ROLL NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Microfilm Publication M887 RECORDS OF THE UNITED STATES NUERNBERG WAR CRIMES TRIALS UNITED STATES OF AMERICA V. KARL BRANDT ET AL. (CASE I) NOVEMBER 21, 1946-AUGUST 20, 1947 Roll 8 Transcript Volumes (English Version) Volumes 19-21 May 1-21, 1947 THE NATIONAL ARCHIVES NATIONAL ARCHIVES AND RECORDS SERVICE GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION WASHINGTON: 1974 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS records of the other Nuernberg and Far East (IMTFE) war crimes trials, are part of the National Archives Collection of World War II War Crimes Records, Record Group 238. The Brandt case was 1 of 12 separate proceedings held before several U.S. Military Tribunals at Nuernberg in the U.S. Zone of Occupation in Germany against officials or citizens of the Third Reich, as follows: No. of Case No. United States v. Popular Name Defendants 1 Karl Brandt et al. Medical Case 23 2 Erhard Milch Milch Case 1 — (Luftwaffe) 3 Joaef Alt8tcetter et al. Justice Case 16 4 Oswald Pohl et al. Pohl Case (SS) 18 5 Friedrich Flick Flick Case 6 et al. (Industrialist) 6 Carl Krauch et al. I. G. Farben Case (Industrialist) 24 7 Vilhelm Liet et al. Hostage Case 12 8 Ulrich Greifelt et al. RuSHA Case (SS) 14 9 Otto Ohlendorf Einsatzgruppen 24 et al. Case (SS) 10 Al fried Krupp Krupp Case 12 et al. (Industrialist) 11 Ernst von Veizeaecker et al. Ministries Case 21 12 Vilhelm von Leeb High Command Case 14 et al. Authority for the proceedings of the International Military Tribunal against the major Nazi war criminals derived from the Declaration on German Atrocities (Moscow Declaration) released November 1, 1943, Executive Order 9547 of May 2, 1945, the London Agreement of August 8, 1945, the Berlin Protocol of October 6, 1945, and the Charter of the International Military Tribunal. Authority for the 12 subsequent cases stemmed mainly from Control Council Law 10 of December 20, 1945, and was reinforced by Executive Order 9679 of January 16, 1946; U.S. Military Govern¬ ment Ordinances Nos. 7 and 11 of October 18, 1946, and February 17, 1947, respectively; and U.S. Forces, European Theater General Order 301 of October 24, 1946. The procedures applied by U.S. Military Tribunals in the subsequent proceedings were patterned after those of the International Military Tribunal and further developed in the 12 cases, which required over 1,200 days of court sessions and generated more than 330,000 transcript pages. 2 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS The crises charged in the Brandt case consisted largely of nedical experiments performed on defenseless concentration camp inmates against their will; "euthanasia" carried out on the mentally defective, the physically sick, the aged, and ethnic and racial groups; and the murder of concentration camp inmates for the express purpose of collecting skulls and skeletons for the Anatomical Institute of the Reich University of Strassburg. The following medical experiments were conducted: 1. High altitude: to investigate effects of low pressure on persons. 2. Freezing: to test human resistance to extemely low temperatures. 3. Malaria: to develop controls over the recurring nature of the disease. 4. Mustard gas: part of a general research program in gas warfare. 5. Sulfanilamide: to test the efficacy of the drug in bone muscle and nerve regeneration and bone transplantation. 6. Seawater: to test methods of rendering seawater potable. 7. Epidemic jaundice: to develop an antitoxin against the disease. / 8. Sterilization: to test techniques for preventing further propagation of the mentally and physically defective. 9. Typhus: to investigate the value of various vaccines. 10. Poison: to test the efficacy of certain poisons. 11. Incendiary bomb: to find better treatment for phosphorus bums. The prosecution alleged and the judgment confirmed that these experiments were not isolated acts of individual doctors and scientists on their own responsibility but that they were the result of high-level policy and planning. They were carried out with particular brutality, often disregarding all established medical practice. Consequently, large numbers of the victims died in the course of or as a result of the experiments. The euthanasia program was the direct result of a directive by Hitler of September 1, 1939. It resulted in the secret killing not only of aged, insane, incurably ill, and deformed German citizens in sanatoriums in Germany but also in the clandestine murder of foreign workers. The killing in gas chambers and by injections in the sanatoriums served as a proving ground for these forerunners of much larger installations in the mass extermination camps. In addition to these experiments, over 100 concentration camp inmates were killed for the purpose of obtaining their y skeletons. Their ghastly remains were found in Strassburg by Allied troops. The transcripts of the Brandt case include the indictments of the following 23 persons all of whom were physicians except defendants Rudolf Brandt, Viktor Brack, and Wolfram Sievers: Karl Brandt: Personal physician to Adolf Hitler, Gruppenr fuehrer in the SS and Generalleutnant (Major General) in the Kaffen SS, Reichskonmissar fuer Sanitaets- und Gesund- heitswesen (Reich Commissioner for Health and Sanitation), and member of the Reichsforschungsrat (Reich Research Council), Kurt Blooe: Deputy [of the] Reichsgesundheitsfuehrer (Reich Health Leader) and Plenipotentiary for Cancer Research in the Reich Research Council. Rudolf Brandt: Standartenfuehrer (Colonel) in the Allgemeinc SS, Persoenlicher Referent von Himmler (Personal Admin¬ istrative Officer to Reichsfuehrer SS Himmler), and Min¬ isterial Counselor and Chief of the Ministerial Office in the Reich Ministry of the Interior. Joachim Mrugowsky: Oberfuehrer (Senior Colonel) in the Waffen SS, Oberster Hygieniker, Reichsarzt SS und Polizei (Chief Hygienist of the Reich Physician SS and Police), and Chef des Hygienischen Institutes der Waffen SS (Chief of the Hygienic Institute of the Waffen SS). Helmut Poppendick: Oberfuehrer in the SS and Chef des Pcrsoenlichen Stabes des Reichsarztes SS und Polizei (Chief of the Personal Staff of the Reich Physician SS and Police). Wolfram Sievers: Standartenfuehrer in the SS, Reich Manager of the "Ahnencrbe" Society and Director of its Institut fuer Wehrwissenschaftliche Zweckforschung (Institute for Military Scientific Research), and Deputy Chairman of the Managing Board of Directors of the Reich Research Council. Karl Genzken: Gruppenfuehrer in the SS and Generalleutnant in the Waffen SS and Chef des Sanitaetsamts der Kaffen SS (Chief of the Medical Department of the Waffen SS). Karl Gebhardt: Gruppenfuehrer in the SS and Generalleutnant in the Waffen SS, personal physician to Reichsfuehrer SS Himmler, Oberster Kliniker, Reichsarzt SS und Polizei (Chief Surgeon of the Staff of the Reich Physician SS and Police), and President of the German Red Cross. Viktor Brack: Oberfuehrer in the SS and Sturmbannfuehrer (Major) in the Waffen SS and Oberdienstleiter, Kanzlei des Fuehrers der NSDAP (Chief Administrative Officer in the Chancellery of the Fuehrer to the NSDAP). 4 Waldeaar Hoven: Hauptsturmfuehrer (Captain) in the Waffen SS and Chief Physician of the Buchenwald Concentration Camp. Herta Oberheuser: Physician at the Ravensbrueck Concentration Camp and assistant physician to the defendant Gebhardt at the hospital at Hohenlychen. Fritz Fischer: Sturmbannfuehrer in the Waffen SS and assist¬ ant physician to the defendant Gebhardt at the hospital at Hohenlychen. Siegfried Handloser: Generaloberstabsarzt (Lieutenant General, Medical Service), Heeressanitaetsinspekteur (Medical Inspector of the Army), and Chef des Kehr- machtsanitaetswesens (Chief of the Medical Services of the Armed Forces). Paul Rostock: Chief Surgeon of the Surgical Clinic in Berlin, Surgical Adviser to the Army, and Amtschef der Dienststelle Medizinische Wissenschaft und Forschung (Chief of the Office for Medical Science and Research) under the defendant Karl Brandt, Reich Commissioner for Health and Sanitation. Oskar Schroeder: Generaloberstabsarzt; Chef des Stabes, Inspekteur des Luftwaffe^anitaetswesens (Chief of Staff of the Inspectorate of the^Medical Service of the Luftwaffe); and Chef des Sanitaetswesens der Luftwaffe (Chief of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe). Hermann Becker-Freyscng: Stabsarzt in the Luftwaffe (Captain, Medical Service of the Air Force) and Chief of the Department for Aviation Medicine of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe. Georg August Weltz: Oberfeldarzt in the Luftwaffe (Lieu¬ tenant Colonel, Medical Service of the Air Force) and Chief of the Institut fuer Luftfahrtmedizin (Institute for Aviation Medicine) in Munich. __ Wilhelm Beiglboeck: Consulting physician to the Luftwaffe. Gerhard Rose: Generalarzt of the Luftwaffe (Brigadier General, Medical Service of the Air Force); Vice President, Chief of the Department for Tropical Medicine, and Professor of the Robert Koch Institute; and Hygienic Adviser for Tropical Medicine to the Chief of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe. Siegfried Ruff: Director of the Department for Aviation Medicine at the Deutsche Versuchsanstalt fuer Luftfahrt (German Experimental Institute for Aviation). 5 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Hans Wolfgang Romberg: Physician on the staff of the Depart- . ment for Aviation Medicine at the German Experimental Institute for Aviation. Konrad Schaefer: Physician on the staff of the Institute for Aviation Medicine in Berlin. Adolf Pokorny: Physician, specialist in skin and venereal diseases. The indictment consisted of four’counts. Count one charged participation in a comnon design or conspiracy to commit war crimes or crimes against humanity. The ruling of the tribunal disregarded this count, hence no defendant was found guilty of the crime charged in count one. Count two was concerned with war crimes and count three, with crimes against humanity. Fifteen defendants were found guilty, and eight were acquitted on these two counts. Ten defendants were charged under count four with membership in a criminal organiza¬ tion and were found guilty. The transcripts also contain the arraignment and plea of each defendant (all pleaded not guilty), opening and closing statements of defense and prosecution, and the judgment and sentences, which acquitted 7 of the 23 defendants (Blome, Pokorny, Romberg, Rostock, Ruff, Schaefer, and Wcltz). Death sentences were imposed on defendants Brack, Karl Brandt, Rudolf Brandt, Hoven, Gebhardt, Mrugowsky, and Sievers, and life imprisonment on Fischer, Genzken, Handloser, Rose, and Schroedcr; varying terms of years were given to defendants Becker-Freyseng, Beiglboeck, Oberheuser, and Poppcndick. The English-language transcript volumes are arranged numer¬ ically, 1-30; pagination is continuous, 1-11538. The German- language transcript volumes arc numbered la-30a and paginated 1-11756. The letters at the top of each page indicate morning, afternoon, and evening sessions. The letter "C" designates com¬ mission hearings (to save court tine and to avoid assembling hundreds of witnesses at Nuernberg, in most of the cases one or more commissions took testimony and received documentary evidence for consideration by the tribunals). Several hundred pages are added to the transcript volumes and given number plus letter designations, such as page number 1044a. Page 1 in volume 1 (English) is preceded by pages numbered 001-039, while the last page of volume 28 (English) is followed by pages numbered 1-48. Of the many documents assembled for possible prosecution use, 570 were chosen for presentation as evidence before the tribunal. These consisted largely of orders, directives, and reports on medical experiments or the euthanasia program; several interrogation reports; affidavits; and excerpts from the Reiahsgeeetzblatt (the official gazette of Reich laws) as well as correspondence. A number 6 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS of the medical reports were accompanied by series of photographs and charts of various experiments. The first item in the arrangement of the prosecution exhibits is usually a certificate listing the document number, a short description of the exhibit, and a statement on the location of the original document of the exhibit. The certificate is followed by the document, the actual prosecution exhibit (most of which are photostats), and a few mimeographed articles with an occasional carbon of the original. In rare cases the exhibits are followed by translations or additional certificates. A few exhibits are original documents, such as: Exhibit No. Doc. No. • Exhibit No. Doc. No 301 NO-1314 410 NO-158 307 . NO-120 441 NO-1730 309 NO-131 443 NO-890 310 NO-132 451 NO-732 357 1696 PS 462 NO-1424 362 628 PS 507 NO-365 368 NO-817 546 NO-3347 403 616 PS No certificate is attached to several exhibits, including ,exhibits 433, 435-439, 462, 559, and 561. Following exhibit 570 is a tribunal exhibit containing the interrogation of three citizens of the Netherlands. Number 494 was not assigned, and exhibit 519 is followed by 519a and 519b. Other than affidavits, the defense exhibits consist of newspaper clippings, reports, personnel records, Reichsgeeetzblatt excerpts, and other items. There are 901 exhibits for the defendants. The defense exhibits are arranged by name of defendant and thereunder by exhibit number, each followed by a certificate wherever available. The translations in the prosecution document books are preceded by indexes listing prosecution document numbers, biased descriptions, and page numbers of the translation. They arc generally listed in the order in which the prosecution exhibits were introduced into evidence before the tribunal. Pages 81-84 of prosecution document book 1 are missing. Books 12, 16, and 19 are followed by addenda. The document books consist largely of mimeographed pages. The defense document books are similarly arranged. Each book is preceded by an index giving document numbers, description, and page number for each exhibit. The corresponding exhibit numbers are generally not provided. There are several unindexed supplements to numbered document books. Prosecution and defense briefs are arranged alphabetically by names of defendants; final pleas and defense answers to prosecution briefs follow a similar 7 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS scheme. Pagination is consecutive, yet there are many pages where an "a" or "b" is added to the numeral. The English-language final pleas, closing briefs, and replies to prosecution briefs of several defendants are missing, as are a few German-language closing briefs and replies to prosecution briefs. At the beginning of roll 1 are filmed key documents from which Tribunal I derived its jurisdiction: the Moscow Declaration, U.S; Executive Orders 9547 and 9679, the London Agreement, the Berlin Protocol, the Charter of.the International Military Tri¬ bunal, Control Council Law 10, U.S. Military Government Ordinances 7 and 11, and U.S. Forces, European Theater General Order 301. Following these documents of authorization is a list of the names and functions of the members of Tribunal I and counsels. These documents arc followed by the transcript covers giving such information as name and number of case, volume numbers, language, page numbers, and inclusive dates. They are followed by summaries of the daily proceedings providing an additional finding aid for the transcripts. The exhibits are listed in an index, which notes type of exhibit, exhibit number and name, corresponding document number and document book and page, a short description of the exhibit, and the date when it was offered in court. The official court file is indexed in the court docket, which is followed by a list of witnesses. Not filmed were records duplicated elsewhere in this micro¬ film publication, such as prosecution and defense document books in the German language that arc largely duplications of pros¬ ecution and defense exhibits already microfilmed or opening statements of prosecution and defense, which can be found in the transcripts of the proceedings. The records of the Brandt case arc closely related to other microfilmed records in Record Group 238, specifically prosecution exhibits submitted to the International Military Tribunal, T988; NI (Nuernberg Industrialist) Series, T301; NOKW (Nuernberg Armed Forces High Command) Series, Til19; NG (Nuernberg Government) Series, T1139; and records of the Milch case, M888, the List case, M893, the Greifelt case, M894, and the Ohlendorf case, M895. In addition, the record of the International Military Tribunal at Nuernberg has been published in Trial of the Major War Criminate Before the International Military Tribunal (Nuernberg, 1947), 42 vols. Excerpts from the subsequent proceedings have been pub¬ lished as Tridle of War Criminate Before the Nuernberg Military Tribunal Under Control Council Law No. 10 (U.S. Government Printing Office: 1950-53), 15 vols. The Audiovisual Archives Division of the National Archives and Records Service holds motion picture records and photographs of all 13 trials and tape re¬ cordings of the International Military Tribunal proceedings. 8 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS John Mendelsohn wrote these introductory remarks and arranged the records for microfilming in collaboration with George Chalou. NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Roll 8 Target 1 Volume 19 May 1-7, 1947 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS OFFICIAL RECORD UNITED STATES MILITARY TRIBUNALS NURNBERG CASE No. 1 TRIBUNAL l U.S. vs KARL BRANDT at al VOLUME 19 TRANSCRIPTS (English) 1-7 May 1947 pp. 6763-7192 1 :'^y 47-:'^S /-l-l-?oator-Int: rLjslor Court ;.*o. 1 Official Transcript of tho -^aericon Military Tribunal in tl;o matter of the Unitod Etatos of -ai-rica against Karl irandt, ot al, defendants, sitting at I’urn’jorg, Germany on 1 Kay 1947, 0930, Justico Deals presiding. • SEE 1j 1RSK- L: Persons ip tho court took rill ploaso f ind thoir sor.ts. Tho Honor bio, tho J-.-d^oc of Military Tribunal I. Military Tribunal I is nor in sore ion. God sr.vo tho Unitod Statos of America end tl is l.onorablo Tribunal. Thoro will bu ordor in tho courtroom. TITS P712SIDE'?: Mr. *-arsl cl, you r.ooortain if tho defend¬ ants aro all procont in court. TEZ RSU/.L: H y it ploaco . our Honor, all dofordants aro prosont in tho coxrt witt tho oxcopticn of tho Dofondant Oberhousor, r.bsont duo to illnoss. THE TCSjLSIT: Tx o Socrotnry-Goncrnl rill noto tho prosor.co of all tho dofonlants in court oavo tho Dofondrt Oborhouscr. Tho prison physician having fllod a cortif j.cato tlic.t tho Defendant Oborhousor is unr.blo to attond court today, sho rill bo oxcusod .xrsuar.t to that certificate, it ap soaring th. t hor absonco will in r.o way projudico her c-.so. Counrol nay procood. DR. VOR'/SRK: (Covnsol for tho Dofondant Romberg): ilr. Prosidont, I think I am corroct in assuming that tho high tribunal has Romberg's document book available to thon. TE2 PH2SID2!?: ITo hr.vo not yot rocoivod it. (Documont book handod to the Tribunal. ) Dofor.co of tho Defendant I.osibcrE vrill nor 1 Ifr.y 47-?S~£ i-l- 2 -Poster-Int: Raaler Court iro. 1 call tho Defendant Itor.be rg into tho witness stand, and in the courao cf his oxanin. tion will submit the Individual affidavits, "itl the approval of the Tribunal , I ask that the Deforciant Romberg bo called into tho witr.oss at.nd. PRZSIDHtT: At tho roo.uort of his counsel, tho Deforci¬ ant Romberg •-.•ill take the ritnoss stand. D?.. nANSP.OJlDDRG, a defondant , took tho stand and to sti¬ fled as follows BY J 'DOB SB3RINO: Q. Tho Defondmt will raise l.is right h nd and bo sworn. I swear by Gcd, tl o . lnir^ty .nd Omnicciont, that I will spook the puro truth and will withhold and add nothing. (Bo witness ropor.tod the oath.) J!DG 2 SZBRII’O: You may bo son tod. DIIGCT 2X.T-Il l .TI0N BY. DR. VCR'.BRK: 'l. Your nano is I'ans "olfgang Ronborg, la th t corroct? ... Yes. '. ’hen and wh ro xroro you born? A. I war bom on tho 15th of hay, 1911, in Borlin, .'oi ld 70 U plearo good onough to doccribo your Cv.roor to tho Tribunal. ... I 1 ont to a humanist High School Gymnasium in Borlin and tfl ilo going to school my main fiolds cf intorost uoro medicine and technique. I decided to chooco tho nodical profession, and from 1929 to 1955 I studiod ..t tho Univor- sitios of Borlin and Innsbruck. In tho spring of 1935 I took ny stato oxam. nation at Berlin and t) on proceeded to work as an ir.torno at tho hospital in Priodrochahaln, Borlin. I was thoro at the Internal and Surgical Depart¬ ment. Since it was ay intor.t..on tc become a surgeon, I went to hrofoscor Buockner as an assistant to tho ?atho- 1 !tey 47-;!-£--i-c-roster-Int: Ranlor Court Ko. 1 logical Institute in crdor tc gain a bcsic education in tlo field of surgery there. '•hilo working with Duochnor my interest in aviation nodical questions v.-a awalconod, sinco in Buochnor»a Institu .0 thoro woro -n l a n l oxp .noients porfomod ccr.cor nir.y thoni- eolvus with t! oso questions. Alroody r.t th-t tine I volun¬ teered ..a experimental subject for high altitude oxpor- iiu-nts porfor.i.d by other physici.r.s because I was intorostod in that fioid. In tho year of 1937 I participated in an air nodical congross ct tl o P.Ii: in Jorlin, to which I gainod accoss by tho mediation of Dtiochnor, and bocuno acquainted with tho ontiro fioid of work of aviation medicino. As a rosult of t*. is congress, 1 ducldod to bo cctivo in that sphoro bceauso ti is roprorontod a very fortunr.to synthesis of my nodical and tochnical int-rosts. On tho 1st of January 1C38 I was omploycd by tho Air Modlc..l Department of tho DVL of which Dr. huff wa 3 tho hood. I was oriployod as sciontific co-workCr ;jid my special assignment w..s tho thoorotic..l and pructic.,1 eval¬ uation of lr accidents. In audition, I simultaneously \/orkod on r.ir medical i*osonrch quostions. "i. i t, in dotcll, w s your work concerning air nodicr.l rosonrch quostions? a. Ir. addition to my accidont work I h.ad rosourch .-.sEign- mente of various typos wi ich at first wore on tho fioid of acceleration research. In fro courso of thoso uxp.rimonfcs I worked in many airpl_.no tosts nth dive bombora and carriod out centrifugal oxp.rinonts. ._ftor tho DVL, in tho year of 193S, rucoivod ti-Oir own low prossuro chamber, ro st.rtc-d tho rork in f. 0 field cf high-r.ltitudo rose; rch. I currently carried on low ro esuro chamber oxporiaonts, concoming flying ability and in addition thoro wero a numbor 6765 1 I Say 47-!*-S^-l-4-Po3tor-Int: Ranlcr Court To. 1 of research c.asi^monta in tho fiold c ' high-cltitudo. 3*0 initiation for thoso oxp~ r^nur.ts originated partly fron aerial accidont -.ork ard f ror. tho oxptrianco r/hich I gainod c.e a result of investigation of air accidoris nl ich had not aa yot b^on ox old nod. Thoso woro r.ir r.ccidonts on tho basis of altitude sickness, rnd it nr.a &oy tint intor..stod no costly. I scon began to aoo the fight .-.gainst high- altitudo sioknoss and : oath aa uy special assignment. Ifco first phaso of ny ctivlty in fci*o combat of accidonts w. a concludod in t'. o spring of 1S40 with tho roport which 0 was alroady mentioned by Dr. ^uff rogerding hi~h-altitudo aicknoaa and high-altituio doath. I spocializod in tho fiold of high alt: tv.do ro so arch, rx.d carried out many lo« prossuro oxporir.onts concerning flying ability in that connoction. 1 Ilry-JMJG-2-i-.fclcy Court Nc. 1 Q 'isbat was yeur tr.sk within the fracework cf high altitude re¬ search? There was e CMbber cf activities going on in order tc improve high altitude fineness with pharaccclocical ttuans regarding th- effect of ccntinuwd exposure-to raspiration oxygen, concerning carbon dioxide content, the effectiveness cf pervitin, investigations cf ,,•rachutu descending free high altitudes, explosive decc repression oxperiioento in the question cf hi.ch -ltitude flying in the pressure chamber, airplanes, nnd c-ny sLail r rttors. Q .ere there any series cf experiments in yeur institutions ccrried cut by you ~t that ti_e, end who r.t th*.t tin- was in eh" rge cf yeur experiments end when did ycu use as experimental subjects? * Uo bad a serl-s cf expcrln-nts in oil these reaor.rch raaignn-nts. ho ourselves were the expert, uital subjects. Sometimes we had exp-ri- ncntal subjects coning fruu cur collaborators in cur own institutes, end ooootinua freu other bronchos of the DVL. Usually 1 aySelf was in charge of those experiments, except in case-s when I .myself was thu cxporinontrl subject. 0 the, for the first tine suggested tc ycu that lew presnuro ch^nbor experiments could be carried cut at Dachau? « In Dccuiber 19L1, -ft-r ..eltz 1 visit tc Ruff, huff called mu into his rcen and t Id c*e about his conversation with ’..‘cltz. He asked whether I w,-3 prop.-rod tc rerk under these conditions wJ participate in experiments for the purpose cf r--scuo from hifh altitudes. Q Ycu arc scying under these conditions, whet conditions were ycu speaking cf? ft These wore the conditions wlch Dr. .eltz mentioned tc Dr. Ruff cn the occasion cf his visit. The experisunts were tc b* performed on s-ntvr.cod c r iminals vhc volunteered for these oq crlacnts. '.as the concept "criminal" discussed at that lieu fire dy, end * whet was tc bo understood by it? A Cno meant criminals who had been sentenced by proper courts. 6767 - 1 It y-tt-DJ 3-2-2-.£-1=; (Int. Easier) C.urt Jfc. 1 Q -rdcn I think it is quite u»-rst rodcble thr.t rlthcugh having tc cvci-cco*. cert in persenel inhibitions I h-d no principle ekrftl nisgivings. In edditien I knew c- -xperinents being perfemed or. Inantca in the v-ri us countries, -nd the bcofcs of Peul dc Kruif, which I possessed, gr.vo at this knerl^dgc. Court Sc. 1 1 /■-ey 47-K-S-l-iB>ii*ckan (racier) Although Professor Do Bruif, an I have l^am^d here free Professor Ale xa nder, supposedly ie s-t in er unobjectionable position in America and sosetisos allegedly d-es net cuite tell the truth in his nubllcotione, It is not S3 decisive vhat ho reports about the individual erciriaents perforaed by Gratei cr other people. It is such sore inoertert to con¬ sider the vay in vhich he is reporting these exocriaents'; that he is glorifying these courageous rosearch workers as heroes; that hie bo'ks vert a great success in Africa and in aery other countries; that the Gtrsar editions v.ri crintid in Zurich, the land of the. f.cd Cross: that I never heard cr read of an opinion vhich rejected the bocks cr the experiments vhich art. described therein. As I knov ncv f i was only ovarc ^f an lr-fir.ittly 6aall cart of hunan oxcorinerts carried on abroad. -h^fo ^as yet another condition vhich strengthened St in ay decision. At that tiae concentration camp inaates vho volur.tc.red v-ero cosaltttd for the clearing of dud boobs end, as far as I knov, vero cordoned aftor having cleared soac tvonty such dud boobs. I think that c.aparcd to that tho lev pressure- chamber exporiaonts scta.d t^ at t- be auch e.ro horsiest. and incurred much less danger. In addition, -f course, I put tfct ouir-tivn vhether I c*ro.r.nlly in the ireo position v-uld have nlacti syself at tho disnooal for such experisonts and I, of course, ansverod that ouistion in tho afflraativc, for that in effect vus vhat I did. Q, Bid it r.«t repel ycu at that tic*. v;rking in a concentration casp? A. It vill olvays be difficult to aak. it clear t: people that hardly cno person kr.--v in Geraary anything about the r nccr.tr/-ti on cacpc. According to nose, I knev of Bachau end, being a resident of Berlin, I knev of OranKnburg. * never sav e casp perectally uo to that tine. I hod heard that professional criminals and colitieal insotes vcrc incar¬ cerated in concentration cases. I had heard n-thing of prisoners of war ;T foreigners vho vtre in concentration cases. In the sane vay I hud Ccurt *o. 1 1 .-lay 47HC-3-2-aWtf^h»n (Eerier) ncTor heard anything of the Jewish extermination program or the raes deportation of Java into concentration cerps, ^.ich allegedly already started in thw year of 1936. When in th= year of 1940 or 1941 the Java vtra deported free Berlin, we vere tcld that they voro 6«r.t to Ihoresien- stadt and fr:e there vent to the various cities of the general government in Poland. Q, When did you takv the first steps in .rder to carry through the experiments? A. I'r.e first step vas =y Journey to iiunioh to Veits 1 s institnto, vfacre Ruff accompanied so. "hat *as in Jenurry of 1942. Q, A conference with Volts vat the turcosc of the Journey, vao It not? A. Tes. Q, Did that conference take oloce in January of 1942? A. Too, vc vent there for the purposo of this exoorinont. Q, Woll, vfeo vas prosent at that tiso? A. rrifessor Volts, Dr. hascher. Dr. Ruff, and I. Q, Had you kn.'-n Ir. Raschvr before that conforoncc. A. So. Had you known b*f ,r< the c-nforcnco took place that Dr. Rascher would be present? A. So, I as sure that I did not knov tho nano. Q. Vere you introduced to Rascher7 A. -cs, he vae intr.^iucod to no as an fborarst of the Luftwaffe. v "as a fifth sen present during that conference or at least present p*rt of the tine? A. Tos, I remember that at tho beginning Dr. Luts vae present. I think ho vas already thsre before tho beginning of the conference. Q. Vhat in detail vae discussed during that conference? A. I think that Dr. Huff already told about that conference lr. essence, "he cueeti'.n -f the experimental subjects vas discussed once sere. Dr. catcher had a letter fren Himmler vfaich give hia authority to Court rc. 1 1 Xay 47-X-2-3-iH.----.ethan (Xaalor) carry out the exueriscats, which he produced. It v*a decided to carry cut the exoerlsenta for the curpoee of rescuing frea high altitude, using the lew pressure chaster at Dachau. At the end of the conference ve arranged to scot again the- next day at tka Heichcfuehror'e office at Munich, where a nuster of.forsal cucsti;ns had y«t to he settled. Wasn't it discussed that one w;uld have to establish contact with the c-saar.der of the cc=p at Dachau? A. I d.n't know whether Hascfcor had already suggested that at that tiao. The first stop va 8 thi conference at the Hoichsfuehrer's offico at Kuaich and I think that then, the decision v a8 srdo to estab¬ lish a conference with the c sssandcr at Dachau. Q, luring that c:nfer«.nco did Hatcher wear the uni fore of an SS officer or a Luftwaffe doctor? A. So, he had the unifirs of an ftberarrt, a lieutenant cf tho Luftvoffo. Q, 'as he introduced to you ao an officer of tho Luftwaffe or on officer of tho SS? A. So, h« voa introduced to sc at ar. officer of the Luftvoffo. "here did the conference take place, a*, tho Kclchsfuchror SS? A. Cn the next day, during that c-nfcrcnco, v® aado tho acoualr.- tanco of Schnitclor, the «unich adjutant of Kissl.r, who v» 6 doo in- forsel about the cxo*ri=tr.ts. It v ao then decided to go out to Dachau by car in ord.r to discuss tho necessary satters with tho coacander there. Q. ‘as it arranged that Haccher was to carry out the oxo srioonte? A. T«e, that was arranged. £ 4 . 'ere y.u convinced that Hatcher vbe sufficiently Qualified to carry out thes c exceriscnts? A. Tea, naturally. Q. Did you confer with his, or why v.rc ycu of that opinion? A. During that conference at Viltz'a office naturally discusccd =any Questions. I evt v»3 a lot -f profcssi.nal talk and Haschor nado a very skillful ispression. He told about hie work at Schcngau, -here ho - 6773 Court So. 1 1 Kay 47-jt-S-4-£EK-ti£chaa (Hauler) vna vorkirg at an eek-ack school, vhere he bed rreuared a dl6tar.ee guagu for the purtose of ack-uck *ork. In addition, he seecc-d to have a go;4 general aedical education. I think he had verked in Munich for three or four years doing surgical v—fc and he generally aade a skillful iapreeslon. Q. Vfccn did you actually go to Dachau? A. V c ‘•ent there the n6*t day, sorting free the heieksfuchror's office. Q_, Vhot vae discussed vith the cans cccr.andur at Duchau? A. Schnitrier, the i.'unieh adjutant, vunt cut vith ua and there *~ro the four ;f us and the conn cor.nandor v»a also ureovnt during that conference. During that e-nf.-rsr.ee all the basical oueslionc of the practical execution verc settled. >iret, the bringing of the nrccourt chasbor to Dachau, Its instollati-n In the c act, further the sclvction of the experimental subjects. The camp cccnar.der had already bs.en inf-rcci about it by Schni trier. Kould you oleaeo or.co sore repeat what had boen arranged vith the caap connunder concerning that point? A. Basically thw fact that thv oxncriccntal subjects vxrc to bo Sentenced criminals vh v -luntccnd for that purpose had Ken dctcrcincd and vas scrcly confirmed diring that conference, "o sado certain do- =onds regarding the caliber of the ewrloontal subjects. They had to be A a certain age, ranging free tventy-five to thirty-five yoars; they had to be in g-.d physical condition, had to receive additional rati.ns in order that a g.vd comparison could be dra-n to the cors;nncl of the Luftvaffe regarding ncurish&ont and rhyslcal ccnditi n. In oddi- tion, it vac dotezeinoi they v^r-. r.-t to v.rk during the tic. of the cxucriccnte. The camp cossacd&r then said that Saschcr var t . Voloct the suitable people. 1 U&y-iWUS—err (lit. Homier J C':rt I'*. 1. T. ZJia ti.e ' r --.-r. -ier stute cn that ctcicn that in eay way he h d ;ried f bring ab-ut a vrluntnry re^rticg :f the innatcc f r that tor ese? d. Ye*, he had n' d'uot whatsoever, that under these "ndici _s a le-se aujher 'f jern'-aB w'ald rcocrt, 'S' e he cade the farts .'C't* t- the... £f-a'oer w*b then t eele't tne auitfle .^e'ule fr'c that nd. I an eure th. t tho caccor in i'fc tho 'acp 'rsewdor vaa t nolr>'t ;1.0 ix-role wn» n't disposed in dotail, if I underot; nd y'U "rre-tly? I *aac wtother they were t' ho gathered by »ay rf a r'll 'all 'r in any ftner way? ... I dr n't kcpw h'w it w*a d'ne, vhothar patera *ora out up 'r whet.o.- they were gathered by .ey ff re 11 'all. -t any rate that rrro n*t dlB'Ufloed at the ti e. -. Via it tne.i air dy deiorsisod that Raa'hor alcr.e wrvld doal with the 'axp eestander in the cattor ff the oxoerlsentnl cub;o'ta 'r vero yu elec authorised t* interfere in these sAttero, woe it thon air .iy dw.erclr.ad sbother Raa'hor nlpno n. a to solo't tho exoarloentrl aubjo'tc 'r wore ycu t' have a veto tee? ... That, rf r'urae, w.ie left tr Raa'hor, be'ouse he had the "rr s ending authcrlsuti n free Hisalor. \ Did Res*h-p Dr'du'e that autherlxaticn during a 'rnloron-c, duriiy; the ore'odlsy "nforen'o? Yob, I elro dy said it banponod during tha tice we with ! 7 ol‘.s. Ho shewed ub Hii^slor'n letter. C.. Dp ycu atill roneeber the r entonta 'f that letter ? Yes, it said in tho lotter that the baei' authorisati'n f*r tao osoutim of tho hi3h altitude emori-enta e aointair.ed and th. t trxh or. orlt-onts <-uld be 'arrlod rut in the ern'eatratim 'a.p Da- au. It farther said thi t 'rixdnnle whe had v'lunteered were t' t* used rad that «rdwn -culd bo granted t' these non after tne "n'luei'O rf tho ex •orioontal series. a. Did you travel ba' - tc Berlin with Dr. Buff after these ' nf cron os? £-775 1 L.V-IXJIS-4-2-X ccjc (2ax=4«rJ Court 1. ... Tes, a?tor this " cferorye we went tr 3erlin. 7, Certain oreparati as had to be cede fcr the beginning ri the. on ■orison cb, »ac was entrusted with this jiro^awry work? ... .-reparations wore divided. Dr. Huff was to deal with tho trar.c -rt 'f the Erbile pressure fhacbor. Then Hanker wan t' b*xc all no essarj projarnti'r.3 in Daohau, seleotiag tho c/voritental sub- Jo'ta rad oxacinlng then, and I wan tc gathor the s'ler.tifl' tatori 1 , an far as it was no*, yet available, and t- work 'ut an oxvor iir.or.tca ,r',\rra, the basis of w . i'b already existed? -. Before you roturaod to ?*r2Xu, tho deering perscnnlly very well. I rnly poasubly lT> r- -he physician who case free the Rosoar'h Institute frr Slider end I didn't at all ha'* Dr. Luts. I cnly know ho hud c'oe fr tho Institute 7olt* lud I didn't a. ” any of the rthorn. *. 'os toe •ituati'n auprcxicatel. tin 3 %m uaic<; the 'h.'_bor at Dachau? To rhnt extent it w.s tho seuo 'f.loially I 'ann't Judge, -.•over, I d' think it wvs rather aitil^r. Tho ■- i- ay presence to carry „-ut expcrissnts which vtr. dangerous, as? la vhich deaths occurred. Iht fact that I had tees -Dreecst several tines at previous exceriaents brought about ny ere bc see at that fetal croeri- sest, tcc. Q, '.red to its 'as-, at - aci.au in the experiaent and would not havu r.l.as:d the choab If I nynclf had not gone back to -nci.au, then ?asch. r would have carried oat th rporiments for rescue iron high ItitudCS tlon.; and he vrould doubtl.so -Iso h-.v, continued his o.n xp ri* Ota. i.aut was the reason v.y I reluctantly -tent beck to Dachau. V No ■, .rfcit was the perpcs. of your trip to Berlin? A The purpose tt,.s this report to Ruff. * Krs that the only purpos-? A Yes. * how did you explain this trip to Kaach-r? a I told Rasch-r that 1 rraa going because of cy wife’s corriiticn. :.y rife had ha.* a child in :: rch, and that was t good r-ason for my going to Berlin. Q Hov.- lore" vrere ye*: in Berlin? A Only on-, or tro cays Mien I >ant back to ; *chau. Q Sow, before you left did you oak- curt o: -ether Huf- *hd done anything in response to your r- oort, wfcetli ur he had oor... anything to get th- chamber cat of er.chr.u? A Yes. Hoff tri-d to get Kippke but was not. iUj to .t that time, sc that I r_ally did net knew rhat sas going on ar.c what roulc be -ccos- plished. 67?9 Court No. 1 case 1 1 U-2-51-ckl-y-(int. Von Schor.)- Q Sid yov notivw any tiling special when you c-i. back to Dachau? Cid you native anythin; soccial obcut *-b- chaafr-r? A Ice. OfcH I caa; back, the b.roneUr vas broken, -s UcSt has already snidj and I had to go rijht back to Berlin to have the btro»-U r. repaired. : H &t Ion;, did you stay in Berlin this tine? A As long 'S tf- repairing too-about t.-o reeks. Q Then during this tine ttv_r rcre no e>c-rin^nts? A So. Q Kr. aid the exp-rinents b-gin again? A The beginning of .ay or the rsidele of Uay I ‘Ult *ack with the repaired apparatus; and then wa concluded the exptriaents as quickly as possible. q Did you abbreviate tn* progran rhich you nad l'id out or did you change it ir. any way; or did you keep it to* wo;- it wts? A No, no snort . • ? •• •' v;ri0 5 altitudes in order to conclude the .hole thing .as quickly as possible but in ouch a way that it m actually cesspit tod with adequate results. q Wh-n w s th- second d.at: wr.er- you .-ero pr-sar.t? A That was soon, ft* days after ay return to ^ochau. q Did the death of th. experimental subject occur ir. a way simi¬ lar to the first case? A In gen-r 1, ; s. I don't knor exactly wist hap .»• a. • .r I recall, it ir .n e>ptrinont at a rather high altitude, nd deOti; oc- cur-d quicker, ncr. suddenly. 3 Arri when ms an. third d*ath r.er. you r.re pr e~nt; A That was rigftt afUr that, on the next day, or th, second day. Q Alter these deaths, :ic you never r.;-e -ny • rtus.nt with Reseller .bout his experiments and the wqr in which he p.rfort.d tho^ A Yes, we ---ad sate ainor argu&.r.ts r.sultinr: free. q; ' j ctinns, widen h- always refused tc accept; tut ait.r Lh- third d-itfc mien . stert-d to obj-ct or air., he said first that Hiculer had ordered it raid I wasn't o int-rfere. fiien I later brought 1 * 6603 i ii3y-*-GJ-U-3-Bl^clcy-(lai. Yen Sekon)- Court .Ho. i ease 1 r- lost his patience, and we got rather excited. I uskod hie «hy he -:-3 carrying out these- experiments; what he *rant.d to achiev_. said he w s c. eC.rin; she proble- of caisson diseases, bends, aero-.cboliSE, that he had to clrrify it because Hi=nier had orc.r.c it. He was eh*. Jirot =r.n coring an autopsy ur.d.r wat.r to pror. th.se sir bubbles in •he blood. Also th. question of the -lectrocardioyr.a in b.nds -nd altitude sickness hxi to »>. clnr. bP l«;r had given hia s spe¬ cial ascisncoont >cr it, and Fshrenk c? tns to do this work together with hia. He wanted to qualify as a professor * ith Schit u.nh..ln with this work. Than he brought out a letter tad r-ad to ia. that the oxp.riaents Were to be continued; that Prof. Fshxvnkosp 'tat to b. called in; and that people condesncd to death ho survived the .xp.rinents sould, of course, be par'.cned. Then n. held the letter out to a- and ask.d a.. whether I could re-.d Hla.L.r'3 signature and whether I wouldn't b. sa¬ tisfied with thtt. Q Vies this the lutt.r fr^n bo Prosecution Docus nt Soak 11, 1971b- PS, E-hibit 51? A l’cs, 1971-(b)-FS, cs Txhibit 51. THE PrCSIEE.n: C'-unsel, can you give nc th. page of tr.. English Lo- cuaent Bock on nhic.a that exhibit app.orc? DP. VORFU'-C 51s. Arvl what does this l.tt.r indicate" A It showed that Hiaslur had actually ordered tiles-. -xpw rioents that ho had cocplete, oflici-.l coverage; that tn subjects *-r. to b. pardoned. It says so in the letter. Of course the person condemned to death shall be pardoned to concentration caua> for lif_." TKn it says that fahrenkaaa is to be consulted, On he n.xt pugc It s >s that this order free Hialler gees to the Chief of tnc 3 curity Po¬ lice and the 3D and to ~ -=riF-defu.hr.r Gluccks, with t copy for their infonauticn. Q Eii Roschcr give you any furth r e x pl a nat ion o: tfiis letter? 1 Lr.j-i.-GJ-11-L—'21akl-/-(int. Von Schon)- Court Ho. lcifil A Since I had been prev-nt-c iron doing anythin? by this letter, th_n I calsly asked his what id.s he had of these -xp-ri^nts; what n. wonted to doj what he war. tad to achieve. He said that Ir. : hrenkaep would help hia anc that he would fcav_ _1 ctroc xdiogr.-.-.s for heart fai¬ lure free the nest various reasons and would compare t -= with electro¬ cardiograms in th- case of death t high altitude, * ith the change in severe altitude sickness, with laUr r covery, nd also in the ftosoiUl in lUnich he load taken -lectrocirdiogr as in eases of heart failur.. In Dachau he said he had alsc r .gisUred electro', rciogr.v-s when there were executions by shooting. If hv bed really ccnpil.d ell this material and had evaluated thia a tcrinl together *. th heart specialists, it was, of cours., quite valuable. 6802 Curt 1 y i-it-12-l-HD-Gro8e-von Scbon. «re you vf tc_ oplni r. th.-t the exceri.S3r.ts vhioh SiBcher -serf.riid vers -.erforuvd in order th t ne u.i 0 ht cusUf? 85 s orofessur? «. Whether th?c was the main 3-r-.se or not I cannot , c y. That certainly pleyeu a role in It bet they oei’tclnly vers .rdered by r.iuctlor. . Nov, re ou of trw opinion thst cr.ese experiments vers ordered oy Hlnal.r -it ..is 3- t; esti- or tr-ac Klmuler .rder d the.a before he went to ionlerJ a. Th . is dlffio-lt tv say. It probably nevel pod oredually u.i tr.e O'-sic of r.ls -sports. The rep- rts are written in such a way that he ^resent* the results es very in ortrnt. Tr.ereuown aiatcler or_erea tn« t the experiments be Cv* tinued. Q. But, it Id no doubt a feet th«t .-ascher - t thrt tine had s 3- j-urjea-Vvn ochjn. = : 80 t - va napxer.ed? «. .-r a Keff .-.are. -eff raid txa: I -'ad altitude .ccr.eas ad v s ir.c-.nsci -e in this e cerix-sr.: nc. I :• v ad 6 xav. -c v.ier. me altltoie ws re-ac-h e.ic. a de : c .-^soaer zc? l .-.e w. - to $ -a c..o o vparlaant nci : I vant tv ^at .it .f the on z: ■ r. 3.t, -Tt -->r r'.ar d oa sent t nl-h r -Itit-da with at oayin any ccanti r. c xy 31^.8. *r.d, I -ccaxo 2 tc< e^vir. r.d no aaci aa ein. no ala. aid t.ot I -Id n,t --va any p ; rt a tne a-t pay lr. any way oeceue- : the severe altitude olcxnesa w/.loh wae d a :t c xtined vlth . iC ores5- n disease. I was, n d i e, nc nsci a*. In C.-.er experiments at j<;c..a. I frequently iia«- of tun cicioiau sickness. I oannoc a ay a r.y taln c ''but an indivluUil experiment. *. Keff also reported ..ere, as a rec. 11, or. l/.cldont wltn c tailor. Jo , *u r-sciia tala lncl .oiitV «. ies. I reoexocr It. Hoff t Id two oaaee when 1 w/e Bipjosjd t. nave intervened. I c n ra.ioa.tar nly - with this toll.r wnioil was i it tne xludle - *,rll. In any erse, It ves after olavera’* visit, w/.icn • . * x; me first a ye f A prll. If It a d bean Mfare c l? Visit .'.?6&fier cartalnl w Id .* ve t«>ld slv^rcc- -’ll d it It -s .1 t Id fr f335-r *.rjc t 1-tor. It '-as o> Jt --a : 11 wa: Koff xet ffle in fcfke .. l', or In thfc office, gic t so - r.e 3el- s .j^t..ln_ wr n & was ..-In c an in tho checb-jr. .-aachcr Oed -rdcr Q a prisoner c :e :r J u ..t •a «*r. exc-.rlxontcl subject. This nsn wee not a v lxr.t#er end w.-.q n-/t l- ndosr.ed t dea til ene w« s be In- or i.ac by an 53 -am, against .As will, ria knew It -ixself because •.new tne man. r.e was a tailor w v s v.riln. In * 0 w r. sn.p. ne Mi xe t>> and se_ ^sener rt-d th incident, nd soon aft-X that th_ Ca p Conaindant c.-.-w and B scii.r -old his about the r;^>lu ii-cider.t indignantly . B- dcavnd- od tha So nar. bo punish.d, and I c;r. roc all that aft. marie ho talked to ~ j cbout this SS aan and said that thoso wore p-r^aps not tha *or8t orv_s but such a r.an could not bo allowed to stay in tb concentration casp service. Ik did consult the c tap Cos :.t ad did probably disp.nr- -rith the charges against his nd r innljy -5 nan cent to th- Eastern front in penal company, rh t reported to th- c-np Jo.jcnndanC and this lnaodintely lir.ppt-nod convincod iau that things in the cone tion c r aorr ctj fcCOo r-y 1 —51-:—12-7—'-ross (Inc. 7on Scl'.oon) Court ::o. 1 5c=h cxccsro* of individuals which co»ild hap en were ircediately settled and punished* After this incident Kucher aide ac .,iw -v »:ord of honor chit I would not say anything about the whole setter. I ins obligated to secrecy nbcut the. experiments and whit I saw ir. the concentration cnap but for this thing he felt certain personal rcs;or.sibility and such an incident night start rumors "jid put th- concentration crup in a bad li;ht. Since this matter rs settled irwdiatcly quite officially ir/ Kucher I sw> him this prouis.. Lctor on we want to iast Prussia • VrotooHK Vast on tie train. H. told Professor luost of this incid-nt with ell details. :»e expresscd his indignation and he spoke to V >• sc for a long tit. whether teodiatj transfer to the front would be enough punishn-nt and Profocsov test nssur.d hin that he had acted correctly. T: : manat Counsel, ta. MW All new V. ir; w*easfl until It 30. 07 1 Kr.y 47-;.-S'~-15-i-?oster-Int: Rnmlor Court 86 . 1 AFT-iHIfOON SESSION (Tho Tibur.-l rooor.vonod r.t 1530 hours, 1 !i.y 1947.) THE : -JISI- L: Bio Tribun rl is :.gr.ln ir. soerion. EA-IS RT32HO - Rosuncd DIRECT 2 u.' iT.-.TI01I (Continued) .jv 7 jR. vor -ERK (Counsol Tor tho Dofondnnt Ronbor3): n .. Ro-iburs, before the noon r-coas you wmo do scrib¬ ing to tho Tribun. 1 th j incidont with tbo tr.ilor. Do you know who the r southing : ctur.lly h..p>onod in thr.t cr.so to tho offoct thr.t tho S3 acn who h d brought tho tr.ilor .long wr.a hold to account? ... Yob, t ny r..to ho t roeaoved fror. the caap. ?. .sc! cr told no th .t bo w. s tr .nsforrod, nd 2 off r.lso stutod horo tlv.t to r:.s r d. o. Hoff wont on to toll bout - socond incidont r} cro r.a roault of your intorvention cn oxporinontr.l subject * a not \d.*.i ttod to tho oxpcricont. Do 70 U remombor th-.t socond incident? ... Ho, I do not rcr.oabcr thr.t. 1 . Tihr.t vr s Hoff 1 s position during thoso ox/oriiaonts rnd whr.t w;.3 his r.ttitudo tonrrd3 thorn? ... Hoff did not plry .ny oscor.ti 1 pr.rt for r.o during thoco oxperinonta ;.nd he did not cono ut 11 into tho Iforo- grourd. He r:.s tho block oldest of our oxocrinont 1 subjects who wero livirr r.t tho block rri r.c . fornor nurso of that str.tucn ho v s to .ssirt us whenever neccsr .ry. Vo h d cert in qurlific .tions in his c. pncity r.s -. rv.lc nurro t’ t Hoff .-opmontly plr.yed r. certr.ir. dcublo roll d-ring tfcofo :inonts only bocao clerr to ao hero. :.t th t timo I soluto inuressior. thr.t Hoff v s foolir.-* s prir- d-V. cr.-r cr.d-i\d tJo s .-re ttitUdo townrda Rr.schor'fi oxporlcor.tr • 5 1 . r. 4$ jis the only vr.j ono cm oxplr.in th -t I rpoko to j j 6(306 1 I'j.y 47-.-£”-12-2-?or Cor-Int: R.\nlor Court Ko. 1 Jfo'f -bout ny ..ttitudo tow.'-rds ib.sctur's exp rimente r.nd cl t I told. Lin th.-.t I wo'.'id ondo:.vor to got tl o ch.'-rabor from there tl rough tho hoi? of !!ilch. If I Iv d consid- -r-d Hoff 5 r. Kr.po, r.a c. tin who w e .'.gainst tho inn tea, • I ' ouId nov».r h..vo apokon to iioff ..bout ?. schor r aid Us experiments in r. rojocting r.nd critic ;.1 r.;r.nur. I cannot iut.gino tho fact tl- t Hoff !:now r.bout Rr.aclnr 'e cxporinor.ts • that hid r. fatoful roault, or th t ho hod :.ny knox/lodgo ' of thorn. I c n only explain that if ho hod known -bout thorn Rnschor would h \ o told bin to k«op ovorytl ing secret. Kr.turally, lo :uat h..vo kopt ctr*ctly to tlr.t diroctivo cinco my betrayal of R .achor no Id hr.vo h d tho most serious coraoquoncoa for Hoff. In ..dditl n, Hoff h. d boon pro:ilsod roioaao tho anno wr.y • .c all ether oxpori»..Gnt..l subjects . nd w..s actually rolor.aed on anrch 1944. jjxy such proraiao, of course, h d a fr.toful Import;.nco for Hoff nd th:.t wr.y porhr.po expi: ins hie poculi .r behavior. In upito of that, thoro cm bo no doubt tl. t .-.’off with his mr.omoct fooling was on tho sldo of tho Inn toe. 11 is ic confirmed by tho fr.ct thr.t after war ho wont back to Dachau rd onco more wont into tl o r r.ks of tho inrr.twS, .-.rd also th.-t ho 1 ndod to tho a&er- icm rroeps .11 incr^.iir tinr ..: ten .1 :.bout tho SS tl ore rd told bout tl u ir<- lid . ctior., -’urthomoro, thir shows th..t ho found 1 is placo within tho ranks of tho victii.s of Fascism. li r.y of 1 ^s o cr.-g.r-tod and incorroct testi¬ monies c n bo explained 07 tho toetincnioc w: ich may mennin to klnsolf too. Wfc* t .jo the testimonies tl-.t you ccnsidor to bo oxag- aorations, or that you consider to bo f iso to tinonios, ’-c wl .t extant do yov. beiiova tl* .t the so tor tinoni-s wore ir.corroct? 6509 I - 7 47-..-S"-13-3-”o£ Gcr-Int: Itrjalor Court :to. 1 I c n onl ox_.l..In t: .t In r. fcv individual cr.sos. Tor ir.rtr.nco, Hoff is : lvmys apo..fcIn 3 of tor. wo non o vroro u.cd during tl.cso oxpor'lnonts. In tfco documents, howovor, only four r.ro bcir-s nontionod. 6810 , . i-A-'S-lli-i-rarrtw (Int. Ra-vlsr) Court So. I hay it please Y OUr =onor, whenever the defendant or defense counsel are referring to statements of the witness Heff, t0 uld they kindly refer to the i»^o n-xzber of the record? EJf D VCC&-3®: q Vfe'ra here concerned for exn r ?le with experiments or. .H-ssian officers - experiments on two officers, if you rtweaber, V. R01- berr.. These ire testimonies wr.ich can he found on page $?5 and 5 7 fc of the German transcript, tet is it you can say about these experiments and Heff's explanation that he is giving in connection with that experiment? A l» not an expert in cold questions, 'out I think that the description of this experiMnt to lordly exaggerated. I think it 1 , lnjoseiblo that it could hare boon ciu-rlcd out in that nnnor. I have looked through the cold question. o. they bocoae opporont, for inotar.ee, the Descent 1.28, Exhibit 91, on page U of foot report, and I also looked at the Document Ho. Ml, Exhibit 93, which io the report on tho cold onforeneo held ot ltumborg, on peg, 1,3 of tho report, According to theeo doecrlptlone of the other cold oxporiaonts, tho rotor begins to a ppear after a .cry ■aort tine, after approximately ton to twenty ninuteo, and makes any lovccwnt or speech on tho port of tho experimental subjact Impossible. After, at the latest on. hour, unconociousness appears, gaff, or. tho other hand, states hare that these two Suasion officers, ever, after a period of threo hours, were speaking to one another and were in poesossion of their full conociousnose and then ha Mid that they even .nook hands. I can not imagine that thla-parted of tine could have elapsed. The ease becoees apparent _ frees the American work on cold „estiona where it is stated that, in caae of sea rescue, the rigor occurs after e eery short tie*, approximately ten sdnutos, and this regor would sake any entry into toe rubber rescue boat impossible, q Neff, or. page 69h of tho Ccrsan trensoript, goes on to My that .(=; 1-A-TK-li.-2 -tarrom (Int. R-nir) Court So. 1 g^scber w?e producing cya n c ali tablets which were to be Brulloved tr the inaates. Sor.e of the people had died under severe pain. At the and he s^-s "Axong our ccxxades we said, by way of figure of speech, and I quote, they are producing a. drug which would kill us very quickly as soon as sooethin happens." A Well, he is contradicting hLrself here by saying that the in- aates lost their life under severe pain. Then he goes or. to say they found a drug by which they car. die without pain. 3ut, it is well known that potassiua cyanide kills without any pain. q i havo .lust been informed, Mr. President, that, through error, tho release of Keff was stated as boin^ in the year of 39L5 instead of the year 1912. It should oc 1912. Regarding tho voluntary aspect of the oxoorinental subjects, Foff, on page 656 and 657 of the Ooruan trrascript, as well cs on Pa&o 711 and 712 of th. Osman transcript, states as follows, and I aioto: "A volunteering for the so oxp.rir-.nto >.«s made possibU rlicn tho person concerned turrwd to Reecter on his ovn initiatiTc. That was not difficult boewise RascJwr vos around the cr. p a lot. NaturA ly, every prison, r who is hungry end is working on a difficult do toil, knowing that at the experimental station ho would rccoivo better nourishment, will try to got there. In addition, tho Roichsfuohror 5 S promised the inflates that they would bo roloseod." yfo&t can you MQT about this testimony of ltoff*e? A Tho first testiaony, There soys that of two hundred expori- -ental subjects only ton worn voluntary, and this latter testiaony that you ixntion cm not be brought into conformity, and, therefore, contradict one mother. In addition, I think that tho. numb-r of two hundred experimental subjects iu largely exaggerated. q Let us now revert to tho experimental subjects. Whr.t '*'d"os did the experimental subjects wear who wore at disposal for tho experiments for rescue from high altitudes? A They had badges as they wer. by professional tri ands. 6Ci w l-A-3£—i_—3—Karro* (in;. Court So. 1 4 -hr: they ^recn only, or wore other badges anon* then? A ! ! o, oil these badges were trec-n. All, with the exce-tion of Kifi, u o v.*as wearing arod bac^e, but ho was not a real expi-rixntal subject. Q Did Hoff participi tc in r.r^ experiments as an exput that? A As far cs I saw tb. axperi-v.ntal subjects, and you oust keep in aind that I only s-.w ao-.all ort of then, they wore green badges end wuro thereby dosignatodos cri-ainals. Thor- wor-, hovr- * ever, a fir., red ones aaon^, then vho had boon sonUnccd because of high treason or such sinilnr offonsos. ; The witness Hoff, who tostifled horu, was also heard in tho filch trial which was running ci ultaneously to this one. Do you know that? AYs. 1 Tho witness cays b.rc, on pa> ?73 to 97h of this record, end I quotot "It wns ay impression that Dr. Hcubcrg was not in corculoto rxcord- nec >ith the oxperiaents Dr. Case her wr.s performing, and intondod to got the chambers aw,-y fror the ca p as quickly as po»ible. faschor, on tl- oth.r hand, 'as attcipting thu contrary. He v anted to keep fro chancers as lor.- *s poaaiblc in th- coroonfcmtion c.aij. Tc hat extent Dr. Rooberg succeeded in gotting the chambers away Tlier, or rather, to what extent Itcschor succeeded in k-^ping then th.ro for a longer period of tin-, I ‘on*t know." Did you spunk to Hoff at fiat ti.-c to tbs effect that it was your vish to rorovc the chambers fro th c.a p as quickly as uossiblc? 6013 r.y l-A-"X-lii-i;-&UTow (In.. 8a l.r) Court To. 1 A all, be is s vir._. I discussed this setter aith Ida at that tiro for the recsor. I siot_d before; naaely, that I considered ikff r.s nasc:v;-rs op one at Rascher, of course, vaan*t allowed to l^irn about that, and it ie for this reason that Neff hnors that I endeavored to gut t'nt ch-»ber awry. Q Wall, how «rer t. s. -xpcrjjxjnts finally stopped? rci4 1 :'-.y 47—-Sh-lS-l-lL-ley-Int: Rualor court HO. 1 . 71.o lx. sis for this atoppr.go v. s the r.gro orient ronchod "lotwcor. Ei.ipkc, Ruff nd nysolf. o intondod to proiond Chcro v a n» urgont re-sen for tho cfcaber being ronovod, r.d tth.oroby atop the oxpor ironts. It v. a dif icult, howov.r, Co oxocuto th:.t pirn. Hoithor towards Ilirrilor nor tonrrds Rr.ccher could ro cito tho ror.son r.s to tlo f.-.t.-.litics c .used V' Ih.achor. Tho only thing wo could s:.y xir.a thf.fc th.oao chrabors \/oro urod for :.ir nccidonta. Ibis, of courso, vr.sn't r. vory strong ror. aor.. Rr.sohor vhon I roturned frou 3orlin -.nd tu.do tho first indie, tiona thr.t cho ebrjabora w.a to bo usod .r.d v;hon I told l it: tl .t wo would h-'.vo to finish tho oxporiinonts vory quickly, Ik.schor didn't ror.ct to thr.t :.t s-.ll, but told .-ao th t ho would interveno with. T.i :lor nd lliicb - nd got tl o permission for t. longer uargo of tho ch-ribor, something w) ich ho in offoct c.clicvcd, Ilowovur, whon llilch'a order to thr.t offoct c ac tl o cl cxibor h:d alrocdy boon removed. Iho br.aic proroquisito for gotting tlo chnabcr ..tn.y vr.a to bring tho oxperinonts for roscuo from hiyh nltitudo to r. quick conclusion .rd in ..ddition to finish tho film w' ich v/..a to bo tr.kon r.'*out tloso oxp rinonts, 3 rosvlt of Klnrtlor's order. Only by fulfilling tlo:.o two doonnds wlich woro n.do by Cinalor v a ho ir. position to influonco Hc.sehor to gr«o to tho toapor ry ronovr.l of th .t chmb-r. I -xph.inod to hix th t there would bo littlo oonso in gutting permission for tho cl.Jnbor to bo retained for furtl or period of tv;o or throo vooks .nd told hin tl t I \k .s suro tl t oi:o noodod the chc.s£>er t the front Vory quickly. I siv ostod to hin tl :.t it t ov.ld bo r. much, hotter wey to got ti ls chr-ribur :.t l~tor cLuto to Dr.chnu tl rough otl or no. ns for r. longer period of tire. I told him th: : ho could thon c.rry out tic work vl ich ho v .a ordered to do by 6S15 1 :v.;- 47-. -ST-15-2-:'--loj-mt: Rr.nl CT Court "o. I yiml.r. I said tint lo also could p rticiy^to cnco :?cro in tho oxJcrinonts for tho pvrposo of savin- pooplo from • igh altitudoa. Only bj* using this t.-.ctic wr.s it possible t! r.t Ihasckor didn't opposo the ronov..l of tl c chc tibor .and tk t ho didn't auccoud to get .an order to t* o crrtr .ry from ki-iOcr or hilch. It cm hardly be concoivod th-at ho would h:.vo succovdod ir. gcttir.3 such r.n order tl rough. Ho actually did that, aid one cr.n soo it by looking r.t tho lottor from Uiloh to 'olff, t: is ia Docunont H0261, Exhibit 63, in Document 3ook II dr.tod 4 Juno 1942. In conclusion I si ould like tcstr.to onco coro tfcr.t r.t no ti.:o would it hrvo boon possible for myono, not ovon ”ilcb or Kippko to ro:.io”o tho chamber r.r .inst Uicxilor or Jl.ascK r's will from tho concontr tion cmp. *1. V/)on w o tho chamber ror-ovod from tho ocr.p? ... Hint was on tho 19th or 20th of Kay. :t any r.-.to baforo tlio order l'ippko'8 or ‘'.ilch'o dated tl o 20th of Documont 343?S, Exhibit 62, could havo achloved .any offoct. Ih- t wr.s on tho 19th or 20th of ?!:.y, :nd not r.t tho boginriing or ond of June .e Hoff said hovo or in ,.uyuct r.s tho Prosecutor a ys, low io it th..t you know ox ctly th t tho ch-mbor left tho cmp on the 19th or 20th of "ay? ... I-’ortunr.toly I havo in ny possession r. fow fim datos bout t‘is oxo. rir.ontr.1 sorios rl ich do givo mo sor-.o hints. At first it w s tho birth of my child, da to 19tl of Hr eh t rr'. ich tir.o I wont to 3 rlin. Sinco tho birth '-..e orig-. inrlly oxpected on tho 9th of -hrch I know I xr s thon in 2-rlin. .-*3 I sc.id beforo I returned to 3orlln cn tho 19th cr 20th of ' ri ch rnd thon I .also know tl- t I wont to lerlin for Easter, .and that I rt.ayod th.oro r. fow days ftor -hastor. I know th.at I was in 3orlin on the 1 st .ard 5816 1 Kny 47-—S15-3-Kaloy-Int: Ronior Court No. 1 2 nd of 2>.y, and I also know that I scr.yod in Dmlir. for scr.otiac because chon tfco bnronotcr was ropairod, I :.lso •-now that T’hitoim occurred on tho 24 th of "ay and I know it.t in tho wo ok boforo '.'it sun I had c.lro'dy loft. Dv.t ur.s on n Tuo sd- .7 or V'odnoadr.y. I spont r fow days r.t tho DVL, nd I know that ovon after ' itsun I didn't rotum to Dr.chnu, For that ro. son I know oxr.ctly th .t tho chamber u r rorovod on tho 19th or 20th in tho wook boforo "hitsun. *. Dr. Ruff, who was fc.ro yostord.-.y or tho day boforo r.s r. witness, h. s n-.uo st.-.tononta to tho offoct that a detailing to branch of tho DVL r.t Dr.chr.u wr.a not possiblo; v\v.t is your r.ttitudo to th-.t question; '/ill you oxplrin thr.t ;.s briefly r.s possiblo? .a. Dr. Ruff h..a sr.id thr.t in ossonco. ’bon tho or.purimonta start R .schor was still do tailed tc tho instituto of Woltz, which was r. nilltr.ry agoncy of tho l'odior.l Dispoctorr.to, L.tor Rasober sug orts, or o kr.ow fron tho lot';or of :^s. Raschor, Document NO 264, Exhibit 60, thr.t to dotr.il him to tho Branch r.t Dr.chr.u of tho DVL. -7b Iff writoa tho e~no thing in his lot tor to Hippko. ibis can bo oxplninod rinco R scher nor r.y othor SS agoncy woro clo r .-.bout tho organization of tho DVL. *;o after .11 woro no military organ! z. tion , r.rd Raschor noitl or during tho oxpcrlmonts nor L.tor uhon ho wr.s in 3orlir. for tho pur peso of working out tho roport wr.s dotailod to tho DVL. fl.oroforo, it wr.s impossible for bin to bo do tailed to my branch which after -.11 was r.or.-oxistont. If in cffoct my such dotails b*d boun ra:do o’ojocti n would h.vo been raisoc in tho Pcrscnnol Department end wo would t.uo found out about it. - t any rate I didn't personally hoar or soo of any such dotails. I re .lly didn't ’mow uhon ho loft tho ~oltz Instituto. I or.l- know that tho ack-ack Artillery School at Schongau had 6817 1 'Vt 47-..-15-4-: Ir.loy-Infc: Rculor Court iro. 1 te^n s“r.tod Ir. hi a orders Ixccuso ho ofton •:ont to this pL.co by c-.r :-ai on th-.t occ tion ho told no ti: t ho would ti.vo to bo officially dotr.ilod thoro sir.co otl orwiso his ex would fci-vo to bo a topped. For tho purposo of 1 is Dr.chnu journioe ho h. d rocoived spuci:.l por...iasion by tho Roich3- fuuhror SS. Tho oxp-ro:sion DVL 1! br:.ncltherefore is wrong rjxl u»y nilitr.ry transfer tl ore is inposaiblo. Q. } .a it often h-.. poned tl t r. Ir forco officora h: d boon dotr.ilwd to Adloratof to t! o DVL thoro? A. Yea, v:o hrd LufturJfo officora working with ua. Ihoy woro dotr.ilod to us by tho ~odic:.l Inapoctorr.to who Imow tho aitu-tion r.nd who didn’t dotr.il thou to ua diroctly, but to tho rdr ochool r.t . dL-rslof, or to sono ..ir forco institution thoro for tl o purpooo of ;.ctu..lly working with ua. Thoroforo, you r.ro of tho opinion thr.t r.ny dotr.iling of ..ir forco p*. ycici..na ur.a iupocsiblo to your instltuto bocr.uao your lratltuto w on't r. uilitrxy ono, do I undor- rt nd you corroctly? A. Yoa. '. ihon did you rxrivo in : 5orlin r-ftor tho corclvoion of tho oxpori.cnt? A. I ulror.dy sr. id on tho 20th of r.y. I nm auro thr.t on thr.t dr.to I wr.a r.g: in in Jorlin. j. fort vooks olr.peed, purlv.pa two or tl rou uooka until R.-.achor :.rrlvod in Gorlin in ordor to work out tho raxtu .1 report r.bout tho oxper- ir.onts. !!o fc.d not boon dot .ilvd to us, ov.n for tl ...t period of ti ;c. Me acr.Iy recoiv^d guest tr .vol ord-re w: ich r.utlorizod hin to ont-r the tcrrr.in of tho DVL. 6818 Court I 1 16-1 - a - LJG . -jefaan (Reader) 5. How was this chamber sent — by rail or by cox to adlorshcf? A. as Rufi said yesterday, it cane back by rail bocaus^ to did not have enough dicool oil for that purpose. How was the research report compiled, the report on tho research of saving people from high Ititude? ,v. Rancher, as I said, care to Berlin in the beginning of Juno and together we stirtcd writing tho report or. the basis of ny book and that is tho report which is available h.ro. Raschor insisted on pointing out the necessity for a continuation and extension of tho experiments. I ha-1 no objection to that because 1 personally intend¬ ed to continue these oxperiianta too. In particular, to find out what the eff^c.o cf cold wor. in tho caso of a parachute descent. Of courso, our opinion as to tho onputtnants diff-rod. Rascher ir.tundad to con¬ tinue tno oxpuriaunts in Dachau on ir. '.toa, but 1 intended to carry then on at r. institute, DVL, but I did not speck about that. 3hon at the end of tho report I acULd tho sontenoo that no cases of death had occurred in taosc oxporlvaor.t3, Raschor had no objection at all. his is a clotr proof that Rascherconsidorod tho oxporinonts, which ho pjrfonaed by order of KimnLx, as his p^rscml work and property, ‘hose experiments hod nothing to do with tho experiments conducted for tho pur; os« of rescuing people from high altitude. ..hor. talcing into consideration Raschor '5 personality, there can bo no do*i)t that Rascher would havu had no inhibitions to introducing a ruport about death cases in a top 00 crat document if such nsc.s Jiad occurrud in ’ho latter report. Regarding the cold experiments, whic Rasc.cor wrote together ith Holxlochnor and Fink, there wore r-any r-ports about cases of death. Ir. addition, I would novor h -ve be.n irresponsible enough to in¬ troduce a r^saarch report, which mas t.o bo the r_scu_ basis for our future flights and experiments and w:ich ras to influence the air-force, in which I concealed such a decisive point as this would havo had tho cost serious conseouer.ces for the future. It is really not necessary 6?19 Court I * tey u?-A - 16-2 - LvG - Xoehazi (Havaler) tc speak ebout itj it is just out of the question. Huff never would hav^ countersigned any such report, it that tine there was really no r-aaon to keep quiet about any cases of death, because no one really would have held re to account for causing any cases of death. Q. The witness, Jfcff; has testified hare that you yourself had s-rved aa an experimental subject during these experiments. Up to ■hat altitude did you ascend? A. I participated in a nuaber of experir.jnts. n t one ti;"e I ■as tno accompanying physician in the experiments and went up to 12,000 to 13,000 liters ard then 1 participated in a nunber of self experiments, 'hioh hare been discussod hare. In addition there was explosive doccapr-ssion axperiner.ts of a pursuit descent at 19 kilo- aetero without a supply of oxygon. 4. In July cf 19U24 report was Bade to Hinnl&r, together with Raschorj how did this roport coco about and what happened there? In Ally -I hovo forgotten tho exact dato — teacher suddonly ippjarod in Berlin. Ho telephoned ao at tho D.7.L. and asked no to aeet hin. I loft .^dlurshof and - at hits in Berlin. Ho told no that both of us had b.un ordered to go to the Fuehrer's hotdquarb.ro to ruport and wo both wont to the Rcichsfuuhrer SS oflicu in Berlin. There thoy already had our train tickets ready for us. Thon no hoard tbs filn about th_- experiments, runt to ay department and I telephoned luff. I told hin about the natter. Thon, I had to cntinge, pack,»and we left tho saw evening. '.to had a special train with sleepers on the train. Hascher mot Professor Vraost, -ho also was going to tho Headquarters on this journey and ha told him once nore about tho notorious reports -about tho taylor. Q« u hon did you arrive at the Headquarters? A. The next cornirg; we w„nt by car to Hlnaler's special train, which had not y_t arrived,but which was due to arrive that •_ voning. He arrived 1 te that night and he heartily grfeted teacher. Or. this occasion, teacher introduced oe to nfcszlor. (a-.=.-ior) c rt : . i. 3 Did HfcrOor say anything else during that ccr.- forenco? - After this G^-rr-ssL-i, ?ilcnc- fib ver, HisAcr e vlca ah ut the d p p nn ds that that t tul x-j- effort node cr. no and Ivj said th-.t it v-sa*t -akin: t? ruch v. use con- cor.tr-ti. a c*r. lnrotus f r those c.vtri^nts, wha were n-t -jipi.V -.t the front. This ie tl~ ray ties, people cculd rehabilitate thoosclvcs, poaple qendtonod to dc-.th could thcr-by bo pard;ncd, -ad they caul-’ bw :.ivcr. an opportunity t* fi^kt r.t tho frrnt. Ho furt‘^r at id that weaver didn't c-^Lrstnnd that c uld n t : r.vo unc'orst d th-.t in this vrr V Cl:: r 6»nth for Oorasay. ?h«n ho or.t n t- spe-Jc ab ut the 1 ssos in the Erst and pertieu- 1 rly the 1 sees cf the SS and h w his ho-rt vna blooding ov-r;- ti-o ho ho-rd th-.t -n-thar thousand f his mrndarful b >s hr/ diod. 1 . t laprossicn did th so at'.taints n-ikc on you? *• ..oil those sure words tir.t actually ondu sonse nr,.. • v r, I V'O firstly decidjc' nov.r - -in t oo perate rith Rasofaur. ", An‘ vhr.t h-.pp_r.ci -ft_rt« r-’a, \.-.s tbj filn eh m? Oh, yes, nft«nrords '« wont into a r. c and there thJ fil ut the oxparlwcnts was shcui. Hlsnlnr was v ry satisfied with the filr. -and the oxnrlints and ho thought ;.-t these ex?rfc*r.t3 n_ro f oxtr-r-o lap rtance fer tho •^•ftwafl-- ‘.ad that they v uld 3~vo tho lives f snny n pil t. Aftjrv-rs ve sax it in tc_ novs reel and in tho P.uroian -Hit ary filr. 1 V.t v-.s y nr i-pressi n r.b:ut the entire confer¬ ence y u and with Hiaalcr? A oil, r.t that tiro I did hava _ very strcnc ii>- -russirn about this conference. Those s_ri-us conditions. 5323 (Sa-iiler) 1 -’ay jC-0.t-2-.Cook 'curt I / I hoard .about the losses Ir. the East and about the total war effort wer ® in such strong contradiction to what I had road in the press, that : woild perhaps ever, have participated in the cold experiments as • they wore &rforned by Raschcr and the carelessness ha had sham toward honor, life. For that reason, when HLmior askod ne to participate in the cold exp.jris.mts I triod to got away trea that duty and I succeeded ir. doing so. 1 Therefore, although you wore selected for those experiments you rofusod to take part, is that right? 1 Yos. ^ '/hen did Raschor first plan to carry out the cold experiments, so far as you krww? A During tho high altitude oxporinonts in Dachau ho oolloctod lit raturo on the subject, ar.d no doubt had it planned, and whother it * Hinnl.ir cr Rasoher I don't know. Ho also showed no tho work by faith and Fay about the treatnont of cancer with cold and ho askod no to work on those planned oxporinints with hin, hut I always carefully triod to pet out of it. rk on tho cold oxporinonts. I was, thoroforo, nploasantly surprisod -‘hen Himlar suddenly personally gavo no tha iuri^Bont to carry out tho axpsriconts with Raschor. ;her. he gavo r.o t; '° as3ismont I triad to got cut of it by saying I was already ovor^- ■••orkod at the DVL. Ho imedlatoly offered no assistance to got free free tho DVL and I gave up objecting. I thought it Court 1 1 -3-Cook lor) l;g «»ld a P°asiile to ^t fro. by rynolf a* I decided to diMSpaar inoonapicnpudly joot « it.too Mtf: alUtodo exponents a d I c,odod it dotai >0. '.a .oatio! *c: , t ^ -, utloa ■drastc- '-'On tS. flL von «<», I, of course, did not brin up tho oobjact_cf tit cold t= tri-oat,, end it iltwlf did not nontion it .it-.-r, I on, all tho noro cottOa-ml toon wton Htschar in Uctobor -p.atrad Ir. !.brtr nth Holtioain-r and they hod tlraody co ...lotod tho exponent a. ^ Did .ou uv-r csk R-ochor Vnathor tho oxp-rinentel subjocta waro pardoned or rol.es.d, tte poopla *-.o hid partlcipat-d ir. tho high altitudo axpwrlaonte A. Cr.Co ...on >c visits Hi aler, Hi ol.r a -id that the people ° Uid JO roloC3 ^ 1 ** v '‘ c " 1 .‘icac .or in Nurnb-rg at tho cold .-—ting, I caked hi < and ha said that thoj had to.n r.lo. s*d. 3. loa -re Jvat awaking cl c fila ahown in thu R_ich Aviatjor. .inistry, and you no doubt wot* a brief report on it. That ia docu- »-nt b. k ; .2 of - - Iroa-cotlon, .\o 2?M, Inhibit 76j Than was thia filai chown? ■ A. * ScRe., tho d to only fro' th is report rtiich I wrote and which ia in ; docu.„nt bock. I ! t*io doich Avi-tion ministry on th .t date and I s*t Packer there. Tfco r jS t of tho rooting is described bottor in this file not* than I can r-perduco it froz =-.nory. ^ft_r tho unsuccessful nttcept to show it, *ilch had failed to turn up and aiscr.er ref-used to t_il re riout tn«sc axparioents without tho pruseaco of Ich. This had annoyed tho doctors who wore Interested. . Raschur 1 *. edi -ly aclo- :.ur: So. 1 1 Hay-*-GLS-17-4-Cock (hanlcr) (20 jfcoced at. Siorers and t-ld hia about the feilurc of the Shoving very is-il gr.r-r. tly, became hi8 vanity vas hurt, iievers, vfeo '-es just about t. go -c e trip, asked both of us to ceaa to the rciir oei eteiion end vhen vc =wt hi= there he tried to ctl= hatcher dovn end thought that n.thing ceuld be achieved with exciteaent. He asked ae to v-ite e brief note eb-u: vhat had happened that coming and to send it to bin. He asked r:-ut the fila end when vw told hia ve had left the file in the Avlntl.n kislstry he advised us to go get the fila bccruso of the .bligation to secrecy, but I ves n.t able to do sc until the nort day. Did yott h.rr anything acre about the fila later? A. ’Jo, I never heard anything aorc about it. In hroaaetttion Soomnt Hock So. 2 there art a nuabor of rie- turcs. Did you take these oictures? A. Ij, I did n »t take thoao pictures. ! cm say the folloving ab-ut these pictures. Vfcen those olcturec voro thovn t. ac during as Interrogation, I vac told they crce fr.a o ootion picture fila and the prvsvcutioc said the scao thing hero. I thought that aoar.t the fila which I Icaev the notl-n ticturo of the ojrncriaents vhon I v 0B nrcser.t, hut vhcr. I looked at tho uictureo I vc# inaedia.tcly able to 000 that f .ur of thoa at the a.tt could have cone froa that notion -oicturo. I osouccd that Heather night have taken another fllr- behind *ry back. In the seantinc I heve realitcd, having looked at tho oictures clorely, that not c single -no -f then cocas free that notion picture. • knov •hot because in the filr. vhich vos taken in tho exnoriaonte there c cl-ck in the background and lnstruat&U in the foreground. Th: t vrs necuseary in order to be able to use the fiLt lrt^r. It v*c oosaiblo ,niy ec the tint 6626 1 Court *o 3-17-5-Cook . 1 . ~ltitu^c vcr„ rl * r;a relator n the fills* ..Iso r-3Chi.r l'-'' put rountcr suits or. tho c,Xf.c.r ir-nt&l subjects -•uriar picture. 0&-27 1 *37 47 -A-lft-I-pkp- 31'kloy (von Schon) Court Mo. 1 Case 1 Q. In those pictures which arc in Document Book II sre there » instruments -nd r.o clock? A. Ko, I’ve looked at then carefully. Ttet could not bo sverlookod. Tfut was & big clock with a big- seccod-hand which was beside the head of the subject. Q. That is proof to yen that these pictures do not came Iron the fila? A. That they do not cooe froa the fils, yes. The witness jv’cff, who was probably present when these photographs were taken, iaaodlately realized the difference when the pictures woro shown to his here. He says on page 661 of the Gercrn transcript, I quote: "■When the fils was token tho prisoners were given a civilir.n suit and it could not be seen thfct they wore prisoners. These are photographs; end I knar that when prisoners were photographed, they wore given a fairly clean suit with no insignia. That is oo in Munich; nd I want it to be clear tfr t tho flLn that was shown at tho uinistry is not in the hands of tho prosecution. Had said film bs~n in the hands of the- prose-cution, it certainly would h ve. be«n shewn hen. during our cae< in chief; nnd m wtill art. in search of such films. a. VQP.ZRK: kr. President, I should Uko to havo the ^ -xol nation of the prosecution tret the pictures in Document Book II * re not submitted as having been taken during the experia-nts for r-scue froa high altitude. If I understood urn. prosecutor correctly, that is the explanation he just made. IE. HARDY: Your Honor, the prosecution docs not state that 6823 1 ifcy hi -A-18-2-an- 31 kley (von- Schcr.) Court !»o» 1 C'55 1 • acs- plctaros «vro not token during the course of those -xperiae.uts. I ^3 c-r-ly trying to clorify it that these photographs which hcvo w^n offer-d in -vidcncc end '.re contained in Docuaer.t 3ook 11 cro not extracts of the fils, that is, as far cs m know. It nay well b« that tte srac type oictures appear on the fila; out the prosecution hes not soon t ho fila that was shown at tte RUi and docs not have the filff that was shown at all. Th- first four pictures in Docuuont 9 odt II have boon oroperly identified by no less than defendant Ro^Jorg hinsolf; -nd th. re.Tr.ind*r of the pictur.s hav- bu-r. identified by the witrv-ss Neff when he w.*.s hero on the witness stand. Me contend that these cxv pictures of the uxp-riner.ts at Dachau. ER. V23t-.'£RK: I esk th't tho transcript show thr.t these pictur-s do not cco. froa tbs fila which was taker, of the oxperire-nts for rescue froa high altitude. 1K£ PRESIDSirr: Eie record will sn*. the statenent of counsel for tbs prosecution. That is ns far as tho Iribur.-1 will go in tho aattor; red counsol nay proceed with tho ux'-duvition of tho witn-oc. IRE i.lTiuESS: Ury I say sooething elt*. -bout those pictures? Bf u&. V£P..tfRK: Q. Plccaj do. A. I said at the b-giming that when I was shewn those pictures I was told that they cren. froa a notion picture fila; and the prosecution said thj orj*. thing hero. I thaxght th-t night mocn .. L.ic-. filn, f or jx.inple, not necessarily a nation picture. Only when the pictur-a Were shewn to s« did I think that they nwint th* t it actu' lly can- frea a notion pictun- nu tnought th t it- night have ccrv. froa this notion pictuie of tho exp-ria-nts. Since ^ I did not know those photographs but only kr,-w tho notion picture, I c 3 suT.;d ir. tile beginning that th--y wore th. s.-^ thing; but becaue- tfo, iratruaer.ts are Lacking and because cf the t-stiaa-r.y of Neff, it is clearly proved that not a single ore- of those pictures coo-s Iren th. notion picture but Iran c private fila ir. the possession of 6329 1 1^7 47 -«-ia-3-3:^ 3I:kU7 (vcc ~chor.) Court to. 1 Cr ^ 1 Rrscr.cr, r. Loic~- fils, photographs which he probably took for hia priru. work or or -Is work to qualify ~a a professor, hen '.ics the Cold sweting in Kumberg? A. That was in October. Q. How did it coa« about that you participated? Did you know * froatlv> 1 -ctur^ which you heard that there- hr d been deaths curing th. cold experloer.ts? A. First if :U cy pcrticipation was a aitter of courts because it was ft .c.-ting of cyi r^dicin-, of evic tion doctors. It was Just coincidence whit it was a Cold acting. I pcrticijr.tod in r.loost -.11 such ocotings; nd, besides, I woj inter-ated in tho s v cold problem since I was “t the tta* planning to carry out cold ox.o-riaonts »ith tho low pressure chaaber, experiac-nts w.hich Were lotur carried out. As for this second question, whether I knew that any deaths had occurred, ono aust aako c strict distir.ction Oetwocn ay personal ;alfta.nt ni thot which was cle.tr to the general public. Besides, . aust r.ot ovtr-ec l » the attention -ttracUd by ouch 0 mooting. ! did not pprove of Rascher ard his -xperirwnts person' Uy. I had Crokon off tho lew pressure experiments for that reason 'nd h'd refus-d to participate in the cold experiments as Himmler had wishud. If now in Nurnberg Holsloehn-r spoke of observations of cold persons nd said tkt b had collaborateC with Dr. R'.scher -nd Dr. rinke, if he spoke of observations or. d-ta persons, I persomll;-, 9 sir.c* I wen praj»diwd r.gni^t. R-nnh-.r, •‘limat «iwwvDtiaMly .inmraed thrt this referr-d to th. exp.rim.nts, uso.ci'lly since rft.r Holz- loehncr 1 a lecture Rasober spoke in a bad eXterrhl fora and said that i Hiaalcr h-.ci taken th. r-spjnsibility for this -nd ord-rec' strict secrecy. 3 ut in his lecture Holzloehner had spoken of the eiperionco of rescue froa s-a, aniarl experiments, human exp-ria-nts, nd had confused then in such a way tbit the listener who was not prejudice wield have cssoi-d that the results were .xporier.ee fra cas.s of n.scue at sea. This is espoci: lly true of people who knew how 6G20 : l-r 47 -A-18-A-?kp Binkley (vx Schon) Court So. 1 Crsc 1 extensive this sea rescue service was, whs knew of its great success, -,n! who knew tfet Finke end Holzloehnor had worked together in the sea rescue service. gev, Ur. Roeberg, one more question or. the previous matter :r . thi pictures. In your presence during the Dachau experiments, w.re any other lictur-s token, whether films or individual pictures, acy others besides the ones which fora the motion picture which wr.s L-.tcr ±J*r. r.t the Aviation Ministry nd to KianUr? A. No, knew only that aotia\ picture. Th t is why I thought of it first when I was shown the pictures. Q. Then you did not tr.kc any other pictur-s? A. No. q. Did Rnsch-r t-ke any other pictures during the experiments for rescue frou high altitude? A. No; efc lo st not in ay presence. C„ Aside froa you two, did any third per sen take other pictures aside Iroa t his notion picturv? A. I don't krvai whether anyone else took pictures. Q. As fer as you were present? A. No. C. L-.tor did you do any further work in the field of hi h altitude? A. Yes. Tret was really cy field of work; but 1 also worked specifically on the question of parachuting from high altitudes or rescue froa high altitude3, the cold work which Dr. Ruff has already pontionod, parachute junping, nd cold md 1 -ck of oxygen, gn-at altitudes, - nd tire reserve experiments — that is , st->lng * t high altitudes >»ith simultaneous lack of oxygen, "nd withhold. During the cold experiments wc first worked on th- question of pcracr.uU Jirpirg, as the non- important cu-stion; -.nd the s-ccrd thing was tho question of the si ailtaifeous effect of T ck of oxygen - nd cold while & • remaining it high ltitud-s. Thes. were experiments on ourselves, together with the associates, As Ruff has already said, w. wore Go 51 1 £-.y L7 -^-LS-5-o:-p- Blfilclfly (vcn Schon) Court So. 1 Cc*u 1 1 bV iijr.t clothing and '.font down to : s far as 15 tegr.es be-lou ner; as I -.a -s tao .-juts. Or.-, report each -os written or. the two teri.s of .-.x-.rLsjris. 2?.. VDHnBBK: In this ccnrv.-cticr., l£r. Pr^siocnt, I should like to submit fro,; joctiSer.t Book Rcriborg Docux.nt f.'unbor 1, the ffir'avit jr. 1’clU.r Fruitag. I should like to sutait this as Exhibit 1. In the first paragraph of this affidavit the affiant speaks of '.is work with eh- djfcrdont Roaberg froa 1939 on at the Institute lor Aviation jfedicins. I should Hire to rend the second -> >h. I quote : "Dr. I.olfptng Roaberg was diligent and industrious and carried out his tasks conscientiously and to th. best ;f rla ability. The -.xp.riner.ts ir, particular the work ir. the low pressure c ha sober oi^thw effects of oxygon deficiency *t rurwl tuapeirtures ?rd in the- cold (up to linua 15 ■e.jTe 1 -s C.) required considerable .iuntr.1 conc«ntr tion *c Well ~s eXtr..’c physic 1 exurtlcn. Dr. Rxiberg was always the first to suUoit to those experiments. The importance of his persorr.l .ffort is >edally caphadsed by thu L rge nuabei of tests and experiments. The elucidation of a raw bur of iniiyi-u 1 qu-sticna was probably only *.de possible jy this effort." Than ttero folio.s a Judg^nt of tlv. character of th. defendant. Then I shall r-ad tha last sentence: ’’I an convirced that he planned •rd p.rfor.o-d the experiments ,on inn't-s .‘ran ~n absolutely uoral st ndpdnt *.ne th t 1~, Just as Dr. Ruff, nas th -io of aoTJi, treacherous deception. B There folla.tc a nignnt.ure n J rert-ffio-tiaa. it is dated the 28th of January 19A7. 5852 I ?Jr.y 47-. -S' -IS-l-Gross -Int: Von S cron Court !?o. 1 DR. VOH'. HR; . s Itosiborg Document i»o. 2, Exhibit Ho, 2, I submit tic next .ffidc.vit b7 Dr. nod. Y/omor Loocklo. First tho :.ffi:nt ape. lea of Ms own work end bow ho sot to knoi tho dofondrnt. Then, in tbo aocond pnrr.srr.ph ho dcs- cri'oos individur.l experiments, Ictv-r ho spo..ks of tho vol- untoor nr.turc of tho oxporir.cnts, of t! o cr.rofvlnos3 of tho defendant in r.ll hia o r.por ir.cn ta, thr.t tho subjects woro voluntoors. Ikon I rho> Id Hi m to rord on pr.go 5 of tho p:.r. sr~.pl th..t at .rtc rx little r.bovo tho niddlo of tho p.'■•o. I quo to: “I imt Dr. P.onborg a r. r.onbor of tho lnatituto remd .-.bout 1938 or 1939. Ko v a m..inly concornod with ruoetiona of high r.ltitudc physiology, nd pnrtioip.-.tod in moot of tho pi nning of tho oxporlmonta, whoro ho provod to bo r.n intolligont r.nd circvmaeoot, oxtr ordin. rily emtious nd consciontious dvisor. Ko :.lw.~e p;-.id ep ocir.l rttontion to r.ll aocurity instr.llr.tions r.nd precautions. No;.rl” r.ll tho pcoplo working thoro confidently .akod hia rdviso whon drngoroua or .-.a yot unknown oxporincnt.-.l conditions h:d to bo tooted. Ko lw.-’*s undertook tho tr: lning of now . saiatmt porsonnol, end Ms offorta woro oxtrorioly auccossful, Ko Qlwx.ys took p t t hi-iaolf o.s r.n • oxporinontr.l av.bjoct in tl o oxporinonts nocossr.ry for Ms own work :rd for thd work of other monbora of tho ir.atituto ovor. if tho ox;\;rir.cnta w^ro unplor.flr.nt or dmgorous. Ronberg only uorkod with volunteer oxporlmontr.l subjects: I think ho would nover h d n~do uso of r.ny # forcod 'roidir.gas to voluntoor*. In view of Ms ch-.rr.ctor I consider it tc bo quito out of tho question for Dr. Rom¬ berg to h-.vc t l:on p. rt in unacrupi'.lous experiments or in curoltics. - Closer ccqur.intr.ncQ vith Dr. Houberg, showo hie 6832 I jfc.y 47-- - ST7- !9-2-Gro S s- Int: Von Schon Court Ho. 1 colitioi.l afctitudo to bo open to the world -nd dofinitoly .bovo tho narrow nr.tionr.llfl tie idor.s prevailing r.fc tfco tino. Hi a objoctior.s against cortain measures of tho rogino «cro woll thought out nd w~rc not without a cortain grin •or.so of humor. ~Long convcrs. tiens with sinil r nindod persons In his * rcon woro a ror.l consolation, to us in thoso abnormal tino a. It wr.a Dr. Ronborg who skillfully providod a poss¬ ibility to listen to fcroiyn r..dio stations in tfco instit¬ ute/' jnd follows tho sign turo ;nd cortific. tion. In viow of tho political attitudo of tho dofondont I should like to submit Doc nont Romborg Ho. 3 as Exhibit l7: Counsel, can you advise the Tribunal as to how •-<* yea -xpoct it will require to prosont your direct case in defense, concluding rith this witness and any other witnesses you nay have, and the documents you nay dosire to present? DR. VOS SSXs For the direct examination I will r.o-d about half an hour. There will bo no ether witnesses. T3 PRESIDE!?i The Tribunal will now b^ in recess until 9:30 0 . 1 deck tomorrow rooming. U recess was Ukon until 0930 hours, 2 Kay 191:7). 6G42 /W 2 *£cy-^-GJ-l-l-Foator-(iafc. Vor. Schor. ~nd Kurtz}- Court 1 Official Transcript of the African kilitnry Tribunal in the sitter of th. Unit-d States of Accrica .gainst Karl Brandt, ct al. defendants, sitting at Nuernberg, Germany, on 2 kay 19h7, 0930, Justice Beals presidn*. :.-ZL KARSEAL: Persons in the Court roos will please find their seats. The Honorable, the J-dgvS, of Military Tribunal 1. Military Tribunal 1 is now in session. Cod save the United States of Asu-rica and this honorable Tribunal. Thero will be order in the Courtroca. THE FR3SDE.C: Ur. Wars hall, you ascertain if th_ defendants are all present in court. THE MARSHAL: kay it please your Honor, all d-fe.ndats are present in the court with the exeption of the Defendant Gbcrheuscr, absent due to illn ss. THE r-E3ir£VT: The seer. tary-general idll note for the record the prcs-nce of all the defendants in court s ve the Defendant Obcrheuuer who is absent on vccount of illness, according to z note filed by th- prison physician. The Secretary-General trill file the note. Counsel nay proceed. Dh. KA:S IXkBERG - Resuc.d DIRECT EXAltftoTION (Continued) BY DR. V0F..TRK (Counsel for the Defendant Rozberg): Q !n. Rocberg, yesterday you nswered to ay last question, why it w a impossible for you by using fore*, to oppose Rnach-r's exp-rinentc and to prove that there would here been no purpos- in denouncing hin to the Reich authorities. I would now like to ask you, assusing the case yourself in a similar position today, would you take the did then? _xtr-seiy difficult becaus. the conditions know fioschc r—I know the whole situation. 1 have about that point. If, ay present knowl_dge. 6843 2 hay-K-GJ-l-2-Fcst^r-(int. Vo a Sc hen- nnc Kurtz)- Court 1 I -^rc again put in th_ sene situation, : an certain that 1 would act differently. I would probably go to Berlin after the death and report it, end then I would go ha*., get a ncdical certificate saying that 1 m3 aick, .and write to Dachau end say that I could not cone back. That Reach or did then and how th_ cxperlcuits turned out th. main thing would be I would be out of it, then I would probably save nys.lf the one end half years in prison -nd the trial. Q Is that your true opinion: A If I think cv r what I said on. of course often la&glnes that, but I really don't b.liev_ I would do that because one can't act • % against one's inn r convictions, -culd prob bly not take this cold calculating point of view and lot everything take its course. I would porbably go beck Just th. vy J did j^d curry out the uxp.rlnaita, see to it that the chacber could o_ take nay. I would probably do every¬ th* Just th- way I did it then. HAPDI: four honor, I don't believe the Ifibun-l is particu¬ larly int-rested in what the Defendant Rodberg thought ho would have done unde: tn. sen, circusatanCeS if they arose again. This is purely Speculative. THE PT-EoILG:.T: CtJecticno by counsel for the prosecution appears to w-11 * .ken. »hat h.7, you to say couh: 1? Th ^ defendant has been asked .hat attitude he would ♦ take if he ».r. faced with the sane situation which he faced t the ti=e. Th Defendant has answered that qu-stion. •HE RtZSILEJC: Bo you intend to pursue this line ray further? LR. VCfvCTS: Jo, he has answered the qu .stion. T.ar. P rE SEfc.fr: All right, x'roce-.d. BY DR. VCSM5BK ( Continuing): C itn.ss, in ti is court Mention has been raade that in the course -he high- Itltude experiar.ntr a v_r 1 visits w v r paid by see.-. So r .rs; i.r, you pr.o.nt in Dachau ah.r. these visits occured? A Th - rlrit ^ ^ Dcchau that I renter ere the visits of Grav.ltz CC-i4 2 Jicy-t.-GJ-l-3-r ostcr-( int. Von Schon nd Kurts)- Ccurt 1 the Rcicbsnrte of the Police, and the visits of Sie-ers which Siev-rs h-s already stationed her.. And I also know that Hiualer was tfr- re, th was on Sunday and I was not there that day twt later, of course, I was told all about it. Q Vas that thy enjy visit you can recall? A -he only visit of Hisraler's, or do yen n. an the only visit— - The only visit by high t officers. • ' A I do not rc acu ber any ether visits. Q Your c-dcfen-ant Si*,v_rs testified here that while he was there, he noticed that an oxp. rifle ntal subject during th_ experiments pointed to his ear in order to indic-.tc that the experimental subject suffered froa pains in the ccr, thereupon, you produced : different altitude. Co yc*i recall that incident, nd what have you to s-y about that? A It was a sign which w had agreed upon, that they should point to the car there if they had earache, perhaps curing the a-sccnt, and that was probably what happened during this visits of Siovurs. We “lwnjr Bade the disc nt slower or w.nt up a little again in order to do away with the cccplaint. Q "n>* do you particularly rvrv.nber that incident while Silvers was there? « Rancher wonted th. deccetit to be rapid and J step pod it on purpose, nd he tcld bo later, -h.n visitors are there that has to bu ion. quickly and 1 s id, * Whether we have visiters thero, cr Sievors or scaubody Os., that nakes no difference, th. .xp.rie.eatc has to be carried out in the ran. way.* 6845 2 I -.y k7-:^'jC-2-l-aDchan (Int., Ycr. Schoon . Kurtz) Court I 1 At that tire when this incid-r.t bau .nod did Rascher roproach you for bad conduct, or soaothing like that? a Ho possibly la:Id tho point of view that when we bad visitors I had to rak: tho axpcrlr-er.ts faster so to say considering tha fact that wo had visitors at iha cxparii^nta, but I refused to do 3o« Q "hat did ho aoan by you should do in taking the visitors into considerations? a Tha cxporiieent was to bo carried cut as quickly as possible, Tfhilo I h-ld thJ point cf view that tho oxperiaont is tho :iain thing and tho visitor has to look at tho oxporlr.ont and watch it in the fom in which it is always carried exit. After , tbej re not douonstrations. Q Another subj.ct no*, vhet attitude did you take after tho Dachau experiments, what was ycer position with tho DVL/iftor tlu Dachau \ / * -- axporinonts? . A At first I was a scior.tific co-xorker Just :;s I had bu.-n before. Our dopartr. nt for aviation n .dicino was expanded gradually and b.cono an institute, and in 19U3 I boerno soction chief in tho soction for high altitude. Q "oday, do you still think that tho oxparlr.onts wore at that tino important? A los absolutely. Rodontly, I accidently obtained proof that thin opinion i3 still correct today, I road an article about a nor avnition oxporinont of a plana with a rocket profiler. T ?iay it ploaso tho Court, at this point.I would like to offer P.onh :rg Document 5, '.oaberg exhibit Ho. 5, an article frea "Iifo" ragaziixi under tho heading, "Scientists Prepare to Fly Castor Than Sound." This is tho issue of life la^aainj :f 20.January 191l7. This should servo as evidence for -h_ fact that in aviation un&tr poo War o aditions similar porblcns ara ro^'.rd.d as important, Just as troro tho prcblons for which theso ox aria mats to rescue people from high - litudo. 6846 2 !i?.y U7—?• jC-2-2-^'©jhan (Int,, Von Schoon & Kurts) Court I p. HARM: Kay It ploase, lour -oner, it is ry understa n d in g that the evidence of this nature will bo offered at. a later date and .dll be actod on at that tiro by the Tribunal. DR. VORYERX: !!r. President, ray it please the court, in thi3 caso t:ds is rot an .xporlnent nado abroad and about which the court has already ruled. This is not an experiment at all; this is merely to show the fact that a certain problem oxists. !y jC-2-3-Wjehaa (Int*, Von Schaen & Kurtz) Court I out of tho experimental stage and ".ho Inarionn exports on aviation nedldne, if they have not already done so, will no doubt be stuctjring th. possibility of rescue freaa high altitude end high speed. The necessity of rescue trau high spood is ryjntioned specifically ir. this article and tho difficulty involved. Q Dr. Hoeborg, tho necessity to carry out such oxporinents, is that not shewn also by the hxsocution Dccunent No. 289, Exhibit 72? THE rFSSirGHT: -T-et Doca»nt book is it? U!. VC^EEX; Froeocuticn 3ocuncr.t book 2 . THE FRESHKNTi On ?.*at page? OH. TO'PESK: It is cn pago 106 cl tho -nglish version. Year Honor. THE WITNESS: This is tho letter, ridel: Hippke wroto to Hlrmlor after tho oxporlaonts woro oenpietod, in which ho discuasos tho rosult. Ho anphnsizus that tho oxporinents were vuluabl and iiiportant in their results. Ho says, it is true, that cold was net consid rod in this -attor, which involves an incroasod burdan. o ourselves undertook these cold oxporinents lator and furthoi* ono of th rest important reoulto of cur report was ihat in rcscuo fror. thoso h'.gh altitude ono sheuid prefer rescue dth . cl->sod parachute and for tho sane r eason, it is suggested, or r* .or dsaandod, that tho .crachutw be oquipod with a blocking equipment for hirn altitudo, so that it cannot bo oponod accidentally or intentionail piano. In tho socond place, dt is douandod in tho case the rar'chutor oocodos unconscious and does not regain consciousness in tino, them will be an nuthematic dovico stored barometrically to toper, tho parachute at an altitude botuoon I:,000 and 6,0CC rvetors. Tho natter of cold does not play any gre- role in this bocauso the tino speed in these high altitudes, where tho tof^ioraturo is very lew, is very slow, 10 seconds por 1,000 motors, -side for possible local freezing of tho face, for oxanple, no serious damage free the ccld can be expoctad. -7 D?„ VOS^ERK: 0, fiancss, a few questions on your reporting to Hinder during that cortferenoo. 6348 2 :'ay !i7- FjC—2-L-'feefaen (Int., Von Schoon '■ Xurtz) Court I Was there any reference rado to thoso experiments which Rase her aade on his ora in Dachau? A ’.to, at least not in ay presence. Q Did Raseher have any other conferences with HLmler apart fron tho one where you wore present? A Tes, on tho next rooming, Raschor talkod to hin again. I was not present. Q Do you knew what problems or orders Raschcr wantad Hiroler to give hin in th field of high altitude research? A When wo visited 'ho Headquarters, :arrlor had spoken of tho continuation of tho high altitude oxpdrinonts. .''hat was intended and tho details. Ono c-an no 'cut* s e ost cloarly fron this Docirunt Exhibit 79, Docicont Bock 2, Docun-nt 1612-PS. That is tho official assignment, which Hinmlor gave to raschor to carry cut a certain sorios of oxporlncnts. 6849 Coart So. i 2 as? 47-W-3-1-iEk-Cooit (7,n Sch:on * Lurtr) It Beys a^cng ether things end I auote: ■SS Eauptsturafuehrer Dr. Sescher ia being assigned by ne to carry thr-ugh the follcving experiments: "(1) Low pressure chcnber experiments, to be errried out under c-n- ditions corresponding to those- actually prevailing under normal -perr.ting conditions, for rescue froa high end extremely high altitudes. Dcterai nation of changes In cheated caulllbriun, as veil os ges ooui- libriua cf buatn body. Irperiaents ere to be repeated until a scien¬ tifically Incontestable basis for finding* Is established. Testing or oreesuri-proof protection garments f-r the highest eltitudes to be curried out vith the nssictcncw cf rcmifoeturers of such protective ' suits." This shoe's that Beschar oerfcroud very extensive assignments end Enecher no doubt intended to carry out the experiments. Eo, of course, did n-t know the dotalls. a Ci. Did Eaachar ev«r tell you In vhat fields ho wo working? I :cnn as fnr as high altitude oxocrir.cnts vero c r.ccrnod. A. '.hilt we vero at Dachau? Cf ttiiie y-u w^xfccd c: S* ch * u '' n y ,Jor fiTboriacnts to r^ocuc people free high altitudes. A. S-, he neva- said anything definite. He did sey that In the cr.Se of 3u tx he wnted to elerr ua vith but, of course, he did not give ac any dotcils r.bout hie rnsv^r. Q. Vitn«-Bt, vhoa rrr-ng your co-defendants did you know in 1945, at the beginning of 194E? A. 3y nrae, Professor Srandt, hr-fcecor Ecndloser, Er ifeos-.r AOCt ck. Pr.fcss.r Sc breeder • knew because he hrd visited ue ot the DYL jnev -r tvice. I did not .'-now Dr. Senzkcn; Profeor .r Gebhcrdt, Prof-.se .r Blcae by naac; Dr. Kn*ovsky a little; Poppendick not ft all; Profess :r Eosu by nrne, I net him et meetings. Dr. Buff wee ny chief. : did n-t knov hr. 3reck. Dr. Bccicsr-Ireystng I ka.w fraa aviation .edicint v,r> '-hich ho did with rr-fess :r Strughcli, rsl Pr -fc.csor 6650 Ccart S3. 1 2 Aay 47-k-2-2-=5i-Ccok (Tan School & hurts) Waltz I know. Of the other four end It. Gb«rheueer I know no one. 3. ’ tth vhoc did you hero ifficirl relations? A. I had official relation® in eviction aedleine *-1 th Ir. f.uff, of course; et tines with 3ccker-Jroyseng, also in tho way of c-nverec¬ tions. I didn't haw direct official relations with Ir. Schrcoder hut he wee on official business vhon ho visited war institute, and I net Professor bolts in 1942. Q. Which of the cTCtrincsts discussed here were known to ycu whon you were arrested? a. Vhea I ‘as arrest.d the high ellltudo eroorients, of course, end the cold crocrinwnte. q, '-hen y«u scy the 'cold exoerlr.onts", do you nero to toy thr.t thu fact that cold erocriiCRte wre corried out w«# known to you, or do you want to try it vnt known to ycu t- what extent and ir. whet tennor they wore carried out? as to the extent and cxcct nanner I knew nothin/:. Ky knowledge is hosed on the ccnferocco in Sucrnberg and on the fact that I had heard thrt old experiments were to bo carried out. Si .vax took orrt in the Kuernberg conference, did you? a. Yes, I spoke rbout thrt yesterday already. Did you take part in rny other ;eetlngs in 3orlln, St. Johann, HohenlychOQ, or anywhere vise? A. Ho, I did not attend any meting* of consulting physicians or pay nettings which have been discussed here. Ihc other race ting* wro internal r.cetings of the Luftwaffe doctors which to:k ul'ce frjq tire to tine. Q. Sow, a final cuecti.n. Why did you sign a retort tegether with a nan like Easchar? A. I have been asked the very is e cuitticn by Professor Al.xander, why I signed a report together with a erininnl like Haschcr. : nay say tuvercl things on that. She picture of EaschuT ec a crininrl is clear t dcy. -or mo at the tine Sascher’s personality end his position. how- 6851 Court Sc. 1 2 Key 47-X—0-3“5St-Codc (Ton Sohoen & Kurtr) ever, vcre act to cl«cr free the l«.gei and fro.- e acrel point of viev. We repudiated Batcher's experiments icvordly. vhet ve did net like vts the fact that he undertook human experiments on tracttices vhich in our cpiaioa vere not of the highest importance and not of decisive orre- ticel importance, end aieo in these exoerlcentt he did not oroce^ti with the necessary cere and caution, ec that death occurred. Therefore, ve not only repudiated the trierir.eute invrrdly, hut vc elto rcuudiated them crtornally, that it, v® refusei to cooperate vith Batcher any fur¬ ther. But thii w>5 rarely our uereonel opinion and vnt alto tfco bpois of our private attitude tovari him. According to knowledge of litera¬ ture rb-ut experiments :r. huun brings is ''ll countries, I today have the pertenol opinion that in a nubwr of cites the cxocriucnte vere aomctlmot unnecetiary md that tone cotta of death could have been avoided; that nan? a pi.Ce of verk van not v e n O nough nrecarod rr.d era n-t United t- vhat vat absolutely necessary. But fr:r. thit sub¬ jective uttltude to advance to the objective verdict that a certain scientist vat a criminal, that vat a greet and decisive oto^, and to I signed the report together vith Beecher. Buff did not have an," nio- givlngt either rgclnst countersigning thit tciontifically correct report and ndklng the retultt avrilrblt for furthor dovclo-or.onto. Today I os ectunlly glad I did so for it is tho clocrcst nrocf of the , sepcrnti-n of tho Batcher cxtori er.ta fron ours. It i6 vory difficult if one hat only the crosecution documents' and orosecution vitneoscs vith vhich to conduct one's defense, and if this report vere r.ot available .r.e A the nott important uroofs egrinst the serious charges vould be nia6irg. ^ J-r tho tine bviag I have no further questions. .-BiSI3i:'.T: /jo there cny oucetlont to bo propounded to thf vitr.ess by defense counsel? IE. TI??: rr. Time for the defendants Scfcroedcr end reckcr- rreyeeng. oS52 Coart So. 1 2 .‘jy 47-H—3—4—££h-Ccok (Vos Scfcoen 4 Zurtz) 3? 2E. II??: VitneBE, ia this trial you gave an affidavit which was oub- sittcd by the prosecution as evidence. It is contained in Docuncnt Book j'o. 2 os page 1 of the text. It is Document So. 476, Zxhibit 40. Do y-u htve the document at your disposal? a. Yes. I would nov ask you to look at figure e in thio document. There you said: "After the lov pressure experiments vere curpleted, Dr. naechor end I ..ado a report which wo t approved by Buff and signed by the three of us. This was circulated to all interested offices in the Luftwaffe. In ".y opinion, Dr. Anthony of nodical Servlc© of the Luftwaffe oust also have received a copy of this report. I do not rerember If Bcckor-Froy- Cbae vne with the aedicel Inspectorate at that ti c but If ho was ho certainly know that these ©rxriuonto vere being ccnductod." Sow, of couroc, vc know, witness, that Dr. 3eCkcr-Froys©ng vno in the nodical Inspectorate froo 1941 cn os en assistant expert. Therefore, it nitf.t be pjseible that trua that nffidivit the orccceutlor. night draw the cinclusion that Dr. Becker know of theso experiments and reports. _ • Ihvreforo, I v.uld like to ask y-u, witness, do you have any factual proof rnd red knowledge of the fact that Dr. 3eckcr-7rcyceng in fact knew of those experiments and rb-ve all of thio particular report? A. So, I have no positive knowicdgo to that effect. In the inter¬ rogation I w-b asked whether the report - whether a copy of the report VC6 sent to the medical Inspectorate a-ad I w e r convinced of this fact - *ay I interrupt you a moment, witness. You say you were "con¬ vinced* of that feet that this report vre sent to the -edical # Ir.spcctor- atc, but did you actually positively know it? a. Ho, I did not sec the distribution list itself when it v C e finally approved ty the Aviation hinistry and I wan? to spy that if the report was sent to the Aviation Hinistry then it ves certainly sent - - the Depart cut for Aviation kedieiae and the -xmert of this de-part- 6353 Court 5c. 1 2 .^eyi7-r.-C-6-lii.-Cccic (V-a Schien is Kurts) -.cat 'culd certntaly here learned about it. I said especially that Dr. Anthony probably received it. I do not re:-.e.:ber whether Becker-freysonc was in the .-.edicel Inspectorate at that tine. I did not rer.t .bcr et that tine the? Becker-freysene was working with Anthony, wps Anthony 1 a assistant in the -iedicel Inspectorate et one tine. I thought that if this Anth-ny had been an expert he vxld have learned of it, but if £veker-7roysang had be*.a an exoort he would have learned of it, but I knew that at that tine he v*s an oseietant expert while I hrd assuned that Dr. Anthony was not there at ell. 6954 2 Kay 47-K-4-1-Schwab-Ku tZz and Von Schon) Court 1 Q. Therefore, you vsrj saying, witness, that you norely assumed this fact here? A. Yeo. Q. Then may I as* you In the same document and in the sane paragraph"under Figure 8; please look at the last sentence. There you say, Dr. Oskar Schroeder in 1542 was the second-highest ranking officer in the medical ser¬ vice of the Luftwaffe, and probably he also know of the¬ se experiments, although I personally never talked to him about then. I should cay from this very formulation you have no positive knowledge of the fact whether or not Prof, dchroeder k*ev anything about this ouslness. Is that correct? Yes, what I meant to say by this formulation which I worked out ax'tor consldoraole discussion In the lnter- rogatlon, I adopted this formulation on purpose. "He probably knew about hese experiments" but in order to say that i had no positive personal knowledge— I said that I personally never talked to him about the matter, that I know nothing positive.. Q. Thank you very much. DR. TIP?: kay it please the Court, the Defense Coun¬ sel for Veltz 18 not present today, no asked me to % put the questions on behalf of his client, and I would like to obtain your permission for this. TH2 PRESIDE:;!: The permission la granted.^ BY DR. 71??: e. Witness, on behalf of defendant Veltz I still would like to go into your affidavit. I would now like you to go bacx to the first page of your affidavit. I am inter¬ ested here in Figure 2. There you speak first of all 685b 2 May 47-H-AX-4-3-Schwab-Kurtz and Von Schon. Court 1 about the tire vh-n the experiments were conducted in Dachau, and what was their purpose. Then you said, -.round the riddle of the paron wo ia.t iVofessor Yfuest. Haschor told a- afterwards th.t ve-st was, I believe ho said, tho curator of tho Ahnen.rbc md Rector of tho University of ..unich, a h that ho was th. su?-rior of Sifv.vs in tho Ahnon-rbe. 3. Then you said that, on that occasion, reference- was made to further axpcrlaonts, that is to say, freezing experiments. You ex¬ plained that, in tho*) ex-erioents, the rewarding with .mi«al warmth was to be carri-d Eut. Can you toll us whoso idea was this? Tho 6863 i/ourt I 2 3y hi-' - S-ix - LvTJ - Xarro (vor. Schoea Kurts) r'rcs-cution dose ib-d these thicks as though that emthod of r-< arming wa3 Sl-vors* brain child. A. I b-li_7& that I ras pr.ser.t at tho birth of this idea, bo to speak, Thor. Hlnnlur gave Reseller the assignment to go around tho aoa rescue stations in tho North S.a — and inquire what radius tho people- applied in such cases of roscuo cf frozen sailors, and ho said that h«- could i-axgino that a fisherman’s wife would si-ply take hor hilf-froz»r. husband into her b_d and uara him up that way. - .3 not a particularly striking suggestion at th. time. I believe that this is done along the coast, but as I saw the suggestion turn up again hero, I, of course, an horrified too. Q. Can you recall whet _r r.- Mler, a*, that time, ordered Ras eh or to have these r-warning expo lsp-nta c cried nut through using tho body warmtli cf women? a. No, he certainly did not give tho assigmunt y-t at that tino. tho _ rater was simply discussed in conversation .bout tho possibility js fer rescuo. Q. And, in tliat conversation, Professor Sueat was present, was ho not*? A. ter, i_ric_nts, but I don’t bulic-Ve so, but h. certainly -p; about it *ie .7. we r v r« to report to 1-ilch ir. the Aviation inistry 6564 Ccurfc I 2 27 L7~~ - 5-5-€J3—Xorroi (Von Sohoon Sorts) when ’>0 did not qu to succeed. 3 And did H i x i r.l or gj.v u any indication that he himself wished Readier to be transforr_d to the .rj present still because you said before that thuro was another conferonco on the next d:.y? A Tea, that's right. ^ How, final q -stion. Dr. Rods erg, would you pie so tako up oncu again your doolatent bock coneormag high altitude oxperiiaents and, in particular, your affidavit hich has been mentioned so of ton boforo. That is Document U76, Exhibit of tho prosecution 4 UO, on page 1 of Docunont Book 2. Cn Pare 3 , at tho hotter : ".'lolfram Siovora of the Ahr.ur.~rbo Society of tho S3 :.a also f miliar with thu&o oxpuri- o~nta and ms in Dachax* several tinaa whin they w«ro being conducted." The word "fpal liar 0 - has it boon put thuro at your request? B.causo, as I jAc.ali, 3iov-.ro h a been there only cr.ce as a moro spectator and that he io not r. scior.tiot, I am rnthor surprised at that tuna BfaoiUar". 5865 2°»fcy U7— - 6-1 - UB - hcloy (von Scfcon • Kurts) A. fust formilttien of ---11 those affidavits did not originate aith aj. I want to say that bo know about those experiments and that .t one occasion he had watched one in Dachau and I saw him personally it the o -pcrinontal station. q. xn ot:-r words, that ho knew of the experiawr.ts — those things which ha had seon himself'; A. YwS, apparently ho know that experiments were carried out u-d ho knew what ho had Seon during th- visit. 3 . c final question, any reports, oral r-ports or reports in writing, wero the. s-nt to Severs or t:o Ahn-norbo, as far ns you know? A. Not to my knowledge. I do not knew ^ ctly, however, but 1 ossusu that prv. cc.\ Of t roso rch report was Sent to tha Ahnonorbo. DH. iftsisaofl'sai I have no furtbor questions, Your Honor. T E E3S1D3HT: ?bo Tr -anal will now be in r-coss. (Ta-reupon a r.cuss was taken.) SB 55 C;nrt l»o* 1 2 Hay 47-r.-8—i—ZSt-Cook (Breve) THE jtiESEAL: Persene is the courtrso: v-in please find their sects. The Tribunal is again in session. 7-1 PBESIBEST: Are there any further auestiens of the vitnecs by defense counsel? There being none, the prosecution say cross examine. CHOSE 1SAXTSATI0B 3Y EAHI/Y: x. Or. B.&eberg, vhere did you study eediclne, doctor? A. 3crlin and Innsbruck. Were ycu ever in the ’ ehraecht? A. Yes, in 19?c and 193’, that Is, December 193d to January 1937 ! had tvo aonths basic training in the Luftwaffe end then tv-, periods if additional training so that at the beginning of the -or I '*nc ur. Lnterarrt in the reservo. Q. When vere you first assigned to the Coroan experimental station f>.r avlatltc, the DYL? A. I never vac in ar. oxoerlaental ctati n but fr:c 1 January 1978 I vaa in the DVL in Adlershof. a bss It bccauso of your oositlon in the DVL and ycur work in the field -f aviation nellcioe the reason vfcy you '-ore not in active ■uty with either the Luftvaffe or tone other branch of the "ehrcafcht? A. Too, I declared cssontlal f .v that agency, the DVL, »/ that I c.uld serve in the DVL during the var. Q, Veil nov, you have exorossed here in the course of your direct crimination by virtue of s.ae affidavits vhick v-u have introduced in evidence that you vero on anti-Karl. Is t?nt the inoresei.n you vent *.- create upon this Tribunal? A. I didn't ask for these affidavits, rather they --ere rent to ae e- that I hod no influence on the »4y theee affidavits vero em/enEed, particularly the Jevish ono frx Berlin. Q, Yerc you a neaber A the Bari party, doctor? A. Tes. then did you Join? 686? ro o ourt Sc. 1 Hay 47-*i-S-2-£EX-C J cie (Srovn) A. 1 hay 1933. v You joined very early, didn't you? A. Ihat vae the tine when ouite a number of people joined the party, right at the beginning. I “£8 c student at Innsbruch at the tine and Joined on 1 May 1933. Q, Vae it to your advantage during the course of the tine you “ere a student to be a senber of the Sari Party? A. So, it hod no influence on sy studies. Qj. Tou Joined by choice? ♦ A. At that tine I thought that good would coco of it. Sow, doctor, you have stated here on direct exasinaticn the first tiae you heard about the exp*rlnente to be conducted at the Dachau concentration carp vos when Puff inforned you ho had a visit froo Profoe- • or Veit*, it that correct? A. Yes. Ci. Aftor Professor ’’eltz raid a viait to Puff, how extensively did you and Puff ditcuaa tho visit of Profeso-r Veltz? A. That lasted a half an hour or perhaps at cuch as rn hour for turo. At that tine vae it established that the concentration cam in- nates voro to bo eubjects used in the exporlrcntc? A. Yes, as I recollect, that was already said in this conversation. Ct, Then it is true that Professor belts inforacd Puff that it *uo *.r.c pier to conduct these erocrinerto at Dachau on inmates :f the concen¬ tration cunp? A. Yes, that ’-as essentially the contents of that conversation be¬ tween Volts and Puff. v bell then, in a setter ,f a few days y u end Puff nroceodod to Hunich for a c-nfercr.ee, is that correct? A. Chri6t=es intervened there, so probably it “as about a nor.th later wkt.n that trie to h place. S.v, “hen you arrived at Professor ’eitz's institute in ..unich, “ u found PeScLor present, is thet it? 6uoB Court 5=. 1 2 Av 47-J-.-6—c-iH.-C>oJe (Sr.vn) - a. As I resccber. he vaan't there at the beginning. rt ceco later. > t arrived first. Ar-i that was the first tlae you ever set Batcher? A. Tee. aid you discuss enong yxirselvcc at that tine - that is the conference wherein Veltx, Paschcr, Buff, and y cur self took nart - the purpose cf these oroerinents? A. Veil, the purpose v,* also discussed although It had already teen established before that on the basis A the decision end vo vent to Kunlch In the first nleco to carry vat these croerlsents. Veil now, in this orollsinary nesting vfcat v C j the ooint which you ver» trying to establish? Vat It research Into high altitudes above 12,000 neters? A. It vat the orosting orogren cf finding cut hov to rescue oooelo froa those altitudes. And this would bo the first tlno In this particular field that such rcsoarch was to be conducted, is that it - that is, highor than 12,000 setorc? a. Jo, •-« hod already gone higher at a slovcr descent froa If,000 and e rapid descent froa 17,000, not only v* in our institute but also other institutes In Ocrsecy already done this. Q, And then, of course, the all inaortant -oroblc-n case uo at this discussion in fcunich that the inaetes of the concentre tlor. cnans would K used, and now you stot^ Beecher had a letter free Flaaler granting his authority to carry :ut these crcariaents at tho Dachau concentration ccnc end to use the inuates therein. V-.uld you kindly tell the Tribunal ns such as you can reneuber *ust *+.nt this letter said? A. I can't say f-r sur<- any s-re now. Batcher reed it aloud to ne. Soughly it said that the aoor .vcl in principle for Beecher to carry out the crrxrlnents in Dachau was still given and that crlnlnal prisoners ••vru to be uecd vfco volunteered. q, Did it contain the words -crininal innate® would be uecd end Court Sc. 1 2 .nay 47-*-e-4-IS(-Ccolc (rr>a) | that the innatcs vere to be volunteers"? Did it specifically state that in Hinder's letter? A. "Crininal inaatee" vas certainly act in tho letter tut the verd ■crininal" vas in it. Vas tho vord "volunteer" in it? A. Yes, that vord ves in it. Q. (k> on. '-hat else did the letter contain? A. I don't beliuve there vee =uch sore in it. There vas sane notice that other offices vere to be inforoed and then there vas the signature. («. There vas definitely a eardon clauoe contained in Hlnaler'e luttor, vqs there? A. Yos, that vas in there. < 4 . Voll nov, these experiaents that you «ero conducting vero to bo In an altitude higher than 12,000 actors, and ’ call your attention to the tact that Dr. Buff said that in Berlin they had only gene uu to 12,000 actors, that is, prior to the Dachau oxuvrlacnts, so far as hie Particular roscorch vpa concerned. Wasn't it e very dangcrcuo situation, .m vhercir. it vould be difficult, no re than difficult, to receive volun¬ teers? 567© 2 liiy W-^JC-S-i-^ohnab (Int., 5ron) Court I A First of all, I don't believe Raff said here that they had gone only to 12,000 net era because he kncms very well that we had conducted experiments at higher altitudes at the Institute and that ho had participated in then. I don't runosber shat his preicso words 'fore, though. You never know ahead of tine how dangerous such ex¬ periments aro going to bo. That was the- case, also | with our own experiments. It was a further ascent such as was gradually taking place in aviation regarding speed and altitude and the size of the nachinos, etc. Q "on, now, what was tho date of this Hiaaler letter? D o you recall? a Ho. I don't know tho date. It was certainly in tho year 19U1, beforo tho conversation. Q And you woro suro that Himlor spocifiod persons to bo usod to bo volunteers? A Yos. Q 'rfoll, now, who roquostod Hfcjrlor that subjocta bo sot asido for the high altitudo oxpori:»nts? A Thoso negotiations had takon placo beforo, betwoon Raschor and HImlor. lo didn't know tho details. Raschor, howovor, shmod us through this lottor tint ho had par-mission and plenipotentiary power3 fresa Kixmlor. Q I soo. ‘*ell, now lot us turn to pago 53 of Docuaont Book io. 11, which is Document No. 'X>-l602-?5—tho fifth document in tho book. This la a lottor from Rascter to F-oichsfuohrer SS Heinrich Jdxsalor, dated 15 ay 19hl. I ask you now to refer to the second paragraph. I will r^.d from it: "For thj time being I have boon assigned to tho luftgaukorrando VII, itunich, for a nodical course. During this course, •‘•ere researches on high-altitude flights play a prominent part lateraimd by tho somewhat higher ceiling of tho English fighter planes), considerable regret was expressed at the fact that no tests "'h human material had yet been possible for us, as such experiments—" -*- 3 the interpreter have tho latter. Document ?J>-l602-?S,'53 of the 6371 2 Kay U7-:>^jC-9-2-Schrab (Infc., Browr.) Court I English* I .in starting with the second paragraph. Do you have the Document 3ook No. II? INTERPRETER: The texts don't seen to correspond. If you will read slowly tho inter pro ter will keep along. • HARDY: Well, thero only three sentences in thj first paragraph. It begins with tho fourth scntonco. It begins! "For the tine being I have boon assigned to Luftgaukcerendo VIJ, Mirtoh, for a nodical ccurso." Do you have it, Vj. 3rown. INTERPRET 0 .: Texts don't correspond in Goman and English. "R. HARDY: ? oll, they corresponded bofora, Hr. Brown, sono throo or four nonths ago. It is obvious that you have tho wrong book thon. INTERPRETER: I have 1602-fS, on pago 53. ’a. H. 1 RDT: That is right...tho iottor. I will road tho ontiro letter; thon noybo it will help you. "1602-PS." Do you havo tho lottur in tho Goman book? "Dear Raichsfuohror. !’y sincere thanks for your cordial wishes and flcrors on tho birth of ry second son. This tino, too, it is a strong boy, though ho has ccno 3 wooks too oarly. I will pomit rysclf to sond you a picturo of both children it tho opportune sonant •" "For tho tino being I havo been assigned to tho—" THE INTERPRETER: At this point tho texts deviate fron ono another. 'H. HARDY: Wall, wo will go back to that, sill you plonso chock that imodiatoly? ’o will go back to that at a later iato. It is important that you chock it in ediately, please. DR. VORERX: (Ccunsol for the. defendant Hmberg) ?fr. President, in tho Geroan Docuaont Book II, page %, tharo is ir. this docunent, tho part that tho prosecutor wishes to road if designated as "illegible." In other words, it is not contained in the Goman document book. 7rE FRESHEN: Coins ol, is tho photostat of thi original available rero? 6872 2 :Cay JC-9-3-Scrarab (Xnt., Brcvn) Court I HR. HoEDI: No, Your Honor, that is in the tends of the Secrctary- Oeneral. TrU PRESIDENT: i-'oll, the Secretary-General will please bring to tha Prosecution, a part is obviously not contained in the copy of the declinent book which is in the original, ’low, if this pa rt is subsequently to bo pit in, this would, in effect bo submitting a now document. Therefore, I rcouost that tho prosecutor bo instructed to show us this document twenty-four hours before ho wishes to pit in in 07idonco. HE. H'lRDY: Of ccurso, in cress—examination I den't have to follow that rule. ”ay I ask tho court reporter to kindly read tho noxt senton co after tho first paragraph where I stepped reading and it boconos incoherent to road in the noxt sontonco? Pardon no—tho Garoonj cental nod in tho Goman docic-.ent. INTERPRETER: In the Goman bock, this is tho word — : as that. How =ony nacos can you ronceber? 5875 £ S-iC-l-:-:-rro- (Int. Court *o. 1. ? :»rc wfia - ncn nnntd i-oc kinder. S-cll, th-t plc~se. n o 3 r e c e r * 1 . o you kr.o- his first nrac? ... 2 *o, I don't 1 * *310" rherc. he t/.-s fro::, • krt hi a hone, cit; r-a,or mythin- like tfart? 1 * 0 , I don't kno- th-t no* -ith-r. ‘I. ou tell nc ou cx-orr?-:itcd or. « ;irn tronty tr.es •r.d you -cn't even knor Ins first nrrv., don't knor *-hcro he is fro:’, or -nythir.r obout hop? - didn't t^lk :•. o’ other's first n-n. a nor 5ut fchoa- dot oils. :t is possible tlrt i did find out "here h- c-ric fror. -nd rhr.t is ‘irat n*ru -r.c, but I h-vo forgotfcon it by nor-. 'ell r.or, cm you i-o us the nrj-.os of ray of the others? it shouldn't be too dlffioi^lt. i think i could % re- 1 -^nbv.r the nrces of ten or fifteen non T "ork-d ••ith for - c ■■ - ter. '3 th-t, on sue. m ? portent problen. i'h-re v-3 r ncn nrnod Sobottc. *i. Sx.ll th-t, pl--sc. ... SO u 0 T T ... 0 -n you give us -n- fvrt: r inforr-tion - out hi ? h. Sobott- occupi-d - spoci-1 position th-r-, bee vse Wf 3 th*. r»an '-ho rent throw ‘ th- ost -x--rar-nts, -nc' " c tkc 3“ r '& tin hrd - sort •>. superior position m3idc tii-.t 3 r 'tp, nc I think Sobottr. r: the m I t-lked viM; -;03t 'll. Consequently, i rdiny bin thr.t he srfeerre »r. Ho broke-into r. 1-rgo ..us trim St-te bmk, or.- other things, md, so 'nr re I knor, he ”-s -n .'.ustrien 1. 7-11 no-, do you It.o-- t! n-r.-s of -ny of the others? 5c 75 2 - S-lO-2-Krrro- (2rcr r.J Court *o. 1. *!• ill no-, do you kno- ’c.a rimes of -ny of the others 5 ' -a, I renenber - rn ‘ loos -nd the nmo Sozla!: or so- t: ir. Ilk- th-t. yloos is oy-llud 3T L 0 or 0 0 S, -nr* the oth-r, 2 0 S L .. K, -or sa-.t i of that sort, I don't : you renenber t: ~t? This is the -r.n you talk wd to the oot . ... To. 1. "or . 1 1 rcncnb.r hir? 6577 2 ray-r-r S-iO-3-Krrror (5rovn) Court r'o, 7.. 3. Thank you. I certainly don't rc^cnber hi 3 first rrr*. : T ov, vhrt r-s the r or ere that these volunteers --re to ;et for being subjected to the cxp-rircr.t? ... '.hat t.ioy actually received :s r. revr.rd, I don't knot for sure. I knor only fror the docunents her- th~t Sobottr. cos released, rnd I know that he h-d theretofore beon pro mised th-t he rould be y-rdom-c? -nr] th"t girr.ler h-d personally verified this rhen .0 p-id Ms vi3it there. Th>-n HiTfl-i*, rhen the report ws -do r.t the conclusion of the oxperinents, s-id it again, and Rrachcr 'Iso arid that they "ere to be set at libert; . a. ro you runcnb.r the ji‘- 3 >botta fror these docu- n.nta, or did you rencr.ber it fra.' ; oru conversations v/ith hir? ... I r-r.cnb-rcd it fro:- our ennv, rae tiona. Particular )y, because c University professor at ronr. h'd the s “.to none and that is ~hy this r-ther unusual n*r.e stayed in ry ncrory. ell. of course, ’-hen ou rcr.ertbcred the professor *t r onn ••ith the sane n-ne, you rust certainly h-vc -sked th- folio-: '‘.‘.re ; ou any relation to Mr?-' Th-fc is - likely quest! r., rcvldn't it be? 1 don't knor *-Mfch..r I -shed that or not. In principle, the fret that r 'Jniverait; professor should be r relative of - s-fccr-ckcr is not too prob-blc, but naybe 1 . did ask '. in, it is possible. '. ou didn't find out fro. tint course of questioning ' .-.thor or not the fcllo- c- c fror yuniefc, .Sesgia/Sttnoo or Mere, did you? ..s I h-vc s*id, in the c-se of Sobottr., I assure -'t he s rr. ..ustrirn. 6875 2 T3-10-4—Krrror (3ro- ) 'curt ;*o. 1. ”i. oil nor, I h-vc cs'-incc hero r.ll -Ion? thrt you r-rv porhrpa - thouphtful physicinn rnd r.ppcrcntly c v_r; —'cdspciontious ro3-~rch worker. It s:.:a uost unusunl thr.t - n *n of your ccliber didn't hrve cnouyht interest in th. people thr.t ho — s subjotftxnr to experiments to h-vc -,or- information about then tk-.n you have. Didn't you errs? - ou sr; , ;ou tell us hero, thrt ••«•. raked the*’ “hether they -ore volunteers. Did you ju3t sr : -.-.re you voluntcenr, -nd not rak thcr -ny further oiest. -.ns? 1 ou rcron't interested? It sc ns strange for r physloirn not bo be interested in sonc of the br. c’.:; round of the poople th~t he is aubjetiny to experiments. von ^r. Mnr kner son., of • he people thr.t he r-s usin'; m his cxp.rirents In Suchcn- r-*ld. ..s I arid, I did talk "it: these people. I’orcovor since I r.ssoci'ted -ith the /for tro or three months during these experiments nnd put the- m the exp-rin-nts rnd or-* rhet the * had to do, there is no ' oubt in ny nine' at -11 th-t tl volunteers. .hen I -aked then quoationa, I didn't ask th^n in r critical spirit bee-use I h-d -.ny mistrust of then, but these questions I -aked simply occurred in the course of the conversations I h-d "ith then o. .ell nodoctor, Titer . -ff'3 job there v-3 noro or leas taking erre of th-s- experimental subj-cts, '-.-.sn't .t? 'fr.an't he the block elder? ::ofr —3 the bloc'.: elr'er for this rroup, y s. o. ell nor, he n-s m r. 'ositxon to knor norc -bout thwse experinentrl subjects f.-n you, —sn't he? He p^r- h.-’-s h~f c card index file on then. ... Fo, I don't believe he had a c-rd index file, c. ell, he kne- norc -.bout then then you did, didn't .? He lived "ith th..:-. Ho xma mother ifinrto. 6079 2 j-lO-5-:rrroT_^£Ero'T.) Court o. 1. -11 no--, 1 -off str.teti that ten lnrrtca h-d Tint's possible. I don't :r,or ho-.: -oil he h-d knorn tie— before or hor roll ho rir.Co friends nth then. Tfc-t, of course, I can't Jut ;o. 1. Jo*c. ver, you rauld. bo villin; to ednit th~t per- hr-s his testimony concernin’; th^ae subj-cts is r.orc relicblc thrn yours? ... I crr.'t judge -s to tii& relirbilit; of Hoff's c stinony. I Just don't hnor. *$• ell r.ov, these tor. or iiftenr. - Neff referred to then 's •'exhibitionists’* or *cx. iblticn subjects 1 '. T>o you recall that? It rm Vie" eg it *o used that tern for the first tine here — ^exhibition subjects .’ 1 volunteered, didn't he? •• • . cc • 1 . .3 r n-ttor of fr.ct, stated, that's pn p-yc *ld . of the record, 'our Vonor. .11 no r, lu. rlso stated th-t only one of the subjects used :-.n t>. experiments -“s r»- ie-sed, didn't he? + ... les, that's «-hrt he said. 'i. '-’he documents support ' is testimony, don't they? ... uc-rrdin? Sobott", he is o •uclficnll: jentioncd 'or jrrdon in l.r-ndt's lett-r or .lasc r'a. '.11 nor, do you rocr.ll . e. f str.tiny h-re th t lto r.r.erbers the first dr.ys of f e erinents ”hen th-; hr;* th- firs- series of exp-rin-nts, an th't he stated th't Huff -nd ours-lf rere pr-.aont? .o ou r-crll th't? ... rirst, he said that ..uf. -s present on the first ^ -n luftcaifc uniform. Later, : - corrected hirself end acid v- —s not ir. Luftrrffe ’in if or , -•«•* it tran't on tlx first cither. Father, he ras in civilian cloth-s -nd it v:s co.pi- o_ recks 1-fccr. 6560 2 ”rr-I -'-S-lO-6-K2rro*- (3ro-r.) Court *'o. 1. '!• Veil nor, tell nc, in these first series of cxp~rir.cr.ts did you use these ten or fifteen non th -1 you hr 1 ct rot r disposal? /». res. 1- f-f.e 622 of the record - “.Titer Keff, o rr.n rho lived rith these gentlcncn, rho v.tc the clock eldest, rho knor rho r:r 1 going in end out of the lor pressure chr.nbor, at-ted thet r.o derths h'd occurred in this first series on tlrt dry, but this first series of oxperinents wrs not errried out on the volunteers? Do you ronenber th*t? .. off 3“ id h~rc thr.t all those ten or fifteen ->cn ”-r~ not volunteers -t nil. I reueiiber that very definitely nd he - Iso srid thr.t thcr- rore no frtrlities. I’ot during the first rev drys, but X t ink he sr.ld durins the first few r oo tea. . rIso arid tht these volunteers rere yoliticr.l prisoners, didn't he? ... Koff sr.id hero that nil sorts of people "ere there - -11 clrsscs or atretn that o\ • -11 nov, -.'hen you :rdo our pie- or Rr. sober r.rd.o h:s "le- to s^curo the volunteers for these experiru-nts, "hrt fonj or in rh“t rrnn-r c id he r.yper.l to the inn* tea of the D" :c’.ru conc-ntr-tian c*:ey3? 6861 2 Kcy4i-JB-H-l-aloy (Int. irawnj Court I j. oust how he did this I don't mow. 2 uis w..s not done 07 tL.sehcr, hut by the C_mp Con-under oa tsc. basis of the discussion of 2 uschar»c letter and the inform-ticn given by tne .adjutant Schaitzlor, fro. ..unich, *t.z w .s prosentut the discussion, as for I fcnou the pecplo Vi.ro ashed at the roll cJl vho wonted to volunteer and :..en r. great number of volunteers - 3* Haw, you s-y roll Cull, do you nejj roll coll of only habltv.nl criminals or crininuls condctmod to death boesuse you only used cr in Inals in these experiments, or did the roll coll consists of nil sorts of prisoners, political prisouore and evoryono also? a. Just how the roll c -11 varus I don't know, :r whether r. tpccific group w_s cstaolished a priori. s. Tou actually don't .:..ow very ..uch ab ut tais, do you? «. I h..d nothing t; dc with selecting then. Sborovas n clear cut agreement with the c...p csx-ondor vuich h~d been rc.xhod during this discussion. He r..h s-id thut wo would find on .ugh, -nd told Er.schcr th..t ho c uld picle tho po.plc wh were physic -lly qualified f-r tho experiments. 0 . How, vh .t did you offer the. at an indue aoent ta undorgo thfcfiO experiments; that w_s the induce-cat, w .sn't it, ,ffaring thee . n.xAth if they successfully ucdervwnt the experiments? a. I didn't off or than a p-rdon. I wasn't in a position t: do th t. q. Tou must h-vo insisted before yr-u worked n then. tft_t they vero to bo 0 xd nod. that is the gist of the testimony, you would a t use men who at l-„st w.rc n-t offered a pard n after you n.d •sc -rimentod on tha., w aid y u? I — sore y u wouldn't, w uld you, D ctor? a. %..t w_s .. clear cut st_tc-«.nt, also th .t the people should bo pardoned end th-t their sentences should b- reduced, -his wee • slooly a theory, but v_s sot down in writing, -nd Hi—lcr had 6S&2 2 :.:y-t^-ll- 3 -h_lor (la*. Brown) C-u rt I n.-f c tho bxc promise when ho v..a there. Cf e:urso f Ei-Mcr's idea -b ut pard aing those uca v.Bn't as conclu¬ sive ac ; u stated, was it? You et-te la the original Hi_nlvr lotto? tb :t Hi iJ.er v.-s in f-vor i: pardoning all the habitual criminals taat wore subjected tc these exoori-ents; now, did Hi_J.or havo a change of heart and l..ter withdraw th_t pro-dse, or what happened? a o didn't take anything b_ck, at loast I didn't know it if ho did, but f c uree, I c-n't check whethor or net ho kept his premise. ! can't forco a ~un like Hi—ler t: keep als word, -wo over at that :L.o I h d no re-soa to believe th-t this was a -oranisi. ta..t v.-.a not tc be kept. Q. Voll, now, whoa those volunteora, no to spodc, did voluatcor, were they warned of the haSards of the experiment? «» ^loy wore not Just'oc-cullcd' and I Can 8ay th~t thoy wero roally coluatccrs. I told tha: wh..t tho point of thoec oxporinonts was, what tho:- had to do, what they h_d to particularly tJcc ears of, and Just \fcat their nctivo purticipati m j cr>-ri. cnt_l subjoctn was tc bo. r. Uoll, now, y ax must h„vo told thou th t these experiments, cat lem on, you aro going to go thr'ugh ar* painless and they won't bo r~-rnful r.t all, y u -ay go^hrrugh s:ae distortions, howovor, at that time ; u njy oo uacoasci us. Vhea you wjee up you won't realise 7 u have gone through experiments; thoro is a: danger f doath, end •h tho purp cc of this exo^ri^ent is t o.nofit tho Ocmaa aviat rs, sv.cthiag tc th .t effect; you must h Vv Said c-.othing sl.il-r to that to tha:? a. oxset-.lng similar, a t in dot.il at y u nave s-id it. *. I ah uld tnink jnu w.uld have d ns it a-rc in dotvdl than I . vc, because I a. n exocrt on th..t subject ..8 you ^rc? a. I have air.ad," explained f tho: wt-t altitude siemens is, erol .ined viiat th_t thoy would bee no uncnsci is .aid this was tho 5833 2 Ucjr-ifr-JB-ll- 3 -iialoy (1st. 3 rovn) C:v_rt I _:st L-p:rtcnt point, after wnicing up 3 for us they _rc cl>—r ir. t_cir minds they sh uld pull the par-chute release. That v_s tho .. :st i^Jortcnt thing, course, and I -Iso Jenow very cert .July I iiss told tcec teat these were experinonts in which nothing v.uld h^ponod cs far ns con's judgment gees. la ether words, you impressed upon thoo that theso ixpcrLionto were harmless? a. I told tnai th.t to tne ocst of -ur ability wo would noo t: it that a:thing happened t> theu. I -Iso tcld tho- th«ro vao a certain rinh inv lved v.iich c uld not bo precisely culcul-tod, but sc far os the physicians wero concerned the;- w-.uld see to it that nothing happened tr thos- people. Veil, now, D'-ctor, if th-t w . iso c-so, in tno c urao of thceo high altitude experiments why vui it necessary t- use habitual criminals and cri .Inals condCDBOd to death; in othor w.rdo, why vao It nccocB. r.- t: -ffor that particular gr.-tro '* individuals an inducasent t undorgo such hem less experiment; why couldn't you -a well cull in tho politic.! prisoners avd h-vo §aid, "Jontloacn , we b.-.vo an ccpcrlmcct.il pr gru; hore", and oxpl.Jn to thee how h.r..loas tho experiment ia, und "if you will undergo tho exocrUoat wo will .ivc y u one moro loaf of bre-d than you ..re getting or -no -era piece of eaus a d^-, "which giving t then would be quite an indueoat, uhoro_8 you uacd criminals. which qb you auy-voro Juo- tifihbly pi.cod in concentration c-^>s -ad voro a aonaco to tho public, b-cause tho;' were criminals, and now yvar. goin.; t: subject tho. t: a porf ctly h-r_K3fl capori-ont -ad -llow tho. t go out into tho public and c ii.it sene core crime; it doesn't see. y„ic_l if it is a har-oloss exp-riceat; there must be some d-agor to it? -w -s to wh-t gro-^j of subjects w-r t to be chosen ..s aporiacatol sabJacts I h-d no influonc.. Hi—lor as Soichofuehrer SS aoc Cniof of Police issuui the dir.ctivo. *-e had no influence on th-t. That io 6:84 2 (Int. 3 rovn; Court I true of tie cose of doctors all over tue Vorld. the doctor d»oaaril 1942 . ■Dear Dr. RoeCher i I wont to answer your letter with which you seat ae your reports. ■Especially toe lctost discoveries a-de la your oxporlaonts havo interested ne. Kuy X ash you now the following: ■ 1 , This export..eat Is to bo r^o-tod on other sea ceadounod to death* ■ 2 . I would iiico Dr. F-hrcaJcahp to bo t Jeon into consultation on taose cjyorfc-onts. ■ 3 . C:nslderlng tho long coatinuod axploitod in such u nunnor as to dotcraino whether theec con could be rec-llod to lifo. should such an ooporiaont succeod, then, of courso, tho person condainod to death shall bo pardonod tc. concentration c^rp for lifo.* &..t was protty white cf him, Wasn't it? Th-t is :l "“» o-ven, -ight, nine, t n; or did you call then by n -su.s? A The nra.s w-re th.ro. . You only ran-nb-.r thn.e n n-s end you used to call than by name? . A I rocecber four neces. 3 Four cut fifteen '.nd you used to call these o-n by nr.a. and mkt sure, one would not ha*u twenty tLxs in th. ehoab.r nd tin other five; ycu wan Cod th-o to file in -v»nly, yet you era reader only four naats of such an iaport'nt project. A That was fiv- ye u-s ago and I carri-d out so many -xperinentn during th-t tin- at Dachau -n.5 w s in the office too, I cannot Ull you :.nts of the pocpl at the Institute cithor. i Yet, whenever a person .ntired that experincntal chanber, you knew whether or not it w -s one of your rxn? A Yes, I knew that. Q .j-.d ycu checked up -nch and ev.ry Ust on these individuals -nd =ad. sur- that a wrin*_r was not wrong in on you; did you? A I kn-w who th.se con w.re, Q 11 nor, what i 1 ttitud-, Dr. Rettbere, . • capacity of a prisen-r or a p-rson incarcerated to volunteer for an -xp_ri_-x.nt? You have n. rd h-rc at this Tri bun al, sooo cay that a pri- ::r ~ r could not volunt__r for anything, son- think he could end sorte -fink he was co -reed, hat ever the situ-tion nay b_, raiat is your at- ccnc-rninr th. capacity of a p-r3cp incarcerated to volunteer r a medical -xprir^nt. C 6887 2 Ks 7 -i*- o =urt Sc. 1 Key 47 -A—15-2-iHK-Jester (Tea Sehon} iur document bock nov. the translation ve have no- I vent to use it as i«. -=ut it ie paragraph number 1 in the Gersan - nunher 2 and 2 . in the 3er=an. and then the last tvo brief paragraphs in Genian before ^orc •he signature aooeer. of Catcher. And you will note the copiea as such. I have here another nineographed Gerean copy, tve copies of it, that contain it in the sane nonner *. this here, that I Just received that I can give the defense counsel for their use. 2 -ill have other nineo- graphed copies of the Gernen cut and deliver it to then later. I -ant to paes this up. TG KGSIOST: Have you a cceplete translation of the docucent? .£. KAPUT: The prosecution didn't see fit to translate the docu- nent in it. entirety because of the inn.teri.lity of the other nere- graphs. If Tour Honor rooucsts it, -e -ill have it. TG HGilDnTT; As long as this confusion has occurred, the Tribunal i.airta the entire docuaent translated rih. KAPUT: Tes, Tour Honor. TG GiSXUKTl —furnished to Oaraan counsel end to the Tribunal SArBFs Thanh you. TG rG£-JJi: C: Then there vill bo no ruction but "hat counsel for both side, have the entire dccuacnt before then. hh. KAPUT: Thank you, Tout Honor. TG PGSBBM* Counsel. I notice also the stenographic notes there. If thee, eoold he trenslet.d, he,, the. «X». If ««r eon * read. I don't hnov vhether they can or not. KB. KAPUT: Tcs, Tour Honor. a-.. TCKtEiS: hr. /reeldent. I oh.-eet to the KteUelm of thl. docunent for the follovle* reesone. 0.1. doeunent -« hy tho oroeeoutlon before. It he. teen -tei-d «•* thl ' 4 ’“' =ent there U . dl.ercnency h.tveen the -relon In the hndHeh doeonent text end the version In the Semen doounent text, Sh. ^ to-. .*• ■illegible* while the bnglleh text confine this portion of tho docn- . I Shtsild Ilk. to eteto that if e doonnent 1. illegible for the 5523 -ent CO « J ourt So. 1 Hay 47-A-13-&-i£X-5ost*r (Von Scfcon) purpose of copying it oust also be illegible for the purpose of transla¬ tion. which apparently was not the case. Is this document now being sub¬ mitted to c-oplete the orevious subaission. or is this a ccaolctely new document? — ifi. HIED?: Tour Honor, that is a very staple hurdle duo to the confusion, thon I will offer this as croaa examination docuacnt and aaaign it the saae nu=b*r that it has now and use it here now, the para- 9 graph, in the sane manner as if ve wore introducing a new docunont. JUDQI SiBRIHG: kr. Hardy. HR. EARDT: Yes, Tour Honor. JUDGI S^SSIK: You say that this photostatic cony which has now been furnished the Tribunal is a correct photo.tatlc copy of the origi¬ nal? HR. HARDY: That is right. JUDOS SSBRISO: Kay v« not a«ot the objections then by having tho interpreters who aro here in the courtrooo read this docunont. trans¬ lating it as they go and road it into tho record? hR. HARDY: That would be oerfoctly suitable, Your Honor. Do you scan tho docunont In its entiroty? Hi. VCS'ZEX: I believe X understand the nrosocutor corroctly if I believe that this docun.nt SO 1602-PS is withdrawn as tho original docu- =unt and ho now wants to sutait ti os a docunont for cross examination. HR. HARDY: It is innaterlal the manner in which I do it. Your Honor. I don't think the objection h*ro has any bads. JES PRiSIUSST: bell, counsel, the Tribunal now has before it a good clear photostat of the entire docusent in German. If tho trans¬ lators will now read that document, and it will bo of course translated into Inglish for the record, will that satisfy you? Will that be a satisfactory solution for you? The entire docuacnt then will be read 'into the record. You nay examine the photostat of the entire docunont in tho German la ngu ag e. HR. HARDY: He has a copy of it in the Gcraan language. Your Honor. 5834 Court Sc. 1 2 May 47-A-13-4-SB4-Ioster IVcn Scbon) nineographed. TEi A copy of the satire docunent? MS. EAP-TT: Tes, four Honor. TEZ ESZSXXfcSTl Is that a satisfactory procedure to you? IX. 1CEUEX: Mr. President, the poiat is whether this document ie w to subcitted a«rely for identification, for cross examination of the defendant, or vhether it is submitted as a docuaont aad ie accepted by the Court as a docuneat exhibit. la the latter case it %-ould hove to be given to no 24 hours beforehand. x YZ p?iS:2i:.T: I ns act impressed vith that objection. That is the general rule tut unless counsel shivs tone good reason vhy in this instance the rule should bo enforced, the natter coning uo, the Tribunal vould not be inclined to cause dcla-' and confusion by eirroly vniting 24 hours for you to read vhat you can read now. It is on unfortunato error tut there vns nothing inUrtionnl etout/^Tho ocoloyco vfcc copied the docuaont simply neglected to state that it vas a partial cony instead of a couplet* copy cad that can, the person vfco certified to it to bo u true copy, also neglected to state that it v B o not a complete copy but n translation ucrely of a portion of the docuncnt. In nher words, those vho prepared this dccunsnt, the stencils for the inglish docunent book, inply copied the sheet vhich ves in the record nc it v 00 lr.tr-educed bef-re tho International Tribunal. It voa o careless nlrtako bit it is easy to bbc hov it could hrvt hapocned. 6895 Court i May a-Ar-14-l-ED-Cook-Von Schoen. DR. VCRVSaK: Then I will consider the suggestion of the President acceptable. MR. HARDY: »,w la it my -nderetanding, your Honors, y.u want the interpreters to read the German ar.d translate it here into the record? THE PRESIDENT: I don't think that is necessary. I think If the counsel for the pro6ecutl n has the entire document translated into English and stencils are cut and c.unsel receives a mimeographed copy, counsel for the prosecution may now examine the witness as to the portion ..f the document which ho desires. I can see no reason for an objection. It will do no harm to the defendant. You see that t..ls d cuaont will be furnished in a completed f rm t the defense Counsel as s on as -possible. MR. HaRDY: In order to do that I request of tr.o Secretar: General that the Prosecutl .n be permitted t, retain t.;ls document Exhibit 44 in it's possession until wo ay check It for oafe-keeplng. . THE PRS6IDEKT: I assume that the document vjill be available in its complete fora by Monday? MR. HaRDY: I hope so. 3Y MR. H«RDY: Q. K w, Dr. P. mberg, you .^ve at-ted here th-1 Hr. Rascher exhibited t; you a letter at this conference in Munich, c ncernlng the fact tnat Klmuler ordered tnese experimental subjects must be volunteers. Kow I wane to " d y »u this p'-rti.'R of this document, which ncited this alleged Himmler letter. I will start with the third paragraph of the German walch reads as follows: "For the time being I have been assigned to the -uftgaukoamandv VII, Aunich, f ,r a medical c.urse. Durin 0 is c urse, where researches .r. ..i fc r. altitude flights >Se6 iiay 2 -A-i 4 - 2 -HD-Coofc-V.n Schccn- play a pr.minent part (determined by the a.mevhat higher ceiling of the Hn a lieh fighter planes), considerable regret was expressed at the fact that no tests with nunan oaterial nad yet been oossible for as, as such experiner.ts are v ry danger »ua and nobody volunteers for them. I put, tharef re, the serious question: can you make available two ,r three professional criminals for these experiments? The exooriaents are made at pernanant Luftwaffe Testing Station for altitude Research, Kunich. The oraeriments, fr in which the subjects can, of course, die w ,uld take ilaco witn ay cooperation. They are essential for re¬ searches on higr. altitude flight and cannot be carried ut, as has been tried with monkeys, vn. offer entirely different teet-cihdltions. I have had a v.ry confidential talk with a representative of the air forces sur o 0 '.n who makes these experiments. He Is also of the opinion that the question could only be solved by experiments on human persons .* and thor. the signature of Rascher aopcars on tho djoucent. How, do /o- still maintain that after receiving that l?ttor Himmler says you will use volunteers? A. Ir. my opinion there is very little connection. This letter la very old. It is dated 15 Hay, 19<1. At obviously records Rascher'a first ideas lr. this dlroction about experiments. It says, for exsm lo, that no expurl- cants could be performed with human beings, yet, and tnsre 1 ? oroof against this In the work done in our institutes, where many doctors and tr.eir associates volunteered lor experiments up to at least 1 ? kilometers, but It is muen rA her tr.an the calling of the fighter planes presently in use mentioned here. i. ;ow. Dr. Ruff, states that Dr. eltz and all of 58c 7 Court 1 ;>• 2-A-l4-3-H5-Coolt-V.n 3cr.oen. these -eople arrived at th c co.'.ol.siv., they visaed to ixaerlaer.t n the Jac .au concentration conp inmates early in 13-1. llov isn't t.iie the be c ir..in t ? A. That the w.nt.d sac. experiments In 1941? No, hoc in& was 6aid about that? i. No this is the be e lnnin . Now they are Just 3 tart ini and ash Kiasler to find criminals for tr.ese croer-ner.ta si.:ly because no bo ay vil’ volunteer for t.wm. In -t. .-r words, 1. they could r.ovo volinteurs tney wouldn't have had to resort to Joo/.aj c noentmtion cam? inmates, ver s incle. A. Not I ashed hi — l.r, -ut nasober oa/.ed Hirtulur. That la n^c. lfc*t is wnet I art t. Uln 0 about, naoc..er ashed Hlonl*r? a. And whit he says here ia incorrect In oan. resueota He r.aya no experiments a ve been performed, that is not true, tad the eu o;: e3tion t-. -ae fc.ble minded jeoule w lc he ua.-.es Is absolutely wort leas. ..r. ivuf. has alro-dy spohen a- at that. «. Now let's c o to the next l.tcer in that dooumont b k. .oa say return that doOumant. It is on oc_e 54 of the dooument coo-. 2. unfortunately this document doesn't contain a i te. however it states: "Dear Jr. flasefaer: 8. ortly before flyin t to Oslo, the rxlcnafuehrer iS a ve me ■ ur latter of lu xoy V 1, for oartlal rpoly. "I cn lnfo-i you that DrlsoQcra will, of course, be -ledly nado available for the ..1 ,n flight researches. I .. e informed the Chief of tne Security Police of cnls a-ra sent ^f the rtelohsfuehrer S5, one requested tna^ the c TcttinZ official be instructed to *ot in t ubh w’t • ; oa. “ 66S8 Court 1 May 2 -xv-14-4-HJ-Cook-Vor. Sohoen. That la Initialed Rudolf Brandt, low this is the letter w.-.ich g ve Mr. Rasoher the authority to use concen¬ tration camo inmates, Is It not? Isn't It authority to use nrisonera for the experiments, and that the particulars w_l be outlined by the Chief of the oeourlty Polloe, doeen't It say that? A. That Is an agreement of the Relchsfuehrer to tola fIrst suggestion of Rasoher of Aay, 1941, but no details * ore set forth. That Is right. It la ar, u 6 reement to allow Raschsr to exuerl ..ent at Jaohau or at any concentration c op, and to ^et prisoners tnorefrom, because of the fact • Rr.scher stated In the letter -wnich Incited thia answer that ne couldn't get volunteers for such a program, Isn't that what those two letters convoy to us? a. hr. Rascher hod to deal further with this problem. lhero woo no doubt furthor correspondence. %. 3.t you don't Know that, do you? You don't know that? You aro assuming that? A. lo, I don't know what corresDondenco there was. *. Your only answer to it Is an lmoglncable letter fr to .ilcclor statin^ they must have volunteers, isn't that It? A. I do not see that. I stated there was a letter from Himmler.' Ve ion't have It here. I Just assume if Jhore was sue a le.ter we would h.ve It here. Ve hove most of them talking about selecting, an- setting aside experi¬ mental subjects, and .-.lmmler then in that letter rrom Rude If Brandt and his other letters talked about persons who were condemned to death, if he successfully lived t .rough the ex .erlaent, or whereas he was recalled to life, 6399 Court i liay 8—A—14— o-gJ— Co k—Y n ecuoen. he asay -e p. rdoncd to She concentration cex? for life, 'it in -11 of there le.ters ..r. r.ioiler never nentione tuat Che; nj't he volunteers. This is not present in a one of ;he document? in tnie case. a. Thera erar.'t vary -any letters on it. T is letter [ry cx -cle says nothin, eb^ut >'rdor.in-, 'nd r.in..ler nanilned th< : in r let ter. «nd perhaps that la t..o firat elite ne aai'.tionad it. I don't think ve should i-tlo ab,ut that any xoro. Lit'* _.o ou to ..nothar subject. how concerning tne low pressure c.-a user, wnen Ruff 6ont this low press-re Chamber from .-.is institute -n ec'c.ou, did ;ou oc.oa? ny tne drivers fr<;a =«• iir. to .nlcu with the chamber? «. •h- tner 1 wont with them? jio. %. nftcr the cnaih.r arrived in »>acnau, accordm*, c- the to tioony of K ff, I belieye, -oe oo isted in as e.a:lln c thh cneaber ao t.*‘t it w,uld >a lr. it6 eroour f r- r.d use bio, la t .at correct? a. Aft r t o c .. uoer arrlv b in i^onaa, I went out to D ci-ai together wit-, assc.. r « nd nasc.ur .rv. the instr^ct.rns vn*t nad to be done, an electric con ootion d c be laid ->nu wnot else was necessary to use the c-.«iabor. *«.• -ell, did ;o urrlvc at whe aria tijo the onouner arrived or diu ou arrive at 8ou^ 1 ter d te? • a. I arrived lj. facr.au wit.'. .v»ecn r when tne Oiwxher * s already there. Veil now, to clarif th .n^s, ve want to et these s trai-.-t in mind. .f_en di che c.'perlxjnts begin? a. The first beginning vas actuall; on tne <22nd nd 3v_ o: rVoruary. 65GC C art I .is? 2- n n. w oh—Von oo.ioer.. K . When did -o _s. e a? yoar es-r.c. t.-^t vsa Cr.o deje v-ien t..c experiments be^an? a. Ihay were eapooeed to e6 c in on tnet do:-- sue v don't a..ow v-iethe: ?.-/ a.'-oeriventr ve a foto-lly oarriod a; n c.iat day. «t any rate the? vera atooned elnoat iuzediHCely. ±o vare Mere on tr.e 22r. o? febroery, o. oa.ld t-- c on direct eraoir.ntior., 1 . 'da raaamber? a. ¥ea, I wtb tr.ere or. the Sind cr the 33rd, yea. 'Then did . ou a ed-enl. diac-over yoa were at tVc:a or. tr.i 3 2 nd ;a- of februer•* Vfiendjd - remo-noer t . t, or v o Xw. ye re-ember-C. jX vara In O .o.iau n Me 22 nl day of fadreary? «. ..o, I juet resu-d-red tn*t »ni./.ere v..tsn Meff la axaoln n told *hia, fcna.t *./o v;otc. - ie alrtnday table, tnen I remembered t.at ft*-t, and ?lao I .ov I in-. t n*ve bov.i there on t v c d-»S' e nd tr.o nc. t _a bio use 1 oen remember che birthday trble. "oil didn't .• I don't vjt to got into a discussion of vhothcr or not you aisled Dr, Suutcr, but he sec.ed to oc quito caphatie aoout tho fact t t you v.uld testify under o_th, .ad I would bo willing to consider tlv t Dr. Santor thought th„t, too. a uuttor of f^ct, I wouldn't third: hr. Scuter would s-y such a thing unless you had either told hiu or unless he ro^caaoly believed th_t th..t w.s what you told Buff. 3o tn..t us it we vill go on. On February 22, 1942, the cxjfcriaents began; is that correct? a. I c-»'t tell you exactly whether any experiments were performed or aot. Shat vj a Sunday. Probably vc didn't do any vorh on that *-‘4 . 'out V_ irohe off the exoeri-eats i—cdiutoly, .md postponed then until the be iaain of .._rch. 5902 2 X;?t-*J?>15-d-?dldt (Inti Vou oczoa) Court I 0. 'ittl the be-jinaing of i._rch. iTov, hov t.any series of e;:pcH ri.--nts did you h-ve? Tour, wasn't it? Tour series, so to span!:? To hod four different copios in your report? 4. Tes. H;w long did it t.Jcc you to collate Oach series of c;r>cri-:onto? a. I can't t.y exactly in dot-11. Sonetl~ce they vcrc gol*- on at the tr.ie tiiio, not one _ftcr the other, but they wore c-rricd out p-r.-llol. Uhtll -11 four scries wore concluded, it too* until about t.io 19th or 23th of i.-y. How, whoa did t-o first donth occur? 2h~t -ust h-vc been the end of April. I* That w.j the end of ^rll? 2nd of *pril. Sica -1-oot L-.cdi tel;* thereafter you returned to Berlin, didn't you, after tfl-t donth episode? -k Tos. ^n!. r.ow lon«, did you raiuin in jerlln? a. I didn't stej- Ion,-; -t first. I wont b.cfc a&-in, us far no I roc all, and then there w^s the incidont with tho barouotor, so that... I*ov, fust u —onent. -o will „ct to th .t, *ftor you went to Jorlia tho first ti -c, th-t is, aftor tee death, tho douth havjonod about tho ond of .s-.ril, tnca ou went to jerlln, -toon vhon you rotumed, as I underst-nd it, you vitnessod oaotflOr one or two doaths, is that ri^ht? 2h-t v-s before the b-Tenet er incident; is th_t ri,*iit7 a. .o, the buraiotor i .cident *.ust fc-vc been rijht uftor 2 roturnoc fra Berlin _ftor 2ech-u. Q. She b..raietcr incident w-o -fter you returned to O.-cfi.-.u, that io, _£tcr the first de-th. fhut is the b-rccetcr incident, all rl^ht. Sou, after tno b-rcceter incident, th-t ~ust c .ve o^oa now aLioot tho first of key, wasn't it? Zac o. ; rcc-etcr incident? You inist h-vc stayed in jtrXia a t‘-c_ or setter. .a. It took uiito ES-c vnile to h..rc tho oarn.cter rep-irofi. I 6903 P-15-3-?eldt (In:, von Sehsa) Co-art I 3. £cu lone did you st.y in n.rlin after tnc first deutr. and until the ti_e you returned and found tne o_.rcu.etor broken? a- Only a few d_ys. *. oil, how naijy «L^s? Can't you oo u littlu -ore specific, two, thr-o, four, five, six? ^ftor I roturnod frou reporting tnc death, perhaps four, fivo 4-C'B* 1. All ri£ht. Four, five day. In -t tJccc you nu..rly to tho first of ..ay vton tho b .reactor was orokon, is t:;-t ri,*.ht? Almost tnc first of i*-y. a. It could oo »oout tn„t tl-o. "U And uow whon did tr.g second one third doatn occur? 2 :..t v-i l..t«r, after I Ca-.o o_cx with tho repaired b..raiotor, 3. now Ion,; did it t Jec to secure tnc o_ra.ctwr? aoout two weeks? a. Lf course, I don't know or^ctly. I don't think it took c^uito two wooes. It wouldn't h-vc ta^au th..t Ion,;. •+ 3. loll, wo Will « a;.- it took ..oout u week, fh-t will orini; us ») to tnc 7th of k^, wouldn't it? ftaon th^tvo dc_ths ocourrcd ^f.or you got b-c freu 3trlin with the oj-o^otor, isn't th-t ri«ht? 3. And they occurred now lon 0 -ft<-r th-t tine? when you colic b.ck with tko b-rcuctvr, I -ssunc you -used tnc uressurc elu-oer boforo Rntchor did. I assume you Carried on so.e of your work oeforo .-Uechor did, anti then the tvo deaths occurred. Sow, it .mot h_vo beon c period, of a week or tvo wcuks, or sacothinc lixe tn .t, wasn't it? a. I ax euro tn_t _fter I ca-o b„c< with tho b-ra.otor I per¬ formed soco experiments. I w^s trying to . ot our experiments finishod. 3 . loll now tnen how Ion,; before the completion of your experi¬ ments did tho deaths occur? 2 hc two do_ths. a. about w week bvfcri the «-ud of th- expn’im-nts. 6504 2 i»ey-JrJ?-l5-4-Jcldt (la*., von Scbcn) Court I 3,. about a week. Ton arc ecowdin^ that ia pretty closely new. Blink hard. about a week, lg to : ri : £t? Ihc do..th didn't occur bluest a ii-nth ooforo taa conclusion of the cxp.rincnts, did It? Ho, th..t is -bout ri^fct for the first doath. 11 right,. *hen, oa the 20 th Dey of iay tho pressuro cn.ufocr left 3-ch_u -ad went b-ck to dvrlia, is ta-t vh-t you wish to toll US? . It did. Veil, now, 'tor you got the pressure chaibor b.ck at jerlin vorc you tho-. when it got o .c to J~rlin? A. Tot, I w..s ia J-rlia, too. %. sow b dly sashed up w.j it vhea it got b..ck to icrlin, or v k .i it in ;ood order? ft. -hen it c_ac bacfc to Jcrlla there v-o nothing broken. It v o in us-blc foru? ^ Tos. How wo are going into hr. Hoff's testimony. Do you recall that ..r. Hoff ot .twd tfc-t he sabotaged tho chauocr at D-cbuuT Do you recall th t? ^ Tes, I rcawber th..t, -hid n:v you co c .Ion.; -cd st..to th..t tho b..ra:our was broken vhen you returned fra. j.rlin, waicn ..ore or lesn corrobor \tcs tho tecti..;ay if ».r. Hoff th-t tho ch^-o-r h-d boon d.ii^;cd, dooen't it? . Tes, Q, Then *.r. Hoff st..tod th-t you went to Jerlin to get spare pgrts to repair tuc b raict.r, or the pressure ca.„ 0 Lr, ,.nd-th..t it took you ne rly two wc.ks, a- 6t-tcd, to gwt ta^ p rts, isn't that ri.pit? Ei t is wh .t lioff told ua. e>. Tot, th.t is about vh..t he s.ii. .. Then by th.t token he «-id th_t was the ro^son why ej^K-rl^to were still .oiog cn ia the -oath of June, isn't tk_t ri ht? 6905 2 2-.eg»wv?-l&-&-?aMt ( 1 st. von bchcnj Court I WU Yes, He even 6-id th-t thoy 1-stcd till tno bosinninfi cf July. I-.t'a ri^it. -oil now, cere ve h..vc . struc,;c thisg. Dofen- d~nt Huff Docucest 3ook, this is -ixhibit 10, Docaicat Jo. G, in tho Doouooct 3ocfc Ruff . o. 1, which is the affidavit of Dr. KoX hatch os. Oa pa<;o 22 of the .-fcaff Docuaest Book, the socoad puTa<7raoh, Dr. ha.tthos S-”S as follows: "Osly at tho th-0 of uy conversations with Dr. Ho.ubor , did I also loara th_t a low pressure chtfJbflT h-d cone bach free Daflh.au .ccordins to a;' rwoolloctioa, the low proaeuro oh.nber uust have ca-c o-cx to tho Institute in ...y, 19«i2. I ca rw.w.bor tho d-to b. cause after tno return of t-o low pressure chnabor I was ordered by Dr. Huff to t Jee c trip to Colo-ync ic ordor to procure spare parts. I ado this trip, and on th-t occasion I was in uy hcoo to \rr. of Bonn. *h..t v .s ia t..o ti-.o froa 1 June to 10 June, 1942, so that tho low pressure cc-.Ov-r auet h-v* beer, returned to tho Institute in ..ay. 1942.' How, hero is a representative of xoxff's fott- ia<; spore p-.rto octwooo tho d .tes 1 Juno and 10 June to repair n low ?VW ouro ch.i.oor, .nd you rcc-11 th..t ..r. doff s.-id taat ho c-J0t vd the chamber in the letter p.Jt of hay, Ad tn.t hr. Rosenborg, woo two vochs ..'attic.? thv op.je v.rtg to rvtura to D.xhnu to repair said chcfoor aid th .fc ho. returned .bout the aiddlo of Juno, How, isn't this coincidentil, doctor? d. Yws, it is. It curt-inly is, isn't itT -w But I thine I can explain it. ->.e b-ra.etcr v_.o rcpjirod in Berlin by tho lutz fir., welch repaired e-ron^t-rs ~nc w..lch feed su;>'licd tho b ..raster ia the first pl-cc. «ad .-...tthus' trip to Bean — 4. To Cologne. =o w..a i.. Joan, his hccc — Yes, Sons v-s hie hc*:o town. His trip to Cefegao h„d nothiu;: t do with - rwp-lr of t,;» buren^t-r. If I reaa;oer correctly, Huff 6906 3 i^ 3 NwvP-l5-6-?«Ut (1st. von Scfcoa) Court I would probably h-r, fcieva Ui bettor — vie fira w..lc.i --do the pitrp* v.a located la Colo & -ac, puops for low pressure eiva-oers. (J. '-hat were you ^'OttlO£ spora p-rts for if the- low pr..96uro ch..:jor was ia ?. ood eoaditloa whoa you brcu^it it b-c.: to Jorllaf did you seed parts for at th-t tiao? That vaa ca tuaecoaaary trip to t-':e uoa fra. hla hoao town oad acad hia -11 tao v-y to Colo.aio to u ct parts when the;’ weren't seeded. 2 ho parts were seeded. X do sot .siow ..... 5? 07 Court I 2 Way UT-A- 13-1 - LcG - Harrow (von Sc her.) Q. leu stated h-re just a rlnute ago th t the chcab-r was in good condition. Sew, i-t's aako up our ainds, Doctor. A. I don't have to sake up ry .ind. The puaps which Vtetthos picked up in Cologne — I don't oven know whether they wore for this low pressure chanter or Mother tho. *.r. needed for one of too otfcr mobile lew pressure chatter which Vero also in operation. This work book of P’ohlaaister ifcich was sub^ttod here, it shews that th.ro *.ru sever'.1 lew ..rvssure chi b_rs in .rlin. That book mentions a low prossuro cha-bor at tho ti.-o when tho other chanter was at Dachau. It was still undor construction and tho pusps wore prct.'bly for this •ther charter. If you have the book t.vre — thr t ork book — you can sec that cl-arly. 3. Wall now, let's discuss anot *-r section of this low pressuro ctva.ifcor tr .rsfor. Who gave you tho authority, and Ruff tho authority, to ruccvo tho low prossuro cheater fro.i Dachau to Berlin on tho 20th day of Say, 191,2? A. tiho authorised Ruff? Q. lus. A. Probably th t r s dona with tho -.dic il Inspectorate just like tho transfer down to Dachau, in order to h ivu travel ord-rs. In this case, it was a little difforont 1080 it was Sent by railroad. 3* That's right. Ho couldn't remove at without authority from above, could ha? At lonst, th t's wiist ho tells us. A. T ';o it out of Dachau? 3. 1-3. <• Tuu didn't n-od p_raissicn fron above-, meaning fro-: Sio Luftwaffo, so :uch as _ mission fro. Hirral.r ir.d ?.ascber particularly, to g-t it out of Dachau. 4 . art!, you aaan to say til .t Dr. Ruff could have rjT>cv_-d tha low pressuro chaster fro •. Dachau -at any ti-e ho so saw fit? A. !Io, •.e certainly couldn't. 69C8 Court I 2 *a; U7-A - 6~2 - LJj _ Sorrow ,vor. SchoO) boat's right. That's what o Bays. Hu couldn't. A. YwS. «. -ell r.cw, lut‘a look at ;.r. /ilea's letter on pug- 77 of Doev.-ant Book luabcr 2. This happuna to be dated the 20th of .-ay, 19U2. It is Document 3^3A-.-5, Pago 77 of the English. Now let's rood this: "Dear -olffy:" (It is oddru33ud to 53-Cb-rgrup.s_'.fu_3rcr Karl *«olff iroa Field marshal hilch.) "In reforcnca to your tologrr. of 12 May, eur radical inspector reports to M that the ltitudc exj.r. or.ts carried out by the 33 and Iultwaffo at Dachau have boon fxnishod. Any continuation of those expert. iuoae . )y unreasonable, Hew-v.r, the carrying out of oxn-ri lor.ts of sonu ot \*r kind, ir. regard to p-rils at high s«as, woulfl bo important. T.-...50 have boon prepared in i- A.il agrotnont with the proper offioos,- Cfc-rst.bs.artt :>elts .\ill be ch.rged with tho execution end St bsrxit .basefur will be node cv-.ll ble until further or _r in -dciticr. to hie duties within *Jjc Vodic .1 Corps of • • A c.v . . : tbjso docauros docs not appear nec-sotry, urrf r. -niarge ur.t ci rha task in not cons id. red pressing -.t this tiwi. “uo low—pressure. civ*•■bur will n-t be noodcid for those low-lorap-r- aturo experiments. It is urgontl; n-eded at cnoth.r place and thoro- fer, car. r.c ior.a-r resain in Dachau. "I convey tno spocial thanks.....otc." -iiA ".41ch a . , h_rc or. thu 23th of -lay, ••Hah is just beginning to discuss V.o fact t.:at it should no lcng.r rca-oln in Dachau. He thinks it is still ir. -cchau, d-^sn't r.c : You haven't received orders to ranovo It ~t. H:. did you reaov*. at: L.t's turn to the next Ltt-.r, Doctor. A. r by spying to Hose her, who >.ar..ed tc 5909 Court I 2 ~vy li"-a - lc-3 - LJ - Narrow (von Schon) carry on the -xp_ri .jr.ts, "Reach~r, there's no point in your trying to ae the c.aixer here any longer. You "ill only succeed in doing so for two or three weeks, at the must. It will be better if v;e stop with the c -jeber new and perform new experiments later", and P^scher agreed to this. I ca led B and said, "*uff, I've managed it. ne car. tale t o chamber away." Ruff sent the drivers down and tho chamber was taken out of Dachau, and that's hew it happened. Q. el new, hare we have another letter, fortunately, dated 1* June 1 2, on pa,e 7b, Document Book Nuatoer 2, and this is from Milch to Hippie. It reads as Icllewa: "According to t.ie agreooent with t e -teichafuehrer SS the lew- pressure air chamber fur ex oriaeato in the neighborhood of iunich is still to be available for tro months Icnioc reover, the Stibsarst Dr. 'asc.'er ia, ir. addition to hia tests in t c H'Xtwaffe, to be on dut; for ue ’rosent Jor the purposes cf the Peichsfuehrer SS. "Hell Hitler, Yours, .ilch." Ko sent a co.v to SS Cfc -rgruopenfuohrer Aolff. 21 :-., esr.'t it ap oar that .alt.r ..off's -emery is muen better tftas; yours7 A. No, I knew very io) th-.t ‘he chamber was already gono at that tiomj tiut the high altitude experiments had been concluded. I at ia, ir. part, cle r fr - a letter which Readier himself wrote to Hippkc. Let's turn to the next letter, N0.28L, or. pa^e 79. Jurt turn # •he pa,e: "Dear Dr. R^scher: "-our letter of 5 *Hr.e 1 - 2 ..." Non we're up to the 5th of June, and, according to these documents, the chaatoer is still there. “Jeur letter of 5 June 1:2, to Reichsfuehrer-SS was handed SS-^oergruppenfuehrer ITolff, Chief of BeJ chsf*ehrer-Si» Personal Staff, 6610 Court I 2 U7-A - 16-4* - LX Narrow (vor. Sctaon) fcr furt.jer action, cr. whose behalf ^ wish to inforr you thut in keeping with an order of Field Marshal -ilch the low-pressure cha.-aber is to resair. available an additional two conths fcr experiments. Field Marshal Hilch also ordered th-1 in addition to your experiments fcr the Luftwaffe, also you are tocontir.ue working until further notice for the purposes of Re'ch3fuehrer-SS." Hew, according to this letter — not according to ycur opinion, but according to this letter, the chaafoer is still at Dachau, isn't it? A. No, I don't 3ee tnat. The letter is nothing but. 3. Well, we'll lot the IMbunal decide. Tell me. A. May I soy something? Q. certainly. Go ahead. A. This .ettor is >*roly or.o to pass on the letter fron dlch which has just been rad. That is, the letter of the lith of June, Exhibit 36. Q. Bight. A. Ar/i xulch writes tjat the chamber is to stay for two noro norths. 3. Teat's right. A. Whether llch, when he wrote hie letter, ictually knew that the experinents r.ad already boon stopped and wrote thi3 letter never¬ theless; cr whether e didn't knew it, I can't Judge. 3. las, but you couldn't remove tiv.s charter — either you or Ruff — withe permission f ppks cr -ilch. 't forget that. You couldn't remove it. You ddr.'t have the authority to |fke it out of there after you had one death occur — to step these experiments of iascher. You ha: to i«avo it there because you would need a superior order. How, here are, acj-e or loss, orders telling you to leave it -.-.ere fcr two nenths, didn't they? A. -i»e higher orders needed to renove the chanter had to coo • - - .-r Beecher. Be dan t agree to returning tbo chamber. 6911 Court I 2 a- 47-A - 15-5 - I JO - Karr car - (Von Sc hen) fclch hlisslf , or Eippke, as tic letter oJ the 20 th of say shows, could say that tho chaaber was not needed by them. .that had to ha/pen hap¬ pened — that Rase her approached Ilch, through Himmler, and asked to be ablo to .ee: it lcn.er and ilch writes, probably knowing th-t the chamber had alreacfy loft: "Yes, you can keep it longer." Besides, as far as the breaking off of the experiments is concerned, which according to the appearance of the documents, lasted two months beyond t .e J.th of Jr no ■— that was far into July — I should like to refer to tho lotter of Raacher of tho 5th of .fane, l?u2, Document No. 283, Exhibit £2. -asc :er writes: "a fen c\. s ago I *aa called into Hippko' office for a oonferenoo. "her. 1 told hira that the report on all the experiments was not available t, h d not demand any report. 0 Race.-.or himself writes on the 15th of June: "A few days ago I saw Hippko 0 , t t is, let us s^ , on the 12th ct Juno, and 'no also rrj.tes °*-he co plots report is r.ot finished", which ir.oicites tfc»t tho experi- aer.ts were already finished at that tL>o. 5. Uf course, that can be inter reted t at tho experiments wore r.ot finished and you had to finish thei u bolero you cculd finish tiio report. • -.re are two irays of intor,orating that. Doctor. Boo, toll co, Doctor daxx.-rg, after tho chufcer finally did got back to Berlin and the ex-ariaonts wore concluded — whether it bo the tlr.o you st-ato cr the ti v that is borne cut by the documents and the tostiaony of (alter Neff — then, as you baifu pointed out in your direct examination, Mr. Rase ;er received an assirnment from Hiitmler liter in the year, t at i3, in the fall or winter of the year, and •no f whc.se assi.nacnto, you havo ably pointed out, -as again rc3w.crch with low pressure chauftcr ar.d in tba s.ie field. How, did Rascher evur get a lew pressure chamber a^air.? In late 19L2 cr 19ii3V A. No, he did net. }. You have stated t. it ho cc* ldn't get one all over Germany, didn't you? Xou stated on direct examination that he tried to got one •r/i ha couldr. t get one? 5312 Court I 2 a; Ii7-«w - lo-c - LJG Karr:»w (von Schon) and he couldn't got on-*? A. No, I did not say th;t. -In qy direct examination I osroly quoted the individual docua^nts showing nascher's efforts to get a new lew pressure chamber. i. .«ell, he didn't got one, did he? A. To as./ knowledge and to the knowledge of the edical Inspectorate which we contacted later, ho did not receive any chanter. 3. Did he get your chaster? A. Ours? No. Ho nust have gotten so-vi cha.bcr because he conducted oxyx-ri- nents in 1&3 with a ch\-fc-.r. H.ro in t o SioVors Diary which 5s Docuaont I?o. 538 containad on page 65 of Docu-!*r.t Book Nusbor 3, ia an entry under date of Afril 6, 1&3, tho eighth 0 ntry node by Siovors reads os follows: S91.3 o to 1^7 ul -A-L7-1-; kp- Bioisi (vor. Schen) f ourt Mo, 1 '• 9 9 ■CoatiJtt&tion of the 1» pressure cipher experiments." * it appears thit he had si_a sort of c: -aber down there, doesn't it? ’-as it yours? A. ;.h£t was the date of this entry? # q. i believe I said the 6th of April 1913, end it is in the Sic vers Diary. ^ need to look at it, Doctor. I quoted it to you. A. So, I dt:i»t have it he re anyhow. I Just want to sa7 that r «ght have something to do with Docuner.t .0-270, Exhibit UO, if. Docwvant Book 3, rfcero Beecher tells boat is conference with Hippke. Again, .a says tint 1* -ants to conduct low pressure efeabor expertaants with r- at the saac t he was in Berlin. Anyhow, ho went to sec Silvers ur.d s*dn told him ttrt h.. wanted to e-.ntir.ue the low pressure chsntur vxr^ri-.et.ts. Just as ho .^d to\A Hippke, q. tell, let's..- •«» fw High Altitudes." And thit you wroiy to.k p- ,lc " n » quickly, up by oxolosiv- M ? nocei-n, end dc«r. I B lflUi.or parachute and that you w-ro o>t interacted in anything «!*«• 2s that right? * it wos your jr internet - in A. TU-t -ias n p' > the Gernnn; n:t of the Dvcu^-nt B; k, but of the Gemui document itself. How, ,n pego 16 of th- .rifiin-1, the L at paragraph the P« >, YAX oay thaw in ttv report - .-xnd by the way I aiffrt ask y« - that was y:ur sign lure on the report, was it not? A, Ics. Q. Ton soy fcboro: "In spito f the relatively Iatr. number of oxperiaonto, tho actual enuso >f the sever* «ntr.l disturbances and bodily failures (jr.ralysia, blindness, itc.) attend-.nt up n post- hyp xesic twilight stAoc r^ins S0B&»hr.t cf a rSdclU.’ ' t 's the * riddle? £911 2 Uc-j 1947 -A-iT-2-ok?- fliolsi (v.r. Schcr.) Court Ho, 1 A. One could net say exactly whether these severe failur.s wore caused line by tho L cfc of oxygon, ir whether they might have sxethLng to Co with tho bond a disease - caisson disease - or the bends disor.Se, Q. Si, then, -u -..ere interested, according to y_ur own rooort, in ttrt problem A -s or air bubbles, And your friend Rcschur ;bli od, suoolite tho nswsr to the riddle, didn't ho? !t> kilL-c’ a fd» people fir y: u, rirht in your presence. You were t'.vro. You watched tte autopsy. He shaied ?m tho bubbles in tho brain, in tho brain's blood vessels - the bubbles which were c us.c by the do- c cprossix.. That ran tho ms*.r, wasn't it...to the riddl.? You thought it i,-8, A. Ho. First A 11, Rsclwr was not .%y friend. An! "bends", -* c.uoted her- in cnn-ctia with the dwoaweaoioo which wer. c:>- porler.c-t tec us this was a f liter tur-, it was kra-wn v-rticulTly by t vy in : isson dis-cs^... it was not roally ro new probl-a. The finding .f ir bubbles in r.n autopsy is not in itself .an explanation A these fr.ilurv synptaas. Cro aieSit bo able to doternin e that in * >\,ry careful ex-ninr.tion if one could prove -ir bubbles in a Certain center. But, s far as I Jmaw that is very difficult or even impossible bec.uso air cobolim occurs in surgical caiKio too, for exacple, if vein is cut during an • operation, it rIso occurs — Q. I think wq -re l.agiUar with *11 that. Doctor. The joint I rs trying to b.*r out is th-t I ca not trying to indie-.te that you rd Ruff er.do Rase her do this, or tx A Rasch-r kill people, but you let him do it, -nd you w.rv Very glad to h'vo the answer to your riddle. Y.u at te in your p'per that ncit.hcr you nor Ruff after the murder saw to it tht Rase her was indicted for murder, did you? You needed that inf max ti on, nd you have it here in yxor report. A. No, t- t of course is not right. I must object to that strenuously. 7 o roierv-ti which Rsscla.r aado, which he gives in 6915 2 Ifcy Z.7 -A-17-3-?kp- 3iolsi (v» Schon) C-urt Jio. 1 his interim re; .rts, he newer and* them public in -ny way, 'nd never supplied then to the Luftwaffe, to Huff, or to ao in -ny way. He reformed. Q. Kell, doctor, ' 70 U go on c little bit in this document, ■here you and Ruff say...you end Rase her in this report... on the aaxt page, an excerpt: "It appeared often 's though the phenomena -f pressure drop sickness hid coobinud with the results of stver. cxygon lack." Your chief, Ruff, now has admitted on the stand that pressure drop sickrfcss does not occur if one takes people merely up and d^in quickly, but that a person has to stay up 1 :r soao tiao to develop this pressure drop sickness. 1 ell, who wen. those people th t you refer to in t his import when you state "It appeared often. n ..ho do you coin by that?....Just you and Rascher? Certainly you don't scan Just the two of y-u. A. I CB referring, for >ne thing. Iso to the exp-rimunt which ■as used tor cl*riflection, nd Iso to the slmi sinking exa-riawntu Shore these synptmis occurred, which *e,-o not clc r to us. And .as an •tteapt to explain those poculi/ r synpt-»ss this experiment was us-c* ■here, without -.ny l‘ck of oxygen, when sustained i -r n long time — it says forty minutes there — t thirteen kilometers, a siiailT 3vV-.ro corviition occurred with paralysis of both legs r ni interruption i the si,*ht which Lasud for two hour 3 . A simil'r condition s in the si*, sinking -xxrio-nts when, there, was really inly * l~ck of 'Xyi>r., nd really th.ru cxild be no bends te Jaigo by the time, but Just b eaus- the Seri us symptoms in this on. experimental subject, and *h. serious cyaatoas on my so If w.ro so ciiilr, this experiment on nyoelf is quote. lierc nly f jr this reason.- £. Th't's ri lit. will ex to th t. e wilL go into that a.re specifically. A. —And it is said "it pp.nr«L often." .. Bight. A. That rexairv-d open. ..o were not - ;i- to -.xol'in it quit-. - =-ant *.v tried to -xplnin thus, sympt,:s. - 2 1fay 47 -A-i>4-?k?- 3iolsi (vcn Schcn) Court Kor 1 Q. ..oU, joctor, you and Ruff both boro h-vu claimed thrt pur report «rdy concerted itself Kith repid -scant and iawdietd descent. Saw, thet was rlready withdrawn by Ruff when ho waa on chi st,-nd when I coafror.te. him with this part of the repx-t, the sclf- experim^nt which you end Raschwr hod perforn-d boccuso you 'nd Re sc her had stayed up forty minutes — I think yai stayed up forty -inutos -r.i Reach-r t*m ainut-s — and them you include this in your xxjpcrt oven th u^h this typo of re*, arch, risht here does not fell in »ith whet you cL' 1- was y^ir pr jbloa at all, d>os it? A. No, it ocs not. Tb-reforo.... Q. Th t «s rivht. A. Thrt is why ^ didn't p-rf»n thes- ocp-riaonts on experimental SUbjwCtS... Q. And further, Ruff 'daitted that it was the most -.nacrous experiment nd if it h-d not bv^n interrupted it might h-vu been fr.tel, didn't he? Do y:u think the same is Ruff did? A. Aac.rdin. to ay krwnlodgo today, yes. At the tlo. wo didn't know .-.bout this death yet, which hrd occurred in such long lasting experiments r.t • cert-in ltitude/ Ruff learned thrt in th- Acro¬ ss die 1 Center. This knowledro originated in 1946. Q. HOW cany tls*s did y.u nd Rasehcr go through this nano typo A experi-ount? Only that or>- time? % A. This uXporL&nt - this extremely lons-or*-? W. Yes, th t orw. A. It was p-rforo-d only once, I am sure, but otherwio- »o stayed up for cor.si'er ble tim. in oth.r _x>rinents. Then th.ro Wo minor disturbrncos. ;. Then you n- Raschur would hv. only exposed yourselves t; such danger -s th t? Is thrt it? A. •*. did not deliberately -xpos- .ourselves to thia danger to make m oxtre.^ -xo-ri®-nt ,but we stayed uo th.iv because other¬ wise in th- two -r thr,o ascents porday which vi. usu-ily p-r! jtc*. 1 .., 6317 2 !£-7 A7 -A-lT-5-pfcp*. 3i-Iai (vjn Sch~a) C-urt b* 1 r<£ * -' tun'-re's ir. th. s-c.rc .r third "scent v- h.d t h~&w sjnpt^aa which jit - t .ccur the -or at tine. And «« -.*jiUc then ted et-.rain~ riv-th-r • he sysot xia wen. c.'.uflvc by going up three tlo-a * isy,&nd, scy, ter. ml mi to a -t * tLo., r whether thu sra. uuld *ccur if -n- ges up for --- Ir.If hour. q. That .-“.a been -xpl ir.ed t- us fully by Dr. Ruff. But y.u nctu".lly went up tv th-a- two b&i;r.ts, 13,000 .r 13,5C: f—t 'n- y u et /eC trvvru 1 ,r n est*nsiv- length f tine on one oectaion rly. Is that ri he? A. Tr.-t r.-oeriJer.t t k place at 13 r 13.5 ton. That is what . it a-ys bore. Q. Y-s; nd u id it nly nc«? A. 1 can't a.-.y th t with certainty, but \k did n t that t :t.n. I M - Id n t Jmow f thia uxpori*mt t • U if it wen. n t .-.-ntivned in .is r<-.> rt. 6918 2 iiay-.w- :S-18-l-::eehan (Yon Schosn) Court I'.o . 1. o. You just said you die r.ct do it very often; rhet do you ’-osn rhen you say here: ;i It cypeered often ns though the phenomena of pressure drop sicknoss (acroerbolis:-) hod co’ binod rith the results of sovere oxygen Irek?" Vo r, doctor, isn't it that you sinpl; ir, this report did not -ant to r.ention the others, because they hrd died, since you one* P.cschor never interrupted cn experiment boenuse of rain felt by subjocts rnd rhen it says it appeared often, i£ certainly did, ir. Ro sober's vork at least. I did not quite understand tho quostion, but in any ccoo, J this happenod often" that moms the t the synptais in the slow sinking exporinonts, paralysis or interruption of sight, occurod that thoso ayrptons rero fonilicr to those In our o.*n exporinonts. o. '.'oil, no~ you don't d.ony tho f^ct thrt Rrschor, supposedly on his orr. initiative, conducted oxporinonts to determine this gas bubblo situation and oir-or.bolisn and prossuro drop sickness or :r you rant to call it. :*o did that on tho people at Dachau on his o--n initiative and p-rfor.:cd autopsies on then; you ar* tic autopsies; Ho ;id that, didn't he? Of covrso, ho did porfor. 1 . experiments rith fatal • results, f -t is provod V t .o Doaurscnts and ho apparently • v ral points in rind, ..ic'. ho -. anted to clenf- . 'ctualli told no hinsulf tiirt the 1.and Benda was one of tho things, he rontod to clear up, he provod they r -ro ir bubbles and he ranted to tvtr.cl: this problo-, but £hat 13 c field rhich had nothing to do ’ ith ours. y. fut neither did tills oxperinent, -hich you oonduct- . You - '. itted here right ...r- that this one experiment ..:i nothin-* to do rith your Xiold. ’.'o'11 go on ; ith this or-ort. In the next sentence ov str.to, ir. tho sere * 6919 2 ::ay-5.-C :S-18-2-roehan (Von S— oor.) Court Fo. 1. * prregrapl.: "In this connootio , t: c subjective accounts ir*do by t e authors m t-o experiments, each r-s intcrcstin;, for -'het happened to the objective findings, they -re only thc subjective findings; rhet happened to the objective findings? Oar om observations? I crnr.ot s~y exactly. hy disturbances ’-ero dcscribod according to the records that Raschcr kept. He wrote dorr. my a motors, I, ?'yaolf, of course, don't know that in detail. I rrs so seriously rffoctcd, oven afterward, that I did not k..or exrctly --hat had happened. .ell then, you did r.ot la o* , vhether or not you had pr.ssurc drop sickness, did you? ... ”o, durla: the experiment, I certainly did not know it. 9 I "1. 'Veil, nor here a.r.j so e tcll-tclo arks of your connection in that pressure drop sic2:ness which played n dofmito part. . Or. Prpe 18 of this report ’-horoin you state: this is in the English copy at the top of page 92, the first paragraph* the last rhrr3o in . ~ Inst sentence, lour u onor, - -here you st'tc thcro and I c ot«: "so that tfco idea of - combination of pressure drop phenomena nth tr.o phonononc of oxygon lack Is definitely suggested." Koc, you her! not othor clues to pressure dro sickness, than Rasch.r's air bubble3 ml -c: he ha shorn to you during an autopsy, had ou ... 3o‘, the air bubbles which one sees in an autopsy- are ot proof of t 13, the; 'or.'t necessarily havo nnytj-ing . For ox , in erso of onbolisn, 1 is Cfiuacd dr'inlny a lun , ' esidec the see 11 blood v-se-l :r_ generally cut and sr3 embolic: 13 caused in the blood stresn and aor-.etir-.es this oa .urs in fatal operations, but it :g not necessarily true that pcopU who die of gas embolism tlon, vc , a. 5320 2 - ah&n [Von s Court "o. 1. One cennot srj thrfc tho picture ol gas erbolisn necessarily lca^a to tho synptocs. Or. the other, tend one cannot sc;, if there ere these syr.ptor.a in 5 death. In cn autopsy, one piat h vc to find bubbles or i: tlx- rre found if they here anything to do nth tho-sy=pto:is, but the syrptor.s ere not V necessarily connected with these bub lea. But, you acy h-rc, I ruoto: Thr.t the idea of cor.binr.ti.on of pressure drop phonoTcna -ith the phcnor.ena of oxygen lack la definitely suggested. 11 Soft, you coul' not hrvc concluded that fror. your subjective experiences could you? Oh, :ea, bends r-r.s not a nc\ problu-. in eviction r.odicinc, the -hole field o 1 beats or caisson disease, or • hatever you ~ant to crll it, is v„r old problen. In tho jrr.vy it is crlltd Crisson-diaor.ac end it is called tho saaio thing in .h erio-, ! believe. 1. liov fror -our subjective experiences you could hr vc stated th-t rrs due t> oxygen mtoxication, para¬ doxical effect of oxygon ad. mis tret ion, or Tiything else in tho rorld; couldn't you? ... I don't think I understand tho question, tfould you , rind repentlng it? *>. i 3r id, you co Id have fra- ; ou subjective exp-r- ir.ents ou r.lrtcd h-rc, when you expeditod the aubjcctlvo .xporienc-s, I s~ld -hat s-- m this report, fro:, the f-c. of the report it 3 clf 'nd cn th. f-cc of your oxp-r- kr.c.s, that ti ls condition* phich you describe, could. have been due to anything else in th- -orId, it could be due to oxygen intoxication, to - paradoxical offcct of ox; gon :dnlnistration or -r.y other cause or reason for it; 13 that true? h. To, Irek of oxygen or Id not have bo-n the.ocuso ir. our eel. expcrir.or.t, - ach is described h-rc, -nd the 5221 2 Hey-;.- ;S-lS-4-Fc.hra (Ton S o...) Court ;:o. 1. ti-c of Irek of oxygen rra only about 5 seconds. The l'c.: of 0 x 7300 ts ccrtcinly r.ot t.c only r. -son for t^sc ayaptor-a. Or. the otixr Urn*, it wo a notororthy thrt in these experiments th~ro ras paralysis -nd interference ' it.* si ht after those five accor/s of Jack of oxyacn. It nca unique cor.! it ion; First there rero for complaints 'nd ch^n 5 seconds of lrcjc of o:;y; cn ~nd then suddenly th-se s.nous interruptions ••if- the s. fct cna pr.ralysis. ?o* - - « reason this cir cutis tr.ncc is used to ctcer-.pt to use the unique conditions in tlu.se lo*. sinking oxp-nn-nts. hor Cr 1 s 3 £#PP3i COS nothin »W , eo _ -fleet of it, for cxnrple, tie disturbance of the eye si;:ht, tlx centrr.l loss of sight in the middle of the of vision, thrt is suffered ’o: almost everyone cko vr.o in the lot; pressure clrrbor frequently -nfi the only explanation r-s, thor- must be snail air bubbles, rhioh don't even hrve to be in tho circulator; system, rhioh can be -n;vhere in the tissues me rhioh lead to p-in, rhich is c'lled fends, -h-n such c~ -3 rro repeated in the tissues, it l-rds to paralysis and vhon in th- brain it leads to disturbance in the sxyht. Th-t v's kno* •?, : n r ’ particularly Ruff and fucker-Frey sens -orlced on this problem in the nedioal cor.t-r, because this natter h-d not b-on cl--rcd up. It v-.o clai: -d and- kno-n thrt such venous co-plnints occurr-d., but it vas not clear rh-t c-used thv s;rptor.s and this had r.ot boon cleared up by the f-taliti-s rl.icnh occurred ropea.tcdly In the cas- of C-isson sufferers, if they -ro*aot taken to a hospital in tine. n. •’ell, doctor, all thrt inforrr.tion is of course valuable, but be th-t as it ::ry, here re h-vc - report. ;. report is, rs I unde-stand, a listin 3 of -hat a re- 5922 2 S-15-5*ochrr. (Vo Schocn) Court i:c. 1 . secrcher found out during the. c ourself the resor.rch ~ork. Kor you hrve rrdc these st-tcr-cnts lr. tMs report, tfc ich is r report of your r-ork ct Drehru, listed -hr.t ; ou discovered there md you h'vc steted thr.t you hrve found this phenononr., this cor:blnotion of the pressure drop phononcnc trith the phenonenr of oxygen lock end you ary it is suggested; hor: did you dot«r:-ine thr.t; rcro you just guess¬ ing, just guessing? It r-a not "just gucasuig", it rna r theory which could bw used to cxplrin the erttcr -rtf for tjict rcraon, I did rritc;. "it often seined tfcrt the Irek of oxygen r;r S cor.bined in orr^ir.otanccs nth yrc-aaure drop sickness 1 ', Thrt is r scientific hypothesis. 5023 2 TZS-16-5-:*eehrn (Vo Schocn) court ::c. i. scorcher found out during the c x;rac^of the research rork. No- you hrvc n-dc these st-tcr-cnta in tl-is report, rii ich is r report of your r-orlc ct Dreheu, listed -hr.t : ou discovered • there end you fcrve ateted th-.t you hrve found this phenonena, this combination of the pressure drop phenomena rith the phe none nr of exygen lack end you ary it is suggested; hoc did you determine thrt; cere you just guess¬ ing, just guessing? ... It vra not "Just guessing", it rrs r theory which could be used to cxplr.in the er.ttcr -nd for that rerson, I did rrito;. “it often se^nod thrt the Irek of exygen wro in aorv.ir.atr.nces with asurc drop sickness 1 '. Thrt is - scientific hypothesis. 3923 2 :lay 47-.j (Int., Von Schoord Court I r i "all you vara not asslgaod to watch thoso, vero you? A No, I didn’t. < Ha- did you knew ?. Q 3Chor wqs going to rarfcm ®n anporinont at this tied? A I didn’t knew it boforohand. Conorally, I was at tho o=;»ri:^o.ital station and a. -ho leu pressure chantor anyhow and Haschor con-iod oat oxporinonts with a different nan, outside of our sari os. 'I And hadn’t you Just carrioi on an ox.sorinor.t bofero and v.lthin .ha 3a-^o pariod, -;ith ono of your :us3 A No doubt. ::o carried out oroorinonts ovory day on our aim ;ooplo. 1 That 1= atroxvso thon. Y 0 u irobably corriod out a couplo of asporlitoats, aal :han Haschor said, :;oi a nirnito nou, Dr. Hontorg, wo ■••■ill have an a::porisont for Himiar. This has nothing to do with you, stop aside, you ; ot out of tho way a bit, I an going to oxporicunt on this fallow for ilimlar. Is that what ho said to you? .» No, it tiara't liko that. 1 Thon ha.. - did you difforontioto botwoon tho Luftwaffo oxporirwnW 3rd thoSS avMrlaonts? .. I kr.a; uhot experiments I ^rfomod .yaelf. * Yes, but you r.’o e collaborators, -• o on't yoU? You woro rrdo ed by Huff to o down there an! collaborate with Haschor, veren' yotf A Yes, fo; those experiments fee reaouo froa high oltitudo. *./o vorkei together on that. ITcw f.-.eso three deaths that took ?la=o, how did tho seoo.d '^ath occur 0 * 1 The second death? *1 Yes. A As far as I rocall that was an experiment at a raich higher al.itudea, Id or than 14, it might haTe been 17, ani probably there ' a^ain a .'a:al eubolisc. After a certain tine at this altitude the subject suddenly died. 6325 2 - a:' 47-i-?JC-1S-3-Cook (Iat., Ton Schoen) Zvirt I * Tell us about tho third death? A Tve third death was just like the secoai one. «, Haw about f.;e other deaths? A I dor.'t -tax-. I can-only Judge from the reports there 3 a scher reported these d eat* is to Klmler. Z ■'ell ic.; I. # ;: :*ou told hit: that you katfi that acre than threo fatalltlos oeo’ir'.l, or-4 you thought it was approximately five to tan .-eople died i« .ese a:.;eri:»nta. Didn't you tall that toltr. llcflacey last OctobeM I r«a- that, yes. I said that in theilileh trial too. Z Vly 11 you hno-. about that? 7here did you get that knowledge ‘•hat oV «r deaths occurred!. .*• I learned that from tho other prisoners who told me about it uhor tJhe exporl-j:. a were brohon off. ?>.<,>' said they were really slad \Ut 1 v vxar finished. X said, "why", and thoy said: "Because things Wi happened." *>sy weren't definite, tut I condoled that thoro had been other deaths. Z ^ell werei't you a3ha=ed whoa you heard or that from the in- -ites at the conclusion of tho experiments sceotime in June or July? -eror.'t you ashatad you had been associated with Sasoher in his aurdor -ill? A The situation was not simple for me. I didn't t.’ant to have anything aore to do with thane experiments; that can bo soon from tho feet tliat I Interrupted them. 2 'fell now la the course of these deaths, Just what were you : °Ing yourself? "ere you Just standic_ thoro looking ia the window or •ore you operating some of the apparatus for a anchor? A ” 0 , I have already said that at the first tir.9 I was looking a : - olactro-car’.io'xa;:, tho point of light t:at follows tho heart. Then you *..ero working with Rase her. You were studying tho sl-icfcro sari lor a ? You were working with l a sc :or under Ruff' s orders. 2fc a y 47-^-c {C-ir-4-Codfc (2nt., 7©a Schoen) Court I You worked with Haschar on that experiment an! studied the olectro- cardiogratJ A 5o, I didn't collaborate with 2aschar. I happened to be • -atebin* this e:periaent and I saw the electro-cardiograe, and when I saw a critical point was being reached where I =yseIf would have 3 topped the experiment, I said to Sascher. 7.[ Well what did it require at that particular point to stop tho experiment? Suppose you vero operating the controls that Hasohor hal in front of him or the controls on tho pro3svro chamber. At that particular point, the fatal point whore you noticed on the electro¬ cardiogram, when you wore studying it, nhat could you hove clone if you were operating it to stop tbi oxperimont and savo the person from dyir.ff vhat weld ha 7 o been the quickest thing to do, '/all a valvo or what? This ia a sir.nlo quootlon, doctor. I think you can answer it briofly. Did you turn a crank, or push in a plug or button, or throw off a 7al7e, or ho./ would you atro hi: A Do you moan if that had boon ay own experiment? 1 Yos, ha wculd you havo done at tho moment to save tho man, If you saw ho warn oing to high, what -was tho crucial thing to do to atop tho arporlaoat? A I ha7o to oak you again. Do you roan what I would Iiavo dono in ay own experiment with ny own oxporinontal sutjoct, or what I could tevo dona to . aka P.aschor atop his axporlmoni? 1 I am not asking you oithar queetion. I an asking you what cculd haTj boon ‘.one to stop tho exporiner.t at that particular point. Ho; would you : top it, ho; would anybody stop it, '4iat did you do with the equipment to atop tho experiment so that ha waild not die? Is tharo o button you push, or what is there? A ?. anchor had a control in his hand with vhich ho rogulatod tho altitude. Ho would -avo had to turn that sc that tho proEtura u-vli 6327 2 Ear 47 -A-? £-15-5-0sole (Iat., Vca Sclvon) Court I o :/ 0 n no , on thoso chatters, you do unioretand h i h«vo hoard it - it dooan't OPtoar in your affidavit and it r.ovor opyoarod in your interrogations bof-ro thi3 but horo for tho first tlno in your direct examination you testified that you warned Saschor; you said: "Ha; bo caroful thro. Signund, lot«s ho caroful, you aro eoine to hie*." Hon did you nay that? If you did you rust havo known that doath *;as coinE to cozo out of this thini, doctor? A Ho, I din* t know that oxactly. I only taic*.- it was a critically hi.h ;«int. I didn't say , I called hiriRasebor: But as far as I ka ©a in ay intarro^tion hero I said that. I pointod this out to Hanchor. This is not th- first tiaa I havo said that. i Toll nou -.alio 3 a schor was opera iAi thoso controls could no hiaaolf soo tho oloctro cardio^ratC 5528 2:.'ay 47-A-’£-19-6-Ccc: (Int., VcnSchoon) Court I A Yos, ho cculd. ^ Coil now could you, with your axccs roach out and poipt cut tho Tribunal hot. far tho controls voro Tree tho oloctro cardio„rar., hot; far away was ho free this-physically? "as ho whora ho could loo?, ovor and study It horo, and just ufcat mixs his position with rofcronco to the oloctro-cardiosran. A Yos, I con shew you. Horo pointing was tho window whoro 3aschor ..as watching tho axporissont, and :o tho loft about that far, w a n tho sachino which ho had to ro^ulato tao altitude and to tho rlfcht was tho oloctro cardloyrori. 602 * 2 Jiay-A-GJ-20-l-5cb»ab-{int. von Scfaoeo)- Court 1 w '4hy couldn't you Just reach right over there and turned that wheel and save that can's life. « I said to Baecher he should go down. y I an asking you a question: Thy couldn't you? You wire standing at the electrocardiogram. You weren't t^n silts away. .Thy couldn't you have reached over and turned that wheel 3nd save that nan's life , *ou could have, couldn't you? A If I said that to hln and he didn't do it—then I would not have been able to achieve anything by fore... I would have had to beat him down, or som.thing. 1 agree with you. Dr. Reeberg, that perhaps scientists ere not ;ood boxers or wrestlers, but ,x. Rasche-r was not a six foot six, p.rfcct Kordic sp-ciccn; l>i was in fact a nan snail r thin you were. You were phy¬ sically batter than he was and you could null hav^ r.ochwd ov^r and tur¬ ned that whval and cavwd that nan'3 life, and than discuss > ita hin laUr by use of word*— as you say, words ore so important, you an do acre •it! words than ou ce with physic: 1 strength. Then you could hav« dis¬ cussed the H robl-a with hin int-lligcntly with words. And iJ you couldn't have gotten further with words, th.n you could have walked out and gon„ back to Berlin, ind let hie do it as he wished. :iow, you v:.r. in a po»l- •ion to r-ach ov.r snd turn that •••heel, weren't you, w.r.n't you? A Ho, sonce I said that tc Rascher, and he didn't doit, he obvi¬ ously didn't intend ;.o do that. If, at that noa.nt, I had attacked hin by Torce— Q You wouldn't ha%*v had to attack hin—Just r^ich over and turn the wheel. LonBt touch Rasch.r—just his hand—just turn the wh.-l. Very siaplv. A e has th wheel in his hand. If he do-.sn't do anything when I t.ll hie to, h. wouldn't do it if I try to turn it. e would simply have gene on with the exp^rin^nt. Q You were bigger than Rssch-r, *uren't you? 6330 2 -ay-A-GJ-20-2-ccrcb-(int. von Scocn)- Court 1 a It nay b- yes, I w a little taller. Q - 11 , now, aft-r the parser, died, you rake it ridiculous that you night w-11 have reported hi= to the police for rnrder. Vfhy didn't you do that? It is a logical thing to do wh-n a non commits aurder. It isn't so ridiculous to turn in a ~urd-rcr. A It looks likv aurdtr now, and now that we know all about it w- can decide that, but at the tin- I knew that Rasch-r was a Stabsarzt of the Luftwaffe... Q *u nv_ ask you one question . ->hcn you saw this dead nan, what did itlook lik- then? It night look like =urd-r now, right in this court- rocs, but you saw that dead s .an lying there—what did it lock lik- than? A *t was an exp-ris-nt with fatal result. Such cxp.rliocnts do hap- cen in th- world, and nobody says It is a aurder. W Well, now you saw th- autopsies too, didn't you? Did they per- fora an autopsy cn that nan? A Its; I said that already. Q Anri after ha vine objcct-d, as you say you did, both while th*. nan was in the chaabcr end th- cltitud- was increasing, -nd then object ing aft.r th. nin died—you still watschcd th- autopsy aft-r all this ur- gua.nt you h-d with Raschor? A I didn't hink it was r.ic- at nil. Rascher had continued the oxpe- ria-nt too long, and th- .ear. died. But wh-tn-r he d-lib-rat-ly int-nded to .rurdcr hie—I couldn't say. Put a death had occured, .nd do 1 wat- :h-d th- autopsy. i' Now, at this tin- wh-n this death cccured, Roschtr was in the Luftwaffe, wasn't he? #r A i-s. -i Ycu were in the Luftwaffe—a civilian -spicy— of the Luftrafl-? A No; I was an -cploycc of the Sc man Rcs-arch Institute for Avia- *-lon. /- did not b-lon- to the Luftwaffe; therefore w. did net w.ar a uni- fera. . --11, ycu 7r;r- doing work for the Luftwsff-? 5331 2 uay-A-GJ-20-3-Scfcwafc-(int. von Schoan)- Ccurt 1 A In part we worked for the Luftwaffe, too. But we also worked for induetry. ij So then you reported this death and all these deaths, as a natter of fact—but you reported this first death to Ruff immediately, didn’t you? A Yes. Q dhftt did h. do about it? Did he call the police? A No, as b_ said hiasclf, he did not. The police were not cccpet.nt in tho case of Rascher. «e was a nuab^r of the Luftwaffe; Luftwaffe courts were cccpctent. Ruff reported it to Rascher and his sup-rior. the Chief of the Nodical Service. Q Well, then after this first death, how does it happen that Rod- berg didn't turn up his coat cellar and go out to get in the tractor part od the charfccmnd drive it to Berlin? Why didn't you get that cham¬ ber right cut of th.-re inacdlatcly? You saw deaths there. Why did you stay around? A Wo talked about that for a long tis~, and as Ruff aentionod that we deliberated what should do. It was dear that Ruff would report it; we didn’t havo to think about that. We also rcaliz-d thatw. would achio- y- nothing with Hinder by going to hie and saying Rascher furforaed an e*p-Tiount and a person died. Hinder would probably hav- said, ■ I know I gave hin the orders. That is none of your business. n For this reason we decided that I should go back, that our exp-ri- a.nts should be completed so that w. could s-.y the exp-rLnents had boon concluded; the chaab-.r rill not be needed any sore. And then , In this way, after the exp -ri.-t.nts w.rc concluded R.ach«.r gave his apporval and ; : i-ehr gave his approval—the chanter could b- rctaov-.d froa Dachau to I r.*Jcc any further nark inpossible. 4 Tho fallacy of all that 3tory is that you had acpl. opo.rtunity to just net repair the barco-t^r. fi»r- you wer^, trying to find a sch^ac nd a way to quickly get that thing out of thor-, that chacber cut of chau, and here was a brok.n part. !h_ only *ay to get it repaired was 6932 2 . iay-A-O J-20-k-Sch*ab-( int. von Schcn)- Court 1 w gc to 3crlin to get the porta, and Ur. Ueff was so disappointed, he «id his story was, h. was disappointed that you had returned with the p-rt ^ fixed it, when he had sabotaged it. But you story is even far acre fantastic. You said that you rushed right back in a naUr of a 2,3,U,5, | days, instead of two weeks, like- Neff said, ruhed right back to get it in order, and tfc-n two people died afur you put it bac*c into operation agaiij. It certainly was an active way to stop teacher's work—wasn't it? A I bcliwvu if it was cccparcd with what Raschcr intended to do¬ na the dccuacnts say; what I read this naming—it was a very effective nothod. Q It certainly was. Well now, doctor, you than still had—after you even cleared out of Dachau entirely, g t out of Dachau altogether— the Chaaber war. retimed to °crlin, whether it bo May or July or August. Then you still associated yourself with P-oscher when you reported and you wrote that report about the filn, and the unfortunate fact that Milch didn't show up for the sho¬ wing in Septentcr. o still <-vcn in Soptv=ber you w„rc still friendly Tith Dr, Raschcr and working with Dr. Rischcr, the nan that had proved ninsolf to you to be a murderer, didn't ycu? A It was not sc clear t~ se that he was a airdercr—neither moral¬ ly or legally i3 it quite clear, I said already... Q Now, .t that tine, >cu aust recall that you have stated her¬ on this witness stand that you personally saw thre- deaths, and that at the ccoplction of thv vxp.rinant—and you bring it way back in *ay that your lnnatcs told ycu that there w-re scae ten deaths. And now, with that in view, you knew this, you say—according * 6933 2 • ■ 2^-1 o-ach v-b (1st. t:s ici 2 ) “onrt I to .ur owe tcsti-.ony ia the -oath if h_y? kr vortj 2s Scptosbor you _ru otiU .ssoci-tia,- yourself vitn H-scaor—proud to oc vitli hi-, vcron't yrsl j. ho, I w-s ccrt-tvdj* sot prad of vori:ia& "its H-schor. -after Ei.-l-r -..vo sc orders to porfor- cold eroeri-cuto I could h-vc vorkod with E-.BChor .JL1 2 w.nocd to. “hor. did Iv.acswr ..ivc you tee r-ca-.oud-tioaa for - -odnl? -'see die. that occur? a. Hocxu.cad .tion....? Sidn't H-ocui,r roexx-oad you for the sod.1 th-t Hi-x;l-r «avo you? So what extent ts.t co:c fro- fiuschor, 2 don't :mow oxc.ctly. It uza doubtless a. th..t Huschor, hL.tolf—if it v^a he vno hundod in is’ a-.:c-—voatod t..c -r ..crit Croat ?irat Clots. He told so hi-iailf t. t ho clro/dy a.d a Second Cleat, and he w..ntod the ?irot Clean. Hnsohor no doubt wanted to brioc uc in a tcnac to ,;ivo his bade t..o lot*-proasuro chu b^r. *o -iso voated to continue with the ecpcri-icnta. He hoped th..t 2 w^uld work with his ogula. hut I a—id hw-ro about -y -ttitude to Hatcher, 2 did not toll Hatcher p.rooaally, of course. 2 couldn't. ^ loll, y ,u were Given - ..cd-1, v.rca't y u? Yet or no. Tot, 2 ^ot it. s. ’Jfc 0 (j ..TO you tho std- 1 ? a. 2 received it b; —11 with n docuaoat welch w„e tl^nud by Keitel. ^ hcltclj 4C.C what did you ^ot the ucd-l for? 7or services in the field of -vi-tion rete_rch the Vur ..orit Cross Second Cl-sr, w-s aw_rdcd. 0^ -“nd the d‘cu*-cnts whicn show th_t Hatcher rocoa .ended you to Hi.-J.or for that scd.-l, as 2 recall? Tes, I h-ve tacu tout in the documents toe. 693 - 2 ^^-«7P-20-2»-6chvQb ( 1 st. voa bcios) Caort I I*, will oal;’ 2 Kay 47- ^ 21-i~Sorrow-Von Soho.n, Court 1 Q. Now, the Nurnberg conference on frwszing took place in October, didn't It? Yes. Qi You were there? 4. I was there. Q. Huff was there? *. Huff waa there. Q. You stated, on direct examination, that it was ob¬ vious that deaths occurred in the course of those exper¬ iments? A. I didn't oay that it was clear. I said that it was clear to no personally Just as the witness Lutz hero testified that it was clear to hia. 0. It was also clear :o you, from the report given, that deaths had occurred? Ia that what you are tryin; to tell no? Or was it clear to you beoause of the fact that Holz- loehner had told you. How waa it clear to you that deaths had occurred? It wac clear to no beoause I nyself had seen that Haochor had had deaths, oecause I had broken off my work with him for that reason, taken the chamber away for that reason, refused to perform the cold experiments with him; and, therefore, I assumed that Hascher had bad deaths again in the cold experiments, and if Holzloehr.er talked about deaths at the conference, obviously they wore deaths which occurred thanks to the work of Hascher and Finke. I personally assumed that these were deaths that had occurred through cold experiments, but this was not obvious to every one. Q. Now,did Huff realize that persons had died in freezing experiments? 6535 2 y.ay 47-A-^-21-2-Xarrow-7on Schon. Court i He was there at the meeting. a. I don't know what Ruff said anyaore. Q. Wh&t has he said here. I don't Know exactly. I believe ha said he didn't realize It. Q. nnd now you realized, or. one hand, that deaths oc¬ curred in the high altitude experiments and you realized that deaths occurred In the freezing exporlmenta. You wore nt a conference In October for freezing experiments, and, at such conference, there were several men there of considerable Importance. Did you objects to these wholesale deaths ao a result of the experiments In the Dachau concentration camp, to any one? An active objec¬ tion? actively, no. I didn't do anything but what I had done before. The deaths which I know about positively I had reported to the Luftwaffe, to Raoher's personal chief and. Q. (Interrupting) How, ao a physician, a man who was fully aware of the manner ir. which Rascherworfced and surely realized, sitting in that conference In October^ that even further deaths wore occurring in Dachau, did you ooject then, as a physician? Did you stand up and object or didn't you go to somebody and soy "This must bo stopped"? Ho, I did not. There were other people there who realized It too, who were much more powerful than I. 2. Well, then, you didn't go anywhere or actively ob¬ ject at that meeting? Did you? A. At this meeting, no. I didn't do anything active. I had done that already. 6937 2 Hay 47—i*- ,X— 21—XaiTow—Von Schon. Court 1 Q. Than I can assume that it didn't bother you one iota if every innate of the Dachau concentration camp was Hill¬ ed, did lt7 It didn't bother you at all? It would have bothered me very much. I personally broke off the h^i altitude experiments for that very reason and took the ohaaber away. I acted against Hitler •a orders and against my signature whan I reported the natter to Ruff which was certainly not without danger, so as to stop the high altltudo oxperlnents. The Rascher experiments in this way. and I can say, that he didn't carry out any core experiments, Q. One other question. You were down thjre as a subor¬ dinate of Ruff in Dachau, weren't you? .1 subordinate of Ruff, according to Ruff's own testimony. A. I was an associate of Ruff, yes. q. it was your duty to report to Riff, wasn't it, the workings and the activities of your experiments? A. Of course. Q. .;o further questions. Your Honor. 3Y JUDGE SEBRIHO: q. Dr. Romberg, at the tlao this first death occurred in the Rascher experiment, who was assisting Dr, Rancher at the time as a technician? -forking the controls. He did that himself as I have described. In the motor car, where the pumps wore, it was probably Neff or So'ootta; he of ton did :hat. Or some other prisoner who knew soaothing about auto mechanics. These three people always took care of the motor. Q,. Do you know that to be a fast at that time this first death occurred? a. That it was one of these three wnc was in the pump car? 5938 2 May 47-^AK-21-4-Karrov-Von Sc th_t I lookod ut tho dcctrocardlogr^a. .Yauu.ua to e^r, toon, th„t yrax activity at tho wcporhiont * act oao of supervision ia whicn you observed the olcctrocardio^rca, b-.t you vented to s-y ta..t boc-usc jrva were orc«*at you .lore or lean by accic.oat c-nt .. gl^nco -t tho oloctroc-rdlorai, which dr-w 0 -ttontisa ts itself uayaov because it coat_ins an electric spark which froa tiuc to tit.® lit up and ..oved. Is th_t corroct? Yos, there is a point of li.>.t .-.oviiy; oa a little screen. In this first fatality who st-rted tho fllr. in .lotion? S^tchor did, on tho b-sie 'f Ms constant observations thoro j vac.; ho vantod to h .vo « o-rt of tho coyori-oat registered on the scroon ho cut tho filu in. ^ Z assume further th_t runnia.: tala ~_caiao involves clso *.ar 1\ ;ff tho filu. 3 ov who turned off tho filu and took it out? a. ihat v_s dono by iL-schor also, and ho seat it to be devolqppod. - l ow, mcordin,, to wh;.t you h_vo s-id, thcro arc six stics in iizi- tc the olcctrec-rdio^r-a; now if tho Prosecution is of tho Cyiaion th * i.. t~os ex?«.ri_ent you took c_rc of tho elcctroc-rdi o.rcn, *• ca y 0 .a.ve don a _11 of tnesa tnin^s yours olf; now vnica of h-.cso Six individual activities did you c_rry out in tho c-xperincnt in • • vI ich the first de..th occurred? 5945 - -^y^^-JJ^-S-a-Coo c (Ir.t. 3rows) Court I ■*. IToaa of thcc. -• - ?~rt ia this expcri—ent ia cay athor way *r uttending the eiectroc.rdi ogrtii? • . 0 , Sascher was ia ch^r,~e of tho cjpcriaeat, and of course ho fit everything. But as lischer'c assiat-nt or for iUsoher you could have done eort..ia thing* or you could a~vo t.acea c-r« of tao elcctroc-rdioc,r.^ or ^ 3a0 :a orr -=d of sxte sort ia support of the ex_5ori_octs of h.schcr, out aow cone«.str_to on the coptriuaat vhica s-d the first f~t- it aad toll ue, since you h-vc _lrcj*y said you didn't jttoad t .o eioctroc..rdio„r^i, did you do -ayhtiag olsc ia this cxperLiontT 'Jo, and ---Bch-r v_a very acch concerned to curry out his • wri .cats hugolf when ho w..s ia eh.ovo of tno experiaonta. * correct ia ay assumption th_t the c^)ori_cnt could havo Doan iatornnted by turning „ little wheel? *. rot. ... 'Jh: tooc c_re of this uhool, cad whoa he turned the wheel vhut .urncaod? • 3.io vhtul controlled tho o.-.try of tno air into the car.ibor. ?~schcr hed tho vhocl in his hand, «md by turninj this whool oao way or .arthor no ro^ulntod tho altitude. "id c..ocher h„ve tais wheel only occ-sioaully ia his head, -r did ho h..rc it in sis hand tarou,iiout tho oxporiuont ? *• -ou sad to ie«.ep it ia your hand all of tho ti^o in ordor to rogulato tho atitudo. - —®*- 5”u, would it have boon possible for you to reach i..:s uhocl without attacking ^eser firet? Since he had it ia his hand. I should hare first had to ra.:oYt his hand free: tho wheel. it is correct f r no to _ssu-e tfc_t ia order for you - at ip tho osporiscst prematurely you could only h..vo done soaethiag 6946 5 Ihy-K-vS-a-fr-Cook (lat. jrcvn) Court I if : ■ h-d .it.cicod H-scacrt A- “es. :> How for the second ccperinea’., the one taut involved the Be cond fatality; a v in this Ssporiaent who took care of the olectrcn * ' . . _ --*• c xli^z&l ' - ^ *. rnschor ...ust hove, but I don't knov aoout this in detail any a-a-o because I didn't p.y any attontion to it. V Sbv -ole-s. Just think of tuie second experiment; did you not e oo t-c dotted light that aovod in the clectroc.r&io I 1 T.o? ^ In tho second orovriuent I v-s la the nutorooa of tho chaibor becatteo vo had Just finishod oorforuing „xuwrL.oats ourselves, and - v..s ctUl oa^.od in cv-luuting the croerU.ont Just concluded; thua I didn't o.*v too much attention to those dct-ils. «. Voro you present at _li three of those oxporLuonte only hocauso ;• ; vero BtiU evuluaticr tnc w^criucats you and Just Curried out on rescue freu hi,>h altitude and Just hmponod to bo at tho ckjjber still, is that conoctT -s Vos, I -lv-ys cv-luatod tacso war>crin«r.ts sitting on tho bench in the cha-bor because tho t..olos -* ultitodos vero in there, and I tr.aisferred uy notos to tho record book. Vo h..vc ha_rd here from v-ri;us vitncscoa, particularly' prosecution vitaosscs, th..t ut most of lecher's ox?uriu«nto you vero not present. Sov, .^cording to *h-t you h..vc Just said, your proscnco in those three c_scs v~orc there vero f-talitiec ic to oc ..ttributod solely to the fact th-t ausekor's experiments took place -ltitvdo end th_t for th-t re-son you wore ttill Jotting down notes -a these experiments -nd tunpeaed by -ccidont to bo still at tho cumber, is th..t correct? a. TOO. Z, In this second oxpvriucnt vncrc you vero sitting and unking : ;c5, did you se^ the clactroc-rdiObTanl *947 s V. & 4-Cook. (let. 3rown) Court I 4 , to, I did act oomerro it. ^ l-a this the only experiment th_t noscher c^-riod cut at is.., yotioca.x ti -0 or n_d ho performed otner caw previously olcac, oao or two or throe or four orfive perhaps? Ho hud carriedcut others before. I thin* about three. ^ -ad than in the fourth one oa that day there w_s a fatattyl a. Yob. ^ ja this second f-t-lity. did ycuK*rn hia? ^ ho, I didn't ouy such -ttcatioa to it. I couldA't oo« n S- t. lity was Lnlnoat. 3 . Do you Uy it P1.-.0 TOUT Honor. .. -re ..11 MU' «“» in oenoh hn. S ran«od oon.14or.blo latitude to both promotion u=d counsel burin.:: the couroo of cxaiinatlon. but it .cent to no defense Cauned this aomlnfi ha. Ju.« been filrlhe uo a par*o of 10.410.. quo.tiono end uaworius for the 4of.n4.nt. 1 roquet that tie quest! -‘.a jut to the dofeud-nt be put oo that tie defond-u. eon sver tnCQ cad a .t dofease c ounsel. 6946 O Y: Th.t's very truo, Your lienor. Hj is about to -.sic that, but :iO oviiocco to d -to has brought out the f-.ct that R-sohor h-d said that. 7H- Pk-SIDJI.T: Couns-1 cay procood. BY DR. VCR G3K: .. To ensvior your question, I :.lro- dy said in ny direct ox ruination that - hen n-soh-r began oxporin-nts of his our. in addition to our oooaon oxporinants, rr.fi I asked Uiti rbout then, h- told ::u that the experiments hud boon ordorud by Hicnler ...ad th-.t they ^r- to bo the nocn3 through which ho hoped to qualify us - professor. .. Did ho ovur thr-..ton you - spying that if you triod to interfere in th-so experiments.... :H_ PiUJIDTrn?: (Interrupting) Counsel, you're propound¬ ing a strictly la .ding question by asking the witness if Raschor a id to hi:; certain things, ~sk hie what rtaschor s id to hia and then tho witness o an testify us to what k scher said. That e;k-s tho quostion not a loading question, when you rep-at .taschor's words to tho witness, you \r- skinj loading questions. Just ask tho witness whr.t -C-asoher said upon r. o-rt .in occasion. 3Y DR. 70H TRK: . Hr. Romberg, did a scher, on any occasion , say ny- thiaj to you ;bout his own ,xporim-nts? .» *s I just said, h- told na that th-se experiments did not concern me; that they wore his experiments _nd that he S952 - - y 5-l'-BK-5— i-X arrow (Inc. BrownJ Court No. 1 -3 carrying thee out on Himmler's orders. v ••hon did ho soy this? *- told Eu this whonhe began hi3 experiments while we ™ rj 3till c;.rryin3 on cur other experiments - num-ly, before thi3 fir3t fatality. . Did ho say this to you once or several times? .. do s .id sovoral tin-3 that those experiments hid boon ordered by Kinnler, and p rticulor^y, whan I objected to thv .30 experiments after the first fatality, ho said again that this did not concern me; th..t I should not bother r.ysclf about natters th .t wore not ny concern. Ho hod tho orders nd he had to carry th-:: out. . i or- there throats oonn-otid with what ho said? - Veil, ho didn't threaten me oponly, but I do renenber tht he once said that if I didn't stop objecting h- would c.anc -1 ny passo while I was in the camp. > *h. t would this hrv- m.ant? •• *h-t would hav- noant th t I couldn't l-r.vo tho c u p ..ny more. . whr t Were your hum n relations with ti eschar? Is the prosocutor correct in his assumption that you wore good friends; th-t you used tho f.r.ili r form of tho personal pronoun, nd th *t you c .lied bin Sigmund? *• No, th .t is not true .t .11. I _ddr-3S-d hin nlw .ys • ith the forr. .1 p.rson 1 pronoun. ISy rel .tionc with hin u-re pure ly offici 1 nd I c llud him Lir. R ,sch-r. * Can you find anything in the corr-spondonco or the # docunents th .t could subst rnti-to this point of view of the prosecutor? - No, I know of no -vid-ncc for th .t in the docun-nts ad, in fact, there are, in th- documents, s-v,r .1 st te¬ nants of -i.sch-r's - in th- docuc-nts which have been - 6955 *• 7 rro [In;. Court .To. 1 subr.it bog - which rove. 1 th.t he w 3 hostile to tic. ->i.-c you oppos-d to .sch-r's oxporinents, is ... correct in .S3-cinj th .t you r-j..rdod th-s- throe * -tr.lities s nurd-r, pur- „.d simple? •• .Co, I couldn't r-snrd those -nporin-nto s just Pi-in curd-r boc_us- ho h d boe;s ord-r-d by the v-ry highest .utlicritics to o.rry out th-so oxporiuents. I, hew-vor, ..nted to h vo nothing to do with then, :nd th.it -s why I roport-d to Huff, . Li cro3s—ox j;in .tion, the prosecutor s id th .t it wouldn't h vo both-rod you . bit if .11 tho inn. t-s of J oh .u h d di xl. Do you think you c n provo th-- contr ry? .. X c-rt inly didn't oxpoot th t oh-rju, boo..use, uabj-otinc; nyo-lf to p-rson J. d ng-r, I w..s th- ono who o T "‘ — oi. nbar out of D oh *u. I wr.s tho one who reported, nd I r-fus-d to h-vo cythin^ to do • ith -*iy subsequent -xp-ric-nts o: Jhor'a. - ~nd why did you net in this w.y? — y re .son w..s th:.t I didn't w .at to h:-.vo -nythlng to do with thosw oxperir..nts of n-.sch-r's, : .nd it w..s ay opinion th t th.su oxpcrin_nt3 w-r- velu-losc end not r.jousscry for tho Luftw .ffe or for .vi .tion rose.roh, so th_t -xperin-nts which do not fulfill n pr-ssing or urj-nt p'irpo3- should not bo carried out und-r such con¬ ditions s those. v Th, prosecution is further of th- opinion thr.t no etfc-r f;.t liti_3 could hov- occurred if the biron-tor which you hud h.-.d r-pc.ired h .d cot b-_n rep ir_d. Is th .t corr-ct? - Ii-.3ohor would c-rt_inly h..vo bo..n bio to j-t hold ef such b'-rcto.tor, p_rh-.ps h- could ove-n h-.vo jot one in Schons u t th. r.irfield in his office, or, nt lcr.st, *954 :: y 5-L f -aX-3-6-K '-xrou (In*. Brown) Court .Vo. 1 ' similar instrun-nt. Othor.'isc, In view of the ^ssist- -jjcc ;jid the too priority thet h~ tins given by the 33, he certainly would hr.vo been able to ict hold of such nn instrument. In other fiords, th- important thing w.sn't th t wo repaired thic barometer. . Kcp. _nothor question, Hr. Honb-rg. How long woro you ordered to st-.y in D ch:.u? .. Until tho /experiments on rescue fro.\ high altitudes had boon concluded. v ,.ftcr those experiments were concluded you would not have boon undor orders to st .y in Bachr.u -von if the ch-nb-r h d reel ined thoro? .. I jx.r 80 n.:lly could have l~ft, of course, just ns tho ch.'Qbor was In Dnobr.u boforo I got th-ro; so after ny .xperin-ntel series vies finish-d I cculd hr.vo left -nd tho ohembor could have boon removed fro;- Daoh .u l-t-r, -lthcr by Rasohor or the oenp oduiniatration. 5 — 2 y— 1 —. lcy-(int. ^rowr.)- Court 1 Q Moving the cl&aber fcra the C-=p was not your Job? A No. Q '..hat w=3 thv reason th.t you :cud cv_r and beyond your orders? A I did everything 1 could to get Rasen^r's promise to no7t the -r—_h..r, although, he didr.' t nnt tc give thar consent and it is quite cle-r that I 3taycd until th. v.ry lest Boaent, until 1 was absolutely sure that the chacb-r w:s going to be movvd from Dachau. That was the reason why I stayed there. Q. ghat was the lowest decoration for a soldier In Germany during the war? A. So far as I knew, it was the War Merit Cress, 2nd Class. Q. A nd what was tho lowest decoration for a civilian? A. Also the ■*ar Merit Cross, 2nd Class. Q. And what Decoration did you receive? A. Tho War Merit Cress, 2nd Class. Q. You were present at t:* Humbert? Cold Conference? A. Yos. Q. If you realized that ccnccntration caxp inmates had beon used in the i rcoiing experiments, why did you not raiao an objection ut this c* nfcronco? A. I saw at this conference that the ox; e rimer.ts had b-^n carried out an official orders. I had already clearly expressed cy personal -.pinion of th.se oxp. risen to before. Ruff had passed this information on. And at the Nurnberg Conference th-rc were much higher offices or raris rcorv-ccnt-d, wfc in part ray also have r-alisod it. I know, Y r r •■xitplc free what Dr. Alexander has said that many of then realized this, '•■it that thoy said nothing. Uy position durLig this whole tln^ ras so * r Jc, on the one hand, because of the refusal to Ras eh or and Hir.-J.cr, and 'a tho ether hand it was Tilt- dear; so that I really saw nc rearen for -J r.iaing an objection at this Kumberg conference* TP.. VOEnSRK: iir. President I have nc farther quostiens . THE HESDOT: The Tribunal has several questions to propound to 6SK 2 -y-!4_3Ioy-(iat, orcim)- Ccirt 1 the witness. 3T JUDOS SEERING: v. Er. Rcnbvrg, is I understand ycur test irony, you and Dr. Ruff, • ~ r - ordered t- Dachau to collabcrat. wit* Dr. Raschcr in a aeries of wsts to deternin- th, possibilities of rcscu. of high altitude? A Q And 7ir.il. you were there you were actually under the cccannd of Tr. flaschcr? A I was not und.r Rnsch.r’s cccraad as a Etabsartz in the Luftwaf- f-. I wac under th. ccc and really of th. carp cae-jader rhilv I was in th; canp. -i rut so far zo th..xpcrin.r.ts thersclv-s wer- coanc.rn.d and th e c r.trcl cv.r th. Ire- pressure ctcabcr, Dr, h. acher hod responsibility in -hat particular, is that corr ct? A Tea. i -.for; you ind Dr. Ruff wn«.t t: Uachau tc p.rfors ycur experic-nts had s tailor t.cto be n aadc by th. G.man Luftr-afic or for th. benefit cl the G.man Luftwaffe? a You --an slail r .xperiaents? Q XeS. A YeB, in th. DVD re carried cut similar -xp.ria.nts, *.nd at ether institutes Me a, rrrlcin for th. Luftwaffe siril.r .xp.rlacnts w.r. car¬ ried out. 1 In cth ' r3 -'ds, th. -:p rir.nts that had b..n c rri.d cut pri.r t: th't tin. did r.ct differ free th. .xp-rioenis that you carried out at a achau7 a Trie \~s continuation cf an axpari-eatol series which v *a alrca- V u.ac.r -.riy r.d 'or is al77-.; 3 the cos. in exp-riaental scri.s, differed fr-c preceding exporiaunts changing th. c:nditicns increasing the altitu¬ de the e ld, etc. . Just hit Were ycur attceptinr to deterain. in the Dachau exp.ri- —ntst.ua.t h a already been d_t.rrir.ed cr ascertain by ycur pr.vicus tests? a Th. r ir. task was tc ir.Vestig-t. rescue at heights 6987 5 (int. 3rown) Court I -o orect _a 20 kilometers tc find out whether rescue of airplane crows is possible _t such u high altitude at all. Theretofore it had been ascertained t..at tue crow survives the explosive decompression vfcich occurs at such an altitude when tee pressure cabin develops a leak, an C now ve wanted to fine, out whothor tao person could bo brought safely to o_rth from this altitude. Vho gwvo the order for you and Ruff to conduct theso <-xperimentsT a. 2ju;t v_s arranged by Ruff in nis t-lk with Professor Hippko, tho -odical Chief. 0 , i. "ns the order a written or an oral ordor? & o far as I know, it was an or_l order of Professor Hippko. From wnou did you le-rn this f.xt7 a. Frxi Dr. Ruff. Ci. 3 of or a going to Dachau, did you or «uff discuss your assi-puont with anyone-other, of course, than tho discussion that you said you a-d with bolts in norlin i . Docaabor 1941 or January 19427 «.rlin f .-loy (Inti jrovaj Court I =-y 'aoe..uae I v^-i t present; it vj u discussion in valet Professor "Ll-.Z, YotvvSliOff, ..ad E^acacr t-laed Vita Hi'J UCO uO'Ut t-iu o^pcrl-ontc, —Ot tnU discussloa Eippiee £nro Lis -u rov_l rn principle. -..ea t -iter t~o belts conference, -B I understand it. Dr. 3x21 veat t: hipplco, to eonfixu tLo aror-y-1 and to ot actual aiuro- V 1 .i or .«,st toso, Purr and nxiber,-;. «ad no c.oic b.xn a-id reported tn .t i’. ct t- ycul •*. Tea. 7..c-.\ l.tor, la C-au„xy or ?eara-ry 1942, y :u and /Caff wont t ..union .../ n_d w ctnfcrcnco with bolts .xd s-.o olacr ..ontlcion? a. Ku.t is ri^t, yot. after Huff r-turn-d fr „ot;in^ ..la ..>>rjv..l fro. Eipptc, but boforc you otd Huff n^d y ur c af»r~nec vita Volts In i.unlch ia cnamry or "wbru-jy 1942, vita vhu. did you disouos tnia usoi'.a- aont? a. Only vith Dr. Aiff. v. You arc quite c.nfidont, tnoa, t:_t aoitawr you nor *uff dl~c"sood t..ia oesigaaent vitb anyone cite prior to that huaich aootia^? a. I cort-ialy didn't t_lx ..oout it, and Huff only tulLod ..b,ut it f "cits m tao tcc_oi*n .f tn-t first visit la Jcrlln. 6959 5 l r ~V 47-::-S r :-5-l-:to».hrji-lRt: 2rcvm Court He. 1 7/ as tho ror.scn for that tho fact that was a ncro cr loss socrot cr confidential assignment? ... It was an oxpcrinontal sorios, involving oxporinonts at Ligh altitudo, in tl is caso up to 20 kilcuotors, so that a tochnic-1 Jovolcpr-ont was app.jont fren tl:o prebloa as ivon. JTew all oxporinonts in which tho subjoct cf tho assignment cr tho title cf tho report shows a toch- nic .1 dovolep .i-nt of tho planning of a technical dovcl- cpiont cf sono s«rt, troro always socrot; in fact, thoy woro tep socrot. 0 ., In tin touts tl t *.. boon conducted by y u and Ruff, prior t: ycur g' lng to Dachau, cm ycu stato how ny experimental subjects had been usod? A. The oxporuaontts in our inetituto — I know moot abcut thou — frr tlo firrt ox onnonts in paraebuto dosconts frou 12 kiloaotors, wo usod si:: cr sovon oxporinontal subjocts; for tlo oxpl sivo dccniprossion wo usod just ,'ocut overy no avr.ilablo at our instituto, nrjwly abcut eight at the nest. . B w, bof. re you would begin an oxporlsont cf t:..t Icir.d, tho tncs ycu conducted in .lorlin, I suppose that it uld 'x» an ii port r.t thing tc kn.tr si nothing about tho physical health cf ycur oxperi.iont 1 subject prior to tl.o ti iu y;u togin; would t: ..t mt o true? ... In cur jorlin oxporiaonts, we did net givo tho oxpv-r- inent 1 subjocts a physical ox - inati a over*tine. T ’now the non, boc us*. tl^y t:ero al. st always tlo s:no Xicplo. Or. tho tthv-r 1-«1, sicl* people, pocplo fer ii'.st.nco * itl . he..rt dofect, n u r u not :-.ong then; there¬ fore , special crcaninntian vas not necessary. In otl.or words, tloso uon .t 3-rlin, I talco It, voro :vr. in tho ir force; and you h;.d the poi-con..1 data on 6560 5 47-::-S'-5-2-!t&tbLa-Int: Irowr. Court I'o. 1 then; you know th air r.mx z , tlxir r.mke, t oir thoir h- rt condition, tloir blood pressure , purl -ps the condition of their other vitr.l org.-ns. Tfcoj* fc d k d to unioi’co cocploto physic. 1 uxnr.in: tion, ..£ r. jv.ttor of f ct, boforo they wore over :dr:itted Into tko ir forco; is th .t net corroct? # ... ''o f tb t is net quito correct, boc .use wo wero civilian ir.stituto, uid tko oxporinontr.l sublets woro ourcolvos — our own .ssoci tec. I v ;s tko uxpori.nontr .1 subject, let us e .y, for m exp-rincut of Ruff, md our no eh mic Fohl:»ietor, vhoco book Is boor subniifcbd here, w.-.s frcquontl; cubjeot In oxp-ri or.ts; r.nd other r.psoc- i to? of nlno wor* Iso c xpori; ontnl subjects. Kono of those troro naibors of t iiftwnffo, but civilians vfcor. ./o kns« pereonr.lly, but r.ot in sue! gro'.t dots. il :.c ro Id result fror; re.-din 3 r. ro.wt on nr. ‘xny pkysicr.l cxr.rinr.tion. roll, the;* hrd undorsono physical ex-in', ions of one sort or cr.othor; h- d the;* not? oil, '-c * shod our psoci toe whuti jt tho;: woro lr. 1 h 1th, whothor tb.oy tuA ho.-rt defect, etc., but wo did not give then ro.-.l physical oxnninr.Jion, euch -.s % ..r i* on to dot-r me physic .1 fitnosa for tho . ir forco. 0 ,. Tow would they Imow thoy './ere in good pi ysiorj. he ltl ? Su oso t’. t I, for o::.--:plo , , rooor.tcd jysolf to your for :r. ex - .in-tier, ~nd c.id tlv t I vv.s *n yood h* sic: 1 h . 1 th; -t wouldnt needs .rii; follow tl ttl\'.t would bo true rt to er.t of fact, unless ;*cu know sono- ing ‘.bout :.ty heart condition, cry blood pressure, nd shcliko; vc-Id it? . . -C £. . r on I suppose th t whon test • 2 :*ur. ov .17 day in 69S1 5 I’,-.- 47—’!-S '.’-5-2 h - hm- In t: 3rown Court Be. 1 •/our Berlin tcotrs you right run or.o tost or two tosts, p«rh.‘-?fi something of thr.t sort? -- then in ordor to r.ccun- ul&.feo your scientific dr.tr. cr your finr.l analysis rad reports, I r. sauce th-.t you would hr.vo r. card for tho oxpori-iontr.l aubjocta; 11 -V* , lot us r.sauno, end or. thr.t you v;ould sot out your findings ..s to "A" in a particular oxpor- h.ont of a dcsi gnr.tcd !:ind, conducted at a cortaln tir.o, r.nd you would show tho roault of th-.t tost, all on tho ono card; ia tfc.t coi*roct? ... '.:o did not hr.vo r. apocir.l card for ovory or.pcrir.cntal subject, but entorod this data in r. roccrd book. Super¬ vision of their at.-.to of health woro undortakon at rogulr.r intervals , not in connoction with tho spociflc oxpor- lnont, but wo took x-rays, an olcctro-c. .rdiogran, and in this vr.y kept on oyo on t; oir ovor-a.ll atr.to of health. 0 .. Precise 1;-. I*..or. , \.kon you would finish with an oxper- iiiont, porhaps you wo. Id hr.vo tad let us a y, for oxanplo, 100 t jsc; on vrrioue oxporii ontr.l subjects. At tho ond of thr.t or.o hundred tests could you look r.t your -.lnutos, or your card, or your file, or wl*. tcv r you . -.aintainod, r.nd dotor: J.no how nsny r.nd uhr.t hind of tosta or.ch of tho oxpori::ontr.l aubjocts h d undorgono during tho courao of tho rosoarcl oapcrir.cr.t; I nn talking about in Borlin. ... Yes, wo could soo thr.t fror. tho record book, -. In other words, it world bo lnposaiblo to hr.ro r.ny sort of noxperi ent for t: o purposo of rorerreh findings thr.t world bo worth my thing, ur.loss you tad kopt notic- ulous re cord a fro:; which. tho final roport could bo nedoj is th-*-t not ccrroct? ... ho:, of courto wo always 2:opt a record book of or.ch .. ri ... ts. 5952 5 I icy 47-:j-ST/-5-4-K(-c!_Jx rT S»t: Brown Court Bo. 1 ion did you actually arrive ct Dccheu, p.r cpr.rcd to begin the Feuff-Ronborg oxperieunts? I errived ebcut the 20th of Fobruery. Things did not stert off right then, but wo wont out for tho first tir.o on the 21st or 22nd of Fobruery; the 22 nd ues Sundry, so it might h vo boor. tJt) 23rd. 7 or. tlioro wr.s tho difficulty with R schcr'a orders, end tho onpcrir.cnts wore brolcon off r.gr.in by tho P.oichafuohrur.r. R- sc her wont to Schongeu r.d I r turned tc Berlin end weitod for nows fron hin, r.s to tzhun things h_d finally n put in order. I was c rteinly in Berlin on Kerch 9th end on tho 10 th or 11 th, I probably :.in rrrived et Dachau, end on t! is dr.y tho ctuel oxperl*:untel curies bogen. n.v.n you would or.y t‘ at your first toato bogan on 10 - 11 Here!, 19-12? . . *'or; I cennot r y for sure, wbothor or not on tho 2 Crd or ‘Mtl of TVoru; ry e couplo of oxperlncnta wore performed; 3 cwover, tho reel work bogen on tho 10 th or lit! of Kerch. . Car. you recoil.c vl t dr.y tho tuctc woro finelly ooncludod? I rr ope-.!d.ng of the Ruff-Ronborg tests. - . Thu experiments c :o to cn ond ono or two deys before tho c! e:b_r was te!:on away; tl* 1 st dey wes spent in peeking, nd the cl ruber v: as drivon out of tho c:uip of Dachau on t; o 19th or 20t: of ’ey, \f. lie I wea poraon- elly present. During that p-riod, fron your erriv 1 until tho cl .I'bor wes fin. Uy takon away, hew :: ny te:ts wero .ctu..lly isr.do in your oxp.-ri-sonts? . It is herd to give t* c prociso nunbor, but thoro ;ro ccrteinly botvoon two end throo hundred oxperinents. 6963 to c v7—£' —5-5-*!oohr.n-Infc: ?rown ’-'o, 1 *, -.nd those two r.nd throo hundred tosts, t-s I undor- st. nd it, v/orw for tho curpcso of deitorriining tfco poss¬ ibility of poaouo r.t higji r.ttitudos • th t is to sr-y .bout 20,000 iiutors? j.. Yea, thr.t w..s thoir purpoao. *1.2 FESID21-T: iho iVxbunnl t/i-1 not: bo in rocoss, (i. rocoaa wr.a trJeor.,) 5964 5 H'? K? r^-Trl-io- 31'klcy (R-aler) e-urt ko, 1 Cr. 3 - 1 IKS J&R 1 HAL: The. fc-ibun 1 is “snin in session. HARDY: U 7 it pie' ^ Your H-n r, in caylirnce with the ruling f the Tribunal -f 1 - st Friday, I h va Just received the c-apUU tr-ncL-ti.n of Dfiustnt 16C2-PS; irxl if you would lik- to h-vc, ao wait until Inter I wiU distribute it then or do it n %t, whichever the Tribun-'l desires, s = substitute fer the Document 1602-PS which is net- in Document Book II. I fcvo it completely tr-nsl-ted nd copies f Gercr.n "nd inglish 'vcil blo n_w. THS .UsSI)-JfT: Y u n'.y h* nd the c-py to the Tribun* 1 now. !H. HARuY: The rigin-.l exhibit is h-.ndod herewith to the Secret-ry G-n-r 1 . EXAMINATION BY THE TRIBAL (JU,Ci. l^BRI.'C): C. Dr. R ober. Just bef >rv the C art te,k its recess you a'.c'.c the ot'tccer.t th-.t during the period y^u wero .t Dachau c.nducting tho Ruff-Rocoberg experiments y u uslisrtu Urt bvtweon 200 nd 300 tests wuro C.n y.ut .11 the Tribun- 1 nppr xim-.tely h-w srny ef thos- teSvS w-rv parachute dr p tests nd, .n th- ther tand, h 7 i sr.njr -f then »-r« explosive dec aprocsi n tests? A. Yes. The pnr-.chuU rop experiments fr -a high altitudes, that is t, a./, ltitudes over fourteen ,r fifteen kilwuet-rs, .-U hnd t be prcc-dod by eXplosivu duc-mpressi n int > the high -ltitude, the -ltitude of th- ctu-.l exporia-nt. In the cist _f a slow -.scent up t*. thirteen kil.enters, f r instance, tSnro is no high ltitude sickness. On the otfnr hm* si;* .-scent up to twenty kil m-tero w ck* result in high altitude sickness, oven with oxygen. Therefore, one r.cccrwls sl-wly *t firet in this experiment, to jioout eight kil .a-ters, nd then g-es n with oxplo a ive decompression to the altitude f the axria.nt pr per, the -ltitude fra which one is to Ju-p. Q. Thw -oint is, then, th t 11 f theso two hundred to throe hundred tests included the cjabinrti n of explosive decxapresaion r.d the parachute -scent? 6965 5 li y 47 ^ImZmpkp^ 3L-kloy (Rcnlerl C-jrt lb, l Qrm 1 A. N-t “11 if thus; only those that went above the altitude of f art-vn or fifteen kU-ctotcrs; r.ll of the*. were connected with -xploaSvu decompression* Q. Of tlx. two hurr’r^d or three hundred tests that were bc.Cq zt Dachau, how erny would y,u estimate went above th. f urtcen or fifteen kiloaotore? A. I think aporoxlo Uly half went up to r. hifhor .-.ltitu.!o -n*. w^ro t hcroforc c^imctod with oxplisiv. decazpression. Perhaps n_>t cuite half A then, because toward the end not s~> nr.ny experiments vero carried ait. K-y 3W:-3K.8-1^:U i>Lr (Iat, j? anl..r) Sourt Z, C :so *Io, 1 ; You arrived it Piqhtu aon-whero our)d the 20th of February 19*i2? - Yjs, Fobru-ry 22 or 23* < ..ad peril..ps oa. csr r o t-sts ’.;,ro aide on this day, ni you than '/oat br.ckto Berlin o-cv.uao 3oao difficulty hid ..risen concerning vino w..a in cwinnd, or 3on-thing of thr.t 3ort. .ih it \i 3 th t difficulty? * .. Th-r* w-rj difficulties rif.rxding Rnschor's being t3signed to D.tchr.u. Th-s- difficulties w.ro in prjt connected • ith bis being issl-pijd to the .ioltz Institute, x‘ on*the oth r h.ni his .ur.ignia.nt to Schong .u. . ..ith v/hon w 3 the nattor t: k-n up in Berlin to jtr ijhten out th-s- diffir.ulti_3? .. I h .d nothin, t 11 to do -./ith th.it. I did not n-goti t- ou th-t ;Uv. stio.\ t 11 . .; sch-r settled th.it •ith the ,.ir -..u . t .lunioh. I personally had nothing to uo ’./ith hia ail it j*y .osi^nu-nt, . Then you c —- b\ck to D .ohtu 3oa- tieio around the 13ti. or 11 th of ti rch. .. -re you ordered bick to Bach.u? - .Ic, it h .d b—a ..jre-d fro;: the outsit th t vie ./ore joiag to c rry out th- -x?-ria-nt3. Only ;.n interruption ’ t..k~.i plr.ee, which .. .3 ov-rcoa- ift-r tho difficulties ...re linin; t-i r:j rd in , K .sch-r’s nssignaont. , Hoe a-.ny t ^3t3 h .d you run r.fc 3-rlin an the s ue -x ,,rir:.nt before you aov.d down to Bach .u? .. I c..: not t .11 you th t .x otly, but in th- pi.r~.chut$ JuR' exp^ric nts, I u sur- th-r- wore -bout twenty or thirty. In thoa- c 3-3 th- .ltitude w s auch low,r. .as fir 3 explosive d-oonpr-ssion i3 concerned, wo p-r- forried consideribl- nunb-r of exp-ri/:-nts. . How n iiy *.;ould you siy? - I sure th r- .poroxinatyly two hundred *967 V y 5-*-BK-3-2-Gallagher (Iat. H^al^r) CcUft I, C..3e Ho. 1 -xplosivj decompression teats. Over what period of tine had th~so tests boon cede? .. The par chute work h.dbocn canoludod in the /all of 1041 , und th- explosive decompression t-sts were carried out up to tho tine of the beginning of th- experiments at D.-.ch .u, about four aonths. v Then ov m* a period of four aonths you conducted about two hundr-d explosive decompression tost3 at Berlin? « Yes. . ..nd how nar.y p-o.>le did you have s exporic-nt-1 3 ubJwCt 3 for your explosiv- dec expression tests, by which I underst-nd tests nado .t ltitudes ~bov- fourteen or fifteen kilometers? .. They wont up to s-ventw-n kilometers, nd as to th- nuab.r of th- oxporin-nt .1 sublets, you will h..vo to keep in alnd th-3e w-r- m-ab-rs of the Institute. There wore ..bout seven. . ..u the poo lo u3-d in 3-rlin for the parachute drop 3 at .ltitudes und~r fourt-en or fifteen kilometers a different G^oup than th..t used for the explosive dc- mxipr-ssion tests? .. I Jo, we -lw-^TS h .d the sx. people in fl-rlin. That was just the difficulty, -.e did not hvave a 1 -*5- nunbjr of subjects; therefore, wo had to conduct various series of exporia-nts on th. s People; during the explosive do- c oppress ion experiments wo c rri-u out a large number of airpl ne oxp-rirwnts, centrifuge oxperirwnts, end experi¬ ments reading the shock deceleration, that is the shock of the parachute opening, or the braking effect in crash landings. „ n exp-rt in aviation medicine, what was your Ti.w -3 to how often cn oxperCental subject should bo X ? 5■4<£-BK-8-3-G'.llcijhur (Int. anool-r) Court I, C.-.su ..o. 1 -xposed to c.n explosive decompression test? Th'.t i3 to siy, how much time should elr.pse between one experiment or tc3t, end the succeeding t-st? .. explosive Jococpr-ssion is not the cost strenuous pr.rt of th- cxp^ric-nt3. Th- r.ltitude which is recichcd plys r: consider .bio p-rt, \nd th- lr.ok of oxyg-n which occurs .s result. In Berlin we p.-rforccd explosive d-coaprossion oxporin-nt3 irons ourselves, 3-v-r .1 tines d:.y. .«o p rforrod sev-r~.l on one d y, end th-n wo c -rri-d out oth .r cxporic-nts, th_r_ were test flights when th-re w .s good wither, md then we vrk on holidays? ,, Ho, t Beat-r, for i.istJioe, I wr.a in Berlin, end there were n-v.r ry experiments carried out on ^und .y. . How cl my Oj.cen holid ys were there in thr.t period of tin-, do you recollect? .. I think th-ro w:.s 2cat-r; then there w\s the 1 st of :i.y, which w a . holid .y. Th-n thero w..s ..so-nsion Dry, which u.-.s 3ur--ly holidr.y, md then there w~rc ell the Sundays. 5 Hay 4 7-Yr- .-JC-a-1-Kaynes-Ra-llc-r C3*j?.: : i Q. At the iftstar holiday, hov a any days did you take off? Good Friday? SSSarday? Hasten londay, perhaps? a. Yes, and Monday too? Thar., at the Taster" Holidays, in addition to your Castor Sunday, there ware three days that you did not experiment? A. Certainly, yas. How many days did you take off on ascension holl- day? s. I was not in Berlin for Ascension Day; there was probably only one day token off. Q. And on 1 r.ay, one day? I was in Berlin 1 Hay. At that tins thoro was this barometer business, so that I was in Berlin for some time. I remember definitely that I was in Berlin on 1 Hay. Q. When you actually rouchod Dachau to stay, along about— ‘Veil, when your rirct oane to Dachau, tho 2*rd of February, vher- werj you billeted in the camp? a. I was not billeted in the camp. I had a civilian apartment. I was living with a farmer or conebody, a private citizen, outoldo the camp. %, Hov far away from the camp? .V. I thin* approximately twenty or twenty five minutes, walk from tho camp. ;. Did anyone share this billet with you, or this a~ par taunt? ... Ho, I had a room with those people, which I rented. Q. Did you aver aiaauns with th.*-5 your being in Dachau? Ho, naturally not. Q. /here did you nes3 during the time that you stayed in Dachau? 69?0 5 Kay - 7-9-3-B ayne s- Rani1 e r COLRT I I .!. I had ay noon meal In a little restaurant outside the camp, or* el3o I lid not oat at all. In the evening I often vent 1 r. to I.ur.ich, uid had supper there. If not I always ate At the restaurant In Dachau, ft. During that tlae, did you discuss with anyone-other, of course, than Rascher or Ruff or some of the inspec¬ ting officers vho night coao to Dachau- the experiments you vore conducting and the reason for ^our being in Dachau? Ho, I don't think that I talked to anyone, apart fron those persons whoa you have sentloned. ft. Did you ke«p the sane billet or apartnent and the sane mess during all the tine that you stayed In Daohau? H .. .j’tervards I was given a room In the SS bar¬ racks, which has outside the camp, out as before I ato it that rentaurant which I mentioned, ft. r.ien you wore in the 33 b/irraoas, did ar.vor.e share your room flih you? No, I had a room to ay self. Q. But there were in the SS b-rraoks a great m»ny S3 people? Xeu. This was an officers' birr eks where other S3 officers were living, ir.d there was also some office space there. ft. THoso wore 33 officers In charge cf the details of rur.nir.., the camp, In charge of the prisoners, and that sort of thing? Ho, these 33 officers, as far as I know, lid not belong to the gu .ra company of the camp, ?ut belonged to the girrison, tne regiment, or whatever It was, which was stationer at Dachau. ft. I believe you sail on Friday that there w ere 6971 5 Xay sZ.— &-Hoynea- Haulier. COURT I I between 60 and 70 Innate8 of the camp who volunteered as experimental subjects for the high-altitude exporl- aor.ts which you and Ruff, in collaboration -nth Rasohor, were going to conduct In the low-prcssuro chamber exper¬ iments. -v ./ell, according to what the experimental subjects told Ruff and me, approximately 60 persons volunteered specifically for the lo'^-prossuro experiments. 3. *»nd i understood that the minimum requirements for tho operation of the low-pressure chamber was two men, one, thephyslclan in charge, and the other, the mechanic •*ho operated the engines. The physician, of course. w, t s neoossary. The mechanlo did not have to be present constantly to attend the en¬ gines. Onco the pumps were working and tho motor was running, everything was .all right. The mechanic had only the tack to supervise the engines, to oil them whenever neoeasary, etc., to see to It that no pump was ever run¬ ning hot. However, It was not necessary to servloo the engine continuously, “he whole apparatus was kept vory simple because It w-.s meant for service with troops, and they did not always have experts available. Q. During your series of authorized experiments, who wore the men who acted as the mechanics for this low- pressure chamber and who ran tho engines and looked after them? .i. In particular, Scoottn took care of tho engines. He knew something about thorn,.oil then there was another per¬ son among the experimental subjects who knew about motor era's. Neff sometimes concerned hloself about them, but --Inly there were these two men who wore experts. Sobotta and Hoff, then, were the experts. 6&72 5 ..ay -i%H-A£-9--fiayneft-Ha=llar. ecu:-.? i cass : .w Ho, the expert wa* Another ona, «a fas a noteroar mechanic. Q. What was the name, do you know? A. I don't know that-any longer. Q. What was Neff doln^ In the car.p? Do you know why he va8 there? I , a. .vs far as ho told me at the tine and as far as he testified here, he was there because he had denounced a bomb attick which was to be carried through by SS men, In .aistna, and after that denunciation the men In¬ volved had been arrested. Q. How long had he oeen at Dachau? He said at the time that very soon after tho annex¬ ation of .ustria in the year 108 he had boen sont to :he camp. Q. as a political pilmnor? A. Yes. Q. What do you Knew ibout the non Sototta? I know of Sobotta that he was an Austrian and that for repeated burglaries he had boen sentenced, as far as I know, he carried out a large-scale burglary In a big Vlonna Bank or the Vienna State Bank. Q. Ho, then, was a criminal prisoner, as you understood it? Yes, he had received a number of sentences, and he was a professional criminal who, because of these rop- oatea burglaries, had been put In preventive custoSy. Q. Do you know what court had placed him In preventive custody? .w Ho, I do r.ot know that. Q. How, what do you knew about the nan, the expert In mechanics, whose name Is now unknown to you? 6573 5 May -fc7-M-.»iC-9-&-Hayaea-RanllJ?. CttQI I C-3* II rt. Why ha vae there, really, I can't tell exactly now. I think It had something to do with his knowledge of aotorcors. I assuue that he was carrying out hurglnrleo In order to steal z.o tore are. But you don't know that? I don't *now that exactly. 6974 5 iiy-^-:3-10-l-Eoxsiu (Int. Haal ur) Court Bo. I. q During the period ef tithnt’you wore in Dachau, just x-otly t activity did Hoff carry on that you know about? Ho r:n V:j _xtor. I believo you said soavathing the other day to tho effect that ho r-a in charge cf bringing the oxp-riaintcl subjects to the chmbcr .-.nd returning thoau 'That olso did no do so far ;s you know? A lief f was the so-colled bloc'.: oldest of these expiria-ental to s.- to it that t "lock -ly. Ho hnd to get food for ther., r.nd in addition ho carried cut nxib-r of errr .da for Srsch-r within tha c-a?. For inat-nce, he vas cftcr. sent to the ccntaon in ord-r to bxry tobacco for the oxperiBcntr .1 subjects by ordur of Hnscher. So;»-tiae3 he assv.st-d during the -xp-riuents. Ho « occasionally Mot into the roon to yet -nothor ^xoirijxnt-l subject; r’.ion one sen was finished 3off va sent uft-r the noxt one; thor- v.ro quit- ? nu. b-r of such errand*. Q -m in efi-ct t>-n r. craa? trustee of eo:.x sort? A I don't know oxrctlj vhat the relationship waa in that con- ocotion. Ho only hid this swell group under him; it v -y high position. From n military point of view, you would nrob-bly do- si; of physical condetior. and age. Q Aid as you understood it, they wore all Gemnn nationals? A lus. Q And th. retard -2d out to those volunto-rs vr.o that coao kind of L.nioncy ra going to bo -xtend-d to then if they surviv-d tho experiments? A fee, th.y n .r. /ran.s.d »vt tiv-y rould either be r-leased fxxna • .) or t « t eeir s id bo mitigated. How-vor, lab r, on tho occasion of Hiaalor's visit, .all of th_a r«re proais.d thoir ro- lc-o-. 3 How do you knot* that? A Tho experimental subjects naturally told no that outhucian- tically when I rent thore tha day -ft.r hi tier's visit. Thoy said t at hey had subjected tb^-.ves to experiments b-forc Hi- l^r, -nd had reals-d thor. that they would b_ released if they ronduct.d thms.'Tos prop-rly. Th.y an.ro jubilant about this. Q In other words, ovor the pariod of tir-o that you wero at ' cl’.au, fror. 9 1 larch to -bout 20 l.ay, you wore in rather close touch itk : : cvr tea or fiftocn axp crimen trl subjects' and had got their con- fid, ac., ~t lunsr to the- extent that thjy told you of the fact that 5 2i7-*-lB-10-3-Hoxsic (Int. -taler) Court No. I. Ktsal~r, after his visit, .--<2 promised then leniency? A Yes, th>y naturally told ae that. Q About what tine of th: year was this? A You ae?n the- Hiaalcr visit? Q Yes. A That nuat have been on a Sunday, the nidale or end of April. Q And when was it that tho sublets told you uhat Kiml-r had ir.p-.rtod to then? A They told no that or. tho Very r.oxt day ».hcn T entered the station. That was the r„xt orday. Q Do you knew who had cotmyod to thes- oxpcrinontnl subjects tho statement of HirrQer to tha effect th-.t those nun uero going to ba granted leniency? A They told so that Hiaal^r had told then that personally when ho was there. Q Now, whon Hinder was thore, had ho witnesrod an oxjx-ri- nent on those subjocts or had they been produced to hin for cbvss in¬ spection, or had ho 7isitcd their barracks. How did ho corn in contact with tho group of then? A Hi-aaler had corn out there to tho c-np as far as I know, with tho aain purpose in raind of looking at theso expori-nentr. Maaler's visit has bo.n describ.d r-thcr exactly in Tfolffs affidavit, which has be.r. subnitted anong Ruff's docurv.nt3. I don't know tho nu bor of that docu_*ent. Q What did tho tar., Scbotta, do -around Dachau in connection sith tha exporiiaents? A Sobotta did nothing exco .t s.rw. th. purps, in addition to taking part in the experiments as all the others did. Sobotta had no saocial position at all. He, to be suiv, was th. most cnorgotic fellow ‘-.-r_, with tho nost initiative. :d_ no doubt participated in tho nost £*- erts.nts, but Lc held r-o special official position. 5977 5 ' ay-}>-! 3-IC-ii-Hoxaiu (Int. Bealor) Court Eo. I. 5 Wtaro did Sobotta live, did *3 live with the otter oxpari- .-v:ntal subjects? A Yes, te lived just liko ell the otter cxpariaontal subjects. q go w < 3 quartered with ttear, end te was nossod with thee? A Yes. Ho hadn't teen brought out in any way free the others officially. Q \la*, this unknoi.T. aan '-ho w-a the -utoaobilo expert, vhat did te do around the oxpcriiijnts? A T.'oll, togutter with Sobotta, ho worked ir. tho ?u=P car. Hov and again ho ropaired Raseter's c-r, but othonr.se ho had no special task. y Q hhoru did he livo? A Ho lived togothor with that group. q Ard took his ^ 3 -Is with the;:, 3 suppose? A Yoc. Q How was ho drassed? A Juat liko all tho other sublets. Thoy tead this stripod or iso nor* a .suit. 3 Do you know what his nationality was? A Ho was a Genian. Q So that of tho throe nanfco telpad you conduct tho o.epori- rttr.ts na rxwhanlcs, th-ro was .loff, tho political rritover, Cobotta, tho Austrian criminal prioonor, and this aan whoso nr-u, was vtavx m who you say was a Genian, and who you thought was a crLadnal prisoner bacauso of aono burglaries or thefts ir. connection with automobiles. A Yos, te ted been sort-need as a professional criminal. 5 Aid thoy telpwd you in your experiments during tho ontiro period that you wore thcro? A Vail, ttey didn't assist ro in any particular wiy. As far as tho two mechanics go, thqy had cert-in supervisory task, in tho saxo w-y - s a driver looks after a rotor car by oiling it from ti-o to tino, etc. That's what ttes- non did. 6378 5 *iy-::-:3-10-5-Koxaii. ( 1 st. Rsr.l_r) Court No. I. Q I aaderstarxl, but unless the engines ren you couldn't con¬ duct cxpcriexmts, and those wore tho ;cn she looked .after the rschonical details of tho actor to see that it was in good order, so you could tuiid up your pru-esure or diminish your pressure in your low-pressure ch":bcr? A Yos. Q Yfor. you said that you had between ten and fifteen expori- ^ntal subjects usod in your oxpjriixjnts, I assure that you included those thrw- -on in your calculations? A Yos, I included thaw Q So that aside fron these thru, een you actually had twolvo to seven expuriccntal subjects rather t.rn fifteen or ten? . A Yes, apart froa thos- you are right. Q Tihon was the first tieo you actually saw .and talked to tho sixty or seventy innate s vho had vclunt^.r.d for thv. high altitude ex¬ periments? A I tv-T er spoko to th.se sixty or seventy innetet, but only to the group of professional cri-einals who *er„ billeted -t the sta.tion. ?h-t w.aa on th- 22nd or tho 23rd of February, «hich was the occasion or. which I saw than for tho first tie*. 5979 Court 1 &sy 5 -H-ll-l-HD-Ceok-Raasler. slow what d- you -con by the group of professional criminals, Just the entire 6 roup that were there, or the sixty or seventy inmates who hod volunteered? a. :io, the group wnioh woe billeted ct the station. You mean the ten or fifteen? a. Yes. q. veil then, who told you there w^re sixty or seventy v lunteers. Dr. Roseher? a. Bo, the e sen told BO that themselves. :on I asked how they were selected, etc., they replied that a number of people had volunteered and fr.-c these Dr. Rnsohor acleoted ua from the point of view of health ond ago. '4. Vns a list ever given you showing the n-mea of these sixty or seventy men? A. Ho, I didn't see tne list of the other people. 3 . what physical or mentc .1 qualifications were the men w.oo wee to bo finally seleoted for your experiments required to have? A. For one thing their ego had to range between twenty ond thirty-five yocr 6 approximately, which corresponds to the - 0 e of the flyln^ personnel of the L ftwaffe. In addition, they h u to be generally fit, th-t le to say, tlwv couldn't under any dreams t-incee ve « weak heart or somo liver illness; they h d to bo n-rmol he lthy aen. hontclly, of C-ursc, no considerable requirements wore mode. They n d to h ve normal ffiont.al c-p city. For lnst-nco, feeble-minded people w u^jln* u have served the purpose. i. Bow who fixed those physical or mental qunlifico- =1 ns, you and Dr. Ruff? In Other words, who determined cho type of non that you wanted for y-.ur experiaotits? A. Ko, Ra'Cher s.lect-d tnen at the time we were in 6950 Coart 1 vny 5-K-U-2-ED-Cook-Rcmnler. sorlin. This was done on the oasis cf nr. arrangement that via maee with the c mp commander. I- had been ' ranged tfant ir a the people ho volunteered Rascher was to select t.-ls s roup. They had to fulfill this and that requirement, and after they were billeted at tns station they had to receive good nourlshaent. They wore not to work, see. i. Who told Rascher that tho experimental subjects woo were finally selected tod to be between twont. to thirty-five years of nge, generally fit, v*th no weak heart or other Internal ailments, and mentally normal'? h. That was act down on the b sis of the conference in Oaohau-Vlth the onmo commander. Present wore Ruff, •• - Veits nMitlM camp coatnndor, and ochnltzler. ... Whose decision w/'S it tn*»t men between the agos of cwer.ty to thirty-five, vno were generally fit "nm xentfSly normal, were to be seieotod? Was it you vno demanded that type of son, was It Ruff who demanded thorn, vc.8 It "eltz, w s It tho camp commander, wns It $ohnitzlor? Stuoonc tod to determine what typo of man you wanted to experiment on. Now, who actually determined that? uou and Ruff wore in charge of the experiments. Who actually determined tho physical md mental attributes that your experimental subjeots were to x/ssoss? a. Well, surely Ruff end I. Wo were to carry out tho experiments and we set tho requirements. Who actually pronounced the requirements or whether they wer- laic down by discussion, I c n't say exactly now, bat at qny rate Ruff and I were the ones. But y.u know the requirement? you needed for tho _-.cn in your 0 yperlmental group because this was simply a c ntlnur.tion of the experiments that you nod D3gun at Berlin, .and you w*ntca men who -s closely as possible baa 65 SI Court 1 Jfay 5-y,-11 - 3- ED-Cook-Sa r. Che fleas physical r.nd cental attributes as the experimental subjects in Berlin? la that correct? Yes that woe one reason, but there woe another rareon whlca wee also the reason we selected certain pers.ns In Berlin. For Instance, we didn't use any girla c _,.ng tho technical assistants, who might have volunteered. ■ie bore in mind thrt oil of these experiments were to serve the Luftwaffe and had to correspond to the personnel normally subjected to similar dan&ore in the Luftwaffe na, therefore, we nad to hve men of that :ge, not e lrla or sick people. i. When w 8 the selection of the ton or fifteen experimental subjects from the sixty or seventy volunteers actually cade? a. I don't know tho exact time, but wnon the ohoober arrived nt tho beginning of February nobody was as yet billeted nt tho station, as f"r -s I recall. When, on Che other hand, I returned on tho 22nd or 23rd of February, they were already there, 60 this must lvvo hn-rocnod during that period of tlae. i. How, ->8 I understand it, this wos, as you say, a vitally important experiment for the benefit of tho Luftwaffe, and as a consequence had to be carried out v;lt:i iieat erro, because froc the results of those tests you vara going to make recommendations to the Luftwaffe concerning matters w-.lch ir. actor 1 combrt mlgflt effect the ilfs of the Luftwaffe members, Isn't that correct? # a. Yes, wo were trying to rescue people from r.ign rltltudcs. And it w s for that reason tha. It w-8 indlspena- ably r.d vitally necessary th-t you have experimental subjects who were between the ages of twenty to t.ilrty- 6?&2 I 0-. art 1 Hey 5J^U-4-HP-C^ok-arsaler. five, who we e generally fit, nnd who were oontally normal? A. Yes, in order to drnv * g-od OMspsrta -n vltl1 t "° ncraol pera ^r.nel. i. Who v-'e preaent when the ten or fifteen experimental sa-Jecta were selected free the sixty or seventy volunteers? A. I don't know thet. I ee sure Rpsoher must have beer, preaent. He w-s the one who selected them. Kao else 6 la-Cook—(Hamlc r) - Court No. 1 r_5 preset I don't kr.tw. . In other i rds, Dr. Raschcr actually made the s clction? • Yes. G TOwt teSts were given the* te ascertain father cr net they hai thjiental and physical qualificaticns Ter experimental subjects? « There was a normal nodical crani ration. In ether words he listened t-' their hart and th-ir lungs and c.nversed with than. Q Hew dc you knew that? a he tcld a, abcut it and the experimental subjects also told no that they had been examined. G Then, as I understand it, before y'u began ycur experiments yeu t'.lked with each ,n. cf these experimental subj-cts? A I wouldn't say that I talked to these experimental subjects tefcrc -ach experiment, but by a large and dod converse with these pers-ns in erder to cake their acquitnncw and in rdcr tc tell then »fcat was a stak. -luring these experiments. Naturally, the persons *nly g:lned a certain c nfidcnce in me ao tic. progressed. Q other w rds, y^u wanted tc get well acquainted with thus so •:.-t they would aak- jxp.rir.ent l subjects who wculd aid y-m in yaur * . because if they Were not willing subjects they would pet be as h.lpful t ycu as though they were willing subjects, is that the point? a loi, we wanted to have pr-per coperaticn on the part cf the xp-rlrwntal subject. 1 • 3U PP'- 3t - that frea tice tc tin.. y?u deaand.d not n n ly prepor perati n but c«rJial cc p.raticn? n /ell, ye3, rr. had te dcp_nd cn a certain an unt cf ca p.raticn And s th- group being v.ry small, cnly twelve tc seven, •-a Keff eliminated, and Sabrt* el i m ina ted, and the unknown man : U.ainat_d, you had a wy small greup, and in order tc establish a •‘lati nship af g-.cd will, I suppose free tiec t time as each ,f than r. ted h ins elf f:r the experiment, y u said: inhere are ycu froa? - r '- y-« here? Shat is y.ur name, and s; f:rth? n 6 98U & ; -i^>r^S-ll-2a-Coot (Baa-lur) Court :~. 1. A. Yes, these trro rxn, Sabots, ana the other did fully be Ion- to f.v.t cxperiicntal group and participated in all our experiments. They -.re no . isolated In any vxy ft*c that group. And I naturally con- Tersed • *ith then frequently. '2. In other vords, you ashed then, — Veil here ras a nan, perhaps : lira*, experimental subject just valkod up and you could say: Arc ;*ou :icntally fit? Are you acntally nornal? Is your h-art strong? Do you Iv.vo any liver ailoonts? Arc ycu generally fit, or nhat did you say to tixn. You rare nooting ficn fa- tic first tine as an export :*o had corx to Dachau to conduct certain experiments? You v re ncot- ir.: then for the first tine in a concentration can?. They ixrc prisoners there. You r.rc a coaploto stranger to thou, except it rat 'mem you -.re an expert frea Berlin r*o rr.-a going to conduct the experiments. :.v I T.ould thin:: that there novld 'x a considerable rcsistens>. on tho p-.rt of die mien to present thc::s.lves unt 1 first ycu t'.x.i roll, or in tlio otlicr hand tlvjy Senov you roll sc* that tlicy vould ha.v. confidence a you and I -nuld think miorooror that .n ord.r to "In their confidence ye- "e-f.d rant tc l:no" ’.hat their n.xxc ra.ro, and perhaps their bad- grrxixl, •-'.•at part of the country they had co^x fron, rrhat fxyv.ro doing in prison, hot* roll the vre tr.atmd. I vorld thin!: all of thos. tilings vovld be ncccss-ry in order for you to g«.t the cv.pl.to cooperation and t-v. good trill that irrs vitally noccssa.ry for your .rpmrinonta, is that ;iorc or less correct? 59B5 Court S;. 1 . £ Key 4?-l.-i2-l-h3t-h*rrov (Baesler) A. Veil, by and large, that 1* correct. Of course, one c&uldn't diccuse all details la the sane manner with these sen. To* Jnstanoe. tho subject of their cvn sentences vas scnething about which they vero ver/ reticent end only gradually started apeaxing. As tine crogrcssed, they told whet brought then to the cenp. It Is ouite typical, and that le also contained in the *olff affidavit, that Sobotka, when asked by Hlaaler what he had done, had said that he had ncroly snuggled coffee, but efterverds It had been found out that ho repeatedly conaitted severe burglaries - breaking open banks. Saturally. they didn't talk freely about their sentences and about their life In the carp. The real acquain- t~r.ee only developed as tine progressed. q. But ovor the period of tine you got veil enough acquainted, I suppose, that ecco of then actually oonflded in you. At least, to tho extent that you knew thtir agee, you know their nance, you know vhoro they -oro frsa, you knew whether thoy had faaillos nt hoso - that sort of thing! A. Toe, naturally that varied. fic«o vero nore likely to converse with ao, others less. 7or instance, one person who had forged noncy told ne his entire background, including aany dotaile, on ono occasion. At tho beginning, however, ho was rather reticent, but later ho told no exactly hov ho was arrested and how ho s forging tho noney, otc. Q. And you certainly knew, ovor that ucriod of tine of relationship, th s t they won between tho ages of 20 ind 26 . that thoy were generally fit, with no weak hearts or liver ailr.onts or bed kidneys ard that sort if thing - and thet they were ncntelly normal? a. Tcs, naturally I didn't exwlno the livers of these ooople In detail. Easchar. by order, had carried out this r.ediccl examination. but one could by merely looking at these people that thoy were fit, aid I also discussed their health vith then. Q, Did you ever see the records upon which haechor had sot down the results of his examinations - either of the sixty to seventy volun¬ teers or of tho ten to fifteen non finally selected tot the cruerloents? 6936 C-UTt 10. 1 C jfBr 4’r-r.-12-2-l&i-£erTcnr (Ea r—l cr) A. Eis record about his ovc experlnents - is that ycu mean? v S-* no, you say that there vert sixty to seventy volunteers; that free than he finally selected tea to fifteen experimental subjects vho, by your direction in defining the neceetery physical and nental requirements, %*.re betveen ages of tventy to thirty-five, vere generally fit and vert mentally normal. lev, in order to doternine that fact, ho undoubtedly geve than physical end nental examinations. Did you ovor ■oo the list of tho ten or fifteen men vho were finally examined and vho voro found to have these physical Qualifications? Did you over non it? A. So, I nor«.r saw that list and ho didn't shov it to ns. Ho just told no, "I hew oranined those people and they aro healthy." ^ Vhoa the ten to fifteon experlnentol subjects verc finally •ducted, vfcat then bccaee of the other fifty-five or forty or whatever va» lwft over? a. I can't tell you that in detail; I don't knov vfcat happened to thon. i*axtly, I'a suro that they vent beck or rather ronalned at their vork dotell or vfcorever they voro, end partly, I an sure, Rescher used these people for his ovn smerinents. q, You think than that, of tho forty-five or fifty M.o -ore loft, Rescher used come of then for his exocrinents? A. Tvs. Q, H-v do ycu knov that? A. Eo told n* that he had volunteers for his experinents and that ho vrs taking ovoulc vho had already vcluntsored. Q, I see. Rascher told yau that. of those vho v«re not solatd f ,r your experiments, he used soae of that group for his experinents? A. Tes, ha said that some of those people "ho bad vcJxmtaarM hr.d ?icon token by him. q. Vhon did he tell ycu that? A. I can't tell ycu that cvactly - vfcen it vos - but .1 'n sure it vss after ha had started hie ova experiments along with curs. 69c7 Court 5c. 1 6 Kay 47-4t-12-5-*5>-£arr3v (Easier) q, Yaea did he start his own oxperinents? A. I can't give ycu the e^act date since he v*« ncrforning tho«o experiments during =y ebsence end also at night. At any rate, I heard ohcut that approximately in the aiddle of April. q. Vho told you? A. 2 a«cher hlaself told ac that. K« aaid that ho was norforning additional experisenta. q. And that vm aoce tine during the niddlo of April, 1942? A. Tea. q, And he t-ld you at that tine that he *«a uaieg, aa hie exoeri- ccatal subjects, sono of the non *fco had originally volunteered? A. Ha aaid that ho had a number of experimental subjects who pertly had boon sentenced and voro profaaaional crininala, mi oartly auns who had been asntencod to death. q. I Know all about that, but in April. 1942, he told you that ho vm using scuo of that original seventy tc sixty non *>o had voluntocrod for your experinents but who hed not boon scloctod? A. I cannot tell that oxactly. Thsso norsons didn’t voluntoor principally for our exnerinents, but cade thcnsolvos available for oxporisonts, generally speaking. q, I understand, and of that seventy to sixty you found fifteen to ten who had the physical and mental attribute, for your oxmrincnts? Is that correct? q. hell, there nay have been lore in that group -ho had the sane attributes, I don't know that. I think thor„ verc about thirty or forty in that age group but I cannot tell you that oxactly. q. Did Has char over toll you that? A. Ho, Ea.cher didn't give n. any details about his affairs. q. Then you don't know vhether the non he used for his private experinents possessed the physical and mental reouirenent. laid down by you and Huff or not, dc you? A. Ho, I cannot say that in every case. 5986 cn*o sort 3 o f 1 s*? -.7-^-12-4--lKr.-icrrev (Sailer) JEJ Tribunal “111 nov be in rebees until 1:30 o’dofk, (a rocesa ve* taken until 13SC houre.) 69e9 5 h-y-xr-Jl^-13-1-7'Bt or (Int. ar'wn) Court I «r^23oai S2SSICE ( 2 io :nbucU roc nvcncd at 1330 h-ars, £ fa? 1947. ) TriS -i So a': Tho rribuncl is mala in *csei-n. £aSS RCK3 jS 3 - EcB’i-Od ZLM1L.2ICS.' 3T ES COUaT (Continued) 3T cUDC-2 SJPaJR)! Q. Dr. Bxibor,-, la too c-.nduet of y-ur tests la tho Buff, Honbcr i HaBchcr. experiment, what data or information wai it necessary for you to roe id la record to Ooch't^t la order to set a true ;?io- turc of that tost? la tho cjc>«ri..oat« inv.lviiv; a relatively low altitudo, tho ©apcrinontnl subjects tha.solr.B wreto ms-bers frxi 1000 on up, or wroto tlxolr acics. Xa cxp-rlnoatB lavolvla,; hlrhor ultitudos or in tho littlo chamber, kj difficult towrlto, thorowoa a ■'it of toicpa-.alo c anoctiOa with the .aorlmoatal tubjoct. Tao subject bod omphocoB on oad fad a uiorcpnno bo th-t no w„b ablo to wioortfcla how he ro.jCtod whea epoKen t-', and n that .no c uld uaowor cortnln tLUOati no, quest! as ao>ut tholr cental cnditiin, Uiotuor they woro porfoctly clear, and b“ f orth, -loo, -id this io very Important, thoy wore obliged t pull tho parachute roleuBO ratnoir owr. Initiative vlth- -ut boiac* told to, thus pr-via,- that thoy woro ca-plotcly in poBoooBioa of tholr faculties, and thoy rocomnisod too situation In which they f und tho -selves. 3 . and all of th„t data or Infoniati-n then Was roe rdod by you _nd procorrod? wa b written down. ' \?/ "U on what- V-b It writ*.on? *v i . \ ... __ V/ tfcon What w_a it writ*.on? ' , r, -.ll T duhka; tho experiment It w_s written oa a pioco of >w.- * J . ‘ 'fcemutinco it vj written directly Into tho rocord, otherwise, V • • :vT l > / - ?^>or. it wns BhtVr id in the record aftar toe vsporinent. also tne numbers 6990 5 ncy-W?- 13-3-7ter (1st. 3r3wn) C-urt I _ad a^ies, the writia,- tosta, th..t the ^aperi-eatol rubjaeta conducted wailo in the eh^tor, wore preserved. la ether words ym preserved the a^ic of tho cspori-ontnl subject, tho day and htur, I- suppose, q>‘-a which tae tost was oede, c .-d hia reactions duria.- the c-urso of the teat. Zs that corroct? *. Tea. 0„ So that *:ea you finished with year aeries of cxpcrL.oata y;u c aid look .t this record, y*u C-uld tell the ach© of ojeh Mpcriuontnl .abject, the date ua& tiuo up:n walch he had be® sub¬ jected to an ccaori-oat and h!a roactloae darla; tho c aroo of each toper nto toot, la th-t correct? *. Yos, th_t la ao. 1513 roeordod th^t infn.ation? a. Daria* tho exooriaont itself 2 -sciior or ayaolf wroto down theao individual data, wo uudo notes r«_rdin tho tiho whon tho poraoa recovered cxaci uaacas -ad theao v*rc tho data on which tho report w.a Bubauiuoatl;' worked out. q. cd tk,t course of procoedarc wot followed thr -v^oat tho ontlro courto :f tho 200 to 300 testa? «. Tea. 0. .nd duria* tho 200 to 300 teats you u«od 10 to 15 acloctod volur.toor suhjocta? — Yos. q, *ad f or tho 20C to 300 tests 70a always used tne aa-o 10 or 15 subjects? - *oa. q. end Lefa tiliO on csperU-oat -1 subject would 00 presented to you or to Enichor in y.ur proaunco f or tho c aduct of tho toff - Boubcrc; experiments, I suppose y:u either -shod Mi. hia m«o or ascertained his use fraa the record .0 that r a could c :.pore tho data for tho tost 6991 5 Uay-^J?-13-3-Fcst*r (Srcwn) Court So. 1 on v.e p. rticul r d-j* with the previ.us tests, Is th-t correct? - Tcs. 0 . «ad toes you h_d finished the 2 C 0 or 300 tosts you then wero in n po«iti‘n to ascertain ~*tr tno course of tne ospcrL-cnt new unay tests Cftch volunteer hjl undergone? Toe, th_t ie ri.Jit. q. ^ad it w_s fr^: th *e so?-rnte lists ..e t- c^ch «eporiuontal subjoct, it w..s fr n taoee thnt y u njdo y ur rec^erdati no to hi„hor nutnrity f r leniency f-r toe a 9 erlneat.il subjects? Secar.eodntl ns f*r leniency were n'-t r.nde by us, at lo.-.et not by nyeolf. This w .e e natter whicn Eiiilur hA urrt-t«d to hiiiself frr. the to 17 bc*innta£. Vo of tno XL hod at influonco ca this. 6992 1 5 kay 47 -A-IA-l-rt?- (Brc*n) Court Ho. 1 Hon would Higgler knew who to ucUnd lierency to unloss scevoody g-'-vo hia the neats of the ucperlMtal subjects who had euccossfully ca-.ol^tod the Usts? A. There was certainly the crap card indue file on '11 those ■ho participated in the experirents. These people had aaved and moreover livod in separate barracks so ttrt their aims could at any tio- bo ascurt aired, The inturredinry who h"d ccr.tact with the crap cooa-ndcr no1 with Hiaal-r and who had received the authority frctu Hisader wns Raschcr. Y.v had no -direct contact with Hi-aolu*, written or OtheTWiSJ. Q. Then that was a nr tUr that wns left, so f-r as you and Ruff ■ore concerned, that was left to Dr. Rnsch-x? A. Yes, Nj was th. ore who froa the v-.ry beginning had received the authority and ^raiasicn Iron Hindi-r. Q. Dr. Roaoorg, how n-ny tett runs on v.xp-rirentr.1 subjects had you coopleted when to your knowledge Rcechcr began his first independent •.xperirent un-’.or rds con r‘te ordv.r itea TianUr? A. About ball of thus. Th t would be roufhly one hundred or pwrlr.ns a little .'ore than r hundred axperirents. Q. -,h.t was the -pproxin'to d‘te upon whid: you r/ined knowledge tte-t Rnscher was conducting ire o undent ocperixints? A. Ths boginning cr the aiddlu of April, tt 'ny r*to after e-ratur of 19 m2. Q. Th-n fron -bout 11 U rch 1942 to the oikll* of April 1942 yau h ,c run a littL. rer- than ore hundr.d of the two hmv.red cr throo hundred hith altitude Ust? th t ycu were goire; to run in your experiments? A. Of course I cra't tell you exactly, but th-t is wh t I estia.te it to be a-proxicrUly. Q. How army test runs on volunW.r -xperia-ntal subject? had you cocpletod ulwa to your knowl-dg- tt* first *o-.th occurr-' 1 La Rascher's irtepetx^ont jcjx-rSrents ur.’.r RLxiLx uring tlw> letter '-rt of A^ril 19 -21 6SS5- 5 Ur7 Ul -A-lif-2-okp- *‘1°7 (Brown) Court Ko. 1 A. That » the ei* of April. It o^ht h v. b^n « many CB 2C0 roughly, -ri*cnts ttot *d bo.n concLx-od by that tine, t v-n oorc. q. Hew anny tost runs had you coapluW. when to your kncmlug. thu soconl death occurr-d in teacher's indolent o^riaents under tho separate or lor of liiaslor? A. That wra Just at the -cry end of the oeperinenta -bon uu „„ -taoct ttow* . 1 th ttw« and didn't hr.» » «W I»rii».nt» loft . W -oro Jurt 'olng tho lat «t-» ’■* grunt rltttudo*. Q. He. ntf do you think you still hud to do? A . net 1. rury hard to ay, tut youtavo to Ora. - dUtlnotlon botnwon thooo th'-t uould fcr.w boon iono If tho oxporiaont. hr I continued in h MMtlnr "* «•»* Met . did to bring tho o-rlco to -doqu.-.te conolMlor.. It 1. .u-ntfinnUy twntlonod In tho Tuport, lor ox-nplo, ttr.t out of 21 IntooCod u*;v.riuwnt. onljr aw .(» c--rrlo4 out. Cowcouontly you o.-nnot uwlMt. tho oonoluolon. roach..' o. >J1 « if they hat! fc-on cartW out on c great number of persons. Q. 9 ut ycu ’a.'t kno« ho* aany aaru exporiaa-nts or tests you probr.bly h":’ to run after lb- n.cor. I eonth.7 A. If «o had continued at tho aw* «t* ~* - h'd intvn’ed there would have boon another 30 or 40 «re, but sine- tho e>rimont:J. series -as United ttoafter less .xp.rirnts -ore aotonUy carried out before wo roachad the end. Q. Ho., I unlurotrh! thtt vhu weend *»th occur™' on ono toy in 2 -.y rat tho third death occurrod th- n.xt dny, 1. that corr-ct? A. Tea, zn'. that -os r.bout the nidO*> of Slay. Q . Ho. nrny t-rt runo did you oak. or. your *n cap.rlawnt uttor tho third death occurr.d, not ho. neny you h, urlglnnlly Hartod to run, but he* aeny pi actually ran? A. net could only baww b-en ^ry fc-, bcnu. after the third I death th. ch-cabor .ao soon tutau. -*uy, mealy on tho 19th, oo th .t It j right have been anchor 10 . Ton s-id t&s norning that the reason you to* of the dor.th . i 7 5 Ua 7 47 Ualoy (Brora) Court So. 1 of ths aacon! an*. third exporisentol subject in the Roschcr test rJ because of tte fact that upon the a&a: day nnd prior to the deaths you ted Just finished conducting one of ycur own Roabcrg-Easchor expci inonts, is that correct? A. Yes. Q. exactly what data were you recording at tin. ti-x Raschcr was cow!uctin, his uxpcrLxnt in which the second death occurred? A. I don't quite understand the question, »*»t data I had? q. Thio morning yen said that you wore not at the controls at the tlT» tte death occurred to the second eocperiaantal subject, but that you were so^vhero -round tte low pressure chanter writing up your date, because you had Just cccplotcd a test, is that correct? I A. Yes. Q. Sou what ate. uero you writing up? A. After the experiments we wrote down the length of tin*, and tho altitude rn ’ so to sp-ak wu drew tte curve in which tte dSsoents occurred, and then wo entered in the book exactly "hat altitude cor¬ responded to any rrticuL-.r status of the oxporiraenUl subject. Tho altitude was ae ■anr^' by a colucn of quick-silver, while lor the practical evaluation wo had to kn;w» tte exact altitude at which tho o-rson gain-d or lost consciousness. Consequently tte p^gue on tho coliran of quick silver he. to bo translated into terns of 'ltitudo c«! auUrs. That was tte work ttat had to bo or*, after tte uxp..riuont. Q. i.tero wore you doing that work? A. Usually I set in tte roco in tte low pressure etenter whore tho doc«pr.«sion chapter was located. This was a Large truck, like a furniture vac, n ’ there was an ant—rooa, -nd in the civ 1 was a tench r*d a table >dth tho EXG apparatus on it, n sitting on this tench I usually wrote up iy notes, :»d perhaps I referr- g“ln to the quick silver b.aroojtcr if I h-dn't gotten soc*. of the figures. That is why I did this work in tho low xessuro ctenter van, but of course not in the ch-nber itself 6995 5 ILzj a -4-1.-4-pk?- Ifcloy (Brown) Court Ko. 1 Q. An that is where you wore -t the ti--c Enschsr's m>cctu. tor.th a-. tte third t-,th occurred with his ux;riG*nu-1 axbjects? A. Toa. Q. Hon for would you ostiar.te th'.t you wcr* sitting tr* a -.V controls? A. About two or t«o ird : htlf alters. Q. '..ho wma manipulating tha controls st th~ time? A. Rnsco-r T.s ccrryir.g out his own ejtpwiaunts, ar.i consequently aanipuLitod tl* lovers of th- ZKC, nd tto other instruments himsobT, ■hen he tes doing tha ji>rio~nt. Q. '.as thoro aajeno there helping ;*ja't tming? A Yes, by that tio w» had concluded our own experiments. 3 Had you and Raschor Ird any discussion botwe-n tho time of tho conclusion of yeur oxpori-xnts at cloven o'clock -and tho experiments -7-.cn tho socond death occurroci? A So, we certainly did not talk with each other very much. I 6998 5 :ty-l-»B-l5-3-4fauhan (Irrt. Bream) cc'.t" ::c. i. ^arob-bly s-id I was going tc evaluate ay aafcorial tb.rc, but wo did rrt, s I a-id, talk with each ctlur vary nnxh. Q Now, after this death occurred, the second death, hew nany oxpjriants did you conduct cn tho sxvj day after th-t on your own, tho Ruff-Sanborg oxp-riiAjnts? A I b-lievo th-t I c-rricd out no further cxp-ricents on that day. Q What about tho third death? A Th> situation ras sinilrr. I do net knew if tliis rns also in the ..omlng, but I bolt-v- it w-s. To had carried cut our cwn ox- pariants and R'schjr did his subsequently.. Q New, let us ccnsid-r for a aasor.t tho occasion when you witnessed tho death of ono of Rasoher's cxp-riuntal subjects; tho first tLath you say you x-itneesod during tho lattor part of April, 1912j did you know this oxpori^jntrl subject? A No, I did not know hia personally; ho was orv. of Rrschor's ctm subjects. 4 Had ha boon used by R-schor for any other cxp_ri _nts aricr to th't tire? A That I really cannot toll you, I did not know hin, but it is quite possibio that R'aclur had us_d hi: for other ones. Q Had you over sc on hia beforo? A No, I cannot recall that I had. Q Did you knew his nano? A No, I did not knew his n- ». Q Did you know his nationality? A No, I hoard hin spoakir^ and ha speko Goman with Raschor. q Has ho one cf tho ton cr fiftc-n non, who had be-n sc lac tod for tho Ruff-Ronb.rg experiments? / A No, ho certainly was not. Q ' "as h_ one cf tte 6C or 70 innate s who had first voluntocrcd, free, when you h-d selected sere ten r fifteen subjects? C-999 5 ’I'-y-A-?3-25—. -iieshen (Int. Brown) Zovrt So. I. A Tint I cannot soy bjc-.usc I dcn't know wfcothor he was cno Cf th«U Q Shat tin* of d-y did this death happen? A That I cannot say for certain, but I believe th=t it was around noon cr after luncheon. Q Had you conducted any oxpsrixer.ts that day? A Tub, ro had. Q How -any? A I really cannot toll you. At that tlno we had conducted a relatively Largo nueber of oxparinonts, but I really cannot give you prociso figures. Q Did you conduct rny cn that dry after the doath? A Mo, 1-don't boliovo so. Q Do you reaenher vtoothor cr not tho first oxp-rirwntd sub¬ ject who diod, was ^conscious at ths tiio ho was taken fron tho low pressure chaobor? A Mo, when they woro brought out, they wore cortd. nly dead, not sir^ly unocnscious. Q I on talking about tho first rsan. A You conn in our own oxporluonts cr do you noon in Raschor'a oxporirronts. Q I an talking about tho Raschor oxporioints, that first urn ’•ho cai» out of there, whon you say diod; wno ho doad when takon free tho choabor? A Tea, ho certainly was. Ho diod at tho high altitude or during tho doscont. I believe that ho diod while ho was at tho high altitude and died of air onboliaa. * Q Vis that tost suddenly brought to an ond, ?r rr-'s it ccn- a.udea as it would have been if a nan would not have diod? A I don't knew haw long Raschor *:uid havo conductod this ox- K-rl-,ont, had tho -an n;t died. Q rToll, how did you cr Raschor knwr that the ran was dead 700 0 5 Liny-A-rS-lp-5 ban (let. 3nrrm) # Court So. I. while ho via still in the L-w pressure chamber? A I did net pay v^ry cliso attention to this, but Raschor cortainly saw this fren the olcctrc-cardigran and probably -iso fron tho rc-spiraticn cf the subject cad for tint reiser, brought hb dewn fron the high altitude. Q In ether wrrds, those machines would not oporato, they •ould go dead ir. effect because there was nothing to register; is that correct? A What machines do you roan? Q The clectro-cardiogmo. A I did not lock at it vary closely, but if tho ran was dead I assuao thoro would bo nothing to register. Q That is what I on trying tc got at; who took thj first sub¬ ject fron tho chaab^r? A Raechor sent vor to tha narguj and two prisoners cate with a strotchcr and took hii; away. Q Tf.vxa did ho sond to tho norgiu? A Sj far as I kn_w, ho sent .''►off over to the aorgixi. Q Yfns tho re any no olso arouxd thoro «t tho tlmo besides Noff? A No, I don't think so. Q Who was running tho onginos at tho tino? A Tho oontrcls ran throughout tho entire exrcrirwxnt, tho pa:po did not have to bo manipulated, only tho air pressure was regu¬ lated, tho accosa ,-f air to tie chamber and that regulated tho alti¬ tude. 1 I aiderst end. TTas tho nochimic around there at the tiro, 3sbctta, -r ycur unknown ran idle so nice you do not knew? A I really c-nnet toll you vhothor cno af then was in tho ■ick of tho van in tho nachino rc.n* There was another truck noxt to t;io v.n, which contained tho machines; n-w uhothor cno cf then was in v~’rc, then I don't knew. The axe. op.rated, whother senoono was thoro tho tiro or n-t. 7001 5 ::-7-«-?E-15-6^4&ohin (mt. Brcwn) Court Nc. I. Q rfeil, if he was thrro you did n?t sco hie? A No, I cruld net :~vo soon hin because he was insido the van. Q TThen you began your experiments that arming, who started the onginos and who was in charge rf then far the Ruff-Rerberg experi¬ ments?- A In the rcroing, a coco no, usually Sabrtta cr Koff, cane around and sot tho naters in notion# Q Do you roroebor who did it that corning? A No, I don't rctxebar. Q Do y u rerxj.ix-r who was thjro as a nechenic nt tho tiro rf tho second death? A No, I don't. Q At tho tiao f tho third death? A I also cannct ay, it wr.o oertainly one of tho throe, but Just who it vna I dan't know. Q In tho ease of tho second death; who took tho nan out of tho chamber. 7002 CGXT«9, q The .san* is true in regard to the thirl death? A Tee. Q And in »ach oase, it would be Seif, Sobctui, or your unknown rsohaaie, * uan who?j rare you do rot rersesber? A Ufco was at the pu--p, you aeen, or who was rent ovar to the morgue? Q Tee. wh- w;s cent to the morgue in each case. k Tiat raa probably no* Sobotta cr the other, because they wore busy with the uoVra- I, war ircbably Neff or one of the others rho bi'-T/ed t: tn.it .roor. SobottA ini he other man were usually busy, as T ‘fi\. yci.tr. the amjc *>\d motors and didn't run errands an often. q In otter *orda, wmen Rau^her conducted his experiments, be always had Neff there or Sobotte there to run orrax^to or to do thinjo of that sort, uho-.ill it become nocetsa-’, i- tap.* orrect? A frao Meal/./, the yon nr a al/aya e t the st.tion. The room thoy lived in rau only a l'-v. inters frta the rax; so that actually thay were al-rnyr. a-^ilablc ai*« it ou'fio.>d uiu Jy to yell A» oruirt- to *"t one of th* 1 .. q In Other words, if anythin^. ai-culd happen in tha chamber, then a sinju.. y ul would brine Sabottt or Naff or the othe.* rum to the ohaor, tociu;. they lived cr^. a very few i»t«r. fioa wtere the experiments were heir* ccndv.oted. A Tea, they lived close by. Q All of yevr exper'njr.tal subjects livod right there so that you ac»ild have them as jc * meded theta? A Yes, tha-.-s ri ;it. q And .you think that on the occasions of these deaths, if Neff or Sabotta was not at t.» pressure charier ~x at the engine in the van, that ^ .jri-r air ply yelled for sa^or-e in bar-achs *lon e by to *>^e out? A He simply had to leave the van and 30 to the terrc*a »»- a 'd rr v?fco^- wc-ild 3urely come. 7005 5 :iar IT-.- (let; r rc.x) jourt S3. 1 Q And 70U think that is what he did on each of these three occasions? A Ias, that Is what I believe. q Then it was a reasonable thine to as3une that those experimental subjects knew that Rascher was conducting experinent3, as well as yourself, and that he was conducting independent experiments? A They certainly knew that. q And the:.* knewthat sometimes yew were there writing up your data at the sc--* tine that ho ‘.ad bean conducting the experiments? A Yes. q • as there any occasion whan you acted as an experimental subject in the low pressure chamber while Rascher manipulated the controls fron tlie outside? A Yes, that happened several tines. Q •'hen was that? A '.Then I went with the eiperlaor.tal subjects into the chanter for a slow sinlinr deceit, for exanplo from 12,000 or 13,000 kilometres, in order to watch the writing teots that they were doing. Thon FAflcher stayed outsiie and nardpulated tlie charier. I also carried out oxplosivo ■‘sconproesion experiments during rhich I was inside the chanber and Raschor was outside. In the experiment described in the report, the experiments or. sc*self, Rascher was inside tut who was outside, 1 don't Invow, it can't i'jwo beer. Rascher in this case. .1 *"hen you wire inside was there anyone outside with Rasohor, or was ho doing the whole tiling by hir-solf? Ke was outside and took care of the machinery, yes. Q !Jr one ra3 assisting h&B at the tine? * r • A Ho, it wasn't noooesary. q '."hen was this? A I was in several tines. q liars the dates. a I can ft tell you really. I was in there in the beginning, when we 7004 5 'ar : 7-w-«7Z>-i6-3-^r^lr-? or (Int Brcwr.) Court :to. X r&io the experlaents at twelve or thirteen thousand zetres altitude and I was in there at the conclusion and several tires in between, but I car.'t fix tile precise days. q -ere you in there as an experimental subject any tine after you had seen the first, the secoir, or the third experimental subject in the Tlascher experiment die? A Yea — I carried out an e*>crfnent at 19 kilometres, which certainly toofc plaoe after the first fatality — not after the seoond or third fatality, ho.-over. q And no one vaa at the oontrois but Dr* Raacher? A That's riht. Q And you had full confidence in hie at the tino? A I was confinoed tixit in tho experiments that we were carrying on continuously, nothin would happen, and for that reason I wont in as an export: um tel subject* q VTtit would have prevented Raschor from pitting you through tho sane course that ho put tho experimental subject through? A Today I wouldn't so in, now that I know what I know, but at that tin* I had no reason to assume that he wis *;oins to kill no in an jxpcriuor.t, q r he luxd already conduotod ono orierlnant in which, froa your observation tho expariaentfll person would dio, and you remonstrated with hin after that, you wore still idUina to go hick into tho chamber, and Ud go back? A In this experiment, I wasn't ir. a position to say doath must occur. I would, terevor, say it was cfcngorous and that 1 qysolf would have interrupted tho export aont. On tho other hand, tho experiment scheduled was a free fallinc experiment. In tho expert-ment in which I participated, they exactly laid down how high I was to go and hew far I was to fall, t ms ms exardned on account of the experiences coined by the experiments that nothing wild happen and I had no reason to believe that ^ascher >/ould suddenly chan-e the program and change the descent in any way, so that ao mo thine rtrht happen. 7005 5 May U 7 -^-ArD-l 6 -Jj-i'iT^ine ar (Ir.t. 3 toto) Court -fc. 1 1 I 9 Before either of those three deaths occurred, did Easchor show you I an outline of the test upon which ho was about to «±arkT In other words, " as to the first oxporlnent did he have a s teteoent there of the kind of excerinent he was goinj to conduct? A I don't kner -bother ho had one. At any rate, ha didn't shoe it to M. Ho always said that these experiments ad not concern no! that they were orders that he tad reoalYed, and that I shouldn't uorry about then. B 3 ad not lot =. in on that experinont, tat kept no at a a.tanoo. Q And that rraa also trio in rotprd to the nature of the cxparlnonts at the socond doath and at tho third loath? A Yos. 0 ’then was tho first tim that you coiviuctod an o*> ^rlnont after you idtncssod tho doath of too first axperincntcl subjoct in Raschor'B oxporlnonts in April? A rihon, after tt death, did I carry out an «peri=-nt in tho franc vroric of ry own progren, you noon? q Of course, that's what I«n tslkire about, A I oortainly carried out taperinonts on the very next day and than I went to Berlin. I Ain't C o to Berlin on «ta sauo day, but carried on tho axporiconts (Nirthjr until ay departure. q '-hat was your purpoco in goinc to Borlin? A Tho roason was tto doato that had occurred. I told Raschor, hewovor, that I wonted to visit wife who was about to hnvo a child. Q whan did you soo in 3 crlin? A First I went home, saw ay facdly, of course. Then I went out to tho DVL in Adlorshof and sow Ruff, q : 7 hat did you toll hin? A I told hin that in those experiments that Raschor was carrylne cut, ho had had a death yesterday or the day before, that I tad seen fren the olcctrocardiogran that it seened to no aslf the ^arinont should bo interrupted and that I told hin this'. So, however. Ad not Interrupt the 0 7X6 5 Vc-7 li7^%.tMS^Jisila*or (Int. Brora) Court Vok 1 cxncrlaont on =7 sousestion. I told hla that those expcri.ior.ts rero nothin" that I ranted to tare anything to do with. Ruff uca of the sane opinion end re discussed how re could bring those experiments to an end. 7007 5 l-31ahlpy (3r3vn/?o£;ler) Court I Case 1 3- Did 5aff advise you to return to Dachau? -w -e t^llced about that at great length, about how we could best do wh„t we wanted; but we both e«v clearly that we could not •ln-ply tell oascher or Hinkler, for inst^e, th,t a fatality hud sccurred and. consequently tne experiments would have to atop, tout we would have to do would be to bring our ejperiaents to a conclusion and then toJre the cho-ber out and »woy fran Dachau. Saschcr's exoerinental subject died in tha low pressure chuobor la ayril—that's tne first subjoct—I bellevo you sold ho vus taken to tho corgue for the purpose of on autopsy, toore was the uorgue in rolatlon to the location of the low nressure cncnbor? a» One had to go through another barracks and then through a long corridor loading through a ca-*> etroot or a court. &cctly what distance that w.e I don't know precisely now. I cetiuatc th-t it Was avrosluctely a hundred ueters, v* On the d-y on the death, which you s-y occurrod -oout ulddty, 70 U had ca ;>lotod your experiments perhaps ^n hour prior to th_t tluoT -w Yos, wo c^rrlod out er'iorimonts In tho ..oralng. tocn wo wore through, I don't roc~ll exactly. Ihcn tfcat did you dc with your oapcrL-unt JL subjects? hi ay wont back in tho barracks? a. Ivor- ono of our experimental subjects went book to tho billots of tor tho experi .cat was ovor. Ev.t billet was Just eovorJ notors from tho chambor? Yes, that Wasn't f ,r at all. “U toff, Sobott-, -nd yourothcr nan whoso xuciO yoa don't k.«ow lived there? O. Yes, the;- lived there too. How long .ftor the dc^th of tho first subject was it before the autopsy tcok placo? I con hardly tell you th_t exactly; but I should think it 7008 £ >U3*-WP-17-2-31 ^elej (Int. 3rcwn/iuilcr) Court I Caso 1 *os about half ca hour l^tor. 3- lio v _s present? «• caachor, I, and tho ixcates free: the pathological station, nobody else. _ Is tli..t wr...t you would cell tho dissection rocc, the innates of dissoctioc rocc? . Yes; yes, that's right. 3* In other words, thoro wort proscat at tao autepsy you, Haschor, two non free the dissection rocc. Vos 3cff thoro? a. Ko, I don't think so. Yes Sobotte there? a. Ho, I aa sure Sobotta wasn't thcro. Ho had nothing to do with it. 'Jhat w..s actually dooo at tho uutcpcyt It was c norcal autopsy. Iho skull, tho breast, and tho abdcuinrl c..vity wore oponod. Is that all? *. Yos, that W.I a ccuplete autopsy. 2h_t is what is ordinarily deno in an cutopsy. 3. Just open the broast, skull, and tho abdouinal cavity and your autopsy is over? «• First tho breast is opened; then the abdominal cavity is opened; end at tho end tho ckull. Ihon tho individual organs aro rponed, tho heart, lungs, -i is nccoss^xy in tho caso of a norrud autopsy. 1. How, what is tho purpose of all this? Vhy in this particular ease did you want an autopsy? Tew know tho ~an w„s doad, didn't you? 3 were to bo taken t' tho noxt hospital ns quickly J possible. 2 hus thc.prlnciplo of this 7011 5 Xay-*r-v?-17-4-3lGkloy (iat. 3rcvn/=.nlor) Court I Onto 1 bubble.? -v. I cun hardly iii-gino th .t the visible ones wore tho c.use bc- c-uso such visible air bubble* oftc- occur .4 a result of - surgical interference and do net necessarily load to doath. la uy pinion it was a sudd or. control failure caused by perhaps u disturbance of tho blood flow. Hewovor, I Cannot s.y th .t exactly. Do you know of deaths c .used by a ouddoa control failure duo to stOTonfO of tho blood flow? I. th..t a known e-use of death in □cdic 1 circles? a» Z know it now boc.uso of tho exporionco of tho jcoricun air forcot whoa they tried to ox.iilno tho fitness of thoir flyers. In 6 c scs during a prolongod st_y - I think th-t in tvolvo kilouotor oltitudo - a sudd on do_th occurrod; and since there is no physici xx pre¬ sent during these *icrlc..n tests but oaly soue sorgo oat or corporal, I oaly knot; of t .is frou what they s..id. Dut Judging frx; tho ontiro description, they c.amot havo been any other eases of doath, but c ;usod by tuddon cnbolisas. Did know U...t f ci at tho tiao of tho doath of tho Butcher subject? Did you h-vo th..t nodical Knowlodgo? Ho, I only knew th„t now. rhea how c.uld y u disagroo with R.tchcr'a diogn.'sic about tho natter if you didn't have that knowlodgc th .t yra nsv say you have? at th t tine vc only know of tho cor respond lag c-soo frou tho subuariae crows who h_d sufforod frxj similar synpts-s in the ease of rcscuos frou D-bOuts th t hjL been sunk. In tho oa:o way a * nu-oor of death eases -re known frou cxn!brciul .odicino in tho c ..so of c.issoa workers. People liko th_t, whonevor they wore found unctasci us ia tho stroct, > ore always carrying - certificate describing the- cs caisson workers who wero to be taken t-> tho aoxt hesoit .1 at quickly _a possible, xhus the principle of this 7011 5 Ki^jrvB-17-6-dl.Jcloy (lit. grown/iUaler) Court I Case 1 illness ic gcaor.-lly *nown also la coa.ercial uedicine. Veil, it is very aach tse sohe tniag, then, as the c-rd that c diabetic carried, who Ojy t_vc b —c tort of ^ strolco us a result of either l.ch of insulin or insulin shock? Isn't that what you aro trying to generally speaking? — Veil, the purely uodic.i progress is different; but diabetics generally c.xry a certific-te with theu et.ting th~t thoy ..ro suffering fra: diabetes .ad th-t this and that i.oasure would have to be tukon in c.jo of thoir foiling unconscious. l» Vas a writ.cn record cf tho findings of ts-c autopsy of that furet de-th undo by K^schor? ■». Tos, liascher noted down .0.1 the dot- on tho individual doath certificate, had the int«ation of evaluating thou in scuo w^y. Shat is truo ia regard to all throe doatho, I sxqnoso, for tno second and third doaths? You witnessed the autopsies .®d vory auch the s-aio orocoduro w.. 8 followod as ut tho first autopsy? «• Vo, I v. sn't present during tho othor autoosios becauso R-scnor didn't usk uo to attend, .*t th-t ti-.o uy relationship to 3oschor v.-.o olroJly ctralnod boc..use of tho interruption of tho onsrluent*. 7012 5 »7 47-..-£--13-1-2 .11 .ghcr-Int: lirrclop Court ITo. 1 . Did you soo or ro.-d or hasp tlo report or writton record of t!-.o findings on tho nutopay thr.t w.-.a nr.do by hir. In tho cr.ao of tic flrat dor.th, -* . Jto, I did not eco It. -• 3ut you ar.tr kin noting cortr.in no to a. Did ho dia- cuaa with you r.s ono pr of o a aiora.l na would likely do with enotl or rhr.t ho thou^.t ho we. a finding, ca ho redo tho ox\n±n-.ticn? •• ' r oa, he p.jticulfply polntod out tho ir bubbloa ho h*d fount’, raid or.proaaod th t t! o-ght wfcon writing dotm tho findinga. • :Iot; # tton # aof-r r.a thr.t r.vtopcy vr. a ooncemod, whr.t posrlblo uco could bo rvdo of thoco findinga rofr.r c thoy woi'ld * conotltuto infor.-.tion to nodicr.l pooplo who roro uoatod in flying, thr.t ia, in vi ti iicino, or, to pooplo who wore intorortod in th..t typo of rcdicino whoro cn :po o ngr-god in working under wr.tor, or in cr.laaone, under tro -.©ndoua proeauro; vlv.t poaaiblo uco could bo ardo of thoac findings? ... .'oil, I t: in’: tl t ono cov.ld not uao iis notoa very '■dl boc vco a sinculrr c- o of docth, ainco ita e.-.uao if v. ry 1- rd to doternino. Ono ncodc lr.rgo oxp.rionooa, cu.ch r.a cor: orcir.l hygionicta would l*:.vo in t: oir corres¬ ponding field, -ncl if such r. hygionist who ur.a very uo 11 c-yv.intod with t! o cubjoct !;.d boon r.blo to loo!: -t the so findings, I n euro ho would bo r.blo to drr.tr ao:-o conclusions fro;, it. * conclusions do you t ink he cov’d hr.vo drr.ttn? If hu ruuld eoi?r.po tk.t finding with other findings cf cri8Bon dor.th c~aoa , nnd wl ich ..ro known fror. thr.t cr.iacon literature, ho could hr.vo ‘bought tho whole t: ing on t: ° B *P a doneninr.ter. Eonevor, in one individurj. ..-.ro it is 7013 5 K-r 47-A-£*-16-3-Oraii3hor-Int: Under C ourt Ho. 1 very hnrd to drrjr my conclusion. f.. Eon :imy cr.aos could it trJco Dr. Kaachor to roally coiio to --.ny roal conclusion about thr.t nr.ttop? ... Thr.t ic v-ry herd for-t.:o to e r.y, be ecu so I m no oxp-rt in t' is fiold. ..n cxp.rt in tie cr.isaon field dooa not only know of tfco r.ccidonta which ho 1 inaolf hrd wit- no eaod, but ho ia noil acquainted with tfco litorr.fcuro on tho avbjoct, and with findings of other pfcyeicirns, r.rd fror. c.ll thr.t ho draws hia own concluaion. 'I. '..fcet about an exp ort in tho high nltitudo fiolds. If, for oxaaplo, you had r. rocord for r. cr.ao history of fivo- fcundrod dor.the rosuiting under tho eroo conditions r.a thr.t Rr.sober did, end when you perfornod your c.utopuy r.ir bubbles woro found t. rougfcout the blood vossols. Would you fron tb“t bo r.blo to £;r.in r. cortr.in knowlodso thr.t would bo vr.lur.blo in fly in-? In tho ontiro litorrturo r.bout eviction iiodicino, I know of r.o cr.ao whore r.ir bubble* h.d boon doecribod. Thr.t ia probably bocr.uao durinc on r.ir r.ccidont r. conaidur. bio tine pr.secs until r.n autopsy ic nrdo posciblo. In addition tho bodies or corpse a in tho c r.so of on r.ir r.ocidont nro usur.lly raitildtod, ao th.t aviation nedioino hr.a no proot¬ le .1 finding, -'-t r.ny rr.to, I ’-now of nono in Gorrtony. Tl’on tho only way you would bo r.blo to dotorriino finding a would bo if thoro h:d boon or to bo r. series of • oxporinor.tc in which you hod uaod oxporincntr.l subjocts, in which tho ::en woro subjected to ecuo oxporir.onts trfr.t 3r.acr.cr subjoctod then to, conducted over r. rp? or.t period of tirio, w ith r. great rimy run, end, if considorr.blo r.id in eviction rjodicino, rout it not? Th: t is not quite correct. Ccrtr.inly in order tc clar¬ ify tfco. findings, or.o ought to fc-.vo the possibility to 7014 5 Kr.y 47-..-sr-lS-S-Sr.lIr.sfcor-Int: Hcnloz Court :>o. 1 pcrfom r.utopsica on r. nunbcr of corpsos ir.dcr auitr.blo conditions. 2 - t quostion itsolf, however, bor.rs no inter¬ net for r.vi .tion r:od'.cino. Cr.sos of don th hrd not boon obeorvod on hmd witi ..in bubblos, r.nd thcro wr.e no ror.son to do thr.t. Ihoro wr.a no ro..son to r.aeuno thr.t t: is condit¬ ion h~d plr.yod my rolo in cr.soe of dor.th. This wr.a r. fiold which vr.s r.lion to r.vir.tion :icdicino rosorreh. Horovor r.licn, this cm bo soon fror. tho fr.ct tJ r.t ..1thouch I sr.r ono such cr.so by r.ccidont, I novor e.gnin dor.lt with tho question. I night , howo*or, for ir.str.nco, hr.vo dono tho or. :c t: inc, ue g r.nlr.ls r.s or.porincntr .1 subjects, if I h d fc\d r.ny prr.ctio.'.l intoroat in thr.t fiold, or hrd onpootod nay benefit. This is proccduro tl t doos • not nr.tt^r ;.t fill, "or thr.t ror.eon thoro wr.a no intoroat in cTrying out lr.rgor nuribor of oxp-rlaanta. • I boliovo you sr.id in your tostinony Pridr.y tl.r.t you of r.t lor.et two or throo of tho non conr.octod with thu oxpuriaonta who voi*u rooora-.ondod for lonioncy, or cor: ut..tion for t: «ir crir.inr.l sontoncoc bocr.uso of thoir i rticip tion in t: o onperir-onta. ho woro thoco two or throo non? -• Ho, I only ’.now xii .t c.n soon Cron tho docunonta horo. Sobotor. 1 d boon p. rdonod by thoao pocplo. In '.dditicn to th:.t, tic two inn., to a in tho dissection roori h d been offered, or rocorviondod for sc::o sort of lonioncy, Ir th..fc whr.t is sh-oi/n hero by tho docun nts; ‘-roco r.ro t; o two or three r.un you roferrod to? - I found thr.t out her- on tho v r.rie of docuxmts. -vt oxcopt whr.t you found out on tho br.als of the so locunonta, would you 'mew f r.t rr.ybody wr.r rocorr.ended for 1-nioncy? 7015 5 :s.~ 47-. -S--I3-4-r-.il -cr-r-Int: R-nlor Court ITo. 1 ... 'To, I cm only ropor.t vl.r.t I hr.vo r.lro.dy sr.id, thr.t • • this h-d 'ivuii proniacd to those persons :.t t’-.o outsot. ELsil-r undo noro prouiaoe to tl on v;hon ho visited tho ..nd rope..ted t - v-v-rr s-.-.o thing, wfcon I roported to kin, s^aoly, tlv t tkoeo pcoplo troro to bo rolonsod. Basel: or .’.Iso edneornod hirrsolf with working on tloso rol-r.aoa, ol-.t -.ctu-.l work 1 -r.d boon done, nd to v/lv.t or.- tunt Kii-.J-or did not koop lila prord.ee, I don't know. I. Dut jo fr ; s you .\rc ccncorncd, you .vdo no rocou- nondr.tiona? A. IIo, I could not do thr.t. '. bon did you trJJc with i.-r:l„r? ... Ij^lnr.inc or lidla of fuly 1942. h t ..bout* • . I nlre dy : ontlonod t: .t nr.se’. or auddonly tolo- phonod no in lorlin, nd told i.o t: ;.t both of ua voro to roport to Eiiv.l.r; tl-.t wo \ oro to lor.vo thr.t vory a.-io nigl t. Sle-p-r tioketa v.oro ulrordy prop..rod. Thon ti e nonfc ovoninj v:o ropertod to l.L. ..bout those o::por- t~n;s on tie br.eia of r. typowritton roport, vrMoh thon wr.e ..lrordy f ini shod. b dry true thr.t; r.ll you iaiow is in July sonotino? A. 17c 11, . o Ian: fron the docurxmts, it rx.y bo, troll, boforo tl o 14th or 13th. of July, bocr.uso R. achor rofors to t* tt d .y in spor-king .bout tho roport to Hirs'.lor. It is poaciblo th t it w..c fcl .t dry , otle rviso, I could not I vo ronoriborod tl.o d:.to oxuctly. .. Tut ..t tiho ti. o of tl ^ confer^nco, you r.nd Hr.sehor ucrc tl ero tog^-tl or witL Mrrilor, risking rn orrly roport on tl u roaults of your orcporiconta? ... Yea. n .. At thr.t tlr.o did Hr. scl u r r.lso rrlro a roport on his 7016 £ 47-.,-S'.'-lC-3-C. 11. ! er-Ir t: Ih-dor C<-ur t iro. 1 0 * * / oxpurinonts? ... ho, t ceny rr.to, those orrporinonts vc.ro not : t r.ll Jcucfcod on in r$- prosonco, ho spoko to hi: ..lor onco r.oro t: o no::t c.crnin^, nd~ it is possible tl .t on occ:.s:.cn of s; ic conforonco ho enid so.ro thing -o kin r.bout th .t. ..t ;.ny r .to vo only d iecr.es od o.' wri*:onts of persons roecuod frou high r.ltitudo, rend n .-l-r a .id tlv.t Ooorin^ w;.a to bo Infcr.ied .bout tho results of tl is oxpcrL.ont ..s quickly : 3 poasibis, 0 # . In your prosonco I!irv:l«r -do no rof-ronco to P.r.ocl or is oreporiuonta? ... Jo, nothing r - t 11 I 3 a “ id -bout it. r .. ..nd Rrcschgr errdo no :-r.tion to Himlor of H:.sohor*s o:cp ri;x»r.tr? A. i’o • n .. -fton:nrds did you *. ..vo r. confuronoo with Oooring, or • ^ roportod to Oo-ring on t!.o subjoct of your oxpuririont s? ... ho. Ilira rl^r rr.5d during tl t ccnforonco t’.. t tho ro suite we i'o of oxtrono inport.'.nco, r.nd t] .t vo woro to report tlx. to 3c-rin,~, ci’ porsiblo. Kovov-r, t*. ..t did not : .turi..li_o, nd I ;.cr.*;co t’..t tho roport wh.ioh vrr.s to t..ko pic.co r.t !lilch*r pi .co, u‘. ich r.lso did not trlro plf.co, ur.s to hr. vo boon tho substitute for tho plrnnod report to Joorir.^. ..c c..n bo coon fro::: tho docvrxmt, Rr.sohur obviously herd boon v..ry interested^ and* r.lvr.ye ho turned to either Ilir_:l>r or 3rr.ndt whether tho roport would bo r_.do, obviously boc-.uco of his porsonr.l r. nbition tie. t it vers of r ror.t vr«luo to roport to Oooring or mich. 5 :£y UWHtfM9-a-asyaoa (Int. Raasnier) Court So. 1, Case I Q You rreant Yarl Srendt or Rudolf Brandt? A I so an Rudolf Brandt. ?hs letters wore always addressed to Rudolf Brandt. Q After the borooetor-and low pressure charbor wasbrokon by Hoff, I believe you said that you had it replaced, ^fhon was it brokon? I havo forgotten. A According to ay nmoiy, that was at the -nd of April. I was in Berlin and then returned. Then the baroaetor '.fas suddenly broken. I took that brokon baronotcr back to Berlin to hare it repaired. Q And when was the low rossuro chamber again In working ordor? A I can not toll you that .xactiy, but 1 should say that it was on tho 10 th or 12 th of "ay, or soaor/hero around there* Q How nary tests woro undo’in the Ruff-Rcribarg expjrirwmto after that? A After the roturb? Q And after the lew prossuro chaabor had again bn put in working ordor. * A Yos. Perhaps about 50. '-oil, I don't thLnk that thoro woro so mny as that. I can't give you tho exact figure. 1 think thoro woro a littlo loss than 50. Q Haw -any tests die.’ Raaobor conduct after that, to your knoifloigo? A 7oll, I oan only rcuabar tho days when I was pres on t. Thon thoro oro about throo or. one day, and a sir'll‘.r nunbor on tho next day, I don't know exactly what he di*', booanso ho nay h-.vo worked nights or overlings. Bowaany deaths occurrod in Rascher's oxp>.rinjntal subjects after tho repair of tto low pressure ohanbar? A Tho two oases of doath which I ha to already contionod. * Q Hew, then, as I understand it, you fina l l y aado a report on tho Roff-ftor-iborg-Ra3 chor axporirxmta? A Yes. Q That appears bore in tho Prosocution docunont book? .» Yos, that is that report. 7018 f 5 *fcr U 7 ^-ATM 9 - 2 -Bayncs (lot. gran l er ) Court !fc. 1, Case I q .^nd that was compiled and your ooaol u sloos wurs drown.and your raco~undations woro aide or. the basis of certain research data aado at Dachau; is that correct? A The report was nod* on tho basis of ry record about tho expori- nonts. In thet report, certain rocorreondations are nado for the future dcvclcpnent. Q bocane of those records which you nado the basis for this roport which is hero in cvidcnco? A 1$ record, you uoan? Q Vhatovor rocards you used. A I den* t knew what happened to it finally. It was in Berlin in tho safe, .’hethcr thoso records were destroyed, toeothor \&th all tho other socrot flics when tho Fcussians oano to Adlorshof or whether tho Russians havo rcr.ovod thoso files, I dor.*t know, booauso I irsnot with tho D7L ct tho ond of tho war. I think that Ruff would probably know • about that. That is to say, if ho rcrxr.bers what the records wore that - • I woro doatroyod whon tho Russians narchod into Borlin. Q !Jow, as I undorstand it, ycu are unablo to say what tho naaos of your ton to fifteen axp-ri:cental subjoots woro, what their nationalities * woro, or for wfet purposo thoy had boon incarooratad at Dachau? You say you don*t raoollect that? .. Yes, I 4>nt rux bar all the natvsof tho individual pooplo, as I alroa-V said. That all of thca woro Ooman I know exactly booauso I spoko to then. They wore tho broen badge of the professional erininals, and thoy also told no rhy they woro there, ftiy ovary individual was there and' what his none was, of course, is difficult*to say. q Do you rcrur:bcr any of the nanus? A Apart fron the four whoa I -ntioned yesterday I do not raa-rbar any. . . Q Tfhat four? A Sobotta, Klos, Rocki^or, and Zoslalr. d iieff, Sobotta — 7 CIS 5 lb 7 U7-A-^TD-l>-3-S^o3 (Int. Handler) Coirt llo. 1, Case I A I didn't nontion "off. 3 But thoro was thoro *"s Sobotta, and who was too next ono? A Rockingor. 3 Haw do yai spoil that? A RrO-C-X-I-H-G-3-R* Q Anti who was the fourth ono? A SLos, X-L-O-S. Q Do you roraj-'-bor oru aoro? A Zoslak, Z-0-S-Z^-K, or C-Sj I*a not suro which. q -Thoro wasRockirsar fraa? A I car.* t toll you that. I ;bn't know whoro ho was fro:’.. Q \fharo was &os fron? A I roally cton't knot vhoro thoy all caias fron. I think that ono of them aa=o fron vrostorn Gomany, but I raally can't tell you that with any anount of caaotitudo* Q "hero did ZoslrJc cono fra".? „ i oar.'t toll you that oithor. I don't kno where ho orou fron. I bollcro ho eauo fron Silosia, but 3 roally don't know that exactly. 1 Those w.jro ell Oormn nationals who wore crininal prisonor3 who 'cr.d bc-n condcnad to doath and -rho had volunteered for tho uxporirvonts? A they wore not OjRtonood to doath, tut they r-oro sontanood to prorontivo custom, bocauao of their rop.atod crircs as professional crinirvils* q Do you know tho nanos of th. two inaatos of tho r'lsa action roots who wero prerisod lonioncy or recorrvjndod for leniency? ' as that I-CLos and Zoslak? A ’to, 1 really don't know their nanos. IKE mESnEHT* questions of the witness on the ..art of Dofonso Connsal? : 5 J. B.prjy* lour Honor, I had assuaod that Defense Counsol had finishod re iireot ox animation. 7020 5 "~y i7^-ATD^94-Hayr.as (Int. feeler) Court No. 1, Casa I TJC PR3SIDENT: Defense Counsel has, but tiny my anr.rd.no too witruss on too testix^ony that IcabooR put in since that tine. This axanination, Counsel, -ill bo lid tod to th:- questions pro¬ pounded to the witness -after tho Do fans a had r os tod. DT. S..U1ER* Certainly, ?!r. President. Dr. Saitor, Counsel for tho defendants' 3lone and Ruff. 31 DP* S.VJTERl 1 iltnoas, taring your present acardnntion, you wore tolling us .-.bout a prisoner at !>aohau who had boon arrested and put into Daohau boonuse ho had donounood saw undartnkins of tho SS. You know when I anon? A Yoe, to-.t was Moff. q ’.fho wr.s it? A "off. 0 Ho was a political prisoner, was hj not? A I os. q ’"hat badge did this !Ioff wear? A Ko wore a rod badge. q A rod brdgo. ' as "off also used for oxp.rlner.ts? A !Ioff, as I already said, -artidpetod in oxporinonts hinsoif booauao ho voluntoorod for thu;, ar. 1 on his own initiative ho partici¬ pated in those oxpjrir.--19-S-Haynos (mt* 3 a. -r i or ) Court to, I| Ccso I q I asstoa that when you oanc to Dachau, you had to report at tho gatoj Is ttat rt-ht? A Too, I had a pass which I had to show there. Q Could you then walk aleno to those barracks, or were you acocrtpaniod by a guard? A Afterwards I was allowed to go there ryself, but at tho voiy boginnijr; a guard of tho SS aooonpaniod no. It said on tho pass that I tad to go fron Onto I or sens thing like that up to Block 5, and it also said that I had to uso the shortest ray to that block. This is oustoia-.ry in the or.so of official buildings in Gemary. '•'hen one ;.oos to c certain office, ore had always to choose tho shortest way, q Tltnocs, is it correct that you woro exprossly ordered not to spook to any one froa tta gato to the barracks exoopt to oxperiuntal subjoota? A I haro alroacV that I was obliged net to opoak to any of the irr-.-.tes and to stay only at thoso places whore ny prosonoo was officially nucossary, and I tad to si^n a pap^r to that uffoot. Thoro woro limitations upon ry froodon, and uary witnesses have conflr.-od that, q :tow, if I un.’ars tan-1 you ocrrootly, you ooull lo-.rn about tho conditions as they prov.ilod ir. tho concentration oanp only by listening to what tho -xp-rir-ontal subjects or tho C-pos or p rhnps Raschcr had told you. Other lrratos, or. tha other hand, oculd not toll you anything is that ri^ht? .. Ios. Do you :»an I'off whon you say Capo? q Yds. A •'oil, Hoff certainly was not a Capo. I ‘on't knr- axaotl/what a C-po is, but I think he holds a hi'h rank aron- innatos. Court 1 Key S-ji-J^-l-HD-Soxsie-Rcnmler. i. „t r.ny race other instates o:' the cr.ap could not tall you anything about the conditions and the method that ?rev«iled in the c^np? *. Ko. Haturally I only spoke to Keff end ay own erperlment'l subjects. You were asked vhr.t you spoke to these experimental subjects about, and you rnswered that by way of telo?.u>ne always -• naged to eperk to them. You wore outside the chamber, and the experiment*1 subjects were Inside the chamber, and you were able to sneak by way of telephone? a. Yes. i. Veil, I assume now that In particular after the o malesIon of any single experiment you hi-d roper.tod vp ortunlty to converse closely with tho experimental, subject. In particular I am vondsrln e whether y.u didn't discuss with the experimental subject oftor the conclusion of the experiment vnrt tr.e subject oxp-rlor.ced during t.ie -xporlscnts, whether he suffered any p.-ln, whvtr.er he suffered any dlcslnoss, or wnether the oars h-d hoard, 'nd then on the occasl.n of these conversations, you were r.ot at all controlled by the S3 sen, and tner-fore were In n oosltlon to specie quite freely with tr.oso exporl .ontal subjects, inoludln-, prlvrte conditions. a. li-turally seen conversations wore not o.ntr llod, unless, of course, R-6cher w-s present, b>it ho wns not "lwnys present. Then, of course, I co Id speck to thc-i., out I must say that even or. the occasion of tr.oso conversations I never heard any det'lls "bout the concen¬ tration craps, p rtlcul rly details rs I know them now. I cannot ia'glno that anything like :h-t h; d h opened '•t that time In Jnohau. I am sure that they vottld fcc.vu told t t once In a while. It ary well be, of course, th-t 7023 Court 1 Kay 5-A-20-2-HD-nox8ie-HanaLer. ir, principle they didn't discuss such natters. I would rather believe though that t.-cy didn’t tell c. anything of that r.-ture because they didn't have any such experiences themselves. d. doctor, whenever you conversed with the experi¬ mental subjects rfter any experiment, I assume you attached particular v-luo to whether any p'in hrd ori6en during the experiments with the experimental subjects, is that riaht? *i. Wall not quite, because wc Knew that during hlgh-altitude alchn-sa they couldn’t suffer any complaint. It Is well Known that in the c-urso of hl t h-nltltudo sicK.noso the experiment is completely foreign to tho person undergoing it ~o if ho was under on rnoathotlc, the anno way that a person isn’t rxaKod of ter on anesthetic whether ho felt some thing because it ia Known he Oouldn't feal anything. But| Dcotcr, one does Know, ~nd we layman also -.now It, that preceding unconsciousness there a a oortaln it go whore one d^oo feel soaet lng beocuso one still does rctrln n oort-ln amount of oonsol.usnoes, and r.l6o zb a layman one inova tr.ero is o certain stage nfts,r awakening fr a unconsciousness where one dooa feel aoaot.iln^. I an Interest-d t > Kn-w whether before tho bo b lnnln a of jr.c.nsciyusness and rft.r this atnte dleccpo'rod the experimental subjects coaplr.lnud b.ut •* pain, for instance, “b ut pains w.lca rose ip to tho point of jnc-nscl-u^pose ,r rb.ut certain aft.r-effects rfter unconsciousness. Ih't is what I cm lnt-rest^a to Kn^w, especially did they h~yo my p-'lns, did they c molair. o- nv p'-lns b_f ld you at that tlao when h"kln b the acquaintance of Rasohor know, or did you na uao th*t Rnecher h-d already onrrled out the experiments with a low-preaaure ohaaber ?t an earlier date? a. Naturally he s-ld that he had worked In the field of ?vrlatl.n aodlolne. •’ith the low-preaaure om abor? a. Yes. «r.d in tr.ia document wnloh I Just aentlonod, '1302, the letter by R?acher to Himmler, the word 'low-pressure camber" la not at rll mentioned. Rracher la speaking of experiments, end he raka the Reicnsfuenrer Hinder for a number of profession? 1 crlaln-la for theec experiments. However, he does n t mention r low-preaaure chamber. 7025 C art 1 .. y 5_rt-20-4-HD-aj^8la-RaB=ler. "itneas, I v all lli- tv draw y ar attention to the t-'ot t _ t in t.'.ia decent Rnscher is vritin t , or.d I quote,: ■The exs.riaents are v_ry dangerous. 9 Teen In .n.ther passage he writes, and I quote rgr.in, “ixo^riaents ir. which experimental subjects aoy, of course die." «nd than there ia » tnird pcss:' e e where it erys, and I vJote, "Inac.ne :a. ;lo cm lsv oe us„d ce expcriaentrl actorlr.l. n These threo sentences ire not correct if wo 'ss-ce the testimony of the defendant Dr. Raff hero t. be correct, an- thOBe sentences cm neither be correct if your own testimony should bo t'ker. re being correct. 3oty of you hrve testified here th"t the oxcorlaonta do not incur any dan Q er whenever they "re orderly performed, -n. I ra now epeailng t f cne high-altltude experinents >f Ruff-ml Rocb~r a . Ruff hrs told us tnrt lnsme ae-ile c-.uld not ee us~d beo use of well inown reasons. *r.d in spite of that R^ oher la steting these three sentenced which I Just reed. C-n you explain th t in ny wey? HR. KaAOY: hay it please your Honors, I stranously object to any farther questlonln a Ion* these linos by Dr. o'Jter. He .v.e rsied this vltn.J6s on the witness stmd whether or net those experiments wera a Inful, Just what the aubjects endured dur the c urae of these experiments, rnd the witness hrs -nswered him. .‘hct more car. he do? TE2 PRESIDENT: I thiiu the quescion is proper. The witness mry answer. 3. (By Dr. Sautcr) How, 'itness, I wrs putting three n-ir.t? to you t~men frun Rrscher'e letter, wh a you et th c time designate ns an expert in this field, .-.ere ao is Iryir.j dpwr. three sentences which do not correspond 7026 Court 1 Hey &^A-20-5-H3-Hox*l:—3a^aler. with your end Dr. Ruff's testi-ony. Hov can you explain that? a. This 1-tter bears cn earl, date, kny, 19-*1, and ^bvi.ual” It la the 'outcome of c soont-n^oua Idea on the part of Rnscher. He vc6 on lspulelvc han, and iai-odletoly sent a letter to Slmaler vltx*. th/'t oontonta. The fret that ho 8pork6 about the dangerous r.6pect v uld not bo conspicuous In Its aelf. I think th : yr.onavar one rsakae r demand to tr.o competent aupre'*- authority to c lve their por.r.l66i.n f«r auen oxr-flaer.ts to oe carried out on prisoners, It is .acre a sole to oxn-eorate rctaor than -lnlalzc In oaso •oa«thine should happen to the exherlaentrl eubjeot. In t 1 b case one hae nothin* to r-proach to onosolr, In cnoo aoaet/ilng should happen. I don't think that this sontenoo la c.neplouous, nnd one could.even nssuno It to be retuer oonelble of hlo not to a*'/ th-t he la sur. n-.tr.lng will h'o-.en but to a-y that people any die. To wh«t extent ho was -lro.'dy viewing Bone concrete pl"n f,r hie own cxporl- nanta I cannot a-y. Howev«r, I don't think that hv already had any pl^na at this o-rly dote. I can hardly lcailna It. % How do you exolalr. the third sentence ab.ut the In¬ sane? Accordlno to yv-xr opinion such a sentence coald not bo undoreto d -*11 oe being uttered by an exp.rt. a Well, both of us alro"dy testified that lr.6nno people c.-ld In n cnee be ueod for vur ejperiaents. Whether he rlready had a ie special experi.c.«ta lr. air.d nr.d wne planning :hcn, weleh were perhaps to be carried /ut with Insane people, ' oanr.-t aay of c >urae. * Dr. R-=b,r e , y u ere.here starting a trend f th ught i3fc 1 didn't veu-.t to aentiort b. f rc, In order not to be "Caused of outting r lending question to y u, but you 5 avo er -esalon b the th ught which I rers nelly had lr. elnd. 7027 5 UByw.-DJG-2>6-Hoxsie (Iimler) Court Ik.. 1 It is correct, end I en sure tfcct ycu ccnfiru it hcccuse *e already heard it, that ir. addition tc high-altitude cxperi.-*u te, Dr. Kascher nas car;yin- out ether experiments. That is a vell-knari fact here, is it ret? Kc», could it pcssiblyhe assumed thet thc^c t'.ircc sentences which I Just read to ycu, (a) clout the -’.pngorcusness of tl it experiments; (b) about the possibility of the death of any experiment! L subject; (c) ebcut the possibility tc uso insane people, that thcao :t »t-c -an could be intoiv % pretod as cpplicatle to the cthor expvrinu.ts whit i 1 a oh if -vp carrying out in addition tc ycur hlgb-eltltudc experiments, hx 8h -oro fer tho purpose of rescue frea hirh rltituit. Cculd net these .'entances bo applied there? n Certainly fer thoc xpe: L^nts he co ill have us> i». ino 0 persons because there vra nc r-r t cooperation c.ccossory on the jv rt of the experimental subject. 7025 5 !fev-»-DJG-21-l-Cooic (/adsr) Court Sc. 1 * C. *hcn you probably also "ill confirm that these ether experi¬ ments of nascher, the experiments he cairiod cut on his cnr. iniotivc were auch core dangerous because people actually died. .'Jew if you cnee core recall that letter cf Dr. Heat erg, is it ycur opinion that Rascher in the case cf this letter, dated 15 -ley 1911, which was long befere ycur experiments, perhaps did not at ell think about the high altitude experiments of Ruff and Rcoberg but was thinking of his cwn experiments', or ere ycu not cf that opinion? A hell I an sure he lid net think cf cur high altitude -xp-ri- nents because this whs r. very special subject which r-suited fr:n our spedcl field cf activity at the DVL. :Jeturally this ».;■ net something which was not cccossi'-le to cyery cr.u in aviation medicine He certainly did net think cf that. To what wXt-nt he ct that tine w:s already planning the ojqjerimenta thich he carried cut a year 1' ter is, of course, very difficult to say. Q lie* sea-thin, else. Dr. Rcoberg. IHZ HJiSlDS»T: The Tribunal will new bo in recess until nine-thirty tcrxrrcw acming. (The Tribunal rocoss-t rt 1535 hours.) 7029 cM-ay-M- J-5-1 4 2-l-K’jr'v(^u:-l. r) Court Ho. 1. omclTl Transcript of tho^orlcan Military Tribunal In the matter of thu Unite! Statos of America against Karl Branit, ct al, ie- fendants, sitting at Hamburg, Germany, on 6 Kay 194?, 109*0. Justice Be -Is presiding. THS KaESH^L: Persons in the court room will please fini their seats. Thu Honorable, the Judges of Military Tribunal I. Military Tribunal I Is now In session. Qci 6avo the Unite! states of .turlc-i an! this honorable Tribunal. There will bo crier In the court. THS PHiSIOitir: Mr. Marshal, will y->u asoortaln If the defendants are all present In court? THS ILASlLd*: Hay it please Your Honor, all lefen- lants are present In the court. THS PR23IDSNT: The Secratary Gonjral will note for the reesri the pr-jsence of all the lofon lante In oourt. Tho Tribunal has another question to propound to the witness. H.*td aOHBiaO - He suae!. SXoMIZ^TIOH. 3Y JUDOS SORING: q. Drt. Romberg, we wore speaking yesterday about the experiments or tests that were conluoted by Dr. Rascher an! you say that those tests or experiments were under a separate order from Himmlor fcnl had nothing to do with the Ruff-Romberg experiments. How many tests ill you sec Rascher make, either while you were pr~30nt from the middle of .»pril approximately the time that I knew ab^ut these he told me abcut them — he experimental or were lr. the proximity of tho low prossuro 70 *0 6 Hny-H-GZS-l a 3-1-Karrov (Racier) Court No. 1. often, referring to the clarification of questions, but these exporlaents did not ini to any fatal cases. ft. I understand that, but how cany such tests would you thin* that he ran froa the r.ii.ilo of dprll on, at least while you wore there. 70-»0a 6 Hay-:*-GHS-l & 2-2-£arrcw (Raminr) Court Sc. I. X I saw directly cyself or, at least, I was in his proxirdiy when he exporinantod daily or alaost daily. It is very difficult for no to estiate the r.urber of experirents because I didn't page any parti¬ cular attention to then at the tire. I an sure, however, that botwoon fifty and one hundred experiments wore carried out. Q That is, from the .addle of April until you left them? A Yes. Q Thank you. THE KISSIDSi.Ts Has counsel for defendant Ruff any furtbor quoationa to propound to the witness? A Ho. THE fR2S.DS.vrt Docs any other defense counsel have any questions to propound to the witness. Ccunsol for tho dofo:>dant uay propound questions to tho witnoai if tho answers givon to tho questions fro-, pounded to tho defendant by tho Court affect his client. Arc thoro any other questions? DR. V&BIZRK (Dofenso couitaol for do fondant Roaterg): Dr. Rotator g you replied yostordiy to a quostion of Jud<-c Sobring to tho of feet that, boforo tho bo ginning of tho Dacliav. ojqxjriamts, siailar experiments on tho on.-?o subject wore already carried out by you in Adicr3naf during which you used sovon oxp«rlao:ital subjects, who wore numbers of your Instituto at Adlorshof. You further said that those experiments oxt-andod over a period of approxir-atoly four months and that, during those four -.aonths, approxiswt-1y two hundred such experiments wore errriod out, during which you reached an altitude of S'.vontoen kilodetors. A Yes, that's ri^SA. Ti.osc •••ore tho explosive decompression exporinonts. q Did tho experinontal subjects that you used there -xorciso enf¬ etter activity but being oxreri»nt 1 subjects. A 1’aturally, and that was tho difficulty with our work. That was orjj of the r-ascns why vo acc-,Ajd tho of for at Dachau. All those 6 Hay-M-KJS-lia-^-jf ,rrov-(RH=lor)-.S Court :;o. i. pvir* ns had their nerval Jobs to do. Ruff was the head of the Institute. I had my cwn activity to fulfill and that vis the case with every one else too. The experim¬ ents vere contlunuing during our time cf duty. At the same time, another difficulty arose because of the fact that Vd couldn't concentrate on one series of ex¬ periments for any long period of time but whenever good flying weather came about we had to carry out a number of experiments in airplanes for several days running, •fnen there was oad weather, we concentrated our worfc on the low pressure chamber and the oonSrlfugal chamber. Q. w.re other experiments but these two hundred altitude experiments carried out with these experimen¬ tal aubjoot? Yes. certainly. a. Mr. President, I have no further questions. TH£ PRJdlD^T: Counsel for prosecution may cross- examine. AmCROdS-mA-eil NATION. 3Y JR. K «RDY: Cl May it please Your Honors. Dr. Romberg will you kindly explain to the Tribunal, in Gorman medical terms, Just what a pathologist is and what hla duties are? A. ^ pathologist is a physician who has special¬ ized in the changes which -are caused by illnesses in the human body and which are determined after death has occurred. To examine these matters carefully is the task of the pathologist. Q. Then, in order to examine these natters, is it necessary for him to perform autopsies? Yes, in order tc examine these matters he has to carry out an autopsy. 70^2 6 Kay“±*-GR^-l&2-7-Xarrov(Rannlor). Court No. 1. Q. I h* v< 3 no further questions. Your Honor. DR. VOR SRX: I have no further questions, Mr. President, ,nd this concludes the evidence or. behalf of the defendant Dr. Romberg. With the approval of the Hioh Tribunal, I should like to reserve the right to submit a number of affidavits which nay arrive in the future. 70’ 2 a : ._v -:XES-l h 2-1-Karrear (P.rjOcr) Court Ifc. 1 ^dSIDHtt: Counsel nay subait affidavits --hen the;* arc in pr.prr - r-ito b»- sub; it ted to the Tribunal before the close of t!» ease. Defendant Eoriberg rill r-sunc his piece in the d;ck. The Tribunal rill n*r proceed - ith the caso against tho defendant TToltl. DM. IL1£ (Defense Counsel far defendant "oltz)i President, rith the approval of tho High Tribunal, I c all start tc suteiit ovidonco on behalf of the defendant Tbits, I nay p_rhap3 point :ut tho subject of :y evidcnco. Tho indictijont d.cs not charge Profoasor *'cltz to have participated personally and directly in the Dachau cxporln-nts c rvuctcd by Dr, Raachcr, The Prosecution docs charge, hwrover, that participated in tho wrk and is co-r-spcnsiblo for tho work of Hasch-r, Ho. berg, and Ruff by jiving the inventivo for those exper¬ iments and, for that roas'n, rould also have to bear responsibility f r the o:rjcri -ntc. Th. prosecution a*so believes to have boro points rojardin . freoring and cans piracy Tith rhich to char go hii.:, with ut giving furth-r partic Lars. I sh uld like ta ask y.u that I RSittod tc subnit ry -.cqucnco: At first, I should like t ask th- Tribunal V- ;xr it u. t* call the dofondant ’.'cits pers nail;* int th- vitnooo stand. In addition, the .nvcocuti^n has appreVv-d that the -.-itfwss Dr. .‘on t fr .. Karlsruho be penitted t t-stify ho re. ~cndt Is th. f r.~r assistant of Pr-fessor Tolf.. furthermore, in rder t- rub.it proof, I '.eve 3ub.itted tue decua nt books t aho Tribunal, including t-enty-fr.-o C cun.nts. Th.se d.cu- n-.ata c ntain, -.or oth-rs, the affidavits by eleven -.ritnossos, u stly c--- rkcra cr pr-fessicnal ocll-nju^s cf Profess-r Cits. D-fer- I start the direct examination of tho defendant, I shall road an affidavit f Dr. “erner Eaatho .at "-rlsruh.. Reading this affidavit ‘ill -Zx if unnecessary f-r a. to ask the defendant about vari us phases cf his professional life and “ill, therefore, contribute tc- ■arc's th, shortening f tho prcco.dir._r, Jranr handing t; Jso 7033 6 ay-h-«jDS-iCarrGW-(Rasclor)- Court Ho. 1 ‘rlfcu n a l the document Weltz ?li*, which I shall designate as Exhibit *1. I shall only read this document where Professor no the mentions the professional life of rofessor Weltz. *rofessor Knothe was the President of the u tmn X-Ray Association and, for that reason, i3 a person well in a position to giv^ a characterisation of the d^fencar.t Welts. I quote: \ " Georg August Wcltz ranks among the first X-Ray scientists of Germany; his works, particularly on X-Ray physiology, have been reco¬ gnized at hccc- and abroad to the sane extent, and have communicated principles which will nur«r lose their value. Wcltz holds a leading position in the lirld of gastrc-intcstinal iymograpty, jnd the d^volop- ment of hymography can n^v v r mentioned without consideration of hia fundamental works, ±t is a remarkable fact that these works were carried out by him in his private X-Ray institute, which he had fitted up as a proper scientific instiutte. In recognition of his scientific achievements, he was blectcd to Uvj board of directors, and the Advisery Council of the German X-Ray Association. In 1936 and 1936 he was sent at Vi„ma, Prague and Turin, to the meetings of the Austrian, Cz-choslovakian, and ‘talien X-Ray Associations, as official rcpr« sontativc of the Association. In 1937, he was at th> internation¬ al X-Ray Congress in Chicago, as official representative of the ”^rman a- Ray Association. In 1936, *eltz was appointed Head of the Ocnaan X-Ray congreis at kiniefc. The fern of appreciation Aeltz exper¬ ienced as a scientist and as a moral personality free experts, can best be illustrated by the fact that he wa3 offered the post of H;ad of the Association in 1930, by Professor Irik, then President of the X-Ray Gorman Association and repeatedly by me in th. following yfars, •is the last President of the Association, with full consent of the Board of Directors. He, however, always riAised it. Appreciation of Welts 1 s personality extended far beyond the limits of the German X-Ray Association, to other scientific associations, of which I shall only Eention the Association .or Surgery, for Circulation Research, and 703ii Court So* 1 6 Kay 47-h-GlS-142-S-Karrcv (EaasUf) for Internal Medicine. A fact by which '.eltx especially distinguished hiaself was hie constant readiness to help in scientific re veil as in cereonel.nattcre. After a visit to hie institute one vae elvers en¬ riched in knowledge; he did not refrain free giving the reeulte of his current scientific vorlee, even if they bed not yet boen published, and ho vi.a pleased if he was able to exercise an inspiring and etiauloting effect on ethers. "As e pilot during the first vorld war and as a balloon pilot he had already been engaged in aviation nodical probltns frea a very early date. On account of this aptitude cf his ho vas appointed lecturer of aviation aodlcinc at Munich. eotablishcd a dcrrrtacnt for aviation aedicino at the Physiological Institute at ..unich, for which ho hiosolf furnished the funds to a great vxtcr.t end vhich he fitted up with his >vn apparatus. The vork ctrriod out in this institute vat also on a high level.* es. President, I have finished the affidavit of Xncthe referring to sonu characterlxatlone -f Profossor Vcltx. I ohould now like to nek you to pernit o.. to call bin to the witness stand. 7M PRiSIIiW: The defendant Oocrgc >»cltt nay take the witness etond. K3. HABOTl May it ploeeo Ycur Honor, coy I inauirc of counsel how long he anticipates tho defendant will be on direct expaination? ES. ’ ILLE: hr. President, this is extreaoly difficult to soy. It depends how Professor heltx will react to ny truest ions. I personally cs tiaate it to lest one to two days. «P. EARDT: Thank you. * Tri PSiSlEEHT: Tho defendant George Veltx will tpke the vitnesc stand. (GGlEGI AuGDST ’ nLTZ, a witness, took the stand and testified cs f-llows.) 7035 6 i:ey 47-H-0J5-1 & <2-7-K<-rrov(Hamnljr) Court Ho. 1 BY JUCGi 3SSaiKG: Q. Held up your right hand and be sworn. I svoar by Jod, the .^Inlghty and oaniscient, that I •'111 speax the pure truth .and -<111 withheld and aid nothing. (The viwass ropoated the oath.) You may be seated. * 70-*6 6 Kry U Halo/ (a-sL-r) Court JJci 1 A. UjX'tbor ..-a a pbsnccist in LoSrigshofon. ily grrad- father was c -v.ysician. A brother of ny father was also a physician. I visit* ' various schools in LuCwigshcfwn an;* Lannhoia. Nothing of r.ny importance. can be tolA .bout that perioi* of time. I engage ', in a groat mount of sport, an- in the y*ar 1908 I entered thu Corxn c hasp Unship for rowing. In thu year of l*>f I was graduate: froa thi Cjtnasiun and I subsequently stuiioc! .medicine. The reasons which novc ' a*. to the study ,f xeJicino tt th t tine I can no longer st-to exactly today . ..t that tis*., as was the case with asst students, I h:' a v-ry incaalete conception of tho profession of n physician. I hac! a .pro.- 1 nuebor of wide interests at th t tLs.. I hie travels', a great deal. In tfc. year A 1911 I visits the Unit-' States of Aauricc i r -irst tLsu. I was intorostod in - rt and philosophy. «t th t tin. .11 the branches of acdlcioo a^n-t'. equally interesting to no. They wc.ro all jww. I stalled at Jena, Kiel, Konunigab-rg, Munich, uboro I had a great znabco* of exooUunt teachers. I don't reC-11 th t anyone f these U-.crt.ra eXorci«*.a ny p'.rtlcul-r influence OB. In lie y r f 1913 I tool r.y str.ts oxaalnation nr>i -.:ent to Gorlin to t:-w Ch'rits, and I workud ;ith Kuolpn at tho ifediocl Polyclinic, .-ad 1 .ter with Fmnx t the X-r.ay Polyclinic. Arounu th t tia’i I lunrnud to fly. 1 rt-.Ve tho International Pilots Certifi¬ cate Ho. 62.',. as roon as the First forld .far st rtod I was attr.chod to tho Flying 3rttr.l±on SchleisshcLa. I p-rticifx.Uc’ in tho First ..orla ..*r partly j a pilot r.d partly .s a physician. At th t tl.au I was concerning ayoolf :or t rt- firct tlau with viition a.dicr.l problvca. . Ihe rroblcns concerned tho selection of fliers wiiic.i i that tla. >.as an entirely r.eW field. Then wo corpiled ccia-nt st tistioa - rtS .orks of sLaiL'r nature. Aftorstho i.-r h'd erdvd. I went to P.oaUrg, to Munich, to the first nodicrl clinic, nd after half - jit I went to lauorbruoh to the surgical Clinic, Vorki.: »ith Sauerbruch I gained t,e first real conception af t aid n Is, r.d ~ v.t trt. x-dic: 1 profession ■%.an3. yy tsacbors thirc two School ~nd Crass-i. .Pile with Sauorbruch I 7037 6 li-f u7 - 1 — 2 - 2 -*~.loy (Rcjalor) Court .-fc>. 1 s~w the huar.n attitude towards physici-n. Sauerbruch pl'ccd the patient in tit center of interest. K- r-pr-sented the point of view thet too radical irof^csion was -n -rt ard not a technical skill. He said it was an Tt in which or.- hod tobc talented r.nd h_ always pointed out tb-fc wfrjn treating r patient science would h-vo to remain ' servant. That, of cours_, does cot exclude that in other fields sci-nco bocaaos an ond ir. itself. In tt*. y-'r 19^3 I settled detn in kunich r s a speci-list in X-ray work, nd I want to mention two researchers whee 1 was fortunate to know, nd who -xurcised s»j influence on ay trend of work. First was the Dutch r.soarcher Storn van Le-wcn, 3-t-o-r-n v-c-n- L-o-c-v-e-n. Storn was a physiologist end his rpeci* 1 field was tho detairo Branch of study. I visited Storn frequently and we worked logo tier. Cur interests then extended to climatic diseases. Wc took balloon rides to;jctJxir studying that problem. Ho died in tho A'r 1533. The oth-r significant r-se rcher who was r. friend of sdno •r.d who exoroisod influence ir. ay .lor'n was Pl.illlpp Rooser, a. physiologist • t tho University of kunich. Rcras-r encour’ god me to start - little .vi tion *.>aic~l department at hie Institute, and I have auch to thank him fer sci-ntifici lly. I was practicing X-ray physician and coil* ocr-ted with * theoretical physic In, *nd this is a practice w ..ich I follow-.o in the future, >roapt.d by the consideration that the isolation of the individual branches of oodieixx, ccnstituteo • «M knows in i- c*n be bridged over by such collaboration. Q. If I uix'erctand your s-aurc^nts correctly your main profuo- sicr. is a &p-ci“li-t in X-r-y work. A. T-6. Q. vou ucre -ctiv- t your oriv-t- institute in Munich?* A. i~e, -v-r since 1923. C. Could you pi- Se t-11 tho Triburr 1 .a little nor- bout your profession -1 activity nc your cKC&jr ships in v-rious medical associations? A. I *.as • cesibur of th. Gera an X-ray Association for Internal 7033 6 May LI li-loy (RomL-r) Court Xo. 1 liodicine, Association for Bosearch of Circulrtioe, a i/omber of the • Austrian Jr-rr.y Association, c-nber of the It-lion X-ray Association, the Goresr. Physiols ic 1 Association, the Lunieh Physicians Society, the Liliunthal Association, end I think this covers all of them. Dp.. Ur. President, subsequent to thts- st tcaonts of the defendant oltz I scbuittoc - list of is sci.ntific publications. This list is contained in docuo-r.t Waltz Ho. 1, rri is Docuaent No. 1. I should like to -ffer it _s Exhibit No. 2. This list is certified by Professor ..'citrus secretary, who actually conpilcd it. There are 50 publications of .alts hiasclf and Z.1 by his collaborators. Q. Professor oltx, I shall have this document handed to you; could you confirm under oath that it r-pree-nts a complete list of yaur scientific publications? A. I triod to check this list r. s far ns it was possible for do to check it n' re tr r .as I knew it Is conploto. Q. Would you oe good enough to tell thj Tribunal with what your work was eercorn-d? A. Tc*j l'rgost part of ay work is of an X-ray naturo. I tried to embark oi. not roads. X-ray work so far had been morphology, which is to toy -rr.tocicrl study of living hucr.n being. I tried by using rv.w oothods to ct rt n X-r y physiology, that is to say X-ray which toes n>t bother so much with tho forn .of the organa, but with tho functions of the or;-ns, consequently I nppliod awthods which concerned thaBselves with knewm s^thods, or kynograpijy and cinematography. Generally I nov-r w s Laterosted in th, rareness of the disease, but I rather tried to follow the physiologic 1 basic re-.sons of *ny given dioe-se, nd on- rn ^ th t looking t a nuaber of my published works. Another : rt of -y mk concerned itself with aviatioi^ me die ire . Now, if I uxx.eTst/.rd you correctly, your work is partly ccr.con.--d with the f.-ld ;f or'ctic .1 a-dicine, and p-rtly with scientific r-aliz.aJ.cn of th t a-dicine. Didn't you also work on negative subjects, subjects of extermination , subjects as they ;«ro 70>9 6 - y 47 -a-3-W:>- il 1 oy (Raasior) Court Ha. 1 desisted by Ocr».ral Taylor when he was speaking here? *• Ha, I nev.r worked on any such sublets. Die you concern jours-If wit a politics, at.rill ration, eothencsia, did you write about th-a- aubj-cte? A. Xo, I never nubliah-u anything. <• I'tur "-u *jr- act It- :.s - i-cturor and & a professor at th« University of oinich; wh't sublets wero you professor in? a. I w.aa an vj-traordir. ry prAusaor for X-ray physiology. Q. And how can you -xpiain y-ur ctivity in aviation oadicinc at the Univ-rsity? A. In the year 1935 I ivc-iv-i • lecture assigrwunt for aviation a- Jicirc t tfc. University of Munich. I 1-ctured two hours r. Nockj an! as I lro'vy said 2 had institut-d r snail exp-ri-^ontal dep-rtaent t -ho Phyaiolocj Institute A th. University of llunicfc, which t that tiow support.’ a, in ay work, 'no this was tno occasion f-r .ae to qualify - a r lecturer. Q. h*t was .h- purpos- of your scientific travels? A. You k-nn ny scientific balloon travels? Q. Yes. a. P rtly in or'or to do research in th, South l/ind oroblua, aainiy lr*a t.ie nodical point of vi.w, then there were a nua.b-r of ccteDlogic l questions which h*J to be cl"rifled, for instance the fomatioa A rlorioloc. P rtly these wer. sport travels. 7040 6 :>v 4T-il-fjC-4-1-4:ooh-j: (Iat., 5“'or) Court i " 31d occmoot any nUitary purp-sos with thorn travels? A no, tho balloon -.t that tico h-4 no longor ray ailltcxy Bigaificaaco aid this b-j agrood upon by nil cirdoa or tho nir-forco. 1 7-tt briefly doscribo you actlTitios na a locturor in aviation coiicino? A A° locturor in aviation aodiciao, I otrurtod to loctuxo two h°UT8 ovory wook and I usod cy tiao, which I could ap-.ro froa ay practise, to work in tho o*poricentol doportnont, which I hod cro-tod. To did thoro what ia dosignntod os basic roao-xoh work and woro con¬ cerned with tho basic questions ooncornlcg aviation nodiolno -ad tho of foot cf tho lack of oxygon. * lad rrrlTl D6 fron tills activity, tho Iaatituto for Aviation Todicino inJIunich was eroatod? A Pertly, yoa. Tho I natituto fer Aviation Hodlcino during tho Vrx Wl28 r - “iWtery Institute. Uy prlvato doportaont at tho Phyalolo- aor.l Iaatituto was on institution of tho University nr* at flrat h* nothing to do with tho airforco. Thoro la a ocnnoction on tho othor hmd, because tho Ir.otituto for Aviation H<*11 clno hod boon croatol by tho Luftwoffo bocauao tho fcuadr.tion for it wig already pxoaont in tho civilian dopart:;out. 1 "hat woro tla quostione that tho oiviUaa dopcartt woa werk- lac, on at tho University? A Thoao woro quoatl:ns ecnoornod with basic rosoorch. ' And thoeo questions woro aainly cf a cciontific choraoior? A ?hoy i.ero oxolu3ivoly cf a sciontific charactor. Uo did not “1 all doal with practical quostlons. * *’~ uia y ;u Plo - so toll u t, stnot.ilng abcut your political past? A I noTor ccncomod aysolf very aueh with politics. *:hon wo rotur:od fren tho first "orld Tar, wo bog-n to knew politics in a • ory unploasant fom. Revolutions proValod and aftorsardo thoro was inflation. P-rticul-rly at this tLej a nuebor of oloror.te cano up in Politics which convinced no that politics is a handicraft in tho 70U Court So. 1 5 nay 47- rt -4-2-iEA-keeh*n (rosier) •xercisa of which one could easily get dirty hand*. I kept away from politic* and did cot become a center of any oarty. After 192? one vaa facad vitfc declaiona which were lsnosed fros the outside and which one could cot circuavent. In =y personal field I had to aake a decision in two factors, first. concerning the Oerean X-ray association. In the X-ray association there was a danger that the leadership of tha*. association would fall into the hands of a few radical cersons who uo to that noint had played no o*rt in X-ray physiology. If wanted to nreserr- the International reputation of the association and if wo wanted to safeguard our representation aborad. then it was necessary that a number of X-ray workers beccmo secher* of the Party, because only in this Banner w. it poe.ible to do .way with petty ouarrel. within tho X-ray association. The other field where I had been forced to Bake a decision was ny department at the Physiological Inetitute. If I wonted to continue v'jrk thor., I could only do p * r, ’ r - Ic lh * C ““ * W baloce rid.., In -hlch I -» Tory Intoro.tod. It ... uo..lbl. for =. ,0 continue -or. -Ithlu th. fr«e-or* of th. P*rty. In th. yo.r 1937 ; boc.no . noebor of tho forty without Identifying Woolf - 1 th .11 tho principle* of th.t norty. In portlculor. I 1-W* r.j.otod th. moll nrlnclple* of th. forty. I ». noyor on .ntl-Sonlt. nnd for th.t ronion I had nwy J-loh ollor.to In Xunlch. I oontlnuod trc.tlng Jo-0, in .pit. of th. prohibition, up to 1944. but tb.n I -.* d.nouncod and I had to co..« thl. bocuo. othor-l.o ny ur.=tl=« -ould hovo boon closed. Q. I no- go oTor to your .ctlTltl.. during tho -w. »hon -oro you drafted? A. I -as drafted at the end of August in 1939. Q. - hen did you go to tho toot ot.tlon for .ltltudo So. 4 In ..unich? A. At flrot I -no In Seublborg «t . Pilot- cr.nln.tlon coot. ^ ct0 I stoyed until .uororlnntoly Koroubor of 1939. I —< *<• «« ?0A2 Court Si. 1 6 aay 47-*-4-3-&&-kcohan (Sanlef) tast station in January of 1940. Q, Vould you please describe to the Tribunal vhereln lies the difference betveen the test station and a pilot's examination station? A. The fliers exanination post, were I stayed at first, carried cut general Investigation vhich is perhaps comparable tc the Investiga¬ tion carried out by a life insurance coopery, vhenever one tries to take cut a policy. It is a very thorough examination of the circulation, heart, eyes, etc. The tost stations dealt exclusively vith the investigation of altitude effects. At the beginning of the war tho tlae had ccoo vhon machines -ant up into high altitude and at that tine a number of fatali¬ ties had occurred as a result of altitude sickness. These fatalitios wort explained by the fact that altitude sickness, as it has been described here freouently, causes no pain whatsoever, but on tho con¬ trary in its first stages has an intoxicating offoct on tho person, causing his to have high spirits, vhich lends to an over-estimation of his ovn pavers and vhich in no vay apooars to bo dangerous to tho person involved. Because of thoso peculierltiesjeltltudc slcknoss o number of fatalitios had cccurrod. It vat therefore decided to cauco altitude sickness at certain intervals of tino cn all the flying ocrtonnol in order that ono could doaonstratc tho peculiarities of that sickness to thea in that cannor and in ordor to drav thuir attention to tho neces¬ sity of recognizing tho first symptoms of that sickness in thoosolvos. These examinations verc carried out at the test stations in sorios and normally tvonty to thirty persons were exeained per day. The persons got this altitude sickness vithln three to fifteen minutes and in this sannor they gained the knovlcdge d.ich they had to apply vben actually flying. q. In that case you were the head for the test station for high altitude effect So. 4 up to the creation cf the foundation of the Mili¬ tary Institute for Aviation Medicine? A. Tcs. 70.3 Court He. 1 6 Aar 47-K-4-4-tEK-Kethaa (Eafller) Q> Veil, how did this foundation of the Military Institute for Aviation Medicine ccae about? A. Continuing the tradition of =y civilian decartnent, we carriod out a nuaber of scientific ojaainations at the teat station Ho. 4. That possibly "at the reason for Elppke's suggesting to ae in the Burner -f 194 i that a larger institute should be created In Munich. This insti¬ tute had been planned on a large seals. It ~s to bo connected with an CTdinarlat at the university and a nunber of new buildings were oro- rldod. I had aisgivings about this large-scale nroject because in the final analysis I rented to reaain an X-ray physiologist. All those large-scale plans were dropped anyway because of aerial warfare, and a slsilar institute was founded vhlch essentially continued the tradi¬ tions of ny civilian dopartaent. 7044 6 i. -v 4 -* »-J?—5-1- C ook (Inti Railur) Court I -V.ou you vore designated _• the ho_d of th-t institute when it v_a fouadedT ros. -Tint tasks did the hilit_ry Institute for aviation medicine h-ve? Che idlitjy Institute for avi-tion nodicino, as I already ■aid, coatinuod the tradition of tho civilian department, that is to say, it mainly concerned itsolf vith basic research, oninol experi¬ ments, whereby particular attention was given to problems with which we Had dOalt onrlior, which was a lack of ojygon and yencral phy¬ siological quostion», for instanco, collapse. v Vos tho research nrogr-w prescribed, which you woro ordorod to Carr/ out as a cort^ln •> 1 an7 a. I die cub sod the brood outlino with Hippko, upon waich too instituto was to be uctivo, but by and largo I had a froo hand, aoro woro a fov excooti jns. Z.o Reich *vlati:n kinlstry and Hodlcal laspoctorato oosiissiaoed uu with a nuabor of questions wnich wo had to solvo, but theso wore relatively raro c-sos and the t-eks had n particular iuport-nco. X* Uhnt w..s : ur relationship t the Rolch Resoarch Council? a. u’o had no rol_tionship to tho Roicn Rosoarch Council. 3. You acy th t you had a free hand. Is it to bo attributed to you thon, that yrar instituto epocializod in tho rescuo of fliors? a. Yos, uo specialized in finding -othods for tho rescuo of , fliers, end t.:is according to ay plun; but this olun was workod out in _grouiont vith tho intentions of tho kodical Inspectorate. * Did tnc ..ilit-ip Institute also deal witn questions of extermination, killing or the effect of offensive weapons? a. Ho, no rich questions were evor worked upon by us. X* Uould you ploaso indicate who y ur collaborators wore? a. iy oldest collaborator was Dr. von Vers. Vers caoe to no 6 k-y-W-J?-5-2-Cook (Iat. Hauler) Court 1 during tho JO_tnaiu s -f the war because he hod reason to change hi# residence. Ho Was being looked for by the Gestcpo, was persecuted for racial reasons, and for th_t reason decided to give up hi# position a# a cnief pharajcologist in a 1 -rger phoxcaceuticol iastitu- tioa. I ves in a position to engage hi.-* in ay institute through a Civilian contract and ho succeeded in staying with no throu^iout the entire war without any intorforence. Aero was soao quostion about th-t frcu horlin wnicn threatened his oosition but decaer-Troysong i n u u god to e..vo fe situ-tlon. lerz wa» a phanoacologist. Ho ori¬ ginally wonted to qu_lify as > lecturer but th..t did not i-utoriulizo nd he caao to .0 afterwards. Ky socoad coll^oor-tor w u s Lutz, Luts. I took Lutz frou an ack-ack battalion. *t tfc„t tlno ho was r. r thor unknow Dun, but wnilo working with uo dov-lopod vory quickly into o very good -ad significant scientist. Hy third colla¬ borator w.-.e Vendt, »&o was an S-r^ physiologist, and aostly workod upon tho ray questions. Eo took Care of tho entiro corrospondonco of the Instituto .ad sinult-noously was hood of tho tost st-tion of tor I h-d bccuo ho.d of tho Instltuto. Later, on undor c civilian contr.ct, vo alloyed a physiological chouist, Dr. Sohlkopf, wno also cu:o froa tho ph..ruacoutica industry. This v_# tho o..sic st-ff of tho Instituto. Eton wo h_d a auabor of coll-oor-tors who, however, cauo -nd wwnt, and ri. 0 only oec.uo taper-ry -unbors of tho Inotltuto. rheso voro Lr. Eanton, who caio frarj tho front and wantod to do his doct3r«s thesis, and there vuro a nuuber of people wao for other roj- coas wanted to do scientific w;rk for a tL.o. I h-d no influence in tne selection of thvsc fluctu_tin<, jid ch-nging coil_borators, *but in -uiny lnct.ac_s tncy woro just assigned to ay Instituto without uy over -nowiag then. How would you pie sc briefly describe what your t-sks wore -s he^d of tho Institute? 70/.6 e Kw-ir-JT-5-o-Ccck ( 1 st. ?-dor) Court I .u a 3 chief of the Institute I at first received, for uyeelf _ field of work, for uy ova research work, and it addition it was ay dut;* to establish the lOlicy of the oat ire Institute, as a rule wo had dlscu sions nco w week during wtict we exc h a n ged our experloncos. Brerybody reported wh_t he hod worked upon and a futuro prograu was detomined. Since wo wore r-thor snail and since wo didn't hare enough ooll_oorators, a d-nger existed th_t we would disintegrate and go different ways, and for th-t re-son I attached v-luo to the continuity of tho whole t_sk being preserved. I wanted to coo that a muber of essontial problans wore s elected and tn-t wo should coi>- ccntrato cur entiro energy upon th*-sO proolans. At too very Deginning, p-rticulnrly, thero was on inclination to follow up orory ide- waich was considered to bo good, and in this aona*r a nuubor of tasks woro started vdiici- woro never finishod. Hew ideas originated which uoant th .t old worx w.s put asido. Pinully, wo draftod a program which hud to be obsorvod rigidly -nd waich represented our oxuct lino of work. 3* I shall now turn to the individual counts of tho indictuont. You woro charged witr. h-ring p-rticip-tod in a conspir-cy. I shall doal with t:iis point only when all of tho other points havo already boon cl-rificd, Tho next count and almost tho only count which is to bo takon soricusly is your connection with tho high -ltitudo o^jorluonts at Dachau* Zi ay arc -11 centered -round tho na-o of Haschor. I thvreforo .a.: you at first, when did you first hoar of 2 aschor? a. I hoerd of a-scher for tho first tiuo in tho suunor of 1941, I he-rd of hfci t a rough Aotteahoff. Eottahoff at that tluo tild uo that Haschar h.d - prc-chwd hi u and had su^t-sted that ho Carry out t.io hi©a altitude experiments at Dachau. Xottonhoff, I uuy explain, Was at tlx.t tlocfl Oberfcldarst with tho Air Gau Coaoand. Xottcnhoff in the years 1933 to 1939 h_d already been with ay civilian dopartuento 7017 6 K-^ii-JP-5-i-Cook (1st. Eoiler) Court I He received his specialists training it the Physiological Instituto it Huaich. Liter he qualified _s a lecturer it ny Institute and verged in uy dc>_rt-.cnt us a guest vhenevor he visited nuaich. auong other uettors, he _t one tlue st-rted a scries of experiacats vita a aorJcsy. %. Dr. Volts, I shall sow h_vo tho lcttor of Hischcr to Hiaulor, dated 1 ..oy, 1941, handed to you. ?1_&!3&3| 3oforc st_rting on th_t phaso of tho oxcalnitlon tho Tribunal will bo ia recess. (a short rocoss v_s tJcea) 7-xe 6 -ay-J-GJ-7-l-Blackiey-(int, Kurtz&Vcm Sch-n)- Ccurt 1 Case 1 Th. Tribunal is -grin inscssi:n. BY EE. TLI2: Q Dr. -.citz, Just before the recess I was abcut to give ycu Dccu- oer.t HO-15Q2 PS, Prosecution exhibit LL; and that is where we st.pped at the- recess. I shall n.w send th. document up to y:u. I understand yep hrve it already. Please r.fer t it. The prcsecutirn maintairs and I should like to hear ycur attitude abcut this—that ycu arc the represen¬ tative cf the Air fleet physician mentioned in this letter here. a Rancher writes in this letter cf the 15th ef -ay 19iil first that he was assigned in -unich at the Luftgau Cca a ande VII fer a medical selec- ti:n course. P.e also writes that high altitude research was icp.rtont in this cruise because the English fighter plan.s had a sen.what higher ceiling, he alledged that it was acnticned in this course that unfortu¬ nately we had net been able to carry out exp.riocnts with human material yet since the experiments were very dangerous and no cne volunteered. He therefore furiously asks: Is it possible that two or three profes¬ sional criminals b-. made available by you for these experiments? What .'.'‘sch.r writes her. is v.ry peculiar because it is likely to have been generally known at that tine that in th. Luftwaffe there was hardly a wcll- kn wn r.scarch w rker who had net p.rf r=ed extensive experiments on him¬ self. Fr-m the lorg. number of names I should like to mention o,.ly n few here. Ruff, Romberg, 3eCkor-Frey3eng, and Lutz have already been mentioned. Klemann, Frauerherger, Doeh ring, B.nzinger, Luft, Febcitz, Kvtt.nhrff, Hal- bo.ch, Sauer, those are only a f.w nam.s which Just ccur tc me. There were s me heroic cxp.rin.nts, fer exacpl., B.nzingor-Halbach -xp.rii.cnts on ox- pl sive docanprcssi-n up to 19,000 c.ntrifuge experiments by Doehlen. *“e 3tayed in th. Centring. until he had subcutaneous heaerriveges) that is, his wh.l. skin by the centrifuge, which was a sensatirival thing at the time. knew -f all th.s. experiments, and there was hardly anyone familiar with aviation medicine who could have made such a remark. Now, this remark c aid :nly haw. been made at a report :r. high altitude aviation research. It- three lectures which were held on altitude during this course I knew. 70LV 6 —ay— jJ- 7-2-5 lac kl _y- (ir.t. Xurtz&Vcn Schcn)- Court 1 Case 1 I held one of then myself. I did net say that. Bucchn-r nade one and K'ttcnhoff the third; and I heard both lectures; and the other tw lectur¬ es did net contain this assertion either. *c knew fr-n further dcval-p- nor.ts that he Seans here Kett^nheffs lecture; and K tt.nhrf Certainly did net say that either. Certainly not in this frrn; and he says the sane thing hinself in a affidavit. .Sew, Rascher gees on th. write that the expv.ric._nt3 are cade at the Bed-nstaendige Prucfstcllc fuer H-chenf^rschung der Luftwaffe in '.unich. The head in this institute at the tine was cyse-lf. Rascher did net cone u oc, although 1 was a lecturer at this course. I did not give hin pv.'-niasi-.n t- pv.rfcm theS- experiments at this institute; and I would net have be-n able to give hin that pernissirn t~ perforn these expertsents at this institut,; and I w-uld n t have been able t give hie that p-missl'n. That w uld have been s nothing which w uld have absolut - ly r.quircd consultation with the utdical Inrp-ct rate and the approval . f the kedical I_spect rate. I c'nsider it iap:ssible that Kettenh ff gave his this pvraissi n because K^ttenneff was net at this testing station; he was with the Luftgau. was in charge of the departaent for therapy and care; and he c uld n:t and did net give Rascher this pemissi n, 1 as convinced of that. 6 :: 7 -i7 -H-S r- Inta« Vcn£chota-iiir t z Court ::c. 1 ilor:, IT Hr.aclor goos on to vrito: tho cxporiiaints Q during which, of courco, tho subjects could dio woro to t*ko ol".co with v' cooper .tion; th t thoy rro c rriod out on isonlcoya r.s Lithorto boccuao ccnkoye .ro of m ontircly diff«ront tost condition; r.s I grid r.lro'dy ho iontionc rsonkoya bocr.uro Mot -on.' of: 's lecture roforrod to l.ia oxporlisor.ta or. ::on!:oya. I l'.vo 1 rvd r. very ccnfidont tr.llc on tfci.t witl. tl o reprurontrtivo of tho r.ir float ph;eioi:n rlo did :srko tide roo^ .rcl oxpori-ont, r.nd ho wr-.a fleo of the opinion tl- c tho preblone involvod cm on^; bo aclvod by oxporinenta on lainra boings. I knew fresi ni r.t Kottonl.off L-.a told so, tl : .t Rr.acl or did tr.ll: to hiii t r.t tl-.t tu.o, :.nd , after r.ll, Kotton- l.off says th.t too in lie affidavit. On tl o othorh.nd, n.'.ecl.or 1 lias0If v/ritoa that tho conversation v.-.s r.bsol- utcly crnfidontr.il. Thin s’ owa tl..-.t 1 0 uid not tr.ll: to so, «o f:r a tl.o roproaonts.tivo of tho r.ir fls,ot plyeicim is ccncor nod, ho wr.s noitl *.r Mottonhoff nor nyeolf. Ul\o r.ir floot phyaioi .n ur.a >ris, ;.t th t tino. I’o 1 * d no ruprosont tivo in Munich. ,\t lur.at vo two woro not Me roprocont..tivu 3 . Ono .airt, tl.oroforo, obsox*vo , that in tils letter R.-seMr h 0 :-/.o quitu r. lot of confusion with prrtly 1 elf-truths, sortl; howovur conplutoly untruo et Xx. .nt:. H.oso ro ;.pp rontly r. dc for r. vury dofinito purpoao, s nd, I ina* ir.o tl 0 pvrpcaos of tile 3 tt^r is % for .. scl>r t! on tc :-.ko fflmlor boliuvo th t t? «.ra rw r.a n urrjor.t noed for hunrn ox >. rs. :onta. ho Isr wmtod to •-ire liss boiiovo tl t ho 1 e talked to so?;o ccnpotont persons on the subject, vl icl could not hr.vo boon tho or.so . cccruin-: to tl - at: tc of -.ffrira. I j obviously ex¬ po tod V, t if Hi:, lor :;ivcs !i tie per sierion, t! 0 f t! or utkbrities involvod, th.t is sr/aoif, tho r.ir ~..u, tho 7051 6 Hay L7-4I-Si:-8-2-C-allaghei^Int3: v-n Sch n-Eurts C urt S'. 1 medical Inepcct'r, and sc f rth, that is, if an rdcr f pcrmissi'n fr : Hirr.lcr is presented, that wo cauld n t .pp so his wishes. I think that is rather el?er in the c: n tents :f this letter rf Rasch-r's. I thuTefere, state :nco aero that Rascher did n t talk te no at all at the time. He certainly did talk tc Kettonh ff. In his lccturo K ttenh- ff ocrteinly did n-t nakc the statement which Rascher pat in his anith. He talked ib ut the adjustment f c nkoys ani rabbits to high altitude, ani I kne-r n thing at all f the wh lo dcvolcpoents at the tire. It rrj quite imp ssible that ’.uring this c urso ho obtain¬ ed pemissi n r assurance that theso experiments wuld be carriod ut at tho Luftwaffo To -ting Stati n f r altitude research. There was nr. no thoro who c uld have given his this pemissi n. DR. WILJE: ifay it ploaso tho c urt, I, pursuant tr tho tostir. ny 'I Dr. Holts, shall n w subrdt the affidavit by Dr. K ttonh ff, which has "lrcady been roferrod t several tines. This is c ntained in Cheusent 9 k I f Kelts Ifccunont Ko. 2, and at the saaj time with this I subnit hero a public".ti n by Dr. K. ttenh*ff which has tho file: "lncr so f erxlurnnoc for nigh altitudos." This is e ntainod in .icltz D cunont N . 2, D cumcnt Ho. 18, and b th d ounonts t'gothor will bo eIts Exhibit :: . 3. rr c tnis affidavit I w uld like tc sake tho fell wing brief 3 bite cents. On page ? Kettonh ff st-tos, at tho t'p— THE FRESHEN?: Dr. Sillo, tho d curxnta boing c- ntained in sopar- to d cuncnt b ks, I suggest that they bo narked separately as Exhibit N' . 3 and Exhibit He. 3-A. DR. WILIS: Uay it ploaso tho c urt. In acc^rdanoa with j ur H n'rs ruling, I shall submit those d cuseats as Exhibits 7052 6 May 47-lfr-S -2-2-Cc. Oegher-Ints; von Schan-Xurtz Court No. 1 Nos. 3 and 4. Perhaps I m? briefly ca-u back to whet I .»es about to say. Kottunboff said on pngo 2, first, t:at during the training co'iroe, ho gave e Itcture on high altitude as to tho adaptability of rrbbita erd nonfcoys. He confirmed th reupon that after the licturo, th.t Rase her opproachsd Kottonhoff, art! th t the t*o of thorn hid a confidential discussion together. On page 3 of his affidavit Kotten- hoff confirms ttat Raschor sndo tho .-iroposition to hL= to have Idgh altitudo tot s scC.o on profess loro 1 crxaincla, and that they had to be volunteers. Hu Iso said in his affid. vit, th t is, Kotton- hoff, errf I oiv.il quote the last prr-gr*ph on page 3: "Suv-ral tsooks altor our first discussion Raschor ciaa to •*>, crxJ inf or nod no far Uw firpt tisie that he tad approached HinUr far pumioaicn to conduct rdfih-altitudo adaptability, ;rirur.tc on professional crinirola, an! ttat he hid received tha uritton p-radssicn fr^ctur«. x ct ids.- . of pwrforcd.no experiments on human v-ings in Dr.ch.~ix; t!i t without s .ylng nythin& to Kett^n- heff about it he sot p-raissicn from Himmler th .t in order to obt .in this permission ho yrotendud to Himmler th -t ho h .d t Iked to authorities end zh t th-r- was urs-at need for those experiments -nd th n it sc ..ex tone that it-.3Cher t th.t tioo ilrondy lnt to :,utiify os : looturor, hoer.uso the f-ct th t ho a-ntion-d tho t..3tmj station for .ltitude research .c tho r^oncy which wrs to c rry out tho uxpvriments le-.ds us to boliovo that at th .t tioo • hw w .3 loo kin 3 for a ccntr.et with tho University which would h:.v. boon possible through no, and tho ? ysiolocic .1 I .stitutu with Testing ec tion ••• i Or. •< lsz, Z . 11 *.ow hand to you an oss -,y by Kotton- hoff and by Fr;.u rtu-hl-3tnisl..us. This essay i3 on ex- pcrlnonts on nonkoys. Your He., r, this essay i3 in D cuiunt B wk 2 of ltz, pegu 69 end 70. Dr. *'_ltz, ••dll you plo. 3 w cxpl .in this p .p-r? .. T is is ; corrwction 3haet of . paper which K.ttcn- hoff Inter publish-d in the journal for -»vi:.tien *iwdic£ne. Is is N . 33 in the li3t of public .tians which hex been submitted by ay r.sslst nts. DR. k 'Hunger Fighters.' 1 My friend Storm via Uouuon h d given it to no ad Storm v n Loeuvjcn had told me about D- Kruif. H- wis v. ..m-ric n of Dutch descent. H- know Storm vm Ueireon, and had visited hi. intending to .n-it- something r.bout Store*s work. 7056 try 6-ir-flK-9— i-il -ioy ( lot . Vo:: 3choon ie /oirtz) Court Ko. 1 XU. .ILL-: II ;y it pi- .so th- Court, ;:t this point a..y I -sic tho Court whoth-r s exhibit I would be allowed tc subait extr *.cts frac. the just c&ntionod book by Dc Kruif. I TlO .11 in this connection th .t r. little tine .130 tho Court ruled that the defense would be allowed to oubcit nil a'tori 1 connected with the hunrjx mtcri-.l cr.ly t tho end of the presentation of evidence. How, this doour—nt I do not wish to sutr.it in oone-ction with th« legal 3>cts of hAi n oxp-rU:cnts, but only to prove th t in this ccnv -rs tion botr.—.j — ltz aid liippko which dor.lt with the conditions of -x,:rir~nt3, ..-ltz ..ct-d in 3ood faith, mil therefor- I think this dooun-nt hr.s a different signific no- in this connection th n just to explain the oxperic-nts to the court. U..y I submit it here? Sl.JJY: Ih.y I inquire Your Honor novo spocifio .lly .h t doounent he is reforring to? D.t. .ItLJ: Your Honor, this is an extract free the beck by D- Hruif .nd it is only that p .rt of the -xtr .ct whioh do .13 with the oxp-ri.-.-nts by ^oldb-rgor. TKJ RL3E»HTs Doctor, which dccunent is that? D.i. .ILIil: It is in Doo unent hock ;-ltz lo, r.nd I would offer it if the court per nits no, .s Exhibit ’.io. 6. U y I c-ntion her., Your Honor, thr.t the book is in ny possession. lie. rl-QY: . Your Honor, I still a .ko . sincor- ttonpt to find out what docun-nt th-y _r- referring to? - 1 • THJ PlLSIDLl.T: ./h t is the nunb-r of tho decun-nt.to whioh you refer? II y 6-41-BK—10—1-11 c oh.‘-n (Int. Von Scho-n i; Kurtz) C-ourt Ho. 1 D--.. .ILL-: I.i Docua-nt jo.I< <-ltz, 3 I toll Your Honor, it is Docua-nt iio. 13 . L'ry it ylor.s- th- Court, it is on y i-js 59 to 63 of th- i*:ijlish Docut-.nt book. »L.y I off-r this Dccua-nr? -i. H—tDY: Your Honor, u:.y I -.sic Mh'.t the, ... .ILI-: L,.y it plw_8u th- Court, ..a I siil fc-foru, • thi3 Doouo-nt, r.th-r tho ^-f-nd .nt .ultz roforrod hiuaclf to this Document, b-o .use ho told tho court .t th..t tLuo h- -x~l: inoc* his kno'Jla*.5- of tho .dr.iss .bility of hun n experiments to Hippko -id ho b sod hi;csolf on this book of Do Kruif. Th-r-for-, for -ltz in this c so tho qu- 3 tior. i 3 not to expl .in tho lir:it .tiens of hua..n ax- -rin-nts to tho oourt, but only to nr.ko it orcdiblo to tho court th t ;t th .t mcn-nt oltz ••/..£ inforn-d by zn ir.t-rn tion lly well known book th t such vxp_rL'i-nts wore 'nissibl-. I do not wish to ont.r r. dob .to on tho lictttc.- tions c.. hiu:.-m cxp-ria-nt3. Id-. H._DY: Your Honor, th t b-inj tho enso, I would t.'.ink st tervmt of cour.s,l is .11 thr.t is nooossnry h-ro r.l th- Docun .nt could bo off-r-d _t 1 :t-r d..to with th- ■ th r3. 70*S i!'7 6-lI-5K-lC-2-L'„„h \n {Int. Yon Schoun k Kurtz) Court He. 1 JUDCi- SEB.v£«G: Dr. -ilie, you _r- rofo-rrin^ to Docuriont Ho. 13 in ..ultz Docuc-nt Book 1 i.t page 59? witness, •when did you first beCun- fxiili.ir eith-r with this exoerpt in your Docuc-nt book or the book itself, entitled "Hunger Fighters?" . THE .iITHKSS: The book "Hunger Fight js" belonged to Stom v si Lo^uwon nd he sav- it to no. JUDG S-BRING: when? THU .ITHEGS: In 1933 ‘he died and no nust have given it to no before 1933. JUDGE *.KBRINC: ..nd wh .t conclusion did you dr .w frea the book at the tin- ;*Jjd p .rticul. rly froca this oxocrpt? THU WITNESS: The experiences of Goldberger doscribod in this book I considered the school aortel for whr.t is per- niss.-.ble in accord nee viith intern .tion .1 st ndr.rds, nd I told this to Hippka in this fom. JUDGE GE3HEIG: You believed in go >d f ith that this represented the intern .tionr.l nedic .1 st nd .rd in reg rd to th- r.afct-r of experimentation upon hun si beincs; is th t correct? THE ..ITNESS: Yes. JUDGE oUBiillli: Dr. -ille, w..s th .t the purpose for -which you vie-re w nting to offer thi3 exhibit at the present tine? ' Dii. .ILLE: Yes, it w .8. JUDG- SEBuING: Th-n th-re is no particul r necessity for your pursuing the natter furth_r at this tine? DR. .ILIE: No, 3ir. THE BRfiilDENT: Thu Docuiient then will be .dnitted for the purpose mentioned by counsel nd United to that pur¬ pose; th .t will be Exhibit 6, counsel, viill it not? DR. .ILLS; May it pie s. the Court, I offer it s Exhibit No. 6. 7059 '•~-7 S-K-BiC-lO-S-iliohrji (Int. 7on Scho-.n cc Kurtz.) wourt Kc. 1 THi SRSSZD2!?: Tho Tribunal assumes that counsel does not intend to read this Docuc-nt into the record. Dr.. .ILLS: No, Your Honor, I do not Intend to rued the Document into tho record, but only to offer it to th~ Court and to put a few brief questions to the defond- _nt, Prafossor «oltz, following this discussion of tho Document. I want to ask you this regarding tho point Hippko ; whr.t caused you to quote a po ; jul r book or refer to c pcpul-.r book betwoon scientists and oxp~rts; don't you think in th t conversation, it would have been noro 3cnsiblo for you, to rofer to a really export scientific work in thi3 connection? 7iI2 .ITIESS: I have already said that the fornulation, which Hippko rnd Kottunhoff h-d seemed to no rather un¬ clear and that I folt a n-ed to olnrify my point of view and formulate it clearly. This example happened to ocour to no end this was good beoauso it shews very clearly thw points which I was interested in and then I oxpl -lnod those points to Hippke. I 3 .id to hixi, first of all the oxporir. .nts 0 one era urgent natters whioh o..n not be ol .rified by aninil exporinents; secondly, tho oriainr.ls r.ust be volunteers and third, they must roooivo c reward. Those w.ro tho conditions, whioh I dealt with in o one id or r hi dot il. In this book, there is nuoh noro dotr.il than i3 c us ten ary in scientific works. In scientific works in goner:.l one find3 only bri-f technic- 1 st twr. *nts performed by so n ny persons, 3uch nd such w-ro the conditions, while h-re in Do Kruif s book t»5 nun. n conditions -.re d^scribdd in considerable dotail and vory clo xly. That the st tonents node in tho bock are correct, I had no doubt. I said before that Stern v n Loouwon and D- Kruif know oach eth~r porsonclly. I knew that De Kruif was one af the most p ipul x and 7060 jr-y 5-i-:-SS-10-i-* l -oh -n (Int. Von Sch >sn & :-airtz) Court 2* . 1 rospootod audio i "Ait bora in tho field of pjpul .r sci-nc_. • This w .3 f-r g_ su x -at__ enough t 5 b- .ble t..- a-ntion eh- bo ic to Hippie-. iicroovuT tho s^n-r .1 popul.xity .jk'. the wide oiroul-'.tija of 3uch -i bo K is tho boat at..r.C..rd f_-r wh t is CTHsidorod p-ruisstblo :.nC wh X is not. iJo Kruif's bo ics wore printed by th- nillion c-nC w«rc tr .nsl .ted into a ny l'.ngu Hvon if tho st .tenants atdo in tho b.ufc vox- incorrect, whioh th-ro is no r-.. 3 on to b-Uovj, .t i»-3t tho book would bo pro>f of whr.t intxn tion .lly tho s-n-r.l public considers porr.iss.tblo. Th .t, a I s 1C, xo the r.r.sons which .t tho tin^ undo cm t pr-3-nt this cl .ssio -x nplo to Hippicc rad I b-li-vo -v.n t/.r.y it wr.s *; vory auitr.blo ox'r.plo. 7061 Court So, 1 5 K ay 47-tt-ll-l-LHK-Sook (Sasnler) • • IS. ' ILL*: If Your Honors clease, in I.cuacnt rook * eltx Sc. 2 under Be. 1S-A to C, on pages 72 to 76 of the English dccusent book, ther* are throe docusents which have tho purpose of supcortirig the credibility and significance of De Xruif'e bocks which the execution's radical expert has challenged. I intend to subait these docuacnts for- aally at this point without reading thee and taking uo the Court's tine with then, but since the first dccuaent has been siaittod in this con¬ nection I beliOTO it is logically necessary also to eutoit those threo annoxuo at this noint. IS. FAEDT: lay It nUnee Ycur Honors, during the course of this trial I believe I fcavo objected to dccueento being adaitted into evi¬ dence nearly a hundrod tines or better but for the first tiae I aa lost for werds. I have reac these dccuaents and to uso tho word icmatorlal sight bo fine but they ere not even ronctoly connected with »-hot is in issue here and I can't soe why they should even bo tondervd. I objoct to their aiaission, Your Honors. 'IKE PriSirEK?: The Tribunal will take this natter under considera¬ tion and anncunco its ruling at one thirty o'clock. IS. VILLE: lay I continue now? HY 2a. '•ILLi: Q, Bjw spike of volunteers ^ the way h fr.cth.. IJurnborg oonforone. to St--.bs.-rzt Kraur^r ir^a St. Jftenn, ’« 1 *-• fry. r.r. ffi-rvit u-. In th. Utter X -schtr's uncU, Men tes bven subaitU’., it v-s stcUti th-t Rancher rr<: etid tte subjects »^re volunteers. I rtfk.r .V rd Rr.eclxr say nythint -1»- but th-t th« subjects would be volunteers -ni, a I tev* said, th-t v.->s the n.»ajn for us not to discuss Involuntary .r.p-rim-nt-1 oubj.cts witn Blppkft. DR. ‘.ILLd: IX .cr H -n r pU/»#, .a j I interpolate hole briefly for y;ur inf r.a ti r. th't tte affidavit mentioned bore Just now by Kraootr was sabnlttod by Dr. --It- on teTnalf of the Defordant !>.nd- losur r.d it is in document book. E xhibit to* IS. Q, -.itn--ss, 1 ill you now toll . d aft-r th n- versation with Ri >>ke? A. ».ftor fta conversation with Hippies nothing ha opened. It was not uxpoctvd t.V t acyl im null happen. - had no astdgiwunt froa ifippko to do anything. On the otter tend 'dppto h d fiven i.ia tecio ropronl. I, in turn, ted no oce. six. to do rythin*-. 3 tevu \lro Oy said t t! r* stlon of tostin U slow osc^nt w • Q. ill you till mo in :»re roblca of cold rt suggested to ■%. thrt he sh^ld o-rfora cold r xrivnts yn hua r. beings. 1. Did you ;*>rov- of th t int-ntion to perforc. cold jxpurLacnts? A. I r-fused these axpuri-xnts too. 1 r< no necessity r huonn Jcperixnta. the n-coss-ry pr-par-.t \-v ni>vl xperin-nts h not b-on fc Ifcjr 47 -t-I3-3-?k>* xr=ic^.r (vcn 3chon)(Kart-) Court No. 1 concluded yet, nd the*. entail experiments premised gre-t success t tb. ti_^, so that h?c no reason whafcuvar to perform any experiments or. human beings, nd I r-fused to lot R-scher perform these oxcxrim-nts. Q. Did you toll Booeber that Kippke could not be gotten for ox- peri.-a.nt a in Dccheu? A. I told Reaeter tb- point of vi->w which Kippke had ocplrixxd to a., tn'.t is, that : : ippko, Just like ajoolf, was of tb. opinion that under certain coalitions, which we considered correct, one c-n Perform experinv-nts cn huana beings, but that this aust be xeserved for n.clly urgent eases, where bo done in a ny oth-r wBy . This was Hippko's point of vie* nd I informed P.-sch-r of this ooint of view of Hippkc's Q. How did you trert the whole P.asch^r rot tor t«arda your collu gues in t ho Institute? A. Dr. Lutz ir.a already testified lv.ro and Ir.s said tht I discussed the questions cn burn beings with him too; thrt wc sookc of it in tb. theoretic1 Sense. Lutz did rot h v» ony rw ideas on it. I told hia aout the diccussion -i the Preysing Palais. I told him whrt concision ro i-d r-ached -nd Lutz had r.o r.-w contributions. Q. Non the question "nich h.s b-en oia. into by various people befere: did you sic or. of your colle-guos to make experiments with Rr.scher in Dccfru? A. No, I did rot. Th-re was no occasion to do this. I did rvot wont to perform ny experiments in Dnchru t that time. 1 did rot esk ki-ndt or Lutz, or «erz or ny other uho r.a in ay Institute to perform -ny exnerimv.nts. Q. But later on, you -llx«ed R-tcheT to rJc- eX>rL^-nts with Ruff-Romberg. My in tht cas., -lid you not c-rry out those experiments in your Institute wit.' Rraebe-r? A. In t h. exp-riments with P.uff-Rccbcrg, we wore de/liru; with completely different experiments. Tits- wore urgent -t the tirU. end Ruff-Re-oberg 1. ve lre-dy -xpl iiwc here why, a l E •- pnrov 1 f or ti.utAj expori.-m.cto, out those uxperLaonts wer- of o sosnletoxy 7067 6 fcgr LI -lt-12-4—ySj>* (vx Schw - Kurtz) Court So. 1 diflursnt degr- :>* iaportanes iron tb* sog^sticna which &‘»chor had • fff.do, r m Did yJi aot cnco s-riously ask your ooUflzgue Lutz to n:k& experizvnta with Beschor in Dachau? A. I told Lutz tfc t-Rzscher 1 a rfiggoations would ..at divert us _ Iroa tho act xr%roa of th- Institute, which * s laid datn in writing. Hatcher was a sea about whom we knew nothing in p-r ticuL-r and I die rot have the slightest reasen to change ay InsitituU'a progr.vn which^ nM been dtscuea~d 1 -ngth and which was pL-r.nod lor the long range, just because a young unknown d >ctor case to us with certain suggestions. I told Lutz that. I said, "I will not perform any experiwints in Dachau. Do you ;«ant to?" 71.-1 "Do yM want to?" was ft purely rhetoric-1 question -m Lutz doubtlessly u^orstood this rhetorical quostiui in tho way it was o-ant. Lutz hr.s testified here, that ho did not kr.J* Uv.t rny pr'yr-ja uxiated. Lutz toetifi~d ihloely thr.t 3 «ado a suggestion to Lendt. At tds discuss!, which c-n be the only one in question, ..uicit woe not «v«n pr~scnt and ^ndt will testify here ..lmself th-t I did not a ke ;ny suggestion to lion, nor did I cake any eugfipaticn to Lutz VCO* Lutz '.lco caaortod that ho a rumored ao th t he uca not robust enough for ouch ~xp~ri.-vr.t3. I do not believe that er. Lutz could h v~ vdo ~n7 ™ch -n vu»ov, boc-.uae hi would. r. v~ or.c~ idnseif rather ridiculous. Of courao, I kn» tho opinions -no habits nd the life of ny osiot-.nt, with whoa I work-d 1 or fo-nr years, *nd 1 den't or.nt to go into Ui~so Uunt,o in too much dutr.il ..ere; but I cen say that :!r. Lutz c.r*->irly h-.d no reason at UV.t tine nnd no opportunity to s-.y to x, that bo wot, not robust enough Tea- than- -xvri vr.ts. Otherwis-, 1 would have iv.-nindod hia thit th-t answer would hrv« » tie -dx -operr rat ~r ri- ic7-.v- 3—13-2-Foster (Ir.ts-7on Schon A P.onler) Court No* Z. his plan, Kith his sug c ostion to p^rforc experiments under you? A I loarnod “.bout that for the first tiue through Kottonhoff who told co about those suggestions. Thin I was once together with Raseher and Kottonhoff. At that tiuo h- already spoke* about his qualifying as a lecturer. I rejected that because he was on entirely unknown nowcorar to this work. It is custor.ory in Gcruany that before tho thesis to qualify as a lecturer ore* would have to cccpletc a nua- bor of other works. Rase her hod conpleted soao papers about tho cryst-llic'tion of salts, and tto study as to whathor one could ex¬ ploit salts for cancor diagnosis or endocrine diagnosis. Those papors, honover, were not of such a nature that would have warranted his being suggested for qualifying as a lecturer. In addition, it would hnvo been a natter of course for » to give preforonco to ry own people, who had be n workirv, on that subject for a longer period of tir». Later, wium Rasctor was detailed to uy institute, which nas approximately in Novc:.*.- bor 19ltl, ho -.ado thi suggostion to carry out cold oxtorlck-nts, as I already said. I also rejected that proposal. Q Tlwn in gon.r'1, I understand you to siy that up to about D-Ce.ilxr 19U1 ttoro w-.s no ,x-ctical work of Raschor's at your instit¬ ute "t all? A No. Q \ as that result of your antagonisn, your rejection of liis suggostion si A Cjrtaialy. Had I approved, thj oxperinents in Dachau would have begun 1. odiutcly. Q Now, tl» pros.cuter assu os that in this tiro you attorapted to a Vo rc ore Hippke's alleged rosistar.co to experiments in Dachau/ Did you do -nything in this direction? A I olro-dy described in detail what Hippie, *s attitude w-.s on the occasion of this rrutual conference in the suxiur of l?Ul at the FTjysong Palace. At that tiv our attitude was quite clear. \y opinion t-llied with Hippko's. Tharo vr-s no reason to remove Hippko 7071 6 ?fay-A-:B-13-3-Footer (lnta-7or. Schon L Hater). Court So. I. in eny way, but, on the contrary, I agreed with hia fully. I didn't dis¬ ease this point with Hippko later, and I certainly didn't try to chongo his CTinion in any way. There was no occasion for that. 7C/72 6 !Jay-A-*0-Iii-l-3lakley (Ints-Racler & Von Schon) Court No. I, Case No; 1» Q Then free y ou r answer I can note that the assumption of the prosecutor is incorrect that you attempted during this tine to uro- aote Rascher's plane in the Inspectorate? Cta the contrary, you actually prevented than? A Tea. Dp to that point I prevented Rase tier's starting the experiments. I didn't suggest anything at all to HippRe and consequent¬ ly nothing ras done. IP. HARDY: Kay it pleaso your Honor, I have no objection to raise at this tine; but for the Tribunal—and I'o sure for myself— it irould be much oaeier to follow this exaaination if both defense counsel and the defendant would refer to tin specific dates noro often than they are at the present tine doing. I think we could follow tho chronological order and the sequence of ovents core thoroughly if thoy used the dates a little bit more often. THE PRESIDENT: Counsol's sug^ostion is woll taken; and it would be helpful if countel and the witness would refer to tho dates or approxlnato dates on which certain events occurred. DR. NILIE: Hr. President, I would like to say tho following to this sug^oetion of tho prosecutor. I shall, in aceordanco with tho suggestion of tho Tribunal, endeavor to givo tho dates as accurately as possible; but I nay point out that on tho wholo those arc events ittiich did not happen on definite dates, definite days, for example, I say that .nscher until tho end of Docortocr l*?Ul was without any practical work. TE rRESIDS/T: Co insol, it is ny intention to convoy the idea to you to use probably only approximate datos Just in order to preserve sooo orderly sequonce so that it can be noro easily foll^red, both as we hear the evidence and when the record is road. DR. 7.IL1E: Thank you. BY DR. TRUE: Q How, Dr. ITeltz, please answer tho questions about col¬ laboration with Dr. Ruff. Ha; did you get into contact with Dr. Ruff 7073 6 Msy-A- 3— Ui-2-Blaklsy (Ints-Ranler It Von Scbon) Court No. I, Case No. 1. In Dcconfcer 19ul? A '.'ay I catch up with a few dates beforehand in order to clarify what perhaps has been unclear up to new? I know that Xottenhoff spoko to ae for the first tine before the conference with Hippko. Hippke's conference with Kcttenhoff and ne took place in tho sunt.or of 1911 I reaoaber that this was a long day and that it regained light very long. Afterwards I was in France, active in sea rescue work. I tr-veiled around France and expired the aviators who had crashed into the water and vrho had been rescued fren the seas. I visited the hospit¬ als in Cherbourg and Boulogne and tho sea rescue stations, and subseq¬ uently had a conference in Paris with tho fleet physician, in which Holiloahnor and tho chief physician of the Soa Rescue Service were present. On this occasion wo drafted a circular about rescuo froa tho high sons. I cannot state oxaotly whether tho first talk with Rcachor took placo before or aftor this Journoy. At any rate, the first talk with Raschoi* and tho second tall; with Kottonhoff regarding that subjoct still took placo in the wrr.or of 1®U1. Rascher could not havo been dotailod to ay institute before the 1st of Novoabor 19l*l because Kotton¬ hoff states that ho didn't find out anything about that. Kottonhoff thon travolod to Ruoania; and that »cs on tho 1st of Hovunbor lphl. In tho course of November, another talk took placo with Rascher. On this occasion, he suggested to e» that I start tho cold work. I think that those are tho dates which I can mention in this connection. In December of 19U1, I accidentally wont to Berlin on nnothor nr.ttor; I also visited Ruff on this occasion. Wo discussed tho work rhich was being dono at tho tro institutes. All tho rest is known es¬ sentially from tho descriptions given by Ruff and Roaberg. I told Ruff that Rascher was at ray placo. I told hia that Rascher intended to carry out exporirwnts at Dachau. Ruff on his part told ae that ho intanded to continue ills old series of ojq>erinuRts, tho parachute descent from high -ltitudos, up to 12,000 ntt_rs, which was known to ae already, but that TO74 6 :ir/-A-:3-lL-3-3lakl07 (Int»-Raalar & Von Schon) Court So. I, Case Ho. 1. he could proceed only very slowly because of his difficulties. Sot only did ho have difficulties because of tho experimental subjects being active during the day but also because of tho fact that he was limited to a very snail raster of experimental subjects. Then, if thoso subjects adapted themselves vary slowly to high altitudes in that case, they could do longer bo considered normal experimental subjects, they would have to bo eliminated. The situation at that time for no was the following: Roschor, without any of ay doing, had been totalled to the institute. It was quito clour that ho was going to execute tho order which ho had re¬ ceived froc Himlcr. The conditions under which Rancher told us that ho would oxecute the experiments woro such that ono could tako tho nattor into consideration. Nothing originated at my place boccuso Rascher's plans could not bo tallied with our plans. It was difforont, however, in tho esao of Ruff. Noithor Ruff nor I changed tho plans of our institute because of Raschor, who was relatively unknown at that time, but tho fact was that Raschor's plans to carry out experiments at Dachau soorod to fit into Ruff's experimental program and at tho s.amo timo an oasy solution was offered to him ro gar ding oxporimontnl sub¬ jects, whorois in ny institute Rascher's plans did not fit into tho gontral plan of tho institute. . I rojoctod Raschor's quaLifying as a locturorj but at that tiro I had no reason to bcliovo that Raschor would not bo in a position to fulfil tto tasks assigned to him within tho framework of tho pro¬ gram which I had arranged with Ruff. Raschor, considered from tho point of viow of an assistant, was a woll-trainod physician. Ho had rxarly cooplotod his surgical training. At tho Schittenholn ClinicJ • hich ~rs one of the first clinics in Germary, ho had been active in raich whore ho mato his doctorate. Ho had publishod a few papers, which spunks of a certain scientific ir.t-Tust. Ho hid a quick mind and know about the basical concepts of aviation medicine. That is in effect why ho took part in that course. Ho had worked out his own 7075 6 laklcy (Ints. Raalor l Von Schon) Court Ho. I, Case No. 1. procedure reading tho distance aoasuruaants which ho learned at Schoongau. Then, considering that ono rsndo demands to Rascher to ful¬ fil tho Job of an assistant, ono could well imagine that ho was well up to it. Of course, the aattor is entirely different if you consider Rascher. as an independent researcher.. Rascher case to ae with the docand that ho qualify as a lecturer and start tho career of a lecturer. For that his qualifica¬ tions were not qiite sufficient for do at that tii*. Today ray judgment about Raschor in that regard is oron noro severe. Rascher, during tho ontiro period, which I can ovorlook, did not have ono original idea. Ho always cLai-od the idoas of others without any scruples and represented then as his own ideas. Ho started to work upon these idoas but he didn't carry out a singlo ono of those idoas with any consequoncos. Ho always acted like a parasite and clung to eoaoonu olso who had export knowlodgo in any particular field. That nay bo tho caso with Ruff and Rooborg, Holsloohnor or Feix. 7076 ::&y 5-A-5K-15-l-Karro*w (I *.t. Von Sohoen & Racnler) Court Ho. 1 Rascher had no personal qualifications in the auxiliary sciences, such as chemistry and physics, and I want to nuke a clear differentiation hero that it is quite different for co to judge soceone simply os an cssi3tant or to judge soneone sicply as an independent researcher. Of course, thoro i3 another judgaent which is the noral judgeont. Porhaps I cay contion in this connection how ny opinion dovolopod in that rogerd. when I ado Kaschor's aoqoint- anco for the first timo in the succor of 1941, ho was a captain of the aediOul corps of the Luftwaffe about whoa 1 know very little. Ho displayed the customary manners and I had to reason to become 3uspioious in that regard. Why should I ic.vo bocouo suspicious? Ho was tho sono o apt air. in tho nodical oorps as any other captain I havo soon. Uy aorcl Judgaont about R sober, howovor, ohangod, when in F .bruury or M.joh, 1942, I was told by ny. assistant -andt and assistant Horgschnidt that Haschor hed got ton his father into a conoontrntion ocuap. Wy judgment boo.'jao ovon uoro rojooting whon I had this quarrel with rfasohor about which I xz going to spoak Inter. Of course, ny judgment become really nogutivo whon X saw his behavior during tho Nurnborg Ccngross. To sun up, I ..ust state that, from a noral point of view, ny judgment about R-sohor changed considerably according to tho kr.owlodgo which I h .d -bout hin. I- I . ow rovert to that arrangement with Huff - Huff only attached value to soo to it that these experiments were to bo - nutu^J. undertaking of both the institutes .ad that R soher was to bo employed as on assistant, I said before his knowlodgo for th.t was sufficient in every way. During tho entire further course of events nothing happened which could have- been the result of the fact that Raschor had not been sufficiently trainee. 7077 May 6 - -BK-15 - 2 -K or r ow (I t, Yon Sahocn & R cmlor) Court Ho. 1 „ Professor -..ltz, than, during the tine which you c-.liod your first period, you learned no thins against R-.sohor -.nd his personality or his soiontific ability . Now, I should like to coma back to a point which is of dooisivo importance for you. T at is tho following: At that tine, did you go to «. 1 rshof for tho spocific pur- po3o of offaring your collaboration to Dr. Huff or, in tho vital senso, Rasoher'3 assistanco, or did this wholo natter ariso booauso you happonod to bo there, in the oourso of conversation? .. Yos, Ruff had boon n collaborator. In a olosor senso, wo had boon friends. wo had oollnboratcd in tho field of aviation nodioino and knew oaoh other very woll. ..s I stated before, I wont to Berlin in order to visit Ruff and, at that tine, I didn't know what Huff was doing or v«hat his work was. I didn't know at nil that Ruff h-.d intandod to continue tho final port of tho first sorios of oxporinents. when I wont to Berlin, I oouldn't know that Ruff had started a sorico of oxporincnt3 during vjhioh he had difficulties with tho experimental subjocts. Consequently, it only resulted accidentally during tho convers ion at ~dlcrshof that those two institutions had mutual interests. Naturally, .... N'lf nor I did any¬ thin:: in any way which would have deviated fra- this originally intended program, ivory one of us could only follow the interests of our rospootivo instituto3. It was my inturost to sco that Raschor, who was unemployod witfi me, would rccoivo setao reasonable occupation. I wnntod to 300 that this unfortunate order or permission by Himmler, of whioh I knew that it would bo carried out undor nil circumstances, would bo exploited and used for an object¬ ive which was worthy. I wanted to see to it that the May 5-rt-BK-15 -3-K arrow Court No. 1 (Int. Vo*. Sehoen & Raculor) experiments ware to bo carried out under proper export leadership. ->s I say, that was ay interest. It was Ruff'3 interest, on the other hand, to got experimental subjects. None of us doviatod in any way fror. the progrnn or the intoro3ts of our institutes. It was an accidental neotins of our autual interosts. Wo clearly arranged how we were to so about it. This was to bo a autual und or taking during which Ruff was to detail Ronborg and I was to detail Rancher. Ruff naturally was to bo tho chief of Ronborg nd I, ns a natter of course, was to bo Rnsoher's ohiof. Ruff oouldn't give any ordors to Rosohor. Rafloher was a captain in tho ncdioal corps and Ruff was a oiviliun. I couldn’t give any ordors to Roaborg boonuso Raiberg was a oivilinn while I was a soldier. Naturally, this is how tho distribution was. It had to bo that way. Furthermore, it was cloar that I couldn't, in any way, rotiro. I couldn't Just lonvo R'.sohor to Ruff. It was quito cloar that I had to participate in thoso oxporinunts by exorcising super¬ vision but not by aotivoly participating. Tho progron had already boon determined. Nothing was changed in tho oro6ran. It was cloar that I was not to collaborate porsonclly. If any publication h..d onorged fron that work it would have boon provided with tho titlo: Fron cho Goman Sxporinontal Institute for elation, from tho ..viation Institute at Munich, and it would probably have'listed Roaberg and Raschor cs tho authors. Thoro was no porsonal cooperation on ay part. There was no change of the program carried out by do. Tho program had already boon determined whon I cano to ^dlorshof. * Do you stiU today, looking book on those things, -lo you toko tho responsibility for tho ngreononts which you reached with Ruff at that tine? '* 7079 H , y 6-»-BK-15-4-Karrdw (Int. Von Schoen ic Roail-r) Court No. 1 . k It 13 cy opinion that this crrangcriont to which I czao with Ruff was unobjectionable in every way. I take full responsibility for it. i Novi, plor.so explain-to ae and to the Tribunal - chd you icnediatoly on the spot in your first aooting with Ruff roach a fin^l agroonont to tho effect that experi¬ ments wore to tako placo in Dachau? No, Ruff has already described that. Ruff wanted to consider that and he couldn't coco to any orrongooont with no ianodiatoly. -t least not to any binding arrangoaont. Ruff hlnself noodod Hippko's porr.ission. Tho basic por- nission by Hippke or rather tho faot that Hippko had no objoctions of any basio nature against theso oxporiuonts I knew and this is what I told Ruff. <4 Now, would it not havo boon a natural thing, at tho tine, to negotiate personally with Hippko for his approval of tho oxporiconts? You had talked to Hippko in Munich in general about oxporinont3 on c.indocnod porsons. « I didn't do that intentionally. I toow whit Hippko'a opinion was. In tho case of tho new sorios of oxporinents wo wore concerned with a plan which had boon drafted at -dlorshof. Its nooossity oould be founded at «dlorshof in a r.uch bettor way than at ay place. ..dlershof was in connection with tho technical circles whereas I had no such connection. I know that Hippko would only approve inport ant experiments and I wanted Hippko to docidc, without ny influencing him at all, whether this soride of experiments was in oonplirnoo with his coalitions and whether he considered it to bo important or not. I wanted Hippke to note* his decision without any influence and that is exactly what he did. Ho gave Ruff tho portion to carry out tho oxpericents. 7G60 May 6-~-BX-15-5-Karrow (Int. Von Schoon & Hnnalcr) Court No. 1 s. Professor, you have already told us a lictlo about your opinion with regard to Raschcr's personality end qualifications, his scientific oai non-sciontifio chrraotoristios which ho had at tho tino. Now, will you ploaso tell us wh it you told Dr. Ruff in this respect? 7081 Court So. 1 6 Kay 47-A-16-l-iSi-Kaloy (Vac Sckoen A Raouler) A. At that tine I naturally told Ruff everything I knew. I said in detail what I knew vken I vent to Adlershof. I knew nothing about the -oral aide of the natter. On the other hand I knew vhat I have already testified here aboit the nodical training. Since Rascher at first had no porsaaent task assigned to hl= In connection with these eroerlnents and since Ecaborg ves to be the pomanent nan, It really didn't oley any particular part whether rascher had progressed further or not in his training. I as sure that he could do vhat he was supposed to do there and I already oaphasited that no difficulty arose because of the fact that Rascher had not been sufficiently trained. Naturally, ae Ruff and Rcaberg have already described. I told Rascher the exact conditions under vfcich this sattsr was to bo carried out. that these were to bo professional crialnals sontencod by ordinary courts; that they were to recoivu awards, otc. All of that has been described her© froouently in detail* Q, Now, I rotor to your agreenent with Ruff, a Question which, in ay opinion. Is of tho groatest iooortanco to the Tribunal. Did you not havo alsglvings against the cxneriaonts being carried out in concentra¬ tion cwpsl Vhat did you know at that tine, at the end of 1941, about concentration caspsl A. Fros sy point of view I didn't really think that experiments vere to bo carried out In the concentration carps. From the outside I had been isprossed with the necessity to face that problcs. At that tine I knew little about concentration caaps. I know, Just as cany others, that there were two casps, one at Dachau and one at Oranionburg I only heard of Buchcnvald later when Thaelsann had boon killed because of an air attack. I knew that uolitical and non-political nrtsonoro were kept in concentration canp*. I knew that at the beginning of tho vnr all the old prison, and penitentiaries had been vacated and had been transferred to the concentration ca=ps. Conscouently. I vas not surprised that cxoerlconts, which in literature are always described as having taken place In prisons, were now being carried out in concern- Court So. 1 5 Hay 47-1-16-2-IEX-Haloy (Yen Sehoen a Harder) iraticn casps. That didn't surprise ne because I knew that prisoners in penitentiaries had been transferred to the concentration cacps. Satuxally, I know that a nuaber of Jews free itunich had disappeared into the concentration caepo for a oartain period of tine. I remenber a col¬ league of sine vfco care back after approxiaately four nonthe. I didn't soeak to his personally but I heard free other colleagues that he re¬ ported that ho had been treated ouite correctly. In addition I cay ro- nind yourself, Ur. Wills, that you told ne about an aeouaintanco, the president of the Bavarian Automobile Club, vfao at that tine as a Jew who of '♦i 30 was also sent to lachau./reappeared after a fow nonths and/it vae re¬ ported anon* circles of the Automobile Club that he had been normally troated there. Of course, there was some excitonent in our circles about the fact of his arrest. Q, You hadn't heard any news free foreign radio broadcasts? A. Sews frou foroign radio broadcasts were not easily obtainable. No had rented a house and thero wero a number of boarders thoro who could easily donounee us. The whole thing would be punishod by a death oon- tunco and it wasn't as simple as that. However, I did listen to for¬ eign broadcasts and tried to forts a Judgaent. I oust say that this vno not ouite so staple. A great nueber of these foroign broadcasts was biased and false. I cust recall now that three tines I heard tho false retort of (boring's death, once free the Strassbourg breadcasting station, and onco frees a southern anglisb broadcasting station, and I have for¬ gotten the third source. Tho reports free the foroign broadcasting station were naturally easily recognizable to us as propaganda and tho character of propaganda lies in the fact that one nixes true and false reports to such an extent that they aro no longor recognizable b/ tho recipient. At any rat* these foreign broadcasts were in no way a sourco of information to us which could have given ua a clear picture of the true situation. laturally, I know today that the persons who had come back from concentration cases had every reason not to say anything, but I didn't know that, and nobody froa =y proximity had dis- 7065 at that tine Court So. 1 6 kay 47 -A-16-3-LEk-haloy (Von Schoen & Rosier) appeared Into a concentration casp, and I e= talking about my close proxlclty. Keturally, among sy farther friends some hod dltoppeared. Up until the end of the war I never had occasion to soeak to a poreon who had come back directly fren a concentration casp. Q, Sov I come back to your agreement at Adlershof vhich me tho point of deoarture of everything that followed. You did not reach a final ogreesent at Adlershof that Elpoke vented to obtain Hitler's ©er- slsslon; vas this done? You mentioned this before but please answer it definitely, the Question whether a definite agreement vas reached thore. X. Ho, no definite agrecaent was reached at Adlershof and Ruff already doscribcd that in detail. I made the suggestion to hie and ho vantod to consider It. "urlng our second talk with Roobtrg and Raschcr at nunlch he told ec that Elppko had givon pereisslon. I think that was alrocdy said here. Q, Vas this discussion which you mentioned r.t your institute tho sece one vhich tho witness Luts speaks of hero? A. It can only be that conversation becauso only cno such conver¬ sation took place In ay institute. Q, The prosecutor has brought out In this discussion soaothlng which he soys Is rother unusual and which Lut* has confirmed, that at the beginning of the discussion you csked him to leave tho room and he thinks that is unusual. Please cromonl on that? A. The situation at tho beginning vas the following: I had to acouaint Ruff and Rcnbvrg with Raschcr and that was the primary pur¬ pose of the conversation. Ruff and Romberg had come early and Raschcr vas not there. Since Ruff and Romberg knew the gentlemen of my insti¬ tute to a greater or smaller extent, I called ' ondt and Lut* into my room to giv^ them an opportunity to converse up to Raschcr 1 $ arrival. Vc conversed. There vas a lot of orofoaslonal talk and w« waited until Raschcr arrived, bhun Raschcr finally came, I told my men that I was going to etert the conference and I think it Is a ouestion of tact as to how clearly I would have to indicate thet to anyone. Lut* 7034 Court So. 1 6 «ay 47-A-16-4-LEn-r.al.oy (Yon Schoon A Rannltr) had nothing to do In that conference. I really didn't need the sugges¬ tions of ny pupil Luts. I was enough of an expert nysclf. Ruff and Eccb^rg were also not In need of Luts'e opinion*. The experiaents were •ecret In the ene that they vere described here by Ruff and Roabcrg. They were secret because they constitute an asslgncent fron which the technical develcpeent of the airplane was recognisable. In other words, it could be roccgnlxed froa the assignment that we were developing a high altitude airplane. If we had needed Luts, however, this would have beon a rer*on against hie presence. Luts would then have cone undor this order of secrecy, but on the other hand it is natural that whoever Is not participating in the work would ao t have been asked to attend any suoh conference. If Luts has stnted here that ho found It peculiar that he had to leave the r-oo, then on the othor hand I aa of the opinion thrt this was natural. I nay perhaps clarify this differ¬ ence of the conception of these people If I speak about a saoll cxnori- e-nco which I had during sy recent lnprisonacnt at Dachau. Luts hi/o only foun: out about that 3ubsoquontly. Frau Rcsohor 3008 on to say that nothing was dona up to tho tino to support Kottonhoff. Thet is corroct and I alroady stated that. Frau Rasohor goes on to soy that Dr. ..oltz was to start tho tochnioal execution of tho oxporinents. This is rather a quick ronark, boocuso I cortainly wasn't tho ono to carry out technical preparations, but, rnthor, R c scher would have to do the work and I was only to supervise it. She goos on to say, 'Since .«oltz foarod inturforonco tty Gonornl Oborstnbsarzt Hippko u ond of quoto, and sho goos on again, "j.s he was afraid of obstnolos on the part of tho -ir Force Uodical Inspoctor, Goncrcloborstnbsorzt Dr. Hippko, who described uxparin-nts of this kind as anoral, Joltz a atinued postponing tho beginning of tho oxperinonts, although ho was thoroughly acquainted with their importance." 7094 I'.zy 6-.--3K-] Court No. 1 (Int. Von Sc.'iocn & Roomier) I olroady said that I feared no obstacles on the part of Dr. Hippies, but I was in comp lot o agreement with bin. Jc wanted to carry out import ant experiments but wanted not to tolerate unimportant experiments as they woro sus^ostod by Rnsohor. I told that to Rascher at that tine and I said that Hi.jpke would certainly not approvo of his experiments. Therefore, the description as Frau Raschor was Giving it must be incorroot. Sho goos on to say, "In Doconbor of 1941 hu - that is .«oltz - askod tho Board of Directors of the ..ir Force Rosonroh Instituto Borlin-.-dlorshof, if tho bosses there, Dr. Ruff end Dr. RonborG could u»*. or taka tho experiments with Dr. ncsohor. Both of thorn inioClztoly ao cop tod, doliverod tho low- prossuro olinnbor and oano hero.*' Th-t ngnin is obviously a false statement. Frau Rascher i3 tryinj to nnko it appear as if tho oxporinonts whioh I disoussod with Ruff and Renter,; \k re tho sane as tho oxporir.ont3 which Rascher had augjostod to no boforo. In reality thoso woro two different kinds of oxporinonts. >«hat Rnsohor su^ 30 Stod to no at first was an asoont with a particularly slow spood; by a slow asoont lnstin3 tor hours tho compatibi¬ lity of tho persons for high altitude was to bo tostod. It has boon explained in detail whet tho Ruff proGrrxi was. It was to tho contrary an oxporinontol erransonont wh ro ospooinlly quick chonsos of prossuro took plaoo. It was ontircly diffuront fra. what Rasohor had suaGpstod to no. One couldn't at all confuse those two series, of experiments end Rascher must have boon very cloor in his mini about that. On tho other hand, Raschor was in a dilcanr. In his lotter dated tho 15th of May he had writ ton to Himmler that ursont oxporinonts were to be carried out and asked him at that time for professional crL.inr.ls. Rascher or iirs. Rascher can not suddenly s:.y 7095 ;:- y 6-^-B£-i9-3-.j:r-in3^r (In* . Vor. Soiioon ic Rcnnlor) Court No. 1 that the experiments which were considered at that tino to be so urgent, '.re ao longer urgent today, but on tho other hand wo wontc d to carry out quit.- a difforont ex¬ perimental prc«r:u., iwue-ly tho program of Ruff and Ronborg. Frau Raschor novoi by hor dilaonc is confusing thoso two series of experiments, although thoy really can not bo o .nf usod at all. Frau Raschor goes on to scy, and I quoto, "It was oloar- ly doterninod that tho experiments w^ro only to bo outhorizod in collaboration with Dr. -tf.sehor." ^nd of quoto. The permission to work at iteohau, naturally, depended upon tho porson of Rasoher. •*> never consider¬ ed carrying out the oxporinonts without Rasoher, booauso that would have been impossible. None of ua had aocoss to Dnohru. Neither Ruff nor Routers, nor I, if Rasoher didn't enre to agroo. If Mrs. Rasohor - JUDUR SEBttlNJ: On several occasions you have roiboratod that tho possibility of oarryine out oxporinonts at Dachau ’.upended entirely ui»on Dr. Raschor. IffD* 6 that the of.oct of what you havu said from tin.o to tino? .ilTNaSS: Y 03 . JUDO- SFB.(Ii»: -«hct do you aoc.n by that? I don't quito understand. In what way wa3 it solely dependent upon Rasohor, end apparently if it was solely dependent upon Raschjr, froi. whet you scy you knew that from tho outset, •/ill you pleaso explain what you mean by that? ..IThHoS: Raschor could refuse us ingress to Dachau at any tine. Ja coul 1 only ontcr Dac!?au if Raschor had ob¬ tained permission before hand, as it v/r.S done in tho ce.so of our journey to Dachau, or, if, as it was the case with Ronborg, Rocibors roceivcd a permanent pass. Raschor, howovor, felt hinsolf to be so powerful that, as Romberg 7096 Hay 6---3K-19-4—-rainier Hat. Von Schoen Bonnl or) Court No. i iica already said yesterday, ho could threaten Heebprg with having this ponsanont pass undo invalid for the period of tino ho was in the oenp. This would have noant that Hon bore couldn't have sotton out of tho concentration oonp. On tho other hand, wo oould never provent Roschor free eoine to Dachnu. .‘hen I was Haschcr's suporior, I also didn't have tho possibility to prohibit Rcsohor's 3oinS: I could assume after the coup oomnondor had ruooivod tho order from Hkxiler that we woro to carry out theso experiments and oertainly I couldn't assuno that Hixt.lur would suddonly recall tho permission thet was 3 ! von rw originally. Himmler's telegram constituted tho opposite to what ho h^d said bofore, for Rnschor says that in a lettor by Himmler of tho 24th of July ho had rocaivod permission to carry out theso experiments togothor with Kottonhoff. 7093 6 W-W?-2C-l~iiol«i (Hauler) Court I This cert-.inly had oe.n arranged with the c_sp cceaander, and tnls entire situation had been overthrown by thie telegros of Kiraler vhich case os a caolote surprise to so. It vna clear to no that I could not get into Dachau -s a visitor, but I could eanect, on tho basis of HisnlorU order, that whenever tho experiaents would nocossitate it I could 30 to Dacha u at any tine. ?eiu_?s I a^' coatinuo to discuss the letter. ?rau Haschor ;oe* on to soy: ■Veits 5..V0 the assurance th-t he would take c„ro of tho corres¬ ponding authorisation of Dr. 3-scher. Ho w_s only able, however, to obtain ono ossigaaent, which would on-ole iu-scher to cariy out tho preparatory worts at D-chuu, and stated ia reply to a quostion on tho subject by .r. Haschor, '3io authorisation can bo oxtendod ut uny tiso.i I I don't know wh„t Truu Haschor ooans by thcso nsslgncor.t difflciv itos. doccaor v-s always t-licing about thceo assignoont difficulties in dot-dl but such difficulties didn't roally exist. I would huvo given him tho o:\'.or to worts at D-chau to r ore or/, .'no .ocoud ro_.on i. that in tnl. letter Uentlon 1. nude that I u going to Berlin and .a. to .peak to Hlpoko. I «cnt to Berlin, naturally, irnhodlatoly after .<_echcr h J *l»en no tho tolegr_n. and I certainly didn't wait for tvo uonthc In addition, fren thi. file noto, Docunont Be. 264. the foUovin, rCuark ha. to be a.doi •Ob.r.tab.ar.t Dr. holt, .till in.l.t. in taking c.rt in the., oa-.erlaent. end ho fully re.pon.ttlc for th*. If not, th. a..lg*cnt of IT. da.chor to tho Institute holt, not be eh_ngoS.- *U refer. Vito ole-rtj to th. .econd t-lk bet.ecn 3a.=hor and ny.olf during vuioh I threatened hie to have bin r-aovod fro, uy Institute if ho didn't report to co. 71*1 6 Kay-WP- 2 ^-V-iiolsi (a_uler) Court I and tie next sentence: nTeltx personally does not c-ro about tno o^crlneate.- -Hot- is underlined. Fr® that sentence it can bo ..en th t I didn't Want to »urticip-te in these experiuents nysclf but th..t I only wanted to exercise supervision over d-scher. I a* saying tfc.t because is accusing uo of haring vaM ^cU ? ra=ptod by scientific Coition, th-t I wanted to ru:ove bin. fiie very saao Krs. -h.schor vie =-de this assertion s^s here, using h.r own words, th-t I w..s not personally interest* in those czoerioonts. The next thing refers to tno conversation with -ntony about w..ich I alre-dy told. If I Bay shortly point to the 1-st p-r.gr.ph: * 3 , Voltt confldonti-lly infornod i. ih-schor th .t there is gre-t uistrust gainst hi. in the Oft boc-use of the exccrincets; -Sb necbor.nl?- there 1. also oniuoslty in the r (Km ond l.unich for this ro. son." I tfcinS th..t this sentence refers to cy h-vin,i told Kascher or. various occasions th-t no would not always nention Hinnlor. If scaothin;; didn't run a. qulcSly or a. cuoothly Ha.chor w-nt«d it to run bv nlw.-ys aontioned hlualor, he always s-id, -I have to report th-t to Hiualor B . I replied to th-t that ho would hardly Bake friondo either with tno nodical inspectorate or with the *ir Oau if ho con¬ tinuously roforrod to hiaalcr in this n-nnor. 2— ?.u^IDE?I* The Trio-anal will now oo in rocess until CMC o'clock fco-uorrev. (2ho 'Tribunal adjourned until C930 heuro 7 Kay 1M7. ) 7i;2 Court 1 v-v 7-H-l-l-HD-?ester-V.;n5ohon - Kurtz. Official Ir^nscri^t of the juaerican military Trlbonr.1 In the a: t r ;f the United 6trtos _ of «meric* ~erlnsc K?rl Br ndt, et el, de^enoants, sitting e t Humbert, Gersu-ny, on 7 li^y 1947, 0930, Justice Beel6 presiding. THE HnAShA-: Persona In the court rooa will please find their se-ta. Th» Honor bio, toe Jja t os of Mlllt ry Tribunal 1. Xllltsry Tribun-1 1 Is now In session. God eeve the Ur.ltod Jtntea of «aerlea er.d this nonorr.ble Trl.unel. There will be order In the oourtr.om. TEE FRErlDSKT: hr. itersh^l, you -scertaln If the defendants are *11 present In c.urt. THE M*R6HjiL: Mty It plerse your honor, 11 defendants *ro present In tr.e c art. THE PRESIDED: The 3acretrry-0enorr.l will note for the record t.iooresonce of r 11 the defendants In court. C. unsel ary proceed. OH. GEORG JELTZ - Resumed DIRECT EXs-iIKaTIOK (Continued) 3Y DR. 't ILLS ( Counsel for the Defendant Waltz): Mr.y I remind you, witness, tnnt you arc still under 0 th. Yostordry, we finished when I - sited you about .no three d counts. rt-'y I n-v ''s.t - to tell mo wh'-t .u mrlntrlr. *s r> reoult of those three documents? «. These :re HO 233, HO 264 -nd HO 318. Those d cuaents without d ubt belon t Cv 3 otncr and deal with cno p ao a-ttors. The letter of Hre. Rasonor, Doouaent 263, Is r^tnor confusing alxture of half-true and untrue e^GjkJtents,Victim: at first It w s not e^sy — even for V— to reco^nlz^. the real uros- of tills letter. 1 yii believe, nowever, tn-S 1 can now soy thrt the r6serti( V-.^t I want d'to dtooae Rascher •'nd tne other, the assertion tVt tnecc werSydifflcultics with the ®esle,naont, thrt .on 7103 Court 1 »y 7 -k-1 - 2-HO-Fo s te r-Vo n Schon-K arts. C.-.oaa two st tosente are not correct »nd were merely made for certain ..ur3oa,c. The -uroose wee tv ellalncte xe :r a control over Ra sober. In order t>- underst nd why chnt se-acd dosir'ble to Raechcr, perhaps I nay brlefl: sux up the situation In which Rrscnar was when this letter was written by lire. Mini Roacner. Raschcr, t c olnst ay will, with.ut ay ?.36ist^ncc, cane to ay office In :«ovc.ooer 1941. Ho v s In Schongnu rt that tlae and I did not urge zhr t he be assigned to ay office. I did not n~od his. Richer said that he still rad things to do -t 3chon a ou *nd I w-a satisfied with tret. But when tne a&reoner.t had been • ronohed with Ruff rnd nomb-r.* when the worX was to otnrt In dachau, rtesoher ctlll did not cooo to uy office but I loarned that ne w*.e in ..ur.ich. I nr.ve alro -dy eald that. This as the occasion for oo to write a. letter to alia, rn offlcl'l letter, wr.lch I still remember very well. Ills lector w-a In a rather allIt:ry f^ro. It fftld about -a follows: You nre to rooort to ou; twice a voeX c ton ir. t e aornln^ on Tuoc-df • and Friday, olgned Voles. The tons of t..le letter was unusual ot ay office. Vo were .v.t very military In our be.v vior. I 0 enerc.lly wore civilian clothes rt the institute nd this letter to Rracher forced no to uo to the institute In uniform twice a weeX. Tr. t 16 why I reaealer It. After this letter R“6caer c uld nave no doubt that I emphasized ay relationship of military superiority towards nlc, and t.e:t I did net desire to ^r-r.t him the special position •; ich hu cl-lxed -*6 a. friend of .-.ixslor. Reseller's c nduct toward /.is superiors has been described here repeatedly. I reseaber uls meeting with Gravitz for instance. Rrscher forxally submitted this order, he "ctuelly anperred three tines. There Is no doubt that Court 1 Hay 7-fc-l—5-Ei)—Foe t&r-Vcn icnon-Kurtz tiie f-.ra in w~Ich I managed the relationship of military eubordlnatl in v. a unpleasant to hi a. I treated him like - subordinate. Medically, I treated him cs an assistant vno • e to follow instructions. And I have no doubt thc.t this was particularly cvroleasont to him end th-t these relationships finally led to the conflict, the core of which le Mrs. nesener's le:tor of the 24th of February 1342. 7 *y aban (Int, Kurtz, tot. Schon) Court Ho. 1 A3 I havo said, Raschor than showed sc the telegran which ho had roccdvod froc Hinaler. Tho fbrra in which I was clisinatod by tills tdiTr.u -3 so unusual and was such a violation of good nil i tary foxn, such aa vo ’ jro used to, that I was very indignant about it and of course, for ay part, draw tho obvious conclusions fron it. I have al- rootfc' said that I told lascher thit ho could not stay in ay offioo, than I dicta tod a letter to Walts dtasandlflg his dismissal and then he was r.otually dismissed. IJjr relationship with Raachor was thereby finally finished and I, for ay part, wanted to h-.vo nothing aoro to do with Rasohor in any forr. if posslblo and I also wanted not to have any roro oontcot with ax& SS agency, because it was oxtrcnoly inoon- aidarato of Htasler to have sy own subordinate, without any explanation, givo no a tolograa olininatlng no froa investigations In whioh I doolarod qyaolf willing to participate, .aeroly in order to permit an order of JL-aler to bo carried out. Q >hy I toko it froa your doscription that Raschor vas rulijvod of hia work in your instltuto by ycur request boforo you hoard anything of tho Dachau oxporinuntnj is that correct? A Ton, rufarrin to this bulugrnn Raschor had rofuood to givo no any report. 0. A for aoro .juustions on th. nltitado probleras. After as oh or 1 a resignation, dL. 1 you talk to Ruff or Roijorg-on the Dachau experiments? A I did not talk about tho experiments oithor with Ruff or with Rocfcarg, because I kne>. that tho secrocy ordor was in of foot and of cour3 a wo had to rospoot this ordor. Q Did you r jojivo any raore co.t unioations about tho oxporlnontn? A Ifo, I did not receive ary coniunioation?. 3 So, therefore, you did not kno* the final report of Ruff, Raschor and Romberg? A Ko, I did not know about it. Q So th-roforo you did rot know of the fatalities that happened at Dachau? 7106 7 S--7 u, Court To. jhan (It-*-, "urtz, von Schor.) A I td not hoar of any of thus* - ycrr what is your osition to what th. 7rosocution charges that ;-cu succeeded at tfca tiz*> in overcozdng tho resistance pot up by tho ?$yttcol Inspectorate against the Dachau experiments? A This ohargo does not offoot no. I exerted no influonoo on :-lppko. After this talk at the Preysing palais vhora wo had both grossed our basio attitude, I did not talk to Hippko about it at all. KLppko had given ocmisoion for the ojpuriaonts, according to Ruff's report. I olroatfr said that I deliberately avoidod exerting any. influonoo on Hippko, because 'iippko was to roach his docision inde¬ pendently and since I not knorring tho construction program of tho luftwaffo, aould not doddo her urgent tho exporirunts wore and of courso Hipoko 2nd =»ro lnsiyht in tho aattor. I in no '/ay tried to influonoo Sippko«s attitude* •fcr-, about tho frooSing an* cold cxporlBentS) what waro your relations toward ti e cold urporir. nts at Dachau? | A I had no relations at all to tho cold experiments at Daohau, Q But you yoursolT werkod a gre t doal in tho untiro fiold of tho oold prograa| would you like to toll us hon you Wuro lod to tills work and rhr.t your werk consistod of in thoso problem? A !fc* attention was oallod to tho cold problan in tho "inter of 19liG-i9kl by a report which I had b«n sont by tho Airfloet physician 3. This report sunod up a nurfccr of oxparioncos of aviators who had fallen into the ohannol during that winter, sono had boon roscuod success fully, sons had boon roscuod after they had (Hod and some had died after titty had boen roscuod, Thoro woro in particular vary moving experiences which thoso mar. had rona through. From tho nodical point of view, I realized how little wo know about doath from froozing. In particular, there was sara. tines a mysterious doath aftor tho people had boon roacned, after they ~oro already in safoty in tho hospital. They died and vary litUo was known about tho causo of thoir doath. Tte ±>ctrlno provaiiod at that tins that such .persons who 7107 7 'fcy 17i4MJr-2-0-*fcofc.nn (Int. Hurts, vor. Schon) Court So. 1 had boon exposed to cold could be rowarsod only very carefully, Wo tlsoardrb that perhaps they had been remrned too quickly. It was not dear vlv.t role alcohol ms to play in those rescues, should the people co given alcohol or shculd thgy not bo givan alcohol. The basic questions ttjpo astonishingly unclear, It ins not clarified whether the person slwuld keep still in tho water to save his strength or whether he should novo in order to create warmth, "it ms not clear whether ho should keep hia clothes on, his shoos and gloves, or whether he should take his dotting off — in order to aove noro easily. All those questions had not boon clarified. Thereupon, I received pemissiqn to visit .all aviators, who had fallen into tho soa and. boon roscuod - nost of then hr.d "civ. bad to th?ir units- and question then ebeut thoir experiences. ! also visit ad tho soft rescue stations along the cl-annul end tho French count. is I said ye sturdy, C also visitod tho cdlitary hos¬ pitals ir. Cherbourg and 3oulo"no TtCjcro sonotirvia scran such res creed pooplo wore trotttod. This work ima carried out portly in tho winter or 191:0 and 19U1, partly when I was ir. Vranoo for a longer period in .about August of iSnl. Then, stajdy by questioning those roscuod persorc Hi) lan mod ft mr*or cf important faots -nd were ablo to draw up a a -orandun containing c irtair. instructions. This for tod tho first basis for ire tractions on conduct during vc. ter Inn dings. 3 This wort you arc talking about, rrs that conncotod in any¬ way rith tho tap erica nts at DftOhau? ::o, th.ra ns no eon . motion as I hava air Cdy said. This work rraa noro or loss conplfcoi in t... saner of 19ul and there was no question of" -any cold juperlaenta in Oac'-au yot. »3o, th Proseoution has submitted Docunont Ho. Prosecution jshibit 52, in order to prove that you had been detailed for tb j freezir.; cficpcriaants ir. Tcdheu. TM.3 is the -.-ell known nifty* Ljtt-r. This Documint is in the Prosecution Book "o. 2 on pago 77 of th- Snglish text. loa Dr. ~*altz, among oth.rs aro aor.tionod as beinr; in charge to '..'ork or. sea rescue problems} please ocplair. this vt V* 5 7 H37 L7- '-ATT-2-1.-'e shar (In*-, :'urtz-7er. Scbon) Court ?k>. 1 to a. .. i r. vc-r h.'.d cry krc-.riodse of this letter. I loomed of it only hero. I was rot asked -.. ongagod in thoao oxperirentsi Prof. Dr. Jarisch, of tho University of Inns¬ bruck, Prof. Dr. Holzloehnur, cf Kiel, and tho Luftwaffe pathologist Prof. Dr. Singer, of Schwabiag Eospital." Oa tho 15th of Juno 192*2 tho plan that I t. -a to carry out tiiosc axporirxmts had already been dropped; and other rraoa woro sontionod. Tho next lottor, NO-286, 2xhibit 83, was addrossod to tho Roich3fuchror SS. It coucs free L. I. lU, and it says that Holsloohnor has rocoivod a research assignment on tho effect of freezing of w-»i- blcodod subjects; that to carry out thoso invast igations a research group "Hardships at Sea" is to bo set up; that this group consists of Prof. Holzloohnor, Dr. Raschor, and Dr. Finko; and that it is intended to dissolve the research group at the latest by l£ October I9h2. \ ? }fcy-:^!5-3-2-eiajcley (Inta: Kurts & Von Sc ho a) Court No. I, Caao No. 1. Koro again the experiments are reported on, and ny none is not oonticncd. I believe that the docioants submitted by the prosocu- tion shew tint I had nothing to do with the cold experiments in Dachau. Q 1 reoenbor here that you mentioned before to *uj that Baschor proposed to you earlier that cold oxperirants be carriod out in Dachau, that is to say, after you had tumod down his altitudo oxter i- conts with a slow ascent. Pleaso explain this to us. A That is true. I said that yesterday. When 1 rejected Rasetor'a first suggestion, high altitudo experiments with slow ascont, ho cane to no with a now suggestion. That was about Novor.bor 19bl« This now suggestion was that co3d experiments should bo carriod out in Dachau. q Now, why did you doc lino to tnko part in the froozing ox- perirvents whereas you approved tho lew pressure cxp>rinonts of Rufft A First of all thcro would not havo boon a possibility of carrying out those cold oxForimonts in Dachau undor good conditions. But ttuse exporironts did not soon to no to bo nocosshry at that tire. At least they soecod too early. At our institute .animal oxporinonts wore still going on; and this sorios of anircl experiments which wo had begun was rory successful at that tire. So that there wm no nood for us to ;erfom hman experiments. Ho wore making good progress with our anianl oxpa-irents; and it was Just tho other way around in this fiold which wo wore working on. In thu field of basic research it is much simpler and rare confcrtablo, realizing our other considerations, to work with snail cniaals than to work with human b-ings. Wo had no reason to want to carry out hucan experiments. q Ac far as I know, you carried out cold experiment#'on pigs, ftjrhaps you can concent on tlicso. A Later, in 19li3, because -f tho air war, I aoved the in¬ stitute to Freysing to an estate eight kilcotcrs away fron Freysing. Tho transfer vr-.s effected with consideration of the point of vaow that pigs wore bred there and that in this way wc would be ablo to got 7111 ■ 7 lfcy-!>-:B-3-3-91fikley (Ints: Kurts /: Vcn Schon) Court Ho. I, Caso Kg. 1. pi~ 8 38 experimental m i^Os, which of course were not available othor- wiao during wartime. The pig was desirable as an experimental anircl be can so exponents rlth aaali animals, of course, are United "trover dimensions, weight, and fur arc important. In the case of the pi& one cones such closer to tho conditions of toe human being. Tho pig is not only relatively clcso to tho hunan rotabclisn; it has also diaunsions co itc 5ponding to these of Iran beings; and it does not havo a great deal of fur so that in tho pig we saw an ideal experimental anise 1 as a substitute for a hunan being for experiments which wore rolativoly close to reality, and w> succocdod in finding a series of facts wo bo- liovud wore iriportont. Q So do I understand you correctly if I toko it that you tr.do experiments on pigs in order net to Havo to purfrm experiments on human brings, and alto boc-uso ytur experiments on pigs wero so satisfactory that you had no noed to use hu-vrn beings? Is that how I should understand you? A Tub. Q TJbon did you horr for too first tioo that cold oxporinonts wore bolng carried out at Dachau? A In tho sun-or of 1?U2 a few nontos bef ore tho Hurriborg conferonco, two dolegates turned up sent by Holzloohnor who asked ny associate Welts to carry out -xygen tests with certain apparatus 'thich •re had at the iimtituto. Kelts asked tho non why they needed it. Tnoy said toot they wore not allowed to give any details about tho experi- -.onto. Kelts refused tr detoraino tho oxygen content, ho inforaod no; and I approved of his refusal. Shortly afterwards, tho two nan cane beck and naked that w e so^d the machine, the chorolcrator, Sc Dachau, loaning it to then. *elts brought the toe non in to ny office tc soa ne and said that wo wauld net give up tho uachino and that ho did not want to hare anything tc dc with Dachau. I was present. I apprvod what ho said. It was absolutely in accord with my feelings .and on ny orders that ho refused to give up this machine. I did .oat want to have 7122 7 ifey-l£*i®-3-ii-dlakley (Intss linrtss -1 Von Scton) Court Ko. I, Case So. 1. ~rytM"g noro to 6c with Rase her under any conditions. Q 77111 ycu please give us the date as precisely as possible as to r;hen these people frea HOlslo e hn ar turned up to see you? A I cannot say anything more definite than that it uust have boon in the aumer of 19U2. I cannot give the date any ovoro ac¬ curately. Q This apparatus of which you talk, was that perhaps the snae apparatus which Rascher mentioned in his letter to Hinalor of 9 octobor 19U2? I cr. handing you this letter new. It is in Dccunont Beck :f tho prosecutirn IT, Pa^o 108 of the Eajlich version, and Docu- ix,nt MO-l£lO-F5 cf tha prasocutton and 2xhibit Number 73« Plor.so ccra- nent on this letter. A Base tor writes, "Tho Oltz Institute dcos not wont to ^ivo j o apparatus sin ply because they are afraid that I will have good re¬ sults on hunan oxporinents srro quickly than is possible in years of anlnal oxperlaants. Kelts, instoad of now admitting that wq roachod cur goal aero quickly in tto frooting problems through exporirwnts on huran bolnge arei nood tto ap.xvratus, r-akus tto oxcuso that nt tlvo pro- sont tito ho is conducting froozing oxforiaaonts on shavud cats and noods tho apparatus for this purpose." This is tho machine of which I apoko. I should liko to rofor to this enornous iapudoncu with which Raschor simply docandt freo .» that I oust give hi:, a machine which bo- longs to ny institute, a naehi&s on which to has not tho slightest clain; and ho said that I nsdo tla oxcuso that I needed it nysolf. Ho oxcecta that I shruld apologise to hia for nodding ry own anchino and for not bolng willing to sivo it to him. I just wanted to mention that os an illustration of Rascher*s attitude. , Then he writes, "Through tto OCT ’toIts is trying to got cap¬ tured Russians as subjects fee hia experiments. Hunan experiments con- dvr ted outside of camp do not soon expedient low." How Rascher cotnos to make this assertion that we were trying to get captured Russians through the K:* I don't know. TTe never oven considered that.- I don't - . 7U3 - 1 7 j4ay-iHG-3-f>-clakley (Inta: Kurtz i Von Schon) Coirt Ho. I, Case Ho. 1. know how Raoctor imagined that; hem ha thought that we were opening a private concentration cacp. I can't understand what this suggestion z*ana. Tie never even thought of it. I said that just about this tine we were having a groat deal of sincess with our aninal exccrincnts and that later we wont on and experimented on pigs. M^y 7-L!-3K-4-l-Galla3hcr (Iat. Von Schoor. & Kurtz) Court I, Coso 1. . Did Rasohor muk~ more lies and untruthful state¬ ments like thi3? .. Yes, ho nolo very many untrue statements, sofar as I can check hero. I remember that h- toll Ronbors ns wall as Slavers, that I was a parson of Catholic oriontetion. I never bolonjol to tho Catholic Church, and I never p xticipatcd In Catholic politics. That was also rn untruth which ho had purely invontod. I was on vory distant toms with -tasohur end oortninly never talk- od to hi:: on ideology. This ronark which Rasohor nado to Roabore, as woll os Clovers about the "blaok robed brother" woll, that is pure invention. I Coming book to Holzlo her, do you not think it was dangerous for you not to fulfill Rasohor's wishes. Thoroforc, you ogroo with tho dofendant Siovors, inas- uuoh c.b ho said on cross examination th it you wore ono of tho traitors who declined to make experiments on human beings, that you prof erred to have Gorman soldiers dio instead of carrying out experiments? May it pleeso tho Court, this passage was taken from the lottor of 24 Ootobor 1942, which has boon roforrod to boforo. This lottor nay oolneido sofar ns tho dato is conccrnod with tho porlod of tine with which wo arc ooncornod hero. It is Document N0-1609-P3, Exhibit No. 92, fra: Document Sook 3 of tho Prosecution, prgo 77 of tho English text. Professor ./oltz, do you still remember ny question I asked you? ./hotter it was dangerous for you not to comply with Rnschor's wi3hos? « according to what I soo hero in tho correspondence I would have to assume so. Howevor, at tho time I did not knew it. I ’i-: not know how dangerous Rasohor. was. 7U5 jj-y 7-ll-BK-4-2-Gallegher (Inc. Voa Schocn * Kurtz) Court I, Cnso Ho. 1 I lid not iongino tt-n of course, that he would report -v-ry detail to Hinder personally. On the contrary I thought that the relations with Hinder, which he was always talking obeut vias just boasting, but I sou now fron the correspondence that he actually had a vary strong inflaonoo, and that ho inforcod Kinder about ovory detail. I believo that Koschor would have bu-n just tno can to use that authority .ihich ho had been given in this Docuc-nt 1G09-PS; similarly he is supyosod to havo dono soaothing against his father, but I don't know the details about that. v ..part frai the fact that Holzloehnor's dologatos ocno tc soo you in order to oelloot tho C-.lorionoter f roc you, afterwards, \*>ro you given any other indication of con¬ duct in; the cold oxporlconts at Daohau? .. Certainly boforo the Nurnborg oonforor.ee, a week or two before, Holzloohnor onao to soo no at tho Institute, and suggested that wo should coop or a tho rosults. * Court * 1 ? olal 0,11 h0r ° bri0fly th-t there i. on affidavit at the di.oo.al of the Court of ^rofcn.or Xnotho which ref or. to tho di.ouo.ion which thc.v ooopla had -ftor Sn.ehorU -ud holxloohner'a locturoo. 3Y IR. VXSSSt q. Dr. *-elts, *-t did you think of H...eh«rU .t..tasont«? Did .-cm, -ftor holtloohncr'a lecture and .ub.«n*aont to *-.ohorU o^ovhat ■tr_n*o boh_Tior, feol th-t Archer w.. prob-bly - crtuin -1 or a dascrali.ee. ch.jr.oterT O. *_t i. -orob.bly tot quit. th. right tom. I ban .oy that tho n_a.tr lh uhioh -t_.oh.r n_4o tbl. r«al «-• ortrmol, dloa«roe- U bl. to M, _hd BcMhor B_fo aooth.r rmaric to m aft.r tho locturo. Ho .out past BO _nd .aid. laughUgU. that OhC. tho roputatloB 1. rulnod, ono oaa IIt. o.ry .oil. a. rolo -blot ho ulayod th.r. apur-M? UlCaBOd Bin T«v aurh. ahd th-t 1. Vhat «. fbUBd «- olQoaant. : u'.'s- say that aolxloahner*. attitude wj q lito difforent. C-art 1 .-:y 7-h-5-2-HJ-Hryr.cs-V,n Schon-nurtz. S.lzloehncr presented tile srtt-r scrl.ualy, ph d of c uree VC; c lhed rb at it. Baechr.er pi id Knothe thought that lzloabn^r had not contributed such that the animal exyericents bed not clrerdy shown and did not :nlnk that Holzloahner'a experiments were valid for that re-son. Did h ne of the orrticlpnnts of the aeetin 3 *..0 anything -g-lnst Rr.echer? =vce of these gentlemen were # obvl asly indignant -boat the lecture -nd Hracher's c.nduct, rad it w.uld hrvo beer, the obvious thing to do for tb.se -pec le to trice action. h. It la perhaps too each to spy th-t tne O o.*.tloaen wore very lndl 0 nrnt. I did :\j t ..err any oplni.n6 fr,a a st thea nt rll. I ern apeoft only of tile p« pie who wore nerr me nnd to w:.oa I talked nb ut the ;ar tear. • Knothe and Bueohner end Vert were three people woo repudiated the zeeter. Te wait -r .ent the ;tnora re llted it et ell, I do not /.now. In a uoh r congress, .an ^no la staffed with lottu ce rnd 6donce, -ne Is not bo rocoptlv*. that one lleter.a carefully t every lecturo If ,nc Is not eapecl lly Interested In It. I could very anally la glno thrt people did not ne r It t all, 1- n.t notice anything soocl-l -bout It. One v'e .t »lv ys lr.ltl * ted. It Is v ry r.-'rd to Judge now frr ce-.^lc understrnd things In such bl- aoetlng. ;. w , you ..uraelf lectured -t the Kumber 0 aeotln a . On the brsle of dirt lecture yoa ver~ charged, when the Prosecution a-de Its ooonln b 6t tea-nt, with 6 met.:iu. very special. I shell now h-nd you r. photoetrtlc copy of th-t lecture. If it pie ses the Court, this la document Volt* No. 5, and It will be ‘iltz Exhibit No. 8. Dr. Veitz, will y-a olecse toll the Court what Is 7120 Court 1 Kry 7-lt- 5-3-HD-Von acbon-Kurtz. significant, end now f~r the charges of Che Prosecution rr« justified? A. The lecture ^esls with rc-warclng eft.r dangerous c. ->lln.. .iry I point -ut once aore that "cooling - or "chilling" nenns the general chilling of the body, for cxr.Eple, in cold water. -This decs not oecn local frcez- lr. 0 , perhaps >t the errs or ciu. feet or the fingertips or the n-.a>, such as occurrs rather frequently. This lecture denis nly with the chilling of th- entire body. It reports cn nnlaol experiments. There Is no doubt whatever that the lecture derls >nly with enlnr.l oxperi- nents. I on -11 re'-d the third sentence: "Our exoarloental animals wore r-’cblto, rats, and ^ulnec nigs." We tested sevor-l aocsurcs to rescue those -nlarls, and wo disc vered that q;ici re-wnralr.g was an extremely effective cersure. Ir. ord^r to O lvo r figure, wj were able lr. a c so of anlcrla ot which 23 per cent died — or rather, were e& per cent died, we were ~blo to snow that the mrsslVv introduction of w rath Is the ,r..et effective. We s.i,w*i th‘t It anies no great ;.lffjrenoc In which f»ra th- weroth Is introduced, whether by short w-.voa jt by hot baths. Vo rl3o .-v« the reasons why wo believed that results which v. hd fumnd cn r.nlaals here were v*4d f -r human bv.in t s -s well. For U6 It was quite clwrr th-t these results did cpply to hum^n boln e o, -nd wo expressed tr.ls assu .ption cle-rly In the p per. Thi6 w'3 b.c-usu thw pnthologic-1 -ni matoaic-nl conditions In death fres cold, which h ve long bo*.n .y 7-IV-5-5ynea-V.n ochou-Kartz. /v. "e wore cortnIn,tand that w*e Very -tally 0 xr.rcG.j 0 d lr. 1 = ice tare, th-t -t le"3t no fora of the llor.tlon iv;at is np Herbie tv hu. zrr. beings too, wrra v tor of ol.ctrlclty. At lo-et -n. v aid bo effective. Now we k*™ tb’t both forns rr. equally effective. It is only "• question of technical facility, *a to which way rcrches tee b.djr quicker. '• K.v, i: • a were t. 0 iv. a final statesunt on nil tela, r.'.v 'oar -*nd r-dzlochoor 1 9 ex-erisont9 era in n t --C.. >tiwr, t..la voai. e-.r^e, I tr.ee it: •.a f-r rg the orr.ctlcnl headline was c.nc-rned, y-.a h.th "ohlov <1 the scjw rcoultfi. «s far ne theories and onlm’tl.r.a nr. c ncorned, you i und the oottor 8' lution. 2 /✓' think th~t Rrsch^r's *nd Kolzlochner's J-chnu or oriaonts v^r. c sblotoly useles ? a. y.j, no orr. not be ef this opinion. If I aoeak nl of tfle techr.lcrl *>nd scientific ascects an:, lynoro Z~.j toral 'Qp-cto C/spletolv, »n_ c*n ooo very cle-rly fr z the tw<. reports in wn~t enoh _>'.i sc.-s his Bain task. ’c K.re lr.t.rested in th_ sector wfclc.. • no al s ht beat doaorlfco "a b"elc research. v® were interested priamily in cnovln b bnsloolly ho-* anlanls cm to srved froa death - c.ld, and secondly wo wore interested in why nn -nla'll dies ir- a cold at nil. H.lzljahnor w-.s ir.terected in -tore prrctlcal questions, .-.olzloohnor w s trying to find .at whether w rctn orn bo - : by - hot Vt.. f by v srtfcd oeth, or by r 11-ht urndle, whether or.v can prevent coolir^- c spocl-l suite. r - lzloehr.-r investorted r. naaber of each questions nnd ujiv^d a of th_s # w..lch wore "beolutely necessary .and i -.ortant in ar-ctico. One can n.i any thot Solzlochner 1 s -r-e ’ iaents wore in vain. Ho erno to quite r n.ab,r of 7123 C 'art 1 -iry 7— i*“5-6-HB-E«ynus-Vvn schon—Kurtz c nclusions which ve .-.•’d not lr-vestl^rled at ell .'nd which ••3 c aid net ..:vj Investigated hoc'use these o-ncluslcns c aid 'sc drawn only fr-ja ojnaricente with hooirn bolnas -r.d n-.: with •nlarls. _ THE FRSSIDSKT: The Tribunal will new ;e In rcco&a. U recess w.-s trken.) ? K ay 47-*;-yjC-7-l-fceehan (Icj., Yon *choen) Court r THS XaBSKAL: The Tribunal is ageia in session. ST 25. VULE: Q. Sow, I have the following Question to put to you; can you without immodesty say that your discovery of the effects of oulck rewarding wra ir.portant and significantT A Kay I correct your Question? It was cot a discovery it vbb a rediscover:-. The fret that oulcic revaming can save the lives of chilled people was discovered in 1868 by Lepschineky. This work was ignored or forgotten, so that since that tine the doctrine nrovoiled that rewcrr. ng was daeger^is and night Iced to collapse. V e realised, of course, that this rediscovery wes of great slgniflcrnce, oepecially in wi>r tl.no, when marp* people are exposed to chill. The Sevy very soon reported to us that they hrd had good euccoes with this method and if I understand this 'inofficial Information correctly, then on the basin of this t*rk hundreds of lives were saved during tho war alone in the c.nvoy dostroyors in tho Sorth Sea and of course in tho future it will to r blessing. It wan vory clear to us that wo hod had tho real good fortuno which a resorrch workor scldto has, that vc hod discovered a liotsure which »*s vory simple and cheep rnd could be apoliod every¬ where. We had found something that would srvo nary lives. It lo known to no that in tho American press this discovery was hailed rs the greatos doed of German mod lei no during the war. I would osnoclrlly like to disown such exaggerations. One cannot rank scientific work in different fields ths way one can rank tennis players, that is impossible. Of course, it was cleax to U6 that our discovery was ir.cortnnt. Then, in the German proas, I was subjected to attacks beceuse of this verk, it wra ::eintained that I had killed nnny people in -echcu together with Saschor. I was celled a beast in human form. I believe it v;uld hrvt been better if the German press had used this spree which was dovoted to these ottac'-s, for an objective explanation of h.v trercherous iceth by cold is rnd h-w easy it is to save the lives of such pe.ple. 7125 7 hey «7-k-rjC-7-2-*eeiaQ (let.. Von Schoen) Court I If I reporter correctly, according to a newspaper report In th, last cold period, 95 ceople died fron cold. I also think that th*.se 95 people right have teen saved with a little hot water frea the locorxtlTe of the train they were in, hut these 95 people died because there wes no one In tho train *to knew what to do end know h-w dangerous death by cold is. I only wish what wo discovered nay bt spread and disseminated as soon ns possible so that such things roiy bo printed in the futuro. ^ hr. President, to illustrate whet tho witness hat Just said, I tculd liko to out in Veltz Document So. 20, Exhibit So. 9 free Docunont Book So. 2, an excerpt fr-c a aagatinu, nan sly the •Reader's Digest* of January 1947. This soys that tho nethod of rewarding was used by Aoerlce in the war against Japan and it is now a genorelly recognized nethod. This is page 77 of Docuncnt Book 2. Sow, Professor Volte, let ns ask you; did you do what you did in order to eoc that your inportant discoveries voro ndocmatcly publicised? A Cwj aont s after the Hurnberg conference, I published an extonsive paper in the wuendhnor Mcdlzlnseho Vochonechrift, a Oc-rr.an porlodicrl with a largo circulation. Of course, wo did not keen our disc -vorlce oocret, we published thor. as widely as possible, so that n^t onl” tho Goman -ehmp.cht, tut everyone who read it, including our onouies, could cake full use of it, once they had reed it. 7126 • - y 7-I‘-3Z-6-l-HoX3 io (Inc, Brown) Ceurt .:c. l However, within ay field of work I saw to It that the know- leljw was I'ias-runnfced, I o.lLi together the doctors of t&*- ' -i.scuu --rvic-. ..o delivered lcotur-s in Paris. However, we colloct-d the discoveries th'.t had boon node in Norway rnd on th- .«ost Const so that wo could work furth-r in this field, and of cours-, th^ro nro a lot of problems involved h-re so that it is not possible at any OR* tine to a .y that the problem is aolvod. There aro £mny questions that nust b- worked on in tho future. D.i. elLLL: Hr. President, I shell put in ns Docun-nt 21 , Exhibit Ho. 10, the paper th t Dr. eoltz just riuntion- o’ th t he had published. This is an oxpandod version of the looturo ho !cliv-rod in Munich. 1 Dr. eeltz, I havi ooncludod uy questioning on tho fre zinj question nd now con- to the last char^o aj».in3t you, n.vuiy, the ch ryo of oorw^i. *'lr3t of all I should lik. to «3k you wha; of thosu in the dock you know. I 3hnll r,. .d th .ir nai*j3. Karl ornnet, Hundlosor, kostook, you don’t know then? .. Ho. „ -mother n Holzloohner returned thu paper and in sub- st nti .tioa of his opinion pointed out things in Holz- loehns.r'3 report. .«e lookou up this report since wo woro very intorostod in thi3 particularly, particularly sinoo at the Nurnberj Conferenoo I had soon Holzloohner and it M was ascertained that tho r-port was not to bo found at tho Jodi cal Inspectorate. Thus .alonj this circuitous path \tc were not able to 300 the report either, uuch as it would hxvu interested us. . Did you know any of the other £o ntlcr.cn? .. Schaefer, Hovon, Heialbocck, Pokorny, Ooorhausor, I ’.id not know any of then. 7129 V.'-.y 7-::-5eC-£-i-2:xsic firown) Court To., 1 1 How, I nn not of the personal opinion that the con- I’wronc s in Nurnbors and cl3c.ih.r3 were aeotin^s of ocnspirator3, but I should like to know whether you took part In any consultins conferences? :io. 4 nd what do you havo to sr.y about the Nurnbere Confer¬ ence? .. The Numbers Conference was not a consulting oonforonoo. \ .T the innumerable papers and works tnat we U3e h-re only partially and accidentally totally a now int .rnrtionrl sfndard will be dcvelop-d r.s to vh?t is permissible, wh.at Is .l.lu to be of n dubious nature end what is to urself were present? - a. Yes, th-t is so. 713 L Court 1 . I'-sy 7-X-3-4-HJ-C^oiL*3rvjira. i. Kjv rt the aoetlng, the Berlin meeting r nd tha Menlch conference, what was the clo~r understanding c ncernin*. the ion who wer^ u> be used rs experimental subjects? «. first, let me make a correction. It Is not correct t- speak of c. conference In Berlin. It w-e slaply c c nv-rsatlon between Ruff and a: a If and later on. tho dleoasslon in Munich, we assumed regarding the -x eri- oental subjects what Acsohor always t Id us, and which wc.s to be rend lr. the letter from himalor, Wi.lc ho showed us •'t that tine, ur .ssaapti.n vra that th-se were legally c .ndonnud crimin'le, not pjlitlorl prisoners, thrt these persona wore to volunteer, -nd that they should bo rewarded In accordance witn the extent to which they voro used. That la vh-t Asohor C Id ‘>e, °nd that Is -la 1.. the Hi rami or lett r. g. Vi- It to be understood thrt nny distinction wr.o i be Eadc ectween ^craan *'nd non-Go’'man nationals? a. .’o did njt dlscuaa t .la point In detail ~.t that time because then tr.e foreigner v e not legally o ndoanod by German Courts -t ell. Thrt took ol*cc only l?.ter lr. :hu coarse of the w-r, namely, that German c irte passed Judgment on th- forced lbor in Germany. There w s very little of that at thrt tlao. i. Did this latter phase teko pices durln e the ouriod »hich hr.d boon set nsl-o for y*ur wjrp-rlo^r.ts, t.irt Is to a-y, eld your rol«tionahio durln^ tiv»t period of tlae cen.j, to . -ur knowledge did tho Gorcnn government ^ „vcr pretend to exercise any Judicial control over n^n-Gerxrn r.-tlonrls with the result thrt non-German nrti.nals were incarcerated In the concentration ccar? -t D-chau? 7135 Court 1 Xay r -M- 3-5-HD-C ok-3ro*R. ji. JCo, we w„re Breaking of people who had been legally c ndenned by German courts and at that tiae nly Germans were under the Jurisdiction of German courts. Tho number of foralaners wes very small at that time 6- th't they :l~y~d no r lo of ~ny rractlcrl lmport-mco. i. Then y.u understood these were t j be nrla nera w. were Gorsra. nati -nals who had be^n tried end sentenced b e regularly c.r.6tltuted German Court In Germany? a. Yes. That r s a re8alt of tr.ls trial* these Germrn nationals wiv. nod b._n legally c ndemned by c G-rorn C urt on oerarn 3,11 were serving t^rns In Jrche.u? a. Yes. Vfifl that the dear under3t~ndln e of all those who were present? a. I believe th-t those Conditions were porfcotly ole-r and were not misunderstood b; 'ny one because 1 : ho understood it correctly -1 ur first Discussion, *»nd 'Iso the witness Lutz nr a s^lu h-r- tn~t he understood It cle-rly -nd I do not bellove there >•' s any d uot that -lr.t whatsoever. Tn-ro certainly w's no d ubt In your mind .-bout the a-Her? a. Ho, huff, ?. mborg and myself did not doubt this r.t •’ll boc-uao this wr.s the cardinal point wnlcn hr.d developed 't tnu first c nv^rertl n with dufl lr. Berlin. y-s any distinction to be n^de In regard t the ;; ;e of ser-t-nce that th^se inmates hr.d received? # 7136 Court I 7/*y rj-fi A 5g, ve knew that persons imprisoned for preventive reasons vere involved. Tht w« cade clear tv the discussions vith Prokovsky, tut vhether these vere persons condemned todiath or people vith long terns there vas no distinction drawn tetveen then. I believe that it vas the general notion that ve just had to draw a distinction here In regard to the dangerous nets, of the experiment. I an referring ncv to the discussion vith Eippke vhere there vas only generel discussion of the experiments and no specific discussion. q Did you knew, at that tine, tho type of prisoners ‘too vere in Bechau, that is to say, vhether it vas tho canp vhich heused only criminals condemned to death and life termers, as ve call it in America, or vhether it also contained prisnors vho vere sorving o nuch lessor sontence for such less dangerous or severe crimes or offensos? Do you understand the inport of ay ouostionT A I believe •&. In oy direct examination I said that I knov that prisons and penitentiaries had teen emptied into tho con¬ centration camps. Thus, all the ia-atec could be cxcoctod to be tho sane sort cf prisoners that you »culd find in orisons or peniten¬ tiaries - froo light terns to heavy '.nee. q And you understood that you would oxpect to find tho sane typo of prisoners at Dachau? A Tes, I knev fron newspaper reports, as I srid, that prisons and penitentiaries had teen emptied of their oontents into the con¬ centration camps. q During the course of any of your prelininary discussions or negotiations vith Ruff, Romberg end Hatcher, or vith any or cithor of then, did you gentler.on adopt any voll dofined policy as to tho typt of men - inmate - upon Wxon you vere going to experiment; that is to say, did you develop a policy that you vcr< going to conduct your experiments only upon prisoners vho had been condemned to death or did you edopt a policy that you v«ld conduct experiments on prisoners vho had beer, condemned to death and else on prisoners vho vere serving 7137 f Kay 47-#-FJ0- 10-2-Xarrow (*at., Brown) Court I long: terms e* habltuel criminals, cr did you say that nay criminal who then was la 3achan who presumably had volunteered v-uld he used during the e-urse cf your experiments? a Skis Question was first discussed when ve sev the camp cocuander la Dachau. Thera there was discussion of the selection of t*t experimental subjects cn the basis of the Instructions that the camp commander had received via Schnltzler frer. Blnalar and then people In preventive custody vere taken. Q Vhat class of people did you undorstend could cone within the category cf tr eventive custody? A I knew that protective custody waE the sentence In the onso of unccrrcctable recidivism and were standard pcllcios here. I hnpooned to know this thr ugh a bock that a well-known criminologist had reed to r.e end had concerned himself with the theory of protective custody. The book is by Kolndl and is ontltled "The Habitual Crlnlnal" and there is a statoesnt of when and under what clrcunstnnces protective custody Is pernlsslble so that I had good knowledge of this as a laynan. Gonorally speaking, then, y -u. Huff, Honborg and Rascher understood that those experiments wero to carried out elthor upon persons who had been condemned to death or upon thu habitual criminal who was In protective custody? Zs that correct? A *eo. As scon as w® had spoken with the camp conrandor wo knew that people In preventive custody were to to used. <; Was It known to you that, at the same tine the Ruff- Rccterg-Rascher high altitude experiments were being conducted at trehau, that Rascher vre also supposed to be carrying out separate high altitude experiments on his own account under some sort cf secarate order fron Himmler? A I didn't kno that no. «s soon as the experiments began, I received no further news fr-m Rascher. I tallevo I have stated that here in some detail. HCarrcv (Int., Srcwn) Court I / A Tou i.ean regarding Rascher's second experimental series? Regarding any of Rascher'e experimental series of regarding the Ruff-Rorterg-fiascher series which was then taking place at Dachau? A Ho, I have already said, in direct examination, that es soon ns Has char shoved ne this telegram and from then on I heard nothing more. And this telegram was the reason why nothing acre was told to ne. ^ Then I assume that you heard nothing freo rny one concerning the death of Rascher's experimental subject which was supposed to have occurrod in the niddle of April or the latter pert of April, 1942? A I heard of these deaths only here in ny interrogations. Q that you said in regard to the April death vould also he true in regard to the two deaths that are supposed to have occurred in Kay, 1942, in what one of the witnesses said hero vae Rascher's separate oxperinento? A Tes. ^ After tho Ruff-Ronterg-Rascher experlnent wps completed - the ono in which Rcnborg was to act as a subordinate to Ruff - Roschcr was to act as the subordinate to you - and you and Ruff wore to collaborate, did you recoivo eny un-fflclol reports as distinguished fron official roporte concerning the rosults of those experiments? A Raschor nov«.r worked undor ay direction. Rnecher loft at e tino bofore tho experiments had begun or after only a couplo of axporlnontB had teon carried out ab-ut which I, however, know nothing. I oersonnlly know, at the uonont when Rase?-;r loft, nothing ab.ut whether the experl- no nts had begun 3T not in Dachau. ^ Upon what date did you understand that Reseller's official connec¬ tions with you or y^ur institute was severed? A I figured out note or lose as follows: On the 19th of February as it con bt seen, fron Frau Rascher's letter, an lnouiry was directed to the Relchsfuehrer SS rnd, at this tire or shortly thereafter, the experiments in Dachau were cut -ff. Tho telegram that was shown to ne is presumably the answer to this lnouiry of the 19th of February and it must have reached Bascher a few days later. Sow, it appears that Saschsr didn't show it t - ne lrr.ediately tut carried it around fra 7139 7 Xay 47-M-JJC-lO-^-Iarrow (let., Brown) Court I ftv days in hi* pocket, and if this conjecture of nine !• correct as la Schnttrior* a file note of the 28th of February, then that wes A Saturday, and on the Friday following I vaa In Berlin and reported to Anthony. Then, according to this, Hascher aust bare left on the Tuesday, before tb: Friday I Just mentioned. I should liice to assume, on the basis of these dates, that Baacher left at the end of February or the beginning of March. It aeeas certain to ae that on the 16th cf February Hascher was already under a nev eoesand. That can be seen froa Dccuaent Jlo. 318, Exhibit 67. In this dccuaent, as of the Hth of March, Hascher is at another station with a new Jot. In tho aoantlae, however, he ves with the Luftgau Modlcal Department. Tho Interval hero Is not very great. Bascher must have left ae during the fliut days of March, 71iiO 7 Uay-iL-' 13-11-1-Arainger (Int. 3ro*n) Court No. I. Q Did Ruff or Rocbcr- ever toll you, or did you ever gain any information from then in any other manner that during the latter part of Ifey 19 L2 a death had occurred at Dachau in high altitude ex¬ periments? A No, I never found that out. Q Neither did Ruff or Roaborg over tell you of tho deaths which occurrod in Hay, 19127 A No. THE raSSIDSJTt Have ary of tto defense counsel questions to bo propounded to this witness? Dil. 70R..ERK: Vorrxirk for Rojxjrg. JUD'S CRAi.FOSDi Just a ninuto. Cno noaont, Coujuiel. BY JUDGE CRX FCRDi Q FTofossor Soltz, you stated that you rocoivcd permission to question persona who had boon rosouod fron accidents at son 1 , per¬ sona v«ho had boon oxpojod to tho cold* '/ho gave you that permission? Fron whoa did you receive tho poraiaeion? A -Frott the Air Floot Ihysicir.n III, whoso scat was in Itiris and I driftjd around in his area. Q Who directed you to question those pcoplo? A I looked for people of whoa I know that tltey tod fnllon into tho soa and had boon rosc-ied. For instance, I knar.* t;*at ono such person was in Bordeaux and another in Boulogne, and I took thoso trips in order tc look the so people up individually and *sk tlwn what thoir experiences tod boon. Q You stated that you expi riaented on animals. rtho gave you this remission, or who directed you to niku these aniaal experiments? A Within the froao work of ay gonorol research -rork in con¬ nection with ny tasks at tho Institute I was able to carry out those animal experiments, and I did not need permission at all. I had general orders to carry out basic research and within tho frame - ark of tho pro¬ gram, I could do these experiments. 7111 7 »fay—”-3-11-2-Araingor (Int. Brown) Court Ho. X. Q As I understand it, if someone received permission or was directed to oake nir.i experiments, he did not have to obtain porcia- ion free Hiacder, but if the experiments were to be nedo on concentra¬ tion canp Iwatee, Himlor's pern, is si on hod to be obtained? 1 Yos. Q Then the only thing that Hianler had to do with those ex- porinonts tea to give pernission for the use of irc-tos of concentra¬ tion caai*? A Of course, we oould not eerry out any experiaents in a corcentration canp without Hirxolor's peraiasion. Q But, os I mdorstand, Hirclor didn't do the planning of those experiments. Kc would Just givo the permission for the material to carry out those experiments. A Yos, wu as nonborc of the Luftwaffe needed in addition on order frees the Luftwaffe, the nodical inspector, for carrying out the experiments. JUDGE CRAAFCRD: No further questions. BY DR. VOaf£RXi Q Profossor Holtz, do you know that tho Aviation Rcsoirrch Institute at Adlorshof in fall, 1911, published a report undor tho nuo- bor FA lhl6, under the titlo, "Parachute Doscont fron Groat Heights"? A This will be on tho oxpuriaants up to 12,000 mctr.n. Yos, I bolievo wo rocelvad that* Q then you knew that the Rasearch Institute was working on thj problun of rescue free great hoights? A Yj(^ I know that. Q In your discussion with Ruff, Roeabcrg and Rnschor, jea a there ever sent ion of other oxpa-iconts than tho oxpcrlmmts concerned with tho rescue free great altitude? A I be lie vo that in =y direct examination, I said that whan I went to Berlin, Ruff had r. credo to rrsinod program which he told no about and so far as I was concorned in this whole natter, noticing was 7112 7 May-’. VJ3-11-2-Aminger (Int. Brown) Court Ho. I. q la I understand it, if sore one received permission or was directed to n&ke aninal experiments, ho did not have to obtain ponais- b lor. free HiarOar, but if the experiments were to be nede on concentra¬ tion canp inmates, Marnier'8 permission had to be obtained? A Yos. Q Then the only thing that Hicnler had to do with these ex¬ periments has to give permission for the use of ina-.tos of concentra¬ tion caapo? A Of course, we could i»t oarry out any experiments in a concentration conp without Hizzalor'a permission. q But, as I understand, Hirclor didn't do tho planning of theso oxpjrLuor.ts. Ho would Just give tho ^mission for tho material to oarry out thoso experiments. A Yos, wo as oenbors of tho Luftwaffe noodod in addition .an order fren tho Luftwaffe, tho nodical inspector, for carrying out tho oxperiajnts. JUDG2 CRAAFCRD: Ho further questions. BY DR. VOBNERXi q Profossor Holtz, do you know that tho Aviation Ro3onrch Institute .at Adlorshof in fall, 19U1, publishod a report undur t!» num¬ ber PA Uil6, undor tho titlo, "Parachuto Doscont frora Groat Haights"? A This will bo on tho ojqx»rinonts up to 12,000 no true. Yos, I boliovo wo rocoivod that. q Then you knew that tho Rose arch Institute was working on tto problem of rescue free groat hoights? A Y oe, I know that. q In your discussion with Ruff, Roaborg and Rr.sc!wr,^wr.o thore ever aantion of other ox?«rioonts than tho oxjxrir>.nts concorncd with tlvo rescue free groat altitude? A I believe that in nj direct examination, I said that when I went to Berlin, Ruff had a predetermined program which ho told no about and so far as I was concerned in this whole natter, nothing was 7112 Court No. I* 1-3-^rminger (Int. Brown) chinged in this program. Q Thus I understand you to say that you had supervisory con¬ trol over those experiments in rescue free great altitudes. Before Raschor loft you, you intended to suporviso these experiments, is that so? A Hot quite. It was very clear that the purposo of our collaboration was to carry out this program. New, what would have hap¬ pened if I would want to change this progroa I do not know, because I novor discussed this with Ruff. Q Frofesscr tfoltr, you misunderstood ne. I moan the follow¬ ing! If Raschor had not left you, you were to havo supervisory control over Raschor in these oxpsrir»nts on rescue from groat altitudes, bo- causo ho then would still havo bolonged to your institute? A Yos. Q Through tho fact that Romberg was to assist in those ex¬ periments, did this fact limit your supervisory powers? A No. Those things wore quito independent of one anothor. ]*y supervisory control and duty over Raschar was a puroly military mat¬ ter and whether Romberg was there or not made no difforonco. Q You stated that you spoke with Hippko about tho varioty of tho possible oxperimntal subjects and that they woro to bo graded ac¬ cording to the dangerous no ss of tho experiments. Did you ever discuss this question with Ruff or Romixirg, or with Ronborg and Ruff separately? A No. with Hippko when we discussed it — with Hippko t!io word murder was used a little bit too frooly tho first time and it was later ascertained that those porsons did not always have to bo murderers. Those wore noraly theoretical considerations, which were not »sod on any concrete investigations. DR. V ■ No f\a*ttar questions. BY JUXG2 SE3RIHQ: Q After you and Raschor, Ruff and Romberg had your discussions at :*unich, when was tho noxt tire you saw and talked either with Ruff 71u3 7 ^y-M-IS-ll-^-Arninger (Int. 3rcwm) Court No. I. or with Rceberg? A Sitter on the next day or the day after that on our joint trip to Dachau. Q Subsequent to that tino, when was tho next time you talked • with there? A After our joint trip to Dachau, I did not eoe Rombarg for several years. Ruff visited co once. That oust have boon when he re¬ turned fron his visit to Dachau. Ho cam» to ny house. In tte meantime I had gono on tho basis of that telegram. Ruff told co that ho already know that Rase her had loft and ho said ho couldn't tell no anything ncro about tho oxperisonts, because they wore socrot. Q Wore tte ex{B rimonts that Ruff and Rocborg wore carrying out at Borlin in tho sano oxporLaant'l scrios secret? A Yes, tho fact that wo wont to Dachau did nothing to change tte fact that these oxperimonta woro socrot. Q toll, he discussod those with you, didn't ho? A Yes, that was a diffororrt sort of a socrccy. Himmler's tologrin was hireling only on the pooplo to whom Himmler had given por- raisslon to spoak of those things. Military secrecy in gonoral was of such a sort that otter pooplo could be excluded fron tte socrot. For instance, I could have callod Lutz and said, "You aw a part of tho question and fron now on you cast observe that socracy. In thoso dovol- opaontal assignaents that Ruff rejntionod which included tho program free Dachau tho situation was generally hold secret only in tho first stops whon it was bo Lag developed. Then after tho experiments woro concluded, thoy were declared perfectly opon, or parts of thaa were made public, because thoso results had somehow to bo cado general, ly Vnown. That is why wo ted the experiments. In other words, at the beginning of tho experiments there was a general obligation to maintain secrecy and later it was oitter partially or totally lifted. q 'Jm what date was it when Ruff came to soe you at !iunich on the occasion of your conversations you have jest been tailing us about? 71LL 11 I Court So. I. (Int. 3rown) A My last aeeting with Ruff after tte experiment began, you Q You eaid that after you wont to via it Dachau, then at •oae subsequent furled of tins after you wore no longer with the ex¬ periment, Ruff esse to HUnloh and told you that ho could not discuss the results of the oxporlrxnt with you because you were no longer con¬ nected with the oxperlcont. What date was that? A Ruff has alrea<$r stated that date. That was shortly after her left, as far as I can see. In tho first half of !Sarch, I think said it was. I qysolf do not know tho precise date for suro. I know that thj visit took placo after Rascher.loft. 711:5 Court I, Case i 7 Kay-K - 12-1 - LJG - Binkley (Brcvn) • 4 . Subsequent to th t ti*o did you over have a talk with Ruff or soo Buff? A. Y-s, I eait hia several tixos; for example, at the Gocrlit 2 conference or the confuroncs in Freiburg; but we did not apeak any aore about Dachau. q. Thon nothing was o7-r 3aid butwoon you and Ruff after tho conversation in -unich conc-rnir.s Dachau; and of the experiments at Dachau; any of tho results at Dachau; cr the fact th-t any of thu tests had resulted fatally? A. I only found out tho results of the experimenta when thoy wore cado public. I never discussed with Huff the individual experiments and, specifically, so f ~r as deaths w u re concerned. Q. Did you ov-r see Huff and have convers itions with hi-? after Uay 19h2 ( A. I-s, I have said that 1 et hi, for cxaoplo, in conferences it Ooerlitz and Freiburg. I »ot hiu : eVoral times. q. All of those conferences wore after tho month of Kxy 19Wt A. Yes. THE rH2SID3:T: Are there any other questions of thu witness by defense counsel? DR. MARXi Dr. Karx for Bccker-f*eyseng. BXAl'IKATIOH BY DR. MARXi Q, Prof-ssor, 1 gathered from your direct examination that re- g rding ^aschur'a plans for high altitude -xp-riuvonts in 19U1 and l?h 2 you spoke both with irof-ssor Kip ke and Frofessor Anthony, tho expert for aviation ^-dicino ir. the ' edical Inspectorate of the Lnftwaffo at that tL»e* Let ex ask you nc U cl. r up this matter whether at this timo you 3 . okc with krofosscr fer.t -.v'liable. Did you receive s-vnv.l r.a.arch ossigne-nts/ A. Y-s, w« did. ... Can you not r- u bor a r—-.rch usui^r. «nt of th. your 19hli? a. 8 re:. nai,n>.nt t.i *e r.Cwlv^d had a sort of p^culi r ori-in. -cause of nrr.-.ucr; ale dif iculties *e h *.d no funds .veil couldn't c.tM- thin 3 in c^hj and We sUply had to send bills. 1 ft £d, wnths 1 t.r, by the Luftgau. santKi tly, it w*o an unpleasant fact th t couldn't buy" nything, not even . ^ncil or r. -rnswr, but could only buy it on ccount. For this reason 1 .ad - r.s.arcn nssi r. -at iv.n to e. This -:-ant w t w« recai -d sorv. r-ady c ah; nd I chos. as the subject for this r_- s. ref. nasi n.-.nt zny old subject ta t wo "_ro working on anyway. 1 ait just told, Frofessor, t' t it was t r.Se .rch assi .is -nt 711x9 Court I, Cesc 1 7 iky -: - 12-5 - Lv~~ - -Inkle* (Brown) ' r«£ rding the g Jtrc-int-stir-Jl charm-1 under pr-scur-. A. 1-5, tat was a for.-.J. r-3-arch assigno-nt. Bef_ro I founded the institute, there verc research 3si.%n '-nts th .t w_r_ of soio significance. Thun at the o-ftinr.ing of ay civilian institute, before tho V-r, this research assiare^nt wan of sotvj taportencoj but 1 -tor, • during tho war, it h d none. It b-c sso _f no i-port-.nco when tho Insti MU* f r -dicino was founded; th t is to say, it had no furth- -r scientific i port nee. It did iavu a financial importance. Q. nhu.n you m-ro giv-n this aasi-in-nt, did you r^ceivo any instructions regarding ho- ou - to carry on your r-s-'-rchY A. Ko, and in general t: t was net possible. THS ;':tESIDErr« Counsel, the Tribun.1 will new b- in rocoss until 1:30 o'clock. (A r-coso rj t-Jccr. until 1330 hours.) 715C 7 kay 47-A-7jC-13-l-7oster (Int., Ton Schema) C-urt I AJTlcSOCS SESSIOK (She Tribunal reconvened at 1330 h.urs, 7 kay 1947.) TFL .iASSEAL: The Sribunal 1# egain session. DR. GLQ3J WLLTZ - aesu-.ed TEL PRLSIDL5T: Any further cuestiens to bb propounded to this vltness by defenee counsel? Dr. Marx does not seen to be present. He had not coapleted hie examination. DR. -on (C -unsol fir the Defendant Welts): Mr. Proeldent, qy colleague Dr. Marx asked ce to tell you that he has no nore Questions to put to this vltness. TEL PRLSIDLS7: The prosecution nay cross examine. CROSS LXAKISATIC® BT *R. KAEDY: Q Dr. Welts, vhere vere you at the end of the war? A At the end of the war I was In Iking, 25 kllonetcrs ouuth of Munich. Q Wero you takon prisoner by the Allied Forces at the ond of tho wer? A So, I re-mined In ny snail country h-use until on tho 20th cf July 1945, I was roouested at ny city heno to report to tho CIC in Munich in Heuerkirchstresso. Up to that tine I was free. ^ When wei tho first tine that you wore placed under arrest and in¬ carcerated in a prisoner -,f ver eanp r civilian interment canp by Aaerlcan authorities? rio* only arrested once, fhat is, I wrs asked to report on the , f/t/KV 0k 21st of July lnNiauerklrchstrasse la Munich, the CIC. 7ron there, I was sent to the pri'sJd at Freising for sone tine, then I was a prisoner in the hospital in liaising—I had beo:ro sick. Then on the 26th of September 194$, J believe it vi«, I 'vnt to the Mcosburg Canp. I steyfd lajj&*wc until the 6th of December 1945. Tho 6th cf December 15v5^—?-vSs transferred tc Dachau. V$1 7 May 47-A-F„*C-13-2-7o-~4r (let.. 7cn Sehoen) Court I q What vs a the reason why yen vere pieced under arrest at that time In July 19467 A I never learned that. q Were you In the automatic arrest category because of ycur rack? A I vas teken avay free Freising In automatic arrest to Moosburg. Q S;v, you had on institute in Munich. When did you first take charge of this Institute in Munich? A You mean nev the Institute fer Aviation Medicine of the Luftwaffe? Q Tes. A This institute was assigned to no when It was founded. It was founded on paper In the fell of 1941. q Hov long did you reaain at the institute after It vne founded, until tho end of the vnr? A Until tho end of the vnr, yes. q lid the institute evor recolve any boohing*? A Yoe. q Was it sovorely damaged a* a rosult to tho bootings? A I have already *aid that in 1943-44 I ooved the institute one soction at a tino. One department vent to Freising, one vent to the State Farm 3irehnu near Freising. Bathing happenod to theso barracks, tut tho original tvo barracks vhlch ro-ained in Munich, and the labora¬ tory that remained there, vero completely burnod out in 1944. They wero wooden terracks and n.thing remained of them. q Well, nev, vhen you moved your Institute because of the bootings were you able to salvege y-ur eoultcent, your filoe and furnituro, and the necessary things, so that you could continue your work? A To Freising and to the State Farm at Kirschau, ve moved almost all the scientific eauipcont vhich ve noede, but the laboratory ifhd tho official files vhich did not refer to tur research remained in the ■pfe in Munich. We couldn't move the safe and besides, the laboratory vns still working there. I have already seid that the files of the Institute for Aviation Medicine and the files of the laboratory ware 7152 ? May 47 -a-FJC— 13-3-7otter -(Iat., Tea Schoen) Court I taken care of together by Stebsarst Vendt, and Stabsarzt Vendt regained ia Munich. All the file* which referred tc transfers, assignments, secret records, they were turned ia Munich la 1944. Ill the new records were kept at Freising, tor scientific records, the library, special publica¬ tions, and so on, we had taken with us. That wes oartly at Hirecheu end partly at Freising. Q How, dc you recall being interrogated in June, that is the 6th day of June 1945, that is bofore the tico you were arrested—you were still ■ free nan—by Major Alexander of the U.S.Aray Kedicel Corps? A That was not an interrogation, at leest • didn't reallzo that it was an interrogation. Professor Alexander ca-.e to us as a scientist who was Interested in jut work. He asked us about our work, Vo had pre¬ viously been visited by sobs aviation oedical comissions end we shewed Professor Alexander what he was interested in. It wan no interrogation. Professor Alexander did not represent hlnself as an investigator but he presented hlaself as a Doctor who was interested in our scientific work, and wo discussed with hin the future of the institute. I c uld not see that this was any legal exaalnation or any such thing. Q Veil, now, Dr. Alexander, that is the sane Professor Aloxander who appeared here as an expert witness, was interostsd in chatting with y.u, or interrogating y-u, concerning your work, or any work, on shock fr ms exposuro to cold on hunan beings. Did you inforn hin about your knowledge of experimental on anicalsl 7153 7 Hoy 47-^-S'-—!1 -co nontionod propounded certain questions to tho wltnoss, and tho wltnoss has answered tho suuo. If tho rcoord is preserved, tno quostlon propounded by that question can bo taken frou that record and propounded to tho wltnoss. With that understanding the objection ovor-rulod. 3Y i.R, ZsSOTl 3 . Dr, t'olts, what w-s your reason for not info ruing tho officlalo of the United Statos aruy in this Gutter about all tho activities at Dachau cencoming exp eric oat at ion on huaun beings, wherein you woro fully aw. jo of tho activities, inosaucb -s you had known tho results of Profossor Holzloohnor's work at livrntorg Conferonco. Vo# it bocauso you thought you eight oo iuvolvod in scco criuinal activity, or, v_s it because you did not want to give tho oceey further inforuation? 7 Key 47-«-S‘—14-3-OaUcfihcr-Iat: von Schocn Court So. 1 *• I olrcudy aold th^t Professor ^loxuador nev_r ia any way vu rocog- alaablo as or presented hinself to ae, or to ay associates, us on offic¬ ial invest lent or, and particularly not as an investigator of tho jeor- ican Judicial or intelligence Servico. He cuae as a scientist uho was lntorootcd. I iurgine the scientist w j extremely lntorostod in knowing wkotr.or or not tho work os result of your research, and the roooerch of Lepchineky of the 1800 , had been performed on huoan bolngs; not frou 0 legal aspoot, but free an scientific -spocj. Tou had far uorc rocsons to infora Dr. Alexander about that work on tho hu m an bcingc, didn«t youT a. I olr c.jjy said that I gavo ''rofessor Alexander all tho filos cojplotoly wo hud preservod oxccpt what woro burnod in Munich, wnloh wcbo not of intcrost to Dr. Alexander. I had ro.ison not to toll any¬ thing unloss I was uskod directly for the following roasons: At that tir.u th.re started a wu*o of orrvsts, wnich no ono could then grasp. I rououber a nuabor of uy ocqualntoncoe hod been or r os ted, and wo did not know for what rousona they were urrentod, und wo did not know whoro tho oooplo woro boing sent. Xhor»foro, in ordor not to bring anyone in tho danger of arrest I said no noro than too things for w,» ch I was responsible. I gave ''rofossor Alexander ull tho inforaation about things for wnich I wao responsible to do. X did add nothing, for ronsono of ccaradoship. I did not concidcr I hud any right to glvo any additional inforaatlon, and put other people in danger of arrest, bccaU'O wo could not soo how that information would bo used. Then you wore uttaipting to covor up Dr. Raschor? 0 a. I knew very little about fiascher's activity. You know ull about his activity. You woro at the Octobor neeting in 1942T a. Vos, it bocaio quite clear here how such I .cnew about Raseher. I know that ho porforued tho exp or is cats in Dach a u together with Holrloei>- 7 Kay 4?-,r-SV-14-4-Galicghor-Int: von Schon Court So. 1 cor. I did cot know th.t any do-ths hud occurred. I did not know to what oxtent these experinents were legj. I knew very littlo about thcc. Particularly of course, since uy knowledge was so indofinito, I and no reason to talk about other institutes, anc boc-uso it h.-p>ened outside of ay ova institute, which was soaetoing about which I had no exact inforu^tion to giro. "octor, this oxeuicatlon is going to tuko considerable longth of tiuo. During the remainder of the examination I want you to coop¬ erate, and I wont you to try to bo consistent. You have introduced a docuuont horo this morning uhoroln you have attcuptod to show this Tribunal how important w a s this work on Shock Jroa xhposuro to Cold to tho united States Huvy aid allies in tho Asiatic uroa, which was writ tor. in the Boudors Digest; and here you state now inconsistently that you yoursolf woro violently oppoood to voluntooring any i.tfor- uation on tho oxoorlnentg! work cccductod on huma n beings, a nd that tho answer vu* avullablo for tho Unitod States hodical survicos by virtuo of your knowledge at the conferonco in October. Mow, Doctor, wo shall try to prococd froc horo uad do so in a bettor uannor than you havo for tho lust half hour. a. hoy I correct what you Just said. Two oxnert commissions hrd visitod us before ta^t time, «riution medical oxperts, and I gavo those two commission* all our ctudios published and wh-t had not boon •published us yet. Vo showod tnose gontloaon all our films; wo sado all our filos available to thou, and also wo 6avo thoo cur ccpaJato prints. I draw vp a report in fivo copies cn the work waich was boing carriod on, and made suggestions how to keep the institute going, and how our ax'crloaco can be turned ov<_r to the hands of tho ^icrican aniioo. uo undo detailed suggestions. Did you also tell those invo-.tig^ting toems tnat exo •.rinents on h nan beings h_d been eocductod at Dachau? 7 Xay 47 -^-s^-l 4 - 5 -G^llu^aer-I^t : von Scnoen Cc -rt So. 1 -w I said.. 3Uit con bo answered, yes or no. Doctor? Did you or did you not? Am I told tboc about the work of ay institute, and not of other institutes. v. ihat is what I understood. When did you join tho aSDaP,Doctor? Am I suid, that was 1937. <• 1937. Tou were also a ucuber of the Satlonal Socialist Physicians' Association? Am roe. Tou were a aaibor of tho Uationul Socialistic Locturors Asoociution? as Too. “ow when did you coue into tho Iwftwaffe? Tou soy in yair rrfidorit in august 1939. “ow, what was tho first rank you hold in tho Luftwaffe?" 7158 (hurt 1 Kry 7-j»-15-l-HD-E»yn08-Vvn Schon. a. 1 wns St-ba-rtC. That Is the s:ce t..in c -s ccptnln. v. «nd then when were ye nr.acted t. anjor? a. I believe round the frlat a-If cf 1940. I don’t rase after exactly. ... Old ou rise any higher? a. At the end of the w?r I w-a Cborfeldnrzt. The.t Is equivalent to lieutenant c lonel. *. Thnt we t. e last r-nh y.»a h Id In the Luftwaffe? a. Th^t wpa trv, .. 1 -nest r/»nfc, yea. i. Vhen .our Institute v 6 first formed, in 1940, s * r was It - a. 1S41. %. In 1941, wh t w s the nra> of oar Institute at that tlce? a. The Institute w a r lv»ye C"ll-6 "Institute for AVl-tl n Hadlolno, “ Hunlch. ■ W. Vhnt w a Luftoau Nuaber 7? a. The Luft 0 nu 7 w-8 tr.e r *lon 1 or^ nlzrtl n of the Luftwaffe. All Oeru-r.y v s divided lnt'. a r, aber of Lui'te"us, -nd Luft^ru No. 7 v~s the one In the -roa r.round H.nloh. «. And were y.e under the Jurlsdlctl n of Luft^nu No 7? ‘ A. : ,v ec nviic nd disciplinary purposes, I rs under Luft^r.u 7. *6 nerd of t-.o Institute, In scientific r-5"vets, I w a under the Xedlc 1 Inspectorate of .-.vlVtlun Kedlclno, directly. d. Th-t would ee ntn. .ys office? • H. Yc8. ’-all, n.w, lr. Luft^u K . 7, did tu-y h.ve r. aedlcal -\o*:rr ta.nt? 715? C.urt 1 I '.-y 7-«-i5-i-iij-fifync6-V.n ochon. a. Xee. They n d e mecic 1 -ffleer there. he w s cne Loft e au physician. %. Did they ov fc r consult witn o- ib.;t rny matters of resj^ren or things of t.vt nature, between tr.e nodical tap t-taunt of Luft c eu No. 7 rnd y.ur Inr Citato? a. No. In scientific t..in s s va ..d nothing t-. to with 11 . luftgru, cxceot in the rare c:eas v.icn the Luf t c au c-llid upon us, for excarcle, in the trr.ning c.ursu which Ere char writes of. In such caec6 wo wire calloc. up. n to help in the projects .f the Luftceu, but the UiftoC.u had no Influence or. ur r-eerrch work. Thu reaerren nesl 0 n- .aent 3 , re I ivve already anl~, wore In p rt ; .c .-r:.in. to directives which I received from t o Hidlc 1 Inspeutorate, pn& a outlines I receiver definite rsel-nmenta fr m the hotlor.1 Ins pec torn to. i. Veil, now, did the medic 1 teprr*.oent of Luft_.AU H.. 7 have c nsultmts or sped Hate or. t.iolr staff; eay, for Instance, did cne n.dic’l cemertojnt of Luft 0 au Ko. 7 .we Intornista, -nd things of t .At nature? a. I wo Id Assume so, yes. All the doctors who worked ot cho Luft 0 cu, nad a oertaln field th?t they were in o-' r^o of. %. Suoose js wanted s^not. ln^ done; bjo >oee you were f- rmln 5 research, for n moment, end you wanted some ‘‘rtloular wor.-c done for ’ou In the c.urse cf . ur research whloh you c Id not dc yourself :aocuA3 of cne fret teat y : c-.ld not h-rvu a specialist ir. y~ur or^rnlzoti-n t^,do lc for you. Then vno w uld you h’ve referred to? •'••old u n ve referred to L ftgau Nc. 7 and asked them for cn expert or ?eked them to t< ke core of this p. rtloular situation thet y.uv-nted cie;red up? a. I car. not im- 0 lne a c se sue.*. s .u re eshln 3 7130 C.urt 1 X~y ?-«—15—3-HD-H’ ynea-Y n Schon. Y'-- -asuae thr c toe Luft c pu = lvea se a research ssaignmsnt? ... Ho, no, whst I na tryin = Co s l j t la this: D. • - recall one cf our docuaenta concerning freezing, vh.reln Dr. Kjlzloehner, Dr. rinkc ?nd Dr. Singer were roc amended t carry out-it la Docuaent I.’o 283, -n P'ge 12. It is ? letter fr^a Poacher to .-..aaler, where he at tea thrt he has tailed for peral6«ion—toot la, .-Up- dee hra .eked for oeralsalon—to eorry out the cold wr.ter experiments In Dsohr u ®nd ashed tort the following oe engr.ged in choeo experiments. He ary8, one, Profaeaor Jr. J-rlac.*., tw , Professor Dr. Ovlrloebner, me. Chen rs well -a the Luft c au pathologist, Jr. Singer of the Sohv-blr.g-Koaoltrl. Tell, now, whrt I ra getting ?t lc fir3t, we aaac eatpbllan tho position of Profeaaor Dr. 3ln-cr. as ou And I both itnow, h; refused to do any w- rk of th t s-.rt na soon a no discovered whrt it woe, ?nd ..ow did the name of Profeasor Jr. ein c or hsp on to ’;a mentioned in t.-.i* latter? ’so ho o consulting ?et.v- olo.lat to -ur institute, or wes he Juat a >• toologlst vn che at ff .>f the achw. bing-ftoapltsl, or how did this cohesion rrlae that Professor oln & ^r was aentloned? h. I'll answer ,oar first questl-n first. Professor Singer In his clvlllrn position w:6 p pathologist rt Bchwabing-Hospitel. During the wrr h- continued with t is w.rk, nd pc the seae tl ce he va e pathologist in Luftgru 7. %. Ir. Luftgru 7? • ,.. In Luftgau 7. I p*.reonelly hru nothin,, wh tever c v 1 th 51r.-er. Ky institute wrs quite independent In scientific respects. If I h d ever hrd nnd cn: ?:£h~ -lo-ic-'l ?nd gn»t.alcol work to do, which w* = not die c?e;, c en I c aid hrve -one to oin^er rnd coulc. hrve Court 1 Kr.y 7-A-15-4-HD-Hoynes-V«.n Scfaon. naked Singer, on the oasis of his c-prclt os consulting pathologist, to help no In this work. Tell, thin actually Doctor, If you needed the services of Professor Dr. Singer, then you theoretically w uld &o thr^u^h the ohrnnel of Luftga.u No. 7 and ask for hie services ea tne patnolo-,lst In Luft^au No. 7;' Is th-t correct? He Is r. Qoaber of the Luftwaffe, so to sc-ok. iL Is p. art of /our organization, the overall organization, end If you n.-oded the services of a octholofclst, then you would &o to “in^er; is that rl a nt? It w uld be because of tne fret 1ft he was In Luft^au Ho. 7, not - private jnyslclm In schwabln^-Hos^ital? a. I p.rsc nelly could *o to any p tholo e lst wno aoeaod suited, and In practice. In 0^806 where I went to * irtn .lojlst at all, whon I ---'a Interested In flndln 0 s, for sxnnole, liver findings—vhrt does the liver look like In ree^le who h'Vc drown.d in the cold, In suoh oasos In pr'cdce I "lways went to -u.chr.jr because Bueohnor had s ;eclflc experience in the field of cold, but Chaorctioally I could h~ve b one to binder, too, or I c uld h. vj b ono to tne Vienna p-tholojlst, If I t.v-u b ht ♦ th!t he ws especially qu Ilf led. I w s quite unrestricted In tn t respect, but the routine path -logical v.rk wont c 3in^r. Let 1 6 take an ^jcaolo. « uvn hr.s been r.aohlxlrted fr.x b sollne fumas . t cr. airfield. The ccso is n t clo-r. There is -n • utopsy. T is autopsy w^uld utoiU ticrlly nave cone under binder, or In Luft b a.u-7 "n airplane had x-de rn emergency lmdln b and ther- h d been Injuries. Th t v.«ulb hrv_ been dinners work. That h-d n thlnt t do with ay Institute. I w"s directly under the nvlati n ministry sclentlflc-lly, and In or-ctice it did r, t ;.~-rren th t * .vur celled upon Singer Court 1 K rr 7-«-15-5-HD-H-yno 6-T n Schon. for assistance. x. '.‘all n w, vnrt kind of a~a vs Dr. Singer? Ho " errantly vs <* suistp.ntlrl ch-r-ct^r, wasn't no? a. H-j~ I rjk whnt o« senn exactly, in what respect? ”j! 1 , it is rpp rent aero fr a the evidence oof ore • a in b..ls Tribunal that Dr. Singer hrd the opportunity to assist nd t collaborate with & sonar nna iulzloehnor •nd -'inke ?t Jr.ohau, end ?po*'rencly ho refused t. cvll-borrto when .10 heard of the nature >T tno exsorlaonts, ~nd being a orthologlst, ha aust h vc known very well tirt dor the w old occur or tnej w uldn't need r.is services, a> consequently ho v aid n vj no p rt of it. Now, I would line to /.n.w Just wa t c pc of aen dr. oin^er was. Was he a credible p«ra-n? f-s he r c iuu >nyaicien, e g'od pathologist? \'es he c-nsldercd by yourself to be of go d reputation, 'nd so forth? A. Y-3, respecting r.iu .scientific onpnolty and ilia char oter, I never ..onrd anythin^ b d. In eeccvtiao one sly internes, « y.e c~n see fr jj a ll6t of publications, wr to 6 r.*.tiln e n the h-rrt rnd rather br.nohltio t Sing-r's institute. I n^v.r he rd anythin^ brd ?o ut Singer's c.i-recter, rnd he h«d a _.o d ronut-tlon ~6 a scientist. h. Did vu ev.r hear of - St bnrzt Cnken, O-N-X-E-N, the -djutpnt of ca. acdlcnl den rta-nt of Luft^GU 7? Did y e ever near of thrt nans? a. I d. aet reoeaber la a~ra nrlly. I do reaeijj^r t;.„ n^ae, tn u w h, but I can't reaeaber tod- - lr. wn t c nnection I he rd it. .'ell, nvw, being the ad Jut nt .f tna aeulcal ..op rtaent of Luft^nu No. 7, he vuld nrve a^ne sort of Jurisdiction, schr.pa dlecielln ry, over your institute. 71o3 (kart 1 M-y 7-jk-15-o-HD-n.*ynca-V..n au-n. w uld no not? a. Til- Luft-,"u pnyslci n did, not the nijut nt. Veil, that office w-uld; the medical department w Id. A . I just r.member, Okon w a adjutint of the Luft a ^.u pir/’lcl-n of Luf t. 3 ;u 7 for sometime. i. '-’oil, now, who would he the sup-rlor of the mo&ioal don-rSmont of Luft 0 u 7? .’to did they In turn ro->ort t.-oir 'ctlvltl-s to? All the i-aft c rus war- -naer the .iodic 1 Inspoctorcte.^ % . Than tfcrt n ule 30 directly to .-.lppito or to oohroedor* «. The Luft s J 6 ?nd th Luftoeu payslclans were under the .'.-dlcl Inspector to. to vn t sootlon that went, th t -op-nded .ras tho hoad of tho Tosting Station four, '-hich I doscribod in dutail. Q This testing station hero, that ic roforrtd to horc, that io ycur organisation? A That is quite obvious Raschcr ocr.na here, I have no doubt... Q I an not concomcu 0 h these harmless nl-h altitude experiments, now could you t 71-0 Court 1 Aey 7-A-l3-2-HD-Cook-K urtz. ton or fifteen? It depended entirely on whet * wanted the people to do end how much time they had end how much I was justified to demand of their tine, our^ly, It Is obvious fast sometimes I could a et students end soaetla-s I couldn't. In ny sphere In any case, within my program there was no necosslty to fall back on prisoners because we did r.ot h ve a program which would make that necessary. Now is Ruff's case it was quite different. Just a mement doctor; you have stated now when I asked ''ou concorntn 0 the meeting In the summer of 1941, why thl9 discussion arose, and Hlppke was there, about those matters, end ou hove volunteered the Information to us that It wosn't necessary to discuss it because we could h, vo gotten all the volunteers wo wanted to, but this was merely a manner In which Kotten- noff wanted to present t..lo proposal to Hlpoke for consideration. Now you mode the statement: ‘16 can get ell th- volunteers we w nt to. Could you get ten or fifteen volunteers If you, Ur. Voltz, ted decided you would like to experiment in high altitude research on hufl»n beings, co Id you yourself havo obtained theso many volunteers you spoke ebo .t? a. Probably not, I didn't try - but - Q. Then why did .ou eay you could In defense to that ether question her* some hour ago? A. I said tr.e q-e=tion would not hrvo arisen as to croetimental persons If Rasoher had not brought up that subject and forced us to define our attitude toward that problem. That Is what I said. k. Veil then you had e lew pressure c/^ab-r vallable in our institute in 1941, didn't ou? 7171 Court 1 „ Kay 7 -A- 19 - 3 -HD-Cooi-A.ur-r. a. Yea. i. «nd vclcntc.rB could taro boon node evallablc, ' could they? A . It depends upon what for and to what extent, i. roll I a- asking you specifically: *> ” ou thlnk et t.iat time you could have got a volunteer to volunteer, a volunteer to volunteer for high altitude experiments as outlined by Ruff and Romberg and RafiOhor at the concentra- tloa camp Dachau? a. '»*1 Shout any difficulty. Then you could have got ten or 15 volunteers without any difficulty? a. The Is more difficult. Well, let's don't 0 et involved, why In the world did you then enter Into a conference with Ruff, Ror-bor* and Rascher to go to Dachau and uu*o all o: those errans ments end spend all of this valuable time during wer tine when you could do other research, whon - 11 you had to do was to *0 out ena O ot ten or fifteen vo untoore and say now Ruff here Is the low pressure chamber and ton or fifteen volunteers, 6 o to It? It was just as alnnl- as that, vesr.'t It? a. First of all I should correct h-ro that the exyerlciwnta could not have been made with our low pressure oh. mbur beccuse our model wee a different one. It could nave been made wit:, your low oressure oc.-m‘ser co ldr.'t it? a. The experiments made hr Ruff and Romberg could ne-or have be * a-do with a* low pressure chamber. Couldn't you have mad. ten or fifteen subjects available to Ruff and Roabor. to be usod In their oressure cumber, bearing In mind. If course, that the 7132 Court i fey 7-A-i:---i-SB-Cooi-Kurtr. low pressure eh mber stopoed in your Institute overnight you could heve cerely held It there end said to then now here ere ten or fifteen subjects, you make your o»3eriment6 ri^-it here. It would neve, avoldad all this confusion, wouldn't It, end you could ht-va 6een what went on In these experiments, because yo- wouldn't have had. to have p pass to git Into a concentration oann, Isn't that true? No, this Is not true, because first of all our low pressure chamber was unsuitable for these experiments, because It did not have sufficient cape*city. Secondly, if I had had the experimental subj-cts in hunloh, Ruff in 3orlin would not h ve had any advantage of that, and t -lrdly, the election cs far as I was concerned was this; That I had to define ay attitude to Rasonor, and noreov.r Raac-.cr and orders from Himmler, In which he w. s ordered to Ooffl- to ay Institute to carry out the experiments. Just a cement now, Raschar wasn't In the sS, was he? flaoch.r was In the Leftweffe. Lot's etralfent3n that it now. In 1&41 at the tic* of these activities and tills iler.r.in a of Che experiments at hachau, Rasohor was not In the 33, em I correct? Piers- correct me, ..octor, If I pm wrong. 4. «t that time Rascher was in the 33 and w s also c jtcbsarzt In the Luftwaffe. He v^s on active duty In the Luftwaffe, wasn't he? Don't w 3 h.ve e lot of correspondence here wherein tiey re blcherln^ bach snd forth about Raachor? a. He was or. 00 officer and In the Luftwoffo. In tne Luftwaffe? a. Yes In the Luftwaffe. I ;we to study the documents. This Is news to . . ow lr. Dececber 1941, you orocoedod to --erlln ac Court 1 » y 7-,.-i9-5-HD-Cook-Kur t *. to 83 3 Huff? A. Yos. i. ?rlor to tat MK you had *W( thca. oxporl- aunts with Luts and Wendt, hadn't you? a. No, tht t la not true. Lutz said you ned. s. *»». I had dleoisee- It vltfl Lutz oni a , ! 8al4 ln * 4l " 0t dxaIlnocl °n I told Lutz about tel. convocation with Hlppka rnl „„ carried on that convocation oni discussed tho posUbllltloe for end e e ainat tho problem. I did not (pack ln detail to -ondt. I don't recall at •11 nevln t ulsouaaed It with endt. ”oll row Lutz testified /oj offered hlu an opportunity to collaborate with Hasober? *• 'Oil, I diSPUtO the t. X: -UCSX3 apparent socofriao before Docombor 1941 , or uaybe ln Do ccabor 1941, that Rasohor was to conduct experiments t tho fftoliaii concentration camp, didn't it? Ha so.*, r wanted to carry out ills oxperlo-nto In Dpoh.'U. 7 Kay 47—j*-SV-l9-l«-Cook-Zur t x Court So. 1 That cecane dour when Huff scented ay proposition. q. tffay would you have offered Buff o proposition If there hadn't teen sene dlecueeion about it before then? 4 , I do not understand thut question. Si. You invited ^off to collaborate with Hatcher. How did you happen to nave knowledge, how did you h*>pen to know Hascher wanted 8 ooobody to collaborate with bin, what did you go up there fort Did you hare a vision suddenly and decide he wantod to have scce experiments and eay to Huff: Do you want to collaborate with Hascher I will assign you to hiu? Didn't you h„ve scce sort of a noeting with Ratchor beforeh.u* and have scce sort of a plan? You wouldn't have invited Huff and «ooborg to assist you if you didn't have soao sort of r. plan. It didn't Just ecne out of thin air, did it? ju I thought I hod described this sufficiently. Probably in Soveubor 1941 Sascher w u s ordered to ay institute without uy doing anything about it. without ay knowledge ovon, and now he was a aoebor of uy Institute and ho hud un assignment free Kiualor to carry out thoso ox.oriuonts, ait I did not know what to do with hia, that wao the situation. Si. Row we are getting to it. In Hovoubor, 1941, Hascher was csoignod to your institute, wasn't ho! A, 1 ossune that, 70 s. q. Ro bcc.-ne your subordinate in the Luftwaffo, didn't he? a. afl it was called tochnlcaiy he was orderod to work in ny institute. q. and he was your subordinate? Vhon you are in tho Luftwaffe or c:qr otr-or branch of the Vohrcacht before you c a n put e can free ono Job to another it le necessary to order bin, ho has to care written orders, tho . : ae in the Gcrcan aTbj ae in tho D S aicy or in the havy or coy other arcy, and so Hascher received orders wnorein ho wao tronr- 7 Hay 47-^-S*-19-2»-Cook-rnrtz Court So. 1 forrod to the Instituto Veits, wasa«t he, cad he bccoao your sub- crdiactet Let'* not quibble about it, doctor. a. Yes, that la hit position. Q. Then Haacher had on assignuent wherein ho could, if ho so visaed, use subjects of the concentration cocp Dachau, is that right? Toa. He jbuld have equally as veil have accccpliohod his objoctivo by using voluntocrs othvr than volunteers of inautes of Dachau concon- tretion crop? • a. x hat depends on vbet Hascher's ala was. Boschor did not havo an a in at that tine. That v^s tho difficulty, *»o proposod oxporinento to ao for which aianler wanted to uso the ejqicrisontal subjocts , wxl I did not approve of Raschcr's ain and that vos how tho unhappy situation, as far as Bascksr was cone or nod, aroso. On tho ono hand ho had Hiunlor's pemission -nd on tho other ho had no cia to do anything with that pi-mission, and ho proposod to no this slow ascent oxporlnont, which Z turned down. then was that, in Hovsobor 1941? a. Th..t proposal he node to Sottonhoff when ho not hin for tho first tin a. Sow what proposals did ho coke to you after ho bocauo your subordinato lr. Sovsuber 1941? a. 'chon in Soveabor 1941 ho bocauo ny subordinato and when I had turned down his first proposal , ho then, as I said beforo, ho thon Dado a proposal to do for tho cold oxporioents to be carried out in D chau, and that I also turned down, os I said before. Q* Voll then vhon did ho propose that ho wanted to uso tho low pros rare chaaber? *0 aust have proposed it soi-o tioo in Hovaabor— when? 7106 7 :fcy-A-iB-2O-l-Karrcw (Int. Kurtz) Court So. Z. A The use of the low pressure chamber? q res. A His first wishes to make high altitude experiments were based on the fact that a low pressure chamber must be used, bit we never reached that point in our conversation because, from the begin¬ ning, I said *He shall not make those experiments" and Rascher had no reason to ask ne what low pressure chamber to use. Q Let as ask you a question. Did they perform some e;.-peri- monts in Dachau on high altitude from your knowledge, from sitting hero in the dock for five months? Did ti.oy? A Yes. Q Well, now, who proposed thorn? In November, 19hl, Rascher cure to work for you, as your subordinate in your institute, ordered there by the Luftwaffo. It ran only the Luftwaffe which could change his assignment bocause he was a rombor of the Luftwaffe. Now, when did he propose tlwse experiments? If ho didn't propose them, thon Weltz proposed them and went to got Ruff and Roaborg. Now, why did you ask Ruff and Ronborg if somebody didn't propose theso experiments? Who proposed thon in Novcnbor, l°!il? You had rejected Ills other proposal earlier on tho slow descor.t proposition. Now thon, did lie oxtond a new proposal to you in November, 19lil, or by what token did you atop forrard aid invite Ruff and Roaborg down to Dachau and get thooe two men in all this troublo? Now, how did tliat happen? A I believe I described this in detail. I say once again that in Novcnbor, 19U1, thit Rasclior cu» to cy institute. He made tho new proposal to have cold experiments. I thon told Raschor that "wo aro not interested in cold oxperirents. Our anise la arc tjuito suffic¬ ient here. There's no point to it." Then I dcscribod htfr, by chance, whon I was on a trip to Berlin, I visited Ruff and Ruff told mo of the difficulties of his own progr am and ether difficulties which ho had with experimental subjects. I, in turn, told Ruff that Hi sc her was hanging around cy institute and I did not know what to give him to do; 7137 7 lfey-A-43-50 -2-fcarrow (Int. Kurt*) Court So. I. that Raschor had permission to mako experiments in Dachau; and, there¬ upon, I proposed to Ruff to have his experiments carried out on tho basis of Rasober's permission in Dachau. Surely I described this all in detail, and Ruff did too. Q How, I have 1 is to nod with great interest to what you have just said. Do you want to think for about one ninute and confirm to tho Tribunal that that is how the ox-orioonts started at Dachau? That is Just the answer I wanted. Kow, think about it a minute and will you confirm to tho Tribunal that that's how tho experiments strxtcd in Dachau. A Tho experiments cano about that I said that on a trip to Borlin, I tnlkod to Ruff, that I told Ruff that thorc was a jwssibility to havo expirimonts carried out in Dachau and that Ruff, in turn, told mo how short ho was of experimental subjects. That, I think, is all I have to say in this connection. Q That's porfoct, Doctor. Ko won't havo to discuss that any further. How, after you talked to Ruff, then you sot a dato for a meeting, didn't you, in Munich, and this dato for a mooting in Munich took placo whon? Whan was that dato? Tfhon did it actually tako placo in Munich? A I cannot give you tho dato. I assume that it must havo boon in December, ftjrhape tho middle of Docember, 19ll. Q That was also in December that thoy wont to Munich? You wAnt to Berlin in Deccsbor and they came to Munich in December, is that right? A Ho, I'm sorry, I made a mistako here. I assume that the conversation in Munich took place in January. I slipped there. Q All right. Now, Ruff and Rcnberg were invited to partici¬ pate in thoso experiments with Raschor by you because they were exports on tho subject, is that right? You wanted some experts to work on this. If you were going to use inmates of tho concentration ermp, you decided 7 >by-A—G-2O-3-Korrcm (let. Kurts) Court Ho. I. you would like to have experts doing it, and that's your reason for asking Huff and Romberg to collaborate with you and Rase her, is that it, because thoso xon wtre exports in the field i A That is a distorted description and Ruff and Ronbor-j's affidavits aro on the basis of this, and in their crocs examination they have corrected their affidavits. It is a distorted way of putting it to say that I had called in tta exports Ruff and Romberg to my ex¬ periments. How it really happened was I effexed to Ruff whothor iie wanted to cako exporinents with Raseher. Rostoerg, in turn, had decidod on the program. Tho program was not ay contribution. And on that oasis, tho collaboration occurred. Q And, in tho ovont that you had not offered this to Ruff and Rocb-'rg, than Ruff end Romberg would net bo in this dock todry, would thoy? A I assume so. Q roll, no*, the hurdlo I na trying to got over is that 'Jr. Luts soya you offorod It to liin. Of courso, you dony that. And ho ro- fusod, ani gives very olaborcte reasons for his refusal in that ho wasn't strong onough — that is, in his hoart - to porforn those ox- perinonts on faumn beings. And tho hurdlo I m trying to got ovor new is tho statement you mute on direct wJ»n you said that such a play on words by Luts was ridiculous; tnat you had nover noticed Luts to bo roli^ious or to have any misgivings about such things and you made a statonont which hae bothered ne considerably "herein you state j n I would have reminded Luts of things which make this answer ridiculous." Jiot, was Luts aixod up in scroothing criminal? What was this hero that would liavo node his answer ridiculous? A Luts' reply wo-ud have boon ridiculous according to tho views hold at the tine by Luts on the overall situation. Luts, at that tine, 7ms an ardent advocate cf total war with all means and his con¬ ception roughly was - I now speak cf 15ll - he realised that the war would be a hard and sovero one and he was of the opinion tint this war 7 L-.y-A-3-2O-fe-Earrow (Lit. Kurtz) Court Ho. I. -ust be f-ught with all means at our disposal. At that tino ho used the following expression quite frequently, tha expression: "If wo are to win this w~r wo, in Germany, nuat use shooting in the nock ncro frequently." I think Lutz didn't mean this litorally. Hhat ho nonnt vms perhaps this. He believed that wo, in Germany, were sitting be- twe-n two chairs. On the ono hand, the daaocrotic net hods with ihich you could wag© war sucoossfully wo had got rid of, and, on tho otlwr hand, ho thought that the total warfare mo the ds which wo saw ombodiod in Russia had not been introduced 1005, -nd tht wes his opinion that he expressed in tho words that "Li Go raw, wo should shoot people in tho nock r»ro." Just at that tiro and just before, thoro wore snail differences between Lutz and rysolf on tho point that lutz usod his elbows quito a bit. I tell thuso things nhich aro not of vast import¬ ance - I an not very koon about tolling those things about ny assist¬ ants - but if it helps to olnrify thoso things I have to toll those things. If over I had snail difficulties with sy subordinates-it oc¬ curred rathor raroly - it was always c-n tho point that Lutz usod his olbcws too ruthlessly. Later on, i* hod a difforonco with our ohar- wenan, and when I eont hie on m assigmont ho had arguaonto vhon ho nisbolv-.vod rathor awkwardly with tho Gauloitor and I had to roocuo hia froc a vory hoavy difforonco of opinion with tho Gauleiter which was not without considerable risk as far as I an concerned. Q So new, Doctor TToltz, thoso little incidents of Lutz' per¬ sonality - what you refer to as making his refusal to participate in hizain being oxporicents in Dachau ridiculous — is thnt what you baso it on? That slin ovidoncc of his character? Tou baso it on that? • A A nan who tolls no that "norc people should bo shot in tho nock in Go many* cannot toll no in tho sano breath "1 on too soft¬ hearted. I an not robust onough." I ;rust say I would have docLarcd that ridiculous. I don't know that that is only cy opinion. Q Uoll rviw, in this meeting in January, 19U2, who rein Ruff and Roaberg attended, whe else » s present at the conference? 7190 7 n'y-A-i£-205-Xarrcnr (let. Kurtz) Court Ho. I. A Present were, at that conference, Ruff, Romberg, Rascher and myself. Q Ruff, Romberg, Raseher and yourself, yos? A Yob. Q And Luts w-.s not thcro? A I described this. Rasebar was late. Ruff and Romberg wore present. Before the conference opened wo talked in ray rocn on different setters and when Roeclwr arrived - !w had n car accident - and .uado apologies and when Rase her finally turned up I told those gent loco n Thank you very uuch. I wish to begin new" and began the conference, and tho gontlonen left ay roon. Q I see. Then Luts' tostLxny that you told him you woro going to liavo a conference and that ;'eu didn't want hia in tho roon is true, isn't it? A Yos, it is. Q This is a good breaking point. Your Honor. THB PRESIDENT: Tto Tribunal will be in recess until 9:30 tomorrow morning. DR. FROGSCHMANN (Dofonso counsel for defendant Brack): !!ay it please tho Court, nay I ask tho Court's indulgonco for two minutes? In the court* of tho trial the following witnosscs havo boon proposod: Wolff, Dietrich, Soivort - I an dofo:iso counsel for Brack - Wolff, % Dietrich, Soivort, Hodorich and Pfnronuoller. I have docidod not to use Soivort and Bsdorioh. Wolff was turned down as a witnoso. Mow, tliero is a difference betw&.n nysolX and tho Secretary General about tho twe regaining witnesses: Dietrich and Pfannauollor# They should be called into tho witness stard as witnesses. I would be grateful for a r uling cf tho Court to allow ne there two witnesses on tho stand. KR. HARDY: liay it please the Tribunal, I nay be able to help you here. I don't knew the status of Pfanrouellor right now. Tho Doctor does. But I turned Pfcnnnuclior over to the Gorman courts for trial sene two aonths age and I don't know whether he has departed free 7191 7 Ifcy-A—!3-2Q-S-Earrow (Int. Kurts) Court Ho. I. J.'umborg yet. "hay ire proceeding very rapidly. Ho may bo hero now - I don't knew that - but I assume that ho is in Frankfurt awaiting trial. I don't knjn whether he r.ill bo available for this Tribunal. TrS PR2SHJEKT: Tfell, if counsel for the dofondant Braok and the prosecution will ccao to ay office inaodiatcly upon this recess, we'll discuss the natter with then there. (A HKCESS yUS TAXE2J UJ/TIL 0930 HOURS, 8 I'AY 19li7). 7192 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Roll 8 Target 2 Volume 20 May 8-14, 1947 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS I 1 OFFICIAL RECORD UNITED STATES MILITARY TRIBUNALS NURNBERG CASE No. 1 TRIBUNAL I U.S. vs KARL BRANDT at ol VOLUME 20 TRANSCRIPTS (English) 8-14 May 1947 pp. 7193-7574 mi Hz? 8-U-3K-1 Court No. 1 Official Transcript of thu -cwrioan Military Tribunal In tho natter of the Onitou otc.tc.-s cf —•aerion c.;ainst KjI ornndt, ot al, defendants, sitting r.t Humber:;, Gernany, on May 8 1947, 0930, Justice Boils presiding. Till ll.UUH.X- Persons in tho courtrooa will ploaso find choir scats. Tho Honorable, bho Judges of Military Tribunal I. Ullitcry Tribunal I is now in sossion. God savo tho United Gtr.tos of ..fierio.nd this honorable Tribunal. Thera vjill bo order in tho courtrooa. THJ PI.ISIJJKT: Ur. ~ rshcl, you ascertain if the defend.at s re all pro a oat in tho court. TH- H..U3H..L: May it plonso Your Honor, all dofondants tro .resent in tho court. T:u ..t-Giaarr: The Secretary Goner .1 will note for tho rocord the presence of all .the defendants in court. Counsel uay proceed. DU. e-C’.cG- <.ULTd - Uosucod C.i033 UX.ddIIT.J10U (Continued) BY .K. H.-OY: t Dr. -oltz - TiL, c. Counsel, just one aonont. The Tribunal desires to r^et throe r.ouburs of the Gorn-r. oounsol, to bo ohoson by tho Gum sn oounsol, a q quart or before four this Jtoruoon in tho Jud;os' entorooci to discuss tho n:.tt_r of tho tine to bo allowed oounsol for x :uc:ent at the clo3o of the oaso If counsel for the do fond ats will choono a cor-iittoc ^^jSmJVioJscot with the Jud ;es this afternoon^it a Wartor bofor£-Your, the natter will b- discuss . Counsel cmy' JCddr;«rio:i (Continued) Uaj S-K-3K-l-2-?cstcr (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 had taken up the noetin,; in L'unich in January 1942, and you stated that .;uff, Hoebors, ^esoher and yourself wore present at th^t ncetin^. Now, between the nootinj in Munich end your nootin : with ;tuff in Borlin, did you then inforu .iasohor thet you had successfully roooived the support of ;iuff and rtunborg, so that iasohor then could oarry out work in hi ;h-altitudo rosoerch nt Daohuu? .. Certainly, otharwiso iiesohor would not havo oone to this tooting. I had tc invito .teacher to this ncotins, and on- of the purposoc of this n-otins was to aoquaint .tuff end Itonbora with ncsohor. 1 Now, after tho aootin : had cssonblod I presume that you had ono or two stops to consider. First of all, did tho four of you disouso tho necessity for tho ex¬ periments, bo rin; in mind, oi course, that all four of you woro familiar with this field of research, nuff, Itonbors and yourself b-in : nor. ,• ;rticuln-ly exports in the field. .. ..o acquainted .tesoher with tho ^ro.^.ui; hcschor in hi3 turn told us wh t the conditions woro. Ko showed us the Kirn_lor lot tor th^t has boon mentioned horo; and tho pro Tar; was already laid down. Th^ro was no further discussion of tho pro Trx:. Tho ^roj-Ji )«3 ulroedy dear at ^dlorshof. . This lottor that you have r.forrcd to, th-t Dr. •tor;b„r ; r-fo r-d to, did you havo tho opportunity ^to road that lett.r of Himmler's? - Yes, -Cisch-r showed it to us in this riuotin> l Can you substantially toll this Tribunal just what that letter contained? - The letter contained tho st tenant that Hinmlor :avc his rr.isaion for ox;>.ri::-nts in Daoh.u, th t these !'iy 8-.I-BK-1-3-?QStcr {Int. Brown) Court No. 1 experiments woro to be undertaken on habitual criminals, th .c thoso habitual originals noro to bo volunteers, end that they wore to receive a suitable nitiqation of :unishnunt. -.11 thoso facts wore certainly sot forth in the latter. v ..oil, now, doesn't it soon stranju to you, Dr. .tow wo don't soo the word "voluntary" nontioned in this lottar, do we, Itoctor? Q I boliovo that this lottor obviously rofors *to Hasohor's oxporirwnts, and not to ours. Wo Id not carry out ary axporiiajnta on which wo tod to boo how lor\ tho hoart continues to boat aftor altitu do sicknosoj Raschor in his rolations with Ruff, Rorfcor;, and no. Q Non, Doctor, I can well soo that you are now 'oin<: to draw this lino of demarcation botwoon Raachor's axp-riaonts, and the Ruff-Rciriborg oxporliaants, an there is no point in our arguing further on this luttor, but I lo wish to call your attention to this lottor whoro Maalor now, you atatod, wroto to Raschor boforo this tine, and statod that tho oubjocts WL*ro to bo par ’onod. ?Sow, in this lottar ho 3tatos that thoy aro to bo par toned if they are killed, and thon called back to lifo — thon you will grant then a pardon to bo jwt in a ooncontration camp for lifo. Jtow that's too only instanco .herein we see tho "pardon" clause coning forth, isn't it? A I don't knew whether what Raschor told us always wot tho sane as what ho discussed with Hinalor. I can only say what Raschor told us, and I car. only refer to this one statement of Hisrlor's that I sr. and there i3 no doubt that the question of the voluntary subject played a role in • the discussion botr.oon Xottonhoff end Raschor, and that our . ntiro dis¬ cussion with Ruff and Roracrg also involved the voluntary olenent in a 71 97 8 »y U7-’W.7!>-2-2-<>allnr*fcer (Int. 3rcwn) Court !fc. I, Case 1 vary ir^xertant role. !*oir I do not knew vhethor Raschcr got a separate letter froro Himlcr stating this, or how it was, Q flew om brier quostion along those lines. Isn't it true, or won't you concede, that, after roadiivj this lottcr which is in I^cunont Book \k. 2, an‘ you say that you saw anothor latter fro::. Himlor, which unfortunately we do rv>t havo hero in ovidonco, doesn't it soea to you that the attitude of Ijoinrich Hitrsler changed considerably, koeping both lottoro in ndnd? A What I hoard about Hij^lor's attitude horo, if I o value to that now, than I oust say that Kinrlor's attitude did change radically. Q You don't have to go into a long discussion. Doctor, on Hirmlor's attitu'e. I ns t r -U cin c about the two letters. You sa\ ono lottor nhoroin you state that Riasler olid tod that tho oxporinjnts r.uot bo porfomod upon cr ininale, for ono, and, t»;o, thoy aist bo value too rn, and, nuiabor three, they will bo -ivon a pardon, '.km you say you saw anothor lottor of Virdor'a wherein ho said that tho oxporirants can oontinuc on persons condcr.nod to death, and secondly, that if aryono ties or bocotaos uncon¬ scious in the course of tho oxperinont, and thoy arc collod bade to lifo, then thoy my bo pardoned to a concentration canp for life, ifow do thoso two letters one of which you saw, which this Tribunal and I unfortunately have not soen, and, the letter which wo have before us, do they oxhibit tho attdtudo of ono ran on tho sano subjoct consistontly? A Whether or not thoy ruro to bo volunteers is, as far as.'Iccan see in this Himlor lottor, Decuasnt 1971-B-PS, not aontionod. It -loos not 3cy that thoy should bo volunteers, ner does it say that thoy should not bo voluctoors. Q That is right. A In other noxr’s, this lott.-r which I knew only dron the records — loos not ippoar to no to ax elude tho possibility that at another tine Hirulor wroto a letter in which the condition was laid down that tho •mbjects should bo volunteers, articulariy since Raschar had to know that t'•> question of their being volunteers was a vary inportant point to us. 7196 8 Ifey u7^.TD-2-3-Gallatfwr (let. 3rean) Co-art Ko. I, Case 1 Q }taw, Dcstor, - this sarx neetiny in January 19U2, tho question of tho uao of the lev-pressure chadsor arose, and, I assumes, it was .vjrcod that .luff and a*borg bring their ler-pressuro chamber dorm to use at Dachau. How, did thoy agree to neve this charbor to Dachau directly, ani what was the reason for s toppin; off over night at tho Institute .felts? This scons to to of consiiorablo intcrost horo. A Ruff tostifiod on this at groat longth. Durin,; tho discussion in ny Institute in Munich, tho individual conditions weron«t laid down under which the dumber could bo usod. If I ur.’orstood Ruff corroctly, the canp cosnandant nado thoso lenands riirectly of Ruff, and I know nothin,.. Than tho oharbor camo I was tcld that the papers and tho key to tho clumber troro to bo loft with no. Ruff has already explained, that. The Berlin drivers arrivod in tho Into afternoon i tho chart or res not loft at ny Institute, however, but was loft noar tho station, and on tho next day tho SS Irivers caao to =xj and fotchod tho papers and the key, and drovo tho chaabor on. Q Thoso experiments, nxf Doctor, woro to bo perforaod on habitual criminals; thr> criminals troro to volunteer, and thoy ;xro to rocoivo a pr.rton after thoy had un orjono tho experiments. ‘^hat was tho roaaon for tho socrocy in the plcxnin, of thoso oxporinonts, if everything con- oomin; thin was honorable? A Ruff hastestifiod regarding this point; the socrocy wa3 doteminod fron two points of view. The Luftwaffo required a socrocy of a linitod sort because of tho naturo of tho cssigmont was such as to indlcato that a high altitude cachino was un dor ''oval? fount in Genvany; all tho3o lovolopn-nts on ra3oarch aasignaont woro tc bo kept sccrot until thoy '‘■ore finished, and, whan thoy had boon condudoi, oithcr thoy bocar.o secret onco for all, thoy vora rario partially open to tho public or anviroly . pen. Tlio '.ecision as to this ..-as, sensibly enough, always reached only after it was ascertained wlct tho experiments had prcducod in tho way of results, .‘.air, -.rhilo .ovale paunts rcro un lorway, thoy were all secret. In contra-^'istincticn, to wjr basic reasoarch on animals, which woro 7199 3 '.ay 19U7-?t^T!>^-iH3allasher ( 1 st. Browr.) Court Ho. I, Cass i always open axp^ririents. That was the reason for secrecy deuandod by the Luftwaffe. Hoi., the 3S also dares led secrecy, bocauso of tho con- contrqtion canp. This was a (;enoral decani of tho SS. It was not because we wore now porforair^ expori&snts, but those were pirnaneht.secrecy requires.* nts pertaining to tho concentration carp. There wore two sort3 of secrocy, and too rules on socracy. Q loll, now. Doctor, you stato that in tha Hinrlcr lottor ho r.oroly stated that the subjects to bo used rsust bo volunteers, that ho gavo no particulars, nor di he not sot forth arc’ regulations for tho selection thereof. Henco, it follows thet Ruff,norberg, Sascher, and Tfolts, at tho neetin ir. ?!unich at your Institute, January 19U2, naxst liavc sot forth a proscribed courso to foil or in tho selection af voluntoors. ffow will you ploaao toll tho Tribunal just what stops y.u outlinod for the selection of ycur voluntoors? X Those points w^ro not deoi’od on at tho liscussion at ny Institute, but at a Hscussion one or t*ro ’ays later with the camp coanandor at Dachau, when wo drove out to Dachau. Q Ioj noan to tell so that at a scientific discussion in your Institute, whon it was socrot, whoroin you had to ask !!r. Lutz and 'lr. ffondt tc loavo tho roco, and tlwt tho pnr.uaount ttoujlit in your rdnd was that tho subjects to be usod wore wluntoors, that you didn't at that tino discuss how they *oro to bo solcctod boforo ymi not tho concentration can? corxsan riant? Tha basic problen horo was tho aoloetion of tho innvitos to ba used, if it wasn't the basic problco, you iidn't have to go tho concentration carp, do ycu aoan to toll ne that you four gentleman with rollogo oducations, =*cb.,rs of the nodical profession, didn't discuss such an inportent problon at your rooting in .Munich? M 7200 n«e— 3rown. «. I do not see why you think tills Is a problem, "e coald find out the v. ,1- tcofinlcel elde of It cr.i the set¬ up only bo scoin;, the crop coaa~ndcr, and t .1 t is tna reneon vc went one or two days la cor to Jeencu. It was only there that tn_ technical details were disc-seed, c know at the meeting in Munich that they were to 00 volunteers, but without exact knowlod c o of tnc living c nations, regulations, etc., in the camo we could not decide whether tr.oy should bo chosen at roll-coil or in s.b~ o tiler \ ay. All these tilings we had to leave to the ccj:; commander, end had to volt till h. oedo suggestions. 5 . Just a moa-nt, Joctor. You have stated nov; that yoc. couldn't tell whether you would irv- to c et thorn from cho roll-call or vhr : you must do. Then you must have talked about It at the Munich a-~tin 0 . You couldn't have :sojrtolnwl these t.An.s unless ou Oh tted about it or j ire d on eoact.ilng . t the Amici. mo .tine;. Now, what did ou rjroe u on? You must hrva arid, "We can't dcoldo on this volunteer business until wo cet to see the concentration camp cone*-ndrr.t. But r'oove til, the man au*6 bo henlthy; the man must volunteer; he muse :o warned of thu hazards of th. experiments; wo must thtrou b hly dlsousa these cxperlm.nts with each inmate to ec used so th t we will b. sure that he will coo*>or?te in the manner that Xottonhoff has elaborately outlined; ..idr.'t • ou a.feree on those things, or were you ncgllo^nt in your preparations? a. Th c w s no problem for U6. from the v.fy first t :o offer made to us nrd been for velur.tovra, and wo ad no reason co doubt tills question or to dlsc.es it. To m.rclj had co s.j to it t.vt the a»nuitlons promised us were fillflllcd regarding the %-oluntrry. consent, there 7201 Court 1 .. •- S-H-3-3-HI>-Heynes-3rovn. was no s reat clsc-ssior., bee. use til t was simply the erereqeislto th. * vcs taken cs 5 natter of course, and it v s not discussed. *. I can understand that it v s no problem for you at that tim_. But It is the bi c problem today. That Is way you are h>re, because you didn't consider It a problem then. 3- that °s it may, then you vent to Dr.c.icu. «ou arrived at itec/xu, and then you discussed the nrturc of the volunteers. Now tell the -ribuncl Just what ’e mulations you set up for the selection of those volunteers •*ow oerofully did you outline to the concentration camp com., r.dent what type of subject you wanted? 3chnltrl.r, tne a-Jutrnt of the Rolchsleitunm, Informed tne c mp c »cmander In our prosenco.that his orders from Himmler were, one, that Himmler had olven his permission for these ex^erlm-nto; two, t.vt all of us were to o rtlclocce in them; thro., that they were to be vol.ntoors end that they wore to b*. h bltual criminals. Then, between Schnltrlar, Roscher, and the camp commander, fere was brief discussion, In which they decided teat C*.,y would cake the rrlsoners from block suoh- and - such. These numbers did not mean very much to us, and thon we f-und out th -1 the camp commander— 'oil, now. Just p moment. The decided they would ta^o the subjects from one block or another block; they s oeclfi.d hrt blocks that they were ^olng to ps.t for volunteers? Is that It? a. Yea. ■«.. Continue, jo or.oEd. «. Tne cam commander said, ■bail. If these are the conditions, ta.en It w.ll 00 best to take tne prisoners from such and such r block." Court i A - y S-I'-3-3-H3-Haync e-ar o wr.. Nov, whet were these conditions . gain? a. Ruff has slr-ady said to t. .*e 9aid tort those conditions wore to correspond to the average requirements of the Luftvoffo. Veil, now, did you then, wr.lle 11 of you were there, the gentlemen woo had arranged the pirns for those c:'oonaont6, a* vo the selection of the volunteers take pl co so tr.'t y 0 would bo obi- to -scertrin wither or not you could use .thjts? a. No. That v s decided on 1 ter. % . You mean any a^n who volunteered vo-ld co of use 4 to -eU if ho vn s wealthy? a. Ho hod to meet certain requirements, pr.d we knew Himmler's ord-r wnioh dchnltrl.r communicated to t.*.o oncp oonmar.der lr. our oreeenee. Vo knew what sort of a O roup of pe. il- they wore to bo. Tho: vore to b- h bitunl crlminrls, and so forth. Vo knew all th t. Th-ru was no room for any doubt or any uncertnlnt: in this mttor. ... lou have c nclueively sthted that a subjeot co 30 used in Che course of tnese experiments must be a •nan who Is willing fully to coop rate. He must be a. person ce outlined by Kcttcnhof on Page 11 of v our dooument book, wherein Kottenhoff states: "Rsech.r cr-e to me after the lecture end spontaneously .ardc tlu •proposition to conduct the above nder No. 10 f..rt.*.er described hlgh-rltltufte adaptability tests, wrloh since 1237 I had plannee to conduct on Luftwaffe . yelolons r.d illots, on professional crlnin Is. I explained to nla that the experiments lr. questlcr. could vnly succeed If tr.e test o-rsons, overcoming t.ne respiratory ir.-d.bicions c c. is altitude, could considerably ir.crose : .eir respiratory activity inc-ntionrlly (by exei'tin- Court 1 hey 3-/.-3-4-HD-Hcynes-3rown. tr—lr will power); furtfa.rnore, that t:ioy had to carry out t.-is forced rcsplr-tion in c certain rhythm, mainly using abdominal muscular pressure (stomach respiration) and in a horizontal position. This increased respiratory activity could only 0 e done volunt-rlly and should, under no circumstances, bo interfered with the thought of c so s Bible danger of life in the Be experiments. Therefore, the only persons qualified for the experiments would be those who really volunteered without any compulsion and who could be convinced that these experiments wore not d-r.gerous. Even a t that time I expressed my doubts whether people other than Luftwaffe physicians and pilots woro suit-bio for the experiments planned. 0 i.'ow, Doctor, "0 "n expert, keeping in mind Kottenhoff'o r-ooomondatlons which you irvo supplied here in evidonoc, v lch you obviously were aware of prior to the tlmo you vlclt-d Daohr.u, wherein you made *rr. ngoments for t.io selection of the inmates, why didn't you—being the expert th^t -ou -r- ( having full knowledge of another -x:ert's views on these nr.tiers—why didn't you then, yourself, inasmuch as rtasen r was to -ct as your subordinate in these jxp-rlm^r.ts, nemberg to act cs nuff's oubordln te, wny didn't you then carefully cso.rrtnln t.ie subjects Co bj U8wd n- be cert in tart they would cond ct tnemselv-s in the srn..*r outlined by yourself an. o* aottenhoff, so you would bo sere of no mi stakes? That Is wtot wo did. Huff h-s testified at * r length on tnle, point in*, oat t.irt ~v_n for t.ils different .roup. e. Huff n-v.r t-lked tc one of te.se subjects. fort do you me-n, Ruff testified at l.neth? no never spoke to oa.e. zou nev r saoko to on.-, •*r.d Roaber c could remember 72 OL • «.» n-e-crovn. cart 1 -j r.’-e3 of onl;- two or t.'.rea, aejsa four. -*ho did -;o theae people? Rr.schsr? Did oi larva IS up to R-sonar? If t.-.c oxoeriAentrl aabjecte did what was expected of : :-n ^a volunteers, pulleu the p«r. ohuto relo so, ieaoribed wnrt t.ia experienced daring their re otlona, c.-_an Romoer 0 zuat fcjvo spo/.en wit.-, them bjforehrnd. The ••u 1- _r:t,r wra settled os for ra I w'a conc«rn.. by t;._ f ct t.irt, r^-lnst a-/ will, I was eliminated by a* 00.1a r—c b . r in a t c; will, at tne beginning of the ox?-rl- fc-att, Vo'lX : o into thr.t - bit l^tur, Doctor. Nou, you ct-tc Somber^ testifies t.-*t they callow the rip cord, t.vt they oolr.ted to tnclr w rs, tfert they did everything 3 inatruotwl. Crr. ou 'newer me t la oueation: duppoao to sorrow uornln-, you .'.~clio to do o iilgh-oltltudo expon¬ ent, *r— I *1 ->n ir.n tc of o oo-.centrrtlon csjp» rnd ;ou sr* to zo, "I B feoln& to e»o ; f ou In on e pcrlz-nt totay." I n not vol-nte-rin., eootor. "I "a -oln... to use you in -n -yo^r a-nt tod?y, ~nu t..io exp.rlient 16 c.-n' 5 or'U8. If ou don't pall Ch. rle coru ct such rnd each tlase, if a don't tall ae t is hrppenln. to yo., how you nro fa.il..., .o .-oar errs ‘re, If ou uon't roeoonc. to our ou. cions qalokly, you'll die. - Sow do you tnlnk Mr. - r:.y Is e oln e t.. cor—uct .ilssulf in that low-pressure c;.;aj r? I Inline I would contact a^lf much cotter CA-n t..: 'V r v lur.tJjr, v: -aldn't I? rt . i • frrId thft 1 didn't quit, anderafnd the :.v .'Ort of tAC question. i. I ?t.*tu :^ln: .ou rra ^olr.e to conduct r.n expcrl- x;nt. Thle Is ..ypot-oticui. I .-a -n ina:ce of c c.r.contr tlon -rzp. iou cose to ao rnd 3?y, ;, -ou, I aa “ tu aa • oa ir. tAls nljJv-Pltltude experiment rl^'.t Court 1 Key =-:> --1 ynes-Brown. now. ■ I cs not volunteering. You ere tekln 0 ao by force, In th- ir.nnor In which they took thea by force In the typhus exp-rinents end other experiments In concentration c.-mps. Then you ey to me, "You ere -oing Into this chamber. '•'a ere ^olng to trice you uo to 15,COO feet, or 45,COO feet"—w.vt.v.r you 6-lect. You eny that you want rr— to pull a rip cord nt a Cvrtalr. tlm„ end that If I go ur.conacious, when I coo. to -g-ln you cro going to ask sc questions end you er.t au, to answer the questions end that you w-nt me to point to ay errs when I foul pain in ay core, or whatevwryou wish a. to do. You ere Instructing mo. «r.d then you e-.y to me, "Mr. Hardy, If y.u don't follow Instructions, you will die. If you uo fellow instructions, notr.in 0 will hera you. You will be oerfcctly ell rl B ht." Now, don't you suppose that ..no Mr. Hrrdy will conduct himself In a manner in that chaab-r whoroln you can get all lnt information you need? I don't w-nt to die, Doctor. i. To this I can oay two things. First of all, I v.didn't h-vo t~kcr. you if you h-d not been a vuluntcor, becaus. It was our pl-n and our lnt.ntlor. from the very beginning to take only volunteers, so th-t that prop sitIon which you fc-ve suggested Is fallacious. That sltu-tlon w aid r.-ver hrv- -risen. I would nev.r have forced you. Secondly, If we hrd taken concentration c-mp Inmates lr. 1 r e numbers r.d wanted to B et true lnfora-tion from those people, then these people. If they had be.ri forced, Would prob oly have had enough s^nse to give us all sorts of wrong Information so that tney could srbotage the experiment, and thus -11 tnls Information we got would be scientific lly useless to us. 72^5 Otars 1 S-l*- 3 - 7 -ED-K ynce-Bvuvn. k. how, Joctor In the coarse or tr.ese experiments— c-la is D-rely a toohnlcal question, end you bcm e ?. _'n *.f.;o hse woried with low-pros sure chrabers for r oonsldor- • ;i_- length of time, h ving had on- in yo-r own Institute —*nd there la -n clement of curiosity or. ay p rt—- a .vpoee I hr 4 volunteered for tneao experiments. Or 84,9083 1 v olunt-ercd for the v.n hehnal exporlm-nts in ^eidolixrg or hlglv-cititudc -xoeriaenta rnywhore, conducted in a nnor -a you ary the Rurr-R.obcrg oyperiaonta wore c r. .acted, nd I hrd volunteered to b- willing to suoalt uyaolf to a aeries of -xperlacnta. how, bein b a layman, I dan's Know just how muon of that I Cauld at/nd. how, /•- long co Id I atpnd these -xaeriaenta—one individual? Kov, you would use ao, we'll ay, in twenty experiaenta .r twenty-five uxporla-nta. Coaid I st-nd twenty exoeriiBcnta? Could 1 stand fifty uxperia-nte? .v.v long c eld I atqnd that, nna over wart period of tine? a. Tn-c dooonde or. the r.-ture of :he experiment, out ur long-time Luftwaffe doctors, like Ruff and A mborg, f r 'nd 1 co-id nrae you otaers—prove that you c n a tend ti: uasands of experiaenta over t.io c.-urao of yc ra without nything rndicrl happening to you. *• 0 aid I et-nd, we'll any these explosive doc ..BDresel.n exoeriaents—could I *t-nd two er.oh day ftr thirty days? 720 ? e Hay LT-’l-ATiJ-a-l-Hcxsie (In*,. Breen) Court 3fo. 1 A Xoo would tare to find that out. Xcu don't say right at tho beginning, I am loin^ to carry out erarinents for 30 clays with tho experioantal subject, but after you have Join one c^riront you reflect on how it turns .1 out. - Q Hr-vo you found in you oxp.ricncc don: these linos that sono- tiaos you use a subject once end you find that you cannot use bin a^ain? That rsust occur quite of ton. A Sproa-ttiv; tho experimental subjects out ever a long period of ti-.’ was lono, as Ruff also said, not bocauso the exporir^ntal subjabts were oxhaustod ncr because their condition was bad. They wore sproad out over a lonr period of One in order to keep th? experimental subjects from adapting thoas elves to hi h altitude, tho condition, for example, tho mountain climber in tho Himlayns artificially creates in hinsolf so that hi con cliifc hi her. Jtow, a person whs has bocoro adapted to hi h cltitudM m this ray is no longer an index of what an average person, -fhon Rori,or^ spread tho cxp^rlronts with any one person out over ■" l0 ‘ a ‘ P yri ° J 0 tlno * not bocauso the nan would not have boon capable of bain- experimented on tho next day, but to avoid tide a.lap- tation to hi.h altitudes on the part of tto subject. Q :iew, h-r many tiros have you ypursclf boon subjected to high- % altitude oxporlstor.ts? A I havo gone throu h a lar- 0 *o nunbor of lor-pressuro chanbor oxp-rl'i;nts, and today I cannot. Q T;cul ‘ yc.u say you hove ;ono threu-ch thirty-five, forty-fivo, -ifti', oni hunirod, ona th?usanhot many? A I can't rocctely estimate that today. That covers a nunbow of years, any years. Q * oll » hcw ofter y-u had undergone these uxsrir^r.ta did you boccno acclimated to than, so to sp? Did you bcccro accustom’ to tho ~ h altitude after tor. uxperin-nts, after ;oing throu^ it ton tines, or :• -in- throu h it five tines, or how ion : bafero you bocano -ecus- to high altitudes? r> U?-.-TTVij-c-H'XSic (ifct. Brrr.; rx'. So. 1 .. I 1 J»«t voric personally in tSxia fiel-’, namely the field of r. dapt.-.tion tc hi h alttcudoe, but poo pie in ny instituto did. That was the rfork... * ’. oil, Dactcr, '-hat I c: fcryin to arrive at is, whan dees c parson coaso to be useful as an cjp-erL-vntal subject? I i-aa ino Ruff is net useful new as an oxporixvntol subject because he has subjected bins elf to these aprfnenta so rany tines that he has bacons adapted to hi,-h altitudes, and the sane for Rasher •. .. Adaptation tc hi ; h attitudes is net so.methin- that lasts for tho rost of your life, but aoaothir. which at first rapidly and then noro al wly is lost a-dn. ! One can assume that if a poraon !vis not boor, in a lo-.'-prossuro charfcor for throe or four aonths ho has roturnod to a norm! state. Q On an avorvjo, can't >*o strike an avorc-o from your experience in this field on how Ion it takes for a person to bocorar adaptable to • hi h altitu’s? I afoul,* think that would be a very important problem in aviation me ’idno, inasmuch as ycu could then Just tako lon-prossuro chambers an.* march your pilots into then an’ keop tten in thoro so loxv each lay, for a period of thirty cr forty 'ays, and then they could fo ar 1 flyan’ it wouldn't havo’as much effect on th-n. lfcw Ion can you un>r -o this bofor* you boccoo adapted to tho hi h nltitudo7 A That is a very important problem in aviation medicine, an', has al- roa'’y besn ’oalt with by a nurtoor of pooplo, such as Luft and Lupitu, ■•ut I myself 1 d r»t work in that field and consequently cannot toll you arythin about it from my own oxp.rier.co. You near, that you oro not qu-Oified tc detoriine wfor. a person is a daptable to hi h altitude? T.-S IdTT'drT.nr;: He misun ’orstood tho question. ,.s it a.:ain« A I aan toll by lookin at a person. IT today he is subjoet to rltitu ’ij sickness at ,50C •’tore, and then a week later ho can stand 1., .00 actors. Than I kne; ho has r ’acted diinsolf. This adaptation varies of course with the individual.* * ith era person it is quieter, with another slrwer. It is bar l to rive H ures for that. L7->-r<.T3-L-3-:taxs±e (Int. ^rowr.) Court Ko. 1 Q (By Hr. tody) Say ycu used a sublet on Hond^ and put ^ up to 8,000 foot, 8.0C0 to taro, pardon no, and then you used tin on Tawdsy I and int tin u'p to 8,000 no tar, a : .ain on Tuesday. Then you used tin on Friday and put tin up to 8,000 nttero araln on rrlday. Over that period of flvo days, raid it be rather likely that on the third occasion ho my not ,-et rick? Would it bo as close asthat or uould tho scries have to o into ton, twenty, thirty, forty, or fifty times, or woul-* it bo or* or two tines, an-' after one, two, three, or four tiaos ho may beeono adapted to 8,000 feat, or 8,000 fetors? A Tho first roaotions occur as soon aa tho aoconi* or third time and iW °“° ^reaftor. It does not happen all of a sudden. It is a radual adaptation of tho bo-> which bo ins slowly with the, sooond or third . oor.t, .an then it .r-vdually roaches a aaximun abovo which it does not rlao. Q Th0n TOU1 you 8fty if 3"°° s«y four tintow a week for a month, woul* it bo very iicoly that ho woul' bo adapted to hi f: h alti- tudoa thon? .v vour tir.es a nonth, id you any? 1 "our tir.os a wook, A Four tlm, , nook? Too, after four tir.es a nook . certain effect on 2 tfa v'ould ’oubtlosa bo ictiooablo. i oil then, in tho oourso of experiments it would bo necessary, if ! "ore oin to conduct a lar.o Rufeor of experiments, to have perhaps a suitable number or subjects available, wcul'nit it? If, for instance, yci v.-aro oin to conduct ono hun’rod oxp.Tiswnts, and you were :oin- to con Met tMt ona hun'ro' exp.rinor.ts in a period of one month - do you rollo-.» no, lector, one hur. ro * experittmt. in one month - you would J*v« 40 W that °P 50 ' ■ -:l« experiments per week, rvant^fiva o^ri.er.ts j*r week. Jferr, how mny subjects woul! you need 40 perfcra ^'cnty-fivo experiments p-r -oak? »ould you r.oed twenty-five ejects or woul ’ you need say five -objects and rive each one of then an seporinent each day, and th®, of ccurse, after you ~nv Q one of then an 7210 « ''.-IV k 7-:h-..e (Int* Bream) Court !fo. 1 experiment each J ay ha ay fcccccc a'apted and you nay not bo able to uso rdn any Ion er. Az I thinkin dearly on this subject? - This question camot ba decided in eneral toraa, because you are ju3t .ivin r e a jonoral outline an’ ire not tellin- s» what the experi¬ ments ore to bo liko. If you want an answer, you -ust tell no specifi¬ cally just what these exporlaonts aro, how rapidly the ascent is, at what altitude tho v.n r«rviins, all these thin s -'etcmin? hov; the boy roads to altitude, 1 Lot’s say that they era experiments "herein a man is oin; to be tnkon above 12,000 foot, lib: "biff an' Totfiorr's experiments. Say they aro oapjri'Vints just of that nature. !faw, if you hi l one hundred experi- :-;t.ts to ,• rfon in tho short time of one month, not throe or four nontha, but ow nonth, than ho-' aany subjects woul \ you, as an expert in this fiol , roquiro, booauio, you see, you hnvo to perform fivo axparinents a 'ay, booauso ycu usually/ 'on*t work Saturdays and Sun’ays, I assurao. Do sciontists work Saturdays or.’. Sun'nyj.? only let you uso tho air-pronsure chinbor for one Month. They have to havo it back, '.’hat voulyou soy would bo tho '•isirablo nuabor of subjocts? 'aild you consider usin five, just fivo i’or. an' put tin the fivo wn throu h fivo exj>-'rhacnts each ’ay cr each . ook, . ar ’or. a.;, oul ’ you use fivo *n an’ \xil each ono of that throu-h five »«7‘ -rl x-r.ts a v,y>!<, or ..-oul * it bo bettor to uso ton -ion, twonty non, or thirty r in, *£wn yew only v a o ouch a short spaoo of tiao to con’act ycur sxporiaents? A If I haa short tine I crosuno I shoul * uso a relatively larce rattfcar of oxperirwntal subjocts so that I ceui ! sproa l then out bottor. Tat Afoul.’ bo a .iattor of course. If I have lore tino I oan ;ot alonr vrith ferrer subjects, Unco I -yself haven't worico! in this field of oxpiosiva locociprossion, as you kner.-, I Von't lave any person oxperionc uj in this attar. 8 X«y ••'7-M- .JC-5-1—Malay*- (Brown) C ,uz*t 1 £. f'.u would bo a little ole cautious about usin' Just rivu son, for this period of a conth? wouldn't you? Jus - five men. ... I never -;..vo .:uch thought to the question of tho nuia- bor of experimental subjects, under the conlltions you cite. Q. Do you mean you arrange an experimental plan anl Ion'S :lve thou ;ht to somethin,; like that? I shoul \ think that would 03 quite important, looter, Just how many sub¬ jects you neo 1, because y-u have to have thorn on han 1. If y u wore performin' experiments in your Institute in Munich ani ualn* Luftwaffe volunteers or, say, citizens of Munich, ani offorln.: them 200 lollars to volunteer or somethin* like that. Thon you'd have to lotermlno how many you would r.eel available. Vfoul i you any you coul l use 5 men for ICO experiments to bo performed in one month anl use them safely anl ;et ijool results? In ether words bear in mini that that man has to go through nr. ^xporlaont oaoh Jay, pretty near, in other words, ho has to 'o through 26 experiments in ^*0 days? I have already sail that tho question lo not simply one of tho oxporlaonta and the numbers lnvolvol in tho experiments, but it 16 important how often and how frequently a person la subjoctel to hl.'h altitude during tho experiments, dad ns I havo already sail, I don't know hew explosive decompression aniparnchuto descent affect adaptability to high altitude, becauseaaa I say I haven't worked in that flolu. I know nothin*; about it. If I wore doing this I >culi carry on with a certain num¬ ber of persons as long as the results soemol to bo homog¬ eneous and.as scon as there vis deviation in the results, I would get more subjects. 1223 Brown) Court 1 «. Iou say Chat you ion't snow much about tbo fieli of explosive decompression, that you perhaps never spaolalltei in it ani nevor ooniuotei any experiments in It, then what In what in the world were you loin., by «rran::lrv; for'aasoher to oor.luot experiments If you Isn't Know any thins -.bout It, you lon't know whether a nan can so over 12,000 reet or not an: not suffer... JUDOS 32ERING: .:r. Harly, you keep referring to 18,000 feet. I think If y.u will look at the reoori /ou win ri„, it is 12,000 meters. I think you win finl also when you referral to the Eaohnu ex.erloents that over the perlol of tine of two nonthe or perhaps a little lon..er, that la to say froa about 10 or 11 ^aroh until 20 Hay when me ohnaoor was suppose 1 to have been removed, there were between 200 an.’. a 00 exper- lnentu, With about 50 per cent of then male about 14 or 15 kilometers, which woull be 14,000 or 15,000 meters not 16,000 feet. 5. That's what 1 meant, your Honor, in as nuoh as ju^-e Bobrin* has jot to the polnr f or U s. woull you klnily tell mo. Doctor, whether It woull be feasable from the 10th of March to tho 20;h of Hnyi — Dr. Ruff anl Dr. RjBbor* maintain, mat the first experiment took place on the 22n 1 of February 22 they discontinue! until Rasoher cams back from Sohon-tau. He returnol from Bohor.-au an l Somber - returned from Berlin whore he was vl si tin* his wife, about 10 Kerch, an they start*! the experiments 10 March, froa 10 H troh to *1 March, you have approximately 20 cays, the month of .,->rll which is approximately -’O or ’1 .ays, ani you have 20 lays In Hay, so you have there a total of Seme 7., iaya , whlch e Hay u?-J-.,iC-o-'-Haloy-(Brown) Court 1 la lass than two and a half months. in a period of two ani. a half months you performed nearly *00 experiments on 7 to 12 subjects; doesn't that seems to be quite a number of experiments to require one nan to endure dur- lng a of .two and a half months? you divide 12 In¬ to 00 and then 11 vide ? into * 00 ; that la underpin a ccr.sl lerable number of experiments, isn't he? ... Yea, are you talking about the effects on their gen¬ eral health, or are you talking about the effects as regards aiaptatlon to high altitude? Ho, I an not. I an not talking about the effect r.n their gonorU health. I an referring to tholr adap- tability t: hl.;h altitude, anl whothor or not they would centinuo to oe useful In the experiments as ox>wrlmental subjects, and bearing In mind of oourse, as Judge Seb- rlr. • intod out, that these men 're going 50 per cont of the tine above 1-,,000 meters. - 31g fl ;uros soon to aako a .jreat lnpresslons on you, but I and Ruff have already told you that the ultimate altltu-o is not alone Important, but Just as auoh depends on the tine. Whether the subjects alapt themselves or not In a certain exonmont, that I can see; in the program that Romborg drew up, I beliovu thoro was sorl, us .adaptation to high altltulo,. Q. You have stated that It ia possible that a person oould be adaptable to cno height In a period of three or four nr five ex oriments; now, suppose you were ex¬ perimenting anl as soon ae you saw he was adapted, would you Irop him ,ut? 1 8a r tha “ * tiireo or four experiments the subjects adapt themselves. I said that if you are trying to achieve adaptation to high altltulo and arrange 8 . '.ny -x7-M-.Ji«B-i-Keloy-(Bn»on ) Court 1 tha experiments so that a high da too of accllBitiia- tior. will result, then you oan start seeln* results after two or throe ascents, that is what I sal \. Q, Veil, as scon as you soo the result, then y-»u wr.ulin not use the nan In further experiments, would you? If In the course of an ocgorlmental series I see that the subjoot la becoming adapted and llsruptln;; the experlaent, then of course I ion 1 1 use that sub¬ ject any further. -ell, the ether an ;le, what a out the health of the subject uniertfoin.; we will any such a largo number of experllaer.ta In tho course of a month as 25, or 20 ox- pexliaents in two nan tbs, would that have •anythin.': tr lc with It? •v. Lot as clear this up. Adaptation to high altitude Is not on injury to one's health, but It la a reaction which la ooaotinea deliberately indues 1 , by sonllni* people to tho noun tains, for example. It has nothing to lo with lam age tc one's health. It is a perfectly normal condition, one that results naturally In high altltules In the mountains, an 1 a condition whloh a person voluntarily brings about If he la going to spend his vacation In a high mountain terrain. No in¬ juries to the person's health are to be expected, I can thlnfc of no case, except for one or two cases where there was sci-e question of tuberculosis having resulted after a large nu^eor of experiments. :%b I say, except fer these o-ses m the course of perhaps Billions of ascents I snow of only two oases «here TB resulted. In doubtful connection with hi h altitude. In other words, for all this Is of no consequence, because It 72i:* g May -:7— - .«K-5— 5- Malay— (Brown) Court 1 is much too rare. For all practical purposes lasa>:o to jalth is non-existent In nl :b-altltulo experiments. 1 . 'Yell, now. Doctor, t$oln£ tic/, to the su bjects use ! at Dachau, ill y^u over personally talk to one of the SUbJOOtS use 17 ... Ho, from what I nave sail It must be pretty clear that I 11 In' t. I was In Dachau only at thl9 or.-- Uscus- elon before the bo;innir..-: of the experiments, an 1 , nevj 0 ,,‘ain. i. I see, an! the iiaoussl^n that you had at Dachau was merely the pr-llolnary meutlnml the inmates wore soloote.V at a later 1 -te; you 11 In't even see the lnaateo? ... The principles were llscussel, aocorlln.? to which the subjects v-.-o to be selectel. They were 'f course actually oho son later. I know nothing aore about all these events, beoauso I was r.o lon;or lnforr-sl of what was -oin.- on. <1. How, you 11 in’t see the subjects, an 1 you no tes¬ tify before this Tribunal unlor oath from your own Knovie i -e that the subjects usol woro volunteers? ... 31r.es I never saw thea, I oan't testify on that subject at all. I can only say that it was a,*reei with the camp commander •-'hat the nature of these experiment'd subjects was to be. That la the extent of ay knowledge on the -natter, ^ftor thatl know nothin.:. Veil, now, after that .aoetin-j, car. you tell us whet¬ her or not you llscussel ;he nature of the subjects, that la the character of the subjects with anyone; -111 anyone afterwards tell you where they *ot the volunteers? ... I toll you in cy airect examination hov thln:s 721V e May c-.urt 1 “Or wn) 7-'A-. £.- 6-o-Mal cy continual as far as I was concarnad. I hear! n thin: '■•trd ab.ut the pre^rass of tha axparlrtonts. Has char vr.e in 3chon,-au on 1 that was thj raason why I aahad ■■ through tha letter fcln to report on what was ;oin, on. Raacnor tell ra that ha vaa atlll In Schon^au, that tha axpcrlaonts In Dachau hadn't started yat. MR. fLiRDY: .»t this tlEc I would llfcu to aeX tha court roportara t clarify tha record wherein I hava rofo rel to floras, na oly 8,000, 10,000, 1-..000, or 15 , 000 , If I hava uaal tha word fact, hinlly atriJeo that an. lnclu a the war. a^twra. I uaal tha vor 1 faat arrone ualy. Thio la a :c *d broa/.iiv; point, Your -Honor. i— ?RJS 1 D 5 .:?: Tna Tri-unil will be In rooias. (Thereupon a recuec was tahan,) 3 ’fey 1 r. in :r (Int. >jnl«r) Court :u>. 1 T~Z .. d'-IJ.: Persons in the courtroa; .vill please find their salts. Tribunal is a air. in session. : . T. .elto, it has boer. called to ry attention urin- the • . rices;: t: t you and I are oon 'uctir. our examination rueh too rapi dly, or. ! tho court reporters are havin' considerable difficulty in takin • lorn tho tos: irony, so, if you will attest to cooperate, I will (to the dame ai. ’ see if we can slow doin', a bit. ? Doctor, wo lave hear’ here in this courtroon tho opinion of various persona, namely. Professor loibrondt, Rostock, Rose, Giovors, an.l several of t:.o othor defendants, conccrnin tho capacity of a poraon incarcerated to volunteer for an erpcri/Mnt. hat is your at ti to do about tho capacity of a prisoner to volunt-»r for vdical e'rporlnente? .. I boliova that in this caso ono must clearly ’istin uish bn two on t;w philosophical concept o. froo ./ill arid tho lor.al froo will on tho ono har.’, ani tho natural, sciontific '.o tor.-d nation of our actions. Hvory ono of our actions is of courso toterrdnod casually by drcunstancoa which have piMc . '.ot that ction, by tho nature of one's personality; and, thcroforj, any dll is ,’otor. irwtf naturally, scientifically by innur»rablo causes. • ; uito indoponient of that consideration is another consi toration which confronts mo with a choioo of vhothor to to somethin or not to to it. Tho ycor person vho voluntoors because of a sun of noroy I ham offeror! hin is certainly not oir., that of his own froo will, in tho othor fom; hi is also boin forco! to accept money, bocau3o of his entiro situation; V.^t the other .ay of lookin at it. If I havo ail opportunity cither yoa or no without boin thraatonod 'irectly because of ny docision, ono has to say that tJ» prisoner has the svo ,'roo ri'ht, to !oci ’.o as is tho caso with any other hunan bein . That obviously is tho poiviral opinion, because, oth3m5.se, oxae coul ’ never su’snlt an affidavit .to a prisoner; ho docidos ;uito fr>oly whoever or not h; is oin*: to si n. He can make nany other icisions. Just as can nako that decision. I was aske ! in tho ccnp rhothar T was «iilin tc to a rather of thin s which of courso arose fron the fact that I wa3 imprisoned. Had I not been Inprise nod, nobody noul' f T U ?—’ V,. 7?-"-;ir ^aSlcr) ^ourt So. 1 h3Yo tharht of askir. no those questions, Idle Imprisoned I was in a .■'ft'Ltioa to '.'-i *.o freely Aether, for oxarqrle, I irante' 1 to .to cor tain , for on i "ition to -y rations. TfcU ms a conplotely fro? docision. - rooll' tor«t 3^3 why a prisoner basically is actin' ur.-’or different cor - tions than any ethos Person. Tba prerequisite is, of course, that I a . not threatened but na . iver. an opportunity to rako this .decision freely 3 :a»y 1 : 7 --..“--3-1-5=(Int. ’anler) Court Jfc. 1 a Then, ir. substance, Doctor, \t is your opinion that 2 -?rsor. oran incarcerated, cm actually, in tho true sense of tho -or’., be a ,nr.; r for 2 laical exparisont? A 3 or thinly, 1 ell, now .’o you think that in tho case of cor.cantrr.tion canp , in-.os — heroin here in Germany :re ha” a unique situation, that you had arininal prisoners or.’. political prisoners — ’o you think that applies to either category equally ae r;oll? .v Th ro is no -,'cubt in «y oir. t over, in a concentration canp, roluntoar ’acisions coul-' be offered to *tho parsons there in 00 faith, that these prsora wore actually froe in their decisions. If I an now subsets er.tly tol? that that 't not happen in nr.ny casos, I can only nay — and that has already boon a r. Luts ~ that it ns nn ojior.tous surprise for us at - vo . 1 szr/i .ms legally' oondesmed, to the:. return to society and rdn.;le therein? i h*t that ele n opt crop up in your tin'? .. 17 on considers an atonasent to society, I don*t think that there is ny iifforence whether this atonanont takes tho fom of a certain rj-.oun; of tii.a spont in a prison, or whether it is sorved by subjecting oneself to danror, in tho intorost of socioty. I don*t know what tho lojml aspect is, and I never worried about it. Whether it was legally permissible or not was so-vothiir for the State to consider. .7e woro rarely confronted with tho fact than offer had boon and* to us to carry out oxporinonts under oortain conditions rd&ch wo boliovod to be irroproachablo. That was tho situation we faood. It oertoinly was not our task to ohanrjo thoso conditions in w ay. All -o had to -sk ouraulvoa waathlsi Aro thoso conditions objectionable, or are they not? T'.io con’itions thoy woro told to :a by Raschor, ns they vroro con¬ tain,. in Hi-T-l-r's letter, an'. as I n rood with -tuff, I oonoidor and I want to repoat oivso sere — to bo irroproachablo fron an international standard, rv* ^esurod against tho strict standards of poaco. Q Well no r, vruro ytx: fonHiar with t*vj manor in which thoso aubjoots usod in thoso exp.rir.onts wore approached? A How thoso persons woro approached? Q Tos. A I already said that the conditions were discussed with Pyrokowsky, After that I didat x^ar. anythin , also about tho further ooursa of ovonts. 3 (Toll, now, baforo you t alkod — or, while you roro talkin; with tho concentration crjr: ccmantmt, di-* ycu at *h'-t no a tint; — or did Ruff or Rorfcerg cr Raschorj ono of your "roup — instruct tho concentration canp eaavmdant on how many subjects they thou Jit they would nood? Did they M say, l! wo will nooi t»r. subjects, or twenty subjects, or thirty' subjects — and woe pick thirty volunteers or a hundred volunteers?' A C-rtainly. naturally, FVrkow3ky would have to know about how many tKrsons woro needed* Hcv cany volunteers did thoy docido at that nootin- would bo necessary? 3 !2xy !j7-M-ArD-8-3-6cnrab (Int. ^-dcr) Ccwrt So. 1 A I can't roceaber now whother an exact was given, Q Well, they wore supposed to co-id from certain blocks in the canp, weren't they? You started to naco two or throe blocks wherein they would go and select tho volunteers. Is that correct? A Tea. Q What did tho concentration cnxro comandant say? Sinply, wo will uso thxa from two or throe different blocks" — or Just what was that convorsati.cn? ’Toil'', you ropect it for ae, please? A I renoabor the follmdnc* Schnitd.or first infomed Phrkcnrsky about Hisraler's central order. Then >*o oxplainod tho oxtont of tho expjrirxnts to Pyrkovrsky — what it was all about, Anl I an sure that ho was given an approximate fijuro. Than Pyrkowsky considerod from which blocks those porsons wero to bo solcctod. Q Do yo: know how nany imatos w„ro housed or quartered, in ono block? A I know that now, after having: livod in those blocks for a con¬ siderable porlo' of ti. -lysoH", 7 ton, of course, I could lnaglne nothing by tho oxprossion "block *• Q Fould you toll tho Tribunal froa your experience in Dachau since tho war ended how .any paoplo can bo haisod in ono block? A Vo wore up to 160 persons in a roc-nj thr-jo bods, ono abovo the other. There wore six rooris. Q That consists of ono block? A Yes, that was one barracks. Q Thon, in othor nerds, you ha*’ six rooms with 260 porsons to each roon? A Tes, that was tiio situation when thu roans were fully occupied, and that i 3 what I expertuncod. Q And h. sot aside t-.-o blacks to bo usod — or two blocks fror which they would select the volunteers? A That I isn't know. Q I see, Toll, you d? knew that they sot asi lo ono block to bo use i — or di ! the concentration caap oc.-rordant say, well, wo will ot our volun- 7223 8 Hay l*7-M-AIZ>-3-ii-Schrab (Int. Ranter) Court 'Jo. 1 tears frco Blocks 1, 2, 3 and h? Or did ha say, wo will got than fron just Block *>• 1? i The figures Pyrkowsky nentionod at that tine !idn*t naan anything to rti. ffc osntiorod ono block or the othor. Therefore, I ion»t know whether he sail that wo shall got than free Block 2h, or that 2*» sold 28, or any other block. I can»t say that because tteso figures didn't naan anything to no. 722Ji S -&V-: H3-9-1-Gillaghar (Int. Rraior) Ccurt Nc. I, Case Be. 1. Q How, Dec tor, after tho conference in January 191*2, and then after the meeting in Dachau, which ta a couple of days later, then the lev pressure chamber was sent to Dachau via y-ur Institute, and tho oxporlaonts were to be "in cn February 22nd. Hnr you had had y-ur quarrel with Raseher? A May I correct something? Q Yea. A Tho experiments . oro nt t start n tho 22nd .f February, that was net known t: no. I know nothing about that. Tho only thing I learned was that tho low pressure cHarbor arrived, but when tho ex¬ periments were to start, or what else was arranged, I don't know. Q Ifell, now, when did you have your first disagreement with Rasclier, approximately what date, in tlie month of January, or tho nonth of Feb ruary, or in the month of Uarch, your first disayoonont with him? How, as of the tire you loft Dachau in January when you visited the concentration comp cc.i arxiant and -ado arrangononts for tho perfcmcnco of the experiments, that is, tho technical arra:igo.acnt at that tire when you wont to the concentration camp with Ruff and Romberg, that is, Ruff was Romberg's superior, and you said in the direct that you wero Rascher's superior; now after that tiro whon arrangnonto wore being mado, when did you have your first disagreement with Rascher? A T fo separated in 1 unlch aftar tills visit at Dachau. Rascher returned to Schongau, while Ruff and Roaberg returned to Berlin; after that I heard nothing more. Q ’Toll, now — tho:; you say that Rascher was relieved in Feb¬ ruary, or in -he beginning of larch, on your direct examination, or, tho latest would have boon during the first week in March thatryou no longer had any connection with Rascher. lion just when did you have your disagreement with Rascher, and received this telegram, and so forth. I want to try to fix tho date. Doctor, when Rascher pointed out to you abo’.rt in a telegram that this was to be a secret, and ho could not toll anything about it and so forth? 1225 5 toy-W-JB-9-2-Gallsghcr (Int. Punier) Court Fo. I, C:-se Jk>. 1. 1 I an just clarifying that. After to had separated at Dachau, Rancher had returned to Schongau. He was at that tine still residing there. It rude no difference to no personally when the ex¬ periments would start. I had no interest in pushing then, so T did not bother about it. I was in Munich. Q You wore in l&inich? A Yes. Q But at this tine before the experiments started on a data which was unknown to you at that tiao, you wore still in tho position as Raschor's superior, and Roaborg was subordinate to Ruff, in the sano position that you wore when you loft tho ennp at Dachau, after tho arranger*nta had been aado, is that right? A Raschor at that was ry subordinate. Ho had boon do- tciiod to ay Institute. This aS3igxnont until that tino had only boon southing on pspor, incsruch as Rare her Jiad told re ho still had work tc do in Schongau, whore ho was doing sorbthing regard i.vg tho distant gaugo, and I did not try to got Raschor quickly, bccauso I did not nood him for cy purpose. I then hoard accidentally that Roseher was staying in Munich, core one had 3ocn hia there. Than I van of tho opinion that if ho cm:* to Junich anyhow, ho may report to no. Thoro- upon I wrote hie a letter saying that ho would have to report to no twico a took, while ho was residing them. I already described that. Q This happened whon, what date, approximately tho 1st of February? A I conclude fron Docoaont Ho. 23k that tho last conversa¬ tion took place at the end of February, or at the beginning of March; the two preceding tines that Rancher core tc suo mo were also* a half a wcok oarlier. Q hell, than you ordoracl Raschor to report to you twice a wcok, after you lad discovered he was in Munich. Kow, that was in Feb¬ ruary, is that right? * A Yes, that ras in February. 7226 3 Jfey-24-y2-9-3-Gallaghcr (Int. Easier) Court No. I, Case 2o. 1. Q Now he reported to you, did he, in conpliance with the lottor, or the order? A The first tise Rascher care to soo no and I asked hin why he never looked ne up, and ho answered that ho still had work at Schon- gau, and ho said that after all the experinents at Dachau had not yot started. Q And did you at that tine have a sovero quarrel with him, or did you then see hin at a later date? A I kept cd- cal* during this first conversation; I could say there was a certain tension, and I nade it clear to Raschor I wanted to preserve sy status as his superior, and that tension was notod free, the tone ir. which I wrote tho lotter to hin. Tho lottor was not addrossod, "Itf dorr Rasohor, ■ but was stated, '’You aro re¬ quested to report to no twico a week wearing your uniform.'' !k> could have no doubts on account of that lotter that I was not approaching hi* os sceo good acquaintance, or a friond of his, but that I was ap¬ proaching hi* as his superior. Ho had no doubts on hi*. Q Ho coco tho first tire? A Yoa. Q That first tiiaa would bo about tho 1st of Fobrv-nry, wouldn't it? A No, I don't believe so. That must have happened later. Q Anon would you say. Could you set some date about that? A If I laid tho last conversation when ho showed re the tolcgrar., about the end of February, or tho beginning of »!arch, I would say the first conversation took place cne and a half rooks earlier. Q That would be about the 20th of February, approximately? A Yes, that could bo. Q Foil, new then tho experiments be^an the 22nd of February * unbeknown to you? A No, that was not known to re. 7227 8 Hay-lHB-0-Ji-Gallagher (Int. Roaln r) Court No. I, Case No. 1. q Rascher reported to you again. When did he report to you the second tlao? A Half a week later, as I had ordered hia. q That was about the 1st of Uarch, or about the 27th of February, or tbo 1st of parch? A No, if I assuao that the first report took place on tho 18th or .20th of February, then the second report nust have tn!:en placo throe days later. Q Threo dv» later. Well, then, ho had started tho exFeri- nonts on 22nd of February, did ho report to you tho second tiro before or after ho had started tho oxporJmonts, do you know? A I never learned that. I can not tell you anything about that. q Ho reported to you fer tho second timo, about tho 22nd of Fobruary, or tho 23rd of Pobruary, around in there? A Tos. • q And what happened on that occasion? A In tho aeantiru Anthony had telephoned mo fron the Ikjdical Inspectorate, and had told no - rather had inquirod fron do how tho experiments at Dachau wore progressing, and how long they would contin¬ ue; wheroupon, I told Anthony, "I can not tell you anything about that." I said that I did not know anything about tho Dachau oxpxiccnts. Vihon Rascher cams, I asked hie about Dachau. I told hin that tho "odical Inspectorate had rung ce up, and that day wanted to know what was going on- Hnschor insisted that he had yet to roceive his instructions and only then would he be in a position to report to no. He would thon knew how nuch ho would tell no, and I then said to Fischer *hat I would not enter in such dealings, oitJxr would not I bo participating in tho experiments, or else he would have to be eliainated fron ny agency. I imagined that tho ifcxt tine thore would bo a considerable quarrel be¬ tween us because I had put Rascher before an alternative. I was quite prepared that Rascher would raise sono other objections, and, ttereforo 7228 8 J&v-H-B-9-5-GaH-gber (Int. Raslar) Court No. !, C-T90 No. 1. asked »Texxit to attend the third conversation. I already testified to that bore. Rascher handed =» Hirr-ler's tolcgra-., whereupon I told hin that cleared this situation entirely, "You can no longer roaain in office." Rascher did not rake aiy further renarks. The report had ended. I dictated a letter to Bondt addressed to the Uiftgna, asking that Rascher be released. I than went to Berlin, wanted to report to Hippke. Hippl:e, however, was not there. Consequently I told the entire story to Anthony. 7229 Court Hu. 1 8 Kay 47-K-10-l-LHX-Eaynes (Easier) Q. And did Anth-ny appr-ve the transfer .f Batcher fr-o y.ur institute? A. Yes, he aper-ved it. He .lust accented it as an acciaoliehod fact and he said n his nart that he v.uld have t c sc t' sene ther oettlecent vith the Air Gau. He did a t say vhat his final decision vac because he pr. bably culdn t du that. He probably had to rev rt the natter either tc his chief of staff vr to Kippke or get int c ntact vith the Air Gau. Z d x't ka v vhat ho did. Q, Vail, nev, this all happened about 1 Aar chi That is the datol A. I assuae that the conversation vith Anthony t«-k place during the first doys cf Kerch. period cf ..... q. After that/tine Enschcr vas no longer y ur sub'rdinatol A. Ho, that elluiaated hi* very clearly. Q, Then y u vore n 1 nger connected vith anything that Batcher did! A. He. ^ toll, n v, y u have dravr. the Tribunal’s attenti n tc D cunont HO 264, vhich is dated 2fc Acril 1942, in vhich y u have efforod the explonati-n that it is Quite tbvi-us fr-B the turn rt events, as y-u have explained the* t the Tribunal, that this dato f 28 Anril sh-uld read 26 February, rather than April. This is n cage 7? f Y'ur Boners' d cusent book nuaber 2, Exhibit Sc. 60. Bov, 3 ct r, if vc ogsuso for the s sent that your oesumoticn that the date should bo 26 February is c-rrect. thon it Ml vs thit herein it is recues ted that the asaignsent f Hascher suet issediately be changed tc the Aviati n lest Institute. Bcrlin-Adlcrsfccf. Aucoenstclle Dachau, and acc rding t- y ur testiseny, because f y ur dispute vith Baschor .a 1 Kerch y-u then vent t the Luftgau and else rec rted t- Eippke via Anth ny that y u vere no l.nger assuring rose nslbility f r Batcher and that Bascher vas to be transferred fr = yur institute. Ecv that is the natural c urse of events if v« assure that this date is 26 7230 Court Sc. 1 8 Hay 47-H-lC-2-IHX-Eaynea (--.asler} February, is that correct? A. Yea, if ay assumption la correct that aascher was etill in ay office on 28 February, the date of this letter; hoverer. he v«b certainly no longer at ay office bn 16 March, as can be seen from Document 318. Prosecution Exhibit 67. Q, That ia page 70 of your Honora' docunent book, 318, that the defendant la referring to. Do you have the document book there, Dr. Veit*? A. I have thoee tv« docuncnta. Q. bill you kindly point out again to the Tribunal vhy you maintain that the docunent dated 16 Aoril 1942. on page 70. ahova that Eaachor la no longer in your lnatitute? Vhat ia there apparent in that docunent that ahova that? A. In Docunent SC 316 la anya, and I ouote; "The Stabertt Dr. Saach,r vs detailed for special evnexinonto, tho execution of vhich together vith the experimental oatabllahnent for uir navigation vaa rendered poaaible by the Keichafuehror SS at Dachau, to the oxpcrlaentnl eatabliahnent for aviation, branch office Dachau, free March 16 until April 16, 1942." That la to aay that Raechor during that time hold a different aaaignnont. Therefore, he could not have been working at ay lnatitute. I think that there can be no doubt about that. Veil, now, vhat institute v^ild ho be at according to thia lettor? Who it he aaaignad to now? A. Veil, I can apeak only of vhat ie contained in thia letter. There ia aentlon nado here of the branch office. Dachau, of the German Experimental Institute for Aviation, 7hi. ia an agency vhich probably has act existed in this fora, because I cannot imagine that there existed ~en cxceriaental institute for avietion vith a branch office at Dachau. Where this designation cones from and hov it originated I of course don't know. For ne it i. important only to prove that Eaacher hod another assignment on 16 March and vaa no longer working with me. Whether this 7231 Court So. 1 8 Hay 47-H-10-2—fcHX-Eeyrcs (Easier) nssigcrsent wes to e place vhich la designated correctly or incorrectly tears no inportance for this caso. Vert then eeieed that this pesignuent te prolonged. The vhole thing ♦'as intended to bring Fascher to Dachau. Q, And Eippko, according to this letter, is veil avero of the fact that you vere no longer connected with Easehor, is that true? A. I don't have the letter fros Eippice bofore no. If you can toll no where it is— q. This lattor of 16 April to vhich you referred is addressed tc Hlppke. A. Yes, but there is another letter in existence, the ronly lettor of Hlppico, vhich I can't rcaenber at the accent. Hippkc then in offcct prolongs Haschor's assignment, as far as 2 con rosonbor, but I haven't got the lettor befero ne. q. Sell, nov, attune for tho nocont that the docunont on page 73, that is, 264, SC 264. Exhibit So. 60, assunc for tho aonent that the date 2e April is ccrroct, as it is on the docunont, rctually is on tho document - that that is corroct. Troa this file note of SS-Cboreturn- bannfuchrer Schnltrlor it atnoers cults conclusively that Batcher is still the subordinate of Veltr on 26 April 1942, doosn't it, talcing that letter on i\* face? A. If vs essuae that tho date on this note of Schnitslcr is cor¬ roct, then ell the statenonts vhich Hrs. Raschor has nedo ero not cor¬ rect. Tho entire letter can then nakc no sense. Q. 3a that as it aay, Doctor, I nsked you n oueetion. Frcn this lettor, in and of itself, disregarding any other letters, from this letter vith the date 26 April thereon, it is eponront that Rancher is still your subordinate, isn't itl 7r;a thle letter? A. Yes, but that is not true. q. All right, Sov, *ust a aoaont. Do you recall the nano Anneliese Frick? A. Yes. q. Can you tell the Tribunal vfao Anneliese Frick is - F-R-I-C-Z? 7232 Court So. 1 5 Key 47 -M-l 0-4-*2K-Eay ne■ (Hauler) A. Kies Frick v»a a technical assistant cf our Institute. She li the daughter, la she not, cf Vilholn Frick, vho vee e defendant before the International Military Tribunal? A. Tee, she is Frick'a daughter, and also the daughter of hie vifo vho divorced kin. I think that at the tine sho vp.o at ny institute they were elroedy divorced. Veil, when did Kies Frick Join your institute? A. That I can no longer toll you. I really don't knov. Q. If Klee Frick aaid that she Joined your lnatitutc on 16 April 1942, vculd y-u aaaune that thrt was about right? A. I can hardly check that. 16 Atsril 1942? Tea. A. It la poealble. Q, Poealble. boll, nov, did Dr. fiasehor ever cone to viait you after you had your disagreement in March? You stated in dlrcot that you only oa.v fclu accidentally a few tluos after you rolievod hlu. A. The statements are contradictory to that offoct. As far ne I roneebor, it vns roported to r.o that Baachar had appoarod several tinea in tho institute, behind ay back. On the other hand, Vcndt did not knov anything about these visits, vhich wore reoortod to no by othor oconlo. Today I no longer knov whether Batcher a.ppearod several tinea at ny lnatitutc during ny absence or not. Cn the occasion of rr first inter¬ rogation I stated that Ha.acher eooeared at tho inetitute behind ny back because I thought that I could rer.cnbcr one such roo'.rt. 7233- 8 May-W-iB-U-l-iioxsie (Int. Rasler) Court He. I. Q Did Rascher over ap;«ar at your institute in late April or May tc see you? A I don't know that. Q You don't renenber that? A You naan, did Rascher once core visit ne after the telogran? Q Yos. A I don't rcc.cnber that. Q Do you recall a particular incident which occurred cither the latter part of April or first of May or tho niddlo of Hay or in that period of tire, not in tho month of March or first of April, whorein Rascher was casing to seo you, and you wore pretty busy and you didn't want to spend too nuch tino with him bocauso you wore too busy? Do you recall any such thing as that? A Ho, I don't renoabor anything like that, but I always said that it is qulto possible that Rascher appoarod at tho institute aftor- wards. I said already that I remember a report which I had that ho Was there onco more. This, hewovor, cannot bo brought into confamity with Wendt's statement. That is, thoroforo, why I.don't know what tho correct situation is. Q I an not referring to Rosebar's visiting you bohind your back. I want to know rvwr whether you can recall having had a visit fron Rascher in late April or early !!ay, or oven 3 coo tino during the month of Uay, the whole month of lay. Did Rascher ever visit you, yourself, go to your office to see you in April or ltay? A I don't renestoer that, but I wouldn't exclude that possi¬ bility at all. Q How, let us try to refresh your recollection.* As it so happened either in late April or early !toy you had broken your watch, or you didn't have a watch so that you could tell tiz£, and do you ro- call asking Kiss Frick for the loan of her watch so that whon Rascher care you »culd bo able to judge the tine because you wore so busy, and you were unable to spend toe such tiao with him. How, en incident like 8 May-lWS-ll-2-Hoxsie (1st. Ranler) Court Ko. I. that oust be cne you can roaenbor clearly, when you borrowed Hiss Frick's watch upon a visit by Raschor so that ycu would be able to titto hin and allow hi= a specific amount of tine for a conference with you- Do you recall that? A Ko, I ten't remaster it, tut if Miss Frick says so, I don't want to exclude that possibility. Q Well now, did you ever ask Raschor for an invitation to Dachau to attend the experiments? A Do you norm en invitation to Dachau to attend the experi¬ ments? After Raschor had »h:wn no the to lu gram, it was quits clear that I — Q At any tlno. At any tin*, before or after. A Would you ploaso repeat the question? Q Did you request that you bo allowed to attond the experi¬ ments at Dachau before the telegran? A Bofora the tologrsm it certainly was ny wish to attond tho experiments. Q And did you tell Raseher that if you could not attend tho experiments that Raschor would be withdrawn or you would roliuv o Raschor or roquast his transfer from your institute? A Cortd nly. That was the argunont in tho conversation. Q And you fully deny cr exclude tho possibility that you issued an ultimatvxa that Raschor would bo withdrawn in case you woro not invited to attond the oxpoiinonts before tho first day of May, not Iferch, May? A That I asked Rase ter, that I wanted to participate in tho experiments, was really the coro of ay arguments with him/ but I don't beliovu that that happened in May. As I can see frcn tho documents, tho entire affair took placo at tho beginning of March. Q Uow, this Document 26i* has a date on it, 28 April, 23 April. You maintain it nay wo 11 bo 23 February, and in that document it ap¬ pears that you want to sea then tho whole arrangement at Dachau. Itar, 2 l^y-^:'3-il-3-:ioxsio (Int. Reader) Court KOa I. if that date ia correct, then it light bo correct that you could have asked F^soher tint you wanted to go there and see what was going on, and it Ruscher was still your subordinate, if that letter is correct, and :u said that if you didn’t sea the experimnt you wore going to relieve hin, as Into as April 28, April that lettor is dated. How, you ox- clude that possibility alto^Jthor, don't you? A The letter by Mrs. h'ini Rnscher dated tho 2Jith of February could then hardly bo explained. (J I dicta't ask tho letter to bo troll explained, Doctor. Wo will oxplnin that in nrgxECRt* I cc now asking you to think again, did you relieve Rancher from your cosrand in March, or did you relievo Raschor fron your cooaind in, say, Juno? A I cannot r.iko any othor statcrasnt than what appoart fron the document. I have tried to reconstruct tho entire fitter on tho basis of what I havo seen in tho documents. I cannot interpret JIrs. Nini Rnschor's Litter dated 2iith of February otter than to mean that I was prohibited to attend tho experiments, md that tho entire dlo- ovoslons as to itaothor I was to participate or not nust bo placod in¬ to Fobruaiy, and that is tho only indication that I have i tlioso \ foots, Q Wo 11 now. Doctor, would you say that Milch would havo boen informd that Raschor was no longer associated with you when this break took plnco in March, or would Milch have been niclod and boon iris informed as la to as 20 May, 19U2? A I can toll you nothing about that. I don't know what happened bo tween tho Medical Inspectorate and Milch. Q noil, liilch did consider you and Raschor associated as Into as 20 May, 19hZ, didn't ho, according to Docuscnt 3k3-FS which is in German Documnt Book and Docurwr.t Book Ho. 3# tho freezing ex¬ periment document book, on Pago 11, wherein l!ilch addresses Wolff in tho "Dear Whiffy" letter, and Milch states: "In reference to your tolc- TvU of 12 May our sanitary inspector reports to no that the altitude 3 :>v'-4>-:2-ll-4-HoxEio (Int. Rader) Ccurt Ho, I, cxporlaents carried out by the SS and Air Force at Dachau have been •'Inisbed. Any continuation of thoso oxper incuts Boons essentially un- onable. However, the carrying out of experiments of sore other kind, in ru,~.rd to perils at high son, would be important. These have been procorod in ircediate agreenent with tho proper officos; Major .cits rd 11 be charged with tho execution and Cr.pt. Rase her will bo available until further orders in addition to liia duties within tho Medical Corns of the Air Corps." Kcw, it appears there that Hr. llilch still considers you and Hascter as associates and hln being subordinate to you, doesn’t it, as lato as 20 '.lay? A That does not soon to bo the case. It be coma a clearly ap¬ parent from Hlppico's state sent hovr this suggestion Uilch to Wolff has originated. Hippko testifios that there was a dosiro to carry out frooting exporlunts and that Hippko hod made another suggoetion com¬ pletely indouendont of tho high-altitudo oxporiraonts, to ask mo to at- to»d the so froosing oxpciLnonto boenuso I hod already worked on that subjoct. That has nothing whatsoever to do with the high-altitudo ox- jxriaants and therefore doos not prove whether I nt that tiro workod togettiur rrith Rnschcr or not. That was a suggestion that Hippko mndo to -'ilch on his own initiative and was ontiroly independent of whether Rr.sc her was working at cy ofiico or not. Q It so.ms rather strange that Hippko would suggest you work with a can again with when you had a sevoro disagreement, doesn’t it, on oxpori.-r.ent3 which are al3o going to bo in a concentration carap who ru¬ in there is an alleged telogroa that you ware not allowed thoro, that ttoy woro secret and Hinder ro-ld not lot you in. It sccns rathor strange new that they would sort of associate you with this nan whom you have absolutely transferred free your organization and don’t want ary cere association with, doesn’t it? A That may be strange if I had later again worked with him, but from the fact that =y name was dropped, and from tho fact that throughout the entire later correspondence qy nano no longer apj»arod. 7237 5 • k-y-iS-HS—11-u-Boxsle (Int. Racier) Court Ko. I* experiments carried out by the S3 and Air Force at Dachau havb boon •'inisted. Any continuation of those oxporimonts soens essentially un- : .onable. However, tte carrying out of experiments of some other and, in regard to perils at high sea, would bo L-yortnnt. Tliosa have been pro cored in immediate agreement with tho proper offices; Uajor .cits rill be charged with tho execution and Capt. Rnschor will be vnilr.blo until further orders in addition to Ids duties within tho lie die al Corno of the Air Corps." Now, it appears thoro that Ur. llilch still considers you and Raschar as associates and his being subordinate to you, doesn’t it, ns lato as 20 Uay? A That does not sees to bo tho ensj. It becomes clearly ap¬ parent free Hippke's otatocont haw this suggestion try Milch to YTolff has originated. Hippke tcstlfios that thoro was a desire to carry out freezing oxporiunts -nd that Hippke hod nado another suggostion com¬ pletely indouendont of tho high-altitudo oxporinonts, to ask so to at- tond tho so froosing oxperisonts bocauso I had already worked on that aubjoot. That h-o nothing whatsoovor to do with tho high-altitudo ox- Txriaonta and therefore does not prove "bother I nt that tiro workod together rrith Base her or not. That was a sugguction that Hippko nado to Jllch on his own initiative and wns entirely independent of whothor Raochar wno working at =y ofiico or not. q It so-ns rather strange that Hippke would suggest you work with a man again with when you had a sevoro disagreorwnt, doesn't it, or. oxperi-Tonts which are also going to bo in a concentration comp whoro- in thoro is an alleged tolograa that you wore not allowed tlwro, that they wore secret and Himler rovld not let you in. It soens rather strange new that they would sort of associate you with this jan whom you have absolutely transferred from your organization and don't want any rr-re association with, doesn't it? A That may bo strange if I had later again worked with him, but from the fact that cy name ms dropped, and from the fact that throughout ti« entire later correspondence ny name no longer appeared. 7237 3 : _-.y-^-!E-ll-5^Ioxeic (Int. Ra&lcr) Court No. I. it cm be Ken that this first^suglostion by Kippke could not be erec¬ ts for acc» reason or other, and I would as|UDo that tte reason was .-.at at that tino I no longer worked with Raschor, that I at that tire V. Tiruady quarreled with hin. I assume that teacher said to Kippke, ^ # ■You arrested Welt*, but to is not tho nan with whom I would like to collaborate." I don't really know tto detail of that disoussion, but tho very circumstance that I was aug'ostod and that this suggestion was not perfected afterwards scans to the contrary to prove that tbora =ust have boon certain reasons not to carry out this plan of collabora¬ tion between R-scher and holt*, and I nuot assure that this is because of tho quarrel that I had had with Raschor bof ore hand. That Hippko was not inferred or. tto 20th of Itey 19U2 about ry quarrel with Raschor reuld not bo very surprising booauso fren tho point of view of tho icdicol Insp«ctor'.to such quarrels did not constitute any groat ovont. I testified hore that I didn't report that natter to Hippko but re¬ ported it to Anthony. Therefore it is quito posciblc that oithur Anthony did not infors Hippko about this natter in sufficient detail or it nay "Iso bo that Hippko had forgotten tho affair in tho rennttao. Proa Hippko«s point of view tho rattor did not boar very nuch irport- anco. I again refer to tho tologr.ua. toy I explain why I nosumo from tho files that this tolcgraa was subnitted to no after tho 19th of February? Q Just a noewnt, Doctor. Ko tovo explained this sufficient¬ ly well enough, I think, and I want to give you another docunont to help you along so that you can explain it. Your nnmo hasn't appeared in any other of those documents, you any, at this later drto. How, wo are going to look at Docurent HO-1359, first offering it for identifi¬ cation as Prosecution's Exhibit h?3, your Honors. Kindly read that document aloud. Doctor. 7233 -k-iS-l- --JD-Kr 1. y- 3 r ovr.. It Is "^TTrce, slen.d "Slavers, S3 Obersturib-.nn- feenr-r. °SS- .nter stureifuohrer Stpbsnrzt Jr. Raacttcr reported ..i -•--r.lcb -n 25 April 1942 bout ttta result of the c nf - -r.cc with Oborstobaerzt Jr. ‘..’eltz. ‘-.'eltz requested, : t Jr. Rraoner be withdrawn in ttta o ee t.irt ... wo ell ..-•6 be Invited to -ttend too exearinent until Fridry, 1st 1242. The Heichsfuehror S3 \:re lr.foracd frccurdinily. re orderci S3 Od^r^r evsonfuettrer uol/f on 30 April 1C42 c. s nd r t-let;-oo to Fl-ld-H'rettal Allen requesting Jr. Rrsetter 1 e detail to the G-re-'n djocriaentrl Institute ' r «virtlon, Jrci'u erenoh, rnd that •’t the dl6noenl of r.-iott fuottrer-SS. * This '* ~0‘ ra in your Jooua. nt 2 04, doted 28 April, *n. t ie d- ca.ee nt hero or ted .iry 3, refers to c..e d"to of 2C A~rll, "lou refers t, ttt- f ct the v; rooue t.-l tttnt . 1 -setter o- withdrawn i the event no w.uld nut .. ve you tcend l.u .?: arimenta bofor- t..o ot. of ivy, r.u then it la v.rv llKely tnla tele^rro you r.ferre- to re :leo • nt; n b at Ifst of April, isn't it* a. ..i, a w t._ ontl - tt.r lootts a^aowift different If I - hv. t..ie file not. of olev-ra in • .dltion to ay . c. _'»cui nts, I wo aid h-v. ttn vn tu-t th. noCeo of .c.\nltzlor vra con-cct, -n- th t croro aust ee ~ncttter -.feasibility t ox'.Is in ara. iilnl Rrecner's letter. This le e r, n c.ie ttter n«nd, c* nr. t oe explained now. I o :: n y try to rec ns tract in tt-tes fr<-in the, i.o.un-nts • 1 c. *• e-e V’il'bl- tterd, sine- I no lon 6 -r xn w t.icia d e' , r. , 1-te discuss the freezing experiments, et v; efter te.is letter of --Her. w.s ls-e-d w-.ereln . u _c_ :-u--esC_d with dasetter t c nuUct the f reezing -xperi- . .r.ttP rr._ ..ilch mie_csto_ r.u were t —■’* C- urt 1 H-y S—K-12—2-HJ-br 1. y-3r wr.. the freezing experiments, did y^- b;c me aware of the ;rct that Rllch had ar-o erran^monts In this arnncr and -d 60 it,C£t-d t^-'t sec.'. r.r-an a cmont8 be m?_o that you h.-ndlo the v.xe«;utl ; n of the* freezing experiments? n. I .irvo already testified noro thet I nev-r learned r.f tnis letter of Milch, d"tod 2C Hoy 1242. Th.sc thlp«fl v>ro happenin 0 lr, Berlin end I never f^und out that I was to be Involved, *n order never reached no and I was never caIced vhat my ttltubo was. %. '/ell, th. fr^ezlne experiments v.ore of c. nsluornble interest to- y» u, weren't they? a. Certainly, ve had also worked in the fi-ld of c« Id, and lready anld her^ th* t I repe^t-dly .*. naked for Rolzlochnor's renyrt, beoauev I wre interested In wii't was fcolng :n. %. ’ell, now, ••ore you c nducti n our »nla*l e* arlmunts th-t are re'jrtod In * -jr document book on w-lch y e r.^ rt-d eo r. :t the Number, o nferenco in Oot-uer; did ”jU c nduct -.or onlmrl crrerlmonta rt the '’cmo time R^.sober r.d AolslOvbner ana Fin/.e wore c.nduct- ln^ c. elr experiments on human beings t Drohr.u, or *v>A y u c rnpleted y.ur w *rk 6 time bef.re or 'fter; can y -lercw e*y just vr. t tim.- you were conducting, your ar.la -1 ex oriaents rs .p :*-8wd to the human experiments f ft-> sober, .vlzloohn.r rnd Fink..? a. ’»a oert-lnly c rrl.d out t..e nlaal experiments slmelt*ne.usly, tn?t w s d.;rln 0 the tlo. th. cxoclmonta 1 series hvizloo.in„r, Finite and R sc.i.r wre runr.ln* rt Dach-'U, we worked on tno animal experiments at -ur Institute .n vnich I re-p.rtj*. <-t Number^,. I think that Is the wey : ve -lw ;s described It. I sa»,; -:eil now, wh.n you worked or. animal c.-rt 1 - y 5-14-12—5-HD-.4 1. y-3r >vr.. experiments, were you working on 1 r~er animals t all or ?.l?rys si~ll nniscls; I thought A understood you tv say . wore working on nigs, larger animals. Is that true? «. No, I dldn'-t say that. Je started to work vn smaller anim~ls an- at fir3t started tv v-rk on the basio problems ualn G 6 e-» 11 anicrls. Once nrving established a certain b sis wc w-nt ov-r to largo animals which wore m-ro -roensive. o st»rted with rrts f*nd guinea ol^a nd wont over to r bblts end c?t6, and nt last wo worked -n olgs. %. '.’n't typo of ^qulpm^nt WvUld y.u use In freezing experiments with small animals? Would there bo a difference between the equipment used for small animals or large an lar is? i*. Certainly, for th- lar.-. 'nlo ls I need a big cage int which It cvuld be run, whero in the case of tho sm-11 anlna .1 I ^nly need a very sa il 0 l.-ss ovntalnor. Vkrt elsl I n.vd for ay vquioaent v.oponds upon what I am v rklng. i. -.ton did y.u e.r.d the oqulncer.t th^t you had used f r ur oxperlraents with the l*rga animals to Dacna.u? . That ws never the erso. i. Vha t h*'o-ened to the equipment? a. You are eoenfcl g of equipment for 1 rge animals? k. Ye3. A. This equipment fvr i-r 0 u animals consists of two c _es -.f ovale cross-section. Two tubs? a. Yes, two tubs. «nd wh't lioocr.ed to th sc, vht -lid you do with tho.e; did • u tiv\>w them away -r n v them burned «.r •were they b mbvd, jc what hrpooned t.. them? C v.rt I 12 --=-•“*D-.v-loy-5rown. These two 1 r b e tabs were et the dstcte Hirachau, and if nobody took them sway fra still there. i. Is that where hr.jor Alexander visited you at the end of th- ver In I believe, 1945? «. Yea thrt Is the plrce. Dr. Alexander v's enable to find the larfae tubs, v-ar.’t he? «. '.'ell, If Professor Alexander hed told us that he v a Interested in scein. two lrr^e tabs I would hvo beer. _l'd c, la“d .'.Is Into the plasty wnor c these tw. tuba were 'nd shown them to him. ‘Jfcot did . . d.. with the tharooaetera c.nd e-i lament y. u used - n the lsr 3 c nnlm«ls; wee tr.-t still rv-liable? a. Cert-Inly, tr.ey were not removed, certainly not u:on y order. <‘e mostly aensured ch- temperature by electricity, wo also used thermometers, osneclrlly f'jr S3'3arlnc the temperature of the w tor. as for as I know n.t in c w'8 ev.r r moved from thjre. «t pny rate I n^v^r a ve noraiaslon to do that. I think I s«id to Professor Alex'.nder z:.-t I vr c uely r-acsbwred that Wendt hed re^rtod C ue th-t Ainlch, r.,t Hlrechau, hed ordered O'..net..ino “ be removed ‘' -lie I v. e absent, -»nd somebody wanted to t'kc 3 aethlne to Drohciu. 'lien I returned 2 hoard ebjut e rt rr.d I brohlb&od any such practice. Wendt does not .oes to remember th-t, so that I cjz nr. t qalto sure r.b ut ic. I -s sure thrt wo refused t. lend the oolorlatfor. i. Then according t^ .‘endt, .no of you witnesses, 3. so -f your equios-nt v-s sent t. Dachau? , ,n the contrary .’endt s~ys that nothin! was sent t*. Dcc-'U, : . t nothin, was ever ..cnanhed. On the e^nbcr_d vaguely tn. t I once returned fr-.m - cner .irnd re c.tft : j~-- ~ -&-I2~5-HD-iialoy-3r own 4 r vr cation nd d'endt had told so mac eomat..an a w e deuianded. fl ; my Me I know for certain t.i c - told .«‘endt tact nior r.. circumstances 8 no aid pr.yt/--n e bo furnished to Dacn»u and I certainly reaeaber t..ls ".ffelr wit/, the C-lorlscter. S-thlng v ae over ..Ivon awry. '•hat I aa ary In- now refers to Munich, but I ra quite sure that t'/.ln 0 w 9 sent t-> Jochru fr.-a Hlrsofaau. There was no 0 inaction between Dacha a pr.d Hlrscnau. I don't think t/-'i anyone w- aid h vc t/.. u a ht of 3-r.dino anyone to 72:3 8 (Bro~n) Court So* 1 Hirschau fron Dachau. I can 3ey Tor certainly not only I aor.lt !t.ot: of any such thing happening, but I c= quite suro it didn't. As far as Ainich I car. say that nothing --as roaoved without qy approval. I aa quite sure the o^-gen voters '.rere rofused and that the Colornetor *.fao also refused. Tihether in :y ebsojioo anything was furnished without re¬ orders I cannot say# IT.. HARDYt Hay it ploasc the Tribunal, if the Tribunal will boar with ix I can conplotc ^ axardnatior. in about 5 ninutos, and -.hereby complete it before tho noon rccoss. T.l T&smxai Vory Troll. Q Doctor, Tore yen of tho opinion it rao nocossary to conduct freezing oxjxriaronta upon hunan bolhga? A I don't knot: tho extont of Uolxloohaor's froozing erper! onto, tlvct rosultc can bo achieved by US in- hunan beings that cannot l>o ac¬ hieved by using aninala was quit, clear to no. That is a snWor of course. a Q Thon you wore not corqrlctelc' opposed to conducting froozing experi¬ ments upon Itunan beingsT A Cortainly not. I approved of tho high altitude ox avto nto vldch Ruff ras carrying on and if froozin, ox;orients had boon used un’.or tho sain eloer conditions it would haw boon vory -llo. leal if I v uld liavo any moral misgivings. Thoso natters always depond upon tie oxooution. However, I rrust say that in thu aao- of frees ng oxptrfciunto I ml set up a .such stroagor measure, boc:.v ;c they arc connected with a rent many :»ro inccnvonioncos to tho exp risontal cvbjwct. These inoonvonionebu can bo Cuju-tod by asthotics. O Than it is your opinion, as: staled on pego 36 of your JocUliont Dook, that is the sooond pa o 36 ; thru raw tyo pages 36, You- Honor. This is hbltz Document So. 5 . Xou stated in your report which •*» report before the October conference in burrtberg, as follors: "I-uiy people rill certainly bo reluctant to apply the -.bovo abrupt nothods of warring to hunan beings without further consideration, since tho former vie- lias always been that lids kind of troata-nt oust load 6 IJay-Ci-D JG-12-2 a-Uzlcy (Bream) Court Ho, 1 to .lost severe collapse. ~e havo, as stated above, never obsorvod such a co 11 apeo rith cur animals. At the beginning of the hot both ttc even found a quick increase of the nu;clc tonus which according to Y. iondcr- cor., should counteract any tendency to collapse. One car., Iiov.wor, raiso tbo objection that the whole orocoss of regulating temperature by Tray of the skin is sc diffcror.t in the cases cf humans and furred cninals that ere cannot draw any binding conclusions. This objection is certainly •.forth attention ami cannot b- refuted by animal experiments. 11 Then it i3 your opinion, as stated here, that ex -jriixnts upon human be in-3 are just¬ ified for freezing? A Hay I ask you tc go on roedi i •ill find ny point of view, cni I cher that as this consideration, namely that t;»ro aro dji Curdncco botucon human beings and ani.als which our. be circumvented by cenoidering electrical rc-caraing and that no objection can bo nado In tho cnoo of cloctrical rowarsdng. If you go on reading you will coo that one of tho two forra of rcr/andne woyld havu to be applied in the caao of human boinyo. Q That is truo. How on pace 37 of this soao document, it sto.toa: » 0 no noro crporionce rith short tmvo warning coons to uo important. Following; a suggestion nado by Profoscor Holzlochiior, wo v/arrwd the aninaln by way cf comparison with snail olco -rodcs on the neck and head only in the region of the vital centres." '".or. did you got this suggest! n from iiclslochnor? A Tills su. - ..stion was nado to ae by Holzloehnor during tho Cortfor- cnco which I nontionod, which took pl-.co in Paris in tho raaaor of 19lil. naturally, wo discussed cur cctusl probloso ro-.ardiiv. thy.cause of loath by cold, Holzlochner at that timo in prrls in tho aumor f 19U was ol' tho opinion that the coding of tho vital cantors cf tho medulla oblongata was to. cause of death. During tho Dachau experiments Holzlochner changed this opinion ami looking at tho Hurnborg ropert of Hdzloohnor you -.rill f?md that it is his opinion that the cold death of a hunan being is caused 72 h$ 6 I^3*4WMG-I2-3a--yaloy (Brown) Court Ho• 1 by a defect in the heart. Free: this change of opinion it is clearly evident that what I was investigating hero ar*d was at that tino Holz- lochner*s opinion, was an old opinion of his ami not the opinion which he hold later as a result of Ids experiments. Q Thon did you first learn of tho freozing experiments on human toings at Dachau? A I already said that when theso people cane to us and asked us to carry out oxygon examinations in tho blood. Q Tfhat date was that approximately? A That oust havo been in tho suivcr of 19li2, tr»e or throe aonths boforo tho Hurnborg conforcnco. Q Did they ovor ask you or sond to you bodies to bo sont on to Dr. Siixior for autopeics? A Ho, Q And thon the next tino you heard about the oxporiuonts at Dachau was at tho conforonco in Octobor, is that right? A Yos. Q Did you perform thoso 'elood tests or thoso oxygon blood tents an roo.ucntod? A ’to. .orz roviewod that and ho reported it to no later. I didn't carry that out, but Tfor z did. I naan basically it was Tforz' task to carry out oxygon tests and not rdno. Q TTho was "ora? A Tfor* was ry oldest assistant. I tela you that, ill. HAR2Ti Ho furthor questions, your Honor. THEi iTlZSIDEHT: Tho Tribunal idll bo recess until 1*30. (Thorcupm the noon rcco3s was takon.) / 1¥7 o- tcr-f^rosn) Court I aTJiXA crSbl .. (Th- hearing rcconven-d at 1330 hour-, 8 -ay 19L7.) THc. The Tribun :1 is again in session. DR. GLOfeG uLLTe - Resuo-d. r.il Has Counsel lor d-.f-ns. any forth..r examination of th- witn-ss? RLDI SCI XZUk':iGS. 1 >.ILL'. (Counsel for the Defendant lta): h Dr. .Teltz, I return to ah. ..u-stion first of all that w..ro dis- cus.'’.: yesterday, n....l y, the- qu. atlohs U.it t.:. prosecutor directed to you curing th ecurs. of ; >st .rday.'s session, tad I ask you, first of ill, to anrw.r th- foilowln question: ifould it not hay- be-en possi¬ ble fo confirm th. xp.rinor.t:;! 3eri-3 that were discussed by Ruff ar.d herb rr in A 1 .rsho*, outside, of concentration c-rps? The prosecutor feels that e.xperis> ntln; in coneentrati* n coops could hav- be n avoided, few, *iv_ :t. a cl a: answer and t -11 ce, would you have received the n - * srary limber of -X? rle.ntrl subjects, namely, 15, iron th- Luftwaffe? a It .v.r difficult to find that nu=b r of volunt- rs lor such a 1 n. th of tin, for th r-asona Ruff h:s lr dy at forth. Pbopli ^re rot released from their officials duties so that •<«. could h-v- th-n .v.i- 1 L . So f r a tr.e, i:-r- .oploytcs of th. Institute, th-y J. d to conti- r.u. do.n* t. ir daily work so that lor this r.ason they were not really ivaliable, t 1 .3 1 pr cticJly ac-. :«ow, I *as ask.d whether enough volunteers would h v volunt red. Incr-. acre lwiys plenty of Luftwaffe volunteers for hivfc ltitud- xp -rin-nts, so fir as it depended on the ■ ill of th- volunteers. If-, ’-skwdrquadron, "who of you wishes to jeu:it.. " ji .-ltitud exo_rin nts? , nd if had b-.n able to “ill K > r !■ v d of your other duties lor the d eorir. . i;.. 4r,*\ -xp.rlc.nts r c riled out, th n, of course .bout v rj- or., irj ch t cquadron would .. v. apoli d, b.cuis 'or ^-'s^epeopl r.i h A'-Mwoe ucpric-nts w-r . soo-thing hat t.h.y ,-r. that i.-. involved r.o p in or unpL isant&css, J * Ui -^- 721*7 : ,ay-*e-GJ-13“2—i C3t-r-(Boro)- Coart 1 -bd tflc conditions brought -bout by those -xp.rix_r.tc wore conditions i tfc.y Ir.ndy knew. That w_ could aot proceed in this wry was dctcr- int by '.uitc other factors, ana-ly th- fact that during the war ov.ry- hie -ore work to do then h. coule do, that the inuividut.1 of ices - --9-frt ib -■ v-ry important that tneir employ.should not lo3e a sin- |1 hour fron their regular work. And w. hid the ana- sort of troubles r.ith students. If r_ .ask.d *.-hnt stud-nt wanted to volunteer, then a lot cf ttudents would have been re.ndy to, but if ir> proceeded to th- pructi- c-1 nngl. ins 8aid:"Tooorroo I wmt you her. for n .rhol. day," then th. difficulties arose, b.caus. all thes- students nad other obligations. This tic. was not a t their disposal. Th-y, of th.ms.lveS, would have liked to volunt. -r nd this app.rvntly th- difference, if on. says that cn th. one hand, then. Were plenty of peopl. in th- Luftwaffe who wanted •o olunte nd, or. th- oth r hind, it turned out to bo'impossible, in tin pr ctioal field, to get then. •* ]:or > let us assure -hta you had received the people iron the Luft- nff.. Could teacher have be.n rtatrained free carrying out his 0TW1 lX* periBents in Cachau? A Cert: inly not, because at th- neoent h.n on the 15th of kiy 19L1 ! cchtr asked Fir.tier whether he could pernit such experiments, and fros •' =°»-nt on Then Jiialr p-raitt.d the.a- -xp riser.ts, Raschur had the -ty s 5 -nan towards hisalcr to oak. use of this p. mission th t Hiar.- l>r had recorded nin. r.aacfccr l -.y? occupied i dual position. On the. Che hand h- was a S'-bsorzt o.‘ tix Luftwaffe, and in tills capacity stood ir. i clearly tl. line* ailit-r. subordination and co..aiasion, r>d on th. other hnd, R aci.er rrx a n-ater ox tr.e ^.neral-SS, nd in this capacity . -ras subordinate to laaLr, nd onl, in this capacity did he turn nt tc i{ta -' - r In ora_r o r-ceivv permission to c xry out thes* ? 21;3 xperiB.ntc 3 Hay L7-T.-Z -L.-l-Cook ( Prawn) Court No. i Tv. us it ors quite clear that at tee sxaent when Hior-ler give r.lr?i:r f r tte experiment s Raseher certainly did take advantage i that permission. . :.o.. a not her question relating to vnur examination of yest rday. * - e Prosecutor among other charges accused you of being guilty of the fact that Ruff and Eo.-.bcrg who carried o-jt the experiments and r.re ir. tie docl: today and you answersd this question in tho affir- ive. I assume t! or of ore tSv.t this is an ad at solan of guilt for your person in f.c Judicial or ever. Aral sense, or a a I -rong in that. ..ill you -lease explain «Our oos'.tion again. n. 1 can my to th-.t that If Raschor had not boor, assigned to ry office gainst ny will er.d without ay intent tit t then X wouldn't be in tho deck here aitler. In the Inst analysis tho whole indictaent tea -,r.o about b or luce Kseebor, contrary to our profroa, without our knowledge, di< thi-va th t arc clorgou in the ir.dictaont hero. Neither I , ncr .It. -itt nor Rocberg ate in any -ay roeoor.aiblu for that. Q. Kan I a vo a few questions regarding thie loming's cross e;jia- Liition. This trains the Prosecutor suddonly showed you a row document !r. order to orovo thr.t Hr odor did not lorve or. the 20th of February because of the einnUr telegran but left only lator. how I ask you first of >11 on t.'O basis of rf-.at date did you dotcrninc tho time for tho individual ccurrcncca, >a-ticuLarly the tlao when Raschor loft your cffico? of course, .stay 1 do no longer have in mint the datos for " oecurronctr tl »t hqjpered five .,a?ara ago. I did try or. tho basis of tfco docuannt* here in evidence to r co.iS.ruct tho clronolo y of tho •jtUz >.nd I i. vc I ifdd v ry ciculy in ay direct oxaainati r.%ist I came to £ 1 - on tho datos t. t 1 aid’fix on. It was oy point of ;• rturo ti t *• a datos arc /tost certainly incoaoatible. Ir. the ooou- -_n*. NO-3IS - r. s th-t Rrsch r or. t.-.o 16 of *trch 1912 a t '.Iroary boon .:•! gr.cd t- t . Dachau fie ic station oi ..ir Ho soar ch Institute, and in . Sc.-iitzlur file note, which is docuse.it 2bU, 8 ifoy -.7-A-J..-L. -2-Cook-(3rc*n) C art Ko. 1 it says: R-sci.r's noaigrctent to -actnu raust bo ismodi-toly clunged - en -a isi sncont to Air Rcaa&rch Institute Berlin-Adlcrshof, Dachau - ■ -*- Station. In -rentlxiOia: In ..&itz' institute, since as Wonts Lis us hi hevo the .assignment cancelled imediately unless ... takes . ..rt. Hon one of these dccuncr.ts has to be erroneous, that is to soy, it oust be wreng because Pr;.u Sc sober cannot on the 2Sth of « ril ask for an aasiga-vnt sco-wh.ro, which recording to tbo • other docu air Lvon to Rasohtr a nonth earlier. Thio w a ajr joint of Jvjr.rtuTe cod I thought I could by assaying th"t tho Schnitzlor file not-, newly N0.264, baa a false dr to on it, and that the da to should not be the 2Sth of « ril but tho 28th of Feb¬ ruary of 19Al. ;bt. fc-rough tho submission of the new docunont, MO. 1359, th* file :oto of Si-v.rs, au-i-.s to neks It clear to ao that tho Gchnitzler fit- ;.otc r.- Uy dots be'r tho correct date, newly the 28 of -oril 1942. 1 rust therefore conf-oo that I cannot clarify this contradiction. Harv.fare, t'.-re really is th» contradiction in tho two documents JO. 264 and KO. 318. Fra the rate rial I havo available ;.--rv I cannot ol.'-r u.a this contradiction. Purely objectively 8?oak- ing thia fait do. s nothing to c l.ir.Qu what I have said kora cxcont as to ay c x.jocturo r arming ti.<« dates which I now dthdr ». p-rticul- rly It changes at* i;:,- in .?y atatcaunt that nothing of th. Dachau -rjaxi.ts . ^ ro ort-d to v. On tho contrary, Siovers Document 0. 1359 co-. rol 'rated anew that I sked Reach-r to re- ort to no and I ,>1. cud before ;j. . the ait zT.ative ol oitherre alining in ny institute an? royortiitg to a. or leaving. It car. cieo be seen froru tha Siwv.rs docuaur.t that th.ro w-a r.o r.*:rt to c>r. the Dachau • xvrir-.ntz an t. t just .-.aa rt son f.r ay ju'rr-ls with Rancher. •*. I have or.- 1 st u- ition t. Glorify t -la contradiction. Mow n.aicb a: r.v. i si^es t is cor.tr Licti r. do you think is the core l ikwly? e have the letter tra: ...Iff or. tlx 10 Jarch u!-J.ch is r rt of fficial Occur-rt, whereas Rase -r*s r-yuftior. for veracity a*t-r .1 I heard -about hia w_s not very cr-at, now w; Jch do you think 7250 y i.7-*»-Sh— Ur-3-^ ^J:-(3r:jfa) Court .*Io. i is C 3T03t? . -ir.ct cutor rw&ordir.- the chain of co •.•and in your institute you redd tr. f->11 a.ii.i : 2c jaaolcally and disci;'Ur.rily I ro subordinate to the Luft nu in L'unich but in scientific respects to tho medical ir.r- octcr* to. yp # :;rdy whereupon asked you whether that was ..nthony'o :ffico -rvdyou said "yes", and fraa tils it could be roducod that yz u recoivid r orders r*' dirocti-.xj. in research nutters or in all scientific natters fraa «nt!.:ny«s office, that is to say, tho office for Luftwaffe ,->.dj.cine, for aviation nv.dicine in tho nodical vetorsto r cy th*. ten L-i charge of those natters. Is that Kh-.t ' ,*x u t nt t)s professor, or how can you explain thi3 rear rlc? ... It ir r * sard: o.--ly ir the scientific ros'ect I 1. a aubox^- ’.'in: to t: tr». -'leal insaectvx-ate, d t e x-iinal Inspectorate tv.?o r >rcsont-d £ r »- eit.vr by the ...r -ctor .in so If by the (ftriof of Staffj the technical ex a-t .il not yivo any rderc. That went on through the Ls -ct.r or tax J' ic-f of St-ff. I simply . anted to sny that r.th r.y a as ‘he dop rt-o.at ex- rt :t th- sax ffice i the modicnl • it rate .r c rich I also received ray srtUrr fr.n it's erf f. 7251 C ::--7 47-..-S..-r.-w: -ok (3 tj n) c art K . I . In the cros3 acr ir.atin you aIso said that in the Luftg&us t: • r- c jr suiting .'hysiciens. Untir fcht t m "con3ultin;; hysic- ns" ujo or.'orsteals that you rlao low* th- doctors who advised ..e wr *.3 c nandants, that is the. ..ir Fleet •hysici'ns, jr tho leal cl.t-fs tlv-i*. Ives. Now, Professor, do you aeon by th~t that ,;^re ’*-r- consulting -hysicians in that technical sense to the ,uft 'us ^r tho ir institutes. Did you say that iraa your torconal It.-hL. l,e .r i.■ 3 whrt you said yoeter'ay oiayly a conjecture? n, ..hethvr the Luftgnu had advisors that 1 do n^t kna;, ..o uoro concenv-d then nith Professor -inrer and I :>nly -nt that tho technical ox -rte ir. t;*j various fields wore also the advisors to tho Luftgftus. whether they hold title of consulting’ ihyaici“ns I do not knew. Pr Xe» or Sir- .r, with whoa wc wore th-n concerned, was, 1 be.lievo, called "Luftjau Pathologist'" Jr somethin’ of the sort. His fficial title );/ :iothing about an advisor in it. But rognrding thoso .natters I fcavo only vrtial knowledge because I had not v-ry vach to do nith t t. 72>'2 c rt I lay .1 - 15-1 - ' 3 -aria _r (®r pa) 3* Saw cncth -r ucsti it rofera t tils I ftgnu path St, Dr. Sir. r. Tao prcsocut.r s * at.rday :n cr ss-^xaain-ti n that . t.- •' ca oats it could be saca th .t Dr. Singer r-fused t c.llnb- :• •• ■- '.-1..r arc -a!- i r ethical rt sene. 1 .vve a.*: clock-c. ti-j- o ,h tr.® drcu«xint3 and 1 era*, find n such d-cuxjnt. oinco j u vcj.j int ..t v. ted y J stox'dny sb* —.t this 6 curort, I want to osic you U'-V.or j r tax.* ;hdt the reference km. - . a D?: jy it j-30 S': "*- Hon rs, t e last question of defenso counsel, I don't lo th t A r... v.rt . ; r- . fro • .•:-* 1 I he locus tnt, h>r.tuncu fr*-a ■- ph : n At the o t-br.. Jc -(Brown) Court No* 1 HA. H..ADY: (sota^ines certificate) The document Is in order, Your Honor. THi PRESIDENT: “ho document which Is W 0 ltt Document li 0 . * la reooived before the Tribunal to be considered. To save confusion, this doounont has boon nnrfcod as -x hi bit 7. The Tribunal will take Judicial notloo of It without its bolnjjosrkad an exhibit, but It la boforo us In this case as Exhibit 7. Does that dose Counsel's case? DA. VILL£: Yes, that concludes my presentation. 5 hay 47--FjC-l?->0oll^xor (Int., Brown) Court I P2B5ID2UT: 2ic Tribunal now calls the coso against the dofei>- d-Jt Brack. 25. 7SG£5Q£.a^h: Hr. Preside-t at tho beginning of the submission of the evidence in the case cf Brack, I shell permit myself to submit to you a short presentation, in ordor to illustrate tho point of view freti which I Shall subuit cor evidence. It is or intention in ordor to refute Counts 2 and 3 of tho iadictuent, to call at once tho witnesses Hodcrich aai Pfaanuuellor, and, then in order to rofuto all counts of the indietuoat, I should like poruission of tho Tribunal to call tho defendant Brook hie self .is a witness to tho wit.'.oss stand. During this submission of ovidonco I snail subuit tho relevant documents. Tho submission of tho ovldcnco by tho defendant Brack hiusolf will includo: First, a short description of his lifo up to his entry into political lifo; Soccndly, to Count L, consoiraoy; thirdly; his -ttitudo towards the Jews, in tho preparation for tho cxtoroinatlon of whou ho is olloged to huvo participated throutfi his proposals for sterilisation in connection with his attitudo towards lc.tional i»oci_lisu; fourthly, his ueuborship in tho SS, with which ho is charged undor Count 4 of tho indietmont; fifthly, to a gonoral survey of Brack*s activity in the Chancellory of tho Fuehror, con¬ sidering especially him attitudo towards tho quostion of proventivo custody inmates, which represented a large part of his notivity. I shall, furthermore, dca with sixthly, tho storiliration proposals, r4 aftorvards tho connection of 3ruck with tho oxtoruinction plans of Hlm.--.lor, which Was doalt with by tho Prosecution on tho Form 14-F-13, which was called genoeido by the Prosecution. *hon, sovonthly, Z shall deal with his participation in the outhonasia prafiren, and his attitude towards the euthanasia program. I ask tho permission of tho Hi eh Tribunal to sutait tho evidence according to this plan. 7261 3 hay 47--7jG-17-2-Gall-ghor (int, Jr own) Court I IhS P=iSID2.'J: How counsel n^y proceed, using his evidonco accord¬ ing to the plan ho has outlined. DR. 720&SCHIUHV: Thank Tou. nS. ¥111 you kindly supply no with tho spoiling of the anno of tho first witness, please. B2. VBOZSGatsSHt Hr. President, with tho approval of tho High Tribunal, I ask that the witness Eodcrich be called to tho witness stand. ZdZ PR26XDSR: Tho k u rshal will sunnon the witness hodorich. iC*?i HiDEdICH, a witnosa, took tho stand and tostifiod no follows: JUDGE SI3RIEG: *x.o witness will miso his ri.-£t hand end ropeat this oath of tor :iOi I swear by God, the almighty and Onnisciont, th..t I will spook tho puro truth and will withhold and add nothing. (The witnoos repoatod tho oath) JUDGE S2BRIKG: You auy bo sontod. 3T DR. TROZSCauHHx ^ Vitnoss, givo uo your porsonal data. a Hy naio is lari Eoinz Hoderich. Born on 29 Octobor 1902 in Vucsiodel, upper Franconia, as a son of a Socondary School Profoosor Hodorich thoro. Q Would you plooso doscribo your gonoral caroor to tho TribunaLt- A I attondod the olamontury school at Vunsiodol. I thon ontorod tho socondury school for u aaubor of years. Then for oovcral years I followed a proctlccl profession in industry, and also worked in various building installations. In tho year 1923 I wont to Munich as a student, whero 1 studied at the University. In 1925 I was grudi>- ctod at tfurnoorg at the Obcrrealschulo. I thon wont to i.unich as a student to the Technischc Eochschulo and tho University, and frou thore I went to technical hi,h school at Doatig. Ir. tho year of 1931 1 node iy examination as a Diplcca amgineor. In the year 1932, to get 7202 8 May 47-*-?Jo- 17 - 3 -Gall a^er (3rowr.) Court Ho. I acquaint ad .ltd th. hl.hor .tut. cdnlnl.tr.tion, I «. arployod - 1 th the Eelch Hallway Directorate at Hurnbers. q Witness, would you please speak a little slowor. A Yes. q Will you proceed! A Tho alii of ny education wae c university career. q. But you later bocauo involved in politics. Vhat vne your political caroerl * I joined the USD-? on 29 October for the firot tiuo. -fter the north on the poldhorrnhullo, la which I participated, I loft tho HSDaT. in Doc tub or of 1932 X Joined tho SSDrf for tho ..cond tlno. In tho year of 1933 X -a. a no.her of tho loadOMhip of tho demon Student Lootfio. In tho your of 1934 I -ent to Roleh.ldtor Bouhlpr. d won. before you got to the nolch.loltor Douhlor, ho- did you bococo acquainted with tale! A O. tho ro.ult of a nunbor of contro-oralo., I loft tho loodor- .hlp of tho Oomon Student League, but In aprll 1934 Bouhlor nohod no to attend a conference In Berlin, and at tho no. tlno node tho unroot- ion to uc to enter into his sphoro of activity. d -hat -ore you to do thoroJ -hat -a. your took to bo thoroJ . at that tlno ho -a. tho Pro.ldont of tho Party Cam.lo.lon for tho Protection of national Soclall.tlo Literature, and ho -anted .one collaborator, on that taok. I had boon roccuumdod to hit. by acquaint¬ ance. of hi.. I only knew bin .lightly, a. a rcult of ny oon-or.atlon - 1 th bln, and after having told hlu about ny via.., and rftor ho had told hln hi. attitude, and hi. opinion.. I decided to accept hi. offer. On tho 1 Hoy 1934 I then enter*! hi. offlco in tanlch. d Witness, would you quit, briefly do.crlbo to tho 'tribunal the work of thl. emulation that you arc .peaking of. bocautO It -ill bo of souo importance - 1 th regard to -hat you -111 later to.tlfy toT » D,. task of thl. literature Cmnl.slon -a. tho clorn.ing of politico! literature frm tho phontnona that appeared at that tlno. During every politick revolution, during every political reorganisation, 8 W-A-7jo-l7-4-Gcll3^:ar (3rown) Court I cs it happened in the year 1933, thoao in power wore followed by c flood of Kariatic literature, and atepa had to be taken to conbat thia. One could today uae the technical expreeaion "hyper denazi¬ fication." Thin taek vta deliberately entni8ted to Kr. 3ouhler, bocouae for thia taak, a toak of political hygiene ono noedod on agency which woa entirely independent of politlc-1 literaturo. Mr. Souhlor had certain qualification* that equipped hlii for thia tusk. Ny activity waa a political organlrational one, and I vna to croato tho nocevaary prorequiaitea for tho carrying out of that work. 3 Iiy-A-r 3-13-1-nayncs (Ir.t. ?-ttlL.t) Court Ho. I, Case Ho. 1. Q Uitness, what wore the positions that you hold in 3ouhlcr's office? A At first I was his business manager. Afterwards I develop¬ ed fx tho coaaission, which contained a number of persons, a new office which I headed. Under ay leadership it became a Reichshauptant a lit¬ tle later. *hon in the year 1937 I left tho Reich Ministry of Propa¬ ganda, 1*. Bouhior asked =c to cooperate somowhit closer with his entire work. 'Tithin tho sphere of the Fuehrer's Chancellery, the chief of which’ho was, ho created a cultural political department. Cl Joro you tho hoad of that department? A Yu9j this department was later enlarged and was then sub¬ ordinated to EJO. q At tire progreseod, did you noro or loss represent Touhlor entirely? A In tho course of all tho devuiopaonts, Bophlor offorod his representation to mo, and I was to be ti» chiof of staff. This intention, howovor, never a-turiolirud boe-uao of cort’in political duvolopoints. In tho yoar 19U0 Bouhlor had received tho order from Hitler to ru-organizo the oducatior.nl litorcturo. Tho praotioal ox- ocutior. of that work wns trarsforred to m, Q You Just used tho oxpression "chief of staff". In tho course of tho evidence, thin word "chief of staff" will play n certain rolo. Hill you please explain to tho Tribunal what at that time in Genanny was understood by "chiof-of staff"? A Under "chief of staff" oro understands tho position within an agoncy which has to coordinate the organizational r.ork of tho various departments within that agency. In tho Party structure,"one coi*d com- • pare tint position with a ministerial director in a ministry. It is a central post for administrative tasks. As for who is in charge political ratters, it is always tho head cf cv.ry individual depart¬ ment, but never the chief of staff. q nhat were the tasks of your offico within tin Chancellory 8 !',-y-A-l 3-13-2-Haynes (Int. Rf*lor) Court Ko. I, Case No. 1. of tho Fuehrer? A I had to co-ordinate the activities of Mr. Bouhlur, which were very diverse in nature; on the one hand the Chancellory of tr.o Fuehrer, on the other hand tho activities connected with literature. In addition to such co-ordination teste, there were individual tasks Khich referred to applications which were sent to Hitler, coninp from tta fiolds of science, high schools, publications, etc. I may, for in¬ stance, mention tha troataont of tho question of tha Frobenius Institute or, for instance, tho p^st Walter von 1 bio. sought tho protection of Hitler boenuso he felt hirsolf op roseud by Rosenborg. Ho rucoivod this protection. Q What ms his naso? A Walter 7on Vblo. Q Thank you. A I had to dual with a number of such quostioas within my department. Q Witness, did you work temporarily at thu Reich Ministry of Propaganda? A I pointod out a littlo earlier that in tho yoar of 1?37 I was working in tho Reich Jiinistry of Propaganda. q Would you ploaso bo vory brief? A Yes. Evun at the beginning of his activity in thJ field of literature, itr. Bouhlur had a great do-1 of difficulty with rog^rd to Dr. Goobbcls, and Ur. Rosonborg at tho Party publishing houoo. As a result of internal events, Dr. Ooobbuls decided in the yoar IV37 to employ a now staff in his liter-turo doprxtaont, and ho approachod Hr. Bouhlor regarding no in that natter. )*r. Bouhlur at tjftt tine was in¬ terested in arriving at sono fire decision with reference to tho diffi¬ culties c.s th-y prevailed with "x. Rosenborg. q And thjr. you again rcro eliminated fnn that department? A Yes. In the year 1938 I left this ninistry beer use of dif¬ ferences which I had with the linistcr■ 7266 8 Jloy-A-' 3-18-3-Hayna s (Infc. Raalor) Court No. I, Cose No. 1. Q Witness, free your description of your career and your activity so far, we can conclwio toot you repeatedly came into contact Tdth tho forcer Roichsleitor Eouhlor. You know that Reichslcitor Bouhlor was alono the responsible person to execute euthanasia, and I aa of the opinion that if Bouhler wero wtill living, Bouhler would bo aittins in tho dock and net Brack. That is ay opinion and not yours. I B-y Maim, however, that considering tho cloao relationship which is alleged to have existed between Brack and Souhler, this similarity in attitudes nay have cceac to light in Brack's activities, and for that reason, I should like to put a number of questions to you which dool with tho personality of Bouhler, in order for th> Tribunal to kne* what personality they are conoornod with in considering the outhonnsia program. )R, HARDY: May it ploaso Your Honor, I request that tho Du- fonso Counsel be requested to quostion this witness. Ho has a canploto sot of notes boforo hia. He is reading from tho notes, ord in addition tho question is a rosumo on tho part of Defense Counsel. Tho Tribunal should bo in to rooted in Iw-ring tho witness testify, not in a logoi argument hero .and a sot of noto3 up thoro. I think wo should put it or. a more legal piano than it is on rip.ht now, THE RESIDENT: Counsel, tho Tribunal will be erateful if you will lead this witnoss to testimony in connection with tho issues boforo tho Tritwrcl. DR. FFCESCKSttNN: I only doalt with that question in order to give thj Tribunal an opportunity to have a picture of the character of those two personalities which aro going to bo repoatodly nontionod. BY DR. PRCESCfflttMKi Q TTitness, could you give us some statement about the Fuehrer's Chancellery, about tho significarco of tho Fuehrer's Chan¬ cellery, and about the extent of your activity? Y.ould you please do that as briefly as possible? A Lot mo at first spo-k .about tho significance cf tho 7267 3 l'ry-A-: 3-lfWt-Hayncs (Ini. Hnjilor) Court Ko. I, Case f.’o. 1. Fuehrer's chancellery. Hr. Bouhlor w s tho business nnns;;or of tho IEDAF at first, and since in tho yoar 1933 this activity was trana- f. rrcd to !lr. Schwarz, he h_cax:o unonployod. When Hess assigned him to tho position of the arcsidoncy of this Cceznittoe for t Yc Protection f Lit-miuro, wo also find that Hitler had arrived at tl» decision to r.-orgnniso his personal affairs. Previously Hoss had had char go of then. Simultaneously with tho nppointoont of Hess as tho Fuehrer's de¬ puty, the situation had changed, and Hitior oxprossed tho wi3h to sop- rrato personal ratters fron P*rty loadorship. Within tho sphoro of Hess' activity. Hitler's personal natters wora dealt with by Albert Boraann. Hitior, however, did. not liko Albert Bom.ann, .and when !io was looking for * now person to take ovor tho personal mattors, ho thought of ir. 3ouhlor; raid that is how Bouhlor camo to Berlin at tho urid of 1931., in ord r to create a new offico to taka care of Hitler's personal affairs, with tho task — THT. :RESIDENT: Ccunsol, T und-rstaod that ycu dosirod thin . witness to give a briuf characterization ,f Bouhlor. If ho will pro¬ ceed to that subject and in a few words give a otatonicr.t on Bouhlor, tho Tribunal would bo glad to hoar it. 1 Witness, I r.sk you to bo rx briof as possible. What was your personal .attitude toward Bouhlcr? Did you onjoy his special con¬ fidence? Did you receive an insight into his pjrsonal lifo? A Thoi’u duVolcpod very soon a spocial dogroc “f confidonco between us. Ho gave no rather o.rtonsivo insight into his porsmal thinking. Ho asked rau to work closely with him, not only r.lthin our official work, but also personally. He often invited mo to join hie fasiily, end the relationship was filled with confidonco. .1 Did Bcuhlcr also draw y u into his confidonco with regard to his opinion of his associates? A i'os, Yr. Bouhler ften took the opportunity tc discv3s his associates with me. At ore tiiao :» asked e to’ 3ubnit d-ta an the qualifications uf his assoemt-s, -r.d for this reason I got in touch with a well-krcnn profession graphologist in Berlin. 7260 8 hay 47-a-?J0-19-l-^r-ingcr (Int., Hauler) Court I ^ Vnat was tko iaoressicn you gainod of Houhlor? * In connection with this question, I nay asauro you that I an perhaps the only person who is in a position to spook about doubler's personality, who is in a position to give scuo sort of cctrprchoa8ivo inf emotion about his inner attitude to life. For ton yours I huvo boon in close connection with bin and I au suro that there is no quostion concerning his lifo that I did not have to discuss with hla in dotail, because litor^turo oxtonds throughout ull shporos of lifo. bo startod freu this. I Bay say that ».r. Houblur was a quiot uon, a aun with porsonul roticouco, a nan of clean thinking, hio ucsital attitudo was gonerous, uot at ull do,;uatic. he v_s n uon tint is generally callod a oon of libera tninklng. Ac difforonccs, which resated freu different choructor pocaaritios of hi* ooad not bo uonc;od by hin oaflily. Ho did not h».ve sufficient courugo, ho Wasn't detominod oaough. Q bhoa douhlor exorcised bin activity a* tho hond of tno Chano- Uor 7 of tho Fuchror, did ho have any difficatlo*T boro diffioatioo c.iusod by othor porflonfl in dlfforont ugonciofl? a Bouhlcr' s work hod difficatio« in so fur us hio enuignuont was novor dourly liuitod and afl a rc«ult he inuodiatoly hod diffica- tiofl with the Rolch Choacollory, which in tho uoantiuc hud boon work¬ ing on a nuubor of tuflk« for Hitler. In addition u strong oontruveroy onfluod with tho «tuff of tho Fuehrer «• deputy situation, howovor, w u o uitigatod vhon Hess «ui tho chief of hitler's staff boc.v.co of Hooo's persona quulitiea. bhen, however, ut a later date, i.artln i.oru..nn took over the leadership of the party chancellory, tho ensuing flifferon- ccs of opinion could not be pruvontod. DP. FEOSSCHi.ai'V: hr. President, in this connection I ah (mid liko to subuit Doc uncut So. 14 free -y Document Hook, which io to be found on pages 36 to 38, as Exhibit So. 1. I shall have it .u-mdod to the Secretary Genera. Skis is an extract f rcxi tho Hutionnl-Sociaietic Ioar 3ook of 1942. 7269 8 h aj 47-2»-7jC-19-S-an;icgcr (Int., Hauler) Court I Jrcc this Tear Bock, I shall confine Byself to reading the two paragraphs which deal with this field of the Fuehrers chancollery and work of tho so-called party c h ancellory. I shall start rouding frca Document No. 14, this paragraph: ■ The Chancellery of the Fuehrer has to secure the ianediate contact of the Fuehrer with tho party in all questions subuittcd to the Fuehrer personally. Thoro aro hardly any sorrowc and troubles which arc not subuittcd to the Fuehrer in boundless confidonco in his holp. The dealing with pious for raaission or suspension of sentences has developed to a particularly extonsivo field of acti¬ vity." I shall now read a short pur-graoh regarding tho chancellory of tho party and I qucto; ■ as f rcxi 12 Kuy 1941 tho Fuohror has fully rcouiiod tho por- sonal loadorship of the party; the agency douling with the cS f-iro of tho lo^dor of the NSDiP is ncaod chancellory of the party; its rosponsiblo loader is Rolchsloitor Kurtin Borcuan. "all throads of tho party work convorgo in tho chancellory of tho party. Horo all internal plans and suggestions concerning tho party, as woll as all vital questions concorning tho oxistonco of tho Ooraan nation and lying within tho scopo of tho party, aro h*Dd- lod for tho Fuohror. Frcu here diroctivos aro givon for tho whole work of tho party oither by tho Fuohror hi.isolf or by hio ordor. In this way, tho unity, hoaogenocity and fighting powor of tho iiSDoP as boaror of tho National Socialist idoolo.y is #?icrantood. ■ ^ Witnoss, I shall now continuo with your oxauinction. You have alroudy spoken of the difficulties which Bouhlor hod *o fuco as a result of taking over tho Chancellory or tho Fuohror, but albert Bo moan, tho brother of kartin Boruunn, was his oido, was ho not? Didn't that create a strongar connocticn with tho two agencies? Why not? 7270 8 y 47-a-?jC-19-3-*»mia.-cr (Int., Hoaxer) Court I * h'o, t—ere was an independent onnity betwooa the two brother* for f_y:ily ro_soaa. kurtin Boxuonn had cone frau tfco private chan¬ cellory ^nd hud then bee cue the adjutant of Hitler. He was a very ordinary personality without ~ny particular distinction. Ho thon iud began to r.avu dif:icultie« with his brother, uhcro was no connection possiblo as a result of the connection of those two brothers. q Witness, in this trial, as well us in all the othor trials which aro dealt with by the HUltory Tribunals, ono porson plays an ehtraordin-ry part and his n^io was Hlii.lor. What was Bouhlor'o relationship to Hinnler? a Tho relationship of hr. Bouhlor to Hlnulor was cool, rosorvod distant. 30*11.107 on tho baois of his norson.il concept was in contrast to tho ldeoloar us it v_s roprosoated by Hliiulcr. Ho hold no func¬ tions of any practical naturo within tho SS. His usuborshlp to tho SS w..s f.oroly foruol. $ Do you Know that frcu your own knowlodgo? a Too. I do Know that frou ay own knowlod£ 0 , bocauoo I re¬ peatedly had discussions of questions with Mr. Bouhlor on nunorouo occasions; allocutions woro u^do by the SS and our at tit'do had to bo dofinod. Q Could you civ® us u brief char xter study of Hiuilor's porsorvalt; 7 a Hn.t is not quite possible for no, becauso I had no personal relationship to Hiiuiler aid I tuvrofore tci in no position to charac¬ ter! ro this person. ^ -hvt Can you s^ about 3r.xk's pcrsonnlityT Do you knew 3rack| How lone have you known hint a I have known Brnck for a poriod of 12 yoars. Ho is tho oldost colleague cf Bouhlor. Ho V..8 alroody activo in Bouhlcr's offico when 3ouhler w^s still in Kunich. kr. Bouhlor, when Brack .. 8 luiy 47-^r-?j0“19-4—Aiulagc-r (lat., Heeler) Cotirt I *“ assigned to Oorlln, took hit. oloos n, hi. chlof of St off. drank >*“ the dlfflcultlo. -Men I hooo olrooiy nontionod. 1 Do you uoji 3ouhlor'e difficulties? a Yes, the Bouhlor-Boraaan, difficulties, the Bouhlcx^Einuler difficulties, and so forth, -hoe trying to deal with those difficul¬ ties, Brack did not always find support which would hovo boon noco- ssary frea kr. Souhlor, that is by reason of the connections of Bouhlcr which I h_vo picturod. q What was BraCAo attitudo toward his work? a flocauso of those difficulties, Brack w^s roliovod of his po¬ sition us Chief of Staff. Saoo of tho reasons for that can bo found in his personality. 4 How? a I knew Brock as an opon-cindod uan, who was always roudy to help. Ho w^s far removed free any fanutlcisu intoloranco or any narrowness of ho. rt but he luckod a purposeful lluitation to his coacroto fiold of work. Ho locked political consequential thinking rxd in cy opinion thoso two doficloacios in tho nan, nro tho rouson for his present uisfortuno. ^ Tou £..Tu us this picturo I assuuo on the basis of your acquaintoneoship for twelve yours? a Yes. I h .vo already s-id I h..vo known Brock for 1A yoars. i hovo ofton visited his faally; I know his parents; I 2 mow his ois- tors; ~nd tills qualifies no to give this Judgment frou hero. ^ Tou did work with Br..ck in tho Chancellory of tho Tuohror? you in a position to toll the Tribunal sene thing about Brack's fiold of work as briefly as possiolo? a After tho applications for pardons, and so forth, had been t-kon away freu Brack's fiold of work and were dealt with as an i -Cpenicr.t office and oftor ao was roliovod of his function as '-lief of Staff, kr. 3oualcr trunsf transferred to hiu tho r.c—called 7272 8 Huy 47-«-?jC-19-5-«rcir--:cr (Int., H a u ler) Court I Departaont 2 of the Cnaaccllery. Tho department was crllod "Political Complaints." Xhc tasks of that offico wore not quite easily doscribcd too haruonious, because there Was on abundance of quoctions and appli¬ cations directed to Hitler which arrived at this offico. Thoro was a huge nunbor of cocplaints. This is why it is difficult to explain this field of work frou ay own knowlodgo. I can illustrcto the con¬ dition there, becauso I was present whilst 3ouhlcr was sorting the nail wfcon Hltlor hissolf ontorod the roai unnoticed. 7273 -t _r - ving locked at 11 this ..-ark he sid *'I know that there nay -- nuocrcus cnoxscua purposeless applications and letters by people who jist grar.lc cr i_nour.ee -jjeng that heap of aril, but I txiink that in cn>- c-'-Sc cr another questions nay ccae up whore the persons concerned r*- c 'llin g for help, where valid situaticr.s cf uaergency exist, ;nd I darr.d that th-se people be helped. Th:e, cf course, gets c. ver; thorough lerlir.g with the correspondence necessary, he often had nr.il an- it ccr.stitutcu applications fer pardons nd releases fror. ccnccntra- -icn coups, ihere were applications regarding racial questions regarding aiti^'ticr. in dealing with the Jewish question. Ihere were coaplains -; ' ppliccticns with rofwrencc to the hereditary laws for the prevention of h-roJitar; diseases. "• Did ; cu ever discuss certain difficulties with the defendant 5rtc #: vhicii he experienced when decline with these nutters in connection with r. third person who pl.-^od - public part r t that tine? 1 ru new p rticulorl; referring to I^rtin Bcrcann, whoc ;cu Just ncnticned, and 1 rleo referrin: to Obergruppcnfuchrcr Heydrich. ... In Uth eases because cf a nusier of ref eons groat controversy -nsu.d, n’ th t for different re-aens. In the case of Heydrich I know th t Heydrich wanted the oiiainntion of Brack free Bouhlur's office, b-cause he did not grew with the attitude of thu dufenJent. 't. ‘.hat wr.s that attitude? ... In the case of Heydrich t is wos r-ostly concerned with r vl'.ints regarding the work cf the Gestrpe nd questions regarding the r-lusc frt. ccncentreticr. croaps. 1 r—uocfcer on the basis of report which I received frea- 3cuhler, because ho r-« r.r«'U'-.rtno*o will hear hia .".gain in the _cming, but 1 v.c ld surest in the acuiwhile that :cu talk the natter ever with the witness end instruct hin to answer to questions directly and rathor cere briefly and give the frets which will be of assistance to tho Tribunal* Tho Tribunal will now recess until nine-thirty tomorrow .aoming. Tho ricunrl will axet the Corraittoo. (The Tribunal rdjeurned at 15:27 hours.) 9 li-7 MMS.-L-l-i St r(Frank) Cjurt :;j. i Official Ti^nscrint of tho African Uilit-ry I rib arc 1 in the aatt-r of the United States 3f lu-xric'. -against Karl Brandt, -t al, deferriants, sitting at .\urnlxrg, Arseny, .r. 9 Ifcy 1947, 0530, Justice 3oals 'residing. Tnd 'IvRSKAL: P.rs3-.s in the c^srt r; a *ill pie?.a. find thoir seats. The Honorable, the Judges of iiilitcry Tribunal I. liilitnry Tribunal I is no* in session. Cod save the United St?.tee f /unerica and this b-norrtle Tribunal. Thvr<- will bo order in tho c.urtrocca. THIS PRES1DXT: &•. Unralrl, y -u ascertain if the defendants arc -11 presort n c-»urt. THE lARSJLvL: Hay It please y or ii n r, all defendants aro present in the Cwiirt. THE PRiSIEal'JT: Tho Secret. ry-Gcncrr.l nill n*te f r the record tho prvSo:.co of all tho dofvariants in c art. .Counsol any proceed. K«RL HSWUCH 1EDJJCK - Ruocaid DIRECT fck«JfI!l.7I0N (Continued) BY eR. FR0ESCHlWa;(C3Ui»a f r the Dcfon ant 3r .ck): -.itneso, ai,ht I rooind you first of -llth't you .are still urc\r ath. ist-ray / u had bc.n speftkin,. ?.b ut tho Defendant Brack's ■.ctlvities in Don-rt-.-r.t 2 of the Fuehrer's Chancellory. I want to nut tills question to y u. Did Brack in t-.is iffice, Depart; nt 2 that is, have “utr.wri.ty t sake d-ciaicns n his *n? 'JOm I.is ' th. rity t nkv ’.c si an:, i'± Ruichsloiter Bauhler better. E uhler and Brack with regard knew -.uhler's attitude regarding tho 7277, 9 Ilay /.7-::-Sr.-l-l-F s' r (Fr.ri) C-urt No. 1 tr r.tr*nt jf tasks assigned t- him, Bouhler? ... The r_l-'.ti ‘ '.ship wu such tixit Brack had to kn.w Bauhlor's • -ttitudo recording this sphere A influence A his. . i ?Ur ay --;u had already talked nbrut tlx fact that B.uhlor's • ttitu's os C;-i«f >t thb Chancellory .. boon = t.lerant -.no, is that c ir-ct? ■ a. Yea, R-Vv you boon able t- make sun. that Brack's attitude regard¬ ing tne tr 't. *>nt f t sks which op prose hod hia, particularly rufarding tho rvlease A concuntr ti n canp inactes and applications c ning fr xx v rious half-Jewish persons, was t lurant? ... ..a far *o I h' d pp-rtunitiea tj Lari f Brick's activities, I saw then -o being t^l-rant and r.er.Lr us. f. Av\-1her ctxisti n. The Defend at Brack during his interrogation ir.a so.'ken ab ut .a a -called ."da. scar plan ntich in 1940 cano up f r discussion in the Chance 11;ry f the Ku-hrer nndw's do-It with there. La y u have ary knowledge .f r. iWoscar Plan? <» •* ? • Q. iVt do y u kj. w abuut t? Viet was the -lia f that *lan? It ias t c Mu f that-plan to dofol pu and submit suggestl -no regarding ti.o solution f the prjblm of halloas Jews which was to be 3 Wed by creating a new rdcr in our p« which w.uld glvo thorn state svstun ;f their wn. This wac d no frxi the p int A view -duptud b Gerern policy -f th* tin., maoly, with conaid-ration rth sat vat i r. in Pal 5 tine and the «r-b quest! n. C.^v ;I %V lust s ken .t at the -ituati n in Eur =pe —I think that auet b- adstakt, yeu -aern tfv siturti n in the a rl!? -‘r.. s y.ur st-te.xnt oining a*, the Jews Living in E-ir-pc at tho tins? .... In comwcti ndth tl» i'-dascar Plan, I'd hoard at the tiro that t, p rsilaUty exist..’ Ur.t tb. war w aid e x to an end, and c rre-3 adlnr.ly ti. t suggestion had b.en -.ado t Great Britain, and ir c rr.-cti r. ivv r l plans of different nature h’d been-dovd. -d 7278 9 Ihy 47-tf-Sf-l-3-F jt r(Frrnk) c-'a-t ns. i • n ir. this csnr.ectir: I c?:x -:r ss t. _ prbbleos c ntcinoc in tin. ; '-.'.scar plan. BnuhUr in hie sphere f ..ark hrd it ic'lt vith or cl.-r.lt with it htaoolf. .. T.is '.-.'r. ?3C'.r Finn, die’ that Lave cr. cr.ti-JeWish tendency? .. for u I na able t sponk n thu strength of x:y «r. kn w- L > .-or.., r . It was njr inpressi >n t;.-t this ms m effort, o I«d sr.it! ftt thj b. £w± .3 , t- eolw. t e ,r i ur "vete rgj, and th“t, tf.erof re, 1 h-d the riyht t ux.’x ct t.r.t t.xso d cu:*nt b >ko * uld bo ct tho dicp cnl A tho Tribunal r.t the tine. Only the .opor.dix 3 c uld bo c r.nlotod ’.urine recent Sya because r.u.b.r f uxhibitis war- c.ntnir.v! therein which 1 iayaelf only njciov. ’ in r»-cont days. I need n.t r ad tho docunont I r ferrod t , 1 1 .xr.ly ;f-ring it t the Tribunal dth tho roquost tl: t y u trJee ju icir.l n tico -f it. THL Pr_lSJDE T: ill c unsol : ~in ref. r t tit i cx-.-nt nuaber in his b-?k. DF.. readme:It is D cu . r.t S . 27, in the 2r.’ v lino i ny c ynt fc k, ’ it is n jr-go 3. I’ • ’-7 - ..'---ir..-, uxtrr.cts ft* trx tncycl :utiia ~nd it S.-is iith the psych l.'giccl f-etd f 7279 y - - -- st r(Frink; C urfc S '. 1 It-ASEr - c:r « t:.: EESIDET: nit exhibit nu=fc_r *.» y u assign t: this U cunurit? D . Pa^SSCffiaffd: Exhibit 2, or. President. HR. K.FDY: ii y it pltr.se y>ur K -n,r, ti.e Secret- ry-Go:xral his .t .t -jy c’is. js-l a copy of Ddcutfmt B ok No. 2, and if defenso ounsolcnros to introduce it non, the pr?socuti:>n Mill agree. H-.i- uv.r, I fcr.vo -n bjtcti n to the- d cu-e.t in as nuch .a the c'.'cu . r.t ia c nceinine tho pr -poaci plan t sene’ the so-c*Lled h odors Jens ti .. ag; scar, -and this Tribunal is r. t .V lin. with mttura f ttvt it tiro. It rs t th-. t ejection that tho d cu.axr.t ia i/. v.tv.rial and I b ^ ct t its -'.ur.i88i.in in evidence. B JTISSID. t la the f t. is • cunont, o unsol? DR.-re.- jC’ r. Pr.silent, nthe c ur.e f ti* ocn.nia-.ti a f t,x Dofen ant 3r*ck I shill oal with the circuaatnnces in detail why sr ck particularly, aid hie c -LL'bjmt re, turned tbjir thought a up ;n the Ieimd ,f ifcdagr.acar. Tho bjoctl n night bo raised that t t lai n’ was a unoc r. deal that tho plan of Bottling 4 r. c 1 ' bo c ns Herod Just u cruol is thoir otructi the oxtoraianti »n f the Jews, and in rl«r t holp this High IVibun'l, which, 1 asarno, f c ursc, fee full kn *»io C& f tho jo ttoro, it sh.jul’ a Is r.v*o d cuxnt ry basis t docido u~>n, km tho liberty »f aubaitting tit d.c amt. That wna all I was a Lain, at thr u,h it. TiS PRESIDE: !: D-fer. nt br ck io directly ci- rged by the indict- -afc with Cvrt in specific ffona~r. Tj*. Tribur. 1 is in >1 ubt ns to the r b-ative v*lue in c nrxeti n.ithcny aich ir f -s 7 u .amti nod -r lx a r in up :: the issues ir. this c-iso, in s - f r as gpfenlant Brack isc no-rned. DR. FROrSC-i—..:.: Do for. - r.t Br ek wishes to doll with tho allogati n f the >r recuti^t th- t he bad lx on hostile t> tho Jens an! that . t rtici; to. in tho plans f the oxtorainati n .1 tee Jews, 7260 . 9 -y 47-21-S5f-l-5- F--stwr(Frank) C art Hi. i -rt wants to T 7/e th t his -ttitu^ irs .lir-ctly -pp;site tD this Iw hrs --Lays drno everything -issiblo in rdor t> c.untomct . pinna -r J wish cxtomimtl m that he had to rC -f. 7.. t is, f c ur.-, L.- r assn why this Madagascar plan, >f which tho riofen- ‘•"xt Jr. a s ker. during his irtorr jgr.ti r., is c insidered to bo rol.vr nt by 20 , T5C .HaSIDSl.T: Tho Tribunal is f tho >ini n that tho rr-.tt-p- t Uaat at tills tiro — is entirely with ut any rrob-.tivo vnluo in c nnecti-n with tho issue ixf;r- tJ is Tribun* 1. Tho bjection will be sustained irith lo rm ti ro- ff v r tho d'cuacnt Inter. »s tho evidence dovcicnes it ary bo do to rad nod that the letter tre s no ■r b tivo value, but t this tiro the >bjucti n is aast-inod. The d-JCtnont will n o bo daittod. BT DR. FRCBSCK Q. ''itnens, wiion and h « did y u le:rn A the euthanasia nuasuros adopted in Gcmony? ... h'-y I t til: p int raw y«r r.ttenti si t a/ affidavit datod th- 23th f June l 1-ct y. or which Dr. Robert Sonrtiuo submitted t tho Int-rmti nal IliUtrry Tribunal in Kurnborp,? Th t 0 ciojnfc is nut a d.ctr.ont whioh I oysolf have Kibaittod •'Wl ttoroforo y.u conn at r-f.r tu it, but I do t: ink that 70 U can toll tto Tribunal such ;» rt 3 f th t decunvnt as ,ry be >f interest with rc-ran' to this spec! 1 qu-sti n which I -nit t y.»u. DR. rROoSCin-u-I.: .* y I ask tho Tribun It t giv. jxraissian th t witness Bed-rich my i\ .d fr tho affidavit sutnitted t> tho Into nr. ti n.l Military Iribunal, such - fo« sentcnc-s :.s can answer ttc question which I have put t * hia just n w? Ilr PRjoTDSIT: 7:w D-extent t which 7 u xvfor has n t boon called ’ tho attonti n 1 ' t.o Tribun 1 with t n. quest that tho Tribunal take Judicial ntice jf the t* extent. DR. t KJJSCITinJK: To. d cun. nt was submitted during tho trial 72=1 si*x{Frnnk) C art I b. f rj the Ir.Unrti -r.al ry Tribunal. It *-s siiboitted by ■y c LLv .juu, br. S-rvatiuE, as an exhibit. I™ PK 1 .T -sKT : I understand th~t, but it hasn't as yet boon br u, ht t t, e attention -f this Tribunal. Thu Tribunal * ;vHA like t t“-..iir— the d>cuaont. 'JR. H.JDY: li.y it please y or H nor, the dc unci it referred t. is nitre8s .% the stand. If in inti tic .r >bLoa of euthanasia r the issues in this case, tho witness is here, ho can ask th. witness without bothering with tid3 d -cu- xmt, r sidn tic c urt t take n tic. f thor d.ouiscnt. Ho has th. witnjas available and can qu-sti n bin -n th-t 3 int. THE FRSSXDSNTs The Tribunal would like t oxnsdnu the d cumont. Vill y u subalt it to the Tribunal? DR. FROBSCKi.fflt : Ci.-xnt is in ands f tho witness. I zysoll' don't have it. (Docusont Inqu.sti n is tended t t'.io Tribunal.) THE PRBSIDS !: Is th re aqy Ejijliah tr nslati n f this docunont v liable? >252 9 li7-::-,.TD-2-l-?cslcr (IdTT. Frank) Court He. 1 D . F33BSCK-.KK: Vr. President, I nyself don»t have an English translation because I nysolf wasn’t . oing to refer tc the ’ocunent. It ytZ3 the witness who ran tod to know sonatfcin~ fror it an* infom tho Tribunal, of these carta. nt? PRESIDENT: foil, tho witness nay use the locuiwnt to rafresh his rocolloetion, answer any questions that are mterial to thi3 inqiiry. 3 s ’ DR. FIEOSCRIi'.im (Continuin ) q Titnoss, l repeat ry question asto 'hen an’, how dir! you learn of the euthanasia ensures a "onto! in Goraany, an’ I also waul’ liko to ask you to uso tho .’.ocui-^nt in tho sonso which the Prosi ’ont has Just instructed you. A Of tho so-callo 1 euthanasia preco^hiro, I hoard at tho bogLnnlni: of 19li0| 'Than tho natter bad to so:» extent alroa ty na lo constdcrablo pre toss, an* accor *lr. • to y rocolloetion thoro wero sourcos of tho dorry who rot into touch :1th tho Catholic Church an' tho Protestant Church, sources with whoa I was rorkin to other. 0 So that.until tho boinnlir of 19b0 you ha! ha*, no knorloigo that Bouhlor or Brack voro occupying tho: .solves in anyway with euthanasia noasuros, is that ri-ht? A That is correct, I hod no kncwlo !"(*. q Did you speak about this with Sradc? A I ton't thirfc that I talked about thoso quostions in detail with the dofon !ant, but I Id s;:ock about then in detail to Bouhler. 0 In this connection I an only intorosto' in one sin lo question. Di.! BouKLeo* tell you in this connection about tho fact that euthanasia noasuros which ho was carrying out, or had carrio! out, had #&.n Is¬ sues©'! by hir. with Judicial sources in the Reich? A That was a very focal point of Bcwhior's an’ or.a of tho lea iing ..roblciJs which occupied hln for c Ion- tin a. q "net di! Bsuhlor tell you about that at th. tine, as to whothor he considered Hitler's do croc- of the 1st of S opt trior 1933 to bo a legal 7283 9 y U7--ATD-2-2-“06 ter (Int. Frank) Court ?«*c. 1 basis of legal nature? A Bcuhler himself — Q fould ycu min' loavln• the Hr. an’ *'rs, off because Bcuhler is enough for us, you knew. A Bcuhler hlasolf rs^aivUn the locality and a oral basis of euthanasia ha ’ no 'eubts -thatover• liis objections loalt with tho formal legal shape cf the tasks -ssi nj.’ to him and tho leral formula. Con- 3i.'.orirr the far roaehin effects of the t?sk, he .ranted to avoid misuse. 0 . Thorofore, if I un tors tend veu correctly, then tho train of theu hts which Souhlor had was that Hitler’s lecreo meant to hin a lo- ally sour.basis, but that in his opinion it was essenti a with recard to tho general public that all individual .measures which wero now boin-; usothrough euthanasia, or should be uso:!, should ho clOthod in a formal Soich’s Law. A That is oorroct, and Bouhlur’s opinion was atronythonod when because of those difficulties ho offerod Hitler his rcsi nation, and whon in the 'iscession r.hich arose in that connection tlv: 1 : lity of thoso ooaiuros was wnfir.ad ‘ hin in that connection. Q Jist onj nonont. Your testimony would loa ’ to tho conclusion that Bouhlur bad ou-ekun .. 1 th Iltlor about tho necessity of a lo a formulation of tSi<. .uthanasia lecroo or order, cr locroo — whichever you want tc call it. A Yes. Q And then ycur testimony woul' further show that Hitler '1th regard to Eouhlor 1 a sup post ion had turned that ’own? A I aii net fully inforao ’. about thu exact contents of tho Fcuhlor- Hitl-sr oonforenca, but t*>- outewa mas that it became Bcuhler '3 that his task was lawful, an that bocnao the subject of further 1 s- cusoions with the Raich "irdster of Justice. q Di 1 tho further '.'jvolojnents in l?hO make it ’cr.orrr. to you that 51 uhler also cenferr ’ tith scurcos of tlv; iMch * Inis try cf Jus tic.: continuously, that a -raft iv. was * * o obtained fr?:: iitler? - 72S4 ? U 7-^-ATD-2-3-?cster (Ir.t. Frank) Court Ho* 1 A Efforts a'a tonar Is such a ’.raft law ro back to tha early stay os sf euthanasia. 1 riC'V do you know? A Bcuhler tol l to thr t when I approached hir. ro.-ar liny reasons which I ha l aentionec* to you at the be inninv of qy testimony. Ho told no that when ha ’ascribe! to ~.o the task Hitler bad assi.-rv. 1 to hin an 1 r rr. Brock. q Did Bouhlur tell you at tha tiro that threurh his collaborators, an particularly Brack, such a lrnft law ras to be developed or had bean developed? A Bouhlor not only told :*> so but he oven showol no on that, and other occasions, of oxtonsive nr.tcrial which "as to servo tho drafting of such a law. Q Di:l ycu ycursolf roa ’ tha draft law? A to. Q i.n' then what happen*! to this raft law? A Bouhlor, when isro- nr ’in: tho fortnl wor in- of his task turned out to bo consi lorablo, an*, when ho had to loci'la — q You sai l that alr*c% «. ’lay I ask you to report tho question. I --t loot. q I want to put this question to ycu. Ti ’ you as uonths wont by in 19U0 learr. o ' th<- fate ro ar in »his Iraft law? A I thsu ht I hal nnsworo* that by syyin- thrt Hitlor hal turno 1 it 'own. q But i 'r^t Pouhler oonfor with the Rich Minister of Justice rogarinr’ its Iraft law? A Yes, Q ’.'oil, then, '.hat wr.s tho attitu lo a ’ortol by the Reich ’iniotor of Justice? 0 A Itr. Bouhlor -’opto 1 tho view th t tills was a -atier for tho Reich Inistr of Jus tic.' anl the P.oich Chancellory nsw to achieve tho proper * - railae for this law. He hinself found hinaalf in considerable i ffi- ’ IM'is '.ec'.'is- os; or.-- .-5.‘a •~'s referring to an or Vr from the hirhost 72&5 . ’ 9 ::~y u7-’'-;,TI>-2-^ostur (Ini. r*sak) Craft itoi 1 rllitary comander at the hoa of t .c state, with all the functions which Hitler hel , and on the ether si ’.© ho saw the responsibility of iirUvi-iial niniators whoa ha ecul !n*t influence but fron whoa he was eran'inr that they in urn, if Ifficulties arose, shcul ’ fir.' tho leval solution. That wasn>t, after all, his task. Q I an askir.;: ycu, what was the attitude a top to.' of the Reich inis try of Justico with regard to Oouhlor's wish that a draft law shoul 1 boccce law? A As far as I knov, the -fitter uas left in aboyanco. Ho further clarification was achieve except that on tho strength of tvs con- feronco botwoon Bcuhler and 'iitlor an a -roonont was reached between him an', tho minis tor that tho attcr '..-as now boin- settled.. Q So that if I understand ycu correctly the Reich Unis try of Jiistico or tho Reich ’dinister of Aistico, in spito of Bouhlor«3 con¬ siderin'- reprosontation, a ’opto l tho vi.r that this s in ordor. .. “hat was my opinion, yes. Q Di ’ you hoar about it, that the defen dant Prack too, ha d know- lodr'o of tho no .-otintionn botwoon “ouhlor an thu Roich :*iniator of Aistico? A Yes. 7236 Court So. 1 S .-'Ey 47-tf-3-l-£B»-Iarrov (Track) q. “itness, in eubseouent tines you yourself didn't exactly deal with euthanasia re a rare a but you had heard about the.: end you discussed then with various gentlenon in the Fuehrer's Chancellery, is that cor¬ rect? — A. Yea. Q. Cn the strength of such conversations, or any other converse- tions, did you ever cone across the words "useless enters" and that they would have to be removed in this vey? Bid you ever cone across that? A. The tendency hidden behind tho words "useless eaters" has now only becoae known to ne through evidence submitted by tho prosecution, but froc Bouhlvr's statement, as far es this problon was conccrnod, they vmIA never have given ::e an indication of such an attitude. Cc Did you hear anything about tho fret or the oucotlon why Hit¬ ler's decree wao issued ,'uet at tho beginning of the war? A. Fran stateuor.ts which have boon nr.do available to no I havo learned that wo w^re concerned with psychological considerations. Ci. Voll thon, what wns the typo of the psychological considera¬ tions? A. They wore of such nature that they believed that the under¬ standing of biological and heriditary probleas should bo awakened anong tho population. q. Just o aoaent. The eugenic and heriditary biological trends of thought, did they have a decisive value with record to euthanasia? A. As far as I rn infomod, that was the basic point of euthanasia naaoly, that the problem of useless living beings - the living beings who had dropped below a certain level - should bo solved by neons of the nercy death. q. I think you have expressed ycurself soccvhot incorrectly thore. The auestion of eugenics and heriditary biological theorios do not, of courso, have anything to do with what you Just said. A. '-Oil, I wasn't really going to try to link it up. Q. bell, I an coning to qy final ouestions. "id you gather fror. 7287 Court So. 1 9 May 47-H-3r2-'BHM-£arrc*' (Frank) Bouhler' b statements any knowledge regarding the point of vie*- which ho and Brack night have had when they considered cuthenaoip to to justified? A. Free the events I had nore than sufficient opportunity to learn of Bouhler attitude with regard to these Questions. First of all, there were his considerations of a legal nature, and then there vee the type of action he took with the objections raiced fron clerical sources. I had the i .pr^ssion there that the religious noaentun con¬ nected with euthanasia, in connection with the otjccti-ns raised by the • church, occupied first oleeo with hr.- Bouhler. I also learned fron tho legal arguments which he raised, a siniljr point of %*iow th»t he was fighting for it oessionately, that he wasn't merely concerned with the formal foniulati ..a of a task, but that he was interested in the legal conception and tho lovful idea of tho whole rffair. q. Did Bouhler also toll you that tho defendant Brack ohared thoso views? A. : nl"ye assumed that sinco Brack, with regard to all thoso cuootions, was, »ft«.r all, only tho deputy - tho r.nn to *-hon u task was essignod by Bouhler. q. I vns Just about to coao to this lest question. I havo a6kcd you earlier during your tostiaony whether Bra.ck in hlo Department 2 had authority to nake decisions of his own and you roiswcrod that ouostion, of ccurso, in the negative. Svw, I wish to ask you which position Brack actually occupied within tho framework of this so-crllcd eutha¬ nasia program. Vas he of tht scni rank as Bouhler? Did he have similar responsibilities, or was he acting on hie KhaJf, or how can you doscribo his position? A. Bouhler called hinself the ->nly responsible person wh»n he talked to about the problem of outhenrsia pnd Kr. 3rack. The port which Kr. Brack played wps that of a. subordinate official who had administrative and organisational tasks. 2 n. FSOLSCrKASH: Hr. President, in the course cf this trial, if I'- net mistaken, Karl Brandt's defense c unsel submitted the document 7283 Court So. 1 5 Hoy 4?-H-c-3-EHh-K*rrow (Trask) SO 156. It vas offered ae Eracdt's Exhibit So. 4A and 43. That document dealt with a letter fros the Chief of the Juehrer 1 s Chancellery, addressed to the Beich Minister of Justice Cuertner, in which the author states that "on the basis of. the authority issued by the Fuehrer, I ac considered as the sole resoor.sible person for the carrying out of the tasks which I consider necessary and I have given corresoonding instruc¬ tions to ay collaborators". At the tiao the signature below this docu- xont could not bt clearly identified. Kay I su^cit this document to this witness with the recuest or the ouestion whether the signrturo over vhich this docuaent appears will be rocognised by hia i-v being that of Bcuhlcr? THE PEESnJU.T: The document tsay be eubaittod to the witness. If ho can identify the signature, he nay testify. (Tho docuaent was subaitted to the witness.) 2Y DR. 7HCi.SCHKAKK j tltnoss, will you please read through this docuaent and will you answer ay ouectlon as to vfco has signed this docuaent? This is n photostatic coo; , by tho voy. A. Tho signature is that of Boohler. Q. Can you recognise it without doubt as being Bouhler's? A. I can recognise it for certain¬ ty Well, I cone bock to ay initial ouestion now; namely, what wuo tho position held by the defendant Brack within tho fraaowork of the euthanasia progrea? A. I repeat, Ernck'a position vac of a very subordinate nature and he was defending on Bouhler's orders. Q. "’ould it be right for ac to say that Srack, within the; so-called euthanasia progrea occupied, the position of a general secretary, shall we say? A. I would say that that c-uression is too strong. Q, It is, is it? Veil, ho vob Ues than a general secretary? A. I would say that the evuresslon is too strong since 3rr>c':'s 7239 Coart 3o. 1 9 May *»7-M-3-4-BEM-£arrov (Frank) authority with regard to other deuertaeats vao limited and since Bouhler always emahasized, when talking to =e, that apart from hit own sphere of influence the sohero of influence of the Belch Ministry of Interior prevented independent action and position in the euthr-nasie orogran. May I then state finally that, according to your statement, the defoedant Brack, in the so-called euthanasia program, only had a subordinate position on the strength of which he had to obey Bouhler'o instructions without Questioning and in connection with which his acti¬ vities wero confined to the carrying out of such instructions as Bouhler would give hin. A. Ye*. EH. reCKSCKhJOV: Mr. Presidont, for tho najon* T have r.o further Questions to this witness. THE ffiSSIBZOT: Eas any dofonee counsel any auootion to propound to this witness in connection with the case as it affocte their r*oooc- tlvo clients? ZSt. FP.CSSCHhAini: I have no further auostions, Mr. President. BY ZB. HGFnuW (Counsel for the defendant Pokorny): Q. ■itnecs, you said that in 1940 the Madagascar Plcn hod boon dovolopod. Mfcnt was the reason for which this Dlan was dcvolopod? Surely you could have loft tho Jews la Germany. A. The reason for th« development of this plan I have already • • dealt with in ny initial answer, I thought. It was general considera¬ tions with regard to a peace of tho future which ono thought “a® 1 “ti¬ nt nt at the tlao. -uring thv development and representrtions of that period, plans and suggestions wore cede regarding any intcr-Eurooean settlement of that problem. As for as I a= informed, e.c far as '■ could gather from Bouhler'* statonentt,that is, it bed been indicated to him that ho needn't bother about that plan any further since it would be the subject of discussions if and when the time cone, and tho way I always understood that that it scant it would be of inter-European 7290 Court So. 1 S ..ay •*?-aC-3-5-£3i-Xarr:v (Frank) coseera because the var was considered to be inter-Zurocean at that tiro. France vas interested - any plan about Madagascar couldn't be discussed without France - and Zngland vas interested. All right, witness, but were there different clans, further plans, dealing with the s5lution of the problem? To bo very exact, vac the question of sterilisation ceniionci? A. I don’t know anything ebcut that. Q. You don't know anything about that? A, So, I knew nov by the an to riel eubaitted by the crosecution. Q. In that case, I have no further ouestions. TKZ KZSIIHST: An.” other ouestior. by defonso coun6ol? If not, the crosecution nay cross-cxcaine. MS. E j&mt Hay it please Your Honors, the prosecution hat no ouestions to put to this witness. TKZ FRZSIHZN7: Counsel for tho defendant 3rock any procood. The vitnoos will to excused fraa the stand. ESv. FRC&SCliiAKS: Of course, I haven't any further ouestions to ths witness. Mr. President, nay I havo tho Tribunal's Demission to call to ths stand n witness whose none is Dr. Hcraann Pfanrxuollcr and hit titlo is Gberncdlrinelrat? TKZ pazsnEKT: Tho itarahel win suaaor. the witness, Dr. H^rcann Pfannsutll<.r, to the stand. (EZ3HASK PFAKWUZLLZS, e witness, took the stand and testified as follows.) BY JU30L SJF.IS5: Q. You will raise your right hand and be sworn. I swear by God, the almighty and Chaise lent, that I vHl socak the euro truth and will withhold and add nothing. (Tho witness -ec-.ated the oath.) Y3U any be seated. 7.191 u u> curt He. 1 iay * ! 7-44-£-6-LSt-iarrGv (Trask) DELC7 xJUfUXAIIOI 5T as. 7SQiSC3iA£3; Q. Witness, please vill you tell at your first end lest ran© end the date of birth? Can you hear ae? , A, So. q. Please, vould you put on ycur headphones end I’ll repeat the question, and then -ill you please nuke a pause so that the interpreter can follow, and will you then answer it? THZ PTiSILL'.^: Counsel vill propound hie ouection to tho vitness again. BY DR. raCESCEHiMM: Cc Please, vill you state ycur first and last nano and your date if birth? A. Dr. Kuraanr. Pfannaucllor. Bom 6th of June. 188G. Q. Witness, please vill you tell this Tribunal briefly of your career and vill you caphasiie your acdical training and tho positions you hold? A. I visited four for-.s of tho oloaentary school in Munich and then I vent to the secondary school in Kunich vhcro I obtained the cor- tlfloate entitling =. to university Wining. I then etudlei nedlelne .1 the University of Munich, unde ny prellnlncry cknu. there, nnd In 1911 pcseod the stole smu. with good results. Subsequently. I worked nt sovorel lnetltutee nnd also n. n prnctltloner: thnt le. I worked In several hospital, and practiced and this Included Hunlch. I then wont tc Breeden to the Konon-e Clinic where I held further training for els nonthe, and then in 1913. upon being por.uadcd by uy teacher. Krepelln - I an a scholar of Kreeclln In Kunich - I -ont to the cental Institute in Wcinauenster - Vcinaucnater, by the vay. is in Sassou - in order to work under the head of that institute towards reorganising the Institute for -oderr. psychiatric diagnosis and treatnent. This was actually done. end then vet caac. 7292 9 ay - ?-?j-ii-i—.’-.lav (Tnt. Franks) Court No. i Eurint the war apart froc workin in this instituto I also ha’ to toputise for tha local gaa.rcl practitioner, an’ I ayself was the head of research occupation. Q It wfin't bo necessary for yen to go into all these do tails. Just 7«:ak Moro generally. 3 I than entorc! the state institutions in Bavaria at Honbor", rlvoro I beoor.a a :»f a hereditary health law in tho capacity of an oxporinont, aw’, also tru ca.*ryin. out of the unrital hero it.iry health lo»j ala- the paychiatrio caro fbr chil Iron, particularly school chil’ron an’, tho liaison top rt»nt froa tho nodical ’.opartnont to tho ny chin trie Depertnont at Au s’-ur , an! thu transfer of cases that .voro in rvioi or hospitalization. Q Di *. ycu st to ^-alfir. -liarr? A Lot no a V! first of all tir.t ’urir. • thin p rioc! frorc 193a until ny rosi^nr.tion fMn j.u s’ ur I was honorary hoa! of tha Catholic nurslnr ho no for ’Tinkers, an’ its ’.o-art. -nt • t ‘aitln-en, which activity load to it that larry.r3 consulted no in oonnootion vith hospitalization of *rinkor3 — accorUn to 1 era r-.-h i: -C - consultu ! rv. a3 a nodical a; .-port, I to think that this is ixiportant. In 1933 v.lthout a. ;lyin * for this position an' without h'vin anybo^is protection or help 1 bocana a 1 rector an 1 hoa-'. — *ron a r> b.c l point of view — of tho rental sani- toriwi of E-elfin , which i3 the ' i cat of its typo in Bavaria, Q That i3 in *wnich? . .. Yos, 15 'dieters frcci Tiinich, 3 How :iany bo’s i tho .nant-l sanitoriun at - olr'in havo? A At tho bij.innin . of y work about 2500 -.n' we increase! that to a' oua 3, O- bods 729 L - >-19l?-* ^TD-L-3-”2lc7 (Ir.t. Pranks) court ::o. i Q An* hem .any insane patients were there on the average? A "ell, a;air. between 27CO an' 28X, an! approximately 3000. The fi Tiro of 30CO was, however, after oxcooded. q Tnich a,-;Q croups reru represented in this hospital? A Every age croup, bopinninc with the smilost children to really ol poopif, since I had a children’s house which I had taken over fron cy predecessor. DR. TROlSfr :.:r *: V. President, tho Srosecution in the course of its cr.au intro tucod a nurfcor of documents which wjro shorin that fron 20 Sj.itor.ber 19?;0 transports left S-jalfin. which included Jcr.rish insane pooplo. For this reason I should like to jut tho following quostion to tho vdtnoaa: Q Di I your nontal institution at Eyolfin hiring the yonrs 1939 to 19li2troat Jewish Inaano pooplo? A Yos, in ry hospitcl Jewish inaarc ..atients roro proaont in tm> cato :orlos, thoy Jsut no . uoh as any oth.r patients, vjero troatod nomally an’ thoy weren't in wards of thoir own. Q 'hat tyyd of instructions di’. yeu rocoivo re par 'in - tho transfer of tho3o Jewish Insane pooplo in 1? : 0 an* if so fro:; .h-t source ’i: you got then? A I ton't knerr for cortnin vhr.t tho 'ato ms, but I ’i ' rocoivo n 'ocision fro., tho Bavarian State inis try of th Interior, nccor Unr to which a nuvb.r of Jewish >atienta fro : all lavnrian Institutions, woro to bo colleotod ir. :y hospital, l-iat ttey shrul * bo placed in spodal wards, which I .;oull have to clear for tho urposa an’ that thoy w oro to be fo 1. in tho re ular cate.'orios, an ’ that thoy wore ta to taken care of and treats ! until thoy war:- tranaferro’. by authority of this Bavarian "inistry or tha Department concerned in tho Daprrtaont of the ’Ministry of Bavaria. Ac far as ay own insane persons wore concerned, by o*.m Jewish patients, th?y renained in their ori inal war 's until they 'ere callod nray. q Did you have further instructions accordin' to which those Jewish insane people wore to ’ a taker, fro: thoir hospitals and should bo brought 7295 amy. 9 !iay li ?-?{-. (Int. Franks) Court !fo. 1 * ros, they came free the State Jflnlstry cf Bavaria, an*, as far as I reacEbor this stated these patients had to be handed over. Q Is it possible that the transportin': of Jewish Insane patients took place on or a*»ut tfco 20th of September 19U>? •'* - as » - think that is the aR.roxinato tine when these patients loft. Q Do yen have any kno.rlod-o about tho fact whether this dopartinc transport of Jewish insane patients wn3 ccnncctod with euthanasia -ensures of any kin.'.? * 7256 Court 1 ;/'-y 5-1—HD-Cook-Fra nk. Ko, it wrs st ted that those patients wore boin t transferred to a Jewish Institute. *. You were especially told th t? n< Yes. i,. Th nit you. Nov mother question. Witness, you rt'vo -oecrlood in r.at detail what your career was and •>u have spoken about your psychiatr. training, which basic attitude did you a .opt with r- e ard to the welfare and care of insnne people, first of -'ll with ro c nrd t^ their treat¬ ment, and, secondly, with regard to tekln. care of them? ti. Without wanting to speak about my own past, I want to Coll yo- that I was a definite follower of therapeutic treatment. * In psychiatric circles, in the pessimistic circles. The circles of Fnlkonhausor, I was cnlled the Poll-pragmatic. It is ay opinion with ro c rd to curln u of these patients thnt everything .mist bo done and that every attempt is essential to holp the insane patients and t nvko available to hl_ curative treatment. I, thoroforo, belong to thos^ practical psychiatrists wno, together with Fnlkonhausor ay friend and teacher, I do want to say that we, made every effort that the admission of patients and the release of the patients w^s a decision which should bo made generally oc.6ier fe»r the her- of an institute, in order to .jOt the cases there quickly when they were fresh and to remove them as quickly as possible from the ataos-horo of a currin._, a,mo, which always has a favorable Influence. Likewise, fur the same reason I was a convinced and fanatic follower of the orir.ciple of soparntin. nj^ntal Institutes and s -crll.d currin t homes which were to be looked after by psychiatrists, experts, oeople with scientific and expert knowledge, mcdic-'l personnel from i .jsc institutes where the more simplified c. re of cases 7297 C urt 1 5-l.-c-2-r.3-C - ok-5 rank. c uld be carried -at, no longer a therapy, I nean patient3 who couldn't be helped by therapy. k. So I car. summarize that It was your point of view that every typo of treatment should be employe! in order t- brln^. about « cure f.r such Insane persons as could bo ourel? ii. Yes. Q. xnd that th-y should bo accomodated In so-called aental Institutes, and on the other hand Incurable Insane people who only noidvu to be looked aft^r - In other words, maintenance of their life should bo accomodated In special Institutes? n. Yes, and in fact that happened In S^clfln^. I refused p tl-nt-- who only were In need of cr.ro in order to sake room for those y tlcnto who ne ded treatment and to kcop any staff for the treatment of the Insane patients. k. Then what typo of insane pooplo would psychiatrists loserlbe no Incurably insane people? «. To out It briefly, Is very difficult but lot no any this: The oolr.t of view ou_ht to be approximately that: Incurably Insane 8K those who are permanently In n_ed of treataont In a institute and those for whom any c nt"ct with their surroundings from a social psychiatrist's point of view. In other word6, the point of view maintained where the common foelln of a human boln_ Is lnckin., that bu a final condition or it may be the condition of the be-lnnlntj of idiocy. For Instance, those Insane patients vh suffer fix;ra organic diseases cf the brain, such ns paralysis, epileptics- k. Now, doctor, cay I Interrupt you please. Would you ; ind spcokin L Into the microphone? I didn't know there was one - paralysis*epilepsy, G-urt i Jfcy 3-#-5-3-K3-Cook-Fr nk. idiocy, certain cases of idiocy are duo to serious dcsinsos the brain, on* In tr.at case those due to Interior '.isturbences, usually they are horodltrry causes, but most cf all the schizophrenia* else dementia praecox, those cases w.'.loh we consider as hopele66 pers-ns who must bo f.cnlol any contact with their surroundings and with the huaan community, end who also lack th_ capability of tainkin$ normally, those who were in perpetual need of caro and for years and those that could only be cakon care o: through outside help in o nur6ir._ home. 4 hey would 9 h.ve to be ronov d permanently from the community, because of the type of their -isease, an., the practlc 1 psychia¬ trist would best describe then es permanently In need of confinonent to a zont ; «l Institute they are a-soclal- doctor, you hrve Just used the worl °a-ooclal", do you near, by that lr. the psychiatrist's conception of tho word a-soclal? A. Yos, an', in connection with it I wont to point -t that tho a-soclal insane al^ht bo particularly n.^ressivo cs the disease _oo9 on and particularly a6 the typo or. development of the disease shows Itself, r.nd that he can b- considered an a-soclal because of hie r ressiveness. doctor, ni_.ht I ash you to perhaps lllustraty by ueans of two or three brief ex.-moles to this Tribunal, Just ‘ r/ - £ - ch 0*608 are, such cases of Incurably Insane people, - mo.r, v;ould you offer a descriptive example of such * people? «. I don't want to quote tho6v cases of serious idiocy who are bodily re-uced w.-.o cannot be spoken to th whom one cannot make cor.t ct, th t fall lr.t^ a co:;ui, who ere anxious to destroy are ohyslcally rjressivo :r *'- w - :o "ued fe^dir._ by hand and who can r.o lon_er cops Court 1 Xay 9-#-5-4-HD-Cook-Frank. with the normal requirements of their body, who are dirty, not only dirty with dirt, and urine, but who would 6mear "boat each excretions, have no fueling pain and who no longer dlmonstrate even simple emotions. I only want to deal with th ; final 6to c es of schizophrenia, tr.at is, with human beln.s who commit senseless aotlons, senseless not only towards their fellow humans, but who actually beoome a-soclol bc.caus< they may kill members of the medical staff. I myself h ve exnerienced four ci-oes when the most valuable numbers of the staff became the victims of such Insane patients. Many fell ill, and many at the age of forty r forty-five, became useless and old, let me talk about those who lnfllotcd upon themselves serious damages, who removed their testicles and tore them out, patients who .amaged their mouths, not because they wanted to oonmlt suicide but oimply because they did not understand their own actions, patients who nalonod themselves in the moat serious manner, I think that ou e ht to be enough. DR. FROSSCKKaK: Mr. President, in this connection I want to submit from my document book the appendix No. 3, I be-, your pardon, it is appendix 2 , appendix 2 , and I am referring to document No. 45 on pages 36 to 44, which Is an edition of the periodical "Life," THE PRESIDENT: Ve don't have that oopendix to your document book. DR. FROESCHMaH: I h-ve submitted it Mr. President, it follows Brack tie. 2, and it is at lecst a fortnight ?feo that I did so. MR. HaRDY: The Pros, cation does not hrvo a copy of that. Your Honor. However, it is apparently n magazine which Ives conditions in the US mental hospitals. United States, and thi3 evidence will come under the category of that Court 1 May 9-M- 5- 5-HD-Cook-Fr e nk. evidence with the Tribunal has ruled will not oooo up and will not 00 offered In evidence until c later date. DR. FR0E8CHKaH: Mr. President, I was eioin a to ask the witness, Dr. Pfannmueller, Just one question, namely, whether such types os rre depleted in this periodical by means of pnoto. raphs, whether they are the types which he hss Just talked ab^ut. THE PftEoIDSKT: It Is a matter of common knowledge that suoh types exist all over the world, such types, cf defective mental exist everywhere end the Tribunal will take Judicial notice that such types ~r t found everywhere. DR. FROESCHMnNX: In any case, Me*. Pr sident, I wasn't trying to moke the Impression, if I have, of only doscrlb- ln the oo.n..ltlon of Insane potlonto In jtcerlon. THE PRE3IDEDIT: Wo understand that counsel. DR. FROESCK/aNK: There was e Gorman book I w?s goin^ tv submit to the Tribunal which oontalne the soay typo of jlcturoe. May I then, Mr. President, submit the document Mo. 45, os Exhibit Ho. 3, siay I submit that to the r.l,,h Tribunal as my next exhibit? THE PRESIDENT: Wo do r.ot nrvo the document book. MR. HkRDY: I want to object to the submission of this document until such time ns I have time to pursue the .'voument. I haven*t seen the document and the Prosocutlon hnan't boon presented with the document defense counsel refers to. DR. FROESCHMaKK: In that case I will put that beck* ntil the document book Is ready. THE PRESIDENT: We will recess for tnlrty minutes and visibly durin.- that time counsel can examine the document 7301 9 Kay 47-y>-S'j C-8-l-hal oy (Int., Von Schocn) Court I THZ KaESHaL: The Tribunal is again in session. 2.5. HaEDY: May it please, Tour Honor, this 3rcck oxhioit which is Docunont Vo. 145 is contained in Liffi iiegazine of 6 Key 1946 edition; it narrates tho bedlaa of 1946; tho titlo is "Koot U. S. kontul Hospitals are • ohaso and a Disgrace." I want to pass tho exhibit up to the tribunal for their perusal cuch as the Prosecu¬ tion doa:s it ic-atorial. 2 to conditions in tho Insane hospitals of the United Statco aro not at issuo hore. The quostion whother or not thu iruutos shown therein as fit subjects for euthanuoia. It does not sea: tho Prosecution fails to soo tho relevancy of tho docucont. SR. PHOiSCnf.aiC;: Hr. President, I stato oxprosnly that tho text to thoso pictures was in no way intondod by uo as ovidonco in tho caso of Viktor drock. I linit uysolf oxcluoivoly to tho quostlon to tho witness whether such types us pictured, tharo uro tho typos of incurably lr.s«no porsons, and I ulso liuit uysolf to tho question of whothor the pr.otcgraphs in this Goman voct book of psyehioly by Ploussnor, on pugo 4C5, following uro also such types. Tho bool; it- solf bus boon glvon uo by a third purty and I oannot offor it in ovi¬ donco, but I bolievo that «n inspection of thoso photographs would bo of lntorost to tho Tribunal and would bo useful for tho cxuuinution ef tho witness as to whothor thoso aro typos of incurably insuuo porsons. hH. HaHDY: kith referenco to this book containing tho co pictures, Y'ur Honor, bus stated tho Tribunal will toko Judicial mtico of the conditions -f ouch poiplc -e existing all over tho k:rld, henco I don't see tno necessity of sh'/wing thoso pictures to the witness. . - * Ta3 PHaSIDirrs Tho Tribunal takos Judicial Sotico f the f_ct that all :vcr tho k rid, in every country, civilizod or uncivilized, there uro insane >ooplo, incuraoly insane oocplc of w.ri me degrees, -uny who h_vo a: Mentality at all, us described by the witness, and tho Tribunal is f the 5pini:n that uduittiog exhibits containing pictures sh'.wing such people is submitting a natter :i no probative 7302 9 ay h7-"-FjC-S-2-,'aloy (Ir.t., Von Schoen) Court I value before the Tribunal, an-* ad s nothin to tte Ju 'ic3l Notice which tte Tribunal will take of such situations. Counsel nay farther ir.torro- ate tha witness as to what class of arsons he !©en3 subjects for euthanasia, if the witness does teen any person n proper subject for euthanasia. That is a ifforont natter, but insofar as counsol showing pictures and Ascriptions of incurably an.! hopolessly insane people tho Tribunal takes Ju licial totieo t 'at thore are such people everywhere. Tho objection to the acMssion of those exhibits is sustained. D3. FSOESCKl.UNt In view of this ruling nay I at least show this book for th*ir notice? THE PRESIDENTi Yos, counsol my exhibit the book to tho Tribunal, Q Witness, You have hoar.* tho statement of tho Tribunal iust now. Later when I spook of euthanasia of incurably insano por3ons I shall cone to this question. Now I shall continue in nay case, and I ask you lid your institution in S elfin:: have a chil Iron's ward? A Yos. q How woro those children tree to'.? A Tho children's ward, tho so-called children's houso I took ovor fron ny Predecessor under the toctor who always was in charro of this house, and tho chil ! ron wore all without any distinction as to the nature or course of their liseaso, or their social position wore all traatoi in the soj-w way, were all ;;iven tho sane ration, tho sono that aocordin-: to ro ulationa existed in such institutions. 7303 9 Hay-iS-Kl-9-l-Cook (Ir.t. Yon Scoot.) Court Ho. I. A The children hcd especi a lly good food even during tho war. They hod vholo a ilk, hot cereal, narralodo, odditional fruit rations and oosily digestible childrens * food and tiut food proscribed by childrens* doctors, =ilk lit nil foms. Tlw children wore t roe tod just as they always are elsewhere. Cl Witness, what is roar.t by children with serious lioredit- nry and genital diseases? A This r^ans children who are conpletoly incapable of taking a placo in huaan society, who are nar.tally or ns a result of disccso, a severe infection, for example, a brain disease in their early youth, who are so ill that any social core of tho child outside of n special¬ ist ir. an institute is quite ixtpocciblo. That those ohildren hr.vo a life a ran which is limited, .and any I add rone thing olso, this includes serious physic 1 deformities, for oStaple, tho lack of iwnbors. I had ono child who had no arms and logo, only just tho trunk, and dofomi- tios rrhoro it is hardly possible to feed t!io child; whox*o tho children havo to bo fed .artificially. I ..ad a child with an opor. hoart, and a dofomity of tho bonos so ti-at tho brain is exposed, .and spinal de¬ formities th paral^-sis as a result of congenital blindnoeo and deaf .and dunbnoss, other serious defects, nicrocophil and . aero cophals. Q Plo.asc speak a littlo noro slowly, witness. A liicrocophals, nacrocophnls, and I believe that is about onough and. idiots, coaploto idiots. Q Now, doctor, havv these children wheo you havo just dec- crib-d so vividly, wore they troatod in any other way than children who, so to spook as a layman, vc lose severs mental diseases and who *^ro taken into your institution? A !«o. Q Doctor, I cay point out to you that tho irocccution has submitted a document. This is No. 863, Exhibit Ho. 333, in tho German iece.-x-rx cok Hi, part I, pa e , and La the English document book ih, p. 5 22 . This document contains tbo toc .irory of a certain Ludwig 73JL 9 Hay-%:-!2~9-2-Cook (Lit. Von Schon) Court No. I. lehnor, who in the fall of 1939 was -it your institute for n visit .-.a a nodical student. Non I show you fron ay document book, I show you this docuraant and I ask you first to cogent on his statement that you, doctor, and it could only''have boon you according to the description which to cakes of tto person, that you, doctor, on this to'ir took such a poor child out of the bed and showed the child around like an onisial as it wore, and said: r .'e lot those children starve to death. This is cuch sispler. Iboplo aborrd '.'ill net be able to object if wo starvo then this way." I have already iivon you a copy of that docu¬ ment. You have this? A Yos. Q How, ploaso doctor, co,: ont on this docurtnt No. 0f>3* A nbon I ruad tto document I was not only astonished at tho incrodtblo contents, but horrified. First of all lecture tours with dononstrations in tv institute were conducted in exactly tho sn.jo way as ray predecessor conducted thon. Tho purposo of those tours was to infona tho public about tho mcosrity of preventing various dlsonsos, cental and norvo diseases, and tho niafortuno v.hich falls upon humnity when such children arc born, and to inferr. and instruct tho people about this nisfortune. First, I nay s~” ono thing, an adnierion ticket, I never issued in qy wholo lifw, and I naver saw ono. That is an in¬ vention. Second, the tour which Vr. Lohnor c.xaks about, ho is appar¬ ently a teacher, not a *>-dical student -recording to the docunant, this is sup.osod to have be.n in the fall of 1939. I never spoke about uthanasia at -all. Euthanasia was a top secret natter. Do sides in tho fall of 1939 as far as I knew euthanasia had not been started and • nothin was done to children. T t-lkcd about hereditary diseases, and for example I showed feeble nindednosr was horeditary and I showed coa¬ litions axxi I told tto people how important it is to pass a law like tho hereditary health law to carry it out thoroughly and op:hly. If one says, and I must go into individual things here - if he says I ter. a poor child out of its bed with ny fat hands, I would say in ay ? -2-Coolc (Int. Von Schor.) >art So. I. life I never had fat hands. I certainly n_v_r grinned et such a thing. I never laughed. I r-.s always fully aware of hem sorious the uattor wee. I never pulled a child out of- its cod. The child was quietly picked up by the nurse according to the condition it wes in, nnd hold in her lands and in her ans and shorn to the people who wore present. The priest Kens Jacob froi Baden, n writer who is fairous for his des¬ cription or his Swiss tour, a Iandtr.g delegate, a Catholic prioat, des¬ cribed such children after going to an insane asylum in Baden, in one of nio Swiss tours, end said - mid I never said that he bulievod that these children — I can't rcxabcr his exact words, - but this about what ho said: Hobody know hew they were civated, whether they were tho work of a d-vUish invention. I never s-id th~t. I only pointed out the horror of this condition and tlio accoarity for relieving theso poor crj'tuxvs awl their relatives of pain and the child of suffering, ana by passing tho hereditary health law as tho greatest good given to tho Nation. Q Doctor, Just oinuto. ay X point out so nothing to you at this pcix.t. Tou arc sup^om-d to havv said that those eventuros, manning those children, of couro-, represent for no as e national socialist viroly burdens for our nation'l health, please oxplain that? A I can cay ovor. if this child wac to be charged frpn tho point of vice of outhonasia, I rover iookod at this child fron tlx point of view of national socialise. 2ut,*masia and tho affairs of the Roioh Con -ittoe in cy opinion had nothing to do .ith national socialism. It is like tho lav: for tho prove .tier. cf die aces of progeny '.nd tho Sar- riago Laws, which are laws, lo;*a measures, which happonod to ariso under tfco National socialist r.£i-x. Tho cause, however, r^v. back for centuries. Gcntleaca, regarding such a child starving to death was not mentioned at all, for nothing - s beln^ done at all in the children's ho'Ufc at this cric-d. I r.jcct such a thin*. These aro prob-biy tho rubsequmt ir.te rpn. tat ions of an opponent. Court Sj. 1 5 Hay »7-.-lG-i-ErX-Oel lcgher (Vos Schoea) q. Doctor, vhet did the Reich Ministry — I shall rcocet — what did the Eeich Ministry of the Interior do, in fact, 'diet reflations did it issue cor.cerr.iw; these children that you have spoken of, these cretins and deforced children, in 1939? A. In 1939 no reflations were issued concerning these childron. I know nothing about it and w uedittricien knows nothing about it either. q. Then when did you loam of such regulations? A. I should like to soy thrt the cate of the establishment of tho Belch Co;v.ittoc Station for handling and dealing with deforned children, I don't know exactly the oroper tern now, I cannit romtnbcr the dote, but I alsays thought it was in 19*1, tut it is not entirely l-.possiblo thst it night have been in the late Sumner or Fall of 19*0. I cannot say exactly today. Sut nay I contim-o end tell you ho« it hepoenod. First, I van celled to tho Baverirn Ministry of tho Intorlor, tho Hoplth Department; there v*ro sonc gentlemen there from Berlin. I ronenber Dr. Venilcr, end the establishment of tho Reich Coivittuo Station in Bavaria was discussed. So fer as I can rocell, thi head >f tho chil¬ dren's clinic in Munich present, end I believe this station ’-eo to oe set up in the children's clinic, bccauso of tho necessity of ^crat¬ ing on those defamed children’freouontly. If I roaenbor corroctly, that is, olceso, I cm toll you only -diet I Just haooen to rer.erbor, this vrs expltinod because of thi leek of soace anc' lr.ek of personnel, that this Reich Craittoo Station could not be set up there, and thon the conclusion vos reached that the Eeich Connittco Station vac to bo set up in ay institution, beceuso th.ero wco a children's house there, end bccr.usu there vere a number of ceces who were idiots, cases of chil¬ dren psychiatry, deformity, neurological ctseB, and, I believe it was tho Deputy President of the District Association who vac to have eco¬ nomic 8uptrvi6i;n in my institute, who put the children's house at dic- posal, end I wes told to taka over the Eeich Committee Stption. I asked the- for a dec:or to take charge of this station rnd he- vas given to me 7307 Covrt So. 1 9 '.lay 47-H-10-2-IrR-0aileghfcr (Von Schoen) to take care of the children's clinic. IE. JHQESCKKAIE: Kr. President, nay 2 e.sk whether Suoplenent 3 of cy document took is in the hands of the President as yet. I handed this Sucplcnent 3 in, ns I hevealroady said, only a fov days ago, tecausc I had just Obtained this final docunent. If that is not the case, then I shall co=c back to this supplement later. T>_E PESSIULFT: Vo hrve only the docunent books ono end two. 3Y SR. TaGLSC&tASHl Q, Doctor, you were saying that in 19-*0, you think, er.d in the beginning you said '41, you learned that the Pcich Cor.r-lttoc to deal with such people existed, is that true? A. Yes. q. It vas only at that tine that y .u learned-that the general diroctivos vere finally issued by the Reich Kinlstry of the Intorlor rt Seriin? A. Yes, I learned of that first at the tine. ER. FRCfcSCEUffiS: bince the Tribunal dooe not yot have this Bupolo- •ontrry docunent took, I shall n t now wish to ureecnt the docunent. ZhL PriSIDilT: Vo have Just received what is entitled "Suooloncnt I of the Brack Docunent Book". Is that the suooleaont to >*hlch you rofor? IE. JRCE8GEMAO: Xc, Hr. President, I an now sneaking of Suoole- jont 3. IS PRhSIIhSI: Sov v« have Suppleaent 2. hr.. HAB2Y: Your Honor, I have Docunent Book So. 1, which takes ne to Document Ho. 25, end I have Document Book So. 2, which takes no to P-cunent So. 40. Then I h; vc the eurplc=«nt which is m ereertt of the Life Mrgezine, that is Docunent So. i6. Other than that I have no other docunent. TS PSiSIDaHI: Supplement 1 contains the documents Nos. 41 to 44 inclusive. «R. EAST:: I don't have that, "our Honor. 73 OG LJ surt So. 1 May i?-4i-lG-3-R=fc-G«tlUghcr (Von Schoen) THi PrISIDiST: Copy must be available bc-cause it was Just handed to us. D?.. JECESCAASS: Kr. President. I shall not go into this Suople- nent 3 et this point in order to avoid delaying the Court. But in the course of the examination of the defendant Brack I shall cone back to this document. Hovever. I say tell you, Doctor, that the nrosecution in the course of the trial has subsitted a document vith a number 1696-PS, exhibit Bo. 367, vhich is in the ingljth document Book 14 - you vill fini that in 14. I vill give you the exact page. In the Gercan Document nook it la page 128. I shall find the cage in the inr-lish Document Book. This document, Kr. President, vas submitted only in Dart by the nrosecu- tion. I got a photostatic copy of the original document from tho Secre¬ tary General; I see from it that the ohotostatic cony has other Dagos vhich tho Drosecution did not submit and. because these pages vere not submitted, I have, by vny of precaution, included thceo pages no a document exhibit in Documont Book 3. Pages which vere not submitted contain a reforcnco to the minister ini decree of the Reich Ministry of the Interior on 18 'higust 1929. Theycontain first of all an information for tho official doctor shoving that such severely deforced chlldron can be sent to a soecinl asylum; second, that every attenot vill bo mado there to treat those children vith oil modern means of therapy, and, thirdly, that this cay be done only vith the oDprovnl of tho parents. BY Da. JRCSSCEMASS: Q. Doctor, nov I vill ask you, do you knov of such instructions of the Reich Ministry of the Interior, such instructions as I have Just described to the Tribunal. A. aubscouently. after tho Reich Committee Station in the chil¬ dren's house vas created in the Rgelfing-Kaar cental Institution. I learned of these directives, vhich ~ere not sent to no as head of the institution, vhich I did not knov about, because I w*s not e government doctor, and I had not been informed that there vas any obligation te 7305 Court So. 1 5 Xay 47-K-lC-4-hBX-Gallagker (Von Schoen) reoort such a case. I don't knoy vhy, because I had children vho fell under the provisions of this lav; but nov I refer to a docuaer.t vhich I have obtained froa the defense counsel, and I have noted it down hero. It is in Volume 14,2, psees-e8-90, HO-1138/349. Q, That is aO-lliJfi, inhibit So. 349 in the German document booh 14, voluae 2, page E6, end I shall find out later vhat the page of the hnglish document book is. It is peg* 151 in the Lnglish document book, 161 . «o on ploaso, vitness. A. Gentlemen, I think this is an important document. On 1 Juno 1944 I had transferred a child vhich from a psychiatric and pediatric noint of view foil under the obligations to report on 1 June 1940 to the Institute Schoenbrunn for highly idiotic children, nerr Munich, for care. Then I vac told froc Berlin that I --an to give the rooort on this child, on tho child's condition. Cn 1 June 1940 there could not hove boon ary Belch Connittoo Station, or institution, boceuso I sent this child to Schoonbrunn. In the sc-ond place I obviously had no idea when I trans¬ ferred this child that I hnd to report it. because I sent it to a nontal institution vithout reporting it, and I vrs asked to got an opinion on this child. Anccrently this child eanc undor the provisions of tho lov at Schoonbrunn when this institution vis registered, and because it vaa a child, the registration fora vas forwarded to tho . corresponding Belch agency. That is ay assumption. Of course, I don't knov that froa ay own knowledge. 7310 CO-'-Tt I 9 Hay-rf - 11-1 - LJC- - Karrcw (Von Schon) T2E ;*.-3SIDE!t?t Counsel, tho witness is not on trial before this Tribunal and I fail to see tho relevancy of such of this testimony in regard to the case against the defendant Brack. The witness has hoen explaining certain documents which apparently reflect on hir., but ho is not on trial here. DR. FROESCHMnNNt Hr. President, I singled out this case only becauao in tha examination of Brack I shall have to deal with this document aa on oxap'e of the ..rosecution's evidence because the pros¬ ecution with t'neso documents, including this particular document, intended to prove that all the things in ^.ich *rack was concerned which tvro stated in these documents, wore against humanity and are war crimes. ^ureforo, rinco this witness can give information about thoso docir.onts, I have aekod him about them. I rcall.o that I must avoid everything thrt right be a personal defense of tho witnsss. I have nothing to do with that, i an loraly coancnting on tneao docu¬ ments in tr.e courso of ry dofonso against Count II of tho indictnont. TPE rt-i5IDENT: Counsol r.ay procood, Bf DR. FdtaSCHJUHMs Q. Doctor, wo'11 go on n<*( and ccr.e to tho questionnaires, very generally, wifich woro iniroducod under tho Reich Committee. Unfor¬ tunately, we do net have such i questionnaire in the documents. Can you rcnu.liur tho contents cf those questionnaires of tho Reich Conmit- teo? A. ius, I rlli toll you overythins th t I can romor'-ur. First, the porsonal data -..ora required cf the child, than tho horiditnxy situation. Then it was askod, as far as I cj renenbor, r.bovt diffi- m cultias at birth. w. ho don't ncjd to hoar all tneso details. Just a general outline. I I understand -ou correctly, th-_ c-us«.s rare askod about? A. Tos, and than tfcw caus.s cf the condition of the child has ho be desc- ; bud very carefully and it finally :isked whether any ensures 7311 Court I 9 Hay-rl - 11-2 - LJ3 Kcrros (Von Schon) had boon token — any therapy ag'.inst the disease — and than, as far a? I can raaecbor, it was asked vfaat the child's life expectancy was ir.d whether too child cculd bo oxpectud tale any useful placo in society. Scr-othing like to t. Q. These questionnaires. Doctor, rare l_tjr s-nt fro: Berlin to tnc .iovorment doctors with instructions th-t when such births occurred tho questionnaires were to bo filled out and sent back to Berlin? A« f-3. 3. If 1 speak of lerlir., I don't know *tetn-r you and I under¬ stand tho so.-o thing. You roro talkinj about Berlin o-feru. what did you x>cn by that? a. hhon - said Berlin I was talking about the Reich Co-vdttco. That's t o only agency T had anything to do with th-rc, and to *oru- ploto ny answor to too Last quosticn I can s.iy th. t the questionnaire was published in sozo ninistoriel journal or so>ro l;w Journal. It was printed there I believe by the Wien /iniatry of the Interior. I lenrnod of that only later when tho Reich Co- ittou Station ulTe dy existed in my instituto. I think clerk told o so. a, any rate, tho duty of midwivos to roport and doctors, -to., was mentioned. Q. Another question. In too proceedings b-foru tho Reich Co vit- too there roro oxoorto working? a. Yes, I L_ rr.cd of tost later. «. You know nothing of it at too tine? A. No, I kn w nothin? f it at tho too. I knew noti.ing about the nothod. W. And toon, I assrr-j, you knar, nothing about who decided that a child was to bo suit to such a specialized clinic? a. No, I know nothing about that. Q. Doctor, I core now to a qu-sticr. which, under Gumon Law, w*uld give you the rigat tc refuse an msuar. ; -r. President, I should like to ask you to instruct the witness t .at, in the c-asu qu-s ions daich -i at expose hip. to prosecution, 7312 Ccurfc I 9 Har-. - 11-3 - L-JG - KarrciKVon Schon) ha ir-y r_iuso to answer. T>3 .-^SISBOTt Is tho witness new under Indictment or charges/ D... FROBSCH&F : Hot that I knew ef. .HE ./IT1SSS: Ho, L-h ve received no indictments. I h.vc merely been interrogated. THE FPESIDEyr: Tho witness is htnover under restraint. DR. FRCBSCmFN: Yes, Hr. President. T E tRESHJBfT: Tloll, the witiK.se is instructed that, if in his Judgnont, to answer any question propounded tohi- would t-nd to in- crindnato hii. or subject hiei to indictment, h- has the right to refuse to enswor tho question. BY D3. FROSSCJTAHNs Q. Did you understand th-.t? You haw, the right, if you are asked a question nhich rtLfcht involve >ou yourself in a trial, to any, "I refuse to anarnoT*. You any .answer it is you wish. lieu, I roV you — when, Lat.r, ir your institute a Reich Corwdttoo Station s s.,t up, .: ■) defer cd children sunt tc this Reich Coramlttou Station? a, Would you ple”ao repo .t th t? Is it true th-.t la tor — 19lil or 19L2, I'll leave th .t ti«no open — in tho provincial : ant el station, th^re wis a so-cal led Reich Co ;,iittce Station for these children? a. Yes. 4. Who told you abort th t? «• T t was tr.o result of a r’isejssion ir. unich in the i inis try. i. ”ot/, did y u recoivo authorization fro*: any source to tr«_.at these children according to -.odvrn Kthods of therapy and, if the treatment was cc pletoly hopeless, t shorten the life of these child re:i? a, Yes, that as in tho letter cf authorisation. 1. Fro ho i did thi3 latter coic? «s far as 1 reorder, fro the' Reich Co—ittec Court I 9 itay_K - n-ii - LJG - Sorrow (Von Sohon) 2 . And tho Belch c OssJ.tfcee was hoidcd by a. (Interrupting) I must toll you 1 don't knowfrois ray own knowl¬ edge. Q. Then you say th*t you received authorization? It was in writing? A. TeS, it was in writing, -uihorizatiens for every individual case. Q. y ou received soparato authorizations for each case; th.t these deforced children - idiots, etc. - wore to be treated by the modern nothods of ttorapy and if thoso c sos rare hopeless ttien the life should be shortenod? Is that true? a. .toll, it didn't any that tho children's lives should bo ohort- onod. K. U.DX: a; it plcaso Tour Honors, I object to thuso lording questions on t rfc of the dofor.se c nsol. It scobs to rae that the witness is a prychiatrist, ho is tho chief of a Rental institution, and that ho is foci liar w 5 th tfi outhanasia program and is fully capablo of ring tho questions without being led in this manner. DR. F.lOaSCH.-WW: * r. Irasidcr.t, I . not aware of h ving askod any loading qu*-tions. TH2 hOSIDB’-Tt Counsel nay procaod, bi dr. yp. oisck^Mi 3. Doctor, the >ast ^uu cion in this connection. Do you know who, in oorlin, reached these decisions th .t a child wr-s to bo assigned t.o the Reich Caaritbee Station? u. I loaned I vor u :.t » e- questionnaires on children which were- recei ved wero axaidnod and the tdical opinion was ...rprosst-d on tho i. who decided, I don't know. Q. '‘non, I shall closo this chapter about too Reich Conaittou for Children witli Severe -eriditary Disoos-s md I cor„ to tho socord pre- ceduro: &;tlianasia f the lac.- / bly inr uae. ■ 9 2-12-l-:Moy (Int. Yon Sc boon) Court ;«3. I. Q I should like to “sk you first to explain to tho Tribunal your fundamental attitude on tho question of euthanasia? A Ccntlcj^nt, I have a positiv. attitude toward the idea of o':than*.'ia. I an .an advocate cf tho subject of euthanasia. T know the literature on Iho sublet. I h'vo : ivon considerable thought to the problem of outkanasis. I ras interested in it already as a nodical stud.rt. ..r.on -y father was dyinfc, ho suflured severe eurcnic attacks repontjd .,v_ry far rinates, a terrible sight, not only for .yaclf but for :iy 4 ioor father. Tho doctor finally shortened ay f-th-r'a lifo. Later I b-cnoe an advecato of it rs a practicing psychiatrist, nftur a sight of t'.io .aisery ir. tho rental it.otitufio.is and th. distress of tho mothers and fathjre of thoso chiidron. That is v.hy I looked at euthanasia positively. And I put ysolf .at tho disposal of tho Reich Work Union whon I *at> < llod upon. I know tto opinion of important Q-r;an rofunsers and their attitudo upon cuthrnasia, nd 1 .xrsonally and seriously accepted tho idea. Cl Doctor, is it true that f ~ru are two kinds of euthanasia up to 1539, rvr.oly, aid in dying, that is relieving th. pain cr fail¬ ure to ••d.alnistor stimulants, and aid ;o dio, that is riving drugs if if n-s Curt in that duath would *ccur vtry shortly, and the tcrriblo death sur’ lu sucl *r ycu haj just d. scribed in the cr.so of your fr.thor could be shortened? A Y« s, this distinction \s -ado. I once t Heed of n major and a minor euthanasia, tn_ ainor euthanasia thj simpler aid in dying and tho -.'.lor cut ha male, hich ;r ii.tanded for individualc incapablo of living, such aa Krttsclxer and H-r.s Jacob and others have advocated. Q Doctor, what was do:uj in 1939, if I judge the r.tt r correctly, is consider>fcly different fro: the typo cf outharr.sla curt- omt y up t fiir.t tine, that is tc shorten tho lives of tit incurably insane who mi^ht live for yerrs cr decad-s possibly in this p*inful • condition in as painless * way as possible, is that true? A That is true only insofar tncsu patients, of course. 9 lay-: -2-12-2-' iloy (Int. Von Seboen) Court Ko. I. were not in coiincnt danger of death ~ixi wore included in tho drive of the Reich burking Union, but even th_so cases could not ir. any ease be expected to live very long. Sobody can .r^dict that, of course, but I wrote a paper once on the lifu s.vn of incurably insane people and I proved ay statistics that, outside of institutions theso cases have a shortened life span. This work ins iven -reat attention in Dutch nodical circles, and I got -a g-od criticisn in a Dutch p:;xr which was sent to ::o by a Dutch doctor. Q iiow, doctor, how did it cone about that you worked in tho so-called euthanasia progr-e:, in tho general consideration of tho procedure within the euthanasia program? A Ono day, I re afraid I don’t know the tine oxactly, I thought it v-a in 19U0, but I can't duny tho possibility that it night have been in tho o-rly winter or late f11 rf 1939, I received a re¬ gistered lottcr fron tho Chancellory of the Fuuhrur with r. requsst to report in Berlin at the Chancellory of th/ Fuehrer for a conference, at a certain meeting. Q "oil, now lot .« interrupt you; do you knew whether tho invitation itself came fron the Grnceliory cf the Fuehrer or fron tho Raich Kinistry -f tfw Interior in the of ice of tho ChancoUory of tho Fuehrer? A As far as I rcc-11 tta onvolopo had a stamp on it "Chan¬ ce iloiy .'f tho Fuehrer", and as far as I roneuber it was signed "Bouhlor." Q That will be enough, hitnoss, now wh“t was tho subject of the discussion at this, oaoting? A As far as I c-n r. onbor this mooting, which ms u*Vv.ry long ti:\j a£,o, ay iepressien w.-s that tho separation of the mental in¬ stitutions into curable cases and incurable cases. Th-t was ay in¬ press ic® at this corXv.rer.co. The transfer rX Certain paticr.tr, to provincial institutions, was discussed. • thought that certain serious ca • r vh: could nrX co tre ted psychiatrical!? were to be transferred 7316 9 * T- 3-12-3- ' -Icy (Ir.t. Ton ^h»n) C x?rt Ho. I. to special institutions. Q ..'-s tho word "euthanasia" used? A As fir os I can ren-. b^r the word "euthanasia" was r.ot used. Q ’..'itiKss, after this coating passed, a fow we~ks later, oven longer, w^rc you asked to work as an export in a procedure judging those insane people? A Yea, I was ir. Berlin repeatedly. I took card of tho questicn-iairos cf the p .tier.ts in ay institute on whoa questionnaires were drawn up, and then I wrs called into a Ducting in Berlin r.1toro as far as 1 re - ber I think there r.r- a a.* professors tix.ro too, but in any ca.co ttere wore psychiatrists -nd doctors. I considered that a looting of oxi»rt Judjes, and w- had a discussion "nd wurc civon dir-otiv^s on Judging thu question.*.'.irer, and I believe this v;ac be¬ forehand that I was asked to w rk as an ox.vrt Judge. Q r.'ha was in chatgo cf those conferences, w r that loohlcr or Lindan? A Ho, I think Union was than.. I think Dr. Brack was there, but I can't say for certain. I don't believo Soohler was at this conference, naybe only temporarily, I can't say for curt-in. q Xoifc what did you do as .an oxpert Judge? A I received an appointment, a letter fron tho Reich Inistry of tho Interior. I can't say exactly whothcr it was sip.rod by Lindon, but I received r. letter in the r.-.xj f tho Reich 7/ork Union, and I don't knir ho»; it read, but in any c-so in thu progr n tf tho Hcich \ork 'hion I vac asked to work as -n ox.crt Judge, and 1 considered it riy duty to sj, bee mse I raa in f v r f euthanasia. q Krr, this work consisted *f passing Judgnont on these questionnaires, is that rif-,ht? A Yes, photest.atic copies f thoia. DR. FP.CESCHMAN.V: lif t, t'ne&j quosti -nr.aircr, ’tr. Ir«.sider.t, -re ceiitai:v;i in the German D cnynt ~ .k 110. >25, Exhibit 35>i, in thu 7337 o V) 2-12-U-tiloy (Int. V;r Schocn) :urt So. I. Gsraan >-curv;nt Book Hi, part 2 , tr -50 133. In the English Document Book, I shall give you tha page nuubor this rXternoon. Q Doctor, do you r^x. ber the contents of these question¬ naires or shall I show you th- docirxr.t? A 1 would appreciate it if you would give m, the. document. THE HESIDEWTs Before going into this natter of the dccu^nt book, the Tribunal will bo in rec-sc until 1:1*5 this afternoon. (Thereupon the noon recces rs taken.) /f«7 9 UTjr-A-IB-lJi-l-Ccok (Int. Rorslor) Court Ho# I. AFTsmax)’; session (The Tribun-1 reconvened at 13‘:5 hours, 9 !?-iy 19U7.) TJ2 ARSHAL: Persons in th- C ;urt rocc will please find their seats, T!u Tritur.-l is again in session. T.'J. iRLSIDErff: Counsel any proceed. DR. JPAWPOELIZP. - Ilcsurcd D7RECT SX.V IH.YTICK BY DR. FRCESCH :iNK: (Cour.s.l for Vilrtor Brack) Q Witnoss, I rer-ind y.u that you nro still under ".nth. Hr. iToaidont. I any repent what I hnvo f-1 led to note? this norning, noaoly, docw*nt 1133, Exhibit 3l;9 is in English docu- nont volume* 1L, pago lSl, 1696 K> Exhibit 3l<7 is to bo found in English docununt book Ik, pngo 209. Witness, this nomine wo stop;*od discussing tho quest¬ ion whot’wr you still ronjefcorod the quca -lc naairo which *rs usod dur- in tho outhonosia procedure in thi case of incurnblo Rental p-tionts. And first I should liko to interpolate a quoation. You were m ox- pi rt, na .an export, did you over : ivo nay opinion r.bout questionnaires which had to bo filled out about tho patients of your instituto? A ho. •1 Vihy did that r, >t happen? A Docvjse we received, directives th-t wo could not qiva such x.-ort :pinions .an quosti n-. airco rhich cava undor >ur own in¬ stitute._ c*-' - - Q to what principles did ycu oxerciSu y ur 1 expert jfeiitfens whon expertising these questionnaires? A I observed- the following principles when filling out tho questionnaire, whan filling out tho l~ft lower corner f that question- V / niirsfim Tho principles were told us in Berlin during th-.t exjxrt con- v * * fertneo which I have already ivntionod. .0 vurc told with regard t. 731? 9 Mny-A- S-ll:-2-Cock (Int. Rr aa lnr ) Court So* I. feeble nindedaow that it was divided into three forra, the light feeble ninded, tho nodluB feeble winded and ah. severe idiotic fern. '..bon charging feeble ninckdiKss, one has to tajeo into consideration tho dc- •;rec of tho intellect aid-tho personality involved. In tho cases of schizophrenia, the cause of tho illness, tho ntntal picture and tho corvditirn :f the patient, tho fair of schizophrenia, and noet import¬ ant, wo wore then concerned with a condition which has to bo considered • when giving an expert opinion, tho valuation tc bo attached to tho do- greo of daaogo to the personality of tho aan involved, and whon giving the prot.nosis of tho rind. In tho case cf organix psychosis and in this conrscticn I nay in particular nontion epilopsy and paralysis, and Just to mention too one has to bsurv^ in tint atago tho paralysis is and vhat kirxi of treatment has preceded that stage. Ono has tc observe whethor thoro is a refractory f.vjr.aay condition, vfcich is .a ccrviiticn which can no longer bo treatoti, a ccoplotoly final condition. Ono has tc tako into consideration whottor any such condition has resulted. In tho case of opllopsy cne has to find out vhothur tho personality of tho nan involved has changed in any way, whether he is subjoct to at¬ tacks, ot cetera. Psychosis rognrding ago has to bo rejected. Tho treatment in itself and tho c.aro in nn institute would have to bu con¬ sidered whoever giving a Judgnont .about tho case. Pooplo who wore injured as a result if war should not be exportizod positively ospoci.al ly in thieo c-scs whon tho danago as a result cf war is not oithor an organic connoction or any cthor conr.octicn with the Dental condition cf tho patient. At a later date the quosticn was discussod whuthor people who received damages as a result cf w>rk should not bo expert¬ ized positively. This quosti n was n.-t dc'lt with ccontoic-fly ac- c. rding tc groups, for instance house work, or paper work. In othor rr rds, it was not graded as tc light work, nodiun work or har.*y work and no nation was nadc about .agricultural work, it cetera, but this merely was ucod as a diagnostic psychiatric .aid in ardor tr evaluate tixj ability ,f the patient t- work within his environment. It was ox- 9 :iay-A-:e-lii-3-Cocic (Int. Rarcler) Court Ko. I. pressed that this questicn ms to bo considered in a very serious tray and the occupation of tho patient should have to be changed very favorably. Furtherscre, rwnticn was aado that tho oadical expert and especially tho previous exports who wore used would only have to donl with radical points. In no case wore thoy to touch upon other questions contained in the questionnaire, quostions concerning visits, ot cetera. S' 7321 :: -y 9 -- -3ZI-15 -1 -Ga 11 a^hor (Int. itaualor) Court I, Caso Ko. 1 4 Doctor, ccy I ask ycu to r.oko a 3nnll pause between your individual sentences, ••ill you please continuo? .. Th- Jaws who wore at the Institute frexi a aodio :1 point of viow wore to bo considered in the soac way as ny other .a-yon. iiacc should ccrJce no difference. Forui-n- ors woro not to fall under the question of jiving on -xport opinion, >>o were told th-t J-ws, us well as foroi ;n^rs, do not fc.ll -itbin the couoept of euthanasia, s it was cronnt her-. -Iso c decidin; factor for the export ;.;.S the way the questionnaire wr.s filled out, Jhun- A*-r no firr. dooi3ion could be erriv-d .t, r» h .d not tho ri*;ht to insert either u class nejor or dnor nt tho lower lofthund oorn-r, but wo oouid o-ll i oaso question¬ able, wo oouid add th t was done by either export, nt any rate, by co. Thoao woro sont on, tho case history, or else n person .1 ex r:in tien of the p tiont is necessary. -11 of thoso things woro actually observed. Thuro wea oven tho possibility to insert a detailed roiiork on the back of the luostionnaire about any natter which was left un¬ ci-..r, or ebout any invostixtion which 3till :u.y b- nocossury. I think those *.i-r«. tho brond outlines on thoso oints which I o..n r.ontion. Can you still ron-ubor, witness, who issued thoso directives? - These uirectiv-s nr- tho oor.3 equonoos of a talk cnonc the expert physicians who . rrtioip-.tod in this conf-ronoo, of experts. This was tho suaninj-up of this outird con- f-ronco. I think that I said that I don't know whether Boukl-r was there, but I think that ho nay h vo been ono of the people who were in the Praosidiun, but it was not of psychiatrists. . Doctor, by insertin’ in your answer th t stajteaont, you answered also mother question is to what category the H.v 9--.-Z2C-lS-2-Gnllajhor (Ir.t. Handler) Court I, Cd3C Ho. 1 p.rsons wore oliiiinated. Cor. you tell no why in spite of this exception, it vir.s sot down thr.t the questionnaire had to be filled out regard in.; foreigners? . .. questionnaire, I never sow ■ questionnaire about foreigners. v «hat exactly do you neon? Dootor, I should like to point out to you that a 3o-o_lied regulation shoot wuo attached .t. tie questionnaire? .. Ho, I never rocuivod that. 4 There see;is to be a littlo nisundorstanfiiai botwoon us. You arc richt that under the activity of the experts, which you just described, you only know cf the photostntic oopy of the questionnaire, perhaps in addition to the ca3o history. However, I new asking you about the filling out of the questionnr.ire, the fillin : out of the questionn¬ aire on tho ba3i3 of the previous questionnniro, which had been sunt to your cental Institution. You wore asked to fill out the questionnaire r.ooordin; to the cate ;orius which wero laid down in the previous shoot of which I an 3;e kin;,. Do you hwo Docun.nt SCO-825 before you? Th.it locu-^nt, you will find it La the Gurnan Docun~nt Voluno 14, pa jo lee. I shall have th_t Doeuuont do ok handed to you. The doeuuont is liO-825, exhibit Ho. 358. I alroudy cited the papu in the -n lish Docunent dock Ho. 216, Document Bock Ho. 14, port II. would y>u please look at this shoot, I think it was on jrocn paper? .. I never received thr.t, never did. «. Didn't you? .. No, I never did. I never even saw it. I would h :ve rc- -xibarcd thr.t. I r: sure T would have rononborod if thero e.3 sonsthina like that thero on ~reon paper. However, I never received it. 7323 May 9-f--SiC-15-3-Gallnqhor (Int. Ilamlcr) Court I, Cr.so iJo. 1 - May I inter polcto a question, ./hen in tho Fall of 1939, or tho boginnin.; of '40, you wore asked to fill out questionnaires about certain p.-.ti^nts La your Lastitution, such a questionnairo would have to bo directed to your of fie-, is that right? .. Yes. Those questionnaires wurc sent to uo, yes. . I asked c.l3 0, perhaps you con not rooonbor it, that a regulation shoot was at too hod to that questionnaire, whether it was on greon or white neper really nnkos no differonco, and I think that in this rojulation 3hoet a oertr.iu oato;;ory of persons vr;s sot dov/n who w-ro to be considered when fillin'; out tho questionnaire. First, those persons who v/ero suffering of illnesses and could th-roforo not be used for any work at all; secondly, 3uch persons who for a nux.b-r of years, I think five years, . had been In an institution; thirdly, persons who frou a le;al point of view could be considered, and fourthly, foreigners. I want to ask you whether you knew for what r.aoono the filling out of «,UeStionn .ire was necessary f:r foroi/ners in3.kto of the st..tev:ont wiiich you Just ciedo to tho offoct thr.t foreigners did not cone under euthanasia. Do you undorstaxxl do? <• Yos. . If you don't know that, .lease don't nakv. any assouap- tion. Just s x/ so. I only received these directives rturin;; the export •> conference, and I can not renccbor having r-Cuiv-d pre¬ viously any re dilation 3heot attached to the questionnaire, sofar as I can rcr.ocbcr. I just received the questionnaire. . In other words, you can not tell us anything about " t. You can not say why qu-stionniire had to bo filled out about these foreigners? 9-«-3K-15-4-G-llQ.*2bc r (lot. xlr.---J.or) Court I, Cr.3c No. 1 « No, I con not sa7 that. t m that case I wish to conclude this chapter by Putting two questions. On tha basis of thoso questionn¬ aires, could a roliablo decision bo node about the fact that the cental illness of a patient concerned was still in effoot inourablc? „ It is ny point of view that a questionnaire is a sufficient basis for a psychiatrist expert in order to Ju j 3 o whether the case should bo transferred to one of the core institutions of which I have spoken about pre¬ viously, or not. In addition we ware told durln;;' this export conference that an opinion by throe pro-exports Should bo subject to a cession of top exports, and that this comission of top experts should onoo core mvo.tl-.-ato the ease concerned la case of anythin-; that „ss unclear. They should either visit the patient con¬ cerned personally, or else obtain its case history, -t on, rate they should do socethiu.; in order to obtain Clarification ru^.rdlnp the oases. The deal.ion would huva to bo undo at the end. The physician who is to accept the patient into the institute is to have another voto • . ..hat you just said is of considerable Interest, espoolally because the Prosecution has sutcittod Docunont 3865-PS, Exhibit 365, which is to bo found in the -man Do.unent Book 14. P~.se 156, and in the dnilish^ocun.nt Book nt pr.,o 230. This is a doouaont wherein feaalo witness points out that a oomission of physicians visited yoar. institute, who stayed there for a nueber of d ,ys, end there personally oxmlned a number of patients, -ft.r havin' studied th. case history. Do you thine th t this oomissioh of which this femle witness is spockinp .y J--.-5K-15-5-G_ll_:;h~r {Int. Hander) Court I, Case No. 1 was probably the- condssion of which you wore just spooking? .. I can not ror.enb-r that a conriission of physicians was at ziy Institution in the year of 1040. I assuno this concerns one physic! a who visited uy Institute. I only assure that. I think that this uust be the physician ur.o gather ad all the physicians of the entire personnel, and al3o the ones of the personnel who woro to doul with the qujstionneiros which woro to ,;o to Berlin. He wonted noro investigating of those questionnaires in order to arrive at soco decision. I think that was the c;.s... But I don’t think it wa3 c oomission. •* u Doctor, you told ac th_t tho questionnaire noant for you a sufficient ba3i3 for Jud ;ing the do ;rco of oontul illness. But I would rather gonorolizo this question, in view of wh.t the .resident hr.s told r.e this uorning, hd I would not like to Unit it to your or. 30 . Tho psychiatrist physicians who woro conorally intended to bo ox, -rtn, could they also rccanriend the dogroo of nontul illnoss on the basis of the questionnaire? • .. Jof r r.s I knew only the nosfc experienced expert physiciuns wore used for those expert jobs. ..non;: then, 3of .r as I know, there wore tLo' University Professors, tho Crdinnriuses, tho oxtra-Oruinariusos, and tho practical .sychir.trists. I don't know the norios of the exports in ciotiil, boonuso that u .a :;-v .r told to r.o. Frou later re. erts , however, for instance, fro:.. Hoidolborg, I know that only tho ;:pst officiant poo]lo woro selocted^ I know and I think that those poop lb had the 3 ur.o point of view as I had. However, I oi not sure about that. 7325 9 £nar—A-s :.J.~ l6-l-Karrc*T(Ir.t. Rrxsnier) Court I q. Doctor, ir. spits of your opinion that, on the basis of those questionnaires, the doly^o of tho rental illness could bo defcor- -ir.ed very cloarly, do you think that errors were possible? a . Doctor, there is a principle which soys "Errare huaamzn oat 11 - To err is hu-an. Even in the case of trials which are last- irg for decodes, trials of a purely lcenl nature, errors have beer, aide and errors will continue to be sado. This is exactly the situation as in the case cf an export. These experts were used in the sane wry as all the exports .aro used during any trial and it 10 possible also for them to aakn an error once in a while, but I do think that ne'ra here only concerned with singular caoos. I don't think that any principal -rrors wore possible. Q. Doctor, I only have a few qu.stiens to put to ycu. One question ay yet have to be discussed in that conwection. In the course of the evidence the prosecution has raised the charge that these questionnaires were expertized by those experts in huge nu&ors and wit >ly short xjorlod of tine. k. Thoso queationnar-s cone to the pre-export in a register¬ ed packago and th-so uuontionnair.s wer- to bo de .It with as quick¬ ly os possible. That n s d,3irud during the expert co: nco, but it ns nl3o point-d out th jy were to bo dealt with c .reful’y. dhon dealing with any such quustionnairo and when considering the period of tL-o it takes, oik rust hear in *ind that ti tm is really not the Important factor. There aro persons who arc in r. position to work quickly and others w-.o work ore- slowly. There are pooplo who have their desks littered with files and c:.n never get anything dorv,, and th-re are the people who sit at their desks and navor leafce it before their Job is finished. In the case of th-se ques¬ tionnaires, tho contents cf the questionnaire is the ost impor¬ tant thing, k questionnaire can be kept in such a form that '’ion Underlin: nf. psychiatric questions -ith red or blue pencil one rji -t often co 30 tc a decision within r. Period of one dnute. One could 9Kay-vfc--^. J«—16-2—Karrc*^ ( Int. Rsaulor ) Court 1 perhaps roach a negative decision, not necessirily a positive de¬ cision. However, there wero other questionnaires, and that par¬ ticularly in the case of the Later questionnaires when the cases woro :ioro difficult and not as clear as before, that one could pon¬ der about such a questionnaire for days and not g_t finished with it. In that case, a question n:rk had to be put down and the decision had to be left to other agencies. In any case, I don't want you to accept that as ary defense of any p_rsonal nature, but I want to put that to you as a defense for oil exports. 1 have dealt with those questionnaires no c ref ally as possible and in order to ba quite sure personally A looked through a few huiidroda of those questionnaires one ornin , let thc*a lie, then perhaps looked at another bunch of th-8e files In th_ afternoon, and then once *oro looked at tile first heap of these questionnaires and only then gave •sy opinion on tYiauu Q. Doctor, tills brings o to the end of th- .jost oxtenaivo point of view rog rding the procedure which w .s adopted by the Reich Co-, dttcu v. thin the outhnnasia procedure. It is now only necessary for m to put a nub.r of 3 aI 1 cu-otlons to you which :ircs- frop your activity and Which have to be illos tr a ted so it. Did you, at any tL -, hoar that th-se poor Amtal patients, .r>d these poor Children tK,ro designated as "useless eaters"? A. Tiio expression "useless c-ters" I he rd for the first ti->o Tinile being here. I >aver heard this expression when doling with -r.y .encioo with ..ich I was iu contact. You -ay believe '*o that if any serious rinded j>_rscn had hoard that expression hf would have thrown everything away and would have- said "I -t. r.ot goin to cooperate."" 3. Doctor, ora witness has stated in an affidavit that in the year of 19u2 there was a conference in the Ministry of the Ir.vricr during which the directors of th. institutes ir v rc to have 9 May-u-, V-3-Korrcr; ( Int. Ha. -tier ) Court I received the directive to kill these useless uat_r3 by slo>< starvation. Do you knot: cf zxiy such conference ir. the Bavarian Ministry of the Interior? A. Thor© was a conference in the Bavarian Ministry of tho Interior of all tho institute directors coring from Bavaria. Thi3 conference was called by the Bavarian Ministry of tho Interior. I don't know what the na -js of all tho participants w 0 ru, but, as far as I reuoabor, th- directors of all these institutes were actually present as far as they held the offices. There was the follovlng reason for the callin'; of this conference. The public rental in¬ stitutions, fro . the point of view of nourishrTent, wore tr-;tud in a riaiwor niiich is uoual to certain institutions *..hich do not correspond to ucntnl institutions; for instance, work hous-o. »o wero subjected to whatever woru dished out in the way of rations, nhun, in tho la.tor years, nourish >ont b-crurte a problem and, in particular, the rations were reduced, difficulties began to nriso within the institutions. In particular, those- patients who w>,ru working within tho productive program of that institution had to starvu. They could no longer oat to thoir satisfaction and, as i result, becarjo worse in thoir condition, as other directors of institutions, I attempted to incroaso the ration by oking a nu bor of applications at the Food Office in itnich. I tried to get a special ration cf food to the sine extent as was iven to heavy workers. I had to visit this office for ten tia_s and I only re¬ ceived rations for that personnel in y institution who were un- ga&od ir. the heaviest work and only that after isany, uny ifcedious rv. jottntiona. I only received that for tubercular patients and People who had to stand on guard for as long as t-n hours. Thu whole thing was refected for the. patients. Then, of course, I had to sake a cocoplaint to the district office -nd I also turned to the :{inis ry of the Interior in 3avoria. .-»t a later date I 9 Hay-i Court I ’alee 16 J-ii-Karrc ( Int. Ra.-r.lcr ) lcorrud during that conference that the sane, thing had happened in the case of other diroctore of institutions without twin? a- blo to co .w to any understanding. However, nothing was given to us. So-so &djusbs«nt had to be j-ade with the rations which wo re¬ ceived at tho institute and it was then dot-r ir.wd that the pa¬ tients had to be treated in a different way who w u rc at a uch loner social level for tho bon-fit of the oth..r patients, and I think I want to point out scuothing .-lae- I would not hav^. been in a position to o&intain one of ”y insulin depart-r^nts if 1 hadn't received enough nourishment'# Q. Doctor, if 1 understand you correctly, this dealt r.lth tho giving of nourish.-ent to these institutions by the Pood Office which had nothing to do at ell rith outhanasis. How, another ques¬ tion- aoong the cental patients who were transferred to an eutha¬ nasia station fron your institution, were th-re any such people who could bo considered as valuable work-rs? A. Gontl-r-on, I filled out the uontiennuir-s of ay insti¬ tution by having every or*. of y patients presented to me persona¬ lly. This -fas done by the head nurse of that particular dooart- TOht. That was dona in the pre3_nce of the head nurse and in tho presence of tho physician «f tho aopnrtoont, who had previously filled out tho questionnaire. Also in the presence of the ordi¬ nary nura~ or the parson who was controlling tho work of that ■atiunt, I looked at th- case histories. I don't really know what other safeguards I could havw token# 3 . t any rato, you sa jf "no to the question that any valu¬ able workers nero transferred to tho euthanasia program? a. Ho, that is out of the question# 7330 j art 1 1: ; loy-Rrmslcr. Di- v r -in knovle: j t.-.n petiants ware trans- ;.rr-i fr * — nt 1 Institutions f r authrnpsln? .i. - c,t r ; I thini I f.r ot avoetolin.. fr.m before. I : - c* o tl-nts-r.:. I ..idn't .-an:, tr^s ;n t. the ■rvns-ort in c aas whore I didn't tl-inh they should be Srpnsferred to the transfer institutions. Sow, I snail once mure repent the quest?, n. Bid yuU «v r .Bln knowlod.e t..st uetlants ware transferred from ;er,:ri instltutl.na into eutr.?n sir stations in >rder to v.rj- Je sufficient e)fve f.r y unded' .©rsonnel? a. I didn't i.„> that It v a poselpla, however, that : on:iot re.fiem:r t.-.le, durin ; tr.c c nf-.rence In Berlin, ^r. E.-nlor'6 c nforence, ■» rclo->ee of soace •■•re discussed .. -he f r.Uf.va of C.vt spree :.r «ray purposes. «t *"• rate Is • s a rticul rl. dleousaed th.t this rp&co v;ps c. be vacated f.p -purposes .f .. elm.., put t within the :r*. * y > rh .f outnrnaaie, eutheneale ves not rt ell 'l v-saod. I . vc -nc : r: question to * u; to whom v*ro the authpaaei* etstione eubordlnrt ::. fr a of loir I point : view? a. :r-. n of id? 1 oir.c i view t..ey •./ere s ub. r:\lanttd i'.lnlitr f tic Interior xe. lcrlly, from the ao.noalc * lnt of view the; rare nbordi «ntc:. c tne rtaHi-iearrt ?r-~ldent, t..- : is c.. ; district president, w..o *i- *. e. arena o: r: nr ta c _ap rtaent. .is was p lc .el sen s ..at chad for ta : -ep rtaent. •• Joct.r, v s there e Xftti ,nal docl-list .Kurscs Oorpe? «. I nevor xa rd of myth in- lihe thrt in »; life. 3?.. rRO£cw-.Aft.- : I s-Id llha t :oln: juc th« • the - : neecutl s submitted *-ocua=nt 3 R2r3, .exhibit 571, - c-aenc 3oox 1-., a 123 of c.e -^racn edltl rn: m Court 1 :->.y 9-^-17-2-HDrifcloy-aeat-ler. the English edition p?^e 262. This Is the rf.’id-vit of Jordans, wherein It Is stated these injections in the cose of c.-lldren were introduced by physicians »nd nurses of the so-called National -Socialist Nurses Corps. THE WITNESS: Gentlemen, thrt Is madness. That is complete C"dne86. We had nurses who cane from r free nursin.; association. ”e had male oersonnel and femrle oersonr.el nurses, end I know of r.o other nurses. I never heard of the National socialist Nurses ^ssocl tion. I w ulu h vo known It If such e tr.ln- had existed. v. Now, the one last question, Doctor. Do /cu .in.w that euthanasia iwd been carried ut because of dsfonoiva and political reasons? *. No, during ay Interrogation by tne /uoorlcan gentle¬ men I hve been asked ob-ut that quc a tion, but I don’t know anythin- ab ut that. DR. FR0E3CmiA.;N: Hr. President, In that connection I refer to another doouaent whloh has been submitted by the Prosecution, Document No. 38 ?6, Exhibit 372, In volume 14, P'.e 184 In the O-roan edition, vnd pr c e 233 of the English document book, w..ich deals with the affidavit A Dr. 3prauer, where he says that aentlvn was ma-e durln w : the c.nfcrer.cc In 3erlln that eutr.'n-sla wes n-cosoary for defensive and political recsons. x. Kow, I npve one other question. Did you -ein ::nowled-.e that euthanasia vts to be extended to elderly psocle? a. No, on the contrary. DR. rROEoCHrUKN: Hr. President, In this connaction I refer you to Document 81 , Exhibit 373, Document Book D-rasan 14, pe.e 167, rn- the English Document Sock p e 35h. This :s sn affidavit c. tn. just mentioned Dr. 3prau«r. Caurt 1 Kay 9- A-17-^-HD-Kaloy-R isnlcr. q. Sow, one last question. When discussing the exceptions you were sayIn : that people who were injured as a result cf the war war.- to be excepted, perhaps you didn't express yourself quite properly. I as5 putting to you that in a document, which I don' c find, suomitted by t '*! Prosecution, there was a list, of a number of death cases where loath notices wore contained, and I thlnx that three or four participants In the World War, 191 to 1918, were also mentioned there. Doctor, It is qv. question now, Is It correct that only those partic¬ ipants In the World War were to be excepted where the mental Illness was in connection with a wound which was inflicted during the war, cr and that I can hardly as¬ sume, that all participants in the forld War wer .* to bo excoptod who became aontally 111 as a result of thoir injury? *. Well, I oan't toll you that. I can only tell you that in the caso or tnose people who oufforod In¬ juries as a result oi the war, and In which case there was a connection between that Injury and thoir nontnl condition had to be considered In a negative way. .is for the others, I canr.ct tell you how they are Juried. I thlnh It says here “military conscription from the year of 1914-1918“ and then we inserted either "yes" or "no". The -xport opinion loos not aopend on that at all. All the nedica psychiatric questions of the transfer which really had nothing to do with the expert. Now, somothlm; else, gentlemen, I thlnK I oan romomber that this was outlined in the file. Whenever participants lti the World War were mentioned you must cons! lor that It is o.uito possible that wo didn't Know from the case history whet¬ her the person concerned actually was a participant in the War or not, because that was net laid down. It is quite possible that 3-art 1 Vi;- 9-A-17—r-HD-iisloy-R?naler e "no" vc8 lneert.d rt first, because -nc only s - it down rccoraln- to tha adainistrr.tive files on tap. 6 o«r« a, -nd ,ne doesn't et all find • it whether c * aan *.•: * in t..e ypr. If «n the otner henA he bed ' very visible Injur;*, -s r result of t-ie war, supposing one of .lie erz6 was tni?sln tt or .ne of his fin^-rs was -ls8in r , .r au-vuem.. - severe hyalcol condition foe resulted be ecus* of t..o war, re tuberculosis, I oen assure you tn t these people vere not considered positive. DR. FRCIcCHo. nr. President, I n ve n. furt. er questions to the witness. JUD32 SS3R::*o: Vltr.asa, the Iribur.yl hrs no or two qUoStlor.s It would like to ask. 3Y JUDC-I 333R K3: .. Ao I recollect your ts-tiu r,y * u s’ld t.vt ct .19 tna aeetln- of t.ie neioh Joaulttc.- in £ s rl!n where t..e euthmael" problem vrs consider .( is */. s there Cerur. nod tie Jews vere not tc be Include; ir. the eut..v.*elr :r-_rnx; did I undereten- you correctly? *. I sn afr id I veen't in - >«it - our question erectly. ot^te whether or not Jv*;6 *-jre tv be included *n c.e euth*ncsle pro.ran? «. I didn't unow th t Jews vers to b. included. I nevsr ne»rd of tnrt. Then -..u don't jcn>.w v-.etaer fi.e vere : e -.".eluded or exeluedcd? ^ * «. That I really -or.'t Ita.w. The cusse an institutions vere tre. : d equally* 1 once no difference rt % » .o i s. Then fiu f- r e- m - in snort inn these v-rl us • * ? icrs r. wo Id be eycrtiti '.id a decisi n aada - r-n Court 1 Ivy 5-1?— b-dD-sp loy-Rp zizltv. - yc tie trie pnd ser.tel colnt f view with -c slightest c^nslderetl-n ba in^ r~e tv vnether he wre . Jew or :i.n-Jew, is tlvt correct? «. ‘.'ell, I navcr_i<-.e any difference w-.an dealing wit.-, these c^sas, bet n^r.a of teen were trensf^rred. None of whom? a. Nona of the Jaws, none of t.u Jews vor* or .isferred. Kona of tile Java wore sent to t.-j outhtnesla tr ns >• rC ns far as I enow. Why? «. as I already eel.. Initially, t.ie Jews ware sent to e Jewish Institute thr-sJ.h ■' c. llsctlve transp.rt n the basis of en order by tne B'-vsrlen ministry vf t.:« Interior. And do ; a know whether or t ^t :.--5 J«wi*h Institution selections were :*•&« for zevey de«tns? a. No, I don't icnov tfcrt. I hid not.-.in- t tj with tfc«t. DR. FROESSStaNK: :«r. President, ar“ I it- te t.. t witness is eoaevbst f, r... t*. t is v.y, I -s.. tb-t •;..e Interpreter ene*fc o 11 c. 1 ? leader when spa-din l.i * raipn to the witness 9 !&y 47 Cs-sk (Baaalfcr) Court Ho. 1 7K2 &E&XDZKT: Has defensu counsel -ny further questions to this .itr»-ss? There Join; non* the Pr >sueubion nay cross ocaaine. CROSS SX.13NAT10N aria, k.jdx: Q. Dr. P.anrnuellfcr, have y_u boon intorr ate ' by Hr. Rodtll? a. Yes, I -nly learned his rca* a little Inter. Q. An.' ou hrsvo boon inter T; 'tod by Dr. H~>cbiald, the Czocho Slovakian attorney workin, for th. Prosecution here ir. Number,:? Tea, there was another ;cntloarn there. I don't know whether that was Hr. KochwnV r not. I later learned a certain "r. Hochwnld »(to th-re. Q. Hr.vo y u 'con into.rro_-.Uj ’ by th. Prosecutor of the Gerst-n Court in Frankfurt? A. Yec, I was interro,-.U * by a nuabor f ir.vesti rating jud{.»s, thruo )r f ur f tton. Q. .. .on y .u tiv.ro inUrr te by Hr. ho ell and Hr. HachwalO wore y.u un or nth? ... Tea. Q. i*.ro you under .nth when y u were interrogated by theGor.vn Prosecutor? A. Ko. Q. Then i*oU realize, f course, you ~ro un’er o".th hero? n. Tos, certainly. Q. will u kindly tell the Tribun' 1 in your opinion why the outhon-.sin r. ,raa was institute in Geraany? I ..on't kr. w that. 1 us not inf r.r^ ab ut that r od I, therefore, conn t tell y:u that. Only rt a later ‘ate I had^.ccasion to sco tho Roichs loiter 3ouhler,'.lvro hu sh we-' .-ae- - letter, aca.,r 'ir<£ to which a decree had been issued by the Fuehrer which constituted the b sis for the execution of the euthanasia ,or -ran. B~uhler shewod .ae that .Krson-lly u,»or. ny request. I 'on't kn« whether at that tlno I already kr.-sr about euthanasia or whether the question was.just >r.'.ir~ t.teo. nt any r - tc I assumed th't euthanasia ar.y case into question. 7335 9 Itiy 47 -..-18-2-pkp- Co k (Rar-ulor) C urt Hi. 1 r.. Di’ iwhler 8how -/m r. letter Vrxt th. Fuehrer? ... Yes, I thou ht thr.t this »ss the ori. inal. I saw the phot terlor 1939, th t is, the h.-toot tic c ay which was ih»n to e in Frankfurt, .h t was tho first f Se't.ab.r 1939. May I add that I sirestate' in Frankfurt that I 1 st of September, 1939. I do know that. Q. You I; vo .answ«rv*d ay emostion. Kow do you recall in your Intorrof* tion of 21 September 1946 when asked the same question th‘t 1 naked you !»re today e to what was your opinion as to why the euthanasia program was instituted and r.t that time you said that -ou thought it was a military m»: sure for hospital purooeor. Do you recall answering that in your interrogation in Suptuabor? A. Me. Q. RooQcbor you ro under oath hero, doctor. A. I don't re=umtxr details any aero. I any say on<. thing. I was interrog: ted so rapidly ~t that tins, th t 1 hardly had any oocsibillty to think, r«d orw mix thing - it is possible that 1 slid that hospital measure* were t~k.n into consideration for the purpose of the army. I still say t which of these institutions but •a mefcor of patients wo Sent i ay institute frea C buroe^ -.nd I .already st ted in Frankfurt so far as I rv.ne.ab-r that p tients had lre.ady been s^nt away r little while after they had coao. I did not p-rfcicipato in the vacation of Gabcrsce. I said thr.t in Frankfurt the vacation if the Gabersee institution was carri.d -ut wit. ut ay ssistance. t lie contrary- 7337 9 k'jr 47 —A-i€-5-pkp- C^-k (Raccl^r) Court. I. . 1 Q. I didn't ~.ak you th‘t, doctor. I ak-o' you uketh&r or not you it-ted thr.t in conn ctd. >n with ‘2,%. outbannsin pr:gr.i c.t Gnbcraoo - A. 74s. Q. Kindly r.awor ay cu6cti».fls, doctor, rna wait until I complete .oy quest! ns b« f*ro you atort answering, Uy quucti:na .%ill bo bri-f “nd y.ur ni-Aura like 'iao ooy be brief. Hovi who took charge of the ir.sone -vsylu= Gnbera.*. at that ti: ( ic? 9 'i-ay-u-: 8-19-1-0llagher (Int. Rader) Court I, Case :.o. 1. A Iho Ifental Institution at Oabersoe was teken over by the DAF, tla Gcram labor Front, so far a» I know. Q That is the Gersan ^abor Front, isn't it? Tlie D.iF? A Too. CJ Thank you. A Yes. .ithout ry prosenco, of course. Q when you entorod tluj euthanasia progrsa, did you t-ko an oath? A ..oil, I think tnat at any rate 1 was obligod to koop tatters a secret. I think that tint happonod in Borlin at one time. At any rate, during the first co»ifcre.nco it was said at tho end that trw entire conference fell vithin the dc-si^ation, Socrut Reich let¬ ters, Top Secret. 3 I nok you again, did you tako an oath? A Ho, I was told that I was to say nothing about thaao nego¬ tiations, and that under tho circur^stancos, a death sontonco would bo carried out. Q •*bc told you that? A - - if that T..is viola tod. Q ;ho told you that? A 1 don't knor oxactly tho told vo that. At any rate I can not ruaouber it. At any rate 1 i c obliged to koep tho secret in a scn3e. 3 At th. tico the individual told you that, did he aloo chuke hands with you to indicate by his handshake that it was agreed that you vcr» : udizittod? A Yes. •1 .'end who was it? A That was not a coronony, there was no •oronony with that. If it were otherwise I would have roaenberod that instance, but really it w.ns an obligation in tho sense of secrecy, and in tho sons® of riy t c -sk which was siren to :u in t o Reich Linistry of tho-Interior, in 7Z'l 9 2-17-2-j-H- shcr (Int. Raalor) Court Ho. I, Crse Ho. 1. sgr capacity as an expert. 'i Doctor, who el so did that. Did someone else ask you to kc.. p fcnosa -atters a secret? A I bog your pardon. Tou had testified in a previous interrogation tint the entire ;roup of individuals took this r ath who directed tho work of cuthar.--.si-". program, and that the oath was taken in tho fora of a hand¬ shake, and you said you r.ust keep this a secret, and now 1 want to tell this “Tribunal who that was, just what was said, and oil the in¬ cidental conversations that accompanied it. You know just what X ron referring to, I boliovo? I no longer knar, '.hen this Reich C omit too was ciuotod, I was obliged c secrecy anyway, and I can no iongor state that in exactitude who tho agency .-s, that obliged .» thus. • Q ‘.ihan were you interrogated? Uhon were you interrogated by tho prosecution in Frankfurt, tho Qorsr-n .rosocution? A I have not got tho d-to ho re. I think it traa in January or February. Q It is not fivu years r.jc? A It can bo in April. •1 It is not five yoarc • ;o, Doctor. It is a natter of .lontho? A Yos, but at tlu tiro also in Fr.nkfurt I stated that I no lor„- .r know who that war. I don 1 - !mow whethor it was Munich : (inis try of the Interior, or w hotter it was in Berlin. I really don't know that exactly. 'X *.iho conducted tho rooting in Munich of tho Ministry of tho Interior? ' £ A Tho e*_ting at the Vinistiy of tte IntLrior v-s headed by Ministerial Director Schulre. .*> That ie right? A That is right. ^ You don't recall telling any or.o within the- past Tan months 9 K-v'-i-®-lS'-3-G2lla«bar (In-, Saalor) Court ;.'o. i, Case >‘o» 1. that it was Victor Brack who shook hands with you when he svoro you to eccrccy? A 3 certainly was not sworn in in any wcy. ?!xjrc was no s '-irinj, and I really would have rc-trb-rud it had such a thine taken placj. I i r.g only obliged to k©-p tho ivitter a top secret, but it is possible Victor Brack would have to know that hinself. I no longer Sene* that, I would not exclude tho possibility, 3 Did you ever hero sveh a ecu ting with Victor 'rack whoroin you shook hands with hin "t tho ti-^o, considering tho socr«cy of tho cuthanasin pro gran? A i‘oil, howovor, wo are coning back to thj same thing ng in. I no longor know of those tilin'.s, and I can not stato thorn exactly. These things ore so rvany yoaro back, gontloaon, that 1 can not no longer recall *.11 thoso details; "13 thus.: dat.s are nixed up in ray aiiid, and I co Id only reconstruct thon truly on tho basis of tho docu’vint. Q Thon I shall try to bolp ycu, doctor. I will not ask you to go h-ck three or four or five yoara. I rill ask you to recall your interrogation of tho past few -ronyis. Do you r-call tolling Just that to an interxa>cator, either to y staf , or tho staff of tho General Proe-jeuter in frankfurt, that is not vory difiicult to ronenber, two or thxa-’u v/>r.thc back? A ' at do you want to roicotoor. I don't quito know what you want. 0 Ono of thoso intorro;;-tors had nskod you if Victor Track shook hands with you and told you tho things must bo kept a secret concerning th- euthanasia pro gran. Did you or did you not toll tho interrogator that in Frankfurt, yes cr no? A I really don't know that cny raorc, I did not receive *ny copy of ny interrogation, therefore, I con not t-.ll you that. You have state/ that they had a conference in Sjrlin in tho :u! . or of l$iiC, who attended that conT-renc-? 731x3 9 1 ay-»-i'-19-4*-Gallagber (Int. Rader) Court No. I, Cose Ko. 2. A .oil, I don't knov what conference you arc talking about, ouid that te tho export conferonce? '. as it the expert conference? ‘1 Herr; cany conferences did you have in tho sun or of 19)i0? A I no longer know that. Sc otines I took tte questionnaires uc thore, and delivered thee to so.ui njjo rcy, xnd then briefly spoko to the so puoplo. I only had tro conferences ir. Borlin, so f.-.r as I rcran- ixr. Ore of t!uso conferercos was the first conference to which 2 was invited by Jouhlcr, sid the second conference was the export conference in Borlin, about which wo have boon spooking today, wherein wo received nil our principles. 3 Now let's take th. first conference. You wore invited to tho first conference by Bouhlor. Tins that tho first timo you I»ad ho rd about the institution of euthanasia progrnn of tho Uoroan Reich? A Tint was tho first tiao I was over in Berlin. T had nev».r been to Borlin before tint, and I had nothing to do with it be¬ fore that. Q Doctor, you will answer th: questions briefly. New you. could have answered tho last question, >us or no. Now, kindly try to do that, and taj will procoed auch noro rapidly. Thor, this v.s tho fLrnt tltt you over hoard of tho outhanasln rrograu when you rr^ro in¬ vited to a necting or conforc.«co in Berlin in tho Sun: or of 1?1*0. That is tte first confurcnco you nteor«dcd whore Bouhlor invitod you. No.; as louhlor present? A Yos. Yos, Bouhlor was there. Q And who else was there? A So far -.s I can rem.bor, Conti was present, Linden was present, Professor Kaido was tterc, ard lotzo. I think Dr ^Brandt was there• Q Yes. A Brandt and 3rack, and I think I can still r.ranter tteso. Q Now you say Dr. Brandt was there. ..as that Dr. Karl 73iU‘ Sruidt? 9 >^A-j:o-I5-5-G&ll2ghor (InU Raalor) Court lio. I, C~sj Bo. 1. A Yes, sir. -i ' -is Frofessor Nictzschj tbero? A So fa r if I can rci^rtb. r, Doctor Karl Brandt was there. 3 *.'rs rrafcoscr Kietscho thore? A I don't believo so. Q TiSa Yarburg thoro? A ’t.’arburg? I don't know hin. Q Yea Horc-Ininn there? Do you know that ran? A Keffcraaro? Q Hevolraim, jro»? A I can not rosoebor Jicvelmnn. I can not roroa-»r ho was present during the conference. Q Yes Blankenbir , there? A RIankorburg? Yea. I nade hia ncquaintoncc lr.t.r, but I enn not ru.urfjor whether ho was tluro. Q Y-a Dr. Schuhnr :« thoro? A Ho. Q Yra Dr. ?alkhauaor there? A Ho. Q 're Professor 'rack there? A I beg your (r.xx’on. Q ‘.as n-ofossor 3rack there? A Brunck? Q Victor Brack? A Victor Brack, yeo, I b-liovc lw W'S there? Q You say at that nsoting a letter frcr> the Fuohr r cliar;;od Dr. :“rl Lrandt sA R-ichr loiter Bouhlor with tho authority to give pomission to oth-r :x-n to aonnuct the outh^naeia progrra vr.s exhibited to you for tho first tire? A Ko, I rxiver raid that. 3!o 3outer was shown to no d’lrins that confer: nco. This eo-called dccnx. of which 1 sa photostat; c co "7 ttt.s shown to co by loel-ier such, mch later when he was at this • 9 3-19-6-GnIla gher (Int. itaslor) Court !Jo. I, C-8v Ko. 1. very institution. Ho did taut upon =y rosuost. I wonted to know -.h.t.^r thoro w~s to l» s trr.nsf«.r of . -.tionts, which had earthing to do rith this question. Q That is contct, tint this outline of the letter of tho ruohr.r was not exhibited, is that correct? *' 0 . I did not know anything about tho outhanasia procure. Viet was the purpose of tho noting? A Tho transfer of patients who w-re to bo treated and to bo < i sc j-rau.d to ot.Vr institutions, .and, persons who were to be tnlcon caro of, to bo sent to otter institutions, the sjrr.ration of these two c.asoa of intionts. Q All right. A That is how I understood it. Id ay 9---B2-20-l-K«rrow (Int. .tar-A -r) Court So. 1 , Then whan was tho first tine that tho innates wore to bo exterminated? .. I nov .r hoard an yt hi ns about extermination. Pardon • ; o if I 3.-.y so, but I didn't fcnow the expression "oxtornin- ntod". I no longer know exactly when tho thought :roso that this was to bo an euthanasia measure. I think it must havj nhppomxl when I visited Berlin or perhaps triton I was in Hunich. I no longer know that. I repeatedly said so.. I c.n't toll you that now. ..t cny rate, at tho bo-r’inninj of thu action I was fully 002 : 3 cious that these people were to bo 3-nt to welfr.ro institutions, probably for tho pur- ose or euthanasia, but when oxaotly outlianasia was to start I did not know. . May I ask you one question, Bootor, nlon; those linos? .« s thor*. over any one, to your knowledge, killed under the outhann3ia prosrna. Phot i3, accorded a ujrcy der.th, or helped ftlon.; so that they oould die without any further sufferinj. To your knowledju, do you knew that? .. Ho, I heard bout that for tho first tine in Fr eikfurt Ono of tho int erro -. tors told r.e In Frankfurt th t the action h J continued aft-r it was supposed to be stopped. I didn't know mything about that. . Then you know about tho com .one alien t of that action? ..hen did this beji:i so far as you knew? V/oll, I don't know t. at either. I don't know when tho action started. I n.v.r said th .t 1 did know it. I d n't know it. I was never asked to participate in any discussions r..,.rha; th t. . How nony children did you accord a mercy death in your ..3yiu:i? .. I cn't tell you that either exactly bocnu3o I no longer know the r.umb-r Hy 9 -a:-20-2-Korro-.. (let. it seel or) Court Ho. 1 % - You cp./liod*... .. (Interrupt in*j) lio, on the basis of the authoriza¬ tion I hod those children fall asleep. . .itict do you call that? ~ ‘fh~ children received luninal. In the oa3o of tho3o children a very littlj dose was sufficient in order to raliovo-the suffering oi those pitiful little bcinjs. . How cany childron did you do th-t too? Two, threo, two hundred, fivi hundrod,• or.o thousand, or eighty thousand? .. f’or Cod's sakel I really don't know how nuny tnuro wore. I don't know whether thero woro a hundrod cases or ov;r a hundrod cas^s. ‘The oases who woro purely put into a slu;:b^r ;.usc niL.bor .round on, hundred twenty liowovor, I can't tell you that with certainty. I cn under oath h*-ra, you know. . I re lize that , Doctor. Do you know when the Inst ohild was aooordod a nercy de .th in your institution? •• No, I don't know that exactly but Dr. itodell - I think, Dr. nondoll - said that ir. Frankfurt tii t shortly before the -.norloans arrived children were still troctod with ot^mnhsi x. He Cent .onjd one child - but I era not ■juito sure. ..t that tine I was Very exoitud a . roadlt x of these questions. . .toll, how Ion; '.id you o.jry out euthanasia of children in your institution? Free 19*10 to what d;.to? .. In 1939 I had no euthmasi--, I on juito euro -that i3 v/ron;. I mi quite oortair. it i3 wronj. I Iror.dy cention-d a document tod y. . (Interrupt in j) I didn't iiention the date of 1939 to :.y knowlodso. I said 1940. d^aybu ;ot an inoorreot tr ns let ion. 1940 I said. 73 hO rl .rro*.' (Ir.t. xt ■ ir-.lcr) 3-..-b;:-2o- 5- Caurt Ho. 1 - I think you said 1939. . .ell now, toll no, frot. 1940 on you woro .... ~ (Interrupting) Dc you want to knew when it started? • I want to know when it started , yea. .. ..ol., I really can't tell you that exactly. I said the acno thins in Frankfurt. You o-.n't oxpeot fro. uo that I roooebur -.11 these single dates nftor so ..any years have passed. with tha bust of :.y will I can not toll you that. This is the question r.^ain nd ajain. . ‘..hen did it stop? .. what oto^od? >.k t do you uoan? . Tho killing of those ciiileren, -. Thu killin’; of th^sc ohildr^n? The killin; of those ohil r-n was never stopped. . TJ- recordiji' of n :i >rcy death to theso ohildren. f ho authorization was never stopped, not until the very end. I n« v,.r received ny such stopping. Tho action r - rein * the .;rcwnups was stopped, end iftur that, .;rown- up people woro no lon.;«r subjected to outln.n:sia in ray institution ,m\ Wero no longer transferred. There, oust be so..u :.ixu.< hero. . How nany ;rownup3 woro accorded a nurcy death in your institution? .. well, these re ti.e very s-.r-o questions which have bee.: put her. before. ..l3o in Fnnkfurt. * can no lonc;or.. . (Interrupting) Just .. aur.ent, doctor. Just a noaer.t. I will ask tho questions r.nd you answer thou. If^you do not chocsv. to answer the question ’will you kindly 3ay *1 refuse to answer the question. 1 ' liit-hor answer tho qu.stioa or don't answer tho question. I don't wont to bu r jjv r:orv quibbling fra. you. we , 1 t's continue. Ho*.- may ;rownups - that is, ■' uits - lid you accord a .:.;rcy de .th in your institution? M j 9--.-3K-20—i-Karrow (Inc. itcsilcr) Court :io. 1 - The n-jrcy death, in ny institution - I didn't prant th'.t to *ny adult. I just transferred tho patients. . *oll now, this first conference in Berlin - tho first ono, tho one. that 3ouhl.r invited you to - thot concerned t!;« tran3f »r of inmtes fren one* institution to another? .•os that its purposo? - Tho purpose of that oonforunco was tho transfer of patients, who could no longer bo tr.;.t«-u, into euro insti¬ tutions. Those wer- county care institutions, and that vtza tho ..xprossion I hoard thero for the first tine. . Then what happened ire:o7 12 ay-2-3-A}J-Galla?her-(vOn Schen)- Ccurt 1 Case 1 Nassau Institutes. I can restater one cf thus, bcc use I worked from • • :r* . - t sjjrt in -ti.n in Nassau, that was Cr. Schnoidcr- I bt? y u par !cn, perhpoa ^ u can help rv . I renembur saecbo y . lse, iknkvl, a physician cr scache-y like that, cut- Q Let's see- Q .he =ai3t also have bicn a Nassau Director, Q I can so through a few for you and si. if I can refresh your rc- crll'-.cti a to help you. A Please. Q Was Beuhl-r the re V « . id that Frankly that I can not remember for sure. It may N r.. was thero for c while, but he did not preside a ithis meeting, other¬ wise, 1 wool' have remembered it, ^ You say 7ict:r -rack was thereY a Tea, he spoke te , so far as I ’-in r«mM4x r, . «»(is Blankor.burs there. j. Blankcnburr was nev^r in such . cl*>3c contact with a., i >\ ul. zeer. and I car. renter ti.it I m 3 a abort man, piyoicolly stall cm, but I r .-ally n’t k:.-». n.. he was present er net. No*, wl h c.r’ linty anyway. ^ ics ven H*-Rer.er there? A I don’t kr.:w. Q Wes Verwerk there? a Verwerk? Q Yes. .» Torwtrk, I teli-.v* Wcrw.rk was present, but I cr.'t know ! r c. r- v - that r.*- was rheru at the n , ut T ..' t k:: • • r : ••• , e-ntleoun. I b-li^vo that a f«w wer ! s were sai about th- transport -l*the patients, and that ni=ht have t-.-.n V'c-rwcric. it was discussv I thvy should V- r.= Ye * ir. buses, d don't kn * for certain. Q Van Professor *\.yde there? 7 think r refers r *Yy:c war. there, j y 12 ±.iy-~-Q2-2-L-Z-.llr.*k>. r-(vrnSchon)- C'urt 1 C23C 1 Q '-hat about Frofcssor Nictschc, he was there? a Yes, he tack a very active part in the cenfcrcncc, in the discus- aicr. about the diagnostic an;', prognostic Judgnents of the institutional cases. < ••as 2r. Linden there? « Yes, I fc .litre Linden was there. k us Dr. Centi there? a I ’cn’t think sc. I 1 n't believe that Centi was present. I can net rerxac*-r havin seen Conti. ^ Cr. B1 sic was there? a I don't knew Bleat. I .:n't knew who Blcac is cither. * Is the none of oilers fasili'.r tc you. #as ,.11 .rs th..rc? a aIIts? Q les. a S’ , no Ahlors. Be was ny supurl-r in nu?abur,-. THE IJT P.Pf T «Ii..rs, nllera, «Ucrs? a Allers, no. BY K. HaRCIs Q -«o Dr. Schunanr. there? ' I thought r for : 1 r. - tj: . ; n* • kr. w f r sure. I 'on't recenb.r whether it was .'ahlaann cr Schunonn. I can't toll, w Waa href sscr Dr. bran t there? a Ho, I believe that he was net there. I don't reQuaber about that very n.ll. I only havw a faint recollection ef hie. I s.w hia a fa in here during t.h_ walks. He rill be abl- •- c-nfinr th:t. In ay pinicn I saw Pr.f sscr - nn t only at this first Eouhl.r nectin/. I cannct r- - :-nber if h- was at th. scccn. conference. 3 las Dr. Falkcnh’.usor there? a lalkenhaaser? -4 les? n :.'o, that was a v.xy g. I frier. : ef nlna, qy paternal friend, nJ -j t-.achcr. •*-. r-_s r.-a there. r -. was art present at this c r.f ronce 12 k3y-«-GJ-2-$-Ckilla6hcr-(v. a Scbcn)- Ccurt 1 cmc 1 Q ‘as Dr. "onacckc thcr.? a I fajlicvi. that ycu aisunierstc-d ra_, probably that was tennckc. Q •‘cnnckc? « Yes, uenneke. ■i Yes, Jenneke? « I e'en't r-aaenber, I can not recast*, r uenneke. I know xunntkc only fren laur scientific cectin^, a stall convention ir. nc.i:’lcberg at the Psychiatric clinic, of Professor Schneider. 4 Can yru tell us new Dr. Pfannou.il.r what developed? a £xcuse*rx for interrupting yru. There were other lectors present, tut I did net Imrw then. Y.s, can ycu tell us what ’cv.lopc : at this acotin Jtpi rts. rjo'it th. caeo history of pc. sanal oxaaiir tio.as nd runarks ; fill .-- out of trx. questionnaires, th-“t they »cr- not till.-d ^ jt carefully. Fin’Uy, :s far as I can rcojafeor, gontl-aon, it wes Iso discussed b» the whole activity was xecnisod, the proli.nin.ary export, thi chief ox ort , how Gov-rnxnt -goncy caas in the Roichs V.orkin union, the adadnistr*tivo elements nd th_ fin 1 de¬ cision by the ir.a in ch rgc of the institution. Gentleman, I eannot say with certainty whether it be cane obvious t this point that Eu¬ thanasia was r. ,'rogma. I don't rceodb r, but I beli.v- it wa:i only la tor th"t 1 heart bout Bothrnr.sia, th-t i.a ne-r to the ti>j wlvn Souhlor appear t y institution. I cannot say with certainty, but I do not want to Cony the possibility th-.t it was said due to th- treats at of d.v -r.tiuits it night lead to their dying. 1 cannot cry with certainty, but I believe th-.t is 11 I can toll you from ay orn twsury .“bout t!ds c-aference -s far r.s I ern n-ouaber after *11 these >'rs. I forgot one t.lng, RwntL.»-n, to riv- you a true pic tun., in both conferences it was said th-.t the discussions were toy suorwt .and that crioinr-.l vocwdin s would bv started if r.yxie would do cl ro -any¬ thing b ut this ho ad;ht be tried and it drht involve tho death pumlty. I don*t roauabur when I was obligated to s-crecy -nd in what way, whether by solemnly shaking hands or *t the end of the acoting wh,n we wore walking xit. I cannot tell you th t, but Later ay >ersonnol was obligated to }xop those things a top s -cret. Dr. Pfannatt.llor, ftir th. completion of this .-o-otin -.rhun did ,-ou far first tine, a far s you* car. r-cali, hoar tfc-t Euthanasia was t e applied ir. th. can. of th-se- incurables, .after they h d beer, first recorded i.. t.ao questionnaire by the chief doctor of the institute when they we-re hospitalized; when did you first near that the fin'd, disposition woulc -e to -ccor.' thusu patients -a a-rev !uati*.7 Do u usx-orstand the i-~nart f the cues n, doctor? 7361 12 ±-7 l ,7 -?:-3-2-p*p- Hcutm (van Schcn) Court Ka. 1 Yes, I Jx.wi whtt pi >.•«, ut I was not Tblw to fornolato nil of your st ct oa un t, 'son nca the. 'irst ti-c th't you borrd or were inforrxd that _ . ji x:-.a to v applied tv those incarable pntiunts? A. «a far na I enn rcxrocr, tlx iirst tio- itna when 3cuhlor visited - I bolievc 1 to in Ux ai.-rr.cr of 1940, t .jy institution. I fc-liuvo I suspoctod it bef oxv hand, but -a f"r 's I c-n ixaesbor I wru tol V t.l>phone a-ca Berlin r.houi nine in the aorninr that 3ouhl*»r was ^.oing to viait a- r.' I was not to leave the office. Thu call hr.d boon omouncod and then I was told ha mi -.-'ini to visit ny institution. I united .t the office axil told the official trr t when the Reichaloiter c? e, ..e should bo shown intc .ry office. Then P.uicholeitor l.il-r 6ua to .iy office iv'. “.sk-J no to show in -round t!.o institution. I took hi- to v-ri^us buildlnra, 3 showed him tlx trontwnt boil in , the reception r. .i, the acute on so a, the v-ry old p.ntionta rv 1 •:. .in t hi purely- tnti-a cial departments, - luo the head working. ctaiis. At the end ,f Ih. discussion, I naked Roicha- loiUr Bouhler tell ae whether Euthanasia -x-suroa were roanenoiblo for the trrnsfui of -rx»e pttiunta. And then I saw U» ducreo of tho Fuehrer for tho first tine. If y-u ok ae - ut the dr.to ~.t tho top of it, I r.uat toll -*ou that I e: nn-t reex ,'xr. _ I looked .-.t tlx dccrou ..-.d I know ti.-t th&ro was tlx insignia at the left top of it. Thoy told a. in rmnkfurt th't it was in > 1 , but it was not in c t>l , I would h.v- notice.’ it it. '.lately. It was bl'ck si>:n. It was not a photcatatic c y, but wixthor it a~.s ; carter. copy or r.ot 1 cannot say. I th:ught it :-os tlx xiginal, rccording to the signature Adolf Hitler -.t the bottaa -t tte rir:ht, but I on't know x'or sure. 1 rlw-.yr thought tr.-.t tho r.-xs Brmdt nd 3-uhl.r were on two different lines, but it c ulx! trve been a fl«- srao lie. I _ r. t sure. I cannot roraonihor that it talked, bout L.cur'bly sick people, but it t lk-e ’bout incurably ins&rx -^ople. I lay be nist-.ken, .ut I think t the bottoa rt tho L-ft, i€ arid, To ..x ‘.eich iinicters." I IS ink i* a-.id Reichs linisters. I road the deerv., tlxn 3 said t rjuiiler nd asked him 7362 12 -Lay i(7 ‘■'-.'-r- ilo-bax. (•» Sch.n) C our t S'*- 2- wlrt would be done whon eathanesla wjoU be tin. Ho »’id not give -v. ::ny answer, be said that the law was being worked out, tho r -ulrti.-r. -r the. execution 1 or this lat: u ru being worked ut. That 8 the s-c. f what he said rel -Iso that tho Law would bo published •t the proper tlx. I said th-'t it ai ht bo expedient 11 have r plebiscite or this question, but Bouhlor for politic-1 reasons rejected t: is, h- it wes impossible for this to be done because there was a war >r.. Th t is re or less what I discussed with Bouhlcr -t that tin* 'n Bouhlcr s'id h. was strcngLy impressed by many the thin s he had scon. he had terrible i~f arny do? rfciaonts in which tbore were the tetri 1- cafes 1 Lscusscd hero already. Q. K*, rr f. . o r, when did y.,u first receive c inclusive knowledge, that io twca-x fully "-re, of the f-ct that those persons declared perrr.iKntly incurable »-rc to Se accorded r*rcy death? A, I L riw * th't in th vay ir. which th. fuiwral p pul ticn le-rntd it. .h transports -ere token way fren ay institution, tho first rws kcim by motor bus. 1 ti.ink Voniurk was present at tho first transport, but I oa n-t sure, hswror, I think he was tnoro, ftio transports left and I don’t know if it was Iter th. J ir3t or second tranap rt, I 'on't re«eatoe-r the date ex-ctly, but I thlrk it was in tho l' i. foil of I960 or tho spring of 1941 but I cannot tell y u . otly, in ny c 3u after tho s.ccr.e transport approxinr toly it was said that .vtiontc in those transports had led, because- the relatives had in t.ho aoantisv. received the death notice. There were .a nunbor of runvut the rti-nts arrival' a* :.is'veil boing. r.'.-t is t V it was as far a* I can rea^abor. Q. :,oll now DocCor when did the -occasion nrisc of necessity for yM to rsk your employee in the instituto to take ai -ath, siiil-r to the enth th t vo sec hero in the Docu.oj.ts that they * nbl keep s. crot ,11 the activities c morning this jr.rticular phase of yuir work; When did th~t occasion -.rise? Doctor, in Docuner.t Bo k No. Y>, thoro is jn tte nsxt v.,o, ye* 8, an nfXlfevit « tn obli-ation signed by Erich Fr-nk, I prosu/v Erich Frank vas otx> of your ooploytos? A. That was jy r dainiatrator, eputy administrator ns the administrator was away in th- war. 73C4 12 Ifey 47-tf^*ID-Hcxsie (Int. vcn Sober.) -l-l Court »c. 1 Q This obligation y Erich Prank is dated 20 February 1942, end then on rc-c. 7 there is an c libation cf contract sc tc spook, sijnod _:;rue -xn. That is dated ;.pril, 1941, I don’t happen to have any there here at the present tine, tut when did it become necessary for ycu tc require ycur cnplcyecs tc si^n such obligations or contrqcts? If Defense Ccunsol has Gcra&n Dccuaoit Boek 17, I rculd cpprocirtc it if ho v-*.uld su -it it tc the . itness fer his perusal. .. YeS, plcrac. I cm ror.-i -r both these deouaents, thr t ia, I can only renu_er soein pfcotcstetic copies. These photostctic co-pics were shorn to so during an interrelation here. I don't render the date, bas it in Octe’. er cr when? Dh. FR02SCKIUW (For Defendant Brack): Ur. ?resident, ivy I inter¬ rupt for a ament? I should rarely like tc point cut thr.t this obligation in Doouaont Bock 17, rngo 7 refers tc proceedin'-* before the fcoich Cora- cdttoo, th-t is, regarding children, while the cn<- cn •*«£« 8 refers tc Measures re -rding the r-'ult incur-.’ ly insrne patients. TfU ITsISS: I nay say the following: The3o two obligations hr.vo n-thin* to do Kith cutWnsie. They v.re drawn up after the erection of the Role* Ceaaittce especially fer children, expressly -t the su cation of cnc cf the sen whe asked ac tc 3ct up this Reich Ccnrdttee ot- ticn in •y institution. That is ccn; lctelj soparcte free euthanasia. Thr.t is why I di n't follcw ycu, Ur. Trcs-cutor, ‘-cc'-uso the Keith Korkin: Ccimaitteo — Hoich "erkin Union and Reich Korkin. Cccsrdttoo were confused. The two things wore entirely separate in ay ain l. This is sc nothin-; about the ..oich Cca^ittce, nl it referred cnly to this personnel. For the ixment I di ln't rcn--a er these c v ligations -t ril luring the interrelation hero. • I thou*ht they were ferneries. But I theu ht it cv-r fer - Ion - tiac, and then I raa«~l -r that I had tc issu- thm. Tint wr-s after the visit, as far as I can reefer, after 1 h*i tc sen! th-pediatrician tc Berlin, end ho e-no back an tell ac it was tc? secret, and that the p.erscn working on it had tc Vc c'.li.-tcd tc secrecy. That referred cnly tc ay aIrdnistraticn an.' t< the personnel fer observation cir! tror. taunt in the HeieV. Ccsrdttce Static.-., th-t is the nursin' personnel. 73C5 12 !fcy U7-4J-A7D-h~2-Hoxsie (Int. von Schon) Court *fo. 1 !icr, to -j> ever to tho Reich forking Onion, the rod euthanasia, Gontlenen, I never issued any written obligation. I said to tho personnel, - . i *t reocrior exactly when, that the transports wore to be kept secret, that they ware not to be discussed or talked about. It was not merely secrecy of th3 official to which ha obligates hir.scli undor an oath of office, but beyond that there wore things which one does not talk about, boc-'.uso tho personnel discussing there night start rumors. I said, "I don't talk about it either." A nan visitod me onco at the institution. I think it wr.3 Dr. Schrmlonbach. Ho earn fro:: Berlin, and ho suggostod to no — Ho had questionnaires frou no that he vas chocking on, tho questionnaires, to see whether tho patients who woro roported thoro woro called realty for tr nsfor frer. no. That is, ho had a certain supervision. I had a fight with his bocauso I ob joctod to that. Ho was a rather young iaar.. I was an old, oxperioncod psychiatrist, and I said that I considorod this thing and took care of it carefully with uy physicians and ray own poraonnol, and I didn't think this was necoasary, but I couldn't objoct. Of course I couldn't (Vi anythin Yiout it. k said to no, 'Is your porsonnol obligated to socrecy?" I said, 'I told than in January that thoy would koop it socrot, but I did not toil than that there was a doath penalty." He said, 'You Jrnvo to toll then that beforo our conference bogins." This wao a ccnforenco dth tho ‘.loads of all tho departments and the hoads of the nuroing personnel and I objected to that. I said, 'Dr. Schnnlonbach, if you have such an assignxmt you can do it ycursolf," : nd at the be¬ ginning of this conference about tho pationt3, he did so. I ditttti. Q (Sy Hr. Hardy) Approximately fhon did that occur. Doctor? Tho conference. A Again I oist say that I really can't ronaaber tho tine. I can only reconstruct that it nust have boon after four or five or maybo ovon six transports. I can't say exactly, but several transports loft beforo that tine because patients who wc.ro or. transport lists, I had keop then back, the sane thing that I disco sed or. tho telephone with "alkanhausor, 736S 12 U7-tt-iro-i*-3-35Xsio (Int. von Schon) Court !fo« 1 feat I refused. If X «» supposed to -duo up a patient, end I thought get tto prerequisites for tremfer an' possible sulhanosia -ere net given I retained too patient.- that is not a defense on ry part but proof .-at as an expert I took seriously the safeguard, involved in the proeoduro. - This conferoneo that took place, that is live conference -herein your oojloyees and your employed .Personnel -ere -r.med and told of the coorot nature of this -ork, that cast have taken place in the fall or -inter of 191 * 0 , is that about right, after the fourth or fifth transport, is that corroot? A I can't say for suro. X don't rosier exactly -hen the transports began. I can only say that it night have been in the -inter. I don't kno» for sure. I think it -as -am in the office, but it night have been in the spring of 19bl or tho -inter of 19W. I don't kno- exactly -hen, but transports loft before that tirw. a go-. Dr. Pfamnuollor, did yen ever see anyone refuse to partici¬ pate in this -ork, th-.t is, any of your cnoloycos that die not -ish to toko this oath of secrocy r'.xm they -ore asked to do so? A No, no om refused. I only had four people here and they had nothin- to do -ith the Sole!, -orting Union. These -ere tho throe nurse, in 9ocu.-v.-nt Book 17, thoso throo nurses ani uy deputy adnlnistrator, -.rich Prank. Other«iso I didn't addnistor any oath. q I an reforrlns to tho group in 19bO, the conforonco you held -heroin you refused to toll you- employees, ani your visitor, Dr. Sclrutlonbach, -us there, -ho adnlnlsterod the oath or told tho employees of the secrecy of the idssion an! so forth. I an referring to that tine, and did anyone refuse to continue their -ork there? A Me, no. .11 the personnel, all the doctors -ho .re there -ere the heads of ivpnrt-.ents an, ril tho chief nursing personnel -he -ore present attended the neotin.. I believe a pretest -ould have had no value. It -as a discussion about the condition of the patients. Oentlenen, it -a. necessary, so that'nothing -ould happen, that the doctor, and the nurses be ares out, but nobody objected. It -as' an oral talk without any discussion 7357 12 Kay U7-^.:D-c-li-3tocslQ (Int. Von Schon) Cpurt No. 1 It was an order, you krow. It ras an order that they cono. A statement • / Sc'ml.nbacfc was what it '.-as. -7 , Doctor, here In 19U) then, in the fall or tha *.dntcr, aftor visit by Boufcler, you, for the first tins realised that evontunlly t’.w patients leaving in transports would go to other institutions and bo .-.ooorlod aorcy deaths, that is, if their condition was such that thqy era suff ring and that a :aorcy death would bo tho proper thins to do. as that tho first tino, in tho fall or winter of 19JiO that you realized that? 7563 12 May 4?-M-.T;<-5-l-Gro6&-(Von3chon) Court I a. I believe that was about that time. The rest was assumption but I thought at anyate that thla time I hoard of It for the first time. A time when the driver was to begin was never mentioned. I don't knew that at all. I always thought that at first there would be a gen¬ eral registration of all German institutions and that Euthanasia measures might than subsequently bo ordered by the agencies in Borlin which I had nothin'; to do with. Da.FF02SOHH.i2IN: Hr. President, I believe that tto time when the witness learned of Euthanasia has boon discussed so long and sc often that no • more questions on the subject are necessary and I ask that prosecution go on to another subject. THE PRESIDENT; Osjeotlon on the part of oounsel for defendant 3raok 1 j over-ruled. Counsel aay proceed. BY HR. H.iRDY: q. Dr. et innnuellor, when I asked you about the administering of oaths to some employees, I was referring to page •• of Dooumont Bock 17 that you have in front of you. Do you still have that there? This is German Document No. 11. I believe it is on page *i of your Document Book - a letter from Kdelzol to you. Now, would you kindly road that through and explain to the Tribunal Just what the situation was at that time? This letter which I read once before when I was looking at the documents I cannot remember. It is a letter from Ooerartt Dr. Hoelzel from the year of 19-.0 in which he states he was at Scwanzsee near Kltzbuohol on leave. I can't remember the letter because at this time nothing had been said about Euthanasia at all, I assume. Gentlemen that the date in this letter 16 wrong, I assume so, 73GS 12 May *i?-H-.»:<-5-2-Grcss(VonSchon) Court 1 I don't know whether Dr. Hoolzol who wont over to tho Supply office, although I asked him to remain at ay institution. Ho explained hi a resignation by saying that hi8 career would bo advanced bettor In tho Supply Office. There were many such cases among psychiatrists at that tine. I asked him to stay and what was the immediate cause for this letter I don't remember If I over receiv¬ ed It. 5ut of all-this In 19*0 I can't Imagine that, i/hat was Dr. Hcelzol to collaborate with and what way w is ho to collaborate. Ho had no collaboration oJcoept what every doctor In overy institution In Germany had to do..»nd I don't know cf a alnglo oaso in which an institutional doctor in Bavaria or hea! of an institute in Bavaria, after the beglnnlngof the removal of pa- tlonts anl after those measures tho ornoopt of Suthan- aala became generally kn wn, lecllol tc resign. I don' t know of a single o/iso. Therefore, I don't unlorstand It ftt *.11. Does ho ..loan conference of tho Sohmalonbach type or release of the patients. I lon't know but tho late, gentloaon, I aust put three question marks after it. .aid, I can't renumber this letter nt all. 'I. Now, Dr. Pfonnmuellor, at the bottom of the letter, I note here on the English copy I have, It stat. s - In handwriting appears the following language "Received 29 .»ugu8t 19*iO 1600 hours" anl then initiall¬ ed xfannmuoller. Nov, io you wish for me to -et tho original copy wo have here or the photostatic eppy and see whether or not that date la different? TH2 PRESIDENT: Tho Tribunal desires to have the original of this document procured and shown to the wltness. 7370 12 May -.T-H-.^-S-^-Groes-tVonSci’.on) Court I HR H.wUK: Will tha Sacratary General kindly go to tho Document Division and bring Document No. l^ia which Is In English Document 3ook No. 17. Miss Johnson will give you tha Exhibit number. DR. PF.iNNKLIELLER: May I add something. a rooeptlon notice of time - I navor had any such stamp as long ho I was director at Egolfing-Haar. It navor happened that a data was recordod on Incoming mall. I must assume that that was added later. It 1s very dlfilcult for me to say that It is a forgery but - It never was done by mo. MR. H.JIDY: Vo will wait until the original document arrives, doctor, and wo will than go Into another subject. THE PRESIDENT: The Tribunal will now bo in reoess while the original dooucont is being procured. I 7371 ll:y 12-::-BK-7-l-*:cloy (Int. Broun) Court So. 1 riiJ M._leIL.L: Thv. Tribunal is again in session. D... 1 Ljd: Mr. President, us Booker-Freysen^'s counsel I request th:.t for th.. purposes of prepurinj his case that Hockor-Proysonj bo excused freti attending tho session this :S tor noon and tomorrow afternoon. THJ P.US2DJZJT: On r-quest of counsol for defendant Ueokcr-Froysjr.G the dofendant Froysenj cay be excused free attendance beforo the Trivunal this afternoon. I understand that Bee ker-rrey song's ccso will bo called following tho ease of the dofendant Brack. I do not know ..hen tho dofendant Brack's case will be closed, but defendint Bcck-r-Freysen;; nay bo excused this afternoon. ILi. H..T.DY: I understand, Your Honor, that dofondcht Brack . (Cjrnr.n coninj threu-jh the niorophone as well qs dnjli3h, not understood.) THJ P.aUIDhl.T: Thu defendant Becker-Froysong aay bo .xcusod before thv. Tribunal this afternoon, and did counsol C3k for tomorrow afternoon also or tomorrow all day? B.v. .L-iX: L'r . President, I asked also for tomorrow aft_rnoon. P.uSIDJMT: The defendant Bockor-Froysdng nay also c» excused frot: attendance before the Tribunal touorrow afternoon on request of his counsel in order to consult with tho defendant in preparation of his ease. c.i03o-j.w..i:J..rio;; U suned) BY 2 Li. H.JIDY: . 3r. Pf-mnnueller, durin;; the recess I presented tho .hotostatlo copy of the docunent I»o. 1313 - which is found :: .: 4 of the iL.glish Docuc-nt 3ook Ho. 17, Your Honor. ter reading that copy does that brine any oth„r thoughts 7572 May 12-:s-3K-7-2-i:cloy (Inc. Brown) Courc No. 1 to your nind, Dr. Pfsnnnuollcr? .. No, I soo now Chet the copy of the docu-iont corres¬ ponds with tho photostatic copy, and I sco that that kmdwritton ronork at the bottom i3 cine, howavor, I can not racr.il that any c jraooonts wore ro&do on tho basis of this letter. Not at all so. Perhaps this latter was written after the ^utachtor conforonoo, or somethin;;, I don't know. . woll, thon is that your initial on tho document, Doctor? .. Yes. Yes. . Noll, now in connection with this docunent is tho writer of the lettor referring to your work in connection with tho Ncich Co:*.it toe, that is tho ohildron, the 0 hi Id r on patients in this institution? .. T’ _t I don't know my lon3or. But it could be that :-.o was to bo used as a psychiatric export or sonothin^ of that 3ort, but I don't rononbor any noro with tho b-st will in the world. . ..ell, now, D r . Pfanncuellor, that i3 all tho questions I have on that document. Will you please ro- turn it to the paja? lieu, when you wore ordered to fill out questionnaires on each ono of tho patients in your Institute did such order requiro you to fill out a questionnaire on each and ovary last patient or only lac patients which you doonod to be incurable? I don't know th-t for sure any Ion or, but I do, know that in tho course of the transports thor- was a • registration requ’irod cf ell tho innatos in tho institu¬ tion on tho basis of tho questionnaire. Then ther- was ...e directive by tho .tcich Minister of the Interior cordin': to which those questionnaires should bo filled rut whenever n-w arrivals cone. i mi ■ ■fc 1 7373 U~j 12-i£-BK-7-3-Haloy (I .. 3 r.) C urt No. 1 v ./oil, now, Dr. Pfannouc 11 or, after you conplotod those questionnaires r.nd they wore sent to Berlin, then trans¬ ports v;orc arran^ad at your institute end said transports took patients to other "hocos, is that, correct? .. Yes, those woro questionnaires. . ..oil, now whoro did you receive patients frou, did the patients also cor.o to your instituto free other institutes? - 3 .ds that boor.no froo in ay institute in consequence of thj transports woro again occupied by patients ooaing free J v riji nursing hones, end as far as I know Nussborg night have boon anon;; it. These bods woro transferred to ny Instituto. That was cn the order, I bolievo, of the Hoieh Ministry of the Interior, I no longer know exactly whoso ordor it was. . 7o7d Court 1 ir;- 12—«-8-l-HD-iv3 e he n-3rown. llov, how -any Jewish inartss did - - Vv t.ore; _ had o cjnsldarsble number of Jowlsn inaetoe? *. I don't know n-v, how a^ny Jewish prtdonts I M.Z., but thare la a Document tart I re d ncre-Ju-c - aoaent. That la In Document i«o. 17, Jr. rf~-i.ia-c.ll-r y; 6 0 6, i‘0. 1310. A. Just n moment, oleeea. I don't fa ve It hero* I cu sorry, Pn-e Si? Jo o'-or Hpybo I can help you. I h ve '-no Document her a, wfalon I wish to refer «nd t la jit:’ ..el3 ue. ’ov: i: you will fclndl rend thrt over once, then I h ve a. me Questions to put to you. Tr-la la Document ;«o. 131 > In Document 3ook 17, P? D o 6. (The Dooumer.t li htn-od t she witness.) how, Doctor, this lctc.-r ac toe -fader the e ojoct, "Transfer of Kent'lly Ill Jers - hinistmll ^oolslon of 4 September 1940, ho. 523o a 44 : ■ on - salimtan ua a to the hlnlet-rlil Decision th S you received? «. That w-a the consequence of sno .'.miat-rl 1 -_c isl - n, the trtmsf-r of Jews fr .a -:* lnitltuia t.- Jewish lnacitation. I lolleve, t.i^rc ware bo c fifty Jewish prtlonts who ver*. in ay own institute. Jo you recall, Jr. rf-nnmuollor, Ju->t w.- t this lilnlst rlr.l Decision arid; did • r—tlvc rn ormr, c or In ted order, rnd -o ou recall t c ntonte A the docielon? «. This hlnletericl nuclei n s-ld t/.*t rll Jewish tler.ta In 3-v-rlm i*ientr.l Institutes were to. c t -ton Into ay institution, where they ware c- be tre-c.i 'nd c red for until on orders of the hlr.lellry t.iay wore .'.?in Fetched away. The 3«varl^r. ..ml? cry A the Ir.t ri.r v:-u_d 7375 Court 1 ifey 12 -«-S- 2 -H3-Meehan-Brown turn these people Over to me end then the Jewish patients In Bavarian Institutes were tc be transferred to Jewish institutes. i. How many Jewish patients were sent to you ra a result of this decision? This decision had nothing et oil to dw with Euthanasia. No, I aa not referring to £uchana6lr. I an merely trying to clarify the transfer of the Jewish patients wore sent to your institute as a result of this order, Just fifty or aore; do you recoil? h. Those th-t were sent to ay institute from else¬ where? S*. Yes. a. There was more than that, tnere was mors than one hundred. I cannot tell you the enret number, but there woro more than one hundred. It v: s all tho Jewish patients from all Bcvarlcn Institutions, which were transferred to me and were out In a seporate buildln 0 . Q. Now whore did t«.ey c o after having be-n received by you; do you know whether tney were 9ent to Lublin, Poland? I c' nnot tell you th*t for sure. I know ^nly one thing, I wrs told to surrender these Jewish p.-tlents again because they were trken to r Jewish collective Institute. This wa6 to be done on directions from Berlin, It was said they were to be sent to Jewish institutes In Poland. Th-'t va never told t- me officially -j the Ministry, but I a6kc& c can in ch rge of a transport, where he w/’S coin* and that Is what he t.ld ao. Tncy were O olng to a Jewish institution In Poland, Toother the word Lublin wrs mentioned, tnor. or later e herd toe Court 1 A?? 12-»-8-3-HD-*fe e ha n-Brown nane Lublin, tnrt 1 do noc know. How you scy that ot tnat tune that ia r. v: the naze Poland becane known to you r.nd 1-t r . ju .ndcr-fi.od they ware transferred to Lublin; vaatf y.u refer tv 1 ter, do '.»u see now or ouch 1 ; ter; Just vh?t do ;. u aean? «. I Clean by that when Inquire? re e rrilni Jewish p.«tlents wore nrde ce t; where the --tlonta were. Low once when I v-s in Berlin, I we t Id thrt 'ch-. were sent to o Polish Institute and I thlnb tnr-t wr.e Lublin. Unless tne am in cnerge of the trona .rt lAc-d. Q. fell now, were ... required t. fill out questionnaires on tr.ese Jewish p Clints Wt pres*d d.r u-h your Institute? a. No. %. Jr. Pfnnnnuoller, It Is a .nderetmdin-, aco^rdlnb to the evidence here -nd accoroln_ a oiv.rt drawn by Viktor Brack, let^r v-erc ^La a.; export nd it v s your function to expertise UdStiunnaroe fra .ther Institutes. «r.d I la 0 ine tnr t tne re* avn f r ,ur being an expert we, becruee of your y-rre of ,r ctlcol experience In your Institute, I ;:o:ld ll.:o tj hnow Just how -'c*- happened t. bee aa ?a exoorc; v requested you to trke t.v t r-ooiticn mi whet ,\ ur functions were ?e rn expert to expertise these quostioa- nr.lrea sent t; . .u by rrofe9Sor tfuyde or one of cue other top experts; do under?t nd t - ''a c luln- ~b.ut, Doctor? a. Yea, I uet the r.*n = n Idea. Tne .-\eloh .hnistry vf the Interior wrote he rere ...ally *uln- ae rn s;:;.ert within the freaework of thea fnd t is fell to cne colons brnlnu union. Then I vr.6 set h ?c m oxo-rt, re I id, upon what-the basis w- s decided :« «::;-erts 7377 Court 1. Hey’ 18-H-8-4-HD-5feehen-3rovn conference In Berlin. X only received a pnotostctlc copy fro»i. Che various institutes. Plus or minus, ell queetlon- eires were marked by me, but only as a preliminary expert. I think Caere were three or four preliminary e:iperce, then It went to a fife expert in Berlin. How -■*- * ^ decision wps there was not my concern, so I dor.'c know about It. Well, now you received those quest ion-Ires fr.m other institutions, vhrt wore you Instructed by higher authorities lr. Berlin to do with the questionnaires? I was to exp-rtlse on the Kedloal quostl.no that wars to be found in the que-tionnrlre. In other words, to make p note lr. the left lower corner whether I thought th't this case vss one th-t should be transferred w a land martin* noae or not. I simply had to juu e e in the preliminary procedure from the aedlcr.1 psychiatric point of view and to put ay observations down. Well now ir you v-ocldod tr.ey snould ee treno- fjrred to r nursing home.? «. I had nothin,, to do with that and 1 h. d nothing to do with tne transfer of these people, not tne slightest I simply hrd to make the preliminary export jud-ment, whether the case ohould be transferred or not, or were editable for transfer, was decided on the be sis of my expert opinion. It w^s not ay concern. Well now vh. t recomxendrtlor.s cuuld y.u arko; could you sake one, two, three or four different racumendatlone on each q*.tl„nn»ir. subDltt.a to yon? Of course. C*. Well, now suppose. I had many doubtful cases. C.. If ou received e cuestl-.nneIre regerwin. the Court 1 •ip y 12 - 3- 5- HD-.'.e s hr r.-3r o vr.. CE ae of a person who wrs Incurable rr.- tr.e nr.' ire c, -Dieted outlined the conditions attending tna p tii.it end y. u decided upon reeding tna qu stlcnneire tart this 3 ETtlculer ?: tlcnt was peraunentl" incurable; v - - sugges¬ tions or rscvmsentecl^ns could y u a A . If he vaa lncurrble? i. Yes. A . In ay opinion? i. Yes. A. Then I could rat down t.v»* he 9 *• o.siclve onso for tra'.efer eltner olus or sinus wrs written .1 - ' .war left hand corner, no cnee his tor'- w t* written or *ny pars-nel sxnainstlon. I oade ay ju„ e aont on the b el* of pinion of tn. questionnaire. According to a: itfpraseiwn. 12 Ifcy U7-iWtT!>-9-l-a^ne8 (Ir.t. "rcm) Court No. 1, Case I Q TThan you save, say, for instance, an opinion, and your diagnosis «aa that thid was a plus case, did you have knorlodge as to whether or not that patient, if decided by the top expert and the other experts that it was a plus case, did you have knowledge as to whothor or not that patient would bo givon tho privilege of a nercy death? A No, I didn't know that, bocauso tho final decision rostod with the doctor at the institution to which the patient was sent. I found out that j»tionts from ay institution who had had exp-rt opinions expressed on then by other preliminary oxperts later died. That I did find out. Q Woll, did you know at all whethir or not a questionnaire which ;ont through all the exports and tho top export and was classified ns n plus caso, that that patient would bo accordod a norcy doath? A No, that was outside «y coi*>otcnco. I did not know, I did not docido that, q What I aa trying to rind out. Doctor, is .vhon you perused and studied ono of ttoso questionnaires and you wero ordorod by Berlin to cake rocoaaendations and you had tSaroo rocorxymdations to nako — plus, ninus, and so forth — and you rocerondod that this particular pationt rna a plus caso, what of foot would your rooomondation havo? V/oro you inforrvid ns to what offoct it would havo? A No, I simply rcccivod orders to det ns a preliminary export and to oxpros3 ny medical and psychiatric opinion on tho condition of tho enso which was then to bo aont by authorities with whom I had nothing to do, to a nursing hone. I hod nothing to do with theso othor things. Q Now, when yea were finally co— issioned by Berlin as a expert, were you told by tho top authorities in Berlin or did you havo reason to believe that you wore acting as an expert within the framework of thu so- called euthanasia program? A Ttet I was working within tho franowork of the euthanasia pro grin? That is probably ate t res’ll ted from the whole affair, but directly within the fmr»w$rk of the euthanasia program I did not rork. I worked sinply as a wdical specialist. As I said, I had nc effect or influence on the out- 7360 12 :t.y lx7-w-.TD-9- 2-Bxynes (Int. Brown) Court No. 1, Case I ccoi of what I happened to do as a •nodical expert Just as any nodical expert appearing in a ease before a court* Q New, Dr. pfanr.r«ellar, did you have a Dr. Schnidtaann in your institute as ycur deputy? A Yes. Ho ras ny first chief physician* Q Hotr lore did he work as ycur deputy? Do you recall? A Fren the noaont that I -..-as called to the institute at Eglfing- Hanr as a diroctor — -hat wn3 February 1933 — until I was taken away on 1 st of Hay 19U5# CJ * 021 , now, did you, aft--r ycu assuraod these now duties as an export to exportdzo questionnaires of other institutions, did you thon ha vo another deputy, or wero you able to carry on both your work at the instituto as woll as your expert work? A I did not have a deputy as an oxpert. I had boon personally appointed as an export. Ccnsoquontly, 1 could not have any ono olso do this sane ^ ork, and I did not try to. At the beginning 1 was vory over¬ burdened in ny work, and the activities os an expert I took care of first bocouso I thought that this tas an honorary appoin.tncnt, T fillod out tho quootionnairos alono. I workod on tho photostat copios alone. Q How long did it take you to expertise each questionnaire? A That quostion was asked no in Frankfurt. I can not bo answorod Just off tho cuff. Only an export cr a physician can answer tint quostion. If I on workirc on such a questionnaire and if I havo oxp;.riaaco in a rid. nr on such questionnaires, T can under cor, conditions t.ako caro of tho questionnaire roletivoly rapi 'ly according to psycbiatric-oadical •mostions. Sodo cf then I get done seen; oth:r3 I !on»t got dono at all. DR. FK)zSZ'Z'j\'T,i 'T. President, 1 object. Tho -dtnoss has gone into t'vsso ratters ir. direct examination at groat length. I do not understand hy the natter has to bo ventilated again* Consequently, I objoct to tho scries of questions now being put to tho witness. MB. HARDY: Hay it ploaso Ycur Honor, just as Dofcn3a Counsol said, - :so mestiers wore taker, up vory elaborately in direct oxrssipatlon, aid 7561 12 Hay U7-9-3-»*&7i>-Saynq« (Ir.t. Brora) Court }?c. I, Caso I it is ry under starv’Ang that tho purpose cf cross examination is for the Prosecution or tho cross exminer to 50 ever the natoriol taken up in .iroct. I can’t go outside tho material that was taken up ir. tho direct. THE rRSSIDBHTt Tho objoction trill bo overruled. BT HU. H.VOT: 0 After you had received these now duties as an export, did Jhat require all your tiai? 'oro yoi ablo to still dovote so::o of your tine to datioa aa diroctor of tho institute? A Tho fact that I was delivering export opinions did not obligato ra to glvo up :y activity as diroctor of tho institution. I used ovory froo :dnuto to work or. thoso quostionnairos. Usually in tho morning I did ry regular dutios at tho institution, and then at nif-5-l-H37T^3 (Int. 3rcim) Court 33. I, Case I Q It will porhapa bo easier for you to folic* no, tritncss, if I pass you up the photostatic copies of this document. A I'll take your word for it, Q The first page of this document is a letter fron you to the Reich Association of Hospitals and 'Mrsing Establishments, Berlin, to the attention of Professor fteydo, Exhibit 35h. I might inform the interpreters that for the next two or throe days we'll bo taking up the problem of euthanasia whilo the defendant Brack is preeonting his case, and it may wall bo that we'll discuss Document Book lli. Part lj Docu:»nt Book 1U, Part 2j Document Book 1U, Part 3, and Document Books 15, 16 , and 17* 7333 1 :*ay L l-Jr-r. T'-IC-l-C-r c ~ 3 (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 q How, this first latter in these series of letters refers t# a letter of 12 No venter wherein Hayda sent to you 300 /aesticnraires for your expert opinion. Now, he apparently sent these on the 12 November and you are re turnip then entoe 19 November. Then you wiU see the next letter, nr. Pfannmueller, is 22 Novecber wherein you are returning 258 questionnaires and the third letter is the 23 November and you are returning 3CO questionnaires. The fourth letter is the 2$ November and yn are returning 300 core questionnaires. And, so or. through this entire list ycu are returnin these questionnaires which you have giver, an opinion on u? to the date of 1 Pecerbor 19U0. And then you jump to 15 April 19U1. But, up to 1 December 19li0, that is from the 12 November, this dorus»nt indicates that you had between theso dates tho opportunity to expertize 2C5* questionnaires. New, what I an anxious to know, is hew long it would have taken you, as I asked you Vefere, to evaluate cr.e questionnaire because it is obvious fr*n this document, Doctor, that from the period from 12 November to, we will say, the 17 December you had the opportunity to expertize and did expertizo 2058 questionnaires. New, if you had boon working ter hours a day or. questionnaires you would have boor, able to do about 121 Questionnaires r -r day, that is, if you took Tivo rdnutos on each questionnaire - new, would that ho a trae pic’xjro? A I don’t understand your firal question. q yould that bo a true picture - what I am presenting to you for your consideration - the longth of tino? A No. 1, as a doctor I rojot I cannot follow this lagalistic •.and of thought. From theso nrabers it carnwttbe seen at all what would h* expertized, where and what tho cases -wre. At tho be^irxing ilifcould rave been cases that could have beer, easily expertized easily ar.d rapidly. Theso numbers may include lots r£ utis that 1 never werked or. at all. I could rave sent the whole batch back without working on •her. and I ask your pardon but here I am a *>ctor fronted with a lawyer ar.d our points of vie* are completely divergent. You cannot 7334 12 May U7-*t-A7D-I3-2-Gor3S (Int. Brown) leurt !fc. 1 calculate the length of ti_* in working or. these questionnaires. Ir. German law, that is penal procedure, you car. find questionnaires that are as long as six weeks ir. (jiesticmble cases that coze up before the Court. And after six weeks yc_ can free those con-* tc a conclusion and, if this actually' cones to -e I would then ask agair for several weeks sere to expertize this particular case. Sco-tines, or. the other hand, It takes eight to ter. days to expertize 'questionnaires. As 2 say, it all depends or. the contents of the questionnaire. As 1 said before, we singly aren't talking the sane language. I regret that. Q Well, now. Doctor, what I a* trying to ascertain from this dc cutter, t io whether or not you expertised ever 2CW-253, which is a chart irawr. by the defondar.t Viktor Brack he aw ted therein: "I, Viktor Hermann Brack, havin' been duly sworn hereby declare that I was Cbcrdierstloiter,- CMof of Department 2 in tta Ctanrellcxy of the leader of the ^tional .socialist Party, headed by Reichsleiter Philipp Bouhier. In this office I knew exactly all and was entrusted with the orgar.inaticn's uthanasla program, and the leich Remittee for Hereditary and Constitutionally 73nS 12 Uay UT-Jt-AH—iO-u-Orc ss (Ir.t. rrcwr.) Court Sc. 1 12 Severe Diseases". And ir. parentheses (approval for operations or. newly torn tables not worthy of life indicated in red spotted line cr. the chart. And he further 3t«:tes -I J»ve carefully studied this plan, etc." Sow, the defendant “rack has outlined in this chart that his organization by the dotted lines was associated with the Reich Conrvittoe for Constitutiorally Severe Disease and this action withe the children. Well, r-cw I aa interested in kno-fing whether or not yew had the occasion to have learned of Viktor Frack>s association with this program, that is, with the progran of the Reich Ccmittce in as such aa I recall that you mentioned the nan> Dr. Hefelsanr. ar.d or. this chart drawn by Viktor *rack ho ir/iioatea Dr. Hefelsarr. to be the head of a division under the Chancellery of the Fuehrer. Do yrw understand what I an pointing out, Deo tor? 7337 :Jny 12-U-BK-ll-l-Hoxsic (Int. Brown) Court ::o. i I don't know tint document th&t you have there before you nor do I know whet Brack's tostinony was, but ns to whether I .v~r kn~w that Dr. Brack was .ctiVo in the -ieich Couaittoc is soaathinj th.t is entirely unknown to no, absolutely unknown. The nmu w..s n-v-r nanod to no in that connection. „ Doctor, would you kindly look cv.r that chart which was dr_wr. by the Defend„nt Brack, end you-will see tho iottod line3 around th~ blocks wherein his nano is con¬ tained, nd tho nnnos of Bouhlcr, Hofolnmn, etc., and that dotted lino continues ov.r tho top of tho chart ov-r to Kcrl 3rnndt'3 and through to linden, tho Ministry of tho Interior, and then tho outside blocks on tho oxtrcr.o Uft-hand side of the chert jive tho organizational sot-up of the iiuich Corr.ittoo. Novi, this wn3 drawn for us by tho Deferent Brack hinsclf, and you will notice tho oath oy the Defendant Br .ck in Goman in the left-hand corner. Now, -..ill yoa kinily study th.t -nd soo v, bother or not this r-fr-jshos your recollection to any extent? .. I nev«r s-w this ch-rt befor-. I only know th..t tho 3oich Coonittou had soaethinj to do with the .*nd signed.for it, but I don't know. Thank you. Now, Doctor, in -pril, 1941, you first he .rd of thi3 lie ic .V Co r ,dttce. How, when did tho ontur- _.risc develop? .> Prob.bly thet is when I hoard about it, yos. i ./hen did the enterprise develop to tho extent th-t tho authorities in 3orlin, that is tho state through the Ministry of Interior, -.ranted tho pornission that ihildron sufferine an incurable disonso, children doonod to bo in such a condition, that it would bo only worthy to accord then a coroy death? .»hon did that start to function, that Is tho actual accordinj of norcy doc.ths to children in this oatojery? .. That w-.o n conforcnoo. I received fron tho Roich Connittou, which I nev-r hoard of before, knowledge of a jonforonoo in the Roich Ministry of the Interior. I Wts .aked to .ttend this confvrenco. That was in tho Ministry of the Interior under tho cheiraanship of Ministerial Director Schulze, as f J _s I con recall, ond I believe also tho deputy of the President of the Upper Bavarian District .jsoei ;tion wa3 there, ~t ony rote I was c-llea to this conforaico. Th-re wore ,-roscnt b-sidos those two I Just national, well, nay bo Von Hojon.r was there, cr Hofclnann, one of thesrtwo anyway, I don’t kn»., and Dr. ..enzlor. I know that Dr. ..enzlor, who was a aecibor of the Board of Directors of the Union of Hospitals for oiok Children, was told by the Reich Coaaittco to take care cf fcju re istroticn of ill those sick children. First of all h a station was te bo set up in tho Childrens'. Clinic in Munich. This, I boUovc, was turned down because of l_rj ia-H-HK-11-3-Hoxsic (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 1'cic of 3paco and bcoauso they had enough work to do there anyway. Than they hit on the idea th..t not only sur;;ic: 1 c 3cs of physical deformation wore involved but also beor.uso nentc .1 c sea w-rc involvud, cs I soy, they hit on tho idea of sotting up a dep irtxaont in tho children's house ct Jijlfini-Hscr at the uxpenso of tho R„ich Conaittoo, and this depextaunt was to take ocrc cf those childron. I ar.do spuco available, and I wus jiven a doctor by tho Children^ Clinic. I h.vd to send,this doctor to Berlin and ho cone bnok with authorization as to just what measures were to bo -used nd thinjs wore to bo done, lika tho term of obser/.tion or tho details about tho treatment, 11 sorts of thin.;s, what tho vitamin troataont ms to bo, what tho operative trontnont was to bo, whr.t sort of occupational therapy w..s to bo usod, and so forth. Those o s.s wor- those whoro tho child could bo oxpooted to livo only for a Very short length of tine, and it was those who woro to be put to sloop somehow. v You mentioned th~ none Von Ho-oner. Could you spoil that for the record, please? H-g-o-;' - H-o- 3 -o-n-o-r, Von Hejunor. .. Von Kroner ployod bij rolo in thin Koloh Corahlttoo, did ho? .. That I don’t know. I only know that he sent no tho .uthorization. On Friday you stated th-t after this .ioich Committee was established and stnto authority was jranted of jiven for this purposo that in your institute you had several childron who you dcv-nod to bo in such n condition that they should b. accorded c corcy death. Now, how nuiy such children did you deer, to bp in that condition in your own institute? y 12- M-3K-U--i-Hoxsi c. (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 Ih--X I can not tell you. Children fror: thv, institu¬ tions and nursinj hone at Nou-Oottin.;, Sohoenbrunn, otc., .11 of tlk.30 children 2 took over alonj with the nurses. How, how cany of thco w^re fit I don't know, but tho jroot najority of then were terribly ill. I have n-v-r seen children .is siok as ell th.t, but just how nany thero •rf.ro, that I cn sorry I nun not toll you. Cm you tell us, Doctor, this is of considerable interest to ix:, as to whet fora would tho outhancsia tdeo, thit is, how would you be able to ncoord thoso children r. corcy donth without too cuch sufforin;, etc.? ,h .t did you use? ..oro thero certain roquirouonts out¬ lined by tho stnto end th- itoich Cocnittoo, or was that left up to the discretion of or.oh doctor? Can you onlijht- cn us on that, Doctor? .. That was left to the discretion of the physician ..inaolf obviously. The doctor who o -no fron Berlin oor- t inly had u policy laid down by Berlin, rnd in uy in¬ stitution luainnl was used, I believe. I boliovc 1 onco said veronal was ;;iv~n but this is wron^j, it was only lucinal. . How auch luninal would be required to accord one of these terribly sick persons a u«roy death? -* Plo.sc? . How auch iuninr.1 would it require? ^ The situ .tion here is exactly as with tho quostion of tine involved, it varied sronbly. -» hydrocephalic can tako lose after dose of luain..l. The naxinun daily dose as sot down by law, th.it dos~ was, under certain cirounstcnoos, :.6t sufficient, nd, on the other hand, it could hr.ppon in case cf an idiot with a stronger developed heart -ctivity, he is capable of takin ; noro than that dose of II-V 12-3K-11-5-Hexsic. (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 lunin .1 . You just have to ;;ive the child enough luainal so th .t eftur a few d..y3 he just quietly joes to sloop, .nd I rust O'.phasizc this is not e n_ttur of poisoninj. The child sinply dies of a certain con;ostion in the lunjs,it docs not die of poisoninj .s I said once before, .nd on interference with circulation in the lunjs. I hove s„cn this wor> nyself, and if there is anythin; such ns puttin, a person to sleep gently then this is oortnlnly it to aocord u cercy dooth. , Nov/, do you have to apply coro luuinal to n person that is older? For instance, v/ould it require noro lux..inel v/ith a person one y-or of or ten years of a^o, or is that a factor rt all, Doctor? .. The nnxinur. C .osos .jo crrnnjod according to ajo. It is prescribed that for children up to n certain ajc vto :lvo r. dose of luninr.l which is one-third r.s snail as in the o-.s- of adults. These doses are proscribed those anxinun doses and vary jre.atly and nro ..lways boinj re¬ vised. ..ell now, theso children in your institute that woro in such a dreadful condition, did you use your own discre¬ tion ns to whother or not they should be jivon luuinal or did you have to fill out a questionnaire and hr.vo that sent to tho Ministry, or was it solely up to yoursolf? u The questionnaires had nothing to do with jivinG tl10 child luuinal and puttinj it to sloop. „ Mo, I x: tryinj to det-raino whether or not quostionn ..ires were also used by tho .ieich Couidttoo as woll^os by the euthanasia projrou. I rtti not confusinj tho tv/c, Doctor. I v. noroly tto.iptinj to find out whother or not r. child could bo -,ivon luninal so as to relievo hiu fron r.is pair, by noroly the decision cf yourself or another aysicion of aiothor institute, or .ms it necessary to hav the o;inion of soue oth-r psychiatrist or -Xpert? 73C2 c — -y 12 -uI-BiI-12-I-—-loy (Int. Brown) ourt No. 1 .. The way things worked was quite different. I did not —kc th~ final decision. The child was sent, or was announced in 3orlir. through th- questionnaire, then as I found out these questionnaires wore worked on by experts. I don't know how finny nor who they were, I only know that Cr. .lOnzler was one of these final experts, and what the roccduro of axpertisinj was in detail I do not know. I C did not have anything to do with it. Then on tho basis of the questionnairo a decision was oado in Berlin and on authorization was sent back to the instituto scyins that within the framework of the directives of tho itoich Cconittoo the child should bo accordod the troatnont and then tho child was treated accordingly. Dospito this authorization fror. higher up I could still, if I was of a different opinion, ncnoly that tho child was not a oaso for troatnont, or to be noro exact, n ease to bo put to sloop, I could nevertheless if such was tho caso still rofuso to follow the authorization and sond tho questionn¬ aire back. Then oftor watching and obsorvinj the child for a Ion": tine with special personnel, two nurses, and then 1 had the child continually observed by ay pediatri¬ cian and ascertain exactly what tho case is, that tho c^3c histories wore worked out cost meticulously, beoauso tftoro also was n scientific purpose in tho proccduro, particularly in the case of our foeble nindnoss and cxijonous and indigenous problems and wc discussed this with all the personnol concerning once more, then finally I could toother with ay pediatrician, say r.ow "the case can be treated," and thon the date for tho troatnont was dotorninod on. Then I received notice when “he troatnont boson and the relatives wore inforned - act about tho troatnont, out thet they should visit tho child. 7393 !2-i:-aK-12-20: .loy (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 How, when tho children were set aside for euthanasia did you then - .. Ploaso? ; .hen you decided that children should bo subjected co euthanasia to relievo thee froa their suffering, did you then notify the parents or guardian of the phildren concorncd? .. Yes, they were told ahead of tine by ny dopartnontal physician. They woro told boforo you applied tho outhonasic? .. Oh, yes. Jo told tho rolativcs that it would bo expedient to visit the child boccuso the child wes sick and tho relatives did cone. In tho bo^inninc of luninal treatment tho child wakes up frcti tine to tine until tho final cunutntivc offoct of lucinnl sots in. i>id you instruct the paronts and guardian that you wore ;oino to adnlnistor luninal treatment to tho child? .. No, no, that was a top socrot nnttor. H.atDY: I hevo no further questions to tho wltnoss, Your Honor. D-l. PiaJOLilu: Mr. Prosidont, boforo this session is recessed nay I request that Dr. Schaeffer bo excused fra: attondinj tho session this afternoon, and tomorrow nernins, since ho is not ccnoorned in tho natter now under discussion, for tho preparation of his cose. ?KJ Rt-SSIDSMT: Counsel, you are attornoy for defendant Schaeffer and you dosiro to consult withrhin this after¬ noon concerning tho preparation of his ease? Dii. PJLHUili: .eid tomorrow also, please. TH- PlLSIDlirT: Defendant Schaeffer's case will soon be called for trial. Upon request of his counsel defendant Sch .offer will be excused from attendance before tho 7394 j.f _y x2-:*..BK-12-3-i; .Xoy (Int. Brown) Court *io. 1 Tribunal this afternoon *.nd t a.or row norninj, in or dor that hi3 counsol nay consult with hin for the preparation of his cr.so. Before proceedin; with the further oxaninetion of this wit no 3 s I would ask counsel for defendant Brack if ho desires to exauino this witness _ny further? D.v. ?»cGJSCrfLL-.ii: Ur. President, I had intended to con¬ duct a r_ther ext-nsiv- redirect oxurvin ;tion. fJL- P.tJSID JIT: V^ry well. Boforc oponinj th- rodiroct the Tribun-1 will take a neon roco33, «..»d will rocoss until 1:30. (Theroupon th- noon recess was tnkon.) 73C5 22 Hay Z.7-..-?JC-l>l-f&s*-er (Int., von Gchc-n * Bro»r.) Court I r—-xm cssajcn (The Tribunal repccyened 6- I33C fapurs { p Hay 15AV.) THE Ji-ESHO.; The Trltjmal is again in sassicr.. IKE pE^ID2.'T: Ccunael fcr the Defendant nay r^-^ajrine the witness. H906JS FFANJSfJSIZh - Reaumed 2EJISBC? 2XAJO&.?KS ?Y DR. FROESCHICJiN (Counsel for the Defendant Era-*): C '.fitness, in the crcss-exanir.aticr. by the preceoutcr you aasen- tially repeated, all the statements that you had nade caring the direct examination, only in a few poir.ta could year answer perhaps be clarified tc avoid any errors, ar.d it is these points upon which I should like to question ycu new. First cf all, a personal question Doctor, you, your¬ self, are a neurologist. A Yes. Q And consequently, knew the tern "prison psychosis" from science. Is it true that you, witness, found yourself in such a state in Frank¬ furt on the Main? A No, I did rot have a prison psychosis any longer in Frankfurt, as far as I remember, it was the beginning of Jctober until almost n year ago now. This prison psychosis was terrible, and I wouldn«t want oy worst enemy to go through "hat I experienced. Q Doctor, I do not want tc kr.-w the condition, I 3imply went to knew when you had this prison psychosis. It sc-ms to have leer. l?A5-Ao. k There were the acute symptoms hallucina tior.s and illusions, ccr.diticri-ot- but there ere many things thet T emit render et ell and «ny things that I eer. only rmesber pertly. q Doctor, I ask this question only bemuse the prosecutor et the beginning of his oroso-exssdnetior, submitted various things to you that you had said in Frankfort to the i.oerican interrogator or the leruan ir.vestigatir.g .rticial, and because the ^partial observer bust gain the impression that -hat you said in Frankfort does not agree 1th ■hat you said during your direct examination. A During the interrogation hero, before I went into Jranfcr., „„ in ..rs. condition. Suddenly being looked up -as a terribl. ex,a- rienoa for na, and 1 beU.ve 1 cm say that I bad sign, .f hallucina- tior. 3 . I was not aware of any differer.ee. 9 Doctor, it is oy impression that you nsde visible -Cfcrts t. -peek the absolute truth? A I think I oar. say that. q and did s. in all the question, that the prosecutor asked you. hat me no. tun. to the .tatters that I should like to discuss 1th you «y- aslf. The first subject is the folldng. » »!*• of the he. Top Secret matters -ere treated. Do you kno. that it «. a genera rule in -.ormary that administrative officers, '.Jehrmacht officers, etc., hod specific orders, according to -hid. the so-mlled top secret matter, were to be handled only by people *0 .ere specificslly authorised ta. A Tee’ that .as the case even before the -nr .hen my personnel .ere drafted into the any. 1 ™ obligated. 1 put the paper, into the safe nyself. 9 Cm you also say that an the basis of this order authorised people .ere obligated by a handshake and .ere inf.muvi sf the rrovisi.ns af German la., that If they failed to maintain secrecy they «ould be subject to severe penalty ar.d tc the death during wartime. A Yes, 1 knew that when the utilization erders came rut 1 vyAt ms obligated to secrecy by a hmdshske by m>- superior authority, and I tola that there .ore severe penalties aid perhaps even tho.death 7397 penalty Court 1. jSay i2-«-l4-l-HU-iteehan-Von 3ohon-Brown. Then this obligation Co was a general secrecy measure In the Interest of the security of the German Aeioh? jt. I assume bo, as the 03t„ of office of the cl 11 servant Is the basis of his function. Q. Now, the second subject I should like to bro?ch. Ihe Prosec/.tor has charged yo- on the basis of Document No. 1313 in Document Boob 17, page 6 of the En-llsh Document 3oob. This la the letter that Dr. Hoelrel sent to you? a. It Is on pa Q e 4. Yes, p-ge 4. It le d-*ted 2R August 1S-10. I an now Interest d only in the date. I doU14 11* to discuss this letter with you briefly. Do you have the boom before *ou now? A. No, I handed it In. yjl. .iaRDY: May It please Your honor, jofeneo Counscx has stated erroneously that the Prosecution has o.vr,cd this witness with some activities.. I don't know what no Is referring to, in connection with this doouaent. 1 merely put tne document to the witness for »r. explanation, I .won't charged the witness with anything, to my know¬ ledge, end I wish that to be clarified. DR. FROBoCHAaKN: Mr. Pr.eldant, I quite a a reo with the Prosecution, but I do believe It will help the Tribunal If I aid ash one question re^rdm* t..ls letter. •THE PRESIDENT: Counsel may propound the question. 3Y DR. FROESCHMANN: i. In this letter on o t .e 4 I shell- c-nd />u cne document. “That bee endered to ce the wor.-. in tne Child¬ ren's House was r.ot the scientific interest, ouc the physician's urge, midst our often frltless Woov, to nelp nd at least to Improve many of our cases here. Tne Court 1 Vgy i2-A-14-2-HD-Me ehar.-von3cho n—Brown. psychological evaluation, and the curative and pedagogic influence were always much closer to ay heart than anatomical curiosities, no matter how interestln- they were. atA sc it comes about that, aUl-uu^n I am sure that I can preserve ny full objectivity In 5 lvir.g expert opinions, - feel my¬ self somehow tied emotionally to the ohiliren as t.ielr medical guardian." Doctor, my question to yo Is, It can be seen from tnla letter of Koelrel that at th: ; timo you wanted to commission him with the dlreotlon of this children's home, so that he could anoly new therapeutical methods there? A. I cannot deny that possibility, but it lo also possible that at the time the first questionnaires were -iven out for the registration of these o.illdren, I don't remember. Q. Thank you. The third question. *t the conclusion of your testimony, It was cold that you, witness, did not ask the consent of the parents of the children who wero to be subjected to Euthanasia? A. No, that was not done. Q. Now my question lo, do you know that the oor.sent of the parents for admission to the Children's nomo end thuo to the possibility of Euthanasia had to be given to the Affitsarzt? a. 1 know that the Amtearzt could send the children to the Institution on the basis of the questionnaire. I also know that the children could be accepted only tith the consent of the parents. The child simply came to me, I did not ask the oarent's consent either. They were sent by the Amtsarst or by the family; but I don't know that the parents were told about the treatment given to t.io Children. 73f? Court 1 . -a;' 12-A-14- 3-aD-lfe e ha n- vonacho n-Brown . This zorninB you said, in answer to a questi.-n v- the Prosecutor wnlch had to do with t.ie .ollect^i. of Jewish centel patients in your institution end cneir later ;ransfer to Poland; do you renenber Chat? A. Yes. I put to you now document Ko. 1175, r..o of tne transfer of the oetler.ts enuaereted In the list below to a Helen Institution." I don't know the letter. q. You do know tnls letcer, don't you? a. No, I never saw it. Q. Your administrative officer saw It, Is Cnac wnat you xean? a. No, we did not fill that out, we nevav saw ic. q. You don't understand av queacion. If e trans¬ port train reac.ied your institution and fetched awa; ostients, you h£d previously received s.'ae sort of notice to prepare for the transport a certplr, r.umcer of patients; Isn't that so? a. No, the method w cs a 11 tele different. I-wp.s jlven Court 1 •'•sy lc-«-*4—4-nJ-Meehan-von 3c.ior.-5rown. transport ll6ts; these lists said that the patients were to be picked up on such and such a day by the General Patient Transport Company. Q. And then the lender of tills transport filled out this certification that you Just read? A. I don't know, I merely n. d him 6 lve me a confirma- % tlon that he had taken such and such patients. Q. -.nd It says here, *Ir. accordance with the decision of the State Ministry of the Interior, A have, upon order of the Reich Association of cental Institutions." A. I don't see that. No, this is cl a ned by the commissioner. Q.. But In the c r.flrmatlon ltseir, It says, "In accordance with tne decision of the otatc Ministry of the Interior and ucon order of the r.eich «asoolatl.-n cf Mental Institutions;" I lay particular weight upon these two words. New, If you will turn a Tow p Q oe over where I stuck the little slip of paper, this is a llGt 01 the Jewish patients who wore taktn away or. 20 ae>tambnr 1540, Is tnere an accompanying letter? A. No, there is no accompanying letter, no, no. i. Please examine the document carefully. a. Oh, yea, here It Is; on pa t e 13, you mean. Q. Now, when adult Incurably Insane pers< r,s were fetched was there not a ;rlnted form that woe used? a. No, this paper — the patients were taken by me today, leader of the transport, Eglfln^-Haar and the • date that Is by me, because I told tne man I wanted a receipt for the patients, otherwise he would not nave lver. me any. C*. Now, from tr.l3 document please note; that ra.srd- in.i ell other Incurably insane persons there were fora 71U Court 1 12-rt-l^-5-jO-Keehar.-von echon-Brown. lists of transports which were printed; you find transport lists six, seven, eltht, etc. «. I don't b9lleve I filled them out, I don't know, i.. I don't believe you did either. I simply want so ask you, end this is tne molnc of my wnole series of questions; in tne transport of 20 September, 19-*0, in t.-is document I nave shown you, t..ia list of ths Jewish patients; wrs t. l6 list also centIn *d in the printed form or was it made up especially by you? «. I am sorry, I did not understand your qu3~tiun. %. In the document 1 heve Just tut to you, tne Hat of the 'V.elsh patients, of 20 September 1940....? a. The 23rd you mean? 4. No, the 20th. a. The 20th? Or. pa d e ie it says 23. Q. Veil, never mind the dete, et least its Sopton'oor 1940. Let's go on. Now, I will p.ak you again. Io this list on a printed fora list for transports, or is this list of tne Jewish patients somethin! that you yourself prepared on a special poper? a. Ho, that la the list v.lon I was O lvon, it is a transport list ,lvln e the names end tr.elr datae of birtn. i. And who wrote this trane-jort list? a. I received it from the tr?n6oort uom any rs far as I know. I don't ..now exactly how it wrs in the trens- f,-r of the Jews, but in eny case tr.t transport ovmpany :r>ught the list. It orobr.bly cam from the minis#;' in Munich* I don't know. If I understand you correctly, you said five minutes a^o that 'ou sew to it t. $ ;ou ot eucn a list so you would nave somethin- in your mends b; vey o. a receipt? 7hC2 12 nay-»-GJ-l5-l-Kaynos-(vcn 5chcn&3rcwr.)- Court 1 case 1 « Mo, no, that is 2 misunderstanding. I got a receipt, a certif¬ icate cn 2 ropy of the. transport list. The acn in charge cf the transport had a list, an I had earlier receive ‘ a list of tne patients who were qcing to be picked up, and on the list which I hail receive.’, on the car¬ bon copy of it, I had had thu nan vivo s. a certificate that he had taken these patients. That is hew it happened. Q Then this e mir.*, you said ols: that you were toll that these patients were taken to Poland? A The nan in charge of the transport told m_ that, I believe. Q An I wren; in saying that on Fri'ay aornin,; you seM that theS- Jewish ncntal patients were to be sent to a Bavarian Jewish institu¬ tion? a I can't remember s.yinr that they went to a Bavarian institution, but a Jewish Institution, an institut. for Jewish insane patients, but I Icn't renenber exactly. Q Do you kr.'w, Doctor, that one cf the Jewish women named cn this list died ir. 3c ho In, according to your own r-pert? A No. 'hen I got a book cr a ccllccticn of documents, free you, I found something, in there about death notice in Schelra. I can't re¬ member the name? 3chela. Q New, -noth.r question. «hen w.*.a th; second co-tini. in i\,rlin in "hieh you took pert? A The no.ting cf exp-rts? Q Th- escen acting. a I don't knew Dee ter. Kith the best intentions, I can't renumber. I havw s-i,'. so r^peate.ly, but it was about I think, a few nenths,per¬ il haps threw ninths, later. I cn't know exactly. Q In connections with this meeting, you w.re th*n asked t<: take up your activities that is how it was. . Doctor, you h27„ repeatedly said, that it was in y-air ideas it the first zee ting that this was tc b_ a total registration .f oil insane p.rs ns for the purp- Se -i transferring then separate mental 12 -»ay-*-GJ-l5-2-ri-:ync3-(v' n Schcniorcwr.)- Ccurt 1 case 1 institutions; is that sc? A lea. l Now, in the course cf the scc^r.-’ acetin^j was there any tonticr. of any measures, without us in. tha wor'""’ euthanasia," which i l, however refer tc euthanasia? n Lector, this questicn is Very 'ifficult tc answer. I cannot deny the possibility. I eonset ren.nb.r anything in -.tail in .ni3 connection, tut I really roust a tit the pcssibility that euthar. sia cr measures for c linin'tine such patients wen. discussed, but I repeatedly saiJ in Frankfurt, toe, that eftor all these years or.t 1 in view of my con¬ dition ir. cannot raseofcur details. Q Consequently, you will .alac a.fait the possibility that wh-n carrying cn ycur activity s an exp.rt you knuw, if not inletsil, then at anynte in gen_r.Vi, that the purp.se of tills expert activity was tc separate the curable from the incurable rental patients? A Yes, of ccurao. Q Non, cn-j last question Dec ter: You were specifically instructor’ by the tribunal to refuse tr. answer questions that nipht serve tr incri¬ minate ycu. You hav. aae no use of that ri:ht, an:’ particularly in ans¬ wer to the qye.-ticn ef the 'rcsccutcr, s to h r. cany children there wer- whose lives y u shortened in ycur institution by the use ci luminal ycu answers: 1 . in a neat credible way that you gave - mercy death tc ICO or 120 -f these wretched creatures. A I don't rececb-r the nucb.rs .xactly. Q I js n.-t a r such interested in th. actual lumbers as in the fact. You further replied, ith na regard lor ycur p rs. nr.l safety, that y-'u haJ been known as an advocate of euthanasia for c~re than twenty-fiv. years. Is that true? A Yes. Q Ycu also said explicitly that in cases naifonce’. or feeble- ::in'e-J children you felt justified, ir. view of the -.ir.ist rial deci- sitn an f what was s :i: in this «. ..pert c nl rer.ee in rrantin; th.se 1? kay-n-GJ-15—3-^3 r ncs-(v in SchcaJtBrcwr.)- Ciurt 1 case 1 children euthanasia after ycu had received previous authorization to dc so, is that true? A Yesi Q Finally, you a Ini t tod ini scil that the Banner of administering death that yeu chest was th. s-'vh^ that cculd put these pc-r children cut of their nis-iy with thhcn you received the questionnaires ruenrJins the inaurablo nen- tr.l eases, you ha ' to fill then wUt? A lee. Q qucstioi is: Regarding hew many Dental cases, approximately, 'id y:u fill cut these questionnaires? a I don't remember. I think it w?.3 less than 1COO. Q Uas than 1COO? n Yes about a thir'. Q fttre foreigners aacn thus? A I can't rcDoct-r any foreigners. I lon't kr.rw exactly. I had a few. 3 k.w many cental patiuits were taken away, transferred, from your 7U05 institution? 12 x-.y-A-GJ- 15 -i-*-yat 3 -(vcrCchan£t=rowr.)- Court 1 case 1 « Dc you tear. peti-nto f-ra ty cun institution? 4 I scan only your cur. incurable ones* « Certainly csry loss than the r.uaxr if questionnaires. Q I want to ask ycu h_w aany approximately. A Veil, aporcxiEhtely, nay be 50C to 600, I estimate. It was lik- thic: These transports generally effected the pocplo in transit. ii I slcply wanted to knew roughly hew tuny of the pc epic c«-vcn.i by questionnaires were in the course of tine transforrei elsewhere. A I can't , ivc figures cxaotly, cf course, but ccrt-Lr.iy net as cany as recorded in the questionnaires. W And these questi nnaircs whieh * rc caie out by you, they were expertise*, by other exp- rts? A Yes, cf course. They wore dene by ether people. Q Maw, if they were expertize' with, a plus sl*n, were they pretty -uch in the cane, prop* rti-n as the questionnaires "hich y:u yrurscli expertized? litre there core or wrr. there ltsr? A Quito a number of eases which 1 ha ju ye positively vt-re not pic¬ ked up. Q In ether werds tc the best cf ycur kn-wlt.'ge, the patients whew you sesifnato.' as p'sitive were .pparently declare. 1 by ether experts to be re.-.iy for euthanasia? a I cannot t- el you the reason why they were not picke. up, l octcr, There -ieht nave been scdo other reason., but the transfer c-a«>s sent to ny institution freo .diet institutions were Oen3i!eroi srre urgent for transfer than ay cwn ca3.s, nd for that reason perh'.ps ny own cases were put aside. I cannot say, bec-.ust the project ‘id net i.c cn. I ion' t knew the reasons. q Doctor, tbc3 aernin-s the -rcsccuticn brought to ycur attention the nuaber cf questionnaires that yeu hat expertised. I> y*u rcaecb. r that? .. Yes. ■:< .-.t the last Breen- I set h i ' cf one rr the questionnaire f th 12 Hay-n-OJ-15-5-fiayn^-(ven Schcnirrowt)- COUTt 1 CESw 1 original typo. I cannot of course, pat this qu-sticunoirc ir. as a ’.c- cuacnt because the tine available is tar sh rt, but, with the p'-missicr. .t the Tribunal anl the Prosecution , I should like v. shew such a qut>s- ti nmirc fora tc th- witness an: ask hie to tell the Tribunal briefly, if possible, whttbor the c-ntents of such a qu.aticnr.aire, if it sets fewn the ceniitirn very briefly of the patient, whether it could be put aside by you as positive, n nassc, so to speak, ir whether or r.:t it couldn’t be sc r. right free the beginning that hun.’rc ls of tho questionnaires «r. fille out incorrectly .n* so tn just put os lie. Hew was that? Court 1 '.•Jay 12-«-l5-1-HD-iro66-Brown-v r. donon. a. In meny cases In fillin- out questionnaires I sew from the very be*innln. thnt t is w; s not a ceea ior transfer. In oth.r caee6, hovover, I ves cal* t <= immediately, If It v s filled - it ri-^t - t.. t is ar, old idiot, that la congenital ldlo-ty , t t le an Id case of schizophrenic deterioration, whore j ~ c.-n jud a only positively. * HR. HnRDY: Froaecuti n h a nj objection ; aa of cnls document, your .-onor. THE ?R£oID£.;T: Counsel may proceed. Witness, please Uhe e loom : t..is question¬ naire. .-ow, fr.»m vn t ; «a s e there o. n you ary whither this man la plus or olnua, or Just what is he? a. as I aiopoaed to form • Judgment on the oitlent on this fora? i. The entri there. a. It aejoa to oc that It la not filled i ut C'.m letely. It ar.ye nere — First of all, it la not dear.... liR. HuRDY: Just a moment, witness. My it ?leroc . ur r.'.nor, apo-rently I misunderstood tna Import of Defense Counsel's queetlon. I th.ugha ..e merely wanted t. use the questionnaire as a fora to out to the witness. There rre aome oencll notati.r.9 v.n c is fora, however, It doesn't appear fr a ay qiicfc o*rued r.d a. 1 ca of uarmen Knowledge th*>t this purports to oa an c > ilo?tion or e questionnaire completely filled .ut In sale winner that he would h ve received sue., a question. Ire w.ian he was acting Ir. his capacity e<3 :n expert. If C.. t ie wh t Defense Counsel deelres to do nere, I su- est t.-at he .utllne a hypothetical ( lesti n in fer mors ha.ail than he has done on thrt queetl-nnaire and explain to Court 1 May 12 -A-lo- 2 -Hio-Grc ss-3rown-von-3chor.. the Tribunal his purpose. Thus far I can't ascertain his pur ose, what Is on the questionnaire, and obviously the witness can't either. DR. FROESCHHidili: In showing this questionnaire to the witness In Its German crl B inal I wanted to a ive the witness the opportunity to read the contents of the questionnaire end tell the tribunal what he hec to say about whet the entiles In this questionnaire, so th -c the Tribunal car. see vheth r a lrreprooch bio evaluation of this patient could be undertaken. That w: s the purpose of ay question. MR. HrtRDY: Your Honor, I feel certain the Tribunal will be as Interested as I will to hear the answer of the witness. However, this questionnaire has not been filled out, and If the questionnaire Is r.ot filled out I don't see now tne witness can answer the question caked. THE PR.2oIDE.1T: Submit tne dooument to the Tribunal. JUDGE SEEKING: Counsel, In t..ls fora that you have submitted to the wltnese thore appears to be a consider¬ able number of questions to be answered If the fora Is to be coniolete. However, in some of tne vacant spaces after questions appears nandwrltln- by someor.o. Those handwriting Is that? DR. FRCESC3U.cn: That I cannot toll you rt the moment, because durln e the noon recess I rcoeas I received this questionnaire, and a doctor wrote what Is on tilet fora In, as an sample, so to soeak. Nov,. I wanted to hear whether. If the witness had received such a questionnaire, he s uld Ivve been In e position to say rl Q ht off *1 can characterize t..is as jlU6 cr minus," or would ne nave to say "I w uld have Co return t. is questionnaire as incomplete". Co-art 1 Key l2-*v-lo-3-HD-Gross-irown- von Scnon. JUDGE 323RU5G: ■ill it not be necessary t. i u ask certain preliminrry qaestl-ns before . oa c -c to th't question? Gr.a, to the witness, "rfn t is the t> ^er ^ now nana you" “Jo yi»- reco 5 nlze the f;rm?" If he b. ould 0a y, "Yes, It is e fore often u-ed by is In ur clinical wor* in determining the diagnosis end oro^nosls of a disease of a certain person," then, "?tote v.-e-har u v n„t the hypothetical clinical f lnain^ tlv t I n>ve written In this familiar or cemuere- with any clinlo.-l findings you have ev~r seen, or Is It similar to tne one thrt was used?" Then, "Can you ep.y fr.a t.vt c * of clinical finding wfai t w.uld ;i vo been your result, olus or sinus?" DR. FROESCa-oil'S: Thar, a y I sic tntt x be 3 lvon the wre a-aIn? The questionnaires re m Document book 14 II. MR. HrtRDY: Ray It please y^ur .-..nor, w;ula lc oe possible for the benefit of the Froeecitl-n th c Jafonso Counsel outline the hypothetical question set .ort.: in tnls queatlor.alre before It Is put to the witness :or r.n answer? THE PRESIDENT: Yes, t..e Trlbuiel see no o .joUion to cnat. DR. FR0S3CHAiI i*.: nr. Pr.sident, In the clinical •ascription In t. la questionnaire t..e follovin c is sale: ■Schizophrenia - 2 relapses - lest one 1917 - elnce 1115 final condition rcacned - ver; reatleee - eaverfu attests at suicide." It seys further, "Scniz.ohrcnia lew case? *No. - Final condition? — Yee. Cure? - Ho. Furthermore "Theracy twice. - Permanent results? - HO. Those are tie entries. ?S. H-vRDY: Xi fc ht I farther inq ire, Your & n r, Court 1 Hay 12-A-15-4-HU-Gro3C-3rovn-von 3chor.. what the note Is on the too of the questionnaire? PR. FROZ3CH.-.OT: I didn't read that.- HR. HARDY: Tner. I assume that the witness is to ignore the note on the top of the q-eetlor.r.alre ? DR. Fa036CHH*NK: ~Kc. JUDGE 3E3RING: Dr. Froeschmanr., I suppose that from the statement of facts that you have now propounded to the witness, you want him to say whether or not merely from a cursory examination ne would recommend tnis man for the privilege of a mercy death. Is thet the point? DR. FROESCh&iKK: Yes, that is rl^nt. Witness, did you hear the Junes' explanation? A. Whether I would Jud.:* this case positively or net. Gentlemen, tnlo questionnaire is useless. You can sec that In this minute I was not aolo to reach any doolaion. The Tribunal could see that, I wanted to nako a slnilar note before. It says 2 relapses 1917. *t the bottom It says, since 1915 final condition. Thet ic a He. That questions ire is Inaccurate. If t..ot man was in a final condition In 1915 he can't hrve relapses ir. 1517. I say that case can't be dealt with. DR. FROEoCiirfAld.: That suffices. Thanh you. DR. PFaNNKJSLLER: 3osldo6, it soyc nothin* about therapy. DR. FROSSCrfiUK:.:. That quite suffices. *'-r. President- DR. PFaUKHUELLER: Such questionnaires would never have been cent out by ay institution, tranks to my doctors nd the Intelligence of ay r.ursln 6 personnel. DR. FRCEoCHIUia>. But, you as an expert did see such questionnaires? «. Oh, yes, I very inadequate ones. And dues that explain your statement tnis aci'nlr.* Court i May 1 £-a- 15-5-HD-Gross-Brown- von ; ebon. that ou cuUld Cake w ole -illes or these questionnaires and aay they were coxoletely useless? A. Y e, I put n red line thv a. a such tarn.a end Chat w s that. Q. No further questions, your a-nor. DR. 3ERV«TIUS FCR T.--E DEF£i3*::T K«RL 3RA. V DT: Q. Mr. President, oleaae permit ae one question re 0 ardlna the nunb»r of foreigners 1 r cne inetituti n ct the beginning of tne war, in 1?32? 'itr.esa, v: -a'ny foreigners in c. e institution when the war started? «. Doctor, it is l-oos l>le for ue to answer t.ist question. Just c.noider, that vr s 7-2 years or somethin* like tnrt. I don't know. i. .’ltness, you auat hare s .je sort of 1 >reae:.v/n? a. No, 1 nave impression at all. -1 •*«& e .• few foreigners - I don't think =ore t .an 5 or 6. q. In other words, ou ore a’ole to answer t..e question - 5 or 6. A. But 1 don't know exactly, doctor, I can't re-e-ber any aor: forel c ner6 ft that tins, q. Ho f :rther questions. THE PRESIDENT: *..y further questions in bans If of Do ense Counsel? There belnv n r.e, .xs the fresco .:ior. er.;* further questions? MR. Hardy: The Prosecution i’s no further questions So .ut to this witness, your honor. THE PRESIDENT: Tne witness PFanonouller is m excused fr a the witness stand. May 12-J-.-3K-17- 1 -Hoxsio (Int. 3rov»n It Von Schoon) Court Ho. 1 DR. FR035CHLL.HH (For Defendant Viktor Brack): Ur. Prosidcnt, with tho poraission of the Tribunal, I should liko to call tho Defendant Viktor Brack as a witnoss ct this tine. THE PRESIDENT: .*t tho request of his counsel, tho Defendant Viktor Brack will take tho witnoss stand. JUDGE SEB..HIG: You will raiso your ritfht hand and tako the oath, ropoatin .3 aftor no. I swear by God, tho -lnijhty and Onnisoient, that I will spoak tho pure truth and will withhold end add nothing. (The witnoss ropoatod tho oath.) JUDGE 3EB.JNG: You any bo scatod. DIRECT XXUIH..TIOH BY D»i. FuOESCHLL.Nl.’: 'I Ur. Braok, ploaso stato your full nano. .. Viktor Hornann Braok. (1 luther of 18 Vnrch 19h7, certi¬ fy ed by the Notary's Offico in nnnboim and I ask tho Tribunal to take notico of it. I noed rx'. read it. 1 Titnoas, w« have r.cer r-achod the time when you er.torod political activity. Before wo consider this natter further, I should liko to discus? the theme tto.t I told tho Tribunal I was going to tnko up, namely Tc*uit IV of th> Indictoent, conspiracy, and I should like t® you v , ides euthanasi sterilisation experiments, you tod any oorr.ecticm Ith the pt oplo now in the dockj ncr. Hr, -rack, regardin'’ the question c ronspiraiy T ask you, which of tho dofendants did you know before l?u5? A I knewtht r^rus of ’dor. loser, ostock, Genzkon, and Febhnrdt. T nev’r talkod to ary of thaso son personally. I never had anythin; to Lj with then officially, I tewpersonally Sari Frandt, ~lcno, ar.d •v.Joif Frandt. I saw Tu elf ranct a fe- times when I was in Miml-r's 18 Ifcy I.?-A-AII>-l3~2-!felcy (Ir.t. vcn Schon L Brown) Court No. 1 office. Aside fron speaking to bin, '.as sin:- the time of day, T had nothing to do with Mb, I have known Blerva since -ha riddle or or.d cf the 1930*3, from officio! meetings where we saw each other and spoko to each other. Between the offices, tha Chancellery cf the Fuehrer or. one hand, where I worked, and the Reich Chamber of Physicia n s on the other hand, where Hr. Slone worked, there were certainly official connections such asthe Chancellery of the Fuehrer had to all Party and state agencies, tut I oan.not renerter and I do net believe that I over myself had any official contact with Blose. Q Dr. Brack, let b» anticipate here, within tho framework of tho euthanasia program you are charged with having be*r. present at the ’iirdeh corXerence with BLaao, ar.d having spoken with Mr. thoro; would you ploaso say briefly whether cr/ to what extent you lad official roiatiers or even personal rclatiorsMp with Mono at this ccrforoncu? A later I shell havo to •<* into rooting in deV.il, but about r.lom> I car. say; I was sont to thin r,.etinv or. behalf of Bcuhler, as Ms representative). Tho Booting was oallod by Conti ir.c* rot by Bloir.o, T do not roK-ssber having seer. Dr, P-loae thoro. I cannot exclude th<* possibility that Blorae wa3 also at this rooting. 1 definitely did not have anything official to do with Mb at this coating, and Blono navor had any official contact with mu about euthanasia. Q How about tho Defendant Professor Marl Brar.dt? A I know Karl Brandt since about 1933 or 193a. The acquaintance, however, up to 1939 was United to very superficial contact?, as in tho case of Bloae. Only through the outhanasia assignment from HI tier did I occo into closer contact with Brandt. I shall have to spoak about that ir. iitail later. 4 Q T 03 , ar.d how about tho ro3t of tte defendants? A All tho ro3t of the dufcndr.r.ts I mot personally and ever, by name only during tho trial. D r.'ow, what answer do yen -ivo to the question as too whether you ~ • *. or wish to deny having taken part in a conspiracy for the comission 10 Mey U7-A-ATD-l8-3-*4al07 (Int. von Schon & Brown) Court No. 1 of war crirea or crinea against humanity with any of tho dofondants whom yai have just Mentioned? A I deny having boon in a conspiracy with any of the defendants to cosaait war crinesor ericas against insanity. Q So far as you were concerned, tho Prosecution hasaado no limi¬ tation regarding certain of the experiments with which several of the defendants are charged; I mist thorefore assume that tho Prosecution still alleges that you could have participated in experiments othor than steri¬ lisation or outhanasia. Now, I ask ycu, asido from euthanasia and sterilization oxporimonts, did you have any connection with any e>porimcnts which aro subjocts of tho indictment in this trial? A No, I was not in contact with then, nor did I know anything about thou. Q I can loavo that point now and go on to tho noxt point. I must concern myself horo with tho affidavit that you mado for tho Prosecution, nils is Document No, U26, Exhibit 160, English Document Book Hi, pago 10, Gorman Document Book Hi, Voluno I, Witnoss on 20th May 19h6 you woro arrested? A Yos. 3 The rxxt day you wore sent to tho prison at Traunstoin, on 19 to the Moosburg Camp, and on 2U August 19li6 you woro brought to .Wirrborg, is that correct? A Yos, that is right. 3 You know that earlier I objected to the submission of this affi¬ davit in ovidenco, and also objocted to the conclusions that the Prose¬ cution drew from this affidavit. I should like to give you an opportunity today before this High Tribunal to make a statement regarding this, in ei *lCh connection 1 nay toll tho Court that with the agreement of tho .Tosacution, I have in the meantime received expert testimony on tho part tho prison physician. This statement of Dr. Buerkncr reached no through Prosecution a few days ago. I don«t believe it is necessary to rut this 7U20 18 Itiy 2j7-A-ATD-l8-U-4feloy (Int. von Schon & Brown) Court lie. 1 as a docunent in evidence. I assume that both the Prosecution ir. its corss-exaa i nation and I in my direct examination will keep the contents of this statement in mind. ?fow, witness, will you please tell Tribunal in what condition you..... HR. HARDYI Your Honor, this document he is roforring to the Frosocutior. has agreed, as stated by defense counsel, but if ho wants to use it he must offer it in evidonee. DR. FBOESCHAT'KH: If I understood tho Prosecutor correctly, ho wishos this document to bo put in evidence, namely tho questionnaire that I sont to Dr. Duorknor, with tho aid of tho Prosecution, and which then was answered by him, is that corroct? MR. HARDY: ?-i6-5-4ialoy (Int. vor. Scbon & Brown) Court No, 1 T® PREGIDBNTi That was not 3tated, Counsel, The Prosecution did not state whether or cot it would use the document if you did not. 71:22 12 Y^y-k-l 3-19-1-ifeehfin (ints: Von Schoo & Brown) Court Ko. I. HARDY: Your Honor, I want to clarify this point. The situation re roly is this that tho defense counsel sufcoitted interroga¬ tories to the Doctor of the prison concerning tho defendant Brack- At the snre tire Dr. Hocftwald, on behalf of tho prosecution, 3utaittcd cross interrogatories to tho Doctor in tho prison. Tho doctor in the prison answered all interrogatories put by the defense and tho prosec¬ ution. I subait scid intcrrogatorios are ono Document in its entirety and if the defense counsel for defense dosires to use said interroga¬ tories thon wo request that ho use the entire documents, that ho subait all interrogatories, rarely his interrogatories -a well as tho croso-in- terrogatorios of the prosecution. THE HIE3IDEOT: That was tho proposition as stated by tho Tribunal. If counsel for Defondant Brack desiros to uso this documont, tho or.tiro document should bo placed boforo tho Tribunal. But so far as I am advised, tho choice of whotiwr or not tho Document will bo uood at all, rosts with counsel for tho defendant. Pit, FiCCSCHTANN t !tr. President, I shall not uso the Document, because I con¬ sider that many parts of it go too far. THE HlSSIDEffT : If coisisol choosos that position thon tho Docuiront, of course, should not be referred to in any way in tho ovid- onco boforo tho Tribunal. Tho vattv-r will rest right r.horc it is now. BY DR. FXZSCHIAN’J: Q '..'itness, without reference to this Document, about which there was just .a discussion, will you picas a purely subjectively toll your opinion of what your st-ato of health was at that tiro and what tho co.asoquoncos wore to you as a result of this state of health you found yourself in. A At that time I was considerably weakened by undornourish- aent as well ns by tho period in tho Tr.aunstoin prison as wall as ir. aho .bosburg camp. I had so=c intestinal disorders, I don't !mow >:~c ;ly of :*afe nature, 1 laad vary painful spasms and I was aindor con- 7:-J23 12 Lry-A-28-l£-2-ifeehan (lots: 7on Schon Brown) Ccirt Ho. I. stmt radical treatment. 3esidos, during tho previous weeks in Ibos- burg, I had received very bad rnwa from sy family. Two of ay children had tuberculosis because of urdcr-nouriohnant. Uy wife had boon arrest¬ ed repeatedly and because of similar things I was very depressed mental¬ ly and vary weakened physically. About eight or ton days after being sent to this prison, I was called before an interrogator in this condition, who, without informing no as to whether I wae a witness or a dofondant, asked mo to take on oath. I did so and then I was asked and interrogated about my rork at the Chancellory of the Fuehrer, ny collaboration in tho Buthannsia question and ottor things including ny ntsborship in tho Se, otc. I was also askod to cake a sketch of tho organization of Euthanasia. That was pore or loss what took placo in tho first interrogation; this was follcwod by many others. I was simply not capable of coping with thoso interrogations and I oft^n tried feverishly to find words to oxplain setae evant. I was mistaken about many things, I was unnblo to romora- bor many things and thou I allowed cysolf to bo persuaded again and again to accopt tho answer which tho interrogator suggested as correct, although partly because of tho German languago and partly bocauso of tho circumstancoB, it was not always exactly true. I certainly v»a« not capable at that time of Judging tfuso things correctly. Tton, in tho course of tho interrogations, I don't know which ono it was, I askod quito cloarly whjther I was under indicta-nt, whether I was a witnoss, a d-fondant or just what I was. I said under Gorman lavs ono has an opportunity to refuse to testify if one oar. incriminate onosolf. This objection was simply rejected with tho remark that this was not custom¬ ary before Acuricon courts, that it had nover hnpponod that soipobody r-fused to testify and besides I was only a witnoss insofar as the interrogator was concerned arri ho did not have to decide whether I would becoaa a defondant. Q In ono of tho interrogations of 1 September 1939, you dis¬ cussed Hitler's order? 12 H"3r-.W3—19-33toeh2n (Ints: Von Sc non : Browr.) Court ho* I. A Y 03 , the decree ins shewn to .» ard a conversation I might say follcwrod tack end forth -.s to trotter this docrco tad tho power of lew for us. I nnswer-jd ttat in the iff iiuntive as well as I was ablo to express -ysolf ard at tta end of this talk the interrogator ashod m to sign an affidavit. It ra indicated by the whole interrogation that it could only bo about this one point, ttat is whether tho decree tad tho force of law or not. At tho next interrogation, after I tad said, yos, of course I will sign such a staterent, to ny surprise I was b ivcn tho affidavit which has been presented as an oxhibit. It contains a considerable number of oount_r-statcrents which I tad nado in the course of tho intorrog-tion. Thoy arc torn out of their content, in particular in thu formulation they do not follow tho wording which I used and tho interrogator told wj, or rather tho interrogator drew his conclusions, which I qysclf did not draw. Q However, you did oiy\ this affidavit; did you na.ko correc¬ tions or any objections? A 1 r.ndo virious corrections, but in many ca.Sv.8 I allowed cyoelf to be persuaded that what w*s written down should bo accoptod. This 1s tho only way that I car. oxpLain it. Because of tho long poriod of tine, fivo, six, seven and oven eight years, cy rocoliootion was very incomplete In many eases, but tho intorrog-tors tad written ovid- • nce, documents. In perfectly good faith, I agreed with tho interrog- tcr fcoc-rso since they had dociments in thoir hands, thoy had to bo bottor informed about the facts than I who had to rcl£ on my imperfect -er.ory. I don't think it is fair and I could not inagino that tho in¬ terrogators would deceive no into m-king incorrect statements as was done. Thcro is no question of .any dolitarately untrue sta.tonor^s. I could tell ir. dotail whenever incorrect words are used, incorrect sen¬ tences or when something was thrown out of its context or vhcro con¬ clusions wore drr*n that I never expressed, I must oxpl'in this. Q Witness, you have now stated your fund-cental attitude to- rd this rX-idavit which was signed on that occasion, and I ask you to 7U25 12 ilsy-JL-: 3-l?-c-Meehan (Ints: Von Schon <1 Brown) Court iiOm I. express yourself in the individual points where there arc inaccuracies. A Yos. Q I can now turn to the next point in ny case, nanoly re- rn-dlng Victor Brack's atitudo tor-rd the Jaws ir. th? pro par-ti on for the extermination of whom bo is alleged to have participated. :'r. Brack, what wra your attitude toward tho Jaws. A Precisely la view of tho charge that I participated ir. tho pronarations for the extermination, I nusi state ir. the boginninc that I never had aty hatred of tho J tr.:a, noithor against any individual or against Jewry as a whole. I rojoctod the bad onos and approvod of tho good ones perhaps to a hl(j»or do;ro- than is customary sen* places in the world. Q Did you havo personal friends :aong tho Jowo? A Of course I always had contact and I had some personal friendship with Jows. An old school friond of mine livod at our houso and he rs at our houso alaoat ovary day until ho wont back to South A orica to his relatives. ilQjr 12-n-3x1-20-1—3. Hasher (Lit. V .n Schoon & Brown) Court I, case N... 1 T.on tUero was another one with whoa I .v-s friendly, evon after I had fin is hod cy studies, end I :f tho friends of nine, oven today, who has .also subnittod an affidavit. D.d. PaoBSCHBLJOl: Mr. Presidont, I put in now as Ex¬ hibit H . 6 Djeucont No. 9, pace 26, troci cy Docunent Bjok No. I, an affidavit by Hr. Hans Offondorf. I have May 12-..-3K-20-2-Gal lather (Int. Von Schnon & Brown) C'urt I, Case Ho. 1 clrondy nskod the Tribunal rojnrdins this offid.avit, which is not in exactly the fore the Tribunal wishes, neverthe¬ less, it is r.n affidavit which should be acinittod bccr.uso it is cado in South -c^ric., and the Tribunal has told no that it would bo acceptable. THi P.iESIDBOT: .hdid you say infornod you, oounsol, that the affidavit would be acooptod in its forn? Did you 3ay tho Tribunal infornod y ->u? Dli. PitOSSCHLLaJN: Mr. Prosidont. On 19 February I appliod in writing to the Tribunal that Dr. Hans Ollonsorf and Gerhard Oilondorf had only on 5 Ootaber 19-16 sent no cncloso’ affidavit. I statod that tho ,ricinnls wero in ny pos80S3i on. That both .^ontlonon live in South «norior., and that tho two non had assuned at the tino that Viotor Brack was not beforo .an .-nerio-'.n Military Tribunal, but boforo a Gornan denazification Court. Thorof.oro, on the br.3is of the rulin;; of tho court af 27 J muary 1947, I roquesto-d as the natt-r that thoso tw > affidavits bo adnitted in ovidonoo cxcoptionally in tho forn in:which they exist, and should bo included in ay Joounent book, and, thoroupen, on 6 Mar oh I rccoivod this letter fren tho Sccrotary-Gonoral, which I now show to tho Prosecution, according to whioh the affidavits aro adrdssiblo. I, of course, r.ssunod that this ruling was sor.othin; that originated with the Tribunal. THJ P.ilSIDZNT: .#‘hat is tho doouri-nt that oounsol has statod? « J-L(. HOCHe.XD: May I hand tho docunont to tho Tribunal. TH3 P.G3IDEHT: It u\y very likoJ.y bo that this affidavit my be received as statod in lieu of tho noto. D.i. F.tOESCIflLaOI: I now show tho Tribunal Dccuacnt No. 9, Brack’s Exhibit No. 6. 71:20 cl-y 12-..-KC-20-3-Ga dllaghor (Int. Von Schoon & Brown) Court I, C^ac No. 1 THE PiiESIDENT: Just a noaent, counsel, until we decide. This docunont fron the So oratory-General says that the Tribunal approved pernission on bohelf of counsel for the do fondant Brack to offer the docun^nts. That doos not say end that is not in regard to saying they would bo adnitted. That porni3sion to counsel is given to offor thon in cvidonco, but it would not bo an ednissian. Tho Tribunal c uld aako no ruling that tho docunonts woro odnissiblc in evidence actually until tho nnttor was considered. I know, however, that here tho affidavit says that tho following affidavit is to be presented boforo tho denazi¬ fication board, and th .t f .Iso statononts in tho affidavits cro punishes' sovoroly, and, therefore, do cl-.rod tho follow¬ ing on oath. I ’.on't know. Has counsel for tho Prosecu¬ tion any objocti xi to tho adnission of this docunont? M.t. HOCH ..coord in g to tho ruling of tho Tribunal this docunont is not executed in tho proper fom, so tho Prceocuticn, of courso, objects to tho offer of this docunont. THE PRESIDENT: Tho original of tho docunont oontains sono certification in Spanish, which is under tho ncaa of Doitood, or seaothing. If sono ono w ml.l intorprot the certificate for tho benofit of tho Tribunal, it night be of assistance. D.t. FKOESCHU.JJI: Key I point out to Your Honor that tho translation is also thorc, tho Goman translation of the original Spanish docunont. THE PRESIDENT: The ccrtificatian by sono officer who witnessed tho signature, have that translator.. DR. FR0I3CKM..NN: This affidavit was originally in Spanish. Then at that tine I ha'* r.ado .a Goman translation and had it interpreted into ny docun.-nt book. Now th^re ust be a tr.anslati n of this into English in the English 7 129 -'•y lB-^-BK-20-4-Gallagher (Int. Von Schoon ec Brcwn) Ceurt I, Cnso No. l Docunont Book, that is, Bxhibit 6, No. 9. ili. KOCH.'.»LD: Y >ur Honor, I just h.avo boon inforncd by counsel for the dofenSo that tho original of the docunont is in Spanish and not in Goman. Jloroovor, I do not soo any certification that this i3 a true and corroct transla¬ tion fron Spruiish into Gornen. But it is not into Goman and I havo no Idoa who translated thi3 docunont into Goman. It i3 translated, I soo, fret; Goman into £n~lish, but thoro is no certification wh.atsoovor who undo tho trr nsl tion fr xx tho Spanish int > Gcruan. Now I would liko to soo a certification that any person who nr.do this translation is entitlod to do so. TK3 PlhSIDZNT: Y~s, that is corroct, counsol is corroct in that tho docuuv.nt book contains nothing con¬ cerning tho translation of tho doounont fr a Portujoso or Spanish into Goruan. It is now tine for roocss, an*. I woul' surest this natter bo discus 30 :’ and o on- si'.^rod betwoon now end tomorrow nornin^', and that counsel also c nsidor tho question of the competency of the first paragraph of tho .affidavit, and tho offoct >f it flight woll bo c .nsidored, to bo undo in liou of this, which flay be considered by the Prosooution. ILl. HOCH ...LD: Yos. TH2 PitESIDJfllT: Tho Tribunal will rocoss until 9:30 tomorrow r.jrnino. ('.•horou;. xi tho Tribunal adjourned until 13 May 1947 at 0930 hours.) 7lo0 mi 13 .Fester (it*. _.rcvr.) Court I c :ici-x . —soR2>» c __ c.- u-ifosr xhlJUl^L It the sailer cf the jiitad abates ^5 erica a^iinst —rl ar-ndt, et al, defendants, sitting . urnoerg, C-er-iony, oa 13 hay 1947 , 0930, Justice jeals preaillng. xl- ciiuL: Persons In the court rccu will please find their seats. 'Jho Honorable, tho Judges of ..ilit-ry tribunal I. hUit-iy Tribunal I is' now in cossion. God s-vo the United states cf jo orlca and tnis honorable Tribunal. iSioro will bo order ic tno court rocc. •jl—?—-ISi-T: hr. narsh-l, you ascertain if the dof^nd.-nts arc all v.csoat ir. court. T..w ...- d af-aLi hay it '.l'j-co your noaor, -11 tho defend—its arc •j;-oa-at in court with tao Question of tho Defiant Schaefer v/hc excused o the friounal yostorday. J—?—SI 1*11.Is The aecret-ry-ocaor-l will noto for tho rocord tho prc<,enco of all tho defendants in ccurt s-vo t«io Dofao'.-nt Schaefer vho is oxc isod by tno Tribunal for tno ;;ur-,osa of consulting with hin co msel. Ccunsol nay pr'wood. Yltio.x JtuCl - KogUEcl. .h 2 . K^hETi h«y it ile-se your ..onor, def-nso c:unsel for tho def nd;uit ar..ck introduced ar-cc Docuccnt . o. 9 and a-rxod it ua -ifc bit .o, 6 in yesterday's -ftorneon session. The prosecution raised objection to the -dnlssion «*f the document into oridonco due to tho fact that tno document v.i executed in Jraxil and aT^aTently tho is in Spanish, which h-s been translated into aoruan oar. is uo& on p-.,© 25 -ad 26. It o-JOars ncro in English, la -s uucfc ua tno deeuxent io only -s to tno ch-r-ctar oa tho • , *ra t defend at --r.ck, tne presec-ticn vitedr-ws Its cb;'ection, however, without urejudice ,io the ri^ht cf tne -ro3©cutio . to ©eject to lo- cabs of taif.jLtu e in tne future, In-snuch ... it iocs net coaly 7lJ1 13 .;jy-4r-JT--l-S-?cct9r (in*, arcwn) Court I with the regulations ef the Tribunal, The trosao tioa agrees to stiyil-.to on?* jdult this deepen t, if defense '•ounsel will in turn stipulate tlx_t they will r.ot re-d it into the record. In addition to that, Tour Honor, I have another point to bring up. Airin the co rse of tno discussion cf the ?rioan*l and defense counsel recording tie auccittlng of triefs 3-.fe.-e this Tribunal, it S*"- 1 ® -o if thora was u uisunderstandirg of tr»-.t conference vr.erein I esr.la-.nod I voul?' =a!ce an uttec-.t to unhe availaele closing briefs, cf the prosecution before the International hilit-ry Tribunal for the defense counsel to study so tn-t they will nderstand t .0 nethei tr.e Tribunal wishes to Invoice tore. I have ono '•ccplotc set of oriefs in uy ovn file and I will hand tnoso over to def.nse counsal. -ofease counsol aiparen- :ly uisundorstoed and thought I was going to sua.it 19 briefs in the case of .debontrop. Veil 19 separate copies aro not available. I uorcly h vo one sec and h„vo sJo theso avail-olo, and if 1 gave the iinrennier. taut . intended to sutdt core tuan th-t, I cust witr.draw it new bccauoo that is tuo only co-ies I h a vo available for tac defense counsel. % ila_ ?. In regard to the last st^ttuoat by tno prose¬ cution concerning the briefs waich were filed vitn tno Sesrotaiy- Osr.oral in connection with tho International Tribunal, counsel prer-nt b..vo heard the atateuent of tnc prosecution to the of feet that he has sale av..liable to tr.e ceftr.sc counsel t.ie only cosy 0 : tais brief Y/:loh fco h .s, th..t, therefore, tno 'ufonso counsel will in t-irr. h-ve to «tbiino th.it briof. For cy ?-rt, I did not luierstaad counsel for :‘-o >rea-o tior. to oay th«t he would f r..i sh 1 ? cepicg ef tne brief, fr-t at any event, th.t is all that it is cr> B «icle tc furnish. j.2. Ha.JTf: I h-ve, lour honor, furnished taa: vita one cosy 6f •-- closing -jriuf of each defendant Otfere u;e International ..ilitury -'rib-aal. ~ — I2A-T: The - -rosocuticn n-s therefore dent all th„: it is "•■ai’olc in order to uic* cf^r.se counsel b* allowing t-.a- to study tho 1? llay-.'£-Jj-1-3-Fcstcr ,Int. Brown) Court i fen cf ths brief such as the Tribunal desires. Did counsel far the Defendant Brad, hoar the statement _f counsel in connection with Brack Document N:. 9? DR. FHCESCKUAJiN (Counsel for the Defendant 3rack): I h.ve hoard nh: t the prosecutor said and an willing to dispense with reading th« t affidavit in such r. fern as tc have it reed into the record. iR. HaTUY: Ycur Honor, in addition tc that, defense counsol hes two oth-r dccuamts, I believe, of n like eh ractcr to this docuBont. I rn w il lin g to stipult^ the sane ccnditicns fer these two documents. THS .RESIDENT: In vi_w of Use statement cf counsel. Brack Docu- r^-r.t Ho. 9 offered as Brack Exhibit 6 will be received in cvi lcnco on: filud ns rn exhibit. This ruling of the Tribunal is without prejudice tc the right the prosecution to cbject tc ether iccurrcnta which fail to ccnply with tho rules laid down by the Tribunal, end tho counsel is free to object, anJ the Tribunal is freo to reject cthor dccun-ntn. As this ruling will constitute fer precedent for tho future, it will not be bin-ling upon th. prosecution ncr tho Tribunal, it is not decided as a precedent, \lith that understan-ling, these d-sununto will be received in evidence. Counsel, whet ore the nunbors cf tho ether two rtocunjito? that dccune.-.ts are they? DR. FTEISCKuAfCI: Dccunent !i:. 8, Document Beck Me. 1, cn page 24, and affidavit by Joseph G-rhard Ollor.dcrff of 21 October 1946, signed by hir., end p-rhaps I eiight also put in at this tiae Dccumont !fc. 11, ccurr.nt book No. 1, ar. nffi avit by Hans Ollendorff's wife, lira. Heine Ollondcrff, of 21 March 1947, signe-d und certified by a n. tray. * Thij affidavit -ertifies tho correctness of the signatures of her husband and father. Hew, dccunent X . 8 will be Exhibit Brack He. 7, and 11 ef Beck I idil bo Brack Exhibit lie, B. *KS «hBSlD2.T: Tho documents will t_ received r.ith Use 7433 13 :;&7-!'-JP-l-4-Foster 3ourt i undowtading announced by the i*rlbun«l. ihey vi! 1 not oe roud Jut vill bo u.dc ef the reccrd btfort the .rlbufi.il and vill be considered for irob^tlTo v-luo they h-v«. 2-. h-gt I eontitue sy r^ae, /our Honor? i 1 --— ?£ESIBB?: Just u =cu*.nt, cc onscl, until ve E^ric cur dccuaea*. — Counsel uoy r.roceoi. 13 Hay L7-M-A7D-2-l-Ueshan (Ir.t. Brown) Coart No. 1 VIKTOR BRACK - Rosuoed. Ttt'KCT m?aiftTION (Continued) BY m. FROSSCittAW: 0 witness, I rioind you again that you are still under oath, ‘Witness, at tho conclusion of the afternoon's session wo woro examining whether and to what extent you in tho period between 1921 and 1923, i.o,, tho date of your entorlrg political life, had personal relations with Jews, Wo stoFpod whan discussing Messrs. Ollendorff, whose affidavit booaso tho subject of soao discussion. Did you continue such friendships, e.g„ with Ollendorff, after 1933, too? A Yes, I an still friendly in tho sane way with Ollondorff as I was previously. I did not cons trio tho Party ar.ti-Scnitism tho way Hianler, Bornann and Hoydrich did, otherwise I would not have continued those friendships, Q Now, it was your view that this anti-Sonitisn, which you .Just mentioned, despite and aftor tho soizurc of power, would gradually tako on a more quiot for*? A Yes, that wasny opinion bocauso I saw in tho anti-Gonitisn that the Party proachod something of a propagandists naturo and boliovcd it would soon bo tusporod. I w\s supported in this view by tho various cases in which Bouhljr was succossfbl when reporting to Hitlor on bohalf of Jews, half-Jews, persons of nixod bleed, etc. Thoso offorts on Bcuhler's part wore directed toward helping Jews and persons of nixod blood not only in the T ar*y itself but in tho ’»chraacht and in civil sorvico. Q Now, witr. 033 , in the course of tino, as a party aembor, you becane f and liar with party's attitude toward tho Jewsj did this not make you doubt tb» correctness cf your views? A Those doubts only arose later. I kr.ewwhat tho Party view toward the Jew was. I considered it Just that .the Jews' influence should be United ir. a curtain way and to a certain extent. Tho fast that Jews had .ohi-ved such error as they had struck st as a .-iniiar situation t"> the 13 V-y U7-J*-ATC-2-2-He9han (ir.t. Brown) Court Nc. 1 power the nobility had during the influence of the Kaiser. In tho Kai3or's Germany the nobility did actually occupy aU tte influential positions and I found this to bo ur.ju3t Just as I consider the autocracy of any one class unjustifiable. I had toward the Jews no other attitude than the or.o that I had toward thj nobility. Tfe spoke only in torm of "ISaorus Clauaus 1 ' and I considorod t?.at justifiable. Q It did however bocoru known that certain violent propagandists attonptod considerable influonco, I rocall nan like Stroichor and his newspaper "Dor Gtuermor;" what was your attitude toward those oxcossos? A This oxaggorctod a wild sonltisn I always repudiated, Bouhlor did tho same and I can roaembor that Bouhlor made tho effort and was nearly successful in having "Dor Stuornor" prohibitod altogothor. Ho regarded it as a destruotivo newspaper without culturo and a dotrimont to tho welfare of tho country. Q Did you support Xurrberg in tho strugglo against Martin? A Tea, wo did, Q Mow, after tho issuing of tho Kurnborg laws, tho quostior. of anti-somitisn bocaco noro crucial? A Of courso, after thoso laws wore passod I saw that tho loador- ship of tho country ms set on oliainatine tho Jews from all influential positions in Germany, ^ithin th: froo oconany, I saw so many opportunities ind possibilities for tho Jews to oarn a living that at first I had no nlsgivinga, to ny own of.lco, Ant II, in the Fuehrer's Chancollory all ronpiaints emanating fron Jews and half-Jows wore worked on. I havo treaty -aid Just what they were concornod with, tho3o woro oenplaints * '-cut political oxcossos ant' all sorts of other requests. I havo already said that Bcuhier frequently had success here. • Q Mr. Brack, I .don't want it to bo thought that it is only at this ~ : Y.r.t at thi3 trial that you iiscororod how enthusiastic ar. anti- i-ito you aro. Lot jm ask you on your oath in conclusion if in your " 'vitios ir. the Fuehrer's Chancellory, with no regard for political 13 Hay U7-£-ATD-2-3-4teehan (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 or material gain, ycu U3ed yewr influence in favor of the people concerned and particularly in affrirs that concerned Jow3? A Tea, that ia correct. Q Lid ycu r.ct on the othor hand have the opportunity prociaely in your activities in the Fuehrer*s Chancellery to work on requests from % Jaws and to take a nogativo attitude toward the® if that had boon your persuasion? A Not only would I have tho opportunity, but actually that was my duty, but T could not rcconcilo myself to theso policies. Q Thor, you actually did the opposite from what the Party doctrines roquosted? A Yea. Q New, wo got to tho year of 1938 and to tho program of tho 10th of Novanbor. Nfcat lnfluenco did that event have on you? A Thia ojror.t surpriaod bo enormously. It appoarod to mo r.ot only svil, but also stupid and false. A friond of mine, tho director of tho Hanborg Torld ’’conomic Instituto, I asked to toll mo what tho reaction was in foreign ccuntrios, to this ho made a collection of more than 600 •xcorpts fron newspapere, which I gavo to tho Roichsloitor, and I also 3ont a copy to Hind .r arxl to tho thon Mini3tor Frank, Q Did this over orouao a vory specific roaction in you. Lot mo isk tho question difforcntly. In view of theso events, did you not want to resign altogether from tho Tuehcro’s Chancellery? A Of course I was strongly Dovod by those ovonts, and it was my intention to rosigr. Actually I had many other intorcsts than ainply doing negative work. Vy work thoro wa3 oba_rvin-. that somethin- waa going wrong and if something was going wrong, I had to listen to complaint*, make out reports arvd try to straighten things out where other people out of ; Vapidity or calico made somethin; go wrong. Now, the only way to do that is to request assistance frer. otrer offices-and aftor a whilo that becomr." r-iuoua 7L37 13 Hay L7-H-ATD-2-U-yeehan (Ir.t. Brora) "curt No. 1 Q But I want to knew if tho events of the 10th of JJoveeber 1933 did rot have seme specific influence or effect or. ycu; did you not at that time draw a plan cr viewpoint? A />s, I did. It was at that time I struck up various connections with private in-ijstry ard received certain assurances from representatives of industry, Q From 1933 to 19U2, in your activities ir. tho Fuehrer*s Chancellery, lr. cany ca3os you used yoir influence in favor of Jews and half-Jews; did ycu on thoso occasions simply havo tho intorest of tho individual Jews in ycur mind or were you coved by some larger principle? A First or all, I was concerned primarily with tho interest of tho individual, but as acre froquunt and core applications of one kind can: in, I saw that a a trugglo «is undcrrrcy here against an ontiro soyaont of the pcoplo and I did not consider this 3trugsl 0 to bo a good ora, Tho achif 3tato Oovemaent. I was deceived by the oucct^ses ar by the success that •‘ati'nai Sccllaisc hi. in «ccncaic fields, and party in the field of foreign affairs, and that is wr.y I ai_r.' t understand this at first. Q Did you later un^rstand it? # a I only understand thsi vvry late, in cy pretty .*icple way of thinking I sew this net as a r. a? n f:r criticise: but a s a reason to ivc «l • an-’ tc try to repair this ill. I was an ecployee of the Forty but certainly net a fanatical representative ; : its interests, v. Di i y.-u fell s? these principles in eing y.-ur work in that ffi- 13 ^7-!4-. to be 6 r coons toward ir. -.r.I saw this end a * the salvation of Jercary frea distress unusploynent. Icrxrpelitleal unity was necessary to achieve this and the Party itruci -.s the ccrr'c*. - m: i ward that end, Q New, let's turn to the year 15!*2, the year ir. which ycu left the Fuehrer Chancellery. *'hat was your attitude ir. 151.2 toward "ati nal So¬ cialise? Did ycu 3till fculieve that the .chraacht would win the »nr or iid you hove soar 3. 13 Liy-^O-J-3-a-C v.k-< Brovr.) - Court 1 a la 1923 or 1729, I taJe Hlarir.r's personal acquaintance. Ky Father a* that tis*5 had assieted ~rs. Hinder ir. p - difficult child birth atti this eiroucstancts br^urnt about closer relations between =y Father and Hinrdor, and thus I tec nadc the aequo intence of Purler and others wno took up relations * th ny father cn Hinder 1 s rccenman- daiiens. Q Yru then Joined the General 3‘ under 'he influence of Hinder? A In 1729 ur.' cr Kisslcr's innucncc, and I rtey say on his re¬ quest I Joined the general S3, and that hreueht with it autenutlcally entry into the party. Then fr's 173° to 1731, I served in a 33 unit. At the boginnlnf. of 1731, : was entrusts with the leadership cf a batallien cf ton ear. which was to bo na !t Inter ir.tc a notorize- squad In 1732 I had erffmiaod a further unit which was used cn special :c- c os ions. y What w.s yeur 3S nucher? a H was 17to. i In 1930, you then receivod the civilian kcoraticn of th-- S3, is that ac? a Yes, that is so. Q that was Its nucterV 13 Jfcy J7-!I-A7lU-l-Grass (let. Brorr.) Court Ho. 1 A 901. This happened because in the neuntizso a lot of non in tho ncantirv; left the SS, ccrt-inly several hundred. Thu3 I was one of tho oldest SS coafcjr3 at that tine. This circucstance was, of courso, r.ot without its influence on ay rola ior. with Himlor. That is how tho r.urfccr dropped froa 19UC to 931 - ny order nunber in tho SS. Then in 1931 on Hirdcr's wishes I sot up a notorized training unit which was used purely for notcr sport purposes ar.d nothing else. And, this unit later had groat success in conpotitions. Q Mr. Prosider.t, in this connection I put in as Brack Exhibit 10 Socwint No. 1, Doouaont Book I, pago 1. This is ar. affidavit by Karl Freiherr Hichol ven Tuasslir,"., torn 27 July 1907, signed by hire on 31 Parch 191*7 and ccrtiflod by tho Intcrnoont Cnnp official at '{ogenstnrp, Frxa this affidavit I road only tho paragraph or. nago 3 which bogira >dth tho werds "Thr.ro can bo no question of Brack's having ongngod in S3 activity in tho usual senso 'tiring th period from 1933 to 1939". I should llko the Tribunal to take notice cf the rost of that paragraph. How, in 193b you moved to "erlir.. Did you mists, nado of r crts to disturb those d^onstrations and did not • iltr.to to attack speakers ar.d aipporters. It is erroneous to bGievo • * Jl - S3 and tlv 2 SA on thoir own initiative wont through Oernnny if.- trouble and attackin'' defenseless bystanders. If an 5 : son nado 13 of *‘ i3 fists it ras done in salf dfen3e. Sooccnc would hit-bin and • Bed hi ;; t a asi*» and this rrastJw only tray that he erulri * i himself. 13 toy UT-H-ATD-a-Z-Gross (Int. Srcrc) Court .Vo. 1 Q How it was the task of the SS to dofond thoso demonstrations. Is that what you want to say, or di' it have a further task beyond that? A The SS had no further task. That is to be scon by the name SS, which "Schutzstaffol’, which a protection guard. It occupied a pa roly security function vdthin the framework of the Party. From 192? to 1933, this was the only way I could sea this, since the SS r.aroly, if over, was used for propaganda purposes durfr« that tine. I participated in propaganda activities only twice during that period. r * Kr. Prosidont, as Exhibit 11, I put in new ttocunont h, pago 9, of Document Pook, affidavit by lari ’ olf, a forn.r Ooncrol in the V/nffon- SS and signed by him or. 27 '-arch 19U7 and cortified by nysolf. I ask the Tribunal to take notico of it and to road only from it pnrarrraph 2, ■hich roadsi "Brack's and ny activitios in the ror. ral SS was doterminod by, ard rillod with, the dociro to h:lp the army unjmploycd compatriots to ot work and broad again, and to r-lnstrta Germany to ar. hcnorabla plaao in th. family of rations. In tho Go no ral SS, wo saw nothing but the Irotectivo Squad (Schuzstaffol) which was to quaranteo tho security A tho leading nor., oxposod an they wore to attacks from political opponents when appearing in public at mootings and .aass rollios. To counter such attacks and to koop political uvonta naacoful and orderly *.ns the task of the Gor. ml SS. 'to nov r observed any criminal activities of the SS during the yo re of our Joint servioo 1931/33." vitr.ess, what attracted ycu to the SS particularly, what sccnod to you to bo its salient characteristics? A In the SS, I saw an eabodiuorvt of the spirit of conrndorfftp end -* sacrifice such as ono could not find elsewhere at that time. I did not 'ind this spirit in sport clubs or ether organizations either to the tent I found it in tho :JS. In the $3 there was a largo number cf .thusiastie motorists with whom I had cocaor. 3port interest. Scorcising activities in the 35 kept no fren doing other work in the S5. Ihhh 13 Hay U7-H-A7T-on I felt I could have explicit confidence. Q Was politics carried on in your circles in the SS? A In tho circlos in tho to which I bulcngod no politics was cirri-d on it all. a tailed about seorto and technical nwittorn. Not only for no but for tho greeter majority of ry comrades this was tho total oxtont of our participation in tho SS. had no notion of tho Gor.cral basic policy according t© which tho S8 was being aini3od. Q Then you bocast ungagod to gat married and ycu rccoivod an OK for this engagement freo Hinelor. Kinder had r^proachod you and it win only than you saw that ocrtiin norms woro laid down according to which an S3 nan was oxpoetnd to bohavo, 'Tvs ms th. consoqu.nco of this bohavior with Hinder? A As I say, I had not concerned rysolf with thoso natters to¬ rero. But then I became ir.t or os tod in finding out what Hinolor had dona with the SS, or what his intentions *or: in th~ future. And 1 saw ir. the roan time Kinder had croatod a Fuehrer Corps, with ar. S3 badgo and I saw •hat 'tUalar intondod to v.: a special body of the SS. 1 hoard it called a "uard or ur. lit a Troop that *is to bo jl.-vited abovo tho r.ie3os. It •ir. Ms intention to -chicvo this through careful selection, through “turn discipline. In this way ho was going to croato an organisation on hich h. could roly with certainty in the future. 13 Haj h7-W-r.TD~S-l-Earrcw (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 Q Did you take any part in this inner life of the SS? A No, I took no further part ir. this inner life of tho SS. From 193b or. I attended no meetings of tho S3 although I had frequent opportunity. I also refused to bo moved to a SS Conmnity although I should have liko to havo cwr. house. Q Now, then, you rocoivod the death-head ring frota Hinrelor with tho data cf the 30th of Juno, 1931. Vow, will you ploasc toll us why you received this docoration bccauso tho prosecution charges that in 193b ycu received this docoration froa Rianler in recognition of your services to tho S3? A This doalh-hond ring, like t:» dagger and ot'...r docorations, was given to noabirs by th: RoichofUehror if they had belonged to tho SS for quite a while over, if th y hadrt«t accomplished ary particular sorvico. This ring is dated 3C Ain, 193b. However, I recall vory d ofinitoly that I did not rocoivo it until 1935 end I think it was 1936. I nantior.od this during interrogations. I me told, during ny interrogations, that tho date was n »Mr.o 193b and I atcoptod that statement by tho interrogator in good faith bocauso they said they had my S3 filoa available and knew that. I deniod it, ut later believed this. That is v;hy I si-nod it in the affidavit, tho date 30 JUr.c 193a. ftowuvor, in the moantlnu, I have boor, thinking it over and I s o that the docoration was given to rao much, much lator. Q Mow, you are lakir.; of y«ir second affidavit, are you net? A Yos. >1 Hr. Presidont, I now jxtt ir. as ’bthibit 12, Document ;'6, Document "ook 1, Pago In, an affidavit by Ur. ernar Post, bem 10 July 1903, of 1 J 'obraary 19b7, signed by him end certified by aa. Dost hero cohc„rr.3 hior If with the donth-ho^d ring its engraving and the dato at which it •as received corroborates exactly what the defendant Brack has said; so T ask tho Tribunal to take notioo of this document. Witness, yev 3 ust said that you did nothing more ir. the general SS. v.?cvor, you remained a rxsnbcr. *(ctt, ::’njr didn't you resign i:' you had nr 13 Hay -i7-it-Am~>-2-?l-irrcvr (In*. Karrcw) Court No. 1 furtfcor interest in the General SS? A Being a n-^.ber in the SS made no further difficulties for nc. It would havo boon sere logical for ns to go to the KSIK bocauso of ray Interest in sportj but ry superior, Hoichsleitcr Eouhlor, was also a ooebsr of tho SS. Further, I didn't rant to arouse any unfavorable attention by loavir »3 tho SS and what probably decided ra to remain was tho fact that by bolon^ins to th- SS many things, that woro associated % with my work in t!« Fuehrer's Chancellory, could bo promoted much better by tao if I wore a Berber than if I w^ra not. For this roason, after my transfer to Berlin, I oven had myself transferred to tho SD from the rater unit of tho SS to which I had previously belonged in ordor that the complaints about tho Justice, tho Gostapo and complaints concerning concentration camp inratoc could bo bottor roprosontod by mo at the SB, bocauso those complaints icado it necessary that wo remain in closo touch with the officials of thu Gestapo. Q Thor., I oay aim: up by sayin\ that ycu roaainod a nttnbor of tho Oor.jrol SS, for or/j reason, bocauso you had friends in it from tho years 1929 to 1933 and, later, bocauso ir. your professional career you found it noro oxpodior.t to remain there to ta!;o care of tliese complaints and appeals that you Just mentioned? A Yus. q Now, vfc have considered yair aoaborship in tho Panoral SS. Now, briefly, tho question 0 " tho ' ’a *fon-SS. Did you havo opportunity in peacetime to observe tho activities of * affon-SS units? A No. I received rry military training with the mountain repinonts 99 and 99. How, why did ycu Join the toffor*-SS instead of tho Amy? 0 A That was the result of an accidor.tal acquaintance with a ecmandor of a mountain division of the SS. I applied to tho J affcn-S3 in April of 19h2 for entry ir.tc it and requested ?ouhl-r to approvo ny rvice on the front. This tpj iver. to a at first for six months and was '.on extended a number of tiras. 13 fey U7-4i-ATD-5-3-KarrciT (Int. Ercim) Court Ho, 1 Q .'tow, what wasycur opinion of the- nil it ary activities of the Taffen-SS at that tics? A I regarded tho feffon-SS asan excellent military organization, bo cause its reputation after th, French Campaign wasgood. Its military accomplishments wore ovorywhero acknowledged. Q * ?h:,n y° u ontorod tho Tfaffon-SS, what ranks did you havo until you left at tho end of the war? A At first, I wasordnanco officer for a division. Later, I was again an ordinance efficor with tho quartermaster gcrcral of a corps. Then, for a time, I was tho su»ly officer of a division, and then I was tho quartermaster general of a corps. In August, 1 9hb, w comandor was sor.t to tho Carpathians to built up a lino of resistance. This p-ovod, however, to be impossible. In October or Kovorfcer, 19LL, I bocamj an export for tho V»affcn-SS in a cortoing-out action for soldiers in Denmark. Then, in March, 191,5, I becaao a transport officer in Gooring's staff. Q I subnit from supplementary voluiso .71, Document 1,3, Exhibit 13, ‘ l ”° 6. I do not havo to road anythin, from this documont. 1 simply ask the Tribunal to ta.'co notice of it. Otto Haslroltor drew up this affidavit of 17 April 191,7, signed by him, certified by mo. I further put in Document K, Documont Book H, Pc 3 o 12, Brack Exhibit Uj, an affidavit by ferbort Qoitnor, Uving in A*»ch, who also knows tho defendant Brack :rm that period and doscribos tho activities that Brack hiasolf has Just Ascribed. Ho says that ho nover heard of 3rack's boing guilty of any inhumane acts and ho says further that ha considers Brack incapable of conaitting any act of cruolty. This is signed by Goitner on 31 March I9ii7, and certified by a notary in Jfcnich. I fu-thor put in from Supplemental Volume 71, tocurent Lb, Page 8, Exhibit 1?, an affidavit by ono Ot,to »toopohl, of 17 April 191,7, signed by him and certified by He describes tho nature o tho fitting in the war zone in which rook Was thcr * tivdly ongagod. He doscribes the malicious attacks, >tc. 1 nOQd not 60 infto in detail. However, I ask the Tribunal take notice or this fccuwnt. I vrely point cut that it is his point 13 May U7-H-ATD-5-k-Karrow (Ir.t. Brown) Court Ho* 1 of view that, despite the inhumane cruelty on tho pert of the enemies, the troops were not guilty of such things. Toll ao, : !r. Brack, did ycu find cut of any activities on the part of tho troops to which ycu bolorgod which wore contrary to any regu¬ lations, to international treaties or contrary to the law3 of humanity? A I krow of no such activities. I knew, however, that my comnnd- ing officers w-.ro always against any sort of infractions and issued orders to that effect, to wit, that oxcussoa and infractions should bo punished. q How, lot no-remind the Tribunal again of rhat I put in as exhibit jfll, tta affidavit by Karl olff. Document Jli, and on pago 1C of Docunwr.t Pook ,ZL, tore ' olff aontlons his n--tin;: with Brack in Berlin In 19'.iZ and ttan lafc-r speaks of his connections with Brack in tho Serbian Front. It be'ins with tho words "I act Brack only infrequent¬ ly during tho war. 8 •low, wo have cono to the yo-r In this connoctlon... T.r. 1 TiSIDChT: (Interrupting) Counsel, before proceeding with tho examination, tho Tribunal will bo ir. recess. (A recoss war taken) 13 May l7-M-n“^-l-raUschor (Int. Ranlor) Court I, Cuso I THE MARSHAL: Tho Tribunal is again in session, DP. VJiBXt Dr. Marx for the defendant Dr. 3ecker'-Freysong. Mr. President, as difonso ncunsol of too defendant, Dr. Bockor-^royseng, I should like to ask that ho ba perdttod leave of tho scorning and afternoon sessions cf temerrow, Wednesday, boeauso it is nocossary for hin to have a number of discussions with no in order to proparo his 3ofonso. THE PRESIDCHTi On request cf counsel for tho defendant Bockur-Froysong, the defendant will bo oxcusod fron attendance boforo too Tribunal tonorrow, Wednesday, In order to consult with his counsel in connection with his proposed defense. This, of course, is subject to tho rceall of tho defendant if his cr.so should bo reached for trial prior to tonorrow moraine or afternoon, DR. '!ARX: Thank ycu vary cuch, Your Honor. THE PRESIDENTi Counsel my pro coo d. "y dp.. raosscaiAWi Q Witness, how wasycur no.nburship in tho SS concludod in tho yoar of 15U5? A Aftor ray roturn froo Doruiark, Bcuhl-r's had a nuabor of largo -ontr'*vjroi«;B with Brrrcom, bocauso Bouhlor disapproved of tho oroctlon cf tho Homo Guards, as woll as tho oxtorrinaticn ordor of Bornean 1 aj f*r that reason Bouhlor approached Gearing's staff went with Gearing to "b-rsalzborc. Than together with Coaring, Bcuhl-r ras santoncod to doath, and I was arrested by tho 3D, when I tried to establish contact with Bouhlor at thj Obersalsborr, and waoincarcorated with Deuhler, and a muiber of oth.r arsons. rher: wo wero told that wo had boon arrested by order of Martin Boraanr. because of anticipation in Goorin3*3 t rc-asca, and that we would bo shot, Wo wore brought into tbo 33 barracks at "alzburg tho suno wight, E«uhl:r told ne later tho sontcnco wn3 not executed, because the order had r.ot transnit ted correctly, On toe ovepiag " 3^ April he received too report that Hitler was dead. This I.felt freed • ' .ay oath towards *atler, I run; I'd with th Ary Scuth which cano 13 1—y_h7-M-A7C—7-2-Gill&ghcr (1st. Rader) Coart I# Cs3o I from ZtU7i and obtained ny release, DR. FH3DSC3IAXKS Mr, President, in order to prove tho assertion which was just node by Hr. “rack, I submit ths Document No. 21; from ny y>' rancr.t Volume No, I, which is to be found on pa go 63. This trill bonesr. Exhibit Ho. 16, I*, ia ar. affidavit of Werner Ibsko, who was bom or. 7 January 1913, Tho affidavit was signed or. 26 February 1917, and was certified to by m in tho proper maimer, I should also lik. to offer tho Docueor.t He. 2t, which i3 also to bo found in Document Volume Ho, 1, cr. a»o 65, This will bccoao Brack*a Exhibit Ko. 17. It is m affidavit by Fritz Gccrnr.ort, bom or. 13 March 1907, Tho affidavit ras sigrod on 7 March 19li7, and signed •y him. It was again certified to by mo. Ccurt So. 1 13 May 47-M-8-l-EHX-Keekan (Seder) I should like to ask the Tribunal to take notice of the contents of these two affidavits, which I shall dispense vith reading. BY SB. 7HGSSCHMANS: Q» Hr. Brack, In conclusion we should like to deal briefly vith a nucber of Questions concerning the SS which hrve arisen froc the Judg- sent of the International Military Tribunal and which are icoortant vhon considering your alleged neabershlp in a criainal organisation. I shall put these auestions before yai very briefly and I should like you to answer then with either "yes" or "no" if possible and only elaborate whenever necessary. I now ask you: fid you know that the units of the Vaffen SS were active participants in the aeasurcs which have led to aggressive war? A. No. Q. Why did you not bellevo that, ospoclelly after the Sudeten countries, as well as Bohoaia, Moravia, and the ncael.had boon occupied by the SS units? A. According to tho official publications of the Ceraan governoont we could not deduce that we were there concerned with aggressive acts. Q, Did ywi know about tho existence of the Eohnloin Froc Corps? A. So, I did not know anything about that. Q, Did you know that in a nucber of Vaffen SS divisions there were shootings carried out on unaraed prisoners of war and that this vae general usage? A. No, I did not know anything about that either. Q, And did you have knowledge that SS units wore used for the execution of the Gersenization plane in the occupied countries and also participated in the deporting of the Jews and fcrcignors? A. No. Q. And finally, did you know that Vaffen SS units were to have participated in the rurder and eistreataent of the civilians of the occupied territory? A. So, I did not know that either. Court So. 1 17 - J -*y 47-H-6-2-lEK-Kcchaa (rosier) Q, “id you know they participated in the extermination of Jews, politically undesirable persons, and other atrocitios? A. So. Q, Eov did you consider the subordination of the SS under the notch Leadership SS7 A. Froa ny own knowledge I know that the Vaffon S*>, froa tho point of Tiev of supplies, vac equipped by tho SS Operational Main Office. The technical commitments and other ecuipaent were arranged by the- array and therefore had nothing to do with tho Heichsfuehrcr SS. Q, In that case all the ordors for the coonitaont of the SS originated froa the aray? A. Yes, they olvaye did end I, as a supaly officer, recoivod oil ny orders froa tho orqy and never froa the SS. Q. Did you know that the concentration caraps vero under the administration of tho SS? A. Yes, I knew that theso casps vero under the administration of the SS, but I always thought that tho guards of tho concentration comps constituted a special body of polico. The political loodorshlD of tho concentration coops was under the RSKA or, as it was called before, tho Gestapo Offico. Q. Did you arrive at that attitudo because you know that Keydrlch was at the head of the Gestapo? A. I arrived at that attitude becauso of the handling of the applications for release froa the concentration caaps, which could always be handed over to tho Gestapo whenever they arrived at the Fuehrer Chancellery office. Q, Witness, you alreedy hinted and the witness Kederich'vrs also dealing with that auostion for sooe tine; you aado the ecaunintmce of . released inmates. I now esk you, did you learn froa these inmates r.bout ony mistreatment in concentration ceracs? A. Ko, I did not. A number of inmates, after thoir rolease, enso *.3 the Fuehrer's office, but none of them ardc any concrete etr't'oacr.ts 7U53 Court So. 1 1? -tay 47-H-6-3-£BC-keehan (Easier) about any nistreatment. It was Quite impossible even for ae to pene¬ trate the cloak which had been spread by Heydrich and others over the real goings-on in the concentration canes; as I realise nov, it was ouite iaposalble. Q, Hr. Srecfc, but at least you did see eoac of these innates nftor their release. Personally could you not base on the personal impression that those lnaotes gave you and deduce thrt you voro concerned with people who had been aorolly or physically burdened because of their long interment? A. Yes, of course I had to gain that iaerosoion in the cpbo of a r.uaber of these Inmates. q, You were also sabring thrt you spoke to these lnnatce, but you voro only able to gain insufficient reports froa then, is that right? A. Ko, I had no concrete reports free then at all, not evon inouffieiont ones. Everyone of then said I had to sign, I would not connunicntc to anyone about the Internal conditions of the cane, they could not do that. q, In that case you aro acroly confiraing what tho wltncco Hilscher has testified here In so aovlng e aenner that ve wore concornod with persons hero who were perhaps veering a arsk, is thrt right? A. Yes. Q. Witness, did you hour anything to the effect that a policy of exploitation was carried out toward these innetos? A. So. q. Did you over hear about the eysten of slave labor? A. So, I did not hear that. Although I knew fron the innates that they were counted for work, rt no tine, however, did ! ItSrn about the forn of slave labor as it was actually carried out. q, And finally, did you hear anything to the effect that experi¬ ments were carried out on ccncontretion cene incites? A. So, I heard nothing at all about that. q, Cn the basis of your general lnpresrion you have been c5-art S3. 1 13 ftoy 47-M-3-4-lcX-heehan (racier) explaining to us today concerning the auelity of the SS. Could you aasune that this highly disciplined orgr.nl set ion, es you expressed, then could he used for sees curder? A. Ko, no one- could lneglhe that and I certainly did not. Q, The International Kilitery Tribunal has used a nunber of oolnts in that connection es e criterion for the crinlnal nature of the indi¬ vidual SS ner. and for that reason I should like to ask you the folloving. Did you hear about the sooeches cade by Klaalor in tho year 1943 vhon he was praising the SS because of thoir toughness and ruthlessnoss? A. Ho, I did not hear about these speeches. Q. In the course of this coming'• oxasim.tion we shall cone back to that point, but I do vent to tell you nov that in tho yeor 1941 in January and in April of 1942 you had tvo personal conferences with Hinder. Thcso coaferonces pemitted you r cortoin insight into his peroonal thinking. Kov I rsk you vhother those conforencos did not com it tho thought that he wanted to uoe the SS for the execution of such plans ns wore nentloned in tho judgnont of tho International Mili¬ tary Tribunal. A. I could not arrive at that conclusion, but on the other hand I oBCur.od that ho was planning these things as the head of tho Goman Pollco. I could not a.ssuno that the SS was to be used for such pur- posoe. Court 1 May 13-K-S - l-E^-Co o > -Ra =al c r. Q. In other words, you didn't associate the Ser.eral So with the rlans of hlousier as far as you got to Know them? % A. No, I did that In no way at all. ■*. didn't your own thinking as an So nan play some p?rt in tnose Impressions? A. Certainly It did because In my capacity as an S3 men I never received any criminal orders. Q. In conclusion I may state that you did not knew "nythlng about the usln t of the SS for criminal purposos and you neither knew about the usoage of tho Waffen 5S for any such purpose u-, to the year 1945, Is that right? *. Yes, that Is correct. Q. And now one final question In this connection. Repeatedly and also In this trial mention was made of the so-called 35 system, did you ever hear anything ab-^ut that or did you hove any th .-ghts about It? a. I have not recognized m any form any existing S3 system, end I, therofore, couldn't have any thoughts about it. m. Hr. President, that brings me to the conclusion of tho point raised by the Prosecution rcgnrdln b membership In the qoueral 3o end tho Waffon 35 and I shall now pass on to the subject of the general activity of the defendant Brack within the chancellory of the Fuehrer. I shall discuss the relationship with 3ormann, Himmler and Hoydrick, and his attitude toward the concentration camp questions from the years 1934 to 1940, and I shall leave aside tho question of euthanasia. I shall try to do it as quickly as pos-lble In order to got to the point of sterilization this afternoon. Witness, I ask you to avoid repetition of everything thrt tho witness Hederich has mentioned here In a somewhat broad form. 7L56 Court 1 Kay 13-K-9-2-:iD-Cook-Ra-nler. You may perhaps refer to hie statements but please try to tell us something new. I repeat that up to the year 1932 you made the acquaintence of the Reichlelter Bouhler only passingly, is that ri e ht. a. Yes, that is true. I only knew him superfically. In the beginning of July 1932 Rouhler offered to me the oosltlon of personal adjutant. He held, at that time the position of the Relcho business manager of the NSDaP ct that time and * took that offer because I was then unemployed. ft. Didn't you nt that time make contact \#lth Himmler? a. I saw Himmler after I hrd been employed at the Brown Houso almost daily when wo had lunch, but our relation didn't _o any further than with any other good ncqualntoncc. ft. Veil what was your at-ltude in general toward Himmler? A. In general it was pleasant and Himmler certainly realized that I nad a oocitlve attitude toward national socialism and that I had a certain amount of personal confidence in him. ft. Did you also at that time make the acqualntonce of Heyirlch? it. Yes, I did make the acquaintance of Hoydrlch in the year 1933. ft- And how did you Judge him, briefly? A. He Gecmed to me to be very c-splclous, not open and really from the point of view of feolln B 1 rejected him. %. At the R9lch Party Rally of 1934 Bouhler received an order from Hitler to hand over the managment of the NSDA? and to found a Chancellory of the Fuehrer in Berlin, Is that right? «. Yes, that is true. He asked me to go alon^ with 7157 Court 1 May 13-H-9—3-KD-Cook-Rammler. him because ha wanted to have at least one man In this strange environment, whoa he knew and In whoa he had confidence. The task Itself also seemed very difficult to him and I promised him. I would help him as far as I could and that I would not leave him, and then I cnce more returned to Munich because I hed married In the meantime, and In that connection I may perhaps say that, without consideration cf future criticism, I was married In ay So uniform In Church, all of my chlldred were also aombers of the Church. Q. The XaF, which la an abbreviation for the Chancell¬ ory of the Fuehrer, Kcydrlch said was the bl e chance for Bouhler and ho said further that tnls agency was to be a very active agency for the purpose of adjusting, the very many deficiencies which were connected with any utilitarian systom. He did not have to deal now with the alms of the Chancellory of the Fuehrer, and I should merely ask tho Tribunal to recall ay document, which Is document No. 14, which was Exhibit 1. This 16 already In evidence and It describes the alms of the Chancellory of the Fuehrer, as well os the Party Chancellory. It Is true, witness, that there were applications coming In from all th-_ various Gaus to tho Party Chancellory and that they concerned all aspects of the Party and tho State? a. Yes, that Is correct. Our Incoming applications w -rc enormous. Within my personal sphere of work I had to .cal with about three to six hundred applications dally. Q. And as a result of these applications you gainod a vary lively picture about the political, especially tho ?.-rty political life and know about the general morale of the copulation? a. Yes that Is true. Bouhler, however, within the 7L<8 Court 1 May 13--4-3—l-hI>-Cook-Ranmler. frawork of his own tasks was not In q position to remove those deficiencies, which beerme- evident on the oasis of those ap llcatlons. Ke was porhaos in a position to make corresponding criticism when ho case into cor.t ct with Hitler r.nd sou to It that such deficiencies were renoved. He confined himself, however, to Bottling these difficulties directly with the r c encles w.iich were concerned and to keep a-'ay these natters from HI tier as far as he Could. He thought it to be nis task to oxerclso n coordinated and efficient activity. In this manner the Chancellory of the Fuehrer became an assisting i^oncy for all walks of life ana -alned a certain popularity as a result, nowover, ,olltlcal success could not bo achieved by that Chancellory of the Fuehrer. 13 ' lay—-—D 01*052 (R 2 alcr) Court :.o. 1 Q And hew about your personal activity? A At. first I was sitting in Bouhler* 3 ante-roca. fennel title was Chi of cf Staff, though I ria i>iv c r Chief of Staff in tho true sanso of that word, I -mat adnit, that I n_v^r had the personal ahbition to play ary political part or to gain any large position, I nereiy wanted to assist those people whon it was necessaxy to assist. Q Tho period of tioo during which Beuhler tried to create this chancellery as a coordinating factor in Oersan life passed v«.ry quickly. As Hodorich already testified certain circles ar&urd Hitler very soon realized Bouhlor's weakness? A Xos, that is tru., especially j-artin Bornann. Q Martin Bornann? A Yes. Ho was the chief of Staff of the Fuehrer's Doputy in that agoncy and after Hess' oli-u nation in the y-or of 19ul tho Party Chan¬ cellory was croatod. Tho real head of that agoncy had always boon Bcrmona sinco the very bo -inning in 1933, Q And Bor-onn was a hard working r .an, is that right? A Xos, 3 H- was in a position to grasp things v„ry quickly and was in a position to adjust hl-solf to any kind of circumstance, is that truu? A X^-s. ,\P far os I could survoy pcsititn frer ry agency Bormann succeeded dthin a very short ti->j tc gather a circlo of men around hi;: whom ho feraed into a strong organization very quickly which was suporljpoeod over the Part; and the Stato and this agency had no adjuting activity but was surely carry n. on power politics. Q A-;ain Hederich talc us that Pomann up until the y<-ur - 193li M>as sonohvat indifferent to Bouhl-r but toon “hen the Chancellery cf the Fuehrer ir-3 founded had of necessity to bring then tc a controversy. Is that true? A Yes, that is correct, Oi .ruanr. ta.-10-3-Gross (R&fc-lor) Cs-'irt Kc. 1 I c.uld alaoat say nost cf the followed Bcuhlor's proposals and that, particularly in the field of the Jons ana poople ?f mixed blood, he vury often adhered to the a unrest ion proposed by Bcuhlor. Very oeldoe ware complaints regarding political loaders who had boon misusing th-ir office given way to because in these cases Bcraann would bo called in. In eases like that Bcuhlor c uldn't carry his opinion through one for that reas n there was v^ry str ng controversy with Bomonn. Q Mr. President in that connection I should like to ask you to accopt c number of Docunonts which all r-fer to Brack's activity with- ln the Chancellory of the FUOhror which I shall not read into the record for tho purpose cf brevity. I should no roly like you to tako nctico cf the d ernonts. Thv-so croi Dcain-nt No. 17, Voluas I, pago U9. This is an affidavit of Gustav Gerhard Quast :f H.rnboburg, dated 27 Jonu-ry 19U7, sisived by lustr.v Quast and cortifiod by th_ Notary Dr. Lucdonann. This will booo^j Brack Exhibit 18. I should further like to submit Doctraunt N. . 18 which is an affidavit by Dr. jornor Schulooann cf Brunswick. This is dated 30 January 191*7. It was cortifiod by Notary H. Hardogon and it will bucono Brack Exhibit 19. Furthermore, I svfc it Docuaont No. 21 which is in Dccumont Book I and is the affidavit of Albert Gcdurbauor dated 13 January 19li7. Tho date 19ii6 ia your copy is inccrroct. This was cortifiod on tho 19 February 19ii7. It will beoo e Brack Exhibit No. 20. Fttrthoraoro, I should like t refer tc in this connection to tho Brack Exhibit 10 which is tho affidavit f Freiherr vvn Tuossling £ which I have already road. And, finally, I subrlt tho Brook D cuaont Bo. 16 in Document Bock I which is the affidavit cf Dr. Hans Grouninger, dated 20 January 191*7 arul signed by hi:j. It was certified by u~ and it is to bo found cn he cf tho D:cir-.ent B ok. I offer it as Exhibit 21. *11 thoso affidavits describe Brack's activity and agree in enphasising the 13 J'ay-y-DJl-lC-ii-Orcss (Bader) C-urt No. 1 readiness to help of the defendant and speak of all the efforts which th«j dofendatn Brack Bade in his fight against injustico. New, witness, you were Bouhlor*3 oldest ccllcbaratcr? A Yea. 3 Could 3ornann as sun i that you too tried to mlntaln Bonhlcr’s attitude of tolerance or was Boraann «f a different opini-n? •v Jfo. Eorr.onn nust have .assumed and he knew no personally froei Munich that I was working fully in line with Bcuhler and fer that reason his criticise was justified, I tried te think in a hunano nannv-r ^nri I tried to act in that manner. I wasn’t any political acc unting machine, I was on a car plotoly different level in tho Jewish question as opp:aod to Beraann, I was opposed to tho total¬ ari an syaton of the Party, I was against tho 11 citations of personal frwodcu and Borr-ann n. d^ubt knew that I was supporting Bi uhlor with theso thoughts, Q Wo aro new getting to tho cenforoncos which you had with Hinder and I should like to aok you, did you c'fton ns.ot Himlor in the yoars froa 1935 to 19ii0? * During: that tirau I very raruly not HL-tnlor. Tfo cccasionally cone into contact and officially only -hon Bcuhler sont me to hici to report to him. That in particular when we were concerned with roloasca fr r. concontraticn camps, Hisnlor in no3t of these cases conpliod with ay attitudo and ay wishes which woro also those of Bcuhlor dospito Hoydrichs' c ire instances and eppesitijn, Hy relate nohip to Hinolor was in no way particularly close. If it was a little closer there c uld have developed p-rhaps a relati-nship -f a fatherly friejjd but in ordor to say that I nust point out I sot him too rarely. 13 Yr li’’-44~ATi>-ll~l-Earrcw (Int. Haaalor) Cw. !rj. 1 Q And what was year relationship to Hcydrich? A ’*y relationship to Hcydrich since the beginning of sy activity at Berlin were alt/ays unpleasant and tense because the work in the Chancellery of the Fuehrer of ton extended to fiol£s which wore under the supervision of Hjydrich# After I had ostentatiously assumed an or.tirjly different ar.titudo and especially in view of political inmatos, and since I triad, partly by order of Bouhler ard partly on w own initiative, to help those people to thoir roloaso, Hoydrich had to oppose no. Ever sinco tho yoar of 193V T had to fool personally threatened. Q Tas, this was tho incident about which Hcdcrich had roportod? A That’s right. Q Jiow, vory briefly, did Hoydrich eonsldor you a ran who was comitting troasor. against National Socialism? A Yes, ho thr-'ator^d no with arrest* Ho said I was cocnitting treason. Ho aslwd oouhlor to release no fron my position, and things of that naturo. Q Hr* Prooident, ir. that connection, I should llko to submit a docu¬ ment from Document Book '2, which is 7 ,29 6n Page 6. An affidavit by Dr* ’fans Zhlich o.' tlvi 7th of fobruary, 19l»7. It was signod by him ar.d certified by a:| I should lik. to point in . articular to Paragraph 2. Thin vdll bo Brack Exhibit *22. I should furthermore like to offer ny Doeumont Y39 from Document Veluao 71 or. Page 60. This is an affidavit or Gertrude Kaiinayor, datad tho second cf April, 19b7, which was signed by hor and certified by no. This will boooae Exhibit ^23. In both of those documents tho attitude of Hcydrich towards the defendant Brack is illustrated and also tho difficulties in -which Brack, at that timo, found bins If. Ir. that connection I nay also remind you of tho Document ^rack /U, Exhibit 11, which is already in evid_nce which is to be found oa Papa 10 cf that docunant where these controversies are also discussed. How, "r. Brack, wo rop-atcdly discussed tho nature of the appli- :*• cions which arrived at eh. Char.collary and I need not doal with that . -y mere; thi.: fi.ld of fork, chose .'"fish irplicitiens and complaints, :tc. Tl6k 13 "ay U7—I '—A7T—11--2-K arrow (Int. Rasadcr) Court So. 1 Conplaints ft?on Party agencies and deali n g with release of protective custody inaates brought you nore and noro into contact with Hoydrich and Bomann, end nor, would you please say in that connection what your attitude was concerning th~ .right of the state to intom persona in an interment cesp where a danger arose for that person and for general society? A At that tico I resigned qysolf to thj fact of a concentration canp. That was net only true of Oorsany. In the neighboring state of Austria there was tho big concentration canp of TTolloradorf vheroin tho Austrian state loadership, vhich >ais than not Katlonal Socialistic, v.aa incarcerating th_ Qor.-nn slctional Socialists and national Socialists who wore th opponents of that rogine. In view of tho political situation as it prevailed in hxropo at ‘.hit tine T didn't consider that any state tod a right to do that, but I resigned xyaJlt to tho fact of their existence. If, for political reasons, you do plnoo persons into pro¬ tective custo«ii~ 5 -Kirr 3 W (Ir.t. Rasxalcr) Court to. 1 data of ay uotiier^in-iaw. After this I called on the Joiriah cornunity who confirmed on the following day that ay cother-irv-lar >3 nano had boon cressod out in the list of the transport." Court Bo. 1 13 .toy *i7-H-12-l-a=M-Keloy (Bailer) The next sentence: "In viev of the assistance vfcich Hr. Brack eo unselfishly rendered to ay aother-ia-lav and ay faally in our greatest need I thought it only Just and right to acauaint -the court vith ay experiences vith Mr. 3n«ck vhen I learned soco nonths ago that he was charged ns one of the vnr crinInals. "I have nade this stateaent voluntarily. No one, neither Mr. Brack nor ary of At. Brack's friends nor anyone else who knows of this affair, induced ae to sake this stateaent. It is very well possible that Hr. Brack does not even reneaber the whole affair or ay nano." Q. Hr. Brack, you have already been sneaking about the difficul¬ ties in which you wore when dealing with these applications, on which I have suboitted in extracts a cusbcr of oxasplec. Bo you believe that there wero only personal reasons which brought ubout this difference botweon Haydrlch and yourself, or wero the reasons of a deeper nature? A. As I Judge the natter now in rctrosooct and in the full knowledge of all these crlsos, I cust cooo to the conclusion that thcoe vers not personal cattors, but natters of a fundnaental naturo. It nust havo boon Koydrlch's aln to oxtercinato nil his political oononento in concentration caaps. As I said before air cad:/, I could find out nothing about that froa locates who had been rclcaeod. Hy own oosition woe far to weak and insignificant to lot ae hone that I could bring about at any tine a fundanontal change of that situation. I could do nothing but report those natters to the Eeichsleitcr, or sonetinOB even to Hiaaler. At any rate v<- did try, through the Party Chancellory, to go beyond tho applications which arrived at our office and belt) those who had been errested. Ve sinply ettenpted to forn grouoe vhifch ve considered to be suitable for release and we suboitted such proposals to Bouhler who then in turn discussed it with Hiaaler. It web in effect achieved that certain categories of persons, forcer participants in tho war, fathers of large feallles, forncr aenbers of oppositional parties were released in groups. I rescabor one figure completely. 7 169 Court So. 1 13 May 47-H-12-2-iS<-*aloy (Raaaler) because it constituted the very first success of this npture vhich Souhler had brought about. On the occasion of Hitler's birthday in the ywcr 1937 , 4300 protective custody inaatos had actually been released. In the yeers 1936 to 1941 the figures of those that were released, as a result of those Basses released I was speaking about, aust, I an sure, hevc increased to 10,000 or 12.000, if not 15,000. On the basis of the singular epDllcetions fr .= the relatives to the Chancellory of the 7uohror, to Souhler, to HlcaKr, etc., at least 3,000 to 5,000 people were released. At that tine we were proud of our results. Todcy, after knowing the enoraous oxtont of the concentration caape, as I can now survey tho nuabers that voro involved, I se« how ridiculously low it wus, whet wo achieved at that tine. Then, however, I couldn't survey it. rR. TROESCiMUGI: To ny rogret. Mr. President, I learn thnt Sueplo- nent III is not yet available to the Tribunal. For that renson I auot reserve sysolf the opportunity to suboit at a later date a docuacnt which constitutes a rhort exorpt froa Kogon's book "The SS State" and vhich io relevant in this connection. I at that tiao spoke about tho rolorso which vns curried out as a result of hitler's 50th birthday, and that was carried out in Buchenvald. BY UR. FP.CXSCEXAK.I: Q. Mr. Brack, ell your activities lead to e nur.ber of letters about you which were sent to Bouhlsr's and also lead to difficulties which were lncurablo for you, is that right? A. Yes. Q, You thoe tried to enter the sport through intervention of Reich's Sport Leeder von Ischoaser und Osten? A. That is true. C. iver since 1937 you vre an honorary acebor also of that organization nnd carried out sports activities there. Vhy didn't you carry tiirough that intention? A. I didn't realize ay intention of transferring to snorts e'eti- Court So. 1 13 Kay 47-4i-12-3-I3(-Kalcy (Scaler) vity cr Industry because at that tine the war had broken out. Sinul- taneously a decree vos issued by Hitler vhich vas a prohibition to lcevo any governmental agencies. Personally I vas not satisfied with =y work because I had too =aoy diffieulties and I saw no basic assistance was possible. The only resistance vr.s in single cases. In the final analysis, hovevor, I believed that I could not rcloese the possibility of helping singular people. BE. FECLSCKHANS: Hr. President, to sun up I would like to submit at this point Docuscnt Ho. 7, Yiktor Brack Doeunont Book No. 1, oago 15, vhich is an affidavit of Irngerd Grube, dated the 4th of February , 1947, which vas certified by the notary, Dr. Stophnns, and vhich will becono exhibit Brack Ho. 27. I ask you to take notice of the conditions of this affidavit becauso it illustrates the entire activity of Brock vithin the Chancellory of the Fuehrer freo 1937 to 1942. This will bo exhibit 27. This, Tour Honor, brings no to the ond of tho conplox regarding Brack's activity vithin tho Chancellory of the Fuehrer and I shall nov be in a position to go over to tho subject of sterllixation. I think this night bo a suitable tine to adjourn. THi PBLSIDESTs The Tribunal will bo in rccots until 1:30. (Thereupon tho noon recoss ves takon.) Court 1 '191 Hay 13-A-13—l-HD-Fcstur-3rown. _ m AFTERNOON SESSION IThc Tribunal reconvened at 1350 hours, 13 Hay 1947.) THE MARSHAL: The Tribunal Is again In session. VICTOR BRACK - Resumed DR. FROESCKaaNN (Counsel for the Defendant Brack): Mr. President, I pr-vlously neglected to put two documents in evidence that concerned the subject lost under discussion. These are document number 2. Document 3ook No. 1, pn 6 e 5, affidavit by Her.nlr.g Von Nordeck of 31 March 1947, signed by him and certified by me. In this affidavit I draw your attention p rtlcularly to paragraph 3. I do not, however, have to road It. This will bu Exhibit 28. The second dooument that I wish to put in Is document 15, Document Book No. 1, pa t e 39, an affidavit by Werner Best dated 25 January 1947, signed by him on th*»t dnto and certlfl-d by myself. Here It is stated specifically tint whole u roups of Inmates were rolons.d from concentration camps In what was known as ar. amnesty. This Is Exhibit 3rnck 29. DIRECT EXAMINATION (Continued) =Y DR. FROEoCHKhNN: Q. Lot me remind you e c aln, witness, thc.t you arc still testifying under oath. Hr. 3rack, this mornln^ wo went into your activities lr. the Fuehrer’s Choncellory, so far a6 was hero nocesoary, and from many affidavits that I have - could ascertain that you were always ready to givo assis¬ tance lr. the cares and tribulations of your fellow men, and that, particularly. In many cases you interdecdod In the - ^ • -:.turesV3 g^Jews. Nov, on apparent contradiction to thl6 chapto'r'wh'lch we aro about to enter upon, nemely the Count charging you with War Crimes end Crimes against Humanity, committed in forst order thr ugh your sterilization propose to Himmler in the course of 1341 and ’42. I ask jX r *°'' : Co g.O'Tnto this whole croblem ct some len D th. 7472 Court 1 Hoy 13-H-i3-2-Hi>-?o8tcr-Browr.. *. Both tho occurronces of -‘ovember 1938 and the refaction of the Jews, both before the outbreak of the wer and durin 3 the war, were not -nknown to me. 3ut I always hoped that things would gradually quiet down, and, actually, 1 had no thin^ to do with these th n 6 s anu could have some¬ thing to do with them only If someone in search of help applied to the office where I was omployod. Any Intention to exterminate Jews lr. 1339 and 19 0 was not known to me. If uch intentions did exist at that time, I can only say today that the persons who had such Intentions wero able to koop thorn completely secret, hiding them behind a hoavy veil. In tho summer, however, 1941, something occurred wnlch gave no misgivings. An associate of mine belonged to 3orm3nn'8 office before he coma to the Euohror'a Chenoollory, Oosoite the tense rolatlons between these two officers, this man 6till maintained personal connections with people lr, 3ormann's office. Consequently, ho know much more about the ultimate intentions of 3ormnnn'o office than I did. One day this associate brought me tho news that Choro was t.,o intention to find a radical solution of the Jewish :ro'olora. Just what the solution was to be lr. otr.il could not Immediately be ascertained by me. I couldn't find out whether the Intention was outright extermination. There was talk of s,.ndln c all tno Jews to the East of Europo, primarily to Poland. *t th. same time, tho onti-oametlo attitude on the part of the Polish population woo mentioned • .lch wa6 expected to led to cogroms was also expected. At any rate, all these things seamed mo6t dubious to ue. However, we ourselves, were comoletely 1 upotent to do anything about it. I, in my Party Office, oould not find ut anything more pb,ut these plans or undertake anything frustrate ti;em. Nevertheless, si roly because our 7473 Court 1 Kay 13-A-13-3-H0-Eoster-3rovn. conscience node ua do 60 , we aid decide to try to do somethin to combat this tendency. After wc of the Party Ch nccllory found out tnat these clans existed, only Martin Bornann coulc; be the instigator of them, JJow, whether that could be traced back to a wish on the part of Hitler or wnether it wes 3ormanr.'s owr. idea, ac tho witness Lncners stated, that I cannot cay rr.d I do not knovr even today. But the essential thln b for us was that Bonaann w s concerning himself with the 60 matters, and whon Bornann concerned hixsolf witn soacthir.tj, then things were very dangerous beoausc witn his radical point of viov we ad to counT on tndr boln 0 carried out in an alto b etn„r ruthless fashion. Thoro was nobody in Gornnny who could oppose Bornann, Hitler was tho only nan who oould give hin orders. 13 ' toy -A — j J-ld-l-Gollagh e r - ( Brown) - Ccurt 1 case 1 In the- tense inimical relation b.tween Souhler inti Boraann, there was simply no question of intervention on Bouhl-r's post. That simply »r?s to be reckoned with tlv. fact that in sea. icm or another, either in there beins, deportee, or in scathing worse, the ( .-»s were ^oing to hav “ trouble, i; any cnc had a counter suggestion, it would cf c:rst have to be norc in a similar direction, but it would be intended to rive the Jews a sccnhat better chance. This proposal would have to be taken ir.otly to Hitler, because only he war in a position to change 3ortuinn's nin.. Others Were too weak for that. Q Mow, *r. Brack, in your if idavit No. 426, Exhibit 16C, in this Document Sock, lk page 10, you stated,'Me developed the idea of depar¬ ting Jers. • Will you plcace say sonthirv, about that statement of yours? A Pirat cf all, the expression of the word •deporting 1 * was not my word, but it was chosen by the man wha drew up the effidavit. 1 alrea¬ dy said what I thought - - cr think abcut this affidavit, and how it came about. I was not aware at that time of the a.nnin* rf tho word. If : had, I certainly would have refused to use it. At any rate we were thinking cf a rc-settlenent in a decant Sense of the word, rather than th- deportation. Q Mow what was the political situation at this time? A In the Sumer of 1940 the situation in Europe ni.-ht bo summari¬ zed as follows: After the Polish campaign Poland was divided between Soviet Russia and dersvanyj Belgium and Holland >.ere in German hands, and Denmark and the Netherlands were under German control. There was ir. Armistice with France nnd a political approche3ent apparently, Ita¬ ly was cur nlly. There w w re good relations with Hungary and Yugos¬ lavia, and for or. outsider, such as I was, it sejaed as if there* was no danger free the side of the Soviet Union cr from th. United States of America. Cnc heard that measures were under way with premises of sucess •'ith England, an: everything sc-m-.d to p’oint tc the fact that the war would sot. be c-ncludod. That is the way the nercal aortal appraise- the situation at that ti-_. 7475 13 liay-A-GJ-lli-2-rown)- Court 1 case 1 Q And what attitude then were these countries expected to take towards the Jews at the end of the war? a It was supposed that iftcr the war nony European countries were to adapt thensolves to U-raan legislation regarding the Jews. Thus, for all the Jew3 in Central Europe it would be irgstssible to levelop further, as I s .id, there wa3 a large- scale re-settlement plan, which was to give th. Jews a now hcceland. This would both have removed Palestine ss a bon. of contention, and so leave the natter to the thoughr of settling, or proposing that the Jews be Settled in Madagas¬ car. It w'-uld net be difficult fer >ranc. to give up Madagascar in ex¬ change for a previous German Colony, that ccul<' be arrange ! in the pea¬ ce treaty, but at any rate, such prep'sal c uld only be put into ef¬ fect through Hitler, and if Hitler agree.! to such a proposal, then Bcrmnr.'s intentions would be automatically frustrated. Q Why Just *4aJ igasc-ir? A Uadogasc .r was ncntior.ed already by Chain ..aitzaunn, in his Sio- nist plans. It is an islan of 6c ,coo square kilccjeters. In other words considerably l-.rger thatn Gerainy, and it has cnly 3,500 inhabitants. It is sparsely settled, and in the cpinion of the GO Bulletin, it could support roughly a population of tw.nty cillion, and the acconoda- ticn of eight to ten nillicn European Je.fs there fore would affsrd no difficulty. Th_ climate in >eada;.asc.-.r c-'v.rs the whole range of pnssi- Kle climatic conditions, nd resembles the climate that is to be found in Pal.atina. The natural resources of coal, cin.rals, oil :ind soferth, aide it likely that a firmly rcut.i industry could rrew there-, kcr.over there are considerable opportunities for cattle raising. The gracs- lar.es are fertile, and what would be needed was an increase of this population in ord.r to cake usl cf these. >rca the agriculture point f view, .11 sorts of crops could be ^r-wn th_re, Tobacco, wheat, cotton, etc., an:, consequently this country soused to be Very appropriate for the reception of oi.-ht tc ten million people. 7176 ' 13 *ay-A-GJ-ll.-3-G=llagner-(Brown)- Court 1 case 1 DH. FRCESCHKANN: Hr. President, in this connection I put in Document Ko. 27 Dccunent Bock Bo, 1 - - No. 2, correction, page 3 Exhibit No. 30, which I have already discussed during sy interrogation of th*. wit¬ ness Hc.-h.rich. This is a brief ,xc-rpt free the dictionary well known in G.raany as "Dcr grease "rcckhaus. 1 T * PRESIDENT: Counsel, it was already offered in evidence, and rejected by the tribunal. DR. PRCESCHlUIfK: I understood this rejection on the part of the Tribunal to apply only cf the .offering of this document in connection with the ftcderich testimony. I want to put it in explicitly here ns evidence, because it substantiates “r. track's testimony here. An I incorrect in this belief, Mr. Pr.siknt? THE HtESIEEVT: No, I think counsel is correct. Counsel had lcavo ts offer, it, to offer v. a govurreont - - a Jewish governnont under ° 5or ‘ , ' ul Governor; this sot fora w.j to end uUtceaticuUy when through tnc consolidation of tnc lcc-l goverroent and tho ceoncuic situation that o-c-vic possible, Z. 'ihore uignt r„iie a possible objection horo, Hr. dr.xk. You luiow th. t the veraan "Government" unfortun.tol;- h„s received an ui>- plonsnnt connotutiot in Gcroany in tno 1 -st few yoers, bocauso thcro two a ita-r.il governnent-- Governor Saner. 1 under 7ran>c in Poland, •ho por-ittod hundred of thousands of Jews thuro to oc Killod. Aono events on tho part of tho Gov.rnoiw<>onor-1 in Poland in 1940, tforo thoy aiown to you? Of thos- events I certainly enow nothing, and 1 boliovo nothing was known ttaong tho general population about that. Q. In your circlo wnoro you were concerning yourself with fchoso plans, did y-.u xnow anything a oout tae personality of tne governor, and did it ooet: to you th..t this nxn's churucter was such as to ua':o it likoly th..t tho Jews would receive nomul, haoano and log^ rights? *S Lot no first of all go into the diccucoion about tho govornuont. -o tnougnt that the "gov^rnaent* would be nee osc.iry because for many years tnc economic situ.ition of a new State; canosbd of icui rants '■-uld h. -o to be so difficult tn^t it would develop only with tho help :i a functioning St_tc free tho cutsido. In order to create a new ia- i aad a new industry, oad a new housing, a new tr_ns-iort..tior., 71*78 13 >.ay-»-J?-14-2»-Gallughor (let. Hildoshoiuor) Court I so f ortfc. E2 ?;aSX3fi?: Counsel, it s,c.s to tho friounal the witness h^ vin o •--id he w„o not on expert on gc7«rcocnt_l affairs, and having st.-to: 1.1 hia opinion teat' tho govcr.tont to bo uaiatainod and sot ia hodagascor would be a f-ir, reasonable and liberal gOYornoont, tho subject has b^on pursuod long enough by tho witness. EH. J3C2SCdUHX: Vory well. Your honor. / 1L11 Court 1 -■fey 13-A-15-l-Hi)-Meehan-Brown 3Y DR. FROEoCHMAlJH: Q. '.'Itn^as, did you think thst such a plan that you have described was to bo incorporated into tho peace treaty and would be successful? A. Yes, wo hoped that if 3ouhlor, whom wo intended to bo tho governor, could create a nev homeland for tho Jews this would provide hope for all the Jews in the world. The coononic connections with Germany offered better opportun¬ ities for tho peace negotatlons and in the future peace these connections would certainly add to tho country's aocurlty. Q. Witness, was this thoueht something that occured on the spur of tho moment or was it based on mutual reflec¬ tion and careful thought? THE PRESIDENT: Counsel, I intended to convoy to you tho ldoa that tho subject of Madagascar and tho proposod oolony had boon gono into sufficiently as to onllghton the Tribunal on the witness' idea. I think that Madagascar con bo abandoned and you cr.n go on to tho next subject. 3Y DR. RR0E3CHHAKN: Q. Very will Your Honor. Kow, you submitted this olor. to Bouhlor and Bouhlor submitted it in turn to Hitler? A. Yes. w. However in your affidavit, under No. 16, it says: r Ve put tho pirn to 3ouhlcr, a -parently tnls plan was'not acceptable, so we changed our attltudo, etc." Now, I don't quite understand this statement in the affidavit, it does not corros:ond with what you Just testified. A. A r e had worked out this plan with groat care and iver. it a great deal of attention, usln c foreign experts "s consult:-nts. 7480 Court 1 •-ay 13 -a— 1 5—2—&)— Xeehan—Brown. It was not Bouhler who rejected the plan, 3ouhlar put It before Hitler. Sow when I signed this affidavit, I did not see that this statement here in the affidavit was wrong. Bounler adopted, the plan, s is shown, and tried to pwrsuade nltler to accept It. Hitler, nowover, turned it down, and Hoderioh has already testified to that effect hore. How, lot us go a step further, I Just mentioned Point 16 in your affidavit, which carries the hendlr. b , "Sterilization Program;" What did you mean by that? A. This heading was not ay Idea either, but was tho thought of the mar. who drew up the affidavit. If you want to define Himmler's sterilization program, you can If you went. I cor. clearly say hero under oath that I nerer hoard of any such program. I nuvor heard of Hadaus 1 work, or Clauberg'e work or that of Pokorny in 1941 or YAZ, nor when I signed tne affidavit did I know anythln 6 . In other words, the expression "Sterilization Program" did not enlighten me at the time or I would h ve objected -o it. It Is of course coarlble that because of my condl- c on at th t time I was so exhausted thot A could not concentrate on what I vr.6 re.-dlng there In the affidavit as Point 13 is rl 6 ht at the er.d of tho affidavit. x. -sut vou must have som. vi fc ue recollection of some- t.-.ing when you s^eak of x-ray exocrlmunts and such things; you must have known somethin., about those tuinga at that :lac; now what do you hnvo to say about that? a. I aid have a vague recollection, I heard something or other about x-ray experiments, which were made by some doctor or other, oat not in connection with anythin^ like e sterilization program. I believe that Bouhler told me - a: .--icier had turned this down, out now that we have Court 1 Kay 13-A-15-3-HD-&. ehan-Brown. looked into it core closely and particularly and since I have seen the documents, I can say that none of that is true. Q. In other words, you wont to say th-.t this statement which you made In this port of thu cfrid-vlt presents an al¬ together erroneous picture? a. It Is Incomplete, it is out of context and for that reason It Is misleading. ;. Now, Mr. Brack, at the end of 1940 did rilmmlor write you a letter? Now, this Is Documont N0-018, Exhibit 404, English Document Book 15 Pago 172; do you have that Document 3ook7 a. Yes. Q. Please toko a look at It - Pago 171. Lot mo quote. THE PRESIDENT: We are not getting the translation in the En 0 ll8h Document book. THE MONITOR: He stated It was Document N0-018, Document Book 15 and oorroctod the error from page 172 to pn^c 171. BY DR. FROESCHMaMN: 3. May I quote? HlmaU-r writes this documont No. 018 to you regarding the oonditons In the Euthanasia Station Orcfeneck, which h d become known to him and h„ writes: B 3S-Standartenfuohrer Victor Brack, Staff-Leader at Reich - Leader 3ouhlor, Dear Brack, I hear there Is treat excitement on the Alb because of the Institution Orafeneck.■ And he says ct the bottom: "May I ask for a report as to how tho difficult problem was solved. Hell Hitler! (signed) Heinrich Himmler." 7482 Court 1 May 13-A-15-4-ED-Meeben-3rowr.. This letter 16 rattier 6tricklng because «lmmler ie ap lying directly to you in the tatter that concorns Euthan-sla; hrd you theretofore communicated with Himmler regarding Euthanasia? A. Yes. Shortly after receiving the Euthanasia assignment Bouhlor sent me to Himmler to discuss Euthanasia problems, and I shall cone back to this problwm lator. The reason for this letter from Himmler to me, Jocumor.t No-018, was a letter tmt the highest Party JudtO Buch wr to t » Himmler. Tills lett-r was out In as No. 002, It is also in Document 15, pa 6 e 3? of the Gorman. Q. Hr. President, lr. the c-n^llsh Document book It is Document Mo-002, It Is on po 6 o 43 and Is Exhibit 332. Please continue. A. Now without doubt Himmler recalled my visit at that time rnd wrote to a with the request that I try to cloar up those difficulties. I showed the letter to Bouhlor and Bouhlor thereupon decided that Grafeneck was no longer to be usodaa rn Euthanasia station and sent mo to Hlmmlor to toll him so. Did you then ^o to Himmler? a. In January of 1341 I went tc Hlmmlor and told him of Bouhlor 1 8 decision. «t that time, to be sure, I did not know that Himmler on the basis of his racial theory was at tii-t tick, working on the development of a cheap and effective method of sterilization. That car. be seen from document No. 440, Exhibit 14, Document Bock 6, which la an affidavit of Rudolf 3rcr.dt. This Document, Hr. President, Is No. 44C and is contained In the English Document Book 6, p.;* 0 e 1. Please c >ntinue. 7^83 13 ?5ay L7-A^v73-16-1-Cgo:< (Int. Frown. Raaaler) Co-art !To. 1 A According to this affidavit H i c alor was interested in eliminating thj Jcv3 but 3till kojping their man power. Perhaps at that tine ho al- roady know of Broaann's plans and did not wish to affiliato hinsolf with thoso plans. Q What plans aro you talking about? A Tho plans to oxtorrdnato tho Jaws which I told you about before and having known them end having boon in the Party Chancellory in the course of this conversation when I told Staler Grafenock was to bo abandoned, Staler also told ao of coicunications he had received fron Poland, according to which tho Juws thoro »oro using tho temporary in- potonco of tho Polish govonrxnt to strengthen their orm position and Himmler said »net-dng had to bo done about this. Bo said southing had to bo undertaken to stop this bocauso through tho nixing of blood in tho Polish Jews with that of tho Jaws fron Vos tom 3uropo a much greater dangor for Gomcny was arising than oven boforo tho war, and ho said it •an his intention to storilizo the Jaws according to reliable not hods, according to a; proceAu*o-which -would rv.it mss atorillsation. Oporativo storilization was out of tho quostion for one thing bocauso ym couldn't do that without leaving some scar. Thon ho brought up the question, could not this bo done with x-ray treatment? Howovor, I didn't know about this for suro, and in fact nobody know about it, and especially didn't know -..hothor tho person in question could bo treatod rithout noticing sonothing, 'iixnlar then said that Bouhlor had gathcrod together so nany scientists and doctors in tho euthanasia program, con¬ sequently I should try to hoar free hin what he could toll no about storilization, and toll hin to report to na again. h Wail, what was tho effect of this corramication fron Htafcr on you? A This cede a groat inprossion on no. I believed that Hoydrich could ~ vo really boon tho instigator of all of this. In r$* interrogation I told Interrogator that I regarded such a plan of exterminating tho Jews ■'orthy Of Oerrony and its leaders. Frcta what I knew of HtaLor it would 7484 yaj li7-A-ATmi6-2-Oook (Int. Brown, Rarxdcr) Court ^o. 1 aovor have occurred to ra the. such a destructive idea could have origi¬ nated in his H i nd . ?o that, however, r.3 it nay, whether the idoa origi¬ nated with Ssydrich or Boxwcm, ay attiturio was opposed to this; and I felt that I was ur.dor obligation to do anythin" I could to provent this. If I had raised tho least objection to it openly I would have aroused groat suspicion of ;4yself and ..ould havo aroused an all togather and falso reaction in Maurlor, Therefore, 1 had to nafcu the bost of a had natter and had to protend that I agrood with Hirrlur. Thoroforo, I protondod to bo villing to clarify tho question of rvi3S sterilisation through x-ray twthodo. "oars ago I had boon subjected to x-ray troatmnt for quito a poriod of ti.vj and had discussed vdth the doctor tho offoct cf x-rays on tho human body. New I r-rxi.ibc.rod fron thoso discussions that the offoct of x-ray on tho soxual erganais only of slight innortanco and aro not lasting. lioroover, I Icnjw that ono of ny associates was personally ncqunirtod dth a x-ray specialist and ho told no that this cp-ci-alist was conducting oxporin-nt3 on the offocts of -'.-rayo on th fertility of onluls. Ha-over, th ro soarnod to bo no result. Q Mr. iYosidont I jxit in now Docuront Ho. 26, fron ry docur.ont ix;ok II, pago 1, of 25 February 191:”, an .affidavit by Dr. Martin Zeller, * specialist, bern 3 .Tocorter 1630, living in Munich, sliced by him on tlii3 sane dato and cortifiod by ny3olf. This affidavit contributes to tho understanding of this ra*tur no.' undor discussion and I quotos "I r-r-^ibor distinctly that 10 to 15 years ago I spoke to Viktor Brack about x-ray injuries. Brack -.as worried that ho night dovolop an ”-ray injury, at that tiro hi3 knoo had boon x-rayod. ,»hon soai tino afterwards he had rough hands ho thought that -dcht be an x-ray bum. explained to Mr that no inj'rries could result fron our x-ray exami¬ nations sinco tho qiantitics of radiation used for diapnosis were snail ani besides, tho acre distant parts of tho body (that is, in the case of a picture f t!~ lavo being taker., tho hands and genitals) .roro not in dar.g.-r zone under aoioni technical conditions. 1- k7-A-ATD-l6-3-Ccok (Int. Raaalar, Brown) Court ?fc. 1 Q I also ir.do tL->: rcr-nrk that :van an intentional sterilization by x-ray trcatisont would, ospocially in the caso of young persons, bo 'ifiicult to achieve and oven then only with a strong dosis of prolonged radiation." And thon in paragraph 2 tho witnoss continues: "It is qtiito pcssiblo that Brack in this way developed the views as brought forward, i.o., that the effect of x-rays upon the sexual organs is negligible, and that the danger of sterilization does not exist at TIjc laynen will not differentiate between x-ray diagnostics and x-ray ttorapy." This will bo Exhibit !lo« 31. '-fitness, nleoso ccntinuo. A I took this associate into :^r ocafidenco and told him of ny intention to docoivo Hi- lor, if only to gain tine. Wo agreod to docoive dj :l .r by "ivinr him a cortificr.to that Soenod to say that storilization by x-ray -xtheds was possiblo and would thus eut idr. to pursue n falso path. Ju-jt wh t was said in this certificate I do not know any longer. At aigr rote thoro wero no positivo results in it so that wo couldn't put it to 7 fir Tiler in tJdo fom. Mr. Prosidont, lot :io remark in thi3 connection, that after groat efforts I have succoadod in finding tho nen who drow up this certificate of which the witnoss has just boon speaking. I havo feund out his name -.rvd address. He lives in the Russian zone and for that reason it was rot possiblo for vo to get a copy of that c^rtificato that ho dr err up •at that time. Howovor, I havo undo oor.tact with this doctor and ho has ■cclarod his roadinoss to cone to IJurnbor-a and to givo mo an affidavit, arcauso as ho said it would bo a nattor of course that ho should help an iTiocsr.t Kan if his testimony could do so. Ho does ronm:±»or having given tais certificate to Brack or to his associates and I ask remission to r - 3 rv ° right to pit this affidavit in ovidunco as soon as I havo it, a perhaps th. doctor vashad a chanco to speak to the nitnoss — to JVndar.t. 7UB6 13 Hay li7-A-;.r>-j6-ii-Cco:< (Int. ?xcnlcr, Srown) C'urt So. 1 THE PRESIDENT: Counsel for defendant Brack nay offer tho affidavit as soon as it is received so long as it ccr.plies with tho evidanco in tho case* OR. FBOESC&i'JRIt Thank y«x, Your Honor. "witness, ploaso continue. A Naturally, this factor of uncertainty had to bo taken into consi dorati on. Q What oxactly are you spooking of? A 1 an talking about tho report wo revived. Q You man tho nan who draw up tho certificate, tho export? A Yos. TrE FR2SIDSI7: Mow ccunsol I don*t rant you to cd sunders tend no. I said Counsol my offor tho affidavit, that noons it is offorod oubjoct to any objoction raiaod by tho Prosocution as to the fem of tho affidavit or its rclovancy. Yoctorday tho affidavits fren Brazil wore possibly offured by you bocauso tho Tribunal had said w-at thoy night bo offered. The right to offor ninply noans offerod sub.loct to objoction and that io not oquivalont to saying that thj affidavit will bo rocaived in ovidonco, but it ray bo offorod. That is tho sonso in which I have usod the word ’’offor'’ in this affidavit. DR. FKJSSCHKA’JKt Yos, Your Honor, I understood tho Prosldont and I shall only suhnit an affidavit which is in conplinnoo with tho regu¬ lation of thi3 Tritwnal. Would you ploaso continuo, rritno33? A '.fy collaborator changod this cor ti flea to in it3 contents in such a .-armor that sterilisation bocccos apparent as sonotliing possible from a nodical point of via*/. That is exactly what is contained in ny affidavit. Thus this lot tor dated tho 28 1-arch 19iil, originated with this docunont Ho. 203, Exhibit l6l. 13 ifcy U7- A-FJC-17-l-Gress (Lit., Racnlor) Court I 5 !r. President, v.ifch roforoncc to tho Document Ho. 203, Exhibit IjI, you con find it in the *nglish -ocumcnt Volume VI, page 35. Lot us reconstruct this letter quite shortly. I shall quote. Volume VI, page 35, addrossod by Brack to ULs-Jor, narked top secret. "Door Roichafuohrcr: 11 Unclosed I sent to you for your information the report of the examination regarding the possibility of an x-ray sterilization or castration. I ask you to toll ac riothor anything can bo done in the nattor oithor theoretically or practically." Timt is the covering lotter. This covering lotter, *7itnoss, in connection with tho report rhich is cttachod ras considered by tho Pro¬ secution as being a sorious suggestion for sterilisation and Prosecution in that connection has statod that tliis noodod no corrxmt. t.Tiat is your attitudo tcnrcrd it? A ’{either tho first nor tho latter is correct. I admit that if one roads this lotter or roport without '.sawing the connections that impression c-n bo created. I, therefore, have to attenpt to onalyzo this report in ordor to explain to tho Tri’x-nal tihat ro tried to achieve rith this letter. I have to c.uphasizo onco more that tho ontiro thing arcs a nanouvur of deceit. Q T.'ith roforenco to tho report rhich you attached to thi3 lotter MO—203 I should like to quote from it a very brief passage. It con bo found in Dociuicnt Velum VI, page 35 ana roads: "Report on Exporimonta concerning X-ray Castration. "Tho exporinente in this field are concluded. Tho follorinr result can bo considered as established and adequately based on scientific , rcsoorch. "If any persons ore to be sterilised permanently, tliis result can only bo attained by applying Xrays in a desago high enough to produce castration with all its consequences, sinco high X-ray dosagos destroy tho internal secretion of tho ovary, or of the testicles respectively. 7488 13 Xiay !:7-A-F jC—l?-2-Gras3 (int., Racier) Court I Lower dosages would only tcwpor-rily paralyze tho procrcativo capacity. Tho cansoquoncos in question aro for oxrnplo the disappearance of nonotruation, climacteric phenomena, changes in capillary growth, modi- fication of metabolism, etc. In arqr ease, attention nust bo dram to thoso disadvantages. "Tho actual desage can bo given in various ways, and tho irradiation can take placo quite impcrcoptiblyv Tho nccoasary local dosago for non is 500-600 r, for wen 300-350 r. In general an irradiation period of 2 minutes for non, 3 ninutos for wcoan, rith the highest voltago, a thin filtor and at a short distance, ought to bo sufficient. Tho re is, however a disadvantage that has to be put up :4th: as it is impossible to covor unnoticoably tho rost of tho body with lead, tho other tissues of tho body :rill bo injur-d, and radiologic nalaioo, the so-called "Rcontgon- kator", •..ill ensuo." 'i’itncss, would you dofinc your attitudo toward this lottor which I partly read? A I was opoalcing in connection with tho talk I had with Himnlor in tho year of 19U1. This boconos apparor.t fron tho paragraph "I hororrith oubtdt tho result of an x-ray examination. It looks now as though in offoct oxporimonts had boon carried cut by 3ciontisto, which was not tho case. Himnlor had to bo assured and that is why ix had to oephasiao that tho experiments had boon concluded and the rosult could bo basod cn sciontific work. Of courso, to couldn't staxo tho result as boing abso¬ lutely positive, “o had to leave it to Hirsilcr hiicclf to Judgo it. In tho first instance it was our intention to remove Hirxlor's mind from that thought. That is hy wo choso the f emulation which can bo scon in that lottor - "If any persons arc to be sterilized pcrrmncntly 1 . It coat in cffoct tliat this this theoretically possible. At tho same tine however, wo pointed out that this succoss cannot bo concoalod and that phenomena will arise. That obviously was done by the contents of tho certificate itself and it is emphasized tliat permanent sterilisation aalccs high dosage of x-ray necessary. Those high dosages would then 7A89 -3 Hoy U7-A-?jC-17-3-Gross (Int., Harder ) Court I bri .13 about tho offocts of castration with nil of the acconparying ayxptcrc which would bo noticed irrxodiatoly. If, however, lorror dosaecs wore used you will have only stopped productive capacity for a short tine. To actually said that at tlio ersi of tho roport, naicly, that the result of sterilization eculd bo ascertained after a conpara- tivoly short tiao but that it was impossible to achieve tho results of brine about sterilisation without being noticed, and in this ray wo tiiought wo could get Hirolor to give up that idoa. Q Voir, this was tho first part of ti>o lottor. ?fow lot us discuss tho socond part. I an again reforring to the aothod which you suggested to Jliieilor. You thought at that tine "One practical ray of proceeding would be, for instance, to lot tho persons to be treated approach a coun¬ ter, where they could bo asked to ansvrer sono questions or to fill in fomo, which would take then 2 or 3 rdnutes. Tho official sitting bo- Jiind tho ccuntor could operate tho installation in such a way as to turn a switch which would activate the two valves simultaneously ( since tho irradiation os to operato frou both sido3.) TTith a two-vrlvo installa¬ tion about 150-200 persons could then be sterilizod per day, and thoro- foro, :rith 20 such installations as w.ary as 3000 - IjOOO porsons por day. In uy estimation a larger daily mefcor could not in any caso bj sent away for th-is purposo." IS-. Brack, how could you arrive at this idoa of turning switches. This is conplotoly unundorstandablc for a laynan. A Hi.nlcr wanted this pracoduro to be carried out as simply as possible. Thcroforo, wo had to suggest a a sinplo a method 03 wo cculd think of. On tho other hand this nothod increased the uncertainty of of directing the ray3 to the corresponding parts of tho body. That is what was discussed by ry collaborator with his acquaintance. '7o suggested this tch rothed to Hinmlor with tho idea of naking this nattor as slw- plc ?s possible and at tho sane tine to prevent any active x-ray reach¬ ing tho body. 7-90 13 S/-'.-? jC-17-li-Gr '53 (Int., ?.r_- Icr) -Ol’T- I Furthermore, only 2-3 ndnutcs were suposted as the length of tin: for these people to be subjected to those x-roys. How wo arrived at these 5CO-&X) figures - or 350 r. - I don't knew whether they wore just invent¬ ed or ufaothor they were based upon a one thine. I don't know, lut look¬ ing at it as a wholo it contained a nu;her of points that wore to dono- atrato to Stickler that the wholo thing could not bo carried out. There is scientific basis for theso suggestions. Q Itr. Prosident, in correction with this point I havo triod to got on unobjectionable irreproachable certificate for the correctness of whn: the defendant just stated. I shall got a cortiflcato fron a specialist. The nan concerned soys that this suggestion is absolutely sonsolcss. I had, however, to wait for this certificate bocauso I had to wait for an affidavit fron anothor oxpert physician. ’?ith tho pemission of tho High Tribunal I shall obtain a corresponding certifi¬ cate fron a radiologist Title can take it appoar credible that thi3 entire suggestion was roally scientific nonsense. A Tho possibility for Hi"dor to accopt this proposal in spito of all thoso difficulties wo had to toko into account, "o know, howovor, that tho preparation of any such installation would tako up a long poried of tire, building, otc. Tfo thought that tho war would ond vory quickly and as I said boforo I didn't knew thorc was any throat fron tho bast. And, in caso of pcaco tho Plan of iiadagaskor which had al- • ready be on rojoctod could once noro bo placod in tho foreground, If on tho other hand this suggestion was to bo accoptod and if at that tino the war had not yot onied, tho carrying out of this exporinont on tho 100-200 Jews was nuch loss of an evil than Hirrlcr taking tho Jews and sterilizing then on nasso or doing something worso to thou. 7491 ij U i—^ria-Lier; Court Be. 1 Q Mr. Brack, if I unlarstand ycu correctly, y:u« re saying that, at that tir.fi, you had to roake a decision between either killing r.illions of Aiks or chocsing the sma l ler evil by only suggesting this snail nurcor which you have mentioned upon whrrj experiments .right be carriod out. Is ay opinion correct?. K During ny interrogations I designated this dilema in a way by saying that this was our last vay out. But, naturally, when judging these two possibilities ono must take into c nsidoraticn that ono decides upon ono possibility and, at the sar*, time, fools an inner Justification for doing so. The sane way as a troop ccumndor sacri¬ fices a few thousand people sc«snhore if he can savo a hur.drod thousand somewhere also. Q Nov, Ur. Brack, in order to conclude this letter I want to say that you havo at'.tod tho following at the end of that lettor, and I quotoi "In sun ary it nay be said that haring regard to tho .resent state of radiology teohniquo and rosoarch, mass sterilization by moans of X-rays can bo carried cut without difficulty. Hcwevor, it sooins to bo inpcasiblo to do this in such a nay that tho persons ocncornod do not, aoonor or lator, realizo with certainty that thoy havo boon sterilized or castrated by X-rays." In your covering letter you apparently mentioned your second lottor, and I quote* "I request your instructions as to further theoretical or practical steps which .-.re to be taken in this mat ter." "Shat is the significance of this latter statement? k By using this f emulation I endeavored to keep tootl'd cf tho dovolcjcont of that natter. I never really counted on the realization of these experiments and I never had any intention to submit a serious proposal to Hinnler which would cause the sterilization of millions of Aws, but if H fcna l nr was to accept this nonsensical proposal I ranted 7492 -zy 13-—3K-18-2-Xarrow (Int. itcrzilor) Court Ho. 1 to have a delaying effect on his idoe for as long as possible. If this suggestion had boon sorious on ny part I would havo had to be a fanatical Jew hator, end I think I have already proved tjhr.t I was not such a person, end, in that connection, I any oqphcsizc- the following: Jit the s-uie tine I sent this letter to Hiunlor, influential circles node efforts that the Kaiser ./ilholn Institute for ooll physiology was to b- transforrod to an old Party noabor. ..t the head of that instituto. Professor Dr. .•orburg had boon placed, who was a half Jew.. It was the aL. of these oirclcs to obtain tho norits of the research work which ./nrbur 3 had boon carrying on - who had in¬ cidentally won tho i.'obol Prize. If 1 had boon a fanatic¬ al National Socialist I would havo supported this on- doavor of these circles. I, however, did oxactly tho opposite. I helped /orburg end I thoroforo sustained this institute for Oar.iany and for tho world. 4 Ur. Prosidont, I or; now going to subnit tho important doouoont // 12 , to be found in ny doounont book on pr.go 32 end 33, of Professor Warburg. I want to point out that this affidavit hid already boon handed to the Panily 3rack before tho beginning of this trial i:i order to holp Brack in tho trial which he expected before tho do-Nezifi- cation board, ..ftor the beginning of tho trial I turned to Profossor ./orburg, asking hin to ohango tho introduc¬ tion of that affidavit tc fit it for tho purposes of tho Military Tribunal at Nurnborg. Dr. •> or burg corresponded tu ny request and I shall now road that doeuxiont and I quote: ■'I, Professor './ \rburg, scientific nenbor of the Kaiser ••ilhcln association since 191-1, dirootor of tho Kaiser • ilheL-i Institute for Coll Physiology since 1931, nonber of tho 1‘oyal Society in London, winner of tho Nobel Prize 7493 - - :-y 13--v-3K-18-2-Ivarro*.v (It.-. Rood or) Court No. 1 for nodicino, horowith give thb following affidavit. I have boon advised that this affidavit will bo subnitted to tho Military Tribunal I in Numbers nnd that I will bo subject to severe jxmalti-s if I r.ako fal30 statements. 'The Kaisor ••ilholn Institute for Coll Physiology', tho director of which I hnva boon since its foundation, was established and partly supported with funds fro;, the Rockefeller foundation. Becauso of this fact, I rotainod ny position until 1941, although I on a half-Jew. " In 1941 I was diSQissed by tho Kaiser Rilholn associa¬ tion. The then C hicf of tho ^hcncullory of the Fuohror, Philipp Bouhlcr, terxnod about ;;y disnissal and orderod his staff londor Viktor Brack to review ny oaso. "In r. few wocks Viktor Brack saccoodou in having t.y dismissal cancelled; in this way ho no3t probably 3c.vod r.y life and for science a nodical research instituto of world ronovm working exclusively for ponooful purposes. "'I did this', Breok told no cn June 1941, 'not for you or for Oornony, but for tho world.' "Consic'.orins that Brack did this at a tino when raoial hatred nnd war psychosis had roaohod thoir olinox in Gorri'ny, ono hrs to adniro the ccurago with which Brack advanced tho cause of tolor.anco end tho noacuful work of 3cioncc against tho bnsic principles of N'.tionnl Sociclisr:. "I have road tho cbovo affidavit and I have found it to be in all parts correct. Signod: Professor Otto urg." Thu authenticity of the cortificato i9 cortifiod by the notary von Lctiinski on tho 3rd of February 1947. In addition to that document I also .... TiiJ PitEJUKNT (Interrupting): Counsel, will you give U3 an exhibit nur.bor for this document?- 7U9L any 13-..-3K-18—4-Knrrow (In-. Sonnier) Court Ho. 1 3Y D... FitOSSCr2L>r.;: . Ilr. President, I bog your pardon, this will booone Exhibit 32. In oddit ion to thr.t document I subr.it Document j/13 in r*y docun-nt volun~ which is the affidavit of Professor Dr. ’./niter Sohoollor residing -t -llcnsbcch on the Lake of Constr.noo. This will be Exhibit 33. I quote: "For anny years I was r. n^nbor of the Kaiser hilholn Socioty and curator of tho Kaiser “ilhuln Institute for Coll Physiology which was hondod by r:y friend Profossor .far bur. 3 . In that capacity I hoard frea Dr. i’olschow, the Director of tho Kaiser •'ilhola Socioty, that the Ministry of Culture has askod tho Kaisor •'ilholu Sooioty to dismiss .farburs, on to ny re¬ presentations and oi.trustod his assistant in the Chanoo 11 - cry, Viktor Sreok, with tho handling of this oaso. Ur. Brook's efforts woro oo:j; lotcly suoocs 3 ful. Tho pertinent dopositlor.3 of r r ofos3or 'ifcrburg as r.ado in his 3tatonont of 5 Soptonbor 1946 are in every respect in cccordanco with ay recollections." Thi 3 st.?tor»nt of 5 Soptonbor 1946 is the one I oontion- cd earlier; nonoly tho one Ur. ./arburc aide available to tho Fariily Brack for tho purposes of submission boforo tho do-Nozification board. I sont copies of this affidavit to Professor Schoollor. Ho 300 s on: «I have carefully road tho above st tenant and found it correct in every respect . 11 Signed and certified by Dr. Carl Hr.cnsol under tho date of 7th of February, 1947. ISr. 3rack, you have stated on the 26th of Uarch, 1941 7i95 13-..-3K-lB-5-K„rrou (Int. iic:iil~r) Court *»o. 1 that you sent this letter to Hitler. You further stated that if there was nc other evidence for the correctness of your statement you would point to the affidavit of Professor /erburg. That is the sense of what you said? .. Yes. 0 In order to brine this nattor to a conclusion, did you oxgoricnco r.ny resistance to your efforts inconnoction with i ir bur 3 ? Yes, I had considerable difficulties. Th~ Gestapo and Borannn loomed about ::y ondoavors on behalf of ./r.rburg* My own collaborators warned ;-.c a few tines not to bring these aattoxs to an ox.-losion out I did th'.t in spite of all thoso difficulties and hoi. cd ?refos3or .fnrburg. I was then as tod to call on the Gestapo and I was given a warning by Gru..ponfuchror Muollor. I Witnoss, I nust again rovert to your affidavit. In this affidavit you aako souo aontion of having nado a ste¬ rilisation suggestion to Hitler. Kathor, that you did not send hin that suggestion directly, but you discu3S0d th-t question v/lth your chiof, rtoiohsloitor Bouhlor. .. It nay woll bo that I disoussed that natter with Bcuhlor. In view of the rejection of the Uadagasc a* Plan I on suro that Bouhlor would havo rcjcotol any such proposal, but I i.ixod these two t ings up and I on afraid that ny nenory vrsn 1 1 quito olanr at that tine. . But, lir. Br:.ck, a i oounent was subnitted here, tho Doounont No. 21G, Exhibit 170, which is to be found in tl?e Gera an d ocunent bock 6, page 5-1, and in tho English docur.cnt voluno 6, pago 56. This is a file notice of July, 1912. This file notice originates fron tho defendant .tudolf Brandt and r.fors to a c nferonco which took place on tho 7th.of July, L912. between t!i~ Aeichsfuohrer SB, S3 Brigade! a-hror 7496 May 12-rt-3K-2B-6-Karrow (lat. itaEaler) Court No. 1 Prof03sor Dr. Gobhordt, Bluecks cad Klauborc- You have tho dccunont book beforo you? - Yos. 7Z.97 13 Moy-A-GBS-19-l-Koloy (Ir.t. Rirr.ler) C'urt " . 1. Q. In Paragraph tw the nano of Profoss r Dr. Hchlfeldar is r.-riti 'nod wh is a:i X-ray socialist In Romany. Re says "It ah uld nls be o xml nod, preferably in c perati n with ?r fa as- r Dr. Kchlfoldor, .n X-rav apooialst in Gom'ny, in what way sterilization f r.en c vld bo achieved by X-rcy trcatrxr.t." Toll us wh.- t r.a Dr. B'iilfoldor? A. H hlfoldor ma the hnad f tho SS X-ray Unit. Q. »hi t d y u rwan by SS X-ray Unit? A. The X-ray Unit waa an instituti n f tho SS and of ’’imlor. It ha J existed 1-n* boforu tho War. It waa cTrittod t carry ut invoati ( -»ti na in aroia which ware subjoot to tuberculosis. A noth d had boon f und portly thr ujr. H-hlfoldor which mdo it p saiblo far X-ny invoatigoti-n t bo oarriod ut with q n rani filn. Such units wore thon oatabliah-'d and w.ru g< in - through tho a untry. Q. But yiv Vn w that fr n bof ro 19-.lt A. Yaa, I think that t k place in 1937 r 1938. Q. Did y u over apeak t H hlfoldor? a. Ho, I didn’t ier w H hlfclJor and I never taikod t.<- hin. Q. Titnoas, roodln^ tint d cunont now uld orriw nt tho th u^ht that Hi.arlor waa r naultin* those X-ray spcolnlista hcc^uso ho didn't quite <• nsidor v- ur su-^osti n feasible Jfrieh hod prooedod that lott:r; cc.n that be possible? A. Y», th t i» Feasible, but in n way c-.n bo c-ntcat with that ay £:•<-nt in *rdor t clarify mttorsi "Top Socrot" nddrosscd t<- "Cborstdior.stloitor Viktor Bnck, Berlin T .*8 Voss Strosso 4, little while before his departure t Grooce by clone tho Roichafuohror-SS govo nu tho • r-1 r t thank yiu very rucy for vaur roport ab ut tho X-my esstrati n experiments f«rwnrdod t< us with y««r letter f 2f Uoroh 1941. He has road tho report with inturost and will discuss this quest! n with v u r.t the first opportunity.’ "That lid y u o included fr n tills letter? This lottor pr voe to ca Hissnior's interest. It c nteins no rojooti n, but node the pursuance r f the ontiro not tor Gopcndont upon an ther discussl a. Tils disoussl n, h wovor, did n >t o-.no about, and th r<-with I th u;ht I had w n . consldorablo ported t, thouch ho was a nnti-«nl socialist himself, ho did not oxpoct every Cormr.n to have tho sane political views. It should bo tha right of ovory Com n to leovo Cormny and to adopt another country, if ho lis- approvod the r.«ticn*l s.-oiclistlcal rogino. If I helped theso Gomans to oaeono, my aotlor. was pr< nptod by idoalistio notivos end should not bo punished by tho Sail stnto. That is why he fully undorstcod ny aotim and did mt hcslt.t? t intorvonu n rtf behalf." And then, Tiltnoss, It c ntinues: "In 1941 I w-s nrrostod for the third tiro, again for p litic-l r .as no. Brock again then personally drafted t^gothor with Bcmhlor a potiti-n t< !llrar lor and kept -v rolstivus inf mod nb ut tho pcsiti «n. Ho noc npanlod B uhl->r t- u imlor, nnd onothrr tlno ho called on Him- lor alono in ardor t obtain nv release. Hew vor. Pis*lor refused my release and doolorod that I w uld hnvo t> remain in tho o nc mtratl.n cirp JVr th- root of my life. Hlrr.lcr r.lso provontod all further offorts c-scorning rysslf with Hitler nnd warr.od both 0 uhl«r and Brack not to undertake an” further aoti n 'nry behalf." This is the -».ttor if Dr. 1/idwig Schmitt. ... Yes. Q. -.-hat reaction did ;* u fo?l because -f this fact? ... This br -ught ob^-ut os ovon str r.gor rojooti. n of Hi-clor’s attitude• : c uldn't understand it. Fer =eny yonrs I ronsidorod him t. have a dacont charaotor end aw suddenly I found that I had been wr-wig. ..11 th? human trends which ho had des not rated up to that p int wore suddunly lost. I nsrur.o thrt Hoydrich's hand was appuront behind the so matters, but r.f c-urso I also erred in nv opinion abrut 7500 13 ’ r ny-.i-r3S-19-4-*a 1' y ( feral-r) C-urt V.r. 1. Hiarl r. Sinultnno usly I think also in the sunrv r f 19-12 s-nt other -as. ir:s" in c nnoction with s>—' reloaso fr ti tho c ncentm ti-n corip. 3 uhl“r had onion v rod th t r f r= r fficcr of tha "ohrceeht bo rc- lansai frem *ho c ’r.cjntr ti-r. cecp end si. rtly b.fcro this prnntad re¬ lease ho lit* under suspielus circ'-astanccs in the c ncontritl n ennp. Thcro woro joed ro is ns f- r suspicion. Ho had boon visited and soon by s-no monbors f his f nily lr. a e npl-toly healthy stoto, and I think th»t ho h d died within two d'ys. B uhl ir discussod that mttrr with Biunlcr, all >f which br ucht mo t< dispeir f Himler’s nttitudo. Q. Thin y u did hr*'., d ybts .»b ut !iir»lor's nontality, but y u didn't quito so thr ugh it yut, did y u? A. 7.-11, I ha-’ brliorod in that »an f r t lorn; a poried >f tino. I th.u»ht that everythin- aricine tod fr n Hoylrioh, and I tli ught that Hoydrioh was dcoclTlns Flro-.lor, but then for tho first tino I boctno d-ubtful ob-ut Himnlor hir.s If. Q. Did you ever !mr thnt Hirrlor was pursuod f r storillsatl-n Intent 1 r.e rn-' in particular dll y u h ar anything t» tho offoot that yair letter which w had nonti nod in dotail b;f ro, hod boon sub¬ mitted to Ft hi, tho Oborgrvp pan fuehrer P hit A. I neither received krf wlod^o f th« fact that Hirrlor was pursuin’ the cterilisati n intonti ns, n r lid I hi'* that this lottor had been submitted t« Hoydrioh, n;t P instances y u mdo G 1 b-chik'; acquaintance? 75^1 13 Iiay-A-iB-2C-l-Qa 11 ighor (Int. Rosier) Court Jo. I, Coso ?io. 1. Be g i nnin g with Sopt-rbor I accccpcniod Bouhler on a rido to the forrer Gcvcrncr-Gortral Fran!:. fo then ret Globocnik and I nr.do his .acquaintance at that tire. 0 Wiat was the subject of your conversation with Globocnik? A I did not have .any conversation with him at all. I just listened to what ho said to Bcuhlor. Globocnik told Bouhler .about his entiro wort: in Poland; about his spec Lai assignment according to whioh tha poopla who had boon ronovod fre-u Go many were c omitted for work in Poland. Furthornorc, ho said that factorioo wuro to bo instituted in tho Ukraine with sicilar installations as in the concentration canp of Dachau, which wore to bo instituted by tho governor-general. Q Did Globocnik giva you .an opportunity to view and ins poet this work vhich was being created? A I wont to ono of thaso works accoapaniod by tho Roichsloitor, whoro a number of things were producod. Part of tho workors woro housed in barracks, and part of thon in town, scat* had boon residing thoro, and sono had boon rc-scttlod. So far as I can rot'.enbor, they were producing shoos, motor errs, snail fvxnituro, and thoro woro sono tailor shops. Those other things I soil! rononber. I an dito that thoro woro a fow thousand Jons thoro who wore working thoro. In this rather great factory I s~w nothing about -ny torture, or anything liko that. Tho physical condition w-.s pod, and they soccod to bo nouriahod proporly. Q !fow, 3tr. Brack, did Globocnik at that time tell you about the exploitation of labor - of the Jewish labor, which w-.s intondod by Pohl? A !Io. Ttero was no cent ion .^ado of any exploitation. Thoro w-.s only oontion cade of proper ccmittnor.t of that labor. Q In that ease you saw — A i/hat I saw was absolutely positive creative work. Q It was no concentration canp, t re it? A :io. It was a big work coopowd. Tiiero wore no barbed w^rcs, 7502 --7-A-I.S—2C— 2 -Jjillaglksr (Ir.t. Rosier) C' jrt :ic. I, Case No. 1 . or anything like that. It looked oust like any other largo factory. Q Did you on this opportunity notice anything of any installa¬ tions which could serve as any exteroinition of Jews? Did you sec any gas chambers, or anything like that. Did you possibly hoax southing of ouch chambers free Globocnik, or sorebody olso? A J!o, noithor did I hoar of anything liko that, nor did I soo anything which attracted ay particular nttontion. It was my impression that this was an absolutely normal fact ex 7 compound. Q When was that again? A It was in the Fall of 191*1. I think the beginning of Sep- tor.be r 19U1. Q Now in the lato Fall of 191*1 you loft for a considorablo period of tiau, and that -at the end of October 19U1 you c.amo bnok from your lonvo, is that true? A Yos. Q During that tino a cort in decision arose within you, as you linvo told no, which matured, may I put it that way? A I wanted to volur.tocr for tho front. I wanted to Join tho Army, bjeauao I did rot liko tho entiro political dovolojnont. So far as I could judge. Hitler's a ins beenno no re arri no re r-dical. I per¬ sonally was watebod by tho chiof cf tha Gostapo. I was wsrnod by him and Hirr.lor warned no becauso of =y interference in tho cnoo of Schmitt, and there woro many similar moasurcs so that I s-w no longer any possi¬ bility for positive work to bo deno on by no. TThjn voicing this in¬ tention I found intensive resistance on tha part of many of ry friends. They said if I loft ny post, thorc would bo nobody loft to whon ono • could turn in caso of political dif J iculties, and who, disregarding any personal agency, was always ready and willing to help, ever, poli¬ tical opponents. Q It. Brack, nay I catch up with something I for cot a little ."hilc ago. You ware saying that Globocnik had boon talking about a special assignment? 13 Jfay-A-:B-20-3-Gollaghcr (int. ?.calor) Court !io. I, Case Mo. 1 A Yos, a few speci-al ascignsonts, Q You Irncw that tho expression "special assignrent" has Gained a vory unpleasant coining during tho trial hero in Kurnberg, because one over* likos to understand bv "special assignront" special troatnont, and spocial treatment in that regard soecs today to have purely a conning of liquidation, f.'cw .then Globocnik was discussing his spocial assignment in connection with the oonnittaont of labor consisting of Jews, did you have tho idea that it coant oxternination? A Ho, no idea at all, I hoard tho oxprossion "spocial troat- r.cnt" of this coming hero for tho first tino, Q Rad you known about this expression "special troatnont" from your physical activity? A Ho, of course not. Q How nay I continue whoro I interrupted before. VYo now re¬ turn to tho ti*3o of tho ord of Gctobor, or tho beginning of November, which brings us before Christens of 19ial. What hnpponod Chrictraast of 19U1? A !{y intentions of becoming a soldier, and going to tho front »/cro a35istoluatoorod for tlic front. Of covrso, with tho approval of Re ichsloiter Eouhlor. But soaothing happenod in tho noant las, thuro was a couv^rs: tion With Hisnlor. DR. FRCESCffi'ANH: Mr. Prosidor.t, 1 an now coaing to tho socond conversation botuoon Brack and HiaJor, which will take up r.ono tino, in which Hiaalor told Brack -'.bout his far ronehlng plan, and perhaps it would bu advisable to take a rocooo new. THE FR&32DEK7: Tho Tribunal will tako recess until 9:30 o*clock tonorrow naming. (Tho Tribunal adjourned until lfj ”ay 1917 at 093C hours). 7?C5 Court So. 1 14 Hey 47-jl-l-l-ZHM-Joeter (Hosier) Official Iranscriot of the American Military Tribunal in the catter of the United States of America against Karl Brendt. et al, defendants, sitting at Suornberg, Germany, on 14 Hay 1547, 0930, Justice Beals presiding. IE*. r-ABSHAL: Persons in the courtroom vill cloaso find their scats. The Honorable, the Judges of Military Tribunal I. Military Tribunal I la nov in session. God save the United States of America and this Hon¬ orable Tribunal. Share 111 b* order in the courtroom SHE PBESI2HIT: Kr. wxshal, you ascertain if tho defendants are all present in court. THE .kAESrAL: Hay it plerse Your Honor, all tho defendants are present in tho court vith the exception of tho defendant BccVrcr-Freyeeng, vho is absent, having been excused yesterday. TKi P&2SXXUR: Ths Secretary General vill note for tho record tho presonco of all tho defendants ir. court rave the dofondant Beckcr- Froyoong vho is oxcustd upon roou^st of his counsel in order to consult vith his counsel. Counsel nay proceed. Sn. FHCLSCHijUr.: (Counsel for tho defendant Brack): Mr. President, I hevu a roouost to sake at tho beginning of this coming's session. In the erso Brack, vhich I initially i.naginod to bo only snail, it has become extended in the last six months, oving to tho onomous emount of material, to one of the biggest cases of this proceeding. Altogether I had received over 7S0 applications, offers, and representations from ocoolo vho declared the iselves reed.” to cor.c hero as vitnessts or vritc affidavits ;n hit b.hrlf. Of this large cur.ber I only submitted 36 affidavits t*»^thi. Tribunal. Three of these affidavits are contained In • a supple-;ontai e'oiv.^ vfcich I submitted to tho Secretpry General only n . fev days ego because,they had coco in too late. I should be very grate¬ ful to the TribuctS if they v*£d asic the Secretary General to have this suuolc-iur.tal v ,)LL ransleted by to-.r-r-v morning because at that tiro \ ^ - ' Xv / J'hope ti bt.fiS^hed vith the direct examination,of my client. V 7 U; .V-* / H-£ rBESIB&i 7: The clerk of the Tribunal vill convey to the Secro- 7506 Court 5c. 1 14 Hay 47-k-l-2-iEX-7o6ter (Seller) tary Gonoral the recuott to expedite, ae puch as possible, the docu¬ ments referred to by counsel for tho defendant Brack, and place before t:.o Tribunal at the earliest possible tine tho suppleucntal document book to vhich counsel has referred. DR. 7EG7SCF. Aif:.: I didn't cuito got the Gcmon translation; I didn't have ay switch on correctly. I vas concerned vith 6unoler.ontal volvuo cuabor 3. Thank you very nuch, Tour Honor. VIKTGR BRACK - Resunod DIRLC? EXAKISaTICH (Continued) BY DR. JRCSSCFMAIB (Counsel for the defendant Brack): Q. witness, I at first ronind you that you arc still under oath today. A. Tos. Yoctcrday vc concluded the sostion vhile you wore talking about tho tins you volunteered for the Ar.*-. Vhat happened boforo you Joinod the SS? A. On tho occasion of ay mother's death I not ny brother - ho was a aochenicnl snglnasr and a aotor transport officer in an SS division. He coaplaincd to oc that he v*s continually rccoiving wrong technical orders, vhich in part hed a rosu.it in the ertostropho resulting fron tho lock of lot ir vehicles. !, .myself, while in Russia aiding the wounded people, had on opportunity to observe our aotor transport problca. ?,r that reason I decided to visit Elnalsr and report these natters to hia in order to improve that situation, if possiblo. DR. 7RCt.sc:-: -Ui5: hr. President. in that connection I should like to revert to exhibit Ho. £, which is the affidavit already suViitted by the br-th.r of the defendant Brack, B.cu^ent 41, prrcgra.nh 3. Thie is to be found on ptgo 1 of supple, icntal v^luuc num.bcr 1. 5Y DR. TRCaSCEtARN: Q. Voald you continue please. a. I reported these -atters to Hinder but subseauently, I don't know why, voiced criticisn about ,thcr natters within the SS. 7507 Court So. 1 14 May 4?-k-i-S-ZEk-JoEtcr (aadcr) Hinder culotly listened to ne out then tried to convince ne in his ’••ay about the correctaeaa of what he was doing. He adnitted that eono -■'.It. a in the So weren’t as he would like then to be, and that eoae of the can in the SS did not aulte fit into the organisation. Sut, ho 6aid, at thia critical point he needed ever;' single one of the old SS ceobero. He said, aporoxiaatoly, only if the old coarades would stand by hin faithfully could the S- cleanse itself of theoo oeoole who did not fit into it. He cculd only expect the nost heavy tasks to bo carried out by the old SS members. Ihen ho euddonly stopped and told ne that Hitler had soae tiao ago given hln the ordor for the oxtoraination of the Jowo. He said that tho oreoarntlonc had already been node, and I think that ha used tho exorcesion that for ronsons of caaouflago or.c would hove to work as quickly as oossible. Ho aecnod to say thoso things devoid of any innor aoorovol of thoo, but ho also said then as if they were a natter of course. I hod tho fooling that ho didn't lnnorly aoorovc of thoso ordors but ho showed no sign of any mental shock. I, hovevsr, vao doeply shocked to hoor of thoso duvelopcents bocauss now for the first tiao I had heard concretoly, by sccobody -ho was In a position to know, that all of those ruaors voro actually true; that there was in offoct tho intention to exterminate tho Jove. I don't know whether Eiaeler expected to cake this inpreeeion on no. I thought thot Binder cxoectod that I vtxild offer ray neoletanco in thia natter. I couldn't say anything but that this aoecod to nc to be an enornoue toe:-: and that I could not understand how Final or could boor the roaoonsibility before hunanity for these ncte. I thon tried to conclude thia conv^raation ea tmickly es posBible, and on thia occa¬ sion told Hlnaler that Souhler hod oorcitted ne to volunteer for tho Army end that for thot ourpocc I had already gone to the /uehrungshauot- ent. After that I departed. 7508 Court 1 -~y l-l-jt- 2 -l-HJ-C ok-Rpoalcr. v. -ffcat ws the result of that conversation? "• 1 redoubled my efforts to get to tne front and I ti’icd t e.nolafta the forianllties aa qaiokly r.s possible. Nov a fate was taking Its -course, which I did not think I c.ld sucoo38fally oppose. I s-w befor- me a possibility to £• a nothing for my nrtIon ir. n decent way. However, I wanted to et away fron an office and a fuenr^r whoso radicalism I had bo c an to realize m r- ana more and whv.ro _y rocson would not allow mo to coopera to any longer. I thought th~t ^nly as t seldler c,uld I pat distance between thoso thin-s and myself. I did vnly *h t .aany of other oomrados had alro *»-..• lone be for.., comrades who no longer wnted •'nythln a t do with tne high leadership and who went to thv fr»nt. ft. ! v Hr. 3rrok thor. I think at the end of April or tno beginning of Key you went to the front, bat wasn't thcro an ther event In a rll which -ay be f some imoor- t- nee for the Tribunal? ft. Yes. Before I left I met - and by ncoldont, we O' Id .ascertain :he date, the 19th of «pril - I met el ,b cnik • t a c.-ncert on the 19th of A prll In Berlin. Globecnik ocked me whether Relchieiter 3 uhler was in 3erlln and whether he could speak to nla. I said, yes, 3o uhler w e tnor*. and he could visit him. Clobocnlk did ti-at and 3 abler t Id m«. ftcr this o nvers-tl n that Glob cnlk had '.sited hi j tv furnish him supervisory personnel :*.r his w rklng s.iops in 3-rlln, w.ilcn w s to be taken fr c thv. i-4 euthanasia program. Reichslelter B.n the occasion of thi 2 visit of 20 April 1942, 5,uhlor, by request of Ql.boonlk, furnished that pers nnol t hlo for the pur¬ pose of the extorslnntl.-n »f the Jews. You knvV what tfc~ witness Kederlch hod testified hero nb.ut Bouhlor. Vo need n t repeat it. I an asking y.u, however, knowing the aentallty and the pers nallty cf the Helchleitor 3cuhler, do y->u c neldor it possible, or would you say that it was ut -f the question, that 3-uhler in that c nversotl'.n of the 20 April 1942, furnished the personnel of T-„ ti Globe cnlk for the purpose of tho externln^tl r-c xy enw knavl- . I con soy nothin.-. I alr-u 'y uanhusized urin oy pr*.-intcrrog.oti-n that I r.-'ird at the cni of 19U2 that thes- p.'-pl. w-r. for th- -xterainoticn f th. Jews, .‘bother the* were ..a ctually used for such a purp.o. - I still don't knew that. I za c- n-dnc d at first that th-y actur.il> wer- us-d in th- pnn.r Aol note by B..uhl.r, nue. .ly •* rkin-. c-rsps. It ic possible that j 1 t.rnik 1 ter ho' start t use then frr th- .xt*.rainatirn of th- Jews, it.r havirv th u.*ht p.rhop3 thot th.r_ woul b- no r bjoction on the pert of -VuM-r. t 1 itr.-ss, as yc-x stot ' corli-r, you w-nt to th- front ot the .nd of /.pril or beeinnin;. i 'iey-your division ms stati n- J in th- 2ruth. In -h. c urs Juno 19L2 !id yru race nrr*. return t. B-rlin? a Up t'. th*. tir. -ho livisirn w-nt intr .cti-n I *-nt o f-.w ' io. -3 tc c.rlin because the li vision wis :nly b-in activated aid I _t- supply Jxic-r h :ft-n tc ,-c tc -Lrlin. That is why on 9 Jun- ' 751A 1L ■ t-y- --2J-3-2—Grcat--(p.irl_r)- Ccurt 1 I ^-s in Berlin b.c:,use ay Ccaeandin Officer hart asked to attend th. funeral cf r-y.-rich an:’ had to fly to Berlin. On this --ccaaicn U - ls t;5 the conversation pr.rr.8sc ' .and t> 1 hir. that he h be.n ccianittci b, the Reichsfu.hrer 1'i-sJv.r t- h.lp carry -ut th xt.rrinaticn cf the Jews. Bcuhler was quit, ah-cke I ab.-ut this inf.-mitim an.' h. lxAs'.iateli with Irow his vr^atnt b- furnish this- p rsnn.l, an' he als asked that p-gcnnel wr.tch h .lr.-. v 1 b.en . tailed tc hin should b. r.turn. B.uhler, as :..t-i: ne, maintain,' the paint -f vi.w that it was utterly i-ip.ssible t. us. p_ pi f.r th. -Xecuticn cf Euttaasia nc. they had already b en uc. 1 r such a terrible parpas_. u. saia that th. nssi.;ntaont as G1 h-cnik was carryin thr.u-h had .s a result tho bs elute de^radaticn r. brut-liz.ti n :f tr.. p.cple inv lv_:. Glebccnik h.DW_v_r, th_n tCld 7515 11. H'.j 3-33rcss-(itarlir)- Court 1 him that Uv.Sc pec pie waul n't be us. for that purp s-, but w.-.uli* '-nly be us ’ as supervisory p-rsenn ,1 in werkin- conns. 3cuhl< r then with¬ er r this rbjectin tc the use ct the personnel. •i AnU wh-.t .abcut y:u witness? .. I ha -1 alrwi’Jy iv-n up all hep- after that ccnv.rsation with M.-j.l.r that th Course cf this fat. ccul 1 * b. stopped in any way. 3ut I had always hoped that feroinn p.litical considerations ai^ht p-r- h-.ps dissuade Hitler f. rr carryin'; out all these plans. Bui, if that was n«t th- ease th- th uchc arose in c- vh.th-r an-- shouldn't cnee more fl.ke th- .at Wept t lissunde Hitl-r free th-3v pi-ns far purely prac¬ tical reiser., which ». .\ul'. «t that st:--. . f tn- w.r th. labor supply pl-y-d • considerable [*art. In -11 c- untri.s lot r was n— Vi forcud lab..r be^.an ta be us_‘. h c. us. ur cwn r.s ure.s wer- nt longer suf¬ ficient. Un r tn-.s- censi enU ns . n. etui.: p. rhaps p-rsuad- hitl-r that it w-ul b- r. re .x^'Uno tc use thes J«ws in ^ab:r rath-r than ext.min t- thm. I t 1 3 dhler i that tine that in th. case cf th.se. C t- 10 cilli-n urcp..an .8 tb-re oust, I aa sure be a Rr-eit nureb r I Vs who ire capable for work. On- su3t put it -o hitler that it was cl iua-.nae inn .—-me. tc 9aV- this p t.nti-1 labor pc 1. Hitler's c nc.ro that Go many its-lf c jl’ be cn an-crcd f r th- futur- woul hav. t b- count-re : by t-llin Me -hat th- sterilisation plan ccul b- me- -or- put int -x-cuU n, bee use by us in.- thi3 plan cf perr. n..nt st.rills ti n th*- danrer ci itness, when discussing this conversation you wore spo kin'; of the labor problon which bo/jan to bo of pern- oount iuportanco. Did Hinclor, in any way, participate in the solution of this . roblon? .. Not directly. Hii*.J.er, as Globoonik told us, had al¬ ready issued the order in the fall that forosts wore to bo planted in the Lkrein^ and that, of oourso, would havo boon a possibility of a lor ;o-scalo labor oonnittilont. . ~nd for that reason you boliovod that Hinnler was tho suitable ;urson, noodiiv; oo nany workers, for you to :;ivo tho arjunont to that workers wore noccsscry? .. We had plenty of work but there weren't suffioiont workers and, for th t reason, wo would have to put it to hia thr.t ho would have to save is r.ony workor3 as possiblo. How, of course, he could put that ar.ttor to Hitler in turn was his own off air but, at my rat©, Hi/^alor was tho noro powerful r.an, not 3ouhlor. g Now witnoss, Bouhl> r thought thr.t ho personally could not approach Hitlor. Bouhlor didn't soon to bo particularly anxious to approach Hinnlor. How did it oono about that you offer..! yourself in approaching H inn lor? .. Bcuhler .L'to-w put this off-r into ay aouhh. He said "You o-.n do it." His own relationship to Hinalor was too •.stran/.od, and he said th .t ho could support no in oaso any difficulties for ne .ro3e. I, -.t thr.t tino, already knew that ;ft-r iioydrioh'3 death thoro couldn't bo any iatttdi .to drjijer. In addition, I was nlrondy in tho arny. I really didn't think that ho would notlou so very quickly that this ; lan couldn't bo carried out in prr.otico - I theu *ht that would take r.ony .lonths. ; Now, Ilr. Brack, let us turn to tho nost inportait point. May 14-il-3£-4-3-Karrow (Int. Nacalcr) Court No. 1 TJio prosecution has submitted tho Doounont 110*205. During th.- oponin; str.tonont at tho bcjinninj of this trial it -’.oai'jnatod this lottor as a 3ub-hunan and dopravod report, vjid they s id that this was no sterilization to exterminate ;o--plo sufforin; from horiditrry rlisonscs, but that hero sterilization was used for criminal purposes. You will have to r.dait thr.t thi3 assertion of the prosecution, can net bo considered in view of this letter, to be without justi¬ fication. I n3k you now, in view of this enormous chorGo which was raised against you, to tell the Tribunal how you cone to write this letter of 23 Juno 1942, .and how you wen tod to be understood. In this way, tho Tribunal will be in .a .osition to join an obj^ctlvo picture of what happened end what was done. .. Hovi I oor.o to write this lottor I already told you. It v/as \a a result of th t conversation with Bouhlor. How this letter was actually subuitt^d to ue in tho intorro.jutions I can't rononber. I saw only tho first two sontonoos, and also ac know led jod uy si mature undo month it. ..t that tine uf tho date of this latter I was already with tho army and when this letter was first shown to no I thoujht that thi3 letter couldn't possibly have originated from no. In tho me ntino, however, I rocallod noro of the details. Today I can only repeat th .t I do not bolievo that thi3 letter >ri -inat ;;’ fren no in actual wording. I think that it had only boer. sent to :ie for my si .nature. I believe I con r-n~r:b-r either th it I Irv.fted this letter roujhly, or • •j.'.ve on- of ;.y oollabor .tors the order to write it. No natter hov. th .t m ly bo, this letter repr-sents essentially the intentions B_>uhl-r and I had. The significance of that 1 ttur is not in its oo jinn in - is not in its introductory r'.s. Th. si jnific r.ce of that lottor is solely that mention is r.vlo of the possibility of the labor committr.cnt Kzy 1* -il -3K-I—l -Ka it c*» (lav. .icniJ.or) Court ilo. 1 of tho Jews. . I think that it is correct that I onco aoro cito thi3 docunent, with tho approval of tho Tribunal, in ordor to enable every ono to understand tho question. It is the Docunent 205, Voluno 8, Snjlish Doounont Book, pt.jo 39. Tho lottur is not Ion ; and will only toko a few uinutos to road: "Viktor Brook, SS-Ob-rfuehrer ‘To;’ Socrot “Berlin, 23 Juno 19-12 "Door .ioiohsfuohror: "On tho instructions of .voichsloito? Double^ I plaood soao of riy r.on - already 3> no tina ry;o - at tho disposal of Bri'jadofuohror Globoonik to exooute his spaolal uission. On hi3 ronowod request I now transferred additional porsonn- ol. On this occasion Brij.adof uehror Globconik stutod his o. inion thr.t tho whole Jew-..otion should bo oonplotod as quickly as . ossiblc so that ono would not .jot ocu.jlit in tho niddlo of it one day if soao difficulties should nako a stop; njo of the action nocosscry. You yoursolf, Foichs- fuoliror, have already ux.irossod your view, that work should ..rojross quickly for reasons of ooaoufl.ajo ulono. Both points -which in principle* arrive at tho snnorosult ore aoro thr.n justified ns far os t.y on ex, orionco ^oos; nevertheless would you kindly allow no to subnit tho foil win or juriunt: 10 Trillions cf Jews La *uropo are, I fijurc, r.t * least 2 to 3 -.illion3 of non and wonon, who are fit enough f :r work. Considering tho extraordinary difficulties, th: labor probl-ja presents us with I hold the view that 2 or o nillions should be specially selected and reserved. This c j howov-r only be done, if at the sent ticu they' are rendered inca. ablo to ..ropajate. ..bout c 7520 ::-y l4-ii-BK-4-5-Knrrow (Int. Roador) Court No. 1 yo .r -30 I rojortcd to j *u -that agents of cine have convict¬ ed, tea experiaents necessary for this purpose. I would like to recall those facts onco core. Sterilization, as norcnlly perforce d on persons with horiditary dlso«.sos, is hero out of tho question bocause it takes too Ion; end is too oxponsivo. Castration by x-rays however is not only rolitivoly cheap, but can also bo porforaod on finny thousands in the 3hortost tico. I think, that et thi3 tino, it is .lro..dy irrolovent whothor tho pooplo in question bocor.o aw ju of h.-.vin 3 boon castrated of tor sono woeks or aonths, or.co they fool the offoot3. '•'Should you, .toichsfuehrer, decide to ohooso this way in tho interest of the .*osarvition of labor, thon iioichaloiter Douhler would bo propnrod to pl.aco nil physicians and oth-r personnel n^odod for this work at your disposal. Likewise he ruquostoi no to infora you, that then I would have to order tho apparatus so urjontly ncodod with tho jre -.tost spood." Si;ned, Viktor Brook. •Jltnoss, I a 3 k you now to define your ettitudo toward that lottor. 753 . lit ::.y-:>-:B-5-lrHaloy (Int. Punier) Court Ko. I. A I bavo already said that tho significarce cf this letter 3s only tho Ichor forces which are aentiorKd. I had nothing at ell per¬ sonally to rk) with tho eoHnitneat of labor. It was a nattor cf com¬ plete indifference to co, and it would have teen a r-attor of complete indiffororKc to -o whence Hitler or Kirsilor got their workers for thoir plans. If I had a proposal to HireJer mentioning tta capability of tho • Jews to work it was only based upon ny wish to stop this aoss murder at tho last i&inuto and try to point out th. possibility of permanent ster¬ ilisation, which was already mentioned in ny previous letter to Hinnlor. Tho pretext which I used was old.and I know that this method could really not work. I didn't concorn myself with tiw manner any core, and no experiments had boon carried through. Tho new thing in this suggoat- ion is ny reference to the bnlntonanco of productive labor, lifter not having spoken to Himlor since April 19U2 I had to find sono ycint of attack, and I did gat this point of attack by ny referonco to tho conversation between Olobocnik and Bouhlcr regarding tlx? detailing of T-U personal. Hinalcr w-.s hardly infonud that Olobocnik had taken Bouhlar into his confidonco about his extermination assignrunts. 3 had to explain that, and for this reason I cede referonco to tho furnishing of personnel to Globocnik. If a special mission is wntionod as tho purpose of this furnishing, I must say that under "special mission" I understood the large-scale work products at Lublin, which 1 had visited. In this way I pointed out the r.anpo.ror possibilities to Hlir.lor I had to mako sono reference to when and how Globocnik told Boufclor of his plans and for this reason I constructed tills introductory sontonco as you already road it. I would like to ouphasizo, however, that tho words "or. this occasion" in this letter are not at all synonor.ouc with tho wtrds "in this connection", what it should moan is "ir. tho course of this conversation", and that is exactly hor I described it before. Q Von, witness, you were saying hor that you had written to Hindu r reminding him that you had spoken to him before and telling him th-t you had olrearfc* furnished thcs_ ixn from the T—ii to Globocnik 7522 11 3-5-2-:Liloy (Ir.t. Easier) Court Ko< I. in April of 19U2, and you then thought: Hisnler couldn't possibly know how I cmc- to know about Globocnik's order to exterminate tho Jews, and I shall have to explain how this cane about; and this is exactly why you node this introduction in this way? •H. EOCHKAlOTt Just a'noacnt, please, I object against tho explanation. This witness told us for quite a long tin* how he under¬ stood tho let tor, how he wrote the letter and why he wrote tho letter, I do think it is unnecessary that dofenso counsel is just repeating what the witness just said froa tho stand. THE PRESIDENT: Counsel for tho lioswcution is correct. This is ontlroly superfluous. Objection is auotainod. Q Would you pleiso continue, witness. Wo had stopped at tho introduction of tho letter*. And now will you please pass to the con¬ tents of tho letter itself? A How I have explained th.- connection with Olobocnik. Further¬ more, it says in tho lotter that tho action was to be carried out as quickly as possible. 1 had to count on a v,ry quick development of things. Therefore, I had to .apparently agroo with Himnlor's and Globocnik's opinion in ordor to find .an occasion for tho lottor. '.H. HOCHTC.UOT: May it ploasc. Your Honor, I had tho Impression that ry objoct was against further discussing tho lotter and the docu- nont as such. The defendant Brack has spoken about his lotter for so do tiro and I do think he has told tlw Tribunal ovorything .about tho lottor. I do think that what ho is referring to new is conplotoly re¬ petitious. DR. FRGZSCHHA.’Ws !!r. President, I c-nnot at -11 agroo to that opinion. Tho possibility raust be 'von to the defendant Brack under all circunstcncos to be in a position to explain to tho Tribunal exactly what he wantod to express with tho letter in detail. Defendant Brack as f nr as I aa info mod, is almost through with the letter and needs only a few more sentences. I ask that thj opportunity be extended to the de¬ fendant Brack to explain himself and defend himself properly on this 7523 , Hi ' ay- 2-5-3-toloy (Int. R-nlcr) Court Ho. I. vital point. THE IPiSIDEST: The defendant any explain this letter any way he desires, but he should avoid repetition and not repeat liiat he has stated before. If defendant desires to =nko any point which he has not already ande, the witness any"sake the explanation. THE WITNESS: Y-s, Your Honor. I oxpxvsscd tho fact that I was counting on a quick dovoloFrent by writing that In ny opinion and fron ay own experience I felt that a rapid dovelopnont of this procedure was r.ore than Justified. Ir. that connection I was thinking of ay ex¬ periences with euthanasia, in which I had found out that crr.ouflago was possible. In that way I apparently agreed with Himlor ac to tho ex¬ pediency of a quick dovolojront; but then I added that I would liko hin to koop sonothing in Rind; and then I said that dorpitc tho fact that his interest in a quick dovclornont was justified, ho should also tako into account ry point of view; and this brought nx> to the real purpose of that letter, nacoly not to oxtcmir.ato the Jews, but to pro- sorvu then. In order to bo able to bring up ay old sterilization plan, I had to renind Hisrlor of what So had told .su in tto y ear I9tl, when ho was developing his sterilization plans. That is why I furthermore adapted cys^lf to his oontolity, .and his w.y of thinking, by saying that that could only b-_ dono if they wore rendered unable to propagate.- In that way, I protended that 1 shared Hitler's worry that the Jura would bo in a position to ur.dangor Go many if they .are not sterilized. If I say then — and I have boon asked about tiw significance of that sontorco — that it was ianatorial whotlxer tho people in question bo- coce awaro of having be r. sterilized cr not. I did so in ord.-r to allay tho suspicions Hinder nust have felt as a result of ny letter of 'torch I9hl* wharo I said that sterilization cannot be carried out with¬ out being noticed. I said' that nor those nisgivir^s were not longer worth;.* of discussion, because knowledge of tte externination of th_ Jons had already penetrated into too largo a circle. In tho last para¬ graph, I oneo nore enphasiso that tho labor r-ter ill would have -c b_ 75 a Ili Kay- 3-5—-~loy (Int, ?. clur' Court llo. I. preserved, and I wanted to enphasiso this print ns strongly ns possible. I Iso mentioned that Raichloiter Bouhlcr would bo Vole to plnco our physicians -ni other personnel nc-ds fer this iork, because Hinrlcr niiht hnvu objected that wc didn't hav ^nou-b physicians for tho exec¬ ution of that work. I'y Inst rcrark to tho effect that v,o ourselves would be able to cot tho apparatus necessary was to give BouJiicr tho op¬ portunity to delay getting the X-ray apparatus. Fron tho Document 206, exhibit 16. in Documnt Book 6, it can bo soon that the first report about tho sterilization experii*:nts had been sent on tho 29th of April Ifbh. DR. P30BSCH?2»K": "r. Frosident, the docun-nt to vhich tho do- fondant is now referring to, Docun.nt 208 can be found in tho English Document Book Volmo 6, pauu U3» A (contimed) Orx. year and a half had passed until oven a report was ready to be r.adc. I personally don't knew mything about the further development of any matter, but I can certainly conclude on this very late d.to that It w-s possible fer Dcuhler to delay tho be¬ ginning of those experiments to a groat extent. TH" ?HvS!DE:rrt Before going into discussion of this othjr letter, the Tribunal will bo in xvcoss. (Th^roupon a rcooss n*s taken.) 7525 Hi '',ny h7-*:-ATD-8-l-Cross (Ini. von Schon) Court So. 1 ~-Z KkPSKAL: Tho Tribunal is a^ain in session. THU sSESIDTST: Counsel my proceed. fs re. rcsscs&rai: 1 Witness, before the rccoss you had concluled 'discussing Document No. 205 and yew were dealing with Document So-206j and you had emphasised that tho erqxirfrfcnts, which Kero apparently performed by Dr. Schumann without ycxir krxwlod^cj, after one and a half years cane to a nopative result, A I should like to correct an error - not 205. I had roforred briefly to Docurv nt !'o-203 which is Exhibit 166. I said that as far ns I can ju %o now Rouhlcr had succoedod in delayin' the bo .innin;. of tho experiments by arran in- that tho x-ray rachinos wore delivered late, bocauso this time ras a year on' a half later. Put, : r^oclf had nothin- noro to ’o -.ith these thin s from that movant on. Consequently the answor letter to linolcr, which was ’T-206, did not cone to ny attention. Exhibit I I, on por 0 11 of the Document Book VI. This letter nho.ro that Kimlor accepted tho siren "workurs" an'* now I soo from this docu xnt that icnl r s-mt a corbcn copy to Pohl. Thin .ocurunt :r-206 also shows that HL .nl r wanted to j .rfom oxpcri.'.jnts first. Thu3, tho delay which I had inter.od in caso Himl.r should -ivo up hi3 intention of oxt-rrlnatin tho Jews ha* b< successful, bocauso tho execution of tho exocrine nts would have boon sansoloos if tho extermi¬ nation of tho Jaws had continued at tho sona tine. To ’my I an convinced that by p ,rfomin- thoso exporlrvinta hundreds ,6f thousan la, if rot noro, Jcr.rs wire saved. This lottar also shows that Hinaler in tho last analysis considered rvj rcrcly a riddle nan batuoon himself and Douhl r because he says, "I would be grateful to ftAchuleitcr Mahler if he would place physicians at ny disposal. 1 naV-r .*y successor Blankcnburv was able also to carry on ’ ilayin tec ics ainnt Hitlvr I do not know. Do curvet id -206, Exhibit 165, Occur, ur.t Cook ’I, pap.o 1*2 in th hvlish, shows that ir. this latter tc -axtal.r ho ha * a Toed to stablish contact >rith tu, ; Chief of tv ..in Office for Concentration C-raps. That all .-3 on. 7526 li; "ay Ii7-J-ArD-c-2-Gross (Inf. vcr. Schon) Court !Io. 1 to conclude that he also attempted tc lolay th_- natter, but I didn't know whs. rsssi-n-xnt Bouplar had ‘4von hia until these letters woro sub¬ mitted hero during the trial. I had no idea of their existence and later 7 never asked Bouhler what happened in this ratter and -whether ho made ary doctors or one ’octor available. I can a. rely aay fron hearsay that Dr. Schumann was rr lo available, but if this was dona by Bouhler then Bouhler certainly ur-red Dr. Schunann to lake as mch tino as possible with the exjvrirx>ntsi ’row I can rofer a;ain to Document :&-20P, Exhibit 166 , pago 1,3 of th. .-:r.;li3h 3ocir»ont Hook VIi This last letter, vhich was submittod by Prosecution in this connection, indicates clearly that the delay which at least X intcn*od> ovon if ccnpljto success was impossible, did occur, bob-use tv lottvr vas written only one and ono half years later. T don't krwr rh-t ffchunann's work was that is mentioned hero. I Jon*t know about it. That Blankcnbur" in this lottor asserted that H i m lor ha ' ashed ao to oontinuo Schurannts work is not truoi Guch a roquedt as seo: o to bo rwntioned in thin lottor was never expressed to io by Himlor. olankoribur- apparently concluded from the lottor - ’D-206, Exhibit l61i - that Binalor was asking ouch a request. That is, however, wrorv , because in this letter Himlor snys that ho himself is interested in havin' tho exports nts carrlod out. Tho request to rviko tho -'actors available to hin prov-.s that Hi nlor himself wanted to arrongo for ar.- cany out thoso experiments. Tho letter which I just mentioned, l*)- 206 , exhibit 166, on yv;o lx 3 in the Ik Ush Document Book ’/I, proves finally that in practice the procedure sumootol was a .rf.vctly -oo * jthod. Cl "fitness, e have finished, tho discussion of thoso letters which tho Froaocution submitted to provo your collaboration in tho Pro ran for the TbcV rr dilation of the Jews. You have explained everythin'; to tho Court, I need not r p at. I should re roly like to express ny personal opirdon an’, a-,!: vheth r it is true, and uheth r you ft :dt, that actufdly y/>i wor - actin' with a banana int_r.tion an fron stupi-'ity i t yourself h-, involves; in a matt r~ dch you li-' no., u. torstan-. 13 that true? 7527 lU 2ta7 li7- , -.«TI>-f-3-Cros3 (int.- von Schon) Court No. 1 A Yes, that is true.* Q Vow, *lr. Brack, the ruoosof two doctors mentioned in theso letters which were the subject of discussion at your interrogation - ono is Dr. Schumann, who has been mentioned repeatedly, and the other la Dr. Eborl. In the ccurae of this trial the Prosecution has repeatedly jxpressed the suspicion that Schumann had sono connection Tdth the T-k Euthanasia ! rograr. or >articipitod in the extorndnation of the Jews. Can yew out to briofly -iva ths Court yewr personal knowlodgo about those tetters? A nr. Schumann ias the head of a Euthanasia Instituto an 1 in port also acted as nn psychiatric oXpert. I say Schurann the last time in tho Rescue work in the East whore iio wasin charge of a nodical post. As far as I recall, after that ho loft tho service of tho Euthanasia organisation and rosunod his privnto practice. hcn and whoro ho was assigned to the sterilization experiments I do not know. But, I mist assure that Bouhlor did that hlnsolf with th; intention, howovor, of delaying tho storilization oxporiaonts, since Schumann was -v.rsonally lenovm to him. I qysolf had nothin-, to do with this appoint.lent. It was long after ny tine. Dr, ^bcrl was also know to no from T-Uj of his participation in tho Hj-13 Irivo I Invrr nothing. Of his activity in an oxtornination canp I heard about in 19)*3 once or twice through third parties. Ho al30, when tho iithanasia pro-ron was stopped, loft tho organisation of T—i», I bell ova, bocauso I nover sin hin again.' q Now, witrvoss, I cooo back to tho affidavit U26, Exhibit 160, English Docuojnt Book 1U, page 10, anti it is No. 15 that interests no at this point, I shall quotoT "Anon*; tho doctors who assisted in tho Jewish extermination program., woro Eborlc and Schumann. Schurann performed nodical exporirnonts on priaorers in Auschwitz. It would hr.vo boon Impossible for those ran to participate in such things without th.« personal knovlodgo and consent of Karl Brandt. Tho order to sand those r.en to tl>; East ccul'l have boon Ivon only by airrlor to Brandt, possibly throurh ’ caihlor. 1 ' Ik Hay li7-r4-nTD-8-i*-Orasa (Ir.t. vcr. Schon) Court No. 1 But it aays there very definitely that you had knowledge about this, that Schurann pcrforrad nedical experiments on prisoncrsiln Auschwitz and also that thoso experiments could not have taken place without the defendant Dr. Cnrl-3rcjv't kr.o>.-irv: about it. This dOvis not a^reo :dth ycur testinorfc* cc far. hr.t can ycxitdl us about that? 7529 lii I '-v'--——-9-1-Harrc* (ir.t. 7or. Schcn) Court Bo. I. A Tho inclusion of this paragraph in the affidavit w~.s not done by ao, but hy tho person who 'row up th: affidavit. I rs told that paragraph 15, just like paragraph 12, case fron no. At first, I refused to sign it but I was told that that was -oroly a logical c0 lii ' ~j-~ ^-9-2—rrorr (Int. 7cn Schcn) Court Ho, I, Q And then at tho end it reads, "possibly through Bouhlor". Did you put that in? A Ye3, bee-iuse I did not know the relationship between Kin Her md Brandt, wh^le I Sene/, through tix. euthanasia assignment, how Bouhlor and Brandt worked together. Q Now, witness, in #16, and this brings sc to the end cf this affidavit, there is a sontenco, "Hinder donarded that a n?no of a doctor be given hin. Schumann, as f*r as I can recall, gave no and Bouhler a report on his experiments." Is that true? A That does net really correspond to tho facts. That vas what the interrogator told =e - that 1 ! idler aaSajd for a specialist doctor. I was not able to check the correctness of this statement and assumed that it was correct. Tho report which is nsntioned in 016 was not tho 19Ua report, which is oontioned in Docuaont No. 208. It refers to a vague rocolloction of nine of information fron Schumann that he hinsolf had som knowledge of X-ray .antters airf had oarlior carriod out experi¬ ments in it. Tho report which he govo in 191^ I loaned about only hero, Q Then, I havo finishod the discussion of tho charge of ster¬ ilization. Do you have anything more to say on this subjoct? A I can only say that J bolievo that in ay testimony so far I havo explained that I never had any intention of exterminating tho Jewish people, but attempted to achieve the contrary, to protoct the Jows and save then fron a terrible fate. That I attempted so nothing that was far boyond ay power, ay position, =y ability, I must admit is true. But since, in all my life, I have always been helpful toward and never had any hatred of Jews, I can't inagino why I should have be¬ come a champion of tho oxtoraination of tho Jews. Q Aro you finishod? IS. Fesidont, I should like to make one brief remark concerning sterilization. I have endeavored to have tho associates of the defendant Brack concerned with this subject found, lfcr offerts and the efforts of the prosecution, as far as I an inTomcd, 7531 Hi !ay-v- H£-3-Harrow (Int. 7cn Schoa) Court !Io. I t have been unsuccessful. For tret reason, I rust unfortunately depend on the testimony of the defendant Brack alone in this connection. I as convinced that if I had succeeded in finding one of the nun who are mentioned, as a witness, tho Court would hear a confirmation of Brack's statement. I conclude my evidence in r- and to sterilization experi¬ ments and near I turn to thj charge that “rack collaborated in cuthanash for as a preliminary step toward :onocide. .iitnoss, you Imotv that on the basis of the testimony of the witness ifennc-cke, tic prosecution attempts to bring you into connection with tho superficial - almost too weak a word - examination of political prisoners, Jewish prisoners, prisoners in preventive custody, ir. tho concentration camps. '.That do you have to say to this charge Gf tho prosecution? A True, tho prosecution called euthanasia a preliminary stop toward genocide. Considering thj documents and tho witnesses available to tha prosecution, I can understand such an assumption on tho port of a rofrosentativu of the United States. Tho socrocy which surrounded Hitlor'o docroe of tho 1st of Soptcmbcr, 1939, -and the elimination of political opponents, prisoners of war, noch-rs of othor nations, and finally, tho murder of millions of Jews could and had to perhaps givo tho prosocution tho impression tint tl» O overa*;nt of Gcrr.'ny, from tho beginning of tho war, had tho intention nf making tin euthanasia arrangemont an instrurent to b_ used against all real or iro-inary onosiius of Gcrer.ny, within tho framework of .an ostensible euthanasia program. This assumption, however, is definitely mistaken — that euthanasia, in tho hour of it3 -irlh, had Lx-un intended as such a method, or that the thought could have oven arisen that, for reasons of expediency, the whole Gercrn people rcra to be fre<-d from t'a so»cailed "useless eaters" and thun, in tn* future course of events, enc aios of Germany would be extorairatad under the pretext of euthanasia. when euthanasia was introduced, ro welcomed it, becaus. it was based on tho ethical principle of sympathy and had humane considerations in its favor, of the same sort that the opponents of euthanasia claim for 'thi.ir 7532 lii lfay-*'- S-9-ft-Karrow (Ir.t. Von Schon) Court Ko. I. own ideas. I aitoit that thsre were imperfections in its execution, but that does net change the decency of the original idea, as Eouhlor and Brandt and I nysalf mdorstood it. Q Witness, we know from tha case so far that, in the 0010 * 3 %! of tijno, euthanasia installations isoro used for this Action lh-?-13 end everything that followed. Do you consider it possible that Hinnlor, free your kncwiodgo of things today, might lv-.vu gotten such idc23 from sone words which Hitler dropped in conversation and fron these ideas created tho Action lli-F-13? Is it possible that non like Hi-TiJor, knowing that those sterilization oxpcrinjnts would bo unsuccessful - tho so experiments that wo wore just speaking about - that he, in ap¬ plying outhanasin, with ttosc coons and methods saw a rwro useful tool than tho ueoloaa sterilization oxporiments? 7533 II; liaj- (Int. Vc n Schor.) Court Ko. I. A As I judge Hicaler today I consider that possible. Q Then wuld that not load us to the conclusion that KiixOur cccr.itted the eri c against huaanity since h. took the idea of euthanasia about which ore ".i^iit have fliffofv.it opinions on tho ideol¬ ogical point of view, distorted it for re aeons of hatred or bigotry, and used it for t'.ic lairdor of Jaws? A Yes, that is doubtless pns3iblc, because tho idea of euthanasia was nis-used by tho coa s is oi on f -.11 cf theso criros. What w-.s dono hero ins nothing tc do vith out hams la as a benefit to tto Person who is living a life inworthy of living. I don't want to say a groat doal ho re abcut tho othiccl basis of euthanasia, but by vay of Introduction to this subject, I should like to say that ny whole attit¬ ude was based on religious up-bringing. Only ry holpfulnoss toward overyono and ospoc Laily towards tho sick _iado no an advocate of tho idea of euthanasia. Q Kcw, witness, I asked yev rt tho beginning to spoak about Monnecko's tootiircty*. leu thought it right to give briefly your othicol attitude toward cuthoanstaj bar, hew about Ibnnocko'n testimony? A According to th. docurcnts it is true that in l?ljl, accord¬ ing to 1151 FS, Exhibit till, th- Dociuent Book 16, page Hi of tho Gorman, 12 in tho English, it rtrs on the 12th cf Koveribor l?hl that Hicnlur sunt radical cccrdssions to tho concentration canp to soicct tiio prisonors. I can say with a door conscience that up to this trial I had hoard nothing of tho order cf Kir. lor. Tho filo note liiF 3.3 was completely — foreign tc to r.s a cc;.co.-t, up to this trial. I cannot recall that I over hoard ttese nu.fx.rs lii and 13, or road then in this connection, but if that should havo boor, the ease then I certainly didn't think .anything about it, but road it over just like .any other file note that one gets when one gets thousands f letters a day. "hose file notes were always copied autoaatically from the incoming to the outgoing letter. But oy .ad_lt : .ir. ; this possibility I do not naan to inply that I have even tho slightest recollection -f this 1M 13, 753 L XL J'ay-L-::3-iC-2-:: lev (Int. Y*\\ Schon) Ciurt Kc. I. but I can say very definitely that up to tlx beginning uf this trinl I did not knc*r fchet these nuBbcrc indicated any particular action and certainly not tiiis particular one. If I led known the nature of the project which Has concerned _u.adcr this sign, 11* F 13, net .nly would I have not consciously participated in such a project, but I would have rescind any possibility of supporting such a project in any form. Q Her, witness, what rj the situ-ui'n? A Tho witness Hielscter, on the 16th of April 15L7, said that the prisoners in concontra-i.n camps, a s. 11 nuntocr of rrhoja I becaao acquainted with nde a tcrrlKLc i.jrcc: ion. !.’o said that :»c3t of then wuro spiritual wrecks. He said that tho majority of thou rouainod cick for tho rest of thoir lives, that thoir umtnlity and I night say vital¬ ity, were broken. This c?ndlti-n of the erioonora uight havo boon known to Hie.-lor fror. roports of tho concentration conpe. To what ox- tont Hiolsch.r'e \ssertion is correct that Hirsalor expressly through his system broko tho spirit and health cf r.c3t cf those prisoners I cannot judge. In this connection I should like to recall -the conversa¬ tion which 1 had with Hirrlor in January of 191*1. I also saw flaws then whon ho spoke cf his intentions of st«.ri: the Jews. I had certain doubt3 thon /bother tho iuprorsicn I had had of Hianlor up to that tine was quite correct, but thoso thoughts wore sr.rohow dissipatod because I hoard nothing r»ro about it, .and I thought Hinalcr hacl given up his intentions against tho Jews. I considered it as a confirriatlon of this opinion of nine th-t Hinlor Jnd bccorw n-.rc humne that in tho suarwr of 19L1 I «•*= tcld by Bcuhlcr that Hirrlor intended to liavo the most seriously ill persons in tho concentration cx-apc examined for their physical and aontol conditi n. Hiaclnr askod Bcuhler to jive hlA neutral doctors, since u did not have onourh confidence in tho . bility cf the caap doctors. Bouhlcr asked =o to jot in touch with tho T-L and inquire, or ratter ask that experienced psychiatrists bo assigned to ax-uina tte prisoners in the concentration camps. I did sc. Whothcr I • passed t:ie request on to I.'ietzscho .ana Heyde, I really can't say. 7535 lii Ua7-y-iB-iO-3-}feloy (Lit. Von Sc non) Court bo. I. Q .'itncss, you Jus . said seething ratixc incidental when speaking of the personality cf Hitler, you saiifl ,-ou \a* tte impression ttet H --- er becorerorc hursno a^ain in t* sucaer of IfLl, that Bo-ohlor said to you that te r: lor hac asxcd hfzi, i uhler, t acid electors to the concentration car.ps to oxmio the per jL e hen Hi- lcc a/ i.as described) that right pive the luprccii n that ;yc •. didn't thin; this thine is very important it the txmc’ t, but it a oe s to no that that ms a very important assipwent, a *. iry irportt nt request that Hlnalcn • av <- to Bouhlor. Didn't ;-ou think 'i\ " tlw tfci:np *06 as important then as it ray appear today? A At tlxj tire I thei !r; a request rate quite a scoondary letter. I ';avo to co-jo beck . ir want I s.-id day b-fnro yostordry. I was von.urkod in thj Cha- cc* . ry _f t:»o Fuoh.-4'r. What work I did for thu euthanasia organic ';i n war roally only o. n t.a side, and at this tie in 191*1 was lin'.c< uoro?y to .v.cair.;; *r.» inutructicn3 from 3Cuhlor, and tho question* roiuosts ef T-l». Diurii* tfeat tire J had nuch i. ro work nt Vjr Chancellory cf tho Fuom^r. I action this asnignnont -uroly boc .uno th.s nado re think that i'i^r.Jer hnd seno good intent!jn here, c nscquontly I didn't hnvo any \Ury exact recol¬ lection to when I farced it on, to ono of tho non in flicrgarton Stras.-o U, and I don't infer rhat bcc-;» cf this nssiennont. I*t Is possible that the result *jf th.no oxroinations \na ivon to T -U, a id tlion oithor to tho Inspoctojr.t.; cf the Concentration Caiape cr to "n/ploi', but “t. tho tir.o I was n t ablo to caunt on tho possibility th-t :! j-a‘l«-r, on tho basis f t'- sc results, intended to oxUnimto prisonarc, whom, ac¬ cording U ry feeling at the tie Ijo ;as having oxardnud for meuano conci-Orations. I could net assure tint. Q lou accepted this assigns.nt fren Souhler lu frh; fV?3ew>rk ■■f all thj other asslgnoents ycu were given at tho tin,; you Wire glad that 'licr lor wanted to give a psychiatric c-xscinaticn to fcbero po'r people, but that y?u had no reason to think that this result night bo usad for such an action as the ritness Ifcnnccko described, is that true? A Yes. 7536 i- H y -if-OJG-11—l-!6»chen (vcn Sheen) Ccurt He. 1 Q Mew, witness, when you possed this assigna-nt on ycu know that it wculd be dcflt vith by Ticrgartenst rr s s c 4; did the personality of the Doctors werking at Ticrsartwnstrrsse 4 cff.r ycu rny certainty that these Dcctors rculd carry cut thw nssijroont fren a purely nodical pcint of view? A Neither free Chief Escort Pref. Hoyde ncr Chief Export Nietzsche was I sv-r able tc obsorvo that thure was ever any inhuann cr brutal treatoont, but in addition, cs far as a lyaaan can judge, I hr/' the impression that these two wero outstanding Doctors. There wero many other good psychiatrists who were called on to help thin cut in their work. 1 thought that this assignment was in the bert hends. Q Ken did ycu know that rTter this assignment was passed cn in the Burner :f 1941 there was any influence at werk, uhethor frem Hi.nl cr, tho Inspectorate cf the Concentration Carps cr anyone els*., in dictating a criminal intent ultir- toly; lid veu knew that? A All of a sudden 1 did not have the ticc tc take any interest in tho erganizrticn at liorrrrtonstrassc 4. At the end cf 1939 or beginning cf 1940, by the order of Rvichsloitcr Bcuhlcr, 1 tcck an interest in the organization of this nor .matter, but lrtcr that stepped. 1 hardly ever wont tc TiirgJ rtonstraaso 4 syadf • The office was under ochnc at first and lctvr under .Jlers end it worked quit* independently. own office wqo cn Vesatrasse rrv’ tho Euthanasia crfice was ct li.rgcrtonctrroso 4* I n.*3 therefore unable tc oba .rvu the relations cf liergcrtonstr ssc 4 tc ether ,e*ici».s and, cf course, I woo unable to ebs^rvo whether in the toccntino »dthcut ay kr.crltdgc or Bcuhlcr* c knowledge, other influ¬ ences had assorted these elves there. 1 can only assuac that tc c>; I consider it cuito possible, however, that cn the basis c! thu events, * in tho spring cr succor cf 1941, >hat Couhlcr asked fer the oxrwsiv ti. ns, closer ccnnecticns iwvolcpcd between Tiergartenstrasss 4 and the Inspector cf the Ccr.centrrticn damps cr sc-au, olh r rg.ncit.r-, cf which I knew nc- tiiir.g a;*: -h t suggestions cane directly fre:- there tc Tior^artenstrasso 4 t: hevc new _xenin.atic.as carried out in the ccnccntr.aticna ca.Tps, widch we.1:1 then f-11 under the «cticn 14-F-13. 7537 14 3fty-.fOJG-U-«fcch=r. (von Shcn) Court He. 1 Q /fitness, let us £c back fer ? y«rr fer r mcmcnt. Witness Hen- necks allowed th«t in th- spring ^r sutler, net cf 1941, but of 1940, he received instructions Cre a Nietzsche, Professor Hoydo cr yourself to visit the concentration carats and tc fill cut questionnaires there about priacr.ers, who were selected by the c nap physicians; cr.n ycu ro~ cnnb_r this testimony? A Yea, but I resossbur that in the Cross Examination, Aianc eke changed this stetooent end he seid he could not ary with certainty tlsr.t he talked * to rse ’t ril ct.ut his rerk in the ccncentraticn craps, jicnucckc’s as sort! on thrt with the people whoa he mentioned he visited the concen¬ tration cr-T>s in 1940, it secos tc no, is doubtless an error in hin ncaory. In the spring cf 1940, Zuthan: si' was just boginni.v in the Euthanr.si? Institute: , the B-Inotitutcs, etc., and at th t tlu. thoro wr.s definitely rot enough time tc send Doctors to concentration crops cn special r;, 3-jiconts. I can only •arune that the .dtness .lonnccko con¬ fuse r 1940 with 1941 hero. It in pcssihic, that he parti¬ cipated in this first ox-nir.-.ticn --ho wh.lv physical and mental oxroimticn cf the ccniiti. f the pett sat* in conce itrati n cn ps, which was ordered by Bcuhler. These sere perfectly legitimate oxAiin- r.tions, is chc:.n by the roues cf the ether Doctors when Mornccko .zonticned, Dr. FnlkoLhauacr, Dr. StoLzxaoyor and Dr. Hiat zb oho. These ore all noricuc ddor psychiatrists, who would certainly never h.-va permitted thcasolves tc t- used for ny non-acdicnl action Ter : jo3itical natives. Q hit.: css, the court Jcc3 net knew Fdkttlhnuacr, Stui/vnoyer end Nietzsche and 1 dc net knew thee either, sc thr.t 1 could net judge. .o arc depcndii cn yettr judgment, but 1 csk ycu aro these men. Dr. Frli.el- hr.uscr. Dr. SUir.r.ey_r end Dr. dotssche, -there they a« U^o F f rjinnu oiler? A • Ol, in particular th-y -vre .1 .r tl;n Dr. Pfennaudlcr, I think they were all cl lor. In any esc, they sc^cd tc ac tc be nature, worthy, highly decent human beings. I cannot o.ve my ether i .pressicn bucru c die-* orde •* very cut—standi.'.: i prcssicn. Q I -ms chcut r.sk ycu whether these, ...n ucro squall: cccnt ir. 7533 14 .L- v v-.i-0oG-il-3-Iioth,-_n (von Shcn) Cc-urt Mo. 1 their thinking, tc «y ncthine >f their action, at least ca Dr. Pfenn- nuciler aha. ed hires elf tc think r.^re? « Doubtless, yes. Q Kev, I have another question; Witness licnnecka said th:.t in 1941 ha received a suarxns tc select Jc*.s arr'. foreigners cr lly frciii Heydo -nd Kiotzscho end, ec frr as he could rasarber, from you, but c.s frr ns ycu were concerned, ho later admitted he c-uld net raaenb^r that de¬ finitely; whet do ycu scy r.bcut this? This was 3941, "hen could t’da assigna-nt hrve bee:* given? A Acccrdinj tc his cun letters, which were sub.:.', t ted by the Ircsc- cuticn, this ctsijnnent cast Jiav. boon in October c: . r of 1941. At this ti-no ltoydo was net verkinr at Ticr;r.rtcnntrraso 4 cnyuero. Ho left in ..u uot cr July cT 1941, I don't knew if it was July cr August, To this extent it is definitely an error r.f ucauiry on Uonncckc'n part, acrocver, I ccnsidcr it entirely isrpcsaiblc that Koydu, with all Ids docont personality, wculd have given sue; an rsoicincnt and this scons txaio cf the eld and serious Professor Nietzsche. Q And did ycu yourself in Kevinber er t any ether tine in 1941 give Ho,inockc such an r.ssigmont to oesnino prisoners in concentration conp; in c superficial way ignoring the i-e-'icnl point of view ro ilcnnock assorts? A I xaxst deny that emphatically. 1 did not give Uunnocko nuch an os3i ^nreent and I nev^r talked to hin r.bcut such an aaaic-nment. Tliat wculd have been against ay whole rxcral attitude. I b«.lievo 1 hrvo al¬ ready proved hew intensely I werked for yerrs against the institution cf concentration ccops. 1 would have had tc be as tw :-facc-i no Hinder presumably was because this assiyxn-.nt was U be carri -d cuS in an irresponsible way, as 'axnocku said and as the letters to his wife in¬ dicate. I wculd net Irvu been * U li:.q tc participate in that. 1 witness, in this ccnnccticn I coo interested in another statement cf I&nn©eke, which is in contradiction tc wh:.t you just said. The Witness Lfennecko said that ycu had objected b_cause’ ir. his judgment f the 7539 U n-4-Jfechan (vcn Sbcn) Ccurtr lie# 1 questienr. ires; ho tcck tee strict nr. attitude, dc ycu raseAer that? A Yc3. Q 'Ant ic ycu have tc say about thrt? /. I deny this tee, according tc contents ct least it is untrue end possibly th feet that 1 discussed such c thine with hia t 11 is untrue. I m net e Doctor end I could not criticise an expert in nr.y ' ey ern- ccrnin.; his ocdic'l work en his questionnaires concerning Euthanasia. But, I adait the possibility that t the requests cf i-refossors i'oydc -ad Nietzsche, I asked Connect in aoao ether connection to bo ixro careful, th't is in f ini nc cut the questionnaires in his trips to tho dental institutes, beca«isc if the qu.sticnr.airca were not flUod cut carefully cncu.jh, *s the hitness . frucvaiollor testified h-rc vihon ho saw a questionnaire net cc^ilotelj filled cut, then the psychritri’t docs net hevo the onto rl id. fer Ju^rinc the ease and then the vsrk has boccno senseless and thero aro no results. Sinco .lar.nocko, as his letters indicate, res striving tc establish records, thero is tho possibility ttvt ho worked a little hratily, but I cennct remomber that I telkcd tc Ucnnocko at all en such r. subject. Hi iy U7-C4-AE-12~l~C do!: (Int.von Schor.) Court So, 1 O “Titno 53 , then hew ;o you explain this testimony of tho witness l-'onnccke, the assertion .'--jf-'-or i ;us in the sunner of 19iiO-19Ul, and whither it rne because of you iiotzschj or Koydo that he ;ot an ossifinosnt to carry out oticn ll—F-13? A /hen •'ennecke appeared haro on tho witness a tan 1 ho *ns in a very bad or unfortunate s'-tu-.tion. Re had been condcnnod to death by another Court. Therefore, this testimony to the extent that it does not corrospon 1 . to tho truth, I can explain only froa an effort in hia difficult situation to shift the responsibility fron hdnnolf to others, in this case to no, so that he could, ro 'uca his 01 m responsibility nn’ perhaps obtain clocuncy. It is quite oossiblo that Yonnecka received au'. test ions for v'vit ho lid fren 1 , ndocrat Borne tat an* his associates. I havo boon able to loarn nw that tho Kosso avont BemotAt ires obviously a ra ’icol advocoto of outhanasia an* had a cirdo of such ra 'ical a ’vacates of euthanasia. I also boliovo that '.onnockn through '■-racist -.res roeomondod to Hey '.0 or aono one also as an expert. 0 T 01 noon that Yonnccko through a third porsen or pjrhaps on liia o'iTi initiative had a very superficial an* peculiar aotivity without orders fror. Hoy’.o or Kletxsche or you? A Ho, ho it anot even ancoura-.od, O How, >»r. Track, it has boon established that tho euthanasia institutions, I rerx'-ubor tho unfortunate nano Bernbur , opjnod thoir doors to these transports of invalids ao that these unfortunato people ho were not sick could be {.assod there, a fact frou which every docent hunar. bein' raiat turn a*ray in horror? Thon in your opinion how could such a thin; happen? A I learned that hero hirir. he trial. It is ccnpletoly inexplicable to no. I kw nothin about it at the ti’ae. I can explain it only by influ nco fro . outsit e, fron so., other source, on T-)i, p'-rh-.pr. tho ins • ctorato of concentration canos, p. rhans "rnwito, perhaps throu-h Lin r., . T-icl: •> puty for intal institutions, : don't krow. 7541 1’; !Iay U7-?5-.lTD^L2-2-Coofc (Int. von Tchoen) Court Ik), 1 Bouhler, if he had any idea of it rrouid have icncdiately forbidden it an*', so would I a Q Witness, you have testifiod to your knowledge about the action lli-7-13, you adnit that in tho~sumer of l?ltl through 3ouhlor you aero authorized to pass on an cssi^nncnt to ?-U, to havo octors available for psychiatric a xnn t n ations of prisoners, but you dory havin' anything to do with action Ui-F-13, as tho witness .-tennecko described on tho basis of th. order of 20 Kovoabor, 19fcl, is that correct? A Yes. DP. FHOISCKV.r.’Ki '.fr, Prosidont, th.n I havo finished the charge of tho Prosecution ccr earning tho action lfi-F-13, and no.; I caw to outir.nasia. Should I V;vin tint no.: or loos tho Court vish to racoss? THE PKESEEliT: Tho Tribunal iriil now bo in rocoss until 1:30. (The Tribunal adjourns I for the noon recess) 75A2 14 —'7 47 -A— 13 - 1 —- Foster t?~Lr) Court So. 1 AfTsC--^:; swisic-a (Tr.- h,-rir.' r-oonv^n-d it 1330 . ours, 14 Jiiy 1947.) -17. 7-.- AL: Tho Tribun 1 is -ciin in session. 77 1 i: Counsel azy proceed. VIXTCil ERACX - i'eauaod DEL-Cr ajkiaiULTIOi; (Continued) 3'/ DP.. F„ 4SCSttl.Ti (Counsel for th. DeTvjxJ-at lr ck ): it.-.-cs, I rusdne yoa thr.t you -jv still under xth. Q. ..itness, dealing with the fine! eh ptur >i outhnncaie, I shill havu to sive you -n opportunity to -o^lnir. your iffidr.vlt 42o, in thoEnglish Doeaxa' Book Voluac 14, 10, 'nd spunk 'bout it ..'it’i ref r-r.c- to tbu point which denis with out tone ale. You h .vo * 1 reedy mentioned the circunat ntxs under -rich you r. -7 tl-is afcr.taount, nd you told no to out tho i'ct tint you considered il the ssertions by thtf prosocutian r.u a oin? Justified, nd y.xa di.r.'t aff-r ny criticiao. Aculd y xi pL-r.oc find out *.hur« the atdtoesonto thr.t you re vi! ( i, v n \» dovir.t- froa tho otrtOD-r.to s '.eiv .,iven by you then? A. I novur r f ■•..'r. sin i -r -r., tho ir.Urrv-torn used th t ward . r t..v first tin.. 1 ' 2m - r I objoctud to th t word, but, in off.ct, -rograa ennoot bo t- Iked of - wfc. n s iw~Jdne about 5ro.yr^ 1 uncorat.' nd - project rhich it lLvitod by tkk. rtf which is plmrwd ccrofully, -nd > :;_r, cucc-cs it expected t UiO -nd. In order to -r iu the uxinimtion * little sicr, 1 ohril continue to uso the .ord ■program", It bough the -Tessi^r. its.If is not corroct. Tho pro&ocuticn r. th 10th of J.muiry 1947 arid tj t t:-is '^30ed in Auyest -f 1941. Ire eut.m r.i oro rvn '4-jring thit pcri.xl/fck tin. dc-.it only with .r.oo. 1 diaca»-s, -s Coo-ral T"ylor sale in his opening statement on 21 . ovembor 1916, page 1 of th- transcript - but it «a& r-th^r an ttwnot to solve or oblcc \ Id. eh is as old -s the Id story of huaanity itself* \!hrt happened .ftor the stoppage if tir.t jx-ogran in 1941 hr s nothing -t " ll to do vjith the execution of cuthenesi.a, dth perhaps fe:. singular exceptions. C. itrwsa, the prosecution i.*s subedtt-d th. affidavit J - certain Leuss-.r. This is prosecution docirs-nt nuabor 3S U?i, ;:hibit 367, English D.-rja^it Book Jio. 14, page 251; German document 3ook VoliMt 14, part 3, page 170. Have y>u th t docus-nt bool: befir* >*ou? Document Volume 14, > rt 3, p g« 251? In this docua-nt Doctor Lausscr soys that the transports extondod Iroa 1940 to 1941, up until 1944. Whftt have you to nay 'bout that? 7544 Court 1 May 14-*r-l4-l-HD-Grcss-Haamler, A. In paragraph -2 of that document Dr. Leusser says rad I quote: "My knowledge about the occurences in the lunatic asylum at nnsbaoh during the war are based on lnforc'-ti n, which I received In the first olace mostly fr a Dr. Schuch, but also from Frau Dr. asan, one Dr. Priosnann, who wt 6 working at the asylum, but was removed on account of nla aomborshlo to the party, and fr.m the nursin, eersonnel.“ In other words, Leusser does not spook fr.m his own knowledge but Is s peakln- on the basis of knowledge he received from third aartles. These thlr- parties are, however, make entirely different statements. One of tho nurc s, as well as «ea:. onu ichuch, places the time of tho transfers up to the beginning of 1942. That Is not quite correct In view of the clear period of time when Euthasnoln etO; ad which can dearly be proved. It was nu^ust 1941. I roalnd you hare of tho testimony of tho witnesses Monnocko and Schmidt. Q. Hr. President, with respect to the witness Onnzor I may ref^r to Prosecution Document 3867-PS, Exhibit 359, English Dooument Book 1-:, p-.;o 256. Gorman Document 3ook 14, part 3, pa^e 176. A. The statement with which we are c ncorned can *oo f and m his last paragraph and I quote: "I ostlm: te that In -'ll five transports of this kind wore sent out from the Heil-uni Pflo 0 e ^nstnlt, Ansbftch, between the years 1940 and the beginning of * 1942.“ G£. Now, would you please speak about NO-246. «. During these transfers - I don't know tho wording of the decree of tho 1 September 193^ which was issued by hitler, which erron.-usly v-s -desisted as secret. 7505 Court 1 11 y 14—*—14— 2 -HD— Gross-Rammler. <• Mr. President, the decree which is Just mentioned 4 'ey the witness can be found in Document 630P3, Exhibit 330, -n llsh Document 3ock Volume 14, po^e 3, and German Document Bo3k Volume 14, parti., page 1. «. It says in my affidavit this decree entrusted 3cuhlor and Brandt with the responsibility of killing poo lo who were not capable of life. This does not correspond with the f^ct but it snye in the decree Dr. Brandt and nolchalelter Bjuhler are ch r e., with the res 'or.slbillty of enlar^ln^ the authority of oertr ln Physicians to be desl 0 nated by name in such a manner that .orson who, according to human Jud sent, arc lncurnblo con, u ion must careful diagnosis of their condition of sickness, bo accorded ^ mercy death." 4. Kow in your affidavit Para c raph 12 you also dealt with the urpoeo of too so-called Euthanasia Pro¬ gram and here some of y^ur statements need also be olucldatod. In that connection I can only say that this entire or -raoh, the same as p^ru^ra-ah 15 of my affidavit, does not originate from me but was draftod by the Interrogating officer. «t first I objected to that pare ,rnph because I never really learned the true reasons of Hiltcr. I also stated that when Euthanasia was ordered and executed I did n.t represent tho opinion that is c ntaln d lr. that p-r* raah. However, in view of everything I h«ve realized since I actually hold the lnt of view rt the time of my lnterro c atl-n that these could have been the true motives which moved Hitler. Thr.t is why I coul_ bo persuaded to si^ my none to that para raah the contents ^f which don’t originate from me. Th t refers to oara^ra fa 12 of my affidavit. . • IbUo Court 1 May 1 3-KJ- iroes-Raunior. 3. Till6 is to ba f^und in Document Volume 14 and it Is -'•ra-rauh 12 of 3nck‘6 offliavit. I quote: "litl^r's ultimate reason for tho establishment of the Euthanasia Program m Germany was to eliminate thoso c. lc c^nfino.’. to Insane asylums and similar Institutions wiv. could no longer be of any use to the Heich. They were considered useless enters and Hitler felt that by oxt_rmin tin_ th sc a -called useless -ater6. It would be possible to relieve z/.vc doctors, male an.’, female, nurses, and other pors.nncl, hospital beds and other facilities for uso of the .-*rmod Forces." Th*»t Is the *-'arn raph? A. Yes that Is correct. Daring tho Interrogations I oir.- hnslzod that ,r. our or.rt nny oosltl.n, any attitude as It Is stated here roGordln t useless oatera was actually nevor taken. If, n the other hand, any such reasons of expediency wore Introduced Into the debate by third parties they were almost rigidly rejected. I have already pointed out that I really need not n-vo to resort to draw any such conclusions. I Just recognized then. N w, witness, we need not revert to what tho wltnu6G Lancers has 6ald hor^ because this really would bo an r^unont wr.lch c»ul.. only be included In tho final loa. 3ut Is It not true that If Hitler had had tho Intention to designate these insane oc le as useless cr.torc he w. Id have used this expression In some manner tuwrr s Lryaners, too? «. I assume with c.rtainty that s m ouch uxorccsion w aid h-ve been used durin ne._-Otlr.ti ns with Lamnor3 If cny such intor.tl ns hr existed at th: t time. I would like to point oat, however, that It w uld hav- been utterly senseless t merxorm Euthanasia for reasons of expediency 72*7 Court 1 May 1<4—A-14—r—H*W5ro 88—Racaler • at a tine when there was a sufficient stock of nourishr.ent and then to stoj Euthanasia nt time when the events of tr.e war required stricter measures and when lack of nour¬ ishment come nb.ut - an-* it Is exactly In that year when Euthanasia was stopped. In that c .nnectlon A submit Breok Exhibit 3-1 into evidence which will be Document Ho. 30 which is to be f and In ay Document Book Ho. 2 on 9. This 16 the affidavit of Dr. .niter acnultze who w'8 born 1 January 1894 in Horebraci, former .Ministerial Director In the Bavarian Ministry of the Interior. This Is an affidavit made on 11 April 19.7. THE PAE3ID2KT: '*111 ou once a-re qIvo ne the exhibit number that you assigned to that document? DE. FROESCKMaHK: I offer that document, Mr. President as Exhibit No. 34. This .ocumcnt bears the date of 11 April lSi? and was signed by Dr. ochultzc. It W's certified by me In the proper manner. I shall only road the following e. rt sentences from the - cuocnt. The witness says I quote: "«t the end of 1939 or early In 1940 the former Bavarian Minister of the Interior an'. Gr.uloiter «dolf J a ner received nr. official visit by the rloichelelter 3\iuhlor. "as the Chief i._ icai Of flc.r uf Bavaria I was asked 1 1 attend this discusser.. On thl6 occasion 3ouhler officially Informed {tuner of n secret or .lnance of the F.fehrer. Bouhlor showed Vainer the orl Inal document which nad in t top left corner the swastika and the name «5olf Hltl-~ Ir. old print 0 . I o on reailn fr □ par- raph 3: "3. I recall tee f llowln ; - details of tills discussion: ■«) 'S also discussed the s.tivce f r these measures 72.8 Court 1 May l4-A-l4-5-HD-Jroe8-nnscler. and felt certain that this Fuehrer ordinance would be -..-elo.'oed -s a measure dictated by purely ethical reasons as ex? ain d by 3o:hler. The ^ve mentioned procedure ensured tfl* t any misuse and human error vs eliminated. On the strer. th of this discussion I was o nvinccd :'n~ hal this conviction c nflraud oy Va..ner after B.uhlcrs '.oparturo, that the intentions were entirely clean and hi hly ethical." ■5) The expression “useless eaters" I never heard oonti nod ’ey either Bouhler or Br-ck, nor h-'vo 1 heard it elsewhere. “oraok once naked -ie how it ml. ht be possible to rc-eayloy the n-nies which would bo saved as u result of the a; llooti;n of euthanasia for the benefit of curable caaos of oontal deficiency. I was very pleased at this question as it ,'rovod to me thrt it was intended to utilize such a.noy for the bonoflt of tho sufferln.. oom.aur.lt/ and not for other ?ur:cses In tho National buV.ot. However, I pointed out to 3raok at the tlco that It was more import' nt In r.y ooinlon t • -rovlde more ’'odo for To victims as T3 was rapidly Increasing to epidemic roportl ns and r.e there were oxcepti mally few T3 cinat »rla lr. CX,rmany. n n 7) Hod I possibly had any doubts In this matter, Bouhler6 ers nallty w.uld hove reassured me that this s-ur.d and Serious matter hn bc^n laced in >od and j;orper h-nds, . ;r I nad known d uhler f.r u,my years as ah exce..tl nrlly fine, hi hly Intellectual almost holy person." - shall ask the Tribunal to tnhe notice of the rest of the document. Aitne63, w^uld you -lease continue with the discussion of ur affidavit NO- 26 as far c9 you think that you can raise any more objections that r-fer to 11 ; ?Ssy L7-.>*ATD—15-1-Cvorrcw (Int. Rarrlcr) Court So. 1 A I would only shortly like to point tc the question of the Reich ^ O'! lit to . ?rcn the vary ba.innin I pointed out that this .nttor was ’ .alt with in tho Raich Ministry of the Interior '07 Dr. Linden ami that I coul only ivo V017 inexact information about that attor. 'hot I can say today is essentially the result of conferences bottroon defense counsel an! persons Tho had knowledge about these natters, as -.'ell as r^* own study of tho files in this trial. According to this result, tho Roich Co.r.itto.. for tt Collection of fooj&e Sufferln. fron Hereditary Diseases was not ore of tho tasks of the euthanasia pro ran. 1 ltn.'cs, this brJ.n.s yen to tho conclusion of your attitude ro; nrrttnr th deviatin ' points in ycur affidavit. *!r. Prcsifont, I think that it is expedient u '.vlsablo that, at this nononfc, I sutrait to tho Fi ji Tribunal tho chart which, had boon ■rown by th. defendant Crack an' it refers to the organisation of uthanasin. It feris c part of tho affidavit which Brack had rad 0 in tho course of the ovi donee on tho art of the 'ofendarit Karl Brandt, whon this otaturunt of Brack was undo on the 27th of January 191? and I incorpcr'tod it i: orient book ft as D.ho naked that a n-arcy death should bo ranted to th:ir deforced children through nodical intsrferonco? Is that rir/ht? A Yos, that is ccrroct, Q Furthermore, is it correct that Hitler found out about that through his Adjutant's offico? A Yos, T Sow, what do you knn/ about t!» further devclopjont of things to tho oxtont as it ms not alron^* dr.rlfiod by Ffannruollrr or Ho derich? I enphasizo new that we aro, at first, concerned »dth tho roi.'5SG^&N?‘* I an not conscious of bavin put a leadin', question* 7551 Hi *Siy ii7-..-.;TT>-l5-3-iv5rrcTr (Int. Basalor) Cc-art So. 1 TJ'S PR2SI0RWT* Counsel my proceed. The witness my explain. TT DR. PHOESCS'JUfiij A Mr. 3ouhlcr stated clearly that Conti had received the ordor to soarch a basical solution to that problem. Those cases want to various agencies and Hitler only, by accident, loomed about one or anothjr case whenever the Adjutant's office got to know about it. Conti, hovrovor, inforrod Me th?.t such applications arrivod at various offices and, os a result, Conti received the order to search for sono oppor- tunity to register all thoso cases in order to enable a nodical opinion to bo nado. Q Witrass, tho witnoss Pfcmrucllor and th. uitrass Hod-rich have ropoatodly nontien. : th. na::a of Linden in that connection. This Dr. Linden, as far as I can overlook tho natter, seons to havo played a conaidorablo juirt altldn tho frarawork of euthanasia. It would bo expedient for you to s-oak sououhat about Dr. Lindon and. his official position because to appears in tho chart in the oryanization of outhanasta as tho .. ich i'lonipotonMarj- for rental Institutions, ’ley I point tho Tribunal's attention to tto bex which oan bo found on tho loft hand sido of tho chart. a This Dr. Linden m3 a : umber of the Health Depart ion t of tho Roich "inistry of tho Interior which was headed by Conti. I only Ircw hin in this plan, mntionirv hio striotly official capacity - namely the Reich PIunipet jnti,ary for 1 Cental Institutions. In addition, Undon also headed the R^ich Ccr.nitta© for tho Ro.-istration of Pati.ar.t3 with Sovoro Diseases Caused by Horodltary or rro disposition. This, towovor, was no state position; his state position ms the position of Roich Pi. nipo- tontiary for fental Institutions an' as such ho was dram under ttto block of Conti. Ho m 3 a physician, .accordixv: to ny recollaction, ho ms oven a psychiatrist, hat his ;dical clitical ales wore, I cannot say. At ary ra to, ho ha d had a consi I.jrabl j expenier.ee in nodical r. ‘rlni- stratlor,. Before tovir.j cone to th-- ? inistry of Interior ho had already bo-sn active ir. -i.-lcal r “inistratior.. at first, \.as subor iirate to 7552 lii !fey Irt^^TtWS-k-Sarrow (Int. gamier) Court No, 1 Frick-and after 19la3 was subordinated to Hiraler. That his other fields of work within the 'Inistry of th: Interior, except the Saleh Plenipo¬ tentiary for llental Institutions, I don't know. In th: courso of tho development of tho porfortanoo of outhanasia, Linden took an incroasinrly stronger influence in that execution. I personally knew nothing about tho nodical problen. I ns only 3cuhlor's assistant. It was, however, roassurln;- for no to know that the Reich "inistry of tho Interior had collaborated in a task which conornod it to that extent. Of courso, I didn't knew a nuBber of natters 'diich I could only fin-’ out on the basis of tho documents which aro available to no. If Linden was only partici¬ pating in tho expert quostions and if ho wusonly participatin' in tho orranrcwvinta of th: transfers, n connection botwoon his office and tho office of Tior; irtoastrasso U has rosulto!. This was posaiblo bocauao Bouhlor was in no way opposoi to his aspirations for indopondonco and tho two officials ^ohno an-’ Allors '.rare officials of tho Rolch "inistry of tho Interior, Thoco two officials have bo:n ontorod upon this chart and can bo found undor tho squaro “Organisation for tho dr-ocution of .,uthanaoli M — bor.jath that, 'Public Foundations for Institutional Caro - Bohno and Allaro." In via* of tho arrant coo nts regardin'.; tho allocations of bods considerin' the air situation. Linden, on his own initiative, do to mine 1 thin or.: to whet institutions th:y wore to bo transferred. This is s-nothin that Bouhl_-r orf-jinally directed, but it was th n of the derlch, I already <.%mticr.ed th-1 t-cr-o, r.-=xly the decree of August 1939, ’is that the du'-rco you are speaking of? A. Y-;», th- is tfK decree according to which 11 r.ursos and institutions h-d ehe duty to report all th, births of deformed children to thin Reich C rittoe. DR. FRC'SJ! ;.rN: iir. President, uni irtun toly 1 an not in a positiar. t‘j subnit this decree to U» Tribunal, b-cause I have not-yot the suppl.sttr.tal volume. However, taaorrow roming I shall have th t doeun»nt voliuB, :»d a 11 t:.-n give this document -n exhibit number. Q. itnoto, did'y-,u at th-.t ti*. gain kr.rwledgc of t his decree? A. Yea, I fid. . Didn’t you have* sr» peculiar fueling -s a result of this deVito? A. No, 1 could only wolc^ae it. as a result of this deer there was a -ssi iility granted that 11 th-Se childr-n » had a- suffer inder oov-rc physical conditions aicr. to be registered r.d then U 2-y 47 —A-lf-2-pkp- lialoy (R al-r) Court .^c. 1 *-r>. to be helped out ns frr ns possible. Brandt hasolruady Ascribed 'r.e c8k n:£r.rding Leipzig, rvd I needn't raonfcion it ones norc, 2nd there ana e possibility to grant aurcy death to - sense in ecu or the other ease. Q. This duty of registration by the nurses end physicians was this to fore the basis for tlfo decision of each individual ccs-, spanking quite go no rally? « A. Jc3, this duty of registration was to give us the opportunity to present these eases to the Fuehrer for ,-is decision. Of course, th. Minister of tho Interior would have preferred to keep tho decision with its own limits, but it was dot-rained differently. DR. FORJSCIv&fXs Ho* wu conclude :ur discussion "bout the Reich Conraitteo and wo shall new go over to th- r-rl r-cults of the elocution of euthanasia, in which Brack participated, nd which has now become the subject of tho indictment. C. Witness, un to the year 1939 did you deal with tho oroblon of euthanasia? A. Ho, up to the year 1939 I did not doal with the problcn of euthanasia rd ,:y sphoro of work within tho Chancellory of th- Fuehrer did not at nil bring .x> in contact with rny such orobica. That, •'part fr:*a individu-'l nrsos which 1 havo jurt untloned, when parents asked for tho a rcy death to b- granted to their d-forauC children, both of tfiotti applications were *,nt over to the Reich Ministry of th Health. Q. a did you hear about ird-r by Hitler that irrurabl rur.tal p-atic.ts :o *ld bo granted th- acrey Coath under certain conditions? *• I i»arre. that -.nd that was -.aal^o surprise tone, -t the -nd f July jt beginning cf August. This was r.ot in connection .:ith noR-ti' tior.s : >ut the R-ich Camadtt-c, but I ncard it quite sponJar/- ously lr-x: ay superior ReicheL-iWr Bqphlor, who told xe oiu last ?r.y that Hitl.r had discuss-d that question with closed circle r /1 bad suid that he nc.3 considering t hu nref death to insane people, j/ that Eouhlcr was to consider that possibility Iso. At that tLo. 3ouhl-r already said that i. was Hitlor's opinio, that. ... r- ; Mt-n •'.!» n«. 7S55 U Lay 47 -A-i:-3-?kp- ifaloy (RaaUr) Court fo. 1 with persons -who wur- unable to live, were r.ot happy and whoso existence ir. this arid meant a moral burden to themselves, hhd to the members of their families. Bouhler, I think told oj on the. no: t day th'-t ho hed considered that matter, nd th~t ho had accepted the order of the Fuehrer, ifc- -shod to toll him whether I knew anything • bout t h. probL.,3, what my ttitudo was end what I thought of it. Q. ‘.hat did /;u toll 3ouhlor? A. I -.t first told him r uite professionally that such assignment rr.d nothing to do with tho Chancellory of the Fuehrer. That it wr.3 a puroly medical ant tor, rrd it oould at the ixst bo called a matter of public hygior.o, nd r.t cny rate foil within the sphere of Conti. I pointed out that Conti w -uld be able to call a similar small coaoittoj who could discuss tho c.u-stion of deformed children and arrive t some • decision. c, of course, didr. 't r.*to any oxp,rta to do that, and wo had no executive functions which would permit us to perform -ny such work. As far 'a I remember 1 lre dy then pointed out th’t this would only bring about iv.« conflicts with Borsann, because Conti in -d<>ition to his position s undor-Secr.t-ry of itato and Minister of Interior, was • iso simultaneously a cumber of tho staff of Boraar.n. Bouhlor chon sold that he had repeated fch.t to the Fu.hrer and had poir.tou »ut ospeci- lly ra to the nroblea of Borraanr.. 'itlor, however, had .answered thr t he would bo ro.dy to sp-ak to 3orm nn person- lly. Bouhlor then tri-d to »>t Frick's support, because- Conti in his capacity ns under¬ secretary of State was subordinated to Frick. JUS fears regarding Bormann, nd also y fears, wore justifi.d bec_use Hermann stated to Bouhb'p himself few days Iter that the euthanasia was n matter for Conti, the Reich health Leader, nd he further said it would not be limit.d to incurable :.ental p-ti-r.ts. Thereupon Bcxihlor thougm that Kltlsr would take this .-sjign-.nt away from him arri give it to Conti, This, however, would >. ve meant th:t the entire euthanasia mat tor would h v-.- been transferred to Boraann's influence, which would h-vc --used extensiva. jds-uso. Therefore, I u r.t t~ Frick and discussed • r Prick, • a the advice f Frick h« i: 7556 14 Hay LI -A-l6-4-?kp- Maloy (Raaal-.r) Court No. 1 of the support of Gouring ard Hinder. Q. Hew, witness, we don't need to go into «U those details, because it would take us such too far away. New, let us cone to the period of tiac whon Bouhlcr finally received this order by Hitler? A. I can't five you the exact period of tia.. 1 ear. cr.ly say this happened in c p-riod of a few days, all th-oe negotiations between Bouhler, Conti, I rick and Goering. At any retc Bouhlcr wont to t h* Fuehrer nd told specific*lly h. would accept this aosignewnt in spite of his questionable incaapo to r.cy. Hitler at that tine replied that he dusir.d a r.or.-bureaucr-.tic solution of this problem, because ^ didn't want an rg.ancy like the Reich Ministry of the Interior which had definite tracks after all to take over such a definito assignment. He said that th.- o’.yaicinna th-aselv-s could not do it because tliey had I no definite- or cniartier. v.il-ble. Hitler said Unt Bouhlor himself was to create the necessary organization for that purpose. As far as it was necessary the Reich Ministry of th- Interior should take over these things which already fall wit! • ts sphere of jurisdiction. 1J * is in cases -.here tho executive powers or th- Reich :anict-ry of the Interior could alleviate the task of the outhanasia. Q. ‘»it:v sa, die d.unl.r Ull you ryt. ing ’-t that tine concerning thu socr-icy concerning thesu oat tors? A. I cannot roojaber th’t. However, I b-lieVe that ho said frvr. tho very - riming that this.- entire -anttors had to be ‘rented ith tho a'llr'ir.t \rfi -:- 1 * . Hi Hny-A-3-17-l-feeh3n (Ints: JLasicr 6 V-n Schon) Court Nc. I. 3 How, witness, after Boohler had told you about these de¬ tailed suggestions by the Fuehrer; what did you do, what was your im¬ pression? A At first I had no idea about the extont of this assignment, no doubt I did not conceive of this entire thought to its great ex¬ tent, however, after I heard the description by Bouhlor about the con¬ dition cf thsse persons, I deciced to cooperate in the collaboration cf that cssignrent. I took a number of the associates of Bouhler into confidence and asked then to ccoporato. Q witness, ycu apoko to your collaborators, you spoke to Bouhlor and vhat was the result c I all these negotiations; what problcn did you solve? A The pro hi era to which I was entirely alien was purely nod- ical. Ho as party officials could not solve it in any way, tre had to bo clear about tho follawinj quostiens "Haw can tb; oxport physicians be included in t!w solution cf that problon?" Brandt was net a psy¬ chiatrist, Bouhlor was not a physician. The ru-sen for entrusting 'thoso two porsons for tbo aeslynrer.t was only bocauso Hitler had epocinl con¬ fidence in thon f :r carrying tho Batter through correct ! proporly. Vto now had the pr-bloa cf patting oxForts, who w.ro in lino with tho idea cf Buthar.aeia end whe were ro-dy to cooperate as oxierts. Only in thi3 uannofc could tho prrtlcn b. solved in a clean and correct run nor. Q Y'.tn whet physicians apeoared to ycu at that tine to be suitable psythi arista for that purp-so and whoa in effect did you chose? A It is correct fer you to say, vhre did you actually got to knew, because prior to that ;xjriod of tiix» I did not know anyone. Bouhler for instance had known Fr-fessrr Hjido through sonc feroor • asscciati ;n, however, neither 3ouiiler r. r 1 knew any other psychiatrists. Fer that reason Bouhlor asked no to try and find Professor Hcido's ad¬ dress. This is hsvr I contacted Eir. ler for tb- first tis:e ror rding Euthanasia. There was no oth-; way cf jotting to Koide, because va did • 7553 . Ui ltoy-A-^3—17-2-4feehcn (ints: Rx:ler i von Schcn) Court Mo. I. not know his adcress only the fact that ho was a nonber of the 3S. On this occasion, Eouhlor repeated his promise of support, which 1 have alre dy mentioned. Tfhetter Growltz had nominated scno noro oxpcrts, I do not knew. I do kn.-w, however, that Dr. Linden had givon a number of nanes of physicians to Scuhlor. According to ny rocoliocticn, six or more University professors were among tho experts which Bouhlor usod. Q ]*r. FVesidcnt, at this tine I 3hall subnit ny Docurxir.t Ho. 38 free !>ocuaent Book 2, page 57, that is an affidavit of Dr. Yfornor Kirch.'rt, da tod 2? January 19e7, *hich tl» counsel for tte defendant Karl Brandt has already sutcittod ns Karl 3ra:x! Exhibit No. 15. 1 need not road it. It doals with tho events which the vltnoss has just des¬ cribed. Ploasa continue, witnoas. A In any caso free those first dlscuasicns, I rorv.mbcr de¬ finitely tho nano cf Prfcsscr Nicttscho, Professor Dikrinic, who was tho hoad cf tho Ordin.riat at orlin, Pr-fuosar Xiohn fren Join, Dr. Schneider fren Heidelberg, Dr. Fnlkc-nlnousor -f Kaufbourcn. Thnoo aro probably the onos who participated in the first discussions and thon core oxperts wore sworn to secrecy. Tho witness Jfanmuollcr already tustifiod about this. They noro net cnployori, but tkto cn an honorary basis. Fran tho number cf those gontlonon, when wo were gradually gotting to know, during tho riddle or beginning of August, Bouhlor callod a tieotin,- in his «n ffice, in tdiich I and sene of ny asseciatoo participat.d, THE jUDSIDENT: Counsel, I did net understand that you assigned a number to Document No. 33; is that Exhibit lio. 35? DR. FRCESCHIIANN: kr. President, I did net give it any Exhibit number, because it was ny impression that since this Document has al¬ ready been submitted, by ny colleague. Dr. Sarvatius, for Karl Rrandt, with tho Exhibit No. 15, this Dccicent is already in evidence, 'hrzly so that tho report will be able to f 11 * w ny are sentati .r. if evidence better, I have copies it again in ny D cunent book. If ti>. court siir.ll Uj /-A-13—; 7-3—c chon (Ints: Ranlor Yen Sch.n) Court H-, I. consider it necessary for no to give this Dccuronfc an Exhibit me&ar, I shell cf course be glad to dc so. TIE PRESIDENT: It is not necessary, counsel, but it should be identified for tho record. Do I understand this is Karl Brand Exhibit Ho. 15? DR. FRCSSCHUAHKs This is Exhibit Karl 3randt Hr. 15. I may reaark regarding tha other Kirchert affidavit in qy Document Book Ho. 1 with tho Ho. 33, dated 7 Fobruary 19k?, that I shall not subnit this affidavit and it can bo struck out. THE {RESIDENT: That is satisfactory, counsel. BY DR. FROESCKAHH: Q How, witness, you know five t!io testimony of tho witnoss Pfo.nnr.ualier that this witness in particular, in answer to quostions of tJxi Prosecution, ropoatodly spoke of tho two noutings in which ho participated; ono osoting at which, in his cpini' n, thoro was inoroly an intended division cf tho ront -1 institutions into two groups, while -t th thor meeting tho group of exports are supposed to lwvu not. In your foil,-.ring tostirv ny, I ask you to consider Pfannnuollor«a testi¬ mony .and to mko it cloar to tho court vhothor there noro only those tno aoetingo dealing with tho ontiro prcblui of Euthanasia, or whothor in addition to thoso two noetin^s thoro wore thor mootings. I also consider it Important that you toll tho court absolutely frankly at what mootings you participated .an-* what y u did in detail, so that tho iapressicn will not ou giver, that you arc trying t' koop anything secret7 A I can only say that of course there wore many r. re- than two such meetings and meetings f v?ri us different kinds, but it is^quito impossible for raj to give any figure. 1 don*t kn w whether there were ton, twenty, fifteen, or twenty fi to. There -^rj big ratings and snail meetings, there wore seating which Roichslcitor Bcuhler called ciroc :ly, especially in the ber inn ia;. Thjro .Tore noetin ;s laarely f t!x experts, which Fr'fossor H-idc, Pnfossor Nietasch- cr Irofbsr r 7360 lii : ay-A-'B—17-4.—’feahan (Ints: Ramler x Von Schon) Court Ho. I. Lindon cailod. There wore all kinds of costings at various tines and various places and with various grouse of people. Q I should like to interpolate a question hero, because I havo been asked by one of ny colleagues to shorten the ease of the defense oounsol saaewbatj I ask you: was the defendant Dr. Blotae involved in any way? A From ay c*m knowledge, I can confirm that Blcco never at¬ tended any of tho nestings rtaich I attended and I did attend very many meetings. In any case, I know that ho was never at Bouhlor 1 a office, as I voulc! certainly have learned of that and I never hoard anyono montion Blooo in connection with Eut!.anc.3in. I have already said that I personally had nothing to do r.ith him in connection with the Euthan¬ asia pro err an* l-Zj li-..-3X-18-i-Ccok (Inc* Von Schocn) Court; No. 1 i .*itnoas, at tho request of cy colleague Sautor for do fond ant Bloce, I should liko to clarify s >cethin;; hero. On oho chert which was drawn up during tho interrogation froa tho inforantion ;ivon by you, that is, No. 2C3, it is No. 253, it says at tho to; to tho loft tho nano ‘'Blone", a., erontly in connection with Dr. Conti, and indirectly in connection with tho defendant Brandt, ./ill you briefly toll us whothor that square Bloao hero was justified at all? .* In view of tho hondinj, "-uthoncsir. Projron" , the addition of tho coco alone is oortainly not justified. I jointed this out at tho interrogation and when I si. •nod thi3 chart that this was not justified but 1 was parsued- od that Blono, ns Do. uty of tho heioh Health Loader logically hud to ap.ocr, but whon I said that 3ior.o had nothing; to do with euthanasia, the second lino was not .at around tho square in which Bioao's nnuo appoars, and that is a . lain square in contrast to the squaro of Conti and Lindon. I boliovo that was how it happonod. It is difficult for no to reocab^r all of those things La dotr.il, but that is how it hr. ..onod I boliovo. It was baenuso Bloao had nothin * to do with euthanasia. . Now, witness, plonso oci;hasizo in your descri.tion those ncetin"3 which woro in.ortont for tho development of tho euthanasia .ro.ran, first of all, tho first moot¬ ing which Bouhler called in order to discuss tho problem itsolf and ir. order to find cut the attitudo of tho doctors? Those wore snail ncotinas md .rinarily the .eoplo • whoa I h-:vu already aontionod pertici. atod. % Just a noaont, witness. I should lik-j to hoar froa you froa the very boginnin^ whon you speak of your associates, which associates you noon. One con os sane liny 1-i -/v -BK -18 - 2 -C ook (Jet. Von Schoon) Court No. 1 with c decree of certainty that the Prosecution and cross oxacination will ask thoso nanus, and oven if it is not pleasant zo you to ccation theso nones, I as your defense oounsol consider it r.y duty to ask you to state which of your associ.-tos, no natter in what respoot, had s quo thine to do with the euthanasia ;roprcn. .«ho woro tho90 assooic- tos? -- — Thoro woro only four of cy associates who had anythinc to do with euthanasia in any decree. That was ny roprosent- ativo and later ::y succ-sscr, Blcnkonbur.;, then HoConor, end thon Hovolnnnn and 'forbore. Thoso aro the four whoa I havo put in tho corrcctod . Ian. -.11 of the other associates in tho Chanceliery of the Fuohror had nothing to do with euthanasia, and to a l'.rco oxtont woro not infomod -bout it. . I should like to heu that last thin.; a;ain. Within tho Chancellory of the Fuehrer there was tho soorooy which wo shall spook about later end it was ko ; ,t? .. Yes, of course, that was an order, even within ny own offico. t Then this ox. lains tho fact that the witness tfodorioh froa 1939 to 1910, as he 3oiu, actually know nothin.; about outhnnasia beinj dealt with in your offico? .. I considor tho stntoaont absolutely true. I con only on. hasizo it. t ~nd you, Mr. 3rack, you worked with thoso nootin:;s? Yc3. Did you not ir. private conversations with third arsons soy soaothln* about your activities cr any hints? .» I nust honestly say later I did so with a very definite intention, and later I had to dual with tho filr: I accuse." Of course, I told a few ;eo; lc who were • connected with it wh t it was ill aoout, but in "oncrnl 7563 I!ay 1--..-3K-1G-3-Cook (I;.-. Von Scho-n) Court No. 1 I hold to.the socrocy very strictly. I ‘itnoss, in answer to ay express question you javo the ri'-.o of four of your associates, I want to know very briefly, ’id Dr. Xiovelnann, whet was his attitude toward tho .roblcra, was ho in favor of it, was he infornod about it? .. Yes. i ./as ho verj* cuch in favor of euthanasia? - Yos, for a ;urely . orsoncl roason. In hiw own fanily he had heel r. horrible nisfortuno. Ho had a nothor who for yonrs, I don't know how cany years, was suffer ins fr or» c.-ncor and couldn't die, although 3ho vr.ntod to dio, and ho was in favor of euthanasia because of this experience of his own. 1 —nd wh-t about Vorbors? .. Vorber/j was not so favorably inclined toward euthana¬ sia, but ho did fellow the order, and since ho fro:i a business aoint of view hd 8 onethine to do with tho organization of this transport oa..-uny, oven if it was against his will, ho did folic*.# tho order. i '••ell, how about Hejonor? 4 . Ho;;cnur was very nuch .aore o>n nindod toward this ; rob Ion because he hic-solf was connected by tnrri ago with an L'vcrtant doctor who had acquainted hin with the problun and ho knew Dr. Un;or, as well ns Hovolnann, who wrote tho book, the raanuscri. t of which I later used in . re-arin.’ the file. i -*nd tho last one, Blarikcnburc? .. .»t first ho Smew even loss than I did about tho ;roblon but later ho warned u, to it, but I nust say it was less for etl ical reasons than for rational roasohs. -hr.t the r.suits were, tho froein ; of bods, for oxnni'lo, he was ;.or interest. I than I. To no it node no difference whrt- 7 ^ over ::..y 11-*»-BK-18-4-C ook (I_.it. Von Sohooni Caurt No. 1 l Nov., let '3 o beck to the nesting -which Bouhlor oallcd at tho bc-inninj of ~u yust 1939. You hevo already told us that as far as you - reneober you ware at this acotiny, i3 chat riyht? .. It is very likely I was at the first do otins- 1 °hn not inline ay not bo in : thero. % wall, What do you rccoabor about this ocotinj 1 ? .. .*s I said Bouhlor wanted to find out tho attitudo of tho doctors toward the .robloa of tho ba3i3 justifica¬ tion for outhenasie, which was unaninously a. yrovod by every ono ; rosent. Of courso, all donnnrtod that safe¬ guards bo oror.tod. r. Hainr In Goordon shewed no a case, f-mcrly o highly trlor.tcd engineer wha had built s~mo bic bridROs abroad. This rr-n hvd porolvsis end the nr.lr.rio cure ms usod too Into. Ho had ty-rv t tho cl into tor lata. Ho wee quite slut id but n tho thar hand still s -.-rossivc. Ko had delusions if Rrandour. Ho osllod silly soribblin^s blue prints. It wo terrible to soo thoso peo¬ ple. In '.uertt-Rb r^/3*. '.on I had the 'npertOnity to visit rthor inetituti ns. I sow at lanet ton r twelve instituti no 'f vari-us kinds r.nd saw nil kinds f ersos but I oen't doscribo oil t thorn. That W'uld bo quit" inprssihl . Q, I think y u node . Mistake hef.ro when y u said y« saw r. povehlctrist in th» institution. Tf-.ni nosnt j paralytic. a. lea, Q, Bow, Hr. Brock, yvu have described y ur wn l-iprossl.'ns whon v u -isitod thTse instituti ns. Did y u ■'bsorro vori.ua wth:de of tr 'tin- tho insane? A*. Yos I saw th- curing Hold and th.' oaring Hold. 1 sow all tho r-. dr.rn -. .thods includin’ therapy, :lcot±lo sh ck, insulin, polorin ntid"to, otc. Than I saw the • ccvpnti ml therapy — n t mly in thr curin’ field hut Is- in the car in- Hold sc tht patients said bo kept quiot under tho necessity f r w rkino Q. t irrr csi r. did - u n t cf this -oth • .:f aocupntionnl therapy? ... I eon say n thin- oh ut it os a lnyaan but what was 1 n: with tV. incur bio oas.-s ms impressive. It w s dostr-yin,: tho di.-city f hurr-r. cr "tur- 3 , rrkir..- them r b:ts — it was r. t w rthy >f hurun h • ir.-s. 7567 i ; Vov-A-G3S-lS-2-Gr-ss (Vca Sch'< n) C ’irt ». 1« D3. KOCJTALD; If ycur Honors plcaso, I do think this line cf quest! nine is nievt*' exhausted. Tho witness has ,;iTun all his r«os r.a -Ay ho nitied thoso po«plo and so a. I *o n t think it is note rial. D*i. FZOZSCHiV.iTi Hr 7 President, I nn finished with this subjoot >ut T th urht it nooossary f-r tho witness t toll us whot ho thou C ht. 73*2 r"2SID2!Mi Prcaood t scon. . thor question of th? ease. Q. It. Brock, through person 1 abscnnti'n y'-u ocnvincod y ur- soIT *f tho Oi-nditi ns of thoso patients hut thoro woe still tho Me quosti n — con T ;ive tsy aid t a projoot which shortens tho life of those patientsT 'Shot did y *j do? ... I road tho literature in this field. First I road the standard w-rk :f Hindin.:-!! cho. I didn't like it von- .-mch. I rood Ifclsor. I also rood T^lthor. I ro“d Berth. I also rood litarnry w rks like 7h tri Morus and Vn&r, oto. All thoso things — tho total effoot f nil the literature is woll os the pars nol impress! ns which I hod in tho rental inr-tituti ns — os woll as what I luornod in talks with 1! psyohintrists hr urht ao t > th: idoo thr-t it wis not anythin,- Md hut that it W.-S :• d to help in this toko if thoro wus cn rdor. Q. Did ” u discuss tlweo ouosti ns with y ur ossreie-tos Hovcl- mnn arv' Dlonkuntar,:, otc? ... i.-s, cf c ursu. Vo discussed th. pr-blon and dot-ails .f the problon rt front length. Q. Vr. Prosidrr*, in thic ccnr.oeti.r. I sh ul<' lik-. t» rofor to by Brack Exhibit 27. That ia D curvr.t 7 in D curvnt 3c Ic 1, pa *o 16, tho affidavit f Imgnrd Crubo, wh w-s f< r nany years secretary in tho Chancellery f thu Fbohror and in this e nnoeti n I sh uld like tc read fr v. 2 b), nly the first t» sentences, and than fr c 'f I sh uld like t r d a little .art. Ko. 2 b says, "Srack's rvst -bvi us characteristic was his unc nditi-nal readiness t help. Brack never refused t help ar.b wh asked f r his assistanco in nr. oror ;ancy. This r"-.diness t help >r.«w "t . f on absoluteIv decent ar.d hunano f' el inr. Braev tried t c rsproh-nd thcr pc pli's feelings end t utf’or- 7568 l-‘ ’•o"-„-Grs-19-3-'3r -s8 (7en Schr.en) C crt v «. 1. stand the irvi then I ah- uld like t h vc y-y c nsIdo* fipuro d in +his e mooti r. whoro the witness *--rnti ns everything th-.t tho da Tonicnt hns just described in detail. She says that sh rtly before tho -utbroak -f the Thp the d>*eroc was issuod by Hit lor. That this rdor w «b tho aukj-et r* may discussi ns in office II md she •ays* "1 *r.s pros.-nt s ratines iurin; tv oh ‘i scut si ns between Brack, Hofelmnn, Blonkon- hur.- and Ho jonor t<- take d am shorthand n.-tos. I c ncludod fr n thnso discussi ns end oxjlwaxt! ns f th-'sc sen that tha ’iscussl ns -n this subject vr rn tokor. von' t ri-uslv by oil c scorned, they continued untJl late at ni-ht. ..11 tho . fronontl-nod were c nvincod that this w.is o probloo f th* hi-host othioal in-ertaneo. Itoas ns • f expediency -vere entiroly rulod ut. 1 r.< v r htord Braofc use tho w rds "usolres oatora", I can r ally n t i-n.nb r ovor t' h to hoard this w-rd. Arpucants and ocuntcr :>r-ur.jnts ware '.iscusscd in dotail. Tho docisivo footer was alwnya 3raok’a froquontly ox-r-asod views that th s ;.c pie wore noroly vc -otatin - end thoir oxistor.co was 'T no vnluo. Fn.fossar Niotrsoho r'ssisaod an ext nsiv librr.ry, which wos e> noornod with the pr bl .m S outhar.asin. 3r'c!e ‘iscuasod in detail n nunbor f those b Jes with '•i tsech-.- : tv! studied o bo f th n. Th> quostl n was re isod whether puhlicati r.s had boon nado c ncornin- tho -.regress f outhonnain in Torsi,*n o untrios." I ask th c urt t toko u.tico of th.- rost f this nunbar -1. j: -r, -fitness wo hr. olr v dy hoard fr n th -.ritnoss Hodorich ond y u h-.vo c nTirmad it that th- issuaneo f the outhomsia nssi.-nnont t 3 uhlor had n thin- t d« with tho Ch.ncollory f the Fu-'hror. 'hit w ro thj e nclusi ns f r Bcuhlnr there and y u? ... Sc machine h-<* t So cr>v:tcd t carry ut outhennsin. <»ll lnstituti ns h*d t bo roj-istorod. Tho pntionta had t. b« r ■ istorod s that an -pini- n oould be Trrvd rn there. Individual institutions had to h found wh->ro ■uihannsin c-njld bo e--rri'-d out in jr'ctico, etc. In vi w -r tho great rombor fT ir.curaSlo cos s • f insanity a -rent burden n the perscnnol h -1 t ba ex-octcd in tho boginnin-. That could 7569 11 ;:ny-..-GZS-19-4-Crdss (VonSchoer.) C urt y . 1. n ,.vcr bo hoar*led by the few po^plo I hadw-rieinf -t tho Chancellery >'f t'r.o Ftohrer. P.rscnncl had t ho f-und f-r tills purpose and an effioo h i t- b< f uni. Bouhlor did this. So rot rooms in tho Colur.bus . H'uso r. Prtsd:irwr Piets -.nd l~tor in Tior rartonstr.issc. He rontod tho ro.'rs. This offico was called T-l fr ra tho nn-b-r Tior'-artrnstrasse -1. “hat Is Tdv.ro this expression c.noi fr-n. This rns oqu’-l in ran): tc m? und'r 3 uhlor. In ~.y ir.pr-vod chart ! hr-c whnt I for.-c-t in tho first chart. — This Forty C *ntr '1 C rr.issi.-n. Tho thrro ffiooc undor 3 uhlor arc equal in r >nk. .’ith th- exception >f xyeelf end tho onsreintes when I fc ve nlr. =dy rjonti'nod oil the poramnol at this Tior ^irt^nstr'isso 1 wero wrrkin v« luntorily und n thoir mm dooisicn. Only w-. f ur were w rkir.. n orders. ..11 others were w rkin-; v-lun- tarlly n thoir wn deciei r.. Only wo f ur wor’ wrrkin- n orders. All cth irs vr-ro w-rkin* n thoir cwn docisln. C. ?'r. Pr sidont, in this c-Twccti n I sh.-uld like to rofor to NO- 170, Exhibit 332, Sn.-Ush D cunmt Bok lv, pn-o 17, G>m.n Document 3 k Id - l.pa *o 15. This is tho affidavit -f Kr.cisslor which tho Pr.socuti n has subnitted and I shall ro-d noroly no sontcnco. Undor M-. 3 "In 1939 I wr.e sunv nad by tho Chief f Polloo t ropert ;.n i Jane r*' 19C0 t- th.. * inlstr- f th.- Interior, situotod in tho Rrlunhis buildin.-; there n an crllod Blankonbur.; tallrod f >ur cr«up which c nsistod ^f 22 r 23 pors r.s." !' w thj witness c r.tinuosi "It w.s eutplotcly vrluntory for th so pors ns it the rviotin.- t-- assure thoir e-.epuroti n." Court So. 1 1 -. nay 47-A-20-l-iE:i-fcerrow (Yon Schoon) A. She personnel were paid according to tho regular rates. The funds vero advanced by the SSDA? Treasurer for the Kinirtry of the Intorior. The administration of this office vbs first out under Bohno and, efter hv left, JLllefr. She ce-dical direction vas first under rrofossor Euide, later Professor Hlettsche. Q, One question in this connection. Bid the defendant Karl Brandt have anything to do with T-4? A. I believe that during ny first interrogation I eroressed myself wrongly and vhnt =y affidavit says is misleading. Karl Brandt was con¬ nected with euthanasia - ho v«b Hitler's deputy - but he had nothing to do with T-4. Ho did not have any office at T-4, as I said during tho interrogations, and, as far ns I know, he ves never at T-4. I do not bolievo that Brandt would havo cone to T-4 without first saying to no or ono of ny assistants, "Please go with ae. I should like to look at it." Q, Sow, witness, in tho meantime the coaaittoo of cxnorts which Dr. PftLnnaueller mentioned - did it doal with tho nodical ouootlono which coso up? A. I don't know whethor Dr. Pfannauoller's words are milto clear horo. I spoko at ono meeting with Bcohlcr but there vero eovoral at which tho first problems were solved and when Bouhlcr gave the declolone. At theso eoscions Brondt was perhaps a tine or two. I don't think he v«s prosont at aort than ono or two act tings. But thorc were certainly four or five such neetings with Bouhlcr where Dr. Linden woe called upon at the end esch tiao by Bouhler because he was a aedico-oolitlcal ojraert - because he could give very good advice, and only then, nftor Bouhler had fiotorained a certain group, including Kcldc, Soitsscho, and Slkrinie, vtre the split up groups of experts forned, and Pfenn- auollcr doubtless oorticipatcd in one of these conferences of exoorts because he vas one such exoert and ho aentioned this mooting. At these expert neotings the directives vere discussed and set down, first in general end later corrected. The directives for forming tho judgaent 7571 Ccurt So. 1 1 -. May i7-A-20-2-i3(-2arrov (Von Schcen) on the cases. I personally often attended these meetings of the experts. Gf co»jae, I could sty nothing to the point but I was there and I heard wfaat the export* were talking about. Q, Sow, at these 'nestings did tho idea cone up of send'.ng the Questionnaires to the aontal institutions? A. As far as I reaerber, that -'as settled earlier in the dlscue- 8 lor.8 Kith Souhler and then I believe Linden and Feido appointed a cos- alttee to drew up this Questionnaire and they drafted the Questionnaire. Q. Do you rerunbor how tho decision about the Questionnaires, when they had boon filled out, was to bo reached? A. Yes, that agrees with vhr.t I said in ay affidavit. The ouca- tionnolro had to be Judged by threw oxperts. I said four before hut thcro were really only three, and Dr. Pfannnuollcr was ono of the ex¬ perts. If throo oxperts independently erso to tho saao rosult - that is, that in this case asrey doath could bo accorded - then everything was transferred to a fourth photootot and cane to tho chief oxport who received only such photostats to decide on. If his opinion agreed with tho opinions of tho other throe, then tho patlonte wore transferred upon orders froa tho Ministry of the Interior. q. And whore wore they transferred? *horc wore the patients transferred to? A. Patients wore subsceuently transferred to an observation insti¬ tution. Tho croatior. of these observation institutions, however - by wpy of correction of ny previous testiaony - woe not in 1939 but the beginning of 1940. Theso institutions were arranged at the suggestion of Professor •‘oide. In these observation institutions the patients wore kept under observation for a period which depended on the*nrture of the case. If the rosult of tht observation agreed with the Judgment formed on the basis of the Questionnaires, then they were sent to an euthanasia institution end the doctor in the euthanasia institution ande the final decision whether he vedted tc subait the patient to euthanasia or rot. In any case, he had an absolutely unlimited veto right in every case, 7572 Court Sc. 1 14 rfey 47-1-20-3-1::.-iprrev (Ton Schoen) just like every expert end chief expert in each case could put hi6 plus, tinus, or cuestion nark on the fern. Q, Witness, ve need not deal vith the nanes of the exoerts, chief exoort-j, cr thu nanes of the inati tut ions because I can assume thet the prosecution will coae back to this natter and ! shall not discuss who selected the doctors in the observation and euthanasia institutions, but I will go on to another Question. That is, whether you know that, in the execution of the assignment of hitler given to the dofondent 3randt and Bouhler, the euthanasia doctors vere given authorization to administer euthanasia after checking every thing that hod been done by the orporte and chief exports. A. Yos, that wo* done. The euthanasia doctors were givor., by Bouhlor ond Brandt, tho necessary authorization which hod beon roruired by tho Fuehrer. Q. Dc you know whother a list of these doctors vac kopt nt T-4? A. I have already been asked about that end I can only say I do not know, but X hardly assume so since tho group of authorized doctoro was so very snail. Thera voro only twelve to fifteon of them. I have been told that there must have boen over three hundred fifty. I could not know that, but I did not know noro than twelve or fifteon. Very well, witness. Then wo have discussed the general propara- tory aoasurcs for euthanasia. Briefly, at the end of this cession today I should like to go into the oucetion in regard to this whole natter - had secrecy been ordered end *hnt effects did that hrve? A. In regard to cuthanrsic ce a whole, strict secrecy had boon ordered. It hed to be dealt with ec top secret ond the regulations, which woro more stringent during the war, were that euthanasia has to * bo relegated to top socret. To my knowledge and ny consent, no death threats were expressed, but this formulation, of course, is contained in the r guletions that in case of violation of this duty of secrecy for things which are top secret the death penalty nay be pronounced, but those ere the general rules which were known to everyone anyhow. Besides, 7373 Court So. 1 14 jtay ■a0 ~ 4-«»*-garrov (Ton Schoen) Souhler forced =e to accept a pseudonym which was very embarrassing to zc pr-A seemed ridiculous. I only did so for a certain tine and without an*ing t big fuse about it I dropped it pgein ar.d two of qy assistants did thu io-c thing. Q, - v, this pscudonya was only in connection with signing documents in connection with T-4? A. Only in connection with T-4, y«s. q. Ar.d then, ny final cuestion on this subject. At this cane tine or later this secrecy lod to giving special names to certain organiza¬ tions, is that true? A. Yes, secrecy was tho reason why the vholo organization was divided into various sub-orgnnlze.tions. DR. TRCSSCm-S: lir. President, I have finished this subject of secrecy and now I coae to tho question of tho legal basis of outhanasla. That will take s^o« tl=o. Perhaps this would bo a good tirno to adjourn. THE PRESIDE!.": Tho Tribunal will now b. in rocosa until 9:20 o'clock tcaorrow r. orning. (A recess vos taken until 0930 hours, 15 Hay 194?.) 757 /.- • NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Roll 8 Target 3 Volume 21 May 15-21, 1947 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS i : * OFFICIAL RECORD UNITED STATES MILITARY TRIBUNALS NURNBERG CASE No. 1 TRIBUNAL I U.S. vs KARL BRANDT et al VOLUME 21 TRANSCRIPTS (English) 15-21 May 1947 pp. 7575-7954 Court Kc. 1 15 .-iay 47-fc-l-l-ZSi-Foeter ( 0 -r in public. % Ifcan, I have finished tr.e suojact of secrecy. Hr, President, I nov co-o to t::o cn-ttor of jrcp-»r..tory -ensures for outumiusin end I oh. .11 discuss the lo;...l b-sie of o-tcanasin, Kr. President, I have ticca tic liberty to sufcilt a n ex.-pic - oat not in order to xvad it into the record, acraly fo. t..c lo.-l inforc-.tioa of the f-riaunol - t..e opinion of a veil icnova yem-n university professor, ^rofonsor Dr. hnrl -ngisch ir. ioidulbcr,:, ,-.u Docu-oat no. 34 in ny Docu.io.it 3ooJc II. Cunt ua tho Prosecution did with ito v rlous opinions see hitler's h-ndvritin ffca jc-31 or av.-.r-t? 7579 15 ..c;.'-:.-a T -2-2rf-:-ro8S-(vofl5cho.i>- Court 1 « Yes, douhlcr showed ne Hitler's original Landwritin. ah'. I had a peotostatic copy of it in uy owe safe. i 'hwn W.* that * the cad of 1939 at tho arliost. possioly only Oarly in 15 0 -not the date of issue. ; la the cxtora -1 fore of the document 'ey hitler did you bco anything objectionable? A o. I Saw nothin,; objectionable. I was not able to Jud^e whe¬ ther .uiy pr scribed foiu ui;,ht have been viol_tcd hero. I tfoulu h. vo li :tyf to sue anyone object to - document ri.-.-nud by adolf ilitlor no aattor what tho external foru of it w a s. ", ’ itr.eoa, you h..ve stated th-t you coasidored the docrco completely Valid lc*; 1 statement of hitler with tho force of law? a Tos. ' ^ut in repeated discussions you have told a« that you Wore working on tho draft of law. how does this o:ruc with what you n..vo Just said? a Such an idea voul- a t h_vo occur ad to ue out the doctors and lav cro who were conc*rnod in the u-tter hold the tho point of t’lew that lav h_d to be patted. ' hov did those doctors and luVyors explain this opinion? a &oy s .id that Hitler's secrecy order io known to only a United ntob r of persons. *Xith_noBla, however is not u u..ttar vhich c a be loft to the individual or the t :ov«.r.uoat but effects everyone In the Ion. run it c-nnot b„ Kept oocrot free the puolic. Primarily people want to know •'hat conditions arc required for -uthaneMu and vh .t a. u-rds have been intrlducod e*t that there will b„ no # .iissuo of it. of course, if possiole only if a lew is proclaim.- With ofiuite orovisiens but that doeB not uoan that the dc-creo itself o~g not .vw-Oar perfectly Media.;. “ ..'id you u.;rcw with this opinion? * I was not ubl^ to Jud I carried out 3ouhl. r's aeni >-.nt 7560 $ 15 . *,-GJ-£-S«- J ros s-( vonSchon )- Court 1 _nd I worked on the dr-ftin*. of a law. Since I didn't understand those ..alters ayeelf I _skcd lawyers and octors to suggest various opinions of the law. t and, briefly what cid this law contain? A basically it contained all rpovisions which arc necessary for the execution of outhanasia and pr-ctic«., - very cuhoeroa«c procossof jud .in. tha patients, -11 kinds of ltgal prec-utions vhlch wculc prohi- oit .jjy i-isuso of euthan-sia fras a legal or acdical point of /low. I rauubor the title now-law for granting cedicul aid to the incurably sick persons. i t'a* this law to put an end to all the secrecy? A Yet, of course, l^at w u s soBcthlng th-t wo J1 jejected. In ny institution I h-vo -lrwudy said wr.at I personally ct the tino about the secrecy. Socle thing that I consider ri,£t I don't have to keep a oocrot. , » ow I should like to interpolate - .mention. »is draft took saw tU— to wrok out diin't it? A Yes. I Wat revised sovor-1 tites. 2no first draft w.i flnishod r_ti»>r quickly out it w a o i-»rovcd -gain —v* again. I -Syjuo there were ten if not acre revisions. hy w. l# this law not passed? a I don't know. I know th-t jouhl . arou,^ht it to Hitl-r'r .t- tx itiou repeatedly. nitl^r r^fused-he aoprov^i of thu contents, but nr.it. that h« di n't Want it a-do public before the «.nd of the wcr. " Did you learn Hitler's reason for this opinion? a Vo. >ld ncu-l-r -nd "r-nr t r-n«.-tcdly k aitler to h-v- this lav pafiflee? a Yes, i know of th-t the c-Sv of aoth of th.c». I know, I just n if, that Bouhlcr su'caitted this draft to Hitler personally n bey- onc that I learned fra; douhlcr, -s w.ll s a.randt, that they h -1 .pc-t- t ly *C') the Tuunrer to r.akc puolic thv. l : .v 'hich he air y 75*1 May l5-A- ; -BK-3-l-Karr cw (Int. Von Schoen) Court; No. 1 i I 3 a copy of this draft available? - I don't know, I'vo Sivori you all the addresses whore it oinht bo. It was sont to various state agencies and also to oth^r pcoplo; to ohurch authorities, for example, bocauso tho o. inion of the church was very important, but, unfortunr.toly, no co.y of this draft has boon found. I hove also tried to reconstruct it, but that would be too Ion ; to jive all thoso details here. ' Did you doubt the validity of the law oeoausc of tho oloaont of secrecy? .. No, I said before that, in ranny oases, tho Fuehrer issued secret decrees and this did not affect tho validity in any way. For oxcaplo, the creation of tho Ministerial Council for the Defonso of tho »or- visory relctionshi. to the exports or the other a£oncio3 of T—1 and there was no ri;:ht on our ; .art to ;ivo in¬ structions. The instructions cane from Bouhlor. Thon, in this . rosocution chert, the B and L institutions - tho ob3orvat -.on and euthanasia institutions were .rosuntpu a3 boin;; directly under tho euthanasia '.uthorities. That is not truo. They were still under the .»oich Ministry of Interior, as always. . -itness, from the chart of the .irosocution I soo 7533 May 13-M-BK-3-3-Korrow ;Xnt. Von 3choea) Court 56. 1 that tho observation end euthanasia institutions were not, as you say under tho organization in general, but woro directly under tho oxports and then indiroctly under T—l. -a I not ri ;ht? .. It is torribly complicated on a chart which is supposed to show organization, at the some tine, functions and that • is the case hero. I myself do not know wh :t’ these various linos arc to indicate, .jo they to show the course taken . by the patients, or r.ro they tc show organizational sub¬ ordination? ..a you ox.lain it, thoso linos ;oin^ up on tho ri ;ht, the observation and euthanasia institutions - if thoso do not represent tho courso of ti!u questionnaires and tho pationts, but sin. ly the authority, then thoso lino3 ere wron^ and your idea is corroct that thoso institutions aro sup. osod to bo under tho ex. orts. That was not tho ease. Thoso institutions oentinuod under tho authority of tho Ministry of tho Intoriof. 1 Woll, let U3 jo on to tho noxt point. How nbout tho questionnaire section? •• This does not thor-foro bo Ion;: to tho foundation j butt to tho iloieh .*orkin: Union for Mental Institutions. I rcalizo that clearly on tho basis of the prosecution documents when I saw that tho sondinj out of tho questionn¬ aires to tho ox.^rt, Pfannnuoller, wont through tho .toich ..’orkin : Union and that tho questionnaires woro sont back by him to the .tcich workinj Union, not to tho Foundation. This ocain, I havo considered when I corrootod tho chart. I have spoken about Bione yesterday. I need not suy anythin; about that today. In the corrected plan, I be¬ lieve that the confusion between orjanization and functions has been avoided. I have indicated, by arrows, and cx- . laincd tho organization and the execution of tho transfers. 7584 "ay 1L : —1I-3K-3—*-K rrov; (lift. Von Schoon) Court -»o • 1 -11 other lines r-f_r not to functions, but to subordination. But I should like to oa.hosize once norc that such a chart nuv-r existed beforo end I merely had to draw it u; accord- in; to the best of ay knowlcd ;e and after lofrcs.'.in;; ay r. oaory throu ;h tho documents. It novor existed earlier in this form or in nny 3inil,.r fora. i Now, . lea so ;.ut tho ohart aside. witness, soorccy led to unfortunate circuastincus in the oxocuticn of euthanasia and, in the Inst cnjdysis, to tho ocn. laints of which tho rosocution has 3ubnittod sever al ex ;;, los, but we shell cos back to this lator. Now, I should liko to ;o on to tho discussion of your s. ocific activity within outhr.ruisin so that tho Tribunal will knw wh;t your work was. -r.d ..l^aso answor this quost ion briofly. ihut was tho nature of your work in tho froaowork of euthanasia? *» It is not sim.lo to ox. 1 in thi3 work. At wns vory com. lio ted. I do not intend to deny that I h il spmothinj to do with it, but I 3hall attorn; t to explain how fur . ay notivity wont. Tho T-; was ;co;ra; hie ally, _nd from tho or :anizctiond .oint of view, so. irato fro- w own offico. Bouhlor hiasclf was not able to novo his office to T—i. Ho remained in his offico in ifosstrasso and .0 0 . lo work in ; at T-l enno to sco him to re. ort to him. If Bouhl.r wns not there, they enno to no or to one of ny associates. The . rosccution has usod the -words "liaison tann" for no. This is confu3in.*. ..s far as I can remember I did not raise any objection to that tor.': at tho tine, Porh.r s I s3 xisa-nce f th. incur lbly insane. Ethical rens' no, cbovu '.11 ccun-asien, demon-Icf th. r.l Se f th se individuals fra th ir suff rir. -. Thera war, n n.ntlcn 1 my kint! of p.lltioH t war •aspect for thu perfemmet f euthanasia. • lkud th-n ibout fuehrer decree t B- uhler an.' “r-n't n* ‘ .alt in full with th. !j*:ft cf a law, which h- been suboitteJ, r was to b. submitted tc Adolf Hitler. He mentioned the various provisions of this ‘raft. 1 was convinced fren Brack* 3 statements that this 'raft law provide - ev.ry r.uarante' for ’he protection oi tho incurably sick n- insane. «.s far an I can remember, certain eXeptioni w-re stipul-.v tar tr.v porfarmonce cf euthanasia, far instance persens nuff.rin fr:m injuries of the cr-i-a incurr-- airing th. first -1 ‘Or r. I think ! r.i r. rs V r. ils > pt . IS ."~ay---:-G J-5-2 --u.ohan-(vcnSchcn) - Court 1 •'Brick's statements r.assure =~, because acciriir.. tv. th-a, it res to b_ definitely assuned that a r-_ich Law .--ail' then b. enact-.; in the customary fen:, ic., by publication in the _eicr; Law uazette. I saw nc nasen why any difficulties should arise..' 1 HR. HrtTCY: ay it pl-_ . o, Your inner, in the case cf “eck-r-Kr.ysin, , wh ich will cccs. bef r. this .ribunal after the cccpl. ticn -f the Defen¬ se of -efcn'ant 7cktcr Brack, Use «*rececuti n has char - the Defendant -\.c« .r-Fr-ysir. in the Lvlictcent unler cunt one with Ccnsprir:icy,un- t!cr count to which sp.cial responsibility fir -n: participation in the high iltitudc cxp.rioen-s, the freesinf exp rLtents, the SuU-water ux- periconts, the epi '.cole Jaundice exp- rinvnts, anl the sulf milaaUc ex- perinonts, spett- furor exp-rLe.nts in in count three it has chart cC the .Icfcaiant Becker— rcyoin vitr. these experiments as set fair in count two. ..t this tin. the rrcsccuti wishes t- with ra\* the char;- arainst the 'efendant 3eckor-Froy*in. ins far as h. w .a ccnnectc ’ with the sulfonilini . -xp riiienta. If th. tribunal requests, I -.'ill aubr.it thia in writin. . .*c will witn’raw cnly • ne char e. U you want ue to fil. a writin with th Sucre tary-o~n~rol -n: c .sply with it. Th:. .R..DIDL.iT: The fr'3ccuti n rill fil its /rith'raral of this char¬ ge in writin with a full st~-Ur.-nt n *. ive c .r.3 1 fer tr.e “efen lent Becke r-F r a ir. ; copy. .-B. AtRLI: Yes Dir. 9Y Dil, R0L5Clwe».r;l; 1 itr.esr y .ur -neub. r s otat-.^nt by the representative ,f the eic! s Ministry f Justic at this ox..tin- t tile eflvCt that the hitler -.cree, wl .ch s « sh-we' t. th se pr-s-n., was ib3 lutely a valid, l.r 1 onsis iar euthanasia? .e Yes, I ooi that bef< re. That was the stat-n-nt I th. acting :lb.r .r, that was th. highest Official 't th-t tiz. , bv.c us. lu.rtn-r hi La the- ioe.ir.ti_e. 1 Then j. PreSi nt; I h. Vc finish- th 3ubj-.ca with the ef.:i- • • :-.at Brack's • r:. in c • • c*i n dtfc ,ut:: .v'-sia. In the .xaninati n f 15 : iay-K-GJ-5-3-.~han-< vonSchon)- Ccurt 1 the Defendant fori 3randt the frc-secuti'n placed preal emphasis on cla- ri:yin the queseicn of shat persons were to be effected by euthanasia. C-;i5equ«.ntly, I see cysclf obliged briefly to ro into this question. 'itn-ss, n w -re ccee to*a sublet, which is veiy much debated, ycu knew that according to the decree the doctors to be app inted by Bran !t and Bcuhler were to have their functions extend.d to th- point that th.u could -rant euthanasia t~ incurably sick persons an.', ycu have just said that the law, which was be in drafted, w s tc contain all provi¬ sions which had become n.c-ssary frea the practice of euthanasia? n lea. Q Maw, the first quo* icn cooes up is, and -hen the f rosecutien asks rightly what p.rsons w-r. effected by this decree, were there any -xeptiena, prc.i'o l an* who '-tormina 1 the exception, in your uxanina- tion before in to- rrc rater y u "d’ly ncu h hcv. s id nothin-- ib ut this. In stu yin. the r-c'rls, I tbs.rve hat this important point is not mention.' at .11 in j j affi avit, as that forgotten, what was the reason? .v I n't kn w. In ry int..rrc atim, 1 iscu33od those thin-s pro¬ perly. I s i, th-. ford ners, ,rl was veterans, in this case where the war injuries were tr.c caus- • f their insanity n. Je«3 were excetip- tee free euthanasia. * list was shown to Re and I had to as3U.r.- it was a transfer list free ne instituti n t a r.u thanes La I stitutc, .n which Jews wcTw listed. . .x. fr«.si_ent, i sh.ui like to interrupt the defendant briefly here and refer to th. c cuocnt. Ihe cunent her- just mention-I is Mr. 158, lochibit iilO, F,n lish Doeu&.nt Bo-k, 16 pa.> U. Please continue n 1 t cuacnt bock. This wce> th- ' cun.nt rhick was shewn tefy I believ. that this r.;s the list, which I was shown, here various pel's ns wh s ntfliS indie te th.y are Je.s, as w.ll as vari us persons wh wer bora utsic f - rr.-.ny -_r. list ’. It Suusc that I can rta-n- ' _r v ry clearly that ‘cr in.rs ha tc be -Xe.-.tte -n ’ tha this was bap. n per. r. 1 r r fr a Bitl r. I was n t c nfus.c, but ins-far 7593 15 -vxOi-n-(vonSchc.'i)- C_urt 1 -s tot Jews are. ocnc- rnt^, 1 nyscli boron to hrm ubts ini on toe ■»>- vi3>. f to.- int_rra-:^l/-r3 I i’ net insist that Jews wer x«.cptot. ,.fur s^e-ln all tiu. :ocu=»nts .-oin on hivinr ncc.ry refresh.: , 1 knew that “c« were -xcipted in the soao my. I oust o.tntoim: tint I ileo £ r jot in the interred-ti n. Lober victim pcrs.ns injur-..! in Industrials accidents fr.fi which insanity r.culto were. ols: nptv .. Q will <& intc this inW.il to mkc it perfectly clwar. Til. Hti^nEKT; Beferu pursuin' t .is n-.ttor ir. -tail, the ‘riburol till be in recess (A recess was toktn)- irA Court Ho. 1 15 nay 47-n-7-l-iivi-ceexd (Ranlor) TS KAHSKAL: All per cons Is the courtroom will nicest fir.i their Swata. The Tribunal is again in session. THe. rltSIDLST: The counsel say proceed. BY 2B. HECESC&iABH: - l<. Witness, before the receee I as'.-c«>eri (rosier) 'ore, could not lcnov why there vet an obligation to fill out this outotionnairt for foreigners. 7597 15 Ifc? 47 —k-8-l-pkp- Bioisi (R-cL-r) Ccurt So. 1 A.. I personally was ir. 2 position to observe the development of these questionnaires and I was prc-Svnt when Linden tnd 3ohne presented tr.<.c to Bouhl-r for approval. These questionnaires wore s-nt to -11 Cer r. Cental institutions through the Reich Ministry of the Interior, Th-ywure p-rtly s-nt there-directly, partly through the subordinate county dninistr-tior.s. As I saw from the docuaunt, the decisive d-.tc wns the 1st of Suptueb-r 1939. As I said before, Himmler ordered strict secrecy to be kept. In this covering letter to the nont-.l institution it had to be prevented th*t the purpose of this enumeration of Xho mental *» tients be recognised for that reason the s-ntonco was introduced in tho introductory pr.rt of that letter, which reads, “With rognrd to tho necessity of coordinating the cental institutions through planned econony —etc. DK. FROESCK. AKN: Mr. President, ir. th't oonx>jCtion Ifhouid like to dr.au attention of the Tribunal to three- documents which wore presented by the prosecution. As I already mentioned - this is Document :«-B25, ’ r.d then th-ru is ono, U*96-PS, Exhibit 357, which is to bo f jund ir. th. Jn-.llsh Document Book, Volume 1/., p gc 209; in the Goman Dacun nt Book, P-rt II, page 126... And I s:ould -Iso like to draw your attention to tho Document JC-U33, Exhibit 335, which is to bo found in tho English L'ocuo r-.t Book 14, page 86. These are the coverin'- letters of which the witness is new sp- -king, rf DR. FHOBSC.'tL®.: Q. would you pleas- continue? A. Ever, il this a.ntonco was intended at a canoufLago sentence Low nr o those institutions, such a systemized registration naturally prevailed; U:* ever, this registration had no connection t 11 with Euthanasia. I shall revert to that question later, .ih if discussing th- ti..:r qu-stimnair s. a? my rate, the heads of those a-.ir.tnl ir.stitutlrs vhich had to d.al with the filling out zi these questionnaires, were-told by this covering letter that this is -tt- r r‘ r registering 'll : . sever - tally ill - tients.. if tho foreigners • • icc'.t^d rear dir. to severing letter, cany he «.ds " c* on 15 toy 47 -Jf-8-2-okp— Hiolsi (RraUr) Court No. 1 of the cental institutions, and cony of the clericil personnel, would have asked themselves about tr>; reason for such in exception. No practical reason could hive- been found which would justify foreigners b-. in#, uxcuptod. That, of course, would hive opened a door to many c wild moor. For that reason or.- took the r-v-rs- pith in order to "Iso register 15»-s- foreign mantel patients. The question regarding nationality ire! race was contained in every quest ionr.-iro in Gor.iv.ny it th't tine, and could not create iny urdue 'tt-ntion. For th“t. rocson it could not create any a t tent ion if, in addition to the categories which ire ccr.tair.od therein, — criminals and patients of certain kind — would also include rationality nd race. In th-t way one achieved cecoufl-go of the exception directives, and ono also svoidod questions being put by outsiders Just why foreigners are to bo uxoopted. Q. Witness, if I understand you correctly - it was necessary for foreigners to fill out those qu-ationr.aires b cause, on the ono hard, orv wanted to koop the true reason frea the he.ad of the montcl ir.stituto; and, on the ether hand, one wan Ud to give assurance to the Porlin head office in order to safeguard these foreigners by registering thorn? A. lv>, these qu-stionnrlres, aft-r having boon fill-d out, w-r.t back via ihu J.'inistry of the In t-ri or to the T-A; 'rid from there were sent to ti;- exports. In the T-4, when dealing with these question- • r.air-s there w.ao the b-ct possibility of sorting out t h- forcign-m, ard 1 personally convinced ays-If, and know, that in all caces where foreigners wen. reoort-d this p-ssage in the questionnaire wan underlined with red pencil. It was sorted out and filed in different cabinet. It wasn't ver. included in the photostatting procedure. Through the above procedure th-r- was -Yen air* certainty of xce-pting ev-ry forvign-r. The saa; procedure was adopted with reference to those who wore injured during the world war. Theru, of coura., we had not that much certainty because tr.-y, of ccurs., we-r- exccot-d, but , rn the other hand, were included ir. tha uxp_rt pr ocedure. In th- c-as- of a control cade by Hitler, which Sraadt has already described, it has actually b -r. as- rtairiud that in ti - tlir-e or four c-ses wh-r<- the atr.Vi illness » 7?9V 15 !£i" 47 -i!-3-3-pkp- Biolsi (Easier ) Court o* 1 could have beer, in sxoe connection with an injury ns a result of the wet, core actually subjected to Euthenasin bee-use these questionnaires t s>rte<: -at beforehand without any expert opinion being given. Q. ritness, it is my impression that for reasons of security this procedure was :-r ndlld in a soaawhat difficult way, although it could have beer, dor*- much simpler. A. Ko, that is not quite true. If this procedure could have been hard led simpler it could not have given us ouch assurance. It had to be dene with -o absolute amount of Certainty. Q. Witness, your testimony, according to which th* questionnaires -bout foreigners were not photostatted in the T-4 rnd wore not sent to the expert, would you not have to change that testimony when reminding you of what ifom-cke has said? Did nut Itcnnocko any th-t he person Uy, as an expert, had filled jut r number of questionnaires -b-ut noi>- Cernans? A. That is true... I remember ilennecke's testimony, but I can jniy emphasize (\&-ln that the cr.tter in which Jenneckc participated io in n- way c nnected with Euthanasia - nd, really, it does n>t deserve the nrau of Euthanasia. I must emphasise - -in nd again that Euthanasia, -ftor August 1941, was stopped by order f llonrxcku - and I already spoke bout it yesterday where he said that ho had received HiaaLr's orders in the year 1940 - must be incorrect. It can only concern the erdur uo way; Q A little earlier you sai that participants in tho first World War wore to ba oxcopted fron outhanasia whonovor thoir nantil illnoss stood in sc no connection with an injur}’ which they had roooivod fror. ttu Tt’orld .‘or. How, considering your testimony I should llko to point to Document :r—i37, Exhibit 361*, which is in tho English Docurwnt Book ll;, pa o 236. There you will find a list which was 0 "arofully compiled by tha Prosecution - a list or 22 dor.th notices taken from a \ Snxcnian ifcropauor. "a this list you will find a renark in Paragraph 3, that they arc voter-.ns of .;rli %-r 191h-1917« On h yen find ho was boarer of the cross of honor fer war votc-rnns and you vrill find something s k-ilar in figure 5# These are participants in tho World Tar who diod at Linz and who wore designated as r . • . y-u bring this fact in connection with tho st-.tea^nt you Just nado? 7602 15 liny ^7-::-.vT2-?-2-Gr ass (Int. Ranooler) Court Ho. 1 That is quite true «hat ycu say there, doctor. Let ne say first of all that thoro is absolute inconsistency in the fact that Euthanasia as an act of grace could only be riven tc Germans and in the fact that war veterans ware exceptod fren it. Thus tho presen¬ tation of this as an act of groca sqors to loso its foundation* But, for purely psychological reasons in view of tho fact that a war was then -oiivj on Bcuhlor, after aaxxy ’iscussions with nany doctors and other persons, decided that in order to avoid any unrost anong tho population the participants in tho first 'crld ~ar rraro to bo excepted under vary special conditions which I shall oluciiato in a noraent. This was done to avoid anyone having tho suspicion that persons uoundod in tho present war, lot us say, tdth brain injury could bo in danger of having their livos token under Euthanasia. However, this exclusion of first V orld ’.var veterans did not exclude veterans altogothor. Exdudod wciro only votor.*ns in wbeta a war wound was tho causo of nontol illnoss. Thus a raan who .as par A ly*od, lot us say, or had rocoivod a aovoro log wound, was not oxcoptsd frota tho euthanasia booauso this paralyois had nothin to do with tho brain injury. That is tho sano for persons who sustained Industri J. acci fonts. I have said that before. q F- haven't answered ty tion yot. How was it those four or five r votorans woro anon, thoso who rocoivod euthanasia. A Here it says worl • rar vet rans but thora is no indication thoro was ary rental sickness in thoso pacplo that had anythin'- to do with 'tar injuries. Q I understand what ycu scan, o alroa£ f dealt with the oxcoptions. Kcw, of thoso who actually did. receive euthanasia you have alroc V sai l that on instructions by Bcuhlor euthanasia within fr.ancwork of your activity could bo applied only to incurably uontally ill yxirsons, i3 that tru ? ix Yos, that is correct* Q Th; Prosecution whan cxnninin. Karl Brandt as lead a rrurbur of questions of Mr- in that connection and I should like to direct the seno 7603 l5 l£ay U7-!f-ATD-9—3-Cr os3 (Ins. Renler) Court No, 1 questions to you. The Fuehrer docroe soys nothin’ to the effect that these sick persons would die natural deaths in th- cour3o of ovents. Is that true? A No, there isnothing to that effect in the decree# Q Is it correct that a person 15 years old can bo incurably ill and yet live to a ripo old ago as far as you learned that fron physicians. A That is possible, yos, Q Should euthanasia only bo usod with such porsons as will dio a natural death shortly* namely within two years, lot us say? A NO, it was not so United. Q Now, I again put to you Docuaont IJO—825 according, to which tho duty of reportin'; is r.ontionod. Now, osido fron point b all pationts cro to report regarding tho naturo of their sicknoss, tho stato of thair disooso if they fit tho qualifications of points 1-3. Is that so? A Yos. Q “/asit not also statod that parsons capable of working woro not to bo subjecto:'. to outhenasia, A No, t2v,ru waonothin; to that offoct. Q But in tJx. questionnaire you had to say whothcr you wore capable of work or not? A Yos, that is so but there wore cjrtain reasons for that and certain limitations. Q "*hat wero tho limitations? A The institutions ha : interests in thoir pationts as thoso being used in agricultural work. Thay would not wish thoso patioijt3 to bo ranovod fron this "Jerk, after they had becoco usod to it. And tho nbaent when a patient can work ho is still in contact with his onviron- nont. Consequently in any such case ttore should not have boon a positive expert opinion but a negative ore. Consequently it wr.3 rc:iu»dant t- expertise questionnaires whore a person reported ho was capable fer vork. 760 . 1 $ }&y U7-«-ATI>-9-ii-Oross (Int. Easier) Court So. 1 That stands verbatin in that formulation, naaaly special persons whs BPO not actually ..orkin in agriculture or industry. Q "itness, did this iinitation apply also to too persons naiaod under 2 and 3. A He, it would not. Q Exr do you ccno to that conclusion? A On this pa jo of instructions tto word "or" appears botwoen too list of various cats'orios. That :oans that ttoso people are to roport Kith no regard to it that thy are actually wcrkiiv- or not unless thay aro sufferin'; fren oik of tte sicknosses lisfcod undor point 1 . Q New lut us take an oxr.uplo. Does a parson havo to roport who has boon in an institution f-2-Haloy-(Srovn} Court 1 out that It vas Dr. Linden. Do you anything to add to Pfannmueller's testimony on this point? is what he said correct and credible or do you have some other point of view with which you night supplement his testimony? .i. In general what Pfannmueller said was perfectly credible to me, as far as I know anythin- about this matter of the Reich Committee, but In a few respects I must supple-' ment hla tiStiaony. For example, I myself In many casos showed Bouhler and Brandt the complete files of terribly ill children for their final decision, and for this reason I Knew that ooth Bouhlor and Brandt in many cases had the child put aside for further observation, over and oeyond the Judgment pacsed by the actual specialist. It never happenod that the expert specialist said that this child cannot oo subjected to euthanasia, and that Brandt or Bouh¬ ler said no, nevertheless we will approve euthanasia for this case. That nevor happonod, rather tho exports decided that the child could be given euthanasia and Brandt and Bouhler then took the standpoint that for one reason or another, not necessarily a medical reason, this child was to be further observed and to bo expertised or. a year or two later. Let me add also that In the proceedings in the Reich Committee the approval of the parents had to bo received and without such permission on the part of the parents the authorisation was not given by Brandt or Bouhler. That Pfannmueller did not receive the authorisation as he said was to be understood, because the children were sent fro him as the local pnyslclan, or some other doctor had sent them or. and he had already carried or. the correspondence with the Minister of the Interior. ^ Bldn't you nay something you didn't mean to? 7612 15 May .Jv-11-.-;aloy_( Brown) Court 1 ... No, what I said was D?. Pfannaueller received the children only later, and the local physician first h.\d had lr. i way all correspondence with the Unister of the inter¬ ior that Pfannsueller would not Know. Q. Didn't the parents have to give their permission to the doctor in charge of the .tmtsarz, the local doctor? To the ifitsartz. Q. Did I understand y 0 u to saw that negotiations between the ntsartz and hinlster of the interior and through the consent of tho parents was received, and then the child was sent to Pfannaueller with emission for euthanasia? a. "fes, let me point out also a document that was not put in evidence at least not this page of it, but the entire doouner.t 1696PS, page ■57. on page 9” of this document it can bo seen that apparently through some error or through some withdrawal of oonount by the parents, if this error or withdrawal of consent was discovered further proceedings were immediately interrupted. DA. ?a0e)30A..ui:': .ir. President, the matter to which the witness is now referring is something about whioh I already spoke when hearln; pfanntnuoiler. These are two documents from my document book 50 and 51. They ire ir. Supplemental Volume No. \ and I hope I shall receive them from tho Secrotary General within tho next 15 minutes, and get them to tho Tribunal, o’. which tir* I shall ;lv,: .vhl'dt numbers to the few documents in that volume, but I cannot jo that yet , of course. TdZ PR25ID3NT: The Tribunal has been "Jvised that Sup¬ plemental Book No. ”* Bracx will b ready tcda- and thov will expedite it as soon as possible. Dr.. ?a 03CH. : Thanh you. I received that information 7ol3 15 May 47-H-.JC-1X—i-Kaloy-Ccrown) Court I already. Q. Witness, continue please. I h'W* 5 only to ad that regarding details of the expertizing procedures at the Reich Com lttee I know nothin*, because I was not concerr.ol In that. I know, however, tnroujh 3ouhler and through Linden that In Reich Co.ialttee matters, only first class specialists wore used as psychia- trio experts. y. ’.witness, I any no iou:t conclude from your stat¬ ements that the correctness of ’-he document submitted by the Prosecution concerning the registry ol' chlllren you do not deny, and I nr. referring to the following four doc¬ uments to whioh I should 11 ko to call the attention of the Tribunal: No.ll&, exhibit *46, 2r.-;llah Document Book 14, page la9; then No. 1148. Exhibit ■*-!?, English Document Rook 14, page 150; third, No, 1145, Exhibit ’52, English Doc¬ ument Sook 14, pa.*e 157; and. No. 1146, English Document Book 14, page 172, and with this I ooncludo tho affair of the questionnaires and I shall now deal briefly wl th the documents which tho Prosecution nave submitted as evldonoo, that In spite of your statement mado today, In spite of brar.dt'a testimony Jewish insane persons wore subjected to euthanasia. Ey way of Introduction I should like to say that there Is a total of seven documents which I should like to touch upon briefly, and then indicate In each case where they were found. Witness, I shall discuss the follov/- ln fc documents: please get them ready. No. 111, No. 11’’, No. 115, No. 1141, No. 114, No. 114-,, No. 1*1C. Now, will you please comment on tho transfer of Jewish Insane persons Indicated by these documents? first of all I should like to say that document ?61t 15 May 5-Maloy- (3rowb) Court I 11 , 6 and No. 720 may have to be aentloncd also. Q. I had Intended to deal with that later witness. .xZ the tine I did not learn about these transfers. I Knew about then in general, just as everyone knew that Jewish patients wore to. be brought together. «11 I can say about these documents is not ay knowledge from this time, but the result of my examination of those documents. This io ill I con say about the various documents. No. 1^10. Exhibit ,, 7, this la in Document Vook 17, the German, on page 6. 7 # 13 15 Hay-"-35-22-1-ifeehan (int. Yon Schoa) Court No. I. Q In the English, it is .also on rage 6. A This Docuctnt shews that tho Bavarian lanistry of the In¬ terior on U September 19li0 reached a decision on the transfer of Jo wish cental c-ses. They were to be transferred free various Bavarian in¬ sane asylums and assembled in the Haar Eglf ing be two an L .and 20 Decoia- bor 19liO. On that day tho head of tho institution reported that these patients had boon assoabled at Eglfing, they rero full-bloodod Jews of Polish or Genian nationalities or st tclGss Jons. At the sano time ho roported to tho Bavarian State Ministry of tho Interior on 20 Kovoribor 19U0 that tho pationt transport corporation transferred them to a collocting center in Berlin. The list of thoso Jews was given in Document Kb. 1135, Exhibit 331*. Q Please ,'ivu this doc-xcnt to the witnoss. This is in English docuiont book 1]., pa.o 25. rib rocoivcd only a photostat. There on page 17, you will find a list of tho Jewish patients and also on pa. 0 hi of tho docuient book. How, doos tho fact that thoso pationts wuro transferred by tto transfer company indicate that this was also within tho frano-work of outhanaoiaj what do you hnvo to say about that? A First of all, I can say basically that tho patient transport company carriod out transports not only for the purpose of outhannsia, but also other transports of patients. I recall t)ie roscuo work in tho oast for wounded, whs wore transferred from hospitals in danger of air-raids, otc. This transport ccopony, whon such transports wore to bo carriod out, recoivcd an assigntBnt from tho I'-inistry cf tho Interior and assignor', a transport loader. This man had to bo an ex¬ perienced official, because all kinds of tiiin 3 could happen to ouch ^ a transport ’uring war tine. He night bo stuck somewhere for a con- siderablo period of tlau and the patients would have to bo taken care of. H« also was iven th.* local assi Trent by the local agency, such as for example the Bavarian Ministry of the Interior. -} How whon tho transport company took over Germane, was - 7616 15 May-::-13-12-2-^ehm (int. Vcn Scfcon) Court Ko. -I. there any certificate, any receipt given? A Yes, these receipts wc have here in Docuasnt NO-1135. The official of the transport company gave a certificate, such ns we havo here with the institute by way of a receipt and thereby be assumed the responsibility for tho patients. Q Witness, I don't have tho document here, but is it truo that tho document says these patients are to be transferred to n Roichs institution? A Yes, that is what it Bays. It s^ys that tha patients are to bo transferred to a Roichs Institution. Q Hr. President: I should lilco to point out that not only in Dccunont NO-1135, which tho witness is speaking about, but also tho docuaont which I contioned oarlior, NO-1133, Exhibit 335, Eng¬ lish Document Book 11*, pngo 86 and Document NO-1131, Exhibit 3h0, English Document Book H, p'e 91, contains such cortlfientos. A New, thoro is ono noto-werthy thing about this docuront. Tho names of thi ins-~.no parsons woro always listed on a printed f PXTJ in a nunberod transport list, these lists contained the first nano, tho next rvaru, tiw place of birth and tho date of birth. It contains no roferonce, hoerovor, to nr.tionalitior. I pointed out oarlior that tho benefit of euthanasia was to bo givon only to Oornan citiaons. Thoso documents, NO-1131, Exhibit . Q T'o havo already boon through that, wo don't have to re¬ peat tho numbers. A Tho names of tho Jewish patients, lewover, which wo r.ro talking about tare are not on the usual trcns.ort list of tho transport company, but on usual typing papor. It rioos not list any placu of birth or date of birth either, cvrcly nationalities. Ono can conclixlo therefrom that in thin ease nationalities of tho persons to bo trans- ferro-* 3oemed to be core important to tie authorities than the date and place of birth. Q Just a rir.ute, witness, in this list thira arc 33 Gomans 1> (Int. Von Schor.) Coart He. I. and 2 Pcios? A Yos. Q And than under 13 there is a Czech citizen, tfcose nano has been crossed out again. A It has beer, crossed ut here on the original ’ocuracnt. Q Yes, it has be n crossed out. A It soys Botanic raid Ifcrnvir. as citizenship and in tho r.ccouj. nying letter for this transport, sent to the Ministry of tho Interior by the Institute E{Jlfing-Haar, tho suggestion was nado that this nan Bur.sol is a citizen of tho m-tectorato and should bo sont to an institute in tho Protectorate. lx. President, this covering lottor is in book 17, cego 6. • • A In ether words, tho authority of tho instituto did not considor it pcr.iisaiblc for a citizen of tho Protectorate to bo sont to tho carao l:atitutc as Icnm-ns and Polish Jews -Sc this Instituto was sinply not in tho Protectorate and tho institution must have rocoivod corresponding instructions. I should iiko also to refor to tho follow¬ ing- on tho certificates givon to tho institution by the heals of tho transports, it says oxprcsely upon order cf tho Roichs Association of Jfental institutions. In this lottor SO-1310, tho institution 'loos not refer to an assignment of tho doichc Association, but sinply to the decree of tho Bavarian State ranistry cf tho Interior. In this case of the Jews, who were transferred, tta Prosecution has not sub- nitued any cortificnto oy tho transfer company. I assure that if such a document were in existanc., it rould be aaong the documents here. 3 Ho., where did this Jewish transport go? A That cannot be seen from this document, but fron .-j»othor dccunxint. I have been able to as suae that Dec uaon t HO-llAl, Exhibit 31j 5, Document Bock 1J*. 3 It is in the English doctxnent book on pogo 150. A Fr - this document one can see that the nano Bertha Y.'ur- ttaior was listed there and she died in Che In on 3 December IS^e. 7 as 15 Jfcy-:WS-12-^fiehan (Int. 7or. Schon) Court No. I. This Berth - - a'orthcirer, according to the file-note, was transferred there by the patient transport cccpnny. Ore can therefore conclude that the entire transport went to Chclu. Q ^aa 3arthn Berthe irn,r in this transport of 20 Dcccrber 19U0. A I an sure that it says that. Yes, it is shewn that she was also transferred on 20 Decoder. TIE KtESTDE.TT: The Tribunal will now tjo in recess until 1«30 o'clock. (A recess was tekon until 1330 Hours.) 7619 •-y 15-~-3K-13-l-Fester (In. Von Schocn) Court No. 1 •JT-aioow session (Th- hotrinj roconvoncd at 1330 hours, 15 Nay 19-±7) TKJ :—.JrLi: The Tribunal is n.;ain in session. THE P..ESIDNNT: Counsel nay .xooeod. VUCTO.t L*c.CN - Nosuned DI.L-CT -lli.1N.JiON (Continued) BY D-. r.20-1ECiCLJJN (Counsel for,the Defendant Brack): - witness, I roisind you that you ore 3till under oath. Lut us hurry and try to oor.cludo. .itnoss, boforo the noon rocos3 v»o 3to..od in the discussion of Doounont NO- 1141, Exhibit 348. I a3ked you whore the transport of So.'tcnber 18 - 20 wont. You said that fron this doounont NO-1141 you concluded that, tho transport went to Chain. Do you havo any further connent on this question? .. Froc- tho doeux: nts 1144, Exhibit 3-.2, Doounont Book 14, ..art I, ,»n ;o 57 in tho Garcan we sec - * In tho En;li3h that is .a;o 110. .. - that Bertha wo Hand frau, NO-1143, Exhibit 343, Document Book 14, pert 2, . c,;o 65 - v In tho *n-jlish Docunent Book 14, .art I> ;>a;o 126. .that wilholx. N^unann, ..lbert Tillnann, Gortrud 0.; ohhoinor, Bertha Hoiuann, So. hie ..ioson.jrund and -.lbert Froohlich, 'were sont accoriinj to tho boforo raontion- od decree of tho Bavarian Ministry of tho Intorior, on tho 20th of So. tor.bor 1340, froc the institution Ejlfin-. Of those, Gertrud 0..enhein-r is oontnined in tho list on a ;a 17, §f-Doc unor.t NO-1135, nueber 3. »nd tho list of *6v>Doo 12, 'art III. N0-720, Exhibit 366, . a';o /k m 1 ^3. i This docunoritj 210-720 is in the English Docuncnt Book \ 14 on _CJ3 243. j rhe^oCh^p/naj are in the lists previously ussntioned. I do not ::now, but __ aan-s are not contained in this list, but 7623 -3y 15-..-3K-13-S^?cst-r (Int. Von Schoon) Court ::o. 1 I conclude it from thoso documents, that on tho 20th of Se;»teab-r 19*i0 there wore other tran3 orts leaving Ejlfin.;- Haar. no have no list3 of then, at least they have not boon submitted. I must conclydo that a transport wont to Choir, on this day; that in Choir, there was on observation or outhonasia institution is con. lately unknown to no and I c-rtair.ly would havo learned it , because I know the names of tho six euthanasia institutions. Tho as sun. t ion of tho .rosecution, that tho ..arsons who woro rouovod from Ii;;lfin ;-Harr on 20 tonber 19-.0, the 191 Jewish non and wonen were subjected to euthanasia, is incorrect und is refuted by what 1 just ox. lainod. . Witness, you ronoebor that the witness, Dr. Pfannf nuoller said that he learned later that thoso Jowish in- sanu . ationts ware sent to Lublin. You have already said that you knew nothin; whatever about all these natters, that only now from cx;ir:ir.in ; the dccunento you have reach¬ ed these conclusions. It is alao3t superfluous to ask, did you know then tho neno Lublin. Do you know that Jowish insane , ationts were Sent thorc? .. No, I know nothin j of that. D... F.IOESCHILJW: Ur. Prosidont, I have covered tho doopnonts submitted by the .rosaoutian dualinj with what persons woro effected by euthanasia. Now I cono to tho fin«jl subject of tho 30-callcd euthanasia . ro ;ran and I shall dor.l in outline only with tho course and tho stopp¬ ing of euthanasia. BY D... SaQSSCHILIW: # t witness, you have already said that the questionnaires received were sent to T—« and that thoy separated thoso ro for Tin.: to forci;ners. These questionnaires woro not hotostated and were net sent to tho ox.-orts, that only the remainin' questionnaires-, that is, those which did not refer 76a ”ay 15-..-5K-l3-3-?oster (Int. Yoi* Schocr.) Court lio. 1 to forci;nors and octs, wore .hotosteted and sent to the exports. I r.eod not ;o into the details that wore jivon by tho witness Pfannmucllor concerning tho filling out and tho judjinj of the questionnaires. I had originally intondod* as in tho case of Pfannnuollcr, to show you one or two questionnaires, not for you to jud;o then free tho aodical . oi.nt of view but fra*, tho purely udninistrativo .»oint of view. I bollovo, howevor, that this nuttor has boon cleared up so thorou ;hly thit tho prosecution will soo no oauso in cross examination to deal with tho subject, and, consoquontly, I 3hell not need to show you tho questionnaires which I hfcvo fillod out by Dr. Pfiann- muollor. I shall noroly ask, you heard tho testimony of Doctor Pfannr.uoller conoornin'j tho judgin'; of tho questionnaires, tho plus or minus si;;n, or question mark. Do you have anythin to add to this testimony? .. Ho, I have nothinj to add. The explanation of tho witness Pfannnuollor was quite thoroujh. v «nd is it correct that the oases do3i ;natod a3 .,03itive, that i3 by a *Vlus“ by tho ohiof export, woro sent to Linden's office, and that Linden's office ordor- od the transfer of tfceso patients to an observation institution by orders to tho trons. ort cor., any? .» Yos, that is true. ip Hay Cc-.k (Int. vcn SChoen) Court llo, 1 Q Do yen knar whether the doctor in charge after tho period of observation subndttod a report? k I ton*t know how that was nana~oi I only know that tha Chiof Experts wore in constant contact with authorize'.! doctors in tho observation institutions concerning* tho selection of the patients under observation thoro. Q Is it true ajoin that aftor the period of observation Linton's office a^ain issued instructions to tho transport co.npany an l thus arraxvjod for tho transfer of tho patients to a euthanasia institution? /. Yes, I nor.tionod that briefly yostorlay. q Is it true that at tho stjv> tino a photostat of tho opinion of tho chief expert rras sent to the outhanasia institution? A In oach caso c photostat was sent to tho euthanasia insti¬ tution bocauso whon tho pooplo arrivud tho photostat had to bo corv- parotl dth tho personal date and tho caso history. Q I can concludo thon that the caso history an’, porsonal files wore also sent to tlvj autJvJvisia \octcr? Yos, of course, ho nootded thor. for tho final opinion of the patient. Hu w*ui net have boon ablo to soo that fron tho condition of tho .rtiont aicn:. Ho noodod tho caso his tar;'• Q Arri new to conclude this sub loot, I ask you whsthor you can confirm what tho -..itnoss, Dr. Pfannnxollur has sni l, that tho outhanasia doctor *bo united everythin in his hands, who had tho patient, tho ca3o history, tha porsonal records, and the final -erdical decision as to whether this patient was to b-j subjected to outhanasia, or whothor ho was V bo returned to an observation institution or to his original institution, is that correct? A The final responsibility lay with tta ©xecutin doctor who ha*, an absolutely u ni Ini to 1 veto riht. q Nor:, lx. Brack, since I have loalt with this chapter thorough¬ ly with you, I can assuro that as this norinr* you Id not doubt tho report on children contained in tho docunents/ you - dll also not wish 7o23 15 U7-.W.TD-1L-2-C eofc (Int. von Scfcoon) Court Ko. 1 to biry tho ccrroctnoss of thu ‘ocurunts subaittol by tho Prosecution concomin* the transfer f insr.no .arsons fron the faU of 1939 until i.u’ist 19U1? A I cannot ‘.ony tea accuracy of those ' cun-.nts. a For the inforrr.tioT. a? the Tribunal an* of the Proa option I renaric that tho Jocuror.ts .ihich tho lofcnimt J oes not rish to contest aro tho folio-sin sovon -tocunants which 1 shall ror.'. brioflyi «). 1133, Exhibit 335, 2n lish Document 3cok Hi, pc-“o 86: !C- 1131, Exhibit 3U0, tocuetor.t book lli, ;a o 93| JD. H32, Exhibit 3U1, ?.n lish Docu.-r.nt Book H, pa*o 100, JO-U3U, Exhibit 3W, » Ush -tocunant bock lli, l*ce 1 *>i >»• 817, 3«s 3n lish 'ocunont took 1U, p.v;o 25U, JO. 827, Exhibit 375, En lish -locuncnt bcok Hi, page 269, an’, the final 'acu^nt is JO. 826, Exhibit Mo. 356, En-lish ’ocuattttt b->ok Ho. H:, pev o 203. IT. Brack, tho «u» r-nsuor «hich you have Just dvon no concernin': the transfer of insane no toubt applies also to tho \ocuainta concomin* th, son'in,- of quostionnairoa to tho exports an* son-la-; then V.<* to tea Dei eh * orkin;- Union? A Yos, I V) not bre* their accuracy. a i nn spor.kln • hero only of ter. Jocunonta which I ahoul 1 liko to brin to tho attention of tho Tribunal. Ttoso aro >». 1129, exhibit 35U, En lish Dccuiwnt Book Hi, * o 179, "-n’ "<»• H3° Exhibit 355, * Hah locusont book li, pa* riXxMB, concernin' -ccunont >1'. 1136, Ex ibit 3U5, of which tho Jofonso coins cl has only .a Photo- rtstlo copy an' which I was unable to fin \ in the En lish ,’ocuuent book. Tto you rish to mke any no ification? Do ycu havo the ’ocunent? Yos, I have it. Yes, tto rr »socutor apparently by rdstako 8ai * that 1057 patients were rervo’ froa tho 5-lfin -Kaar institution on ore ‘ny and that report is an error on the pert of the prolocution, hoeouso this nurd)or 1557 appearin in cclunn b of the SooUWrt is the total or all patients raaowl froa lfin-Baar. rols is fren tho •ocrr .nt itself -.a' this b cantata, the total of tho in-ivi-ual 762A fi uro3 ivn in cclurrr. 3 l~ 'y LTT-lc^>-Cook (Ini. von Conor.) Court Ko. 1 1 '^r- Pro si lent, I const'or this ate tenant ir.~ortont only bocauso the Prosecution an' the Tribunal -d. ht com to the -dstaken L. rasaion that on one way free, ono institution nearly 20CX) insane persona rare trunsforro '. That woulof course, throw a very . eculiar li ht on the testdmny of the witness Pfann-weller, which otherwise at least ir. ny o;inion is quite crodblo. The Prosecution has just kinlly brru h.t to ny attention that -.oounont 'k>. 1136 is in tho inflioh iocu- r.ont bock 3Ji, on .*a:o 1 ]j7. itnoss, I conclu !o the questions about tho locurwnts of Pfanrraiallor. )'n to with tho 3cno causo of '.oath rl ht bo rocoivo'l aoro than onco by tho sana farily. Thoso thin a, ro. rottablo as thoy wore, woro tho nocossr.ry censoquonco of tho 3ocrccy, which wo driliko !, an ' thn relatives in art waro ablo to chad: up on thoso thin 3 ime Uataly. I ram. ber the vory rc rettable caso vhon tho causo of -loath was iven n3 appondcitds althou h tho appendix hail boon ranove 1 Ion boforo that. I cannot cubt the accuracy of tho -’ocunonts -ubnitto.’ by the Prosecution in this raspect. ) *!r. :resi '.ant, 'bora aro thrao Vacuaonts concornoi horo, *Io. ■2 f , r-hibit 361, Ush 'ccuront book U : , paje 228, also r4opc ! a feeling of legal insecurity. This is especially clear, in the tter cf the Kea*. «f the Institution Statta, that is Sc. 520, ex¬ hibit 3b7, in docuu^nt bock lb, part 3 page 199, in the 6cman. In this letter tc the Reich ^.inlst r if Justice , Dr. Schleich speaks of this focl±n~ cf le'al insecurity. Q lir. President, the Iccujeant which the !efcn lant just aentionod is in the English Jocua&nt bock lb, pa|o 267. « it is eqjially regrettable that expedient measures were often taken — purely technical toOSUTvS, such as in transport, transfers, as shewn by \ cucont D 906, exhibit 376, in dccuocnt bock lb, part 3 page 192. "ju-lish docuoent bo k lb, pa e 271. And free locuacnt SO. 665, exhibit 37e need not into -rcat detail -n '.he individual shartccuinrs with the cunents r.:vr. Yea h-v 3tate that th_5. thin-s w_re as is a rccible t- yen an-’ E’.;ufcl_r, *• cth rs c^nc rnc os V any n. , rt. that nil nr:, rs arose which r-ve rise t assertion that people w-re bein ainicred, indescrisi- 7626 . _ 15 s.y-^-GJ-15-2—3car' , .-(vcn Schon)- C-urt 1 nstily. But now, I vhcul like to kr. w fr-.m you what position Bouhlcr to k to th.s_ c jplaints cause by Th-s- un-'crtanates circunstonces? /. Bcuhlor wantol all such cexplainta shewn to hiasclf, p-rs.nally, as far as poscibl-. That was not always p ssible, but in gen-rcl that hopn-n 1. To s-'. h w carefully those thin; s were I edit with can be ss 191 - 216- in the ".n lish .-'ccucent bo-k 1L, p - 271. This latter shows that Hcveltvinn, one of ry associates, was int r.sU ‘ in this coaploints, that was n Bruhl .r's instructions in', that is als ■!» . wn by th- ®nvj ocun nt, that • f Dr. Lin .eh answer--', this L-tt r nnl txk car- f the w.tt r. Q Hew wore thus c nplaints er.lt with? Pjen s<- distinguish between caiipl .ints fr a hv.ntv.nt :i ■ .neks n c.oplaints T :i Church authori¬ ties? * Crepliints fre.ft privot. p- rs ns w.r- n t s-nt t the Tier ( ~irten- str.asse It, .hich ms not kn -n, but they wer- sent V Fai thornsia Insti¬ tutions. iJ tl ’iroct r in’ p.rs m .1 f th^r Instituti.ns c ul 1 n t settle-! the r-itt-r satisfactorily, then it r.as sent n to T-h with a x- quest i r a dcoinionj then it was a oiopl r, they t k car it :r if it was sonethin c aplicat r basic, it was reported to the R-ichsleiter Beuhler. Conplaints Ir a iffici 1 a--vnci-s, f.r .xatpl.. authr rities of Rustic-, r. . itt inhere they «*er- rent, w-r.. always pas¬ se’ on Lr the r< cichal-iUr Bouhlcr, to k care r f th r. r .;av- th- n-.- c CBS ary instructions. : r xtspL., c apl into sent to she h-ich in is try f Justice, 03 we learnc I t r, .-.r sent :'irst to the Reich Chancellory an rren the r- t- ibe inis try f Ir.t.ri r, ..n only foro ther«. tf- i- r.i3 try f Interior, i Bculil.r 1 am ob ut then. That was cnan -e when Spul • '- nelu ‘ on.' a r Hint with Gu-.rtn 6 FS 622, exhibit 366, English iccucent beck 15 , P*12, :h. 636, cxnibit 335, Liylich docununt b: k 15, pagu 17 PS 616, xhibit 356, Eng lish iocuaent bork 15 p-rs 20, Ho 636, exhibit 3c6, Em lish Orcun.nt beck, 15, page 26, Ho, 9l(ii, exhibit 369, En lish <*ocuc-nt bock 15 pare 31, Ho, 81:5, exhibit 390, En lish eocur.-nt bo-'k 15, page 3L, one PS 681, exhibit 397, En¬ list 'tccurxnt bo k 15, p ’v 51. « C-cpl-inta fr e the church, Protestant is well os the C itholic church eculil not b wait dth because cf . b:sic instruction of Hitl-r 's but had t b turn. ever tc the ‘--‘.eh Chine 11 ry. Th-Se c rities are contained in six drcuc-nts, which I shall list i r the ini eras lion cf th-. Tribunal , Ho. 1?, -xhibit 39S, .n lish document b k 15, p f- 56 scCerv' . • 115 .xhibit ’07, Er- lish ’ccua-nt b k 15, pare 157, thirl Ho. 623, xhibit bOC, Fn liah cun.nt b k 15, pas*. 157, H • pi:5, exhibit 1.01, Ere lish ’ .cuav.nt book lr, p 156, P3 615, exhibit LU2, En lish 'Qcuia.nl b k 15, pajc 166, an PS 616, exhibit 603, En-lish loeunenb b- k 15, p - lao. •itn ss, -hat h .pp n.J in Aurust 191:1, wto-n Euthanasia wa. steppea? 15 s-y-^-GJ-la-l-riolsi-l vcn Scbcn)- Court 1 A The ncT*s f the cr-i-r o; Hitler tc step was transmittal by Brandt. In response t c this r'.cr I informed Tier :ar t_ ns trass e, Ji, Imsdiatcly, probably Pr f. Ki^tsche an ..ll_rs in this c:>se, an.: I saw t it that nil -uthonisia institutions, and -’ll euthanasia eject, rs lcarn-d :t this .rd-r f Hitl,r. »s sc nod as th_ or.cr was receive.' luthanosia stepped c cpl.t-ly. «ftor 3aae tic. Bouhl r learn- 1 that n. early resuupticn cf ruth-anas in ms tc b- - pect_ and h- retimed tc euthanasia in3tituti.ns tc their owners, an-t th- superfluous per3cnn..l wen cither tf thuir former prsiti ns, r * re :i3ai3Se.'‘. DR, 7WKSC^-».hI: r. Fr.ci \nt, Ihvtc spluUd thu evidence in re ori t- th. nc-c'llel cuthan sia pr'rr.= by ix aainin t i- .ef-nJant Tr ek. In this cent, cti-n, tbs dacuaonts wr.ich I have afar, all that reta .ins is t submit one e xjuo .nt that I i r . t . subnit this a. min.* when I r e speaking f the 1.e .lit; ©1 hlt^r'o i-cruc. • t.i D ounent 35, in ay Docuc-nt E k 12, :n par. 52, which I ff.r as Brack Exhibit ti?. 33. This Is th- affidavit a! Dr, ern,r -.at, f th. 10th of rcbruiry, 19b7, *hich is certified by r~. Trie ritne3s Beat in thxe af¬ fidavit stat.s, .n li base A his superior kn-wled- j th:it a Fuehrer lecrec r a fuehrer r ,r was rcprrd. at all tiia.s as law, in' th..t he hr.-' th- p'wor, t>. chanro, cr V r -Deal ny law, he p-inted ut that the ‘S.ich Cabinet ha' net been Seetin f r r. lea time, and that a law Jcvolopeu this way , I cnly the sv.rmcnt r > pi , but the -enerrl pepul ti n , *-n convince 1 that Kltl-r ha' thu ri ht tc issue such dccr-cs. Now I oca. to th final chr t.r of cy cise. ihat is, th. Euthanasia prcbl.j; m 3en f?ca th. p..i;:L :f view cf th- ’.for'’ant t/.warJ tiiia prcblea-bec'.u3e it is eiy opinion that th- motives cf the jafenJant : :y hr.v- i-cisiv-. influ-ne ea the qu-3ti.n 1 whether he actually coa- .•aitt.: scat ffonsin U ju'rnt .-f the tribunal - I b^li-v- that trds vi one which I shall att.^pt t- r.dc v_r> brief 'Cannot b-. denied the- .i n nt. . .itness, V u hrv.., v ry t. rcu hly, iscusse itj il p.irits. 15 *-a7-A-uJ-l6-2-3ial3i-(vc nSchr-n)- Ccurt 1 of tli. Euthanasia prograa. I have already .sked you one.-, he* it hnppe- n i that yen, as a ran ho ha. n v r ha 1 anythin.-, tc lo vdth such thin».*3 b,f- k, -n were . sir pi- . tninsitrativ- -fficial rf Ecuhl-r, c nsiderod y urs-11 justifi.: in eollabarctin in Euthanasia as a prtbl-n. I c net want any rcpet,iti:ns, -ny points that y'u h v. already liscusse ycu nay leave th^a cut. I hr.v_ > nthcrod froa ycyr testie. ny that you r-aUz-d that ehv on.blen r«, first of all, a n-.’ical prcbl-e, anJ that l-rsal cans* -rations wtr. involved, th .t carpi.ints count frrr. th- churches - fcj-cti ns &a:, fr s th. d int j view of n.li- , . that tb^ac complaints ccnc-m-d the humane ? int of view, fr .a these four p.ints cf view: ltftl, n lical, tte4Lo?ical, and hu¬ manitarian, ... I want to ask you a v_ry few »,u-.5ti:ns. a-, that tin-.. I .eph.sie- "at that wine’*... It }'u think ab ut th-s- questions? *- Of course, I thought .about these questions at that tine. Xc-u yours. If, in th. -xaninati- n f witn 33.-3, hav- asked qu.ntins osi'-na- tc' to illucin' tc this point of vi-w, - but at the v ry bwPinnin 1 vrrul like to i y that I, in ay way f thinkin , m ay oimpl- trainin' an in no p:aitiin t: .nav^r ju-s i-. nr n uh- int-ll.ctual lov 1 f the Witness ,'r.f. “ ibbran t. I ask y u * take this int c n:-i .. rut i n. 4 I rh.uld b. la* to J s an’ ko.p cy du«-3ei n afc.nle, .n 1 n th. l-v-l ch:t a 1-yr. n c n un rstan *. Y •» hav. Ire y 3.ai ’ that ac- ccriin. to the v.l pra.nt f th. u.rv.nn L. al stnt. fr r- 1933 t 1939 you h n ubt c Hitl-r'3 auth rit;. t. issu- decrees, orders, "ith the fore :f lew. is that c rrect? n Y*. 3. ^ Iny.ur pinirn, can stut. issue a law ic the -fleet, that incurably ins r,, persons can b. iv. n = rcy ath — that is, vftat lif- any b- ah rt_n. ’? .e i ar.i. this l- min that irst I ha n- w rrieo -t ill ~b- ut the 1- r.l pccsibiliti .s. irst c: all, I -a net a lasy-r, in th- second p lac I c asi or- tit ere p.rf ctly l_-al. tot r, I h ar fr a Ju- -Le "ritints f -in .in—:-..eh-, n :I5> .rs-tycr, -n I riots. r • 15 Eay-n-GJ-l6-3-Biclsi-(vcn Schon)- Ccurt 1 v.'.s c nvinccd that a stat- has the. ri.ht tc puss such a law. And 1 r«.- d-cber at that havin. rca. th-t scm- states ir. the United States, *er- said t hav- such an Euthanasia law. I r.CeD b -r anly the node !Lbraska. in En Ian tn-r. arc sev.rol saci-ti-r try in, t« hive, a .uthonasia law passed, n* - in Switzerland to , aucr. -ff.rts hav- buen • ;ln cn I r about tw nty years. Dft. ?R3£SC:E..im: ..r. ?rcsi _nt, I fi r m ovlkncc of the. correct- n as r.I th. steteoent just i-.de by the (.fen :.nt, from uy fecunent bo1 -nron; but 1 cannot Sec wh translate ’ it, th e-fite’ it, who • a- - personal pini n 'n it. I .. net know whether # that is whatras cal in n lar. , r.clly. G-many - is in 1936, unier th. Hitl r rcoirvj, Th- fficial public a ti- ns *-r- - :.v.mt: by prrpaf "Jiia, and I an unable t 3 ay that what is sal*, t have happen-', in En lan , really happened in ?ji 1 a. . This is by n r. ans in .n li3h publication. D?., -'v “GHi-.SMs r. President, w G-mans ore f c urse, dtpen- Icnt cn the public .ti its iv-.n tc us by th. c moo tent auth rities. I point ut that this is a * rk call. ’, U G man Justice-" aitainistratirn of justice .n 1 - 1 p licy, which t s air. r. fficial paper, issue, by h- fteich Inist^r f Justice, Or. Guirtner, n. t by Schle <-}b-.r -r. Th n :n basis ' r.p-rts r c Iv. 1 fro n lish newspapers, this pu¬ blic ..tin points cut that in En 1 r.: ther. were f forts, Iscussicns, Eeetin 3, Ji S' rth. Precisely b. cruse I its year r publication, 193 , tiz h.n there m 1 no i a ei Lu.h n.si in QaorJVt it essenti.l tr CCR’ im th. V-sti -ny of th- witness- Brack, by 5eeSS ! 15 ay-rw-GJ-l6-b-3i :lsi-(r:nSchcnJ- Ccurt 1 the f'.ct that three, years bef,r-- there -xisted similar efforts in -ther ccuntries. Th_r .1 r_, 1 ask that the objection of th. presc- cuti n hot bj unh-le’. 7632 15 ifayH'.-:2-17-i-Grosa (Int. Brown) Court Ko. I. JI^GS SS3P.2C: Witness, your attorney had referred to 3rack Exhibit Ho. 32, appearing on pege 16 cf the Brack Document Book II, in English. Are you familiar with that exhibit? A Yes. JUDGE SE3RIJJG: When is tho first tire the- text matter that appears in Brack D:cur^nt Ho. 32 caiu to your attention? A This is tho first tine that I rccoivod the docurent. From py studies cf literature >-hlch I spoko of at thj boginning of ry testi¬ mony, but frea what individual pieces of literature I do net recall, I knew tho writings of I/ird Monoyhon who was tho representative of 3uch a movonwnt. I knot: that in Enplane such bills have got as far as Par liam e n t and in ay pru-intorraction I stated, .and Prosocution vrill have to corroborate this, that I brought his attention to tho English efforts ir. tho quortion of Euthannsi-. I did that at a tine that I havo not had tho opportunity sirco f.vjn to soo this d~cuncnt. TPS PRESIDENT* The objection to this be inf uffored in ovid- oncu is sustainod. The docirvat -'ill not bo rocaivod in ovidunce. Si Dfl. FRGESCH AIOJ* Q Ttan, I shall dispense with putting in D'eununt 31 in Docu¬ ment 3ook II which is an article frea tho Tires. A I bo j y-.ur pardon, I thought tho President docidod tho decunont w.’.s accupted in cvidonco. THE PRESIDENT: Ctojceti n was sustained. Tho docurent will not be rccoivod in ovid.nco. 31 D?., Fr r BSCH- iAfflf* Q I/itnoss, you just rr.sw-rad in t.ha iffirr.ativo tho question that, in yc'-r opinion, th. Statu has tho ri ht t. pass Lavs that incur¬ able -or.toliy ill parsons shall bo given a earcy death. Did you assuao tho sore in Hitler*s cast? A Yes. Hitler ,t~.c Chief of State in Germany. I spoko about that this r-min and I sh:ul*. assure that Hitler know of this basic work by Hindis;-fioche and concurred in their cpini n, and arrogated t Mr- 7633 15 ' - 17-2-Or _ ss (Int. 3ram) Const lie* I. self tho right tc mate ethical grounds and reason fj this decree; Q When a Chief cf State gathers all the powers of the State into his wn hands can, in ycur opinion, a Chief of St-to that is not a government consisting, that is tc sry, f -any persons but one singlo Chief f State, decide what is right cad what is wrong? A Yes. That is the sarjo situation that crists in any absolute oonorchy whore the king decides unilaterally what is ri«.ht and what is wr ru_. Q Mo* there is an othicrl standard that stands abive all States. Should not a Chief of Stato tako re: .rd for this ethical world or'lor r/hen docidinr what is rirht and trhat is wrong? A Yes, he should, but opinion is di'/idod about the justifi¬ ability .-f Euthanasia in tho wh-lo world end it cannot bo said that outh.an.-sia is repudiated by tho majority of humanity; ncr c.-n it bo said that it is accoptod by tho majority in Gorrv-ny. At any r.ato it could bu assured that a largo port ^f t!x> population oharod that opinion .-.id for vory concerto reasons. I should liko to .aoruino that tho majority f the cr-up boliov-.-! in tho justifiability cf tho moasvro .and this was justification for tho Chiof f Stato passing such a low* Q Thoa, S'.' far as y. u c-n judgo, fren tho legal point of view did you havo nis/ivings about tho directive, the entry, .and tho irnplo- nontation cf this decree and did you bolicvo that y. u wore n t acting in anything that was illognl? A I believed in tho .absolute justifiability of that decree for outhoi incod of its logoi justification. Q .fitness, you are not yourself a doctor but you arc tho son of a doctor and you havo discussed tho rcbla: of euthanasia with #rony -lectors, how did you yourself see the .-roblo:i of euthanasia frost tho point of view of nodical professional othi.es? A As a layr.an and non—’.cctor, I really can say nothing about that. Or. the basis of literature and of conversations vith doctors I could only forr. ny own opinion abo-.it that natter. Re. arding radical 7o3/i 1 15 lfey-A-% - -i? -3-Cros s (Ir.t. Beotoi) Court . o. I. ethics I cannot testify oven if there is rny such thing as special nedicai otliics at all and if not a part of ethics as a whole. Certain¬ ly a doctor should see as his highest goal tto. aid for the patient and tho effort to ac.ro the patient * s lifo. This obligation and effort on the part of the doctor must not, however, bo exaggerated. Ttoso of- forta -and this obligation find ttoir nr.tural lir.it:,tions where tlioro.apy is no longer possible and when tho further existence of such a patient is of no real si nificance. Q You rish to assure We conception of euthanasia for i.ncur- ablo patients as a whole? A I Bust say frankly that after I have thought about this euthanasia probloa I thought of it only in connection with incurable nontally ill persons and vy answers havo related only to that partic¬ ular field. Q Then, I soc frer. your answers that you Seo a diffcronco euthanasia for incurable cunt ally ill parsons and outhanasin for por- Bons who havo incurable physical illnocs. Now lot no ark tills quito generally in tho case of an insane porson, is not his rill to livo broken against hie will? A It is possible that an ins-.iv. orson will retains a spark or will to live but every other living bo in- has tho earo. Tho question of tho case in an insane .\jrron is whothor ho i3 livin a life that is dignified or unworthy to bo lived. Q Then what do you think should bo clono with sich .a life that is not worthy of being lived? A The i:tcur blc rxjnt-liy ill person, so far as I havo scon and observed such persons nysolf, is frea the point of view of a*xcental¬ ly healthy -arson a seriously suff«.ri.. and hopolossly lost cn."turu. He is 3inply a wrotetod reminder of what w-’s once a wholo ran. In the opinion of psychiatric rcioncc a:*? in tho opinion of philosophers thero are c‘*f fcr_nccs of opitoor. as to rrh.ot .cr oo\H .nd spirit have actually ted or whet or they hare .. only concealed by tho ill no sh. Ilor- 7635 15 lay—A-. Ji-IT-ii-^Sross (Int. Brown) Court .'O. I. aver, on the whole, tteso creatures are persons who have lost the last remnant of contact with real life. Q That is your opinion about the relations between tic phy¬ sician and the rent ally ill persons under his care? 15 raj 1 7-..-..~>-i6-l- irro* (Ir... ro.-r.) Court HO. 1 The life of 6 hi insene arson nas, for hlisalf ar.’. for his ral'-ives, lost -11 purpose, an I corals ts only of pain an' uisory. just -_s the soul melon s in th: hclpin hands of tho priest, so the holy beloa 2 in the b-lpin hen's of tho -hysician. Only sc can tho sick ./man really ho assist© in that oaso, however, this :aeans for tho 'octcr that his *uties, particularly in view of tho arson’s spiritual • - state - it is his duty to free tho parson fron his urrrorthy con 'ltion or, - I ni ht ovoy say, - fro- his prison. 1 In your opinion, what const ’.orations shoul*. novo tho ’octor to r:co-non ’ euthanasia? 9 . Tho aotivoa would ’.v.vo to ho ur-ly nw*icel an’ coul only bo on aot t. I should liko to soy that h: mh>s hL-solf thj vjhiclo or a nor© exalte t lovo of .ondrospaot for humanity, Thsro ai=t bo no rr.torial -otives. 0 If Jurists rant a certain 1. al rl ht for octorn to comit euthanasia, horr shoal:' thoy treat this -.tatter? If tho . .tiont is ra- Uy honolossly incurable, that cannot b.) loci'!’ by a Ju ’ -o, only by thi ’octor, an, it is only suoh conditions that cono into question in tho question cf euthanasia.... THS (Intern ): Counsel, it soons to fcho Tribunal -hr.t ' he ithess has statj.l his hil schical i toao at suffici ont ox tent, unloos yc-u hnvo ono or two noro definite questions alor. that lino. *y D'.. n: v/sr 1 Coul' not tho 'octcr err? . s lr a*V -i’, "to err i3 human." for , ns a l:y-v>n, x. .rt's .or :c : list's scrutiny an’ observation of th. -atient he’, to suffice. , Q itness, ym r.-.v: 'v-j: l of co l.intr on th- ,*rt of the church, an’ noreovar, you were reared as belie. as it laiown in 1939 that... IT "T: (Intc-T - :; tin ): Counsel, I think further oxasd- ation ^Icr, • those oneral linos is not -nli htadn- to tik fribunal. you r, ny other questions alon; more direct linos to rc.-jur.' to the witness? 7637 15 "-ay ^7-..--.H>-ie-2-SarroTr (Ir.t. ~rowr.) Ceurt He. 1 DR. FriiHSCKT. V: "r. Pros!'.’.ant, I wished only to ask tho witness Mother, in treatin'; this probloB, to had reli-icus rls ivin a and whether tho religious rAn ivin-.s th t vre expressed to hin by others vroro taker, into his sensi oration. That was tho purpose of this question. THF. raSSHEh:* You nay a3k tJ> witness that question, nr D~. proses :jh : Q ' itne33, you havu hoard of th? objections of Church. I renin! you . srticularly of th: a. 11 cations by the Sjdscopatas of Colo - 710 , Fadorborn an’ . unich, fho Insisted that tho sanctity of hunan lifo mat, as Uvlno law, under all circunstancos, bo observ . !tow, I ask you, * 1 1 you concern yourself with this iroblen am* ho , vory briefly, 4' you justify th? fact that euthanasia was nevertheless carried out? A Kron th. rcli ious oint of view, killin is, in itself, not an evil act. It ipor.’s what the reasons for it are. Under aono circun- stancoe, tho roason for tho killin can mko a rood not of tho killin . An unjustified killin'* -rill not swot ’4th approval in tho eyes of Qoi. «to’Jt as He avo lif., Ho car. also tak it sway through hurnns. Thu Fifth Coman'•ant "Thou 3 halt novor kill" but sinply says "Thou shalt net kill". In certain s.ocific c-ason, for instance, in war, in tho xocutin of capital scr.tuneos, an lately, th killin of an unborn chil* to save th lifo of to.::othar, thoso are -all cases of a spoolal sort, and it is a question «both r a 'rillin is justified or not, j; en'in on tho s ocific caso* 'l “i J you ov-r ’iscuss thoso questions noro elaborately '4 th Catholic thoolo ions? TH . FRSSUE:rr: Counsel, tho Tribunal fin 's no profit in these farther questions alon, this lino, unless you have so-io noro definite Tactical questions to propound. w tp. rprrscT ash* 1 Th-jn I shall turn to the last chapter which rust bo treated ’lely fr~n th. • oint cf vi of th rosecuticn. The . resccutior. charrcs . w: that, by yirticii -atin in t v. euthanasia pro rs;:, you ccrittc-* crin.rs 7638 1? ::-y ii7—.i-^TD-0.2—3-Serrcrr (Ir.t. Brown) Court ffc; 1 i ainst humanity. Wow, fron the point of view of humanity, what 'o you have to say to this char 3 by the prosecution? - The word "hunanity" naans a heartfelt participation in tho niff rlnj-s of others. Syr. ethy an hilpful actions arise fron this f clin of huranonoss. ’Jo , all of those feelin s apply in the case of euthanasia. Q Tou have frequently usod tho wor'a "sympathy for the pationt" in ycur testimony. Sympathy dth a sic!: person, was this on*» of the points of vie - that roved you to .varttcipato in tho euthanasia program an' a' a you affirn the .urposo fron tho othical point of view? A For no, sympathy for th., sick person wau tho *oci3ivo con- si .’.oration that 'ocilod whothjr or not I nffimud tho principle of euthanasia. 1 Di t you consider it correct an' U»cont fron tho J:u:aan point of view to sparo a ids persons Ion years behind tolls, or 11 you con¬ sider it nore Worthy to short ;n thi3 life throu h a :-.orcy 'oath? .. I saw this not only aotariaivjly uirorthy, but as huartloss, to loav theeo poor cr> ."or yours an ya r . t is not, livin any Ion .r - vt they :• ‘oin in th<;ro, 1 j.r. nor t'v. last question, "on sal’ before that tho ins an o : rson is still a v.n ' o -1 .t yjt '-.vo a certain till to live. This will to live is broken by what t!io *.octor wrier toko 8 in outhanasia. Now, at /.o tin that t/iosc thin 3 -re oin. on, lid you have sono notions in your rdn' about this fill to live? hon on saw t’.v.so sick or sons or. coul ’ roa'ily cja that thera was no 7.111 to live in t:» ., \ut orr» ha * to rc-i. r.b'jr that at one tin thosa j-.oplo ha* b»n healthy an' ha* a rill of thoir c.mb-.n’ this, their forr.cr "ill, ha to bo th-, basis for th ’ceisicn whether outhanasia was to • -iso * in th caso rr not. '.h hor.lthy rson, '.then ho sacs thosj wretched crcaturos, rcil ..-core such a person Mnsolf, and What j .«• ourc.lv.s i * di .Vo vo car. a33U2>j is ,.a wish "Iso on th part of t'i sic rson . ro he as .as fomarly, healthy, so.that h could 7639 15 'ay -Io-ii-Mantr..* (Ir.^. 3rom) Court So. 1 for.’ a healthy Jud'aent. If the sick >atient was in a osition to rceor- rdxo the situation in which ho fin ’3 hiaself, ho hinself woul* ho- to that, condition star toned. ifcucver, the nature of tho ’is case rovont3 liin Crer. '’oin- that. These wore all tho various considerations that led no to r.ffiir. the principle of r.uthanasia. 1 ..n‘ ;-ou rcr. ifost conclusion fro- these considerations? .v I ted 'iy\ that these peoolo should be roloascd fron their toriontoi condition. } Now, one last question, Thi3 was your point of view which wo have tr^atcl hire in a aonerhat ibri’ :o fora. Mi thoso thou hts novo you Uioply at that tine? .. Too, of courcej they til bocauso it is no trivial mttor to foric on a mttor, ovan if ycu aro or 'orot! to, rhir. it ia a nattor of lifo and ’.oath for p-a-sons who usot to bo hoalthy, but I have Just told you .rhjr I bolijvo! that I was Justified in this, norally as well as 1 illy, ml bo&auae th .00 thru, hta novo : jo 90 roatly I a’ tv\ tod to •a!:any. I rocoivad a nanvscript which, to bo sure, could not bo U3ed in that fora but caul ’ bo revised. The filn conpany rocomendod a . ood ircetor Kerr Lieboneinon to :o an'. I asked hir. to be of assistance in ‘ratlin u; the book f<-r this filn in such a ray as to mho it public iocuBoion so that on coul' tVn clearly ’.cci !o whether wo had^hrsuod corroct , ath or rhoti r 'dtl r fc> ' issue : 1 false order. Tho success of th filr , not only ir. ’or>li n ccur.tri >s -jcausc of its artistic <•ir-lity, Cut also within •- many, proved to 30 that the majority o« poqaLo aro in thanasi t on! duo their own convictions, r-j .ct it. T’iis 'iln •" ..ccuso", as I was I ter tol ’ by tho filn corrjvany 7640 15 :ty l;7-.'.-..TD-l8-^Xnrroir (Int. Srosn) Court to. 1 ’.'oc tbo filn that *as nost frequently played of all those they had pro ucc U Thfl latt.rs thr.t roachec- the filn company regardln this filn, I asked for fro™ the filn cc^pary; nare than 90? of thoo were en¬ thusiastically in favor an" only a few rare arainst it. 15 ' '-'v-..- 19-1-iIaloy (Int. Erown) Cciart ->o. I. Q fitness, one last question, did you sun up your thoughts in fcho find words of the file spoken by tlw defendant Dr. Hcidt in the fila, wore those thoughts that he spoke yours? A Yos. V.e were,_ unfortunately, not able to get hold of tho scenario. Otherwise wo could have showed it to tho Court. DR. FftCESCK”X‘i’]J: ''r. President, I intend now to put in ono lost affidavit f roc Supplementary Document Book Ho. 3, Doc urgent Ij6, rage 1. Hovnvor, I greatly fonr that Supplementary Voluno 3 is still not in tho hands of the Tribunal. I Just hoar that it is not yot ready. THE PRESIDENT i Tho book is not yot roady, but counsel any of for tho docu-ont when the book is boforo tbo Tribunal. Tint riht will bo reserved to hi:. OK. PitCESCKWiXi Thon in this collection I offer Brack .Ex¬ hibit 39, th- affidavit of iiobciwi:*. r, 2eth of April 192,7, si nod by hir. on that into. TIE rRESIDEJIT: Counsel, in what document book Is tint ox- hibit to bo found? )... FRCESCHX'ANHj That is in Su?pla?ant-ry Voluno Book 3 on pn;o 1. I of/ur it as Brack Doctcxmt 1:6. :a. HCCKJ.A U)t Counsel, that is tho document book rrhich is lacking. :'a do not havu that doc\raor.t book. Dl. F XSSGffAMNt Yes, I understand tho President to say I eight put it in now. THE HiSSIDENT: I said I rosorvod tho ri. ht to you to put it in when the locxuont is prepared. BA. PKCESCHTAKH* lot e say briefly that this doeuiiRt dos- criboc tho no .otiations between tlw defendant Pr-ck and tho director at that tii.'. Vihon the Tribunal has this supple;ontary Document Book I shall return to this doc'rccnt and ask that the ri ht to do so my bo reserved to -:c. T.z: PRESIDE: .7: Yos Counsel. And J you desire to do so you 7tL2 15 *ay-A—’ 3-1J-2—' r m2o> (Int. Rrcwrr) Court Ko. X. may then ex-nine the defendant upon this document. It is not your fault that the document is not hero new and every right corrected with that will bo preserved to you until this document book is ready and before the Tribunal, DR. PaCESCSSjnis Thank you. Q VJitnoss, ona last cnvrsticn. You Jravc hoard the point of view expressed by the Court. i> peaking in your own defense nor; then what do you say as to the unjustifiability of tho charge of tbo participation in tiro outhanasia program; ner„ you guilty of crir*s a~-inst humanity? A In my actions and in my attitudo the definitive consideration was pity for the sick person. Tho pationt was to be helped — TIB FRESIDEIC: Counsel, I m at loss to interrupt you. I don't want to curb tho witness, but tho witness has been over this * round again and n, ain, and in your briof and in your final acrutaont you \d 11 have tho opportunity to go over those things, and at tiro closo of tho csso tho witness himself . ay make a statoaunt. DR. FRCESCHHAUNx hrosidont, I simply wanted in conclusion to havo an answer to ny quostion from hi-, whothor ho boliwvos that tho tray in which euthanasia was carriod out and tho methods used in killing millions of human beings, whotljor tho kncrrlodr.o of these things had any effect of his attitudo toward outhanasia. I singly want to know what his reaction was to that. That is igr last quostion. THE xUSSIDEl.T: Tto witnosc raa j have three minutes to ox; r,63 that. A (continued) I ion't w nt throe irinutos. I fool that the charge of inhuiane activity on cy port because I took part in outhanasia, I fool that this is unjustified because euthanasia Or tho fora tlct I iiavy laseribed is so: retiring that has nothing to do with what others did in misusing euthanasia. DR. FTESCH AliRx :s*. rresido-it, nc further questions. T1 1. IS ID El .T: The Tribunal lias some questions to propound to the witness 15 :iay«A—.r—I9-3-Jlaloj (In*-. Ircwn) Court :'o. I. BY JUDG1 c£3?-IhG: Q Ti'itrwss, when adult persons wore selected for euthanasia and sent by the transport to euthanasia stations for that purpose by what stthods wore the mercy deaths giver.? 1 The patients went to a euthanasia institution after tho writ ton formalities wore dona which I need not repeat here, namely physical oxmination, comparison of tho files, otc. Then thi patients were load to a gas chamber and thcro wore killed by the gas carbon ocnoxido (CO) by tho doctor. Q hnere was that carbon nonoxido obtained, by what procoss? A It was in a cooprossoi gas contained, such ns ccuprocsod oxyron or atsothylon is kept in fer wolding a big container. Q And those pcoplo w_j-c placed in this chamber in groups, I suppose, and then tho conoxidu was turned into tho chanbors? A ftorhaps I better dcscribo this in sore detail; Bouhlorjnbor those r.onths. Bouhler, Conti, and I don't knew who olao, thcro wore r. few othor doctors for tho first tiso saw this being deno, and on tlw basis cf this oxrorin;nt '.iitlor decided that only carbon Bonozido was to bo used for killing the patients. I 7&*5 15 iy U7-»-T»TB-20-l-:‘eoh£n (Int. brown) Court Ho- 1 q -Tall no-.-, before or after that tine bad you tried any other -assoa or any other naans of a tir&starin Euthanasia to these people? „ '.k>, we - and by that T :*nr. doubler's oryanization - never used any other - as or other mans. Q You round the carbon r.onaxy le quite satisfactory, so you never ha' to resort to any other n.-ns? A Yes, you can put it that way. q How, nh.ro was it that those four people wore .accorded the priviloaa of a uorcy '.oath in December, 1939 or 19! 0? A That was in tha first Euthanasia station in Prnn'onbur”. Q An'. 'ncn? A ?'on. q All r.on. 'hat roro thoir : as, rroro they youn aen, rdddle p. -o’. r>’n or ol J .orly :.»n; ha; -ul.* ya: classify then? A T really 'ont ro:.j-'b*r that. a -n: t can you sr.y in ro'-r! to th-dr nationality} lo you knov; anythin about that? .. 7hzy oust have boon C- jrr.ans, they coul ' not bo anythin • but Oar-vans, because -cccr In- to re ulations only Geraan .ion tally ill persons wore use in Euthanasia- Q And you cay Hitler was thcro? A Ho, Hitler was not there- Pouhlor was there, q Bouhlor? -e, Conti was there ’ bdiOTO "ranIt, q Karl Aren't? A Too, Karl "ran ‘ t. a jc -r V r - r :iy ef V'.. other *efononis who were tlwrof .. Of a *af baats ore, certainly nona was resent ‘excepting myself. 7t46 15 !fcy L7-..—..TE-2C-2— Kachan (Int. Brown) Court Sc. 1 Q -oil, thin you ra&jMp that yra, Bouhler, Conti and Karl Brcndt were tb-roj r.r: o yax rc:::-bor ~r.y of th other rrentlomen thoro at the tine? A Yes, I said there were sono more doctors thero, but none of the defendants hero. 1 Dr. rfannraxeiler, perhaps? A !»o. Dr. FfanxsueUer was certainly not thoro. They nust have boon Berlin doctors* Q 'hen after T'occnbor of 1939 or January of 19hO vns it that you ar'ain witnessed a Euthanasia procedure? A I shjul l say that in tho course of the yoar of 19U0 in nil tho Euthanasia institutions oxistin at that tioo, I personally assured nysolf that tho duthanasia ina ’ cin- correctly carried out or.co or twico, but I boll a vo I recollect thr.t tho Instituto Ifadanar was only set up in 19fel and in that yoer I ’i not soo Euthanasia boin? carried out, thnt roul-' J.inir.ato thj Instituto -adamr. 'l Tho Instituto at Hadojvxr, I think you said thoro were fivo otter stations? A Yes, thoro woro six alto-.othor. q So that Yxrin tho yoar 19U0, you assured yourself that each of tho Tivo stations on , .rhaps one, taro or perhaps norn visits that tho procu hire, insisted upon by Bcuhlar, was boin carried out in a hunano manner, in a ainloss ramor by carbon nonoxydo? A Completely unnoticoablo. q And now rho wore tho peoplo... .lot no put it this ir.yj tho first tico -at Eran-'an l ur< thero were four poorL-, all non? A 103. q Xo~, 'an ycu -r3r on your subsoquont visits in 19kO to tho otter Euthanasia stations ho the ;oople were; non or ^onen? A Beta, js --n in' soa*ti_aos wosjtm. a _.r. ’ .ali.at car. ycu say in ri -r! to their nationality? .v I car. only say that those were only Gomans, bccauso I am perfectly convinced that Ecuhlor's re ulaticns, which rested on an order 15 -7-..-..73-2C—3-liaefcan (Ir.t. rear.) Court :io. 1 frc:a :5 tier, namely that no foroi ners mere to bo riven Euthanasia, -era observe! strictly by all t»ij Euthanasia institutions. 'I "here wro these stations located, witness? A I don*t wn ’erstani That you .moan, whero they were? In what fart of Gerviny or in what port of Poland, or in what part of Csecho Slovakia, in what part of tho Protectorate of Bohonin- ’’ora via, in what part of Derrwrk, in what Part of Holland, in what part of France and in what port of ’luropo w&ro those stations located? A Hov I understand you correctly. The first one ran in Brandoribure on the Havel in the noi hborhood of Berlin about ?0 or 80 kilometers any, Tho no:.t wr.3 the Institute Graf.-neck, that wr.s in Wirttombor . /.r/ether institution .-as Sonnonstoin and that is noor Pirns near Eros ion. There was t:» Institute rthaln which vtas noor Lina on tho r -rub.j which was in Austria. Than thero was tho Instituto Bcrnhurr on tha Sa-.io lUvor near Dessau* hoar is in Hessen* Q >.ro any of thoso stations looatol in that .ortion of Poland, rhich to s occupio i by tho C-orans in .-dlitary occupation? A Ho. Q An’ th-i six stations you have Just nano I woro all tho station*) known to you that ads to j thero roro just six? A Thoso woro tho only one3, yea. o Htncse, can you npproxi.vito th xepulation of Oormny as it axis tel in the y.r.r of 1939 or tho year of 19fc0? "ora thero soro fifty or sixty million people? A ?.’o, rou hly flight? to oijhty fivo million. q Harr by that rhon you say oi nty to I.hty fivo iLilion, you inelu’o tho entire '’•or an Saleh, ir.du lin Austria, tha SacUfconlanl an’, th: occupied tarritory? .. .ustre a and the "•id ft dan but not the occuplod territory. q ,.r. u ;s-ir.etj rw hly 'h-ro - re i.-hty five million people? A I os. 7<*6 ; 15 .7-- Z y: rt :*o. 1 Q Of that oi-Wy fivo -illion, hsr: -any Jows would you say woro livin' ir. G^raany at the tl-e who wero German nationals? « Maybe two or three Billion. q Tc«:r9 talkin' not* about the Greater Goman ?.eich, including Austria in ! the Sidotonl&ni ? A Yes. q You astir.' 1 .to there vmro bobtrecn two or throo Billion who were Goman nationals? A Rou'hly, yea, r i !Iar with tsro or three rdilion Gsrrain Jews :untl naatail into the G or ran Topulr.tion of oi hty fivo Billion oooplo, who were Cm min nationals, explain, if you */l- , to *.’k Tribunal *-hy it res that tho Goroon Jews truro exclude l fron tiw Euthanasia program, if an you say it was a s iutary pro rau accorUn to ;iooplo tlw priviloyo of a norcy oath for takin then out of thoir nlsoryj why was it that the 0 «man Jaws w.,ra not includel ir. tint pro ran? .. I hove already sal*, that. As -outlier uxplaino ! it, tho philanthropic act of Cutbanaola should bo ranted only to Homans • q lun ’oratin’, that, hut I thou ht you sal-’, at that tine thoro •roro h.ttw, n two in*’ tftre j dllion Gomans In Oemany, Gonvin citizens ./ho tfors Jcwre? A Yos, that is so. Q hy •.:aro thoy not include ’ in tho oroTam, if tho riviloro of Vvi pro- rn was oir. to ho accor ?od to ill Osmans? .. rhf; roason possibly lios in tho fict that tho Go varment ttd not .ant to .rint this philanthropic act to ths Jews, n Thsy wanted to rant this philanthropic ict to all Aryan Cur.-.“.ns, but 11 * not • to rant it to 0 man Jows an:' thy 1' not ant to -not this hilintbropic act to (hron sol 'iers of tho first war, -.tion of tto Defendants Oobhardt and Coorh'usor, absent duo to illness. TIC rajSJDENri ?ho Socrotary-Ooncral *111 notu for tho record tho presence of all Wv. dofo i dents in Court cave the Defendants Oobhardt and Cfoorhausar. Tho Tribunal has cortificatos from tho prison surgeon certifying that Djforvdontc Oobhardt and Cteorhouscr are unable to attond court on account of illness. Pursuant to thoso oertiflector, those do- fondants -.till bo !arch too, I don't know. Q And you think that Hadaaar was tho last ono that wac cot up? A I <13 quite cortain that Hadaaar was tho last ono. Q How, of what materials woro thoco gas chamborr built? VToro they movable gas chanters very much liko tho low pressure chanters that Professor Dr. Ruff talked about, or woro they something that woro built pornanor.tly into tho conp or installation? A Ho special gas chaster was built. A room suitablu in tho planning of tte hospital was used, a roon attached to tho reception «ard, and the roon where tte insane persons wore taken, whore they wuro kept. That was 'nado into a gas chamber. It was sealed, it was ;ivon special doors and windows, and thon a few motors of gas pipe woro laid, -crx) kind of pipe with holes in it. Outside of this rocn there was a "bottle, a compressed bottle, with tho necessary apparatus, njcecsary 7652 16 »v3y-c>i3-l*-3-Foetor (Int. Von -chor.) Court No- I. inatrasenta, a pressure gauge, etc. Q Now what department had the responsibility for coi*structing or building those gas chancers, ahat dopartnant of the party or of tho government? A No office of the party. I don't understand tho oucstion. Q Somebody had to build those chambers. Who gave tto orders and who had the responsibility of bui l ding thee., was that your deport¬ ment? A Tho orders, I assume, wore given by tho head of the in¬ stitution but I don't knew who actually -.avc tho orders. Q In other words, wore those chambers not build according to sono specifications, plans and specifications? A I can't Icagino that, ovory chamber wes different. I orrr oovural of then. q Do you know what dopartnont gave tho order for having tho chanters built? Soo that your dopartaont under Bouhlor? A No, tl«t was Pouhlor hlusolf. q Arid ho gavo thj order to tho various toads of ins tit ut ions to install this chaaber, is that correct? A Yoe. q How, how would the ho-.ds of each of those institutions !cnorr how to install a gas chamber unloss thero .roro certain plena and speci¬ fications givon to ttoc? 7653 15 ...y-fc-JP-3-l-Zarrcv (i-t. Ton Schon) Court I a. I never suv any such nlan. I don't haow of any. Vould you kuov now to go out and build a -a chamber unless si:- c . i.-.Cvr or planner h^d told you? Cort.dnly I wouldn't. -i. I don't anew whether I would u.iov it either, Procuucbly he culled on a uccha.-.lc. Z., ih.t'a »d*.at j'u trying to ouy. Vhut aochoaic or on .ineor or rov.y of o.i, • incurs Wwro rosnoneiolc for a coin, th-t tneoo.v..o oheubors uoro milt eo that they would do t..c joo they wore supposed to do? a. There w^s certainly not a .roue of y.vjin^ors. I presune th..t there was so-iobcdy at the institutions who had enough technic .1 ability to dc it. I don't know. Then, so f .r ai you .;..ov, sene one at one of these institutions ''T.\ld 00 told oy -fcounlcr to constrxt a .t cn^.oor ad ho would cell - tiio head of tho institution tnea would call on so..o one, you don't icnov vhcci, to , o out and build t..c chamber? Is that ocrroct? a. Thut la how X iuj^ino it. v -oil, wouldn't it aaico considerable difforunco vhothor tho c.m'ecr w..o to bo constructed for oithaUusi.. by Carton nonouido or by sotio other uo^ns? couldn't there nuv« to eo sone technic_l i.ifor-u>- tion available to the head of tx.e institution oo th-t he c uld .*lvo ir.ctloas to his aecfcar.ic to ouili tho thin, to do the thin; it was axrionui to do? a. I aust 8 c,v honestly I really don't -now any thine; bbttt thr.t. I cr-i't Jud,je. Do you Ihiov waotner or not an: - dopurt.-o.-.t of tno /.v.or.iaont, uador aovhlor, or undor droudt or under acyoody olso, v^s rotnonsiolc * for noein. th..t tho gas apparatus w„s Inst.lied pronerly? •s I don't . -|0V, but I dca't oolieve so because I would 'rob ,'ely nr.vo icnrd of it. How l_r ,e were taosc r-*c chambers? -a •:.-j wore of different sixes. It was siunly an ad^oi-in rood. 7654 16 ..c^..r-JP-2-a-S^rrcv (int. Ton Schon) Court I I o»'t reuaioer whether they wore 4x5 voters, or 5 x 6 voters. 5k >ly nonaal sizod root#, but I can't s.^’ tho ozjct sizo. It we too ion ego. I c_a't raiuibur. q. torn they «s lur^c* as tuia court roca? *w so, tney were Just aomul rocus. q. boll, u nun of your Intelligence oust kavo souo idea ,.bout t..e aizo of these roona. Ike u3fcrtion "noruul size" doesn't acan anythin, in particular. a. 3y th-t I no-n the eizo of tue norad roca in. e noraal heuso. I didn't i.wuQ on assembly roou or a cell uitnor. I iiuaht c roca, but I c.n't th*. ciz«. exactly ooc-uoo I really don't )aow it. It night n..vo b-ai 4x5 uetert, or 5 x 6 uutora, or 3? xtf, but I redly don't taiow. I didn't pay tmeh at.nation tc it. q. Have you eve) visited a concentration Ca.p or a uilifcaiy c.n or any kind? a. I visited » concentration canp, afti 2 v^s onco in a uilitn- ~ c.s> as a soldicr. Huvo you ever seen a shower roan or shovor b„th juilt into a c _n of tn„t kind vhuro the ixxietcs of concentration cj.jo, or wnoro soldiers in a uilit_ry oarr-cics, c*i ta,.o nhoworot a. Yuo, I huVb. In uy ovn Oarrucics. q. -nd voulc you s* tn-t t..ic euthanasia rooa at the various i;.st lent ions v_s about th-t diueasiont a. I think it VaS uuch S-.allor. q. toll, perils we c-n .;et ut it this way. I tuou.it Jurheps - cu :ac- eaaituinj -.oout tad accoonicul construction th..t ; oujposod everybody :aov so-otuin.; aaout. Ttia roan of yours that you t II: cl ".t, now —_v would it acc.cuuodatbt ^ Testard^ I s .id tn..s, accordin to uy estk-atc, it - i -t t. 4i tventy-five cr shirt, people. q. t is still ycur estimate to:’. •? I r<—i_ oorc< ; c tardcp* 7655 16 J?-2-5-2arrov (let. Von Schon) Court I tx.; you o-id that. and th-t is still your ogtiu-te today, tn..t it could caifortably t^cc c_re of twenty-five or tnirt y pooplsl Yen, th-t's -y estimate. 2. tow. Silo Carton uonoxido ,;as tn_t v„s used for tec vr^sc of axCluumsia where did it cev.e frx:? I Know you fluid ycster Do - ou K-.ov how tnco- rw-Cfcui -tAe c—u? Bo you Know whether any / op-rU-ent of tr.e -roverna-nt Wd» responsible for furnishing the c-* to t.,e c—p? rt, .o, tney wore nrobuoly bought. ... Y 0U tnlttSc taen th-t perh-oo the superintendent of tao ino- titution, if r.o rated so-« c-rben soaoxido »•-*. would Just Vain :.o-.'.;- to'.v. end v-lic into - store -nd buy - otevl tube of it and >ut it wider liin ..m and c-rry it on b-c< to tn. p.y for it out o: Mo lochot? .W Ho, not cut of uis cvn ooc/ct out tfcreu.>» tao institution. .ho institutions oou. at it, I uo-a. IHd you :,iov fro- • n-t rourcea t:.e institution acu at it? Yes. «U t.-.c funds c-.e fro., tr.e Hoieh ..iMstxy of the Interior. 7a o; ver -dv .need to M» oy tr.c ’urty treasurer. Veil, nev, at th-t ti-c. wasn't virtually ever;,thin i- „cr_h>y of a critic -1 n-ture on sa.o sort of riority? Do you un- dorst-x. what I ae;n? a. Ho. ;. lould not th- Aversion of t.ic Carbon uonoxido in tuooo *.-> .tne - r cut institutions have to Oe iwn - priority r .tin .uid . w O- bo— e one or ay o'_<- dea-rtuca* U tuo icov-nm-eit — tnus 765o 1: »7-2-4-2urrov (Ir.t. Vca SchonJ Cor rt I J»r~G OTuiluOlo tC the £08->it_l8f ./on't . ou understand vn..t I ae_n? ■»- Yes, I underst-nd. I h_vo no ie'Cj, but I don't oolicvc co. •*r t ^Qut v„a done vita tr.c oodles of the. people after Uwrc; doaths wore given? Vhen tno roo_ hod o«ca cloor-d cf ;_o ag-in town >ccnle c.*io in with .. stretcher and too* tuc orgies iat. ..n adjoinin.; roou raid t on t.ie : octor ex—.ined tiuc to determine vr.wtr.er they wore dead. .• Then va-t hmponed to the uocies? «• ' hoa the doctor hjd ascertained oath, he freed tr.c bodies for bur..iiu uiid tnon tr.oy wore burned. after h« n..d freed tr.c bodioo. n-d ficter-ined that thc^r uoro r o.. , t..w vert then cremated? Is that correct? •w Too. ,'isuro v a* - c. cu-tory ouilt for wvo.— oa» of tr.eoo institutions? a. Yos, creuatoriuuB wore built in tno iaetitutionp. "o you mo'- whether or not - vhut cwt.ent or n>ne;-, wither uiv.or the ovem-oat, that is, tnc Hole- ftovorrooat, or ur.’cr tho cu- u&rintwfx out of the v. rio- s institutions, vs retnoasiol- for t is ot .11 of cra-_tion? I don't uat.crst.,id, nouhler on'.or^. tr.o era a tin . Jflufclwr lore , ... principle, that h. .oc.iws vwr- to jo crw..w. nftor do..th. : .c.*w v .c no office for th»t. r. .b then, —v rx>o •. elude - -w too f c. th • certain lecolo, ”... Qj < i.en Gwl.ctwd for « ;tn—\o8ia, hj_ fin-11/ uTrivod .1 these* institutions, had -ctu-lly bc-oo _c corded tr.c rivile.u o. a^rcy ('oaths cr.<- tr.en flji been erected? A a. ho, I K.iO« note in. about th-t. ... ;o rvcor s v v re /:vpt at - 11 ? .a Ch, I thoutuf jo-, s-id reDorts. Jcv tcuuji rcc'^r s? 7-57 16 Hay^-JP-S-5-Zarrow (I-it. V 0 n Schon) Cor-Jt I ?. : don't core vaut you Call it. Inct c uust have o_on u rcjort or record of icl. kind - 58 . 16 Any ‘»7-^. 4 K-“-l-'!uloy-(Von 3c ho or.) Court 1 - Q. They were finally sent to Tlergorten Strasse 4? Yes. Q. Ian't It true that only In that way could an accur¬ ate redord or report of this program be made? A. I didn't understand whether this fact oroatod aooup- ate redord6 About the people, or whether records wore kept? Q. Records wer'e kept, were they not, of this entire transaction of eadh Individual from the tiro he was oxper- tl ted? a. Yes. Q. Until finally he was cremated? A. Yea. C. «nd those records were flllod wltn T-4? Yos, tnoy were kept there. Q. Now, I believe you said that those outhamela cham- bers wore built to reoemblo shower rooms? A. Yes, that'6 how I rerember It. Q. «nd the only people that were accordod euthanaola wero poople who wore lnourably lnoand, I think you oald? A. Yes. q. These wore people who, aa you put It, on ethloal grounds, did not hf-.ve the mor.tal capacity either to consent or to resist the decision to grant thorn euthanasia, and that consequently as you vlewod It, It was i humane proced¬ ure to accord them a meroy death; la that correct, did I understand you oorr3Ctly? A. Yes. Q. Now, were these people, the ones whom you saw, so insane as not to understand where they were or what was going on arouna them? I car. only say that of course I am not a doctor and not In a position to Judge the condition of such a 765 ? 16 Hay 47-M-K-'-3-lCaloy-(Von Schon) Court I patlont, but when I was at such institutions I myself saw that tho patients, inasfar as they wore able to walk, went into these chambers or rooms where they wore told to £0 without any objection ar.dsat down on the benohes there or lay down and were quite quiet. How far they oould reallzo where they were, I don't know, but I do know they ware not in any worried, but perfectly calm. Bouhler had ordered that the doctoro were to arrange It so that the patients would not realize what was being done to them. Q. :»nd that was the reason that tho gas chambers wore constructed to resemble shower rooms, I suppose? n. Yes. Q. *nd those people thought that they were going in to tar.o a shower oath? *. If any of thorn had any power of reasoning, he no doubt thought that. q. /ell now, were they taken Into tho shower rooms with their clothes cn, or were they nudo? A. No, they wore nude. % In evory case? a. fher.ever I saw it, yes. .md you said, I believe, yesterday that you witnes¬ sed perhaps seme 10 or 12 or 15 or 20 occasions when groups were accorded mercy deaths? a. No. I said that I was at each of the institutions, with tho exception of Hadamar, at least onoe, perhaps twice. Q. rtnd or. each occasion did you witness the according of a meroy death to a group? Yes. .iT.d I believe you said yesterday that seme of these 7660 16 Kay aK-’'- ''-Haloy- (Von Schon) Court 1 groups were adults, that some groups were non, other groups were women, and that on some occasions the groups were made up of both nan and women, Is that correct? Ho, I apparently did not express myself clearly. They were either men or women, out I saw both. Q. And you think perhaps ycu saw as many as 20 to 0 comfortably accommodated in the chamber? A. Yes, quite comfortably. There was plenty of room. BY THj£ PRZ6ID2HT: Q. 'fitness, will you please state -.gain briefly the reasons assigned In these various meetings which you at¬ tended for the establishment of this euthanasia Idea? A. T^oro wore various roasons. The first mootings which were called by Bouhlor wero not meetings of the experts. Bouhlor was there, and doctors, and Jurists or administrative officials, whoa Bouhler called as a coun¬ cil of oxports In order to determine what was to be done. I don't wont you to go into detail, but toll mo the reasons that wore assigned at the various meetings for the establishment of this idea? A. «t the mooting of exports the experts were asked to ilsouas questions of evaluating the questionnaires, purely medical questions; how the various dlseisej had to bo Judged, and so forth. Q. But at these meetings, what reasons were advancod In favor of or against the establishment of euthanasia as a practice in Germany at that time; I dor.' t mean the mechanical details of operation, but the roasons for or against the establishment of the practice; wore there any? Of course the Justification for euthanasia '-as dis¬ cussed, but, as far as I can remember, only by the >artlc- lpant3 ir. the meeting recognizln-' the need for it. 7i«l 16 ..ay ■»?--•Y-' I —4-haloy-( Von Schon) Court 1 Q. feat reasons did the;.* Ive for recognizing the need ior it? a. Different people had different reasons. A doctor has medical reasons, and a layman like Bouhler, for example, has reasons of a purely r.umanc nature. Q. /ell, what were these reasons that ware idvincel besides that of a humane nature? I don't ltr.ow any other reasons. C*. The only basis, then that you heard mentioned a3 a foundation for the cat lollsluent of outhanaaia va3 simply the humane Idea that It would benefit the insa-.e people, la that correct? .w Yes. Q. You heard no otner reason advanced at all. I did not hear any othjr reasons. Q. .'as It ovor sweated that it was advisable as a war measure? Ho, nobody suggested th»t. Q. Had you ovor heard of the Uoa cr of the practice of the ldoa before It vis ilrst 9u,;.'Ostod as v u hive testifi¬ ed; v. er, was It you first hoard of this Drograr? . 1 . /hen Bouhler told so acout It. Q. .ibout vhat date was that? That was m the sux.er of lt^, either July or Au¬ gust. •i. Had you ever heard of e.thonasla before that time? . ; hy-W:.-5-l-L«-rd (Lit. Von Schon) Ccu-t :.'o. 7. A Thoro was not a single order in that fora. It ms t.io re¬ sult of examinations by variouc systems, and the sun of those examina¬ tions and checks ms what Hitler had wanted with his order. Q .roll, these questionnaires that were signed by tho doctors must have gono scco where for final action, did they not? A Yos. Q T.’horu did they go? A Tiber. the exerts and tlio chief extorts had finished with the questionnaires, and the patients had undergone their period of observa¬ tion, thon tho questionnaires c.tvd, tilth thi transfer list of tho J-inie- try of Intorior, to tho euthanasia institutions. Q That is Ticrgarton Strasso 1 tion? nL. P.iioIDhirr: Well, tho .lan which has bo-n followed is that counsel for defendant may re-wXar.in tho witness after 11 tho Prosecution has been conducted. You ‘..ill h 1 V 0 tho "1‘ht to re-examine the witness after‘the Prosecution has 'ross-examined the witness. I would sujpost, however, 7675 i5----3X-5-3-1.„loy (In-, ikcsnler) Court No. 1 Counsol: tho Tribunal now hc.3 your Supplement No. 3, - Document 3ook 3, your supplement; and I chink it would make for orderly procedure if counsel would introduce the documents in evidence now. D * ; * ?-*°-5SCaU2W: Yes, Your Honor. Mr. President, in tho 3U * ! * ^mentation of my submission of evidence I now submit tho following documents contained in ay o u _ element Hoi 3 : Document 48, to bo found or. poje 15. This is m affidavit -• Dr. nod. ./altar Schultzo. It boars the date of ... ril •:s, 1947, and it was sijnid by hia and certified by no. I offer this document as Brack Exhibit 39. I dispense with read in" this document, and I should like to ask the Tribunal to tike notico of its contents. The accum-nt con¬ tains a factual doscri.tion of tho knowledge which Schultzo hA8 reined on the basis of his personal icquaintanoo with tho defendant, nn'd speaks about Brack's personality. I should not like now to road anythin; about the dofondant's personality. I should further like to offer Document 49 oa J0 19 * ?his is - certified copy fror. the book of Dr. Kogan, who has been hoard here cs a witness. Tho book is entitled The SS 3t..te. 1 ' I have included here only u sentence taken from page 229 of that book. I offer this Jocunont r.s Exhibit 40- I h .vc the book available here. I w,-.s not in a position to jet the necessary . hoto3t._t copies since yesterday afternoon. I sh..ll submit those ho tost at co. ies soon, and in the meant ii* I h .vo handed a c-rtified pyotostnt co. y of th-.t book to th_ General Socrotary. I offer that document is Exhibit 40. It confirms fact of whiQh tho dofdndant Brack has already s. ok~n, that on the occasion of ..dolf Hitler's 5Cth birthday in tho r 193? about 2300 prisoners were released from Buchonwald lono * 7his 13 one of the so-called densities of which the -~f end ant Brack was spe kin;;. 7676 ::-y i 6 -::- 2 K-s-^-c: .xoy (int. -tanrhUr) Court No. 1 Furthermore, I offer Docum-nt 30 which is to b- found on ,ijo 20 of ny su.iploCentol volume. .Hare I should like to ask for some clarification on tho ..art of the Tribunal or the Prosecution. Oocucent 1696-P3, Sxhibit 357, which .a submitted by tho Prosocution as a document but which does not contain that particular ; ijo which I an submitting. This pa^o, which is not contained in the Prosecution document, I have on ay part subr.ittod to tho Tribunal in order to clarify tho situation to the Tribunal and support my oaso• I ask for the docision of tho Tribunal whether I should ndcl on exhibit number to that docunont or Mother it i3 cuffiolent to road it horo. :;:i. HQCK....LD: If Your Honors . lease, in th- . hotost-.t ro. y which is in tho bands of the Prosecution, thl3 pa-jo is r. p-.rt of the document. Of course, I can not say whether this . ;3o is also in the copy which was h-nded the Tribun- el as .in exhibit, but anyhow wo ajr-o th .t this is certain¬ ly p rt of tho docunont, so I do not think it nuoossory that Defense Counsel jiv- this pajo Defendant Brook negotiated about this filM which has b. n ntioned. Tho diroctor of tlxj film at lira ed when Brack had not appeared yot. Then ho hoard that tho Chancellory cf ti» Fuehrer was involved, and had misgivings because he h.liovod that this was a political natter, which ho did not want to express ir. a fil., fio tJ^rcfore cays: "In ray spontaneous as:. dubious again whon J'r. von DeraanduT/sky — that wa:: tho nan La ci.ar;.v of tho whole tiling — told cxj that tho Chancellery of the Fuohrcr was interested ir. tlio production of this filra, as tho interference of .a not only non-artistic but oven political group in our work had .already on several cccacionc caused .«o troublo in ry profession." Then he neats Brack and cays tho following, at tho bott*«n of page 2. n, :uch of ray surprise, I found in r. 3rack an entirely different rain than I had feared. He: was itodiatoly croparcd to discus: tho scenario witti i.;c." . I 6hall itrvo >. bit ut. "Ho then enlisUd tilt aid X .xdical experts, Dr. Hi.fcliia||n '•nd irofossor .Miotschc." Hol-Lni v not physician but - lawyer. "A so lies of long discussions followed during which tho ^r.tiro question -s discussed.;" A>; Li I o*it the rext f.ir li&js. I continue with tho oarayr’ !. on page 3: was :f tho pinion Unt a law ’should be issued, t:. 7o£0 16 H=y-M-H3-^-ifeoban (Int. Rasler) Court Kg. I. draft of which ho showed zti, which would enpowor a Tribunal conpjsed of doctors and jurists and undor public control to naka decisions on tlio requests of patients." And I read the Last sontonce of this paragraph: ■Brack wanted those against the killings to be given the opportunity, upon request, of putting forward their arguments." And now the witness continued "In this connection, wo -Iso discussed the position .f the Church, whose interpretation of G-d's will has varied throughout the centuries, and in particular, the problem of when God ta-.de known his will of lotting a bomsn be in.- die, when tha artificial prolongation of such a life represents interference with the intentions of tlv, Almighty, and when the intorforur.ee of the doctor to prolong or shorten suffering can bo recognised by the Church and -.-hen not, is a frequent subject f conversation. Tr. ' rack thought a t t deal about nil oT tliose questions", etc., "and I would like to point out oxprosoly that it was not about tho supposed effect of tta now Law upon the Church, but rnthor tho problem itself, which ha nado his cwn." I shall skip the next parfl^aph mxl I continuo: "A border sphere, tho inclusion in tlx; filn of which was dio- cuaood sovornl tinoo, naturally wes tlw case in which an incur;blo patient is not in & position to request deliverance, because l»o is pro~ vented from doing so by hie conditi n, or wh n hj makes such a request without being full*\rc sponsible, that is in tho case cf the ins-nc." I shall skip the next sentence: "Brack was for tho killing for the sure reasons ns in the c.aao wnore death was requested, that is, ut f deep pity fer suffering cr.atures, -:,d because- of the conviction that net only the distortion af tho human image in s:=c entally ill and some physically dof rmod is ' n unbearable torture for those ers'-ns themselves, but actually r_- presents a destruction of the bedy, soul and spiritual taka—up f tho h-r -.n b-_- . If one of thc.se links wore niscing, so ho -ar.u.i', d's 16 3-9-5-: "c-h-r. (ir.t. : rJL. r) Court So. I. 1-Age would be destroyed and the huaan, no longer a hircn, would there¬ fore, no longer full within the Huron Sight, but would place on the actual hm.n the duty to deni txrcifully with th: suffering creature." I skip the next paragraph again, and I quote para ;r-.ph 3 on pare 5: (he is now speaking of tho production of the film). “.’mother scene, hot.owr, which Mr. Brack suggested was carriod out by us, that is the killing of .a sick experimental nnlnal through the application of other by a synpathotic doctor (fosalo). fir. Brack was present several tics when work w-s going on in the studio; on ono of thoso visits ho brou ht fteichsloiter Bouhlor along. “In sunaarixing,“ tho witness cava, "I would liko to point out tho following: Tho nontal attitude of tho persons in tho filu “I accuse'* while not agreeing to euthanasia, is built up on tho conversations and explanations which :T. Bract had with no, and which ho gave no, and was strongly influonood by hiru Tho othicc of tho fiLa personalities, also of Dr. Lnn^, arc ovidenco for tho opinion of Hr. Brack in tho years 19li0 and 19U1. Tho opinions of tho oppononts of outhanasla, which aro brought up in tho filn, arc typical of the ebu ruinations of Hr. Brack in which ho tried to clarify hinm.1T as to whether his rioalings were right. "Ooyond this, tho objoctive presentation of the 'pros' and •cons* which Mr. brack brought into tho file, is not only oxprcsFivc of his charactox-, but is also rdthout parallel la tho history of files in tho Third Roich. “Tho file, 1 Accuse could nj\a r h?vo boon created in tlds forc, if it had boon produced under tho control of tho Propaganda ’an- istry, which permitted only black and v&itc sketches. Tho cooperation ith r. -r".ck j.avc n- new cour-. ; e at that tino to start again in tho lino of .art, which was considered degenerated." And the last paragraph: "Tie filn 1 Accuse was roco'.nized by all sides, oven by ati-rascist artists, and over, by ti» Cssorvatore Rocano, as work of 7682 16 (Int. SnsUor) Court No. I. art, and general surprise was evoked that this should suddenly bo possible* This can.be credited to Hr. Brack and his refined, not-vain, and izu'.rti'l attitude, which ms at all tinDs huaan. ” T got to know Mr. Brack, during the months of cy contact with hir., as a air.coro, intelligent, and abov r.U, conpletcly uns.lf ish nan, who, aside fror. this, was entirely polito during the discussions and conferences, and was always perfectly willing to liston to his partner, to reflect on his arguments, and to bo convinced thereof. «Svj» though he was, by conviction, a National Socialist, he was far ronovod in character and in his behavior fror that which is to¬ day called Nazisn and loilitarisr, abovo all, fror. inp.artii.nco, self- justification, lios, and brutality. "I cysclf was never a no^bor-of tho KSDAP or any of its organ¬ isations." 7663 Court 1 ifay IS--'*—1C— l-HD-Bcard-iv mnler. Your Honors, I only hrve to add one tiling to this document. I want to expnssize that not one word of this pffld-vit was out into tne south of the witness or was 6 Ufc,.ok Io. *7, and docuaont No. 3, in document book No. 1, I oh uld llkd to reserve lr. c.-se the cross-ex alnation by tho Prosecution ©lvo me ?r. occasion to offer the;.-e documents. I shall prob* bly not cose book to thea. T..2 PRESIDENT: V„ry well. Counsel, I just wonted to :o sure th t you had not Inadvertently overlooked it. DH. FRCSSCHMaNN: I dls-.ense with the submission of • • document Ko. 33 lr\ document took No. 2, rv.ge 21. THE PRESIDENT: The Pro-ocutl n aay cross-oxoralno tho witness. CROc 5-E.WI!*,4TICN 3Y DR. kOCKVhLO: v. Hy it .l^asc tho Tribunal, Herr Sr'»ck, you arc not a doctor, arc you? a. No, I r.m nut n onysician. And 3o;nlcr wasn't a doctor either? No rounler was r.ot a nyslclrn, either. Did you receive psychiatric training? * «. Ko, never. Q. You we e, however, very iucr. ntere6ted in the quest .ja 'f euthanasia from the theoretical aoint of view; ore u not? Coart I hay 15-M-lo-2-Hi>-3eard- ncaaler. a. No, I never was Interested in the question of euthanasia. But eft r when you -ot the information from 3 oihler that yo were-going to work with him in this program, y. started to be lntore t d in this question, and you reed ; ood >Joks didn't you? a. Yoe, at that tine I started to get interested in that question. I considered it .-ay duty to infora myself a rout this as ouch as possible. Did I understand you correotly in saying tne work of Binding and .-loo he w c t.ic standard work on euthanasia? a. I was told the work of 3indin b and Koche was the standard work a'o-ut euthanasia; lr. r-ddltl-n, however, I read some other hooks. ... Do you know t..ls work of Blndln t and .-.oche very well? a. Ko. Do you remember whether it is • tnlok volume, or o saall :ook, or vh t fora it nas, ?na v.Vt is in thoro? a. Yes, I do remember t.vt. It w e o rolatlv. ly small v.lume. It consisted of two -arts; one part contains the chrcers of interest to lawyers. Binding, and tho other constituted the cr.coters for tne osychlatrlst, Hooha. You Just 6aid tnere was a o rt made ur of legal .natters, in Ckriar., by Professor 3indln b is the le b pl arn, isn't he? So, I take it -any legal questions enme u in tne eutncnaslo rogran; for cxamrlo, wn.thar certa n -craons should be informed about the true cause of death of‘the victim , further, attitude of tne different Judicial a Choritlea, and so on. ho handled these questions in the office of ro-r.ler, if Cr.ey were handled in tne office o.: =o i--r <*t all? I ':e t our ardor., do you mean the decisions wnicn 76B5 Court 1 Hay 16-k-10- o-HD-Beard-Ra-nlo r. Bouhler oadc with regard to the notification of relatives? There -..ere some ceople, c certain circle of people who wore, in a jlte of tr.e secrecy, so I understand froo your testimony, who were, in spiot of the secrecy of the Suthaecsia prograa, informed about the tro^ras itself — certain d'.ctors and possibly also certain le a al peo;.le; the Hinlstry of Justice, and so on; who nandled tr.ese questions rnd the correspondence which resulted from these questions? a. Those questions of a legal nature were generally dealt with by Dr. 3ohne. He was .assisted, os far as I know, by o certain neglarungerat lervalsfcy or some such nerson. Q. Hot by you or by one of your coilaborotors in the Chancellery of the Fuohror? a. Ho, not by oo. Q. But, I ha vs auen from the evidence horo that you were tne person who was approached in questions of an administrative nature, whether tne questions caoo up from the logcl authorities or frop the 53. Do you ro.seobor they ntroduoed some evidence, correspondence with Frelsaler? «nd y u yourself, mentioned yesterday quite extensively the ojrreoponuencu with Hl-ialor end that you wore twice for a c nforonco with Hlnnler, rnd there you smoko to hip about euthanasia and he s~o..e to you about it; is that correct? a. No, I went to Klosler once with a question regard¬ ing euthmna6ia. Z. But, no wrote to you when he 6 ot these ccnjlalnts ftv... Huch about euthanasia; ho wrote you a letter, ulun't he? A. Yes. Z. bo, you wore the person wh- was approached in such questions, were you not? 7oS6 Court 1 Stay 16-K-10-4-HD-Be a rd-Ra~ le r. a. No, I was the person to whole Hluualer turned in cases like tat. v. And what about Frelosler? Frelssler also turned to you, didn't he? a. No; as 1C can be seen fr^s the docu-er.ts, I gave oertr.in instructions to Frelssler by order of Bouhler, but Freisaler did not turn to ~e. Z. You contacted hie by order of 3ouhlc.r; wa3 that reg .1 rly that o- handled tnese taints for bjuhler? a. Thrt differed, « nuusber of jitters were dealt with - the Heichslelter directly, rnd eoxetlrues he told so: Y .u de?l with this In t.-.la or that fora — end that is what I did. qb it often that he gsve .'wu o.c;. tasks to preform? A. That vorled. c- i. "as it once a waok or once a itonth? Almost dally I hrd to report to Sour.lcr; or I was called into his office to receive instructions, because I had to report to hia ab.at ay entire work. You rosorted dally to file In connection with the quest!,a of euthanasia? a. No, ab at tr.o work of ay office. %. I oa c.-uing beck to tne q-estl .n wnl J\ I nsked you Just n.v. '.’as it often that you 6 ot tasks of tnie *ind? Tasks de?:lng in the eutranasla question, of a legal or •duii.iistrstive r.-ture, froa Souhler? a. _es, I ccrteir.l did receive such asslgnsents f?on 3 x:\ar, -Ut I cannot tell you how of ien. — rtil right, 1 want to a6k you now — I h-ve :ef_re •e d c ant 330 Fa, Prosecution's exhibit 33C, document bo k 1., “art I, pa_,e 3, your Honor. This is tr.e letter :r - Hitler to : ar.dt and Bouhler. You have been speaking Court I >: y 16-:^-lC-5-HD-2eard-Ha^ler. q ito a while about this document, and I only vent to nsk - — n the oottoa h. re — do yo- have the- docuaent before you? a. No, I h* vo not. 16 Kay ';7*4&-Si^H-l-C.ro53 (HasOor) court :;o. i '• Or. tho bottoa thoro is a hand written note "Given to nc by EoulOor on 27 August l°aO, signed Guortner". Dr. Guertnor was tho .inistor of JUstico, cs ho not? &• Yes, Q. Guertnor, according to this note, received the document nearly a yoar after its issuance. ?7hy rasho not infonaod oarlior? Ho was tho hipest legal authority. This vis a very important natter. It Mza tho logoi his is to tho Thole euthanasia pro gran. Hot; was it possible that ouch a far-reaching and inportant authorisation ovor tho lifo and death of ?50 to 600 thousand pooplo was net handod to Quortnor oarlior th.cn that? A, 3 0 eauso of soareoy Bouhlor didn't want to a ond this lottcr or dccroo to any othor a encios. Quortnor, of courco, was lnfomod nuoh earlier, but at this period of tiro Bouhlor upon his request oont liin a photost*tie co.y of that dcorco in order to hoop it in Ids own filos. Q. I cn at a loss to undorstand that. You toil no that Bouhlor oortainly infemed Guortner long boforo that tine, so tho authorisation woo not nocrot any icro to Guortner, VJhy didn't ho givo hir» tho doounont, such an iaportait document? A. I didn't got your question, •1. You told r.o that Bouhlor did not rant to hand tho docuncr.t to Guortner because tiio docuasnt was top socrot, did you not? By this Baco you told r» that ho certainly infonaod Guortner such oarlior than 27 August 1?U0 about tho contents of tho docuraont, I rc«?.C. liko to know why then, after tho infornation Guortner Got f«n Bouhlor, tho thing wusnot secret for tan ary noro, Tty he did not got t o docuront right away fren Bouhlor. Can you explain that? A, I'cll, pcrr.aps I didn't ogress nyscli projrly bcfcrc. Bouhlor lidn't want to give the origin! or a copy cut of his hand. Ac far as - -mow io infemod Guertnor orally ouch earlier ir. the serce ray as ho 7639 16 Hay U7-l^-U^-Gro33-(Rr^or) Court Ho. 1 also inforncd others. In tils connection I remind you of the affid¬ avit of Scnultso, Tiio coufirsos how Bovilor informed the :'dnistor of the Interior of Bavaria, ffagnor, to den he only showed the document. He didn't give it to Mb, I knew this characteristic of 3ouhlcr*s. U Isn't it afact that Boihlcr inforaod Guertner only after too □any complaints wore aalo to tho public prosecutors all over Gornany and thococcnpld.nts cane to Guortner, their chief, isn't tJuit a fact? A. I really don't knerrr rhon Bcuhl r informed Guertner, 2. Bid you ever, or your offico, rocoivc thoso complaints cf tho public prosecutors? A, Ho, o novor rccoivcd any complaints fron tho public pro3ocutors. 17o had none fr:o the lilnistry of Justico, Q, "fh<» handled thoso affairs in your offico? A. Bovhlcr at 'irst doalt with t!xso questions,sad I thon roccivod ordors fror. hia to investigate tho ccnplaLnts that socnod to bo • justified. I tndo excerpts n thoso enpldnts or porlvps sont tho original to T-Ji in ardor to investigate whether any aistakes had boon aadq md I wanted to s.o tliat all mistakes which roro caused by tho secrecy — bo avoided in tho futuro. s , Bid you also investigate tho so-callod unjustified ccnplaints? A. Actually ever.* cplaint raainvest! atod itich c roatod tho ir.jrcssian that a. mistake ladb.sn :.ado. If, however, a cor.plaint read ns fallows: "I 3tffto that within tho area X ton or fifteen topic led died at one institution T.lthin threo months," I cortainly couldn't investigate any such complaint, because it rarely Sewed facts, . 1. I *-nt to hand you now Docunont !X>-1325 which rill bo Prosecution Inhibit .95 for identification. This is a letter frn you to Gchlcgelborger — who icstke acting ! i:ds r cf Justice, was ho not?— :f 22 April 19U1; *-'.c.re you have s :x of these cv plaints, o you renccfc.r tids letter, Hera* Brack? 7690 16 Hay ^7-^€”^H-3-Gross(aaai:r) Court Ho. 1 A. I don't reresbcrtiis letter. I would '.a c to road it first. Q. la that your signature? A. Ice, that is :y signature. .• "ou nrito horos "Very honored .'crty .caber Dr. Schlogolbcrgcr, Corresponding to our agrocajnt, I beg torcf-r to some dotalsof tho proofs, v.ich roro put at ay disposal. I rule! appreciate their clar¬ ification and / :r regulation. Fart 1 of the enclosure contains a roport by tho president of the regional court at Xlagonfurt, datod 7 '! 0 vcribcr 19h0, on tho interro¬ gation of a counacllor at tho loner court. Dr. Spusta, rho undo almost nonstrous uttcrancos regarding tho «A :ticn« in a civil verdict. Dr. 3pusta»c attempts to Justify hijsolf in thisinlcrrcgation protocol appear completely insufficicnt. n Does that rofer to the outhanaaia rograxi, thu word "Aktior." l»ro? A. Yes. 1. I go on: "In Part 11 of tho onclos ru, t o prosecutor gcnoral at Linz ro.»orts to tho Roich HLnisier of Justico on '& !Iovu.ibur 19U0 on on investigation procoduro against asdstant physician of our 'Iai*thoin Lastitutien in connection vr th caso Guenther Rottoonn. The iroaooutor General ,t evented tin quoo’.iir.;: of this pr oceding. Cinco it car. ho asarud that the Prosecutor General at Linz belongs to tho persons rho wore infor/xid by Seorctar; of State Frcislor about tho "Alrtdon" in August 19U0, »>ia boh-avior is inconceivable in overy respect. " In Dart IV f tho pr-ofs at ry diapcaal, tho president of tho '.iighcr court at Bromberg reports m II. January 19U1 about a petition of tho jud'c at the court at Kitzingen concerning its la*.r officer Railing. -lion his nothcr-in-lat: brought her daughter, Frau R a n l in g, into a ncntal institution because of mental siefaos^ she had to sign a document statinp :v.r c nsent t^t:o imdncnt death of her da: ;*ht r. I -uld appreciate it very sich if t-.c 1"r officer Ranling ^tuldl'c X6 :iay 47-^-£"^-ll-3-Gross(Ranlcr) Court ::c. i A, I dorit rormbor this letter, I would ha l to road it first. ~i, 13 -that veur signature? A. Ice, that is ry signature. !. You T-xitc hero: "7cry honored Forty 1'cnber Dr. Sclilogolbcrgcr, Ccrresponding to our asrooaent, I beg to iuf .r to sono do tils of t]*j proofs, v.-.ich roro put at uy disposal. I r,uld appreciate thoir clar¬ ification and /or regulation. Part 1 of the enclosure contains a report by the pronidor.t of tho regional court at Xlagcnfurt, la tod 7 Hovenber 19U0, on tho interro¬ gation of a counsellor .t tho lower court. Dr. Spu3ta, who uado aliiost nonatreus uttcrancos regarding t LVrticn* in a civil verdict. ’Jr. Spwtaic attests to Justify hinsolf in this interrogation protocol appear cc-^lotcly insufficient." Does that refer to tho euthanasia progrsr., tho word "Aktion" hero? A. Yos. Q. I Zo om "In Part 11 of tho oncloc ro, t o prosecutor gonoral at Lins roporta to tho Roich Unis ter of Ju3tLco on '£> Itovcuber 19U0 cn an investigation procoduro against assistant physician of our institution in connection tt* th the caso Guenther Rottaonn. • r General jrovontod tho q f this proceeding. Slnoo it can bo assnod that tho Prosecutor Juixral at Lins bolongc to the persons who wore infor-xd by Secretary of Stato Frcislor about tho "AIrtion" in August 19!i0, his behavior is inccaccivablo in every respect. " In ."art IV of tho proofs at ty disposal, tho jresidont of tho higher court at Pmberg reports -n 11. January* l?Ul about a potiti^n of tho judge at the court at Kitsingen concerning its law officer Pnnling. -non his thcr—in-lx brought her daughter, Frau hauling, into a ncntal institution beca u se of rental sicknosq she laid to sign xmmnt stati r consent tc^tho ixEdnont death of lxr daighto r. I would appreciate it very uuch if t!x lav officer Hurling -.oild be 16 "ay hl-HrSZ-nrlt-Gross (“—lor) Court :ic. 1 officially requested to indicato the institution as roll as the none of tho director of the institution and/or tl.c nano of t!io aebitting nkysician concerned, »that the cat tore or. bo investigated. It starts to rcas-n that dthin tho fraao of our »aktion« relatives rrcrc never requested anything corresponding to Panling«s statement, ,: I request als to ask the juc'go at tho court at Kitaingen as to 3 ivo tho nano of tho professor in a large term uho is in charge of a hoooital there, so tint thds fact can also bo clarified, "Hany tlunks in advanco fer tho treble yau are taking. Heil.Hitler, Your very do voted Brack " Co j"u handled this natterin tho offico of Bcuhlor, didn*t you? 7c92 U r curt I'C. 1 .5 ..ay 47-«-12-l-23i-Karrov (Easier) A. I can rtBerber this concoction rather well because rouhler her 1 ready told ne that the ministry of Justice w flB concilia#* such cceplainte =ade by the Public Prosecutors. I received these cosolaintn, cs they »re sectioned here, in about three or four boohs. I verkod through these ccsolaints in detail and took the necessary steps os fi-r as any sistahee could cx. ascertained which were cade at T-4. I transferred thes« cozplaints to that agency in order to crcvvnt ouch mistakes in the future. As can be seen free this lett r, I sent ronerts to the ..inlstry of Justice in three or four caoeo where mistakes hod apparently hcor. on their part, so that they could investigate these nistokeo. Q. It is a natter of fact, then, that these legal Questions, so far no thoy cose u? in louhler's office, '-ur. handled by you, is that correct? A. So, that io not correct. That does not constitute any dealing with legal Questions. <;. Did you concern yourtelf once, durinr the year* you worked with roubler on this problos.as to vkrt the opinion of the official legal authorities vos no to the auction of euthanasia? A. I inforsed aytelf obout the fminlon of the jurist*, not the opinion of the legal authoritie., and I found out that minion. differed. Seat v».rc for it and othore were against it. I never heprd oersonallv of any objection raised ir. the uinietry of Justice. I heard, however, that eooc la^’-rs *\rc against euthanasia - not oil of then were for it. ^ You lectured in the /-inlstry of Justice about euthanasia, did you not? A. Ye8. '-hat did you tell these gor.tlener. as to how cany ccoole approximately in &vrary would be adainisterd a n.rcy death? How zany persons? A. I don't believe that I zt.ntior.t-d any nuabtr thert. that izprusbion could thes* gentlemen tr ve about the number cf people vr.o should get the nrivileCe of n.rcy death bv this action? 7693 Court -o. 1 16 .iay 47-k-12-2-*i£i-£arrov (ZaUcr} A. Ac far os I re=o=b«r, tfci.se setters aren't discussed et all. I first showed then Hitler's decree; secondly, I presented to thea the iroft cf the lew vhlcfc had been worked upon. Cn the other hand; Hoy do spoke about the eedical execution. Q, Vfcat was the ispression fe'eyde gave to these ncoole? How aany persons possibly would be privileged to get a a«rcy death in connection with this action? A. I don't know whether Haydc sectioned any numbers, cither. I only lens- that no objection was raised during that neotinc against the *rroblc= of euthanasia. Q. Did you tell in this locturc who would be crccrted fror the privilege? A. I don't believe that I said that. I think that that wee sectioned by Kaydo. C^. Arc you rure about that? A. I said "I tollevc". I really don't know any sore. It vus aor.tloned, wasn't it? 7hct*. classes of People who were exempted w^rc sectioned? A. I really can no longer say today. <<. Can you toll ce about this work of binding and Kochc? You ore very fasillar with this work, aren't you? A. So, I ns. not. I said that I studied this work, end I olrcady stated yesterday that I didn't particularly like it. I said that I w^n sore favorably disposed toward another book, the on. by i*lxer. I didn't particularly understand the legal statements naie by rinding. Q, That was the only reason why you did not liku this book by rinding and Kochc, or had you other reasons too to dislike it? A. I really can't tell you that at the accent. I only kr.ow that it didn't sees as clear to ae ac other bocks. (v But you ere ftnilier with the principles stated thiffi, aren't you ? A. Pertly perhaps Court So. 1 16 :-cy 47-#-12^S-iB;-£nrrov (Bonier) Q. I have the iapr t 6si3a froa this took that these authors by no -oar.6 ask for the right to kill incurable a.stal patients no longer eacablc of work or eventually even incurable, but only suggested killing of incurable isbeclles - and, so'far as I knew, there is a difference twtv fc en an insane person and an inbecilc - in accordance with »oao forca* legal procodurc, a very ccepliceted legal crocedurc, iaplenentcd »*ith crery possible decree. Is that correct? An I correct in asfuning that that it the principle on which the book of Binding rnl F.ochc is bused? A. ' ell, I nust toll you ouite frankly that ! really cannot confirm whether you are right or not. I didn't ouite agree with '■hut -indirg oays about denying the ri«rht of life to the rati.r.t. "hot is how I con¬ ceived his opinion. On the other hand, I al-ays thought that it 'no n duty to aid the- vatUr.t by grantir..- his nerejr death. I think thtt Z wes on o different level, although I arrived at the ona% ai*. So, in other words, your opinion then ubout the acre?' death or about the privilege of narcy death went such farther than the orinicn of Binding ar.d 'echo? Isn't that correct? A. So, not farther but different. Ci. And where is the difference? A. Binding hoc said that the incurably insane n.rson no longer hoc a life which io legal property. Shis ir a rarely legal concert under which I couldn't inng'ne anything. VJwtfcwr the life of nr. incurable patient constitutes a legal property or not I cannot Judge. I re oily cannot Judge whether sercy death could be granted to such a *crson. ‘■ihet vsb isportent to at was the cu.etion of whether he is ruffering to ouch an extent that one io Justified in relieving hie of that suffering. This it en argument thet I understood. -ut the-re are vtr;.' snsy insane who aw not suffering at all, are n't there? *ho have nc rair.r? *ho arc, nony tires, feeling subjec¬ tively ouite well? ’ho do not 'v»nt to die? Ic it possible to edcinict.r -.0 such peODl. t!.e EeTcy death, according to your opinion, or according : t-e opinion of rinding? 7o95 Court ?e. 1 16 .-.ay 47-1.-12—l-LHl.-i&rrov (Saslc-r) A. ’all, I really cannot judge that. Please ask a Physician. IP. 7£CiSCH;X5: hr. President, I object to this type of cucetion- ing. ar. President, you will reneab r that the Tribunal yesterday . afternoon forbade =e to deal with the rroblec of euthanasia .16 regards • the legal and aedical point sf view. : think that this ruling should also be acplitd to the prosecution. IP.. EOCrVAID: If Your Honors rletsc, the witness stated at great length yesterday his personal position to the problcn. THL K-SIHEIT: She cress-cxenination is proper. The objection is overrules. If, on cross-exaninatlon, the prosecution Opens uo avenues vhich were not proper upon direct examination, upon ro-Jlrect cxoalnution counsel for the defendant night be permitted to es't certain cueStionc, But thw difference between direct -xasinotion and cro.s-exnr.1nation in ■ronounecd. The objection will be overruled. At thio tini the Tribunal will be in r.coss, end today it will be in reccoc until 2:00 o'clock. (A redos wj.s taken until 1400 hours, 16 :;ay 1947.) my I .'ay lS-A-5K-15-l-£!aohan (Int. Hasr-lor) Court No. 1 sjssig:: (Thi hcarinj convened r.t 1,15 hours.) TIL- ILJiSILtL: The Tribunal is ia session. Lli. IL-iDY: Hay it ploasc tho tribunal, before the conti¬ nue t ion of tho cross examination of the Defendant Brack by Jr. Hoohwald, I have two questions to take up with the Tribunal. Th- defense counsol has roquostod thr.t tho c-se of tho defendant Eoijlboock coco before tho oaso of tho Defendant Hovon, so that tho cases of Bockcr-Froysonj, Schaefer and Boijlboock will bo continuous,; in c.snuch as tho throo oases dolvo into tho soa-wator oxporir.ents and it won't break up tho continuity of tho presentation of tho evidence. Tho .rosocutior. has njroed with the dofonso counsel if it is agreeable to tho Tribunal .r.u we would like to hoar tho ease of the defendant Boijlboock before tho oaso of tho defendant Kovon. T:C P.IL3IDJI. T T: The supsostion cade by counsel for tho ,ro3ocution and for th~ defense will bo approved and adopted by the Tribunal. Mi. KMiDYj In addition to that* defense counsels of or *. tho dof ord ant Jrujowsky, Dr. Fleming, hns notified q u this nerninj that ho inters to c.ll another witness on behalf of tho defendant Mrujowsky. Ho wishes to oall that witness after the testimony of the defendant Brack has boon cceplet- od. I have no knowledge as to what that witness will testify and have not bo_n able to fOTGUllly object or aoquiosco •nd I should like to hear .froa tho defense cthinsol for the w defendant llrujoyretsy. as to tho nefio of the witness and what / tho witness will testify to. THJ ?. MS ID JIM: The dLf^nso counsel for the defendant Jrujowsky -./ill advise the prosecution and tho Tribunal. / / B... FLSM-3HG; Mr./Presid ent, wo are her-- concerned with 269 ? ::-y 16-..-5IC-15-2-Hcohoa (Int. . hi ready ot..twd -bovc, any authority of aanihil .tin.-; io to bo excluded if connected with breaking tee will of life of tho Individual to be killed or tho killed." Do you u,;reo with this point of view? I h .vc Ire dy snid this ..orai.v these purely lc,;.l considora- ticno cannot bw cooncntod on by -o; I c.Ji only s-y th-t I w-.o aot in a fr.vcv -.bio disposition tow-rd these consider tloas. Kuybo I did not understand tho., occ-uso I a*i not - 1 -wycr. haybo it is oocnrao thcoo consideration* cont-ia ..spects to which I could aot -..'roe. -t nay rate, those -re considor .tions w.lcn h-vo nothin,; at all to dc vita tho considerations which prompted uo — which were initiated si .ply by uity for the hu.aa Coin; - r-thor than by c-lcul .tvd reasoning q. all right, but, so you -re of tho opinion th-t tho privilOtfO cf ;:orcy do_th Cun -Iso be given tc people wno still h..v- t..e possibility 7700 16 K«-tfvM6-J3flor4 (Int. hauler) Court I to resist and who want to live,is th..t your opinion? •a. Eo, no, in nc w_y at all. If eoneoody t-» the will to livo it vould no longer constitute en -ct of norcy. ?. nut, you do r*x.ooo«.r tna doeweat 3906, Prosecutions orhibit 376, th.t is in docixient book 14, part 3, page 281, Your Honors, and I want to quote only one scntvaco. unfortunately I do not havo. tho Go ram, but it is only ouo sentence. I want to quota* ■Tho wildest scones iu^ln-blo -r- reported to n a ve tekCU pl.oo then, ns tore of these people did not board tho bus voluntarily and wore theruforc forcod to do so by tho ^ccoqp.'ayia,; personnel." Be you not think tfcvto people h A still tho posoibilit: end powor to roslst .and they did resist? Didn't they? 7701 :;.y i6-,.-3K-17-1-Gross (Int. u rmal o r ) Court; Ho. 1 ~ No I do not believe that. Shore arc two possibilities here. Hither this is a stntocont which is based upon r. rumor which nay have resulted in connection with and bo- c .uso of the seorccy.and an oxajser .tion of soaethinj which really tock a different course entirely or in the oaso as it is represented hero we -jo concerned with ;ationts of the kind I saw on ny visits to thoso institu¬ tions who had boon locked into the so-ciJLlod stronj houses and who oinstitutod severe d.-njor for entire humanity. .. If they were behind lock and koy the dnnsor for humanity wasn't so bij, was it? This is in offioiul roport so fur us I can seo from the document and not information cf runors. Do you know that the idocs of Bindin-j and Hooho were by no nouns universally approved in Germ any and in other plaoes? .» I really c an not Jud ;e that boenuse as I already said up to the time Bouhler reooivod that order I did not at all concern myself with the problem of euthanasia but durin; conversations I heard just as many ap/rovin ; us lujectinj o; inion3. i «11 ri^ht. The letter of uthorizntion which wo have been Spo^kin about, exhibit 330, to Bouhlor and Brandt says that Brandt and Bouhler had the responsibility of enlur.;inj the authority cf certain doctors by name, who did soloct these doctors? .. Bouhler soloctcd thorn. „ Bouhlor was not a medical man. Did he know the doctors? .. No, tut he had that order by Hitler. Professor Hoffmann or Professor Sohnoiaer couldn't soloct thoso physicians. It was 3ouhlur who had roocivv„*d that order to inorenso thoir authority. . I take it from the document Brandt alia Bouhl~r jot this authorization frer: Kitlor, and not 3ouhler alone. 7702 May 16-«-3K-17-2-Gross (Int. namelor) Court; No. 1 Yes. Brandt, of course, had to ‘jlvo his approval but 3ouhlcr at first oado the selection cnonj the physicians which wore designated to him by nene. .*nd Brandt pave his approval, is that ripht? .. I don't know. I must assume so. I wasn't always present during conversations between Brandt and Bouhlor. 1 ^id ycu ever rocoive a list cf names of doctors who wore authorized to administer euthanasia? .. No. I already stutol that I don't know whothor I did recoivo such a li3t. I don't know whothor any such list existed. ,.t any rate I didn't roooivo or.o. I also said that considering the small number or . hysicians I hardly think th-.t any such list wes oompfilod. i I ripht in assuming that it. must havo come to your knowlodjo whether such a list existed or not? .. No • i (horo oould a li3t havo :bcon without that you would have aeon it? .. Such a list could have existed In Souhl-r's offioo. It could havo been the anno in Linden's offioo. » .(ho select ed the doctors in the euthanasia stations about whom you told the Tribunal today that they had tho last Jud^nent whether mercy death should be administered or not? •* I can not pivo you ar.y information about that in detail. I do know, however, that Lind on ando such .rojosals to Souhler and I furthermore know that 3 ouhler then had th030 physicians call on him end tho.n talked to then. . Bouhlor ilono, in other words, solocted those poo, lo on his own responsibility? - No. I wa3 just saying that Linden mad., the corresponding .r sontatiGn to him. . You said that Linden cade the proposals but that Bouhlor 7703 I'. y 1 ----rX-l7-. z -jrcss 'In-., ilscdcrj Court No. 1 selected then, i.3 that correct? Bo abler decided, yos, which oius wore to bo actually selected. hon 2 nd how he discussed that not-or with Brandt I really don T t know. ; You noned soco of the doctors who wore active ir. euthanasia stations. Do you know who was in oharja of the iUthenosia station Brand on bur 3 ? Darinj ny interrogations I already 3tat^d that I could nc longer any with certainty where or at what stations those .hysicians wore workin . I thought at the tine to rononbor and I already stated what I know ut that tino. However, I ion't knew that ir. is ell quite correct. . I 3 tho nana Jlrtfc ( «-i-r-t-h) faniliar to you in this connection? .. Y 03 , I know that nano. i "ill you toll tho Tribunal who Mirth was? .. » irth was a Ca; tain in the Folic who was in oh:.rgo of tho local ro ;i3try offioc at Ornf-nock. . Is the nacc Gor3as3 foniliar to you, G-o-r- j-a-s-s? .. Tjjo nano Gorjnss,. yes. I heard tho nano Gorgass now as ir., result of reading the newsp apers. I, of course, can r.or ronomber whether ho was active r.a :in export or in any other function within the euthanasia . rojma. . But you know tint ho had a funotion in thi3 projrcn, don’t you? •* Yos, I reoDcbcr that ajain. . You nnoed sc&o of tho doctors who wore active in tho nhana3ia . ro^rar:. Now, I would like to kno whether you C; * c -dviso us ho* rainy exports there were? experts? I really can not ;iv- you the nuhber. I know there was . It a nunbur of then, 1C, 15 or 2C. I ar. afraid that I -•’t jivo you the exact nunber. '.70b :; - i5-/k-2K-17-4-Gross (Ir.t. Sccmlor) Court No. 1 „ How nany tor oxports were there? .. There wore threo to; experts ct any rate, there nay have boon four. ■< You javo us tho nas£s of three. I understand you arc rijht? They wore Hoydo, Niatsche, Falkolhauser. Is that rijht? No, Schneider. Koydu, Hietsoho, and Schneider? who was tho fourth one? ~ The fourth cay have boon Professor Docrini3 but 1 no longer know that with certainty. v You w,.ro chiuf cf Office II of ^ouhler's office, is ; t. that correct? .. Yos. would you say you wore socothin;; iiko a deputy to hin ns far cs tho euthanasia . ro;;ror. was concerned? •v No, certainly not. . You wore his collaborator, is that correct? “ Yo 3 . what exactly was your activity concerning tho euthana¬ sia ;ro.;rnn? .» My activity varied. ..t first I had to jstablish connections with all those r.jcncies who could nano physicians. I had to ;ot into contact with tho ;hysician3 thausOlvos. 6 *»hioh were the a>ncics hich javo you the naaes of those doctors? .. There was tic Ministry of the Interior, that was Dr. Linden, then there was tho .(oichsarzt-iV Dr. Grewitz. v Socebody else? .. No, nobody else. wh t else did you do tc jet the .rojran in operation? I ; artieijated in the conferences. I arrnnjod confer¬ ences for ouhlcr whenever he ‘intended to hold then and . .. :: y 16 —a-BK— 17-b-Ores 3 [ant. xiacr.ler) Court -So. i nony core thinjs like that. . You could possibly state this a little bit core in detail, can’t you? -* It is rnth-r difficult to state it in renter detail, ^y duties wore of such n varied nature that I could hardly rue .11 the details after 7 or 8 years have lapsed. Nobody could dcaund that free no. . .net did you do r-ft^r the euthanasia pro iron was in .rojress? -»uthcAusi stations worked, -iuostiennair-s were filled out, the . eo. le w«re udeinistorod nurcy deaths, what w is your activity in the projraa then? ~0o Csurt So. 1 16 ..ay 4?-A-18-l-£fLi-Karrov (rosier) A. I no locker or hardly any longer concerned cyself vith that cart of Soohler'a assignnont because I didn't have to, since it ran by itself, and I again turned to the t: sks vithin my ovn sphere of work to a full extent. Q, All right, sut, for instance, who supervised the operation of 7-;? It was the* clacc where all these cues:ionnaires were koot. It was the heart of the thing, v^on't it? A. Yt-a. 1-4 had its ovr. chief. . * X. 'ho war the chief? A. That v C e t at first, rofcne, and Inter Allcra. A r.d what was the position of the toe o^oe/ts in T-4, or in con¬ nection with "-4, e roe daily hsyda and Slot ache? A. That is very difficult to say. Cne could nerhaos say that fiohne, to all intents and voroooec, vuc the Chief of T-4, but really, fa far ts acdlcal natters wore concerned, h-yde si>do the decisive doci- aionc. Bohn-- was no ohyalciar.. ^ And you a .dc the liaison between H«ydo and Eoufclc-r, isn't that correct? A. Yortwrday/ruJcCtsd the words "liaison nan" which, ft one tin-, I ill recognise bemuse, altar all, I didn't hove ay office in 3M hut wan locate- in =y office on Yoostrascc. I cry have been the ncdieting x*n between Eohnc and Boufcler. Vhsncvor Bohr.e or Linden cane, to louhler'p office. Bcmhlar os r.ot always there, wne not always ir. a position to receive then. and often detailed mo to listed to then personally and then, ir. turn, report to bin in the course of the general r-rortr that 1 had to make dally. A v. J-uthanaeia, es you said yourcclf, involves o considerable stdiral rroblen, isn't that correct? A. Yes, certainly. v ho wre ir. charge of this '■art of the prorrsn? A. All the cerscne who ~ trc designated V' Scukler, tr e-p.rtp ar.d * * i portly os consultants. Thsro were psychiatrists, there were physioinna, 7707 Court 1 ’6 .iff- 47-A-l=-2-ia-:-iarr3w (Hanlet) there vere urofesiors. Q. So, and the top expert - the first top expert - wes Feydo, ves he not? A. Yes, he ves ont of the top experts. q. So, he '-»• directly under Bcuhler, was he not, according to vr.at you Just said! So, he really had a free hand, ^yde wasn't Soukler'a erroloyoe, in the sosc vay es --refessor Schneider or rrofessor Slener or anybody else weren't Souhler's employees, these physicians were the representa¬ tives of tht aedical thought which prevailed during the execution of euthanasia. Q, But SaihUr was in ckerge of the execution. Bouhler and Bmndt ,trv the two people who got the neslgnscnt by Hitler, were they not, so it sotns to a*, natural that these ooonle were Just in charge of Kcydo. A. loll, in that case it would have had the rccult in Foydc giving ue his position eo a lecturer and going over to Bouhler and Brandt ns their coployce if there wo* to b«. a definite relationship of subordina¬ tion. but that certainly w.sn't the caoc. «^ Isn't there a possibility that one oerson has two different tasks? A. Yet, that is possible, but these arc coooidor*tionft which didn't prevail st that tino ond I ccn hcrdly give you on;.’ authentic ctctonont no- aa to hov to distinguish between these relations. ^ But you know that Esydc voc the first top errert? Shot you know, dcr.' t you? A. H^ydc vi-f the first top «rr>vrt. You testified her® that you ere convinced that o nan like Heyde rev- r would havi lent hiastlf to the carryin* out of the euthanasia nrogroo lr. concentration eases, is that correct? In the way it woo described by the witness .ienneekt? • A. I don't thine that Hvydc would have nlacd hint elf at the dis- -osa 1 of sooething like that. 7708 Court :o. l 15 -ay ^7-A-18-3-aS£-£arrov (i-aul^r) v You have further testified that he and iietseke ar.d "olkelhauscr were the people vho gave you the assurance that the exacinetion which was carried out in concentration cases by order 'of Kinder, or at the roouest of Klccler, would be for the benefit of the innatec and that these peocle never vould have taken art in such censures as Action 14- ?-13 --as. Xo that correct? A. Kc, what I said w»s that * did not believe that ncoole liko Hcydo or Xictsche ••ould have participated in anythin. - : lifc*- that. I cer¬ tainly never discussed that with then. _ . . v “ut I understood you testifying thi t you kno« that doctors who were connected «ith the euthanasia nrogran carried out t'-aalnatlon in concentration euros. Isn't that correct? On the re-ueet of Finder? didn't you soy that? Sxaalneticnc? A. Ko, I said that I vos convinced that such pcoplt, If they hove cerforced on,'* cuch txurinations, hrvo oorfcreed thes in r. w,-y which corresponded to their scientific ideas uni *-ould have done that cor¬ rectly. Q.* Did you know that crasinutionc of lnrone or cnr.tnlly disturbed iioplu vgr. carried out in concentration carrs? A. Ilo, I didn't kno* - that. I received th- order and I rasped it on. I don't kno~, hovtver, Mother, hcv, and by vhoe this order w,, 0 ©Xe exited. C*. To vhec did you transfer this order? A. I already said that I no lor^cr know whether I transferred tr.ia order to Ke.rdo, Kietsche, or Allers. X issue* that it cust have beer, one of these throe centleccn. q. -a n J^this order ves curdy for the carrying out of e’calnctionn, not of th. applying of the Eercy death to people who ^r« found insane in theconcentration r&znz, wee It? A. Tes. this woe done exclusively for th* purposes of crcc'nation. q, Do you -•no’- anything about a connection of re-do with th« Action 14-7-13? 7709 Court :;o. i lfi hoy 47-A-lS-4-lr2I-tarrcv (?.a=lcr) A- Sc, I kr.ov of ao connection vhatsocver. tj, ' ould you, as collaborator of Souhler, take the responsibility for such activities of Ecyde about ~hca you testified her*, that you ere convinced that it “ould have been impossible that he «ould have lent hiasolf to such ectiviti-s? A. I cannot assume responsibility for any acts of any person of vhlch I icnov nothin. If 1 say that I an convinced that sent *.rocn did the right thin*, this certainly dooc not constitute a positive knowledge that the person concerned alvays acted ccrractlv. This is ouroly an expression of ay conviction. If tcy third nerron should have acted in an incorrect v«y, I certainly cannot aeeuai responsibility for hlr rets. Q. out you v*rt the close collaborator of Bouhlor, andPOihlor 'W> In charge of the crogram. Che top expert, the first too extort, of the program v U : heyde and Ecyde carried out those aeaauroa. I tnt to put to you Tocua-T.t ho. BO-2799, Miich •'ill be .-'rocicution Ixhlbit 497 for identification, "hie Is an affidavit of a coma doctor in Dachau, Huthig. I on reeding free paragraph 2 - no, raragronfc 4 - X 1 * sorry: "In the fell of 1E41 during on official visit by I*r. Lolling to ay infirmary I tid informed by his that a cceaisrion of :cur physicians undor the -iroctlor. of rr of esc or Kyde »ould virit the Concentration Pans lechau lr. a short vhilc. The tmroose of this eomaicrlon v,,s to select concentration camp prisonero vho could not vdr’now i+.rt ycu naan by initiative. Do you neon, *re I an ardent rccreocn- tativo of euthanasia, or arc you referring to the extent of =y authority? Q. Ho, I sa tokir/r you whether, in the circles which w.n s? naas- cp 3FX fulesx CBS2FIXEE1P SHACK' " To you roae-'b.- r th- teletype now? A. ro. v lo you aelntaia th-1 you never s-r.t cuch a telatync? --L. I a v. r c-nt cuch a teletype. 7714 Court So. 1 16 JCay 4 7-A-1&-4-ZHM— Mel cy (Sarltr) q, I want to sneak briefly nov with you . bout the euthanasia of children, the Reich Connlttee far Research on severe hereditary diecnscs. Yen testified here that you had nothing whatever to do vith that, is that correct7 A. I aoy correct cyself. I said thet I vas not in charge, I had soacthing to do vith it and I talked about that at great length, during ny examination, 'lease don't ni sunderstand ae. I don't vant ;-cu to understand I had nothing to do vith it. Q, What ves your activity in this? A. I hid to eutr.it to Keichslcitcr Bouhlcr thoso individual flloo which had bean completed by Linden's office regarding individual exoor- tited enses which had to be decided. In a fev cases I dealt vith that personally and in other cases aocociotes of nino did that work. In the sa.ie vay I sutalttod these files or.co or twice to Brmdt ncrsonally. Sorully they were sent to hin because ho vron't present. q. Did I understand you correctly that you testified hire that in the erso of euthanasia of children the oreviouc consent of the Barents and relatives wpo reouired? A. Yeo. I always maintained that. I said that in euthanasia of children, contrary to tho sut hens sin of the insane, the consent of tho crrents vat already obtained. q. She consent for whet, tho concent for tho giving of nercy death, or the consent to tho transfer in tfco tnet.itut.ion r>f ha SeieJ coa-.ittco? 7715 l6 :'V 1 -7-A-53 -C O-l-ifcJ o han (r anler ) - rt Kc. 1 ... I’?, the consent that all possible othedsof treatoent bo nsod on - ±2 child , even in vicr of the danger that tho child nay die in that ©Kssoctiou. Q, in ether trrda, thoir parents had to give their consent that Suth- -jaaif- -ruld bo administered to tiw child; is that vhat yourmnt to say, far asl an informed, this nssnot arrays done ir. this particular few. A nuabor of pironts na c direct rjpUcaticn^ thoy 3 aid ro ask that this ciiild bo rolievod. • • just sncccr.t, I understand that, but I cb rant to knw; That hoppenod ir. the ease rrhero the p&ront did not csk for n ncrcy doath af tho cMl'l; t.t ro thoy inf'ruedthoy had to ivo thoir consont that tho child ray ho artainintorod a corey doath? It r as put to then that thoy give t oir consent for a norcy doath boing ; ranted to tho child and onco tho;- had given that consont tho child res transferred to a Role ho Comittoo Instituto by tho treating physician, . This Euthanasia of children ras top socrot; vac it not? I no longorknor that, 1 dcn*t boliovo it,, q. Una it official In Oorrary aw:’, ov-rybody could knew ab ut it and trs infornod about it; dc you romemfc r tho vitae os Pfannuiollor tosti- ryird iv.ro ho never InTomod tao .jaror.ts sit T-a3a top socrot iiattor, ... execution of Euthanasia ltoolf vuneortdnly carried out 3i. ••o'-.rot, r,ut certainly I -xi not inf or. sod .bout that in dot'll. he *ro taent of children, I an only rn-.-fcinc ab ut n'tildron. ... I an only spoiling ab-ut c'ildren, yoc, . tear soul1 it bo possible If it ;• secret that every officTOl -?ctor ir* Gonniy, who had to roport theca eases, could give t a iV’ron : s address and he vnsr.ot supposed to knewab ut it, •• I hog your pardon, cv.ry person who had to ’cal vr.th tho secrot -r 13 f c urso inforrvrd ot it, tiwfc allays includos the respective * 'Ins .••hys* clan or the h.fti * d c'inic. 7716 1- :-V li 7 ^V-Sir- 2 Ct- 2 -ii«jhan(Ha 2 lor) Court Ho. i nr?* oxinatoly ir. 19li0 of tho 3cxvwn doctors know; Is that right? -*. -'mt I cannot Judge, I cannot say Ivstr mry there were. I --ill road n-w fron your document b-ok, Suppi caon t 3 , dociucnt ? 2 , Crack exhibit Ii3 cn page 2 3 oo* :ploaont 3. Your Honors, tho last scntcncos "It is the business-f tho .apical officers to infena tho cronts ;f too ohild in question, of tho treatment available in tho a tud Institute or dopartac-.t chosen and to induco thon torond in thoir c!dld uoronornptly, ifaro tho parent* shouM bo told, that in tho caso 'C individual clisoasos, tho re is a possibility of a-hioving certain soccoss with treatment evon in cases which hitherto hid t; bo rognrdo,, as hopoloss." I havo rocoivod tho inprossienfi* r. rhat 1 a:* reading horo fron your om doeunont that tho official doctors really had tho task to ek tho paronts to give thoir censont to a :x>rcy doath of tho child. ... ^ cannot toll ou anyuoro than I lr..o alr< dy said, ovon during interrogations, nanoly that that order had been given that tho noor.t of the parent* had to bo obtaLnod , ovon if in one or tho ithor caso tliat "bald havo to bo dono in a soorrrhat camouflaged fom. Lu principle, the p rents -roro to to info rood that it wild bo hotter if tho child woro put to sloop. • . 3c, I would liko to read fron pago 21 of your Doeunont book. rhis«i 3 your dacunor.t 51, your exhibit 12, on pago 21 of Supplouont 2: vi'-tuo f the arrmng onts.uado by tho koich tie ■* care will bo taken rf tho cl did !>:ro and everything p-odblo in ' -a '.ray of nedorr. therapy will bo carried out." — 1 You read out cf this scntcnco tl'.at tho ~cronts wore inforcaad that ’ -• children should bo adninistcrod a noroy oath? ••• I oartairly cannot dcduco that free t i3 3or:tcnco, 'out you nust connection have thn basic doc roe dated 1*3 August 1939 and ir. 7717 :--rt Ha. i .addition tho discussions and the conversations with their parents had with tho doctors that were treating the child. In tho dccuror.t which I have just road, it is exactly s to tod rrhat the doctor isspposed to toll the parents. All right, let us go on, You reactor that Dr» Pfannaiollor testified hero about tho treatment -- "uthanasia of a child was initiated, ho invited the parents and rclativos tc '/is it tho child; do you rcuonb-r that? A. ::os. Dr, Pfnrraiollor said that. C. Jfeno of tho parents or rolctivos ov-r told that thoy thonsolvos •-avo thoir consont to give tho child tho prlvUogo of a norcy •loath; othonrlflo ho xuld not havo stated hero that it was a top socrot natter and ho would novor havo spoAon to tho parents about it. A. ..ell, thcro is nothing I can say about that, I really don't know, 1. I r uld llko to put to you again docunoat Ko. 825, this is porsocutior. oxhibit 358, it is in docunont book 11a, part 2, pago 219 . Your Honor, tiiia is a • Docunont which vo havo boon spool: ing about at groat length yostorday afternoon. You spoke yoatcrelay ab ut it. A. I havo net rocoivod tho Dociu»nt. •• ^ ou testifiod yo3tercfcy about tills doeunont in groat length and told ua why quostionnairc3woro filled out about pcoplo who roro not of Corum nationality or not of Gornan or Goman related blood and for tliis sinplo reason theso pooplo roro not r.d.iinistorcd a ccrcy doath; is that right? A. You, that is true, G. ‘bo Jews could not got thoso rivilogcc bocaso thoy woro not considered Gomans and also to foreigners tho art ~riration of tho ruohror did not apply; is that right? A. Yes. V.'ill you-ivo no now your infamation why under nunbor thrco, quostionndres had to bo filled out for all interned crlninally insane P-rsons uliithout the question of whothcr thoy woro able to work or 7718 suffering fron a disease; just all of then? I don't knew, You displayed considerable 'rncwlcdyc yosterday about this decuna-t; can't you inf am us why that wradcnc? A. Thsao aro psychological condi tiorswhich I c-uld not possibly ovaluato. Regarding the ability to’erk, I also said that I could not judge to rhat oxtont tho ability to work constitutes a source of psychological knowledge, end tho srrx: is true of crininality, 4, '-let is absolutely rijjxt, tut the people under nud>or tlirco had also to have the quest! onna.ire3f ill od out, wtath-r thoy could rcrU or net. You say hero bofero "rrunbor three, or aro intornod as crininally insane pooplo," and yen ;-ourself yestcrdiy testified to tho effoct that it all nokos a difference b -trccr. point ano and tho ether three, ... I did not sy that, C. I think so. A. I:: aid very clearly that oithor thoso mild bo considered Tho aro contained in paragraph ono, or thoso of pTfwyaph taro, or paragraph threo, or paragraph four! ~hr.t is that I said. .. Can you toll no then, why it : ."as accessary to fill out qicstionn- ■iros on all poorlc who woro interred as crininally insano x-rsans, accrrding to port threo of the d-cuncnt. Possibly because crirdnallty also royrcsont3 a special poss¬ ibility f r the poyshiatrlst to ju _o tho progress f tho illJioso. .rs aally I car not ovaluato that. \, -id that rolato to all other as — namely all insano n -ns, 'ho privilege -»f norcy death that tho subjects roro given? A. "o, had that beer, tho caso a directive vruId have had to be issued to the exports tc tho of feet that every insano pationt, i radios a ease this paragraph -~s affimed, would havo to be released f--r Euthin- sia, I , h■T'ovor, never heard of any such directives given to tho 16 :>/ U7-^-Sr-20- S-j&chanfcanlar) Court No, 1 exports# . leu testified this eraing th't ou had no kncrlodgo about I&tbanasir. carried cut in Poland tfton caiesti ned by the Tribunal ; is that oerroct? No, what I said Tras that I ’axrrof no Euthanasia institutions in Poland. Q. Do you know of the canylng out of Euthanasia In PaLaixi? A. I Imcrmotliing of tho oxco -tion of Euthanasia ir. Poland, Did you over concern yourself with tho transfer of Polish insano pooplo? A, Ho. •. Did you over issuo tho funiafar cuoh transfors. A. I cortainly did not® Q. Did you ovor nako arronconoatofor tho transfer f ren tho Roich coahior or Roich Treasury? A, In trinelplo I had to apply for funds to bo given to no fra tho koich Troaoury for Euthanasia b. order of Bouhlor, but I really cannot roaenber tho do tails cf t*iio. < 1 . 'I CO asking you entirely about tho transfer of insano pooplo fron Poland, not in Gomiry or in 3nst Psussia? A, I cannot rcrionbor that. 7720 16 ::-.v-.i-S33-21-1-3 3rd (ite. 1-: r ) C urt K . 1. Q. I want t- -ut t y u d cur.nt 2906 which will.ho Prosocuti^n'a exhibit *199 f-r identification. I w uld like f-r vui rood — tr rood to y u tho first persoraph -.-f this letter* "Th . s* -onll-jd Spools 1 Detaohnent LaBO, which has boon put ur.d.r -y o Ti?"nd f r spociel tasks, wns ardorod t S- ldau in East Frussis fr n 21 Kay t~ 6 June 1940, nee rdin,; t the ograonent nado with the olch llnin Socuritv Office (BSE/.) end durlar that tine evacuated 1,568 potionts fr = tho Scl^au transit car-p." O- v u h:w any roc<-ll«.oti ns n w? Q. \vt that tiso I nrnnxd with SS Gru; ponfuohror Rodioss that an an unt f :&!. 10 . - w uld h- vo t b raid f ■ r tho ovnountl n f onoh pstiont. Tharu w uld, theref re, b .• a sun f H!'. 15,580 tr bu paid into tho nee vnt f tho SS Vain S-ct r Trrt! ., see rdin; t the aj-r-io- rwnt." Id nt want t r*nd nnv furth.r. D. y u rvradnbt r nnythin,; at ut this m>-w»y? ... ?:•, I rosonbar n thin,- nt nil. Q. I w uld liko t .ut t- v u th r. * cun'nt V . 2909, which will bo rr-sucuti n's exhibit »*. . 500 f r ldontif ienti- n. This is c lottor n ic rn.1 with th- sin. subject. It is t SS Grun nfuohrcr "< Iff. "Enolosod I oufcrit t- y u n dorrnl r SS Orvjr — 1 ur ?- r. r, this is wr ait sh ul! be ;e ;o 2, I an s rry. 773 . K y-~-G3S-21-2-3csrd r) c art ¥-. 1 . "Thj adtoneo which Criniml C rrifsar Lan-o had rocoived fr -a the I-.sject r f the Security r lice and the SD, SS Ob- rfuohrer Hatch was : Yen fT - - tremnent funds, t, ny knwlod-o. By virtue of this fact 1 r.j the snnttdr Bisuvd f r r.o thfr-psyeet f « -vetch nssi-ramt*" Cn tho left si-!o f the psra*raph is a handwritten n-te, « ur nwoi v» u rononhar that? ... Oh, it is r. t here* Q. I think it Is there, '.'ill y- hand hin this. (.. * ounent was tended * tho witness) That is n t ny ntw. Q. I did n t say v u wr-to it, tut It is y ur nnc. ! did n t say y-u wr to it. ... Id n't boliove ttet is r.y now. Q. D y-u renenter tte e:scj y u r ’ n’t y u? ... I alr« • *y Mid J hr. w n thin - at all nb ut ’Ms m tter. Q. .’ill Y ur II n r . --rr.it r.-. t ;ut an thor d cua.-nt t tho witness. 3 . I jut tr- y. u then, •* eurwnt 2*11, which will bo Exhibit 501 f r Hontlfieatl n. or.. rrtOHoC"!-toy I interrupt f r ninuto. I conn t s tho r.sno Brack c ntainod in any f th. 6» !« ^joints which have batn sub- -itto-1 t wjb, ..11 I sow w.s the t»a> f Dr. .? sah. Q. Di' 1 y \i over hn*n> rny tulojh ne c nv-rs ti r.n irtth 33 Gruppon- fi hrer ~ Iff n this mttorT ... Id n t te w th t. Q. Y u t Id Re just □ w y u o uld n t roiunb.r tho c.-tw. C .n yu •’“lude th-1 fret th-.t y u r ’c arnn^onentr. f r the transfer f those i£0 r 300 F les? ♦ «. I can s iv n nir. at ut th t, bonus I a t roc nb--r the ctlre nffeir in *.ny way. *. But y u conn t oxcludo it, c- n y ut “.’hot d- currents? ••• ” Iff e uld r. t -ive r-3 any rdor t .iv- a< nay t any no r f r nay pur so. Q. I -’id n t si- ho r>7o tho rdor, tut h>- ashed y u f r it, r.nd it ras uao'l in the Suthannsla business? «• That n.'ttor is cntiroly strin-e. I thi-fc it is quite in; salblu thot even no ; fonni,; hod be n iron by F uhler f r that ;urj su. I on e nplotoly oxeludir. thrt ; ssibility. Q. X w d y u then ox,all in those tw pencil r. tos n 2909, 3rack; •r.J 2911. I can read thus* tw> r. tes in’ it is ; ssiblu tint it doos say 3 r ck, hut I c»m t ox;lain than. O'. FCCF7..LD* If 1 ur IT a rs, rnt t idj urn, I h v n forth>r *’“unati ns t th witness r. this subject. 0.7. FLT?" ; IKG (F.r tho daf n ant *.ru wtky)i r. President, I shelly r t c'll th. ■ witness Schnrlnu, but 7 shall subnit an nffi->vit bv hin. I :«t no qy sti n, !!r. President. Th Triburr! n Thursday, last week, whon Hi cuss in,- the f m .f 1 •'s f th. nriur.?r.t had pr vidod th*t a 'iscussi n w rid t ko place * I oak wfcet!wr thrt is t t- lac - Say; if n t, whan 3 "*h e discussl.n will * kv ..lace? 7723 16 I'-y 47 Cress C5urt No. L 'H. HARDY: Your Heners, I dj-.'t kiu* * tat ttitudo the Tribunal h-.s t-ken on this but this proposition has slipped ay aind for day or two due to other setters nd if oossibL. to rrrance tha meeting on Monday or Tuesday it would racet with th_ approval of Prosecution. I do not rcoaxbcr that the n oting was fixed for today* He mid tentatively l-.nt Pridry we would ..tv- the coating this Friday and if convenient to tho Tribunal we cculd sect tlx first of the wools and discuss it core -xtenrively. TE FHSSri’./.T: That " ult be better. Counsel will consult sith the Tribun J. ad we will discuss that in detail. Tho Tribunal ill n w bo in recess until V:30 lionlsy morning. Court 1 'I* 7 May 1S-M-1-1-HB-F oster-Raanler. Official Transcript of the American Military Tribunal in the matter of the United States Of America, against Krrl Sran&t, ot el, defendants, sitting at Nurnberg, Gernany, on 1: Hay, 15-17, 0930, Justice Seale presiding. THE MaRSHaL: Persons In the court room will ^lerse find their seats. The Honorable, the Jud es of Military Tribunal 1. Military Tribunal 1 is not lr. ease Ion. God save the United States of *murlca and this nonorrble Tribunal. There will be order in the courtroom. THE PRESIDENT: Mr. Aarshal, you . aoertaln if the defendants ore all present In court. T.-S MhR 6H«LL: May it please /our nonor, all the defendants are present In tr.e c urt with the exco don of she Dafendor.t Gebhardt who Is 'bsent due to Illness. THE PRESIDENT: The oecrotary-General will note for the record the presence of ell the defendants In court save the Defendant Gebhardt who will be eyoueod on r.ouount of illness, pursuant to a certificate from Dr. Martin tho via n surgeon. The Secretary will file the certificate f-.r the record. Counsel aay proceed. VIKTOR BRaCK - Resumed CROSS EXAMINATION (Continued) 3*i DR. -OCHTaLD: xA .'lAay.'i^slease the Tribunal. Herr 3rnch, I hrve a Xv/ * \ • /vg.e tlona fot-vou about your affidavit, I am referring %'■ ' .\ f - Dr cument No -*25. 1 Prose cut ion Exhibit 150, on pa^o 1C of D-cuc nt jSooh 1 -I> part 1 . Xou signed tr.ls affidavit, did jji not? j is r.ot before me t. u-ji. Go art 1 Kay 19-.*4-l-2--U}-Fostfcr-Haaiiler. v.. This Is the affidavit you s~oke about several times I on't think It Is necessary tfart uu fa ve it before you, I c.c r.ot want to go into the details of the document itself Dll s me body compel you to- sign this af:idrvlt? A. Compel is certainly not the right expression. I felt innerly obliged to sign the statement without being conscious at that time that many of the things oontain3d therein were either incorrect or incomplete. This only ontsrc . my mind l^ter wr.en, or. th t 1 6ls of the documents, I was able to scertcln thet many of the things were not represented corroa ondlr.g to the f ct3. But nocody told you you would so punished or you would have some dlsndvantogoa If yo- would not sign it, la tilpt correct? a. Thero was no threat ox reosed towards mo. ... Is It not true that you were leraltted to mnko changes In tno wcrdln. and In every other raoovct In the affidavit? A. I vr»o permitted to make changes. It w :e ointod ut repeatedly, however, that the word I had suggested v.r.o difficult to transit e and I was therefor a6ked to admit r.nothur expression with which I br.clcolly did n & roo, .-*ut the' convinced mo. Is It furtner not true that you made cnan c os in the affidavit, that changes were made on your suggestion r.nd on the basis of your information? a. Yes, e few changes were made. 4. >»nd wfa't abo-t the chert, you signed this chart. Hov aid It ceme about? How was the chart made? A. I hrive already described ta-t. I think a female -raftsman drew uo this chart In my presence. I nel.-ed her as far os * could give any in-iortione. I don't know 77d6 Court 1 Hay 19-H-l-S---iD-Foster-Rcm _ler. Co what extent I emphasized at chat time that any such chart ~-'d not existed before, and thu>t c..le was a conn let ly new construction of that organization. The sketch which I drew did in no way enewer tr.e requirements. ■*. But you drew uo a draft, aldn't you? a. Yes, I made ar. r-.ttea^t to draw It up cut I did not succeed. *. Do you remember the draft well? H. You mean the one I 6lgneu? The draft you made yourself In the prison, not In he lnter\*ogatlon room. a. fco, I don't remember It. It was incomplete and insufficient. ... Do you remember whether tnere was a bcslo difference between the draft ana the enurt as .to the position of Bouhler end Brandt? a. I really can't tell you that. ■ i . All right, .'e have tne draft and I wont the right Co ut to you this document KO 2758 wnloh will be Proeocu- * Cl n exhibit 502 for Identifiertlon, your Honor. (Document nenaed to the witness.) «J. Is tills the draft? a. Yes. DE. HOCHULD: If your Honor please, ~ay the record s .w t.mc the witness acknowledged this draft as t ie draft he urdo In the prison. THE PRESIDENT: The record will show tnat the witness * - -n examination of Prosecuti r. Exhibit for Identification r -Z s ated that this was a copy of the dreft which r.e ma.de vhlle in the *rison. DE. HCCH *hLD: how I want to discuss witu. '-o- tne sterilization 7727 Court 1 ;4ay 13-H-l—*-HD-Foster-fianmler. of the Jews. You testified here, in a sense, that ; vu were u osed to the nrogroa of extersin ting the Jove and, there- - re, together with your collaborators, conceived and for¬ warded Ians for a less drast-to and ruthless solution of Che Jewish proclea, is that correct? A. Yes. Who was the collaborator or the foraer collaborator f vours who first told you that the plan of exterminating the Jews was cunoelvj«? a. That, I think was Dr. Hewelnann. 7723 19 loy (1st. Ejclor) Ocurt I 5 » -od who were We coll-oorators wits »&co you uado this plan to to El—.ler tea surest Ion of sterilization? a. I can't Give you the nscos in detail sow. at say rc.to Dr. Serein ana p.a-ticipated here. - q. Did -slanJccaourg participate ir. this plan -Bout Ucdcsasccr, end so f orthT a. Yes, ho certainly did participate, but the pecplo nost iato- restod in this plan were exports «-ich h_d nothin; to do with tho Chancellory of the Fuehrer, for inst..uc© the witnoss Lo^ut ions rat Rad anchor, -for whoa I bad asked a* a “itnoss end there were rleo a nasbor of other age&cloa who could inform us about the circuastancos inrolvod. q. but Blunlconburg collaborated, did hot a. I boliovo, yos. q. jh I uUt Jeon in as«ual &6 that you wanted to prevent ortcr^- nlnntion of tho Jowo, as you -nd your collaborators considorod thin to o a crino? a. So, that is wh .t I test if 1 ed. l>id you co..aider tho axtorcinution of tho Jews a criaot a. Yes, wo considered it a crlJiO. wo did not considor it worthy of tho Oon.ua pooplo. bo eonsidorod It to ou lrro*ponslblo towards history, ifcat, I think, is tno oppression I used. q. You and your collaborators wore of tula opinion? a. yes, wo wore of this opinion. q. Ycu nudo tho first plans, for the rosottlaoont of tho Jews in n f..r away country, for ox-jplc in kadasaccar, is th„t corroct? a. Yts, th .t is truo. q. *n& vhor. these plans wore not accepted you approached Eiuulor with tae su. ;estion to storilizo the Jews, but in reality you did not vent tho Jews to bo storilizod. You did th t Just in order to prevent ro brutal ne..sure3 free, the port of Hi—ilor or Hitler, did you not? 7729 19 2 - 2 -haloy ( 1 st. &Jilor) C art I u. *h-t d'-cc not exactly correspond to the facts, out according to ito sense It docs correspond to what I intended. Is it not true that in 1941 when you forwarded your report to Hi.-siler, — I as referring to Docineat 203, Hxhibit 161, -Ocuxiont Book 6 , on page 35 to 37 of the Docccent Book 6 , is it not truo that it ves then a cutter of cccu.:n knowledge th..t it was very well poseiblo to sterilize people with X-rays, is it not? I cannot judge th„t, it w..e cy personal point of view that it wns not possible. q. 1 .oll, did you not oxnect th..t hi.~lor would b.vc chcokod tho rocord with u specialist and would huvo c .sily f und that tho uattors you sug ostod wore not effectod; if you wore cf tno opinion you could .ot sterilize people with X-r.y? a. Ho, 1 didn't cxD-4-itulQy (Iat. a.-.lor) Court I ;'cv. a fov questions in connection with it; will you look at tho soccnd --~ r re & tl-i« latter; this is Docuacat 205, Tour Honors, Prosocution Dccuaoat 163, Document Hook 6 , p^-e 39, and in tho second par.-, r ph it st tes: *^.onfc 10 uillicas of Jews in Hiropo „ro, I fi..urc, nt l-.-xt 2-3-uillions of tea and waion, who are fit for work.* It ooaas to uo ycur plan w uld havu only worked for these 2 or 3 aillioa; whr.t would h..vc ha-ponod to tka other ? or 8 aillioa; you ora spoafcl:*; only in t:.is plan of organisation of tho pooplo w.. are a-lc to work, Shat did you Object wruld hu-npoa to the 7 or 6 aillioa wao were not nolo touorkl I bxp octcd tno very s.,.e tain.; to heppoa to thou as to tho two or throe aillioa. Ir. ccnnoctioa with »*jt I h_vo already tcotifiod during; uy direct ox-i.in_ticn, to the offoct that in tho ;onr 19-J2 tho war possibilities frou ry point of view woro not b_d at ull and th.-.t uo actually counted on a quick and to tho war, sinco wo continuod to •/v.ncc in Ruseiu. If I could orirv; .i-out a cortain dole;' in this action I hoped th-t in conditions of penco uo could, undor cirouaotnn- coo, carry throu,* tho Kudw oscnr plea, tfcieh hod previously boon ro- Joctod. %• but I do bco tr.o doaly only — Poi'nnpn you cux. advise no, - but I do seo tho dolay only with ro;ard to tho pooplt you attu.pt vd to oe storilixod. I do not boo tho dOaly fer tho 7 or 8 uillion wno woro not nolo to work and thoraforo would not bo Btorilixod, io tk..t correct? "• HO, it cortainly is not corroct. Until one c-n solcct poqplo U1 ° aro fit to work, until the ontlro organisation is sot w>, liontho and h;ntho ust nocossartly elapse. 7732 Court »:o. 1 19 ^ay 47-*-3-l-ATD-l£eehan (hamler) Q. You speak in the sane- document about the people whom you placed at the disposal of Globocnick. has Wirt among the people you placed at the disposal of Globocnick? I mean the director of the Brandenburg euthanasia station. A. Ho, ho was not the director of the euthanasia station. He waa the official, the registry official. Q. I mean this Tiirt, who was active in Brandenburg. A. He certainly was not among them, because after the stop of the action in 1941 nany releases wore ordered by Bouhler and it becano super¬ fluous, if I nay call it that way, to maintain the registry offices, and also other offices became superfluous. For instance, wo no longer needed trail,cd nursoa; therefore, a groat number of eaployeos of the euthanasia organization were either dismissed or insofar as they wore put at our disposal only thoy woro sent back to their old officos. Q. Right, but did you say that Wirth was acong then or not; Wirt? A. I assume with certainty that ITirth cannot have boen among than because 7,1 rth was a police officer and os such was sent back and put at the disposal of his superior agency in August or Septaobor 1941. Q. What about Schumann? He was the chief doctor in a euthanasia station, wae he not? A. Yes, Schumann was the head of the euthanasia station. 1 saw him for tho last time on the occasion when wo tried to roscue the wounded in the hintor 1941-42. Q. ’..as Schumann among the doctors you put at the disposal of Himmler for tho examination in the concentration camps? A. I put no physicians at the disposal of Himmler for the purpose of the extermination of Jews. Q. No, I said examinations in the concentration camps. We men¬ tioned this in your interrogation and you spoke of it in your direct lamination and also with mo on Friday. This examination which was carriid out on orders from Hinder in different concentration camps. Did ycu not say that 7733 19 Jfey ii7—!7D-3—2—Maehan (Int. Easier) Court No, 1 73 U wtxxt to T-i; and asked that certain doctors be rut at the disposal of KLanlor and that aaon? thee was Schaannn slcnp with other doctors for the examinations in concentration cacpa? A I have already said that I transmitted this request of Hinder to th- T-ii, I farther said that-I had no idea who on the part of T-i* was er.trustod with the radical examinations. • * Q Alright, I wjullike to put to you Doconent Ho, 3010, Prosecution Exhibit 503 for identification, Ycur Honors. This is an affidavit of Dr. Oormss, who was also in the Euthanasia pro-ram ns you told us Friday, I nn roa'irr from para-raph two* "In the bo rinnin- of activities in the Euthanasia pro L ’ran I . '.s infornei that Professor Karl Pran’t was tho chief ar.d Viktor Brack the executive head of Euthanasia. I was oonvincod that Brandt was the lea in - spirit and Brack tho operator of tho so-callod Euthanasia. "In Juno 19hl I was orclorod to accompany Dr. Schumann on nn official trip to tho concentration oanp Buchoraral 1. Tho purposo of this trip ms to acquaint mo \*ith tho assi'Tiaont of concentration conp imates for Euthanasia institutions. This was rgr only visit to any corcor.tration camps. Dr. Schumann was shown approximately 100 concen¬ tration camp inmates by tho can? physician in charje an questionnaires filled out. Th.y woro not noroly insane persons. According to iry boat knowle-Jro and belief our ono day visit In tho concentration camp Buchenwald was male at Bran It* 3 order issued by Brack. Police Captain Vfirth, whoa I knew personally and who was a bd.nl- strutivo director In several Euthanasia institutions, told no late in -irnor 19U1 that ho ted boon transferred by tho ’foundation T n ar.l I put to yo'j that wastto four/kttion for Euthanasia oaro.... n to a Euthanasia lifc'itute in tho Lublin aroa." Tin do not kr/wr anythin; about that? A So, I knew nothing about that, ror do I know th t I had sunt ..“h rnjj. to tho Bueh .ramld 'xowiontrvtiun »y«p. i? toy I7-:-itD-3-3-toehan (Inti Realer) Court No. 1 q Is the narw ,r or~en faiiliar to you, o-n? A Tq3. Q You know .rho ho is, will you toll the Tribuml who :fer*on is? A Daring the trial hjro tho tostinony of Morgan was sherm to x by ry defense counsel end for that reason I know that Morgen was a feraar SS ^uigo and testified bofore tho International !tLlitary Tribunal. Q As a defense witness for tho SSj iid he not? A I don't know that. Q He was a defense witness for tho SS organisation and I would liko to road to you parts of his testinory here. This is Document Ho. 2611:, Prosecution Exhibit $Ch for identification. Your Honors. D3. SSRVATHSl (Counsol for tho dofenJ&nt Karl Brandt) «r. 9 Prosidont, in oonnootton with tho Docunont No. 3010, I roa.rvo tho' ri:ht to call the witness Gorgass to tfw stan'. in order to examine hin in cross-oxanination. I shall aako a written application to that offoct. This is again ona of th: documents wheroin is stated by tho witness that it was undo dear to hin that Professor Brandt played a oor-si datable rolo in that progra*. I should liko to at lsast havo ono of tho witnesses hero in orior to have hin toll us Ju3t exactly what was dono horo and what was nado cl oar to hin. It is ny depression that a certain mount cf propa -andA was made in connoction with tho nano of Dr. Xari Brandt after ho had with trswr. froa tho Euthanasia pro -ran for a Ion-: time. That is tho reason "hy I want this witness to tostify hero and I shall nako a written application to that offcot. TtE PRESIDENT! If tho counsel for the lofonlant Karl Brandt will filo M3 application it will bo promptly acted upon by tho Tribunal. BY CAPTAIN HXJHCAlDl 3 Ian reading frea the last answer on pa-o two, Tour Honors. ■Hhen "irfch took over tho oxtorsdmtion of the Jews, ho was alrca iy -i specialist in .asa destruction of hurr.n beings He had previously -•uric ' out the task of rs*»vir. - the incurably insane. On bohalf of the 19 :ay 17—?^JB-3-W•:achan (Inti Raalor) Court !io. 1 Fuehrer himself, through the Chancellory of the Fuehrer.." and the Chancellory of the Fuehrer was 9ouhler*s officoj wa3 it not? "....«t the he-;inr.lir; of the war he had set up a detail probably fron a. or.ts an J spies of tho criminal police, "irth doscribod how ho wont about carryin- out this assignment. Ho roceived no aid, no instructions, but had to Jo it all by himself. Ha was dvon an insti¬ tution in Brandenburg. There he undertook his experiments. After nuch consideration and nary individual expordnonts, he oamo to his later system, and then this systeta was used on a laryo scalo. "A oorioission of loctors previously investigated tho filos, and thoso insano who wore consi' , .orod to be incurablo woro put or. a separate Hat. Thon tho institution ono lay was told to send thoso patior.ta to another institution. Prcn this institution, tho pationt was tran3forre 1 a tin, efton aoro than onco. Finally ho came to "lrth's institution, "hero ho was killod by pas an i crccntod. "This, system which dQcoivol tho institutions and aado them unknewinc accomplices, this system that ho worked out with vory few assistants for boin a bio to oxtordnnto lar.o numbers of people, this sy.tm was now enployod with a f tills statonsnt of horgen rofers. In tlio yorr 19J,h tho dofondaat Brad: had boon with tie arny for two yon to .v'n in tho yoar 191*3 ho had boon thcro for ono yc.T. I think it is ono af tlio nest prinitiro requirenonts for tho prosecution to ascertain -•hat yoar the statements refer to. A. SCCKDALD: I think Dr. rroosc'.uiann is at liberty to uso tliia ••'volo document , so ho can as contain free tho docunant irhatovor ho TTx.t3. It is tho right of tlio Prosecution to put to tho -..-itnos3 quo3tions fron a part of tho docunant. *JE SRESIDEHT: It is, hewevor, only fair to the witness to give * tho witness all of tho inforaation tlio dccuaont discloses. D.w, ISXSiAIDj Tour Honors, I certainly ‘.rill. -E .T^SIDE:r: "ounscl for tho Prosecution will ascertain as soon - ?’ ssiblc to That ye ortho wit no 3 3 was testifying to whon he gavo the -ceir thich is before tho Tribunal in tho transcript. 7738 25 liay (Sasuor) Court SO* 1 DR. HOCJT-JU: I shall do so at tho ©arliost possible nooant. tit:essx A. To rhat extent this roport of l.'irth's to ..orgon corresponds to tho foots I cannot judgo in any ray. Oao thing, however, is Tiitc clear. Hhet he has dose rib od as Ms activities and particisbLcn in tho outhonasia progron does not correspond to tho facts, bocauso ’ ’irth was employed as a rogistrary official and os such had to do office,work arc could in no way have tho possibility of actively participating in tho euthanasia. That was cxolusivoly tho task of tho responsible physician and nov .r t;» teak of tho civil servant. To that oxtont his infor.aatlon regarding 3 rnndonburg nust bo altogether faloo as f.or as I can Judge, m ill. KCCX AID i » 1 , You rvivor oooperated in tho prograa of oxtomination of tho Jowa, is that correct? A. Ko, I p^rsorally never did, f>. Is tho nooo -ichran, Ctooroturnbannfuchror Adolf "ichnann, fax d liar to you? ... Tea, the nano bccano Imorn to ao now. j, Tcu didn't knonhin b of ore? That ;x..ans during tho war ? ... :ro, not to ny knowlodgo , :. uid you knor anything about Ids activitiesdurint tho '.-nr, Iron your 05.71 lomlcdgo, not rhat 70 U heard now? I cannot reexmbor over haying hoard tho naao Eichnan before, Q. In ord.r to keep the record straight I -,ould like to offer doourent He. 2737. ‘bis is an oxcorpt of tho Judgment of tho Intc»- national Military Tribunal "bout tbc activities of ^ichnon and I mild liko to 3k tho Tribunal rhothcr I sliould givo an identification rrarfcor to this docui»nt or nhotior the Tribunal will take Judicial notice of the docunor.t? TIE 3SIDE;.Ts .nilo the Tribunal’in take Judicial notice of the 7739 15> :iy I;7-» oxtornin- otior. inatitutiona," q. Did you over havu any conforoncos or dismissions with Eichnnnr. concerning the oxtemination of tho Jews and tho solution of tho Jewish problen? ... I already said that I did not. re. o.bor having heard tho nano Eic'.cmnn at all, . I rant to put to you document Jfe, 997, which is Prooocuticn Exhibit 5C6, for identification, ycer honors. This is a uraft of £ lettor firm the Reich minister for tho Occupied Eastern Torritcrio3 to the Reich Comtssioner for tho East: "Solution of tho Jewish ProbiflB* ".-.of ere nee: Tour report of i Cctcbor 19U1, concerning tho solution of the Jewish prcfclca. 29 -j L7-:^r-l^-C^ok (Rainier) Court Ho. 1 • •I have no objection against your sucyestion for the solution of the Jewish problem. Attached please find a naaorandua con- sc.-nlng the conversation between aj roforent .jrtagcrichtsrct 3r. .otzol, Oberdierstleiter Brack fror. the Chancellery of the fuehrer and Ctuxrfcannfuehrer *ichnan, roforent to the Reich Security I Hr. Qffico. Fror/ this noao,please be advised about the do tails of the natter, "ill you, please, ta!:o tho accessary steps at tho Roich Security -Air. Office ard rith "bordionstioitor Brack fro a tho Chan¬ cellory of the Fuehrer via your ichor SS and Police leader. Plcnro hoop no irloraed. (.’iandrritten) F.D. H.il. (For tho .sinister) (3) Copy (A) Roich Security liain Office (B) Chancellory of tho *uehror Attention: Cbordionstloitor Brack, Copy of (1), iacudin;- onclosuro for infcnation." J id you rocoive a copy of t!da lottor. A. .ay I first nek you what tho date of thialottor ia? :. Only 19U1 Is rwitionod here, ^ut this ia the date of tho draft that ia mat I told you. Did you reooivo a copy of thia lottor, Herr Brack? .. I did not rocoive a co;«y cf it nor did I even soo a copy of that letter nor do I :mow t'.da Airteccrichtsrat ~otzol. ;. 3id you have conforonco with Rich_i*inn on this problon, on tho solution of the Jewish questinn? ... I already 3aid I ca/oiot ovon rouonbor tho nanc lic’.iaann , nor K * can J rcccnber tho nano otzol. .. J o you knew ponothins about tho natters discussed at this c- rforonco as to tha solution of the Jewish prcblor.? .. Ko, I know nothing. 7741 19 ..ay li-5-coot(Rac2lcr) urt :.*o. 1 You have no ido:. Y?u never na o any suggestions ns to "hat kind of treatment or what hind of gas chambers should ho used for the solution of the Jewish Trebles? Ini r.evor did do .that? A. I can rc.'flsber noting in this connection. •. You wore auostiorod by '>.0 Trite r.al,quostionod by tho Tribunal Inst Fridy, as to whether » arm -cm node for the construction of tho gas chanters in tho outhanasia stations or whether tho onginc-or or specialist uasordor.d to :ssirt iho directors of *-he stations in sotting up such gna chanbc.-3, xraro you .lot? A. Ics. i. You rero not otle to givo any information to tho Vribrnnl on that fact, roro you? No, I "assaying I didn't concorr. rryoolf with those mttors. 77L2 Court So. 1 19 Key 47-K~2-l-££k-Gross (Easier) v -• the nano Eallneyer, K-e-l-l-c-e-y-c-r*. faniliftr to you? A. Yes, hut I really don't know Just where he belongs. Q. Ele wife executed aa Affidavit for you here, that is your Pocu- t-Gros6 (Hauler) a. I should oven like to uelntain that misuse, terrible nieuso, vas .^de vith =y naae. I sue frcn this letter end free the date of this letter thrt all thuse negotiations wuro carried out at a tine vhen I was fer away free Berlin, vhen I wts on sick lerve. If I have the possibility, I hope I shall be able to bring witnesses vfco vill testify to thrt effect. I oust openly adr.it thpt at this period of tine something was going on which van entirely in contradiction to Ty opinion but that ft this Pnly could be done under nieuec of :;y nano and ".y agency. I did not declare igrsolf ready for these things. q. Can you tell no, Kerr Brack, whore Hig/ and Minsk aro located? A. Elga is in tho Baltics in Latvia, end i.lnsk is in Huecir. Q. Xheso two places wore outside of Oor-.any, were they not? A. Yus. Q» Prosecution has no further aucstlons rt this tiro. IKS PELS I DEBT! The Tribunal will now bo in rocor-s for a few nimitos. (A rocoss wrs taken.) 19 Hay l7~<-ATD-7-i- ialqy (Xnt. Rasler) Court to. 1 TIE !LvRS3.X: The Trijur-.il is again in session, 'n. JDC-T.JD: If the Tribunal, please, I would like to ask the witness two or throe no re questions. THF. PRESIDENT: Counsel nay ;iroceed. CR3S3-EX.J-TM.nOH (continuod) 97 IP., H3CH17ALD: Q Herr Brack, whor. you made ycur report, vour first roport on sterilization to Rimlor in Kirch 19U1, this is Document 203, M) 203, Proeecution Exhibit, No, 161 on page 35 to 37 of Document 3ook 6, Your Honor, You woro 7ery interested in tho quostion whothcr the people ':oinr to bo otorillzed would knew -.rhothor they are storllizod or not, would rir. kncwlodge of this procoduroj is that correct? A Ho, that was Hisuler's wish, Q That ttoy should not know? A Yon, That tho people shouldn't notico it, 3 Lot's turn new to Document 2U5, which is in tho same book on P you di ! not answer ny question? 77A7 Court Ho. 1 19 May 47-ii-8-l-£EK-keehan (Vos Schoen) A. I did answer It. Q. la this the only explanation you can give for this? A. I cannot give any other explanation. All right, you naned hert six cuthenaaia stations, as far at I can rone-:ter? A. Tea. Q. Mil you toll the Tribunal vhero theso euthanasia. stations vere located In Gerry my? A. I told the Tribunel that. -ill you repea.t that pler-ae, ec far cs you can? A. Grofcncclc vea in Vuartter.herg; hadr.iar wa in Reason; Sonnen- atoin vaa in Saxony; Harthcir. w*a in Austria; Brandor.burg nonr Branden¬ burg, and Bornburg in Deeaau or in Anholo noar Dessau. ^ Can you toll no what concentration ca-:pa wro in tho vicinity of thceo dlfferont euthanasia stations? A. Ko, X cannot. Q. Do you know, for instance, how for or whether it is true or not that Kauthauaon was in tho vicinity of Kartholr.? A. So, Kauthauaon is near Linx. Q. Ar.d where is Ear tho in? A. Yob, Ecrtholrj is also near Lin?. Q. You know that Kerthcln la not far fror Aouthauaen? A. I assure ao. I » nev^r at rtnuthnueon, I don't know exactly where it was. If they cay kauthauaon la near Lins, I know that Hart- heir. is not frr rvy fron Lins and then kauthausen is not frr iron Lin. <<. Vk/it dc you know about the location of the Grosa-Eosen concen¬ tration canp? A. The Groas-Roson ceno is in Slleaic; I hcv» learned thr.t now. Hov far is that froa Bornburg? A. I really don't know - two hundred, three hundred, or fcur hur.drod kilonetera. 77L8 Csurt So. 1 19 stay 47-H-8-2-i34-*taefcan (7cn Schoen) Q, bhct About the locetion of BucheawddT A. I don't lenov. i-r.eehaa (Ten Season) of reel living. Aa far as I, as a layman, can judge, there were very serious operations which night be fatal. Q. 'ell then, the fact that tne child via placed in the inotitution would not the doctor* larediately endeavor to restore the child to none- thing like e norael state aa soon as possible? A. I an. sorry, I did not understand your ouestion, Your Honor. *.hat do you Bean, a noraal *ay of life; yroocod with tho oxunination of tho witness first. BY DH. PR02SCHU.JJH: I should Just liko to jot t:y doouaont. lir. Prosidont, I have only a very few quostions to rut to the v/itnoss Brack ’oasod or. tho cross oxadnation which has Just boon con¬ cluded. . Witness, tho Tribunal has asked you whether you wore over .rosont at outhnnasia of incurably insane in nontal institution.;, and you said "yos." Whon you woro prosont or. such occasions of euthanasia on insano, did you take any active part in tho kill in.; of those insane persons, -van by only r.ani. ulr.tin ; sonc lover or any other kind of nachinory? - Mo, I did not participate. That was u 4 to tho doctor, witness j froti tho quostions of tho Tribunal, I boliovo to huvt. path.-rod that the Tribunal has a certain assuu tion that tho jas chaab^rs in which euthanasia was porfomod on 7753 I'.y 19--i:-3K-9-3-CQok (let. Von Schocn) Court I»o. 1 incurably insane persons could be token apart end coved to other places. In answer to the question of the Tribunal, ycu tried to r.akc it cloer that these ohonbors" - xrhaps the tern was not v-ry fortunate - were 3olid ports of tho buildin,; of the cuthan;sia institution, is that true? .. Yes, that is correct, it was a rooc which was fron tho very boGinnlnj an or;er.ic part of such a building. . Thon if thoao cos chr.nbors should havo boon dismantled, then is it true that nothing would have boon loft but a hoa;: of ruins as i3 nado of a building aftor an air raid? .. .»s for as I oan Jud ; ;o It would have boon aotually technically ia.ossible. One would have had to renovo a ;iooo fro:; a house. That isn't possible. 1 Thon it wu3 not tho caso thet thoso parts of the build¬ ing oould hnvo boon loaded on c truck onu rcooved in ono .ic co? No, that would hr.vo boon quito impossible. But you, witno33, pointod out that tho pipos oonsis tod of tho seno sort of . ipcs that can bo bought onywhoro in tho world for vory littlo oonoy? .. It was a pipo suoh cs is . used for wntor or jas any- ■<out 200,000 part-Jews. Witness, do you knew of any data fron tho Statistical Year Book which were far below your ostinato? .. ..t that tine I knew of no statistics. : Then you v-ry carelessly avc tho fi:;urc for which yo.u had no official evidence, is that correct? 7755 - y 19-i.:-i5K-9-5-Cook (Int. Von Schoon) Court Ho. 1 .» Yes, that is true, but I will state I need evidence ond I don't have any. ■i Then you should say: "I don't know." In any case, according to tho cvidcnco which I hnvo obtainod in the noontide there wore at tho cost one uillion Jews and pnrt- Jews. DR. UOCBJ.JJ): If the Tribunal Alonso, tho Prosecution objoots against this kind of questioning. Dofonso oounsol hos not ;roduood a docunent showlnc that tho ossuni>tion of tho witness was wron , tho nunbors given by defense counsel any bo oorroct. I rxi not able to oheok it. THo. PitliiliJiSNT: Tho Tribunal understands that. Counsel has singly offorod thoso fi ,-uros and if tho Prosecution u.'on investigation believes thoso figures to bo incorroot, it mny introduce ovidonoo if it desires to tho oontrery, and if it ngroos that thoso figures nro a •>. roxinntoly oorroct, it aay 30 state later on. The figures given by dufunso counsel nro in no wiso binding u;>on anybody at this tine. Dll. HOCH...LD: Thank you, Y 0 ur Honor. Court So. 1 13 Kay -47-&-10-l-G£S~vro*« (Von Schoen) ST m. THCiSCHHASS: Q* Tho next oue.it loo. The Jodge al6C a eke* you Aether and to vrat extent veterans of tho Vorld Var 1914-1918 were Included in euthanaaia or were tc be included. Do you recall this Question? A. Tes. Q. Tho Judge pointed out that insanity is said to be connected vith a brain injujy. As you have repeatedly said, you aro not a doctor. I ooroly wsr.t to ha'e you elariiy ono po-_nt. That is, vhat veterans of Vorld W*r 1914-1918 vero to b< exeapted free euthanasia. I would liko a very dew, precise answer. A. These were to be excepted in whose cases the insanity vao tho result of any injury incurred during tho Vorld V a r, rcgardlecs of whether it wrs • brain injury or any other typo of injury. Q. That *.s vhat I wanted to know. The Court also asked you whether there was a central offico in the Party or la tho Eolch for couipping tho gas chasbors; on whoso instruc¬ tions th«so gas chanbors woro set up in tho varlouo euthanasia institu¬ tions. I ask you, and plcaco answer this ouostion with "yes" or "no", was tnoro such a central offico in the Eelcht Do you know that it organized the gas chaabcrs according to a certain plan, a certain rehene. A. Ho, there was no such offico. !<. You were also asked hov could tho head of an euthanasia institution hit upon the idea of installiivT a gas chaaber in his Institution for the purpose of euthanasia. I ask you, do you know when the idea of the use of gas cane up in the deliberations of the M doctors, the exccrts? A. I really don't reneaber that. Q. Do you rezeeber that originally tho idea was that those incurably insane persons were to be given an injection of nornhino or secething el=ilar7 A. I inforaed thcc. At first it was said that the cetients were to bo given sooe drug, whether it was an injection or pills I don't 7757 19 Yiy-”-GSS-10-2-Gr cs (V r. 3ch r.) C urt r . 1. *• 1 ronorbor whoa and nr. n>de thr su *-.-sti n t-> B uhler •hit th.t w Kl-I be l^o.eibln >r that ;as ah vU bo used «v r thor r >i* r.s. Th-.t w-.s o ,-urclv Radical o'-tter. iJ» thor quoatin In this c nr. eti-c. D y.u r d v u " j rolv '.»»■ th-.t B uhler cs“the rr.r. nl.n- res; nsiM f r lutht-aftsio ~' 7U iaatructl ns t the h.-ods 'f the ncstr.l inatituti na t build such chaabora. t have then built Ur th ir 1 c.l aoeJ.anies? B uhlor ’l • n t iivj suoh inatructi ns. E uhler 'id n t toko anv -*iroot intorcat In what w.nt n In tho inatituti n. The inatituti na ,w un '- or tho - inistrv f Intori r. Tho Unistrv f jntori r rwo noooaaorv instruct!. na .a t wfc t hrt bo d aw. ?hit « i in 1937. That was nr t quite clear fr r. •• ur toatir. «y ' f ro. la it cl mr nvth'tyu ■< id th- t nlrc- iy y.u w ro f th ; ini n th t it ■is the : iniatr" f the Ir.teri r which pvc inatructi na t. heads f nenMl inetltutca nl ut technie.'l mttora c noornin; the inourably inaonol H w # i ah uld like t into relate • r.j briof queati n. • '.■hon did y u visit r. c noontrati n cunj 7 “* Oneo in ny life I saw n 0 noontr ti n on:. Thit was ir. 1937- 10Z*. Th-t r.s car; Ornnlonbur/. Th.t war the uly tin . !. Th n in maw r t tho qu«st: n f th rr-ai'ont y u at ted thnt in th vrl ua diacucai na nnd ;rolinin:rio* l>of ro ’ u w re t Id th-t tho roia n -n 1 tho r. tivo f r euthanasia, r r-th-.r yu f It that the rons n and r. tivo f r cuthniwsic wss nl- * v/8 •JWpnthy with tho . at lost and tho idea -f rale no in - than fr n th,ir sufforin » that y u never had inv ther roia.n, f r oxinflo Maloney, i 5 thr-t truo? ••• lea, thit is truo. .n-' th-. quest: n was -Is hr j- ht uj durin-- y ur axaninctf n *h th r Hitler in v tu - ini n c uld deei do ab ut th- life f th.- ln- with ut tho c nsent f th- rclr.tiv-o. Ia it tru-.- n‘ ! »ub< •r - ht wont n r.t th t thnt the s nsont f rolutiv s f the ins-.n- n- ana n -1 « nai-’croJ dceireMo s th t nv ; -rs n 1 int.-r.tl ns f r 1 ' tlv ' 8 ' ^inst s- ek ;-.rs ns c vld b .lirdrated — • ny intent! na 775C ’S " -y-I'—10— S-Gr ss r. 3ch r. C urt 3.1. f bt'-inln,- the ,r pert*’ f nJletlv s ty brin -in i v .ut the rolrtiTo's cnrly death? ... * th u-ht I h-.-* alr-nd" s-id thefc that w-.e the acne rena n why !-ct r in th; instituti n c I.', r. t ;. 5S *u‘.-n-nt n th i quo at 1 nnair.s f his ■wa patients, in r ’or t olinin-te nny • saibllitv f intor.ti as t" >btoin tho r utrtv f th« ir.S'in* pers n. * ..nd un thor auhj ct hr u ht uj *.« tho Pro a i’net. Ia it true th-.t in outhanaaia f inoumMy lnsr.no iftor th quoati nniir- h: ’ been filled • ut on«• Jumped b” ox; orts end t j ox’.orta, tho ..oioh Vinlstor f Tntorl r, Lin’en’s ffioc, assigned th: incur'. My inanne «rs ns t- bs mti n instituti ns 'tv' 1 tor t ovthnnaaij instituti r.a? •. los, thr.t is trad Q. Is It trim that in th ; r c«i)<'in s bof*ro tho .t-.ioh C rroittoo nfcioh la crqhrisizln- th ox.-rt, th. fin-.l oxnort wh rnaso-l n tho quoatl-'&nairua nasi.-nr ! tho .rtior.t thr «u h Linden t th . Ilyich C rritt-o stnt! n? u. I 1 nt. bivt wh-.t oxtoat tho d ct>r -ivinr the tror. tenant in! tho d ot r aasi-ninr th» ;otir.t t tho irctituti r. ires tho final rx : rt, f r T •• n t kn w Linin's ays tea nn * .r e* durv in tho x.oich - mittoo. C. But la it tru th'-t n -oncr-.l ; rlnci. 1 n snoh child c "Id k o nasi,Tied t th- “oioh C mitt re at ti n with ut tho , nrunta h'virv* ‘.rori uslv b-»in* ex. licitl" .ski-! whether th v c naontod t this ssl. nn r.t orn with th'. *cn * r thit •>, n rr'lic-ti n : » 1 rn *h.cra;v tho child ni ht -let ... »:e, thr t is wh’t hi:; -no- end tht ia wfc:>t I X, Ini no*! to thr Tribune 1. %. In t ia e nr-.cti-n, !'r. rival V.nt, I ah uld lit t rcrfir nor ~ rr t ny exhibit Br-ch -11. It c nt ins th a .nt-.nc : Sinor n rlneijlo Id n t -ssim. cMl J ror. t th. .Mich C r-itt-.o St ti n ins* th c nsont f th :r<-nts, 1 ah ul’ lit t cnaidor th- c- sj ■ th- Fr-nx chil' scttl 1 ." ■'ltn-ca, r - ir. »n • rsx r t th quoati n - tfc. “ri'.iur .:1 -.s t why J.xa w.ro t >■ cxerrtod fr r _»-thrn:ai<: v u 7759 15 !'-.T-J!-C3S-10-4-Gr ss (7 - Sch r.) C -urt K . 1. atotoA thrt oothannsla ms o nsi-iorof* o 1 m no fit which sh -ul<* n t be iron t<* Jaws. Tr»s th:t v ur ;crs ml -ini n r wes th-.t tho !is- t rtod *; ini -n -f Hitler? ... Th't ie what I oan eav ob ut it n w. I con nly iraw tho c nclusi r. r-w 1 kin - heck; t wh;.t extent these c nolusi ns bel n>- t* th fc-t I ’ n’t kn w that ni -ht hr-vo been uroly y -litioal. Q. " itn.'ss, ”-u hero n t nnswero'’. ny quosti 1 n yet, whoth r this ini r. y u her-- ox; res set*. hire was v ur ,o.-s nal ;:ini n r whether t u were -sort t this ini n? ... K , th.it was n *. ty ; rs ml *j ini r.. The so ire nv o n- olusi ns. Ur .y lS-il-BK-ll-l-Korrc*; (Int. Von 3choonJ Court; No. 1 . Now, I cor.--- to the crces oxminntion of tho Prosecutor hinsolf. I con bo vory brief. • H.JDY: Hoy it ploaso Your Honor, inusnuch as defense counsel is join; to n now subject I have scoothinj to take u* with the Tribunal. If you will poroit no to do it at this tine when it will be r.ost convenient. Sovorol nonths '.jo tho Proscoution was concornod with looatinj Dr. Dujon Hajon - th t is, tho sono Dr. Ha ;on who worked at Strasbourg nd Natawoilor. Durin ; tho courso of several nonth3, Dr. Hr. ;on wus located and tho Prosecution then did not t.ako forward sto::3 to have hin brou .ht dirootly to Number ;. In tho r.eantiuo, tho defense counsel requested Ha;jon zb a witness. Hrv;on has 'rrived hero now in Number;; and is classified as a '..rosoout ion witnoss." Due to tho ovor- 3iht of the . ro3ocution to call hin as th.-ir witness, and inusnuch as defense couns-l did call hin .:o a witness, tho .ro3ocutim now relinquishes their rijht to o.:ll Hr.jen and will r*ivo the dof-nse counsel the o...ortunity to intorro.jato hia first. ,.t the con., let ion of tho interrogation by tho I’.vfonoo counsel, if they do not soc fit to oall hin hero before the Tribunal ns c witness, then we should liko to have tho opportunity to oxar-ino hin. Duo to the foot that thi3 chonjo of c.atojory has arisen, defenso counsel is in a position wherein they nust potiticn the Secret iry General which nu3t bo done n reasonable tine before thi3 .articular intorro^ation. Dr. Ti_ t tho defense counsel for Bockor-FroysoUs, is not in a position to do thi3 at this cine because hi3 case with Bccker-Fr .ysen;; will bo jin either 1 to today or tonorrow, and he would like to interrogate -r. Ripen this evening; so if th- S^orcttry General c n a-.ko • note t j ch. n ;e the classific tion of Ha jen fron a "..rosocu- *-r. " to a "defense" witnoss, then I understanii Dr. Tipp 7761 1! .y 19-ii-BK-ll-2-Karrow (lac. Von Schocn) Ccurc No. 1 c a carry out his intentions without any interference. n-U P.iJSIIEHT: Hay I horr froa defense counsel. D... ri?r (Defense Counsel for the defendant Booker-Frey- suaj): I will bo -rntcful, Ur. President, if the Tribunal should toko notico of this dooision of the prosocution end should u3k the General secretary to n.ako this dooision tod;, and, if possible, during the noon rocoss and to infora lioon 57 30 that I onn sponk to Ur. Hn*;on tonight nlror.dy. Th :t is tho only foraulity which still has to bo sottlod. TIL. P.iaSIDiaiT: In vIm of the stntononts by tho ..rosoou- tion r.nd counsel for tho defendant Bockor-Fruysonj, it is satisfactory to tho Tribunal to have tho oounsol for Bcokor Frcy3on ; interview tho witnoss c.t noon and put hin on tho st nd tomorrow or this ovonin if possible. IL». H..DY: j.a I understand it,, Your Honor, it isn’t tho iurposc of dofohso counsel to call Hv;on h^ro as a witnoss now. Ho Just wants r. pre-trial intorrojation. THJ P.LX3ID12IT: Th. t an y be porcittod. Dofenso counsol ar.y interview the witness this noon or thi3 ovonin^ caid o;.ll hin c3 c witness if ho desires. H.„J)Y: In order to ox.odito natters, if the Tribunal would request Ur. Travis, the Secretary G.. nor cl of this Court to clarify thi3 discrepancy in tho Secret jy Qonarcl's Orrioo, thon Dr. 'iipp oan acko his nrrrji^oDont without too nuoh trouble. ~:L1 P.iZ3IDT2JT: The olork of tho court will inform the oocretr.ry General. I would surest that counsel for tho * .rosocution and for tho defendant acoonpnyy the clork of -no court to the office of the Secretary General so that tllc entire natter will bo clarified at one tine, and every¬ body bo advised. 3a. TIPP; Thank you. 7762 h r cy I9-£I-3K-ll-34Carrow (Int. Von Schocn) Court No. 1 D... F.vO^SCHU.i.lI: Mr .y I continue? i'HJ xicBSlDENT: Counsel any .rooccd. 3Y 2.. F.tOESCHIUiN: - Witness, in cross examination, .1 number of documents •<-re shown to you and I have a vory few final questions about thosw doouncnt3. Is it true that in Document NO-8799, Exhibit 497., it mentions tho "..ktion Hoydo” in the F a ll of 1941 and t at you knew nothing about it until tho moment this document was submitted? ~ I know nothin;; about ‘’..ktion Hoyde". w Is it true th-.t you did not know anything about tho "-.ktion Len^o" either whioh is in Exhibit 500, of tho Fro- socution , Document N0-890 9, until this document was subnit tod hero? “ No, I know nothin; about it. w Mr. Prosidont, from tho moment I took this oaso I have tried to clarify r.s objectively as possible all natters which accused or oxcusod tho defend nt Brnok. In tho last fev; days, 3 Lace this docuoont h.s boon submitted, I hr.vo boon tryin; to tr.aoo this "..ktion Lnnju" throu;h witnossos, booauso I ex; still lookin'; for that one person who is responsible for .Jetien 14-F-13. I *sk for permission that until my colloncuos hnvo ooncludod their eases I nay oan- tinuo to 3ubait ovidonoo, porhc.s .affidavits, to ol^ify that "-.ktion", booauso I an interested in havinj evon tho 3lijhtc3t suspicion of tho defendant Brack, on tho basis of these docuaont3, refuted. THE P.G3IDENT: Tho TriounrO. jrents tho .-emission roquost- -d by counsol. Da. HOCHm.ID: llr.y it _loaso Your Honor, if Dr. Frooschnnnn ^ouid desire to .resent affidavits as .to tho question of -ktion 14-F-13" in evidence it should bo in a time when 7763 yry 19-M-3iC-ll-4-KarrGW (Int. Von 5chocn} Court No. 1 Che prosecution is still in the position to c.-.ll the witness for cross-cxnnin rtion. TiL: KCS13SZTS: That is certainly true. Those unttors will hr.vc to be nrranp^d in r.ccordnnco with the circumstances do, endin'; u; cn each individual c .sc, but nn opportunity v.ill bo cccordod tho prosecution - and accorded the defense co call witnossos up to the tir.e that tho evidence is closed undor c ire urns t moos which nro f .ir to both sides. D.t. HOCili.XD: Tho only thin; I wnntod to point out is if twenty-four hours boforo tho closin.; of tho enso, an affidavit la subr.ittod by oith~r tho prosecution or tho dofonsc, tho o.posito party is not in u position to call the witness for cross examination if the witness can not be produced boforo tho Tribunal in such a 3hort tine. TIK P.uSIDi2JT: Ye3, that is truo and thoro would have to bo r. docdlino fixod boyond whioh such affidavits or wit¬ nesses could not bo offered, of course. D.c. HOCH./.XD: Thank you. Dil. ?,i02SCKM.JEJ: Hr. President, I shall oortainly act in accord with tho .rosocution on that procedure sinco I *; only ;ratoful to thor. for the docur.ents which they havo 3abr,itted today. ST D.i. F.tosscituai: ' witness, I don't know whether you noticed a little word this norninj which the prosecutor used in asklnj one question. He asked you about your letter on sterilization plans, ric t3kod you who thor you wanted T ’to avoid scill more ruthlosfl coesuros." The word is "Still". Do you understand ao? You 3 -id in your interrogation that with your supjestion you want¬ 'd to prevent tho brutal measures of a Him lor aid at least --lay th:c. You answered this question to the _rosecutor in -he affimativo, and with this answer you vculd admit that your suj jest ion could already be considered fii ratiloss. uur 'J -«y 19-^i-BK~ll-5-iCarrow (Iat. Von Schoon) C,urtt No. 1 ru-suro while, nccordinj to you, it was somethin; entirely iifforont, that is, to faring Kixnlor frets his intention to use ruthless methods. I ask you, do you intond to adnit -bat with your su~ ostions you. wantod "to prevent ruthless measures but not still noro ruthless measures?" .. I should like to formulate that very oonorctoly a join. I wanted, as fur \s possible, to prevent or at least re¬ direct all no '.suiViS. I o-.n't say it any other way. . Is it r.l3o true cs yoiffanswer to the quostion of tho .rosocutor just indicated, if I understood it correctly, that you were convincod of the complete inofficioncy of your sterilization su ppstion? ••• I believe I explained cloarly that I was convincod that the suggestions oould not bo carried out in .-rcotico. . Tho prosecutor also askod you, roferrin ; to tho offoct that you su;;;ustod tho sterilization of two to throo million Jjws, what vr.s to bo dono -with tho other sovon nillion Jews. Tor you, in your official capacity, was thoro any obligation to try to frustrate Hitler'3 or Hinder* s plan to oxtominnto tho Jews? Yes or no? No, there was no obligation. . Tho .rosooution finally submitted documents to you 'orin;in.- you in connection with -ichnann and a Dr. Kallnoyor md drafts by a Dr. ••otzol. Did I understand you correctly th t the none ^iohnonn was completely unknown to you at that -ir.e and that until theso documents wero submitted this horning you kaqw nothin about tho talks which Dr. ..etzol • * or sogo one else is sup osod to have h--ri with Obordionst- 1“ iter Brack in 19x1? - "ntil those documents were submitted I hod no knowledge of I con not ovon remember the nano of Dr. ./etzol or '-tzler. . ”r. Brack, is it true that in the course of our many 7765 — ’.'zy 19-11-3K-11 -S-K err ow {Int. Von Schoen) Court No. 1 conrorsr.t ions I nysolf contior.cd the none Sicbc-nn, to lr .! find out if this ^ichmonn hod any plans for the cxtoriaina- ^ion of tho Jews, and is it true that I node an a.plioi:- Ci°n to 0 -11 this i-ichnanrr cs a witness on your bohr.lf; thzt this up. lication was G_rovcd, end that it was only iiscovjrod later that l*ichr:nnn was dond? .. Yes, that is true. - My final question. ..t tho end tho prosecution askod you whothur the sentence in the socond letter of tho 23rd of Juno 13-42 'it nakos no difforonco whothor thoso Jows booono gwoto of sterilization" or sonothinc liko thnt is oonnocted with your first letter? You suid "yos". Is that truo? .. Yos. . I* I r. not mistaken, during your diroct examination, you said that you cade this ronark in tho socond lottor booauso at that tine in 19-12 tho Jows alroady suspootod thoir fate and no indications that storilizntion was intandod would have boon n oossary. Do you undorstnnd ray question? for -:3 I recenher, I said durin; ny direot oxcaina- *.-on that the Jows had an idea of their futo. 776 >. < ■ IS Knv-H-CS-12-l-v-l v (lot. V n Soh on) c urt l. ..r.d =v vor^ finr.l quest! n, the Fr secut -r this n rnln,- sj ko f D cur r.* :ro - 126 , i-erha: s I rev f mulate : 11 , f the statomnts la • l is no quesii a. Is It c • •Vt l' -alit” f Hitlers Deeror f 1st Z •: t« >r 1959? ... I w s firmly c nvincad f tho locality f that r*ocrec. %• ~oro yu awnro th-.t in e llnb-ratin- with the euthanasia ; r -ran y u w iro a raittin : n . oml ffonso? -*• K , I w^s n t awsro I was j .rtleluting in a jenal ffonso. Q. Di • v u act ir full e gnlsonoo «.f the 1 r.lity f wh ;t v u »>ro d-in.-t ... Ins. DF!iOBSCP7V/Qtt ?*r. Prosidont, I hare n further questi ns t- ‘•‘•is witn ss. ?x 7*3 y .S3IX T i a. *itn>6s, ; loose rtosoriV n outhamsia station, f what build¬ ings -’.id it c nsist? ... .. uthanr.sia st-ti n wr.s c nontl instituti *r., f r oxotaplo instituti n - * 3 nr.mstoin. Th-. instituti n t S' -noons to in c nsist- ' f several buildings in a iar/o piece f r un's. In th.so bulld- ir. s wuT' th" a:e ssir;- r ns f r th , : rs nnol, f.r therapy, eto. r euthanasia sfoeifioally n f th s lniil in-s wr.s used. It ro- # ‘ lr.. J as it v s, except that n-- nf theso r rs was arrenrei a •tttennsin r r. I c~n*t *-iscri'>. it in ay thor w y. The euthanasia irctituti ns w r: r t ■'uilt, end the- were instituti r.s lrc'^y in xir*.. r.e- which ir r- used :s cuthat sir instituti ns. . ~»ro th •- lr - cc» i’d by thor sick r ins r.-. pers ns? 7767 1 ? V".v— v -O r S- 1 2-2-Vftloy (v -n Schoon) C urt K . 1. «. H-. *h<> patients w»ro transferred thoro n instructions f r n tte ’’inistrv f the Interior. Q. rrhrt hoi the txiildinrs beer, used f r baf-rc that? That differed. Ono -f then at Oraffonock, I v eliovo w.is o h w f r crip. les rf the Sanaritor P-undati n, and tho inrtitos wore transferred ond tho instituti n was wa do evuilnhlo f r euthanasia. In this c nnneti n t TurttonW - instituti n was turnod >vor fr n tho Turttonhor.• finistr? 't tho Intori r t the Itoich ‘Ministry f tho Intori r. Q. R- w rtny f tho ;crs ns t he subjootod t outhur-osia would bo In such o stati'n at -ni tir»? • I oan't say. Thoro was, f o urso, r' n f r a fr oat noi^, but h w nany wor» thoro ot tho saru tiao I don't Icn*. Q, K-w Ion,- nftcr o shijajnt rf jors ns nrrivod f.t a outhonasin stnti n w ull thoy bo subjootod t- tho outhnnnsio? A. I can only say fr n what the drot r at tho euthanasia in¬ stituti n t Id no. I snid bof re thot 1 was at thoso tuthnnnsin Instituti ns sovoml tiros. I saw ;otlonts wh had boon thoro nly o sh-rt tino f r hservati n by tho outhnensia d ct r, and r ls< patients h»ro thu euthanasia * ot.r trld w. that ho was still in d-ubt as t' shethor ho w till subject then t outhonosio, cr whvthor ho w- uld send then v ack t- th.' bsorv^tirn institution, r thoir ri.-inol instituti n. ?hrt do.ondod n h w 1 r. tho outhnnosia •* etrr nerdod t bsorvo tho individual patent In rdor t f'rn his rwn o nclusi n, because it wos he who ha'* tho final ros. -nsiMlity. <• ~ old thcro bo os runy as 100 'f thoso pors ns in tho T uj f buil-'inre nt bna tirw? ... Thoro wore cortainly buildio-s which would h'uso a hundrod, 1 ‘■oliovo s<. I w uld sav n hundred, yos. Q. ns tho rss ehar.bcr o soporatc buildin >r Just n r-.cta in .-no f the ohor bullin.-s? ... That w.-.s rnly no r n in the buildin.-,. ■<. But it was s r n in tb: buildin.-. and t a sc-crctc ocnstructim? I 19 lfcy-J'-GPS-12-3-Helcy ( v ~n Sehoon) Ccjrt . 1. A. K<-, n«, thcro was a-t o sopereto building «. tihapo was tho ereaotory lccatod? A. That vnriod t'o. In Gmfenock, I beliovo tho cronstoriun was at e‘3io ''iatuncu fr n tho institution, in another fcuildin*-, whilo ot S nncnstoin it w-a in tho min ‘uil’in,-. It vr.riodi I h vo no r°ry clear roc -ll:cti n f that. In Somanatcin I op prottv suro it wr's in tho min building* Q. Jii* thoa ,ar8 na w. ro to bo subjcctod tc outhonaaio, after rominin- aiv'rnl day a in th. buil.'.in- and they woro put in tho r«a chamber, wold Juat think they woro ( yin- t*> h? *lvcn n ah-wor bath? A. I d-r.'t believo thoy had any fdon whero they » ro r. in;- at all. Q. D you noon bocauao they w.ro insane cr icoo*oblo of hnvinc an idea or air.* ly i* they had iei do ;roo of intolllgonoo thoy didn't kn-w whnt waa roinr tc hn; jon? A. Tea, I noant tho foraor. Q. Oc yukrnr nnythin about tho station at Radomr? I h vj elrondy said Ha 'nnr.r ia tho nly atoti* n of which I kn w nothing, boccuao it wr.i tho loat cn*> which waa built. That waa idion I woa no lor.-or isuch ccncomod with thaso things. I think that Ha da rc r wna n-tdo n ovthcnnain inatitution in 19*1. TIE PIESIEEtfTi Has c unsol any furthor quest! ns? DR. FCttSSHK.-KHt Ho, lir. Pro aidant. THE F.JSIDENTi It ia n w tiso f r ur r n roooas. The Tribunal will be in recess until 1»30. (Thcroujcn the no-'n roco3S wna taken.) 7769 1? liy I*7-^-OT-13-l-?oJtcr(Peeler) Court. No. 1 -S' AFTERNOON SESSION (Tho hearing reconvened at 1330 hours, 19 Hay 19k7.) TIE lURSf&Ls -ho Tribunal is again in session* VIKTOR BRACK - Rosuaod KJtDTi -jy it ploaso your !onor, dofonoo counsol havo cdlcd to ry attention that they are desirous of having another nesting concern¬ ing tho submitting of briofs to the Tribunal, “honover it is convenient for tho Tribunal, tho prosocuticn is Trilling to neot with tho dofenso counsel and tho Tribunal. TIE HUSDBHTt Thi Tribunal trill be glad to t»ot with tho caanittco Tron dof onso cousol tonorror afternoon after tho rccoos of tho court at 3:30; also ith tho nrosocuticn. ELL j:- .?!.:: BT T.B COURT (Continuod) BX1HB ry rogrot, I nst object to t»is foxr of <*ro dioning. I Wrink that this nattor --as oxhauatod by toe direct and cross oxarjinntion. El* rhESJSSIT: I rill -*»k dofonso compel for toe Dofondaat Pokorny .c purpose of theso questions j. t. HOPF; l.Nlf (Counsel for f.» Dofowiant Pokorry): :'r. r*es . lont, I should like to go back to too original affidavit "ado b > tho Defendant ‘-.-fxc’.:. There is a cortain discrepancy botooon that affiravit :-“oscnt testiaony. This dlscrotxccy b.t- --nr, tooso too atatcrxnts is r. ry nlsn for too dufonso of ay oliout. For'hah roasot. I 7771 i$ lixf li7-A-^-13-3-c’Mt^(rc3lcr) rgurt So. 1 rantod to ascertain whether the Defendant Brack actually c^ild 'mow aathing about the possibility oT sterilisation by I-rays. ViS HUB DENT: C oun scl nay proceed as rapidly as possible. Counsel ~,v proceed with tho interrogation along that line but .alee it as expeditious as po3siblo, DB.aOWBlNNj Xos, your Honor. WDR. 90PTJUW: -itnoaq I shall onco noro ccno back to tho question >«*ich I havo put to you; on tho basis of your nodical ’.'n«7irlcd-o tfcich , aftor all, you had, Tculdr.'t you havo to havo considered it probablo tlxt one actually could sterillsa hunan bein'? b; noons of "-rays? A. I should like to correct you. I had no nodicrl ’.avyrlod c. Hevrover, I could roly upon fho inforontion given to no by a clinician tfcnu i conoidorod to bo reliablo and who hinsolf had tro'tod no Tdth :;-rnys, ho told :» that danasos to tho genitals by 1 -rc^ aro not . esiblo and if they do ooro about they would piss mray. ThSa pirsician oonfimod that in an affi avit. .. hut that inforuatior. c-s 15 years back, wasn't it? ... ’.few it is 15 yuars apo, but at tf»at tiuo it was only r.ovor. or oirjht years. Horov.r, I an no A-ray rososrehor. . “itnoos, didn't you discuss with tlw Defendant Bokorny, Tile you vroro Ixro, tho reason Wh;- !vj rroto ‘.iia letter? ... "os, I did talk to ol:omy. (. "id hn toll you fer chat reason ho troto tho lcttor-.hich Stas boon subnitted hero as a docunont? £ A. I bolievo to hinted at tho reason. SR. HQFFMlEx Thank you. I havo no further questions. T.2 FPISIDSHT: Argr other questions to bo propounded to t i ritnosa v*» v,o dofenso counsel? oir.co thoro arc no furt.xr questions, the citnass will bo o ‘='-5cd :‘ren tlx srKaiS and rosuno ‘is ylaco. 7772 I 1; 1-7 L7-A-c^-13-fc-- , *«t.'r(J-r) H Court Ho. 1 (Tho witness ras excused.) BE PRESIDENT: Has counsel for the Defendant Brack an. furthor Tidccco to introduce? D?.. FRCESCi£ii\NN( Counsel for the DofowUt Brack): ilr. .d-csidont, I forego tho subaission of tho affidavit in ny Docunont ok No. I, -'ocunont 3, on affidavit b- a certain Arnold Honoig , and tho affidavit in ay supplement 'to. 3, affidavit No. h7, on page 8, rhich is tho affidavit by Kloffol, sinco the prosecution has jivon no no reason to read thoso taro affi Tits, I vnr.t to draw your attontion to cno affidavit, i*r. Prosidont, in oonncctic.n with a nattor rhich carw •-? this morning. This is tho Kallnoycr affidavit. I-.anted to ostabli* frei this affidavit that title iiallao yor at tho end of 19JiO — that in Exhibit Brack 23, knllrcoyor affidavit — I ;r;ntod to cstnblidi that tliis witness says "Freer tho :*oar 1?36 to tho end of 1?!>0 I •.ras onployod .as a clerk in tho •uchrors' Chance lie ry.- 1 ..0 far os I 9 knew , this Kallrviycr rras lawn to t>o Dofondant Brack virtually only under her noidon nano ..ooso, nfortunatcly, 1 can find no indication of that in tho affidavit liovovor, and I should liko to add that information, fh roforo I shall subnit a briof supple¬ mental 3tatonont about that none. 7773 x '• So. 1 19 l ey «7-A-l4-l -EHH--Keshan (Hauler) I have now concluded the submission of evldcnco, hr. President. I fc/ivi triod to establish thet the defendant Brack had hunano motives in carrying out his sterilitetion evxrinents, and furthermore was not involved in the nurder of 50-60,000 insane persons, but that it could only have been - end was - euthanasia. That is ell I have to say and I should r.ov like to conclude ay case. OX rrESIDEET: The effld/vit which you oaitted froa Document Book 1 vas Brack Document 3? Dfc. FRCESCHaAKS: Yes, Brack Document 3, the affidavit of Arnold Kennig. THE PRESIDENT: The defense councel for defendant Brack having rostei his ccse, tho Tribunal r.ov calls the case against the defendant Sockor-ireysung. IR. TIP? (Counsel f >r the defendant Bockcr-Froysong): Hr. President, Dr. Marx, thj dofense cconrel fer tho defendant Bockor-Frcyscng, is suf¬ fering froa tho aftor-offocts of a war injury and vill unfortunatoly bo unable to apocar in court for a few days. Vith the permission of tho Tribunal I shall begin tho examination of the defendant Dr. Bocker- Freycong until Dr. Harx returns, which I think will bo in a far days. THE PRESIDED: Veil, Dr. Tlpp, you are a peering at this tiao at the roauost of Dr. Marx? Dh. TIP?: Tos, Dr. Karr asked no to examine tho vitnesp on his behalf. THE PRESIDE!!!: And with the consent of the defendant Becker- Freyseng? DR. TIPP: Yes. THE PRESIDE!!: Then counsel nay proceed. Dk. TIPP: I should first of all like to call the defendant as a witness to tho witness stand. THE PRESIDE!!!: The defendant 3cckcr-Freyscng will take the witness stand as a witness in his own defense. mu Court So. 1 19 Kay 47-A-14-2-!HH-ftcchan (feeler) ( EJ a ASH BECKEB-7EEY SZ SQ, e witness, took the stand and testified P G follows.) BY JUDGE S23EISG: Cu You answer to the nane of Eernrnn Bockcr-Freystng? A. Yes. Q, Hold up your hand and repeat rfter no the oath: I swear by God, the Alnighty end Ctoniscient, th».t I win sneak the pure truth and will withhold end rdd nothing. (-ho witness repeated the oath.) JUDGE SEBHIHGs You nay sit down. ER. TIPPs kr. .-resident, I have one reeucst to nake to the lntor- oroters bofore the beginning of this case. The word "Referent" will play a decisive role in the case of the defendant Bcckcr-rroyscng. I know this word can hardly be translated into English by using only or.o word. This also apolies to the word "Ecfcrot", which is hardly trans¬ latable into the English language. For that rccson I should like to suggost to the interpreters that vhonevur the word "Eofaront" or "Refo- rat" appears they should always use the Gernnn turn, which I ntsuno io auito cloar to the Tribunal. I bellovo thie will oirvo the clarity of the case considerably. THE PRESIDENT: I think that for the sake of the rocord thooc torns should bo explained for the rocord according to the signification which counsel pieces upon then. Z&. TIPP: Certainly, hr. President. I would suggest that tho Gerncn words be used end then in parenthesis the English translation. 1 think that is the host solution. a IKE PRESIDENT: bill you now eek the intorpr-ters to give the English explanation of the vord6? ZS. TIPPs Gladly. '-Hi the interpr.tcr plcrse explain how ha thinks "Referent" end "Eeferat* should be translated? THE ISTSiSSISEEs Certainly, Your Honor. The word ■r.eferent" is 7775 Coart So. 1 19 Me;' 47-A-14-3-£Qt-#e ehan (Etiler) the nan who is asrlgced to a certain deoartr.wnt in order to deal with any of the subjects that coce up there. He is ar. expert assigned to deal with e special dopartnent. A ’Referet" is the entire department where these special subjects are dealt with. THE PRESIDENT: Those explanations - ere they satisfactory to counsel for tho prosecution and for the defense? EE. TIPP: Yes, Your Honor. THE PRESIDENT: Very veil, those explanations of the use of tho word being now contained in the record, 1 don't thinie they need be repeated pfter the uso of either one of those words because the crolnnn- tion is contained in the record. MB. HARPY: I night rsk defense counsel. Your Honor, what other words ho thicks right create a discrepancy. It there sooc other definition which was used here which he thinks is orroncous, so we can clear that up now? DR. TIPP: Ho, Mr. President. The difficulty, ns I see it, lo that various interpreters use different English orpros'’ions for that word end as a rosult there Is no clarity in the record that the torm "Roforcnt" is Meant. THE PBESIDEST: Which tern do you mean, cour.sol, "Referent" or "Boferat"? DR. TIPP: I an referring now to the expression "Refcront". Thlo hr b repeatedly boon translated with different weeds, defending on which intorpretur speaking into the Microphone. I should like to bring to your attention that at one tine I had to object because that word was translated as "chief of the branch". In order to be ouitc explicit I should liko to sco that the sene verd is d»m usod throughout the proceedings. I v* a t to see to it that the English tore does not change. THE PRESIDENT: It appears that the word "consultant"in English generally corresponds with the word "Referent” as given b y counsel. 7770 Court Ko. 1 19 May 4?-A-14-4-IS4-*eehan (Re^ler) I®. TIP?: I rust object to that, Kr. President. TEE PEES ERST: I was Just caking the suggestion. It ie perfectly satisfactory to use the words "Referent" end "Refernt* with the evolann- tion which is already contained in the record, if that is satisfactory to counsel for the orosecution and the defense. PR. TIP?: hay I clarify that? "Consultant" ir. the record here ie always the nan who is advising, for instance, the advising physician. The position which Professor Rose had is a "consultant" but that is not s "Referent*. TEA PRASIDAJ.'T: Shat is unieportanfc, counsel. Tho Tribunal will follow your suggestion, using the German words which have boon e*plainod to tho Tribunal end for tho record. MR. KASUTi Your Honor, that of course does not orejudice tho right of the prosecution to riolntoln that the Referent is tho chief of n department, X prosuco. THE tERSIDAST: If counsel for the prosecution contends that it is tho proper translation of tho word, the prosecution nay offer oxuort opinions as to ths conning of the word "Referent" - tho proper trans¬ lation into English. Tho prosecution cay have that right. DR. TIP?: In that caso, I nay coaconcc. DIRACT AXA.iIKAlIC3 BY DR. TIPP: Q. Witness, ycur none is Eorr:ann Josef Beckor-Frcysong rr.d you vtrw born 18 July 1910 at Ludvigshafcn on the Rhino, is that correct? A. Yes, thrt is correct. <*. Would you please briefly describe to the Tribunal your oduca- m tion and training up to the tine you entered collcgo? A. I grew uo in ny parent's hoae. Ky father died in tho year 1917 during the First World War rs * captain in the Zngincer Corps of the Reservo. then aoved to Eeidelbcrg where I a.ttcnded cchool. At Raster 1929 I graduated froa secondary school (Eucer.istiches Gynnasiua). 7777. Court 1 is Kay 47-l~l4-fr-iTtK-«fo*has (Easier) After that I started =5* Dvdical studies. X studied et Heidelberg, Innsbruck, rad Berlin. In 3erlin in the year 1534 I passed Oy -udical stato cxaainatlon. Q. -'ad now, witness, would you please Just as briefly describe your crofossionei activities which followed thereafter? A. Free January 1934 until July 1938 I was at first active no cr. intern and after that as en assistant p.t the Fourth Medic/1 University Clinic of Berlin under Frofosoor Kelcut Dcnnig. During ny clinical activity I cade ;jy doctor's thesis through cxp.rinentnl work. In August 1938 I beear.c on assistant at the Aviation hedicel Research Institute of the Reich Aviation Ministry in Berlin, which was under Professor Hubortus Strughold. I retained this civilian uositlor. until the cooltuletion. In 1944 the nodical faculty of the University of Berlin granted no the decree of rector Ked. Kr.bil. on the brsis of exoerinental work about so-called oxygon poisoning, and in the vintor •ssester 1944-1946 I was appointed a locturor on internal and aviation nodlcino Court 1 May 19-jv-lc-l-HfJ-Cooh-Raaler. v. Mow weald you ',lesse describe tj as your military career? a. My brslc allltiry training I received In 1937 In t..o for., o:' 4 so-called ei^ht-weeics course. In the auaaer of 19-10 I was drafted Into the Luftwaffe e6 an unterarzt. «t first I was at an aviators examination station, wording with 2 motorized low-pressure chamber platoon and In .-.u^ust 19vl I was order.-d back to Berlin from the southern doctor of the Russian front . nd was tranefereed to the .'.udloal Inspector: te of the Luftwaffe. There I stayed antll Kay 13 4 ’0 -n '\salstont A-ferent. From tnen on I was a •ief-. rent in the Raforat for -.vlatlon Medicine. My position no Referent I retained .ntll 8 May 1945. Did 'ou yours If aenl for this osltion In the Reich .-.vlatlon Ministry, witness, or do '-ou .• 3 arrested on tne 15 September, 1345. s . *nd now let us ooonh cbout your -.olitlcal otxvltlea. 'itr.os', were you jolltloelly active as a student or • ther- wise? a. In I4oy 1933 I entered the NSDaP r.a e twenty two year old student. I held no office or rani within the party. In addition to that I a a member of the NOKX, tne National socialist motorized cone, In the medical service of w.iioh I c lev d che ronfc of *.«n Ober-trupp-fuehrer, whloh corres- ndo t that of a eer c eont. as a prying meab-r : belonged to the N8FX, the National socialist rlyin^ Corps. 3. In addition to tn. t wer> i a member of any other national oooi^llat professional organization, j-s for lnatanoe the Ncti'nel socllalct student Luo 0 ^o, the National Socialist Physlclens League or tne Notl nol ^uclallots Lecturers' League? a• Ho, I belonged to none of these organizations. ... On the basis of the testimony of the expert who was c-lled b tne Pros cation, Professor Llebrsndt, v:e neurd A suaefc ing ‘beut tne pnyslcians' school *t Altrehse. Can cell us whetner y.u at any time visited «*ny such c urse? a. No, I never visited a c.urse at altrehse, but In - - c nnectljn I may mention tn. t I was nev.-r compelled I v: .ldn't h vo been c .apellea *cy the Rol.ch ?hy6lci'.ns' a t. -ccend ony such c.urse. Only my local out., rlsy 77?C Court 1 -try 13-«-15-3-HB-C-> ok-RaaL or. in Berlin, the magistrate f the city f Berlin, asked me to sttand s ch o c are, but I never did thet. ... 1 ' a were tellin e as before that y.u wrnted to become a lectar-r, end it is Known thet lecturers v aid hove to -o thr a;./, r lltlcal cans in order t, a et tr.elr coliticcl training, Did you aerticlprte in such a lecturers 1 c arse in e c-uap? a. ;; , I went to no lectu-erd 1 camp, prob-bly because there wo.e ,','j each camos during the va . x. That I think is sufficient as to your ly.lltlcal activities, l.'ow let us tarn to your medical scientific activity. Under whose B idnr.ee aid y. a receive y^ur clinical specialized training? a. I ia?y repeat th t brlofly as -n internal physician I wr.s od.’.c tod at the Robert Koch hospital in Berlin undvr t.vo o*,rr_,e of Professor Or. Helmut Denning. Th t etvrted in J nu~ry 1935 and wont on antll July 1938. Jennln- had formerly been a first lieutenant In the medical corns and hid been ? assisting the famous ollnlonl physician, Aud-lf V n Krehl *t Heidelberg, and durln- which ur trnlnln B .vaa often r.aolotcd by a laboratory Boston. Z. “ltnoss, this "Ctlvlty is not the subject jf the c ar e j f the prosecution, fou arc sitting in tne doo* because -.a prrticlo ted in aviation medicine. How did ou c-mo tu b. active within ihi-t sphere? ft. It wc6 my intention to Complete ay education rs an^ lntv.rnr .1 hyslclan, by aa_ltl»nrl theoretical education. • r r tivt reason I looked for some possibility to work in p aysiuloglcal institute. Tar j ugh ray cnlef physician I v.-nt to Professor ctru^nold who was tne ..oad of tne jedlcr.l institute at 3erlir., In wnose institute certain research wrs carried ut re B crdiR B tne questions of breatting 7781 Court 1 Jp.y 19-a- 15—4—.-ID-Coojc-Haaler. and circ 1 -tion na they came uo under srecl"! conditions of avirticn. Since from the clinical tjolnt of view I was Interacted in the esse - roblems, I asked to b et a position :c zec-sOQ an associate of that Institute. Professor Streghold was e student of tnc physiolo.1st, Dv. Van Von Fray, -nc. Juet as Dennln- fled been active in the United States for s-.c, considerable ocrlod of time. In ex Ianr,tlon of vh t Professor Liebrandt has stated here I should 11 :e to sp. tr.-s both of ay teachers were in no way what Profea .r Leibrandt designated as the Nazi professors who allegedly since 1933 had been tralnln c all the medical sonerr.tion whloh ; row up of ter that oerlod of time. Both or tnec. h'd been university urofossors before 1933 and both of them «re today ''gain or rather 6tlll "ctlvc In leading positions. n. You were tellln^ us Or. 3ocker that you went .over to rwlrtl.n modlolne In the year 193B? A. Yes. «s «n the br6ls of this trial It 1 oka as If the entire viatlon medicine was only designed to work for the Sermon air force, it looks now ns thou ; h this entire solonoe from r rraotlcal oint of view served for tae oreppretion of the V?r. *'ould you -.lease tell us somethin- about th-t? 19 Kay 47—A_J«C_1S—l-C-roso Hamler ) C urt I A ATietirn Medicine fb ouch wee carried •n In ell cruntrlco where there was aviation end. In particular, during the lect two dtcedee. It developed end it naturally followed aviation technique end was always In accord with-the tasks -f the Air Forces. The endeavors of Aviati n Medicine, however, were f-r the nalntFining 't the health of the flyer and for the reeearch regarding the necessary conditions of life as they prevail during flying. You can in that case hardly ereak cf any science In that c nnectl-n. I nay point out that the aost well know Aviation physician of Italy, Professor Margarla was a priest with a cnth'llc -rder at Mailanl. Bven aftor 1945 the- Gcr- nan avlotl n physicians wore peraltted t* w-rk at the Aero Medical Center at Heidelberg and carry on the oaac w^rk in which they had been active boforc. You know witness that the Prrsocutlon In their oral stntoaont has designated y u as a can who in spito of his y^uth had already nchlevod ooac scientific succeos. It is, cf courso, natural that y u had yourself been tho author of a few eclentiflc theocs whon you bo- erne a lecturor. Could y u toll us briefly about your fvn scientific work? A Hell, during ay clinical training, as well as during ny avia¬ tion aedlcal training, I werkod scientifically. A nuaber of publica¬ tions contain the result of ay work. << Mr. Prcsidont, I think that the scientific work of the defen¬ dant is 1-rortant f ' r * he Jud£=*nt personality. Me have on- deovored to get hold of these scientific puillcatl-ns but it was not possible to do all that because of the aerial war which wont on in C-e-rspny. However, vc have c-apiled the titles of all his w^rks which list I sh uld like t- subult as 3ccker_TReysing docuaent Ho. 1. This cph be f-und on rages 1 to 4 of Becker-Frcyseng Itecuaent Book I and I should like to offer this list as Exhibit Ho. l. We arc here only concerned with this up to the year 1942. The last w'rk cruld n"t b>e included because unfortunately Dr. Bccker-Frcyseng has not ell the material for that purpose. I have the original here and Prosecution 7783 1 ? Key *. 7-A-5 ■ C-IS-2-Ct-.ss (Int., Bernier) C^urt I can look at It. I should a t like to quote anything from that docu- =£nt. In this connection, witness, we ere not Interested In your cli¬ nical w-rk tut arlatl>n medical problems nay te of ooae importance, rflth what particular aviation aedical pxr*ble=s did y u deal? A During the yorrs of 1938 end 1939 I dealt with tine reserrch experiments up to 9,COO neters altitude. That is to say, with con¬ sequences of p lack f oxygen which suddenly nay occur. In tho year 1939 to 1940 I dealt with the questions regarding adaptation to high altitude. In that connection the titles 24 and 25 in the list would te relovant. In the years 1936 to 1946 I concerned myself with ques¬ tions of so-called oxygen poieons. In this connection the titles 15 t 21 in the list are relevant. In the yearo fron 1945 to 1946 I con¬ cerned ayself with explosive docoaprcssion sickness during altitudes of 30,000 meters. q You vero giving ustho years of 1945 and 1946. That was after the capltulat! n, was it n't. *hcrc did yiu carry on that work that you Just mentioned? A This is tht sane kind, of work about which Dr. Ruff as already been speaking here which was carriod out at tho Aoro Medical Contor at Heldolborg. It is natural that you carriod out a nusbor of tests within tho framework of that work. Kay I n w ask you how you were carrying out those tests? A This entire work consisted of tests. A number of these teoto wore cerricd ou on animal*. *e were using the ordinary laboratory animals: nice, TPts, guinea pige, rabbits, etc. In ddditi n tr these animal experiments I carried nut experiments cn human beings. Ihio was done in tho fora of experiments on his own person or experiments on colleagueo or associates, as for instance Dr. Hane-C-corg Clanann, Professor Rrich Opltt, and Dr. Ulrich Luft and in the year fron 1945 t 1946 Dr. Huff and Dr. Ctto C-auer. 7784 19 Me? /7-A_FjC_16-3-C-ro B 8 (1st., Seller) Court I tt Mr. President I had originally intended to have the witness testify personally ahrut this questi n cf self-experiments. In order V erredite the proceedings I think it would he acre advisable t Unit ry«elf to whet I can shew or. hand of a rruaber of affidarits which I shall offer as 3ec: oxygon trcatxxont in oortain illnesses and the respiration 0 f oxyson vxhilo fly in-3. Sicoo it was known that of tor pro- 10x1301! bronthinc of puro oxygon rmiacls contracted pnounonia, :nly solf-oxporix;onts ocno into the question whon tho first cxjeriBonts of this ty.o were onrriod out on huaans. On tho third day of this self -expo riaont, Dr. Booker-Froysong stowed syaptoxis of cerebral irritation, such as hoadacho3, n-.usop. and dizziness, end penuuonin, and required nearly B days' clinical treataont. Those oxporinunts woro published in tho ;oriodioal '..viation Kodicino.' I shall skip tho noxt paragraph on'! then I quoto: "In nunorous other cx.orinents with Dr. U. Luft and Dr. 0. itz, Dr. Bockor-Fruysono always placod hinsolf conplctoly st thoir disposal." I can onit tho re3t. Follows the si mature and tho usual cortifioato of the notary. The noxt doourient whioh I offer is also frax. Dobunent Book 1, 3ook>-r-Froyson3 ^cunent if 6, as Exhibit tf5. This is an affidavit of Professor Dr. nod. Opitz of Kiel of tho 4th of January, 1947. Professor Opitz is a professor at tho University of Kiel. Under ffl ho tolls how he not Dr. Booker- ?reys-nc; that he was in alaost daily oentnet with hin professionally fro.: 1933 to 1942 and that ho know hin very •oil, and I shall quoto tho last parajraph on tho first .t.e; "••ith regard to science, Booker-Freys one always nnintniifr- - a cor.^ lately ethical attitudo towards tho quostion of nu.a.n ox.\-rinonts. During our collaboration, he noted .as 11 did, and tried out every soenia3ly dangerous experi- • -at; first on hixasclf, bofor- carrying it out on others. ; • -r, during the tine we worked .together did ho carry out -x.erir.cnts on fellow hunan beings unloss they had voluntar¬ ily ; laced a he; iso Ives at his disposal." Kay 19-v.-3K-17-5-Kr.rrow (Int. Von Schocn) Court Ko. 1 There follows n description by Dr. Cinnann of the oxpori- -onts on his own person whioh I oan oait. Porhaps I any quote on pngo 2, the lest few sentoncos of tha first Para¬ Graph: "In addition wo onrriod out dozons of joint 3cif-ox;>ori- nonts in tho low-^:ossuro chauber, whoro tho offoots of hijh altitudes woro studied u.> to tho throshold of un¬ consciousness. Dr. Becker-rroysonc took part in those ox, orinonts in tho saco nannor ns tho other doctors of our working group." Tho rest donls with an o. inion of Dr. Bookor-Frcysong fren tho hunnn .>oint of whioh I shall not road but I should liko tho Court to take notioo of it. Then follows tho signature and tho custonary oortificato. Tho last docu£v.nt which I should liko to subuit in thi3 connection is 3cckor-Fr^y3ong Docunent fl*7 on pago 19 of Docutrent Book 1 to which I givo the Exhibit tf6. It is on affidavit by luoturer Dr. Otto Gauer of iloidolborg, of tho 21th of January, 1917. .10 had orijinally intondod to call Dr. Gauor as a wit no ss, but unfortunatoly, that is inpossiblo oocauso Dr. Gr.ucr has olroady gono to -narioa. D r . Gauor first tolls how he not Dr. Bookor-Froysong; that ho not hin in 1937. Ko doscribos tho sclf-oxporinonts with Dr. Clanann whioh have alrondy been ox. lainod and tho harn whioh Dr. Bcckor-Froysong suffered fra; those oxporinents. I shall quoto on the first page, tho last paragraph: "In s; ito of theso un; levant cx.erionocs, Booker-Froysong Would 3urely have refused to oarry out experiments concornod with his own soi^ntific , roblcns on people of whoso willing -r even voluntary cooper .tion he was not convinced." Kcw, on tho second pr.jo I shall quote on tho first third this pR30: 7792 _ _ - --1 'Ik i if ”-v 19-..-3X-17-6-Kcrrow (Int. Von Schoen) Court No. 1 "Later I undo investigations with hit: - that is, B^okor- Fr-ysoa” - end P.uff on tho ctiolojy of 'bonds' .at a height of 12,000 notors. Those aro very painful and can load to d.-JGorous con, lioations. This is abundantly illustrat¬ es by tho fact that during this invosti 3 . 1 tion I su3tainod - icnoo injury, which forcod nc to hnvo to walk on orutohos for throo nonths. In spite of this, Bockor-Froyson^ nnd Huff continued tho oxperinonts on thonsclvos eftor ny eccidont." I shall not quoto tho rost. It dosoribos how Bockor- Freysone was ap. ointed in tho Modionl Inspcotorcto. He says that 3ookor-Frv-yson;; oouploinod booauso ho didn't hnvo tine to porforti his own oxperinonts, and thon ho speaks of tho dofondant '3 political viows. Follows sleanturo and tho custoi.ory cortificato. I believe, v»itno83, your aotivity has boon explainod suffioiontly by those docunonts so that wo nood discuss it no further. I should noroly like to ask you, on tho basis of your nur.orou3 3olf-oxporiixnt3 whioh wore in part 'an.jQrous and your ox.-orinonts on colloa,;uos, did you have ;r>j t experience with physiological oxperinonts - in ;rrtioular, oxperinonts on hunan beings? .. Yos. -i You know, witness, that oxporiuonts .» hunan boincs is, on tho wholo, tho fundanontal ^roblen Df this trial. .» Groat Seal has boon said about tho ethics and local foundation for oxperinonts on hunan boincs. I should liko to havo your pinion on this typo of oxperinonts, particularly because you one of tho few witnesses who can testify frea his own -.vcricnco. Do you consider an ox; orinont on hunan bcinps, 3 the .rosocution expert Leibbrandt said, illegal or crinin- 2 I undor all conditions or what is your opinion? 7793 19 :'37 17-.7D-I3£i-:iiloy (Int. von Scbon) Court So. 1 A Tbit. I do not share Pro fo S3 or Loibrnndt*s point of view can no dcubt bo seen frca ry numerous solf-exp* rinents which "wore not .dthout danper, but I did axporiuants on other human beings considerably Ifforont than Professor Leibrandt, because I believe that hunan experiments is both good and bad, like any other human action it can bo pornissiblo or criminal, depending on tho special conditions under which it takes place. I consider tho problem inch more serious and much noro oonplicatod than Profossor Loibrandt described it here. For hin and for Jtr. Itoll, whoso book Profossor Loibrandt quoted hero at length, ex¬ perimental noUcino is a subject of historic philosophical, psychological ccnsidoraticn. ?ron such a point of view from his dosk, it is vory easy to Judgo experimental todiedno an! orx; of its nost important tools, hor.an uxporinonts, and to coMam it, but at tho sano tino to recog¬ nize tho rosults of axp^riiiontal rusoarch an l to uso thoso results as Profjssor Loibrandt doos, for oxanplo, as a practisin’ psychiatrist, as ho us os mlaria tro.'.b.uint for paralysis which a *fcr' yoars a p was still in a stage of human uxporinonts, but Profossor Loibrandt was kind onou.gh tc explain hinsalf that lifo is a logical and ho hinsolf is no ixcoption. Tho wholo ;iec*ical world has a different Feint of viow thon Profossor Ldbmndt doos. It is vory easy to find Jo zona of examples of this. I have said that I consider tho problem more sorious and noro c:nplicatod then it looks according to Profossor Loibrandt^ doscription. It ia sorious bocauso it affects tho basis of rac lical action and Midi cal responsibility. Thorp is no doubt that tho doctor is primarily o.llrr.tod to help tho petiont who asks hin for aid, and thero is no. °ubt either that tho doctor as a research workers has tho obligation to work on the pro rcss of :-l£-3-:tiloy (Int. von Schoen) Court 1 obligation to the corcunity in which he is placed by fate# As a witness who is certainly not suspected of Nazilsn, I ray say tho Swiss Psychiatrist Professor Bleulor, who in 1919 in his book "Artistic Thinking and Modicine," wrote "I should like tc emphasize that a doctor is not tho helper of one patient at tho expense of tho other living beings and humn beings of the futuro, but is tho helper of oany. And for that reason ho must let his results be influenced" by tho general social point of vi->» just as well as fren the individual point of view of a certain patient." I road this book for tho first tine in 1935# I havo quoted it repoatodly in rzy own wsrk. For oxauplo No. 7 and 9 of tho peporo on this list which is Exhibit No. 1. '•'hat is said hero by tho doctor as a holper of tho individual, and tho cornunlty, is valid in ry opinion, or tho sano way for tho doctor as .tho rosoarch workor. I consider that tho vory soriouo side of tho problem whioh boconos complicated, bocauso human oxporlnonts aro carriod out daily and everywhere in onomous raicbom ir. all fields. It is porfornod on volunfcoors an*' non-voluntoors, on healthy persons and on sick persons, on childron, insane persons, prisoners, intcmoc3, rich and poor. So auch has boon said about it hero that I don't want to "carry coals to Ifaff Castlo." I shall therefore not cito any individual oxomplos, but only want to say that not only for tho laymn, but also for the exports in looking ever tho literature on the subject is it oxtromoly difficult, if not impossible to drew a dear lino cotween experiment examinations, tosts or simple observation. 19 May-A-: 3-19-1-4eehar. (Int. Von Schon) Court Xo. I. Q Tiitness, you have told us your basic point of vie” brief¬ ly; do you consider all types of human experiments equal disre arding the question of the experimental subjects or of their basic clif/or- erces? A Of course there are great differences, and distinction must bo nado between a clinical expertaent on one hand and a phy¬ siological experiment on the otter hand. In the clinical oxtb ri-»nts, the research worker oust have sick persons if possible for hi3 rosoarch work, or lie must cake persor.3 sick in order to observe the origin, course and influence of the diseaso. For instanco, Goldberior't pellagra subjects in Uiesissipr-i aotually contracted pellagra, the Mae aub. ects of the Swiss scientist Rleuler, whom I mentioned before, wero actually sick and were observed and giver, specialized treatment, while they were sick, so were Amins famous experimental subjects. Klauson in I t feehar. (int. Von Schon) Court Ho. I. fora of fatigue and hunger tests on conscientious objectors in the United States. In aviation cedi cine we wire used to this sort of problem even during peace tine, because altitudo is one such problem of endur¬ ance. The decisive thing in all such physiological tests, to my mind, is that the person in charge of the experiment always controls, always is able to approach the extreme cinute, step by step and can stop tin experiment at all tines. He merely need make the conditions normal again which had been made abnormal for the purpose of tho experiments. The coa-water experiment, which is one of the subjects of this trial, will later give ~e an occasion to go into this subject in greater detail. Hore specifically I hope to be able to show that it was not the purpose of tho experiments to penetrato beyond the limit of what la normal, but to test this linit. In conclusion, I should like to say that I hope I will not be nisu.xlerstood to moan that I consider only physiological experiments permissible. I know that clinical ex- periaants can be absolutely essential and that clinical experiments may be performed under quite poralssablo conditions. Since Profocsor Schroeder and Dr. Ruff have already gone into the same subject, I need not say any more about it. I cannot see how these experiments oro sup¬ posed to have boon among destructive plans, which in the opinion of the prosecution aro held in cobbor by all tho experiments on trial hero. I believe that evoryono who seriously deals with this problem, especially anyone who performs dangerous sell-experiment 3 on tho problem as a Doctor mist corre to the conclusion that the point of view of completely re¬ jecting human experiments does not help at all. • Q .fitness, I have tho impression that you have thought about t’e a-obioe of human experiments lure than the normal doctor does. So far you have spoken of this problem oruy from the point of viei. of sedical ethice, but I do not believe that medical ethics is the only point of -vie-: rhic'n must be considered here. Kill you please tell us sor.eti.inf about this problem fraa the point of view of general ethics, 7798 19 liay-A-' 3-19—3-^0eban (Int. Von Schon) Court No. I. I believe that is rather important in this question. A Of course general ethics also play an important rolo. The doctor is only ore side, on the other side is the rest of the public such as private patient3, cxpertr-entol subjects, such as prosecutors or as judges, but I should like to point out trro things. First, these are particular questions belonging to a very cexplicated specialized field which are very difficult to judge and it Kill not be possible without tie opinion of an expert. Or. the other hand, general ethics is sono¬ thing which has been established eminently since the tine of Adam and £vf, which finds only one correct sol«ition for every question. I don't toliovo that the problen is as staple ao tiiat and raieuidctstood and alsdirocted ethics would not bars the Doctor, oocause there aro always f!o. I. cine; now I an a lawyer, cot a doctor and I had little to say against this point of vie- of the prosecution and was quite astonished to hear scce tiao ago on a program broadcast by a Munich radio station a com¬ mentary by a Doctor Sue:skind rho ccccents on this trial and '•ho cco- nented on the previous trial that a number of doctors had written to him saying that this oath had been to then only a vague concept up to this trial, because many of thee had leamoc* of it only long after they had finished their studies and worked as assistants. I was more aston¬ ished to learn that no doctor in Geraany is over sworn to this oath in its original fora or any cthor fora. Hon, witness, will you pleaso com¬ ment or. this matter of the Hippooratos oath, which goes like a rod thread through the wholo trial? 7SX Court 1 , . tey l9-A-&-l-hi>-Cooit-Von Sofcoen. I knew the oath of Hipocrates as a student already. „ft-.r I ixv’durted from nigh senool in ny first senest».r as a nodical student, together wita a friend who was studying pr.iloloyy, I reed Hi operates in Greek. I did not trite t. io o th tu Zeus nd other areck Gods any more than eny ocher Gar urn doctor, nor did I take the oath in n moderniz¬ ed rnd ltcoorvcd fora, as is the custom in some other c.ur.t- rlca when ’ young doctor receives is certificate. The orth of Hip oe rtes, of course, contolns n number of very lm ortent and fundeaontnl nuties of a uoctor, but it aces not contain any tore then '.toll's book does *ny indications of tho duties of r. doctor as ? rese. rc i worker. Slnco rilo ocrctes .inseir was not only a practicing physician out without d ubt a aodic.il reserrch worker of some quality, one o. n nly conclude tn t he says nothin* In his oath nb ut the duties of the aodlcrl researcher, because ho, orobrbly Just like hr. .toll, realited the enormous and la no 61 ineuroountrOle difficulties with w Me.', this problem confr nted hla, and o a pln like .toll the oath of r.lpoocratos contains ainy things v..lch, wnen it w.'s written, 5Go yonro 3 C, was vr.lld and corroct, but which hr a been changed In the ne-*ntlno. For ax -Thle, the strict soorr-tlon between Che dootor -nd the stone surgeon ana tr.e surgeon, has not in^ to do with aoc.lc '1 ethics, and if todey in Germany the sbru le a ninst ■Damgrrvoh 218 , for the role-’se of eocl -1 .n. lections, for the lnterruotlon of progn-ncy- fey I interrupt you, you a,-nn ?arnropr. 213 of the Helen ran 1 Coe.e, witness, wnlch in Germany prohibited and furnished nbortion r.a -ormittec it merely for nedioal reasons ? Yes, th-t is vast I meant. If tala strung}:*} is r. carried on tocL- ; uasalon tely and as t.-.e article of ■IJurnbergornachrlobten 11 of tr.e 15 Janu-ry 1^47 s.:ow6, 16 Court 1 Hay 13-A-S0-?-HD-Coo4-Vor. Schoen. carried out uCllcly, cn advocator of paragraph 218 will hardly be able to refer to the oath of Hippocrates In his defense where an abortion v:ts« prohibited for all reasons, _ver. for medical reasons. It w-s not forbidden because Hip cerates considered it unethical, out singly because In those days surgical technique was not developed to the extent that such an ocerntlon could 'oe performed without danger. But I should like to point out one thing that I h-.ve always raissed so for In the discussl.no of the Hippocratic octh, Hippocrates was the founder of a very Halted msdlool school or guild on the lrl nd of Cos, and nls oath was Intended for the protection of this young guild or doctors against the priest doctors who had been nil powerful up to that tlae. Hippocrates sealed nls sohool hermetically against all others b t.-.ls oa.tr. and his great otnlco wore th't the followers nod to swear tnat everything he learned at this school wo -Id never be told to any other lector exes-.t to t.*c members of the senool of Cos who had tnkon one same oath. For Hippocrates tno medical Journals and medical text books would heve been c v.ry great vlolc- tl n of his oath and unethical for the purposes of his sohool. The oat.; of hlp.ocrates does have one great advan¬ tage, It cooes from antiquity. Hippocrates himself did net write a Ion,, commentary on his oath, and anything or notning can bv proved by it today. x. "ltnosa, I think you .urve s^id enough about the o:llccl ’ s ect and I g?ther t.v t you moan to say that neither .toil's book nor the oath of Hlr 1 ocrates .or any other publica¬ tion clarifies the etnicr.l side of the medical activity, c ‘1- roble.,. is so comrlicrted th t it cannot be t.Ii simply. How, In conclusion a fin 1 pri ctical qu Gtlon wh.ther the subjects were volunteers or not, under 7802 Court 1 liay 19—A-20—8-HD-Cooi-Yon cchoen whs c c nditions would -ou personally consider experiments on uuxan beings, not self-experiments, but ex-erimer.ts on ot.'-r human beings permissible? a. First of °11 the experiment must be necessary, that is, the problem underlying it must important, and no solution use be possible in any other way. Second, the exerlment must be conscientiously pre r-d for by r.odel ex erlmonts, :y onlmal experiments and if .oaslole ay alf-experimontetlon of the doctor; nnd, t.ulro, of course, the execution of the exerlment must correspond to the rules of medio. 1 rctlon. That la the root of considerable tnou lit wr.loh must be given to the matter nero. Those are the three conditions which I consider necessary. JUDC*£ 5EBRIN0: I didn't under a tana your lost words, ho n?cr.ed thre& conditions. I didn't get then. I didn't understend the last one. •'ITl‘133: In the third place, the execution of the exerlment muse strlctl: conform to rules applied to medical action. I meant to s'-y by that for th«- doctor as a research worher the eoorlmcntal subjects must not be considered as a number or erso b-t must ba n numrn being Just lliie any patient who comes to him f.r eld ar.d he must take into consider"t:on all tr.elr needs •’s human beln 6 a. DR. TIPPS: At. President, I am at the end of the e,en»jral queetlon*.- and I would surest that we adjourn now before ^oln. into Cne individual counts of the indictment. A JUDo*- 6EBRIN3: '.fitness, in regard to -our views on human experimentation ;-o- have named three requisites, three, - one, two, three? a. 'fee. k. kow, suppose those requisites or prerequisites rro resent, Cw whet extent lr. -cur view is it et ically Court 1 May 19-^-2C-4-HD-Cook-Von Sofcone. necessary to advise the ex- ueriaental subject of the natural cur oso and perhaps reaction so far as ho, the experimental subject, Is concerned, to be expected from the experiment? A. I would out that under point 3. I would say that Just as the doctor 6hould tell the patient as far as he can wh?t treatment ho considers advisable for a certain case, especially If It Is an operation with a certain decree of danger, of course, the doctor as a rese'rch worker must tell nla experimental subject so thrt the subject under¬ stands what the experiment Is all about, what danger may be Involved, what dam-ge any be done, but also how Import¬ ant the problem la and what C3n be achieved b the solution of the roolem. Could you approve os medically ethical any experi¬ ment which foil short of that point, of giving oomploto advice to tno experimental subject? a. If I nay repeat your question, you asked whether I vo Id consider It unethical to carry out an experiment with a.n experimental subject to whom I did not explain the danger rnd all of the details of the ox'orlment3? •i. Precisely. a. In an experiment which Involves danger I would consider It absolutely essential to ex.lain these dangers to the subject boforjhand. THE PRESIDENT: The Tribun-1 will now be In recess until nine-thirty o'clock tomorrow morning. 7eCi* 20 Pay 1 a 7—I!—..TD-l-l-F os ter (Int. Raaler) Court No. 1 Official Transcript of the -narican Military Tribunal in tho natter of tie United States of Aocric&j against Sari Brandt, et al, defendants, sitting at »urobar~, Geraany, on 20 :-Say 19U7, 0930, Justice Beals presiding. THE i -iftSH-'J,: Persons in the court roan will please find their scats. Tho Honorable, the Judges of JdUtary Tribunal I, Military Tribunal I is now in sossion. God save tho United States of orica and this honorable Tribunal. Thoro will bo ordor in tha ccurtroon. THE PRESIDENT: *Jr. .’Larahal, you ascertain if tho dofondonts aro all presont in court. THE ’1’JlSfc.L: ISiy it ploaso your Honor, all dofondants aro prosent in court. THE PRESIDENT: Tho Sccrotary-Oonoral will note for tho rocord tho proaunco of all tho dofondants in court. Counsel nay procood. ffiRJtiNH BECKER-FRSYSSX - Rosuiiod DIRECT EX.. I:L.TI0N (Continuod) BT DR. TTFP (Counsel for tho Do fondant Bockor—Froyson"): Q Dr. Dockor-croyscn-, yostorday, at tho ond of tho suasion, wo wore discussing tho general ethical fundancntals reforrinp to tho oxporlncnts on humn beings which wo conclude U Today, wo aro roin- to iscuss tho indivi fcal counts of tho indlctaent as the:/ aro raisod against ycu. The prosecution charges ycro at first to have participated in a conspiracy to conait crinos, to other with your co-dofondants, • - -« ccij'.es. rv'aifist^hoanity and war Crtnos. I shall bo very brief .in con- AV \ fortion witk tfci&jfeiunt because in rxy opinion there i3 no logal basis <0 _ \c.» for any conspiracy in that respect. However, that is a question which ■ •till later be tLsooe^ed in your final ploa. Therefore, witness, I a3k Spa what was your Connection before !hy 19U5 with your co-defendants with when ywi'sre^ilic'od to have carried on a conspiracy? 20 J tay 19ii7—? .TD-l-S-Fos ter (Ir.t f Harder) Court No. 1 A I did not know ton of ;y defendants. These arc Dr. Gonzkon, Professor ?'.ru.-ow3ky, Dr. Rudolf Brandt, Popp-andick, *r. Siovors, ;!r. Brack, Dr. rfoven. Dr. Pokorry, Dr. Fischer and : iss Oborhousor. I knew the nanes of four of the gentlccen on the basis of thoir position, but T nevjr oxchanjod a word with than. 7hc3o are Professor Karl Brandt, Profossor Han’loser, Goneraloborstabsarzt Frofossor Gobhnrdt and Professor Slone. I know Profossor Rostock in his capacity as head of tho nodical faculty of tho University of Berlin. On the occasion of quclifyiiv' as a lecturer I was introduced to hin and I .Ha cun sot! this question with hin. On the basis of nutual activity within tho .dr Forcos, or rather within aviation radical rosearch, I know Profossor Rosa, Dr. Ruff, ». Rocfcorg and Profossor *»ltz. In tho anno 'my, I naturally also krww Gonoraloborstabsorst Profossor ScJiroodor as ny hi;.host superior. I know Korr Doctor Konrad Schaofor and Profossor Boi lbock. Q Boforo I start entering upon tho subject of tho individual exporin unto, which aro tho subjoot of the in’ictnont against you, I nay ask ycu to 'oscribo ycur position during tho war. You know tlvat it is your position in particular which has boon tak..n by tho prosecution as tho basis of tI;o in.Hetaont against you. In ny opinion a nui-bor of concepts havo to bo clarified which have boon either rdsum’orstoo! or nistranslated. Tho first point, t!»o prosecutor in tho sossion of tho 12th of Doctor 1917, in the English recor d, papo 309, riesirnatod you as Chief of tho Dcpartcont of ^vtation *'o Heine with tho Chief of tho •fe&eal Service of the Luftwaffe. Accordingly, you oro to havo occupied a Ion din- position in rcsoarch work. You had the key position in the ±r urlical research, as Profossor Alaenndor onco described it, *fay I ask yty:, witness, to clarify this oir.t hore? A First, I have to say in that coniwcticn that with the Chief of tho K u Heal Servico of tho Loftrmffa thero was no dopr.rtzaont at all for aviation codidne. 7606 20 'ay li7-:^v73-l-3-?sstor (Ir.t. Fanler) Court Ho, 1 Q "fitness, I believo that before clarifying your position in particular it *±11 be necessary to ’escribe to the Tribunal briefly the organization and the structure of the Jlodioal Sur7ioe. I think it is necessary to do that in order to understand vthat you really wanted to testify, “ould you please do that. A Yes. Professor Schroodor has described the structure of his office in this witness stand, soon fron his own perspective. In other words, he saw the pyranid fron its top. Since I tras really at tho baso of this pyrasdd, nay I a ain doscribo tho structure from my porspoctivo. In tho !todical Inspectorate, rather, in tho position of tho Chief of tho Ilodiool Inopootorato of tho Luftwaffe, approodiiatoly 2$ roforonts wore active. Every roforont a.tainistorod, I night soy, a definite roforont. Ary such roforont oonsistod of this ono roforont, one fonalo clork, and on sono occasions, ono sol ttor who as a dorical assistant. I do not boliovo that this unit in tho Gcnvin usago of lanr.uago can bo dosi natod as a dopertnont. Thoso roforonts roro organised in raipe or doparteronts. In tho office ro had two such lopartoonts, tho so-callod first ’o; lTl*un"l lr. c.-.at ochroeder s.oat-sose time on-it -nd -v. Dienoch stent some time on it, and now we are Court 1 Xrv 20-'.--5-2-H3- Co ok-Rade r. ro r. = ain and 1 must frankly adalt from the explanation ::o hr.vd this com In- I am confused. I knew whet referent . 8 rnd I stnew whet referat was and I don't know now and I 'c ^oln 0 to ask the Tribunal If they will ask the trans- 1 tlon department for an Interpretation of It and to study tr.e difference between the translation of the word referent end referat. I understand referat is a department and reforent Is a eub-dep rtcont, and therefore the words reforat and referent 1 s perfectly clear in the chsllsh 1 nfeur.^e and to quibble about vnethor It Is e department, referent for aviation medicine, or a referct for aviation cedicino Is basically lceoterlal, and I think we should rt . nis point of the trial establish a definite definition for a rwfarent and a referat -nd consultant and so forth so that vy can orooeed ir. our briefs and set forth Just w:.?t t.'.e re without further arguments; the prosecution orlntrlns t reforat Is a dooertoent and wo hove nothln & cu object to, and it Is Just o minor point and there Is no olnt of nr e uln^ "'oout It If we can establish It now tur Uj.' the Interpretation department. % DH. TRIPP: Mr. President, I cust object to rir. Hardy for the followl e, reasons: F.p has Just stetod now for the very flrot time that the prosecution Is now of the opinion a ruferot was a subdivision of a department. Up to la olnt the Prosecution naa not expressed that ns clearly *8 that. It may be that this difference could be explained the various translations v-nd I think that I can a-ptes •-tn Mr. Hardy now by sayin 6 that a referat Is a aub- tr a.nlzrtion of a de-^.rtment. In other words, the depnrt- nt is the superior agency of the referat. If I have ierstoed hr. H^rdy correctly so fa*- nd If this is now c inior. of the prosecution we ore in cb olute o^ree- -nt. 7814 Court 1 Hay 20-14-3-3-HD-Co >k-3e-ler. XR. EaRDX: If that is the case. Your Honor, theri :-;re is no croblem any longer and'if defense counsel admits refer" t is e deoartcent. DR. TUP:: Ho, I beg your pcrdon, -*-r. Hardy unfortun¬ ately contradicted r.ioaelf. He Just stated two minutes a a o 6h-t che referat was a sub-department, and now on the other hand he is anyln^ that the referat was a deportment ?r4 I think-these two concepts would nave to be dlstln B uia- ed once and for all. In order not to speak at length about i is olntt I cay suggest Mr. President that the defendant 3ecker rreysen 0 xeko a eketch Which would illustrate the str cture of the m&dlcal inspectorate in detail and that in t .Is sketch the corresponding Gorman .’nd English names • v Id jQ insortod. Of course, ne couldn't do that today v no W’ .’Id do lc witnln a few days and in this manner it yjUld ra oi some amount of clarification. THE FRSSIOSt'T: The defendant, Becker Frey sent, may •len he c"n, prop-re this skotch which h s been suggested *nd present it t the Tribunal and I think tho Tribunal a - lco *• .ood idea of tno xonnln Q of these words but . .0 de endant may prepare this sketon. a DR. T3PP: v. vitneaa, after this intorrjptlon, let us oontinue v t . ur questioning. You were saying the t you were a referent ns far as /•-> haven't done that already. a. Veil, the tc.eke of tne referent exhausted theiu- lvos m is rl = ht to eke salvations. The referer.t*had possibility to make ar. lnde indent decision. This meant : ..o v/'.s not allowed to sign any one's letter person— f y nc\ that without any exception. The only exception v: ich I may perhaps refvr Is that in :hc case of a Oopy s in position to certify the authenticity of that 7C15 S8? r Iol*t-3-4-aO-Cook-Haaler. cony, but that, of course, has nothln D to do with the sigr.rture ae an expression of the decision made. 5. In this connection, nay I recall that Dr. Witt r.nd Dr. August Dienock, the two witnesses who were both referents in the medical Inspectorate, have given the ooae testimony about the rights of a referent. That was lone on 28 February, 1G=7. The two passages can be found on p -o 3751 and 3768 of the German, as well as on pa 8 o 3725 and 3749 of the English record. Witness, what was the collaboration with your super¬ iors within the framo-vork of the .edlcal inspectorate? In particular tell us about vour coll borotlon with your superiors and especially with rrof. Anthony, as long as he was th- roferent and you were the assistant reforont? A. In ordar to answer your second quostlon first, which refers to uy relationship to Professor Anthony, rrofessor «nthony was lacking the most essential property of a superior, namely, ho was in no way to make any decisions which concerned me. I was attached to Prof, nnthony in order to assist and support him. My relation¬ ship to him mry be illustrated best by saying that «nthony was about fifteen years older than I and that for many yo-ra he had been a University rrofessor and an indepen¬ dent herd of a lar-,e clinic for internal medicine ana that from a military point of view he had been a stabsnrtt, for e lon^ time, whereas I was only an assistant physician, an ooorar&t, end I might 6ay that ay relationship to him . itrhrps corresponded to this relation of a elinlcal aosls- t-nt or a scientific assistant to his medical end scion:Ific chief. I always addressed «ntbony with the -oris "Herr rrofessor" and It was quite natural that •r.thony was working on a large field within the referat 7816 Court 1 Hay 2C-y<- 3-5- HD- Co ok-.-^le r. independently and only entrusted ae with various tasks within th t sphere or rather hod orders given to me by sy dop'rtaental chief. My personal relationship t?wards his was good. I think this is all I can say abjut that. 7317 20 Itxy Ii7-U-1~Gross (Ran3-r) cw Court No. 1 Hot, witness, rculd you please illustrate your relationship to your next superiors ufiichcro, first your dcpartaontal chief, and Chief of Staff, aid Nodical Inspector? A. :y relationship to ny Military superiors can be soon r.hon considering the structuro of the rgoncy. In other xrds, I had to deal with a 11 suggestions,ctafts, proposals for reply, etc., uhioh I had to s ubait at first to ny departmental chief who signed a part of t'i03o lottcrs bins elf as far s they irorc not concerned irith decisions on principles. The 1 ttcr ho oithcr submitted personally or in ny company to tho U hiof of Staff rho again signod a great part 0 m of thoso letters and then, in turn , dooidod rt ich lottors wero to bo subaittod to tho Uodicdl Chiof of tho iiodical Inspoctor for his oignnturo. Q. ‘ho lowost man holding tho lorrost position who could mako dcoisions and sign letters, if I understood you oorrcotly, was tho departmental chief, A. >os, this was the lowest positionwhioh could acko indoporxiont decisions. r i, 1 toi t witness wasitroally truo that tho roforont boro no respon¬ sibility for what ho suggested and for what ho proparod. If that is not so what vashis tack, what was his responsibility, in your opinion? novor sow any job diroctivo on Job regulation, for tho roforoit but I always considcrod my position as a roforont as a vory responsible one and I .always considorod very c arefully whatever I was 4 ““posting, I may say that for that rc.-aon I had torork day and night. •trhaps I nay point ot tho following: Not only did it occur very frequently that I as a roforont subci .tod a number of pc3sib. litios to my dojnrtaontal chief for Ids decision from Thich ho oould thon •'loot tho one which socaod nost proper to him. It also occur rod very -rcq:ontly that altogether he rojoctcd any proposal which I nado. For - -torcc, approximately the end of April or the begiadiig of '.Lay 19UJj 7818 20 ISoy I;7—2—aTj3S ( .licler) Court :to. 1 -'>cn taking over too referat fron Anthony I had suggested to attach an training ccapany to the lecture dojnrtaent at Juoterbog. I did that in order to got a personnel reservo in tint training conpary f ron vh ich an could obtain sufficient soldier volunteers as oxpcrirontal subjects about whoa an agency within the radical scrvico would bo ablo to dispose. Had this suggestion teen adoptod at that tiro Dr, Schaofcr and Dr, Poiglboock at loast would not bo sitting in this (feck. *hia suggestion of mine -..-as rejected by ny dcpnrtaontol chief, Q, lx, Presidont, in connection with letter point I shall bo in a position to subait an affidavit by ft*ofcs3or Dr. Knodo tho chlof of the thon Training dopvtaont Juoterbog. This affidavit has bem requ or, ted but ms unfortunatoly r.ot yet rccoivod. w itnoss, gonorally you dosoribod what tho responsibility of a referont was. Could you perhaps illustrate the details of your activity by giving us a ooncrcto crcanplo? I think tho eon water Qxecriaontvould be tho best oxcaplo in W.vioh you yoursolf participc.tod in tho capacity of a roforont. TThot did you do briefly in that connection? A, At first I inforaod sysolf oxactly about tho n-.turo of tho two ,rocodurco of which v;c know. I inf one d cysolf about tho necessity and tho rvaturo of ary now ox:uriaonts. I inforaod cysolf .“bout .rofessor Eciglbocck and hia qualifications as an o jqjcrinontol lcador ard finally I inforaod cysolf about tho various posdbilitios •ich existed in the sunaar of 19uli to carry out tho oxperiraont, This material was presented to ry dopartaontal ohiof, then in hia proscnco it ~ra sibnitted to the Chief of Staff and after tliis information had bocnaainod and approved of iy spporiors it was submitted to tho Nodical C'liof vh o on tho basis of it thon nado his decision, -• Accordingly your responsibility as a referent wasroally an inner • :f ico responsibility whereas tho actual decision which w>nt to other goncios was rondo by your superiors? this is how you could porlnps oxrrcss it. 7619 20 liny -7-^&T-4-3-Gross (Raslcr) Court 'fo. 1 -aw, tho Prosecution here on tho 10 Dcccrfcor I 9 J 46 has asserted that you had issued orders. They said that you had issued orders to •rofessor Kaagon who plays a considerable part in this trial. Accord¬ ing to what you r. ro saying now tds opinion of tho K*c 3 oc ution is erroneous but wild you ploasc repeat it hero? A. I neither had the tight to issuo orders nor did I at any tine issue such orders. .. Finally in connection with point nay I agalr.rofcr to tho tosti- rsny by tho witneas-'itt, on 28 February 19L7, pago 3789 of tho Gomrn transcript and 3751 of tho Hngli*. transcript. Ho redo a adrdlar statcoont to it\ at tho defendant has just said and I also point to tho testinony by Professor Schrccdor who was tho highest technical suporior of tho defendant of 26 Fofcru. ry, 19li7, on papo 3559 in tho Goraan transcript and on ?jo 3536 of tiw English transoript. Now, witness, ay I :ak you to d iscuss tho details of your xtivity. You wero already saying boforo that you had boon an assistant roforont frocn August 19U1 until 19U*. and that you wero a roforont f»n Jlay I 9 M 1 until tho 0011 apoo of tho Gcraai '7 0 hmacht. K ould you nor; toll us . ’hat ycxir tasks wore as an assistant roforont? A. As an assistant roforont I "as entrusted with a nurfcor of detail tasks which cino upr'tiin tho roforat for which I boro tho sar» inner -offico responsibility as when Her on I booauo a roforant. Tho '.if.oronco in of foot was that as an assistant roforont I didn’t have the possibility nor the task to lncludo ays olf into all qiostions concerning tho roforat and concern nysolf with thon. :. Apd tt o, witness, gaveyou thoso individual tasks? A. It was ay departmental chiof, at that tino Gc nor alarzt Dr. Marius :i ‘0 vea ny direct military suporior. . ’itness, in your position as an assistant roforont *roro you tho . rsanont representative of the roforont. For instance, rhonov.r -c.'.csor Anthony was on vaent on or or. an official trip, did you - 7820 20 Hoy kl-U- ST-W*-Gro3s (Healer) Court !fo. 1 represent kin? A. Uo, I rosnot is pernanont representative buy only ren ' aso to cose rticn it raa soccifically ordored. ijgr I point out that only iro or three of all the referents had any assistant referents attached to then. It oocurcd very frequently that -hen a referent vent on a one official trip although ho hod no assistant reforont, therefore it wasn't necessary for every referent to have an assistant. The dopartnontal chief alrays knorr -hat ras happening. 76a 20 Kay-.?- 3-S-l-Karrc* (let. Ramier) Court No. I. Q Witness, I think that we can clarify this point by the document which was outfitted by the prosecution. Ii is in Document Book 12 of the prosecution .on rage 77 of the German and 7li of the English Dccunent Book. It is a letter written by Professor Rose dated the 9th of June, 19hh, addressed to Professor Haa-en at Strasbourg. It was submitted urrier Document .Vo. NO-^Ctf and bears the exhibit nuc- er of the prosecution 296. I say ask you to give your opinion about that letter and I shall quote the second paragraph: "Did you hear anything free De. art rent 1 relative to its position with '*itte? It will tako so^e Uae until "2-F" produces its new research ordor as Anthony is on a duty trip for several weeks." These code letters "2-F" \rero, at that tine, ths dosigna'tion for the roferat Aviation Modiclno, woren*t they? A Yes. y % Q T/ould you tell ue at first how this letter originated? It is, r.o doubt, from Frofessor Rose, but porhaps you can rente 'ber tl>o incidont which led to this information. A I can only say that on the basis of Professor Rose 1 3 testimony or. the witnoss stand. I have no personal recollection of tho incidont, but since Professor Ro3o has stated horo that ho asked oithor the departmental chief or tho reforat how the Haugen research order was proceeding and since he received the reply that ono would havo to wait until Anthony rotumod, it is, of course, absolutely possible tlxit I ivo them that information at that tine. GT course, after four years have elapsed, 1 can no longer re^eaber all that. Q In that case you are saying that nothing could be 'decided 3*oo ut the new research order for Eaugen mtil Anthony can® back fron his trip. Is it correct if I conclude therafron that you were not % Anthony*s deputy in these questions? A Yoc, this becor.es clearly evident fron this letter for had -r. Anthony' 1 s deputy in this special field or even quite geocrall^ - er. one co'ild not really understand why one should have waited Many 7822 20 3-5-2-:.arrcsr (Int. Rar-icr) Court Ho* I. years with the issue of that research order until Anthony returned. A But I nay -sention in t'.iat connection that it naturally occurred that certain part assignments which I received also meant research orders for tjs. I assume that if, in the question of this research order to | Haagen, we had been concerned with the mere prolongation of an order ■shich had existed for many years then I may have perhaps roceivod the order to work on the subject, but this document proves clearly that in this field even in the year of 191*3 my authority was very’ limited cr rather hardly existed at all, Q Witness, ore aero clarification in that conr>oction. Tbo Department 1 which io nontioned here is probably the organisational de¬ partment, isn't it? A Yes, that is the first or organisational doiartiiont which I rantionod before. Q The position with Uitte which is aontionod hore is probably tbo position of the consultiiv hygienists with tho Air Floct lhysician which Hacgon lator occupied, isn't it? A According to what I ioarned hero during the trial this can only mean that. Of courso, at that tine I had nothing to do with it. Q Now, witness, lot us continuo with the reforat. What sub- Jocts actually belonged to tho referat of aviation medicine? A The layman, when dealing with tho words "aviation .icdic- ire", if he imagines anything at all, thinks of the two classical fields involvod. This is, at first, the effect of acceleration md, secondly, the effect of high altitudes or, in othor words, tho effect of any lac’.: of oxygen. Those tw> fields, naturally, Jnvo thoir*pricr- ity and retained that priority even during the last yoars. ^ut by 'is int. the Air Force for war purposes an cnorraoue amount of now problems •as added. I can, in passing, natc only a few cf these problems ter¬ rors. There wore general physiological questions about respiration and irculation. There were ques iens concerning general and special pi* ho logy which resulted from air accidents and, in particular, in the 2 C Ifey-. *3—5-3-Karrcw (Int. Ramie r) -ourt Mo. 2. case of high altitude accidents. Questions arose in connection with the co-cal ed physiology* of the aenses; for instance, night-sight, space-sight, or the special demands made cn the person's hearin cr the inference of the noise of the rxtor to any one person's hearing. In that congestion we have to deal w.th pharmacological questions, o.^. the Id or ovens nt of resistance in high cltit«ides by the introduction of drugs which would increase efiiciency. Thore were cei*taln psychol¬ ogical questions which concerned the selecting of fliers are! the train¬ ing of fliers, radical research under particularly difficult emergency situations; for instance, sea emergency, docert erasrgency, mountain on- ergency situations. To this subject belong the nodical special ireasuros which Ivivo to bo taken in connection with tho flying personnel. Tor in¬ stance, wc havo the fliers' exaaination stations, the exaaination sta¬ tions whero rro testod the offeots of high altitudos and, in part, thero rero hospital d-; ; -artconts whoro the fliers rested after extensive fly¬ ing. Special institutions, liku special equipment, special clothing and spools! nourishment for the flier. Thon there is tho dovolo,-mont of the apparatus for tho piloting of airplanes from tho point of view of the psychological and phyoiological considerations, and, finally, 1 should like to point to the nacrous problem which arose during tho air war. The carbon monoxyde effect, the a feet: or heat, etc., in v/hich Aviation medicine worked. In addition, tho roferat had to deal with the construction and sodomizing of the low pressure chambers; educa¬ tion of tho flying physicians; current orientation about Special literature. In that connection, interest in patent questions which arose fren research in aviation uedicine. In collusion I ^ay say*lhat the aviation -..iodic ins is, in no way, a nodical special field which, in the case of all other medical special fields, concentrates on a curtain or, mic system or concerns itself with a certain manner of the rapy or • -nation as, for instance, eyes, eye diseases, throat, ear, nose, otc., aviation medicine com,miser ail spheres of medicine in its connec¬ tion to tho flier. 2 D- -■ 3H>-J*~Karrow (Int. Rasler) Court Ho. Q The witnesses which ver: hoard here - Professor Dr. Veltz and Dr. Huff and Dr. Rosoer<, - have already conveyed their impression to the Tribunal concerning the .Tactical -..-ork in the sphere of aviation medicine. They were telling us what fields were worked upon within the reforat and, in that connection, T nay ask you what, in affect, vss the practical work of the referat in respect to all those spheres which you just rentionad? A If I aay answer this quosticn briefly, the referat had, ir. aose tray, the position of a uodiator, between aviation jodicine on ore sido and the flying units or. tl® other. ?roa both sidoc wo re¬ vived sugfostions, reports about on., rionc.c, requests, etc., which vere dealt with at the referat. T’eeo suggestions were either pasood or. or woro realized in the fora of direct. 1 vea, diroctod to troops, army physicians, research institutes, or hospitals. In addition, of couroo, there wore co.-vioctions with the civilian research units to when, of course, wo could issuo no orders and :>ho roro in connection with ’is by the Issuo of the so-called research assignments. Thoy rccoivod finan¬ cial support and other support for thoir scientific help. Q Witness, at a later date *o shall discuss tho research as- tiROBCnto in detail. T:s FRZS1SZHF: Counsel, tho Tribunal will be- in recess for - far.* ninutos. (A recess was takon) * 7325 20 ''~y U7—lt-AID-1B—i-'feehon (Int* Brtwr.) Court :io. 1 THE ZVtRSH&LLi The Tribural is again in session# 3? DR# TIFP: Q Hr. Becker, when ve stopped wo wore discussing the tasks of tho roforent for Aviation '.'o&dzurin general. You said that he occupied a sort of intercediary position botwcon tho theory on ono hand, which is invited in the research are', the requirements of necessity on tho other hand aabodiod in the troops. I must assume that through such intor- nodiary positions a largo number of negotiations were nocessary for each si 'o, that is to say negotiations both with the troops are! tho r-cntlonon conductin' research. Tould you ploaso tell us her. this was in detail and what duty the roforont had in such negotiations? A Tto 'Teater part of our relations with research and tho troope took placo in writing, of courso, but it is cloar that in sono caaos thoro woro also oral comunications. Sinco tho departmental chief was in char,70 of about oi- ht roforats and referents, it is quito urelorstnndablo that roany of theso negotiations Wc.ro carried out by the referent alone, particularly in connection with official trips outsido of Borlir.. Horo also, it was a nen>rol principle that in such conver¬ sations tho roforont could not :vdco any locisiom, but roportod tho results of 3uch discussions to tho departmental chiof for confircation are! thin this confirmation was iven in writing to tho ;x>rson who was involved in thooo no otiations. Q Now, ritrvj33, a conclu in; quostion. As you said from 19lil until 19lil; you were in tho 'C'lical inspectorate, that is to say at tho vory top of tho Gorman Luftrraffo an', you know that in the troops in thj field th^ro -.as the rumor that the won who wuro active in such positions ha l £ Toat advantages on tho basis of their position, either to roccdvo pro- rontial promotion or that they received hi-her salarios and that they r- 0 'J.ve \ military decorations. In tho courso of your activities, which oov.red years, tL 1 you notice any such a 'vantages in your position or ~a fit free then? 20 Ha J i7-H-ATD-8-2-Heohan (Int Brown) Court ». 1 A So. I received no such advantages, I received no docorations, I r-coivei no higher salary and I received no higher rank and lot no add that iras not custonary at all. Q ifaw, I would like-to clarify one further point with you, tho so-called technical aviation research: what connections woro there bo- Ufe-en tho reforat or the aedical inspectorate as a whole and tho techni¬ cal aviation research? A As of 19UI* for the sake of brevity at this tin., tho technical aviation research was un.’or tho direction of tho 30 -callcd ro3oarch leadership of tho ministry. ;.t tho hoad was Profossor Ooorii, the woll known aviation rosoarch ren. Ho had a nodical raferent free 1937 to rd: 19Ut and that was Dr. Benaingor. In or lor to avoid tlw difficultios, of uncoordinato! nodical research wnsdifficult, having already boon noticod in tho soa-wator export urnts. in tho sumor of 19UU, I was node Dr. 3onzinror's succossor and thus was Profossor Ooorgiiis roforont. Q Sot to when was tho rosoarch loadorship subor inatod? A It was tho chief of tho .dr Anaanoat, it had nothin- to do - 1 th thn chiof of tho no leal inspectorate. q Tho activitios you just Ascribed, as nodical roforont rdth tho rosoarch loa torship is not ono of tho char-os in tho indLotnont, conso- qu-jntly, wo can 1; noro thr.t aspect of your activitios. I now roturn to the borirodir of your work in 19U, at that tino, as you haVo alroa ty :*-i ', ycu woro assi.nod fron tho front to tho nodical inspectorate ithout your having done anythin., to achiove that; what was tho practical roc^or. for your boin; called to tho nodical inspectorate as assistant roforont? A The roason cr reasons are known to no. In tho course of 19U. n ' v * ial ' 3 °f ’‘ork aroso. Tho than inspactorato. Dr. Anthony, was to evor, ha was however not articular as it woul' have noant too nuch rt: for bin. Dr. Ruff already saithat in 19ljl in tho sumor, on tho •Wtructions of Hippkc, tho notieai inspectorate at that tino, ho inspectj J 1 •* rossure charier in Gemany. Ho res.- up a report on this inspection 7827. 20 Hay U7-:W.TD-3-3-ileehan (Int. 3roro) Court So. 1 tcur and turned it over to tto nodical inspsctorats and explained in this report that practically all the lew pressure chambers were seriously jjficient in one way or another and iwjre not conplotely sodom and did not .Mot modern roquiraaents. This =oant that the nodical inspectorate had to take thoss thirty or so lew prossuro chambers and modernize then and ronodel then. That was the first of the two tasks which I mention. The soconi now field was the following: when tho war began the flying units in the Goman Luftwaffo rocoivod for tho first tine their own troop physicians. Theso troop physicians had to turn in every month n so-called aviation experience report and those aviation experience reporta woro sent to the nodical inspectorate in the original along with oo.nents of the people on tho way. Slnco at that tino thoro woro throo hundred to four hundred flyin;; units - so-oallod groups - thoro arrivod a similar nunbar of thoso aviation oxporionco roports ovory month. In thoso reports, tho air physicians wont into all tho now oxparionces that they ha 1 had booauso tho air army was b-^-JH<-CooJe (Prown) university institutes above ell received very littlo financial end per¬ sonnel support free their superiors. For exarplo, the Physiological Institute of tho University of Wuerzburg had an annuel budget of 13,000 arrtes, another Physiological Institute had an annuel budget of 6,000 -arks. In addition, during the var there vas the difficulty of retain¬ ing our scientific personnel and to receive the necessary catorlel, «vcn If ve had the financial scans to obtain it, because we couldn't /pi e high enough priority, and. of course, during the var cost of this stuff vent to rtilitrry departments rad institutes, ^ov, the institutes of the Luftwaffe ouito understood this natter end vero only too happy to nest it. On the othor hand, I don't want to create tho Irorossion that thoso research assignnonts voro slr.ply senobody doing somebody olse a favor, kcay applications for research ooslgnncnts voro turned down if there socciod to be soce objection either tv tho person or to tho subject. I boilers that the 97 research esoignnents that can bo soer. fron Docuncr.t 9J4, Exhibit 450, can nelntrln thcr.- lolves against any sort of criticiso even today insofar as tho porson in auostion end the detail of rosoorch is concorr.cd. loch of those 57 rosoarch non could show such authority and clain for hlo rssoarch rosignr.ont no support. Court i .icy i Q-h-lC-l-KD-Gro ss-3r own Now, witness. If we take a list of your research s i nuer.ts we 6ee that e p^rt of these research assign¬ ments are concerned with allit_rlly important natters. Secaue the work is daring war tine that is understand¬ able, particularly since the aedlcol Inspectorate is a ;*rt of the Luftwaffe. However, one sees also that some • • of these nsslgnments are concerned with natters that appar¬ ently have nothin* to to do with = 111 t ry or specifically Luftwaffe natters. Kow, witness, was the case not ns follows: The :*.edlC9l Inspectorate ns-i nod only commis¬ sions of military importance and only Q -ve financial sup ort to sue assignments and, if tnnt is so, r.uw is it that Ghtre -re assignments in this list wnlch are not of mili¬ tary lm ortanco? ft. The reason for tnls le th. . -oth the hedlcal Chiefs *nd the departmental chiefs and the referents saw rfectly clearly that applied research Is not .oa i-le with ut r very broad foundation in a sic research end rjclssl rvlatlon medicine no no ilod reserrer. always saw itself before the necessity of acquiring basic s<-ien- • • tlfic .nowled v e 6 to t e foundation of it 1 , no lied researoh. If -p lied science le to be carried out as science in the true sense of the word then tnore nos to be n vury broad f undetion of wort I referred to as b sic rc eorch. -ou • ■ - vs already referred to Document 934, exhibit *-50. 'hen L. xhe ~utuan of 134. I turned over rll the research "sai nmonts to tne training groups in the hint ry Hcdical rtcadem in Berlin there were or. that v*rticul«r dny exactly esl-nments to date. I hao ;en to h ve a list fr a that v- 1 • ;le which shows the followin*: - o; these assignments, th-t is 45> of the whole, were - : b-’sic research, tee applicability of which to 7634 Court 1 May 20 -a-I -2-Si>-3r08O-3rown. practical questions dorin e the Mas was neither considered nor or:acted to be very likely. This was a sort of reserch t..-c had been and would hr ve been carried or. durin fc peace tiae as well. 40 a8Slj.nnents, that is 3; * of the whole, c noerned the collection rnd coapilotlon of nllltary ey erlences in the sedicel sphere durln_ the Ver, aeasures eo prevent nocldents and disease. P'rtlcul rly anould be u-ntioned here research into protect on u&oinst air raids. % 15 assltnaants, or 15 ,i, concerned t e selection rnd oonpetenoe of flyers and only 4 assUnio.nta, roughly 0> or tr.e vh.le, concerned the Increase of aviation or fly- in;, e: *eolency in Var tine. I believe that tala break d.wn of thla list clarifies adequately the ,urposo of Ci'.usj resuaren csslenaenta during the 'ar. With the of ouoh roserro.; as8l 0 nnents the Luftwaffe alone orted the work of -.any veil novn institutes and workers »r.d r.ot only supported It but erde it possible at -1 . *. ltnoas, let ne sun up your -never by soyln t.v t v. Medical Inspectorate of the Luftwaffe did not carry ut vl tlor. nediclno specific research out carried out cse-rc on ver , very broad and 6 on. : rol .nsls. «. Yea, I jellovo that car. be seen fr>m cna lint of 7 resocro - assl nnents. v. Now witness, another point. You now what the -- rjsoc.t'.on has deduced fron the tnones involved in th^ csearc * assignments ana now I want to -6k you now were •lose research as i.muits check.a on? How wore the "usirve,. cien chocked on who were working on the aasiiniaontfl? Me re e 5 »lr. let me refer to wr.at Frofessor instock -u;i:lac. to. anyone \uo nna ever .ut nls r.end lnsi-e the u' o scientific institute gr.d wno ur.ows the position . 7«35 Co art i ; j-y 20-2^-10-5-HJ-Gro 86-Brown. of r Ger-ien professor or r Germ n lirector of on Institute .now- fcov such a checxln- Is possible ft oil. In view of : .is lie: t. ct n s been mentioned several times, document K0-93-I, exhibit 458, it can be seen tn°T 40> of these -a:i ; r.mer.te were e ivun to ordinary German professors directly. ... itneas, let me interrupt, b this word "ordlnarlus" you mem regular urofes3ora that regular professors that -a£-SVf-U-2-Karroir (Brown) Court :.'c„ 1 sad tho Chief of the Ucdical Inspectorate hinsolf, bocauso, at the very test, they would havo been specialists in only ono field with specialized knowledge tint would have o nab led then to supervise that or-o field but certainly did not have specialized experience in tho dozens of fields that verc crbracod by t' ia list of research assign- rents, A, That is so. >'ttacss } one additional oiostion. In what forn wore thcro rosearch assignments nadc? Lot nc say * riofly regarding this that the Proso- cuticn socaa to havo tho idea tliat tho rosearch assignment did not contain ncrcly the thcnc but also prcciso and oxhaustivo dotails as to how tho research was to bo carriod out# That is to say, tho rcscarchor, according to tho prosecution, was not givon only tho thono of his rosearch, but also a working plan as to how ho should carry it out. Now what do you have to 3 cy to that? A, Basically I cm say regarding this that tho ray by which a scientific goal is to be acfdovod is usually tix> oost difficult aspoct of tho wholo problon, ‘hat is to say, it is prociooly tills ay to tho goal that has to bo found. Consequently, you arc conplctcly idcumcrstanding resenreh as a tholo if you boliovo that you could prescribe to a reaoorch worker ahead of tico Just how ho is to roach ;iis conclusions. At tho very .aaont you cm sinply toll him -.’hat problcn !xj is to attack and what his final goal is to be, but how ho achiovos this goal that is prccisoly what his task consists of. If I sinply havo to tell a nan that ho slxuld earn’ exit such and such ♦ experiments on a tr.ousand Guinea pigs or a thousand dogs thon I can Just as veil gut a technical assistant. I don't neod a rosearch nan for that. So it vas that research assignments contained only tho there of tho research and usually a; ?roval for certain financial support fer the research, and, fran 19on, dates voro set for brief reports on he progress of the work. These reports "ore treated in a very 20 iay M-:>sr-U-3-Zirrcw (Bronr.) Court No, 1 generous fashion not only by the >dical Inspectorate but by tho research nen tho esc Ives. It could be rolled on that when the rose arch •..'orkor had achieved sorso peeitive goal he would hinsolf sond in the report. Loreover, wo weren't trying to increaso the scopo of tho paper war, but to broaden tho basis of tho research as a whole, and that is not done by adninistrativo orcorc. Iho final reports on tho roscarch nssigncorla were usually turned in in tho fona of ro rints fron various scientific publications or they wero turned in in tho foro of manuscripts for such publications, Q. ‘-kn: t a question about tho roprts, witness. You spoko of interim roports wiiich r»ro to bo subedited at specific regular dates. 7/hat did thoso reports contain? -o bo spcoif'.c, did tho research rai doscribo oxnctly what ho had dor.o or what ho intended to do or Just what did ho put down in this interim report? A. -’irst, tho interim roports had to givo soco accounting for iiow tho coney had boon spent that had bcon ranted for t!ds rosoorch and a y or.o tho had onough scientific oxpcrionco or knowlod^o could 300 fren tho way tho aonoy had )>con opont what had boon workod on. Tho interim roports on tho courso of tho scientific work wore limited . ainly toa*y that "wor’c is boing carried on in th? direction it was being carried on boforo, Sooo results havo been achiovod but tlioy do not yet suffico for a final decision, consequently it is requostod that tills rosoarch aadgruent bo untended for another year and that sufficicicnt funds for this extension bo cado available." It is quito easy to understand free a psyche logical point of vies, why thcro iras M nr - extensive or detailed roports in theso interim reports. First of =11, no roscarch non likes to ifiiow his hard before the work is finally d-nc, and, secondly, every serious research worker only uaixs Ids results public when the Togran is concluded ard when ho wants to got his credit. .. And, as you said, the final reports wo o submitted in -he fora of 7BW I£sy hi-it S3-11- li-Eurr or' Brown) Court No. 1 scientific pxblications which woro intended to bo or had already been nude public in scientific periodicals? A. hat was the custonory lay in rtiich it was done. Q. 4 ho next question, witness. During the war vhat was tho policy on tho secrecy of these research assignments? A. As littlo S3 possible was to to kept sccrot. Only natters '.iiich \rould allow poraons to dcrivo conclusions of anilitary or tochnic.il nr.turo, -uring uyactivities at tho Aoro odied. Contcr in Huidolborg I again had opportunity to soo tho cornunications fron tho Chiof of tlio licdical Inspectorate in t;» fiold of aviation ncdicino, Aaong tiio tronty-fivo research rooorts tlvero woro only&ur or fivo, at tho most, that wore indicated as secret, In addition, tlioro aro tho oieht or nino voluaosof tho periodic! "Aviation odicino" thich vas printed and distributed porfoctly blicly and oponly. B 0 th Profossors ilii-pko and Schroodor roro of tho view that tho results of tho nodical research should bo nado accossiblo to tho public in tho hono country and thus bo cado public oven to tho population in foreign countrios, ovon while tho war wo a still on, ovon in casos rhoro Dr, Anthony as roforont or lator, rgrsolf, os rofcror.t, thought that to should disagroo with this and, without boing critical in any way, let no say that according to a commicr.tion in tho English periodical"! ancot" of 13 April 19U6 tho English Government ordered that, fron 19U3 until a considerable period after tho ond of tho war, it was forbidden to publish anything about tho new drug penicillin, Q. how, witness, in the rosoarch assignments acc ording to thq prosecution one fact plays a v„ry decisive rolo. That is tho famous file note 55. You know that tho prosecution charges you with all tho dcements carriod urrier the filo note 55, and which carried tho - • various reforat numbers for tho referuts in tho judical Inspectorate. *'-t ::c point out that this mot or 55 has thrown the prosecution off ir. a fow points. At any rate, witness, I should like to ask you about 78A1 u7-Jt-Sc-H-5-“arro^fBrcsm) Cecrt Ho. 1 f.ia dcci3ivo point. According to the prosecution »8 chargo, all research assignaents, under nunber 55, did not go only through tto refer at for aviation a-dicino \nt -..ore ! andlcd there as to thoir "-ntentOo !i or, can you tell c soaotling about that? 20 day-U-GJ-12-l-5um3-(3rc*n)- Ccart 1 ^ rirst let co p int cut that up: tc Hay 19LL I had nothing tc 'c ith the mrkSnf. cn the research assignments as a whclo. This belonged within the specialized fid of the P-fcevent, namely, Frf^s r «nthc- ay. But Profess~r *nthcny like cysdf later c-ncerno himself cnly v.lth the assignments cf a purely aviati-n nodical character. Despite this fact all of the resoaren assi.jnnonts went thr u~ht there- for tn. fell win. reason: in the Luftwaffe we ha', the sc-calL. ’ ..'ehrmcht Unificati n Plan. That is to say, every field was Set !nm under a rubric. The file num¬ ber 55 was the cnc use’ by the nhclc fiol -f research. Inlepon.’cntly f whether the a flatten ru.’icinc r aviation technical research *r sne thcr fid’ was invrlvei. Let ae p-lnt tut in this connect! n Ruff's Dccusxnt He. 5 in Ruff's ccuccnt V k pa e 16. This is a question .if fin'in a research pr fess rship f r Dr. Ruff and a 1 thru h this is a questi n inv-lvin nly tlx. tiers nnd ’cpartixnt this letter, because it c nc-rned the research pr.fossrrship is carric ' un or File He. 55. Ha' this lett r c«ae t the nc.’ical Inspectorate, f r example, it w:uld aut aatically have cea. thr u h the Referent Aviati n ^o’icinc, as rrt nly a ifen-nt ftyferat but 'nly an 1 wholly'a lifferunt 'epartnont was c npot.nt f r p.r3 nnoi matters n research natters and wer. carrio ’ under thi3 sane Fill il . 55. Since in the helical I n apccV rat :f the Luftwaffe- 90 cr 95,. cf all research assi rr-_nts c> ncornin aviati'n tee licine an.' only a Very snail part concern in- the ther fid's 11 ' cunonts with thi3 file number 3imply in rdcr tc keep things strai htenc- ’ ut in thw filin; system were sent threu h cur epartc..nt. This ha the Teat a'vanta re when it coco t w rkin.; 'n tliesc assi nments that if any research assi aments was beia-- lc ke-'. for the Filin Department knew v.ry well that the File ” . 55 reforre nly t-. natters that went through the ‘k.ferat f r Avia¬ tion *e. licin» and Were tc be f;ur.: in that Ref era t. -nether roas-.n was the f:11cwin.:: prrticularly urin the war, many fticcs issue ’.irecti- v-,s rc. ar 'in istributicn f pri riti.s n the usu uf fun Is cn the em¬ ployment - personnel for research pure. ses. .i.w, it is clear that the 7SL3 2C ^-Si-CJ-12-2-3uro5-(Frcwn)- C-urt 1 &efcr..nt i*u hen lea 90 :£ -11 respire). assi iruonts r a re, is b.tUr acqualntc. ' with thi.se various directives ttn otner ffic«s, then a referent who has t- w rk cn only no :r %w res ceres assi. nevnts an perhaps nly -nc^ r twice in a year has n thin tc< -V with these i*at- t jca at all. In the list cf the 97 research assi-noonta, Drewsent tfc- 93f«, Fxhibit hfft • f ’97 research _ssi rca-nts 8 arc net f an:.aviation xe’leal ch-racter. = r this re's.n '.Is , naady, f-r these purely a !- oinistrativo aatters cf a^cin- that these directives arc boin.: ibeyed— fer this reason also ell cf these file nunbors 55 natters went to the Referat fer Aviation Mcdicino. Thcro was n third reason, nanely, the fell.:wine 1 all f these w*k received research assi-nnunts rcro, as I said bef re. Profess.rs or Scientists f Ion* standinc- The ftjfcrat Aviati n Kodicinc was free 1939 tc 19U. always adninistorod by active pr fess rs an’ thcro is a lifferent point cf view of a.ainictrativc and r..anixati nal ccrrcsp nlcnco an! if off .rts were to be aa !o t- ore- serve the style cf acodealc circles aa! sc it was Ur.t the Reforont in thi3 ’oportaant was c neemed with these research assi awaits and this c ntinued event aftor 19Ui when I bocaao the Referent even though 2 was r. t at that tine a profess r, D.T. 7IFP: Mr# President, in this connection I had intended U put -a cuiobvtr of iccuaonts — deouaents re.-ordin* the entire research problen. That is tc soy, tho asai. ament f this research; the form, c.ntents, the supervision, etc. Unf rtunatoly I recoivcd theso Veunonts £ l - * thoy are in Bcckor-Froysin- P-cunxnt Byk 5 and one if toon is in Br rk I* aa! so far as I aa infrrned tho Tribunal has not yet received these vcluacs. However, the Dofenso Inf ration Center has t 1! nc that I aay have n t translation cf one of th».so affidavits and =iy receive it during recess. If that is the ease I sh uld like t-- put it in then# It is an affidavit by Professor Dr. Schaefer. Otherwise I ask pemissi n v put in the d'eunents lat«r as s:cn as they have ' n translate 1 . 7 8U 20 Jay jC-12 -3-3urns Court I THE FRESJDSNT 1 me dccuccnts nay bg offered when thoy are avail¬ able t- c-unsel. I sy.\ost that this ex a mi n ation be soac-what expedited I think wo have had vcry.lcn^ explanation but dcubtloss have their ir>- pcrtance tc the defense counsel but I think that this examination could be expedited sene what to advantage. DR. TIPF: lir. President, I have Just concluded the treatment of this them an-’ I cat new tr the discussion of the individual oouats in the indictment an'. I should like t . ask that perhaps the n^on rocoss be taken now. THE HESHE.1T! The Tribunal will be in recess until 1:39. (A recess was takon until 1330 o'olock) 2C I ay L7-A-6 J-13-l-?oster (Racier) Court No. 1 AFTSUfOON SESSION (The Tribunal reconvened at 1330 hours, 20 ay 19li7.) THE i ARSHALs The Tribunal is again in session. DR. GAi.’LIK (Counsel for the Defendant Hoven): Ur. President, I ask you to excuse the Defendant -ioven fron tomorrow aiorning's anl toco rr on afternoon's session in ordor to pro par o his defense. IP.. HARDY: I ha/e no consent in this regard, your Honor, tut while toe defense counsel for Hovon is here I have a question to put to him regarding the case of the Defendant Hoven. x o date we have had two witnesses apdear on behalf of Hoven. The prosecution is interested in i.hotheror not the dofonso coun3ol intends to c all other tdtnc3scs on behalf of tho Dofondant Hovon. DR. GA' LIK: Throe other tdtno33C3 have been approvod, tho T.dtnossos Richard, Dorn, and Schoublo. I have rocoivod an affidavit fron tho tdtnoss Rickard which I an going to subedt. ’Dhothor I shall call tho rritnessos D om ard Schoublo to f.io tritnoss stand, or whothor I could profor to &>t affidavits fron t!ion, I cannot sfty today, sinco I hn/o to discuss that quostion with tho witnossos as 30on as they arrivo in Nurenborg. T:E HiESIDEltT: C 0 unsol, as soon 3 you havo discussed this -rattor with tho witness os, will you ad vis o oounsol for tho prosooution as to j;hothor thoy till bo put on tho 3tand or you will U30 an affidavit? DR. GATLIK: lo 8 , ir. President. THE RESIDENT: Counsel for tho Dofondant Hovon having roquostod that Do ford ant Hovon bo cxcusod f roc attendance before tho Tribunal tecorrow in 7 order that his counsel cay consult with hin cor.corning his dofonso, quest is granted, ‘ho Dofcndant Hovon will bo e:;cu3cd fron attcn^onco before tho Tribunal tomorrow. Counsel nay proceed with tho c::anir..tion of tho witnoss. HBUftNN 3ECKER-FRETSEIC - Rosuccd DIRECT ZXAHEIA7I.H (Continued) DR. TIP? (Counsol for the Defendant Bcckcr-Froyscng): IS". President, 7646 20 'Jsj U7-4»-SS:-I3-2-Postcr(lUBalcr) cou t ;ro, 1 ->ith reference to tho complex uhich I c OPpleted this norning con¬ cerning the research asdgnncnts and thair treatment, I said that I ms going to sutadt a document fron which I -nsgoing to qiotc. As I already said, it is contained in J oci=ont Book No. U v.iiich is not yet available to the Tribunal; howover, I havo Ju3t received tne translation of that documnt fron t: e language w ivision, and the necessary amount of copies havo bee-, landed to tho Socrotary-Gonoral, niti tho request to hand then to t: o Tribunal. *ho interpreters as nil as -r. Kaxdy havo also received co,ics. If it please tho Tribunal, I should like to quote a few passage e froo tils document. (docent handed to tl» Tribvnal.) r.L. r.£SiDS;fT: Tho Tribunal hac not yet reoioved tho copioo of this document In the Ocraan language, but I assume they trill ~-o providod later. Counsel ray proceed, DR. TIP?: This is Tcckor-"royaonc *>ocrnont '.X) Qi, contained in Docu.ant Book h on page 3U0. X offer it as 3cckor-Frcyson. : bddbit Ho. 7. It is on affidavit by drofossor Dr. -ans ^chacfor, of Kurckhoff Institute, Tad Kauboin, dated 2U April 19U7. After tho custa*ry Introduction he says, under figuro 1. 1) "I, Prof. Dr, ^chaofor, phr-iioiogiot, dopartaont diroctor of tho filliaa J. Kurckhoff Instituto at Bad Haahotn sinco 1 January 1-?U0, rccoivcd in 19U0 or 19ld fron ‘lac tfcdical Inspectorate of tho Iuftrraffo a research assignrxut on tho subject of "research on the electrical by-cffccts of anoxemia srl hy xr-aoration". ; ith rofcronco to t;.is asslgnaoot, too intermediate roports a3 veil as 3 publications rxro issued. It *. nsnot yut completed by tho end of tho -.nr. ■2) The subject t ns selected and ropescd by mo. I had previously orkod on ±ailnr subjects, although not on the effects of anoxia. Tho subject represents part of ny special field i.c. the corhiantion of electro-physiology and circulatory research, on which field i ac still working today." _ 7847 20 :^y l;7-A-SS^13-3—Foster(Ranicr) ~ourt So. 1 Under figure 3 the tritness describes uhy ho asked for this '“Sigmxnt — in order to obtain prioritiesand defersents anti thus to be r.blc to carry on his scientific activities. X. ?I?? (Continuing): I qxoto from figurc U on the 2nd page: - did not subject nysclf to any aip-rviaion by the ledical Inspectorate by the as si gnoent of tho roscarch cosrission and it acceptance, ‘he research assignment gave ao absolute latitude regarding tho method of otxcution and tho choico of tho no a ns of research. 1 only obliged to give reports or. schedule ard to account for tho sonoy spent. "5) ’ 4 Vro novor vaa a chock-up b tho -odical Inspectorate, nor •.xro tiioro any rcqujsts. At ono occasion, luwovor, Prof. Anthony, 10 oificial in chargo, aid a private visit and raa d:orm through tie institute by nc." 1 shall skip figures 6 and 7; i olwuld li!:o to ask tho Vribvnal to take notico of thorn. I qioto again from paragraph 8: '•'0 nstructions regarding tho oxccution of the coaiission-.roro •' -"od, and had thoy been, I should ‘n any caso havo rojoctod thon." • 0 rest of this paragraph isnot relevant. -n figuro 9 ho says, and I quote: " v . should not on principle havo permitted a ny kind of control c - scientific results, -von by «xq orts. If contmIs arc dcsir-d t: 7 "-*c only possible in tho fern of neremporinonts by a second -dentist." * I shall dispense with reading the rot of tho do ai cent. Thoro ':ll0K3 thosignature and the oustooaxy certification by a notary. ‘his concludes tho question of roscarch assignments for tho tin: -hag, and I novr turn to tho individual counts of tho indictnont. 7648 Hay 20-..-3K-l*l-l-3card (Int. Itcnnlor) Court Ko. 1 ; Witness, you have heard the desire of the Tribunal •hat the procoeiin 3 be shortened; for r;y part I shell stride out part of the-questions which I intended to put to you, .and I should like to ask you to Unit your replies t wh.'.t is absolutely necessary. .titaoss, the Prosecution charges you with spooi.nl responsibility for and pnrtioi. ntion in hiph- -.ltitudu and cold ex. rinont3. .r the r-octin . M~y 20-.--BK-l*i-2-Bocrd (Int. Il-nnlcr) Court !»o. 1 ny . Tticul .r i::; rtancc to whnt the dcpnrtr.cnt chiof said, -.’o ut one ---ry s.ocific oases. V Then itnsohor s.;oko of originals who wore to boo erne experimental subjects? .. Yos. A ; Dirt ho say anythin: about the typo of criminals? .. No, not in da tail. It was very clear, however, thr.t they wore criminals. I ruuunbor that ho nontlonod that those pooplo were to have the op. ortunity of rehabilitating thonsolvos in 3ono way by virtue of thoir . articulation in thoso experiments. Ho furthermore sail that for that reason not every original who volunteered would !>o permitted t > ; jticipato. I roaanbor very clearly an oxauplo whero q S exual criminal who had boon convicted of a number of effunses against your children, had volunteered but was not permitted to .rxfcioi; ate in thoso experiments, whoro ho vnuld have had an opportunity to rehabilitate hinsolf. . hew did this conversation end, witness? - I con say nothin; about that. I was only called to attend the conference after it has begun, .and I had to 1 -ave tho conference before it was finished. . In that caso, you do not kn ’c not know. . Now, witless, on this occasion you saw or. ncsohor for 7651 U'y 20-..-3K-11— x-B- nr (Iat. *ter.r.lor) Court No. 1 tho first tii:o, and you hex’ for tho first tirio that ex¬ periments wore to bo ..erfomed or could be performed on criminals In Gornany; is-that ri^ht? •• y. s. i ~s you toll us yesterday, you had informed yourself to r. great extent about tho experiments on human bcinps from th- theoretical . oint of vi-w end you had performed ox. ori- tunts on yourself; new toll us, whet i/.prossion did you have when you hoard th .t outsiders, criminals, were to bo usod for those oxporinonts? - This announce: ant n-.de a big inprossi;n on no. I had had sufficiont experience with ox. orinents on human bcin ;s in jortr .l and solf-oxpori/nnts in particular. Up to that .>oint I had known about ox. orinonts on prisoners only free literature. I knew about thor. only as a result of r.y propatory work for tho State oxanination, when a fow famous canes had to bo known for bacteriology or surgory. Thoso wore Str ing's famous plague experiments in Manilla, ..mini's leprosy ox.orimont; and I knew of oth-r examples l‘r.v; "Hiorobc Huntors" by Paul do Kruif, which I had read lik- ^very other G.-rn-an nodical student. . ..ftor having already concernod yoursolf with th.-.t .-ruble In theory, boforohand, nay I now ask you, witness, wither y u considered th-so oxperin-nts which wore boing planned 1-;al experiments? •• Yes, I considered the/, to bo just ns legal os all Vh. tl^rs of wjiich I already knew .t that ‘-Lo. I knew that no • J-ction had been rnisod to thoir legality or admissibility. in addition I was told that tho originals were to volunteer. - toi-w that a special -xc. .inat ion was neoossary, and that -ci .1 per:J.3sior. would : „ jiven. Furthermore, I did hot "" -bout this mr.ttor in son- dark corn_r where a conspiracy '■‘■2 :oinc on, but I hoard about it in the offico of r.y 7852 L'ay 20-^—BK-i:-5-Bo ard (Int. .irjinlor) C _urt Ho. 1 auprorio superior, about whon I had tosssuio that ho had known *.asohcr free before, and that ho had already doalt with that question for soco tine. ::-y 20-..-3K-15-l-iic^hm (Lit. ivonnlor) Court Ko. 1 1 'ic'.l, witness, thr.t was your nttitudo about this ,/lnn at that tino, just as you have outlined it to us now. Wit¬ ness, how do you Jud'O the question of locality today? In 4 -rinci_lc, just as thon: today I havo ::uch norc roof an', nrjiy r.oro oxaa_.lcs for oxporinonts on orinin.als, which woro oorriod out in on absolutoly l«jQr.l and adnissiblo way. I onn not ica’ino that tho orininals of cth-r c ^xntrios would bo idonlists and would out of ~Airo idor.lisn voluntoor for thoso ox. crincnts in lr.rfto numbers, nhilo Gorrx.n crininr.ls would not voluntoor for suoh ;mrposos. don't actually bolievo thr.t tiurnnn orininals r>rc ..ron;.tod by id or. lisa but booauso they ox.xict oortnin in. rovoraents in thoir condition thorofree, and I think the saao holds true in other oountrios. In orcUr to ;rovo that, I any quote a ;r.3sa.;o fro:, tho book n ~n ..n^ric.n doctor's Odyssey" by Victor Hoiscr, free ,iC£o 1-19 j f tho Hu mm outhorizod transla¬ tion of tho year 1916. It says thoro, .ind I quote: ".jj soon as roaody for sono di3or.se had boon 3Ub jested, tho Institute established whoth-r it was offeotivo. Tho ox;>Dri- ronta were oorriod out cn innatos of Bilibid, who ournod a little ooncy and, if tho ox:>orinoats wore dnn.;orous, oould c.chiovo ; niti ration of thoir sentence." Tho institute i3 tho .loroostor Instituto in M nilla. 3ir.il.ar ; roof fro* nodorn tines can bo foun’., for cxuoi»lo, in tho Journal of tho *•£. j loon Modionl -.ssoci ation, 27 ..;ril 19*6, voluno 130, : a-.o 1256. I quote: Under tho hoatliflr?, Prisoners Used as Guinea Fi s for Mo die :1 lex. uriiijnts," there follows the report. Ginil-r th.r.to is r. ro_- ort that ox;>orironts wcri. carried ut uq s tie 77 innatos in a ..risen with hashish or narihuana. .at ion has already been a ado h'-re of a nunbor of oz 1 orir^nt3 . conscientious obj-ctors, so I lo not javo to jo into all 7654 ;i«y 20-..-BK-15-2-Uoohnn (In-, Lanier) Court No. 1 ..11 thcso examples, which ’.o not orijinnto froa antiquity jut froa tho last few yoars, soon to show very clearly that chore is a possibility of findinj onoujh voluntocrs anona ^onitoncinry incites for 3uch oxporinonts, that thoro no always cn>uh physicians who nro roody to porforn such ox. orinonts, and that apparently no ono in the world raises any objections to suoh experinonts. q, Lot us new "o hack, witness, to Dr. uaschor; when did ycu soo ^r. *>fossor Holzloohnor. .ithout ,:oinj into dotail, I wqnt to ask you whether you : -inert the ix;,.res 3 ion fren .lascher's rarjurks that what .icschur had Ijeen cloin; in Jachau was in any way criiiinal? .. ..t that tine it did not bocoaj evident to uo fron what ..a3cher 3aid that what he had boon rtoinc in collaboration with Holzloohnor was out3ido tho law or outsido tto sphoro of r.'lnissibility. . But wo do knov;, witness, that th030 discussion ronerks ando by .ia3chor durin ; tho Nurnbore cold nootin 3 raised an occasion for sono discussion onona the participants in that neotin. 1 . How do you explain th«30 discussions, ;"rt of which were r-jcctin;; Haschcr '3 proooduro? .. Ono really can not spoak of any discussion in tho true ser. 3 C of the word - a -iscussion .t the ncotin;,. I think there was only . ; uroly priv -.to discussion after tho lecture. . That's what I noon. 7655 Hoy 20-.--5K-15-3-L-U -hnn (Lit. .»cnulor) Court No. 1 .. If I can Jud^o fron ny own ooso, the discussions did not refer to what *iaschcr said, but to tho nanner-in-whioh. ho scid it. The unnner in which ho spoke about his oxperi- conts was sonowhat slo.py, and not quito suitod the serious-* nature of the lecture. , You said, witno33, that you r.ot nschor in Juno in 3orlin in Profossor -Hippko's offico and that you saw hia a;-ain during the Number a oold aootin.^? .. Yos. i, 3of ore this Nurnbora a cot in;, did any one worn you ajalnst hr. Unsohor? .. No. ’i Nov/ lot us turn to anothor problon, witness, in connootion with ->r. itasohor. 00 know Tror. what Profossor ioltz tostifiod horo and .also free a nunbor of doounonts, whioh woro au nitted b y tho Presooution, that «r. .laschor »antod to qualify as r. locturer by suhnittin ; a thesis in tho fiold of aviation uodioino. unsohor was in addition •1 nodical offioor of tho Luftwaffe, and it oould l>o assunod that you, or the Nodical Inspootorato, would havo loarnod sonothin,'; about theso . Icn3 of Aaschor and as a result would also havo found out what .lasohor actually did in order to exoouto thoso plans, witness, fiay I ask you whothor you icncw anythin; about .tnschor's intention to qualify as n lecturer? .. N , I knew nothin* about that. . I do not want to discuss ell thoso docunonts with you, •.»itno3s, which wero submitted by the Prosecution in that connection; thoy show no connootion with tho Luftwoffo, apart fra. two oxco; tions. These two exceptions which I Just ntionad are in connection with aviation nodical research, .id f or that reason I nust ask you about then. 7856 M y 20-*»-BK-15—I-M;:ohr.n (I--.-, Junior) C.iurt No. 1 Tjxo first doounont I shoal:' like you to look at ocn bo foual in Uncunont Book 2 . This is doounont NO-290, Exhibit 121 , which oan found on *030 166 in the G„r..._n book and 156 in the Bn lish i> .aunont Book. I 003 your pardon, thi 3 is in doounont B >ok 3. It is a lottcr signed by Us . Siov-rs, bo aria; the lcttorhead of the "Pawnor bo" Society, with the date 21 M rch 19.*i. It is ed/.rossod to doctor Bud: If Brandt, on tho porsonnl staff of tho Boiohsfuohror 3S. I should like to disouss only ono sontonco in this doounont with you; it is tho last aontonoo on tho first - 030 , and I quoto: *Th u diroot or of the Instituto for ..vintion Medioino in Frankfurt, Oborstarzt Frofossor Dr. von Dirinashofon, who hnd clrondy ooncontcd to tako -art in tho ;'rusontation of tho thosis in linrbur :, would r.ost oortninly hnvo boon in- '■.ucod to fawr idnission to tho faculty in Frankfurt.' Oborstarzt Professor von -'irinr.shofen was a nodioal officer of tho Luftwaffo, end in addition on Institute for ..vlation Medioino i3 nontionod hero. U-vy I csk you, wit¬ ness, do you know von uirin;shofon, end do you know this Instituto for ..viation Mcdicino of which Ur. Siovors is 3 k onkinc horo? .. I knew Professor von Dirin;shofon, but thoro was novor an Instituto for ..vintion Modicino in Frankfurt. Professor von Dlrinr^hofon wes the hoed of on institute for noohnn- ionl influences on the surroundings. T'.is instituto was^ founded by the city of Frankfurt on tho M..in and had nothing whatevor to do with the Luftwaffo. . I.n tho sr.ee connection, witness, would you plcaso look at another doounont in the sane doounont book: ti is is -ocuncnt N0-230, Exhibit 115, on ?a;o I 53 9* thc Gorn0n . njld 142 of thc B . lish doounont book. This is the course of •'•aschcr’s nodical trainin whioh he hi.nsclf has written Hoy 20-*.-3X-15-5-i:ochan (Int. *te gn l o r) Court No. 1 under tho date of 17 May 19-13; on the last pa^o of this docunont, * 1 , you will find tho followin ; passage, and I quoto: "..ftcr tha cone usion of this rcsoarch work", cf which he has previously been spoakinj, M I intond , cs n proed upon, to return to tho Univorsity Instituto for -.vintion Medicine and Hy ;iono (Professor 3r. Pfnnnonstiol, Marburg) for ny further scientific training." 3inoo aviation nodicino nattors were under tho Medical Ins.ootorato, witness, I ar.y ask you whothor you know of this institute, aii f. whothob throu ;h this institute you know about Unschor's plans? .. 1 oan say that there was never an instituto for aviation notticino r.t Mar bur ; an' that I knew nothin': of .iasohor's Ians in this connection. . Ur. Prosidont, in that oormeotion I offer as an exhibit Bookcr-Froyaon ; ^ocunont No. 21 on pi..;o 09 of isoounont dock I. This will booonu Exhibit »o. 8. This is tho affidavit..:. THS P.v^SIDSHT: Counsol, you don’t no n wocunent oook No. 1, do you? 7666 20 l'ny-.,--~ZS-16-l-C k (Hit. . nrl r) C urt F . 1. A Da. Tirr* I bo.* y ur ; rice, Ur. Proaidont, D.'cuB-'-nt B k ¥ . 2.' T^E ~xSID3FTi TThnt exhibit riir>'r do y*u psai *n t • thr-.t? D!:. Tl-:r Exhibit F«. 8. I rv.y quote briefly; it ia on ~a~o 89. It ia an uffid-,vit f -r-'fcaa r Dr. aod. Eoinz v-n Dirinah'fon, Frank¬ furt n the fain, 7 February 1947. ,.ftor the cuat mrv intr 'ducti n I qu-to Firuro I. "Tho Inatituto aatabliahod by no with the cariatonco of the oity f Frankfurt/! to in in 1952, and which I diroctod, w-a o.llodi Ecdieal i^aenroh Inatituto f r Itochanicnl Influence*. Thia Inatituto wea neither ottnehod t- the Tnsnoet rnto f r Fodiool ..ffoira f the Luftwnffe, n t did it w rlc under ltt erdora." Cndor ;r:rir-rij h 2 the wi tn. aa dcacrib->a hoc thia qu-tnti n which I h vo Just rut ta the witnoaa erinimted, manly th t .r foaaor Dr. Bcoh aaked the witnoaa Ten Dirinj ah fen whether ho w uld bo i-ro;.srod t -ivo n acientific ;ini n -n n thoaia by the Luftw.'.ffo Stnbaorzt Dr. .naehor, written f'r tho jur; au f quollfyin* oa a lccturor. irofoaaer vrn Dirirvah. fon further atntoa ttot ho deolnrod hiraclf nndy t< *.o ac twit that he hoard n-thin, further nb -ut that firm. I quote e :ain fr-’n po,o 2 «:f the dtoun nt, the l*at pern -raj hi "I woe never requested by tbe Inapeotorat- of the Luftwaffe !V«cnl Sorvieo t- oeep.jrate with Dr. Sic.-nund Itna-hor n hia hobili- t-ti'-n jejor, nr did I inf-rr. t)io lna;«et roto na to tho above- mnticnod disouaai. n with .r foas r Be oh." Thoro f llewa tho eifnnture and tho custrrrv oortifioati-n. s tho noxt ' .curvnt in that oennocti n I ah eld like to offer B-'ckcr-Freyeon.* Decur. nt Vr. 22, which c .n be f und n ; ,-a 91 f the wn d curv nt b k. Thia will hccr-» Exhibit V . 9. It ia on official rtifient: f tho administrative direct r f rhilii.a Cnivoreity f r’ur-, doted 10 January 19.7; I sh <-ld like t qu- to tho first »rn -r j h: "an Institute f r ;.vir.ti r. Itodicine and Fyienc aev;r axisted nt ■ *111; o ^nivoraity ir. "r r’ur - n t .v .n Vrir the. yur.ra 1941 *. 19.3." I shr.ll n -vs qu tc the last ;.’.rc T ;hi 7859 20 May-.v-0ZS-16-2-C k (h.mlor) C urt V . 1. ■Tho s’- to facts arc taken fr c the files f tho c ur.cil (Xumt riun) f rhillips Cnivorsity. Then fallows the signature, tho stnc; and cortificati n. Viitn ss, "hen y u saw Heschor in Hinge’s < ffica ary 1 , at tho yuromborr c-ld ncctin : *, he was a Strtsrrrt ir. tho Luftwr.fft? A. Yes. Did you 5en-w Anythin- ah-tit his oenborshir in tho SS, ob ut which much aentl r. has boon made hero? n. Kr f I knew n<-thine in i*rticulnr ah ut that. I «nly know, and T heard it durinr Rlri>c«onweriati. n with Ifcschor, that if.eohor wus sjookin- ab ut his r D,v * rolct! M Heinrich v ’imlur. Q. H w wee it, witnoss. that o »ji »h ..Vri usly h"d closo o nnoctirna with tho richsfUnhrcr S e.-uld h vo boon a ihysicir-n in th Luftwaffe r.n' wne n t in tho Tnffon SS? a. 1 A' n't kn w ab ut “hichar's spocirl er.so, but thero ware a number f similar casus. Bof.ro tho war the '..'affun 3S had n.-t yet oxlstod ns >n Independent •?ohrr.-.cht branch, t th t a number f rosorvo fflours whr bolon>d t» the C-ncr-1 SS hid ;«rf mod thuir M'ln-u sorvioo in other bronchos, with th. ..my. Kvy. or Luftrr-ffo. -ihen tho war Sterted th- sc iwof-l*’ were •'rafted int- thoir respective Johimeht hronohos with.ut their civilian aanhnrshi? in nny Tart f imti n ’ in- t"'con int e nsidornti n. Q. ..s we «avw, Dr. liaschor c no rn-;d hinsulf with tw. subjoote, thr subject f altitude nnd the sublet f c Id. 3 th of these sub¬ lets were ;roblcps cf i-vinti n n-dicino? <>. Yes. q. That it c-n bo assumed, nnd tho fr socuti n Sri usly •?« nesurvi, th-t n«- tirti-ns an’ c-rrcs; r.'onco c-rriod n with the Luftw-ffc - in particular the edical 3ns;ect -mto - ah ut those subject* rm.st hive ;• no via th, A.-fomt f r ..viati n liudicinc? ... Th-t c -Id be assumed, yes. Sit fr n nil of th d-cu-^nts *f th - -shor c nrlox I hvo f und -nly tw- d-cur.-nts which vor. hint at -ny r'.rticipnti n f th, ..cforat, whereas 11 th -- d cur.-.-nts sh w 7660 20 HayW.-G3S-ie-2-C* k ( . -r-.lor) C urt U . 1. "Tho a*- vo facts ire tnkon fr n the filos • f the e unoil (Kumt riun) f 'hilli; s Cnivorsity. Thor. i*'llow» tho si c -ncturo, the stars; one! cortificoti n. !7itn- sa, when y u saw teaohor in Hip;ko's < Kic'. an', nt tho “uroaborr e Id neotin;', ho was a Stsfcsrrst ir. tho Lultw: ffc? A. Yea. Did you kn--w nnythin" about hia neaborship in tho SS, about which rueh aonti n hna boon rodo hero? n. Mo, I knew n- thine in lenticular o v ut that. I «niy know, and I hoard It durinr Pinko'* e nveranti* n with Iteschor. that Ihcohor wna ■rooltin- ob ut hia rood roloti na with Hoinrieh ‘■’irelor. Q. How was it, witnoaa, that a nra wh bvi.usly h-rt oloao c moot Iona with tho ^Ichafuohrcr S* ecu Id hnyo boon o physician in th tuftwcffo r.n’ woe net In tho TTaffon SS? n. I d»n't bn w ob ut *haehor'# specie 1 cr.so, but thoro woro n number f similar e-sea. Bof.ro tho war tho Suffon 3S had n t yot oxieted na m independent ^ohraaoht branch, ft th-t a number f reaorvo ffioure whf bolahor e bjIox 1 h vc f• und • niy twr ’ cur. nts which von hint at f th. ..cferat, whorena 11 th.-r d 7660 r.y r- rticip-.ti n cur.-r.ts sh w 20 K*y-,.-C3S-16-3-C k C^ml.r) C urt S> 1. clearly th-t the IJjfcrnt had r.. thin - at all t do with it. Q. .md h-w do ycu explain that, witness? -"hat I swan is, how ri- u ox; loin that the =oj rity of the c-rrosp-ndenco with tho Kodioal Inspectorate did r. t r vor tho Aoferat? Toll, this cor. n d ubt partly bo cxpl* ined - v tho fact that th> i'odlcnl Inspect r, ?r'f. Hi-pko, v r- frequently dealt with such art tors without the rid :f his Hcforonts. In addition, I think that this was probably bocauso 3osehor .r.ly dealt with, tho hi -host auth¬ orities i'ors»'nnlly. Saw, witness, in this ccnnacti n I hove t discuss several d. ounenta with y u fF.Ti which the Irosooutl n will probably infor r. c nnccti n totwocr. Ilischcr and y u. Tho first d cunont in that c nnootl.-n can bo f-und in D-cuocnt Bo k V . 2, p«to 137 of the Gorr.m nnd 113 in the Snlish dacunont b<«*; it is D eur.ont SO-226, Ir so- outi r. Exhibit V . 55. It is c letter fr .n tho ..hnonorbe, af.ain sipnod by Kr. Siovors, and it is detod 21 Cot.h-.r 1942, eddrossed to SS-Ofcorsturmfbshror Dr. Brandt, n tho porecnal «taff cf the IJolchs- fuohror SS. Pndor th« sana dnothing to do with the administration of the loi-CTCJCTro-pijlin the Medical Inspectorate. Can you tell nc- • whether you receivod-knowledge of this letter and whether the Reforat for Aviation Medicine had anything to do with this natter? A I had noither soon that letter before nor was the Reforat for Aviation Medicino ever concerned with that setter. That can clearly bo seen from two thij^s in this letter. Tho assumption th?t the German Research Institute for Aviation Medicine should on its o.vn initiative place a lew-prossuro chamber at their disposal is absolutely erroneous. If tW.3 letter had boon previously discussed with tho Roforat for Aviation Medicine, tho writor would havo known that only tho Kodioal Inapootorato of tho Luftwaffe would havo furnished any such chambor. In addition, if I had boon nskod about this point I would havo told tho porson concorrvod that I know nothing of tho so-c.-llod differential pumps and that nono of tho low-prossuro chambers in tho entire Luft¬ waffe wore equipped with then. 7P62 20 Kay-A-.' 3—17-i-Gross (int- 3rown) Court No. I. Q Kow, witness, we core to r-nother docusant in this connection. And this la again a setter of aviation medicine pro biers which '/ore dealt with by Dr. Raschtr - eviction madicine research. In that con¬ nection I should like to discuss with you tbo Prosecution Document 1512 PS, Exhibit 79. This can be found in Document 3ook II on pope 136 of the Go ram, end page 122 of the English Docusent Book. It is a lottor, “the Reichsfuohrer-SS", and signed "by order, Srandt, SS Cfeorsturrabann- fuohror." It is addressed to a nvebor of persons whom wc shall discuss Inter. This Is a lottor of the Rcichsfuohror Koinrich H l sn lor, apparent¬ ly, dated 13 Doccrber 19U2, in which Rnscher, who at that tl-ao was a Gtaba.arst in the Luftwaffe, is entrusted with tho execution of realistic low-proosuro chamber experiments. Furthoraorc, ho is entrusted with exporLwnts for re-warning after fr. citing. Tho other points .are not important in this connection. Since ttq are clearly 5»ro concerned with aviation nodical re- • search questions, witnisa, tho conclusion is likely that tho Rofcrnt for Aviation fedicine or tho iodical Inspectorate had gained knowledge of tills nss^rvent which wae given to Rrtschor or in which Raschor was Included. In that connoction cay.I ask you :ihothcr you loarnod any¬ thing about this assignment given to Mr.Raschor? A Xo, I found out nothing about that assignment. 1 As you say, no copy of this letter was acknowledged by the Rofcrnt of Aviation Medicine. A No, that can clearly bo seen froo tho distribution list and I think it is a matter of ar^acont to point to various otter matters rhich clearly show a personal nature between Rcinrich Kiarler and Rase her. Q Now, witness, you ar^. saying that tho Refornt For Aviation V- dicine Rad nothing to do with this part of Rascher's work .and tho !&d“ .cal In? rector at a -.vis not conconvc with ttese matter?. In that connec¬ tin'. i must put to you a document .Rich does not soc-n to tally with what you are saying and which most rrobnbly was submitted by the prosecution 7863 20 ky-A-! 3-I7-2-Gro5S (Int. Sroro) Court !!o. I. in order to :ro7. your connection with Snscher*s experinents. This is the djcuoent MO-262 of the rrosecution, Exhibit Mo. 103, znd is in Document Rook Ho. 2 on page 130 of the English Occusent Book. The letterhead "The Institute of the Ifadical Services of the Luftwaffe, dated '■ 3‘r.rch l';U3." It is directed to Cfocrgruppenfuchrer .Tolfl, the Chid cf the Personal Staff of the Reichsfuchrcr-SS. This Jotter is signed by t. Mippko. As can be seer, from its contents, it de-lo with Stabsnr*t Dr. .tocher, and the prosecution nay well conclude from this letter that you participated in this natter hjeauso you arc the only one of tho deforciants who was working in the Itdical Inspectorate dur¬ ing tlx> tins in question. Vould you placso toll us, witness, whothor you hod ray knswlodgo of this lottor and of tho points contained thoroin? A Ho, of that I knot' nothing p.s can bo eeun fron tho conploto lottorhoad, moroovor. "Let no rend tho lcttorhoad onco again to show that - "Tho Inspector of the ‘todic.al Services of tho Luftwaffo. Kilo noto none, ho. 2299A3, werot, and tto abbreviation for tie word In¬ spector". ?> abbreviation IHSF for Inspector noons tint this is n letter that tho Inspector has worked on personally, because if a Rofornt had ucrkod on this lottor there wo'Od havo toon an appropriate file nun- hr to shew that, Itoroovcr, Professor Hippko spoaks so unmistakably of himself ir. this lottsr that it is perfectly clear that ho had personally varkod or. everything aintioned in this lottor. q How, witness, in cor-.oction rith T)r. Rase her, a further document, also from Docrant Book III, 133 tho English. This is Raaclv.r's letter to Brandt of Hi I'rr ch UU3; it is Exhibit 110. Ir. this lottor Rancher reports or. *. conv-rsation that ook place or. 12 Shrch with yo-r chief at that time, Profesror hippko. The entira re¬ port concerns its .If with Rescher'; kish-nltitud- and frev zing work, and as -ou s-y you knew nothing about thoso negotiations. C-n you tell rru something about that ple.aso, noi&aly that you knew nothing of thoso r^f.otiaoinns jf itaseber's? A. i :8 w-» ta_t of a large-scale >rison in c—-> foru, is that oc? -v. uk-t v_a wh_t all of us imagined under the tern "co.iccntration co- ero you able to see in an y way who tho ina.tos of ccnccntra- tion cjups were? I know no details -oout tali, of course, but I n .d he.rd that both political and oriainal innate* were to oe found in concentration ca >*, end I also Know that during tno wj those woo wore considorod m'orth> to Dour urns wort also put in concentration c- pc. 3,. You say those w.io wore considered unvortts' to boar o», witness, How, -ou .re a doctor, and Oeforc tr.it court tnoro has boon c grout deal said of u lo-.ol nature by doctors. Vnf ortunately. a grout deal of it van wrong, l'o« lwt oc ..an you whence you know wh.t you noac to know and wh.it you underst ad by t ie tor- "unworthy to oo u r ur=c n ? a. I baTO cy knowledge fron uy training -t an air war school, in an 0 i leers' training courso, specifically froc tho otrudy of nilitary discipline and silltary disciplinary law; at that tluo, I lo.raod or hoard that those uouoers of the VounSaCr.t ••no were condoenod by c c rt a. ti -1 for criuinal actions While tho;' w^ro in tho oorvico wore scaconcod to •oenltc.itiarius and, in addition, wore design .ted as "un- wart ny to boar .vtob" and, for the duration of tLc war, wore put in o conco.i.r. tion Can, „nd th-t those usi tons sorved tnoir SvUtonco in penitentiary only -ftc: tne conclusion of tho w_.r. * ery woll, witness. an* aov frot- a docut-ont one aore question «n this proelaa of tho i..u.toc of concentration Ca-ns. a doc-.*cnt was put in ©y tho prosecu¬ tion. It is DocuBcnt joo* +2 or. oar*- 132 of tho Scruan, 118 of tho -ii inh. It is document 1617 PS, ?ror<.cution inhibit 77, - letter f rt.’- tne eichsfuchrcr SS to TiUd Mars h al Mich. I '-at to jut two - rat of this docsienfc to -cu, froa the s-cond t.r^r v.t, jSic 7666 23 l.-v-^-J?-18-2-larrow ( i-t. jrova) Court I Soic^u;fncbror SS writes nor- teat ho t ^toa personal responsibility for t - ‘ : altitude crperiuoats and soccific.illy tJces responsibility i ia.\ uoseci^i individuals arc crisinals who desor'-o to dio f ras c_.-. a r„tio.. car?* for these ctnerlaents. How, witness, 'it', you ever uc.-d in connection with theso exporiuents tneso words a aesocinl Individ vis vgo deserve to die"? a. To, and oven today I don't quite .v.o\r wh-t tcoso td»:s .ro c»q)- to ac_n. .. vo ouu up then, you ^nov only of politic.! prisoners .jvd of lu;, convicted criminals vr.o v«re inoates of concentration ca-ne, u'd -’so those contidorod unworthy to ouur arus, wno h.d oloo bo. lly convictcd? a. YOS. Sno .'lest ion of t;;e voluntary coasvnt of tuo experiment. 1 o 'o;^tB cf valcn 3r. r^ionur soofc«, at tt„t tl-o h„8 alroaf. - boon dioc- ;eod by you, witness, and you a-vu told us tn-t you odieved tnc f ct t.v.t thuso persons could and v:uld volunteer. Is that not \fhut YOU testified? «. I believed th .t and o..v no roaoon not to Relieve it, ", I n^v roc .11 to tr.c .‘rioun -1 at this tiuo tn..t t..o vitnons iioff Tor t .o ■’rosccution corroborated tne f„ct th_t tho oxporiitent.l ou'o v Soct8 ver voluntary on 18 Soccabor, 1946, pa*o 70c, .11 and 712 of tho Soman record, 614 and 696 of tno a££lisu record, .n.t concludes c:\r 4 c.lin£s vita coo'-r-l questions, u nd not' I co^o to t..o no.* charge since wo fu.v_- do.lt vitn conspir.xy; to wit, your ticiv.tion in tac high-altitude ex wriJw-.ts. You arc cccmod in Indie tuo nt of p .rtlci'Oat ion in or soeci-1 responsibility for those k: evi.orlaonts. ihoeo lot;orn havo nothing to do witn tnc ..odicul Iaspoctor-to, consequently i shoulil lil:o ti ..nit ou, tc K.ep things in ordo;, wuotner ju over learned of tnosc letters in uay Way -t all? a— Ho, and in hay 1941 I didn't cron belong to the : ot.ic J I..o»oc- cor..t o. low, Witnoos, there caies a letter tn t s .ans to i .die tc .no cc moot ion of tno r.edicul Inrocctor_to «ita t..c nigh-altUudo ccoorinonts -loo oeixia to i .die-to tc..t you hod oa o co.-nection *lt~ ShtB. -h o is Document JO 21V, ^culbit 46, wnich is to Oo found i. -.ocuoont Jooi: *2 p.. *i 58 of tne joruan, _nd ?u-.o 51 of tho naglish. I put # i is docuaoat to y u bec-uso tnc low-pressure cn^-eor is -oationod hero — °-c uso you said th_t you vorked o:. tne question of •'low-pressure c.... ouvs in tnc ;.cdic-l InsicCtor-te. Hascher writes, let -a ? to brie— c* e third p-rn r_ph: 20 -P-18— 4 -£urrov (lat. jrovn) Co-arc I for c.jrrylng out the axoeriaents (hign -ltifido low-pressure) within tho corn of D..chau itself. I forgot to -ontioa to n-uptsturofuchror ?-olochloin th_t a aov-olo low-pressure ehnuoar h-e been provided for mr-oso out of the Reso-rch fund of tho Reich *vi-tioa hiniatry.■ In ocher words, Rascher assorts th.t a uobilo lov-pressuro ch.-soor war. put at r.ls dlsTos-l for tnese nigh-altitude c^erlnoatc frou tho rooe.rch fund of tho .;oich aviation ^ir .\inistry. h*ov, -ou vovfcod on lor-iroasuro cn-noer "•roolais in tao ..odic..l Inspectorate one* so I r.sk you, In this statocent of Roscher's correct? ju This assertion is wrong fron ocgi.ui.ig to ond. Tirst of all, thoro w.a no rosv-rch fund of tao ..oich A vi..tiOu hInistry which eo"ld hovo laid for such - enjaber. If they wore paid for at all, tho ch.yj'oorc wore paid for by tno ..odic-1 Inspectorate. Socondly, tho four lor-pro«suro chjtsbers that the Coniun Luftwaffo owned h..d boon ordorod boforc Rascher wrote his first letter to Hsiuricn .limlcr. i r ao lest ch no or Was ordorod on 20 -ipril 19-1. .anchor wrote Uin fivot letter to hi*.-lor rc,...rdi.ig t..is Butter tr.roe wooes 1-tor; nenoly, on lb ...y 1941. ..orcover, this vnolo ousinoss, including the ordorihb a tho four low-pressure cnauboro, lios al=oat half a yoar before I entered tno r.*dic-l Inopoctorate. ... low, i.r. President, in order to corroborate what tho witness h a just Said, lot r.o ->ut in jtcKor>-?r^-seng Docvsient wr.Lc.; rill bo jochor-Jroyseng jSiioit 11, on p_ac 93 in Document Book II. Juia ie on offid-vit b tao engine or, J. 0. Zeusaa, of 23 Jon -.vry 1947. ‘ itaoss, first let ac as< you, who is hr, Zcusac? a. i.r. Zeus c is the propriotor of the only fira in .-*.rueay # f. C a .auf-cturod such low-pressure chetioors*. 7671 Court 1 May 20-A-19-1-H0-Ma loy-Srovn. Let ne quote briefly fro a tfcle doc-ment: °I delivered a total of 4 mobile low-pressure chambers with -rchine equipment to the •"'eich aviation Ministry, Medical Inspectorate, Berlin. “The first low-pressure chamber was commissioned on 1 December 1939, and delivered on 3C January 30 1940, to the German Experimental Institution for aviation, Berlin Adlorahof. The second Low-pressure chamber was commlsslon- ed (I am not quoting verbrtla) on 10 June 1940 and delivered on 15 August 1940. Third and fourth low-preeeure chambers were commissioned on 28 «prll 1941, r.d delivered in January 1948. I shall return to this document lator. 5. fitness, we continue now with the question of our prrtloloption in the high-altitude experiments. When Or. itoaber. we in the. witness stand 1 dlsoussed with him his affidavit in whloh you seemed to be incriminated. This is Joe lent No. 47S, Prosecution ixr. lblt 40, to be found in uoo ment Book 2, pege 1. I need not quote this. Let •-j, however, remind : ou th? t Romber^. expressed r. is eeeujrp- tlon>th t you knew of these experiments, '•.'hen I asked him about this on the stand, page -5873 of the record, Mr. Romberg stated this w s an expression purely of conjecture on his p'rt. how, witness, had you seen the concluding report on the hlgh-rltltude experimente of wilch Romberg 6poke? a. I saw that report for the first time here in Court. %. And when did ou first bear of these experiments? I he/'rd of them for the first time or that the; did ■'X~.eriaenta when Raschcr and Romberg read cr.eir paper and -.owe choir sovln- picture before Field’Marshal Milch, and revd when they wanted to do that. I found out about Chat as 7672 a Court 1 Mr y 20-A-19-2-HD-i4aloy-=rown. follows: I was called up by telephone et the .neferat either b ?rof263or Kalck or hie assistant, Dr. Buehl, end asked ethjr the ileferent knew anything of nis Intended film 6 -.owing before Flal'. Marshal Milch. I anaverod that ho would h Vo ay clerk get In tougn with ay eaperlor person- rlly about this a tter to find out. froa then on I had nothin- acre to do >.lth this matter, and it has only been hero in Court that I hard been able to rigure our what tnis wh.le kiting was about. Lot n- draw your attention also to the chief of staff .•f th. Inspectorate, who hod this matter brought to his ttentlon and did attend the f11a. Then Dr. Wuerfle, v.:o testified here for rirndloeer on 1C February 1947, and whoso testimony on pa c e 3135 of the dngllsh record--— A. That is tho testimony to which you Just referred? Q. Yes, It is. ilov, witness, rs you know, there Is another docua^nt put In by the Prosecution to-wlt, No. 224, 7 US of tho -nglish Ooouflcnt book 2, exhibit 76. • Thlo la p ro ;ort by R*ab«rg, und-'ted, regardln. rocorte that wore tc t ke nice on the 11th of October before field Marshal ..lloh. This Is apparently the re >ort that ; ou were talkin - at before? «. Yes, it aust be that. Q. In this document, witness, at the beginning it was sai.\ th-t tnis L ill was to oo shown lr. tho course of a 4 discussion of tr.o way tr.ls work wes being developed. Tell ^e, witness, who organized t:-eaa de?~rtmental alec-sslcns, -•'.e uiedloel Inspectorste or somebody else? a. The .medical Inspectorsti die. not oruer then, because c is is a dlsc-ssl n of technical developments and lr. the .-Jr ministry anc. in the Technical Department of it there 7873 Court 1 May 20-H-19-5-H0-kaloy-3rovn. was one section that was entitled "Developmental Section". I presume that it was this section the arranged for this discussion of development, _'out I don't know. I never participated and therefore knew notnln- of It. Q. But witness, you can see that tae Technical Inspec¬ tion had nothing to do with arranging and colling these discussions of Medical Develooment? A. Yes, that I can eoy. 3Y JUDj£ 5Z3RING: 4. 'fitness, you were pr.aent at the film showing a. No, I vna not. ... You don't knew what was s.own there In the film, do you? A. No, I do not know that, 3Y DR. FRITZ: r o know that Dr. Wuorfle, the Chief of Staff at that time snlc. regarding whet he himself knew about thlfl matter; I have already quoted the pas ago fr a the record that pertain# to this. Now, since you wore motive In ti>o competent refera.t, did you discuss this whole occurrence with Dr. 'uerfle rt all? A. Ko, Never. I Believe Dr. Vuerfle sold that here r.lmsolf. 2. I hrvc to correct an orror by the interpreter. You sold, witness, with regard to the telephonic conversation . c r.trwduced this whole question, th*t the oorson who. talked tils up presumably Jr. Xnlck, and said that he would spea:: with your superior, Is that correct? «. Yes, th-t Is so. I hove just been told that tne Interpreter trans¬ late th t that o- woulu speak with yc.ur 6-parlor? a. No. Tne person with whom I was telephoning con- ?e^-i . _ . •_ * - - A Court 1 Kay 20-*-19-4-HD-Koloy-Srowi. cludoi tho conversation by saying that that settled the wrttsr ior him, - Q. «nd that he would get In touch witn year superior and that was probably Herr Kalck. That clears that up. Now, ’.fitness, the Document 22i, a number of Medical Ins .ectorate doctors were mentioned who apparently were .recent at this film showing; Dr. Wuerfle has already been dlscucoed by us. Dr. tfucrfle C9me after the showln^ was c ncludod, 'cut according to this document Professor Kalck and 8ta.bst.rtt 3ruehl, In other words, two of floors of tho Medical Inspectorate were present and Kalck was tho consulting internist with the hod leal Ina-joctornto of tho Luftwaffe, as we kno;/. s.. Did you In this way hear from Kalck and Bruehl anythin* about this alscasalon or roout thu contor.to of th:t film? a. No, throughout the Var I did r.ot speak with Bruehl r.t all. I did not oven know him. Nor can I hardly recall any conversation with rrofesoor Knlck either, nor can I recall anythin^ about this sr ttor. k. Vero these two medical officers members of tho Medical Inspectorate of the Miftwaffe? a. No. >.. What of lco did they belor. t to? a. Kalck was the cor.sultln_ Internist with the hedlc-l Inspectorate, but w. s not subordinate to that of;lco, the Medic-’1 Inspectorate, that la In rny rate not In the ray th-t h- w-3 there all the time. But Kalck and Bruehl so f~v as I know h«i close connections with Field M rshsll dilch "nd were -t this discussion in that capacity. Witness, this report has beer, put in by the Prosecutor which Is the final re;crt of saving rescue from high altitude 7675 Court 1 May 20-A-19-5-HD-Maloy-3rovn. * and Binned by Dr. Huff, Dr. Romberg and Dr. Rascher. This Is cle?rly a report on aviation medical problems. "as t Is report sent to the .-.edlcal Inspectorate In toto as Dr. Ruff has already exp laInc'S here, or Just what car. you cell as about this? A. Cn my own .*inowled Q e I o^n tell you nothing .’ooat It. I Cv-r. only tell you what I can deduce from the documents a re before me. ’nether this re ;ort was sent to Kiipke, tne Chief of the uedlc.'l Inspectorate, I do not Know, nor do I now whether Anthony saw it. I /.now I did not see it. It was c.ocordlng to the documents here not distributed by tno Radical Inspectorate, bat Allah drew uo the list of parsons vno was to receive It, ana os Ruff has explained It we distributed b ; th. Qsraan Institute for hediolno. V. How, witness ,ou say you did not see the report ct f. t time, nd t» nuke this perfectly clear It was not in the files th t you -.now of, -i a a Referent too over? Am Thpt la oerfootly cloer. I never sow It. ... Did you find jut nothin* at rll t’ooat tnese .xperi- mento or when did you find oat about them for the first time? a. I already sola I found out that some sort of experl- a.nts nd ceen mde which were to be discussed nt this develo mentel institute. I found out ©bout it tr.rouih t/.ie tele-hone call from Kale* or ale Assistant Bruehl. Ae a rdin 6 the results of these experiments I read some¬ thin- In reprint fro* the publications of che Gorman academy .or Air Aviation nesearen valch w, s sent to ue w/eVe r report of Dr. Ruff on scvln* fr-i hi.h altitudes vas re r .nted. ■C. A bout tails Dr. Ruff soohe already on >3 April ls47, - 6520 of the English record. 7676 Court 1 May 20-A-13-6 -aD-Ua loy-Srown. That, If I understand you correctl , concludes what new fefore this tricl or before the end of the war, V3 c erd:ni these high r.ltitu e ex :erlment8? A. Yes. 3. Now, there Is a docuaent here that eatv-bllshae a otn.*eotl.n between the Air .'.Inis try on .-.va lotion Med lone your flaferot, nr.d nascher's expernents. This le Document :.'o *64, p 0 e 73 of tnc inullah Jocument Book 2, Exhibit 50. It la .-.o .ed ’•File Note for 35 0ber3turabp.nnfu.hrer 3chnitzler". It concerns Itself es entlaly with Jr. eltz, but on3 y?ra fc ra.n la Interesting to ua. vuote: 7677 May 20—.-3X-20-l-3card (Int. Brown) Court No. 1 asks Obcrstnbsnrzt Dr. Uoltz how J.on; the cx.crincnts will last or*', whether it is justifiable to detail a nodical officer for so Ion: a tine. DIM domnds fren »fcltz on o.-inion on tho oxporinonts, which he, however, can not .*;ivc unless ho i3 fully inforaod about thon." Did you call hiu up or did scoobody else cull hin up? .. I did not telephone hiu. I can only rofor to what Professor Doltz said lntor, nanoly, that ho had roccivod the call fret: Professor ..nthony. ■<, Now, witnoss, another question, naaoly, did the quostion of lew prossuo chrnbors - you have hoard both Jr. *r. i(uff nor I considered either nocossary or ox;>odiont. ..t tills tin-, I reported to ay dopsrtaental ohief and was order¬ ed by hix* to tell tho Zouzen firn, which built cur low . ros3ure chor.b-rs on*, delivered th^n to us, that if any or..-rs cane frac; any oth^r sources but Luftwnffo sources, he 7679 *!c.y 20--.-3K-20-3-3cor.' (Int. Brcwxi)-~) Court lie. 1 was to turn it ’.own at first until ho had the ap. rova.l of the Mod.ier.l Inspector.''.to of tho Luftwaffe. The grounds for this were that we ooul’ adopt such on attitudo toward this firn, because the lledical Ins. oc ter ate of tho Luft¬ waffe v/cs just about this fire's only custccor. 4 To prove what tit witness has just said, Mr. President, let no turn to loourant 2», Bockcr-Frcysorrj Jocuneut No. 2-;, tho affidavit by tho on'inwcr of tho Zouzui. firn that I havo put in as exhibit No. 11. .Zouzuc. writes hero on papo 2 ct tho botton: "In wintur 19il/42, I can not rouonbor tho exoot late, and rinny tines after'wards, *>r. 3uckcr-l'roy3on, told no that under no circun3t.anoes was I to accept orders fr or. othur dopr.rtconts for the dolivory of low-pressure ch.-nbcrs unless they had boon approved by tho ^wdic.al Chief of tho Luftwaffe, br. Booker-Froyo on'; os.coially war nod no ropontodiy gainst nr.kln; deliveries to the 3S, boo..use otherwise every single Luftwaffe or’or to ny .l.arrfor the Modioal Ins. ootorato would bo stopped. "In tho event of any such ore!or, I was to inforn tho Hodioal Ins.cctorcto irnodintoly on* to tell tho dopartr.ont $ laoin ; tho order th-£ ny plant was fully occupied with tic execution of Luftv/affo orders and that we* woro even in arrears." itnoss, that concludes tho prcblcn of tho hi jh-altitudo ux orir.<-nt3. I r.ay sux: u your testimony s follows: neither a in the plcjinin : or corryin; cut of these ux^.orinonts for Che rescue fra. nijh altitude did you in any way participate -a . only -fter th~y woro concluded did you hear About tho3o ox.'orinonts and. then only in the nost oner .1 terns; is that correct? .. Yos 7560 «ay 20 —SK-2©--;-Board (Int. 3rcwA>r) Court No. 1 TIU P.tESIDEHT: Tko Tribunal will now >x» in reooss until 3:50 o'clock tcr.orrow uornic (T; . Tpi-iuani cdjournod until 21 May 19-47 until 0930 hours.) 7581 mi M~y 21-AI-BK-l-l-Fester (lat. ^rov.n) Caur« Nc. 1 Official Transcript if the .-iectornto. Jo you know th at before tho 20th of May 1912 .any such discussions wore enrriod out? .. No. I ’Id not. <- No’., witness, you told us that you hoard of .vaschor's oxperinonts for tho first tino durin : ; the discussion between Professor Ui 4 .ke md ’.seller in Juno of 1912. .. document ha3 boon put La by tho prosecution ro ;ardiiv$ this '.iscus8ion. It i3 in ^oounent nook 3, .>n.;o 12, wocuuent nuebor 233, Exhibit 82. This is . letter froa Jr. -vasohor of 15 Juno 19*2 and ho.adod "Estooaod uoichsfuohrerl " In other words, this letter is eddrossod to Himlor. You know this doou-.ent, witness. Is this tho discussion to which Hippko ordered you to at ton:' at that tino? •* Since I was ordered to attend only one such discussion botwooa iii.r ke and tho noichsfuohrer, this nust bo the one but l«-t no nafco a snail correction. I found out for tho first tino a’mut this think not on the occasion cf this iscussion ut frc.: :.y su. <-riur, -'r. llrjrtius. . Yes, thank you, you have air- idy said that. Now, you v.aro ..re-sent at the discussion cn this letter, consequently, *-'y 21-4I-3K-1-3-Foster (Int. 3rovm) Court No. 1 I nr.y discuss a few joints of this letter with you. The first ; ora ;ra. h concerns itself with tho hi ^.-altitude ez. eri::-nts. -Let no ask you woro you prasont durin; that .'rt of tho discussion? - K , I was called into tho discussion in tho aiddlo of it, consequently, I don't know what was disoussed beforehand or how ion: it had boon lastin':. ‘1 Tha socon’ para ra.,h concerns itself with the froozinc proeloa. Lot no quoto briofly: "..t tho sane tine, ho asked for percussion to carry out the colcl and water ex¬ periments in ^achau, rod asked thut the following bo onposod in thoso ox. erinents: Profossor Sir, Jarisch, Professor ^ r. Holzloohnor and Professor «r. Sin;;or. Tho Inspootor design¬ ated tho experiments a extraordinarily important, as wo nust count on .-.nothor winter in tho East." .•itness, were those points takon into consideration rturinj the discussion, md v/hat o:.n you say by way of sup. lamentation of what you said y os tor day regardin'; thi3 natter? •• Thcso . oints wore touchod on yostv-rday but I rononbbr very definitely that at least when I was prosont it wasn't 's if Hippko requestod somethin:;, but it was that ho was Coin: tc carry out freezin ; experiments and to do so he noodod r. 30 ’istros3 specialist frxj tho Luftwaffo. So far as tho nones quoted hero are concerned, I rononbor Professor J .risch and Holzloohnor. I rue :11 both nrr.es in connection with tho so.-, distress discussions pl.jinod for the la to fall or winter. The whole .lan was already under c )n3ider■ .t i• :n and it .Iso had be.n .:ut before Hip; ko .as somethin • he should deal with. Professor Sin or, tho Luft¬ waffe .atholooist in h'unich, is com. lotoly unknown tone ir. this connection, neither was he included in the plan con- coivcd of at that tine nor did ho take part in tho confor- M 21-'.:-3K-l—i-Fost _r (Int. 3rown) Court No. 1 -no; here in Number-;. I do net knew liir: ;\:rsonnlly .nd ./heth-r cr not I oven knew his neno at that tine I don't me , but it is ;:cssiblo th.-.t later Hi,,pko nnnod hin to -^.seller. * Hoy. , v.itnoss, you described what was sold in thi3 discussion briefly yesterday but there is one x >oint that should bo nentionod a^aln, what .roblc :is were thoso ox- porioonts intondod to solvo? 7835 21 2-2-l*Jocfc (Int. Brcm) Court No. I. A So far aa I can still recall today the propositions that Reaches . ado to Hippka at that tl-te were rather devious and not very preerre. Professor Hippka clearly emphasised two specific problems, one wes t'.» testing of the fosca suit that Kolzloehner had developed ar.d the other was the problem of the so-called rapid rerarming. Q In that part of the discussion when you were present, was there any discussion of the dancer ova ness of the expo rimer, to? A That was mentioned to tte extent that Rascher mentioned tho paper by Smith and Pay, which had boon published shortly thoretoforo, I think in 19lil, and in which it was staled far tho first tino that it had boon found possible to roducc hurvn temperature 2 k degrees contigrado, tho temperature taken rcctally, without killing the subject. I took particular noto of this bocauoe 2 found that vex-y surprising; I had never corxernod syscif before thoretoforo .1th frooting oxporimonts, and I had supposed until then that the reduction of temperature of Just n few dc'.roos below normal woro vary clangorous and then in July, l?li2, there appeared ir. tJ» German Clinical .feokly, the paper by a Danish physician nn.oed Dr. Sltorn, who had chockod on Smith and Fay's article ard also reported on numerous reductions of temperature for the pur peso of treating cancer. Q Thon your answer to ray quostion es to whether or not tho dangerousncS3 was discussed is that Raocher doclarod that they woro not dangerous and referred to scientific periodicals and papers to prove this? A Tea. He did in that collection. How witness, when did you a^.ain hoar of those Intended jX- periaentD? A In Numberg, at ths fro.zinr conference. Q In thi -.oanti-s did you sc; cry letter of .any sort oitivr that coxae to the xx-ferat cr that caae to it? A In the meantime I had nothin; .o do v ith this -.at cr. "J Hen* ;et me put to you another prosecution document, document 7836 2i : - 2 - 2 -Cock (int. aram) Court ::o. i. book 3, page 22, document No. 236, exhibit 33. This is a letter from the i'edical Inspectorate to the Rcichsfuehrer SS. Below the heading, thero is tho file no to 55, and for the referat in question there is tho indiertien L I li lh, Arabic 2, Renan 2 B, that is the referat for Aviation "edicino. How does it hapnen that you didn't soe this letter? A Lot re refer to tho signature. It says: "Draft signed by order of Wullon", who was the chief of staff, and certified 2 copies, signature Anthony. Cn the 23 Pebruery l$hl, Aujustinok, a witness, on page 3730 of tho English record, stated that in view of our regular of¬ fice procedure it was obvious tint this lottor had boon worked on by Anthony, Q New, witness, though you didn't concern yourself personally with tills letter, - can you nevertheless, on tho basis of your general knowledge of tho work in the rofornt for aviation Eodicino, clvo us sowe information about this. This is a letter regarding freozing and in tho first part Anthony writes that Stabsarzt Professor Dr. Holzloohnor on tho 2U February 19U2, was given a rosoarch assignnent on tho cffoct of freezing on wans blooded subjocts. In connootion with this rosoarch assignment was there any nor.tion of any furthor intention of carrying out oxrorir«onts on human beings? Could you givo us so-ne general infor¬ mation on this? A I mysolf know nothing more .rocisoly about this rosoarch as¬ signment, but first of all tho subject of tho rosoarch assignment, tho effect of freezing or. war* bio dod subjects, nnkos use hero of a scient¬ ifically perfectly usual oxprossion for experiments on animals. In the list of the ‘?7 rt so arch assignments the Prosecution put in, Docu*oont No. 93J», Exhibit U5', wo find under IX, to research assignments to other men, using almost identical torninolcgy, to wit, experiments on Vara blooded subjects, and also in foreign scientific papers, for instance that by tho Americans Dill and Forbes, you find the same extension in English. If experiments on human b_i:s;s had been intended that would w/u *oo a. oxprjsced in the definition of th. research assi^itont. ~or: - 21 Iny-iB-2-3-Cook (Ir.t* Brora) Court So* I. ever, it says verbatim in this letter and I quote: °Cn t to proposal of Stabsarzt, Dr. Rase her, appropriate oxamina- tiors vara nado on human beings," that meaning that at first at least the as; i_r_jor.t was United entirely to aninal exporinents. i I want to ask you one core question, namely, about tho next to tha last per;graph on the first eeges "Tho research documents and extensive documents will bo prosontid to Roichsfuehrer SS by Dr. Raschor at his request, that tho original and cop-' of the roport of tho docu¬ ments to put at tho disposal of th> inspectorate of tho nodical service of tho Luftwaffe." According to the ft*ocecution assertion this is an experiment which was carried out on tho initiative of the Luftwaffe. How is it that tho Luftwaffe on tivi 8 October 1912, in other words, after ti» conclusion of tho experiments, has to ask for tho first timo from tho iioichsfuahror 5£? A Sinco I know nothing about this directly or personally 3 can only dravr tho doduction regarding a point that was, it sc.ns, quito clear, thr.t tho office which ordor~d thoso oj;x>rirents and tho offico dotc-minad when tho results • oxv to bo naclo public, was the lloich Fu.hrcr Sc .alone. Lot no say also that in tho experiments which tlx> Luftwnffo ro lly carried out by itcalf, for iustarco tho son water o.r- fxirlmontn, it never occurred to any ora x> ask tto Rcichsfuchror Si. cr any ono oloo to porait tho publication of tiv findings. Q ith that, I can low. that document, -r.d I can ash you tho folitxring: You said before that until tho Hurnbcrg fro-.sing confcronco you am no furttier reports on this matter. However, th. witno3f Hoff, who was Raschor’s collaborator in Dachau, said on thj IQ Decotbor, lfl*5, or. io c .c 6 1 of tho English record- that Raschor dictated interim re¬ ports on his fro.ting exporinents in Dachau, which went through as top secret material, and that tho rop-.srts wont to tho aviation office 7 ir. !!unich in tie Prinzregonten Strasse. : rho attended tho conference heard at that tIn othor words, Raaohor nado known no do ails at all. .. “itnoss, then interim re -orto did not roach you. ] a , he*’ about tho final report which too -rosoc-tion has put in ns docuront !JO-h28, I&iibit 91, page 27 of J ocu.oat 'ook III? 1 don't rant to road any- ting to you fron this report. • siupl; ant to know if ou know of it? A. I heard about it tho first ‘:sw hero in tho trial. 1. T ion you didn't 30 c t 5.3 re rt in jour reforat, that's what you ixan? . A. I_s, that is s. let uc ,»oinv out ono thing which is -xr.cctly clear to those who knerr horr Z-: r.r. eo rcspondencc is carried on. In •a c; y of f is report put in fc; -rosecution it can clearly bo scon - at tiiis is copy * 2. It was .evsoribed ir. the caso of top sesroi 7390 21 Hay 3-S- Gross (Tjto) ourt !fo. 1 pattern ttey state homany copies of top s ccrot nattors had boon nado oxxl on each copy or on each pago of each copy, tho nuribor of tlx copy has to bo printed, ~incc this copy is coy no. 2 there is also the copy that Raschor sont to Himlcr, It cist bo a sained that liaechor kept copy no. 1 in Ids cr.m private files and sent copy no. 2 to hia Chief, rho had given the asoignaont, Heinrich Htanlor. It is unlikely that, in addition, ha root off 3ovoral ot’wr copios olsocvuant kcolc II, pago 96. T’.iia rill bo .heidbit 12. xhis is an affidavit by irofoosor 'notho of ^oolar of 8 .arch 19U7. Let no ask you first of all *.hat Job did .rofos3or Ilnotho havo at this tiro? A, -«o ran Caosodcr of t o odical .r.pcrincntal Dopartnoht in Juotoborg. f t , nyl <*iotc thon t. is docviont rhich is very briof. "At tho request of dofonso ocvinol, I • ish to state tho follcruingl I roc all that during the s;axr or fall of 19.’iU dr, -e’eor-froysong telephoned no froa Sealer', t*.ic sanitary o^orinontol and lectv.ro section end irvy.ird Trtioth-r I knar aj-t ing abrut a final rcpqrt by Holzloohncr on his lo~ tonperat -a ex crincnts at lechau, or rhotha* si’oh a report ras to be f und la ny action. "to strtod that ho hin- sclf so thing ef such a no rt. 1 th.rcupen on lain A - to $r. Tec .r—.';«iy3ong on ti • tolcpknrx V. rt I '-nc.-no thing ,V‘ .v?h a report • 7691 21 1:7 -3-3-:ross(: res.?.) : urfc :ro» l o5.t:-. r -sd th it it could iZmroSoro -.at -c at ny section.* 1 TX-re J ; io.:s tiio signature an:. Lite vs al cortIT: cation - ’o , witajss, it s:.*t entirely clear iron this document shy it was refessor . c t t you called up. kso there any closer connections botroon _*!o:..r, Iblsloohner, Hippko or anybody olso and •rofoscor ."not'.'.o? A. -t -03 very n.tural for no to mil .» bocauso Sblss- loohnor's llitary Planning A cncy * as this Sanitary i:: -r so .til one’ locturo section in Juoterbory. . l, cr: • o cono to &occ; ent 2 5 , exhibit C fren Dccuscnt Book III, pago 127 of tho “nglish Jocuumt Book. It his the sans codo l.ttors ns thoso Tihioh tho prosoe -tier, uses ns basis for its c liar goo n .oinst you. V.v, let no ash /o' v et 1 -r or not you liner. thin letter v tch ront to oichsfuohrcr- : froa hip. ko on 19 Fobmnry 19!i3? A. I cannot recall 1 is luttcr and c rtainly didn't dr. t it :$•- solf at that tino bcca>iso this w ■ t ->:»y'n affair. I 1 lot knew it then. But lot no point cut >no t;in- which can bo soon very clearly iron thisluttcr, tv t, on tlo 19 February 19u3, w ithor tho edieel Inspector hi self, iwwly 'i. pkc, nor .Vof, • m' ro in . oosoas or. of this fi al report tdgnod b; Iblzlochner, -oohor and . jdical nape etor thanks that tho freosing o-rxjriner-.tshr.vo b^nmrricd out nad state 3^ explicitly and I Q oto: “Tho result raa reported •. non by th030 vfco worked on ther 'hiring a coiifarcnco on nodical probloco .iris, ny free distress at son and -.inter hrrdshipe on 26 and 27 'ctobor 19’ 2 at ifcrnborg.” 1 an convinced that if t written rop-rt wore also v.-:.lri3o then tho fact fiat a report res to be nado at the confsronoc- -- ; d not have boon rationed but than.’3 raid havo boon given for .ritton report, h. we corn to the i vm'aor'. -onT - ich has boon ropoatedly oontiottid by tho r* rosocution her . .rofesser HoLsloohnar o/c!co it nee - or ganl yod by tha borate! I 21 lay 1;7~-c".'-3-U-Gross (Brcrm) Court Ho. 1 conforonco of this kind or x'cro there c-ovoral such? A. "h:rc were 12 such conforonccs tlircughout tho courso of tho ' .'nr frcii 19ll to 19Ua« . Tils conforonco, witness, cor-comcd itself rith tho freezing -problcn in contradistinction with the consulting confcronco of tho VTohmscht uhioh troatod nuacroua subjects at 1fcc sane confcronco. Tfas it cnatonary for such Luftraffo conferences to discuss only ono oroblon. ithcrrrisc tho injrcssion could bo that tho only reason this confcronco ras oall-d ttss to he r iolslochiK-r's report. A. Tho confor nco as called by tho c*'ical Cnspcotorato for scientific discussion rrtoro in contradistinction to tho oo:u»ulting O'.nforencos of tho ohroncht consult .d only one th:nc at a tine and this thono tms illuninntod in all its facotoon one or taro days of tho conforonco. I night nar.o ono or ts.*o other thorns that occupied tho other 12 conforoncos. TI» jost io»p rtant -as tho one a year previous to th.it in tho sun -or of 19li2 in .’aria which concomcd itsolf ;rith soa distrc3sproblons in xhich I did r.ot participate bocauso 3 didn't bolor.g to tho -cdical Inspectorate at that tino. And in tho ouxrrr of 19h2 a oocord nodical confor;r.co retarding night sight and space 3isht, ard then ir. 19ii3 a conforcnco regrding nodical air raid protection ccnsuras, and in lr'Lh a confer-nco on tho uoo of tho st-called efficiency inoroa3in'; drugs ouch ns caffoino, bonsedrino, ophedrino, and so on. 7-93 Hoy 21 -l.'-BX-i- 1-Xor r ow (Int. 3rcT/n) Court No. 1 *1 That'3 enough, witness. -» laoo of tor ..nthony left ana, in that case, since I had hi3 Job, I was in oh nr go of thor.. i Now, witness, frea that it onn bo seen that tho grope¬ r' tions for the Numberc conforor.oo was done by Profo3sor -nthony? - Yes, that is so end, of cour3o, tho non in ch-rgo of n conferonco has to know whr.t tho .ajonda is join;; to bo. . Now, witness, you wero assistant referent r.t th-t tino undor -nthony. ./hot did you have t> *lo with this conference. - -11 the oonforenoes that took . lr.ce undor ^.nthony^s rof^rat I h . ’. to orjanizo. That i3 quito n Job boceuso thoro aro ’iscussiona by eighty or ninoty scientists who r.ro •;cin; tc ror/ .apers in two days. . That is to say you had nothin; to do with tho scientific .■re. orations of it, but Just tho organizational and. tochnio- nl sldo of it. Now, did you know wh t Holzloohn-r was goins to roport on? Noi I didn't. ; *3ut di I you know Professor iiclzloehnor before that? .. Yes, I did. f i -'here 'id you know hi:, and what did you know about hiu? - I c-ado .intl’.onyts acquaintance in the course of further trainin’ for Luftwaffe physicians in£ fliers that took place in Juctorbor:. Lurin'; this trr.inin • course Professor Holz- lov-ancr delivered a lecture on sea distress ,roblor:s and liny 2l-iI-3K*-i-2-Kcrrow (Int. Efrown) Court No. 1 rrosontod a novlo rep.rdin; his foan suit that ho had : already dovolo;xjd. - Witness, if I understand you corroctly, this was a lecture in March, 19-i2, at which Holzlochnor spoke regard- in; his practical son distress experiences and about a new foan suit; nnaoly, c the ore tie a 1 problon which had to bo solved practically? .. Yos. «i Dr. -*u ;u3tinock, on the 26th of Fobruary 19.7, pa ;c 3736 of tho English rooerd, said that Holzlochnor was, for a Ion: poriod, tho dirootor of a rosouo station on tho Frenoh Coast. How loa; did Iiolzloohner's roport in Nurnborj take? .. Not oxoo. tionr.lly loh;. I should say thirty or forty ninutos. . Did ho 8how any pioturcs or filns? No. . 3o far as ho spoke about ox.orinonts, did ho say any¬ thin*; about tho oxporinonts oarriod out on concentration coop inr.'tcsv - H-, he didn't. c .ndennod criminals woro nanod. . M ;w, another question about this affidavit. "..s a result of Holzloehn-r's report and others ;ivon at tho conference, issued instructions to the flight surgeons that tho wor.e bath uothol was to bo usod in re¬ viving aviators who hod boon sovoroly chilled." First of all, what do you noon by "wo"? You said that you couldn't issue any instructions t . 11 . .. It is possible that in the interrogation that ;receded this affidavit I used the word "we" and said that "we had Ion- so and issued such and such instructions." That , of course, noons tho office to which I fcelon;»d and, in norool 7396 Hey 21-LI-oK—i—i-Korrw (lit. Brown) C urt :io. 1 conversation , it is . perfectly o croon wny of oxjrossin; ono3olf. -i’ you yoursoif hove anything to do with the issuing of t;.i3 directive to the troop physicians? .* X hr.f. nothin : to do with that. This directive was a result of the Harnborg conference and, from tho purely formal . oint of viow, it was not tho roforat for aviation medicine that had anythin: to do with this, but tho roforat 2-1-3 with its file auabor of 9. It w \a this refornt that had ell tho dealing with the troop physicians. That was tho roforat for hy ;iono. i iio have attempted, Y.>ur H nors, to jot our hands on this dirootivo. It was, for toohnionl rousons, impossible unfortunately. This is tho dircotivo of tho 3rd of .-ujust, 1912 - "Directions to Troo. Physicians for Preventing Danar.o to Persons throu h Cold.” I have inclurtod this in ay doounont book primarily to show that it boars tho fila number «i9, only to show that it ha3 nothin:; to do with tho roforat for aviation medicine. This is on par.o 97 of Doounont eook 2. It -will be Exhibit 13 and it is Pocunont 26. TiiJ P.gXjIBEMT: Counsel your last exhibit you offored was your -'•jcur. ;nt 25. TIPP: Your Honor, this is ‘'ocunont 26, Exhibit 13. It i3 noticed in this document that it bears tho number 2-1-3 _nstoad of 2-II-B. BY ilv. TIPP: , I return now to your affidavit, witnoss. Yeu say hero that it was "fairly well known that those non wore ex.orinont- in; on concentration cm:, inmates." Did you have any ^ositivo knowlod ;e \s to vjho these subj-cts wore and how they wore chosen? 7697 SI y 2 l-.I-3K-*i~5-K-a-row (Inti 3rown) C jurt No. 1 No, I had nothin ; to '.o with that selection end never had .ny . ositiv^ knowlod ;c of it. v witness, after the Nurn'jcrj conferonca did you have anythin • to do with tho results of tho iiolzloohnor-.v schor- ?inlcc ex. orinants? Did you soe reports on it nftor Num¬ ber ;? -• No, nor nro any reports known that wero to have boon sont out after the Number-; conference. : I cone to tho crux of the Numbers conference, so far as tho ;>rosooution is concerned, at least; nanoly, Holz- loohner’ . lacturo. ^ucuucnt N . *10, Exhibit 93, ^ocunont Hook 3, ;>ace 96, says the following: 'Hoizloohner ;avo this r^.ort on his ex.iorinents which woro, of oourso, ox t >orir;jnt3 carried out in i/aohau#" This is on m ic.:o 319 of the D, ;lish record of the 12th of y*> Daconber, 19-io. This fornul tion of tho natter the ;)rosocu- tion soons to have trJccn frcn its own oxhibit booauso, under »/5 in your affidavit, you said: "..t tho Nurnborj oonferor.co hold in Octo’oor, 19-12, Dr. Hnlzlochnor : -r.ve a reboot on tho f.roozinj cx. orinento con¬ ducted in Dachau in cooporation with D. . .i .schor." However, 4 rovioualy, witr.oss, you said that Hoizloohner had 3;.oken about his .notical cx;>cricnco3 in soa distress work. Now, Just what did Hoizloohner actually report on? Those two statenonts do not correspond to oaoh other. 7393 21 1fey 47-^“n>-5-l-Sfeloy (In*-. 3fora) Court :ic. 1 A Holzlcchncr's report was a fixture of practical st_a distress experiences, results of animal experiments and results of experiments or. human beings. 4 Then if I understand you correctly, a combination? n k combination. Q And again I would like to quote tc you something that the Prosecution said on the 12th of December 1946, page 310 of the English record. Lot me quote. Ur. UcHancy said the following — I should like to make the remark horo before I continue although it has net boon said so far definitely, that these experiments were not carried out on persons roscued from sea. The i&tncss Lutz told us, however, thet it wa3 mado perfectly clear that thoso wero experiments that wero carried out on human beings here whore humans were in a planned manner sub¬ merged in ice water. This is clear from the following part of the report because it would have been impossible for any scientist to rarkc these detailed clinical observations on the ease of individuals exposed"-. Witness, ns you said you arc not a specialist in thu fiold of freezing, but you" have mado general medical knowledge, ther-fcrc 1 can ask you is this decision on thu port of the Prosecution corroct as hero stated by ICr. UcHancy? A No, a great ddnl con bo said in answer to that. First, let mu tell you Tibet Lutz actually said. This was in testimony given on tho 12th of Doc nber 1946, page 242, — page >42, I guess, of the English record. In answer to the Prosecution's question I should like to ask you whether or net if one didn't understand at that conference thet the experiments had b-.cn carried cut on inmates in the concontrrticn camp. Lutz manured "I cannot Judge th t for sure, but I believe so. I bulidvo that most of then must have seen that clearly." This shftws quite . clearly tb:t this point was not made clear, but that it was loft up to every individual's imagination. Lutz.himself had worked in animal experi¬ ments on the freezing problem, and worked in the Institute in »diich the .4 sciefttj fic ^an lcal experiments on these questions w-r-_ carried w., and if he seea something more clearly than others that is, of course, -uito 7099 21 Hay i.7-:--TD-5-2-.^lcy (Ir.t. Broun) Court .Jo. 1 understandable. 1 had not worked p rsonclly on freezing problems, nor had 1 had anything directly to do with icascher, and in addition lot me point out that Holzlochnc-r certainly gave no report on the course of a freezing exp riaenb where, for example, on the sane man the various stages c- freezing ere carried out and observed on the sane man. In medicine it is quite customary, it is true of so-called typical case histories, end you think in terms of them. You speak of the normal and usual course that a disease takes free its beginning to its end, and it is perfectly clear that such a case history is coafcined from obser¬ vation on very many individual patients, and also contains the result of experimental observation. Let me alsc point out that between a report which is a top secret report, and e publication made without any secrecy i.hctsoevor, thuro is a very evident difference to anyone. The report that Holzloehnor, hoschcr and Finke signed on their work there and which Rcacher sent to Hiatal er was r top secret natter. The report in the eonfurcnco of sea distress or winter distress in Numborg which the Uediccl Inspector of the Luftwaffe end Holzlcehncr's lccturo stood under no secrecy. If the competent person Lh-n is what actually stood bohind Holsloehnur report, and that the experiments and the conclusions from thus were to be treated as top secret, then it is perfectly clear that this report would not havo been acdo in a perfectly open publication. '4 -itncsn, regarding Holzloehr.cr's lecture, the Frosocution aosertea in its cr.oc that the Holzlcthr.er report contained a number of passages frera which it could bo clearly and uncruivecally seen that thero were fatalities in the experiments in Dachau. In other words, this repert 3hew3 clearly to you at least who knew the facts of the experiments as such, that in the course of the experiments ct Dachau crinea were ec .'pitted. Xc this essortion by the Prosecution correct, as far os you know, 'witness? A From Holzloehner's lecture Certainly no one even knew that experiments hod been carried out woo'd deduce that there had been fatali¬ ties is: -h course c? the experiments. Perhaps what hr.scher said in connection with Kolzlochner*s report ) t^r could give seme on -ideas, but ?9CO £1 :iav 17-:TD-5->Halo“ (lot. BrCi-r.) Court :,*o. 1 that would not be seen free Holzloehncr* s lecture. Seen from the psychological point of vieK today, as I knea ail the oth^r natters, it is v-.-y easy to see in this Holzlochnor report everything I have found cut in th_ ,-.cantinc, but at.thet tine kc didn't know these things. QR. *ITF: Hr. President, I should liko to discuss a few of those passages which the prosecutor feels to be particularly incriodn.ting, with th-- witness. This will take, I believe, roughly half cn hour, and I do not knov whuther the court wishes ac to begin on tliis befero the recess, or if it would be better if we waited until aft.r the recess to take up this natter, which nust tc understood in its entirety. !£.. HaHDY: Hr. Prosidont, Tour Honor, it scots tc no the dofenso counsel has labored under this point a long tiao. He has been hero nearly an hour discussing thu rhirab.rg conference. It seuas to Be hu has covered it nnply. I don't see any reason for going into it very extensively. There are four or five ether chsrgos again:" dofondant. He will bo in the witness box four or five acre days nt this reto, THS F.LSlDHiT: The Tribunal, of course, is net aware of the i,ucotirs. counsel desires to ask the witness concerning this report, but counsel will bu permitted tc pursue the ssrtt-.r at lcr.3t until the Tribunal feds he is pursuing, it too far. In the moanvhilo the Tribunal will bo in rccoss, (Thereupon a recess was taken.) 7?0i 21 Aa? 47-.4!1-Gro a s- (Ramie r ) Court I THE : ARSHAL: Tho Tribunal 13 again in session. TH£ PRESIDE:.'?: Counsel may proceed. 5Y DR. TIP?: . Z. Dr. Becker, I was Just told by the interpreter that the word "Xrankenheitsbild" which you u6od was not clearly translated. It was translated as "case history". Case history, on the other hand as I heard is the history of one individual case froa the beginning of the disease until its end,.whereas "Kranhenheitsbild" meant something else, ,/ould you please clxrify for the benefit of the interpreter what “Krankenheitsbild" is Intended to mean? A. I agree with you that in the German usage of lan¬ guage one understands case history very specifically to bo the course of the illness in tho in the case of one indi¬ vidual patient. Under "Krankonholtablld" on the other hand one .understands the typical course of any one illness. For instance, if an university looturor is disousslng an ill¬ ness, and lr. particular is referring to influenza, he galno his pictures by his experience on hundreds and hundreds of patients and on the basis of all this experience he then arrivos at tho typical picture of that disease, whioh of course deviates in the case of one or the other patient but on the other hand there is a typical picture of that illness. This for the medical man Is quite a matter of course and it is very clear to him that any typical obser¬ vation cannot hold true of any one individual patient but represents a combination of all the oases he has experienced. Q. I think that can clarify that point, witness. You wore last saying that according to your knowledge at that time from Kolzloahnor's lecture nothing could be learned about any crimes having been committed. Y 0U didn't hear anything -.bout fatal cases either, did :ou? 7902 21 Kay 47-jf-£<-6-2-(>ro8B—(Ktnler) Court I a. i/o, Rolzloehr.er aad> no mention of any fatal cases. -• - ow . witness, let us refer to some of the passages ir. lolzloehnor's lecture which are possibly held to be in¬ criminating by the Prosecution. Lot ne quote from prosecut¬ ion Document 4C1, Exhibit S'*, on page 86 of the German, jnge 79 of the English record. This. Is the report about tea res¬ cue. I.. that connection I would like to llscusa the report of Dr. Holzloehr.er with you. At first, witness, let us turn to one particular passage, you will find this passage on page 4"* of the original report which la on page 69 In the English Document Hook. I quote:"The rapidity with which numbness occurs lo roinarxnblo. it was determined that al¬ ready 5 to 10 minutes after falling in, an advancing rigor of the skeletal muscles sets In, which renders the movements of the arms e 8, eel ally increasingly difficult. 0 /hen examining Professor Schroedor the prosecution pointed out t.iut this determination of rlsor after five to 10 minutes could not have been made In practical cases of sea rescue but that leads one to oelievo that experiments wore carried out. \*nnt can you say about that, witness? a. Thle conclusion 16 In no way correct. I am not an expert on the freezing natter and I never served In Sea Rescue Service of the German Luftwaffe where I gained personal experience> but I am In a position to give you a reply to this question on the basis of a report mado by the Anorioan Sea Rescue Service. Thl6 report expressly refers to praotical experiences as they wore galnod In that - service. It car. be found in a work by :er vc?. Ito EultJpliCdtion of t. o erythrocytes corrosnonds to ua incrc_sc in hcuoglobin o: freu 10 fco 20,:, . otico-«lc oad icnortant is a rent incroase in viscosity of \\) tc 7.0." I jn not - pnysicl-n, -s «r. £~rdy s-s, and I en Just an ordinary siailo 4*a and : c-a luogine nothing ay re-dln t. is fomul-tion. I vc.it to .iox you, -ro tcoso dotcruin-tioas w.ich c_a only be uio in t-o c Vic of oa uxveriaeat? -re teese dotoruin-tions vj.ich aro ando in tho c.no of _ livin.. >orson or in tae cjo of - dead person? O. -huso, nutur.11 . aro exoai..utiono v ich only h-vo cny senso if ai.liod to living hucan oeiigs and c-n only oo c-rrlod o*.t in that * v.v”. 7. itnens, norhons you vlll first toll * *i-t thono oiaiuidutloa concern? ' o ire nuroly concornod vith tno co-uiting of tho rod . .id uiiito blood conusclus. f.-.ls is -a ex^iaatioa v icn ro-lly does not ruuiro C physician but can bo Carried out by over tech.iic-l assist nt or iicdlc.l nco. In th„t connection, I o^- -.-in refer you to tho work by Co’t.da r.asor vhero he s^'s: “.‘no «b^. of strii differs ia every individual c-so ccordi.v, to tho circuit nces. Ac connidor-tion of tno olood coacontr tion vc you a icturc to th .t offset, nut n determination of y..o e elood Concentr-tioa c„n also eo -acortained r' t.ic cooper c .to no*..,cd." I v.-at tc point oxt tr-t in is remark ay Obtain haaor refers clc. r- ly to r ctic-I sea rescue oxu*.rieac>. - I v -14 -'- n ~- c th . 1 , 7907 21 .-v~?-9-2-- -rro w (Int. Healer; Court I t -s-a rose :c »..* 7 lcc, taese setaodn ur. applied i- m )C..rs c.cdiola that the even simpler aotnod of the counting of blood cellar, cl os is used in the S«roaa «e_ rescue service in tao Channel. v:cli -'taod c.jx even be applied ia a rescue bout oec-use all tfco bo_tr *-e covered. low, she next oa-icugu, witness, voich c-r. be found on 91 of tne Higlish Socunuat jook. This is tao 1 -st pur-sr^h on th..t pu&o: "iho conditions of the he_rt _llov -a opinion to be foraod on tho problcu of course after roscuo." Collapse _ftcr rescue n.^as tao death after rescuo, isn't th. t ri%ht? Can tais detomlnatioa ou u_ac only in the c-oo of .h c">oriuont, vitnoos? io, This collapse after rescuo was tho very thin; union.all physicians who do-lc witn tc-t nroblau found to bo a purzlo and t is vno S o prooloLi w..icn worried every physician. It nlwayo puzzlod J»iu tn..t ..ftor these patients wore already rose ;od they would ou dcnly dio a few hours j'tcrvurds, wfter tee. ver« ..l..udy safely in .. boat or in t:ie hospit.Jk. I uuy point out th-t '’rofessor tolxlochnor initially in n n report is spooking eo-.ut c-so c-tastrop-ios occurring in tho .V.v;* vuort such l..to or rescue collapses with - f .t-1 ond occur _t,..in cat. a in. Jfcis unfortunately w-o the >r.vr 1 experience ovoryuhoro, not only ia -ernaay. .vferring to thu BPoci.J. questions of tie con¬ dition of tiie ho.a-t and the uudical interest in tho conditio., of tho nc..rt, I Cay _g..in refer to tno vorX jy Capt.An ..after who also is vriti a; lit tho SoOe fidlnga of tao fae^rt oof so;’B, uad I quoto: "Ale ojsorv tioa in these tvo Cases is particularly in o.csting bcc..U8 it is proven that the re-th i.. the v..tur is orougnt aeout by 4 circul tory disturcancos. It frequently occurs during tnc process of VeCCUC." Horc a,-la we n-ve tuu coll-pso after acscuo. .ow, vitaoss. another quotation i th t connoetio. v-sicu is to (I r.t, gaoler) 21 K^i Court I oc f.nind on page 92 of the o/iglish Docustat _ioefc and on p«>.,c —a of - -o em-oi original. Holzlothaer is speJcing, and I shall r.ot quoto -L- vcrowtta, about the good experiences node in tne cose of c n lacl c w i.c.. -3 with quich ro-waraing and he is saying that water tcmo- r .tv.re of -iO degrees not only accelerate tao return to aoru.l ttupo- iv.et'ro and -osoroed the sudden dangorous falls of tdiperaturo cS tor rescue, out tuy -Iso be of 1 if o-Saving effect should tne heartbeats be 0 ia to stop. fa..t very clearly v„s an exocriuontal Ogpurlcnce oy Dr. folzloehaer. 'Wouldn't you Cave to conclude that so>.c cricos wore cctmlttcd in that connection? ju l‘h-t is, in f.-ct tho only p^ss-go which clearly points to cn o;*o»vi-.oat, at lo..st, to - tnorqqjoutlcal o^Jjriuent. Axt not only I, but cortainly ull tho otners wao /aiev considerably core about tho freezing iroblcs than.I, found this to be extremely coining end eutic- fectoty ta-t Holzlochr.er states oxorcnoly that ho never s«v jay such dai Vi or for thooo wno uxr'orwont th_t troatnont. Froc that it boenuo elc..rly cripareat to all listcn«ro that no incidents and no death cr.sos occur w during talc experiment -vd this, fo: all of us, uc r.t tho solution of chc Holzlochnur loctu c. at any rate, this, in opinion, Vos tno only question of any pr..ctic.l iuportnnco. <. i.r. President, in this connection I aay offer two hoc:or- 3rroyoon& documents. fho Docuuont *27, which I shall givo Inhibit yl4, _«'■ ciio Doc'juent ?28 wnich will receive aXf.i'oit vl5. I “<-1* &.• , Pres if out, th-.t in tnc case of that ovrfc wo aro cot concornod v-ith o:o>eri..onts conducted on huxan acings abroad a-out which .ccordi.v. to ...o deoision will only bo labor, out «:>orlencce of :no ..uorionn .:t tno -ribunal, So_ Hescao oervicc. fheso documents ..r. in Joc-coi^- ~ U DOC’—ent aook -2. U-.o 55 and p_gt. 103. I ..11 r.-bc quote fro: thesv documents. i T :X_ S_3 -1 a: Page 89 or p^ge 98? 7?:-9 21 i..; Co-art ;rrow (la;. .-_^lcr) - 3a. 21??: 3 . 98 and 1C3. Jr. a brings to an one tho lecture by nolslochaur, vituoss. One, .d u nueatioa. ,»s we *-ov, th6 first spooler -ftor Jolzlochnor was '.iVm — schor. fatso *.scccr reCarfca woro repeatedly tho sujjoct of discussions in tn;s court rocs. bo toll iio, vitnoss, wh..t v..s Uio vory sens tioc^l tning vaich Dr. a.schOr nontloned during tout uaoting? a. —»c uer s_id tn,t in th-t connection expurinento wore c.rriod out by ordor -ad resuoatioility of tno .oicacfucfcror S3 noi.irich . - in n lor on sentenced cri-in-ls vao had volunteorod for that mryoso after aviag Ooon orcaised th„t t~.ru woulc oe - uitigation oi tholr contonco or aot.o other -loviation of tnoir f-to. A is is ell he said. 21 Hay A7-!'-. .TD-10-l-i£aloy (Int. Healer) Court N'o. 1 Q f&tnessj cid it beceme evident from these reaarks made by Pasohur that primarily death cases had occurred during those ecperdencos, s r o.-ri.r specifically or quite generally that ih the execution of theso experiments any criaos were ccecitted? r. ,c, neither one cr the other became apparent. I acy point out again that Rasch«-r himself had obtained the approval by Rcichaiuchrer SS Hianlor to treat this matter as top secret. Q Recently, in a different case you said once, when speaking about a lov/ pressure chamber, that you didn't consider theso renarks by Itaschor cs very nice or pleasant; tvll,us again witness, what was the reason for your rejecting theso marks aado by Raschcr? A Subsequent to these statuaents of Raschcr I raontioned a few words about oxp-rinents with a local cooling of the nock area; theso in themselves w«.ro absolutely harmless experiments because ho had stated before that any local ccoling of the neck end the oroa behind the hoed would not load to ary dropping of temperature or at least not any essential dropping of temperature. 1 think that what wo learned froa this report it only concerns dropping of one to two degrees, which ere not very dengorous. Therefor--, it urs not really whet Rancher had said that 1 didn't like, but the gvnorcl Banner in which ho was saying it. Cf ccurse, today after almost five years have olopsed, I cannot repeat his words v.rbati*, and it is very difficult to describe such an indefinite impression. I con cnly say that the manner in which he was speaking, perhaps the iianner in which he was speaking about his experi¬ mental subjects made a very unpleasant impression on us both. Nobody thought rod nobody could have thought the t anything criminal had teen committed. ; You w.r>- saying before, witness, that thv basic rosultfrca all this Kolzlo diner was that quick rewarding was to be cnccuragcd and that quick row?rntng had h?d the very best results. Wasn't y™r solution soucthing sc basically new and so revolutionary that on- cculd only really believe that stated .nt until details w-r>- also given? 7911 a J&y 47-J^TD-10-2-!iaLoy (Inti Rrmier) Court Jfo. i A Holslochnor's result hr 3 , c: course, extraordinarily inport ant. ■ o'.■ - t can exist about that; but it was n-ither completely new nor w's it : ’.attionel First, during the very same nesting Professor *»dtz alr-pij had reported the very sene result on the basis of his animal expo rim nts. Furthermore, the problem of cuick rowaraing had beer, mentioned an.' dealt with ever since the first sea rescue coniercnco in Perir in the year 1941. Secondly, in tho periodical, the G-racr. tLlitcry Phyaiaian, dready in tho ouccer of 1945 there appeared a study by a certain ienhold, who was also ruconr,ending the subjeot, the quick rewarding procedure. This vork wps ouoted by Prcfosscr Jerisch during the Kumbcrg Cold Hooting, and it was discussod by hia in dotril. Already before the lecture by Holzloehnor, the quick rewarding procedure h?d boon threo times the ogress subject of lectures, pnd after Holzloeimor four lecturers w_re also reporting on that very prcbl.m. I should like to point out rpccifinally thrt curing thL l.’urnberg meeting f. few experiences hed boon gained during ratucl sen rescues where results wore obttir.od through quick rewarding. Q Itr.css, for purposes of clarification, cno norc- question; you »uro saying that the result was neither sensational nor basically now; or. the other hand you woro 3'iyin: that these oxpcri.mur.tn woro important. The inprossion aay ariso as if thu importance cf tho experi¬ ments would r.cvu been decreased sinco theso things ha.d merely been tho subject of discussion. ..hy w.rc human expo: iments at all nocoarnry? A I sco t..c significance of these experiments in thu following: I thin* th-t in tho course o: pr.actico cnc would have anyway have arrived at the sirdlar n-suita, but ir. th practice of sc* rescue it will always be U . c“sc that the ship wrecked, — cnc we arG here concerned with shin wrecked during the l>.r, — will rise have injuries, damages tc their health, so that a result will nevur be as clear as in the experiment. Tt;is experiment, or the oq _riuvr.ts 'ey Holzlouhner have cl earl: given un r.hir- result quickly and thus obviously centre ry tc >x. -ri-cr.cc r.-inod during rrr.cuicDl experiences. 21 May i.7-:K.H!-lC-3^sloy (Int. BeoLcr) Court Mo. 1 >3. ilt-F: In connection with that question I may offer Bcckor- : ng Document -9. This car. be found in document book Mo. 2, on rn- 107. This document was already submitted by the Prosecution. It i3 the report cf the sea and winter rescue matter. However, the full dccua-nt was not submitted by the Prosecution. I am just being told that this document can be found on page 108 . I have sufcoitted this document in order to confine what the witnoss had mentioned about that aeoting. I shall not quote rnythir.g from this docuncnt, cut I shall only give you for the purpose cf simplicity a fow page numbers. The lecture by Jerisch can be found on pago 108 a; tho lecture by professor Welts where he reported on his cniarl experi¬ ments can be feund on page 113. On page 118 you see reports about experiments in practice by Zschukkc and Doerflcr; on page 121 else it speaks about idacnta in practice. I shell shortly like to touch on this pnrscgc. Dcerflor say a here. Base 3: "On 25 April 1942 two Englishmen were rescue who had allegedly boor, drifting for 6 hours. n) Symons: "(which is obviously the name of the person rescued) "ooverc cxhcusticr., slightly benumbed. Abdomen hard ns a bo. rd, sonsitivo to pressure (bladder filled). Temperature: armpit 35 dcgre03, rectal 34.5." b) Dixon: The seme as r), but tho temporaturo was 37.3. i^iick recovery. Caso 4: k German technical sergeant whe came down and landed on the sea on 17 May. Temperaturo: rectal 34 degn.es, armpit 33.5." Q 'Witness, new ono concluding question: as ycu were saying, thoro was n scientific r.-eting concerning sea and winter emergencies. As you said, ye u n-.rc not ar. expert in this field, you were making experiments in th field cf practical sec rescue, end sc shall assume ycu had worked in tliis fi-ld experimentally; I aay, cssuae, henevor, that th. leading experts c. the Luftwaffe and leading experts cf ctrur br.-inches cf the Wchrmacht were present during that meeting; what these people concluded 21 Jcj itf-fc^TO-IQ^-iialoy (int. Raaier) Court !io. 1 •roa the seating and fres th_ lectures you cannot tell us, witness, but I would like to know one thing free you: did any cne of the ..i cipents in this meeting protest publically against Holzloehnor»s lec.vr. either before, during or after the lecture? I-’ y 21-W-3K*ll-l-iI chan (I t. .i rr.lv rj C-urt No* 1 ~ No, I ri.y sr.y in that connection at that tine I would not at all have understood any such .roto3t had it, been . ade. ..eocxdin; to the “'ocunent, which is availablo horo, Co v.a.„rs of tho Luftwaffe wore .rosont durin; that r;ect- inj, lb ro; r-sent.ativos of tho ~r:;y, re-resentatives of the 1-Javy, i of tho • .ffen SS nfi Police, and 19 civilians, i.c. university .rofessors and othor sontlooon. . I. I . y .:u—rizo briefly, witness, you arc sayin.: that you would hnvo considorod any .rotost as bo in’, sense¬ less baoauso you nadc no observations whatsoever that oven could hnvo hintort at orincs. Mono of tho loadin; ox;x)rts of ‘Jernony, who no doubt woro .rosont, nado any such observations booausc no one in cffoct .rotestod, is that true? .. Yes, that is quite corroot. . I will leave that uootin" and I will ;o to another doouflont, which was subnittod 'ey tho .rosooution. Ono 1 rolininnry question: would you .'lease toll tho Tribunal who *rofe3;ior Juochner was as ho was r^ntioned aa a lecturer durin tho Nurnbor ; uootin ;? •• Professor Buoohnor was and still is today tho ordinariat for .atholo 7 and the dircotor of tho Pathological Instituto of tho University at Freiburj. Jurin . tho war ho was con¬ sult in.. .atholo'ist with thj Hodionl Inswootorato of the Luftwaffe and head of the Institute for -viation Pathology *.t i'riibur;;. He is now tho Pro-.tector of tho University of Freibur;. i ./oultl you .loaso tell U3, witness, what xb*ofcssor suochnor had disc us sod in Number ;? - -rof-S3or Juochner reported /.cut the atholo 7 in rofcronc. to coolin on the basis of the liter ture and on tlw • ;sis of auto, sy find in s. 7915 May 21-K-BK-ll*2-^Qhaa (Inti Menaier) Court :1c. 1 - 0- what cor. 3cs .1:1 ^'ofcssor *>uochner jain his o> -ri.nce of which you wore s^cckin;? - - Uv. experiences wore joined by auto, sics of cor.-s^s of soldiers of the Luftwqffo and th- N^vy, who had died as a result of 3ea distress. . In what way did Professor ouechn-r obtain that cat^rial? .. I ..lrondy said thattt3uoohnor was a consultinj jathol- o ;ist and all the autopsy oortifiontos of tho Luftwaffe woro sont to hin. i I>i that case, if I understand you correctly, Professor Bucchncr was tho nonbor of tho Luftwaffo who hod .joined tho isost exj'orienco about death eases in connection with 9 3oa distress. ..t any rate ns far as it concerned his s.ocinl field of .watholojy? .. Y.s you arc rijht, with that notification. . Mew, the - r'seouticn in its subni33ion of ovidcnco h.as jrosontud •. ilocuiiont, which I should like to discuss with you in that connection: bocunont Mo. 922. This was sub- nittod as Exhibit Mo. «J5, it is .n cxoorjt frea a report of tho nootin ; of tho consultinj .hysici.ms in the year of 19i2. T^ll no, witness, woro you ..resent durin; that nootinj? •* No. . ^id you hear about tlio lectures ,:ivon durin; that r:cot- inj before this Trial? .. ./a 11 , I know that thoro was to be . nootin:, but I hoard nothin* :x>ro about it. . ..ccor:'i:i to tho docun.nts subnitted by tho Prosecution, Professor nolzloohnor o:i that dry .Iso hoi', a lecture. This is obviously sunnary of his lecture which he hold .t Murnbor •. ~s it can o soon fror. tho tocimeat, Mr. Juochnor also s. okc durin; that ncetin and the . rosccution quoted 7916 Mcy 21-i!-BK«ll-3*4!o«han (Int. linn:-lor) Court No. 1 that discussion anil lecture r.s follows: "Buochn^r: .ic 1 - v- studied the norjholojy of the adjustnont to cold nd eh .thole ;y of tenoral severe chillin; in 20 eases of dv tli c used solely by severe chillin ; ini in nuncrous ex. :ri:.-nts carried out on aninal3, and hevo deturnined tho f ollowin •:" It was not explained just what was ioduoed fron the docun-nt. ..t any rate, wo nro horo concerned with the ;uto. sio3 in eases of death, casos which woro concerned with the Holzlochncr lecture. For the purpose of clarifica¬ tion, witness, can you onoo uorc toll us on what tho oxanina- tions by Bucchner wero basod? *» In r.y opinion this statenont is clonrly based u, on tho knowledge which ho joined after working on those autopsies and records; at my rate, I know of nothing else. If it ,lor.3C3 the Tribunal in this connection, I now offer tho 3ook'.r-Froyson ; document No. 30-.. and 1 '.tor tho 3ceker-Fre 30 n; docunent 30-3. This will bo Exhibit 17-,. and 17-D. 3oth of thoso docunont 3 can bo found in Bocurant 3ook 2 . Tho first on pa;o 12 -i and tho socond on pajo 127. I nay confirr. the testimony by tho witness by quotin .3 fra.i B :cur.^nt 30-.. on P: o 12 -i of tho ^ooununt Book. Frori 30-.. . :o 121 , Br. Buyehnor r.t first describes his position as .,rof~ssar of . atnolo ;y and director of the Patholo.jioal Institute of the University and his political attitudo; I quoto: " 1 ) .m institut- for r./ir.tion nodical . atholo y undor i-V direction was attached to ny university institute in Pr-ibur • durin the wx. This institute received, anon;; oth-r thin ;s, .all autopsy r^.orts cf tho Luftwaffe patholog¬ ists v/brkin • in tho various hono districts and occupiod territorios." I shall ski; the next few sentences and I shall continue May 2l-M-BE-ll-4*^oohnn (Int. *tccnlor) Court No. 1 to quote fret; the sane . second paragraph: -iu- in ere as in; losses of the Luftwaffe fra: fatal und-rcoolin; of aviators after boinp shot dawn into tho nn l or the ..tlcntic nnkc it necessary to work systonatic- "Uly on c 3us of death, due to undercoolin;. ..t ay instiga¬ tion n: y order of the Medical In3.ectomto of tho Luft¬ waffe, -’utc^sics on aviators and marines who had died i throu h undercoolin ; while in distress at sea, were : systematically performed by sorio Luftwaffo pathologists..." Thu next sentence deals with tho trontin; physicians. Then lr.tor: "The evaluation of the rocords and .articularly tho microscopic examination of tho organs of those bodies wore carried out at ay Froibur ; institute...." and a few nanus re -lain muntionod, n-moly tho physicians who woro conduotin these examinations. There is also mention nado of the work which was attached to theso examinations. It is Exhibit 30-B. Mr. euochner continuos: "3) For each of the 28 cos os investigated in ny*oponinc re.ort at th Luftwaffo mootin I spoke in dotail about thu3o tw nty casus an' the thorough experimental tests on animals. The report 'The r-.tholoyy of Undercoolin ' was publishein tho Cii n i 0ril (oin . orticularly not in the unit re.: el in : ex. ericonts on hu-ions which we-ru carried out ’oy - r f.ssor liolzlochncr an:: i>r. liaschor." Thor - fellows tho si'uinturc and tho cortificato of a Notary. I shall not quote the enclosures,but I should liko to ask tho Tribunal to take notice of then. Now, the Inst question on cole’. »«itnoss, you know thut tho i-rosecution assorts that those ex, oriuonts were entirely sensoloss, wore unskillful, and did not ;.roduco anythin; now for ujuic.il science; could you , loose dofino your attitude toward that with a few words? 7919 Court So. 1 21 Key 47-*-12-l-i£H-Coofc (Hauler) A, upon the heels of ay knowledge of Eolzloehncr's ocrsonality tcy : first eey that it is ay fira conviction that the cxreriaents v;.ic:. v^rc carried out by Kolzloehner vert- absolutely necessary, had eenct, and were admissible experiments. ! vas confiraed in this con¬ viction of nine by vhrt *he prosecution witness Keff seid here in thin courtroom, --oicing a very clear distinction fcctvccn the cold eroeriaonts in the period of Kolzloehner, rinkc, end Poacher, and the oeriod when Raeckor was working alone. That such experiments, suck as Quick re¬ versing, for oxonplo, cannot be performed on oniaale is ouite clear, and also becomes evident free a number of foreign papers on that sub¬ ject. In order to recognize the significance of the rosults, one need not bo rr. expert on cold. I think that e winter during which, according to official r^oorto in the English House of Cocoons, 534 persons died free cold in the British occupational zone of Gornany nlono, and 175 people died ir. Eorlir., when 776 persons hid beer, admitted to hoooitnlo in the British zono as a result of freezing, ar.d during which in 3crlin 15,615 people were in "very urgent danger of freezing to death", ono would at lor.ut have to recognize the significance of tho nroblen as it existed for us after tho first winter in Russia. After all, thousands of frozen norcons wore treated wrongly, and finally tho right solution is found ar.d is iaaediotely confined. The decisive answer to your cuostion I should like to glvo you on the brciB of n work which I read recently where quick ro-vnrning is colled e revolutionary thin*: in medical science. Tho author, who is on American, writes: “Before our vor against Jaoan ended, this method of Quick ro-wprning nad been occcptcd as ihe recognized treatment by nil American sen rescue cervices, and is today generally accepted by* nodical circles." This statement originates free Major Alexander. ZE. TIP?: I nay say that the document shows that this is tho Professor Alexander who is the nodical expert of the r-rosccutior. in this trial. In this connection, Mr. President. may I offer Becker- 7920 Court So. 1 21 Hey 47-M-12-2-iS(-Cook (Healer) Jreyaeng Document So. 31, which is to he found in Document Volume II, P'S® 140. -his will receive the exhibit amber 18. It is ar. excerpt -r- r ouhlicntion "Eerpers Magazine" entitled "Secrets by the Thousands", b:* Letter Volker. I should like to auoto only a few passages which seen to -e to hu particularly important or. that coint. I cuotc fron tho first page, page 140 of Becker-Jreyecng Docunont Book II. These arc the lest few lines of the firct p?gc of tho document: "With reference to the nedical secrets in this collection, one arry surge or. has remarked, 'Scco of then will save American nedicino yenro of research. Kocy of these secrets are revolutionary, is, for instance, tho Gernan technique of treatment after prolonged nr.d usually fatol ojnocuro to cold. 1 "This diocovory, which was revooled to us by tho aforementioned rccort of Major Alexander, revolutionizes all nodical knovlcdgo on that oubjoct." BY ER. TIP?: Q» witness, concludes tho Kolzloohnor, Beschcr, Finko coaplox and there arc only two r.oro cuostions of a vory gonornl nature. Wc know, witness, that Dr. Hacchcr carried out other cold work long after the Luftwaffe experiments had boon concluded, hoy I ask you, did you at ary ti:;o hear of this further work by Bnschor? A. I hrvo to cnover that Question in the affirmative, but not during the war. Q. Vhon did you first hoar about these experiments? A. I hoard that for the first tine during njr activity in the Aero Medical Center in Heidelberg, but I heard nothing vory specific * then. Only here was I thoroughly informed. Q, This testimony, witness, seems to be contradicted by Prosecution Document riO-238, which ic in Document Book III, on o go 130 of the German and 118 of the English version. This is a file note signed by Mr. Siovers, dated 4 February 1943, end it concerns itself with SS Eauptsturnfuehrer Stabserzt Dr. Beecher. Mention is npdo in this docu- 79a Court “o. 1 21 Aey 47-M-I2-3-=Bi-Cook (SarAer) oer.t that Genereloberstabsarst -rofessor Dr. Eipcke allegedly said on the telephone that one could no longer tolerate Dr. Batcher's exocriments, end sof, oetion vas cade to transfer hie very quickly to the last. The cor.c_* nicn could he dravn, witness, that you, as a center of the Beferat for Aviation Medicine, did know these exoerinents. ‘At any rote, perhaps the oro»ecutior. could arrive at such a conclusion. Please consent briefly on this docunent. a. First, if Genoralobertiabserat Eippke actually did know any- thing, this in no way neans that I Jcnev about it. Professor Fipofco, aftor all, vno ay suprene superior and I was an assistant Referent. "ut it dooc bccaso clearly apparent fron this letter that not even Professor Kippfcc knew anything because had he known anything ho wouldn't have hod to instruct Gborfeldarst Daniels to reoort to his or to inctruct Rateher through Daniels to ronort to his vhnt ho vao doing. Then, it con also bo clearly seen fron this letter that this work of Puncher'o vao assigned to his by the Reichcfuohrer SS, Heinrich Hinmler. Daniolo, os tho local Luftwaffe superior officer, sorely gave Rucchor tho opoor- tunity to carry out this order by Hisslor. Ir. conclusion, witness, I say state with rcfcronco to the coo- plox of cold questions that you heard about tho plans for the experiments during tho Professor Kicpke-Rascher conversation in June, 1542, and that on this occasion you hoard about exporinonte which were to bo carried out on voluntary subjects with tho approval of the head of the state. Hitler, .and the Reich iilnietry of the Interior, without learning any details about the setter, er.d furthers ore that you hoard about tho result of these e-verisents on the occasion of the Nuernberg cold sooting without it bccccing apparent to you that any crises won. cocr.ittod during the execution of such cxceriser.ts, and finally that you knew nothing of Reocher'o further work ir. that connection besides what he was doing with Finke and Eolzloehner, is that correct! A. Yes, that is correct. DR. IIP?: Hr. President, this brings at to tho conclusion of the 7922 Court So. 1 21 May 4?-K-12-4-iSi-Coo> (fianltri cold cosplex and I think It would fee advisable to adjourn at this tir-e. Si rl&SIIHSf: The Tribunal will now be in recess until one-thirty o'cic.k. 7923 /*V7 21 &iy-A-?i>-i3-l-&iclsi (Brown) Court iio. I. AFTEPJiCOK 3:' 5 o^lhis mission rc.^diae-lSepatitis 21 lfcy-&-L*3-23-2-Biolai (Int. Brorm) Court Ho. I. research coocission? A This coeBdssion vos given by the Reich Research Council. It i3 number 5 in the Document. It is also a top secret research assign¬ ment. Thus, Raagen had not only no reason to tell us .about this, but since it r;as a tor secret setter he '.as forbidden to do so. Q Now, re know of the dual position which Haagen occupied, and .-hioh played a large role in this trial. Ho was Director of the Hygiene Institute of the University of Strasbourg, end, at the oans tiro - fron a certain date on - he ms a Consultant Hygienist in the Air "loot Reich. To which aspect of Haagen 1 s dual activities doos thi3 letter refer' A Of course, it refers to his activities as Director of the Hygiene Institute of the University of Strasbourg.• • .because it is dircctod to the Rector of the University of otrassbourg. It concoms itso’f v/ith tho fact that tho Uygionic Institute is to be recognizad as a so-called . Hit cry Institute, and it is signod by Krof. Dr. Haagen, and not STABSARZT Haage n, and there is nothing in this letter concern¬ ing hepatitis. Q Ncv, one r.ore question. Haagen m 3 a nodical officer in tho Reserve Cor^s of tho Luftwaffe. Did ho not, as such, have on obligation to report on all work and all research condcsi ons that ho received fron my office whatsoever? A If all taodic .1 officers had had to report on all the wor2: that they did, ve should have had to open up another Medical Inspect¬ or.ate. •» 3 In other words, there ms no such obligation on tldir part? A "o; there was never a— rention cf that, cither. Q In the coze context, -.fitness, please look in the sane Docu¬ ment Bock, Number VIII, NO-299, Kxhibit 190. It is on page -3. Tiiis is again a letter fron Haugen to Dr. Schreibor at tho Military Academy in Berlin, and it is addressed, "Honored Gene r a l . a rst■ ■ There is no signat¬ ure, consequently we do not knar in vhat capacity Haagen signed it. At 7925 21 i2y-A-i5-13-3-3iolai (Brown) Court Kc. I. any rate, from the heading, "Honored Ger.eralarzt," it can be nss'srod that this i3 a military natter here, an affair which, perhaps, had sorve contact with the Usdical Insrecterato of the Luftwaffe ever, though that nay have been circuitously, ’•hat can you say about it? A ?irst of all, it cor. bo ssjr. iron this letter that it did not cone through channels. It 'rent through the iiedical Insj.octernta. Moreover, there vrc-r^ no military roLationrhi.es betreen Hacger. and Sc hr other. Cn the contrary, it is tiio Univorsity Frofestor Ha agon v.ho is v/riting to tho University Professor Schroibar in Berlin, in this iot- ter. ?y accident, ono is Genorftlarzt, and the other, by accident, is Cborntabs .rzt, of the Luit iffc. It is purely fortuity - and plays no rolo in this letter. Q Just to make it cloar... :.*ho was this Professor Schrolbor? A Ho was a rote arch worker for tho Reich Rosoarch Council on tho question of opideaics. Q Morr, 'hat was hie rolationnhi in such fork on opidcnics -'nd his rssoarch work, that is tore wider consideration. A V.Tiat his relationship >rs I should not liko to s-y any¬ thing urwLr oath about this. !!o was a do;uty of tho Reich Rcsorrch Council, =3 I said, but since Rangen rcc- vsd cocr.issicns regarding ty¬ phus and lie pat it is from tho Roich Research Council, one must assure that ho received thon fron Schrcibor. 3 You neon that Professor Sclircibcr, in the Reich Re so .arch Council, vns forking on this hepatitis question on a research cost isrion? A That can be deduced fro- rhat -jutzoit said here, -as Hand- + losers witness, but I know nothing about it syself. 7926 21 ::-y i7-A-C7-Ui-l-5iol3i(~rcrji) Ca-rt 8 o. 1 c >nor that the crosscut or. is a-tting in all thcro documents in order to prove the cxistor.ee of certain oxncriccnts or. honor, beInge. i: ~ : i I t re ref-r to another drccaont in dich tho nano “ohuen a, x>oro. r. Dohnon is .cut oacd hero. In thu first >aragr-ph of d ocuccnt thorc 1:. d of on invitation that * r. J chnen discussed this natter with you ... or ratter, :.ith Uoagon. -id *u knew anything of this planned xork, involving i>oluxn rr.d Haoror.? A. ..‘o, I bne-no thing -bout that. . urtheraoro, ir. this docuacnt, • it nose, in the next para.i , it is aid that Hngor. is approaching "c’.ToiKr for his assistance ir. prewiring nice. This isth- oocond ragraoh — let no quote it— • • • -. Haagon-ritoss "/.t tho anno tlno I should like to a poreceh tho subject of your r -° for dec. --y mp.lics, -and particularly t^o . , aro tolutoly n t to rejuvenated and ref i. fov. told ,'X) in Hohc.nlychon t r.t it is visible for you to accv.ro nice, ever, in ler-c numbers. ay 7 I: c* to endeavor ao9J.ro >r o .icv.nl thousand nico of bet o. cr, r of. r.ably only •. nung a;r\calfl." itr.C3s, to e as a lay-i=an t s ana •• t ir.-, and Iror.'t imagine havo to do vlth o onto a* a o o arrpert in the fiold of lie >atitir bet yen arc a doctor and perhaps you can just toll -is *:hat Jte connection is? w -y 6-- that 1 can find in tdslottcr .--t tte least • intiir.tien that there is any quant-an hero cf exeerLronts cr. humn beings . . • : last paragraph, is of particular inj-ortenoe for ■ov. ... Kaagon - rites in t ds paragraph: urdly, I to- old like torsi: rhether tlco 'opatitis research *.rill ■o carried or. ir. future out of f'.nh -f tho hcich -.cscarch Council, 7S27 21 hay U7-A-SS-li:-2-?lolsi (Er of d-ogen, on ti»c other land? A. Inn rcoront rrith tho ^ocunoat ”0 137, Lxidbit 10? ... it can bo neon fron thislottorlnut tho rone-arch for hepatitis van assigned by tho 'xich Res. arch Council, ax’, also "inanccd by then. At least, until 12 Juno 1?1|U the .cdic-1 -auector of tl:o Lift affo had not', line at all to do ?dth H.aa^n'c hopatitis research. Haagon lr.t r turn toIho Chief of thr odical Inspectorate of the Luftwaffe for a research 03signaent in hepatitic .. ul’ich is, after all, a possibility? I .jr of no tt*c n 'da .part. 0. It this docuneat, :itn ■, sro is of coll.boraticn conctmiRe'thj . 1 - ohner, •.. . , ot :ex* research ”.cn. All tl-cco piyr.icians, .0 - o Yur; frm cl].or to, ro fxJboro of vo Corps of tho .'ufti .ab’c, TJwoo aro roc arch natters .... and 00 I ,ay ash y-vi hctlr you bncr.: anyU.ine of this collaboriin. .. '.itneos — just tcclariiV tlds’.i.jlo business - ono iuteri’-, question .. Tbeso special fields that a.c hero under discussion •hepatitis, r p llcrr Fever, Typhus — and so forth .. In otb-r trords •all those fie xds ... v.'oro you, in the 1 o fiolds, a socialist? o. 1. Zou kn-.Tr of no such collaboration .. Voll, nouon tho question of hepatitis. Did you knor* anything about hepatitis voric in Breslau, '.duch played a considerable role here? 7528 21 ifcy Li7“.-^S‘.i-*Ui-3-Biolsi (3roun) Court :io. 1 A. I heard of this hepatitis ccnf; re nee in Breslau for tho first tii-o ’..ere, ard I _ay recall that even Professor Peso 03 consultant hyjioni3t of tho nodical chief of tho Luftraffc heard of this conference only after it was all ov.r, DR. Tli'P: Your Honors, let vc bring to your attention in this corni¬ ce tion that regarding this collaborati r. with regard to Has sen, Duochmr nnd ICalk, wlrnt was said in the case before by Dr. behroedor, to 'fit, ar. affidavit cf 9 Jan'uoxy 1917 : 'm.; Ducchncr, -.Jiich wnsput in ovidcnco and is in S.hrocder's Docuiont ' ooJ: os: page 58, Jehroedor Docuaont Mo. 18. It was given d>hibit ItaSxar Schrocder 17• BuociMur, in this affidavit, oxplcAno Just \ct the n tnre of t\v& collaboration was to tc. DY DR. TIPP: 1. Anothcrhopatitic question, ritno: , b -sod on Documnt 1 .'0-126, Exhibit 185, Document Book VIC, pa^o l»j. -‘.is is o letterfroa Choretabarzt Hsagor., f 27 Juno 19M, to — aid I qu'r. Haagonras active at t:» institute in Strasobcurg and that ‘ .“^n liad received ..is rdors froa th wfcrnfc >-c. nong. ‘ H .t c this Institute, and regarding ’be fact that you a -c olio god to lnvc given hin orders in '.sopatitis research? 7ScO 21 K*y 47-l~¥3G_T5-3~£«ylord (Int., Brown) CoUTi I A First of all, I knew of no Institute for Medical 3csearch in Straaobourg. ?rcs Fraulein Bdith Schmidt or Olga Rycr, I did hear in this court that there was in effect sene such institute and that it was pert of the medical department of the University cf Strasbourg. How¬ ever, sirce I was not dean cf the Medical Department of the University of S-raoobourg, I was not in a position to iesue ary order to thic in¬ stitute. Secondly, Keagon was director of the Hygiene Institute of Strassbourg and wen not a member of this Medical Research Institute. Then, moreover, I couldn't and didn't give Hoagen any orders. «< In this connection, Your Honors, let re drew your attention to an affidavit by Zuckschwcrdt cf 21 January 19*7, which is in Schroeder Document Book 19, Page 61, Schroeder Exhibit So. 18. ?cr the convenience of the Court, I have included this document in the Bcckcr.Prcyocng Docu¬ ment Book. I don't want to put it into evidence again nor give it on inhibit number, but it is in the document bo k on page 142, in Document Book Ho. 2. Let me point out that Dr. Zuckachvcrdt, In hie affidavit, declared: "The Institute for Medical Research in Strasbourg, no an into/ral part of the Univoraity, come under the Dear, of the Medical Faculty. The head cf the Luftwaffe Medical Service had nothing to do with It." Ir. ccn-cction with the hepatitis research, Mr. President, I have also to put in evidence Beckcr-Freyscng Document Ho. 33 on page 143 cf the Document Book -«o. 2. This is something to supplement Dr. Kalk'o affidavit. It ic the report on the Journey made by Professor Kalk cn 10 March 1545 in his capacity ns consulting interne, which wns submitted to the Chief of the Luftwaffe Medical Service and which tells what was dene by the Luftwaffe in the field of hepatitis. This will be Exhibit 19. I dc n^t wish to eucte anything fr*a the document, but should like to dr3v it tc the attention of the Tribunal. This ccncludca ry treat¬ ment of the hepatitis cues*ion. Summing up, witres*. I may say that this entire subject w BG un- ta-v- to you at the time, and you hare pointed out that the prosecu¬ tion witness, Idlth Schmidt, ha3 stated that there were no human being 7931 o (J •. M.y A7->_ 5 ^-l=-2-X-&ylcrd flat., Brown) curt I experiments in hepatitis research. H*vc I cussad ycu up correctly? A Yes. ^ I turn new to anether subject, the subject of typhus. You arc charge, witness, with special responsibility for and participation in typhus experiments free Leccnber '41 to February >45, in Buchenvald and in Satxveilcr concentration c»npc. You have heard the prosecution's case in this setter, witness, and consequently you knew that the ex¬ periments were carried out in Buchenvald by It. Ling-3chulor, anl ac¬ cording to the prosecution, by your co-dofer.dent It. Kevin. She ex¬ periments in Kattweiler, on the ether hand, are connected with the nose of Professor Dr. Haugen and his associates. She prosecution kept those two subjects opart. I shall follow their example nr.d ask you what co¬ nnections exist between you and your referat in the Hcdicol Inopecto- ratc and the experiments in Buchenvald. A Hone. ^ Eid you knew anything about these experiments? A Nothing about the experiments, nor about Buchcnvold, ncr about Ding-Schuler or Boren. <4 You havi heard how Fr-ftsser Rose, who wnn aloe charged with this natter, spile cf the Buchenvald eucation and his participation In it. Therefore, I need only ask you regarding thio ratter; during your activity in the Medical Inspectorate, did you knew anything of this aspect of Er. Roso : c activities? A No. Lot =c remind ycu that Prcfccscr F.mc stated here on the stand that everything that he had done or written in this connection v P0 dene in his capacity as- a member of the Hubert Koch Institute. ^ I new turn to the experiments which Haugen is alleged, by the prosecution, to hav, carried rut in Ket*wcilor. Kaagen v 0 s an Ctcr- atebaarst of the Luftwaffe, and from the end cf '43 on he was consult¬ ing hygienist in the air fleet "Middle." What did ycu knew about Hearer, and his work during the war? A Cf his work, I knew nothing, 'hen I took over the referat in Ma- 13^. I found out that Professor Kaagen had « research assignment 7932 21 (let., Brovc) Ctfsrt I an tV.« production -f typhus vaccine. Theretofore, I had nothing to do with these research assignments, end Professor Hose was kind enough to corroborate thlo for me in the prosecution document HC-306,-Bxhibtt Hr. 206. Pace 47 of the EnglislrDocoaent 3?ok. << Witness, you here already said that all research assignments had the file note 55, and that for the sake of keeping things straight¬ ened out in the files, they vero all worked on hy tho referat for Aviation Medicine; hut actually only research assignments thnt really concerned aviation were worked on by your referat, the ether ones wore turned over to the referents who were concerned in the fields which were involved in the snccific research Assignments, is that correct? A Yes, it is. ^ How, in point o' fact, which Boforat competent to handle re- renreh psrlgnacnts involving typhus research? Whc vn- the competent fellow? A That was the reftront for vacclnos, nancly, tho referent for hygiene. jC_i 5 ^j:- & y lerd (Int., Brown) I A Tea , nd dcoon't happen to know very much about hygiene, * n '* if he th»r«f)r' sends tho research aBsirnconts that concern those =attcr« over to s*-o referat for hygiene. •i ^ow '.i .r.tc :o the offect that haa or., as the Prosecu¬ tor assorted, van cam in out any 3ort or riorh lr. Patrwoilox? A, I avo .:o rocolloovioa of that b-'. I consider It out of the question, a=d I u .v aortoi in ay racolloctl&s h ro by ono or f.;o affidavits \:hich a: o to be pot i: evidonco It tori o. Ma-, row oorc'inil rolotious ’ ith Profecs.cr Matron were vhat, did you kna.: hi.? A- Yon. Can you toll v v her. 'ou calo his ac -^iutaneaft A. It ba-ronn that I can do so vary -roc. 11 ly, about tho third or 4th of July 1-V- in an as 'roes train eti.oou Moi'lolborg and ?roibur . I -'as In tho couFany of jy Chiuf, Profoauor Schroodor, orwl war oinc to e co*.faranco at the Cordon Acaoiy for Aviation re¬ search which woo co t. o laco in Duocbaor's Inotituto, onl Hoa.on •von or. tho awa train and proforsor schroedor Introduced .no to hln. Did you .-iOt Au a vain v»rsa.ally aftar that, and if so vihon and jndor vhat ci :wteta.-.coS7 A- I sa< Ha. on for tho socor.d tiuu> in tho 1 st days of July 1541. I ovo.1 a'; t i* virnj vor.turoi into t .» lion's ion lt- selt, and saw hit ir. hit Irsti tito at Strosbcur . 1 had othar business in Struct* r . I 111 state briefly 1*X that vas.. Short¬ ly thore-to-foro I : o- talon over the radical cub-do par tnont of tho rued leal inctituto of tho Air -CiaistxT "hich Dr. Sunzlnfiar had rro- viously royroranted. a rose arch coxlssions had boon fivon by this offleo to cantla-an in the Strasbourg university, indudinc the a=- si: ruar.t to tho Pharmaceutical Institute of Strar ouri. Professor Schlermor. This -oioarofc ass 1& meat concerned ;he artlficsl produc- 7 9 % 5 21 ^ey-A-?3-16-2-?:Qloy( 3rcwn) Court 1 tion of coffein. Sir.ca the office of the IIviical Inspector had a conference planned for tho ond of August 1944 on pervitin, bonzo- dria o-Tl coffein, I wonted to tall: with Professor SchlaEser in order to soo just what this work ho ’-as Join£ was, and •-bother it would ba a good idoa for hin to participato in tho conforenco, and to road a paper on his v.’or*:, anl actually ho did coco to the conforonco. Yat said, witness, that you didn't go to Strasbourg to soo Haaaon, but that you did visit hie in hi3 instituto; on this occasion did you discuss Hoa .orf • roooaroh assignments with hi.* A. 7fhoul subcittod ay roruoat for a day trip to :y dopart- noatol chief, 1 also ashed nfcothur I right visit Kaar.oa to discuss a fov quoations vit: hin, to-rit, tho quostier. of tho oxperinental onir-aln. Then 1 vi.-lt<* "acvoa in his inatituto. Ho showed no through port of his inatituto a l ho afrouod m tho cni.-al brooding. stations, which tho witnose A - istizlflk has alroody doscr.' ed horo. I diocucsod at groat longth with !dru what anoint and what torts of oxpori.eontal oninols ho noodod. I was lrzaediatoly concorro* 1 th tho quo®tion of oxporL-nontol animals officially, bocauro fox our oivornous rosoarch in- ntitutos, I had to concern nysolf with their cs«ut woods for oxpori- aontal animals ond censoquantly hod cloco conuoctions with tho poraoas in Chareo of brooding o»! doallnc -.dth thoso or~.oricor.tal oxdmalo. T7itnoca, Jo you rorjob'r what sort of oxporimontel animals Hangon oakod ;ou for at that time, rico, r^inoa pies, wb-at two tho>? A. Above all it was mico and rabbits. }. Haogon thou oskod you to procure roro exporiaontol animals for 1dm; could you ;aat hi3 roquost for him or what did you do about It? A. A fo ' days thoroofter I spoke with a coapetont nan of tho Luftwaffe in this matter asl I adkod this Dr. Suchalla to himself get in touch lith Eo-v eu bacauso Haagon had very specific questions about tho quality and nature of theso oxporiaoutal anLiols. D3.n?P: Hr. Prosicont, in this cohtaxI pro.'oso to put in a documont freu Becker Froysong Document Book 4. I do not knot 7936 21 Kpy-A-ir-16-3-«iLcy{Br«.n) Court 1 "hotter that voluso has yot cor_ i-to thi harals of tha Tribunal. In any ovjr.t tho 3 6 vr at ary Gerard has tho 3r;,lich tr-n3lation of those documents a bI I should bo « lad if ho *uoulC &ivo colics to tho court, tfco Pros jcutioa aal lutarprotor. IK. HARDY: I '<111 corcoivo. Your Honor, I looked on ay dock at noon and it *.men' ' tharo, and I do not havj tho docuront book. 1TI3 SRSST'ZrT: Bag counsol for tho Prosecution this docunout nor/ £ 0 lnt offcrod? DR. TI?P: Porhar-o tho aocrotary Go rural uould to oo kind os to Llvo a copy rim -o tho intorprotors. TbonKr. Prosidont, free thia Docunant Book 4, if I nay put in Document 61, froc ?tv.o 319 of tho doounor.t book. This will bo oxhlbit 20. Tnlo la in— XH2 r'SSror’”: Koa connool for tho Prosocution road thin do- cuaont? IK. HARDY: .’To, Your Honor. Eo nay put it In at this tino and I will folia. it by any objoctions. DR. TIIY: Thank yew. This la an affidavit by Dr. Harry Suchalla, that Dr. Dockor just ujntionol. It -as drtf.Jn up l:Volbort Rholnland, and ir. correctly cortifiod, ira"r. u ; on tho 10 of April 1947. 3!2 FRS5I3.S*’: 7111 you givo -o ouco .soro t'.o nunbor of this oxhlbit- I liar.’ ; * qYj tho docmvint *~hon you (.‘'Vo it. DR. TCT: Bxhibit 20, Your Honor. In nur-.bors 1 a ’ 2 tho affidavit doscriboc first of all Dr. Suchalla’s clerical a 1 ;-rofosrional activitios. In:;o.2 ho nay's that ho \:as comisslouod ; ith tho scientific control of tho yroiuc- tlon of all Luftffaffo rabbit brooding, "About 500,000 Angora rabbits rare kopt for tho production of Ancora wool and the Luftvaffo supplied approximately 200,000 oninolc, os tost rabbits. I quota free No. 3: 7937 21 llay-A-i T-16-4-;;-loy (Bra.-n) Court 1 "A* tor I ha- .orkod ■ ith tho -illitaiy rad: of signaller as scientific expert a: tho Luftiau coscaui 5orlin free January 1542 to July 1S42, I as tranaforroi to tho Luff.raffo uofiicc.1 sarvico qs a riedicnl ordorly first class in August 1343 and sent to Ifco aviation nodical institute, Berlin. At the nano ties I was ordered by tho Suprone Canan:. of tho Luftwaffe, Chiof of radical services, to do- volop thoLuftwaffo'a brooding facilities for rabbits aai also to 3 up ly lAco, rat-, guinea pigs and do&s for ox.vr.lnental purposes. In connection with this official task I was in constant touch with tho consulting Ctabsarzt Profossor Dr. Anthony at tho nodical Inspoc- torata, section .••.ieti.on -odicine until op or on boat oly Hay 1944; aftor that ti-e, Dr. BocIcm-F roysor.t bocaxe ny conpotont suporvisin\ au¬ thority in connoctto. it'_ ay official work. "4. At tho : July 1944 I had a disousnion with Dr. Bockor- Froysang durin^ ...ioh \o Arm: spoclal attention to the nocoscity of supplying Ice do:: wjto vantod by Profoauor Haor.on for tho r.onu- iacturo of a typhus ricclne and ho askod » to c wok to Profossor Kao on personal 1; in o; '.or to find out Ms s ocial roo! on to Profossor Hancon of r.h'ch ho a-ticularly Informed re tut novortholosn ho con- sidorod it osnontlai for Profossor Haa; on and uysolf to bo in diroct contact ai*v5o ho hiiiroif had no special knorled.o of tho nanufacture or vaccinos and could tfcarofora not ans-or r.y .-oacific laostions a- bout tho particular ro^ulrauar.ts in connection ith tho tost aninalc# Since Profossor Kao .on left Stra ours as early as A’Je-ust 1944 bo- causa of tho war ovontr. in the west, this po soial contact c-roo about only in J anuary 1945 at 0 berschrolbarhau .'here Haakon had xoanv/hilo a^Alr. opor.jd a lat-cra-ory. y.y various cor.vorrations uith Dr. 3ockor-FroyEeng about this •uattar convinced a '.hut even after ho had boon personally instructs ha know oi-ly about Haigon's aniral oxpori onts . n 7936 by Profossor Koa cu. 3ourt 1 •-ay 21-«-17- 1 -HD- A 3 ehan-Rattler. I nay spy somethin- about the rest of the Jocuaonc, specific lly -:c. 5, let nc q,ote from It: *o±nce daring the war It bcc-zc nor and more difficult Co oot'in experiment*l_anlc. Is, or. rcCker-Freyseng discussed with me in the summer of 19-.4 new poselblllties of e. % .lying the lnscutes of the Luftwaffe despite these diffic idea thr . u a h own reeding st'tlons. I mode rporo- mrir.te si gesti* ns, which were supported most generously by all fleacere of the office of the chief of medical servic¬ es. I Chon w«a given two research orders by the c.*lef of medical .rvlcoa of the Luftw ffe, ^jnerrlobcrstrbo-.rzt Professor ochroeder, each tv the value of 5C,00C floioho- c'r’:o. The flret order w. s concerned with fcreedln 5 certain e -rn.no of mice for the production of typhus vaccine, the OJG nt order referred to tnc building up of an experimental .*.nls 1 fare for ill the usual test anlsi- Is such ca mice, rate, ,ulaee el a, r belts, c-nto n 00 e.° I believe c.-.-t 1 neod r.ot rood the rest of the dooumont. IC is correctly signed end certified. "1 tncse, m connection witn the tycnua research, It is necoso?.r to discuss p few Prosecution doc.nents with you fr e v:*s the consulting hy cniet .is eu 3 .uatlons n.-furslly went to the Heforat Hy one and not to the Referat AVletlon Medicine. This letter \m sent on 29 August 194.. It was cuetompry in our ofi"loo, as everywhere else, that the dote wes Inserted at tho tlroo the el,nature was written. In this connection, I aey point out, hr. Prominent, Chat In the 'hotostatlc copy, which la before me, the Or to io not written b- typewriter but w-s Inserted by Ink or aoncll. Ilia t means that whoever sl-ned that letter at the ,-affic t 2 x 0 Inserted the d"te. T.i£ rRZSID-lM: Jli t..e counsel for the Prosecution sea the si 2 nture of th- 1 -tter? DP.. ”Irf: I an sfrrld th t I did not understand your question. HR. «RDX: I have the original hare,-Your Honor. 7941 Court 1 May 2l-A-l?-4-KD-Meehan-Ramler. 3Y DR. TIPr: v. The signature reads Kar.nt. "lthout having to ask She witness, I cay be able to say X»hnt w s the chl3f of steff at that time. a. '.Jell, this letter was presented on 29 August 19-14 to the chief of staff for his signature and according to our office procoeduro and been dictated perhaps one or two days earlier by the Referent. I hr::en to know that during these days, the 27th t as 28th and 29th of august, 1344, I was certcinly not in the ofiice, but was eonewhoro else. ... wr. President, in thst connection, lot me offer from Doouc.nt 3ook 3ockcr-rrcyseng No. 34. This ern bo found on Pcr.c 150 of the document book. I shall gi Vu 11 cho exhibit No. 21. It is an rffidrvit by Dr. H 0 n3 Denrc-r, it was made in Altunhundora on 18 March 1947. Let mo quote from Pare ,ra,h I. "1) Cn 28 and 29 Au.ust 1944 n discussion took laco in Cr.atlo V.lkeradorf lr. cilesln between t:»e directors of cho C-orrn Institute for «vlation medicine. "2) On the following day, 30 August 1944, according to a. Gocrlltz hotel bill lying before mo, c aedlcal-oclcr.tiflc •lisc. sslon with a It rger attendance took place in Gocrlltz, Silesia, about 35 kilometers away. Tne subject for discus¬ sion v'?.s: ‘Methods for Increasing Efficiency 1 . *13) .-^s a colleague of rrof. otrughold -nd head of the ‘Schloss Welkersdorf branch of tho .-ivlatlon Acdlcine nosoarea Institute, I wrs in ci.'r^e of the accommodation and catwfin for tho participants in t.V two above-mentioned dis- cusoions. Dr. Seeker rrcysen^, who was then aviation Medicine Consultant with the Chief of the Luftwaffe Medical Services conducted both discussions. 7S42 Court 1 ;-iay Z I-.1-17-5-HD-Keehan-Ramler. Dr. 3eck3r-rr&ysen& errlved at the latest on 26 or 27 -u,U3t 15=4 lr. 'elkersdorf, end did .ot leave It until one or two days after the conference In Goerlitz, which took place on ?G njguat 19-4, that Is to spy on 1 or 2 September 1941." There follows the sl^n ture of the witness and the certification by the Notary. Witness tnls provee that at the time this letter was Si-nt off, on 29 August 1944, you were not .'resent In your office. On the other hand, you told ue before that tho Ron'.n Numeral One (I) originates from you rr.d I am roferrlnt to Joe mont 131; can you tell uo how this letter camo about before It was submitted for .'.r. Kchnt'o signature? * 7945 21 Hiy 17 -l&-i-gkp Cook (gassier) Court Ko, 1 A. The signature cn any letter wherein a report is cede about a financial rat tea could net be rade by er.y cepirtacntal chief but only by the chief ^f 3ta:‘f and in nony cases only by the chief of the radical service. This scans that during the days of the 20th or so I oust have submitted a letter to ny depertcer.tr. 1 chief which would probably teve corresponded to Paragraph 1 of the lottcr which is beforo us here. The dsparurcntnl chief then kept this letter in order to in his turn suhait it to the Chief of staff. 9 Q. May I put an additional question to you in that connection, witnoss? Tils really slaple letter wos preperod for you ready for signature, wasn't it? You oust tevo attached file notes and file Index nusbors, otc? A. Yes, th :t was custaaary In the cnoo c S such letters. Q. .ell now continue to describe this document? A. Everything else I only aasuae but I think ny explanation is wry proto.ole. Dunr* the last few days another letter by tho Hygiene Referar.t r.ost h‘ ve bocn sufcaittod t© U» dopr.rtosntal chief, bearing tho contonts of roam II, IH, rd IV. Since all of thooo four points wore addressed to thu very saao f n, Professor H«u ;-on in Strassbour^, *txJ sinco in tho fir. 1 analysis ’ll thcoo four points concorr.ud tho sc.® thing, nasoly typhus productim, cither the do- portnental chief or the chi«f of staff aaalgwted thesottio sopareto lotters aaJ produced letter which is before us ntm. Q. The n:xt lettor, witness, is Ha son's reply. This is docuaent of the Prosocution Ko. 132, Exhibit 310. This is in document volar*) 12 on page 99 of tho English text. It is ontitled: "Chief of Stiff Surgeon, Oborstcfcsarzt Professor Dr. E. Haagen, dated Strassburg, 19 September, 19U. n It bears the designation "secret" and is directed to tho High Command if the Luftwaffe, Chief of the Nodical Service. Do you know that letter? A. I do not rc-aesber it. It is possible that I saw it. If I did I deduced no -are than that there was ft typhus epidoaic in villa“c _c - llod :>.tzwoil*r about which I didn't know anything and that ?K4 21 toy 17 -A-lB-2-p3q>- Cook (Ra r g- l cr) Court Uo. 1 this epidemic was introduced frea the outside. In other -lords, thin was a natter which did sot concern st officially nor scientifically. I rad nothing to so with any such reports nd if this letter actually did ccxje to ay roferat I would hove had to add that this famous remark did not concern end w »ul* have *nt it to the Hygiene referent, but I think this is highly probable, that because all letters after all had to go over the departmental chief oof ore they were distributed among, tho reforents. Tho departmental chief, of ccursc, know exactl;- what his sever, or eight rvfcr-nts were doinc cad cert' inly wouldn't have sent ,» such a letter as the referent for eviction medicine. Ho certainly wouldn't hrvo s-r.t no any rer-ert about o tynhus epidemic of which h. kr.e*.i I had nothing at nil to do. Q. In order to suaoeriso, witness, you rru nssertinc yau had nothing to do with typhus vaccines and typhus production? a. At ny r .to not before this tri'l started. (.. Th> Prosecution has submitted ^ -'ocu^nt in this connection from which the represent-:tivo of tho prosecution has drawn a contrary conclusion. This is in docuaent book 12 >r. pngo 86 of the Salieh docuxnt bock. It is .:ocu-*nt ho. 302, -n bears also Exhibit Mo. 302. As it becoa.s rpparent from the signature it is r. letter written by the 0bcrstabs.ar7t, D . dugor. ifeagon, dated tho 27 Aoril 19U, "r>. is directed to the kinistor of Aviation and Caxruvler-in-Chicf of the Luftwaffe, L In. 14, SaalcM. Counsel for Prosecution when submitting this document or. tho 9 January 1947,. ok p -e 13A9 of th. finish re con has stated the following - r*I I nr.y quote: ••The r/.xt .tocusunt 3C2, Ho. 302, which is being offer-d as Frosocution . hitit 302, is r. report by h-.gen to tho Coanrrdar in Chief of the Luftwaffe, er.Ud 27 'rt 1, regardin' freezing on xgo 7 of tho Geraan and .la, lith text and boars the na-nbor 44fi, Exhibit Ko. 01. Sew witness, would you pl-aec continue. Q. I Ladly drit that tr.jro is r. certain difficulty ruyarding those rambors oinuo the rvlstr tion nuabers hr.Vu beer, subjoct to .a doublo change. liny I ivpo.t briefly: tho referot for -vi-tion noc'icino bo fore ny sr.try ir. the .utusn of 1941 until pproxiatcly tho raiddlo of 1943 bore tho rogistr tion r*t-b..r 2, II .-B. ever sir.ct the cdddlo of L9/.3 until aporoxLa tcly «,>ril 1914 the ontixv 'f-ncy only had .a rogistr-tion nunhor consisting of two fi.uros rd tho reft rat for aviation oodicino mte a-si yvatod ;, which was 11 . 7943 21 C'-ir-l-Fe Idt (Int. Ranlcr) Court ’’o. I, Case So. 1. Then cane the last designation, lasting Iron May, l?hU, to 2 t.y, 191*5, which again was composed of three figures. And then the Referat for Aviation bdicino rss 2 I2A. The correspondirg R^ferat for Hygiene during thoso seme periods was designated 2 - 1 - 3 , then 2 - 3 , and at the erd again tfco designation of three figures 2-1-3. Those two registra¬ tion numbers which are found in Docunont \io. 302, Prosocution Exhibit Ho. 302 crco under "Reference* and the second tine under "Suojoct" aro in the first case 23, which was tto Ref ere t designation for tho Ruforr.t Hygieno, as of 3 January 19UU. Tho second is tho registration number 2-1-3, which is the registration number as of 25 Juno 19h3. Both of those designations belong to tto Referat Hygieno, and thin if. cor.fi.nnod by fcvo further points in thet lottor. AS first you have tho ontiro contonts of tho lottor. All this in concerned * ith tho production of vaccines from chickon eggs. I novor understood anything about that nnttor and any such nroccd'-xc was novor vrorkod upon within the Roforat for Aviation Medicine. Tho socorvd point, which soons to correspond with tho Roforat designation for Hygiene is tho filo nuber. This file reforonco is raont- ionod twice, orcc under "Reforonco" and tho second timo under "Subject". We aro concerned with tho number U9rl2F. This,-as I know now, but I corridor something which I didn't know before, is the filo reforonco for typhus. In order not to 'How any more misunderstandings I nay point out that this file number Ij9rl27 belongs together. 7f it is separated skilfully and tho two list lot'-ers or figures aro soperated from tho rest of that reference, you will suddenly find tho result of 2F, which in tho meantime -ras tic Roforat for Aviation ISedicino. I would like to correct this nisundcrsbwjding at this point, or I should 4 s~.y, tic possibility for any such misunderstanding. Q In ether words, what 70 U arc saying, witness, is that the Ro- ferat designation, the file reference 1*9 had nothing to do with tho Ref*.rat for Aviation Ifcdicine, just as little as tho Referat designation I IB and 13. Those were matters fer tho Referat Hygiene. 7947 21 Itr-A-lf-iP-Z-Feldt (Int. He a ler ) Court No. I, Cass No. 1. A Correct. In addition, I nay point out that there is not the slightest hint contained in that document that any oxTcrinent on o human being was contemplated. However, that isn't important in this connect tion. q Tho file references which I Just mentioned can be found in a mmber of other documents, end it c^ be assured that the Prosecution, on tho besj8 of these file references, intends to incriminate tho de¬ fendant Eockor-Troysing with those documents. The first of those docu¬ ments, ngclr., con be found in Docvaont Book No. 12 on Pago llh of tho English Docuraont 3ook. It is the document NO. 310, Prosocution Ex¬ hibit 31^. • The second doeuxaont, boaring tho booo filj roferonoe, is clso in Docuaont Book No. 12, md it is docuaont NO 130, Exhibit 319, Pago 120 of tho Gorman and English docunmt book. Tho first letter I nmntionod is by Oboretabsarzt Dr. Kaagon, consulting hygienist to Air- floot Roich, and is adiressod to tho Air Floot Physician Roich at Borlin- Dohlm. hr. Hacgon writes that be is enclosing tho copy of n latter to tho Roich Miniotor of Aviation and snprema cosraandor of tho Luftwaffe whore in ho suggests tho establistoont of tho typhus vaccino induction cont^r at tlo Hygiono Institute or Roich Univorsity at Strasbourg. You hove already clarified, tdtnesr, that tho file roforonoo U 9 -r and tho Roforat reforenco 2-D rhich is contained in this luttor has nothing whatsoever to do dth thj Rof jr.nt for Aviation Wodicino. In spito of all that, witness, let Da ask you whether you at any tixoo ear this letter, and cen you parhaps toll do how any connection rith an oxperirent on human beings can be established as a result of that lottor? A This letter is a typical rat tor for the Hygiene Rcf:rat, and obviously deals with the establishment of a vaccino production cantor. Tho mebor of rooms for guinea pigs, sterilization roons, ‘packing rooms, are discussed and I cm seo no indication for my planned, executed, or intended oxp-rirer.ts on human beings or experiments. JUDGE SSSSXNQ: Dr. Tip?, has your defendant stated for the re¬ cord how many Raforats there nere in his departoont md tho names of 7S46 21 Lny-A-: 2-I9-3-?lot (Ir.t. RasOur) Court Ho. I, Case lie. 1. ttem or designations? I don't recall. DR. 71??: I beg your pardon. Your Honor. The question doern't seem to be quite clear. *hat I heard rras that the defendant wa3 to cay how rany Referats there were in his de pert rent. In this way the ques¬ tion is not intelligible. JCDGZ S2 XBKi Did he not cay this norning or yesterday, in making the distinction between Referent, Referat, and Abteilung that there was a — that the Referat was, in effect, a subdepartnent? Isn't that what ho said? How then ho has been continuously referring to tho fact that this coa-.unication having to do with vaccines was not a ratter for his Referat. Isn't that what he said? How aany Referats wero thoro in tho Institute or in that phase of it? DR. TIP?: May I clarify that natter briefly, Your Honor? The Medical Inspectorate had as its tead the Chiof of tho Medical Sorvicos. Under hia, in turn, thoro were two de art rental chiefs, oach of whoa had one dopartccnt. Each ono of theso dopartoor.t3 could bo subdivided into a nu-±or of Referats. Horo wo are concornod with tho so-called first and sosond dopertaint. I n addition to othor Roferat3 tho socond departrant included tho Referat for Hygione and the Referat for Aviation Hedicine. Tho Referat in tho Roforat for Aviation J'edicino was until 15UU Professor Anthony, and after him tho witness Fvof. Dr. Becker-Freyseng. Does that ansirer your question, Your Honor? JUDOS SSBRE.'G: Yes, I understand that. 3ut than an I to under¬ stand when tha witness Beckor-Frcysong keeps remarking that tlioso com¬ munications do net pertain to hie Referat that ha means by that that they did pertain to t*x only ot;«r Roforat under the second department chief, to rit, the Hygiene Referat? * DR. TIFF: Yes. And to ake it clear, in case the testimony didn't cora through right, ail those Referats -.i*.ich boro the number 1»9 referred to the Referat for Hygiene. 7545 H j 21«- k -3K-20-l-janlols (L.t. Junior) Court :-o. I S£ j... Tlrx-: . ..'itnoss, those theoretical discussions about tho nunbors of tho various .coforats, of courso, aren’t very 7*Ioasnr.t, neither for the Tribunal nor for us, but I think they aro so*.awhat nacessary. Lot us, _»rha. s, coaso saoakin; about .toferats, but discuss tho none of tho particular ..eforont, for ;ur.osos of clarification. Could you toll us what .^foront, within tho Uodioul Ins.octorato, doclt with tho natters which boro tho nunbor -19? .. During ny tine it was n Stebsarzt ICnptain in tho Medical C r.>s), -trior. . I other words, otalsarzt ..tner was tho .cfcror.t for Hy;ieno? .. Yes, that i3 true. i Now I shall turn to tho next Cocunont in this connection. U... TI?f: Ur. President, I .-n boin . ronindod that I Just aisund car stood sonothin •. Perhaps I -dsundorstood Juf. jo So ,rin*-. I understood soaoba.y to say that Judjo Sobrinc G 3 ked how t.any itoforrts thoro wero in the second do. art- nont. ./oui : Jud;o Sobrin ; bo -jocM onou* to toll no whether I uisundor3t.x>d hin? JUJGi 3EIUINJ: I i’.n't precisely say that, but you 3ay thoro woro only two? 3I(. TUP: I bo: your . -xdon, Y<.ur H-nor. Thoro wero -wo do.jor tr.onts. Tho first wr.3 tho Organizational nt, nn-l tho second was tho Medical */o. artnent. This trial hero is only concerned with the second flopartnant. Tho sub¬ divisions cf thoso do; rtnonts woro tho hoforats. Concerned here are tho .loforat Hyyicnc, under Stabs or zt ..tner; and the itoforat for ..v inti on Medicine urn* or Professor ..thony, latjr under x-rofossor Bockor-Frcysona. Ia addition, there we re u nunber of ether .teferats in this doyartaont w.:ich, so far, have., -laycd no part in this trial. 75£0 t. r 21-..-3K-2C-2-J iols (I.t. U- nBlor) Court N . 1 THii &7KESS: ..coordin;;* to cy nocory, thoro wcro oi : ;ht ii.forats alto-eth-r in that dopcrtcxont. 1L:. IL-OY: That answers ay opostion, Y^ur H„nor. I had e question shJ.lar tc Jud;o S-brin'/.'n in thet I understood - or.;*. I t ou-ht jerh^s this was tho reason why tho Judjo v;n3 r.skin : that question - that they nontionod yesterday sono twonty or twenty-five .. .forats. Id..ybo dofanso oounsol could olccr that up. Div. TIPr: I certainly can. I', tho entire .iodioal In¬ spectoral - that is, In the first do; 'j-tnent and in tho second doynrtnont, plus .(oferat bud jot, which wc.3 indoaond- ent, . Iu3 .iofornt P.i-rnnoy, which was Independent too - there were al* thar twenty to twonty.-fivo .. t rats. I 3 allowed y .sterday to subr.it a chart or a sketch about this ontiro or ionisation, which would rinko tho nr.ttor 3till oasior. bY o... TIPI*: ; witness, lot us turn to tho next docajunt in that connec¬ tion -which ajoi.ii boars tho file reference -19, and tho -t.rorct dosijnntion Z- 3. ..ccjrdinj to your doscri.tion, this was a natter for 5j 3arzt ••w ..r | the afferent for Hyrjiono. T:.io *^-ls j cunent NO-l.iO, .cariV tho £.:•.!’jit No. 319, rnd can bo found in ^ocunont b 0 ok Ifo. XII, on pnjo 120 of tho Gori:an and Hn lish texts. It is a letter froa Oborstasarzt Prof- ossor hr. Har.con, who was tho c or.sultin- Physician to tho ~ir Fieot Physician *toich. Tho titlo roads: rt *ort3 of individuil -ir -lojt physicians. It concerns their ex.-rionces with a n~w vaccine, which is the T....B. Choi. Vaccine. In that connection, witness, r.ay I nsk you-whothor this opinion of Professor Hoar in; is oorraot? .. I hasro r.o personal knowlcd30 abtfht this particular lottor, r.n.1 I aa no hy.ionist. Sinco, as a nonbar of tho Luftwaffe, howov.r, I wr.s personally vaccinated with thi3 vaccina, I can 3ay whnt any internee or physio ian would say, that this is r v~ry si:r lo experience re. art on the application of a vaccine. <1 I11 oth-r words, this doounant has no connection with any oxporincnfcs on hutian bain s? .. Certainly not. D.t. 71??: In this ontira .a? obi an, Mr. Prosidont, tho quustion of fila raforanoos plays a considerable part booauso, in tho ease of typhus, the Prosecution always reforrod tho Tribun ;1 to fil ruforono^s in order to .rovo tha responsibi¬ lity of ^r. Bocker-Proyscnj. In ^oounont 000k No. II, on . a;o 152, I inserted u docununt under the nunber 35, which I will ;ivo the Exhibit N 0 . 22. 7KL P.JioIZENT: That is your Locunent Book No. II? Dn. TIPP: Yos, Ho. II. T k: P.ESIDSNT: On wh it pft-jo? O... TIP*': Pa.'o 152. Thi3 docunent will rocuivo Exhibit No. 22. It is a dirootivo for typhus no . boostor shots. Its head in.; is, and I quote: "Tho .ioich Secretary for ..via- tion and 5u. re no Cacuaodor of tho Luftwaffe, Pi lo Nunbor 49r, 12F, No. 25969", tat in froa tho yonr 1942, (L In 14 2-I-B). It is dated 1*3 Soptenbor 1942. I or: only suhnittin * this docununt, Mr. President, bocauso 7952 'A ;.y 21-..-3K-20-‘i-I><'_iicls (Int. ifaanlorj Coirt No. 1 this shows vary clearly that those file nunbers fio not refer to the .loforafc of -.viation Modicino. One could hardly assort that ty;hus booster shots would bo a nattor for tha i.cfcrat of --vintion Hodicino. I 3hnll not quota any orrt of this docuncnt, Your Honor. I shall now c jntinuc with the discussion of those documents, which I only have to do becauso of tho Prosecution's continual rcforonco to the do fondant i>r. Pockor-Freysonj. 3Y TIPP: . Now, would you . loaso turn to ^ocununt NO-137, whioh is Exhibit 939? This i3 tho roquost by Profossor Hendon - which was ro entodly oontionoeV - to tho ^iroctor of tho .ioich Univoroity at Strasbourg, dr.tod tho 7th of Ootobor 193. Counsel for tho Prosoouticn, whon do alia ; with ty?hus, said on tho Sth of January 19i-;, on aa;o 1367 of tho English rooor:’. tho followin;: THE PuZSIXJfT: ..hat doounont is th.at? J... T3PP: Jocunont NO-137. 'i (Continuin':): I shall quoto oounsol for tho Prosocu- tion: "On tho next ;-a ;o wo 3hnll find n Acouuont whioh wo have already subnit tod to the Tribunal. This is Proso- cuticn Exhibit 1G9. ..s you nay well rc:»onbor, this is Haakon's report whora he refers to the foot that this concerns tho ro; entodly nentionod urgent rosooroh nssi;n- aont. I shoull like to draw your ..ttontion to tho part which denis viith typhus. Here wo have the well-known oodo nuabors and letters, 2 -II-P, which is the offico of -r. ooc kcr-Proys^n- ." I think, witness, that this question of filo reference has now been clarified, but would you ,loaso onco ;:oro define your attitude towards this _oint? .. In this connection I nay .erha; s point out briefly 7953 "••y 21-«-DK-20-5-Daniels. (Int. hannlor) Court No. 1 that this letter originates froa the 7th of Octobor, 1943. I, on the other hand, booano tho -vofcrcr.t on the 15th of Mey 1944. If there was any connoction with any ono office it would bo tho offioo of -nthony. My General oan;>etonoo • as to th- handlin'; of research.nssi :nnonts oan bo soon fror, Exhibit No. 136 of tho Prosecution, tho lottor of ?rofo3scr -oso to Professor Haakon of tho 9th of Juno 1943, in DoouTiont -«ok XII, . n^o 77 of the Garnan book, and pa 70 74 of tho En lish. Perhaps I nay also 4-raw your attention to yet another little error. On tho 9th of January 19*7, on . uju 1397 of tho Gor.ian and v >n :c 1337 of tho Snjlish r ocord, oounsol • for the irosooution stated, end I quote: "professor hoso had knowledge about tho activity and plans of tlio ^hiof of the Medical crt.nont of tho -vosor.rch Institute bolonj- in” to tho Luftwaffe. This was nthony, whoso deputy was Bookor-F royson"." The Modioal Do;:ortnont of tho uosocroh Instituto of tho Luftv/affo con xily bo tho .tofornt of ..viution Hodioino, •voferont ..nth any, whoso assistant ..oforont I wqs. D*t. TIP?: Mr. Presidenti I havo a nunbor of further questions on this oonplox, which will take sono considerable tine. I thin!: it would bo ox. odiont to adjourn at this tine in >rdor to conclude this natter tomorrow nornin;-. THE ?.h3DJ?n*: I call tho attontion of the Socrotary General to on extra ;>n -o fren Docunont Book IV that was sent up here. 3one other doounont ni ;ht be short without that. Th»- Tribunal will now bo in roccss until 9:30 o'olock tccorrow nornin^. Ut 153C hours, 21 May 1947, c rcooss was taken until 0930 hours, 22 Mey 1947). 7354 ROLL