp.rincnts? n I rant to correct on e thing first, I said oven today I take responsibility for the- sca-witer »xperin.nta, that is the responsibility rhichws due \c at the tine according to zy position as referent, to ecru back to ycur question - Q Just a accent, Doctor. In connection with that if you assume responsibility for the sea water experiments. Then you did .nticipate :r .rculd you state that Anthony nould or should assume responsibility for -.11 t!.„s- .xperinents performed cn behalf the Luftwaffe, — that is that rr.pp-.nod prior to iLny, 19Mi? A I cannot say that, because I don't knew what part .mthony had an the planning or suggestion of these experiments. Q You Just stated Doctor, you ascur.e full responsibility for water experiments t-cause of your position as refer-.nt in the Refc- ratSf Aviation L'edicir.e, new by the sea, tnk_n don't you think it pos¬ sible that ..nthony should accept responsibility ef the -xp-rl-.onts was tr ught ha. to th. Ref era t? •* -'^der this Lost condition I believe Anthony would still take tn_ r sporisibility today, but I should like- to paint cut that I naku a distinction between the scr. mkr experiments and other experiments ~ i-ir as the p.rticipaticn of the Re-ferat for Aviati n Medicine is ccn- r -rr»_d. I this fr . th-_ documents submit t_d by the Prosecution, and 2 ■' ~-y-GJ-ll-h-*alcy-(vonScjccn)- Ccart 1 1 dc act bull-vc Anthcny wculd tike the resp nsibility fer experiments ilch he n-ver suggested or In the planning of which he participated, cnc can take responsibility cnly fer things which one plans cr sugges¬ ts cr carries cut ones self. Q vYculd you assume responsibility fer the sen water experiments? Cr.e must assume that have had jurisdicti:n in order to assume responsibi¬ lity “ I believe in the course cf cy direction examination 1 ex¬ plained ay responsibility very carefully. I did net have jurisdiction r.:r independent sup.,rvisi'n, but I had sine- tnerc was nc ether pos¬ sibility for carrying out these sea water experiments, and since ay .wn plan which I mentioned of tr-ating a group of the Luftwaffe at ^-terbeg in order tc have experimental persons at the dispos il at jry convinicnt time. This plan was rejected by ray superiors, 1 pointed at that as a last possibility that these experiments, which I considered completely hamleas, and I take the responsibility of that — Q o’e will ccao to the sea water phas- a little later. 1 wnnt t; gc back tc the subject cf volunteers used in your sea water experiments .'-a kn-w they w-ro going tc use ccnvictod criminals, that is what you 8^..-steed would take place that convicted criminals wore t_ be used in th, experiments? a Yos. ^ And what did ycu understand would be the reward given to convicted criminal for subjecting himself voluntary to the sea ^ter oeperiaont? « In the ease cf the sea rator exp-rimen*. he never mcnticnod special re-wards. I said before that 1 can imagine that a criminal lur.teers,-not cnly fer a special r-ward, but also without sucj a r_- - r '- -here were sovcral reasons — Q «nd ycu,are net sure whether any reward;were offered? .. I knew that ‘refoss-r Bcigelb.ck procured special cigarettes 5123 27 -ay-J-GJ-H^5-*-alojw(voaSch on) Ccurt 1 riticns for these pc«L. and give thc-o t thee, end that be triud tc g^t ether regards. I'rof-ss-r Pcigclbcck will tell you about that himself. k Did ycu set hie give the cigarettes to the prisoners? “ Since I was never in Dachau I did net sou that. I have already stated. Q I n as nu c h as ycu were talcing full responsibility for the sea inter cxperin.nts do ycu think that it would have been =uch butter had y.u though abcut the cutters cere Seriously and effuTud a reward to the pclitical prisoners that vcluntcercd for the cxpuric.nts or offered a reward U perhaps a Jew incarcerated in a concentration coop fer ha¬ ving c:naitt.d Rassenschando, rather than offering a reward to a criai- a -1 The night go cut ano be a c-nacc to the public again; didn't that •ccur t' ycu? Ycu art a clear thinking young roan, cr weren't you intc- r.ated? A I oust tell ycu that ay chief, Profusscr Schreed.r, as is true with the Rcichoarat of the SS Police, t:ld ac that he had talked *-. Grawitz about soldiers unwrrthy for nilitary service being used : r these cxpcrlnonts. «s far as I knew everything -lse was clininatod v.c-.usc I had nothing to dc with tho s.lotion cf the sublets nor with t.S„ question of reward. Besides I an convinced that if I had suggested •hat political prisoners be used for these oxpcrlncnts tho prosecution T.uld uso that as a special charge against ne tc*ay. Q Toll, now in the field cf high altitude research ycu have '-stifled here quite extensively cencarning the adaptability ;f uxp-ri- -at:.. subjects tc high altitudes, in.snuch -s y.u art on uxp_rt in ■i.is field, a can who has d-ne c nsiderablu r rk in Huilcclberg since •Jil uni of the war in oxplcsivu occrs^rossian, can yu tull eh* cany* "-:-s an average individual can undurg a high oloitude -xp-rL-a.nt ondin - s P iCc c * h: can undergo said cxp-riner.ts b-frr. hu b.CGncs to high altitudus? •' 1 d_n,t too* *<-ru y.u gut tho idea that I had dlle t L\ U j - rticipatc in this -tiscucsicn. On lr.ee 11 cf dccu;:.nt beck 3, this ic 1 .cumait 3W-IS. .;e 12, I . sorry, this is document .Jo. 203, that is the leW fr i --h- r the T eichsfuchrer c-r.ccmi;,. the -asi-TU.-oct f Joriscii, lslcchn-r -r.d Singer t. v. rk :n th- . r ':1m rf freosir..*;; c ycu ti. t letter, teeter? * * |t .. I have the photostat f the cu-e.-.t, yes. . ‘ as Jr-risch in the Luftvnffc? - T1 * is is Trefesser Jrrisch, h- had nr office r pcsiti. . in 1 Luffrffe. • Kclzlc-hn-r in the Luft rffc? 9135 27 - ’ -JG-12-4-I&.chrn (v a Scb- r.) %urt h'c. 1 Klslcchn-r n"s a Stitsarst or O' crstmbs-.rzt in the Luftwaffe, -i .-6 Sincer in tho Luftwaffe? .. I have learned here that Singer v-s a Luftwaffe prthrlorlat in JAlnich. I believe in the research assi. 7 r.ncnt list there ktjj acme ro¬ se rch essifisacnt jiven tc Sinner fr. 1 vhich I have aeon, ho si't have been an ObersteLsnrst durin the war. I dc net knc*. hi-i . ers: nelly an-: I bed n chin, tc Zc with hia. 0 Itaschtr was ir. the. Luftwaffe? .. Yes, Rnschor im a Str/ 3 -rat in the Luftwaffe. q ‘ oltz wes in the Luftwaffe? .. Yes, that hr 3 been established here. -1 Tore th- freezing experiments rt Dachau Luftwaffe cxpcidncnts -r SS ex. orients? *. ..cccrding to '.hot I heard at the tine fr'a Rrschor, 1 theu^ht they rore iofinitely ftaachox’s experiments, based cn specific crier rnl np Tovd cf Kijxsler. ' here did Heclzlcohner report cn th uc* urinents, or rather Roaoher; hero did he re,crt ab-ut hi 3 wert:, lid ho reprrt at the October Booting in Humbert? .. The experiments wore reported only and exclusively to H ii an le.'. ftischor hr. 1 obtained , orsdssicn from Hi-nlor tc speak at tho loctur-,. -he s-ryviatcr experiments were n tep secret natter and he tveo t«. ivo caly a mi eh inferoatien as necessary. » Th-t ncetinp in October in tarnberg was a Luftwaffe a etir. ; •-3 it a t? .. Yes, it nr. s Luftwaffe n.otinj cr c. nee tin; or. '.'chrlf ci tho ;vlic"l ir.rpcctcrr.to cf tho Luft..-ff j» “c ycu knew '.here Jnrisch is new? .. I as suae that he is in I nn s b ruck. c .c ycu knew where Hclzlcehncr is new? net, I he'd he ".rs 'lead. 3134 I ' 27 I ch^(von Sc-.cn) Ccurt 3 Q ycu kncv thct he c.crittcd suicide? .. I hoe Pi that, y<-s. 'i *.cs the c-usc fer his suicide his portidpoticn in these coc -ri~.er.ts? l. I :’cn»t knev, I cculd act scy, Q Thio is c -cod brockin’ point, Y^ur He nor. TTZ rRESIT Z~: The Tribunnl vill ' e in r-coso until ls30 this nftcrnc n. („ rccoss una token until 1^30 heurs.) 27 Ifey 47-».-DJG-1/.-l-Ccck (Raaalcr) Court I AFHWIOON SESSION (The hearing reconvened at 1345 heurs 27 Hey 1947) THZ l.S&uLi The Tribunal is again in session. TK2 iRESDSHT: Counsel mtj proceed. BECKrR FKETSE.NG - Resumed CROSS EJUlfBL.TICN - Continued BY Ift. H.U.DY > q Dr. Becker Freyseng, in Juno 1942, luring the course cf the conference between Frefosser Kiprkc and Dr. haacher did tho nanoa Dr. Jeriach, Dr. Hclzlcohncr and Dr. Singer ever appear cr ever ccuc into the conversation? I dc net r counter the noc ef Singer because ho never played any prrt in -ir force rcsc.-rch, Hc»ever, the n-mes Jarisch an' Holzloohntr wore mentioned rt least in ay prosenco lecauso !>cth the -jo n-mcc cculd bo found on r. liat cf these whe had to lecture during the planned meeting about emergency aca matters. I never horxl at a later deto that .ra- feaacr Sin er in any "ay icrkcd cn the scientific cold questions. Q New let us refer again, doctor, tc decuaent No. 2S3, that is a letter free haschor tc the Koichsfuchrcr. It is on pr.go 12 of English document beck No. 3. This letter, as ytu knew is dated 15 June 1942 and reads as follows: .. I may correct you, it ic really June. Q I said Juno, I am sorry: "A fow days age 1 was erderei tc a c.nferoncc with the Inspector of the Luftwaffe Uedical Service, General Oberstabaarzt i'rcfosscr Dr. Kippke. :ihon I told him you had net yet rccoivcd the report concerning the experiments as a whole and you still had tc givu permission for thv reportTha cf the results, he lid net rsk fer any report. Tnc In- >>\ specter was extraordinarily kind aivl ask~d ae as liaison nan with the SS tc express tb jjV:, esteemed Rcichsfuehrer, his private thanks fer the experiments." * C136 27 hay 47 -„-L£r-2-3k.>- Cook (Rasnler) Court 2k>. 1 2 .’cti is it your contention Dr. Bicker Iroyseng that this nesting 30 ra roforro-. to 'y HaseVr was cV auotin* botseen Rase her or.. Hipoke at uh-icfc yew -.lore resent? I would SS3U3J so, yes. C. Ka* tho letter goes.pn to say, doctor: ^At th- aa._ ti -j .V (which r«.f^rs to General Oborstabeorzt Profess or Hipoko) asked for p^r.cissio.n to c^rry out t.V cold oix- )»at«r erp.rltents in Dachau and ssVd that the following bj in the*, vxpcric-nts," and Uxroin v. note -hro. naxv.3, Jarisch, Hslsloohrwr on’ binder. Kw during tho course of tho conference did you .Vnr or did the .xttcr cooo r> thet it would be n»cosoary to .ngugu a pathologist to caeiat and coll.'urate with Raachcr and. i.oltlo-hn-r r whoever wns picked or chosen to ::ork with Raachvr? A. No, th.olo 1st was not eiscursu in ay pr«3enco. Q. ft. 11, new, c.3 a Oidical *..n utr.t 'lould bo tho purpos for ~ssignir. a pathologist to this research dutiiil? A. T V )ur os. lor that .:ayvar;/, boc-.uao for ocov.rij»-ntrl pathology a nvudwr of papers iwr- written by ao in collaboration -.;ith r.toolo.ista orri 1 therefore sewowhat informed about this a vcl- l fora of pntholo I n.ver .Vard t.Vt .’rofessor Singer :.t -ny tljo conc.rn-d hics-L ,.ith cold questions. When I saw that dociMont Vre for tho lirbt ti-v I mj very 3urcris.d. It srya tho n*raj of Singvr. At no ti« boforu had I se r. th.-t nra- in conn-ction ..1th ’:'.ld or 'ny other air force research work. Q. '.lit t ro thu duties of • oatholo ist in Gernon aedicino? A. T;»c ’uti-c of the octholo. 1st re tensive and varied. *•“ Bain task o£ c .ethologist is to Oe-arch XortV c;usu on’ the • - liuCt of thj illness on th- living orfenisn. for instance, i.f part ‘ bad tisr-u- is j oir£ cut out during n oovration rrd if IV •- --icing physic! n-:ants to knew vhother there is cancer. this ;-rt hiiyz r.rk. to ih. o-thnlogiot. On the oth-r hatf*, Vnev.r f!37 27 Hay 47 -..-14-5- Cook (Pannier) Court Ho. 1 any patient dies, cn autopsy is very oftonbeing carried out in order to clieriy find cut the cause for the illness and the death. I have r Irocd y told you that aodom pathology in x rticular performs a great nuobor of cnxuriatnts. For instance, cninel locpurlaants, end ov-n -ftcr this letter 11 does-not 'x.cou. rppor.nt to -w *t .■’ll that jr. Lipilo :t that tine counted on death coses cur ins those wspuriasnts .'u t becue- he ask-d pathologist to particip a tv. It is cuite oosoiolb that ho nontioned tills nemo of winger to Rtachor ir. ore or to got then into contact with one another since he know perhaps, tSfct Singer hod particular inf oration in thit I i-ld but I knew nothin about that o-rsorr.il/. Q. Ilan 70U exclude th« possibility that ?rofes:or Hioplio vac fully \.:rsi of the fact th:t death die' rosult froo theo. -no- i-ionts at Dachau me* that it was n-c-ssrry or would b- n_ c _ s e ~ry to hrvo c pathologist on it so that ho can perform an autopsy in ordor to dotercinu th- cause of death. I c nnot oxcladu that possibilit bo cause as a result of the i 11-0 41 ch I xvac :n<3 hich roro suaaitt-d during the Iri-1 of Uilch regardin', arolcssor Klppku, I can sou ?rofesoor Kippkc , 2Cc, which is "’rosuoution irhibit 86, to be 1 ounl on peg- 22 of the ax lioh. This i3 a r-s.'rch order on ir-voing to Holaloohner: A. Yen, I have th- eocunent. C;. 11a: *.io see our fil- r.ot tion, that is the r.uaber 55, th«n rrbic 2, r.c .n numeral II 3, those re ih. file nuaberc of -d-t office, in dvl ri at? ... Sir.co :to to concernad with ti«e year of 1942, tv.is is fcho refvrnt Anthony Iwre I was working, that is correct. Q. And .that tin. Anthony was ref. rent nd you wt.ro ssictnt ny* r-f. r_nt? 27 ila y 47 -ir-Ur-Jr-?-?- Cook (Sasnlsr) Court j»o. 1 A. Yos, that is true. i. Then is it true that t.is letter criginntod from Anthony's of: ice? A. Yv8| it c -to from the refemt. Q. I mo. ell nowJ rote in th- first parr-grr.phjift-r.. >be‘ salutation there ia the foliating lsnguage: "The msx ctorct- of the Medical i^rvice of the Luftwaffe !r.a given order .or roseorch to tho Stebserzt .’rofeasor It. Kolzlo-hncr, r- ferenco .'’jovo| doted 24 February 1942, . or work on the following problems '"The effect of lreuzinc on w .aro-bloodud subjects. 1 " Her/ did this order for rose.irch to Professor kolcloehrv-r initiate from 70 nr office 1 ? A. I canaot tell you that from ay o n I-nowledyu. Dr. n??d: Hr. ('resident, in order to avoid any nisu:x!er- st.rdlns I .ucy coax-nt or that docura-nt a follows: It was quoted h»r. : "Th- effect of freezing or. warn blooded subjects." Object, Iw.eVoT, must be understood an meaning tho human being in Ux. canon ussgo of tho relish language. Perhaps th Interpreter would do kind enough to confirm that warm blooded beings as it is stated in th- German docurxr.t book, in other words " Tabluetor" does ;vot limit itself to the human beings but Iso extends to t!ie -nifl.il. In other words, it cuans every being which has warm blood flowing in it'3 veins. I on r king this remark now b-c uik the very uaae nisunderotanding rose r eCer.tly during direct •-•xanixv tior. and on that occasion the interpreter was kind enough to canfira that this tr nsl tior. wns not correct. H should rood, nc' I quote: "On wen blooded beings”. Perhaps I may sk the interpreter *hoth-r he thinks this interpretation is more mxitoble. THi ZLZSJDZ'.iT: l.iil th- Interpreters give their opinion •••a t;.e matter? I'TiHT?. Yes, Your Honor, the other dry defense counsel S139 27 Msy 47 Cook (Hsalur) Court Ho, 1 -sk^d for cpinion nhcn I suggested thrt interpretation to hia, it should o. ■ orn blooded beings, instead of ^orz. blooded subjects 27 Kay 47_IjC_15-l-C-T08C (lhtj| Ba-ler) Court I ^ I new continue, doctor. It is immaterial to Prosecution whether that is subject or whether it is toeing, I eight add. But did this reee-rch order to Professor Dr. Eolzloehncr initiate from Anthony's office? A This research assignment wee handled by the referat Anthony because certainly becomes apparent fron the number of*that research assignment ifcove t^ere. In addition I already mentioned repeatedly that aviation medical assignments were necessarily handled in the refe^ rat for aviation medicine. Here ve were clearly with such a problem. H How, we will note the next paragraph, doctor, which reads ao follows: "At the proposal of Stabarzt Dr. Raecher appropriate examina¬ tions were made of husain beings, and in agreement with the Beichsfuchror SS suitable facilities wore used for the examinations.'' It continues on: "In order to carry out those examinations a research group "Hardships at Sea" was set up, consisting of Profess Dr. Holzloehner as loader and Stabcnrzt Hr. Raschor and Dr. Flnke." How, might I gather fron reading this document th* the reforat for aviation medicine was fully aware of tho activities in which Raschor, Finkc, and Holzloehner wero engaged in at Dachau or might I acouno that their work was merely working on actual cases of persons rescued from thO BOB? A I didn't puitc understand your question. Arc you asking me now about the meaning of the research group "Distress at Sea"? Tot. A I cannot clearly answer your cues*.ion fron my own knowledge ^ because I don't knew whether at this tine, in the summer of 1942, Pro¬ fessors 3olzlcchner, Rancher and Finke were at the channel coast and were working on "distress at sea" questions. I know that a number of other researchers were sent to the channel by Anthony end Hlppke in or¬ der to gain experience. I do not know whether Holzloehner, Plnke and Rancher were among them. 27 Hay 47-A_JjC*l5-2-C-ross (1st., Baalcr) Court I * '■'ell, than I subnit to you, doctor, this possibility. Aaeunc for the scsent thi« research group of Eolzloehnor, Finke, and Hp.echer, as outlined In this docusent, were working as a research group on the sea shore, on the coast, with actual cases of persons rescued fros sea.- In as nuch as the document Is signed by Anthony would you assunc that Anthony was aware of the work being perforacd by Eolzloohncr, Ilnkc, and PaocherT A I«t ne say at first that this letter was not signed by Anthony,. Anthony only certified tho true copy. Ct I roall-e that, doctor. He olgned the true copy. He cuot hovercad It to sign It. Bo you think that he had knowledge of those activities? A I would assuao so because I hac nado a little file notice about the conversation betveon Hippie, and Bascher which I handed to Anthony when ho cane back fron hlo vacation. He then continued to doal with thio natter. k Then on tho faco of this docusent It Indicates to us that It originated froa Anthony's office and this further that out - we see Anthony's signature appcrrlng on the docusent. How, Isn't It true that Anthony's office ordered Professor Holtlochncr to work on this particu¬ lar subject and, in fact, set up this research group of Kolzloohner, Raochcr, and Flnkc? A I an sure that the refarat wag no*. In a position to do that. Only Hlppkc was in a position to issue such an order. k But, doctor, .it has the initials and the code, flic nusbers, of Anthony's office on the order. *hat arc they doing there? Hippko doesn't write out an order and put down the flic nusbers of Beckor- Preyseng's office. He puts down his o«n file nusbers. It sta.tes here in the first paragraph that “The Inspectorate gave an order for research to Professor Eolzlochncr,.reference above*, and the reference that • appears above is reference Ho. 1 and it has *55 there as the file rus¬ hers of Anthony '3 section, isn't that true? A Ho, that is not true. 81L2 27 Kay 4 7-A_F »C_15-3-Btobb (Int*, Busier) Court I I suppose that you are going to tell me now reference Ho. 2 le the reference referred to In that paxapraph. That is the only way that you can slip out, doctor. A Ho, nc, no. I think in ay direct examination and also yes¬ terday I discussed the- fill notices in great detail. I nay repeat once more. The reference So. 55 and lib 6hov th>t this asslgnaent vps worked upon in the referat for Aviation Kedlelno and I repeatedly stated that all the original rcsoarch assignments as far as they vcr< not aero continuatl-ns had to be signed by the Medical Inspectorate or the Chief of the Medical Services. ^ Hell now this report that is aentioned here in this document la undoubtedly the report which Eolzloehner was to deliver at the October netting. Io that a correct assumption on ny pert, doctor? A ihat passage of the document arc you roferring to? H I an referring to the sixth paragraph which reads as follows? "The research documents and an extonslve report will be presented to the Boichofuehrer-SS by Stabaarzt Dr. Hascher. It is requested that the origlnalo or copies of the report and of the documents bo put at the disposal of the Inspectorate of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe. "It io intended to sake the results, in the fora of an extract, accessible to experts at a conference which will take place in Hurnborg on 26 and 27 October 1942. The daily schedule of the conference is enclosed." How f then, as a result of this order fron Kippkc Holtloehner, Bascher, and Fluke are to give a repo-t tha* is a concise report at the Humberg Fretting Conference in October, isn't that the gist of thin docuaer.t? A Were you talking about an oral report? Or e brief report? Tea, in thio letter by the Bcichofucfcrer-SS'e permission is asked that the results of 'he experiments be published at Hurnberg. *4 I sec. Hell, now ve win proceed to the- report which weB published at Humberg. This i* Document H0-401, I believe. 27 May *7-UjC-15-A-Gro«8 (Int,, Ee=lcr) Court I A Tea, I have it. It la to he found on pa#-* 79, of your Honor's Docuaent Book, Docuaent Book III, Prosecution ixhibit f93. If you viu turn to the second page of this report, doctor, the section referred to as the "Contents". c go down to IV, headed "Trcetnent of ?roen Persons" and we acc there tho nance of Jarisch, Veits, and Eol-loehr.cr. A r e those the sane gentleeen we have been discussing here this norning? A I only know one Professor Jarisch and this is the one. Then we have Professor Veit* here who is sitting in the dock and then there is Professor Holtloehncr whoa we have discussed here. << Sow wc go down to VI which is entitled "Measuroe to conbat Thirst". V© see thore the rare Schaefer. Is that the sane as the defendant Schaefer? A Yes, it is the ease. H Schaefer was at this nectlng, was he? A Yes, he was present during thatasoting and he held a lccturo about conbat of thirst. << Did ho participate in any other phaso of this nocting? - A Voll I an sure he didn't participate in any of tho discuss ions. I cannot say whether he was present during tho loctures. At any re. to I don't roneabor it. Ho had never had anything to do with tho questions of frooting and cold, vi Sow we go down to VII and under there wo see 5, the nano of Euebnor. Is that one and the sane Huobner as tho Huobnor implicated with Bppirgcr in the sea water experiments? A So, not only is it a different nen but hie name is different. This nan here is H-u-e-b-n-c-r and the Professor whoa ay departnent chief asked for advice about the sea wat*r experlacnts is not Huebner, it is Ssubncr. They are t«o entirely different persons. Ccurt No. 1 27 Hay 47-A-16-i-LE>:-Harrcv (Hanler) Q. Nov, the na=e Just above that, »4. Doorfler. Who is that? Do you know that gentlercan. A. I think I have teen bin once. That vat on the occasion of that Suernberg seating. He was e caotain in the Kedical Corns of the Luft- vaffe and hod been connitted as a physician near the channel coast in sea distress sorvice. That is all I cen tell you about hla. Q. Wo note on the next page, doctor, the first nenc is Anthony. A. Tet. Q. And thereunder, we go dovn to *7. That is your none. A. Yes. Q. Wo go dovn to *11 and ve find the nano Buechner. A. Buechner, yes. Ct, Do you know that gentlcnon? A. Yos. Q, Was he the gontlenan that worked with Professor Volts? A. I know of no such collaboration. Q. Was ho one of tho lecturers at the Luftgau School? A. At first, I never in ay life heard about a Luftgeu school. Secondly, I never heard that Suechnor was ever a loeturer in any insti¬ tute of the Luftgau. Ihero oust bo sone nisundcrstanding. q. Do you rocall, in Raschor's document to tho Reichsfuchror, which vas Docunont 1602 PS in Docuaer.t Book So. 2, vhero Rascher stated, "For tho tlno being I have been assigned to Luftgau C-xr'.ando No. 7, Hunlch, for a nodical selection course"? Maybe I erronooucly called that a school. I'a sorry. I ask you now, was Buechner one of the lecturers at this Luftgau Connnndo No. 7 Kcdical Selection Course? A. I novor hoard anything about that. I really don't knov.^ Q, And then ve go down to *22 and see tho nc.no Pinko. Is that one and tho sene Pinke as nentioned in the other documents here? A. Yes, that probably is the case because, up to now, I have only heard of one Pinks. Sov, Doctor, when you heard these lectures, particularly the Court Sc. 1 27 Kay 47-A-l6-2-5EX-£errov (Easier) lecture gives by Eolzloefcner, I understand that it wasn't possible to ascertain that the work upon vfcicfc his report ves based ves verk on experimental subjects. Is that your position here? A. I have stated in great detail that one had to deduce from this Eolslochner lecture that in his results we were concerned with conclu¬ sions derived free a coabination of practical cxooriences with sea dis¬ tress, experiments on human beings, and experinents on aninals. Q. I see. Well now, I vast to recall tho tostinory of Professor Schrocdor vhoroin he said, on page 2625 of tho official transcript, that he tasod his statement solely on Eolrloehner's report vfcich was the only thing that interested his. la answor to a question by Hr. McKancy wherein Kr. HcEaney asked, “I think you stated to your dofonee counool that it vac impossible for you to conclude from this reDort that oxperl- nents hnd boon carried out. but rathor you thought thoy were clinical observations made on rsoople fished out of tho North Sea. Ic that right?" And I repent Schroedor's answer: "Yes, I bnsod ny testimony solely on Holtloohner's roport which ««s the only thing that interested no." Now, do you concur with rrofessor Schrocdor that, after seeing the Holzloohncr roport, that you could only ascertain thrt the results thereof wore obtained from practical experiences and not from oxocrincntntlon? A. Yes, I say rccind you that the situation under which Profcsoor Schroeder read the reoort and under which I Just hcord of it orally were entirely different. I knew beforehand, by virtue of ny participation in Eipcko's and Bsscfccr's conference, that those exoerinents were olonnod. Professor Schroeder, on the other hand, did not know that. Ho neroly knew tho feet that Eoltloehner had gained experiences in practical Bea distress servico. In other words, our points of departure are entirely M different. Veil now, you testified here that you felt the reason why tho witness Lute was in a position to ascertain the nothod used by rolsloohr.er ves because of his extensive knowledge of freezing uroblcas and that other people, such as Schrooder and yourself, and, I suooosc, ar s v other eii.6 Court So. 1 27 Xay 47-A-16-3-£EK-Karrow {Easier) -edical nan not specializing in this field, would be unable to ascertain the ease thing# that Lutz ascertained. le that correct? A. Tes, that is correct. I nay point out to you once noro thet rrofessor Schroedor wasn't even nreaent during that meeting, hut only read the printed report atout half a year later. Q. Veil, reading the printed report would he to hi9 advantage in being able to ascertain the method* uaed in the experiments, wouldn't it? I would thick that you could gather nore fron reeding the report than froe eitting down lietcning to an oral reoort, or would it he vico versa. Doctor? A. I nay draw your attention to the fact that on the 26th and 27th of Octohor there voa no vrltton report available, hut that thero was only tho oral roport by Kolzloehner. Q. How do you know that? A. Becauae I heard the roport. I listened to it. I have already ■aid oo. Q, How do you know ho didn't have the written one available? a. At any rato, I didn't have a written report ovaileblo. I novor ■aw one except tho one that waa later printed. Q. Let'e go on. Doctor. Sow, aa I understand it, you havc.ltatcd hero thet tho method of rapid re-warning wee not new. Vat nothing new. That, in fact, it was a very old nothod. Ia that right? A. So, you niounderstood no. Q, hall, do you know, as a natter of fact, that tho method of raoid re-warning is a very old method and that it was firet worked out in 1880 by a Hussion doctor naned Lepczinsky? A. Tea, that is true and it la included in this report. This method, as it frecucntiy occurs not only in medicine, vrs entirely for¬ gotten so that decades later nobody else thought about this ouick re¬ versing method. Vo are here concerned with a re-discovcry which so often occurs in'human history. eu7 « Court So. 1 27 Hoy 47-A-l&-4-HEX-Kar r ov (Easier ) q, That's true. It nay well have teen a ro-discovcry, tut it had bees discovered in I 860 by LepczinslQ', had it cot? A. Yes, it says so somewhere hero. q, Veil now, Doctor Volts here had admitted repeatedly that, ic his own experiment el vorie on animals, that, in addition to Lepczlnksy's earlier exneriencos, the problem was full>- settled and was ready to be applied to human boings, hasn't he, without further oxperinentation on human beings under artificial conditions? A. I believe Professor V e ltr said so hore. >hat ouestion do you with ae to answer now? q. Voll, in view of Professor Volte's testimony and in view of the fact that Lcpczinoky had founded this method of re-warning - raoid re- vornine - in leeo, wasn't it roady to be applied now for purposes of thorapoutic trial on people actually exposed to shock from exposure to cold without any further experimentation on human beings? A. I don't believe thet any nodical authority anywhere in tho world would havo boon preparod to introduce catcher's method of rc—yarning officially without first experimenting upon human bolngs. during tho slow re-worming— q, (Interrupting) Just a moment. Doctor, you're trying to got nvoy from no. Raschcr's method? Thet wao Kolzlochnor's, Finkc's, and Reschor's method, wasn't it7 It wasn't Rascher's alone. Raschor had on ordor to experiment with Holxloehner and Finkc. A. I don't know exactly what assignment fiolrloehnor had received from Hippie*.. I assumed that this was the main assignment. q. Well now, you hove mentioned, in the course of your examination, that those experiments - these freezing experiments - were decidedly useful and you Quoted Harper's Kagazino wherein it said that Dr. Alexander had found the method of rc—warning a useful ono end reported it as such. However, Harper'6 didn't quote that passage correctly. But, nevertheless, it was Lepczinsky's method of recid and Intensive rc-warning that was found in the Raschor experiments, -wasn't it? It Court Ho. 1 . » 27 Key 47-A-16-^S«-*arrov (Ka=l«r) vntii't Veltr's end Eolrloehner'e end Hatcher' s findin* or discovery, vtn nothin* but e reassurance of Lepczinsky's ncthod, vas it not? 27 r.ay ‘.T-A-aK-lT-l-Kaloy-(Rainier) Court 1 *v. I cannot rep.'.y to that question because I neither concerned myself with freezing research generally, nor lid I read the paper by Professor Lepczlnskl, and I don't know exactly what he suggested. Q. You concerned yourself with it h;re for nearly a aay on direct; since you exhibited such an exhaustive Knowledge in the natter I think it necessar* for you to take a stand here? A. Only on the basis of the documents. 'J. Is it necessary tc porfora exjcrlaenta or. human beings to reassure tho Lapozlnsky method? -i. ^8 I laAglne tho situation once more I could affirm the situation clearly. Q. /oil, now after hearing thlsnjport and the roassuranoe that tho Luftwaffe do to apply that method? To be sure some 100 gontlenen, as set forth In this dooumont llatonod to this report by Holzloohner, what did they do about it, did they use it? './oil, lot mo point out to you that during this meeting n number of researchers held lectures on tho basis of a number of experiments and all arrived at tho samo result, which was finally confirmed by Profeooor Holzloeh- ner. Professor Kolzloehnor's lecture was only the final confirmation, and I Know that the modloal Inspectorate afterwards introduced quick rew.mlng no the only decisive Qethod of treatment. Q. Veil, now. Doctor, what la bothering mo and bothering no terribly is the fact that extensive rosearoh was conducted at the Dachau Concentration Camp on rapid rewarding, — tostlcony here in this trial shows that many deaths occurred. There isn't one shred of evidence Cl 30 27 May 4?- rf -AX-l?-2-:-;aloy- (Raaler) Court 1 available in this Tribunal produced by the defendants that indicates to any decree that these methods as dis¬ covered by Holzloehner, Hascher and rink a were ever applied oy the Luftwaffe or by the ^nay or by the :*avy, yet you have taken the'at.rnd here and attempted to in¬ troduce Harper's .»a.;azine to show that these experiments werj Justified end that we, as a matter of fact used them in the United States .iavy; why didn't you use thorn in tne German .o*ay and -«avy? The method was used from 1942 on. Q. l/o 11, all that Schroeder could tell us about it was that someone in an air sea station In Greece requested a bathtub which as a matter of fact was never delivered, because of subsequent retreat from Greece, but he didn't toll us anything about the actual use of the method; there is no evidonco hero that you ever used the method; what was the reason for this ex.naustlvo research If you novor intended to use the method, and in fact never used tho method, apparently? tfe nevor tnod to prove that. This lo the flrot time that the Prosecution has raised tho onarge that this raothod was never applied. Q. I havon't raised the cnargo, doctor, I am merely seeking information from y?u. inasmuch as you have defin¬ itely taken up the tls» of this Tribunal to explain groat- ly the value of those experiments; now what was the value to the merman Luftwaffe, to the German .-onay and tho German Navy; you haven't been able to show us that? -»• I nsver tried to show that. I don't consider that relevant, I and my defense counsel. If I were to go Into everything connected with the trial from a scientific £151 27 :*.ay -«7-17- al oy- ( Raaal er ) Jourt l point of view then the time I have used so far would be completely inadequate, but I as quite -willing to bring a number cf wlmesses to prove that quick rewarding was applied. I believe that will be quite easy to prove. ,»s to the Professor Lepczlnsky - £. Now youare getting at it; you are coming along with me. Then the method was actually applied, the method of Lepczinsxy was .ctually applied in the (Jarman Vehrmaoht? -v. I said before I didn't know the LopetinSky method. I never reed his paper on the subject. Z. Then the method rediscovered by Rascher, Holzloehner and Flnko was actually used, and adopted by the German Vehrmacht, la that correct? I am quite oort.aln of it. I w.ae never present myself, because I wasn't working cpeclfioally on these quostlons, but I believe I can find people who will bo able to confirm that the method wao actually used, Q. Woll, now. Doctor, in regard to the position that Sohroedor was unable to ascertain from Holzloehnor '0 report, that the results were secured from experimentation, I have a fow questions to put to you; now, on the seoond page of Holzloehnor's report, that is page 10 of the document itself, page *2 of the original, that is document Wo, 401, Chat will bo found on page 38 of the English Document book III, in the second paragraph on that page, Holzloehnor speaks of human curves, "human curves." It is possible, Doctor, to obtain curves which require special measurements from people floating in the sea; don't you think it would bo a lot to actually obtain one good meas¬ urement under such circumstances? A. Lot me point out that these cooling curves very C152 2? May -i7-,r-.i£-l?--r-Maloy-(Raaler) Court L obviously refer to the animals. Professor Holzloehner •-'rites; "In tho case of water temperature under 15 degrees of interest to tho Sea Distries service, all reflect reg¬ ulation appears only slightly in the usual test animals. The freezing curves to a groat extent resemble tho phys¬ ical nodal which can only bo compared with many reservat¬ ions to hun.in curves oecauso of their different measurem¬ ents and differing constant tem.»er .ture." This shows qultool early that these curves wore obtain¬ ed from animals. Those are the experiments that professor Kolzloshner mentioned on the previous page, and now some other rosults and constant figures of normal body tempera¬ ture, and freeting point o: fat, and so forth, that for these reasons the experiments cn animals and the physical context cannot bo applied to human bolngs. Q. Now, this report of Dr. Holzloehner refers to statistics found on reecuod iiersons from the sea, refers to statistics found fro-, experimentation on animals and the roport Is more or less a comparison, is it not, and that Is I assume what Professor Sehroudor thought when ho road this report, that the mention regarding human beings referred to those rescued at sea, and not to aotual experimental suojocts, and nereln he refers to human curves, and data concornlng human curves, unions it was on a human being. I would think that would bo elementary, wouldn't it. Doctor? . 1 . That 16 not elementary, and it is not true, bec¬ ause suoh coolln-j curves can, of course, bo obtained fron blood, 1 « can be determined how long a ship wrecked person has been in the water, and then I can enter this timo on a curve and the temperature which I have obtalnod from the '153 27 Hay 47-^-ja-17-5*.Kaloy- (Raalar) Court 1 boat. These were covered boats with cabins, and I could measure tho temperature. I could correlate the tine ••'ith the temperature and after I do this lr. 10 or 20 cases I ootain a curve, but what Professor Holzloohner says her; clearly refers to animals experiments. Q. Let's refer to the next paragraph; I wonder if this refers to animals ex 'criconts. The next naragr-»ph states: Q. The blood count, as well as the changes in tho blood analysis wore also tested in such severe friczlng. Is that referring to animals, to the aoga and cats he mentioned? That has nothing to do with the tost on hura-m beings which ho refers to later in the report? Any I road tho context? Q. Yes, that is paragraph‘s. of page 10 of page -k2 of the original? Court 1 May 2 ''-a- 16-1- HD-i-loehan-VonSobo n. «. Ye8, I would Ilka to reed the context. It rends: ^r.-.e blood c ur.t, es well r.s the chr.p.gae In the blood ar.'-.lysie were rlsj testec. in such severe freezing. These investigations yielded few new results ana they cort’es *ond the results of elow freezing or the results deterialncd fr c local freezing. aso ng these ch >n ; us, the c- n^lderncle rise m viscosity lr. dogs and cats o mentioned, which cokos It obvious that they were •'nlnel experiments. alright, let . s ref r t the next -j-ge. Tuls will bo >,n ;V c e 11 , which is oage 63 of the document bo.k lr. onglieh. nefer to the third par-graph fron the top, pnrdon no, factor, we will b ck up to th. s C'.r.d *r>r O ro?h which G-ya ns follows: “It has now been noaolbl- t. conduct n aorleo of A n- voetlg.- tlons of hunar. ooings wno were rescuec of tor Iwlng seen n cold water for a lon w tiae. The relevant otuto- hents we owe to t.ie coopernti n of ofbearzt Dr. Rnscher and otabearzt Dr. flnkc. They refer t. r etc in w tor f Z th 12 degrees." There Is no question but that the relntir. 0 facts in this report were facts deduced froa r series of invostl^a- t^ons on human beln = s who were rescued after being In c^ld water for e long tine; Is thet corroct? Yes, thrt Is true. 1 he rd late* that Dr. Finke v 3 'no of r..lzloehner 1 s assistants at the a^a rescue 9 station In Beeen. I as convinced that p t of th- findings were based on actual experience m erretlsu In rescue froa sea. Let us examine a few of these ^es, Doctor, the utri paragraph Holaloehner soys: “The re-idlty with which n-n:ness -ccurs Is remarkable. - */ s determined that already 5 to 10 minutes after fall- Court 1 Kay 2?-*-18-2-HD-.4eehan-VonSchon. Ini m, Qn advanceing rigor of the skeletal muscles 6ets in, which renders the movement of the a:'=3 especially lncreaingly difficult. Inis affects respiration also: inspiration is deepened end eviration is delayed." Do you mean to say now that during rescue operations one would actually watch a can fall into the water, then sit by and do nothing for five or ten minutes until he becomes rigid, until his respiration slows. No, but one does pull a man out of tho water with rigor of the muscles nnd slow breathing. Such experiences have occured everywnere. In my direct examination I spoke of this same experience of rigor within five or ten minutes by Captrln .taxer of tho ^mcrlorn servlco. Tho same experience has .been had by every rescue service in the * world. <1. Now further down in tho >nr O rcoh wo find tho words and tnls is the sentence after the one I just read— wc find the words. "Tho rigor is a conditional reflex and not, as many persons apparently think, a contraction of the corresponding muscles due to cold. It censes spantanoouely at death.* Now, do you moan to imply seriously. Doctor, that you as a member cf the armed forces would ovpoct one of your nodical officers to treat members of the armed foi'ceo thaA way or that they would sit there and let the ill man die in the water so they could take measurements, moke observations end investigations? «. These sentences do not indie to that either. 'I g.-, eld like to refer to the first per-yrnph of K. lzloehncr 1 s lecture, which re-ds: "Observations by the oea Distress service h"Vo shown t.. c chv; roduLtl n In body temperatur~ proceeds very rapidly Court 1 May 27-A-1S-5-HD--^8han-V. nSehun. _r. the esse of persons in distress at s.c subjected to •;-ter temperature below 15 degrees. «6 uncor.scl-usness or jven deetn c?r. occur already fter half an hour, the OBslblllty of using olons and boats is greatly decreased. ..oroovor, observations of ca.es cr.tastro:hle6 (the sinking of transports or war ships) revealed that even r rather long time aft r the rescue, drng-r to Ilf still exists. : us, sudden deet.is were observed 20 Invites to l£ hours rfter rescue, w.'.ic.; ntil now h ve regained unexplained, (Collapse of ter ro.-cue.)" Those aro the ae the whic . -r - ctors observed. - ey ybaervod th“t w.ien deot occured, t_o rl. or suduonly ceased, I ayself rwver ob urved that, I v; s nev^r prooont or, suik occasions. .. Let us go to the next paragraph, Doctor, here is Che most oropoetorous and obvious uossn^e,. This lo the iaeglnnln.. of the next oar ^raph, No. 43 of the original, j. o 11 of the document and £9 of the dooun_nt book. -.is states a.s follows: "*’lth a drop of the rectal tempuraturw to 31 degrocs, a cloudin 0 of consciousness occurs, which masses to a oop cold-induced anesthesia if the ecllne reaches below 30 degrees. “ now, Doctor, t • have made this observation It would dvo been next to lcpoeslblc during an air sea rescue operation; wouldn't it? a. No, no. at oil. ‘.'oil now in the first Diace to measure the rcoUnl :j_rpe.ra.ture of r ran bobbing in the hi- seas would be ' i;o a. Job, wouldn't It? a. No, not at all. Tht w re something teat was done ’■'jr frequently. :-d57 Court 1 Mr.y 27—.-i-l;—4— HD—He eha r. - Vo n 5c ho n Vhnt aid you do, Joe tor? Did you Just bo by the non floating In the sea In ° rescue boot, come up to him ead Instead of throwing hin a life line, throw hie a tor-uniter and ash his to place it in his rectum? «. Jlo, but the temperature was taken after the people wore in the life boat. I have already sold that the rescue boats were bli motor boats with covered cabins. 1. New, Doctor, Just r moment, JU3t a moment. In t-fcin- the mn ir. the life boat to perform this; what did you do aftc-r c.iis, ut him in the life boot and then throw hin back in th_ water? h. That is an interpretation of yours, vv.ich dooo not correspond to real conditions. «hrt v:e ivvc hero is Chat when the temperature drops to below 3J decrees there can be a cold anesthesia and one need not bo nn export on c Id to know this. «ny doctor will recognise , that thore nro two oos-iblo exlanatlons. One is thot ihero wore ‘ibsovvrtions on various people, it coos not say that chcoc observations wore all xodc on the s mo nan. doc .idly, a.n oven more oo33lble solution is tht when one 'orson was rescue:- and to.ap^rature of 30 ..e. 3 rees was taken and his toaporaturu continued to fell while he vr.s in the bua.t, *b.-t is the new fnot which ncs be>n discussed by American '0 well as German experts durln_ cals w r and th: c unless one applies warmth to the rescued people immediately buo alanly covers him, s is done in tile life coat, che temperature c.ntinues to fall. One has no need to >ut Che -rs- n beck in the ice weter. I n- tiled thot you have a definite opinion on ;fl "- Doctor. Let us look further on down on this pr.^e, vi u h will be on t.'v rey: jr & _ of the ducunent book, 43. This is the to*' paragraph. The next sentence Court 1 hay 27-n- 18-5-HD-Heeban—Vo nSchon therein. It states: •'It Is certain that the rapidity of the drop of .e-terature increases when the neck and occiput are washed by v*ter. 1 Do "ou see It? Yes, I see it. It would take pretty careful observations fro.: a ‘toat, a rescue boot, to find that out on n can floating in era sot., but It would be pretty easy to do it or. a nan floating in s tub the experimental station In Dachau; w«.uld It not? Wouldn't you have to follow hia -round in Cho boat pretty cucn to see how cuoh of ..is neck rnd occiput was wished by the water? «. This observations aeons that in the Deraan Luft- wr.ffe, oa well ra In che &ercnn Kpvy, there were various :oc.el3 of life preservers. One codol was constructed in auen a way tk t the person fti the back of his head and :ho bock of : 1 a reck out of the w*ter, that is the baok of rlo neck aa protected. The other .uodol wca constructed in i c.- a wn- tha: the back of the neck wr.a not r.rotooted. To thin., was norn sia le to see what happened to the oople -o?rin jnc :odel compared to people vearin e t.;e other aouel. Besides, I can -oint out tn?t .-*r. Rase her, after .*-Itloehncr‘s lecture, cade a renark in that direction 83 " ia b c es:erlner.ts rtrd eeen carried out on c..lu subject, : - c c^orelr.i :o what ..r. Rpscher a id «t th*t tine and vruu ho -rote, they were completely hrrrless. He -.-rlCes - '0 c,:o coolln t of the beck of the neck rlono, even over • VC5ep of nours, c uses only e ell c bt change of body * ' -jer-ture up :o 1 do = reo Celsius, noc-crdin^ t> what - Cf - Cr “eiortcd, it vs ;• very slliflt result for dlls "* ^rl-.nt nd one nust casune tnrt aulzloehn.r's remarks .-3f»r to ..is -ctuel experience in sea-rescue ear vice. 8159 Court 1 Kay 27-A-18-6-KD-X3chen-YonSchon* Q~ Veil, let us go to the passage on page 44 of the criminal document, prge 14 of the transition. This is on page 93 of the document book. You note here the following language in the first paragraph on that page. The sentence, •.r ich is seven lines down'from the toe, rends ns follows: “The t oud results with quick w: rmlng obtained in ;r ei’lr.ents with animals enccur- ; ed c corresponding procedure vith human beings. These experiments showed that b the with a w ter temper * turc of 40 degrees net only accelerate the return to normal temperature and absorb the sudden dangerous falls of tomuercturc after rescue, b..t may also be of life-saving effect should the heartbeats begin to stop. Now in this :olr.ted discussion, the author w~s even far more outspoken, was ho net, which I understand was an ?boro via ted and expurgated edition of what ho actually said rt the ao-ting; is that right? Jhnt did ho say at ho .‘.coting to elaborate on tr.ls point in the corresponding rocodure on human beings to bo used, inasmuch as they fuund such good results on their work on animals'? 27 Key b[t-i^S . - 15-l-Ccok (Vcr. Scbcer.) Court 1 I believe tlx t isbest shorn by the feet tket Mr. Rcachcr hr.d en order free Higgler to Resent the results of the experiaert es c to? secret setter, -bet Holzlcehner sold ebsut the ex peri rer.ts c 3 I acid ir. ay direct exednetion, rhrt I tech ta referring to exper- laer.ts, res thisperegrephr here where it sold expressly thet no denser no ever observed to persons treated in this my. As fer the other ccccri rents concerning which Rescher sent c repertto Himlcr end which report to Hinder is signed by Kolzloohr.cr m3 Rcachcr end Finkc , thero ves s-id nothing ct Numbers, r.or did Holzloehr.cr, Finke or Rcachcr s-y mytfcing fbcut it. Net only I but ninety otter pooplc herxd it cndacat of the otters ere et liberty today red r.r.o cf thee heve vor; high positions. \. -oil now let us turn, tc cnothor aoctlcn cf -this report, which is cn pego U3 cf tho o rig inti, prge 12 of the — this rill be found cn pego 9* of tho dncutxnt book 3, the ptssrgc cr.teinod in the socond portgreph frea tho top, five lines down, beginning in the niddlo of the per greph end tho aiddlc cf tho sentence lir.o, rteroln I rill qlioto , wherofroo I will quote* 'Noticoeblc f.rd iaoertent 13 c tc.* t incroeso in viscosity of up to 7.9 . This lncrcf.ac epporrs very orrly, thft is, rlrcrdy with 0 body ter. poreturo cf 35 dccrocs. Ikoso incrocsos ero greeter fchm thcco found in eniad experiaonts. “ith does for instmeo, or. ir.crcrso cfrxro then 6.2 era never obssrved under «x> me spending cir- ciastrr.cos." !fcw, i'r. Becker-F.oyseng * in order tc determine how high the viscosity of the ticcd cor. bo, wouldn't it teke c a--.sidor.’ bio creunt ofreesurirs? A « No, I den't kreT how Holzloehr.cr did it. '•■oil now, doctor, thft would test ever your ingenuity, you re c pretty capable fellow, tc teke cno seaplclemo enough to deter¬ mine the visccsity cf the bleed fr-n n acr. fleeting in tho ocean next tc c bert, let alone sufficient for rcr surcrcr.ts — 27 He7 47—S'—19-2-Cook (V-n Sciser) Court So* 1 *'hc rxc 3 ^rer£r.ts uculdr.ot bnve to be race cr. c men soirning beside the beet. Either e s~x.ll errant cf blrod is teker. from r. ran -ho rxsbocr.tr tu^ht into the beet or clso the bleed ~oll you do not eccocplish this free: y~ur experiment of you do r.ot nee aplish rhit yen ire looking for, dc yoi? You did net find cut the necessary infcrrxtion from that aenner, did you, if you Just pulled him in, you can't he ecrtcin hr-.? it rcects, you hove to determine him m riimcl rescued mould rccct, in er.prrisen to tho ro; cticr. of humor. being. You htvo to hr vo sore sort cf ccrptriscc. Isn't thet whet Holzloohncr, Finkc rr.d Rcschcr did ct Dcchru? ». I never heerd anything cb-ut thet, tut the purpose of Hclz- loehncr's cork ft Excheu, let r.o print rut tlx next sentonco rhich reeds* ■••ith decs, for irstrr.ee, cn ir.crorsc cf more than 6 . 2 . re a nevor observed under corresponding circuratfr.cos. * I cn corvhcod thet Mr* Holzlschrxr ardo his cercfjl tests with cninels end thet rith human toiogs ho carried out moroly r fee prccticcl tonts r nd I % eacenvincod thet the aoraweaent of Tisccsity is very sinplo ovon in prectlco. In r.y direct cxcr.imtlcn I discussed this point. I reforrod tc the report of Ccptcin or Mojor Kczer, rho performed clr.cct coccctly tho seme tests in tho Aacricen see rescue servico, blood concen¬ tration tests, cr.din offcct fc-und out ox* ctly tho scao «: ing. / 0 C.. '-oil, doctor, let's turn to cnothcrscctien here, thin is per-o 15 cf the roport under discussion, note the ntr.o ftrschir. Hero H'seher stetes in thisperr. r r ph, 1 leh ispr.-c 93 cf tho doaincnt bock, end I quctc» sentonco beginning rithi 'After tekin*’clco- fcol, body toepertturc deertnsps t c quicker prcc. Hies the inter¬ preter he.vo thetr "«ft<.r taking dextropur tho dccrucso is slorcr then uitk the experiments in both sober end clccnolic condition. Hit infusions, <1 ,¥ t dextrj-solution, physioleg. tcblo selt-soluti on, tutc- fusin. physic led- Tcble srlt x lutien rith pencort-.x) "<.rc successful ohly for c time." ITco frm rci.diq* thet doctor, do you seen tc s* y thet you could issue r.lcohrl tc airmen Ju3t on the eh cnee they L 6162 27 ¥ey 47—S.-i9-3-Cock (V c n Schoen) Court No. 1 sight fell in the see so that you cull make comparisons trith otter airmen who hadn't taken alcohol? A. I ±ould like to point out toothing and I an quite Trilling to bring proof of this too. Ir. the emergency equipment of the Lr.ft- csffo, goodwhiskoy- ^ *hen when you pulled c men in from the water did you cak each run if he !a! teken a drink yet? Yes. in meny ceacs kc wculd cak that beccuso the doctors hold tho point of view thet alcohol iaharmful in such ceaas. Firm 1943 approx¬ imately on tho olcohel rra roreved from tho oncrgcncy oquipnor.t cgelnst the rosiatcnco of ncn-r.cdiccl son. I cm quit? -illing to bxirg proof of thia tco. Nos easuna for e moment. Just caauno for tho moment hypoth- etlcclly you were working with Raachcr, Helzloobncr r.nd Finke, end this roport was the results cf ycur work, would you be willing to cssumo ti lft responsibility for everything cor.tcinod in Holzlcohncr'a report as being ®cplctely on tho 1c vol, nothing crlrlncl rbrut it. I think you ero toing bit ncive, doctcr, hero is Lutz who erno hero aid testified it "ts obvious Just wtat tho roport roent. DR. TEii Mr. i’rcsidor.t, in tho direct exeninrtion !!r. Kcrdy roproachod me with eponding too nu* tir.o on n subject. I ' ont into tco much dotcll with thcao quostlcna, ho seid. Bow he is going into then again. I have net otjectod butnow Mr. H'rdy amen with e completely hypothetical question. He, rs soil cs tho Tribunal end tho dofondemt know that this is not true. 3 tolievo in answering this question "whet would hevo happened if * — is a purely hypoth¬ etical question and will net get us enywtere. I should like to object tc this question cs ecopktcly irrelevant. I’H. HARDYi H/ving learned c great deal during the course of this trial, I have just finished a subject ord -ill go on to sens thing else. THE 1 RESIDENT; x lease proceed. 27 Hey i?-—5—19-i-Ccck ( Veto Schrcu) Court So* 1 MR. HARDY* f. Doctor, let's turn to pro® 127 ef the document bcok, which is Exhibit 1C6, document No. 268. This is e dccir:cnt which originated fror. A*r.th3cy's cf flee, which is signed by Irofcssor Hippke. Sonc- body ore to thftt, somebody in Anthony's offico exist have written it or it wouldn't hove Anthony's code letter or. it, beceuso rs you sry Hippke did aost of his work without referring to Anthony if ho ehoso to do it. New this lottcr reeds ro follows* A. I en sorry. I r.ovcr sold thet. I sold tbr.t Hippke sometimes felled to ® nsult tho refortt but I never sr.id in meat o'" his work. f. you think now, lr. cs nach ta the eodo ktters eppeer, tfrr t in ®nnoction with this document Hippke referred it to the referet? «. I not only believe Hippke referred tho It tter tr the roferr.t but I think t: is letter r*s worked or. in tho roferet. I r.ysolf did net work on it. I see it here for tho first ti no. fu Let's reed it, doctor, quote* ■Tho experiments conducted in Wcheu • oncoming protective ncesurcs egeinst the effeets of freezing cn tho huren body by irr.crsicc in cold voter have lrd to results cf prectlccl uso. Thoy rcro a rductcd by Stebserzt ef tho Luftweffo i rofosscr Dr, Holzlooh- nor, Dr. Firko ond l*r. Hcschcr in croporrtlen with tho SS, end rro now finished. Tho rosults vrs repj tod upon by thoso who worked on thee, during e ® r.fcronco cn nadiccl problems cxisi rv; fron distress ct see ond victor hfrddips on 26 cr.d 27 October 19t2 rt Number/?, The dotoiled report on the oonfcror-co is rt present in strtc of proportion. ■I think you root grctofully for the greet cssistcnco thrt cooper¬ ation of tho SS hr s ncrr.t for us in conducting tho exper¬ iments, end beg you to express our thonks too, to the cocvnder of the Dcchru err?. Hell Hitler Fref. Dr, Hippke,* Slot 1 27 Key &7-£-&.19»5-Goefc (Von Schocr.) Court No. i Now vhrtcvir inprcss ion wcs giver, to tho listeners ct the Num¬ bers conference '.fter he'ring the report, it is c feet, is it ret, tbet the reports were btsed on experiserts upon hurxr. beings '.t the Desheu ecr.ccr.trcticn cerp r cd here is tho 'TherJc you' note fren Hippke? - m. In ny direct oxerdnetion I hero clreedy scid thrt I held tho opinion frer. the very beginning thrt K'lzlcehr.cr's report rrs Just c osnpllctior. find thrt in the ccurso of tho cerpiliftion he included tho results of the Dccheu experiments in his rep'rt. I never doubted it. f. ••oil, W* Lutz !»d no difficulty ir. csccrtrir.irr thrt either, did ho? 5165 :sy 27->BK-20-lGr:ss (Int. V„n Scbocn) &urt Nc* 1 .. Iat nc refer to three things: first of all Lutz hicsclf worked cn the col/’ question; scecnd ho workod in the very institute whe-rc c raider able work was den c on the sane quosticn; third, Recording to whet he said, ho knew !!r. Raschor nuch bettor than I did. If he rood senothinp else fro-. Bolzloc hirer's report and Rascher's rerark fchar I '’id I re: not surprised. Q Of course, yu can recall that Dr. Lutz naintri nod in the ecurso of his oxaaination here that an average nodical nan could have ascertained the sre-u thiny., didn't he say that? A. I don't understand your question. 0 Didn't Dr. Lutz say here that any physician or zvcdical nan, regard¬ less of his specialty, that is, ho didn't necessarily have to be a specialist in shock frea oxpesuro to cold, could have bean any nan, if ho had. slight kniwlodgo of rwdicinc could ascertain Iran tho reports that worn: hoard at tho Octobor cootin; tint tho ox;»»rl-.enta rroro vado on htnan buinga and wero not just air rescue practical tests? L N-, Dr. Lutz did not say that. In tho course of ny direct examina¬ tion I repeated exactly what Lutz said. He said he beliovod it was clear to uoot poopla that is to say, at least that it was not quito clearly expressed and that was his own personal ■ pini< n. ihat ho rualizod ni^ht not apply to othor pooplo. Q Lot us turn to the yellow jnun'ict c,aplex, doctor. This is Dccunont .VO-137 '•hich is on par© 6 of Dociuvnt Bock 8. A Yes, I havo it, Q '.oil, now we note her-, ur.’or 1 - th: subject is yellow fever vaccines and we find there three references to tho code lotters of tho office of Anthony. Is that correct? Co see this #55 on three occasions there, I aa seny, un^or ye 1 lew fever vaccine, is that what you naan? I Under prabic number 1 — A Yes, you cnly sec two naibors which do refer to referat. The first 55, etc. 2 II B and then 55/lb - the rest is nissin^. I ’on*t know • >y 2?-:.-3K-20-2-Gr ss (lat. Yen Schccn) Court llo. 1 what the original says. q Those references, be there one, two, or three - refer t; Anthony's office, is that right? It is very simple, answer it. Do they or don't they? ..If I have to say yce or no I will say no. They nc an norcly that there is a research assi^rr.ont sc that if the files arc lcokod. f r in tho :ffico of tiio 'fc'Acal inspectorate the registry pe-ple know whore to lock - under file #55- 1 Let's straighten this out. '..hat is 055? T.hat ''.ocs it can? A In tho correspondence of the Gcr.uan '..bhriacht there was a so-called ’..'chnacht file plan. q Lot's forgot that a vonent. That do numbers 55 no an. You can answer in three words. You have answered it in direct examination. I want to hear it a*;nin. I don't nxeuber what you said. Doesn't 55 2 II 3 refer t th. office of Anthony? iv He. This Ko. 55 ycu will fin' in correspondence of tho ontiro Luftwaffo and the ontiro Gor. an Ibhrmcht where Anthony leans nothing it all..... Q 2 II 3 refers t Anthony's office, doosn't it? •>?.. TIPr: : : T. President, I an afraid I raist cbjoct to this tyjc of questioning by Vx. Hardy- Ho has interrupted the witness three times ncu. if Hr. Har V will let Doctor Bockcr-Freysong explain everything •-ill be clear. I : cn't want tc attack It. H ar *y personally b;, any ncans but I think this continual interruption ’ocs not scr-.*c the causo. 2. HARDY: Since the object! n has boon raised.. Your Honors, I 'dll Instruct tho Tribunal tc instruct th; witness tc answer ivy question "hat ’ocs 2 II 3 roan? He has testified on direct oxadnation that they no an ..nthony*3 office. He is hero under oath and. now he says \hey do not near, Anthony's office an.' I wish tc clear up the confusion. "HI PriSIDZ T: Ccuns-1 for Prosecution asko-’ the witness what the ■•Juhjr 55 -cant an interrupted the witness before he answered, by ‘skin- what the letters 2 II 3 acan. ..'ill counsel a ain prepound his -y 27——5 K-2C—3-Gross (Jr.z. Vcr. Sc'.:c^r.) Court !*o. 1 qixistion to the- witness? BY IR. HiHDTi Q uhat is the code initial 2 II 3 refer to, doctor? A That is the registration abbreviation for the referat Aviation :!eclicine. Q And at that tine 7 October 19U3 you were assistant referont? A Yos. Q And £1 in this docrant refers tc yellow favor vaccine? A Yes. 0 . And "2" in this document refers to spotted fever vaccine? A Yes. Q And tho code lettors 2 II 3 appear tncre? A Yos, that is true. Q And so on down through th« document? A Yes, that is truo. Q That is all I have in that ccaplcx. Your Honor. However, I havo ono request to Make of the Tribunal boforo wo ndjoirn today. Dr. Tipp has roquested that ho bo permitted tc seo tho defondant Bockcr- Froyson3,thi3cov*aina. I havo agreed that he coul ’ coo Bock^r- Froysong, of course adhorin to legal othics and not unking any rcforcnco to the questions boix considered in the ccurso of this croso-cxarinaticn. Dr. Stoinbauer has a prcblcn to tako up with tho Tribunal before adjourrc-unt. DR. STdIHBAUER (For the Defendant 3ci;;lbocck): !'x. President, tho court has approve.’ for no a witness naned. Dr. Rolf Jaogcr. This ritrv-SS has boon brought tc Hurnborj. This noroin. tho General Secretary's office, 'dr. ..artena, told ^ that Dr.Jaeger is the head of a British Hospital in Graz .and th: British military Govcrftx.nt in ..ustria have urgently asked to have hiia rcturne'.’. Ho has to be taken back Thursday nornin. and I should like pjr. lssion to call this witness tonerruv when the exar-inntian of Bcckor-Froyscn; is c r,eluded. Itr. Hardy, to wheel I have told this, thou ht I should - 27-A-3X-20ii-Gr3Ss (In-. Von Schoen) Court Ko. 1 subnit an affidavit. I would be very very glad to fulfill :x. Hardy’s irish but could not do so; I acrcly pro-lse that I will be very brief. If he trill do the sane thins «u Trill gain what we would otherwise have lost. TH2 iftESIDoKT: Has coxmscl for Prosecution any objection to calling this witness at the closing of tt* testimony of the dofondnnt 3cckor- Fre-yson^? P. H.J5DY: On the ot-tenant cf 'cfonflo coir.sel, Your Honor, it appears to bo that in as ...uch as this witness will only testify as A to the rank and organization within which the defendant Bci. lboeck was otetionod or rhero his orders cans fra., I don’t think it necessary to tako up tho ttno of tho Tribunal. I undorstnnd the witness has nothin, to add c^ncominig tho soa water cx^riacnte of any of tho plans or ontorprisos connected therewith. Ho will noraly testify ns tu superior ordors of Boijbocck and I feel for uy P" rt fch -nt an affidavit could accomplish that object without taking up the tine of the Tribunal. TH2 rPxSIDHiTj I undorstaix! free defonso counsel that dofonsc councol desires to put the witness on the stand and not filo an affidavit of the witness. Is that correct? A Yes. TH" H&SXQgNft The witness will bo hoard utu-r '•lose of tho tostiaony of defendant Bccker-Frcysertb tonorrow, Thu Tribunal will be in recess until 9:30 tomorrow uorninr;. Tw.: V.BS4 u. Th«. trl,W Vivwte -nnoss unf.O 9l30 ^OTTO* •:crnin-. 28 S v b7-K-S—l -l-?sttr (Vcn Scheor.) C;urt Nr. 1 OfficiU Tr'rscript cf the •ceric-r Hilitrry Tribur/.l ir. the ertter of the United States cf Acericr. egeinst Krrl.5rr.ndt, et cl, defendrnts, 8 it tine ft Kimberg, Gerrer., on 29 >!cy 1947. 0*30, Justice Beds area id inf. •BS HiJaEOj ? era ora in the cr urtrrrc nill ple'fc find their 3V tS. The Honorable, the Jii ca of Kilitry Tritunrl I. Militiry Trihinrl I io raw ir. session. God srvo tho United St' tea of •ocriee end this hor.orcblc TWtuml. 7h-rc *-111 to order in tho crurtrooc. THIS * RESIDENT* ?*r. Krrakrl, you racertr-in if tho defordenta rro prosor.t in tho court. THE V>JSH-Li llcy it pierao your Honor, ell defendants -to proaer.t ir. tho court. TVJS 1 RESIDE? Tho Sccrotr.ry-Gcrorrl rill note for tho record tho proaor.ee cf rll the defendants in c*urt. Cour.aol rxy prococd. BECKEUPREDSCG - ^oaiaod CROSS EWT'/.m' (Centinuod) BY iSL H-.RDYi r u vjy it plor.se tho Triturxl. Dr. Becker-Freysonc. yestordey , during the ceurao cf cross oxrrdr.ctior., I caked ycu -rhothrr or not yett hed error porfoiTcd oxperinonta ir. blrh-eltitudo rcscc.rcb cbovc 12 , OOO rttora md I rccell thet ycu enrr-tred thrt y-u hrd dar.c th t type of research yourself up to 15,000 cctirs. I acid thet I pcforced c very fen , pcrhxps or.o or tw eoeper- irer.ts ?n^elf. Generally, faovtv r, cy rcrie vra up to 12,000 cetera. Th-1 r: a % k in 1945 w 1946. Ken, tail work Therein you rent tc 15.000 cetera, rrc t: t also in 1945 cf* ' u6 ‘' •. No, the*' era t of rrc. thrt era during the cnr. 28 Jfey i.7-::-S~l-2-?cst.r(7cn Scbccr.) Court ??c* 1 There ~tre sere oricr.trtier exp-.rincr.ts ahich I performed, perheps '42 of '43 only to lccrn cbout t*e sc things by r.ysclf. T-.ro rrs not er.y extensive research. Just r fern experiments for ay on orient'tier. Hr:’ my one olso to your knowledge per fornod or experimented tbrvo 12 , 0*0 et that tiro or prior tc 19427 *• Yes, quits e feu people. “ho? "• &r. Ulrich Luft end Dr. Hire Geer' JQcnenr, et the eviction Roaerreh Ifcdicel Institute, end Dr. Berzir-cer :r.d his people in Hedtlin. Tho highest cltitudo torched thet I knee of urs r little over 19. r C0 rxters. JV.ls via rccchcd by Bens *rieh Hilb»ch in r self oxpcrlner.t. Ho is no- 1 i^±rc in Irion In tho Chionsoc. He worked for Dr. Bonoinrer. Do you knee how reny tires experiments hrvo been conducted rh,rc- lr. cltitudcs over 15,000 actors trero rocoked7 approx in tsly, doctor. Just c r*u;:h cstinctc. Ccrtoihly 50 tc 6o expert cents. Ov..r i5,coe? *. Yos, over 15,000 rxters. Tea rll thet cork eond doted prior to the oxpext-ents ir. Drchxu, in ether cords, prior to robru.ry 19427 *. Vert rxs before the Dreheu experinerts -nd prt -ib r.ftor the ^roheu experiments. "culd you hevo my rty of telling us Just her ruch vis done before tho "cchou experiments in f is particular field, ir. cltitudcs higher then 15.00C rxters? a '• Unf .T tunc tel y, I cm ir. no position tc d: s~, hut 3 cm tell you ^ he cm give you very cxcct inferv tioc. Ttiso men ere ell in tho "-.ericcn service — Dr. H: r.s Go err Elc-tr.n, Dr. Left md Dr. Benz- irccr. I myself did not ccrry cut this s-ccific type of cork myself, end 23 Key W-H-S—l-3-?=st-r(Von iohcon) Court 2fe. 1 I did not work on it in the reforrt. Ur.fortur.rtely, 3 aa uneble to snarer your quest!on. I ccn only refer you to the correct curse. r .. -ell, r.o-, in these experiments thrt were conducted in the altitudes higher then 15,000 meters, whet field of research -r a thitconcorncd with? ’-f S thrt with explosive deccrprcssicr., dew docor.t, or whrt phese of high-dtitude resorrch , do you knew ? «. Yes, prrt cf them explesivo compression expression experiments end pert of than experiments su h c a were dcscritod hero, experiments on rescuo free high r.ltitudo. New theso cxrxrieor.ts thst re 're rofc;r‘ns to, those eorcorr.ed with altitudes cbove 15.C00 neters, rcro the results of theso exp rimor.ts published so that r.ll students of cvir.tion medicine oould study thee? "a".'Y es, quite c number of results of experiments rrc tvrilrblo which I myself sew in tlx cxvrctrlcr.l Conter in Hoidolborc S.-r.c c i them wcio published in tho ^rurr.el for vi tier. Medicine, end some of them rcro Just of field roports Coart So. 1 2o hay 47—:-2-l-£M-'.-?r Inaen (Von Schoen) JUDG* SaSHlSG: :-'r. Hard;- - , vill you ascertain free the witness en those reports were published? 3T HH. HA-DY: Q. -Itr-cGS, will you kindly tell the Tribunal vhen the yeoorts concerning the exoeriaents above 15,000 netero, which took ol-ce prior to 1S42, February 1942, when and where wore they published? A. Z cannot say e-actly. They '-ere published in 1941-1942, aporoxl- rately, but I etnnet givo an enact date. I had nothing to do with, the publication of these reports but the reports are available. They arc at the Aero Radical Center in Heidelberg. The date can be checked. ^ Then I oresuno that the experiments that were conducted sftor February 19*2 in the sene field were also published. A. Yea, 1 an sure the:' w«rc published, too. Q, And was the work conducted by yourself and Huff and your col¬ leagues ct the Aero Medical Center at Hoidolbcrg after the cessation of hostilities? tfero they published in this work or wero they noroly put in United States Ar=y Publications? A. A very snail oortlon hod a report published. At least, Ur. Saver infornod no to that effect, but the rest of the o-ocrlnonto wore interrupted before they were cccolotcd ec vp hod not cono to an:.- final conclusions that could hevo been pub-ished but one snail oaoer in said to have been published. 2Y JUTOh SlS?.r.:G: Q. fitness, who had accese to thoso early reports thpt you eay vere published concerning e-perinents prior to 1942? A. To you neon, Your Honor, now or to when they were evaileblo at that tine? To vhoa they were available innedictely after the date of publi¬ cation. A. irinorily, aviation nedicine institutes and research workers; also the conseoucnces resulting, for tcchnioue, were available to the T--chr.ieai agencies. ::urt Ho. 1 2: ~ey 47-«*-2~2-E.--'.-rrimeau (Von Schoen) Q, Then the” vould here been eve liable to the defendants Huff end Somterg7 A. I an suro they read the reports vhlch vere published oreviouely. I an not able to say erectly vhlch reports vere uublished before the Deehan ercerinents and vhich vere published after the Dachau eruerlments. Q. But ycu feel reasonably sure that such reports as vere oubliehed beforo the Dachau erperinents vould have be.n available to the defendants 5uff and Soobtrg, and that as experts in that field the assumption is very strong that they vould have read then? A. I assume that it is extremely likely that the reoortB that were published bofore the Dachau erperinents vere sent to Dr. Buffo institute. 3 : yjsmi Q. Dr. Bcckcr-rreyoeng, 1 vish to nov turn to the condor “Tyohus" in Doeunoat 3cok Ko. 12 on page 74 of the English docuncnt number HC-206, Prosecution Exhibit Ho. 206. A. I have the d.cument. You recall In this document Professor Koso vrote to Kaagcn und referred to the production of spotted fever voccino for ell nrned forceo in the eastern area. Ho stated he had not heard anything yot fron Deoartnont Ho. 1 ar.d that it vill take sono tiae for 2? to produce his r.tv research order innoauch os Anthony is on a duty trip — and do I understand you clearly that ycu had no kcovKdgo vhatsoover of any of these activities concerning typhus rcsoarck or the production of typhus vaccines? A, Yes, you understood cl correctly. Hov, in this letter ve note the code or file nunbers 2F. Doctor, I var.t to clarify a point at this tine. Jirst of all, in the 2eferat for ' eviction aedicino you have had the code or file numbers 2113. That vas the first ono. Wasn't that the first one that they had in the Beferat for eviction medicine? A. Ho, that vas the registration abbreviation, -he firet note ves if for the research assignments. These arc two cuitc different thinge. Court *fo, 1 26 Xay 47-si-3-3-Eji-?ri2eftu (Yes Schcen) Q, You know VCry '■ell vh£t I as referring to. You have tried to quibble ne os this severe! tines. Tell ne Just '-hat the Roman mineral ceens. Vkat does it scan? Is it the reference number? A. "he registry number for the Eeferat for aviation medicine. Q, I yes't make the error again. V'ould you tell ce - 2113 - what that registry number mease, when that came into exletar.ee in the Rufcret fer aviation medicine? A. I cannot toll you. In August 1541, vfcon I vac transferred to the Reforat for aviation medicine, tbo Refcret already had this number. I don't know when it started. I never took any intero6t in that. I presume in 1940 or 1941. I don't know. Perheps already beforo tho war. I really don't know. (*. '.her. did the registry number 2T ccoo into existar.ee? A. According to the documents which you have cuteitted here it must hivo boon in June 1543. 2h«ro are occc among the document* dated during this a with which still have the old number and some which hove the new number. I assume in the course of this month of June 1943 the chango took place. "non the numbers would have overlooked. Is that truo - tho uso of tho numbvrol A. Tos, they no doubt ovorlapoed in a few let tors. Q, When did 21IA coco into existence? A. 21IA vns introduced as of the first of April 1944 oe deadline. Q. And I oresumo that the registry number 2? ond the registry number 21 IA would have overlapped during that ocriod of Aoril ar.d Kay. Vcu spy ha--*© well used both su.-b.rc. A. It is quite pocsiblo, yes. I have not bus cuy such document here but it is possible. I don't knew. Q. Xill you turn to Document XC-131 '■hich you will find on oege 58 5f document 3ook 2io. 12. A. Yes, I have it. v :,'ow, this document — do you bavo the German cooy that has tho 3175 Court So. 1 2c May 47-H-2-4-53Wri3eaa (Ton Scfcocn) code designation on the top of the document, Doctor? A. Tea, 55, 2IIA. Q. Would you kindly read that slowly so the Tribunal cay Insert the code designation on the copy of their docucent inascuch as the English copy does cot have the code nuchers set forth. It norely has •he parentheses 'cede designation". “hon they translated the letter, thoy did n-t put do*-n the nuebers, so would you kindly read that code designation so the Tribunal cay insert thee in their docucent. A. It reads, "High Caicand of the Luftwaffo"; next line "Chief of the Kedical Service"; next lino "File note 55/6026/44, Secret, (2IIA)". How, that code designation with the registry nunKr 2A refers to tho Roferat for aviation nedlcine, does it not? A. You. Q, Tho date of this letter woe 29 August 1944. A. Yob. At that tlco you wore Referent for Aviation Medicine. A. Yes, that is truo. Q, How, as I understand in tho course of your direct examination, you a&nit knowledge of this letter which yx state that you can only recollect reading rocenboring the first paragraph therein. !c that correct? Court 1 lia;* 8-h- 3-l-HJ- Ore 6 s - Von 3c non. 1 worked -n only the first saragrach of this letter in vy Ref era: end dictated it to ay t:*?ist. k. Ooes the Secretary Oeneral heve the ori_lnrl copy f c-ouent ;i0-131? Vo ala yoa hi.idly brin u it in .lease? row, this first pers^nTth that you sela that ; a drew voads ae f .Hows: "The research derlln u vita* two dry = jcc-. fev_r v’ccino free vltellinu sac cultures vo oo continue:. Therefore the 4,0C0 RH requost-a -or the r beirio -l cad et - poscl. 0 . aid y,a hlndly ex lain to :ho Tribunal Just what ;• . can bj thre rnrr e rooh? ... T.oia v>r ; .ra“h ncr-ly eo r.s tn.-c the rssi~nccnt earlier ...Iron to Haugen to ddvolon c cethod for producing vue vpc^lne ia to rcoclve farther o . :i*ovnl n& it inf ris-i .vag n th t In 1C4-. no will ..•'in receive tho •id- of 40.0 caries which he requested. ... Now this is written by you when you were referent? a• Yes, thee is whet we worfcc. out r s a referent. : is tywlcel of the wori which the referee fvv aviation -- Heine did in non-rvictlon "e;l ncjnts. .‘ell, now how did you ir eten to unow about .ese-ren dealin- with dry spotted vaccine? a. I know that frjc the rose re.. naal_naonts whivh :eon issued to Raagen, In tv.ia c'se jrobnbl; hr. Season said tee subsidy which he obtained in 1943 w o up. He, therefore, request d c.vt the nsslgnaant be -tended and that hie subsidy also be extended, -his letter to the office. Probably the j)e>ortaent 3hief sent let er to the ne referent. He either erde a - :l v. of the let: t r or wrote . asaiorauidus: on it saying * t H acen’s woric v : s desired by the Hygiene ref eiat. • a :.-.3 let r w.ald be sent arch to the deport cent Chief 3177 fleer!; 1 ;>y 2S-iv- 3-2-H3- Gro s s - Von 3 cho a. ;.e a notation "rese:ren assignment can oc entencLed" god sent It to cy ref-rat. I went wit'-, tills letter to the Finance Referat nl found out whether ther- w a or. u 6 h -oncy vallable, to'see whether all conditions could be : lmiod for living him 4C00 arts. «nd, if the Hygiene rofirent and the Finance referent h*c had no objection I -.roV oly lidtated this to my secretary *nd submitted it to ey lopartaent Chief. /ell, now nore ou -ru utiorltlng eroenditure of 40CO 324. No, I aaid already yertorday.... ... You -./rote this p* r-_rn h? a. I wrote tills, diet ted It for ...y Doorrtacnt Chief but the authority for oz-endlng the 400G r^arks bo- longed to the ann who 3lgnjd t:.e letror, -nd that ir e the ii'-rtoont Chlof. v. ¥ 03 , but no leos a man thrn rrofessor Sohvocdor rolls jc th t you had power of attorney to i:y out funds for o:r eriaontr l purposes nd this eeaas to be rather consistent with this statement. Yoatordny I scld th: t this must be come □lsunder- -trndln a which can be very easily cleared up. Neither for • : search assignments cr for any other turpooe did I pay or - :rove of 5 pfennigs. Not even ay dopartaent chlof had to power to do that. The authority 1-y with the Chief of staff, '.'her. it w-g nev c-'ses it was the Chief of the ••c fieri cervices hies elf. That i3 something clo-r, It :*n be -roved «ny time. v. Tell, doctor, w..en you issued or when you a -proved rdon so, th-t is the wrong word, too. Ihen you suggested t 40CG Hi-I be set aG?ide for .-1- gen's work what did you : Investigate the necessity of the c.ntinuetion of tl-.la 0173 Court 1 2S-: roes-Vonachon *3 order to determine the efforts rare being used for the benefit of the Luftwaffe? a• Vinr t I did wes very single. I baaed ay work on ;hc judgment of :h v Hygiene referent who nc.d to vrss judg¬ ment n It. I already said sac., cn resi-naer.t w.vioh did a! effect aviation uodicsl, accordingly the referent v:ho ..new somethin- >.ut tne field wrs oo:r>eter.t. i. how, Viler* ygu use the tern "research f ;.nd n , arc a referring tj "research f-nd of the PL.-."? Th.t arc you rtierrir.b t by use of the tern "research fund" in tho .ivst prrrfcrrt'ph? a. No, th t refers to tr.a _-ney w .ioh the offices of who oiiief of the ••odlcnl Service ned available 6 -oolfic- 1 " for research ounosos. ns in ever/ other office thcro : .re w"8 - br.dget v..erc the n no-/ was listed nci.or&lng t-: ur*oso - for construction, for our.osc of 8qv.it/mjnt, and also fer research. Not I, because I had a chin- to do with finance but the 3udgct ref-rcnc Know .it these twinge. a research fund of the a.‘ lotion .dulstry did not exist in thr»t _ener.il sense. Tell, this coordin :ion of chi a -rose re,' fund vH'.ln the Inspectorate, ber*rin e In hind, of cour o, that -•/.! took over cs referent in tr.v referst f.r Aviation ••oleins all u-'tters for research oas• ed thr.u b h «. ur .f ice n le’6t for forward to ot.ier referents, which was due tv schroeior’s procedure. Ko*.r vhv coordinated tho c. unditure of thj research fund?: homebody ..rd to • - .ruinate th«: f; tv determine whether it WuUl- allow *::o marks to hr i,en, 5000 to r.irt, 5CCO tc some other - '-or ro ., 1.100 to a lershof, 'nd so or.. Kow, who fin tud tie ellocrtlon ;f rese-rc.. funds? a. First of 11, let ~e point-out that Professor Kirt 3179 * Court i He ;• 2c—I — 5- 4-Hd- --ro a e - Vonoc ho r. nev.-r received rny subsidy c - ell. Excuse oe. 5ry John Doe in :l*ce of Professor Eire. Sow, 'ns--er ay question. very well. This cooralr.- tion of the money vrr.s up ; the refer? c for Che budget which wre responsible for :he coney. v. Just v" ainuce. The Saferat for the Bullet didn't hnow my thin? bout these research problooe. Only one nc.n . the over- 11 picture-tr. t w s Becker-Freyseng tho voferont ir. the ref erst for *virtlun ^odiclne. Hov; did * i.u finance n know whether it wvuld be r worthy cruse fev jive $dCOO :o Hangon. .a. I thought I hr- rlre _y explained that. I didn’t r.it to rene^t It. I sr.ld when such research assignment nd ouch r resorren subsidy woe issued I O ot ir. touch with tho Bucket referent if it was cn avirti.n aedlcr.l rssl 0 n- .wnt -nd I g ve the necesorry information. If it was In acme other field either the other referent went with no r - got n written note from him so that the Budget rerorent c ;i: be convinced tiirt the use of this money was sensible. Sosldes rny ;rovrl of on ex^cnditui'e hrd to bo submitted fin lly to th; Chief of tha nodical Service hiaaolf end ho signed for this expenditure. k. Tell who did you c^naulc with before you wrote the -'- •• c r-graph of this letter? *>. The budget referent - th t was Oberfeldintendont or.zcl. ... did consult with tne referent for Hygiene? In this specific ense I cannot scy whether I C-..s.-.lcod with him orally or whether In documents which given to me there vre c. written note from the Hygiene eferent. That al^ht hrve been either way. Court 1 lie: - 28—k-3-5-HD-3roS6-7on3cr.cn. In cay event you suggested that 4000 Ri< be placed ~ 5 disposal of Hanger, end your suggestion was made to cho 3uduet referent? On be hr If of my depar taer.t chief I worked on the suggestion which case from Has can hlaself and I discussed -e problem with the Budget referent. - I will ask you gain; "he v>6 the coor .lnrtor of :sec rah f -note? It wasn't Jr. Becker-.-royaeng, w s It? a. You really overestimate u:e. I v«s referont. Of c urso, I n?4 part In the coordination of this money, not only I but various other people had part in the coordlna- tlon of this m.r.ey, no: only I but vari us other people had s net.-in. to scy about it and the final word wp.o up co iohroder the Chief of the .-.odlcal service or one Chief of Staff. ... Yo. said hu would take ur w#rd for it. He left th ac matters up to you. DR. II- 1 ?: hr. President, I must object against this type of questioning, for the fourth or fifth time hr. Hardy is tellin- 3eckor-?reyseng that hr. ochroeder said t.vt Beokor-fvoyseng was res-onsibla for distributing trip noy. I think hr Hardy will grant that I know the cu_-.er.te ' , r.d that - know very well wh-t •-•r. 5cn\*oeder ft 9 ® ai£ - * : «ither In the documents nor in the testimony j: cchroeder h-ve I beer, able to ascertain when hr. Schroedor s"id t is. I would like hr. Hardy to tell us when ind "h-re and to whom Scnroedor mode this statement. In the oro=e examination of hr. ockroeder, as far as I am informed, cni5 point was not wrought up. i:-3 PRESIDENT: This Is cross examination. Object cion -s overruled. aim 23 ' r -.y l7-i-^ATT-L-i^Karrew (In-, von Schon) Court Sol 1 BY If?. HABDTi Q !fen, lot* s turn to the third paragraph in this letter, Doctor, -dwrein it 3tatos: "Plonso advise whether it nay bo assuacd that tho spotted favor apidonic prevailing at ?fo.tzPoilor at present is eormoctod with the vaccine research. 1 ’ Do you hr.vo any knowledgo of that particulrr ir.3tanco? A Yes, I know now that in 1914* there actu a lly was an opidordc in KatzTfoiler, Q r/hon did you first loam of that? A Hero, at tho boginning of tho trial. Q You ncv_r hoard of it buforo that tico? A At least I didn't roneribor it. I nov..r had anythin'; to do v/ith opidcnic reports. Q 'oil nor, was it custosnn' for c letter to bo rrritton, using your registration rackor or rogi3try nurbor, and prornred for tho signature of tho Chief of Staff Kant by an office othor thr.n your offico? A In sty diroct examination I said that this possibility did oxist. Horraally, if I had boon thoro and had known about this lottor, it would •wvo said at tho top at tho loft "2 II a/ 2 I 9". That of ton happenod that a letter cono from tiro difforont roforats and had two numbers, but since I iri3 not there Airing those days that was unfortunately omitted. Q • ff oll, —s it customary for ch. Chief of Staff Kant to docido that he was going to write a lottor tc Prcfossor 11aagon and thon ask you to writo ono paragraph and a3k another referent to rite another paragraph and then only give you a copy of shat you had written and toko a pair of scissors and cut off tho oth.r paragraphs sc- th-.t you ccuidn*\ read then? A It wa3 cust--r.ry for the deportoent chief or tho chief of staff to change letters which ho obtained frer. different roferents and son j tines t? nakc one letter out of two that v,ro addressed tc the s::;o nan. Besides, 26 —U7-'!-..- >^.-2-'tarrow (Ir.:« von Schon) Court !ibi 1 I did net receive a carbon copy in roferat. This was sont to the Registry vdiorc it was filed and I never saw it again. Sven if I had seen the carbon copy lator — which night even bo possible — thon the establishment of a vaccino .sanufacturing plant and an inquiry about an apide.de would not have interested no, because I never had anything to do vdth such :cttors. Q Touldn*t the fourth pcrngrnph have interested you, which states: "The report of 21 Juno 19ldi, in which tho investigations at ilatzrroilor arc nontionod, should, have boon sont as secrot." Secret ? A I happened hero, during this trial, to loarn tho explanation for this final paragraph which I would not have understood oarlior. Professor Rose told no that all tho typhu3 r-ports had to bo sent as secret in the »7ohmacht and, since this list was apparently none infor- natior. about tho typhus opidcaic in Katzrcllor, it is clear that this roport had to bo sont as socrot. Q “oil, this fourth paragraph doosn't rjf.r to an opidoaic at Jfctzwoilcr. This rof.irs to "invoctigations at Natzwoilor." Tho third paragraph is roforring to an cpidordc thoy'vo hoard about and want to knew if the so "invostdgations at Jfctwoilor" havo ary connootion with th_ opidordc. I3nt that what that iottor conveys? Ita perfectly obvious that :Ccnt or Rose or uhoavar suggested thoso two paragraphs was wondoring whether or not the research work done by Kaagon had caused disease cr opidcadc in tho caap. Isn't that tho inport of this letter? A It is -.rh:t Professor ?.oso tostifi.-d h_ro on tho ritnoss stand. 2 It«s quite obvious too, is it not, frar. reading tho letter? A But lot cv. point out, sinco I know that Profossor Haagon was a bacteriologist or a Zionist, it would not have callod ay attrition particularly, at th: tiai, that ho ras carrying out investigations during an o pi deni c bocauso that is what hygienists are supposed to do. Q 'ell no , ycu state horo that ycu have bocaia mrrro of th; fact titat typhus problems like this are supposed to bo dassifiod as socrot 28 : jy 1x7—: W.TD-k-3-Rarrow (Inti von Schon) Coirt So* 1 rjTd in this lottor Baagen is being politely reprimanded for not having classified his report of 21 June 19hh as secret. Yet you spent con*, sidarcblo tire in the course of your direct examination to point out in connection with J>ocuc^nt ho. 93k, which is not in a document book but was Prosocution Exhibit .:'i;5S, which was a list of radical rosoarch con- missions drawn up at the tine rhen you wore referent apparently, and within that li3t of research co-missions you nado an attenpt to indicate to this Tribunal that tho entry concerning tho typhus research of Hangon was erroneously classified in that paragraph as socrot and that you introduced an affidavit to indicate to this Tribunal that your steno¬ grapher nay well havo nado a typographical urr'r, or the st r.ocraphor who typed tho copy introduced here into ovidonco nado said error. Now, how do you consistently attempt to doclaro that there is an orror in this particular list of comissions when wo find this language preva¬ lent In this lottor of 29 August 19Ui? A I shall go back to the. beginning of ycur spooch when ycu said that I reproached Kaagon and told Karon that ho wan to nr.ko these roports sodrot. I must say that th_ lottor is signod by Kant, tho Chiuf of Staff. It was not I but sc:xj one 0I30 who told Hangon...... Q (Interrupting) I don't boliovo I said ycu. If I did, I stand to bo ccrrvctod. I refer to tho writer of tho lottor and tho writer of tho lott.r is apparently Kant, but you vreto tho first paragraph. A As to this famous list, J. Prxi a scientific sonso, ono oculd still soc from tho record that Sirory*a conclusion was wrong though easily to bo explained, Q Vfell then at that tisx, studying tho records, wo noto that Professor Sc brooder 5 tat os in his affidavit on paragraph Us "Th-ccnsulting export (Referent) on Aviation todidno, Fockor- Froyaong, '.ho had boon ny subordinate sinco January 19UU (prior to this tiao Bockur-Frcysong had boon C3 istant t Anthony who was chief under Hippko) took tho position that tho experiments conducted by Simny woro not conclusive sinco tho conditions iroro not as difficult as thoso on tho high sons." Is that tho position you took? A So, ny position was tho opposito. «gain this is a nisteko on the part of Professor Dchroodor, who for two years had nothing to do vdth this problcfu In tho courso of ry diroct oxnaination, I emphatically oxplainod that I ansidorod Siroiy's to3t conditions oven more sovoro and oven noro dangorous than tho tost conditions existing later ir. tho oxporir-jnts conductod by Dr. Beiplboock in Dachau. The fact that oxporinontal conditions arc never as sovero as tho conditions existing on th • high soas, I think i3 obvious. IJo experiment can bo :iado sovoro -ncugh to correspond IOC# to actual conditions at soa, T.ith all tlx- psychological conditions, etc. Q ^J3t a nooont, Doctor. You say this is a nistako on tho part of Professor Schroodor; a pain tell no is it difficult to bueaxi a Goneralobcrstobsarzt in tho luftaaffo? A It i3 clear that a chiof whs lias about twenty five rcfcrunt3 subordinate t hin cannot bo inf ormd about all tho details of each referent, so well that tyro years later ho will know all the do tail or one specific statca-nt lado by each of his twenty five roferonts. &188 2? 5ay -1 ^5—3— xchan (Int von Schon) Court Ifc. 1 I ar. convinced that over. General Taylor aay not bo oxactly or conplatoly inforaad about every statenant you have rede hero, that would bo Ixoanly inpocsiblo, « Toll :io waror.it you scrx sort of a sup-r roft-ront, you wuro tho one that h a n dled all the research assignments, they all wont through ycur officoj you were in the position to Professor Schroo&jr similar to the oxocutivo officor of General Taylor? Bo that as it nay. Doctor, lot us go on. In Document l8lt, which is Pro3ocutdcn SAibit 132, found on pago 9 of docunont book 5, wo find tho first letter concerning tho sea water prblcm. This lottor is fron tho tachnical offico, da tod 15 'ey 19lilj. Under 1) in the lottor, it states i • "Tho I.G. *'.athid usin^ r-inly slaver rdtrato," The I.G. noth*! is thy Schnofor nothod, is it not? A las, Q Thero is also another nano for that ruthodj isn*t thoro? A Tho factory rvux was r-o-f-c-t-i-tf. that was tho factory nnnu, it has no si;nificanco, Q doll, now, who infemad the technical offico about tho Burica no tho i? A The Sjrka nathad? Q Yos. A I oxplainod that in s$ : ir:ct ox-adnation too. Professor Anthony first hoard of tills ~ .rkn nothod and then in tho courso of I larch or April, I dan»t know oxactly as I was not there, told tho tochnical offico that such a zaothod oxistod and thun tho technical offico no doubt got in touch with IS*. Sorka, Q A Hero again I should like to rofor to ry direct oxanination. I said that in the first days of Ik;corker of 19u3, Dr. Schaofor hirself denonstratod his rxthod and gavo tho neccssary explanation. In tho caso of 5189 23 :iay U7-MTD-$4W!oohan (Int. vor. Schsn) Court No. 1 this danonstrntion and this littlo lecture, the aadical inspector Gorvjraloberstr.bsarztappko was present and so was Obersti.ngcniour Christenson, who was a deputy chief in the technical officer '.here this lottor cones fren. Q Tfhat relationship did tho chief of the nodical scrvicos havo to tho technical office? A They woro both egoncios of tho Luftwaffe, thoro were no diroct relations. In 19Ui in particular, tho chief of tho nodical scrvico of tho Luftwaffo was under the High Comand of tho Luftnaffo directly, whils tho technical offico had othor subordination, but I an not oxactly informed about that. Q /oil, now, you have taken oxcoption to tho opinion of tho vrritor of this lottor whoroin ho s tatos under paragraph 1 that this would r«xiuiro 2$ to 3 tons of poro silvor a nonth. You said that was a croat oxa&foration and y.vo ycur reasons for it. Hon, who tho r or not that would roquiro 2$ to 3 tons of silvor a nonth; can you toll us v;hcthcr r not silver would havo boon roadily avrdlablo in Oornany at that tins? A I knew tint Dr. Schaefer told no at tho tino that according to his lnfc nation frea tho I.C. and fror. soao agency of tho Roichs- bank he believod tho nocossory silver could bo obtained oven in but I nay ref-r y-u to Dr. Schaofcr. I did not inquiro about that, I rolled on what Dr. Schaofor told nc. q -foil, inasnuch as this Schaofcr nothud would roquiro tho uso of silvor nitre.to, would it not havo boon tc the advantago of tho Luftvrofro at war to nako c serious attonpt to develop tlx Borka iJothod duo to tho fact that tho Borka nothed was inoxponsivo as caaparod to the Schaofcr £ nothed? A I havo explained in groat detail as I boliovo that thoso economic reasons and raw anterial reasons were what influoncod tho technical office to advccatc Borkatit and what in tho final analysis G190 28 Kay Ji7-i'tohon (Int. von Schon) Court Ho* 1 dotomfnod Genoral-borstabaarst Schroodor to hovo the quostion of Berks tit investigated by Sppingcr and Houbner. Of course if Borkatit had boon just as good in its final offect, it would have boon a groat advantage if one could got along withontttho silvor. Q You would like to havo the experiments to dotorvi.no whothor or not it was good? 3191 23 Ksy-ci-JB-6—1-Cooic (1st. Yea Schonj Court I Z didn 1 t wuat to h„vc tno esperincnts. author I hod to parti¬ cipate is t.iu prepur ..tioa for those orporiueats because it vus or chit;-, lirct of .11 I h_d to prevent the Jerku notaod being introduced without Mias tested again und wo Lad to doternino wh.,t advice should oc given to the .victors .sid secern, if for ucdic.l reasons aorkutit could not oc introduced, ernd for oconceic reasons the liofutit could not bo introduced. .. Yet nil of the tU:e, th .t is while laying theso plans and instigating theso cxocriuoato, I understand you knew th_t ->orkutit vusa't cay good? Isn't th„t iii_t you suid oa diroct ciaeinution? a. I nuot tell you th..t v a s ny personal scientific conviction out cisco : hud coiootific opponents of the caliber of Professor nj linger end - rof cssor noubnor, w-.o ur. rccongisod tnroughout tho world end who n.wc y.»tients free ovorywhorc In the world, I hud to assuhO t..o jocsioillty th .t even I night be niotukca oaco in a wnilo. ikon you are not M a a of your convictions, doctor? «• Of course, I uphold ny convictions. I said if you think tils uet od io good vo c_-. docido only through ah erperinent. .... iwJY* Pn'.i sl.'.l oo a good breJdag point, Year »oaor. . - >13111. * notice th. t on yesterday's witness sheet Jugoa Kaogon is listed uo o witness to oo called by tho defendant, heckon- Tro-song, Oa tills aora lag's witnoss sheet tho n.-.-c nugon i.—v,on do os ..ot %fjn o n- but Koif Juogor uppcurs oa the witness sheet for tho fief end ant Jcd:or .ruyseng, Ih-t witnoss is it tho defuafi..nt noc.ror Toysen; wishes to Cell? ..... E-iSYj *a I undorst _ud it, your Honor, jr. Ea..gon is going to ..o'Or.r after tho so M wator cocpKx, nuflely _ftcr t.io c jo of Dr. hciglboock. Ur, Jaegor is the witness am roved by tho tribunal for Dr. Stolnbcaior. 0 Dr. Jnogor is the witness culled by the defendant aoiglboeck. -t t is tiuo, Tour ho ior, I wish to request Dr. Stoinb-uer to nrovido a with a notation vita reference to Dr. Jaeger out ling ouost.J>- tl.J.ly un. t he will testify to, vnere he wus boon and soac of tao c!92 28 ::^-*-C?-6-2-Cooic (Ini. Ton Scfcon) Coart I particulars. ■a— ?:13132-2: Counsel for the defend ait jeiglbocch will furnish the prosocution with such a st-tcccnt concerning tho witness. •L_ 2 _I£ ,L will now bo in recess. (a short recess w„s t.Jcon) 23 Mcy U 7 - S^T-8-l-Xerrcw (Brc«m) . C-urt No, 1 THE SUFGHiLi i'erscnais the ®urt rocn Till plccse find their sects. Iho Tribune1 is egoin in session. 3Y IP.. H-aDYi Dr. Bccker-Freyscng, rill you kindly turr. to D-ciront No. 177, *hich is i'rosecution Exhibit 133, fcund on pege 11 of Deal cent Book ft 5* I hevo it. I gethcr froa your testimony hero in direct cxcnincticn thrt you think thet this do«nent is e freud. Just rhr do you think perpetreted this freud? I bcllevo you harecocplctoly aisundorstcod ay rholo dofonao if you esauao I acid this dccxnontrcs o freud* I cover scid juch c thing. I 4, n't knou hoc you «:ldhsvo one to thtt eor.Aiaicn. I ainpiy cxplcincd thet tho Tochniccl Offi o hed drem up c ncdlcd report end thet, unfortunc-toly, in ao doing c lcrgo number of erroaa waro emitted end, in 19 Uh. I dretr the Tochniccl Cffico's ettontion to this feet but, dr.co I uuldn't knoc thrt this drcuacut res going to bee no involved in a airier trid, I didn't send in tny rritten ccrroction tt thrt tiao nor did I csk tho Tcchnlcd Offlco to do so. Ifcwovtr, thcro rests telk of c fr»ud it ony tiac. 0. Veil, let us lcok tt this docunont, Doctor. Cn tho first peco of tho document re find tho ninutca of tho cnfcrcnco regarding tho notheds for acking sec re ter drinkcblo on 20 Mey 19U4, r nd it lists tho nuabc-r of pocplc present. Theroin re notico the t thero rcro feurteon pooplo pxxsont ft the acoti ng. Nor, right I rsk you this. It secas thet you heve testified thrt you rere uncblo to secure, volunteers for tho oxperiaents froa the civilicn populcco, froa acsbers of tho Luftreffo, erd thrt res rhy it res ncccsscry frrycu to resort tc Himler's source, -by didn't htc3C fourteen aen volun¬ teer for the experiaont? You hrd fourteen aen right here, interested 23 liny Kerr or (Brown) Court Not 1 / in the problem; ycu .rf rents were efrricdr.it, they woro in tho e neen tret ion ccrop Decheu. Just whet their f: to res beforo thon end eftcr thon I don't know* Nett let's refer t= --ego 12, Doanont Bock % 5« ^his st;tcs in tho first jcre/arr.ph r.rd this will bo the second scntcnco efter the list cf tbeso presort ct thonecting on 19 !k.y 19&4. It r«ds ns follcwsi ■Tho Chief cf tho Kodieel'Service "(Chef dcs Senltccts'.roscr.s) is con¬ 'd need thet . if the Berks r.ethod is used, dcccgc to heelfch hr s tc be 8196 23 Kay &7-K-S—5-4-®arr:w(Brown) Crurt So. 1 expected not Iter then 6 days after taking Berketit, which denege Trill result in permanent injuries to h;alth end — according to the opinion cf tfctererzt Dr. Schaofer — will finally resist in dorth after net lttor than 12 dcys»’ Now this report, that tics bitten by e 3c ynen end not being c aediccl non. «nteinoi that information. '-'es thet information incorrect? "• Not only were they erroneous thon, tut they still ero. f.. Lot's turn to Document !'o. Zj 7&, the affidavit cf Dr. Konrad Schaefer, c defendant hero, irosccution Exhibit 131, on page 6o, Document Bock If 5, peregreph 3. Turn to the third for.tonco therein* ■It uca dooidod at t his meeting to cr.duct experiments on • concentration carp inmat.s Tilth the Bcrka process, although it was generally admitted that Bcrta-tit s^c water prceoas seriously impairs tho hoolth after six days and causes dorth after troolvodcya rt tho It cot. It r s farther decided thet tho human oxpcrinontal sabjccts Here to be fed only see rater, processed by the Etrka netted, for a period cf twclvo days.* Taking into consideration this affidavit rf Sehcofcr, it aopccra thr t the or.try in the ninut cs of the 19 Key meeting ero correct, does it notV *. First , let me draw your attention to the fact thet you your¬ self prevented me from specking bcut Schaefer's affidavit in my direct oxamir-ticc when ay counsel * -l shod to ask mo questions rbcut it. Now, I ikr.'t know whether it is very fair to ask no about a docunont during during the cr:33 examination. fc (Interrupting) Boar ir. mind thet I did not prevent you from d-ing thet. The Tribunal did. The Tribunal ruled on thr t. Not I. Now, i-t'3 continue. «. Then I ccn say new whet I ir*c.r.dcd to sry duifcg my direct cxnmincti n, on which matter the Tribunal ,■ on yrur auggestfcr., Tuased a rulir.T. -- * ... W . - •• * Z happened tc kr.;w that Dr. Schaefer mr.s shorn this °hri stems on S197 23 Key &7-M-SV-8--5-Eerrc*(Brown) Court Kb* 1 re pert before he signed his offidevit end thet Sr. Schecfer bolfcved that he wculdfcwc to aipplcmer.t his rcoc llvcticn en the besis of this peculiar report erd, consequently, hes set down in his effidevit whet you Just reed to oc, ted I believe thet Sr. Schecfer willdiscuss this effidevit ot greet lcegth. You ccer. thet you ere testifying now on behalf of D r . Schrofer thet he prjured himself, under ccth t in this effidevit? J.. ::o. no , no perjury. I think perheps this question should better be discussed during the heering of Sr. Schecfer. r. . "ell, it vis evidont to ycu, however, thet deeth would result eftcr not letcr then tvelvo deys with tho us. of Borkc scr. water, wouldn't it? Didn't you sey thet you fla-ted thr t es propegende so thet you oculd hevo tho experiments conducted to prevo thi t Borkr.tit nes c fcko end so thet it wouldn't Jooprrdlno the lives of r.vi'tcro in tho Coraon Luftweffo? *. I c ocnvlncod thet under ccrtcin circumstcncos dorth will occur such sooner then twelve deys if the Berke method is used, end I heve pointed out ct greet length that c scntcr.co such es it steeds here; namely, thet eftcr using the B C rke mohtcb, scr 1 us demngo is to bo expected eftcr six deys -- thi t sontcnco issorothln^ tha t c nodi eel leaden could 'rito but not c -xdicel specif list. First of ell, eftcr you tike Bcrkr.tit nothing ccn hoppon to you. "hot tho lcyr.rn wants to any is ’eftcr teking see w*ter which is ‘rcitcd with Berkrtit". Thus, from this false formulation yon cen see thet tho person v o rroto thin sentence didn't roclly recognize the true medical * nd scien¬ tific implications. 8198 Court 1 Kay 28-:-.-9-1-HD-Meahar.-3rova. Q* I aa net * a-dice 1 aan, but I can recognize the implication you r.re trying to convey at the present time, I aa sure that the Tribunal can see and 1 na sure that Christensen, the author of this report, wnoee signature is .r. th_ original, and rt is to be assumed that it v;as written by Christenson, oan certainly recognize it vra stated at this meeting if the Serkn method wa.6 usoci, it would result in death. It siaily eaya that in this sen¬ tence and I think you have shown th-t same fact in the course of your c::aain tior. here when you now say that it « would r 08 ult in perhaps leas than twelve days. Kov; l^ng do you think it w»uld take after drinking tho aea-wator treated by the 3orkn method; six days, sevon days? According to the < vnllable literature on ohlp- wreok oataatro 'hes death can follow even after a few hours after the person drinks sea wa.tor, that depends first of ell on the person’s condition who drinks the aea-wator and secondly how much ser-wntor he drinks, 'ih t is to bo ascertained hero was really and in o.'foct a specific t experimental subject v s tafcon from Slrnny'o experimental aerloo and It was explained to the technic 1 n that if this specific pors-n drank in the next six or twelve days as much sea water as h. drank in the first two or threo days, then this s cclflc -erson under these very specific re-c nditlor.- would probably die after twelve '.nyG. This waa t-ken by the technicl-ne an: generalized by them nc. chat is the basis of this unf-ctu -1 report. "e will let the Tribunal decide as to whether it* is nfactual or not. Tell me, when ere the sympc as "pp-arent whan a -oeraon drinks sea water for any period • •• • of time; ‘hat happen* to them? a. Here again it depends r, wh~ : c-jnditiun the person 1?5 Court 1 1; - y 23-M-i-3~H3-}feehan- Brown. la ir. ~n& how auch he drink6. They ni^ht s-f:*cr froa diarrhea; is that rld'.t? Thnt entirely depends on how -uch sen-w"ter ho drlnk6» %. It Is possible, of course, tlvt v. person could hrve diarrhea as r result of drinking eea-wrter. «. You cannot answer Chat q.^estlvn In such ^ener 1 terns. «-• It It possible they could h ve convulsions, that la the synptoas of the effect of drlnkin. sea-water; isn't it?. In a hundred cases ni 3 ht it appear in one? a. I never herrd that. DR. TI??: hr. President, c^aln the objection thnt I unfortunately had to a:ho yestordn;. I nrve to aelce ny\ln. hr. Hardy is not letting Jr. 3eclcer-Freysen£, finish his aontences. I believe it would contribute to the general olnrlty of the interrogation if the witness c^uld conclude his euntonco6. THE PRESIDENT: T.:o witness ary be allowed tv finish *ny sentences he desires to answer no nut to fc. o by the Prosecution. BY XR. HaBDY: Q. Is diarrhea a sy^cptoc after a person drinks sea¬ water even .no percent of the tine; in one r.unhred caooo - 1 -ht it hn aen once? «. Thnt .vis nothin^ to do with n percentage, it depends wholly on the quantity contained in the Individual dose of sea-wrter. If yo; drink 3ore than 3C0 cc of sca-wnter m no 3in^le dose thor. you have dlr.rvnea, if she dose # is scalier, then you do not. •i. Car. j u suffer fr,u convulsions '3 r. result of drinkln- ?. certain mount of sea-water? A. I cannot answer that question, Pro- the literature - read, 1 -:n w of -.v air. le case of c r.vulei ns and 6XC Court 1 Hhy 23-&-9-3-m>4feehan-3rown since I did not see the sea-water ex.-sriaents myself, It 19 impossible for me to answer the't question In the affirma¬ tive. I dc know th-t in the case of the disease that I referred the technicians to os a horrible example, namely cholera, you do h-ve convulsions, but these c nvulslons r.ro not solely the result of drinking sea-water, - v ut ere a symptom of sickness itself. I cannot designate between those two possible sources of the rucctlon at the moment, what is the result of thirst or of the sickness itself, perhaps Professor 3el t lboecke can answer that question. (t. nfter drinking sea-water for seme period of time, is it possible that the person may suffer from hallucinations; will they have halluolnotlons? «. The literature I have read on cases of ship-wrecked arsons and this is • bout all detailed descriptions of English sea-wreoi ta , they speak of "Fata i4or b ann u and other natters. Now whether In a etrickly psychological oonso these are genuine hallucinations or not 1 do not know, the literature is vory llmltod in this matter. I am not a Psychiatrist and I cannot answer this question, but since I know that you ere referring to this document, this Christensen document, let me say that in my dlroct examination I quoted a passage from Bergmann’s text books regarding thirst symptoms of oholera rnd there was nothing there about hallucinations. i. And you have testified already death can result from drinking sea-water? a. ’fee. Q. Well now this sentence here in this report written by a lay-m^n, Christensen, st-tes: "External symptoms are t be expected, such as drainage, diarrhea, convulsions, hallucinations end finally death." That Is n -retty good 8201 Court 1 .Icy 28-H-9-4---:i>-Meehan-3rown. accurate statement, isn't it? Let me say first of ell in xon.ral it frequently occurs trot lay-men do core talking about difficult subjects nd are sore dangerous and unuleassr.t tnan specialists, ana sec ndly, I a?ve already told you what the 'oasis of this Iry-xen's etc tenant la, which is mainly the quotation fr that text hook. I mentioned that sentence in the text book and oertclnly it suet h've made a .rent impression on Hr. Christenson or perhrps os Schickler, if ho drew up the \-eport, thrt la why you find it reproduced here in report, .loroover in Sirsny's erse oxtorinontal 9 ibjoots -ctuclly ..id h-v*. diarrhea bet clrany'e experiments were vach x^ro unpleasant nd d»n u vr us than the experiments th?t ay associates lanned * nd wnicn Slvglboeck carried utt ... in thoso arses of -urs we did not h»vo any diarrhea. Well, now, Cnristens^n soys hero In this report tit” c a n result of the prellnlnrry discussions it was s teed to -r^ng.- n new series of experiments of short duration; tn°t fact is true isn’t it? /i. Ih.it la nd ubtodly true. There ler.'t cuoh in s’ in. tr. t, eocause everythin, revolved rround that question. It was 'iso agre.d th?t In t.i- series of experiments ersone would be ^lven sea-water processed with c e ierx; tit method; wasn't it? Let ue juc-t set aside the report for r. moment. It was also reed that persons vr-uld ie used In the eroerimer.ta 'nd said persons Would^ ecelvo sea-wrter -/rocesscu by toe : .erko actnod; isn't t- t right? .•i. Tnafc did not »v.ve to ce reed J?on, because that t.i- q.estl n we were trying to decide. Court 1 l-r/ 23-14- -5-HD-*eehan-3rovr.. It w's also staved th*t o r6ons selecte.. w uld be *- ntrol arsons *nc the would ..rink rarely plain water; didn't they? Tr.-*t c 9i-i is >ne of those c ntrol jr^acs, w .lch ~e frequently been senti-ned in tills trial, namely the ov.cr 1 ccsae. The) wove such better off than the actual experimental groups uao drank the oerfcatlt mfi aon-vaccr. I JS -ibly Q ~i- t t nt that ti e bao^uea these wore scientific objections which I made to Dr. Von olrenl's *'lr.n for tha ex:ericent as he did n<-t nrva such o. control v in ni , series of experiments. Sow, ; . ve stated here in . irect exsminatlon t -c persons would be given SCO cc of Sorketit, nothor -r up would be cjlven 1,000 cc of Serkatlt, the t.?lrd ^roup - 1 - ' ot « ncrunl 5 roa. c iven ordln-t • drinking water, the f urc e»roup would be a lven aea-w ter without rnycnin B and r ©V up • ould ; .c nothin.,; is enw rl = h; what you said ncre in direct examination? I.Vv was o prrt of what I sold in direct oxaaino- ci n, out n,t "11 «nd vnrt ,uu ..we left out I consider very important, nr-wly the conditions under wuich t.:o or^eriaenta wor. to ^ carrier j ut, wnlch were docidod n .n the presence of Professor -5:>->in*or and fceubner, icii -s f ndiaentally difference fr.o n aediccl exporl- onfcc.l series. v. Veil now ou said in your direct exonun 61 n that intended t aake the Cheese -or* bind in ^, Doctor, when stated t-.vr. •..•-a c fifth c r an nd a fourth . roup. 5 flft. will B et nothing " t all, tn. fourth wall B ht l-in sen-rre-r; y a wouldn't even hv. . the c urtesy _vln_ u.:os Si-a-water Cre«t d wit.: he Berk?vie toethod; - i - t ri_. t? I.. v is not nr eve lane kqrc in t.'is report e2C3 Court 1 hay 28-i—9-o^KB-Kechcn-Brovm» cither that you intended to use people end give then: nerely sea-v. ter and nothin-, else. I arc very gird that the Prosecution has finally stated that what actually was decided on and what atate- aenta ere lr. this resort is in contradiction to each other. I never thought that Berkntlt w'.e a particular act of philanthropy or that drinking sea-water is not such a horrible anttor as you soca to believe. 32C4 2 ? - - J-JP-1O-l-Coa* (1st. orown) Court I PoojIo die with it, don't they? iv, you c_i die with anything. Certainly. Let's go on, urJbie Ho, 2 on page 13, Christenson st tee hero ur.or the section: "Persons nourished with sou water .aid bcrX-.tit, end ns diet also the cnorf «cy ee_ r_tione. i>nr_tion of experiments: 12 d^i. ei-ce in tne opinion of tee Chief of tho uodic.l tcrrleo (Chef des SaaitACtsveeens) permanent injuries to health, th .t is t_c do.th of tno ejperineat 1 subjects nos to be exocctcd, ns on?oriucat.a subjects such persons should be used ~s will bo put ut tao diB 'Oa.J. oy the ueichsfuchror SS." Dr. Christensen a-do th .t ra;.\rk .tad ho obviously b..sed th_t rui_rh on what he hc_rd at tho co.ifcrcr.co, did he not. Ho didn't Just conjure up th_t idc. by hinsolf, did no? ..e corcainly no.rd th-t out wft.t is written down hero is not wn. t ..o heart frot: ac or Sr. Sch.offer verb .tin out lo tno result of what Christensen understood. .oil no - l_iaod tne experiment. I n.von't asked you t. c o.-.cstion _t nil. I have asked you ccncor.dng wn.t Chrin&cnsoa vroti in t is roport right hero in this p.r_^r.oh: "Since in tho cni..i .. yl .no Cnief of tne kcdic_l services penaanunt injuries to hodth, tn..t is, t-.c e'e .th of tao cx>eriacat..l subjects n..s to oo expected", 28 -2-Coolc (let. irovu) Court I .or ■ -C he re. th-t t t;. t ceoting, did-'*, he, or hu wouldn't h-vo written it n«.rc? a. ho nasi certainly did not c«.ur it _t ta_t tiue because I 36VO" S.id ca flUCh aOU3CT.BC. T„ He s;j s he hc..rd it rrt the aoctia^, doesn't liol A. Ho S. J*B BO, :-C8. r. .*nd fr.rthcmore no «.ya in t~io n-r^r .’jn th.t due to tho f..ct t . t dc..ta is to oo cxpectod, vo vill h_vc to &ot our oxperiuontrl subjects f vet. tho ..clchcfuohr.r SS, taut Ib wn .t t.iut s.ys ir. thio p-r.<;r ph, does it not? Plo.Jic let j. tell you ny second rc..Boa why t.iiB c.unot oo true, .uid tain X c a -cover your question. Juat .. uouont, dove tn..t Buy th .t in tnit parugnph frou rcadi.^ t ia p..r.r.,uh on it'«f xo, doeo it not «.;• tr. .t tr.o do..th of t..w c:;.)oriaaat-l subjects a^a to 00 expected, und us experiment.1 • objects arch )»rcona should 00 uoed -0 vill be put ut :.-.c diooo.l or t.:o .oic.ua’uehrer SS, does it s»y th_t or doosa't it? u. fhoro 1 b no doubt it io r.wrv. iooody doaios it i« writ ton hero, and. Z newer denied tn..t tno docc-ent is genuine. ?. Hotf could Christenson Jtow tho .-.clcfcsfuchrcr SS would amply co..:ouSr tio: c.*:p inures? ^ Lot tell you firot of -11 th .t between Christenson'a office und s. - .O-Chfuehror SS, there, without tac ChUf of t .10 i.cdlc-1 Ir.Bpoctorr.ti or ays.If h..twins „o©ut it, tr.wrc v.rc cloeo connections. ..oroovo: at t-r meeting cf tno X sioko of t o possibility in c-sc VC f; a t r.o other ox-^ri-out-l subjeetc of mah: ^ -a effort to use iatL.tos, uad net boc.mav t..e orjoriuonta were dangerous or co Id Cu"Ji- dc..tu, out parol;' for oru_ai rut i caul rouaono. How I _sk y -n for tl._ t lire*, tine, plo-se let ue fi..ish ay second re-sen. -»ftcr the coot* :. : -o 2cth of ..-y w tried to c-rry out tr.o exp cri Junto such -e t sc .c. Oly to he carried out in O-chuU on e-dots from the C206 28 ::^--:i-v"?-lO-3-Cock (lut.arovn) Co rt I -Hi: ry .caiica;- aad taor. vr.on v t vcr. net successful ia th-t, tacn to Carr t_ou rat oa persons la the LuftVaffe iosuit JL ia .rfrunaviok, Th-i t.’Wci vita out doubt ta_t taa conclusion v.ich Caristvaaea scam tc :...vo dw*a ia to.ls rc ort is certainly not - correct conclusion. .. "acre is th_t cvidcr.ee? It B-aas vcr; sieplo to tie - ..r. Christens oa b^« - "aerc is t*.c evidence to .t you a_d ca sorinonts ..fter that tiuo, iter too 25ta of ...y, oa c.-dotc? -tore i^. that oridesco? _ .hofer to the ..ffid.vit of toe Ccuaacdor of the r.odic_l ^.Aaay of tao Luftv.af®. I don't bolleve you vill accuse hiu of CO - it tin;. pvrjuxy. Otaerviao, you vould n-vc- to aJto aiu et..nd trial and taat a ..a ..ct yet tje-a ol..cc, -ad too Ca'.cf of fac Luftveffo .vault 1 ia -runovick who fi-m also givoa an -ffid-vit oa tr.lo subject, c-ya ta t clto«r Scirrocder nor arcane ->tnorircd by tin, v..o to car;* cut a;jori..cat« ia too LuftV-ffc Hoooit-1 ia arunoviefc. .. i)iu they c..rry out tao croon-onto? I c-ld o-v «. r„l ti-os tr.-t ooc..ub« of coaditions in 19*« unfortrn..tol:* to- c^3o.-Uur.t« could bo carried out neither ..t top ono nor rt oto.or >l-co .jvd ta- o v„s tau re-son toy tae letter v_ D ooat tc Hia-ilur .-.c^a* titot these ox-erinc-ts bo carried out on i»atoo, pad V...I lo toe rc-sen ?. Of c - rou. Caristcacca iaplius hero too only roaoon way you -ro *>ia; to -i.~l-r lo *o.c axoc you ejected do-too ufld you c..n very vt-li hill concoatr .tlon c.ir* inuntes vhurv you ccri..ento i -,\d in tho ono or tho other testimony here 1 co_rd ti'. t corroborated. •*, Did you nc-r free defuse counsel or othor sourcos tnat Professor lining or coiuitt^ suicide ia u Juttor of heuro after being vioited o; a representative of uy offiect a. -.To, thin is t o first ti_o th..t 2 have ho.Jd th-t. You don't n..ov whether or not Professor Droingor ever hod uis- jlvi •> about boiag ic-^licatcd !r. the B*>ori. eats with sea vatcr r.t tho ynch.vu c ..co-.tr .tiin c._''7 —. If a over ..„d .jy such aisgiviags Just g.iertly before his do..th. 8209 23 Ifey-iS-jJG-ii-l-<5rcss (Brown) Court 1 Q Let's turn t_ ikeument NO-185, page 18, Document Bock V, wr-ich is i rcsccuti; n Exhibit 13L. You *rcto tnis letter, doctor? .. I drew up the first ircft of this letter end dictated it. Shewed this draft tc =y department chief end he, as I clearly rcaentocr, cade a few changes that I dc not remember exactly today. . erhr: 3 you cay have his files end there ere in cy original draft tho changes that he ancle. Then the letter was soicittod tc the Chief of Staff end finally was submitted to the chief hicsclf to be signed. 3 Acccrding tc the translation cf this docunont by dofenso counsel. Dr. Urrx - the important scntoncc that *o have been discuss¬ ing hore is the second statement in th't letter. Dr. Marx's trans- 1- ticn roads as follows: "Today a yin I an standing before a decision, which, after numerous exj-cricenta cn an Inals and also on human beings demands a. finrl solution cn voluntary experimental subjects." New, using that translation can ycu tell no whe tho hunan beings wore, that is, tho ncn-v.luntoors that ycu used prior tc this. Y~u are aakine fer vclunteors. Free that sentence it indicates tc me that ycu had toepori- centcd with rnicals, thon n;n-vcluntocrs, rj»d new ere stressing the fact ycu want volunteers, 'ho were the ncn-vcluntcers ycu used before ycu asked Hinder fer volunteer subjects? .. First cf all in this whclc 1-ttcr there is n.thin; about vdun- tcers. Life dees net consist scl-ly of contradictions sc that bocauso there is the word volunteers ir. cr.e sentence ycu cannot ccndudo that all the other persons that were used were non-vclunt<.cr3. That is net necessary antithesis. There were tw t,u 4 >s cf experimental porsens. First cf ell, in the two series of -xperiaaits there Wurc the associates cf Dr. Schaefer an! cn the ether hand experimental su Jocts used by Sirany in Vienna, E.th of these croups cf subjects wero volunteers, no doubt. 1 . oil, y:u have already experimented on animals, accordin' to the translation by defense ccuns 1, end y u have already experimented cn hunan beings, but new it demands further criaents. ’Set is tho re-son ycu couldn't use the same hunan beings, f.r instance, that y.u used for the ethers. Is it because the final solution is death? 23 ^y-JWJG-ll-2-Grcss IBrcwn) Ccurm 1 Sc. Schaefer* a experimental subjects wore in tctc four tech¬ nical assistants end I think nothing threirs a sharper light cn the sere oli; 7 it in which Germany fcun: itself in at the tine, then the fact that Schaefer, during the course cf his experiments had tc uso feur technicians as experimental subjects at the s&ne tine carrying cn their regular work. If cnythinr c uld have been dene it avoid thrt these technical assistants certainly we uld have given up regular work during the experiments. Sew, the second group of subjects were inmates cf hospitals. These are people in pert, as 3r. Schaofcr will be later cfclo tc state, whe had wounds whe, hewover, cculd net bo usod at tho front because of the wounds. And, theso consequently were persons when we cohsidorcd net tc be appropriate fer the testing of tho Berko method because whet we needed for oxpcrincntal subjects were healthy porsens free th ago of 18 to 30. He . ersen among tho specialists concerned ever mentioned cr thought of death in cc.incction with these experiments and in this letter te- there is no nentien cf death. It dees n.t oven say in this lettor pors-ns ccndcnnod tc doath should be usod fer the experiments which should certainly bo in the letter if death was censidcred at all a possibility cf the cxpcrlacnts. a ’.oil here in the letter in the second paragraph you atato "As the experiments cn human beings ciuld thus far cnly bo carried cut for - period cf four days, m* as practical riccicnds requiro a runeiy fer these who aro in distress at see up tc 12 days, appropriate experiments are necessary." .j\'. the other document signed by Christ¬ enson says death nculd result in 12 days. Ycu have it in here thrt ycu thought of death when you vr.te this document. These two documents fit tegothey like a jigsaw puzzle. .. I beg y_ur pardon. Ycu said thrt death is again mentioned hero. * According tc the true- copy that I have before lx. I sco no oonticn cf the word doath. q Ycu said here necessary tc experiment with than for 12 days, and any experiment lasting 12 days acccrdin; t; ycur cwn testim:ny and acccr ir. tc the document rill result in death using the Berica method. 8211 28 :!ay»:.-.vG-ll-3-Grc3s (8kwa) Court 1 Of ccursc, I admit that ycu need the other document. leu aoist realize that it is apparent here, isn't it? It is not at all apparent. I have cade efforts but I 30 c they have ‘cun in vain tc say in my direct oc ac i n ation why tho numb^r 12 ccr.es up here in reference tc the numicr of '.rr s. If ycu stress it I will repent that testierny new, otherwise I can wait until later ,n when ccur.acl re-direct examines no. Gc ri^ht ahead. .. Thrnk yeu. This sentence simply says th't the autho ’ that wculd subsequently be used in practice vas t be tested for 12 days experimentally. !.’cw let us esaumo that I h'd 12 different Methods and wanted to chooso tho test ene. Th-n thu first aethc l would fell cn the very first day, end the persons .ho were used for this first nethed would bo eliminated fr n the ocpcriaentr 1 series on the very first day; this would keep cn until* cn tho 12th day of tho experiments, only theso persons would be left who had bean treated by the best aethod on.', that would be the method proved to to usable in practico, which would thv.n jc introduced. There is no mention in this letter cf .-ny experiment tc be carried cut fer 12 drya with the dangerous and unsatisfactory Berkatit. ..ni I bjiov. I cm io.av . the rest tc the preef of the actual results of this . x^ronents • wWch oho no th't they we.c enried eut as I have just described *J Doctor, at the tc;: cf this letter we Sv e the registry nun! cr 2F. Hew does it happen that y.u used the ru-istry number 2F at such c late date as 7 Juno 19UU, cr was th't just ene f those instances whero 2 F and 21 L. overlapped? I have enly a type! co,y hero, net a photostat, but I assume t what ycu say is correct. Either that was one of the eases whore tho two overlapped, cr I made a mistake in the ictu. i oif.aps tho new number was not introduced until ii.y. ..t my rate there is nc dcutt that this letter was handled by my Eeferat. -j Hew many tir.es had ycu requested inmates from Hiamlur prler tc this tiioc? fly ? 26 Hcy-K-3JG-ll-4-Cross (3rc.nr.) Court 1 •» I cysclf, never. 1 Hew Hd you knew that y.u ccul<: get inOates from Himmler? .. I ' oliovc that *as explained at greet length during the exenin- ti. n of * ref. Schroeder. Tref. Schrceder was j rovicusly employed with the Rcichsarzt SS and iclicc end found cut frer; hin whr.t procedure wns tc be pursued in this ease, and then I received an erdor, frea the Chief of the Medical Inspectorate via ry department cni-.f tc draw up such r. letter. That's hew I knew about it. ; ell, you of eovrso kr.uw in 1942 free; listening to the cenfor- unco hotwoc n Rcscher end Kip; kc that you ccul 1 cot uxporiracntd subjects frea Him-ler. You knew thet at en early date, didn't you? Had ycu gene to Himmler r.t any ether tiao? Or had Schr-cder gene tc HinJ.tr? Or had Hippke gene to Hinder? Frea this letter it appears ycu ore quite f.“oilier with the procedure necessary tc ret tho proper nuraber of sub¬ jects frea KLxder. Ycu sry here "Earlier already y»u aado it pcssiblc fer the Luftwaffe tc settle urgent nedical natters through experiments en huacn beings." New, when, other then in the hijjwltitudo and freeling experiments, did Hiaalcr arJca it possible fer the Luftwaffe tc settle urgent nodical natters? Ycu apparently -t this time knew about all ether experiments conducted en concentration camp inmates fer the benefit of the Luftwaffe. Ycu urcto this letter. •• Fr^.a the c^nf«r^.nco betwuen General Oberstabsarzt Hippke and '.ir. Rcschor I found out nothing about the way Rcschor get his experi- °®ntal subjects. I dearly renumber that Kcschor named not only Kircm- l- r ftt that time but dsc Hitler. Sc, if I h:d had tc do ti .-lone I aa-ht have filed ay application with Hitler er with hcich Ministry cf Justice, er I don't knew rtizz I n ,-ftt have sent it tc. .nd, moreover in ay direct examination I said ct re. t length that this fipst sentence refers tc the fret th-t I inferaed Irefesser Schrcciur ct that tine th:t iTefesser Hclzlcchner h-d carried cut oreria.r.ts in 3r.cb.au end th.-t Rcschor h-d stated in Numbers th: t these exporinents were under Himmler* s responsibility. That was t c total oxtcr.t cf kno* ledge in 2213 p 23 ::-;'-i:-JJG-ll-5-Grc3s (Brcvn) Court 1 these sitters, ind I cannot reedy cny acre into this first sentence. This give the Luftwaffe the opportunity u clarify urgent acdicel prcl-clss — quick req-rsing — threu^ ocp .riment — net experiments — on huar-n cir.-s. I don't knew hew you can draw the conclusion frea that that I knew about oil the experiments. Q .ere you ewaro of the fact that Hasten get inmates from tho SS? .. Me. Of that I knew nothing. I believe this question will bo thcrcuJily clarified hero. 62 1L 26 —ay-~-j J-12-i-r.ar ro _ — (?rciin ) - Court 1 *11, now this SwCoM s-ntcncw, t:„ one which the interpre¬ ters s j is rati._r ambiguous. however, they co state t&at thy rros.cu- t ton's translation is more likely. This sentence as it stand in tlx. copy p:\JcnUnd by the prosecution, or the translation present-r.a by the prosecution, or. pege 16 of Document ~ock 5*, states us follow a Document V5, not 15. Q I believe I srid 5. ‘Today I .again aVxr.d before a decision, which .fur nun.reus -Xp.riments on animals and also on voluntary humn: subjects, demands final resolution,' Mo.;, as that stands hen. now, isr.' t it apar-r.t that you had -forked as far as possible on voluntary human subjects >nu tint you Wer- lookinfc for inmat-s oth-r th n volunteers? TIP.- . r. .rcsii-nt, perhaps this would o- the appropria¬ te r.oo nt for a brief remark, n ml; tli. : olio-ring: Jlr. hardy has just stated that th. interpreters said that the prosecution's version was more lik-ly. I ale p.ruicsio:. to put two questions to the interpreters to clear up this difficulty once ar.d for all, tn.n 1 b.lieVe We shall a.. thi3 natter r-"f-ctly clear. The first quwttion. . H. n. Oust a zccxnt, 'four honor, I h-v. - 1 ready filed with th- Tribun-1 a neajoroadaa. Dcfens. couns.l r_s that opportunity to do • sou-. The Prosecution has fil.d their a morandua, a copy has be.n Sent to defense counsel, natter o: ..re. months ^go, .;ith th. opinion of the Chi,, of t;»e translation Section, nd the Chief of tho transla¬ tion Secftaon , who is core an authority o.i this matter icndcmicolly ihan th. int-rpr-ters in this cour. rcon, has stated in that a_aormdum rcth to the Tribun.1 nd to Defense Counsel, that the translation as » pr.scnted by Defense Couns-1 is absolutely incorrect. Ther-fore I think I can continue =y . go a l na tion, presuming that -h_ Prosecution's con¬ tention is right, "Ithout int.rruption. T:xj FILe ID£"'i: as far as I know, no c_mb_r of t.-.e Tribun::! has a. n *,h. Certiiic t_s •••hich rare filed concerning th.se different trans- <3215 23 tiy-JH5J-12-2-Karrow-(Broim)- Court 1 lations. I understood that the interpreters, who reported to the Tri¬ bunal in open Court, would file a written statement of That they had reported. If Counsel desires to cross-examine the witness upon the assumption that the Prosecution's translation is correct, th_ Prosecu¬ tion nay do so. utK&Y: Pardon n., Your Honor, cay I cross-cxaain. the witness following the contention that the translation is correct and not assu- ain^ it to be correct? DP.. TIP*; Hajr I reply briefly, r. President? ..r. Hardy stated that a memorandum from th. Chief of the t ranslation Dcparto.nt was put in three months ago, stating that the Def.ns. Counsel translation is in¬ correct. Let Qe nention two points in this connection. First n-ith.r I nor ay two colleagues conc-m-d in th Sea water natter. Dr. Pelcknann and Dr. Steinbauer, ever saw such a memorandum froa the Chief of the language Division. Secondly, the sentence which . r. hardy s-.ys th« Defense is translating incor-.ctly is apparently the one which was put to Beck r-Ffeyseng four days ago, by Dr. ;rx, in direct examina¬ tion. .Vow what Er. Hardy says cannot b. entirely corect. I do not believe *r. President, that it is permissible, before it has be.n cleared up without any dcubt rhich of the two interpretations of this Sentence dOvS justice to the spirit and the letter of the Geman that cross- vxmination be carried out on the basis of the translation submitted by the Frosecution and contested by eh- Defense. If this cross-examina- tion is tc have any point, it can be carried on only on th. basis of a new translation which is accepted as cor ct by both the Defense and the Prosecution, -nd such a translation w. do not have. THE p.'ESirVT: Does Defense Counsel desire to have hos # own _x- p_rts a-Jcc another translation of this, with their reasons for the tran 5 - L-.tio.n which they contend i3 ccr..ct? DH. TIFF: Yes, -j. PreSid. nt. This memorandum is in - state of preparation but is net yet finished. I b.livc »e can dispense with. • written memorandum however if the interpreters would not answer two GZL6 25 —ay- '.-0 J-12-3 -:.orro-(Br 111 not r.sk tl e quv*tions without the p-mission of th- tribunal, but counsel was making sob- further statesunt. D' . TIP, : s. Pr-sident, I should like to put to th- int-rpr-- t-rs only taro questions, th first of vhich is. TKL r. ZIZ .:i( Interrupting) Just a nonr.nt befor. propounding those questions, Oh. t h v. jou to say conc-rning that proetdur.., .r. Hardy? . hn.Li. lay conc.ming that proccdur., Your Honor, that it isn't prop.r to ask the court int.rpr-t.rs this questions. This is a uc deaic on . Office for Chief of Counsel for >.'ar Crises has • :oui’ Abtilujifs in th- language Division, on- of hich is th- tr nsl\- tion Suction. In th. translation Section are p-ople that have different qualifications ir. -any rsp-cts froa th. intrpr-ters ncr-, nd in such .iatt-r as this t.-,-y coaf-r with on. anotn.r nd sit in a rcur.d-tabl- c nf.r.nc-. Just that has be-n don-. To ask th.s int.rpr-t.rs h-re to rinuttnn.ously runr.r qu.stions conc-rr.in th-s- points vhich re oo abiguous, nd to uo it in a p_ricd of l-_lf hour, is unfair, nd I subnit that if D. i_ns- Counsel r.qu.sts to nut qu-c'ion» cone-mine translations, that tb.y should b- dSr_ct. d to th- Chi-f cf the Trans¬ lation :ranch of the Of*ic_ of Ch. .'V Counsel for far Crivs, nd th- 3r-i-: of that Br nch will nsu-.r his qu-. tions. D: . TI.’ . 1 r-gret that l-r.riy is cccusin. j- of unf ;im-s£. - b-li-v. that i h.v- not d-s-rved such an accusation ir. th. course of ~y pr-s-ntation so far. low-v-r, if 1 h*-v- so b-.n r-proach-d, .ir. :r-siO-nt, I 1 that it is Just as fair that th- Iranslation D-p-rt- . , according to . r. ! xd;, turn . three months a c 26 Ii-ferroF-( ;rown)- Court 1 bout this dcc‘3iv. dcocuix.it in the seawater case, which def.nse counnsel h:.d n-ver -v,r heard, until now, such less seen a copy Oft THE P:-SILENT: The Tribunal finds no occasion for any reproach to uefunst Counsel. During th- noon r.c.3s, rhich is about to take place Counsel for Defens- nay procure - the S-cretary General nay deliv-r to Ccuns-l for Lcfe.ns a copy of translation which the frocecetion says ;r-.s fil-d tit:. the BbfUnsc Counsel see- tin. ago. Defense Counsel nay th_n prepare th- questions thich they d-sir- to propound to translators and submit those Uestions to th- Tribunal when it r .convenes at 1:30 o'clock. • Copies of all these pap-rs should be prepar-d so that each n.:3b_r of the Tribunal nay hr.Ve *. copy. -“*• Ha.DI: Tour Honor, ir. corr.-ction with this topic, I undcr- st vnd that this situation arose see- nonths ago - was brought up by D-ftnse Counsel. At that tlx, ix. .icfcan-y - oj cours-, I m busy rdth a-.ny other problems. I didn't ban le this prOblca. .j. hcH-n-y handled it. .ir. mq honey at that ti-n requ-st-d th- Translation Division to a- laustivcly stud;, the docuo-nts, and h. ( 11 .d a o-aorandua, writt.n by -ranslation Division, with the Secretary Ckn-ral for distribution. It a--y r.ll bo that it has not b-.n distributed to date, but that was, .as I understood it, .and it was in answer to an objection previously rai¬ sed, by Dr. : one, not Dr. Tipp. JUEC2. S2~:a;!3i .Tell, .ir. Hardy, if that has been don-, shouldn't it be a Very easy thing for you to procure copies and deliver thus to 3 uch Counsel the Defense as are interest-d and perhaps deliver than to this Court. This Court have never seen then. HAHDY: All copies wer- delivered. ..'o copies were saved, Your Honor. I hrv- be a unable to find th- other copies and I an preparing • icvr one. to sub nit durin rebuttal. •-- .'iL.lI DLJ.T: You say the Secret_ry u e.ieral has no./ no ori- Din -1 copy on fil_? r». 'EY: ..-11 I didn't check with the Secretary ’civral. a BZLC 2'- -ij J-12-5-:: arror-(Trown)- Court 1 I:i ?:23nsy - ; Itot -.fOBld b- th. Office. - that node bo the plocw ~-r. e.rtainly ar. original should be. Counsel for the Prosecution ^ C ~ fui8t rin -wceXttin, curing th. noon recess, whether the S.cre- t.-o-i 1 -n.rol -till has an original copy of that translation as it was r.ported end filed with the Secretary- General end delivered to Counsel s stated nor by Counsel for the Prosecution, although he 7/as not Personally connected with the preparation of that translation, a copy of that translation should b, r.ad: to pr.Sent to the Tribunal at 1:30 o'clock. By that via. D-fense Counsel nay pr.pare th- qu-stions conccr- nLng this disputed translation which they d-slre to subsit to adequate int.rpr.t.rs, whether our own in court or others or a combination of both The Tribunal will then deUnain. how th- natter will b. handled and a final report will be andt to the Tribunal. Th- ultinat. d-cision rill, of course, r.st the *ribun . 1 . KAliDT: Your Honor, I'n afraid I won't b- able to Secure those copies of the tmaslation. I would hav- to explore around to find theSo I copies, and I could not oak- the* available at 1:30. n:. ela'N'T: It cccured to =. that the origin:-1 would be on file with the Secretary -aural, it hadn't occur.d that th. disputed translation would be very Ion?. I suppose it would take fiv- ainutui to nake copies on typ.-.-rlt r. I nay be wrong. *- • iji "hen, could I request eh- cl.rck her. to piocedure that froa the Secret-ry O-n-rals Offic.? Ti . ISi. fi : The Court is about to *o into r.cess. I would cugr-st that Counsel for the Dcf-nse ind th. ‘ros.cution and the Clerck of this Court proceed tegeth-r to the Office of the Secretary ‘enural nd .scert in if that record i3 available there and can be found. If it c nnot, and no other copi.s ar- available that would be an lapass! I 3 * r -* this tr:nslction is conc.rn-d, and w. would hav. to start ev.r if :in. Is there anything lurth.r th_ Tribunal can st- te prior to t.irir. a r-c.ss? Z • :I? * : - c “haps, ir. President, I could ask that the noon r.cess 0219 25 ay- -3J-12-6-Karrow-{3rown)- Court 1 bo until 2:oo o'clock. In the. period of one hour I doubt whether I or r. Hardy -vill be bl. to slake these necessary ascertainments. .. .. HaED?: Tour Honor, I think the best solution to this pro- ;lja is, _ think the objection has b.-n raised to a question put by - in the course of cross-cxaaination. The problem is that d-fenst coun¬ sel n :s submitted a translation which creates a doubt .s to th. authen- city of a translation submitted by the prosecution. That is argument I think chat if we can put this off to a futur- date - p.rnaps during th. tine of rebuttal and clothing wh-n both sides can ably prepare a trUf on the subject and submit then on that drw, th.n the people in¬ volved can be c tiled bafor. this Tribun :1 as itn-ss s and testify, if necessary. I think the probl.a i3 far too .cut. to try to settl- it today jid rill continu. ay cross-.xanination by m.r,ly r-f.rrin. that ay copy is tni., as an assumption, as I did in th- case of th- d. ^ns- course's copy. I hav don. that in on- instance end I should lik. to do it in another instr.r.c-. Ifl. SICr.iT: If counsel -rill base his questions upon th- issuaptlon that the translation subnltt.d by th. prosecution is corect f.'.n the examination any proceed. It would b- inpo3Sibl- oth-rwisc bc- c-une the ritn -33 do-3 not admit that that translation is corect. I tlini; th. r-.k-.nd is approaching and th- Tribun-1 r.lll recess tonorrow- noon - until ..ondoy r.omin* which will aloe little bit long-r tU=.. luring that tic., 3 oc. progress might b. n de in settling this transla¬ tion, tut if Counsel for Defense dcsir.s to pr.par. the questions which th.y wish to submit to a group of int.rpr-t re they x_y pr.sent those qu.stions to th. pros.cutior. -ad to the Tribun .1 os soon .as they ire pr.- par.d. Is tii-rc anythin, furtr.er that can b. added? • Df.. ilPr: n this occasion, r. President, unfortunately, I have nothcr c t u - Etion brinf up that cone .ms the translations. Many days •c I g.v. a :ocux.nt to th. Translation Division which is of decisiv. Kportcnc. in clarifying this s-.a wat-r probl-c. It was an affidavit by D22D 26 Ksy-4>6J-i2-7-Sarro»-(Ero>n)- Court 1 the scsi. -r. Christensen who dr_- up this report 7 , fciv. recently dis¬ cussed here. E-spite ay efforts every day, I hav, not succeeded in receiving this translation within a period of t-n days although this is - document of only four or five pages, .nd, in qy opinion, should take 1 aaxisoa cf t-.ro hours to translate. I wish to sake nc charges her— 1 do not knew what the r.ascn for this is. I do not knor why this decisive dccus-nt has not yet been given back to n- r.nd p-rh-ps th. Iribunal can h~lp Je in obtaining this translation in tin. to use it in the c’.sc of cecker-Freys.ng. V E PH S1ESHT: The 'iribun 1 has be-n-uvised that th- Transla¬ tion Department is v..ry h.avily loaded with work and has bc-n un..bl- to produce the translations as rapidly .3 pos;ibl-. If Counsel Tor D.fense till call at ay office, I rill endeavor to c'll the Office of the Secretary nd oe- cf this Translation can b- -xp-dit-d. Ti*at is Just inaudiet.ly upon the rtc-.ss nor. Counsel -rill con-, to aiy office and ; till tel.phone and c..<. if I can ascertain the r.asons for th- delay in th translation At thas tint will b_ in rccecs u ,iQ 1:30 o'clock. (A recess was taken u. til 1330 hours, 2t i-.y, l?u7.) £221 Court So. 1 26 ..ay 47-A-13-l-iHH-Mcehan (Von Schoen) ATCHBIOOS SiSSIOS (Tho hearing reconvened nt 1250 hours, 26 Kay 1947.) TKZ iiAr.SKAL: The Tribunal Is again In session HIPJIASa 3RCRi--.-JRlYSi.SG (Resuned) CROSS RXAmIKATICS (Continued) Mr.. HAEXTF: hay It please the Tribunal, first of ell I oust hunbly apologize to the Tribunal for stating this docuaent was filed three nonths ago. I was inforned at noon tine the nenorandun «ps dated 15 Mai". I nust odnit I an thoroughly eabarrasaed that I said It vat filed three nonths ago. TKR PBlSinST: You are referring, counsel, to this translation? KA. HARDY: That is right. Your Honor. ! havo here a cony of tho nocorandua vritten to Kr. Janos r.. KoHaaey. Chief, SS Division, by Paul Joosten, Chief, Translation Branch, attached thorcto a carrier noto to tho Socrotary of Military Tribunals, subjoct: Translation of Docuaent BO- 185, aloo a copy of the nenoraniun to The Secretary Gonorel, Military Tribunal: "(1) The attachod acno.-anduc, subject 'Translation of Docuncnt KO- 185', presents accurately and vithout oaission tho viov of tho Langucgo Division on tho translation of tho sentence in ouestion." (Signed) Thooos K. Hedges, Director, Languago Division. In order to clarify this point. Your Honor, I suggest at this tine that this conornndun be given to tho court interpreter and csk her to read it into the record. It is only one and one half peges. It clarifies the point to egrecnent, I think, of defonse counsel. After it rppvxi, I think defence cainBel will sake a etatooent on JrJtHoa ve ori.*»j\ar up the .uatter here end cow. After having beon read by tho interpreter^ it is suggested that the copy be turned over to *-he court reporters so t/iat they will place it in the record vithout - 4 errors end emissions end then returned to the Tribunal. THL PZxSIDRST*^Rach -c:bcr of the Tribunal desires a cony of that “eoorandu::. , ^ it toy t£ c2Z2 Court Bo. 1 28 Kay 47-A-13-2 -S St- K e«han (Von Schoen) KS. HA2TT: I vould like to have It read into the record end turned over to the court reporter* end then returned to ne and I vill have a sufficient number of copies made for the Tribunal. THE PSISIDEST: Hos defense counsel eny objection to thet proceed¬ ing of that being read into the record by the interpreter? That will in no way be binding on defense counsel; they can still nnke any arguments they dosire as to whether this is correct or incorrect. Very well, that procedure aay be followed and the interpreter nay road it into the record. I will »*y for record that the defense counsel signified no objection to this orocedurc. I vould suggest that the interpreters first rood tho sentence in Demon and then read tho document which has boen given to then. HE. KAEDY: Tour Honor, the nenorondun ie oo written that it has tho ontiro passege in Geraon in the memorandum. IKE PRESIDES!: Very well, that is all included in the nenorondun. THE INTEEPEETEB: "15 Kay 1947. "TC s Hr. Janes K. KcKaney, Chief, SS Division "FECK i Paul Joosten, Chief, Translation Branch "SUBJECT: Translation of Docuaent No. 185 •Dr. Hans Karr, counsel for defendants Professor Schroeder and Dr. Becker-Freysong, objects to the translation of a sentence in Document NO-185. The disputed sentence reads in German: "•ich stehe heute vieder vor einer Entscheldung, die each zahl- relchon Tier- und auch Kenschenversuchen an froivilligon Vorsuchs- personon oine endgueltige Loesung verlangt.' "The translation of the docuaent in euestion was certified by Kiss Gertrude Levingor and the sentence reads as follows: ■'Today I again stand before a decision which, after nunorous experiments on aninals and also on voluntary human subjects, denar.is final resolution.' "Dr. Karx claims that a correct literal translation, according to the sense, would be: 8223 Court So. 1 25 Kay 47-A-13-3-SHX-Heehan (Von Schoen) ■Today again I am standing before e decision vhich after nuncrcue experiments on animals end also on kunan beings dcmends a final solution on voluntary experimental subjects. 1 "'Resolution' is, of course, wrong; it should be 'solution'. The German sentence is very awkwardly worded. You do not find a solution for a decision. 5ut I cannot accept Dr. .iarx's translation, however awkward the sentence nay bo put together in German. Ee asks for a correct literal translation, and the one he gives is supposed to havo these cualiflentions. However, it vill bo seen that in this translation ■oine or.dguoltige Loesung' does not appear in the correct seauer.ee. Dr. Marx makes an arbitrary traesoortation. A correct litoral transla¬ tion, without commas, just like the German original, is as follovo: ■'Today realm I stand before a decision which after numerous animal as ^11 as human experiments on voluntary experimental sub¬ jects demands a final solution.' "If the Gorman aoant what Dr. Marx claims it to mean, then tho ooxo scouenco of words used in this inglieh translation would also oxlct in tho Oernan version. "Tho Gorman sentence uncauivocolly states that up to now animal and human volunteers have been experimented upon and a final solution is now demandod. "It is correct that nart of tho lest sontencc of tho first para¬ graph is missing, namely the words 'nach unscron houtigen Kenntnlsscn' (uccordlng to our present knowledge)." (Signed) Paul Jooston, Chief, Translation Srcnch. MR. HARDY: Your Honor, Z submit that tho new litoral translation intended by this memorandum reads as follows: "Today again I stand before a decision, which after numerous animal as veil as human experiments on voluntary experimental subjects demands a final solution." I could ask if defense counsel is willing to accent that translation for the passage of the German document, in other words, this is different 5224 Court So. 1 23 May 47-A-lS-4-i34-Mcekaa (Von Scfaoen) than the other two that have been offered. 7EL P S SS n a ai : refease counsel nay ask that Question if they desire, but if they desire sore tine to study the natter they will not be reauired to answer that Question now. IS. TIP?: hr. President, I do speak scce nnglish, but on this inportant point I should not like yet to sey that the translation is cotc- olotcly correct. As far ae I can tell, the translation last suggested agrees with the Screen words, but as I said I should like to have an export in tho field oxaeine it. 8225 2b ::ay 47-A-A''-14-l-Goldbsrg “(Von Schon) Court 1 - Case 1 X.-iJ PR-SIDi.'T: Defense counsel may consider this natter over the weekend cr sooner, if possible, and r;port to the Court as to the translation which thpy believe is literally, gr-fnma tic ally correct. Meanwhile, in cross examining the vitneas, counsel for the prosecution could either ask the witness, upon the assumption that the translation Is correct, or avoid that suoject to be cross examined, If desired. 3Y ».a. mxxs Q. Dr. Bec/.er-?reyaeng, In this document, that is, the letter written to the a*iohsfuehrer, signed by Schroder, was It your Intention to ask for voluntary experimental subjects? A. Yes, that was my intention. If you permit, I shall briefly glvo a few reasons which today too, prove It from this sentence. Perhaps that is a matter for later argumentation. I as not informed on that. Q. I think we shall wait a bit on that, Doctor. After you had sent this letter, requesting that voluntary human subjects wen* to be used, did you after that time follow up the sequence of events and determine whether or not the persona used actually vere volunteers? A. In the course of further events I t-ico concern¬ ed myself with the question of whether these persons were volunteers. The first time before the experiments and the second time, after the experiments. Befor • the experiments^ I talked to Professor Belglboeok this question, \b I have already testified on direct examination, not for legal roasens did not interest ua at the time, but for medical reasons. 8226 2o Xay 47-*-AX-l4-2-Goldberg (Von Schon) Court 1 - Case 1 After the experiment, I talked to Professor Belgl- boeck about the question of volunteers vhen I ashed hln what kind of prisoners ha had obtained and how those prisoners wore actually put at his disposal at Dachau and were turnod ovor to hln for these experlaents. Q. Let us turn now to the next dooument, Doctor, which la Document NO-179, prosecution Exhibit No. 1^5 found on page 20 of Document Book No. 5. A. Yea, I have It. Q. This Is a letter of 26 June 1944 from Gravltr to Himmler Including comments by Gv'ohardt, Oluecks and Nebo on who the experimental subjects should be, and In this I want to coll your attention to Paragraph 2 whore Orawltt reports tho attitude of Oluecks, and therein Oluecks stated: •Referring to the above letter, we report that we have no objections whatsoever to tho experiments requested by tho Chief of the Kedlcal Service of tho Luftwaffe to be conducted at the experimental station RASCHS1 in the concentration camp Dachau. If possible, Jo v s or prisoners held In quarantine are to be used." Does that sound like a good expression of volunteer subjects to you, that Is, "Jove or prisoners hold In quarantine"? A. I may say that I saw this letter here during the trial for tho first time, that I aa not accustomed to tho wording of 33 agencies and I don't know what this sentence Is intended to imply. At any rate. It does not say that poople are to be forcod to submit to tho experim¬ ents. Why prisoners were to bo taken from quarantine I have no idea at the moment. I do not know I had nothing to do with the matter. 6227 28 Hay 47-*-AX-14-^-Goldberg (Von ^chon) Court 1 - Case 1 Q. Well now, If It 1 b fully understood that you did not soo this letter— the prosecution doos not con¬ tend that you received a copy of the letter — but I am now assorting, after all, the evidence 1s In at length that the experimental subjects wore volunteers, that is, the evidence on the part of your defense, and we are now Interested In shedding some light on the subject. I an sure that the Tribunal 1s interested in getting your understanding of the implications of this letter because It doals with *oso persons who were, in fact, selected to undergo these experiments you sponsored. 3o let us forgot whether or not you received this letter and Just devote your attention to the letter itsolf and what it points out; and I will ask you If Gluooks' comment doesn't raise a little suspicion in your mind olnco ho suggest the uoo of Jews or prisoners held In quarantine". Haybe thoy weren't going to be volunteers and maybe they were. A. I thank your for admitting the theorltlcal possibility that It could have been voluntoors, but unfortunately I am unable to answer your question because I do not know why S3-Gruppen-Fuohrer Gluecks suggests taking prisoners from quarantine. I had too little con¬ tact with conditions In concentration camps to know, per¬ haps he meant people who have beer, through quarantlno, so that one couldiciow definitely that thoy are healthy, out, I don't know that Is merely an assumption. I waq not consulted anil was given no opportunity to make suggisvions. If Gluecks thought people should be taken who had Just been through quarantine, - perhaps - who came from 28 Kay 47 -a-a:-'- 14-4-Goldberg-(Von Schon) Court 1 - Case 1 an epidemic district who had been In quarantine, and of whoa It was definitely known that they would not be com o sick in the near future, then this was quite a sensible suggestion from the aodlcal point of view. It must hav; been clear to S3-Gruppen-fuehrer Gliaok 8 that for this experiment, which was to last four weeks, we neoded healthy people. But I am unable to say what Gluecks had In mind because I never talked to Gluecks In my life. THE PRESIDENT: Witness, I am entirely unfamiliar with the German language. Is there any other word In German which might be translated as "quarantine" and also give some other translation? THE WITNESS: Y 0 ur Honor, I know of no suoh second meaning for tho word quarantine. THE PRESIDENT: Very voll, Proceod. BY MR. HARDY: Q. In other words, Doctor, If you had recolved a copy of this letter at tho end of Juno, 1944 — say you had seen a copy of this in June, 1944 — would you have still gone ahead with tho experiments? A. May I ask for a moment to look at the letter first? I have not studied it as carefully assomo of tho other documents, since It did not refer to me. Q. Go right ahead. A. Against at Ifcast two of the facts given here I would have objected. The first la In the statement of SS-Gruppenfuehrer Gluecks that the experiments be carried out at the Experimental Station Rascher. There was never any question of that. After the Nurnberg meeting, I never had anything more to do with Mr. Rascher. Neither I nor £829 26 May 47-A-AK- 14-5 -Go ldberg-( Von Schon) Court 1 - Case 1. anyone el6c thought of bringing the sea water experiments into any connection with Mr. Rascher, not even the slightest connection. The second would be that I would have suggested that It bo written to Relchsartz Dr. Grawitz concerning nis view; that gypsies, since they are of a different raoe, might give unreliable results. This Is a very childish statement from the physiological point of view; that would not to b. expected at all. If Prof, ichrooder had seen this letter he would probably have called up the Relchaarzt S3 and reminded him that he had promised him to find the experimental subjects under the soldiers unworthy of bearing arms who were sunt to concentration camps. Those are the points which I can pick out Immediately glance as things which I would have dealt with if I had got this letter; but, I did not got it. But I can say one thin; For me, in 1944, it would not have been clear, v\y more than today, that our pre¬ requisites for tho experiments, th'.t volunteers be used, was in any way doubtful. Q. Doesn't the third section of this letter, a do ament Hebe, create some sort suspicion also, wherein ho states, and I quote: B I agree with the proposal to conduct experiments on prisoners of concentration camps in order to evolve n method for caking seawater potablo. I propose ta/.mg for this purpose the as oclal gipsy halfbreeds. Ther> are people among them, who, although healthy, are out of the question as regards labor commit¬ tment. Regarding these gipsies. I shall shortly make a special proposal to the Reichsfuehrer, but I think it 6230 28 Hay 47-A-AX-14-5-Goldberg-(Von Sohon) Court 1 - Case 1 right to select from among these people the necessary number of test subjects, should the Reichsfuohror agree to this, I shall list by name the persons to be used. " Now, In fact gipsies were used in the seawater ex¬ periments and Nebo says chat he still alt up In-3orlln and list by namo the persona to be used. Now, woulin't that in¬ dicate that there would not be any volunteering here on the part of the subjects? A. That is a conclusion on your part with which I cannot agree to. Hr. Nebo merely says that he will name tho required experimental subjects to the Helchsfuehrer 3S. He does not say how he will do that. At the time I would haw assumed, quite naturally, that he would have gone to the Comp Auschwitz, which I aotually heard of for tho first time in 1945; that ho would have had forty gipsies volunteer and would have sent this information on to the Rolchsfuohrer. according to what we r.now today It Is very easy to find a different Interpretation, but at the tlno It would cer¬ tainly not have occurred to mo. 6231 23 issy-A-iO- 15-1-Cook (Von Schon) Court 1 o. * 7 cll nor: vhcn did 70U learn gipsies rcro used in tho ex¬ po rinonts? A. I learned that rrxn Bciglbocck came bake froa Dachau rftcr tho experiments. la sy direct examination, I said that I grant¬ ed tho possibility that I night have learned it during the course of the experiments when I agreed to ncct BeiglboccU near Vrutstoin. And unfortunately casx tro days too late because of an air raid on a train on vhich I -res travoling. I found a short note fron Professor Bciglboock rhen I got there and it is possible it said something a- bout gypsies but in any caso I rcccxbcr only that Professor 3ei;jibocck said something about gipsies only after tho oxperiaonts wore finished and ho caae back to Berlin. 0 . 7c 11 vould you have confix*, sod tho oxporiaonts if you had !motm that before, that gipsies rould be used? A. First of all that is again a hypothetical question so that I can give a hypothetical ansrrer; since I did not tour: befero hand. Tfhy should not gipoio3 volunteor? I don't lenerr rhat I rouli ha.vo done at tho time. I can't say. ■1. Did you.soo Bciglbocck boforo tho experinonts? A. "'bother I sarr Boiglboock boforo the oxporixaents- yes, of course. q. "ell did you say anything to Bciglbocck about the oxpori- nontal subjects? A. I already said that for purely medical rci3on3 I tallied to Bciglbocclc about the experimental subjects and I told him I expected to ^ct volunteers and rould not have any difficulty fron the subjects in carrying out the experiments. I she’aid li ke to emphasis^ I hau no anticipated legal reasons to say anyt'.iing a'-out these volunteers 'fat a '.surely nodical cau3o of the- ^xperi. cats for radical reasons. % Did you say anything to Bciglboec:: about asking suro that tlu cxprinontal subjects "he ~crc volunteering fer the experiments 6222 28 : hy-JUi SJ-lS-2-Ccok (Von Sc ton) Court 1 nust be of Gernan nationality? A* I an sure I did not say that bc.ca.uso I never doubted that# I never thought of any other possibility for I don't kno" ho:: any other possibility could have occurred to rt. n. Do you knon rtettor or not gipsies rerc recognized as Gernans under the racial lor of tto P.oich? A. ’I knorr that the racial lars of the Reich and the so called Nurnberg racial larr3 specifically' left the question of gipsie3 open because just tho racial affiliation gipsies is a question on vhich scientists arc not quite agreed, but I too:: that certain gipsies woro definitely recognized as full Oer.ian citizens. I don't toov horr it raa in general. Q. Do you think tht the gipsies vxro recognized ns good Gcraans Nordic citizens? A. Nordic Gomans, I wouldn't rant to reject that. Tto idea is told that tto gipoioa cone froa India and sinco there is a great oany intor-Gcnaanic racial faailies I consider it quito possible that 30:10 peoplo hold the point of vicr th t gipsies are Nordics but I don't too::. I an no oXpert on racial problem. 0. Of course, if they rorc good Ceraanic Nordic citizens they - ouldn't have been in a concentration emp, vould they? A. I rould not toor for certain. I van never in a concentration cranp but I have toard since and I h vc s.cn tho ritness Kogon vho looks definitely like a Nordic type, raid I wouldn't consider it in¬ possible for Nordic gypsies to bo in a concentration canp. ft. !tor you have outlined just vhr.t you instructed Dr. Doi-;l- bocc’; to do :.hcn to arrived at the concentration canp to cozrxncc •* his experiaents? A. Let i>o point out I did not say that. I talked to too- fossor E i'lbccck about it but I didn't give Ma any orders. Q. ell you said that Dr. Deiglbocck—I --111 read it to you 8225 . 23 J-l5-3-Cook (Von Schcn) Court 1 hero ir. a minute. You said on direct examination that you told Bciglbocck that this ms a specific military order and that he ras to follow the following instructions; vhon he received then, and one of tJv. instructions wa s that thorc would be no serious damage to toalth and no fatalities, two; to interrupt the experiments if they became dangorous; and, throe, that they ranted clear results from th3 oxporin;nt3 and also the experimental subject's consont. '.!ov; I uniorstood you to say thoso were the instructions you gave Bciglboock befor he proceeded to Dachau. A. I an convinced that if you :-ill read over the transcript that you till find vhat I actcrlly said. Boiglboeck received this order in -v presence fron ay department chief and after •ro had left the doportnont chief f offico and gone back to c$' office, porha.pa it :ma tix. noxt day- I don't kno~- Professor Boiglboeck asked no ::hothor that ordor rhioh ho had received fron the dupartraent chief •.•an to be token as a dofinitc nilitary ordor and I aaid "yes", but Id * vo hia tho order aysolf. Besides if I had givon hiu tho order I would take the responsibility for it today sinco 1 consider tho ordor which ny department chiof gave hin quite a permissible uattor. Q. Tell now was th. judgment a v out whether or not tho ox- pcriaontal subjects could continue to tolerate Derka v.-ator left up to the experimental subjects or warn that left up to tho discre¬ tion of Dr. Boiglboeck? A. To at tho tia: did not think of this question fron the lcyl but from the radical point of view and I assume that I nay atill leave tho legal decision to the Tri‘ unal. Fron the purely medical point of view it is cl^ar that the decision as to -bother an experiment is to bo broken off deponds on the findings of the doctor, as well as on tho statements of the subjects. IT I nay clarify that v- on example, it night be that cnc of tie experimental subjects in 6234 28 kay-A.i:J-l5-&-Ccak (Von Sohon) Court 1 the course of tho experiment beesm: unsonsciour: If the nan in charge of the experiment wanted to wait until the subject woke up, end said, "Let's stop the experiment no*. ', that a ould have be-n too late, n t Then actually the conduct of the experiments was up to the discretion of the doctor? A, I would like to put it like this: The responsibility for tho health and lifo of tho experimental subjects was, of courso, in the hands of the doctor, and it is quite clear that a doctor lilaj Professor Bciglbocck will take into consideration the statements of tho subjects, that is, a natter of course to a doctor, n t Toll then if soosono died in those oxperinents Bciglbocck would certainly been held responsible by the Chief of tho hcdical Sorvico* I an conplctoly convinced of th*t, because that it would have boon a violation of his instructions that no deaths -.to ro to • • be allowed to occur, Q. 7c 11 if a death had occurred would you have felt re¬ sponsible, in as much as you take full responsibility for tho ini¬ tiation of the experiments? A, In 19UU I -ould hov_ had to leave that up to a court martial of the Luftwaffe, I can't judge, Pbrhaps I nitht havo boon indicted too, I don't know, T, 'ould you have expcctod to have been indicted had .a death occurred in these cxpc-irxjnts at Dachau? A, That is a double or triple hypothetical question, I would have cxp-ctcd that if I had been indicted I would havo been acquitted, Q, Doctor, after tho conploticn of these experiments a roport "as liven, in October 19Ub, in a bunker near the Zoological Garden near Berlin by Dr, Eciglboock. Tho was present at that nccting? A, I assume that the see tin-, "as in October, I don't know, I heard it was in September; September or October, I an not sure. At 6236 28 ay-A-l "J-15-5-C c ok- (V c n Schon) Court 1 -ny rate it t:os only one nocting. I enn rcrx^cr definitely that CcnomloboratnbBcrzt Schrc.dcr *./as present, Professor BoigU.- cic. cf course, otj there. Dr. Schaeffer tras present, Berta ms present, and representatives of tho lfcty xrorc present. There vcrc all to^-ttor about perhaps tronty people. I can't roneaber any acre individuals than those I have just given. e236 C urt 1 28-*-16-l—3B-Gross-Von5chon. i. Who presided over the rieetini? GeneralGboretabs^rzt Dr. Sohroodor opened the noetln fc 7.:on I spoke * few v«,rds boat the ur use of ti.e ex'crinents T on Profess-r Belgltoeck held his lecture. Then "Xter It I believe, Professor ochroeder left, because In t :1s hunker Chore was a Luftwaffe hospital end Professor oo-iroeder hod r.r.lsed to attend on operation which he wanted Co perform himself. In the dlscussl.n whlc . followed, I presided :ecouse I w^s the referent In ch-r 3 e. But the discussion lasted ;ilr - 2 .at ten minutes and thot was the end of it. i. Dr. Bclulbocck c rve 0 c--u. lute clinical ronort of the results of the experln.nts? «. He .. ve r reuort on the clinical course of the cx-.oriments, yes. x. Did ho state wh-t synntons were apparent 00 ft result of the op llcotlon of sea-woter to t.ie subjects? /v. Yes, I am sure he re»rtod that because thot was one of the *:r. loses of the report. ‘..'hat sya-it-jas did he find prevalent after a certain n.:.u3or of day8? In this trial I neve neerd so much rbout the symptoms thet I cm unable to toll you exactly whet Professor jo 1 lxjeck sold then rnd vnet 1 hcv. read in tno meantime iut chose t..in-9 Professor 5el;-lboeos will be able co ^lve . 20 re feflnlto onever. But, I shell try to cell you h t I remember for certain. Professor Bel b lboook oxpllned t'.’c the feelln. of tr.lrst was -.ch stron^r in the ^roup •• - v ic: had dr \nk sea-water thon.in the y 28-A-lS-2-H£>-Gross-Von6chon. C. Vbould che report of the meeting In October contained in Schroeder's affidavit, which is paragraph 6, document KO-474 which is on page 6 of the Document Book 5, the passage la found on ?a~a 7. This narairanh 6 reads as follows; ■The experiments were carried out at the Dachau concen¬ tration coop by Dr* Belglboeck, in summer of 1944. In October 1944, Bei 0 lbocck reported on these experiments at r meeting which took pi ce in r bunker near the Loologlcnl Gardens in Berlin. Schrocder, 3ecker-Fraysen 3 and I were :rC3ont. It i3 -/jeslbls. that Dr. cchuster, an ..lr Force physician who worked at the Luftwaffe Medical academy in Prague, was also mresent. Bel 0 lboeck showed those present -.c the meeting auoorou6 charts of analyses of the urino a blood of the ojrorlmontnl objects who were c lven only 3crk~tit to drink. Photographs end films were also proeonted and various c roups of oxmorlaents were discussed. On the basis of. this report, I estimate that 20 to 40 persons were used for these experiments, which were c.-.rrled out &urln e a period of seven to twelve days. Or. 3olglobQCk also re ortod that the experiments had resulted .n the swelling of the liver and vervous symptoms. Delirium nnd mental ilsturbancos also "ppeored. «s n result of cl"is meeting, it was decided th~t the Berko process was resolutely of no use to the Luftwaffe." Now, is that c concise rnd more or less accurate report of -:hat 3d lboeck had to say? a. ho. Q. What dlscrep nciC6 do you wish to ooint out? A. First of all Dr. Schaefer is perhaps the only rsmn vno saw a film. It mu^t ivve been such a secret sAo\rin th-c only Dr. oefcaefer noticed it. No film was 625c Court 1 Hay 28-«-lS-5-HI>-5ros3-Von6cnon. ever taken. nZ any rate, I never saw one and there at the 3 nk«r seating r.o pictures were shown. He could have aeant by tnat aerely onotographs and used the expression fila. Let ae point but first it says - photographs and films." Photographs were shown end will be submitted in evidence here. ftny other discrepancies you wish to coins out? a. Yes, I w'nt to point out above all the “nervous tjyupt ns, t.;o dollriua, pr.u the ncnti'l disturbances." First of all, thw n-rvoas synptons, can neon so many things. I don't know wn-u dr. debaofor aeant by it but he v;ill be 'olo to exrl'in th t •iiiaself. I know nothing about any norv us a yaptoms. It could be, I believe Or. 5oijlboook a k« of a tot-nold oleture of e mptoas. That is a condition in '■'hion the muscles to very easily excited if no tars n muscle, a nusclo knot is formed. Th t is a v r .armless thin-. If ‘..-it is called o nervous disorder th t 13 possible, but it la very h rmless t..lr. . “Delirium roau-rosed fever." The transl-tlon is iaposslele. Poe lbly it L .ht bo fover-dellrlua. I do not now from Professor 3ol;lboeck'8 report that the subjects had rny fever. 3o, I don't kno- whorofr _ they should have b otoon “fover-dollrlua. ■ «nd "mental disturb nces 11 , I know only that Professor Soiglboeck spoke only of so-called "apathy." Ik- t is nothin, but stron = sleo-jlnoss nd some lack of interest to Che outside world. That 1 J known from ell uvular and thirst cures that the stole prefer t*- slceo and are r t interest d in anything. Just ns if n person i6 tired. ftCoot\.ing z, wh-’t I Anew of osychlatry, I would not call that r "mental diecurbancc. " "ell, did Or. Bei 0 lboeck tell ou how many* “* 0 o::le. S23S Court 1 \'jxy 23-A-15-4-HD-Jross-Von3chon in tha experiments? .-v. He said definitely that no one died. Toll, did ha tell you what Joseph Sultolng says in his affidavit which is found on page 28 of Document Book 5 wherein he states, and'I quote: a. no far as I know this is not an affidavit. It is a Viennese Police record which is not sworn to. MR. HaRDY: This hns been admitted arovisionnlly and to bo aworn to and Prosecution has had tho seme affidavit sworn t and when we Introduce our documents formally, the one with the Jur-te on which contains the srao information will bo then odmlttod. The Tribunrl had admitted this provision¬ ally pending receipt of the Jurate. Therefore we can use It here, doctor. Nov, in this document- a. Thank you for the Information. Unfortunately I do not have the doouoant. DR. TIPr: Wight I ask Hr. Hardy to give me the exhibit number of this new document. I know only what (.no is in o document book. MR. KaRDY: The same number, your Honor, slnco the •:;i:.-vlt was only sent down for the Jurate. DR. TIPP: Has it already boon Introduced? Has it already bojn given rn exhibit number? HR. KaRDY: Your Honor, it v-s last January 15 when I Introduced it. THE PRESIDENT: Yes, I have it here. It seems to be exhibit No. 139. MR. KaRDY: It was admitted :rovision: lly pending * obt"laini of J urates from the affiant In Austria. Now this d C '.uiant, in the English copy on p G e 28. The interpreters "ill note in the middle of the page the words pa.,e 2 of -- iriginoi in parenthesis. If you will 3 o up towards the £240 Court 1 day 28~A-1 5 - 5-HD-Groa s-VonSchon . : . of the page tj "page 2 of tno original" in the middle Ccie -a~a - 6 lines I will start reading where it says: ■rrofessor Belglboeck ceae' 1 - "rrof. Sel^lbooc.' erne with a stiff of three Luftwaffe "5 1 ster.tsi end the experlner.ts began. as far as I know In various methods; starvetion diets to be = ln with, son- vrCc-r nnd salt diets, 6alt lnjeotione, '.nd so on. The i rtures led tu enfeebling of the tody which resul'cod In loss of consciousness and, > e rsr as I know, in one doath.■ :>w, did Dr. Bol-lboock aentlon anything of that nature in hie report? A. SO, v. How It spy3 f erther down here - we ski 5 one scntenco :nd o to the st-tenon t beginning "3el_lbocck del levelled -hoso so-called troublenrkers to the zs, which treated c . c In the rnn-r customary In the c-xp." Did he ...rttl n nychln^ about that In .'.Is report? a. No, he said nitr.ln a r bout t..i?t end I consider it a erfect lie. ell, now he snys forth.r In t.i.s affidavit that vlll bo down 2-3 no re sentences be^lnnin^ with !, *.b In all Che txi .rlnontat Ion stations", th?t will be 2 sentences after tne last sentence, I read: "«g In -’ll the oxperl- centatlo . st-’tl^ns, it was 3cl .lbocck 1 s ornctioo to send s rlsoners .ndcrnlncd by the experiments, to the v lnr infirzrry in order to c nccnl the nuxb-r of deaths “ '•n th_ e~ -crlnental subjects." Did he coll that to your rttentl^n? a. Not only -id r.e not call th t to ay attention, but C the tine I sow t.-.e records of these experiments and ■ -ble t note that all tnc subjects with whoa he md • i-rted were .-til. : .ere nt the end . the experiment. 6241 Court 1 Kay 28-«-lS-6-HD-Gro ss-VonSchcn I think that Is up to Professor 3eiglboeck to present proof of that. Q# Doctor, did he tell you about the fret that when t. m presons died in the experiments they were put then on • stretchers, covered with a wnlte sheet and delivered to the oor 0 ue, as testified here to by the witness Viohweg. I think you neon the criminal Vlehweg who is charged again for calling himself a doctor illegally. So much for Vlehweg. *nd as for the dead persons whon Vloftwog says he saw for the sake of brevity I may refer you again to the case of Professor 3el a lboeck and say In his dofonso because to ay own knowledge I can say nothing about those dontna personally who were resurrected later. 26 .vay-A-G J-17-l-Knrrosr-( Brown) - Court 1 Q Did Dr. Eciglbocck tell ycu wh-r- the experimental subjects com free.? A I consider that possible. I don't knar today where they ewne free, but I don't knew whether Professor 3eiglbocck knowns, I can't re¬ member. r 4 Did he tell you that they cone fren an other concentration camp other than Dachau? A I just said that I can't x\-uerbcr that. It's possible that I asked Professor Bdglbocck what kind of subjects he got. It is pos¬ sible that if Professor B^iglboock knew that he told me, but in three years since that ti.ee 1 have forgotten again. It may be that he told me. Q Did he t-11 you that th;se volunteers w-rc men who had volun¬ teered for a "special commando"? A "Spocila Coecondo". No, that was rv-ver mentioned. Q I see. Doctor, in connection with typhus and virus research, did you kno* of the Typhis and Virus Research I stitute in Lemberg, also known as the Letibcrg Fleckfivber Institute, th. Lemberg Spott-d Fever Institute, ot the Behring l w stitut--L_rh-rg? A No, I heard of all these Institutes for the first tine hero. I never heard heard of thee heretofore. Q Do you know wh .th r or not the Lemberg institute had any connection nh tsc.Ver ^ith the Luftwaffe? A I can neither affins or deny that. Never heard about it. 4 You don't knew anything about, th administration of the L_ab.rg Institute? .bether it was administered by th- Luftwaffe or by 1.0. Fnrbcn? A I have no idea. Q I hcv- no further questions. Your Boner. THL F:iSE;.;T: Any redirect examination by Defense Counsel? :i?.. HARDY: Your Honor, it is my understanding that w_ arcgoing to call the witness Jaeger at this time. THE PfESIDSfi?: I would ask Dr. Steinbauer, is it satisfactory 8242 23 koy-A-1?-2-X .rrcx-{crown and vcn Schoca)- Ccurt 1 to you to, at this tin., coll your witness Joagcr? D? - STSIKBAUER: . j. President, :Iay I call the witness Jae-gcr at this tin-? T: - PSLSUSh'JT: The defend mt Bcckcr-Freyseng is excused froa the iritn^s stand temporarily and will r_suet his place. The .’--rshall rill svreen the witness Rolf Jrteg-r. ROLF JnLGER, a witness took the stand and testified ns follows: 3Y JUDuT SEHRL'.'G: Q “ ou P 1 ^ 30 hold up your right hand md take the oath. I swear by Qod, the Almighty and Omniscient, that 1 will spoak tho pun: truth and will withhold and add nothing. ( The witness repeated the oath.) You say seated. THE r.E-SlDrLVT: Cou:»sel nay proceed. BY DR. STEIJ/HAUIR: 1 Witness, what is your exact none, where wer. you born, what is your nationality and what is your present address? A i'y rune is Dr. Rcl. Jaeger. I w a born on the 1st of Novon- b-r, 191c, in Qraud.nz or. the Vistula ir. Testem Prussia. I x .i doctor by profession. I t a G.nvan citizen. ~y present «d«*rcss is t»raz-Li.be- nau, Austria, 721ct S.E.P. hospital. Q rfh-.t is your _-iploye..nt there? A I sc an Ob.rctabsarxt and s.nior Jtdic.-.l officer for S.r.P. units under British cc -and. I nn p.rsonally directly subordinate to th- hoadqu tors of the British troops ir. Austria. I an tlao ,a chief physician of the ?21st S.E.P. hospital. 0 Hew is it that you know Professor Pciglbceck? A I net Professor ‘.iglbr»-ck under the auspices of th. adjutant - the Corps Physician in P- r 1 in-T^r.p,lhof about the end of 19B3. Ho as sent to ay hospital in Tnrvisie in Noth.m Italy about Easter, 19M, *nd he was und. r tv- free that tin- on. low long was he your suberdinatv? 5244 28 -Lay-A-17-3-Karrcrw-{frown-von Schoon)- Court 1 A He ins my subordinate, until the end of the war. 4 What ms his position there? A Ho was leading pliysician of tfc. internal department of ay hospital* Q Do you know whether iJclglboack had tbo title "Consulting Physician of the Luftw-.ffc?" a No, Professor ®ciglbocck ms not ft consulting physician of the Luftmffei’ I remember, howov-r, that ho would suggested as such. *rco a p.rsonai renark of the Gcn.ralstabsarzt, Dr. Ncuoueller I lear¬ ned that he was proposed at the consulting internist of the kray. C| Why was he not appointed? A He was rejected by Generalstabsartt Neumuollor since he did net think he was a good enough soldier and was "too soft ", as ho said to ne pjrsonally. Q ..ho then took the position that he w.s intended for? A His position wis taken by scce else who took over the duties of consulting internist. K. ms r.ot a academic teacher. 1 cannot remem¬ ber hia none today. Q Now, what military rank did Boiglboeck have in Jun- of 19LL? a Profesaer BeiglbOeck ms an CfcKrarzt of the reserve at the time, but he was already classified for Stabsarzt at the tine when ho came to Tarvisio. Q Can you tell us southing about his previous employment in the Luftwaffe? A He cane to U3 free the Luftwaffe Hospital in Brunswick with a good reputation. I knew nothing of his previous work. i Yevr hospital in Tarvisio, was that German t.rritory or was that outside G.rr.any? A Tarvisio was cn Italian soil. Th, hespit-1 belonged t' the ..rmy operating in Italy. Th. borders were strictly blocked. Q Did Professor Bciglbe-.ck have any personal connections with :a; h.r offices, particularly to the Ifcdical I sovctorate? £245 2* Hay-A-GJ-17-L-Karrcw-(Brcwr. vor. Schcwn)- Ccurt, 1 A So,.he did not. I don't bcli-v- bo wanted any. Q •'hit can you t.ll us about his medical activities and his attitude a - physician? .. His radical activities consisted in talcing care of the inter¬ nal dapartment and caring for the patients, -*y hospital had 1500 beds at that tine. L50 approximately belonged to the inUmald:partox.nt. To this was att ache d an infectious ward and a tuberculosis ward, an X-ray d-partnent, a clinical laboratory and a department fer physical thera¬ py. As a physician Professor °ciglbocc:. had a very good reputation, not only among his patients but also ■'song the personnel under bin and above all rrxnj his colleagues. As a can to every on. respected hin and liked hie. Q Old you h.v. only tx-nlx-rs of the “im-n '.Vchrnacht as patients or did you h;vu also foreign patients? a Not cnly O.rman nenlx.ro of the arced forces, but Iso Italian soldiers, and also Pel ,s, Russians, Yugoslavs, Anericons and Englishmen. The latter rr_rw fliers who had bov.n shot down and sou- of them in cur hospital for months. Professor Bciglbc^ck made no distinction as tc nationality when tr.ctin; his patients. Q Did Eoiglboeck, during his stay in Italian territory, hwe touch with tlx. civilian population? a Yes, v.ry close touch. He had good reputation as a doctor, net cnly or.cn: us, but his reputation got round in the small town of ~ rvlsio and, in hie free time, h did all to h_lp the peer mountain papulation. He v s often cn the read at night which was without danger tovards th>. end cf the war bee use thcr. w_r>. partisans in th«. area. i Now, Dr. Jaeger, let us turn to the exo-runents. Do you knew *h.n Bwiglbcck was crdcr-d to n-port tc “^rlin? « I conn t give you the. date -xactly. It was about the. second half cf June in 19LH. «t In what way was this carri_d cut? a oy a tclctyp. rossngo. £246 3g-.rt_iS-l-H3-.-ie®han-Von Sc hor. £ Brown i. Do you recall whether the teletype message con¬ tained a reason for this request? rt. Ke, It merely sail that rrofesaor 3ei£lboeok wee to report inmedl tely to the .-ledicel Inspectorate In 3erlln. Did you ask by phone or by telegram what was afoot hero? a. Yea, I inquired by telephone and I woe Informed that Professor leiulboeck was to be assigned to sono scientific work; I could learn nothin- else. Sow, when Belglboeck vns in =erlln, did he tell j a wh't w-a uoln ; end nsk you to request ..Is return? a. Yes, he did. "hrt teas n :.l- he c lve for this request? .-v. He exvl 1 nwd ..Is wlan to be oent back by soyin£ t.y»t ho ‘1 not Ilk- t, ccco :t tno nssl tf nraent to carry out cxj^rlu. nts in a concentration coop >n.. bo si oa, ho wanted to c mu b ok to the internal Department of the Hospital and shod au to try to arrange it. Did you make efforts to h ve hiu tor Ught back? a. Yes, I Aid, I sal;. th e I .inf. entrusted him with Che h lldln. up of the Internal v-ep rtment nd It was hard : r o t -ot along without hie. ... "hy was this request u.n your part refused? n. Hy request went through official channels to tho -.'J it nt i the Army Surgeon and he h to ask for tho release fv »a th. -iodical Inspect..ante. It ws rejected and sal', t -t the assi-nsent ho hnd to carry ut vs important. i. Did Bel.lbock then tell -ou tar: r.-d asked that :experiments be c r led oat In larvlsle? k. Yes. " aid tlv - h ve been technically pcssiele? «. fcdm 1 cnl ly, yes. 524 ? Court 1 May 22-rt-18-?-H3-:i3ehsn-VonSchon-Brcwn. Q. How bo? n . "e had q ilte a vood lrborntory end the laboratory vorkors would h o vo been adequate to carry out the normal experiments. Z. Why was this then 'not done? rt . The military situation was such that we needed every bed In the hospital. There w s also an order that the borders cf the Reich were closed for the return of patients and It would have been difficult to solve the bod question. Immediately after tr.o Invasion, we received a Fuehrer order which again strictly prohibited any return of patients end this order w'8 binding on all Wehrmncht offioes. Q. Vhon 3clglboeck went to Dachau, did ho write any¬ thing t you or did he write to any of the other doctors about what vent on there? Yes, I romomber thrt very well, ho wroto to several cumbers of the hospital staff, and in all the letters he said how unhappy he was at Dachau and how much he disliked carrying .*ut the experiments there. I remember before tho experiments began, he wrote me personally a letter and asked mo again to try to arrange for his return. I tried again, but without success. I myself, of c urso, was o-rtlcul-rly Interested In getting him bock, because I had -ssigned him to do this now building, Z. Dr. Jaeger, y u were In f~ct the medical offlcor; ay y 'relieve that Sleglboeck could have refused to cbey^ this military order? «. No, I do not believe so. .-*fter all. It came from the supreme superior nnd Professor 3elglboeck wos a medical ■:f*lcer. Orders for medical officers were the same as for ’■iiy ocher officer and soldier. c24- Co art 1 Mr; 28-A-l£-3-KD-Meehrn-Vbnochon&Brown. Kov, 3elslboeck carried »at hi 9 experiments and "'ter the experiments wore over, he c'-me hack to Tnrvielo. 'ort . ' * he report to you about :iis ex: rlcents? a'xit the middle of October, Professor Solglboeck re ported hack to me s his disciplinary 6 U'orlor. Then I inq irod, he tjld mo about his assignment, ho told me that he carried at the sea-water experiments as ordered. Ho "Iso said tht to fore tnc :e 6 lnnlng of tho experiment ho also porfrroed an experiment on himself, he srld that the e.T ohiaental subjects were gioeleg, who had volunteered and that chjy wore granted extra food rations, less work, eto. Z. Toll mo, Dr. Jaeger, did he eey anything to you •'b ut wi.r: hie relations were with the experimental rX : Joe to, those c. ncsntrr.tlvn caco inmates? A. I had the impression that ho had vory good rola-iono wit his experiment ?1 subjects. Q. Dj ’ou think that Dr. Eelglboeck had any reason to conceal the true facts? Ko, I do not; he under the t .on existing conditions had no reason to conceal anythin, from me aside from the ct tlv fc I asked hie as his superior */fficor. Tell, Dr. Beiglboeck came b ok to Tarvlslo and ho ccmo b ek f'uom " concentration camp; - id you ask him whr : is looked like in a concentration or nr:? a. ’fee, of c arse, I as well as the ot/.ers who heard 1 : were quit.- st-nlehed trr t he c »uld not say much about the conditions, ho only said that his movements lr. the c ncentrati- n comp were restricted and relations with the S3 were richer tense. xow, I want to .sk you something else. Do you : ink Professor Bolglboeck had any personal, scientific or Mcer?v/ .nterest ir. these sea-water ex'eriments? 62 49 Court 1 Ifcy 23— a- 18-4-HD- ISe e hen- Vb n Scho n & 3rovn. A. Jio, I do not believe sc. On the contrary, as far -s I cr.n remember, he •.■•as doing scientific work or. hepatitis ;ha tine in the clinic and I think he wanted to publish bovh or, the subject; thus I believe the contrary would bo true. But maybe you think that he did these experiments, ns the chief prosecutor said in his opening statement, from r I'azlstlc point of view ir. order to torture tne enemies of national Socialism. «. I do not believe thet as that w^-uld not fit in with hla character. I nover knew him ns a fanatic, hl3 sympathy and hoart nlwoya belonged to tne weak ^nd oppressed, he never refused them aid. I think he V"S a party member, yos, but if .no hoard him, one had to irve the oppoait impression of his ideals; his criticism of party or political mea.3uros of tho hlghoat agencies indicated that. I don't believo that I can assume that. S. Xow, lot mo n3k you c lrst question. You nro a Siyslcian, r medical officer, and I know of your erreoer; C-j •" u c-nslder tho problem of such soa-watcr experiments such as these r ouporfluous one; do you think they werc unnecessary or do you think thoy were serious experiments and a important problem? Yos, I believe it w: s an Important problem. X -r.y say that I was a parachutist on Crete and know the s ocial dangers of the sea. I was 6hut in for two days near the coast In Crete and suffered greatly from thirst. • After these two days we reached the see.; we were sitting practically ir, the water rnd were suffering neatly from thirst, but were unable to drink. Or. the fourth day we received fresh water from a well, anyone who has thirst r-cticrlly sittin* ir. the water will realize how important S2£C Court i • -~y 28—*-l£—5-HD-He e nan- Vo n 8 o ho n ic Brown. toe problem is. •.. Did you have ship-wreched people who suffered from thirst re tivt tine? .•v. ’foe, Chore were e number of people who flew to Crete who err shed and I s»w quite a few people who had aenegad to reaoh the lend and who had been fished out of tho water, I saw tha conditions nnd the greatest problem for ell those people was the water and their great thirst. Ho further questions. THE PRESIDE!?: «re there any further questions to be propounded to the •..•itnoss by defenso c uneel? If not, the 7-rosecutl >n say cross examine. CROSS EXaHIKaTIOK 3Y HR. E.-.RDY: h t v'S the s joclflc date when Dr. Boiglboook vent to Berlin to roport to the .-.©dlcnl Inspectorate? a. I sold before that I don't /.now the exact dato; I believe It w-e the eooond half of Juno 1944. n. And when did ho return? a. as far a3 I can remember, that was about October, ; - i ld.-le of October. *.• “-•.on did ho toll you that he had nn "sslgnmcnt to c riu’hl on concentration cr mo lnaK tos - t Dachau? a. He told ue trrt in n \etter. %. 'To. t was your interest in this matter? a. In his carrying out the experiments? Yes. a. Ho, I hed r.o interest In them. I wanted hie as nn rnlst for my hospital for medical reasons and because - w^re building a new building. " s Jr. Beiulboech a man of good character and v cmtion? 6251 Court 1 24ay 23-A-18-&-KD-Meehar.-Vor.3chor.-Browr.* a. Oh, yes, I cay well say so. G. Did you ever tear of the Fuehrer Order of Secrecy? a. For this earcrlncRt? k. The Fuehrer Order of .Secrecy in Germany, not for this experiment? No, I never heard of It. *.• Do you know what “Secret" means? A. Of course. G. Do you know what “Top Secret" means? A. Yes, I know what that Is. Q. If you were given a secret order, would you go and tall your friends about it, or would you consider that a broach of your allegiance to the Fuehrer and to the Natl Government? A. That depends. I do nut know. G. Do you think th't 3olglboock was being very consldorate end very loyal when he lnforned you about natters which wore "Top Secret", a man thet hod nothing to do with the probloa? ’..'hother that w o loyal of Professor Belglboeok; w-s that your question? C. Well, wasn't it rather unusual? A. No, I don't believe 30 , I don't think there was any reason for secrecy In this natter. -.ell, for your Information, Doctor, the matter wn6 classIflad "Top Secret 8 . Don't you foci Dr. oeiglboeck w-s broaching his olleglance when he Informed you, an outsider, about his proposed work at the Dachau concentra¬ tion ca.ap? .-v. I don't believe so, otherwise he would probably nave created it as such. C. Now, you scy that Dr. BeiglbccCk enjoyed e cordial £252 Co -rt I* Hay 23-«-16-7-HD-Me efaan—Von5chon-3rovn. relationship with the experiment subjects; how do you know that? n. I know that because he told me a treat deal about their existence in his series of experiments; He said th< t they came to him with their personal troubles, ho said that they all epoke German. Since x knew him personally, I believe that he hod close contact with his experimental subjects. ... You know that only fr-.m 3el 6 lboeck himself, a man who hPd broached an oatu in giving y.u information about a Top Socrot project? Is th.pt right? Court So. 1 2c Aay 47-A-15-l-lHH-Coole (Yon Schon & Brava) A. Professor Boiglboeck, yes. Q, Tou said that Dr. Beiglbocck didn't want to conduct these erpericcnts at the Dachau concentration caap. Did ho toll you vhy he had nisglvlcgs for not venting to co n duct these experiaento at tho Dachau concentration canp? A. That vts even in a letter vhich has been nentionod before, that he didn't like to carry out these experinents in the concentration canp; I gathered that froa his nentality. Q. Vhy didn't he like to do that, do you fcnov? Vos it becauso it vas a criminal ret or sooethlng? Vhot vrs his objection to it? A. I can't read his aind ao veil as that but I don't think that he likod the concentration caaps. He didn't llko working thoro. Q, Vhot vas your rank, doctor? A. Cborstabsarzt. Q. In tho Luftvaffe? A. Tos, in tho Luftveffe. Q. Vhon did you Join the Party? A. I vn« en active officor: I vas not in tho Party. Q. You never Joined the Kati Party? A. So. Cc. Tot you voro an officor in tho Luftvaffo? A. I vas an officer In the Luftvaffe, yes. k- Kov do you spell your lost none, doctor? A. «J-&-g-c—r. Ci. Did you ever hear of tho experlaents conducted for the decontanination of voter? A. Yes, I heard about that. Of course, the decontanination. Vhat did you hear about it? A. Hot the renoving of salt, but tht decontanination? Q. That is right. A. Decontanination? k- Yes, vhat did you hear about that? 6254 Court 2o. 1 2c Hay 47-A-19-2-R2.-Ccck (Ton Schor. 2 Brown) A. Sothing esoecially, only vhat everybody knew, that is a filter to remove bacteria fro: water. Q, Did you ever year of experiments conducted by the "Reichs- esstelt"? A. Bo, I didn't. q, You never heard of that? A. Vhat "Eeichsanstolt*? q, "Roichsanstalt" is c Gornan word. I will have to ash the interpreter to read it. It is spelled Vasser and Luftgau. A. So, I never heard of that. q. If your mo appears in a document concerning experiments conductod on ISO hunan beings to detornine the value of certain decon¬ tamination agents in tho decontamination of water, would you bo inclined to think that that was another Dr. Jaeger? A. Yes, I think that must havo been eonobedy else. Hr.. HaRDY: Bo further Questions, T-'ur Honor. THL PRESIDES!: Is there an.'- further examination by counsel for defendant Bciglboock. Thcro being no further Questions to bo oronoundod to tho witness, the vitnoss Jaeger will be oxcusod. Tho dofondnnt Eecker-Froysong will resume tho witness stand. miviWR BECiCRE-FREYSEl-G - Resumed Ei-DIRECI EXAKIHAIIOT 31 DR. TIP?: q, Dr. Becker, the direct examination and the cross examination have been so exhaustive that I do not believe I shall hove to ask many more cuostions. However. I want to clarify fire*, of all one Question to y iU that Dr. Hcrdy broached tfcie morning, the cuostion of the so-called ■ Super-Rcferents". Did you actually, aaor* the Referents, of vhem there were twonty-fivo in the Medical Inspectorate, have c position that cut 70U above the other Referents? A. I took this statement of Hr. Hardy es a captatio benevolentiae, and I don't think he meant anything of that nature by it. At lt-est I 6255 Court 'Jo. 1 22 May 47-A-19-3-lHK-Ccok (You Schon a Brown) vei one of tventy-four Befercnts. I did act have the highest ailltery tp-*. among then. There vure scce lieuteneat colonels there. There wore some older non there. There were experienced university professors. I did not hove any particularly high position. it. Sow, according to the evidence put in during this trlel it would seen as if the research work in general occupied n very pro-eninont position within the office of the Chiof :f the Medical InsncCt-rato of the Luftwaffe. It would seer, es if the whole office concerned itsolf with research. Sow Just what mb the actual situation; what importance did research occupy within the entire work '0-306. This is Exhibit Bo. 296 and is in Prosecution Document Book Bo. 12, on pngo 77. unfortunately I do not have the English page - it is page 74 in the English document book. Vc have elreedy discussod this document three tines. Kr. Hardy tr.ugfct it up twice and I must unfortunately refer to it agein. ^ut I have only ono Question, witness. Mr. Hardy concluded fre this document, which is a letter of 9 June 1943 fron Professor Hobo to Professor Eeagon. The last sentence reeds: "It will take some time until '2-?' produces its new research order, ?s Anthony is on a duty trip for several weeks." Ur. Hard;/ interpreted this sentence to cean that this resoerch assignment ves nut to one side c2E6 Court So. 1 25 May 47-Jt—I9-4-33C-Cook (Vos Schoa & 3rovn) because the nan was not preseat who issued the orders ia resepreh assign- I neats. Sow ia one sentence, witness, can you tell us why this research assignment was put aside while Professor Anth.ny was absent on an official trip? A. That is very simple. Because the Heforent was not there who had to do the technical final work on the assignment, and because it was not an urgent natter that had to be settled overnight and it veo not given t> no, and because even as assistant afferent I had so much to do that I didn't look for any additional work. I don't think azqrbody docs. *nd so the natter was loft until Anthony cane back. Sow, regarding tho question of research asslgnncnts, which vo h=vo been kicking around ling onough, now one aro Question, witnoss. Y-u said in cross exoninatl.n that the scientist apulioo to your offico and y-u dictated the rosearch assignment. I bolievo that is rathor a telescoping of what took place, but plocsc tell us Just oractly how nr. apDlication for a rosearch assignment was hrndlcd in tho iffico of tho Chlof of tho ksdical Inspectorate. A. 2 shall try to answer this quostlon vory briofly. Tor tho sfko of simplicity let us essuuc that it is an avlntl.n ncdlcir.o aonign- ment. Tho epolicati-n fr>n Professor John Doc, vh>n Mr. Hardy nontionod this aornlng, erne first ^.f all to the Chlof .i Strff, who decided vhothcr this letter would be submitted t> the Chlof cf tho Modicrl Service or sont direct to the department chief, and ho nr.de mo nota¬ tion in tho margin - either."please consult", or "cm be granted”, or "inquire of such and such a person" - then the lottor caac to tho department chief, who also signed it end put a note in the margin for no, *nd then I got the letter and sew what ay two superiors had already said about it. I either reported to the department chief about it, Bir.ce it an aviation medicine assignment. I night have euggosted that frofessor Strughold or someone else bo consulted, and if the donrrtnont chief approved the application I took the documents over to the budget afferent, vho was responsible for finances. I got his p.o'rovrl, end he 5257 Court So. 1 26 rui;-' 4?-o—IS-5-S3i-Coot (Ton Schon i Prawn) clso signed it, and after I hed all of this together I dictated to ny stenographer the draft of a research assignment vfcich I submitted to ny depertr.ont chief, and ho alone, or together with no, gave it to the Chiof of Staff and the Chief of the nodical Service for signature. Q. In other words, you did not actually dictate something which vould be in the neturc of an order, but your work was of a purely technical nature, was it not? A. Yos, i believe I have explained that sufficiently. I was nover o rosoarch dictator. Mr. Hardy, who has flettered you in certain ways here, has also charged you with being in chargo of the aviation medicine research institutes. How, after what Dr. Veits has testified here, I do not be¬ lieve ve hevo to go into that any further, but like Mr. Hardy I should like to ask a hypothetical aueotion. If the Referent had been in chargo of the aviation medicine research (of course the;.- woro not), would that have boon a nilitcry subordination in the sense of subordinate or superior in the nilitery sense? A. I car. answer this Question only by loading it ad rbsurdum. "ho heeds of our rvietion ncdicinc institutes woro: Professor Strughold vith the rank of colonel. Iho office was that of a brigadier general. Professor Veits had the rank of lieutenant colonel, and tho office had the rank of colonel. Professor Puechner, head of the Institute for Aviation .iedicrl Pathology, also held tho rank of lieutenant colonol, and tho office was clso that of e colonel. Professor Knothe, com wider of tho Training Section at Jueterbog, was first a major end at tho end lieutenant colonel. That was also a colonel's position. Only the head of tho Institute for Aviation Medicine in Hamburg was e StrbsexrV (captain). I don t think it is customary for t-rp prny in the world to kavc «ii colonels under the cor-end of a captain, and I an convinced that if I had tried to give orders in the military sense to Cbcretarzt Professor Strughold or Cberfelder rt Professor Veltz - all old enough to bo father - they vould have teen ouite astonished. 23 Ifry^.-lJG-420-l-Grcss (Vcn Schrn-rr wn) C-urt 1 5 Thrt then rr.svore =y hypothetical question. Hew, I v-licvo th-t vc ’ net need tc enter intc my further discussions cf tc in- f.-jcua file note t 55, end the Refemt nuub.rs. I think they r re clc'r enough. .kreever, en nffidevit is reins tc be rut in carding this osr ttcr lr.ter. «.c do n t h'vc to discuss ycur position in the Referat nny len :cr. Kcr. cn. question rcrrrdinr the lot-prossurc cir.i - er. You !oic«, Vitn-ss, thrt thw labile lev-pressure chonb-r used by tho DVL -.t /.dlcrshof rnd When to Dachau rn-’ used there in the ccurso of tho ex. crincnta h's pl*yed - l-rre r:le hero. I dm't knov? whether it \/ a brought cut thqt this lev-pressure chcn2>cr »: s nrvdo subordin-tc tc tho Refer't fer ,.vi tion tfedidne. .. You r^rin ere putting r. unit under no irllch ms n-v-r un-^r sic. 1 .lust c Jeet tc th't. I couldn't >vc .-ny erdtra to th. rn in cl-.-rgo cf • ue! ile lci—prcaeure ch-nler unit. ^ I r'on't referring tc when the unit vrs evdc subcr in^tc tc ycu, .ut then the lcvv-.rosaur- ch-.v -r itself v.rs i«t uj/.er the Kefere.t fer ..vir.ticn Uo'lcine? .. Tlirt vi"o r.t the end of July or the beginning cf ..u ust 19/.2, ».hcn this actc.izcd low-preosur. eh rat or unit nr.a trJ:en ever *r St V- s-rzt Kollcra-n end lvia cron. q This then ura after the conclusion of thu hr.chr.u cx.-cadocnts fer rescue fre a hi-h *ltitu;lc? .. ..ccording tc wSu-.t 1 hr.ve he.-rd hero, these exp crl.vents v:crc c. Ujlctcd ?t the end of June ct the i'.tcst. 1 S-nothing wise in this n-ttcr, -.-itn.ss. Ycu aai ’ in crcss- -x*. l.v ti. n th t when the ccliio lcw-prcssur- ch'.a'er ’units v .rc used ycu acid th't "ue saw tc it th-t these netcrizei lc.pressure chrflbera were use'*.," Jtew, yU.ao exlnin the use of this - er’. "we", sc ®ct v.o cm ,vu J . the impression th't y:u -..e.e s. no s;rt of •* aupex^-forent? .. That is -n inaccuracy cc.uu.ttcd 'y every.ne -^hen s -Jdn >f hi? . flic-. The lcw-prcssur- chra era were iodt with in X ?.*-fer't. Criers to . issued ty ry icvrUwnt cll«-f er the Chi.f cf 31 6259 26 ;t-7--.-3JG-20-S-GrcsB (vcn Schcn -Br. va) Court 1 q Bcrrrding the. hirji-cltitudo experiaenta, Utneas, I h:.vo -niy one question. Since Hr. Hardy hs take ycu in crcss-c^idr.rticn rbcut jr. K: wtc.*iv.-ff, tell =c, hew lcn. ;• -s 3r. Krttonheff in your Referrt? - I hrvc rlref.dy arid th:t in the succor cf 19U. 'Jr. ICcttcnhcf «rs there Xcr c very brief tine. Kc hrd just iven u? me ;>ositicn ml w's * itinj t: ’-c rssijncd f -ml in the nerntix orcauncUy nobody kn/.. ahr.t tc dc with hin, -irl fer y^rhrps s week or two cr thr^o weeks, porhrya leas, he v.rs in Berlin rnd kos in the fiico cf the Chief cf the ifcdicrl Services, :nd since ho w~.s interested in ..vision kodidne, he ws in kefer t -b r guest, I ai-t.t s*y, fer r few dry a. c . . , ’ itneas, cno quosti “ding the fr^ezi ■. trlocnts. Ycu a-id in rep-rd t: this ns well rs rltitudo, thrt Prefuaaer Hippko errrio:'. cut r grert dcr .1 of the ir.rk in this fivAd on his orm initiative end di sc without infereinj. tho competent Referent cf this. '1 , tho questim '.rises, could Kippko dc this - did he hove rny kncvlcdrc in the field cf rvi-ticn medicine sc th-t he cculd reach ~utcnc„v us decisions? .. Profess-, r Kippke hr.d not conducted "«y cyir.ticn uvlic-l re- oc-roh hi-iself hut hf.d tfkcn rn intensive interest in ' vi-.ti. a n.'licine, rad, n- doubt, hr* h in ttur field vhich TO8 f r - eve the nfiraCL cverrye cf • dcctcr. } r.ien, if 1 mvicrstrnd you ccrr-ctly, y u :.tfn to s:; thrt fuwlaacntrl questions cf this sort he coull decile without ccncultinr * npccirlict. D ubtlwss. \ Than, tdtn.ss, pic-sc take u. the freesin; cunmt dk, first cf rll, 3ccuccnt :»-268, . 14C in the G.rnm v-rsim cf tho dccument heck cn fr.esin : . It is - letter of 19 Februrry 1?43, the Ins., .ctcr cf the i-udicl S-rvicc f lto Luftwrffo, tc the "eichs- fuohrer-SS, si n^d by Hippkv. On this occuuent tln.ro is the f-oicus file note 55 ~n\ then in p. renthesos the registry nun 1 or kill 6260 fvU 26 ! JG-2C—3—Srcss (von Schcn-?rc> n) C'-urt 1 in cr-ss-cxa-min-ticn, T.itnvss, tht this dccuacnt v-a net r.crkori cn Ly ycu. l£r. Hardy -.sked ycu r. fei things about this letter, tut regarding the qu^-sticn cf the freezing cxp-riccnts I should like to rsk ycu a few acre questions. Witness. How ices it h-ppen that -'es-ite the f-ct tfc t y_u s~y ycu arc art a specialist in freezing -ir'-tcrs, ycu c;ul’ cake - perfectly dc-r, understandable stetuaent about th-ec freezing prcll-ns? Cculd ycu arkc these st-tceunts from specialized experience in the field cf cell, cr on the ' -sis cf experience cf a. purely _jicrr*l nature th:t ycu had r.s : sci-ntlst, research . erker, and experimenter. .. I nev-r perforaod any cold experiment either cn -ni-rlo cr cn lysclf cr cn mother human boin . I, cf ccurs-, read scuo papers cn the su Jeet, tut the statement which 1 have ua-’c here refer ■ enc re¬ ally to r. careful study cf tho dccuacnt rnd t; qy general q-.'.ic-l training. Q 7r.cn ycu u"ic stat—nents cn the hr sis cf jur«-ly general in¬ fer.: tier which ycu had as r. lector, supported by, a study cl tho dccu- :.cnts v.’ y infer ..'ticn cn research in ,-tncral? .. Yes, th-t is right. 1 Cn ;ar;o 22 cf the fccuaent bock on freezing, document :.'0 2C6, exhibit (W, there ic r ward which Hr. Hardy put to y.u — laoumont NO 2- 6 — - letter to tho Reichsfuehrer-SS frcn the Reich .lr Minister, 6 Oct-’ -r 1942. Do ycu have the document? .. Thrt is the me ycu were just talking -.lout? Ics, I ha.vo it. dj In tii.3 dccunmt pi- se turn tc the 1: st prrr.arr.ph cn the first \ -, r-h-rc «*nthcny writ-s: “Tho ruo. rcli records mb n ex¬ tensive rep- rt will be presented tc the I.^ichsfuehr-r-SS by St-’.s. rzt Hr. R-seller." -fr. H rdj contended th t th- extensive rcp:rt aaiti neb here is the repc:t th*t lr fess r H Izlcchn^r '.v- in liurn' -r;. -i y I ask ycu rheth.r tile cpini.n of Hr. Hardy is c-.rreot, cr just i t is the r. rt hero nuiticnod? 6261 o 2S 11"'-.D JG-2C-J.-C-r zss (von Schcn-5rcwr.) Court 1 .. As :*• r -s I rcncr-icr, in the ensrer which I & vc l£r, Herdy I sri*. th't me cf th- next documents shc>>s thr.t wh't Hdzlcehnor sidd r.t the. Hurnhtrg electing its the prrt cf this report which ccul -c a*ic pullic rs tep secret. ..cccrdinc: to iih:t I knew tclay, t:ds ex¬ tensive report was th- one which rrefesser Hclzlochncr, Jr. FAiike, end Rr scher signed* It wr.s sent by Knachor to Kimlcr cs top i-crct \ ith c pcrscr."! letter, wt was certainly net wh. n t rrefesser Hclzlcchner rbout thr-c weeks lr.tor tcld the cceplo as seeded ct numberg. 6252 - ‘ 7 ~. ;JG-21-l-Kzrrc(Brewn) Ccart 1 Q In ycur direct exce-lnc tier. ycu h*vt alrcedy stated thrt this extensive report, sc for 's ycu know, did net £c to the office of the Chief of the Uedicrl Inspectorate of the Luftv-ffc, rnd tfcct, .".t any rate, ycu never s'■ thv. report in the office, .. Tht’s whet I arid, yes. q How, the last question re. rrdinp the freezing experiments, '..Itnoss. Very surprisingly, th~ Tvesecuter stated here for the first tine, thet the method cf rapid r^wirain • as net introduced i.-.to prr.ct- ico in tho Coruen ’’chraccht. This st tc-aent surnriccd ao re. tl; , since I found no document tc this effect, nor did I hu-r .anythin" orally tc thrt effect. Hew t«-U us, >itn^ss, was this net-hod ctunlly introduced in the Guiae-n * ohroacht, end if 3v, when? .1 positive kncvlcd/o about this introduction is cm follows: First of ell, I knew thrt in the course of the winter of 19/>k-19/*3, instructions fer acrtlchl officers woro issued .-dvoertinr 'li nt crier- in.;, quick rowindng '3 the only acthod for tr t after fraccing* Secondly, ever;- Germ soldier in the Zr st ir the Herth received r. oofflormytua :n his pry bock .-’ cut rh t tc dc f>r cold r n:’« tr~' taunt of frozen persons, .Iso, I knc. tirt the Kedic'l So Din trees Strtions, in their .-aster heats, life torts, had - rr-ngcaonto fer U3in the het ~ tx.r which c--_.es cut cf the ootcr efter cooling the aorcr, fer the tre’toent of frozen persens. But I elievo thrt c-n proved 1 y rn -ffi i.vit fren r dec. distress dcctcr. * I’ncn the fin -1 question cn ccld, which ycu c-n answer vdth '-no sentence, Witness. In yeur direct cxasdxvtlcn you s-i ' th*t *'pi - rcoerninr h-d been discus sc: t great length, -nd then ilr. Hardy -r:u-ht the discovery cf c Russian dcctcr freer the year louO, I bc- licvc, tc y ur .attention rnd asked ycu why these exp _rim-nto ’ey Kclz- lcchncr ~t Dachau were necessary in vi-h cf th.-t. Can you r.-r sene- thin: tc thrt? .. Vh_sc oq-eriaents — spccificall: Kclzl:diner’s ex _ri :nts — n quid: rarc-Anr, where, ir. Hclslcvhncr’s cwn nerds, n- c^eidmentrl 8263 23 ,-3JG-Zl-2-K?rrcw (Brown) Court 1 subject suffered Miv h*rd cr vs cnd.-ncorcd, v.cre ncccss'r; hoc’use ir. spite of the capcrioonts cf the Russian Ureter, Lcpcsins!-' in 1CCO, ow- in spite of nuacrcus rninrl oxporirwnts, -nd in spite cf sotic iscl ted o* 3erv ti:ns in .ir'oticc, iv: cno c-ul-I decide “.^rinst slow r or-min", *-hich hr.d teen used fer thcus“nds cf y-rrs fer frees? np, "nd tc chrn"c orcund ccuplctcl7 rnd dc oxr.ctly the opposite — -xr ctly whr.t h"! *lv *73 boor, considered the greatest denser — th t is, .Tiick rev.'rain.. 1 Jr. rresident, I h-vc - fet. questions rogrrding the ncact sut- j^cty but I think this would be c _- CJ.- Then, in ccndueicn, witness, a last question. The prosecutor repeatedly asked ycu about documents regarding which he assumed that they oust have reached the Medical Inspectorate and must be in the files there. For ex'iiple, the concluding reports by Hozloehner, Richer and Finke re- 9263 29 J£ayiI-FL-2-2Priaer.u (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 gprding the freezing experiments , you denied tbet ycu had ;ver seen this report and e large lumber of others* There¬ fore, I should like to ask ycu, dc you know what heppeted to the files cf the Chief :iedicel Inspector rf the Luft* waffs ? At - Cur registry office was in Harzburg in the Herz Itountains whGnce it was transferred in February from Berlin, whereas I stayed in Berlin until the middle of April and then, with the rest of this sm«ll staff of nine, went to the Tyrol where at the end cf liny wc were taken prisoner# < 1 ,- Now, what happened to these Herzburg files and the registry .ffice of the Medical Inspector ? A.- in the first half of April the office was taken by American troepst In this oey the files certainly foil into American hands since later when I wps rt the Aero •Me¬ dical Center in Heidelberg, I received a number of these files to bo worked vn by avo for the Aoro-Mcdicol Center* t #r Witness, among the documents jxit in evidence in this triil have you seen nny dccur,ents that originated from the files wf the Medical Inspectorate, that is, used for the prosecution. Hwi Dr* TIri . No further questions# THE PRSSI LENT : Any questions to bo propounded tc this witness by any defense counsel ? BY DR. SAUTES (Defense counsel f-r the defendant Ruff and rppocring also for defendant Romberg) ; Q.- Witness, yesterday and the day before yoi want in¬ to the experiments with the 1 -w-prcssuro chamber at great length. However, a few points oust yet be clarified in this tatter. You said yesterday - - :r maybe it was the day befere 8269 29 :isy-Zi-?L-2-3-Primeau (lot. Brown) C.urt Ho. 1 yesterday — that when these experiments began with the low pressure chamber in Decheu in 1342 they h»d been preceded by :ther experiments which were ^lsc to clarify the problem for rescue frea great sltitu.des — experiments by Dr. Lutz, y:u said, Dr. Claannn end Dr. Ec-nzinger. These expcrimc-nts, y.u said, were carried :ut above 12,COO actors and there were reports en them but you weren't able t: say whether these reports cn the preceding experiments were already avni lnble at the time of the Dachau experiment or net, I should like tw take my p^int of departure from th-6«. statements -f y.urs and ask a few qucsti.ns. You mentioned the names of Doctors Lutz, Clroann and Bcnwingor. A.- I believe there was ?. little li.nguinistic misjndcr- st°nJing here. I do not remember having mentioned Dr. Lutz in this c -nnection. At any rate, I w"s thinking of the name Lift, who w.rkod with Clcrann or. these problems. However, those experiments of Luft were ta^de in 1312 and 1343. Clr- mann h-d w.rkcd on this subject before alone. Q.- Then let mo ask you something regarding this. In these experiments with Dr. Luft are you thinking f the oxpo ritnents which are carried cut by the experimenter with White mice, instead cf people. .»•- Those -r_ the experiments that Lutz carried cut. Ho carried thorn cut with white mic^. '«• - but tiu experiments you were thinking :f were dif- foront experiments ? The luft experiments took certainly pi-cc after , the D 0 chau experiments. And what about the Lutz experiments ? '.'ore they bof.ro the D-'Ch'ii experiments, *nd when I say Dachau expe¬ riments I am referring t- the experiments Dr. Rur.bcrg --rried .ut on Dr. Ruffs authority. New the UJtz experi- 8270 29 ’Say-H-FL-2-4-Primeau (Int. Hr.v.n) Court Nc. 1 ments were white aice instead cf experimental persons. Were they be fere or after the Dachau experiments ? /»•- I can't answer that from ay cwn precise knowledge but only .n the basis the documents and from the documents it can be seen that apparently these two experimental scries were carried out acre _r less sicultancously. I believe thet R-oibor menti-ns in his report that the stucics of Lutz wore concluded only eftcr his v/erk. Q.- This is d.cuacnt 402, I believe, the concluding re- p rt by D.ctcrs Ruff and Re uberg which c-'ne cut <*ftcr the ex¬ periments were c.ncludcd *»nd in this report there is mention¬ ed, if you remember, the fact th*t through Lutz's experiment the problem ~f rescue fr.m gre-'t heights h*d net been solved yet. Dc yeu rcu.nbcr that passage in the concluding report cf Ruff *»nd Romberg ? a.- That is certainly so. I c-n rcmombGr the Lutz rc- p.rt to extent. c*- Dr, Becker, is it still ycur opinion today that Lutz's experiments, with white mice did net solve yet, the problem .f rescue from great altitudes ? Is that still year personal opinion as an expert and specialist ? That is n~t *nly .my personal opini n but the cpini.n f scientists in general. <.•- D: y.u remember that after this report of Dr. Lutz's it was s. asc-rtained thr.ugh further experiments, particular¬ ly thr.ugh Ruff 6 and Romberg's experiments, that the- c nclu- si.r.s and results t- which Lutz had c.mc were actually wr'-ng-- n'Mcly, ir. the following respect. In this report v/hich you Oust oenti.nec Dr. Lutz -- -nd I ra asking yeu if this is s: — comes to the c.ndusicn thet rescue fr.m grc*t altitudes -s p.ssibl. only up to the altitude of 15,CC0 meters .to which -*• is tru<., Dr. Lutz adds. "So far as that can be ascertained 3271 29 lioy-K-FL-2-S-PrL2Ccu (Int. Brown) C-art Nc. 1 fro a animal experiments." Than other experiments went to much greater heights and it was seen that rescue was possible from the60 heights Rise. Is that correct ? A.- Yes. I c°n corroborate that be ecu sc in 19*4 I, cs a referent, concerned oys-lf with this pro len but I must correct you tc this extent. Lutz's c nclusicns reached with his white mice were certainly correct. However, there is p difference between a white ocuac and a human being in sueh smell animals arc very narrow channels and thU6 present different Cwnditi-ns f:r absorbing and taking care of air pressure or pressure in general and are thus different from what rosults in cases <-f larger air passages such as are f.und in human beings. Q.-' men I think you are trying to say, Dr.. Backer, that Dr. Lutz's experiments did n>-t solve the prcblen of rescue frea great altitudes -- at loc6t did not sclvo it for human beings. Is that so ? 29 Ifcy 47-J£-S5->l-Iteniels (Brown) Court No* 1 Yes, that opinion isorrect. C. Now, how about the experiments carried on by the other two nor. I mentioned previously, ncmely.Drs. Qlanann endBantfi£cr, In your opinion , res the prctlem of rescuo fran great altitudes arlvcd oon- pletoly by the experiments cf »ra. Clamann end B eaZ in^ or , 0 r was the problem net yet solved by thso experiments in the sprinc oT 191*2? A. Lot ae refor to what *\iff expleincd from the witness stend record¬ ing this sfcole problem* cndscy thot within the framework of this prob¬ lem es e whole there were two main questions, ^bo question wns, how does n ran stand explosive doecz^rossi on et ell if ho is in o presaire cabin in e bcllcn or in on eirplcnc? litre is in thic chcnbcr, first of ell, o prosairc of 3,r»e or 8,000 aetcra, lot us say. Th> Qlr- plenc, horever, is tt cn altitude of 15*000 or 20,000 raters, end - suddenly the ccbln is hirst. Now, tho first question is, whet heppens to the huz»n being when til of c Bidden this oxploslvo decompression tokos piece? Cl erne nn end EcnAiger concerned thoasolves with this pmblon of cjp losive decompression. T odty I ccnnot sty without documentation Just ct whet dote the vtrious reports thot thoy issued on this problem ccao outj hit even on the assumption thet those cxporlnonts were ®n- el"dod before Huff's end Haaterg's oxporinonts began, tho se®nd noin problem cr question would still not teve been solved, namely, hovr c hunon boing, when ho hes survived explosive deajmprossicn, ern bo br-ught down free Q greet cltitudo to lower oltitudea end whet hr.ppons to hin. *nd this eeccnd question wes, sc fer cs I know, tho problem which formed tho basis for ^ff's end ikmbcrc'o rcric. fV The, °r. Becker, in ordor to state this perfectly dearly . you soy — end if I err, plecsc correct me — there arc two problems ^to be jclvcd. 9ce is the problem of explosive de-compression, nir.ely, the problem res: lting wh6n tho pessure cabin in an cirplcne bursts ct e ~rect altitude* end this feet is simulated in the experiment. Thus, the experiment is designed to discover how c human being reacts to this ai Men redact lot. in pressure. That is thoproblee of explosive 2$ l£ay iclalvo this probltn, end this -rofclea cesthe nt.in a ncerr. of Drs. *\iff 'nd Rcnbcr;;» this tea the problem they rerc to solve. Is thrt orrcct, sof'r rs.I cs t loyrxn cc.n undcratind thiaor. iter? Yoa, you understood me completely, I $-Dt-ida(3rc*n) Court Sc. i eak yai the fo Herrins. D o you kr.ow that even several yecra before the Second ~crld '~cr ec Italian, I believe kia name c.s Fetal, cacetried with e stratosphere plere without^*eaaure cabin, only with a pressur¬ ized suit, and he did thlsin erder to sake the plene lighter — to 17,000 cr 18,200 set era? This, cs I say, rta a c-vert 1 yctra before the aoccod 'world -er. Did you know that? a. ff ccurae I did, Ihet is the recognized altitude record rith airplecea to dote. Tkla nee the Italicn Colonol by tho nano of Tctsi, fran the Itcllen *ir ?orce Rcaccrch Institute rctr Scce, in Guidonla. I bclievo this world record era aotin 1937. 0. Thao were oltitudoa between 17,000 and 18,000 actcra? I believe that tho recognized oltitudo was 17 ,500, but I cn not auro. -t least over 17,000. azr* 29 Jfay U7-:^TD-i.-i-Ccok (Inti Brown) Court Ho, 1 Q Dr. Becker, do you know that in other ways nach grooter heights bnvo been reache ’, heights of as nuch as 21*,000 noters, at which the huaan boin* survived? A Yes, The experiaents woro carried out several tins3. Onco at the bspinning or the niddlo of the thirties, two American Captains, I believo Orville Anderson and Albort Stevens, in the Anorican stratos¬ phere balloon Explorer II, reached a height of 17,200 uotersj sono tine lator the Swiss or Belgian Profossor Piccard with his assistant. Dr. Kuepfer or Knoopfor, or seno such nano, wont with his stratosphere balloon to a height of aaao — what noro than 2l*,OCO aotors without any¬ thing happening to then, but, of course, this was in a pressurized cabin. Q Do you know, Doctor, that in the poriol that followod, those altitudes woro oven oxcoodod? I sota to rcr»r.bor a oaso whoro an altitude of as nuchas 26,000 notors was attainod. I don*t want to toll you tho none for tlio nocaont. Porhaps you can ronenbor tho nano yourself. I should profor thnt. A I cbr-H know that 26 kilonotors was actually reached, but fron ry activitios as a Roforont I know that tho Goman Rosoarch Institute for Gliding in Ainring near Salzburg, under tho direction of tho well- known ooro-.ymnic export and aviation rosoarch nan, Profossor Georgij, developed an airplane, or rather was in tho courso of lovcilop- infi it, and this piano was intondod to roach an altitude of 26,000 neters. Howovor, I don*t kmrr whether tho plane actually ovor flow. That wa3 at tho end of 19UU. Q Now, Dr. Bcckor, when yew rofloct on Ruff*s and ftanberf-'s axporicent3, do you agree with no whon I say that on tfio basis of those oxanplos, an ur.^ont necessity existed in the year 1912 for solving tho iroblor. of rescue free proat'altitudes, at loast altitudes as hirh as 20 or 21 kUoaetersj do you as a specialist agree with no in that assertion or do you not? 3277 29 Vs? L7-V.TD-^-Cook (Ir. -4 Brown) Court No* 1 A I an entirely in accord with you. Dr. Sautcr. Q Than Dr. 3ocker, I want to ask yew a few questions about this lcw-pres3uro chanbar. Do you know who delivered theso low-pressure chambers? A Yes, I do. Q Who? A They woro all delivered by the 1.0. Zeuzco firr in Frankfurt on the 'iain. Q Do you know whether the chaEbors wore delivered ccwmlotoly roady for use, or woro the chambers when they woro (tolivored not yot roa'V for uso, and, if so, what was lacking in thon? A I don't know what you are driving at. Q I fold that sinply bocauso perhaps sinco I don't know what you aro drlvii*; at ry answer my bo a little nsido fron tho point. *7olI, for one thinj tho fira didn't itsolf ranufacturo tho punpa but bought thon froa other firra. In addition tho oxygon oquipewnt was not nanu- facturod and not ontiroly installed by this fir=,cnd abovo all tho intor-con systen, that is, tho tolophono systenj those piocos of oquipnent woro usually built into tho chanbor later by I.uftwaffo units. q Who built thon in? Wero they not built in, on tho basis of orders fron tho Hodioal Inspoctcrato, by a technical dopartnent of tho DVL — that is, tho Goman Rosoarch Institute for Aviation — bocauso that technical dopartnont of tho DVL had the necessary technicians nvail- ablo, always on orders fron tho "o 'ical Inspoctcrato, that is? A Yos, tiuxt i3 ri ht, in tho caso of the four low-prossuro chanber units. Q The nanufacturo of the low-pressure charbors, including Ahoso piecos of oquipnent tint woro nissinc, the inter-con systen, the oxygen systen, and so forth, was not according to you, done by Dr. Ruff's Inctituto, is that so? 8273 29 May L7-M-A7I>4i-3^Cook (Int. Brown) Court Ho. 1 k Surely not, because Buff's institute was a medical research institute! the equipping of tho chamber was surely done by sane workshop of tho D7L. I don*t know the details. Q How this mobile low-pressure chamber that cane to Dachau in Januarj’ or February, 19U2, when it reached the DVL, was this chamber immediately allocated to Ruff's institute, or was it still under tho orders of the Medical Inspectorate, that is to say. Prof. Dr. Hippko's orders? A Dr. Sautor, I beliovo that that is an economic or logoi problcn. Just who owns sccothing which has boon allotted to someone olso but not yet delivered. 3o long as tho chamber was in tho DVL, Dr. Ruff could of course not disposo of it with comploto froodom, but if ho had somo spodal pxrposo for tho chonbor, had to got Professor Hippko's permission. Q Then tho disposal of tho lc-w-prossuro chamber, oven tho ono at Dachau, was hold by &•. Hippko as Chief of the "odical Inspectoral, is that what you are saying, are. if I understand you corrootly Dr. Ruff coulcl not dispose of it independently but only with Profos 3 or Hippko's approval, is that what you aro saying? A That is what I think is tho case. Howovor, I cannot tako responsibility for tho oconocdc and logoi problons involvod. Q How, how did this work out in practice? For oxanplo, who issued ordors for this charter wasto bo sont scrowhcro, thoro had to bo travel ordors, a directive with ?omission for tho chamber to be oovo . Mow nho issued thoso orders, *ld Dr. Ruff or hi3 institute issuo thorn, or did tho Medical Inspectorate, or did sons luftwaffo unit issuo then on ordors from the Medical Inspectorate? Are ycu personally informed regarding this matter? A First lot no tall you that of ny - 77 m knowledge I oan toll you nothin' regarding the conditiora at that tine, because I had nothing to do with the transportation of these chambers. I can speak only on tho basis of ny ~encral information. I can say for certain that Dr. 8279 2 9 Ifey U*4S-ATD-&-h-Cook (mu Bro«r.) Court !fo. 1 Ruff could not sign such travel orders, because that was a purely military natter, and Dr. Raff, as the head of a purely civilian institute, had no right to issuo any such nilitary otders, so those orders aist havo been signed oithor by Hippko himself or by soneono olso with the necessary nilitary powers who was caoiissioned to do so by hin. Q ffow, regarding the right of disposal of this low-pressure chamber, I should bo interested in tho following: Jhen the chonbor was in Dachau ready to bo usod for experLunts, who, in your opinion — your are a doctor, not a lawyer — vhs, in your opinion asRoforont or the Nodical Inspectorate, had tho right to disposo of tho chamber? V/ho do torn! nod -bother it stayed thoro or was rmovod, and Dr. Bockor, before you answer this quostion, lot no lesdnd you of a lottor that has frtquontly boon roa hero, a lottor fron Prof. Hippko to Oborgrupponfuohror Wolff of tho SS, I boliovo of 20 May 191#, in v/hich it is statod that tho chanbor was to bo brought back to Berlin and was to stay thcro and was to bo usovi for front-lino purposos, but was not to bo usod by tho S3? ?R. H'.RDY: In view of this last question. Your Honor, I mist object on tho "round it is a loading quostion. It soorw to no that tho Defendant has oxhibitod that ho can well tostify for hlnsolf, and undo- tho circunatancoa it is unfortunato that I cannot cross-oxanino ur. Sautor. I can only cross-oxanino tho dofondant. THE PRESIDENT: Tho question is certainly a leading one. The objection will be sustained. Tho quostion nay bo propounded to tho witness, but lot hin answer it instead of counsel putting the words in his nouth. BY DR. SAUER: Q Witness, I shall then ask you tho following quostion: Do you kntfw Hippko*s letter to 'olff s f 20 -'ay 19h2? This is the lottor in which Hlppkc writes that the low-prossure chamber is not to bo made 8280 1 2? ISay l i 7- , -W.TD-u-5-Cook (Int. Brown) Court fc* 1 available any longer but is needed for front-line purposesj do you know this letter? A I know it, but so that I nay answer ycur question, nay I ask you to hand ae the docuoont? I don't receefcer it well enough* 8281 29 "ny-H-J?-5-l-Grcse (int. 3r-wn * Court I Q. Dr. Seclcor, v u ore r t t" nnswor the «*jc9ti~r. as I nsfcod it first. Tho Tribunal acid it was a leading quosti n, just answer tho quest! n I ;sk y'U n«-w, certainly .30 leedinj question, wheth r v u kn-w th it letter which was fr*quently reed durinc this trial. This is tho lottor in which "rites that ho conn t mice tho ohanhor avrilnhlo any 1 re Nicnuac it is needed f r fr-nt line purgeaoa. I huliov' it is tho lottcr .-f 20 ray ly.Z. T7 it ness, I hav, n o* ;y f the lottor horo. I soo it is n t o lottor .... T:G ::j»ID33Ti Comae 1, just su’-nit the lottor t- tho witness, the ncssenfor will take it t the witness and ash the witness if he is familiar with tho letter. D:;. SAUTEI'.i It la n t a lottor fr n HI; 1*0, ns 1 SCO, hut a lottor fr n Field P rshnl Hiloh. I must c rrc ct nysolf. ... Tot, this is tho infarv.ua lottor hosdod "Doer T7olfy", and I nn of e'urso, familiar with it. Q. Dr. Sooker, when y t road this letter when y^u woro a roforont, whrt e rvclusi n d ycu as nn cx,ort draw fr r this lottor recording who was ontitled t dis. -so f tho chanbor whilo it was in Docheu? TTas It tho SS, r tho Cmap Cfrmndor f Dachau, r wh waa it? A. It soens t mo t ho o r^thor difficult legal i rahlom. Hiloh anvs, n thr no hand, that tha chnn v or cannot r. rr.in in Dnehnu. Thus, Field ’Marshal I’ilch is a.j-arcntly nasuninj; that in thie oceo ho, ns o rc;r aontrtivo f tho luftwaffo, was entitled t toko tho chnmtor nwny fr r Diohau. But wh w-.s l:relly c-m;otont t dis; so of tho chnnbor in DcoVu, I ns a fora n n t familiar with leg 1 matters conn't clonrly soo. Q. Is there anythin • in the lettor t' tho effect that Dr. Duff cr hie institute had th.s right f dis, sitis was rnnufneturod \v the Viunneso flrn Karajan. Tho Karajan n «Jol wos o cothcdo-rny oscillograph with a Srr.un'a tuho, •ut I conn t soy f r sura which mchinu Dr. Jhnbcrf; hod. Thoro ore c-srt-.in raehin s which d n t poroto witn .rcun's tu’o ' ut still w rk. It is a vary likely c.njcoturc, but I d n't kn w f r sure. Q. Is this the so-called Klcino Siemens n.jnrstus? In answering this quest! n, let re renin^ y u f Dr. 2 nborg's testin ny n tho stand. At that tiro he said that it was n - vinp ; ir.t f li'*-ht n a s-mll scr-on. That is what r ’or - said. V w, ;crha s y u will rrwnbcr that. *• w, is this th- s rt f nachin that y u just r.jnti nod? A. H , I nust c rroct rrysolf. In this case f the anil scrucn thoro is a sen?cn r _-t lCxoy-, end this is tho screen vu fir.’ in th. Xloinc 29 12ay-M-Jh-5-c -Or osa (Inti 2r wn) C urt I Siencns olcctr cardief-raph. Q, y by « bacrria^ this n vine 1 int *f lirht rf which Itodbore s; 'lco in his faatin ny, can no c no t a r-cisc diagn sis f the c r.diti n f the heart r is thot singly o vacuo indiocti n .f the honrt retivityt TThot can y u, ai a d-ct< r, toll us about this? A. riot so <1 ate rstruo what I an o’ -ut t soy os tho testin-ny • of a hoort socialist because I an n t nc, K wovor, I «*. kn.w n little ab. ut olectr cordi- graphs. I w uld r. t trust nysolf t- -draw on occurato diof.n sis a the fcosia f th s n-viar p. int . f lifo. Q. Last qe.-sti n, witnoss, ro,rnrdin,* tho hor rutor. Did this bir rotor have nrj> technical C ' nnocti n with tho yunja? ’Jos it nttachod to the .-unps, or whoro woe It instollcd f r tho . urj. sc -f noasurinc altltudo? A. There was n diroot tcohnical r rochnn*cal ornnocti-n totwoon tho v "r nrtor and tho ,uapa. That con bo soon fros tho foot that tho punps w oro in a difforont truck fr n tho truck in whioh tho chanter was, and, f c urso, tho tor no tor was in tho 1 -w pressure ohnn'-or itself, Q. I horo n furthor questi ns. Hr. Irosidont, r.rrz fo;» r.oss* Q. Dr. Bockor-Froys> ng, in yur er ss cxnninatl n, witnoss, y u snid tint tho rosoareh nssi,-.nr*jnts nf tho !!odicrl Ins.oct rr.to that did n t c ncorn oviati n nodical quosti* ns ri,-lnatod fr r. Itoforat 219 f tho IVjdicnl Inspectorate. Fra the w rd " ri -inat< d" no understands that tho initiative was t- kon by th*. t lieforat ir. issuing those research nssi ,'mponts. *ref. Ts.aa c- nsidors that statorent inc rroct and c nfr nts y u with tho fact that s fbr as ho kn.ws n sin^lo hy.iono research nssi^nrwnt, p articularly r. r.o to Iref. Il^sa, was issued -a tho initintivo X tho ?!odio«l Ir.spoct rate; rather, those research assiyn-nonts with ut oxco ; tion riijinatod in a n aj.j licati'n a the . art f the research nan in quostiv-n hinsolf. Do y u wi3h t su; plcnont r c rroct tho ststonont yu nado ir. erflas-oxaninnti n a tho v asis f this inf nonti r. fr-n Ir-f. :{r S o 2 323L 29 ••oy-Jt-JT-E-'l-Gf-ss (Int. Brown) C urt* I A. Of c urso, I unf- rtunatoly dc nrt ha no tho rorhotln r-cord of what I sold in er'-ss oxaninnti n tefcro no n.-w, txit I very nuch daibt whether I actonlly said what y u Just said I said. In s-i nany words let no richt away correct a nisteko that y u nado in nenin C a eocene. Yu said esaienponta t- "rofossor 2cse, rad y u naan rrefossor Eaejon. Q. Yes. that is ri-ht. A. Thor., when I was speaking of tho Heforct far Hyciono in er««s oxaninaticn, I was openkiiv; mly of o wry few hyciono roscarch ossiennonts, and n t oil rcsoaroh nssienronts that awro n t aviati n nodical as*Un- oentsj end finally, if I really said that rosoorch assignments tc Enn C on roally riginatnd with tho Itofcrnt f r Hyciono, then what I noant to soy In this ocimoeti.n was that the actual w. rk tho opinion oxproased by tho licforont, was done Vy tho hyciono .Toforont. X, h wovor, dr net know whothor tho assipr^nt t Hnneon was issued on Haap-n's application or beoauso tho Roforont for Hyciono c nsidcrod it nooossery, but, oocord- in C to tho general custcn, it is tho n«st probably thing that Hoa C on opppliod t tho Jtodicnl Inspectorate f r the nssipwont, 9nd 1 b * 41#v0 this questi•n c uld be cloorod up -7 & 8-5-Meehan (Int. Frank) Court No# 1 Q Could you plooso toll =e what do cure nt book it is in, I think it is 3. A It is an appendix to 3, I an afraid this is all I can say. Q gut, you have tho document before you. 7/culd you bo good onough to clarify this and to road just what Siovers said in regard to tho high altitude oxporirents at Dachau. Perhaps in order to naintain con¬ tinuity you can start with tho boginnln: and thon road tho subsequent paragraph. A I havo only a brief extract hero, an extract fron tho scientist's diary of tho Ahnonorbo Socioty for 19b3, kopt by tho Roichs Manager SS Standartonfuohrcr Siovers, undor No* 8 # Q Bxcuso t n, witness, but would you rdnd tollinr; ao just what tho dato of this ontry was? A Unfortunatoly I cannot tell you tho date, :jy docunont doos not show it, but thoro aro thoso words, "Continuation of Low Prossuro Chanbors." Q Dees tto docunont show Just what wo wero coneomod with thoroin, in other words on what occasions was that roproducod in Siovors' diary? A As far as I know tho entry was nado in connoction with tho con- foronco betwoon siovors and Raschor on an inquiry Raschor nado to Siovors. Q !!r. Presidont, I can cloar this up. It is 6 March 19U3, tho roforenco is nado to a conference between Raschor and Siovors during which a raimbor of points aro listed. Under No. 8 of this point of tho conference thoro is nontlon of tho continuation of tho low prossuro oxporinonts. You cannot draw any othor conclusion fron this entry * excopt that it was a conversation between Raschor and Siovors. »!R. HARDYt I request the Tribunal to instruct Dr. Tip? that that is an argument and camot bo taken up at this placo. THE PRES IDE NT: I think that is Deroly an explanation of tho iocu- nent and ho did not state the contents of the ctocunent at all. Counsel 8291 29 liay U7-H-ATI>-? & t-6-Heeban (Int. Frank) Court No* 1 nay proceed* DR. TIFT: Mr. President, I have no further questions to this >.ltness. If I nay have the pomission of the Tribunal, I would like to continue with the presentation of docuaonts and tho witnoss nay bo excused. THE PRESIDENT: Did you understand tho ruling of tho Tribunal? You can pro coed with tho question! ng of tho witnoss, did yew or did you not understand tho objection by tho prosocution was ovorrulodj did you understand? DR. TIPP: I understand !!r. Prosidont, but throur* tho‘explanation I have assunod and tho addod tostinony of tho witnoss, tho quostion is cloarod up and I don't think thoro aro any furthor questions necessary. In conclusion I want to ask you. Dr. Boekor, you probably ronaibor tho contents of tho Siovors* diary, do yai agreo with ny intorprotaticn that this is noroly an extract of a eonforcnco botwoon Siovors and Raachor which doos not show anything about tho continuation of tho oxporinonts? THE .ITNESS: That is r$r opinion *>o. At any rate, I an absolutely convineod that in 19U3 no low ;iro3Suro chanber was ovor a Rain novod to Dachau. D*. TIPPt Again, in that ceso. Hr. Prosidont, I havo no furthor questions to tho witnoss. THE PRESIDENT* Thoro being no further questions to bo propounded to tho witness, tho defondant Becker-Froysonr is oxcusod from tho witnoss stand and nay rosuno his place. 8292 2 ? Mry-M-ie-9-I-Gros5 (Int. Frank) Court Ko. I. THE PRESIDENT: I understand, counsel, the defendant Bcckor- Frcysong will not call as a witness Eugen Haagen. His nano was 1istod as a witness for the defendant Bockor-Froysong on the witness sheet of May 27 th. DR. TIPP: That is quite right. Hr. Frosident, and I can clear up this point. I agreed with Mr. Hardy that in order not to interrupt the sea water case the witness Haagen will not bo called until tho whole soa wntor caso has boon cooplotod, after the examination of Dr. Schaofor has been completed, as well as Beiglbocck. THE PRESIDENT: I Just waited to see that nothing wr.s overlooked. Counsol nay proccod. DR. TIPP: Mr. President, tho noxt docunent which is offered on behalf of tho dofondant Bockor-Froysong has oxhibit no. 32. It is con¬ tained in Docunent Book III and is Bockor-Froysong Document 1:8. May I now continuo with subnitting tho documents from Book III and it is no. U9. I should liko to offor it ns oxhibit 33« MR. HARDY: May it ploaso tho Tribmnl, I have throo or four docunent books and Dr. Tipp has several docunonts to introduco fmn onch book and I don't want to interrupt tho continuity of his caso or tho soquonco of his caso but it would bo ooch aoro convoniont if ho would introduco the affidavits and docunonts through each book and con- pie to the introduction of Docunent Book 1, then 2, 3# and h in that order if possible and I could follow so much nore rapidly and could intorposo ay objections without too auch difficulty. DR. TIPP: I don't think this difficulty will arise. I an only going to subnit the remaining docusents froa Docunent Book III. As far as tho remaining documents in 1 and 2 which have not been offored in evidcnco, these are documents concerned with experiments on human beings which arc inpossible to offer now, in accordance with the ruling of tho Tribunal all docuaents which were meant to be submitted since Prosec¬ ution has recognised the inportancc of the exporinents. Therefore, as I said I will turn to docua;nt U9 in Document Book III on f&go 210 and 8293 29 lfcy-lMS-9-2-Gross (Int. Prank) Court Ho* I* I shall call it Exhibit 33. It is an affidavit dated Hi February 1947 and it is merely being offered in order to show that a nunbor of thirty high ranking officers of the Goman Air Forces were having confidence in Bccker-Freysong and Professor Schrocdor to tho effect that thoy wore carried out on strictly huaano principles. I don't propose to road this docunont. HR. HARDY: Sfay it pleaso tho Tribunal, I have agroed with Dr. Tipp. I will not object to its introduction in ovidonco ovon if it does not ncct with tho previous regulations of tho Tribunal. It doos not have a jurato, isn't in good fora. I do not wish to object and v wish to have it admitted but wish to roservo tho right to objoct in the futuro. THE JRESn)E.vr: Tho record will show counsel's reservation to tho right to objoct in tho futuro. DR. TIPP: Now I shall, >tr. ft-osident, submit tho document frera tho soao docunont book, pago 213, Bockor-Froysong Docunont 50, and 1 will call it Exhibit #3b« It is an affidavit from a clergyman Dr. Ooatroichor fron Hoidolberg datod 23 Deccnbor 191:6. This witness con- fims in this docunont that ho know Dr. Bcckor-Froysong intimately sinco 1928 sinco ho had boon a friend of his son and ho was a rogular visitor in tho house of this witness at the tine his son was at tho university. I should liko to quote paragraph d fron tho first page: "I an ablo t hero fore to testify that Dr. Hornann Bockor-Froysong had a truo Christian conviction and dovotod hinself to an irreproach¬ ably pure way of lifo. As a physician he was filled with tho highest sonso of responsibility, and only tried to help his pationts. In ny opinion Dr. Hcraann Bockor-Froyseng had a Christian character and never did anything against his conscience." Paragraph c deals with tho reason for Dr. Beckor-Freyscng join¬ ing tho Party aixl the witness says that Beckor-Frcysend told hin ho had cerely done this because the Party was based on Christian principles and had promised to relieve the great unemployment and need of tho masses. 8294 29 May-JME-9-3-Gross (Int. Frank) Court So. I. This is paragraph 3. I should like to turn to page 2 of the document: "Liko so nany othors, ho, too, ras disappointed in this trust, and abstained thoro- foro iron any political activity. Ho never agreed to what was called later the national socialist outlook on life either in theory or in practice, but as I learned in 191*5 after a prolonged conversation with hin, he regained unalterably faithful to his cbtistian conviction." Then follows the signature and tho certification. The next document I should liko to offer is Bockor-Froysong No. 51 from tho sans Docuccnt Book on pogo 215. I shall call it Exhibit Bockor-Freysong 35. It is an affidavit fron Profossor Dr. Albort Dour who was a rosidont of Hoidclborg, dated 30 Dococfcor 191*6. Dr. Dour doscribos theroin that ho had known Bockor-Froysong as a school boy and that ho had continued to noot hin during his university tin© and tho boginning of his nodical career. I should liko to quoto free paragraph 2 of this docunont, tho last sontenco on tho first pagos "Ho wants to create, not to dostroy, and his nodical offorts can only bo diroctod towards helping, 1 waling and saving". I shojld like to continuo ny quotation urdor paragraph 3, tho socond sontenco* “I consider it inpossiblo that ho could ovor have takon pert, on his own responsibility, in any wrong doing or any kind of i ab man o bohavior, and if, as Stabsaret of tho rosorvo, ho was on- trustod because of his activity with sono special tasks, ho is suro to have carriod then out only as tho good nan ho always was." Tho final paragraph of tho docunont assumes that tho witness hinself has not boon a nenbor of tho HSDAP and that sinco Dccocbor 19l*5 had boon working with tho peraission of tho Military Government. Thcro follows tho correct certification. Tho next docunont is on pc go 217 of tho Docunont Book, Docunont 52 of Becker-Freysong and I shall call it Exhibit 36. It is an affid¬ avit of tho wo11 known physiologist professor Dr. H. Ruin at Goettingen dated 21 January 191*7. After tho usual introduction tho witness states 8295 29 lfcy-K-KB-9-UGross (int. Frank) Court No. I. under paragraph 1 - and I should like to quote; "I nevor thought Dr. 3ecker-Freysong capable of c emit ting Q crirc against hunanity as ho never gave ze any cause to think so either in his conversation or by his behavior. I was surprised to hear that ho was arong tho Hamburg defendants and to this day I aa entirely in tho dark about how ho mdo hinsclf guilty." The subsequent paragraph undor 2 contains tho statement to the offect that Dr. Bockor-Freyscng had intervonod for a scientific book which was to bo prohibited in Gcmany since tho introduction had boon written by a Jowish author. I don't went to quoto from this paragraph. Paragraph U on tho noxt page I should liko to quoto if I nay. "Dr. Bockor-Froysong conducted oxperinonts on hinsolf to tho very linit of tho possiblo; ho oxperixontod, for instanco on hinsolf for days with oxygon poisoning to tho point of pneunoniaj thoso expori- nonts were oxcoodingly elucidative and thoroforo noritorioua for tho whole nodical scionco." I should also liko to quoto tho last paragraph in ordor to throw additional light on tho personality of tho dofondant and tho witness says, and I quoto; "I nysulf havo boon affirnod by Jiilitary Govcmncnt as tho Rector of the University of Goottingon, os a norher of the scientific advisory cconittoo for tho British Zone and as tho oditorin chiof of Flat-Re views for Fhysiology." And tho signature is once again followed by tho proper certification. Court So. 1 29 May 47-M-lO-l-iEM-Ierrov (Frank) The next document I should like to offer you will find on pege 220 of the document took. It it Becker-Treysong Document Ho. 53, vhich I ■kail give the exhibit nunber 37. It la en affidavit free Dr. Front ruechncr of Freiburg dated 22 January 1947. I ahould like to etote in suppleaentation that Dr. Buechner has, of course, been auoted repoatodly during thia trial. Under figure one of thle document Dr. Buechner describes, to begin with, hi* persoaality. He eaye that ho hlneolf hae neither boon a center of the Party or any of ite aeeoclated organitatlone end that during tho tine of the Third Reich, becaueo of hie poeitlon towarda the national eocielietic doctrino, he vne subject to pcraocutlon. I ahould llko to cako a brlof quotation froo figuro 2: "I net Dr. Beckcr-?royaox« whoa ho vas an aaalatnnt at tho Institute for Aviation Medicine of the Reich Mlniatry for Aviation in Borlin, if ceaory aervea. In 1938. During tho var vc wero in freouent official con¬ tact, when I vns In charge of aviation aattora and pathology and he repeatedly vlalted ae in Freiburg, partly for the renaon that he worked with =y aaaiatanta Llebegott and later Plchotka on a n Inal erperlnonto regarding oxygon poisoning. Sevoral tiaoa ho had lunch or dlnnor in ay houao. I therefore conalder cgrself Qualified to givo an opinion as reoueatod on Dr. Beckor-Freyaeng fros tho 'gonerol, huoan and profoeoional point of view'.* Tho witness then continues to deecrlbe how Dr. Beckor-Froyeong, because of kla personal attitude and his Christian education, rosalnod true to these characteristics and he describes hin as "open-ainded, roliablo and very correct" in official setters and ho describes his as a ■dentist who, during exoericents on hinself and aniaal exuerinenta, had achieved great results. The witness states how far he had authority to sake decisions of hie own and the signature, as usual, is followed by the required certificate by a notary. The next exhibit I ahould to offer is the Docunent Becker-Froyscng So. 54 on page 222 of the docunent book and I will call It Exhibit Ho. 38. It is an affidavit fros Professor Hernann Koeoke of Koidelberg, dated 27 8297 Court So. 1 29 Kay 4?-M-10-2-I£X-iCarrov (Track) Decester 1946. I should like to cuote free this docuaent where Professor Eoepko says, after the usual introduction: "Dr. Becker-Freysecg vus a student of nedicine in Heidelberg fron 1929 to 1932, and as such attended all my lectures and courses. Since I 9 respected hin very such as a talentod and industrious pupil, I invited his several tiaos to ay house. Dr. Becker-Treyseng has stood by mo since that tiae and later always visited vith ay wife and ne whenever he was in Heidelberg. Ho did that in spite of his knovltdgo that ay wifo was holf- Jovish and that the Satis had dismissed ae from ay office as a univoroity profossor for this reason." Tho witnoss states, and I continuo to ouoto: "In Daceetor 1937 he revioved, in the aagazlno 'Gyanastlc and Folk Dances', 12th year, 12th issue, =y book published in 1936, 'Tho Mueclco of tho Hunan Body and Their Play'. I have tho copy at hand. Tho follow¬ ing eontoncos aro inforaative: 'Hermann Koepkc dedicated tho work...to his pupils. I was fortunate onough to be ono of thoa... Ae a tokon of gratitude to ay ttachor I boliove that I should direct the attention of German gymnastic circlos to this book.'■ I think I night say in connection vith this docuaent, Hr. President, that after all it takes Quite sece ccurego and faith in on old tonchor for a Gorman scientist in tho year 1937 to oppress so openly his faith in a aan who is being persecuted on racial grounds. Tho next docuaent I wish to offer is Bocker-Troyscng Ho. 55, but tho following docuaent I don't want to offer. It doosn't actually offer anything new and would merely mean unnecessary burden both to tho Tribunal and to tho record. It li6ts points which other affidavits have alroady proved aoro clearly and efficiently. So, therefore, I will not.offer Docuaent Ho. 55, but the next docuaent I would like to offer is Becker- Treyseng Ko. 56, page 225 of the document book. I shall Bake it Exhibit 39. It's an affidavit froc -rofcssor Eerl Matthes of Erlangen, dated tho 18th of January, 1947, and I should liko to give a brief cuotation freo it. After the customary introduction the witness says, and I ouote: 829S Court Ho. 1 29 Ha;. - 47-*_i(>_3-i£M-Zerrov (Frank) "I certify that Professor Dr. Hernann Bccker-Froyseng, in his capacity as scientific consultant for the chief of the Medical Service of the Luftvaffe, always supported =e in =y scientific work =ost appreci¬ atively though he knsv that I was affected by the then racial laws because of ny wife's ancestry. "Zvon in 1945, when for racial reasons I was threatened to be callod into e work cenp, he pronised ce the support of his office." That's the ease point which was proved through the provious affidavit. Tho signature is once again followed by a notary's certificate. The next docusent I would like to offer is Becker-Freyseng No. 57 which you will find on page 226 of tho docusent book. I should like with your pornisslon to give it Zxhlblt No. 40. This is on affidavit fron Dr. Josef PichOtka, dated tho 20th of January, 1947. The witness describes, to begin with, how ho got to know Dr. Bockcr-Freyscng nnd ho says, following the usual introduction: "I havo known Dr. Hcrnann Bockor-Froyscng slnco 1940. We got to know each othor because tho fiolds of our scientific activities wore tho ease. In tho course of tine theso relations becaso consistently closor with tho result that wo sonetines worked in direct conjunction and voro closo frionds. "As to ay political attitude, I want to stato that, because of ny anti-Nnsi attltudo, I was exoosed to persecutions during the wholo of ny period of studies - this is officloi/recorded in a lottor of the Univer¬ sity of Freiburg. In Decesber, 1944, using a weapon contrery to ordors, I rescued a parachuted American aimer, free a crowd of people vhich wanted to hang hia. The proceedings against ne were cuaehcd." I go on and continue to quote: ■Because of ny close relations with Dr. Bcckor-Freyseng we very fro- auently discussed the burning problens of this tine. Froa these conver¬ sations I know his strong antipathy towards the neny National Socialist nachinations; he elveys abhorred in particular the inhumanities which resulted free the consistent application of National Socialist idoolo©’. 8299 Court No. 1 25 May 47-K~10--j£X-errov (Frank) As I knew his attitude free several conversations, I turned to hin in 1944 in connection with the case of a half-Joviah friend of nino." Then the witness goes on to describe, and I quoto: “At that tine this friend. Dr. Franz Froehllch, now living in Keidelberg-Handtchuhsheia, Kirchgasse 4, was a nodical student at the Institute where I was an assistant doctor. It is true that, for the nost part, nobody troubled hin, but ho had no Incone and w»s always sub¬ ject to the danger that one day ho w»ild be put into a caap or that, at least, ho would lost tho right to go on working at the institute. I thoreforo appoaled to Dr. Bcckor-Frcyseng to try, with the help of his official influence at the Medical Inspectorate of the Luftwaffe, to procuro for Froohllch a ooraanent post at tho Institute for Aviation Kcdlcino In Freiburg. Dr. Bcckor-Troysong pronisod his support. Shortly afterwards Dr. Frrnz Froohllch did, in fact, obtain a permanent post at tho Instituto of Aviation Kodiclno inFroiburg." I would liko to add ayself that that is Profossor Buechner's insti¬ tuto. I should liko to cuoto tho final paregraph of this docunont: “For his fairness in scientific natters, too, Dr. Beckcr-Froyeong deserves ny highost ostoen. Eo never aonopolizod an idea or a rosult as so frequently haunens. I an in e position to Judgo this osoccially voll as we worked for years on the sane subject." _ — Tho noxt docunont I should like to offor is 3ockcr-Froyoeng 58, which you will find on page 228 of the docunent book, and I will give it exhibit No. 41. It is an affidavit froc Dr. Linda Vunderlich in Stutt¬ gart, datod the 21st of December, 1946. I should like to briofly state that Mrs. Wunderlich was a colleague and physician together with Dr. . Beckor-Frcysong at the Robert Koch Hospital in Berlin which ^s under Professor Dr. Daunich's control, who too has already given an affidavit on Dr. Becker-Freyseng's behalf. I would like to ouotc fron approxi- aetoly the niddle of the docunont: "It struck ne especially that Dr. Becker-Freyseng had nuch synpnthy 3300 Court So. 1 29 May 47-M-10-&-EEX-£errov (Frank) vith the patleata and always ahowed deep understanding, even towarda the aoat difficult ones. He did cot indulge in conversations of a political nature and so I do not know whether he belonged to a:$* organization of the SSDAP. I never say Dr. Becker-Freyseag in unlforn either." In order to elucldato, I should like to state that, of course, the witness is thinking of a Party unifora and not the Gernan arced forces unifora. I continue ay quotation: "Iron his conversations on setters of cedical ethics it was apoarent that his ideas were not influenced by tho Hational Socialist conceptions of aedicine." Then follows the cuetocary signature and certificate. The next docuaent I should like to offer is Secker-Jreyseng No. 59 which is on page 230 of tho docuaent book and which I will give tho Exhibit No. 42. It is an affidavit froc Dr. Hans Denser of Alboun/ Sauorlond, dated the 2Srd of January, 1947. Dr. Donzor describes first of all, aftor tho custooary introduction, what his activities were and he soys that since tho 4th of January, 1946, he has boon the head of the Reich Institute for Fishing, Director of tho leeching and Research Institute for Trout Breeding ard of the institute for Fishing Drainago in Albaun/Sauerland. He states that tho British Military Govorncont had confirncd his in this position. Under the following flguro 1 the wit¬ ness statos: "Since 1940 the Medical Inspectorate of the Luftwaffe continuously sent so research tacks concerned with 1 corporative physiological high altitude erperinents on an l cals. 1 During these investigations I intro¬ duced now ways and rears of exocrinerting on anlrale which had been reported to the public as veil, o.g., In the Periodical for Aviation ‘ledicine and the Clinical Weekly, Voluae 21, page 126, 1942. Thoso oxoorinents were to serve general physiological knowledge and had there¬ fore no direct rilltary-econocic purpose. I sent the rice which I had inbred especially for the purpose to nur^rous institutes and scientists. Court So. 1 25 May 47-H-lG-6-Za(-Xarrov (Track) "2. Dr. Becker-Treyseng has supported oe since 1941 as Assistant Specialist (Eilfsreferent) and free 1944 as a specialist for aviation cedicine in nunerous cases." Shea I'll just briefly explain the other points. Ke says that Dr. Becker-Freyseng helped bin to get test aninals and the witnese draws your attention to the fact that rabbits were supplied by Dr. Suchalla to Dr. 3ecker-Treyseng vfco is the sane nan who has already testified regarding the use of rabbits for exoerinental ourposes and has alroady given that affidavit. Under paragraph b the witness states that Dr, Beckor-Treysong was always interested in anlaal expericents and several tiaos aade sugges¬ tions during conversations. I should like to quote froa paragraph c: "Dr. Bocker-Treyscng has carried out auaerous exporloonts on ani- aals. During recent years he frequently coaplnlnod to ao that his dutios with the Medical Inspectorate wero robbing hla noro and aoro of tho possibility of pursuing his own exporicontal rosoorch work on anl- aals." Tho final paragraph describes aeroly Dr. Bockor-Treyscng's attitudo. I should like to givo a very brief ouotation froa figure 4: "I do not know whether Dr. Becker-Freysong was a aeobor of tho SSDAP. He has never shovn any attitude which could indicate sympathy with the Party, ^e also criticized soveral tiaes the aethods of tho Party in the presence of cany colleagues. I nysolf have never boon a oosbor of tho SSDAP and have never belonged to any branch of it." Then follows tho elgnaturo end certificate. 8302 29 May-n-5L-ll-l-Goldberg (Int. Fr-nk) Court No. 1, Case 1 The next document .f this bock I cannot yet offer, Mr. Pre¬ sident. It de=ls with human experiments and must, therefore, bo submitted at a later stage. New, Hr. President, we are faced v/ith a difficulty. I had already had the h-n-r to discuss this with you yesterday, end it is that Document Beck Nc. 4 has been landed in for translation by us a 1-ng time ago and I had been promised that it w.aid be- ready for the second half of this oerning's session. I do n.t know whether the General-Secretary has been able to obtain this bock during the recess or whether the Tribunal has it on h^nd. I 6huuld like, .f course, to submit those very few do¬ cuments from IXcun^nt Ecck Nc. 4. I think there aron't mere than two. I should liko to submit them now. But due to the orders _f this Tribunal I can cnly dc sc if the translation is available alr.ady. THS PRESIDENT : , v t this time the document books have not been furnished to the Tribunal. 1ER. HARDY ; What document numbers is counsel referring to ? I have some from Document 3ock Wo. 4. Inc. rRbblifcnS . The Tribunal has some odd documents from Book No. 4. LIR. H.kHDY ; I have No. 62 and a copy of this was given to me by :ir. Travis. DR. TIPI ; I can dear this up, Ur, President. Two do¬ cuments of cur Document Ecck He. 4 I h-vo given exhibit num¬ bers ar.d they have been introduced. That is Becker-Freyscng Nc. 64, which is an affidavit from Dr. K~ns Schaefer. That is E xh i bit No. 7 and the Document Beck cr-Freyscng 61 which is Exhibit Nc. 2C. It is. Dr. Harry SUchella's affidavit. The translating Branch has beer, kind enough, the other 2S lhy-::-?L-ll-2-Goldberg (Int. Frank) Ccurt Nc. 1, Case 1 dey, tc place at ay disposal the translation cf these two documents and the document which I would like to read now frea Document Book 4 is No. 62 — I beg your pardon — I should correct ayself -- No. 63, the affidavit of Ufred Christensen. I don't know whether the Tribunal or prosecu¬ tion have had a translation of that. THE PRESIDENT : The Tribunal has available Becker- Freyacn# Documents 62 and 63 . 63 scene to be the affidavit of Christensen. • 5 HARDY ; I have both of then too, ycur Honor# UR. TIPI : In that case, Mr. President, I should like tc continue with Bcckcr-FTcyscng Document 63. I should like tc deal with the affidavit cf Mr. Brigitte Crodcl dated 1? of .'.pril and jut a question with reference to that. Scao considerable tine ago I had sent — TIi£ PRESIDENT ; What nuaber do you offer as Becker- Brv,yscng Document 63 ? Is that the document you are offering now ? D3. TIPP : Just one second, please, Mr. Presidentf I on told just now that this is ^cing to be Document No. 43. Now, Document No. 63 I should like to offer as Becker-Froy- seng Exhibit Nc. 43 and your question — THE PRESIDENT ; Ycur document is He. 63 D3. TIPP ; No. 63 rnd it will get Exhibit No. 43. It is on page 335 cf the Document Book. First of all I should like tc say that the author cf this affidavit is Alfred Christen¬ sen. ./ell, then, Document 63, Exhibit 43, on Page 335 of the Document beck, is an affidavit cf .J.fred Christensen and I would like to add that this is the Christenson often mention¬ ed during the Scawa.ter case who has signed a statement dated 29 licy-I'-FL-ll -3-Gcldberg (Int. Frank) Court Ho. 1, Case 1 the 19th end 20th of I!ay, and I should like tc quota from II: "With regard to myself I declare ; 1. ) Trained and worked as Engineer. 2. ) Worked with the Luftwaffe, was a Group Leac’-or du¬ ring the v/ar and later Section Chief in the Tech¬ nical Office. III. To Document No. NO-177, Prosecution Exhibit No. 133, shown tc me by Dr. H‘nns !!arx, Attomcy-at-low, containing transcript of 2 aectings held in the Technical Office cf the Hoich Air Ministry, Berlin, on the 19 and 20 May 1944, I state os follows : 1. ) In the photostat of this dccunent I acknowledge and recognize the signature as being nine. 2. ) The transcribed report on the meeting held cn 19 and 20 liny 1944 was n_t made from shorthand notes or any other written remarks on the result of the discus¬ sions. Neither was there any resolution accepted by all present at the noeting and passed according tc the wording or the sense which cculd serve os a basis. The report was furthermore net sent to. the other de¬ partments which had token part in the .meeting for co¬ signature end consequently fer expressing their agree¬ ment cr disagreement '’nd fot* stating their objections, before it vr-s sent off. • 3. ) The report was only made 2 cr 3 cays rftcr the mee¬ tings from ma^ry by zy Referent, Staff Engineer Schi- * cl'.lcr, and I signed it without checking it thoroughly. IIr. Schickl.r was a Dr. Ing and had no medic-'* 1 knowledge or experience, just as I cysolf had ncr.c .t the utmost th* report noy therefore only be considered unofficial as a randan cf the Technical Office for the files 29 L£y-:i-FL-ll-4-Goldberg (Int. FT*nk) Court lie, 1, Case 1 or for other offices. IV. A8 to the contents cf the report and the progress of the discussion on the 19 end 20 Hoy 1944, I declare the fol¬ lowing : 1.) 3y virtue of the tests already carried out in Vienna by Dr. vcr. Syrany with Berkatit, the opinion given by Professor Sppingcr cf Vienna, as well as by vir¬ tue cf the fav-rable raw materiel and manufacturing situation with regard to Bcrkatit, the Technical Office of the Reich -»ir Ministry was determined to introduce Ecrkatit. In this respect ay department has already settled this with the German Navy and the S3. !iy cc-workors w c re of the impression that Dr. Bccfcor-Frcyseng was p.rhaps materially interest¬ ed in Vofetit and consequently opposed to Bcrkatit. .it the meeting on 19 .»pril"-- and I should like to c.rrect this, 'It. President. Of course, it should acan 19 of '.'Ay, a nd I should like to add th^t in the original the date is the 19 of Hay. "At the aoeting cn 19 :ipy Major Jcworeck therefore at¬ tacked Dr. Beckcr-Frcysong personally. It w^s only due to ay interference that Dr. Becker-Freyseng did not leave the seating together with Dr. Schaefer. There were, however, no grounds for suspicion or even proofs regarding Dr. Bcckor-Frcyreng cr Dr. Schaefer. 2.) '/c had informed the Navy and SS that the introduction of Bcrkatit was paracticolly certain , the letter was ccaposed with a view to covering us airinst the objec¬ tions code by the Chief cf theLuftwnffo, -'edicrl Ser¬ vice tc Berkatit. In ay cpinion therefore, the medical objections arc exa - crated *>nd represent ■> biassed 3306 29 Iday-:I-FL-U-5-Gc Idberg (Int. Frank) Ccurt So. 1, Case 1 emphasis cf seme remarks, while leaving ethers out. 3. ) This refers in particular to the remark made by Dr. 3eckor-?rcyseng about the consequences cf thirst. At the tine, Dr. Becker-Frey seng mentioned that with one disease, I believe it w?.s cholora, the patient dies frem lack of water. His description cf the convulsions and hallucinations referred to this. He then also re¬ ferred to a case free thw series cf tests by Dr. ven . Sirany, who had lost n great deal cf water j Dr. Becker Frcyseng remarked that if this lack of water continued it could lead to disturbances after a few days and af¬ ter about 12 days depth oight occur. 4. ) The decision to have r. detailed plan for the expe-riaents, as set down in the transcript vr.s deferred cn the 19 and 20 :day 1944 in the presence cf Professor Eppinger." Might I correct this, !lr. President ? Unfortunately we received the dccunent so late that the copy couldn't be checked. There is a copy .mistake v/hich disturbs the conti¬ nuity. I aa not sure whether it expresses it in English. In orckr to clear this up and recti fy the record, I should like to road the sentence under 4 from the beginning such as is contained in the original document : "A detailed plan fer the experiments such as is set dexn in the transcript vns not made cn the 19 and 20 cf ‘lay 1944, but wrs deli¬ berately deferred to the meeting cn the 25 which was to take place in the presence cf Professor Eppinger." I should like to c ntir.ue quotin' fron this document : "Cn the 19 and 20 cf :Pay 1944 only the necessity of further experiments was discussed »nd genor^lly referred to. Dr. Becker-Freyseng then immediately h~d serious drutts n s t: the possibility cf carrying cut these tests in a. hospi¬ tal or institute in the required manner, since the sur.mer 8307 29 rfey-:;-FL-ll-6-Gcldberx (Int. Frank) Court KO. 1, C&se 1 cf 1&54 there were neither sufficient pers.ns for experi¬ menting en ncr suitable space available. In -'newer to a di¬ rect question put by -no of the ether perse ns present at the meeting, whose name I cannot remember, s to the possi¬ bility of txperiaents on convicts, Dr. Bccker-Frcyscng re¬ plied that he thcu~ht it possible that prisoners would come forward voluntarily for this experiment, which wrs net dnn- joreus, an- that he v. -uld m-Jcc the necessary inquiries about this thrcu h his office." 29 Uay-IS-H3-12-l-Samp6on (Int. Frank) Court No. I. But the reason for this was pot the likely danger, but the abovo-nontion- ed organizational difficulties in tho organization. "5. ) Dofinito decisions were not taken at tho roe tings of 19 & 20 Hay 19UU, but were reserved for tho discussion on 25 Nay 19UU. Neither could a resolution bo passed about tho oxporircntal station at Dachau, as there was no representative of tho SS or tho police present, the authorities responsible for tho concentration canpe. Therefore, thoro nust bo a niaundorstanling on tho part of ray "Referent", which I unfort¬ unately overlooked before appending ny signature. Dachau can only have been mentioned in connection with laboratories, in caso prisoners wiro used as experimental subjects. I also bolievo that for roasons of air protection tho concentration caap Dachau was referrod to, since it was go rurally known that no air attack was ovor nado on this canp. "6. ) But I do know, however, that later on tho oxForinonts wero actu¬ ally carriod out at Dachau and that staff onginoor Borkn hirsolf was at Dachau. Having boon told by hin that tho oxporinsntal subjocts wero volunteers who had core forward on tho proaiso of hotter food boforo and after tho oxporirent and a special ration of cigarettes and that nothing could happen during tho oxporinonts, I regarded the so oxpori- nonts as entirely admissible. "7. ) Sono tino after despatching this roport, n and I should liko to say, Mr. President, that the roport referred to is tho mooting of tho 19 th and 20th, ard I continue my quotation now. "a cxinbor of the chief of tho nodical offico rang up ny depart¬ ment and pointed out several orrors in tho roport. As, however, in tho re entire tho mooting of 25 Iky 19UU had boon hold at which I was not present, whereby this report was superseded, the matter was con¬ sidered closed. D 8.) Tho meetings of 19 4 2) Hay 19l*U took place at tho instigation of the Technical Offico and under ay supervision. "9.) Tho Technical Office alone was responsible for passing prepara¬ tions for airplane equipx-nt fit for use, to which also the moans for 29 lfcy-li-4«2-12-2-S2=pson (Int. Frank) Court No. X* tasking saltwater potable belonged. The other offices, as for instanco the radical chief of the Luftwaffo, rarely had the right of veto." Tho docuaont is signed on tho 16th April, 19U7, and it has tho certificate, signed by an alliod officer fron the Adninistration Of¬ fice of Civilian Interment Canp No. 6 Neucngamc. In connection with this Docunont Book No. IV, I should like to ask a question, Mr. Pres¬ ident. Sono considerable tino ago I handed an interrogatory to tho Secretary General, addressed to tho witness Brigitto Crodol. This wit¬ ness had boon granted for tho defendants Schroodor and Bockor-Froysong, but sho info mod no that tho Soviot Military Coaaandant had prohibited her fron leaving Borlin. Up to now I haven't had a reply fron tho Socrotary Gonoral's office as to whothor tho interrogatory has boon ro- coivod and rotumod. Such parts as I introduced in that document book arc tto sane quostiono which this witness has rocoivod through to this Tribunal, and I sont ray questionnaire through the ordinary mil in ordor to achieve that sore statonont free that witnoss my bo obtninod. Howovor, I don't want to introduco this roport today. Profossor Haagon is now avnilablo as a witnoss and ho will bo testifying boforo this high Tribunal. Thoroforo, I consider it advisablo that tho questions which aro connoctod with tho typhus oaso, and that includos tho affid¬ avit fron Crodol, should be offorod in this connoction in order to procorvo continuity. But I do want to say, ifr. FTosidont, that as far os I know, it is within tho ruling of this Tribunal that if an inter¬ rogatory fron a witnoss is handod in, cross questions as desirable for tho IVosocution should be cade available to tho Defense so that re¬ direct quastions can bo added. So far I haven't soon tho cross exam¬ ining interrogatory, ard, thoroforo, I do not know whether tho Prosec¬ ution proposes to or has put such cross examination questions, and nay bo Hr. Hardy will be obliging enough to give us sooo information on the question. HR. HARDY: I have not cone up hero for that purpose. Your Honor, and I don't particulary know what he is referring to as cross 8310 29 !£vy-^MS-12-3-Sa=pson (int. Frank) Court No. I. interrogator/ and rc-direct intcrrogatcry; it is conplotely strange and foreign to no, and I an afraid I will have to bo briefed on it further before I corrent on it. However, I Tould like to ask in con¬ nection with Doc men t No. 63, the affidavit of Aifrod Christensen, to ascertain free Defense Counsol the address and location of Alfred Christenson* THE HlESIDSNTi Can the Dofonso Counsel furnish that inforaation to the Prosocution? DR. T1PP: Yos, I would lovo to, lir • President. Tho affidavit itself shows it, nocoly, ho is at tho Civilian Intomnont Cnnp No. 6, at Nouongasro. That is in tho British zono, so that in this case tho witnoss is quite oasily accossiblo. And now tho second quostion, !Jr* Prosidont, regarding tho interrogatory of tho witnoss Crodol. I gathered !!r. Hardy is unablo to cloar up now tho quostion, and I will try to do so during tho rocoss; and I will be ablo aftor tho rocoss to subnit tho ronaining docuccnts fron Docuaont book, Bockor-Frcysong V, and I think that on Itonday ono hour will suffico to subnit tho ronain- ing docunonts, and I would suggost that wo rocoss now bocauso at tho nocont I Just sinply havon't got any translated docunonts I could sub¬ nit* Tf£ FRESIDEOT: As stated yesterday, when tho Tribunal takes its rocoss this noon, it will rocoss until Monday noming at 9:30, and at that tine we hope tho rost of tho docunonts itill bo in ordor to bo prosontod. As there is nothing furthor to jrosent to tho Tribunal at this tine, tho Tribunal will be in recess until 9:30 o'clock lionday norniW. (Tho TrttW rt i adjourned until Juno 2, 19li7, at 0930 hours. )• *311 Court So. 1 2 Jun 47-K-l-l-EEH-Karrcv (Von Schon) Official Transcript of the Aaerican Kllitary Tribunal in the natter of the United States of Aaerica against Karl Brandt, et al, defendants, sitting at Suernberg, Gem any, on 2 June 1947, 0930, Justice Beals presiding. TEX MARSHAL: Persons in the courtroco vill please find their seats. The Honorable, the Judges of Kllitary Trilxinal I. Military Tribunal I is nov in session. God save the Unitod States of Aaerica and this hon¬ orable Tribunal. There vill be order in the courtrooo. THE P3ZSIDEHT: Mr. Marshal, vill you ascertain if the defendants are all present in court. TEE MARSHAL: Kay it please Your Honor, all defendants are present in the courtroc*. THE PRESIDEHT: Tho Secretary General vill noto for tho record the presonce of all tho defendants in court. Counsel say proceed. IS. TIP? (Dofenso counsel for tho defendant Beckor-Freysong): Hr. Prosldent, last Thursday I stopoed with Beckcr-Froyseng Docunont 63, Exhibit 43, an affidavit by Alfrod Christensen, dated 16 April 1947. Tho rost of tho docuaents free Docunent Book 4 I should like to offer In connection vith the oxoalnation of the vitnese Haagen. There is an affidavit by Kiss Crodel, Mr. Haagen's associate, and I believe thie docunont vould be bettor outfitted at that tine than nov. I should like to continuo today vith Docunent Book Ho. 5 vhich has bcon distributed to the Tribunal today. Tho first docunent vhich I should liko to offer froa this docunent book ie Bcckcr-Froyseng Docunont Ho. 66, vhich is on page 344. I give it Exhibit So. 44. It is a supple- aent_tO--thfiaffidovit of Christensen vhich I havo Just nentioned, an affVdartt'by the sane Alfred Christensen, dated 6 Kay 1947. I shall ’ o 72, all deal with tho re¬ search assignments issued by tho Aviatl-n Ministry or the Medical Inspectorate to varl-us scientists. All the witnesses wh- have test¬ ified horo received such asalgnacnts ar.<* Break av^ut the c-nditi'no in tho dcrarticnt, the check cade 'f the aeulgnncnts and speak aVut tho conditions in the department, the check -ado rf tho assignasnto, otc. Tho next drevnent which I offer is Docuncnt 67 on pago 352, which I five the Exhibit Ho. *6, jvuro 1 of the English. Thcro is an nffadarit by the Professor In tho Medical Clinic at Erlangen datod April 2^, 19^7, Dr. Karl Matthcs. Tho wltneso says *n page li ■On 14 Kay 1942 I received an ordor fr--n tho Inopoct'-r of tho Luftwaffe Kodical Corps to conduct a scientific Investigation of tho following problcns 'Tho action of carbonic acid on the paradoxical of oxy*on following acute oxygen deficiency.' Sec supplcnont for copy of this ordcrl "I ga also enclosing 1 copy of an~thor research order issued by the Medical Inspectorate on 13 August 1942, directed to Prcf. Buerger, dlrcct-r -f the Leipzig University Medical Clinic. I was head physician at the Leipzig Medical Clinic. I head physician at tho Leipzig Med.icnl Clinic zycelf at that tine and had w-rkod in that Institute since 1930. At *-rcsert, I a.- director rf the Erlangen Uni¬ versity Medical Clinic." 6317 2 June £7JC-TjC_2_2-Pri=e«u (int., vonSchon) Court I In the next paragraph the witness says: "The ca'-se for =y reeelvli^r this order can he traced back to a discussion I hurt In tho spring cf 1942 with Professor Anthony who vp a then a specialist for tho Medical Inspectorate.* He says then that he had been for soao tine boon dealing with the subject of this osslrnnent ond he also soys that the Medical Inspect~rate supported science In every way. MR. HARDY: Hay it ploeae lour Honor, attached to this affida¬ vit arc tv- suppleocnts — that Is, two original C-oraan doeuaonte — one dated August 1942 and the other cnc May 1942, originating fron tho offlco of the Beferat for Aviation Modlclno. I night ask rtofoneo coun¬ sel whothor or n-t he Intends to substantiate those documents — that Is, certify the authenticity thereof. IE. TIPP: Certainly, In his affidavit tho vltnoss rofore t" those two docunente and srys that they are included In his affadavit. I believe that th-t institutes the proof which Mr. Hardy wants. MB. HARDY: !>-os ho state that theso d^cunonta are truo copios of tho original In his affadavit? IR. TIFF: Yob. Yes, ho does. MR. HARDY: I won't object your Honor, but I think It lo rather an unusual procedure and I will not objoct without projudlco to the richt -f the prosecution to objoct to docunonts of this type that nay bo ontersd In the future. TKB FR1GIHUT: I win ask defense counsol if tho original documents are attached to the original of this witness. MB. HaBDY: The original affidavit is hero, your Honor, and he merely has copies of the documents. He does net have tho original documents attached theroto. DB. TIPP: The original docuaents, M r . President, are of course not in the p-ssessicn of the witness. As was custoaary, tho witness aade a copy at that tlr.e and attached it to his affadavit. He certified the correctness of these crplee under oath. If Mr. Hardy has 8318 2 June 47-MJJC_2_3-Prineau (In*.., vrnSch'n) Court I any objections, it Is, of course, possible for ae to send these dccu- aents back to tho witness who lo living in Erlangen and infora hln to cortify expressly that these arc true copies, but I believe it is su¬ fficient in his affadavit ho refers to then end thus certifies that the copies ere corroct; but if the Tribunal wishos it I will be rlr.d t« send these tv- copies back to Professor Matthes f'r a certificrto. TiS niSHDIi The first copy referred tr is apparently a letter written b 7 tho inspector of the Luftvnffo Medical Corps to Dr. Buerger. TR. TIPP: Yes, Mr. Prosidont, and I eh-uld like to point out that I have Just said that the witnews says on page 1 of hlo affadavits “I an also oncl-sity 1 c-py of anrthor resoardh order issued by the Medical Inspect-rate on 13 Aurust 1942, directed to Professor Buorgor, director of tho Leipzig University M 0 dical Clinic. I was hond physi¬ cian at tho Leipzig Medical Clinic cyself at that tlno and had vorkod in that institute since 1930." Tho witness very dofinitoly refore to those suppleacntary d-cuncnts in his affadavit. THfc PRiSIDLNT: Bros tho witness stato in his affadavit that ho hlasolf aade a copy of this lottor whon it was rocolvod? I havon’t had tiao to rend the witness's affadavit in full. IP.. TIPP: The witness d-os at say in his affavit how ho pre¬ pared tho copy. Ho ncroly encloses it and aakes it a r«rt of his nffa- davit. 7HL PRSSIIErr: I think a.t least there should be sono state¬ ment fr-a tho witness that ho made c-ntcaporano-us copies froa tho orlrln"l docuacrt when it was received, that ho v*e not ou-tinr it fron nea-ry. Thero is n-thing hore that acc~unts for the absonco of the -ririnal d'eunent. Thcro should be a rather corplete statement concern¬ ing that bef-ro It should *e offered. IE. TIPP: Yes, M r . President. Then I shall not subait this d-cuaent t-day. I shall wait until the vltnoss Haafem i6 hero. 2 June 47-K-JJC. 2 4- P riseau (Int., vcnSchon) C'urt I TEE FEXSIHS?: I would iQfmit that the docuaent he subnittcd provisionally and subject to Inter clarification on thl« natter. !B. "IP?: Hr. President, nay I renark that if I offer it today the criminal will he in the possession of the General Socrotaxy and I win have te have a ruling fr«a the Tribunal to get it back % fron hin. The stalest thing for me, I think, would be frr no to withdraw it today and offer it again in the Haqgen case. THE pPiSIEldT: 7ery well. Follow that procedure. IE. TIPP: Then I shall go on to tho next docuncnt, H r . Pre¬ sident. This Is an affadavit by Froiherr von Eonbcrg. This is Bockor- Xroysing's IhcuMnt Ho. 68 on pa po 360 of tho docuncnt book. I shall glvo it Exhibit nuaber 46. It is an affadavit by Froiherr von Boaborg 25 April 1947. Xros this docunont I should like to quoto only a few oxcerpts and explain tho contonto briofly. Tho witnooo on pago 1 describes hio activity in tho flold of bio—physics and ho says that toward tho end of tho w*r there wero difficulties In carrying out this w«rk to such an ex’ont that tho was obliged to got aid froa tho authori¬ ties, which aid was rlvon hin through the go~d offlees of Profoosor Strurh"ld, Hodical Inspectorate of tho Luftwaffo in the forn of a re¬ search assignment. This witness says: "I encloso a copy of -tho resonreh assignnent riving all the dotalls* and ho continues: "Through this rcoonrch assignnent I was in no way subordinated to tho Hodical Ins¬ pectorate in a military sense. However, I hnvo never sLsuaed that fron a scientific vlcw-p-int this carrcid with it the duty or tho right to control and eurervise ry activities. Moreover, this 1 b not at ell the practise either, because the object rf riving a research • assignnent has always been to entrust the assignnent to a roeenreh worker wfa-se nase guarantees that the work will be done in a strictly scientific Banner and any specialist would nest emphatically reject intervention fr = n-'r—professional quarters, be they ever so highly piece. Consequently, the Medical Inspectorate has never exerted any influence in this respect." 3320 2 June 47-X-J*C - 2-5-Pri=emj (Int», vonSchon) Court I la this respect I shall skip the next sentence and shall qnrte fro- the next paragraph! 'in viev of the fact that a research •ssirnaent also carries financial support. It was only natural that this authority requestod to he kept informed on tho progress of tho work as well to be plvon an account of the nonay used. These reports, however, were rendered only at rather lone lntorvais and only ns a sunnary." Tho witness says he had the i-yrcsslon that the rosonrch assignment was ^onerously Fiver. fron n purely scientific interest and with full confidence in the research workers. The rest of tho docu¬ ment I shall not quota. Tho cnclosuro, Mr. Prcsidant, is a typical rcsoarch assi/m- nent. The witnoss in his affadavit has cortificd that it is a true copy and X, therefore, believe thcro can bo no objection to tho sub¬ files ion of this docuacnt. MR. HAHDY: Y-ur Hon'-r, this attachment of tho -'riplnnl Ger¬ man docunent brings up the sane situation n in the Inst do canon t t*at was offored. It is ncroly a typewritten copy and isn't substan¬ tiated t« the derroo I think it necessary to bo substantiated for this Tribunal. I night surest tho sano couroo bo tnkon with thio document, that tho dofonso obtain proper certification in introduce tho original GcraAn docuacnts. It noo=a to ac tho Tribunal should bo a llttlo bit srro striegont about having then duly authonticatod — that is, as opposed to bavin* nffaditvits notarized. T^ls document purports to be n i original Goman document but, like the othcro is ncrcly a typewritten ©py with an cortificato thereon. X night ask the Secretary to pass up the- copy sr the Tribunal nay peruse it. I i M 3321 2Jun^- JWss (Tea Scaon) Court 1 TH3 P52SX32*T: I win ask dofcase counsel, this docuaeat, if I «c looking at the correct document, was a letter written to the af¬ fiant Rcnberg, Is that correct? 33. .'TIP?: Tes, The witness In his affidavit In the last sen¬ tence says and I Quote: "I state again that the enclosed research order corresponds to the research order actually given to no and that it is therefore ’lurt of the affidavit." I believe that would bo suf¬ ficient authentication in this caeo. TH3 P23SI33ST: Voll, if the original lotter was sont to tho xdt- ncso ho should huvo tho original lotter, if it ceco to hia. Undor tho olrouust.pxcas tho original lottor was written is noithor proved and he ncy or nay not have it but if tho lottor was vritton to hin ho ohould have it—this original lotter should bo in his filo and ho could eubuit tho original lottor with his affidavit. 3?, TIPPi Yos, your Honor, but it is an oxporionco which wo havo had rtnoctodly that old gontlccux>- Profoosor von Rcnborg is an old scientist -aro voxy roluctont to glvo up thoir original docunonts. If tho Tribunal ballovos that original rosoarch aoslgnnont should bo cd- nittod I will try to got it free Raiborg and to outfit it. 'iaS ??j&I3BoT: Voll, if he has the original docunont ho could havo a cortifiod copy node .-aid tho original docuaont bo roturnod to hin. ii?, KoRDIs This is a natter the Prosecution docas uost inportent. 33, TIP?: Tory woll. I shall try to got tho original frea Kr. von Bart art end prosent it as tho Tribunal has Just suggostod. TE3 PB3SI3E-T: You can toll 3r. Baibor L . that his docuaont will not oc taken free hia but if ho would loan this so a cortifiod copy could bo undo and certified by tho Secret ry General, to bo a truo copy, that would be sufficient- th^t copy would bo received aid ho ori¬ ginal returned to hin. 33. 21??: Yes, your Honor. tho document 2 should like to offer is Pocuacat 69, page 2-., 8322 2 Juno-iHU—3-2-Gross (Yon Schon) Court 1 the exhibit no. Is 47. It is en affidavit of Profossor Eaas Hettor. s: gmsipan?: Counsol, you n^ricod the last Olhibit by Hcc'oorg as 2 Mbit 46? Da. 21??: Tot, 46, that was doeuncnt 68. How the next doeuncnt id Document 69. ?=? PRDSIDEyT: Bat tho docunont of Dr. Rcubcrg will bo adult tod provisionally ia so f r as it refers to this lottcr which ho rocoivod. DR 21??: as I said tho noxt docuucat io an affidavit of Prof. Hans Hottor, datod 25 ^ril 1947. Shis witaoss again describe* hio carroor and ooys that ho rocoivod a resoarch aosignnont frcu tho Luft- weffo 19 ilovenbor 1942. Ho goos on to say that tho distribution of re¬ search assignments was very goncrous, that his aoslgruont constitutod priunrily a scientific work. I do not intond to quoto any furthor frai this doc'V.ont. The noxt document io an affidavit of Dr. idchholtt in Hoidolborg d .tod 28 ipril 1947. *hio docuuont no. 70 which I ohould liko to offor as orfilbit Ho. 48. On pngo ono of the docunont undor r2 tho witnooo scys and I quoioj "about 1942 I rocoivod an order, datod 3 Doc crib or 1941., Silo Hoi L in 14,55 Hr. 46 007/41 (2 II 3 ) "Influonco on altitudo Tolornnco by Chaiical k oans". Tho research ordor was lntor handled by tho aviation Bcsoarch, Hoidclbcrg, end was not concludod. 3. ) Tho ordor was not given by the Kodied Inspoctorato, it ori¬ ginated on tho contrary, frea oursolvos; a third party was not in¬ volved.* I -o on to Ho. 4, on tho noxt pogo. I quoto: 4.) I askod for this cssigoiont for difforent reasons to rocoivo this ordor. Ky uoin • aitivo that I wuntod to project tho employees of tho Instituto as long o.s possible frtxi being cdlod up. It concornod oxperts who could not have boon replaced. Therefore, tho plocasont of tho order, its occcptnnco end perforcanco -as in tho interest of thco Instituto, end only in the second instance in tho intoecsts of tho *odical Inspector- 8323 2 Juao4»-iU—5-3-Grcss (Von Schcn) Court 1 ato, which garo the ordor. It was cxproscly state* that this roooorch order conccrnod a so-cdled fund am ental research." I shall ship do. 6 or at least no. 6. On pag.0 3 of tho document at tho top I quoto: ■ I never noticod that thoro was any thorough control, e xam ination of tho protocols, or, oven iatcrforonco in ro- spoct of tho sotting up of tho oxd or in onto. I nlvcys gavo Dr. 3ockoi'- Troygonfc tho opportunity to got in touch with tho experts, but horo also I aovor noticed th„t uoro than gcnoral scientific intorcst was shown. ■7.) Tho reports wore sutnittod in tho fora of short, scientific reports. 2 io reports novor contained any dot dls about tho axporiuants." Tho rost of He. 7 and He. 1 I roecc;:end to tho attention of tho Tribunal . a*. I shall quoto Ho. 9j * I oennot laagino at all that a ropresontativo of tho Kodlool Inspectorate could h..vo givon uo any instructions in such a special tonical quostion concerning tho Carrying out of tho ordor for rosoarch.* *hoa tho witness doscribos wh .t support ho got free tho Hodic.'l Inspoctor-tc and I should liko to quote ono gontonco freu this paragrrsjh at tho bottom of tho pogos ■Thoro uoro novor negotiations about tho control or suparbinion of tho rosoarch ordor; this would also have b~cn quite unusual." I do not wont to quoto any noro free this docusont. I uoroly rof-r to tho fact in Ho. 10 - tho witnoss says control could havo boon exercised by a spccialish, that is a r>hamacologiot - no ordinary ucdl- cnl officer. It boars tho signature of tho vitnose and was notarixod by a Hotary Public in 3eidclborg on 2 Hay 1947. Then thcro is attached \o this document o copy of on accounting If Ur. Hardy has an objoctioa to a;- submitting this copy I shall '-lth- drr.v this part of the document. I do not attach any great value to it. I attache it uerdy becauso the witness refers to this attnehaont in his docuaont. 113. IhJJJT: I have no objoction, your honors, to the admission of 2 J—j-Gross (Von Scion) Court 1 the attachment but unfortunetcly I do not hcvoa copy of the attach¬ ment, 2S PPJiSIDIL'T: There is no copy of tho accounting in tho Document Bcoi beforo no. DR. TIPPS: Tkon I shall withdraw it, Hr. Protident. DR. -I??S: The next document is Ho,71, on pago 32, tho exhibit will bo 49, This is un affidavit by Uaivorsity Profossor Dr. Hubort Mooisen, of tho 29 ^>ril 1947, This affidavit doscriboa how ho got a rosoarch assignment free tho Medical Inspootorato. says in parogrt®h ono, 2 sontoncoa after tho boglanlagi ■This rosoorch ordor consisted of a puroly financial support of tho furthor work on o subjoct tfclch I had already begun in 1936," Thor, tho witnoos doocribos how this osoigroont was isauod. I eon ■kip this part, Tho witnoss continues: ■ I never rocoivod any i»- st rue lions no to tho nannor in which my order should bo carriod out, fr.o resonreh subsidy corresponded ontiroly with tho assistance given by sciontific organisations or pharmaceutic-1 lndustrios.* Tho rost I roconr.cnd to the attontlon of tho Tribunal. Tho next document is Ho. 72 on pago 375. I assign to it Inhibit Ho, 50. It is on fiffidavit freu Physiological Chaiicol Institute Irolburg dated 2 «cy 19*1? Profossor Joseph Kapfh;muor. Ho also had an r.soij^iont free tho Medical Inspectorate. Ho guys thut unfor¬ tunately ho cannot givo any exact dates bocausc all his records woro destroyed during the Var. I shall quoto free it, tho last paragraph on tho first pagos ■I obtained tho research ossigrnent through tho kind ncdlation of my colleague Prof. Ducchncr, who, -t th„t tine was in chargo of tho Medical Research Institute for aviation in Proiburg. The theme orgi- nntod solely free my own sug. Ration, as I bud worked in this very field of aotabolism of tho liver for years." Shcn the witness says that he had worked on this field years before that end that he was not r.eroly working for the Medici Inspec¬ torate but was working in the interest of scicnco in general. In tho 2 Jun»-K—lU-3-&-Gro bb (You Schoa) Court 1 2 nd par.-grcoh oa the second p^o cf tko document I should liicc to quotoi ■I was ia ao way subordinated to tho Medic i Inspector ito by re¬ ceiving this ossigreont. Oa the contrary, I bed cccploto frcodcu of action; I was air/or given orders with regard to tho progroso of ny work. Eo oao over chocked the work I had done. I was rostrictod in ono point only; I was to sulci t intermediate reports evorythroo nonths but I troated this point so liberally that I dalivorod a short report concerning tho st^to of ay rcsoorch work only 10 -12 nonths at tho cost.■ I oaa skip tho next fov soatoaccs and I quatot ■Thus, tho Medical Inspoctorato did not oxort any prossuro what- soovor with rogard to tho rosocrch assignment so that I was ablo to work ceuplotoly unrostrainod and without being choakod in any way.* Tho docmcnt is signed 3 Key 19*i7 by a notary in Troiburg i/ Broisgnn. 2 Jun-IW 5—ii-i-Haloy (Int. Von Schoen) Court No* I. DR. TIP?: The next two docurents. Hr* President, No. 73 and No. 7U, deal with a different subject. They deal with Professor Baagen* I do not believe I should offer these documents at this point because Professor Haagen is going to appear as a witnoss, and will be able to testify as to how long he was on leave from the Luft¬ waffe. If it should prove necessary in the course of the case I may offer these docuaents lator. Hr* President, I have now completed the presentation of evid¬ ence for the defendant Becker-Freyseng. All that remains is the ex¬ amination of Professor Haagen, for which the Tribunal has already eiven its consent after the conclusion of tho sea-water case, and in this connection I should like to offer a fow more documents which I have rocoived in tho meantime, and which generally refer co Profossor Haapen's work. THE PRESIDENT: The docuaonts referred to by counsol for de¬ fendant Bockor-Froysong may bo offered later* Has tho Prosocution any rebuttal ovidonce to offer? HR. HARDY: Not at this time. Your Honor. THE PRESIDENT: Counsol say proceed. DR. FELCXHANN: Dr. ftolcksann for dofondant Dr. Schaoffor. lith the permission of tho Tribunal I should liko to call de¬ fendant Dr* Schaofor to tho witness stand. THE PRESIDE-VT: Defendant Conrad Schaefer will tako tho witnoss stand. DR. FELCKM&NNi Before the witnoss takes tho oath I should liko to submit a few documents which deal with the personality of Dr. Schaefer. These are documents about the political attitude of the do¬ fondant and his scientific qualifications. It is necessary to’ offer these documents, because tho prosecution has made the assertion, for all the defendants, in considerable detail to explain the charge of conspiracy, that they were obsessed by Nazi idealogy; that this ideology affected tlie medical sen, especially the younger ones; that during their 2 Jun-M-hB-u-2-i!aloy (Int. Von Schoen) Court Ho* I* studies they were trained in ?Jari Idealogy; that they beloneed or had to belong to various tori organizations, and similar things. Without going into the question of whether this argument is necessary for the charee of conspiracy I shall prove for the defend¬ ant Schaefer, at least, that -these assertions aro not true of hire. I shall deal in those affidavits with another charge, that is that this tori idoalogy reduced the scientific work of the defendants to a low and that on the basis of this -tori idoalogy the defendants, including tho defendant Schaefer, wero unable to perform oxperi-nonts such as form the subject of tho indictcent horo. I shall disprove theso assertions too through those affidavits. First, I should liko to offer Docirnont Schaefer No. 1. It is tho German No. 20, tho English Document No. 1. I was forcod to in¬ troduce two different sorios of mmbers, beenuso by accidont tho nun¬ boring v/as not carried out in tho sano way in the Qorman and English docunonts in tfc translation, and I shall always havo to givo difforont pogo nunbors of Gorman docunonts and English docunonts — English Docunont I, Gorman Docuaont 20, is to havo Exhibit No. 1. This is an affidavit by Frofossor Dr. Hubortua Strughold. I shall road all of it. "Dr. Konrad Schaefer was assigned as a Junior grade or assist¬ ant physician to tho Research Instituto for Aviation Medicine, Borlino. Up to tho end of 19U3 — at whioh tiro I wont to Silesia to stay — I frequently had opportunities to talk to him and therefore I am in a position to givo information on his scientific capability and his per¬ sonality. "Scientific capability: Dr. Schaofcr is a serious scientist who applied his thorough knowledge of tho most modern methods of biological science to all problems with which he was confronted. In this canr.or he also carried out tho scientific research assignments which ho received free the Luftwaffe Ifcdical Inspectorate. Ho also handled his investigations on the physiology of thirst in this way, G323 2 J«> H I B U»3-;taloy (Int. Von Schoen) Court Ho 4 I, and it was due to this that his experiments on the development of Zoo loth for making sea water potable were crowned with success. Ho was not afraid of performing experiments on hirself, and in 19U2 he and two of his female assistants conducted a throe-day thirst experi¬ ment, This experiment belongs in tho category of heroic nodical self- oxperinents ard the three participants nay bo justly proud of it. "Personality and political views* Dr, Schaofcr is a very hunane and socially tainted nan, a good friend and conradc and a modost char- actor. Ho is very intelligent. In tho Third Reich he was unlucky in his university carocr, as ho was a pronounced antagonist of National Socialisn. I had repeated examples of his views when I discussed pol¬ itics with hiri. It was also duo to his anti-Nazi viows that ho had to go into industry, wbero ho worked successfully as a sciontific dopart- cont chiof. ■As to his views on oxporinonts on humans, I know from a conver¬ sation which I had with hin in 19l*2 that ho was decidedly against ex¬ periments tho voluntary naturo of which could bo doubted for any reason at all. I thoroforo fool that, as far as I can judge from horo, Dr. Konrad Schaofor cannot bo involved in tho matters now being ploaded in Nurnborg by anything but an unfortunate constellation." Document No. 2 on pago 3 will bo Exhibit 2. It is an affidavit by Dr. Helmut Vcnxjst, dated 23 January 191*7. It roads: "I have known Dr. :*d. Konrad Schaofor, born 7 January 1911, for many years. We both studied at the saao high school (hunanistischos Gymnasium) in Landau/Pfalz, whore we graduated in 1930. Wo woro to¬ gether for nearly all the sonostors of our medical studios at Hoidol- bore, Innsbruck ard Berlin universities. >7o were not merely chance school follows and study companions, but wero also close friends* I therefore have exact knowledge of Dr. Schaefer's w>rk outlook and con¬ ception of life. Until 19l*0 whon our paths were divided by profession¬ al duties, his political attitude was clear and distinct. It was in opposition to National Socialism. I know that up to this time Dr. 2 Jun-M-JB-Wi-Jfeloy fjnfc. Von Schon) Court Ho. I. Schaefer did not belong to the Party or to any of its organizations. In all our political discussions ho rover failed to express his stark opposition to National Socialise. Shortly before taking our Stato 2 {edical Examination in Heidelberg in 1935, considerable difficulties were created for us both by the National Socialist Students* Council which questioned our admissibility to tho State Examination. Tho offic¬ ial charge against us was based on tho fact that wo did not belong to the Party or to any of its organizations or to the National Socialist Students* League• " As Exhibit No. 3 I offer English Document 3, German Document 2lj, English paec US, Gorman pagO 52 and 53. It is an affidavit by Dr. Hel¬ mut Roichol free Bad Fyrmont: "I cot Dr. Schaefer through Prof. Juorgens when I workod with then both before tho war in tho Naturo Health Clinic in Berlin. I had no official connection with Dr. Schaofor. Through my friendship with Prof. Juorgons, basod on many years of joint work, I was woll informed about tho internal affairs. Prof. Juorgons, as a world-famous homotol- oeist, had principally scientific interests. Ho rogarded tho political point of view forced upon his subordinate colloaguos in tho clinic as falsa and irksome. In this connoction Dr. Schaofor was montionod to mo os an oxcoption and as a man who, although possessed of scientific obilitios, did not approve of tl» political tondoncy at that tine. Prof. Juorgens was therefore always afraid of losing him. "Whon Dr. Schaofor had to loavc tho Clinic, his doparturo was described to no as a confirmation of our fears. "/if tor all those years I cannot ro member do toils about discus¬ sions which took placo then. 3ut I renoaber Dr. Schaofor as a man who dedicated himself to serious and conscious responsible research, and* who wont into private industry because his path to tho State Clinics was barred for political reasons 8330 » 2 Jun. 17 iivc'rrn (von Schon) Court ’to. 1 I should like to stop there. As Inhibit -Jo. 4, I sh“ll offer Znglish Document Ho. 4, Gcracn !.'o. 25 , pngos 6 to 8. This is rn affidavit by Dr. R’ns Bruns: "I snko the following affidavit: "I made th- acquaintance of Dr. Konrad Sc hr. offer in 1935 at tho Hydrothor.apoutic University Clinic, Berlin, Harwikstr. 2. '.'o wuro both working there ns sudical internees nd 1 -ter .is voluntary physicir.ns under Professor Rudolf Ju_rgcns. Sinco ft’ofessor Rudolf Juergons :.n internr.tiorrlly ronewnod hematologist — r. dicvr.sc of the blood investigated by hin on the Aland Islands wo a rr.ojd after iii_i "Thrcnbr.sthonia Juorgor.s-Uillebrandt' —>nostly dealt with problems of hooatology, wo worked at first on such probleas. "Nhilft working together . rd 'Iso through our friendly relations, which Lasted for several years until 19A1 — when 3 wos drafted for military service - I learned to estcon Dr. Schaeffer as an excellent, judicious, diligent 'nd horv-st scientist with a knowledge of chemistry and physiology far exceeding the usual medical level. In 11 ids scientific research work his self criticism ard honesty stood out prominently so that .11 the works publishod by him are products of tho .-aost serious scientific research. "!!y reason lor fostering ay friendly relations with Dr. bch-efor, which b y f*r exceeded the usual contact between two colleagues, was due in no mall ol a sure to his high conception of scientific honesty nd fairness -nd to his high -steoa of tho nodical profession which I ah ro also, conception which surely prevented him, from a scientific as -.*uU s . roa human point of view, Iren carrying aut expv.ri.’xnts on human beings which could h'Yo d'ngerous or ov.n fatal results. °!ly friendly relations toward 3r. Schaefer were, moreover, influenced by a far re-chin.- agrecojnt in our political views. "hy awn ’nti-na.zi attitude is to be sc.n ! ren the attached 8331 2 June LI -i$-£-3*>pkp- l!cohan (von Schon) Court Mo. i affidavit node by Mrs. Serti Schncidor, at present in Zuurich, Switzerland, at the u e If are center for tfo. vie tins of Facisra, Hildoahoin." I need r.ot reed all this sta tec.cn t, it will be Exhibit No. 5, it is Docusmt :io. L-k, English pages 9 to 11. Gcraon 29. I shell read it. I shell continue to read Ex h i b it "In ids frequent ling conversations Dr. Schaefer ofton usod drastic expressions -gainst thu rrovailing systea of that ti.au end its lenders. I also confided to Dr. Sc hr.-for that I was engaged to c half Jewess, the then lira 3urgschnt, new* lire. Schnoider. Ono aay Jvx'.go froa this the extent of confidence I nlaccd in Dr. Schaefer an d how convinced I aust br.Ye been of his political reliability when I told hie a fact which would hrvo cost rae raore than ray position at th't t ico. What infuriated oo raost was that Dr. Schaefer, who had proved hlraself so outstanding .a young physician interested in science, could not continu. his career at th- university, because he did not belong to the NSDAP or to any of its or. animations. Hcnever, Dr. Schaefer preferred to renounce a c^rt-in career at the university father than bew to * systua which he rejected as contrary to Ms political convictions. Sven after rer.cn at rat ions by our rautnzl chief, Professor Jurgens, who greatly usteesxd Dr. Scha-for and was unwilling to loso his corvice -s .a collaborator “nd who told hir. that ho could not kc-p hin i f he did not join sco- or aniz.aticn. Dr. Schaefer regained true to is politic" 1 convictions. Dr. Sc hoof or was r-novod ‘ ft-on the university as voluntary assistant because ho did not belong to any of the party organisations . when the reraoval took place I do not uxactly kn:»*. I know cr.ly thrt I was a>3t indignant at the tie- -bout this incident as it showed that when appoint nenta wore/rr.de- to scientific posts at the university 2 Jurt L7 3- pkp- fcc.sbr’.n (von Schon) Court Uo. 1 politic "1 views - rd rot scientific qualifications noru decisive, I ar.y therefore tcintr. in with r. clear conscience tlr.t Dr. Sch-cfcr was not * physician or man possessed of any Nazi ideology." Tton, I should lilx to offer Docuacnt 5, P'f>s 12 to 15 , This will he -Inhibit 6. It is by !£rs. 3aillr. Rahenbrock, Urjburg- Lohn. I shr.ll not road the entire affidavit, it begins: "I, Cailir. Rahenbrock, i&rburg-Lahn. have known Dr. Konrad Schaofor 3incc 1939. I j husband introduced hia to so. Uy husband know him already in 1936 and Ms anti national socialist political r ttitudo which ho had held. Dr. Schaofor 'sorkvd .as .an assistant in the Chcrite, Berlin. tt. had been ccroc lied, so he told OU, to give up his position beesuo- of his political attitudo, particularly as ho refused to join tho Party. He describod t*mt happonod in following words: »'I was called to the Profossor of ny Institute was -ak-d why I had not yet Joined the P.arty. To ny answer thot this would not agr^e with ay political point of viju, !i- toll. to fact thu consequences .as I could not longer stay in the Inst.t ute." V’hon I a»t Dr. Schaof-r at that tiao, ho had a Job as aciontific collaborator :dth tho Schoring AG, Borlin. On tho occasion of our froquont conversations Dr. Schaefer cponly and without any lestraint spoke against rational Socialise and the goveraawnt. * e ofton listonod to f oreign b roadcasts with him and Dr. Schaefer was always very interested in them. I gathered fro-a Tia remarks that Dr. Schaofor was an outspoken ar.ti-faci3t. On 20 July 1944, Dr. Schaefer was with an in ay Landsberg i/artho apart sent. * e had switched entho radio, and suddenly we heard tho ncw3 afccut tho attarpt on Adolf Hitler. Assuming that the attfept had succeodcd he las so overwhelmed w ith Joy that ho entirely forgot ho>; dangerous the situation was. I raaenber that ho said tho follcwirg words "at last the bastard is dead". Unfortunately we were informed soon afterwards that Adolf Hitler was still alive. 2 June Ll Hechan (vcr. Schcc) Court No. 1 Dr. Schaefer was bitterly disappointed by this news and he openly expressed his opinion about this. The chances of success of this attaept were discussed again." a I cortinuo aftor two paragraphs: 'Dr. Schaefer was completely against all alii tar iaa in tho nodical fiold. *fnilo he was called up he hardly ever '.ore unifora, at least I hardly ever saw Ua in it. Ho was strongly against the use of specialist physicians as troop physicians and the use of practical physicians as specialist physicians, respectively, 03 bocaueo of t Yclr ^ack of experience they did n>t meet tic requitc- no.nts of thoir duties. Accordir^ to all ny observations and experiences, I oust say that Dr. Schaefor had an ethical conception of tho medical profession, i.o., to ba a helper of his follow mart, 'Dr. Schaofor r.narked that Cornany would never win tho war. "On occasional visits Dr. Schaofor laitatod Adolf Hitler perfectly for general aausmoor.t. Ho pulled part of his hair ovor his face erti ioitatod lisaothod of spocch, his voice and gestures and tide Hitler incredibly ridiculous." Tho document ccntinuos under tho saao Exhibit Ho. 6, it reads as follone: 17 February, 1947. "I, Dmi.lia Rah.nbrock, "I would liko to add tho following to ay ctataaent of 30 January 1947: "On the occasion of a convorstaion rv-ferrin,; to an announc-munt circulated by the th~n chief physician. Dr. Conti, I asked Dr. Schaefer whether i>u and his wifu r. ould not havw to visit this organization too, 03 th*. requested stated. Dr. Schafer rupliod that this 'association of idiots' would iv>t be visited by any decen^ physician nci certainly rot by hia and is wife." The n»::t docuaont Ko. 6, will b. i hibit 7, on page 16, by Johann- s Nowak, Ifcaburg: "I hrivu Iajo:m N:. Konrad Schaefer for -any yuars. I net hip 2 Jum 47 -i^5-oIa- Meehan (von Scfaon) Court rto. 1 one day in Berlin at the becks hop of Ernst Doenig through a autual friend, Mrs. Erika Koenig. .Dr. Schaafor at that tico was junior- physician in tho Luftwaffe; in the ensuing conversation tc expressed his hatred and antipathy for tho Nazi regine. After that I frequently ait Dr. Schaefer, at the bookshop and at other actings ho -xpressod his groat disgust about the regiac, especially a bout the treatment of Russian prisoners of war and Jews and tho drafting of Juveniles a nd woman into the armed services, so that I had to warn hi*, since h o was wearing uniforn, not to be so careless as to -ndanger b oth of us. I oust oop ha size that neither Dr. Schaefer nor Mrs. Koenig knew that I was not of aryan descent so that he could not have talk.d against the No-is so adversely just to please mu. Our cocraor. hatred for tho dictatorship led to a genuine friendship and after I had to floo fraa Berlin I tret Dr. Schaefer hire in Knaburg whore h*. expressed his happinoss about tho end and told at that now • at last he could work as a free nan and live for his reoearch work. Dr. Schoefor is a -reat idealist who rosoocts hucan like abovo everything and who® views are known to ju as definitely anti- nazi." 3335 2 June U7-?W.7I)*«6-l-?utty (von Schoen) Court No, 1 English Docuasnt IIo, 7 Goman #27 will be Exhibit No, 8, pages 17 and 18, page 65-66 of tho Goman "Erwin Schulz, Borlin-Gatoir, "I havo known Dr, Schaefer since 19U1 and frequently not hin as I was in chargo of and looked after his sailing boat. Since I frequently spoke with Dr, Schaefer about the Hitler rorinc and the National Socialist ideology, I fian but say Dr. Schaefer could not possibly have thought and acted along Nazi lines. He also knew that I listened together with foreign civil workers to English nows broadcasts; he warned no to bo careful as it night cost no ny head. During his loavo wo listonod together to foreign broadcasts, I wasnover ablo to detect Nazi tendencies during tho ensuing discussions. I looked up Dr. Schaofer when I was drafted into tho Navy at tho end of 19 Uj to ask for his advico. Ho gavo no the following instructions as to how to conduct nysolf, I should wait until tho Jay of ny drafting, then call a doctor an’ pro tone’, that I was suffering free ischias. Dr, Schoofor explained to no oxr.ctly how I should act. *"ith his holp I was ablo to succeed in this docoption so that I was roloasod fron ailitary duty. If nocossary* I can produco witnossos in this nattor, 'rs. &•, Olatzol, Spandau, Jaczowweg, Antsarzt, Dr. Franznoior, Spandau, as well as Hr, Franz Pycha, Spandau, ’/oimoistorhom, Tho latter can also tostify to our listening to nows broadcasts, "My political foolings aro woll known and o3tablishod facts in tho district in which I live, that I thought and acted as a Socialist boforo and during tho Nazi period. Proofi ny absolute opposition to military Aity, ny refusal of war work and ny nonborship in tho Legion for Hunan Rights," Document 8, page 19* will be Exhibit No. 9. It conos fron Erich Lehmann, chemist, Hannovor-Horrcnhauson. I shall road na ny excerpts. "I u ave known Dr. ned, Konrad SC3/.ZF2R for abort 10 yoars. Ho had been rcconcar.ded to se in professional circles as being well acquainted with phamacolo'y and as being an important scientific 2 June li7-'4-A7D-6-2-Pu r ty (Int, von Schoen) Court !fo* 1 chords t» At that tlaa I was working on the'Emyne preparations which had just been introduced, and I was in need of an absolutely reliablo nodical nan with the above-osntlonod reputation to assist no with control experiments. "In the many years during which I was permitted to work together with Dr. SCHAEFER, the specialized knowledge nentioned above was proved to tho full. Our sciontific work led to a vory doso friend¬ ship, so that I was ablo to gain a doop insight into his human and political views. "I porsonally have boon a Socialist for nany yoars. I 3ubscribod to this conviction ovon boforo tho first World War, and I an a nonber of tho Goman Social-Dcnocratic Party. Owing to ry political views I was violontly opposed to tho Nazis fron tho very beginning. IXiring tho Vforld War of 191AA8 I sorvod on tho Western Front fron tho start until I was soriously woundod in tho fall of 1917, and I was o confiraod pacifist whon returning to ay civilian occupation* I thoroforo was dolightod to find in Dr. SCKABFSR a nan who shared cy viorrs and who, in full agrooraont with no, disapproved of Rational Sociali3n and all it stood for. ’.'o ngrood Just as mch on tho subjoct of war and its consoquonooso SCHAEFER Was a dyo>in-tho wool pacifist. I do not think that until thor. SCH..EFSR had over known hatrodj but ho hatod National Socialisn with an urtooliovnbly strong hatred and usod to tann tho syston to hell. "We often usod to discuss thoso outrageous torrorist and dictatorial measures. At such tines SCHAEFER usod to expross hinself in tho nost violont toms against the despots. How often did wo air tho question, whether it would not bo possible sonehoir to olininato 0 thoso bandits, in spite of everything . "Dr. SCHAEFAR consistently-^nt-.>d the !lJ7i racial theory. ..'hen SCHAEFER was called into the airy at srj later cfato wo wore separated for a short tine; however, Schaefer often wrote and told no about his * life with tho "PrussiansI could tell fron the thinrshe wrote how 2 Aina li7-»U.TI>^-3-Futty (Int. von Schoen) Court 1 difficult it was for hie to adjust hisself to the blind Prussian discipline. "Then Schaefor then was ordered bade to Berlin, it always pleased me to see that ho never woro uni fore when in ay company. He ha tod the amy and the uniform as nuch ashe hated fiational Socialism." I skip the next two paragraphs. "Publications by Jewish authors, oven works which contained only brief references to such, woro banned by the NSDAP startire fron 1939. I had, at that tine, to run through air wholo archive in Borlin in order to sort out and disposo of all Jewish works on the subjects of medicine, cheeds try and pharracolosy. Thoro was not a Journal or rovier which would accept such articles, oven excerpts of than for publication. In order to oxplain this toStirsorjy, I offor Document Schaofor 38 qs 10. THE PRESI1HT: 3cforo procoodinc with this, tho Court will bo in rocoss for a few ninutoa. rocoss was taken,) t June 47—M-AX—8-1-Xarrow-(Brown) Court 1 TH3 MARSHAL: The Trltxjnal is again in session. TH3 PRESIDENT: Counsel nay proceed. DR. MaRX: (Defense Counsel for the defendant Bec¬ ker- Frey seng) : Mr. President, I ask pernission to make an explanation. The nan called as an expert for professor Scnroeder, Becker-Freysang and Beiglboock, Professor Dr. Volhardt, from Frankfurt, who was approved by th; Tribunal, has now arrived. Professor Volhardt is a scholar and scientist of International repute. Therefore, what he has to say will be of goneral interest and perhaps it will bo very docislve in deciding the outcome of this trial and the evaluation of these throe defendants. Professor Vollhardt has only a little time at his disposal Hu la the Director of the University Clinic for Internal hodlcino of the University of Frankfurt .and must return on ’./odnosday to r. tto.V a scientific ccnfjrenco. I there¬ fore ask the Tribunal to permit Professor Vollhardt to testify tomorrow morning at the boginning of the sosslon so th.it ho can tostlfy as an export. Tti£ PRESIDENT: Has tho prosecution any objoctlon? MR. HrtRDY: Tho prosecution has no objoctlon, Your Honor, but the prosecution would llko to know substantial¬ ly what this witness is going to tostlfy to. Vhothor it will bo tho sen water experiments or other experiments. TH£ PRESIDENT: Will counsel advise the prosecution as to the specific matters of the proposed witness's testimony? DR. MARX: Mr. President, this expert will testify for us primarily regarding tho sea water experiments. Perhaps, in addition, ho will make a general statement regarding experiments on human bolngs, cut that is not 8339 E June 47 -H-aX— d-3-SCarrcw-(3rcwn) Court 1 absolutely nocossory and. In the main, he will confine himself to the points regarding sea water experiments. THS PRESIDENT: Will defense counsel, as soon as possible, furnish a statement of the witness. The usual written statement that the witness will be called? DR. H.»RZ: Hr. Proaldont, I don't believe that that is expedient since the expert will testify hero before the Tribunal. Questions ore to be asked of this expert... THE PRESIDENT: (.Interrupting); I referred simply to the usual typewritten statement that such-and-such a witness will be called for certain defendants. DR. rURX: Wo applied through the Socr^tary-Oeneral ar.d the witness has boon approved for Schrocdor, 3ockor- Froysong and, so far as I know, for Dr. Stelnbauor for Dr. 5elglboeck. THE PRESIDENT: That will bo satisfactory. Tho witness will bo hoard tomorrow nornlng at the oponlng of tho Tribunal, but this usual form that tho witness will be called at ouch a time should bo fllod for tho records of the Tribunal. Counsol will have no difficul¬ ty in procuring that fora. DR. MaRX: Very woll, Your Honor. HR. HoHrtNSf: Hay It pleaso the Tribunal, I am advised and bolleve that tho expert witness to be called tomorrow will tostlfy from original German documents or, at least, alleged original documonts, concerning tho soa water experiments. That is to say the defendant Belg- lboeck has, in his possession, original charts and records concornlng the experiments which he carried out in Dachau. If the witness is to testify concerning those original records and is to base his testimony upon thorn, I think 32.0 - * -I 2 Juno 47-arrow-(Brown) Court 1 that thoy will havo to bo Introduced Into ovldonce tomor- row bo that ho will testify concerning those documents. The prosecution has not received any copies of those original documents. I think we're entitled to them In ordor to be able to formulate our own questions to put to tho witness and to permit our experts to study tho originals, tfe'ro also entitled to twenty-four hours' notice on any documents which rro to bo submitted. I therefore request that, if It Is true that this oxpert Is to base hla testim¬ ony upon alleged clinical reports prepared by 3olglboeck at Daohau, that thoy bo roducod today in their original form and pusentod to The prooooutlon. THJ PRESIDENT: «ny original documents concerning which the witness will testify should be filed In tho offlco of tho Sooretary General where thoy nay be examined by counsel of the prosecution. If copies nro available, copies should bo furnlshod the proseoutlon today, but if copies are not available, tho original documents should bo filed in the office of the Secretary Gonoral. DR. STEINS.JJER: (Dofonse counsel for the defendant Boiglboock^; dr. President, at groat troublo to myself, I havo found the originals of the-records of those exper¬ iments and on tho 20th of January I showod thorn to tho export of the prosecution. Dr. Alexander, In tho prosonco of an American professor who was a specialist In this field, Profess?r Ivy, and both these men have roturned the documents to me. Thereupon, I made thorn available to Professor Volhardt and I hope ho will return then to me at noon and, f£ that tine, I shall turn then over to tho Secretary General. Thus, it will be possible to show them to the prosecution. However, It is Impossible for me to 2 June 4?-M-a2-3-4-Karrow-( Srovn) Court 1 naico copies of thoso because a great many of them arc Just notes, partly charts and graphs and such things which It Is technically Impossible to reproduce. However, as I said the exports for the prosecution havo already seen those documents. HR. HcHjiiiSf: Well, of course. If the documents are In the possession of tho export thoy can't bo made available today and wo will not Interpose any objection to calling tho witness tomorrow. But, at the 6amo time, we will require that wo be furnished coles, which oan bo photos¬ tated vory simply, for future study. I do not think It la truo that we have soon all tho originals of those documents. I am alvlsod that Dr. Stelnbauer oven has tho names of the pooplo who wore subjected to theso experiments, yot I find no reflection of thoao documents in the document books so far submitted for the dofondant Boiglboock and, of courso. It la quite Important for the prosecution to havo that information. • IH2 ?fi23ZD£NT: Counsol for the dofondant Belglboeok stated that those documents might bo available to him at noon today and if thoy are, he will fllo them with the office for the docrotary Oenoral whero they nay be examined by tho prosecution. P 0 Counsol for the dofondant Schasfor may proceed. Just a moment. 3342 2 June 47-V*-S3-^-l-Uelcy(£rcro) Court ?fc. 1 THE PHeSIDETi I would like to address counsel for defendant Beigcl- bcck. It wea the intention of the Tribunel to instruct counsel thet ell of tfceso documents, vheteTir they ere, cssoon (s they errive should bo filed with tbs office of the Secrotery Ger.erel to bo eveiltble to the Prosecution. Thet refers to all the avd leble (bcuaor.ts. Decs counsol unloratnr.d thotf DR. SIEKBaDERi * p?rt of these docuaor.ts cro lcrcedy induded in ay dcainont becks Ko®» 2 end 2, which will bo put in evidorco ■hen the Boigelbock ceso ones up. THE FRESIDSrTiGa cr.urso, these docunentathr.t tro f voilcblo in Boigol- bock's dccunor.t book need not bo filed In tho Office of the Secretery General. They arc elreedy ttoro. CB. STn:SADcRi How over, it is not neccsscry. for lnstcrcc, in order to understand this wholo aettcr fer ao to jut in the r.tnos of the oxpcriaontcl subjects. It is quite oncugh for ac to put in tho nurbtrs, However, to ho to nothing to aoncoel end nothing to hido. It is not r.occoscry thet tho noses of theso unfortunate persons, who perheps cro still clivo, should beccdo public here so thet they ero tvnlloblo tc tho press. I . ca e dccor.t huarn being, feel rvyaclf obligated in tho wey in which tho storilizod Polish subjects wero protected from unplecaor.t publicity, I fed tb» t tho nctxs of thoso pooplo :lso shoilld bo kopt free being acdo public, ^ut if tho Tribunel wishes I'll nubnit the list. THETRlSIDETi Tho TVituncl sees no creprrisen between these experiaerts end such oxperiaonts cs thoso thet were cnductcd by ray of sterilization. If tho prcpcaod witness is to testify fren dooinents containing the r.eaea of witnesses, then those docuaonts should btf filed in tho cfflco of the Sec ret try General • ith the others. If the aibjocts were not herned by these ex-erInert3 then there cen be no hr.re to % then if their renes ere contiored fr:a tho witr.oss stciid end nothing will be lest with c few hours delay in or king these r.cones cvcllcblo. &3L3 2 Juno 47-:^ —Q-2-Mfl-y(3rcT7n) Court No. 1 IR. STEDiaaJERs Very voll* Consol fer defendant Schaefer nay proceed. DR. PELCKX’^i Your He©or, I bed reed Exhibit 9 in jn-t. In this exhibit Ur. Latcenn certified that the publicctior.s of Jewish cuthcrs --ore strictly forbidden b the Netionel Socialist Party, end thet it xes elao forbidden to quote thcc. In this connection I put in Exhibit No* 10. Thet is Dccunont 33, frm which the foil owing can be soon. This is c Kiontific paper by the dofendent Schaefer rogrrding tho blood picturo of whito rico in cxperinontel infections end chcniccl therapy. This is Docunont 39, end eppeers in the supplen'ntery voluno. Tho Prosecution arrf tho Court teve tfco dexuaont, but tho interpreter' do not. Hcwover, I shell not qurto fr.-a it, so perhaps tho inter¬ preters cor. dispenso with it. Tho rork is ontitlod ’Tho Blood Picturo of tho -hi to Meuso in feporlaontaX Infoctions and Chcr.othorr.py, • end on pogo 26l is a bibliography, and it is this bibliography which Dr. Schaefer oppor.ds to his r-rk. This bibliography contains tho nones Levy and Lcowonstoin. M tho oonclusion of this pepor thcro is rvor.tion of tho fbet that it wesnot pcsSblo to print colored reproductions because of the war situation. This proves thet tho pepor was published during tho war, that is after 1939. end tho ritr.oss Lohrenn in l.is affidavit hessteted that at loest 4 nee 1939 it *ca forbiddon to queto Jewish scientific papers. Dccunont 38 -ill bo exhibit 10. I oontiauo nowin ry reeding of exhibit 9. Decuoont 8, Exhibit 9. on pege 21 , the third paregrtph froc tho last! •la ny opinion Dr. Schaefer is a research scientist with uraisuol intellectual gifts and idocs, of when one cay still expuct greet things.* I shell new skip the next paragraph end ra;d the concluding paragraph! •In ry profession as e ehezdst cr.d scientific worker I rcy scy wit cut flattering nyself that I have bec^voo ac-ucint-.d with alncst ell tranches cf r.edicir.oj I knew clinical physicien£ end priveto 8344 2 June 47-:i-S7-9-3-L'olcy(5rcvr) Court No* 1 practitioners elnost ell ever Germeny, end thereforo I tsr. eble tc fern on occur etc opinion cn e doctor* * doctor oust, ebove ell be on understanding hum® being who is eble to comprehend end appreciate the nee s cf sick people. Only then his nodical knowledge oonesin. In a hippocretic sense. Dr. Schaefer conforms to both cf these ©inceptions. Extensive physiological learning end inexhoustiblo knowla-dgo esc physician — thet is D r . Schaefer.• The next document is Dccinent No* 9. Pego 23 of the English Dccunent Bock. This will be Exhibit 11. This is a phctc-copy, end on tho second page of this phctc-copy there is Dr. Ilso Kuntzo's effidevit of 2 J emery 1947. pert cf which I shell rerdi •Sinco tho Spring of 1943 I fatf boon working on ry Doctor thesis under Doctor Ocnred SCRaX?SS. I heve knora Dr. 93HAEFZR sinco 193& and through his conversations with no and with others I learned to know hin as c determined OD«cy of National Socialism. Of that period, I know tco, that his rofuscl to jcin tho Party or er.y Nrtlcnr1 ScciollPt association compelled hin to resign his appolntmont as assistant at tho Hydro-thcT 1 peutical Instituto in Berlin. Ho froquontly voicod his anti-Nazi opinion so openly ovon in tho proscrco of strergoro, thft vvo, his friends and acquaintances feared tho consequences which this attitude night havo for hin and s-metises rcstroinod hin. Noithor by OOeviction r.or in his bccrirg was ho c militarist. After his dreft into tho Luftweffo to accepted a pceiticn in cviction- rxdicel rcscerch, s ho hinsclf told no at thrt tine, only In order tc be able to continue his private work at Sc hexing A.G. end tc cacapo the nilitcry restrictions to which a Tkupponcrzt has tc submit . Ho detested wearing uniform. Eo therefore usually appeared in civilian clothes end wore uniform on official occasions only. He wont into the Research Institute for aviation Medicine only in order to deliver his roport3, — I cstimeto that thrt heponed every month, sinco he worked *n in the laboratories outside tho Institute. ' 6345 •: i 2 Jure &7-y.-SV-9->i-Malcy( = rcun) C^urt :.*c, 1 At that tine I vesbusy preparing =y dee ter's thesis on the moltr c cceectretioc of the blocd during thirst. My aileborttion with SJHAEFER enabled me to see that his scientific methods were exceed¬ ingly ex'ct end reliable. His long eetivity in the reoln of pher- rxeclogy hod eccustcccd hln tbrtfcb prretico of trying out medice- oenta and ether rccodicson human boings only after they htd been tested chemically, liercocclogicclly end in experiments on ft n l ce ls. 1 distinctly remember the following ineidont in tho Fell of 19/i3.» "hilo uo wero inspecting tho lcborctiorios which wore jxit ft tho dis¬ posal of Dr. SCH*ZFEB and n solf in the Fhysiolcgicnl Institute of tho University of B od in end discussed tho prollnincry rosilts of cur thirst experiments on voluntary experimental aibjccts, o Stebscrzt of • tho Yokraceht wes present, nho, during c privtto discusd on on tho difficulty ofpxocuring voluntary oxporimontol subjects sold, why not use inmates of con or.treticc corps. Cutrogcd, SOH EFB< rojcctcd tho idoc with such orthosis thtt I secretly nado signs to hln to restrain hlnsolf since I thought SSHAEF-Jl's romarks vory hazardous, considering • tho rank of tho Stebsirzt.* I shell retd tho lett paragraph on. erbtfxr occasion. I one new to the affidavit of Miss Inc ven Bocttichcr, Document Kc« 10 , page 36, of the English Dccuacnt Book. This rill be Exhibit 12. *ron this document I shell reed first of ell only the last tno paragraphsj pego 37 end pego 38 of tho English Dccumont Book, bcccuso tho bt of the offidevit I shell rerd in a different context. •As I lived for elnost two years with the Sc he ofcr fonily, I res well oequianted with the political opinion of Dr. Schaefer. Right ct tho outset he t:Id me that he *cs-bliged tc work in industry because he htd refused to join the party and wes not cllc id tie refrre, to hold on official position. It -is for this ret son th-1 ho loot his Inst position with e University clinic ani therefore could not fulfill his greatest desire of establishing himself cs University lecturer. B%6 r 2 June 47-&USS- Q-3-M1 oy (Brown) CcurtNc* 1 Tiro end egain he expressed his regret ebcut his. Dr. Schaefer frequently had arguments and violent political discussions cith Dr. Foldt who had national socialist tendencies. He ueanot afraid to : record only the l~st p°ra r^ph. L-t me say that this is "r. affidavit by '!rs Ursula I'lcff and I quote . "From the be..innin;j :f eur acquaint<-ncc- I .r.thered from his r_.arrks that Dr. Schaefer was an opponent of Notional Socialism. This continue, threu h the v#rr. Dr. dchaefor pass¬ ed reanrks which, as far ‘•s the ideas of that tiac were con¬ cerned, were rbsolutel • 'opposed tc the state.' And it was tnr-u ;h this attitude that he occasionally enne into con¬ flict with cur Chief, Jr. Fclet, who \vr6 a convict'd suppor¬ ter of NrtienPl iccinlisu." This cvr.clades ly presentation cf those documents, which I consider t- bo iei.:ortrnt in clarifying th^ defendant's po¬ litical attitude end his scientific achievements. These two natters have been considered by the Prosecution i.opcrt-nt f r all the defendants, indue in; the defendant ‘Schaefer. The charge that the ofendant Schaefer c:nspired with all the ether defendants is supperted by the Frcsucuti n an the charge that Jehaefer occupied a high position in the Hierarchy cf the Health cervices in Gcraany ant that all th<- defendants knew of the criaos connected because cf.their official contact with ^nc an: thor and their ccoiocn medical interests. This vv~s said cn December 12th by the Prosecution at roa.t lunjth. In interrojrti.a: Schaefer, I shall refute this on the basis of d-cuacnts in which I in dolineatin r 8348 2 June-::-*'—1G—2-"e,han (Int. Court K— 1 his official position Shall prove thrt he- was in the Insti¬ tute only vR rare occasions, that he tcck no part in the Humber ccnf-r-ncc, etc. I err. dispense with r’iscussin- the defendant jchaefer's career, that is sot f rth in its essen¬ tial points in the affidavits. Dr. Schaefer, after you left the Hydro-Therapeutic Ins¬ titute in Berlin. JUDGE S3BRING : 5y request of the counsel, the swear- in,, of the witness was dc for red , dc you want hiv. sworn now? DR. PSLOCUN . Yv-s, Ycur Honor. BY JUDGE SSBRING i *}•- Vhr.t is your name ? ...» K-nrad cchacfor. hill you repeat this octh after ac s I swor.r by God, the .'.lai hty '•nd Omniscient, that I will speak the pure truth "nd will withhold and add nothing. (The vfitness repeated the oth). jUiXil jSLRING i You *U"y sit down. ey dr. PELcri/jn; . t .- Dr. Ichaefer, after you left the Hydro-The ropcutic Institute in Eerlin bccaus. you n: fused to join the Nazi Party , what position die you take ? a.- I went to dehor in*, Aktion - estllschaft to tho Chc- :.utherapeutical laboratory them and was under Dr. Foldt, •h; vrs chi*.f of tho laboratory at that tine. ..- In what field did you work there during the course of the years ? In the field of Chemical therapy, that is to say the examination cf che-nic*>l substance to ascertain their effects or. various diseases 2 Juno -IFL-10- 3*1 lech an (Inti Court Ho. 1 V- Did ycu c-rry cut anin-1 experiments in this con¬ nection ? f»-S. 4 «- llany or few ? riany. c .- Di- you also cerry cut experiments cn huoan bcinp.s? A— No. ■ 6 .- Until whet year di- ycu function in this capacity at Schorin^ ? Until the end cf the war, until the bo'-.inninj: of 1944 r.s Dr. Feldt 1 s assistant and from then cn ee director cf the department because durin/; the spring of 1914 Dr. Feldt was killed in an air attack. V- Frea ! larch of 1944 ? A.- YwS. r i- m out in 1911 ycu entered the Luftwaffo •, is that so? A.- Yes. A .«- Hew was it possible then for ycu from 1941 to 1945 to hold a position at Sch-rinj ? .vftor ay period of basic tr-ininfj, which lasted o fow .»nth6, I return.! to Schcrin- .».G. and I reclined a. scl-ier. • v . - ..nd when did ycu beccrx. an Unterarzt of the Luft¬ waffe ? A.- In the ©.inner cf 1942. 4 .- Dhat is an Unter-rzt cf the Luftwaffe ? .»•- That is one r~d_ bclcw r lieutenant , in ether* words a sorvoant. «.•- In this context, I nay p-int cut to the court that in Decu.ivnt 5ock He. 5, Document Ko. 177, Exhibit No. 133, there is the- minutes -f the conference of 23 *fcy 1944 and Dr. ochaefer is mentioned as a participant in t .is ccnfe- • I- 8350 2 Jane-II-?L-10-4-* ic chrn (Int* Brown) C_urt Kc. 1 rence end under No. 14, Dr. Schaefer is dcsi~nated ir. the Sn. lish translation as a ncn-commissioned officer, which of coarse is not on officer 4 * Hew did you co02 to take up your activities in the se¬ rial medical research institute ? A.- In 1942, I was transferred to Juctcrbo~ and assign¬ ed t. the Research Institute for Aviation Medicine in Berlin at the sa„t«j tine. Q«- You singly aenticn the nanc of Jueterbor } what w'-s your position there ? A.- I was in the medical trinin£* and «x?crinentl de¬ partment. t .- In thiB medical training and research department in Juoterbcg what position did you occupy ? A.- None. Kow 1 8 that ? A.- That was simply n formality at the Rcsocrch Insti¬ tute for Aviation Medicine, there were no military ranks or offices, only civilian offices end since I had to be offi¬ cially accoanodated in one way or another I was put into this or v;as trar.sz*erred to this training and experimental department in Jueterbog, which paid my salary by money or¬ der to Eerlin. The Prosecutor, however, has assumed that there was some official connection between everybody who belonged un¬ der this table of organization to Jueterbog , is this assump¬ tion so and Professor Holzloehner also officially belonged to this department, does that mean you had official contact with Professor Holzloehner ? A.- No, that assumption is entirely incorrect. I heard here that Professor Holzloehner did not work in Jueterbog *it..er, bit mainly in Kiel. I do ncjt know irofessor H 0 I 2 - 2 June-;i-*~-lC-5-::e«har. (Ira. Brovr.) Court No. 1 loehner at all nor car. I even remember his person. '«•- perhaps you sent reports to the Medical Train¬ ing and Experimental Department ? a.- No, that never happened. *•“ was there any actual connection between you and this department which could fce charged against you really by the Prosecution ? A.- None at all. you said that you simply drew your salary from there by money order , is that so ? A.- Yes. t .- Now, to clarify this position of dr. Schaefer, I should like to put in from Document Book No. 1, Document 13, this will be Sxnibit No. 15, page 42 of the English Do¬ cument book. This is an affidavit from Dr. Warner Knothe of Gosiar. When Becker-Ereyseng was on the stand and also through on affidavit, it was ascertained that Dr. Knothe was the director of the Medical Training and Experimental Deportment that I anst state here, because unfortunately that state¬ ment is not included in the affidavit. I shall reed the docu¬ ment, it is very brief ; "Dr. med Konrad Schaefer, whoa I hardly remember per¬ sons liy, cr.s not a member of the personnel of the Medical Experimental end Training Department of the Luftwaffe and never worked in Jueterbog either. It is possible that ho '/ns assi.jr.cd to the department's payroll, this I cannot rc- meater. The Medical Inspectorate sometines put people on the budget appropriation of the department even if actual¬ ly they had nothing to do with the department. The files of those people were kept in the office of the department or in the administrative offices of the Jueterbog aerodrome 3352 2 June-.(Int* Brown) Court i\o. 1 for purposes of administration and pay." L;t me again draw your attention to Document 177, Ex¬ hibit No. 133 f This document you will certainly remember it, Jr. .,chaefer was in the list of distribution that would subsequently be sent to the experimental department in Jue- terbog , if that is so, can you state whether you ever saw this document ? A.- No, I never saw this document. That is to ery that I saw it for the first time when it w^s shown to me during ny interrogations. 2 Jane U7-?S-..:D-il-i-Ritty (Int. Brown) Court So. 1 Q Can you in this connection say whether you saw any of the documents which the Prosecution included in Itocuncnt Book No. 5 as 9 incriniratlr^ docunents, particularly the ori.-Inals of tho documents on conferences, letters of 3i*nlor»3, letters fron the defendant, Schrocder, etc? How was the conprtible with your activities at tho Aerial Hodical Research Institute? A All of these docoaonts I saw hero for tho first tino. Q Now what is tho significance of your assi-mont to tho AArial Hodical Rosoarch Instltuto? A That noant that I was to mko ny scientific capabilities availablo to thio institute* Q But you Just said that durin- tais wholo Foriod you woro activo in tto Schorine fim, evon os a director of a department at tho end. Now how can ycu Co this and still bo activo in the Aerial Nodical Rosoarch Institute? A That was quito conpatlblo* In tho Research Institute thoro was only a lied tod nunbor of positions. Consequently, tho director of tho Institute, Prof os s or Strughold, rocolvod permission to carry out tho work of tho Institute in tho laboratories of tho Schoring A. 0. I askod for this portdssion and rocoivod it. Q And this nado it poesiblo for you to stay always with tho firm, is that so? A Yes. Q Vital t was tto relationship botwoon tho work ycu did for the fim and tho work you did for tho Institute? A I could keep ny provious position with the fim an:', in addition I did tho work for tho Rosoarch Institute. Q You did then sort of incidentally, you say, on tho side? A Yosj they were a relatively snail part of ny total work, Q How often mro you actually at the Aerial Medical Research Institute in Berlin? 335A * 2 Juno Ii?-*^TD-ll-2-Putty (Int. 3roim) - _ Ccurt No. 1 A About onco a aonthj Q "by wore yew thoro? A To ropert on what I had dono or to settlo sons formalities op to fetch apparatus. DR. fSLCK'AKNi In thia connoction I eight return to Exhibit No. 1U. This is i!rs. Ursula Zgloff's affidavit, and I nay road tho following fron tho first para graph* "Fron 1936 to 19U5 I was a nedical-technical assistant in the chemothorapoutical do parent of tho fira of Schorlng A. 0., Berlin. In 1937, Dr. Konrad Sc hoofer boca&o a co-werkor in tho sano laboratory. Dr. Adolf Foldt was our oitual chief. During this tino, that is, ovon after ho was drafted into tho Luftwaffo, B*. Schaofcr was nostly presont and nt work in tho laboratory, oxcopt when ho was away on an occasional official trip." I should now like to pit in Docur»nt No. lh. This xri.ll bo Exhibit 16, pago ii3. This is tho affidavit by Ulrich C. Luft and roads as followsi "Birin*; tho poriod in \rttich ho was assigned to tho Aviation aodicino Ro s oar eh Instituto, Dr. nod. Xonrad SCHAEFER oontinuod his civilian work with tho fim of Schoring A.O. in Borlin. Tfhilo carrying out his Aitics for tho Uodical Inspoctorato of tho Luftwaffe, ho was novor actuaUy in the Aviation Ttodicino Research Instituto builcling itself, but worked in his laboratory at Sobering and lotor on in rooms at tho Ptysiological Institute of Berlin University, ffl.3 connection with the Aviation Ifedicino Research Institute was purely of an a-fcinistrati^o-technical raturo, and ho only appoarod thoro ovory U woolcs or so to obtain cquipnont otc. On these occasions ho usually wore civilian clothos, and remarked to no that ho did not like wearing uniform. I know that Dr. SCHAEFER did not belong to tho National Socialist Party. Various rorerks he nade concerning political events at that tire definitely proved to no that ho was no ?hzi. 8355 2 June b7-M—ATD-11-3—Putty (Ir.% 3ro*n) Court No. 1 ’Frco Jamary 19Uj until tho end of the 'ar I wai frequently Deputy Director of the Aviation Medicine Research Institute for oxfconsivo periods and nade the afcovo aontioned observations in this capacity.' 1 * That was Exhibit I6j and now lot no return, please, to Exhibit No. 9, Docunont Mo. 8, freo which I should like to read another passaco fron tho cdddlo of the docunont, tho last sontenco of tho socond paracraphi "Ho went to tho Institute only once a nonth because he m3 working at tho Scboring laboratory." Q When you did cono to tho Institute, now. Doctor, whon did you speak to? A Either with Professor Stru^hold, the director of tho institute, or with Ms doputy. That was oithor Dr. ELarnann or Or. Luft. Q Tfas Dr. Struchold prosor.t? A Froquontly ho was not prosont, and fron tho Autunn of 191,3 on ho was not thoro at all. Q '.Thoro was ho? A Ho was at the branch office in Silesia which hid boon transferred to thoro as protoction acairwt air raids. Q In other words, ho was hard to got to? A Tos. Q -.That -as your official relation to Beckor-Froyoons, to Prof. Schroodcr or to his pro doc os s or Hlppko? A Tho Bos oar ch Institute was subordinate to tho ModicAl Inspectorate. Professor Schroedor or Hippke was the chief. Subordinate to hin was the chief of staff. Then care tho depertaontal chiefs* Q Ploaco nano tho nanes as you co on. A Tho chief of staff was Kahnt; the departmental chief was Hertz, and subordinate to the departaental chief wore tho roferats. But in how the Research Institute was specifically subordinate to the Helical 3356 2 June li7—‘-'-i'.T!>-11-^-Putty (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 Inspectorate, that I do not know. Q How often did yew see Professors Rippke or Schrooder or spoak with then? A Hippko I saw once, Schroddcr twice. Q How did tho orders that Schroodor issued or which wore issued in his nano roach you? A First they wore sont to*the Institute, and tho Rosearch Institute infornod no of tten since I was not active in tho Institute itoolf. Q Did you currently rocoivo such written ccccunications, daily, or just wtot did happen? A No. In unimportant natters I found out about thoso nattors on tho occasions of r$r visits to tho Institute. In important nattors I was callod up by tho Institute, which, however, was not always possible bo cause in Berlin tolophono cccnunications wore ofton dis¬ rupted for weeks at a tine. Q YToro you tho only collaborator, in this Aero Hodical Rcsoarch Instituto? A No. Thoro wore nany collaborators who, howovor, did hot work in the Instituto building and whon I do not know today even# Q You said not all of then worked in tho building. Is it corroct that only vory fow did so? A ‘-'oil, I had that impression, yes. • • Q I now cone to tho freezing conference in October, 19b2, in ttirnborg. At that timo ycu were an Untcrarzt and had boon assigned to tho Aviation Itodical Research Institute for Just throe months, is that corroct? A Yes. Q Durinr; that tine did ycu know tho numerous collaborators of that Institute? A No. 8357 2 Jane !i7-:5-..TD-ll-5-Putty (Int. Brown) Court Sc* 1 q How eeny did you know? A I knew Professor Strughold and possibly Dr. Xlarnann or Dr* tuft. Hovrovor, I cannot recall that in detail today, Q titter this tine* nancly, October, 19U2, until tho conclusion of your activities, did you nake the acquaintance of others? Did you nako the awjiaintanco of nary or for? I*n satisfied with the nunbor of then* A I nado the acquaintance of a very few. Q Did these few have anything to do with oxporinonts which aro counts in tho indictment in this trial? A No. Q r 'hoc of tho contlonon in the lodical Inspectorate did you know in Octobor of 19U2, in othor words, at tho dato of tho Nuroborn conforonco? A I know Profossor ..nthony and Dr. Bockcr-Froysonc. Q You say ycu knowProfossor Anthony. Villi you, ploaso, explain that? A I saw hin onco when hu ^avo no tho ordor to spoak on tho thirst problem in cases of soa distress at tho Numbor.^ conforonco. That was on orior on tho part of tho dopirtnontal chief at that tino, Gonsral- artt .’jartius^ 2 Jiu>-44-:3-12-l-Gold=erg (Int. Brown) Court No. I, Case Kol li Q How did this order to you cone about? A In the Sucrer of 19li2 I was told to work on the thirst prob- len in cases of sea distress and in the meantime I had collected sono literature on the siiject and had oriented nyself by way of animal experiments* Q What W3s the content of your paper read in Numbers? K This was a report of a bibliographical nature on works by Goman and foreign scientists concerning the problem of salt and tho water content of the body. DR. FQCKIJANN: I put in now Docunent Ho. 15 which will bo Exhibit Mo. 17, listed on Pago Ua of tho English Document Book. This is tho report on Dr. Schaefer's papor which is to bo found in tho official minutes of that Numbcrg conforenco. Since the prosecution put in ovidonco only fragments of tho total roport on that confcronco, but did not put in Dr. Schaofor's paper, a contained in tho official report of tho Nurnbcrg conference, I shall do so now. BY DR. HSZCICANH: Q In tho session of tho 12 Doccrbor tho prosecution assortod that you. Dr. Schaefer, road a roport on oxFcriconts that had boon carriod out on hunon beings. Is that correct? A No, that is not correct. I, until that tine, had carriod out no oxporinonts on human boings. Q And consequently you did not report on such experiments? A Ho, I did not. Q Did you report on experiments that others in tho Luftwaffe had carried out? A Ho, I dito't. Q ITho of those who wore present at tho Nurnberg confcronco did you know, Dr. Schaefor? I on referring now to the list of thoso who attended, which has repeatedly been cited by the prosecution. This is Docunent NO-JiOl, Exhibit 93. Presumably this is on Page 80 of the English copy. S359 2 Jun-:5-:s-12-2-Gc:dberg (Lnt. Brown) Court Ho. I, Case No. 1. You don't have to go through the list in detail, but lot no just ask you. Doctor, whoa did you know who was at that conference? A I knee Professor Anthony whcc I saw on tie occasion that I just doecribod; and I knew Bcckor-Frcyseng and Professor Strughold. Q You did not knew Professor Hu-'orer? A Mo, I didn't. Q You know that the prosecutor, on the 12 of Doocnbor J.9li6, for the first tiro, ard then a few days ago on the 27th of I'ay, for the second tine, assorted that Professor Huebnor, who appears in this list, is the serco Dr. Huobnor as tho ono who later took part with Schrocdor in tho soa-wator oxpcriconts. You also know that this orror was cor¬ rected and that at tte conference there was a Ft-ofessor Huobncr but * that the nan who appeared as an oxpert in tho sca-wator cApurinenta was a Professor Huobncr fra- Berlin, not tho sano nan. Is that correct? A Yos, that is so. Q Thon Frofossor Huebnor was not at tho confcrorco? A Mo, he wasn't. Q Whoa of your co-dofondants do you know? A Profossor Schrocdor when I have soon twico. Thon I boliovo I saw Profossor Rose sorwwhorc or other. In addition I know Bcckor- Freysong and Profossor Boiglboeck. Q You were an Untcrarat in tho Luftwaffe at tho Nurnborg con¬ ference. There wore rany otter participants. Wore others present who did not have officers' rank? A Yos, there wore a for; there. Q How nary? One, two, three? A I should estirate four or five. * Q And how cany attended the confcrorco as a whole? A About seventy. Q Did you attend tte conference with Dr. Becker-Frey song? A No, I didn't. Q Is the reason for that this, that tte officers sat in the 2360 2 Jun-”-«-12-Xk)ldbQrg (Lot* Brown) Court lio. I, Case Ho. 1. front rows and you In tte back? A .ell, that was ore reason. Ibreovor, Dr. Bockcr-Fruysong was very ixssv at this conference. Moreover, I was so unacquainted with the othor participants at the confurorce that I didn’t ncct Frofossor Becker-Freyseng there nor any of tto others actually. Q Wo have hoard hero about your attitude toward the a my and military rattors. Did you fool at hoco ttaro at that meeting, as a non-cosnissionod officer? A Ho, I didn’t; and I don’t think any Untcrarst in tho Goman arry felt at hcuo in the conror^’ of officers bocauso up to tho rank of Sargoa.nt a soldier ms, so to speak, second class hinan boing, in ccra- parisonto the officers. Q Did you hear Kolzlochrv-r's and Rascher's statononts at the confercnco? A I cannot recall neither Holzloohner nor Rase her nor r;!ut thoy said.. I must say that I did not hear tha papers read on tho first day of tho conforjnco bocauso thoy roro oxclusivuly piporG dealing uith cold, ffcith-r boforo nor after that tiro had I had anything to do with cold. Moreover, I had not yet fully prepared ay own jnpor and busiod nys-lf exclusively with it. Q How is it that you had to proparo a paper? A Tho period I had in which to do so was relatively short. Iloroovor, cy job at Schoring noant that I had a ereat deal to do and this paper was to be particularly well prepared since it was my first public ipjcaranco and tho audionco consisted solely of persons of scientific renown ard in high ranking offices. Q Could it be said that you had stage fright? A Yos, that could bo said. Q You do not recall having heard Kolzloohnar’s or Raschor’3 reports? A Ho, I don’t. Q Aft-r r. ading your paper, did you h_ar anything about these 2 -Goldberg (inti Bresn) Court Mo. I, Case Mo. 1. reports, Hol z loeh-Tcrs or Rase her s reports, or the experiments that preceded then in conversations with private persons? A No; I had no private discussions with the other participants in the conference at all. Q Good. Did you perhaps spoak with Professor Bcckcr-Frcyseng about that report? A No. Q Thon that is all you have to say about the Nurnborg conforonco? A Yos. Q Did you take part in otter conforcncos? Dr. Bcckor-Froysong stated Yihor. he was on the stand that there woro roughly twelve ouch conform reus. A I took part in no othor confere.-cu at all. Q Mew, to return to your pr.por, what conclusions did you ar¬ rive at in your papor? ftrhape you would liko to quote sonothing fron your papor to shorten this nattor? A Tills is Docurwnt 15, Pago ldj to 53. On Pago 52 of tho Eng¬ lish Docunont 3ook under No. 2 it says: " 2 . ’tonsures to bo adopted when conbatting death fron thirst t a) do not drink any hypertonic sea water, b) toko as littlo nourislxxnt as possible, with tho oxcoption of dextrose, c) use drugs as sparingly as possible, and no drug recouxndod for qujnchirv; thirst, d) dc not bathe in sea water, o) take as auch fresh water as possible, which contains only a little salt." Frra this it can bo soon that I always recorronded not drinking any sea water. Q Did you continue your research after you read your papor? A Yos. 8362 2 Jurvr 2-12-5-Goldber (Int. Brown) Court Kc« I, Cos. Ho. i. THE H'.ESIDSS'T: Counsel, at this tire tho Tribunal will bo in recess until 1*30. (A recess wca taken until 1330 hours.) 2 June Z, 7 -'*-S'"- 13 -l-? 3 ter (Greu U • crtcnberg ) Court Sc,- 1 *fTSg;BDYi It hrs the* listed in the index, your Honor, tut it doesn't hove the docurer.titself in the contents. THE I RES UK T i The so dccicents in cy book ere simply cherts. I cssune these wore No. 16, I don't know. IB. riLCXilANNi They cro merely eferts, your Honor, thet is correct. MB. KjRDYi Might I ask Defense Counsel whet ho is attempting to prove by uso of these charts? " Tbs so charts don't olicit or.y dote on experiments that wero conducted et Oecheu or cny experiments thrt ore et lssuo in this trial* It soor.s to me thet they a®o enlrcl experiments. I can't soo tho motor id it y of thorn la this ccnnocticn. DB. rZlCJQW;Ni Tho irosocutlon is cterging all tho defendant#, including tho D C fondont Bohaofor, with having used non-scicntific not hod s. Tho Prosecution spent a considerable amount of tlmo trying to provo this one choree, and I want to provo that in occupying hirsolf with tho thirst problas owl with tho task of finding c nothod of taking tho selt out of soc water, the Defendant Sc hoofer proceeded in a strictly scientific mennor, so t hat this particular, ebergo dees not apply to him and thet for thet recscn ho, of course, also rejected tho Borka nothod, end his rejection pf the Berko netted was for scientific reasons. I shall thoroforo havo to shew generally hew scientifically Schncfor worked and, porticulcrly, hew scientifically ho worked on tho prebite for tho solution of whipfc ho is prosecuted her*., • 2-fl. HiBDYi i.fter hearing the remarks of Ccunsel, Ycur Honor, I object to tho continuation of the examination using this materiel. I don't see tho mcterielity of whether or not Schaefer inducted himself in cn ethical manner in otter experiments. The point et issuo here is whether 5365 2 June &7— -3~3~ heater(Grtu & -crtcr.bcr^) Orurt 5c. 1 or not he la icpliceted, whether cr net he took pert in the -lena end cr.tcririfloa involving the acescter experiments tt Dcchau. The ircaecuticn chcxgea thet he sea icpllccted therein — the two nethoda were to ho uacd £t Dec hen erd ho ms a perty to the crino. I ctr.'t ace thft whether or not he ected ethicelly free, the tine he grcductcd fron cedicol school until the tine he beeme involved in trie criminal plot hea no hearing here. DR. TELCIQUiiNt If tho ireaeeution would be ao kind oa to tell no in accewhct rcro detcil, at leest or>:o, why the ftjfendent Schaefer is rcaponaible for the epplicction of tho Berke sothod in the experinenta, then I could lirdt ny dofOnao aach r.ore intelligently . But is tho i'roaocutlon only lota no infor what it ao raiders tc bo incriminating, I nuat nako my dofonao ca aure ea pcaaiblo end , therefora, rust bring ovldoDCO for, firat. tho personality of Sc hoofer, aecond, hia aclontific ochlevor.onta gcnorolly, third, hia acientlfio cchlovononta in tho queation of the solution of tho thirst problem erd fourth, in connect¬ ion with tho invention of tho Eofotit rat hod, end fifth lr. tho rejection of tho Bcrkotit mothod. T!*. iTOSIEENTi Thoobjoction of tho Trosecutlon to tho cdrnlasion of tho as c tart a ccnj-rialt^ Schaefer Document 16 ord tho decunonta will bo rccoivcd in cvidonco. ^hat nunbor do you assign to this exhibit? DR. l'ELCP3^?5»’i No. 18, Mr. President. 3366 2 Jun-A-IE-lL-l-Frineau (inti Grau) Court No. I. :rk was always interesting. I constantly carried out hunger and thirst oxporinents on rabbits and aico for hin, after Dr. Schaefer had again takon up his work with Sobering in tho spring of 19l*2, fol¬ lowing upon a fow nonths of tr-i ning after being drafted to tho Luf t- waffo (outuan 19lil). n Then I should liko to add to the charts Docvanont Ko. 39 which will bo Exhibit No. 19, and uay I be pcrriittcd to read a fow 2 Jun-A-:-3-ili-2-rb*iri3au (Jnt. Grau) Court lio. I. pages only out of this affidavit. (Int. Vfartenberg) I ask you to oxcuso ao for a oonont. I shall find it in a sJnute • It begins: "Dr. Konrad'Schaefer, H.D., during a very heavy air raid or. Berlin during the night of 22-23 Hovorber 19h3, which dcstroyod almost tho whole Hansa-quarter, lost his apcirtaer.t and all his property." Excuso no. I believe the Court and tho Prosecution have tho supple¬ mentary vol'jx;. TIE PRESIDENT: Tho Tribunal has this suppleixmtary voluno. DR. PELCKSiANH: It has bo.n translated. It nust oc just an oversight that tho interpreters did not rocoivo it. I have Just givon then a copy of tho translation. "ly husband and I rccoivcd tho Schaefer family into our housw, and I thus becarc very well acquainted with Dr. Schaofor and his wife. Ftoq that poriod until tho ond of ths war I cssistod Dr. Schaofor in sorting out tin literature and undertook his written work, which con¬ sisted chiefly of copying notos on tho oxporimnts of Hr. Kr.ulisch and of dictation into tho typowritor. Tho copxios of tho notes on ’Schaefer's Aninal Exporinonts' (hunger and thirst oxporiaonts with rabbits), Docu¬ ment Ho. 16, and tho two last tables of Documnt Ho. 18 regarding tho compilation of th>- results of thirst oxeorijjonts on voluntary subjocts, the originals of which ware shown to no by Counsel, Attornoy-at-Lnw role krona, wero drawn up by r ». "Dr. Schaefer dictated to rc in Ifcy 19U; his viems on tin re¬ cords of tho oxperi rents of fc-rarzt von Sir any, on aking sea orator potable by Berks (Documents Ho. 25 and 27), tho originals of which 1^ was also 3hovm by Attorooy-at-Iar Fblc’.cmnn. Through this collaboration I received tho impression that Dr. Schaofor was a very conscientious and serious research worker. His zeal often nado hin work untiringly throughout tho night." 2 Jun-X-:2-Ii*-3-?rtneau (Int« Wartcnbcrj?) Court No* I. 3Y DR. reiCKKAHN: Q This for the identification of the tables on the anted experiments, Exhibit No. IS. Dr. Schacfor, did you not also study the thirst probloc ty Beans of experiments on human beings? A Yes, during the course of 191*3 I carried out some hunger and thirst uxporinents on voluntary human subjects who were froc. They wero technical assistants who in pert woro working for no. The oxperi- nonts showod that while continuing one's full work one can very woll hunger and suffer thirst as long as four days without suffering fron it nontally or in thi ability to concontrato. Q In ardor to prove this, I submit the affidavit of Dr. Kuntso, which I havo already introduced as 'Ixhibit No. 9. I ask to bo allowed to read now only tho Last sontonco from this affidavit. It is pages 23 to 35 in tto English Docurscnt Book. The last scntcnco roads as follows* "In 191*3 I carriod out for ny doctor's thesis simultaneous hunger and thirst oxporirents, lasting throe to four days, on nysclf and otlior persons. I one lose tho ro suits of the so oxporl*xnts arxi con¬ centration tests." Thoso aro tho following pagos attached to this af¬ fidavit. 2 JUno J7->-^'-15-l-Gros(*-rtonbcrs) Court Nc. 1 ER. :2C;CW.i I eak farther tc bo roraitted tc introduce into evidenco Document No. 17. peso 63 , English docunent book, cs S xhlbit 20,. These ere records of tho experiments - the hunger end' * •• thirst expcricents - cerrled cut on c Miss Gerdc lierio Sctaidt. Like- also, Document No. 18 es Exhibit 21, jngea 70-80. These ere records co roc mi ns expeiteenta on iSisa Irr^crd von Boetticher. And, fi nelly, I ask porrdsfflcn to refer egaia to Doc\r*-ont No. 10, affidavit 12, tho offidevlt of Miss Xna ren Boetticher, frea whoa I Just introduced tho record of tho oxperiaer.t cs Exhibit 21. *roa this document, thet is fithiblt 12, I should liko toroed tho following, on pgo 36 feOGlnnlng with tho third paragraph of tho affideviti "After tho cnincl expor- irents, thirst experiments on humno were clso ccrriod out. I nyaolf volunteered throe or four tires. Just cs soao of ny ccquclntoncoa end or.co ay sister did. be found tho oxpcrlnonts nost intorosting and sufferod no ham cs c result. Burins tho first two deys ono hod roolly only a sonsetion of hunger, which thon chcngod to thlrot. Cnco I festod ord thiroted for four days, usuclly for throo deys. I wont cbout ny work ct tho lnborotcry cs usual, stcyirv: hono only on tho fourth doy, bocouoo I wes very wock end doprossed, which however pcsscd icncdirtely after drinking. Naturally I observod tho regulat¬ ions strictly and really took neither food nor drink during tho expcrinentcl period, because I knee that tho expcrirxmt would cthcr- wiso have been absolutely sor.sclcsa. I bcllcvo it pcssiblo to go with¬ out food or drink for or.o cr two days longer if one ccn renal n In bad. ■«11 those hunger end thirst experiments were carried cut by Dr. Schaeffer for tho Luftwaffoi otherwise he continued working for tho fire Schorl!^." 0. Only ono thing for cl criflection. Dr. S=hcefer. ~ith these exper¬ imental subjects you experimented neither with ^ofotit nor with Berketit, because you hadn’t proceeded th-t far yet? 3370 2 June 47-* Court No* 1 15-2-Groaa (••ertcnberg) K Y.a, that la correct. ^ Hew did it occur to yew to occupy yourself with removing the selt fron ace be ter? 411 theoroticel conalccretioca end ell prectlccl cxpcricents shewed thet aeo water la not uaablc. Therefore, It wea of courao neturd to «m aider e cot hod to rerove the salt free see reter, since In cony cases or.o la not eblo to teke along aufflcior.t fresh wetor. Q* Andif ono tea no fresh weter one =ust ren=ve the salt free sec water? A. Yea. C. About this dovolopcent of the resoirch of Dr. Sohoefor I subnlt tho fbUoainga dcourentai Docunont No. 19. on ? gca 81-33 of tho English Document Book. It la tc bo Sehibit No. 22. This la on affidavit of Dr. Grlessboohf Dj.. Louth, end I’ohl. It rccdoi 'For nmy yecra tho treatnent of wotor, in pertlculcr by obacrptlon proper*tions, wes o scientific field of work in tho inorganic brooch of tho Jolfon dyo works, in which wo cro ccployod.* Tho “olfen dye works belonged to tho 1.0. Konzern, I rcy cdd. •In tho surrer of 1943 c wero cssl.^ncd tho teak of r.ckln, selt water pctoblo for uao in the rescue ct aoo of airaon, autocrine crowa, etc. A rosocrch caaigrernt for this w:s issued by tho Luftwcffc. Untcrcrzt Dr. Kcr.rcd Sc hoofer wtaccmlsaioned ts cn expert for this work by tho Research for letleu Medic ir.o. •At tho stno tine tho Navy wes also interested in this problem, end c alnilcr dcvolcpsent order vea irsued by tho CR4. •Tho I.G. itself undertook to pay the cost of the research work, including the expenses for those sen detochod free tho Johrr.eeht for work in Jolfen. No ether kind of fir.incicl agreement. wes node, either with official area:lea or with any of the jErticipanta. •The process dovelcped involved the reoovel of the selt fron tho water by using the specid prcpercticna for this curp-so to ebsorb the cdclun, G371 2 June £7—-lS-S-GrcssCSertenberg) CcurtNo. 1 cxgneaiun, cad elkoli ccntent end to precipitate the chloride end sulfate content in the fexr. of insoluble selts. The desalting wes so effective thet a ccnpcund wts echiered with e salt content belcw thet of a physiologic cl ordiun chloride solution. The rater was not erectly testy, tut w s do-daltcd enough for really successful use. ■Certain doubts, expressed in pcrticulcr by Dr. Scheoffbr, led to experiments crncornirg eventual silver erd beriun ions in purified wetor. The tests, however, disproved the o^istonco of aediccl scruples in this direction. ■Otherwise the problem wes dealt with on c strictly scientific be sis, and two applications for patents wero file!. ■By lcto fall 19£3 the process resdoveloped to such or. extent, that at a lceturo given by Dr. 3 ehaofor no criticisms woro roisod by tho Medical Inspectorate. Thcroupsn. at the beginning of 19«£, ^olfon filed on application for the establishment of a nor.u featuring plant. ■At first, hewovor, no erder for this wr.s given. Lctcr on wo lcernod free Dj*. dehoofer that another rot hod hod recently been rccconondcd which had first to bo tosted. He hinted thft eccordlng to observations nedo with toaatcoa it had sccething to do with r.ixtxrcs of fruit Juices, etc. Dr. Sc hoof for said thet ho hcdobjoctcd to this not hod, to it was useless free a oedicol point of vie*, ^ut his objections w to not sustained. In view cf the scientific facts wc hed to r.rreo with him* •Later - at the beginning cf 1%5 - Dr. Sihacfcr's (end also our own) views on tho mitebility ajid ireontcstcbility of cur process woro confirmed, choc news reached us from England nndAocrlcc, thet tho somo method was being used there. The periodical "Iho Illustrated London News" rubliahed rescercb. reports of tho ^cyol Aj r ?crce lhysiologicel Lahoretcry, the Ministry of Aircraft Traduction, ord the English I emit it Company. «-t the setae tine publicrticns eppoorod in Sweden tc tho effect that in cerice elso the Icrrutit Company, New York, hed de-selted scowcter in a similar way. S372 2 June 4?—-S--15-ii-3ros3(»ertenbers) Court Nc* 1 ■The effect cchievcd with the Anglo ■ faerie an emthod was not so for- rccching es thet achieved with ours, -je rt fren tho feet thet our rer-einin 5 aediua chloride contest =as only half that of tho Ter- rutit Coepeny* we elso achieved on eldest ccnplcto el ini net ion of tho sulfete content, while with tho Terrutit prccess the sulfcto scstoot recoined in the voter, -o Lai* occasionally voiced rur intention of not removing tho sulfete from the water. Dr. Schaefer, however, relsod objections, pointing out tho disadvantage of t laxative effect of the sulfate content. "On tho whole wo con stete that in the discussions with Dr. K, Scheifor wo always hod tho icpresslcn that ho res o serious scientist end a ®nsolcntlcus medical can. Dr. Criessbeck Dr. Louth Dr. Xehl" This already states in dotcil thet the Eolfotit mothod . whloh Schoofor rocccr.ondcd was unobjectionable *and ncs tho boat nsthod that oxisted. Mow, turning to Dccunont 20, pego 81 of tho English Dccunont Book, excuse no, pago 84 of tho English Dow cent Book. This dccunont confirms that ct tho request of Schaefer tho exper¬ iments regarding tho pcssiblo dorego cf tho potcblo water producod with V*ofotit wero cerriod out. Dr. Schcofcr, hevo ycu turned to that pego in tho docurcont, yourself? N 0 , I haven't. l .+ I should liko to quote free the end of Dccunont 20 - Schibit 23- it soys 1 '3nmjvi "hen 7 opering potablo rater fron see water by neons of ^ofetit SW f nc silver cr beriun Ions o->ncar in the drinking water either if the given -ropertien of Hofotit to searctcr, i.c. 1»5. ie iccrocsed or reduced, nor if diluted scawcter is used, nor if sea water cf a higher tcapcri-ture is used. Only after the water hrs been filtcrod ray any sort of odd it ions be medo or nay the drink! ns water to uoed for booking "unooes.* S373 3 June 47-A-S'>-15-5"^r®35{^£rtenfcerg) Court Jfc. 1 THE PREUMi -*hct staber document ia that? DR. nUHJ!^ That is Document No. 20, Mr. President, on pegea 84 to 88, Exhibit 23. THE IHSIDE.'Ti I don't find In ny document book, the portion ycu rood, ElURxHEIlfli Your Honor, at the end of page 38, the k st paragraph on pege 58 - su rr z-ry. THE ^RESIDENT* I have it now. DR. xELi&iNNi I reed only the sundry at the ond of the document. TCE ifl ESIDB.'Ti I underetend, C C unaol. DR. i£LKU*NNi Thus, ^r« 3c hoofer also considered tho pnaeibllity that eoewoter with a low salt content ia found , for instonco in the Baltic, end if ono also ©naiders tho tompcreiurei then tho chcmlool process is olao so that the water which ono obtains ia potablo end ianot dangerous. Now so turn to Document 21« ?hia *ia to bo Exhibit No. 24. It ia co pagos 89 to 90 of tho English Dcounont Btx>k. This la o document frea Dr. Schustor. MR. H*HDYi If it plocso your Honor, eight I oak Dofonso Counaol if thia purports to be an original copy of a letter? There la scco difficulty in tho presentation of documenta horo. In occh instance lr. tho past two days, these original German documents that ere bolng submitted arc not authenticated in tho monner ca sot forth by tho Tribunal. IV.la ono here hcanc outhonti fleet ion on it whatsoever. Duo to that fact, it gives ecuae to doubt the cuthonticity, cndl would liko to autnit it to the Tribunal for tholr perusal. It nay be thet Dr. 1'olotaenn con in due course receive c certific* tc of cuthonticity erd offer it ot thia time provisionally. IE. x ELCQUNNi May I =eke the following explanation ? "a is cp^srcnt from tho dato on the document, it is cf 10 February 1944. end the sig¬ nature hero on the original la by Dr, Sc taste rj it is c docuaont in the sane way as a document that the Prosecution submits from the year 19^4 free, let us scy. Hi trier or any other person vhc is not here as a -374 J 2 June -7-^^*-i5“£"'£”08s(-artenberg) Court No. 1 defendant cr u a xitncss. It is *c original docicer.t, end, of course, I uz net in a position to certify the sign; ture, boccuso this Dr. Schister is not eveileble. MR. Hir. Schaefer, Bcekor-Frcyscng and variue affidavits have oh-wn us that 7"u wore against the Bcrka. ncth"d and t v at y"u were •jralnot experiments "n rris-nert. You also stated that during thle dlocutel"!*.. How, yu stated that an tho occasion of the previous con¬ ference. H"v, why didn't you do so .gain o n the 25th concerning cx- porl-orte o- Luftwaffo personnel or concentration ca=p Inmates? A Cn tho 25th of Kay I again said that tho Bcrka method was n't useable after several university professors, Including persons with a European reputation, such as Ir' lessor Epplngcr and Kuobner, had. stated that the Bcrka method could n"t be rejected without a further experiment. I, ef c-urcc, could not present any nodical countor-argu- ments or refutations since I had -- military rank nr did I enj-y repu- tatl'n In science. I was, after all, then simply *n cmpl-ycc In pri¬ vate Industry. However, you had -thor reasons which yu explained to Mrs. K'-enic and which »rt corroborated lr. her affidavit, misgivings c-n- ccrning prls'ner3? A There w.s n' mention of rris*r.trs lr. this diccussl-n and. * e395 2 June 47_A_JjC.£0~2-C-*iat>erg (Inti. B r ~,) Court I I could not return to something th?t had been *aid in a previous dis- ensslnn and take that occasion to express ny private opinions of that experiment on prisoners. Moreover, such a thing would have teen a political attack on Rational Sociallsa end its systen of concentration cases, which w-uld net he exactly the thing to do in a meeting attended ty -ffleers. I- don't believe evon the aost courage~u* resistance nan would have done such a thing. * Perhaps you would like to describe to the Tribunal how you hed previously been threatened. A In a discussion that took place with Dr. Christenson be¬ fore the 19th I had serious difforonccs of opinion pnd he forbndo ay interfering in his business and he told no that Obcretar*t von Slrany certainly know alot noro about those thingo than e-nc Untcrartt. Tho aan whs had a colonel's insignia on his shoulder cortalnly was scien¬ tifically in the right also, and the higher his rank tho noro right ho was. Then thcro was ay clash with Major Jowrrek; n-t only my clash with hla, but also Bcckcr-Troysong's; and then in addition thorc was the throat that Schlcklcr rado to no at or after the meeting of tho 20 *h. All that would have boon necessary then would have been a little noto of some sort in tho ainutos of that mooting and Borka or Chrlston- son would have been ablo to get their opponent, namely ae, out of tho way. h Then, in other w->rds, you c-nsidcrcd it lnp< aoiblo, ~n tho 25th of M«y, to express you ideological objections to tho Bcrka nothod? A Tea, that was quite out of the question. TR. P2.ICDUVH: I shall read now tho rest of Frnu Koenig'a affidavit. This is again Inhibit 19 in tho supplementary v^lurfc in which she discusses Schacfor'a disappointment in the failuro of the last possibility of preventing these experiments. In the third paragraph fr-a the ond it reads — this is on uago 12V, tho first »nrHgraph: 539 > 2 June 47—i-I jC-2o-3-GeZaberg (Ir.t., 3rnWa) C?*lrt I "A sh-rt while Inter Dr. Schaefer returned hone soon after a severe air-raid, with the fallowing word* which I clearly rcne=ber| 'These asses have alto failed. I cannot understand what qualifications secured such persons their professorships. I am tired of It and I vnn't do anymore. The experiments will xrv prcbably be nade at Bruns¬ wick. 1 *1 also very voll remember that Dr. Schacfor returned froa a discussion In an enraged state saying that he had Just coao froa a neeting with officers of the Luftwaffe. He and Dr. Bcckcr-Frcyecng had been called saboteurs when declaring the Berka preparation as completely useless. Thoy also had to submit to ether strong attacks and the acotlng had noarly been broken ty," The throats against Schaefer charging hla with oabotago can nloo be soon from this docuaent and aloo froa Herr Fahl'o affidavit, which Is D'cuaer.t H-. 40 to which I have given Exhibit So. 37. This again la In a supplementary volume and, as I said, this again mentions threats against Schaefer on the chargo of sabotage. In the nlddlo of this docu¬ ment — rr, rathor, I shall road the third paragraph: ■The so-called transcript of 23 M».y 1944 (Docuncnt Ho. 177 Ex¬ hibit 133) lnc-'rroctly reports the discussion on 19 Hay. One rf tho O'tt obvious mistakes In this transcript Is the mention of a series of exporlncnts which vero supposedly to have been’ agreed upon at that time. Actually, no sorics of experiments were scttlod on this day, therefore, als n't thoso listed under rignro lA_d (6day period) and ao experimental series (12 day period). Sot one word was mentioned to the offect that the experimental subjcctc would be supplied by tho Relchsfuchror-SS or that tho experiments were to take place «t concentration camps, as tho Hr fatIt acthed was considered acceptable by all present at the confer¬ ence, the question -f experiments on humans did not arise and v* 0 n*t mentioned. The experimental scries with V-vf 8 tit was later neither suggested nor ord.ered by Schaefer. 2 June 47-l_7jC_20-4-Cc'ldbetg (Int*J SrownJ Court I ■Curing the neeting either Major JeWefek or the Chief of the tceting station Trevenucnde accused Bocker-Jrcyeeng end Schaefer of being financially interested in the Vofatit aethod. ■3ecker_Preyseng, Schaefer and I protested against this accusa¬ tion and got up tc leave the aoeting. Christenson interceded and there¬ upon ve regained.* I now nut in Dseuacnt 3*. This will he Exhibit 38, page 118. This is an affidavit by Professor Hubertus Strugh"ld. This proves that the B3RA, in other words, the C-ostepo, took ocasurcs against scientists saying th*t they wore saboteurs if they enbraccd nodical opinions that differed froa the officially accertod opinion. Tho affidavit roads: ■In fall 19*4, my two collaborators Dr. Heinrich Brso, Luftwaffe 5tabs«rst, and Dr. IrgeVrfc Schaidt investigated tho offccts of vitamin A, on night vision. They found *-ut that when coabined with a sufficient supply of fat vitaain A - when given in ncraal dosos - it improves night vision. Proa another source, it was discovered that very big doses of vitaain A - whon glvon in certain solution agonts - inpreve the night vision in a way never previously experienced. My collaborators did not conflra this. Thereupon, soac tlac lator, tho Roscarch Mrnegcacnt of tho Luftwaffe or tho Medical Inspection received a lettor froa - * bellovc the 3S Slchorungshauptaat or wha.tever lte nano was, and in this letter, ay collaborators and ay Xnstltuto were reproached of sabotago. Ac far as I recall, a correspondence took place between the two agencies named, the subject of which I d- not rcaenbor in detail. Later I hoard nr nc-ro aVut it. Anyway, the fact remains that Vth ay scientific collaborators were attacked by the aVve acntlrned organisation ncrely because they C'uld n r t conflra the results rf another research wrker. This lo a matter unheard of in tho field of science." 0390 2 JU&-&-4S-21-1-Gross ( i nt* Brows) Court No. I. DF:. ESLCKKAI.'K: Perhaps at this tine, Your Honor, we could break off. T?C rP.2SID2OT: If you have only throe n.oro you nay proceed and wo will conclude this evening. DP.. FBICKUAHNt I have only throe nore that is correct, your Honor. However, I see that the connecting test in what I intond tc crasont Iwro is so long, it would bo bottor if I presont it tomor¬ row. THE mBSIDBBr: The Tribunal 'dll be in recess until 9*30 tonorrew morning. 399 Roll 9 Target 2 Volume 23 June 3-9, 1947 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS OFFICIAL RECORD UNITED STATES MILITARY TRIBUNALS NURNBERG CASE No. 1 TRIBUNAL I U.S. vs KARL BRANDT et ol VOLUME 23 TRANSCRIPTS (English) 3-9 June 1947 pp. 8400-8789 Court 1 June 3-M-l—r-HD-rr lmeau-Frnnk » Official Transcript jf the American Military Tribunal in the matter of the United States of America, a g a in st Karl Brandt, ot al, defendants, sitting at Hurnborg, Germany, on 3 Juno 1947, 093C, Justice Beals presiding. THE 24aRSHaLL: Military Tribunal I is new in sosslen. God save the United States of America and this honorablo Tribunal. There will be order In the court. THE. PRESIDENT: Mr. Marshall, have you ascertained that tho defendants ore ell present in c urt? THE '..aRSSaLL: May It al^aso y ur H- nor, all the defendants are .'resent In the c iurt. T>2 PRESIDENT; The oecrotary-Genoral will noto for the rec'.rd the resenco of .all the defendants in court. D. I understand thrt the witness franz V-llhnrdt will first *:e called n behalf of the the defendant 3eckor-Fr-yeeng? DR. MaRX: '1th the permission of the Tribunal, lir. President, I should like to call rr foes', r V.llhardt whom * l * . Tribunal has permitted t. on-oar as an exoort wltnoss n boh- If f defendant 8c..roodor and Dr. dcckor-Freyoeng, and vh .- -s also been allowed t • testify on behalf of defendant Dr. Bolglboock. THE PRES IDEM: The marshall will show to the witness stand Franz Vollhordt. FRa1:z VOLLHaRDT, a witness, t ok the stand and test¬ ified as follows: BY JUDGE 8E3RING: hold x your right hand and be sw* rr., 'lease, 1 me the oath: I swear by God, the Almighty yx. Car.isclV*Aj\ that I will s enk the mure truth and wljl (withhold -nd n- thing. (The witness repeated the ootr.) M\ / JUDGE S23RIKG: You may sit down. ^ DIRECT EXAMINATION BY DR. I^RX: 8UOO Court 1 Juno 3-i4-l-*-HD-?rlodau-Frank. Q, Professor, please, would you state y'.ur full name. A* Frcnt Vollhardt. £. Where and when wore you born? A. Munich, 2 May 1872. Q. Ploaso, w.uld you briefly toll the Tribunal what your sclontiflc activities have been and reg-rding which spocira field and since when you have taken a particularly groat Interest? A. I an Professor of Internal Medicine at Frankfort and predominantly, I have dealt with the question of circulation, metabolism blood pressure or kidney diseases. Q. Which aro tho Goman Universities where you have boon a lecturer? A. Halle and Frankfort. 2. Hove y u boon an author of scientific work regarding this sooclal field of activity? A. Yes. 3. Have they been circulated and translated in forolgn countries and in foreign languages? A. Yos, they have boon translated in Russian, behand my back. Q. C nslderlng tho facts you have Just stated, would it bo right to say th-t you hr>vo had honors allotted to you in this c.untry and abroad, so would you please telo tho Tribunal what types of decoration you have received abroad. A. I really have to? Q. Whloh foreign academies and Foreign societies have you been a member of? Professor, I really want you to answer my questions because I am sure my questions pursue certain purposes. A. I am Honorary Doctor at tho Sorbonne, Paris, at Gottingen and Frolburgj and, as far as societies are o401 I Court 1 Juno &-!4-l-3-HD-?rlocau-Frank. c nc-rnod, there are i lot of trios, Medical Society at Edinburg, at Cenf, at Luxemburg. I as an Honorary Monbor of trie university et Santlage, and so on and so forth. <. Thanh you very such. Thor. I w uld be lntorostod t. hoar fr s you whether you had c •nnaotions with the N8DAP and what s .rt of c'-*n..ectl-ns they wore and whether trio Party persoout d y u in any way. Perhaps, you night answer tri. last question first. When I was lecturing In Spanish In South «norlca nd when I was giving a lecturo in Corjoba Argentina, beforo a sedlc-’l Congress, I recelvjd a tclegrau to trio effect that I nad been relieved fr.n ,:y office and the reaa a giver, was loch of antl-socitlc attitude. Q. When was that? «. 1938. Q. «nd since when hrve y u nco sore be-n reinstated and aro r a active again? «. Since 1945. I 3t02 3 Jun-tt-i3-2-1-Gross (Int* Frank) Court No. I. Q As a full ja*ofesscr? A Yes, as full professor far Internal Medicine at the Univ¬ ersity of Frankfurt. Q How, Professor, a few questions recarding your own re¬ search work. You have dealt particularly with hunger and thirst treat¬ ment in tie oase of kidney diseases. Is that correct? A Yes. Q So that you have personal radical and scientific exper¬ ience regarding the observation of human beir-gs when they undergo hun¬ ger and thirst treatment? A Yes. Q Mr. President, bofore continuing with the examination of this oxport witness I should like to permit nysolf to make a suggestion. There aro two typos of possibilities for the examination of Professor Vollhardt regarding questions which interest us here. One possibility, the one which I nysolf consider the corroct one, is that Profosoor Vollhardt should give us a continuous oxport opinion regarding tho ontiro complex of questions which are of interest here, arri that at tho oid I would thon permit ays elf to put a few concluding quostiona to the export hore as, of cou-sc, any defence counsel and prosocutor is entitled to do, too. The other possibility would bo that I put a number of individual questions to tho oxport which would deal with tho subject chronologically ard technically from a nodical point of view. But, that would distort context and would not give as clear a picturo of the situation as would tho first possibility. I should like there¬ fore, Hr. Frosidont, for you to make a decision whether tho expert is to give an opinion in tte fora of ono iecturo first. TrE i?.ESID2:T: If counsel would propound to tho ritnoss a hypothetical question covering the basic facts which hero arc at issue, and if tho witness would answer that hypothetical question without fur¬ ther question from counsel and rake his response brief and to tho ard without enlarging too much upon the fact that salt water is not fit 8A03 3 Jun-!W!E-2-2-Gross (Int. Frank) Court No. I. to drink and is injurious, which the Tribunal very well knows, >ro might proceed that way aa suggested by counsel* The hypothetical question should cover the facts here at issue, that experiments wore tried upon a group of pooplo, a control group, a non-control group and others, thin the witness may answer that question without further interruption by counsel if his answer is, as I said, brief and not enlarging too much on generalities* DR. : ASX: Very well, ISr. President. Q Now, Professor, do you have sufficient insight into the planning and carrying out of tho so callod sea water oxporironts in order to give an oxj*rt opinion on that subjoct? A Yoa. Q What docuaontary ovidonco did you have? A I had tho original records propared by Boiglboock which I had seen* Q I shill first of all doal idth tho character and typo of t tho ojQorinonts. Are thoro difforuncos bo two on tho character of tho so sea wator oxporisants such as oxporinonts with artificial Infection with nalaria and cholera and; if thoro are differences, what are thoy? A You can't cooparo tho two at all, becauso in tho caso of tho sea wator exporinonts you have things so jxirfoctly under control and can interrupt 30 instantaneously and because tho experiments liad boon planned at 3hort notico, it could bo oxcludod with absolute cert¬ ainty that no darage could bo done* In tho case of artificial infoc- tion you can not do that* Q You are saying that in the case of sea wator experiments, % providing they aro interrupted in time, danger to health and bocy can bo avoided with certainty or bordering on certainty? A Not tha Latter* I said with aboolutc cortrinty. Q I shall now coco to the planning of these experiments. Did Professor Sppingor's participation and the participation of Professor Kouoner during tho meeting decisive for tho planning of 2 $ Uay 19Wi, auoh 3 Jury-IME-2-3-Gross (Inti Frank) . Court Ko. I# • which I assume you know about, did they givo a guarantee for purely scientifically and medically proper treatment of the problem? A )lo doubt they did. Professor Heubner is a loading scientist and an extremely critical porson, and Professor Eppingor was one of tho leading clinicians in the world and a most outstanding ox- pert, and I ftSEixao both of the so gentleman had reasons for allotting the so experiments to be carriod out, presumably in order to strengthon tho back of tho aadical nan, vis-a-vis tho technicians. And, secondly, it scons to havo been in Eppii«or»a mind that during such oxtromo ex¬ perimentation conditions eight bo possible that the kidney would suffer noro than up to that tino and it night havo boon that Borkatit which contains vitamins might support tho work of tho kidnoy. Q FTofossor, what is your opinion about tho individual ex¬ perimental groupe? A I think that sciontifically spoking tho planning was ox- ccllont and I tovc- no objection to tho ontiro planning. It was jpod to add a h\ngor-orl- conts nourishment doesn't play any part. HR. HARDY i Kay it plor.so tho Tribunal, night 1 inquire whether tho tritnoss is now testifying to facts as ho has ascertained than from stutfying graphs and charts raado by ft*cfossor Boiglboock or is ho testifying free hearsay that food was givon to the so inrv.tos or what is tho basis of his knewlodgo that ho is oliciting here? A I was giving ny testimony basod on the records which I hnvo studied. HR. HARDY: Thank you. A But I don't attach a-.y irportanco to the aoagor food sorvod dicing tho oxperirents because that is an insignificant point lfhich as I have said wo havo alio ted to others many tiros. T!C HISSIDSIT: Witless, idicn you referred to this examina¬ tion of tho records, state briefly just what records you oxaninod. A The original records. THE .-32SIDS.7: Comprising tie charts that were taken fron 3 Jur.-H-> 3-2-5-Gross (Inti Prank) Court No. I. day to day during the experiments? A Yes. TIE PRESIDENT: I would ask counsel for the defonso if those charts arc available hero in the Tribunal? DR. MARX: Ur. President, thoso charts are not in ay hands. They aro hold by the defense counsel for the defendant Bciglbocck. THE PRESIDENT: Counsol say proceed. % HR. HARDY I Your Honor, I have the charts in ny hands at this tine. I will pass then up to tho Tribunal for their purusal. I haven*t had an opportunity yot to purusc then, thareforo, I don't know what thoy scan. THE PRESIDENT* It is not nocossary to subnit tho charts to th.- Tribunal at this tire. I would ask counsel for dofonso if thoso charts purport to bo tho conplcto record of thoso oxperinonts fron tho beginning to tho end? STEE3AUEP. (For tho Dcfondant Bciglboock): Hr. Prolidont, I m in tho nost fortunate position of laving boon able to study Boigl- boeclc's records in his previous office and to find his additional notorial which ho usod for tho cccposition of thoso records. I found corn of the30 in Vienna and brought tho- along at Christmas rnd imed- iatoly showod then to Dr. Alexander in tho original. Dr. Ivy wr.3 hero fron Anorica at that nooonfc and dor.lt with t*.viso records, locked at thcci carefully and ther. in tho prcsonco of tho dofondant roturnod than to no. CU07 3 Jun-IM .3-3-1-" arrow (Int. Frank) Court ;!o« I. T— HSS3DEKT: Counsel, ny question was whether or not thoso cherts purport to be a ccoplote record free the beginning of the ex¬ periment to the ond of the experiment. That was the only point con¬ vince in ny question. D.l. ST2H01USR: Yoa, at the tine I was looking for then, the tables of weights wore missing. I started looking for them and I have found the original potionts' histories, aade up for oach indiv¬ idual .ntiont froa 1 to Uli, so wo can prove, in groat detail, how thoso oxporironts developed, How, thoso tables are ava.il~.blo, Tho P.-ofossor ccwposod then in a weight table which is contained in Docu¬ ment Book 3 bocauso it had been i;-«ss^blc to copy the so things. T3S .RESIDE!.?: I understand that. Counsel. But thoso charts purport to bo complete to tho end of tho oxporireont? That's tho point in which tho Tribunal is interested. D... STIINBAUERj Yes, ttoy aro. :P.. HARDYt U‘y T ask a quostion of counsel. Your Honor? Tho proBecution desires to know whether or not those charts and rocords purport to bo thoso charts and records undo during tho c our so of tho experiments, or whothor Profoscor Boiglboock coaplotcd then after tho er.«rlr*.ent3? THE PRESIDENT: Counsel will answer tho quostion propounded by the prosecution. D.l. STEDi'BAlER* Yes. That's quito out of tho quostion sinco Professor Dciglboack didn't oven know where tbo docurants woro. Ho is a typical profossor who leaves things lying everywhere. I aanagod to gather then togottor - bits of paper, notebooks, all sorts of things. I got it together with much pair. 1 brought it to Tiurnborg and I didn't part with it until the witness saw then, and by comparing tho handwrit¬ ing, this car. to ascc-rtairod. It's quite out of tho question that any¬ thing could possibly have been altered in thoso notes. IS. HARDY: What disturbs mo, four Honor, is that on ono of the charts the name of tho subject is erased. The subject's nano appoarod CACC 3 Jut.-. — 3-3-2-:;^rrow (Litj Frank) Court !fe. I. hero and now it has tx:cn erased free the top of the chart, and througlw out the clarts I have bc^n unable to read tho German language and I only received then about thirty minutes ago, T” fRmSHEHT: Such a natter as that can properly be tnkon up in cross-examination. h’ith the understanding that these charts contain a complcto record free tho beginning of tho oxnorir-unt to tho end of tho experi¬ ment, counsel say proceed with tho examination of tho witnoss. 3Y D?.. VJiSXt Q Frofossor, how do you judge tho individual exaninations carried out by Professor Bciglboock? '.ere they adoquato for tho solution of the practical question whether Borkatit was sufficiently usoful and a preferable thirst troatasnt, and was it sufficient to judgo tho daily condition of tho oxpurinontal subjocts so that tho right tiuo to inter¬ rupt tho oxcorinonts could bo ascertained? Did you get ay question? A Tes, I«Vc got it. I thought that tl» nrrnngci-onts of this., oxperiixnts was splendid from tho scientific point of vie.., and, apparently with trenv- ondous industry and great responsibility Boiglboock dovotod hiasolf to tho carrying out of those experiments which ho had boon ordered to do. Q Would it bo right to ary that a personality such as Bciglboock, as a professor of Interior Ibdicino and chief nodical officer at a clinic for nany years, on tho basis of daily oxanina ions and through his personal consideration and examination of the experimental subject, would 1>j in a position to recognize any threats to the health of tho person before s’ich threats could actually t\.coao serious. A That was a tatter of course. 3eislbocck is an excellent internal .nodical aan and the gr«.r.t care with which ho carried out the so oxyorinonts shows that he was fully conscious of his re sensibility. CTily, it's hare to imagine that, during such brief experiment* serious damage could have occurred at all. i 3409 3 Jon-: S-3-3-? arrow (Int* Frank) Court "o. r . •?.. :cHAJEY: I object to tlx Latter part of the answer and ask that it bo stricken free tlx record. This aan is an oxcort and, as I understand it, he knows nothing whatsoever personally about tho aannor in which tlx so oxporieonts wore conducted. I therefore) tnku it ho is not in n position to State h an Dr. Beiglboock conducted tho ox- poriaonts. T'C raZSIDEMT: Tho Tribunal understands tho knowledge of tho witness and tho objection will bo ov-rruiod. The record may stand. !R. ?*c HANEY: While I ns on ay feet I ».ould lilco to observe that of course tho tostinony of this vitness is of suppositivo probative valuo at this timo. Tho records upon srhich ho is basing his tosticony hrvo not been adbittod in cvidonco. Tlsoy have not been, in any va.y, identified. Tin EVIDENT: That is understood. That is tho situation beforo tho Tribunal. DR. KAftXt Vi*. President, I do want to say a few things nbout that. Professor Vollhardt, -XUr all, is an internationally’ recognized sciontist who, particularly with rog.ard to tho fiold in which vo aro intorostod tore, nnaely that of thirst and water supplios, is tho inter¬ national capacity, as one puts it, so that ho is in a position, on tho basis of thoso clinical records of rrofossor leiglboock, to fort. an opinion regarding tho way thoso cxporixnts woro carriod out. I can*t iragirvo that such a san would not be in a position, on tho strength of such Material, to fora an opinion. T : -:: rxaSJDSNTj Counsel, it is not a quostion of tlio ability of the witness to Torn his opinion, but tlto records upon which ho is basing l»is opinion are not in evidence before tho Tribunal. Tlioy Uavu not been subject to oxnaination and crcss-cxTaination, and tho witness* testiiony is based upon tho supposition that ti;os_- records aro correct, .and they aro not ev^n before tho Tribunal at this tire. That was all tho st-.te..xr.t ’cf counsel was intended to convoy. If the records had al¬ ready be on admitted in evidence, and ->_cn oxaninod, and people oxxi_nod C410 3 2-3-,-farrow (Int. Frank) Court Vu drink a largo quantity at onco. If you distribute it over a dry you suffor frea consti-ntion. Q Yus, but you didn't quite answer ay question. I inquired about the individual d^eos. A Yos, woll, I 1 n trying to say that if you spread it out over a day, giving snallcr individual dcsos instead of all at cnco, then thxro isn't any danger of diarrhea. Q Can you deecribj soa wa.t-r as poisonous at all? A Absolutely nr. There is a trond towards tho troatoont with sea watox* which is increasing, and ;«oplo aro drinking half a liter of soa water, -vary day, for wooks. Thoro can't bo any question of poisonous quality. In fact, .uoplo say they are fooling splendidly. Tho only difference is that in t?» case of such euros fresh water is .administered too in tho manner :f tea, coffo- and soup so that tho do- hydrifying offoct of tho s^a. water is ecno away with. Q rtc£v.sscr, I wonder If you would spe“lc a little naro slowly and make a pause aft^r individual answers in ur&_r to arable tho intor- pr-t-rs to folio*.:. Has thoro been an experiment during which a desj of 5O0^lo 1 ,CC0 cc of soa rrat„r doily w-s taken and it is to be dcscri'ood as dan ge r ou s providing tho experiment is discontinued as seen as thoro io a threat of a danger tc health? A Thxr^ can't ex. any quest! n f thoro b_ing .any danger to health during the first few days. niy quest! n is, how long can 3412 3 Jun-^j-!B-3-&-Xarrcir (Ins. Prank) Court lfc>. I. the body stand up to this continuation of the deprivation of hiaidity? So- water has a three per cent salt water content. Generally speaking, at least so far, re hove assumed this to bo so, that tlx. kidneys can- r."t deal with such a salt concentration sc that salt will remain in tho • syston which is anxious to collect water fron the tissues. In tho be¬ ginning, this is of no icpartanco; but after six or seven or eight days, this bee ones unpleasant and it is to bo expected that after tho twelfth dry thoro is sore danger, but there have boon casus 'X son rescue when oven seventeen or Dare days afterwards recovery' was achicvod, but one would generally say that I would novor continue such an experi¬ ment - dare to continue such an oxporinont beyond tho twelfth day, and in this case with which ro are concerned, all oxporinonts woro dis¬ continued "/tar the sixth day, so that danger to health during that porird was rut nf tho question. Q Could the ain of those oxperL ontc have been achieved wit}i a safti-ponotrablu suflbrano? A I can't understand how one should inagino this. V/hat wo ore concorncd dth is tho question of how long tho htsacn body can sur¬ vive idthout water and under tho oxcoss quantity of salt. Now, that is tfubjoct bo tho water contents of th~ body and it depends upon whotlior, first of all, water is only usod by tho intermediary tissues or what her tho coll liquid too is being used up. In tho latter case, there i3 a danger which bcccrras apparent through excess potassiun quantities and this was also continuously observed and chockod during such ox-xrl-^nts and there Tore no oxcoss Potassium quantities such as can bo axcoctud after six days. Court 1 June H5—I^aloy—Fronk 3. Nor would It be right to say that these experiments • ore lanncd scientifically and medically, is that corroct? absolutely so. v. Could they have been planned differently? n. I couldn't Imagine how. C. "ore these experiments In the interest of an active warfare, or in the Interest of the care of ship-wrecked sailors or soldiers? The latter. C. In other words f r aviators and sailors who woro ahlp-vrocked or would bo shlp-wrockod? A. Towards the ond of the war there was an lncronBO In tho cases of pilots who had been shot down ns woll no the cases "f shipwrecked aors^nnol, and It was therefore tho d ty of the hy b leno department concerned to cor.sldor the question of how no c uld deal best with such cases of shlp-wrockod personnel, that was tho roaeon how this c nforonco o^ao ab ut. Previously Schaefor, as wo ho. rd yeaterday, h"d rec- amondod not to drink mytnlng. *.‘(‘hon t gather with I.C. he succeeded In eliminating salt and ‘ lcter salt fr c sea water thr-ugh V* Ifatlt tho problem was really solved scientifically. There were, however, c nsidorabU technical difficulties ond It lGn't exactly aim lo to equip o-oh filer with Sv much 'Jo If at It In addition to everything else ho has t* carry in order to ’protect him a alnst the danger of shlp-wrcck. That is no d.ubt why Spplnger and nuebner were In f-vor of tho ox orient, and it w a unfortunate that hr. 3crka appeared with Bei'katlt at the same time, and Impressed the technicians, because his method was more simple and cheaper. J.. rrofos Q cr, v-’e there any rcas- n to epict la.tor syp.pt ms of dnmr_e which might o .near l~tor than 1C days. 'MU. Court 1 Juno &-I4-4— 2-K3-Hnloy-Fr?ink aftor tho end of the experiment? "• It was entirely ^ut of tho question, even aftor tho seventh day. Late* "lagc is out of the question, because the duration of the ex ».xents is toe. short. Q. To what do y^.u attrltxito the loss of weight during such experiments? A. That is almost entirely the loss of water. «s I have alroady told y^u the excess salt supply in tho bsdy deprived tho b^dy of water. Tho body au6t have a supply of water if it is to supply salt. In other words, if the body is not receiving any othor water than sea water tho attack against tho water held by tho body must toko place, and thoroforo a loss of volght is b und to happen, which, however, can bo caught up with instantly. Q. What would y:.u say to bo oxpoc'tcd in tho way of tho loss of substance of tho body and how much loss of water? A. I would say tho bulk is tho loss of water, but to s jilt this up is s'nothing I consider Impossible to do with cortnlnty. Y.u night possibly oomparo Just hew much was lost during tho tine applied by Schaefer when there was consldorablo hunger and how ouch was lost in tho case of water. Q. Does tho speed play an important part with which the loss of water takes place? A. Yes, of c urse, a tremondcus part. Tho colored nostras is a well-known example during which disease, tho must tremendous loss of water and salt takes place during 24 hi urs. I knew a case where 10 liters 'of water and 150 grams of salt had to be added lntraven- usly through the venes, the skin and through the stomach in order to save that part¬ icular life of a person suffering fr-n such an acute loss of Court I June 3-H-4-3-KD-Maloy-?rEn}c water. IT on the other hand this 13 spread out ov.r a period of days and If you ac not have tc. expect such a dangerous loss of tha salt, then the holy can stand up t:. It d-r a such l nger period. I eight -orhaps add that the loss of salt is Just ns dangerous as excess quantities of salt, nr.d also in the event of the loss of salt wnioh Is always C'nnected with voter considerable losses of weight are suffered. It Is well-known that an expedition on the mountain M nto Rose lost 5 kilograms,, and the loss of salt and water, and that the weight could not bo replaced In s;.ito of the addition of water when salt was also addod. *i. Professor, according to the doousonts at y ur disposal wore these experiments sufficiently woll prepared? a. It was ay laprosslon that thoy wore extremely woll prepared, and I was particularly impressed by tho faot that Bolglboook had sufficiently exanlned tho partici¬ pants oarefully and had considered tho use of thorn to bo unsuitable slnco ho f und a defect of the lungs. 5. I dso wont to doal with such preparations- 151. KcKaNEY: I do not think by nny stretoh of tho lnuiglnatl n o*n this witness testify fr-a the rooordo that BoigolbOock conducted an oxaaln'tlon or rejected throe ox orlnontol subjects. In ay opinion It does not a poor froui tho records, and he can • nly testify what Soi-clboeok t' Id hla. Unless he can say it d'os s, :enr In tho reoord6 I think It should 'co stricken. THE PRESIDENT: Counsel has an - :~ortunlty of cross- exaainlng tho witness at the close of his testloony. k. Professor, w uld y u n t soy c at preparation for these experiments also means that certain experiments, suoh as experiments on oneself and animal experiments, ..rinted preparations. If y/a like, must have beer. In oxlstonoo or CU6 I Court 1 June 3-'4-4-4-HD-Kcloy-?rcnk was that true cf this ease? A. Yes, a report from oclgelboeck about an experiment carried out upon hlcsolf Is In existence which describes the condition nost efficiently. In which ho found himself during a sen water experiment, and this description talllos to the highest possible degree with what ay voluntoers have doacrlbcd who h^ve submitted thensolves to theso oxperl- nonts. I night doal with that later. Q. Whot opinion do you hove regarding the experiments which wore carried out by 31rany In Vienna? A. Thero appeared to laok a critical attltudo to no. I think Schaefor had tho sane lnprosslon yonterday. Q. nro symptoms reoognlrablo regarding tho planning of those exporinont3 whloh would go beyond tho absolutely essential practical pur. oses and whloh w uld load to considerable pains or painful feelings or night have load to that? h. Of ojurso It Isn't fun to be thirsty, and that Is tho major complaint In theso casos. Theso poo /lo aro Increasingly thirsty, and they are disappointed to find that tho administering of sea wator doesn't dooreaoo It, but lnorcasos their thirst, and towards tho end of tho experi¬ ments arc disturbances of tho muscles and the mood doesn't exactly lmprovo. It Is the sane In tho salt water experi¬ ments v/nore there aro cramps of tho calf, becr.uso of tho lack of water, but the chiractorletlcs of that oro theso symptoms disappear Instantaneously at tho very moment when £ the first gln6s of water Is dr^nk. 3. Would you cnsldor It possible that disturbances of the nerve end might appear, - temperature? A. Temperature doesn't happen at all, and I can't imagine there are disturbances of the nervous system at all. oU 7 Court 1 June 3-&-4-5-HD-Maloy-Frank Q. How about rage? In the case of insane people there any appear Insane r-ges, say bo, but not In the case of n rnal human beings. If y’»u y .urself had been placed lr. this o ndltion would you consider your attitude toward nodical et/.los, do you h'-.ve objections to carrying .ut the sn.mc typo of oxporloont -a was o: rrled out here, if healthy stron- young ncr. had been at your disposal? A. I actually did it. Since I was interested in c nneotion with sen-water ex eriner.ts. I colled for volunteers nffloung ny young doctors, mil five of then volunterrod, amongst then: ay youngoet s'.n, and thoy drank the synthetic sea water, hnvln b the ox^ct amount contont of ooa w. ter to the extent of drinking 500 oo=; they _ot n little food, because thoy were to continue on duty durln 0 the ox orlaent. The loss of weight varied and was around one kilogram a day. nt the end of the experiment ny son got .retty thin, but aft^r h?vln a a cup of tea was flno. Two days later ho had regained It fully. All five part¬ icipants desorlbod the experiment In tho onao way ns 3oi_olboock doscrlbcd the experiment carried out on hlnself. Four of those subjects interrupted the experiment after five days. One carried It out for six days, and utsldo of the resent tnlrst he had no c n-l-inte. Any sorl.ua disturbance or darxuv is . at of the q uoetl-.n, and the extraordinary f ct was the aieod with which all symptoms -' tl-.lrct dlsr. * oared after -eater had been administered. Court 1 June 3-5-1-H-KD-Moehon-Frank. Q. Vould it have been possible at all to carry out such experiments if cxperlnental subjects had not cooperated willingly? A. No, you can -nly carry out such experiments with v luntoers because that collaboration is indispensable, but that d'es not exclude that they might treat the man in chargo of such experiments, such as many educated persons will try to deceive the ^edlc^l expert during such casos and thoy will probably oat n beefsteak during such a hunger cure or drink somethin© during thirst treatment. In this oaso thon there wore s< me failures nnd some did got a hold of drinking water secretly. C„. Professor, you said that the cooperative attitude of the ox'erlmontal subjects is indosponsablo; night I ask you Just why It is indispensable? A. occauso thlr6t, as I havo told you, is not a ploasnat symptom over a longthly period. It is quite un- plocBant to bo able to think of water alono and droan of wntor and to have a dry mouth and a dry thront. Thus, you havo t'. have a certain amount of power of resistance. I can wall imagine that unoducatod end weak.individuals night lose tnolr willingness to collaborate after that. Q. But it is not right to say that for the samo reason it is lndlsponsable if the observing doctor is doponding of the statements made by the experimental subjeots if ho cannot control and check everythin^ that ..000 on in the rar.n^ mind. h. That is correct, but the analysis later on would show that the man had sooetaln^ to drink during the findings. £. Did you see any photo t raphs of tho expcrlnental subjects? «. I saw the pictures, the neJccd bodies, and I saw C419 Court 1 June 3— '/•-5—2— HD— lieo han-F re nk« they were etr ng, well fed and well-conditioned people. Do you know. Professor, to what extent and In what direction filers and sailors of other nations had been equipped In order to survive the ship-wrecks? A. There were a gre-t variety of experiments, but I d.n*t think that Is important because thoy were nr.do with water catching sails, etc., but at any rate they did not have that excellent dru 0 Volfatlte. itR. KaRDY: The witness has Just testified a6 to the condition of subjects used in the experiments as he saw in pictures. Inasnuoh as the witness has testified to that effect, the Prosecution desires to see the pictures which the witness and defense oounsel has mentioned. Thoy are In the .i: nde of the defense counsel for Professor Sol^lboeck end t.ie prosecution thinks It is only fair that tney be turned over to the .;rosooutlon at tr.la time. THE PRESIDENT: On cross-examination the proscoution may roqueet to se^ the pictures. Counsel for defendant may exhibit tne pioturos to tr.e -roseoutlon; thoy have no objections. l-Ci. aaRCY: Your Honor, it would be rather late for ue to study the pictures between now and during the time of cross-examination. THE rRESIDENT: If the pictures are available, I think the defense counsel enould submit them to the prosecution for examination. DH. AaAX: Mr. President, I myself do not nave those photographs and I would think that later on durln. Prof. 3elgl;oeck*3 testimony or durln- Dr. dtelnbauer's examina¬ tion with the witness of Professor Vollhardt, the opportun¬ ity will aris- to snow the photographs. • C420 . Court 1. June 3-Iv-5—3-HD—Meehan-Trank 3Y D3. ;^.RX: Nov, Professor, the experiments we were talking about; did they have a practical valuable ale and did they show a corresponding result? A. Yes, that is correct. For instance an Important observation was mado which Epplnger had expected and desired to carry out to see If the kidneys d;d concentrate salt under such extreme conditions to an oven higher extent than one expected previously. One thought that it would be some¬ thing like 2.0* but 2.6 or 2.7* and rocord figures of 3.0, 3.5, 3.6 and 4* are shown so that the fortunate man who Is In a position to concentrate 3.6 * or 4* of salt would bo able to live on sea-water for quite a long period. THE PRESIDENT: Witness, after a question Is propounded to you by your counsel, would you pause n moment boforo giving your answer so that the question may bo translatod and convoyed and when you begin to make your answer, would you 8*poak a little core slowly? THE WITNESS: Finally, one unsuspected fact occurod which may be connected with this and that 16 the rosult that the drinking of small quantities of sen-water up to 500 cc given ever a longthy period turned out to bo bettor than *'uro thirst. 3Y DR. MARX: Q. What do you think of Wofatlt generally? It Is a wonderful think. Q . Is It correct to say that sea-water really assumes tho character of drinking water through It? A. Yes, the only difficulty would appear tc bo to obtain the drug In sufficiently large quantities for a man who Is sea-wrecked and did not have r.is luggage; but It is a. wonderful discovery. Court 1 June 4-HD-ifeehan-Frank, * *-• So, you think that the result of these experiments does not only have importance in the case of o war, hut is of importance for the problems of sea-faring nations? «. ^uite right, it is n wonderful thing for all 6oa- farln. notions. So that both the experiments with --bfatit, as well as tho experiments made regarding the symptoms when such a drink woe not vaila'ole, were important to display, such for instance ns the consumption of sea—water In certain given dosos. n. That is quite correct. ... That w■ s only discovered by use of these experiments? a. *ulte correct. 1. hr. President, I have no further questions to tho Witness Vollhurd at this point. TKS ?R£5ID£'.'T: Any other defense counsol have any questions tc be propounded to this witness? 3Y DP.. 8TEI;'3aU 2R: (Defense counoel for Defendant Prof. Dr. 2el 3 lboeck.) Z. Witness, first of all may I put a formal question to y u. The Prosecutors, are, as a rule, the most suspicious people. It is quite poslble that these Prosecutors might state that the documents which I have submitted are collosol forgeries by Professor Belglboeck. Let me ask you then, as a scientist, would you consider it possible that c..ese documents which I n-vc given you for your expert opinion ere original documents or If they ere for-ed? a. I consider that the latter is out of the question. Z. Thank you. You also have .:ad an opportunity tc look at the weight tables which I submitted already In document book 2 ; would you consider th t the figures re gar d- in_, v: lghts °nd loss of water contained therein are correct? CL22 Court 1 June 3-*H-5-5-HD-Meehan-Frank. a. y e8l 2. One further question; Do you believe as a scientist that one could not have saved oneself the trouble of these experiments and satisfied themselves by animal experiments? n. In the case of problems" of water and salt metabolism that is not to be assumed for the simple reason that rabbits and dogs react differently, that is the difference between vegetable and meat eating beings. The dogs, our most Important experimental animal, has no perspiration glands, and can concentrate water much more efficiently than the human beings. Q. Let me come bock to the question of diarrheas once again; Do you consider diarrheas occuring a fortnight or two later after the conclusion of the experiments as being connected with sea-water experiments? A. I consider that out of the question because sea¬ water experiments lead to constipation and how one may suffer from diarrhea afterwards is a mystery to me. Q. Is it correct that during lack of water the body restrains the persperation lnterslvllos and the govlng off of perspiration through the pores? A. That is correct. <2. Would it be right to assume that the consumption of fresh w. ter by the expcrlmental subject would reduce the subjective and objective symptoms considerably? A. Yes, you have to assume that. It is extraordinary how much the subjective symptoms ore decreased by s mall quantities of drinking water. 0.23 3 June Itf-Vt-S—6-1-Cook (F-enk) Court 'o. i TEE Jt XDEJJTi Counsel, the Triburxl is about tc go lr.to recess. I sec r.c possible retscr. rhy counsel for the deferdent should r.#t subr.it these photographs to counsel for the rrosecution. I feci compelled to direct thet counsel shoo these photogrephs to the FJ-osecution* I see r.c retsen that they shcttld.net. The Tribuncl now will be in recess fer e feu ooaonts. Cd.21> 3 J0n-*i-!3-7—I-Gross (Int. Bronx) Coirt Ho, I. ?*— l&RSHAL: Tte Tribunal is again in session. TIC HGSUCOT i Counsel aay proceed. BY DH. ST JHBAUSRi Q Professor, teforo tho rocoss wc said that the ingestion of even snail quantities of frosfi water influences the subjective and objoctivc condition of the wibjoct. liar, tho question - from tho tables of weights that have been presented, can it bo ascertained whether tho subjects have drunk fresh Trr.tor? A That is certainly possible, since tho loss of weight must occur with a rcdund-.nco of sodiio nitrate and tho woight is not lcet if frosh wator is drunk. Q Ignoring tho question of the state of tho blood, tho con¬ tent of nitrogon, otc. A witness horo nontionod a certain incidont that occurred, a screening spasn, a tetanic spnsn; do you regard that incidont as dangerous? A !fo. * • Q 'i."ny not? A Scroaning spasns occur in casws of hysterical persons. This ire not tetanus. This was a to ta no id condition which occurs liko tho craaf6 in cholera, and the increase in ausclo irritability in tho sea-wator oxpjrir-onts. This is ontircly unimportant. That it was not truo tot-mss can bo socn fron tho fact that tho nost important synptons of tetanus x.-crc uissing. Q Thon, surrlng up, I should liko to ask you, is it corroct when I say th~t tho experiments nado v<*y high donands ospocially on tho will-poTajr of the expertntal subjects? A Yes, you c-n say that. Ti.^5 Court So. 1 3 Jus 47-K-S-l-iat-Serrov (Brown) Q, In carrying out the sane experiaent in a hospital, vould It also have teen necessery to keep the experimental subjects segregated and under strict control? A. It vould have been even nore necessary* It takes a great strength of will to subject oneself to thlrsi. q, Vae It nedlcally Justified for Beiglboeck to continue the experlaent after it vas discovered ty analysis that the person had secretly drunk water? A. The experlnent should really have been begun again. Q. Sow, to exclude any possibility of doubt, your answer applied to people vfao have carrlod out the experiment the way they should and have drunk only sea water? % A. Tes, that Is eo. Sow, does this oxperlaent involve special pain or torture for the subject? A. That vould be an exaggerated statenant, but thirst is a torncnt I draw your attention to the ancient a>;the of Tantalus and Sioyphus. Of course, it is a tornent not to bo able to drink and to droan about drinking, tut ay aen said it wasn't really so bad that it could be called torture. Q, Sow. let as ask you, to sua up, vfcat about fatalities, in these experiments? Are they inpossible or not? A. They are entirely impossible. Q. Co you consider a lasting injury to health possible or inpoc- slble? A. That is Just as iapossible ns fatalities. TKB PHKSiroi: Counsel, will you instruct the vitness not to answer your question until the interpreters have fully coopleted inter¬ preting your question? 3T DR. SBUBABER* Q. Professor, I esk you to answer in such a way as to permit the interpreters to have finished translating the Question. Court So. 1 3 Jun 47-i'-6~2-2EH-Xarrov (Brown) Sow, I have one last ouestloa to put to you. If fatalities end serious Injury to health are assumed ns e hyr>o- thetlcal possibility, then I want to ask you whether you. es a physician, eabrace the point of view that arranging and executing such experiments ere offonses against hunenity. A. If I did, I would not hare carried out the experiments on ay own son and on ay students. There can be no ouestion herein of inhumanity or of brutality, as little as in the case of therapeutic hunger end thirst cures, which I like to carry cut. In vie- of the good food given to the experimental subjects. I should like to ncntion that one of tho vcoon shoo I treated in this way had the oitiful weight of 51.7 kilograms and lost three kilograas during the experiment. DR. STEISBAUEH: Kr. President, during the rocoss I gave tho nrooocutor photostats and photographs of the experioental subjocts oo far as I hare thee. I shall show theso, if tho Tribunal wishes, to tho Tribunal, but I should prefor to subalt the originals, at least, to tho Tribunal in tho course of ay caso, which has suffered anyhow bccouso tho expert case first and not last. At that tloo I ohall give thorn exhibit numbers. TEE PrSSinUn: The photogronhs may be sutnitted to tho Tribunal lator in tho courso of the examination. DR. STZIHBAU5B: So fur*.bor Questions. THE PRESIDES!: Any Questions to be propounded to this witness by any othor defense counsel? DR. 7LE.-»ISG (Defense counsel for tho defendant Mrugovsky): Hr. President, I ask permission to csk the exmert witness four Questions regarding the circulation of the blood. -HE PRESIDES!: Counsel thon desires to make this witness his own witness for this purpose? Si. T&Mn ISC: Tcs. TEE PRESIDES!: Very well, proceed. Court Ke. 1 3 Jus 47 -H-&- 3 -EB«arr 0 v (Brown). 3T 23. TLSOilSS: Q, Is it true that after typhus there Is freouently a weakening In the circulation of the blood7 1. Tes. Q, Can blood-letting in such a case hare a good therapeutic effect? A. One can't answer that in general. It depends on the specific case. In general, if the circulation is weak, one avoids blood-letting. Q, Zb the case of convalescence after typhus, do you considor thnt blood-letting to an extent of 400 cc in order to nrke typhus sorun - do you consider that is peraiseible? A. Yes, v* do that to get sorun, becauoe that blood can lator be replacod, olther by transfusion or by soao llouid or by food. In gcnoral, the body can well stand such blood-letting. Q, And a last aucstlon. So far as you know and asouno, can blood¬ letting to tho extent of 400 cc in a porson convalescing fron typhus, who is in an avorego good state of hoalth, bring about doath?- A. I cannot laaglno that It could. Q, thank you. Ho furthor ouostions. THZ PEZSIDiOT: Any other Questions to propound to tho witness by ony other defense counsel? There boing nono, the prosoeution nay cross-oxaaino. CaOSS-EXAi.IKAlICK 3Y id. KC E^riT- Profcsoor, you ere prepared to testify to this Tribunal, as an oxpert, thnt the withdrawal of 400 cc of blood froc a person convalescing fron typhus end who, wo shall as suae, is in a '-eakenod condition is per¬ fectly permissible end would be rccosicndod by you7 A. 2 consider that oeraissible for the purpose of getting serua if one is in a position to ecopensate for the loss. Q. *nd suppose there wos no coaocnsetion by voy of blood trans¬ fusion? a. In that case sufficient additional nourishment and liouid or Court So. i 2 Jim 47-*-&-4-LEK-Iarrov (3rovn) even an injection of sodiun nitrate eolation vill suffice. At ony rate, there would always te sene way of coepensating for a rather unir.oortant blood-letting of 4CO cc. Q. Vould you, as an expert, reconaend the withdrawal of *00 cc of blood fron a tyuhue patient, without conpensation? A. That defends on Just what aort of food he recuirea. Q. Veil, let's sunoose he ia a concentration caap innate and he is receiving 15C0 calories a day. Vould you recccnend that 400 cc of blood bo withdrawn froa that patient, suffering fron tyohus, without any cospensation by way of food or otherwise? A. Z do not believe that vould do hie cuch bars. ^ Vould you recoa-aond it? A. Uo, Z can't toy that Z would. think that with 1 E 00 calories per day and with no cce- penoatlon by w*y of injections or blood tronafualone the withdrawal of 400 co of blood vould not veakon that patlent7 A. Of cau-oe It vould weaken hie, but he would recover fron it. <<. How do you know he would recover? A. '-’e hove so a any blood donors who do not receive nore calorioe than tint. Previouoly, It wo* custoaary that the oorsoc who donated blood received aono coeocr.sation, but later this cocoensntlon beenno smaller and soaller, and the ounber of calories which they actually recoived - not Just on peoer - also bccaae anollor and enaller. Conso- cuently, it happens very frecuontly that they donate blood without being thereby injured. C*. fell, but these blood donors were not suffering froo tyohus, were they, doctor’ 0 A. So, but v« also like to take blood fron oorBOns cick with typhus because ve want that for sens. This ^ do not do et the accent because we have no typhus today. However, when ve did havo.it, wo did take blood fron persons convalescing froc tyohus. Q> -id you ever have any tyohus patients under your care? CLS9 Court So. 1 3 Jus 47-tt-8-*&-£EK-£arrov (SrovsJ *. Yes, of course, ^ Did y®" eTer v'lthdrav any blood froa tfcca as they vere con¬ valescing to sake senm with? A. Sot 1, but ay assistants did. <*• Under vhat conditions vas that done? Eov ouch did you with¬ draw? A. I can't tell you that today. It vas also 400 cc, I believe. Q. And hov cany calories vere they receiving! A. I can't tell you. At least, in the hospital it vub core than outside. Taking blood free persons isn't looked on by us as so tragic a setter. 3- Vhat stage of recovery vas this patient in froa whoa you directed that blood be withdrawn? Had ho recovered cocpletely froa typhus? 3 Juac—ii—iU-9-l-it.loy (3rcwa) Court 1 a . I can't 8 _y chat, because all that was done by ay assistants. £.0 wouldn't h.-.ve chosen for this anyone who had suffered particularly serious case of typhus. la other words, a person >co hcd a very severe case of typhus would aot be used for the withdrawal of blood, is that right? a. Shat is a nodical icstiact. 2. Did you cojpens-to these patients froa whco you directed that blood bo withdrawn by blood tr.nsfusioas or by further feeding? a. I can't tell you that now vhethor wo ^id that. That was too long- ago. Z . you would h.ve recor.ended th t as good practice, would you? 4 . Yob, I would have told ny assistants that, of courso— 0, . Do you regard the defendant Schaefer as an oxport on soo- wetor problems? a . I bolleve he knows enough about tnut probleo. •. . aTO you fw.ili.ar with tno ncio Profossor a. C. Ivy? a . Yes, I believe ho has concerned niusolf with thoee pro,lajs, too. Q. Veil, have you road any paporo by hin, or nro you acquainted witli hie refutation in nodical circlos? Am Hot very woll, ncr can I rcncobor whothor raoag tho nany things I hevo read on so.T-w .tor thoro was o peper by Ivy. £ . C.ux you tostify whether Dr. Ivy is regarded as an oxport on son-water questions? a .1 know nothin,, about that. On vr.at precisely is your testimony with respect to the .ex¬ periments by 3iegelooeck based? Am On tho records and tne descriptions that 3iei,-aloock nudo of tho o^orii'.cnts. ^ , ? rccisely wh..t rocords have you seen on these experiments? 3431 3 Junc-i-T-S-2-K-1 0 " (Brown) Oourt 1 A . Ehe record* th.it the defense counsel had yesterday or to- dry in his hnud . Doctor, I will here pcssod up tu you a set of rocords which nro nuobored free jne to 44 in red pencil, and I ash you, did you mm havo thoso rocords before you and did you uako & study of then! A . Yen, I had these records, and I uskod one of ay collabora¬ tors who took part in those osperi-.onts to read through these ro- cordo and to sake excerpts froc thtc. he happens to be horo also. Q . bho was this collaborator! A. On of ay assistants oy tho a*ic of tfornor. Ho is at tho tiue auong tho audience. Yra said souctnlng about his hiring participated in ox- per Inoat s; you don't neon tho Dachau oxporinents, do you! a. Ho. In experiments that I carriod out with qy students. 3 • Did you porsoa.illy oxaaino thoso rocords at all! a . I saw tho;, but I didn't study ovory ono of then. I loft that up to tho young nan. ^ . And what did tho young nan do! a . Ho gave no a vox:* exhaustive report on thou. u . In what fora w.* his report; vh-t did ho hsve to toll you! a . I should prefor to show you tho report itr.olf. $ , Do you hevo it with you! a . Hot at tho acnont, out I do h„ve it in ay belongings. Dux*- lng n^oa recess I could fetch it for you. $ . Your testimony, tnor., is based 'jp on a sua:,iry .-ode by your assistant, is that correct! A. Yes, that is so. $ . Kou what othor rocords wore node available to you upon which your testimony is based hero! a . She charts that were filled out in pencil with figures. ^ . I'll have passed .up to you a pqjor-bound book with the 3 Jca©-l^fc?-®-k_loy (3r:Vn) Court 1 n.-*io "Schuster ■ written in pencil on the front of it, and down below in indelible pencil two words which I cannot decipher; I will ask you to rend -I'.an into the record when the booklet is passed to you; was th.-.t booklet unde available to you! A . Ho, at least Z have not studied it. You have never seen that book before? A. I don't believe *o. Porhcps it was Given to ao at the sauo tine, but thorc aro too nony statistics and figures in hero. I h..vca'i lookod through that nil. This is a laboratory book. Iho two words on the book aro ■Gastric Juice, ailiaotor p*s)or", end this ia no doubt a record usod in ca-plling tho original report. Xt is a so-o.Hod laboratory book. ^ . 3ut whethor or not tho book was given to you, at least yOu aro clfl,r that you node no study of tho book, is that ri,;ht? a . Yos, that is so. a ad you don't know whothor it Was turned ovor to your assistant? A . Shat I don't know. Z . In . % ny evont, he presented you no digest of facts baood ig>on that book, did he? A. Ho. Ci . I pass you now Aoigclboeck Exhibit Ho, 36, which has not yot boon offered. This is in foot an a&glish suuuary, but I think porheps tho witness night bo able to testify noout vhothor or not thin was node avail..'ole to bin. A . Tec, this I have seen. r.. Did ; on personally a Jcc «ny study of that? Yes, I lookod at that personally. hh.t does that record purport to show? a. Shis shows the changes that took pl.vco in tho body woight. It is b.ckca down into loss of water, loss of bod;* weight, percentage of ihe body loss, ^n L 60 forth. Ci.33 5 Court 1 (Brovu) '* 3"°^ turn that aver to your assistant, and did he ucko a su.-v.ry of ih*t record? — Tea, lie else reported on this, but I nj-self looked at this vevy carefully also. *'• Z'.at shove only the weight changes, is that right? * • £’ *- 1 ‘ largo, yes, But Z said there are all sorts of the¬ oretical calculations here uoout los3 of vator, tho vator ret_ined, the probable absorption of fluids, and so forth. Z* How, I think you dso said you sou sane pictures; thio has boon uarhod ns 3iegoloocck Sxhioit So. 34. A . -os, I h.,ve seen all those too. Q . In what fora did you soo those pictures, did you two tho orlglads or did you soo photost..tic copies, such as thoso? - . Z saw tho; in this fora. Z . Eton you novor s..v tho bucks of those pictures, did you? A. Ho. Tou don't know thothor on the backs of thoso original pictures tho iusios of tho oxporinontul subjocts ^jpoarod, do you? A . Ho, Z don't. Z» "ill you look at the photogruoh on tho pego .;nrkod nueber 5 thoro? Tcu will find in ink a Henan V on one of tho sots of picturoo. Z>o you obtorvo tho picure vhoro tho young non Is lying in bod, appax^ ontly with c tourniquet around his am, und in tho lovor left-hand port of the picturo a hypcdomic syringe? a. Tos, Z soo that. Z . Scvo you been infomod that thes pictures uro picturos of the crpa i.icntal subjects during the courgo of tho oporiacats? a. Z assumed so; coreovor, tho experiments wore ooncludod by injections, in the thirst experiments with sodi'-so nitrato solution , in tho aea-vutor Csnorimmts with sugar solution, by intravenous in¬ jection uhich immediately improves the condition. -434 3 Juno-i;-i:^J-^-5-i..Joy-(3rcvn) Court 1 ^ oa vhat is y°w opinio- bo»ed that these are picturos of the •oc-u..ter o^joi-iceatal subjects? -- -XI of the pictures or Just the one with the syringe? •1. *U of thoi. * • I v'BBime so. bocause the defense counsel put thai to no ca ■uch. Z. Dr. S teinbouer told you that th.i is what they wore, is that ri:*t? A . Yob. 0.35 3 lUne-T'-GSS-IO-l-’V-ofcnn (Breen) -ourt 3* » thi * Picture which I hovo called ycur attention to on the shsot norfced Kc-. 5, would ycu say that this picturo sh you Dootor? A. That I don't knew. Q. New, woro thoso tho only records made ovniloblo tc yru — tho sorios of individual reports which I possod up, tb: weight chart and tho pictures? A. I i1st sow o eolloetlon 'f roccrds written in pencil. Q. Do y< u fcvw whoro they arc now? A. I nssuRo that tho dofonso ocunsol has then. Q. 7fhat did t.heso records sh w? ... They also contained n large nunbur cf stctistics on gastrio juice, loss of woight, nnd oil sorts of clinieol findings — tho nunbor ■ f rod blrod c'rpusclos, etc. Q. .md did you porscnolly study those roc-rds? A. I saw then but did not study thon. Q. Thov were givon to y.-ur assistant? a. Yos. _ .. .. .. ! Y- u which wo Q. ff w, wore thorc any other raeurds th t - - haven't hoord ab ut, n which y ur testimony hero is based? A. I conn't say at tho rv-nont. Q. 1'u wo; ld here t confer with — - a. I boliovo thnt tho defense had roperts by Bockor-Froysong aad by Boiglb >eck? A. , These wero reports n the wh lo dcvolcpncnt f the quusti.n. CA37 3 Janc-r-CZS-10-5-::3oBaa (5r r-) Court :..l. Q. "ill. Professor, what sort f reports wore thoy? "a have not soon than, ycu knew, and wo would like t<-> kn-w on what you are basing :-"ur pinion before this Tribunal. Descriptions of the wh lo course that tho matter t k regarding the c nforenco, h.w tho docisicn wna rcechod, hew tho experiments were planned, and thor. Boiglbrock's report on his own oxporinonts on himself, which is a vary caroful description and c-rresp mda exactly to what ny subjects experienced when they ccrriod cut oxporinonts on themselves. C. Did you read and study theso oxporinonts corriod out by Bcckor-Freysong end Boiglboock? *». Of course. Q. -uv* thoy influenced y-ur testimony bof ro this Tribunal; you rolled on thorn in making y.ur to a tin. ny hero? "• theso I had an idea >S the aituatl by dofonso ccunsol? A. H;, I had been osked vor often t interest nysolf in this imttor, and I nysolf w-s int rested t. soo ryeolf, tho of foot of son- water on the cxporln-ntal subjects. This was intorooting tc no boenuso I nlrcady hod censi I.mblo oxporionce in tho Mold cf hunger and thirst. Q. TTorc y u approached at all with rospoct to this enso boforo tho time ycu started those sor.wator oxporinonts? /*. Yob, that is why I startod tr intorost rr^solf in the mattor, because I was askod t. apjvocr here as r witness, but I carried cut thoso oxporinonts entirely sprntcno usly, with ut cutsido interference and on ny '-wn interest. Q. But the fact that y u wore approached t ccoc hero and testify influenced y ur docisi n t- c=rrv ut these oxporinonts, is that right? Of c-urse, f curse. r i. And did y. u ror.ko cny effort t havo those experinonts ccincido with the c r.diti ns which >*• u were t-'ld existed in the Dachau experiments? 3*39 3 Junc-U-OZS-10-5-Vochnn (3r-*n) C urt !.* . li ... Yob, wo nr.do only 'nc 'istincti '-n in this, noncly, that the oxperinontal subjeots received r urhly 1,600 calcrios n day, because they w re n t t‘ interrupt ttair we rk. ?• bo suro, as tho oxperinont nt 'n they ato less an' 4 loss f tho 1,600 calorics, because tho thirst node thee lose their appotito. 3. leu exper inonted err five non? A. 2os. Q. Bof.To wo go on to that oxporinont, I w uld like t« go bock to the roerds a littlo bit; whon did yu first L *ot theso records? A. Thich records? Q. Tho rooerds which purport to be rcoords on tho oxporimonts of Boiglbcock in Dachau? ... 1 u will have to ask Dr. Stcinbauer t»hon he sont no thoso rocords, I don’t kn.’T. Q. i 'u d. n’t to w hew long thoy wore in y ur possession? /•« No. Q. Can’t yai cay njproxirntoly; ono n nth, sixty days, ninoty days? Porhops ono n^nth. CiZ.0 3 Jon-i : - 11 -l-C :ok (Inti 3 r t.) Court He* I* 3 When did you return thus? A I brought then with ue. Q Then you returned then y0stv.rd.7y? A That is right. Q Did you get theu froe Dr. Stcinbauer? A Yes. Q And you returned the?, to Dr. Stoinbauer? A Yes. Q Did you Mke any changes in these records? A Ho, no. Q But you yourself aren't very faailiar with then, are you? A Hot very, no. Q Can you state whether the records which I have Just passed up to you, that is to say, those records nuabered froa 1 to JsJ; in red pencil, can you say whether those records boro the nano of t1» oxpor- inontal subject at the top of the pago? A I didn't interest ayself in that. Q I pass you up a nurborori sheet picked at rondos from this 6 roup; it is narked No. 2 . I will ask you if above the word "nano", it does not appear that a nano written in pencil has been erased? A That 800*3 possible. Q Do you coon to say that is so? That the naae has been erased, isn't that what you oean to say? A No, I wouldn't say it is possible. It looks as if a name had boon erased. Cne can still see traces of it. Q And you didn't of feet that erasure yourself, did you, ft-ofessor? A Ho, no. Q Do you know whether your assistant did? A I think that is quite oiTt of the question. Q I '-'ill ask that that particular sheet be passed up to the Tribunal and I will remark that a number of other sheets are in the suae 2441 3 Jur.—-11-2-0 ook (Int. 3rcr.Tr.) Court 3cl I* condition. V,o will have a careful study nado of them and make a report at the proper tire on that problem. Have you ever seen a full list of the naces of the experi¬ mental subjects? A Mo. Q Now, I take it you have no personal knowledge about the Dachau experiments with sea water conducted by Beiglboeck? A No, I wasn't present, if that is what you mean by personal knowledge. Q And you had no associates who participated in then and re¬ ported to you about then either, did you? A Ho. Q Your sole knowlodgo about those experiments is basod upon these records which we havo gone over and what you wero told by Dr. Bolblboeck and Dr. Becker-Froyseng? Is that right? A Yes. Q Now how many oxperinontal subjects did you use in your experiments? A Five of the*. Q And you say that thoy were volunteers, your nssistans, is that right? A Yos, thoy wore all doctors, voluntours, and, as I said, included also ray youngest son, who also hap ons to be hero. Q And ixccisely what happened during those experiments? A Those persons woro as sorb led in ono roca, rocoivod the same amount of salt each and jrotty much continued thoir work. Thoy drank 500 cc of so a water and ono of ttea drank 1000 , and thoy stuck pretty close to the jrovisions sot dem for the experiment. Q You say four of then drank 500 cc of soa water cor day and the fifth ono drank 1000 cubic centimeters of sea water? A The fifth drank on ona day, I think, on the last day I think he drank an additional 500 cc, because ho was very thirsty. 3 Jun-. - 3-11-3-C oak (inti 3roi.ii) Court Jo. I. Q Fnen did you start the oxperiaents? A Cto the Monday before tho beginning of Lent. Q And how long did they run? A As I said, four, because of tho carnival season, broke off t&» oxpurijnnt after four days and one of then stuck it out for six. Q Well, you spoko of four days, do you know how many hours they wore under the experiaonts? A Five tii.es twenty-four in general and tho otter one six tiuos twenty four. Q Tfoll, I »isunderstood you, or olso your tostinony has changod; you said four of the students stayed on the oxporinonts for four days and ono went for six days. Is that right? A No, four did it for five dnys, four broke off at tho ond of tho fifth day, and ono stayod until tho ord of tho sixth day. Q And you are prepirod to tostify it was five tinea twonty- four, is that right, 70 hours? A I would havo to chook on that for sure in tho record, whotlior it wns five tines twenty four or four tines twenty-four, or sixtoon or eighteen. Thcso things didn*t soca very laportant to no. I ras interested primarily in sowing how greatly tho persona suffurod under the oxporinjnts, but tho nan who did it for six days, did do it for six tines tr/unty-four hours. Howjv w r, I don't 'rant to cako a strtenant for certain und-.r oath r^garding the number of hours. Q Wo 11 this little oar.oriu.nt conducted by you, as I tako it, had as its purpose to find out hor nuch a nan suffors, is that right? A los. Q You didn't kr.au that before you conducted this cxporinunt, is that riffht? A I asstssod that they would be very thirsty but I ^ranted to see what tho subjective sensations or feelings of the cxpcriaantal sub¬ jects were, '.bat was tho cost important to no was to know can those > CAA3 3 Jva~ - — 11-- -Cook (Int,* 3rvr..n) Court No. I. experiments bo characterized as cntl car inhuoane or brutal, end aro tlv.y exporiaonts which lead to a pro tty strong sense of discomfort, rv:a_ly, thirst, but do not do any daaago to health, that is what I wanted to know. Q And your testimony before this Tribunal is based upon those ojQtirlacntsj is that right? A No, on both, of courso, both on those carried out by . Boiglboock and on ny own. Q '.'all, your Jodgaont was also influenced by what Bcigl- bocck told you about ht* ouch tho oxporia>ntal sublets suffered, is that right? A Boiglboock drew up his own report on his own oxpcriajnt on hinsolf .and a general report on whatever cooplaints tho subjects uttered. Q that is that tho oxporiaont Boiglboock conducted by hiia- solf? You noon ho has boon undergoing an oxporiaont back in tho irison? A Ho, bofore tho oxporironts bognn, ho carried out a soc wator oxparlzunt on hiesolf. Q rhoro did thoso oxjxrrinontal subjocts of yours stay during this oxporl-ont? I seen to recall you said they contimxd thoir work or sonothing of tho sort. A They all stayed in ono rooo where they ate and slept and this was dono to sake the conduct of tho oxporiaont oasiur, as thoy wore to receive special rations. Q .Toll, now tho re wore all five oxperlaantal subjocts in ono rooo during tho whole cours, of tho experiz^nts, is that right? A Yes. Q And what did they do? * • A They wont froo this rooa to rhorevor they had to work but they returned to th_ rooo for slopping and eating. Q Woll, doctor, we arc having groat difficult}’ in really get¬ ting a clear picture about how this ex-erigent went on. Van you moan 3 Jua-*i-lE-lirr5-hy tiny lost their appetito later. Q They got no Bilk end no fruit juices? A No, no, that would have violated the whole oxporinont, and than they had not lost so nuch weight. Q I can appreciate that, Profossor. Where did you get tho soc wat.r that those oxpcriaontal subjects drank? A Wo xonufactured it carefully in the c heal cal laboratory according to a choaical analysis of soa water that can bo found in or.ny text books. I hare a chenist who was in oharge of tho laboratory and ho undo this soa water according to tho fomuls. We couldn't gat any natural soa wator for this oxperiaont. Q You don't knew tho salt oontont of this water? * I can give it to you in writing. Q You don't know how it oaaparos^with Hoditorrnnoan soa water cr son water free tha North Soa? CU6 3 Ju*>-a-i3-12-o-Cook (Int. 3rowr.) Court Ho. I. A Mo, that was the whole purpose, that they should receive no otter fluid end that is *y they lost their appetite later. Q They got no milk and no fruit juices? A Ho, no, that would have violated the wholo osporinent, and then they had not lost so such weight. Q I can approclato that. Professor, Where did you get tho son wat-r that those experimental subjects drank? A Vo manufactured*it carefully in tho chemical laboratory according to a chemical analysis of sea water that can bo found in many text books. I have a chemist who was in ohargo of tho laboratory and ho iar.de this soa water according to tho formula. We couldn't got any natural soa water for this experiment. Q You don't know tho salt oontent of this water? *• I can giro it to you in writir^. Q Tou don't know how it oaaprxus with Uoditorranoan son water cr son wator from the North Soa? GU6 Court So. 1 3 Jun 47-k-ia-l-iEX-Grcss (3rown) i. So far u I know, it vu nanufaetured on the sodol of the Sorth Sea sea vater. There was sooe deecriptlOB of it in a hook sooe- vfcere arZ that vae iaiteted. There are such analyses of sea vater in textbook*. Q, You say you think it was according to a fonsula for North Sea. Do you know whether North Sea «ater was used in the Dachau experiaente? A. X don't knov for sure where the water cane froe that was used in Dachau. That wasn't the laportant thing to ne to repeat the Dachau experiaents blow by blow. Is X said, ve siaply wanted to know how unpleasant it is if for days on end a person receives only sea water to cover his needs for liquid. Q, When did you tell these five expericental subjects that you used that they were to undergo the sxperiaent or when did you toll thee that it would begin? A. A few days theretofore. Q. A few days before? Heaaaber how aany days? A. Haybe a week before. First X had to have a conference with the kitchen to set that they %*re willing to prepare special rations for the five doctors. Q, And you say this special ration was eooewhat above that which the Dachau innate* got? A. Yes. For four days people in Dachau received eoergency soa rations and ay subjects received about 1600 calories a day in dry food, Q. Veil, how sany calories are thore in this eoorgency sea ration? A. For four days there are 3200 calories. Q, So that is 800 calories a day. A. Yes, sir. Q. Vho told you that tbs cxoerlaental subjocts got tliose rations in Dachau? Do the records show that? A. That was the plan for the exoeriaents that was worked out in that %ay and X aesuzed that the experiaents had been worked out as they had been planned, but, as I say, I laid no inoortance on the whole CUU 7 Court So* 1 3 Jan 4?-K-12-2-££X-Gross (Brown) Question of the calories because the ieoortant point is the loss of body water and not loss of body weight. Q. Sov, you didn't keep ary of your eroerlaontal subjects without any vater whatever, did you? A. live hundred cc of sea water vas the liquid they received. Veil, weren't there sone experiaental subjects at Dachau vho didn't get any %«ter at all, soa water or otherviso? A. Tee, the first group fasted and thirsted. I have already spoken about that and said that thirst can nore easily be tolerated if one is fasting at the seae tine so that the kidney hae as little as possible to do; thus the body is able to retain nore water. But you can't testily to the Tribunal about what pain and suffering those oxpst leant el subjects were subjected to, can you? You didn't run any elsllar erperinsets yourself? A. I do not understand you. I carried out theee experiments to know what tort of suffering the experimental subjects wont through. But you didn't carry out one where a nan fasted for five or six days without either food or water. They did carry out such an exnoriaent in Dachau. So you have no basis to testify about oain and suffering to which that grouo of experimental eubjecte were subjected, do you! A. Z aentlored that at the sane tine purely I was having four voaon fast and thirst that had cone to the clinic with very high blood pressure and for six whole days these women fasted and thirsted. This so improved thel- condition that they consopuently forgot the unpleas¬ antness involvec in tho fasting and thirsting. I also nentloned aaong then one wocan who weighed only 61.7 kilo and who lost 3. However, her blood pressure, went down froo 246/125 to 185/100. I carried odt such experiments alnost daily in the clinic. That le done in the hundrods. And, in the case of persons with kidney disease that is the accepted nethod so tliat during the ~ar people froe the fronts vent through thousands cf such hunger and thirst cures. I didn't have to have any GA&3 Court So. 1 3 Jus 4?-JC-13-3-IEX-Grost (3rovn) eontfol experiment In this; that vet furnished daily by the clinic. Qi And these voaen vent vithout food and v-ater for four days? Ai Six days vithout food and water. Q, And what vat the retult on then aside from their blood creature? 2id they euffer ouch pain? A. There it no oueation of pain in such cates. They siaply felt thiret. Strangely enough they do not coesplain of being hungry. The bo*r water that ttill reoaint there it enough to koep the body nctabo- lisa supplied vith the necessary choalcals. However, there is lack in tho body of oodiuc nitrate which, however, can bo overcose by giving sodium nitrate. They never oosplain about hunger, only thirst. Soao- tises thoy cocplaln of a feeling of weakness but fasting for six daye is nothing very special. As I said, soao oeoplo carry out hung or cures for four weeks. To be suro, they drink fruit Juicos during such a long cure. Ho also aako use of It for therapeutic purposes. They will rccolvo fruit Juices but that is by no noans eo unploesant as an oight day* long hunger and thirst euro. Q. And you gave then no coapcnsetion for going vithout food and vator whatever? Tou have then no injections of any tort? A. So, no. Ky whole purpoec is to ollBlnate free tho body all tho unnecessary fluids In tho blood to that tho blood pressure will drop. X gradually bring these people over to a fora of nourlshaont without any salt. Q, How you say that four out of five of your eroorinental sub¬ jects broko off on tho fifth day? A. Tot. Tor external reasons only, not bocauso they could no longer tolerate it. It Juet happened that four of the non had dates on the 5th day, but the 5th one stayed through until tho sixth day and I asked his specifically whether he felt particularly tortured or in pain and he said no. Eo said that with the first drink of water he took all unpleasantneee end disconfort vanished. I observed ay son tayself. As soon as he drank a cup of tea, be was perfectly ell right and two days oW.9 Csurt So. 1 3 Job 47-H-la-4-iawfroM (3r*m) after tfco experiment he had recovered all the weight he had lost. He had loot roughly one kilo a day. 3* Ton say those four men had a date on the 5th. Tou mean they had an ongegement vith a young lady? X. I do not know vfcat the detail* vero planned for the carnival celebration. I could simply draw the regrettable conclusion that tho interest in tho carnival vas a llttlo sore than tho interest in tho eroeriaent. But this does indicato that the oxueriacnts did not hove a vory deleterious effect on then, othervlso they could not have gone to the carnivnl and enjoyed it. Q. Voll, it night also indicate that they didn't regard tho orocriaants as boing very serious and that, oven though sovorel oon in this dock ore ouito intorosted in the results of this ©articular expori- nent, your four young assistants didn't regard it as sorlous enough to refrain froc going out on a dote. Isn't that about tho site of it? A. I can't dory that. I wasn't too ©loosed by thoir behaviour. Q. Voro thoso non iaforaod of tho sorlousnoss of this under¬ taking? A. So. k. And vhat reason did you advance to thoc for undergoing tho oxperiaonts? A. Of course, I told thorn and this vas known that such son voter ovuorlncnts vero an issue, but I was perfectly convinced that thoso experiments could by no aeens be called lnkunnno or brutal and conso- euontly vo didn't approach tho ex©crlnonts in too tragic a manner. All we wanted to know was how unpleasant such an oxperinent vas. TKo PriSnJLETi The Tribunal will be in recess until 1:&. 3 Junc-A-FL-13-l-Frimoau (Int. Brown) Court No# 1 AFTERNOON SESSION (The hearing reconvened at 1330 hours, 3 June 1947.) THE LivRStAL : The Tribunal is again in session. DR. FR-vNZ VCLZHARDT - Resumed (Continued) BY 'JR. UcKANEY : Q-- Professor, vhet experience had your assistant who helped you in your sea water experiments had in sea water problems before that time ? None. Perhaps I cculd take* this opportunity tc ma¬ ke a few corrections. I have been told that the interpretor failed to scy that I said that the sure proof for the cor¬ rectness of our experiments — and that the experimental subjects had not drunk any fresh water, wns that otherwise they would not have lost as much weight as they did. More¬ over, I elso said five times tw6nty-four hours and I added once -ight hours less and onco twenty-four hours more, Then I made a misteko saying that the emergency sea rations were 32CC calories for fair days. I havo bc>,n informed that in reclity they were 2474 calories. Then I spoke of students when spooking of my experiments. Perhaps the English v/erd "Students" refers to students in a University or some school. I should like to s^y that *11 of them wore accredited ooctors one of which had taken his degree as early as 1941. just s n id that the assistants who worked submitted to you by the defense had no with sea water problems. Is that cor¬ is ec. Moreover, I had had none either, not have found anybody with *ny experience 0451 3 June-.*-?!--13-2-Prioeau (Int. Brown) Coart No. 1 in sea water experiments because this - as the first time that people had carried cut experiments on themselves. <•- Have you ever before studied questions concerning see water ? Yes, of coarse I read literature on the subject, even foreign literature including the work of Liddell and a large number of other works, also reports on persons who had suffered shipwreck, the literature on how long after c per¬ son had suffered shipwreck he could still- bo saved, but I cannot recollect any details now. v.- You had yourself done no practical research on pro¬ blems in connection with see water ? .*•- Not in this field but in the field of hunger and thirst I had. ^.- What do you aeon by — you h«d done research in the field of thirst ? What research had you done ? A.- I couldn't list rll of the investigations I have c-rrisd out, That covers a period of, probably, 3C years, and in O onorr.i, tho important dement is tho behavious of the rosidud nitrogen. This i6 thw important point, aside from the diminrtion of srlt, and the mechanism th~t pro¬ duces residual nitrogon suffers, both in cases of a super¬ fluity and in cases of too little salt because cf the lack • of water. This example of acute do-sniination in the case of cholera shows that slag is retained in the blood in the same w?y as ir. the diseases of the urinary tract. t .- Professor, could you tell us the day-by-day clini¬ cal symptoms cf the experimental subjects in ycur experiments ■ ith sea. water ? 3 waa^-A -t^J-14-l-Iarrov (3rown) Court 1 /' A. I have already report*! oa that and said that oa the first two days the thirst was ao sovoro, oa the third day it becjje uinlo- soat, cad oa the ftxirth d^y the thirst was ■ y . -aln reduced, .mi* oa the fifth ley it bectce wary strong, the nocuous membranes in the mouth were dried up so that the situation was quite unplosaat. '-hat about the a^n who under went the sixth day) A . So suffered no ill effects a* all and said that it hadn't aodo mich difference to hiu one way or the other, *nd one of than oa tho fifty day, attsadod a court proceedings whore ho had to de¬ fend a friend of his. ^ . Veil, can't you &vo us a few aoro dotoils about tho sub¬ jective rocction of these experimcatal subjocts! a . Uiscles bec^is so-evh.it hard and aoro oeasitive so that if you t.-i on the uusdo a muscle knot is foniod but, in general, their ability to work did not suffor. Howevor, they all felt the urgent □ood for v..ter, Z Can guaraatoo that thoso experimental subjects did not drink .ay fresh Water on the side, Tho nourishuont consist*', of neat but tor, broad, j*si, two eggs, us on and threo >iocos of candy, Z . Zs is inforoation your assistant has given you over tho rocosc? i. I loolaed it \q> in uy records. Z • a nd how can you guarantee that those experimental subjects got no additional watorT A . is Z said, on the basis of thoir loss of weight and bocauoe I can roly on my ass is touts, Q. But you made no blood checks, did you! A . mood Was also tested—ox .mined, yos, Z~ Are you going to make all of these rrcords available to the Tribunal? Ics, Z can do that. vU In your enpert Judgment do you state that the experiments cca- a 53 3 Juaa-»-l-r-a-rrov (3rovc) C ou^t 1 S, * you «M in .11 —ntiol M to th. ««•«'• In Dachau? * . I ho,. dr.™ your .tfntlon to th. dl«-r««l Mly. u • V «ij«t. nil u* nor. to ..« *«— *»•«' v.ro not Jyuif. it l»d but v.r. Mfr»lnt on th.lr rH5*« ,ort - % . «a, do you think that you vould h.T. *ott» . aluabl. ro- it. fr« ;,oor Mp.rln.nt. on th. probl« 1* vo. *• jfrtg.t occhl A . I dlda*» un^or.tant your *u®atlon. . I .ay, .1 yol n-j ». 3.rit*tit in your Mp.rin.nl. and you uj.l w-t.- pro..,.* « oh. Mf« n.thod «d T~ 1- f — e.u vat or utd.nl toother sroup ab.teln froo nil liquid. and .11 food., your eapdrlnont .-id h... yielded .aid roll.. 1. that -" 1 * . I do not O.U.T. .o, bec.u.e X didn-t •* "*• from Jorfiitlt end of .ho Sehaef.r n.thod I knee th.* it vould raoov. al tho tern eat. of thlr.t nnd I h* «nou.h Mp..l«m=.. m «“"*• .bout fnlrv 1 didn't h«r* to h-v. eny contro on.... X . Doetor, l.t>. put it . 11‘tl. ■«" ,h * r>17 - ^ u) ..rcntl7 er. tIiU« «bU •««- «“* ^ oonirdd vlth tho Dadh_u eiporlnont. and you bu your.olf upon your -Mpoo tuMt. in re-hl»« certain conolu.lon. about y-n 1 «*- fMUG 1 about th. llkllsood of injury. Tour -tW* .uV JCt. Oa»ri*d on thalr daily Mtiritl... They vorlcod and «h«, voro -not clo.aly confined. Tor vh.« r.a.on lit n~«.«T that Dr. loljlaoock e e to D-hau 1 Carry out «•»«*. on ooncontr.tl n cxr, l^tee, Thy couldn't h.. a. y~. ha« «•«“- °° ^ in th. W in Benin. Thy counln't h.lndo* have U.0d th. d.f.nd-nt , chroedo in hi. ~p.rm.nt., Dr. Bchrood.r could contiai. vlth hi. daily activities, U. only necalty bela* that h. oat and 1«P. « that i. n uartlvularly nutMlal factor, in n certain roe, * . I don't b.lm. it 1 . an -pert., task to .ay vhy Mp~m»t. 3 Jun£x*-::j-14-3-Zarrov (Brown) Court 1 • wo:o not carriod out ih a different w^y. They wore decided on at a conference at which such eoinent scientists os Bppinger and “eubnor vero present. Shis plan was drawn up and given to Beiglboock and ho was told to carry it out without any chaagos. 3. I won't ask you to f>eculate, Professor, but you are brought hero as an oxpert on these problems, and X'a asking you if the o»- pe-inents could not have been conducted in Borlin in a nannor sinilar to tho o^jorinonts conducted by you? i. Pros tho reports on tho conferences and on what wont on bo- foro tho exporinents, it could bo soon that efforts woro at first Budo to find othor ways of doing thoso exporinonts»and thoru is no doubt that Proffcesor ^jpingor would havo preforrod to carry out tho exper- inonto in his clinical or in a hospital. But tho war situation was such at that tiao that it was out of tho quostion to Baking uoo of a largo nuobcr of bods and Bale hoalthy pcrsonnol as oxporlncntul sub¬ jects for those exporinonts. In addition, thoro was a strict ordor that evory soldior, lmodiotoly nftor ho hod rocoverod fresa his wounds should inaodintoly bo divissod frea tho hospital. Ho couldn't oven stay thoro for another twenty-four hours, but only as long as wns ab¬ solutely nodossory. That procludcd currying out tho oxporioonts on convalescent eoldiors. It would huvo been bettor in evory roepoct hod that boon posaiblo. $ . You didn't carry your experinents out on convoloscont soldiers did you? A . So, but I hod enough doctors. I had core than forty doctors at ay clinic free when I could chooso the voluatoors. Q. I supposo you road tho conferonco report on tho nooting hold on the 15 th of May? There wero about fiftoen nen—not tho 15th of Kay, I thick it was the 24th of Kay, 1944. Thoro woro about flftcon non at that Ejecting, weren't thoro? Is thoro any reason why they could- n't undergo these experinents and continue thoir daily work without ui>- duc inconvcnicnco? G 455 " 3 Jun&-A -4iJ—14—4—Sarrov (Brown) Court 1 A . It Is lsaossiblo to prosuan of tho fiftocn participants in:, a cocf eronco that thoy should go to a hotel, or house, or hospital end thoro subject theesdves to such experiments. With all tho noc«»- scry blood and laboratory tests. Q. Profoasor, your experimental subjocts didn't stay in one rocc all the time. They went about their business, didn't they? A, Yes, but they livod in this roc*. They woro all woithod in this one rocc and uto in this rooc and olept in this rocc and this facilitated tho orrporinont groatly. It would havo boon impossible even if they hadn't oated in tho seco rocc. Oan you, ossiblo, or ho would havo to toko draconian noesuros and lock ovozy export*octal subject up in his own coll* Q. Voll, do you exclude ths possibility that they would tiy to choat if thoy woron't roluntoorsT i. If c porson is in en oxporinent and is not voluntary in it then ho vill nost assurodly cho.:t whonovor he colw ^ A nd did you find any ovidonco in tho purportod original rcr- cords sutaittod to you that the oxporinentol subjocts in Dachau had cheated? 4. Tos, that con bo scon free on a or two of tho weight charts. If tho subject does not lose woight, that neons that ho has drunk water on tho sido. Q. And your statement that tho Dachau cxpcrinontal subjocts woro voluntcors is sinply a stutaaent free Bciglboock or Bock cr-Troy song which you aro passing on to tho Tribunal, isn't it? 2457 3 (fcrovn) Oourt 1 s' JL • lo, free tho Tory bogl^zlr^ ard for porfoctly ondoretr.ndablo reason* it vaa planaod that tho ■objoct* hiA to bo Toluntoore, end whoa Dr. Bcdglboock oliainatod throo eubjoeto bocaueo they wore not in good enough etate of health, throo other Tolantoori innodlatoly oppliod. 3 Jun-u-i3—15-1—- r nloy (Int. 3rowr.) Court :io. I# Q Did you participate in this planning of the so experiments? A Ho. Q Thon thu 3 to tenant you just made is nothing you know any¬ thing about oxccpt what was told you by Boiglboeck and Bcclcor-Frcys-ng, is that right? A Everything I know I know only froa the sources in question. Q If you wero-autcittins those records as clinical data on thoso experimental subjects without being told anything about it ono way or the ether and you ascertained as ycu did ascertain that n mnber of the subjects cher.tod, would ycu bo quite so sure in your str.tenant that they woro voluntoora? A I havo already said that tho fact that tho porson is a volunteer is not a certain guarantee thr.t tho experimental subjoot will not oho at, you will aoko that oxporionco with all pationts. They foci that thoy have abidod b7 tho rulos and doctor's instructions, but novo rt ho loss you find out thoy did drink water or did odd salt ard that thoy did do sooothing — even though thoy wore volunteers — which thoy should not havo done. Tho notto applies, *Tho mind is willing, but tho flosh is weak." Q Of course that is pure assumption on your pert ns oppliod to thoso oxporinonts nnd tho only oonoroto fact you can tostlfy to is your observation free thoso purported original records that sorno of tho oxporiaontrl subjocts did choat and did obtain water, isn't it? A Tou could see that froa tho rocord of tho experiments. Q Do you know what Berkatit is? A Yos, I do. That is sanething to correct tho tasto of soa water, originally manufactured froa tonatoos. It covers up tho nausoous tasto of soa water so that it can bo drunk oven with ploaturo. Q And what is your opinion about tho effectiveness and re¬ liability of Berkatit? A I consider it c aspic to !y superfluous, unless in cases of s.~ distress ono prefers to follow tho edviso of drinking rather 500 ccs 3 Jun-A-itB~l>-2—lfeloy (Jnt. Br o w n ) Court !fo« I. of sco water than to thirst. Thet could be pleasant to »moono If he could drink sea water without it tasting bad to his, but it has no effect on the da hydrating of feet of drinking sea water* Q You did not use 3erkatit in your experiments? A No, wo didn't have-any. Q In what fora is Borkatit manufactured, is it sosuj solid substonco one oats or is it a powder applied to sea water? Just what is its form? A I don't know. Q Bavo you over socn any Borkatit? A No. Q Thon who tcld you what it was? A That beea*o obvious during tho course of tho confcronco. Q '.'ill you ropoat your answer, plonso? A At tho conference I believe on tho 15th of Ajwil or sono- thing, I boliovo, the conference wo wore talking about yostord.*y, whore thjro was tho discussion about Berkatit and Wolfatit, it c.-mo to light that Borkatit was rocoaaandod by tho technical offico aid given tho profercnco to tho Wolfatit. Nor, incidontally, have I over socn any Ttolfatit, but I na convinced it is a wondorful lnvontion or dis¬ covery. Q Tfoll, professor, I cn completely lost to understand how you can testify anything about Borkatit when you have never soon it. Up to tho present tlao you haven• t told mo anything about information you have received on it, and there is nothing in the conference report which discussos tho content of Borkatit end its process of manufacture on its fora ? A It was said in this confcronco that Borkatit was sirfcly a taste corrective, and for a doctor that is a concept of which ho knows *hrt it naans, cv_n though he hasn't soon it or tasted it or actually had it in hir hands. Q So as an export you ur-, willing to say that Borkatit is no L460 3 m-A-!3-l5->:feloy (Iat. Brow.) Court Hom I. good although you can't tell tho Tribin.il what is in Berkatit, how itfe conufacturod or its fore? A 103, that is rigfct. In this connection I sn in exactly the a fine position u Schiefor who irr.udiatoly cone to tho conclusion that if it was simply a taste corroctive then it was not ?ny good for our purposos, namely to overcame ar correct tho dehydrating offccts of son water. Q oil, I dare say that Dr. Schaefer his more information about 3ork.itit than you hawoj hov do you reconcile tho fact that Ep- pingor, who you xvcomaondod to this Tribunal a a an oxpert was support¬ ing tho uao of Bark.itit? A Ctf courso Eppin^r didn't think oithor that Borlcatit re¬ moved tho salt fron tho w-.tcr in tho wry ‘..blfr.tit doos, but ho believed in tho possibility that tho vitmin content of Bcrkatlt could perhaps contribute to permitting tl» kidneys to concentrate noro se.lt, and tho quostion that interested hin was how long a person could drink such son water with tho tasto corrected without suffering serious injury; thr.t is what I assisoo without actually sporking to hin. Q 3ut you ontiroly disnissod 3ork.itit in spite of Eppinger's opinion. A Fron tho very boginning I was of tho opinion that for eases of soa distress, in other words to correct tho dehydrating of¬ fccts of soa water, Borkatit could not bo used at all. . Q lien i, free the notes rrhich wore submit tod to you wore you able to ascertain how cany subjocts wore vsod in tho Dachau oxrorinonts? A I didn't bother to count thus. I estimate or believe 1 knew that thsro wore U* of ttxrs. Q And could you ascertain fron those records how A so ox- p-rlaEr.tal subjocts wore grouped? A Yes, I have alro-dy said that there wore five groups, and I know hew those five groups w^-ro treated individually. Q How were they treated individi.-J.ly and how largo were tho 0461 3 Jun-A-I3-l5-ii-ibloy (Ir.t* Bream) Court :fo. I. groups? A Tho first group fastod and thirsted, the second croup, Schaofor, tho third group had sea water with 3crk.itit, tha fourth group sea water without Berkatit, and the fifth group drank son wator straight up to 1000 cc. Q And how arny wore in oach group. A I didn't count the, about six, but in ono group I think there wore noro. Q And woro you ablo to ascertain froc tho records hew nuoh so.- wator tho group cons icing Berkatit was given, that is ho-.r uuoh Berkatit procossod soa wator? A In tho Berkatit group, 500 cc of sea wator wore given. Q And in what quantities wore thoy given that? A 500 cc in portions of 100 cc. Q In othor words, thoy wore given 100 cc. five tiraos during a 2U hour poriod, is that right? A That is roughly it, yos. Q And how long did that continue? A Tho oxperiaonts were discontinuod after six days. q CouM 70U toll froa tho rocords what tho reasons for in¬ terrupt ing tho experinents was? A I believe that f\5ndancnta.liy they did not wish to continue tho oxperinonts aftor tho sixth day bocauso froo then on tho synptccs bocoiva very disagrooablo. q And hew nuch plain so" w.at,r was giv^n to tho group that was fed only sea water? A Ono group had 500 and tho fifth group had 1000 ec. q How oBDjr experimental subjects were in oach group, cluld you tell that? A I believe six. Q In othor words, ono group of six got 500 cc of sea water per day and another group of six got 1000 cc of sea rater per dy, is 3 Jur«-A-I3-15-5-^t-loy (Int* Browr.) Court Ho. I» that right? A Yos, that ia roughly it, but ->s I s-y I cannot swear to tho oxact of cxpcrl-xntr .1 subjects. Q How, you got this infornation fron these records and not froa what 3cclear Pr.yseng and -fioiglbocfc told you; you can toll all this free tho records, is that right? k Yea, that can bo so_n free tho records, above all fron the photostat tables of ■eights shore tho nuabar of experimental sub¬ jects is along ono edgo. Q How long did tho oxptriaonts continuo with tho groups get¬ ting 500 cc of soa setor? k All oxporinonts woro interruptcxl after six days and only in ono or two oases they woro prolonged for a day or two if tho subjoct had drunk fresh wator. Q And tho group that got 1000 ccs also Lasted six days? A Yos. Q Did you food any of your oxporiaxmtal subjocts 1000 ccs por day for six days? A Hot for six days. Cno of ay subjocts on tho last day drank a thousand, bo cause ho thought that would in soiio usasuro quench his thirst. Q And how way ware in tho group that fasted? A Just as many. Q And how long did thoy fast and thirst? A 3otwocn four and five days. 3 v'un3-..-G2S-l6-l-!:oeh=n (1st. Brrwn) Court Ho. 1. r \. ,jv\ you found nothing in those rocords which indicate to you thrt those jxrcrincntnl groups suffered any sovero pcin; is that -right? ... X u cannot speak of pain ir. tho easo of these experiments, you can speak simply tf discoafert, unpleasantness, had nerd attacks, n goncrel fatigue, but sevore pcin is not eausod hy hunger or thirst or drinking soo w~ter. ;. Hew such unploasnntnoss end disomfort wculd bo causod; could you toll anything about that fr'n thoso roports? regarding tho subjootivo reaction cf tho sublets, thoro was nothing to bo scon in the records. 3. Tho best imv to fin*' out about that w.uld be to call in ono of tho oxperir.ontal subjects; wouldn't it. Doctor? ... I beliovo so, yus. Q. Did you observe any different symptoms fr<.« thcao rooords ns betwoon tho vnriius ,-rcvpa cf oxporir*.nts 1 subjects? A. Bet thit I kr.ow cf; cort.inly net fr n the rooords obtaining tho figures from tho ,;orwnl roport, that is. Q. In othor words, tho onus that w?ro fed soo-wntor and Borkntit wore Just as well off as tho gr-nip that got Tfclfatit; is that right? A. He, that is a Tory sort us mistake because the onos whe rccoivod • rlfntit did n't how any treble at all, thoy fp t along fine. Q. But tho others did ha-o n little trouble? .. lot of trouble, the*' wore very thirsty, very soveroly thirsty. Q. .(* an expert, supposo you tell tho Tribunal, if you con, what tho synptens would bo each day in a twolvc doy oxpcrlncnt, using for one group sea wntcr, for another gr.up, Borkntit, for another ;r up oolfntit and for tho Inst group no feed and n.' water? A. This situati n c uld never arise, because I wculd never extend a sea water experiment for twelve- days unless it was with Schaofo/'wntor. I w.'uld net lot a hcnlthy person go with hunger and thirst for twclva days. The nenxinun ycu c'uld oxpect rf r, pers.-n is six days. Fr.r. the twelfth day to there is already danger f death. I thereforo conn-'t ’.escribe whnt th- synptens w. fid be n the seventh, eighth, ninth. 3 June-A-C3S-16-2-Kcehan (3r<-wr.) Court Sc « 1. tenth, olevcnth or twelfth day. I can soy thet thero i-ld ho -one ml dehydration and they wn'ld be very thirsty indeed and that thoy would n^t yet bo dead cn the twelfth day and that I would «vor undortaleo to corrv „ut such on experinent nyacIf, H. Ycu connot glvo us then the clinicol syr.ptcos Airing tho days free the so vc nth day on? a. 1 osk you if y«i want that inf.mnti n to road descriptions of pors ns ship-wrocked. Q. I want to kn'ay 1944. This doouaont is K0-177, Prosecution Exhibit No. 133. Doctor, before we turn to that dcoun- nt, I would lilpo to got veur rooetion to a statenent redo by a cr.n who was in Dachau and who hod an opportunity porsonclly tc learn saacthing about tho soa-wetor expor- iwnts. Tint is tho affidavit Tschofonig, D-. cuaont No. 911, Prosecution Exhibit 139 cn page 28, tho English d'eunent book 5. Irofosscr, Vs. Tachofonig, wh was, as I say, in a position tc kr.rw personally about 6466 • I 3 Juno-A-02S-16-4-!fcohac (Brcrnn) C^urt He. 1. these oxpJrinents, states that tho cxporinontnl subjects could act oat mieh feed, that srjjo of then hod creeps end naniao attacks, that ho know that oxparincntal sabjoets had hurlod thoasolvca on tho floor and sucked dirty we tor out cf rags usod to nop tho floor. How, aro y.-u 9 willing to state as an oxport that these ata tenants ccnoornlng aufforlng and thirst aro incorrect and unrelieblol A. I don't know those stntcnonts but I oensidor It quite out of tho quoatl^n that the experimental subjects folt it nocoaeory to drink in tor rf acp«, bocauso thoro wore air raid buckets tho re and if thoy folt thoy noedad a drink thoy could drink mt of then. How, insofar as tho oranpa aro oonoornr 1, I don't bclicro that oithor. Neno of ny subjocts had oranpa. Q. Did you say scoothing ab^ut then haring difficult anting food? ... Xoa. that ia ao, thoy loao thoir oppotito boocuac thoir ncutha bo on no ao drv thoy oil egrued thnt thoy bconao lose and loao intoroatod In food fro* day tc day. Q. H^ oranpa? A. Ho. Ho nnntol disturbenooa? a. Ho, I oensidor that out of the quoetion. Q. ^Thr-t physical lajoirncnts of-ony sort; no inpairnonto -f Iho eyos? ... thysical or paychologioal? Q. Phyaiool ia the questin. A. Konkncaa, atiffoning f there toeing an authentic record of the nesting vfcich took niece et that tine, tout only a fov days later a nan by the nano of Schickler, who was neither cuallfiod nor entitled to sake it, orepared a rocord froa his senary, end ho v&s definitely not a nodical nan, he vos a technician, and vhat is nore he was a prejudiced author of this record, and vhat is ncre, ono nust consider that hero vc are not concerned vith the planning of oxperinents which vould aeke any cloin towards real existence. It is proved beyond doubt that only when Professor apoingor and Heutonor voro there vero these oxperinents planned and that thoso natters arc faleo end if Professor Vollhardt is to define his attitude at all thon ve could only too concerned vith a hypothesis. In other vords, ono night •ey that, assuning this rocord hero does correspond vith tho truth, vhich on the other hand vo deny, then it could too so, tout not as if vo vero c neernod hero vith a true record of the outoone of that conference, and that in fact no planning for an experiment v*s carrlod out at tho tin©, and, therefore, I object to this type of cross exaninatlon and I naintain ay objection to tho record as such in its ontlrety. 3473 3 Juno-i^J-18-l-Gross (Frank) Court 1 722 ?22SE>arT: 2ho witness has testified as on export vitnoss celled by the dofehao. Ho is now undergoing cross examination. Tho roles of cross extinction cro llboral end Prosocution is entitlod to tost his kaovlodgo of these nnttors and had not oxcoodod tho propor bounds so for, Couaaol nay procood. DR. iUHH Mr. President, nay I soy ono noro word. There is tho alditlonal point that tho ninutes procisoly stato under II that tho Ccnnisslon* end this is at tho bottco of pago 3 of tho Goman tost, tho Ccucioslon for tho planning for tho conditions of tho oxporinents to bo carried out i s coaposod as follows* Profosaor Ippingor froa Yioana, then a reprosontotivo of tho Hygiene Departnont. a representative of tho air Force, a representa¬ tive of tho Goman air Ministry, and a roprosontativo of tho OEM, tho high oooBand of tho levy. So, tho caxrl.sion who vas to draft tho plans for thoso oxporinonto was only being nado up—it hadn't net, but was only to bo constituted during a further uooting and then draft plans for tho oxporinents. *hus, in this nost roioront point this record is folso and thor-foro the assucptlon is Justifiod that tho record vas not prepared on tho 23 Key but oven lutor after tho 26th of Key. Ghristonson, you soo, upon ay questioning, ansvorod uo that it vas oven possiblo that it vas after the 25th May that thin re¬ cord vas proporod and it porbobly ha* boon antedated. For that reason alono, when you rood that particular passage, it is quite unnecessary to State that there voro no details, that the emission vas only being foruod and then during a later nooting vas to uako tho plan, to bo carried out. Consequently. I bog you to take this into consideration and to hero further extinction of this vitae., refused. DR. S«XHB-3S.. JOB 3SIGLB0ICX: I also object to tho typo of cross extinction carried out by Prosecution, but uy reasons are different- thoy arc of a fomal nature. It is not proper that an expert witness should bo shovn a doctoat that a sentence should bo 31 * 7 *. 3 Juno-*-W-l&-2-Gross (Trade) Court 1 tom free Its context- without tolling hie what wo aro coacomod with aad. without giving tho witnoss ecplo opportunity to peruso the entiro docuncnt-to poruao tho oatiro docunont in hi a ova tino and then ho would know what is going on. In ordor to provo this I would like to point out how Prosecution quo tod free Tschofoaig's interrogation saying that Tschof onlg had experienced all that but in tho niddlo of tho eocoad pogo- tho witness is seying duo to ny position as io- sponsiblo prisoner for tho X-ray station of tho ccep hospital insist in tho csporlncnts." Which could havo boon only a siqjorficU ono. Thus, tho assertion that this witness was inforood in dotoil io con¬ tradictory to faots boforo this Tribunal. ms ?HSSIS3«T: V hon tho witness Is being cross oxcoinod in con¬ nection with any cortaln docunont tho wltaoso nay too, oxauino, and rood that docunont in full If ho dosiros. Othorvlso tho croso oxnulna¬ tion nay procood. Objection is oror-rulod. 3T iw?. KcH-STT: Witness, I ac not asking you to nrguo whothor thois onporlaont of 12 days as outlined horo was carrlod out, but I understand you aro an unbiasod export on soo-wator problems, testify¬ ing in cn un-blnsod nannor, I an asking you to os-uno that this ex¬ po rlncnt was carried out and, os it statos, It was to lust 12 days, end tho sole oourco of water was to bo soa water and Borkotit, and I put tho quostion to you os an export-what In your Judgment would havo happened to tho oxporluoatal subjects? Con you onswor that? a. Tcs. Without o doubt tho cxporinontal porson would havo nanrgod to get ahold of wator gcoc wey or othor, booauso even tho uoot enthusiastic aoluntoor wouldn't continue that long. Q . Doctor, lot's ossuno that ho had no rocourso, no acccsr. to 0 othor wator, ho was put in a cell, whore there was no othor wator. He had to drink soa water. He hod to drink Borkjtit, That is all ho got and that wont on for 12 days. Kow, as an oxport, what porbnbljr' would h.vo hepponod to tho oxpcrincatal subject? 6475 3 Jua>-A -(J-l&»3-*ro6s (Trank) Court 1 A • After 12 days ho would have shrunk considerably and all sorts of sysptcca would havo bococo apparent. I can langlno thoro would havo boon hallucinations and physical woeknoss, hardening of tho nus el os, acd so on, Sit, if a porson woro ahlo to conoontrato ho had a chanco to survivo thoso 12 days. 4 . Zs it probablo that tho oxporinontal subjocts would havo diodl ▲ • I wouldn't describe it as being a probability but as bolug n possibility. Q. I'ould you doscribo it as bo lag proballo that tho axporiaontal subjocts would havo survivodf A . that I ccmsidor very possiblo. $ • Veil, is thoro cny probability in horo anywhero or Just possibilitiosl i. In biloogy you cannot figure out forocosr. Much dt^onds on tho typo of porson you arc ooncernod with, how is condition is how ho can goaorally roect. Ono can say gonorally that dangor to llfo coo- aonooo after 12 days, ono cjn assuno that aftor 12 days ho is still Alivo A nd it is proballo that if ho survlvos, os you stato is very possiblo, is it probablo tha t ho would have suffered any ponaanont daneA'Ot A . Ho, that is ioprobablo that ho would suffer permanent injury. Profossor, can one kill a porson by aaklag hio drink soa water as his solo sauce of water supply? A. Tea, of aourso you can kill anyone if you only give hio soa wntor to drink pcrtiancntly. Ho hue an bolng can stand up undor that, ho drios out, Q, A nd, as an osport, what is your best ostiuato as to how long that would teko? A . as I havo Just said danger to life c cm one os aftor 12 days . is a general ostinato. Cl. That is tho best testimony you can givo in rosponso to that C476 3 June^-j-HJ -l ftifOroaa C ourt 1 quoation? Ho la giver, only ioa aator, that ia hla aolc aourco of v-tor. Tou can't cay anything noro definite than around tho 12 th dry It bee coca quito dongoroua to hla lifot Toe, I can aay that on tho 12th day thcro ia danger to hit lift. Voro you in court yoatordoyf a. Toa. Q . Proaocution would call to tho Trivunal'e attention rulo Ho.9 B of tho rules leauod by thia Tribunal, which roquiroe that witnOBBOa bo cacludcd free court prior to thoir tcatinony. Vo call that to tho Tribunal'a ottontion for %*mt ovor weight they night widh .to giro it. Vo nokc no notion* bocouao that rulo waa vlftlatod in thia lnatcnco, DB. TIPPi Hr. Proaidont, thia Justified objection by Prooocu- tion can bo clarified oaaily. Mr. HcH-ncy dooan't know thia fact that wo aakod tho Tribunal in writing to allow Profoaaor Vollhardt oa an oapoit witnoaa to pornlt bin aa on except ion to bo in court during tho examination of Bockor-7rays eng, Schaofor, and Boiglboock. Thia roquoat by dofonao waa grantod in writing by thia High Tribunal. Poaaibly that doclaloa of tho Tribunal ha» not ceno to Mr. McHonoyle knovlodgo. Mr. McHcnoys X hovo no further quoetiona. 3T JTOGB SiKRIHO: Doctor, con you etato for tho lnfoxnation of tho Tribunal whether ao far aa you know thoro la any food value in tho preparation Berkatit? i. An actual nouriahing valuo la not containod in Borkatit aa for oa X know cbout ita ccnpoaitlon. X bolievo that initially if was s ado of taaatoo# and than later on otfcor typo a of augar woro uaod, but I don't think thia waa of any actual nouriahing valuo. Q, . if it should appear that thoro ia acne food value or noui*- 3 Jun»-A •KMMnii (Frank) Oourt l isfcaect Taluo In tho preparation them would It not bo iwo that error an oxtondod period of tlno tho oxporlncBtol auhjoot tdio was taking Borkatlt would bo placed In the oaoo poaltloa as would an «®erinontnl aubjoct who was glron foot but doprlrod of all foroa of watort 1 . If Bcrkatlt cron did haro ono to 3 oalorloa thee It wouldnlt pi aj any pert ot oil alnco that would bo without any Inf or once mveo tho dnngoroua quality of ooa water which la ita dehydrating quality. I would noror nor or daro to oontlnuo a too wot or caparlnont with Bcrkatlt longer than a ooa water oaporlnont without Borttatlt. That U, to tny, not baycuM tlx ditfs. C47C Court 1 June 3-A-12-l*KD-Xarrov-3rovn. 5Y TEE PRESIDENT: Q. Professor, taeae aabjects upon unco you conducted an experiment In /our Institute were very excellent subjects for such an experlnent were they not? A. They were char oterired by the f->ct that the;.* were nedlcal sen who understood tne meaning and that I oould rely on them. Physically, they certainly were no better-condl- tlonod, according to the photographs at least, then those rather well nourished experimental subjects. 4 . I was not thinking so much of their pnysloal condi¬ tion, but they wore non who wero interested in thl6 work, uere they not? A. Yes. 4. The results of the experiment - each upon hlmsolf and upon each of his associates - would be Interesting to or oh one, would It not? Is that not true? A. I would osaunj so, yes. 4. Eaoh no wes entirely controlling his own partici¬ pation in the experiment, was he not? A. Yes. 4. If, at any time, any one of the subjects felt that tho conditions which he was undergoing In the experiment were beoonlng too heavy for hlo, he would have been relosod from further oprtlcipatlon upon his request, would ho not? a. Ho doubt he would have reported and ho would have said "I want to step out. This Is too bad for me." 4. That's what I meant. He w^uld have asked to be released end he would .eve been Immediately released?^ Well, Is It or is it not a fa,t that a human being will voluntarily nderuo hunger, tnlrst, pain, discomfort, and stand It better when he knows that he is doing It under his own vlltion with a scientific objective, than a person of G479 Court 1 June 3-*»-19-2-HD-Karrow-3rovn equal phyeloal condition will stand such an experiment when. Insofar as he Is ooncerned, he has no personal Interest whatsoever? A, No doube that Is correct and I am perfectly oonvlnced that Professor Epplnger tried everything he could In order to obtain such volunteers. He w: s cost discomforted through the fact that these experiments were carried out In Dachau. He would much rather have seem then oarrled out In Vienna on hi a own scholars or students but, at that time, there weren't any students any more. They had all boon oalled up, and nodloal officers were very scarce so that there was no question of obtaining volunteers. Hence, In this very tenso and difficult time, no subjects could bo found to ccrry out such a series of experiments ae was planned here In a hospital or cllnlo or any kind. It would have been better, more praotlcal and more sensible, by all means. If tho experiments had been carried out at that time upon medical students, but, unfortunntoly, that was Impossible. ft* perfaced your statement. Doctor, by saying that Dr. Epplnger had this sentiment. How do you know that? A. Because, during the oonferenoo, it was mostly Prof. Epplnger who was In favor of these experiments being made and, since Professor Epplnger had earmarked his favorite pupil Belglboeck, for the carrying out of these experiments, it la a matter of course that Epplnger would have llkod nothing better than that these experiments had been carried out under his own control In Vienna. ft* * ou ore assuming that Epplnger would have felt as you would have felt under similar circumstances, Is that correct? A. I know that all those who were interested In these experiments were making efforts to find places where theee CJXO , . _ Court 1 June 3-*«t-13-3-Hi)-Xarrow-3rown. experiments oould be carried out in a military hospital on soldiers or convalescent patients or other persons, but, unfortunately, everything turned out to be Impossible. You can only. Imagine the situation If you know how every hospital bed and every doctor was being utilized In this tins. That w s the finsi poriod of the war. You prefaced this last statement by saying "I know", "ow, how do you know? 3y any other method than assuming that these gentlemen would have felt as you lhlt? A. Mo, I recollect that I have rend that In ons of the reports, that one had tried to carry out the experiments jlsowhore and that one had come across locked doors evoi'y- w.-^re. for Instance, one had Brunswick In mind, I know that accidentally, the *lr hospital at 3runewlck, and that was impossible. Thus, all lnq.lrles had no 6 atlvo answers. %. I gathered from your cnsier to one of my Questions a short tln^ o©o....I would llXe to return to that subject . ..that a person of Intelligence will endure moro discomfort, pain and suffering, pursuing a voluntary experiment which he knows he can terminate at any moment chan a person, prob-bly of less intelligence, would display upon ‘ndergolng an experiment whloh he could not stop at his own volition. Is that correct? A. Veil, there isn't any question that, for those persons in Dachau, the only talt v*a the good food before and afterwards and the cigarettes that they had been promised. Th.-t w-sn't poa lble In the case of ay doctors. They did It because they were Interested and, of course, that w. old h"vo been by f n r the most preferred solution If It uia been possible. And, lnsof-r cs the aibjecte at Dachau, If any of them, at any time durln- tee course of the experiments, believed Court 1 June 3-A-13-4-KD-Karrow-3rown. that the pain or discomfort or whatever It might be called, which they vere suffering »*>uld not be compensated by cigarettes or other promises wr.loh had been made to them, that they would be very rnxious then to be reler.sod from prosecution of that experiment. Is that true? a. Certainly. Thrt's why quite a number of experimen¬ tal subjects oeoretly drrnk water, because the strlot pursue nco didn't please then too much. ’•fell, unlike the experiment-’! subjects In your Institute, thoso subjects would not be particularly lnter- ostod In the result, w^uld they? They had no clcntlflc Interest In the result, did they? *. No, no. None at all. None whatever. Tri£ PAi8ID2NT: Are there nny furhter questions to the wltnoss. 3Y DR. TIPP (Dofonse oounsol for the defendant Bocker-Froyseng:) Q. Professor, tho stntononts made by the prosecutor during the oroas-exaaln tlon unfortunately neoesaltato certain clarifications. First of all, might I ask you one thing? In your direct examination you have, of course, emphasized tho purpose of these experiments. Now, would you finally say Just once again what was to bo aohieved by means of those experiments carried out at Dachau? a. The situation was the following: After Schaefer had developed the Idea of his excellent drug, the question of sea water was solved. Unfortunately, Hr. Berkc arrived with his taste corrector and, becr.use of very euoorficlnl experiments carried out by Colonel Slrcny, the Technical Department spoke In favor of this drug which, from the medical point of view was not suitable beoause tho CLQ2 Court 1 June 3-*-19-5-H3-Xsrrow-3rown. dehydrating effect of sea water wee not being eliminated or it. Thus, a oonfllct orose between sediclne and technique, and the teohnlclans had the greater force, they had to grant the funds and they said "The raw materials for ’•'o feat It were too difficult to obtain. It is easier for as to nanufrcture the Berks affair." Consequently, :hls meeting cooc about during which the two leading experts spoko in favor of carrying out these experioonte although every one of thoa know tha: Vofatlt, of course, oould not bo be ten. Ait It might h'-.ve beon that Berkatlt too hrd a certain advantage over ordinary Sda water nd, as I have said, 2?plngor was thinking of the possibilities that the o.-ncentrrtlng owors of the kidneys might some¬ how be lnoreased. However, the experiments didn't give n definite supportive evidence of that, but thoy did have an la.'ortont result - not only the obvious result, namely, that the ochaef-r water was superior to onythin Q else - but, also, the observation that the kidney onn, never- :hsloes, oonoentrate solt so astonishingly well up to the concentration of sen water that, In futuro, on- could give Che advice that In oases of sea dlstross. Instead of being completely thirsty, one could rather, drink 500 co of eon water end, In tn t annner, lncroase the salt contents of the blood but would not nrvo to be afraid of dehydration q lte so quickly. .'ell then, Professor, if I understood you oorrectly, It w s the ala of the ex^erlaent to estobllsh whether 3 rkctlt, -fter all - probably In preotlcal c'-ses <$f sea distress - ought not to bo Introduced? Is that correct so far? a. Yes, that Is quite correct, since the aviator w uldn't be quite so ourdened by It as by Tofatlt. 8403 Court 1 Juno 3-s»-13-6“3>-iarrow-3rown G. Then ney I put another question to you? According to what you have said, these experiments actually materialized since the technicians had the stronger influence, as you put it, and since they were being supported by Professor Spplnger and Professor rioubner? a. In not quite that sense. That possibly they might have gone over to the technicians 1 side, but thoy did oonsidor it appropriate not to deprive Berkatit of all its useful purposes. G. Veil, then, if it hadn't been deolded, during that meeting, to carry out experiments - of course, this is a purely hypothetical quostion, Professor - what oould you say on the basis of the details? What would have happened? Would WOfotlt or Berkatit have boen introduced in practlco? A. I'm afraid tho technicians would have boon victor¬ ious. Thoy would hevo been victorious over deoonoy. G. So you mean that, without those experiments, berkatit would, nevertheless, havo boon lntroduood in practlco? a. Yea, I believe so. G. And you went on to say, Professor, that tho admonition of water with Berkatit, which is equal to aoa water, would have done serious injury in prnotloo and, provided it went on over six days, would load to doath? a. It would have serious oonsequonoos after going- on for over six days and would most certainly lead to death after. G. And you are making those conclusions on tho basis of final cases of shipwreck? A. Yes. CUiil* Court 1 June 5-«-lS-7-HD-K?rrow-Brown Then, may I put the final question. In this connection, the Chief of Che rfedloal Department, General mr.rtlus, and his assistant, Becker-rreyseng, would have boon actually Irresponsible If this development had boon used without the action being token? In fact the only possibility for preventing the introduction of Borkatlt was t achieve that experiments were carried out? a. It appears that It seamed to be the opinion among responsible persons that, considering the increase iu air crashed, one ought to deal r.pidly with tho question of shipwrecked personnel '•nd achieve the solution. THE PRESIDENT: Counsel, I oust again ask you to prooeod a little more slowly. It Is rather difficult for tho reporters to follow. they were t* *o carried, "ut on c'-ccn- of tho Luftwaffe Hrspital In Brunswick.^ done nothing else because the chair, of coaaand v *uld have been the s^ne; namely, through Dr. 3cckcr-Trcyscng, Tt. Mcrtt, SU9L 4 Jur.c 47-HJjC_i_2_Priaeau (Inti« 3r-vn) C-art I dcpartoent chief, and thee Dr. Kahnt, chief of staff, end, finally, frofessor Schr-eder hiasclf. Dr. BeckerJrcyseng end Dr. Morte were theasolves prossnt at this conference and took pert in it ell together. I could act hare cede rcconnendatlona to Dr. Schroefler directly because I should here had to hare the pornieeion rf the doportaont chief to do io. Moreover, Dr. Schrcoder testified here that ho would not allow hlneolf to be influoncod in any way in hie decieicae. u like to assert the sane n-w ro- cardlne tho oth 0 r co-defcnd.-ntst A H-, n-t at all. *4 Is it not so that, on the c-ntrary, when you Inters yated y-u descrlbod hiw it was that precisely you were not responsible f-r the expcrlnonts? A Tos. ^ Dr. Schaofcr, If y-u say that, hrwever, I nust lo-k Into vhy that opj-lon of yours is not set f-rth In this affidavit of yours. *• nust po through this affidavit point by p-lnt. T-u have the d~cu- rnent before y-u? A Tcs, I do. H Let us first take 73. It pays here: "In May, 1944, I v PS ordered by the office of the Chief of the •fedieni Srrv'cc of the Iaxftwrffe t- attend a neetir.f called f'r the 'ur-^ge -f c-nsistiiv further research on rvOcine ecp water potable.* C49C f- Jc-e *7-H_TjC- 3 . d . F prrw (Ir.t,, Sr-vn) C-urt 2 Is this statement correct? A I should say that It Is badly f-raulated. S-» row research v^$ to he considered. It was alaply to he decided whether Bcrkatit or V-f*tit was to he the preparation Introduced. Q If I understand e-rrectly, the Idea of carrying rn further exrorlacnts was discussed by ether participants In the conference, art by jru, during the c-urse of the c-nfercr.cc. Is that correct? A Yes. *crc is ar obvious confusion here between conditions that arc to be expected in an actual case of shipwreck or sea -Metres*, and 0501 4 Jure 47-XJjC_3jfe_M*loy (iht., 3rcvn) Court I any experiacntt that night hi carried out. <4 Tou say then that in the foraulaticn in the affidavit there it e cenfutien ahont what you said about the proposed experiacntt rr.d vkat you said about the dangerousnees of the BerJea drug ft tuch, if it it uted in an actual cate of tea dietreat without being tested* A let. % And you tec that particularly clearly in this scntcnco which reads: "It was decided—" tuch and tuch, although it was generally adait’ed that tho Berkatit seawater process torloualy i'npairs health, ate.: now what it the incorrectnete you tee here? A The incorrectnete lies in tho fact that in practical caect of tea distress t*c sh'rwrcckcd person drinks seawater in unlimited quan¬ tities vrter the taste of which has boon improved by Berkatit, and dcot not have the will-power to drink only small quantities of the seawater. The ruantltles that he consunes becos© larger and larger until they give grounds for tho apprenh*ntions regarding death expressed in this scntcnco. <4 And for this r»ason you opposed Berkatit as such? A Tes. ti Tho experlccnto that in your opinion would not lead to these injuries, why did you oppose then? A Because in cy opinion they wore oooplctcly uncccssary. <4 And in your previous interrogation you had clearly delineated this distinction, had you not? A Tes, I had. And you a da it an-* want to cay today thnt that distinction of 7ours is not to be seen in this fomula.tion of the natter in this affidavit here? # A Tee, that is 00 . H But your opposition tc Berkatit ao such and your oppocitlon to *>c c-pcrincnts, did you make theoi two oppositions clear to the inter¬ rogator in your interrogations also? G502 t June 47_M-JjC_3_3-M*loy (Xr.t., 3rovn) Court X A Yes, I did* Q, And It it true In this affidavit there is nevertheless nothing to t*at effect? A ?ht 1 bo. ‘v You fid aor.ething shout notes you had set down? A At the end of the Interrogation I was — Uloy (Iet|J Bt-eva) Court I <4 But I>r. Schaefer you will edait that the wey this So. 4 la forsuleted fires the lapreaelro thet tfcc experiments wf hclnf celled d»8Ccrotuf A Tea, y-u emld fet the.t lnpresalon fr*a thla fmrauletlon. C505 4 June 47 -U-S^-i-l-:fcohe=(5ro=r.) Coirt Ko. 1 I r ^Dt4 ycu overlook thet fcctwhen you accepted end signed this effid- eritT ». It is quitoeleer thet es e former kberetcry research me n cno 2 cca not woight every A nglc 'erd cal think ones vey through tho -.-sibio aonsoquoascs of every wexd. L't no retd to you tho lest sent one o from n unber fouri ■Beefc-.r-freyrerg end I wero of the opinion th»t Sireny's experiments vers not ccnsunetcd slrco they did not i naktc cctuel conditions of o sec or.ergoncy.* D®s thet am ell the Sireny experiments -ere irc-nplcto end there¬ fore tho noocsdty existed end y~u ocUrboretcd to cerry on further experiments? *. No. In !=y opinion Sireny's experiments - ere not sufficient to • errivo ct c Jud nor.t rcgrrdlrg the Berk t rothed. \* ®ut, 3cheofcr, hero again you will edrlt th't the fnxuolr tion hero , : ives tho impression thft you er.d SoeVtr-Freyaeng, boccuso tho Sireny experiments wore ineonploto, nedirted f-r new experimentsi wrs thet tho Impression you wish to give in this f-rculrtion? No, not rt ell. I hcllovc thet oar. be soon f ren ny finel turnery, In which I steted ny opini-n of Sirrr.y's experiments. Let us teko o lock ct cumber six. There is discu.-eion here of Boiglbcock's experiments in tho surrxr of 1944 rrd it soys hcroi •Photographs end film were else presented erd verious groups of experiments wore discussed.* 'ov f whet dc you heve to scy flout thoso phetegrepha end films, vbi&i by tho ccy were olrccd diseussod in the interrogation or herring of Bockcr-Prcysongi whet did ycu understeed by this rexd * films* | does thot word •films* lr. the efdid-.vit criginitc with you7 Yes, it did. .* *r.d whet did ycu undorsterd under the term? I wes net thinking of nvin§ pictures, but I did roccll t’. -t ,3-nc photographs hed been projected cn c screor. r :d thought thet theso S506 4 June 47»l-^*’-Zi»2-£Iecbtn(Brorr.) Court No. 1 sere filna of the servo sort ts x-rcy filra, dicrositive filns thr~u~h vhloh li£jht peases. ^urthor it reeds fceroi •Dr. Bclglobccck else rop-rted tbrt the experiments h.d resulted in swelling of tho livor endnervous syr^trcB.* *• Thet neons tho nusclts acre noro sensitive, thr t expression * nervous syr.pt cco." °id you uso thtt phreao, "nerv-us synptoca" in ycur previous other lntcrrogationst -.Yes, it is qulto possible thtt I did. Q» M*het didyou understand thet to neon? *• I understccd thtt to neon e senertl incroeso in reflexes tnd increcsod sensitlvoness of the nusculctca*y system. '‘U "ell, it seys herei •Deliriun erd nsntcl distrubcrccs olso cpp»erod." The nerd ■deliriun" Is an error on ay pert, crlsinc fren oonAislon cs to thirst thtt is ottondent to cholera. U H^r did it htnperd thet you nede this oonfiieioni her did you concern yruraolf provl-usly with the thirst »yz?tr.cm of di 'lore? Thirst in Cholero, this thirst cts tho only thirst previously known rwailting tree c sovere loss of vetor in the iitestines. In cy Numbers ixiper I nedo use of this cnorlgyi thtt is whoro the confusion arose. s* Ho«, how about rental disturbances? "ith this I neavt on apathy end sonnolenco. °r. Sebeofcr, do you have onrush dinical experience, ns yru have cot tetuclly scon these synptcos y-urself, to describe then y.~\yself? *• No, I did not have thtt degree of clinical experience. My d iniccl experience wesnot ltrge. I was prirxrily a labrrrtrry researcher. *t says here furtheri '«s c result of this zeeting, it was deoided that tho Berlcc process 3507 » June 47-tt^.^>Sfcchafc(Bo«nJ Z -urt No, 1 wta cba^utely no use to tbe Luftwr-ffe." H ci thet olrcya been your opinion? Yea. .. mt I mat to rek y.u whet the word cetna ’decided? a. -all, thot ia cn ill dj caen expression, I ahruld here said It m.a ascertained cr reported eedthet res the reault of the oxperinenta. >%• -c.a nrything dedded ct ell, did you be we the right to rr-kc cny dtcld :nj dcca the dlitery cckn declaims? a. The a© ere tfao ailltery orfera. New, I aero to cucber ewwon. •It via or. open aocrot lr. tho highest codiccl circles thit the Berko nethed woa uaed on imetea of concentration cecpa." 'het do you wont to acy obait the necning of thia phrcaoi ’An opon aocrot in tho highest nodicol circles?" a- The expression •open aocrot" did net crigincto with no, U -het bed you than sold in the procoding lntcrro-rticna ao thr-.t tho interrogator chcee this famuleticni whet did you octunlly soy in dotoil? a. I don't beliewt I acid anythin; in thia connection. But it vea dlacovorcd in your interrogations first of oil thot lrcf oaaor Sohrcedor knew of theso things, secondly thet BcckcT-Froysong tajew of then ond who olao? latonson* Now hero by tho phrase "in tho highest acdicol circles" did you apock with tho highest nodical circles, or did yoi Juat happen to hoor tho nonaa ycu Justnonticred? • Yea, thet ia tho phroso "in tho highest radical circles la not Just tho one thet should hare been used. I res told if o nan like frefesaer Schrooier wos present it vculd be perfectly )ustifleblo to use the phreae, "in the highest nodical circles,.* r «. And thet satisfied ycu? Yes, S50C & June U7-H3 .-4-*-aiecfccr.(Brc%) Ccurt Kc. l in the sene =cy ycu ucro satisfied to use the ~ord ■ decided* entirely ealdo fron the question whether you hrd the right to veto? *• Vta, U Now, ^r. Scheofer, I shell aua up. Ycu h -re lust steted thet this affidavit occteics correct lnfomet len end aloe incorrect info motion end the Incorrect lrfoxnatlca reailts Trcn the feet thet correct etatenonte erebreught into eaaccietior. with one another, trhich leed to a construction which you did not intendj ia thet ao? Yes, thet is ao, but I rust any also thet et thot tine I did net aee the full oonsequencea of this erroneous construction. U *nd ycur own attltudo about the axperinonts ia not exjroaaed in thie affidavit! ia ltt -. No. In thia affidavit only your attitude on the Berkctit “ethed ia orp*eased ea such? < Correa t. HcwoTor, durinr the intorro^aticn you did exproaa your opposition to all acperinor.ta end ecnseqaentjy deny rcaponaibiilty for all of then? Yoa, tut apparently I did not do that clotrly enough. teaidoa I acw no roeson far car r ying out tho experinanta *co thore wca nothing to investigate on -ofotit end the cxpa'lnonta on Berkotlt wore uaoleaa. S. Novortholo ss you signed this effidevit, elthough it oontolned portly with ycur knowledge end partly without your knowledge txny errera. It aoya htrci •No duress cr threat of cny kind.’ “ould you please cako e atetanent ebcut this ateteoen subjected tc no daroaa or throet of cny kindf* C509 t, 'I wos Court Sc* 1 1: Jun ii?-4t-5-l-2HK-Cook (Brora) A It is quito true I was subject to no duress or throat but if one is suddenly put in prison there is a certain shock end ono roncta to things thnt really don't exist. Q Until your arrest you wore working in the Aero Medical Center in Heidelberg, is that so? A Yes. Q You woro arrested on 17 Septcater? A Yes. Q And you woro first interrogated hero on the 27th of September? A Yos. Q Wore you told with what you woro charged? A Ho. Q Hew did tbo interrogation bogin? A It bogan by ny being askod if I would recognize ft-ofossor Boiglboeck* Q Didn't you ask why you woro in custody? A Yos, I was told that I first of nil should give infonwtion as an oXpert. Q ’iforo you told you had tho right to rofuso to nako ctataajnts? A No. Q Or woro you told th-t you could rofuso to answor mich questions ns eight tend to incriminate ycu? A Ho. Q VToll, woro you nover told that? A Only .after tte indictocnt. Q m other words ycu voro not told that before this affidavit? A Ho. Q Were you told that you had tho right to have counsel? A Only after tho indictment was tho right of counsel granted. Q I gat ter now fro- your testimony regarding this affidavit and all of your previous testimony that you asserted you wore net respon¬ sible for tho planning or carrying out of tho experiments for tho 8510 Court So» 1 4 Jun 47-U-S-2-£E(-*Cook (Brown) following reason*: First, yj u considered then completely superfluous tsd then there was the further rceaon that during the conferences you could not say any more than you did, thet you had spiritual misgivings about experiments in concentration cenps, that vo know particularly froc kr*. Koenig'■ affidavit. Inhibit So. 19. Bov I should like to ask you the following: Vhat •hsuld you have done had you received tho order to carry out the oxperi.--.ents yourself? A. After the conference if that had cone up I should have askod that I neither bo put in the cccrolsslon or receive any order which had anything to do with that. Q- *hat is all very well, Dr. Schaeffer, but I an asking you vhat you should have done i f you had received that ordor to carry out tho oxporiaonts. A. That is a hypothetical Question which is very difficult to answer. Of course, it Is very easy for ae *o soy today that I should not havo carried out the order. q« Hot havo carried it out? A. So, but vhat I really should havo dono in that caso I don't knew. I should have made efforts to oxtract aysolf free that situation. Hjwovor, that would have been vory difficult. q. K jv could you have extracted yoursolf? Vhat risks would you have run? A. I could have reported as sick. Q. And if you wore not actually sick? A. I could havo given aysolf an injection In tho laboratory or saaetking of the s-rt but that *rs Just cs dangerous itself, bocauso after, I was adnitted to a Luft-'affe hospital it would have been easy to fee vhat I had done and there would have been vory sorious disciplinary conseouenccs. q. Did you have any chance to turn to the public, let us say, through tho pross, if you really did not feel that you could not have a--ything to do with these natters? Court So. 1 4 Jus 47H-5-3-I3i:ocic (Bro*;) A. Shat »«a aulte out of the question. There w no public, not even In peacetiae. There we* no one to turn to If you objected to obeying a state order. Q. And through the regular channel, through official channel? A. There wee even less poibility there. Q. Sow a final aueetion. Are you *till opposed to those eroeri- cents today, after you knov the defense put up by Becker-Freyseng and in part by Beigltoeck? Sow you knov that froc the nedical point of view these experinents ware not dangerous or lnhunane perhaps? A. Ay reasons nov are the sane as they were, naoely, I object to the* on the grounds that the experinents vere superfluous; secondly, because I nyself would not have carried out any experinents on concen¬ tration caap inoates? Q. Shy not? A. Because the voluntary consent of^a concentration caap lnonto is a very relative thing. v And for you this reaeon was sufficient to deteralne your unwillingness to oarticlpete? A. That is so. DR. PLLCXkAXL’: So further questions. THE. PRESIDES!: Arc thoro any further ouestions to be propounded to thie witness by defense counsel? DR. KRA'JSS: Counsel for Rostock. 3T ER. KRADSS: Q, Dr. Schaeffer, I revert to the affidavit you signed, NO-474, Exhibit 131, in which under So. 7 you recETk that it was an open secret in the highest cedical ciities that the Berka aathod was used on • ireates of concentration cnaps. In the exclamations you cad© during your interrogation ’ * your counsel Just nov a raiabcr of further ouos- ‘.ions he.ve bcccae superfluous. Lot so esk you the following emcetion*. Vas the Berks aothod as such a Batter that concerned the Geraons and that was fatiliar in general to the Gercac physiological chooists? Court So. 1 4 v'uc 47-X-6-4-ZEM-Cook (Srown) A. So, by no neons. v Dr. Schaeffer, It it your opinion that for exaaole a veil-known 3arnan surgeon was inforaod about whet the 3erke orocess vns? A. A surgeon - certainly not. 0 . Q. Dr. Schaeffer, do. you have any concrete reasons for believing that the defendant Dr. Eostock knev of this nrccese and of the exuerl- aento on concentration canp lnnttes? A. So, Z didn't knew Professor Rostock at all. I siaply knew ho had a surgical oilsic. Q. Is it true. Dr. Schaeffer, that the ouoted statenonts under Ho. » 7 in your affidavit could not ani vas not intended to include Profoseor Soetock? A. Toe, that le so. X. OAUSSl Thank you, Hr. Preeident. Ho further euestione. Da. STSXXBAQZSt Counsel for Bolglboock. £T DS, STilEA'JXfil Q, Vitnuss, Z havo only throe short Questions to jxit to you. First, when did you sake the acoualntance of Profeesor Bolglboock? A. In Octobor 1944. § In other words, after tho cxperincntsl A. Tos, after tho oroerlsents. Q. The second euostioni Did Dr. Belglboock perticionto in tho planning of the oxocrlnoats in any way, in particular, did ho take port in the conference aeationed in Do curie nt Book 5? A. Ho, Dr. Bciglboeck took pert in no coaferencoe. Q, And until he wns given the order ho could not have known anything cbout the natter? A. Tee, that is so. Q, And now ' It tie final Question. Did he tell you anything about his oxocrinente on hinsoif? A. Tes, he did. ER. S2SI1GA£S3: Thank you. •^513 Court So. 1 4 Jun 47-»-5-5-2ZH~Cook (Brown) THE FrJLSlZLl^: If there ere no further cuestions by dcfer.ee counsel, the prosecution nay cross-exaciae the witness. Prior to the beginning of the cross-exacln/itlon the Tribunal vlll b« In receee a few nirntes. (A short recess «■ taken.) h Jun— r— *— 2j¥. r.loy (Int. Von Sclaer,) •ourt Jo. I. T.'i iLKSHiX: JLixU r; ri ur~l I is t;ain in session. CJC65 1XA1TCATI0N 31 :R. I-XTUT: Q Ur, Schroeder, you ucro in attendance at the freezing con¬ ference in lcumbarg in October 19U2? % A Yes. On the second day of this oeeting I held a lecture. Q >’ho ordered you to that conference? A Goruralarzt Uartius. Q TJho approached you and roquested that you glvo a report at that conference? A I received this asci^-ruont fron Professor Anthony. Q Uoc; did Dr. Anthony happen to approach you? A He knew that I was voicing in that field. Q Voro you conaidcrod an export in that fiold — thirst? A At that tiro? 5 Yes. A I really don't boliovo so. Q Did you have any discussions *.;ith Frofossor Anthony prior to the dolivornnca of your loeturo or report at tho Octobor nooting? A Yos, I talked to hia. Q Did you have any do .“lings irith Bockor-F roysong concerning this natter? A Yos, I talked to 3cc!ar-y«*cysong too. Q l.Tut did you talk to hin about? A Tho thirst probler. in ersos of distress at soa. Ibro or less rhat I know up to that tiro, and -hat I had porforvod an orient¬ ation axporinont. . Q that did you think Bocker-Froysong• s position -..-ns at that ti-r ir. reference to tho Cctchor rooting? A I h-.d the irpr_scion tint lio had to tako care of the business to supply billo* - etc., but that is Just a vaguo depression, I don't, kne-; exactly, Q "ell, vhy did you talk to hin about your report? :-515 l Jun- - -:-2- -4°7 ('int. Von Schoen) Court Ho. I. A Because he happened to be present when I was talking to Professor Anthony. Q .ell, then when you net with Professor Anthony to deter¬ mine whether or not you would give a report at the October neeting Dr. Beclcer-creyaeng was present also? A Yes. Q £»-d you hear any of tho other lectures while you wore at the conferenco? A Yes, on the second day I herrd tho others. $ Did you hear Kblsloohnor's lecture? A I cannot reooctoer Kolxloohner's lecture. I «ssu.» that it was on a dlfforont day. Q Did you hear Hascher's lecture? A No. ’ Q Did you see Becker-Froyceng at the seating? * Yoa, I saw hi.-. Q You stated on direct oxnainetion that 3ockcr-?royson(j was so busy that you didn't havo tho op.ortunity to talk to hin at tho ooting; can you tell us what Iso was busying hiasclf with? A I saw hie in conversation with other people. Q '..'ore you able to ascortain fron faring tho loctvrcs, the various lect»res at this eating in October 191*2 that concentration c-m- in-atos had bejn used for experimental .Purposes? • Ho. 4 Did you hoar any talk about it aft^r the Dotting? A No. Q Did you read the reports that wore published? A V'hon I saw tho record of the eating at tha Institute for Aviation. Iodicino- I read ny locturo to sea whothor it had been ro- ?rc veed correctly and I was u int -rested in tho rest. Q Then the first eico you *oard clout th? axpe-r iron tel prog- ■■rith huaan beings was hare in this courtrooa? £516 sea - Jur.~ 3-3-3-:hloy (Int* Von Seboon) Court Ho. I. A So, the noting on th: 19th ar.d 20th concerning the water experiaents. Q And after having bean co the Iruraberg confcrc-rcc in Cctoeor 1 . Ii 2 and at a later date laving read this portion of the re¬ port of tho October seating you r«rc unable to ascertain that, hunan beings ware used in experixnnts those various officers? A That is correct. q And the first tire that knorlodgo was brought hoao to you that concentration canp incites wore used as experimental subjects * was that conforcreo of 19 Hay 1914, is that correct* A Sot that' th*y had been used, but that tho idea of using thoo was being onturtained. Before that tim, it was through an officer of the Vohrrnclit who had pointod out to no that ho knot of difficulties of getting oxporiaontal subjects for uy thirst oxpori-aonto and suggested that I use prisoners. • q Was tho frocting probLaa of intorost to you? A Ho, not at all, not boforc or afterwards did I over have anything to do trifch the suitfoct. Q Yot you listonod to Ko:zlochnor«s locturo? A I cannot acy. I thin;*.'I did not hoar Holtloehner's luoturo. Q How surely. Doctor, you nvxt rccrl 1 whottor or not you hoard HolzloohncHs lecture? A I would certainly havo rc.M .bered Haschor's rennrk, conseq¬ uently I assix-.o that Holsloohnor's or.d Hasohjr's reports woro on tho first day. q In Kov>;labor 15U3 you ro _ ortcd to the ifcdicrl Inspectorate -'■ :t You had developed a cx-thcd to r.*.a coa .ator potable, is that cor¬ rect? A Yes, that is c err act. Q Was that tho first tl e you had reported to tho hodicr.l I.~-;cc torato? - «-’ur.— rloy (Int. 7or. ichoar.) Court Ho. I. A 3o£ore that I had ndo a report that work ms boin^ carried or. and I rcTXjrtod h cm far the ror!: had gon_. Q Did you conduct experinintetien on antoals wiiilo you wore developing Tfolfatit? A Yv-s. I carried out aninal cxpB r ssiblo to deteminu ehenioally whothor cr n.t Berka water W'uld 3x> offootire, that is water treated by the Borka prooass w -:l'* bo offcotiro t‘ rondor the son-wat».r r r t 3 "l* , T a. Thrt is true and T have prewod th-t. Q, P-w D^ct r, whon yu o.'.rric»3 cut your oxperiaonts then y u" .-vroly pava these »*xperinonte 1 subjects, which y u usod in 1943, so •r.nv cubic cor.t: tors f s -.-water troatod by y ur nothccl; is that * '’rroet? An, y u speaking ab ut tho experiments, which I subaittod as ' cunents t • ny technic.'1 assistants ;u tJw experiment® where 1 drank -519 4 *m0-K-G3S-9-2-H«ofcnn (V.n Sch.cn) Curt s-. 1. tfco «ca-wnt*?r trootod with ""lfntit aysolf? I \. Vnybe I nisun' , cratood jwi, Dcctcr, I understated yru V say this - rnir.r, in answer to my cjjcsti ns, that in tho process cf ioTolopins y ur Schaefer arthed, y:u had experiments or. eninals and experiments n hraan beings. N'w maybe I nlaunderst.' d, did you neroly skate that ym had only tried tho water on y ursolf and did net aubjoct experimental subjects t' sso-wntcr treated by tho Schsofor noth'4? ... That is true, *hot is true, py on ire 1 oxparirents end tho cxycrinonts on hu-rn subjects wv w n -1 cameotcd with i.'clfatit beenuso it was n»t necessary. In tho oxycriaonta, the nnirnl experiments and the human experiments, did y.u subject tho experimental subject# t- son-wator? Only in the animal experiments end ir. s<-no oaaca in tho human oxporlncnta nt tho end -f tho oxnorirxnt. Q. ‘.'oil, whnt wr.a the pt rycao f y-ur hurr n oxporiraents that y-u c nluotod in 1«3; t< lay the .-r.und wrk -f developing tho Sehaefor noth Th'-t did v u d. in these cxyorirv r.ts, did y u ,-ivo tho human sutjaeta wator t* -’rink; just whnt did y u d- with thorn? ... Those subj-. cts wore t •‘•r- nstrote h-w long no e old yo Xith ut wntiT rnd food with<-ut rtcnoginr the ability t-; o< ncontrato sad ability t"> irrk. Q. Then I prosuaw after they hr..’ fia. for a few dr.vs without water r v u w-i-id hsvu thorn ’rink o certain nc unt of soc-wntcr to buo ■hnt the off ots w uld be; can y u explain t us in dotail, D-ctor, Just whnt y u w ro tr”in.y t acc npliah by y ur oxperinents? • I held the peint f vi-xt that it wus better t . with ut fond thrn b*. -’rink sca-wat r. C r.sequ. ntly, I wrntjfl t t03t with oxperirvntal subjects h w 1 -n ; .no can .• with ut f-*cd and r#tcr ith ut 1 sin ir. .fficienov or-’ whether at tv end if nc drank salt ■^tor ‘hirst was lotscnod r increased. Q. -11, at t v sane time did y u --Is. Ir rc an ther ~r uj drinking ?-w:tcr, s.- thrt.yv cm»ld compare the tw<-? K. , I ’id r. t hrvo any rr uj th'.t drank soa-wntor all the time. 3520 •i .*J3a-4T-G'S-3-3«!-'?aHan (7 r. 3eh on) Court V . I. 'Q. Tell h -w did ycu rrkc 3 c -npsris n, Doctor? ... I quest!'ned the s-^nr fors- r. bef ro 2 nd after ihev had drarJc : It ir.t'.r , I asV:d then how they f.lt end whether th t was a god thing «- 11 . n "- or - y« n rc subj.ctir.*; ;ers ns t sclt water, is it necessary t c nfir.o the* ur car. thov c n'uct th-.-ir usual brfsin^ss : r.-» tend te th->ir w rk lilto th*. oxrcrinntal subjects Tr foas.r Vrllhnrdt used In his or,orients? «• That depend n hew rolln^lo the eubj.ets cro. If I hnvo s.no¬ ne in wh n I have c rifletc c nfidonco th"t ho will keep tho c nditi ns f th cx-erirwnts, then ..f c urao ho ©an c ntinuc t pcrf.rn his w.rk. Q. Ccrtainlv if a rrn volunteers f r y ur cxjorlncnts y u w. uld hoeo o nfidonoo in hie, w ulln't y u? ... '>t if ho was j r Toleod r rowor', t ha ref tj r.v ex; orlncntal subjots did n * t ar.v reward. Q. T.tll if w.-u wro c n^uotinf: cxfvr'.nunto n v luntocro and c mr. ha 4 drank eoe-wntcr f r tw J evs and thor. 'ocidod ho c mid n-t stand it any 1 n-or nd thon Welded ho did n.t went t. -o thr uj:h with tho r> st f tho ex; orirrmts and ask if or f d net! wot f 0 urso y u w 11 hero ;ivor. It t- hlr., wuldn't y u D et r? ... F' , of c- ur3c n t. • Thm, he e-j.as'e t- he a v luntcrv subj et, doesn't ha ... Th-t is truo unloss hi had ,Mi,-3tod hlnsclf in th<- beginning fra c .-rtair. nrr-.r' t h Id -tit f r * cvrtoin peri d. If he withdraws fr r his c ntr’.et, he w old n t %t his ;.ov on* th-. oxjcri’V.nts w uld h 'isc-ntinnod. Is it injur! us, D ct r, t ’rink se-'-wnt-r as y ur nly s ”rce f -.ntcr suyj ly? ... Th:. • J :v r. n tbu - ORt f W * r ftn' thi pori «' jf tine • vhich tho water is t ' - {funk. '. quantities f 3 * .-vr t.r car. a n rml pera.n t' 1 rati »ith ut injury am’ f r hew 1 . n.;? ... I w-vld say 400 t 5CO ce per day in Individual doses during 4 Aine-H-CiS-9-4-UochSn (7 / 'n Schocn) c urt y/>. i. Q. "Jell n-w, aftar h*w nony days un’or th'se c a'iti-ns dees the •raiment if hcilth 1 oke plrco? ... In tho £■*: bo >f 400 to 500 cc? *. 1 s, D ctir. ... I wruld thick fpi= tho sixth day .n pai-hops. Q. Toll V'uld that ccur if they continued t drink the sen¬ ator; mslly wJkc would don th "ccur; eft or h-wjttny dry 8? ... Yh-at *ia oxtrenoly difficult t cq-% Q. C:n r u toll us th: ror-a n why eca-wnter is injuri us t«- health nrvi o n esuso d'.oth? A. 1’os, tho rgonlsn has t. olirainato the salt which has boon t kon with tho sea-wr.tcr, but slnoo tho kidneys cro unrale t- raiso such o hi.rh C'r.contratii'n in the urine os son-water, in tho l*«ng run tho •V rust usa up its wn wirplv cf s r-water in rdor t* ol ininn to this »oIt a ad c-nsoquontly dchy’rcti n ecurs. This 1 as • f water • f c urso influences unfO*r robly tho bi 1 • icel process in the tissues. Q. Then e^c it b sold th-t tho nly roas n why son-wr.tor is in- Juri us is tho fr.ot it is n hynort nio salt s lutirnT ... ics, :p w that - q. Toll, was this fhot well mo gnitod by MAloal scientists, bof ro 1M4T - Yes. o522 0 >urt 1 June 4--4-1 0-1-KD-Co ok-Vo n Sc ho en. Q. "ell, doctor, you say that If a person w>a to drink four to five hundred CC of sea vatr that an Impairment of health cay normally occur after five or six dayi, can you tell us vhen on impairment of health would occur to a person drinking one thousand cubic centimeters of a water dally? a. I would say that disturbances eight occur In such cases as early as the. third or fourth day. • Q. Veil under those circumstances could you dotermlno or la It possible to state when death would occur? a. That Is extremely difficult to say. I would not venture to say It. The oapneity of the kidnoy varies groatly from ono individual to another. Q. Doctor, what syaotoas develop while a person la being subjected to sea water exclusively, say after the first or second day, what symptoms develop that nro unusual? a. You moan In the case of distress at oea whon ono can drink unlimited ouanltlos of soa water or deflnlto dosoa? Q.‘ "ell, are you familiar with practical casos at son? A. I know them only froa lltcraturo. I have nover experienced any suoh case ayself. tfoll now what symptoms would develop In a practical* cr.se of a human being at sea where he has access to unlimited quantities of soa wrter? A. If he has unlimited quantities available there would be severe diarrhea. Q. When would that take Diace? V^uld it depend upon the amount of soa water he had drunk or is It ordinarily a second or third day occurrence? A. That would depend on the 6lze of the Individual £ se, from 3CO cubic centimeters on. Court 1 Juno 4-M-10-2-HD-Cook-VonSchoen x. What other symptoms would appear? A. Great thirst, then the symotocs of dehydration, dryness In the mouth and mucous membranes, dryness of the skin, reflex Increases, the cusoles become harder. Q. Hay a person devlop hallucinations as a result of drinking sea wnter? A. Yes, I should think so, because of the need for water there would be hallucinations. Q. Well now would an experiment conducted by a scientist in his laboratory on human beings wherein he applied four or five hundred cubic oontlaetera of sea wator to the subject daily, would those same 'symptoms appear thr.t would be found In practical sea wator oases at sea? A. No. DR. MAAX: (Dofonse Counsel for Professor Schroeder and Dr. Bockcr-Froysong) Hr. Prosldent, I should llko to tako the liberty of Inquiring whether tho Prosecutor ia cross examining the defondant Schaoffer or whether ho is consulting him as an export. If tho lattor is tho case I should have to objeot. I cannot assume that Dr. Schaeffer is in any position to give an opinion here as to the harm which can bo caused by sea water in this case or that, because from the point of view of tho defense I cannot ascrlbo to Dr. Schaeffer tho nodical experlonoo nocessary in order to give an opinion hero. Moreover, it is not compatible with the role of tho defendant in the witness box to appear at tho same tlmo as on export, Moreover, the defense could argue that ho lacks not only the qualifications but the Justification for doing so, I should, therefore, like to suggest that the Prosecution limit Itself to cross examination and not ask questions of this defendant which should be put to an export, C52A S Court 1 June 4-#-10-3-H3-Cook-VonSchoen. TEE PRESIDE}!T: The cross examination by the Prosecution -ay proceed to the extent of determining the reasons of the defendant Schaeffer for establishing his opinion as to berkatit .n the one hand and wofatit on the other. The cross examination should not proceed to the extent of exam¬ ining the witness ^s an expert upon acre general matters. The cross examination may proceed. 3Y MR. HARDY: Q. Well now, doctor, what symptoms would develop In an experiment after a percon had drank 500 CC of sea wator per day? A. If It was given In Individual dosos of less than 300 cubic centimeters In the course of time the s^rao symptoms develop as in ordinary tnlrst. Q. Vo 11 would the same symptoms bo apparent, that Is diarrhea, hallucination# and those symptoms that you out¬ lined that would be apparent in tho case of a person aotually at sea? a. No, diarrhea would certainly not occur, but dn the contrary constipation. Q. Veil If you used 1000 CC would diarrhea appear? A. No, ee long as the Individual doses were under 300 CC. Q. I see, doctor, was there ever a method Invented or developed In the history of Germany to render sea wator potable prior to the time you developed wofatlt? A. A t least I knew of no method. TIicr you were the first one In Germany to develop a method which rendered sea water potablo, an effective set hod? a. Yes, one could say so. C525 Court 1 June 4-I4-10-4-KD-Cook- Von 3choen . Then you are perhaps the only expert In Germany or. the potability of sea water, doctor, you and Dr. Ivy held that distinction In common? as far as removing salt fr^a sea water Is concerned 0 • that seems to be so. Q. Well new In November 1943 when you reported to tho medical Inspectorate that you had a method to render sea water potable, I understood you to say that you actually had an experiment at the medical Inspectorate and at such time Professor Hlppko and others present drank tho sen water rendered potable by the ochaeffar method, Is that correct? A. Yos, that Is true. 4 . Can you toll us or can you recall who olso drank your soa w-tor? • I assume Profossor «nthony, Dr. 3eckor-Froysong, I can't -lvo the nomoe of the other con, I didn't know thorn at the time. « • Q. Now, when you conducted this so-oalled experiment at tho medical Inspectorate did you have raw soa water and then apply tho wofatlt tu It In tholr prosonco so that they could determine you were actually using soa water? A. Yes. Q. And after applying your method the water wqb drinkable. Is that oorrect? A. Yes, tnat Is right. 5. The gentleman at the aceting wore fully aware of tho f ct that water treated by your method was no differ¬ ent than natural water, natural drinking water? „. That is right. 4 . Then actually that was not ~n experiment, It was merely a demonstration on your part? Court 1 Jun e 4-&-1&-5-EB-C o ok-7on 3cho en. Yee, It was a der-or.stratlon. Q. Wien did Professor Schroeder first hear of your sea water, pardon ne] of your method to render sea water potable, that is vofatit? 4 flun11-1 -Grose (YonSchon) C ourt I -- I cannot say when ho first hoard of it. I can only say that I dcncotrctcd it to bin in 1944, perhaps in - provod tho taato and this brought about a psychological danger for tho porcona in distress at oca. Q. Voll, would the food vjuc in Borkatit havo aldod tho distroosod person? a. Bo food content of Borkatit is very groat but tho aaount of Bcrkatit which was to bo put into tho soa water was so eacll that in practico ono can rorlly not spook of any food valuo. Q. Bon whon you reported to Profossor Schroodor you carplotoly outlined nil thoso disadvantages of tho Boriea acthod? A. Tea. V 08 it obvious froo your report that a poraon subjoctod to con w-.tor troctod by tho Borka aothod would dovolop tho iiso syeptOiB oftor t poried of a few days that a porson would develop hod thoy drank cco- aoa ordinary soa wator? A, I onpreoBOd that cloarly. q. Vhat did Profossor Schroodor say? Did you talk to hin about it? A . I had tho iaprossioa that he ronlized that. ^ Bon you stoppod ovor von Sirany's work wore you ablo to tost a srrrplo of tho Bcrkatit? ^ I obtained tho Berketit Inly later. q. Did you ovor test it chcilcally yourself? A . I did not analyse Borkatit itself. Shat would h .vo bocn on- trcsicly difficult, That would havo kept a whole instituto busy. *acrc were various cccpounds in thoro, sugar und fruit acids, etc., but tho 0529 4 Jur.o-i5-iiJ-ll-3-Gross (TonScfcoa) 0 curt 1 effect cf 3crkatit on salt contoinod in soa vetor I tested. CU Voll, how long would it have takes to prove that Berks water van chcr.ic.Uy nothing but see water? Would it take ton yoors, t\:o -:-3-12-3-': arrow (Int. Von Schoen) Court Ho. I. nothod wes nothing rvor- than sea water with a caaouflagtd taste, and that a person subjected to sea water treated by tha Borka itoxIkk* vouid suffer injuries to health and, after a sufficient length of ti_o, die? Did you bring that hose to th. nce-b-rs of that uceting? A Yes, I did. Q ./oil then, tho note by Christo nser. on tega 12 of Document 3ooI: 35, Docv.unt MO. 177, Prosecution -Hiibit 133, wherein ’..a str.tos - on r.go 12, tixj aucond Sentence aft-r tl*. liai of nacaa of those 4 xo3ent at tho 19 'by -etingi "Th» Chief of tho : edict* 1 Service (Citi deS Sr nitactwosons) is convinced that if tho Berkr. uthod is used, ir.i-.gc to health has to bo -x.ected not iter than 6 days after taking icrkntit, which datage will r-ault in >jr»*.mnt injuries to hoclth and, according to tho opinion of Uaterarst Dr. Schaofcr, will finally result in death after rot hater th*n ttfjlv- dry a." Thun, it ia apparent, that Dr. Cliriat-r!in waa fully nrrro of tlx. drnf.era of Barfcntlt as djeer:bud by you. Ia wist correct? A Yea. Q Did you eaphatic-lly state, th'.t d-’ra'i e rould roeult in jxraanont injuries to health and finally result in death after not lr.t-r than t..elvo days? A remanent injury to health - I did not c-y that. T <-ro *= no ;roof of tint. I only arid that aft r twelve days one would have to exooct d-oth. q sell, ac a reauit of this oxjarersicn of your o.-inion, do I understand that you v-ru tlir^atoikid? A Cn tho 20th - at tho end of tho 20th of Kay, Schicklur took no to one side and s-id "If you go on liko this, you will *kve to aisu-jr to ilch for sabotage.* And I asruu, and it is urobably true, that :>j aad, this stfttcacAt because I said that the exp-rfa-nts which to be xrforn_d ware un-ec-co *ry. 0 Did you iawdiately tell Sc]a*c-d_r about that? £53* I Jen-' - —12-k-Airrow (1st. Von Schorr.) Court llo. I. A I told Dr. Bcckor-Pruysosg about thin threat on sabotage. Q ^xn? A Iuadistcly after tlx ix.ting, Q Did Dcckcr-Fr.yav.n- go to Cchrood.r about it? A I don't know. But, according to what I know nor:, it was imposeiblc b-caus. Dr. Schro-d.r was not in Berlin at tlx tine. Q Did you consider it your duty to att_npt to stop tlx ca¬ per lx. at 3 .at Dachau? You wore nn export on son wat.r. That is, tho {Stability thereof • A I considered it ry duty to express ty opinion that tlx ox~ ptrlxnts wore unnooossnry and I did so. Q Did you note Ccbrooder for his support? A Irofessor Sc hr cu dor was not in B.rlin tt the tine. Q '.'oil, is it possible, Baotor, that you wore anxious to have t!x oap-rixxnts conducted with tlx Zorlantit so that a carpai-ieon could bj drawn and, as a r.sult cf t!w 0 aperients, your nuthod v/ould b. the outstanding ora and it irould be necessary to produce your h'ofatit in .r-f.rv.rce to the incffoctivo IXrlcatit? Is that tho reason why you took this passive resisto-nco to tho exp-riaonts? A I didn't show passive resistacx. to tho oxpcrl: ents. I had no int-r.st in bringing this about. I didn't want Tfofatit to bo intro¬ duced beenvao of xibition. I had a nothod t.iuch was bettor. If TTcfa.tit w.ro introduc.d it would benefit only I.Q. Q This is a good breaking point, ’four Honor. T U iF^6!DS,Ti Tho Tribunal -..111 now bo in recess until 1:30 o'clock. (A roCv.se irs taken until 133C hours, ii June 19h7). U Jun-i.-'2-13—i-rriaoau (Ir.t Brcwr.) Court Ha. I. AFT3EJCCK SESSION (The tearing reconvened at 1330 h'-ura, h June 19lj7)» THE :'A2SHAL: Persons in the ccurtro-n pleas,- find thoir s^ata. The Tribunal ia again in scasi.n. D.-i. GA'LDC: As Ccuna.l for Dr. Hevon, Hr. Presidont, I oak th-t Dr. Hovon bo excused fren attonding tomjrrow«a session for tho purpoa, of orvporing hia cnee. TIC 1?CSID2«T: On rocuost of counsel for Defendant Hc-von, ^X.fcndant Hevon say be excused from attondr.noo joforo the Tribunal to- n rrm aerning in order to consult with hia counsel for tho povparati.n £ hia caao which will bo ter.rd very soon. D.t. GA’.XIKi I hava ono further request, Ur. President, For sovorcl days I an having a witness hare by tho naao of Dr. Hern who nuat loavo by tte end of this week. Perhaps it might be possible for no to .ait tho witness Horn cn tho su-nd Frid*y j'rning. I already talkdd it ever with tho counsel for t!.o prosocution. THE mSSIDEhTi TeS — hew long? 131. HARDYi £>r. Steinbmior anticipates his direct ox'ninntion cf tho Dofendant B-iglboeck. It night bo forcible to call tho witnoas Herr, after tte caae of Bciglboeck who will not take nor, than a dry. If not, I cn agree able to having iorn cr.Uod upon tho completion of tho Schaefor case if the Tribunal fw,ls it 'rill n't interrupt tho sequence' -S tho B ea r at-r evidence,. c, : It trill probably be better to c~U tte vdt- hterr afttr tha'c cf tho Schr._f,r caso. lit. liAiiDjSpt is agreeable with so, lour Hor-t. THE I -./ill ask counsel f r defendant Coiglboeck h\ it^sg ,w-onii^pat_r. D.'TST.XN3.'»DE?.i I agr-- that this witness ia hoard after the caaplsuirn f roll. T ©sorrow morning will bo satis¬ factory. itU HARD!i We haw- a request of Defense Counsel for tho filo in offico with notice of tho haclcground of tl* witness Dorn — that is, his nationality, d-to of birth rod so forth. I TIC l-USSIDENTt Counsol for tho Dofondant Hcv u n will find the u3url state.vjnts concerning the witnoss as soon as possible. DR. KONRAD SCHAS^SR - RESU&D CROSS ECIJHATItti (Continued) 31- :a. ha-ot« Q The conf renco 19 iry l9liN — did the members th.roof dis- cr3: - at that time what plan would outlinj tho actu*l vXjxrijKnts which •■c-Jri bo later p-rforaod at Dachau? A Ono suggestion or another vas _cd> but plans in detail not dra.m up. Q it obvious free that moeting on tho 19 th 's.y that ox- Pirlajnts wor- ir-.viV.ble? U Jun-i’i- 3-13-3—?rir«. - a (Ir.t. 3rotm) Court -*o# I. / 4 “ I don't knpK how you intend that question. Q "hat X cm driving at, Doctor, is sL*>ly this. On the 19th of ay, Christenson, Schicklcr, Berta, Schacfor, Beckor-Fr,y^n«. -r. • Jtehl and Jirjcr Jowerok net togethir to discuss further research -.s to the potability of son water. Can you kindly t^ll no whether or not on the 19th cf I .ay — not the 20th or tho 25th, but the 19th.— a discus¬ sion took placo concerning experiments to b_ conducted; or was that a neetLag limited aaroly to tho discussion concerning the attributes and qualifications of the Berta aothod as opposed to tho Sehoofor nothM? Court So. 1 4 Jus 47-A-14-l-E3i-Maloy (Brown) A. The conference on the ISth was Halted to ccr^arlng these two aethods to one another. Eoverer, the proposal wj *e also aade that this difficulty he attacked exocri mentally. Q. Did you raise any objections to a proposed exoerlacntal plan on tho 19th of hay! A. Tos. I said that I— I said I couldn't soc why oxocrlaents should he carried out about that. Q» Vhy did you object, aore spoclfleall"? A. Bocauso * didn't see tho reason for that, 0- Too thought that they vero absolutely •innecossary! A. That is right. Q, Did you consider that these axporlaento would have beon crlalnal? A. So, one could not have boon of that opinion. 15-l-::eohan (lot Brown) Court Ho. 1 DR. PSLOCI^HH i I should like tc object. '•*. Hardy is asking questions regarding thrcughts which Becker-Freyscng perhaps entertained or could have entertained regarding the reasons for the experiments that were undertaken. I believe thrt this is a hypothetical question because the defendant Dr. Schaefer cannot state what thoughts Bcckcr-Frcyseng has. He has repeatedly said that he repudiated the experiments and that he had to do only with Vofntit. I do not believe thet the witness can answer cny other hypothetical questions but the so relating to that. UR. HARDY : I am unaware thrt I asked him for his opi¬ nion, I asked the 'witness just what thoughts Beckor-Frey- song expressed when they planned these experiments. D.i. PDLOCl/klJN . Then in that case I did net understand the translation, it is perfectly alright fer Mr. Hardy to ask the witness whrt thoughts wore expressed. IKS PRSCIIBNT i Ccunsol en cross-examination may ask the witness what was said at these ncotings by the different members and present if he* remembers wlv*t was said and if ho has the information, but he shculd net be asked for their thoughts, ideas cr purposes insofar as they were not expres¬ sed in words. BY MR. HARDY . These ex. vrinonts, Dr. Schaefer, ns I understand them - and I might admit th»t at this point I am slightly c-nfised - w^re conducted f r two purposes , one was to sa¬ tisfy the curiosity of frcf.sscr Eppinger > what w°s the cth^r purp-s. for ? •».- To satisfy Frofcsser Eppinger's curiosity , I don't believe that was the purp-s- cf the experiments. 1- - rf'ell, one was te test thv. efficacy of Eerkatit cn 85Ui 4 Jano-*-7L-15-2-:'eehan (Int. 3rown) Court Nc. 1 the kidney and that wps Fro fe seer Bppinger's question j was th.re another purpose ? «%•- I assume that . As Beckcr-FTwyscng stated it here. There wos also the purpose cf deciding whether it is bettor to thirst altogether -r to consume scell quantities cf see w«tcr, but who first had this idea or drew up that plan I conn-t recall that. His opinion was that ''Iso small quanti- ti s ,f that s-a-water should tc drunk. Veil, in viev/ cf ycur constant pretests to Bcckor- Freyseng, didn't he else strenuously object to any experi¬ ments ? A.- N~, ho did not. >- Wb6 he also r doubting Thoons, so to spc*k ? A.- Ho was c.nvinc,d thpt Wefatit was good, but Chris¬ tens,n said there is nc silver and everybody including mo th-ught that Woffetit is out of the question because there was nc available silver. Nov, I resume that then the ques¬ tion wps, should the 5c-rkc method be used r not, should p little bit jf sea-water be drunk or should the person thirst. 3y the way ir. quite n different position than I rs in. I do not knew it, I do n-t kn,»/ his motives. Thrnk you, J,ctv.r. ’/ns it discuss:d at this meeting on the 19th -r at the ncctin 0 on the 2Cth cf ?fcy as tc the du¬ ration of the experiments ? /».- Regarding th- duration .f the experiments only this rs s r id, p drug r prep? rat ion is needed which will permit pc,pi-: tc survive for twelve days at sea and the experiments '.re t; be continued until seme physical disturbances occur ir. the experimental subjects -’.nd if nc disturbances occur, then the experiments »r_ tc be discontinued after the twelfth day. That was r.ughly the general impression cne ga- 8 5U5 4 June-A-rL-15-3-::eeh£n (Int. Br.'wn) Czar t No. I therod from that discussion. i>id it annoy you that the moating went this far after y.ur objections had been raised ? A.- Yes, that did annoy me. i*~ -ell, when they discussed tha duration cf the ex¬ periments did they at that time discuss the subjects to be utod ? The discussion cf the experimental subjects wa6 taken up later. It ws generally ascertained that there were nc experimental subjects available and sc ffcr ns I can re¬ call, Jr. jchickl«.r spoke tc Beckor-Freysong, and they were speaking nt this tin. ef mother pcssibility, and then the proposal was cade to use prisoners. ... .as the prep', sal net tc use prisoners brought up because of thv fact th"t you omphesizwd that <*ny experiments lasting tw.lve days wherein Ecrkatit vrs used th^t death Q“y finally result ? A.- Ho, I consider th^t quite cut ef the question. It was n^t said th»t the experiments had tc last twelve &~ys, tut that they should last that long if there were nc dis- turbancas that occurcd. This passage on page 13 ef document bo Jc He. 5, the same d.cumuit, He. 177, Prosecution Exhibit He. 133, under 2 states ; "Hiration cf experiments : 12 days. “Since in the cpini.n of the Chief cf the nodical Ser¬ vice (Chef fC8 S-’nitactswcsens) permanent injuries'to health, * .rt is, the death of the experimental subjects' bad to bo expected, as experimental subjects such persons sh'.ul'- be us>.a 5 s well be put at the disposal by ReichefUchrer $5." DCcsxft th-t passage, written ty Christensen, convey the 85Jj6 4 June-A-?L-15-4-:fcehan (Int. Brown) Court Sc. 1 thought that the necessity cf resorting to the Reiehsfuehrer OS t. obtain subjects wns simply because the death of the 6 xp6rimont°l subjects had to be expected ? A.- Sc, nc one ever sold anything like this ncr do I recall anything of thot sort. I>-es that passage convey that thought oven cf it¬ self ? V- Yv.s, if you would rend this passage you cculd get that thought. Th»t is however simply a coapileti.cn on tho part cf thG pers n who ’.’-rote this statement. v .- Vos this the first time that you have henrd that jxperia.nt 0 ! subjects were "v^ilcblc in ocnccntraticn camps, ine&auch as you were unable to -scortain fr~m Kolzleehner's report -f the Numbers conference in Octrber cf 1942 that cen centrrti-n cemp inmat.s v/crc used > \vp 6 this tho first time that information vas br*u3ht home to you ? •m- Yes. ;. - -Jit this horrify ycu, D-ctor ? A.- I oust s y th°t I found that ? very unpleasant thought, because I dislike experiments cn prisoners. k .- li?.C y-u ev.r b.«.n horrified at -»ny other aotheds used in c-rtain research circle*s ? A.- .re ycu thinking cf ether literature ? U J^-.WP-16-l-Ccok (Int. Dram) C-urt I C ; . !Io, I an thinking of a passage in your doainent book Ho* 1, in Schaeffer docu.-*nt boo!: 'o. 1, Docir-ent Ho. 3, which is Schaeffer Exhibit j:o. 3, on page 5, "hich is the last page of an affidavit by Dr. Heljsufch Reichel, and ho states therein in the last paragraph as follows: mj vas separated froa Dr. Schaeffer by the war. Not until the vrar was ovor did I r»et him again in Dad Fjrraont, where, as he had done be¬ fore the war, he expressed tc -» his horror at the Mthods of certain resoarch officials." ;* 0 w, Dr. Schaeffer, nhat of .ods do you have in =dnd and That were the horrors i*- snnnce that is expressed in than affidavit which you just axxtod refers to tho quackery on the part of Borka and Sirany, ^o, not only in this field, but also in otuxr riolds, -.wrc sold on throvdnK their weight around. To ra personally o:nori:nnt3 on prisoners did not anpoal. q. Do you feel in year opinion that a person incarcoratod in a concentration ccnp or a orison is not in a position to volunteer for radical ortporinonts? It looks os II ho could but his active for so doing oonnot bo checbod on ond p^cholosically easily influenced persons sdght un*r certain clrcunstances apply to ho subjected to such eaportants *on under other circunstancos t*yrould not. Ihis is in a certain sonso an exploitation of the situation ir. nhlch these p.oplo find thonsolvos, and the ratter is still bouv. debated. q. yctrat these varies conferences where it wnsdxciJP-lo-J»-Cook (jnt, Tram) Court I A, Yes, that is right, Q. Did aoiglbo-ck report at th'.t rating about the ejperirfints 1» performed on hinaolf? A, Do yOU runn Mother bo ro. ortod on it officially? I . It is ox- tronoly difficult to re ranker all thoso things and the consoquoncos of one little word that night be wrong I have soon horo. Q Hell, did he toll you, for instance, that it was necessary in tho course of the experiments to tio one of the experimental subjects in bed bccauso tho Gxp3rL-ont~l sufc joct had succeeded in gotting sane water to drink? Didn't he tell you that? A Ho didn't say that anybody was tied to bed, no. Q Tell, you recall in Document Book 5, the affidavit of Bauer which is on page 25. I anticipate an objection. Your Honor. This docu- 8553 I Jun-A-!3-17-3-C-ross (Inti Brcrm) Court lib. I. sent was admitted provisionally. DR. STEINBAIBR FOB BSIG12CGCK: I object to this question be¬ cause this document was a (bitted only under the condition that a sworn certificate bo subnit ted later. The xTosocution can, therefore, not use this doc ice nt and I object to this question. IS. HARDY: Tho docunont has been suanittod provisionally, your Honor. Tho FToeecution was to obtain a jurate to tho docuaont. That has been obtained. The docurorrt is in duo fora and will bo of- forod forrully when the Tribunal sots aside a date for Prosocution to do so. I hare the jurate, it states: "Boforo co, Lionel Shaffrow, special agent, CIC, appoarod Ignaz Bauor, to ao known and in ay pros- oncc signod tho foregoing statorsont written in tho Goman language" Signed by Lionel Shaffrown, CIC. So that hurdle has boon ovorcono and I should like to continuo ny cross oxraination. DR. STEINBAUER: Thank you for tho explanation. BY IB. HARDY: Q Now in this Docicont on pago 2$ of tha Docunont Book, Uth paragraph, this witnoss states: "Tho thirst was so terrible that scco patio nt s did not hesitate to drink dirty wator usod for washing tho floor* I saw ono of tho so poor devils." Do you havo tho pngo, psago 26 of Docunont Book 5, Docunont NO-910, Prosooution Exhibit 1]*0, tho socond pago of tho affidavit, tho paragraph in tho ciddlo of tho pago occnencing with tho words Tho thirst was so torribla that sono patients did not hesitate,..." It nay well bo - you havo it? Tho thirst was so terrible that so no patients did not hesitate to drink dirty water usod for washing tho fleer. I saw one of these poor devils falling on his knocs, bogging in vain for water. Doctor Bcigolboeck was pitiless. Ono youtfi, who succeeded in getting sono water to drink, was bound to his bed for punishment." How, did Beiglboeck report about any of thoso conditions that ho encountered during the course cf his experiments? U Jur.-.’.-KB-17-u-C-ross (Int. 3rcwn) Court Ho. I. Q TToll, didn't you ssk tho all important question of tho ex¬ perimenter Bciglboeck - how well tho experimental subjects cooporr.tod and whether or not using concentration era? inmates would be advisable in tho future? fferenH these questions important to a sciontist and a san who was horrifiod at using concentration crap inmates? A I don't understand tho last part of your sentonoo. Q I s-y, weren't you interested in knowing how well these experimental subjects cooperated? A Yos, tho Boiglboock said that aany of them drank wator. q Did ho toll you whether or not deaths occurrod? A Ho said that thcro was no death and that all pationta re¬ covered extraordinarily. Q Did 1 » tell you what ho did with tho subjects after 'no had couple tod tho oxporiaonts? A Ho said thnt ho gavo then a follow-up examination and at tho end tho patients got very good food, and that they wore givon specially good oaro for a ccrt-in time afterwards. Q Woll, do you recall in tho affidavit by Pillwoin uhoro Pillwoin stated th-.t tho patients wore put back into tho regular in¬ firmary in a vory weakened and darngod condition where they diod after a short tiro? DR. IEICKMANH: May I make an objection, Mr. President. Mr. Herdy is hero asking the witness whether ho remembers tho affidavit of Hr. Pillwoin. I boliovo this question is relevant. Tho issuo is not to tost tho memory of the witness - whothor ho is able to roro>sbor an affidavit which was submitted four wocks ago or 8 weeks ago. Only that can bo shown by these questions. Tho witness can say ho can ro- ur.bcr it or cannot renenfcor it but that is completely irrol(frnnt in the cress examination of this witness. I soe therein only a moans of bringing up for discussion prosoctuion documents which have alroady been sutaittod and I think that should be avoided. MR. HARDY: I think the objection is veoy well takon, your U Jun-i-?S-17-5-Orc85 (Int» Brown) Court Ho. I. Boner* I sill rephrase ny question* 31 B. HARDY: Q Did 3eiglbocck report at the tieeting in October that patiants were put back in the regular infiroary in a very veakenod ard danngod condition wherv. they died nftor a short tine as set forth in ?illv;cin*3 affidavit? 4 Junc-A-?L-18- 1-K°rrcw (Int. von Schcen) C:urt No. 1 2 ic, Frefess^r Boi_lb.eck oid n:t report that, and I do r.:t believe thet that is in tho effid^vit of *tr. Iill- vem. Yea will find it in the. effiervit of *!r. Pillwoin, which is Prosecution Exhibit // 139, lament Ko. 912, in IX-Cv^nt 3cok // 5, Year Ken.r. TH£ PRESIEGOT : C-uns«.l should exhibit these affidavits t: tho witness if ho desires to question hin. BY :S. H-uRDY i i h"ve n. further questions on the affidavit. Did Dr. Beiglb: ock tell ycu vhrt nationality the sub¬ jects were that he used ? Iw# Did he t-11 y-u whether cr nrt they were volunteers? I r.member that he sc id that they wore volunteers in tho experiment. uid he tell ycu that Gypsies hrd been set aside by the deichsfuchrer SS f.r use in tho experiments ? .v- I heard that Gypsies were used, txit I do net reacn- eor frea when I hoard thet. dc ycu have D cuhont Beck // 5, Doctor ? .*•- Yes, I do. -..ill you turn tc Document No. 179, which is 1 r: se- cutier. Exhibit 135 ? It is on p«-go 20 cf the English, The letter fr.m Grrvitz, R;ichscrzt SS, te Heinrich Kianlor, % ccr.c.rning the experimental subjects tc be set aside fer these sea v^ter experiments at Dachau, .ould ycu kindly turn tc the p^r°graph numbered vith 2 stating tho # fpinicn -f 35 Gruppcnfuohrcr Gluocks fren which I quote : "Referring t~ the above letter, we report that we h*va nc -bjucti.ns whatsoever to tho experiments requested by the 8557 4 Juno-'»-FL-13-2-ICar row (Int. vcn Sch. on) c.-rt Ho. i Chi-f -f the Icaical Service cf the Uiftwrffe to be conduct¬ ed at the cxpcria.ntal station Rp.scher in the concentration camp Dachau. If p-seible, Jews cr prisoners held in quaran¬ tine are to bu used." New, Doctor,' I «*a fully »wprc of the f p ct tlvt you old n.t "oceiv- this letter end th«*t here in this court room is the first tia- th-t you hove 8v-cn it t However, dess it *p- pc-r. t y.u th^t the language ‘‘If possible, Jews cr prisoners h.ld in "uarantine arc to b- used" conveys the thought that these subjects were volunteers ? I don't know how aiuiy prison.rs thirc were in qua¬ int in-. I c-uld imagine that if there wore several hundred prisoners there, one c^uld go and esl: for volunteers. That c ndusion is net ce spelling. «til, d-es th- next paragraph, written by 3$ Gruppcn- fuehr..r Ncbt c-nv-y to y-u that the subjects used wore volun¬ teers *? Thj pri-graph reads as folicv/s : "I n & r.e v/ith the prop oar 1 tc conduct cxperir.ento on pris-n.rs cf c-nc.ntrati-n caups in order tc evolve' a method f:r unking see. wnt^r potable. I propose taking f-r this pur- r-se the asocial gypsy h-lf breeds." DR. iSLCKTliK: • Mr. President, I should like to object to th- c-ntinuati-n cf this lino cf qudstinin?. *!r. Hardy has elr-ocy confirmed that Dr. Schaefer s r v thi6 decunont here in the court r, a for the first tine. Theref ro, quos- ti.ns es tc his interpretation of th- contents of this dc- cuent cannot bo the subject of an ox«ainati-n of a witness. Just as w«.ll as this witness, or cv-n bettor, the Tribunal can interpret what the 1 -ttor uc'ns. :a. H .Rrn . ypy I call to the attention cf th^ Tribunal tO.Pt t.liS S--»- objection was rr.ised when I put - or orybe 8556 4 June-.'»-?L- 18-3-Kcrrcw (Int. von Schcer.) C--irt So. 1 [r. ITcHaney put the sroe questions tc the defendant Schrcedor ?nd I put the aecc questions tc Bcckcr-Frcyseng, end, at that ti2c, the Tribunal overruled the objection. IKS PRESIDENT : There is ne recollection cf the ruling of the Tribunal on "ny similar question, but it scens that the answer would be ueroly a supposition cn the pprt of the witness. ?3. B.RDY : ?hc question I nn driving et, Your Honor, is tc ask the witness whether or not, if he hod knowledge cf the frets elicited in this letter, would he core stre- nuon sly objected to the experiaents on the inaates et Da¬ chau. JUDGE &SB3MG ; Why don't ycu ask hie that, !Ir. Krrdy ? :n. asRDY i I'a building up tc the creation, Your Ho¬ nors' Witness, will ycu kindly answer that question. THE 1RESIDENT ; Propound the question again to the wit¬ ness. HR. I-^RDY * If you had received this letter, would you have core strenuously cbjcct.d tc the ^xperiaents at Do- ch«u ? DR. PBLOCUKH : I should like to object fig«in. The pro¬ secutor hinself hrs acid.that he knows that the witness did net get the letter. Therefore, it is unnecessary to ask vhcth..r he did get the letter. THE ^RESIDENT . Objection sustained. BY-*#. HARDY . * Dr. Sichacfcr, when ycu executed your affidavit, which is Decent NO-474, prosecution Exhibit 131, was that submitted tc ycu in the Gcrorn language fer signature 7 4 Jur.£-.»-rL-18-4-f:arrcw (Int. von Schoen) Court Nc. 1 Tht was -n the 23rd cf October, 1946, was it net ? J \ A.- Yes, that's what it srys. It's probably right. - Jid anyone compel you to sign this affidavit ? A# - Nc# Did you have the opportunity tc make corrections therein ? A.- Yes. May I finish answering ycur question ? Q.- Certainly. A.- On the unimportant points it was very ecsy, but on the -lore important things it was acre difficult and, tc whe- ly oppose the arguaonts cf the interrogator was difficult. I, at the moment, thought it was true. You, in fact, did make n considerable nuaber <-f corrections in the original, did you not ? A— Yes, in the original, Yos, I did mako a number of. correct!-ns. You wore unJer ceth when you executed this affida¬ vit ? A.- ^0 8. D-ctor, new in auaaaticn, you were in attendance at the c-nforcnce cm the 19th cf 'Ay, wore you not ? .»•- Yes • At that conference you submitted objections to the testing and use .f the EerkA method ? if Yc.8# You etteno’cd the conference "n the 20th cf '>y ? • Ycs« And you attended e conference- in Octeber, 1944, when Dr. Leiglheeclc reported the results cf hie experiments ? A.- Yes, bat I was ordered to attend all throe. I was -recr^d te att.nd -’ll thr-e meetings. 856 o 4 June-A-FL-18-5-Karrcw (Int. Vcn Schcen) Court No. 1 t .- I understant that. I have no further questions, Your Honor. 'uu. r^^siDSTJT : Any further questions to be propounded to this witness in connection with the cross examination ? RSDIRECT EXAMINATION BY DR. FSLCXHANN s q.- Dr. Schaefer, the prosecutor asked you whether you demonstrated your method among others also to professor Schroeder, in the presence of Dr. Becker-Freyseng. Then, on the basis of this demonstration, yrtte everything done - all steps token for the introduction of Wofatit in the Uiftwaf- fe ? A.- You mean my demonstration in December, 1943, to professor Hippke ? q.- Yes. A.- Not Professor Schroeder. Yes, of course. q.- Orders were given to do everything to introduce this method ? A.- Yes. q.« The prosecutor spoke of your opposition to the ex¬ periments end said thet there was only a passive resistance because you sow an opportunity in these experiments to ma¬ ke it quite clear, by way of experiment, how good your me¬ thod was and how poor the Berka method wos. He said that, didn't he ? • * Yes, he did. v- First, I should like to ask you, was your resistance passive ? A.- No, it was not passive. There were violent alter¬ cations. 7 .- ait you didn't have any success with your resis¬ ts! 4 Jun.e-A-FL-18-S-Karrow (Int. von Schoen) Court 2i o. 1 tance. Therefore it oust have been we»k. ...» Cne couldn't say that. After all, I kps only an Unterarzt. I could not do much against a group, of universi¬ ty professors, world fsaous sen. I couldn't do such against ay superiors with the highest military ranks. -*nd the possibility that you wanted to bring out through these experiments that Vofetit was good and that Ber- katit was bad, that would probably have existed only if experiments had *160 been conducted with Wofatit ? . A.- Yes, that idea is divergent.... (Interrupting) Just a minute, just a minute. Answer my questions concretely. The possibility of contrasting these two methods in an experiment and proving how good your method was could hove existed only if your method had been included in the expe¬ riment ? .»•- Yes. (*. - -»nd did you do anything to hove your method included in the Dachau experiment ? No, nothing at all. .;- On the 19th or the 2Cth, at these meetings, was any¬ thing said about introducing a series of experiments with '.’ofttit ? A.- No, nothing.' At the meeting of the 25th of May, while you were present, was anything said about introducing a series of ex¬ periments with Wofatit ? •a.- No. Jo you consider it possible that the introduction of a * Of at it series of experiments was ordered after the 25th 4 June-.v-FL-18-7-Karrow (Int. Von Schoen) Court No. 1 of Uey on the basis of deliberations of thQ so called com¬ mission 7 A.- That is possible. 4 .- .ind is it possible - the defendant Bcckcr-Freyseng testified this - is it possible that n series of experiments with Wo fat it is exactly the s«ae things as a series of ex¬ periments with fresh woter 7 A.- That is not only possible, tut that is a certain fact. o r- June U7-^-».TD-a9-a-»aloy (Int* von Scboen) curt No. 1 Q Then suming up all these considerations which wo have Just elicited in individual quosticns, what do you have to say to tho assumption of tho Prosecutor that yrxi had a personal interest in tho execution of tho Dachau experiments, would ycu reject that assumption? A Tea, completely. In this connection I should like to remind ths Tribunal of Exhibit 37, the tostlr»ny of the Witness Pohl where Pohl says that no mention was ever made of tho Introduction of a Tolfntit scries of o xp-rinonte, I should like to say that If I had had the slightest lntorost in this I would have taken an activo Interest In tho oxporlmonta, and how they woro arrangod. Professor Eppir^er had boon invol'od by Eorkatit, Ho was in chargo of oxporirwnla for SIrony. Tho oxporinonta showed what tho ucthod of the execution of tho cDcportoonte, what significance it has and tho objectivity of results oan inprovo on tho nothod of axpuriaontation, Q On tho 19th of ‘lay you oppoeod Borkntit, ypu also ob Joe tod to undertaking oxporinonte? A Toe, Q But experiment* on prisoner* had net boon mentioned yot? A Tea, that is right, Q For what ronson* did you objoct to^cxporlnonts on tho 19th of Xayt A Booauso I considered then superfluous, Q Did you havo any roason to rofuso to oboy tho ontor to attond on tho 20th of !toy? A No, thoro was no roason to do so, , q Was thoro any roason you had to know that oxp-riuonts would bo performed or would at least bo discussed, oxpjrimonte on £ concentration canp lrnatoe? k No, I did not know that, q If you did not particularly want to go to this meeting on 2* Hay why was that? o vr JUTJJ U‘W-iTlW. 9 -a-»lor (Int. Ton Schoen) ;urt ffc, 1 A I vr.3 annoyod because the other people rofbsod to under¬ stand* q Ycu thought tho whole thing was superfluous, the discussions cf experiments? A Tos. q Thun on the 20 of 'ay us Beckor-Froysang and ytxirsolf h?.vo tostifiod, tho idoe of experinents on prisoners was brought up for tho first tino? L Yos. Q Vfjs-t fooling did you havo then ssido fren your cbnscious- noss that tho oxporir.onts woro superfluous? A I folt tl»t it was unpleasant to carry out cctpurinonts on prisoners, Q Did yownntijxithy oxtond only to p-rfornin-j oxpurlnonta on concentration oaap inintoe or waro you then are you nowi convinced that oxp-risents on prisoners should not bo porfomod at all, cdthor on concentration ctrip prisoners, or prison imatos, prison irwatos in r rany or •-'erica or any place ulso in tho *orld? A Yos, that was oy convidtion then and it is :iy conviction row, q Mow, aftor tho 20th of ’lay did you do anything toward expressing onco :»ro your dovintinp opinion? A Yos, Q Km it did you do? A I talkoi to Bockor-Prcysore about it, Q You telephoned to hL:? A Yos, q Arvi was your telephone conversation indudod ir. the af A- lavit exhibit 19 of firs. Koonig of which I havo subidttod, and is it described c.rroctly? A les, it is described correctly? 8565 I U Jtao U7-n-t'.T>193-'2l03 r (Brt* von Soho on) Court Ho. 1 q What caused you to attend tfca conferonco cf “ay 25th, first oxteraally tb.ro was a rdlitary order, second whr.t considerations, what inrlfcr attitude did you havo at that tine? A Tho axperta wore to consult with each othor. Px*cfossor Sppirvgor, rofossor Huabner an-' Profess or Setter ware to decide nhother oxporinonta woro necessary at ell* Q lour nodical opinion waa settloi? A Tea, and I aaau-od for sura that those throe gontlcnan would roalixo that Berkatit waaocnplotoly useless. Q And thon in the Booting at least ac far as you woro prosont, until you wore aaporctoi fren the ethers bocauso of tho air raid, yxi woro sorioualy disappointed in this opinion? A Yos, I was quite bitter and I lcot v faith in — I will havo to speak gen-rally, — ny faith in scientific Ju ’gr-ont. q Do you thin:; that tooso gentlaacn gave their opinion against thoir hotter knoslodge? L Ho, noj why ahould thoy 3o thet. q -Tho rocs on I ask is that tha Press cut 3r has stntod that Professor Bppingor eo.isittod suicide, awl aa the Prosooution said apparently booauao ho was aware of his yuiltj thoraforo, I ask you do ym know whothor all tho other gontlcnan •-arc still alivo? A Tos, tha others arc still alive-, ind are still working os pr-foasors in thjir flal-’a. Q Tho;.' havo not oo :dtto J . suici ’o? s A Ho, they havo not ca nit tod suicido. q So apparently they arc not sufferin • fren a uilty corsoicnco? A He, -pparontly not. q If csx? ri ajr.ts were porfemod with Hdfatit '.-as your P»r- ission require’ t-' p:rfor: axp.rir r.ts with "cifatit? A 'r, cno .could ut the '-olfatit flren tho I.C. h June U7-.'.--TI>-I9-^Aloy (Int. wn Schocn) Ccurt ?fo« 1 \ Q Con y jo li^slno that too ror-dssiun of & Untomrst would havo tc bo obtained? A ffo, that la quito fantastic. Q Can you l^ajlno that too experiments with >lfctit woro performed to aoo what effect ^olfatit or rath or toe s<* vator troatod with '4olfatlt had? A Mo, there was nothin? tc bo soon. Q !tr. 5fcr-V cakod yea about what Professor Bicgolboock roportod concerning too ox^rinonta in *chauj I assume it escaped your attention that !. Hardy *1"=) «•» Profossor Biogolboech ask you and you answered ro panting a cyoat doal of what Pro foes or Biagolboock rc per tod about the oxjx-rlrcntsj did you noon to say that Professor Bertatit told you all that personally or that ho told that in his locturo? A (to, I Leant to say ttat bo said that in Ids locturo, at loaat sw*t of it» Q Professor Biogolbook spoko to you only briefly? A foa, only briefly. DP_ pslcC'AW* I have no further quostiona. It Jun-A-4©-2^1-Meehan (int. Brown) Court No. I. 3T DH. MARX (Defense counsel for Professors Schroedor and Bocker-Frcy- aeng.) v Q Dr. Schaefer, you said in your cross ejcsalnation that Professor Anthony had given you orders to go to Vienna and look at Sir any* oxperiaenta; do you know eatently whether Professor Anthony gave you this order on his cwn authority or whether ho passed this order to you dn behalf of the dopartnent chief? A I assuoo that he gave it to m on bo half of tho depart¬ ment chief. Q Can you rocer.ber who sipiod tho travel order and the nilitary ticket toe this trip? A No, I cannot recall that. Q lou said that you warned Prof. Schroodor and Dr. Bockor- Froysong that Borkatit was dangorousj now did you warn thon about ths danger of 3ork«tit in practico of soa distress or tho dangor in oxpori- nonts? A This warning roforrod of oourso to cases of distress at soa. Q Thon I should liko to ask you scoothing else, tho Prosoc- 'Jtor askod you Mother An tho nooting whon it was docidod to jX>rfona tho oxporiaonts in concentration cnape, those aro tto words of tho Frosocutor, ""hotter you woro offered to suporriso thoso experiments or to carry then out yourself"; in tho threo raeotir^s on tho 19th, 20th and 25th of May was it decidod to carry out oxporinonts in concentra¬ tion caape - the oophasis on tho word "decided"? A No, that was not docidod. Q to 19 )L\y 19Uli was it jicntionod at all that experiments ware to bo jnrforaod on prisenors? A No. - Q to 20 Hay 19U» at tho nocting, what was said; was a de¬ cision reached at this nocting? A No, the suggestion was made, i.o. the possibility was a Jun-A-ffi-2 0-2-itoe han (Int. Br cwr.) Court No« I # brought up# Q fta tho 25th of May, 19UU, were prisoners nentioncd at all or was not everything else to bo triad first to carry out the ex¬ periments; for example in the Luftwaffe agencies, in tte Military Ifed- ical Academy, otc.j were not all other possibilities to bo exhausted first? A I was present at only a part of this rooting on the 25th, as long as I was there nothing was said about prisoners, that is 3howi by a few affidavits, too* Tho possibility of carrying out tho experiments in Brunswick secned to bo tho predominant idea. Q Tou can reuonbor that Brunswick was discussed, the Luft¬ waffe hospital in Brunswick? A los, that is right. Q Do you reroebor any other agency; perhaps tho Military Nodical Acadotqr of tho Luftwaffo? A Yes, I roseabor tho Military ; tod leal Acadony. Q You rtnonber that too? A Yos. Q It was not then said that tho carrying out of cxporlaonts in cTips was tho prinary idea? A No, no. Q No further questions. DR. ST5INBAUER: (Coixiscl fc r tho Defondant Boiglboock). Q Witness, tho Prosocutor oxr.mired you as an export, I ask you,^ have you worked on tho effect c£ aoa-#atcr on Jnnan boings or have you only concomed yoursolf with the question of removing tho salt? A I worked primarily on the renavnl of salt. Q Then you havo no practical oxpcricnco? A No. Q Your statements a'cout tho loss of water with 500 ebea and 1000 eben with various kidney concentrations are than purely an as- 8569 li Jur>-A-?2-2G-3-4feehan (Int. 3rown) Court Ho. I. suaption frm your part? A That is ay personal opinion gained froc literature, re¬ ports and theoretical opinions of ny own. Q Then you cannot scy that this opinion of yours is ab¬ solutely scientific and accurate? A No, of course I cannot ascertain that 10C%. Q No further questions. HR. HARDY: Q I have two further questions. Your Honor, if there are no further questions by defense counsel. THK PRES I DENTi Does defonse counsel desire to propound any further questions to the witness? . DR. FBLCOLUWi At the end, I have a renark to aake. I havo no further questions to the witness. RE-CROSS EXA-*ORATION BY *!R. HARDY: * Q When did you learn for the first tins, Dr. Schaefer, that sea water treated by your nothod was to be aaployed in Dr. Boigl- toock's experiments? A As far as I know now that was in October. Q In other words, you did not know about it until after the experiments had been ccnpleted? Q No one told ne anything about it. A They employed your method and never infcraod you? A It was not necessary. I did not have the material and it was not generally known that I was connected with this nothod. The I.G. Far ben industry was in contact with the technical office and with the Navy; whether the gentlemen knew, I don't believe they did. Q Did you develop this Schaefer method of rendering sea water potable in your capacity as an Unterarzt in the Luftwaffe or in your capacity as an‘employee of the I. G. Farben? , A In ay capacity as Unterarzt in the Luftwaffe. 1* Jury-A-iS-20-i.-Jfeehan (Int. 3rcwn) Court Ik, 1, Q Have you ever had any c lini cal training. Doctor? A lea, after I took xqr state exanination, I was for about one year an interne and then I was an assistant for or» year and in 1938 I had to leave the clinic. Q I have no further questions. Your Honor. U Jun-A-MB-21-i-Cook (int. Brown) Court !to. I. DR. IBXCDONHs At the end of ay opening statcuont xaony weeks ago I sjade application that the defendant Schaeffer be released from custody and not subjected to the trial. I an of the opinion that this is a case where according to the practice of Aaerican and English Courts, the Court is able now. to accede to such a request, and X nnke the sane application once nore. THE F2ESIDS.V7: Tho Tribunal will consider the notion by counsol for defeniant Schaeffer for a dischargo at this tine. The Court will tako the notion under ndviscoont and nnnoimco its ruling on it in due tine. Tho Tribunal will now bo in recess until nine-thirty o'clock in tho aoming. DR. GAWLIKi Hr. President, tho Tribunal had ordcrod that tomorrow tho dofondant Ho von ary rcra-in away. I r.-do this rppliontion on tho assumption that the witness Dorn would bo o::-ained only Friday, but sinco tho witness Dorn is being oxr-ainod tomorrow, I would like to concol application and have tho defondant Ho von prosont taaorrorr. THE HISSIDEHri Very well, counsol. THE JIARSHALx Tho Tribmal will bo in rocoss until nino- thirty in tho norning. (Tho Tribunal adjoumod until 9x30 5 Juno 19U7). Court 1 Juno b-'i-l-l-HD-Xaloy-Brovn. Official Transcript of the American Military Tribunal In the natter of-the Unite! States of America, against Karl Brandt, et al, defendants, sitting at Kurnberg, Oornany, on 5 June 1947, 0950, Justice Beals presiding, IKS MaRSHaL: Persons In the courtroon will please find their seats. The Honorable, the Judges of Military Tribunal 1. Military Tribunal 1 Is now In session. God save the United States of «nerlca and tills Honorable Tribunal. There will be order In the courtroom. THE PRESIDE!:?: Mr. Marshal, will you asoertaln If the defendants arc all prosont In Court? THE MAHSHaL: May It ploaso Your Honor, all defendants ere pi-ssent In Court wltn the oxooptlon of tho defendant Gobhardt, absent boonuao of Illness. THE PRESIDES?: Tho Secret ry General will no to for tho record tho presence of tho defondants In Court, oavo tho defendant Gobhardt, vh-. will bo oxcusod fron nttor.dr.nco today pursuant to certifier to of tho Captain of tho •icdlorl Deportment In chare® of tho prisoners, as to tho Illness of dofondant Gebhardt. Tho Soorotnry General will fllo tho oertlflcato for tho rooord. Counsel nay proceed. DR. GaTLIK: (Cour.sol for Hovon): With thu permission of tho Tribunal I would like te oall the wltnoso Paul Frn to tho stand. * V ••Wv THE PA£du}SST: Will you ploaso repeat? I did not have tho eai^lnes on. DR. OiVtfflr: Ulth tho permission of tho Tribunal I* would like it call th. witness Paul Friedrich Dorn to the s>y vl’tnoee' stand. THE PRESIDENT: Pursuant tc a^froosont between counsel c roved by the Tribunal, the i-iarshal will call the witness Court 1 June 5-B-l-2-HD-Maloy-Browr.. Pr.ul Friedrich Dorn a witness for defendant Kove.o. The Tribunal will trie under advisement for further consideration the option made by counsel for defendant Schaofc-r to dismiss the charges against him. Ruling on that motion will be passed until the conclusion of the testimony, ct least. PAUL FRIEDRICH DORN, a witness, took the stand and test¬ ified as follows; THE PRESIDENT! Hold up your right hand and be sworn, please. ’.fill you repeat this or.th after me; I swear by Ood, the almighty and (fcr.lsciont, that I will speak the pure truth and will withhold and add nothing. (Tho wltnoao repeated tho oath.) THE PRESIDENT: You may bo seated. Counsel .-tay procoed to examine tho wltnoss DIRECT EX/tAI NATION 3Y DR. GAVLXKs Q. "ltnoss, your rws. Is Paul Friedrich Dorn, Is that correct? A. Yes. Q. When and where wo\*o you born? * A. Tho 16th of February 1916, In Vlnzholn. You are a German national, Is that correct? A. Yes. Z. Ploc.so, what is your present address? A. Eschwcge, An don «nlagon, 14 a. Q. Uhnt Is your -resent profession? A. Taxi service and renting of fotor cars. Z. For what reason wore you nut into the concentration camp? «. Before the war I wa6 the proprietor of c snail transport ( buslnes6. In 1940 cy truck wes requisitioned 6574 Co .rt 1 June 5—rt-1—5-HD-Jtaloy-Broihi. by the German Wohraocht and I was instructed to work as a workman In an armaments factory. In «u s ust of 19-*0 I refused to do this work and was arrested by the Gestapo of Leipzig. The Judicial proceedings against me for refusing to work wero squashed, end I was turned over to the concentration camp of Dachau. 4. How long woro you there? a. From September 1940 to to 20th of December, 19-1-0. 5. Whore did you go on tho 20th of December 19*10? A. To the concentration camp of Buchenwald near Weimar. Q. ’That commando were you in in the ouchonwald ccncen- tr-tlon camp? A. First of all I was omployod In tho quarry. C. How lon 3 wore you employed there? A. Until 15 January 1941. v. What hap cned then? A. Cion because I was sick I wis sent to the Prisoners Hospital where a necessary gland operation was carried out on mo. Q. *.nd what happened then? «. For 8 days I wns nn out-patient and then I wont back to tho hos-ltnl for o second operation. 3. And what happened after the operation? rtftcr the operation I at first received nn easier Job and was employed In the prisoner's kitchen for light work. Q. r *ow Ion.: were you there? Until Hrroh 1941. £. Where did you then? A. I was ut into the prisoner's hospital ''nd since March 1941 I was used there ns a clean-up man. ^575 5 Juno 47-2-1-neehan- (Brown) Court 1. Z. Hov lens did you do tills cleaning work? a. Houchly ona year. Z- What dll you do then7 a. I -'as a sale nurse. Z- How l)n b - wore you a sale nurse? a. Until 20 September 194*'. Q. font happened then? a. .iftor Dr. Ho von was arrested onl I lost the support I had had in Suchenvaid, I vaa transferred tc .iuaohvltr. Z- ^' on » vltnoea. It 1 j correct that from March of 1941 until 20 Soptoaber 194\ you vera In the prisoner's hospital of the ccncontralon caap of ruchonvald? *08. Q. Durln; this time who was oanp dcotor? .u Until 1942 Dr. 31anka as far as I Know anl later In 19*2 Dr. Hovon was appointed o-iap doctor. Do you know when Dr. Hoven v*o arrested? a. I know that vary voll, on 12 September 194'. Q. Do you you rocojnl to Dr. Hovon aacn.; thoso In tho look? a. Yes. Q. Pleace state vhloh of thaso persons is the former caap uootor, Dr. Hoven. a. In the last row, tho thirl aan fren the left. Z- Perhaps the witness ai.vfct ba allovol to stop forward and point to D r . Hovon. THJ ?RJ3ID£.\’T: IV e vltneos may stop to the dock and examine tho defendants an* identify the Defendant Hoven If he eftn. *H 2 VITl^SS: /ary well. (IHJ WITN35S ST £33 TO TH3 DOCY -ViD POIUjS TO DSPSUDdlIT HOV&H.) 2576 5 June 47-K-AX-8-2-Hechan- (Brown) Court 1 THi WIIN'iSS: Here. TH£ ?R23ID2::T: The record will show that the witness when stepping in front of the defendant's desk has ocrrect- ly identified the defendant Hoven. BY OH. OA/LIX: q. T^en you know very well ’that the conditions wero in the oaap hospital In the tine during which Or. Hoven was the oaap looter? A. Yes, I do. q. Are Blochs 4* and 49 or Blook 4d known to you? *. Yes. Q. Hew la it that you know of then? a. Whon Block 46 was being used as an oxporlnental station I was there a few tines and hai to take druerlnont9 that wore oarnea out with lice? v. I know that at the end of 19i2 cages of lloo, In¬ fect, d llco, arrived In Buohenwald for tho first tine. Dr. Hovon conferred with the .cost laportant prison nuraea of Block 4c and afterwards these lice wore dostroyed alnco the danger of opllealc vao too great for tho whole oato. q. Vnat do you know about tho aooond shlpaont of lloo that arrived at Buchonvad 1 ? I know that thla aooonl shlpaont was brought to 3uohonvald by a higher Wohr.e.ioht of floor. In the presence of thla fehraacht of floor those llco wero to bo put on tho prisoners lauedlately. Tile would have constituted a great danger not only for the prisoners in tho oaan, but also for the 33 meabora In tho oaap. Ihereforo one was very eager to rcaove this Wohraaoht officer frea 31ock 40 aa quickly aa poaalblo. .Jso thla second shipment of lice wao destroyed In the presence o: tho orjp dootor. Q. What do you mow about tho way In which thla ’.'ohr- M aaoht officer reaoved fron the caap? Frca a telephone conversation that took place bet¬ ween Bloc* 4o and the prisoner's hospital, I know that Dr. Hoven used a trick and told this officer that if he dll not 5 June 47-a-.JC-a~i-Heehan-(BrownJ Court 1. go back to Vslmar with the truck that was than made avail¬ able to fair., fae would have walk that Ustanoe In the evening, since there wore no other naans of transportation between Vole ar ar.l Buchonwald. 'I* Vas the experiment dbtoontinuod Immediately after the Wohrmacht of floor left Bloch -.6? Yds, according to what I learnt from Jelllneck and a nurso froa Blook 5 who wae aocoaodated there the 11 co wore _ ostroyoa as soon as the Vohrnaoht offloer had left. Who was tnls nurse; what was this nurse's noae froa Bloch 3 3uohenviil whoa you Just mentioned? -»• I cannot give you his name, as I hai very llttlo to do with hlo. What do you fcr.ow about Dr. Hoven's visits In Bloch 46? I /.now that Dr. Hoven dll not visit 31ook 46 for .nodical reasons, but I /.now very well that Dr. Hoven had sot up In this laolatol blcok a taller shop and a shoe shop and he .'id so since It was already voxydlffloult at that tlao to have shoos and uniforms repaired or to get now ones. For this reason Dr. Hoven had this w-rh done illegally at this Blook because the pationto were aoooncolateX there for this purpose. They war; ^pt runnlnj the danger of being suprisod by any 35 of floor and punished. What oon you tell the court about the prisoners who were working In those shops? -*• The prisoners who were omplo'ed there by Dr. Hoven with the understanding of the Illegal car.p management, who were hidden here In these shops and they wero people who hai drawn the attention of the So camp management in some C579 5 June 47-K-^S_2-8-Keohan-( Brown) Court 1. way and ware ther-foro to to removed from the own on very poor transports or ware tc be liquldated. q. Was Dr. Hovon Interested in tho typhus experiments in Bloch 46* I -ust honeatly state bore that I never considered Dr. Koven to bj a good doctor and I did not believe he ev experiments in Block 1*67 A I must say first of all that I do not know this Vondelink. A prisoner who was not employed in the prison canp know nothing what¬ soever of what took place in the prison hospital ard in block 1*6 bo- cause tho prisonoB could enter the canp hospital only with pernis-icn of tho canp ccmaardar.t and they could not ontcr any wards at all. Vondelink probably hoard this as a ruaor in the canp and repeated that Q5CL 5 Jun-tt-ae-ii-Z-Coolc (Int. Broro) Court So. I. runor in gocd faith. I believe that if I myself had not been employed in tho hoopital and if I were asked today who was responsible for the conditions there I also probably would have said the camp doctor on duty. Q Can you erawer the question whether Vondolink was em¬ ployed in tho hospital? A Ho certainly was not employed there. Otherwise I should know him. Q Do you know of the action A Yes. . Q How many transperts left the caap under this action lh-F-lh? A One, nasoly, at tho end of 19U1. Q Whore did it go to? A Tho rr iso nor s and probably also Dr. Hovcn did not know what tho roal destination of this transport was. However, aftor somo tine the property and clothing of thoso prisoners wore sont back and this allowed us to conclude that this transport had gono to Dornburg. Tho prisoners nust havo boon liquidated thcro, othorriso tlioir poroonal offocts would not hgve bocn sont baok to Buchonwald, and curiously ohough it was at this racoont that the nunbors lh-F-13 bocano curront among us prisoners. Q For what reasons wero no furthor transports sont out with¬ in tho fraaovork of action lU-F-13? A As far as I know all Jewish innates of the caap wore to bo removed free tho canp in tho subsequent transports. Tho illegal camp management iasodiately took measures and all the Jews thoro wero thenceforth listed as mason apprentices \c.dar the loadorship of one Robert Soibert from Dresden, who treated those Jews vGry well. Q Who prevented thoso furthor transports? A The illegal caap management in collaboration with Dr. Hovcn, because tho second transport that was sot up was declared by Dr. Hovcn to be in no condition to move and was thus roc oiled. I C505 5 Jun-A^G-ii-3-Cook (Inti Brettn) Court So. I. Q Can you give the Tribunal information regarding furthor measures thet Dr. Hoven took in order to prevent the carrying out of action Ui-P-13? A I can only say tliat Dr. Hoven, whenever transports were to leavo, always conferred with the illegal caap management and with all the prisoners in the caap who were of any consoquonco and who oc¬ cupied any illegal offioe and approved and brought about the nocosenry counter noaaures. Q Is it true that the defendant Horen, only in order to prevent such transports, undertook the so-callod anthropological moasuroaents of prisoners? A Yes, I know about that, there was an SS (toerorat in tho caap who was interested in this sort of aoasurcTwnt, and those measurements wore consequently undertaken. If tho SS cup nrniogo- nont had knew that those noasurononts voro really pro toe ting many very interesting Jewish types, anthropologically spooking, then they would have boon stopped, bocaueo asnjr Jewish pationts had boon hiddon in the caap for years. ,Q Io it corroct that tho dofondant Hoven acccnodatcd in Block U6 and 50, persons who wore threatened by tho action iii-F-13, perticulnrly Jews? A Yos, I oa in a position to giro you a fow rut 30 3. For 0 xt. pie, tho Jewish prisoner August Cohn, whoa I root recently in Kassol, whore ho was the Public Prosocutor in tho Donat if lention court; also of tho nurse Jcllinock, also a prisoner named Kurt Qliosor, and thon in Block 50 thero was a prisoner rvuiod Hoogotor, I boliovo there was quite a number of Javish prisoners who wore removed frqw tho action in this way. 5 June £7-]*-33-5-l -Ztosa (Brcwr.) C-urt Ko. 1 •„ Ccn you tell the Tribunal bow -f ry Jews there were in ^ichenweld when you left In September 1943 were still there? *. Precise figures I eenrot give you, of ®ursc, but I beliovo I ca r.ot overeat lac ting if I sey there were 10C/" to 2000. {.* Did the defend ent Dr. Keren ever examine prisoners intended frr ►renepert to Btrr.burg? *. Vc, beceuoo ttoe transports were not Judged on c ncdiccl br.sis. I knew thet tbc first transport thet lc ft wrs rrrraged for fron Berlin • erd thet Leelelr airyly put hii CT on it. These prisoners were not token to the ceap hoepltel before tfcoy were put on the trenapert. f*. I now put to you Roenhild'e testiaory. This is poge 1634 of the Geraen transcript. Roeahlld sell thet the tro eery doctors, irduding Dr. Hoven, exerdned Jews with reference to their cbility to work, thet lists were drewn ty of those who could not work erd those wore sent to Bcrnburg. Her, whet do y-u hf.ve to sty rbout thrt? *• Z otn only tcy thrt there were very frequent oxeninctions on til the Jewish prisoners because the Jewish prisoners rocclvcd only hclf the reties thet wo rccolvcd. Ter this rc'son Berlin, or perheps tho canp oorsender, wts pcrticultrly interested to knew Just whr t tho phyaioel ocrdltlcn of these peoplo on hclf rttl^na *■# But, theso oxcalnotions bed nothing to do with the trensporta bceruso ca it heppena for rxrre then c yeer I hfd to be jroaor.t during these extn- i nr tiers, or rtthtr during the r.s feebly of the trenaports end o-noeq- uently I wts elreya inforotd by Dr. Koven rhero tho «T 0 r.sprs "ero going erd who wee on thoa. ^ Thoso exeairxtima with reference to tho prlacr.crs' cbility to work, were they errried cut by the eerp doctor? No, usually by lnaet© nur scs. f- Y-u yoke of hclf reticus thrt tfcc Jewish priecr-ers received. Is it true thet the lllegel eery a.ncgecert with Dr. Hover.'s support illegally supplied theso Jews with food contrary to expl oit orders? 0537 5 June 47-ii-S'—5-2-Gr3 fl(Erovr-) Court No. 1 *i I do kr.cw that the Jewish blcoks were supported to e very Irge extent tree the ce^> hospital. Q« Do you know Rcachlld? Yes i I* dc. How long hevo you known kin? ». I have known Roechlld fron thrt nenent on when I w^a employed in the oecp hospital. What did ho do there? *• tree. 1%9 to '43 Roechlld wes the so-ccllcd tree.surer of *ho ccnp hospitd. Thet la to acy he took care of the prisoners' -oney there end in 1943 — and this took plrco very shortly befero Dr. Haven's erreat, Rooohild ms used ca c olerk for the doctors. -as Roechlld ns hrspltcl treasurer presont ct excel net Iona? *• No, nover. Consequently, doss Roechlld have the neccaacry kntvledgo In order to be tblo to ncke atr»cnenta regarding events of this sort In 1943? *• No, he doos not fcccruao befero Roechlld wra carp tcapitc.1 treasurer he w*n for coat of the tint efcacr.t fror tho hospital in the flntnoo offico or it the qu'Ttcm-atcra end only nt very abort irtorrcla ho VLB in tho hospital Itself. -hat do yru kr.o-r about tho killing of lr.forr.cra In the carp? I know thet in Duehenwddpr 1 sonora, who did rot obey the ruloa set up by tfco Illegal cccp nenegeoent end who rerkod rlth tho SS dor.'utclr.g rthar priaoncra erji th.ua br*ught cb~ut their dex ths, tmxo liquidated by Dr. Hover, ir colic here ti~n with t Ye Illegal errp Beaagt&snt. The ceac 2 e- specking : f now concerns a forcer ~h.ito fiuas- ler. General by the nerx cf Bistlncr Eusehnersr, e rtcld German by the none cf Built, erd threo Gcnxn ^cfcralonal criminals. These nen hed bur/ n Uvea on their c-rseiereo. Life In the ccnp res very rugged end "he prisoners -ere very bitter tor^rd these traitors. Consequently, th.cy hed to disappear free crong the living. 3522 5 June i7-iw—^5-3-ar353(BrOT=) Court Me. 1 Tell the Tribund abet the lllcgd eery ntr.cgeccr.t 'a tesks crx! activities seret *• The Illegal cerp manegener.t ate cn institution act up by the priaontrs themselves for their ran protecticn. In the c-urso cf tire it developed to o atr:ng illegal organization which sin to it th; t necsurcs token by the 3S carp ccccandcr wero acbotcgcd in every possible aey end the cecp wca kopt free of traitors end informers. G* Describe the ectivities rf the infezners end treitera on the conrur.ity In the cccp. Let no first tike up the ctsc of Kuaefcnir Kuschr.crcv, the ^hlte Hussion General, bcceusc that was probably tho most prodigi us drrroc of treason thet ever took piece in Bucher.weld, then Biaohnlcr Kuschncrov wca in Buehenwdd k. rge numbers of Russicn iTis-ners cf Ear wero turned ovor tc tho cecp Buehenwdd. The 'ai» gnrxnt thet Kuschncrov hed fron tho 33 coop e^rxxndcr uts tc esacclrtc with thoao Russicn irla-ncra of Wor end tc pump then regerdin* their opinions cr.d to find cut If thcro wero ony Rod *rny officers c=ong thee end. If sc, tc inf err. the canp ccrrxndcr, elao lnforcntion on ell prisoners who worked in connection wi»h those Russian prisoners or who ncturally sympathized with the Ruosiui prisoners or. the teals of thoir Cccrunistlc pest. Tho prismers wten Kuschncr Kuschncrov donounced were token by tho Obcrschcrfuohrcr Boicr.Tenfrctshofcr, Corrxndcr of tho Laundry Sc he of ex, Kitchen Chief Schmidt, 3orr.s, Locleir, or either they were shot ir. tho stcblc or hanged in the crematorium. I cen rasert here thet it was cn incredibly lcrgc number ofpersons whose death Kuachnicr Rischncrcv ccuscd. TKt iRESIDE.Ti ’-itneso, oounsel, the Tribund is cbout to teke its recess. Tho witness mty corplc tc his story efter the recess. JDDCE If the Tribund will permit *no to interrupt just c moment. This is Judge Tons, presiding in Tribunal II. Cr.c cf the defender, te in this case h.ca beer, authorized ts c witness in Ceso IV r.c v being tried in '•Vlbunal II end, if a?r.venier.t, I would request thet this defendant • S5S9 5 June 47-^‘-5-fc“ G rcas(Br''trr.) Court So. 1 be excused et this tire end the Ikrshcl be directed to conduct hin to TVlbur.c.1 II fa: the purpose of testifying for the defense. THE iKESlXEhTi the Is the defendent before this Mtxinelt JUICE TOSi The witness Is Ridolf Brendt. THE nOSlBBflfc Judge Robert U. Tees, presiding Judge of Tribunal II now In sosslon, hewing requested fchet the defendant ftidolf Brendt be cxcusod free or.der.ee before this Tribuncl fer c sho r* tine In order to testify refers Mbunel II, the Hcrshcl will see thet tho defendent »dolf Is esiducod to ^Vlbuncl II to testify cs c witness before th*t Tribune!, to be returned to this Tribune! ebon his testimony Is finished. JUDGE TVdfli Thenk you rcry such. Til . RESIDENT i The Tribune! will r.o* t* in reeoss for e few slnutos. Court 1 June 5-14-7-1-HD-Jfaloy-Franks. TKI KaRSSaL: The Tribunal is again In session. THE PRESIDENT: Just Q moment. The Secretary General will note for the recori the obeenoo from the Tribunal of defendant Rudolf Brandt who has been excused to testify before Tribunal Nol 2 which is now In session. He was excused and his absence from tne Tribunal will In no way prejudice his case. Counsel say proceed. Witness, did the activity of stool pigeons consist pcrtloulrrly of aoousing prisoners wrongly? A. It has happened repeatedly th-t people because of Lntylguo by those traitor:- with the S3 Casp administrators were reported and due to this type of treason wero severely punished and lost thoir livos. Q. Could you tell the Tribunal an exraple of that type what -b ut the reolal company of prisoners? a. In 1942 some criminal prisoners wanted to got tho oaap administration over to their side and they went to the earn- leader and told him that political prisoners In the oamp had a radio station and were thus listing to enemy stations. The camp administration renotod Immediately and relieved oil polltloal prisoners who had Influential positions, suoh as capos and blech leaders, and prisoners in the hospital such as vlce-capo and many rn'ls nurses and they formed a special oomppny. It was tho tr.sh of tr.ls s-.oclal company to worh In tho garden, 'under oturafuehror Duabeoi and cart soli all day long, and all this worh had 0 to be done running. i. Did tale hilling save the lives of numerous accent prisoners? A. I can any that In the case of Xusehnlor Kuscharew, yes, because Kusohnier Xuscharov during* th”t time of 1941 C591 Court 1 Juno 5-»-7-e-HD-Jfclo y-Frnnks. until tho end of 1941 quite certainly w?.a responsible for the death of one thousand 1200 ftasslan prisoners and Goman polltloal prisoners. In the case of other killings of which I know for certain, the situation Is exactly tho sane. I believe that If Kusohnlcr Kuscharew had lived to oxporionce the end of the 3uohenwald one? he probably would have achieved a reoord figure four tc five tines as big. In what canner did the Illegal can? adnlnlstrator ascertain who the lnforaers and stool plgoons wero? Court 1 June £—!4-o-l-KD-Me ehan-Frnnk a. The illegal oca? administration really only consisted of prominent political prisoners. This illegal canp admin¬ istration saw that every position, be it commando, lender of the oaap, or the camp physician, in other words every position where interesting things might be learned, was held by their confidence men and everything they managed to find out, be it orders from the SS, be it work of the traitors and Informers, whom I have mentioned, was immedi¬ ately reported to their own men. I would like to add that tho seat of the illegal C"np administration always was in the s lok-bny as long ns I knew Buchonwald. Dr. Koven was porfectly well informed about what was going cn inside tho oanp and without resorve approved of tho measures adopted by the detainees. I con woll say that Dr. Koven has always been tho bok-bono of the lllogal onsrp administration. Q. To whet extent did Dr. Koven participate In these killings? A. I did not understand that question, would you mind repeating it? Q. To what extent did Dr. hovon participate in those kllllnge? A. I know for certain of five killings and they arc th080 which I have already mentioned. Those killings took place in tho presence of Sturnbannfuehrer Dr. Ding and a man unknown to no, whom I think was a doctor. C. '•.’here did these killings take mlnco? A. In the Hospital Theater Ko. 2 xi. 'Ihere do you derive yoJ knowledge from? A. I would like to tell this Tribunal that I an '.ossibly the only risoner of Buchenwald who without tho knowledge was ocservln- all killing of Dr. Koven ana the camp administration. I spent a long time in Vard No. 6 3553 Court 1 June 5-H-8-2~rID-Keehan-Frank. where Dr. Hoven placed me as a nurse. Everytlne n S3 man entered the cann I knew It. I of course, did watch out froa ay window by cllnblng on ay bed or by taking a high 8tool| I could froa the latrine look directly into the operational theater froa the top window. Consequently, I could see every aove In the operational theater. I oould see the Inside of the operational theater, I could see the operating surgeon and ascertain accurately what was going on In the operational theater. <%, Did you see that apart froa the hi .J\ informers rnd traitors you centijned Dr. Hoven killed other nconlo? * • a. That I never aav. S. "ould you have soon It If it had happened? A. I would have ’occ-uso I have already mentioned that overytlao a oosbor of the 35, be It a Doctor or onyono clso, entered, I lascdl-'toly wont upon ay observation post. Q. For what period con you testify to this? a. I was op jointed In Hnroh of 1941 and wont fron 3uchom/nld to Auscnwltr a few days after the nrrdst of Dr. Hoven, that Is to say thnt during the period fron 1941 to 20 Septoaber 1943 I was there. During this period were yo.» always -'resent In ward 6? a. Yes, I was always In ward 5. «i. ’rfhr.t about the nl t hta? a. During the nl-ht I slo t in tne ante-rooa of operating theater 2. In otr.ur v rls, everyone wno had to enter opor-'tln- theater 2 ha- t* ^r.sa tl r ugh ay bed rova '•.nc. thus I could really see everyone who hod any business In o-jercting theater 2. During the night no one could m enter the c -erntln- t eater frov. t:.c br.c- since I hnd orders to lock the back door of the o era:in- theater every night 'f top the end of treatments and n-nd the J5% Court 1 June 5-:i-6-3-HB-Heehan-Frcnk key to the chief nurse. Q. Could It have hap~ened that these killings wore carried out lr. another operational theater? A. No. Q. Can ycu give any detailed reasons? a. Operational theater No. 1 was worked In exclusively by Dr. Horn, the Crecho Slovakian prisoner dcotor, who carried out all operations and also the Cceoh prisoner, Dr. Matnsohok and I believe with certainty If anything happened In that operating theater that .-iorn would have op osod It and would have lnforcod all of uo«immediately, ovpnrt froa that Oporatlonal theater no. 1 Is o roou whore only operations of an Internal nature arc carried out end for that reason had to be kept ooapUtoly sterllo. For Instance, If I wanted to or.tor operational thoator 1, I had to undorgo oonrleto disinfection boforc and I cannot Imagine that any othor personnel could have onterod operational theater 1 at all. Q. '.’hat do you know about Roox Ho. 11? A. I know that Ro^m No. 11 until 19-41 was n hosoltal ward In the T.3.C., the so cried Aim. Q. And what do you know about Roc- No. 11 after IS il? A. At the ond of 19-41 new f urniture wao put In and It was mndo a recreational and dlnin- rooe for the nurses working In the T.3.C. station, since the ccmy -.hyelclan had strictly -rohlbltcd that rooms v .ore T.5.C. -^tlonts were c nfinad should be used for oatin L . • x. Whet do you know about the refutation of this Room No. 11? A. The refutation of Room No. 11 was the worst In the whole corny of Buchonvold, be ecu sc at the time * hen Dr. Slsele still racted as camp physician, he collected all the Court 1 Juno 5—14-8—4-nP—Meehan—Frank. -or.ticnts w. y. no longar had any ho-'o for recovery In noon No. 11. I hardly think that «ny of tnese nctlenta left t -o rooa alive. It was said tmt Dr. Slselo was liquidating lncurc'olo patients there. In to what tine would It have beon -osalble, there¬ fore, that killings went on In Boon No. 11? «. actually only until the end of 1941, ns long os Boon No. 11 was a w:rd and nardly after that tine. 2. Vho was chief cacp physician until the end of 1941? «. Dr. BlAnhe since Dr. Hover, only becaze can; physi¬ cian In 1942. 2. Let ze put Doctor Horn 1 a testimony to you. It Is pa o 539S of the Gorzrn record. Dr. horn only workod In the slok bay after the be lr.r.ln. of 1942 and he testified ho had to <&gn a oertlfloato that ho could not enter Boon No. 11; how can you explain that If according to your stc.tcncnt he was there ns early os 1941 and Boon No. 11 hr.d becono a recreational roo _ for nurses? *. The way I can explain It is that In 1942 and 1943 It was strlotly orohibltod that this departaont whore T.B.C. patients were was to be entered by anyone. I, too, had boon instruct.d by the can- ohysiclan rnd even by Capos to the effect that I had no business In the roon for lnfectuous wards for T.5.C. patients and I never tried to get there either. 2 . Nhet do :*ou know about the nunber of poople killed by Dr. Hoven? m a. I have already said before thst fr-z l r 41 to 1943 I was an eye witness to all klllir. = s. I can only testify In this court rooa that I have seen for ay self how Dr. Hoven killed the five prisoner? v.ooz I zentioned. I would like to add at this point that after the second killing. Court 1 Juno 5-;i-8-5-nD-.He«h-rt-*J , rnnk Dr. Ding took the syringe r.wny fron hln end accosted hin. Juat what Dr. Ding said to Hovon I could not read from his lips, possibly ha was not satisfied with Hovon'8 work. I shall now put floenhild's testimony to you, accord¬ ing to the Goroan Transcript Pago No. 1639, ho gave a figure of a thousand. A. I can only reply to you by rests ting the fact that I was actually an eye witness to thoso killings. Hoonhild, who did not work in the sickbay wards and had no opportunity either to wntoh tho killings or to bo cotually present, cannot possibly know who onrrlod out those killings. Naturally, it was assuned in the onap that the oanp doctor wns carrying out those doedo. Q. Did you over boo that tho Defondant Hovon killod peoplo who did notcct as stool-rlgeons or lnforaers for the oanp administration? A. I have certainly no knowledge of such a caso. Q. Vlll you ploase tell this Tribunal Just in what nannor it was ascertained in the case of these five peoplo, whon you have talked about, if they were lnforaors or stool-pigeons for certain? A. The case of Kusohnlr Kuschnarev was quite doflnitely a sensation in tho entire camp. I don t believe there was a single prisoner who was so hated as this nan, but I do know that Dr. Koven nevertheless oade absolutely certain Just who Kuschnir Kuschnarev was. I an quite certaln^that during those two days when Kusohnlr Kuschnarev was in the hospital. Dr. Hover, interrogated one hundred witnesses for certain to find out whether Kuschnir Kuschnarev wa6 really the traitor whon he had been told about. 'C597 5 June-IM 1 i^*9—i-Pr iceau (Irst. Frank) Court So. 1 Q.- Did the defendant. Dr. Hovon, kill prisoners who wuro unable to live any longer ? A.- So. Q.- uid the defendant. Dr. Hovon, kill prisoners aho reported to hia for treatment ? So, I hrvo never seen Dr. fever, send a prisoner may who wont to him for troatcunt or blame hia or hit hla ns ao xny other camp doc¬ tor® <^d. Q.- If any other persons corriod out similar killings, would not Dr. Hovon havo had to hoar of such ccts ? A.- I really couldn't give you an explanation Just how Dr. Hovcn would have gained such knowledge because if people wore killed thon it was always done at the exact aoew-nt when Dr. Hovon wasn't in tho camp. I would like to give you a brief explanation on this point. At the cntranco to tho sick bay there was a doorkeeper's hut and in that hut a political prisoner sat whoso nano was Franz Blass. In this shod thore was a bell and when Dr. Hov-n como down tho camp otroot which was clearly visible from this doorkiopor's shed then Blass had ordors to ring this bell twiev. If anything illegal ms going on in tho sick boy by prisoners or by tho SS and this bell rang twice, then all activities ceased. Consequently, Dr. Hoven co»jJ.d rvivor surprise anyone who was doing anything or trying to do anything without his knowledge or had pos¬ sibly done 3coo such thing. Q.- Wasn't it essential that Dr. Kovtn had to gain knowledge of these killings because of the fatality or casualty r-parts in tho camp J A.- To my knowledge, that w.ac impossible. The ordinary normal doath figure at tho caap 3uchcrenld at that tkt was v„ry low. Up to ym I have rued every publication cna ch-cked everything Uiat was written about Buchenwald and I tv vc devoted mys-lf intensely to the study of those articles but they all concurred that the nora'l death rate in the camp at Buchenwald did rot exceed 2%. It was, therefore, quite certainly not C592 5 Jur.c 4’-:(Ip*., i'raSk) C'urt I difficult to snuggle ir. a fc~ de*d, particularly since Dr. Eoven didn't aigr. all the dc~th certificates: bat 3ir.ee this vp.b purely a natter far prisoners and in ca*.s where the bediet were dissected the death certi¬ ficate was issued togetk. r with the findings of the dissection, signed by a prisoner in the side bay, and then passed on tc the 3uchenv»ald registrar. He countersigned it and then sent the certificate tc tho relatives of the dead person. I, for instance, w C uld never have had the courage if I had know about the killings to go to Sr. Hoven and say, "This and that nan has killed," bccauso the capos vculd have iamed- iately taken ay life for it. ^ What can you say e>cut the ex*cr.t -f the cr.tiro e'.ings on in the sick bay? Vas it pretty blr? A The sick bay at 3uch. rald was aeually vory large, indood. T hcr« waa a large b-rr-cks for internal diseases, two barracko f^r surgi nns' patients, and then across the park th, n wore two further b-rracks. Tw C ro were altogether -p rr oxinatcly eight rocas and I think that it was Just as inpossible for Dr. Erven as it was for ayself to control all those eight barracks and supc-vise then eiaultanoausly. ^ rf as it for those rerscns that defendant HvV.n couldn't corv- cern hiastlf with all details in the sick bay? A X would alacst like to sry that the sick b"y -f a prison C"mp isn't a rrlvatc clinic and that Dr. Even didn't know »-st of the pa¬ tients who w t ri there personally at all and, therefore, he didn't dis¬ cover if one or the other prisoner wam't in the sick bay -ny n re. The following day if he had really r.adc ir.culrlca on any occasion then he would have gotten t^e answer that thv prisoner had been released back into the c-ap. H wa? Dr. Owen's attitude ria*rding prisoners and, particu¬ larly, sick prison.rs. A T'-at Question I c~n "nly answer "excellent," if I draw a c-npariaor. between -thcr eaup d ct rs and during ry detenti n I -.ct 20 or 25 ^99 5 Jur.--i:-?L-9-3-?ri- a:u (let. I rank) Court No. 1 emp doctors. For instance, I rcaccb^r one certain doctor by the name of Eiaelo who took special pleasure in accosting elderly Jews in tho ca^p and caking them if they were hungry end telling thua if they would go straight to tho sick bay ho would givo then aooathing to cat j and then, instead of giving then food thire or any typo of assistance, Or. Siscle took his hypodcroic syringe* froa his pocket and took two such poor wretches and gav_ then doses so that the victims usually sufforod terriblo cramps and, for Dr. Bible's aous. ^nt and in front of pri¬ soners who alght liko to &e that sort of thing, wuro rolling about in front of the barracks or night start screaming and raging. In conjxori- aon to all that, I nust say that Dr. Hoven did a proat deal for pri¬ soners, particularly for recently operated prisoners. You alght think it somewhat funny if I tell you hero that in a concentration emp people who have Just beer, operated receive on «k!i- tionnl ration of -ood butter, silk, whit- bread and fruit or that the treatment of convalescent people actually included the construction of a wondorful garden ordered by Dr. Hoven and tfrit thoy managed to got deck-chairs in their garden so that r^curer*ting patients could lio in tho sun in dock chairs durini. their stay. During ay prison tern I got to know threu ccnp doctors and I never saw any othor doctor doii^ any¬ thing like that. apart from that I would liko to add that all prisoners in tho camp liked Dr. Horan v-ry ouch and that ev^ry prisen-r who h"d any troublos, bo that he bo sentenced to f logging or anything like that, whenever ho went to seo Dr. Hovun he always found a willing ear. I cane ortainly put sufficient eases to you here where prison-rs had boen sentenced to 25 Lashed, and when Dr. Hoven con?god to carry out so at sort of manipu¬ lations in order to save people from this t~*x o: punishment. Q.- Did the defendant. Dr. Hovo::, makv. offerts to give sick pationts every conceivable aeaic.al attention ? A.- I can certainly s-.y that to the best of zy conscience. 3600 5 June-J5-FL-9-t-?n=cau (Lit., Frank) Court So. 1 Q*- Can you examples to this Tribur.il ? *'•“ Pir3t of rill » 1 - ould liJco to describe the case of a 17 year-old Jewish prisoner. This prisoner, mart Kurt Glacscr, used to carry soil for the head gardonor an Unterscharfuchr.r, Donbock. Some how, on one or so occasions, this men took a disliku to him and he tri^d to hit him end hit hi* so unfortunately with his boot that Glaoscr dropoed to tho grourd. Donbock jusped upon this young am with both foct and this in¬ flicted a complicated double fracture of th~ thigh. That was somewhat un¬ pleasant for Doabeck. The prisoner was taken to the sick bay and there he was supoosed to bo liquidated. When this ->riso»~r os odalttud Dr. Hovon was present in ay ward and allocated a bed in aj ward to this Jew. I can say that this young am would rv-ver heve survived in that emp if Dr. Hovon hadn't loft him in ay ward for a year and a half. I have experienced frequently during that period that Dr. Hovon ccae along and asked him if ho hid anj^iohoo ard 1 know that this prisoner w-a operated probably nine or ton tino\ within th-t period without knowl*.dgv of tho Kexasa ndrnt • a office. Then there is another case I would Lik«- to tell you about. It was forbidden as a rr.ttur of principle that Jewish prisoners should bo ad¬ mitted to the sick bay or treated th.re. Dr. Blaule cert-inly observed that instruction most strictly ; but, or.ee Dr. Hoven gained a certain amount of influence in tho camp, ho found illegal ways and means for es¬ tablishing a eodl ward for Jews only i.-xl lie forbad expressly that wo, nurses should draw Jewish marks upon the patient's history and favor chart. If thoro wore visitors or if tho Clip Konmadabt wont through. Dr. Hovon always described tho so patients as bwing no.i-Jewish. I cm firaly convinced that army a Jew that ras doctored there is^otill alivo today but otherwise th"t ho would nroba !_y neve o'vd in 1942. C601 5 Jaa-M-iB-10-l-Cook (Int. Frank) Court No. I. Q Will you please describe to the Tribunal Dr. No van's at¬ titude toward you wh:n you sere sic'.'? A It that tine I was working in the quarry and I contracted a swelling of the glands* I was operated on by tho prisoner Walt or Kraoncr and ttan was discharged Iron tho sick bay and got eight days of light duty, but unfortunately a for days later tho sane trouble oc¬ curred again, Glnndula Inguinalis, a spoiling on tho left side, and I rotumod to the sick bay and reported sick and ay reception wasn't oxactly glorious, because first of all Kraeaor described ro as on asocial olcncnt, and thflt these *..or_ ponitonti ry rot hods, and I had inflicted this trouble upon r^E-lf, and I had done eorothing to cauao nyny second hernia gland to swell, and he ordered no to wait until tho out-patients had boon doalt with, end I didn't know at tho tino what this roant, but I loarnod la tor that this waiting would have noant ny doath, since after tho other prisoners had loft the operating station, I would havo boon transported olscwharo, you know where - and then Dr. Ho von coat along and asked nc -hat I «aa suffering fron and took an obvious interest in ro, and I can't toll you why tody, I don't know, but at any rate Dr. Ho von sade an Lvcirion ’.rith his crm hr.nds, and after I was discharged fro:. the sick bay he aanngcd to got no n job in the prisoners' kitchon, and new I -..'ould like your pcmlssion to describe just how I got into tho sick bay. A political prisoner Tho was suffer¬ ing fron n very serious infection und^rrunt tho reputation of an am. This prisoner's lif*. depend.' upon whother ho could be given frosh blood or not and thus the loud speaker of the oanp -nnounced that if there was a prisoner in th. canp - ho hod once given blood, then ho should inodiatcly report to fro sick bey. Saio tiro previously I had givon blood in a University clinic and I knew I had blood group "0" and was therefore universal, and so due to the loud speaker's announcement I wont to tho sick bey and cave JCO cubic cor.tirotcrs of . 03 * blood to hin and I wee about to leave the sick ‘cay at the nooont and Dr. Hoven said: "You will stay here- first of all and relax pro; _rly, and you alll 5 oun~^ 2 -Cook ( 1 st. ?r±) Court Ho. I. refresh your food situation," and I stayed in bed for about throo or four days, and after that I got up, and Dr. Hover, gave ae instructions to report to the food store of the So, which was under the e re of Hauptaoharfixihror Aar sc h, and Dr* Hovon .rroto down for rx that Kaupt- schcrfuohrcr Sarach should give no very large quantities of rations, end this special ration at that tine consisted of approximately two pounds of butter, 5 litres of milk, several pounds of good sausage, white bread and grapes, and than I xecoivod glucose in addition to thet, and I was about to leave the sick bay about four weeks later, when Dr. Hovon ca.oo along quito rddonly and told _aci "You don't havo to work in tho carp. You cm st'y right ’ere in the sick bay. You can bo employed hero as a nurse.* And than I was a oloaner for about a year and after that I was «^>lojvd as a nurso. Q Tho story you havu j’vst told no, was that tho dofondant Hoven'a attitude toward all prisonors or was that his attitudo toward you because you woro an acquaintance of Dr. Hoven? A Lot no say b-forj that that I hardly kntr- Dr. Hovon at all. In fact I only e*. him orcc befor. ’.liven ho operated on no. Dur- ing the poriod of ry blood transfusion, I didn't soo Dr. Hovon at all since it was carriod out by a nvrs^, and I don't think he was even a doctor, and I can cort.ainly say it v.ao only v'.ion I vac about to leave tho sick bay that Dr. Hovon took a ronewod interest in no. I fool al¬ oes t nshaaod bocauao sone of ay fomcr cs.-r-.des nay be sitting in tho audionce and I would find it r ilxu.* nrd if I would say 1 aei tho only ono ho preferred in tills w-y. Q ’ 'ould it be right to s ; that up to tho norvent you onterod tho sick bay you were on. of a ny cf th. 'nlavrrr. prisoners to Dr. Hovon? A I would like to add to t’..-t that any nan i ho can aoe no sitting horo tod-y and who nig.it h™. s_on e at the tine would probably not havo given five cents for ay life, because I had spent months in the penal company at Dachau .and .ay hysic.nl condition tr.as miserable. Q Would tho defendant. Dr.- 3ov_n, gain any advantages frea 603 / 5 Jun-I *4 2-10-3-Cco-k (Int. frank) Court ’-'o. I. you? 'EM that the reason shy he helped you? A TTnet sight I offor to Dr. Hover.? Ail I had *.-ere tho prisoners* clothes I was wearing. I wasn't even allowed to ko^p vy wedding ring when I wes ir. prison, so what could I offer to Dr, Hoven? Q What was the general ro.mtaticn of Dr, Hover, in tho canp? A Let ac s»y that contrary to other carp doctors, cost prisoners took an interest ir. tho personality of Dr. Hoven, boceuoo I believe caong all ambers of tho SS there -..~sn't a nan about whoa any good runors circulated in the onep. It boerxo known, fer instance, that in one block in that cu:p, and I can't give it to you accurately which one it was, but it ras in too row botro-n blocks 1.5 nni 50, thcro was a block with a fonco around it, and in that block fon^r high officials of tho Dutch State vero confinodj acong than tho forraur Dutch l ii n ist^r of Flnanoa and tho 2 : iniotor for Colonies and a high ranking govurncxjnt official free India, and also a certain rrofocsor. Dr. Sldori, »rtio had onco been thi head of tho International Rhino Con¬ trol Cocc lesion, and there wore anny othor veil known personalities fron Holland. Theso people had a groat doal of advantages over othor prisoners, and they succcodod in getting Dr. Hovon ovur to thoir oido coaplotoly. I knew for certain that Dr. Hovon hoi pod a groat nany of the so people to regain thoir froodoa and it is a wo 11 known fact and case that Dr. Hovon really onployad ;*eans to have those people re¬ leased, and had he boon found out It would have resulted in his ir>- rodir.tu dotontion by the Gostnpo, and having to face vary probably the noxt special court. Dr. Hoven succo-.dod in having these people re¬ leased when they wore only physically weak or sick, to fako x-ray findings for hoolthy people by substituting photographs of tubercular patients, by rhich neons ho succeeded in getting these people^ out. Q hould it have boon possible to say that in accordanco with Hovon*s position in Buchenmld that ho actually kiUod prisoners when there was r.c other in tho ccammity to do so? A Your Honors, I can't iragino that a nan who helped a Jew . C6C4 5 Juan’:-;3-l&-L-Cook (Int. Fran:-:) Ccurt So. I. whc had nc right to lire in tbs national Socialist state, th-t he people is possible, a can The asked hie for his wishes regarding food and nursed hin and aided hin in the sick bay for months and oven helped conceal hie in the sick bay for years, that the eaj» nrn arbit¬ rarily night have carried out killings which were not necessary. I just cannot Laagino such a thing. Q tfhnt was tho nodical care like during the tiao vlon the dofend-ant Keren vns caap physician at Buchorr.ald? A I aa glad to o--y that this raodicnl care whs a vory good one. I would like to emphasise perticuiarly at this point that this was a considerable ac hie recent on the part of tho old ostatlirhod political prisoners who collabcr.atod with Dr. Heron, because it is a fact that no obtained radical supplies, bandages and additionrl foed fret: the Chief cf tho Hygiene Pood Dopcrtjor.t at Borlin, Lichtorfoldoi. Apart fron that it was possible during Heron's period that ho addod two largo huts to tho cuip hospital which *.roro oxtronoly voll oqui?:x>d and woro raaliy quite werthy cf hunan ooings. I can r<.colioct t'.r.t on several occ'sione during tho inspections carried out by d'-ct -ra v-!3-C0-5-Coofr (int. Frank) Court Kc« I. certificate, which rcunt that they could stay la bed in their own blcck. I cca reaweber very accurately fer instance that at the be¬ g inning wben Dr. Heron had bocoao canp dee ter that the death rate in the o ip BuchertKild really went dcca quite a bit and it happened that half cf tho wards in the sick bey were aapty. A^ong us prisoners there was a gon-ral nror that Dr. Keren really deserved great praise fer what ho did in the sick bey. 0606 Court 1 June 5-&-ll-l-HD-Gro sa-Frank Q. I would like to s ubalt to you once again Docuncnt 1063 of the War Crimes Commission at .%nstcrdon and I 6hall now mut to you 3chaltor's testimony on page 16 of the German translation. Schalter states in this doounent that tho cesap doctor, Dr. Eoven, played an extremely bad port and, no doubt, had on his conscience the death of innumerable people due to insufficient oedloal care. The witness says ■food supplies" but the translation of that is a mistake. It is medical caro in the Dutch original. Nov, let no ask you, was Schalter working in the Sick Bay? A. No. Q. Vould Schalter tr.en be in possession of the necessary knowledge which would onablo hln to pass Judgment cn the medlonl situation at 3uchenwald? A. Counsel, I think I have already said to you boforo onco today that an outsider would have found it quite impossible to have gained insight into the rrison hospital or tho 8iok Bey and the acturl canp had boon two ooparato canps at all tinea. Furthermore I on flrnly convinced that if I hadn't boon working in the Sick Boy ayself and wore told today that Dr. Ho von played a bad pert that I would assume that to bo the truth without orltlclsn because outsiders are not lnforaod about the conditions and about tho activities of a can? physloian. Q,. Do you know a case whero a prisoner during the tine whon Dr. Hoven was conn physician died bccauso of insufficient nodical care? a. Ancngst the people who were operated on by the prisoner Dr. Horn, with Dr. Hoven as tho assisting surgeon, I c?nnot remember a single case. q. Vhat do ycu know about the defendant Dr. Hoven 1 9 political views? Court 1 JUne 5-M-ll-2-KD-5ro e s-?rank. A. I oon*t inline that Dr. Seven was a famous Nazi because I think if he had had any plans of that nature then he would have lcoed his whole wireless set at the disposal of the people in the hospital - that g;ve us o wonderful opportunity of listening to England and Moscow every night. Apart from that Dr. Hoven was most oertalnly informed that there were two night watohmen in the hospital especially for this purposo. I can remember very well that Dr. Koven placed his dog at the disposal of one of these watchmen sc that anyone who ap-reached the Sick 3ay was immediately announced by the do 5 and the nl fc ht watohaan said "’.fatoh out, trouble, turn off the switch.* I beliovo if Dr. Hoven had boon an oonvlnoed 33 man he would hardly have made Jokos llko that. A. You have already spoke about Dr. Hovon's attitude toward the Jows. Do you have anything you want to add or would you Just describe Dr. Koven 1 s attitude toward Jews summarily. A. I believe that it la genoraly known that Jewish rlson-rs in that camp were actually suffering the worst lot of ell. If an S3 mar., be it the doctor or bo it another ascertained the blook leader of the Jewish blocks was taking an Interest in the Jews, tnen he had to take quite some risks because he always ato d between che prisoners and the S3 and I know for certain if the preferential treatment w.-.ioh Dr. Hoven gave the Jews had been mown then Dr, Hoven w uldn't be in the Dook today. I think at that, tlse he would have gone the way bj many prisoners went at the oaaro in Buohenwald. I would really like to remind y* from Buohenwald. Dr. Hoven immediately adopted the necessary measures and brought Cohn to 31ook 45. I can remember that a few weeks before Cohn left for the United States, because I live near Kassel, I met him In the street quite by accident when he had a break down of his car. I reoognlted him Immediately and stopped and started • talking with him. For the first time I learned that tho defendant Hoven had later been a prisoner In tho concentra¬ tion camp of Buchenwald. Cohn also told me that an American Armored Troop had put B.ven on top of a tank end had taken him from Weimar to Buchenwald. When they got to Buohenwald Cohn saw .-.oven standing on top of the tank and he stopped tho American driver and said to the officer wh- was thore, "Gentlemen, don't do any harm to this man. Ho Is the an who fought In our ranks." Your Honor, oould you Imagine that a Jew of all people - those people who suffered most by hardship In that camp - would spoak up to savo the life of an S3 man and describe him as a decent human telng? I don't bellove so. I wouldn't do It In any other case either. Q. Will you please tell this Tribunal tho measures adopted by the defendant Dr. Hoven In order to camouflage Jews In that legal Sick Bay? A. It happened very often that Jews who arrived In the prisoners' Sick Bay were Immediately deprived of all articles, that the markings were removed fr -a the prisoner's clothes and all that was left was a number so that any camp commander who might come to the Sick Bay, even the comm?-nda:i« C609 Court 1 June 5-H-ll-4-KD-Qrc as-Fre nk. or little 8S men, could never find out that these prisoners were Jews. It happened every day after all that Jews suffered 111 treatment In the open camp streets. If one of these gentlemen eight have had a bad breakfast he would then go out and assault those Jewish prisoners, beat them senseless. And I must add that all these people who came back from flagging were admitted to the Sick 3ay by Or. Hoven although this was severely prohibited. I would like to tell you about the Jewish prisoner Brandt from Hamburg. I know I am under oath In this Court Ho m and that I must think onrefully rb^ut every word I em saying. I want to tell you that this man Brandt had four operations on his behind since all flosh had been beaten off his hones. Dr. Hoven kopt this man perhaps 8 or 9 months In the Sick 3c.y and I assure you ho was excollently fed first of all for pity tho nurses felt for him, and secondly, Koven saw what this man hud gone through, o terrible torture. I an not exaggerating when I say he had sores on his behind as large as ay bend and It must be highly considered that Dr. Hoven helped so nuch at the time. Q. >Jh;t was Dr. Hoven 1 a ooneem regarding food 6upplloe for the prisoners? A. I would like to say that I myself acooapanled Dr. Hoven during many Inspections of the prison ketohsn and It happened quite often that Dr. Hoven took a plote from the kettle In which the prisoner's fed was cookod and tried this food, rtiea Dr. Hoven felt that tho food was not edible he wont straight to the phone and got In touch with the commandant and replied that the fo <1 would go straight to the pig sty©, the work would be interrupted, the prisoners would return to the ermo and a new meal would be c. ked and only the newly cooked meal would be given out. J610 Court 1 June 5-M-ll-5-KD-3ross-rirrJc. I know he went to the prison kitchen three to five times a week. What other measures did Dr. Kovon adopt in the Interest of the prisoners? A. Counsel, would you kindly repeat the question, please? Q. *Vhat additional measures did Dr. Koven adopt in the Interest of the prisoners? A. I know for Instance that a largo number of oases when prisoners had to do hard physical work In the working party so that many were near physloal breakdown. I have also experienced It that Dr. Hovon crossed the parade square several times and that during rool call, which bofore Dr. Koven's time occupied three to four hours, convinced him¬ self of the physloal condition of the prisoners. No doubt the whole camp was deeply groatful to Dr. Hovon that ho suocoedod to reduce the roll call period In Buohonwald to d minimum. I con well say that roll oall during Hovon's period hardly took longer than 20 minutes. Now when Hoven saw poople cn the parade square that locked weak and badly nourished ho gave Instructions to tako down the number of the dotalnee and saw very quickly that thet prisoner wont to another working party. 3611 5 Jur^tf-FI/-12-l-Xarrow (Int. Fp*r.k) Court No. 1 - a.- tfhct do you know .-.bout aeaair-s adopted by tho defendant Dr. Hover, to vc Polish pcoplo who were to be hanged because thoy had sexual intercourse with Goran girls ? A.- Tho situation o i those Polish prisoners in the canp wes rather b-d. kost of thus, rft«r they'*,re in Buchenwald for two or throo wcvks, were called to tho political department by either LcClair or Serno and hanged. After tho illegal ca.p administration erri Dr. Haven hod disco¬ vered that there did exist the possibility to «ve these people sinco thoro was cn order frea Berlin to tho offoct tf»t Poles who spoke Ger¬ man well were bo Gorarnited if possible. Dr. Hoven ar.de excesslvo uso of this loophole. I could describe you asxy a case when Polish prisoners, who were in the crap for thr-e or four days and could, therefore, not be recognised r.s good comrades in that shor period, were instructed to r-port to the sick bry ..here they were then physically and medically examined, assuring was carried out - this always nppuiKd u»st ridicu¬ lous to a. - and then thus, people were included in soac list - I think it went up to 5 - rad then when Dr. Hoven succooded in putting theso nui on List tf 5 then thoy had escaped doath because a Cera in who had intercourse with a Goran 6 irl couldn't very well be hanged for that. Q.- Had prisen-.rs requested th* dofondrnt Dr. Hoven that wh.n ho was away froa Buchcnwald he should always leave a mossrgu to tho offect where ho could be found ? A.- I'd like to say that the hospital hrd connection with Dr. Haven's appartaent, ov»n I think with the the commandant, the caoaandrnt's of¬ fice and thw gate by telephone, end every tine that Dr. Hoven loft the hospital he told tho nurs- on duty where he could be found. It happened for instance, that operations hrd to be carried out right in the niddlo of the night. Saactiaes, quite possibly. Dr. Horn didn't know whether he could carry on without Dr. Hoven*s, the ca? physician's permission :r not and then he wont to the tolephon. and got Dr. Hoven, but I have ot to say that in no case which I ever saw did Dr. Hoven refuse to cox, 0612 5 Joce-l‘-rL-12-2-Karrcw (Ir.t. Frank) Court Go. 1 * crkiRi som. excuses or even delayed. It was generally known that when Dr. ffoven was needed in the cc-p he was thare. There wuro circumatrjt- ccb socoo tines when, quite suddenly, two or three cnap loaders arrived in the sick b'-y. They had got an idee aoouhow that t;>e coop hospital ■r.s really the ooat of the illegal ca=p administration, and they start¬ ed to turn everything up side down looking for papphluts, written and printed documents, rcdio receivera and trcna.aitt.rs, end it never took a lor, tlvi before Dr. Ho von showed up and stopped these people fron c-arrying out further search, tel lira then that they nadc c nuisance of thesselves. I tliink ".any a boot Lag was saved in that way nrd many of our good cxircdes osoaped the erwsatoriun that way. f..- las it generally known in the cnap that the do fondant Dr. ll-Ven collaborated with the illegal camp cdininistr’tion ? A.- If I were to any "generally" in the camp that would probably be too ouch because if wo question one hundred persons froa 'dixhcr.nnld in this court roan and ask thea who ms tho illegal ea^> administration then ninety-nine of then wouldn't bo able to give you c definite anawor. I .rust tell you that I .ay^lf had b-on in frequent contact with tho il¬ legal ccjxp administration, but if you csk me today or if you toll nc to write down tho names of the illegal camp .administration then I Cer¬ tainly wouldn't jet beyond .ay ineodinto superior. If there Wero any .nessarus or roporta or orders to bo transmitted by e* then I only had ono non who was directly ahead of a who was dosigmted to no and all I knew was that I Ird to Ull him but I didn't even know to whom ho Vent as th. next ono. The illegal comp administration, therefor., was always quite definitely a very aysUrious affair. Admittedly, the SS camp ad inini st rat ion alw-ys stated that the former hospital cap* Ernst ousse, had been tho head of this conspiracy, but I wouldn't like to state that her- because, quite definitely I ccn't tell vou for certain; What o ;*ou xizm .ab-ut the reasons for Dr. Hoven's arr-so by the £^cr_t State Police ? 5 Juno-!f.FUi2-3-Xarrcw (Int. Frank) Court Ko. 1 A.- Of the official arrest of Dr. Kovon I hoard very little, but I umc that subsequently to this arrest I ms iradintely sent amy froa Buchonwald because it wes very probable that tho SS wore convincod that I night have scon too ouch with liov.n and that it was high tt-o, aftor Hov^o went, that I went too. I'n absolutely convinced that tho reason why Dr. Hover. was arrested was this. The SS cacp administration quite definitely did not fail to we the collaboration between the il¬ legal coap rdainistration and Dr. Hov-n. In order not to nr.ku thciorclves ridiculous they couldn't obviously arrest Dr. Hovcn nrxi say "You have collaborated with tho prisoners" because the prisoners who collaborated with Dr. Hovcn could well be hanged without c word of treason ever pass¬ ing their lips. Vo certainly saw this case an as-a of tines in Buchcnwnld because people being uni^r suspicion of bcin? in the iUogal cup adni- n istration went to the so-called ■banker" in 3cchcnwald where they died in axtre.no .-misery ; forturrtcly, however, without ever gibing their ca> races awry. So I think it would have boon quite useless if Jr. .'.'oven bad been arrested officially in order ot get fren bin the names of the illo- £•.1 ca^j od’lnlstrr.tion because I don't believe Dr. Hovon would have bo- eono that weak. C,.- ..'ill you please describe to the Tribunal how it happened that you arrived hero as a witnass ? A.- I road in tho news capers that, at present. Dr. Hovffn was in • the prison in Numbers and that he was be?ng held responsible for tho euthanasia progrra before the International liUtary Tribunal in 2iurnbcrg and, at fhc snao tine, I road that a certain Dr. Go*ilk tad taken over tho dofense of this dofoodant. Now, sincu I owe -ay own Ufo to Dr. Hovcn, and since I taro soer. s; cano good duds done to ae during tr* tine of ay detention, I erne here as a voluntary witness. Neither tta prosecu¬ tion nor the defense noted ae to do that -ad it's really incoaprchunsi- ble to De that -11 those ocn who cnee lived Well thanks to Dr. Hoveq awl who, tod-y, have very important positions in Germany, and I'll Just 0614 . * 5 Jone.-M-FL- 12-1 ,-Earrca (Int. Frank) Coart So. 1 briefly aontion tho Vice President of Thorii^in hero in this connection. I do not urdoratant the personal cowardice of this sen that he hasn't coa- to Nurnberg today to say ".Tfcet'a how the situation is". Tlv.ro arc other pcoplo too who are holding high police offices in tho Russian Zonu today, ny do these people not consider it necessary that tho atan who has done so .ouch good lor then and saved their lives or ar.de thoir li¬ ves easy for then during nany years of detention - that these pooplo didn't cone hero today. I'd also like to say that it -..as tried to crocto difficulties for no. khen it bocaae known to tho Caxdtte for Racially Persecuted People that I would apj*ar r.s a witn.ss in Numbers, it was actually tried quite shortly beforehand to have rv imprisoned. They wer-n't ov.n eahoaed to talk to fellow prisorv-rs behind ay ba.cl: -nd ask then if it wasn't possible that I .dsht have beaton a Jew on saao occa¬ sion or wheth-r there wasn't sono reason for ny arrest thus provor.ting ay Journey to Numberg. But these acn didn't score in that effort. Q.- Thank you. I h.vo no furtlxr quoationa to the witnoss, *ir. Pro- sident. TYx, rReiIDJiT : Tho Tribunal will now be in xecoss urtf.il 1:30 o'clock (a recess was taken until 1330 houro, 5 Ju:* 1947) 8615 Court lo. 1 5 Jun 47-1-13-1-iSWtaloy (Zrovn) ATTLE50CS SLSSICS (The hearing reconvened at 1350 hour*. 5 June 1947.) TEX KABSEALl The Tribunal is again in eeealon. hay It please Your Honore, the defendant Rudolf 3randt has resumed his place in the ecurtroom. TEE PRESIDED!i The Secretary General will note for the record that Rudolf Brandt has resumed his olace in the dock. Do any of the defense counsel have any ouestioas of this vitnessT If.. STinEAUIR: Stelnbauer for defendant Boiglboock. 3Y If. STXXXSAQBl Q, Witness, ! vas interested in vhet you said at the conclusion, namely, that you vere subjected to sovore pressure not to opuear hero ns a vitnoss. I ask you, do you believe that if a former hospital capo in a concentration cemu today is the regional chiof, let us say, of the Coaounist Party in a country not under American nrotootion, vould ho have enough po*cr thet former concentration cnap inmates *-ould bo afraid to opuoso him? *. To this cuostlon I can only sny thr t efforts «crc made to nako difficulties for me before my d«.ocrture for Duornborg. rloasv speak e littlo louder. ! don't hear you. A. I repent, X ern only say that difficulties vcrc made for mo boforo ny departure for Su.rnberg. Q, Thon you believe thet if less intelligent fornor concentration camp inmates are subjected to such orossure they ere likely not to toll eampsT that Quito possible, wxrt you in a conccntrction cc-tdT to 1944. exhaustive cvo*riencc vith concentration that can be stii. .ere you detained in one concentration cerx, or in different Court So. 1 5 Jun 47«A-l£-2-Hfc-4aloy (Brown) caspil A. r -«• first in Dachau, acd froa December 1940 to 20 Seotenber 1943 in Buchenwald, and froa 20 Septeabor 1943 until 16 July 1944 I was in Auschvitt. Q. Then the inmates of the concentration carp wore they persecuted by the SS and w B re there political struggles for power within the concen¬ tration camp? A. I would say the inmates hed more to fear of those letter struggle* ?=vor than of tho Sb, bcceus^ the aotto in tho eaap was ■Bo who doesn't toe the line or it is bolicved hv doesn't toe the lino," death sontence is already ureparod for hi-.. Q, Then there was a fight b twoon the blues nnd the reds In the caapT A. It would bo better to say bet-eon tho greens and the rods. Vithin these individual groups, let us say -ithln tho red group, were thoro also not struggles for oc'-orT A. I can answer that oucstion only in regards to Cisap Buchenwald, and I can say that es long rs tho ccr.tor cf the illogrl canp manngonont -os in the camp hospital it wvs possibly determined through Dr. Hovon'o protection, when tho political prisoners, particularly if they wero for- aor cccnunists, were practically united, and Bujhenvnld %es tho only canp group this >rgi nisetl >n -to extended to all ::c:.bors if tho canp no •matter W-.rt thoir nationality was. Witness, because you Just mentioned Buchonvald, wore there gypsies in that canp? A. (o vero not designated In the filing syetea as asocial, as unwilling to work. Q. iov ve have these various designations, the rods, blues, and browns. Did any of these groips have aore opportunity to escapo froa the carp aore culckly than other groups? a. The green prisoners, the professional, crialnals, had no chanco whatever to be released free the caap. The political prisoners - of then I know only three or four oases who wore released through channels. To be euro, there were soce releases which X said this nornlng which Dr. Eovon was behind. The black ones had quite a good chance of being released. in« what in Block 45. Q. Did any of tho nurses over tell you that Dr. Hoven was performing exr?erla,.nts in "lock 46? 0 * A. Ho. Zculd it have beer, possible for Dr. .-.oven to perform experiments in Block 45 without your knowledge? A. - hardly believe 30 , Ar. Prosecutor, because such things v uld lanediately hare become generally known in the 8622 Court 1 Juno 5-A-14-5-KD-Heehan-Browr.. camp lr. our circles. £. Suppose Fritz Klrchheiner stated toot he personally saw Dr. Hoven experiment -n -- ubjects, In 31ock Ho. 46? DP.. 3AYLXZ: I object to that question, Klrchheiner never said such a thing. I wish the Prosecutor to show the trans¬ cript to the witness so he say a^e what Fritz Klrchheiner act¬ ually did say. I knew that Klrohholmor stated he never saw Dr. Seven giving an Injection. HP-. SARD': Pardon me, Your Honor I did not say lnjeotlon. I said experimented on. Fritz Klrchholmor testified hero that Dr. Hoven tied the cage of lice on inmates legs In Block 45, if I roo.lloot ocrreotly. Did Klrchholmor over tell you ab ut that wltnose? DR. GAVLXK: Mr. President, I bollovc that the ruling .f tho o art Is that tho transcript sh.uld be shown to the witness s. ho himself oan road what the vitnoeo Klrohholmor said. 2 ®. HARDY: Your Honor, I don't think that Is nooossory. I will aok him whether or r.^t Klrohholmor over told him that he saw Dr. Hoven ever experiment on Inmates In tho camp. THE PRESIDENT: Then y u will withdraw tho previous question? MR. HARDY: That was my previous question. Your Honor, I asked If he ever talJccd to Klrohholmor and If Klrohhelacr over told him that Dr. Hoven over experimented on Inmates, that was tho Import of my question. THE PRESIDENT: The translation must have cone through wrong then, Mr. Hardy, I did not understand you. Tho prosocut r will propound his question - gain. I-H. HARDY: Did Fritz Kirchhelmer ever tell you that ho saw Dr. Hoven performing experiments n human beings In Block No. 46? Oourt 1 June 5— ^-14—6-HD— He ebon— 3r own. “HZ‘ITHZSS: Ko, noreover Fritz Zirchhelcer was* so far r.s I know, oaployed only in the bath and had had no pportunity to observe the functioning physician during hie experiments. KH. HARDY: If Fritz Kirahhelner stated that he hrd tho -P ortunlty to .bserve that; would you tend to dlsbellcvo hi a? 5 Juno-A-FL-15-I-Prioaau (L-.t. Broun) Court So. I EE. CA'TJX : I spin ask ttet the prosecutor put the transcript to * tho witness. I dony that that stateoent was ov»r aado by Kirchhoijaer, ir. ay recollection. The witness Kirchhoiaer did not say that and, in or¬ der to bo sure on this aattur, I ask again that the transcript ho put to the witness so that he can boo what really was said. THE PRESIDENT : I think in ordor to oakc the question proper tho transcript should be procured. JR. HARDY : Strike tho question. Your Honor. I will not hotter to put it to tho witnoss yet. I will savo that far the brief. BY JR. HARDY : 4 Q.- Di you knew on w of your colicages, an innate named L-ounnrdon, spoiled LueuwnrdoR? A.- No. Q.- Did you know another >no >f your colleages, a witnoss nanod Schnlkur, Schalkor? A.- Ho. Non, you say whon this first shipment of lico 'rrlvod. Can you tell us wh*r It caco froa ? A.- So far =8 I knew, froa Cracow. f;.- How did you happen to know that it arrived from Cracow ? A.- Ttero was orxr-1 talk about it in that caop and it rras s-.id ttet tho .fehmacht officer who brought tho socond shipaent of lice had cooo froa Cracar fra the Wtbreacht Institute there. Q.- Did you sou the lice ? A.- I personally did not. Q.- Did you seo the lice destroyed ? A.- No. • Q.- Do you knew wtethur or not it was destroyed before or after uso in the uxp;ri/x.ntr.l block 46 ? A.- Tho first ahipaupt was cert-inly burned before any experiments 3625 VN.ru done nit a it. 5 Jure—A-H>-15-2-Prlaoau (Int. 3r awn) Court :io. 1 Q.- ‘..ho told 70 U that ? A.- In the whole hospital that was noil known to ell the nurses. Q.- './ho told you that ? A.- Hy suporior in the.illegal organization. Q.- ’..-ho ? A.- Holljaith Dioannn. Q.- Ia ho tho nan who wee one of thu doctors working in the hospi¬ tal barracks ? A.- Ko. Q.- ..hat was hia position in the hospital barracks ? «•* HolLauth Dieaann wae a prisou-r nurse. Q.- .hen did the second shiptaent of lice nrrivu ? A.- That was at th, ond of 1942. Q.- wid you sec it. A.- Ko. Did you aco it destroyed ? A.- Ko. Q.- Do you kr.» whether or not it was destroyed before or after use in the oxporinontal block 46 ? It was burr.ee' after the lico had boon pLacod on the prisoners for a few oinutes. \hor. the person who brought this shipment, tho 'Wohroacht officer, had l-.Xt blxk 46, the cages of lice were taken fron block 46 and burned. Q.- '.»ho told you that ? A.- In the illegal oragnization that was explicitly -rde known, be¬ cause wc prisoners, so far as we know what was going on in block 46 , were Just as afr-id of an attack of disease as anyone else who had anything to do with block 46. For this reason those jocsutcs were taken fjr our own reassurance .arc’ so far as possible to roassure all tho prisoners in the cr-.p, and for this reason this .‘.nf onsetion was ianodiatcly or do known. C..- was present in tho illegal caap aan-^oaent when thoso lice 5 Jur^A-PI/-15-3-Prliacan (Lit. Brown) Court Ho. 1 »cro tied on to the logs of inmates ? A.- Vary probably, only tho prisoner capo of block 46, Arthur Dietzsch. Q.- 'feo ho a muaber «,f tho illegal cccp management ? A.- !Cr. Proaucutor, in this irotonco, you nro asking too xAuch of m hgro i if y°u ask ao about the organization of tho illegal camp na- nceu^nt, I cannot answer this question on tho basis of a list. I can't say such and such or such and such a prisoner was o ■oenbor. I can only tell you who ay superior was, who gave no ay instructions, and to whom I reportod. It was abs-lutcly necessary to builc the illegal organiza¬ tion accordin', to this pattern because if a ftur.ber of the organization was tortured by tho SG in the Bucher*.aid bunker then, at most, ho could only naoxi one nan who was his superior and only one none was his infe¬ rior. Tt^roforo, h- cojld betray only two people \ end, if tho camp or organization had been differently set up there would have boon a groat misfortune in the camp. C.- Kaw tai\y criminals wore auabers of the illegal ennp management ? A.- I beliove th-t is ono of th« hardest questions that you could have asked no. In view of tho Ihct, that I an testifying undor oath, I cannot answer that question definitely. Q.- r/as Arthur Dietzsch, hospital capo of block 46, a criminal prisoner ? A.- Ho, Arthur Dietzsch w~s a political prisoner of many years standing. Q.- Aim you sure ? A.- los. Q,- Do you know why ho was incarcerated ir. a concentration ca op ? A.- Diatzsch 'as a foraar Hole :swehr officer and had bc-n punished because within tho Roichswohr ..v. had carried Coaounistic propaganda, Q.- Had Arthur Dietzsch been in jail for so-* 20 years ? I believe he- had served 15 years ir. a penitentiary and from 5 Ju.Te-A-FL-15-4-Pri.se.-iu (Int. 3r:wn) Court So. 1 1934 on h«. hod boon in various concentration r. --< ps, Q.- Ke woa classified as a political prisoner ? A.- Political prisoner, yea. c -«" r«! no reported to the illegal coop onnagecunt that the lico in cages acre tied to the thighs of experimental atfcjecta ? A.- Yea. Q.- '..ho tied them on tho thigha of tho experimental subjects ? A.- So far aa I knew, Arthur Diotzveh hinaelf. Q.- *nho naa pr-aont ? A.- Or. Ding, and a doctor froa Berlin. Q.- .fca Dr. Hoven thoro ? A.- That I cannot answer. Q.- Waa Fritz Kirchhein-r there ? A.- :io probably ice because Kirchhci^er na ->r.c of the a trangoet aeu in the coop and he waa uaod for auch aervicca. Q.- You etato that Dr. Hoven, in order to atop the uao of thcao lico, called the SS officer on the telephono and told him if he didn't return in tho truck tfrr.t ba would have to wlk later in the evening. Ia that in thia connection, that you told ua that ? A.- I didn't quit*, urxleratand tho quaation. Q.- On direct oxr.-dnatlcn you stated that th. second ahipaont of lice waa to bo uaod in on o.*porirxnt and was, in fact, used and that Or. Hoven, knowing that tho lie- wav being used, attempted to interrupt tho experiments by calling tho SS officer froa Berlin by tolophono and tell¬ ing !iia that il would not bo possible for him to return to ./eiaar lator in tho evening and that tho nly transport' tion available waa a truck that was leaving imodiately and then the SS officer took t» availablo transport - tion ::hich enable Kovon to destroy tbo lice. Ia that what you tried to cortv-y to us ? A.- Yes, but apparently there was or. error it. tho tr-nslation. It waa rot an SS office- tut a o..abor of the Geraan Vehraacht. 5 Ju.t-A-rL- 15 - 5 -rri 2 oau (Int. 3rcwn) Court No. 1 Q.- I X6. 1 hero did Hoven telephone free ? A.- I hr*vc already auntionod this v>rning that the prison hospi¬ tal had direct telephonic connections oith Block 46 so that there, was cn opportunity that anybody who had to be celled up at any tiao could bo called up. Q.- Uwro did Bowen call this Bohr.wcht officer free ? 'Am Hoven in the hospital barracks and the 'Dehroocht officer in Block 46 ? A.- At ttet tino Kovon was in the hospital end was brought by a prisoner in-.odlately to block 46 and apparently was inforned by this pri¬ soner in the hospital what was going on nt that tlao in block 46. C..- Then he tolflph r*d the '..ohmacht officer and told hlu a truck was ready to leave. Is that right ? A.- No. Dr. Hoven thon returned with the prisoner froa the hospital the jno hurfxed Mtura to block 46, and called tho notor pool, Q.- T.’hero did tho use A tho telephone cooo into ploy ? A.- In the hospital. Q.- Did you Joar tho telephone call ? A.- No, but 1 taow all about it becr.uso this was a aottcr that was of wast iaportance to us prisoners. Q.- Non, Dr. Hoven toloph i the ..ehroncht officer from tho hospi¬ tal, is that ritht, aj* told hin the truck was leaving ? A.- Nj, Dr. Hoven telephoned in tho hospital to the aotor pool and had tho truck arranged for .and thereupon he xvtumed in person frora tho hispital with this prls-..-»jr to Block 46 and p-obably told this officer personally that the truck was ready for hie, that he should seize this opportunity because otherwise he would hr.vo to nake the long trip fron Buc Ik nuclei to \VLoor that evening on foot. 5 June-..-OIS-16-1-Ccale (Int. Br'im) Curt No. 1. Q. *hcn, Krven proceeded to Jestr'y the lice after the 'Vohrmacht rfficcr left? a. lea. Q. What was Dr. Din ds in Busae'e r a; Busso bciru: the Iipo. Q. "h was that first zan? a. Reu&hild. w. Ferdinand Recahild? a. 4 hat is rieht. Q. 1'nr.nks, D y u recall wh-n bl.ck 50 was bcin constructed? a. Yu pr. bably m^n wh-n bl ck 50 was started t- bo use' as an experir/.ntal stiti n? W. That is ri ht. a. I b-lieve in 19lil. h- ha', char c f equi. pin it, sc that it c ul' b- used, as an -xpcrU-cntal stati n? D y.u kr.w whether rntit was Dr.* H~von? i.. Dr H vwi equipped 31'ck 50, but I b-li-vc you want t know the naacs f the pris n-rs wh functi ned there... •i. N , I want t kn w whether or n t Dr. h^ven ha char-.o f C632 «. Y.s 5 Junc-*-GiS-l£-lHCc'k (Br nr.) Court Ho. 1. Q. Eow aany inmtes were ther- in ruchcnwai: crnccntriticn canp in 191*0? »• In 1910 there nust have teen n- nr re than 5000. Q. Hew nany Scathe dirt yru average a no nth thr urh natural causes? • A very snail nunter ct natural deaths. Q. roll h w cany w ul' that be, ten, twenty, two hundre-.’ or five huaired? •*. Kr. Pr s.cutor, I sh ul' like t‘. say that I caruv-t freely Judge in this natter because I have roa J . a reat ical ah ut 3uchenwald since ny rcl-asc an’. hav_ r^a ’ a let f statistics an’ n the basis cf what I have rca ' I c ul! say that the nunb-r was afc ut tw percent. <4. Tw percent :f five th usan.:? a. I.s, thr.t is ifcat I asc-rtr.inetv? p.rcvnt f five th ucand. Q. How at ut 19L1? H w nany inrr.tcs in the can.' in 191*1? H-rc the ’ovel pr.ent at the canp Buchemr.i; ,-lnyei a lar.*c r It. In 191*0 at the be/innin -f the Russian canpal.n innunerahlo prisoners of war w-rc br u.-ht int th.. cat, an ', then wh-.n the Ukraino was ecu led there «or. iruv.xdsj-ablc Ukrainian pris ners s th it tho p .mlnti n f the can;. increased ra. i’ly. I bellovc in cnc year we had ten th usan! n-w ar.-toils. w. Then in 1911 y u had 15000 people ther., y u think? •v. That nuat bo appr xinatcly c rrect. H w nany ieaths !i.! y.u have then? «. hen the ttasainn pris iw? f war cane there w„r\; relatively nany heaths because tdes^ aen hi! walked fr a th« b r _r t the cap an.'. « r. c nplwtely exhausted an ’, cnaciate in c nscqu-ntly iod in relatively large mnbors. U. "3 it as i_uch is five percent r ten p-rc_nt? Court Si. 1 5 Jun 47-A-17-l-iHX-Gr css (?renk) *. Sot as cuch as ten percent under ary circunstecces. If it had been possible fren the very beginning to treat the captured Russians in ths carp hospital, then in nany erses death could have been avoided, but there were strict orders fron Berlin that the concentration oanp and oris oner of war carp, although the prisoner of v*r C pnp was within the barbed wire, were to be kopt segregated froa one another. For instance, a large nuebor of Geraan prisoners were tarnished because they threw bread over the fence to the Russians. Because of the fact that sick Russians could not be taken into the caln hospital, a little special hospital was set up Inside the Russian carp. The drugs— Q. Doctor, Just a aonect. Can you kindly toll ao whether or not the death rate was over five percent, under fivo percent, ten percent? Do you know? Ycu have sade a stateaent hero in direct exaninntion that in 1942 and 1943 the death rate dropped. Now, whrt vas the death rate in 1941? A. If I spoke of the decrease in tho death rate, then I was talking about ordinary prisoners, but now at this nenent I a a talking about Russian prisoners of war for vfaoc no old soasures had yet been takon. Q, Veil, lot's forget tho Russian prisoners of war for a nonont and talk about ordinary prisoners, inascuch as you have based your tosti- nony on that. How nany prisoners were there in 1941, still 5000, or wae that roduced because there had been so nany deaths each nonth? v« r o thero 3600 or how cany ordinary prisoners? A. Now arrivals of Gomans took place all the tine bccauso the campaign against Russia started. All politically unreliable persons wore arrestod then as "actlonlsts*. How cany ordinary prisoners were in the ccnp in 1941? A. Approxinetely 8000. 9 What was the death rate? a. I would estimate that coopered to the previous 7Car it certainly didn't increase. It did not increase? Court So. 1 5 Jun 47-A-17-^-iSi-Cros« (Prank) A. So. Q. That vould bo tvo percent again, canely, about 160 ueople a nonth? A, Tee. Eov nary ordinary 1coatee vere there In the canp In 1942? A. ! vould expect that nev arrival! anountod to 5000 oooplc. Q. rive thoueand? A. Tee. Q. So there «as a total of 6000 In 1942 or ordinary prleonere, or ie that 13,000 - olght plue five? A. Quite right - 13,000. Q. Thirteen thoueand. *hat vne tho death rate In tboeo 13,000? A. I believe that It vould not exceed tho tvo porcont. Q. Veil, nov. It dropped, didn't It? Tou eald that vhen Hoven took ovor ae carp doctor - and he took over In 1942 - tho death rato dropped oonelderably. Eov, did It drop one percent or one-half percont? In 1942 it vne tvo percent and nov ve have a considerable drop bocauso of tho efficiency of Hoven. Did that drop lover than tvo uercont nov, or didn't It drop? A. The death rate certainly did not Increase. Q. Old not increaee? Did It decroaee? A. Tee, I aseune eo. Q. Well, vould you say that It vould be rathor exorbitant to etato that 300 lnnatce diod each nonth In 1942? A. Hr. Prosecutor, the nore the casp vae crovded the worse tho checks and controls In the canp becane. *here one nan used to live previously vhen there voro 6,000 innates there had to be tvo o* possibly three later on. The larger the nuaber of innatee beca-.o the vorse the living conditions becene, possibly not so nuch fron the point of viev of food but froa the point of viev of spece. Q. Veil, nov, didn't the cenp doctor each nonth subnit a report . on the nunbor of deaths that occurred during that particular nonth? G635 Court So. 1 5 v'us 47-A-i7-3-nHh-Gross (frank) A. I hare no information on that subject. k- Then y-u don't know vhat the death rate actually was, do youT A. Hr. Prosecutor, I an here under oath. I have to think about every word. Q» Veil, now, did you see '-r didn't you sec the death rate reoort that vaa signed by Dr. Boven and was signed by the camp doctor before hint You had access to these records kept by P.oenhlld ani Buese, Sow, did you see those death reports? A . Yos, they were always rceuosted fron Berlin concerning the number of innate* in the eenp, and how many sick, how many capablo of working, how many sent to other canps by transpes-t, and how nany dead. Q. And you saw then? *. I saw then often. 0* Veil, how nany deaths did thoy allege a aonth, in round figures, in these reports that you saw in the year 19407 A. I will take an averago figure. It variod trx\ 100 to 120. Q* 1941? The year 1941 wfcat was tho figure? A. This was in 1941. s. I asked you first vhat the figure in 1940 was and I want tho flguro now for 1941 and then I want the figure for 1942 and then I wont the figure until you left in Sopter.bcr 1943, beering in r.lnd, of course, that you sew these resorde. Q. hr. Prosecutor, with regard to the year 1940 I can't fom an opinion or pose Judgment because I didn't arrive thorc until 20 Decenbor 1940. Aa far aa 1941 is concerned, I an giving you the figure 100 to 120. k. How nany in 1942? A. I would like to stress that cuite often large transport®, arrived in Suchcnwnld, for instance, fron Dachau, fron Auechwlt*. Those people were very poorly fed on their way and had often boon severoly exposed to weather conditions that they died on the transport. They were unloaded at cuehenveld end immediately increased the death rate in that n a nnor 0636 Court So. 1 5 Cun 47-A-17-4-EE4-3russ (Trenk) rrupt" that Hover, hod a pair of boots node or had a par# of his uni- fora nade, then I wouldn't dery that he did, but, or the othor hand, I kn-*i ttet these articles which wen. nanufacturcd in the illegal work shop were only used in order to satisfy Cwp Leaders Gust, Schobert and others in order to have thoa close their eyes to prisoners on some othor occn- C639 5 Junc-ft-FL-lP-2-Karrow (Int. Frank) Court Be. 1 ai^i. «part froa that, everything in the ccnp of Buchenwnld woo "corrupt", every hunan ‘Join, rating to live in the cc^p enJ renting to live better than th.usarda f others had te be corrupt. Of course, not corrupt to tho extent that others light ^>eriah in the procoss. Q.- •'id you over see people give Hovon rxngs, fountain pens, silk und*.rewar, gold teeth, etc. ? lEr. Prosecutor, I believe that the doferrinnt Hoven didn't nood to have presents given to hia by a prisoner. Q.- Arc you fimiliar with this book written on Buchonwr.ld ? (Shows book to witness) Yes, I kn -j* it. I know all tho litoratun, published about Duchon- wnld. 0 .- ViU you kindly road fr^i page 67 the paragraph I have marked ? I don't have it translated. Your Honor, 1 neruly want those paragraph read. DR. GA'LIK (Interrupting) : 1 .bject, t. President, I bjoct to tho presentation of this book. It has not been introduced os a docuaont. It is not a pioco of evidence. .'I 1 .. HAPDY t four Honor, I will give it c nuober. I do not have .py nuabers. Out I will givu it a nuubor and offer it formally later. I do not wont to USB it as a d„cu.xnt now. I =»i\ly want to rufrosh tho aono- ry of the witness ard if he can state whetner tho facts clicitod in this book are tru- or false. THE fH“-3IDo2.T : Exhibit the book to tho Tribunal. DP.. GA LIX : Apart Iran that, I deny the probative value of this book. It isn't in any way know. : y wK-.a this bjok is written, ho is not under eath, and the person by whoa it is written should be bAught to this court if it is to be presented. At this n.aent, particularly, so "ny books arc being written cont ining the =. st exorbitant inaccuracies. Ir. tri"l ll!:o this one here, such a book can't possibly be celled ovi- f '«*co. In that cas_, the person who wrote the book ought to be brought 5 Juno-A-rL-lS-3-Knrr ow (Frank) Court Ifo. 1 h * re nnd JBWt > »winod and like every witness, oust submit to ay cross oxoainotion # :R. HARD! : I subinit, T*ir Kon_r, that in toe passages I w iah to use in this book the writer there devotes :nc page to Dr. H>ven. Ho s'vs that Dr. Korun was caap physician in Buchcnwald in 1940 and 1941 and worked out a racket with a prisoner noaod Hotz whereby inantes of the penal coon*ny, for example, - prisoners who wore treated sono-./ha.t worse than others in that penrl coapeny - would bo actaittod to the hos¬ pital for a few days if they would turn ver their valuables liko rings, fountain pons, silk underwear, gold teeth to this imato , ;totz. Thon * in turn, delivered the valuables to Hovt*. Thon if somebody didn't have valuables t« offer, then they w-uld bo admitted to tho hos¬ pital and done away with by inj.ctioos. Now, I want to kn^. if this witness is fhailinr with that particular opisodo. THS mES!D.:'.'T : Tho objccti-n is overruled. Tho question is enti¬ rely pr -per. The book is not being offered in evidence, but the witness nay bo quostionod as t statements appearing in the book. WITNESS : In .Tier to elucidate on this point thnt in Buchcnwald no innate. DP.. Gjc/UK (Interrupting) : L*. President, I want to, at least, mvu an opportunity to ajc tho book before the witness makes a sta.to- nont m it. As far r.s I have Just boon informed, it deals with the yoar 1940 and, at th-t tin*,, Dr. H.van was not oven caap physician. «T.. HAP.DY : It deals with the ye-rs 1940 and 194ll I shall ask tho witness to road the ocssago in tho book which states that Dr. Hovcn was the assistant c.-cp doetjr and that he was at the Buchomald con¬ centration coop serving in the. .-.-spitH barracks. THE HlEoD -IT : • hat is your question to tho witness ? Tou asked the witness to ixo C the passage rv fox-rod to ? --*• HARDY : If your Hon'r desires. I r.«ulo prefer rather have hira r^ad the passages. 5 June- A-FL-lS-/,-Xarr w (Int. Frank) Court No. 1 THE {RESIDENT : Tho objection is overruled. The witness nryroad ttx. passages and, t.on be questioned by counsel. IE. K«RDY : But for the Tribunal, lnasouch as I da not have this translated, if the witness weuld road tho two paragraphs alou:! then the Tribunal oould foil:* ay qu.stion. THi FRESEH.T : Very well. The witness will read the two para¬ graphs aloud* ER. GAT/LIK : :!r. President, noy I .ask you to chock your docision onco -.gain. By having those two p>r-grabs read they will go into tho rocorde and bococc evidence. THE PRESIDE*! : Counsel, the paragraphs will becone part of tho roc 3rd but thojr-~.ro rat ovidcnco in tho cr.ro at all. Tho purpose of roa-ing thoa into the record ic t. enlighten tho Tribunal as to what thu witness is being questioned about, but reading then into tho re¬ cord doos n-t cake thea evidu-.co. BY .P. HARDY : C.- 7oul you kindly loading the passages which aro oarkcxi, ,7r. Dorn ? A.- Certainly : "In 1940 and 1941 a now d>ct^r orrivod in.Suchonnold, His naao wrs Valdoorr Koven, SS-Cberstumfuohror, always kind and nice. Ho said abr-ut hiass-lf when ho received tho Kar Cross f fcrit "You arc no horo, but a .an wtio ploasos." Haven wac proaotod to S3»Hnuptstumfuohror and becano cajp physician, ith that began his -.dual career. He had .aany irons in tho fir-. Or.e of his sources of supplies was a pria nor nened ^tt. Ho had roor. sorvico t.> do in the p-cal coapany and it was up to hid t: produce the sick rixl weak prisoners iro.a tho penal coesp.aj$ call¬ ed the "Houslunon" in tho sick ward. The granting of a few days decent treatment in thu hospital and easy work, granted through the doctor, >r admission to tho hospital depended upon what the individual deliver¬ ed t; :_>tz, I.ur.trin pens, rings, silk under, err., golden teeth, etc. C642 5 Jun.-A-FL-lS-o-X^rro*' (Int. Frnk) Court Ho. 1 parcels with laundry could be sent to every one, at the tiac, froa hose. Uiti hand - the aajor share nvor to Hovon. For this ho received a free ticket i;r all his p-rpetratl»s which he c-znittcd against pris.n.rs in the penal cccpany. Anyone who didn't give presents or any to ILtz was token into th- hospital -nd injected b7 Hoven. At thi end Mots b-enue a lugalooenlcc. He no longer had any feeling for prop-r a-aaures applied to his s-st-r and foil into disfavor nnr* one day wes finished off tiitiin two hours : he was injected. *Xotz was only one of aony s .ure.s of suppli-s for Hoven. He got furniture, carpets ant’ ra¬ dios 1-r Oborsturufwhrer V elker Iron tho 3uilc'ing Brigade #$.iron Cologne, de of our outside X mantles. Pris n. rs who woiv- w r’.tin«; thero wore giving aid to b obed—out citi s in dorning-up operations. 11 Q.* Die you ever hear f this? A.- :tr. Pros-cut r, let - t-11 y u, that I'd like to soo the pris.ner .iho still had a silk shirt in BuohemaLd -r a ring. I think I said thin noming :n one xccsi ys f Ouchersrcld under such a nyo- t. a. 3y .rr'-r . th- ill*-..'L c-up - Jainislr-ti n ur c arades v old probably have t r-T. hia int the barbed wire fence. Such -xcosa-s in Buchurold ha bec.:x Lop ssiblo in 1940. If y u had said in Ausch¬ witz then I ru the first t ,e- -w Ln, -aZ & y "yes", but X.:r Bucben- wr.l'’, since 1?A0, vrfectly rderly c.r. * ti ns -xistec". Q.- Dir' y a knw br. K-rn? A.- I knee Di. K-rn Very w-U. r .- Di l>r. K m >r. mst J th- *pratijns in tho hospital C$43 nr cks? 5 Junc^-A-FL-lO-c-Karr :w (l“t. F r mk) Court Kj. 1 A.- He lv -^1 to wixth^r b- wanted t >r rut, because Dr. Hovon cer¬ tainly Hasn't a g-od surge.c. Q.- Was Dr. Hovon studying under Dr. Korn? a.- -'ell, I always felt as if H>m was tho msn who wr.s having to teach HoVen ov^n the surliest typ^ of operation. Q.- I sc- • Did you know PiJc? A.- Dr 7 ^ Jh-an the Dutch painter, ?iok? Q.-Tws. A.- I knew hin Very well, indeed. Q*- *te.t was Pick's profess! >n? A.- Piok was a painter by pr-fvsai.r., Q«- Did he. ever paint any p.rtr-.its i r H,ven? A.- I think n-t cnly for K ven but i >r every SS leader in tho «eap. 1 kr.w for certain, f4* instance, that he p'inted Dr. Dina Wallenstein with a flying cloak. $•- Did lu paint p 4 -tralts of H-von's children? A.- That I c >uldA'i possibly tell you hero with ourtrinty. Q.- N.m, y.u say in bixk 46 H-von ,nly Went to visit tho tailor one oh,worker because he ted set th«xn up in business there where they wuld be free £rxx bother by the SS. H.w ofto did he visit the shso- nak-r one tcils-r? Did he go ,vcr there two, three, four tiioes a week, ,r h m often? 0644 5 Jun-A-^E-19-i-' tloy (Lit. ?r=nks) Court Kc. la A Yes, you can say that Dr. Hcven visited the work shop generally frequently. Q How often would that be? A Every second day, quite frequently. Q Chen did they set :? this tailor shop and shoe shop in Block U6, was it installed and equipped at the beginning or during the Riddle of 15U1? A Well, I think the block hadn't boon in existcnco for four wsoks when the work shops had also been equipped. T’.jo situation at the beginning was that Block I 16 could not be entered by anybody not a jozber of the SS, even with permission, and I believe Dr. Woven was also offeoted b 7 the prohibition, consequently the work shop would only havo boon constructed four to six weeks, or 6 weoks later. Q HctiV long did the shooaaker and tailor stay in tho shop in Block U6, for two years 19U2 atxi 19U3, or for how long woro they thero? Q .^uite decidedly until Hovon's arreot, because I don't re- neober that tho natter was best ope nod in any other way previously. A And Dr. Hovon onl;. went to Block U6 to visit the tailor and shoemaker in the workshops, he didn't go thero for the purposes of the experiments? A Hr. Prosecutor, if Dr. Hovon left Block U6 with a parcol uider his arc or a pair of boot3 or a uniform Jacket, I can't possibly and really imagine ho got those fro- the sick ward. Ha probably go* those fron the work shop. Q I see. He went ever there about ovary other day? A Every second d3y. • Q Did Dr. Hoven have about 500 suits and 300 pairs of shoes; ho wont there every other day for over two years? A Yes, that would be so, if Dr. Haven hadn't been passing on these other things to other people, for instance Oust, Schobert and 3iester, they all walked about with shoes soled in Block U6. 5 Jua-A-13-l?-2-lfeloy (Ir.t. Franks) Court .To. I. Q In other words. Dr. Hoven, a nar. who was a concentration can? doctor where you had sons 15,000 inmates and you had about 260 dj-ina eech month had tire to go see the shoe nan and tailor every ot'.ser day? A l!r. rrcsecutcr, the facts are that the nodical work, ir. fact that the doctors' work in Buchenwald was in the hands of prison doctors in a vary considerable extent, for instance you only havo to think of the systematic training of nurses. T/e had an evening school for two or three hours every evening given by Dr. Datuschok and Dr. Horn. Q Do you know who uroto Dr. Horen's thesis, did ho wrlto it hinaolf or was his thoeia to boccxae a doctor writton by Dr. h’ogoror of Vienna? A 1*. Prosecutor, all I oon toll you is what I happened to road a fow days ago in a book. It soys thorc that Dr. Hovon's thesis had boon writton by a cortnin Dr. Ttogorer from Vionna. This nan is supposod to bo a doctor or profossor of chonistry. I read that a few days ago. I can't give you any certain inforaction on that subject. Q In tho hospital barracks how often did you soo Hoven, did you see hin continually oach day? A I saw hie daily. Q You saw hia also adninist.r injoctions to five persons, that is all? A That killing I obsorvod. Q And you state that Dr. Rovan is correct in his figure of 60 killings either by inaates or by hiasolf? A I can't answer that. Q And those inaatos, accofding to Dr. Hovon's affidavit, 60 persons wore killed and others ware beaten; of those 6C persons ho statos that some of them were kiliod by inxatcs, is that ri$ht? (No response.) Do you hav^ a copy of Dr. Hoven's affidavit, please? 5 Jun-A—12-19-3-lialoy (Int. Praia) Court So. I. This is paragraph 12, Document Book 12, Doc leant HO U29 on page 5 of the German, paragraph 12; will you kindly read that, Hr. Dorn, an affidavit fay the defendant T.a ld en ar Horen? Q "The total ni=ber of killed traitors was approximately 150, 60 of ahich were killed by phenol infections oither by nysolf or under ry direction, and the rest rore killed by various methods such as boatings fay tho litotes." Q Troll now, he statos that there were killings eithor by himself or undor his direction, is that right? D?.. GAVLIKi Mr. ftrosidont I wish to objoct to tho sufccaission of this affidavit. Tho affidavit hasn't ;*ot boon admitted in ovidonco. It is an affidavit that has not yot boon admitted. Its admission has boon retarded until defondant novon is put on tho stand. 13. HARDY 1 I was not aware of that, your Honor. It boars an oxhibit nunbor. It isn't a fact that it is not admittod in ovidonoo. This is scoot .Lag now today. ; .o hr.vo boon using it throughout our cross-examination continually. It certainly h".e been admittod into ovidonco. If it hasn't boon admittod which is so nothing I can't ijuag- ino, than it has baon ovjrlockod by tho Procccution in tho presentation of its caso in chief, and we subait it at this tiao. Tho documont is in order, it contains a Jurat, is srewnto and signod by tho dofondant. THE RESIDES Tt Tho first question is to doteraino rhothor tho document has boon admittod in ovidonco. I will ask tho Secretary Gcixral to pro-'iico thi original document end dotoiminc how it is aarkod. :a. HARDY 1 Do you have tho prosecution oxhibit number? Your Honor, I dan't know the oxhibit mrbur off-hand. TIE fRESHJEOT: It i3 docunont Ko. HO 1*200. HARDY* Do you Invu tho ivosocution exhibit number narkod in ycur document book. Your Honor? TrZ EPZSIDEIT: I cannot tell free this book. There is a symbol aftw-r that, but -rh-’t it is I - HE. -LARDY* 5k-. Travis -ill have it in his file of tho proscc- 5 Jun-A-JS—19-4-Maloy (Int. Franks) Court Ho. I. ution nusl-crs. If ho will call ay office phone, 61212 and ask for Dr. Hochwald to give him the p.\.sccution exhibit number of that docu- ?acnt, he will be able to secure it. GA'TJX: Lr. ftusident, I had placed an objection to the admissibility of this document, it has once been submitted and then its submission ras put back until Dr. Hoven has been examined. I havor.*t got the record of that boforo no. I trill have to wait until tonorron, but I could submit tbe record of it. iE. KAPDYi lour Honor, I submit if that is true thon all tho ottor doeixaents admitted in cvidoncc voro admitted incorrectly by this Tribunal. This document horc is no different from any othor affidavit we havo submit tod. I m sure it nas admitted and thoro is prosocution oxhibit nunbor, and I would liko to finish up ay ox-mina- tion and I only have thro- or four more questions and cloar thoa from his affidavit. DR. OA'XIKi I havo Ivcn dcV.ilod reasons for my objoctlon. Tho document was submittod to Dr. Hovon at that timo in tho English lnnguago and not in Gorman, and Dr. Hovon has not suffioiont control of tho English language fer tho knowledge of oxcoining on it. Ho in- tor pro ter rras prosout at that tiro. That was tho cause of tho object¬ ion and the Tribunal docidcd that arteicsion vould be put back until after thu examination of Dr. fbven. For that reason, I trill oojoct to to¬ days use of the document. i-R. HARDYi I proceed to mother question or tu>. Your Honor, while tto are siting for tho document. BY HP.. KAPDY: Q Dorn, do you know for what reason Dr. Hoven wr.s nr- rcstod by tho SS? A I can only repeat ay explanation which I gave this mor¬ ning. As far as I re informed “r. Havon was arrested because tho sus¬ picion existed against him he was cooperating with prisoners, cooper¬ ating with them extremely closely and as ti;oe progressed the suspicion 5 Jun-A-i3-19-5-^107 (Int. Franks) Ccurt Ho* I. increased* Professor, Dr. Hoven is supposed to hav3 been arrested be¬ cause of the case with Hauptsch-rfuehrsr Koehler. Just how this af¬ fair developed is sccathing I an not informed about. I only know that it was 12 September 19U3 Hoven was arrested on leaving the camp. Q Do you know whether or not any other officers of the conp were arrestod at the saao tire? A I know that tho c ccn a ndan t Koch T.-as arrested, but I can't tell you with certainty today whether Koch was arrestod oarlior or later than Hoven, and I know at that tiro Cbcrscharfuchrcr Sceanor was arrestod. I don't know what connections there wero. Q You don't know whothor Koch was also arrestod for collab¬ oration with tho ircatos? A Koch? I think ho was tho biggest devil wo prisoners over clacipod oyos upon. Q Do you know whothor or not Ho von was indiotod after being arrestod? A That I do not know, bocauco on tho 20th of Soptcrcbor 19l*3 I loft Buchoronvld and then novor again established contact with Buch- onwald. Q Do you know whether or not tho crap coravandont Koch hnd Hoven were indicted in tho saco indictuent? A Ho, I don't know. Q Do you know that Crap Coarondant Koch and Dr. Hoven wore charged with fraudulent conversion of Raichs' funds, of frauds on con¬ centration coop inoatos for thoir ora benefits, and condoning and fostering corruption in tho carps. A Hr. FToeecutor, I know that Koch and his brothor-ip-law, Hauptscharfuokror Michael were arrested for corrupt actions in tho crap. Q lou know that Hovon was arrestod in the sane case along Trith- Koch? A Ho. 'Jy information is to tte affect that it ns because 5 Jua-A-!3-19-6—jfclcy (Int. Franks) Court He. I. of the case of Hauptscharfuehrer Koehler that Koch was arrested. Q Who? Hauptscharfixihrer who? A Hsoptwcharfuehrer Kcehler. Q 3aa he a witness against Koch? A I can't tell you that. If I had ronalned in Buchorrrald then I would certainly' have had the exact details the fortnight after Hover, was arrested. 5 June-A-<3ES-2G-i-;ieehan . Matuschek in 0? 1 — Internal (^orations in the Uedical wine. OP 2 there was a certain Hcllnuth Dicaann and another ran and I can no longer roaoefcer his nano, I do know that the aan cane freu Upp^r Silesia and I can see him with ay own ^yes but 1 cannot rcacaber the nanc. He had a Polish nano which it is difficult for ix to pronounce. W. how nony nurses did he have; Ben in ycur capaoity? A. Altogether possibly 90 ocn, possible acre than that. How, realising you are under oath, can you Ul1 this Tribunal how nany nen you assisted in the killing of with Dr. Hoven? *• T' that f can answer with a calc conscience that 1 did not assist with a single killing, nor assist in any aannor, nor was I pro- 3ent at any ticc. H-.w cany cen did ycu kill when Dr. Hoven was not present? ... I havu never killed a hu:on being. Q. You hsd access tc the drugs, didn't ycu? “• N., but to the phenol drags no one had access. Q. ‘hen you know they used phenol in killings in Buchcnwald? «. I think cv.rybcdy whe ever worked in the sick bay knew that. W. I have rv: further questions, your Honor. THE P ESIIE.'iT: Ccwnse-1, hew aich tice will ycur rc-cxaniniation f this witness consuac? 5 hnx.-»-jeS-20-ii4£cvhan (Brcwn) Coart Ho. 1. DE. G&.UK: I Just heard that ay colleague. Dr. Holte, has a fuw questions and I would say about fifteen tc twenty minutes for ayself. 7HS P.-SSTEEJfT: I would dcsiro that the Investigation be node now before tcaaerrow nerning to ascertain the status of this affidavit of the defendant Heven. The Tribunal would like to knew whether it was formally admitted in evidence or wheth-r it was net because the record indicates it was and if the record is incorrect. The Tribunal would like to be advised. The Tritaiml will be in rtetis until 9:30 o'clock tomorrow corning. THE iivRSH.»L: The Tribunal will be in rocoss until 9*30 o'clock tomorrow morning. (The Uribur-al adj-umod until 0930 o'clock, 6 Jun_ 19li7•) f*rr 6 ' r-JF-l-l—Jrocs (Int# T-arf:) Court I Official Transcript of the laorican i^litary Tribunal in tlx setter of the United Status cf .w-xrica, a-ainst ::ori Drnadt, ot al, cfcfo-.jdanta, • slating at -umberg, Garraqy, on 6 Juno 191:7, 093^-1630, Justice goals prosiding# 7'; ''.SS'.^L: Arsons in the c urtroor. nill please find their go at 3. Iho r n a-ablo, tho Judges of "ilitnry Tribunal I# • !', lit jy Tribunal I is new in 303si:n# Cod save tho United States of .jaorica and this Honorable Tzibwal* Thoro will bo order in tlio c urtrocc# T.* . ESHei.Ti 1 *. rjxrabal, will jxu ascertain if all thada- fondants are present in c mrt? !*-. SL.Ls ’.'ay it pleaso ytur Honors, all the defendants oro prosent in court# TI£ j'lSSEJBITi I}jO SjCrotar; Gonoml will note for the jaecorri tiw presence of all the defend*nts in court# Tho vitnoss is ronindod J*j is still under oath# Counsel nay proceed with tho o miration# DCTuI - Coavrod ICDrECT SI.' J ' JIG' (Continujd) K 'X:, 1 ZLT 2 (for dif ndant Uaadloaor): 0# l.‘itr\»33, during y ur com -nation and a- so sxmalnation you have s oleen of tho ccnsignixints of ty^ius carrying lice to Buchonrnld# eid, if eg* notes I tock aru oorroot then you said ir. that cnnOction it -'as .j rurally talked a*: ut in the cr. p that tills officer fr.r. Cr-zeen ca - r an institute cf tlio ehnr.cht# Is this n to of nine corwct? -.# *fes, your note 70 U tool. Is correct. t-ll anything, th-r-for-, fr on y ur orm personal 4f^ ^ ?*! • *• 1 i Q» Do you hi# Vof Xioe crj»? y ) th t Dr# 'oven knew fr) -wore erroneous, narely, that aasicrewnts of lice camo fron Cracow.” Thank you very such. Or. urt I June 6-J&-2-1-HD-? r lcea u~? ra nk. DR. GaVLXX: Mr. President, to begin with, I should like to speak about the affidavit which case up for dleousslon yeaterday and I would like to say that the decision of this Tribunal Is In the record of 3 January 1947, on pcgo 1113 of the Geraan record; and this ruling of the Tribunal s tates that the Tribunal has ruled that to begin with the affidavit oan be admitted subject to a later objection by the defendant Hoven and that the defense Is not showing whether the defendant Kovon has aneworod any (luostlona at all. Should ho havo boon Interrogated without having boon properly warned, he can say so on tho witness stand at a letor date. If ho did not understand the English language and If the affidavit was n«.t translated to hln, ho will be able to clonr that up, too; but It was adnittod provisionally without prejudice to tho right of dofonso o ,unsol to lrtor vbjoot t. Its cdalssablllty. If tho Tribunal should then assu e th*t this affidavit Is not to be adnltted in ovldenoe thon It will bo struck fron tho rooord. THE FRESIDE:*!: Counsel Is correct. That Is tho ruling of tho Tribunal. MR. HaRDT: May It pleaso your H^nor, to note for tho roo'rd, the c''nter.tl n of prosooutljn of this catt^r during yost-rdr.y's session la correct? THE PRESIDE!*!: The record will bo aade to dv;w exactly what happened and will epeak for Itself. ay dr. QaVli: i. Witness, the r.ur303 In Slock 46 — did they act indopor.dor.tly to a considerable oxtont? a. I wouldn't fl- ouch any tho nurses as tho prisoner k-.po, Aurthur Dlotzsch. 8657 Court 1 June 5-14-2-2-HD-Frlmeau-Frank. i. If Dr. Ding was ebsent, was it necessary at all in such cases that an S3 Doctor took his place7 a. No, all the work and every action wcs carried right out by Diettech, Dletzsch Independently. i. Did defendant,_ Dr. Kovon, have the essential knowledge in jrder to give orders to Dletrsch and the -ther nurses who were w rlclng in 31ock 46? j%. I have already said before that I never thought that Hoven was a g^.d doctor and I hardly think tnnt ho took as muon interest in the typhus experiments as was necessary for him tw give instructions. Q. Is it true that you met the nurso6 working in 45 repeatedly? A. Yes. i. «nd did you also talk nb.ut d~rlng such meetings that Xing's experiments wore carried • ut by the Kopo Diotzsch? A. But, of oouree — wo, the prisoners, interested -uroelves c nelderably in tnose matters "nd wo had it o nflrmod repeatedly tn«t Dletrsch and Ding carried them out al.no in Block 46. 3. It w uld be correct t- say then that amongst tho nurses f Bluok 4S ond the nurses in the sick bay the iencral assumption was tent tnwso experiments were carried u- by Dln c and Diotzsch but n.t the defendant Hovan? A. Yes, indeed. The figures relating to deaths wore dlscussod yosterday, tho Buononwald dootn figures, that is, and you said that y : had read vrrl^us publlcati ns about B.iohenwald vhlohdi.wed that the death rate never exceeded 2*. A. vulto o.rroct. k. But this wouldn't exclude the possibility, would it, that the death rate In Buohenwald was considerably Court 1 June o-H-2-3-HD-?rlaeau-Frank. lover temporarily. That la correct, too, Isn't It? A. (No response) %. In order to refresh your memory, I now submit to you, not ns on exhibit but merely for till 6 purpose, a d puncnt which has been submitted to Tribunal II In Cneo IV and I would like you to,road please — read aloud, the donth rato In the concentration camp of Buohenwald from It. KR. KmRDY: Is It proposed to offer this document In ovldonco here? DR. G»VLIX: No, I don't want to submit It In evldonco, as I have already told you. I am meroly using It to rofrosh the memory of this wltnose. That Is the purpose and also to question him on It, cf oourso. A. The death rato - THE PRESIDE!!!: Just a nomont. Did this witness tostify before Tribunal II? DR. CUVLIX: No. THE PRESIDENT: Veil, you asked him to road this affidavit Into the record. That Is not refreshing his rooolloctlon. Ho Is not testifying from his own reoollco- tl-n when ho answers your question. Ho is simply reading this exhibit. If he knows he ay glance at that to refresh hla rcc' Ueoti n then he could testify from his own know¬ ledge but If he Is simply reading a record ho Is not test¬ ifying fr:m his own recollection at all. DR. 3«’/LIK: : I shall put a few questions subsequently *'lth reforonoe to it but. If you like, I will rend rt. MR. HrtRDY: Imsmuch as that Is the case. Your Honor, I suggest that the defense counsel prooc66 the icunont In i . • duo form end offer it cs an exhibit. DR. GhWLIK: No, I a-.n't.want to submit It as an exhibit. 3659 Court 1 June 6-H-2-4—ED-Frlaeau-rrank. THE PRESIDENT: Counsel may present to the Tribunal a certified copy of this exhibit which would be admitted In evidence or If the witness nos his own recollection, ho can tostify from his own knowledge as ho pleases. Ho could also be asked whether or n^t he agrees with the statement In tho document. DR. SA’VLXX: I now propose to reed this figure and then cak tho witneaa whether tne figures are oorroot and I teg to have y.ur decision whether this Is porml6sable. THE PRESIDENT: Counsel nay proceed. Of course, you understand, Counsel, that tho document will not becono ovidenoo unless It Is Introduced before the court. DR. GkVLIK: V.o I don’t want to aibnlt It In evidence. I nm merely using It in order to - lve a basis to ny question. This is 'x letter fr^n Pohl dated 30 September 1943 and addressed t Himmler. Attached t j It Is n tablo of death figures f r the month of August, 1943, In concentra¬ tion amps. It mentions Buchcnwald and there tho etrongth v;aa 17,600 detainees and the number of doathe was 116, equalling a percentage of 0.67*. THE PRESIDENT: Counsel, there ••ao that cany deaths In what period of time? DR. Oa'-T-IK: August 1943, Your Honor, the month of August 1943. THE PRESIDENT: For one month, and that was the record. DR. GaVLIK: Tne average for all concentration comps In Ml list 1943 was 2.09*. 3Y DR. ChYLIZ: Z. Is It correct thnt It wrs owed to defendant, Dr. von, that tho death rr.t~ for the concentration camp of Huchenwald was considerably lower than the overall rverage? 3660 Court 1 June (M4-2- 5-HD-?rlneau-Frank . A. Yes, that Is correct. i. It was later sectioned during the croBs examination whether you knew anything about the death of Jupp Colllnet? A. Yes. v. >.*111 you describe this case in detail? A. I knew the prisoner Jupp Colllnet during approx¬ imately two yoars. I know that Jupp Colllnet case from *ld-la-Chcpelle and that he owned several houses there. Tho spoolal cosslssloner of the political auction of Buchonwald had boon a crlnlnal cosslsslon.r In Asohen earlier and he had a row with Jupp Colllnet in tho oourse of which Colllnet fired a shot at Leclair. Later on Leclalr wont to the political departaent of Buobenwnld as a special commissioner nr.d amongst the prisoners there he rcoognizod Collinot. Following efforts ande with tho camp Kor.wnndr.nt, he suocoedod In getting an order for Colllnot's liquidation. I know for certain that Collinot was not killed by Dr. Hovon. On that day, on the day when Collinot had been beaten half to death and was or ught to the sick bay, Koven wasn't present In the casp. The killing was oarrled out In tho prosonce of the first and second camp lendor, Max Schobcr, and 'Jntersturmfuohrer Oust. I cannot give you any more detail about this affair. Is It correct thr the ?ollt leal s action was under the secret state police? A. Yes. You were speaking about gypsies yesterday and the grouping of gypsies. Du you have anything to adt^ to that part of your testimony? I can merely say that Initially all gypsies were arrested for racial reasons. Later on this was changed. Some of the Gypsies who were not declared as social elements 5661 Court i June S-*-2-S-HD-.?rl=eau-?rank. were removed fron Dachau to the labor house In the Rebdorf Bavarian penitentiary. DR. a».LIK: Ur. President, I rave no further questions. THE PRESIDENT: Does tne prosecution have any nore questions to be propounded to the witness? 6 June-2fr-5I/-3-l-Cook (let.* Frank) Court to. X gg-caoss zaitmuM 3Y Jft. HAP^Y: f..- -hat ia the extent of your education? A.- Initially I was a waiter at the Grand total in Humber-., For condition, in xy family I had to give up this profession and I was re-trained as a ootor mechanic. Ae a very young aan I went to Africa and I was a soldier in the French arey for several years. In 1938 I return¬ ed to Ger-any and went into business on ay own. After the German capi¬ tulation I started afresh, starting as a taxi owner. Are you a graduato of ary University? A.- No. Can F° u toU - us whether or not from your knowledge Dr. Hovon was considered to be a so-called ladiea' man? A.- I don 't qulto understand, a so-called what? Q.- Lacies' a§ in. DR. CA’.'Li::: :j. President, I object to that quostion. First of all this is an utterly irrelevant quostion, and secondly, I beliovo that n» in the re-cross examination only such questions can bo put -hich are due to ay re-direct examination. 1 do not bolieve that a cross exa¬ mination can be started ail over again after the Prosecution had com¬ pleted oross examination yesterday.- IB. HARM* I subait, Your Honors, this is a question concerning thc cheractor of the deferment. THE HU Bmaff i Defense counsol states the rule correctly but tho practice of this Tribunal allows vary liberal direct oxaoinatioa and cross examination, and counsel for defense, of course, cay ro-exuaino the witness in connection with any natters which are now. The objoAion will bo overruled. 3Y ?R. HARDY: f..- To your knowledge, did Dr. Horan have nistressos, that is Indy friends otr.or then his wife? 8663 6 Junt-lf-FL-3~2-Cook (Int. Frank) Court So. 1 A.- Ora axi~ht well ossuae so. °° ^ ou to®" whether or not Dr. Hoven had relationships 'dth the wifu of the Cano Cconardant Koch? A.- Quite decidedly no. Q.- You don't know that? A.- T;iis wuld not havo reecincd unknown in the c?ap. Q «" Aro you nerriod, witness? A.- Vho, _»? Q.- Tes f A.- Yes. r .,- How long have you boon aarriod? A.- Since tho 10 of August last year. r ..- Sow friendly wore you with Hoven while you wore in tho Buohan- wald concentration caap? A.- I -.ust say that I hrd a largo nuaber of odvant&gwc through Hoven cut there was novur a relationship which you could cell friond- 8hi P bntt ' un JJ ® v#n V®lf. I havo never U Iked with Hovun off duty. Q.- Did you wear a violot triangle? A.— So. Witness, when ycu woro testifying h-ro on direct examination, I noted that you woro using natvS to refresh your recollection, do you still have those notes before you? A.- ho. Q»- h*horu arc those notes? A.- I only have befer. au here the nivus which i!r. Prosecutor road out to ae, Diotiaoh and Collinet and others. f,.- -ret ic you do with the notes you wore using to testify why? A.- I aa not sure but I think they ar_ lying on tho table in -ay apartment* C..- ..ore thoso tywritfcon note?, soac ol then? A.- That I don't knew. G664 6 Jur»-H-FI^3-3-CC05c (It. Frank) Court No. 1 Q.- W 011 , who pr-pered the notes? A.- P.'rdaa. Q.- ho orcpcrod the notes? A.- Nobody iar prepared anything for me. Q.- doll, you had typewritten notes boforc you in you wore tes¬ tifying yesterday; nho typed those notes for you? A.- As soon ns I knew I wia coaing to Huroborg, of course, I oro- pered syacll with reference to the trial, for I waa able to toU eporo- xiaatoiy the questions which would be put to Q.- Did Dr. Gowlik give you any typewritten notes? A.- I talked with Dr. Gawlik a few days before npponrir.g here. G.- Did he give you any typewritten notes? A.- No, I filled a typewritten sheet before a> which had U ques¬ tions on it, end I Sent it to the Tribunal. Q .“ Did ' 5U tter0 “7 otour typewritten notes befon you? A.- No, only whfit I wrote with ay own hand. 1- . HARDY: I have no further question. TK« PRdSIDlfT: Doicnse couns.1 aey casain^ tho witness, if he de¬ sires. DR. GA-’LIKi I don't tave any furthar questions. The PRESIDdlT: There being no further questions to bo propounded to the Witness, the witnoss wiU be excused froa the str.nd.- Tho Tribunal will proceed with tho oaau nginst Boiglboock. DR. ST3L:3A'/.R: (For defendant. Professor Dr. .ilhela Bolglboeck, froo Vienne.) Mr. Pr.aident, .our Honors, I shall begin the case on bo hr. If of ay client, Dr. Eei lbo.ck, by reminding you with one sentonc. of *y opening apocch. First of all, 1 went to picture to you the personality o. this defendant and then I shall show thet he carried out son water eX'xriak.nta a ainst his own will under explicit nilitr.ry orders, and, thirdly, he carried then out ih such a wry that you cannot conclude 3665 6 Jur*^-FI^3-A-Cook (Int. Frank) Court Ho. 1 criau.3 Qjninat huaonity or war criaos froo the way they were carried out. In order to draw you a sood picture I should like to remind you of an air railway, when I speak of ay re ore sent *t ion as an air railway, as a row rope, and that is represented by the defendant on tho witness st".nd and the few documents, ar.d on tho corttrrry if that ropu were to break then I have tho safety rope. The scientific pillar, nnocly, tho evidence that beers cn internal rxdicine it is out of the qi^stion, that thuso oxpurlnonts can be called criminal. - I aa not pleading Hr. Hardy, I a * A,r\.ly plaining. I oa awfully sorry Professor Ale¬ xander hes bed so ouch work to do but I should like to envo work for tb. Tribunal ruv’ ayacir and the scientific deccrlotion lists, I think the crr.rt has 13? pages, *nd I would like to #r.v» ay honored collar uc, lr. H-rdy end ly&elf the trouble since *. are no experts md also I would like to put ell of theBs. scientific questions back. I would like to nsk you, Pr-sidcnt, that ay client, Dr. Buirlboeck, take the witn-ss stand r.s a witness now. V.IZ »2Sm\RT* Tho defendant Beiglboock will take the witness stand. The defendant Bciglboeck took the witness strnd and testified as follows: BY JULGo Sa-vJ Xi: r .*- Please raise your right hend and be worn: repeating after ac: I nw.- r by Cod, the ALaighty and Cbnlsciwnt, that I till aperk tho pure truth rad . ill withhold and add nothing. (The witness rotated the oath) You ,»y be a-ated. DI RaCT SU I1..VII0H * BY. DR. SI X IVUffi: Q.- Your naao is Dr. ilh,-la Bviglbocck, isn't it, and you voro bom on th. 10 of October 1905 at Hochrev.’circhen in Io*-:.r Austria, as :.T, of a c ntr7 doctor. You r.tt_r.dod the Second "ry school .t thu 6 Jurc-K-i 1^-3-5-Cook (Int. Frank) Court Ho. 1 Benedictine Monk* College in Malic and you studied :v.dicin- at tte Univer¬ sity of Vienna ?nd them gat your degree, didn't you? A.- All of that is corr-ct. Q.- What is the Jkodical training you h~d? A.- I first of cU began working ch-oically, pathology and ato.ao- logy. I turr.od to intern"! cxdicine and after I was promoted I joined the third nodical clinic in Vienna, the chief of which was Prof. Dr. Chwoatok. Q.- ./ho was Frofessor, Dr. Ctooetck? A.- Cbiostck nr.s the son -f an also very well known and famous in¬ ternal ffledica.l van, r. student of Ueinort rnd J.eussert, and also acting as an internist ani neurologist, and was particularly famous for his diagnosis and was highly esteuaed in this field and sought after in tho whole of Europe as being a representative of the typical old Vienna school. &•- How long did you itaair. with Professor Chwostek? A.- I stayed * ith hia as Long as he wns the head of that clinic, in other words, rbout two years, and then Chwostek was pensioned off and his clinic was cliasoiv-d, end I wont to tho first aodical clinic, the chief of which became at that tiao Professor ippinger. Q.- oppinger, he has b. n nentionod here quite often - nho was Kppiagor? ...- It is difficult to say, in which .field of internal medicine Pro feesor Epoin^er did not contribute) highly important work. Evon when ho wis young - bcc.'eao famous because of his w:rk about internal Secre¬ tions, particularly activities of the thyroid gland, and ho carried out research into the vegetative n, nr, us system nd created with *,q»s the conception of Vago Unsiapatioonus. Q.- Tou i avc to speak wore slowly *nd sake short sentencos. A.- Those two c-x.cepti.ns have b.c.ac general knowledge in aedicino t dyr:. Eppir.vor then varied on kidrh-y diseases, dropsy and Later as 8667 6 Juno- 'J-FL~3-6~Coo 'Int . Fr-.nk) C-urt &o. 1 S-nkobach's scholar ha worked on shock and collapse tivetaont and ho bt»~ ccsfc. the son who cleared up the erases of oollnpso to a ooneidorablo uxter.t and lixliiiod and cleared it ip in a basis rtinner. 8fc6G 6 June k-i-Grcss (Ererk) C urt S3. 1 *• (continued) Later on he corked on aetcbolian of heart diesoasoa. er.dhe erected a beaia for the fane tl end diseaao of the heert acicr.ee. His first work wee on pathology of theliver erd his research in this field erected ® relate novelty. It oca due to this thet hia reputation becaoe international, end it o< 8 If ter on that be do voted hia ontire r<.acirch to this field epert fr:a hundreds of smaller rorfca in tha cotcboliaa field. The race Eppirger ocs knewn the vorld over end I do know, ea hia chief deputy, th't hia scientific airrcapondeneo oxtond- cT to dl cur.tr 1 cs of tho world. The external ayaptcoa of thiaintemet- ioncl reputation ca c phyalcicn erd scientist wes thos tho Tribunal understand froa counsel that tho docunont is :xwr properly- cortiXicd? It will bo sutraitted ns such. HARDY: It is not jroporly certifiod. Tho certificate put on by Dr. St-jinbovkir was put on of tor tho dnto of tho signature. DR. STEI:.BA'"JRj Tho Prooocution '.won't understood what I said. I rocoivod this letter of Mrs. Brover and si:wo sto gave it to bo personally I cortifiod its authenticity but in tho noontloo tho Tribunal has fulod in spite of tho foot as of 11 torch lvu7 all signatures wore to bo notarised by a Notary. Consequently I returned this to Mrs. Brovor end askod her to havo it oortifiod by a notary. HR. HARDY: Just a nwcwnt. I will havo Dr. Alexander look at it. Tho English document doosr.'t indicate this and I can't read tho Qormon. No objection, your Honor. £ 6 Jur.e '?-y_J v lC_5_lJ(*l-y (Int., JrPTWa) C-urt I IP. 3'IHEaCIB: In th*t c»ae, subjoct to the Tribur-f 1 1 e per- risai-n I vrnlrt like to ro>d the litter, I quote: “Iro« 1937 Fr-fiBBor Dr. ^llhcla 9lof< lbocck wps ay eupori-r et thi clinic of I r*f . tppinfer, vrad C 3. In Karch 1938 I wps t' he dls- aicBcd fr;a the clinic fer =y outspoken pntafonlsa tcvprds nMlon*l aocilisa. Professor 5 ic.~c lbocck stood up for a in the s et helpful sinner, end succeeded insofar th^t I w«s left in sy positl-n. In the course of the following ysprs I -es often nttnch.d, becouac I tried c ntinurlly to flfht <■ins» the irfpti Refine, end it w*p plwpyo Irof, BioclV.ock who helped ac. After the days of the Jewish Pogrca I hoprd. Dr. Bi«f«lbocck soy to r eollerfuc whoa he know well: "I will not trkc prat in this, this is too ouch for ac, wc dn n't wpnt this." "X wrlto thc-e lines freely »nd without c nstraint, in cr^tltufiC f-r the *sf1strace which BicrclWck fpvc ac fr-.a 1938 until the tiac of his Km tray Scrricc (19*1)/ The next d-cusent I tubait is * certificate froa the Medic*1 University Clinic, Professor Dr. Kcllncycr, which is pore 96 of J>cu- aent Book I. 7JC FR1SIDUT: ht document nuaber is this! IB. S-l.IHBAUlP: Lxhiblt 6. TW FPi-SIHJi7: Jh*t Arcuoent nuaber do« c u beer? IB. buabor 2/. I bee y ur » radon. KB. HiBDT: Hpy I Psk c'unscl if it cratrins * Jurot? IB. SlilJBALUt: Xr. Hprdy, this is » certificate of the Univer¬ sity Mcdicpl Clinic. In order t' 1 acit * possible ''bjcctira by the Iro- necut-r I hov, returned this tistia'-cy t the Ir’fcsr'r with ra order t' return it to me properly certified la-.cdirtely. *Jnf rtur.ptely this letter hos n t yet c'=c bpek since the npil t«*kcs p v ut r frtrifht, but I would like to *ek thrt it be "daitted provlsi-nolly until the s^-rn certificate is returned t ' ne. «cturlly it is raly r University Clinic hepded by Fr'fess-r Ecilaevcr, rad perhaps jr'u ''ill be food cn-u.~h t' shew this t' the President. 9673 6 Jure .•-7_M_JjC_5-2_ 1 'plojr (int., Ir-nk®) C-wt I X2. HAP.DT: The doooacnt V® nr* jurrt. “71 PRISimr-t The Mbwsl -111 adr.lt the drcurxnt provi sir re¬ ally subject to tho correct certificate being added Inter. IS. S-XimOBs I don’t even want to read the whole document, only the first paragraph! ■l nude ths personal acquaintance '.f Unlr. Prof. Dr. Jilhel a Belglbocck of Vlonna, nt lecture® given at iclentlflc acctlng®. I h*vo known hi® scientific works however, for a lrng tlae. He drew particular attention to hlcself through hi® excellent work as * pupil of the on®t pronln«nt German internist, Jr f. ip-lngcr. In particular, his resenreh Into the effects :f vrricus vjt-nlna and lnt'- tho pathrw loiy of the liver and cplAcelo Kopatitie hr® aide a grert inprosci n. Iref, Botrlboeck 1 ® doubtless raong the =>■ ®t promising reoerreh work¬ ers In the field cf lntcrarl nedlcino. I kr.-w aleo, thrt Prof, fcpplng- cr always spoke <-f hla In terns of the highest regard." tfc Iw, let’® e-rry o RJ wi trees, whet showt y-ur allltory ser¬ vice, h-w did thrt progress? A In May of 1941 I was celled up Into the Gcr-an Air 7'.roc as n Medical Soldier, and z? basic training I passtd In Baden nerr Vionnr. In August of 191 I becamo a nn-cr Missioned officer, and I w no «ont t* tho air firce h-srltal rt *cl», Au®trlo, and I wr® promoted to n n- e*>nrls®toned efflcor corresponding to ehe rank of sergeant, and after sorvlng in the rir force hspital of Vienna for a short tint I went to the war college at t-ecr In 1942 rnd then In August of th* sen*. yc«r I loft f-r c aotorlscd c:np«cy In Russia. I remained *>• re until tho end cf 1943. «i hrt duties did you have la Hue1.-7 A I headed th«. lntcrarl ward rf a field hospital. Bid yen hold the position of a ®ecti a doctor? a Proa point of discipline, no, I woe kert on the list "a i»3»l3tpnt t' the surgean. £674 6 Jure 47-MJ«C-5-3->Ul y (Int., Pranks) Court 1 H *nd -here did jru fo fr'= Suasiaj a Subsequently I *r« transferred as »n Mililrat t' the internal ieyrt-ert <-f the air f-rce hospital at 3runsvick, and fro there In K«reh of 1944 vent to the war hospital at Taravist, Italy. H So rren In Brunawiek y~u didn't bco-r.c department medloal officer? A Bo. i And you didn't receive that title In eplte ~f three year of •crrlcc and alth-ugh y-u were a university pr'-fceoor and already had beta admitted f->r pr'ftet'-rehljT a It wrt only lr. March 1944 I bec-nc an Independent oceti n medical officer for tho flret tine. % In the indictment yo arc described ae an caaultcat medical officer of the air f rec though? a I vat never the cnsultant to the air free. Admittedly at the bcylnalny if 1*44 I had been aarn-rked for that petition in tho Parachutlet Arny, bu* fc-r rcar-ne which Pr-fcaa-.r Dr. Slcvcre hat deecrlbcd hero a y-un^r oellca/-uo of nine wo# preferred. k So you didn't participate in *ny meeting, partlculnrly n'no af the mooting Bontloned hero in thta trial, la that rlkht? A Tou mc«n the meeting, the eorvreaa 't the aaeiatlnr coneul- tantat •4 Tea. a I-u arc ri^ht. I didn't oarticipa.to in any ono cf thoac acct- iaca. \ Did y-u have any contact with y-ur fcllcw defendrnta before this trial. a I only know Profoaaor Handloaer durln,: the yeara of 1939 and 1939 worked in Vienna where h*. waa the military diatrict medical officer, and. I alao knew him llatcniny to lecturce cf hit occasionally, but I do not believe he knew ac, becauac he probably impressed me more pb a genernl than I impressed him as a civilian. Of course I knew 8675 6 June 47-X_JjC_5-4-K*loy (Ir.t,, Pranks) Court I Pr fces-r Schmcdcr, Chief ncdlcal officer, toy naae. He v*s ay highest superior. The first tine I sw hi- personally was when I va ordered tc v-rk on experiaeats and reported to the nedleel inspectorate. It w»s dor* toy noens'of the cocroc torief military report for duty. It was in that occasion I net Dr. Becker-Treyseng and later in October 19 *a, Dr, Schaefer, as the evidence h»e already shown I had r toriof e-nference with Xr, Slevers In Dachau end I didn't know any other of ay fellow defendants before, <4 Xell, X think X can conclude the chapter regarding your charac¬ ter and personality, and in order to save trouble to the interpreters a nur.toer of testimonies and certificates hart n-t yet been submitted by ns. How, let's pass on to the question of the order, when did you receive the order to cr.rry out seawater experlacnts? SB FShSIHiT: Counsel, before proceeding with thrt natter tho Tribunal win be In recces. (Thereupon a short roccss was trken.) 8676 Court So. 1 6 Jus 47-J»-7-l-EHX-Xeehan (Brovn) IH* KABSEALt The Tribunal Is again in session. Trie. PriSin.iT: Counsel cay proceed. 3T IE. STZIi^AULE (Counsel for defendant Seiglboeck): <<• Witness, ve shell turn no- to the second chapter, to the wiestlon of cilitery orders. When did you receivo the ordor to carry out soa voter evoeriaents? A. Today I cannot give you tho exact date vhon that order reached ce. It oust have been the siddle or end of June, probably the end of June. Q, At that tine voro you already told tho purpose of this order? A. So, the order cece to ay chief phyeiclcn at Tarvisio, a tolo- typei this toletype told =o to report icoodlrtoly to the kedlcal Inspec¬ torate In Sorlln. There vrs no reason for this order In the tclutypo. I vas side at the tiao the tclegran arrivod. I thought at first that I vculd be collod to gvt the position of a consulting internist, which had been prouised ao; hovever, since ths rebuilding of =y dspertnent in tho “arvlsio hospital had Just begun, ! asked py chief physician to toleohono to Berlin and if possible get porsission for ac to eti*y In thc’hosoitnl in Trrvlslo. Ur. Taegsr, cy chief physician, then callod 3erlin. Ho vns lnforced that I vas not being tranaforred for tho reasons I had thought but that I vns to carry out acicntific experinonts for tho cco- ciasion froc the hedioel Inspectorate. I wi to get preclso dotalls about this in 3erlin. At any rate, I vas to get under vay inaedlatoly to get to Borlln and a fev days later I vent froc Italy to Borlin and rooortod to the Kedlcal Inspectorate, as ! had boon ordered, ond there I vas directed to see Dr. Boekcr-Freys*ng. Q. When you had not knovn theretoforoT A. Whoa I had not knevn thcrctoforo, neither personally nor by aaao. Q» What did Dr. Becfcer-Frcyseng tell you? A. he told =« briefly first of ell vhet ves afoot and then took ao to Dberstarrt Dr. I-.ers froc vhoc I received the forcal order to take over the carrying out of those exnorinents. Court So. 1 6 Jon 47-h-7-2-IEi-*«oka-n (3rovc) V 2i4 yai accept this order without any opoositlon on your part A. After I had been lnforocd exactly what was going on there, I Loaodictely faxed perclsslon to carry out the experiments In ny denert- nent In Icrrislo. I vested to carry then out on eoldiore who would volunteer for thee. Z alto said that S did not v«nt to carry out exoeri- noatt In a concentration eecp and gave aa =y reasons for this, acong other thing#, tho fact that It sscaod to oe aore practical to carry then out In an Institute vhore tho nocceetuy laboratory fecllltloe -tro avr.il- nble. Of courea, I could not expreee very explicitly rgr ocreond opinion* regarding concentretlon caepe bocrusc In 1544 In Gcrnany that not •0=othing that one Just did. I vee told that the Hodiccl Inspectorate had originally Intended a hospital to be ueod for thoeo experLicnte and I rooo-.bor very exactly there vae trlk of Brunswick; X r as tabor thle for a poraonel roeaon. Sot to long ago I had boon working In Brunswick In the hospital and It vould have plotted ne greatly If In thle way I thould hrvo had an opportunity to eoe ay frlcnde there again and conaoquontly X nuch rogretted that thle plan vae not carried out. Q- 7or l ^at reason vaa your proposal that tho sxpsrlr.ent* be carried out In Tarvlelo turned down? A. Ihe reason that Oberetnrxt Dr. Kor* gave no, that le the roason he expreeaed to ae, vae thet the very aggravated situation on all fronts did not perr.lt keeping eoldlere In hospitals longer than wee absolutely necossary for their convalescence. Thle wi shortly after the beginning of the Anglo-Ar^rlcon invasion. He pointed out thle fact to no specifi¬ cally and asntloned also the fuehrer ordor about vfclch I had heard already, that very strict neasures were to be applied In Judging vho vns to stay i n hospltale. for Instance, we had to releese fra: the hospital persons sick with gastric disorders oven before they were healed. 8676 6 Juno-y-FI^>l-Pria_au (Ir.t. Brewn) Court Ko. 1 V.'c had peo ph. with gastric ulcers who wero absolutely in need of h_s- pit^l rju. „'c ted 13 take theso people Ir.-a the h saital -nd sent thwa to thj so-called *st«ach batalli.na." Thoao were coapcnios cx> pj»;d a lcly of p~rs na with gastric ulccra wh_ received a special diet but nevertheless did full active service. P>r exrs-plc, there waa auch a etaoech cocpony stationed near Tar- viaio which in iull active survic. coebnttlng partisans and I r^riwr vory well that fra thie stoat eh c «p-ny wo frequently at the hospital received cases of gastric hen^rrhnge in the surgical dep-rtraont; wound¬ ed 8‘ldiera before th-y wen, c Uplotoly healed were put inti the so- called convalescent cinpenies. W« had difliculties again end again when we had hepatitis caeca wh kept relapsing when we released thus because the liv-r ngnin relaps¬ ed. Th-t, in renoral, ica the situation. \io did not act according to purely nodical .r acientiiic principles but acted aiaply in orders that were dictated by necessity, lhnt was the .actual situation in 1944 at the tiae I was given this rd«r .and fir this reason I regarded this reason giver, to by Oberstarzt Mur* as a justified -no. Q.- N u, witness, did you say s o-thing else to escape frm this asslgnoent? A.- When I realised. that tho l ection of the oxperirvonto c -uld not be changed and since I did not want to go t> that ch-son 1 ecti n, 1 asked aeckor-Froysong t Send ae back t Tarvisi -nd to C-onisslor. ny deputy in Tarvisio r .ho was also an internist with th. carrying out >f these oxperioonts. Beckwr-Freyseng .-nowore. that it was too Into n^t to change anything. ?r:fesa-r Zppingor had r«-c.mended ac cs a suitable ■xp-rt. Beckoie-Frcyseng said that ha hrc supp sed this h-d beer. t r.o *ith ay pc mission, That, however, w-s n t actually th- case. Becker Freyoonr said that he hiaself was n t ‘pleased th-t a c.nc_r.tr-. ti r. c-iro had been chosen .as the 1 c -ti-n ofr the oXrx.ria-r.ts. K .v.v.r, he w-s 6 June-’A-FL-3-^-PrL :e?.u (Int. 2rjwn) Court Nr. 1 c r-vincod that this problca of see distress ted to be solved boenuso tie nany rua^rts that he had received in the last time a-do it imperative t a lv« these oribl^as. He told ». that I h*d been >rdorod to carry out the cxp.rimcnts. TMa was an rder fr a higher up. It was just as binding n hia as it was nai; nnd more,Ver, I ted already been n.oinated to HLaalor as tho person 'ho would c nduct tte experiments. Consequently, it w uld be imp 3sible for a* am to withdraw. I then naked hia whether I was to understand this as a strict mi¬ litary order rn' he answered "yes." Nxi, in tte year 1947 it is perhaps r .~t quite so oaay to understand that in the year 1944 it was abs lutoly ixcossnry to regard a military -rdcr as binding, that ne did sj, Q.- Then it was Pr.'foes.r Dr. Spoiler that pr-posed you? A.- Yes, it -.ins ho. Q.- Had you previously spoken ab at this natter with Bapinger? N . Regarding everything that happened before I arrived in 3-rlln I kncti nothing white.ever. Eppingor, -a he told ae Inter, had unterud this wh.lo affair jT had attended this conference with tho in- untim >t carrying out the experiments at his clinic and f'r tlr.t roa- oan he wanted .Vj of his assistants ti make the ojqjerLaants. Since it was a military assityvwnt ate since 1, as the only -no of hia older assistants, tt-s c neater A tte Luftwaffe, hu orop-sud ae as the person to make the exporia-nt. Q.- Did -'ou, h wevvr, pert *ps, Lat-r apeak with Eppinge-r ao ;ut this assigia^nt? A.- Between tte, time A ny arrival in dorlin *ind tho actual bo in¬ ning A tho axporlaonts, I was ace in Vienna and, of c urse, soolfc with Sppinaer re^rrding this cuesti n. I '*id n.thing to conceal the fact that I was ver- unhappy t have iec--iv.xi this -rsirr.aent. teacher t Id me that 1 r the ab-vu -v-nti r.ed reas ns he had pr n.sed x. ate, -r r- ver, to said that he expected ne t carry ut these .xperiaents ut G680 6 June—M-FTr-S-3-?ri-A.cu (lot. 3r*n) C. -JTt Nv. 1 in perfectly irrx-cccblo aannsr. M-ro ;ver, he srif it was neither Ills reap nsibility n r had it been his intent! n that I sh.uld be assi.jwd t Dachau. Ke had neither prjp.Sed that n;r had he been asked his api- ni n in that -r.ttor end, as a natter A feet. Dr. Eppinger had rtasjlu- t-ly n tiling t- < j with the ch.'ice f Deichra cs the l catin A the ax- jKrlicnts A A iris ners as thb experl \.r±? I subject. Q.- what t;.«i had his intenti -ns beun? I have already said that ippingor wanted tv carry »ut the ex¬ periments -t his clinic and tad already agreed n that with’Sirany and Berka bof-rc 1 vonfc to Berlin. D:.. sriI*.3AlTu.: !!r. President, in tnis c nrx-cti n 3 should like tj put in D-cuaer.t 12, page 26. Ihis will be Exhibit Hi. 7. This is a letter free a then iear.le d-ct.r at tho 1st Medical Clinic — naaoly, Dr * i shall read the ®-c nd pcragr.aph frva this: "As assistant i the 1st Medical University Clinic in Vienna, I tad the jpp art unity jf attending tv a port A the report f Dr. 3oi$l- b-eck an his w rk at Dectau sutnitted ta Pref. Dr. Eppinger. On the >ccasi-n A this c jcTvorsr.ti .n. Professjr .Dr. Beiglb-eck generally can- J. m~d the principle A the perf raar.ce *1 scientific ex-xrtaento in c.ncentrati n crjpa just str.r.;ly and at tho sane tine roprscched his chief, Prjf. Dr. nppir.fer, f-r electing hia I r his wvrk. Thereupon Pr.f. Dr. Spoinger assorted that he hr.’ nat nxainatod hin. "S xe sunths later, 1 ng after the terainati-n f the uxn-ri unts at D_ctau, he frocuontly talked in ay presence ab .ut the uxperL^nts at Dachau t. Ger.tan and f .reign physicians and nurses. Up n .ay rc.iark that the86 experiments surely were Ushraeehb ex^rio-nts and ttaruf-re "=.cret, n they w. rut intended f .r evory ne’s ears, Pr f. Dr,-finger r-pliud n. c.uld frankly spe-.k nb:ut then as n-case A death has c- aurred with tho seawater experia-nts rjvl .alsm that n- experimental per- s r. tad suffered any Seri.us consequences thr u'h the experiaent s*. ~.-t th-re vms r. reas n tv aa.ke a secret f it." • "631 6 June—M-FL-6-i-Priatau (Int. Brown) Court Hj. 1 3T If.. SraKP.JHii Q«- .itn:ss, it mobs t- am I detect a slight cpntrndlcti n here. Ttw u-ct .r who write this letter states that Eopinger had r. t n siiir.twd you but y ai just s-id that ho eid* A.- I think ttore is c aisundorstanding bore, bhen I jbjsctod. to receiving this nssi na-nt, £pping*r said t- m litorally, "It is n t fault that 'j u h-.vo beer, assigned t > Dachau." N w, apparently. Dr. Spiesa' waphnais should fall r. the •. rd "y u." H wev-r, the emphasis A whnr Dr. Sppingcr sold should lie r. the word "Dachau," Q.- N-w», did jr JU accept this aasi^raent with ut aakir.g further of- f rts ;r Jit. ym into Jther eff.rts to otcapo fr..a it? A.- i.o a. Last att-opt I a billed ay chief physician in Torvisio and -akor' hla t request ay return. I h ■pet 1 th't such c request throu.;h p.roy channels Mould lead t. ay return t Tarvisiu. *s Dr. Jaogor has tes¬ tified here, he di ’ ao. H.wever, he had no succpsa. Q.- Now, in tho cr-aa oocialnation Ur. Hardy will certainly way tj y u; "Sure, you di-n't w-nt tjg-t Dachau because y >u c-noic’.oruc’ the experiments unnecessary .at all." Ia that the tive f.r y.ur attitude. a.- «s I gradually becaav. a;rv and *.:re experienced in the av.-nti n f aan water experlaontati n, I cr.-iw, to think that th- experiments woro n;t unnecessary. Court So* 1 6 Jon 47-K-9-l-*EK-Cook (Srown) Dr.- Beckor-Jreyscng, on the basis of various observations end experience on the part of the £»err«j air force and navy, informed ne of the urgency of the sea water problen and pointed out the unfortunate feet to ns that precisely In the problec of alloying thirst we had Schaeffer's preparation but the Introduction of this preparation was apparently going to run Into insumountable difficulties. Therefore. If ye didn't succeed la Introducing this preparation, we had to know what sort of advice we would give a person vfco found hlnself In a state of sea emergency and under these oircunstencee I considered It ny duty to work on thoso oxperlr.ents. If ! were ordered to do so; I not only considered It a r.Uitery duty which I had to fulfill anyvny but It was also the kind of a auestlon tfclch concerned =e as a physician. At that tlno I had not been lnforned about the foregoing ovente of this affair, or at any rate was lnfomod of It only very superficially and I know nothing about the Intrigues of the technical office as they hove been described here. I knew nothing at that tine and fren ny point of view I saw tho natter as follows: Both Bccker-Froysong and particularly Profossor Spplnger told ne that ve could assuoo that the Schneffor ncthod would not bo Introduced under any clrcunstanccs bocause tho technical office declared It vus lnposslblo for reasons of lack of raw material. However, If the Schaeffer nethod cwxld not be Introduced, then tho ouestlon etlll ronalnod open: le It better for a person In son distress to drink nothing at all or should ho drink sea water and If ho drinks soa wator Is It expedient to give hin tho Berka prepare tion? Begardlng the cueetlon of the effects of sea water thorc had been up to that tine no systenatlc scientific Investigations cnrrlod out. In tho neantlno such Investigations have been carried out and # the results becano known, but, of course, e problen that is solved In 194? cannot bo viewed re of the yeax 1944, In the sar.e way that you night reproach Hippocrates with not being fanillar with nodera train surgery, and it 1 e ouitc understandable why fron the nedical point of view this nroblea had been greatly neglected, because in tines of perce thore 8633 Court So. 1 6 Jua 47-fc-9~2~£EH-Cook (Sr>n) really vbi no problem of sea distress anynare. The greet liners had solved their drinking veter problems but the wer, both navel end air, suddenly made this problem a very burning one, not only for the Gorman Vehrnncht ves It a pressing problec. Th-»t can be seen frer. the fact that at precisely the sane tine vhen we were concerning ourselves with this problem, l.e., at the tine vhon I received the order to work on •he problen, experiments In that direction vere being carried out in A-orlca, and It is a great tragedy that we learned with this work too late. If It was Intended to decide whether the consumption of eoa vator was good or bad and whether It is good or bed to add so-.o dextrose preparation to It, then this problem had to be solved on the basis of fcasaa oxporl.ttats. There vrs no other wry to docide It. Q. I road through the indictment yesterday and the ouoetlon occurrod to no, couldn't you have contented yourself with animal experi¬ ments alono? *, I think I can state that vory briefly boca.uso Professor Yoll- herdt has already explained the essential nattors concorned hore. Thoro Is no laboratory experimental nnlnel whoso sodium chlorido motabolien and water metabolism can be compered with the human. Herbivorous anl- nils rorct to salt much differently than err niv.roue anlnrls, or an anlael like tho horse which ocrsolros a gr«.r t deal contrary to tho dog which dooe not svoat, end how specifically a cat rc cte. So far as I know, thoro have been no very exhaustive exporlmcnts to invest If'to this matter but X should have been only too girl to buy o-nsorlmentnl animals for this purpose in order to escape from that nssign-ent. The essential reason was that the human boing Is tho only living bolng which uses salt not only as food but elco uses it as eoice, and for this reason tho human being is adapted to the consumption of ouitc different ouantitles of salt than arc any animals. I later saw that America® scientists when they completed their studies on sea water reforming an2al)that 8 thoy explicitly noted that with dogs they had to use not n throe percent but a five percent salt solution in order to got aporoxi- C6C4 6 Jan 47-H-9-3-IEK-Cook (Brown) natoly th« aan« reaction aa a fcunan would here. 8635 6 Jun-J{-J£3-iCi-i-Grcss (*nt. Brora) Court Ko. I. Q iir. Resident, in order to corroborate what the defendant hae Juat a aid I wish to put in a docirjcnt uhich will bo Sxhibit 8. This ia on page 71 of Docuoont Book I and this is Docic^nt 20. This ia an extract froo the Vienna .fcdicnl Weekly of l$!Vl9U6 regarding physiological effects of the drinking of undiluted son. water. I shall re? d only one sentence free this docaao.it, the fourth line - "It was necessary to give dogs a $% eodiiuj chlorido solution instead of a 3.5£ one, in order to ostablidi an oxpirinental situation analogous to that of Qjin# * However, weren't these ox^rironta enrriod out in this .ray in or'’or to accord with scientific regulations? A Tho jroblocs of tho water and salt notnbolisa, of course, bring up nany jroblcss. So fer as bop. ./ator was concornod I know of no writings on undiluted sea rater. Tho first papers that I nan thjro, which I Later realised to bo tho first in this field, vorc those of Dr. Sch ofor which war- given to ai. Proa then I could see that Dr. Sohaofor had dono all the prulinin-ry work on this subject but I could also Suv that Dr. Schaefer, that tho knorlodgo th-t ho had derived fron his oxporisante werj not relevant in any way for hunan brings be¬ cause, for ins tare o, Schaefer discover,! that rabbits fed with barloy oats cm live for an enormously long length of tine in spite that they arc. drinking sea water. Ho gave ttaa daily dos^r of o.a rrat-_r which for hunm beings would hnv. aamuitud to l/2 to 2 no tors. Mover- thcloss tiwoo rabbits lived for woaks and weeks. In other words those results c annot bo transferred to hu=an beings. Q Did other scientists, especially those outside Gomany, also ruport on aniasl oxpcrLxntr in this field? A I think I havo air. ~.on drank such and such amount one day and either core or loss on the n_xt. In short, this was tho crc- parlmaatal urogram of a man who /-rhape vas a good dermatologist but certainly not a specialist in tfk field of metabolism. Simcy over¬ looked in his results sore very elementary and prirury thing, and unfort¬ unately ho ando an even mere unpardonable arror, namely ho did not find out how soa water worxe alono and connected everything he observed to tho use of tho Borka method. If h, had not overlooked tho most prinary necessity of having a control group I know for certain no man vould bo indicted for having carried on sen water experiments bocauoc then tho tragic error would not have occurred vhich in the last cons-quenco sot tho 'hole v-Lancho in motion. Berks vont to Eppingor with Sirony's experiments -nd told him that Sirany's oxporirxmts had proven that finally sea water is potablo end secondly that it is much loss lt£uriouc than cthon.iso. Bertha, like many char La tans had unfortunately certain nug- gostivo lnfluenco on his environment, rnd I boliovo that to cooo extont Eppingor foil under this influonco. Whon I visited Vienna I discussed this whole problom with Profosscr Eppingor in all details and I askod him for what reasons ho was r^com-oni ng this preparation at all be¬ cause choaic lly tho Borin prepor-tion c-nr.ot c'mngo son wat^-r at nil. That was pcllucidly clear and Schaefer who - as a chemist rnd fortunat¬ ely npproachad this problem only from a chemical point of view var por r fcctly right, of courrq in repudiatin'- the 3»rk:. method 10 Q 2 . C6CC 6 Jun-tt-ie-ll-i-Kalcy (Int. Braun) Court No. I. In Eppingor's cm the situation was scaowbat different. Eppingor had heard constantly fron both Sirany and Berks and it had been confirmed in Berlin that Schaefer's excellent process would, under no circur.- atancaj be introduced. Eppingcr, of course, was no am who said to Ua- 3 -If "if I have n c'nenic d. dosalinating method on tho basic of the Schaefer procedure then that would be worse than cy putting a little sugar into the water." Eppingor always told ao personally, of couroo, tho Schaefer nuthod ie bead and shoulders above this other r*thod. Thor* con bo no discussion about that whatsoever. Tho only thing that could bo discussed now was that if tho Schaefer method was not intro¬ duced the quostion re reined opon, .as tho Berks preparation was not in a position to giro at loaat slightadvantegos. And no*’ tho tragedy rf which I spoke previously cocoa to light, because Sirany did not havo any control group that drank only sea wr.t r, in other words didn't do what tho FTosocutor was so outragod about boforc, namely ns ho did not givo pure sa.a water, for this roa.son th.ro was no basis for comparison. How, Eppingor saw in Sirany'a records of tho experiments that one of tho experimental subjects noachod a concentration of salt in tho urino as high as 3 pur cont. Soa water has about 2,7% of salt. If tho kid- noys can acccoodnte this concentration than about U or 5 ccs of trator nust bo added fron tho body daily. But experimental persona, howovor, nust givu much aoro water than that because it is absolutely nccossary for him to socroto urine, and in order to oonbat thirst, and it is by • drinking more that you do combat thirst. Now, literature has always assorted, and this can bo soon free all textbooks, that tho maximum salt concentration in tho kidneys is 2 por cent. Eppingor relied on those statements, and consequently ho can bo pardoned for making toe error of construing tho higher concentration of salt in the urino as a consequence of the Bertha preparation. Since Berk-itit contains vitamin C and citrate acid, aid since it is known that vitinin C has ar. effect cn the kidneys and thar_- are many papers on that subject, so Eppingcr thought that it was impossible that Berkatit teas having 6 Jur.-i?-MB-ll-2-3fcIoy (let. 3rcwn) Court Ko# I# rjch an effect on the kidneys. It i^sn't as if Eppingc-r was tornonted by a vast curiosity, or rather it was not as if Eppinger was tornonted by an e no me us curiosity, but because of this curiority wanted to push US concentration camp ireates into an experiment. It was that Sppingor was asked his opinion and he based his opinion cn difforent presuppositions than that appear tcd%r, namely on the presupposition that tho Schaefer nothod could not be introduced because of raw material shortages, and • from tho jwoly nodical point of view ho could not shoulder tho rosj-on- sibility not to tako this possibility into consideration, this problem which had to cone to his attention by Sirany*s experiments. If ho had founl this suspicion confined, then this of feet that ho thought tho Borka method had, would have prolonged tho life of persons who had suffored ehifwrrock for a fow days. This is the sort of thing that is characteristic for s clinician and not fer a chemist. And if Sirnny had nrt, modo this mistake in conducting his oxpcrlnonts then also tho oliniclan wauld not havo Q»lion victim to tills orror, but then that Ep- pingcr was not ontiroly wrong was proved in ny exporinonts, nanoly that tho addition of vitamins does actually c lightly incrcaso tho concentration of salt in tho urino. That is psr'^aps quite inter¬ esting from tho theoretical point of view, but tho incrcaso in con¬ centration was so slight that it was unimportant from tho practical point cf view. This was tho reason why Ffrofosscr Eppingor and Dr. Schaefer were talking two difforent languages in this conference. One was spooking as a chemist and tho other as a clinician. Q Ultra ss, do you on tho basis rt your previous opinion accustom yourself to this Hoa? A I must say that I persenally didn't have confidence in tho Eorka nothod, but cf course as ny tc-cher whoso knowledge in tho field of atabolism I have tavr.n and respected for lli years admitted such a possibility then I hod to bo of the opinion th-.t his possibility did exist. Q .'itness, did you havo any opportunity of speaking yourself 6 Jan-iWe-lI-3-|faloy (Int. 3rcwn) Court So. I. with the sc often nontioned engineer Berko? A when I was in Vie nna I did havo an opportunity to nako Bcrka'a personal acquaintance. I saw him then for the first tine and discussed his disccvaries with hie. Nov, r. doctcent has been pit in cTidonce here which shows that Borkn was of the opinion that his dex¬ trous solution passed the salt through tivo body. Just what ho, as n technical chooiist, iregined under this torn "passed it through the body" I don't knew, but he was convincod, and this is hard to under* stand in a choriist, that apparently under the influence of thoso fluid acids corn coaplox compound took plnco between the sugar and tho salt. I also saw his laboratory in Vienna and ho had started a wholo series of experiments in order to track his favorite idoa down. Ho had also taken this idoa about this compound to ottor chenists and hod had then give !iin export opinions, which ho showed to ft-ofossor Eppingor. C»io of thoso export opinions nffiraod tho possibility of tho formation of this ccnpound. Tho nan who gave this oplnicn was a chenist of very considerable reputation. I think thoro was a caso of nlxod crystalixn- ticn. I inediately asked Bcrkr. whothor his compound was solublo in water and that cf course ho had to confirm, and then 1 said for us fren tho soiled, point of viow that is tho only important point. If you oannot nako this salt insoluble then thoro can bo no quostion of anything boing tossed through tho body, but I was spooking to deaf oars. Borka was particularly obsecssod with his idea, and I believe I can ex¬ press tho suspicion that even today he still considers his nothod bettor then Schaofor's. I If effort to pursuado hin to withdraw his cethod fron ccr.petition, so to sponk, was unfortwxately in vein. If he had done so, a groat ranny of those exporinents would havo unneoossaxy. bocone C691 Court 1 June 6-.-1-12-1-HD-Beard-Brown. 5. Shon you wore not convinced that the experlnents ware unnecessary In theaselvea? I can only deny this question. What struck ae as the oost Important aspect of the experiments wee the clarifi¬ cation of the problem, that had not been clnrlflad oxperl- aontclly; ncaaly, whether thirst Is better or sea water is better, and how big sea-water doses have to be. .is I wish • to ealphas 1 to again In 194-1, oven the great sea faring nations had no cloor knowledge regarding the effect of drinking son water. I personally, however, was of a different opinion, If .no has developed prop-rations which con provent s.Idlers from bolne injured, then It Is both Irresponsible and Incomprehensible to oonccrn onesolf at oil with the worso preparation. In ay own opinion the technical offlco w-s undor tho obligation to remove all the difficulties In \ ordor to Introduce tho Schaefer ajthod. If there was talk of sabotage when tnoso efforts wero boln 0 aado, thon I wot to say that tho ro«l sabut-ge was committed against humanity and health by tho attitude adopted by tho technical offlco; if that attitude had not existed thon wo could have dispensed with at lo-'et h-lf or at loaet two thirds of tho experiments and could have started a short expcrlaentnl series which would have been better fr,a every point of view, also froa the scientific point of view as the sucoose of suoh oxporl- aents had to bo doubted froa tho vory boginning, becaueo thirst cxperlaonts with sc aeny parsons cannot bo so closely supervised, undor whatever circ-astancos the oxporlaonts • are conducted, so that the inevitable oxpcrlaental mistakes occur. «nl it Is decisive that such errors are to bo expected in so many such exporlaer.tations. Because of -bo expectation of this sort of errors, the number of experimental persons was aadc ler^er from the beginning. Court 1 Juno 5-H-12-2-H0-Beard-Brown. I recall v.ry voll tact 3vCkcr-F roysoag toll sc at that tino we want t U 30 6 • uaay rooole because In the conference .f the 25th of May, one of the scientists, I do not Know wk. It v?s, drew ay attention to the fact that a larga number of experimental subjects would confuse the experi¬ ments by drinicing fresh water. Now, Professor, when you received this assignment with — the precise Instruction? how t> carry out the experiments, did you start on tnea loswllotely or did you ;rve to wait a while? «. I could rui begin Immediately but I stayed, I think for three weeks, In rerlln. ... Now, whrt :i; you do in those throe weeks, take walks? A. I used this time to c ncorn nys~lf with the questions that w nil oosc up in Judging sue: ex orlncnts. I did this 'ey re-ding 11 eraturo on the subject. I hod alrondy pre¬ viously c.ncerned ayself very a oh with the problem of wrter and 89lt metabolism. I had to work to n ..rent extent for this information, and since sea water o-nslsts of Belt and water, tnose are the two fundamental tnln*s one must know. Sut, of c urao, I did not wish to reproach myself for hav .n« overlooked e.aethln e that was already generally known, and consequently I vent to the libraries In Berlin and road thr uuh a very a rcct amount of German an. foreign literature on the subject. I sat there end took notes on everything tha: w-s known -n the subject at that time, and I do not believe that I overlooked anythin* that was accessible to ue at t.mt tlao. V Vitneae, did you write words of your own, that c ncern 'passives with this :roblen or ts least this general problem, If not with the s;eciflc sea wat^r -rohlea? £693 Ccurt 1 Juno 6->^-l2-3-HD-3e?rd-3rovn. In the clinic. In EpplBgor'e clinic, a groat leal of attention had nlre- dy boon devoted for years to salt metabolism, and slnco It la practically Impossible to separate aalt metabolism from water metabolism because they rra ao closely Interwoven, I of course, also concerned myself with the problem of water metabolism, and In several V'.rks of my own I tre t-d this subjeot or collaborated on It though not precisely fr-m tho aoa-wnter point of view. From the documents which I put in ovidonco whlcn lleta your 8olentlflc publications, will you owrhaps Juat lvc tho numbers of these works that rofor to that, whloh doale with this general subJoot7 Vork No. 15, wnloh states tho influonoo of Insulin on the min.ml aotabollsc; No. 10, on wat.r aotabtllsm nnu tho Internal soorotlen; No. 21, takes up the question of salt metabolism and three or four of ay works oonccrn themselves In -roa.t detail with the changes thnt take place In the mineral txt^h^llso under tho influence of vitamins. S. Did y^u find much literature on tho offoct of sor. water? A. In Gorman literature, I found -' a c: "In any c-eo, I know very well that he used *"ic dwj or Strou weeks he s-sent w-itlnj. in Berlin for zealously insult- in-.. who libraries in order to ^-ther still more accurate knowledge re a ~rdin_ the pertinent questions. I recall •; is sc. well, because I was then detached to tno forensic Institute in Berlin, end procured from ay chief at that tlm the ocrmleel n for him to uso oeo, though he, at that tine still hoped that he could -et away from that o88i e nmwnt. B .Then I should like to read from the top of the samo pc^o: ■3. quite frrnkly told me hie point of view, that he not ,nly tn u.ht such experiments unsjlt'>ble in a conoon- tratlon com out particularly also nad strong weighty doubts, though he hod been assured that only volunteers would bo used. 3ut hj, wno on principle woe against concentration c-r:e nevertheless wanted to hnv. not-iln* to di with them.• THE PRESIDENT: Hov t you finished readin. from that document? DR. STEIKB^'JER: Yes. THE PRESIDENT: The court will now be in recess until 1:30. (’Thereupon a recess wrs tekqn until 133C hours.) SW5 Csurt So. 1 6 Jus 47-A-13-1-JW-Jo b ter (Ciberall) A?ti?5CC3 SSSSICS (The hearing reconvened at 1330 hours, 6 June 1947.) TH5 KIBSHAL: The Tribunal le again in eeeelon. VILHxXK BIIGLSCSCK - 3eeu=ed DIEiCT IXAMIHAT10S (Continued) ST SB. STilSSAUS (Couseel for tho defendant Beiglboedc): Q, kit&eu, laet ve dlecueeed that In American literature very little was contained ebout nnking eea water potable — Concerning this chapter, I should like to eubrslt Document Nunber 21, I'hiblt Susber 10, pegee 73 to 89. That le a scientific study by a Mr. Label1 who is a aenber of the British hedlcal Ecsoorch Council. Ho vroto a study concerning reaction sfter drinking snail ouantitlos of soa vrtor. A. first, I should not like to read anything froa this docuncnt but I shall refer to it later. I should like to deal with another cuostioc. In this study it is vory clerrly orprossed that uo to tho yoar 1944 ir. nedical litcrnturo nothing was systonaticolly known ebout the results, the reaction of sea wr.tor. Q, air.ee you oentloned this, I should like to cuallfy that. It can bo found on page 73. There it soys, "During tho last yoar work has boon carried cut in the laboratory, for the Hodlcal Keeearch Council's committee on tho care of shipwrecked personnel (KP.C Vnr Mcaorandua So. 8), on the phyrtology of subjocts receiving the saao food and water as shipwrecked non in lifeboats." Cn page 13 - in ny document book on page e5 - Leboll oays - and unf ortukkt^s^I cannot bring his here because he hnpnons to be in Africa nov^vjtf^^beria - he says: "So referCdpLs heve been found in the litereturo to the uhytlolo- gicnl effects of /drinking sea vr.ter but the effect of rectal instilla¬ tion has been ©*e=ined in eoae detail. Ixoerinents have been reported VToj-j AXt^ann, and Kondi (1942) on this subject, and 3radish and hie colleagues (1942) followed the effect of instillation of sea wator not 9696 Court 3o. 1 6 Jus 4?-A-13-2-iHA-Toeter (Uiborall) o=Iy Into the rectus but also up into the colon." To elucidate thle, I should like to say that rectus 1* the anus and colon le the wider part of the anus. To return to our experiments, you described that icnadlately after being Informed about the order you ashed not to be sent to a concen¬ tration camp In order to carry out these experiments there. Vfcy ve re you so much against It, carrying out these experlnents thoreT A. I had not so such an objection to curry out the experiments but I was against tho feet tlrt these excorlnents should bo crrrlod out In a concentration camp. If these exocrlments had bccoco necessary, I vented to carry than out In a hospltel or In a clinic. Did you know about theso conditions In concentration cicps so that you wsro against thon? A. I did not know any no re about concentration camps nt that tlno than that they existed, that It v«i* an Institution whore political and criminal prisonero vers kept. As to vhat actually occurred behind that barbod wire enclosure, tfcrt I only rood after the wrr In tho nowsnnooro and tho roal Insight I gclnsd only through this trial. Tou think It It ridiculous that I say that, and incredlblo, but although I nysolf worked at the time In a concentration camp it was also under thocs circua- ttencos that Z had no opportunity of any kind to look behind tho ocono. Tho objections I hrd at that time against the concentration can© was based upon a fooling of sor.c sort which was causod prlrarily by tho fact that It %rs known to me free tho Austrian cross before tho Anschluss that strict rules end regulations apparently did not exist for that institution. In tho Austrian newspeoers at that time I could froeuentl^ read that tho treatment of inmates was bod. Ccceslcnrlly there wore rocerts about casualitlot that had occurred, end one said nftorvrxds that these peoplo had been shot Alio trying to escape. Cf course, thooe were newspaper reports end nobody, not exes in Austria, hod an opportunity to make sure whether they were correct. Added to that wrs the fact that Court So. 1 6 Jus 47-A-13-3-IE4-yotter (Ulbcrall) grti nelly the novo stopped in the Austrian press. The Austrian nevs- pepers gradually took up a nore defensive ooeition in their propaganda end in 19M, after the Anschluss had been effected, all nevs about con¬ centration carps ceased to be published and Whatever had been rerorted in Austrian nevspaoers vee described as an invention and ralicioua cropagande. , S696 Court 1 June 6-«-14-l-HD-3eard-Uberall. Then in 1341 I became a s-.ldler. Most of the tine I wt.b at the front for o long tine, a lunger period in Russia; there of course, one did not hear anything at ell about such natters opart from the fact that our duties os physicians consumed so ouoh of our time, that beyond that we hardly had any jy? rtunity to think about anything else. Q. Kr. President, In connection with this fact, may I refer again to t.io affidavit by Dr. Grthner, documont booh I, page 94, on the bottom of the page. Dr. Grthner says: ■If I said that 3elgLboock objected on principle to the soloc:ion of a concentration camp as site for tho experiments, thon it Is to bu attributed to the fret that ho Is an ldocllat throughout, and, on his port, would have rejooted every forcible method rnd every arbitrary ootion. Especially characteristic of this scorns to bo tho fact that he told no of oxcmplos, with which irresponsible 'generosity' tho detention lr. tho oonoontrntlon camp wne ordered. I rooall that ho particularly referred to tho medical studonts who woro allocated as prisoners to him for assistance. u Since I h~vo Just mentioned the word "prlsonor" I should llko to osk you, witness, wne It your opinion that no experi¬ ments should bo made on prisoners? A. That Is a question which Is Very hard to answer, and a question vnlch v s also discussed time and again by ay teachers. Cf c urse, from medical literature I know that such exoerlaonts on Inmates wero frequently made. I know, of course, the world famous Plague experiments, the fan us Loper experiments by *rnlng; and from dealing with vitamin research, I knew of experiments with 3erl-berl nnd Pellagra; and I knew froa dealing with liver Path logy, llv.r research, that in the year 1935, eleven criminals who 6699 *4 0 I ' urt 1 une e-A-14-2-HD-3derd-Cberoll. had bo jn sentenced to death were used for experiments In order t- test the reaction of a Llv~r poison. In Vienna vs vero also somewhat opposed to experiments with prisoners. I roaemb.r lr. tolhlns, that my teaohor Xos-rro , also violently rejected that idea. On the other -end, no has t admit, of course, that certain problems of medicine which are of utDost importance under certain o ire instance a require *r. experiment on human beings, whloh of course, entails a &ront rlsh. I believe, therefore, thnt it is extremely difficult to obtain ra .it;lt.de here yhlch would be decisive, and aonca thor- re no regulations by law, it la probably true that the research m-rn who, with the aut-orlzatlvii .ranted him by the leodorsr.lo of eteto, is glv^n th^ possibility, to coho auen experiments, nos to do that on hla own res .onslbillty, and to decide on his own now fnr tr.ls wr.s oom.atlble with ftla et:.loni attitude *a o physician. I, on my mart, was oioosed to it in my lnn*r moat footing, rtnd the attempt to, 3 vt eway from these oxo-rlaonts was mr«e by me, brsed on sy lnnwrmost fc.lln^s '•grlnst it, and I ocrtainly suff.rod when I realized that wna not oselblo for me to do. =ut, I received absolute assurance that the experiment exclusively would be made on volunteer subjects, and since, on the whole, these were experiments, which, if conducted correctly would not cnt -11 d-n^cr of Ilf 3 -nd that together wit.: the as-urar.ee th~t I would got vr.l.atary subjects, a ve me the pr.—requisite that ^ did not refuse to carr out cn orv.cr, an order which I could only lv*ve refused in e manner which w.--Id hvvo t..o most serious consequences for myself and my family. Let us deal further with thl questlbn of voluntary subjects. was it that t:ld you tn-t these suejocts were 7700 Court 1 Juno 6-*—14-3-HD-3eard-Uberall. all volunteers? That I would c et vol-nteere for these experiments, that I vr.s told on the occasion of the first conference with Dr. Becker-/reyseng. He nssured me of that. In order t. ' vc ms furth-r assurance on that point, immediately after arriving at Oaohau I ashed whether those conditions would he ho;-t. Dr. Slce^ener, at that ties, before witnesses,, assured mo tr.at volant: ry subjects would bo used for oo ex.ori^ente. Vhen I rc-.orted to the adjutant of the comp o mmrndont, I raised t..e question "^aln and I had him ”3euro no als’ once uoro that there w-^uld be voluntary a bjects. -then the experimental subjects arrived at Daohr.u o Sturabannfuehror of the 33 arrived to 0 other with then, who a>iarontly had accompanied that transport. I ashed aim a^nln If tr.oee people volunteered, ho ovnflrnud th t n c aln t o experiments. I -;do thcao inquiries ir. Dcchcu or. zy cwr beetuso it s.czed to nc to be c rv *Mt of course end for rctsons which : re to be understood t the besis of t*» exp lent t ions I hrve given Just before, *i. Die you hevc influence et til in the solcotion of tho piece where the experiments cere to teke pi- cc? Sc, ir. no zcnrxr t rll. I h? vc a tried clrccdy ftt ev rything concerning thcao experiments, everything drvn tc the list det: il of I 8702 i Juno *7—a.-If-2-O-ffk CTSbemll) Crurt :*o. 1 their execution, wos stlpuli*td before I *«s ever ordered tc take pert \ in then* •* Dld Torn have influence in the selection of the experiments! subjects! "• » 1 wtfl *=13 tt the medical ?napcctircte thrt r.rrtnge-cr.ta h'd bees =/de with the iS end that the S5 in tccordrr.cc with thcao crrtngc- sxnta would supply the oxpcriaentcl aubjeeta. I did rot hr re to worry cb:ut thtt. * v ° u order to find out rherc the exreriaoctcl aubjeeta ccae from end wbtt the apeelfic circunatcr.cc a erd conditions rere? Wo, that tlso wea neither e deoiaior. thrt I could here a o, nor did tho Luftwaffe* D * d y before tfc. t gypsies htd been u-odf a, rv 0 feet that gypsies were crnlrg I only found out in 2 re he u by the Cc-jp 0-^;, rdor. -ho vero thcao gypsicef a. They stro aoatly helf gypay people who hxd gypsy bl:~d but were not erectly vh. t one would expect r. gypay tc lock llko, c reel Ikingir- ien gypay, aty for inatcnco. They wero r.ot puro gypsies. ^>c os lor of the inalgnic they hed to uccr ’u black .The Stunfeconfuehrcr who brought thee, sold thet they were csoolal elements end rddrd thtt for veri-ua offonsea they ked previous criair.el rooerda. ^croupon I raked hia for whet kind of effeaaca, cr.d he acid their records htd not been for.:erded, but I could rely upon It, erd ;n thet occ»-alcn he- dao t-ld no bcceuao I htd geined tho iepresti on thr-t possibly t;* fee t of thclr deacon t uls the ccuae for their err cat end their irepria.-nnent, he to Id mo thtt gypsies vert no acre kept lr the eo ncer.tr: tl on cess 0 ' c recount of their dercort or belonging t- thrt rt.ee tv. t htd been the ceac prtrisualy, end then thoy rere ret ring c trorn sleeve insignia, end thet only ties® were still Interned who rere put in tho ettegory of en csccitl end cllegcdly cene free such fcrllies. I ah-old, » ref ore, 8703 6 June &7--S - -I5-3C' c fc ( Uibcrell) Court re, 1 llko to etherize ihi* I hrd no p.-ssibility to check on their records and I htd relied upon *-k' v that -cn hts toldro. I had elso received the esaig na ent or rather the cxclenrti n ef »hc instruct!-ns th:t I •eta r.'t to interest aysclf into any ether pr.blaroa -f the ccrcontri *ion coops that h d nothing to do with the carrying -f the experiments and the feet that ny own interests were in th;t direction, end tho assignment nedo it nuoh c'sier for ne tfc't I had to worry ab-ut c'thing else thee ny ctocriacntcl place. I, *kcrcf“ro, do not fed thet I as rcs-cnslblt either for tho selection of the nit co where the experinonts rcro carried rut nor f-r tho solecticn of those pcrs'ns who were used. m r. .resident, in tVia ccmeetlm I should like to refer to tho document produced by the .'rcecoution, Wo. 179. fr-o the act rx t.er dooincr.t book No. 5, rfccro Si* Gruppcnfuchrcr Neber stakes spccif- loclly about the cxptriraortj.l subjects, th/t aw: old gypsies, which is very importer t for us, had tc be healthy. These two terns I should liko to derive from thi » d:«uncnt — asocial end heclthyj th-t the eocoiels actually had to *c'r e black triangle cr.d rot o brown nno. -ith the permission ef the irrsccutor, I should like to show to tho Court free the Kogen Bock, — I could not have photostats node, bcccuao :f crurso tho so colors would sot ceec out, — but If the court desires to l ok at it it can be soon that thcro is e difference beacon the brown triangle frr gypsies end *ho bltok triangle for an asocial. Unfortunately , I here only one eooy. Therefore, I eannot subrite it in eridence, but only shew it frr illustration purposes. TKS uR2ilDlNh, i n this iretenoo if defense counsel naild prepare a paper containing these triangles end simply describe the colors, write In the colors, tho freo first, red with F end rod with S and next the Jewish sign, e yellow trienglc with red *rienglc reversed oror it, just describe thee in color. yn. HuJCYt May I ask defonac counsel uhr.k Ms purp sa is in lr>-r-d- ucing these v rirus *r‘angler. It scans to ne they were elabori tcly lTO 6 June 47-—S -15-4-C^lc(01berell) Ccurt Ifc. 1 described by tj» tcatiixay of Kbgcn whoa he we* boro or. the witness ■teed. - BISECTi Counsel chained that he desired to cell the cttentlon of the Tribunal tc the dlffcrerce between the br-tr. cnJ block end the Triburxl obserredthe difference in color. ZB. a»Ur®«31R| !*£y i elucidate briefly upon the objection redo by the prosecutor. My client is eherged with hewing emitted crirocs rgeinat hurxnlty. Control Counoll Lew No. 10 unfortunately does net contain e definition of crises against hurunity. It acess there is elso little dorwatio cad foreign, pcrtlculcrly American, literature c neerning the tern •crises egeinst hurrr.lty" cr *het ccn bs found, but it hes to be persecution (geinst pcoplo for politiccl or redd reasons. Thorc- foro, I went tc say thet re ere r.ot dcr-ling with rfoitl persecution, tut theso ere peoplo who fer other reeeone here been in tho concen¬ tration oespe, erd therefore waild here tho insignia of theso persec¬ uted for roes:ns of their rccc, but r.ot of those who rro persecuted beoeusc they woro e-neldercd cscoicl* I will ropeet thet lr ter* I Juat went to submit it to the C-urt now to support whet I heve arid. THE i rtSEETi -tuld counsel explain to »hc 'Vi bun cl your ur«5ar- stending fotha word ■csccicl.* 1‘rccosd, c- ur.aol . — CR. SrziNBmJcRi 'Asocial* la c terr., the concept of which la very well known even in the Unitod Stctes, porticul rly in the Uni tod Stctea end thet egreca ooeplctoly with -ur ooncopt 13 far ra I know It fr.'n Europeen literature. The oo*hcd applied la theThird Reich, of course, went ruch furt: or in ooplylng thet tern 'asocial' than ro used to do it. I vnr.t to put the same question to =y ollent, sinco he ccn answer it tr-c the nsdiocl point of view, but since the Crurt asked re about it, I went to state frankly cndoponly that in the Third Reich , of cour3e. thr t terr. was applied In the nuch wider sense then we know it fT's the metriccn erd French lav. Indicer.tally I heve here tho Austrian bock about ocncer.trction camps which I really originally 6705 6 June 47 -^--15-5-Cc-k (Uibcrcll) C :*_rt No. 1 lctooded to submit but I did not rent to dreg the nc=e cf Christ Into these proceedings. Tv e book res rrittcn by o Ceti'llc I'ritst sho w ta here in the cor.centrcti:» camp Buchenwcld end todcy he is e rycr e.fc Salzburg. -but the *aocitls at Buchenrcld those tsocicls who -ore my subject persons he says, the rest of theta were mixed from the h»micas proper up to the dangerous vegrant. They v or 0 the blrck trlrngle of an cscclcl. The numerous Jcrs were marked by the yelloc Deris star with differences *xde between political and asocial in¬ mates.* That can also be seen in fact frnc the color scheme cf Kogan's book wh ro he also had eddod the Star of David to the Jewish asocial insignia. -ith the emission cf the Court I should like to tsk my defend¬ ant, now would you like tc answer the question from your point of view. T15. ..iSIDE.Ti Before inquiring of the witness as to whrt his idea is cf the meaning cf the word 'asocial* the TVibuntl would be vary glad if you weld explain your legalistic idee of the nerd "asocial*. EP. Sti:'S.Uini ~e designated as asocial, the person who consciously co-nits cots ageinst human society and by theso acts is asocial, an enemy to occioty, that is tbs ocnccpt vro here. I bcliero in English it can be expressed by the terms, a-soelcl is cn enemy of sccioty. T!E iRiSIDS.T: You can proceed with the exerdnetix. TJEGE 3EEar*Gi Under your view cf ►he natter, is it your view that simply one isclctcd act of criminality might tend to bring a main into the cctcgory of rsocicl or do you understand by that classif¬ ication that type of individual or classof individuals who constantly s end persistently ere guilty of ar.ti-s*cial c-nduct? 8706 Court 1 Juno 6-j*-16-l-KD-Moehan-Uberall. DR. 3T£IH3/iU£R: Your Honor, If I cry bo permitted to tell you my opinion without that ay college on tho other aide Mr. Hardy will use It against ae, I wish to any that I personally at cf the opinion that one offense never makes any person asocial, one violation of the law, but that part¬ icularly in the caaa of gypsies we are ?ble to soke tho observation v-ry frequently, that we are confronted thora with real aaoclals; that Is with people who roaont with oil force to bo Included In tho normal process of work. In studying the problca of the gypsies I cam© upon a book which revers to that quality that asocial quality and I am "lac quoting fr>s that book In my dooucont book. It oxplnlnt to what extent tho gypsies themeolvcs hnvo contributed to term, that oonqopt of the gypsy pln 0 uo. It is o book published by tho Bavarian Government In 1905 and a similar book existed in Vienna. It Is a hand book for tho use of the police force in both oountrlos in order to ootobllsh the oltltonshlp, nationality, and family origin of the gypsies. Later I shall refer to that quootlon again. It Is Important because 3ol 0 lboock is not only charged with crimes against humanity, but also simultaneously for th>- same acts ho Is cnargod with w r crimes and war crimes, in my opinion, can only be oomuittud against allied nationals. Fr a that bjok, which I quoted In my document book, I should like t' .rove that It was just a asocial feature of tr.e gypsies that at ell tlmos tnoy deny th-;lr nationality, they dony their desoent tyid Just wander around. I an submitting this ns my opinion, however, not as the o lnl^n of 3elglboeck, who might not have the same, in order to ovoid any undue conclusl n on the part of *Hr. Hardy. I repeat, however, that the method of concentration 6707 Court 1 June a-16-2-HD-jiaehan-U'oarall. car-' administrations to consider people who were late for two days or three days, to consider these asccials, to dent unco then and to send then into concentration comps Chat I consider a uroat injustice. Do you h-ve that pas?a 6 o in the hook? Hr. President, for that curnoee I refer to A cuaent bok 2 , p‘ 5 e 105, document 28 , which I should like to eu&blt to the court cs exhibit 11. The original; v; -lch belongs tv the University of ^rl-n«.on, rnd whloh I have 6 return, I hove brought h-re. The ooy.y is certified by no and is n ncourr.te copy of the origin*! of this document, I should like tv olnt out thrt I hov~ copied .on..o 5 • ioh lndlo~tos where the 0 ; teles ooae froa, sec ndly, tnelr csooinl activities, wnicn rrve been terned the "Plo.Uv of c .e Gr'Bios 0 and thrt w. lch seeaa t me the coat Important and which I intend to \-ead namely on 3?,o 2 the first and soo nd ?cr = rc;hs: "The greatest difficulty arises in sec-rln^ o cenous .f gypsies. The majority of then cakv every effort to obeoure their identity thrvU^h false statements or thr u,.n r .retenco ,t ignorance. "The number of false census stntea-nts and of/icial certificates or. the r. rlsr. rc.istcr of births and doaths, -it do by thw 3 y".eiee, is v.ry extensive." >?.. : noy I lnqulr. of C.uncel by introduoln- “-•is d cun nt ?nd by nis statement he intends to a-cv the Tribunal thrt the word "ravels!" in this connection aeons e -rely thrt 2 ore n n^y.oo as^i"! 1 : he is r -- ey? DR. 57SIK3«jER: Thrt would be absolutely v-ron a t-. be . that opinion. I only ary aers,ns who were supplied for the -v ori;,nt- had riot beer, or'.a ht t the concentration c-nrs for rrciol reasons, but for reas ns of bo in consider_d C708 Court 1 June 6-»-15-5-har.-Jb.roll. -social, because ns the witness Dorn said yest.-rday and this zornln. slr.ee 13*2 there wore no Gypsies -.ersecuted on raclc.l rounds Tor the it 1c reason th~c German laws ns I shall describe In _ro-t detail In ay trial brief, the gypsies nro mentioned only twice In the lav for the protection of the Govern rice. In 1942 Hi--lor who was very .yeticnlly inclined • s -"do to believe that the gy-alea wore really the original typo of the Indo-ierar.ns, that they v.ere decendants of the original Indo-CK.re?ne and ?ro the iurc Indo-Jv.rfcr.n3 In Eur-oo and they wer. cr.eref .ro no lon..r sent to o ncontrn- tion c-c a, for rooicl reoson9. Is that sufficient, hr. Prosecutor? HR. H-JU)Y: On that b ale, I auat object to the dooucont as join, nbs lucely lnarturl"l to this case. 7} is PRESIDE: - ?: The objection la 'Vwrruled, the doounent will be admitted. JUDGE SE3RIXG: Dr. stelnb"ucr, I unlerst"hd also that oner lly t ..re w.-uld bo included vlt.'ln your concept of 'soolrls; r.^ucs, v^obonds, Idlers, drifters, wanderers, and lorfera who wander ab ut the c entry alio with no a • icrent hone, resoct-blo voonClon or visible s. uroos of 11 elyhood; Is that the central concept? DR. 5T£I!’3aU£R: Veil, that w-uld nean a t narrow Int r retnti.n. always, os-eclally today, when th.ro aro nilll ns of ..usen 'eelhjS vno h"vc lost their hoses and have wander around, that Is not s-f lclent for v-. va.icy. *’e in «ustrla prosecute only those wno rru nntl-soolrl, the plrp for instance. He hrs his nous.., llve6 well and Is still asocial. THE ?AE5IDEHT: Co-nsel nay prooeed. •709 Court 1 Juno 6-A-16-4-HD-Meehcn-Uborall. 3Y DR. 8TEIK3-UER: Q. VItnose, I should like to ask you what you, as a phyelolon, seen by or would understand by the torn "asocial"? £710 * Court So. 1 6 Jus 47-vL-17-i-^3t-?ri3cau (Ui'oerell) A. At far at I hav« noticed as a laynan in legal natters, thoro is no absolute legal definition for the tern of an "asocial eienent", red if tfcia vas done around the conference teble then, of course, vc vho are scientists cennot be biased if ve havo even less definite interoretatione or concepts of thet tern. In our books on psychiatry vhere vc discuss such natters the chapter on tho ouostion of "asocial' and "entl-social" eleccnts is one of thoso nost difficult to deal with. Speaking fron the nodical point of view, the torn "asocial" vould cover a porson vho in cost cases has an inborn, sonotinos hero dltary defect of his ethical instincts; that is, a typo vho not by reasoning but on the basis of instinct cannot abido by prevailing rules and lavs of society. furthermore, those people, of c^xrsc, do not liko to vork, aleo ono of tho rocuirenente of hunan society, and froc thoso tvo roots for the individurl there derives a vicious cycle. The nore crininal ho bocoaos, in tho widest ncaning of tho word, tho noro ho cocos in conflict vith hunar. society, so society, of course, tries to countoract that. Eo considers this to be rn injustice bccauso ho thinks that the donando of socioty axo unjust and inapplicable. Thcrcforo, ho considers hinself persecuted although innocent end continues to coruit further violations against lavs and regulations and that brings about tho tern of the "asocial" and "anti-social" as a sociclogic Urn rather than a -.odicol ono. Tho physician is only interested in thet cortein inn.r defect, tho lrck of a natural, healthy sense of ethics and tho fact that in neny cases this is hereditary; ,-od as birds of a ferther flock together and as Just the fact of vagrancy - that is the rosontnent against settling dovn, to the sar.c extent as rosentisnt '■gainst every typo of ccnuulelon - m belongs into that picture, it hapsens frequently that tvo asoclals got carried. Zvcn nore frecuontly they didn't get carried but they have children together and that tri^s it about that asocld families, entire r.BJcial families, coco into existence and on these fpcilies studies have been c. dc, especially in the united States, where as far as I know these £711 Court Jo. 1 6 Jus «7-A-17-3-*3i-?ri=eeu (Sibera11) studies here becooe very fen*is, and In these families one ear. find tho entire scale of examples which vc considered covered by the terr. "asocial". Chase fasilies distinguish thersclvcs in soce cases only by hating to vortc. Other nenbers of the fanily axe habitual thioves. A third cate¬ gory again nay be vagrants. The fourth type nay bo real criminals all the way to tho habitual criminal. Anong the faoale ner.bers of these fanllics prostitution is extremely widespread. All that epoorently cooes frx: sane psychological aberration which •ears to be the clue to the reason why theso Inclinations show to a dif¬ ferent extent In various families. Generally, recontn.ent Of every hind of authority is apparent. There rro :-»ny ar.ing then who nay have other difoctc of the Intellect but also racy who, apart fron an othicrl defect, hsvo a great-r or high dogree of intelligence. As far as I know - and X only know it fror. occasional reading of nedicsl studi-'s - in Gor acy especially the cuettiin of horedity of such Instincts wrs greatly ocpha.slsod, purely fror. tho r.edical point of view, but ho*- the lvga.l ferr. *r.s found that, of courte, I could not say. 0- Vitnoss, now wo can go on free the subject and I ask you after you receive! that order to carry out sea water ovoori ents you wont to Tachau*. a. Tos. * hen those exocri-.onts woro supposed to start, I w„ 0 ordorod to go to Tachau and install the laboratory thorc for the o^orl- ••.entn. Criginolly I had boen pronisod that that would be necessary only ti e very snail extent because et Dachau there w c s an excellent and vory extencivu laboratory available. In fact, I did not find ary thing thoro v*ich I could have used for that ourp-so and piece by niece, laboriously, I had to carry everything together. That vp 8 particularly difficult at that tine because .Munich, ‘dierc it night fcav c been possible to b rrow eouiorent, wr B just at that tins the subject of heavy r ir raids rnd frn that r-.oking her.p of rubble one could not get anything. 5. Vitnoee, what order did you get for the purpose of c:Trying cut the axporir.^nte? -"712 Court So. 1 6 .Tun 47-£-17-2-ZE:—?rineeu (Vartenberg) A. -ha order said that these experiments were to be carried out vith the instructions that four different group* were to bo included in tho experiment: one grrnp vfco vert supposed to be eterved tad suffor frs. thirst, another group vho received only eea w ft ter, end another grAip wfc j were supposed to drink *ep water together with tho Serkn preparation - that 1 *. vtre given five hundred th-usend cubic ccr.ti- aetor* each bccrus. in the cae of all of these groans one would have to count cn a loss of water end all of the would be subjected to con¬ ditions of nourishment which were unusual, s >r tho purposo of being ablo to decide h w much water is lost, a grouo would have to bo included also in tho wxocrimccts ~ho received a nomal mount of lleuld but who rocoivod tho sp.:o solid food as the other groure, and, in regard to this gr Juo which was /rlginally supposed to get ordinary drinking wr-tor, they lrtor received tho Seha.cfor wrtor in order by that r.erns to assuro oncsolf -ncc r.;ain that even in the orr.cticrl use of this water no cfcx nges of any kind became epurront. 7urthem«ro, as I havo a.lr*rd;’ stated, I wrs instructed oxjctly vhat observations were to be cade during those experiments and this was a rather extensive progran %4:lch gave us a. groat deal of v'-rk for that period of tin*. Very oxtenslvs blood analyses were undortrken, not In rogrrd t, tho amount >t tho blo:d tut to deter ino the different constituents of tho blood rnd vory exact urinelysos were renulrcd oo that wo could cake sure, to a vory large extent, vhr.t effect the charge -f tho water contents in the body would bring about. That is whet I was told. I did n-i, h/waver, the discussions of the ISth axd 20th which fctve ployed such pn important role here but I knew nly the con¬ ference -f the 25th end only to the extent tc which I wrs cncerncd r with it; nr;;oly, first, the unfortunate choice to c'nfirn no as being in chrrge of the experiments pnd, secondly, the regulations which wore edited there for the executi n -f the experiments. The purpose of the experiments was es follow*: first, I w\s sh'wn *'713 Court So. 1 6 Jus 47-A-17-4-iEh-?ri=eeu (Vertenberg) exrxrinents carried on so fax by Schaefer pnd Sir ary and I eleo vat given an opportunity to study the records of their croerinents. It wne pointed nit to ns ercressly that Sirary's sxoerinsnts vere inadacuato f x the reasons vhich I .have alrerdy neationed in pert end that they vere of the opinion that they vere in no vay sufficient to urovc tho prectical suitability of the Berk* aeth*. Above all this was so for the reason that Sirany only cerr.cd on the eroerlnent f<*r four days and the Luftwaffe wanted to have e nctfcod which c -uld bo used and would bo found valuablo, especially if sea distress lasted for a longor ooriod. em I 6 Jir>A-I2—l9-l-3aard (Int. Hartenborg) Court Sc. I. F:r tlir.t reason only such a ;»thod cculc oc introduced, could ba con¬ sidered for introduction. At that tiro, 12 days were requested as the nininui rocuiroaent to prove the value of such a nethod for tho reason that at that tirx several cases of sea distre® bocano known who w_ro saved after 12 days. So that I shall not be nisui.dorstood, tho roquiresent was that the notiurd to bo introduced could bo taken fer 12 consocutivo days without homing, damaging, the health of tho person, ihe conditions of tho oxporirout ;»ro, as far as poseiblc, to bo aado the sawe as threo existing in soa distress, but only in res¬ pect to the -mount of water and foodj on tho cthor hand, everything olao that is at a disadvantage during sea dietrose, that is tho in¬ fluence of tho client*, cold, boat, changos in the woather, otc., tho *iind which lets the salt of sea water, .affect tho person by forming a crust on tho sirinj tho inability to slo-p in tho rescue boat, all the so conditions of courso woro to provail during tho oxjvrinont:. I have discussed thoso questions with EwCkor-Froysong, thoco questions which vuru of importance f or ay experiments. Ho alec discussod tho theoretical basis. Ko called to ;jy attontion spocifically tho stato- cont of Schaaf-r which were given in sotao kind of a report, which was available in a typowriton cor, and also ho pointed out to no that Scha-for had made calculations about c Certain na-'unt of soa water th“t could bo toloratvd for 12 dayc, but, of course, not without causing changos in tho water oalarco. Tho quostion was not whothor smaller aucunt f sia wat_r could bo given for c longer poriod of tine, and -hothor with about 50C cubic contiaotors of son water, ono could liv- fer a certain period of tine. Our aviators, at that time, vuro provided with a very snail anoint of water supply which 3nst~d f or only t:.*o days. If now, one of then was out for eight or ten days core, drinking snail amounts of s-a wnt-r against his thirst, ho had thun, of ccure-, tho advantage not to jnd.ang.-r his health s,ri usly, I .ad h. c.uld survive at sea. The as-unptirn, f course, was also at that tir.u that tu Schaefer hr-..-rations would not be introduced. -715 6 Jua-4-!E-l9-2-£eord (Int. VabtoEfcarg) Court Ho. I. TToll, he told ne that this naxiroxu limit of 12 days was a dcsir.a'olo air. in sons fom or another, but it should net bo forced and in tho different experimental groups I should try to approach that dm to tho extent as I could take the responsibility free the nodical point of view examining tho persons. Wo thon discussed the queatim where tlio danger li;it to the less of water begins, whore ncrnally this bordcrlino is, and where ono could normally assume that life was ondangorod. Tho period botwcon tho dangerous bcrd.r and tho border endangering lifo ccr.porjd to tho fortaor loos efwater only tho following conditions changei originally, only tho free wr.t^r is olimdnr.tod, rhilo during tho period be two jn ten or twelve per cent and about 22 per cent, tho water fron tho oolla too, is ollainatcd. In other w rds, the intracellular wat«.r supply is affected. At tho very beginning cf the diocusei on I oaphasisud that under rv' conditions would I carry cut experiments which would LXj-n donogs to the ha~lth or would ondargor tho lift of a subject; that I »ould refuso to do southing liko that. Aid, Bockor- Froyssng r.plied Ik edintoly that that was aloo in accordance with his viows, and, that, of course, d.r.th should havo to bo avoided in any case, and that the limit should bu sot vhoro no d.ar*ige to tho health of the subject had to be fearod. 3ut, anyhow, tho experiments would h-vo to bo carried on so far that thirst reactions woro notic.ablo and without any doubt -ould ncko it ;x>ssiblo to r.ako o comparison between tho two groups. As for -si could toko tho responsibility for tSmt fror. the rodied point of vimw, under the giv.n circumstances, that is by pr-venting any dor. ago to the torlth of sub joe tc, I was cupposod to prccood that far. I also discussed with l»iu, discuscod with bin, that, of course, :a. would have be-n quite clo-rly in our mdnds that thiyit experiment is not a pleasure, .and that it asks v u ry much fron the 'dll pov:or of oxpcrirontal subjects if they arc required to thirst for s_v.ral d-ys. Arid frer. that aoir.t of view, of course, one would have “O r j r rc t' e a experi _nts as core .act -*d with cotjo unplc.rs.antr.es.' for the ox'urixmtol subjects, and as a consequence tho oxperinoat -1 subject 6716 6 Jun-A-43-18—3-Board (Int. Tartcnberg) Court No. I. had to be volunteers. And, axpcrirxmts on volunteers who made thea- soIves available for those thirst, oxscrir»nts would, of course. sake it possiblo to put these high requirements on thin. In order to protect the experimental subjects in other ways, they had to stay in bed. Thoro woro two other reasons for this: First, the aviator who is in sea dis¬ tress is “Iso forced to lie desra in the rescue boat; and second, every covenant that is by walking around, incrcasos tho elimination of water by the lungs. So, that a lack of aovcaant, tho quiet lying in bod re¬ tains the wator of tho body somewhat core. In otbor words, tho ex¬ ternal conditions were kept in such n way that is, with tho oxception of hunger and thirst, as far as possible no unpleasantness and no hunger would result for tho oxporinontal subjocts. Tho nia of tho ox- porinont was to achieve absolute clarity about tho following question: First, whothor thirsting or tho drinking of so a water would bo hotter; whothor tho r.bstinonco fron water or tho drinking of see water would bo bettor, drinking of a snail * »unt of sea wator; secondly, whothor tho Borkn preparation contrary to expectations would bring .about an inprovorunt of tlv to lor ability of sea water; thirdly, whothor tho Schaofor preparation could be tolor'tod for 12 days without ary danago to tho body. And, this group of oxporinents was supposed to bo car¬ ried out for 12 conscoutive days if tho obvious conclusions recultod, i.e. that tho preparation proved to bo hamlcss. On tho occasion tho metabolism of those suffering from thirst and those who drank sea water was to be studied for one eight obtain clues whether any changes take place within tho body, and one would perhaps obtain hints for the treatment of persons rescued from sea distress. As I have said, this program of experiments was laid down in the meeting of 25 H~y, 1 re¬ ceived the respective record and asked whether any one of the Wavy, or of the airforce, Luftwaffe, had found any papers on research work about sea water which Becker-Freysen- d e ni ed. In nodical literature there existed nothing but very nebulous reports and opinions, to the effect, in general, that sea water is dangerous. Nobody concerned hinself with C717 6 Jur.-A-»3-l3-i;-5eard (Ir.fc, Tf.-rtenberg) Court Ho, I. the question of */fcy it rt dangerous in detail, and it was strange that nobody ever asked wither this was not conditioned by the acount. I also have to add that in all the report* about cases of sea distress, it becomes apparent ag-.in and again that usually one only starts to drink sen water only after one has suffered thirst already for sovoral days. In other words one expects an organise to tolerate son water, an organise nhich is under quite different conditions than a healthy organise. Now it is as foliovsi 7!mt a person who has been suffering free thirst alrotdy for a few days has already reduced his elininntion of vrater to a niniaun; if such a person is now expected to drdnk about one or tno liters of sea water per day, that is a quart of sea water per day, then this dehydrated body ia forcod to elininnto a r.ultiplicity of the anount of water which he irould have lost if ho had continuod to suffor froa thirst. Court l June 5—«-15-1 -HiWfe - ban- - a. r t anoa r t . Since a -.ors n who is suffering fro- tnlrst and sea '.le-ross usurlly drinks c l“r«e amount cf wat„r, aaon d the aocfarrer3 the d^n-er of the sea water is ..r.cvn as a degna :all reports about sea distress wnloh I have f ’end so far, with v.ry snail exceptions. Indicate that the tokln^ of sea up t--r occurs in an uncontrolled Benner and this practical ox;orienco in partio'l^r was avarently the reason why in the English end ASerlcen papers on the subject studies were nr.de predominantly on what the effect of sea water is on a body which hrs boon -ehydrctwd already, while we ashed our¬ selves how developments were wnen fr.n the very betinning one drinks sea water. Spanking from a nedlcrl joint of view, t -ro is r difference in principle. 4. Witness, woo had to docldo when the experiments vroro to be interrupted? a. This dooiei>nvas of course up to ny modloal .Xpert Judgment on I con assure you hero that I dleoontln- u d the experiments in such o way that the oritioal limit wta not exceeded in any experiment. «s far ns the aubjootive elements were o-nsldored, I also took then into oonsldora- tl n, but th-t o-uld t ke mloco according to the nature of the experiment only to n certain extent, beoause the C irst was in these oxporlnents a "Conditio sine qua non," condition without hloh it could not be carried on. Such *n ox erlnont could not have boon carried out without ..'.Ting the oxnerinontal subject suffer froa thirst. I certainly can understand how it feels to suffer froji t iret and I had node sure what the sensations which ere caused by t is thirst. i. With reference to this experiment on y -.rself, I ' v«: already -er.tl-ned the cnlzd experiments and d ancll ref-r to then later; but now I want to ask y/a, witness, Court 1 Juno &-*-19-.2-HD-H3ohan-Wcrtenberg. did you carry out tha experiments yourself alone or did you have medical or other collaborators? It would of course hovo boon absolutely impossible for aa to c-rry out those ..joerlaonts, which wore propounded hero, all alono; that would have been laposslble. Therefore, throo physicians of the Luftwaffe, medic 1 ohonists, who were otherwise working In largo University Institutes and laboratories, helped so carry out the laboratory work. On this occasion, I plso want to etato that theso throo phyelr cions carried on the laboratory work *nd they aro only rosponeiblo for whet they found In the urine and In the blood. In other words, they made analyses of tho body fluids I sent to then, but they ore not responsible for the oxperlmento In theaaolves nor for the Conner of tho exooutlon of tho oxporlmonte. For that I alone aa ro-ponslblo. In addition to the oodloal personnel, did you have any other collaborators? «. I also had three ncdloal officers of tto Luftwaffe, who In oert wore also working In the laboratory, In addi¬ tion I received too aale nureea who wore prisoners to holp mo and three French medical students, who olso holpod mo to oarry out the exnnlnatlon and in tho care of tho experi¬ mental subjects. Furthermore, I oonsulted spoolallsts from Dachau. They were exclusively prisoner physicians who holped me with the examinetlons In tho specialist's field, and In tho roports, which I still have In my posses¬ sion. although I mode the greatest effort, 1 did not succeed In procuring ono of the French rselstnnts so that here he oould testify cs e witness about the execution of the experiments. Please ask me another question. 8720 Court I Juno S-A-19-3-HD-iteoban-'fartenburg. How did the experiments begin ?ft-r the experimental .•ts ned arrived? Taon Che ox:erlacr.tol subjects had been hrjidod over .x .:o, first I extlclned to then very extensively what was rt otrke in these experiments end what they wore about. For no that wns natural fron the audioa1 point of viow. Hover in •: life did I require a patient or oxperisontrl subject t. dr. suoothln. that they did nvt know anythin- about, but if I as not believed then I seat sdy tht for prr.otlor.l roatone alone it was absolutely necessary to toll the o x:oricent a 1 subjects what c. urso natters wuuld take, because an ox.orisent of sioft a r . n tare cannot be unlortakon at all without bavin- the expericentol subjects know what they have to do. Such an ex erls-nt depends exclusively upon t.io ex eriaentrl subject and I did not keep it fron tho oxTorlsont-.l subjects in any way, that the thirst was v v ry unploaeant and that what we were requiring of thorn would ✓0 vary difficult for them. I still renoob.r quite exactly th t one of thvfi thereupon told me, "Oh, well, p few days of hunger and thirst." I then told his he should not under¬ estimate this at all, how thirst will feel. I then requested them to support sa in this experiment and told thoa also, that with those un leasant things tnoy would now suffer they mi e ht be able to contribute to savin = or prolonging the lives of a lcr £ a number of people Inter on, r.nd I told t~o group who were suooos-d to suffer . un-or and thirst in particular ar.d t.ie t roup who were supposed to drink 1,000 cc bf sen water"that the were b far in the worst Asltion. "or that reason, I selected the strongest ones for these two grouos, and contrary to the original orders I had cceivod 1 kept specifically these -roupe down to, the smallest number of people. That t.e group that received Court 1 June 5--19-4-H3-Meehar.-' : artenburg. 1,000 cc of s 60 water loter became larger is not duo to the fact that X enjoyed Inflicting this torture on another large .-.umber cf -xperlmontcl subjects again, but it is by the fact that of thla group in particular during ell the first experi¬ mental series none of then, not one of then, carried out the experiments without in addition to sea water drlng a large amount of fresh water. I also told the experimental subjects I would always be near then and I also kept that promise. Furthermore, I -romisod them they oould have absoluto con¬ fidence in me that nothing would happen to them, and thirdly I promised them that with the influence I had, duo to the nr.turo of t.'lngs, I would uso all of it to soe to it that the oromieod ndir.ntr.^os were glvon to them. I then asked than whether they would agree to eubmit to tho oxporlacnte undor those conditions and they said yee, they would. Q. You 'flentlon-d before that bofae tho boginning- of the experiment you c-rrlod out an experiment on yoursolf; would you please describe that to us briefly? The ojporloont on myself did not oonsiot in ny tasting from the water when it was being administered to tho o^orioental subject or when it was given to them in order to make fun of them, but this experiment on myeelf was carried out by myself before tte beginning of tho other ex¬ periments and that was at tho time when the experimental subjects were not oven there yot. I did that for tho roason that I wanted to find out first whothor Berka's opinion that his preparation quenched thirst was oorreot, and socondly I wanted to suffer thirst myself, because tho director pf such experiments would ce at a disadvantage if ho had no idea what the aperlmontal subjects wore faeling when they were under^oir.i his requirements. Perhaps for an experiment, of another nature, under certain conditions, that zljnt be C722 Ocurt 1 June 6-74-19 -5-HD-hee han-'&r t anber&. X)e?lble. For an experiment, however, In which tiio subjec- ti symotoms of the experimental subjects are predominantly ertant It Is necessary that the person carrying out -x crlnonta know how It feels. For that reason, I carried ut the experiment on myself to orient myself and to Inform ayswlf, I am not very proud of this at all and I cm ready at any time to repent It. 3ut actually this was an experi¬ ment on ay own eerson, which v'6 executed In the regular fashion and I believe I know now thirst feels. £723 6 June 47-*-S--2C-X— t irxcufccrtcnb'-rg) Court So. 1 '.•Dldycu ctrry out this experiment on yourself without c ny i: J~?T »c your health? I c'-rriod on the cxperlner.t for four dtya end rights, the cttct- irx-ts with acawctcr. I drenk fivo hundred cuMc centimeters c day. Of course, I scs K.irstyi Jn ft-et, I wes very thirsty j esrtcielly on the third dey cy thirst wia cxtrccrdinrrily gre.t. I else oba. rved thi t fren the fourth dey on I got srnev-het '‘rosay, th 1 1 cy alccp sea dietrubed by the thirst, tfcet from the n*nont ahon tho msclos be gen to loso their otter th.ro res a certain lercltudo in the nueclea erd ovac t weekr.css'.f the nxaclca, c ccrtrir. hervir.eaa'n sy Unba, end t greet need for reat. I then diaoontirued tv. crptriaont by beginning to drink art. r end, even though I bed lost rsoro then four erd c helf kilrgrcna — thit is acre then nine peunda — after tr- doya I '*ca tblc to erke t *rlp to Vienne from Uunieh without cny Mr.plcln*a. -ltr.osa, after *hc experiment you carried -ut cn youraolf, lettr cr. didyou oeecalontlly oleo a till drink a< center? *.