ROLL NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Microfilm Publication M887 RECORDS OF THE UNITED STATES NUERNBERG WAR CRIMES TRIALS UNITED STATES OF AMERICA V. KARL BRANDT ET AL. (CASE I) NOVEMBER 21, 1946-AUGUST 20, 1947 Roll 4 Transcript Volumes (English Version) Volumes 7-9 Jan. 30-Feb. 19, 1947 THE NATIONAL ARCHIVES NATIONAL ARCHIVES AND RECORDS SERVICE GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION WASHINGTON: 1974 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS records of the other Nuernberg and Far East (IMTFE) war crimes trials, are part of the National Archives Collection of World War II War Crimes Records, Record Group 238. The Brandt case was 1 of 12 separate proceedings held before several U.S. Military Tribunals at Nuernberg in the U.S. Zone of Occupation in Germany against officials or citizens of the Third Reich, as follows: No. of Case No. United States v. Popular Name Defendants 1 Karl Brandt et al. Medical Case 23 2 Erhard Milch Milch Case (Luftwaffe) 1 3 Josef Altetoetter et al. Justice Case 16 4 Oswald Pohl et al. Pohl Case (SS) 18 5 Friedrich Flick et al. Flick Case (Industrialist) 6 6 Carl Krauoh et al. I. G. Farben Case (Industrialist) 24 7 Vilhelm List et al. Hostage Case 12 8 Ulrich Greifelt et al. RuSHA Case (SS) 14 X 9 Otto Ohlendorf et al. Einsatzgruppen Case (SS) 24 10 Al fried Krupp et al. Krupp Case (Industrialist) 12 11 Ernat von Veizeaecker et al. Ministries Case 21 12 Vilhelm von Leeb et al. High Command Case 14 Authority for the proceedings of the International Military Tribunal against the major Nazi war criminals derived from the Declaration on German Atrocities (Moscow Declaration) released November 1, 1943, Executive Order 9547 of May 2, 1945, the London Agreement of August 8, 1945, the Berlin Protocol of October 6, 1945, and the Charter of the International Military Tribunal. Authority for the 12 subsequent cases steraned mainly from Control Council Law 10 of December 20, 1945, and was reinforced by Executive Order 9679 of January 16, 1946; U.S. Military Govern¬ ment Ordinances Nos. 7 and 11 of October 18, 1946, and February 17, 1947, respectively; and U.S. Forces, European Theater General Order 301 of October 24, 1946. The procedures applied by U.S. Military Tribunals in the subsequent proceedings were patterned after those of the International Military Tribunal and further developed in the 12 cases, which required over 1,200 days of court sessions and generated more than 330,000 transcript pages. 2 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS The crimes charged in the Brandt case consisted largely of medical experiments performed on defenseless concentration camp inmates against their will; "euthanasia" carried out on the mentally defective, the physically sick, the aged, and ethnic and racial groups; and the murder of concentration camp inmates for the express purpose of collecting skulls and-skeletons for the Anatomical Institute of the Reich University of Strassburg. The following medical experiments were conducted: 1. High altitude: to investigate effects of low pressure on persons. 2. Freezing: to test human resistance to extemely low temperatures. 3. Malaria: to develop controls over the recurring nature of the disease. 4. Mustard gas: part of a general research program in gas warfare. 5. Sulfanilamide: to test the efficacy of the drug in bone muscle and nerve regeneration and bone transplantation. 6. Seawater:' to test methods of rendering seawater potable. 7. Epidemic jaundice: to develop an antitoxin against the disease. 8. Sterilization: to test techniques for preventing further propagation of the mentally and physically defective. 9. Typhus: to investigate the value of various vaccines. 10. Poison: to test the efficacy of certain poisons. 11. Incendiary bomb: to find better treatment for phosphorus bums. The prosecution alleged and the judgment confirmed that these experiments were not isolated acts of individual doctors and scientists on their own responsibility but that they were the result of high-level policy and planning. They were carried out with particular brutality, often disregarding all established medical practice. Consequently, large numbers of the victims died in the course of or as a result of the experiments. The euthanasia program was the direct result of a directive by Hitler of September 1, 1939. It resulted in the secret killing not only of aged, insane, incurably ill, and deformed German citizens in sanatoriums in Germany but also in the clandestine murder of foreign workers. The killing in gas chambers and by injections in the sanatoriums served as a proving ground for these forerunners of much larger installations in the mass extermination camps. In addition to these experiments, over 100 concentration Camp inmates were killed for the purpose of obtaining their skeletons. Their ghastly remains were found in Strassburg by Allied troops. NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS The transcripts of the Brandt case include the indictments of the following 23 persons all of whom were physicians except defendants Rudolf Brandt, Viktor Brack, and Wolfram Sievers: Karl Brandt: Personal physician to Adolf Hitler, Gruppen- fuehrer in the SS and Generalleutnant (Major General) in the Waffen SS, Reichskoomissar fuer Sanitaets- und Gesund- heitswesen (Reich Conmissidner for Health and Sanitation), and member of the Reichsforschungsrat (Reich Research Council). Kurt Blome: Deputy [of the) Reichsgesundheitsfuehrer (Reich Health Leader) and Plenipotentiary for Cancer Research in the Reich Research Council. Rudolf Brandt: Standartenfuehrer (Colonel) in the Allgemeinc SS, Persoenlicher Referent von Himmler (Personal Admin¬ istrative Officer to Reichsfuehrer SS Himmler), and Min¬ isterial Counselor and Chief of the Ministerial Office in the Reich Ministry of the Interior. Joachim Mrugowsky: Oberfuehrcr (Senior Colonel) in the Waffen SS, Oberster Hygieniker, Reichsarzt SS und Polizei (Chief Hygienist of the Reich Physician SS and Police), and Chef dcs Hygienischen Institutes der Waffen SS (Chief of the Hygienic Institute of the Waffen SS). Helmut Poppendick: Oberfuehrcr in the SS and Chef dcs Pcrsoenlichen Stabcs dcs Reichsarztes SS und Polizei (Chief of the Personal Staff of the Reich Physician SS and Police). Wolfram Sievers: Standartenfuehrer in the SS, Reich Manager of the "Ahnenerbe" Society and Director of its Institut fuer Wehrwissenschaftliche Zweckforschung (Institute for Military Scientific Research), and Deputy Chairman of the Managing Board of Directors of the Reich Research Council. Karl Gcnzken: Gruppenfuehrer in the SS and Generalleutnant in the Waffen SS and Chef des Sanitaetsamts der Waffen SS (Chief of the Medical Department of the Waffen SS). Karl Gebhardt: Gruppenfuehrer in the SS and Generalleutnant in the Waffen SS, personal physician to Reichsfuehrer SS Himmler, Oberster Kliniker, Reichsarzt SS und Polizei (Chief Surgeon of the Staff of the Reich Physician SS and Police), and President of the German Red Cross. Viktor Brack: Oberfuehrer in the SS and Sturmbannfuehrer (Major) in the Waffen SS and Oberdienstleiter, Kanzlei des Fuehrers der NSDAP (Chief Administrative Officer in the Chancellery of the Fuehrer to the NSDAP). 4 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Kaldemar Hoven: Hauptsturmfuehrer (Captain) in the Kaffen SS and Chief Physician of the Buchenwald Concentration Camp. Herta Oberheuser: Physician at the Ravensbrueck Concentration Camp and assistant physician to the defendant Gebhardt at the hospital at Hohenlychen. Fritz Fischer: Sturmbannfuehrer in the Kaffen SS and assist¬ ant physician to the defendant Gebhardt at the hospital at Hohenlychen. Siegfried Handloser: Generaloberstabsarzt (Lieutenant General, Medical Service), Heeressanitaetsinspekteur (Medical Inspector of the Army), and Chef des Wchr- machtsanitaetswesens (Chief of the Medical Services of the Armed Forces). * Paul Rostock: Chief Surgeon of the Surgical Clinic in Berlin, Surgical Adviser to the Army, and Amtschef der Dienststelle Medizinische Wissenschaft und Forschung (Chief of the Office for Medical Science and Research) ^ under the defendant Karl Brandt, Reich Conmissioner for Health and Sanitation. Oskar Schroeder: Generaloberstabsarzt; Chef des Stabes, Inspekteur des Luftwaffe-Sanitaetswesens (Chief of Staff of the Inspectorate of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe); and Chef des Sanitaetswesens der Luftwaffe (Chief of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe). Hermann Becker-Freyseng: Stabsarzt in the Luftwaffe (Captain, Medical Service of the Air Force) and Chief of the Department for Aviation Medicine of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe. Georg August Weltz: Oberfeldarzt in the Luftwaffe (Lieu¬ tenant Colonel, Medical Service of the Air Force) and Chief of the Institut fuer Luftfahrtoedizin (Institute for Aviation Medicine) in Munich. Wilhelm Beiglboeck: Consulting physician to the Luftwaffe. Gerhard Rose: Gcneralarzt of the Luftwaffe (Brigadier General, Medical Service of the Air Force); Vice President, Chief of the Department for Tropical Medicine, and Professor of the Robert Koch Institute; and Hygienic Adviser for Tropical Medicine to the Chief of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe. Siegfried Ruff: Director of the Department for Aviation Medicine at the Deutsche Versuchsanstalt fuer Luftfahrt (German Experimental Institute for Aviation). NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Hans Wolfgang Romberg: Physician on the staff of the Depart¬ ment for Aviation Medicine at the German Experimental Institute , for Aviation. Konrad Schaefer: Physician on the staff of the Institute for Aviation Medicine in Berlin. Adolf Pokorny: Physician, specialist in skin and venereal diseases. The indictment consisted of four counts. Count one charged participation in a common design or conspiracy to commit war crimes or crimes against humanity. The ruling of the tribunal disregarded . this count, hence no defendant was found guilty of the crime charge^ . in count one. Count two was concerned with war crimes and count three, with crimes against humanity. Fifteen defendants were found guilty, and eight were acquitted on these two counts. Ten defendants ' were charged under count four with membership in a criminal organiza¬ tion and were found guilty. The transcripts also contain the arraignment and plea of each defendant (all pleaded not guilty), opening and closing statements of defense and prosecution, and the judgment and sentences, which acquitted 7 of the 23 defendants (Blome, Pokorny, Romberg, Rostock, Ruff, Schaefer, and Keltz). Death sentences were imposed oh defendants Brack, Karl Brandt, Rudolf Brandt, Hoven, Gebhardt, Mrugowsky, and Sievers, and life imprisonment on Fischer, Genzken, Hand loser, Rose, and Schroeder; varying terms of years were given to defendants Becker-Freyseng, Beiglboeck, Oberheuser, and Poppendick. The English-language transcript volumes are arranged numer¬ ically, 1-30; pagination is continuous, 1-11538. The German- language transcript volumes are numbered la-30a and paginated 1-11756. The letters at the top of each page indicate morning, afternoon, and evening sessions. The letter "C" designates com¬ mission hearings (to save court time and to avoid assembling hundreds of witnesses at Nuernberg, in most of the cases one or more commissions took testimony and received documentary evidence for consideration by the tribunals). Several hundred pages are added to the transcript volumes and given number plus letter designations, such as page number 1044a. Page 1 in volume 1 (English) is preceded by pages numbered 001-039, while the last page of volume 28 (English) is followed by pages numbered 1-48. Of the many documents assembled for possible prosecution use, 570 were chosen for presentation as evidence before the tribunal. These consisted largely of orders, directives, and reports on medical experiments or the euthanasia program; several interrogation reports; affidavits; and excerpts from the Reichegesetzblatt (the official gazette of Reich laws) as well as correspondence. A number NATIONAL. ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS of the nedical reports were accompanied by series of photographs and charts of various experiments. The first item in the arrangement of the prosecution exhibits is usually a certificate listing the document number, a short description of the exhibit, and a statement on the location of the original document of the exhibit. The certificate is followed by the document, the actual prosecution exhibit (most of which are photostats), and a few mimeographed articles with an occasional carbon of the original. In rare cases the exhibits are followed by translations or additional certificates. A few exhibits are original documents, such as: Exhibit No. Doc. No. Exhibit No. Doc. No. 301 NO-1314 % 410 NO-158 307 NO-120 441 NO-1730 309 NO-131 443 NO-890 310 NO-132 451 NO-732 357 1696 PS 462 NO-1424 362 628 PS 507 NO-365 368 NO-817 546 NO-3347 403 616 PS No certificate is attached to several exhibits, including exhibits 433, 435-439, 462, 559, and 561. Following exhibit 570 is n tribunal exhibit containing the interrogation of three citizens of the Netherlands. Number 494 was not assigned, and exhibit 519 is followed by 519a and 519b. Other than affidavits, the defense exhibits consist of newspaper clippings, reports, personnel records, Reiahageoetzblatt excerpts, and other items. There are 901 exhibits for the defendants. The defense exhibits are arranged by name of defendant and thereunder by exhibit number, each followed by a certificate wherever available. The translations in the prosecution document books are preceded by indexes listing prosecution document numbers, biased descriptions, and page numbers of the translation. They are generally listed in the order in which the prosecution exhibits were introduced into evidence before the tribunal. Pages 81-84 of prosecution document book 1 are missing. Books 12, 16, and 19 are followed by addenda. The document books consist largely of mimeographed pages. The defense document books are similarly arranged. Each book is preceded by an index giving document numbers, description, and page number for each exhibit. The corresponding exhibit numbers are generally not provided. There are several unindexed supplements to numbered document books. Prosecution and defense briefs are arranged alphabetically by names of defendants; final pleas and defense answers to prosecution briefs follow a similar NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS scheme. Pagination is consecutive, yet there are many pages where an "a" or "b" is added to the numeral. The English-language final pleas, closing briefs, and replies to prosecution briefs of several defendants are missing, as are a few German-language closing briefs and replies to prosecution briefs. At the beginning of roll 1 are filmed key documents from which Tribunal I derived its jurisdiction: the Moscow Declaration, U.S. Executive Orders 9547 and 9679, the London Agreement, the Berlin Protocol, the Charter of the International Military Tri¬ bunal, Control Council Law 10, U.S. Military Government Ordinances 7 and 11, and U.S. Forces, European Theater General Order 301. Following these documents of authorization is a list of the names and functions of the members of Tribunal I and counsels. These documents are followed by the transcript covers giving such information as name and number of case, volume numbers, language, page numbers, and inclusive dates. They are followed by summaries of the daily proceedings providing an additional finding aid for the transcripts. The exhibits are listed in an index, which notes type of exhibit, exhibit number and name, corresponding document number and document book and page, a short description of the exhibit, and the date when it was offered in court. The official court file is indexed in the court docket, which is followed by a list of witnesses. Not filmed were records duplicated elsewhere in this micro¬ film publication, such as prosecution and defense document books in the German language that are largely duplications of pros- __ ecution and defense exhibits already microfilmed or opening statements of prosecution and defense, which can be found in the transcripts of the proceedings. The records of the Brandt case arc closely related to other microfilmed records in Record Group 238, specifically prosecution exhibits submitted to the International Military Tribunal, T988; NI (Nuernberg Industrialist) Series, T301; NOKW (Nuernberg Armed Forces High Command) Series, Til19; NG (Nuernberg Government) Series, T1139; and records of the Milch case, M888, the List case, M893, the Greifelt case, M894, and the Ohlendorf case, M895. In addition, the record of the International Military Tribunal at Nuernberg has been published in Trial of the Major War Criminate Before the International Military Tribunal (Nuernberg, 1947), 42 vols. Excerpts from the subsequent proceedings have been pub¬ lished as Trials of War Criminate Before the Nuernberg Military Tribunal Under Control Council Law No. 10 (U.S. Government Printing Office: 1950-53), 15 vols. The Audiovisual Archives Division of the National Archives and Records Service holds motion picture records and photographs of all 13 trials and tape re¬ cordings of the International Military Tribunal proceedings. John Mendelsohn wrote these introductory reaarks and arranged the records for aicrofilning in collaboration with George Chalou. NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS Roll 4 Target 1 Volune 7 Jan. 30-Feb. 5, 1947 I OFFICIAL RECORD % UNITED STATES MILITARY TRIBUNALS NURNBERG CASE No. 1 TRIBUNAL I U.S. vs KARL BRANDT et al VOLUME 7 TRANSCRIPTS (English) 30 January - 5 February 1947 pp. 2207-2553A ftn 30 January -IWWG-l-l-Grosa - Court Bo. 1 Official transcript cf the Jerrican Military Tribu'd in the oattor of he United States of Jewries, / gainst Karl Brcndt, et al, def -ndants, sitting •A, Numborg, Germany, on 30 Jan* ry 1917, 0930, Justice 3cala presiding. THE 5£A. SKAL: Persona in the Courtfooc will please find their seats. The Honorable, the Judges of Hilitary Tribunal I. Military Tribunal I is now in session. God save thu United States of At.'. rice and this honorable Tribunal. There will be order in tho Court. THE PRESIDENT: Ur. Marshal, will you ascertain that tho defendants nro all present in Court. x THE MARSHAL: May it please your Honor, tho defendant Oborheuser is absent today In oontinurtion of the illness for which sho has been absent several days. The defendant Karl Brandt is also absont, hrving been excused by this Tribunal yesterday corning. THF. PRESIDENT: The Socrotary-Oonr ral will no to for tho record tho presonco of all the dofondants save the doftsnant Cborhousor, absent on account of sickness in accordance with the doctor's certificate »hlch I have, and the defendant Karl Birndt, having been excused by this Tribunal, and tho defendant Brandt's counsol. Tho secrotary-Genoral will file thio certificate in the absonco of tho defendant Oberheusor. Counsel for defense cay proceed with their arguconts. DR. PRIT2 FLDMIW (Attorney for Mrugcwsky): Hr. President: Tho de¬ fendant !!rugowsky is chcrgod in the first place under Count X of the indietcont with a cocnon design or a conspiracy. I shall prevo in respect to this Count that the provisions of Con¬ trol Council Law 3o, 10 concerning amspirccy cn which the Indictment is bnsod on t£^p^nt ^/‘no^npply to th^ case which is hero under review. As a prfc*(onary measure I shall further prove thrt the actual condi- ltions \$£ a conapirrcy arc nco-nxistent. Under Count 2 of the Indictment, -%r Crises, Jlmgcwsky is charged V'-v • 7/ With Hi 2207 30 January! ! 0 *>»l-2-Groaa Court J*o. 1 Sea water anileaide teriiis;ticn cxncrimur.ts and riment Hels, furthermore, chargod under Count 3. Section 11 c l the Ir> With Crises against Humanity on account of the s«ao experiments. LCtnon* In connection with The experiments with Ccint II, 6A of the Indictment Count II, 6C of the Indictment Count II, 6D of the Indictment Count II, 6H of tho Indictment The Prosocuticn in presenting their uvidonco submitted nothing to show that tho defendant Urugowaky had any part in these experimenta. The Prosu- cution did not submit one document nor called one witness to prevo his part¬ icipation in tho said experiments. Tho Indictment ia entirely unsubstant- inted in those respects. It hrs merely been esaortod that tho defendant Urugowaky, togothor with other defendants, ia guilty of a special responsi¬ bility and participation in thoso experiments. ivS regards tho Sterilization experiments Ccunt 2, 61 of tho Indictment Tho Prosocution have merely produced, in crd«.r to charge the defendant Krucowsky, an affidavit of tho co-defendant Rudolf Brandt, dated 19 October 19A6, Document Ko. ULO, Prcsocuticn Exhibit lid. This reads as follows at tho cndi "Blum^nreuther Poppcndick and itrugowsky probably also knew about this.' This is a mere rasusption on the part of Brandt which is given without -223B- 30 Jsnar.ry-M-DJG-l-J-Grcss Court 5c. 1 •rj wore detailed support end without ruference to actuel data and does not therefore constitute a proof of Jrugcwsky's participation in the stcrlizatioi experiments. pass thes_: The Prosecution have neither presented nor given any other proof for Ifrugowsky's participation in sterlization experiments or even only for his knowledge of such experiments. The Iwiictjjcnt against Mrugowsky is therefore inadequate in the points which I have Just aantionod and I move that lust nentlonod. Count II, 6a, C, D, H & I of the Indictaont. And also in regard to III, 11 of tho Indictment. The defendant ilrugowsky is further charged ir. connection with Free ting cxperlcvnta, Count II, 6B of tho Indictaont Sulf&nilan ida .jfperinents. Count II, 6E of the Indictment l»Ki us experiments. Count II, 6J of the Indictment Experiments with poison . Count II, 6K of the Indictmunt Exs-.-rlacnts with lnc-ndlnry boaba. Count II, 6L of thu Indictaont* »&th War Crlr.es and on account of tho srau experiments undor Count III, 11 of the Indictaont with Crimes Against Humanity. On thoso Counts, I shall coll tho defendant Urugowsky and other wit- nossoo to tho witness stand. I shell refer to the evidence given by wit¬ nesses interrogc* .-d by the Prosecution and by co-defendants as wall aa to the evidence of the co-iofer.dar.ts given in the witness stand, 1 shall submit documents and refer to documents submitted by tho Prosecution and co-defen¬ dants. PACE FOUR I shall prove that the so-called Ding diary wes piucod together subse¬ quently and thus is a fake which hea no value as evidence whatsoever. I shall prove that the so-callod work report drawn up by Ding for 19A3, which the Prosecution have submitted, is a draft ifr-lch has no valuo ns evidence. I shall dc «U this ir. order to prove that th<- defendant Ilrugcwsky under -2209- 30 January-li-OJG-l-L-Grcss Court Ho. 1 the counts of the Indie teen t was not a principal in, ar. accessory .to, did not order, abet nor took a consenting pert in, and that he was not connocted with the performance of aedieal exp.riatnta mentioned above without tho sub¬ jects' consent and that he ccanitted neither aurders nor brutalities nor cruelties, tortures, atrocities and other inhuaane acts. % - 2210 - 30 Jan -^l-JP-2-i-^ njrx a - sw Court Ho. 1 Ab regards the freezing experirants I shall prove thr t the defendant Krugowsky had no pert in these exp< riaents at all. The Prosecution have submitted no conclusive evidence of his participation in these experi¬ ments. As regards the sulfanilanido experiments, I shall prove that the defendant Urugowaky was not in any way involved in these experiments. The Proeecution have not claimed that h« took part in tho p«-rfor!»nce of the experiments, and I shall provu that ho had no association whatsoever with the sulfanilamide experiments. A As regards the spotted typhus experiments, the Prosecution have not claimed that Mrugowsky was involved in the experiments vat Katz— weiler. As regards the»ttd typhus experiments at Buchenwald Concentration Camp, the Prosecution have presented comp-ehensive evidence. They havo _ repeatedly claimed that Urugowaky took part in these experiments and Umt he is responsible for them together with others. I shall prove that Urugowaky objected when his superior, Grawitz, for the first time referred to the intention to have spotted typhus experiments possibly perforrrd on inmates of a eoncentration camp. I shall prove that tho experiments cn concentration camp inmates wore ordered against Urugowaky's opposition by Hlrraler and Grawitz. V .rugowsky did not became activoly involved in these experiments, but Dr. Ding was directly instructed by Grawitz to perform the experiments. The Prosecution have not claimed that Hrugowsky took an activo part oven in one singlo spotted typhus experiment. I shall prove that during the whole period during rtiich spotted typhus experiments worn carried out, he was at Buchenwald only twice and not in connection with those experiments but for other reasons. I shall further prove that the spotted typhus experiments which General Taylor himself calls on page 115 of the German record of 9 December 1946, "The nest important but fatal spotted typhus research" were no crime at all 2211 30 Jan 47-H-JB-2-2-fcayi*s- sw Court So. 1 On the contrary, they constituted a research work which had to be carried out uni os a furth-.r hundreds of thousands of non, whose lives could be saved only with the help of these experiments, were to die of spotted typhus. I should prove that the so-called checks introduced in the spotted t: phus serial experiments were unavoidable if the e«id was to be % achieved to obtain quickly a clear idea of the effectiveness of the various vacoinM and drugs. But I shall above all prove through the ovid* nee given by witnesses of the jrosocution that the nuabo* of doe.tha givon in the documents furnished by Ding and presented by the Prosocution is wrong. x As rogards the experiments with poison, the Prosocution mentioned three cases in presenting their evidence: In th# first case which ma carried out upon the initiative of the SS- Tribunal at Buchenwald, it is not quite clear whether the Prosecution intends to charge Prugowsky in the sano way as tho others. I shall prove in this case that he was not lnvolvod. One of the two other cases i» tho killing of six pooplo by poison, mentioned by Dr. Ding in his diary ss "Aspecial experiasnt performed on six persons by order of Vrugowsky and of tho Reich Criminal Polico Office." I shall prove in this case that the I 'rosocution havo failed to give proof that ^rugowsky ordorod this killing or that ho oven know about it. As regards the experiments with poison there remains tho killing of three people at Sacheenhauscn Concentration Camp, on which Hrugow- sky reports in his letter to the Reich Criminal Police Office, dato 12 D-cectocr 19A4, Document No. 201. I shall prove that this was not an experiment to ascertain how ouch time it takes to kill a man in the indicated manner - that is what the Prosecution assert - but an execut¬ ion which had been caused by the Reich Criminal Police Office. As regard the incendinary beeb experiments I shall prove that they were performed by Ding, not by order of Mrugowsky, but by order of other agencies. 2212 30 Jan P-2-3^aynt«- sw Court Ho. *1 and that krugjwaky was not involved in these experiments at all and r/roly received a subsequent report when the experiments ahd been concluded. In eidition to the experiments specifically mentioned in the Indictment, the Prosocution have presented further evidonco concerning a numb r of further experiments which it includes in tho Indictment. I shall prove also in respect to these experiments that l.'rugowsky was not in any way concerned with thee. The erilence which I have mentioned, in connection with war crimes, will also show that Irugowaky has in no way committed crimen against humanity. k’rugowsky does not deny his c«bership in the SS, which was declared a criminal organlzrtion by the Interortional Military Tribunal.. I shall prove, however, that in many questions, scee of which were of decisive importance, he was in open opposition to the SS. In conclusion I repeat ay motion to declare the Indictment against I'rugowsky inadequate insofar as it is concerned with. High altitude experiments 1 'alarla experiments Sea-fater Experiments Experiments with epidemic jaundice. Sterilization experiments concerning exp n rim«fits under Count II 6 • s well i.s Count III 11 of the Indictment. 2213 30 Jan. -U-2-U-PXP- Haynes Court Ko. 1 Dr. 3oehe (Defense Counsel for Defendant Poppendick): Ur. President, seobers of the Tribunal: The defendant Poppendick is cer.tioned in the Indictment as Oterfuehrer in the SS (Senior Colonel) end chief of the Personal Staff of the Reich Physician SS and Police, erri,like all other defendants, he is indicted under Counts 1, 2, and 3, ns well as under Count A cs a .aember of the SS alter 1939. He is charted with special responsibility in the high altitude and freezing experiments, in the mclaria ard sulfanilinido experiments, as well as in soa-watcr experiments one. experiments in respect to epidemic Jaundice and poison, and finally in respoct to sterilization cxvJ ir^.-ndiary bomb experiments. In presenting their evidenco over o period of about four weeks, the Prosecution have sutcittod far acre than four hundred docuaonta, of which only six contain Poppendick's naac in one fora or another. The Prosecution have called twenty-four witnesses bo tho stand and h vo interrogated thorn in groat dotail. Only one witness know Poppendick's naoo. No further cvidonco concerning tho defendant Poppendick was subnittod by the Prosecuticn. Ir. opening tho defense of tho defondant Poppondick, it is necessary to correct tho designation which has so far been used by tho Prosocution in respect to Poppondick whon they called him tho chief of tho Personal Staff of the Roich Physician SS trd Police and to replace it with tho more correct name "Chief of the Porsonal Secretariat with tho Reich Physician SS and Police." a Thi3 is to pro vent at tho outset misunderstandings in respoct to. the position held by the defendant Popoendick. It will now oe tho task of tho defense counsol of the defendant Poppondick to define Poppendick's position with the Roich Physician SS end Police as well as his activity in the medical service of the SS before and after its reorganization in 1913 and furthermore, critically to consider his association with cortain experiments with which ho is charged by tho Prosecution. Although the Prosecution heve in no cose furnished even -??U- 30 Jan. -44-2-2A-PKP- Haynes Court Ko. 1 approximately conclusive proofs that the defendant Poppendick actually ■as the deputy or the assistant of thu Belch Physician SS and Police and had, at such, knowledge of til secrit machinations, the Defense will clear up Poppjndick's activity cs chief of tho Personal SocretatUt, bo it only in the interest of finding tho objective truth. The Defense will then doa^ in detail with the experiments .with which tho defendant Poppundick is associated one way or another *.nd in connection with which h« is represented cs having a special responsibility. Tho five oasential documents which are to be above all the sutfjoct of a more detailed examination end of counter evidence ar«: 1. Cortain entries made in Sicvora' diary of 19U, PS-^546, Prosecution Exhibit 123. 2. Ding's Acridi/w* Publication, no. 582, Prosecution Exhibit 286, which is stamped "No objection free tho point of view of the modicel service by order (sigrv*:) Poppendick." 3. The letter addressud by tho Reich Physician SS and Police to Dr. Ding concerning the research |ono by Dr. Vaom.t I!o. 1300, Prosecution Exhibit 259, bearing thu signature, "By ordur Poppendick." U. Balachcwsky's affidavit No. UBU r Prosecution Exhibit 291, about the ominous supervisory committee in which Poppendick, who is promoted Gruppenfuchrur by tho author, is allugcd to havo beon a musbur. 5. Rascher's ollogod sfnutos on a conversation between Raschor, Grawitz, Poppendick, Concerning thu freezing oeoo sheet, No. 320, Prosecution Exhibit 103. Th« witnesses whoa the defense of tho defendant Poppondisk will call ■ill make their statements „ss4ntiaUy in the form of affidavits. Tho Dofonse plan to call only a few of them to the witness stand. Thu witnesses ■ill testify on the personality of tho defend-nt Poppendick, on his position in thu Race and Settlement H-ad Office, cart with tho Reich Physician SS and Police, as well as on bos association with curtain experiments with ■filch he is charged. As regards the experiments cade by thu Danish physician. Dr. Vaornut, -2215- 30 Jan. L7 -M-2-3A-PIC?- Haynes Court Ho. 1 r.s well as Dr. Din?'a Acridine research and tbeincondiary boob experiments, Che Defense Mill submit expert opinions from medical experts. Although no information has been recuivod un to Cato as to the whereabouts of the witnesses requested by the Defense, it is hoped that at iv".st 3:00 of tho re quo stud witnesses con bo hoard on the questions under review. % Tho Dofonso at any rat* have dono all in tboir power to have tho necessary witnesses nvailabl*. Should, however, apart from tho submission if a few affidavits and other documents, this whole croup of question be ultinatcly dcr.lt with only by the defendant himself as a witness in his own cause or by questioning of his co-defondants, this should not place the Defense at a disadvantage on the grounds th't the evidential value of such atatoaents which are aado undor oath is considered very small. It is certainly possiblo, particularly in this trial, for tho ? -Prosecution to check the credibility of the defendants in respect -2216- Court Jo. 1 30 Jen 47-H-2¥i-£at-Krrrow to their evidence toy confronting thsa end thus U esiist in correctly ecore- ciftic* tho evidence value of their statements. The vvric of tho defense in this trial is c.nsideri toly core difficult thrn thr.t of tho dufense in the trial c^elcst Hermann Ooering and othore. In the foruor proceeding at S^crntoerg the charges cade against tho defendant vero laid down in spwolal trial toriefa and the whole evidence of tho orosc- cution in resoect tc tho individual defendants w B e presented in one case rfter the other. Although Article 4 of Decree Suntoer 7 concerning the oro- cenure fnd coupvtc-nce -f certain military tritoinrls issued toy the Military Oovorn.snt of Ggmeny specifically provides Uat tho indictment should give defense the charges si-.ply, clearly, ind in rifficient detail, the indict- cont in this Case Juntosr 1 against lari Brandt and ethers, and tho whole presentation of evidence toy the prosecution, h»vo refrained f roc specifying in greater dctcil the charges against every individual defendant. Ce the contnry, ir. this trial the crosocuti-r. has presented their evi- dsnes strictly according to tho sutojocts dealt with rnd have not dcflnod in gr enter detail what the charge* against the individual defendants are. Tho.v have considered In each e»So the individual experiments and tho ovidcncc presented in connection with theu cs n whole rnd hrvo only occasionally con* onted upon certain documents concornln; tho dcfondnnts individually. Tho defense thvrwf.re is confronted in this c/se with a certulnly not vory e-sy task critically to appreciate tho individual charges against the defendants, which h vc -nly teen very lovsely or very aporoxi.’J-tely defined. This it Pirtlculcrly striking in the case of the defendant rpcondick. Bis superior, h^ich rhyslclan Dr. Ornvitx, having died, roppcndick is nw to do wfcr-t ho never did during; Ornwitx's lifetine; he is to take his place htre. g-ppeadiek, who v- s never authorised to take Orrwiti'e place and who htd never received ethor covers free his chief, finds binself here in the defendants' dock and is to tc rendered responsible for Dr. Grr”itx's deeds. That et least is whrt the defense supposes they can infer free tho presen¬ tation -f evidence toy the cr jsccuti-n. 2217 Coart So. 1 30 Jen 47-M-C-2-ir>.-Karr -w In view of the evidence so far given, It vill not he difficult fer the defcr.ee to refute the indictment against repnendick or. all ccunte oe unfoun¬ ded, If the renueeted defense witnesses ere cade available and con he heard at iuurnhorg. HR. VilSGiiSIR (Counsellor the defendant Slovcrs): Kr. rresldent, Tour Fos-rs: Cc 1 July 1925 the society "Das Ahnenerbe" vns founded and entered on the registry of associations at the district court in Berlin. Aifi and pur¬ sue of the "Ahnenerbe" wart to conduct research into the language, culture, history, and geography of the Indo-Luropcan peoplte. That ic to say, an institution dovoted purely to research in the literal arts. Koinrlch Hionlar Mid the top position in this socloty; his title was ^resident and Chatreen. Under hin the position of curctor and scientific director was held fr or.: 1921 to 1937 by the crofcssor of the rrc-Hietory of Ideas, Dr. Hernann Virth, Berlin, and frer. 1937 on by rrofceeor Dr. Vclter Vuost of Munich. Under th. ic, in turn, vrs the Central Secretary or, at he was cellod fron 1937 on, the Reich "uslnose Hacagcr. This position v. s hold by Wolfram Slovurs. Frwn 1942 on the society "Das Ahnonorbe" - which until then, although it bed tv.cn under Hixilor'e protection, had teen outside the hierarchy of the loDAr or the SS - became un offico under the haln Offico "rersor.nl Staff of the Rolchsfuchrtr SS". rrofossor Vueet was given the title "Office Chief", vrlie Sievv-rs' title of Reich Business Manager reoalnod unchanged. His ac¬ tivity was and continued to be of a ourely adolnlstrativ® nature. Slev.rs was neither in a positi n to give research assignments, nor war ho rble to interfere in rny way in the scientific part of the croerinonte. The clarification of this ooint soons to oe to urgently noceoscry, in order n.t t- leave uncontested the coaplutoly deviating opinion of defense counsel f-r the defendant Schroecer, asserting that Dr. Eaagen stood in relationship -f subordination to the defendant Sievers. iven before 19*2 the then Oberrrtt of the Luftwaffe, Dr. Beecher, had .tnaged to prv-oote his particularly ambit loos research alas with H tinnier, nothing would have boen aore suitable than for Dr. Sescher's ostensible re- - 2218 - Court SO. 1 30 Ju 47-K-3-2-XSt-Eerrov search work, which hod nothing to do with the literal crt6, than to be in¬ corporated Into the -edlcel service of the SS. Instead, Eiirder incoroor- eted Bcschor's enterprises Into the •Ahnenerbs*. Because Dr. Rnschor't work vts In a suite unreltted field, Slevers cade an attenpt to have Office Chit: fcuest Induce HLtaler to withdraw his order. The intention of Belch Bucincsi Krn>gar Slevers was of no avail due to the passivity of Office Chiof Vucst. la spite -f the apparent hopelessness of the case, Slevers or. hie owr. Inltir tive, nporoached Etc..lor In an attoept to get rid of the undesirable addIt 1 to the Ahnonerte. Ho was unsuccessful. This was the beginning of e devcloyeent, the tragic fclUuur of which Slevers could not suspoct, rnich loss foresee. In the sane year Elnolor created the Institute f-r Military Scientific Research of the Vaffen SS and Bailee. This Institute C-aprisod research projects in which Hlnrlcr vne ccrsonr.lly Interested, almost all of thoa were war-connected; at first they were In oart carried out on behalf of anc. with th« a.sslstrr.co of the Luft¬ waffe. There wns no unlforu scientific direction. HL.nlor issued instruc¬ tions to the hoods of the Individual sections, s.ven of which later car:o Into existenco. The Luftwuffo or the Reich Research Council also Issued orders to Individual Institutes. The heeds of thoso Institutes nude scien¬ tific rep.rts to Hlsnler -r to the Luftwnffo or the Reich Roscrreh Council. The Institute vis financed exclusively free funds of the Veffon SS or the Vehraacht but n-t fr-c funds of the Ahnor.erbc. Hlnnler asslgnod the odnini- itrttlvo duties to the Roich Business Manager of the Ahncncrbc, the defen¬ dant Slevers. This w.ric br-ught Siovors in contact with things which lay exclusively In tho utdlcrl field, doctors carried out cxptrloents of various kinds. Slevers, as a loyman, had to procure :ujtoriale, arrange for laboratories, pay antcys, conduct tho correspondence, end perforu other such ndninistre- tive duties. The prosecution has alleged that Stovers realized the crlr.inality of all the experiments, at least must have realised it. Through the nature of his w-rlc, it is alleged, he was guilty of ccplicity In part of the -2219- Court lo. 1 30 Jan 47-M-3-4-9(-£arr,r crimes vhich are here charged. It vill be my task to shot* and to prove to the Tribunal: first, to what extent the allegation* of the oroeecutlon are Incorrect: second, to vhat extent the activity revealed by the document* vhich hi vo been submitted ves due to Slever'a ovn lntltlativc; and third, when end in vhich experiment* Slaver* realised or must hi ve realised that they were Irreconcilable vlth the rules of vurfare and the principle* of humanity. I shall cuito openly present the projects which Siever* realised were Illegal and erlclnal. Thu* ve heve oone to the ouestlcn: If Slovers rea¬ lised that certain experiment* were orInInal, then why did ho not l:icedlatcl give up hi* position as Reich easiness .uineger of the Ahnenorbo and his work in the Institute for Military Scientific Roseaxch. Why did he not oppose Hi"ffll©r's ln*ar.o and criminal orders? Vhy did he do nothin/; to prevent people*t suffering ohyslcol ham, often -f the noat severe kind, or oven losing their lives in experiments? This second pert of ay defense will bring ae into the field of aotivitj ,t n vary considerable group of the German rvclstir.ee movement which during the war undertone to -verthrow Hitler's Reich by violence. The prosecution has examined a number of foreign witnesses before this Tribunal, who had beer. arrested as members of n resistance group in tholr own country end sent to German concentration camps. They were there placed In the category of persons condemned to death. Today these dotoralnod end uncompromising fighters for freedou In their homelands ore celebrated ae heroes. Today no ono asks whether theso brave tnd ferrlcse fighters conalt- ted deeds vhich, objectively considered, were irreconcilable with tho rules of warfare or with the lows of buurnity. They are not called to account before a tribunal, and vhy not? Because everything that they did In the struggle against tho enaoy power was done out of ardent love for their * % homeland, for their fatherland. Thus everything vhich they did Is stripped jI Illegality end legalised. £ 220 - .. J-JX. -/ -4f-d-l-P£r- Ku .porstoir. Court No. 1 In Germany, too there existed, from 1933 on, a constantly increasing resist'nc- movt-sont a.ainst National Socialism, the grave-digger of the Gcrsrn Raich. Sine- all the powerful resources of the st-to and Party wore ruthlessly employed -tr.inst everyone who opposed the National Socialist re glee, the stru ^lc c"-inst this n^ime wes subject to its own lews. Uor. ■ho wore willin-; to toko the utmost risks hid to penetrate the positions of thair political opponents in order, under various foms of cam-uflagu, to uni-mine these positions .am in painfully detailed work to make th- prep¬ arations require- for on ' raed uprising against n superior eneny.^Ono of th.su men was Kolfrna Silvers, whom a tragic fat* has mado a defendant in this trial, Mien Silvers, in the trial of Gowring and others, proclaimed hia membership in a resistance movement. Court and Prosecution were extremely skeptical of this assertion. Then, wrs at that time no occasion to exmd.no hia st’t-sents. But in the pr-sent trial Siuvcts oust bo r.iven tho oppor¬ tunity, ir. his own defon*-, to prove that as early as 1931 a croup which was strongly o^poa-d to National Socialism deliberately sent hia into the NSDAP In >rder to jot a- auch insight os possible into this Party. From 1933 an he w-irko., on behalf of tile resistance iroup, taw; rd cuning into contact with tho highest P rty authorities. This goal w^s achieved when, in 1935, ho succeeded in bocomin. Business llirva^or of the Ahnwnerbo. Thus, ho had penetrated to the entoura.-o of the Keichsfu.hror SS and tho Police, Himnlor, who united in his hands all instrum-nts of powo: within tho state. There be n a period of great tension then. SieVers bad to avoid carufully any¬ thing that might have brought him under suspicion of being opposed to tho National S-cialist re_imo. If he wanted to .achieve his goal, ho had to -ttcin to the circle of Hinder'a confid nts. Ir. 19^.2, Siovers was confronted with fateful decision, wn-n, through Kixilcr's order, ho come in contact with the wretched human experiments. Should ho, xiwn ho r-cogniz.d in this case or that the ille^lity of the -xperinor.ts which Kinder ordered, rufuse to continue to perform his duties in any fora? Kith his friends from tho resistance coveawnt, ho deliberated whnt was to be done, '.ould tho human vxperic-nts bo stopped, if hia oppo¬ sition was express-. more or less clearly? Sever. hould the resistance -i-ul- 30 J-ru 47 -1S-4-2-PKP- XuppersUin Court Ko. 1 aovacjnt ".gainst the fctiooal Socialist regime, in the determined prepara¬ tion of an overthrow by violence, lose in Sieves one of its cost important exponents? los. Therefore the ■—clsion was th t Sievors had to run.-.in at his oo8*. In consistent execution of those instructions Sievers therefore had to raster the duties whicS were assigned to him - the execution of which node enormous doonrvds on his spiritual resistance in such a way th't thore could be no suspicion of a hostile attitude. There thus arose for Sievers the undeniable necessity of performing what administrative dutios fell to his lot by virtue of his position, even in his contact with the human experiments. Through witnesses nnl affidavits, including a numbor of members of foreign r-siatrnco movoeonts whose Uv,s Sievers saved, I shall prove to the Trlbunr.1 1) that tho resist.nee mov^a-nt to which Sievers belonge . was of c-nsidor-blc import-now, 2) th't Sievers as an exponent of this movomont was of great impertanco in the Rulehafuohrung SS, 3) th't Sievers had mado preparations f.r an ttack on Hitler and Kl-aaler, the execution of which, however, was erde impossible by th- -.ction taken by the officers' group and the situ tio:i wider. followed the uncucc-ssful ttack on 20 July 1944, 4) that Silvers, in tho execution of the duties which devolved upon him by virtue of his position, did n. c-.-r\> than he had to do to carry out the orders given him. I intend to c* U five witnesses; two of them will testify to the activity of the Defendant Sievers, ns Roich Business Uansgor in connection with cun- n<»- *- -ric s .tit, w^ich ho is charrod, two other witnesses will testify to tl» inpAr».an.*A *f the resistance novoaont, and one witness will testify to Silvers* activity within the resistance aoveoont to which ho belonged. Kin- lly, I intend to c 11 th- Ocf-nier.t Si_vors himself to the witness stand, and X sh .11 examine several of the c.*-evfondanta on individual points. I hope th t 1 shall thus be r.bU to give tho Tribunal the nocoss: ry evidence for e jud-m-nt which will do justice to tho spe-cial situation in Sie-Vers* case. ER. FRITZ (Counsel for the defendant Rose): Ur. President, Your Honors: The defendant professor Dr. Gerhard Rose was appointed vice—president of the Robert Kcch Institute in 3crlin in 1943 a research institute of worldwide fame for the cantr-1 of contagious diseases, after Itu nsd boon a momber of 30 Jan. 17 -U-m- 3-FKP- Kuppurstein Court So. 1 this Institute tlrcady, sir.co 1936. In 1939, at tix, beginning of thi war he was drafted into tho Gorman ehnsaeht is conaultir^ hygienist -nd tropical hygienist with tho Chief of tho -ouic' 1 Service- of the Gorarn Luftwaffe. At first ho w*a given tho rnnk of Obcrarzt of tho reserve cn was finally pr'-aotod on 1 ^oy 1915 to tho rnk of eunomlf-rat of tho n-sorve - I wish to emphasize: of the rcoohvo. Perhaps it could bo asked, whether the defendant Rose attained the hi. h position jf vice-president :.nd the high military rank because of his— if onLy nominal — membership in tho KSDAP. or because ho is "one of tho most eminent scientists" in the fields of hy L i-nc and tropic: 1 medicine ‘ s he was intro- uce: to Your Honors by General Taylor in his opening speech -f 9 D-roia- ber 1916. The further evidence in this case will show that the letter is tho answer. .,t first it is th. t sk of the defense to make clear 1) whether nl haw Rose- Ms fillc ! the position of Vice-president of the Libert Koch Institute an* 2) ’..h t w.re his tasks, authorities, : nd competencies, in his position as consultirv hygienist and tropical doctor with tho chief of the medical department of the Luftwaffe. Thin clarification will show: r.) thet R.se, despite his hi : h position as vice-president n\ despite his hirh military rank which he finally tt-lncd, i’ not tnko p-rt in ilanninr or in carrying out the experiments 'n‘. measures indictod h.ro, nor b) that he was the superior cither in tho civil field or in the Wehraacht of persons who participated in planning ~nd carrying out those experiments rnd measures. In the indictment professor Rose is charged with special responsibility for war crim-r or/d crim-s a ainst humanity which are considered as such in th experiments of human beings -ith typhus -nd other contagious diseases in the concentration camps Bach-nwald and .Natzwe-iler and in the alleged experiments or. human beings with hepatitis epidemics in the concentration camps Sachsen- nausen and K'tzweilcr. iirst, as far as the hepatitis epidemics experiments arc conccrncl, 1 -2223- 10 Jon. *fl feu, — Court Ho. 1 ay -lrcady r.o* dry■ the attention of th* Tribunal to the fact that the nomo R 2 sc 'io- £ n-t appo-r at nil in document book Ho. 8 autcitted by the prosecution in correcti r. with this matter. Rose did n-t participate in the hepatitis re¬ search and core over states tfc, t he had no knjrl»!gu of these alio go'I hepatitis experiments. In the further course of this case I hope to be able to prove tho accuracy of tho Icfamlant Rose's st tekent. «a for as the typhus experiments an- concerned, it is true that Rose - tnouih ho never w-rked on typhus - if only just -nee - was in Buchorwald whxla tsuSe experiments "ere boiog corriee out. I believe to bu able to prove beyond boubt ttat this visit to the concentration crxp Buchenwald was not aade because Rose was ccncorncJ with - or even approved of these experiments but ttat, on the contrary, this visit was connected with his fundamental ob¬ jection to ouch experiments or. huc;n bein s, "hich led to several protests by t!.o ’.efeniant Rose. The witn-ss Kogan has already forcibly drawn out attention to this. .'J-.r can it bo denied that in tba c-urae of ita presentation f vi -nco, the prosecution ms produced eoiae Jocusents -.nd hoard acou witnesses fr^n which a layman could coucludo *. certain connection of the dufondant Rose with tho experiments of human beings in 3uche-nwald -nd Jh.tswoilor. Thus ”r. Hardy, f r example, submitted docunont K>-1 22 - a letter by Pro- f-'caor Rose- to ?r-fess.r Hi.'ima id ted 3rd December 1943 "ith this rosurvr.tion soyin* tint he expected an explanation from Professor Rose. I hopo to bu able to offer this requested explarrtlon to the High Court in tho course of ay presentation of .videnee not only concerning this document but also con¬ cerning other existing corn.sooneunco, in a sense favorable to tho defendant Rosa. In the course of its oral statement rcgr.rdine tho extent of the- accus-tiona against Rose, as contained in the indictment, the prosecution has oven gone beyond those contained in the indictment. Thu3, it has also connected hie wit;. ti>c malaria experiments by Professor Schilling which the latter carried out in the concentration coop of Dachau. It was evidently led to this because of the frequently recurring -2224- 30 J n. L7 -X-U- 5-PKP- Kupperstcin Court Mo. 1 of Rose in Iccunents connected with Schilling's experiments in Dachau. Fro prosecution has in the first instance overlooked tho fact that Professor .•.■-so ia o aelnrln expert of intern-tionsl repute and it is hardly in* .inrblu t..’ his a'jti woul not be nur.tione: when experts arc discussing malaria. Over -.ru ".hove this I hope to be able to prove th.t tho defendant Rose - who •.ltojethor ro joe ted Schilling's research net hods quite apart from his experi¬ ments in Dachau - alsi hurt, st n:s wron.fully accused. The last v-sti^o of doubt abeut -this will bo ruaoved wh~n in cy presentation of evidence, I ccno to speak about the sanitorius of Pfaffunroco, where the dependent Rose on his part conducts’ a-laria experiments and used ralflrla therapy up to the arrival -f tho Aoeric ns. 30 Jan 1x7 -M - 5-1 - LJG - lesser finally, Pr feesor Rest, as well as all cf his cc-defendants, arc accused of having ..articipated in a consjiracy to cocnit war crimes and critas against humanity according tc Count I of the Indictment. The prosecution sees proof of the existence of such a ccns,.iracy especially in the repeated meetings of the consulting ;hysici;jis luring the war at the conferences ef she consulting specialists at the alii tar y tactical academy. I shall prove that the defendant Rose, as far as his . a-ticipation in such conl^rences is concerned, and in other respects, can on no account ta considered a conspirator, iu.it.tr as a L-ador nor os cr^anizwr nor os initiator or abettor. For it is Just his attitudo, be it at such a conference, be it at a meting of proainent physicians, or be it towards the Reich health leacer Dr. Ccnti, cr towards the president of tho R-bert Kcch Institute, Professor Gildwneistur, which shews that there can be no question of this. Ir. the c-urse of ay presentation of evidence, I plan to examine tho defendant Rose on his own case, to .resent various dc/cunor.ta and affidavits as exhibits t. the Tribunal and finally t question sovoral witnesses and ex; «rts. DR. S..UTER (Counsel for tho Defendant Dr. Slogfriod fluff): Oentlcmen of tho Tribunal, I hav. njw tho task of submitting to you in what manner the Defondant Dr. Ruff Intends to conduct his dufonse: I) The subject cf the indictmnt ajvinst Dr. Siegfried Ruff deals kjroly *..lth his . rticipntion in tne hi h altitude ex.-crioents carried out in Dachau, as thoy iro explained in D cuaont Bock 2. N further count f the ir ictent mentions Dr. Ruff, except for tho question of "Conspiracy." Consequently, the lefar.so cn its part, con linit itself U doalirv* with these Dachau hi-h altitude e;c eriwnta. II) The Ctz f Dr. Ruff* a dafons* will be tc establish the fell owing fac ts: 1) Tho hi h altitude or criaents carried out in Dachau by Dr. Runberg and Dr. Reactor with the a.prjval cf Dr. fluff were necessary for the clarification of the roblea cf "the rescue cf airplane crows fror high & - 2226 - 30 Jan U7-M - 5-2- LJ3 - altitudes.” 2 ) Th& 3 « uxparlaents were prepared in an unobjectionable scientific ^mi»r 07 Dr. Huff and his associate. Dr. Roricrg, and were executed in an un-bjecticnafcle sinner by Dr. Rcoberg. 3) While carryirv out t-:ose experiments, Dr. Ruff knew that tbs only exporinsntal sublets usee for that purpose w*re Goman convicted criminals, who voluntarily r ut the.-sclvos at his disposal and who, as a reward f;r undergo!^ these ex crinents, were suosequently to bo pardoned. Dr. Ruff nods certain -f t. ese facts at the tine by askinj various participating ex erinental subjects. h) Dr. Ruff .!id n-t kn ». Dr. Raschor closely before the Dachau hlji altitude ex.erijauntc. Ho was at that tine introduced ta hiia by an absolutely reliable Scarce and considered hit to bo a conscientious physician of tno L»iftwaffo. 5) Bvhind Dr. *V.^erg's back, this Dr. Raschor proceeded to carry cut still other ex.oriroents, t. which Dr. Ruff never (1 vo his c.nsont and which he would never have approved hid he boen asked. 6) These other experiiasnta of Dr. Raschor were in no way connected with the parachute descent «x. -rirwnta carried out by Dr. Ruifcer,;. Dr. Ruff and the Goman ~ir F rce wv.ro n t at all interested in these wthor expvriaeots f Dr. Roschor's. It was only in the course f this ..resent trial that Dr. Ruff f-unc. ut in ootail with what th*so 3 .-called "oxpori-xnts" of Dr. Raschor w„re concerned. 7) .'hon Dr. Huff heard thr u-* 1 report by Dr. HcntosTg that a fatality hia .ccurroc iurin those additional, that is to soy unauthorised, ex; arinents f Dr. -aschor, he (Ruff), ordered that these experiments be 9 discontinued and had the 1 w- f rcs*ure charier returned fron Dachau to Berlin, an ‘ he prevented having the low-pressure charier ,;ut it their di» pusol durin the subsequent period, althuu.ii Dr. Rascher and various hi.;h 35 offices repeatedly requested the return cf the charier to Dachau for the purpose if carrying out further .or.erinents. -2227- C urt Ho. I >0 Jan 1*7 - X - 5- 3 - LJG - Us^r 8 ) Dr. ?- ff Is a serious and ccoaei««t1 •dentist# -as "iH be confiroed by all witnesses. He is herd cn hinsclf but considerate towards his ax^orir.er.tal subjects. His attitude was, cn principle, that hu would carry out his ex erinents in the first r lxo an himself and with the voluntary associates of his institute. 9) Beth before and after the experiments at Dachau, Dr. Ruff, t ether with his associates, carried out cruntluss experiments on him- sulf which, f;r tho a.st port, were r r« un;-asant fron a subjoctivo .int f view, and a ro dan arcus frc.a an objective point cf view, than th s j va erinents at Dachau of which Dr. Ruff knew and which he authorized. Ill) Dr. Ruff intends t.uao thu f^U win: as ovidonco: Altogether no has applied f r 17 witnesses, all of when wore granted by the Tribunal. Frco r.ost f theso witnessos affidavits are already available, which will bo submitted in tho Drcunont Book Dr. Ruff. I assune that tho Prosecution, t , o reus to tho submission A thoso affidavits. Tho naturo cf tho tosti- xny -f the witnesses has been accurately described in tho applications subnittod t the Tribunal. with ref-rosice t. tw wf these witnesses, naouly thu twi .owricans, Dr. . od and Dr. Bal.es, b- th f wh *i arc n w in rcsidin in tho United Jtat^s, I havu submitted qu-sticnnairos n the 13th f January 19li7, vhich ore t be, answered by the “b vo-nonticned ,ors.ns in thoir capacity os witnesses or/d ox r _rt5 and which, t ether with tho c-nsvorc, I intend t. r^ad int tho roc rd as seen as they will hove teen rocoivod. with reference t a furtner African citizen, Ccl n.-l Benf rd, I havo a, plied .n the 15th of January 19U7 t. .fctnin a statement of s«rvicos rendered and a ors tial evaluation of the Defendant Dr. Ruff. From tho autunn of 19U5 until the autvem of 19U6, Dr. Ruff was e^ lcyed -»t on Institute in Hoidolber*, * »hicb CcVnel Ba.f :d w« tho obiof. I intend to h-ar only twr witnesses in person here in the witness stand, namely the witnesses Dr. ,fxlt*r Freitag and Kiri Fchlnoister, far when I a plied as witnesses cr. Dscectoer 13 and January 9 respectively, and wh so oxaainaticn in court has been granted by the Tribunal. If, t r C.Tart !L. I X> Jta U?-b -5-i; - LJ3 - lesser 3 ny reason, the personal appearance cf these witnesses before this Tribunal cawwt be carried cut, then the Defendant Dr. Ruff is reserving far himself the right t: submit affidavit# frem these two witnesses also. The Defendant Dr. Ruff will sis toko the stand hitnsolf, in order to be ©xanii*i as a witness. It appears su table f-r this to bo done nef.ro the ther witnqpaea are called, so that Dr. Ruff can make tho necessary explanations regarding the technical details f his ex.urlswnts. The laymen, too, will then be in c bettor petition to understand and aj reel ate tho teettn-ny of tho witnesses regarding these technical questions. % In tho course f the direct oxaeiruticn «f Dr. Ruff, I intend to hovo a short fila, which had been made in tho institute of the Defendant Dr. Ruff at tho tiao, shewn to tho Tribunal. Th- purp so of this film io U onrble the Tribunal and tho Fresocution to take thoir own c'oclairna about the high-altitude oxperinJTits carried out by Dr. Ruff, in particular in regard t^ tho character and effects of tho so-ctiled "high-altituclo- oickncss," in rdur to enable tho Trib nal to sake its findings as to whether this "higlw.ltitudo-sickncss B can bo considered under tho huading of a crino against humanity. IV) «a I have already ountionod, Dr. Ruff is acouaod of special roa, onsibility by the FT socution an ono count nly, that of tho hi.h al¬ titude ox, oriconts at Dachau. It has n,t boon alleged by the Pr. socution that Dr. Ruff had in any way ; ortici;-ted in ther ox, orinonts at Dachuu,— for instance, in the freezing experiments .f Dr. Rascher. H.wovor, ho has ala beer, indictee fr:a the point I view f conspiracy. In this respect the case f:r tho Fr socution is in nr way specialized and is not sup; rtud by any evidence. -lroady tc<^y, on the strength of the evidence submitted by tho prosocution, it is an established fact that Dr. Ruff, apart from tho hi-gh-altitude exporirants in the s. ring f 1 ?L 2 , had nc contact what¬ soever, no natter f what nature, with Dr. Rascher .r with the SS or with tho concentration crops. Particularly ho wjj never a number of the SS cr any -ther affiliated organ: zation of ti* Party, which war connected with such exporioonts. During the period dealt with in this trial. Dr. Ruff -2229- 30 ssibiUty of punishnunt frr [ art\ci,.ation ir. a conspiracy only in cases _f criao3 against. .oace. Iheref- re, this rule is to bo regarded os lex s.eciaHs and cannot sickly be extended to war crines •ux' ciiaes a.alnet hunanity, n which tho entire chare is bain; based. -2231- 30 Jan M-Ji*-6~l-Cook- m» Court So. 1 b) Ths deforciant, Dr. Reno erg has never been a asnbcr of any of the organizations declared as criminal b the ElT, he was not even a nenber of the Luftwaffe. c) From the evidence presented it does not in any way appear that the charge in question is based on facts. 2) With reference % to the charge cade is to participation in high altitude experiments, it is to be stated: a) That is was not the purpose of the high altitude experiments in question to investigutv and I quote: "The limits of huar.ft endurance and existence at extreme high altitudes', and that those experiments % were conducted properly. b) It is further to bo stated that the experimental subjects used in those oxp irioeots - re criciorls, condemned to by ordinary courts, o had volunt*« n-d rnd who wore to bo pardoned rs a reward; c) That Dr. Rocb-rg was, at first, to considor Dr. Rnsch* r, whom ho got to know only at the b-22 2). Tho prosecutor states that Welts also received information about deaths subse¬ quently. Tho witnesses Luts and Hoff woro to give testimony to prove this, but their statements did net really implicato tho defendant. As regards tho high~altltude experiments, the prosecutor draws the following conclusion frcri thus. It Is true that Welts did not actively participate in experiments, but ho obtained export assistants for Rrscher, who was not convoreant with high- altitude rosoarch (German Transcript p. 222). 3. F reezing Sxperlaents ; V?elts is known as the real discoverer of tho freezing problem md was aware at trn early date of tho scientific investigation cf it through animal experiments. Konco his basic experiments on small animals, anil also the experiments on shaved cats which were treated with irony by Rancher. Himnlcr : s offer of an opportunity to experiment on human beings did not seem attractive to him, not to sperjr of his basic repudiation of experiments on human beings. A co—responsibility of Wolts for tho freezing experiments, which only began in May 1?A2, that is, long after Raschur's dismissal from tho assignment, • cannot seriously bo considered. Therefore, the prosecutor could present hero only cne single fact. In Document .Vo. 3A3 a-PS, a letter from Milch to holff. Milch notes the conclusion of the altitude experiments in Dachau and suggests going over to freezing experiments which Waits wr.s ordered to carry cut. Fer this purpose Raschcr could be mode available in the future. I shall prove through witnesses that this order was n,vor given. - 2233 - 30 Jenuaiy-»J-Dv , G-7->-&fcahan Court Nc. 1 n. Tho charge against heltz is not complicity, but instigation and assist¬ ance. Belts is alleged to have given Kascher tho idea of making experiments cn hussar, beings and afterwards to have helped him in their execution. These accusations ore in no small measure tho results of tho one-sided and noticebly prejudiced affidavits by Brandt, Ruff, end Romberg, Lutz also i3 not cn un¬ objectionable witness, as he is politically too implicated by his SS member- ship. H«. thereforo avails himself of every opportunity to make hlhsolf appoar in a core favorable light. In reputation of tho statements cf tho prosecution I shall prove through documents and witnesses: 1 . Holtz had nothing whatsoever to do «sith Rancher's assignment to his Institufio. it was net '.idtz but Stabsirzt Kottonhoff, cf Luftgau VII, who gave tho lecture cn tho aonkoy experiments. Tho suggestion to mukc experi¬ ments in the future, not on monkeys, but or. two or threo habitual crisinols can therefore only have been node by Kottenhoff. I shall substantiate this through presentation of a reprint cf Kottonhoffs article in tho magazine VLuftfchrtsaedizin" (/.victicn Uodldno) and through witnesses. 2 . Raschor’a aasigneent tc Holtz' Institute tcok plrco at his own insistence and with the support of Kottenhoff. Ranehor wishes to establish hiuself in Halts' good grocos." Cutsido of thu text, may I h^re dorr up t misunderstanding end a foloc translation into the English language? To habilitate, according to thu German concept, that is to gain permission to be an active lecturer in tho German Higher School. Hew, I continue with the text: ,: 7he- experiments cn human beings that Hinder peniittud him to carry out wore to assist him in tils, heltz, however, repudiated th«, proposed experimental research, the gradual ascent to nigh-altitudes and tho freezing experiments. The reason for this will bo seen in .itltz' basic negative attitude toward freezing experiments cn human beings, •3 set forth by nc under 1, 3. I shall further prove thrt heltz, on the occasion cf Hippke's visit -2236- Court No. 1 in the succer cf 1911 ex p l i citly, stated to him that experiments or. human beings were to be nedo only in the nest pressing cases and only cn criminal prisoners serving long terms. These prisoners would have to nake themselves available voluntarily, end be rewarded by a termination or shortening of their sentence. ?. Thus hoscher*a assignment to i.elts frea the late suiter cf 1>U U the beginning of torch 19L2 meant absolutely nothing. Rascher went to lAjnich only soldca, without visiting the Institute. Therefore., in fulftUm-nt of his official responsibility, Wdtz ordered Rascher to report xwaca *<.vi.0y < shall prove that the second time he reported, Rascher produced a telegram frea Hinalcr stating that ho should keep the experiments secret from ovtryona, ovon Kelts. I shall further produce witnesses to prove th-t Kelts discharged Rascher at thet very timo and rujuastud his ianudietu transfer back to the Luftgau, at the beginning of Uarch 19L2. On the brois of document No. 310 I shall prove that dready in this letter Rascher appears after 16 torch 19L2 as member of tho Ruff-ftccborc-Rascher uxpcric to.tlmny or .1 too.to., lootoont., tlto, cud oy. vltto.ooa and al.o by .boolhi th. til. , "Ieh Kla... in-, -I acouao", to preva tto roUo«l.u. and too. hlo sr.no' lira and to" hi. onto « iatotM la la. no asylum. Thl. lo to adlltloaal port of :.y text. 1} ~r-cl: va-hau la the Fuehrer's Ch-^collory ns syoOinliat for II, "huro It w Li a function to h>udlo 'll cor.plnlatn r M 1 a?porls cSdroMod iiroetly to tho fuehrer * y.orhous free. nXL - lies of life, rad to mxfelt then to Rolchnlolto. aouhlor for hi3 decision. In addition to thw duties Brno* .to Instructed by aolohsloltor Bouhlor In 1939 to assist hlr. In tho ttohnlc.nl nron.-r-.tlm or sack to-s.ro. »oro require in tho oreeutlon or tho task th-.t ritlor had aral n»l to Douhlor; th-t 1. ohort- onln* tho worthlos. liras or Incur-’ ly Insane roroons, attar nost critical “•fi¬ ns,!,. by s-toirlc-.il-, d»lto-tod doctor., and In tho technical preparation or t osoutlon of tb.so mantas. Brack Wt no doubt., nftor tho dwUimnt of Cor an lu» slue 1933. a. to tho constitutional loyalty of idolf Hitler's 30 Jon .;7->'-?JC-8-2-niMtuok Court HO. 1 directives. Brock cvrie- ut tho instructions 3i~cn hin and bin other duties la his ca"'city rs mx ivtiinistmtlvo official soborllnftto tc Bouhior nai subject to tho isdlTMud instructions of noichaloitor Scuh.er, with no indepondant power to tako :*cisians. * Dmck hr.I nr coatcct whntaoovor .:1th any of tho lofondonts who mrs rinaninc cr pro^rin.' a - or cri^a or a srU-J against humanity. Only with tho lufoadont Karl Brandt Hi ho hero o few =r loos incidental conforoncoe, the purpose of which, hovovor, was not tho erosion of war crlx^o cr orluoa against hu-ianity. 2) Tho tack whth which Hoicholoivor Bauhlor oatrustol Zrcck lnvolvod only lacura-ly liwerui parsena. Brack h-d nothin te It tilth :-o-suroa deal, nod to shorten tho llvos of dofer-ai chlliron (whioh was within tho coi:potonco of tho so-callol nolsh cu.hsslon for tho Surroy of Sorious cr lahorltod ,Vff notions"), nor with :on«uros offoctlnc inour-Uo invalids in f.onoral. Tho task oasi r.,! to '.mck involvod only Gor nn ins r.o arsons, oxcluoing joroona wounlod in tho -i at "orId ~or and industrial ccsualtloa. It did not lucludo forol n anti wilr, ;articularly tho-o of natlora at war with Oonmny, ut r. th. 11 -rty Editors ind J«bb livinc la Oonany. Brock rnva cloto atu’.y to vrltia;:* cn tho probl*. nf shortonln^ tho oorthloaa lives of Inc irmly Insane parsons, '.dtlch has boor. disputed for conturl.8 y physicians, Jurist.-, philosophers, scientists, and ordinary dtisoac, and, for othical reasons and on the b sis of a carefully fon od e.iarlotio:i derivlu. fr ; his n icperloncoa, education, spiritual oriontr.tion, an! poraonai. study, aneworo 1 la tho affir.*tivo tho question, which oonofi up in connection vith tho abovo-iantionad probiu;, as to tho Justification of euthanasia in such cases. -22L2- 30 Jan 1-Putty - sw Court So. 1 Brack did not participate in the other oxteraln.tion naaauroa .ith which the Prosecution charge, hin, *ich -ere directed against G.r=an= and ncn-Con=n, through a clause of the organisational apparatus that Bouhler^had created. 3.) Never in hie life was Brack's attitude anti-Oocdtic. On the contrary, in .any cases he interceded in the interests of Jews even at the *nger of personal detriment. Consequently, Brack became an cn«y of Hcydrich and Bcrran. Just before the end of the war at the instigation of Boroam he was even sentenced to. death by a ciUtary court nartial. And I continue with cy original text: Cons' cucntly Brack was dismayed by his progressively clearer recog¬ nition of the radical intentions and extenrlraticn plans embraced by Hitler and hi' advisors. Prsek wicked to frustrate thsso plana st »11 costs, for lids purport, .busier th. confidence h. -uOd-sd, h. attaopted to indues th. ran in th. on itrol to adopt «ana and roo.dura which apparently ore raised success but Which actmlly , according to the state of rasesrch st that tic, hod to bo regard* .. urtlsss. and ot any rat. .Me . succssoful affliction of those plan. iapcaibl. for a con.ld.rnbi. ported of tic. This is th. origin of Brack' . correspond¬ ence with and sterilisation prop,sal. to influential person, in th. govemennt xn 19U — WM. Brack's activity In the., year, will, in the light of the evidence that the defense will produce, take on nn essentially different psychological aspect fr«. that which tho Frosecution has pr sented. Brack did not furnist ooraonnel for the extonslnsticn of *»>- U.) in -ha spring of 1MZ Brack volunteered for sarvios at th. front with. th. vaff.n SS bacauso, after tho failurt of hi, effort. and realizing that the radical tendency -a, now irresistible, he did not wish to fe. associated with or even to cos. into contact -ith an activity that seared to have criminal tendencies. 30 Jan ,.7-!<-S*-3-2-?x.cty- sir Court Ho. I Fa transferred to the troops In ignorance of facts Going to prove that trn SS was used for crinirnl activities, That is th- end of fay staterents. DR. UARX: Ur. President* your Honors, I ar. now beginning the opening state;.«nt for the Defendant, Dr. Becken-Freyseng. The Prosecution charges the f error Stabsarst of tW Uiftwaffe Reserve , Dr. Hermann Beckeiwriyseng, first, to have participated in a conspiracy and a .'oint plan to coreit crines against humanity and war criors. Those crises are alleged to have been ccomitted under camouflage as so-called scientific, eedical txperiuenta. Tho indictment thereby was based on tho assumotion that in the execution of individual exporters or a»riaa of experiments sovoral of the here present defendants or the age.-icles they ropre*A>ted at that time had taken part or were interested in th; or should have had knowledge of theta. However, the Prosooution did not leave any doubt that in Its opinion the carry ns out of so-called radical experiments "as only a pretext to dc h'-rm to anomies of tho Kaal State, to torture them, even to exterminate them. Tho Chief Prosecutor, General Taylor, dovotod * nAjor pox-tion of his ??y t i 30 Joo-H-OES-9-ty Court ». 1. addraei before the High Tribunal la iononstrating that the basis for such a B conspiracy vero the doctrines of the Sat local socialist Goman Vorkore' Party (HSH 1 P) particularly In regard to the race question, and that also tho personal basis of tae cruel cad abominable crimes le to bo found In thoso characters vto frooly foil for tac rosults of those slogans about 3 oco and Stutu, vita out Inner ties vita and religious consideration, true cortical calling;, genuine science, and tan tornal hua-a v.luos. That is th- plcturo of tho conspirator vhicn ta.. Prosecution dovelopod boforo our oyos. 2) In contrast to th t. Counsel for tn« Defendant, Dr. Bockor-?roysong, will ntto-pt to prove tn-t the latter, r.e a rornlt of his aduc'.tlon and his con- copt of cue nodical profession, as v.ll ns h&s general philosophy, for tho factual results of *.lc.; vu vill offer evidence. is really unablo to show •uca attitude. ,u) Co-lng froa a Christina family. Dr. Bockox^Troysong prosorvod his r.liglouo attitude nt later tli.es also as n etudont. as a husband and fiuilly father, ho did not abandon his Christian posltloh. ovia at a tlco when uany Geruuxs broke vita church and religion, cor. ly as a natter of oxpodicncy. in accordraco vita tho P««rty trend, and left the church. b. ) neither did ho belong as a studont to the Bngi studonts ‘.seoclatioi r.or did he belong, ns n physician nod young academic te-caer. to the V\tl Fhyslclans ^seociution >r the Hi.tl •.crdo-ic 7v chore Longue; only In serious scientific vork und evrvico to tao 111 did ho soo tho fulfillnent of his froc caoscn profession. 31s superiors • nd t^xaers voro no so-called Snxi Pro¬ fessors but v„) today r .uin hold honored positions. c. ) This picture of tae Defendant vill bo completed vfcon I subhit cvl- durxe to the Hi*. Tribunal that Dr. 3ccker-?reyseng — ns far a# It vr.s In nis pover — aided cni supported racially and politically persecuted people, thereby certainly not follovlng tae principles of tho P»\rty. d. ) iready froc tho boginning of his ova scientific erroer tho experi¬ ment carried out on hlcself is of exceptional importance, already as a youn Interne ho toetod nev drags on his ovn body Had studied in cxporlaonto on hi ovn person, tao results up to tac Halt of his physical endurance. 30 Jan Z.7—!H!ES-9—2s~Fut ty—sw Court Tfo. 1 At th- Research Institute for Aviation Medicine in Berlin Dr. Becker- Frcyseng carried out on hlaaalf even the most dangerous experiments that ever were carried out there and the-eby contacted a soricus case of pasuaonia. % In more than cne hundred experiments with lack of oxygen ho 3orvjd ■.a experimental subject for his colleagues, thereby losing his conscious¬ ness and exposed himself to other dangers; and when, after the war, he with other Goman aviation ;hysicians wus j.akcd to coop*rato at the Aroo-l'rdical C-nbir of the American Air Forco in HoidolfcYrg, ho carried cut almost one hundred dangerous low pn ssure chaatoor experiments in loss than a year 1 s tine, which caused an illncse of several months duration to one of the participating oollrnguro. All these experiments on himsolf did not bring any naterial gain to Dr. Bock-ti^-Froysong. Hia scientific works aro regarded cs cl*an and abaolutoly raliablo by today’s critical obs' rv_rs, too. Ho cannot bo accused of an unhealthy acfcition, in unf actual f-naticiso or reckless egotism, and nothing of th« kind co-ild be proven against him. >fcv r did h«> carry out *ny dang-rous oxperir.onta in hia own scientific fi« Id any other my than as an experiment on himoslf or on similar minded co-woriccrs. e.) The outbreak of the war int- rrupted the medicnl-sciontific activities of Or. Bwcker-rrcysong. In 1940 he was drafted ns Unterant of thr. Luftwaffe Roserve and transferred in 1941 to the Medical Inspectorate of the Luftwaffe. The iiY'ictc.eit chiractericcs Dr. Bocker-Freyseng as "Chief of the Division for Aviation Medicine" -dth the Chief of the Medical Service of the Luftwaffe. Actually no Divisicn for Aviation Ledicine at the Medical Inspectorate has ever existed; thus, this is a contortion by tho Prosecution that cannot be proved ct ail. “Ithin the Division 2 (the Medical Division ) there existed only a branch (a raferet) for Aviation Medicine. Dr. 3eck«r-rreyseng was working there as an assistant consultant up to tne middle of 1944 22Jj> 3C Jan t?-4J-CES-9-2£-Pu'.ty Court o. 1 without authority to sign ary papers and without any independent respon- aibiUty. Only free Slay 19U. until the end of the war Dr. Bcckor- Freyaeng was hiaeelf the head of the branch (Referent). 2246-a JO Jao-!WF-iO-l-Sampscn - aw Court Ho. 1 Ifey it please the Tribunal: The presentation of evidence will prove that thia clarification is more than a merely formal correction . Sphere of activity arai Mainly responsibility of a division chinf wore in principle different free those of a chief or even assistant subordinate to hie. Along at all the defendants, who had any function in the civilian or military sector of the Genian health service during thenar at all, Dr. BFCKJB-PRZTSEKO is the only one Whose activities were never autonomous, and who never wne authorized to make independent decisions. This, high Tribune 1, is th' picturo of tto charnct-T of the defend¬ ant Dr. BECKTUPrEYSENG, *iich the Dof- nac will prove in detail, in order to demonstrate, that in no way does it conform with the descript¬ ion of a criminal conspirator tho prosocution has drawn. Pur the more the Prosecution ' s assumption that Dr. BkCKER-FREYS&iG participated at the "Coneultlr* Conference" of tho year 1943 incor¬ rect. The Dof.nso is going to prove thnt he actually participated only at tho Conference of 1944. Most of tho dofon 'ants he saw for tho first tine here in tho P lr.co of Justice, others ho kn-.w by nar.o on account of thoir high position. Tit* tho renters of tho Luftwaffe ho had naturolly official contacts. n. In particula r, the indictae* charges Dr. BEEKEi-FIXYSEIG of participation or specie1 responsibility for high altitude experiments, freezing experiments, sea water experiments and the experiments with sulfonamide , epidemic Jaundice, typhus and other infectious diseases. 1) The Do far sc is going to prove, that Dr. BBC KEh~FR£YSE*C had nothing to do whatsoever with the high altitud e experiments and heard about these experiments only after their conclusion, and thenonly unofficially and by chance. Furthermore, wo are going to prove, thut th# low pres*:re chanter . 2247 30 Jar. AT-T-JP-lO-l-Sasracn - w Court :»c. 1 uaad in Raocher* a experiaenta na not furnished to W. RASSHER by the Aviation Medicine 22A7-A 30 Jan son- court :io. l Hra'ich of the nodical S.pectorate of the h*!; that Dr. BlEKHtr- FUSTSTO actually saw this ch«ber for tho first tine about July 1942, •hen it already fad returned fron tfcchau, and tfcat he took it over free Cancan A viation E*paria«tal Station (WL), » brand ne w. Ur. President, I «ill % oait the foiling paragraph; I request that thi. pawph be stricken f*» the record. I -LU now continue with the next ''aragraph. A "To lllurtret. th. attitude of th. dof.nd.nt Dr. BKOK-fHETSEI*) to . request of Dr. RASHCH! to b. foml.«d »1U> . oh*.r again, th. D*f«nso point, out th. folio-tag, .nd -ill .ubdt avldonc. for It, During th. -dolor 1942^3, *n inquiry *«■ “• of tl * SS " offlc — receiv'd by th. 1*1«1 Inopretcret., .bout lotting th. h.™ . aotorired lo. pro.sur. «dical Inapectorate of the Luftwaffo waa not at all concerned, he n-ver had to voice an opinion on any of theoo qjeetions, he never participated on a conference concerning then., or oven heard of than. These questions did not even belong to tho field of aviation medi¬ cine which waa tic exclusive fiold of ncti vity oi this aoionoonc. Scientifically Dr. BXKZR-PrSYSEC never worked on these problems eithir, and is entirely unfamiliar with this specialized medical field. Dr. BECKER-FREYSr.C «s in contact with tho affair HAAGEN only insofar as his branch forr*lly -wjrtad in single casos on research orders, in order to uniformly control the porsanunt regulations about allocation of funds, priority rate assignment of porsonrfel, otc. Furtimnaare, nll . q £ these rocetrch orders 2249 30 Jan 47-U-JP-lCW#-Sa=pson - sw Court Ko . 1 •.he 9a.-.o flic into , (no, 55) and, therefore, a-raly for filing purposes were handled by his branch, Ihus it was nothing but an administrative and file net tor l Tho real, that is the f actual contents of the ordor were handled by the respective consultant for that specialized field. In the caso of tho defendant Prof. Dr. 3CHJOEER I dealt already with the dual position of Pro:. RAACEN the different typos of research orders he *crkod on, and therefore how the ordering agencies opposed each othor. The Defrnso is go:ng to prove, that Dr. BIEKEWTtEYSEJG even in th« succor of 19 Uh novor oonsidor. d the cxpiriaonts HA/GB1S ns anything but of an aniaal oxporiaocl.nl type, This is to bo deducted from nn order subedited to Dr. SCUHALLA, chief of tho brooding institution for such oxperiaental an'.-als. A.) Dr. BZCKHi-PPrrSEC hoard first about the $ttlf?fla-4,d 5*P!>E: c. As far ns these exneri-.enta are concerned, the notives, which had been guiding for Dr. BSEKTR-FRETSEX) as veil as his proposal of carrying out experi¬ ments for this purpose on hunan beings, wore alrendy elucidated in ry plea for Fjof. Dr, 93i’K>EDER. Tne Defense will effer proof , that Dr. BKKER-FRKTSENG advocated the conduct of these experiments not for vicious planning or with tie intent to torture, and to destroy. Cniy by the attitude of the follower or the Other method "E rka" and due to the particular circunstances caused by the war then forced to suggest experiments to bo carried out cn inrates, after the originally.intended experlcantation on roldiers of the Luftwaffe in a Luftwaffe or parachutist hospital and in the Military Fedical Acadecy had proved to be inpossible as a result of the war sitation in the sumer of the invasion. 2250 30 Jan -7-i4-JF*-10-^-Sa.-p3on - sw Court Ho. 1 Tho Defense intends to be in a position to prove that the planning of exp-riaentc, fr uhich from the start the volunteering of experi- s^ntal subject s-h ad been the first ccxdition, had bc«« so prepared and that the carrying out had been laid down in such detail that according to all medical exparionce and nodical estimates evexy procaution had been taJcon to prevent any disturbance of health, but certainly fatal results. ^ In sharp contrast to experiments the outcone of Wdch caild no longer be directed by their irresponsible initiators, th«» naturo, the preparations and tho carrying out of the so-ctliod soawater oxperioonts guarant od that r.t any time when reaching the limit of «.-iduranco the "inglo experiments could bo brck.m off. And only in those senator ex¬ periments did tho defendant Dr. HECKBt-FREYSEKC participate directly. The volunteering of oxperiaontal subjects was a roally necessary rrruislte for the e.cporloerrts, as it would have been impossible to obtain an absolutely unobjectl Table observation result in forcing peraons to take part in. Because the physician and scierAist does neceotmrlly depond U”on the cooperation of the experimental svfcjecte in ovaluctlnfl subj; *13~l~;>-AID-3ums-JP Ooart 1 C0HB2CT3D COFT rr? yj&SE&i The Tribunal It again In session. HU BZLCZKAilF: Year Sonare. Dr. Boldceonn for the defendant Dr. joarad Schaefer. tppeero to bo of a tpedal kind, even to the superficial obtervor of this trial. & In those proceedings, vhlch havo lasted for weeks, the nar.o <*f 3CHA2FZ2 bus boon nontioned only a few tinos by the Prosecution. So ia nllogod hy tho Prosocution to haro participated in only o£e oxporlr.ont conducted on ooncontration carp lncctoe, in which oxporlncnt a drug woo tostod which was intendod to rondor soa wator potable. Tho Prosecution all egos that, in spite of this very United activi¬ ty, Schrofor was participant In tho conspiracy which conprisos all thooo defendants. To proro its thosls of tho conspiracy of all tho dofondnats, tho Prosecution has prosontod'two points in dotoil. 1. Tho porvasion and corruption of Goman nodical scior.co, prl- uarlly tho young nodical non, by Fatioaal Socialist idoas, culminating in a dioro.,-nrd for h\nnn lifo which found its expression in tho oxpori- rents on concentration conp lncatos. 2. Tho doso cooporation of all dofor-danls in various sphoroa of nodicino, primarily in tho Amy, in tho Luftwaffo, and in tho SS, which put each dofondaat in a position to rocognito the criminal activity of tho others and to contribute his share knowingly. In this connection I shall provo that, ospocially in Schaofor'o case, those too do not npply: SCiai^f'haa «. ^cen an outspoken opponent of rational Socia¬ lismof militarism. It. was ho who already in 1933 and in tho sub¬ sequent years as a student and as a youn£ physician opposod tho noasuros which 'the Prosecutor described so fully on 9 December 1946 (page 100, 101 of the Soman transcript, and which were intendod to nako of those youns 30 Jan.-12-2-»-*TT>-rurTB Court Jfo.I aer. willlr*. instruants cf the Motional Socialist reclao by training then within organixatiOM of the Party, eren at the nxpenso of thoir scieiw tific achievements. Ir. spite of extremely strorv pressure - which the Prosecution has described very vividly - he Refused to Join the Party or any other organic zation, thereby eniangoring his a (Mission to the axaninations. Ho finally' had to dve up his position as assistant at a university clinic, although his scientific achievements would have entitled hin to a position*as locturor. Later, too - fron 1937 until the outbreak cf the war, still more during the war, and also after having boon drafted into the Luftwaffo in 19U1 — he continued to criticize the existing systea and its cxcosscs especially in the field of noOieino, and last but net least the experiments on human beings "hich woro conducted in tho concentration camps. Ifaw is it to bo explained, then, that SCHAEFER hold a position in tho public health service of the Third T.oich (Ooman transcript pngo $7) Dut how can the irosocution contend that the sharo of oach of tho 20 physicians - including tho defendant SCH-iTETt - in tho conspiracy and in its execution corresponds most closely to his professional interests and his position within the hierarchy of tho Third Reich? (cf. Goman transcript page llli. I shall prove that thoso contentions of tho Prosocution concerning the position of tho defendants within the hierarchy of tho Third Reich and their closo cooperation with each other do not apply in tho case of SCHAEFER. From 1937 until 19U5 SCSL>EFZR held a position as medical man and chemist am’ as deputy section chief ir. privr.to industry, sinco official positions wore not open to him on account of his antl-Mazi convictions. In 19Ul he was drafted as a private and after 6 months became Untersrzt in tho Luftwaffe, sinco ho was a medical can. An Untorarzt in the German :vehrnacht does not have the raric of an officer. Through an accidental meeting with his former fellow-student 2ECXER-FRSYSEJC, he was given the opportunity of 2255 30 *iw~12-3HH.TD-aurna Court So. I entering the Research Institute for .Metier Hedicine. He seized this opportunity immediately, because in this way he was able to continue his activities in private industry, naturally in civilian clothes. He rarely entered the Institute, and he aelcton wore a uniform. Ho knew only a few of the other medical can in aviation. He talked only once to his supreme % superior, HIFrJCE, and he talked only twico to HIPHE's successor, SCHXEDER. Such an unimportant person was SCHAEFERJ One cannot speak of a position within the hierarchy of tho administration and of nodi cine of^the Third noich. Duriix: the war be held a position like nany thousands of othor Gormans, who wore glad to be able to escape the deadly dangers of tho war at the front, who had no inner comeottora with this war and with this system, who oven woro its radical opponents. Ho was given th> order to investigate problims arising from distrass at sos, particularly tho problem of thirst. Ho obeyed this order with groat satisfaction, bo cause ho know that tho solution of this problem would put an end to tho tortures of Tantalus suffered by shipwrecked persons all over tho world. Ho sjt to work with scientific thoroughness, which I shall provo in detail. A study of tho entir literature, which took ronths, enabled him to hold aloe lure on thirst and tho ncasuros to be taken against it during distress at soa, by order of tho Chief of tho Medical Inspectorate, at tho neoting in Nuo-nberg in 191*2. The lecturo contained pure theory and was not a roport on experiments on • human beirvs. The Prosecution assorted - tho contrary on 12 Docontcr 191*6, it is true (sheet 331* of tte Goman transcript, but the complete Document 1*01, Prosocution,Exhibit 93, proves that this assertion is false. The further occupation with this problem'brou ht SCHAEFER to acperiironts, which wero carried out by the IG—Farbcn. In a scientific cooperation with this firm, a drug was finally found, by which sea wator could be made drinkable without any prejudice to health. This result was obtained by many chad cal, and pharmacological examinations of the bac toxi¬ cide effects and experiments. Jfc expexdaents on human beings with this 2256 30 Ja ru-12 :7>-3uma C«irt So* l drag were necessary, for SCHaEFEU had recot^dsed on the basis of all the other scientific methods of investigation that this irur was absolutely inroccuous* 33 Jtrutrj-k*: JOl 3-1-? «ldt Ccurt No. 1 The drug was called "Wofatit St* "IG Drug ■ cr "Schaefer Drug." It is fundamentally and also in its nay of presentation with only very slight differences the some drug which was invented bv the American Dr. Ivy and used by the US Armed Forces. The Schaefer drug was co mpletely ready at the end of 19A3, end Schaefer's supreme superior, the Inspector of the Modical Service of the Luftwaffe, in¬ tended to introduce it in the German Luftwaffe. The Technical Office, another branch of the German Luftwaffe, however, opposed its introduction, offering as a reason that thuro was not enough silvc available, which was needed for tho production of the drug. Tho Important men in tho Technical Offico, Oberstingenieur Christensen and Stabsinecniour Stickler, demanded the introduction of a drug which has been invented by Stabsingenieur of tho Air Force Borkc. It consisted of glucoso, which recovod or diminished the salt tasto of tho coa water without changing the actual salt content. I shall prove with special aephoaia that Schaefer opposed this "Borkc drug" as being a fnko, ovor aince the origin of this plan. He wrote a crushing report on the results of experiments which Oborctarzt von Sirany hod conducted with tho Bcrka drug on volunteers, patients in a Luftwaffo hospital, by order of the Tochnical Office. Schaifor had boon ordered by his superiors free tho Medical Inspectorate to o&ko this chock. Tho result of Schaofcr's attitude in this respect was that he wp.s sus¬ pected of sabotago by the sen of the Technical Office end by tho officers of tho Luftwaffo. Schaefer knew very well what this accusation meant in the Third Heich during the fifth year cf war. He knew of other instances in which nodical sen had been persecuted by the RSKA, that is, by the Ge3tapo, only on account of their diverging scientific opinions cn subjects of vital importance for the war. But nevertheless he explains his opinion of the senselessness of tho S'-rke method also at the conferences cf 19 and 20 Jay, during which it is pro¬ posed that this method be tested on concentration coop inmates. As a final warning he states that with the Bcrka method death Sets in on the 12th day at 2258 y, jir.uary-A-DJ3-13-2-Feldt Court Sc. 1 lotMt- This is proved by the Prosecution Document JO 177, Exhibit 133. This was all he could dc under tho circumstances, not being an officer, but the least important person ng the brilliant uniforms of the 13 high- rcnlcing officers. At these conferences Schaefer makes no "resolutions." This is impossibl in the Army. Tho top-rankikg chiefs of offices present "order" and "coanand. But the defendant Schaefer is not evon ordered to conduct experiments on concentration ermp inmates. He is not even assigned to tho cession which had been appointed to dotcraine the conditions for the experiments, because he is known to be an opponent of tho entire enterprise. x Another chance for preventing theso - in Schadfor's opinion completely pointless - experiments on human beings with tho B«rka drug, whother in the concentration eemp or in tho Luftwaffe hospital, passes by. On 25 ilr.y 19W. the world-famed internist Professor Eppingor from Vienna declares thr.t ho does not consider entirely wrong Berks's idea that his drug would "sluico" tho see water through tho human body without any injury, which Schaofor had hitherto considered absolutely absurd. Thruo aero professors, outstanding medical sen, shared tho opinion of professor ifcpingor. Thus Schaefer lost one coro medical pretext to declare himsolf still core openly against tho performance of those experiments. No law in tho world can dee nd of Schaufor more than h® did, if ono appreciates rightly and with understanding the generd circumstances in Hitle. Cormany and Schaefer's special situation on account of his official rank. Now I already put tho question why none cf the participants in tho conference of 19 and 20 Jay 19AL, who in contrast to Schaefer kept silence, ere prosont here in the defendants' deck, with the exception cf Bcckor-Froysong, and why Just tho inventor of a method which selves a very ancient prcblio of humanity is accused. In none of tho conferences mentioned in tho documents of the Prosecution, ir. which Schaefer took part, was it proposed or ordered that tho "Schaofor drug" be tested on concentration camp imatos. Cnly for ouch an act could Schaefer have been held responsible. But ho would never have shunned this medical responsibility, in view of the good quality of his drug, although 225 ? 30 J aruary-i-DJG-1 3-3-? cldt Court He. 1 he never have approved the uae of concentration caap inaates. The experiments with the Berka drug, which ho is net reapcnfible for ordering, wore carried out without his cooperation. Court I 30 J an U7-A - 13-la - LX - Feldt He therefore cannot be charged for having listened to the lecture of professor Beiglbock, which fully revealed the uselessness of the Berka A method. lour Honors, I hereby ask you to consider the Prosecution documents % and the speech of the Prosecutor, before listening to ny case, and to take into consideration ay stateaonts concerning tho Prosecution documents. This examination alone w.ll put you in a position to realise 4iiat tho Defendant Schaofor is not guilty. In accordance with the practico of Aaorican and British courts in penal cases, I request as a measure of precaution that the trial of ths dofondant Schaefer be discontinued, / without tho submission of any further evidence. DR. OuiLIK (Counaol for Defendant Hovon): The dofondant Hovon has been accused on all four counts of tho indieturent. Regarding Count i of the Indictoont, cost on plan or conspiracy: In tho first ploc^,tho fust of a conspiracy rujuiros a cosnon plan or agreement botwoon at least two arsons. The prosecution shouln, thoroforo, have stated: 1, when; 2, *soro; 3, between what persona this comuon plan or this cannon agroeoont was r^achod; and L, what tho substance was of this coor.on plan or agreeraont. The prosecution should have uado a particular point of stating that this plan or agreuojnt ai»,d at the conaitting of those war crimes and crimes - gainst humanity, which are the imbject of those proceedings. Furthormoro, tho prosecution should have proved that tho defondant Hovon took part in such an agreement. Now that the prosecution has concluded its presentation tho following nu3t be stated: tho prosecution has no reason whatever for assuming and has produced no proof whatever that a plan of this kind ever oxisted or that the defendant Hovon took part in it. I thoroforo ask that tho defendant Hcven be declared not guilty under Count I of tho indictment. The opinion expressed hare this morning gives mo occasion to add a fow words at this point. I s of the opinion that the Tribunal does not 2261 Court I 30 Jan U7-* - 13-2a - LJG - Feldt naod ary instruction on ho* proceedings should be conducted most efficiently. I shall therefore a* rely conmt on the question of Aether such an application is legally admissible or not. According to Geraan penal la* the Court can at any tine refrain from hearing defense witnesses if it is of the opinion that the evidence presented by the Prosecution is not adequate. As far as I know, and I mke theso statements with a certain Reser¬ vation bocause I have foreign literature available only to a limited extent, this principle applies under the law of all states. This principle also arises freo tho lows of lc*ic, for what purpose would thoro bo in .-resent¬ ing defonse witnosses on the count of conspiracy undor the presont diffi¬ culties of bringing then to Nurortoorg and of taking up tho tino of the Tribunal by their examination if tho Court is already of the opinion that what the Prosecution has presented is Insufficient to prove tho partici¬ pation of tho defendant Hovon in a conspiracy? I shall now c ntinue. If this application is r-fusod, I ahnll provoi a, that the defendant Hoven did not tako part in such plat* b, that ho did not oven know his co-dofondants, with tho exception of V4rugowsky, until tho boginning of tho present trial; and, c, that ho had only net tho defondant Jlrugowsky once, unofficially, and that at thi3 mooting thoro was no discussion of an agreement for the cccnittuont of war critaos arxi crimos against humanity. Regarding Counts 2 aivd 3 of tho Indictment (war criws and crimes against humanity) i Undor these Counts the defendant Hoven is accused of having carried out on inmates of tho concentration cacp 3uchen»ald: a, typhus experiments, and b, tho euthanasia program. As an introduction I should like to point out tho following in order to clarify =y presentation cf evidence: 2262 33 Jan-i-S-t-lS-lb-Poldt-J? Court I Thxj fact that the provocation hae proved that a crlno has toon omdttod does not .office. Lav Fo. 10 1. only applicable If these erica, voro coralttod on citizen, of the United Hattons. I gather fron the orldonee so far sulcittod by the Prosocution, and o.peclally fron the vitnoa.o. auctioned by t$o prosecution* that they also oro of this view. I shall now doal with tho individual war crlno. and crino. against tacanlty with which tho defendant Enron 1. charged, and enno first to tho question whether there is t ba«i. for tho assunption that tho defendant Horen participated In tho typhas exporlnonts - a punlohablo act acootding to Law So. 10. It cannot bo doubted that between January 1942 and tho ond of 1944 typhus oxporlr.onts wore carriod out on lnnatoe in tho ooncontratlon canp Buchonwald. Tho do fondant Horen wo. nrro.tod in Soptccbor 1943 and was, until March 1945, a prisonor in tho concentration carp Buchonwald. TM. is cloar fron tho oridonco pro.ontod by tho prosocution. It Is thoroforo out of dooieiro inportanco whothor and to what oxtont t!io dofondrnt Horen actually took part In tho typhus oxporlncnt. January 1942 and August 1943. Tho pm.ocution hae etotod ooroctly that it wao not tho dofondont Eoron who wae supervisor of tho doprxtnont for typhus and virus rosoarch nt tho Hygiene Inetituto of tho Waffon SS which was o.tablishod at tho Buchonwald Concentration Carp, but that this wo. tho Into Ur. Ding-Schulor. Tho activity of which tho dofondont is nccusod nllogodly consists in a) having boon Dr. Ding's doputy. b) haring soloctod prlsonore who woro used as hucon oxporlnontnl subjocts In tho typhus oxporinonts. Ho point c) As has been correctly eutalttod by tho Prosocution on tho strength of Dr. Ding's diary - Doc. rC.265, Doctccnt 2263 33 Ja=r-Jr-S*-13-2b-yeldt-JP Coart I 3ook 12, psgo 36 to 56 of the Goman. pages 33 to 53 of the Snglioh text _ lho activity of the defendant Horen as Dr. Ding's deputy has to ho orokea down into* 1) His vork as deputy in tho oxperinental station 31ock -46; 2) His work as Deputy in 31ock 50. Tho cvidonco of tho prosecution has shown heyond any douht that tho experiments woro carried out only in Block 46. In Block 50 on* tho typhus vaccino for tho Gerr-an soldiers at tho front was nanufacturod. This is shown by tho tostir.ony of tho witness Dr. Engon, pego 1192 of tho Goman transcript* Only tho pcrfomanco of tho typhus cxporir.cnts in Block 46. how error, con bo oonsidorod a crininal actirity in accordance with Law Fo. 10. Tho nanufacturc of typhus vaccine in Block 50 is beyond any doubt neither A war crino nor a crlno against hunnnity. Only in Block 50. tho section whoro tho vaccine was nanufacturod, was tho dofondant Ho von Dr. Ding's pemenont doputy. This is ohown in¬ dubitably b7 tho abovo nentlonod Ibcwiont 2!0-265, Document Book 12, proton 38 to 53 of tho English and page. 36 to 56 of tho Goman text, parti¬ cularly by page 41 of tho English and tho saco pogo of tho Goman toxt. Thoro is tho following entry on 9 January 1943* •3y order of tho surgeon general of tho Vaffon SS. SS Grupponfuohror fuid liajor Gonornl of tho Vaffon SS. Gcnxkon. tho hitherto existing typhus research station at tho concentration canp Buchonvald boconos tho -Doporteont for Typhus and Virus Research". Tho bond of the dopart- r.ont will bo SS Sturr.bannfuohrcr Dr. Ding. 2264 20 Ja»-ir-S*-13-3b-?oldt-JP Court I Soria* his abscaco tho station nodical officer of tho Voffon SS Vcinur, SS Hauptstumfuohror Horen, vill suporriso the production of raccinoe." I drew tho attention of tho Tribunal especially to tho expression "pro¬ duction of raccinoe." * The defendant Horen was Dr. Din* 1 * deputy in tho experimental station only temporarily. during an illnoe. of Dr. Ding'8. Thio ia to bo soon fr<« tho entries on p. 37 and 38 of the Goman Do<&nont Boole 12, pngo 38 end 39 of tho Znglith Docunont Book 12. According to tho.o ontrios, I*. Bing raccinatod 135 prisoners in tho ported from 6 January to 1 Tobrunry 1942, and aftorvarde on 3 Kerch 1942 , infoctod thoto vaccinated priaoncro and 10 control poroone with culture Yirus. On 17 March 1942 Dr. Ding, who had infoctod hinoolf, foil ill with typhua. During this illnono tho dofondant Hovon actod at his deputy, according to tho ontry in tho diary on 17 :larch 1942. Tho next infoction took place on 15 October 1942 and wan undo by Dr. Ding, iron tho ontrios in tho diary ono can ooo without doubt that in tho period from llarch to October 1942. especially during tho tine when tho dofondant Hovon actod as deputy for *. Ding, no infections woro nndo. 2265 30 Jan. 4? -A-14-1-PKP- Blaklcy Court Ho. 1 These entries aro corraboratod by the testimony of tho witnesses examined by the prosecution, who stated that the defondant Haven did not porform any experiments. Witness Dr. Kogon declared that tho defondant Haven could not begin any experimental serivs on his own initiative, but that only Dr. Ding, as head of tho experimental station, could make decisions in this matter ♦ (p'.re 1210 of the German transcript). The witness Kirchhciacr stated, corroborating the testimony of tho witness Dr. Kogon, thrt all tho typhus experiments wore begun by Dr. Ding, (page 1360 of tho Gorman trans0 J'n h7-A - 15-la - LX - Foster Esiglboeck: -that he, although still young in years, is, nevertheless, known for possessing remarkable scientific aptitudes." Beiglboeck had tbe good fortune of meeting among his teachers two people #iose names are imortal in the history of medicine. They are the two internists, Frant Chvostek, head of the Th*rd Medical Clinic at Vienna, and Hans Enpinger, head of the first Medical Clinic at Vienna. Chvostek enphasizes at the conclusion of his certificate not only the scientific abilities, the Industry of his student, but, abov* all, his humane attitude towards the patients entrusted to his care. Epplnger, the famous internist who counted the most prominent statesmen like Marshal Stalin among his patients, calls Beiglboeck in his certificate his most capable student. Chvostek and Eppingsr are already doad, and the two certificates originate fran a period bofore the experiments which are here under review, thorefore, must bo considered as correct and unobjectionable docuaonts. I can, thereforo, sum up ry remarks about tho personality of tho defendant by saying that the words apply which Euripldos, tho great Grook poet of tragedieo says about Anaxagoras, the philosopher* “Happy is the man who achieved knowledge For the bonefit of rosoarch t Novor ho fools tho urge to make his neighbor suffer. Nor is ho driven to do wrong for such motives f II. Order free Above: Ity second line of argument is going to bo the reply to tho quoation as to how it is possiblo that a nan of such high qualities finds himself lr. the defendants' dock as an alleged criminal. The saiai question was asked by the Heidelberg psychiatrist. Dr. Mittscherlich, the head of the joraan Doctors' Delegation, when he wrote: "In the defendants' dock there are side by side with scientifically meaningless doctors exports of great reputation. Free the prison witnesses with prominent nines are brought in. Two famous scientists have ccrsitted suicide in connection with this trial. These events prove that in passing Judgment on tho ovents, con¬ siderations of a purely legal and criminalistic nature will not suffice; 2273 Court I 30 fee 17 - k - 15-2a - LX - Poster that, on the contrary, the question rust be asked how it could happen that such aen found theaselves in the defendants' dock." 30 Jre>-15-lb-A-.C3-To a to r-J? Coart I I ic not going to reply to the question of the ethical notives as a defense counsel until I deliver rxj final ploa, and I an going to linit nysolf at this stage to the purely legal aspect of tho subject. Tho reply is: 3eiglbocck vas forced to uadortako tho soa-vater experinonts for which he is indicted anchrr.odor whom ho know ~.a his suprono superior Juot r.e . ny soldior knows tho nanos of his gonorals without over having had any closor associations with thou. Boigloboock subsoquontly not dockor-Froysong and Scha.ofor. All ho can bo inlictod for fron tho point of viow of crininal law, thoroforo, is his cooporation in tho oxocution of thoso oxpori '.onts ■'nd this loads no to tho noxt point of tho procoolings: B.) T1 o Crininal Cfc.,r.. tor of tho Exporinonts in General: 1.) Tho Prosecution considers oxporinonts as 1.) T/ar crinos. noro priru. facio const Aeration cf tho Prosocution docunonts rovoals that there c:n novor bo -ny quostion of war crinos for -lo sinpla ro..son th. t such war crinos. accordin'- to articlo lib. 2276 30 J n 47-..-S’.7-lS-2-C-Fostcr Ccurt Ko • 1 of ConCT ol Council ... 10 o_n only to .—*« in ro.poct of „ c ^ on ..la of 0111*1 countrio.. -1 the ?™..cutio» utterly f U oi to pro.ont proof of 0.1. to th. ^un.-.li I- 7 . P°«" ; p5 rou ina you in tMf connootlon of O, SOS .ell * z ——- - —- ~ “* -r . nty wuro t,o inru-to. -let » » — - f ° r “° 7 !;t0r oxporluonta?" a* 1 . roplll. »X ~ ««• “« r ^ r jurt So* 1 3C Jar. 47-l-16-l-IE»-Kolcy (.«. 4,3 of th. t,™ record). The U»m, Vle«. n!.° te.tifled thet tt , .ohj.ct. of the experluente vere vl.h»t exception OT . 1 „. I ehalli therefore. not utter . .!«!• vord .tout «r crln.e « ou. et«. end I an nov turMu to the oueetloo M to aether the eo.-uet.r .ro.rtu.ut. reproeent eo-c.U, crlne. «.in.t huu.Mty. Control Council u . 10 «,r.e .0 defimtlou Wt content, t.e.lf «lth eitl« «»• !• -order, r.oo, end other =.... of tnh^n treutuon, of ,h. ct.iltnn Popul.- tlon. „ 1 . nn old erportono. of 1» thet th. oroe.ou.or «».*• loud.r n»d oor. ecphotlcally vhoncr.r th. fnot. .. .uch furnt.h only Itttl. proof. Therefore, the chief ~o.o tutor « conp^.ttr.ly little ehout the n... curler, vhtch h-r. .hechod th. clvtlt.ed vorld hecue. they ..oh. for thon- e.lvee. hut he ho. ..Id rol.ttr.ly uuch .tout ...-.Ur omertnente. I e*U. therefore. d.el .« n, T«un.n» of proof tn th. ftr.t piece utth B ) the character thu experiments to) the manner &f th*lr ©x-icutlcn. * 1 . «otn* to pro,. t- you ty ..« lent the def.nd.nt htneelf. ty product* ... expert., the eo.-v.ter oxpertn.nt. -A* hed t.. rr.ecr.hod to n, oltent free the out... up to th. -»»» - nlcced under . eut..,u,nt Chech vero .xp.rln.nt. vhtch eld ho .topped .t . w accent. In th. eeno vny I *o .o.re, to prove to you thet Dcthlhooch. .« w rate, eotu^ly dtd tntorrupt thee. .xPortnont. o„l, ono«h to render . dn=«. to the e»h>ct.' honlth cult, tupoeethle. . «1- - or a completely h*rzl«e. Injection va. eufficient to re.tore to the ^Jeot hie full efficiency. Iu hl. opening ep«=h donor.l Teylor ..Id. 'The cxp.rtnent. »ro pro ducod nothin* that could.he ut.ltrod for ctrtltrod nolle In.- < * Gorurn rocord). I -t very definitely contradict thl. concootlon. So ^ ns there notion., th.ro exl.t. .1.0 the -eh. rnd 1, hr. O-y. teen on nln. vhlch It me -rthvhlle to 1 — *• — “ vhich 1. on el«.nt nr.ll.hlo In .uch Irr*. —title., ecrrlco.hlo to hu- iee , p^cicm- u «=.. - -■ - ■*"- '• “ i —X. —ft- — *“ “ r ■' ltCtl,t ‘ ° f 7 unci«— -—- •-— ,o ,=i ”• ^ ; 0 thll r .^ loi ... — »«.. i -a — *°»- —— vor “ — - u * u . .- «••*• —• “ s 77 7‘ c „ Ukl nton. froi — r~ - - «- —“ “ l “ tl *“ ,h ° u ; ... .... U t. «- —“ - •“*, ,.!« -lob 1. * M * ° rlM - KM ‘ «u «m.——- -*«“ iu ' iw * * ooe of tho *;;; „ «—«.«. --——• —• 777 ,. 1 « tin. Wor. tk. 0 .r=xn 5th..f.r Wdcl.d It. C «, VU1 turn .l«h herror fr~ th. -W «hl«h nr. tb. — of thl. Indietnont, «h r. «... ft— * *“ -Wl „.cb.r; tut ... tnw .111 cl«rlr r..uu ft- - * - -—*• - - - ~ 7 1 :;: lutplolon in front of .orld ft*. -pin .on W — thn. non cxn.riuoati — .men tn. indict* te ‘ „ contribution to 0lT.U..tl=n «d bun.nltjr. , no. prop. to turn to th. U.t point of * —» tb. crlninnl cbnrrct., —» - — - — '«» ^ cm. out. ,o chief P r,ccu,or bo. - -t -« - — “ “ ,uc.cb. H. acntlon.* in pnrt.cuXnr tb. .on vnt.r — - prrtlculrrlp .trlbln, - - «“• — ~ ^ “ 1. of fi .lbtln. . — — - ~ ““ ” 7771 . tb. — V.bruncbt vltbln . ft. hour, t, rep, to - — tlon end . ririw. If «, bed bnd to W tb. ~U — of t.o do „ for .neb .ubloct. tb. -on. Pblc. .bleb -1- — 7 ‘2 [ t Z tb.. nubt bur. con.ld.red tb. nntt.r nor. cr.fuUr - — - ::. —-——- 7771 .0 «r. t,tur.d, ,.. : bnr. tb. *».t«t -ft- - - - 77 cutor .0 ororot blc.lf to,, -nent - — » ° U ' ‘ Court So. 1 3C Jtn 4?-A-16-3-13K-*aloy .«. U ,1. «~h — *. «— E ^ f ' * h ‘ >utalt ,o « MU «-* “ — 14 - «* “ tM C “ PCt "‘ eXPert * “ ,iv« rculie. on special quctlcn. of detail. DiCU= ent ibit » 132. report of the technical office of the Air jorce to the Belch-fuehrer SS. nov .hove that tvo asthma for rondorin^ .ter drinkable ver« under dlac-i- «* -thod invented by Schaefer. for «. nor. ..«« »P of «* *UU *" of Iron ,nd «.« - «P— - - «" « U.M. M UP Po Pon. of pur. '-«» ~ *- .,1. proooo. nor, PM. M *-«-» !«««. U ”” Ml Mi U P-- — ~ —* °° lh ' “ ,h “ 1 U8 ' »> PP. 3-rKo ooPh.d W on tho POP unfororpPlo UU«r M m* on. or Colon.l M «* *'• °" th ° 4 ^ ' ,P ° nly ^ M» Of .fficPlvon..*. in .P». 01 •» *« — ^ , V „ n CT „ n .uch snail profit could not bo turned do*n ty tho aedical prufeaalon. cv«n .ucn >uh BaffIcl.nP e.rP.inPy .n «r .« .« «- — * “ “ M " “ ^ for ... «M. TM. M.o l* nn UPinM* roo.nUod ,U. 11" o— *° f ‘” r ,h “ 4 6y cv.d.neo .Mod Ph. fnnou. pParnnooloK... of B.rUn »«"« *• ~ vu; *.. M V- nonPlonnd, PP, — “ . on ;..or,odPonroUonPnpPoPM.—■ • ^ ~ m »»*.—«— « - ~' f “ - ,h "; '7 . m.. ^ «• - mite ^-.fd-d... p-——■ “ - - in th ‘ :;r .nporP^P oue.Pion .. .. -» - — ^ ^ V.P- o,rr,d on.. « -1 ^ V - — “ ^ ^ no.... PMP u P" 11". PI-". ^-T 1 '' C'^urt So. 1 3C Jen ^-J.-lo-3-lHK-Haloy in a. w-* *- 1 Stsff ' tat h * lW4 ,o th. prince thnt U .We h. Uf. » ~* *° , 1Y . renlle. on .p«l«l «u..t»on. of d.t.ll. _«» HW «-« «. "»» - *“ “ ehnl ^ ° fflC ” 01 ,h ° A ’ r Iorc . ,o th. B.lc-fu.hr.r SS. no. .ho- th., t« —• ... -,.r drinkable «r. ond.r duel- » *— * 5 ^ Cf ° r ' v ,,h for Oh. .■»>« »P - - ——“ r00Ul " 4 tV ° «. too. of iron tad coo.* - «P— - *" ‘“' 4 " 4 *" u, V. thr .0 ton. of pore .ll.« W.h» for th. Pro¬ duction proto.., nod. thl. nothod pmctldl, ltpo..lU. In ,U. of «*« * -.t.rlnl ohort«e In th. o.r»n »nr »«- °* - •»« “ *“ nothoe r.oulred no .pocUl nW.c.orln* Ph rod no hottl.-n.ch r„ caterlol. rnd tho. offr.d ,h. P-lhUlt, of .pood, Introdootlon t, th. Luftwaffe cad the ntvy. xa 1 . .b- hr th. Tlonnr polio. r.oord (Whit, ^ 1*. - *, tho Burxn noth. - W tho tot unfcorohl. or.UolnrrP ori¬ ent. eorriod oot hr Colonel *U -hod op.nod op -W ^UlhU prcp.ot. of offectl.cn.... In .*» of .U tho dooht. orpr....d hr th. n.dlonl prof...Ion, «.« .ooh .nnU profit oooid not ho turnt, “° .Uh .offlo,.nt cor,-lot. In ~r nt th. tin. .hon . *r.at « <«" for It. .xl.t.nco, Thl. U~ W nn Int.rnrtlonUlr r.c*nltod .clon- tu. llh. th. cllnlcnl phy.lci.n BpplnBor to f.vor th. ro-oxonlno.tl ..ld.no. -hlch «... f« phnrnacol!.. of Berlin Unl-r-ltr, Pr o. , . .ha. already boon nontlonod. th. «P-« nroc.dor. :i:..cr,od ton, client OP to th.Wlo.te.t.1,, H - forth- h. th-vn h, th. .ho,. Cdonc. thnt th. -f— of th... on hunrn .oh.oct., -oh nr. ,n thon.ol... ooltc -ml..., 1- — Ratified. Th. P.n.1 l.o,or. howe.er, U “ ~ ..«--—- - --• T r ::..t- .or. erriod oot. . W1 pro., h, th. h-rl« of th. dcf.ndnnt -W« no.... thnt in th. flr.t pUC. .coordl« to XPP^.. orcpo.1, 2 co-J _te W to * P— —^ " ^ rj rer tt „ =« — and thl« -U — »"» " ™ °J . w * t-t «. -M~ - — — "" ^ z x. •. -—- -—^ - 1 " : ,0 M8l e« - X«t tt «■. “ - 111 ^ ^ W r—«—- >—-*~ - „ *. —-r - - •— BOiSlbMCk ‘ h " I ^ to co-t in th. operation - — «• — —‘ v ■snU wore 30 juv ■-A-ATO-*feloy Court So* 1 Mrrl ^ on. The concentration camp and it, method, .cm absolutely urknen to bln. and they ha„ cc to hi. horrified kmcledge fd 1" th. coumo of tide trial. it jo Chau they had deliberately kept him .pd^ fK- everything. Mt finally. I am altk, happy to Sheri th the 1*1# of original notes cade by the mediool assistants InVhese concentration camp exporimnta "hieh have haen found end by affidavit. made by the., same persona that Boiglbeoolc garrlod out these experiment. .hich he had been ordered gainst his rill „ a soldier to perform. dfr exporimnting on him elf and in accordance !Tlth the rules and precautions of nodical science. The,, doeusenta -hen oxmrlnod by expert, -ill she beyond doubt that the experiments hsd no laatlng dmmglng effect. and caused no death .song the subjects. They rill objectively refute the contradictory eridonco of the prosecution ritneasa. .ho esthomd their knclcdge from hearsay. Frm this it must be concluded, hcovor, that them can be no quoatlon of crime .Ealnat humanity either. In conclusion I can therefore say that if the evidence «hlch I shaU protore only yield half of .hat can be expoeted, the rid. atmorim of Cmrgo. emoted by the pmseoutlen on the subject of .cantor experiment, rill coll.*., like a houae of card, and give effect to my sutal.slon to acquit my client. Prof. Dr. Blegiboook, I should be happy shout this h.oauso I-mqld thereby have contributed tor w Part to preserving an onlnont physician and nan for my country -hloh mod. every man for its moonatruoUon, and I -ruld fur the mom havo pmvod that scientific research and tho physloito in the mom direct sonso am not exclusive of *roh other but that they can .ell be . synthesis in the serrie. Of hummty and for the benefit of suffering nartdni. DP„ KARL TOFFXANi 1 tr. President, and Tour Honors i The Prosecution has sutsdttod only .a «i»fle Jocunont gainst Dr. Attolf POSOiWI, vritton by himself. This is his letter to HDKA dated October 19la - Documnt t*-3S, Exhibit 1U2. The o- rcr document, .Mch tho prosecution has sutrittri in this case am outoardly in no connection rith the defendant Dr. iWDBK. They even, as Document 10-39, Exhibit 153 arxl tho fencing abes, start a ride nc causal scries, in .hich the 3D Jsn-j^lS-2*-Jl3>-Maloy-JP Court I .urgo.tlon of tho defend,. I». KtOPit i. ovor.hto.=d by tho ou^.tion =a dc by .uch a powerful .gene, .. the deputy Gauleiter 1= Hiodordonsu. ^ho defondant vlll now toho tho witnoas * l “ d “ 4 el, ° tBo r0 “°°” which led to hi. lottor - *xhlblt *o. 19«. So .111 poiht out that o. . physician ond a person Interested In Botony ho .»o oourlncod, oftor .tudyine tho puhllcotloa. of Dr. !'adauo ud Dr. loch, that tho plant caladluCs fro. the nodlo^ point of rlov. doe. no. have a sp.cifKtoll, .torlltsing offoct. and teat. fro. tho hotonlcal point of rlov, a plant Udiconou. to north merle. e*mot ho grown In Gomany'on onoh a largo ,enlo that It would ho available In largo enough Sumtltio. for atorl- lltatlon. So .111 explain .hy In hi. lottor ho «ld exactly tho oppo.lto of .hat in hi. opinion «. tho truth. Ho vlll refer to a report which h. received, that .torUl-tlon h, operation ... to ho carried out on a Urge .calc, hut that It night ho po.tponod If there should ho any po.ol- Mlit, of carrying out .uch .Mrlll«.lon hy now., of a drug. The do- fondant Dr. Pohom, .111 .«.«= that It .a. hi. Inton.l n to dooo.ro hy praising ..eh a drug and thu. to po.tpono tho .torll.aatlon by operation as long as possiblo, Tho Pro locution h». .Iro.d, Indicated that It doo. not propo.o to admovlodgo .uch an ardent. (P. 557 of the Goman tran.crlpt). The dofoadant Dr. Pohorny, ho.oror. .Ill .toll .l«o..eo to prove that ho nontlonod thn.o con.ldar.tlon. ween ho .rot. hi. letter, and that ho ha. not juat invented then nor. Tho defends. Dr. Pohom, .111. In addition, reroal .hat tho Pro.o=u«on could not pro.ont, the fact that ho received „ an ever to hi. letter and that ho In turn answered onoo nor., .o that in *11 tho crlno. -1th which ho 1. charged hi. ectlvc p«t.clpa«..n inrolYod only letters. The defense will show that Stonier-e effort, to produce a .torili: tion drug free cslad.un were un.ucce.sful. Tho -Itnoo.o. to ho oxanined on thl. point ere the rospen.lbl. non of the hadau, Tim In Dresden. Tho cuoal.t of the fira will dlscu.. the -d «mtho,ls of a caladlu. 2283 - 33 jai>. 16 - 2 »-Jr-JLTD-«aloy-JP Co'zrt I pl » t u tb. b.tbc».. rww. w »• <*» h “ ' dro * i; ' w Bro,10 ° o4 ,„.«1 tl«. 14 16. "f *41. IrlU, the «Sl«i director of the Itodam* 2283 (a) Court lfc>* 1 nrc , riU appaar a. . 1««U #r. «WR -111 be .eked by the dtf.n .0 to -ho artent he M-..H ball.vea ttat the BdenUflo aasertlen -hi* he cade, that caladln oen b. teed to sterills. . hunn being, 1. true. He rill *l»o b, .eked b, the dofene. -bather It ie .t all poeelbl. In precUce to produce ccujh ealadlun to jueUfy oven thmdn,-: of poleoning by oaladlun. Finally, he -111 ri. be .eked to to.tlfy, -hat progroee the ealadlun experiment, -hi KDSlEa had ordered had node by the end of the »ar. It -111 then be eho-n that the caladlun oxp.ria.nt. -erei at the end of the -ar, .till In the .tag. of arinl experlaenbi and had net yet led to aw ueablo reeult. If the ritnoa.ea fron the HiDiDS Fin In Draaden ehould In thl. oonnootlon not aeon to be dl.lntora.tri ritnee.oa, Inetruotor (Dr. JDIC of the Ph.rn.oolo, *ori ImUtut. of the University of -uortburg, -ho ho. been wiled by the lefena. ae an export, rill disease objoctlvoly the eolontlflc value of Dr. WDA'Bi urd nr. KOCH', the*, of et.rlllt.Uon -1th caladlun. Horwver, ho rill .tat. ■pacifically -both* oaladlun is eapabl. of .terllitlns a hunon being at all. He -HI flnlly .tat. ho. high the eoneral eolontlflo value of drug, pro diced by the IimOS Fire Is and -hat Ooman physician, thl* in general of the preparations -hlch the HIDAUS Fin ha. produced. Dp. JDID »1U say In thl. oonr.ooUon that It 1. hi. opinion that Conan nodlwl non kne fron cxporlcnc. that publications and drug. of.the HMUDS Fin do *t have absolute eclontlflc validity, bocaue. It noetic considered that this 1 . a fin -hose ain It 1 . olso to .HI the drug, -hloh It produce.. Finally, the defena. rill call ritr.o»e« -bo rill tetify to the reputation tho polltloel attitude, and other conduot of th. defendant Dr. TOKOHNI during M. civilian aoUrit, up to 19« a. -ril a. during hi. period of military service. Evidence a, to Dr. WKOHHI'a stUtuda rill furthencro bo -van bv nucorou. affidavit, -rich rill appear In the docunent book. 226k 33 Coart I au Htnr.JOT: Sh. opening statement. hate no. boon concluded. M3, iwmxi If the Tribunsl pleases, the Prosecution hn. .ororol r _u s. to nskc concerning urtaln question, which here hcon raised h, the opening statement. of the Defense Counsel to the Tribunal. Docs ,he Tribunal wish to adjourn prior to these rnnuts for the afternoon rccoitT a BE PiCSIDSBT: »=•» ore the noturc of the cements the Prosecution desire, to coho ad ho. long -ill It toho to coho then! „ KB. HdLUmi They conc.rn briefly to notion, end the neture of the notion, to diesis, cortoln par.gr.ph. of the Indictment «. conUlnod lB . n'dbor of the opening sUt-ents. o. ..11 .. the .tuck on Count 1 of the Indictment; thnt i. to soy. the Count .hid, chorgo. con.plr.cy to coff sIt war criaoa and crlno. a*nin«t hunar.ity. The Proeecutlon. of oourso. is not propnred st this tlno to Cab¬ an, argument on sny of these points, but I think it would be «11 U .o could roach sue a^.-.C « to tho corner in .hlch those question, are to bo settled. In other words, tho Pro.ooutlon would look with disfavor upon tho procedure now. to settle ench sad ovory notion to dismiss prior to tho tine tho Defuse Counsel began to put in oridonco on Wf of their defendants. Ko would prefer, if it 1. suitable with the Tribunal, end with the Defense Counsel, to hare tho Tribunal rule upon the particular notion, to dismiss, a. made by each Defense Counsel, prior to or immediately after such Defense Counsel hu put in hi. approval. IE PT3SIET: Tou coon tho rulings will bo node in tho ease of each individual defendant -hoc that defendant has rested hi. c.soi KB. KdUBTl That would suit tho Prosecution very nuch. Tho problem is this; Tho first question raised by substantially all of the opening statement. 1. the legal basis for the crlcc of conspiracy. That quoction is coirr.on V* nil 2285 Court No* 1 30 to U7-* - 17-1* - LX - Beard „ drftotots, .!«• «■* * -= — CMrS ' d ^ ^ "" — - P-P-* “ —“ ‘ 6rl " th! ‘ ‘ P “ U “ “ * r ,,.,r early date. I should think, .t tho laast, * ^ of next -oek, sc that the Tribunal could et ^ tin. rule on the ,u.,tion of conspiracy. , fl that's. it msy, I do not think there le ^ -e.sity *- * ^ that particular Ration hec.ua. . do not think It affect, the rights of ^ of th. defendant, in eo far a. proof 1. concern^. In other -«*. a conspiracy 1, «d. out normally by .being the parUcipation of th. defendants or their connection 1 th the subsequent ci».| that is, 1 th th. crises as alleged in Count II or th. cine, again.! hunanit, a. alleged in Count HI, and ehlch is not normally th. subject of .operate proof in and of itself. and, I should think that ehateeer the ruling nay be on th. conspiracy question, each of th. defeats 111 put in all of th. proof that he ha. available, that he -as not connecUd in any sub.Untlal .toner 1 th any of th. crises charged there - Counts II and III. *. to the notion to dial.. 1 th respect to certain paragraph, of Count II, there nay bo a slightly different question there ehlch night retire an early ruling by th. Tribunal, but even a, to that I am not sa-e. The third question 11 ch has b~n raised by the opelng .Mtone.t 1 . that a nu*er the defendant, have been ..plicated by proof of crlninl experinents ehlch wore net explicitly particularised in the Indlctnent. For exsnple, the blood coagulation, fleckfieber and -arfaro experiments. The Defense Counsel uniformly have taken th. poeltion that they are going to ignore this proof on the ground they -ere not claimed 1 th the crine. ehich ire Involved in the experinents. As to that point, I should think there mould necessarily have to be a ruling by the Tribunal before any affected by such proof, has conpl«tod his case. defendant, who is -fi jaai-ry-«-DJG-17-lb*9>-ard Court Ko. 1 «nd, I might say, without octsftdetf argueeent, that the Prosecution takes tht position thet the defendants hft*« been sufficiently charged under para¬ graph 6 of the Indicta-nt with having committed war crimes, in that they performed medical experiments cn involuntary human beings which resulted in surd era, tortures, and other inhuman acts. The sub-paragraph of paragraph 6, purports to give particulArs^of certai. of such experiments, but it is explicitly stated in the Indictment, and in par-graph 6 that the experiments were not limited to th' e jjarticulariaed. The Prosecution urges that, because we have made every effort to advise the defendants in great detail of the nature of tho crimes with which they aro charged, wo should not thereby be limited in submitting our proof and incrim- • •• * inating these defendants because they happen to have been involved in ono or tho ether experiments which aro not particularised in tho Indictment. This laat point I should think, would roqui.- an -arly ruling by tho Tribunal. Tho ruling on tho motion tc dismiss, and particularly on tho conspiracy Count, I think, could bo handled on an individual basis sometime boforo tho defen¬ dant had rested its case. a To rule on ell of those questions, as raised by the defendants, would put cn intclorablo burden upon tho Prosecution in preparing the nocossory briefs for all 23 defendants, and would also require extended study by tho Tribunal before a ruling could be roachod, and this would result in a delay in tho continuation of tho presentation of the defendants ovidenco for, I should thirk, a minimum of c wcok, and very likely aich .ongor then that. So, ny position is that wo bo p-.rn.ttod tc file brief on each defendant at a time, I should hope, before he begins tc present his defense evidence. Such briefs, of course, would be m do vailtfclc to the Dcfonse Counsel, 3D J az.—Jr-C?-17-1 o-5e ar d-JP Court I asd at sono point before tfco conclusion of his caso tho Tribunal would reach a ruling on the question raised, 7rZ PH2SIIG2*7: The Tribunal will oak tho Counsol for tho Prooocution •hat boforo tho defendants are call upon to proccod with their ovldonco, the Prosecution ietonds, itsolf, to ask a disnlssal as to any oount against any dofondant? XP.. KcfiASZTl That nay woll, bo. Tour Honor. I an not propared, at this tiro, to rako any dctallod statonont on thr.t point, but aftor a caro- ful analysis of the proof as it has gono into tho prosocution's cnoo in chiof, wo will attempt to bo quito liberal in ol 1 = 1 noting any points which wo do not think wo gonuinoly in issuo and not gonuinoly provod by tho Prosooution# TK2 -KMSimtt It would aooo, as to tho objections rnisod by Dofoifto Counaol, to cortnin ovldonco that has boon introducod, as not falling within tho char£0s nanod within tho Indlctoont, that tho soonor that quoation bo eo'.tlcd too bottor in ordor that tho defendants would know what ovidor.ee they would fcavo to proper®. If that quootlon was not eottlod until or.eh dofondant was callod, ho would probably fool onmpollod to proparo ovldonco on those points which night or night not bo portinont. KP.. KeSAHETt I think that is vory truo. Tour Honor, nnd that was tho third p* int which I hnvo stated has bc:n ralsod tho oponlng statononts of tho Dofcr.oo Codneol. THE Fassmttli I understood tho Counsol for tho Prosocution, but I had tho inproasion that tho Counsol for tho Prosocution though each ono of thoso quostiono could bottor bo sottlod ns tho enso of each individual dofendant was callod instead of sottling it in r.dvnnco. I cay be incorrect. I nay have cisundorstood tho Counsol for tho Prosocution, KR. IIcHAFET: I probably did not oxprosa nysolf clonrly. I think tho question could probably be ruled upon rathor easily and without tho sub=iB3ior. of any oxfcansivo briefs. It sinply is a question of whothor or not tho i 2283 JO jaa-*-G2S-17-W.-3««ri Coart 33- !• ctarfifl contained in paragraph 6 is proof enough to perait the Prosecution to , # > a proof of experiments which are not particularised in *uVparagra--hs of jyiragraph 6. And. once the Tribunal has decided one way or the other on question t5ien it will be either incumbent on the defendants to Beet that proof in their case or they =ay if they chose disregard it. Of course, the evidenco. I think, no natter what way the Tribunal rules on the question Just raised would be adnissible aai could be considered by •a* Tribunal against the particular defendant, especially on the conspiracy Count, and in any event, going to the notice and knowlodge of *he particular dofennant; th^t ia, knowledge of the scope of medical oxporiaontatlone on concentration camp lncates. Going to the question of cdaiseiblllty of evidenco. it is simply a TjUestlon of whether or not it now constitutes a charge of criaoa against toe defondant upon whether he could be found guilty by tho Tribunal; and, w.«t is the question whica, I think, would haoo to bo rulod upon probably boforo any of the Defonse Counsel presonts any ovidonco In ordor thet thoy would bo odvlood of the Tribunal's attitudo on that point. 2239 M 30 Ja&-Jr-JF-16-l-?itxgorald-JP Court I JUKE snusat Mr. XcHaney* tho Tribunal understand* as far as Count II and Count III nro concerned, charges of cricos against Huaanity and ver crinos they are in and of thonsolvos sufficient basis on vhich to predicate proof of crlalnality. The particulars of sub-parngraphs A to L, inclusive, are not a linitation upon the general allogata, but ooroly descriptive particular* of tho gonoral criea chargod. Is that vhrt you contend? A J3U !!eEA23Yi That is corroct. Tour Honor. IE. Fiaxzrot Attoraoy for tho Defondant Hrugovsky; Mr. President, tho Prosocution has Just suggested that it did not soon dosirablo to thon if tho Court should now docido whothor tho lndictncnt is insufficient on cortain grounds and should thoroforo bo dismissed. I would liko to point out tho following: Tho cajority of dofonco couneol hold tho point of viow that thoro Is no logal basis for tho chargo on tho count of conspiracy. If tho Court decides this quostlon now, thoro will bo no nocossity for any defonso oouneol going into this question during his case. It will thoroforo savo tino for tho dofonso counsol and it will also savo tino for tho Court who would hnvo to llaton to statceonts of dofonso counsol lator. Turthomoro, tho Prosocution in rogrxd to Count II of tho Indictaont, hoc stated that thoy considor it dosirablo, unless I ni^ndorstood tho translation, to state in dotoll what is chargod against oach dofondant only when tho coso of that defendant cocos up. j 2290 l-o Jin-47 A-?JC-lS-lb-Gitzeonli ! 'r-urt no. 1 If tho auacostioo of tho prosecutions followed on thl3 point, tho . :sSd -uoaco would tbr.t the dofenso would not know, durine tho whole period -r prepnrr.tion, for which counts it asst propnre mterlcl. yor oxr^plo, la the cof Defondint Uwccwsiy, I hr.ve fivo counts of Count II 'of tho Indictamt. I hnve atr.ted thet tho chnrso-is aot founded and ' aUould ho dlsnissod. Tto ^uostlion new* ia 'Aether I rust 0*01 witnesses for taose five counts, have cffidnYita prepared — conorrlly, pro-aro the ontiro defense — or whether the Court will now ax-rlno tho question whothor tho p-caocution has presorted evidence on these counts wbioh j\ y he coasfderod ^ cccelusivo proof nealnat tho Defendant Urecowsky. If tho Prosocution has not autxxittod such proof, thon, la ny opinion, tho ohrr» should bo disniasel and tho Tribunal the dofonse will not havo to concorn thonaolvoa with thaso counts rnyrv’rc. Othor dofonao counsol aro in errctly the mne position. Furthor, the rrosooution pointed out that durin r. its caao, it aubulttod rr.torlil on counts whioh woro not inoludod in tho Indiotuont at nil* I any point out that a regular chnrco, aa de.w«dod by the Chartor, has not toon undo. ■3x0 Charter roqulroo thot the Dafoadant known when he is chnrcod and »lth whnt ho is chnrcod* fittl that ho 3o prosontol with this infomtion in sufficiont do till. We do not know ovon todny, -hloh of tho dofonlanto tho Trmacution ia ohnrcln, for tho varlcua expori-vonts. i rofor, for axacplo to the Polyral oxpori nntB rod similar oxporisxmte. >D J: r.u ry-A—DJG-18-lc-Fitzgercld Court So. 1 In the entire c«e of the Prosecution, this hoe not boon etotd. Ho are told only new which defendants are charged with which crimes, and what evidence and whet proof the Prosecution has. I should therefore like to oak the Tribunal, whether at the present stage of tho trial, a docision can bo reached as to which counts the-charges arc inadequate and not according to the charter of the Tribunal, and should therefore be dismissed. I ask that so defense counsel may know for the preparation of our ccso, ■hat we have to deal with and what evidence wo will have to present-, DR. FEZlAGNGs Attorney for Viktor Brr.ch, Ur. President, part of de¬ fense ccunssl in their opening otatoownto did not mention the inrdmiasability of Count I of the Indictment. I do not know tho reasons for this. I cen cnly speak for aysolf, consequently, when I sty that I ocpressly end inten¬ tionally did not discuss this question because I consider it a part of tho final plcc. However, sinco tho Prosecution has brought this important point ^ up for discussion, and has suggostod that it migit be expediont to hc.vo tho Tribunal decide on certain Important points new, I should like to state, ex¬ pressly for ay client, Viktor Bruch, that he agrees with tho otatments of dofense counsel who objoctod to Count I this morning. JR. UcH^NEY: I would like to stqto tho Prosecution recognizes that tho issue of the logal basis cf Count I is being raisod by all defendants. They need not make their application, i.o concode they all rciso this question, although it has not been mentioned by all of them. THS PRESIDENT! The record nay show that that is understood and agreed to by tho Tribunal. DR. SEIDELt Attorney for the defendants Cobhart, Oborhauscr, and Fis¬ cher; Jr. President, to supplement tho statement of ay cclloaguo. Dr. rloxdng, I should like to add the followings I make tho application which the Prosecution has Just suggested. In tho ccursc of tho proceedings, dccu-»_nts have been submitted concerning experi¬ ments and oedical experiments which are net listed in the indictment. At the beginning c£ the trial, one defense counsel stated that the In¬ dictment did not fulfill the requirements of the Charter. It was pointed cut that the Indictment did net list, in detail, the crimes with which the 2292 y> Jam r7-/.-WG-l&-2c-Fit*€crald Court Ko. 1 defendants are charged, and that it licit©! Itself to legal statement*. I refer tc Article IV of the Charter where it says: -To preserve the rights of the defendants, the following procedure is tc bo laJcen: The defendants ore tc bo given a copy of tho Indictment as well os all documents within a reasonable period before the proceedings. The Indictment is to list the charges dearly and in sufficient dotcil in order to inform the defendants about tho punishcblo actions with which they are charged." I take the liberty of pointing out that before tho proceedings 4 2293 - JC Jaa-^-KS-lS-ld-ritsgerald psurt So* - • • U defendants were not given any docunents *.® r. I take the liberty of jointing out. further, that in all these nine count, of the Indictment. for exasplo* the exporin-ni. on Polygcl are not aentionod. -ten. aonths after the begirding of the trial, the Prosecution cone. with now charge, fnis is in opposition of the Charter, and the rights of the defendants are being Infringed upon. Those rights wore to bo protected by A t&cfto rules. tb.refor.. =•!» *pUe.tl« th.. th. Utobtion of Ibo Pro..cuUo„ to latroduco new char go 1 be rojeotod. ,B. KcHaWT: I thick the Tribunal understands tho position of the Pro¬ secution on this point. I do not ~nt to oven begin to engage in extended argusont. It couo. a. southing of a surprise to hoar any defense eouneil. » 0 participated In Case Sumbor I before tho International Kilitary Tribunal, tt^gost that wo have not advised tho deforciants of tho nature of the crinos with w.icii they are chargod. The Indletcent in this case contains so nany tore particulars and is "> mi mt9 definite than the Indictment which was sustained before tho Inter- a national Kilitary Tribunal that th.ro is no comparison between tho two. The Prosecution ha. node an effort to advise each and every defendant in the dock of the ^ajor charges against hiu. We now hoar th- suggestion =nde that wo ar* to bo United because of the particulars shlcn wo have given. Th- crinc charged against those defendant, is t hat they hav* conuittod war crinos aid crinos against humnity in that they they have unlawfully and criminally experimented upon involuntary human subjects. I submit that it would not h..vo been r closed question if Paro- j gra* 6 without any particulars whatsoever would h-vc boon a sufficient indictment, particularly in face of tho Indictment vnich was sustained in _ Cu#d I. Use. in the charge sheets wnicn are submitted to tho defendants before -.no . .litter. Cessions, such a. the one at Dachau, they have tried upward, of 75 on a charge Keel of not more than one page nrd which contains only JC jan-^-OZS-ia-ld-msgerald Court S’. -• .« defendants were not given any docunsat. *W>Mr. I take the liberty of pointing out, further, that in all these nine co-date of the Indictaent. for exasple, the exportin'.* on Polygnl are not nentionod. ^.en, aonths after the beginning of the trial, the Proeec-ation cone. with new charges. This is in opposition of the Charter, a* the rights of the defendant, arc being infringed upon. Those right, wore to ho protected by these rules. I, thoroforw. =«*> application lh.1 Ih. lnt.ntlon of loo Prowcution to X introduce new chorgos be rojected. l8 . KcHdUXT: I tnirJt the Tribunal understand, the position of tho Pro¬ secution on this point. I do not want to cron begin to engngo in extended •rgUBODt. It couos a. soothing of o surprise to hear any defense couna>l. *•<, participated in Case Sunbor I before tho International Military Tribunal, suggest that wo have not advised the defendants of the nature of the crinos with wnich they are charged. Itoo Indictcent in thia Case contains so aany noro particulars and is so cued aore definite than tho Indictaent which was sustained before tho Inter¬ national Military Tribunal that there is no coeperison between tho two. Tfco Prosecution ha. undo an effort to advi.o each and ovory defendant in the dock of tho -ajor chargos against hiu. Ve now hear tho suggestion code that wo are to bo United because of tho particulars *ich wo have given. The crinc charged against these defendant, is t hat they hav„ committed war crises aid crino. against hunanity in that they thoy have unlawfully and criminally experimented upon involuntary human subjects. I subnit that it would not h..wo been , closod question if Para¬ graph S without any particulars whatsoever would hrve boon a sufficlont indictaent, particularly in face of tho Indictment wnich was sustained in &.8d I. Uso. in tho charge shoots which are submitted to tho defendants before too . unary Commissions. sue:, ns the ono at Dachau, they have tried upward, of 75 =»on on a charge sheet of not more than one page nrd whicn contains only 50 Jhn-.*-5I& i l>-ld-ritxgorald. Court So. 1. general languor* of crises. It is sot hero a question of dismissing any paragraph of tse Indictment. Those son are charged under Paragraph 6 end osier Paragraph 11 vith having connitted van crises and criaos against humanity respectively. Vo describe tho way in which those crinos wore sub- nit ted. If tho Prosecution is prepared to concodo it has not proved that Earl Brandt was inpllcated in the hi^>-altitude ezporiconts or that ^Looo «b not implicated in ono of the other ezporisonts; it is not a (jiostlon of die- nlosing any pert of the Indictnont. Tho crlno char god Sc cor-tainod in Pnra- gra.-h 6. The Prosocution nay woll concodo wo have ondo no proof on a part¬ icular sub-paragraph thereof: but it constitutes no disaietal of anything Against that particular dofendant. It docs rolisvo his of tho liability of going forward with proof that he was cot i.plicated in that. Of course, this Tribunal has ovory right to caw review the evidence in tho prisa facie caso srdo by tho Prosoaotion. If it decidos wo hevo not put in a priaa facio caso agninet Karl Brandt on the uign-altitudo experiments, tho Triburol can so advise Karl Brandt, and ho will not have to go forward with vro of on that particular oxpurinent. But, certainly, thor. is no question of dismissing anything in tho Indictnont. Earl Brandt stands equally accusod under Pnragrn.h 6. 7K1 PHSSIISKTt Counsol's position is corroct in ruling that if tho Prosocution has not aado a cuso under a count, it would n*x cdll for a dismissal. It would call for a ruling that tho dofondant would bo rollovod froo going ahead with robuttal ovidonco on that certain charge or count or what it night bo callod. KB. KcHilZY: Bint is correct. ?hf* is tho way tho Prosocution undorstands it. 2295 Car t So. 1 3G-*er. 47-A-£2-a-ia<-fc£yac TK£ MA R S H AL; The Tribuna.1 it again la session. I 5 i rRiSiriKT: The Tribunal has tehee note of the cueationa raised by the defecae counsel ea to whether, aa e natter of law, not a netter of feet, the defendanta any ho held to anaver the charge of ccnaplracy to oonalt war crlaea and crlcea against hunacity. Thla la a basic legal cuoatlon which, toetuae of ita extreoe lnportance, the Trlbunrl la of the opinion ahould bo answered only after the aueatUn has been fully briefed and asgued by all pertlet to the caus*. Therefore, the Trlbum1 will not prse upon the quca- tlon at this tine, but will reserve Its ruling thereof until finol hearing ,nd rfter full consideration md argunent and will Incorporate lta conclu¬ sions on the oueetlon in such cplnl-n and Jud/pont of the Tribunal na will finally be rendered. Second; Soas thing was said by the r rosoeutlon innsdiMtely prior to tho afternoon recess of the Tplbun/1 to the effect that It wee not the deelr« of the prosecution to put any defendant upon proof as to any charge which tho prosecution night feel It had failed to establish. In view of tho etetenent of tho nroeocution, which the Tritun.'1 contends, tho Tribunal suggests to the prosecution that It be prepared to Mice any announcenont upon that natter which it wishes t^ naJce prior to the opening of tho S defendants' ceso on Monday, 3 Jobrurry 19-»7. Third: Concertfts^:'Questions roieed by defendanta' counsel ae to evl- donco introduced by tho prosecution concerning acts of defendants not spa- eiflcaliy charged os crines by paragraph 6 nnd paragraphs "A" to "L", inclusive, A the Indictnent, tho Tribunal nnnouncce that it reserves lte ruling upon any such question until the close of the caae. 2256 JO Jar. 47-A-FJC-22-1 Cocrt i* 5 . 1 ; - Is thero any further cutter to be cfilled to tho attention of the -ribunul? ja. UC H;jfK: In connection with tfco Tribunal's ruling on tho sa-oal point, I would like to ask if it would bo satisfactory if on Monday TO c«lo such announcoccnts as wo cay haro to cako with rospoct only to tho ease of Karl Brandt* 1H3 p'BSIDZ’.T: Ite*PP®are to-tho Tribunal that it would bo only ftXr to the defoliants if that annou n co c ent wore nado as soon as poaslblo. It dfrt not necessarily bo u*io Uondny corninc, but, if any sucS announ¬ ce .on t is to bo cade, it would b. well to nrjco it as soon as possiblo so X ■MX tho dofoalants would bo ndvisod that as to rjjy such specification or chnrse it would not to nocosa-ry for thou to procuro witnossoo or introduce rrtdoaco. That was tho only point in the alnd of tho Tribunal in suRfiootlne that announcouoat be urdo Uondny ivorninc. Iho Tribunal is sot holding tho Proaooutlon tc anythin*. In oonnectTun with that nattor, -at if tho oanounaoajint, if any, is nrdo as soon as possiblo, with duo regard to tho cutter which I havo Just nontionol, that would bo satis¬ factory to tho Tribunal* W. UC H-J3Y: Tory well, Your Honor, THE ra dP HTi Does that answer your quostlon? IX. UC H'JfEf: Yos, indoed. U!. R.VJSCH2NZL.CH (Counool for Dofondant Schaof jr)s Hr. ?rosidont, I have a quoation which has boon touche! upon noithor by tho discussion^ toforo the rocoss nor by tho rulinr uhich has Just boon -iron by tho Tribunal. It is a question connoctod noithor with tho quostlon of tho conspiracy nor vith th^ by th© 2297 Court I 30 Jar, U7-A - 22- lb - LX - Haynes fTosecution. I aade the request with regard to the defendant Schaefer that his ease be i.-sai dl ately dlsaissed. I believe that I have understood the ueeber of the Prosecution ©crrectly to the effect that he aeans that such a dismissal could only be decided upon when the case is being presented. However, when the case is being presented and the presentation of evidence has been completed, then wo may Just as well wait until t£e vortiict. It is the pract ce of the English and kserican courts to which I X have referred, as far as it has cone to cy knowledge from the literature tiiich has boon nade available to has the effect of finishing the case before the presentation of evidence; that is, after the presentation by the Prosecution when it is already demonstrated that the defendant can not be sentenced. Ihoreforo, I want to point out once ooro tho possibility with rogard to the case of Schaofer to make a ruling to this effoct boforo I present evidence on behalf of the dofendant Schaofor. That is the quostion of the dismissal of the proceedings against Schaefer and his discharge fr«a confinement. DP.. WEI3Q8RBER (For defendant Silvers)j Mr. President, nay I bo permitted to ask one more question withregard to point No. I? If I have correctly understood the ruling of tho High Tribunal, thon tho decision can only be aide on Foint I when tho defense has raado a statement with rogard tothis quo^ticn. In my presentation this morning I staUd that I have not taken any atar.d with respect to tho question of the conspiracy bocauso I have joined in tho state amt tj f try colleagues, and, therefore, I have not --ado axy statement of ry own in this connection in order to avoid repeti¬ tion. If the Tribunal should desire a statement of all the Defense Counsel who have not touched this question specifically, then I would request the Tribunal to nako a statement with regard to this subject. THE PRESIDENT: I stated thatT this question would be reserved until *>.€ close of the case when all defendants may be heard upon the matter. The ruling cf the Tribunal is nade strictly without prejudice to the right. 2296 Court I 30 Jar. U7-A - 22- 2 b - LX - Haynes cf ary defendant to urge the natter of the conspiracy charge and its inapplicability to ary or all defendants. The right is expressly reserved to any or all defendants. The right is expressly reserved tc the defendants to argue and present that question at the proper tire at the close of the case. Upon the question Just suggested by Counsel for t\o defendant Schaofer, *ich has been auggosted by other Defense Counsel, the Tribunal will reservo its ruling upon ary such notions, »hich cay be renewed at an X appropriate tino. The Tribunal strictly preserves to the defendants the right to urge tho question «tiich has been suggested. The Tribunal ut this tine reserves its ruling. Thoro bolng no further question to eons before the Tribunal, the % Tribunal will reaoss until 0930 o'clock Monday Morning. (Tho Tribunal recessed until 0930 hours, 3 February 19U7) 2299 3 7ob-S35-l-l-7ostcr-JP Court I C033XCTE) COPT Official Transcript of the Ac ericas Military Tribunal in tho natter of the ttaitod Statos of Aaorica, against Earl Brandt* et al.. dofendante, sitting at Furnborg, Goraanyi on 3 Fobruary 1947* 0930, Justico Beals presiding* TEZ MARSHAL: The Honorable, tho Judges of Military Tribu na l. Military Tribunal 1 is now in Session. God savo tho tfaltcd Statos of ^norice and this honorable Tribunal. Thore will bo ordor in tho court. ^ TEZ PRZSIDETT: Mr. Marshal, you ascertain if the defendants nro all presont in tho onurfroo*. THE KA? SEALS May it pleoso Tour H«n'.r, all tho dofondants aro presont in tho court. 7H3 PRESIDENT: Tho Socrotary-Ocnoral will noto for tho rocord tho proscnco of all tho dofondants in tho court. Tho dofoaso ney proceed. MR. UcEAXET: Mo/ it ploaso tho Tribunal, prosocutlon wlshos to announce that in ordor to shorten tho trial and to ollnlnato arguoont it Toluntarlly renovos as lssuos in this action, tho following chargos containod in tho indictaont. Agalnet tho Defendant Karl Brandt, tho Chnrgo in paragraph 6a concerning participation in tho higi>-altitudo o»- porinonts; against tho Dofondant Handlosor, tho Chnrgo in paragraph 6a ooncorning participation in blgh-altitudo oxporlsonts. Vo will havo further announccsonts of this sort to siOco in tho courso of tho next fow days we oxpoct. It is undorstond that tho rceoral of thoso lssuos fr»c tho ccso with rospcct to tho foregoing-dofondants constitutes no adaloalcm by tho prosecution that such dofondants did not as a natter of fact in thoso experinonts. will noto for tho rocord tho by tho prosocutlon. tho Dofondant Earl Brandt): On behalf and with tho penalssion of tho of tho Lofendont Karl - ? ?c' ? Jcb-Z3r-l-2-Tost^r Court Vo. 1. Tribunal I shall call the d-'frndant to the witnesc stand at once. •y? F’"«I’"T: The Tribunal grants the perr.i salon. refon¬ dant lari aren't will take the witness stand. : ;c "At'BT: .‘ay it pi. ase th< Tribunal, we havo no objection to the defendant Brandt taking the witness stand it this tier. However, I wish the record to she*? that the prosecution has not bocn advised that *.=c lefendant Brandt would take tho stand at this tine and hencoforth I will ack that all defense counsel comply with the rule of the Tribunal vhich requir s that a rininuc of 34 hours notice- br given to the prosecu¬ tion. It is to br xn'ct. d that pros-cution will have a few quostions to put to one or the other of the vitn.o«.s to be called by the defonse end vc would like to hire cone tin-' to consider those questions. yr fTSI^: In the fdtur. the defrns-- counoel will obs-rvo tho rulo end give the pros- cution 34 hours notice of the calling of any witness whether a defendant or a witness. I*. S~BYATrJS: Kr. President. on Saturday the ! arshnl of the court asked r»r who the witness s weuld bo that I was going to call and I told hie that the defendant hlrs. lf would, be tho first to take the stand. I assured, that the prosecution too would be inforoed accordingly. That is how the error arosr. l'JLU 3 r AFTT, a defendant, took tho stand and. testifi'd. ac follows: 3Y JUICE ST3VIKG: 0 Hold ur. ycur ri-;hth»nd and. b. svsra, rep. ating after nc; I cw.ar by God. the Alrlghty and OcMeci. nt, that I will sp «k the pure truth end will withhold and add. nothing. (Th. witn ss r-'peated tho eath.) ■uiAriFtTio' BY STl-ATIUS: ^ Witness, state your nan.' and when yen were bom. A Ky race is Karl Brandt and I was btrr. on January 8. 190*. ^ Will you describe to the Tribunal an element of your life until 2201 I 3 }Vb-IBH-l-3-?ostcr Court Fo. 1. you started studying at the University. A First of all, in ny ho=c- town at Kuohlhausrn I visited school and a condary school. In 1919 when i:u.'hlhaua«-n and Alsaco had been oc¬ cur loi ^y the French I was instructed to 1-avo and I ter-porarll;' took up rcsid. r.ce in Thuringia, *h ro I visited a prep school for secondary school, and tne last two years until cy ratric I spent at Ircsdcn in a boarding school vher- I passpd ay ratriculation exaninntion. I Faosod sy ratriculation in 1933. stock to give ne his assistance nainly bocauso of his organi- xation of talent. In addition, I knew that because of the porsoapl friendship which existod between us there could bo found a special roliiw- bility. Horo perhaps I ray point out tho personality of Trofossor Rostock. Urory person who had any doalings with hln will at first say, and tho expression used in Go many would bo that -ostock le a good nan, and as our oocnoa teacher Magnus ho had a consoiously hunan attitudo towards pationts and then this attitudo can bo found in Rostock, and it originals free a bora friendliness. With roforonco to tho treatment of his subordinates in tho clinics and tho nurses or assistants, it Is a foot that tb 07 , as woll as the patients, roepoctod hln. Ho is nedically absolutely rolinblo, and all of his activities wore devoted to tho benefit of tho pationt, and ho was superb teacher for to studento. Iho Prosecution has alroady pointed out tho rospoct which hns to bo granted to tin as a scientist and rightly so. How nognificont it is nay bo soon fron tho fact that tho faculty of Sorlin noclnatod as thoir Doan and with that thoy ebowod vory clearly and with that ho bccono vory dourly ro- prosentative of all tho Goman nodical faculties. q. Vitnoso, I shall now turn to your political caroor. Vhon did you .Join tho H3DAP? A. I bo car. o a c«bor of the National Socialiet party in January 1932. q. And what was the reason which load you to it? A. Tor no a docisivo reason was tho ooncoption of the social ques¬ tion. At that tino I was an assistant in tho Ruhr territory and every poraon who rocords thoso years will inegiho the bopoloso situation 2311 3 ?eVW-?JC-4-l-Ook-JP Court I which existed at that tino. Ihero was unccployneat end suffering, a ror 7 uncloar prospect of the future. Ihero was unreliability. All of this in a country of this rod earth daaanded soncthing fron us. Pron the start, he cans o of family acquaintances, 3 Job 4 7-lC-TJ C-4—2—Cock joart »». 1 I ~ 3 clcsa *» circles of y-iedrich fcunann, and erlslne free this connec¬ tion tho decision to beccne.a corbor of the Party was sot very difficult. 'I Did you belong to cny othor nodical association? A I becar-o a susbor of tho national socialist Loacuo of physicians, but 1 cr*o into no closor connection with then. Apart free this rxnborship, I did not at teal a slnelo sooting and it nay have keen an oversight on yy F that I renamed a Mtftor. •! then Joined.the Lo-sue of Physicians with a condition which i put in writinc, that I would not oxorciso any active duty in any SS or Si fornation. i thoafjkt it was nocossary at tho tine, so that aa a physician j waild not be ooasidorod a politician by r-y patient^ who followod devious political linos. X \ 30 thon 7°° •rorcisol no activity m that association? A Ito. 'I :;oll how did you oexje into cont-ct with tho fuohror in spite of that? A I forr-orly pointed out tho rotor car accident of Bruocknor and it * in 1954 whon tho first nootinc of Hltlor and Jluscolini took placo in T»sico, and Hltlor hlnsolf noodod an oscort hyoician thon beoauso thoro was possibility of an attoiiptod assr.ssination. Bcnonborlns thio rotor car sooldont I*is Adjutant Bruockhor telephoned :» in Borlin and ordored ne to ccuo io Bunich and i flew with bin to vonlce, and this ovent really was tho b*,1aalnc of ay subsequent funotion as tho oscort physician of Hltlor. I should liito to point out tho difforontiation *iich I rate botwoon tho personal physiol an cal oscort phyoioian. Hie personal physician is porhaps a physician who occasionally is called in casos of illnoss. in ay c-so as an oscort physician I tad to bo In readiness, at sia disposal, and whonovor Hltlor had to leavo lirlia it w s ry duty to accompany hia. That, of oourso, entailed, at any p,t * r - ftor th ® be-ainnla.- of tho war, that I needed two roprocontativac for ^ function, oao was In Eorlln and tho othor lr. Munich. Othorwlso, I oould k*. hare regained in Berlin at all. A , ”oro you at that tine already a :xn'or of tho SS? A In 1933 I was a ronbor of tho SA, and only aftor tho visit to Venioo, 1 v ~ 3 transferred to the SS. This v-s for :;oroly external reasons. Thon all r-arsons acconaanyia.; Hltlor voro SS unifon-s and 1 had civilian clothing and in :r;or to presont a uniforr: picture ho wanted ro to waor a unifora. 2312 3 FoWWU-t-S-l-Grosfr-JF Coart I Q. Vboro did you serve your nilitary duties? A, I sorvod with the Amy - it was ia 1935 - at first with tho Infantry Eeginont. It was in Slankenburg/Hars and la tor after I bccano nodi dal officor la tho Airy I sorted ia ho«pitala whoro I served ny yoar- 17 duties. I havo boon aasigned to Berlin as a surgooa. Q. Aod what activities did you axorciso during tho Var? A. 3y ordor of tho Airy Iaspoctorato I was assigned to tho 'uohror's Headquarters in tho ysar of 1940 and also, bocauso of fornor roasons, I A was troneforrod to tho Vaffen-SS by tho gcnornl SS without holding a con- % cand and also without loading a unit. Sinco I was still sorving in tho Arry and Exorciso thoroto ny promotions woro a proxlnatoly parallol. Usual¬ ly.' I was first pronotod by tho Amy. Uy last rank in 1943 was Gcnoralnrzt, and in accordance with that tho SS pronotod no. Q. Uas ouch a ere bination of activities, both in tho SS and in tho Amy, soao thing custonary7 A. Vith tho oxccption of ny own oaso I know no othor. Q. How wan your rolationaship to Himlor? Did you bolong to his closer circlo? \ I had no personal relationship to Hinnlor. I pointod out boforo that I really had oorious nodical difforoncoo with hiu - von Brohnor and Strolchor, *nd also during tho Var when a closer contact night havo taken placo thero was certain poroonal tonsion of the circlo around Hitler and tho circlo around Hinnlor. Q. Voro you alwayo officially askod to attond Grupponfuchror discussions hold by Einclor? A. As I said, I had no rclatiofiship to Eimlor. Shis also oxtondod to the official fiold, I took part in nono of tkoao co-oallod Gruppon- fuohror or SS leaders' discussions. I was novor invited to attond any¬ one of then. Sren professionally there was no contact be two on us. Sono- tifioe it even went so far, and documents will probably confira, that, that Hinnlor consciously tried to ronovo no fron his circlo and his path and soeotincs even pronounced prohibition to get into any contact with no. 2313 3 7 pb-*TMAJ^ 5 - 3 -Sro ss-JP Court I How was contact of tfao staff belonging to Hitler and Hlnsler? Vas there a close cooperation? A. They did not collaborate, they hardly saw one another, and over. free tho point of view of location woro vory far apart. At lowral occo- Bions tho word "Tuchror Bauptquartier" is used hero and one nay gain tho icpresslon that it was a litVle carp whero evoryono was togothcr. That wasn't tho caso at all. Binder's Headquarters or tho Instituto of tho C*V, tho Instituto of tho Vchrnncht Gporatlon Staff and the real Fuehrer Eoadqurrtoro - and that was tho only ono that could boar that nano - woro wry far apart, eaooticos 30 to 30 kilonotors apart and nunberod a % largo Mount of porsonnol oach. I rooonbor that at ono tino when wo had to novo fror tho Ukralno to another torritory wo had to transport sonothing liko 18,000 hvean beings. Q. And how did thoso two staffs collaborate poroonally? Did you hero any cloaor relation with Roiohearst S8 0rnwit*7 A. I had no porsonal contact with Orawit*. Ho wno a typical subor¬ dinate of Sicalor, Judging froo gonoral uttorancos, ono who wns crrplotoly doTotod and oubordinato. During the last part of tho War in 1945 I had a fow discussions with hie but not in tho capacity as Rofcchonrst SS but ao Prosldont of tho Rod-Cross, since at ehat tino togothor with tho ^ Chiof of tho Aray Kcdlcal Sorvico I triod to doelgnoto cortain citlbo an hospital cities in ordor to'keep then away fron the Var in that nannor, and for this purposo wo noedod Orawit* in ordor to uso hie oonnoction with tho Goman Rod Cross and thoroby establish oonnoctions with tho Intor- nationol Rod Cross in Geneva. q, Then what wore your political tios in your officoT U In any office fron a political point of view I was loft conplote- ly along up to the autxcn of 1944, and by that I moan cy office which I hold ovor since 1942 after I bccaso Gonoral Coanissioncr for Hoalth and Modical Sorvices, not a singlo ono of cy co-eorkors, noither in ny offico Planning and Econony or Science and Ho so arch, was a nor.bor of tho SS, not even a d cr.bc r of tho gonoral SS. In tho Departoent of Planning and 2314 . . - . _ : j 3 7c^--i^5-2-C-ro 8 »-J? Coart Z Scotty, even up to >rccber 1944, I hud t. Jevish vortcero out of ten •ocrctarioi I had, and vfcn caao frre Industry, together with their section chiof. I cfcaao ny collaborator* only going hy tholr % 3 7cVK-Kl^-S-3-^"«*-JP Court I professional knowlodgo - everything cl bo did not natter to ao. Q. D ld you than reject tho SS or. principle? A. So. I sorer sew la the SS a gathering of car. who had only not in those units a load through- And if I think of tho young officers who were etchers of tho Waff on SS who wcrkod in Hitler's Eoadquartors aa Ordnance-. Officers, then ! think of thoso four non, throo have died, and the fr.uXth was hoavily woundod. I. whenover I wear tho uniforn, always were it with on ldoe to hare a spocial coral obligation and I did not roar it without prido. Q. Witness, I now coco to another subjoct, sooothlng which wo haro already touchofi upon, nacoly, thoeo Bpccial hoBpital inatitutoa wo haro alroady diacuaood, spociflc task of hospital planning. Will you shortly dofino your attltudo to that? A, X pointod out that arising free tho planning of tho Borlin Uni¬ versity Institute X had a spocial study of hospital buildings of tho entire Oornany. 3 oforo tho beginning of the War I nado nany journeys abroad with an architect and X inepoctod hospital buildings and studlod thoir orgrnlxatlonal fraco work and that noodod certain knowledge of tho situation of hospitals In Goroany itself. Before tho War, and I re just giving you tho round flguros, wo had approxiaatoly 5E0 to 600,000 hospital bod in Go many. And you haro to take away approxinatoly 250,000 Mid 250,000 bolongod to Genoral Hospitals, that is to any, gonernl hospitals, surgical clinics, etc. Tho tmo anount, thet is approxinatoly 250,000 bods up to approxinatoly 300.000 conprised tho nontal Institutes. Bods for tuboroulootfc lllnossos. TMe was a bad situation which probably now has bo coco nuch worse. There wore cortain cantors of cravlty In this hospital concern which wore cnlnly at points where Industry was concen¬ trated, that is, in the Ruhr territory and central Goroany. In con¬ sequence there was a lack of hospital space in these territories and it van especially serious there. In tho year 1941 tho first Snglish air raid took place on tho tpwn of Sedan. At that tine tho entire hospital vas destroyed. Ur. Todt who was carrying out the repair work and tho rebuilding as f -r as possible and who 2315 3 Feb 1 7-..-ibb.-5-l-Grc3s Court ifc. 1 '.-as au.vcsod to be In charge of that vrrlc osro tc the Fuehrer's Ifcadcuartcrs with a de. anti that a new hospital *>c built an .ierfen. On tho sere day \rhcn iviJa.j tlvis dcicni I was assigned by tho Headquarters t. designate evacuation li.ffiitals for cthwr cities which wore in danger. These plans, which in tho h^imir.j '~?rr c a .-rativcly s -V . ll , attended in tlx. subsequent years, that is up to 1?U2-U3, end iron tiiis ifv.lc qaootx'n there developed even later after Tedt line’ lie.'. 3 Peb. 47 -M-6-1-PSP- Leaser i Court Ko. 1 Then, In connection with Speer and his department, Building, thor« dovolopci the task of the building of the special Hospital Institution Action Brandt. Up to the yo\r of 1944 approximately 30 institutions which at that time had operated, were being used. In every case there were cceploto hospitals with 500 bods each which wero buUt according to a systen of villas -nd were % located approxi-a-taly 20 kilceeters outside the linits of the city in clangor. Starting from the y«=r -f 1943, these hospitals had to accept mainly such patients whoso trontnent would probably last for s:oo considerable tine, in order to use the space inside these citios in c-nror for pitionts whoro illness was only enticipitod for a short tine. In this connection I should like to point out that it was necessary to start a special transport system of the sick which was intended for those hospital institutions which wwi\» *11 under ay administration. These woro busses sit trucks which were rebuilt in accordance with its purpose “nd which had on their outside tho designation Hospital Institution Action Brandt. There wasn't one of our destroyed cities whoro those busses wore not used • — them- busses for the sick — and it frequently occurred that they not only collected eick people and injured pooplo who wero offectod by tho last raid, but they also h:/ to take care of evacuating other pooplo. I assuoo ttat this was submitted horo, I think it was in the form of nn affidavit by Ifcser, whoro the question of general sick transportation erno up. Q. V.itnoss, this yas “ spooial assignment belonging tb the building system which you received for tht institution of those special hospitals. Did you administrate this work fr_c the Fuehrer Hondquarters and did this taka up nuch of your time? / A. I exorcise 1 ! this activity, which at first was a planning activity, certainly up until the yoar of 1942, end I directed it from the Fuehrer Headquarters since I was tied to the t Hvadquarters.lt w-.s only in the year of 1942, in the suomvr, when I took ov*.r the Office of the Commissioner Gonoral, that I received a representative so th-*t I was in a position to move about aore fraoiy. In addition, the situation was tb t the Fuehrer himself currently wanted to be informed about those building operations. It was a hobby on his part to build and the building of hospitals :K bunkers was 231? 3 Feb. 4,7 -54-6-2-PX?- Lesser Court Mo. 1 really a thing which played an essential role during the lest yoars of the war. Q. Did those assigraents extend to other fields? A. Liter, certain connections began with the satire air raid precaution medical program, which really h=d more to do with the defense against % poison gas, but still established a certain connection with hospitals. Q. Urs this poison gas doerte in any relation to the nssignnent to the hospitals? ^ A. Mo. Q. And th t took place in the year of 1943 - 19U* ani that was tho situotion as it was then. At th-t tine you hr..-: already bccooo tho Reich Commissioner General forHcalth cnl Uodic-al Services? A. I becaao Roich Coaaissionor for Health and kodical Sorvicos through a Fuehrer Decree of July 19A2. TIE PRZSIDdM: At this tine tho Tribunal wiU ixcose. (A rocess was token.) 2316 3 G—Kc ohaa-JP Court X 733 KJ3S LAL: Ao Tribunal it again in soteion. K2. !ic£LL3Y: If tho Tribunal plcaiO. X an adriood that tho witness, Karl 3randt, is testifying free*, nates and other papers which he had before hia. I objoct to this and if tho court nwer-rulos this nbjoctian, I will ask that tho Prosecution bo furnishod with copies of theso notos and translations tho roof. IF.* SS27ATIUS* Hr. Prosidont, in tho trial boforo tho International Military Tribunal, it waa pornitted for tho dofendant to testify tho witnoss stand and to tako notos with hia in ordor to sicplify tho procood- % ings in riew of tho oxtonsiro notorial, othorwlao, tho oxanination will bo carriod out, but it nay tako a littlo longor. 733 HTSIIBBTl Tho objoction of tho Prosocution is oyor-rulod* DIB2CT EXAMINATION - Rosunod. BY m. SB7ATIUSI Q, Vitnosa, now I cono to your position ac Cocniosionor Oonoral for Modicine and Health natters. Vhon did you roooivo this ooaniaoion? iu By a docroo of July, 1942, I was assigned to this office. It was callod tho Gonoral Coaaisslonor for hoalth and nddical nattoro. Q. I shall hand you a copy of this docroc and ploaao connont on it. It is Docucont Bo. 000 and it is in Document Book No. 1. Will you ploaso first oxplain how this docroo cono to bo issued? A . This docroo was issued on the basis of a prictical dec and ■ nf tor tho wintor battlo in tho East in tho wintor of 1941-1942 and a roport cono through Dr, Todt and various other ngenclos to tho Puohror. I was oont along tho road froc Ssolonsk toward Moscow bofiauco rory nany battlo wounded woro said to be thorc who could not bo taken core of. Tho infor- nation was inoccurato and in part ontiroly incrediblo. I wont to tho area of Niascar end thorc at tho railroad station in tho snail vllingo, tho picture was about as follows: Thorc were ton big froight trains, closod froight cars all filled with wounded. Tho tenporaturo was botwoon 35 and 40 degrees colsiua bolow zero. Sonc of the bandagos and drossings of the 2319 3 7eV44-7-3-LJG-KccfcjL>-J? Court l 233 ) wounded wore eetua-'-ly frosen to the floor of thesara, Tho looonotlroe «r» fr«gon asd tte boilers broken. Tho nedieal persona©* troro trying to bolp th* wt.uni'ad as auch at thoy oould, but, of course, thit • ;rut&«U| iap'iggiblo. Xn the district, tfcoro woro about 10^00 woundod* At the rollroa f gtatioo, thero wore Wo nodical officers with a ntalnua Of ncdloal supplies and thogo two officers could hardly stay la tho town Itsolf, Ikr.ro wero snail building, which had bac# axran^od to jocolro the side, Vt they wero ovor erovdod and tho situatloa for tho woundod i i j r | ^ ( 9 ij/i »* m • 1 * wag slnlljr. Vchraacht a^enclos, with which X ostabllshsd sontaot, attonpt- od to nr tribe thogo conditions to a falluro of tho aodicri gonn*nurt I wa« Issued bccauso of tho noods of the frost. For tho Vohrnacht head thoro wero a few basi» shortconlngs. *cd attanpt was cado to invostigato this caso in 1944. Tho now chief of the Ychrnacht Kodical, Genoralobore- tabsarzt Hendlosor, who had previously hooa Amy physician and Arsy nodical .Professor, rotaiaod this position. Tho organization an eot up was not adjusted prnporly to tho Luftwaffe and tho Hovy, bocanso tho Ar=y itsolf was not represented, hut that tho Chiof in chorgo of all throo hr an eh oo was of tho Xxry. \ Q. Kow, would you plonso look at tho docroo itsolf and connont on thoso points whoro you yoursolf aro naned, that is B 3* and "4" of tho docroo? A. "3" says Z onpower for spoclal tasks and nogotiatlono, for special hospital supplies, and so forth, "I ocpowor Prof. Dr. Karl Brandt, subordinate only to no porsonally and rocoivlng his instructions diroct- ly froc no, to carry out spoclal tasks and negotiations to roadjust the roqulroncnts for doctors, hospitals, nodical suppllos, otc. botvoen tho nilitary and tho civilian soctors of the hoalth and Kodical Sorvicos." Point "4’ says, "That as Connisslonor Oonoral I an to bo lnfomod of all hrpixjnings in tho military and Civilian Soctor." Tho practloo undor this docroo uoant difficulties for no too. JUDGE SESinrGt Just a nlnuto, plooso, Vltnose. Dr. Sorvr.tius, In tho translation which wo havo hero, which is apparently tho official docusont filod with tho Socrotary Oonoral, this docroo of 28 July 1942. IE. S3EYASIUS: Tos. JUDOS SSSIIiG: It takes caro of Paragraphs 1, 2, 3 and 5. "4* apparently is onittod. IE. S—IYAT I US: Thero is no "S" on tho docroo. It oust bo a nio- tako in typing. Vo. 4 roads, *Wy plonopotontiary for Hoalth and Kodical Service.■ 2322 3 To b-H- SV-S-3-Kal 07-JP Court I 7SZ VITS3SS: ... I had direct contact with tho Luftwaffe and tho Vary end a Nodical Officer of the Luftwaffo was assigned to hixu IE. KdLUBTt That had bottor bo repoatod, tho ^liglish toxt didn't coao through for six or oight santcncos* I think it would bo host if they repeated that for tho record* ST IE. CTVATIUS: Will you plcaso gn back? Tho English translation did not cone through, - and com on t on points B 3* and *4" of tho doffroo7 A* Soction 3 says that X an ccpoworcd for apodal tasks and nego¬ tiations to adjust tho roquiroconts for doctors, hospital and nodieel supplies botwoon nilltary and civilian soctors, and the Hoalth and Nodi¬ cal Sorriccs, and that I re subordinate only to tho undorslgnod, that is to Hitler pors<-nally, and rocoiro instructions diroctly fr»n hie. Soction 4 says that I an to bo kept infornod about fundmontal ovonts in tho civ 11 Ion oorvico of tho Vehmacht and Nodical Sorrico. It oays ho is authorized to intorvono in a responsible nnnnor. Q*. Ifcon tho purposo of tho docrco wos to guarmtoo this eooporntion? A* Tto purposo of tho docroo, fron ny point of flow, was to adjust tho noeds of tho Vohrnneht and ncods of tho Civilian Hoalth Sorvico to carry on tho negotiations, and in addition was fron tino to tino glvon spocinl tasks. Thoso social tasks, of course, crosultod fron dlroct instructions fron Hitler. Q* Tbon y<.u did not got any gcnorol authority, but spocial ins¬ tructions in each caso? A* In tho courso of tho noxt two yoars I csticato 15 to 3) spocial docrcos wore siffiod by Hitler for tho individual tasks. It cay bo one or anothor of th ce can bo suboittod as a docunont. Can 70 U nontion any such spocial assi&mcnt? A* In tho boginning I had to ostablish hospital basos. Such 3 rob^t-SV-S-^Haloy-JP Coart I b docroo wca foroulatod rory cloarly and signod by Eitlor. But tho ono dcpartcont wan important, — I believe I hero to toll this, that whon this docroo vac issued vfcoa Hitler si£icd it tho SS was not includod. Apparently H i m! or had already talkod to Hitlor about it. Slnco thoro were basic differences botv^on Einnler end no in our ieproanions of tho dutios of a nodical officor, and vo had quarreled about it on ono occa¬ sion, I was of tho opinion tho nodical officor is first a doctor and eeo- ondly an officor, whilo Hlnnlor was of tho opinion ho is first*"! officer and sooo.idly a doctor. Shis was cado eridont by tho fact that nodical officors of tho Vaffon SS, not liko to Arry, Vary and Luftwaffo, and so forth, woro tho insignia on their shouldors and could not bo distinguished free a roguler officor. 3 Peb-fc-GSS-^-l-Hlcabuok Court *o. 1. Sow, In cosher 1, paragraph 3* the Waffen SS is sectioned. Will you please explain the seanlng of this paragraph? It ssys; "for tha ^irpoao of coordinated treatment of theae problem a nodical officer of the ISovy and a nodical officer of the Luftwaffe will be assigned to work under bin, the latter in the capacity of chief of staff." Bow, there followo the eontonce: Puaianontal problems pertaining to the cedical service of the Whffen SS will be worked out in agreesent with the nodical Inspectorate of the Waffen SS. ■ A. I began to point out before that there was a nodical officer of tho Luftwaffe and one of the Bevy as liaison officers to tho fcovly created chief of the Vehrnacht nedical service, but that althougi the Waffen SS, as long as it was assigned to Wehrnacht units, was undor the control of tho Vehrnacht nedical service, the Waffen SS did not send an officer to Handlosor. And lator whon a request to thrt effect was node to get closer contact, it was refused. This is what I Just said with reference to nyoelf; th-it tho SS. tho General SS an well at toe Woffon SS. wore outelde this decrou for the nodical and health service. ?hii is the standard decree. The lutcr docreoe for the General C« ulseioner or the Reich Coaslesioner wero b -eod on thin ono aid it was nover ropvaled. n. *>w will you plorte put this decree to one eldo? Bow, did you built up a big agency for thoso duties? a. So, In Berlin I had a sort of post nail offico in tho Reich Chancellory fros where wo hid courier concectione end docuoonts ver.? brought to so constantly. Tho sail waich wo roculved was first of a quito genoral • nature, but aftor a short tixe, six or oig.it weeks, it consisted prisarlly of inquiries and dosands fron industry. Ihesc requests wore quite outeido of tho task as originally Intended. It had been intended th t I was to coordinate the existii* installations of tho ccdical servico. q, 4hat wts tho oignificncco of the fact that industry approached you with s eny inquirios and requests and opened up problems? 232E 3 7b-^-5£S->-2-l.i3*buci Court 50 . 1. — X obtained insight Into the production situation in «42 and 'U 3 . end on the basis of the information *.icn I received I saw that unless a unified planned econoigr was established the production of nodical suoplioe would bo crippled conplctely in '1*3. Th^s wac because within the production agencies tneasolvos there was no unified leadership. There vcr» throe agoncloo wnlch conflicted with each other; First, the i-iaistry of Econonics, the actual produotl >n a. ency; then, under Gocrlng, tno Four-Yorr Plan: i-nd finally, tho ainl^try for ircacoats and Var Production. -oido froa the fact th-.t the limitations of the Jurisdiction of thoso throo Of.loot wore not clour tho organization within thoso agencies was based on tna raw natorinl situation end not adjusted to tho deoand. Tfco hlni-try of Foono-lcs and tno Spoor Jlnlstry had crooted spocinl connlttoos end working cou..ittoos, specialist groups welch took caro of tno a torlols. Thor* was no contrul agency for acdicol su piles: for example, our surgical antorinls, our catgut, was in chi-rgo of a group who took onro of uusical lnstrunonto. This group for Lusicul instruments wn* iaterostod only in getting strings for violins and so forth, but they did aot core wnstner wo had surgical catgut or not. v Witness, thus* demands froo industry ’pcaod up n now fiold then. Did tbit load to Decree Uuab.r 2? a. Yes, this led to Dccroe Eusber 2. I shall snow you tais docreo. It is Document 1XM.1, KO-081, also in Document Book 1, page 14, in tno 2ngilsh vorsion. (Document handed to witness). .k. Cccrox. 2 of the 5 tc >f Spetenbor 1913 vrs to the offoct th*t I w^s outnorizod to trJco cne.rge -- to coordinate and direct centrally tho problons nd nctlvitlos of tao .ntiro -cdical and h-.alta scionce and rcsoarch no well as to tho orga irational institutions concerned with tho uanufreturo and distribution of aodical cctcri^ls. <. Witness* can you tell no wnat your collaboration vita the civilian an. Vcar n i c Bt sectors was? 2326 3 T\>*-GZS-9-yiiaabuck. Court mO. 1. A. I suit distinguish betvoun two things: first. the noccity for no, frou the sca.l office of throe or four persona which I had at thot tino, to dor clop two offices, one dealing with neterinls, planning and econouics, and one with tho scientific a*tt V s. the office for science and rosonreh. Ifeoso two officos. together with no, had to coordinate fisst tha natorlal hoods between the *ihraacht and clrilian soctor. Our position 2327 3 Fcbruary-M-OJG-9-le-Kinabuck Court So. 1 *aa that cf a differential. Through this second decree the first decree was not repeated. It was outside the authority of material needs as wall as science. I did not establish any connection with tho SS, and until the fall of 1944 when there was a visit by Gcnzktn, the SS did not attempt any coordination. Uy two offices, planning and economics, and science and rosearch. Professor Rostock was in ch:rgc of tho latter, hed assignment* which moro or less complemented each ether. If I referred to tho production difficult¬ ies before, I did so in order to dcscribo the necessity and the need for thet production. The ogroatant with the three competent production agencies was that I was the o.ily responsible representative of the needs cf the V< three eh t and civilian sector. plan of dosends for civilian supply had to to sot up first. Until 1943 in spite of the war conditions this plan had not been com¬ pleted. Tho Ministry of the Interior hed no idee of wh't these demands % wore. 1.1th tho aid and support of Lohrateht ngencios end industrial agen¬ cies, it was finally drawn up. This plan of civilian deornds was worked out in do tail end coordinated with tho central plan of tho l.ohmncht which had boon worked out in tho ceantioo. The adjusted pirn, coordinated plan between l-chrnacht and civilian wrs dicussod with the production reencios again, and this was tho first task of qy offico for science rod rosearch. Production; that is, industry, ottunptod to prescribo what wo could got. It was Rostock's task to establish wh t was nccossary and not what wrs offered us, in a v.ry difficult procedure. For cxamplo, our pharmaceu¬ tical preparations which, up to than, had been producod in numbers of about 35,000 different pr^par*tions; they were divided into groups rcducod to 12,000 -ni 6,OCO. 4nd finally, a program was s^t up in which only about 40 absolutely essenti; 1 preparations were contained. The same was truo of x-ray machines, instruments, all pieces of equipment cf a medical nature. Tho distribution of tho supplies within tho hehrnacht was within the l.ohraacht and within the civilian health service, their cwn organizations, and I had nothing to do with that. 2320 3 FcbO4!7“M-0JG-9-2a-Kinebuck Court So. 1 Q Then the office for science end research gavo research essignaents itself ns they have been discussed here? A The office for science and research did not give any research assign- aents in that precise fern. It supported research. It mist be considered thet in 1943 =nd '44 in general there were other d cards cn the aidical rnd hcelth service, net only in thwarting scientific activity, but the Uinistry of the Interior and the Propaganda Ministry, the Party Chancellery and oth-rs triod to h-.vc studies, pnrticul*rly nodical studies, stopped. In 1943 * decroc was drawn up and signed that all tho universities wero to be closed. «t that tine I tried to^rnvc this repe.ilod and as far as the acdical fccultivs were concerned, I succowdod. 2c29 3 Fob 47-M-S VlO-l-Putty Court Uo. 1 Ho °fficw for Sclcnco and Roscx'.rch undor Rostock rocolvod frar. r.o tho r.osl^aiont to try cvcrytl in- to ppovonl* tho Interruption o l nodical rttfliv-s which 'as pl.nnod in 19'.4y In individual ass i£> nomte w! let .vO stock au£portod — I could nontion the cttor.pt to cultivate tistuo culture a — the question wca breu'd t up ox“ flndin- nn a^r subatituto which is noooesnry in r.rbj. .r:\ry work, Ho supp¬ orts t) o work with th.o oloctronica nicroscopo and various othor tl in s Mild ho hlrs.lf can dueo^ibo hotter then I r I si ould only like to say ono tl -n~, first of all, tint th.o work wl ich Rostock did, ho did on ’ -k«^Lf on ny or ora, and I n.aolf, if I clclnod successes forriorly, ©ontj. uod to boor th.o res¬ ponsibility for ovwryfehlnc olono, Q. You spolto of attache on r.odicr l studies. Whc.t woo tl o pos* Iticn of nodical scloncc rt tint tii o in -onoral? ’'loaso connont briofly end conaidor what tho wryoft Profosror Lolbrnnd h.r.c test¬ ified hero. A. •■r. Lolbrand doscribod tho situation qrito oorrootly in nany points. I do not went to ’0 very far beck, Tho situation in 1933 was that rlth th.o boyinnin- of tho influonco of politics on ovor.tl in-, .n otto pt was rondo to have politics provc.ll in univ¬ ersities ns poll, Tho If iional Socialist bccf.uo of Studontfl was cle. r of rll tl wee units .nd orv*-n}s:.tipnr wflch v/cro forr.cd, That led to a false conclusion. If wnc bolicvou tl; t if tl is was ach¬ ieved, science itself would bo furthered^ ovorytl in- that was Qctivo in any way, all the c.ctivo forcos available whoro m rttowpt was opdo tc iliroct tl on into politics. It was not realised t’at scionco itself, scientific r-aep.rc'. and nork essentially Jv.fl I'ofcl.Jry to dp nitl* politics, A nunber of pen who obtained influence 'pp half odpqctcd. 3W0 3 7eb 47-Jk-JJC-lO-la-rutty Court !fc. 1 So resulting inferiority feelint they triad to compensate for by trying to push the scientist, the real scientist, aside as unequal to then, and cn the other side helped the dilettante. I refer to the description of von 3rehnar which I cave this nornine. Jkrr when the war had be^un the question of science was overlooked ontirely, Dqforients for tho universities had not been ^lvjn so that teachers woso sullenly drafted, and the training of the 3tulents u a s distorted in sene cases. Co nailorations of basic research had boon overlooked, and the idea of resoarch on the ba3is of excellency prevailed. The lack of interest of the universities thaneelves led in 1943 to the decision to closo the uni varsities altogether, Thero were a amber of doctors with whai I was In contaot at that tine who exerted their influence to liave the unlvorsltles reopened and contlmed, tho doan of the University of Bonn, for instances Sohulecaan, and ono of Kuenator, Slociamd, and Souerbruch, rnd, of course, Rostock who was dean of tho Berlin faculty and oxortod a certain influonce in this respect. After that thero waa an enomous nunbar of llttlo annoying difficulties. 2 vor 5 *one waa suddenly Interested in these questions of universities, and everyone had sooathinc to do with thor.. Tho Hieh Cajiander of tho Uataraoht was interested in it beoauao of defendants. Sauckel as plenipotentiary for Labor Comitrvmt wanted to havo studonts fiven acne sort of labor duty. Contingents for ostablishinf institutions, otc., were in charts of the ::«nlatrr of joononioe. The Sneer Ministry rofusod to take charge of tha_. if social papers ware to be printed, tho % Reich Press Chanber opposed it, and in spite of ^11 that thero was no person who was roally in chare® of tho universities. I say this only to 2331 3 Fea-Jt.JP-10-lb-Putty-PH Court Kb. 1. show that from my Office of Science and Research that this was the primary decisive task, and I attempted to keep physicians free of politics as far as possible. Without knowing It directly, S found support In the tfforts of / Dr. Blome essentially directed against Dr. Conti. Professor Lelbrand has already described Conti. He was a political oxponont end called himself that, and saw the task ot the health leadership whloh he represented aitlroly from too political point of view. That the training of the young dootor, the studont, o suffered eapeolally during tin war in Germany I don*t bollcvo I need to emphasize espedlally. Everyone knows how difficult training opportunities were. Novortheles a, a groat dealwis cortninly done for research and actual raodloal troatnent of too doctor at homo, and before 1939 the modlcal offlcore wore on the wholo outstanding. Thoro wore oomo scientific suocossos, tho dorolopmont of oulfonmldco in too surgical field because thet was tho closest to mo, tho bone troatmont according to Fuetsohor and too further rosults of hoart surgery are significant. Q: Witness, I cooo to a different subject. Zbu woro given ar, assignment called by tho Prosecution Chemical Warfare Agent Decree from tho first of March 1941. Wo do not have this Decrco Itself, tut you wrote n lottor atout It to Himmler, a copy of which Is here. It is Document NO-012. That is also In Volume I of the document book. Z on not certain where It Is In tho docunont book. It Is a very brief letter. I shall read It so tint the Court any take notice of It. 2332 3 Feb 7---I —.-10-lc-rutty Ccurt Jc. 1 3irlin » C --^ch 191*. Tb_ Gener a C-rciMicncr cf the Fuehrer for bcdical rr 8 ^- 1 " &er “‘- ^ rtf -W«te.tete. —3noW y« «m «*; the . bet-etna,, c,-/ rf c. erfen tr n tbo nmr ^ u * a,^.; t . - * “ < - *™hnl Z an’.: , . ^ t , in _ *“ *“ ^ °“- a “•• ^ m y . ««. x « u ^ ^ ““ t= f.ot in tend _ thon ;r~~ ■ tcic ' An ° — - ■« -* >—- ,« „ t sottlo : r ^ icea,5i * lto —w. Hou latte, " i 1 '•“ lte “ ^ ^ *»-» •'••=* -« th, «, t,. _ “• “ °^ X ™ - W ' * *» •— P— Wte y:u ^ ~ i0 intcr - ,r, -tcr can't V He; othoruieo. • !SS:=,,ti °' un “ 1 ’ 1 ~ * r» t, te tte *u *««t « =lrcr. t v in ovi^nco. “* S=ViI1BS: IJewtS ““ 611 “•-=■• » the aJU*. 3 ciucnt D ac t:X ^ » 1 «“ «■ X-o mrfttre *<. *„ rocoM . T. - -r-SEClir. Can ycu tecr,. * the ncia- cf tho a«9 ^ aiV - JnWl 1 hc ’- •» «»• «*. I ten.! .vw a act “* to It. Oarrott cf tie te n.-.U.n Center - tbi. ^ , net 2 333 3 IoV*OJG-ll-l-3oarncics, vhich he could net roach directly, about the result of this discussion. Since I went to the Fuehrer's Headquarters the sane night and =et Go«rinr, who was really the nan responsible for air raid pre¬ cautions, I informed hin. Gccring had no idea of this situation at the- timo. For his it wrs of the same importance; Tor hin, it awrnt that uftcr one gas raid over Gcrnmy, the war nauld havv been over, .md, with this ettitude and with the drnwn-power cf conviction, he infora.d the Fuehrer, himself. On tho noxt 'ey, I was celled to the Joint conference 'nd asked whothor I would toko the production of g-® nask® into ay effico for planning and cconcalcs. I took tho point cf view th:t such *t. rssignn-nt which night have further developments was not exactly cccmensurato with ay office of Planning and Econo -ics. 1 said thrt 1, oyself, night set up a p'.rrllol organization to coll ber-to with tho competent polntod without rtandlosor's lnfluonco. In tho translation tho opposite wao said, namoly, appolntod by Hand- * 47-A-DJG-l4-2a-Gross-(«K) • • COURT I loser. I visa to correct that. Wltnoss, It la truo, isn't It, that the Radical Inspector of the Array was appointed without Handloser's Influence? Didn't you say that? «i. Generalartz Walter;- who at that time was Army physician and Army Medical Inspector, became ovldont to Himmler since ho had Instituted certain hospitals ancT there In ho saw something very special and on his ovn Initiative, probably through Burgdorf a:d Fegololn, appointed Woltor as Medical Chief of the Army without Handlosor, exclusive of any Influence In that respoot. Q. I now sub-alt to you thoso six charto which aro documents coming from Document Booh Volume I, at first 645. The chart Is headod "Organization undor tho Reloh commissioner, Karl Brandt." Those two linos, howovor, were struck out. Is this chart available and doos tho Tribunal have It? TH2 PRESIDENT: Do you have the oxhlblt numbor of that chart? DR. SERV.iTIUS: Tho exhibit numbor I in afraid I don't Know. Tho ohnrt was subalttod In the first document book and Is NO-645. I am Just hoarlng that It is oxhlblt #"S. 2*48 * Fab 47-^MA.V-15-l-Lesaor-(AXJ COURT I Q. Witness, would you define your attitude to this chart and say something about Its creation? -i. The decisive thing about this chart la that at the head, the designation "Organization of the Gorman Nodical Sorvlce under Reich Commissioner Karl Brandt" was struck out and this was then signed by me. In ordow to understand it further i must say something how this chart originated. In the last year during the course of 1945, I was repeatedly Interrogated about my activities and position in 1945 In Xranzberg. In connection with theso Interroga¬ tions two charts wore made by mo and on theso oharts I illustrated the possible organization as it maybo should have been at one time. During thoso oonvorsatlons, In order to keep ovorything simple, cortaln designations of tho offloos wore not consldorod Important and thooo two charts wore then submlttod to ae horo with tho quostlon whother I made thorn, which quostlon I answorod in the afflrmativo. I thon slgnod thooo charts but with that signature I did not moan to any that whatever la oont lined In thoso charts, ar.d thoro Is no accompanying toxt to It, is corroot. It could not bo correct at all, slnco it says on tho chart horo on tho right sldo, "The Chief of the Civilian Health Service, Dr. Conti." From my present testimony It can clean¬ ly bo seen that there wasnit such an office but that It was the wish of tho people who participated that there should havo such a position. This "Chief of the Civilian Medical Service" firstly did not exist at all and thoro was no department In the Reich Labor Service co-ordinated, a6 It Is indicated on this chart, so the entire combination Is wrong or. the civilian sldo as they are described In my two 2 , 49 3 Fob 4?-out thlo rolatlonshlp. I must now point to tho Dopartmont of Planning and Soonomy, the loader Slcklngor, Hero, for lnstanoo, thore are arrows pointing to tho Roloh Ministry of Economy or tho Roloh Hlnistry of Armament and the Four Yoar Plan. That, of course, doos not moan that I could give any dlrootivos to the Four Year Plan, whoso chief was Ooorlng. Tho chart can only be used for tho purpose of giving some kind of idea or picture of the ontiro field of the Civilian and tho Vfehrnacht 3ector. This adjustment was my personal responsi¬ bility. In other respects tho Office of Scionco and Research and Planning and Economy were for the purpose of adjusting the needs in those departments and bringing them up to tho needs which at that time were necessary. Q. And you described the whole thing as a working chart 2350 * Fob 4r-^-JU4-15-afcr« end that everythin'; else in this eh -x-t can bo left aside. * Q Then, I ask y.u tc lock rt tho r.ext chart. It is Ho. 119. This is else c ch'rt signed b th. cc-'-oi^olmt Schrjvd-r and is for the time fre-t January 1, 19U cr. :r.1. A 1 can only say the c--r.e thin. in ccnnecti.n iith tids chert as 1 had said befor:; I ou not --ell en.uj. infes-d sbeut th.- jener l fl.att.rs with reference V. position at the »U aention J:i*?ry 1, 1911 nc chmr,o occurred ccup red u Janu-ry 1, 1913. Tbs cnlj ^u.sti r. :.ay be the dusigrw nticn cf the buichs Joe laser full th t ccc-xvei cliruv-qu rters .f a year later sad cannct bo included in tfcst plcn. 3 54 * Fob 47-A -SW-16-la-Hoofaon-(«JC) COURT I Q. As tho fifth chart, I should like you to look at Document No. 416. This Is a ohart headed "Organizational Chart of tho Modloal Sorvlco of tho "S3" up to August 1, 194* drawn up by tho co-do fondant, Profosaor Dr. Mrugowsky. I r.ak you In this ease to doflno your attltudo Insofar as It concerns your position. A. There 1s a blank lino here going from my nnmo poraonally. On the oasis of the decree of July 28, 1942 tho Chief of tho .u*mod Forces Modloal Service and this black line la oxplolnod as tho channol of command. Tho docroo, which we dlaoussod this morning, gives you no Indication and doos not Justify such a description. It says that my function was tho coordination b otwoon tho l/ehraaoht Modloal Matters and Civilian Modloal matters and oomo ospoolal tasks and I quote the last dooroe of tho 7th of August onco more, that Is a much Inter period so tho superior offloe Is roally tho Chief of the O.K.VT. It oar. bo soon from that tho superior agonoy la the Chief of tho O.K. J. That means that this black on thla chart la cortalnly not corroot and I an suro that Dr. Mrugov3ky wantod to Indicate some othor description. Q. How about your connection to tho Rolchsarzt S3 Professor Crawltz? a. That, of oourso, is completely ridiculous. I had no connection at all to Grawitz and oertalnly there was no channel of command emanating from me. I thins thero Is material to confirm that. I said this morning that after tho signing of the decree the SS as suoh was very clearly out-ie side my Jurisdiction and that was done by tho Fuehrer himself in the presence of Hlmmlor. Q. «nd I should nov like to ask you to look at the last 2*55 * Fab 47 -«* 3 i- 16 -l^-Meohan*(iJC) COURT I chart, No. 417, which la a second chart signed by tho co- iefondant rrofoascr Dr.* Mrugowaky , which doala with tho porlod starting fron S^ptonber 1, 194*. This chart la essentially the ease aa the ono I looked at boforo. I should like to ieflno ay attltudo*with reforonoo to ny 2^55a * Fab 47-.,-3'rf-lS-£a-Heehan- (-JC) COURT I own position. It la wrong becauso on September 1, 194^ I neither had the ordor to institute a Departnent for Science and Reaearoh nor was th# aooond deoroe that la oonoornod with that oatter Issued at that Ueo. With roforonco to Handlosor and Grawltr, the aace relationship oxlsts as is indicated on the chart. q. you put th-so oharts asldo now? On tho basis of the third deoroe, you had rocolvod a speolar position with roforonco to tho execution of your old task. How did these new authorities actually affect praotloal dovoloi>- ments? 2 T 56 3 F ebru«ry-M—DJG-i7-l-^=Icy Court Sc* 1 „ At that tine in the autuan of 19 UL I tad to take two basic uiffi- cultiea into account, one wrs tlut the civilian cb.rtcr una nen-exietent, that is decrees for the Chief cf Civilian -edical Scrvico. It was surgestod by Minister Lemurs c/vi should hr.v« received aiidltr designation, ..s the Chief of Nodical Services cf the «rsy, but it never originated. On tho other hand, the authority of Dr. Covbbels tcck place at the sane tine with refer¬ ence to results for total warfer.. That has as its consequencethrt Dr. Goebolls interfered and had the power t~ interfere in o/ory department ho cculd dispose cf, end adept aonsuros which tv his cs^he said at the timos sceaed necessary for optical reasons. Cnc of the first a.asures in this rcspuct was a-tin tho attest to discontinue studi.s ct hi^hschocls, and fer this reason 1 had a heavy quarr J., a serious quarrel with him. 1 must point cut th't .*t th: t paric i cf tine ohe discussien b tween Dr. Centi and muself h*i intensified and Dr. C.(«ti, with the support of iiartin Bchr- aann and his cennection with the party chtnc-llcry end Gauleiter, nede difficultioe in every r-spect. Durin such a quarrel Dr. Cocbbels errivod at a formula Lion which I did net understand rt the tine, whsn he said thet I had te bo quit-, cle*r th't th.re .ru lirtin Soroann ojflnst me, and with hia the G-ulcitcre and else Dr. Centi. ..ft.rwr.ris I f.und out that the real cause that l‘rtin Bcmrnn »•» a ; :inst appointment as heich Coimio*- icner, and fer this reason during ay rbswncc fra:i the Fuhrer Hoed quarters put forth a mincer of V. 2:57 * Fob 7-.r»3W-17-l-Kaloy- () COURT I arguments, which In hit opinion wouli lnoi .ruinate mo. Certainly some mention was mado regarding m;» attompto to establish connection with the Red Ctjsg, anc a few other □aybo not so othur Important faotor* vero mentioned. «t any rate a few days later I lost sy position *s Escort Physician of .dolph Hitler, what a' tfc*t tlmo I occupied. Hitlor in those days had been 111, and 3 jj was « nly presont In the headquarters for one lay. A' this oocasl^n I was told that he would rocolvo medical supplies frot Professor Morrell, among which strychnine was avallablo. . t was not quite clear to me what he meant, since Professor iorrell, as personal physician slnco 1S*7 wr.s rospanolblo for internal dlsoasos and had tho ordor not to inform mo about anything which oonoornod the Fuohror hlmsolf. Whon I lnvostlgatod tho mattor I found through a sorvant that Morroll notually in January of tnu year 1S*-1 had orlered thoso tablets which oontalnod stryohnlno, but which at that time Hitler too* In suoh an amount that he dally roaohod tho maximum dosago. I pointed that out to Himolor, and I also spofco to Profossor Morroll. I tun loft and two days lat«r I was ordered to come baoX again, and vory shortly without .any further words was dismissed from that position as Escort Physician. Ky doputy was Immediately llsmlssud too, and In his plaoe the Escort Physlolan of Himmler, whom I did not know until later was appointed as my successor. Starting from this period of time my office 2358 Court So. I 3 Fob 17- - 17-lb - LJ3 - Haley »aa placed under control and ever increasing ocntrols were exercised. That is something I found out because of conferences which were heard at the Fuehrer's Headquarter* which I attended a few times because of official business, and I was warned of a poesible interference by xartin Bormann. In October 1911 I asked all my staff tc com to There were only o few people, kri I clearly told tluc about my situation. It the sm tir.e I told th«* that this should not desist then in any way fren their technical rorkj everything thich was not technical, which did not belong to their tasks should be loft aside, and whatever was necessary should bo continued under all drcuaataacea. Ov. has to lock at tho entire situation for /hat period of tlsb, includin': th« beginning of 191*5, It was hardly possible to mintaln a connection with cne mother. Tho possi- bllity of Conti, in territories whore troops were, Conti's position was not vory important ary longer, since the *rry n-diOCl Service also had to toko caro of civilian r.eoda. At that tK rd- s » u rc lvun to transfer •fflcos at that time lccnted in Northern Gerr.any. I had rocoivod directives from th. ministry cf the Interior to transfer my office slnco it was r.ct tiod down ta Berlin to Thuringia. This opportunity was at the end of March, and the first April days of 1 J L5. I sent r.y family to tho location of ry office. This was used as r.ascn for try arrest later, and I was con - dtanod in a w,ry peculiar procedure by the Oau Court in Thuringia. Tho procedure was peculiar for th-reason that tho judges who were to participate, that was an S° ^cr grupponfuehrer, and . n* S« Fu hrer, had received a handwritten letter by Hitler tefero t^.c procedure stsrtod, whoro it was said that a death sentence was to be paused cna. In this manner questions and answers won r»v_r in coapliar^e, because ry ans-«r was always interpreted in such a manner it would 1-ad to ry sentencing. It was printed out to m I was giving directives which eaus.d the hospital to fall into enemies 1 hands, a oeasuro which was a matter of course, because there was no purpose in sending wounded people free -«stern Germany t- ^astern Germany and fren ^astern Genoany to western Germany. It was pointed cut 1 ostae- 2359 Court Ho. I 3 Feb U7-* - 17-2b - LX - U shod connection with Switserlaad, and I think it concerned qy attempt to establish contacts with the Hod Cross in. Geneva, in order to point out the aodical difficulties,in the crerrurt countries, — in the overrun territories, a' sort of res^rv* of radical supplies, which was callud by us a so-called "pcaco reserve-, such a store was interpreted as a si«{n of dopotisa, and th-ro is hardly any need to action any one poUt. • s 3 ?ub-Jr GZ 5* 18- l-ll cebuc k Court Ho. 1. A t ney ruto tho roeult ve.e that I ur.a trenefcrrcd on tho sane day to tho Geattpo yffico In Prinz ^lcrcchtitrano la 3orlin aftor tho death eontonca vaa confirmed, and I taink it ia duo to Spoor 1 a offortthnt r. poatpononont of too execution took place, ff poatponcaont of 24 hours, since it was triod to inclwio professor Hoatock in that procoduro v*:o, ia tho nonntlao, had {pno to acurth-rn Gcrtny. Rostock vs to bo brought to Berlin. Eovcvtr, thoy wore cot ia o poaition to find Boatock at th/-.t tiao aincc tho co.-junicntion oyatci. did not function quit- veil, since. in tho nuxtluo, t.:o cnony hi.d ponotn.tod V into Thuringia and Saxony. ./tor another fov poatponoi«r.ta of day* t nd half-dry a I vne tmnaforrod to a Gestapo offico in Schvorin at tho -ui of .^ril. Or. t:.o 28th of April thia offico received a tel.tno frou 3>nnnn fro.. Borllr. t»..t 1 and to bo aont to tho priaon in Kiel, but bocrusc of t:.e advance of tho Suecier.a tr.ia Gestapo office had to -ore tovorla the voet, to flor.abur,:, ao that thoy could not to Kiel, v.'.&oa hod aa it a course tnnt I vna aubaoquor.tly liberated /.round the ulddlo of hoy. So u.*t van your situation, too situation under wold. you rccoivod your authority aa Rolen Co:~ltaioa. r. Sut v-t tao ru;#oa I put thut di-ation to you. DR. SZSTATICS: hr. Pr-aidont. I a nov couin.; to thoieporiuonte in dotail and tuit Lay bo un opportune uosoat to atart 1 . rccoon. TEE PRZSlDZiTT: Tho Tribunal will bo in recces for a few nouonts. (ReCwta vna t;-kon) TEE PRESIDE!": I will nek tu- reporter if he hr.s c correction to ivJco for tao benefit of th« record, tao translator. I . oan. IiCSRPRSTER )hr. S-Alor) Ion. your Honor. Th- *ord ..ontlonod oarlior today, the DoT.-^a word, aydrlorverkc. should hnvu boon translated aa hydro- donation works, vnic.. ia tho vorka fo.- tho process of tho rofinoaent of gasoline. 2ZS PR. -I2S.T: Counaol -ay proceed. I viil suggest to tho r-portor rjd tho Soorettvry Goa-ral th_t they see th? t tao trr.nalc.tion ca contained in tho record appears correctly. 236I 3 .6b-A-Gc3-l5-2-N3 c nc-rning the Hire and Gebhart experi¬ ments. 3 Feb A - LJG - 13-3 - •- &0UCX Court Nc. 1 DR. SERVATI18j Then pleaso put this chart to or* side. I cffor the document as Exhibit ftaber 2. THE ffiESIDEJff: Referring t-xl.cu.3ant of Juno h, 19u5, this document was identified January 27 as Xarl Srindt's Sohibit 1 for identification. It has not yot been formally efforud as an oxhibit before the Tribunal in this ccso. Does the defendant desire now to offer it as an exhibit? It was oscroiy identified. I :-*an this document, counsel. x JIDG2 SS8Ri:Ot Drt Survatius, during tha case .f thu preseoution on 27 earner 19i*7 y^u ertviblted, ce A rvceUect, tc *nc ^ the prosecution's witnossos un omurpt fr "life* ic,nsinti *-t tht.t tine tho Court tns of the vxo* th t alth ugh it c mid then be catalogued us I-vrl Br. ndt'a uxhioit for identification only in order to uli&dnato confusion, th-t it sh uld b- off-rod prior to too oxhibit you tv~.ru in y ur hand, ns *arl Brandt's atfiibit l.'cfcor 1. D:t. Si.1V..flOS: I should lik« t? sutait it .s iutoibit 1, but it is nit available ~.t too n. unt. T«vt is why I Lit th.t aifcbor opon and suV.it this ucuaont s iblt >u bur. 2. THE r. J5SIDE'. 7 s Vary woU. 2363 3 ? Ob-ArGSS-19-l-^i - *7 Coart yo. 1 'Te&t)ET: The Prosecution has just a fonoal question with rospact to tori Brandt's Document *>. 2, end I understand it is now being offered - s Exhibit Ho. 2 for tori Brandt. I 4>n«t thii* we have any groat objection to it voin; in as an exhibit, but there is »ao question in ry uind as to • whether or not it really isn't a setter ef ar-.unont rather than a document which has any probative value in an.’ of itself. It simply purports to ffivo the chronology of tho various o-.p.rients charred in the indictment together with tho throe ocr^s which vested the Dofondant, X:rl Brandt, v.lth certain authority. I cfan't kno- but chat it would be hotter if this document not bo includod as an exhibit in th. rcccrd but simply presentoi as a attar of argUBont. TJE PRESIDENT* Counsel for tho Prosecution m;’ have tin to a tudy this document. It con bo used today for axamin.'tion. C-unsol nay study it to- rl^ht and infom tho Tribunal in th nornUr- if ho a,-rocs that it is oorroot or if ^ <’-ojs not, ar/* then Counsel nay crons oxrjd.no tho witness upon this particular docansnt if h- lociros to to so k Tho Tribunrl will delay pass in on tho a ' dssibility or nri>-a .lssibilit/ of tho V'ounont until tomorrow nomin , but it . ay be used this ft.mocn’by Counsel for tho Dofondar.t in xr.dnation cf tho -dt,:;.. ~.i 3x. szswrinsi q , v. in.-dvi-li.al oxp ri-.ntn ir. tho order in which thoy are listed in the in.detoont. First w* coto to tho freuzinc jxperinents h-re during tho trial. Did you hr.vo any part in then? . t Ho, I had no part in the ft-eaRlnc’ wperlncnta. I board of thoso oxpcrincr.ta for V.v. first time oft_r 1 rs arrest. If I recall correctly, it waslast year who.* I was hm-o in IJumber.. oef--ro that I had no know- lodgo of than. It is not quite clear to » in what way Office. for Scionco and Research cculd have boon inf.rved about it. It is possible that a general report was received there. Schrocrkr sal ’ once in another con¬ nection that copies of reports w~ro scr.t there, but I bdioVo that tho fraez- inr, experiments were sc lor.-; a S c - I don't have the tablo of chronology hero 236L 3 Feb-ji-GE3-19-3-Putty-PM Court No* 1. Hay I — ttet I don't believe I hod that Offlco for Solence anl Research yet at that tine. The freexlng experiments were In Jfcy — they were already oonoluded in Hey, 19-13. That was at least three months^ before the nominal decroc according to which 1 Was to establish an Office for Science and Research vhlch actually went into operation only In 1940. Ql Ybu wont to correct yourodlf; you soon ’44? «. As Yee. * 44. Q: How about Count C, color la experiments? •* A: I learned of malaria experiments only after I was arrested. I know nothing about them before. During tho whole war I had something to do with malaria on two o ocas ions quite Independently of tho experiments mentioned hero. Once the dean of the University of Bonn, Profossor Sohulomonn,. In his capacity os a nodical officer had a scall malaria hospital near Bonn in whloh the normal treat¬ ment of refractory patients was carrlod on. Booauso of an air raid on Bonn, the continuation of this hospital and tho University Institute was endangered, and ho approach¬ ed no on this c»tter. We never discussed any experiments. I never made any such request of hln or he novor ntxdo any suoh request of me. The other tine when I had something to do with malaria was that Profossor Rose, who waw carry¬ ing out malaria treatment on Insane persons, or at loast had a part In the, approached me about the sheltering of those patients. He came to me because — It was wither 1943 or *44 — because In connection with the transfer evacuation of hospitals I was connectied with an agency of tho Propa- ganda Ministry, and he knew from the Uftwaffe through sone agenoies of the Air Raid Precaution Medical Service that I was connected with It. 1 bid Rose at that time to & to 2365 M 3 Feb.-A-SZS-ia-a-Putty-PH Court So. 1« the competent agency in the Ministry of the Interlo?| opd he did whatever was noceseary. e took up the nooesBany negotiations. I had nothing else to do with malaria or with patients suffering from malaria. Q: What did you have to do with lost experiments? Do you remember the diary of 31evcrs, the final report of Himmler — the final report of Birth* ^ A: After 1 had received the assignment to make gas masks on the first of ' 2366 (« * Fab 47—ArGSS-19—''-Putty- (.uC) COURT I March, '44, at the end of the aano month Slaver called on me and on Himmler'a orders, aa ho said, ho gavo mo a final report of Professor* Hlrth about tho treatment of lost Injuries. Ho visited mo In my office In 3elltr. Ho said nothing else. Tho void ■.ibnonborbo" was not mentioned. Nothing was said about any other vorh of a scientific nature admin¬ istered from there, and I promised him that In April, In % tho next month, I would visit Professor Hlrth myaolf. Sievers could not glvo me any furthor information about It, and apparently did not havo eiy Inclination to do ao olther. Then In tho following month since I was In Strass- bourg for another reason, I vial tel Frofoocor Hlrth thoro onco. That was at the end of .ipril, 1944. Hr. Hlrth explain¬ ed to mo the essontlol points of his plans of treatment, and with the aid of a nunbor of animal preparations, ho explain¬ ed whit he had called significant in this final roport. It was tho question of supplying the organism with vitamins and the rolo of destroying poison whloh tho llvor plays In connection with lost damage. I assumo that I was with him for about one hour., cortalnly no longer. With tho aid of a nunbor of explanations of a chemical nature which I cannot ropoat altogether, tho final conclusion was that it was necessary if one wants to treat lost Injuries to lntroiuco certain vitamin groups Into the organism In larger quanti¬ ties. In this conversation between «r. Hlrth and myself tho quostlon of lllogal or special human experiments was certain¬ ly not brought up, not because there was the Impression that wo were trying to avoid anything, but because the questions a9Ked during my visit to l-ir. Hlrth were of an entirely dif¬ ferent nature from the beginning. I was there after I had read Hlrth's report In order to obtain Information about 2 -* 66 * Fob 47—JrGES-l9- , -x > utty- (aS) COJRT I tho special vitamin questions. It was, of course. Hr. Hirth's lntorcst to prosont hia special view-point? and If one consldora gonoral lost treataont, this* was not anything so special. Tho previous treatment with llvor oil salvo had tho sane la. It Is not cloar to me whether In tho course of 1944 I had any further connection with Hr. Hirth. It is posslblo that there was X some oorospondonoo. It cannot have been important. I never saw Hirth again. I novor visited him again. I had no further oontaot with him. 2*66a * Fob •i7-.^G£3-19-'*-i > utty-(^X) COJRT I tho special vitamin questions. It vas, of course, hr. Hirth's Interest to present his special view-point, ci*i if one considers gonoral lost treatment, this was not anything so special. Tho previous treatnont with livor oil salvo had the same -In. It Is not doar to me whether In tho courso of 1944 I had any further connection with Hr. Hirth. It Is possible that there was some ooreepondenoo. It cannot have been important. I never saw Hirth again. I never visited him again. I had no furthor oontaot with him. 2366a s Feb -i7-,r-DJG-2C-l-Seard- («K) COURT I Q. Now, what about the sulfanilamide experiments. Did you understand the question about sulf-.nllamldo and % tho treatment of wounds? A. Siorthly after tho beginning of tho war and In every theater of tho war tho question of tho sulfanilamide was dlaoussod. At that time sulfanilamide was oxactly the same thlr& that a few yoars lator. In tho Uni tod Sfatos, penicillin was. Every one was interostod In It, and the Profosaor Morroll, whom I montlonod before, had dovolopod hlo sulfanllaoiao oxporlaonts, and tho qaestlon of sulfan¬ ilamide was dlaoussod at largo. A sulTanllanlle treatment In the Wohrmaoht was started with tho oloar formula, with the aim — I must mention tho namo of Profosaor Kruogor because anybody who had anything to do with It know what It wae- prosalon that ho had teatod a llaitod nunbor who were effec¬ tively condemned to death. So, I oortalnly did not objeot in any form; otherwise I would have a different memory of the report than I do. I oannot reoall the aotual working of the report. I remember the fact that I waa there, and that I did not object. From that, I conclude that Gebhardt made hlo report in suoh a way th«t those who wore present, who heard, the report had no reason to object in any way. Q. Persona condemned to death were mentioned. Did you have any misgiving a that suoh death sentences were complet¬ ely unobjectionable from the legal point of view? A. No, I did not have any misgivings in that form. I said before that if i reoeived suoh I would havo misgivings. Q. Now, I come to the experiments on transplantations and regeneration. Wore you informed about them? A. I can say nothing about these experiments. I was informed of•them only here in Nuroberg. I knew nothing about thorn before. I have nothing, whatovor, to say about them. I wa6 temporarily of the opinion that they were repor¬ ted in some other form; although I was not present at the discussion but later on, that was not the case. Q. Now, you are charged with participation in the Sea 2*68 S Fob 47—A-3JG-20-’-Baard-CAJ:) COURT I Water ibcperlnente. Do you have anything to say about that? A. I learned of the Sea Water Experiments for the first time through the Indictment*. I knew nothing about then beforehand. I did not learn of then — I had no part In then, and I only knew of thorn after reading the l n dlotnent. I could not, at first, realise what It was about. I asaumo 2368 a * Feb 47-A-DJG-20-*-Beard- (AX) COURT I Schaefer say a In hi a affidavit th*t he thought that the higher circle* of phyalolans Knew of thla problom, that It waa an open secret, he*probably meant tho people who partic¬ ipated. Q. He will be able to tell us that. Now, did you have anything to do with removing pol8on from water? * A. I had a oonforenoo In 3erlln for obtaining apparatus for disposing of polaon gas. It was a quoatlon'of obtaining apparatus for tho war against oheoloal agents. Apparatus for removing poison from water was dlsouaaod but no final doolalon waa roaohod. J mot Mr. KrugoweKy onoo, who was oonnootod with auoh apparatus; this removing of polaon from drinking water aftor gne attaoKa. Q. TMon, the Indlctoont list's axporlmonts with Hopa- tltls. A lotter from Grawlti to Himmler aaya that you fur¬ thered these oxporlraonts. Did you, yourself, work on this quoatlon, ollnioally? A. I never did any work with Hepatitis Spidemloa. If so. It wvuld have had to have boon during tho war, since the war this disease was of no loportanoe In Gormany (during the war). I did not deal*with thla question beoauae I was too buoy with other things In tho first place, and In the second place such a purely lntarnal disease Is of lnteroot to Hygienist, and was relatively uninteresting to mo as a surgeon. Q. Did you Issue research assignments on this subjoot? How about Doctor Dohment A. I do not know why I should have given a research assignment to Doctor Dohmen: Of course, the quoatlon of Hepatitis was *>. question which interested everyone. Every one oncounteed it trverywhore In the East. But, for that 2*69 3 Feb 47-A-DJ&-20-^-Beard-(AX) COURT I reason I would not have given apeolal attention to that disease. It had no relation to other things which Interest¬ ed me more as a surgoort. I know the lottor. I was told about It last year. I saw It here for the first tlmo, this year. It says that I had asked Mr. Grawit* to *»ve a Doctor Dohmen oarry out speolal Hepatitis work. Doctor Dohaeh, the letter goes on, was to obtain soven or eight prisoners for that purpose and the lives of those prisoners iould bo en¬ dangered. It Is not dear to ao In what 2*59a * Feb 47-*-DJG-20-4-3eard-(AX) COURT I connection and for what roaaon. In the letter, mentioned my n ,me aa the instigator of Hepatitis research for In all the rest of the correspondent* and in all the other documonts there la not even the slightest hint that I had any particular interest In this question or That I was so Interested that I would have started It. Assuming that the experiments vote carried out. I would never have received any report citing roeults. i-horo aro indications against the sonso of this letter, espoolally when It says theso experiments are to bo oarrled out on persons to be oondomnod to death. Hepatitis Zpldomloa la not a dlsoaeo aa dangerous aa all that. I havo inquired meanwhile, and know that for example, oomparod with Malaria it Is dangerous only about tonth of a fraotlon as Malaria. Today, I havo alroady dlsoussod my relationship with Hlmmlor and with Crawltz; that was not lnvontod; that was actually the truth. On the other hand, all the corrospondenoo - in all tho corrospondenoo, Hopatltis, ono yoar lator, after tho first letter failod to have the desired offoot, Profoosor Sohrelber is looking for a way to approach Hlmmlor in ordor to havo Hopatltis rosonroh work continued. 2^70 •» Fob 47- A- 3JG-21-1-Bliley- (AX) COURT I Sohrolber was tho deputy for epidemic control In the Reich Research Council so that I may assume for a reason which is not quite dear to me that Gravity possibly confus¬ ed Sohrolber and me in the first letter. That is conceivable The letter' Is dated the 1st of June, 194*. a short time before there was the meeting of the Military Medical Academy; and probably Gravity who was prosent, talkod to Sohrolber as well, in any case I am not able to give any information about this question of hepatitis and certainly not about any experiments which actually took place. I have no infor¬ mation; I roceivod no report; and I did not hoar from any othor source even now that these experiments woro roally conducted. It soocs to mo significant th^t tho witness Schmidt who was here testified that the experiments woro not conducted in Strasbourg, as Dohoen. who was to conduct them, was thore for only two or three days himself. MR. HoHAHflf: If It pie as j tho Tribunal, I don't llko to got up and objoot; but It soems to me that the wltnoso should oonflno hlmsolf to answering questions whloh aro put to him by his defense counsel and refrain from making arguments on the basis of tho evidence which has gone in. He has now been discussing at length the testimony of various witnesses and the assumptions that he draws from them. I think that argument can be taken caro of by dofonse oounsel at tho appropriate time. DR. SSRVATIUS: Mr. President, the onswors were no doubt all essential. Whether I chop those questions up In pieces or lot tho witnoss speak consecutively makes no great difference in ny case. It would only take longor and would bo confused. 5ut if the Court wants me to ask him short questions. I will do so. 2371 s Fob 47-AOJO-2l-l-BlaKl«y- (AX) COURT I THS PRESIDENT: Counsel had boon proceeding satisfac¬ torily with tho examination of tho witness. Tha witness has included occasionally natters of argument which night proparly bo nade by his counsel but has not oonsuadd much tine; and tho prosecution witnesses were allowed considerable latitude also. Iho examination nay prooeed in the manner In which It has been conducted horebeforo. q. wtnoaa, you are moused of participation 1 sterilisation oxporinents. 2*71a * Fob 47 -a- DJG-21-2-Blokloy-(AX) COURT I You 'snow tho documents which the prosooutlon haa subnittod. Whan did you first loarn of thla problem? A. I learned of thla psoblom of sterilisation ^ftor I was arrested here; and I learned for the first time only now tho typo of procedure. From this fact that two or throe minutes of X-ray treatmont was lntonded to storlllra I wank to prove that I cortalnly did not know about It for that Is such an unsclontlflo conception of this biological phocoss that one oannot lmaglno any doctor would be In favor of such a plan. I was oonnootod with It by the fact that a Dootor^ Schumann, who was connoctod with an agonoy of Bouhlor, was lnvolvod In thla question. I oannot remember over having soon or talkod to this Doctor. Schumann. I cortalnly novor gavo him any lnstruotlono to tako up this question of storlllra¬ tion; and I was not consulted, I was not aokod whother ho could do that or not; and tho namo of Dr. Glnuborg, who also played a role In this, I hoard only horo during tho trial. Concerning Dr. Schumann, whom I mentioned first, and tho agonoy In which ho worked, I must add that I novor onterod his offloo and, of courso, I had no lnfluonoo on tho hiring of poroonnol by Bouhlor's agoncy. Q. We'll come back to that when we discuss outhanasla. What part did you have in the typhus oxporlmonts? A. I i^arnod of tho typhus experiments, not dotalls, Just tho fact that such oxporlmonts wore conducted, as far as I can recall In interrogations last yoar; but It may havo boon at the ond of 1945. It Is asserted in tho documents that my agoncy and Prof. Rostock wore informed; but this moans only that tho subject but not the manner of oxecutlon was discussed If at all. Rostock was not asked for approval for tho oxecutlon of these measures; but I know that In this 2*72 * Feb 47-A-DJQ-21-2-3alk*iy-(AX) COURT I case he received a carbon copy. I car. testify about these experlaents only what hae been presented by the prosecution here in documents. % Q. Now, did you hear of the report at Hohenllohen and protest by Prof. Rose? A. No, as far as I as Informed this protest ot Prof. Rose's was not reported In the minutes of this meeting at % Hohenllchen. If typhus was dle- 2'72a Feb 47-A-DJG-21-*-31akley-( AX) COURT I ous sod then, this was within a certain group of interested persona; and I did not participate In It. Q. Witness, now there are a number of points which are not directly the aubjeot of the indictment but which have been brought up here in the course of the trial, the questions of blologloal warfare, polygal treatment, phlegmon, oanoor research. Did you have anything to do with any of these fields? A. Cf those which you have mentioned, phlegmon, cancer, I can answer only that I learned of then solely hero through tho prosocution. Also about the polygal experiments. I may aay tho following about tho polygal experiments, that Prof. Rostock on tho basis of a publication about tho blood ooag- ulatlon drug polygal In the Hunohener Weekly approached this papor, this magazlno, and askod for further Information. The fact that ho approaohed this magazine onTho basis of the published artlclo shows oloarly that ho had no provlouo knowlodgo; and after that ho did not reoolvo any further Information about theso things. I know nothing about phleg¬ mon exporlmonts. I know nothing about them before, if biological warfare is dlsousod, 1 must explain a little. When I received the assignment on the lot of March, 1944, % about the ohouioal warfare apparatus, Field Marshal Xeltal spoke to mo and asked mo whether I was Informed about biolog¬ ical warfare. I said "Ho," then he told mo tho followlngSit< > 194* and apparently at the boginning of 1944, too, altogether three times on express orders from Hltlor, he had passed on Instructions that preparations against defense measures, against biological warfare, were forbidden.as well as offen¬ sive measures; but he said It would bo Important If I had some knowledge of what work foreign countries wore doing on 2 , 73 S T a b 47-A-DJQ_21-.VBlaj£l8y-lAX) COURT I biological varfaro; and he said that through Generaloberstab- sarst Handloser I should go to Stabsarst Kllove, who was % gathering the material, I obtained the permission from Hand- loser to taUc to Kileve; and then I did talk to Kllevo; and ho showed mo the material whloh agents had brought him, whloh showod that preparations for blologloal warfaro wore being made by the United Statos and, above all, by Russia. 2S7Ba S Feb 47-A-DJG-21-4-31akley-l aX) couar i He himself had no special laboratory or anything else. He was only registering thoso reports on paper. A letter was submitted horo or a fll« noto, rather, from Hr. Kllevo, which 1 s supposed to show that I had close contact with 31omo concerning the question of biological warfare. This contact certainly didn't oxlst in this fora. After I teamed of this clear ordor of the Fuehrer to Keitel, I could not on X ay own Initiative malco any preparations for blologolal war- faro. I could not oven present oountor-moasuros. The file noto of Xllovo probably means that 51omo wants to tell Kllevo that hie Institute in Poson was being generally sup¬ ported by mo. That is truo. At the end of 194% I thlnlc, Bloao oailed mo up, called me on the telephono. I polntod out this morning that I was conoornod with construction and ropalr questions oonoornlng medical matters. Ho askod me to uso my lnfluonoo to have his lnstltuto In P 0 son promoted from the construction anglo. It was to booomo a genoral serum Institute. Since I rocolvod this roquost by telephone, one can see from that faot alono that wo oortalnly did not dlsouse biological warfaro. I vroto a lotter to Spoor's con¬ struction office and suggostod that this office should support Blome on his plans as for as posslblo. Thoso were all the con* noctlons I had with biological warfaro. 2*74 3 Fo'jru-r 7 ~- 0 J-:- 22 -l-Cr 'Sc C urt H • 1 Q B*t) at ^hlc^i n and concur? A I in a* n.thin,; ab ut >fcl^a r. _r.x.rir.nte. I lcarnoc’ X t ^ 3 tore, .* fur ca career ia c -neemed th-re was rwv-r any quusti n of -xix.ri-- a^nt*. I kn.w thet Blooc was the aan in th- Reich Research Council in olvtreo of enne-r and that ho hart hejun ' -f r- th. war t bo interested. in this question .£ cancer r-acorch. I n_v_r ’ifcusa-C with his that -x w rii*.nto were necessary -r ah uld bo c orri.-* at, I .acstiru ho ha<’ n intonti n -xcopt « jk whioh rd. fit bo c rv Hie tod roxyv.v-To -Iso, ^ Q H.w ctb.ut the ty.hua -x.ttor. I --lx-Vw th-rc ms a i.iatrico. Y.u eaid that ir.Xv.as r h-a- w-.eln H-onlych-u in 19 UI, rtan't tnat in 19 U 3 in Berlin, in th. Military Jfcdic-al AcaVy? A T-a, that waa a oittako .n y .oart, that ia « c nfuai n botw-on tbo ».otin: in Rc-nlych-n an-* th- fth-r :.uotii\,. Q II jv, wiuv-ea, will yu iOurao tell uc eV;ut th- *cn-rnl aa^ot of the 0X4J.rin.Rta. Y u are aware that ax. -ris.nta n hurnn bcin. a can '» criainal. Will y u ploaco c .w-ont up.n this? « *irst f *11 1 can say that -x. .n.-nta n hxraan ocirva have boon c rw’uct.d -a 1 n. a a any aci-ntilic off rts h-v- boon nV c in ^'‘lcin- T what extent they can been clo~rly classified -a criw-s rno h.aa t: Occid.0 ,n th- basis -f individual caa-s. It nt. -nt to go inta the -*criu-nta rloht n w ainco I ka* «f th-c .nly fr a th- Fr c-cuti n ci '0, ut t. vent oxtent huaan -xp-rijxnta arc etiU c-n-.'uctod. t.'iay I can ah'.w 'y a literary r-.foror.ee, a r .f.r.nco t 8-rx.tHir. .hioh ca,x* ant- ay hm-i lnat year. Jraf.Bsor K’.uTi, I bcli-v. f th- University f BceVn, printed, ut that if «no wmts to -i'k- ,r rcaa in th- c neer .r Mojj 'iv. abe lut-ly has to oniuct certain v-ry car.ful anij al ex^rii^-nts and th-n tv. w.wld have to decide fr a the aninala. 5 ith cancer n. voul’ have t. cxnalno th- r.;ana by takir.. a r.rt ,f th- liver and th-r r, anc and -xasinin thua .ace nlins ta 87A.ci.al aethv'a. T.hon that has been d no, it will be necessary to c.m’uct sinilar QX,._ri -nts very carefully n huraan *x.in_e t ', that is, r-.: ve parts f r^ana, the liver, etc. I r ’ n.t -i.-n thia in the sense that .no c nai-ers such thirds fr a the sci-ntific . int f view which c tv.8 within 2375 3 Vcbruazy-l-OJG-Z2-2-C ark C urt Jfc# 1 the herder line between rl%ht and wranj;* ftv. w;uld h».v. to conflict such experiments bccrusc fru cert-in int n a '-i U.ical c-aparieon '»tween ordj^la .-.nd imwn boioa i« n I n cr p-saibl.. >.o tomd recently tort crinnale ore, under certain circuuatonc-s, «*.«! f.r ouch -xi^riraonta. ?hia la c naldor.d triin i chanco. Tto criaixvl ia ,-ivun the rp^rtunity X establishing hlisclf by a ''cciai n f iT-.videnco and it ia nfT.-cessr-rily cmiv.ctod with -any alleviation X ais ln.riaoai.nt, out thoao th up.hts nro nly th- c naoq«v.nco X .1 1 iatic t.ttokin., and *s frVowor Inibwndfc said, the further advnnood and the wro differentiated scientific w.ri: bo- c -men, the » r_ accurately rmrt it to nine'* at th- fin-.l 'hjective. Hew Xaat this «llffwrontl.ti n hs r.dvtnoed in th- 1st •'eoadc ia ah \m 'rj an exan.-L. 1 hav. roenti n.d, bl ed. Durin. th. first tori'* T.ar wo had n iOoa thcr. w.ro bl rou.s, bar-ly ton y.ars 1 -tor rlr.oat ov.ry n. ko».w anothin. abut the f.ur bl cd ,x upe, an-* t. wo r.luc that within the individual lT -u;.a there nro five •‘iff.r .ntiatl na, juat ts bl rd was ri inr.lly dividod Into f ur bl <1 r u;-a. .^dically -nd >i 1 ic-ily science with tho aid cX tccnnolojy, end with th. -1 * f firv.r bl 1 xc-.l invest! -.ti n is r.dvrncin i; into th. atr-tos.hure in which actually nly th- tamn bein hi.ua.if can brio th. fin-.l '’cciai n, an wj Jen -.r t -bay vciy tx. 11 that anlarin cx;..ri- *.nta mat In th. last analysis be conducted ^n hvn-n bein a. Th. sa x. is true X tto classic typhus -n" den uo f-v,r nnd th.r inf-cti.us diseases* In to. -3Qx.rir .nte which wore c nductod in Gorrany tho ,.ors-nr.lity 'f Hireil.r c-rtoinly ’id play a r lo. I kn w that h. *ae f-racrly a torctor and he nev.r 1st this quality and he r-3 t. .’.tod t. t-.ke uj. thin a f all kin's an' carry th-. n Ho was -’istrvstf. 1, to l-.t o. n. sx his fil.a. Oub- hard.t will to able to toatify t this t , n . if n- wants to escribe tho "scientific ftold" * th which h- c ncerns hi self, an- s.os th- dilottantiss. He a-Jeta ;r colair., he had a 1 srith; to tri -d to ;akc jas lin- rut f water r.nd cml. He. f reed his wry Int --"leal aatters. This armin. I s. 'k. f V.n B uker an'' hia canc_r r-sc arch and :n this aido to had his cxcavnti ns .an-’ G:-dn«.83 kn-ws what -Is-. I assun. to 4 r-V.bly >*culd havo 2376 3 ?cnru-ry-u-9JG-22-3-C»ck CurtH. 1 C'nsii'orv *. a, insxi- if ha had hoard that in 19>i I «Rde attaints ualor tho -> st difficult c n-'iti ns tn btain cni*’ls n-c-ssary for oxp-ri: a-ntd pur- sus. J just sv that tho qu-stx n cf t» wfl-ctiVcrK.se cf Oor.aan civonical w-trf-.ro ms i. -.rtant in ocnnwCti.n mth tbw c. unt-r ocasuros, ant' tho hchrf I rr.cht t Id _vj th-y hnc* 'ifficulty -ttin -nli-ala. I turo-d t. yth- iAiftwaffo an . rt had a>nts in ft-rdo.au* on't k y.r thw tr. 1 : ic.al rrdens in Or-s-cn %c'oac that sccti-d tho fastest t. us. I cito this nl" in rlcr t sh w that the ;xin- cl.'lw was .a t Juct t c nduct tho hxtar. ->i ri. _ntc, rut that .y --a vi.de ab'ait thwSw quwfti:ns was that thw anlrl -x x:. -nts r.rc tho wcisivc fact r arv* th -1 hwvan .xi~rir».nts v.r- c ndocted nly un'*cr c.rtr.la circuv otincce -n ur. -r c-rtiin •v.dical •o. -r. s. If rv. scales f barn -x.crinent at all, t'.n in .ini n n. ws n-,t c niuoo thw r.sult cl tiK. w7.--rii.i.nt t with thw Ju.'itiTicati n f r it. .. Jurtifi-.'* x. -ri-^nt ray l-ad t n negative r.sult because it : zs n t th- final titan and th. ri. ht thin and -na aust , -tforve ju . rinciplo, that rn -x.orient must n t be leapt ns siall ns ^ .ssi 1 , but it aust ho as *ji , as .xUnsiv- :.s r-ccsaar/, s that th- r-sult is actually user.;!-, THS . SSF/vT: C urt till r-co-s until rone-thirty -'clock in the n?rnin • (The Tribunal ndj unv.-’ until 0930, U Fohru-ry 19u7) a 7 e b 47 H«?JC_i_l_H*ynes (MSB) Coart So. I ccsRicrrD ccpt Official Transcript of the Aeerlcmfl Military Tribunal in the Hatter of the United States of America against lari Brandt, et al., defendants, sitting at Kurnbwg.Psraany, on 4 February 1947, 0930-1630 hours. Justice Beals presiding. SHI PHl$ia!TT: Mr. Marshal, will you a certain that the defendants are all present in Court* *H1 MAR SH A L : If it please your Honor, all the defendants^are pres¬ ent in the Court. TKX PRX3ir*3i7: The Secretary General will note for the record that all defendants are present in the Court. Defense Counsel nay proceed. DIRICT LXAMXSATIOS—Continued BT IP. SZZ7ATXU3—Restated k Witness, yesterday afternoon you were diocusslng your attiltudo toward experiments on human beings. *111 you uloaso say when such oxperimsnts in your opinion are pernieelble and what tho guiding prlnclplos in such caaee are? A I said yesterday that within modloal scientific research in cor- tnin dlsoases and under cortain conditions, in order to guarantoo further dcrolop-«nt exporironts on human beings aro absolutely csnontial. 1 said that there can be tenoral rosaions for this. Of couroo, there can alao bo special reasons — I refer to tho vnr—for spocial experiments and spodal work in certain directions. It is a natter of course thit before ono undertaken a htaan experiment ell possible animal experiments oust bo oonductcd first. of an experiment on human beings requires all ced¬ ed briefly that "nr can not Judge rotroactivoly from tho romultt of. an experiment its testification and that, rice versa, a negative result does not nean that tho experiment as such was not Justified. v 2370 4 f 0 b 47-X-7JC_l_l_H*ynei (KSD) Court *o. I If one does conduct cxperlecnts, they W»t be kept on as *=11 a scale as poaalble and, on the other k*id, mist be sufficiently cxtoneivc that tho results are certain. I bell ere th-t there are two basic 'questions which one must consider If one intends to undertake a hunan expcriaont. That is tho question of the l^>ort*nco and the question of the unlrportanco. * 7 e b 47- u -JJC_l_2_E syn et (KSD) Court So. I "Importance* la tycoBorua Oth 'nsceesary", In the Interests of humanity, which ono must consider as represented by individuals. Assuming that the experimental subject volunteers for tho experiments as such is not danforous, or is as little dangerous ns la humnly poaaihlo, thon I consider that such an oxperinent is not ouch disputed. % It is different vhon I do not say that tho aeperiment is lnportnnt, the suhjoct is voluntary md the experlecnt not dangerous. If I sny that the experieent is not irpOrtant, a hiaan experiment, scon fron tho point of view of tho unimportant, is In ay opinion impossible. That Is, porhaps, ths first point where one could actually spqak of a crioo. If tho experiment is unimportant, tho subject a voluntocr, and tho experiment not dangerous, this is nevertheless no Justification for tho execution of such an experiment, because It is in tho first placo un¬ important. Tho question becooos difficult ns soon ns tho question of tho voluntary character of the ■xpcrlaontal subjoct is dlscusnod In an exportoont which Is rocognised ns i^ortant. It la that tho subjoct docs not volunteer, evon if the experiment as such is not dangorous. In such a ca 0 o, tho words *not voluntary" must be dofinod, and ono will oobo to different points of view. Recontly tho question was discuscod whothir a prlsonor can voluntoor for an apartment. I do not want to take the dofinltoly opposing ▼low which was taken at that tlao, for I consider it quite posalblo that a prisoner may voluntoer to have non-dangerous oxperinonts performed on hie person, but froa tho moment when there Is danger—thnt is, duigor to tho llfo of tho experimental oubjoct through the experiment—at that aonont, the physician « such can not alone decide whether or not to carry out tho experiment. H 0 re it is necessary that a superior auth¬ ority giro at lea^t approval for such an experiment: that is, permit H. Here tho question of persons condemned to death booomes acute: whether tho person eondoaned to death volunteers or not. I will leavo that 2379 4 7ob 47Jt_7JC-U2_& v -ci (MSC) Court lo. I ooeatlon open for t he accent, ffae peraon 14 ^iveO an opportunity* h chaaCB, • and the declelon is core or leae left up to hl». ?h«e® experlaente will also lie discussed where the lsportance of the experiaent Is reoognlcod, the subject does not Tolunteer, end the expert- sent la diuifercua, or, even If the subject volunteers, where the oxporl- aont la dangerous. « Tab 47-*:-?j:-i-3-Ha7ao« Court !J°. 1 It *111 probably ba accessary to aattlo these questions basioally, probably on an international basis; all the acre because Ofi the basis of the indications Siren la literature, oTory oirilirei state today — if ono considers huL»n axperioenta a crioe—erery state is guilty. I should Ilka to say that the hi^er scientific research is csrriod, the furthor this dereloxcant has p-otjesaod in a stats, tho grootor,would ba the jillt. The purpose of an order for experlaents would ba siTon; the point of riev would be established free ■blch exporiconts can be conducted, and, in tho third ci4ss, for tho oxocution, of the oxperiuent Itself, the nocossary nethods would ba established* C‘JQTt Sc. 1 •i 7ab 47-*-2-l-£B(-Hcehan Q. Sew, witness, will you pleas* eons beck to the uxoerlnents carried out hore in Qernary. Would you have been able to stop such exnerinentsT A. It is difficult to snsvsr such a question tine* it is oore of t theoretical. Question, but nevertheless I do not believo that I would have been able to stop then. If I had been inforned hbout the nethods of exccu- % ti.n in the ease of the dangerous sxporlaents, I would corta.ily have been told that they were persons who had been ccndemed to death; and in the non- dangercus experinents I would Juve been assured of the voluntary nature of the subject, also the luoortance of tht exper icdnts, Which in s-ae cases were ooual to a strong dispute! All this would krve^been pointed out so on the whole I consider it lnpossible for n* to have stopped or prevented tho experinents as tuflh. THE HKESIDESTTi The Trltwnr.l understands the witness has nla.ccd basic stress upon ths loportrnce and the non-inportones of the experinents, having in alnd tho goal to bo attiined. Tho Tribunal would bo interested in learn¬ ing the attitude of tho witness concerning his view, having in nlnd the cir¬ cumstances of tho occasion and his view of the lcportanco or non-lnportanco of the exuerlusnts cnarged in this lndictoent to hive boon conducted by tho defendants. Do you understand, sir? m. SaEVATIUS: Tee, sir. Witness, you have hoard what lnfornntion tho Tribunal wants about ths oxoorlnents. You know tho exoorlnents. i>lorso spoak of the cold exocriuonts. the freezing experinents. as you know then. THE VTTXSSS: I oust state that I know the experinonts only froa the prosecution's side and that I do not yet know the attitude of those who actually carried then out. I could possible express ny views on tho ox- periaents nure clearly if I were asked to do so ct tho end of tho oxaninn- tlon of the actual defendants; if I uuet nvw conncnt on the ectuol oxoeri- nents, I night later have to sake scue c'-rrectiope. na. SZBVlfflWH Mr, President, I do not know if I understood tho orurt corroctly. THE KfcESIDEST: Tho poiwt la this. Doctor, n®. u ossune for the nonent that the prosectttixi' e vsrsoo of these various 1 * nwroct. 2>.l Court lo. 1 4 lob 47;K-2-2-SHk-Me«hrn Beaod upon that supposition, the court vould be concerned in knowing the attitude of the witness ab«it theo. If an untold theory or point of viov ie presented by the several defendante -hen they take the etend on their own behalf, I ac confident tfco Tribunal will alloy thia defendant to go back on the etend aw*, exorees hie attitude or viov in consideration of the entire evidence thon before the Tribunal. BT SR. SLRTaTIOS: j ■ k- Vltnuee, you heard vhat the Judge hae eaid. Would you pleaee assume that vhat the proeecutlon has presented ia correct? A. If I apoak of the cold experiments, thoy vere conducted in the year 1942 and the occasion for thoao vi*a a deaand of the Luftvaffo in order to brin* aid to those fliers vho vere in energency eituations. A superior state of interest, which I aentlonsd bofore, vns no doubt decisive in this case. The execution of the exuorlnenta, insofar re they concorn Hr. Raschor, soon to as exaggerated for his oerson froo e certain period of tioe on. I knov that similar exoeriaents in tho year of 19*-1 vere carried out in the United States vlth sluilir nsults. rrlsoners vere not ueod but insane persons vere used. The cooling vr.s down to 25 dogroes body tsoperaturo and thoro wore six ca.see of dea.th. I aseur.e that sitiilar interests and conditions voro decisive as vero later decisive for our Luftwaffe. That these experiments thonsolvcs have certain importance ia shown by the fact that tho American Air Force also announced in the past nenth that tho experiments in Dachau hrd given then an Advance of several yoars in their ovn research, so tho eroerlnonts in Dachau have led to a generally pcsltivo result. C}. Witness, about the high altitude experiments. Can you comment on thea also, ev«n though you vere not a specialist? A t leaso please express your opinion. A. The high altitude experiments vere possibly initiated for the sane reasons. As far as the person of Dr. Raschor again is connected vlth theo, ->aa aust assume the seme thing that I Just said about the cold experiments. I believe that freo a certain point on he acted beyond the Units necessary. Cte is the importance of tho experlnents being carried cn as stall a scale as Court Ho. 1 4 rob 47-H-2-3-hEM-Meehaa possible. Q. Vhat is your opinion about calarla experiments? A. They axe a tyoical exaaple of the fact that exnerinonts on hunan ' beings aro neeesscry. Eesevch into urlarla can be conducted only with fcunan beings. I referred to Dengue fever yesterday where the situation is slallcr and the references, which you yourself nade recently to the research in Acerica now being conducted on one hundred prisoners, soaaks fur the fact that this is not of a criulaol neturej that it is siuoly n demand in tho interests of humanity and one knove about one Dili ion persons dying annually in India of ualria and the downed to help here is all the greater. Q, hi ease eoeakahout the Lost experiments? A. The lost experinent# are to be ooneldered first of rll ns ocm- dangerous. Thsy have generally been carried out ever since chonical warfare agents have oxleted. A low Quantity nllllgrtu of Lost la out on the skin in ordor to examine the roiction and later new ustbods of treaUiont aro devel¬ oped. It is e typical oxarple of the fact that tho volunteering, tho aeoect of the volunteering nose, is decisive. I know that in the Military Medical Acedecy praotically every officer candidate riade such a Loot exnerinont on himself. The degree of danger 1# virtually nono. This would be on eroerl- nent which foil into the first group which I said vot necessary, voluntary and not dangerous. You havo also hoard of tho sulfonamide experiments. House spook about then. A. In 19*il and 19-2 the Question of sulfonamide was dobatsd in tho Vet^oscht aaong the phyoicione of the Vehmacht cad at hoca. It was not dear whether the use of sulfonamide administered locally on the wounds, or orally, that is, by administering sulfonamide tablets, whothcr this would give protection in all front hospitals. This Question was dobated end the decision as tc whether sulfonaaide was to be applied or not was at that tine Quito unsettled. There were individual surgeons end consulting surgeons who held the point of view that for the hosoittls sulfonaaide was to be rejected in erring for the wounded in operational .methods and one should not put Court So. 1 * lob •i7-K-2-i-E*-#®«hes aulfonaolde powder on the vcunde end thick that that was enough. I know that In the eroerioenta of I'rof eager Gebkcrdt and other agents possibly the death of Heyirlck in Prague cloyed a role, perhape as setting the tioe for thie esalnm«nt. I eaid yoatordaythat I ay a Hi was of the ooinion that thla question ahould be aolTed in a different way b* establishing a aort of noreble hospital which would follow the petlente end thua control the effectiveneaa of the sulfonanlde. ^ . %, Vhot la y-ur opinion abait the trrnaplnntatlon and regeneration experimental A. According to the ono-aided proaentation of tha oroaocution I cannot undaratand thia problon coupletely. I do not underatand the reaaona for the type of experiments conducted and I wiah to aak that I apeak on thie after Professor Gothardt haa toatlfled hiaaalf. Q. Tou have heard of the sea water experlnentaT A. The tea water exoariaenta poaelbly fall within the framework of the two experinenta nenticnad where the interoate of the Luftwaffe wore the In- pulse, whleh in the lost analysis cace free Guerin* and were exocuted with that lnpulao. Whether danceroueneea played a apodal role I cannot aay. 4 ?eb 47-X_3_L-UC--L*Mcr (HSD) Court *c. I ft *hat it your opinion of Hepatitis rcsoarch? k Hopntltit ^pldoslca was a disease which effcctod all the *ohr- racht la tho last severely. It is known that certain units lost 40$ to 30$ by this sickness. The disease, as such. Is not dangerous; in tho llteraturo which was published only last year, 1946, it Is said that special measures for prevention arc not necessary bocauso thoro is no danger to life. I said yesterday that the aortality figure Is about onai tenth of that In tho casd of sal aria. If experiments wee conducted, and I assume that they were now, they were no doubt not d^mrerous and It Is probable that the methods used In tho Investigations, such as tho stonach Juice investigations, or tho liver functions, wero not danger ours. The dlseaso, as such, in view of tho mob or of lossos • t which tho *ohraacht had froa this dosoase, was of special intorcst, and I assuao that experlnonts In this oonnoctlon vero Conducted In other countries in tho saao way as I assure they were conducted hero, ft S^orlllsatlon oxperlront* were also oontlonod - Schuaann and Glauborg - will you plonse oosoent on thcat k Tho Schuaann oxperinonts soeaod to ao to havo boon useloss cxporlnonta. I cannot larglne that with two or throo nlnutcs of x-ray troatoont one can offoct etorilltation. I cannot doclaro eyeolf positively In favor of tho principle. There wero no modlcal Indications of why tho sterilisation was to becarrlrd out. ft ViU you pleaso consent on tho Thphus oxporimonts? k "yphus is a disease which Is to bo consldcrod as euch ooro serious than Hcpatltla or Malaria. Consequently, bocaure of tho ■ctual lose of life through typhue the superior Stato Intorcst in this disc B so during war tlno was all tho greater. In order once acre to givo a a^arieon of tho dangerousness of these diseases, one era as sue o that Typhus is 100 to 200 tines as dangerous a6 Malaria, An exes^lc occurs to =e on tho question of the experiments. In tho first *orld *ar D ‘'crkish doctor, in order to study typhus and Its transference froa one huaan bolng to another, infected Court No. 1 U Fob. li7-M-3-2-»T!>-Lca 310 Turkish soldiers with infected blood. About 170 of then fell ill* The others had already had typhus and apparently were incune. Of the approxi¬ mately 170, 65 patients died* The result at that tine, it was 1916, was declaim in many respects for the nodical service of the Turks and they sought an excuse, a Juristic excuse, for this physician who was responsible for these deaths, by declaring him teeporarily insane. 0. Now there remain the phosphorous experiments. Will you please A speak about then? A. The dangerousness of phosphorous exporinents, as such, can bo Judged only as in the case of the Lost exporinents. I ssw innunarablo phos¬ phorous burn* on wcnen and children in our citios and tho oxporlnonts con- .• ducted in Buchomald mu jA have dealt with tho sano symptoms, since phosphorous came from English incondiary bombs) Tho wounds healed after suitablo troat- sent by various methods. Doath oocurrod only whoro there woro extonslvo bums and where tho symptoms of the patient woro those as in burns in general. DR, SE.1VA7I03I Doos tho Tribunal dosiro any further information on these individual experiments? JUTOE SED3ING* Assusdrg tho Prosocution*s testimony to be truo conoemlng the chargo of extermination of Jews for tho purpose of completing a skeleton oolloction and tho lator extermination of tuborcular Polos, will you have tho defendant ooenent upon what military nocossity existed, if any, for conducting those programs? Q. Witnoss, you have hoard the question of tho Tribunal. Will you pleaso consent on the tubercular Polos and tho skeleton collection? A. There was cortainly no military intoroat in question in the skeleton collection. In the case of tuberculosis, I must assuno that sueh things did occur. I wculd not consider it Justifiod. I consider it necessary that as long as ore can help a hunan-being and as long as there is any prospect whatovor, one must help him. That one nay consider transfers of tuberculosis patients from ono place to another is a ttought which is not Unfamiliar to me. When I spoke of these 3pecial hospital installations yes ter- 4 Jrt. 47J(-3_3_An5_L. #ter (MSD) Court *o. I day I can add that we considered aoriny tuberculosis patients and concon- tratlny than at certain points In the Allpau end aoreral such Installs- • tlona, hospitals, tuberculosis hospitals, vhlch already existod, or In tha southern Black Borest near St. Biaelen; but I*soe no Justification because a person is sick or lufferlry, or because ho can no lonyor work, to kill hln, no natter what Ms nationality is or what his aye is. TE1 FRZSirXKT: I hare a question. A question by Judye A Beals. I understand «he witness, In discussing experiments upon human- belnys, to stress the danger to life only. I would llko th^ opinion of the witness upon such experinents which it would be reasonably anticipated or known would result in serious physical injury to tfao expcrlaontal subjoct, whether internal or external, as to whether that would not also be an ol*aent to bo considered, ae woll ae danror to life only? BY m. SHTATIUS: ^ Will you please connect on that? A It le a question of serious sickness and of subsequent symptoms to be considered but in sr opinion a distinction aust be aade botwoon whother there is actual danyor to life or possible dnnyer to lifo. X •aid before that I consider an exporlsent a# not danyorous if it le not danyeroue as far ae a human bciny can Judyo. Of oourso I admit that there it no experiment which actually and undar all clrcuastancos is not dnnyerous, slnco cron In tho cost olaplo injury there can bo cos*licntlone. But it le not oxpected, Bor example, if a nalaria patlont, vho has contracted nalaria through an experiment, cannot yet rid of ms- laria and dooe not respond to treatment, that has to bo cvaluatod differently than If tho solaria could bo treated and cured. But tho conditions under which one undertakes such experinent* is that ono aeeunos that it is not danyerous. PPISIBBT: The witness did i»t quite answer ry q-»ostion. I intended to request the opinion of the witness as to whether or not tho pertically certain serious bodily injury, peraanent injury, either in¬ ternal or external, to the experimental subject, was not also a serious consideration 2587 4 *eb. 47-H— 3 -4-J rn -Legaor (MSB) Court »o. I that the only cone 1 doratIon la not the possible death of tho subjoct? That le, In any experlaent upon a huaaa-beinr If It would reasonably be anticipated that the experlaent would result not In death but In serious pcrtoml Injury to the subject, either Internal Injury or external Injury, would net* that also be a aerloua ooneideration In de¬ termining whether or not any experl-ents should be conducted? A Such a point of view la decialvo In tho eolectlon of experi¬ mental subjocte. I would consider that of about equal lnportanco with giving a person condeanod to death an opportunity to preservo hla % life ur.dor the conditions to be expected. I fallod to point out ono thing — that Is, that In all oxporlsents ono nuat -sake It clear to tho subject what tha experlaent le about and what results nay bo expoctod. Whether tho oxperiaont Is dangerous or not, this eoens to me to be a decisive factor In tho question as a wfcolo. 2388 4 7.b 4%-Sf-4-l-Haloy (MS) Court So# I BT 9# SHTATIUS: y, C 0 nti, and so forth, and Bionc *>d taken up a ror7 doflnite attitude against Conti. 1 net hin occasionally on the ■see question of leadership of Wohrracht physicians, but we never dis¬ cussed the things which are under discussion hore. Roso visltod no onco in 1944, I believe. Yesterday 1 nentloned his desire to hero the paralytics, whoa he was treating with aalnrla, put in a hospital,'and X was in contact with hla a second tino, X believe it was in writing though, when he asked for additional food rations for thoso aalnrla patients. I passed on his roquest to tho food oinistry. I roforrod to Sievers yosterday. I saw hla only onco, when in oonnoctlon with tho ap¬ paratus against gas ho gnro so a final report fron Hirt. H 0 did not toll no about tho Ahnenerbo nt that tloe, or about other oxporinents which woro boing conducted. Then thoro is another group of gontloaon, Hmdlosor, Bostock and Brack. I dlscustod zy contact with Professor Rostock yostor- day. I worked with hin for 19 y^ars. Oenoraloberstabsarst Handlosor, aftor 1942, the events ovor v lae=a, 2 caao In contact with hin and since that tiao I have had Increasingly clot# oontact with hits. At tho end of the war, his office as Chief of Medical Servico wpb opsn in Bents, a inall suburb of Berlin, where I w fi s also located nnd fron tho practical necessity of location wc case together there, I did not discuss tho Mporiaonte which are on trial here with hin. 5fee last is Brack. I net 3rack In 1934 as the Adjutant of Buhle, the head of the Chancellory 2390 4 Tel. 47 -M-SV^_ 3 -Mal 07 (MSD) Court -~o. I of the fuehrer in 3erlin, I had acre closer concoctions with his Inter in 1939 or 1940, when the proxies of euthanasia had boon brought up, and then until he went into the Vehrsacht in 1942 I saw hin frequently. H Xho»c * crc tfc* individual portonfj shat contact did you have with the nodical societiest A I did hot belong to any radical socloty until 1933, I was e aonbor of tho C-orman Society of Sur#ery, and in 1933 I tisif-ntd n# that X had no connecti'ne with those societies. k How about tho Bational Socialist Lcaguo of Physicians? You men¬ tioned it once? A In 1933 I Joined tho “ati-nal Socialist League of Physicians. Before those was any nccting or discussion X wr* tent material and with a request to make a speech on racial questions. X refusod bccauoo in tho first plade the material < iv«n to me seemed to no toe primitive, and in tho socond place bocauso I did not havo adequate sciontlfic knowlodgo to say anything basic on this question. I do not mean to say I would not rocomirc racial points of vlrt in few nestings during tho war. Until 1942 it would • A not h-vo boon possible, because as Escort Physician * was tied to tho Eoadouarters. Pros 1942 on I was in Marburg, once ft a celebration. I then participated in the third sorting of tho consulting physicians of the Military Medical A^dcry, whit* was in 1942 in tho spring. Ono norn- lng I epont at the sooting of C-croon soldiers in Dresden. Ii^ tho fall of 1943 on bohalf of the Juohrer, I had to give Sauerbruch the Knights 1 Crose of Mar Merit Cross. The-c vat a eeoond sooting of consulting physioians of Eononlychen in 1944. At thie at ating at Hohenlychon did 70 U hold tho -elconing addross? A Toe. k I will show you thie eponing speoch, which ie Document MO 924, which ie not in any doeusent book; which was euboittod in ono of tho lnet acssino. I do not know whether tho ?rjbuual hrt a copy in English. A I suet explain the history, tho events loading up to this aoctlng, and point out tho reason why U was hold in Hohenlychon. In tho spring of 1944 It was hardly poeelblo to hold a sooting in a Oernan city, bccauso of constant air raid alarns tho oxccution of a Dott¬ ing would havo been lnrpossiblo. r or a reason which I do not know Oebhardt learned of this. Oebhardt loarnod it hod not boon settled whoro this aeoting was to be hold and no doubt offerod Hohenlychon os the placo for holding tho sooting, and Generaloborstabsarst Handloser accepted the invitation. 2592 4 ?et>-*-G3S-^-l-I/enhardt. Court uo. 1. It was possible to put up the sany participant* rt Hohealyehen -sA receive then, and there was enough rooa to hold the icdividual conferences. Kohenlycaen v s. at tae sase tioo. ar. SS Hospital. 3ia supreme Coldf in t..ls c so was Hli-lor. I tu& to partieW.td ia this conforonce becnuso a word was to bo given on behalf of the Huohror by oach one of the represent¬ atives froa tho Luftwaffo. the juy. end tne Savy. In order to docido W-.o was to a'Id tae opening speech there, in any cane, I hnd to distributo the decorations. Gobharlt. who vt-i the nost, asked no to hold this spooch, end no s- id t..is was in :.roeiont witu Kial«r. 1 did not dltcpss this question vita Hia-lor hicsalf either before or aftor and for fornal roi.sons I nedo tols spooch in tho xuao of tho H.ichfuehror. I pointed out the nocosoity of eonAD work of the doctors, in tho intorest of thu s> Idlers, and gr.vo this decoration to Gobhardt hlasolf, first. I onphasirod tho value of Hohon- lychon as a place of knowledge whora post-operative care was carried out. Hohotilychen hod gained a certain reputation in Goraany during tho llynlc*. Gcbhrdt wr.s in charge of the nodical care of tho sportsnen and through tho nature :nd uotnod of this tr«.»t:.ont he was a nan who was known far boyond tr.o bordors of tho Reich. Th- t Hohealyehen wu* to play c special rolo in this direction wr.s backus* in tho acdic-4 Zone Uxor was a hue and cry for a new Hohonlychon, und it wr.s upp. runtly .-.greed tJ ostnolisa r now aospltal in Luedenscholdt. Sohcnlychon, as l sports place of treatment, in tho cr.se of Ocbhr.rdt, wao a well known conflict with us. s to the oth«.r gontlonon who wore gi*cn an award, thoro was ftitsoit. Gutxoit was the consult in, head of the /Jirnocht nodical Section. :xA I had oxprossly given hlu the ewerd, because, in addition to ..is pood work itself, Internal Kcdlclno, which he represented, «\s to be honorod as tho text re:ding. Gutielt was theonly Internalist th> t rocoivod this award. So far as surgeons wore concerned, Gutsoit had alruidy rocoivod the Knight's Cross froa Gobtn.rdt, and the third was Profostor Tnooniss a well known brain surgeon known in G^raan nodical circles. Hcroon Backnoistor. at tho head - 2393 - 4 ?eb-w-C3S-^-Z-Ls hr . hA rdt. Court . •. 1. of tie ..cdlc.-l Center at St. 3lasioa as I nontionod a while ago. received :ae award in view of his work and participation in the fight against Tuberculosis. 3T DR. S H7.JIUS: * Sow, I should like to conclude this subject. I cono to the Helen Research Council; you woro a not-bor of the 3orrd of Directors of tho Helen Re scare.'. Council. v„ro you nott ^ In 1943 I bee.no 0 aeubor of the Reich Research Council. ,.t thi.t tine the Reich Research Council was under tno Education ].inistor, «.nd by a spec!el decree in JUnu of 1942 they reaovod it fron tho Education ! lnistor and it was put under Gonoralnrts Schreibor. Scientific work was to bo put on very broad basis of goncral scloncc end Schrolbor scoaod tho right nan to do this. Thv Rolen Research Council consistod of a prosidont and an administrative nchino. Toon, it hud a sot of loodorshlp staff, about thirty or forty branches of difforont typos of rosoarch. Thor.- wore bonds of oreh of the spociolist groups. Medicine coning under tho hand of Clnssic 1 Medicin. was placed under Snuor Mhch. There wero a nunber of Deputy . inisters. The Doputy ut tho hoad of tl.e Roi h Hedichi Control wns Dr. Schrolbor vno wn« nentlonod yesterday* ^sldo frou the Board, and this ..didnlstrativo uhChiBu, the R_ich Research Council, wp- » roprosontr.tlvo € | - 2394 - I reh^OT-4t-«7D-5-»la-iehnh?.rdt Court So. 1 arrangement, There were representatives of the highest Reich Authority, and free agencies of which one could assume that they had sooo contact with scientific work. The Plenipotentiary Minister was in it. Speer was in it. And I was also one of the neobers, there were over twenty. The Board did not have oiy right to issue instructions and could not exert any influence on the heads of the specialist group and the deputies and the Corrdssioners. This was not possible because the composition of this Board was not from the point of view of Profession but of Agency. And it did not in effect play any inportant role itself, by reason of the faot that froa a Military research viewpoint, the Society was founded in July 19Ui. This faot was not even ro ported to the coshers of the Board, and I Byself 1 oar nod of it only on the basis of the document. I must point out that in April 19U*, shortly before the end of the War, I received an appointment from Goering bins elf. That is, as the individual Deputy over a specialist group to tako up the point and establish aedidno and to take chargo of then, I was to bo tho Deputy Oeneral Surgeon within the Reich Research Council, I rocoivod tho dogree only a week before sy nodical agency was dissolved in l?ldu Q Were you connected with the Roich Research Counoil through your offioe of Resoerch? A It could only be a natter of gonoral nuaca which Professor Rostock has for all office ehiof direotor with Prof. Ur tad. He had no right to issue instructions to the heads of specialist groups because they wore undergoing supervision tho re was no other connection. Rostock node all of tho appoint-onts bins elf. Q What is tho Ahnenerbe Society; what was your comootion with It? A Until I was arrested, I considered the Ahnenerbe Society . Organization a sort of SS Administrative Agency concerned with Research in connection with antiquities of sene sort. I did not know aqjr details or any facts of c.ry thing that was done. I never had ary contact with the Ahnenorbe at all. The only contact I had with Hr. Si overs is that he did not inform me. I did not even know that he came frea the Ahnenerbe. -2>9*- t Teh 47-H-A7D-5-2a-I*chnkardt (HSD) C"irt Ho* I EH. S1B7ASHJS: M r . President, now I cone to the next count of the ir.dictaent ab-ut Xuthanasla. Shall I begin n-V ot after the recess? "HI PSTSimr?: C-unsel, you say oontlnue wish the exanination of the Defendant. 3T IB. SIB7A7IDS: it Vitness, you appo nr to have participated in tho expcriccnta on Luthanaaio. I shall show you tho decroe of the 1st of Docoabor, 1939,^ that i» D oc. 360. It is in Docuncnt Book Ho. 14. Ploaso discuss how this decroo caae about. . x A After the erd of the Polish enr^aign in about October, tho fuehrer was at Obernnl t burg. I cannot longer cloarly renenber tho advaaoe but I was called to hia and ho told =o that bocauso of tho Docuaont, which ho had received free Professor Bcuhlcr, he -anted to carry out a solution of tho *uthanasia question. H 0 favo no gonoral diroctlvos of how ho inafinod it, and tho fundasontal; insano persons, who wore in such a condition »hat they could no longer tako any conscious part in lifo. Theso pooplo wore to be givonrollof by doath. Gonoral instructions about info mat ion which ho hlnsolf had rocoivod followed, and ho told so to got in touch with Boohlor hinself about tho natter. I did so by tolophono on th« sane day, and then I inforoed Hitler about cy talk with Boohlor. Then ho sont so lator tho decroo, not in tho fora In which wo hrvo it hero, but in a sioilar fora, and cortain changos woro made. My request wps that a precaution bo introduced for tho participation of Doctors, and I used an expression which was fanillar to no,It said that buthanasio could bo carried out on persons incurably side with probability bordering on certainty. Sinco this formulation wao itr-ngo to hin, it was added with tho nost critical Judracnt of thoir con¬ dition of sickness. This dccrco was signed about tho ond of O c tobor, which repds as follows: "Bcichslcitcr Bouhlvr rad Dr. Br-ndt, M.D., arc Charged with the responsibility of cnl*r.- ing the authority of certain 0 doctors to bo designated by nano in such a nanner that perrons who, ac¬ cording to hunac 'u^gaent, arc incurably ill can on tho omst careful diag¬ nosis of their condition cf sickness, be accorded a cercy doath. 11 • leb. M-TP-16-L-Hinabuch (USD) Co’^t 3o. X <1 Did you tAlk to Bouhler? ▲ I talked to 3ouhler only by telephone at first and after the decree wee timed I did not talk to hla immediately but sent the decree to hla in Berlin. • <4 A c d what was Hitler's idea of euthanasia? *hA did ho understand by It? A The decisive thine for hla was what ie expressed here in the decree; that incurably ill persons — really I should have said insano, other persons were always exceptions — a mercy death couli be accorded. That is a noasure dictated by purely htaaano considerations, and nothing oioo could bo thought under any circuastanceo, and nothing oloo was ever said to bo. Vt Tou said that tho Fuehror ,nvo you tho assijtunent on tho basis of a call froa Bouhlcr. It could not havo boon a call froa Bouhlor alono. Thore must havo boon other reasons. A It was not a call. It was eo»o kind of a documentary prodocuro which was doclsivo. It =ay bo that tho Tuohrcr already had thoco documents or that Bouhlor epoko to hin about it. I don't *now exactly. But this was not the cause of the euthanasia problons being taken up. In his book, "Mein laapf, Hitler had referred to it in cortain chapters. The law for tho prevention of the birth of sick children is a proof that Hitler had concrotoly conccrnod hlnsolf with such problems onrllor. Tho law for tho prevention of the birth of children of ctfigonltal dcasoao follcvod tho evonts. It was written because people with congonital diecasos oxistod. It is a problca which affects tho whole world. Similar laws have been passed in other countries. Dr. C-ehardt Wagner, who was tho predocossor of Dr. Conti, at tho ?-irty rally in Hurnbcrg discussed these questions. I did not talk to &rhardt Wagner at that tine and had nothing to do with these things, Vat I havo heard now that in 1935 Gerhardt Wegner had a filn made present¬ ing the problem of the insano. It was apparently a fila made in asylucs With insane persons. 2397 4 Job. -M—.T’-S-l-S inabock (HSD) Court So. I H Witness, wore there not request* reeoivod toy Bouhler and tho TuchrerT A Bequests to th^s effect were cer^irOj received constantly by 3ouhl#r 4 7.b 4 -JJ:^_£Jlnabuch (*SD) Coxxt *o. I ?he Chancellery of the Fuehrer always recel-ed euch thlnfa. I only knew that theee requests were jilted on to the H e ich Ministry of the Interior. I sgraelf know of one reques^ Ip the spring of 1939 which vaa sent to the Fuehrer hlaself through hie Adjutant's offieo. The father % of • daforaed child approached the Fuehrer and asked that this creature should he killed. Hitler turned this natter over to ne and told me to go to Leipzig 1 mediately — It had taken place In Leipzig — to conflrn the fact. It was a child who was horn blind, an Idiot — at least It aeesed to he an Idiot — and It lacked one leg and part of one ara. 7HS PH 1 SIIKHT: We will have a recess for a few aoDenta. (A recess was taken.) U ? Q b . 4* 7-4Wn-7-l-Pot ty Court Ho, 1 THE MARSHAL* The Tribunal is again in session. 51 DR. SSRVATIUSI q. Witness, you wore speaking about the affair at Leipzig, and regarding this deforced childj what order did Hitlor give you? A. He gave no the order to talk with the physicians who were taking care of the child and to, first «f all, test the statements of the father as to their veracity. If they wore correct, then in his najje I was to infora the physicians that they wore permitted to carry out Euthanasia. It was important in this respect* that this should not hap?on in tho fora toward the parents that they themselves at some other period of tiao should feel incrirdnatod as a result of this Euthanasia, and, there¬ fore, that the parents should not havo tho depression that they thcoaolvea had boon tho cause for tho doath of this chili, I was further ordorod to stato that if these physicians should becone involved in legal procedures, they should take care by order of Hitler that this procedure should be halted. Then Boraann also was ordered to inform tho Minister of JUstico, Guortnor, in this caso, ♦ Q, what did the doctors who wore involved say? A, Tho physicians maintained tho point of view that tho keeping alive of such a child could actually not bo Justified, and it was pointed out in this respoct that in natornity wards under circumstances by dootors theasolvos in such a caso Euthanasia wcaild bo performed without arything further being said about it. Any preciso instructions woro not given in that respect, 0 , This problem of deformities, was it treated in any othor way? A, The problem of deformities has probably already been discussed before this caso in Leipzig, Hcwover, thon in the course of the aurmer there was work done in a roro concrete fora, first of all, on tho part of the rtinistry of the Interior, and in this caso we were involved as woll as special consultant to Dr, Conti — who became Reich Minister for Health after the death of his colleague, Wagner, and then after that became Stato -2399- h Feb. 4i7-4-A!T>-7-2-Putty Court Set 1 Secretary In the Ministry of the Interior, so that Dr. Linden continued to occupy himself with these natters, Q Who was Dr. London? A Dr. Linden was Ministerial Counselor in the Reich Ministry of the Interior, and he was a physician, and ho was a oonpotent official who later on was in charge of all these sanitorixos, and la tar on in the course of the treatment of the Euthanasia question he was appointed na exponent for all these natters, Q What was the proceduro at th: tine? Was Hitler informed about all those natters? A In August of 19U* by his ordor I participated in a conference which took place between Dr. Linden and Mr. TOuhlor and some additional cor., and in its course tha question of troatoent of these dofomitiee was discussed, and which also Included a discussion about the nothod of treating thoso cases. On tho part of the Ministry of the Interior Dr. Linden put forth documents, questionnaires, etc., which had been furnished which wore then discussed or.co sore in iotail, and in this case it was tho preparatory work for the later-established Reich Corrdttoo for the dealing with sick persons who wore suffering froa inherited diseasos. Q Did Conti attend thoso conferences? A I have never soon Conti in any conferences of this kind, and I have never hoard hin speak in this connection at ary placo, q To what extent did Conti deal with those natters in tho Ministry of the Interior? A It certainly is not only the question of this Reich Comnittee, but it is the question of dealing with dofornitios, and it was discussed in the Ministry of the Interior as long as the question of Euthanasia was discussod at all. At that tine I did not havo any knowledge of this purely *>-v-inistrative work, and only new I have had the possibility of getting a certain in3ight into tho existence of all those conditions. In the oourse of the Polish campaign around the middle of September, a conference took place between Dr, Conti and Mr, Laaaors and tho Fuehrer. - 2100 - u Feb.-l;7-it-ATD-7-3-FUtty Ccurt Jfc. 1 This conference took place at Zopcot near Danzig. There the question of the introduction of an Euthanasia law was discussed, and Mr. Lascars M a int a in ed the point of view that such a law would have to be worked out through the general ASainistration. E©cause of *he Iona adalnistgative channel connected with this. Hitler apparently'objected. The whole question at that tine was that no result was achieved between Hitler, Lastsers and Conti. Q. were you at that tine already inforned about the natter, about the question of the legal prcblen with the Ministry of the Interior? A. I was not inforned at the tine, and I havo only been inforned about it now. I did rot attervi these conferences, and I havo neither dis¬ cussed then with Conti later on nor with Laniers about the question of Euthanasia. Q. This, all those incidents took placo in tho year 1939? A. This conference near Danzig took plaoe in the middle of Septem¬ ber and when I referred to tho Decree and Its signing, this took plaoo towards the end of Oetobor. Q. Jfew why was this natter dealt with and star tod during tho war? A. I mist assume thnt the Fuehrer was of tho opinion that such a prcblen could, first of all, bo earrlod out nore snoothly 'hiring tho war beoauso tho opposition which night have been expected fron the aido of tho church would rot play such an important part during twrtine as it would in other times. 2401 4 TebJt-JP-Xl-SaEpson CMSI>) Court I H Therefore, there 1 b b large prelislnary history to the Euthanasia pr-grea. A It certainly has been traced back to the time of 1933, and before. It would perhaps be is^ortant to point out that the decree was actually predated, and the formulation'only took place in Oetobef, While the date of the decree was the 1 st of September 1939. This pre-dating toward tho beginning of the war shows that Hitler actually believed that tho lntro^ ductlon of this law would be easier during war tlae. In 1935 he Is alleged to have told the foreor Helch physician, Vagner, that if war should ever X break out, he would deal with the Euthanasia questions and that he would have then carried out. Q How, If you cone back once core to the text of the decreo; then, you were given orders, together with Bouhler. Vhnt official position did Souhler occupy? A Bouhler was Chief of the Chancellery of the Puehror. Q Just a ninute, witness. In connection with this I aa handing you the sketch of the Euthanasia program which was presented by tho prosecution. It is SO 253; it Is located In Part I of Document Book 14. \ It tho sane tine I an handing to you a docuaent. It is a eketch conposod by tho defendant. Brack. Xr. President, the plan has not been translated ao yot, and for the tine being I have submitted a plan in C-ernan; it is not very Important beenuso 1 am not going to deal with the details In the plan, but only tho top containing the naaos, so that you will alio bo able to follow the '-•ornan copy. In connection with this sketch, the defendant Brack has givon an af-1 fldavit and I want to read it. It Is Itecuacnt E3 8 , with tho skotch belonging to it So. E3 15. I want to subolt both of thee as Exhibit Ho. 3. Th 0 plan will later bo presented to the Tribunal in English, and 1 hopo It will be ready by noon. I shall now read tho affidavit: "I, Victor Sreck, 11/9/1904 at Huron, near Aachen, at present a defondant beforo Mil¬ itary Tribunal at Humberts depoee the following affidavit, after I have 3402 Court So; X boen informed that violation of an oath, by standing or making false statements will result in aovere punishment. ^ho plan submitted waa Document SO 426, inhibit Ho. 106; it ia plan So. 254, which I an submitting, waa at th« tin® partially conposed by ay *tatemonta and partially according to tho suggestions by Dr. 3 0 ckwald, who ia an interpreter. t waa draftod by member of the proatcutlon. A* tho tino I objoctod that auch ® organisational plan had rv*vor oxlated, and now a this only can be construed by =e, and thcroforo it may contain in¬ correct st&toments. The Proaocution aaaurod so of tho fact th*t tho plan X had only boen composed according to the beet of ny knowledge. In tho -oantime, I have diacoverod by looking at various docuner.ta of tho Prosecution, and I have obtained a clearer picturo than I had at tho tlaoj and, therefore, I have composed a now plan about the tuthanaeia Prorras and its organisation, «nd it shows tho relationships to tho persons and officos involved in it and that they actually oxlatod. I en submitting thle skotch with tho request now to submit this plan to Military Tribunal S 0 . 1. *he truth nd correctnose of tho plan X have cortifiod. The plan forma a vital part of thie affidavit. Sumberg, 3? January 1947. Then follows tho signature of Victor Brack. And then the document concludes with tho certification by Dr. Prooschsonn, counaol for tho defendant." k Witnoss, first of all will you give us your opinion as to tho skotch of tho Prosecution, and only as far as tho top agencies woro concorncd, with which you wore conncctod; that la without firat going into detaila. A In the plan Ho. 253, which haa boen presented, there ia a lino under ay name tfich connecta to the naso of Bouhloxi and below there is a further line In the program of Euthanasia. IMa connecting line la incorrect ao far aa it haa been dr«m to sy naso. ^he edainlatrativo machinery for the acention of tho Euthanasia program was an establish¬ ment which was exclusively subordinated to Mr. Bouhler. It had boen established by him and it wn« administered by him. Likewise, tho connect- 2403 4 Tsb -K-JpJB_3_5«^aon (HSD) Court So, I lc« line fro« ay nn« to Dr. Conti, la not correct because It did not exist at all. -be upper connectli* line froa Bouhler to Brandt, which has boen struck out In perl, end which In pafrt has bean continued at a lino, to Minister Brack la not correct In this fore either because when anything ♦ ® took place as far as the administration was ooncerned, that Is, It all con-.ected to the Ministry of the Interior. Then this al B o originated. with Bouhler. In =y opinion, In order toocplMn the sketch, It would be A appropriate to state that also tho statoacnt In tho affidavit by Brack would have to be repeated onco sore because also, the other ^skotch in this plan which refers to tho subordinating agencies are alto incorroct, and I would aloo consider the title kuthanasla Prograa ae incorrect, bocauao It wao not described or outlined froa the vory beginning as far as Its extension was concerned, Tou aay put the sketch aside now, Kow, I want to doal with tho sketch which tho defendant. Brack, hao coaposed. I m now handing you tho plm. Havo you already seen the plan! A Toe. Q C»n you confirm, with regard to precision, that this plan has now boen drawn correctly according to your opinion? A In ay opinion this plan lack* tho connecting lino botwoon Bouhler and sysolf; and furthcrsorc, It is corroct that tho rod lino froa Bouhler to tho executing agency of kuthanasla is Tiergraton Strasso 4, and that fron thore also tho connection for tho Belch Comlosionor for tho cental institutions and to Dr. Linden is correct. I assume that If such an organixatlonal plan as nca* dream up. It Is correct in principle at least. <4 Of what a/ency was 3ouhlcr in char. o? A 3ouhler wps tho Chlof of the Chancellory of the Tuehror, \ And with what did the Chancellery of the luehrer doal? A Tho Chancellery of tho luehrer, first of all, dealt with tho privato natter* of Hitler himself* then, it wps alto a receiving agency for everything th»t arrivod In the fores of requests and conplainte* and 2^04 4 J?-l8-4-SKT>ion (KSD) Court lo. I frca there compensation* Mid bther assistance vas granted concerning requests. And then later — during the first Bonhler vai able to nek® certain decision*, and then later the Job was taken over by Dr 4 3or*ann. * 4 What the character of Bonhlerl 4 Tab 47JOUA-*-l-3eard (KSD) Court Ip. I A Bouhler na<*e a eaewhat reserved iapression. Ho was very quiet sad whenever scnebody Bet his ho gained th* lsprestion that ho was dealing with an honest pef eohality, la hi* character, he nay have been somewhat soft. • <4 What was the party political connections of Bouhler^ A He cay have become a necber of the party at a very early period of tins. Hitler had known hia for many years, and certainly before the tine prior to 1923, and he had an unlimited faith in hia and confidence. x As a result of this fact he obtained knowledge about nany things in his official capacity. Ho certainly could always act as a barometer to¬ ward Hitler as to the attitude and feeling of the population. I did not know ary thing aore in detail about his office, but X hare said that X made the aeouaintanc# of Brack in 1934, as on Adjutant, and prior to the time of 1939, end later after 1941 or 1942, X did not have any closer contact with hla. What was the contact between 3ouhler, ContlT^And LacnersJ A I knew of lasers, and that a closo relationship existed thore, and certainly was the esee with Dr. Conti, and the Ministry of Interior. Since a lot of nail arrived in the Chancellery of tho fuehrer, it woo also the task of this offico to distribute the nail further to the con- potent agencies. (4 Did Bouhlcr deal by hiasolf, particularly with tho Euthanasia problos:? A I assuao he wps also personally interested in this probloo, Lator on I al»o hoard that he was one of its originators because he foarod under tho circumstances that existed in the individual districts, lator on ho would coac to deal with this question individually, without having — without being able to cause the proper effect there in tho diotrie'e. X cannot Judge as to what extent this plan was dealt with. -ov to the question of Euthanasia. When X discussed this question in October with hi-., he had cade the decision to carry out the question and so solve the Euthanasia problea, end ho calntained the sane point of 24C6 4 7ob JO(AA_9_2-3eard (KSD) Court So. I Tie* which I previously stated. Be ha* noi stated anythin* to =e about Euthanasia. as it is described by th« *ord, nor has ho =ade any other requests 4 b words ^Useless oat«V never foil in =y prosehco, and I do sot think that thoj* played any inportant sajor part in this problee boeauae that refers to the consumption of food, and the number of patients coneorncd did net play any iaportant part. 3 ut new you nuat have had soao personal contact with Botlftler? A Later on I net Bouhler; that, as far as I know, was only in SoYoabcr. Previously X had not spoken to Bouhlor because Bouhler was in Berlin and he continued to work tho-e by hlnself after he had rocoived =y letters. * Thero was no special organisation necossary in order to onrry out Euthanasia? A T 0 s, a special organisation was established, and it is located in tho oiddlo, and it io sketched in pink (reforrln* to tho nap boforo him). Shall uac the nap once noro? I want to assume that this representation, by dividing it into threo parts, it corroct. Thero was a .'.utual Transport Company which was closely connoctod with tho problom. Thon,thero was tho Mutual Transport Association, which lator on was connected with, and carried out the roaovals. Alto in tho Ministry of Interior thore was tho Roich Association for Ksntal Institutions which dealt with the diagnosis, and tho evaluation of the questionnaires and so forth. These throe or four nenticned business titles were connon noneo which wore used during tho tine thrt Euthanasia was being carried out. I finally mentioned tho Belch Association for Mental Institutions; that was the group which, first of all, dealt vith scientific evaluation of the Questionnaires, the rroup of diagnosis, ®d tbc previously oontionod agencies which evaluated the questionnaires, ft Whore was this agency located? 2407 / 4 7et>-J<-Ji , -9-l*-Seard (MSD) Court So, I A This agsncy «u located at SLergaatsn Strasse 4, which ie generally described afterwards aa T-4. (4 Were phyeiciane working at the T*4t A Te«, there were phyeiciane workihg at the T-4. The Bain diagnos- tlcitt and the chief diagnostician vert there, ^he nain official agency was at this address. <4 Sow, what was you takk, at the sain office, at that addrosa? A fho task of Bouhler was connected with that of execution. My task within*. the entire Euthanasia Program had already beei detornlnod by the docreos. It consisted that I, together with Bouhler, had tho authority over the physicians who wero participating in this prograa, and furthermore, we had the provisional task toward the Fuehrer, hlneolf. ind, then, I had to ^intaln a certain contact with Bouhler with regard to decisions about questions which could be dobatod in any way, q What was your agency and how wero you included in the adminlstra- tive apparatus? A I dd not havo an offlco, and I was not included in tho ontiro or¬ ganisational aachine. Outside of special authority which was given to bo by vlrtuo of docreos from the fuehrer, 2 did not havo any Instructions ordlroctivss in any fora. I was not the exterior in any way toward this administrative =achine. 14 Well, who did havo this superior position? A Bouhler- it was Bouhler's T_4, end that wns his agoncy. <4 What v*s the connection with tho B c ich Ministry of Intorlor? A Tho H«ich Ministry of Imterlor had another agency In connection with this program in the for* of Doctor Linden, who was rerponslblo In this question that Is, the Belch Committee which I have nontloned before. 3etween the office of Liaicn and the executive agency of tho * Luthanaeia T-4, there was a corresponding direct channel. 24 C« 4 7eb-X— JP—9-2a-3eard (KSD) Court So* - S. I eo now submitting DscUi^nt So. 156, I vas unable to ascertain in what document book It is contained. It Is 4 very short letter and I shell read It. 1 shall submit the report tt yon ltt the Ceraan text* xa. KcHjISXT: The Prosecution hat not lets furnished with either a copy of a Ceman tranalatlon or an *vli.h translation of this document. I roaenber It is a document *±ch we had some discussion about in the early stages of the trail. The document. Itself, subaltted by the Prose, cut Ion to the Defense Information Center, but was not used In the trial. I have no objections to this docueent. This natter wn's not introduced in evidence by the Prosecution, and if it 1. now offered it will have, of course to be an Ixhlblt for lari Brandt. l urthermoro, it is not certified by any one; however, I sake ho objections on that ground since tho docuoent was secured by tho Prosecution, and we are willing to adalt its authenticity. However. I think that unless tho Defence Counsel mthor pro^tly established a more smooth working procedure for tho introduction of documents, and furnishing of copies and trons^ lotions for tho Prosecution, wo will be in a rather hopolcos infusion with respect to tho progress of the caso. Vo will have to start maintaining files on the Defendant* documents, and it is going to bo rather difficult to be going back constantly to bo sure wo havo recoivod coplos of tho documents.* JUICE sEBaUEr Xr. HcHancy, is It not true that soao of tho con- fusion that 1 . beginning to arise is becauso of tho fact that tho proper administrative agency ha. not yot been able to translate those docunonts into English? MR. XcEAKTT: I « not sure that I understood tho question. *ill you ploasc repeat it? JOTC-I S5B3RIKC-: I understood from Dr. Sorvatius that although ho had been reserving exhibit number, for acnc of these documents, he had not been placing them in evidence solely because of the fact that tho Translation Division had not yet been able to put them into English. *o that truo? 2409 4 ?«b -M-JT,9-3-a-3e>rd (USD) Court So. X K3. McHASIti 2 Understood his statement to that effect. JLTCB SttSmB: It aay not have been exactly that, but I understood It In that nanner. MH. HcHiSST: In «o*far as It ^plies to this document. It has been in tha possession of the Defense Counsel for two or three nonthe, •o obviously there should be no difficulty In getting It translated. - as perfectly willing to have tha document go In as an axhibl*nov, but I «uld ask that Dr. Servatlua and the other Defense Counsel be advised th*t It would be necessary In order to proceed snoothly with the trial that the Prosecution be furnished wlthalrance copies of these a docurents, both In *n«llsh and in C-ernan, as the rules of the Tribunal prescribe. And, "nly In tfcnt -V w111 v * 10 “ P 0,Ulon t0 aako our objections at the tine to the docuaents as offered. TCE PRISI3ST: In tha Interest of tlao, ^nglleh coplos of thoso documents should be furnished to the Prosocutlon, and should also be made available to the Tribunal. I do not know whether the fact that this has not been done has boon due to sdalnlstratlvo procedurs or to some other reason. C'iurt So. 1 4 It'D ,7-H-10-l-ZEH-3uras ». SiBTitlUSl M». Pre.ldent. 1 bculd not Ilk. to iUH -11 of the technical difficultly. .hieh the d.t.n.. he. had “ lll > «>• tranalatiM e. «J1 r. the other cectl-u. It It very difficult to run everythin* monthly end xe ere trying to Key the’., difficultly, to . very «nll -tent. With regard to thl. Docnaent to. 166 I hex. looked through the doounent hook, be¬ en,. I -.tuned thnt the, h.d already been nro.ent.d <• on exhibit end there¬ for. i e.suned thnt it bed been tron.lrtcd b.e.u .0 I ve. given thl. doeun.nt by the pro.eeutlon. I r.oue.t thnt It be t.cuorerlly -(tallied -nd I .hnll then tutnit It inhibit So. 4. da rniSiantT. Thnt nrocedur. «111 be foiled. The pro.eeutlon he. contented to thnt end If. .11 right vlth the trlbunrl. Whet nunber 1 . thl. exhibit glxonl Whit nunber e. to the def.ndend Brendtl DR. S^hVAlIUSt It *111 “» lblt So * 4 * na rhnSIM?. nine, -re too doeun.nt.. exhibit to. 4 end hxhlbl, to. B Bn. S»VnTIliS: they or. ixhlblt 4 end 4-B. I »n»t to reed the .hort letter thet the, hex. no, tren.li.ted. The letterhond 1. -Chief Bro.eeutor. Stuttgart, 16 July 1910, .ocr.t. ■To Reich MJnUter of Juatlc* •Attention of klnltturlrl of Dr. Stnd.l^ann or hi. deputy ■In offlca, Berlin .Subject. Inf or action n. to th. unnatural death of Inarte. of ln.,itu- i tions. •Anclo.uro: One nnonyuou. letter vlth cnr.lcno. The onclo.ur. nddr.M to the Chief I'ru.ecut-r at Ravenehrucie. ■ I enclose ,h. folloxlng for neknovlodguent. Sine, recent elnller ruuor. hex. coo. to ay knoxledge. I traction. If I -hould laltlet. Investigation* -nd hov for thl. ^rpo.e th. Snore, State hollo, end th. State Pcliee 1 .hnll find nt Stuttgrrt.* Jhen follow th. .lgnnture. -By order of. signed Kol.hnen.cr- Then c-ac. « rer-erlc. -Dr. Frei.lor hn. dl.cawed the natter vlth Hol.hneu.or pcr.onnlly end secondly no action 1 . to be taken and third th. Incident U to be kept to- 2111 4 ? e b 47Jt-10-2_SaLBar» (KSD) Court s o. I ether with all other Better* pertaining to the subject. - This letter which hss been sent to me by th» prosecution has the following lncloture with it: ■The Chief of the Chancellory of the Fuehrer of the 3SHAF ■Berlin, V-8, 5 June 1940 ■Vositratte 4 "Vilhelaetrasee 65 * ■Dear Dr. Ouertner: "This ref era to tho telephone conversation of the pnl few days, I -ant to infors you of the following: by virtue of the authority of • • tho Fuehrer, I, ae the .ole person rep.on.ible for tho execution of the.o tasks, have issued the neceaeary order, to ay collaborator.. In excoaa of this tho derreo of .uch guiding regulations doo. not seem necoaanry to ae anymore." Then follow, tho signature which I consider to be that of Bouhler. Witness, will you .tate your opinion with reapoct to tho to tho oocond lettor? »U1 you tell us whethor tho .ta'eaent by 3ouhlor about Me po.ltion le eorroett A Tho referonce of Bouhler with reepoct to hi. po.ltion within tho euthanasia question 1 . cortalnly corroct. I cannot al.o confirm that tho signature of this document io th»t of Bouhler. In thl. ca.o ho roforo to hie po.ltion at Ticrfartenstrasso 4, froa vhero this work was being carried out. A. a parallel to that there oxi.tod another outside offico of tho Boich Minister of tho Interior as far ao I know in tho Columbus house which ha. also been casually mentioned in this connection, t* Hare you ever been at that office in the Columbus house? A I hrro never visited the offico in tho Colunbus house and I havo never visited tho offico at Ticrgarton 4 cither. 1 * But you did work together with Bouhler. Of vbat did your mutual tasks consist? A They consisted of tho fact that first of *11 wo were together with tho Fuohror to discuss foreign questions which resulted and later on tho * Teh 47_jdT„ r C_.10-l-Srs* (HSD) Court *o. I procedure V». that —tine. Bouhler alone and » by «y.elf vent to the Toehrer and then he, Bouhler* obtained these dOcunents Vain. ^ V)»t questions -era discussed there? 1 In th« beginning jiccc very fur.dancntal queetione were discussod. Tiret of all the question of the vetcrene. *bet included tho.o in tho first World War. ?hen sone persona who had beecne injured in the lino of work end the following were to be excluded fron luthanasiai foreigners. Thue the order only applied to Geman nationals. Another exccption-I _ cannot recall any other exception* and by ny.elf 1 cohld not confirm that tho Instructions were given to exoept Jew. fro* the frasework of luthanaaia as far as tho Goman nationals wero concerned. ^ How, wha t vaa tho procedure? X First of all by tho use of a quostlonnatro all of tho.o sick parsons -ere to bo registered. This was not so such discussed and dlsputod as there was a socrecy In connection with tho uao of luthanasla, *Aich had been expocted by the Fuehrer. He was of fco opinion that this entire luthanaaia prograa oould bo carried out with¬ out tho public obtaining ary wnsiderablo knowledge of It or without it having indefinite influence on tho public. Mr. Bouhlor as well as nysclf pointed out several tinea that this wao lnprobpb> that perhaps it would be oost appropriate to nako tho Iuthanasin problo public. However, this vr. fundacontally disapproved and Hitler clainod that tho ndainistrative apparatus 2413 / 4 7#b 47-^WC-10 Court !to. 1 could not function ?rprly In tho execution; that this h«J to be possible. X just cautioned the earenc© in concentration cacpe? a A The esnnrctlon is not clear to no. Of the two rinse which appear hero. Dr. I-bncr is unknown to ne. T hen occasionally this Doctor Schumann has n'de his appearance; and 1 do not have any idoa about him olthcr. 1 an of tho opinion that this cosplox 14-T-13 undor tho cir- cu=8*.anco6sv actailly havo been connected with what Beichsloitcr B^uhlor oithor expected or feared; and when he thought that tho euthanasia pro^ fran could arbitrarily bo usod by the individual district lcadors for their own individual actions, in this case 14-J-13, in ry opinion the decisive factor oust have been Eirslcr because it is also shown hero that he alone was entitled to decide as to the lives of prisoners, and he also always made the decisions solely by hinoolf. Even subsequent measures after 1941 to which I shall yet refer speek for the fact that sono individual actions of district lcadors did pley a pert in thio but that in the documents pertaining to 14-Kl3tho fact becoaes apparent that 14-1-13 did not cover all the concentration 2418 f a ?eb 47JClL-lA^kp Blailey (KSD) Cotfft So. I C a»Si But this action only ea'e It. appearance In the Bavarian area and for the =».t pan In Be... and thurWial I eanntt ... any connection between 14-1-13 and whatever represented euthanasia to zfntlfi How, 1 have one que.tfon about the extermination carp of Lublin* TEE pRISIZEST: It will be understood that the two doeunente offered. 3418—A L Feb. Ul -4I-L1-2A* PK? 91ikli*7 Court No. 1 u.curent Km r 156, worn adaittol in evidence as the defendant Karl Brandt's Exhibit 4. DS. S2WATHJ5: Yes. THE P?xSIDE;.T: It -ccura to zl thrt it possibly ai. ht be A convenience r£ save time if the proxovti .n could pro pore, a Hat A the documents which it h a introduced in evidence, thie -in- in ehronslo; icnl order and followod b 7 the nusLur of each document sain exhibit; find if that Hat were furnished to the !cfcndanta, it w old be a ccp-.r tively aiaple atttur l »s dofondant U ascertain whether . inct. -d during t.._ w-r a-.d l_o to - -.nt-1 ditturo ,.c-, or th t n dis- s- h- • o- ntr.us.-d by '.ny -v_nt of ir. it wis i t.Tpor r> &_rv*Ce of th- p ti.i.ts. i bcli-v- th-r- war- four iltogeth-r, *a f-.r -.8 I c n ru..i-mb_r. ih- die.’8. .hich led to cuthinnsie l't^r had no connection with th- r~r s.rvice. I know not ing els- .oout th t a-.tt-r '-^d th- report to this -ff-ct wr.e a.r.t to itl-r. 4* ::ow .-.oout tnoa injured invror;, or toot. »ho b.cn. inv lids, did you heir an. tun cut th-.t? A. I a .-jo not-ung a oout inr -it-s oar t. t suer, thun « s nil ;n.d. Q. Di >.-v not rcCviv. r. orts ir. tiue cor.-ction froa instit ti ns in Fcncrmia? A. In 19U*, 'h$ t I e-nnot st t- -xr.ctly ^th-r it 'lifa or th. begin¬ ning of 'L5, it bri-f int.rv-ls I h- r<- .r 6 -cunt* Serviceo.n working in th- ca-nc-llory in .rlin tQ-.t in t o c i.c in nixony -nd in on- c-.t. in Pcexnni-, cut.-n-si'. » 8 ,-.in s.m t rr. d cut in r.nt 1 institutions. I inforxd ouhLr's office ims-di t-ly. I r-./Ort-d to the Fu-hr.r, nd I ilco r.port-d to Kr.ialiit.r . -rtin cna-Jin, s ince both c-s-a in jixony indie-ted t: p-rtlclp- tior, off t.. ti-ul-iter. I know th-.t tn- .u-hr.r iccu-d inttructiono to -.rtin 3cra-nn ia»-di~tely to h.'.vu the a- n.-5ur-& Etopp-d. 3cuhl-r ttl-.s li ir. touch with th- co::.A.t-nt officers. I did not l-.-rn til-1 theS- obv . usly llult-d ■-■aur.s . «r. '.ny r*y outsid- of th- ;r-.ctic- of cuth-.rv-si- -.s it -xiated up to 19U1. In ot -r words, th-y w-r- ..-lly s-rious- ly ill persons. 1. Tn-n you i-r. led only o, s-tic 1 joints of vi.w in -uth n*ai-.? A. I w-.s corx-m-d only in -ur lj -*icnl n_-.sur-s ind consicLr-.ti ons cleirl; -.rising fro..; th-cbcroc its.ll. I, -nd -s 1 r t I know, ouhltr, nev.r intensified this euti.-nrain in r.ny, on t - ccntr.ry, if -nythin;, s-ejv-d qucBtion-.jl- tie. X ct th'.t it ns qu-st.. r. i- l_c* uf to conclude th fc tills w-.s i r--son *.. '-list -x-cution. Q“. You s-.o - of th- proc-cdufc, is it tru- th-.t a qu.atxotmair. tor i would b. b *.sis for it? 2i*21 Court I U Feb L7-A - 12-3 - LX - Foster A. first basis was a questionnaire. 3. I shall show you such a questionnaire in document book 1696 FS, will you please caaoent on it. (Document handed to witness.) THE PRESIDENT i Has this docusent already been received in evidence, counsel? •A DR. SERVATIUSt I assuoe so* It is in the document book. There are several questionnaires, all with the sane contents. ^1 assume that it was offored in evidence. It is on page 209, part 2. A. The questionnaire indicated, gives indications for determining tho disease. There er* general registrations, whether tho parson is a twin, whether there are insane relatives, and then an indication about provious histoxy, the ccurso of tho disease — . witness, Just a mlnuto. DR. SERVaTIISi It is Exhibit 357. 5. 'witness, will you pleaso continuo. A. There is a note that in every case there are adequate indications of tho aontal condition they are to be aaded. Ao arc getting individual diseases which aro montionod, Schisophronia, in addition to the condition, whothor it is a fresh attack or a final condition. The reaction to troatmont is also asked for. And then there are similar subdivisions under feeble¬ mindedness, epilopsy. There is a question about tho treatment itsolf, and it is asked when treatment was carried out, whether there was permanent success or not. Then, it is asked about crimes as to bo evaluated in Judging the condition of the patient and it is asked about the value of the work of the patient. 3. Ahat was tho purpose of this questionnaire? a. Tho purpose of the questionnaire was the indications given in it which were given by a specialist were to give a picture of the disease to another specialist who was to Judge the case. +• Bo you believe that this questionnaire is adequate 1 Don't you think that it is too s\x>erficial to fora a final Judgment? 2422 Court I U Fab U7-A - 12-1* - LX - Fee tar A. Tfto questionnaire alone would probably not have boon sufficient for a final Judgment* it was necessary for the records of the patient hiaaolf to also bo consulted but this was certainly done in critical cases by the chief sxperl. Jmd when the patient was transferred the observation institution had all the records and the patient himself was ebserved so that there were various opportunities for control. Court I U Feb-A-Si#-13-l“?eldt-LJ} The other document* were added to the (fciestionnaire to help in under¬ standing the entries. Then it was indicated whether the person was a foreigner or not. 3. How, witness, the creation of crises is included here and it la asked about paragraphs* 51 and U2b of the Penal Code. A. I have already pointed out that these questions were designed to have a standard for Judging the condition of the patient himself. As it was similar to the questions of the employment of the patient, it was not intended to fore any legal judgment on the basis of this information. Q. The questions about the patient*s ability to work, was tho purpose of that to remove persons incapable of working bocause they wero incapable of working? A. Euthanasia was not intended do roly to romovo huaan beings. It was designed to free him frox his sufferings. It had nothing to do with his ability or inability to wcrk. Q. Then if I understand ycv correctly these symptoms of montal dotoriorotion, that ho can no longer warts, or that he has boon a criminal — A. The;' or.» to bo evaluated in this connoction, but they havo only a partial influence on the decision. Tho docisivo thing is tho entire, tho whole condition. Q. Titno: 3 , how was tho responsibility of tho doctors concornod with tho questionnaire divided? A. Every individual doctor was responsible for what he did in tho course of thceo measures which led to Euthanasia. Each doctor was absolutely responsible for his Judgment. The chief expert was also responsible, and the doctor at the observation institution, as well as the doctor in the Euthanasia institution, were also responsi¬ ble. It oust not be assumed that the doctor involved in these measures would have boon obliged to.carry out Euthanasia if he did not agree 2UZh Court I l Feb-A-SS-13-2«?i;idt-LJQ on the basis of his own decision* He had the.right and the duty* if he did not approve, to refuse to carry out Euthanasia. Q. Veil, What did these powers mean to the doctor? Didn't this put him in a special situation? A. First of all the doctor was given enormous responsibility. It was not only a responsibility in view of his right to decide abcut life and death, but was also burdened by the fact that he was responsible for the continued suffering of this human being. One must mention this in order to make clear the extent of the responsibility. Q. Now, was the responsibility on one doctor alone, or was it divided? A. No, the responsibility bolongod to each person who was concornod. I estimate there were ten, fiftoen, perhaps ovon twenty exports who, according to instructions and directives which they had received, to¬ gether with the chief export, had carriod out their activity. Q. Were those exports independent of ono another? A. The oxporte worked completely independently of ono anothor, and that was how it was intended from the beginning. Not the question¬ naires, but photostatic copios of thorn were sont to the exports so that none knew what tho othors had decided. Q. Did you help to select the oxjrts? A. Thoy were suggested by the Roich Ministry of the Interior and Bouhler assigned thorn thoir duties. Q. Did you negotiate with then? A. No. Q. Did you instruct thorn? A. No. Q. Was thoro any appeal? A. No, there was not. It nas our opinion that since each judgment *»a3 independent, each successive judgment was a type of appeal, and we saw in thi3 measuro a sufficient safeguard against any excesses on 21*25 Court I h F*fc-A-S#-13-3-Feldt-LJG f allurea of the ays ten which sight otherwise have occurred. And besides. Decausa of the necessl ty for secrecy, no other appeal procedure was pos¬ sible. Q. Did not the physicians involved have any legal misgivings? % A. In practice they no doubt did not} otherwise they would not have been able to participate. If they did have legal misgivings, they were certainly dissipated by the entire nature of the procedure itself. First they were instructed about Euthanasia in the Fuehrer's chancellery by Bouhler himself. They learned that the Reich Ministry of. the Interior was connected with this measure from the beginning to the end. The Ministry of the Interior had rocognirod the decree and acted according to it. It supplied tho necessary information. It assigned the physicians. The questionnaires went through the offices of the Ministry of tho Inter¬ ior and later through those of the provincial governments. The insti¬ tutions thooselvos had beon suppliod by the Ministry of tho Intorior. The Ministry retained its position superior to tho institution. Regis¬ tration offices had boon arranged in the euthanasia institutions and the physicians knew that the Reich Ministry of Justice was inforsnd. Tho financing of the whole thing was cloar and regulated so that tho doctors cortainly had no Justification for having legal misgivings. Q. And what do you yourself think of the question of logality? A. Ctao decisive point for no, perhaps, was that the head of tho State hinsolf had given no this assignoaent, and I cortainly could not expect that I was given such a decree for any criminal action. And at a subsequent tire for me as well as for the others, it was soon that everything was done as if everything was in order, and it was in order as far as we were concerned. Q. How about tho question of the approval of the patients? Tho Insane? A. Tho question of the approval of tho insane was disregarded. Court I U Fab-A-Sl-13-U-Feldt-LJG The point of view was that the insane person himself is in no position to Judge his situation. These were not persona with light cases, but the worst ones. For this reason since the patient lacked understandiig of his cwn situation, there could be no question of approval. If one • were to say that the patient gave his approval, that naans exactly if one says he did not approve. In individual cases where th j s question of euthanasia was discussed with mentally healthy persons; sane person*, the point of view was gained that the patient cannot decide about him¬ self, but that the decision «ust be left to the doctor alone. Through ncoentary pain the patient nay be so deceived. Just as through a rolative ccofort he nay be deceived about the severity of his disease. Here one can Judgo only on the basis of the diagnosis, and considering the con¬ dition and the prognoeis, and only the doctor can reach tho decision. It cannot bo left to tho patient hiesolf. Q. Than *iat about tho approval of the relatives? A. In tho case of the insane, tho consent of the relatives was not obtained for Sindian roosons. First of all, tho question of secrecy was important. Cut more important froo the nodical point of view was tho fact that the layman is not able to Judgo tho condition of his sick rolative. Ho lacks knowledge of the disease. Frot actual criminal considerations he could not give his consont. He can bo deceived by uncritical pity, and actually tho relatives nero not considered in this respoct. Another decisive point was that one cannot expect a rolativo to docide about the life or death of soaeono else. It was the opinion that the doctor, with the support of the state, has to take the responsi¬ bility. 4 Feb-X3E-14-1-I«nhardt Court So. 1. especially la the case rf insane persons. Ths relatives frequently *ro inclined to jive their consent tc Euthanasia. There le an Indication In liter-ture where lc absut 160 questions to relatives of idiotic children, 1*>0 parents can consent. Also the cany appeals and approvals within the Euthanasia escrlax showed the attitude of the relatives toward the atient, but this is no reason for giving the responsibility to the relatives, who are unable to bear It. ^ ^ What was the purpose of secrecy, was there s-ncthing to be con¬ cealed? % A The secrecy was certainly deeanded by the Fuehrer for political reatens; mainly on account of the Internal political situation In connec¬ tion with the question of propaganda, and so forth. I do not believo that inner oil tics was the decisive thing; sere solution could b found in that respect. Final resistance from the churches, for examrle, could not be obtained permanently. $ Sow. witness, I show you a letter fron the head of the Cental In¬ stitution. air. Schleich. It was Document Ho. 53C, Exhibit 774, Docuacnt Book 14, Fart 3. This Is a letter tc the Reich inieter of Justice, in which this head of a mental institution objects to the ;roceduro. rleaoo read ths letter end ce-n«nt en it. A The letter from hr. Schleich to tho Reich : inister of Juotice points out that among the node there is great uncertainty in connection with the removal and the death notic«s about insane persons. "Is it pos¬ sible, ■ tho second aragraph cays, 'that such n measure is being carried out without such a law having been rroclai—<.' And then it go s on, "In conscqu'ncn of the coadeto secrecy in which th o measures arc being carried out not only do the wildest rumors gc about among the people (for example that also people unable to work on account of vre or injuries receiving during the first world v«r have ben done away with or ar- to b< J ono awey with). But al3o the impression,-I shall ski-, a little- as if a toally arbitrary manner prevailed at the a*lection of tho parsons conce rned 2428 4 rcb-HBH-14-2-Le=hardt Court to. 1. •a 2 c you consider the attitude of the Blither of thie letter correct? A I consider the attitude of the author of thie letter »s abBolutoly correct. If a physician who is in charge of an institution has no idea of what is actually going on, in py opinion it was his duty to ir.quiro of the conpctont officers whether seeething unjustified was not being done. r roo the Documents, which hare been subnitted here - this is the only letter of this type one should really wonder that no ror* of euch letters woro handed in. The necessity for such letters arose frot the awkward attempt at secrecy which was net practicable. The letter was also inter¬ esting because it refers to nrors arising fre* the lack of clarity. I said before that in the case of tho war wound, d, there was serothing of tho sane kind. Q *®re there any eiailar cooylaints? A I nyself saw fov complaints. I loarnrd of others fros Blshon Safclcn in '..venstor; and from .' artin Borran I learned of the letter fro* the Bishop of Yuitj. I know, and the Documents '-ill show, that a large nusbor of other letters were rec* ir d which wore sent -ither to Bouhlcr. to the Seleh I inister of the Interior through . inister Larnars. or the Holch hinister of Jus tic . In any case, they wore sent to the nearest agency. is far as I know, only the letter which I hawr n^ntioo-d beforo froo Cafclcn and fron 'Jure w^re referred to Hitler hinsrlf. Whether he learned of th*r later on. I do not know. Did you hear of -ny other obj- ctions, ru-oro or eonolairtB? A I heard about complaints and obj ctior.c. first, in the course of 19<0 Court I L Fob U7-A-SW-lli-l*-Ienhardt-LJG through Dr. 3oehe, who was connected with a wall group of physicians o want to sot Martin Boraann, who caaa to See =i Be expressed his objections to the secrecy and he spoke of the rtKors which I have nen- tioned. Then, later I was in contact for the same reasons with Pastor 3odelschwing of the Bethel Institution. I had several talks with Dr. Bodelschring. Ho case to soe ee and I went to see hia at Bethel. Uy contact with his was not on an administrative plane. It was our mutual need for discussing these questions. The consideration of secrecy was discussed by the two of us. The question of legality of Euthanasia on principle. Me observed that there were no cloar indica¬ tions in tho document itself, and that that could be explained by the fact that the Christian Church is opposed to these ideas. It was men¬ tioned to a nan like Lutherj he was of the opinion that such dofaraod children should be drowned. It was said Uat the solution of this prob¬ is® is less theological, but rather not so right, or — tho concept of pity was discussed. Talking to Pastor Bodolachwing in Bethel, I visitod patients with him. We were in the Children's ward and after that wo discussed the individual children, not as to whether we should actually subjoct this particular child to Euthanasia or not, but as to whothur such s croaturo is still a human being, whether it has any feeling itself. I rocall children of eight or ten years of age, who were really nothing but a pitiful, miserable creature. Children known aa "head cases" could not even sit up, with an enormous head ard a tiny body. And Pastor Bodelschwing also folt it is a blessing if such pitiful creatures are (pauso) — if an end is put to thoir lives. We were not always of the sane opinion, but it was possible for us to respect each others' views and to understand each others' views. Pastor Bcdelschwing is of the opinion that if a legal regulation of this question was publieally made, the decision of the state would havo to be binding on all, of course. That had no connection with tho fact Court I ii Feb-A-S*-lli-2a-Lenhardt-LJ0 that innerly he was Boat closely connected with the church, airi that he saw ever, in the ooet pitiful creature, a human being. Q. New, it waa stopped. Execution of Euthanasia was prohibited, lhat was the reason for that? A. The talks which I had with Pastor Bodelschwing were perhaps not the final, decisive eleaent in this, but thero were quite a few other considerations, misgivings which had arisen meanwhile from the question, and so forth. But tho responsibility of the Church did play an important role in having Euthanasia stopped in the sumyr by the end of August, l?bl. The Fuehrer gave me orders to act on these instructions and from the Headquarters I immediately passed on the news to Dr. Booh lor and he did whatever was necossary. That is, the Euthanasia institutions wore in this case given the order, through tho Roicb Minister of the Interior, that thoro was to bo no further Euthanasia. U Febi-JiT-A^nVl^-L-Gallartor Court Ho* 1 Q Could you yourself not hare stopped it sooner? A I believe that objections or opposition fren no would not have beer, sufficient to stop it. For froa that I approved Euthanasia in tha for I have described it. lhe question at issue was the nattor of socrocy. Q Now, was tho idea of Euthanasia given up completely? A fc| aft^r the end of the war Euthanasia was to bo rosuraod, and was to be carried out further. ^ Q What was the offoot of this stopping of Euthanasia for tho organisation? n A Aside fron tho fact that no nora Euthanasia was oarriod out in the Euthanasia Institution, tturo was no further consequences. Tho ques¬ tionnaires continued to bo sent in f t six aonths intervals. They continued to bo registered and evaluated, but nothing olso was dono about than, q Now the Roich Comittoo for Dofomod Childrens Interest, was that also offcctod? A ?to, tho task of tho Roich Cocnlttoo was not offoctod by tho stoppage. Q Was there a definito irobloe in tho Roich Corraittoo as in tho other Euthanasia institutoe? A No, tha procoduro was not tho sano. Tho quostionnoiros in which certain entires wero to bo nade about sovero mlformtion. Scheldt had re¬ ferred to these ccor-ittees. Thoao questiomairoa wore sent to tho Roich Committoo, which was subsidiary to tho Roichsrdnistry of Intoriorj from thoro they wore coordinated with tho necessary othor docuner.tsj they woro fiUod out by aidwives, and doctors, and aatornity hospitals. Tho purpoao was that such deforced children wero re per tod an 1 woro sent to tho special institutions. Q And to whom was the authorisation ^ivan? A In concert with Euthanasia, which had boon aentioned boforo, the authorization was connected with the individual child; there was no gonoral authorization that tested a case. Authorization was requested and was riven. 2432 U Feb.-iiT-A-ATD-lS-S-Gilli-hQP Court So. 1 Q Saw does tho consent of parents as to bein' necessary enter? A The consent of parents was necossary. Tho consent had to bo obtained scoetlmes through the official position, and s one tines through thw institution which reported the case, and it was Hr.. Undents task to , ot those Jocunenta together*. Q And what about letting these children starve to death. New, Jid you loam anything about that? A No, I do not believe it in that fora. I believed that it was tho iiannor of roalfomation in the inner organism which caused complications. I X never learned arythiry; about children, or casos of childron or adults whoro ira tractions beinr given to let theso patients starve to death. The food rations given to these institutions ir. ny opinion were oxaotly tho sane ns • giver, to the noma* consuner. Sinco they wore not acutely sick persons, thoro was the idea that it was net nocessary to givo then spocial rations. The concerns had to send food rations as to tho nursos, doctors, and so on. Q You said boforo that this procedure of the Reich Coraittoo was not offoctod by tho stoppago which was put to Euthanasia? A Jfo. q ffas it continued to the end of tho war? A In tho year of 19Ui, in the sooond half of 19UU Hr. Douhlor inforned no that a doar execution, which wore difficulties of corrospon- donce for technical reasons, was hardly poesiblo, and ho askod us for this reason that Euthanasia be stoppod hero as well. In 19U2 sinco I was no longer tied down, I gave up ns* authcriration. I did not loam that after¬ wards, after the stop of 19Uli, any furthir Euthanasia approval was i.lvon for children. q If I understand you correctly, the reason for s topping the activity of the Reich Ccmitteo was the technioal roason of the general Festal conditions at that tine? A Yes. q Did you work in this procedure until the end? A Ho. in 19U2, as I have Just said, 2 gave up the authorization 2433 I ?eb 7-A-. 73-15-3-0 alloghsr Court So, 1 which I had received sinea I was no longer so easily available, as would havo beer, necessary#. 3 Mow, Witness, if you consider this whole Euthanasia . - 1 s a wholo, is thero not something horrible about it? A It has the appearance that it night look horrible, it can look % inhumn,.bufc in this light the execution itsalf was not oonsidorod from that aotual point of view alone when you considor what is behind it,. Tho hucan boii^s who cannot help tho natives, and whese tests show a life of suffering are to be given aid. This consideration is net inhuman, I novor felt that it was not othioal or ».-as not noral,.I know tha\ tho external drcunstancos at tho execution in spito of this soctcr of socrccy, and that went through the sector of socrccy, rogrottablo instancos occurrod ropoatod- ly, irreepootlve of all endeavors to provent then by the authorities,. It has been said horo that two urns weso sent to one address. It wns said that bocauso of post diagnosis difficulties aroso at the doath, which is ragrut- tablo, but that this doe# not offoot tho principle, anl in ry opinion can- rat shako this principle. If ono die cussed tho problon of Euthanasia openly, and t riod to fern a basic understanding, a basic nutual undorstan ’In” of tho faot, than in ny opinion a way ray be found for such execution in tho future, Tho problca on such ie not new. It has always boon intorosto l, and has boon discus sod for conturiee, A Profossor Loibrandt nentionod tho oath of Hippocrates. That -aeans that ,-art of it which calls upon tho doctor to not to ijivo to a pationt poison even on tho patient's request, This is a dograa which is tho basis of our science of diagnosis today, an' our know¬ ledge of prognosis, anl tho knowledge of the lirdts of therapy, can no longer bo naintained in this fore,. I an convinced if this Hippocrates w a ro all vo today he would fornulato his oath differently,. Hippo era tos was not a nan whs did r»t rivo life its iuo«. In Athens about tho year of U30 thero was an epideaic, and Hippocrates wae asked for aid. Ho rave tho simple in¬ struction that the patients should be left alono, nothin- cculd be done for then,. Ho ill not do that becaueo ha had any idoa cf tho prc.mo3is, or the 2434 U Fabi-^T-^-^TD-lS-^allarhei* Court So* 1 Infection, for he ted walla built to keep the wind out of the city, nc, V did that sinply trem the feeling of what ia health and whet is sickuos . You see, the Rippoomte. oath ia alao cited today, and it is sal’ tet patients and sufferer, are not to be given any poison, and a lector el r declare, and assert, such a thing, that is, either a lie, or a hypocrisy. There is no ctoctor today who doe. not give a suffering patient narcotics, and tries to sake the final hour of a dying person easier- One oan say that 1 , m t euthanasia. In any case it is against the oath of Hippocrates. It begin by not giving the patient who ia expected to die axy more heart atimlante. 2435 court l U Peb-A-«AA-l6-l-Karrow Tho next atop is to give hia narcotics. One nay hang a copy of the Oath of Hippocrates in one’s office but nobody pays any attention to it* Tho patient expects the doctor to help hir and the relatives also expect it and I aay nention in this same connection that since I have re.--, ‘i- a newspaper that the sick person was finally released free his suffering. But these thoughts have nothing to do with the concept of dussonic order ■fcich Mr. Leibrandt mentioned. It is shown by the fact that today, and perhapo at tim about any details. Q Did you inform hin about ycur oth.r activities, for instance, in connection with the Bithaneaia program? A No. Tho cnly subject of which 1 informed hin was in the preliminary work which was connected with the sick transport and other latter hospital facilities. Q For what reason did you not inform hin about your authority and activities which you exercisod? A That was in the fundamental part of the orders which I rocoived, which 1 was net oven able to stato to Rostock in detail. It was noccssary for me to keep this thing to qysclf and to only inform those who wero inmedi- atoly effoctod by them. That was a directive which wo always strictly com¬ plied with, and which appliod to all of those who wore in the close circle around the Fuehrer. Q If I understand you correctly, thero was a concrete onier to that effect, namely, to keep everything secret? A Tes, secrecy by all c*.ans, y«.a. d And, you personally felt, yourself, obligated to carry out that order, even toward your acquaintances? A Yes, naturally. Q Now, through a decree of the 17 of August 1942, and that is Document 080, Exhibit No. 5, did you redeve certain coordination tqaks on the econ¬ omic field between the civilian sector cn one side and the military agencies cn the other. You know the decree? A That is a decree which also simultaneously appointed me General Cuaaisslcner, yes, Q And, that was in August 1942? L Feb. 17 A-20-1-PKP- Lessor Zoart Ho. 1 Q. In order to exercise these tasks did you institute a new office? A. Not in the beginning. At the beginning I exercised this activity fran the Fuehrer's Headquarters and only had a nail connection with the Reich Chancellery, but then I did not have any further office. Q. Kith reference to this activity which started on the basis of the docroe af 1912, did Rostock take over any official activity for you? A. Ho. Q. And then in Septaober 1%3 the seccnd decroe was issued, and th?t is &i»nt 061, Exhibit No. 6. On tho strength of this decree the co-ordination Ufko wore extended and you wore givon thu task co-ordinating the various interests, that is, in the fiold of hoelth services, and, as it states in tho decree, y=u .ere to etoor tho.. «t«r. eccordlnf to il^«lve» or by -ay of dlroctivos. How could that have been understood. Judging froo your knowledge at that tine? A. I nysolf received certain directives and I had boon given tho authority !>7 virtue of the sane decres to appoint deputlos. Kith roforonce to Rostock, in the course of the subsequent tino, on the occnsicn of the second docruo, ho took over the office for Science and Rosonrch again by virtue of tho diroctivo ■hich I gavo to him. Q. You alroady previously stated a nuaber of tasks which were taken over on tho basis of this decroe. I shall not revert to that once more. Later, in c .nncction with tho offic*. of Rostock it wiU again bo clarified. But I mpi to ask you very concretely whethor, on the basis of this decree, there ■88 any directive froo which could bo soon thet you had to doal with research, that is, concrete research assignments or research fields? A. No, these were not concrete fiolds but in tho beginning "o "ore dealing ■ith fundamental quosti^is of the highor schools, which Rostock was to handlo. "tet was the maintenance and continuance with regard to students as well as ■ith regard to teachers. Of those tasks then, is perhaps one which I could naoe new —collaboration with the Office for Planning and Economy, which dealt ■ith retterw an! saw that these supplies were set according to nodical viewpoints. It was a fixed task for Rostock which arose froa tho office of Planning and Economy. A Feb. 47 -A-20-2- PKP- Lessor Court No. 1 Q. fitness, if I understand you correctly, I can conclude fra* your ms»er that you were concerned with goneral questions but wore not concerned ■ith any concrete assignaent of tasks in the field of research? A. No, there were no concrete tasks in the field of research. Q. You already mentioned, witness, that you chose Rostock because he was i scientist and 70 U gave hia the task in order to naintain scientific levels in Geraany and you aontioned the differences with othor agencies which you sxpjrionced. He* did it cone about that you nonaged to choose Professor Rostock as your collaborator? Uas there any political intention, any tactical intention, in connection with that? A. I selected hostock because in ay official position I wanted to have mn to represent qy two office groups who could certify to the outside that thlo ■as a aodical office. I initially selected Rostock because he was n professor at tba University and because I knew hia; any politicql considerations did rut play anjr part whatsoever. If they had plr.yud a part I would probably not have seloctod Roatock. Q. fitness, ay queaticn was not quite answorod. When I askod you whothor you tai any political reasons, then I could also hnvu ooant that you oithor wnntod to choose a specially active representative) of National Socialise or that you nnted tho contrary. -2449- Court Ho. 1 4 Tab 7-A-20-la-£EH-L osier A. Ia connection vith Rostock there vas no aucetlcn of ary politlcol considerations. Rostock was n strictly non-political person. Ko did not pursue a political extreme in any vay. Q, I w-Mld like to frase ny ouestion even nore concretely. When giving sor.ebody this task, didn't you wnt to give it to soue non-nclitical oerson- slity in order to establish a counter-balance against Conti, etc? A. This fact alreacy resulted out of cy position because when I selected Rostock for this office of Science ind Research X vns already engaged In a % severe struggle vith the political exponent. Dr. Conti. And the lino pursued by Conti was in contradiction to a scientific and nodical purpose? A. It had nothin#; whatsoever to do with it. These wsro tvo different varlds. 9 Q, The work in your deorrtuent, Science end Research — did that al¬ ready start in Decscber 19*.3, or only later? A. So, it practically began in February 1944, when this branch agency for this agency at Belit* was ready, so that ws could both novo in. q, It is correct that rrofessor Rcatock, up Ontil the ond of the war, continued his activity as dean of the asdlcal faculty and tho loadorshlp of the Surgical University Clinle in Berlin? A. Tos. q. Isn't that in contradiction to the tasks vhich you had glvon hin? Didn't you want hir to reaove hicstlf cocplstely froa that activity? A. Bo. I have already Just stated that I had selected Rostock because he vas dean of the nodical faculty of tho University of Borlln. I vafitod to occupy ny office with a clear exponent of the higher schools of learning sc that this ct fic« would not be brought into a nanner of acting as was the erso vith other political offices. I also wanted Rostock to continue directing his clinic. I have stetod that I also rerdned in this clinic for tho sane reason, in order to dearly enohesixe the nodical aspect. So I nay suv-arize that you approved the continuance of Rostock's activities fight fron the start? -2L 5©- Court So. 1 4 Tat) -i7-A-30-2a-iZK-I.o*ser A. Tea* lor you, as Cocalaaioner General iar Medical and Health Service*, wore there other field* of work vhich were not Included and worked uoon by the Depertuent of Science nnfi Research end the other office? a. To. lor ne there were decisive taak vhich I had to handle ny*elf ACd with which the Juat previously nentloned office* did not have anythin# to a do. kith reference to theae teak* vhich were net Included by the*o two Jut nantlonad office, but which ybu worked upon yoiraelf, did tho oro#raa of the coabettln# of chemical warfare c#onto — wn* thi* pro#raa included! A. Tea, that alao wee Included. . Q, Did you personally work on the oueation* or did you have any col¬ laborator*? A. Within the cuabattln* of the ehaaical airfare a#onta I handled all these quaatlon* by ayaelf. My collaborator* were not free ny offic* but they wore froc aatnbliafcconta which until then had occupied theaaalvoa with thoeo rroblen. Thera were certain office of th* Speer Minlatry and there were Individual aan freo the proving ground*. there were reaoonalble oeople froo air raid precaution ayator., ato. (i, Tou at lecet inforaed Roatoek ab ut theat taak* which you keot for ycureelf? A. 1 did not bother his with then bteauaa Roatook had ao nuch to do with tho clinic that 1 woe «lad when I could devota fill ny tine to the other teak*. He did not receive any further inforaatlon free ne. q. How if your were inforaad about one of theae field*, and I an, for instance, thinkln# about the infuraution #iven to you by Dr. Slover* ab?ut the result* of experinenta of i-rofaaaor Hirt with reference to Loet dnna#ea, didn't you then lnforo Dr. Bcatock about thi* oueation either? A. S«, 1 did not lnfora Roatock about that. -2451- U Feb. U7--TD-21-l-Meehan Court Ho. 1 Q Tou roc aired yet another authority and that was in March of 19b$J you were to sissnarize aedical questions within the Reich Research Counsel. Will you pleaso oca acre confirm that this was actually in March of 19U5? A It certainly was in the year 19U5) it nay be that it was in % April when I received this decree, which was signed by Goerin?. In any case, in this connection I did not answer nor did I do anythin" else, because at that period of tine Berlin was already located within^tho zone of operations* / a Q Wore your info raid by Rostock, as the head cf thp Sdonce Rosoaroh, aiything froc which you could conclude that the office of Rostock received krowledgo about axporlnents on fcusan baings? Do you remember ary such information cord nr to you? A I had not rocoived ary information of that kind fron Rostock, however, I an convinrod that if ho had had it hinself, or if ho had known anything at all about that, ho would have informed no of that fact at that tine. I want to concludo that ho did not know anything at all about then I did not discuss this prsbloa with hits and I have only, with rogard to axperlaonts, discussed tho jrogrea cf m l c als with hia, which had boon detailed and bequested to hie by semo institute. In o.y case, wo did net discuss ary experiments on hucan beings Q Would it have been tho duty of Rostock to inform you ol v.ch nuttors if ho had cone to know about then? A He certainly would havo informe;' no, It would also havo boon his duty to inform no ache wasry subordinate in this case. Q And you can confirm that freo the practice that when you collabo¬ rated in such a case, you would have been informed by hin? A I certainly would have boon informed by hin. Q Thank you, I havo no further quostions* THE PRESIDENT: Papers to the Secretary General. DR* SEIDL* Ccurmel for tho Defendants Gebhardt, Oberbauser and Fischer, -2452- li Febi U7-A-ATD-21-2-Heehan Court !tci 1 31 DR. SEIDLi Q Witness, yesterday when you discussed the Sulfanilamide Exporinonts, you sentionod penicillin) what did you scan by that? A I Mentioned penicillin In ordar fco express the fact that wo, in % Gersany, in the years fres 19lil to 19U2 reoonsiderod Sulfanilard.de as tho therapeutical nedicine, which was discussed wherever doctors assembled) similarly as on tho other side the problen of penicillin was taken. I only meant to sake a comparison in this way. Q And on that occasion you mentioned Professor Kruqger) is it oorroct that Profossor Krueger was tho consulting surgeon with tho Airy and Navy in Reeoarch? A Profossor Krueger was consultant physician with tho Group Scuth and Group Center in the East. I havo at ono tire seen hin in tho vicinity of Posna and I had also violtod hin lator on. Ho was problenatical porso- nality and froo the very boginning he had decided hinself for a cortuin Sulfanilanide dru* at a period of tine when the effoctivonoss of Sulfaniia- nldo for prevention of injuries did not toes socure. For this reason, ho was cochatted in his opinions beoauso it was believed that tho younger medical officer deponds too much on ths offoctivonoes of'Sulfanilanddo and as a result of this night neglect tho necessary troatnont of tho wounds, Q Professor Krueger was then tho representative of tho groups, whloh attached a spocial lnportanca to Sulfanilanide whon combatting wound in¬ fection contrary to other groups, which woro of another opinion? A In contrast to otters, yes. At tho tine, tho opinions woro still conplotoly experirwntal an! tho effectiveness of Sulfanilanide had not as yet been dote rained. Q Tostorday, you spoke about the difficult situation of tho German treope in Russia during the winters of 19& and 19U2) wiU you agree with mo when I say ttet in view of the experiences of that winter the question of the affect of Sulfanilanide was a military, medical problen of the first degree? -2A53- U ?eb* U7-A-IT>-21-3-fc«tan Court Jfa. 1 A I agree with this ooncept, Q I have no further questions 4 DR. WEISSGERHSR for Defendant Sievers. DI DR* WEISGERBER* * , q Witness, this nomine you told us that you saw the Defendant Siovors one single tine and that you spoke to him thenj is that corroot 1 A Yes. * Q Did you know his official position? A Mo, I did not know his official position. Q Did you know that an institute for .military science and research was affiliated to the offioe of Ahnonerfco? A No, I did not know that. q When talking to Sievors that one tino, did Siovors thon toll you that he had an ordor to speak to you about the Lost Roaoarch »©rk of Frofossor Wrt? A Mo, he told no that he had the order to give no this final report about the Lost work of Professor HLrt and ho had to do that by ordor of Hlnrnlor, but ho did not say he had the order to discuss tho eontonta of thoso mttors. q At tfrit tico was any nention nade about any othor experiments 7 A Mo, we did rot discuss axporinjr.ta at all, Siovors noroly handed this report to so as tho final report of Profossor Hirt regarding Lost treatnontj as such there was no further connection, Q You knawthat Sievers was rot a physician? A I had to assume that imediatoly, otherwise ho would havo approached oe in a different manner; I did rot krow hin and I did not have any concep¬ tion whatovor where he car» from; what agoncy ho came Trca and I did rot ask hi* about it. Q You, therefore, had ro reason whatsoever to discuss any experiments with hin? -245A- b Feb. U7-A-ATS-21-b-Meehan Co-art ?fc» 1 A Ho, I did not apeak to Ms about that. Q Did you knew Professor HLrt? A Jfc, at that tiro I did not know Professor HLrt? Q But later you beoana acquainted with tho official position of Professor Hirt? A Yes, I was told he worked at Strassburg University. Q This no mi nr you spoke about the military xvacossity of the iwistl- tution of a skeleton colleotion and you denied that necossityj would such a necessity be confirmed under different pointsof view? ' A From the point of view of a scientific interest it would bo corroct if skeleton collections were made. I knew of vory extensive collcoticna whLoh are affiliated with ovary anatomical institute. In particular, I know of a large collection at the Haseun in Berlin. Thoso aro really purely sdontific interests, but certainly not military interests. Q Could a layman, a nan who is not a physician, sako tho doclsivo jadflttnt about the necessity of such a collection? \ A I cannot answer that question. Q I have no further questions. -2A55- 4 F cb ru* ry-A-D JG-22-1-Xinabu ck Court So. 1 31 DR. FRITZ: (Defense Counsel for Defendant Rose) Q witness, did you know the defendant Rose before the 8th of Uay 1945, that is , before the collapse. A Yes, I spoke to hia once. I net hia once, yes. Q Did you ever have any other official connections with the defendant Rose as arc nentionod in his affidavit of Septeaber 1946 which is Document 872, Exhibit 408? A A I only had two dealings with hose, and since I don't know what docu- aont you aro speaking of I think that we are there concerned with malaria treatment of paralytical questions, and then again thoro were nourishment questions concerning the same persons. I think these arc questions whoro I dealt with Professor Rose. Q Did you ct any time speak to him about any points as were mentioned by the prosecution before Uay 1945? A No. Q Did you have any correspondence with him or did you deal with him in uny other form directly or indirectly? A No, neither directly or indiroctly, nor by way of writing. 3 Did ycu over ace the defendant Roso as a prrticipant in a discussion where the points were diceussed which are hore under indictment or where reports wore taade on those points? A In order to answer this quustion, one would hove to assume a common participation in such meetings, but I cannot remember any ono occasion whore I sew hia or spoke to hia. I add this morning whet Beatings I attended. If Professor Rose also attended these meetings it is certainly possible thit I saw him, but certainly we did not establish any contact or speak to one another. Q witness, you were just spooking about meetings. I meant conferences, discussions. Meetings usually mean to describe lergcr congresses. « I had no discussicnns wh.tsocver where Rose was present or whore I net him. 1 cannot reeeeber that. DR. FRITZ: Thank Ycu. Ur. President, I have no further questions. -2456- u ?ebruar7-A-DJG-22-2-Hinabuck Court lie. 1 3 Y 31. KAUnWffl: (Defense Counsel for Defendant Rudolf Brendt) Q Dr. Brenot, I Jiave one single question to put to you. Ihe prosocutio:. designates tho defendant Rudolf Brendt as the so-called special referent of Hied or. Kould you agree with % ac if I say that Rudolf Brandt was everything but a counselor of Himmler in matters which are the subject of this trid? A That is ay conviction. It is =y conviction that first Himmler did net accept any advice in his questions on principle because had thi^ been the case, such matters would not have been dealt with by him, and I am quite sure that Rudolf Brandt in particular would not have been in a position to give any advice to him. He would not have tolerated it. DR. KAUFlUINi Thank you. I have no further questions. BY DR. ShUra: (Doftnse counsel for Defendant Blcnc) Q Dr. Brendt, you nay perhaps rcembor that the prosecution in their material usboitted o file by Professor Klieve with reference to a mooting of the ao-callod Blitzablcitcr Comittoe. This ao-callod Blitzableitur Cecrw ittco was known as the agency in the Uehraacht which dealt with the prepar¬ ation of tho defense of biological warfare. In this filo about the mooting of this Blitxbloitcr Comittoe Professor Klieve writos and says that the defendant Dr. Blooe made utterances during that meeting which woro to tho effect that the Blittableitor Cccsaittco was working much too slowly; that it had to be dissolved. He said that Blooe would have to turn to Brandt; that Is, your, or to Gocring. I don't know whether this nan, Dr.Klievo, will appear as a witness. I asked for him, and I therefore want to ask you Dr. Brandt, at any time did defendant Dr. Blcne turn to you in this matter? Did he make any proposals to you? Please reply. /. I heard this work, BUtcablciter, for tho first time through this document Klieve. I did not knew thit before. V.ith reference to such a pro¬ posal Blcme certainly did not turn to me as can be soon fran this Klieve docu¬ ment, orally nor by writing. I had no conversation or correspondence with him at all, and he nevor approached me vith reference to this problem, 51itze- bleiter, Q Dr. Brendt, I have e further question, referring to a different chtp- -2457- U Fobruery-A-D JG-22-3-Ninabuek Bcurt Bo. 1 ter. This morning during your ex a mnation you repeatedly spoke about diff¬ erences which you yourself had with the Reich physicians' leader. Dr. Conti, jnd you also spoke of differences which the defendant Dr. Blome had with the same Dr. Conti. Dr. Blcae was the deputy of Dr. Conti, end I am inter¬ ested to know whether you can*give us any more information as to what kind of differences existed between Dr. Blaze end Dr. Conti, end to what these differences refurrod? A Without going into details, I would like to describe them "as follows: -henevor physicians ere represented as a community Dr. Blcoe was of the X opinion that only professional reasons must be decisive for the manner in itfiich they are represented, but that it would not be correct to involve a physician in political questions and put him into a political harness, thinking that one could further medicine by that. In this connection whenovor 1 into contact with Dr. Blorac I had many discussions with hia. «t these occasions it was clearly nentionod that in addition to the personality -of Conti himself, which brought difficulties of lta own with it, these mentioned material reasons wore dccisivo. Q In this connection , Dr. Brandt, I should like to put the following quostion to you: During these conversations which were cairied on b; Dr. Blomo with you, did he say anything about wanting, under all circumstances, to tako cut physicians from Party matters and that for this rocson ho dosirod to separate the union of personnel which existed between the Reich Choker of Physicians on one sido, and the Main Department for Public Health on tho othox and ho wanted to do that for the- reason that this so-callod public health office was on express Party institution? A The situation was as you described it, yes, exactly. 2von in December 19U. we discussed this question. I think it was even after the decree which was mentioned this morning, the decree number 2 where tho Army Medical Chief was separated. Q Dr. 3r?ndt, do you r«aazbcr anything about tho following: Ifith refer¬ ence to these conversations rtiich you had with Dr. Blome did he complain tc ycu that Dr. Conti, the Reich physicians' leader, kept many things away free him. Dr. Bloce, so that Dr. Blome was net informed about important -2,5*- 4 P cbru a ry-A-DJG—22-4-Winabuck Court No. 1 matters in tho heloh Chamber of Physicians and matter.. which concerned the laedership of the medical profession? My question is whether he told you the. or whether he eccplaincd to you about it? A He did that and the por*jnality of Conti was always mentioned, who was a distrusting porsen, a difficult person to cope with, who concentrated everything to himself personally, everything that happened in his office, so that not one collaborator of his could receive any insight in the^activity which ho himself exercised. Q Witness, one further question. Do you know th*t this Dr. Conti, apart froo other offices, had two main positions? Which wc^e thoso positions? A Thoso wore tho two positions. Ono was a Party position, Reich Hoalth Loader, and the other, Undor Secretary of State of tho Ministry of tho Int¬ erior. Q That is Roich Health Loader; is thet identical with flho Doputy Roich Physicians' Leader?.? -2459- h Feb. U7-^-ATT>-22-larJiinabuek Court to. 1 A The position was that, as far as personnel goes, ho was tho phy¬ sicians* loador, and at tho sane tine, Raich Health Leador. In addition, in tho state aootor he was ^Jndor Secretary of Stato of tho Ministry of tho Intorier. °r. Blene was his representative in his capacity as physi dan's loaderj that is, sorely partly a representative of Conti's personality, not on tho stato sector. *■ Q The latter is vary important to no. On tho basis of your know- lodgo cf quostions of co^xitcnco, you said that Conti in his capacity as Stato Secretary was not roproaontod by Er. Conti? A to. Q For that ho had other collaborators? A Tos, for that ho had offici a ls of tho Ministry of tho Interior who represented hi;'* Q In that connection, Dr. Brandt, I want to put tho following quostions to youi This Doming you told us what position you yoursolf hold within tho euthanasia progron, You naturally know tho jurisdic¬ tion and tasks of tho participating agondoa and porsons. Did tho dofondarrt Dr. Blono exorcise any function in tho euthanasia progron? Was ho in ary *=y participating in it? A I did wet noot hfcn at all, and I hoard nothing (ibout that. Q Witnoss, I an putting this quo3tion to you for tho following rooson* You rcoccbor that on tho wall behind you thoro usod to bo a chart which wca nado according to tho sfcateconts of tho defendant Brack, awl on this chart which I thirk you had, thoro is in tho oenter a squaro for tho Stato Secretary Conti in the Rcdch Ministry of the In¬ terior, awl you, I an sure, will rexaerhar that to tho right of this squaro thoro was a scalier squaro whioh said Dr. Blono. You roaonbor 0 that, dent you? You already explained that Tar* Blone had nothing to do "1th tho euthanasia progron and did not represent Dr. Gonti when he actod in his capacity as Secretary of Stato. tor, is it your opinion that this chart which was mde according to the static.onts of tho do- - 21)60 - h F obr.ii 7-A-AnV^ 2-ia-Nirjbuck Court So. 1 fondant Brack, 1* wrong in rospeot to tho squaro whoro Dr. Bio no* a nano is nontionod? % - 2l/>0 a - h Feb. U7-A-ATD-12-2a-»ilnafcuck Court !fc. 1 a This square with reference to Dr. 31coe is wren*, and Dr. Brack In his new chart already corrocted that; Da. SAITTE?.: In that case I hare Do further questions. Hr. President. Thank you, THE PRESIDENT: Is it aftticipatod that there will bo ary further cross examination by ary of the defers e oounsel torerrow aorning7 DU. FROESCHt'.Ni (Counsel for defendant Brack) !(r. President, I have n nueber of question which I want to put to the witness. Dr. Erandt, which will t ake hobo time. THE PRESIDENT: Mr. Secretary General, hero is another paper that bolongs in your custody. The Tribunal will now rooess until 9*30 tonorrew — MU. HoHAKEIi If it please the Tribunal, I would liko to ask that the Tribunal rulo that the witness, Karl Brandt, bo confined so that ho nay rot be talked to by any of tho dofonso ecu ns el, including his own dofonso counsel, until he has completed his exanination on tho stand, DR. JSRVATIUSi I 4>n't know whether I understood correctly. I cortain¬ ly shall bo ablo to speak to cy diont, or is that to be axcludod? MR. MoH'.fET: I think he has now taken tho stand and is to bo trontod as ary otter witness, and I think it is propor that in tho case of any ordinary witness appearing bofore this Tribunal that ho not bo talked to by oithor side during the courso of his exanination once that exanination has begun. JUEG5 SEBRUC: Mr. HcHnnoy, does the Tribunal understand from your statements that during tho course of prosocution when tho witness had once takon the s tand, that throughout the courso of the exanination no m.Qber of tho prosecution or its representatives attested to discuss any natter with bin at ary tirt during the course of the examination? fTv, HoHAKETi Well, I thick that has boon uniformly true, ycur Honor. However, I can’t speak for everyone. However, in view of the Tribunal’s po¬ sition, or rather, the question Just put, I will ask that when Karl Brandt «ces under cross exanination tomorrow, that his defense counsel not be per- iL61 L Feb. U7-A-ATD-12-3a-NlBabuck Ccurt Nc» 1 nitted to th*in confer with hlcj at least, I would like a ruling to that effec- DX. SEH7ATIUSI Mr. President, I would be in conplote agreenent with this ruling. As soon as the witness is at the disposal of the prosecution I will not apeak to hie. H^rovar, before cross axaaination has started I rast have tho possibility to speak to =y client, THE PRESIDENTi The Tribunal is of the opinion that under tho circun- stances at this present tiae ccunsel for defondant Karl 3r^dt nay speak to Hn until tho defendant is turned over to tho prosecution for cross exami¬ nation, and aftor that tine tho witness should bo under the rule to not talk to ary one until his cross exard nation by the prosecution is conploted. I understand that counsel for the defondant, Karl Dranit, is in accordance with that principle? DR. SEIWATIUSi Tea. THE r?ESIDENTi Tho saao principle will be followod with tho othor defendants whon they take tho stand. Tho Tribunal la of tho opinion, and I think the Tribunal's ruling was dear, that defendant Karl Dranit's own counsel and no other counsol for ary other defondant or anybody olso, should consult with tho defondant Karl Srarxlt durii^ the course of this night. That's understood. Tho Tribunal will row recoas until 9i30 o'clock tomorrow naming. (Tho Tribunal ad Journo d until 5 February 19U7, *t 0930 hours.) -2462- 5 Feb l*7-4«X«I^LHCaprar (n ) S«Tt to. 1 xrercrr coft Ofilaial truncript of the Anerlcan Hilitaxy Trltwnftl ir the rat tor of tho United States’ ot Aaarlra against jfcrl Brandt, ot al, do- Xtcdanta, s.t'-ine at tourrberg, Goran.-.-, on 3 FabrufiT 19U7# 0930, Justice Boals presiding. 7HZ MARSHAL! Pcrs-.na in the Court Roon will plcose find their *oats. Tho Honorablo, tto Judges of 1215 tajy • -iburol I. *“ Solitary Tribunal I is now in section. God save the United Status of Anerioa and this horcrublo Tribunal. Tho re will be order in the Court. THE PRESIDENTi ltr. Ifcvrahal, will you ascertain that tho dofon- lanta are all proaent ir. Court. TIE MARSHAL! Iky it ploaao your Honors, all defendants are proaent in tho Court Rooa. THE PRESIDENT* Tho Secretary Gunoml will no to for the rooord tho fact that tiio defendant* aro all present in Court. JWtL 3RAJDT - Resuaod «AK:a*iDjf BT DR. FROESCHUIiH* Q Mitnoss, yebt -rday ir. the last j-art of /cur discussion of the Euthanasia progrna - I would ^iko to address sono questions to you in that oonnocUon. Do you knor that in August, 1939, an oral order had alroady procodud tho written deer jo by rfltlor to Bouhlcr? A. No, I do not know anything about that. Howovor, I ccatiidor it possible because otherwise this coneroto order to Bouhlor would re>t l^vo boon assuae that perhaps Bouhlor say havo had a certain th/^. itiora which wore taking placo botwoon Dr. C°/\tinnd Lai r ors, which', at the tine, wore Innediatoly discussod at in tho rddilfl-of ^optcebor. •-\Q .-Tosterdajr hare already spoken of exceptions — the por- Jora were r»t all<^7ad to fall under the euthamsia progren — and * n “W-® connection you have already nonticned tho -21,63 S ?eb U7-M-SW-l-2-Earrcw (n.) Court No. 1 war invalids. Hare I understood you correctly that thoso war invalids were to be excepted from the euthanasia whose cental disease was in direct connection with an Injury during the World .7ar I or World War II? A Toe. Q Do you know anything about the fact the the defendant Brack, together with his coll a borators, drafted the law? A I have only fomd cut about it at a later poriod of tine. At the tine I did not know anything at all about it, ' Q It should bo of interest for the Trlburd to know the nunbor of insane in Germany in 1939» «fould you bo able to givo some inform- ticn about that subject to tho iVibunal? A I oannot givo the exact mabar for the year of 1939 to you. In goner&l we have no idea abcut the nucbor of mentally diseased in tho country. Tho rnnbor which I know had probably been dotoreinod in tho year 193U, but I cannot oay that with certainty. Tho rain contin¬ gent concerns people oufforing iron parol;-ais in all tho phases of tho dlsoaso. In this ocnr.octior., of courso, th ro wore not only tho siok porsore who had to bo confinei to an institution out altogothor a nunbor of pationts who wore suoJoCtod to gonoral nodical treatment. Tho nunbor ims estimated at approximately one million. The next bipgost nunbor of patients was that of schizopiirorda which was locatod around six hundrod thousand and that was out of a population of about Sixty million. This schizophrenia, at tho sane tine, represents tho mental contingent for tho cental lnatitutioro and that was approxiratoly two hundred thousand. ?or the nurfcer of beds available, that n eo n s 70$ to 80%. Of these Ms os of schizophrenia, approximately 20> could bo cured. The remainder continued to be patients in mental institut ions. Tho sano nunbor of approximately two hundred forty thousand patients is the number for iloptics and for the mardo^opressivo patients. 5 Fab li7*4S-&#—1—3-Earrow ( 2, Court ffa. X The statist}.oo for the Huntington Disease stands at about 60 % against tho others. However, altogether, the nurber of noptal l y insane and idiots nas approxiratod at one rdllion. Altogether there nay have boon three nil lion cental oases. Q How =any, in your opinion, of those cases wore confined to in- stitutiom? A Of tha three nillior, tho nr bar of two hundred fifty thousand occupied beds in institutions. That is, about kiu hundred thousand wore under constant radical oc.ro and one part of tas'., approximator two hun¬ dred fifty thousand, wero confined an hospitals xhilo the othors wero troated by a private physician. Q Do you havo an insight into tho fact of how cany people koto included in tho euthanasia pro gran described by you yesterday in tho years 1939, 19hO, 19Ul, until tho ond? A Tho nurbor woa ccnputod iron our statistics, ono thousand — 10 to 5 to 1, ir. which oount is tho nurber of porcono who aro healthy; ton of th»jo a\: under nodioal caro, fivo aro undor constant troatrwnt ir. institutions, and ono cocos undor tho euthanasia pro gran. That r.oana that aaongst one thousand healthy pooplo thoro is ono such caso. That again is figured froc tho population of sixty rdlli on - that is, approximtoly sixty thousand* Q Hotrovor you had no access to exact statistics? A As far as I knew no statistics have boor, ocnpilod. Q How, one other quostion. If he gave orders within tho euthanasia program? Did you give then or did Boulor givo than thoro with raspect to the physicians? A Yesterday, I stated that tho T-Ji was an office of Bouhlcr. As far as I know tho physician* wore suggested on tho part of the i’inistiy of tha Interior. In tho course of that ti=o I attended about four conferences- which took place at tho office of Bouhlcr 'There tho expert and three other experts also attended. Tho recoining con- 5 Fab li7-H-fr^L-3-Karrow (31) Coart So. 1 ferencee which took place elsewhere ware carried out without cy partici¬ pation. . - 21 * 66 - 5 ?eb-£3H-2—l—Lessor (H? Court Ho. 1 Q Could the Defendant Brack issue .ny independent orders within the Euthanasia Program? A No. Q Wa a 3rack eubordiretod to you, witness? A No, Brock ms not subcriinatod to no but was subordinatod^to 3ouhlor. Q Did Brack discuss nodical oattars with you? * A No. Q Did ytw knew that in the -./inter cf 191/1 to 191/2, at the tino when tho cataetApho breko over the Oaraar. in the East, aesnbors of tho T-4i wore assigned to carry cut r. rtcouo action in tho East by ordor of Hitler? A I an of tho opinion that tl*jy ::oro air oft tr used baforo I visited Vic ora which I hero doscrlbod x> ycuj that would be alrea^' in Docanbor of 191*1. Theso units wore alroacfcr usod on tho railway fron 1’d.rok to Scclonok. I think that this was a nor.suro which was suggostod by Dr. Todt, Q Do you know how long this roscuo action lasted? A In ty opinion and as far as I raoonbor, it ms ooncludod with the or.d of winter, around Jfcrch or April. Q Thor. I would like to ask you tlic following question, witnoss. •• By virtue of this iecrcj of Hitler of 1 Soptoefcor 1939 1 wore you apd Bouhler given tho assignment tc authorize cornain pliysiclans to givo "-?rcy deaths tc incurably nontally Insane — m 3 it your opinion to obtain tho assurance of Hitler that those physicians, after having perfornoi such euthanasia, if they vox* threatened with legal procedures, ‘bat they should bo saved fron such rith intervention by tho adrdnistra¬ tion? A Tcs, absolutely. Q Therefore, in the decree of Hitler, you navo soen a statement ~j the head of the State, according to which theee physicians were ex- - 21367 - 5 F *!>-£= Looser (IL) Court, Jfo. 1 cop tod forn any le, prccodj^ras? A Yea, that •& quit© cj^ar. That has also been the caso in tho continuation of to* prcgrfl in 191*0 and 19lil« Q Mow do 7o\ agree with no that tho State did not cease intoroat in the lifo of a hi san being which :.as worth;. of protoction? A I have noi. understood the previous question* Q I have cs!»i the question, do ;*cu arras with no that the State X haa not oeaaed an i.nteroat in tho llfo of a fcunan being worthy of pro¬ toction? . A Toe, Q On the authority of Hitler ar.d being fa. il liar with thoao pre¬ requisites, that is, the incurably inaano, have you aeon in that tho ■tatenont by the he id of t!.o State that too intoroat of tho Stato cooaod in tho livoe of thoao people, nacoly tho nontally andi rxjurably ill? A NO, I ho\i not aoon that* Q And why net? A In thia I have noon only tho thought to '..dp the ccnUtion of tho person and to brii^ it to an and in the intorost of the afflic- tod p ora on. That was part of the Stato intorost. Q Theroforo, tho reason for those otatenonts in this ca3o lay in tho person of tho patient? A Only in the person of tho patient. Q T! it nos a, new according to yctrtaodical knowledge are they alive or hive they lost so nuch cf their legal valuo of living that a continuation as they ere for all tine has lost its value for tho person? A Yes, for tho person Idrsolf, yee. Q Do toe sc—calidd mentally dead balong to.that group — that is, nooplo who are in a condition of final incurable idiocy? A I would count those people into that group, yes. 5 Feb- EBB-2-2-t*o3«r (IL) Court So. 1 Q Tou hft7o stated th t the deed si» about the diacnoaoa aa to thoir Incurability *<;aa In he bends of op or ta wto worked independently of each other on the individual oaaos, la that correct? 21*66 a 5 ?ab-€BH-2—3-Les ar (i-) Court !to. 1 A lee. Q for : n your opinion nan -ho3b export*: now, in a certain sense, % State Organa? I rant to repeat too questioni K era tho p^-sicians whoso task it was t> nake dicgroeoe, through the fact that th*' had been given the authoritj •, woro they now in a certain sens 3 organs of the Sta^o as far as thoi: diagnoses wore ooroornod? A F.th regard to the do-reo thec' have t * a Just in'that capacity, in an off.dal position* Q Tn^did not have on o;‘*ioial position b it with rogard to tho decree '.hey have had that cap* ity. fitness, wi'.h the specialised physi- dai« is it possible to letcm -o ouch cases ol Incurable Rental disea¬ ses with abaoluto certainty? A Within tho frarorxrtc of the goi.'orc- dua i ctnii-or ..1— , y-#, that possibility oxiats. Q ,/ith tho irfiuffioior.cy of humn kaowiodfte tan a edetoko occur ir. the person of ovun a p-yaidan ith such ur, •rioncoV A A niatako ia, of courso, possib'-u* Q fow, foes not now a ioputy of the hood ol tho Stato have to boar this possibility of nistakoa in dnd? A This possibility was taken into account *jy tho foot that a rxzbar of experts and also subsequently a rainbor of observatory possi¬ bilities of tho pationts woro mdo available to tha physician; furthor- rcra by tho fact that after :svvii^ boor, oonfinod to ar. institution for 5 yoara, tho institution whoro the pationt was located would still subject this patient tc a period of leng obsurvntion. Q Therefore, to sun up for conclusion, you have aoen in tho security noasuros widch you have Just nentionod, you have seen Stato and r.edical guarantees? A Yes, the State and nodical guaranty. Q Then I ±> not tove any further questions. THE PRESIDENT: Is there any further cross-exadnation of this - 2lj6 9 - 5 ?eb-EB?V2-U£e' 3 ex (IL) Court !fc. 1 witness on the poft o5 ary defense counsel? .t re being 7*0$; tho Prose¬ ction nay crcas-exazdno. r jUTJ.TlOW BT ISR. SCHANETi Q Herr Brandt, eince you 1 ve Just co i Hecusdjg Euthanasia wo shall centime on that subject. I would liko .« ask you hew raiohj^y- chiatric training you have roceiv »d? A I have had no psychiatric training in particular. x Q How ouch first-i Jind kncwl< d o lavo you receivod on insane pat- ionts? A I an afreid I shall have to ask you to repeat the quostion. I did not quito understand it. Q I asked you tow mch first «JanJ knowledge cr oxporlonco you hnvo had with ireana persons. A First of all at the unlrere. ty I tod ry ordinary training and r.ftartrarda I hod no ooro praotioal axporlunco in touching rogarding insane pationts. Q How nany ireano asylum havo you bo.'n in for tho purpose of obaorvation and stu. 1. Q : Now, Kerr Brandt* lot's got clear at the beginning that wo don't want to bo quarreling about the use of the vords "ccthcnasla program. “ I am going lb continue to say ■program*; and I underatnni that you disagreed with that use of the word. 35t I think we understand Chat we mean. So lot's don't consume time arguing about Chl3 triviality. How, are you ready to 6weor that only income oorsons, incurably insane peraons, were subject to ouUtonaela in spite of the broad Fuehrer order hero which aaya that outhrnasla can bo applied to any incurable person whothor insane or dtherwiac? A: Yea, that la preclaoly what I wish to express boco.uso of tho individual cases which I Know about bolng no more t.xxn four or fire as years wont by; but in rogard to tnoso oaaoG I auat say that outhannoia wno not oarrlod out and there were no corresponding authori tat ions coning through* 0,1 You made a consldorablo point of tho humanitarian notivo in relieving these peroons from pain and sufiorlng. Thoro is nothing in this lotter whloh limits tho applicability of euthanasia to those porsons wro are suffering pain, is there? A: If I wore to read through its text, I prooa.ely wouldn't come across that >x>ri, r.o. Q: Veil, I suggest to you that you couldn't swear to this Tribunal that tne program was limited to tho persons, insane or otherwise, sufforlr.; severe pain, could you? AS We weren't concerned with pain in tho case of tiiooo insane patients. We were concerned with their condition, their entire condition, their mental condition. It isn't tint stupidity or being demented is a painful affair 2472 5 Pobrtxcry-K-DJG-S-S-Blakijay - PM Court No. 1. It is dcf .ctivenoss of thi mental structure; and it is cou. octea with the disintegration of a nan's personality; and, of course, those people because of tie disintegration of their personal structure vero included in t! t program which you have Just described. Veil, I an 6ure that we all rcalito tha t, Herr Brandt; but you had made auen a considerable point of tho huainltnrlan r/otlwo of relieving tho patient from subjective pain and suffering; and I'm putting it to you that thore aro a la.rge numbor of persons who cen be classed a.s insane who arc in fact porfootly happy poople. Isn't that true? A: I don't thin* that an insane person is a happy • hunan olng, nor do I think that the life of an inor.no person, considering the circumstances under which it pro- groosoo, is something which is wlthlr. the keeping of human dl jnlty. Thcco are considerations end trains of thought with which ono will have to grapple again and again. Ur.dor oortaln circumstances this may be :iothing but an avgunont with wo vds; but the fact of the condition of ouch p..tionto and tho fact of a condition unfit for the continuation of llfo — that is the decisive factor. In that connection tho question by She psychological burden which socoone will havo to bear who is, for instance, suffering fi*oc t..o condition of depress ion. Q: Of courso, if you trso the Justification, tho moral Justification, on relieving people from pair, and suffering, you ernsjo that it la both consistent with that nigh 3Dral principle and the wording of this Fuonror letter to ap,ly euthanasia to so-called hopeless cases of t. bcrcaiosls or cancer or syphilis and what not; isn't that true? 2473 5 February -lU>JG-3-8-Blakley-?K Court No. 1. A: That Is not possible. I have already said earlier to Dr. Froeschmann and I ccphaslzcd it yesterday that as far as the status is concerned it cannot be considered a burden and patients v:ho are still in a % position to ba helped should be holped. The burden which is after nil nothing but a burden to the budget must not undor any olrcuastcncos fclny a pert. That woe'1 be sad condition. It is a end condition in nil olvlllzod 8 tat os that they do not raise tho coney md tho^fund osncntlal for this purpose, both, I aeon, for the supply and tile welfare of such persons who aro worthy oC such cere in insane asylucs. On the other hand as to cr.ro for tuberculosis patients, I should dislike to see thoco pcoplo included in tho euthanasia program undor any clrcunatanoes. It is a principle and most docisivo difference which play a part horo. I have told you onrlior that euthanasia can only play a part in tho interest of tho patient hi©eolf and undor no circumstances must any other lntorcot, auiy dthor facotr, be of significance in this connection. If I apply this to conditions in Gormaiy. then bo fore tho war wo spont 2473 (a) Court So. 1 throe hundred fifty niUicn fc • th^gg asylias, >*iph In com¬ parison to other states fj t largo .u- of non. in £}# 28 2 total expend!turo it i; , s .f -on consider :hat three fzpdrod fifty -11 Ilo na a day went for t*o pursul » ©a. t •- "r, or -f you ocascro it rith tho coot of a battleship, t*' ± U ©lout the sico. These funds, this equipment, and the cay f • the 3* »et -ry personnel ic aoaet&ng v*ioh overy well organised tU a ough to riig$# Q !fow, this Fuehrer levtar ctoo* • »t e«; tf at tog patient has to bo doonod to an early death, dcos itt A Ho saya that if tho situation is x.st ari&ttlly Judged by tho dcotor .then t!w nercy dev.tho oar. bo granted. In the otoo of incurablo diseases, any other quoctions wldoh right havo ,nlay»d a part in this ooimootion aro not dealt with in ..-rlting in this 1o.too| but appropriate lnstruotions issuod by the Fuehrer to Bouhlor or to re in order to have thoo paaaod on to Bouhlor for Us carding out rare, c.*oalt with in that natter. Q ' oli, : don't tfairfc you aasawsi sr luottion. I A*s put it in another my. Tho outhanaoia progrer - not licitol to persons who woro downed to die an early death, «s it? A I don't knar whether you aro applying tho words early death to tho ago of the parson or the condition of hi a illness, It right havo boon possible — it was possiblo that pationts voro included in tho pregren who under certain circumstances right have boon able to live another two or three years; bit it was not tho easo that with rofcronco to tho insar.o patient only the aged person ms affected. Of importance were tho auostiojxairo and tho stage of his illnoss which W» shorn in those details and facts. Q Dr. Brandt, isn't it true that yen can hare a porscr. of fifteen years who is suffering fincurable insanity cf one sort or arothar, yot who say livo to rips cld age cf seventy-five? Isn't that treo? - 2Ji7U - 5 Februar7^tt-OJG-3-3-eliiaaS' (XL) Court >fo. 1 A It3 r»at l^robatala 7% Edfht U^i^« eeptajp drcuMtanaea heppon occasionally, cooaadcmlJyj but 1/ ^ i* insana. It U root Inprobablo that % fie will livo to tho aeo of eevonty-fivo. I en pretty auro that thir would be one of tho rest outstanding exceptions. Generally - 2Ji72i a - 6 February -IUDJ&-3-4-Blafcloy -PH Court Nc. 1* It uouldn*t bo the case at all. Tr.e life of lnscnc poroona who fall 1 X 1 at on early age usually coses to an end fairly early, too. Q: Well, whatsis tho averngo length of tine that on insane person spends in on asylum in Gcvmany7 As I am afraid I car. ! t tell you that, what tha nvornge flguro is. It will depend on tho jbype of disease^ but I ocn*t give you an average age. I'd afraid. Q: Now, do you want the Trltunal to believo thr.t tho euthanasia program was applied only to such porsons as in tho Judgment of tr~- exports would die within a period of ono yoar fir two years? Is that what you want tho Trltunal to bollovo? A: I boliofo that the translation into Gorman is not as cl oar no it is nccossary for me to understand your questions. Maybe I night ask you to speak a little ne»a slowly oo that the interpret or can kcop the pace. Zi I aksod you, Doctor, whether you wish tho Trltunal J 2475 5 Fcb-24-JP— 3-la-31akloy-£K -ourt Ho. X. to believe that euthanasia was applied only to such persons vho v.culd In any event die within ono or two years. A: I can't tie cy^sclf down by saying that tho patient effected would have alod one or two years later. Sorac of tfcon nl = ht have died earlier; some of then all it have died n little later, lhc decisive point was not that tho antici¬ pated year of ebatr. from tte date of their being found vice condldorod but wnat wc6 decisive was the condition of the patient at tho time he was being considered. Q: Bouhlor was not a doctor, w-o he, Herr Brandt? A: Ho, Bouhlcr wca not a doctor. Q: Now, this lottor from Hitler says that you have tho responsibility of enlarging thcauthorlty of certain physicians by mao. Did you do that? A: Those wore authorisations given to certain aedloal offices by Bouhlor and myself Jointly. Q: It says here to enlarge tholr authority by a-nc. I take that to nona that you know who those people ware? Ihcse doctors were dealt with through the Hinistry of tho Interior, which actually had Jurisdiction ovor those aaylua3 ard vhlch nominated them, since noitnor Bouhlor nor I could make n survey of these asylums to this degree, so that in fact suggestions were made by the ogoncy concerned, who had knowledge of tho personnel under their Jurisdiction. Afterwards, after this designation had trkon plnco, tto authorisation was then given. Q: Did you investigate these men or enuso any investigation ts be made? A: No, it was done on request of the Ministry of tho Interior, which was the superior agency of that institution. ft: 3ut, Herr 3r-ndt, ultimately It was your respbnslbllJ 2476 5 ?cfc-y~J?-3-la-3lokley -PH Court No. 1. and ths responsibility of Bouhlcr to design" t- those men and to authorize thee, was It not? A: With the authorization and the signing, I carried out an order which was given oc, a task of thu soloctlon of those rwn, I noon, "e ourselves could not carry out the designation of those non; and In that connection therefore we relied upon the recognized department, vhlc.. rl^v.t from tho beginning was r.sponsible for such instbtu .ions; and wo had to rely on then; and we did rely on then. There was no other solution in practice. Otherwise It would have boon necessary for ono of uc to have first of all tho management of euoh institutes in our hands; and oC oourso that was not the sltuc tlon. Q: dut as a good follower of tho Fuehrer, you of course accept responsibility for their designation, Isn't tir.t right? A: as to responsibility for the designation of thoso aaor., tho designation, the selection, took place through tl.o Ilialstry of the Interior, n* through no. Qs So If els takes were nadc In sclcotlng those cion and thoy picked out o few reprehensible characters, you don't accept responsibility for that? You hnd nothing to do with It? Is that right? A: No, I couldn't say that. I wouldn't say that I had nothing to do with it. Tho selection did tckq place, nowover, through an offlci'l a .cnoy; and also of courso it was to make the difforor.ee between authorization and tho aatftal currying out of sue*, anx-ion. authorization alono in not the only decisive factor in the fitting lnh, effoct of this plan. Thoro wore various cnannels which wore instituted; and the possibility of a wrong selection there¬ fore* appeared to us to be out of tho question. 2477 5 ?cb-K_JP-3-2a-31ciley-?K Court No. 1. q. Now, you must hove been interested In who was being selected. Do you recsr.bor cny of tne names of the •people who were authorised to accord a mercy death* A: I can't tell yo* a single one of tr.-sc nr.ncs. Eioro weren't neny of then. There vrere chief a of institutes. I jnvo Just rend one none, Pfannmeuller; and th n the name Kartell played an important part. a Q; Now, how about the nano Bonno? A: It doesn't mean a thing at the noment.' v He was strtioned ct Hartheim. A: No, the name henno docs not mean a thing to no at c.*j ..»~ent at any rate. I did n-.t learn of hin 2477 (a) 5 ?cb-K-GZS-3-3a-31akley -PM Court Ho. 1 ft: You knew Hartheln was one of the extermination stations? a: In Hftrtheia there was a euthanasia institute, yes. • ft: I don't suppose you knew toe nn^o Christian Virth? A: I krow him from the files. I know his from toe files, without the Christian. I know the name '..’lrth ficm the files. Probably ho is the some. ft: That 13 very interesting. You reecabor'that iir. Oorstoin la his affidavit said that Virth was running tois Jewish extermination camp at Trebllnka. Do you remember that? That's how I knew the nano, ft: You moon you know his name fron the filco of this or.oo; you didn't know l^ls nano during t m euthanasia program? Is that whet you neon? h: No, I can't reoolloct having oono across this n-no during the euthanasia program. I n u aorcly trying to express toe fact that I know it fron the filos hero. ft: I misunderstood you. Virth, I will suggest to you, also voricod at Kr.rthela; :nd of oourso you don't know the none Schumann, do you? a: Only now fron toe files did I get to know it. It wasn't know to no beforehand. I didn't even know that he wte in Karthoio at cny tine. ft: No, he wasn't; ho was at Grafeneck. How many aon wero.authorUed to administer euthanasia? You said there were -eryfcv. I should think that you t*>uld member them. a: Those were the people, presumably t n to fifteen, I should assume, apart from individual autnorizations which 2473 5 r cb-H-SE3-3-3c-Blr-kloy -?M Court No. 1. hrvd boon given In connection with the Reichs Connlttco Children. Those, of course, wero different doctors. ft: Ton to fifteen non — well, let's see that wc understand one mother* tforo those ten or fifteen uon the non who actually geve the Injection In the oxtormlrvntlon station or herded the people Into the gas ohenborf :.ero those the ton or fifteen who wore r.uaior-* ltod to administer * 2476 (a) 5 7ol>4-3IS-.' J ->-3l'Jclo;*>JF Court I tho -ore 7 deaths, or wna th*t Heydo and "iotsche "-nd the top exports? row, whoa are wo talking about bore? A. In ay opinion we nro talking about these people who had authority to carry out the euthanasia na such. They woro tho people who had to carry out tho work of exports. Vill you repeat tfco question, ulonso? I*a not buto that tho translation caoo through ao I'll repeat it. I understand that you are stating that tea to fiftcon non woro -a authorized -ctually to carry out outhnnaAia in tfco outh- -asin atationa? A, I do not think that there wore as nany as th^t aiarltanooualy. The total w-.a that hi£w Ono or two doctors woro working in tho cuthnnaoln institutes who had authority; and, if I rocollect it oroporly, thcr. the total nunbor of institutos amounted to six, so thnt this would bring us to a total of twelve. 2 ut I also bjlievo that doctors changod so that ono sight havo droppod out and then another ono would bo glvon authority. At any rato, tho figuro was a vorr low ono. 3479 5 Court .to. 1 5 la avr^Utef^tU drop ctW X^^->-Jc>y«i <\'\~-'irth went to the Beat to help with the cxurnln: ticn of the Jews, end SchXuoann we-.t to tMoctorttz to help cut wit 2 i thc-mxUa wi na ti on of the Jena, but I cn .'uriv- to knew why a acn in your position ;.ith Vio responsibility to dc*i$nat« theso non with authority to perform. jgfumaaLa c. uld net rtnoeber the neats of !• or 15 non who were actually dome it. You recalled cnly yesterday thrt t>-o to ficur per cent cf the people ac.:t to a cuthanrax. at..ticn were rejected end weren't killed. I ccn't undtrat-nd in the f. ct of au^h roaerkatlv. naaory th t ycu rculdn't r«iuc=b..r th- iv-acs cf 10 or 15 a»n? « I can't rcacobwr the nr ua. 1 -a quite sure thrt nene cf those pcoplo ccnccrned Here sent to the Best with qy knorlt*-'. e, noithcr for tho axtcr-dnntlcn cf the Jens nor for nay sterilisation ectivitioa. Q Hew arny outhanr.sia stations did you visit? A I have visited cn cnc occasion. C ‘ h:t atetien did >cu viait and *>h«»n? a Grrfcncck. This aust have been cn cr rbcut the beginning cf 1910. It vos r t e tiae when the first rdainiatre.tiv*. act up there had begun to oyercto in connection — thcae ..ere dvpr rt-.cnta instituted in ccnnecticn with .Ministry cf tho Interior. It v: a bee-use cf thcau registrar offices rnd news which hrd cc.ac frett there, there had been cbjocticna cn Bcuhl^r'a pr-rt right free: the werd ".jc" rnd on :ny cwn part reg.-rdinf the secret procedure connected therewith, rnd I desired to bo once acre- informed abcut the prcblens cn h.-nd ana sc I went there on cno ccceaicn rnd sew it t'.ex-c nysclf. Apart fre . thrt I heve not visited nny other cf these institutes. Q So ycu w»r.t tc Grafcncck in 1910; dc ;tu r-iuaber whet month? A I crr.'t tell ycu exactly which aonth it v.r.s. Q hell, was it the first p-rt cf thv year or the sccend pert of the jut r? 2180 Q. Now, how rany observation stations did you visit? A. I didntt visit any. I only went to Orafenodt", 0 Q. I want to understand this, Grafonock was a outhanasia station that is whero the poople were actually kiUod. I now put tho quostion to you, how naigr observation stations did you visit, which is a placo they stopped and they kept th«= boforo they went to tho euthanasia stations? km I have novor visitod an obeorvation station, noithor an ob¬ servation station nor a euthanasia station, I havo 21,81 - 5 ?cb-:>5-PH?-Kalo3-J?-p-e lA. Court I only boos 9r,aefncck is ill. q. gov, you h-re testified that this letter of Hitler was pro-dntod aoaotluo in October 1939. 1 September 1939? A. That is right. * q. The day Poland was attacked? A. ?os. q. Vhy wr.s that done and vhat wore the conditions of pro-d-Hing the lottort A. It vob attempted to express that thio decroo va£ the fora in which during tine of Var ouch an euthanasia progrtm could proporly be carried out aftor the war. at loa.t that wan the interpretation of nine at a lator stage aftor I hoard about conversations between Dr. Lannoro, Conti nad the Taehrer. At n later stage tho progran was to bo defined in another fora and continued. The roa.ons wore of forvor dooireo. tho reasons for pro-dating of that, q. I find thio a noot curious conception that euthanasia oonohow in peculiarly applicable in a ti-.o of war rathor than of poaco. A. It vaa r.oant to bo continuod in tino of poaco. I ®aid yootorday that before that it had apparently boon quite clear through tho discussion, on tho part of thn Ministry for tho Interior and Dr. iA-.ncre, and oven boforo tho Var a-roprlato preparation:* had boon nado. but at that tino. at tir.t nonont aooarontl7 theflo preparations had not reached such a otago of formtion and also apart fron this in 1935 Hitler appears to have said thr.t in tho introduction of such a Law and carrying out of such a euthanasia progmn. it was said by bin to bo r. good thing for the begin¬ ning of tho Var. He also added that he was quite clearly of tho opinion that in tho Var tho introduction of ay possible objections raised by tho Church would bo tho easiest, and as far as that is concerned tho datin/ and signing of this decree is in ay opinion to bo interpreted why it wn* signed on 1 Soptonbcr 1939. 2482 5 Court X q . you undented I an not argui:* vith you that thi. roallvas a ‘Sax uo-^oro. I Just thiak thoro is sorvj fundft-.onV’l disngro-^ont tetv0 c= u. a. to th. rowon. !« «. carried out during the «ar«l«. I an .ugj..tln* to you It »a. carried out during -.rtlno In order to •1 Inina to th. hind of .o-colled .orthlo.. H'«». to il r ho^ltnl. for 00 ..IM. woundod .oldlor., to rdre noro doctor, and nu«o. avallatlo for tfco caro of tho voundod soldlors, to ^ 2482 (ft) v 5 ?oly.a-5-2fy-PFP-M'*-o'^>J? Court I •lialnnto tho noce*ait7 for the care a-.d feeding of tboeo vorthloas lives. Iac't that tho reason that tho orogran wae initiated at tho beginning of tho 'far? u Regard lag tho quoatior. of food, tfcis oxprcaaion new used by un ■uaoloaa oatora*. lot no aay this to bogin with, if wo take into coneidemtion 60 aillion population for ainplc reasons of arithmetic, and then toko into 2483 5 Jan IiT-*S-5^>-BHWblo7 (IL) Court '.a. 1 oorai deration 60 million patients, and this work concerning thfa, then this means nothing further than the maintenance of these 60 nillion people, or 6 to 6 calories per head of the population per day, and I an sure this would not bo ^ decisive factor in the condition of the war, and another consideration if this had been decisive this certainty would not have remained stopped at a tine when the food situation beginning in 19U2 was infinitely core ooqxLlcated, and certainly wo would^have restarted the program, and it would not have been dropp -until the end of the war. I thiric these mat be decisive arguments speaking against the conception of the "useless eater" and gaining space for pa¬ tient*, and gaining medical offices nay have boon a consideration which was acre of an administrative nature* It is not, however, decisive 0 since this gaining of patients* space 'n amount of 60,030 bods did not play and would not have played an important part. During the war wo had up to a million wounded, apart from ordinarily sick pooplo, so that 60,0C0 would be a very small percentage of that. In fact tho gaining of a corresponding number of beds oould not be oxpoctod opart from tho firal gain of Just a few thousand. Since tho further arrival or accruing of insane persons T.-a a taking placo at a very rapid rate, such considerations as I havo Just described wore in any caso without any inter oat whatever to the medical tain concerned — to tho doctors con¬ cerned. Ho was only concerned with his patients, not v th ooonordcal, political or administrative considerations. Q. Woe it not also decided that those persons able to work should not be killed? A. The ability to work has nothing whatever to do with these euthanasia or not euthanasia* I pointed out yesterday the question •ontained a statement not concerned with the extent of the program but \in order to find an expression there. Just as it oan be in the case of a criminal person, a question of th© mental condition of the person him¬ self. We are r»t concerned with the process of the work of a few years — 2ij£U — 5 Jar. l»7-4*-$^Lt>-eaMfeloy (IL) Court Ho. 1 t’.iere. Q. Well, I taka it than that the questionnaires were filled out on those able to work as well as those unable to work. Is that right? A. We were not groomed with the question of subdividing then into people capable of work and people not capable of work. What is significant ia the reaction of the person to this treatment and the re¬ sulting s ta taient as to how and to what octant he is capable of work, how he can rx>rk and what he ia capable of doing, in order to form a pioture about cental activity and ability to ooncentretc* and I - 2U$ 5 ?cVK-?JC^&-lcv-»aloy-JP Court I la ordor to for= a picture of that and in order to find out to what oxtont tka uorsnn fcSnsolf can ho a possibility, soon fron that ooint of view. you fcrve told us ttet twice already. I wish :-u would pay closo attention to tho formulation of nw quostion, and answor it profcrably in m fcriof aonnor. Tou said that consideration of ability to work all ployed „ jrrt insofar as a diagnosis of tho patior.t's condition is concornod. I then, put tho question to you whether or not indlTiduols tbaKdid not fill out questioanairos wore fxun both tho. o able to wort and those unable to wort, and I as asking you for a -vos* or "no" answer'. A. Tho quostior. whothor aonoono is capablo of wort or not can bo -nswored with a •yos* or -no*. I can answer it "yoiT or "no", if you put it separately with the ™ napablo of wort and tho ono not capablo of wort. Korr Bmndt, you invo stated th-t there arc questions to bo answer od in tho questionnaire which concorn tho ability of tho non to wort, tho patient to wort. It baa to bo stated whether ho can wort and if so what ho dees. vow. you state that thnt quostion is not nut in thoro for tho purpose of ronoring fron possible outhunasia those -hlo to wort, vhilo applying euthanasia to thoso unable to work, A. I understand that. q. i then put tho quostion to you that quite noart fron tho content of tho questionnaire was not required that the questionnaires in tho asyluro bo coalotod and bo filled out on those oano persons in tho c.ylun whs wore ablo to wort -.8 well ns thoso unablo to wort. It is ninply a question upcnvMt patients did they co^loto questionnaires, and I hnro secured no answer. A. Upon persons who for at least 5 years had boon in the Institute.. Q» How w-s that again? A. Tho questionnaires wore filled in regarding patients who had boon in the Institute for at la*.t five years. And in reference to that it is possible that patients had questionnaires filled out about then who were perfectly capabl. of wort, patients likewise who in no way wore 5 Tob-Ip-S-lo-I'.oloJ'-J? Court I lnciaiod 1= tho pror«u 7. rocol.od to.tructionc -.0 ud questiomlroo to tho ««clo. coccornod ov.r7 .1« dot-Jl. r.bo« jntiosts .ho hr.d boon ir. th. IMtlWto. for « loo.t tlTO 70 a-ro or :aoro 9 2486 (a) 5 ?ob-JS-?JO&-?o-K«loj-JP Court i Yov, i think ve arc ateut to got the answer. You state then that questionnaires were completed then at least or. ono class of por3ons who had been in the asylum at least five years, and that quostionnairoo wore fillod out on such persons irresponsivo of ability to work? A. Yos. Q. veil, I trust you soe the importance of the question, because if la fact the requirement was that questionnaires bo 2567 5 Feb h7-&4l^-W-U&oy (IL) Court Ho. 1 filled out only on those persons who had been in the asylum for five years* and those who also were unable "la work then there -ight be a serious question as to whether or not really ability to work was not a very great and compelling consideration in the applicability of the program to insane persons. I don’t get a clear pioture of Just what you did to get this euthanasia pro gran in operation, and what y«- aid after it was functioning; would you go over that Jus - briefly now please; v.hat did you do to get the program under way and what did you do aftor it was functioning, briefly and concisely? A I had nothing to do with the putting into effect of the program. The carrying out of this program was headed by Kr. Bouhler. In fact during that period I eyself, with a few exceptions caused by different oircumotanoes, such as tho Fuelirer being in Borlin, I did not cono to Berlin aysoif Airing ail the years, and in 19U2 I was tied down in the Fuohrer 1 * Headquarters where I hod no deputy for tho carrying out of the program and preparations, and which wore nontionod oarri out by Bouhler in collaboration with Undents agency. I sysolf was prosent during Just a fo.: conferences hold by Bouhler but my function was to be able to inform the Fuehrer repeatedly fron the point of view of general medical considerations regarding ary special oausos, any special events which might occur in tho carrying out of the rogroa and in connection with which it might have appeared necessary to Bouhler to have the decision of the Fuehrer obtained. Apart from that it was ty task as designated earlier to authorise, together with Bouhler, the doctors’ selections for the program. On the chart, which is hanging behind mo, it is apparent in cy opinion Just how Bouhler, through the corresponding channels of orders, authorised the carrying out of the euthanasia program, and how from that the channels load off to tho agent concerned in the ministry of the interior. i$r function within the carrying out of that program was individual, not in any way in existence apart from the a thority, the authorisation which I have told you about. - 21*68 - 5 Fob U7-4WttA-5-lI>-aaloy (H) Court !k>. 1 Q ”*11, you hare spent considerable tine tolling us what you didr.it do. The only two things that I think 70U said that you did do were to assist 3 ouhlar in 00operation with Guertler in designating the doctors to perfora • - 2U33 a - 5 ?3b 47HMUA-^-2Mial©y I=z) Court 7o. 1 the euthanasia, pad pl»o g$ pctinr. es somethin-.: ia the nature of * • • * * * * * e liaison am tetveen the ^uehre? red Bouhlor cad the rest of the proijrra, Is that ri^htt .v T'-.-t w-s la fp^t =y pcturl fuactlor. ia that connection, vith one differerxe though, thpt I did not designate, I did not select the doctors. I .-eve then the authority, the selection pad desi.rne- tlon erne fron the Mnlster of the Xntorlor, ^ 243g 5 Jeb-K-GSS-’r- lc-;>loy (31) Zsjjt To. 1 \ I take It that although you and Bquhlcr were charged with the responsi dlity for this pro-ora, you ir. feet, do not rccept thnt responsibility her before this Tribunal? a ?or the carrying out of such, no, end I ni ht cnll youx a.tten- % tion to 3ouhler's letter to the Xinirter of Justice, Guertncr, in which he strtes quite clecriy he alone was responsible for the carrying out of the pro crm. I, nyself, could not h-ve been responsible for the carry in*: out of the pro.-rra since durin. the period this pro,jrre. wns running, durin tlie period of I 9 UI, I vra in rncti\c end novor in Berlin, with v.o exception of a. few days and wr.a working in an offico rv*y fro.: Berlin cr.d it vra never planned la this connection thnt I should be at the hord of the pro-rm, or it*i cexryin : out or that I should supervise it fror the point of view of_n nedicrl expert, I could not hrvo been in control because I was not «, psychiattic expert, but a surgeon, * Vo IT, now Horr Brandt, euthanasi- involves a considerable nodicrJ. problsa; how could e layc*n like Bouhler fortulnto r.ll theso piano to carry out the prolan, r rr.tY.tr elaborate structure? It aeons to no that poaaibly vou nust h^ve conferred with Bouhler and Jointly ronch- cd aono understanding of the nechanics of the pro rrea, the question¬ naire, the fora of the questionnaire, the places %fcors euthanasia was to be carried out and a. whole host of probleno which your ?uchror surely nust nave had sone interest in? a These natters which you have Just nentionod were principally dit- cussed botvoi-n Bouhl'r and Or. Linden’s dcprrtner.t, rnd not with oc; becruse firstly, I have no knowledge as to the nwiber and situations of these -sylur.c, end secondly, the interest, - perhaps that is not quite the ri ht word - should I say perhaps ny p rticipntion in the ratter va B co-ncctc-* with tcnerrl nodical problems, but not special redical jTOblcrtB, which the chief expert or ox-erts had dealt with and v«re dealin .with. I hr 4 said errIter thnt I bad not actually participated in the conferences dealing with those setters, end in 5 ?rt 7“ loy Co’irt "o. i fret the r.uthorixla of the nedicrl croer.ts too v.'j carried out hy Bouhler r-nf not hy ne. IrT PTSIDZT: “rl'-ucrl vill he in recess. (- recess v»e trleen.) 2“^0 n 5 Feb L7-d«IfcA~4-l-ttachca fccurt Bo. 1 THE ILJLSKlLi The Tribunal is egein in session. CROSS KI w >n'iUTIOH - Resumed EY Ifi. JfcH.JCY: Herr Erandt, before the reccos we uoro dealing with the question cf ysur responsibility in the operation of the Euthanasia program. 1 have und or steed your tcstla-'y to b«. to the eff-ot thrt if my criraos war© ccrsattcd ir. the operation cf Euthmeoir, then ycu were not rospon- siblt for th'.ec- crim-s _nd h-vo bo-n frlacly chrrjwd ir. tho indictment; • is th-t a correct conclusion? a I did ;ict ary whet ycu htvo srld Just new. i.cn?rdL'^ to .:y opinion, ry fcraul'.ticn was a different cne. I ahculd like to sa; thrt within this Euthanasia proeren, eriaes wv.ro excluded according to zy opinion end thrt cno hra to differentiate basically h s-er. tho lopal program rs d:find by the decree end ril cth-r setters which have happened in Lublin with stcrilizrticn end tho li-F-13, »W.oh has Act been nont.cncd y:t. kll those things hevw nothing rt ell to do with the Euthmraic progress and ero ir. no way or. the ocuo at died rnd human level ao nra defined by thn decree. t Kerr Frendt, I understand ycur difficulty ir. answering tho question. The purpose cf this question is, 1 -a asking ycu to assume thet crimes were ccaitt.d pursuant tc the operation cf Euthmcsic. It ia a question cf f ct whether such crimes wore cesnittvd, hut right new, I went you to assuac that, and I ra trying to dotcmir.a who can bo responsible fer tr.-s- cri es. 1 have understood your testimony ir. such p ucinr.cr that it ie-ds ac tc the ccnlusior. thrt if crimes wore committed; ycu assert ycu were net roopcnsiblc. Is that right? .% I did net learn that cri—s cerurred within the frsnewerk of that program. If crioes had occurred end I rssusu, thet - thon they only hr.v; occurred at the Euthanasia station itself, but th t too ia impossible since the prtients whe caae there cnly eisao through a number cf exp-rta whe passed an opinion cr. them. The purpose was that rdthin that progrra very person - and I arid thrt yesterday - that is every phyoiden hod tc act within his cwr. responsibility and all physicians had 2L91 5 Feb 4?-L-k'w6-l-^hen Csurt lo. 1 to eet Lviopcndcntly of one encth-r. If rnycno hrd ccjai-tei r criae cn thet stc.ticn, the person concerned would bo z.yi* 5 Feb U7w-&Jr-t-2ilc chen Court Ho. 1 responsible icr thet crii-e personally; because IT h« h»d ccaaittod such - crir.-. he eoxdttcd it contr-ry to the directives, which he nrc giv-n 'a e physidhA. 3 .ell, new, Herr Brendt, pc .*rc st getting rlcng very fc at with tile point. Let us cssu-.e thrt there w a no valid G«rsccn l'W pur- -attinj Zuthrarain end I suppose ycu r re not ijr.crar.t cf the fact that «\ number of Gcrscrn ocurts hrve ilrecdj sc held; I t;i: > it v*.ct you deny r.v.cnai'oility fer the cp-r.- lien, the functioning of the Euth/uicadr erorrru cr. th_ raauxpticn th.-t it crirunrl; y.\ rr ..o? r. S:v. execution - a not etrrivd cut ca & criainrl pre- j-.n. I yest-rdc: at Ud whet re-aons the physician hed fer hie canu,jpticn thr.t it > a r 1- '1 x. sure ad in r^kiiticr., during the -.ntiro ti jo tida prorr-x ..ra c-rrl-d ut, it w: a hmiled in such c nenner th-t uYcryeno had to o.vunc - if he prrticipcted i . the execution - t! t it vna r l-6'l pr-jr.-. Ir. *• letter fret Guentler t< Fcuhlcr, it i» arid thr.t there non he no l.;,'’- coqjlrinta. I s-v tria letter h.re cn paper, tut it Justifies .sy cpirdon th.-t :t my perit i cf tine wo, whe prrti- cipcted i. thrt pregrrm, considered it .-a .-naclutely lugd sc th.t tho • xccutio n cl t crime during ita execution crane t bo considered. * q .ell, y.rhrpa you would be willing to give ua tn cast, r to the question if vo exclude your responaijility; would ycu acy thrt if tho presrex n s cri.~r.rll: ccrri-.d cut thrt the docecaci Hcuhlcr could bo found rospciutiblc fer thr.t? « Thw entire vroprer., rnd I aist repeat thet, nr.a net consif'orod by Bcuhlcr; Beufcler ’ » of the cane cpidcr. as 1 was, njsoly, that tho Suthgncair. pro^r;i vra net crirdn'l. Certainly if he hed r.asunci thrt it wr.a crlnLnrl, he wculd net hrve p-rticipfted in it any xerc than anyone else. 2L92 5 ?eb - •- 7JC-7—1-”inabuck (3K) C 7o. 1 3ida*t you receive reports on the op^ption of the prormat a Vo reports were nrde ns far ns I know, rnd I therefore did not receive any reports. v I thought you stated that part of your responsibility, as B^rll n It was, was to report to the fuehrer about the operation of thie pro Tan. How could you report to the fuehrer If you didn’t receive any renorts or otherwise gain knowledge of »*r.t vra ;;oln' onT ^ A I hr/ these first discussions together with Bouhltr and tho ?uch- rf r. When you said report I thought you r.car.t a. writte’h surcarry and strtenent, and I then said that no such reports were erde. As far os directives wore concerned, all of then were £ven orally nn A a report, I understood n jrocrly report of soce report ..Ivon ct n certain period of tine about the results of the execution, and I wanted to say that such reports were not ar.de rccordir..* to ny opinion. I havon 1 1 rocoiv- cd rny, end f certainly haven’t seen any. * ‘/ell, how dotailed knowledge did you grin of the actual function- in.: of tho pro xan and ifcnt reports did you nrJco to the luohrort a With roferenco to the raanner of the exocution in the forr. of reports the Juohror was not infomed by u. Whenever any oxcoptionnl questions r.roso md whenever soeothinr inportnut croo up which Bouhlcr didn't want to docide on his own initiative, ho oither aporonchod Hitler hi ns o if personally or he ashed ao to report the natter to the Juehrer and- then Inf ore bin in turn. V‘ What wn:i the arturc of soue of these special probleas that Bouhler didn't want to trhe responsibility fort V e rd.-ht be interested in those. A ^or instance, there occurred the case of the children, children that w c .-c seven or ei-'ht years old rnd were to bo indudod.in this Eeich Conaittco natter or whether they wore not to be included, or tho question crao up whether they vert too old, and in individual cases such natters were reported. obot 5 7 mb -iWJJC-7-WTinrback (3S) Court ~o. 1 Vith reference to the euthanasia program there were administrative technical questions vhich partly were because of ^oznpleiniu- lettore and ones that started after Septeeber 19 ^, end then we* were also concerned witb letters that c*=e (rdz the church, it that tine I car-e into contret with rnator 3odenschwrcrler cad I talked about that yesterday, pnd these were the natters we were concerned with. A v In other words, you were sonethin.- in the nature of a trouble shooter, were you! 5 ?eb :-rJG-7-2-5i na tuck (21) Court To. 1 * That would 30 1 be correctly expressed is that way.. I was raked to eoncorr. nysolf with these difficulties without bein:,- a.ble to decide upon the rgrsclf. ^ You -or.t* mec the euthanasia of children. I take it that that or^-naixr.tlon, tho Reich Con-.ittee for research on severe heriditnry ( iecr.sea, was :art of the whole euthanasia picture re wet up after Eitlr’ o letter of 1 Seitesber '39; is that ri ht? A :'o, this Reich Coscittee hr.d already been or.rrnisod beforo. It was only up to the tlse of this decree it was not crlle\euthnna.oia but nerely n collection of these children.! aentioned ono caso of Lelpxlr yestordpy *.ich hnd nothinr to do with this Cosrdttec. < Veil, that would be the actual killin' of children did not start until nftor Eitler issued this letter of 1 Scptoabcr 1939, did it? A It did not take pines before October sinco only fror that uorsent on tho authorisation had b«-un; that is, frou tho tlao this wns si Tied. v And tho extermination of these children: that is, tho authority for doir- that, cone fror. this sree docuocnt of 1 Soptcnber 1939 addrcoo- cd to you nad to 5 ouhlcr, is that ri^ht? A Too. ifc 3ov, didn*t ycu help formulate the o.uoetlonnaircs which wore used in this >ro rnr.T I wns ire sent durin.- one conference where drafts of these oucstion- r.nir s were -resented. The drafts rod Questionnaires h*.d boon prepared by the ministry of the Interior rod we were concerned with tho question¬ naire in connection with the Reich Coir.ittec. ^he questionnaires ■ which wore .reparec for euthanasia propra , accor’’inc to py recollection, were ar.de without njr participation. They were prepared by the expert ih^sicir.ns w’-o ver* at the disposal of the Ministry of the Interior, if they hat not already been ready at the Ministry of the Interior before October. v l*ow, you knew Mr. Eeyde axe Hr. 3iotscho, didn’t you? A Yos. \ Ihey wore t..e so-called top experts for Questionnaires? 294 5 Tcb V-^JC-7-3-5iw*^cic (Bfl Courb "o. 1 A 5ot r.t once. At first It was EeydeEeyde, es fsr as X know, left either at the end of 19^0 or r.t the betfinnin.- of 19^1 ond his successor was iletsche. * Did you select thee or appoint then to their Job of expertis- In.; these questionnaires? A Ho. } Vho did that? ^ A I bellcvo that that wes done by tha Ministry of the Interior, but I on sure that at the end Bouhlcr did It, -ftcr he had r-a«Io the acquaint¬ ance of the .'.ymtlccer. of the Ministry of tho Interior. 1 Did you confer with Heydc and riotechc? A I re * -.her hrvlrv spoken to Eeyde on two or throe occasions at the Mlaco of 3 0 uhler. 1 think two or three othor physicians voro present and it r.ust have been at the he„-lnnin,< of the year of 19 1 #. ; Herr Brandt, whore was your offico located in Berlin? A I had office at the University clinic in 3orlin. i »et f Herr Brandt, you also had an offico in tho Belch Chancellery. didn't you! A In the putunn of 19*2 I instituted an offico there consisting of a telephone, one roon for n secretary, mi ono assistant, which I had there oftor I became Coucissloncr Ooncrnl. Before that tino I had no offico in the Eeich Ch-ncellcry. Vfhcrc was this office locatod with respect to *ouhlcr's office. V-s it the saro floor of the building .v It nay *ao that it was on the sacs floor. The Seich Chancellery va, a Irr-O -mildin^ mounting to three hundred esters of lcn.-th, md consista' of various win's and conr.ectin; corridors. There wrs no contact ~ith the offices of *ouhler fron the point of view of space, tho offices of Souhler were at a different wine. i Sow, Eorr Brandt. Just how far was your office in the Beich hanccllw-ry fro: the office occupied by Bcuhlert 5 ?■ -b-47-!:- 7 JC-7-in.-iuc* (=r) r - irt ;*o. 1 A It vrs ncccserry to dovn tvo fli-~hte of stair6, to co through one connecting corridor located rt tho penter of the bail&in.~ t then -o op or.c fli ht of strir6 rad to the other «i4e| then .-.•o rloa? n corridor for about sixty Seters 2U 95 e 5 f • V47-lv-?JC-7-4-»iafbock (SE) . Sturt Fo. 1 nad r.t the end of t tint corridor Bouhlcr* s offico vrs located, i Shut sound* to be about e sixty dnute trip; is it? a To, ccrteinly not. i Di Hcyde and Fictsdhe over these questionnaires tith you in the early stages of the pro.^rant A I cm not rcceober Tietschc having boon present. ?ho discussion of the Questionnaires for the Purpose of outhonnsin only stnrtod, accordin’ to oy opinion, vith reference to the questionnaire vhcre X the synptons of the disease were nentionod. Hoydo, I think, was present r.t t.^.t tine, but 1 don't think that the qui stionnnireo wore drafted r.t that tine. I think discussions took place after the questionnaires had been finished rad nrlntnfclo. Vith roforence to the contents rad th* foraulntlon of tho questionnaires, I was in no position to participate, this was carried out by the expert physicians theaselves. % Aro you villinr to svtax that Hcyde or lliotscho nevor vent over or.o of the so conpleted questionnaires and discussed thoir din-aosio vith you? I don't think that that has hrpoenod. * Vhnt ordors were issued by you and Bouhlcr concerning tho classes of persons upon whoa the ouestionnnlroo verc to be filled out or coir>lcted in the nsjnlunsl A If anythin.- was srid by ce duxir.: these discussions vherc I jartlcipate', it could only have beer, concernin': the fact that tho nodical res- -'nsibility had to play a decisive rolo rnd that tho physician had to be quite clear about the neasuros that ho took rad about tho nanner of his expert opinion that ho rave, and to bo rw.-re of the responsibility rf-.ich he took. I can sry that ronorrlly since even at other occasions vhnnever any such question arose, I rlvryB naintained that point of viev. Court So. I 5 ?eb 47-K-9-l-LJG--*Vtty (AJ) q. Eerr Brandt, you either didn't understand the question or in oay i J • event y :u did not answer it. I assure ou were not interested in having every so-called insane person in Gerreay fill out one of these nuistion- aalres. Certain clesses of ceoole vara not to be considered, isn't « that true7 . A. There were no erceotions with reference to the filling out of the questionnaire. Later on, of course, this chaged, but at^first the questionnaire vara filled out hr all the patients who vjre in thooo institutions, and then the certain prereoulsltes vara, taken lntc consid¬ eration with reference to the length ofstay in the snstitution and the progress of the desease. Q, Herr Brandt, suppose a ©arson had been comitted to an nsvlun for a period f one -.onth. v as it required that a Questionnaire bo filled out on such a person? A. If a ©arson was in the hospital institution for one mnth, I don't think it wne ncc.'Si are according to tv recollection to fill out such n auestlonnaire. It could have been filled out if it in refor- ence vo the disease itself such ao schlroohronia, epilepsy, and it w« provided that such patients should also fill out these questionnaires, but according to qy opinion, it was not absolutely nocesrar”. q. Veil, that is v»-.rt I an trying to get at. I should have supposed that there would be certrin obvious classes of persons «ho were exempt fron the program, rnd I should further think that ••m wouldn't bother y ;urself and so end the tine nd trouble in having oueotl'-nrairos cn- pleted on such persons; and I have nut the question to you rs to what orders were Issued concerning that problem. Do you kn-w or don't vou? A. Vitfc reference to the illness I g ve no directions, and I certainly issued no orders. he ou stionnairs were compiled according to the possible sv^tons. There are certain os-chiatric illneor-eo which i d not lead to such c oneeauences rs prralytica.1 diseases. In cnaeouenco the droert physicians listed the illnesses where the:* thought that the series c nseouences —~uld ccur aost frequently. 2497 Court So. 1 £ >eb 47-Ii-9-2-IJC rutty (AJ) Q, Harr 3renit, suppose yM had a non-Gernan Hntiond in rn insane rsylun for a period of thirty day*. E« had Just he-a com.itted or.d had been thtre thirty days. Did they fill out »• Questionnaire on thnt person cr not? «. The pr cedure of the filling rat of Questionnaire in reference to Gernnns or non-Gernans scde no difference at all. A ouestionnaire «po filled out in the sane wry for a non-Goman as for n Goman. ^It «rs not the nrinciole of natlon'lity hut it w e the principle of the illnnsB. Q, /ai right, I dvn't thinlc you hrva rnswurod t$o Question yet. Suoooso you had tvo oer* >na, one r Corora and '•no r non-Gorrvn who had boon in the nsylun for »• period if thint" d»y 8 . Did they fill out n Questionnaire on both euch oorBOna or one of then, and if s->, which -/no? •i. The Questionnaires were voiced uo n in the 1 are wry whether vo were concerned with a Qorann or a non-Oemnn. Q. I didn't ssfc you whether they vero worked on in the onn.r wny. I naked you If they wore filled ou*. Sow la your answer that they voro fille out? A. According to ay rocollection, they did not have to he flllod jut at thnt tine already, hut only at euch p oeriod when the patient had boon in the institution for a oerftod of five years. It deocndod on the length of tine he stayed *t the institution with reference to the question of filling or not filling out. Q. Herr 3rar.dt, I an not in the least hit of a hurry. I will keen you on this etand for three days if necesrry to got resoonses to ny auestions. I go b ck to ny hypothetical Question. Ve hrve two persons who have been ’n the p sylun for thirty days. One is p Gemrn and one is a non-Goman national. I ask you whether they filled out the ouesti'iv- ru-ires on those two persons. ... .according to ay opinion, they need not he filled out. They were only to he filled out if they had retained for mother f tit wears and eleven nothfcs in that iastituti n. Court So. I 5-^ < ”’-<>-9—e—LCS-Ptt? ty«*( Aj) Q, Vary wall. Your response is that thay weren't fillJ d Tut. Y u hr 70 testified that luthuuir yps no? arolied t' nonparr.an Hatlocals. Is that correct? Is that yw testi-tony} -il. % Q. By vfcoa were euch orders issued? A. *his vrs decreed by the 'uohrer eroretsly. Q. Did you get the order? ... Scuhler and I received It. ‘hat occurred rt the sire tine when thewar wounded were accepted. x Q. And to *hon did you rad Bouhler issue the orders? r o whon did yju oass it d-vn to? A. -ouhler cassed cn this :rder to his own agency which workod on the Questionnaires. The nuestlons of foreigners and wnr wounded wore donlt with within the ..gene:* T-4. The Questionnaires of 'ftr woundod and foreigners were not passed on for furthor working on so that a transfer if such patients could not take nlace. Q. Io vhon did you orss down this order? a. I didn't receive this order for -yself, but this ouestion wr>s reported to the fuehrer by Bouhler, and the fuehrer decidod that wf*r wounded owl foreigners wore to be accented. I think that vre evon before the ..goncy T-4 vrs instituted, and that neons that before any Questionnaires wore worked uoa, and I rn sure thnt it wps even before the tine when ridstionnaires had been oreoared because the designation of foreigners into Questionnaires can be deduced fron that cause. Q. Kell, you want to change ymr testin->ny and then say that ym did not receive the order that non-Ger-an Nationals were to be excluded, that that order v?* given only to 3ouhler, and that you did nothing with rosoect to such order? A. The execution of euthanasia and the execution of his orders and directives vis carried thrtugh Yy Bouhler in his own agency, rad it va.s r. t d'ne by ~.e. I never entered this *gency T-4, add I never CJuid issue an:* orders to ther.. 2499 Court I S Seb 47-K—9—4—LvC-Put ty-( AJ) Q- Sow J-J.tr erectly to vhon did Bcuhlar v«a down thlsorder that non-Gernan Satlondi we to to eveooted? 14 -hit order, according to ny opinion, he had to trot on to the agency which worked on that# oueetlonnalreo. I didn't atk Kr. Bcrikltr sMt It. I didn't* ask bln to Aon h# petted tklt order el nee ho received th t order very clearly, and I an are that he mted It on In the tace fora at he received It. I tr os laforaod ehofit the Interior itructure of thle agency, and I vat neither lnfcrned abo*t the nann or how thle adnlnistratlv* eooaratus worked in detail. I can • X only eay that Bouhler reallv did that elnce he, I an ture, evecuted ouch an ordor. Q. w ejl, you are attuning that he did; that It what you r.ean to eay. Isn't it? *. If Bouhler received en 'rder, he -.uit have executed it. Q. All you know It that he received the order? A. *ee, That he received the order. Q. "by. Herr Brandt, If thle nrogran v not to he aoolltd to non- Gerncn Xatlonrle were auettlonnalros euboltted on Son-Gerian Hatlonalt? A. I cm. not i ay anything about the tingle r eat one about that. If tocrjed ei.njler to have these ouestlonnriree filled out tr* theta institu¬ tion! with the order to ert out the non-Gerroans. Q. I haven't heard arthlng about any order to tort out non-Oornan Hatl nols. All I kn w it that the cu;etl onnr.Iro con taint a blank label "nationality.■ Are y*i now suggesting that orders went down to the etyluns that they were to tort out non-Canan B*tionals? A. So. The orocedure wrt reverted. The cuettlon -tf deciding uoon a foreigner or non-flreignar «at not left to the institution, but at the Central Stei on 1-4 the differentiation ws arde on the basis of th 06 ® Questionnaires, these foreigner- rnd n.n-f-Jt'gnert, war wounded, and with reference to these ouestl-anaires where we were concerned with war wounded and foreigners, we keot then there while the others ware distri¬ buted. 25CO - _.• J 5 Feb 47-X-9_5-LJG-Put ty-PM Court Ho. 1. caong the experts for further treatnent. In this rxmnor It Mis made lapoaslblo that during the later procedure the transfer of such a patient couldn*t be made possible to an observation or Euthanasia Institution. • 2501 5 F-b -Sy--10-1— Beard(sw) Court So. 1 Q. Herr Brandt, do you realise that the execution of non-German na¬ tionals in this so-called Euthanasia order would have beu not recall that Mennecke testified be¬ fore this Tribunal that he, hiasalf, expertized a rturtoer of no^man na- tioMla* ques tionraires ? A I & not r3Be=bar\hi3 to-tinony in detail, but it is quite poa- aible that he said it. If you are tel Ting that to =e now, if thinker- • flupua work had boon carried out in one or the other case, I an really not clear why it was not done because it was really superfluouSj but, it is possible, even if this expertising was carried out,^thon I an quite suro th*t a transfer of the pationts .was not carried out, and I an of the conviction that on the basis of this procedure such foreigners wore ex¬ cluded. I do not know with reference to what period Kennocke spoke, and when he roceived such questionnaires for expertising, but naturally 1 krcw such expertizing had no senso whatsoever. Q Well, I think your Attorney will agroo with the statenent that •tennecke testified concerning the period froa 19U0 to 19U-. How, Witnoss, you apparently wore nistakon whew, you said that those questionnaires by non-Goraan nationals wore not photostatedj and you apparently also wore mistaken when you stated that the questionnaires of non-Oonxm nationals wore not oxportiaed. Now, just exactly where was the safeguard in this program which made it inpossible for these non^oroan nationals to got transferred after those questionnaires had been expertised? A The safeguard could only hare been with the central agency in the T-h. It was not possible at any other a E ency as far as ny opinion goes. Fron there the order was issued that patients wore transferred through the office of Lind*; and on the other hand, the transport dir¬ ectives were given froa there, sc this information nust have boon ini¬ tiated fron T4i, aM there the separation between the Osman and non- Geman wac aado. Q 3 ut you, yourself, do not know exactly where that sorting out of non-Goraan nationals took place, do you? A », I dr not krwr whore it took place. It is qy conviction that 5 r-b.Ui-lC-A-iie ird-3Cr Court ho. 1 it could only h v. ta:.en place at the central ageaey because oily there did ttw ou -stlonrvxiros arrive with the designation •’foreign", and only there did they hsvw t. possibility to separate these questionnaires, Gtraana and • • no.a-Ge naans. And, th t ■ *os boforo the questionnaires w-re photostated; was If not, Herr Dr .ndt? A. According tc ay opinion tn t occurred before th. questionnaires were photostated. Th- judgment rad -xpj-tixing of those questionnaires was superfluous and foroi«{n-rs were to be excluded. x Q. If you do ;ot h.’.oe exactly wrwrv the G-mans aid non-Ceraan* sorted out, hcM c a /ou swear to this Tribunal that non-Gemans nationals Were not actually tnnsf-rr -d to a tuthnnasia, SttionT A. A guarant-e .;ich enables n. to cay th t is th* order which was given to Douhl-r v.rv cl. j v, and w.iic.i I ac quit, certain X executed. I think it is quite out of the que&ticn that when he r-ceived the ord.r to ex¬ clude foreign.rs that A- shnuld have t.u-. included. “. But, that is an aasuB*tlon on pour prt, Hut Brandt? Is that right? • A. I cannot r e t it in any other a-nner than 1 h v- Just »-id it. 2505 5 Fob Irf-^ATD-il-l-Blnklcy (FJC) Court I Q Now, Horr Brandt, vc have talked about those questionnaires and th. classes of persons about whoa they woro fillod out; and you have testified that it made no difforcnco whether a nan worked or not; that they filled out tho questionnaire on hin. You further said that it mado no difference whether he was a Gorman or a non-Goman; tluro was no dis¬ tinction made between tho two and quostionnairos woro fillod out under the sane circinstances for both classes of persons. Is that right? A I said that it was ny opinion that it was so. Q I want to show you nor Docunont ID-825. This is Prosecution Ex- * hibit 358. It appoars on pc go 216 of the English Document Book, Number lh, Part 2. Horr Brandt, I want you to turn to page 3 in that document whore it says up at tho top, "Instruction Leaflet." Do you find page 3 of tho original, Horr Brandt, where it says "Instruction Loaflot"? A Yoa. Yos, I havo found it. Q "Instruction Loaflot. Head carefully before filling out tho quostionnairos." A Yos. Q There was an instruction leaflet cont to tho asylums, ’.fas there not, advising then how to complete those quostionnairos? A Yos. Q And this instruction loaflot tells then upon which petionts tho quostionnairos aro to be completed, doosn't it? A Yes. Q Lot no road to you the first paragraph: "All pationts are to bo enumerated who ( 1 ) arc suffering from tho foil erring illness-s and cannot bo ocployod, or for mechanical work only, plucking or similar work, in tho institution." Notr, Horr Brandt, doosn't th:t instruction say quito clearly that those persons who suffer from tho illnesses enuonorntod but who can be enployod, who can work, aro not to bo enumerated or aro not to have quostionnairos filled out on than? 2506 5 Feb. A?^.7D-ll-2-31rkley Court Nr. 1 m I leek at it in the following tray. These persons had tc fill in the questionnaires when they tier* afflicted tdth those diseases and, reforrir.; t: Paragraph 2, when they had been in the institution for five years. Q Sow, Herr Brandt plot's net \ley with cno another. Ycu can road the German language; and 1 den't -.tent ycu tc sake a st' -aaent which is net true cn the face cf the document. New isn't it true that Parsrraph 1 and Parc roph 2 are mutually exclusive? Isn't there the word %:r" be¬ tween Paragraph 1 and Paragraph 2? A Yes. q *11 right, lot's forgot the answer ycu wore about tc give and divert our attention to Paragraph 1. Doesn't it state thcro thr.t quest¬ ionnaires ero tc tc filled cut only or. theso per sc ns whe have the enumer¬ ated illness os and who cannot bo employed, or fer mechanical work only, plucking and similar work? Isn't thr.t whet it ssys? A Yos, thet's whot it srjrs thorc. q Then ycur testimony wns quite incorrect thr.t employment or ability tc work ployed no pert in the euthanasia prefrra oxcopt insofar as it permittod a diagnosis cf the patient? Isn't that right Horr Brandt? The question cf cut : ut of work rs such is net listed because cf the offoct of the work tut is listed in order to Jud t - tho health of tho patient end condition cf tho patient. If a patient is in c situation where ho ccn work in an institution and work in factories, cs is scao- tincs tho case with p-ll-3-Blakloy (FJC) Court I can autcnatically state n priori that if porsons with thoso illnossos can work then there is no justification for putting than to death. Tho point scans to bo that if they arc afflicted with tho same illnesses and for on- reason or another cannot vorie, then you put thus to death; and I'n asking you ifHhen one of tho aost decisive considerations is not tho illness as listed in Paragraph 1 but tho ability of tho person to perforn work. A T ho ability work ocn only bo considered whan Court Sc. 1 5 Fob i,7-^ll-Ia-5E*-aiakley considering th^ condition cf the patient. It is quito absurd to think cf tho output. The output cf werk as such cakes nc difference at all. It plays nc part. Sven if it is productive, it is net decisive bocauso whatever a non can dc in such an institution is only saall errands. Q Uhat was it that ycu said wasn't important, tho output? k I said that it was net important, that tho out .ut cf work was Kt Important, and with that I understand tho calculable value cf tho work bocauso it plays no part whatscovcr incsauch as there wo only snail teaks being performed in such an institution. Tho output of work con only bo ccnaiderod when ycu consider tho ability tc m?rk which in % turn is tho ccrviiticn cf tho patient. Q Hew, H«rr 5randt, lot's turn bock tc the questionnaire itself, one page bock in tho document book. Do ycu find new at tho betton whoro it says -Kind cf Employment ••? k Yoa. Q Thoy apparently theught cutput was important for the diagnosis cf the insans person bccouso it reads -Kind wf Bsployaont, nest prcciso designation cf werk and cutput; for example, agricultural labor, Jeos net do a:eh, cr a locksnith, good specialist; no vague str.taacnts llko donostic work, but particular cncs, re on cleaning, and sc forth; also state always whether .mployed continuously, froquenU; , or only toapor- arily". Now, I think that they were very aich interested in knowing quito a lot about the ability cf this person tc porfern work, and I suggest tc you that they were int -rested n.t ftr reasons of -liagncsing the cenditicn :f the patient's nir.'’ cr the nature cf his illnoso, but to find cut his valuo as a useful werk tc the German war machine. For instance, a locksmith, geo." specialist, whe c;uld make bcob fuses or tho p-rts fer a V-l. Do ycu reject that suggestion? A Yos. I think it is cut „f the question that an insono person could be used for tho production of V-l's cr V-2«s. This ruforonce hero in =y opinion is in connection with a reference cn page 2, nunkor 3, where patients are listod whe were in these institutions ever since five years bufere. If a aan is in one such institution for five y-ars, it is under the circumstances 2509 5 Feb li7«ftll-2a-Sa —3laklay (IL) Court '*Ca 1 quite possible that he had even beer, there for longer, and it is possible the ho worked in such a factory and that this reference is concerned with his output of work and as such sh old be taken into consideration when judging the condition of the ran. • When it says hero, "waridng as a locksmith", etcetera, one would havo to investigate wl»t actually was produced in these locksmith*s •.forkahope of tha institution. It is single repair work which is being carried out there. Partly thr.y were used for therapeutical measures. Q Witness, what diagnostic >idgr.ont did you draw froq the fact that one patient who had sohisophronia for fivo years could havo a good output of alarm clocks while another pationt with the sano disease for tlio sano poriod of tiso could =ako wood carvings, wood . ‘-oppers for bottloa, with a reasonably good output, 'km, what diagnostic judgmont oon you draw from thoso two typothetioal oases? A None whotoeover. 7m Hissne:.?! Tho Tribunal will now rocoss until 130 o'clock. ( A recess was tokon until ’ 330 hours ) - 2510 5 7eb47-L'-MR- Court No. 1 CORRECTION 3 K 3 3 T V % Page 2511 io non-axist^nt. 5 Feb Z.7-A-ATO-12--1- Foster- sw Court Ho. 1 AFTERNOON SESSION TJ'i &.V&A:.. Th« iTibc-ai is again jV jejsio.-.. DR. SETDL: (Counsel for the Defendant Cfcerheuser): Ur. President, the Defendant Cberheuaer ddee not f 'el well and, therefore, she requests permission of the Tribunal to leave the court room at 1500 hours. THE PRESIDENT: In view of the physical condition of the Defendant Oberheuser, she cay be excused at 19W hours in accordance witft her request. X KARL BRANDT (Resumed). CROSS EXAMINATION (Continued). BY !!R. IfeHAlXYt Q. Herr Brandt, wa ware examining before the luncheon rocess the instructions on filling out the qaeetionaires and no saw iif paragraph 1 that no questio'rfiaires were to be filled out on those persons who wore capable of ecploy-i«it, isn't that correct? A. It was done in such a way that after the first paragraph — (Document book handed to witness) —yea, that is correct. C. Doesn't that seen to be a bit inconsistent with your slatwwnt that theso questionnaires rally constituted a registration of all insane patients? A. That does not r«-for to all mentally insane patients but only to those who fall within that framework. In =y opinion *-ven pati'.nts who were si« for short periods were not raportod so that a regiatratlon of all patients by means of thjse questionnaires was not possible anyway. that was what I had suggested to you this were filled out on those to euthanasia if they fell within the incurable, and as I recall you rejected that sutVstion of cinia.C'"/ A. I X dcn^t I have understood you correctly at the moment. The auestionnaires were filled in for the purpose in order to establish 251 2 5 Feb 47-A-ATO-12-l-Po3ter - sw Court No. 1 general baaical document a, in order to register all the patients who night be Bade available to euthanasia.’And within the group of porsons registered in this way, and whose registration took place on the basis of their physical condition, there were several exceptions; and in order to determine these 2512- A 5 Feb U7-.W.3U-12-2-FC 5 ter Court Ho. 1 exceptions certain info nation which exceeded those fields, which excoedod th> medical fields as, for exacpla, to their beins injured in the course of tho war, etcetera* Q Karr Brandt, since those persona who wero afflicted with schizophrenia epilepsy, and tho other iseases listed in paragraph 1 wero not reported on, that is, questionnaires wore not ocnplotod on such persons if they wore capabl of woric, I havo considerable difficulty in understanding why you Insisted that questionnaires on Hon-Gcrsan nationals be conploted, 7/hy woror.'t they also oxoaptod on tho sane ground that othjr persons wero exonptsd, Looauso of the ability to work? A In tho sane rospoot tho war invali ’.s woro not exempted olther and that had to bo registered separately. This certainly has nothin." to do with rogard to thoir transfer to a euthanasia institute. I tako it fron your question that you aro of the opinion that tho roforonco on this quostionneiro that Non- Gorr.nns are oonsidorod in this case was doeorvod to the fact in order to rocognizo a group of patients in such a way then, under tho circumstances, to havo then subjected to euthanasia* You have not expressod that but apparently your question is pointin. to that faot. I have previously stated in connoction with that tho the foreigners wore tc be excepted under all oircuostanoos. I only want to havo thoso references understood to the feffoot that they woro redo in ardor to bo ablo to determine thoso exceptions, that they wore not to bo subjootod t- euthanasia, and that they wore itot to bo subjected to outhanas porhape frr reasons of another 'Usoase. Q •'oil, Horr "raadt, you will concoed that tb< aoat offootivo way of soo- inr to it that Hcn-Goman nationals woro not included in tho prolan would havo been a simple crier that no questionnaires woro to bo filled on such persons, wouldn't you say so? A That depends what place you believe to have the most security. Ho doub* it can bo ar„uod and disputed if it could bo done this way or another way. P rhaps there is evon a third possibility that nirht have been use-1. If this proceedure was folluwod here in this forr., th:r. it certainly is in connoction 5 Fob. li7-«r^TD-12-3-Foster Court Jfo. r with a general re -istration about transferring th* tsnMl institutions, but certainly ®t with any ether intentions. Q Herr ~rar.it, by dropping down to paragraph 2 of the instructions, isn»t it true that the questions concernin', ability to work cane into play only when the jctlent had boon in an asylua for at loast five years7 A I only believe that this also hold in the diagnosis and Juioent bo- causo with reference to the kind of occupation the difference was made if the person could constantly work, frequently, or temporarily « In any cnee, it wasonly tho possibility of contacts which a subject rd~ht have to his sur- roun'inrs. And certainly those were not the sole roasons which led to tho Judgment f 'la ncsos, “ut they could only be ovnluatod in connection with tho ether statements which had been aide also. Court I 5 Fob U7-A - 13-1 - LX - Sorrow 5 . witness, I an sicply trying to sake cloar »ho was uxcluckid fraa tho program on the basis of ability to work, and wo see in paragraph 1 that ary one vho could bo eaplcyed was not reported on - did not have • a questionnaire filled out on hin. Then we drop down to paragraph 2 which says, "All patients aro to bo emigrated -to have boon in an institution constantly for at least five years" and it is on that category of patients that tho question of ability to work cases into ploy. If the patient had been in the asylxso for only three y-ars and, in tho Judgnont of the chief of the asyluc, could be craplcyed or could work, than no rusntionnaira was filed, dut if tho saao patient had been in tho asyltsa for rivo years or sort they hd to file a quostion- naire and then and only then did tho questions in tho quostionnicro concerning hility to work caw into play. Isn't that correct? a. Tho questionnaires havo to be uruorstood that way and then what I have Just said is correct. *. *11 right, that is sufficient. So wu exclude, undor paragraph 1, all of thoso who have not boon in anasylun for at least five years aid who are able to work. No quastionniaro is filed. Paragraph 2 - if they hva been in an osyluci for five years or core then a questionnaire nust be filed and tho questions in the qu.sticnnaire concerning ability to work are filled ir.. Mew then, cn tho questionnaire under the question! doaJing with -jnplcyrwnt and ability to work, is it not truo that thoso persons a could be •jojloyod in a skillful waploycont, skillful work, and who had a reasonable cutput wore excluded? nero ox. -pted frora euthanasia or oxenptod froa filling in the questionnaires? •i. Exempted freo euthanasia. « If such poopls wore acle to carry on sock special work within their respective irsti tut ions then this wus proof of the fact that their physical condition was probably not so bid that tney w c rc dis¬ integrated personalities. *515 5 F b L7-A-13—^-UG-Karrow -ST Cc.rt So. 1 Q. Very well. I think then that the picture cone3 a bit clearer that the ability to work was a very substantial consideration in the operation of this oregras and a great deal of weight •••as placed upon the question of ebiiity to work. Is that true? A . That dc ends on how Vou interpret the words "ability to work" and on what the nost emphasis is placed. The decisive point is that it nay b* usod as a reference, tog* th< r with other statements, if A the patient is psychologically or severely ill or if he i3 not severely ill but thon his work has nothing to do with the effect arising from the % work. That is, if the can plays a part in the war potential or not and in this case the statement coitalned In question 1 certainly does not have any connection but is only th'*re in order to serve as info mat ion - additional i''forcation as to the picture of the disease. Q. Lot's turn now to one of the other questions in the questionnaire nan'-ly that concerning race. Do you find that question? A. That is on Shoot 2. Q. The footnote is on Swot 2. The footnote reads, "Of Goman or Goman related blopd; of Goman extraction; Jew, partial Jew of Grade 1 or Grade 2; Negro, partial Negro; Gypsy, partial Gypsy; etc." Now, what was the point in having the race of the patient reported on? A. In ey ooinicn, that could have only been used for on evaluation In the statistics. I carnot see any other reason for it. Q. You can see that it was not needed by the expert in diagnosing the patient's cor*iltion and thus de-ensiling Aether or not euthanasia should be applied? A. That would have nothing whatever to do with it. I cannot rcnccbcr either, but I k-«w it has been discussed - that I have been asked c bout it - if Jews were exempted iron this program. I cannot reneeber if this has been the case. I would not k«ow in this case either as far as Reich Germans were concerned. 2516 5 Fwfc Z.7-A-13 -3-UG-Ka rro »- sir Court !*o. 1 Q. “5b 11 , I at not suggesting to you, Herr Brandt, that under any properly enacted law - valid law dealing with this sifcject or any other subject that Goman >-’ew8 should be excepted,but I put the question to you of what is the value of balding up anothor category of persons in theso questionnaires? T.-.at 13, distiijguiehing between a Je« and an Aryan? What possible pertinency dees the answer to that question have to tho deter¬ mination of whether euthanasia shall be applied? ^ A. In ay opinion, it does not have any special value whatsoever. I havo Just said that I a.- of the opinion that this was ohly a natter for the statistics. That it was not a creation, which on the basis of the statements, wa^li have had any influonco whatsoever. Q. Cf course, witness, you will concc-do that the question would have a great doal of portinonce if in fact euthanasia were boing used as a method of exterminating the Jews, wouldn't you? A. If that had been thn case, a certain basis would havo boon ostablinhod in this way. That is quite possible. However, Nogroos and Gypsies are stated here and also "of Goman and German related blood". I havo nothing to add to what I havo previously stated or nothing coma to ny knowledge that such statements would havo boon used for any other purpose than for statistics, nsido free tho fact that I do not know tho very cloco dotails of those questionnaires and, above all, tho enclo¬ sures with further explanation an 4 . instructions and I havo Just 3oon thorn through theso documents. I only know about tho references to what oxtont theso questlo'i-jftires might sorve to assure againr^--i*ieorrect diagnosis. Q. Witness, since you mentioned Gypsies, I think there is some reason to boliovo that the Goman Roioh indulged in some discrimination igainst Gypsies as well as Jews. So there again that category' of persons - .;ht possibly bo of interest to T-^ and other operators of tho euthan¬ asia program. A. I havo never known T-- in any other capacity than as an estab¬ lishment which was connected with euthanasia - on the basis of Decree 5 p-b 47-A-13—3—I-JG-Rarrow- STf Court Mo. 1 Q. ‘‘ow, Herr Brandt, let's go bade to the instruction leaflet and 1 ask you to look at paragraph 4 where it reads that ■ all patients ere to be enunerated 2pl7 5 Feb Harrow - sw Court So. 1 ■ho are not of Geiran nationality .or ar* «.ot of Genran or Canaan related blood, indicating the rece and nationality". You will recall, Herr Brant, that I put a hypothetical' question to you here, citing a patient cf Goraan nationality and a patient of non-Geraan nationality who had each pent one tenth in on asylun. You stated that no distinc¬ tion was made on the basis of nation lity. I now esk you - don't you* have to change your testimony in view of the feet that paragraph U explicitly requires that questionnaire bo cocpletod on any end all patents of non-Gcraan nationality? x A. I must correct myself in this fora. Ho..over, I would still llko to add th*t now as before I still mints In tho opinion thrt the timo of reporting those patients consist'd of fivo years and, in this respect, I ea also of the opinion that if tho questionnaires had to be fillod in by non-Co nanns that this probably served lor sooo sort of statistical computation whose origin I do not exactly know. I cannot soy why this was done. 251B PC f* 5 Feburar>*-A-DJG»lA-l-Lesser Court Ko. 1 Q uitnoss, - o understand thot you are insiting that no ncn-Gtrmns were exterminated pursuant tc the euthanasia program, but *e are now trying to investigate why it was, firstly, that questionnaires bed tc be filed on any non-German nationals^ and secondly, why questicnmires in fact had to be filed on all ncmf—Geraan nationals whether or not they fell in the foregoing 3 categories listed on this instruction sheet, which applied both to Germans and non-Geraans. A The reason, in ny opinion, can only lie in some st. tistical evaluate I do not knew cf any other reoson why this formula tio>j took place; it nay bo that as to other circumstances, tlso cn tha part of the .linistry cf the Int¬ erior, there was a certein interest, but I do not know. Q Lot us turn to the next page of the docuaont, Herr Brandt. Tho 5th paragraph, which reads: "In cases cf patients boing newly aijitted after the deadline date, questionnaires are to be filled out cs well end to bo sent to me collectively every year, on 1 February for the doadline date of 1 January and 1 August for tho deadline date of 1 July." Doesn't that para¬ graph otrte, in fact, that questionnaires were completed and sent in on pa¬ tients who had been in asylums for one nenth or loss? a Yes, fer subsequent reporting, yes. <* Tho questionnaire, however, w s completed cn tho basis of observotior made over a period cf or.e month or less in some c; sen, was it not? a If the patients '-.re not located in ether institutions before then tho quest-c-v. ires were then filled in with proper ref rentes and ieie sent to tho collecting pcint. 5 «nd tr.ercaJter expertized? A I do net consider this probable because after question 1 there is the reference as tc r.cw long the patient ha3 been sick and in a further question there- is a reference >ith regard to the condition of the patient. If these quest - ennrires were then passed on fer diagnoses, it cay be possible, but then the decisions cf the diegneses \culd have corresponded. Q 'feu have testified that 3 to i& of the persons transferred to an observation station after an affirmative decision on euthanasia by the top 2319 5 Febnu ry-A-DoG-lA-2-Lesser Court U-. 1 exports, were returned as ineligible and euthanasia was not applied — is that right? A /vs fr as I can recall, there vere U to 65. ^ Ho-- do you knew thin figure ao precisely? A Bouhler informed ne about it, that is to say, — yes, it u>s Bouhler- he info reed ae of the fact with the reasona which I also stated yesterday when I aentioned the subject. Q Does this not indicate a rather remarkable analytical and diagnostic dbility cn the part cf the experts, with only a two-p-ge cnicstionnaire to wo) on? A I also asked oyeelf thtt question at the tii4 but I was assurod thot a proper questionnaire would to filled in by a specialist physician and that a diagnosis would bo Bide by a specialist physician; furth.-rmoro, it was pointed cut chtt here the description was not sufficient for the synptons, ooiresponding differences could be aade. Q But you aade no personal investigation into this mstter yoursolf, did you? A I had beer, told that it was possible on the basis of this question¬ naire to obtain ccr-osponding Judgment of the condition of the 'patient. Q Does not this -can, in offset, that the great ua.lcrity of patients were assigned to death without ever having bocn seen by the experts who passed tho Judgment? A The experts thacselvos never saw tho patients. The experts thmselv- only roached the decisi n cn the basis of the questionnaires. Q And ycu seriously surest to this IribunLl that a psychiatrist can actually det< mine froe this short ''uesti'-nnr ire whether a person is incur¬ ably insane, is that right? a 7h t he was to get a total impression as to the ccnditicn of tho pati-r.t was assured to me ty the s/eci. list physicians who participated in this natter. „ftvr all, this was net the only diagnosis, for subsequently further nedicai exasinxtions took edece; in addition tc this, outside of cer- tain exceptions, they had been in an institution for a very long ti-e so thol 2p20 Ccu-v 8*^. ^ d dear picture cculd be obtained as to his condition. Q But the first and last placo -here a p- tient was actually in a pos¬ ition to be physically ax c slr.ed r.as in the observation stttion, wesn't it? A In the observation station ar.i also at the euthanasia st-.tlon, be¬ cause patients hove also been returned by euthanasia institutes. Q As you had vary accureto inforcaticn about the percentage returned from observetion stations, suppose you tell us tfco percentage thfft was re¬ turned free euthanasia stations? a The number AX to 6 1 ccn be applied, as far as 1 cin reaeebor, to both institutes, to th«. outnanasia institutions as well as to the observing institutions, although I c.nnot say if this ►as in every c«-»e AX to 6%, or a total of AX to 6X. Q '..hat instructions wore issued to those observation stations anl euth¬ anasia stations tbout their right to over-ride the affirmative decision cf the exports? A Nobody was ordered to errry out uthancsir. if he did net agree with the findings and in observing institutes no outhamaio wrs carried out rt nil. Q But you do not knew cf cny precise ins’ rurtiens that wero issued to tho cboerv'-ticn stations and the outhuioaiA stations con coming their right to cv.r-fido th- opinion cf the expert in Berlin? A It was never a question at any place. Tho ordering of the doctors did not take place under tho condition that they had to comply with the diseacais but it »-s always doter..in-d in the opinion or the phyeicirn; S thojo also tho experts did not hav- to ugreo ir. their di'-er-osis. Q How long did t patient r-*t.' in the observation station? A That v ri-d, in ay opinion. Ihe tine cc.ld consist of several months; sometimes, es I have s«o» fres the files here, it .xy have been from A to 6 or 6 weeks. Q '..ell, your opinion was to tnrt off ct. Bo ycu actually Kft'Cto approxi¬ mately hew long these people remained in the cbs«rvticn station? A I cannot st;te exactly how leng they rtx- intd there. 2^21 5 Fabrua:y-A-DJG-I4w.-Les3er Court Ho. 1 Q Hew big were the observ. ticn st. tiona? A I cannot t»U you that. Aa far as I knew, tiny ~cru whole institu- tiona which had b-.cn oatcbliahod end furnished as observing institutions. I hevo pwvcr soon ray of thca. Q You don't know how nany doctora they had per nuatur of patients in _ • thu observation station? ^ A No, I cannot tell you that. Q You don't know anything about their tj.ining cr haw'jxpcrt they wuro? A Those things v.«rc handled only by Bcuhltr together with the i&niatry of the Interior. Uy opinion ia th. t r.c doelt rith Buitrl institutions which in thia caso woro unifornly established »a observing institutes and where partial transports «vi larger trenanorta weic then sent to euthanasia in- etitutoa. Q ’..hat precautions did you taka that proper ex.-ainatiena would be con¬ ducted it the observe tior. stations? A 'dll you plonso repvat your queatic*. or.co sore? Q Wist precaution* did you Uke that prop nr extinctions would bo conducted at the euthanasia stations? A I ayaelf hevo not issued rny astsurcs ot all. G And you do not know by your own observation th*t Boulilcr or cnyono else took ~ny precautions, dc you? A I *r. of the opinion that these positions wore occupied by specialist physicians end that those specialist physicians had been instructed no to the activity and their responsibility which *»s connected with it. Q Can you nno any of those experts at thu obsox-v:.ticn stations? A I cannot give you any wies cf these physicians. G Td.tn.ss, you appreciate the i_pcrtance cf thu issue of the annner in which thic euthanasia pragma was conducted, do you n.*t? A Y-s, I knew exactly. Q And ycu appreciate that the- only opportunity for personal otanincticn by n doctor cr. the scene was st the observation st: ticn? 2522 5 Fcbruiry-A-00G-lA-5-Lea»«r Court So. 1 1 Yes, certainly. Q Wasn't it part cf your duty and responsibility tc «*u v-ry auro thst the proper type of cx-sdnctiai was conducted on these patiuits who were b«ing put to doethf A Tvt coxt’-inly was not J task. In order to carry cut this task I first of all would havu h-d to personally visit th-ao institutes -md then I tlao would have had to obtain specialist training, neither o'* which was pro- Tided for so. J was neither able to pu-sonclly visit th« institutes nor di % I have any specialist control or supervision. 5 February 47-A-A1t>-i&-l-Mechr.n Court So. 1 G. T 1 '.a, ^ was going to put that to you. Nc:r, on the basia of the nunb'r of visits you made to the observation stations, which you admitted was none, are you in a position to tell the Tribunal anything? A. I never visited any observing institutions. Q. Yes, that is shat I say, therefore, you cannot swear to this Tribunal about the manner in which the examinations were carried out there; can you? ^ A. I can only say that I am of the conviction that they wore run in a professional manner. Q. Can you tell us anything about your observations at the Eutha¬ nasia s’ation? A. I have visited one institution, that was at Grofcneck. At the beginning of the yo-r or during the first half of the year 1940 I visited it. Few Patients were located there there were approximately thirty patients there and I saw the patients. Then I visited the adminis¬ trative office, which '•s established as a registration office. It wus then discussed further how the question of *he formal written correspon¬ dence program should function after the Euthanasia was perform«xi. That is the only time I saw such an institution. Q. Has there any one killed? A. Ko. G. Do you know how these patients were killed in the Bithanasia Station? A. They were killed by carbon monoxide. Q. Co you know what was done with their bodies? A. The corps® were then cremated. Q. You saw the pictures of the Hadamrr Institute in this Tribunal; did you observe the disinterment of large numbers of bodies from the general grave? A. Yps, I have seen that. Q. You spoke of the humane way in tfileh these peoplo were put to death; I cannot say that you ere in a position to testify :oncerning 2524 5 Fet /.7-A-ATD-l5-l-4fe*han ( belles) Court Ho. 1 5 Fob. U7-w.A7T-l5-2-ifce&m Ccurt ?»o. 1 q I said I think you arc urahla to testify about the humar-c-waanner in Khieh those people wars put to death) isn't that true? A I believe a bij difference ms*, bo aada bjtweon the pictures of Hadanar and between the Euthanasia Institutes, for example at Orafenook. Hadamnr with the oorpsos, who had not been credited. cortein3y has nothin#: to do with tho performance of Euthanasia, which was known until the end of 19U3 A azvi I say that for the reason that at Hadoxar the corpses were not crcoatod, while tho oerpsas, who were accuralated in connection with the Euthanasia X program, were cremated* q Is it your opinion that the Euthanasia stations wero operated in the host possifclo nannor? A I an of tho cpinion that they woro ©onluctod in tho best manner, yos. Q lou spoko «f relieving thoso patients from rra't^ln and sufforingj do you thiric all those patients wanted to diet A That is a question which I cannot answer in this form, I raa of tho oc:iviotlon that tho patient* ttd not havo a cl oar concept of their actual condition because they were insane and arson; then wero cortalnly oasos, which in oxcosa of that, certainly woro suffer!» • It Is quito possiblo that a lumn boiir;, who cd ht bo doscribel by tho sicplo word "cra*y«, ndf.ht under circumstances mt evon roallxo the difference botwocn lifo aj d death. In this fora, you cannot OTen include such people as to tho question if they want to 'Ho or if they da «at want to die* Q I think that you will concede that possibly a substantial number cf thoso victim were fully aware of what was happjninr V themj won't you? A I -to not think sc. If I ip back and r»fcehaR Crurt to, 1 A Such patients, feeble drxiod of cairse tc a severe degree and also certain foma cf senility could also bo included in this frcup., Q Did ycu employ a can by the rvu» of Fritz Blelch? A notch c'xo into =y office n 19U2 or 19L3 . q What did ho do? A Ho workei for no in the regLstreiion office, Q Registration of docuaonts, nail and the like? *■ A The registration of r b Roral nail uittera, Fur the mo ro in 19UU when ny office was novod troa >rlin, he got tho anil and brought tho mil back to the dty e q Which offico waa Frits working in? A Ho workod in ay office* q Fritz Dleich? A les. Q Tou have stated that you had two offices in "orlin; one in tho Univoh- sity Clinic end one in th> Fuchror*s Chancellery, I oak you whothor or not Fritz Bloioh werkod in your offico ot tho F»Mhror ! 8 Chancellery? A I did not have W offico 1-. t!» FuobrcSa Chuncollaty. I had ny offico in tho Roich Chancollaiy and in tho Utica Cncncollory waa located tho Chancellery of the Fuehrer, tho KLnfetry of Lojaraurs and ’(cleaner and tharo were still sovorol othor office q i an sorry, I aide a rdstake, I neant tho Reich Chancellery "horo ycu did have an office, Waa Fritz Dleich working in that offico? A to, Frit* Dleich did not woric in tkrtt office. office there oon- siatod of three roeaa, ono bed the telephone agency, one contained tho secretary and ny collaborators, rieich cane tho re senowh-t later on and it nay have been as late as 19U3. q Ho*-, I an aaklnr you whether Frits JUeich physically worked in your office ir. tho Reich Chancellory or your office in the University Clinic? A to, he did a=t work at tho University Clinic, Q And ha waa a clerk in the Reich Chancellory? 252o 5 Fab. Court So. 1 A Ha was aaplcyed by ne in =y office in the Heich Chancellory. Q Herr 3ran.lt, who wsuli know core about the operation of the Euthanasi; prograaj you or Frits Bleich? A I believe that horpaje Frits Fleich nay have sore informtion about % lt r Q lour cloric is better info mod on those natters than you arj> A In this case, it nay perhaps bo possible* a Q If you consider the Euthanasia pro-;ran to bo in the interests of tho patient and not for fiscal par-poses, why wero veterans ff tho first World War and thoso injured in tho course of iirsts trial labor exraot frou taAa proerwa? A This question is in the fiold where I ha rc to say Is basically not corroot, Accor tin* to the ©inlitlotui and chc sufferfi* of tnoso pooplo- it is cot ri^ht to aako thcoo exceptions. however, other considerations wore dodslvo in this caso, in ardor to have those exceptions nade« Thera was tho consideration that boc-.uro of tho war and also because of vho co;scription of labor, tho nontality cf tho people tcna.Vs such ;uostions would bo difforont than in casae whoro only purs insanity is ecncvrnad, an! bcoav.ro of thoso considerations, tho oxcjptior of tho wav end the pooplo injured In Industri?l labor and tho aotual point of view fro- which tho thought of Euthanasia originate!, it would not have been correct to nako those axooptloiv 5 Feb. uT-A-uTD-lS-l-l&lcy Court *fa. 1 0 Tcu hi Vo testified that the euthanasia program would have ro proper relationship to concentration eenps, is that correct? A lee, fl '.fhy is that so, weren't there insane persons in concentration carps? A I an of the opinion that there were no insane persona in tie concen¬ tration canpco Q Upon what do you base the opinion, did you cake any InvoatiRation to find out? A ffc, I did not. However, I rain to in the natural pdint of view that scraebody who ccnes into a concentration canj becauso of a political or othor crino, would have no correction with a nental disease, 0 Hut you didn't inquire os to whathjr there woro any insane persons in concentration ensps when this pro.Tan started, did you? A too Q I«.u heard the toetliicny of the witness Vonocko about his visits to concentration carps, what say ycu about that? A Kenocko has testified that this ox-nination, - I Vo not even want to call it in oxaaination, was a nodical wrljthot he had the inprosslon it was a purely political racial ratter with whi'-i ho had occupiod hinsolf in th« case, Q But Harr Brandt, Dr- Mcneci.o was ono of the operating experts undor T-h In Berlin* A The propria is I personally passed the -aateria.'. in 19kl, and it was halted in August of that yev« I not know that after the prolan wa3 hilto- that euthanasia was performed in one place or another on a getor scale. It is not clear to ae either freu what office or froc what possibilities Dr, Vine eke nade his exardnatlons or was able tc carry out his exard nations in th< nuchenwald Concentration Cnap. It certainly is not possiblo that it started with 7-Aj, bocauso frea all that has beer. 3hewn hero th:t what took place in the concentration caeps was the sole responsi’.ility and was subject to the sole docisicr. of Hlnnler. Tron the files ocncernlr -3 the subject it was stem that Kerr Monocko received orders free his clerks in oirav-ction with the 5 P«*. U 7-A-A ZD-16-2-Jiiioy Court So. 1 Inspectorate for the concentration canps. Q How, Herr Brandt, you are a nan of intelligence out of tho or Unary, and I aa sura you rtceaber Honeeke*s tostlmory qiito vividly. He was oallod to Berlin in January 191 j 0, glvon instructions about what he was to do in connection with tho opera ticn of euthanasia. In the suaeor of 19U0 ho was instructed by perhaps the defendant Brack, who issued instructions to him on at least one occasion he testified, or Heppelnanr., or one of fcfio other pcoplo nentioned on the chart consornirv; the euthanasia pror'ran, Ho wrjj ordered by the* to concontration cacpe awl to nako excadnatiuns, 'end he testifiod chat ho visited a nuaber of concentration caaps frees tho aumor of 19lj0 until January 19U2, so these visits woro otartud quito early in tho program, and wore carried out oven nftur you say tho pro-ran had on-led in August of 191*1, Munecke was wot a concontration amp nan. Ho os not un-ar the direction or orders of 01sucks, Pohl or Hu color. Ho wca a rum worldn- in tho pro,-ran wldch you assistod in setting up, and '•ettin- into operation* A I can only say tho sano thing again on tho subject, I theu -ht that within tho concentration cacps there wero no nontuUy insane persons and I have never heard or discovered that such e\c dilations ha 1 boon carriod out in the concentration canps, and I have not biarn aw/tidi*- about tbo fact that after tho susnar of 19id outhanasia ras still bciw: continued by sono other agendas. Of ocurse I have not taard aiythuv; in this respect from tho con¬ centration canps. I a* also of the opinion that'tho fact that Monocko has been sent to canps by order of T-Ji, that such a .decision would not bo undo either by T-h, without Himler sotting it up such seasuros could not bo carriod out in ary carsp. Q According to the tosti-oory which Keneoks has -iren here about the exocirations in 1911 and the te-innin- of 1912, it certainly tad ncthia* to dc with the euthanasia prepran, as it ta! beer, da tend nod with Wi or either in tho fiold concerned. ?fcw, Witness, I lon^t wish t arfuo with you a’xsut it, . but it is quito obvious it did have scoathing to to with T-li, and }fenccke»a testimony vas to the fact thet Brack hinsolf tad ordered hin to jo to the cany, new, thero is no dispute that the concentration oaaps were also in the progress 2^29 5 Fab. h ?-A-»ID-16-3-i4aloy Court'So* 1 and they had to cooperate and they did so, and I also will not argue with you about the oode nane, 1U F 13* The witness Ifenecka hinsalf did not know that code case, but how do you explain the fact that these concentration oaap operations could be carried out by personn.a of the eu hanasia pro.’ran and they could be oxturninated in an Euthanasia Institute like ~>ernburf’ without your knowledge* '»ltneis? A I cannot give you any expC .-aticn to this question, I canno^ say because it is not dear to no in what e-innor and by wnat orcceiuro TWj parti¬ cipated and in what way the connection w-is establish*; l. I erfr. o.»ly say X did not find out any thing about it, and in addition I want to stato if I had found cut arythln, about it I would havo tono anything in order to stop such Eioasurwe whioh later on def’eOr.’At.id into Just a jdain forn of oxtorrination, % with all possibilities available » nc. Li cy opinion it had nothing to do with tho concept of suttamsla, uvd I cannot possibly axplain it, - first of all how this oontnet wna estab.isho 1 , and it is not clear to no with whom tjho criers for such aeasureo were .sauo i« 1 What waa the oxplanat.on you gave on direct ax-.sdnation about tho • lli F 13 order being sent onjr to concentre uion ocaps in Bavaria and Thuringia’; A I havo stated here :hat ry attention vas drawn to the fact that the reference nurfcor 1U F 13 .n connection with what tforecko has tostifiod at one tioo, is concerning the istrict of Bavaria and than Hess and all Thurlnrin, and sono docurvjr.t state* that sose poople woro sent fren the concentnti in oanp to the Ducherwali c cap in this aotdon, — I think it was 3uchonwald, and fron there they wore ircnsforred to r-ernburg, so that I an of tho opinion that perhaps within «rtain areas under tho leich Def.jnse Cxsdssioners, are perhaps by ojjdsr c: HLanler, and in collaboration with Kinder; because they listened to those eaanda theic results w^re carried out in this way. This is an assunption n 1 perhaps a way to roach clarification on this point, I * canr/»t say anythin in addition about this subject, Q Ycu t«f\ified the progran was stopped in Au aist 19U1 duo to the re¬ sistance of the church and press; is it true ycu got the order for the dis¬ c'r.ttnuance :f the progran fron Hitler? 2530 5 Fob, 17 -A-^7T?-l6-ii-4feilcy Court So, 1 Q And then you passed it on to -ouhlerl A Tea, I passed it cn to 3och* r by telephone. Q Wlgr is it the cessation order was ?ivon to you since your teJtinony hero indicates yru had so ^little responsibility in connaction with tho prorram A I was situated in tho Fuhrar headquarters, and I reooi’'©d tho ordor fpoo thera beoabse I was together with Hitler, * Q But the operation of tho children-a euthanasia continued ur.til A It was oarriei on until tha fall cf MW., or tho late turner of 19U*. 2531 5 Feb-..-JP-17-l-Ninabuck Ccurt No. I Q. Why was th: cfistincti.n drawn betv-^n the twe typos of cuth.-nr.8ia7 “• Bocauao in the question of thy children we wanted ta avoid and prevent the fact, also because of difficulties nith th-ir families and so on, th’t this ob.uld develop furth-r. uc wanted to kill and put an end to theso dofor-dti-s - a seen n possible after they had been b-rn. Q- Now, I uw'orstacd you ary yn diroct oxasdnsti n that y>u c ntinuod in sene association with euthanasia uhtdl 19U2; is thit ccrroct? X ... Until 19U2, ne. Euthanasia was disc nti..u_d in tho summer cf 191*1. • i Q. «nd y ur testin-.ny is th* t yau had nthin,, f urther tc do with outhanasir. ~fteT ..ugust 19fil? ... That is s a.thing different. I have at ted tht in the year 1912 I roslgn-d th- -uth rity which I had bo-n „ivnn by tho special decree. That ryfors t-. the at nty with regard to the children *.f the Reich Ccmaittqo. Q. toll, that's what 1 wns trying t. t et straight* Now, pr-cisely wton did y.u resign thy authj-ity which y u r-ccived n 1 soptoaber 1939? • U I resigned this auth.rity in tho spring of 1912 Q. Well, y.u sh:uld bo abl- th-n to give us acua infernvati n ab ut what happened t, the p-rs-nnol in T-l* anJ in -t.-r parts ;f the euthanasia program? A. I canu.t o~y that. Q. Tou said QUeSti.nnairos c ntinued t bo Sent in and evaluated after ..ugust 19Ulj is that correct? ... Yos, certainly th. questionnaires c ntinued t- bo w. rk-d on b.cnuso this material was pnasod ».n t oithanasia institute. In this c.as- it w uld bo 191*1. Q. Did thyy c ntinuc t yxperti*-- th- qu-sti nnaires? ... I assume that perhaps tn.y c ntinu-d t handle th_m, but I cannct say it with Cert"inty. Q. In ether words, th-y c.ntinu-. t. < eVerytilng except oXyCuU. the patients, is that right? ... That ~ay have been tho case during the first tict trv.ro, yos. *5 Isn't this an thy r -tiu of th so absurdities? Why ware thuy going • ' * *1 • u “' 2532 > < 5 Feb-.'.-JF-17-2-Hinabuck Court rio. I through ell t,h_Bv. useless notions whonthe German Ruich * p.b in such .rising need of doctors and other medical personnel? 1 boliovo that the titter of the diagnosis were elso di8c_ntinuud, and only that for the time being a diagnosis was givon because th«so ques¬ tionnaires rcr_ still arriving and f r tfco tl. o being tho personnel was still available and th-y w.re occupied with rg-nisati-nal matters. .ji office had boon established and wo wanted to r-strrin fr a dissolving it c .apletoly for the tiev. being. That was the only Teas n. Q. roll, d>-s itsoet a bit s.ns.ldss Uc ntinuo t- file these ques¬ tionnaires in vi.v ol tho fact th“t it c uld n. molly be cxpoctocl that thou¬ sands of these patients » uld prcb.’.bly dio be. -re the end ef th- v.ar frou nature 1 causes or they night recover and be with ut — U, Th-t w uld have been senseless in p*xt t. c.ntinuo with the so questionnaires. 1 d net cv w n len-w if these qu-sticnnaircs were completely disc 'ntinued. I co.iUKt s»y that. Q. 'bro yeu familiar with the fact th't tho Gem on Gc.v_rno.nt was indulging in repressive ooasures against Jews? % Lm ..t the ti ac I did net know anything nb ut those noosuros in the f arm as I knjw of thoa today. I did not kn~w any acre than shot could be seen generally; that certain groups of Jaws woro first of ail given r certain dis¬ tinguishing "rk and th^t later _n it oocomo gcn-roly clear th*t t'ney had boon settled in ceitnin ar-.as. Outside this I did net kn-w anything. Q. Y u did n.t kn. w that J_ws tor. bein systematically oxt.nlaated? A. Mo, I did n t kn .w th t. Q. Do y u n w admit th t they were, in fact, systematic ally murdered.? Nc, I die n_t know it. Q. I osi asking ycu if y_u n w k.i f sea- sixty thousand (fcraena, using your i wn figures, in -uthanasia prograa was c-oumon knowledge in Oewany as the proof in this caa- has sham, while a man in your high pcsitl.n did r. t knu that Jews metering in sev^n figures w>ro being executed? A. I do n.t bcliovo tnat a nuru-r ci SwV.n figures was g.n-r-lly known in Germany. v Q. Kell, will you nako an aejission ab ut something loss than seven figures? Lm Bo, I do n.t want t de that either, but I * nly want t p-int out in this way that the meber as such is n t t’w -cisive fact r bociusc if sixty thousand insan- purs ns w.rc kn-wn, tn-n, -1 c urs_, the seven fi^uro nuubor of the Jows w uld _ st certainly h-v- be~n jon-rliy kn wn, tut this has n:t bo-n th. cas— The fact th'.t euthanasia boccno piblic — that 0*\n bo tracod back t the oppesitien by th. church no! tho fact that the church dlacussod the so questions, and th.ro fere it b«cauo kn wn mere c-ncretoly with regard te tho Jews. I have net heard anythin*. Ilk- it. I nn c.nvincod that the maaber of th.se wb had nwv«r heard of It ;r did n t kn w anything ab ut It within the Roich will oo cn.r.j us, cert-inly within tho Reich. Q. I tak- it fr. d y ur st-tom-nt that th- r--s n f r that is that thoro was n opposition t. the Jewish oxt-rainatxon? A. It just was net known. Q» Horr Brandt, did ycu issu- errors 'iroctly r indirectly t- thi Patients Transport Corp ration for t. - tr-nsfer .1 innatos? A. Vo, I did rut issue any such rcers. Q. Is th- nreu £lankcnbur s familiar y.u? A. Blank.n'ourg, y-s. Q. Did. y u $iv_ Blankcnburg orders directly r indirectly for th- trans¬ fer of imates of insane asylios t. euthanasia stati.ns such as Graf-neck, Eadaaar, Kartheia, Bemburg? 2534 5 Feb-..-JP-17-&-# ins buck C urt He. I Ko, I did n-t give hia any such erders. Q. After the ..uthanasi* pragma aU-r,odly cane tc % st’p in 19lil did you «Tor issue .rders ciructly or i..'Aroctly t- civ. cf the euthanasia stations that imates of insane asyluas sh:uld b_ tr-neforred t. thes- st.-ti. ns? -• Wo* A Q. I would like t. put to y.u D cu^nt VO-892. m. heHAKE?t If the Tribunal He as-, it difcht be ap^r-priato tc tr.ko the afternoon rocoss at this ti e until she c~n leC'to the cadiibit. TH3 Pd£Sir»iyr* The Tribunal will oo :t recess fra fow minutes. (.1 rocoss was takon.) 2535 ?--= 1. it r -in Si. : -*ntou. V.qv It ?loaso YMir Honors, D-Xcnd/.o. Jburheusor is absent this ir t-ruo»»» h-.. lrv b.ue o/.rueod by tho TrJbunrl earlier todey 772 PHESiTYCf: Xte .-bs^ntc of »'.o >f:vl j . v:i* :,.• .‘or tho record. ob*erc® parsona' .o . zouso. 2Y XS. hcIUSSl. 'V Herr 3-tn.it. i .u-1 to yai to jn-i D^uu.m ;/. S-.r^ imndt, this is a loiter on the luivorheao of »..o Con -.il S-i er.es VTnnr.crt o-'rp-.mlloa % dated Berlin, ?0 July I$ 4 j • »ae Ow^to.Ioi :tdau.r f-tr dnburs/ icon. it roods as ■In the cours- of the owountioa >f : .•sti'.vicns sir.unt.ji. ii tno H>rtorn ter.itory of Gera* y opdoftfe . t? ai I order trjnf •«:» of iusr.no persons to your Jai'.tntl>.a «_o. t i ey onlor 'i ?.*cfob%or .u.ndt, t‘»u Co-jaiisioncr-O'.Cit/u or for Kod>.fJ ud H:w.a f v:\icos ■you will tho «?©<£ of yuly, l^UJ, >:.j hcnirod f \f cy Ii.sr.m '/soon fr•’« ;• hc-ieio/; «. rwtura to their oi/i:s.. «n.tlM\t«cu. ’In rll —.tiers cf bills ed equate nr o-.uk. w. lob ruf.hi rcfj.lt fxou i tho trunoport of 1:# val-_..u:s, J r quest you to -vtirocs tho Control Ciefrlx-s Office for Aintfl i. ••.ItuvLor.a. -~c» *rtcnitr. -r - U, Berlin V 35, r.fcrrirv: to tho foct that »/.? ;rjirfor hr.j tom ct.vrie -1 v of this letter, don : t you nov wirh to chv.ro y'ur *oalic''ny to ?he affect tYm ym never file isr.uo any orders to J lmA -BbuiV icaitrali^: t.:c at/e. e.i. of Ir.scre p.* .ora to on Scthnnosin s^.tltn ?iis letter certainly c-vxot be c nsidoreJ to be in ccaacetfon wrt’a 5 Februory-*-DJG-18-2-Futty Court Ho. 1 the Euthanasia station. In the year of 1943 the ~ir Rrid Freenutionary Cone ittoo, which I touched upon yesterday, was already cctivetod. This w?.s an institution which was activated occordii. tc a Reich decr-e. In this «ir Reid Irccauticnrry Coeeitteo there were Dr. Cor.ti, ar.d I wes also a mcnfcer of that Ccedttuc, and in this Air aid Precautionary Ccasnittuo X was in¬ cluded because I was already in cfarrgo of these special hospital institution A If in this enso ths ChnrUcblc Patients Transport Company perticipi ted, thoy did so bccrusw of their transport facilities, because ^cthun ise no transport would have been available. This nomine it »cs already nonttonod th:t this trrnsport which was available hod tc bo specially' coadttod during the wintor cx.tastrcphe of 1941-1942 with the Group Center. I asoui-e with¬ out raaaaboring the details in th:t ocnr.ccticn th-t w u rro here concerned with tho saso thing, r. -a«iy, that considering the hospital iacasos which wo had in the host end which then extended tc tho rest of Germany, & transft had to bo c*rriod through. The n-mo cf the Lirtitution Hudom-r boccc.o known to no through tho trl.-l last year, end 1 do not know where the Institution Varstidn is located. Q Do you knew whether thoso enu hurd.vd fifty Jnsrno persons woro exteruinated at H-dcarr? A I don't knew that and I dcn : t blievo it, and it is not known to no that tho prtients would hove tc bo sent there. This letter dees not clarify tho situation at -11. I merely w-nted tc point cut what it says at the top, the evacuation cf nlr-dcaaged territories. ihyt. ycu could toll me whore Karst win is loeetjd. Q I dc not know, witness. However, ycu will recall, I think, that th* fora letters issued from the Feticnts Transport Corporation concerning Euthanasia in 1940 and 1941 usually carried such words as, "Dub to planned uccnccy, *« sw;t order the transfer of sc aany patients to such and such a pi -nee." Ycu recall that don't ycu? A Yes. fi Dc ycu deny th-t this letter is in fact on order frea tho same Patients Transport Company, irtJfiferrinf: insane, persons' f. :n an twyluu 255/ 5 - evruary •#»-DJCr-l S •W. .t t~ tc the SuUianasia station at Raisas?? A According tc the letterhead *e are concernod with the Ctortiable Patients Transport Ccapan.-, G!SH a one cf the sut-departeont of T-4. % Q a»!, ncrocv-r, 7-4 covered tho jrovcoert totpcnj'-s, didn't they? A The oxpcnsej of the oitire Euthavoaia P.-ogran rare dealt 't.tn by an advr-r.ee cf Reich Treasurer Sri. ware, an-: Ch« wore then accounted with the State. It so; s here that queatiens cf account lit/o to be dealt wilh that, agency, thr.t ia, with reference tc transport. Q Wall, Schwarz advanced ■onlcs t.- 7-4. did he net? /. You. Yea. That vns so„ Q 7tad T--4 t.&o peying for the transfer of these ir.Moe pereor.o to H&daai was it not? A Yes. It was sc c n car. be seen free tho letter. r 2T3* 5 Feb 47-A-F jC-19-1-5card- an Court So. 1 * C. Did you have any supervisory control over insane asylums in Gem any, either during the operation of the Euthanasia Program up until 1942, or thereafter by virtue of being General Coccissicaer? A. So, I certainly had no supervisory duties regarding these in¬ stitutions . Q. Did you have any authority to give orders and instructions to the doctors of such insane asyluos? A. I do not receeber ever having issued such an order to any such A mental institutions. I cannot r«neafeer any one such event. Q. Did you ever issue any such orders to directors asyluns through the Reich Coccittec or any other agency of tho Rithannaia Prog ran? A. I do not rcsober. fJe could have been concerned Kith questions of inforoaticn. Although, I <*> think that they would have been passed on to Doctor Linden. Kosovor, I do not rtsoaber any such incident. Q. Did you evor intervene for victims of the Rjthanasia Program, so that they sight not be killed? A. Since I was only in one way aancornod with reference to these Euthanasia institutions, such a question could only refer to a conver¬ sation I had with Pastor Bodelschwing regarding his patients. That, accordii^ to ray recollection occurred in the year of 1940 — 1940 or 1941, I as not quito sure. Q. Now, Horr Brandt, you have Md eooetioo to consider this subject vory carafe ly. I am asking you if you over intervunod for tho victins of the Euthnasia Progrna so that they night not bo killod? A. I do not believe that I intervened in that matter since I was always in full conformity of the id^a •! Euthanasia. VTc can only bo considered with discussions in Bethel, as far as I think, that iv> wh re I spoke to Pastor Bodelschwing. And, this discussion which I carried on with his was decisive, not finally decisive but helpod to decide the -stoppage of the entire action. I do not r question wasVtaether Anna C-asse was to be improperly executed Her relatives - h--r parents were showing saae concern in that natter, and I ask you if you had ascertained that there had in fact boon an improper dioj> a ncsis and that she was about to bo improperly subjoctoi to euthanasia what would you have done? X A At first I would have aide a report to the Fuehrer and in ary case I would have notified the Reich Hlnlstry of the Interior, in this oaao Linden's agency, but all thoso aro assumptions. Hut one cannot soo from this letter that ary such question cculd have arisen- It only ap.)oars firm this letter that tho rwsabors of the fmily had semo'desire that this child bo released, but it could well have boon that I wroto to the paronts after I had oonfiraod that request, ai«d I think that is a matter of ccurso that I would havo tried to convince than about the correctness 01 euthanasia. Put tho docisivo thin.- is that with reiorunco to tho children belon^nr to tho Reich Cotxxitteo tho approval of the parents was nocossary. It my bo that In this connection the parents did not £iva an approval and for this reason a let tor cano to rac. 3 *)r. D tt andt, are you seriously sur as ting that no children woro sub¬ jected to euthanasia without tho consent of the parents? A Accor din.- to ry knowledge tho approval of tho parents was absolutely necessary cni had to bo given, and itwas the task of the agency of Linden to esta'lish oorxocticn with tho - cal physicians in order to rot that approval. At that period of time I he-.rd 'f no case where a child roceivod outjianasia without the approval of tho parents. The fact that tho parents wore told that it was done cr. tho basis of approval is somethin’ completely different. Q witness, this is the first tine that I havo over heard mentioned in connection with the euthanasia program ttat arybedy's consent had to bo obtained and I take it that it is a rather fundamental natter. Are ycu ready tc swear to this Tri'-unal that the Reich Cosrdttee never performed euthanasia on children without obtaining the »:naant of the parents of the child? 5 Feb. l*7-K-ATc420-3-Xarrcw Court Ifc. 1 fi I said yesterday that the approval of the parents was necessary for the euthanasia of children* and I an of the opinion that such ar. approval was actually given. Q Was the approval written approval cr verbal approval? A That I *>n't know. I cannot say that. Q Have you ever seen ary written approval? A I believe that during the first period, when this authorization was submitted for si (-nature to Doubler ani ae, all the othor papers wero tegothor with it, such as approvals, etc. It nay be that '.urine the later period wo woro only concerned with the authorization papers and that tho othor papors woro left with tho Reich Ccmitteo. However, I did see such letters of approval but I don't bolievo that they were in every case in writing but I think thoy wore partly given orally thrcu;di the local physician or other agency which dealt with Shat oase. Q Well, witnoss, let's look at this letter again. I find con© difficulty in reconciling ycur tostinony about tho nocossity of consent by tho relatives of tho child with what's writton hero in this letter. For example, tho thirl lino roods. "It soooe that the relatives cf Anna Gasso tried to obtain her roleoao by evory possible too ns." If, witness, it was nocossary to obtain oensont why was thoro any question about releasiiv- Anna Gasso? A I cannot say that olther. According to ry opinion, the child could rot be kopt in an institution if tho parents wanted it at homo. Q And tho last sentence which roads, "If from a noiisal point of view such roloaso is warranto*., one cc-uli perhaps take into consideration whothor one should rot perhaps ocnply with such roquost in the interest of the good reputation of the institution." Don't you find that laiv-uare Just a bit re¬ strained, witness? A Tos, I thirk it is very restrained. Q Let's pass on to anoth-sr matter. .That happened to the insane as/luas in Poland and in Russia In the areas which were rverrun by the Geman army? 5 Feb. U7-t>nTT>-2*-i.-«arrcw Court Jo* 1 A I oannot say what happened to these institutions. I saw one sin lj ■ • • *• institution in Winiza which ms oonpletely evacuated since 7ehroacht unite had moved in. Otterwise, I saw no other institutions for mental patients and I don't knew what happened to 'ten* q Doctor, you had authority under the order of 1 September 1939 up until the Spiing of 19U2. Tty that &! =•.- all of Poland and a substantial part of a WoeternTRussian had been overrun? A Tee* Q Didn't ycu obtain Information about hat was bain- :k-no with tho patients in Polish and Russian asylums? A Ifc, I received no inforcation about it. Q Do you know what happened to then? A Mo, I don't know th-t oithur* Q Do you know whether euthanasia was exton loi to such aroas? A It is not known tc no that euthanasia was oxtonlcd to thoso torri* riva. Q Suppo»a wo pet ycur roaction to Docunent H3. 1758. Witness, tho Q And or. page 106 , "October 1, 19U, General *aoner (Quartermaster General).Insane aysluns Itawgorod.." Dees this docuner.t Indicate to you that Euthanasia was extended to a sylucs in Pussia7 A It says here, "Despite of that, killing necessary" that is under the % 26 of Saptecfcer 191*1. I did not speak to General Qiartonaaster Wa.gner nor with !tr. Ilnldor recording these questions. I did not speak to hln nor -did he approach ne so that I can say nothin further regarding these 3 in'ications than what is seen anyway. I to not know who was supposod to carry throu gh this killinc; and I (to not knew what this one word "Insane asylums l^rwgorod", that is the 1st of October 191*1, neansj this is Just one worU It oan well be tho caso that this was merely is cussed or that something sh~uld happen there, but I do not krow. Q HorriTrandt, ho~f much tine Ud you spend in the Fuehrer's Headquarters on tho Eastern Front? A Fron 1939 until 19l*2, with vory short interruptions, I wns thore f Later, the ro7erse wns true. I was thoro or. lossor occasions and was more on tho way — on Journeys. q And you also have relato-l to tho Tribunal that you nndo an inspection tour in the front areas of the Hussion Front beforo Hoscow in 191*1, tho wintoi of 191*1? A In tho winter of 191*1, that is from tho 7th until tho 10th of January, I was there. q Anl you wjro novor consulted in the Fuehrer's Hea-Yjuartcrs about extending euthanasia to asyluns in Ifussia? A fo. I did nst take part in ary conference whoro General Oborst Haldor wnoprecont. I did x»t participate in ary conferences whoro General >*arter~ nastur TTaznwr was together with the Fuehrer. All this took place—those ’iscussions of this kind, which were colled discussions of the situation — t ok place sor.«whoro else and I did not participate in thoa* Q Do you finl it curious that euthanasia was jxtend-ad to Russia without consultation with one of the leaders of the euthanasia prerran in Germany 2^0 itself? 5 Feb. l7-w-TD-21-2 -Le 3 3 er Court Ho. 1 ' A I sust say that I was not included in that prograa and I was not in- foraad by tho Fuehrer about this question. It was never under discussion, Q Kerr Brandt, after 19U2, don»t you think that you had sufficient power ani authority tc put a stop to kill i ng of Eastern workers in euthanasia insti- tuteo? A lidld not know anythin- about it. I lid not know that Eastern workers wore killed in euthanasia institutions. Consequently it was not possible for no to do anything against it in any fora wtetac&ver. If I had learned that healthy persons were killed in thoso institutions I an sure th\t 1 would hero do no everything to prevent it, not only because these wero institutions for tho slok. Q Herr Dran.lt, lot*s novo along to a different subject. I listuned to ycur teatiaony with rospoct to your own peter an*, authority as Oonoral Cosrnissionor and Reichs Ccmisslonor and also as to tho power and authority of tho Defendant Hanaoser an! tho Defendant lostock, with groat attontior., nn! fren the picture you havo drawn it soew that ono oust conclude that you hoi vary little authority anl ver littlo powerj and that although Har.dloaor was appointed as Chiof of tho Hedioel Sorvioes of tho 7chmscht in July 19U, ho roally was not Chiof of tho HedLoal Sorviaos of tho ^ohrmcht because ho didn’t have my jxwerj an' 1 , although Rostock was Chief of your offioo for Scionce and Roaoarch, ho had no concern with nattore of science an! rosoaroh and that that was Just a ross alsawr, and was roally concerned only with tho cat tor of ecorKcy .an the allocation of raeiical supplios, except that it nay have had 3 one passing cone urn with trying to keep nodical schools open. I mul i like tc invest!geto with you aoao of th>3o natters now and I surest that wo first discuss for a nonent the position of tho Defondant HandLoser. Ho was the Amy Medical Inspectorate frvn 19ul until Sept nber 19Ui, was ho not? A You taint tako into consideration the double position which he hold by being Airy Physician and iXKf Medical Inspector. In his capacity as .my Physician he was tied to the CSHj in his capacity as Arry Inspector he belong.* to an institution which belonged to tho Sane Territory. Since Oeneraloberstnb- 25^7 5 rob. L7-A-^TI>-21-3-L©S8er Ccyrt Jfc, 1 ar.rzt Handlosar was tied to the OKH, his position as Ar=y Medical Inspector was a Vlcistratcd by hie together with the OKW and this position ho hell, I think, up 'intil August of 19Ui, when, on the strength of a new docreo, this union was -oparatod and he hinsolf bocar^, in 191:2, the Chiof of tho Medical % Serviaea of the Arasd Forces. Q Witness, which branch of the Wehmadit aad the largest uedioal service*. A Certainly the Arsy and for that reason at that tine, in 192:2, the Chief of the Medical Service of the krry r. j-roootod to Chief of the Medical Scrvicoo for tho Araed Forces, which Includes ill branches, x q Would you say that tho nodical service of the any wns larger than tho nodical services of the other branchee of tho anaol forces combined? A I canxvDt say that with certainty but I wcul! nosur.c that, according to figures, that is with reference to th^ nurber of nodical officors, it wae larger than the Luftwaffo and Navy together. q Arvl didn't the ;xw Hodicol Inspectorate handlo substantially all nodical probluns for all branches of tho TTohraacht with the exception of thoso nodical problems which rolatod primarily to ono of tho other branches of tho anaod forcoa, for instance, aviation medicine? A The ir.divi '.uol branches of tho arnod forces worked on aodioal question by themselves. 9ucause of this independent activity, rwarkabla hspponincs occurrod. For ins banco, ir. tho sane locality, let us assunc it is the Crimea, whore thoro were certain Navy units,tho sanj vacoinatlon procoduro was carried out which wi3 bra at Iffarcnt periods by tho ,»my, Navy and Air Force, This i3 merely an in ‘icatior that within the indlvi 'ual Wohmucht branches thora was a basical independency cf action an* it was the dosire of the independent ~«ohrracht branches to maintain their special position, oven ttlfeh reference to their owr. acadicios. Therefore, it ms not the case that the «ruy wa3 in any way in a leading position rop-.r ting its measures which it t'ck within its own branch and was in any way suggestive to tho measures of tho F-.vy and Air Force. 25U8 5 Feb i?-A-i£A.V-22-l-Nimbuck - Stf Court Vo. 1 Q. Now, Herr Brandt, after; Handloser was appointed as chief of the acdical services of the •’ehmacht, on 2B July 19A2, was \it> or was ho not the superior of Hipj*e? A. He was aot the official superior of Kippke. G. Now, Herr 3rendt, »e ait not in this trial concerned with the right of the superior to punish hie subord nate or natters of that con¬ cern. I aa, however, concerned and this case is concerned with whothor or not Handloser could stop certain research w rk which was being carried on by Hippke as the Luftwaffe Uedical Inspectorate? A. According to nsy opinion that would only have been possible; that is, to stop thee or not to atop thee, if we were concerned with natters which equally concerned all branches of the a mod Torcea. But tlile word, nutual, I think, was expressly eentioned in tho decroe eo that everything which does not represent a nutual basis was outside tho Juris¬ diction of Handloser and wao within th* freaework of tho respective •"tohraacht branch which dealt with any such natter. It nay have been the Navy or tho Air Force. Q. As I put it to you, nodical research on typhus, nodical research on epidemic Jaundico, nrdical roaearch on yollow favor, are nutual probleos. Could Handloser issue orders to Hippke initiating or stopping research work with respect to such rrtters? A. Before giving ay reply sny I look at the decree once nore, which is relevant in connection with this order? That is tho decree of tho 26th of July. (Document handed to witness). A. (Con'd.) On the basis of this decree and its formulation and in view of the situation which prevailed, I would net essuae that Kami- locer was in a position to give such a directive. The entire complex of science and research was not mentioned in this decree at all, and if I take into consideration tho history of the creation of this decree and taking into consideration the lack of materials, a special readiness for conrdteent h^d to bo gained. 2SA9 5 Fob i.7-A-4HA-22-l-Kinabunk - mt Court Jo. 1 In the heading of this decn-e, the first sentence is of ira- portance, idiich says; ”The utilisation of personnel and material in the field of 2549-a 5 Feb rue ry 47-A->JAA-2;.*-2-?.'inabu ek - sw Court No. 1 medical and health oat tors demands a coordinated and planned direction." And this refers to paragraph i, namely, the coordination of all tasks coxon to the radical services of the Mehrcacht et cetera. I ar. of the opinion that on the basis of this decree Dr. Handloser quito apart froa tho Question whether fie had any knowledge or not, could not have been in a position to give any orders to Hippke in his field of science. Q. •‘ell, this opening paragraph you have referred to talks of "Tho utilisation of personnel and naterial in the field of medical ahd health natters demands a coordinated and planned direction"; is that right? Is medical research not a problem very directly concern'd with the ooordl- nfttad ard planned use of personnel and naterial? A. But thr.t is not meant in this decree. I havo Just said that you have to take into consideration in addition, the history of tho creation of this dtcroo. -'obody, wh* n speaking of personnel and nate¬ rial, will connect this with research work as such. Q. Is that right? Wall, let's look at Document JO-924 — A. I would like to ask you once core, did you ask ne whether that is correct or not? I said that personnel and caterial <*ieations havo nothin.' to do with research. Q. That's exactly wh’t I understood you to say. N 0 w let ne put to you Document 1C-022 which was introduced as Prosecution Exhibit 435» and read you the words of Genoralob-rstabsarzt Handloser himself, and these words were spoken at the me* ting of the consulting physicians of the Military Medical Academy from >3 Novesber to 3 Deceebor 1942, approximately six months alter this Fuehrer order th'.t we have b«en studying was issued. He opens his address: "Gentlemen: The demands and extent of this total war as well os the relationship between needs and availability of personnel and mate¬ rial require measures also in military and medical fields which will serve the unification and unified leadership. It is not a question of marching separately and battling together, but marching and battling must be dene in unison from the beginning in all fielns. As a result , as 2550 5 F«b LI -k-Al}Jt*2s. imbaek - sw Cc-rt So. 1 concerns the ailitary sector, the Tehrcscht Medical Service end with it the Chief of the Medical Services of the 255^-A 5 Feb t7-A-4iAA-22-3^>inabuck - sw - Court To. 1 Wefarmacht, came into being. Not only in matters of personnel and material, ever, ts far aa this is possible in view of special fields and special tasks itfiich must be considered, but also with the view to medical scientific education and research, our part in the 'fohmacht * Medical Service must and will be an unified one. Accordingly the group of participants in this second work conference East which I have now opened is differently composed from the first work conference^ }{ay of this year. Then it was a confererce of the Arty. Today the three • • • • branches of the '>fehnacht, the flaffen SS and police and labor service and the organization Todt are participating and unifiod." Do you wish to change your testimony, witness? A. No, I do ot want to change ay testimony. If this has happened in this case and if these questions went parallel to scientific questions too, it was .ot something that was based on an order which was initiated by Prof. Dr. Handloser, but it was the realization of tho participating p ehroacht branches to try on their own accord to coordinate their functions. Thr.t wasn't the case evorywhoro, and evon on the occasion of such meetings of the East and I don't Know who ms detailed to attend those meetings, there was some copying done with reference to the various ••‘ohraacht branchos. Q. ttell now, Herr Brandt, I think that is a dually what tho situation was. Weren't the various branch*s of the "ohrmcht being coordinated b 7 Handloser and aren't they boing coordinated in tho field of medical rosoarch as veil? A. The academies ere not carried on as r ehraacht acadtri.es, but there was the academy of the Air Force, the academy of the Army and the academy of tho Navy. Even the "affen SS had later started to insti¬ tute their own SS academy. Thet cay have been earlier too. At any rato the acadenir-s are not sub-organs of the chief of the anacd forces medical s- rvices but they rerained institutions of the cocqxitent "uhr- macht branchos and had their names. Dr. Handloser, as medical inspector 2551 5 Fftfc-H7-A-UAA-22-0-Ninafcuck- sw "ou-t So. 1 and Arny physician, had the Military Medical Academy and similar situation was with the Kavy, Q. And he used the Military Medical Academy to coordinate research activities in»all the branches of the "ehraacht, did he not? 2551-a 5 Pc —-22-lHttna'cck C u*t .1 » - ..c wore then c rccmo>‘ with the :u.otin- f Itx. a nsultins ;hysicia:is t T.ijich ; .u . r ' print. Tiese .ectin s cf the. c nsultin; physicians Tx.ro - r the .jut;.- 30 of cxchnncinr .f experiences, ' ut acc-rdinr t a channel f c -wan :ian!I'5cr certainly c uli net interfere with any if the thcr research • rancho. In such a ease the respective chiefs <.f the Navy tr Air F.rco w. uld have r-ferroA t this decree which nl, s oaks cf pors.imolOK' .latcrial dircc ticn. A l Herr Cran’.t, bef re we adj urn f r the evening I n.uld lil:^ t. put 8 x f Y^r own » ri tv y u in c n:xcv,i n with the p^siti n f the dofonclant Handlooor, and I want ycu t recall t .in’. tJx. wer *a Uct y u s rko at the co^tiir of the Illltary ...’lcal ..cade;/ at ILhenlichon In ..ay f 19! i which I nec-l n t ra-trr. y u, was bef re the doervx .f August 19Wi w Idi y.u assert oxten.'nd Ben loser's powers s oewhat. T..A is 2 cu >ont .r sccutiIc, the Judges of Military Tribunal l. A lUlit.-ry Tribunal 1 is new ir. session. Ood savo the United States X of Aaoricn end tills honorable Tribunal. There tilU bo order in tl^o courtroom. THB .T^SIDii'Ts Ur. Marshal, will you ascertain thet tho dofondants arc all present in cosrt. THB 'URSl'ALt Jny It please your Honors, all defendants are presort in the Court Ilocu. THi HtaSIDZiT: The Secretary Cener.'l will note for the record the pro sen oo of all the def„ndnnts in court. Counajl my procoed with cross-aaa a iratl on. KARL BRAi.DT — Rosiuod. CROSS 2XAME.ATI0.'.* (Continued.) 3Y ffi-UcHAKEI: Q.- Herr 2r. rdt, at the end of tho session yesterday wo wore inves¬ tigating the poDor and authority of Gonoral Hand loser and I tad out to you ourtcir. -lords which you had spoken in Lay 1944 at Hohenlyc'cn. 1 vent to ask you on which occasion you uere r i ht, whether when you stated as 2fay 1944 that Bnrdloser was responsible for the use and porforornco of the- □odical Qffi^-.’PDyfcpthur, as you testified here, ho was not so rospon- the question of responsibility ir. tho s&ac differentiate b.twocr. the responsibility of the entire the redteal officer within the aray rx.d within the troops. - 2554 - 6 Feb-UFJC-i-l-Footor (FL) Court Ho. I in roforcncc to reserves, etc., and the things which are connoctcd *.?ith research as »- spoke about yesterday. In addition, it has to be added that wt*an I sooku in Koheolycboa in tho y-ar 1944 I was speaking about a feraal use, end it certainly wasn't some kind of an affidavit that I was tanking at tho tine. During such a meeting, where medical officors of tho various armed forces A % - 2554 e 6 Fob 47-M-rJC-i-2-Fostor Cc^rt Hq, 1 bronchos hr.vo gothorod, It la quit* custcwery thr.t tha chlof of ono arch *?ahiur.ent branch la contiocod. It la a gosturo, ra cpprocir.tivo Gooturo, rothor than -a fixing of lila functions la various cnpocitlos. 1 Horr Bronit, lot no put a hypothetical coao to you. Supposo Hnndlosor In Aucuat of 1942 ar.do .-a inapoctlon of tho nodic-l service of tho Luftwoffo, if ho i\*. that tine was undor Hlppko, -ad aupposo Hondlosar found conditions Mhlch woro not to hla likinc, could Kr.ndlooor lcauo an ordor to Hlppko instructing hin to correct tho conditions of 7*1 ch Hondlosor did jiot approvo? A Ho probably wouldn't V.vo boon in a poaltlon to glvo dlroctlvoa of thr.t enanar to Hlppko sinco Hlppko rocolvod Ms directive* fro tho Chief of tho Air Forcoo hlcsolf and wr* subordinated to !iln in n allitnry w*y. Horo wo would cor.carnad with a purely nil it ry ordor. Ho prob-bly could hnvo pointod out thr.t southing was wronc, but recording to ny opinion ho would not hnvo bodn in c. pealtioa to tiv- any ordura to a difforoat branch of tha ’’ohrancht r.o for os it was not concoraod with unto rial or poraoanol matters. Svon in tho coso of nr.toriol and parsonnol aattoro it would hovo boon nocoocary ovon boforo such an inapoctlon took plr.co to infora tho Chief of tho roopootlva !7ohmnoht branch about hla luj -autos. q I toko It that you oxclwiod nolle -1 roaonrch free whr.t you doscrlbo no •tho flold of nr.toriol -ad poroonnol? A Z .alroaly ttedo that dlfforonco yoatord-y, In thr.t docroo tho word rosoorch in cot usntionod at oil* q Lot no put onotbor hypothetical crjto to you. Hnndlosor nndo tho o-co inapoctlon of tha aodlcol corvico of tho Luftw-ffo undor Hlppko nd found conditions of which ho did not r.pprovo. Hmdlosjr than wont to Koitol and told Koltol thr.t intolor-.blo conditions provr.ilod In tho nodical aorvlco of tho Luftw-'Xfo. TTould Koltol or would Kc' tel nr.vo not, aont on ordor down to Hlppko to straighton out tho affaire which woro cceplainod of by Hondlosor? A I dbn't bollovo that Koltol would have dono so, and for tho foil wring reason, tho nodical aorvlco of tha Air Forcoa was an lndopondont institution and tho supreme ccrricndor of the Air Forces has a diroct channel to tho Fuohrar. I have already pointed out that the position of Koitol w-a uoro or loos r. joock position claco Koltol was olrcucvontod by tho various chiefs of tho TTohrcnoht -2555- 6 Fob 47-i^?JC-l-?-7C3t8P Court !ta. 1 bxvnshos and , thorofore, it would not h-*va boon possiblo for Koitol to givo Cooricfi ".*J ouch directives in nay rash ovont. I think th.it it is out of the ^uastlon. Koitol coy havo nontionod this or.ttor to tho Fuohror so that ho, ovor Goorlng, could biro erdors to Eippko and Soil with tho natter, but I don't bollovo that Koitol oa hio own initiative could hero sivon my liroctlvoa Hippko. • t\ './can't it proclsoly tho duty end tho responsibility of Handlosor to nako such iaspoction trips? I think you ycursolf stntod that you wont on such iaspoction tripe with h i zj ifow, hariaG cado such on iaspoction trip Just exactly what did Hirailoaor do concerning tho conditions which ho Found? If I V uoioretand your tostlnoay you aro tolling thts Tribunal ho could do nothing, is that right? A If ho undortook such a tour of iaspoction to tho Crli-oa, for instinco, or Poland, ho lafornod tho rospootlvo aodic 1 offlcoro that ho war on his way and it is iulto probablo th-t rftorwirds ho r.-do -n according roport to tho nodical offlcoro. But horo wo aro cmcornod with tho quostions as laid down in thu docroo, whoro it wxprossly said that it doala with the porsonnol and natorlal coiitnont. « q Hon* Brandt, lot'r issuro that tho natter of whloh Hmllooor disapproves fills within thu scope of the docroo — I -r. try lie to find out proclsoly what Hanllocor's powers and rooaoasibilltioa woro in such a caso ml oxactly what orders ho could iosuo, occctly what a-n ho could go to to have such orlors issuod, and you havo oxcludoJ tho possibility of Koitol. You havo oxeluded tho possibility of Kandlosor hinsolf issuing such onlors and I tea loft with tho picture that Dr. Handlosor had no pomrs whatsoever. A Tho fact that tho power that to had at tho tii» was not sufficient is conflrr-od by tho fact that in tho year 19-14 a soccnd docroo was nocossiry whoro ho rocoivod noro oxtonslvo functions. If in 1942 on tho strenght of this docroo ho actually had boc>.'_o tho nodical chief of tho ontiro at'-x! Forcos, that is to say if ho would havo tikon ovor tha ontiro lo-dorship ml ascu;^>l a clear posi¬ tion of superiority ever all ^rnod Forcos bronchos, this second docroo of August 1944 ::ould r.ot ha Vo boccro accessary. In this socond docroo tho wasn't only tho separation of his position as tho Amy Insroctor-to and tha Hedic*l Chiof of - 2556 - 6 7ob <7-L-FJC-l-4-703tor Court Ho* 1 5*0 # vcod TOTC08, but it W ns Tory clearly ost-bn 8 hoi thoro that he rocoivod certain functions. ito functions which ho rocoirod thoro cortainly woro not ^ivon to hln boforo boc-.use othoiwlso this aoconl diroctiro would hr.vo boccco superfluous* -2557- 0 ?«b-JfSaS-3-l-B«ard Court So. 1 . q, Undor the second directive could Handloser iaauo orders directly to Ui« Chief of tee hcdlcal Surico of the Artsy. of the Iuftwaffc, and of the Uevyl ^ r *y I *»sk you to give thii aocond decree together with the official directive? • Q. Herr Brandt. I would like for you to testify froa your own know¬ ledge of the nodical eorvico in Germany. Aftor ell, I think, you wero in a position to kn w. Tku Tribunal has the decroe of August 19W4. And, if it is sio.ly a question of interpreting the written words, I tnink perhaps wo ero coupotcnt to do that. I would like to csk you now to testify fron your own knowledge. I askod you if Hnndlosor could issue orders after tho docroo of August I 9 UU to tho Chief of tho Kodicel Service of tho Amy. Luftwr.ffo, jfavy, and Voffen SS. ns attached to tho Wchraaeht? a. .xcording to ny opinion, he could only do so within tho fr/ujowork of ais entire tasks: tb t is, within the fraaowork of his autunl tasks. X do not believe trial it is dourly stated in tho docroo that bo oould havo done so in suen tasks that wore not sutual. But, I still should liko to *. soo t.ie docroo onco noro together with tho official dlroctivo. In ony ci so, tt.ls socond docroo of 19 UU cocparcd to too docroo of 19 b 2 , r, nro Hnndlosor very cloar powers and authority which previously wore not cxlstont. v Is nodicrl rosoarer, a mutual task? A. opart fro- the special fiold, yos: end, I should like to designate aviation nodicino os a special fiold. Well, could not Ef.ndlosor issue a general ordor that there would bo no nodical experimentation on concentration coup inoutes? A. Tho proroquisito would have been that he hrd tho knowlodgo thnt such oxp.rincnts vwro being Ci-rriod out to a certain oxtont or at all. If ho did not know thet it is very icprcboalo that ho wold hi-vc issuod such o docroo. I do not bollovo thnt ho would hj.vo h -d the influence to bring such a decreo to its final offect. sinco he than would interfere in n field which wio not nodical and which wes subordinated to Himmler. Iho only channol would hr.vo beon to roport to the yuehrar, and neve falu deal with the nattor. I an -2558- o y.cx'-K-OES-Z-a-Seard Court So.l quite sure no could cot have issued any order to Hiu_ler. q Herr Brandt. you did cot answer the (question. Ve are not concorned with the likelihood a S:.ndloser having issued an order. Ve are eicply coccrnod wit! the power to do so.Asd, I bar* put tr.e question to you: Vhec in SopteaborigUh Eaailoser, as Chief of the fcodic -1 Sertico of the Vbhrcacht, could have lonue. an order to tho Chief of the Kedicol Sorviso of the Any, Havy. Alrfoce, and tee Vaffeo-SS. as attached to tho Vehrcacht. that no nodical experir-ontation would bo carriod out by officers of those services upon concentration crop incatos? ^ A If succ an order n d been issued, tho succoss or non-succoss ard, an ordor would hove occursod whother or not it was in oonPr. st to an ordor which any chiof ot the Vahruacnt rocoivod fro- his own superior. That ie to snp, if a directivo hod boon glvon by Qooring that such and such ©xporloonts woro to be carried out, and if the order of Hnndlosor was in contrast to this ordor, tne order of Eondloser's cortelnly would have no offeet. It would have boon * corely lllusionnry. q Horr Brandt. I insist that you answer tho quostion with a yos or a no. Vo aro not concorned with any conflict betwoon nn order of ».ndlosor'o or an order of flooring's or an ord^r S1-—ler's. Vo aro sicply coocornod with tho powers «.ad tho right of Hruvdloser to havo issuod ouch an order to tho Chiof of tho hodic- 1 Service of the Ar~y, Kavy. lAiftvrvfio, and tho Vaffon-SS. os attached to tho Voknwcftt. I think you can answer that quostion with a yos or a co. Did ho have such powers or did he not7 A Vitnout seeing tho doxroc once aoro, I cannot unswor thio quostion with wither u yos or a co. q alright. Herr Brandt, wo dll pats on. You do not c--ro to answer that question without seeing tho decroo; is that ri htT - I cannot answer tno question in its prociso fora with yes or no. wl thout a- vlng once ore tho opportunity of seeing tho decreo togchtor with tho official directivo. q You mentioned tne 3loao in connection witn n pocition ho hold in tno Intwrl^r. - 255 ?- 6 Fco-U-G££-2-3-3oard (FL) Court So. I A.- In connection with the f.iot that he hed no position in the istry tho Interior. Q.- I understood you to doscribe Blctx cb h'ving two positions: ono with tto Party end o:* with tho State? A.- That is an error. I do not think that I have stated that. Doc¬ tor Conti had a doiiil* position, but Bloat, wns aeroly the roprosontfttivo of Conti in his capacity as Leader ol physicians. Ho was tho deputy leader of physicians while Conti was tlx lvcdor of physicians. And, ho was Reich Hoalth Leader, as a party lunetion end at the saao tiiuo ho was Undor Socrotary of State ir. the Ministry of the Interior. Blono luu\ noth¬ ing at all to do with Doctor Conti'a position as Under Secretary of State in tho Ministry of the Interior. Q.- And, you testified that tho only Job that Bloax hod wns that as Deputy Roich Hoalth Loader. A.*- In his relationship to doctor Conti, he was only hio Deputy Physician Leader. Q.- Horr Brandt, I did not ask you whet his Job was in relation¬ ship to Conti. I cskod you what Jobs ho hold. Now, will you plonso answer? A.- Doctor 31ooo was the Deputy I^ador of Physicians, nnd I think ho had in addition a function in tho Party with tho main office for Pu¬ blic Health. Ho nos active within th« Roich Research Counool as pleni¬ potentiary for cancor research. And, I do not knew h:*t far his official position in tho Party had something to do with the educational rr.ttcr or whether lx hod aoex ofiicir.l naao for it, I cannot say, but I did not hear about any other functions of Blooo. Q.- iierr Brandt, your attorney asked you, during tho course of tho direct examination, for your Judgment on the importance of tho experi¬ ments with iihich this cas^ is conceraod. Do you rorxnbv-r that? 6 Fcb-Ji-GiS-a-3- xsrd (PL) Court So. I Q.- I recdl thr.t jou toatifi:, in affect, that nil of tho aipcri- aoata charged ir. tto Indictment worv Inportent oxporiaonts *ith tho ox- c-ption of atorlLiaation? * - 2560 a - o — *<4 Court *>. 1 A lfcon answering tho quostioa about the importance of cxperioonts, I answers* In the affiraatlTO, but vlU that. 1 aid not want to express that at tho tl-u the Banner of execution. *=4 the oxperlr^nt • in this form, vero important. I can only open* about that if I had hoard then spook Ao participated In tbusu oxpo?in«:.ts. The fact that such nuostiocs of sulfnr.il- u—lie playod an important port with us. and that Its clarification was im¬ portant, and that tho of foot teat high altltudo oxporlcunts could bo of importance Oocauso of special doaonds of taw Alr^foroo. It was In this ■ ur.so tant 1 wn.itod to establish tho Importance of tho qxpcrlncnts nrd I, lr. that connection, poir.twd to tho skoloton collection and storllltatlon, and thoso oro two groups which hare to bo oxoludod frou consldorntion. -2561- 6 Feb- ■-Jr-3-l-£l'Jclcy Court I a.f-r datinui.., w th this 11. of quosta.ning, Herr,Br-ndt, I would like to clo r up y ur relationship te t;i- rx y. Is it tru_ that y u h-1 a r-nlc in th- aray? * 1*084 Q. ;hat was your r-iti nsnic t tlx r^y an what r nk did you held? ... Ttv- last tlsu I was 6-m.rolrrst f the H-torrc. 1. Did y.u hav- any fur.cti n fr.n th- r.ivy? x ... I had r. furtlwr c noocticn with th- tray. .‘.ftcr participating; in- the first jr.ixcxs s in th- ye r f 1?35 I c.ntinu-d the cxercis-s up until the bo innin. f Uv •; rj ’nd during th. war I was ccwdssi.n-.! t. exercise functions -t th- .u-hror'a h_--*qu-rtors. Q. Horr 'rarn't, d> y u regard as crlalnil oxp-ri xntati n n hu;.~r. Ooines with ut tlxlr or.o-nt? ... That ck.pur.is up n what -xp-ri. -nts y u 'r- ep-nkinc «b ut. Tho quos- tl.n of apjr v'.l -ctr -inf. t ny pin! n pLya an essential rclj in the entire jud,h-nt f the ox;xrLc.nt3, th'.t is, in Jufclv xl y.u want t us- tho w.rc. crinlnal. 1. '.oil, Herr °r-r.. t, shy ‘ y.u draw a distinct! n between tl*. typ. f cxp.ri.xnte? Vert difference 00 s it nako nhrt typ- -f oxp-rir-nt it is If tn. capcrl-nta. subject has nte ns-nt-’ t. un'er^o the oxp-ri’n.nt? :.. Y u c*n sp.ak ab ut -xp-ri vots .ifccn > u st-rt usinr, a now drug. Ono is th-n f tr._ pir.i r. that it is f us- it ut kn.wir* it in its final details. 3v-n such r thin.- can o_ c usi cr-d at an experiment; and that is why I w*ntcd to "ifforontiJtc betwo-n the pr blca; am in acdlti n th- question * Of v .luntary r inv luntary n tur- iltn r_f-r_r.ee t an innate plays a psy- ch logical part, an* if rv_ c.nsidored inaat-r too re f n. .no w old have to bo clear if a;iswcria such a qu.sti r. fr n tho st- rt as criminal wh-t cxp.ri- =^::t rx is c nc-rn. - with. Tlx di.ficult poir.ts retarding t» crits arc Suco in thre- p intr. Cn- is involuntary ..~tur_, that nainl> t... lack -f n-_c--ssity £ sue:, an-xp_ri.-m.nt; an , tliird, t _ '-n; _r'.usn_sc f an -xporia-nt. 6 ?ob-’:-Jf->-2“ 2i ‘ ifl -' y Q. th-: u r,'s, y-u fin'.* siconti n: vh_r. it la p-ssibl., alth ugh wj expori-~nt*- subject koa n t v lantour, th-.t n rt>, tne leas th_ -xporlawnt ic pur alas ibl_, \xVi by way f law ' •-ris? la tn-t right? ... Beth car. bo p-aaibl-, yos. Q. leu cro a factor. I ah uld think tlvt y.u aro probably rnthor frsili-T with aalprrctico ^aaco an. at".tut-a in c-Tinny. Supp. so, Herr Branch, y u trie! ut c jww 'ru*. n n. cf your p ti-nts in pre-v'r G-r.’~.ny wit;. ut tollin'. th_ auoj.ct -a ut it r aakin hi a c. ns.n- in any way, ^a. as a r-eult tho pera n w-r_ in.‘,ur— by this -’ru^. «2*‘. y u nr w ul-‘ y u net bo subject to a char> .t rr.ljr-.ctico? x ... 1 certainly* ul o- aubj-ct t • such a charge. Q. roll, ttxn I f! n't quit. uncUffat-n* th- situ-.ti ns ir. tf.ich you aay it ie p> r laaiblc t a •v,thin v> t a xrocr. v.ith ut Ala c neent* U. F-r th t n-.i n I arte th- iiliun-otintl.n bof ro, nm* I a-i' 1 that we iru at t.u. a — tir- e ncorn.with th- ru-ati n »r uan.aa in a6 iti n t < oing f -n invo¬ luntary nttur-. fnis nakua it .' ubly A i ~:i i c ura if it io n t essential, then that <• ul’ bo th- crux of th. pr blu >. J. Hurr ^-n t, w ulrt the -xp-ri.v-nt* c.i in th- if.'Ictn-nt bo e-l-dnal if th- orp-ri...nt ;1 tubj-ett n t c.newnt t uitfer. in;, thoso VXD rlr* r'«? 433 ' u ".»s>er t.-x ,Ue8ti.n? DR. £ jiV., f U’S» Hr. Pro«i'!ont, w. 'r. hero c ncerne*' vitftth- lo^r.l quoati n hich cmui t bo put t th- eltixas. TH5 PR SniNTr I w ul' aek c uns A if by hia quo a tic a no l.ic-r. a to nsk th witrxas whether th. -7? ri’xn-.s — I dsn't kn w t which oxp.ri wnts c unaol refers — v ul b- bj-cti.v.olo r ill-, al if c irrie l n by a physician up n p-ro.na in civil iifo riscennocto with ti illitiry s-rvico. ’irLL'EY? That ia correct, y .r = n r. I v. ri ply trying t.» s-"rch th j.r-.l value* '■•tic rh it»a plrc i n-» -vr-rin-nt.nl -itu-.tl •• l tnia type. JUO'" P.I..G: S- w thon, r. cHnney. in .sin*. y ur quoad, r., are you -J3©3- 6 Feb-KJ-3-3-3L-JtU»y (?U Court So. I attor.ptins to oUcit from this vitrxss hia views r.a to wialftcr each of those cicjxri :orts i t illo £ al or criminal cruaauro or oro you cotxorncd rri j-rily with :*ctlxr\ pawing the prosecution theory of tho cose to be true, these vxporLeor.ta were iUcg'1 »■ criminal becauaa of t’.x ■xnrter in which tboy were executed? IE, 'teKUSXs -oil, I think it ia the latter, your Honor. JCDG3 SEFISGt I think oerhopa tret ie not too cioir. % IP.. UoHAIZT: I ax trying to determine U* importance which tho uit- r.oaa attaches to ccrsunt by the oxo-rimontal subject in tlx context of tr» expurinmts here c’ erged. jyOG3 SKMXfc It would ae^a to on that there night bo a certain typo of so-called o-dccl exponent ifclch in and of itself night not be anticipated to produce painful or diro corus-quencea. On tho otbor hro-.d I apprdtend that any typo of •xporls.r.t, if continued tc OXCOSS, aiglit oo a erfclnal axpori^ntjand 1 would suggest, if I nay, that if that diffovcntiatico ia oado tc tho witnoaa, perhaps wo can yjt at nhnt are trying to here sore quickly. >2. iJeWSY: If tho Tribunal please, 3 think I wiU proceed to put^ ting questions to hia with roapoct to oaeh experiment in Uw inrtict- Mr.t rathor t.ion in tho general aannar I hr.vo stated it. C,.- Horr Irandt, you rave heard tlx testimony rnd ovidonco in thia case with respect to tho freusing vxporinu.ta carried on at the Dachau concentration eno:. I will •* you to assus* that tlx proof as adduced by tho prosecution, for puipoaes of this question only, ia correct and true; and you will recall tint hh.ro was substantial to at loony and proof that tlx experimental object. in that experiment did not consent to un¬ dergo tto o^erWta. wiU toU tlx Tribunal your view on the crlrw Inal character of that experiment on tixt assumption? jUDCS SfflBIS: Ilr. UcHcn-7 are you ccooomod don with tto c^ori-xnt cr tlx armor of its ^x-cutior.? •jr. HcHoncy: Tlx experiment ca it was carried out. 6 Fcb-y-JP-J-U-S^* 1 ^/ C -urt I jODGi SJOSIuO* ^ It «« aup^5-h- of tho state to the interest of .wdicino and thon 1 -ad to »ho yr, that such f\>aing exporimonta have to be carried out. Them, frer. s certain point on, »e arc ccmcerood with the manner of jxeeuti.>> Tho execution of such experiments oust again bo subdivided into voluntary nature or involuntary nature. If, in addition - I spoke about tho darioruisiv*s3 and harsTulnoAS or the experiment - then the oxpurioont, if it is harmful, can't possibly bo carried out by phuslciuns when considering all husan considerations. If any dangor c o-ao up, then the physician has to assume tho responsibility for tho dangor in connection with that experiment, mxy state order con be a safeguard, and a state order cun be interpreted in various ways during a war. Jut I ca r.ot dofino ny position with reference to the freezing experiments and I cannot establish whether such an wxperiarnt, from n juristical point of view, was criminal or not criminal. W. Do ycu Think the freezing experiments w c r<; dangerous? A. '"ino•* fatall''# \w\ u (J. •'••.7 ... r- i:~ ,r dwTer 1 '" nants. JUIXJE SjSRIWJ: Hr. HcHar.ey, I would like to address a question to the witness. aitness, for the soke of clarification, let us assume that it would Court I fc VtH.W? u _ »* - Narrow b~n hUh* i^-t to *. t to —tn, - • —' 01 f „t. ho. lo* . husan being could -i«h.W e^oauro to cold before suoettijirg to the affects of it* Do you underttand that? Uf. «. toco^ that h^ccn .*J-U -.re aolecUd for euch freeing c^rDtente rttheut their ccncSnt. Lef. thirdly that euch lnvclun«ry hunan subjects .era subjected to the oxp.rtn.nt. end died as a direct or Indirect result thereof. He, .ould you be good enough to intern the Tribunal .hat your vie. of such on exp.ris.nt 1. - either from the legal or from tho ethical point of viow? IHB : IHBS 81 I oust repent coco more, In order to make sure that I understood you correctly. Aon assigning tho experiment the following things are assuaxit highest military necessity, involuntary nature of the experiment, and the dangorousrwss of the experiment with the eventual fatality. In this case I am'of the oponien that, vhon consider¬ ing tho circumstances of the situation of tho war, this state institution which has laid down tho importance in the interest of tho state at tho some tic* takes the responsibility r.way fren tho physician if such an experiment ends f • filly and such a responsibility has to be taken by tho state. JUTGE SEBRIHGs Now, doas it taka away that responsibility from the physician, in your view, cr does it share that responsibility Jointly with tho physician, in your view? TME ifITKSSSt According to :y opinion, this responsibility is token away free the physician because, from that moment on, the physician is rarely ar. instrument maybe in th. sa-e sonse as it would be in the case of an officer who receives an order at the front and loads a group of three or four soldiers into a position where they have to !*eet death. That relation, if I apply it to German conditions during the war, is In principle tho smo. I don't belic-vo th t the phusician as such, fren his ethical and aoral feelings, would carry out such an experiment this assurance of tho authoritarian state which giv-s him a fntan 1 and -25‘7- Court I 6 F»b U7-M - li—3 - LJ - Narrow legal assurance on oa« side and, on the other side, gives him the order for the execution* Naturally, in this case, it is a tnooretical quj3tlon since I cannot survey the position in the case of the freeling experiment. I don't know hem this assurance was given and hem the order was given* Basically, I want to differentiate between the order for an experiment which arises fron radical mods os such and whore, under the circumstances, the stato only has a secondary Interest on the basis of medical initia¬ tives, ard I would differentiate between the reverse stato of affairs where the state uses nodical activities. JUIXIE SEBRINOj Tho Tribunal ins one further question of interest. In your view, would on order which authorized or directed a sub¬ ordinate radical officor or subordinate nodical group to carry on a Certain radical experlrant - lot us essune for the moment this freezing experiment - wo have then o general ordor, let us assume, direcUng a certain institute to carry on frogling experiments without delineating or specifying in dotall tho exAot courso of theso experiments. Would you conceive that such an ordor would authorize tho medical officor to whcc tho order who addrocsod to solwct subjects involuntarily and subject thorn to experiments, tho execution of which that officer absolutely know or should have known would likely result in death to tho subject? 6 Jc&-«-£££-7-1-Putty Court Jo. 1. 13 ¥IBESS * 1 have 7Jur U8t -ntenco reputed, please? This quctloc i. Ctrc-el7 difficult to answer. ft order hat to be taken into consideration wich i. giran in such a case. :* y ■ >Jrhapi . enBw ., an ont.io of sue- an order. If 2i-ler give. an order to n Dr. - Z - and toll, hi, to Ci-rry out ^certain exponent. then it would have boon possible th,t M. a Dr. -*• did not vise to adhere to this order. In such a c so. covcver. this Dr. will not hare orerlookod the inportanoo of tho experiment itself, tho sai* way a. tho Lieutenant wno received a certain -.Hilary order - and w B are horo concerned with a uilltar.v order - doe. cot overlook th,t ho would hare to hold out with a group of eight non at a bridged «* vnlch would end in hi. death. , a . plto of thl . offlcar with hi, wight aen to ^ou ho passed this order on would Boot hi. death nt thfcl P °* Ul0n - So tnls physician -X- who rwccived this order frou Hlnnlor V ° Uld thu ••*■««■«■ have to carry out an experinont without ovexw looicinK the importance of the ox..orinor.t whicn prompted a central agency. If * lAT,lcUa ^ n0t c ' rrlod 0ut th-t exporluunt. he would have cone into a posits vLoru ho would be taken into account If ho h «4 not ' Ut tb.it expwriwnt. In this case, and thorc we havo to consider the authoritarian i*turo of our State, the personal fooling and tho fouling of u sped* 1 professional, othlcal obligation ha. to step behind tho totnli- tsrira nature of Ih, war. I nuct soy once o3r0 theso -re theoretical oscuaptions which I an expressing here. At U. 0 sane ti;-o I want to oxproo* now difficult such decisions arc if I wu'd point to an oxo-pU weich recently was quoted f.jre, .ad I wean tho olgfe hundred innate* in a prioon in Africa who woro infectod wit* uil^ria. I OncH want to point to this oxaaplo in ordor to Justify tho cxp*rii.ents which.ro under indictment hero, but I want to express t^t the question of tl« iu ortoncc of an experinont is basically end ro-ilns basically of a decis-vc importance. Sven in tint case a certain amount of fatalities ca£ to bo t£k.,a into account from the start won in¬ i' ectinc; oifit hundred people with seluria. In. voluntary nature wnich an It. to adopts nd with wnich tax innate ii*u -O - 6 ?ufc-.-3IS-5-2-FMtty Court jJ. 1. put* hlusclf ut this disposal la a relatively voluntary naturo. I don't it !• tho same if one vo id receive such voluntary natures fron poopl< vno ?utt7 Court Jo. 1 Vith roferonco to freezing experiments. 1 can only say In tnls con¬ nection tuet In <■. certain for., without saying "criminal" or "not criminal" tawy snowod their value. The Indication for that is that tho results in t.'.e j-eriC'-o .^ir yorcc voro considered as something particular end hclpod t cxi _£orleun ..ir yorco to gain years, and I think that those experiments would alto bo of uso within Dining works tdtoro n nunbor (£ fatalities occur boc uso of froocinfi. If you consider tho freezing exporinente in that li^J tho victims in offoct aro tragic, and it is to bo regretted, but with rcfcronco to subsequent periods tnls victim is a real sacrifico for words or :oybo thousands of pooplo would keep thoir llvos and prolong tholr lives bec-.use of it. JUDOS SS3RIHG: Vitnose. this question of tho nocesslty for ar. oxpori- uont, is it your view th t it is for tho State to detornlno tho extrono nocesslty for such oxp-rluunt >-nd thoreaftor thoso who sorvo tho St to aro to bo bound by that procedure? I think you can or.swor that "yos" or •r.o". VTlTeZSS: ?.il« trial snows that it will bo tho task of tho State utd.r ell circumstances to basically clarify this question in tho futuro. JUDGE SEBHI9G: Witnoss, as I understood your statements a nonont ago, Dr. 3r ndt, they woro tin t tho :hyslcian having onco bocono the soldior thereafter cust subordinate such medical-othleal views as he may h vo that -ay r.riso ir. confliet with a military ordor from bi,*or authority, is th-t true? :a tflTKSSS: I didn't wont to express it in that fora. I did not can to say that tho physician tho uonont ho boconos uodicnl offlcor should ca-ngo hi s basic attitude as a physician. Such nn ordor in tho vory same woy can go to n physician who is not a soldior. I meant it referring to tho ontiro situation as it prevailed with us in Gemmy during tho tino of nn authoritarian loadersnip. This authoritarian leadership intorferred with tho personality and tho personal foolirge of tho human being. At tho nonont as r. personality is dissolved in the concept of a collective body, overy -2571 ~ 6 Fob-ir* CIS- 5~4- Put ty Court ifo. X. iaujvd which is put to th t personality tu* to to dissolved in tho concept of a collective systo-. Therefore, tho dcnnrds of society nro put abovo — every individual hu;jui being as an ontiro con-plox, and this Individual coi*- ;.lex, the huu-n being, is conplotoly used in the intorcst of that socioty. TCc difficult tr.in#*ond sooething which is hard to understand beoio- nlly is that during our ontiro period, and Dr. Lcibrand roforrod to that, that ot thr.t no:wnt everythin,; was dono in tho interest of huaanity .^ad do taut tno individual person hrd no P e nni ng wfcrtsoovor, and the fr.rthor tho wsr proyrssiod, tho strongor did this principle thought appear that wub dosignotod at the oai as total war furc, and in accorfcnco with that tho losdorihip of tho Str.to quito generally ordorod and Aoaxndod th: t ordors bo errriod out. It Is a very tragic for a nusbor of persons not only within the framework of those oxperinents but ulso in other situations th t they »..d to work under such orders. Without consldcritg tho ontiro situation as it provallod in 0 «r~-ny, one cannot understand tho question of thoso particular ojqericents at rll. -2572- 6 Fi»b-*-SM>-l-Cro3s (FL) Court !io. I J\EGE SZERIfJG: Dr. Brandt, is it not true that in any military or- gr.nlactior., over, or* of an authoritarian Statu, there comes c point beyond which tha officor receiving an order subjects himself to indi¬ vidual responsibility, at least in the oyos of civilised society, for carrying out any .uilitary ordors, particularly if tho ordor is unlaw¬ ful or transconds tho linit of extreme military necessity? A.- There was a gonorol law stating that an officor doet^not have to carry out an ordor which ho roalisod is a crimo, but tho question with reference, to these various experiments is whothoj tho ordor con¬ es. n«d can ror.ilso what he is doing is a criac. If ho can realize it tto, according to .ay opinion, he cannot follcw the «*dcr. 1a. McHAHZY: You hov* stated that where no are concornod with an oxporiaont which is extrsosly important for tho SteU, then t!w Doctor who is diroctcd to carry out such on coq>oriaont is oxtrical and is not n aponsiblo for any death which aay occur. Is tho person who issued the order responsible in your opinion? A.- Are you referrirg to the freezing experiments and would you tell .no who gavo tha order? Q.- Ho, wo aro going back to tto hypothetical question put to you by the Tribunal which stated that an officor ordering a subordinate to carry out an oxporlmor.t, which wo will assume was of Stnto importance, that that subordinate carrying out that experiment upon unvoluntary uubjocts, so-xj of trhco died, as I recall you stated upon thano assump¬ tions the doctor who carried out tho experiment which was of Stato im¬ portance was relieved of tho responsibility beenuso of tho totalitarian State. Is that correct? A.- I said generally that in such a -2-Gro3s (FL) Court So. I responsibility far thct experiment? A.- Tixjro ia the question whcthur ho cm assume it. .Lion consider¬ ing tboce series of experiments it lust bo dependant or. who non jus¬ tified to decide about thi life the experimental subject. IX I cassidor the case of craontrntion'cases, the, according to ay opinion, the oor- aoa who is alow responsible was Hisnlcr himself for it was only liith his consent, or only on the basis of ids order such experiments woro carried through. These people attached to the concentration cojips had been hcr.dad over to him and, therefore, he boro the responsibility fer these for theso people tar thoir living or not living. If Hiaalor has given such an order, or if he ordered the execution ol such an oxpori- n*nt, the,according to ay opinion, the responsibility was with his, o responsibility which he had to assume in his position as tho snprono do- ciding am in these affairs. G.- Suppose you have a case whore ttw experiment is ordored by tho Chief of the lirfical Services of tho Luftwaffe. TJ» export, aont is carried out by tho Luftwaffe doctors, and all that Hlasalor dooe is to xftlo tho experimental subjects available to tho Luftwaffe. Does Hiaalor boar tho sole responsibility there or does tho Chiof of tho Nodical Services of tho Ljftwaffc also share tho responsibility? A.- Accord!.^ to my opinion tho rc^>onsibility in that rosooot rested with IdAfLor clone and not with tho Chiof of tho Ifedical Sor- vices of tho Air Force because without Hiualor's consent and furnishing of experimental subjects that mod* it possible to carry out such expe¬ riments. Tho Chiof of the Uudical Services of thu Luftwaffe couldn't have carriod ttea out. Ttoro is perhaps a very clear proof for tho fact that tha responsibility rostod with Kiaalor for those experiments woro carried out, so to speck, in his house within tha framework of tho con¬ centration ermp. I don't believe in this case tho i\.sponsibility bon bo attached to - 2574 - 6 Fob-!*-3f-6-3-C-ro58 (FL) Court Ko. I the Chief of tho !ixlicd Services of tho Luftwaffe. The Chief of tho &dical Services of tbe Luftwaffe could 'ut forth tho problem end the urgency but in that manner ho would have regained at a vacuum if tho person of Hi m l or, together with hi a personnel and huaar. boinga at his disposal, would hot have helped hio putting at his disposal his space in his camps. - 2575 - 6 Fob. 47 -*-7-l-«CP- Lesser Court No. 1 THE MARSHAL: Tho Tribute 1 is again in sossija. DR. SAUTBH (Counsol for the Defendant Dr. Ruff): Ur. President, bo fore •he 3rond> case is continue! I should liko to present to you the following matt, and ask you for your decision and for your assistance. On the 13th of December applied for a witnoss, Dr. Erich Hippko, that is, the forcer Chiof of the Modi Inspectorsto of the Luftwaffo. Tt&s witness was approved by the Court. His who: abouta wore unknown. I endeavored to find out the address of the witness. At t! beginning of tho trial he was at liberty -.nd shortly after the beginning of th: A trial ho had been put in a British prison in Hamburg. In response to my application ho was brought to Numbers and I was informed that the witness had Trivod hero. This witness hed also boon approved for the dofonso counsol of Cvnorrl Field Marshal Milch and hat*, been brought to Number? for him, too. In th- last few days I have ropoeUdly tclkod to the witnoss. Dr. Hippko, in order ta determine whothor I an to submit as affidavit iroo him or call him to tho witnoss stand for oxemination. Yesterday afternoon, botween 3:00 and 4:00 o'clock, I was talking to tho witness, Dr. Erich Hippko, In the interrogation room. Tho Prosecution had a Lieutenant Garrett telephone down to tho interrocj tion room and say th t I was to stop questioning the witness, Hippko, immediately, and that during tho next 8 days tho witness could not be question by any defense counsel. On the basis of this situation I ask the Prosident to ocide whether this action is correct end whether I have to accept it. Accordii to tho rules of the first Nurojor-, trial and also according to tho rulos of the present trial, if I umlcrst'-nd them correctly, a witness who has been requester by r. dofense counsel and has boon approved ani h s. been brought to Nurnberr •t the application of this defense counsel — such a witness is primarily available to this dofense counsel. I do not believe that under the rulos of African trial procedure the prosecution has the right to destroy this ri ( ht -f the dofsnse counsel because they perhaps .-.lsc want to examine the witnoss. If such a right is _ivon to the prosecution in the future-, then, in effect, ‘•K- defense counsel would no longer h-Vc my clAin to examine tho witnesses rMi » requested and to prepare for his caoe. I therefore ask for a ruling of 'ne Court on this question, which has a certain basic import: nee for the befense. As defense counsel, I do not want to claim anything for .myself wnich 2576 L 6 Feb. 4,7 -M-7-2-PKP- Lessor Court Ho. 1 is not cy duo under Aaerican Trial Procedure in a fair trial, but, on the other tend, I cannot tive up any of the ri,*ts which ar- granted at by law or by tho co'JTt-. This is especially true if I would thereby cooo into denror of being unable to complete ay document books cs e result of this delay and turn them ir • for translation. Mr. President, that is what I had to pre* ot to you. THE PRESID-AT: I hove not the facts of this situation entirely in mind. I remember aiming on order sock; days since, sequestering this witness for a period of 8 days only, after which he would be op-n to ex'i/aiivtion by any of the defonse counsel. The Tribunal will examine tho record at tho earliest possible moment and announce its ruling on tho matter. I Qoticu, however, that counsod for Defendant Ruff, on the 30th of January, advised tho Secretery General that the witness, Hippko, was no longer require! as a qitness for tho Defendant Ruff* Tho Tribunal will take this under advisement-and edviso counsel it the earliest possible cement of its ruling. DH. SAUT3t: Mr. President, may I add socothinp? V,hon Ulting to tho witnessi Hippko, I had 't first had the impression th't it would be sufficient to submi •.n affidavit free this witness end 1 had worked out tho affidavit together ■ith the witness, Hippko. At tho Inst n»ent, however, the witness. Dr. Hippko, told me that for some reasons he did net want to sign this affidavit. Thoroforc I a hr. 11 presumably have to coll the witness, Hippkw, to the stand nftur all. 1 c.y add that the sac* thing is true in tho case of attorney Bor gold, who is defending Field Marshal Milch in the trial downstairs. The witness, Hippko, ■»s also approved for him nnd he too is not allowed to talk to this witness ny core and we do not understand whether that is ri-ht or not. That is why *. are asking for a ruling of tho Tribum 1. THE PRESIDENT: It was not ey intention to indicate that counsol ■:uld be bound by this nvtico of January 30. He may stiU call the witness if he desires to do so. The Tribunal will announce its ruling on the matter sr.:rtly. Has counsel for the Prosecution anything to say in this matter? * a ‘ ^cHANET: I thind I any be able to clear up the situation to tho aitoal satisfaction of everyone. It is not correct th’t Hippko was found throur “y of defense counsel, he have been looking for Hippkc since May of and wu discovered, through our own efforts, his address in Hamburg. 2577 i it fc F-b. 47 -i*-7-3-PXP- Lesser Court !io. 1 *“ lh ° rCq ““ t ° f ““ PrJS '- c " Ui " •“ ■’■ there arruated erf kept in Kanburg '* ° '“ rt tJa * ' n ' 1 U ’ on Sroa e ht ^ Kurnberg .t our requeat. In the m*Mm, :.rt-lh of thu defend counuel applied for hha as » .itness end, of course, " node » objecti*. On thu othur hr, hi, thu Prosecution take. thu position In -.r.l, coo.-, and »1U toku . slrflnr position in thu cut of Eagur.. Hocgen, for ..--■,olu, thr.t thu Prosecution hA oucry right to interrogate uuch poruon. ufon, they aru turnud o«r to dofonuo consul, m thi. particular c-uc, duo ; »*> misurderst-nding on thu port of thu Prosecution ond thu Secretary it hoppoiud thot curtain of the defense Counsel in thi. com ok! in “ ““ ““ 1 “ t#rr0 * ,,U ' 1 "*■ — • length before ho h»d over boon aeon 1 thu Prouocutlon ond, o. a aattcr of fret, exhibited to hie u uubut.-.ntial •xoror of docununto .hlch fom thu haul, of thu record hen,; and, c. Hlppku i-o.lf ho. put it, ho 1 . no. uo confused thot ho dou.n't kno» »h-.t ho oun ..tiff to frea .unory end fro. .hot ho ha. ,„u„ in thooo docununto. Consequent! O, Prouocutlon asked thu Tribunal horu to rule tht thu Project ion h-.vo ono •'* “ i,h ° * th “ rl ^ ht «■' interrogate Hlppku. *t thu conoluuio. ! ltr,t h ' ,nrU ' 0f '.rallablu to dufunou counoul for Ruff d any other of the d.fonoo counool .-rf I think there .111 bu.no delay in rx.din with this cr.so. Dr. Bor^W ir. thu Uilch casu h-.s n.quustod th t Hlppku r = s r. witness * rr^, in th~.t fcourt an! hu h-s also n-qu^stod the rifcht to intorro^to this .iXtornoon. I hive confer^ with the prosocutor In thu Uilch wse, L Ih'^ Jn th * r-r t of thu prosecution in this wsc, th.t that is risible, but tho render of thi. wouk wu would like to h'vo Hippko * to thu prosecution for Inturrogr.tion =nd on next Uzodzy ho will bo ii blw to dofunsu counsel ? .t =ny tiao they went hia. 2578 6 FOb-lf-KBohnn (FL) Court No. I < EP-. SUSTSl: Just a ainute, please, Ur. President, I do not believe that I can oo satisfied with this explanation. It is ay opinion that this cr.se would bo aiitablo lor roaching a basic decision of r basic question.^ The following is the issue. As I understand African trial procedure, the defense is to* be put on an equal basis with the P roso- cution insofar as it is at all possible. New tho situation is as folios: I apply for a witness; Dr. Bergold also ap P Uos Tor hin. TJw wit^ss is unknown; we send one of our associates to Kruaburg and this aan finds out • the address of tho witness, then tho witnoss is brought t» Nurnborg. ”o would cssuac as a natter of courso, that ho coaoe cs our witnoss and that c onooquo.it ly he is at our disposal so that we can prepare our cas-. Wo believo that in such a cas*. the prooocution should not havo tho rifeht lo uxoaino this uitness without our presence and without our Jcnarledgo. If no work frees the principle that in general, as far as possible, defunoe is to have tf* soac rights ns the prosecution, then in ay opinion this action is not quite ri,ht. If tho case wore opposite; if i lx prosecution brought a witness boro, then the defense dooe not iicvo t.x right to say. "I will now oxnnir.o tho witness ono week for tlva do- fense and when I no finished, then tho prosecution can havo him." Of course, the African prosecution knows African trial orocoduro bettor and no dolonsc counsel are dependent on esperiur.ee in tho first trial and tho rulings of this tribunal, but I would be grateful to tho President if lids question could bo cluarod up. In ay opinion it is noo- euarjr so that tho trial can precocd quickly and without difficulty and ir. a fair mnner. Thank you. *• fcHAIST: I can only repeat, there is absolutely no disagreement I betwoun thu prosecution and tho dofonsc about their right to their onn -1 trusses md the prosecution cortainly does not take the position that it . :-a interrogate any of the dofoneo witnesses in the absence of flofenso Joursol, but it sc happens there will bo certain cases, such as in tho - 2579 - L_ 6 Feb-i*-<3-2-ZHii-lfeehac (FL) Court So. I witness. Those are just situations that will have to be worked out. as they case up. The Prosecution can do nothing .wore than take the position that ■hen we find th»a and bring t'roa to liucrnfcerg, or. our own effort, then «e have the right* to interrogate thea first excluding the right* of tho defense to interrogate then. ‘Jew, He poke was not found through tho efforts of the defense,-his address was found by ua at the Aero Jctiical Center ir. Heidelberg and we then got in touch with British authorities at Kaaburg and agents of the British authorities arrested him then and he was then brought to Kuernberg. But, by some strange coincidence defense counsel also found hia adilroso and located hLa before that time. \.*hy, it is no nore t..an a coir.ci'Jonco and I don't think t.’.ero is any fiuvdaoental disagreement as to right of the defense counsel with respect to these witness, but we nill lave to have these cases coae up froa tiae to time and they wiU just havo to bo decided upon when they arise. THE HtBSIDdiT: how, Kr. ItoKanty, can you jivo soae indication to the Tribunal no* as to the nazes these witnesses that you say you havo boon looking for and aro anxioua to get as witnoss, who perhaps may also be usod by tho dofonsa. You eentioned the name Heppko and n» Hogon. Hr. McHAHBY: Hoj.on and Heppl.o aro two that coao to oiirf; there are of course many othor numbers of possibiUties that wo listed when wo first started investigating tho matters at issuo. U drew up a list in oxcocs of 250 to 300 doctors whoa we felt oither '. ore icplicatod in so_tu uuinor or who at least had soce knowledge of the matters at issuo. Jo circulat¬ ed that Ust with tho American and British authorities to try to locate thea. Sene wore found and a groat number of them were not. .0 could nake that list availabto to the Tribunal. On the other hand, even though a ran is on our wanted list, if the defanes counsel locates him first and brings him co Juornberg as a volunteer witness, thea I as willir.- to con- - 2533 - 6 F«W-SHS-8-2-io«ban (FL) Coi»t No. I calm they have exclusive right to that « a dIffcroat vio:?. II that wore trio what you have Just said then it would sake no difference whatever to ti* prosecution who examined the witness first. If tho prosecution is interested in questioning the wit¬ ness first anti demands that wl^n tho defense counsel questions the wit¬ ness a manbor of the jroa-ciiion should bo jrosent, then the daiense should have tto oar— ri^ht, or one should say in the beginning that tho Prose¬ cution awl defense do not have the same rights and we would have t3 ad¬ just ouraclvos for that. THE PRZSHJa.T: The Tribural will tk~ the natter under adviaant end cnnounce a ruling as soon as possible. DR. SALTER: Thank you. C,.- Horr Brandt, if an order was issuod to a medical officer instruct¬ ing bin in general Urns to carry out a free ring experiment without stating the *nn~r in which the experiment was to be urformed, would you say that this nodical officer was resoonsiblo for the manner in which this oxpulaent was carried out? A.- My point of view would be according to a phmso I uood justor- day, that tho officer would have to keep the experiment on as small a scale as possible awl tu possibility of a positiv- result should bo assured; but ho is retponsible for the. mannor of oxecution of such ox- porlr.onts,since nr. experiment may be extended unnecuosarily and may ohai accompanying fjrnptaas which have no connection with the question at issue. For all these things th> person ' .rrying out the experiment would bo responsible, that is to say for the manner of execution of the o;pcri- SM’lt. Q.- Korr Brandt, is it not true that you held positions of groat poier and no»>oi»ibility in the medical aonricos of Goranny after July 19U? A.- 1th reference to the tasks which were assigned to ao, yes. Q.- Couldn't you ev^n direct German doctors to disregard the Oath - 2581 - 6 Fcb-!*-IOA-9->:iloy (PL) Court Ko. I of Hipocrates? A.- I think tho Oath of Hipocrates is not an oath which is to bo cttsngcd as a law. Oath of Hipocrates is a foraulation concerning sorcl • - 2534 a - 6 Fob--' IA-9-~-A'-loy (FL) Court Ho. I end ethical obligati crj. I do not believe that anyone is ordered not to observe tto asral obligations of a doctor. If I said anything jfcout this it was that t to ^ die el end norel attitude aust be the docisivo % thing as fir as tix. doctor is ^oncornod. I do not know whether that ia an answer to your question. That is be* I understood it. £.—Didn't you cn at least one occasion, and I now have roforunoo to a cattur other than euthanasia, diroct that ctoctors should not bt bound by a certain provision of the oath of Hipocrates, and a certain provision of the oorally accepted code of ethics for physicians? G.- I do not be Li vo that I _ssu_d any instructions, the irord in. ^ructions tiouM ooan soo. thing general, to observe anything but the rxortun'.ty to look rt the docu- QOBtT A. I Just ate it aov. .;ay I reed through it? Will ycu look r.t >age 3 of the document? Is this not ^n order frc a Hitler /living ycu authority to instruct all Gercan doctor! that they are re¬ lieved freu thoir olod^o of secrocy concerning their patients end further ivln you authority to direct thea to report confidential inf or nation re¬ ceived concerning the condition of their o. tlcnte? A. Thttu ver» not py patients. It «rs an order signed by Hitler say in r. tho following: ■I not only relieve ohysiclens. nodical nractitionero, end deatlots of thoir olodgo to socr.cy t-wdi ny Ccoalssloner-Oenorel ?rcfecsor Dr. Xnrl orendt, tut I plr.ee upon then the binding obligation to adviao hla - for ny own lnforcatlon - lmcdUtoly after a final diagnosis hr. established a ■oriouo disease, a dioenao of ill-boding chrracter, with a neroonallty holding a lofdinjc poeitlon or a position of responsibility in the State, the knrty, the Vehrsccht, in ind.uatry, and .o forth. (signed) Adolf Hitler" Q. You passed thia order d.vn to all physicians, doctorc, and. dentists in Corn any through tho agency of Dr. Conti, didn't yc/ul A. I ^ysolf did not onto ,on tho order, but rs far ns I recall, Martin Boroann passed on this »rd«r frou Hitler and. Martin Boronnn or .bably addod the necessary words so that it was prod/ iaed ra nocossnry. q. Voll, look rt the second p<.„-«. That's n lottor fr«n Tr. Conti to tho heads of the nsdicel chambers, dated 9 January 1943, "Subjoct: Fuehrer Decree on Suspension of r'lo.^o to Secrecy in special erses. Oentloien; I an sending to you enclosed c Fuehrer Decree which I received fr» ''refossor Dr. Brandt." Wouldn't that indicate that you erased the order do^n? a. It ie possible that I passed it on. 25 <* -2586- C-«rt S^. 1 6 7sb *.7-«-10-2-Sa<-S i na buck Q. And that dees relievo German nhyoicians fro." one if tho nornally ac ¬ cepted principles of nodical practice, doesn't it? A. In special cases. Q, Did you ever relluvc doctors froa their code of ethics in any other instances? A. I did not fr>s thee in this case either. It was a clear or«rontly did not oonsider then fundamental. Q. Wasn't the very -surpoao of requiring you to bo inforned. so that you could at.viee Hitler? A. Since I was subordinate to bin Personally, the -mrotsc va> that I could inf ore hin. Didn't this Fuohror decree cf 28 July 1942 enpower you to intorveno in c responsible canner? A. Within tho framework of t>* assi.pir.ccts *iven no it would havo boon possible. Q. If Encr.loeer had cor.c to you on 1 August 19*2 and told you tho de¬ tails about tho typhus experiments in Suencnwrld, what would you h^vc done? A. It is not clear to no in what forr. Handlcowr *mlfi hrvo described these experiments to ne. That cones bade to tho noint v hich I nentionod once before this uernin*;, discussing the basic attitude towrrd experiments, *\ ., that the person who conducted the experinonte, the causes and so forth, -2537- Court lo. 1 g Jab 47-H-1CK—LEk-S inr tuck v*ro n-t discus sec yet. I cssu-c that Eandloser's description cf the oxperl- sects. If ho had kn-vn It, v:uld have bien different fron the one vhich has been given here. crl::inrl er-x rinent. He denies such knowledge. Ve will ettennt to prove, end I think ve have plrerdy -2538- Court So. 1 6 Tab 47-H-10-*«-i3i-B lncbuek Trowed, that he did hare knowledge, but he denies It end I now vent hin to aaauae that knowledge ie brought hcce to his by acceone who Is eubordinetod to hln In eoce decree end try to get en anaver froa hla which will givo ua aoae Indication of the atepa he would then have taken. THL ehiS I3ZET: Tho uao by counsel fee oroeecutlcn of the nace of the defondaht Rendloaer hna no effect uoon the Tribunal. The Tribunal understands that thla la alnoly t hypothetical questiofa. The nan* of nny^nerticulnr defendant al^ht well hr.we been submitted but the Tribunal urdorairnd® orxctly what the oroaecutlor. Intend* by hla questi n and the Mfe of the neae of tho defendant Randloaer la entlroly wlth<»t prejudice tc hia. -25S9- 6 Fg b—^-DJG-11-1-? u tt y (FL) Court So. I BY !Xr. 'fcHAKSY: Q.- Son, ui tress, tell us shat you would hive done if yor had re¬ ceived this information? A.- If I had received this information, I would have rocctod to it in a cortair. fora, but this wsuld have had nothing to do with the. pos¬ ition *ich I hold at tint tins. Hy position in respect to fr. Hcndloser at that tine was not in anyway that of aubcrdinatico of Handlbtxr to oc. That is a decisive factor in this question. If 1 disregard ay pos¬ ition at tto timo, if I nssuae that the year was 1941? I woulu first hr.vo triad to [rot aon. inforcction and find out exactly what hid hnppon- ed and what Lx; reasons wore, and in soce loro possible to .* I would probably have tried to clear up the situation if it was described to .x as critical. With rogard to ay position r.» C&a-issioner General and Hcndlos-r's position, my position in resect to Handlocer, ay position in 1942 v;nn clear that it t.-ao a mxation of ooordiirtion of general needs with xv- fp.ct to the Civilian Health S-rv'.ce, and within tlx framework of this work, I could have tnhjn action if it ur.s r> special task which !iail been assigned to me. C,.- /ould you have gor*. to Hitler? A.- I rould probably have gor.e to hi-i after I had discovered what *is going or. by ay sc If. Q.- Do 70 U think your influence w re vent experiments would hove been limited in its effect. As far ".s I nc concerrud, it is an open question whether in ouch • on actual ease I could tavo pxovuitcd an arporlaunt or not. C,.- Didn't you concern yourself at all with medical experimentation on human beings during th> tiou you woro General Coraissioar? ^ A.- You -ay bo referring to the letter of 1943 concerning hopatitis cpidonica concerning which I said yestordajr or day before. fcat it is pot clear to me to chat extent this letter was writ ton by Granitz date t;x. first of Juno. Up to that tiau I ted promoted research in tho field of epidemic.'., r.t first, and ttnt to clear up the virus question 1 had sug¬ gested to Grnnitz thet experiments should be carried out. Thus I has for- aally brought into connection wltfe those experiments after ay time in 1942. ./oil, witness, I Bgv« to get a different picture nee about this 2391 6 Fc b-l^^HU-ln-Put*.7 (FL) Court No. I letter thin the coc I received froe your direct examination. Do I urcor- st-rd tint you nos admit that you spoke to Crawitz and 3uggcst_d to him that cxp-rlionts be carried out or. concentration cnap iiwxtcs in con- zvjction with Jaundice virus? 9 % A.- Ho, You did not understand ac correctly. I said when I began this sentence that this assusption nay hav., criginntcd with this letter. Tso or three days ego I said that it is cy opinion since I ftid not dono any work in connection uith hepatitis ooidcaica beforohand that there was probably confusion iktc, but at the oaucr.t I cannot prove it, of course. I pointed out that om jear lator on the cane question of hepa¬ titis cpidocdca :!£alcy Court Sc. 1 part ir. the friedrv. of the decree In the year 19Ui. Frick maybe had some kind of lea dration about itj but when I beoame Reich Ccseissioner Frick had ix>t been Reich Minister of the Interior for a year and a half, no ho spoko aa a Reich protector for Bavaria and Moravia, so I djn't know if he oould overlook a situation like thatl * Q Did the decree of August 19Ui give ycu any power in addition to that which you had as a practical natter on the 5th of Septesfcer 19U3t A He said that the authorities at that tine wero not oRxosod and he therefore gavo ne the responsibility to oarry out the tasks which wero assigned and tho basis for tho aasignaent was the docroe of July 19U2. Q Well, precisely what additional powers did you recoivo in tho dooxee of 25th August 19Wi? A Tho decree stated that in order to carry out ry task I had tho right of dreotive to those agencies which were dealing with questions of nodical acrvicoo, that is Stato, Party and Axrxxi Forces. q Conti really knew he was your subordinate aftor this deoroo, didn't he? A Keithor Conti bocane ny subordinate on the basis of this doerso or Gancralsiabsoberst Kandloser. If it had been one it would hado been the othor. Q Didn't Conti, as a natter of fhot, subordinate himself to you aftor this docroo of 25 August 19U*? ‘ A No subordination was mentioned in this docroo. This decree was not a docroe which creatod any Ministry of Health where I became its chief, but on tho strength of this Jocree =y possibilities of functioning were extended, — and the word "extended" probably wouldn't be quite right - "Strengthsnod" •wild bo better. I have stated that the decisive thing for tho creation of this decree was the attitude cf Conti, who prohibited his associates to : ti lid no in ny tasks which were assigned no by the Reich. % -2602- Court I 6 Fcto-A-G=S-l5-l-3ro33-LJG Q* Foil, that is ifcat I Say. After this decree, Conti was no longer able to put up any objections, was he? A. Certainly ho could raise objections. Wo wore not concerned that I becooe his superior in the Ministry of tho Interior but wo were concerned thfc whonever I roffoivod any assignment I could only carry it out with the air of othor institutos. The budget of ny office was kept so low that it was ir^oesible to carry out the task which I received. As I just centioned, the work I had in ny office Planning and Econccy, it was necessary to extend it by aid of tho Ministry of Econony, Ministry of Speer, and naybo use Industry itself. Thj Four Tear Plan at that tino no longor playod a decisive rolo. Sinco, how¬ ever, that was not possible, tho situation was that tho tasks were carried out with tho holp of cortain parts of those agencies. But I did not becoso the suporior of tho Ministry of Speer, tho Labor Minis¬ try, and the saco was true in relation to Dr. Conti. If a demand was put to mo to carry out sene additional nodical care, for instance in the Ruhr territory, I could only do this with tho support and adninls- trativo holp of tho Civilian Hoalth System, Dr. Conti on one sido and the agency of Gonoralcborst’bsartt Handlosor on the othor sido. If one of theso parties rejected such aid, tho carrying out of measuros *hich I had to carry through was cade isspossible. Khonevor I took ovor such a task I was always responsible for its carrying out and I could only bo thnt if I received aid free tho two participants accord¬ ingly, but thore was no relationship of superiority. Q. This decree rupresontod southing of a triumph over Conti and 3onnann, did it not? A. “no circunvonting of Bornann could not cemo about by tho signing of this decree. Q. But ho was opposed in fact to you, was he not, Kerr Brandt? A. Tcs, that was so. 3. So it would bo true to say that the issuance of this Third Fuehrer Doc roe did constitute something of a triumph ovor Bornann on your part? - 2603 - 2603 a 6 7e'3--r- SIS- 15 - 2 - Gro % a Court ; o. 1. it la In reference to tho talk which I had to carry out and which I had to tJw over. The notorial work which I hiA to carry out went far abovo any personal feeling and certainly above cy fooling towards an oneny. q. Herr Brandt, you do protest so such that I taink I nay have to put a document to you. Z havo aero in front of so the ulnutcs of tho roport of party sc-bor, Dr. Gross, to the Holchsleitor, dntod 6 Octobor 1944J wr.ich says "prosent relationship between Dr. Conti ond Professor Bornann it suen that Dr. Conti at the request of Bornann and Kinnler is to koop his position as R«-ich Couniesioncr fo; Health. In tho npnntlao Dr. Conti has subordinated hlssclf to Professor 3r. ndt. Thorcforc, Bornann drops Dr. Conti altogether.■ I ask you t,sin if this T-.ird Puchror Docreo doosn't roprosont something in the nature of a trluuph on your own part ovor souo very powerful forcos th. t wero opposing you? ... I c. n only ropoat what I havo said before. In such n enso tho question of notarial necessity is uore important than any personal fooling. I know at the tit-c after this dogroo, without roforrlng to thoso ovonts that y.u havo Just contionod. I knew at that tino I had hardly any contact with H rtln Bortnnn. Tho question of a subordinate of Conti undor ao aroso but it novor case about and cortalaly w.-s novor intondod by tho dooroo. Othorwiso ssao othor titlo, soao othor position would have originated than Reich Couuiosioner. Tho position of Conti and Gonoraloborwtabnrzt Hond- loscr wore oxoctly tho stao to do. Thoro was no talk about that whntsoovor. Did Hitlor ovor show his rpprociotlon of your good work by gifts of oonoyf A At one tine I roedved oonoy froc tho Puohror. ^ When? A Perhaps vns in the year of 1943 , or perheps I 9 U 2 . But. I do think it was I 9 U 3 , but it say havo boon I 3 UI*. But. I think it is norc perhaps 1944 than in 1942. $ How such aoncy wore you given? A At that tlno I received nonay amounting to 50,000 narks. And, about 30,000 regained for sysolf because of certain expenditures I had at that tine -2604- 6 February-A-OJG-l^-3-Grcss Court No. 1 Q Did you have tc pay any inccnc tax co this racnoy? A No. I did not have to pay inccoe tax. Q For what reason was the ocney given to you? A )fy pay as escort physician I have sinco the year 1934 was very % scarce. I received a oonthly additional salary - I dca't .mew hew it was designated - of 350 narks per aonth. Then I received ay foes free the clinic, that is, what 1 earned through cy activities there. This sura was increased to 750 aarks durine the War. Uy personal expenditures, boceuso of the docrease of ay incoeA *iich cans about aftor th^ beginning of tho bar, were in a different relationship* At that tine I p>t into dobt and the Fuehrer knew about it. Consequently, I receivod this sun of noncy. Q Did you say that you received 750 narks a year as General Coral 33 - icner? A I never nenticned tho rcount 750.jaarks with Reich Coraraissioner. You asked ao for what reason 1 received this sun and I said that at first as escort physician 1 received 350 aarks and that this sun at the boginning of the bar was increased to 750 mrxks. When I bocarae Conrdasloner General this sun dropped out and I received, I think, 1200 nrrks, that is monthly end not yocrly. Q New, Herr Brandt, you have already mentioned that you were a raonbor of tho Presidential Council of tho Reich Research Council? A A ncabor of tho Prosidil Council of the Reich Research Council. Q hhnt year did you bococe a a«cb«r, 1942? « 1 boeace a ntuber in the year 1942. That's right. Q And Gocring was the Frcsident of tho Reich Rosonrch Council, was he not? A Coering was president. Yes. Q There were twenty-one ntnberc -1 the Prosidial Council, were thoro ret? A I wouldn't knew that. I didn't count then. I cnly know about it fren the documents that are available h<-re and it shews that there were twenty-one if they were all listed. -26C*- 6 Februrry-A-OJG-15-A-Grcas Court. Bo. 1 Q Conti v.3 a ateber, wfca he r.ot? A Yea, Conti waa a 3 ccbor of that Preaidial Council. Yea. * Q Bonaann? A I don't knew who the individual nttafccra wore. There is* a liat % available arxng your documents *ere they are all liated. I don't know who exactly compiled that liat. In the Preaidial Council of that Reich Research Council, that ia to aay, a aecting of that Council nevor took place and I never loamod that any such netting cane r.bout. It waa in the rutujm of 19A2, subsequent to the decree giving the Reich Research Council to Goering, thero waa an intrcductory neeting of the Reich Research Council in ita entirety ■here about 150 to 250 persons attended. That took place in tho Ministry of Aviation. At that tine no differentiation waa nedo whether anyono waa a Preaidial Council ceefcer or Plenipotentiary and I cannot aay ».ho tho in¬ dividual moabora wore. - 2606 - 6 Feb-il-JF-l6-l-Lesscr Court I Q. Horr. Brcndt, the docusent which you hcv. reference to nos obj.ctcd to and consequently it is not in the record; so, therefore, I ecu having to you -a fow questions about the R.ich Rusu.rch Council and the ambers theroof. If you do not know, than sisply say so, v-ry shortly, and we will procood* Ves Riailcr a richer of the Prasidinl Council? ... I do not know that. Q. Keitel? * A. I cannot say* I cculd only say on tha basis of the list which I saw hero anc which I do not know whether it is correct* q. oil, you roxnber Hentcl? ... .enrol, yes. Q. .jxl ycu rc.fe.sbor Osenborg? ... Osonborg, yts. q. So we have 6, cumting .^njol and Csenbcrg. They nre ell doctors, aren't they? ... Csonbor;, was certainly not a physician *nd '-enrol was not a physicJ an oithur. q. eo only 2 doctors on the i-rosidial Council, ?e tT as you know. ... ..s far as I know, th.r. m.re only 2 physicians thv.ru• I do nit know that Os.nburg .r Itonrol were in that irosidlal Council. I * s in a Chip to¬ gether with Cs.nb.rfs and I was of tho opinion th~t ho was th.ru on th. brsis of his activity in the planning Offico within the Reich Research Council, but, :f cJUTS., I jey b_ wrong. q. Did y-,u ku.w that the Dof ndant Siov.rs was deputy to . enrol in his capacity ns th. . rma^.cr of ... ... I die not know that at the tiio. q. Y u Icnuw that th. oper tin suction of th. R.ich Res.arch Council was divided int scientific depart ^nts Xiclos of pl.nipotuntiari.s, don't you? ... Th.r. w.ro certain ne.ads of usp.rt '.p rUi r.ts and certain plenipoten¬ tiaries. q. -nc’ in thus. .Xpert or sci-ntific rtex-nts th.y w.re cenc.rned with -2607- 6 Fcb-..-JP-l6—2-LjS3cr Court I a greet rnnbcr of thirds oth_r then _*»dc-l r~ search, weren't they? For sxaaplo, thuy ha a do part-*, nt on physics, choaistry, mathcoatics, motels, engine ring, n^riculture, forestry, an:, goo-physics, did they not? — I hare soon a list ho«e and because cf that list I saw the nun-rcus kinds of departaants rtiich existed within tha entire organisation of the Reich Research Council, Q. Her you re.:u--bur the naye Sauerbrvich, den't you? Ywa kncw*whc he was? V A. Yes, I know that. Q. .Csn't he twad of t hj scientific dep-rtr>;nt for nodicino of tho Roich Rose ireh Council? A. Ho was the hoad of the scientific department and I think the nano was •classical ijcicino". Q. And in tho fluid rf plcnipetonti-ri-e you had Schroibor ns plenipo¬ tentiary for upi-’eniics. I think y«u havu already at'tcd that, havon't you? ... Yes, plenip. tentiary for th- c :ib*ttin; .f epidondcs I think it was. Q. And Blcno for enneor? ... Yos. Q. .nd did ynu know a nan ivuiod Jotton? ... Jotton - Jetton, yes. Q. Ho was plenipotentiary fer lung diseases, wasn't ho? ... Yes, the sc-callod lurv dur - -iecasv. q. De ye u recall any other heads of sciuntific departments r 'lunipotun- tiariws c ncciMinfc .-uilcino? -• Ko. Q. .s'ow, doctor, I put it to ycu th t ther„ wore cnly two ambers of tho Presidiol Council of tho Reich Research Council who wuro dcctcrs and thoro wero cnly four sae-ibers of scientific dop-rtu._nts »r fields of plenipotentiaries who ■cro deters. I ask ycu, weren't each cf you . -ntlorson fssiliax with itho wDrk th t the oth-r nu was doing? ... I don't think so. - 2608 - 6 ?eb-WP-l6-3-Les3ar Court I Qi Dicin't you ever c -nsult with Soucrbruch, Bloae, Schroibcr, or iny f then? ... ;.s far as I roneeber I did net speak to Saucrbruch ab.ut cny ques¬ tion: with reference to the Reich Research Council. I occasionally not Sauerbruch but that was costly in connection «ith conplotcly difforent questions, xroly of z c: nsultntivo nature. Neither die* I speck to Blia, nb ut questions cf cancer rcs».*rch as f-r as I recollect, And I certainly never spoke to S Schrclbcr ?b ut tho c. chatting :f opidcnica. ;.t the beginning of the wnr I eccasi.nelly saw Schrciborj After 19U2 or 19U3 1 hardly saw hi:a nftor that. :.a fir as I recollect, I saw Hr. Jetton only cnca end that was at e period of ti o whon the Instituto for the ccnbittlng of lung-dust disease had net yot oxistod. Q. Did Honxol ever c-nsult with >.u? ... I talked t: oniel regarding general academic quostions. >Jon*el was not -nly th- busin-ss ennsgor and prosi'ent cf tho Reich Rosoarch Council but his inportent tr.sk was the leadership .f th. Department scionco within tho •'inistry of Education and this deportment c ntainod tho Sub-dopnrtront Kodicino, I spoke t; hi_; with reference t; this Sub-depart; lent Kodicino within tho ‘inistry f iSrtuc ti;n btt as far as 1 to n I never discussed any research tasks with him. Did you knew anythin, -b ut cr have any c.nncction with tho assignraont issu.d by t!w oich Research Council to Rascher t: conduct dry freezing experiment*? ... I die not kn w that. I learned ab.ut Uv.se axperirents hare for tho first tino. Q. Did y u kn.w nnytning ab ut r have any c ..t.octi^n with the assignment issued by the Reich Research Council o- ilirt i Strasbourg to conduct gas cx- fCriionts? ••• I di ' not participate in this * 33 i^naont an - 5 I did not kn:w about it. i heard ab ut -:irt's activity an.' the work itself because of tho final report -2609- 6 Fob-. JP-16-ti-iA- :sor C urt I which Dr. Slevora brought to ae in I arch of 19Ub. But even at thot time I iid not knew that this resignaent and this work ware done in eonnocti n with tto Raich P_i search Council, or < urc initiated by the Reich Research Council. Q. Di-’ you kr. w anything abcut the support of the Reich Research Council and th« Luftwaffe of Hasgen's typhus, yellow febor and. jiundico research? ... !*c. 1 only learned about the a. experiaents ho re, on tho basis of djeuaontary ovidenco. ^ Q. Wore you or Rostock or any c«Vj in y.ur cffico connectod in any way X with the research conductod by Raschor, Hirt, and Hongon, or any .no of thon? ... I don't know no ut that. Q. Did y-.u kn. w that c .ncontmti.ncr p inentwS were boing systematically usod in Ger.rny f r .cdical exp-ri v-ntati n? A. Mo, I did n.'t kn-w that. Q. Did you never hear anything ab ut such uxpiri;}nts wled/jo “.b ut tho use of concentration canp iirates for exp.rinont -,1 jwrp:ccs. - 2610 - 6 Fob 47-A-S’ -17-1-lwohcn C< urt He. 1 A, Any kncwlotlro, ifr.ich wont boyend tfco frcxio of whet hr.a boon plrcod in tl o Indictoont against no, is n^t knewn tc no; Tho ontiro ^-.torial ernprisos r. nu:i>or cf experiments end thoro oxporJnonts woro net k.cwn tr no. Jays rgc, I dofinod ny attitude towards tfcg individual oxpcrinor.ts. Boyend that, nothin" bocano known tc r.o ab« ut any oxporinonts end, apart fron that, I know nrthinc r.b ut ttoso oxporinonts, hew thoy w-ro c rriod rut, olthor nunor- ic-lly cr to whr.t extont thoy woro or.rriod thrru^h. Horr Brandt, is it truo that Hit lor had ordorod that criminals fii-ht bo uaod fir nodical oxporlnonts? A. I assuno tl at sue! an ordor was issuod by hin, Hinnlor, on Ms wn initiative, wrull ‘not hr.vo d'no that without bolng’ covor- o.l by Kitlor. "urin;- r. provlrus interrogation, I atetod that, nccor- :in tc ny opinion, it hepponod subsoquont tc tho throat rporntion which ho oxp-rioncod in 1935, when ho said th. t ronorally it would bo ccrroct t use crininals in order tc clear nodical prcblons with tholr aid, Ko did net rop-at thr.t in any prociso cr basic caso, but it was his crncopticn that it was ccrroct. That is why I have fefco pinion, abevo all, after cettinc to k. cw all cf tho ovidonco horo, thr.t Hirnlor was only carryln" than t hr curt after boin'-. m vomod by Kitlor aftor ho saw to it that ho was covorod. u c you knew, as a nut tor ef your knenlodco, that Kitlor ovor issuo-l such, an 'r’.«r? A. I nov r loamol tho fact that ho Issuod such rn erdor; this is merely a crnclusien and rotrcspoctivcly apoakln-, which I acs- uno is corroct. ^id ycu ov^r hoar Kitlor discuss such a natter? A. Nr, I noV'.r ho. rd hin 'dscuss it, oxcopt in c*onoral stator.onts abut such a natter. n .. 7oll, wkr.t wero his "onoral statonents? 'hr t I said bof ro. According tr :iy rpini'n, tc ok placo in 1335 whoh ho discussed tho question rf oxperinonts cn human boin^s -2611 Court I 6 rub U7 -A-CT-17-2 -iiee'nan-LJj as such. It happened without any particular case or without indicat- i-g an 7 cortain procedure, ithother he caae back to that subsequently or during the war, I do rot rcccrber. At any rate, it did not occur in ay prosonco, but I an of the conviction that he did that especially in view of the personality of . Hi mm l er. Q. Aral you state it is also your conviction that this oust have been so bocauso even Hlmlor would rot have undertaken such things without being covered by Hitlerj is that right? A A. I only drew a parallel with Martin Bornann and I should like to ronlnd you about ay discussion regarding Pastor Nloaooller. It is possiblo that tho discussion between Hianler and the Fuohrer could have bcon carriod on in a similar Banner. It nay well have boon that tho Fuohror said sooetning liko that quito generally and Hiraalor thon urderstood it and appliod it to sono specific caso and thon on his cwn initiative continuod to deal with it. Q. Horr Brandt, I know you havo boon interrogated many tiros, but I would liko to ask you if you roroebor having boon interrogated on this sano subjoct, about a Hitlor order, in August of 19U5, possi¬ bly by a British officor. A. I don't know that any ordor wont fren Hitlor in that fora in 19U5. Q. You did not understand do. I askod you if you remonbor having been intorrogatod by a British officer in 19li5 on this sane subject cf radical experiments? A. In August of 19li5; it is possible. Q. Horo is a report I havo in front of me, it indicates that you stated: first, thfc Hitlor hioself had ordorod condemned criminals to bo used for rodical experiments; and socondly, that nobody should bo purdshod for obeying orders; is that an accurate account ? A. I can do nothing with thoso two sentences. THE PRESIDENT: Has the witness boon shown a copy of this Document in German? 2612 6 Fob i7-;.-S - 17-3-*doGhm Court He. 1 *T.. I 1 CEAHEY: If it plor.so tho Tribunal, I don't attach such in- p-rtanco tc tho ovi..onco nccoaaary md I will just withdrew tho question. This ia aiuply cn intorregatim rop rt, it ia not a verbatim report cf the ^ntorregatien. It shows arch 24, 1945 by ^ejer °ill. It wna deno by on organizaticn known as FIAT; a Field Intolligunco i-lliod Tochnicr.l organizaticn. KB PRESIuEFT: ‘.Jhoro we a it node? * MR. hCKAHEY: At a coup known as buatbin r. thor cloao to Frnnk- furt. I on net suro of tho oxr.ct neno cf tho city, hewovor, wo will net offer tl ia w ccunont in ovidonco. I on si :ply trying tc rofroah tho witnoea' roc: lloction end I on asking hiu new r.bi ut this Hitlor order and whether cr net it w-.a actually iasuoil. IKE P;£Snr;NT: Tho c unsol can r.al: tho witnoaa if ho knowa of ony auch order and if ho rononbora any such ordor ut this tiuo. BY MR. ’ICHANEY: Q. K orr 3 rundt, havo you t< Id ua all 7 CU knew about thia erdor cf Kitlor, about which you ate.tod it wr.a ycur conviction th t it wr.a isauod; do ycu knew cny uro ab ut it th;n you havo clroady told ue? A. I den't kr.< w an erdor in tlr.t foru, With roforonco tr thia intorrogatii n cf Certain 0111 , which ?• aaibly originated after a nu.:'jur cf diacusaicnb, it must o a fc mulaticn wl ich ho nr.de for Ua enn pm*pesos , m.rcly , a ropotitirn tf what I havo arid, iheso quoatiens wv.ro put tc no at tho sar»o tiuo that tho chart or¬ iginated abtut uy functi ns and physicians when nly partly truo statements *oro ru-do. M. iiorr -randt, did ycu kn> w a Kcitol trier that tho amy wr.a to t ve nothing to dc witl -xpvriiwnts cn bmr.n beings? A. i»o, I den't know that erdor cither. Q. If ho did net in fact iseuo auch an order, hew do ycu oxplain t -voitcl know that nodical o::. riuonts wt.ro boing carriod cut r. human boin\a and that you did not? -2613- 6 ?cb V7-A-S -17-4-Hcchr.n Court Hr. 1 A. This possibly is sinil r t' yesterday's ronrrks -.Ik Ut non to. 1 institutions in the eastern territory. Thicso thirds c uld hr.yjo been iiacuasod during c'nforcncoa 'n tho situ fcien in connection with tho . ily rop rta » n tho vr rxcua illinosaoa , otc., end r.t such opport¬ unities thoao oxpurinonta crulu woll *>o nontioct, in connection with hunen exporiuents an*, s. forth, thcro was nothin; ncro bctwcon uc and Dlcto. Q -tat was this scruu that i*c was tc manufacture? A I cannct say exactly what kind ef suruu it was. I -ily raicrior cn institute in which ho wanted t nkc arranccounts t bo able tc produce various scrums. Fr n later discussions I knew that ho c nsidoroc! dcvclep- iaj various substitute pr>duots, but I cabinet civo any exact infenction a’: ut thnt either. Q bill y;u lc k at the see nd sentence in tho soc.nd paragraph where it starts, "In particular, irefesser bi ne sees an obstacle -n the onplcy- :.cnt rf the Chcaical h'arfarc Section cf the --ruy Ordnance Cffico. There— f re, he wishes tr ;iakc the suppoct*:n t. tho Rcichs liarstel and - 2616 - 6 Feb —-16-3-fcrrcw C;urt H,. 1 C acxdcrst .r fcsszr 2ra!t ttu-.t tl caaccinticn be di 53 lived ad he bo knitted, net thr.uji the inter.* aiti.n cf the Chcoicel .1st f-rc Scctlcn f tl'.o .j-_y Ordnance Office, t' requisition cir.:lanca fer ox.-cri:xntel .ur.. sea directly freu the ..ir F.rco .lniatry.- .ihy enzuld ho aontien 7 ur rxox in c nnccti-n with e cati.n that the ..ssacir.ti n dlitxer’.citcr bo diea.lvod? -2617- Court I 6 Feb !7-*TD-3$-Wttnabuek A. I do not know. Perhaps ke hiftself will be best able to say why ho did that. Ho certainly did not report the natter to m, and I could even asstna that ho did not report it to the Reich Marshal. Tho nast, Blitzabloiter, I learned of for the first tine through this docu¬ ment, 1309, itself. I never h^ard it beforo. Q. Did you have any connection with this chemical warfaro section? A. Chemical warfaro? With the choedcal warfaro section I had a certain amount of connection under the anti-cheaical warfare program which began in 19U*. It was a tooting station for the necessary dofonse materials, and in connection with Luftwaffe Ministry’s own testing stations, but it was certainly a different group of peoplo who wrkod on these natters than the ones contacted with this raattor. Q. Well, Horr Brandt, I rather thought that you had something to do with chemical warfare and Lost problems beforo Peering's order of 1 March 19U1*. How long woro you connoctod with this chemical warfare soction of the Array Ordnanco Qffico? A. Thoro was a Colonol Hirsch, whom I boliovo I net for tho first tire In the alddlo of March »Uli. I did not know him before then. Q. Well, Herr Brandt, this document is dated 23 February 19hh, and I oust assume that you woro therefore interested in chemical war¬ fare problems beforo the order of 1 March 19Ui, that has already been oentioned in the record. A. I have already said that this question was certainly outside of that. Tho decree, because of which Mr. Slevers visited me at that tiae, it was dated 1 Harch. In ny opinion the question of Blitzableiter and ay connection wl th the Blitzableiter is to be traced back to Blaae's idea, i#io approached re about his general institute, and the reference that he wants to report to the Reich ilarshal and Oeneralsarzt Dr. Braixit tr..it the association will be dissolved and so forth has no Justification in ay opinion, has no basis in fact. Mr. 3lose could not have had arty ■eason to think that I had anything to do with the central office for tr.e *W K Prufstolle 9" before 19Ui, and I myself do not remember that 1 aet these gentlemen for ar^r other reason. 2618 5 Feb* U7-A-* . , rc-19-2-JJl»buck Coart !fa* 1 Q Herr Branit, did you hare ary connection with any experiments with c 38 prior to 1 March 19UU? A In the fall of «U3 I was info reed about general laboratory experiments which a Professor Bickenbach had sale. These were experiments such ashad been iono in Strasbourg and I belief in Heidel b erg too, and these are the only ones which occur to no in this connection* I also know that I no longer recusabor the dato I was informed in a conversation that experiments had been oonduoted on cadots in the Military Medical Aoadery, but these are things *iich had nothing to do with the problem of W H Prufatelle 9. Q Upw did it ccno about that Cickonbach’s experinents were reported to you? What interests did you havo in his gas experiments? A I had r» intorest in his gas experiments, I not Bickenbach for a noth or reason, for a different reason, and then whon wo net again ho infornod rao about what ho had done, q And what did you do with respoot to nickcnbach'a reports? Did you havo any othor association with hin? A Later I helped him to arrange a laboratory in Strasbourg* q And thit's the laboratory wo heard ooat mention about fron ono of the witnossos fron Strasbourg, was it not, Herr Drandt? A I assune that it was tho eano one* q Do you rocall that the witness Schmidt testified that thoro woro runors in Strasbourg th-.t Bickenbach was experimenting with gas in ono of the old forts? A Yes, I rocenber that. Q Do you also recall that he said that those rumors included tho use of briar, beings by Uickenhach? A !fc, I do not reneeber that fron the testimony of the witness Sobnidt, and it ni;ht havo boon a rarer, I Jon«t know, but it is improbable since Zdckenbach hinsolf ted approached ne on the question of ardnals and I nyself aade eveiy effort to get suitable experimental animals. And I do not believo that the fact that crdoal experinents are conducted Justifies tho conclusion that ai ring! experiments are ccaiucted in order that human experimento nay be Court I 6 Feb !i7-A-A7I>*19-3— Ninabuck - LJG conducted. The problem la rather 6f the opposite sort. Animal experi- aents are conducted because one is convinced that they are right in theaselvos and can lead to a result, Q. Did you ever visit Bickenbach's experimental station in Strasbourg? , A. I do not know that ho had an experimental station in Strasbourg. I looked at an electrical apparatus in Strasbourg,the cyclotron. I be¬ lieve it was one of the only ones of this type that we had in Gemanyj it was finished but it was not used, Q. Do you deny any knowledge that Bickerbach did experiments on human beings with gas? A. He conducted aniaal experiments and he approached no expressly in order to obtain animals. I was only able to help him to a Halted extent. It was very difficult for no to obtain animals, ard before I set hla, Bickerfcack had only conducted animal experiments. The quostion of huaan experiments was something rtiieh was not diacuesod at this time. The experiments which he had begun before the war, I bolleve he wantod to continue, and these experiments were significant but only in rather theoretical beginnings. Q. But so far as you know, Bickerbach did not experiment on huaan beinge? A. Bickerbach did not cenduet any experiments on human beings. Q. »fay woro you so interested in Bickenbach's work that you went to considerable trouble to secure experimental animals for him? A. The task which he had sot himself was a special one and it ■weed quite Justified to support this work. I was only ablo to help bin in tho year 19 UL, after ho himself had established this laboratory for himself. Q. Let's look again at the document before you, 1309; at tho botten of tho second paragraph we find the language: "Especially necessary is an examination of our vaccine, the pestilential virus, plague vaccine in particular. Experic-srts mist, accordingly, be made on human beings. 2620 Court I 6 Feb ii7-*-An>-19-3-HiMbuck Furthamore certain misconceptions concerning the effect of naxianaa dose* of several poisons can bo corrected only by experiments on huaan Dairgs. As scon as Professor 31 coo has conferred with the Reich garshal and Generalsant Professor Brandt, he will notify me." • 2620 -A- 6 Feb. i/^WT>l£-L-tfLmbuck Court Ifc* 1 Did dcoe confer with ycu about these virus vaccina experiments on human bainrs? A No. Q Did ha eonfor with ycu about the poison experiments? A to. Q Lot*s torn to the next page of tho docunentj tho memorandum dated 22 Hay 19Ui directed to Dlitzableitor. In tho last aents cf criminals tried by ordinary Genian o urts? Q Yeu were a c- ndcnnod crirdnal in April of 19U5, wero y.u net? A Yos. A Q Sentenced tc death f*.r tho allogod treason; is that ri:;ht? A Yes. x Q I assuco that yeu da not regard yeur trial os a fair cno — that is the trial for troasen? A No, because the contenco Jiad been established boferoliand* Q Korr dr ant, cf your ctm personal experience with Oernan cri:ilnal Justice, oast yeu net conclude that Inindreds cf thousands cf c neentratien «... inuates were improperly incarcerated an.*, ccndccnod t. death? A in the ' asis f ny nm coqioriwr.cc I ai. cinvinccd that that is so. 0 H u cany e.nccntrati .n ca^:_ s havo you visited? .. 1 !i! not visit c.ncentrati n cai^s axactly; .nee I was with !r. 3ic!:cnr.ch; I was -utsidc the emv cf llatzrroilcr where ho ha his animl station, and ha! set u.- an cuor.;cnc 7 laboratory thich he wanted to five u. and he wanted t* sh w no what it was all abvut. On this ccaaicn wo wr. a.t the oar..: itself an*, we pichod up scao administrative efficial there c rvductc.’. us. Then, as far as I rocnll, it was during the war ; I wont thrru'h the caiq> ‘..authausen, \tacn the stinc quarries wore to to exauinod ait*, the- Fuehrer w s in the noi^hberhecd. <1 boro th-sc the inly t*r. cv.uccntrr.ti_n cos ps yau havo ever toon in? A Th so were the cs:.»s wSiich I sa* . n . Had yzu ever been in Sa::cn Hausen rr Cranicn'ur.? A I z-za in Granicn urr nee *. cf.rc the raj. ! V u were never there* durln t* ; war? ~ I think it was def fc the war; perhaps in ..u-jost cr July, 1939. Q Have y u ever ‘.con in Dachau as the witness Neff testified? - 2622 - Court I 6 Feb li7-A-MAA-2C-2-Saspson-LJG A. No. G. Have you evar been in Buchorarald? A. I was not in Buchenw&ld. Q. I aa glad to hoar you nention that you had been in Natrwoiler In connection with Dr. Bickertoachj you neglected to say anything about that when we discussed Bickerfcach a few ninutes ago, and we will return to that subject a little later. How, Herr Brandt,do you reaccfcor having boen interrogated in tsy presence on 5 November 19ii6j at the Interrogation — the interrogation you went over with your attorney X last Tuesday aftornoon; the document that was Introduced in the record. That was Doc\*ent Ho. 1730, Prosecution's E>hibit Uhl. I don't havo a Goman copy to hand you right at the rccaent, but I Just want to re¬ view with you book answers you gavo no on that occasion, arri to ask you then if you still maintain the correctness of the answers you gave. The quostion was put to you to give us a briof statement of what you know concerning nodical oxp-rlnonts on husan beings. You answerodj ■Thoro is nothing olso I could say bosldos th-1 *iich has alroady boon recordod here and Hiich was said in tho courso of the interrogation by tho porsons interrogated." Tho next question was: "I only would like to know what you know about thoso oxporiaents." Answor: “I only know about tho experiments of Oobhardtj this nattor case to cy knowlodge only after I was arrootod in Hay of last year." Questioni "And what did you know before you woro arrested?" Anawort "Before ny arrest in Hay of last year I know of tho cotters Dr. Gebhardt and Dr. Fischor enphasizedj I rofer to the quostion, krugewski. Anything olso in tho way of exporioents did not cone to =y knowledge. I had no contact with any of the offices, institutions and persons *iich played a part thcroin, ncr did I know then previously. Harr Pohl and I not for the first ti*e when he pas sod tho death sentence on me as President of the Summary Court." ^-cstion: "What I would like to know is what you had to do with the exporinonts." Answer: "I had nothing to do with then." 2623 6 .o'_ lx?—--.— .-20-3-Sai^acn C:urt Uc. 1 t*icsti:n: •nthat da y:u kn w ab nl . ru;; wski?" «naw^r: “I said that ..mbcwski was attendin'- this neetin anil was explainin'; at .r-blcns ctn- cemln: the cicccntaainatirn of water." Quest i-.n: "Did yru knew before cf any cx.erincnta be in;; uado cn hunan ’.diva?" iowrer: "As I havo^lrca:^ stated the natters verc Qcbhardt's." Questicn: "Do ym knew that Gcbliar’.t t/as uakinr experiuonts cn hunan •oinct previous t< 19U5?" answer: "La 19lx3 he cave a lecture at the IJlitrry Acadojy. He speko abcut cxcriccnts cn hunan bain:a." Question: ■'..•hat did .rujowski tuli abcut ueperinonts na.'o on hunan beings?" answer: "liruccwakl was nly cxplaininr nattors c« neeminc doccatardnation cf water." Question: "tore those experiments concominc docentadnation over aado :n hunan bcincs?" Answer: "I an cf tho opinion that pcplo drank this water." Question: "Has anybody elsu carriod threwfh o^orlnonts bosidca :ruj .wski?" Answer: "That I do not knnr." Question: "Dr y u knew a^rthinc about lew prossuro ax.wrinonts?" Answer: "lie." Question: "Do you know anything abiut typhus experiments?" Answer: "No. Question: "Do yru knew anythin: nb ut bene cx,>criiicnts?" Answer: "No, I cannot say anythinc at all abcut that; I did net hoar of these thincs." Questi n: "Dc you know anythin: abcut the Lest Axperinents?" Answer: ■No," Question: "Do y u knew anythin;, a’, ut the w- rk in ca^criixnts at tho Univ-rsity f StraaVu ref Answ-r: "I hoar:' ab ut it nee, but these "cro net ex, crincnts cn honan boin^s. Sievers went ti no enco only and told no al ut c^crincnts :n animals -ede by irof. Hirt; it was a very »h:rt visit only. I talked tc .-ref. Hirt and he shewed no idcrcsoopic sli -cs cf rabbits, but ne won* was uttered then ccnccrnin; bi:lc leal e^criaents on hunan Icinrs," Question: "Hut y.-u told us that ycu had no contact at all with these ^ poc. lc, and new ycu say that these people have Visited you," ..nswer: Court I 6 Feb U7-A-MAA-20-ii-Ssapson ■Stivers visited ae Just once. That Professor Hirt is an SS nan is not known to co to this day." Q. Kerr Brandt, do you have anything to add to what was stated in that interrogation, or to what has been so far stated by you in connection with experimentation on hixaan beings? A. I should lilce to go back to these experiments of Professor Hirt once mere. The roport of the findings of the Final Report. J read hore carefully: If one is looking for tho question of human oxperi- sents, one could get the impression that they definitely wtfro node. If one considors tho question fran a chcoical point of view and wants to nako his observations in that respect, then then this question of hu&an experiments, expocially in connection with concentration camps would not bo rocognized. fihen I visitod Professor Hirt I did not talk to him about oxporlmonts on human beings; and after that I did rot bocano awaro of any fact that night indicate then. 2525 6 Febni?.rx-»-0JG-21-l-Kaynca Ccurt He. 1 Q Witness, I want to put a report rsxdo by Hirt to you. This ia docu- cent NO 099 end wes introduced as Prosecution Exhibit 268. Can you say whether this is the report which you received free Sievers? A I assume that it ia this report; Q And you, I think, have already ednittod that if on© reads this report carefully, one re.-chea the conclusion that experiments wore carried out with Lost on human beings; is that right? L That is quite possible. Q Have ycu also observed that mention is made of heavy, medium, and light wounds caused by Lost? A Differentiations were made between the various types of wounds with rtfercnco to their severity, general sysptens and local symptoms. Q Tou hod menticned in an earlier stage cf the interrogation that you did not think thtt Lost experiments were dangerous. Does not this report indicate to you that scae of the experimental subjects wore rather severely injured? A This report is not a report of findings about individual experi¬ mental subjects. It is a general report, fran whach ono can conclude, how¬ ever, that supplementing previous general experience and ovidonce, further experiments can be mado. I have said that the Lost experiments, as gener¬ ally conducted and as I knew thoc, as they have been described to mo in the Uilitaxy Academy, arc unimportant, at first painful local skin symptoms, ■hich later heal. In the meantime I have seen literaturo on the aubjoct which confirms this. Q Well, Herr Brandt, ycu did read this roport, and ycu got it free Sicvcrs in «pril 19 UU, did ycu not? A I read it lcter. *t thet time 1 merely roccivod it. Q Did you road it fcoforo ycu visited Hirt in Strasbourg? k Tos, I no doubt read it before that* Q .-nd didn't ycu observo open reading it. Just as you have now observed hero, thet it was perfectly obvious th-t he had experimented cn human beings? A I did net examine the repert to that effect. I examined it to see -2626- 6 ?ebruar 7 -.- 0 ^C- 21 *- 2 -«ayna Ccurt Sc. 1 whether tharc we* anything for ne to do in ccnneeticn with the result, end vhet seemed significant to me was the reference to vitamins. Q Yes, it says, dees it not, that the "organism stands the best chance of absorbing the daa&go caused by Lest if there is a largo vitamin reserve in the body"? Didn't ycu further Hirt's experiments after reading this re¬ port? A He, this final report hod established the result, and at that time a I attempted to create a certain vitamin reserve, seeing in that a certain protection. I did not support Hirt himself. Q You deny that ycu and Rostock issued priority orders concerning Hirt's Lost experiments? A I do net underst:nd what you noon by "priority orders". Q Did you issue any orders to any insitutulcn concerning Hirt's experi- asnts with gas? A I don't know. Q Herr Brand t — A Do you mean any aenticnief Hirt's results or the fact that vitamin reserves were important? Q No, I mean, did you issue rny orders supporting research by Hirt with gas? A I don't recall that I did. On the contrary, free a statement that has been made now that Hirt is supposed to have complained that I did not help him. I am not awaro that I gevo Hirt any special aid or spocinl support of any kind. It might be that thero was something in tho Institute, since the name of Rostock was mentioned. It night be in connection with tho general demands on the Institute from the University, eddrossed to Rostock, but I do not rmember anything of that kind. Q But ycu do not exclude the possibility that somewhere along the line there may have been some support by ycur office cf Hirt's work? A I don't know. I can only say that I dc not remeefcer anything of the kind. It might have boon something tc dc with tho question of vitamins. Thrt might have been possible. I Just said that I tri*ru easily if I knew aero precisely the events from the side of thi, picplu whe actually ;*.rriod out tho experiments. Tho one¬ sided presentation makes it difficult to Judge because those who participated, for example. Dr. Fischer, I know personally as human beings, and I am con¬ vinced that they would have been willing to Conduct such experiments only for definite reasons or under definite conditions. It was certainly not merely the desire to conduct experiments. It would perhaps bo easier for me to i-.sver tho question when those who have participated in the sulfanilamide experiments have spoken themselves. £?eb. U7-22-L-A-^ZMJaylord Court No, 1 Q Witness, isn't it a fact that this Loet gas decreo or chemical warfaro decree which you received froa Goering on 1 March 19Ui concerned itself not only with gas nasks, but also the treatment of wounds caused by gas? A It referred to the apparatus against poison gas in general. That incl u ded deeontaai nation including calcium chic ride aftd ether drugs, Q But did it include medical therapy of gas wounds? A It did not include therapy, but it included the naterialo for therapy, Q Well> witness, how oan it include naterials for therapy such as drugs~- I assume you have drugs in nlnd — unless there has also boon sons stuefy as to X hew effective such drugs and material are on wounds causod by f;as? A It did not inoludo the studies, I said that originally it included only gas nasks and that in the course of tine the prorraa was expanded* As far as the drugs noeded for the treatoont of gas wounds was not ostabliehod only until 19UU, tho methods of treatment in gonoral are tho sarao as in tho First World War and havo not chang od in principle. New gasos havo been added. The effeotivonessof these new gasoa was not quito clear and special oxpori- nents woro oortainly nocossory, Q Can you suggest any reason why this docroo of 1 March 19 Uj, whloh you s ont to Hirclor, should havo been ferwardod to Grawiti and Siovors if it % didn't cor.corr. Lost oxporirantation and gas oxperiaentation? A I oortainly did not pass it on to Siovors and Grawitz, I onlyn approached Himlor. I have alroady said that I apnroachod Jttmlcr because the Reich Itinistry of the Interior was competent for cortaln noasurea of air raid precautions, of tho air raid police, and becauso I noodod information on tho need of air raid precaution apparatus. It waspassed on to those two gentlemen by Rudolf Brandt, apparently bocause they misjudged the situation. He was presumably of the opinion that because I had passed on this decree as a doctor, it was a nodical natter. It was, in principle, not a medical natter but it was ry task in tho controlling of production, Q Herr Brandt, I want to put to you an extract fron the Sievers* Diary for 19UU, This was Docunent 35^6-PS, Prosecution Exhibit 123, On the 2nd of February 19Uh, Sievers cade tho following entry* 2629 & Feb. L7-A-ATO-22-2-Oaylcrd Ccurt Bc # 1 ■Met Professor Bickenbaeh in Karls Ruhe and he put his research *crk under the oontrol of General Ccasiasioner Professor Dr. Brandt. Discussion with SS-Kauptsturefuehrer Hirt. Professor Dr. Dickonbach, without instructions frea Hlrt and Profossor Stei>. contacted General Comlssioner Professor Dr. 3randt concerning the phoegene experiaente that were in Natsweiler with hin. Cocniaaions to be withdrawn; For our part, Natsweiler is to be dosed." Tell the Tribunal what "phosgene" is, witness; A Phosgene Is a chtdoal warfare agent in gas fore whioh can bo usod in gas fore# Q What was the Professor Dickonbach doiiy; with tho rosoarch station at fatxwoiloilor? A He had beon given aidaals at Natsweiler and had conducted his aninal axperinonte there. Thoro wasobiiously a tonso relationship botwoon hin and Hlrt so that ho wanted to disassociate bins elf free the group there. Ho asked ao to help hin and I did help hin then to establish this laboratory which was Independent of totxwuilor. It was near Strossburg. And thors he wantod to rosune his phosgone cxporloents and ho didn't begin to work — later his work was brokon off throuch the war conditions, about in Soptonber. Q Herr Brandt, is it not a fact that Dickonbach was performing phoscone experiments on lnaatea of tho Nat swell or coop? A Dickonbach conducted aninal experlnonts thore. Q What kind of ardnals did he use? A Ho had dogs. I did not boo the exporinents thero itself* I visited fdn, I sow cat experiaente in Franaedd. I aseune that there nay hare boen cat experiments too. When I was thoro, that was in February, we woro thore only a* about ton dnutea and ho showod no the kennels and tho cages to give ne an idea of the extent of this experinental station in Natsweiler, in conparlson «lth what he intended to ostablish in FranrecJd, 4 Q Dickonbach was a Stress burg University Professor like Hirt and Hapon, •asr.'t ho? 2630 7 Fab. U7-A-^TC-2?-3-Gaylofd Court tick 1 A Ha workod at tho PoXydinio in Strassbur;;, the tiedloal Polyclinic, Hagan was tho lygienist. Q Was Dickenbach an SS nan? A I do not know that* % q Do you know that the Strassburg University was in effect an SS Uni¬ versity, don't you? A No, I do not knew that either. The only SS neabers that I know^ according to tho iocuaonts here, where Wrt hiasolf was an SS nan. q Witness, since we are talking about the Sievers' Diary of 'M, I would like to put anothor entry to you, this one dated 1 June, "To Dachau, SS- HauptstumfUehrer Dr, Fleet nor and SS-Untorscharfuchrer Ebon. Answer of Inquiry concerniry; Polygol froo Professor Rostock. Dy ordor of the Doputy of the - : Ooneral Cocnissioner for Medical and Hoalth Mattors." Do you know that Rostock got in touch with Siovors concerning polygol which had been dovolopod at Cachau? 6 ~7-».-FX-23-l-Grc5s Court Kc. 1 I kn w that Hcstcck -n t.h_ '.attach publication ah.ut .s-lyral in tho t-nlch Medical ./ockly (tfxnchntr Ixdi. inischc ••ochonachrift) wrote to the addresses clvcn in tho ac&sinc itself tc fine’, ut what it was abcut. ilostoek certainly did not fire! cut that the testing cf the pro/aration pclycal was carriod out as a hucan capcriixnt. Q leu have .rtrrioualy aonticnod that ycu had kncwlcd-c of experi- uonts .n hunan teinca cenecrainc the chad cal troatoent of poisonous rotor, ia that cor roc t? 4 That is not richt in such a ease as you t. oak of exporixaenta I IC8 cf tho opinion that this water was tested in acno way. It cculd just as troll have boon a treep axporinont cr anywhere else in thop.pulation. Q °c ycu knew upon when these cap crii»_nta were c endue to-’.? .. Nc, Z do not know that. I assurro that ih-ucewsky will bo able to tell ycu that. Q Didn't ycu receive any report ab.ut these oxpcriixnto? A He, 1 did net receive any report ab ut than. This quosticn of apparatus for dee. ntanination of water codo up bocauso in connocticn with the rcncral apparatus tho question of water dcccntaainatina apparatus was also discussed. Within tho Mohrracht thoro was nc acrccajcnt upon uctho ’s which wero not suitable and tho Civilian Air Raid authorities were acrecd. In tho Ministry for Aawniticn end War rroduction thoro was a social rcutino for tho prcducticn of such dccc ntanination apparatus. I cskod tho head cf this c-crdttcc tc Jiavc these who wero interested in this quosticn an’, cculd tell nc aVut it tc ceix tc soo ix. Ho did so and since he else knew fren the product! n side that such an apparatus had l>ccn constructed with which Jin^ewsky was in sort cf cennocti.n, I an not suro T/hat the connection was, -ju..cwsky nrs also invite*, t. this c23-E-Grc83 Court Ho. 1 iFZ PPJtSIDffTT: T^o Trlbua»»4 »i»l adjourn until 0930 ta»ltcw nornlng. fx witness to bo put to cross orrcination will be kept so per?, to frcri tho cthsr witnessos. CRe TVibunel adjourned until 7 yobmary 1947 nt 0930 hours) 7 FeSjSp-l. Ccurt I 1-Leaser (iJ) Official transcript of the Cnerican ailitaxr Tri' unal in the natter of tho United States cf *aorice, against Karl Brandt{ et al, deferxla-.ts, sitting at i.urecl erg, Gemtj or. 7 February 19A7, 093C, Justice Beals presiding TtiZ Persons in t»c Court I.oae will please find thoir sects. The Honorablo, t .c Judges of Military Trlbuncl.l. Jfir.itary Tribunal 1 is non in session. God save the '.‘nit od States of Aaerica and this lior.oreMo Tribunal. ^ 7r.Z P.3SIDL7: br. Marshal, you ctcortein if the defend .ts arc all present in the courtroom. ? n —J5IIAL: May it please your Honors, all defendants ?rc present in t..o Ccurtrcoa. THE PRESIDE! T: Tho Secretary Oer.oral till ncto for tho record the pr.so.icc of all tho defendants in tr.c ccurtroca. Tho Prcaccutico nay procood. K. KL bWD T (hcsu.od) CROSS S3WJJL.TI0K (Continuod) 3Y .J.. IIcK/JETi Hay it please the Tribunal. Q. .’ err Profocsor, mo voro discussing the poisoned vator exponaonts. Did ; cu suggest oxperinents :1th poisoned n-tor? A. f.t tho discussion which teck placo cn tho question f tho pess- i' ilitios cf rcaeving pci sen free atcr,thoro woro t*o fundanaatsl points of view; cne, as far os I roc ell, nas that certain dooent . ihetien epparctua Us needed, 2 r.c ledger re-.u-' or the nano c ovxlurt. r.v- ot. cr ires a procedure uhore chlcric ccid i os usod. The result of tee i ? discussion uas that by virtue cf the situation a decision as te'le prcceduro uas not possible, rt t.-c'vtl^ was that in ccso of poisoned vator one voulc jt& | ring fresn water in tank sets cr other containers free an area lei: Jad act eon pcifs^iod/ The ti c representatives ex t.:c doccr.taiJ.- was tlict in case of poisoned ator one vould \vi\ . not boon pofs/iod, n-tic processes were of* The ti c repres IJCzg opinicr. that th c representatives ex tho doccr.taci- their apparatus >-s ccd. l.’o :--cisirr. rencl.ee ■ 7 ?ei-!-JP-i-2*Lcs3Gr Court 1 at this mooting. I issued in?tructions to continue testing the apparatus. I said that the tests should to continued but in r.o concrete fern. Q. Why did they cccc to ycu with this problem? Wes that in your capacity as General Ccnaissicncr? ... Tnat was in iy function of the quostion of production of apparatus to ccotat gas in general. It was connected with ny function os General Ccacdssioner ctly to the extent that it was a special assign¬ ment, not otherwise. Q. Did you not suggest that experinents ;o conductod with tho poisoned *atcr? A. I aay possibly hsvc suggested that tho apparatus and tho process should be tsstod. These were primarily laboratory tests and wero no doubt continued aftor tttf discussion as they had boon carried on before. Q. Don't ycu kiKw that it was necessary to ... don't you know that the experiments wore in fact carried out on concentration carap inmates? A. That was not knewn to ne in that feru. Q. Ycu didn't concern yourself with tho -annor in which those experiments would to carried cut? A. l.'c, I did Not. Q. Ycu Just gavo thoso men carte blancho to do tihat thoy wanted to? I did net give thee carte blanche to dc uhatovor they wan tod. The offices concerned with it ccntinuod their work as hoy had boon carrying it cn f oferu. It is not possible in gonoral to cstn‘ lish the aanner ir. which tests ore to be carried cut. I vaa interested only in Iteming whether a certain appera tus for docontanlnoting wator was considered tho Lest nd the easiest to produco in this special cconittoc in the Spesr .Ministry, cr whether there was any such apparatus. Those conferences were devoted only to tho possi’ ility of producing apparatus. 0 . lihe *as 0‘ erstarzt Dr. irth? 2635. 7 Feb-M-Jr-1-2-Leaser Court I A. Clcrstarzt Dr. wirth was the oonsultant for gas natters in the Military *edical Acedeegr. I do net knew whether that was his official title but in any case, in eg opinion, he was the Chief of the aen concerned with chtnical warfare agents. % 2635A 7 Fbb-:;-JM-3-2<5»er Court I 3. arc h* cc nf erred with you on th_s. sxiscr^f* water exporl-xircs, ut'n't be? X .-!a n t >_licVw that h- we 8 jx-cscct at this cv-s-tin^. I cvuct for euro but I do not be Hove so. V 2636 Zjart So. 1 7 ?cb 47-K-2-i-£EX-*te'nan Vnan vaj ^ci« neetin.;, to the best of your recollection? A. In the sucaer of 1944. Ant- Hi you not surest that water he oois-ned with Lost and then •cst«£ for the «ff«ctlveaess of the dec-ntar.inetlon process? A. It is ouite pocsftlo that soosthing of this sort was said. It ie a Question of the apparatus itself. It has to he poisoned with sons gas and. then with aoae filter ncthod of chenical ncthod. The poison has to he re- moved, that is the point of this prohloa altogether. Q, What is t substance? A. That is a chcoical warfare agent! gas in general. Vhat is S substance? A. As far as I as inforned, it is a fuel which was «,o he used for ex¬ plosive purpwses but which the Woaoons Office rejected at that tine and it was thereby eliminated froa the list of chocical warfare agents. In ny opinion it was to be used ir. a alullar vny to phosphorous. I nay be oietrkon; fc.vever, I have a) exact knowledge about It. q. Could it be that » substance was a type of Lost gas or nustard gas? A. So, certainly not. And you don't know whether or not thoss exocrironts wore carried out cn hunon beings? A. In ny opinion the water decontnuiw-tion crocrinents wore ourely la'orctory experiments with cheolcrl tests. I did not sec any nyself but that was certainly the general aothod of tests. q. Did you follow up this ruvter and receive rooorte on It? A. I did net follow up this ouestion of docontaninetion nysolf. There vns the head of a special c^oaittce for thnt pur-v-sc who tostod these things.. It is cossible thnt I received one a-re report to the effect that one woeest - another *r.s more suitable. So neasures or stops were actually taken be¬ cause the row material wns cot available. (± vhrt was this coauittvc that was concerned with this natter? A. That vos the Speciel Cccnittee for Drinking Water Deeontonlneti n Apparatus 2637 Court So. 1 7 let 47-M-2-2-B3i-Meehar. v Suppose we put Document So. 154 tc you, doctor? I h»>ve mt Doenaent So. 119 to the witness tut I felled to have that narked for identification. I would like that the record now sh-w Document So. 119 has toon offerod cs rrosecution Exhibit 446, for identificetion. This is D-cucent So. 164 which we offer as Prosecution Exhibit 446 for identification. Herr rrofessor, is the Reich Institution for Voter and Air x-urificetion the cceaitteo which you have nade reference to? A. So, tho head of this coanittee which ! nontioncd was a Ministry of Henrlch. I believe this ccunlttee which I aentioned. belonged to the Ministry for *raaaent and Var rr-ductIon and ves nanaged like tho other special coa- nittoee there. You stated that it was one, and that those oro*-rinon'.e woro not carried out on concentration eaap innntes. Lot ue look nt this document, which it Report Ho. 26, dated 31 March 1946, epoerently nede by the Reich Institution for Vater end Air Purification and concerning experluents ccrried out at Htabur.T-Heuc^amo, a roport by Or. Jaegers and Reg. Bnuinsooktor Kunpfert: ■In agreement with the Reich Puehrun,; SS, exuoriaents voro carried out at Hanburg-Heungatiiw with drinking water preparation 44/6 in ordor to detor- nino whether »-ocid of various concentrations would ccusc any disadvantages to health and vhathcr, if this wwro not tho caso, drinking water containing £ substance would not be in^hirious to health rfter treetnent with V-ecld. ■The exporlnonts vero carried out on eoproxlcctely 150 poreone who eoo- rxised a singlo cooaur.ity. Tho corns doctors uade the nodical observations. Sturabennfuehrer Dr. Ztel also took oart in the oxuerincnts for sovorol days during which the high lewisite concentrations were used.* Do th-se first paragraphs indicate to you that concentration entro ln- netos were used? A. Yes. Q, I don't think it is nectseary that we r^ad tho whole reoort but I would like for y-u to turn to the second nage. Do you see the sentence which eays, "The caao doct-re could not observe any effects hemful to the 2o5S Court So. 1 7 ?et *7-M-2-3-SX-Mt.«haB hedth A the erocrl=eatd aubjecta."? A. Tee. I*. And the following pare^rtnh reeda as follcwa: *a third scriea -f ereri-eatc van carried out with an r,;ur.t of the Lost •T °?> the A*^ty»iatlB< at ( in accordance with the eu^veation aede by Cberatarrt Dr. Virth at the conference on 4 Dececber 164-; with Reichakoanieear Dr. arandt. Since chemical analyala can nrovo the oroaence of tho naohyxi- otin* Loat only within a ooriod of euproxlaetely one hour, the nreaence of l subetenco in the untreated water vaa probable in every inatance, whllo in X the crae A notable water it vac believed the ievel of notability (below 8,< silli^rara ner liter) or tho S-Loat had already been doatroyed by tho V-ncid." Ia that tho conference ond. neetln,* which yai hrvo been tell in/; ua about here, cr la thia another neetln,; hold by you and y./ur aaacclitcs? A. I cannot any. I had -aly one r.eotln* with thia coocittoo about drinking water apoaretua. I aaid that v 8 a in the aunnar of 1944. If the date ia lvcn hero aa 4 Decanter, it la o.aaiblo thi t tho dlacuaalon *a» not in the auaror but in Doce ibor. And you now rnxat conclude in fact that the «. r^erlcente woro carried Ait at tho Eaatur*- 21 eun,:a'i::a concentration ccr-p. Ia thrt richt? A. On the voala of thia docunvnt it aooeara that aoccirl teats wore nr.do in the caap at Kcntuz«-Kcuna'no f-llvvin.; the dincueeion. Tea. In order to be purfeetly fair with you. Doctor, I want to point out the r.cxt to loat ^erajooh of thia roo-rt. It arye that thoao exoorinento, ehich were aucated by birth ia your oreaence and. apoarently with your auo- ?ort, thet they did n^t cause any effecta haruful to the health of tho ox- oerinental aubjecta. Do you fine thrt? A. Tea, Sw, Sector, did you ever au^eat any other ex , oerlncnt6 on concm- treti.n canp lnrirtea? a. Ae far as I know, I nede no oreciee su,v;eati-ns concerning concen¬ tration ce-ra inantee. I r:uet esauno free tho report thet even before thft the cxcerl-ientB had been carried -ut in a ainilrr way, tut none wore eoccial 2639 tipwlMata. This nitrasen-Lost exparicent vns cade later. I do not recall, either In this case or in any other case, that I sweated experiments on concentration camp inmates. 7 Fcb-*WF-3-l-Nin«buck Court I Q. Kell, now, ycu httVo told us -ccut yiur astool-.ticn w ith Bickcnbach. Ycu deny that ha experimented on c ncontrcti_.. cn Is that your signature :n that letter? ... los, that is sv ai 3 naturo. !R. ItoH-dCT: T.o offer this d,cu:xnt as ir^socuti'n Exhibit 1^7 for identificati.n. Q. Sup. .a. y_u read this lottor t* the Tribvrwl? ... "Obor^rup-onfuehrer »clff, Headquarters ?f the Fuchror"; the date is 26 January 19U3. "Doar Obergruppenfuehrer, Sincu I hav. had ar.plo material ln thc co ut the dovol pent ol concentrated feed, as a special scct-.r, f- r oxrr.plc, thowea of the f rtress of Stalingrad, 1 would like - repeat .nee r*:ro the rnttcr a s discussed at that tine. Is it possible * carry .ut pertaining nutritional experiments in a neentratien cnnps? 7 Feb-k-J?-3-2-Hin. buck-(GJ)- Court 1 In this connection I should think it necessary to contact Dr. Luft at the medical Research Institute for Aviation and idnistcrialrct Zicgulweior, the consultin' nutritional expert with the Tchrnccht. A dear chart of the experiments, corr.sponding with the actual conditions, should then bo drawn up Jointly. I think it quite possible to obtain eventually now, valuable results in coapnrativ> 4 y short tine." Q Well now, witness — x A Tho letter is signed by bo. Q This was a contact by you with the SS, wasn't it? A YeS. Q I unitrstood that you have previously testified you novor had any official contact with SS nan? a This Ob.rgruppcnfUehrer -olff was at the Fuehrer's headqueters. That is shown on the address. Be was tho liaison nan with the SS. He was formerly the adjutant of Htnalcr and then in 19L3 or the begin¬ ning of the 'Ui ho was replace. Tho discussion which ire nonlloncd here, s tho first sentence shows were results of concentrated food eiv.-n to our Wehrnacht in surrounded an: os in the East which was dropped to then by parachute. ?;>.s«- concentrated rations consisted of various groups. There were distinctions especially in the Banner in which the fat was included. They also varied according to the protein content. The rations intcndc-d far ono aan, as far as I recall, corresponded to about 3500 calories. TheS*. 35CO calories w_rc calculated in the basis of various suns of fat, carbohylrates and prfctain, and aft-r the expe¬ rience of Stalingrad it was not clear, -sp_cially in view of the food which the Feed ilinistry could nakfa available for this purpose, which was the cost suitable foro. In order to cle3r up this qu< stion, I .“.as cade this suggestion to or. Wolff s this document shows, after ? Fcb-fc-v?-3-2 -H inabuck- ( 0J ) - Court 1 I had inforccd the Fuehrer on the basis of a discussion with !>. Zitgelweier that there wxs no agreoaent in this food question. had said that this was probably the quietest way to solve the question, and I passed on this assigeeaent. I did not consider tnis anything special, and besides, I had forgotten about it 261*2 -A 7 Pttb-H-JM-3-Ninabuck C art I Under oth^r circunstancos it valid have boon called a troop exporiisont. q. nG® the export»cnt carric * out? ... I cannot say whether itw.s c nrriud cut. Q. Didn't y u havo *^»c contact vith SS Obcryuppenfuohror P hi in connection with this matter? /„ I do n:t recall that I receive ’ any inferaati- n froa £hl ~.b ut it. It night oo> but it la possible that according t tho suggestion :aado hero the continuation of this question was 'cnc by Ziosolwbior an Luft thciaaelvoo. Q. And this natter cane up Iona oof.ro the Swccn*' Fuehrer ccrte which explicitly coverod nodical science an* research, didn't it? A. The date of this letter is the 26th of January 191*3. This was n.t a quest! -n jf rose rch. It was c question f practico. Q. Don't y u ixacabcr that ..olff wna sick ab ut this tii*. an’ that ho passe*' y ur letter on to Pohl? , ... No, I .len't reajQber that. It is possible that ho wna sick nt thia tiso* It is els: possible that ho pasao the letter < n U fohli q. YiU eel * tho other ay that y u had nly a-t Pc hi horo in the prison, .re you sur- th~t } hi did not got in touch with you in crnncction with this ratter? It ia possible that ho wrote t -*j. 1 cannot renunbor it. As far na I kn-w I saw Puhl fur the first tiac heru in the prison. I night have not hin onco before without knowing th-t it was pehl, but I -'c not rua-abor. q. Ifc you roocaber whether »hlt.l'yu ab ut certain food experiments he was carrying .ut in c nccntrati.n ca pe, oxperiutnts with poisonous food*? ... I cannot roncabcr hnvin sp.ken t ihhl at any ti 0 bofcrc I was 1 treated h-ru. It is, ;f c utsj, p ssible. It is p. ssiblo that tho re aving f p is .n fr f.cd w-s sai t ce n rj c occasion, but without any documents I cannot r-m_::bcr it. Perhaps I ai ht explain it Just as I have explain^ this case here If I have a ':cuncnt tcfcrc n_. 6243 Court I 7 F«b -7-H - h-1 - LX - Ninabuck h. ZeS| it's always nice to know iftat's in the document. a. In this document htra, yes, it is very clear what's in it. Q. Horr Professor, did 70 U ev^r suggest that arjy drugs bo tested cn concentration cajp iwtes? a. I do not believe to* I cannot rcaenber. hhat specific drugs? i. Suppose we soe if Document NO-1382 will refresh your recollection, in that regard? This is offored as Prosecution Exhibit UMl for identi¬ fication. This is a telotype froc the dofondnnt Rudolf Brandt to SS Ctorsturrbannfuohror Barnert, narked secret. "Door Paul, SS Erigadofuchrer ft*ofessor Dr. Brandt called up and requested tho approval of the Reichsfuehror 3 S that ten prisoners fran Oranicnburg should bo nade avail-.blo as of tomorrow for two days, to t-st a certain drug. Nothing would happen to then. "Iho tosts have already bean discussed and oust be started taaorrcw noming, 5 February. 35 Qrupponfuehrer Dr. Grawitz is only waiting f'r Remission fr ob the Reichsfuohror SS. Please obtain tho decision and pass it on immediately to Dr. Orawitz, H«il Hitler, signed, yours, Rudi.» a. I do not retaenher what this was about. I dc n 't Know. Q. Do you dony the possibility that you requ-stod Grawitz or 30 E 0 other S3 nan to have those prisoners nade available to you? A. According to tho telotypo Dussago horo, I did that, assuring that this is authentic, but I cannot reoesber what it was about. Thera ie no indication — it says two days. I don't reaeaber It. 3. Tou ace the second pago of the document, wltnsor,, indicates that the prisoners were aade avai lable . This is dated 9 February 19Ui, Field Co -and Poet. "GS Gruppenfuohrcr and Generalleutnant of the •i ffen 3S Gluecks hereby ccnfira approval of Reichsfuehrer 33, for ten prisonars froa Oranierhurg to be placed at the disposal of SS Prinade- fuehrer Professor Dr. Brandt (S3 Gruppcnfuehrer Professor Dr. Grawitz). Signed, GrothEann." Tell the Tribunal who Gluecks was, witness? Coart I 7 Feb U7-M - U-2 - LX- - Ninabuck A. Gluecks was the head of all the concentration camps. I did not know hie. I did not even knew his name. I waa of tho opinion that that was Pohl, but I have learned hero that it was Gluecta, ard ti'^t rohl had only on intermediate or a liaison position between ♦ Glueclcs end Himlcr. Kell, Herr Brandt, Aether cr not you knew Oluecka you knew where to go when you needed concentration carp inmates for ^experiments, didn't you? A. If there had been anything like that 1 addrossod Viclff in this cose, as in the first letter in «U3, and hero apparently through the anno channels an appeal wont to Hi-waler. Q. But you havo very expressly denied ary connection with tho Jaundice matter ifcich is the con ton t of the letter of Ainu 151*3 whore it eays you were furthering Dohaon's experiments and wanted ton prisoners fraa Oranionburg. a. I do not reneefcer that I turned to Orawitx on behalf of Dohaon or that Grawits approached no in this fore, ihoso thrue letters »*icn I have horo, the first with the food question, there is nothing which could fall ur. -jt the cot.copt of experiment. The second lottor, this tulotypo, it's not clear to me what could have been tho causes of it. I do not knew whottv-r anything was done. Certainly I did hot knew »hothor ary thing was dono. Certainly I did not oo anything. Othorwiso I am 3uro I would rorcstoer a drug. I don't know what it was. 3. But, Herr Braivit, it says you called up and requested — A. Yes, I can road that h-re, but I do not rertenbor what it was about, what it could havo beor. about. I want to clear up this concept of experiment. This document that you show>d mo before, of tho 26th of January 13 cn the food question; that is not what wc normally * understand by an experiment. It is a parallel use of cortain foods, but it is not cn ex;«rii»ont on hissan beings. noil, Harr Brandt, it does chow though that you ware in contact Ccurt I 7- :.7-h-6-3 UG-Kinetuek (;.J) ith the SS and that jxu had gone there to obtain prisoners for whatever -uryese, er .d you have very vcheecntl; denied that earlier in this inter¬ relation end in ether interreg.-tiens that you had anything tc do with the SS, end nor we find that you knew exactly where tc 50 when you h i o:-.c little teat thet needed tc ho made or. hu aa n Vcings. «cw, do . - -rant tc tell ue about any further experiments whero ycu wer.t to the S3 for priseners? I have already said that I dc net rcaa-'or any. 1 have no idea of rny. Q. hell, oay? c ycu *dil recea) or tide cne a littlo - otter. Lets have a lock at Document Hc-1620. This is effored as Prosecution Exhibit U9 for identification, (Document handed tc witness) «. horr Prefosser, will ycu plccso road this docu.vcnt olcud? ... fcs. k lettor signed \y Gra» tz tc t.jc hoichsfuohror SS filmier. "SS Srlgedofuchrcr Prcfoeaor ^r. Brandt has ey.-fochod us with t:i- request tc tost a new ointxnt fer tre: Lacr.t vf phosph reus bums which is still in the experimental atr^a. "..a I concidor trying cut this cint sent on Conran civilians f:r ' ms received in terror raids, would teJee too ouch tl .10 and would c unroll, tlo in respect of testing netheds, -uA cn, in vict. of the i- rttnee cf the protloa, I do net o’ -lve thet axporlaonts on animals -dJ prcduco sufficiently ccncluelvo cride .ee, I rospoctfully esk ycu, Roichsfuehror, tc grant pond salon for cxpurinor.ts to *o rjado in tho bespit cl cf the Sachs enhnusen concentration cacp on individual prisoners *-'• prisoners the ere unfit for work er. account cf illness• Sigi.cd, “ra-itc." <• Dc ycu or anything a* cut this matter? ... I rtmen. er this ointnent. I eleivc it ;as ado " y c firr. in I vent tc various agencies vith the it which hed something to dc i::. air r erf arc. 1 gave, it tc the civilian air rai service end I no t . eve it to tho Batch physicians cf the S_ nod tho police. In 2646 Court I 7 fob U7-M - h-h - LX - Kinabuck this letter Gr suits saysx °ks I» 4 . 4 meaning hisself, ..."consider trying out this ointoant on German civilians for burns received in terror raids, would take too auch tine and would be unruliable in respect of testing methods, and t, in -/lew of the importance of the problem, I ■...Qrewits...’ do not believe *hat experiments on animals would produce sufficiently conclusive evidence, I "...Grawitz...." respectfully ask you, Reichafuuhror, to grant permission"... ^rd so forth. I certainly did not Kiv„ this ointaent to Grawit* in order to have it tested on any concentration canp inmates. I ^ayu it to him as well as to other pooplo, to other agencies, so that it might bo triad In practice. This suggestion did not soon right to Grawitz sc that or. his own initiative ho translated my suggestion of a test, and ho oenoidered that it would take too much time to test it on civilians in air raids. I suy expressly that I &avc it to him to be tested in this way. 264? 7 ?.*o-:.-0-S-5-l-Putty Coart !• f.-.ia latter la only obiut throe uonths aftor too Jaundice letter fro.. &r wit*, l«a't ItT ... f.a, tarcc con tea lrtor. .jjd it ia only twenty-fivo days eft or too issuance of tho Second jUchror Dccro. voice you state wee thu firat tico you co Id have had any oaal'olo interest la uodlc*l aclonco and research? x: Ifae dates aro correct, hut aa appolntaant which I pas-! on to other moacioa boeausc It w £ivon to so haa not .la* actually to do with the loa itself. at la generally UMknt by aclonco and r^socrcr. la a noro oxton- •lro concept tluv. the rcfororxo to thv tooting of a salvo. 3. Lot 'a look at tho aocond pu*o of the docuucnt, Horr Brandt. It la dated 7 October I9U3. It ia a lottor froc the Dofundent, Rudol' Brandt to Gr.vlts, •7r. 0 Rolchsfuohror-SS aroo to exp .rloenta boln*; undo with tho ointnont for phosphorous turna at tho Snehsonhnusen Concentration Ou--p on Individual ;rison«rs who havo bocouo unfit for work throu^J illness." with the ir.lt&ala •3H“. I would like to roclnd you, Doctor, that too incendiary boab oxporl- nent na charged in tco lndictccnt In this c * so took ;- iresent too starting point of tho inc.ndiary bocb oxporinonts which took plcco at 3ucho.iwald r ther tuan Sictscranuaen? ... I cannot say wnothor ther. ia nay direct conr.octior.. I cannot elluln. to tho possibility. I can odd text fron 19U3 on tho problou of incendiary boob* and injuries froc /.hosphorous was 1 tenoral prooloo in Quraangr, and If one uxaclncs oodlccl litoraturo. ono will fix* thnt thoro vna probubly a new ccntion of it lr. every weakly. It ia quito poaalblo that 1.-lope ado ntly of oach other oxp-ricont* woro carried out in Buchenwnld no veil c« In Sr.eUcnhnuacn eal at other place*, ha for as tino la concornod. '‘t this tlLx ve wcr. ell intoroated in tr.la question of phosphorous burns practically or theoretically. 2648 - Fe -4WSS-5-a-Putty (i-J) Ccurt Ho. 1. Doctor, isn't it a ncnstrous thing tc conduct phosphorous c^psrinenta cn concentration caap inaates *her. you have sc -aeny pitiful Goraan civilians who had icon burned in air raids? A. I vas not of the opinion that such experiments td to Is carried out in concentration cac*ps. The lotter shows that this ires Grawitz 1 s :pioicn. If this was his opinion, he, no doubt, had t.-c idea that in seas casos of injuries which wore kept parallel, & conclusion could be drawn sore readily concerning the effectiveness of a thorapeutic agent than if the prlaary injuries and bums wero different, siail^r as in the ceso of gun shot wounds during uertiao. Phosphorous bums, no dou't, cccurrod in tho concentration csnps, toe, tecauao they woro sccetixocs hit ’ y air raids, As far as I know, that was the case particularly in Buchenwald. If cno overlooks tho • .-rosary pain involved in the injury and tho wound is not *x> extensive so that there aro gonoral burn aiontcos, tho injury is not too soricua. Decisive ir. the quoeticn cf tho thcrapoutic agent is Tibet chexical is used tc neutralize phosphorous which has a rolativo low burning tcrapor- tturc. cocporiaonta carriod out in tho cesp Saohaanhauaon, I lid not leers anything about than free tny report, and the first report cn such urns inflicted for tho purposo cf thorapeutic tboataent I heard of in the trial. Q. I can appreciate that ycu fool it necessary to Justify theso incendiary 'cxb axpnurnl ieprossion 0 f th. condition of thr child. q, Vitaesa, you told of the case in Leipzig where this child was borr. that KUnd -.nL without a hand and a foot. Mint specialized knowledge did you need .. that -ice in -rdor to fulfill the assifrraont which was ^iven you by Hitler? A. There wes no question of Ipoci lizod knowledge here. The decision was on * hua-n othical basis in regard to the child 'rod the parents of the child. Q. Witness, you talked to Pastor S-dolachwii^ the question of Euthanasia, that specialized knowledge did you need then? A. Here again it was not a question of specialized knuwlod-o, olthor surgical of psychiatric. The talk was entirely on a medical rnd hum.-ne discussion of ideas. It did not require any special psychiatric kn^lodfo on ay part as 'or as tbo Institution at Bethei was concerned. A part of the pationts at Bothol ■ere not psychiatric casus prim-riiy. Tb-y wer« deformed and monstrous. a jerwril medical knowledge was quite enough to bo able to talk on thoso quooti^is in general. Q. Thun I may conclude that yuur -ctivity w's not that A specialist basically? A. It could not bo If you mean mj activity rs far as the problem of Bithanasla was concernod. 1 did not exercise any function as a specialist in psychiatry. There woro other doctors appointed for this functi.n. I was concerned ■1th the general medical questions. A. Then how was tho decision of specialized question taken c*ro of? a. Specialists were appointed fer tn t purpose. Thr-o '.ays ago I said th't not «Hy psychiatrists were included uf spurts and chief experts from general mental institutions but that the heads of university clinics participated, \ uorzburg, f r inotanco, Berlin. I believe there w,.ro tw„ -or throe others, tco,Hoidelbore. You were also shown a document NO-625, ExMbit 356. Ibis is tho qu-sti-rr.nire with the aeaurandua. s this questionnaire sent t. all hospitals in Germany? a. No. It was sent only to the cental institutions, tlr.t is, to plhcos ^ thc P rti ^ nt8 -.no primarily insane. 2651 7 Feb. LI -Sfr-5-2A-FKP- Putty Court Ho. 1 Q. Was it sent to Kuppurheiacr? A. Ho. V.s it wont to tuberculosis sanitariums? A. K-». Q. Is othar apccinl institutiasa? A. I do not believe as. The indications, referring to specific dosoascs such aa uoilepay, echir-ophrenia, a now clorrly that they ^ro in snn,. It wos Bont only to euch inatitutiona. Q. In th*» inatitutiona wh.r». no questionnaires wore aont, wero thoro N persona incapable of workir*;? Q. D- y-u boliove thrt there wore lrr^e nunsbera? A. Tlr.t woull dopond -n the institution in quoaUai. For example, tho tuberculosis sanitariune have a euch larger percentage of seriously ill persons ■ho wore iU for lone porieds than o small city hospital with a rapid turnover of patients. Do you believe th -1 in tho institutions which old not receive any questionnaires that there were aor« people incapable of workln.; th.n in the aontal inatituti .ne? ... Ho. Thoro would probably bo aero in tho aent^l institutions. The numbore •ere c tanned urin the w.r ’_y tho nuuber of injuries, the injurioa in Gomany, Q. But you believe that there were a lar.> neoser? A. A rolrtivvly larpu number. Q. N.w why 'id those inatitutiona not receive any questionnaires when tho question jT inability to work wo a buourht up? A. I h.vfl pointed out aav.ral tiaoa hero that the question of inability to ssrk had n-tnin.- to do with product!» but was only a part of tho diatnosia in -re-r to ;ot a picture of tta total condition of tho inaan. per o on. If it ho-: teon a quest! «i ;f gotting 'hold of people* in ocpablo of working as such, •-her. questijnnairos wjuld h'vu .Kjon sent to all institutions. h. I have another question about these questionnaires. In 19?9 an: 19A0 ■^rc there still Jewish hospitals, end wore thare Jews in other hospitals? 2652 7 Feb. 47 -¥-5-3A-r?J>- Futty Court Ko. 1 A. Yos. Q. Did tMsc hospitels rocolvo quostionftairus? A, /. "-in it liquid have bc«n nucols'r/ to send questionnaires to all hospitals. £. Then I a*y conclude thet it was not intended to >t hold of all Jews in hospitals? * A. No. In 1939 th; questionnaires ware set up purely for the insane erv! s«nt to tho cental institutions. Probably for general ati tistical reasons oirtiti-nal information was asked for on tho questionnaires Just as a gcnorcl questionnaire on the institution was included. 26*3 7 ?o* 4?-v'-?JC-6-l-3o--xl Court |o< 1 - t you hr.ro already sail that during cross oxrxainr.tlGn. 'fitness, ycu belonged to tho ontour-go of Hit lor. Ifhon Jo you boliovo thr.t Hitlor docidod to ojtorr-in-to tho Jews? Do you knew anything .-bout that? X I era say nothing .-bout th.-t. Looking back at tho porioi as shafn by tho iocur-onts, I o.-a assure it rj about tho niddio of tho v-r. I did not lo-rn anything about it nysolf at tho tire. o Y-uaforo also shown Dccic^nt !fc. 1750, Exhibit Ik. 44-1. This is an oxcorpt fren Raidor’a diary. According t° this, tho killing of ins-no persons • c tho insano asylixjs in tho occuoiod *-.ntor torrlt-ry is loscribod ao noco- rsrxy. TT.o that decision free, tho nolle 1 point of view? A I do not know ho»; thio decision e-no abcut. I hoard nothing about it at X tho tiro. I do not know tho condition. It night h-.vo boon duo to Othor nattors rr.thor than tho nodical ono. I do not know. ^ '/itnoss, tto incidout >t 21 3optonbor, 20 Go?toiJ>or, and 1 Octobor 19U, rj that tho tiro th- oon-an .jay Croup North was odrancing? A Worth anl Contor, I boliovo. - Do you boliovo that tho killing of insano porsinr at that tins was p;ofliblo without tho aid of tho organizations undor tho aathry.asi.a prccoduro? A I ru convince that tho two things had nothing to 1c with oach othor. Do you boliovo that th-.ro waj any intontion of c rryino this <"*t by way of zuthanasia as 3ouhlor*s offico had carriod it ait? A I do not know. I cannot say anythinc about that. Tho infomatlon tifM have to bo supplonontod by thor inf mention. It io possible that tho diary of Haldor’o doos not contain >nly thoso throo ontrios, but furthor lafcnw.tion. Tho eno word rental Institution Kc*.r.orod has no running in ny opinion. it could noan that see adi-iuiatrativo staff or scuothlng olso w-.o to bs ostabliehod in that uroa. a Thoa, I nny conclulo that thoso re-sores co-ill bo carriol out without 7W being infoniod? A I was not infotted. ^ Thon, Decineat He. 092 was shorn to you, Exhibit No. -.42. That is a Inter free: tho Public Transport cenpany of 20 July 19«, tc the -_ont-l institution Hoiacar. Tho lot tor cencemstho transfor of ins no persons in connection with tho ovacuaticn of -rcas onlanaorol by air rails, ‘.fore cnly - -i 7 Fc\ A7-K-FJC-6-2-3card (aJ) Court Ho; 1. inaa.it persona trenferred fraa theso areas at that tiao? «. No, at that tine there mas a general evacuation of the sick, which was undertaken at that tiao. 1 locked at a sap and dioccverod at first a sanatcriuo a little south of Padertom. I assuaed that this • sight concern an evacuation of the institution for the insane tc have an evacuation hospital for Paderbcm which was continually boing attacked becauso of its railroad Junction. And, in the saae way as Doctor v^haidt indicated fer Eichberg free 1V43 on it wes used as a gcnoral evacuation hospital. v Q. Then I aay condudo that theso wore general measures and not specific acasures? A. No, not specific neasmros. x t was a gar.oral ncaauxsc which was necessary free thia tiao on. Q. Did you issue instructions as to how the individual hospitals inif is used in such o way as though it had already been tested for years in practico. Q (.itness, in ycur interrogation ycu have stated your views with regard to tho individual experiments end you hevo Judged thee with regard te thoir necessity and with regard to the voluntoors. kill ycu plocse toll us some¬ thing about wh’.t has boon nonticcod today? perhaps first ef ell you can toll ua something ebcut the question of drilling water, that is dcccntom- irvetod water. A I vrnt to statu in ccnnoction with this that I aa not acquainted with the exact procedure. Tho document shows that thu testing of this decontam¬ inated water no doubt already had behind it o long period of preliminary testing in laboratories. /.ftor all, these ere special appomti and such apparatus was suggested for production. Q witness, will ycu give me- a brief staton-nt as to the danger of the experiment8 wuich have tocr. presented hero? A 1 want to describe then os negative because the- document itself set3 forth th-t no danger was iaplicated. In tine cf war the production and pro- paration cf apparatus for the decontamination of drink in: water is of tho 7 Febru* ry-U-3vO-7-4-Bl*klcy Court Sc. 1 highest importance. Q Hen can you judge in this fleso the question of the vcluntoers? A In this case I cannct Judge whether these experiments were carried cut on volunteers cr not. ^ You used the word# "troop experiments." Is a troop experiment a voluntary oeporiaent? A k troop experiment in ay opinion is quite natural. «n order is issued or. the basis of considerations which havo boon undo pr^icusly; and then within the unit a corresponding erdor is issued to test and to carry cut the experiment. The question of using vclunteors cr not using volun¬ teers is of sufcordin-te importance in this caso because in the imposition of such an experiment the dancer end othor consider tiortin_ of diseases in h s.-ltals". 1 twlicvc it will suffice for uc to point ut that-tills bos keen a nisundoratondin... VI.. ..J-SHQfT: Is that in cn- i the documents, or in v tj witness's tcstiiKny? L.. SL..V..TIUS: This ter : was pr bably niaundersta*! by tho inter¬ preter. Titi ...LSIELKT: liy qu-stt n for inf-rjati-n was whoth.r tlie .Istakc ns in cne of the docuucnta or ft .dstronslaticn of wltnoos's oral testimony cn the stand. 15.. S 1 -CV..TIUS: It w s a .datoko in tho oral statCBients. I do not have any further quostiona. Zl .IGSUCtfT: The witnos.; ua. bo o;xusod, tlicrc boin, :v furthor oe-dnati n of the witness. tt«J)Y »rosccutien has ao farther questions, T*ur 1! nor. T : i.-ESHOIT: The wifcviss jny be excused^ 11.. S.-.V..TIUS: ZSagr it please the Tribunal I new want to call the witness Laniers. Y;:. ii^snciff: The Larshal trill suncn the witness Karr Hans Lannors. JUIXF Sb3T.HK) dr. inrabal, place the heat’, phenes on the witnoss. T.uIS HLDf.JCH L- ILS, a witness, to !: the stand an-’, tastified as follows: JUKE STtilHQ: Y u will hold u. ycur ri ht hand and rc.»oat after ac the follcwin oath; I swoor by Ood, the XJulJity and .anisciont, that I will speak the ;mrc truth on *, will withheld and add nctiin-. (The witness repeated the ath.) 2661 7 Feb 1*7- Ccurt Ho. 1 i—.-9-2-Grcsa Di.-CV - uTl.il VX SDL.V..TIUS: Q bitncss, please state ?"cur na.^ ok 1 , date of birth? A Hans Heinrich Ladners. Dorn on 27 ..ay 1879 at Lublnit*. Q bhat position die! you occupy durin;. the Vnr? A I was Chief of t^ic Reich Chancellery. Q ./hat was ycur assirnwnt am! y.ur activities? *• Tho Reich Chancellory was the office cf Adolph Hitlor in his conceits* as -vcich C hone oil or and it was the aconcy which nontally handlod tho contacts between the inis trios an/, tho Roich Chancollor as far as nc otlcr channel was prescribed. Its t£in task ccnsistc;! in tho for.iaticn of directives, it tic loyislati n, laws, docroes, and Fuehrer decrees which wore submitted by the : inistries cr which wore rebooted by tho Fuehrer are! Reich Chancellor. Court I 7 Feb U7-H - 9-la - LJ3 - Gross Q. Witness, I am now handing three decrees to you. According to one the defendant, Karl Brandt, got a special position as Commissioner for the Medical Services and also as Reich Cccraissiooer. Do you know of these docrees? • A. Yes, I know of t.«se decrees. Q. Did you play a part in their drifting? A. Yes, I have helped to draft then and I have suboittod those threo decrees to the Fuehrer for his signature. * THE RESXDBfr: Counsel, have these documents been admitted in evidence in the cose? DR. SSRVATIUS* Yes. THE PRESIDENT* For the sake of the record, will you refer to the nuebers of the exhibits? DR. SERVnTIlS: They were presented .as exhibits. THE PRESIDENT * Mill you rofor both to tho document ninbors and exhibit numbers so tho record will identify then? DR. SERVaTIIB: Tney are* Docioont N0-080 - that is Exhibit 5, document N0-081 - that is Exhibit 6, and document H0-082 - which is Exhibit 7. BY DR. SERVATItB: 3 . witness, will you now state your view with rogard to the docrcos, first of all with regard to the first decree. What was tho purpose of this first decree? A. Tho purpose of the first dec reo was U appoint a Cocmissioncr who was to carry out the coordination between the interests of tho rtilitary Medical Services and the Civil Medical S.-rvices. Furthermore, it sets forth that the person to be appointed Ccacissioner for the Medical Services, Dr. Brandt, was to handlo curtain special tasks in the Military and Civil sectors, also for the coordination betweon tho two sectors, and particularly he war. giver, the right to be constantly informed and given authority to include himself in hi3 responsibility. C^urt I 7 Fob 1*7 - * - 9-2a - LJ3 - Gross q, as a result of this did Karl Brandt fceccee the superior oi other officers? A. In ay opinion .rofessor Brandt did not become the superior of igancios 1*1 ich have Beer, enumerated expressly h-.ro. Ho only had the right to issue directives according to State legal procedures *iich wo used. Such a right to issue directives did not yet establish a superior relationship, a typical exasple for this is probably the Coaoissionur fer the Four Year Flan, Geering. He had the extensive right to issue directives toward all agencies of SVuto and Party and he still did not becoao superior cf those agencies. This docroo had also boor, intended that Brcndt lid not beccea superior. Ho could only issue orders arxi issue diroctivos if ho wanted to include hi:\self and ho had that special right. 7 FcL-JW?-9-l v -Gross (AJ) Court I This authority depended orj the feet that a certain directive existed - tr--t he issued such a directive tc these agencies for tho fulfillment cf his tasks. And, such a directive had tc be cc.jpli«I with ' y all agencioa and he cculd only give sue. 1 , a directive in else ieid cf Lis special *-c»k. He was only authorised tc issue orders within the frame nr.rk of his tasks. Q. '..hat vas the meaning of the second docrec? ^ second dccrco, in ry estimation, is only a relatively unimportant extor.sicn cf the first decree in which urp. \l ..as appointed tc represent tasks and interests cf the Nodical Services and in this supervision .-..re included certain special tasks in the fiolds of Scionco, acsocrch, and organizations! ostablis. jaunts for t*«c distribution end production of medical supplies. Ho hod also been ^lvcn the authority to appoint certain cocrdacior.ors and deputies for tho f'-lfilLcent cf his teaks. c;. In the order regarding science and research, . ut did the subject deal with? This individually wero tho orders which Dr. - received. - ca.-inct rcr.erd.or it all. I only knew that tnoy *rcra lr. the fields of tho eodicol cervices or that they wore connected -it., u is, fiLld. Q. Hew, give us tho r-aaons fer the second uccroo, and what is its importance? ... in t:.o year 19 Li t tho Fuehicr wanted a consi.'ora' lo extension ef tho authority of •'r. ‘-rondt for tho fulfillment cf the tasks which had ccr. ecsigned to him expressly. I had several notes Lav sC t. mo. I received the erder to draft this decree. I aysolf maintained the point ef view that th<- new authority txuld have tc bo Halted, that it would :.p.Vv tc limit the competencies \ ith record tc the rtLor arencics of tho -'.odiccl Services. I feared that extensive authority would lead tc strong competition in the administrative field. Therefore, ao I cen romunior •-xrctly, I drafted approximately four different decrees in v hi eh, first -- 1 precisely limited the competencies and in tho third on less, 2665 7 ?cb-!i-JP-9-S-Grc33 (AJ) Court -I end t 4 .cn in the fourth and fifth decrees which was not limiting then vary dose. I myself fevered the acst United draft for giving authority. The Fuehrer, however, favored the cost extensive version, that is, the • version which was contained in the decreo of 25 August 1 %i t . For the previously aontioned reason I did not liko this vory ruch and I uado the remark that it would be otter tc transfer the vholo Ucdical Service from the “cich ^Iniatry of Interior and the other Ministries* and tc appoint a Minister of Public health. Then tnc Puohrer repliod, "That is exactly uhat I do not want. Brandt is only to have as freo haj.d as possihlo for this special task, and extensive right to issue liractives." Because this as legally of tho utmost importance to bo I expressly stated that as a result cf tho third dccrco the authority cf Brandt from the flret and second decrees "cro not roscindod and tho Fuohrar answered this quosticn in the affirm raativo and as a result of tho third docroo also contains tho words "at tho same time". «t tho aoao tiao ho was Reich Ccenisrlonor for Sani'- tation and Health System and this was tc shew that tho two other docrces and authcritios wero continued in existence. However, os a roault of tids I the.-, publicized the third dccroo in the Reich legal ccdo without roecir.dlng the *wc other docrecs because the first t:io wore tc remain offoctivo. In this decree, namely in tho first, it is stated that tho main direction was with the Chiof of tho hohnaacht hedical Scrvico and Chief cf Hoclth Scrvico and i&nistry of tho Interior, competent Stoto Socrctary, and then what is r.ot contained in tho docroo, r.cturally, to tho Roich Ministry of Interior who raa tho superior of tho Chiof of tho hoclical Scrvico. Q. Witnoss, you aro speaking cf tha right to isauo directives. Did tho first and soccnd decr^os already issued give such authority to issue directives cr was this given only in the third dccroo? Court So. 1 7 Fet *»7-M-10—1-EHH-Xa rr ov rlceae pernlt ne to lock et the decree for a ninute. In the first decree paragraph 3 eete forth that for the social tasks Brandt will receive personal directives free the Fuehrer. However, in the first decree I do not see anythin* about e ri*ht to issue directives and only nt-ut the authority to intervene in a responsible naxmer. Of course, this uay have aoant a certain rlht to issue directive. In the soc-nd decree I do not bolieve that this is particularly nontl-nod. But then tho third de- cree sets forth thi t Brandt is authorized to issuo directives to or,vmiccti-.ns of the state, Party, and Vehrarcht. x .rrcv into ay statecents in detail and stated that thie still could he examined, tut he cp ictaincd the order kfaich he had ^irec to Conti rnd dienleucd u«. Q* At that tlno wae the nane of trcfeeeor Brandt aentloned? A. During the discussi^p the nace of rrofessor Brandt, according to cy recollection, wa not centlcned nor were any other naaes mentioned. The dis¬ cussion only referred to the general soluti-n of the orohloa and, lnnodia.tely foli-win* the discussion, I told Dr. Conti I would think over thi* netter once core and that I would contrct hia lrter. I tfcon bo*en to draft a lav which, ae I inclined, would contain the le^al .guarantees i^.ich were necessary undor all circunetancee - exact lluitotione of the noet eevero casts which had to be deUruinod by aedical nen, and exeaptione which were to bo aode, for example, for those patients who hac bocooe insane during tho war, during .inneuvcrs and other civil service, or so-called "old r^e Insanity" and slcilar cases. In ay opinion it vas also necessary to specifically state that only Goraan iesano patients should be subj. cteft to this procedure in ordor to cx- oress the feet that foreigners would be oxcaptod. Q. Vitness, these aro views which ycu nalntalnod with regard to tho problsc. However, that was not tho subject of tho discussion. A. At thi t tiae this was not the subject A the discussion but I only flnlshod this and I waited now fvr State Secretary Conti to contact -is in a.ceordcnco with tho instructions ho had received. <%. Did Conti do this? A. Conti refrained fron doin^; thie. Only after several vocks ho tele¬ phoned ao and told ne thet he had been rolievod of thie r.eslfinnont by the Fuehrer and at that I considered this setter as closed. However, in tho year 1940 I a;aic Kid to occupy ayself with the ouestion. In tho serin: of 1940 nelchsloiter Bouhler visited ce. He was the Chief of the Chancellory of the Fuehrer, 5SCAd, and he visited ue in ay railroad conch In Bel*:iua und told ne that he wes just c-oixw; fr-c the Fuehrer and tho Fuehrer now wanted to turn over the solution of the euthanasia cuesticn to hia. I discussed the severe jbjoctl.n* existing e^nin&t thot with hiu and also submitted the drpft of the lav to his cad told bin this would still be n solution if this subject could Court Ic. 1 7 Fob 47-K-iC—V-EKH-K«rrcv *« approached in auch a vay ao that a publlclaad Raich lav vra eatc.bliehcd. 3:uhl«r didn't Bees to approve of ny draft and did not refuae it, but he tcld r» that the procedure to be applied cculd be routed through adniciatrotivo channela . 2670 l ' 7 Feb. U7-tt-ATO-l!-l-Lsscr Court Jlo. 1 At the conclusion I told Bouhler that I wauld have to report to the Fuehrer once more about the mattor. I did this a short tine later. At that timo tho Fuehrer read over the draft of ny law. Ho did not expressively disapprove of itj however, • ho stated Jhat for political reasons such a law soenei undesirable to him. Subsequently I did not hear anythin* noro about the subject# Q At that tine, duriiy: the discussion which you ha ' with him, did the Fuehrer mention the name of Professor Trandt? A That naru was not mentioned# Q 7/itncas, when did you hear of the authority which actually was pi van to % Brandt and Bouhler? A I was not informed about tho authority which had boon i.lvon to Brandt and Douhlor through official channels. As I havo previously said, after many renths, it may havo been oarly in 19l/>, I rocoivod knowlotleo that action was actually under way of which I had not previously known. At that tino I found out that the Fuohrcr had actually i^ven an authority to “ran't and Bouhlor for tho oxocution of the euthanasia program. This authority did not pass thr^uph ny hands. Only in tho course of discussions which later on I had with tho Reich Ministor of JUstico I four*! cut and was infoirmd about the contents of those auttoritioa. Q Kcw what sort of Cbnplaints woro there which oaro to your attention? A Theea complaints wore not vory numerous# First of all thoy earno from individual parsons and thero ware seno trea relatives of those insano patients who had dloc!# However, the asst important complaints cane from tho church. I also can remember that thero wore two complaints which I bolioved it to ba ray duty to follow up icEedlatoly# One was free tho Ucrttorbor^ LarvJos Bishop, >*'unt, the evangelical Bishop, and the second cane froo the Catholic Pishop, Count Gahlonj I beliovo toat ho lived in Huonstor. Thoso complaints woro officially ahhcn'Oed by soj I passed thsc on to the Reich Minister of tho Intorlor, who was coopotont for tM.3, and I brourht ttem to the attention of the Fuehrerj I also discussed toe question with the Reich Minister of Justice. After the complaints wore drawn to tho attention cf tho Fuehrer tho wholo action was d-soontirued. ffowevor, I did not get aiy official information about this 7 Feb. L7-*-ATD-il-2-Los«er Coopt Mo. 1 cither. I had not boon consulted but I only obtained knowledge of the fact that in tho year 1911, this nay haro been in the spring or tho surnor, tho action was discontinued. Q Witnosa, w:ron't there also ccaplalnts by prosecutors courts and other authorities? * A Yes, wo had such complaints, especially by Judgos and fruardiana who had to earo for their adoptol children. I followed up this aattor and I contacted tho Reich Minis tor of itestioe. Tho Reich Minister of Justioo started an investi- • Ration and I can re n eaber exactly that two detailed reports arrived, one fron the Osneral Attorney at Stuttgart and tho second one fron the Chief Prosecutor at Haumburp. Theso reports occupied thens elves with these questions. The Raleh Minister of Notice passed this on to no an! I took then to tho Fuehrer and then passed than on for further handling to the Roich ’tinistor of tho Intorior. You havo those oonplr.ints hero in the tem of docunonta and they havo boon prosonted to no in previous interrogations, Q Witness, what did tho Roloh Minister of .hxstice do thon? Did ho con¬ sider the natter illogal and did ho doclaro it illegal or was it legalised in tho end? A Tho Reich Minister of Justioo, Dr. Gucrtnor, cate to see no and at that tino he was in a great difficulty. Ho had gravo misgivings and he did not knew what to do. I advised hia that he could only report to tho Fuohror — I myself sould not give him any advice. I considered a law necessary under all circum¬ stances. I had played no port in granting tho authority and now I could also not toko a stand at this tino, However, tho Rolch Minister of Justico, Ouortnor, as far aa I know, did not consult tho Fuehrer but he probably maintained tho point cf view that in issuing tho authority tho Fuehrer had laid down a Law which he had to comply with. I do not know—this is only an assumption on my part. Ary later procedure which ho wanted to do in this aattor, wa3 stoppod. Q Do you know how the authority was distributed between Doubler and Brandt? A I do Kt knew tho least thing about it. I only know that only BouhLer confronted ae in tte natter lr. the spring of 19UX. ?randt has never nado his 7 Feb. rV-H^-3-Lessor Ccyrt So. 1 appoaranee before se. I knew that Bcuhlar has nade his appear arte o with the Hatch Minister of Justioe. Bone rax*, I have never dealt with Brandt at all in the whole natter, neither before the action.or after tho action, and I havo only discussed with hin a long tise after the action, when I was a prisoner together with hin at Mandorf, in Luxecfccurg, in 19US, However, I knew that the authority was in the nano of Doubler and Brandt. D3. SSV/.TTUSi May it please the Tribunal, I Jo not havo any more ques¬ tions to put to tho witness. DJ. FH)ESCHfeM?fi (Defense counsol for Defendant Viktor Brack) i Mr. President, I want to ask tho witness a nurfcor of qiostions. However, I bcliovo that tho Umo would new bo approprl-.te to call a rocoss. TfE iraSTDhMTi Tho Tri'mnal will bo in rocoss until 1*30 o'clock. (A rocoss was token until 1330 hours.) 7 ?&. hi *A-12-1 -PK?- Foster ( J) Court .'o. 1 CeSPJSTdD CG.Y A?rae;oo. session ■ ■ - ■ - .. ■ ■ ■ (The hearing reconvened at 1330 hours, 7 Fobruary 19c7 .) THE -AESHALi The Tribunal is a-air. in sossion. D . S-iluL: .r. President, t'.io Defendant Oberhouscr asks the ‘Tribunal, ir. consideration of her status new, to bo excused again today at 3 o'clock. TIC RCSUKrTx Upon request of Defendant Oborheusor ext:nc<*l through her counsel, tho defendant aay be excused ro- attendance in the court for reasons of hor hoolth at 3 o'clock this afternoon. x Counsel iay .iroceod with tho ex am ination of tiio vitnoas. ILLS c: . Lb 3ts — - - ad. SLUXIAXxCSI BY Dh. FROESCKX-I* Q, V.’itr.oss, you woro Chief of the cichschancollory? A. las. Q. As such you had opportunity to oast high parsonalitios of tho ioraor Goman Oovornaunt—at lotst .-art of then? A. At least part of then. Q. Do you know Lartin Dsn .urn? Too. Q. \f.iRt position did cor .arm lold? A. o una at t..o end, head of tho Portoikantlui, after .bolster Hess loft in 'hi. Q. I ooroly want .to have this cliarod up for tho inl'oraatlon of tho Tribunal. art in Doruonn -as a personality .v> ‘ill ,.1-ty an inixjrtant role in -he course of tills trial, '.'itr.sss, 1 should like to ask you vhat line of a was hartin Borasnn? to say in a fc n sentences. Plcare, .lake concrete. •f-ro prcdcair.ant in the tiinkir., and actions sistaken about his character 1 finally' reached he *xis a very subelo and hypocritical c. arr.ctcr -..ho oa able to sak his truo intentions skillfully. 7 Feb. 47 -A-12-2-PTF- Foster Court Hoi 1 Q. has Martin SjK'jm c men who trio_ to cenc--r.tr.-to as ouch power .is possible in hissolf? A, He actually ’id attempt to i: that. Ho always denied it, ho always said vh t he wonted r.othin fc less than power. But cn tno basis of ay tawwledau of dovuljf>cacnts of which 1 Lx.raud to c largo extent only .after tho collapse in 1945, I ccod to tbo conviction that ho actually tried to out-in a certain p mr and tried to elinir. t« other people ir. his field. In particular, I had the a experience that he tried. Q. Please speck ft little aoro slo^y, witness. A. I wac ccnvinced that ho tried to take eway 's nuch pwier as possible froa me since I was r. state agent fr.a which he Uliev-d that he was constantly rcceivinr opposition in his actions. This position whicn I might have nr.d ho constantly tried t- un onai.x, esp-cia’.'.;* y having himself appoint*;.’ Secretary of the Fuehrer ~rx! r.a such bccnce ctivo in the state sector too. Q. i.'itnoss, re you -.ware that Martin Borodin was filled with rdent hatred of Jets? A. Ho did not tophaslso it when spe?kin* to ae ’*ut I 'a convinced th-t he was 'n opponent of the J~ws. Q. ’.iltness, lo y_u agree with ay opinion tn t Adolph Hitler, under the influence of boraftnn in tho years 43 r.! 44, srdu r.nd partly realiied these plans to evacuate ni exterain te Jews in Swrepo? «. Yes, those wero things wr.ich I .as c witness under oath, testifyinr to f.acti those are things about which I can say nothing. Q. .it:;eso, d: you h* ve any indications, any reasons to share this opinion which I h' vu Just expressed? A. At the accent I c-uld not .jive . ny indication, Q, Did you have the Lapressi n, witr.-ss, that Kitle-r was under the influence .«f Borar nn? «. In ny pinion Bomann’s influence n Kilter was rather yeat, exactly h w •T X it was I -n n t -’,1* to jua r >. Those ar_ subjective things that happened t Bmanr. ~ n. Hitler bout which I can say nothing rs a witr.uss. Q. Thun you will not be able to answer th_ question whether Martin Bonaann was Adolph Hitler'o evil spirit. 26?5 7 Feb. 17 -A-12-3-FX?- Faster Court Ko. 1 A. That was as a personal opinion w.iich I would like to affira, but that is only a subjective fatliac, intuitive feeiinf which 1 cannot prove by any c incrctc facts. Q. Do you know Obergruppenfuehrer Heyd rich who was aerdorod? A. Ye*, I knew HoydrichT Q. -s Hoydrich r.lsj a person like Bohaanr. who was striving for power? A. In xy -pillion Huyurich was to n auch Te'tor degree wen, rnd it was a expressed each aore openly. Q. Did Hoydrich influence the hoichfuohrer SS Hianlur strongly? Do you know anything about ttet? A. Ho certainly had an influence m hi* Lut I cannot : *ivo any concrete facts about these things. 2676 7 Kehpu&ry-«^MC-i3-I-l*e«fcaa Court No* 1 Q Now, witness, wr.zt was th .-sletionship between Martin Boraann and F.eicbsleiter Bcuhler? n I believe it was rather loose, they did not see each other often and they were in a sense rlvalV The agency of the heichsleiter Bouhler widen was called the Chancellery of the Fuehrer of the N5DAP was a party organi¬ zation. In addition to the Party Chancellery, there were certain orgajdzat- ions, end I knot- there was strong friction between Bouhler and Borrtann, be¬ cause Boraann wanted to control matters hioself. Q '.Itnees, dad you leam that dartin Borcann did not approve cf Bouh- lor'a so-called weak attitude on Jewish questions? A I never talked to Bcuhler about it end I did not . <*ar about it. Q Did Dr. Conti telonr, to Bor-ann's staff? A As frr os I know, no. He was under the Heichs Ministry of the Int¬ erior, alio he was an honorary officer in tho SS - 1 must correct nyself, he wcs later made suboriina'.o to Boraann by being made legal health ieador in tho party sector. Q i.itnosa, do you know anything ebout the fact that «dolf Hitler, befer-j the events which you diacu-oed this morning, gave tho assignment to Bouhler to introduce fcuthtnasia? A I can say nothing about that formally, but today I am convinced that the powers which were given to Brar.it and Bcuhler bear c different date — f. I will come beck to that witness. A Than the date of the signature. C I merely wentud to ask you when in the suaaor of 1939, or in August 1939, Adolf Hitler might have given hcichslcittr Bcuhler tho assignment to introduce Euthanasia for uncurcbly inscr.e persons. A I knew nothing about thi t. Q Do yen knew that ICartih Boraann heard ebout this and tried to appro¬ priate th* Sc Euthanasia measures? « I dc net knew anything at that either* U' Then ycu do net know either that Ifertin P.crmann aug> acted tc Hitler thet he assign *his tc Dr. Conti. 2677 7 yebrucr7-^X'G-13-2-Cteeh«n Court No. 1 A Nc, I do not know about that either. Q You probably do nat knew th t Cent! did not want tnia assignswnt and than the situation became as was described? A I can only say th£l Conti tcld him the assignment had been taken away from hie. Q Witness, I shall stew you Document 630-PS, Exhibit 330. That in the a decree of Hitler of September 1, 1939, which I need not read again as it has boon acntlonod several tiacs. Plccae road through this decree witness, hhet do you consider the legal character of this statement of ..dolf Hitler? A If I aoy express oyself generally, I can only say that in this cx- traso fore it doos not correspond to the foro which wao customary for state decrees. C Did Adolf Hitler issue many such important decrees in such fori.;? A In individual cares, but I believe ti^r- wore only e few cr.ses. lho Fuehrer did not like to worry .about Jdtnnl for.a>, so....tines he usod this fora when it was not suhnitted by an expert but th t happened very seldom. Q How, witness, what did you do when such significant ir.structions fror. Adolf Hitler ccao to your attention and they i.ore not .n the correct fora? A That h-pp.ned v.ry seldca, only once or twice. If such r docroo in this fem was submitted to co, because I el so'hud to si gn it, thun 1 adjust- f ~d tho fera to whet was custoa&ry for a state decree; that is I crossod out Adclf Hitler and at the bottce. rbovo the none Hitlur, I wreto The Fuehrer or the Fuehrer, lieichs Chancellor, or I changed it at thu top rnd I wroto tho Fuehrer cr l.eicns Chancellor and that was changed in tho course of tino. Thai, I put the Reich seal cn such decrees and 3inco I had to certify these stetauents cf tho Fuehrer, 1 sign-d than. Q Witness, new this stetoaer* f «dolf Hitler of September 1, 1939; did you ever see it? « 1 believe I saw a copy or the criminal; I do net know. Fcr the first tine when the heichs Minister cf Justice Dr. Curtner, at the end of 19A0 cr the beginning of 19A1, visited = as 1 testified before, and talked tc uc about what was to bo dene about the infometion received, that was the first 2673 7 fefcrui ry-A-WG-13->-24cehen Court Mo. 1 I had acw-i it. It did net 20 through ay hands, but today i cannot say Kith certainty whether I saw the ori'ii^l or whether I eaw a copy. Q i.itncss, you Just ^id that a parson who did net have tho necessary specialized infoiaatdoo could not find any objections to the form of such stetecvttts of adolf Hitler; is the' true? A Yea, it happenod that if Minister Speer submitted sa.ething in a fora which was not correct, if it caac to jy hands I corrected the fora. *ho Fuehrer himsolf did not thinh it was v_ry important, if ^cnathing was shcim to hia, he thought it oust bo right and he aien«d it. Q hltnosa, I :-3k«xi you before whet you consider the legal character of this stataunt of Adolf Fit] ,-r without consideration of tha f •_-.3wor insofar co it has been nsae will be stricken. 2679 , .BY Dr.. Fr.QzSZrsirJV .: 7 Feoraary-«-C JG-13-A-si-.er.an Bcurt Ho. 1 q V.itncsa, this acmii-g you spolo of e meeting between you and hoicha- loitar Bouhlcr in 1940; dc you knc» wh-th.r heichsleiter Bcuhlor in Uay or June of 1940 Visited Adolf Hitler in order to ask hifi that he be relieved of hi a duti-'s as head of tfiv Chancellery? * 2 Jo, I do net rtaaeber that. Q I have no further questions, » hr. President. % 7 -Ob c7 -A-JJAA-lIi-l—Jinabuck (3J) Court .!o« - TiC xOZSID21T: Is there any further examination of this witness by the defenso counsel? (. 0 reply.) Prosecution nay proceed to cross oxaaine. cRosh nmi/jicw 31 .a. IL'JOYt Dr. LooMrs, do you still have the throe decrees, the Fuchro* deer 003 , concerning Karl Brandt's appointomt as a General Coxjissionor before you? v A. I do not havo the docrcos. (Docunonta handed to witness.) Q. '.Titnoss, you soy that Or. .varl Brandt \ma authorized to issue instructions within the wdical fiold of hie social tasks. Now, those tasks have not boon defined. Do you know w.iat those sp.clal tasks lforo? '• rili8 “orning I said that th: contents and oxtont of tho special tasks -ro not kno-.n to no in detail: tiiat I only know that ti.oy :orc in fields of oconouica and scicnco which had sane connection with the radical T4id health sorvico; for oxoaplo, in obta. nin^ drugs, otJior nodical suppli, ond ci.L.iar things and in scientific rosoarch in the field of war injuries, fruit is what I know about it. I did not eonoorn zqrsolf with tho details, and Z had no interest in tho do tails of Dr. Brandt's special assignment. Q. How, Doctor, will you kindly look at tho first section of tho July docroc of 19h2 and 'rtdeh you aided in the draft.nc thereof concerning the powers given to the c..icf of tho nodical services of tho 'ohmacht; aotoly, Dr. handloaor, and .dll you toll us hat powers as a practical -•attar did this first decree give to Handloser? A. Para^ra/h 2 of liuuber 1 says about liondloscr• s tasks: "The chiof of ^ -dical Service of the '.hr -acht is to represent the ’.Tclirnacht tolcro the civilian authorities in all corzaxi nodical problems arising in '•••* various branches of ti.c . -hraucht, tho .offen SS and organizations •-.its subordinate or attached to the .’ehraocht, and will protect the -i.iercsts of the .iuhraacht in all uadic .il a-asuros taken by tho c:.v_lian aut; ion ties."' This defines tho task of Handlosor. 2681 7 F 0 fc Ii7-A-^U-Ui-2-iiinabcck (BJ) Court „o. 1 Q. Could you toll us as n practical latter /hat powers Kandlosor received Iron th;s language you hav_ just read to us? A. Ho reqrosents the .'ohrxacht as c.ilof. He negotiated irith dr. Conti on the civilian side and also idth ‘x. Brandt as far as Frandt bad any special assignments. •-i. Did no have any powers over the. other sectors, such as the :o_dical services, tho .ou$r, tho Luftwaffe, the :iavy and the doffon SS? a A. Tlia powers of the chief of the .e'.iraacht n-dical s-rvicc l don't taiov in detail. They arc s.t down in other acUinistaativo formulations, not only hero. Thoy are all tho powers wliich tho head of the fohrnacht ■v. ducal service hid. They wore not repealed by this. They *orc o,:ly n-.itioncd hor- in a curtain direction for tho purpose of this decree to coordinate military and civilian Iwdwh services. Q. Wow, itness, as Z understand it you were chief of the Welch Chancellery. now, in that position you woro considered to bo a so-called link bo tween tho Fuohrer and all tho T—ich niniators; is that correct? A. Yos, unless there :erc express exceptions. Q. '.lon JXUI . 1 .. HVU 3 Y: Thank you, Doctor. 1 have no further questions, your Honors RZDIiGCT Hl-.'IV.TICH EY DR. OBiTATIUS: Q. hitness, you i.rj eked whether tills was a for ally valid In:. You said that fcio cuatooary requiivoents wore not fulfilled, x- thero other .cosibiliti-s in .addition to a 1~;? Burt the prosecutor asked :j- -.as only vhat in Gcr-.nn jurispru -uoo call a for.ial 1 at, a law v ich has ' -a passed by way of legislation, and n- of 5 ucs a 1 ; -ssad by K .-.m^-nt. Other aays w-rt . passing a e-cr- or a d_cr_o of t’.u, :-^u'.r. Tin Fu.hr.r dcci\-e had been ‘ever froa tile period of von Hind a nburg. it ...is nothing r. a. .* that had h. .1 established b V the Puolir-r, and this .'ushr-r d-cr-e «as not pasood in ..is forrual ay. . 0 one had anything ‘.o do *rith it -xcept t’. e :lirist.rc who 7 Feb la7-A-J3-I5-2-Jiin3cuck (2J) Court .io~ 1 were participation, end they were only csiruitod. Their ;.p roval -s not nieces'-”’, r.ic Fuehrer alone determined. And ii the Fuahr jr /anted r. Fuehrer deer— or if a sinister vaniod a Fuclirer decree, then I sent a • draft of such a doerv-o t^ the idnisters concerned and nak-d lor their opinion. It was sufficient if the -d: lister a aero consults, ."hether they hart objected, vhotlur thogr had approved Aide no difference actually b-cauao tivc Tuclircr .done decided. ^ Q. Then the -ztarnal fora of a < ccroo does not indicate tint it vos invalid? ' A. That is, in :y opinion, a doubtful question. Q. leu ajntioncd two cas_a before • .lion th.es. r.-qulrcjcnts wore not nccossary. A. I produced then. Q. The liinister of Justice considered it a legal docroo? A. 71 vo . inis tor of Ju-ticu co.sldorcrt it a legal Aiclir.r ox-dor aivd a lair. Oth.-rls- he would not have etopped the proceedings. SS3V TIU3: I have no further questions. )T>. 1~LT2: (Counsel for Handloscr): lx. President, through tlvc questions .asked by .x. Hardy the question of minber 1 of tho -croo of 19U2 •.•as brought up for the firct tine. Therefore, I ask t at I nay he allowed to ;ck a question on this nunber 1 -.rtiich rffocts tho ’ .'chmaclit IJadical Servico. THE ;iti>IDEirr: Counsel ary px*o~e chi_f of t - -dgn Cojamd of the A. r.r.cht, Keitel, was the ou;xrior of the cocaand-r s-in-c hi of of the branches of tho Whhmacht? A. Till clxiow of tlio :dgh Co-x-uxl of tho ttahraeht, Keitel, ;ao not co aondcrnin-chlcf of the branches of the >x _\c t. Q. Then Keitel could not 0 ivc orders to Coertnc or Kaeder or Doeritz? A. They could issue ord-rs in t!k lr “ n fields. Q. * said Keitel could not £ive orders to the co r-mders-in-chivif? A. Keitel could not sLv. an. or re to the coaaand-rs-in-ahief. Ho could only tranerdt orders fron the -hielircr to then, but that as true only of the rdlitnry field for the -ere comax.d r-attors. ..s far is tho chief of thcOKi.' rcis-cl tho functions of a sinister of xrsr, than tldngs tore different. Q. Handlosur was ritBin the O.T.' tho subordinate of Keitel? A. Hot' — uh t Handler,r's iHtiry ositi . vus, I don't know. 1 don't bur; eO .;hoa he .as subordinate. 2607 ere 7 ?cb Ii7-A-JB-l5-t-JIinabQCk (3J) Court i.'o. 1 Q. T!icn the internal conditions of -he .chmacht ^-cic~l Service cocplotclj' unknown to you? You cannot c;otcss -jy opinion? A. The organ! z '.tional plans of the 0*37 — Q. I uas asking you whether you could express aqy opinion Vo-ut toe powers which Handloocr had, froo your an knowlodgo? A. Ho. ER. JCLTEs Thank you. I hav- no further questions. 26oS 7 Februnry-A-D.tG- 16 -l-Futty Court mo. i DR. FBOESCHUAKN: Mr. ^resident, Dr. Frceschmann for Viktor Brack. I havu cno question arising frea the ex amination by the Prosecution. May I ask it? TH2 PRFSIDB.’T: Counsel nay propound the question. 2UMIK..TI0N BY DR. FfcOESCHMUffil Q Witness, do you recoaix-r th-.t.-.at the uid of 1940 or tho beginning of '41 the Defendant Brrck called on you at your offico >.nd th t you told him about tho draft of the lew which you have Just been discussing and thet finally Brack rsked you to give him this lrw? A I cannot r«««*£.cr it, out 1 consider it possible that Brack celled % on no and that wo discussed thj draft of the law. Q Witnoss, cen you ren^ebur ttv*t this draft nliich was worked out by you was Jivon to Kuichsluitcr Bouhler or the Fuehrer Chancellory? A I do not knew, but I consider it possiblu th t 1 gave Brack or Buuh- ltr a draft of thia lar, but it w s - rough draft; 1 oust state that express¬ ly. It loft quite a number of questions epon. DR. FROSSCHMaUN: Mr. President, I have no further quostions. RECRCSS EXaWUaTION BY UK. HaRDYs Q Dr. Lantiers, will you kindly toll us what wro thu limits of validity of r. Fuehrer Docroe? A Free tho local point of view which had prevailed sinco 1933, tho Fuehrer Decree had the same force ns i law passed by tho Roicharociorung or by tho Reichstag. Q Than, re I undorstsnd, your special decrees of thoJhKhrcr usually contained your name an' tho name of tho particular ainist.r and then duly published in the Hdchgesetsfclott, i3 that right, such os these decrees conferring tho authority as General Cccaissar- for Health and Sanitation on Karl Brandt? A Tho Fuehrer Decrees were published in the Seiehgesetzblatt cn principle if they wore to have full force as lrw, but ther-- were Fuehrer 26S9 7 Fefcruory-A-OJG-16-2-Putty Court So. 1 Decrees which were not published in the Reichgesutzblatt because that did not seas necessary. Fcr example, all the organizational decrees aocut tho occupied territories, none cf thec were published in the Reichgesetzblatt. Q Well, those were usually decrees cf an adodui strati vo nature, wcr-‘ they not? A Yes, they we. e adniniatrativo organizational decrees. Q WOU, then, Dr. Lacners, if I h-ve understood you correctly, it is your opinion that the Fuehrer letter of 1 September 1939 pertaining to the rXithonasia program was not a valid Fuehrer Decreo, ia^thet a correct presirap- tion? « I nave already said that I would have considered a law necessary. DR. SERV«TIUL: Ur. President, thi witness is now being asked c legal question which it is the tack cf the Tribunal to docido. 1 do net believe that this question is adsissable, end 1 ask Uvt the nnrwer bo stricken from the record. H«RDY: I submit, Your Honor, that the witness here is an export on Gorman law -nd 1 put the question to hie was it his opinion. THE PKESIDan: Tho objection is overruled. Tho witnoss may state his opinion on the question propounded to hie. UK. HaBDY: The witnoss has answered the question, your Honor. I havo no further questions to put to this witness. hEDXKBC? swjcn„tio:: BY DR. S?icV..TIUS: Q Witness, ycu said that there were decrees which wero net published. Was the reason for this secrecy? A That wps partially the reason. Q These wore docreea concerning the -.dainistraticn of the occupied territories, is that ccrroct? They did not .ill hive to be kept secret. Q But it was tb.- pppsop tc keep thu secret as far as possible. /. Yes, and also the fact that it did net affect the Reich territory. Q Are there not also other decrees which were kept secret concerning 2690 7 Fcbruc ry-,.-0 JG-l6-3-Putty Court He. 1 the conduct cf the war? A It cay te thrt there were such decrees. Q I as thinking of the r.eich defense laws. *. The Belch defense law was not published, and when I was examined here by the big Tribunal last year, I always called it an administrative order which was quite valid and permissible because the measures in the field of Reich defense did not require publication. Q Then the usual fora was dovieted from? i. The lew was not published. x Q «nd who ordered this violation of the fern? A The Fuehrer did not want this law published end it was net published. Q Then I conclude that the FuOiror h-d the right to dot. mine devia¬ tions from tho usual fora? A Yes. In tho case of every law ho could say, "I do not want it pub¬ lished," and then it was not jwblishod. It has only a question of whother it cane into axistenco, as a law. It was certainly not a law if it was not published, a formal law, I underspend, only a published law. Q Viitruss, I aa not opoaklnr cf fcrwl lews. 1 an speaking of a decree, You said that tho fore could bu modified or changed at tho discretion of tho Fuehrer. a Ho, not always, formally the Fuehrer Dccrcos w^ro published. W licmally, yes, but you ycursdi* nur.ticnei two casus where this form was changed. A Veil, then, the Fuehrer ordered thf t they should not be published. Q «r.d ho had tho power tc dc th- 1 ? A I assume that ho did. DR. S2tV..TIUS: I have nc further questions. DR. FR0£SCH1A.NNj iff.. President, I ask that the riling Just node by tho Tribunal bo reviewed. I asked the witness whether the Fuehrer Decree of tho 1st of September, 1939, could be understood as a decree by persons vhc wore net legal experts, thrt is, the population in general. The Prc3ecutor ob¬ jected to this question, and the objection was upheld by the Tribunal. New 2671 7 February-*.-iJJG-16-i-Putty CiliTt So. 1 the Prosecution for the sc~o reason has asked the witness about the signifi¬ cance cf these decrees. The Prosecution in view of the legal kncwledgo of the witness ccr.siderod this question Justified. I believe that the Tribunal will have to change its previous ruling, since whrt has been granted tc the Pres-cut ion mr.y also to granted to the Defense. I therefore, nuJce cpplicntic that the ruling of the Tribunal be changed and that the question and answer which was stricken froo the record be rostered. TH£ PRE3IDLIT* The question pounded by Counsel for the Defense to the witness sought tc elicit cn onswer as tc whet sono other pooplo thought or nirht have thought of tho lew. The question propounded to the witness by the Prosecution was as tc tho opinion of tho witness upon tho law which is qulto a different scatter. Mr.. H.J-.DY: I havo no further questions to put to this witnoso. DR. 3ERV..TIUS: Tlth tho porodssior. of tho Tribunal, 1 shall new call tho witness, Gutzcit. THK PhESILLYi: Thoro being no further examination of this witness, the witness. Dr. Lasers, will bo excused. The Marshal will surra-n ths witness, Gutzoit. KURT GUT207, a witness, took the stand rod testified as fdlcwsi JUXS SaSRli.G: You will pl-as* tree thu Tribunal, hold up your right hand end be sworn, reporting -ft<_r ao tho oath: I swear by Gcd, the tlnifrty and Coni sclent, thet 1 will speak the pure truth and will withheld and add n-thing. (Tho witness repeated the oath.) JUDGE SZBRi.'fc: Tcu any bo so*.tod. DInSCI EL UHIIC’..’ BY Dh. 32*V..Til'S: Q \.itness, when -nd -here w«ro you bern? what is ycur naiae? „ Kurt Gutzcit, bem on the second cf June, 1893. 1 You are a prof-sscr n^dicioo? /. Yes. ‘ q Dc you h‘ive specialized kr.owlt/ig© in rny field cf a-.dicin.;? 2692 7 February-*-!L>JG-16-5-Putty Court He. 1 * * 9 % .. In =y stdicel activity I dealt prlmrlly with stccach and intestinal diseases, liver diseeses end infectious diseesos. Q Witness, will ycu plecso tell the Tribunal rny infomation that may indicato your specialised kncwledgo, especially since 1 am .Tcing to examine yeu cn the subject of hepatitis? 1 In 1920 I took the nodical State oxae&nation. Then 1 was an assist- A ant at the City Hospital in Hcu Kcdn in Berlin. Then I bccaae assistant at the nodical university clinic in Jana. There in 1923 1 ^qualified as a lect¬ urer and received porsdssicn to held lectures. In 1926 I beca.sc assistant at the university clinic in Breslau. In Breslau I alsc obtained percussion tc hold lectures and was instructor for internal aodicino. Internal nedicine is ny special field. In 1929 I bocciu Professor of Internal dodicino at the University of Breslau. In 1930 I fcccnaa Chief Physician of the Breslau University Clinic. In 1933 I was ^trusted with the direction cf tho Hospit'l in Berlin. In 1934 I becsco r regular Professor for Internal Jtod- icino at tho University of Breslau end boenuo director thcro of the radical university clinic whore I had fcnacrly worked as assistant. I hold this position until Broslru was evacuated ir. January, 1945. Q Witness, durinj the war ycu woro consulting jhy® lclan of tho Wohr- .r.-cht and work cl in the l&lltrry lAxlicnl /.endeuy, is that right? A Tos. Q Tc when wore ycu sutcr.'.inato there? A In the military Helical ..ccd-xay I was under tho conrnnling officer cf Instruction Croup C of the Jilit- ry dodical ..cadocy. Ihr-t was Gonoral- arzt Dr. Schriebcr. «s Consulting Internist, vhich I was appointed at the beginning of tho war whtn I ves drr-ftod into tho i.uhrcacht, I was undor the ,.rrjy Medical Inspector, Professor Dr. holdacnn. 7 Fob !:7-.>17-l-M3rd (3J) Court ; .:o. 1 Q. That Information will be sufficient. -itr-ess, did you concern yours-If -Jith H.po.titis r-sjorch? A. los. Q» Do you fcner.; the- specialise, the other sp-cialiats vho vorkod in tha fi-ld of Hepatitis research? A. I hno-./ nua>_r of tlioa b„* a vs-, perhaps all of thee. Q. hill you please ajnt_an ti-o -ore important ones? -- ... tn the -Alit.ary .-dical as atabs-rzt Doctor Donen, >'ho iSM also suberdinnto to the CorruuV-_n- Officer of ti.e -iHtary Ivdicnl •verdetx*. dealt with Bacteriology; tluat is, 1th research into the cause of Her t.'.ie htidaiica. .Iso, I know of two ..osiat-ats frau the Lei>ciC JaiYoroit;* Altaic, .aid .. third nMo 1 do not r»naibcr ut too uouent, iroro coaconud trlth roscarch into the causo of Jjindlco. The two ussiot.ats of Prof j'.aor hur r.~r wero hied or ad Curtr.cr. who hud. at .n o.Jllor 'oriod, worked oa the question of Hepatitis. 1. ‘-Itaeso, that will bo onought, thenk you. You cpofco of Doctor Saico. Did lector Douen hare a ro->c rch asoigauent? . 4 j f.r as Z roo 11. -ad ! do sot bulUvo th-t I t» alotcCcm, in tho course of Me work on Hepatitis. Donee roceivod a rooo.rch asai^xi^nt. ho 0*4 know frou u;y>a the assignaust cjjoT ^ Tho aai.igrtioat cmc free tho Commission for ^>ido>ica .lace- - eh of tho ..cicr -LCoourch Co^nool. that was O-Aorul.rst Doctor Schrcibor. Did you work with Doctor Dor.en? a. la tho fiad of Jaundice it vos one field, bo worked tosether in different ooctors; and I was latere.tod in tho c.*ar.o of tho dico co, ini tho coailitioas which cauaod the diBO.se, *lth tho st-tistice of t.;c dioo.'.oe, tho question of how d_n*eroue it was -nd tho consequences. Ulilo Doctor D-i.et t;.!S is charge of tho bactoriologicJ. research. I tried to dotck-jiao \itr.t < as tao 2694 7 Pet L7-K-S -17-2-1 e-r-f Court !'o. 1 Cause of thi* dlso s«. Chat this dicease ..as co.-.ta 'our had .already been r. -w to be very prcc-Lle t:* the clin' research wlich 3 had conducted. itness. what kind of voric did Doctor Danan do 9 Do you knc» that A. Doctor D.sen woriced froa scratch. Ke tried by coans of animal cxperlxce.it a, froa certain see rations of the stlent, to cultivate the tom in the anlaal. It •.»* necessary first of all to fin-* the right ani-ials in let these -er-s con'-' be cultivated and finall* It Mas -osslble to tmnsfor the seras to the animal, to inject the mi-sal, that is tc •'roduco an ani-oal dieojse; and r.o > .- y transferrins the er.: froa cn*i a;. a»tg to another, to ass on the disease froa one aniael to another. — that is colled animal culture, aniral orra.-e, And, t eso in vor*. lotions t ere carried on later >7 the cultivation of the era in the clinic. It v*as shown t at this vas not a bactorlun as 1 i: s oen a oaed r. revioup sears; that the cauno of the disease wao a suh- ver sco r e crganlpa »J icfc ha.* to be gr.M'csc* -lth the virus. Q. itr.oso, what :d ~octor Do -eft actually ’’oi *ir ■!'* his vork A. He believed V t he :.V - u r/ the cau'o Epidoiica Jnun'ice. This vas In icatod b'* a na-ilor f fict-rs. . Itness, th.»e * ."nnaation is sufficient, hV.r, did Doctor Graultz have anything to do wj.th tide experiment* A. hen Jcctor Couen had cultivated Lis cultures in the anlsal and i.en in the aoctincs of . oical Societies, Vis research work of lector Donen had been diccucsed frequently, t! e wls« mbs er.-ressed y various oeo-le •hat those cultures shoul* bo ta'o.i ever fro.-. Dce*n. -rai-itz -as ir. tores led in Jaur.’ics rerc»rc:. because evaixihero Geranv, varticularlr among the trca a and in the c».»-a, in refugee cim, concer.trrtic-n c/unps, in children e" aeration 2695 7 Pcb 4?-A-S‘-17-3-B«»rd (3J} Court :'o. 1 csjts. Jaundice war 'lftying vs erv>rsrus role : n Curwiy. Ho a? so wante- to 1 avc cu3 taros frai !>s-on so that he, hiaeelf, could l, avo further ox;eriJsents aade. This request of Srmitp, 2696 7 Feb A7-3K-17-1*-Beard (FJ) Court Uo. 1 as well as i aicilr.r request f rca i.aagen, another research worher, also concerned with the bacteriology cf Jaund5.ce — Co-:on rofusod this ret.va st. i. hat vaa tie re’son for this' A. And, he did this fcr the i'oll<;.• iantitn is porfcnxoi. A . Ti’or of ora you consider it lr.yossiblo that f-t-litios e-uli occur? A !*c, I cannot iraglno that . OH. SSSf’JOVSi Thon I da not havo any further it ati ns f tho witness. -2699- 7 ?obru ry-.r-3JO- 19 -l-Gro ■ t Court 5>. 1 ST IS. ,2L?I (for th- defendant Bandl .0 s«r)j ^ 'iitnoaa, you aro Con ultant Internee vith th. Kftdlcnl Inspector: to of tac .jr^rl A Tot. ^ Tint vita Profoator Unlduxnn acd then afterwards. froa tho 1ft of January ljhl on, vith Profcaeor ludloiirT A 5xat ia coraoct. A q IXiring your activities a a Consultant Intornco vith tho Ar~y Medical Inspectorate did you aaintoin your position at rofcssor ur< diroctor nt 3r 03 lout A I anvo u-ictoiaod cy civilian activity t Broalnu r.a far r.e nilitary duties vhlch had boon ,:ivon to o* T»ruittod it. Part of the tiuo I van nt tno Military Wedioal :*nde.y in Berlin, at ay pluco of work, and looctiaoa I vns nlao at tho Brcalau Ohlvwcalty Clinic and I havo troutud tho pntlontf K.ich voro located thorw ard I have alao given locturca. ^ Mrs t..ia alao tho caao vith other consulting phyeioiona? A H- t vaa co.~or. prsctlco in tho case of clrttit all consulting physician v..o vorkad vithln tho fono of tno Intorlor. ^ Th. t la vita all taoto vno hero worked vith tho Nodical Any Inopoctor ato. Tbit vet couuon pxactlcot A Ho. Th t cannot bo sold. I vaa a reserve Dodic .1 officor and I alao cad a civilian activity. Sovcver, there voro alao consulting physicians who voro ectivo : llitnry ^yaiciuco or'. tn-y, of courao, worked at all ti 00 in tho military aoctor. i •/oil, of courao. I only referred to tho .-os.rvc ;hysicinnt. All thorn consulting physicians *.;o woro only civilloi v-yalci-ona, did they not alao oxlst? A Thoro wore several consulting hysicians who woro not in uniforu nt nil. I can rano-bor Professor von Siccen in 3-rlin, the diroctor of tho Snr Uni vor city Clinic, and Professor Iphloin, tee director of the ^.’C Clinic of tuc University of 3 rlin. -2*700- 7 Fob A7-A-DJ19-2—-ross Court He. 1 .. Is t, therefore, correct to r-?y that the consulting *ysicians who othoxviae had a civilian aodical activity al«o durinr their censcrintion as cor.sultir.? physician carried out a double function? A. Y~3, certainly - in a «ay. And tfat alo in their civilian sector they w_re not subordinated to t:.a A ray epical Inspect ore to. A. In civilian dical Activities thoy wore not subordinated to the odical Inn ectorotc. .ill you pie iso toll the Tribunal about t' c official positions of the consulting hysicians which layod an Jancrt»nt orraninational role in tl:o caso of Kandlosor' A. Thorc w«.ro c>n«u!ton: hysJclnna in the field Arqy, within tho Sicao »rsy, and further. or. with the -.icyr eO:col Ins octorato and wore ovoryvh v rc "hero so-called .udical officers in c‘ arjo oro located. Furthoroora, con¬ sult n; physicians -. oro usod for the _ or*, of the hysician An d arge. Q. Did those eons- It' ns -hysicians hav a cortain military rank' A. frat «as r.ot tho caso. A certain rt>do had boon -rovldod for t! o consulting hyaiotans r. "uo-tion. Fo'uror, ho tins only *‘-lo to roach this -rodo vhon thoy had roon into that position on me of thoir ago. "or osaarlo, there * .re ocneulti.i? 'h sic ins with tho relatively low .ilituy ride of t: - assistant physicians ard thoro 'ere other consulting physicians vho in accord»nco *.::t.\ their ago or their special skills occupied hlrher Glittery grades. Actually there w;ra all officor grades represented by ccnsultin ph.veicia.is. Is it not dlitarily un-.norml to a certain extent? A. The uholo sta us cf consulting hysicione froz a military point of ’•‘I- ac unusual and it wo un-ncr.nl. The consultin' -hysicianc on the asis of their portion actually di^ r.ot fit m -ithin t:*, s-ali ailitary fraaei rk. ilroe^f fw* tic reason bee they > -re in art also: taking caro of the c.v:_ia.. r’:. *7 . consult r. sici-na or example in con- -r t lit ot'.-.r lodiccJ officers did n* t have an; authority and they .'id not •--v any disciplinary author 1 ty cither. Thoir activity consisted, as is ai-ovn by 2701 7 Febru2r7-A-:0G-lS-3-Grcss Court Bo. 1 their ruse, of consulting others. -:.~7 actually did net hr.v-. any office. They did net have any official stanp. They did net havo any coccand author¬ ity. So, that actually the position of the consulting physician basically varied free the other parsons eff the cdlittry systja. The activity of the consulting physician consisted of scvoral functions. It is sot forth in thu so-called directives for consulting physicians. It represents part of the directives for the collection cf military nodical experiences. ftccSrding tc these directives the consulting physicians, first of all, had a consultinf X function. Secondly, they had a collecting function for the effect of exper¬ iences which had accunuleted within the Medical Services of the ..ehroacht. And, finally, the function was to teach and to lecture in erdor to raiso tho level of training of the a«. ileal officers. Point two of this activity, the activity pcrt'-inir.g to the collection of experiences and the effects, is also known ns scientific resosrch work. Q ..o will refer to this lotcr cn. Is it corroct th: t all thoso con¬ sulting physicians who were with the «ray -nd *nsy groups, who for tho roost part harl a collecting activity, and who at hoa*o in particular, thoso who worked with tho arny Medical Inspectorate hoJ a utilising function at hone? A Th't aay well bo said but it is still net quite corroct. Tho con¬ sulting physician in tho ,%ruy and in tho Corps Areas had a utilisation act¬ ivity as wull as a collocticn activity. W Is it perhaps sc that Iced prctluns wore also utilizod r.t tho front and th t acre octensivo problems were utilised at hone? « Th’t is correct. -2702- 7 /Ob L7-X--' 1-20-1-Loss or (BJ) Court .To. 1. w. Km: do you »rcw that the *rry medical regulat ons havo contained tfco Tact t:iat tl o consulting physicians, and this is tho technical ox ression — since tjc question of tho cxtablishsont of sroups plays a certain role in this trial, I rouid like to ask *ou tho following ruostion: • Docs a ;roup of specialist physicians, with all tho officers Jn charge, indicate that they vaoa.st V aasolves constituted a *rouj>? That is, that they subjectively w.ro ccnn„ctod with osch other' Or is this only^a statement as to tho coistonco of a number of physicians with equal objective marks' v A. Tho latter is correct. Q. has tho ontiroty of tho consulting hysiciane at tho front os well as at homo anoncst themselves, — ore they connected with each bthor? A. Ko, in many eases they did r :von fcnm» each other. Q. Kem do yew kr .a that tho consulting physicians .not at conferences which also placed a s.-^ocial part in this trial' how did tho consulting physicians cornu tojothor by agroasont? A. No. Tho consulting pfc -sicianr wore ordorcd nnd dotachod and the a ray medical inspector soloctod thoso consulting ohysicians rho woro to attend •» conference and than thoy woro sent by their dJ roct suroriors, tho raodical o.'ficcrs in charge, to Attand thoso particular mootings. Tho proeoexttion has cla mod that these conferences had boon typical mootings of conspirators, that is to say, of physicians who net in order to coezit war crisis, crioos a alnst humanity, and o plan thoso erimoa and to carry them out. Ycu knot- of those conferences and tho composition or thoso people who att-ndod. Tthat can 'ou say to tho accusation of the pros ocution'’ A. Ihc confcrcccor served a ocr'ose, ac far as I know, to discuss the experiences * hich had been gained ir. the various solical fields in the field and ’.t heuv, which wore ;ainod by tho individurl consulting physicians, and tfcon to put then den in sort of directives. Tho consult- ir.r physicians then a~ain returned to thoir offices and they then utilized the experienco of which thoy had boon informed in thoso conferences. 2703 7 ?-b i7-A-41U-2C-2-L.ssor (3J) Ccurt Ko. 1 lectures t:oro ~ivcr. and they wore discussed -and then directives r. sro issued is to certain methods cf treat-cat and about the diagnosis of certain diseases and tho evaluation of tho physic*] condition with r.jard to the diecso. Tfeon these directives wore axaoinod by the a nay nodical iar -.ctorato and they wore then sent to tho front lino units in order to have ticso d rectives carried out. ». Do you "c* ether those printed reports .-.ad the Printed ^ directives wore clcss.fi-d as-secret? A. I do not fc ink that cost of th.s. reports •,;ore classified secret. Q. Hone .f then wore classified secret. I only * ant>. exp-rloac«s ullch had been gained at all the various s .c’.ors and to discuss t’ ec n.jonfcst representatives of this up.cial field and perhaps to correct *-? inc fi’iure, I 'is r.i van t.-.e assl nrarnt by tho ory modi cal '-rctir t. particular] c:>v sreolf Kith this diseaso. In purfurco cf t. is aesi-nont I t on >ent to t'o *ri us theaters of Operations, to roocc, to Russia, to ranee, i d T have ersonally lookod at tho various cr.con at U i viriour hospitals. I think In t! > courso of tho time 1 saw an* touMi..*" of -uch *v»tlente. Then X ! ave lcokod ct t! o ca-ser for I s 'i.rovo an* 1 /avo pars aally doemined that tho rear r.s which ’ad for :orl* boon C'.r.s dere’ &r ba ,r. ■ '-* cause of tho dissaso, for tea >3o, food poison in,, c'ixr.Uc influenco, bad conditions <•:' drink • --or, iftd other factr, vero not tho evens cf this disease. I mv in t'.a niroof tlao f at ti e disease could So enrriod from one h’VAT coin; to t i no:* and t st thir disease bolon o<1 in tho jroup of stalled infectious d u?* rcro G.-ceot.or.-’. 1 -..as -'urth ?r ablj to d 0 terM‘.o that jaundice i.eral y is a hi:-xlaos dise-.ro wi ich doas not causs any pain and v'.ic! c.-r.cje the itimt to be -ellt*: litre in 2 , «, and f -oaks and fcol very _>ha"'.cd. c uld bo furf ur scarf -lid Uat no injurious cr iic-:lions ou .* serin after tho dircasj. *hat as ccrtrnst to the union vlich var 'sv.ously held, which -tated t:.xt da.-a.;us to th.o Jivar r-,uA_n. 2705 7 Fobruar7W.8DJG-2i-l-Karrcw Court So. 1 Q ifcy I interrupt you for a airvute? In tho speech cf G_ntrcl Tqylor - in his general speech - in the tres¬ cript of 9 Deceshor the transcript contains the following sentence cn Prge 82 of the German versin> and the speaker here tells of a letter »iich Gr-- witz wrote nd in this lotto? he i~ alleged to have discussed the ovor-all importance of a vaccine of extraordinary military vrluo for the treatment of epidemic Jaundice end he ccntinu-s, end I quetos "In several companies there wore fatalities up to 70* os e result of epidemic Jaundice." k Kay I esk you who -rote thJ letter end te hc it was addressed? Q It is "Uo.-.d to havo been written by Grnwitz tc Hinder. „ This stnteaont ia in contrast to all experiences. I believe that this is p .-aiatake in printing. It probably should not road 60* fatoliti-s, but it means tc say that in scoc companies 60* of the entire coupany cc.ught the disease. If uny such asrtality rato hrd occurred at any plnco I beUeve that it cert-inly wculd have eoch of -nrural Tay:or tho addition for six --joks had :ocn loft ait. That as the cnly reason I *jstod a uistake 'vad recurred. Ti PRZSH) M: I ..ouid sta‘-o to lounasl t: at a cc>y of th-j 3h;lish vora. on -ill bo .ado available to hi*. In so far ?s tho statement of Gjnoral Taylor ia corcorncd, it is clear t‘at sooo oiror lea eon carriod through In tho record. It is not or any inoortnneo, but as stated by Counsol, tho Olen¬ ins statement of cithor tho i-esecution or tho 'Wenao aay contain or.lv uh&t that aide cf tho caao expects to ?rcvo. It I as no binding .orco as ovidoncc. OX DP. "SLT3: %. .'itnoss, .«tto:*nov Sorvatlua has oreviou rly as od vou *) o occupied Idnrulf v'th this rollon of hepatitis jnidoac'. You had rvun..i two officoro and * lent to ain r. correct picture ;.r>d I ant to j.-.-s on 'is oicturj to the Trib'U-.al. Just ho*, frequently did this iseaso occur and also l ow many officers occupied thoosdlvao * 3 th ti.»a xoblaaT A. kay I first of all state tat in tho veers 19A-C and 1941 t: o di«ooeo ; a.I an cnore us increase by nunbort. In order to ;.ivo a picturo 1 would like to n&rj tho folio-, n; nuefc ra which I can still rj.uar.bor. in ono sin 1. sooth, I ’.-oliovc it t as Saptaabar 193, <. tho ist ?rn Front alono - within one uinth t' ere vore 1*0 or I? M.ousanc now c^.aos. Tho anutl in-;’ ervaao ,r. eases cf ti:. disease in Oort my, 'nclodii our troops* at tho front, is uatimatad at l\ or 2 tillions. .Is xs already soon staled in ono lotter, in seen lac os tho dir,, so '•at-, reached 50 * to 60 - of tho uoricora or tho soldiers in tha c©.. mine. In tho - ar 1T6C, 1, ' avo soon 95 h’er- roceans in a French field hospital - that res threo-fourthn of ar. entire cu any. In a prisoner of war can- in Fo- rania, here S-.rl'rh officers -iv located, ’ithin - vory short period of time, of 3ll tho oooolc that w t ri there had C&e^ht 27C7 7 Febru-jy-..-WG-Sl-3-Xarro* Court So, 1 the disease* In twe other prisoner cf war camps in Greece and Crete, amongst the thrao or four thousand ins- tes, 30% tc 40S fell ill with the disease. This already indicated that hepatitis is dourly a camp or c oan nnity disease end that it appeared everywhere where human buinjs wore located in crowded billets and where the general hygienic conditions did net correspond with these which he h*i in Germany in ti-.-s of peace. I believe this indicates the inportanco cf the disease elonc dread;’ because of the enormous casual¬ ties on human beings - first of nil, fer the ccabtt units, and then for tho work r.t heme. Of ccurso, it was quite natural that with an epidemic of such gian proportions - I don't believe the we rid has over seen anything like it - every physicicn who hod a laboratory tried tc find the cause of the bac¬ illus by scoo means in sea* way. Many thousands, end perhaps hundreds of thousands cf bret.rlolcgical investigations of the urine, of tho stomach Juice, cf the intostinal Juice, end so cn, wore carried cut practically with- cut the least success, ar.a cnly mn of research, who on the basis of their preliminary kn.vlcdgo, weic fibs to carry on virus research wore rsoro for- tunrto in this respect. In Germany, at least 5 to 6 officers worked in order to find the cause fer the contagious Jaundice. *Ricy included Demen, Hnagen; they included the two assist onto from Leipzig when 1 havu .already n'aud; then irefesser Horzwald free Grcifswald, and there arc still throe or four others wncae names I can't rocall any more. They all tried tc find the virus. If the virus had bv.en found then it wculd have been possible tu first cf ell tr*et the disease in acccrdenco with its ccurso, end, secondly, to find a vaccine and a protection which wculd prelect millions cf people froa this disease. Up tc new, the treatment of this epidemic jaundice had only beer, carried cut with symptoms. The medical trocteumt which was civ an I hav« named. Drugs, rust — -- r . Do you knew hew the tn-'.Uiont for hepititis w.au carried out bread? .. ..eccriiro tc the literature which was available to us up tc the be¬ ginning cf the war end according tc the lit^wturc which w« wore rite to re¬ ceive fx\e. 'treed during the war, th- foreign countries did net have any other methods cf treatment end protection thm we had at tho beginning cf -2703- 7 February-«-DJG-2lW.-i£crrcw Court He, 1 tho er Sv.r. during the war, as far as 2 tux*, no specific therapy and r.e specific protection *a developed in connection with the disease. /. number of becks have been written abroad which indicete that the foreign countries also tried tc Jind the cause fer epidemic Jnundicc and tc appar¬ ently develop a protection against the disease. I cyself can remtober a beck from the year 194.5 contained in the Journal of the American Medical association by the authors Seefo, Stccktcn, Kncwley and hhinetoaxt. Ihe book described that within a circle cf pursens consisting cf s-coiled "conscient¬ ious objectors" that the excrements of petients fuffeYlng from this disease were mixed with water and then these excrements wero given to twenty-fivo people tc drink. They were in throe groups with five to a group. Certain chlorides end disinfection drugs wore given to thus. In thocasc of two groups such disinfection drugs wore not used. -2709- 7 ?eb 47-XJ-22-1-,..o’ zn ( J) Court Ko. 1 Ir. this froc s i ng or hepatitis a?idcr:ca ten pooplo bocanu ill, but not of epidemic Jaur.ico. Ih.sq ~oop>o wore such an oas'- caso thPt it cculd oot be countod o:.ons tho cases of cpidcaic jaundice; all tho others remained healthy. Thereforo, that is roof of the fact that tho foreign countries lik-wiso occupied V »-wo1tos for tho cause- nf this din,as j and they tried to kill the bacteria and uxcraiont and thus orotoct othor people. i. Eut, no fatalities occurred in this -lay A A. /all, that had to bo axpocted. '• *•«», »ill you please toll the Tribunal about you? res-arch and your attcapts to find tho virus; so far -ou Javo not done that. I aean your sothods of work. A. I, myself, '..ave never looked for virus as I am not a bacteriologist. Within tho sector of tho army, Dohaen trlod to eultiveto thio virus. I hivo att^-tod to d.scribe th-Se ex-arlaants. ./ell, firs*, of all I ar. interested in 'our activities, because you as consulting internist of Erofcssor -andlos.r to a certain oxtont belonged to his close surroundings and porha s ho nay be held rcs-ror.siblo for * hat you night lave done and what .aay not have been poraissiblc. Therefore, I think you should describe to us Just he* -ou worked, what were your methods in curr/in^ o-t ycur activities ir. regard to he -otitis research. A. I havo actually described it already. Mil you •'lease repeat it orco xoro briefly. A. I have .ndj observations bn patients in tho field hospitals, I have listed the case history, subsequent coa-licationc vnd faUliti s and frt».. 3wV„ral hundred thouaand of case histories, our young physicians and i ! av ! d.tciriincrf what da^a occur aft-r hepatitis, vhat is the iv.r* e de roo of tho sis^asc and what fatalities occur, vhat causes t:.c fatalities and I haV0 ruined tk*t hepatitis is contagious. I ;&ened this experience froc -v.y examinations an-* x rave further dot.rained that tho cause is not of t-acteria ret of virus. '• Hav. you car ie-’ cbt -unctur-s of ’ivers iuri.-r vour work? 271C 7 Fvb 47-i-an-22-2-K6ihAa (BJ) Court *o. 1 A. Punctures of livers ' ;re carried out, Hut I personally have not carriec. ti c out, b*.-t tinctures f the liver *ore oerfomed in individual fie d hcs-itils. ;1 i as a method - a technique, -title!, had sen dove!cped j two Danish authorities, loh^la and Ivoro'.n. For t! is puncture c< the liver, he atit's c:cld not to treated, 1: cat ever. It could bo dotero'ne'* - hat da_ia:es the liver ! as sustained arr* vhat t l e chances cf c ue » ’re ith t! ir diroaee. It cxl be determined if fter tho e-idesic jaundice -helivor vas ajain i'ioe lonin. vit! it' organs or if in; ' had raaa-nsd In t! e livor. This t. '5 i-aoortn t :’or - s erojnosis, it is also ia>ertsnt fer the q oatlon should sue:. huaan coin ayain be r*tur-ed to woric, could he to allcr-ed to serve, cr •■cuid l o further have to \ erso treatment. h. Can this j*.v.jtur>a£ cf the liver be cc-nevcioreJ as an «perL.ent on hu-Jin tei.r.a' A. Tho 'unct"ii% of the liver . ..ot in ox^eriuent, but a t >thcd 2711 7 “ob J.7-A-G 5-22-la-: ©ehan (3J) Court ;*o. 1. ■r lamin ation. It equals \.he so-celled lumbar ur.cture where the spinol fluid is drowned in order to exsuine the fluid secretions and consequently this puncture could not b-_ considered as danrercus. It is not daP7eroua in the hands of a person qualified to carry it cat. It is not more ;’•> aye rc-us thin i lirJrax- puncture UCT'ld be in the esse of a person who is not ex-er- ienoed. Ir. /our -'O'itior. as consulting internist; have you diseased the hepatitis research ith I rofessor Hmdlosor. A. I h've discusso* he; atitle quite a lot. * i. In this resroct, did the question evor arise that ir tie frtae of he-.atltis researc eX'Orlcants should cr ould have to be carried out on t.xuan fcein-oT A. As far as ntx t is question has never been discussed. «• iut, surely you have also nc .aports a_out t!.e ^ro?ross of your examinations* A. I 1 ve atu-o cither written or Orel roports when t' e necessity scoood to ariso. m. And in that r js'oct, did xu on -our ert over nention the quostion of [ortorolrtS oxcorlnonts on human boinys? A. No, I cannot rxcorbor. }. •, have yew over urittan a ijttor, vhioh I am -oirs to hand to -ou? It is a lettor date-' t o 24th of June 1944, to “rofoseor Hainan and in this lattor it is atat-V, "In lino with sy statements at the Joint hepatitis discussions -1 " roslav, * havj tried to =ako cru 1 " rations fo. ox'.orimonts on human bfti-'is". (2:-orUer.tu= Ciucis der Uebortragunc honinen)." nz sr-ZSHIT: hat is the Tocu-ont hock !‘3TZ: P- .t is the Document took about the ha-»atitis oridamca and it dees not have -ny nu..>er. *'es, it a- .V'cu.vent jeok Ito. 8, pate 11. Here ou will fin,-' the letter which I h've Just sectioned. L?.. VJCDX: It is Inhibit 193- 2712 7 Fob L7-*-G27>-22-2r--ll ea.«na (3J, Ccurt He. 1 i V:3 PK3SID—T: T.-.c exn.unsticn of this ritnese •»111 take how nuch Ion, eF; KT. :?2LT1: It \ ill t-“Ice a little acre tine. : r. Frasldent, thi" is ;galn*t Xarl 3r':ndt, ot al, defendants, sitting at Nurnborg, Goraany, on lOFebruary 1947, 09*0, Justice 3eals prosldlng. TH2 MARSHAL: Persons In the C-urt Room vlll ploaoo find seats. A Tho Honorable, the Judges of Military Tribunal 1. Military Tribunal 1 la now in session. God save tho United Stateo of America, and this honor ole Tribunal. Thoro will be order In the courtroom. Trfc.’ PRESIDENT: hr. Marshal, will you ascertain that tho do\*ondants aro all present in court. THJI MARSHAL: May it please your Honors, all defendants .re present In the Court Room. THJ PRESIDENT: Tho Socretary-Goneral will note for the x’uoord the prosonoe of all the defendants In court; Thu witnoss Gutsolt Is still cn tho stand and the witness is reminded that he is still undor oath. Counsol may prooeed. DR. 32AVATIUS: (Counsol for tho Defendant Xarl Brandt): May It pleaso tho Tribunal, may I first discuss briefly a technical question. On Friday the two witnesses, Relohemlnls- ter Lacaers and the witness uonoralartt Dr. Outsolt wore led here in handcuffs. I do not know tho reasons why Rolohsmlnls- tor isomers was handcuffed. I do not know if any special reasons oxistod for that. Professor jutrslt Is a prloonor of war. At present he is in an open coll In prison .nd la allowed to sore around. I be 1 lev a t.iat It should bo avoided to bring a witness here in such a way so that ho will not have *-r.e feeling of being under pressure and that ho perhaps nay 2714 1C F 0 b 47-K-DJG-l-l-Foater-lA?;) COURT I refrain fron tolling the truth hero. I would be very grate¬ ful if the Tribunal would nafco a ruling In this onao. THE PRESIDENT: Thla la a matter concerning which the Tribunal has no lnf.rantlon. Neither la the Tribunal advised as to the status of these witnesses- The Tribunal will inquire into the natter but that is, of course, 2714a 10 Feb 470X-OJG-l-2-Foster-l AX) court i 1 nit-or for tho seaurlty officer In charge to determine. The Tribunal will Inquire as to the situation. Proceed with the examination of the witness: KURT OUTZEIT - Resumed EXAMINATION (Continued) BY OR. NOLTfi: (For the defendant Handloeor) Q. Witness, at the end of the last session I had A doouaont booh Number 8 handod to you and I had callod your attention to tho letter of 24 Juno 1944 which you addressed to Profoasor Kagon at Strasabourg. Ihla lottor la part of correspondence In which the namos of Dr. Orawlts, Dr. Dohraen, Gonoralarst Schrolbor, Professor Hagan «i*l your name la also mentioned in connection with Hepatitis research. Will you ploaoo dosorlbe to the Tribunal If any and what connootlona exist between those persons with regard to Hepatitis reso tr'.h and your luttor of 29 Juno 1944. THjS PRESIDENT: Will counsel repeat the numb or of that doouaont. DR. :I0Li£: I did not understand your question, yc-ur Honor. TH£ PRESIDENT: rill counsol repeat the number of tnat uocumont. DR. N0L7S: It Is ptgo 11 of Doouaont 3ooh 8, Document No. NO 142. It is Exhibit 19*. A. This lettor of 24 Juno 1944 vhioh was dlrooted from me to Professor Haagen, It la the result of a Hepatitis conference of all research poople who wore ooncornod with this problem In Germany. In Juno 1944 thlp Hepatitis con- f-ronco took placo at 3roslau. 3otweon six and seven — I do not know tho exact numoor — various rosoarch mon wore there who had worked on tho Hepatitis experiments on 2715 10 Fab 47-M-DJ3-l-2-Fo8ter-lA£) COURT I animals, and also many other persons interested, physiol ms. In the course of the conference the experiences vhloh had been collooted In the meantime by the Individual research • men wore publicly printed. It became ovidenS that the various rosoaroh men hod roached completely varying results as a result of their experiments on animals. All these research men strovo to find the oourso of Hepatitis through animal experiments, ./hlle one p'irt hod carried out thee* experi¬ ments and the other part had carried them out with nlco, the third group carried 2715a 10 Fcfcrr r7-ifr*DJG-l-3-?cster Ccurt Sc. I thea cut with rtts nd tho fourth -Tcup carried thta cut with canaries. Tfcqjr "t-r* unable to dotcraina if tho bacteria which had been cultiv ted et different pieces ell represented the sa=e 'Tcup, of if they included a Ufi variety cf different haejerie. -2716- 10 Fetru :ry-M-QJG-2-l-Hinetuck Ccurt Sc. 1 If any human material is vaccinated cm animals, cr if nay animals are v-ccinftad with material cf human Lein’s, and if then the animal becomes sick, then in the. bo'i.inina it cannot b« stated with certainty if the disease cf the anir.'.l has been caused by the specific bacteria cr the dis- % case cf the animal has been caused by bacteria which is h - raless to human tein-s. Then, in the course cf the discussion at Breslau uhleh .tas presided a ever by Generalartt Schreiber, Schreiber su -osted or ordered thrt the in¬ dividual reaesren men and cuthcrs should form. md fellow certc in procedures of work, in order to compare the results they had achieved in thw ccurso of their experiments cn animls. Che of those rcups c.nsistod cf Dchmen, Haarui, oysolf rad severe! cth.r authors who \ v-iv. v.sy dcso tc H:.a-cn. The becinnin* of the letter deals with -u assignment cf Dchm-n to Hfisrcn. This assignment w s approved by Gvhordnrst Hr.*. -u r.s a result of tnis rc*rtupin :, end it was intended that Dchmen, t- -other with Hon ran, should ccapr.rw the rosults they had achieved in the ccurso of animal exp-ri- aents in their respective laboratories. That is the first prrn'ropi ihe second paragraph then dorls with the fact that during the ccnfcrenco V. Breslau I had acdo a statenent which deals with the expirir..nt c* crucis hecinco. I will have tc explain this. In the ccurso of every prr*. of ro- so^rch, medical resu rch, which dorls with buaen t.in s rnd which is then eentinuod ir. the fem cf .xp. rluv.nts cn cniu'ls, scut time tlio nest important prrt cf that research has tc be reached; th. t is, experiments crucis where the results p.chi .vcd in the c.urse of ntpericients cn aniav la have to bo transferred end applied tc the human b.in-; because ell experiments cn animals, in the ccurso cf research, can only have results hen th. results cf the experiment cn n :nimal are applied t. human tcin.-s. This part represents the m:st important phase cf the entiro research because all research h'd tc -c ardc cf uso to th. human fceinr; the possibilities cf diagnosis fer the '-'an t inr, metheds of trofim-nt rnd preventive measures a;inst diseases. In Breslau I had e number cf medical students. I hd wen th^a ov r to '-he point cf view that the virus which had been cultivated by Dchac-n after. - 2717 - 10 ?ebr-r- ry-U-SJ j-2-2-Kinabucfc C'Wt Kc. 1 as is likwwisc stated in th«. 1-tt^r, it had been frozen for a period of weeks end ser.tha, it was tried tc bo transferred tc e huaan boi nr and it was to be applied tc- the students nrri internees tc whex I had explained the x-.ttor previously. Sine.- the virus jx.t-.rial was frozen end Dohaen did net have any ether material, it bed to be assus-d th t thesu bacteria hrd already b.on killed cr that with rorerd t-. tho virulonta they had become sc weak .Ircady that this vacciruXi.cn boc rice e true vaccination; th t is to say, t preventive measure afeinst this heprtitis. It was the seme thim^fer txcaple, as tho sac 11 pcs vaccine. Since it wr.s not absolutely certain that the becteria sere completely ncn-virulent it therefor ct case of hepatitis. I then, in tho letter, discuss certain criteria which have to be applied if this virus is . ppliwd to hucan bein *s. then a certain dan -er odstod that in tho case cf Jaundice, on infection cculd le transferred free the viccir..«Ud persons tc their nci-hbors. I thoreforo had tc prepare* f.-cilitles for isclatinr thoi sc thrt the people who hrd b c*i tre'tai in this :/ ■or o ccaplctoly isolated free the cutsido world end these isolation facili¬ ties were net so aisplo to cbt-ir. in Ereslru at that tine- because \ were subject to severe air raid re uUticr.s rnd the clinic hr.d tc be cle:..-3d tc sene extent so th: t tho individual *jx 1 separate recas first of all had to be prepared. -2715- U« _ MSkLa '. J - MM J C 3irt II 10 ;eb U7-M - 2-la- N'inabuck - LJO This ax^rlr.ent was to be carried out during the holidays, during *h3 acadeclc vacaticr. which was between ’he middle of august and the niddle of Septerber. Since I had students and nodical students at try disposal I had asked in this letter if Haagen would and scoe cf his virus material to ne so that I could carry out this experiment on his naterial, on Dchnen's saterial, and on my material. The expari.aont was never carried out because the students concerned and the radical students concerned uer* conscripted f^r military service at the beginning of their vacation and thus were rec ved fro* -y field of authority. That is the explanation for the contents of this letter. a 3 .. NoL.£: Mr. President, bofero I continue ry exar.inaticn I would like to point cut that the interpreter has changed the stateront by tTofeasor Outxoit. Professor Outxeit has stated there and ho has translated tho statement tnot tho virus was transferred tostudentc and internees. I do not know if the word "internees" in this ccnnoction rey not perhaps be clsundorstood. Tho doctorar.den ar«- studonvO who 11 v 3 in ccoplit*. freedom. I requo t that the transcript bo corrected if possible. q. (Jy Dr. Molto) professor, you spoke about the Breda i sonfer- cr.ce-- THE PHESIDB.VT1 The Tribunal understands that radical students are called interns. If tho * tness roferrod to theso students who wore serving their period as i terns you car. ask the witness If ’bet is "hat ho intended to say. D?.. HEtTJi rrusidont, tha witness did not suy interns, but ho s.dd doctorandon. Tnoy are persons who war* once students and are 2 bcut to take thair radical oxanination and who have already c-unplotud their studies. 3. (3y Dr. .'Jelte) itr.es , you spoke about hepatitis *rch at the Erosion cenforunca and also the attempt at coorcinati: g the vari us a ancles whe occupied the selves with nopititis research. Did Dr. Dohmon ulso attend this conference? 271'?- C urt I 10 rob U7-M - 2-2 a - LJQ - Kinabuck k. Dr. Dchaen attended the conforerce and presented the results he had achieved In ani*il experiments; also Professor Haagen who also reported about his exjwricents on animals and the results ho achieved. - 27 ? 1C Feb %7-X-;iAA-^l-reard-(AK) J0U3T I Q. On tho basis of the Broil ou confcrarco. It Is lctoralnod then, until that time, experiments we.*o only oarrlod out on animals? A. Yoa, In tho courao of tho Breslau conferences on¬ ly experiments on animals wore discussed. Q. I now roquoat you to re .d pngo It~ls a latter of tho Rcioh Physician S3 Grawitc to tho Rolchsfuohror-SS, Hinder. It la Doounont Ko. 010 of the prosoout^on. Th :t letter states tho following: ■Tno work, namely, the research for the reason of Spldeclo Jaundlco hco been ao far oarrlod out by Oberatabaarrt Doctor Dohaon within tno Roscarch Laboratory of the Army Hodloal Inspectorate, and with tho cooperation of Robert Koch Institute, In conformty with results obtained by other Goroan Scientists, -hi a research haa led to the dlaoovory that Infectious Jaundlco \t tot caused by b.nctorln but by a viruo. In ordor to o *ur knowledge which to date la based only on lnnoculrr n anlaals with gorna taken fron huaan beings, tho r *•. la now neooeaary, namoly, tho lnnooulatlon of human telnet with viruo cultures. Casoff of death oust be anticipated." I now leave out tho noxt aontonoe.and I continue; ■Sight persons condemned to doath — young If possible, — are noodod In the prison hoopltal of Concentration Canp iachsonhausen." The no-.t lotter of the Rolohsfuehror S3, Doounont No. Oil, on pego 5 of Document 3ook No. Q, contains tho approval of the Rolohsfuehror SS; that olght criminals condemned to death at Auachwltr should bo used for these experiments. It further contains the approval of Rolohsfuehror SS that Doctor Dohmen should carry out these experiments at Saohsen- hausen. You will see that the letter is of June 194 T . That 2721 10 Feb 47-H-HAA-*-l-Board-(AX) COURT I la one year before the 3roslau conference. You have tes¬ tified that Dohxon has reported at Breslau about experim¬ ents on animals. Do you* know anything about'the fact that Doc tor Dohmen had worked at the Concentration Camp Sach- sonhauson? A. I have alroady stated in the course of my last examination that the Reich Physician S3 Doctor Grawltt shovod a very lively lntorest In obtaining tho oulturos from Dootor Dohmen in ordor to personally carry 2721a 10 ?Jb 1:7-.- C art U . 1 3-2-Do=rd at tS 3 »rfcxnt 8 with these cultures vn ..unan beings. D cVr D.Jcioo tel'! ss ab v.t this thine- Dihsen refused te l»=nd th_sc vaccines "v-r, and I sjr/trtcc hie in his refusal because Dduisn did nrt want f l:s- c r.tr. l :.r these,cultures and because it r._:.crr_ a scientific arc asiti,n fur Mr. and because he ha’ cultivate! t.-ae cultures. -‘Itor •> ,.u.n Lac! : .f see! te hand *ver tbs.se cultur-s Grrx.itx hicsclf ur.cd hi t ; .era anally carr; exit tie. wx.^-ri-ents which bed -rcvieusly ir.toado.*. t carr. cjit a self, and carry then -ut at Sachs-nb-asan. In order t. a. ease Or-dts, and in crier t ov i‘ . - It* - - -a laddc _r he had been ur. ed several tia.es, t.. x;.r!c at S-.cistnhausen , but n.t as Qr-Mlti: ranted t — infect heal ’cars there. he nly wanted ♦ rr:rk there in cr '.cr t r. uakc. thin s lc k ;r >:r t- tfa. tutsidc and ux rder t' .-./,c se Or-."it a in t.iis .-armer. T» _ivf-re, in the end he carried • ut ea* t”c r/.ainst what Orcr/it* brA nantod., Then uc olmys discus see! :ur res.-ctivc Hepatitis n-scarc’. fret tie. t tine. D ctor D.ivvjn always r- rte ‘ ab ut lAs w rk at Sachsoniuuison. Eo nadc ex.-xuin.ati ns 'here cn tu risners The had Veen plr.ee! at .As dis.xaal, In %U ecu . .us this in als carrival eut in field bs.itals am*, h spitals, in di- c ... X . c.-.;lo \ri “to suspected f bavin. Jaundice .and tn sc x.1w hav.. .ir .t alroady. Tlacn he ala, carried ut pr-v.ntitive infeeti ns tl e liv.r by .'sc cl vitadns, which is als n c . . n nodical practice, ut he ncx\.r inf.at-'. 1 .ir.an beings as far .as I !cn w. I want t r..;oat. *J star liheven, when ho rep.-rt-.! at Lrtsl.au, ’id net refer t U-.Sc experi unto a*.' did nit press theu? /'• <] ..s far s y u kn v at it this w.rk at S-ohsenhausun, d.i ’ you -v r iscuss this w,rk with .T-foss r Handlrscr? .. f , I never did that. •: y u leave state! that D.ct.r D.luxn in the y-ar 19LL "as cssi/ned t Str-ssbur by Sebrti’ _r. D. u ii.v anything; a! ut th. results -f 1 • £ „ umey rr the discussian with Kaa_.cn? .. ..s far as I b.v, D;ci- r D .riwn carried ut s x hexae -2722- 10 17-.-— .-3-3-3e :rd c ~-t 1 os^-riauits with vires at th_ la.-rat-r. t -otter with D c' r . ~ on. ;L .nl; spent a few >ys th-vc. I d. xt Icuw aqythinj 3b at anj f:r- r-'-clil-. results -f this c:llc'. rati.n. r ; -ftor ti» j uruy.as’ ’.e~n c .vlotcd, was th.ru anythin ^enticnod ah ut the fact that *.kj .au! been at Ur.tswoilcr? H , I eld net kr. it a-sythinr ab ut it. Q D-. ycu kn.w where .iatswoiler is? a L I did net lauw anything a'.-ut It . revi nisly. I -'id net even ta w tho ncuo. I have new disc-vcred that a,.. >rantly itVwi a c ocontra- tiiii coup. I, ..ysclf, have *icr-r c-n at tfatawcilfr. I da net knew it. I Save nuv.r visit-'! any ce.jccntrsti n coups at all, an! I dc net Sokw any- thia;, a' ut ti_j c . .sltisn I th. c ncentratl n cr -..-c ,t cnyttiiv, obtut •• r ;.i • visit a c ncuitrsti • n ca:. s. 0 ;.t the *x."innirr- uf / ur err. i-e-.ti.n, y u hr.v~ alsc jJvnti.ncd Ty d-.us a a a specifically an:’. particularl curl us disc ~o, r.J far os the .s ^ c nccmcl. Did ysn discuss t*- problcu of Tj-pLus research ur i; vs vaccine with .refess r II-Vl-ser at the end *f l?lil? • orally I discuss- *. tl>e a-.:.te~nt rf fy; iws with . r i .mo r :-->.lvscr by diacn-sis. - 272 >- 10 Feb. 47 -M-4-1-PKP- Blakley -sort to. 1 Q. Can this be explained by the feet that in 1941 for tho orcy and the ,radical -enoies of tho arny, fa- all tnese arencics, typhus was only a question of asdiesl treatment? A. In 1941 tho research institute for typhus had already been oetablishcd -• Ooehauj and there the woll-l^.:wn lice vaccino which had previously ooen i-tr vjeed was oanufteturod. That was the neigel vaccine. It had proved itself; :rd as far as it could be produced in larger anounts, the troops who had becoato erdang-rad wore vaccinated with it. Therefore, the typhus vrccination was nothing for the amy; and when typnus aade its appearance for the first tine, only n certain poriod of tine passed until technically sufficient Vaccine was produced in order to innoculato ell the troops in all the units. Did you at any tiae receive an ordtr to carry out research with regard to typhus? A. to. s. Did Prof. Hnndlosur ovor or.ke an expression towards you that it was necessary in the fiel. of typhus rosoarch to sw\k« use of oxpurlnonts on hucan leinra? A. to. Q. It h's boon st-toi here that on the 21st of Docwnbor, 1941, a coherence li allufod to have t-ken place which was attended by Prof. Gildoaoister, Prof. r.eiter, Dr. Cor.ti, Prof. llru^owsky, Dr. Brandt, and still others; and the prosecution claies that in the course of this conference Prof. Hmdloser in his capacity as represent tive of the l.ohraacht suggested then to carry out typhus V research through oqvriaonta on huaan boinga and to continue thee in this certain way *y infecting huaan lyings to brir. typhus research to ccmplotoly Afferent fields then ha I orovi ouoly been done in accordance with the Bodlccl profession and science. I on now asking you, if Pr^f. H'rviloser hr.d actually considered this problcc. it 1-,r, 1941, w-uld he have discussed it with you? 1 assur.o thrt I would have found out something about it. Actually, however, - did not hoar anythin*, about those things. .. H:w long werx you consulting internist with Prof. Handlosar? A. During the entire tiao when Prof. Handlosar was tho aroy aodicol inspector. -c7c.'^- LD Feb. 47 -tf-d-2-PKB- Binkley ',MTt Hz. 1 Q. Thet is, until the 1st of Septanbcr, 1944? A. Yta. Q. Then why die you not have any aoro official contact with hia afterwards? A. Because I was consultant to the army r.s.dici-1 inspector end Prof. fcndloser frea th-t period of tiae on — an« I do not knew the uoutet date — became chiof J *.r- - ray nodical service. Does this she* tfrt ttw chief of toe nod*ctl service In tf^t capacity did not have any consulting physicians? ^ A. Tho chief of tho ewdical servlet did n.t t, v t zny consulting physicians. Q. has he able to lsau*. tny direct orders to tno consulting physicians of tho Idhraccht brioches? -27 2*- •* Hn- l iC Fct 47-Jt-*-^.-7»^Slekley A. He vr.s cot rble to do that directly as far fit I know. I had net re¬ ceived cny direct order* froa bi= as chief of the cedlcal eervice. ^ Your contcct vlth rrofeor Handler aakes It risible fof you to Jud^e hln as a physician, aea soldier, and as e hunm bein. In this trlnl it will be laoertint for Professor H/ndlosor that a picture of his personality tm gained. For this reason I would ask you to describe to the Ki«h Tribune! froa your own personal knowledge how rrofessor Handloser rpoeart^ to you and to others as n soldier, as a physician, and as a hurj-.n being. A. In ny opinion, Judging Profess-r Handloser as a clinical nan, he wi s not only n sbldier. I cannot Judge the ounllficaticne of a soldlor becouso I have always v„rk«d In clvlllrn life and because I have not been an active sol¬ dier, but I have always belied to the reserve. I can only Judge hie ©artj- cular nedlcrl attitude. He did not only personally take care of the organl- istl.n but I hi ve oersocally seen and have always heard that In nony instances he took ptrsom.l cero of the sick and wounded. Hat Is somethin*: which was not always done by all cedlcal officers. As a nan I believe that Professor Yj ndloser had c very n-tlo nersonallty and that he hod a :'lawlt*s character, Kov, .-v final ouestlon. Frco ycur knowledge of tho oorsonallty of rrofossor Handloser ere you rtle to sny whether Professor Hnndloeor In his orders rnd directions had followed any other rules than the acknowledged rulos of jcdicel ethics? A. I have never personally scon any Indications of the fact that Profes¬ sor Hcndloser hi d violated the rulos -f nedlcrl eciccce or that he had Issued orders which would lead tc It. Q, I thank you vory ouch. Ut. SiLTn: I do not have rny further ouestlons. iXAkIKAlIWi 5Y JUStt bnPHISG: Witness, how nany tines during the course of your orofosei< nrl carter hi ve you actually ccce Into personal conti ct with r rofe»sor Handloser^ a. At the beginning ’-f the v f - I had been o-nscrlntcd for military ser¬ vice. I wes conscripted fr-n ny civilian activity. I w ■* icuediatoly asalKOt -272o- Court Si. 1 10 7eb ‘.7-M-4-2a-iZh-31akley r« consulting physician of the eray uedical inspectorate. That was without ,cy activity on ny part. Hy first ei>ief wee Generelober ‘nbsrnt Professor Valdnnnn. Veldnann became 111 end Whs retired. Ee vas succeeded by Professo: Handleser. 7raa that sonant on I was subordinated to Professor Erndloser es his consulting physician. During the tine vhen Professor Eandloser vas chief of the aray uedical insuecotaf I v*. also at ell tines his consulting Internist. ^ Q. That continued over hov long a coirsc of tine? A. I do not coonletely reuenbor the exact dates* I believe free December 1940 on. I think the*, is the date vhen Professor Handloser bocano *roy aedicol inspector. EH. KELTE: hay I perhaps sey that in Dccecbor he becane deputy of rro- fssscr Veldnann and in January 1941 becant uedical inspector. A. Until his final ooointaent tc the cedlcal sorvlco. As far as I know, thxt was on the let of Septouber, 1944. -27df- J 10 7ob i7-i>7JC-S-l-Cccic Court So. 1 JTT333 SZ3TT21 r 4 that «M r. porlod of aoro thnn throo yoers, is that true? Y«3 sir. n ,j* during that lira hr. Iftnn ad you actually erne in contact with p^onn.r MlMT. 1*» in a r»i«a pornnnnl «T or in . Jrofetoicnal «« ,, oro prcbioun, prefennlonal Slieal problem. »uld in dlncunnoi between y.u, r.z cfton «C osoo C. Kooic for oxrr.plo? Tti.ro * no rosular ucrtinc. It «a» doro in cuch n my that whon- 0 v-r -. mdlcnl noeonolt* eppoarel rithln the /ry, »««« BandJoeer called ... «* then in oeeorlance with w dutloe. «>* --tout M. thine, but it „ nr*. Tico-vorea, that «hen t, on ay trip, or othenrteJ, In «•» hcnpltale, „ Sy mean. of ro-ortn fro. other eoMultlns phyrlolann, if 1 had *° report B ,. ud *. , f importance to hlr. then I tan. to soo hin or I eubulttod a report in writing. There me no procedure .nlch edW for ro.uior •.actla.o onco n Mlt . araetlirw eev.ral woke Pneeed. Ihorof-To, the Moline and the am- CU231-M cr c Jafaroncon tci* r-lcco fr PH. nSLTl! Kay I ank a luortl.-n in -rlor to complete the «ubj«t? 3Y 33: :r2.T3: ^ rjo yM fensa «tet fucctloaa profoccw Hrnilooor h.%1? 71rnt of -U ho w.i oruy 'Jodlo-a Innpoctorr.to and at the e-nc time ha cceneetod «... thin the cc-callel Chid IMI. 1 Offieor of the May. a in order to expl-in anl clarify the provlouc guontion. ovory tie that Prufonncr HarrUonor rleitod Dorlln V It the procedure that ho «uld dleeute the mot important ,uon.ltnn «.h you by ankle, you tc report to bin r you rant to 200 hl:i *!wo you !mar tfcnt ho ve-vs in Borlin? i not orory tiro .hon TWfoerur Srndloner — In Be-tin was I called t coo Mr. 1 h-.ro alro^jr et-.tol that the lUeueeiono took place from can. , can... If ho h-.d ..«toiw. important he called =®. If I happened to hi in Berlin I went tc coo hit., "hen I M « :* Uhl. in Brcnlnu I «uW rocuiTo a tolepi-.no *01 toUin. in to e«. to no, hit. at Berlin, and *onovor I btl nenun. -f i J? .rtar.co to dlecucn «.h him. then .hoc Profonnor Kandloncr nan not at Berlin I «uld report thi. to the Chief of to. I 0 Itt the recent . oaon it on to Cooor-larr. Dr. Schxeiher. pd -hen he had nufficien. tine for - 272 &- in the cjurso 10 7e* 47-:i-sJC-5-2-Coo5c Oourt Jfc. 1 ;a I couli O o to so© fail- personally. a llny x j&r-so the quoatioa in conclusion rs follow: tt „ ^uninto*. «hioh y» hM -th hiu; 1 = th. course of th. throe yonM, _v, it sufficient tint o-n Jud.o Mb «h*Mt«. nnd hi. undorat.-niinc of 01 . iutios, -Id that ycu fhflnt aUrx Ji=ture of tb«« A X boliovo thot » for ««.. field. «ro =oornd in «Mch I d.nlt or rtlntoi -th bin, I =-n «. thro, ycnra, «hl.h 1. o Ions i»rld too, nod I enrol «. no» it re—bara JuBt too roar «.« I bln. hot in tto ocorro of th. tftro. yonr., of courso, I tod fr.,u.nt orcortunlty to hnT. root dlBcuMionn -th bin. DR. :r*L7S: I d" not tr.ro my further quoationa. .'.TWIT MOW: (Counaol for the Dofondmt UruK^;) :t dr. 7Ls:rt;: , Frofo.nir, on S Joomry you fiovo : on dfiin.lt. If. «■>*.»« hnv. .aroniy boon clarified for tbo : ot ,«rt by th. ouo.tlonB »hlot hovo been n.kd on until a». I only w-ot to .:t you th. folK-lny Do you knc« th. iofondont, Uruc^o^ 7 L 1 40 net to* :-rui.o«*y Tory cloa.ly. In th. corn. of th. »nr I h.vo -oon hiu nt th. ccaf.rooco of th. consult!* phy.lcl-.na nri I hovo .lno tniked with hlr. there but v.-o do not kneu o~ch other very oleaely. n in the c-urao of yir bo.octitla «r «•« th* ^ VhMfccarrty over *nslcooft? U Bo* • ^ Did y u to-r in nny »* thnt ho ocou,l.l M.-oolf — th hepatitic roaonrol I do r.'t ^ thnt. It noror boon a ta-im to o. n Dn you holloro thnt you o uli rtlU roro-bor if th. no.* hnd boon rantlaxwd In tiv.t cnnr.octirn? /. I boliovu, yo3. . w - I atlll -.-to ono :-ro gallon. Attorney Bolt. ho. J»* told you t th. Fronooutlon elnjlis thnt on tho 29th of Sootohor. 1941, n oonforonoo to.e Jlnou. nt nhleh, o«,a< othora. Hondl-oor nod UWC«A, * roaont; on! shore tho «r.ri.nta on hunon bol* -th typhus •» doclhod on. -2729- 10 ?o'< :7».5-FJO-S-3-Coofc C crt "To. 1 t „ M already been tuestloa* os => ' aur relationship to Dr. Kanilosor. Do ’ . t, Um that professor Haniloser would tats discussed the typhus »«on rttt yea. ui particularly tbo gotten If you aonsiderod It appropriate to cirr , ..at srporinants oa hu.-n taln.5, .ft..- suoh o dlscus.l=n bod taboo jlaco <* tfco 29 Doca-ibor 1941? % . , bailor. that I hero alrorfy WWW.* this Station that I would personally taller, ttat If =spsri:ents on hutan taints with typhus hod boon planned, that Professor Horflosor would have told no sc.ootMnt about It and •bet if ho said anythin. I taro alterfy stated I haoo not head -uiythlnc about it. x 35 . umci' Thank you. I have no further a uestlons. -27}0- 10 Feb 47-H-KAA-o-l-Groas- { AX) COURT I BY DR. FRITZ (defense counsel or the defendant Rose): Q. Proroasor, what did Dohnen do In hla civilian capacity, in what Institute, and whore else did he work before he vaa coneorlptod? A. He *->.8 assistant of the Hamburg Cllnlo for In¬ ternal Dlaoaso8. Q. Car. you tell me the reason that he was especially selected fer fcoi'ktltls resoaroh? ' A. At ace.- . artier period Dohoen apparently had been assistant t. 01\0 Bolster or worked with him I personally do not knot/ that exactly. Howover, I believe that was the oaso. I bol: .*ve that at the tine Dohaen was reoommendod by Gildonoitfter nu ooaeoody who was acquainted with hepatitis rJtear'fc »nd I have stated earlier that In tho courso of the ollnlc work with regard to hepatitis, tho necessity had resulted to appoint a physician who was acquainted with virus research In order to find the cause for the Jaundloo. Q. Professor, can you toll no when Dr. Dohmon was assigned to the Robert Koch Institute? A. Apparently that was In the year 1942. Q. And do you know how long ho was assigned there? A. Until the destruction of the Robert Koch Institute, until tho loss of the cultures which had been cultivated by Dohnen. I bollovo this was in tho fall of 194*. I do not know the exact month any more. Q. And with whoa did Dr. Dohnen collaborate In tho Robert Koch Institute? A. He worked In the laboratory of Professor Gllde- seister and -as udvlsod and s pported by Professor Gllde- 27*1 10 Fob 47-K-hAA-o-1-Gross- (AK) COD.-.T I aeleter In his work. q. Do you know If Dr. Doh-en had anything to do with professor Rose? A. I have never heard anything of It. I do not know. Q. Do you know after the destruction of the Robert Xoch Institute, do you know whore Dohmen continued his ' hepatitis research? A. .Ifter tin destruction of the Robert Koch Instit¬ ute Dr. DohT..*n went to Giessen by order of the Coranandor of Arny Croup 0 , to whon he was subordinated, and In Gleason he or hud in a laboratory which had boon 27*la 10 ycb L7- -» —-6-2-Grcss C art 1 Irc ct at his lisp sal thv.ro t t.x &. r .aar University. Can 7-u tell ne, A-ofaes-r, tfxn and rticr^ and wn Jr. D.Vccn i.st hie hepatitis cultures? tryin t find the cause lor hepatitis n ani-^ala Dr. fthnen in the course cf tlx ocpv.ri.-cnte irs var/ unfortunate. -IroaOj in the year 1512 he frequently had had difficulties by animal opAdluics am! Indues and in the year 19h3 ho suffer ' fro: Ik Ain.; attach rail then he alroys lest his -aicrial aid Ms cultures. then vhon ho finally rent t. Giessen it was main attested t transfer hu en Tutorial - n juiliials by . uncturinr livers .f patients sufferin' fr*a Jaundice and these cultures did not have -.ny effect mi the anir-als booausc apparently tlui Kv&ila'ulo animals were unsuited and there wer- also difficulties in •rjcurliy. tho anicals. Various races f -doc reacted diffcrontly tc those •/cccinatl n cxjcriucata. Those axe the a,.; a rent rca« ns; (fi.cn Oiesaen was c ylctwly destroyed tin- u^h air attacks ".yam all uatcrial which tl.en exist a =a dostreyad. D y u rc.xj.Vcr th_ incident botvixjn . rr.fwcn r 11 on .".ml Dr. .. ... -.r; let. urs caused by the fret that Dr. b huoa rofu ver ’us cultures? U ..t tlx c nfercnco in -~y l?li3 & lean sp.ko a* it hifl ojeperinonta i anlals cr.l Ms culUvatl ;n af tie bacteria and Hejen also attended t.ds c'-afcrcncc. «fUr tlx cufaroaco H ;en rrdcrod Oh ion t hand ever his cultures t hi- Be tliat no like o uld cany ut such cocyorlronts. At the tine D taxa felt t r ctly the sauo wry tooord Gravdtz. Ho refused tc turn -ver the cultures in rdcr tc avoid l^ttins the jatcrial int hands which c-ul‘. * - nai.ve’ frtu hie cntrcl. .. . RolBXs If the Tribunal Ur ^ thin sa... ,r end has coen c vcrcd , tiic itftocas when questi-a.-! J Dr. H-ltc aix! I can* fc se- any rcas.n ■ r flrrtl.cr questi ain- al n*. those lines. ..LSSCOT: Since tho Tri' considers that the . siti n cf iro- c-cuti n is correct that the .dtnosr has testified at c.nsidoraU- length b.-s, -atUrs, the Tribunal - 2732 - 20 Feb-WP-o-la-Gross Court I ices not cWsire to licit yoir cross •xtnlnatioo 'out it she Id oe cc.-fina-- 1 to uq cuterial w.ich it not already in tfce record. 3 ? DR. 7HITZ: q. rrofessor, cid joc*c- var co? liberate tdch the defendant .-cote on hepatitis? A. So. q. AO f.-r 3 3 ;ou know did ;roToss«r hoa take any active: «art in hopa- titis research? A. I did not hear anyth*. , aooufc it. q. Do you now that irofessor Rose did not p-.rticipato at the hepatitis conference it ^reslcu? A. I believe that be was not th-re. q. At that flr.-sliu co:.f*ronco ^11 the lc-iin { hspntitia research awn had boon i .rite c“ the chrocht r uvt rtu fro > the -^cbora of t.:o luftwaffu enn you ruDO.bev attendoi? A. I -alre' -v stated th-it Ho;,en a= there. »bon Koo atUb od. also "uc-'hiur. A-v. 1wr. wua the patholo^st losUr th r;. because it olao a patnolo iat'o vetir;. TlRfc .'era cartrxnl oc. . sorters of th; luitw ifo out 1 ..’o n o hr.* tV- xact n.s-a. If I would teosked for cortex v> us I inir.ht be ijI- to ivo >cu tort is.or -tiofl bout thw.a. q. That rrofotarr Kos.-, ns i sci -Uet me -eater of the Robert Koch Institute, had to ^ interested in th. result* of your hopatitie rose, rch, Just like for any othor progMM in t - lieldi of Infection* diaonao, is «f courre natural, «r, I want to a\ ,.u, rmitrsor, in oxccca of tliat would you consider .r?icsscr Ror- as a sect lift fur hap-title and would you aantion his n if ,ou ne-tiooe i 1 owl- '« hopatitis specialists? A. ;;o, I '*'ulu not consider ,i.f. hixtitis scientist. q. j hoards lecture t ceor ttoao -bcut » ti Lis? A. 'Jo. 1 . !iv. you -vur s-cn any scientific article in a. ic»l literature on *-ne subject b. ;r:fcisor Rose? - 273 > 10 ?eb-i?-JP-6-2a-Oross Court I A# ifo* 'l. J.-.v- • .rj heard hi . s -rtc ir. ?; it evasion durln_, .-.nj scien¬ tific ---.tuv u . thj subject o> hepctxtas? ,ii Ko, I enn't recall eus.a an occasi ... Do yau tau't anythin., ., ut haf.n c-pcri^-nts on hepatitis by professors -tee.n and Kolb? I do ..or. k ur* anythin-;. . it Lw exec -ion cf such cx-x.rim.nts. y.v hi:v» previously stie-d, xruf«ss..r ••heut the intended hui&nn . xp--ru-wn'.s • rich vur. planned at £>r .si u. hr.t wise do you' «cno : *ui. he- patitia jxp- -i »jnts on hua»n ocin„s? a. I fcr .01 only ci two export onto. C!no ms carried out in 19li2 oy .anist .nta of clinic. In thos- oxf-wrii^cnts it v as discov^n d lor the first tiw t-.'t vith ttw. duodon -1 licpld of the- patients and by placing it In Uw stOMieha . jeplu that t ; .ic (UtwUuO uld b. caused. Th-tuna th_ basic wx.e- at in crckr to shew ti «-.vtcis can K tr.anof-rrerf throu^ duodenal liquid cn. that it ia infect) ua »*»-n tr'r.sfwrrcd iron .u.w '.mien h-iin* to another. This uxp-riax.nt - carrier cut by aociatints nd ctu 4 - 10 Feb. h TD-7-l-T.arrow Court He. 1 THE JOaSH.'.Li The Tribunal is arain in session. THE FHESIUStfTi la there any further cross-examination of this vritnoss by dafttDM counsel? yr CR. noEHM (Counsel for defendant Poppenrtick) % Q I'n oire: to submit to the witness a publication reparding tho typh treatment with acridin by Dr. Din^. This is Document No. 582, Exhibit No. «fi< JUKSE SSTRllCt tfhat bock, ploaso ? D3. TOEH!: Exhibit No. 286. It was not in any locunent boot;. It was presented sinrly. X TTf DR. TOEHJIi q Professor, did you fevo sufficient tioo to investigate the acridin work by Dinr so that you con state your expert opinion boforo tho Tribunal today? A I read it, yes. Q Anon * others, you particularly doalt with questions of infootious isoaaoa? A Tea, that's right. Q Is it corroot to say that you wroto a book rewardin': infootious ‘iseasoa where in .articular you worked on experiences Bade during tho Inst war? A Yes. q As a consultir. physician in tho .,rvy Inspectorate you oust hnvo .ainod experience in the field of typhus research, in rticular, regarding the circumstances which 'eal with the ori inatin- of opideaios. A Yes, I dealt with that question. Q Tho document which was submitted to you boars tho stamp "No objoctl from a radical point of view-'. There is a 3i;-nature, i.a. Poppondick - by order of Poppen •ick, is that correct? A Yes. 1 ilell, is that thesis a typical report as it is made to a superior agency cr toes it have the fern of a publication in a professional periodic - 2735 - 10 Feb. !i7-H-.‘TD-7-2-^rc Court So. 1 A It has the fora of a publication In a professional periodical. q jfcw do you soe that? A I can aoa this by tho lotto* hood - by tho h»d of this «ork. Furthorooro, I can ooc It because of tho scientific di.ouoolon «hi=h ioals with use of other author. foGOriin* tho «a> Hold, flat 1. at tho end of this thesis. 0 . 5-0. it custocnry with tho ors? to approve .olontiHo work, in that fern? Tilth the omy it wo. oustomry to ootablioh tha modiool homloMne. of the work, q Now, „ on ..port in typhu. ro.ooroh, if one lock. through thl. wort •oo. on. hove to earn to tho ooncluolon that one 1. horo concerned with in- tontionol artificial infection of le»t bingo a. it i. de'eribod in thi. work? A on. doss rot hjvo to coco to that ooncluoion of noooo.lty. Tho onl; passage which nay porhap. in-iooto that 1. U.t >*>. 1 -horo tho trootnont thor. uood 1. laid b« in tho oooo of two poti.nt. -horo it «. .tortod on tho first and third day, of tho incubation period. That i. only po.olblo w». one i. concerned with n *aoll opidonlc which 1. oorofully observed ond -hero on . enn oxordso tho .tally control Hardin* tho lino with reference to »U th, offoctod person. out wh.ro o louoo «aa still found in tho por.on of son. hunen bin, -he appear, to bo health!'. If thoropi- i. .tartod on that doy. th. you can M out on tho first or oooond incubation doy and you can .tort treated. For inotonoo, in tho oooo of transport whom ddouolnr ho. taken pUce - that i., oomfuly dolousln. - ond whore tho.e ; -plo orrlvod at thel. •ootinotlon with llco, you con, du-lr, a tyrhu. K-riod, assure thot tho in- footlon took place on tho day th. 1^' too* pUoe. Thot io to .oy, in tho case of woll-observod eplddea it 1. poo.ibl. that treat™at .tort, on th. first or ..coni incubotion doy hat thorn are only only very fc ouch ocoo.lc o Thar* you* that is suffiden* . According to your knowledge io Poppondlck on export in th. Hold of typhus research? - 2736 - 10 Feb. U7-M-AT!)-7-3-Sarrow Court Ho. 1 A PcppeBttck is a physician dea-in? with internal diseases - internal aedicim. I don’t know that bo specially dealt with typhus cases. Q How, if you just exmrtne this thesis as a non-expert ani if you roa it through could you cone to a conclusion or suspicion that crininal export- aents are beir« desdribel in that thesis? A I don’t think that is possiblo. Q Thar* you, I have no furthor question. ^ A Because in that thesis you can, at no passage, find that there is any artificial ejddonic in question. It says here "typhus ^search wit* acri-'ln" and then it further says "within U» franowork of an opidonic". DR. ~0E»': Thar* you, I have no further question. -2737- 10 Fob £7-::-S r -8~i-Ic060r Court K . 1 2 Y jp. # STS2;3AU2R (Counsel for the Defendant T7ZIEE. I 3EIGLE10CL): Mtnese, last weolr you shortly nontionod liver pur.ctions. In - publication of tie First diversity in Vionnu, I road tho follow¬ in' sor.tonco: "Ifco Liver junctions, when local nnoathotic is used, i5 pair;loss end hardly interferes with tho patient's health." I tek you, do you Sfcr.ro that opinion? A. Yes, that is also uy opinion. ^ n. y0 you know that ocpecially r. t tie Clinic Sppingor in Vionna this no the d rca workod upen a groat deal? x A. In tho Cimic of ~ppln~or, as tl oy boccro known, livor pur.st- iens woro often usod. Do you knew free literature or personally, the "ofondcmt Dr. 3oi3lbock? A. i laiow i in personally, mu bocc.uso of cttondlnp scientific uoo Inca. n, ,ould you so;* ti r.t lo aciontificclly oxorcisod this nothod and tk: t ho is fully acquainted with it? I think cl at ovorybody can lonm that nothod who is skillful annually. o. i 8 ia correct tl tho Dritld sciontiats, Svonson and Hoholn, porXemod t. Is livor punetica an oven quito fcoc.lthy 1 unnn-boings? A. 1 do not ro tonber t: t oxactly. I boliovo, howo vor, that pictures of quite ncmr.l li*‘ rs rro contr.irod in tie nono^raphy wl i has appoarod on tL.t subject. Jut I dc net rouonbor it quito woll. I do not ro..o;ibci whcth-r liv^r .junctions vr.ro purfonaod cn porfoct- ly healthy hunan-'Joints. Hank you. I ha;o no furtl or questions. tv? ?.Z23IDE''T: Is there cny further cross o cnination of this wit r.css by any of tho defense counsel? There boing nono, t’ o Prosocotl ray cross or.:i:inc. close h a::mTioK - 2738 - 10 Feb 47-!'-S' -8-2-Lcrscr Court 1 3X :3. E/.HDY: itnoss, you fc.-.vo stated In direct oxauinatlcn that you wore consulting pfcyslolan rltt tho Hodienl Inspect or,-to of tho -'.my end that Kandloser told tkt poslton ns Hodlecl Inspector fron .Tnn- urr y 19/.1 to Soptonbor 19-14. few Wo Tribunal has cskud you how neny tinea did you consult with Irnilos-r. I ask you again, how nany tines did you physic.-.lly contact Eandlo.cr In the course_of your duties .-.s a consult Inc physician to hint u I tr.vo .-J.ror.ly sold that I ernnot sry that I .spoke to h.ln onco . , u0k ; soaotlr.vS It occur rod cn-o In 3 nooks, ot! .r th-os onco In /. weeks, end sonotiros I S.-.W hln one week after the other. H r.t Is, 6 ph sic:.l contact, .-3 you said. Toll, tie, witness, null you say that you saw Eandlosor 10 tl tes r. j-o-.r? A, Yoa, I could quit* a:.y tfcr.t. hro or loss? ita-ss, I or. shyly asking you hew nany tlnos jo you ostl te tl. t you saw Eandloscr in tlo course of a yoar - 5 , 10 , 15, or 20 tlnos? flat lsi't tee difficult to re -.c. bur.islt? ... I should say tl. t I net hln 10 th-.es a year, but It nay well h aTO been 15 or 1-1 or 15 th os; I rn sure th.t It differed In tho indlviduc.l yjf.ra. e. thank you. Tcu w.ro «Iso a touched to tho •l.llte.n- lodloal Acad on y ;.s I ur..orst;.n i it? A. Y.s. n. You have stated th t ’oner, lent Dr. Sohrolbor wr.s the com- ndlng e-fleer of tl o K lltary Ucal -etatoay end t! at you w.ro subordinate to hln in th t oonn.otlor.. Is th t correct? ... V. H e Wat not tie err. ander of tho rilitary ’lodlOnl Aoadony but the CO. render of the so-called Trainin'- Oroup C of tho unitary litiicfj. rtlch is i. P- - rt of it. a. .vt fcj Hit ry noilcpj. -c:. y tr s under the control of tho ::-lic;.l Inpscctrr of the -.rr.;*,M. ? it net? 2739 - 10 fob 17-’!-S -6-3—Lesser Ceurt He. 1 A. Dx T-ainlng Group C was auborlin ted to the ITilitcry 'ludlor.l ixndcuy ini its ccrrxadcr; and tho -ilitc.ry I.odlc^l /.cadony end with it this fiv.ining Group C, was subordinated to tho Zroy hodic- ul Inspectorate. "he 1 v.r.d cf tho ~my liodical Inspector, to was tho‘ V-1' -lo<*icr.l Inspector. • o. Honco, ^r. Sclrolbor, r.e chici of tlis dopertr.ont in the 'Ill- | ltery “cdical ..cadony, wr.a, ir. fact, r. sub-vrdinato of tfco bodice! Inspoctcr, *»crdlnaoy, during tho tl. o 1 *andloaor hold thnt^pooition cs Hectical Inrpoctcr, is fclut corroct? A. Yea. In tho find .analysis, ell nodlc: 1 officers wero subor¬ dinates of tho h.ighost nodical officor; thr.t, rf ®urso, also in¬ cludes Oonoralcrrt Schreibor; r.s the ccnnandor rf tho ae-callod V-inlrG >roup C he it. r tho aubordinr.to of tho Arr.y lo('.icel In¬ spector. 1 . cw, witness, in rdditicn to the duties you ht.vo outlined in tU direct oxauln tion, .11 you ov.r rocoivo quostlona in scientif¬ ic roaoa rch f roil tto .»oich Hoauarch Council? A. ’.culd you plcr.se rup^. t t! t qu.ction :xro precisely? I did not quite undorstend. ". Did you over rocoivo roqu.ats or questions frm tho Hoich ly rritira. Iheso quest¬ ions concerned nunorous fields. >cr instance, I ro enbor ono qu r tier about r pr poeoJ trcr.tnont rf typhus. It w.-.c intenflod to •reat it with certain bathing prrcoaaoo -- warn b. thing precoasoa. 3wro were also rtLr questions I had tc deal with — questions incoming cortain tr.: trie.nt cf diavasoa, whether c. cort..ln r^thod ‘ tx^ntoont proprsod by aero '-no had .any value according to r.y tptaxon so that it could generally bo exploited :n\ used. Ho aol- •c'icn cf cert in drugs w..s doalt with by r.e by request .of tho -2740- 10 Fo'j •’,7-1l- S r -8-4-Lo a so r Court Kc. 1 Hoick hc.aot.rcfc Ccuucil. '1. llcw tkoau v ri ua roaoarcl: t ska tL..t Kr- assigned to yru— w-ro tl.cy assigned to yru by Profits r jr. ..cstrck of tie Roicfc Hos-r.rck Ceuncil? L. •K.au rch assignuunts v ro act rocoivod by no fron tl o iioicfc Rv.aoi.rcl Council. Tioao w..ro t.roly inquiries ..bcvt propcac-ls wl.iofc ccy h o ccuu frnly q part of tho Jaundice illnesses aro in compliance with the sc-cellcd infectious diseases. Q Ycu have st ted, doctor, that the llsoaso lasted from four to eight weeks. Now, is solvers-n used for tho trc'taoot of Jaundice? A Srlvtrstn was not used for infectious Jaundico but thoro is a kind of Jaundico which is r. symptom cf tho sc-called syphillis and furthermore thoro is c Jaundico which originates as r. result cf thv salvr.rsan treatment cf syphillis. ;dl cf those aro various Jaundico disposes. Salvr.rsan it- solf, when toalln* with infectious J'undico is net used unless, cf ccurso, syphillis exists simultaneously. Then syphilUs, although Jaundice is thoro, has to bo treated with salv, rsan. Q Ycu said this acming cr. direct examination th t cno could trout hepatitis, if I understood you correctly, on the saae Jay of tho incubation period. How is th't possible? «n incub. ticn por.vd is known es the poried preceding the actual manifest.ticn cf tho disease. « I didn't sperk about Jaundico in that connection but I speko about typhus. I was askod efc.ut tho foetus which dealt with tho treatment of typhus with acritlvno. I was rskod thrt question ty tho defense counsel cf Fcppendick and in ccnr.oction with thrt work in the- cesa cf two types of illnesses, the treatment w'.s strrtcd on the first and third day of incubation. This, however, is impossible in the case cf jaundice because one nvver knows -275°- i 10 Fabru: ry-MJG-ll-2-Burns Court Ho. 1 whi tho patient concerned was inlected. In the case of typhus it is scao- tices possible since we knew thrt typhus is usually cnly transferred by lice. How, if I, for instance, deloused the husm being today I know th. t he h-s no acre lice end if on the next -ay I found a louse on his body I can ’.sauce that this very day As tho very first incubation day. l.heroby, of course, it raar.ins unclear whether this louse really trensferred typhus rikettsir. t»v t is soexthin- that cne doesn’t know but this holds not true ♦ in the case of jaundice. Q Dcctcr, you have ccnvcyod the thewht to no th-'t liver puncture X is not considered to be dangerous. If so, why is it necessary to obtain an operative perait in writing free tho jr ti COURT I Schrolbor. He had to go to Haagon thoro and a comparison bet¬ ween the viruses as wore bx*ed by Dohman was to bo oarrled out with the ones that were bread by Haagen. Q. How do you explain tho fact, doctor, that Sohrelbor sufficiontly arranged the collaboration of Haagon and Doh- nan when in Exhibit 19*, presented to you this morning by Dr. Nolto, tho socond sentonco states; "I" - moaning your- solf - "havo roquosted General Sohrelbor to assign Mr. X Dohman to mo as of 15 July for a limited period of time to begin with." './ho arranged this aaslgnmont of Dohman to work with Hiagon? A. Haagon and Sohrelbor arranged the collaboration of Dohaan and Haagen and I belonged to that group too and in addition to the formation of this collaboration of work Dohman had to, of nocesslty, got into oontaot with Haagon. Suoh a mooting had to bo arranged by Schrolbor and ho had to detail Dohman for that porposo. I spoke to Sohrelbor after the Congress. I told him that those two pooplo would havo to got together. Thon Haagon invited Dohman in a lottor to oomo to Strasbourg. I had arranged with Schrolbor that this channol was to bo in aocordanoo with what had alroady been established during the Sroslau mooting; naaoly, that Dohman wont to Haagon. THE PRESIDENT; Tho Tribunal will now bo in rooess until 1 : 30 . (A reooss was takon until 10 hours.) 275* if+7 v; r«b-A-jp-ia-i-rddt (bj; CeTt *.o. 1 ccR?ugTiD c:ri A-arcc. sissia: (The hiring res'-r.venod -t 1330 Lours, 10 Pe’aronrr 1917) TC;2 ,.\RSH\I1: The •'arsons in V” court rooc ill please find ti oir seats. The Tribunal is ncftin in session. OR. 53HL (Courts >1 for Defendant Obertutuser): -ay it plor.se the Tribunal, the defendant Cbert.-.uscr asks to be omitted to leave ti e courtroom o* three o'clock in vie" of her physical condition. TVS RSS133KT: The roquest of the Defendant Ctcjt.ausor, oxtondod through h«r counsel, uill bo granted. Tho defendant awy be excused fron »tter.d-ncc in the court roo* r.t throe o'clock. 1 *!C?. 3UT2 TT - Hosuaod CSGSS vOiCTStTiaf (Continued) rr; r. :ar3Ys ,. itness, I cii still uncort-tn about four answer to sy cuostion co.t- cuminy. th.o ncub'tlon ?riod. I repeat that the incubation i*riod is !:no-.m as the oriod procodlftj the actual stnifoot tion of th.o disois... ? *ou, ;ou h-.v.j told nw that not in connection » ith her at tir, ut in connection vlth ty h.us, that yee oar. ot -raino on tho second day f tho incubation period - hat twt-aont woulf' bo nocosanry. I want to -ok /m to answer very briefly, '.on could you toll tint a -arson has t! j 'iso-so unless infoctod then yourself durinj this incubation oriod? A. In th.o caso of typhus tho infection is transmit tod by toons cf Infected louse. If, ti oivforo, in t c c-.so of a -ationt ./ho r.-.s previously frjj .'roc: lice, --.v* if 1 find a lots? in a tyrius r c^A~, then I c-.n safe¬ ly -ssuffio that this ious., cn the day on which I h-vo tiscovarod it, that is. 10 Fcb-.v-v^-12-2-:-clrt Court I It isr ah-r duficult to txa* a crocturt of that six- on r. person, isn't it? A. Our wIdlers and also er_ mirsin, jv-rwnsvel hiv- r&nak-d tc do that hundreds of thousands of ti*»s durian the war. Th-n, jcijr, if Ur you fin-* the leuso, then you havu to ntsu^c that th. louS' is carryic. the disease, don't y u? A A, I any th-t in a juried fla.ru cas-s of t;.hus occur, that it, iu.in 1 United 0|_f.«- I hswo discover-<. tho louso, m lice nt ell w-re pros-nt. 3. You -Iso have to nasuiu th the i e person 'luring thio incubation period? Yeu t.uui<' ft t kn.w whether tnot |X.rson had contracted that eis-'s- at that -arly St: e, w ulc you? A. Th •- ic ccrr-et. It is cciTeCt f. '.t I cannot knew th-t a 1 th certainty . sutpiclon ta t t. louse has hicctcd the- patient, tint vhen I have such s suspicion, th-n it 1 h: v- n. lt » if 1 believe that th- budlcinu c-n bo - IiWJ -f*:-ct:ve “ ainst typhus durin,, the incu- * bition period, then I can apply this r- icir. iro^ tl- first 3 10 Pab-A-JP-22-3-AOdt Court I q. Now tli- question of hepatitis. As I unJorstoad it, toon it oul' bo ispossiblc for cn; to idadniator tror.txont f-.r hopititia nn the soccnd day of *n incut-tlcn period; is tort correct? •v. In the c-.s- of hepatitis? 3 . Yes. a* In th- e ls- of hujwtitis I cannot -’oUrino. ^ Now, b.' ru toe afternoon rjc.^s, vitn.ss, wo voro Jiscrssin. the collaboration cf Dofuon and Higen in whicu ;cu p rticipatod, rakin' jour lugpaation to Gen. Schruitur, end sc forth. Did jea rvport tc tho dofomVmt Hv.dloswr on this collaboration betwwvn Polcc-n -.ix’ baton? y 10 Fdrcai7-A-OJC-13-I-Fitx --raid (3J) Court Ko. 1 A. I have not cute any suggestion at all. I have not aado any sup .cst- ion. X law* not su&vostod that Dohcoo and Kssgon shouV vork together, ftie collaboration botuoon Dohaon and Kaogen v s discussed at tho Ganoral Parotitis lonforcaca vhich I .*-vc already jsontionod. it -as suggested Vy tho rrosidont of this Conf-mnco whilo formula tin* voicing aotheds. I do not viefc to quibblo with you about vi.othar or net you suggested the collaboration >f Do'cscn and Baagon. - havo roviously s oferr ^ -o the second sentence of your letter to Baagen "hare y©« *tatad you requested a : to or ‘1 to assign Dohaon to you as of 15 July for n limit & orlod of tlxu. to bogin *ith. How I ask you, did you evor ro-ort to Handlesor in rop-rd to the colla¬ boration of Dohaon and :>.agon? Anr.jr yes or no. A. I did not have to report about this col 3 -' oration at all hoe-use during the Conf-runc., tills collaboration had already b_.n dptomlMd. jror-s"or laadlosor was also pr.sor.t. .. Thank yeu. or- you in attendance at the so various ttilit-rv Hcdical kuotings for Consulting .hysicians" fact, 700 ; X>ko at ono such -looting, did you not? la it true that reports voro fl'do at thus- Bootings on results of jxojri-xnts in vrious fi-lds of aodic-1 research? A. In tha course of the coaf-rone-- of c at 15 physicians, 1-cturcs were liven about too experiences and also about tho ux-jsir.atio.is which had 'ccuaulatod. In this connection, I h vo also reported at see: of to 18O •—otin-s about vl at ‘ad been discovered *’ith rogard to "jpatitls up until that tin- ty varicus vork. Th-n it is true that the cxpcxiaertal cone’ tions wore jxolAir.cd by tho ro. ortirv; physicians, is it n-*' A. Durinp the conferences, -s far as 1 knew, the cX'X.rbaenta rorc only 'iiacossod insofar as the cultivation of b-etcrl* ir t* ; cocnorimonts on Sniaals ware described in tho fori cf a lecture and address. Q. itrvoss, r* arias the war, did -ou «-v.r ’.car anythin concerning -x.. riii.nt r or. concentration c-xp inn-.tos, that ic, free your com knowledge, fren reports or ixetings, or conversations with ot! r ooopl-, -T • re:-. rejrora -2757- • 1 C Fobru r 7 -»-DJG- 13 - 2 -Fitz?«rald Court So. 1 cr eny ether scurco wh tscever? „ 1 cannot reaach er th:t I have hoi rd anythin:* ccncrcte about tho execution ana also about tha results cf such exporisents. Q Since 70 U are fauilirr with Jaundice research in Germany, you pro¬ bably knew of th« work cf Professor Dcctcr Drcsel, Director of the Hygiene Institute cf th« University cf Leipzig, do you net? Hay I ask tc hear the nrne once acre? Q Dr. Dresel, D-r-c~s-o-l. „ I have seen this nac in litercture. «s for cs I can recall, experi¬ ments on rninals ner« involved in this case. 1 believe that canaries voro used r.a aninrla. q Did ho net cultiv; t* 1 Jaundice virus frua persons sufferin'- from Hepatitis, and succeod -ir. transplanting it to adonis? * Sc f“r ns Z know, and cs it was always done in ether Jrundicc uxpori- nents, ho tock tho infectious sntulrl freu infected persons, tnd injected it into nniaals. He then continued tc trrnsait this disease fren one cnimel tc another. Q Doctor, do you net knew tliat ho cariled out experiments on concen¬ tration caap inortes? I have never heard that. Q In connection with Denaen's eerie cn Hepetitis at Srxhsenhcusen you h-ve told this Tribunal th-t these were acre or less uxperinunts of cppocso- =.,nt. ;.hy should Dchaen core two phennirs ebeut the feelings cf Grawitz in this connection? A Gr*wits wnnted the cultur-s which Dchacsi hed cultivated in the :niiual experinents. Ho wanted tc obtain thua froa Dchcon. Ho wanted Dohacn to -iva theffl to bin. ,.s fer as I knew, he personally wanted tc have hepatitis experiments carried,cut. Dchaor. h*d refusal tc leave these cultures with Grawitz. Grawitz was unalle to obtain these cultures. Dolmen did not want to let these cultures cut cf his hrnis because he did not uant tc lose centre ever then. He ordered Dobson tc dc these thlr.-s hiasolf. 1 have already described ihrt this aomina. 27 5 * 10 ? ctru ry-*-DJG-l>-3“Fitz‘%reld Court Ho. 1 Q y 0 u stcto th: t Dohaen did net went to turn his cultures over tc cthor people so he would not lose centre! of thee. Miy would Dchcon waste his time swain* ei.^ht Fellah Jews condemned tc death in Sachsenhrusen to sac if they, perchance, had Jaundice? I did not completely understand the Inst p* rt of your question. Q 1 say, why would Dohaen «sto his tine exaaining ui^iit polish Jews ccndasnvd tc doeth in Scchscnhnusen to see if they, perchance, had Jaundice? V>es this act to appease Dr. Grcwitz? x k Tcs. Things were such that Dohaen cs»ried cut tho work in ordor to avoid h?vinc to turn his vaccines over tc Grawitz. 1 have already said that D.haon had sabctr.red Griwltz' erdor tc carry cut such epeporinonts. Th: t is the reason he worked at Sachscnhaua ji. Q ..t Sr.chsonhauscn in conn action with Dohaen* s work, you cannot swsar tbrt Dohaen did not infect these inartoe, cen you? .. Dohaui has always tol l an reportedly about this wcric. He told aw ho was only deceiving Grtwitz in carrying out his work there. Q Do you net think, Doctor, th:t Donaon alcht bo a little reluctant U publicize his activities in Scchacnhausen? Otherwise, hv used to toll tc all about th- results of his work. „fter all, the cdlctor tion consisted cf the f. ct that ho hcndlod the bact- ericlcrical part of the Hepatitis Kcseurch, and 1 handled the clinical pr.rt. Whenever I discovered scocthir.'- iapcrt.nt, or r-n-rknble, within this field cf »-«- tbn.. 'JP3 FRSGIDS’fP: ILnvu thoao dcea oats :oor. furnished to tho Socrot-xy Oor.ornl*.-) .leak? DR. S3R7A7LUS: I bolloro thnt Dccu^ont Pock Ho. I hr.a saw boon proaontol to t;..j rribinnl. /.a first dccir.ant, K5-x, co>;tniii3 nn excerpt free tlv. Life, which hna nlro-ly boon iiocussod nnd I wnat tc sub-iit this A - -'3 si’.iblt 1. I So czt a*?at to xonl it nay r.ero boocuso It hna ^rcni;- boon rod la tho c :urso nf tlx socsloas. :3!. ::c H/JBT: If tho Tribunal ylenao, I woulh like to hnvo r. attaroat ■iV<» ! It 7eb /.7-A-7JC-15-2-3e/iord (BJ) Court lo. 3. fro defense counsol as to the Air-ose of the offer of the Karl Brandt Document ll o. 1, which is an extract fra: Life Har.-.zinp concerning certain ^ lari a experiments c-irriod out in the Uni t ed States. I think, under cor- tain circv^s tar.ee?, I might tjf/o no ob Joe tier. to its admissibility, but 3 thLJc we will Kayo icue very strong objections de~onding upon the purpose for which the document is offered. DR. S-KVATIUS: .'ny it please tho Tribunal, this docucor.t has Soun hand¬ ed to tho witness in the examination. It his boon offered as evidence and I think that It las already boon admitted. It is of further ia'.ortanco for the question which has to bo decided hero of tho admissibility of oxpori- aente on human beings and in oxcoes of this in order to Jud.c tho question — tho humanitarian qu.stion—all together. Tho prosecution charts tho • ■ dof ndants with crimes against humanity. In order to clarify this oonccpt,, «o will havo to soe W.nt 1 c bolrg con-idored as h"x.anw In order to bo able to sake con arisen#. I e\nt to suboi.t on additional number of documents fron litorat iro which Ukowlae deals with jx; i riwits and which for tho can. reasons will bo of tho utmost importance. T, theroforo, roquaot that Document lie. 1 bo admitted as S±ibit No. 1. 7. •: PPES.tDST; If ay recollection is correct, l is exhibit was narkod for identified cn: Karl Brandt, ^chibit 3 fa- identification, but has not bc:n -vinitt xl lr. ovidorco. VLR. :C ilAIICf: If tho Tribunal pluaso, re offered no objection whon this docuaont was put to Irorossor Loibbrand becauso the witness me called upon tc ;ivo his opinion as to tho othical value of th. ciroori-ajnts hare carriod out, and ho testified that he had some objection to ti e xpcrirxmta rclatod her. in Life i'acazinu. Tor tho purpose of eliciting an ex-rossion of opin¬ ion from tho »itr.oss, ro had no objection to that procedure. "c havo very rtrenous objection*, tc the ether puiposo, ns stated V - defense c-unsel for Karl Irandt. Chic document obviously can have no probative valuo in f roving that any of the experiments -2765- 10 . Ob i.7-15-3-^aj’lord (BJ) :oirt .io. 1 charged in this iniictamt are lawful or non-crininal experiments. If the Tribunal -omits docu_wnts of this kind to do into evidence, it will very prooablj sean that the prosecution will be forced to assure the burden of Justifying cvory cx-iorlront vhifch has ever been carried out or at least all of then that the defonso counsel can find informtion on, wore carried on in a lav/ful aannor, that is to say, upon volunteers. Id’ - u7--. C art . 1 lS..-1-Galla h*r I thiol; ttar- is n- issaa in this case ccnccrninf: h- ..act that an jc. -riuant ccrriod -ut in n r.-7olrr.t3cr= js r. t f the nature cf vi-lr-ful r criminal c^icrixats. Tik defendant s. tastifta • en tit stand. 1 iu:.’sratai»c'. lie ataitto' it* It *.cs noeessary tact the ar.crincntal subjects • g vluntaars. The -rcsccuti-ui Li tils ease lias undertaken ta .r;vo that the cc^tri. uital su* jeets used in * - c.Tcrixats at issue core r.. t v Inn- A tears, tlicref re, adds nrtiiin. t tdu. .r; f, r the. clarlficaticn -f aitf iasuad in this ocs*. frr tlw 'efense c.uaacl to Irin; in roat h:ots -f docuuents in writing c nccroin; ^3Q>eri-c:;ts carried -ut in t..~r c*untrics. There is tin. v.ry str »;cet ofcjecti.as ta have adnlttc! that t pc »f atarinl into evidence in on> event, i lliink in substantially nil casco t.-sc uritin-s trill net tvv ,al the circumstances t>urr un-Vi i t: - ex. crl- ixats, end, I au quite sure they -rill atta . t U dr.r.r infcruioos fn. these oriti.T.8 tliat dec ton in the United States, cr clsouhorc, .wave cl no the sc c thine as d n- in this cast, newly, carried at r, jri..oi ts on ,.c ,.lc idle wore not vc luntoc.ro under circumstances jus til led to the -clicT n tho . art f the c^oriacntors, tdiich aid .t bad 1 * result in .loath. Tl.-t a ul ! sioan the *r c.c» t‘ n lor the circunstcnccs on its n initiative c.uld investigate orch nc ~t these instances, an l rin.. ir. .ire f ire think rt can brir,; in tVat tic oc>ri:xnU wr, unotiiical rr zttj -nc point f view. JULGL SS-'JKa. Ir. Servatiuo, .lid r. t y ur witness, Karl ran-lt, alee tilt statc.xnt that in his c.Ani n ~y . n- wh is tnlor ..caical restraint, such -3 a ..rlsirwr w ui -c in t ienitentiar/, c nix. n-.t o -all;, ivc v luntary consent t f a. subjection of nodical er.purii-.cnta n hi:., even though he cave li. service, even tli ttgl. hw ha *.::tari rly str.t that he * aid vduntcer f r such oqxri uits. I thin: th. doct.r- .itaese aril ta t even then acccr’in: t his 3^:ise r.f je’ioal ct.ac3 * -at c aid net Vo said t bo a voluntarily hman service. ’ td.u, r cue din up-a the .reniso that y. a hav- ostrv'licV. by :• r TTita-ss, u all it n.t rta s-.e-th.in; as a -.attar ;f ;jt.I ativo value t.'t Dr. Servatius wh star tad with t. .sc .xcciisoc tuat ta so .-epic 27»7 10 >V _-l5..-2-Galla'yxr C'-urt 1 a : oatt-r how juch they consents c ul asfc la fact .Tilli.-._ly consent, -nd, then tc s.. w j.Jcr these circ stances cx,>crlr«at3 rare c aducted .. . su Jeeto? I UttSara fe t «s the .ur^ese f r c/ Dr. Sarvatius ha introduced thJs -jticlc ir_ ■Idfo". Of c urso, i-s tlx li-.t analysis It rr.ll c u,> t. this Tri'.uroi t. say what .r Native value 6ho> trill l-Ivc the natter, -f c ursc, the crtiole as it a ..or. v; n a its face, end in accc.it in'. tfw . raise laid down Ly year ’.fitness Karl rrr-v’t, ir.ui: t.nt ,rvo -aly that in other parts .f tlx v rid cx.cri- .«nts rare c nductjd u;.n ha can su’.Jccts. SBRJ3Y: If tie. T r i>-ncl .'Icrsc, th- * x* sceuti .1 ij rf/ared tc adit that. I Just ’ n't s~c that the .atter is at Issue raid .r ves anythin;. -Yen if it Vo aasoMd that c: ;.criox;jts wore ocrrlod cut in sccio ether ccur.tr>' of ti.c world, and La ccrtaji or. cs u. n a •i.-vrluntccra, 1 0 a't think it Justifies any of t.~ nllcjJd crimes in this ease. T;.ty can c rit cri-ics In tlx Unit*' Stat—, -r elsewhere, Ju:t ro t-'.-y can in Gor.any, and ;r. f -f any >vc.- 1 atac-ca that such a erL-j l.ao . oon c^. it ted in tlx doit. St".t>. s I thin!: d as nt boh vc tlx *oic.inc any¬ thin.. in this ease. 3 Fob 17-A-S -16-l-r.ym.a :ur6 Ko. 1 J : JL-OE FE3RIH0: I h--' understood tl t . a tho purposo cf this offer. : irn't suppose that tfcoao dofandmta r.ro will in- to a dnit to tho er.ao of tho Prceocuticn ;t this ti :o, in'. I hr..; auppoaotl that tho purpose of this prcffor was to shew th t thoso dofondcnta tr 3 con- pert d with whrt ihoy hr.I ccnaidcrod to bo accoptod standards in tho fiold cf codici l oxpori. ents. Isn't htr.t tho purpt so2 A DR. SERV/.TIUS: Yos. :3. ::c HANEY; I don't want to naJco an oxtondou ar~ur.ont, but r.s I aoo it, thoro ia no diaputo oitthor on tho bi.ais <-f tl ia article :r cn ti o pr.rt cf tlo Lofcnso with tho Pmsocution thc-t it ia r.occasary th: t cxporir.cn t..l subjocts bo volunteers, and I do not aoo that leading down tlia r ccr.l wit', oxtr.-.cta takon free Li fo and codiec.l Journals, :n.’ ..11 cthr pcaciblo sources ia ~oin3 tc r id tho Tribunr.l or do nytMry except roault in r. lot of sarko boin^ thrown up around th.o cl ..motor cf tho oxpori or.ta carrio 1 cut olao- • here. Per o.tarplo, the \fon'.j'.t Karl Brandt rn tho stand, une'.or ques¬ tioning by hi a rwn Ccunsol, tv.do an : Hurl on tc cortain frootin'< .xp riaonta ; llosodly carried cut on six Insano persons in tho fttitod States. I thirk he said that thoy diod. 1 .lid not oxanino trl 3r:jidt about tlv.t atatonont because I did net went tc oonsuno tho tlno that it wruld hr.vo taken, but I think Karl Lr.ndt will •Miit th t ho lid not la rt a t in - ..bout what ho was spoakin^ about, "o looked into the natter. Tho oxporironts wero c. riod cut, in f'.ct, at tho ?'c*s, cr in Frrr.c~, cr dcouloro. Tl o rrcBucutlt n will bo put tr the burden of inv^aci^.tinj tl.rcu~,h. its •cureca ;.a to prociauly wl r.t wont cn, cr tl.o -nfcr.30 Crunccl will *5^ r;.iainc drubta in tic nlr.d if t!« Tribunal tl .t tl.o smo^tlins Itpponod in t! o inst:nco wlich thoy cito c.s hr.ppono <1 in tl o Dr.cl-.u neentr tier. cr. o will kr.vo to co:*o in c.n -1 pr vo'fch't It aid net Ir.ppon fcfcr.t wr.y, th t tho oxpcrli entr 1 aubjocta we r o ^ivon r. cert: in fern to oonpleto, that thoy voluntarily un orwont tl-o ox- perli ent , tK.t it t; s fully ocplr.inel to tlon bcferuh'.nrt, tl . t tho wide pirprao of tho ox -n.-ont w-a I. 1A cut tc tlon — nil eh ro rnttura. /.a pr-ctic.i n. ttir, I thl;’ th. t w uld bo tro burden thr.t w'uld j lsi.-p-u upon the Pxx e-cutirn, cr wo weul find t: ia rocerd apror.d full rf littlo short oxtr eta frii tl ia rr tint nulled jcurnr.l, rr.k- ln.3 rof ronco tc r. frouzlxic oxjcri :ort 1 <.re ( r. Jic.lc.ric oxpcrl lor.t there, or yollcw fov r cxpori. ont .n tic Fen joc C-nnl Zeno. XIo rcul. than h&vo to ccio fcrwi.rl nn oxplc.Jn tl^ao oxporlrxnta bo- cr.use I think Afonso Coioxawl ir und« ubtodly net In r. pcpiticn to ah;w tk.'t in • ny cno of tlv co lnctrncoa w;.s tlo cxpcria:o.it or.rricil ut rn inv'lmtc.x-y aubjocta or in roy wr.y t. into! with crinl nr.litty, IVo Pr socutior. i ro 13 willingt' accopt tl.o burlon cfpavvlng tint tr.u uxporx: :onta lore cl rxd woro CMri.l rut o tl eso porplt witl Coins) why, t! on, it cor t..inly would Y '• o ac:.o ur.tcrlr.lity m' prrMtivo vr.luc, Otlorwlao, I fc r i no cbjoct t ti e offor ur. sc since tins olrco/j loon s', m tho cuxnt nvl has ;iven Uis - Xdcn. £-.V..TR*S: J-. .-rasi lent, A.' I state sy int cf view with re ,t< tho speech y tho rr.socut r? fee ..r itivc value f ‘-is . cv :;nt, in ay /-inin, ia cry «;■ *rcnt. .' .st -.That Uc 'efen’.eat is 'win cher.C with ttoru is s’.: un V/ u*:c cn- Li.nt with the. ease it Bets f-rtrt. It cl. s that, ' y r^r f the •vorn- .xnt, uc;x.ri'vnts ere -oir. carrle : at a ..era ns t wh tx . x>rt f t;» * r- occuti n his-lf says teat tl«.< c .XI net ' - c nsiXav.’. s v lun- WP/• in £•• "iti n t this, the ,-n-rai i . rtrjvco «>f t’nia '.ccua-at ?s r.- r - ..arant. ene s. aaks a’: ut cr es v.; ca t.w 'uXcixhmts r.r- alJe .ix‘. tc ;-.av« c .Acte;’., * ut wont -in-.- - if t.xy an. crl-s. . r-CiSely . : A: ical lial X*s.s arc v..v - u tfal in tills ease Tx .r. Btcu- % t; a r-'ers t the cri X»ol lto '.c :i .all countries, which ia t 1« •sic in Ju.’ in th-sc cfcn’^.to, cut! t.x .n sccuti n :«o lac-’ an ex- -rt the ston-l Iwro wh- has vies.: an .•>.:! a in tho ethical sonac. Xa .ur. ra- vs t esta’ lia!-. a *vsjs t r e.:o rccusati n. Inn .wit 'o Lrori tie . 3 :' Llitg t .-- .sort tho srtterial that e enters t..-->e i lives. ! iX r. t ncei t * Int. the facts X .-II t?x o: ^crXxntc a.c Xccri’to! la articles an. * hs In acc r.'~.:o. vith u j truth. * r :£ it is an 1 ^- rta.it . iit I vier that thoso tlo-i.e arc ' ein : . Ua ; v .c ..u Uc all v.r . • " « ut any , - ... r :.-rc in E caxnt 1, n. v ir- as raisc<: in .. ._rica l s j*ct V< -i=. ii is is ttot a sir. X cru... ha SC ot • U c '.’n'riwS f r :-nj years. Ia i cc *nt I: 3 I l.avc c . s- .. n.aXr : articles fr : literature al-.vc*. J . 1 * -sXniah every' :t it is till -.re C3t nishin. that i tl»c w rl*. has ?ecn _x--:L. . at !• •.; Tie have an accusstr n r.'.c li t x srr*. sens-, aisa - la\- f or.it; is r_I-rre.’ t —that it «st c f 1-'. rtrnce t _ o' lc 1 c 2772 10 7ob 4?-3 :-lS-2a-:*VROS (SJ) Court Ho. 1. >?rov« that fcucaaity and hus an oaoss have not beer, considered to that extent up to no*. It is correct that tho deeuaent has been presented only for identifi- cation thus far, but I new request that it bo admitted in evidence. DR. SUDI (Defonco Counsel for defendants Gebhardt, Cfcorheuser and Fischer): lay it lease the Tribunal, in consideration of the fact that this is a basic question, I request -eraission to axoross aysolf briefly in connection with this question. May it please tho Tribunal, a nunbor of defendants, and ;articularly the defendants vhoa I ro'resent, arc boi-v* accused of havins carried out nodical oc^ericonts, and U.at these acts ronros^nt criaos. in ordor to support those clniiic, tho ; rosccution has referred to the sen oral ref¬ lations of the erlnir.il code, is s.t forth in Control Council law I’unbcr 10. This law does not set forth that an axnerinont undor certain condit¬ ions is a crir.c, but this law cr-ntains every ethor law and reads like aurdor, injury, and so on. -2773- 10 Tab A7-*-fJC-17-l-Sup.3or3toin (SJ) Court .Jo. 1 The law is not something that i- hovorin- ir. tho air, but, in order to reach a just verdict, it i a necessary to 9ha. actual conditions Li the field in question and to examine thee. Therefore, if tho defeneo presents • ovidenco of this kind, it is not in ordor to claim that in other countries — in tho Unitod States and In Franco — crimes of this kind are also boing e.gaittod, but t’.o -no to fulfill th.o abstract contents of the criminal code. It is a fact t! at eanv lars do contain those characteristics of tho actual deeds. — Indications which have a oet4A±n evaluation as a ovel- uation as a prorequisito. In ordor to Judge the quost on, if a aodical experiment, it's a crime. The question has to ’-c examined if this oxpori- sont violates a Jaw. Furthermore, tho question has to bo oxaminod If such experiment is a deed with which a -orson can bj charged. Ibcaaining those questions, It cannot bo indifferent If ~hyaiclans In othor oour.tr'oa act In such a fiven situation. Per tha dofeneo, thoroforo, it is decisive, if also in other countries and under application of tho j unorally valid, ethical and nedical prcfoeaiocal standards, physicians, in tho interests of a higher goal, of a view to a special necessity, can cony out -ucp CKperisents. Insofar aa evidence eo far presented by tho dofense is im¬ portant boeauao it laces the Tribunal in a ro*»‘ticn to ..xardno, to abstract the lv s in their application and reality and to nroporly evaluate tho presentation, Jurt like international law, can thuro things bo equally % represented, Just as little as possible in Judging the quostion, if n cer¬ tain s.odical experiment rot resents a crime, without considering the pract¬ ice of physicians ir. othor countries. That is all I have to say. I7CFZSS0F. SttJT-S: (Counsel for the defendant Blooe): lay it ploase the Tribunal, first of all I would request vou to tell me if a voiy principal question is not invol-ed hero. In ay o-inior., we have reached a I^elrlve piase in t o trial. For us dcfur.so cour.sols it Is not a ca3e cf raining a lot of anokc, as the representative of tha prosecution i.as stited. -2774- 10 ?o'r 47-d-7J0-17-2-Eur*por2tcin Court *ro. 1 .. '.jfeaco which realiz-s ita responsibility &ci fulfills this duty ■*zv»rly rejects that. ?,r us, wo on our pert war-t So contribute tc the ilorificatida of t:» lo^ai situation, and so, to ,,ivo the nocossary ‘.coin to tho Tribunal la -rior to roach a verdict which will actually. frcn all Silas, to considerables fair, correct aai wiso. Tho dafandants havs been accusoi of iaflictir^, injuries, physical injuries and uirlor. ji t jj law is written, in yiur law colo as well as sura, "Thou ahalt not kill. Thou ahalt not inflict physical dcia^o. Thru ahalt nov injure anybody." hut what the huuan boin. has to do individually in order tc fulfill this la , and In what casos ho can liter >> frc:. this law, we aro not diroctly told by the law. In a case, like the coso -n hand, the rolic 1 professional othlca will hovo a doclsivo vol,.ht. /. professional concept of tho physician who pro>j-ly fulfills his duty, •'ill shew to tho Jud o, in ~rder t'- onablo his; to Jud. o What is uococcary for radical silor.co, and what is nupjrfJuous; what oan bo c nsilorod as lo„al, and whet is without any dnubt lllo.al. Tho 'r-fosslonal concopt of jho radical prof os ti a c lvoe this information -a tho subject. That lc the profosaioaal concopt not only of tho Gor-an physicians, tut also of th j for-ii^i nodical profession, Just like cortaia basic principles exist which always return In the su.« way la oil criminal Cv>ioa, oo for tho uadioal prorossion, in all cirilizod statoo there aro cortaia prooodurec on’ dl-octivos which are hoinj followol by all countries and which :oist bo oensidorod correct. If now the dafonso is ablo, by .a ns of a lar..o auior of liturory ovidonce frau th_ oroes and also fret; spocial :adlcal Journals— IT tlt» dofjr.no is able t~ _ivo u -acis for tho Tribunal in -rdor to clarify this difficult 'uostioa, under what conditions anl with what precautionary -ecsuro3 such oxpdrli-or.ts ero par: zlsniblo, then tho ?rl‘ anal will certainly wolcciyj, if it can also consider this material i vouching » voriict. Tho dofonsc cannot bo satisflol th;t any L dividual export, frr axanplo li-:a Professor Loib>-nnd, is a certain a.- 13 th. nly noaistent of a. Tribunal In io?iUa; the no iifflcult iu*-stlcaa. Your Honors, already tfc. fact that Proforccr Loibtroni 2775 1 C Tab Ll-k-? JC—17-3-Xu*perstein (3J) Court :.'o. 1 saintains the point of vi er t!.at & prisoner was not at all able to give his consent to an experiment requires a certain aauunt of coercion towards accepting this opinion, Furthermore, wc have heard that a large number and series of experiments was mentioned by this ex-ert rhich the medical * literature deala vith. For the most part, he did not kno*. it at all. And then, he on^' stated: "Yes, I know then", but :.e did not with a single word state his opinion to thee, and he did not oontion any word, if ho likewise considers the experiments carried out in forei'.n* countries ao criminal, or if he ccnsidors these experiments abroad Justified and legal. ' Your Honors, if it has been statid, crimes are being coeiaitted every¬ where, not only in Germany, but also in foroign countrios. Then this phraso dees not servo tho dociaicn f our caso at all. If serious scient¬ ists rooort ir. nodical Journals about experiments which they havo carriod out and if, furthermore, no public prosocutor and no crurt in tho world objects to thoso experiments, or has taken those soientists to givo an account of thocsolfos, then this oxproasos tho fact that, in tho case of the rosoarch emcornod, no crlsas v 0 ro cooaittcd, but that thorc wero aoricus scientific attoopts. And, when i road t! rou^h thoso document books, whon a.-.«ong3t tho sclontists fron whoa tho reports oripinato 1 sco Jlroctorc of international refutation, directors uho have rocoivod tho highest distinctions for their work, for thoso ox orloonto. -2776- 1C Fob Li -A-Ji -17-la-Kupr e rst oir. Court Vo*. 1. than this say load to a certain caution with regard to the quostion that it is stated then, those eople who are living abroad, also aro Just simply criminals, and thoir research aast be considorod as criminal. But tho pro¬ secution does not bear this consequence into account. And, in tho intorosts of Justice, in =y opinion, it nust bo oxaainod if, and to what extent, and ir. what connections on- or the other exporioont, 'hich ono or tho othor of tho c'ofendants say have carriod out aust bo placed on tho saso lovol vith a experiment* which have boon not ■'cscrlbjd as crLios by tho intamational press, but as aedical achiovieonts, which in many cases rocoivod tho highest recognition. As a result of this. Your Honors, 1 an of tho opinion that it is not only in tho interests of tho verdict in this trial, but also ir. tho intorosts of radical scionco itsolf, that thoso trials should contri- b uto to toll the nodical aciontista in Germany and all ovor tho world, when they can carry out experiments, and under what'proroquisititoe thoy lav- to start, and that precautionary s»asuroa thoy havo to follcm, and things of that kind. Your Honors, if this question is clarified as a result of your verdict, then this -. ill contributo Just as .such to tho noods of tho nodical profess¬ ion as tho first Turcaburg trial contributed to tho furthor dovolonmont of international lan. I thoroforo roq»*cst that it is necessary that you should obtain knowlodgo of this Utoraturo, and t >t perhaps you shall occuoy "our- solf with it ir. yoar vordict. That is all I havo to nay, Ur. Prosidont. Ul. .£ KAK2T: 2 havo listonod with grer-t interest to the inoassionod pleas of Dr. Sautor and other doftnsu counsel, but I havo not yet heard a clear dolinoation of th. purpose for which this proof is offjrod, and tho aatcriality to this caso. 1 would suggest that the Court rororve its ruling, that the defence f.«t t.gather and sake un their collective ninds :.s to pre¬ cisely what they expoct to prove with this, and Just exactly how it relntoa itself to the aetter at issue in this case; that, on the basis of such a stateaent, the prosecution wiU subsit a brief to the Tribunal. The proso- cution has alvays assured the burden, and has added in the indictment, that these experiments or these surders and tortures and other inhumane treatment- resulted free. -2777- 10 Feb Z.7-A-J?-17-2a-rupperstein Court Mo. 1 cedi cal experiments can -ed cut on involuntary human subjects. I do not think they can find one word or one statement, anywhere the world over, that says such medical experiments are lawful anywhere. The thins *t issue in thie case is the voluntary character of the experiments hore carriod out, and it behooves this Court nothing, adds nothing to the proof, to have thorr. load down this record with hundreds of oxamples of human experimentation. This trial is not condemning human experimentation ger.orally at all, and not one word has been uttered by the prosecution to indicato such a thins* ordinary l*w of assault and battur/ and manslaughter certainly ives to the Waited States; and I take it they exist in So many, and if those defendants comsdtt*i od experiments upon versons who didn't consent to undertaking thosa axpori- oorits, then I soo no difficult legal question presented at all. And now wo can talk in very ia<*ssioned terms about the nocossity of this Tribunal oriont- ing itself upen the procise conditions undor which ovary human ax orimunt has ever boon carriod out. I submit that it is both unnecessary, immaterial find constitutos an intolerable burden, and will prolong this trial beyond any asure cf reason. Tho vary experiment thoy'ro talking about in Life Uag- i:ine, roads on its faco tfat it is voluntary; then how can it bo material to justify tho experiments carried cut by Schilling in Dachau, then tho pro¬ secution has undortakan tho burden of proving thoso oxedrimonts woro carriod out on non-voluntoors, porscos who wore forcod to und».ryo tho experiment. Thon whence comas the materiality of an oxporlracnt carriod out in a orison in tho State of Illinois, with rvalnria. Kow it so happens that wo knew* a l.ttlj bit about that cxocrlmont. Ho have tho forms which wore submitted to the prisoners, which ndvisod thorn what wculd bo dono to thta, and which re¬ tired that thay sign their non. to it on tho bottom if they wished to under¬ go it. Ho have t radio speech made by one of the 'arsons vho did undergo It; ■» have quite a mass of facts concerning this particular experiment, and ho thing will be true of other experiments, to which they will make some sort of an allusion durin. the course of this case. But I submit they -rove nothing, -2778- rt ; o. 1 they don't clarify anything at issue in this trial, and uooU ;ui, fac ‘> the burden on tie nrosecution of clarifying the little scrap of evidence - if you call it evidence - which they will try to t! re* into t! e record of this case. Then we will have to cone fon*a-d and really tell the Tribunal ahat it's all about, or the Tribunal will have the uneasy feeling that rC?-19-l-S«cpaoa Court 1 THD IIaSSEaL: Dio Tribunal it rgain in session. May it ploaco Your Honor tho dofeaient Oberoauser is absent in accordance with tko ap¬ proval of tho Court. Tho question of admitting an exhibit was being considered by tho Court beforo tho recoss. DP, lUMCTOl Yes. A TEE ??.aSID2 ^T: Tho Tribunal is ready to rule on that question. The Court has considered tho docaaent of the defendant Brandt no &>• Mbit Ho. 1, and without establishing any rule which will be a jrroco- doiit In cay future case, each case as it ariseo will bo individually conolderod by the Tribunal, The Tribunal sdnito in evidence tho do- fSK&ont 1 c lari Brandt, Exhibit Mo. 1. IP, SZBTaTIUS (attorney for defendant JLirl Brandt): Docxtsent Ho.2, 2 shibit So. 2 , I submit tho periodic list of o*?or- iuonts; it hasn't been node ready in the English yet, and it vill bo ouboitted to the Tribunal in the jfeglish tranelation at a lntor date. ae Exhibit Mo. 3, X as outsitting the chart, xdiich can bo noon on the wall, together with an affidavit of tho co-defondant 3rnnk, iftich was already rood into the. record. This will becoeo Exhibit Mo.3 a; it is DoctKoat 23 15. Exhibit Mo. 3; 13 0. Exhibit 3 a. TED PRESIDENT: Tho Court will roquiro that copies bo fumichod to each cumber of tho Tribunal. DR. SZRVaXIUS: They haven't boon a ado available as yot sinco tho aicoogrtqjhing department is overburdened, but they will oc oub- cittcd to tho Tribunal ot a later date. Hr. President, I subuit tho oricladn and I shall see to it th^t the Inbund will rocoivo their copies. THE PR1SIDKT: That vill be sufficient; you ncy submit tho copies. -2700- 1C ?cb 47-BS-2&-l-iiinabcck (BJ) Court So. 1 JUDGS SSBBDrGt Is it the chart, D ctor, or Brandt's affidavit that you are asking to be submitted as Schibit y DR. S2WA7IUS: Tho chart as 2, and the attached affidavit as 3-X. I further submit as Exhibit 4-A the iocunont 13-29, which was tho docu- n>nt ot the prosecution, NO-150. That will become Zxhibit 4-A and 4-3. It was already submitted during tho course of the examination. LR. HARDY: Vhat does that docuacnt refer to that you just mentionod Doctor? DR. S2RVATIUS: Thu contents cf tho docuacnt constitute a lettor by Bcxihlor according to which ho has to rive directives with reference to tho execution of euthanasia. THE PR2SID1I - ?: Voll, whoro lc that docuacnt to bo found? Is that contained in Brandt's document book? DR. S2RVATIUS: To, it Is not contained in tho document book. It mas submitted during the a-uuninaticn. It ^^as suboittod by tho prosecution and you will rocolvo cooios la tor, and I have already submitted tho Pho¬ tostat. 23. HATJY: Your Ilonor, I do not recall that Document !.'0-150 was suboittod by tho rosocution. I bollovo it was suboittod by defense c cun sol in jxoni nation of "randt, and I ioaglno Khglish copies aro avail¬ able and I will tiy to assist Dr. Sorvatiua in jotting thco for you. DR. S^vVATlUS: It has boon suboittod to tho Language Division but was not vot returned, i shall submit it as soon as I have it. I as now off.ring in affidavit of kiaa Alike Krchno. Sho is an aa- ployoc who worked in tho office of Trandt. It cm Ho found in the docu- sar.t book, oago nunber 7 under .:3-4. I have a tobhnical question in that connection. Thoro aro two Iocunont books, This In contained in docuaont book number 1, •'ago 7. IK2 PR3SID3J7: Copies of this document book fu mi shod to tho Tri- ' r ;r -al i: not . avo the pages numbered. \horo do wc find this docuacnt? DR. S31VATIUS: Thoro is an index at tho beginning of tho ‘ocumont book, and tho document books aro numbered according to their figures so -2781- 10 F;b-SC-20-2-ffiaBtacic (3J) Court Kc. 1 that you can easily find document KE-4. IfcZ I-TESIDJT: Unfortunately, the index pago of tho Brandt dccur.^\t book 1 is illegible. DR. SETVaT!’ 5: Your Honor, It is page nuabor S. Your Henor, tho jiglish UiXt isn't quite legible. THE PRZSID3rT: '!o have found tho document, -*arl Brandt Jbehibit U. DR. SET'AUUS: Ilr. President, I v.ould bo grateful if you^rould toll .o how •• u want cc to road tho documents. Till it bo sufficiont if 1 Just rcughly toll you tho contont and then cito certain passa oa, or is it rocossaiy to read tie document in its entirety? 1 nay point out that during tho trial before tho IKT it uaa considered sufficiont if merely tho essential -oints wore referred to in ordor to shorten tho orocoodings. T.;s FR3SID3 T: Iho Tribunal is of tfcu opinion that that will be su¬ rf lei on t, to call attention to jssentiil uortions of the docuncnt. UR. HARDY: Hay it oloaso tho Tribunal, I havo two questions to ask Dr. Sorvntius in connection with this affidavit. JCD0H SEBRDC Uay I ask first, that is ccoing in as ..hoc oxnibit number? DR. sav.ms: It "ill bo &hibit -unbar 5. UR. HARDY: In connection with 3chibit Kusfcor 5, as I ooo it fren ay copy, I boll eve this docuexmt was not signed in tho >rosonce of Dr. Servatiua, and not having the rulos of tho Tribunal before ae no* in con¬ nection with the rocedure necessary to receive a docuncnt hero in evi¬ dence in good fone, I qtiosti.n the right to admit this into evidence due to tho fact that such certificate that it is a correct signature was not obtained by Dr. Servatius or in his presence. It shows on tho faco of the document that the affiant is froa Ervmen. 1 reserve tho right now to object to this document later after 1 hav- had tins to ooruso tho rule of t! c Tribunal in connection 'ith tho admissibility of affidavits. THZ P^S:D3:T: The prosecution may reserve tho right to object to the iocuaent. DP.. SERVATIUS: L'r. President, I signed this docuacnt and thereby 2782 10 ?cb-BSK-20-3-3tinafeuck (3J) Ccurt !io. 1 c.rtifiod that it was sijncd in cy presence. I believe it is an error vx: the part cf cho prosecution to say that just b .cause tfco vo:an was in Bronon it wasn't signed in =y prosjnee; it actually was. If this ex¬ planation doesn't suffice I wmld have to bring a new certification of • tho witness saying that aho signed this in ay presence. kR. HARDY: The prosecution accepts the word of counsel that it was signed in his presence and refrains freo objection. ®B j R3E)3!T: 7o nvo future trouble a corrected certificate should be found shewing that tho witness signed the document in* presence of c>. unsol. DR. S3WATIUS: Tho witness Xrohnu was caployod as a secretary with the dofendant Sr..j.Jt free tho v -ginning of the wtr until January’ 19U, and aho says that tho Agency was normally in the Reich Chancellory- but that in reality Brandt uorfcod in tho surgical university clinic. She knows atout tho order if Kirch 19UU which referred to tho anti-ch-anical '.rf-.ro agents and she says th t that docroo was very brief. I quote: "1 definitely know that It did not contain directives on exporiraxits. with poiscr. gas nor did I soe lator in tho corres; ndor.co r olsowhoro anything that w-'uld have intLaitcd that hrofesse r Brandt had anything tc dc with such." aid quote. Then tho witness refers to a radio interview regarding tho offica cf Trofass r Brandt and she says tho following, and I quoto: -27*3- 10 F oh-..-J P-2 0-1*—Rtr-sbcc Sc Court ?fc. I 'Jlr. January 19U5 Professor Branf.t participated in a r- 'io interview by Dr. Ott in t-.j Berlin Broadcastin. S»aticn -rod ssade tis« followin-clar'tiens as to the functions of his new agency. I rc.j-i*er th~t up-.n t«w quest! n as to th. character of Lis position towards th- other agencies of the Raich ho r-^li-j - that no hr.' tc oonsi ‘or his position as th t *»f a sort cf •differential' 7h- witn-ss c .ntinues and I tjjfto: "I wr^te that interview to-ettvr .. 1 th th. secretary Hrnk- at the ti e an ’ was also pr-sent wh-n it was oci.V; recorded xnr' was c iparln. the transmission with ay rnvscri. t." Finally tiv. xitiv.se sft-s tfc - the irefus‘..r Brant was active o an Ctoerirxt in addition t his otlvr 'uti-s, in r&.*iti.-n to his uth-r or-r.nisa- ti ml duties. This ! >rln..a ... ti ay next *V?cu-;nt nicn can t- found in th- ’ exigent beck un!ur KB-5. It is an *fii Jaw fr.r-. the testimony a l itn.os Dr. Laj*v.rs, n\4ely, the six., th- -ffico, i - sc-rcity of fun s, an’ thonc. cs t th- qu-.sti-r. f c nth-ana si , an in th-t connection he s _ yc, and I qu.toj "I can „ivc the ~ssur j:co tn-.t n-_ to- c r.tralled cash receipts no itoas p-rtrin -* t .r ver- in c .nn-cti u wit . th- euthanasia ro-r _i.“ Th>; witn-cs knows su-thirv “b ut th- j'S ef-nso d-cr-v of tlie let of rch 19Ui which «as racrc ’ un er tiv osi n-ti-a, » li, an-' in that ccnn-c- ti n he ..../. 10 Fob 47-A-S -20-1B—i'insbuck (BJ) Court Vo. 1 sa.-s tho following and I quota: "•ho idcraa v fc lc h «as filed among tho usual secret records of tho c^jncy hod been fc*^K?o». ^ver to so by tho 'sec rotary for a quick study. I da not roe oil act its uordin erectly but it reads about as fallows: 'char - ay U-noral -osaissicnor : rofessor Dr. Xarl Drendt to ir.tervcno a-vhoritatively in questions of -as defense. The .’.eich Minister for A:m- a~*nt and -ar Production is instructed to rive Professor Drandt ad-aittar.ee A to the assembly stops at any tine and to offer him all necoesary assist¬ ance and information he might require.'" % I new cojae to tlo following ’ocuaer.t rhich is document Kr-6 which I offer as Bchibit aber ?. It is the affidavit or anothor employee, .a certain Prau Jutt- facto Proa the 1st of April 1943 until April 1945, sho was active .n karl Inimit's office. Sh» vaa In charge of keo;ins tlie registry and she became familiar with the contents of the records kont there, amen.. thee Hitler's initial euthanasia decree to Prandt and Beuhlor, and in that connection the ray* tlio following and I quoto: "Kith reference to this outhanasla docroo t! ere was no special corros- -or.donco and what thore was only in tlio for., of reports frt«r. doctors or a rents on births of r+.yecially or mentally hondJcaopod chlldrod for whoo oirhanar.ia was roqueated. Hoy ucro dealt with only insofar as it was nd- vlood to consult rucomsonr'od aodical authorities for study of the case or to et financial assistance, \pprovals for tho roquostod outhanasla wore never given." Tho witness furthor makes statements about the rorsons that had access to tho office and says the folia inf, and I quoto: "Reichslotter Bouhlor and the agency chief Br-afc I am acquainted with as -jjetoors of ti e .'uo'ror'r Chancellory. Thoro vas no official corros- por.dcr.cu with thus in any way connoctod *-ith outhanasla or the Reich. con.jittee. iho r.vws of Professor Dr. Eoydo, Professor Dr. Viotscho aro >' n<*»n to w. If tl.oy had had anything to dc with our -2785- 10 rub 47-A-S -2C-2B-:'in9tuck (B J, Court Co. 1 ssencjr in ay tico I voaU necessarily have known tfcaa. Thu naaes of Dr. :fanreuollor, Schuaann ond Fa Ikon hauscr wore not known to so in tho a^nr.cy oithor. Corrospcnder.cc with Dr. Linden's office, so far qs I know, was liaitod to boabod out hospitals and their transfer. 71 era was no corr.s- ndor.ee oithor with Dr. tenti in connection with euthanasia and Reich Coj.rittco ratters. So f ar as I 'mew ihoro was also no written corrcspond- xnca with Blankonburs, Hog on or and Kao f nor. Blankenburs and Jlacfnor are indeed known to ao but only for the reason that they worked In tho suno office building." -2736- 10 Fub-A-JP-21-l-3-.ord-( GJ ) - Court 1 I don't know cf any discussion on Euthanasia with Bouhlor'a office. I would have necessity known of this. I ;:ow skip a paragraph and I coee to the part There the witness spooks about Bodolschwiii^, and I quote: "I furthor testify that at that tiao Professor Brandt enjoyed thoroughly friendly relations with P_stor von Podclschwing. In the Susn-.r of 191*3 I was present when raster von Bodclsci.wing on^o spent a whole afternoon as a guest ir. Professor Brandt's residence, and both of then conv-rsed very unreservedly. I can further recall that Pastor von 3edolschwing once spoke publicity of tt»c fact that his institutions had been spared such cnreachn^nts." I now cone to docuue.it !»B ?, which I aa offering \s Exhibit No. 8. THE FRFSZKMT: Just a cooent. fhnt document did you offer as Brandt's Exhibit 6. DR. SJWAYK5: Exhibit 6 is Docuaxt Karl Brandt, KB 5, and tho document vhich was Just read, KB 6, rill bocono Exhibit So 7. That la the document of Jutta Rich. I now coau to Docuaent S3 7, *rich will become Exhibit Vo. 8. It is an affidavit of the nura< Netty Gerornn. It only h.-s a general content and shows that the Jofondant Karl Brandt was an active physician in tho clinic and that hu carefully cared for hie patients. This is being submitted in erd or to slior in what tanner tho activity of Karl Brandt was exercised and how he was engaged in his various tasks. And, the Cocuaer.t KB 6 has already been submitted, and that brings ao down to Document KB 9, ::fcich .rill b.-coae Exhibit No. 9. This is an affidavit Of Professor TTemcr Schulcminn. Doctor Schulcmann is a specialist in Ualaria research, and I quote: 10 Feb-*-JF-21-l-5card-(GJ)- Court 1 Hospitals Godeshohc and Rhcinblick in Bad GodeSberg, in the A ray Coenand District VI. In th.se hospitals in connection with ay institute Uilaria research was carried on, and carried on in accordance with the nctnods recognized and custcaary with specialists 2767-A 10 ? c b-.v-JP-21-2-f--r’. Cjurt I -.t hor-t md abored. "I cr-x in contact with Prof-ssor K.arl iravdt or. the Sumer of 19k3 wlxn I apf-ro'.cnce' him in order to sake uk- . alarin hospitals secure frtn other claims end was successful ?n winking his help. In the scientific dia- cuscions on "claric research which took plnco then rrofesser Karl 9rnn;'.t never m-tc any su .cations or ^avo any •.fractions to su, or even inace any allusion to tno effect that expcrixr.ta f'.ioul ’ o: perforce?' or. hurra ooinjs in nn unlawful mnner. In particular, he ii ’ rot spink of Malaria uypwri- X •xnts which had be«n carried out in Dachau. "If frolessor Karl Brandt had been active in this typ. of research he would have had to discuss the questions involved with a- especially cs I no known r.a a specialist in this fiol«’. I r-ccivod very hlfh scientific (dstinctlons for zy -thieves*.nts in ti production of synthetic rr.l.ri-. ncdlcinos, men. others the >'.nry-::in.;sl«y oednl of the Livorpool School Tropical ieiicihc in 193dj and -fur tie occupation ay the allied troops I l-oncdiateiy r ot ..emission tc continue the vork in :sy institute. On f.jc • isls of all that I ta.o» nbiut .Tolcusor Sr-ndt. I ci nsidor it hi t hly ir>- prcbnblc that lx had anything te dc with criminal exponents, or that he npprovod of th-.-., naked for then or su ;•>» tod. then. "I net rrefesaer Brandt twice ut Dncu.xr.t KB 10, which is tix witn-ss Gutsoit, and 1 subnit now Docun-nt K* 11, lirfiibit No. 10. This is an iffid-vit of Doctor Schiuber. It is Ocsi-nat«fc’. as ..ffidavit IT, since, uo:*e then one ran iiv»n bj hin. The witness Schieber speaks -.bout Vo "icticn 3r-.n«t". This «rk wan already •.ntioce. c’unn tc-.-urfe of thu rocccdin. s =r. ha e.^l'ins tlx ".Icti.-n fron.'t" as tlx execution of a n-dic .1 ..re r ... He ous on to sr. these special orders which 3„am't receive ar 1 quote: This or ’-r w s issue it the boiinnin b of arch 19U* ns a parallel v* tlx nedical pre^r'.?., ZJSb 10 r b-il-J i>-2 l-3“3card Court I "..cticn Brandt". This decrt- in itself, co.. -ents, is addressed to tho Spcor !i,r.istry cnt'ms, ccccrdin. to its purpose, i-ixdi-atc production order by ■nich Frofv-ssor Doctor Karl Bron it *rca opaosc to the samifacturc, ns p. buyer, on*’ ccnceaina tho production ha full ;cvrs of control st t/v. cooe -i .. .4S fr "s I re..^ ber th.ro w.as nc scientific medical ros-irch criLr for irofusscr Karl Brandt attached to it. Vb aro here concerned with ttvo ir.ti-chuaical wnrcf.ore decree. 44nd, I now co~ to th_ next document i£tich*cs -lao nude by the witness Schicbor. It is KJ 12, which I sa eutaitti.* as exhibit K... 11. It deals •dth thj fact that Defendant Karl B .rn.'t cauerc' w let aninals 't ro".t expense In the Sir. .r of 19Wi, arrf tut to transferred thw fror Spaor. to (Lmany. It says hero in order to c'rry out the task, and wo are concerned with biological rosearch parallel ic honor. bcin as certain ardnr .1 p.cticn ms started by nc and Krufosaor Karl 5 .an’t for tho Arsanent office, of approximately 20C,0C0 Swiss Franks, noi. aft.r »y njcornitior. ae Chief of aray Supply Office in Ootetor 19l*L, fr. tto Spoor niotry, 1 sedo stronieus efforts tb.ethar with rr^fwssor Krl Brcndt u h .v a It.,*, amber of aniutfs broutht by oxtre.a^ly iifficult air transport ti n fr.i Spain to O.n any. ThuCu -re put at Fr.fosaor X-rl Brandt's Ispes 1 fer export until purpa. s. I thon submit Docuaont KB 13, as Exhibit no. 12. This is an nffl avit by the co- ’cr-n .ant Su If B\ndt, itilch I o ;.oing ta rear., and I quotoj "I, Ru if ran-It, *ofe.a '-ant in Cane 1 before, the ’lilitary Tribunal r.t Surenoor , x. Pr-c .cution Win tils cas . I -mm, under oath, ehat ' tUjr h=vin b -* n '“ly warned to at I a liable to .uidshavr.t if 1 nnk- c fisc tt'U-v.nt. v st ta.nt corr^spon . tot.. . truth *.n w.s tsrio t- be ilier-d in ?l ' oncc at ttv- slitary Tribunal I at . ure. bur*,, C-r. arty. n Ir. this -ffi '.avit I have sivji t\. t,;e iraswcutisn, and wnlch wure -ro- " s evi-Vjnco, 1 declared that t. a co-.'oi .a'ant ITofcssar Karl D-amit, ^Vs.ly has hab kncwlc t of th- Stcriiisati;: j an tiirt, '-femurs., he had Icncim 2739 10 l 'ufc-.--JP-21—2;-3tar J C on- T of «- tfo t ha n a ala cpcriacnts, an-that h. surely tec known of the Ty.-auL x- ptri-aonts. I ^ n«t tears any actual -vidence for this atrtownt n-.do by I n vo sirred tl.w affidavit a it r . 5 proser.tod to *. without proper knowledge in no knowL. ’ u o oftte circuit .Sieve, cn the fact which Juatifiad thlo - ncluaicn. In one affidavit I declare/, furt.tr that the decree dated 1 - rca 19lJi ccnc ‘- rns chanicel wnrofnr. ijonU, tad confine’ an nuthcri- xition for jrofcaaor. Doctor Kcrl Brandt to ep. naor wdical roa^-rch in connection with 3P.8 raids, -.nd 1 vxntj nod f t tola conccrnod oxporim.nta. "I have ai^n-d thic reels. vor.in, olthcu„fc tit c ont.nta of the ‘ccrec wore not present to cy tlnd. Likcvifo, i c-nnot aacartein that fron sy own knc.wle.lcc, *hcn frcfoaaor, Doct r ;tr.rl Brandt, h-.d been informed of too ietaila of the Kuatard 0 "a Exp.ri-t.nta." *790 10 2-1-L-r. .-r’t Court .1. I furfwr su’iiit th_ 0oco.xnt ns ixhi'jit 13. This is a fur- r,h-r -iffi "arit ia:o by the witrviss Schij'.-T. It cone ms a letter fren iniator T'r ..nr-.unt Sp-ot to the Fiji-*. . arshal Keitel, which is atta¬ ched as an anr.jx. Tb-j witn-ss h-ro in this effi Vavit confirms that the vxt is cornet. ..n'., in this connection, 1 wouli like to ay that lv a co yj on his . rs-n, only T aontion h-re the onissicr. if the 'otnils. ' j-i dt this letter in or or to prove fat in th_ Istri' uU^n list at tbo on* of tho letter, Karl *ran't was not .xntionc J , an', th-rof .ro, oalt 'iroctiy with Ktitol in ictt.rs -f . In the lottor itself, the lidtationa as product ion are sot out. T»o next 'ocuivmt is cn effi avit by t»w witrv-sa Lam_rs. I an lust tol * ' y the r sucutiin t vat *ho ori Inal letter Is rvcila' lo, with tl-j . rasecution. ,"0Y: I 'o not wish to 'x. on borate o*. as aayin that I ask> 1 Dr. Sarvatlue If tv. ori ind 'ocurvint .os stalin' lo. ut tat I n'.rstoo hia tc say that it ^ss availa lo. -k. has a copy c-rtifij* by liasolf. Dl. S' 0V..TIU3I I tn-n hav- thu 'ccunont X" 16 which I n.i iff-rln.- s *bthl’it lh. It is n chart on Euthr.nasia in th r uiich Coiteitt^o which has not • won cc-a. 1-tc 1 -a y-t. .. copy will be pr s-.ntoi tj.hu Tribunal at a 1 tor ato. c aru tv ro n-roly o^no rno with th- Chart. rr ’"STTEKTs ‘hat ..ns th- last -xhi.it before this Chart which coun3«l has referro’ to. TU S* ty^nus* Tzit was bchiblt 13, Docuaunt r 111. T~ . *“SID“t , T: That's curr-ctj I have a note of it. •01. STUBBS: Cw:J-nt Ho. 17 can V. 1-ft out, since it was ns-e '■y Lau rs, wh~ was -xavin. ’ h_rv. ..n' .( now su* .ait Docunont S'-16 ~-s x i* it 15, which is a ocuumt in tha fom of an affi ’avit aa'o by Dr. .nv.r Xirch-rt, who was foraer n- leal officer of the \-.ff-n-SS, an' ho -ns conc-rnc’ with th*. 1-a’orship of on Suthanasia institution. ~n' I lU'te fWatfco affidavit: "In Sap^ a -r 193> ioich fhysician SS Or. Towitz suraasna! 2791 on 10 H-22-2-Lohnhar "t C'urt * ; :. 1. -3k.-- ' 30 te nake a list of tho r-cr.ian Lunatic asyluns an’ their nun or of iryv' -s, as :' 1 an th.. ’etc in the loich Medical Calanar, The reason, I vr-3 tol’, vas the fact that because of tbo ova-*uition of ti» cstwall zone the imate a ha’ tr :c transferred to oth-r asyluns. fU I ha finished eonpdlin tte list an’ hal hanrio ’ it in, 'rawitz sont no to r T. r.^jmann- ihcncvllery of tho Tuohror-. Th.ro I learnod that actually it was a natter of euthjnasia of the insane, an’ that the- transfer was only a j.ra- t-xt. It was pointc *. out to uo that it was lone on direct or‘era fron tho Fuohror an J that i-ich Leit^r ouhl-r ha .con instructor^ to carry thoa out. I was vary stocked at such an order fronthe Fuehrer an* I spoko a ain to nr. ^revitz an*, had another two r throo ’iscussions vith Dr. Hofolraann to which iVofossor nr. Koy'o of u;rz\ur- was also callod in. Tho ontiro cuthania .iroco-hiru was still ontircly in its early sta .8 an' a iilan was ’.rafted as to how th. natt.r should bo carrio J out. It was to *.» ’one in several institutions. ..t first 3 institutions in ’iff rent *c.rto of f \jr>>?ny mjro mntioned. Tho insane tropic concerned whs shoul ’ c o un'or the ,rrrn woro to he soloctod, wh.ro. y "oy-'o as chief .x?.rt ros.rvu* tho final Aicision for himself. "v rythin should So ‘ased on strictly re ’leal views an* only such ix*-- s-vns were to bt selected irtio in a psychiatric Definin' cul” o callod "chron¬ ically" ill. Hoy’o hinsalf wanted to isit the lunatic asyluns, to se¬ lect tho . .rsonn.l an J instruct it acordin ly. •.s I oould not and would not arprovu of such n glen I told 'bvivitz that I refused to tnko • v.r an outhanesia institute. Ha, th-roforc, ’corad it a-’visa’.lc that I l.avc “erlin as soon cs pcssi* lc an’ or’orod -sc ta take over a nodical c n.ony of tho affon-SS which I ’±1 on 7 Oct. 1939. Durin all the na -otiations t*» na^s which woro aontioiwd or the j.rsons who took 1C F sb-A-JP-22-ln-Lohnh ard t-( BJ ) Co’irt Ko. 1 part wore: GRAI/ITZ, R3FF3UA.V, K2TDE, BIATXHTaEG, BRICK, and CORHiat. Tot - single *oni -s sid about Dr. Karl Brandt. Svorything at that tirco was still in the early stages. I wish to odd that I was told at the negotiations in tho chancellery % of tho Fuehrer that out>-was!a was regnal tod by decree of the Fuehrer and Iso by Goail^G's signature, as chair-van of the Reich Defense Council. I did, hcMovur, not see those signatures. Later tho problira arose aeiin when I was p. dc artnent head with KationaJ Qkhoff, who, cn his own irdti- ativa, approached me. This witness denied givi*- his oath to Hitler» an! he - 2799 - 11 Feb. !*7-M-,.TT>-2-2-^lUcloy Ccurt Ho. 1 says* "For reasons of conscienco I refused to .’ive the oath of unconditional ?Ile:danco to Ritlerj ani ry wife in her aradoty turned to Ur. Karl Drandt to ask for blip. Frof. "randt in a lottjp pl^dvod this hole to ny wife, riving a prerriao to look after rry cafe." TJw docuaont XT-35 I an offering as Exhibit 25. This is an affidavit of the wifo of ths witness Just oontionodj and ato describes in detail how assistanco was Ivon at that tin«. The next docuDant is KT-36j andl an offerinj this exhibit as Exhibit 26. This is an affidavit froa "taria Kellner, who is tte !tother Superior of the Frenoisoan Hospital and who on her own initi¬ ative approacho-* as. B.T statesxnt is of importance in so far ns it shows that Dr. Karl "randt was not an outspoken Kami as he is being indie tod hero. Sho doooritos in detail his character and soyas "Dr. Drandt was always vory friendly towards us an 1 , novir showed hinsclf to be a !!ati," Further, aho saysi "Consilorir.- his kind disposition towards us Catholic Sis tors, I cannot boliovo that ho would oonsclously ccadt a criminal act." I now cono to t*v. Doounont KT-37, which is Exhibit 27. This is an affi¬ davit aado by a priest of a Chtholic erd-.r. Father Unto Sebastian Woih. Thin Catholic priost approached no and at ry repost (jmvo no this affidavit in this fom. He describes here a Bootin' with the defendant "randt at Christmas, 19b3j an' ho says that the dofondant Brandt at that tino, on Christnas Evo, wont to tho front dispensary in order to hslp so=e of the physicians thoro and to take ttoir turns. Ho further statos that Karl *Yandt lntorvoncd is favor of the Sisters of tho erdor, and ho soldi "I shoul' like to givo you a Chris teas surprise. I have boon ablo to intervene sc that tho Sistors can roaoin in that hospital." The priost told us that there was a hi * do.*ree of 03teen for reli-ious values in ’rar.dtis character and that all the assistants wero very nuch inpressod with his staturo an* that he 6 the ref ore Judged ‘randt vory favorably. Then tho General Secretary sent a letter tc no, askirv- no to su v Rit it to tho Tribunal. This is a lotter of a woman physician, Louisa Errwoin, of Muchlhauson, who, as a French conan, was confined in a concentration canp. This lotter is addressed to the Tribunal. The witness says that Draodt had -23 OO- 11 F 0 b. h7-*W.7D-2-3—'l^kley Court !to. 1 helped har in ordGr to get her out of the concentration can? into a position as a physician. Tbb essential points of this staten-nt arc that sho thought . cf turning to the defendant Rraadt for hilp, and that neons that sho con- % sidorod hirs a person whD Hd not belong to the circle who hold the extrone SS views. This lottcr cannot \o submitted by ao as an affidavit since I have not yot received an answer fron the witness. Hot ever, la sk you to^itnlt it. Th3 letter is hero available in the French languapoj and I ask tho Tribunal to adnit it. ' THE ’--RESIDENT i Do I ondorstaa! thrt this lottcr was delivered to tho Secretary General of the Tribunal? DR, SERV..TIBS 1 Thj General Socrotary had this lettor handed tc mo by Lt. Garrett and asked that I translate it and thon su'mit it. THE • RESIDENT 1 I also un ’orstan! that tto lottor was roooivod without solicitation of \ny kin’j this witrvoss was unknown to ccunsol, as I understand it? DR. SSJW..TIUSI Toe, sho was unknown to r». in. H..RDT: Tour Honor, th.re are throo letters in this docunont book. One is attached to. Carl ?roo‘t Exhibit M*&er 31, one to Karl Drondt Exhibit f!uchor 37, «n’. th-n this last one .tert fierllw: *>“• lh ” case, I should like to Bake ax acplleetion. V. .horifi llh. to fr...rt to 7 c 1= *hl. courts or. of the n.fileel -2i05- C'-urt Be. 1 11 Jet 47-M-3-2-IHK-Ce'-k experlae&ts end should like ts have your peraissica fur thoi. Ve ere con¬ cerned with the followin,; uattor. I en speaking In this case for the defendant Dr. Buff and for the defen¬ dant Dr. Beater*, whose defense eounscl Is prevented fron attending hero be¬ cause f e derth erne, these two cefendents ere nostly Indicted bacrueo of the so-called "hitf. altitude" experlaente «n Dechaui You will oerhaps rsnooter thnt tho urosecutlon has arlntalned with reference to th.se -r.eriaent. thet the hl*h eltltudo^constltuted a torture of the exncrla.ntal subjects; thnt is. a cruel aer.uro which hes to be cCn- .. . erluc cflnn. ta»»lty. Wo .hould Ilk. to Ho* you crodf to tho contrary. Already In ny oomln* .tnt.nont. I pointed out that th... defon¬ dant. MO only rc.pon.lbl. for n part "f the »«<»““ andrlsont.1 nnnoly, for th. flr.t part, dor In* vhlch no f.tdltlM or d«o«o. to h.dth occurred Mi „ nl.o already hoy. points cut th, t th..a defendant, arc not ro.oon.ltl. for th. ieeond part of the .xporlnont., that L, not ro.pon.lhlo for th. pMt where f.tdltle. oeourrod. Durln* that part of th. .xoorln.nt., for which th... two trfenmt. M. re.oon.lhlo, th. .o-call.d hl«h altitude .lck- n... played a PMt. that la. th. c .ndltlon. th. OTP.rln.nt.1 .uhj«t 1 „... ccn.clou.n.>. when th. nlr pro.mr. doo...... nc.ordlnnly and when tovord. th. end of th.. .xp.rlo.nt th.y r.wlw. chain fron thl. uncon.dou. and where th. pr-mention nala-dn. that thl. con.«l.«.o. a torture. . cruelty, toward, th,... oxo.rlu.ntd .object., ,nd wo la thl. c... In thl. courtroon would Ilk. to pro.cnt to you thl. oxporln.nt 1= order that you, .. Ju'*.e, cm (tain a plctur. of thl. kind of exporlnent. Pa.ur.lly, feller... of the inland, « cannot trio* « 1« nrodurc chanter Into thl. eourtroon hut that redly 1. no. noe.rn.ry and f=r th. fell-win#: r««s >ns: *1. entire oxo.rln.nt. Including dr dekn..., cm h. mrrlcd out and nro.anted to you com without thl. 1» P-.ur. chmh.r. Tor thl. nuroo.c . only need n few little neccmorlc. which can ...lly L hr-wj-.t into the eour ron; nnr.ely, e.pecldly m dr Conor...! .n hottle. that L. ho.tl. cr cee.d air. with . ulxtur. of » -Uh oxy.. md hydn, ; cr.. Then .. ned , - 281 *- Ccurt So. 1 11 reb 4?-M-3-3-MC-Cc ok r.-.TZJtl breathing apparatus fc r the aouth, as one usually uses In pirolfinoe, and, thirdly, ve need a rubber breathing tube. Then ve need o can as used by air erevs, then ve need a breathing cask ns air crews use It. That Is all ve shall need here In order to present this txoerir.ent to you in nr. orderly nanner. So* the question arises: Who can be considered as an experlnental sub¬ ject here? I would surest to you that ns an experimental subject oither the defendant Ruff or the defendant Rooberg be used, ioth have aerforned theso exoerlaents on numerous eecasl.ns, on- concerned with the excerinental subject and the other one as a person in charge of the porfornance or ex^erinent. If you consider it necessary, you oould have a nodical expert present and I an sure that the expert of tho oroeecution, Dr. Aloxrndor, would be very euitnblc for he vne active in the air force. He knows these cxnorlaents and at any rate is at *11 tines available. The natters obiut which I have Just spoken. that is, the acocsecrice which are neceeeary for the experiment, oould be gained free the Aoro Xodicnl Center at Heidelberg without eny difficulty. Dr. Ruff knows thcec accessoriei ire available and I v-uld like to eay about the danger, that le, the danger for one of the Participant eubjccte, that dang-r it ontirely out of tho ouoe- tlon end the entire exnericent will only last for ten nlnutce, that it to spy, if the Tribunal attaches value to it, it could bo reported without taking uo too such tine of tho Tribunal. Vc attach value to this orcericent for the reason that v« are horo to nrove to you end offor a vory concrete crenels r.s to what tho cxoorincr.t is considered to be and. how erroneous it is to nake a eocelotoly wrong Picture of this oxeerlaent. V«, want to show you that this unconscious state, which ■tarts with th* expcrisenti-l subject and which is a completely unconscious •tntu, vc want t. show you that this unconscious state is a ccrolotoly hrro- lvss affair. The experimental subject, a few nonents p-ftcr the end of the experiaont, will regain his full consciousness and. the Tribunal can convince itself that the cxperimcnti 1 subject will l-oaedic tely be eeoable of action, the experinentrl subject will feel no pain, the experimental subject will -23C5- COUXt So. 1 11 7efc 47-H-2-*-SEK-Ccok her® no after effects of this eroerlaent whatsoever, and really the cfcaer 1- -ental subject would «• a mle n-t know et all that eoae euch exoerinent wet carried out end thet they were la fact unc ntcloue. If thlt It decouttrated h-re before your eyee, then you will convlnco y-ureelvst, at leate at far at the Dachau evperlaente and at far et rr. Buff ic-dv about then, rad you will nako a ecnolotely different and e very objective picture of thlt affair. Kr. rretldtr.t, I th.uld like tc atk the Tribunal to contlder thlt, ay or jposal, during the next few day* and then lot ut have their dec It lea, eo that perheps la agreement with Dr. Alexander, perhaoa we could nrenare thlt procodure and for thlt reason, kr. President, I allowed aytelf to aake thlt application at thlt tlno although the eaeet of Ruff and Roaberg any only be trpedted to dtoe un in-. few ..dee, and that 1. all that I have to e«y to you. -2306- 11 Fob 47-25R-4-1-Gross-(AX) COURT I TH2 PRESIDENT: Doctor, would It bo your purpose to con¬ sider those human subjects ns volunt :ry or Involuntary ex¬ perimental subjects? * DR. SLUTER: This question with reference to those experiments can only bo considered In a sound line because If we are concerned with experiments that entail no ^aln nor any dioaivnntAgo for the experimental subjects then, according to ny opinion, one could never consider theao experiments as crimes against humanity for an unconscious stato which Is not felt by the experimental subject and bocauao of which he fools no pains whatsoever. This according to our opinion, doos notpprosont a orlmo against humanity but, in my opinion, the question of voluntary naturo had to bo considorod. And, If prlsonoro at Dachau had known and soon how harnloas thoeo experiments were, and I mean tho oneo Dr. Ruff and Dr. Romberg carried out, then I am suro they had no misgivings whatsoovor to put themsolvos at our dis¬ posal booauso carrying out thoso oxporlmonts constituted no danger whatsoovor. THE PRESIDENT: Can you say that thooe human experimen¬ tal subjects whom you want to produco here for demonstration nro in tho same physical condition that thoso oxporlmontal subJoecs at Daohau wore in? DR. SAJT2R: I cannot say anything In that connection sim¬ ply because I do not know. Those persons, and I moan tho ones Dr. Ruff 6aw when ho onco visited Dachau, wore as far as ho could Judge in a proper physical condition and wore well nourished. JUDOS SSBRING: If t'neso experiments were permitted would It be your purpose ns far as you could to slmulato 2807 11 Feb 47-4-1-2BH-Gross-', AX) COURT I conditions at 68,000 feet altitude as charged In the indict¬ ment? DR. SAUT2R: Yos, quite. The experiments, even without tho chanbor, will be carried out in the same manner and In the same conditions as Dr. Ruff carried them out on hlm- solf and on his voluntary collaborators as numerous times. The conditions are qulto the same and, theroforo, tho effoct will be tho same and, therefore, you will convlnco yoursel- voe that hero ono could not speak of torture or a crime against humanity. That la something we want to prove to you booauao wo maintain tho point 2807a 11 Fob 47-23B-4-2-Gross- (AX) COURT I of vlsjw that If the J u dgcs can see something for thomsolv- 08 then they can better understand it. JUDGE S£BRING: You say It would slnulato conditions as they would exist at 68,000 foot altitude as charged in the Indietaent? DR. SAUTES: Absolutely. Absolutely. Sxnotly the samo and the experts will confirm that to you. If x thnt wero not the oaso, gentlemen of the Tribunal, thon we would not nako such an application. Vo are only making that ippllca¬ tion for the purposo booauso wo know that the systom will bo exactly the same as thoy aro during experiments in that high altitude. THE PRESIDENT: The Tribunal will tako counsel'o sugges¬ tion undor oonsldoration and will adviso counsel in a short tlmo as to the ruling of the Tribunal on the mattor. DR. S.JJTER: Thank you very ouoh, Mr. Prooidont. MR. KcHANST: I might say Just a fow words conoornlng the proposal mndo by Dr. Sauter. Prosooutlon objoote largoly booauso we don't think it will prove anything. ^ I understand it. Dr. Sautor proposes simply to show that during the oourfo of altitude sicknoss, whloh results during tho oourao of certain low chamber experiments, the exporlmental subJoet undergoes no physical pain or suffering. As I understand that, based on tho supposition that tho experimental person blacks out or loses consciousness within tho space of a fow seconds of tlno, I think there is no doubt that 6ueh persons do show expressions of pain and reactions of pain, such as scroanlng, etc. I take it Dr. Sautor is trying to prove that in spite of that tho subjects undergo no physical suffering. I think tho simple way to take care of aich an issuo, from the 2808 11 Fob 47-ZBH-4-2-Gross- (AS) COURT I point of view of the dofenao, Is to obtain affidavits from properly qualified exports who have oonducted and undorgono suoh exponents. Certainly th ro aro «corloan Authorities avallablo at Holdolborg Aero nodical Centor without the noooo- slty of conducting experimentsJn this Court Room, Sooondly, as the Tribunal ltsolf has obsorved, both Ruff and Romberg havo undorgono a largo number of high nltltude x experiments, tho result of that bolng 2808a 11 Fab 47-3BH—i-^-Gposa-(AK) COJRT I they havo galnod certain altitude tolerance, as I understand It, So, qQlte clearly, the experimental subjects, I don't % think, could be ooaparod with Ruff and Romberg, that le, the experimental subjects actually used at Dachau. Furthermore, whllo I am not an export on those matters, I undorstq^d tho question of pain depends quite largely on tho physical con¬ dition of tho subject. For example; if tho experimental sub¬ ject has a diseased Eustachian tube, which 1 understand Is In tho naturo of a passage to the middle oar, If that tube Is blookod so that the subject Is unable to adjust the pressure In tho Inner oar, to that ere itod externally, tho.n very severe pain is apt to result. Unloss defonso is prepared to assort and establish that they su-.de examinations on tho subjoota used at Dachau with respoct to the propor function¬ ing of tho Suatnchlon tube I don'X soe that tho demonstration proposed horo would really provo at all that tho subjects thoy used thero did not suffor. I object to tho above boo au so of the cumbersome and unnecessary manner in which to prove a rolatlvoly slnplo lssuo slnco In either case tho ansvor to tho quostlon of pain and sufforlng Is based on a numbor of assumptions, namely, physical ocnditlon of tho subjoot and the clrcumstoncos .ndor which thoy woro carried out. Xcroovor, I would bo quito at a loos myself to urdor-' stand what was happening during the course of tho exporlaont and to interpret It and I believe It would bo bettor to have an expert do that for the Tribunal. For examplo, If Dr. Ruff suddenly lot out a piercing scream I would assumo ho was suf¬ forlng pain. Howevor, after the experiment Is over he contends he was In an unconscious state and didn't feel a thing and the screaming was completely Involuntary. Thoso aro all ques- 2809 11 Fob 47-ZBH-4-.‘'-Grcss-(.C<) COURT I tlons which could bettor bo detorained by on export than by tho demonstration whloh has boon suggested. OR. SA'TER: Hr. President, any I Just nake a fow short reaarks on that question. « nunbor of collaborators of Dr. Ruff have alroady subalttoe* affidavits to us. Mostly they wore nado from thoir own initiative, not at our roquost. At tho proper tlao I shall submit tho so affidavits. Naturally wo havo no objection whatcoov * that an export, for Instance 2809a 11 Fob 47-SBH-4-4-Grose-(AX) COURT I somebody from Holdelborg, would bo consulted on thnt ques¬ tion. On my own part I askod two fcorlcan scientists who wore active at Heidelberg to answor questionnaires. Unfortu¬ nately, I havo not yo t rocolvod thorn. Tho Prosecution attaohos a special Importance to the physical condltlorvof the experimental subjects and, as an example, statos that an experimental subject..., x THE PRESIDENT: Counsel, I think tho Tribunal under¬ stands counsel's position In tho anttor without furthor onlargomont on tho subjoct. I do not think furthor argumont or statement on tho part of oounsol will onllghton tho Tribunal any furthor as to tho matter which oounsol has already statod which will bo glvon duo consideration by tho Tribunal. DR. S.JJTER: Very woll. Thank you vory much. DR. NELTE: (Counsol for tho dofondant Handlosor): Hr. Prosldont, ^ontlomon of tho Tribunal, beforo I start my sub¬ mission of ovldonoo, I should llko to say tho following and ask for your decision: During tho sosslon of tho *lst of January, Mr. McHanoy, prompts- by the High Tribunal, doolared hlQSOlf vory kindly roady to compile facts and ovldonoo In trial briefs, upon which tho Prosocutlon bases their indictment against tho individual defondants. 1'ho record of the transcript of tho *lst of January, unfortunately. Is not available to mo. Howovor, the Tribunal will remember this event and will also romember tho promise that up to Monday, that Is tho beginning of Brandt's submission of evidence, all tho trial brlofs against 3randt would be submitted. Up to this present date I an not yet In possession of such one Indictment against the defendant Handloser. u job 47-*i-?J3-5-l-Iesssr -ourt HO. 1 It is tho first privilo.o of a dofoniact and an urgent prerequisite for ilc lofonao that ho know® OoaizJt -hat concroto assertions ho has tc dofonl iiieelf. Tto Infiictoant against Pr-fossor Honliosor is basod upon tho respon¬ sibility which eriaos or which should arise fra. his official positions. Tho Tjitunal and tho Prosooution aro aware, fro.. oponin; stntorant, that thoro oro no coneroto facts available) gainst tho defendant Knadlosor. I havo on- ioevorod free doouuonta, toatlcony, witnoaaoa, and tho presentation of tho : rosocutlon, to find out hew and bocrusa of what facta tho possibility w-uld griao that a roapmsi'oilitjr c uld eocur in connection with his p-sition ns Chiof tho Uodical Sorricos. In s-'ito of hard labor I did not succood in 'India: 'ut any such nooslMo rolati-.nship fra. thoso facts. Tho prosocution paosod tho indlot-.jnt against tho dofonl ant l^ndlooor or,.-rather, withdrew tho indictment OoQlaat tho dofon'ant Hondloser on account of hi oh altitudo jxporL-oats. In rdor to clarlfj tfcla na..->r I ah.uld liko to point out that thoro ia a coao whloh ia oron ..uoh clour jt than tho o^so of hi (J h altitude oxporL.onts and that is tho ccoo of tho ;.alarla oxporlrenta. r.a dofondant Honll.'wor is now Vofcxo tho bo.lnuinc of auVx-iaslon of ovilonco on his bohnlf and I ir. n.t 'ey what I oc to oak hiu on tho witnoas stand oni what individual points ho is V- spook ob^ut and I should thoroforo bo .rato.ul if tho rr-.socution u uld at to whothur, tn inat.eaco, thoy oointnin tho indictment against tho doferad-nt Handlosor on tho participation and particular rosp nuibllltj -f rsalcrin an.rUn b, If yos, I should llko to eoh you t- ur.o tho roaoeutl'h to ^lvo us tho concroto f-ett on which it bneos this responsibility. If, on tho othor hand, tho -r-socuti'n nrlll not oanply •rtth this ->rreoduro, I w-uld bo f-rcod to request tho Trlbun-1 for a decision that tho indictcoQt atilnst Professor Honilosor, becauco tf participation and lersrnol r-spcnai v ilit7 zz. -alaria oxpori onto, bo withdrawn. 13. !*.C lfcjr It plonso tho Tribunal. I w uld lika acr.ln to point :ut to dofonso c unaol that thoro is r.e question in this o-.se of iis;4ssinc any c unt -r any pcra,.raph in tho iallotruct. Handles .r has boon charnel, as havo til tho defendants, with participating in nodical axpori-en;s up c mv luntcry bian subjects, which experiments resulted i;: ..uidjra, tortures, Inhumane tront- JBt, otc., waich constitute war crimes and cri.es oddest humanity. 3y way f ttomple wo cl tod - 2611 - 11 Fob 47-H-?JC~5-2-Lessor-t.JC) COURT I certain spcolflc experiments and alleged In one Instance or another that tho particular dofondont was concerned with thoso. I do not think 4.t is incumbent upon tho prosooutlon to now go through and produce proclsoly for tho bonoflt of dofenso counsol. Its ovidonco on eaoh such particularltod experiment. Tho count stands If wo make proof on ono^expor- lmont as particularised in the indictment. Now, as a natter of fact, wo have tried to slnpllfy the isouo and to ollmlnato from oonoldor itlon certain experiments on tho pa*t of somo of tho dofond/ints. tfo havo not ohoson to dlsnlss tho malaria oxporlnent or to remove it as on issue against Handlosor for tho ronson that tho experiments centinuod ovor such a long period of tlno and were oarrled on on a rathor substan¬ tial sonlo; during tho whole porlod of that tlno tho dofon¬ dant Handleser was Chief of tho Army r.odioal Sorvioo of tho Wohmaoht. It is the prooocution's position that by showing a knowledge of nodical oxporlaonts on Involuntary human subjects, plus his position of very substantial rcononolblli- ty—physiolan of the hood of tho nedioal sorvlcos of the nllltary sootor—that a Judgnont of guilty con bo prodlontod upon tho malaria oxporluonto ovon though ho hlnsolf person¬ ally did not lnfoct any one of tho experimental subjects and tho like.In any ovont, I cannot soe that is burdonlng tho dofenso in any mannor whatsoovor not to ronovo tho malaria oxpGrInonts fron the indictment as charged sgalr.st Handlosor. Tho prosecution has cortalnly not elaborated that point in its pro8ontatlcn against Handlosor. I should think that all *o lefonsv. counsel would havo to do is ack him "Do you know anything about it" and “Did you participate in then in any manner whatsoever?■ The prosecution will be quite rank with • • tho Tribunal that if his part in tho malaria experlnonts was 2812 11 Fab 47-K-FJC-*5-2-Lesser- («X) COURT I the only thing in tho caaa I should think that we had a vary weak case against tha defendant Handloser. But for reasons which are satisfactory to tha prosecution, wc do not find It desirable to remove tho malaria experiments as an Issue igilnst him. They want on, as I recall, from 1941 until 1945, and wero carried out on from upwards of 1300 poople, so wo don't ohooso to remove that as an issue now. I don't sea that it is any burden to the defendant and II:. don't think that there Is any reo.ulrer.ont that wo treat it 2312a 11 Fob ■?-V.- FJG-5--IiCsb or-1) COURT I as a notion to diaries, booauso there la other substantial evldonce concerning the defendant Handloser's participation' in nodical oxporlr.oata on involuntary subjects, which is the charge in Paragraph 6 of Count Two and it la not to bo expoct- od that the particular setup in the sub-paragraph are to bo divided up and viewed as anyunlng in the naturo of^sopnrate counts or separate charges. Thoso are simply particulars vhioh we gave. The Prosecution is sorry that we have been unable to prepare briefs on oaoh Individual ns wo had hoped to do. The Tribunal will understand that wo have * attorneys working on this oaso and 2 of us are in oourt substantially all day so it is rather much of a burden, in addition, to got up anything in the nature of a woll preparod brief, wo will do that aa fast as wo oan but it is not moving as rapidly as wo hoped. 3ut I ask that dofonso counsol for Handlooor oxpo dito natters anl procood with his oasu. I do not think ho lo being imposed upon In any way. TH£ PR23IDSNT: The ootlon of dofondant Handloeor to dismiss tho specification lr. connection with the malaria experiments is donled without prcjuilce for ronowing tho notion at tho close of the case when such notions nay be nado .and considered In tho light of all tho evldonoe. DR. WiLTS: Hr. President, I have yet another oonplaint. Yosturdny nornlng the marshal gave no a list of the witnesses whoa I named and who wore approved by the High Tribunal. On that list were tho names of Schmidt-3ruookon and Hartlebon, and it was stated there that they wor^ in prison. I asked that those two witnesses ccne tc no last night for a conference. Tho security officer stated to ne that after to had telephoned tho prison office ho was told th:t neithor of the witnesses 281 * 11 Feb r JC-5-Losacr- Ui..> CCUHT I wore In the prison. I oust as sun o that tho official reports 3 f too marshal ftro correct and I should ask for the assistance of the Tribunal In placing those two witnesses at ny disposal so that I bo In a position to speak to then bofore they appear on tho witness stand. A TH 2 PRESIDENT: Tho Tritunal will do anything It can to procure counsel consultation with the witnesses. Tho Tribunal has no Information concerning tho aattO'*. If ooun- 80l will request tho Dofondar.ts Information Center to procure possible Information as to the whoreabouts of the witnysjos, tojaattor will be given consideration at the earllost possible date. 281* a 11 76b *:7-Jl_7JC-:->Lo'!Sjr Omrt a-. 1 3r T- ttaffi I -• ai rt tho SU-. lesion jf U'.l-oto or. Joh-nlf of tfau fyar Chief f tho ;;o.ic-l Jorricos of tho Fcrcoo, tho l.-vot Ar..y llodic'l la: oct r -a: ^r.y Physicim, Profoes-r Dr. He^Ilosor. Ho Is :.ot inilotod \jc usj . crl ui f .uV'_-a~si storillsr.tlrn, ox jri' .ants with ^oic .n c~, It.. rois-n, fci -ltltu-lo or-orl ants, iacondiery b3;b ca;'ori:ants or enthr-vrloclcnl oxTori—oata of tho sk. AJ .-.n cllocti a. Furthor, ho is afct iaiictol tac-uao of .oirlorlrc tuborculosis efflictod Polos end • ray oti:or frets. % -^1U il F-_-6-1-Indian C.urt :• . 1 I ddl c-nfine - 73 df ta tix iiidivi-V'd. frets, as state -1 in *J.c Indictxnt ar.d I shall n t teach p;>:-n t!i so 7 .ints in re an 1 t '. Jet. n:. ir.divViial ii vile tint is raise! i dU.:a^h lx* lioRaacy, if 1 urn’, ere t ! !L c rrectlj, state! tlct«tf the Lv'tctaunt is aintained .n : 11 counts , -van tlx ir'secuti.n does n^t want t .alntnin oxyrcosly a >artici;>ati n .f rosucnsibility in tlx indi vi du al c unto. -x. . reel lent, I -..-ant yea t .cr.lt . 0 U call the x?itn.ss? . r.fcss.r Jr. .andl'.scr t vltrwss stand. X Vu. . -SIX.T: TS.» :er*atent, St- fried kandloaor, uiU trJee the uitoaor stand. r. liui'-ait, 1 sub* it Utrc« Dcottxnfe k». Hi. l c riL’. first \>c a*.: r-. il-Grai-D L.iCl S-u, r. witr.-aa, t !: ti . stand on’ testified ao f.liens: f vTiCL GSUtlJOs (1 “hat ia yur na.iw? .. Siv;fri. nandltscr. ij ill y u r-v^'-t t!in mth rJt.r cl I avaar , G , t . ..ld;:t; an.*, uniscicrit, Uxt I will s.cak the . ore truth n! rill uitiih 1 ! ..n a n tfcii... (Tlx vita.ot; rc.icatcl ts- cafi.) t::. .uLsxmrr: n.aycit *. -.m. lhlx 7 u.L. . ,.Ti h Tf j... .LIT : Q Ir. . real tent, I hav. cv‘ t.n.u f the defendant ika X-.scr, Vcer.UiX I in t qa* tc these ’ cxxr.ts 'uriiv the - vrse I .ds oxaidnaticn and I shall su's dt the. t- y u, with y:ur a.^x.-.-al. .ref-33 r handleser, jive as y ur first and lr t nax frr the record. / 11 Fc\ 1x7—^ -6-2-c-cohan C-urt il . 1 Sicfricd 1-anClcscr. 'i “hen and ttf-.ore wore you Uat? I was born n 25 -larch 11 j 5 in S cstznz near Ikxlonsoo. 3 ‘ all y.u . l£asc- toll tis s'vut ycur cducetienal career u. tc tile ti—o cf year real study? r‘r..; ld?0 until 1 visits', tlx Elc.xnt-ry Sen. 1 i e-nz. la the at toon cf 199U I -ent t. the Ku-.anist Sic.ndary sea X ia K.nst'nz, uhiek - visit- a t l.rrch 1503. In l-arch 1J03 I undo ny mtriculsti n. % ••lor 'id y a stu'y .wCldnc? .. ->urin tlo lost yeera :f y .cri.-l at tl*. Soccniary Scliecl, I a or.t y vacation, tiblch lasted f r thro.- ii.ntl.o will; ;\y Swiss relatives in Geneva; a brether cf y n u _r %cs t: ere whe vr.s a nan am’. a .hysician Tdth re.at; and was very ~uci. res lie trek a groat interest in re ami . hr.’ su'co.quont cccari n t; receive r. vary «’coi insight Jnt hio .radical activities; ir. Ids r.laU ;u t. : Is . atient3 mxi r. Ms ccnccpti n ab'ut bio . r fesai a. Ibis was the fact nldch influence' do Curin' the last yerr i .y .orled at the S^c ndary eel. 1 . . at cf all, locaucc a very extensive civilian -ract ice d r.- -ritb th..ir ailit-r/ 'aties. In adliti.n, tlure rre a sen f -he Sr.ttcli nC aesndcr, vli -..-.a als r illtary rielical fficer, trh: visit the 1 _litary edicl -c*. eo --riin. .dl :f t.'.ezc circuii- e 'v-..;c_s, cc. ^cially aft.r c nfcranc-s :stl :isc-.ssi ns with thx.se cntlc:xn, i--.' t. tie r-sult that they advise' :j ^ nakc .an ex.xriiicnt - rather n. t -2uIo- ii ?c I*?-:. C CUT- . . 1 : v an tx. criier.t, ut try a..:: a-.dsi n tc tho fnanus /xxlic^il A.’adt y Berlin, ‘ids won extrenely difficult, ijcaust there ttzs a [Test dcnaiid : r adaissi n and a'- ut three hundred ay; licaticnn were nadc far at cut thirty vacancies which tr-rw t;.orc ;cr year l H *cvtr, I r.as successful hcvca-liclcoa tc receive an a.^reval an' that is hrw it cane ab.ut that I started tc itu ly at tnc Academy in -orli.i, rtdeh at that tlx hold the title £ K:dsv.r «ilhcL. ..cadct^r. I its aAiittcd there as a ctudont at tho Berlin U.dvcraity in 1?03. % . Tell os ai ut y .ur .Ur/ol . ixnt as a .'nysicisn. .J£SXAl(, I bocncc dofonro district f..ysicion in Stuttgr.rt; that is, I was tho chief -edlcrd officor ir. this Vohrkrois. On the 1 st of Jam. ry 1935 I eecono Gcaerolorst, »nd or any group physician I w s eer-t to Dresden. I remained in this position until 193 d. At that time I was transferred to Vienna. still ns r.r:y group physician. In this position, ns any group physician rxd later as any physician, I worked under ?iold Karsnal list. I participated in tho campaign in Poln.d and then in tho campaign in ?r nco. 2813- 11 ycjroirj^k-SJO-S-Z-SlrjiJUCi Court l'o. 1 la October l^hG our uraj vcc sant hack to tho Sast. to Zrnkov, r.nd there on the 5th of lovciAor I rocoivod an order fron 3orlin that I was to ler.vo the trie dr./ for 3orlin since the Kodiool Inspector vns sick. On the 6th of Kovoahorj in Borlft:, I ti-lkod to Professor Vcldaonn vary briefly. £0 was 1 o«.y 1 ..» 1 .--odli toly for r snnit.»r*xe in southorn Goranny sinco ho wns v^ry seriously 111. On tho 1st of January I9UI I was appointed his successor aid also promoted to Gcn-raloberstnbsr.rst. Pro.. 19hl on I vns Arny Modical Inspector, \nd lr.tor, Chief of tho Vahr.*icht Medical Sonrico. -2519- 11 Fob 47-;..-SV-9-l-Putty-( AX) COURT I Q, You had tho position of Army physician Heorosarzt? A. Yos. Q. .That happened After tho capitulation? In 1945 until tho 21st of April I was no at Borlir.. I suddenly h id tc loavo this post slnco tho Russians voro approaching. I wont to tho Northnnd came to tho area of Flensburg. Flold Karehal Xoitol was also th^ro with a largo part of tho OK*. After the capltulat.on I *o woll as tho rost of the OK'T roportod to tho English staff and work devel¬ oped slnco I w'.s vo.*y frequently callod upon to work out a number of questions. When thu High Command of tho Kehmaoht was takon Into custody on the 2’rd of May, I romalnod whore I had boon and was still callod on by an English staff to work on furthor questions. Later an Anorloan Army doctor was also odlod to this staff. This was callod tho Control Commission OK'T North. I did work for thlo Commission which consldorod from ay point of view was to holp to tako care of tho Innumerable wounded and sick, especially of tho amputees, and to trans- for those pooplo to civilian life. This was a very close collaboration, and on the 16th of Juno the .imcrloan Colonel told no that a Gorman Hodlcal Ad¬ visory Staff w.i to bo created of about sever, to ton nodical offloors. I was to moke sugge *lons. I did so, and 6lnco a few of my nost important associates wore lr. tho South of Germany, I suggested that they be called upon. On the 2*rl of June, 1945, the English Colonel £s- critt ordered no to cono to the airfield at two o'clock with nr. escort sc that wo cculd fly to tho south together to look for these gentlemen there. Ye left at two o'clock 2820 11 Fob 47-H-SW-9-l-?utQr-(«I) COURT I and arrived lr. Munich at throe-thirty. Wo vent to tho hond- qu«rtors of tho daerloan /tTnyi thofu tho English and ;R. K2LI2: In t*rl3 ccnn.ction I suter.lt _n oxcorpt from tfco 7r.r -cdicc.1 Cccrco, Bocurnont EA-28r., ?»'* o 44 of ay docxncnt bool: 1 r.c Exhibit 2. -2823- 11 Fob 4?-M- FJ 0- 10-1- Board- («X) C0U.1T I n. Thoro was a spoolal decree, tho docree of 1942, s.-oolflcally, and ths dooroo of 1944 with the regulations pertaining to it. Jhoro was tho soat of tho various agoncloe? ... Tho soat of tho .irny Physician was at tho -«oad- quartors of tho High Co^arnd of tho ..ruy; that was usually In East Prussia. For sluunonths In 1942, It was In tho Ukraine. 2823a ii rob -:7-: :-r: c-io-3-5o-r■ (Jcurt jr. 1 ria SO-C :f tho .try ::o.'.lc 1 Ins.oc.tr-.to *ns 1- Berlin, osl the seat of tho C'ljf ' tho ::o'.lc-J. Gorrtea --S also la Berlin. Until 19-K It w-.s ir. tho julllla -f tho .jy IToIic-l Iasrootir-.to; fro:: so. tcribor 1944 on, It ••-£ 50 fcilo-otors fret; Eorlla la a acr.ll town* ^ koro woro you r*-st tho ti: <4 ?ri-.-xily at tho :~§qiquctors. 1 Thr.t -.s tho relation, fra: tho ;>olat of vicfi< of tho tL, Iwtwooa tho tlra a-oat at He-.: quart ova or. tho oao silo ani la Borlia or. V author silo? .1 Ono o all ary alao tonths of tho ti. a r.t Hor.dquprtara, r*al ‘ro-tonth * f tho tlao rt Borlia. At thor ti.ao -no oculi 3 - 3 - throo-^urjtors of tho ti;-o -.t rio-.qurrtors, rai 'no-qu-rtov cf tho tiro .t Borlin. .T». 1>. rrosi ont, in this C'ur.octl'n I sutr.lt trhlo, thr.t • is >ou: ont 1L’. 29-;., thlUt 3. This tr’ la hr- tho follcwia si, ni- fic-nco: Y-u will '.oo thoro tho r rt t .y -s’ tho lcagoat trips inayooti'n tri-n, f tho TofoiJmt H-nUoaor tc tho TRTi us thotor rf vrr, tha tiro is rlvca -a rocanttol;* -.r o-solblo. Y-u will fi::‘. it lr. t!» Dtoisjnt B r 'ie 2, 7. :o 67. ia tho caso of tho .of-aVat Hon lonor, it in is^ortTat. !2. HO F.JSY: If tho Tritunrl ;1 * •*, I will not offov iui c'ojootion t tho ci-iasl ,illty wf this lcou:^nt if it c-n bo ,-ut in without ror;!inc; ;• -..It:.out -ay llscusfliuith tho witr.oss. *h.o Trlhund will noto this 1 j nrtlaa ..:ro t:u-.u rx .-Xfidtrl*; fr .. th- uitnoss, ot-.tin,. that ho ill .rho thoeo tri s. la r'or t; shtrton tho .T'-coolia^a, If doctor Ilolto U vllllxv t ,\:t this la -Jlth ut ro%Llai it into tho roevrd, -a. - , with mt quostions f tho witness, 1 -ffor no rbjoctirnc. If ho is oia to oa,-..o ia intorra^-tir^ tho witaors r.h ut thoeo tri e or -nythiiv 3f that r.rturo, than I c .'set to its r£: laalhlllt? an tho ~r unf. it 'a nothin ro th-n etrtoL-oat tho Itr.oBs if;- ir a~ -a tho 3t*nl. ' rr ~i ?R3^I?TT: O-os thr.t rofor t' vnT ror's 1 ex oat !T . -10--i—5oa.*d- (.vC) CCU.-.T I In the s%rz.y possible at . 11 . «nd, if I may give an example, sonothlng which played n, role here. It must be emphasized that research has nothing to do with S-inltaoatllonst. Those wording in the Sanicaosdloust in the Kedloal Servloo have, on thv> whole, no opportunlty to concorn themselves with research. Hovovor, the basic work of the Sanltaeswoaon does include research. Conoornlng the extent and the manners as to how research is connected with medical matters, I night X say It is another phase. 3. How, will you ploase tell the Tribunal about your activities as .a-ay Physician? .i. I must make a distinction boSwoon tho two fields of work horo. MR. Ho H.'uJ2f: if the Tribunal pleases. I think that Doctor Helte should be admonished to try to keep to the issues of the oaso. How wo aro about tc hear a long and dotailod exposition on the exporlenooc and functions of Hooresarzt .»ray Physloinn. I aaeumo that the lofondant onoo h-ld suoh a position, but there is nothing In tho Indictment, or no issue in this case conneoted witn his activities as tho Hooreaarzt. »e have got an affidavit from the dofondant, beginning on p go *8 of your Doouaont 3ook, and it runs to pago 52. Pages -i5 to 52 all doal with tho aotlvltlos of an .uasy Physician, and only on page 52 do wo begin to hear about tho Hollcal Inspector of tho .,my. I an perfectly will¬ ing to have tho defondant explain at longth about his activ¬ ities, duties, and functions, as the Army Hodloal Inspector, but I do not think there is any necessity to hoar any groat exposition about his activities as .easy Physician with vhioh ve 2826 C*urt Sj. 1 11 leb 47-M-11-1-ZB1-Binkley Dn. h<X: Hr. President, I wn# also of the opinion thr.t the defcndrnt Knsdloaor wea not indicted aa Keerearrtt, hut the prosecution suhaittod re D.eimont EO-1766 a diary Hrldef, or «xccrpta fTcn It. I do not kr.ov the exhibit aunbcr* It wea handed la late In the proceeding*. In this dirry Ocr-eruloberatataorat Kandlosvr is sectioned four tiroes. One tlao nrny phyei- einn la ncntlcncd. That wee Dr. Cbernrxt Schrelber. ^ Q, In vfcr.t capacity wero you, witness, In the headeiurtera when you re¬ ported to Haider1 x A. I vta concocted with bin only in ny capacity aa an e.rny r.hyoician. IS. K1LTI: Mr. rresident, would you »ah the or'aecutlon whether Docuncnt 1768 la lr. conncctl .a with the defendant Eandloaer. If they do not Intend to draw any conclusion* In connection with the l&'lctoont, then I ar. ready to diapenae with the diacuaai .n of the defendant*e position aa aray phyalcian. If they do not want t< do that, then I shall hi.ro to Insist thrt this activity of hla he discussed her*. KH. KC KaE&Y; *he document cb-.ut which Dr. Salt# la new hi viiv: «ono con¬ cern contrIns certain uctriie dated Axv;u«-t 1*1, 1941, and thcrorfter. Aa I rocall, the witness becaac the a ray eedlerl inaovctor on Ji-uary 1, 1941, or seven nontha procedinc this entry. Bo thrt re it any, we don't draw ray crlr.lonl inferer.cea froo this docuoent. It aiaoly ah. we thrt the witnoao hrd aooe interest in August 1941 in typhua problems, a artter which I think ho would not docy in rny event. So, therefore, I think that wo ito nil probably orP’eed thr.t it !* unnecoatary to discuas these ectivltlee of the defendant aa ar=y physician. KZL7B: Then nay I any that oa to charges rrlain/: r,:nlnot Handloaor free Docuawnt HO-1758 the prosecution dooa not wrnt t; nrlce any charge* on this basis. Then will y.u plieao till about yvur cctitlt 7 xd 7™ functions, witness, ca arty uedicol inspector? A. T- cxplein the contrast b. tveen the activity of the rrry physician rnd the arny aedicoi inspector, I nuat any scaethin*; ouito briefly nb?ut the pray physician. In the field he bar a ssall atrff. His activity was United -2827- C.urt So. 1 11 Jet , 7 -*-ll- 2 -L£it- 31 akley entirely to taking erre of the tiff .1~», troops and was directed to a lrrgo ex¬ tent by nilitery viewpoint#. In contrast to this the Activity of the aroy nedical insocct-r was sore A A fllnifcteriel nature, I should lilte to say, n % fer as ik did not refer to the practical care cf the sick and tho v-undod in h,#citals at hoca end rt far aa it did not refer to the nodical erre of the troop* A the roplacenent arry ct hone. She i.etivity A the ^rny ohysiclan recuired oulck decisions end it wrs free of all bellrst. Tho oray nodical inspector had to deal with big profclcae. Ke hi d to efoate the foundation for evorything Aich the troops needed in the fiel' and at huso. Consequently, tho arsy nedical inspector had a big staff. He had to deal with tho ocroonnl data of all nedical officers, with organlsetloucl qu«»tione, with questions of scionco and. the care of health, with supplying Use injured and voundod, with tho nodical cere of tho prisoners of war, with nil the volunteer nedical holn, end with all the transp-rt systea for tho sick and. wounded rs far ns it was carried on on lend. The ar-y asdic-' inspector vat also cocp*lled to nalntoin nunoroua connections and contacts with other authorities or institutes or organisations at h o. o, which woro «bswlutoly nccos.-nry in cn-rying out his duties. OR. S££T1: Hr. ^resident, Mr. KcKatey has already minted this out. I hrvo a work of the defendant Hendloser. HA- 29 , Document Book 1, orge 48 . Thli work Contain* tho eehcre of work and the nesting of tho herd# of tho nodical sorvico of the erny rnd the Vehrnacht. I subnittod this work in ordor vhon cxaulnlng the wltni.se on tho stand to envc tine and also to help you by a detailed exposition to Judgv the functions of the defendant as Hooreserst, as ar.-y aediccl inspector, and «,s chief of tho Vehmccht nodical service, ns well as the nethod* of v.rk in these agencies, nvtn if tho defendant is n t indicted as Hecresarst, os rmy ohysician. he held this position and thle activity took a greet deal A his tine and his efforts and therefore I nsk that these carts of this document also be e,neldered boceuee only through tfcou can y gain a true picture A the total .ctivity of frefessor Handloser, n knovlcdgo wkieh Is ieportant in judging the further auctions as to whrt extent he had cpn.rtunities to learn A certain things or not. I ask that -2S2a- C-urt Si. 1 11 ?eb 47-K-ll-a-i»-Sleklajr this dicunent he ecccpted os Exhibit 4. An. AC EaLETi Ik* pr^eecution rs with the crecAding docuncnt will uake c: objection, with the un^ei'stan?lag thet the general statcncnt cf the wltn v . : which he hae Just given about his functione ae any ne<*icnl inspect.r, will suffice end that c.u noro ouestions he nut to fcia. I would ask, if that is satisfactory to Dr. Seltc, that he auv nut a general ouceti>n hiu about his activities as chief i tho Vehrcacht nodical eirvicoe, we oust spend a littio norc tine. 7-r tho stato-.ent which y-u nust nr.ko, I will hevo sfc.wn to y:u E cunent K0-C80 of tho srvocoutiun, Exhibit 5 of the tx ^so- cuti-n, in Decurent Book 1, page 10; also rr'oSocutlon Document BO-837, Exhibit 6 of D-Cua«r.t Book 1, page 18. - 232 ^- 11 Fob -i?-M-..-wl3-l-C20fc~(^K) COUr.T I You will also receive your diagram, to which you have sworn, on tho nodloal service of tho Yehrmnoht. 3ofore y.u explain your functions ns Chief of thj './ohrnnoht Modlonl Service I oust point out to you that the Prosooutlon alleges that in your capacity ac Chief of tho Yohraaoht «oi4oal Service you had authority and supervision of the nodical Sorvlcos of all throe branches of the 1/ohrnaoht. This Is quoted from the speech of Gi..»ral Tnylor, page 61 of the Transcript. General Taylor also says slnoe tho SS developed to an Important part of the German .irned Foroos, Handloser'a • supervision also applied to the do fondant, Gonxhon, Chief of the Modical Sorvloo of tho Vaffon S3. Furthermore, tho Prosooutlon In a document which Is not an oxhlblt, but which was given to tho Tribunal, It says: Basic facta about the Q 0 rmnn state Health System, tho Prosecution says the following about this; ■3y a docroo of 19 j 2 Hltlor appointed dofondant Hand- loser, Chief o: tho .lodlcal Sorvlco of the Yohrnaoht. In this oapaclty he coordinate! and suporvi sod the activity on the Health So.-vices of all three branches of the Wohr- naont, as well as of tho rfaffon S3. In this way hj beoamo thu Supreme Health Of floor In the military flold as Conti was in tho civilian sector." How, ylll you please comment on these decrees hero, tho decree of 19-.2, and the decree of 1944? -vs far ns the history of the origin of tho Chief of the *ieileal Sorvlco of tho tfehrnaoht la concerned, Professor. Brar.dt has Already t03tlfled. I ytn only confirm his statements and I should Hie to repeat briefly that tho occasion for the creation of tho Chief of the rfehrmacht Medical Sorvlco was tho 26*0 11 Fob 47-H-h12-1- Oook- () couar i emergency In tho winter of 1941-1942. The deoroo of 19*2; In tel8 docroo I aust onpjiaaize the Introductory sentence, which roads: "Tho utilization of pereor.r.el and natorial in the flold of tho Kedloal and Hoalth aAttera takes a coordinat¬ ed and planned dlrootlon. ■ Undor Ho. 1 It 18 also said: "That tho *my Modloal Inspectorate as Chief of tho tfohraaobt Kodloal Sdrvlcoa is coordinating all taaxa oonaon to tho Nodical Sorvlco of the tfohra iOht. ■ and so forth. 23*0 a 11 Fob ,7-x-Ji*r 12- 2- Co ole- («Z) COURT I The eaphasla was definite^' on tho porsonr.ol and material tasks, and for the soke of completeness one should real¬ ly hare added that In addition to poraonnol and material q cations, there was abovo all the just distribution of tho accomodations for the wounded andsioh. This Is no doubt included In the concept of material in oon .action with this decree. X I should 'll so like to sapbtsl&e that I did not partic¬ ipate in Its fin 1 ooaposl :lon. That was done by the OK./ and a .ny thlr.-;s «er«- changed from the draft whioh I had aub- □11tod. Thus, for cximplo, I had not requested that I shoul have a Chief of dtaff from tho Luf swiff o and an assoolato from tno Navy. ;*y application was that the ..ray Nodical Inspector will be given the tasks of a Chief of the bhrnacht Hodloal asrvloos, his working staff for the .erzy ltedloal Inspectorate. It did not do ne any good to have this Chief of Staff and this man fre i tho Navy who were In no position when tho tasks of all parts of tho .cht woro coordinated to do any ooaprehenBivo work horo. In offect, they primarily mado the work more difficult since there were thus two Chiefs of Staff, enu from the .iroy Mouloal Inspectorate and one of tee Chief of the 7ohrmaoht kedloal aervloe. On the side of tho .*roy hodloal Inspectorate there wore all of them workurs. On the sluo of the Chief of tno ifehrnaoht, Kodioal Sorvloo or his Chlof of Staff thor~ was only one person, a r.odloal officer from the Navy. I omphaslre this bocauoo It forms the basis for further conslloratlons. Now, if it Is a question of whlcn work th.. new chief of thj 7ohrmncht Holloa Scrvlco at- t exod first, this tiovelopod from two points of view, first, urgency, and second, the point of least resist moo. Cno must understand that it is very difficult with a newly created 2*31 11 Fob •»?->.-;,.^l2-'-Cooic-US) COURT I ngonoy to Incorporate one's self Into the activities of the old branches of the 7ahrnht. Consequently, the first things that wore undertaken aro work dealing with personnel .nd tho oorjaltQent of personnel. % 88^1a LI Feb. 47 -41-12-U-PKP- Cook Court No. 1 Tfca winter of 1941 - 1942 was not only the occasion but also a very ?ood cxocplo. The tutorial work, that was the field where there was the le:st difficulty end least opposition to bo - .ctec, but ir. this field too, as can be proved, it took cm your untiil *« hed core or loss ccccopliahed wtet had ’> dear.ndod of the Chief of the Vehroacht Uodicnl Service. I oust at this point describe the relation with the various branches of th- '..ehrcacht. I stall skip the laffen SS, bectuso it was not very iaporfcant. Wo tave heard th; t in the year 1942 when the Cniof of the Wchrr.acht L'cdical Service <11 established tho Waff-n SS htd about four divisions. At tfte end of the war it had thirty or thirty-six 'nd since tho Chiof of the '.-ohmeont ldodicnl Service doalt only with tht front divisions, that is the four divisions of tho 1'affcn SS, this h*d no iaporUnt role in tho fr _»-work of thb whole tning, but it was socn shewn ttat tU Waffon SS insisted strictly tta the Chiof of the Wohrancnt Uedic&l Service was cavtt^Rt oruy concerning those divisions of the Waffon SS which w-ru cocnittod to the Wehrnocht. They refused any interforonco boyorvi those divisions. Nothin; was changed in this relationship when tho nuabor ef divisions of thu :>rr.n SS inercuod in the course of tho years. Whet was tho grentost burden to th. Chiof :f the Wohraachfc ilodic-l Service in tho following tine was tho clrcuost-r.cv tint tho \>cffon SS always approached tho Chiof of th* Wehmacht Medical Service with deoands. This roforru primarily to doctors, but also dentists end other personnel. The Chiof of tho i.ehmacht Itedical Service was in no position to decide whetbor he snould lot thus n've their personnel or not. The dosiod was nedo with the explanation that the Fuehrer \r a ordered sc ;nd so aany divisions to •'o set up, *nd h # c at tho IMM tiae issuer the order that tn* Chiof of the Wohrcncht Uodical Service is to sake tho rx,c.osry personnel r valla bio. TIE f?.Sbl;El-7: It is tic*. for tho Court to recess. The Tribunal will recess until enc-thirty o'clock. (A r~cu3s was taken until 1330 hours) - 2532 - «*7 U i e t>-A-13-i-FM?—Gross (FL) Court Ko. I coascrj copy AFT3S00K SESSION (The hearing reconvened at 1330 hours, 11 February 1947.) TKJ 1ARSHAL: The Triburwl is again in session. THE FRCoIDof.T: Before proceeding with the evidence, counsel, the Tribunal desires to read a statement, an amendment to Rulos of Procedure for Military Tribunal I, 10 February 1947. "In all cases where persons are detained in the Humbeyg jail ard who have been approved by Military Tribunal as witnossoe for tho defense, it is hereby ordered ttet aftor the date of such approval by Ulitary Tribunal the following procedure shall be followed in the interview or interrogation of such witness or witnesses by either counsel for Prceo- cutiOB or Defense: 1, Counsel desiring to interview such witness shall petition the Tri¬ bunal in wrltinj, stating in general the ocooe and subject .nttcr of such interview. 2. Tho Tribunal W'.all thereupon appoint an impartial caanissionor to represent Tribunal at such interview to tho end that it shall ho or¬ derly, prepor, and judicial in character arri within tho scopo of tho pe¬ tition filed and to the further ond that thoro shall bo no atta<>t to tJirr&ss, intL-^idato, or improperly influence tho witnoss in giving his answer. 3. r/henever such a witnoss is being interviewed or interrogated in the presence of such cosaisaiorEr by counsel for eithor side, counsel for the otter side shall not be ortitlod to be prssont. 4. If in tho course alssionor that tho proper scope.hKalich ifctv^ViCwV as sot forth in tho of such intru-vioTiyshall appear to such cou- \ _ g -- _ \ proper scoj^^aUch petition thoreforo, is being exceeded by the cour^A^ conducting such in- | I '2* torviuw or that it is in any;oihor manner being ir^Sfopcrly conducted, said ccnuiasioncr shall or. behalf of tta rrib^jnal^itop said interview. 5. In such event said ccaaiisloncr shall import in writing to the - 2333 - U Fc b-A-FXP-13-l-Gross (FL) Court Ko. I Tribunal fee substantial and significant facts in relation to such in¬ terview and his reasons for having stop"x>d the saae. 6. Counsel conducting such interview may, if he so desires, proopt- ly bring before the Tribunal in writing, after giving notico to opposing ccunsa, his objections, if ary, to the action of thu conrnissionc-r, nhereupon the .residing judge of the Tribunal shall either confirm the action of tho 2333 a 11 Fcb-A-l>-2-?:~-Oross (FL) Court No. I cceciissiorv-r or direct the interview of the witness to procood r/ith such directions or li.il tat Ions as he cay order. 7. In any appeal to the Tribunal from such act of tha connisaion&r, counsel so appealing shall stale the naco of tho witness, the -coo of the defondant whon ho represents, and tho title of the cause in which . ho is acting as counsel. b. The above rroccduro shall not bo ir.torprotod as in cffoct in cases, a) whero tho witness or prospective witness has been procured by tho Prosecution but has not boon x>provod by the Tribunal as a witness for the dofense, or b) whero tho witnoss for tho (tofonso has boon procurod as such by the defense and voluntarily appears without being confined In the Nurr.bcrg ^ail." The Tribe r*l understands trtit this procedure has boon previously discussed with counsel for tho Prosecution and with counsel ior the De¬ fense and has bo .n fc*ind satisfactory to both counsels. I will file this original with tho Secretary General to bo notod in the record. Translations will be furnished defoiso counsel. I will also file with tho Secretary General the doctor's statuuent that th. defendant Obcrhauscr should be oxcuacd on account of illness. Counsel nay procood with examination of tho witnoss. DR. inLTB: •*. President, with rofororce to tho ruling of tho High Tribunal which was Just road, I should like to ask that dofonoc counsol bo permitted to sako a statement after having read this rulir . Tho translation was not such fctat we can at the .soaent sur/oy tho fur ready¬ ing effects of that ruling. I hope that the High Tribunal will perait us to present cvuntuel considerations which uould be in the intorcst of tho procoodln^a, if such suggestion can bo made. TH2 PRESIDE IT: Counsel for defense may make any presentation to the Tribunal t..at they .iay dcsir>- in connection with this ruling. Any¬ thing they nay present will be considered by the Tribunal. - 2834 - 11 Pcb-A-?S?-l>3-Groas (fL) Court So. I ER. K5l*TJi I thank you vury euch« SIEGFRIED -.IWOLOSai - Seauncd DIRECT SXAMDttTIO*: (Continued) % BY DR. MSUB: Q.- .ritncaa, nhon unding thv aarning auaaion you wero aocaldnc «><»* the * - 283* a - 11 Ftb-A-?S?-13-3-Gross (FL) Court Ko. I relationship of the Chief of the Araod Forces Uedical Service to the Waffoa-SS. Would you please continue that part of your statoixnt? A.- I was saying before that the ruling regarding pcrsonr.ol in tho oaffen-SS was uost in reference to distribution of personnel to other parts of tic Arad Fcrccs. ;.ith reference to the scttluocr.t regarding sate rial the attcr t as such; the Chief of tho Ajjied Forces liedical Service had a control agency. This central agency was at tho .lain nodi¬ cal office. This doparta-nt ted the task to cover the u^iro rood of med— ic* oquipeunt fer tte Arncd Forces and ord-r it froa a central agency and distribute it according to the strength of tho r^sp-ctlve '/onriacht branch. 11 Fcb-A-ZHL-U-l-Lcsscr(FL) Court Ho. I In tho case of tho Waff on SS difficulties resulted in that connec¬ tion. It was because only a small part of the. Waffon SS was subordinated to the fchmacht, while ert-her parts, and that includes the polico which % belonged to the Reich Physician SS, had nothing whatever to do with the •ichraacht. ’.Jhorcaa it was possible with tho Army, Navy and Air Forco to control thoir needs exactly and establish it, such a procedure was not possible in the caao of the SS, that is tho Roichsartt SS. T:» Rcichs- arzt SS not only had to cov^r neods for thi Vaffen SS bqt also for other parts of tho SS, including thj police. At no tine, not even 1944, was it possiblo to exercise an exact control and an exact distribution in connection with tho SS. Too SS <*iito clearly rofused any such Interfer¬ ence and oven ir. the year of 1944 rejected making reports to tho Chiof of tho Uohrsacht loth cal Offices about tho statu of thoir oquipment. They gave as tie reasen t.-nt the Roichsfuohrer SS hod an authority from tho F u ehror, according to which his oquipment and his orders wore only a natter for tho Rcic ha fuehrer SS to docidc. In this nnnner thoro was no control ox-rcisod with roforonco to the knffen SS ard thorc wao no such task in cawoction with material distribution end stuorlng of such distribution. I now cone to the Navy. Q.- ftjforc you continue, I should like to speak, Mr. Prosident, about tie relations nip of tto Chief of tho Araid Forcos !fadicrl Services to the Mr.ffcn SS and in that connection I should like to submit two affidavits. (fr.e affidavit mado by tho co-dofindant, Professor Dr. fru¬ gal sky, which is Docusunt HA 17 in Docirsent $*>k 2, page 28, and fur¬ thermore tho affidavit of tho defendant >r. Gcnzkcr. as Document HA 16 in Document Book 2, page 27. Both those affidavits are dooling with tto relationship of tho Chief of the Armed Forces ifcdical services to tho inf 1 en SS and I think it is o-ecssary to submit th.se affidavits in that connection since this will simplify the procedure and will confine - 2836 - 11 Fob-HM-H-1-Loseer (FL) Court No. I it to the cooploxes ani thoreBy the proceedings will bo shortened. I ask for poraission to offer these affidavits as Exhibits 5 and 6 to the High Tribunal. THE fttESlDZhT: Vhich affidavit docs counsel offer as Exliibit 5? ER. MELTS: HA 17, iocuacnt Book No. 2, page 28. Exhibit 6 will bo - 2836 a - U F c b-A-£K!I-U-2-Lfcssor (FL) Court So. I Docucont HA 16 ir. Docuncnt Book So. 2, page 27. Jr. f'cHAKSY: If the Tribunal please, it so ess to the prosecution that instead of stertcnlng the cay of^ the defendant Kandloscr, it is apt to prolong it considerably by this procodurc of bringing in all of tho evidence while tte witness Handlowr is on the stand end calling for his concert on each affidavit and other docu^nt which is going in. How a* have hero two affidw'.-its, one froo Urugowsky and one from Goniken, coirorn- ing the relationship of tho Chief of tho i/jdical Services of Cho fchr- cacht to tho Motion SS. 1 don't understand tho order of proof in bringing those (faaicents, which arc quite unrelated to tho testimony of this uit- ness, into tho proceeding while he Is testifying. I (ton't have any par¬ ticular objection to tho admissibility of the docittnts thcmselvos. It is more a question of order of proof. I think wo would g:t along much foster if ho would proceed to interrogate the witnoss, release hin for cross-examination, and tten put in his otter documents. DR. NEL7E: I bolievu that Mr. UcHaney is right and that it in a ques¬ tion of tho expediency of the subaission of evidence. I think it would bo core oxpodiont if a certain cosplux of questions is concluded »hilo submitting evidenco. I don't think it is advisable to let tho dofendnnt spook first and tten submit affidavits when submitting documents. I think that the Tribunal will gain a auch better picture about this oor- tain complex of <*icstin n s when it at tho saao time tokos Judicial notico of the documents rather than after the examination of tte defendant So • concluded. I thin!: this is a question of expediency ard I think that tte procedure as I. adopt it is in accordance with expediency. Ur. KcHANZY: I »»uld ask the Tribunal to request Dr. Nolto to stato whether or not he now plans' to read those affidavits into tho record dur¬ ing tte course of the interrogation of this witness and, further, wheth¬ er ho intends to direct any questions to the witness Handloser, based epon natters which are 3tnted in these affidavits. - 2837 - \ 11 Feb-A-SHS-L'.-2-Lesser (FL) Court Ho. I Dr. K2LT2| X sorely wanted to aufcrait ard present those affidavits *rrf should like to emphasise the nost essential points end then loavo it to the prosecution to put any questions they nay desire in connaction 11 Fob-A-tMf-14-3—lessor (FL) Court Ko. I d cement. THE PR4SDJ.T; Counwl for defendant nay proceed according to tio plAn which he .ica outlined, for tho present at least. BY Lfi. liZLTZ: Exhibit 5 is on affidavit of the co-defendant. Professor frugaicky. It refers to tho cinrt which he him so If handed to the prosecution and A which was aiiwittcd to the High Tribunal, He says: "In thj pcrphlct known as 'a-.sic Pacts about tho German State Health System' which uaa uibuitted to the Tribunal by tho Prosecution it spears as if tho Chief of tho Uchraacht liedical Service, Profosatr Handloscr, hnd directed and supervised th. ILdical Service of the Wnffen S3. "I have to stato the folio* lng: Basically and generally, tho ifcdical Service of tho Batten SS was not subordinate to tho Chief of the Y.'ohr- aacht nodical Sorvicc. There was only Halted supervision by hia, *.s»cr (FL) Court No. I n r» Institute for Typhus and Virus Research at Buchorwcld, which ■as subordinated to did not have any official connection with tho Chief of tho Ttohroacht Ifcdical Service or thu Aray Medical Inspectorate. It was neither subordinated to, nor was there any supervision by, the Chief of tfc i.ehrancht Modical Service." Dr. Gcnzkcr., in Exhibit 6, confirmed this statenent in its ontiro- ty as being correct and true. Now, Profossar, I ask you to continue describing tf^ relationship of thi Chief of tho Vehraacht Medical Service to tho various branchos of tho Armed forcos. 11 Feb-A-FJC-15-l-lScc ran (FL) Coart No. I A.- I n m come to tto Kavy. The Navy was an armed unit with special tasks art* they always lod - special existonco. Even in peace time there aere only Halted a>nnoctionsj>otwcen the Army and Mtvy. As closed as the Navy always was, it continued to be that way toward too Chief of the Wbtnacht .'fedical Service. It strictly observed its jurisdiction and whoever it was possible, they rejected, throught their Suia-cn*! Ccaanndur, any intcrferrcncc or insight of tto Chief of tto Ar ud For¬ ces lfodical Service, giving the roason that ho was only thwre for tho purpose of coordinating out uni tacks, but not in ordor to intorforc with tho sjxci&l tasks and special sphere of the Navy. Concerning tto number of nodical officers, the Chief of tho Tfchmacht Itodical Service was fully aware that to could not decree tho number of medical officers who wore in tho Kavy. Tto Kavy Airing this war, in addition to thoir tasks at son, that is within tto so-called floating units, hod a nuabor of tasks on lend, which it had to take over; to that one has to count tto anti-aircraft • system of tho ontiro wooUrn coast starting froa Norway down to Spain. Tto roods of tho Navy on medical equipment octorially differed to such on oxtont from tto ocjiipocnt ttot was needed by tto Aray that oven hero a coordination was hardly possible; that meant that tho poonibility of oxorcising influence by tto Chief of tho t/ohrancht liidical Scrvico on tto Kavy rocairod vory small. I now coco to tto Air Fcrcc. Q.- I should like to interrupt you tore. You are spooking about tho actoal facts, which rade it impossible to coordimte mutual tasks of tto Navy and tto other Arr.ed Forces branches, but I do think the High Tribunal will bo interested in knowing whether on the basis of that de¬ cree of 1942, you had the authority to assume that authority whenever the occasion arose. The Prosecution maintains cn the basis of ttot decree of 1942 you - 2340 - U F eb-A-FX-15- 1-Heehar. Court So. I had the obligation to assuae authority ana exercise control and had you not dona so, under circus stances, one could say that you neglected to be a*are of your taske aod exerciee supervisory powers in such a namer as your responsibilities should have required. - 23L0 a - U Feb-A-PJC-l5-2-4fcehan (FL) Court So. I Sow, fill you say so ne thing about hew feha authority has to be interpre¬ ted on the baais of that decree; the first thing, of course, is the au¬ thority to issue orders? % A.- Th® Chief of the no tarmac ht Hedical Service, on the basis of th> decree of 1942, did not in any passage receive the authority to issue orders and it -las not expressed in any passage; just as little was^it expressed that he ted the authority or the duty to exercise supervisory functions. On the other hand, I interpreted the decree of 1942 as it "as thought and that was cn the basis of its fornulation that in ths field of ccCrdination and adjuatawnt of personnel and equipment, I had the duty to do everything possible for the purpose of salvaging in order to aake a just coordination; that is for the purpose of saving .mterial • and equipnent. That did not present any difiicultiee with the Amy, Navy and Air Forces and I concluded that the introductionary words of the do- croo of 1942; namely, the leading of personnel and mterial direction into the various branches of the armed forcos had to bo interpreted in such a way as I did. The armed fa-cos branchos would never )avo givon tho right to tho Chief of tho Arced Forces ifadical Service to oxercisc any control in their nedical service or any supervision. Thie was novor wpressod. It wao rover said that this docrec could bo interpreted as an authority to is¬ sue orders. In addition, I should liku to state quite basically th»t it was not at aLl irtoidcd to completely leave out tho various nodical oorvico3 of tho anted forcos branches or to interfere in their independent rights. Ihat actually never took place. Just as little as it was novur intended to create such a situation wh-n introducing the Cocnissioncr Gonsrai and t^oreby cut dexm the jurisdiction of th>. Ckiof of the Lfcdical Servico of tne Aratd Forces. Q.- Did you at any tisc inspect an institute of the Navy; and you krxw there was 3uch an institute in Tuebingen? - 2841 - 11 Ftb-A-PJC-15-2-Uoohan (FL) Court Ho. I A.- In Tuobingon Uiore was tho Stodlcal Acadcoy of tho Navy. I never inspected it; I rover vias even there. Q.- Yoa, will you please continue and apeak about the relationship of tho Chief of the 'itdical Service of tho Araed Forces with tho Laft- waffo? A.- Tlu Air Forco was a young aray. At the head of tho Air Force was * - 2841 a - 11 Fcb-A-FJC-15-3-]*Jchar. (PL) Court Uo. I Geering. The Air Force whwi it mbs first created could, with right, ex¬ ploit everything tmt was available and Gooring did everything to fur- ttor that. In connection with tho Luftwaffo, we grarted that right to tho Luftwal fo and by saying Vo, I the Ar=y. There was ..o one in the Array who was not of the opinion that tho Air Force had to bo equip¬ ped better than the aray in every sphere. In peace tine and during tho building up of tho Luftwaff-, that was quite understandable, but^aftor tho kray had to boar the :ein burden during the war and that quite ob- % viously appeared to bo possible; that this difference in oquipicnt could not bo maintainod. Therefore, it was quite cloar to the Air Porco that a Chlof of the Ar-xd Forces 2Sodical Sorvico could have not other task, that he intorforod with thj nodical equipoent of tho Air Force in favor of th3 kray. It is quite urdorstandable that tho Air Force dofonded it- self against that procoduro as well and as long as it could, but bocauso of the events in tho winter of 1911 and 1912 the relationship of tho position oC tho various araies had become so obvious and the Air Forco was in a position to transfer about one hundred of th^ir radical officors % to the aray. That node it clear that further interference with tlx- Uift- waffc would bo possible. As Chief of tho ’ odical Services of tic Arraod Forces, handled this matter in such a way or.d wo cano to scoo ogre era ent in that connection. - 2812 - 11 Fcb-A-A7D-l£-i-Haloy (FT.) Court Ho. I The ate rial coordination and the stoppage of the supply channels to ttc Luftwaffe made no difficulties whatsoever. However, what rightly was con¬ sidered by the Luftwaffe as thoir property were tho tasks and the work which was in connection with Special affairs of the air fccces and in connection vdth oar field, aviation medicine. I, end the former axdical chief of tho air force and tho last acdicnl chief of tho air force, Schroedor, never had any doubt that aviation medicine and its research was a special sptoro which ecu Id not fora within tho coordination of % othur tasks and coi-ld not bo coordinated by the Chi>of of the Arnud Forces lkidical Service. Tho sane was truo in tho case of aodical research :iork of tho Navy, which often had to specialise in hygonic and special medi¬ cal resoarch with rcforenco to things peculiar to tho Navy. 1 rofer to U-Boat Hygiene, and whatever else eay bo in connection with tho aorvico * of tho Navy at sea. There nos never cny quarrel about that, because free th. vory beginning there was a clear differentiation made. Q.- Docs that conclude your description and report with roforonco to your Jurisdiction on tho basis of tho docroc of 1942? A.- I hevo yet to sent ion the Aray. Ia the case of tho Array, tho re¬ lationships were very simple, since at tho same time I was at the head of tho Ifcdieal Service of tho Army. All aired forces branclus know exact¬ ly th\t the Amy could not give any of their bos.s away, but rather tint they had to receive sane more, aid I should like to say •mMthinfc in that connection in order to clarify tho situation. At soon, point tlx. pro¬ secution put tho ouostion to a witness, "hew the nunarical rolatiohship between the Ar~«y and tho other armed forcos branches wore, nhethor air fcrco and Navy together were larger than the Ar-iy" and for that reason I should lik« to spook about these numbers in round figurus. I, as Army '4-dical Ir.s-cctor, that is during the war years of 1942 to 1944, in ngroo- acr± with 0X7, had to dual with tho stan«iart figure of the Array of 10 mil¬ lion, and thee wac the basis or. which I planixd. Iho strength of the Air li Fcb-*-AO-16-l-lfclo7 (FL) Court Ko. I Fcrco aaountoc at its peak to around two million. That was a fifth of t.*v strength of the Aray. T^o Navy probably never oxcuudod cxio—half or ooe-fowth of a ciliion. Fraa that one can oco clearly that tho Air Force in rclaticnship to th# Army was ono-fourth to thrao-fourtte, — rather ono-fiftfi to four-fifths. 11 Fub-A-AiD-16—2-*&loy (FL) Court Ho. I Q.- Ifcy I rm •uaoarizc your juristctioo on the basis of the do- cro. of 1912, first -ith referoreo to the Wohwach Branch and the Uaffon SS, on the basis of the *croe of 1912 as Chief of the Medical Services, you had not authority, is that* correct? A.- fee, that is correct. As fax r.s a coordination of -sutual spheres of sork tins striven for you and reached, you had a technical ri £ ht of giving direction* and wxercising oar.trole, is ttot correct? A*— Yc9« q._ Thirdly, the rosecrch system did not belong to this sphere, that is Fiffxo 1 of the decree of 1912? A.- Ho, rot the research systea, only nodical measures ;:hich could b- adapted to a ooordirotion. If I can give you an example, the ccmon vcccimtions r.hieb hod to bw carried through on the Army. That is the b>st value available for the rocossity of such a coordination. For in special parts of the front, more for i tanco the Army, Navy roC Air Force sere forking along side of one another, and wore committed together the type of i-jioculr.tlon as soli as the tine of innoculatlon, or a pre¬ vention, for instance in the ease of mlar&a, differ, in the cnee of all thD throe '..'ohraacht Brinehun. Of courso, that *ns such e situation nhich could not last. q._ It is clear tfrt tho prosecution did not consider that s?l:oro of rosonrch systcu, OKI I -TO roforrlnt to -.hot you hnvo just -ontlonod .Mch .o. coordination in rvf.ronc to innnocuUtlon «lth provoo vaccines. Fourth, I next to my scruthi.-® rop.niirc othur nodical . rvic of tho . woffen SS; there ,.os only o toctaioal ri s :.t of giving directives for troops .ho uorc loco tod ot Us, front, and during tho tl» of c nobat, is that correct? .nth roferurcc -l6-2-Haloy (FL) Court Bo. I ■ubcrdlmUd to the Corps Cettaarder, tho Corps Csmndor to tho tony Cooaondsr, the A;-ay Caaaandsr to the Troop Cocaandor and tho Troop C«*- nar.dor to tho SujroM Coaoan^r of tho Ar-y. In tho saac say tho subor¬ dination of n Division Physician* of such a systoa kb carried through, that is Corps Aray Physician, Troop - 28 AA a - 11 Feb-A-AID-l6-5-Sfaloy (FL) Court .So. I Aroi- Physician, Ax-ny Physician and Ar*y Ucdical Inspector. Thoro was a very clear sufcordirntion for the medical service of these divisions. But not for the rcdiccl service as such, no. Q.- .Ihy not? A.- 3ocause those divisions could not deal with nodical scrvico or ret her medical affairs, that is research, assigna^nt, and so forth. Q.- Now — Mr. NcHAi'SY: If thi Tribunal, please, I think it would be helpful if the interpreter uculd use the German word Sanitactsdionst as dis¬ tinguished foxm Sanitactswosen. I think that is the distinction the wit¬ ness is trying to do note, and when translated into Engli:.. it is uxtro- rely difficult to follui. I think if ho uould uso the words Sanitaotsdionst and Sonitoottfreson, which the witness uses, in drawing this distinction, I think it might be oasier to follow. TK. L.TSlPflETSR: I thank you, !!r. KcHancy, for this suggestion. BP. iL-XTSt It is ore of tb. most essential points to duflno tho dif¬ ference botwoen Sanitaotsdionst and Sanitaotsweson. I* will sou thr.t dvir-; tho course of th: fa-thor presortation of evidence. q._ i should like you to look at tho dccreo of August 1944, end the official directive dated tho srac day — DR. JELT•: !ir. President, you have both of those documents in your possession. G. (Cor.tinixd) - ..ould you pl-as^ ctr.W what difference thero was between the decree of 1944 rnd th- jurisdiction which you received thero nrd the decree of 1942, nne t..c tasks which* ero then in’ nded for you? in U.U decree of the year of 1944, it says -In extension of ay decree or 1942.“ n# - In the decree X 1944 it has to be pointed out that here in ad- ditior. to tho decree of 1942, it is being expressed that we arc corccrred with a stronger ability to gat ter strength in the sphere of ocdicp.l • • - 2345 - 11 F6b-A-i“n>-Kr-3-fcloy u add thooo v.orda aid take not*, of thj jou will urdor&tand whnt io being ebant. The difference • - 2845 a - 11 Feb-A-A'D-lfi-/^liloy (FL) Court 3 io. I aa regards to 1942 are very clear and obvious, and authority to issue crder- being given, which however, confines itself and limits itsolf to a technical, authority to issi» orders to the nodical chiefs of the Arood a • Ftrees Branches, Tilth reference to the h'affen SS and other unite, cs far as it deals with their activity within .e arraed ferces. 11 Feb-A-S3H-17-l-Kinabuck (FL) ' 9 t Court Ko. I Q.- la crder to enable the Tribunal to understand better, would you state what difference ther* is between authority to issue orders, as such and technical authority or authority to issue orders in tech- * nical matters? A.- An authority to issue orders as ruch presupposes a relationship of superior and subordinate; that is to say, that anyone who has a to¬ tal authority to give crders must be a superior. Then, we further have to differentiate between a total authority to issue orders and a limited • * authority as it is :*re, limited to technical matters. * Here this authority is technically limited to the Sanitaetsdionat, and ono may understand it better if I say that a medical officer always had two superiors; one military superior that was his divisional coranand- or, his regimental cousaardor, his ccrenandor or supremo compandor, and on tho other hand ho had a technical suporior that was his aray physician, division physician or regimental physician. An authority to issue ordors in technical natters it has to bo understood that tho chief of tho amod forces medical service in technical .-otters could give an ordor to tho Chief of t.'o cdical services of the Luftwaffe, but you havo to add, • without his becoming a suporior on tho strength of that authority. I shall later cent back to this superiority relationship. Tho rcxt thing was tho separation of tho personnel union botwoon • a chief of the amod forces -odical service ard tho amod forcos nodical inspector; that is, tho croation of irdcpcndcr.cc of the office of tho chiof of tho firmed forcas nodical services ar.d tho appointajr.t of a raw nodical ins¬ pector of tho ar:\y and aray physicians. In connection with that a rr,w work5 ’ staff was croatod belonging to the chief of tho armed ferecs medical services. Tho third now tldng created was tho natation in tho Fuehrer order to the offoct ttot the of*, icial directive by General Kcitol had the approval of th. Fuehrer; ti«st is to say, a sanction by the Fuehrer. - 2e47 - 11 Feb-A-£HK-i?-l-Hir»b tick (FL) Court Ko. I Q.- ten acid that you then received a row staff. In ordor to give us a picture of the situation can you toll no hew largo the staff aftor 194* was in relationship to 1 Soptcaber ,'44, as far as the budget was % cor>- * 11 Fob-A-£3H-17-2-?iinafcucfc (PL) Coirt No. I corned? A.- The chiaf of t ho sodie 1 services of tie arrnd forces had# in tho year of 1942, one =*dical officer of the Air Force, ono nodical of- fleer of th i ‘. 'ivy, on.- registration official# and a few clerks. Tho staff of the chiof of tho ccdiccl services of 1944 comprised about thirty raedi- cal officers bolontixv* to all the :fad *or^os branches, and about ae- vonty oth^r coployocs. i.- Dil that include officers of tho V off on SS? V A.- Wo, they tier officvrs of tto Any Air Force and Wavy. A suggestion of nine that a number of SS physicians wojpo to be included into that staff was roJuctcU by the Waffon SS. • i.- Ihy did you want to include .icdical officers of tho 'Waffon SS in your staff? A.- I oi phasixtd boforc that I had .o possibility to gain my in¬ sight into tho . ersonnel arc! aaurial situation of the SS, and I -.ias of tho opinion that in this nonnor 1 would aucceod in receiving ouch an insight, "hon ay suggestion was rejected this channel, of courso, tras blocked. Q.- On the atr ngth of thu decree of 1944 did cn extension with re¬ ference to the Uaffun SS arise? A.- JIo, ir. no wry at ell. The numerical relationship of the SS divi¬ sions who voro cuslttui ir. tho Wchraacr.t had b-ccnc different, I should aeroly like to correct a figure that 1 aontionod before. previously mentioned tho yoar of 1941 wher. spur.kin about divisions of tho Waffon SS, tfturo&c I should hnve spoken c'-'out 1942. In the year of 1942 thoro weru nine divisions of the Waff on 3S at the Eastern front, but with ti» decree of 1944 nothing was changed in ay relationship towards the ,/affen SS conparc-1 to the year of 1942. DP.. hWLTE: :<*•. President, in that connection I refer to the official footnote in tr>- official directives intended for tho chief of tho - 2846 - 11 Fc b-A-SBH-17-2-Hinab uck (FL) Court No. I anned forcca aodical service^ dated the th of August 1944, which is before you* Q.- In this footnote it says in thie sense tho Arafed Forces, tho % Ar«y Air Force, Nary as well as tho units of the Wcffcn SS subordinated to - 2C43 a - 11 Pob-A-£EK-17-3—Nincfcuck (FL) Court Ho. I the Vchmachfc arc the organiaation* ard unite included within the fac- work of tie TZchraachtj that is to eay, this relationship of subordination Juet ae before referred to that part of the l.aff-n SS and tiat part of thu nodical sorvico of the J.'affon SS that wee coaaitUd at the lYont? A.- Toe. THE PRSSEa^: then counsel refers to an exhibit if he would »ivc tho ntnbor of tho exhibit for tho record it would aakc xv^ronco ranch easier; :,h. 'SL7Z: This was already aentionod by no bo fere, since uc were dealing with an otfilblt of tho prosecution. Tn2 FRESLSTi I urdorstand that, but if the nunbor of the orenocu- tion exhibit wore included in tho record together with counsol'o statenont It would na!» future referoneo to that c :ibit sasc other time .aoro con¬ venient. Counsel :*.od not 550 back rnd cite those nunbera, but in tho fu¬ ture when attention is called to an exhibit alroady in evidence, if tto uiabor of tho exhibit could bo nxntionod it would faciUtato raudnetion of tha record lntor. DR. VuLTZi \lo are here concernod with Docuaont NO-227 ir. Docu-xnt Book iJuaber 1 of tho Prosecution, page lfi, nrd Echibit 6. Q.- or.»t you please continue? Extensive authorities and extensive tr.aka wore planned, ’..herein were thoy extendod? Tho staff that you non- tlor.od was intorriod to ou your working staff, interred fo: larger function a what were t:»So larger functions which you w^re to nssuw free that po¬ rt od on? A.- Those interpretations arc not ouite correct. One oust not fergot that up to that time the working staff of the chief of tho jodioal ser¬ vice of tho armed forces was givvn by th People from tho Arty Ir.coccto- ratu with roforerco to the .-ntcritj. and technical tasks that had to bo performed. The Any Jiodicai Inspectorate was an office with over t;o hund¬ red people. A. or., t.boa I ca sur. there were fifty or sixty ac ical offi- - 2349 - 11 Feb-A-i2H-17-3-Hir-abuck (FL) Court }ic. I cere. After the regulation of the year of 1$A4 that aeant a so jaratior. of the chief of the amed fcrccs Mdicol eervicee with the arny iasoec- torate, tro >er3onrol - 28J.9 a - II Peb-A-HJH-17-4-KImbuck (FL) Court Ko. I that was at the disposal up to that tine had ba be substituted by now personnel of necessity. T^at was a necessity, autooatice necessity, automatic necessity, in order to create an extensive independent staff of one's own. Q.- rfher. was .hia now decree put into effect? A.- It casn into effect with the 1st of September 1%U, and I tliink A the uonth of septerfcer 1944 passed before the individual .-radical officere arrived in Berlin free the varioue Vehrnaeht branches, ur^il thsir hous- itii was rattled, -.ost of aU until the female clerks had boen employed. One could Util say that wo started to work on the lot of October. - 2850 - 11 Feb-A-UC-13-l-Futty (FL) Court Ko. I Q.- What did you actually do on tha tails of your new tasks? A.- On the basis of ay newly-given authority of issuing orders, I ordered at first that all J.ehraacht branches and the Waffen S3 jive ne * an exact re wrt about their personal and -aterial strength at that tLne, Secondly, I started to see that tho ccitral departaonts who up to t.»at point were still nor Icing within tho fraamtork of Aray Inspectorate were to bo tp.’con ovor ana includod in tho staff of tha Chief of tho Arrr- od Froces .’odictil Service. FuTthuraoro, tho sphere of hohmscht caro o:ri X wolfaro was takon ovor from tho Arey todical Inspectorate, thm tho Do- partaent oi Voluntary Care for the Sick and basically tho oroblcn of cart for orn».ro of war. This, of courso, extended this sphere of work quite considerably. Furti»jraor.., tlxro was introduced, and this was ixi- pertant for tho -dlitary services, a central exploitation of the old; ro- ports which oao from thw variouc . chraacht branches. Q.- 1 soo under III aider this Service regulation 3 that as Chiof of tbo Medical Service of th. hehr.-acht you had tho right to insooct cor- tcin units. ..'ould you please say southing about this riyht of inspection or right of control that you started to assuie free the let of Svptc^bor 19U? 2851 - 11 i ob-A-MAA-19- 1-Bcard (FL) Court No. 1 A «- Thia right of infection is Halted to the Sanitaotsdionat Ifc- dical Service, to the tedical Unit, among others, roughly soealdnc, 0 hospitals, and xdieal troops and institutions of the Ar 1 Kfrcco, tiwt is to say, the various Ar.xd Force ararchcs. In addition to this li.Tvi- tation, the Chiof of the Wehnacht of the vdical Service nad tho ooli- gation to roort tlx reailts of such inspections to tho various branches A of tho Aracd Far cue, or rather their Cosuandcrs. And tlx re is tho fol¬ lowing to an/ in this connection: In ay capacity as liedical Inexictor of thu Aray, with the Aray, I had a unli-dted right of inspection. '.Tion- cver I did not riant to, there was no nocossity for ax to infora any ono about any intondjd inspection tour, ihirin*, tho years of offico, I also aalntnined the point of view that any inspection could only rxrvc a purpose if It corxs unexpectedly us possible, and that it uould bo com¬ pletely nonsensical if days before an intonded inspection all sorts of pmw»rvtvis w^n beire* mads so that tlx mar. wno is inspection ujuld bo satisfied, i.'ith this limitation, namely, that tto 01G. was to bo inform¬ ed, the min perpooo of such an inspection was lost. For *hoao inspoct- l .rs that uer- carried through with tho Chief of the ifohr acht liedical Service could ixvur servo tlx purposo of controlling tho medical •..•or!;a of hospitals fer tint wr.o th right and tho duty of the Ixdkal Chiefs and ’ heir subordirr.tod ag. ncios. Thu p«u*poix would have been to establish hai the hospitals oi one Armed Force arc oquipp.d with T.teriul and >r- sonnel In r-lntior. to the hospitals of .other Armed horco dra.mh. Yfixth- er this purpose could havo beer ful-iU-ci with such an inspection tour wea highly quostionatle. For example, I wanted to emphasis© particularly ti-at the Chief of the hehrsaoht lidical Service did not heve tho ri~ht to appear as a controlling person at an> branch of tho Ar ed Forces; I na sure that tho Chief cf any such branch would havo re^ctod Uds intor- ferc;:cc, riglS ly SO. The:., it -ne^irs that cost of your authority was in your capaci- - 2852 - u Fub -A-^-19-l-3card 3rd to whoo I *aa suberdinrtod aa Array Medical 2852 c - LI F-b-A- 'A4-19-2-5card (FL) Court No. I Inspector, told oc whon the question became acuto. Whon preparations were Bide in the Spring of 1944, he said I would receive a high sounding na:ro, but I would re.tun a ppor sen, end that is actually what tappciod. . Q.- Ir. the C-rvicc Regulations, I see undur Renan Kuneral II, Arabic 4a, wiiat ttt« duties of the iedical Chief o: the -hroacht will bo: "A) In thi medical scientific field uni fore -asur-s in the field of health guidance, r-soerch, ano the coabating of opidi.nics. " «ould you oloaso ~tate what cor. bo understood in that connection under y£ur Jurisdiction gone rally? •*e shell ecc— to thi research question Later. A.- Already under the old Wohraccht Mod leal Chief of 1942, and then strengthened by the Regulation of 1944, the mutual tasks in tho field of Health Leadership, and that do-e r»t only seen innoculationa, but that also includes directives and regulations for Hygiene with units, new regula¬ tions about troop Hygiene, the introduction of mutual vnccin-s, tto discussion of questions whether it would bo nocossnry to nl with tho question of I.ifluonsn, and the ccnbatin, of such a disease, am' similar questions w_n dealt with. rx.t us asaicK thnt you had in this sphere of Typhus — tho Air Fcrce res conducting research, that is to any, tudical officorc of tho Air Force were dealing with tint proble... On tho basis of your authority, would you frm. hrd th- cfcliration to interfere and to »y that you mat r.ot dual with Typhus research and Typhus experiments; that is ooncthing that is be. 1 .; oso: Inr*, d; t.et is bei.\g done in Krakew, for instr.rcc, • “rofessor oyer is working on that or somebody el3e i3 working on it. Can your jurisdiction be understood in that manner? A.- Jeit.i-r jurisdiction can bo uiderciood in that manner nor nould I rev- .an occasion to do it nor would I ,.nvo thought it correct to 11 Fcb-A-UG-19-La-&icr4 (FL) Court So. I JUDGE SSIHIliC: I wart to direct a question to the witness. BY JUDGE SucKLiGj a.-Supsocu you had learn, d, Doctor, that in those exporinonts they were being cend'X ted under the cireuistar.ees Doctor Suite has tnlbod obcut, upon nen-Gomen nationals in concentration camps without their consent, and as a coraeqixr.ee secros of them wore dicing froa the .xdical experiments. Vould that chanpj your an»er to the question? A.- If I ' ~d learned that which you have Just describe, tho first question would hrvo been in what sphere it was done, and by whom it was done. And, s ch r rxort which wool© have roached rx. as Chief of Tho Arard Forces edical Service, I would have transmitted, by official chan¬ nels to the Kcdioal Chief who was responsible for the porsons conoorrcd in the first place; that is, uith-r tho Army, fovy, or Air Force. And when tr uuvnittiiv thir report, I would have asked him to supoly me with inforanticn, ackin, hi* hew the «tur stood, whether it wo correct or Whether nc !awu anything about it. This would have ended one obligation or. ay part. The accord obligation which would tavv resulted, tut only after I ivsolved a confirartion frcn the .xdical Chief concerned, would have beer, a report to ay military suporior; that would h -c been tho Chief of OK;. And-, no doubt I would tevo aado a report to thu Couraiosionur General because in tfx Service Regulations it said that ho is to bo in- forrasd about basic utters; and by that I also understand thoso important matters. As CM f of t’..o ‘.ehra-cht Edical Service I hnd no authority tewnrd the individual aedical officers Z vould have had to turn to tho V medical chiefs of tho various branch-s of the Aruxd forces. Tho situa¬ tion world rt vc been clear in rel-tion to the Voffcn SS; namely, that any ouch report r out such happenings would have- boon reported to tho •tedical Chief of the Voffcn SS. In thu Latter case, however, thoro would lave been a difference; nasxly, that this would have been a .attor out¬ side trx sphere or the Vhoraacht, and in that conrection tills -i i-ad to work becaac so diflicult and the transportation conditions boccft. worse every day so that the connection no longer exist¬ ed which would have been rccessary in order to put the intentions of \ the ni» regulation into effect. One auat not forget that aa early aa at tho erd of 1V44 and above '11 in January and P-bruary of 1745 tho supreme agencies of tic '..ohmaehfc had gradually been troreferred /.way frcci Sorlln in part to Thuringia; and when sent free one by railroad to establish cer¬ tain contacts, or-, could count on boing mry lor several days. 9 u t that fan .ot only to r..; that heppenod to nil agencies, ns can bo proved. - 2855 - 11 Fcb-A-FJC-21-1-Cook (FL) Court Ao. I Q.- Can is it correct if I cssuce that your seir. activity fro.a tho point of vior of tf.-x ana fran the point of view of subject utter it -11 under the decree of 1942? ^ A.- Yes, one can aay that. Q.- I have hat' c diagram, a chart handed to you, which is ccllod "lfcdic'1 Affairs of tlx i.ehnaacht" and to which you have sworn. Will you please look at tlx chart and tell us what the document number is? A.- JC-2C2, Q.- It io in Document Book I of the Prosecution. Do you have anything to say about this chart which boars your signature? A.- Yes, I :?.vo seas thing to say. First, I must explain t.ia follm- irg: Tlx hoatini of this chart is m uhraacht !!odical Ser*. co (Snnitr.cta- d least). .Ihcn .r. Itavp, ifco was interrogating sx asked ao about this Kchrnr.cht . edicrl Service (S-.nitaetsdier.st) he shvwod ao o slxtch which ho had probably .icde, which contained tho ohmacht and Civilian iiattors and th- SS. I pointed out several errors and then I was given this sketch and I was to propero a now or® for the ehr*rcht, that is, for tlx Chief of the fohrncht 'udiccl Service and I did so. New I oust remark in con- tvetion with this sketch tret thu squ-.re at tho top abovu tho Chief of tlx \ehnaacht ’.fcdiccl Service assignud to the Roich Coanission-r, Profes¬ sor Br*rdt, cm or must givu the iaprvssion that hj was a superior of tin Chief of the chr.iacht a.dical Service. Ho was not. I considered it i\v duty to .sake that clear. In this connection I should like to say tint a few days later 1 was shesin ft report of jy career. I do not knewt who wrefco it. I nndo at least fifteen to twenty corrections bocauso it said a nura- ber of thirds which sinply were not true. I recall that ’t said the Gcn- sr"l Cotaaissioner, Prctfessor Dr. Brandt, nns ny .-ailitory and .xdical oj peri or. That any Icve been at tlx end of this report of ,ay career. In ay corrections I crossed out th- word "-ilitcry", and, t 1 a. ref ere, ns I can reex-oer 1- read "radical superior". In conrxction with my explanation U Fcb-A-FJC-21-1—Cook (PL) Co art :*o. I thet tM3 15 -ouU =»«*~ Iroe thi. .k>t«h thct SranSt «P^or, I .hoild nb. Uto to correct thi», if St i, triB thr.t U ,o .ord "ailltory" ...pcrlor ... cr*»od out In the report of ty corccr, hut the word «,dicrl» re. loft. 1 rould cm* thet thl. report i. i„ tho Docusunt - 2856 r. - 11 ?«.b-A-F JC-21-.;-Cook (FL) Court Ko. I Book which contains all of tto careers of ell the dofondatos. Q.- Then hai irculd you describe your relationship with Professor Karl Brardt? % A.- I would explain thet ea hns already been done hero. According to the assignments to red cocrdimted between the V.'ohrmacht end the Civ¬ ilian Sector, end that within the frcmeiiork of his duties, if itched been tfc.cesscry, could hive given =>- instructions, whether general direct¬ ives or in a specific case. I have or.e .lore thing to say about this chart. I made eoae notations which arc unfortumtely hard to read. Ttoao notes arose from tto two interrogations and acne qu.stions coreorning the request to roper© such a sketch. Thu Prosecutor lias h<.r~ roforred to a noto No. 5, which indicates a note concerning ay tophus research insti¬ tute at ICrakon, whether, to what extent end in what way, thcro was cor¬ respond enco between the Typhus Institute in Xrak-ction. 1M» . ote was mdo because I was shown a stotch, in which the research Institute at Krakow was listed un¬ der the r&hrcftCftt and the Typhus Institute in B u chenwald was listed order the SS amd a lino had been drawn between the two. Thereupon, I crossed out this line with pencil, rad said that was not right, there -.as no of¬ ficial con.«ect>on here. Ttor. I was asked specifically w to ttor they had anything to do with each ottor, and I answered as for as I kr.ou, ''no". Because of this incident, the sketch with the connecting line and tho specific question I added note ?io. 5, '.a - ell as four other notes. This was done -Iter *. direct question. I have nothing elsv to rey about this. Q.- Jbw eo ccau to another subject. You arc told responsible for actions and amissions of persons for whoa you bear tto r© span db Hit . That is what ehc indictment says. In view of tto various positions 'i.ich - 2857 - 11 Feb-A-FJC-21-2-Cook (FL) Court Sio. I you held I oust DfCm it clear what group of persons is concorrud ior wh aa you oust bocr responsibility. Pl*a»- teU ac who wore tbo toads of the agencies of tto Army UcdflSal Inspectorate and the Votttaccht ISadiccl Service, if you Hero not present at the aoat of your ager.cy? A.- The regulations on this subject state very clearly in the oaso 11 Fob-A-DJG-21-3-Cook (FL) Court r«o. I Array IbdLcal Inspector, as wo 11 as Chief of the Ara y Ifedical Service, i.x> reTcsontativ- ir. ell current business is the Chi~f of Staff. By "current business" wo now tho norar.1 official business, and in addition to t:« % corretpondonco chore arc only personal authors of a^dicnl officers *.iho aro considerably older then the Chief of Staff and have higher and apo¬ dal positions or if fundamental questions coao up of social importune , in which tto Chief of Steff is not in a position to xvfor to his absent insp-ctor end if he -mat be reached iiwaodiatuly, in such cas%3 ay chief uould have approached the oldest medical officer in tho fiold or at home, but ttot hardly happened. - 2358 - 11 F»b-A-J?-22-1-Gross (FL) Court Ko. I Q.- It will bo very important whether you ted knowledge o l certain setters precisely, including reports. Therefore, I oust ask you what was the course of the business, that happened when the anil was received in the agencies in the aoming? Hon was it handled, and Ivm: was it dia- iributcd? A.- I a tel), tala, the lldic.al Inspectorate as an exoaplc. The prSbo- dure was the saa- with tte Chief of tl«e i.ohrxacht IS^dictl Service. The V so-called "open sail", tl*j ;rdirnry anil, vos sent to a central office, th». ref&stry office, was opored by the rc^strar, and according to tho contents was sent either to tho Chief of Staff or tho heads of tho in¬ dividual departments. "Secret ratters" wore ontored in a special bool: and tho procedure differed at different tices, eith-r all sont to tin Chief of Staff or part to the Chief of Sta.i and part to the heads of doportajnts. Far "Top Secret" iapttors tlacru was a special remoter and th.se thin^ wore all sent to Ux, Chief of Staff. These things, even the "T jp Secret" clings addressed to the Array '.iadical Inspectorate or representative - tho Chief of Staff was oopewered to -pon those. Tho only things ho could not open was what was sent as "top secret" with ray nano personally without the addition of the words "or representative in office". But those w^re .ixtreordinnry cases. Q.- 1 ar. asking you tr.is becau3o I 3teuld like to lenow whother on prir^iple your Cilels of Staff know what was to coae to your attention or what did corao to your attention. A.- \Tr.t erne by anil th«y had to kn^» as I teve Just described tto procedure. The only cxcepti ns would be the f-w "top secret" lettors sent to ay personal address. C.- '..ould it not be a possible exception to bo rede for things which the registrar s^r.t directly to heads of departments? A.- Yes, that is true but tbu heads of departments again hofl the obligation to work on these matters .and, according to tte urgency, to - 2859 - 11 F.b-A-J?-22-l-Gro3 a (FL) Court Ho. I present th.a to tho Chief of Staff, either imedictcly or within a fo« days Just as tho heads of tft d-partoents who reported to &3 whan I was present first had to % 11 Fob-A-JP-22-2-Gross (FL) Court No. I fwvc reported t: sc entters to tho Chief of Staff. Th-roforo, tb.ro ruacined only cases which were, not questions of sale, but where I bad ttgdlntkn or tclles with sooeSn.. And, again or*, must distinguish bet¬ ween whether I was titr« cion, or whether there was someone with cx>. In .-at cr.scs I did not go to such talks alone. Generally there was an c;:- pert on the subject needed and, in the second place, it was ornctWl for oc to have ay adjutant with ce because telephone calls were rocoivod, etc., so that, in fprxrol, t*x: person ;>bo Went with no usually infonwd the Chief of Staff afterwards even if I did not so and even if 2 par¬ ticipated alone. If they w«re aore or less important matters then I ab¬ solutely hr.d to infom the Chief of Staff, because in ay absence Ik- had to know what was going on, what could happen, or what had been discussed. Oth-rwi*., it would not have been possible to carry on business of our office, sinco in ny absence thu people always approached ay Chief of Staff personally or by telephone. Q.- Then tho two Chiefs of Staff who will appear here aa witness oust be rble to toll us what you desired on tho one hand, and on tho other hnnd what you lesrn-d of? A.- Xcs, absolutely. Q.- It any be necessary to explain a few terns inportant for tho questioning of your competency ard your authority. A little :Mlo ago you spoke of the relationship between superiors .and aub-rdinr.too in de¬ viation fror. tho tern "authority" to issuo orders. Sinco your responsi¬ bility is dependent on this point I should like to know whothor terns like, direction, aanagoaont, etc., fbotljor they are anywhere set dam and regulated authority? A.- That can be best seen as I an to give a concrete example es¬ tablished by document. In the Docuaont Book on page Lb and 46, tho Ar¬ my Hcdical Inspector is prase rlod. Q.- I ui.r.t point out that this is document HA 28A, Exhibit fe. - 2360 - 11 Fob- ft -JF-22-2-Gross (FL) Court Ho. I Docuaunt Eook I, pa go A4. A.- T7» tcc:t spooks for itself. It seys, undor £6 "fho Ar«y Jlcui- • • cai Inapoctor is the K*.ad of ^tbc ISodicel Section of the, Her Ti,ae Ar.jy. Ho is tho - 2560 a - 11 Fob-A-JP-22-2—Gross (FL) Court Bo. I superior of the entire audical personnel of the Var tia- Arzy in ,aoci- cal aattors and he is the superior officer of all nodical units of tho . War tiau Ar.iy." % A footnote hoc been ceitted here which is contained in the ./nr ilodical ii. crec which orpin ins whet is ..eant by cedi cal personnel. It cays "nod- cal personnel include n odical officers, non-coonisaiorod officers, oflicinls of tlio Kcdiccl Sorvico, pharmacists, dentists, officials of tho Adainistretivo Service, special leaders ir. the Ucdlcal Sorvico, ard volunteer nurses." This shews clearly that thla is a superior and I oust add that under tli the follcwire io stated: "3y deans of inspection ho convinced hinsclf of the execution of his orders and of tho state of health of tho ?iold and Reserve Aray." In rogard to tl>c ri^ht of lnsowCtions it was not said that he r.oodo to ask anyone r.bou' it before hand or over, to infora any uno. Q.- Tl.en that is a clear ccso of the relationship of superior and subordinate well as the total poi^r to issue orders? A.- And, another orx> which we do not have a copy here is -txdo equal¬ ly clear - the case of the .'say physician, the Array Corps and Divisional doctors of t!~ Ar-y. In Aher branches of the Wchroacht it was tho saao. It said that they are superiors of thoir . .died personnel in question of radical servio- and they are troop superiors to nodical chiofo undor their cunoand. ;2-Lesscr (FL) Court Ho. I aician and Aroy iSodical Inspector ? I ”ill, in a nacA.nt, point out ivhat is ia^artent for -y ccs. so fret thj Prosecution does not think that I aa bringing the Arty Physician into the case unnecessarily. Amy Physi- cL-n and ! Sortie al Inspector were two functions which up until then had required ell tho services of orx U Feb-A-J?-23->Lc5Ser (FL) CviTZ Ho. I an, c high military dec tor. They wore united and a spiiero of work ncs created fr:n which I au3t assonc, without explanation, that it ties too auch for one p-rs:n ar.d wouij perhaps not give you tte opportunity to do jostico to tho reqoonsifaility which you had in this high position, ill yM pL-nsc explain this art! tell us how it was possible to fill those 2 positions and later 3 positions responsibly? «. A.- In 1939 I was in Poland. In 1910, I was in Franco. I was an Ar- oee Arzt (Arny Physician). Thus froa two s.c rs, from tWb theaters of war, I was able to fora a Judpoent about the nan' gonent of tho fxdical service and of course I also talked to their cxirades about it. I was in ttx> first ..orld *. ar, too, and I was able to a-i that wr Siire.oo Hod- IciV Coaoardcr, that was von Cumin, as full ’^dic.-l Chief raid Ocrcrnl- stabsartt of the «rcy, was in the field, r„ huadqa-rtors, and not at hfb. Ho arranged it at that tiiae s > that he was in charge of rnttors in the field hi/ass-LT and that nt hxao ho liad o representative, who was a Gonuralarzt, but ho hLoself was in charge of the dlroction of all nnttcro nt h ou and in the field. In the recent .Arid ..ar the Ar.jv Ilodical Ins¬ pector, Haldoonn, was ir. Berlin, and a Kooresnrzt woe appointed for tie Field i»r TJrt wes certainly not duo to tho desire of tho Army Ikidlcal Inspectorate ant! cy preueceso r. That was c luxetod with the ai Lit ary or¬ ganization end with the point of view tret in the Hold *vj cannot have aay ministerial people with ministerial habits. !{y predecessor, Profoo- s >r Valdnann, during tho campaign ir. Polar.d and during the campaign in Fr.’.ucc, lie wai i net in Berlin eitixr; out he led the fooling, just ac • 9 cvory:nc else did, that the pri-cry thing ar.d the nephnsis, — the first concom — was with th; troops in tho field. - 2865 - 11 Fofr-A-33B-24-l-aochan (FL) Court Ho. I If tl»7 i»ro not cared f >r properly, if things did not run right at the frxit, then no mount -f work at home die any good, Uy may in Poland, ca well as ay army in Franoe, in spite of tt* brief duration of the enra- paipis, he visited iiy arnics repeatedly. h’ow what I bocams his successor, I was imrxjdistcly confronted with the question in ftorlin, if there is a change n~M ar.d it was known that A Generalstabsarzt Ott in the very near future would give up his position, it was said, "Hew or Never." This obvious ni. .ke in org-r^zati on must bo dono away nith and therefore from ny 3»n experience, as noli as on the basis of tl» fact that from t*x first Vi rid nor rnd frw tho precod¬ ing ccapci^ns in 193° and 1940, case that decision that Goncralobcrst Frora, who was Caxundor of th; R»sorvo Army and th- Co-nsandor in Chiof jt the army von Bracchitach, that I should suggest to thorn that tho two xgenirations ah-uld bo united. First, this was to bo a simplification, • • froondly, tLw was to be saved and third, ovory possibility for friction, which f course o:dsted between the field armies and tho homo ir.y, nr.s to bo reojvod. C,.- Toon, La your opinion and in tho opinion f tlx. aray oodicrl of¬ ficers, you prose..tod tho necessity, hat is important, hare, howovur, is ttet you soy hew y.u created th- safeguards, tho -rdor to safoguard tho responsibility of aicha high officer as tho Any Ibdical Injector. Ploaso clarify your responsibility. Tix. extent of tlx duty alono, from tho point jf view of aroa al*ne, had bee cx so jrc .at as thi ter expanded tfet no one in charge, even tho Hoorcsarzt could bo ovoryw.xn.. The Army iedical Inspector at homo could not do that, everything had to be built upon the basis of the decentrali¬ zation ar.d cxi the selection of the best people as supports for the exe¬ cution of the duties on tho principle that the best men should be put in the best places. This was done at home by the selection of the 1/ekrkrcia physicians and by the promotion ar.d support of their authority and that 11 Feb-A-:3H-24-l-Iiehan (FL) Court Wo. I was done ir. tic field by the selection of arsy phys clans. l.'ner. the area became substantially rreater and the difficulty be- - 2366 &- 11 Feb-A-£3H-2A-2-iieeban (FL) Jourt No. I carae substantially greater, tto railitary agencies, on their own initia¬ tive, since they eel's in the sane position, created a new agency be¬ tween the high coxierei of the axny and the various araies - tho so-crilod % a my group coa-onds, since it could not at first be achieved that array group physician should be asai gned to those army group canr.ands. Con¬ ditions later shewed the High Coosand of the Array that this bed to bo done later and so at the end of 19U or the beginning of 1042 array group physicians, with the rank of Cereralarzt or .eneralet^bsarzt vtoro creat¬ ed, who were above the physicians of too various araios as connecting link to tto Heorcserzt and the Array Medical Inspectors. That is a tyo- Ictl exar.ile of the fact that the «:pa:.ded duties and tho expanded aroa required a new safeguard for tho execution of control and supervision and advise. I flhoull only like to add to clarify the rattor, that tho 'JohrlTOis physicians at ’:aae, I beliove with one or two exceptions, and thero noro nineteen of tnor., that thoy were all oven older than I and tliat a con¬ sider- proportion of thora had for-Mrly been ray superiors as '.iohrkrois physicians or as array group physicians ir. peace tine and that in tho field, thoy inro of tto sarau ago as I with very few oxceptiono. Thoy More can with tto rr.nl; of a Gorcralarzt ol ConorsIstabsarzt, who had roaciwd this rank only on tho basis of long oxpcrionco and fecial achiovo.snt. Thcso won not .-on uhea ono tod to watch or control. These rn.ro mn tiho guarantood *.tot thoy would do their utnost atw their best and that thoy had the reccssary experience and tto necessary ability. Q.- In connoctior. witn this policy of putting tho best non in tho most difficult posts, there had to bo added, I should like to say, tto ^ lepfelitlve activities; you r.ad to issue instructions, directives, orders, etc., was tact cr anizod in that way? A.- Do you ,xan those Amy Ca.ro Physicians? All physicians froc your point of view? - 2867 - 11 Fcb-A-23K-2A-2-}'eehar. (FL) Court Ko. I A.- Yes, of course that was done. Q.- This is wcat I should like to learn; were nuaerous instructions, directives ard orders issusd by you? 11 Feb-A-23H-2/.-3-!fcohan (rL) Court lio. I A.- Tcs, of course. Q.- I aontion this because unfortunately nc have no doeuwnte in the PrceQCulion'3 Docuaoot books bearing your signature. If such orders had not corresponded to the riles dosanded of an orderly coaaand, I ai con¬ vinced that no would have seen thea horc. I should also liko to ask you i: you knew of any si-nificant, or were there any significant violations a reported to you in connection with lnaded ssrbiLity, or the (Stucution of the nilitary .-xdical point of view or t.';_ --hical point view? A.- .‘Jo. Q.- I aa not -icrciy tweaking of the front, the doctors at tto front; I an opeakiir of at hoe*. too? A.- Yos. DR. KEL1E: !&•. President, now I want to coco to the quostion of tho consulting specialists, on the ; motions of those consulting specialists, but Goncralartz Guizcit has testified about this as a witnoss, so I be¬ lieve 1 can dispense with this matter; but in this connection I should like to present t'.K> docuajnts to the Tribunal. In the first place an o;.- cerpt froa tlx- or .edical uocrev, Vo-222, 22b and 235. This deals with tto group o; consulting physicians in tho Aroy. • THE PRESIDSI.T: In what Docunent Book arc those documents contained. DR. h’ZL'E: You will find these docu'onto in 3ook Wo. 1, 'a c 36. It is document ;!A 19, ard will be Exhibit Wo. 7, if the Tribunal accepts this docunont as ar. exhibit. THE rfcEJIUlT: Is it counsel's intention to read the doc iocnt into the record or sicply have it offered in evidence? DR. leJLiE: I ^croly want to subait it. In tho exaairetion of the witness Butzcit the contents wore already frts-ntod. It is only the lo- gal regulation of thu position which Ux consulting physicians had. THE PREuIDEilT: V^ry woll. - 2363 - U ?wb-A-2BH-24-3-:fc^han (FL) Court So. I DP.. CUB; And the rext docusent on the seat, point I subait a statc- x ent of the defendant Professor Kandlo»or on the establishment of tho consulting physicians. I shall not read this either. I cr.ly offer 2363 a - u ?c b-A-3BK—24-fcchan (?L) Court No. i it as an exhibit. It is in th« Docuaent Book Ko. 1, Pago 32. It is docu¬ ment HA 13. I ask that you accept this stateatnt of th*. defendant as Exhibit No. 3. • THE PBEolBS 7: In tho Docuaent Book I do not find Docuaont HA 13 Listed in tho index. It is in tlx. book, but not indexed. DP.. KELTS: Tho section which producod these documents loft this do- c-xnt out, but only in tho index. In tho document book itself, on Pago 32, you will .ind the. document. x THE mESIuS-T: It is in th. Docuaont 3ook. I havo it. I ins calling attention to tho fact it was emitted froa the indoc. Thoro being no objections the documents will bo admitted. Tho Tribunal :dll n«i recess until 9:30 toaomxi aorning. - 2869 Roll 4 Target 3 Volune 9 Feb. 12-19, 1947 NATIONAL ARCHIVES MICROFILM PUBLICATIONS OFFICIAL RECORD UNITED STATES MILITARY TRIBUNALS NURNBERG CASE No. 1 TRIBUNAL I U S vs KARL BRANDT at ol VOLUME 9 TRANSCRIPTS (English) 12-19 February 1947 pp. 2870-3212 ostor-JP iM 12 Court i : GOTBECTZS COPT Official transcript of the Jeerlean Kilitary Tribunal in tho nnttor of the United States of Anorica against Knrl Brandt, ot al f defendant it sitting at Suomborg, Gcranay, on 12 February 19-17, 09®» Justico Beals prosiding. 732 ILAHgUI: Persons in tho or.urtrooc will ploaao find thoir sor.ts • Tho Hon'.rablo, the Judgos of Military Tribunal 1* Military Tribunal 1 io nov ir. session* God snro tho United States of Aacrica and this hoaornblo Tribunal, Thoro will bo ordor in tho O' urtroon- A THZ P~~-S ^TT; Kr. Marshal, will y u ascertain that the dofondnnte pro all pros ant in court, N TE 1X.SHALC !’i*y it plonso Tour Hon r, all defendants aro prosont with tho oacoption of tho dofendant Obcrhauoor who is absent duo to a continuation of hor previously existing illnoss. THH rosiUBT! The Secretary General will note for tho rocord tho prosonco of all tho defendants in court with tho oxco^tion of tho doforv- dant Oborhauncr who is absent on account of illnoss as por hor physician*a cortificato. The Tribunal has considorod tho application presontod yootordoy by dofonso counaol Sauter for a dooonstration boforo tho court in connection with tho high altitude oxporlconte. Tho Tribunal has considorod tho application and tho application Is donied. Counsel ncy prococd with the cxnoinatlon. SI20FB1B3 HAH3L0S2H - Rosixsod. ZXJXXXiSZOr (Continuod) FT TR. ItELTS s Qr Profossor, you said yostordry that tho Modi cal Sonrico of tho An^y, whoso chlof nodical officer y~u woro, had to cero for tho honlth of about tor Billion nonbors of tho orcod i^rc^» clrrifj- this question I shuld like to ask you: Foe* this no an ~nl? . ^ldiorc for whose hoalth y'*u hud to cero? , w w A, So, not only soldioVs, Of theso nF^r ociKp.tcly ton nilllon thoro were included all the c bors «- acotcd vita tho Vohrr.acht including all tho aursos, all tho S ignal Corps assistants, all staff assistants. *lso tho population of tho occupiod torrltorios until tho civilian nodical authorities vexo cblo to toko over tholr caro and B’^orvision; also the prisoners of w:-r in tho oporationnl area as veil no at hone. 3. Hov nisny nodical officers, active and rosorvo, bclnngod to tho nodical oorrico of the arcy? ^ A* I can giro oxact iafomation nbfut that since I still have rocordo, docunonto, of tho 1st of Fobruary 1943. At that tl~.c th* Amy had 2,191 active nodical officors. Including tho reactivated forocrly activo offi¬ cers who were 3,242, That nakos a total of 3,433. Own thoro voro rosorvo nodical officers, 19,580; together, 25,013. On tho 1st of Fobruary 1943, and lr. tho following period too, we had the senior nodical otudonts as so- callod Folduntcraorsto; that is, assistant doctors in hospitalc and vlth tho troops. Thoso voro 1,638 at that tine. That nakos a total of nodical officers at \vco and in the field of 26,651. At this tine tho Luftwaffe had about 10.CCO physicians and dentists. Tho Vaffon SS at tho front had about 3,000 nodical officors. That nakos a total of 39,651, Unfortunately I do not have any figuros froc tho navy. This nay bo a good opportunity to nontion an official figuro which I have that is tho lost official report of tho «V including tho tino froo tho beginning of tho enrpaign on 2ussia in 1941 until 31 January 1945. Aftor this tlno it was no longor possiblo to oonpllo roports, at lonct wo did not got any roports. Tho &unbcr of dond at that tino was 2,100,000 o Tho ninbor of womdod during tho empaign in Hussia was approxinntcly 5,000,000. Tho nur.bo r of prisonors token during tho poriod of fighting was 2,500,000. This nay also bo tho appropriate opportunity to nontion tho casualties Kwng tho nodical officers. I have official figuros hero too giving insight into tho confehs of Juno to Ooconbor 1942. At tho front we had 6,048 doctors. In thoso six non tho 791 of then foil; that is, about 12.5 percent. 1,533 were wounded; that is, 25 porcont. Fron tho yoar 2971 12 7oVJi-2Z2«-&-?ogtox-JP Court 2 1943 as Azsy Itodical Inspector I should lilco to aoation that with tho disnotor of Staling ad wo lost 274 2871 (a) Court 3c. 1 12 Jeb 47-M-l-S-EEH-Fcster doctors ot -see. Vitfc the disaster of Tunis vo lest about 25C nidicel offi¬ cers. I section this because it ves cy duty as Medical Inspector to cover these lo'ses, to fill these geps, tad this ves an especially difficult end expensive field of vork for so. TFs. eTJ. SI2XST: Just & accent, counsel. I neglected to renind the wit¬ ness that he ia still under oeth, having been svurn yesterday. Counsel nay oroceed. 12 ?eb-tf-4UA-2-l~I7 innhuck-JP Court I As chief of the Vohmacht Modi cal Sorvico you woro tho highost nodlcd officer la the Vofcrracht. Iho prosecution has concluded froa this position en organisational responsibility for tho •tttlonst tho allowed actions of or/ nodical officers* I should like to ask yru, woro you as chi of of tho Vfohrnncht Modi cal % Scrvico responsible for tho actions of all nodical officers of tho Vohmacht? A* I aust on over this quostion in this gcnoral fom^with no. I was responsible for tho Individual nodical officer, for what ho did on epoclflc ordors free no, or what ho did as tho result of gonoral ordors which I had given, nothing olto* Q. ITow, It Is possible that without such an order or such gonorol x^rdors a nodical offlcor undor your ooacaad in oxocutlor. of his profosolon sight coii.lt a pualshablo action. Must you bo rosponolblo for ItT \ If I loam off*clall/ or in any othor way of this punishnblo action and if I did not clou up tho situation, and If nocooonry f tako stops against It, thon certainly a chargo could bo nndo against no. Q. Sow, I should llko to exhaust ell possibilities in connection with your responsibility. Vhat about tho ohargo of inadoquato ouparvlolon in this connection? A. Tostordoy I attenptod to oxplaln tho relationship and tho poworo of a ouporior and this lncludos tho factor of supervision, but it Was not understood end It cannot bo undorstood to norn that a highor ouprono supporter Who is rosponsiblo for all thootors of war and for tho boaolnnd* that ho cen oxorcioo supervision over over:’ lndlvlducl subordinate. That is lu-possiblo and that is not possible anywhere in tho world in nllitary or Civilian lifo, and It c-nnot bo dorandod. Mjr supervision, for cctavplo, as Amy Hodical Inspector appliod to tho amy group physicians, to tho Vchrkrois physicians, rad to tho cocnanding officorc of the institutes and organisations diroctly under ny comnnd* I will noniion ar. oxnnplo. A nodical officer with tho troops or in a hospital, just like a soldier in tho c-npany or battalion, is undor tho 2873 12 Jefa 47-*J &A- 2 - 2 -«iiiabuck Court Ho. 1 supervision of his immediate superior; that is, the chief physician in a hospital and above hia the camandins officer of the nodical section, end then tho .'ehrkrais physician, but that goes very far. 0 Another example; Stabsarxt Dohner., who has been nantionod repeatedly, ..-as ono of the 26,500 o-'dic^l officers under comand. The commanding officer of tho training group C is rcs.xnsitlo for supervising hia and in addition, tho coanandin.’ officer of the -ilitary -odical Acadonjr* lihat I said quite generally, of course, applies. If in any way I hod^lcaraod of anything about on individual ncdicel officer wno was far away from 30 it would havo been duty without consideration of tfio many superiors botwoon us to take up tho ease to sue that it was cleared up end to take tfio nocossary stops. Q IJow, I cojq to anothor chapter of ny examination. As you know, tho individual charges which aro raisod against you concern experiments connected with research. Tho prosecution alleges that you wore not diroctly connected, but that, bccauso of your position as Arty ;odical Inspoctor and chief of tho T/ohrcacht .cdical Sorvico you woro connected with tho oxperiaonts which arc called illegal, and that you havo special responsibility. Does tho fiold of medical rosoirch boloni; to tho nodical natters? A Tos, research is connected with any health service. Q Is there a special military medical scionco? A Yes, thero is. It i3 called rllitary aodioino, or '*> use tho expression, "irohnodisin", for it. If I aa to explain that briefly, ex¬ plain it to this group, I raist make a co:iparison. Imagine a big strong treo with widespread roots, with a strong trunk, and with many branches and twigs. The roots and the trunk which give strength and which give lifo to the whole treo, that i3 general aodicino. And the branches and tho tirigs are the nany individual fields which aro larger or smaller, which aro tho specialties. Cto- such branch is military aodicino, under a:dicine in general. This branch is an indispensable and integral part of uidicinc as a whole. It has a certain life of its own which, however, is dependent 12 “eb U7-a-v-•-2-3-riin-buck (H) Court ?Jo. 1 on the strength end the influence which it gets from the roots -nd the trunk, -nd it will newer h?ve the idee of dis associations itself fro= this 'trcrk because that would take aw.»y the source of its lifo. This br-nch again. h«e branches rnd le-ves -nd fruit, -nd in the lifo % of this tree it gives the whole tree » great de*l of nourishment. That is how one mat mdenrteod xllit-iy B3dicine ra r -n integral p»rt of the whole thing which grows out of general medicine ~nd receives an :noraous amount from it, but by way of gratitude in « sense rnd as ■ natural consequsr.ee gives it a mrsber of suggestions *ivd experiences which only military medicine c-n collect. Military medicine Is determined b-» the character of sdlitaiy life ■nd the ■ilit-ry on he re. I -ust sum th-t un briefly. I c-n give only • few ex-roles by w*y of exultation. We h-ve definite military diseases, if I a ay cention a few surgio'1 cnas. There -ro the woll knewn dlse-scs of the foot which soldiers acquire when aarohing. The foot swells. Often there is • fr-cture which is hard to recognise, of » act-tarsal bone. In "11 countries special -ttention was devotsd to this disc-se. It has -lw.-ys be»n said the r«n we-pon of tho infantryn-n Is not his gun; it his his foet. "nd the great majority of the Gcra-n soldiers in the second World A-r were not driven but were dependent on their feet. May I bring an example fron internal medicine? We soo-k of the dangers of the spec!si surroundings of tho case eccerodatlons of soldiers which formerly had existed only in the -rey. This, of course, brings the dangers of the transfer of diseases to a much greater extent th-n in civilly Ilfs. For the scientific senate I worked on epidemic rer.lngltis. ’t all times we had c-ses of this frequently fatal diac-oc. I went through all the literature on th» subject, and I sew th-t in cany countries military medicine was especially interested in it 12 Feb 47-ir-S-'-3-l-Putty Court Fo. 1 Ike English ir. India in their barracks often had actual epidemics of meningitis. They found thrt the bacteria which cauced this dis¬ ease exist everywhere and that tl irtv — forty — fifty porcent of the people in their nasal passages havo theco bacteria., Only under special circunst nces incases of colds, special physical offorts such as marching do i l ese bacteria suddenly got tie upper hand, as it w ore, becomo donjorous, and apparently healthy soldiers fall down and if thoy aro unlucky they are dead in twenty-four ol* forty-eight hours. -art was the beginning of a loi corios of oxperimonts which fin¬ ally lod to varloue measures with wi ich the military doctor is familiar w! ich aro still In use today, the most si pie one to koop the pooplo separated so that during sloop tho broath dooc not affoct thoir noi.rh.bor. Q. Professor, may I interrupt you. You havo alrondy givon two' oxamplos of typical military modic.no, I boliovo that a p .cturo has boon given to tl o Tribunal of Mb. t it is about. r 1 at I an intorost- od in hero in conr.oction *ri th the trial is tlis: was military nodicinc a typically Goiwn, I nitf.t nay, nilit. ristic phonomona, or did tlis military nodicinc exist ov rywhmrc? A. Tfccro w. s military medicine in all covntrl s whorovor thoro was an army. I personally had tl.o inprocoion booauso in IPS 6 rftor tho first World Ift.r a Goman nodical aologa.tion consisting of ono nodical officor of tho army, tl o navy .»r.d tho Luftwaffo was undor ray direction which was invitod to tho International Congrats in Irus- 80 l 8 . c. *ic th t only c Congros? or u a It a socioty, a. pornanont soc- ioty? ... The basis for it \.\.s a pomanont organisation, an intorm.tion- al organization w*.icl included .bout fifty countrios wl ich had a per¬ manent office ir. Hors taal no r Brussels under tho direction of tho Bolgiums. 2*74 12 Fob 47- -S'-3-2-Putty Court No. 1 r.. I think it wcs ftt Liogc? A. Toe, t -loco. Every two years thoao nllitrry doctors hr.d r. ntictir.g, I attoneod the aooting ir. Buchrrorfc. 3'rr.ony hr.d bocono.a ucr.bcr 03 -in aftor the first orld riz r althcur:! I was still a guost r.t Brussels, rad tho lr.st "ongrerr in 1939 w; = in arhington. It tl.oeo acetings or Congress quostlors nv.ro discus sod which *. 7 uro important fer illltary nodicino in pee.co timo and J.I 30 rorpoct to a pcrsiblo war, and I bolicvc th. t tho cruntrioa ccncornod brou¬ ght ono or two nilltory doctor” rho a. io a speechevgroed upon bo- forohend at t: is Congress. Than if I hvo ur.-oretooi you correctly, r.t thoao planned r.oet- in:a of nllltr.ry doctors o i tho wholq world questions r ro discucsod end tfc. dangers w-rc dircursod w'ich threatened soldiers in peace end in war? / A. Yos, th.t is co. y * rs that the orr.o f-ing thr t w. r tho purpose of tho ueotinys which tho Prosecution has hero cr.ll„d m-ctln'-s of conspir.-tors, tho mootings of tho consulting specie.}icts of tho Wohrrsnch.t? A. The purpcoe and tho :S feet of these ^ongroares v;oro exactly tho fir.no as in our riu. tinge. After the so uo. tings, too, a printed report of the Mooting rr.s publishod »i ich was sent to tho pv tici- panto and to the highest nodic -1 agcnclos in tl o countries concern¬ ed. ' Ih.on tho nedioal ir spec tors oi the so co»«rtri r and their oconop- ic advisors selected those spoochos wl icl t.-ro of special inport- anco and bro ugi t ooaothi cr nor, cn in each country thoy were nodo known to tho public, the saao tJ in." that t;e- did in .. so:icwhrt diff- cront forn .Tt^r our iio.tinyc. "• In th .ro r-ports ;1 : ch. t! e wet fe.*>ua Military doctors of tho world n ado at those r:_etiry3 in roportiny tic r suite of their ro¬ se:-rch, cculd on. alua-a judge how they reached there conclusions? A k fc was possible in many o.-.a-s end in oth.r cases not. 12 Feb 47-::-r*-3-3-Putty Court Ko. 1 Q. fcow 1 t u s go Into your cr.sc Concretely, »\.t fields of nodical research foil under your control as --my L‘odicc .1 inspector? i, c will reach our aln -*ost quic! ly if I nontxon a few oxoraplos. Lot u c take dysentery, for cxcnplo. I nontlonod tils or.or.plo In uy affidavit. 1HE :HE3IL~ T: Counsel, tho Tribunal hoc listotsed to tho witness for seno tine on funeral state:>onts of tv u nlllt ry pr$f sslon vrhidh tho nonburs of tl o Tribunal und ratand, nd I thirk It Is rbout tl:no that r.oro ccncroto questions are : sked and rnsw,>rcd. I understood that counsel wr3 about to ask poxnt-d questions concerning tho nu, s- tionc now boforo the .Yibin.nl, but tho Tribunal would not bo inv¬ ested in dircussions of questions which .re foreign to tho nrtto.ra slid are now before th w -Yibun:.l for consideration. DH. NEi-TE: Hr. Presidont, I lavo ..shod, “Ebr.t fioldc of nodical research oax.io under your control as -rray .odi'..l Inspector?" dooa not tho Tribunal bwliovo that t) is is a concrot„ question? 12 ?ob. L7-H-»TD-ii-I-Board Court So* 1 jrjrftZ SE3RI1C: Doctor 1 can clarify for you what the Tri¬ bunal is Interested in> which encompasses not only the question you have asked but tba entire field of inquiry that the Tribunal would like to knew something about and I -an soing to ask a few questions, to the witness, if I nay, and ± -hiric per’.iapa you will see $hon the tyve of informtion we would like to have from this witness, if he can give it* or judge seam i Q Doctor Hanilosor, during the course of your prcsonco on-fcho witness stanl, you have exhibited a traaondous knowlortgo of the •tanner in which the various radical activities of the Qomn Govorrrwnt wjre' organized, and the nannor in which they operated durian tho recent war, ar*J I should like to put this question to youi You have heard tho testimony of tho Prosecution wit¬ nesses, an! doubtless have read tho documents submitted by tho Prosocution. Now, lot us aswurK that such ovidonco produced by tho Pmosccution is suf¬ ficient to prove that tho nodical or.perinonts wore, in faot, carried out in coreontratlon canps upon non-Gorman nationals without their consont, and that such uxporlnmtal subjects were killoJ as a result of sucho xporinonts. Lot us ass’xao further, for tho purposo of pointing up the question, that tho ovi¬ donco submitted by the frosocution is sufficient to provo that tho oxporimonts wero ccraMctod by and for tho benefit of tho *affon-SS. Now then, in your opinion, gainod from your intimate knswlcdgo of the frano work of tho Oerman Govermont under Hitlor, what officials or agoncios in tho German Govomnont would have boon rosponsiblo fer tho deaths resulting to non-Gormnn nationals fron 3uch oxporinents? A That would have boon those who had ordorc 1 the experiments. I must as sum that they woro illogal crirdnal axporiawnts. q I am assuming that for tt» sake of this question. That is a mattor ultimately tho Tribunal must decide, but for tho sake of getting your views lot us assume that faot. A If it had become krown to the responsible agencies, that they wore criminal, than the agency which had official supervision would have boon obligated tc interfere. That would have been for the concentration camps. As far as I know, the Raichsfuehrer Himler, Raich? Physician Grawits, sinco they 12 Feb. L7-B-«TB-t-2-5eard C-Ji-3-Soari Court Mo, 1 tte experiments for tho benefit of the nodical prcblens in the Gorman Air Forcoj what would be your anawir? A If the Air Force learned about it after the were non-Goman nationals whoreby hundrods of deaths occurrod wlth-ut that fact bucaiin,c either actually or officially known to tho hitfh officials in the respective branch of the service under whose auspices the oxycrl-.ents wore conducted. Is that correct? a. I understood you to say, your honor, that tho suorcr.c authorities had ordered then in tho interest of tho branch of the Vohmacht concernod. The fcnolddpe A tho exoeriront itself rnd the olaco whore it was carried out w.uld result frcel that fact dine. Ci. Let us assume, then, th/.t tho heed A tho - well, tho hoed of tho German cr:y emld h/vc c.irectly ordered such hupan exoorL:onte to have been conducted at Dachr.u, lot us say. And, thr.t in order to carry n those experi¬ ments it was necessary to have the human ia tor ini sent fr-x: Kctsweiler, and that it was ols> necessary to have the apparatus and couippunt with which tho 2.c2 C~urt 2*c. 1 12 7eb 47-n-5-2-2&-Oross oxr-«rlaesta were conducted sent free eo:s other p'rt of Germany, necoBSita- • i-g a c-nBldarrblc amount cf detail in assembling in that one soot the scr¬ eens who were g-_leg t. conduct the experiments, tho honan subjects upon when the experiments were going to ho conducted, pn<* tho material with vhidh the experiments were goiu,g \o be conducted. And, lot us rasu-u, for tho sake of •to auostion, that many hundreds A such subjects ware killed ra r result of such experiments. Would it hare boon ohysicinlly ocaslblo for such a orogrem A to hi vo been carried on rnd yet the knowledge A thrt fact be known only to the nrn at the ten vh. gave tho order and the .".an rt^ the bottcei who exocutcd the order? Would not necosscxy agencies end At icicle in betwoen tho nan at the top who gave the -rder rnd tho cm at tho bottoo who executed tho ordor have known about these things? A. Ycur Hon^r, y.u said that all kinds of crgrnixntionnl measures voro necessary. 7or exnmplo, bringing up instruments end eoorrr.tus. Then o sub¬ ordinate agency "ust have received orders t < hnw dsllversd those things, to have delivered thee to a certain p^cs, >r to deliver then somewhere. I con¬ sider It quite possible thrt such intermediate agencies recoivod ouch de¬ tailed MiUKMBti Without kn-ving, or without having to know, for what pur¬ poses it wrs neodod. There may to intermediate agencies vhich carried out a particular assignment but where it was not possible to sec froo the assign¬ ment vhrt it vbs about. Q. Y.u do not exclude the possibility, however, that those lntornedioto agencies under cortcin c.nditi-ns may hrvo known tho reasons for the experi¬ ments or why they were being celled uo.n to oroduco ccrtrir. oquipoent rnd mrtoriel, do you, Doctor? A. Thrt they did lo/xn southing, I moan that occcrding t- this nro- Svntntlrc it is oultc uossitlc that they did not kn-v anything because in view of thu strict eocrecy thi t existed - one must assume thrt a vnr was going -n - rnd in view f munlshoeot for breaking secrecy, and in view of repeated orders and Fuehrer orders which were p-stod in every barracks rnd in ever/ office, and there were ell kind* of Placards in trains, etc. In view f these circumstances cvery.nc was ellcved to learn ebsolutely vhrt ho 2 :y Court He. 1 12 >'eb 47-M-&-S-LEK-Grce« ,jy i to kn-v. I ec of tM G'ti&l'.n thnt an order say very veil hcvu been givon fer e particular action end that the -rgnrlration, evon if e cccorratively high agency, would not know the uurpoee. Xny I give an exeitulc that hr8 just occurred to at? I believe in connection with the chanter It vae lenraod here that the chanter vra not delievored to Dackeu at ell tut it wa.e intentionally delivered eaievhero else to -«revent it being ie/.e cleur that it «r.s to to taken to Dachau tccrusc the nano Dachau hrd r. certain escciia notoriety. That VAild fit into this question. or whatever it vea that poor ccndUima began only na r. direct affect of the air war, when, for oxa-.ale, lneterd -J? Court I Qa ^nd concretely you woro At the ncoting in Breslau as Profoscor Cutset t said! *. Tes, Q» Vhnt vtts the situation as far as you know at the tino ns Amy Kedical Ine -octor, and *hnt da you know about cxporir.cnts which had boon conducted n? to that tine* and was anything snid about whothor othoro wore to be dono7 1^ knowlodgo is limited to the big rooting on internal nodicino. on the 13th and 14th of October, 1943, In Vienna, where only aninnl cxporlncnts voro roported on, and at tho Breslau ncoting whore only nninel oxperi-jonts wero nontioned. I went to Breslau fron hoadquartcra, especially for that ono thoro and listened to tho nccting at which Schroibor presided, and I was glad that Schroibor had ouccoodod in getting all of thcoo scientists togothcr who voro partly in tho nriy and who wero partly eivilian, and that thoy had agrood t'- tho work which Schroibor had suggested and tho oxchango of rosulto ff«i ono group to nr.oth.or. Ho thing was said about aeperinants on huann boings in concen¬ tration carps at this rooting. Tho n;otlng wac in Juno, 1944, 3, H'.w, another fiold, how about nolnrln? A . Krlnrir. - a disonso in which wo woro greatly interested, of c- ur sc, r.ot only bocauso of Africa, but bo cause of tho 3alknno and othor areas. Tho nost torriblo noct of onlaria which I nysolf saw was in Salonika whore it was oron worso than in a fiold of particular intoroot, in the Caucasus, whoro I looked at the nalaria prophylnxio of tho Huasione, nalaria expert was Professor Bodorwald, Ho has his tro¬ pical hj'gicno institute in Berlin at tho nllitary r.cdical acadony. Ho had zoologists rad entomologists at his disposal there who advised bin and he had special nalaria training groups which wero to go to the front ir. Africa., Italy and tho Balkans and to lo-k for the enuao of nalaria and oonbat nalrxir. and hold cr ursos for the doctors. « spocicl laboratory train was created which was takon b7 rail to tho worst plr.cos and covcrrl especially trained doctors holpod the troops in 12 Tob U 6-4.- L J£-Cook-J? Court I their prophylactic noasoro*. In rogerd to nnlaria research wo had a dosed subjoct undor Frofossor Hndenwald, who was a fomc? nllitnry doe- •^r. Before tho war he was a Professor of Hygieso at Hoidolberg, nnd our aalarin question, as for as you would spook of it being conplotod, wo had a very g od prophylactic noasuro in atabrinc, end for troatnent through the nev drug such as placiaino. Vo had nado considornhlo nd- theco but I W'.uld not want it to bo nisundorotood, what I said boforc, Tho research was not c/'oplotod and wont on, end thcro woro nnny problcno to bo solved, a certain advance had been roachod fron uy point of viow % bcc&asO I o-uld issue an ordor regulating prophylrjcio and tror.tnont in ordor to provont rolnpscs. Tie. Thoro will bo a rccons of a fow nlnutos at this tlno, (A short racoon was taken) 2890 12 Pcb 47-:i-S‘-3-l- L cs3~r Court Ho, 1 THE ’uiESEAL: Poraons in tfco courtrcon will pleaso find thoir scats. lfcs. Tribunal is again in acssior. SIEGFRIED HAND LOSER - Resumed DIEZ97 SXAUNATEON - (continued) 3Y DR. !EL1E: Q. i/itnoos, wo faevo previously spoken aboutthu malaria oxper- lmonta and re a. arch wild the *rny and tl.o l«odle:-.l Inapcctorato hen- dlod, Bxo froaocutionhas not prusentod any ovid^nco that it was ccnr.cctod ir. any way vdth tho nelarift oxperliwnts at Dachau. Sinco, however, the Prosecution has claimed that in thia respect, I ir.uot ..3k you tho quo at Ion: Did you or cro of your officos hc.vo any conn¬ ection with rtgr rd to tlo nr.laria oxporlmonta or with tlo oxperinon- ta at wc.chr.u which woro there carriod out 'yy Dr. Shilling or by others? A. No. Did you over obtain lmovlad o of ouch oxporironta? A, w o. '. Now probably you will loiow from tho field of your rosearch, you will 1 avo rogul.-rly rucoivod rop • rta. ihr.t wea t) o procoduro? A. Do you n- n genorally about roaoarch or about nr.larla in particular? Mc.lr.rla, sulfon..nid«.3, ard wh..t you havo Jurt eta tod, and all tie other fields w’ri l w_ c.nnot mention and discuss because thio could load ua tee fra*, A. I havo received reports about t ia reaearcl in v:rioua ways. Oi one occasion throng, tho consulting pfcyaicima who wero porson- fll~ p rticipating in then or wl o w.rc personally inforraod of them. , for oaccaplo, through the *1 litary Todlcal ..cadony or through -loir official reports whicl i re frequently submit tod to vs. Also lecture of individual a who visited ab at Berlin .nd wj.o reported about the etato of affaire. 2vyl 12 ycb-K-S?W-34ossor-JP Court I Q. Ihun ;*<-u rccclvod such reports free your field of cnnpotccco. 3lc, tho Spoelrl Surgical aospitol at Brussels oulaittod tho roporto about its work directly to tho Amy Medical Inapoctorato; then for tho consulting phyciciaao thoro was a roport-collecting agoncy within tho Military Nodical Accdony. ?irst of nil, nil of tho roporto wont t ro which tho consulting physicians had to submit. Thoy voro thoro ovnluatod by tho r»coulting physician of tho Amy liodioal Services, — evaluations about corerlcncos nnd results or nVut questions which still rcr.ninod opon. Q, Voro thoy free tho consulting hysleisno with tho Military Aesdeny or fr(-i others? Zxclusivoly frm the physicians of tho Hilitcry ’lodicrl Acodcoy. An' fir.nlly, in es abbreviated f->r=, boforo thoy wero sent out again to the front md at hone, they also voro br-ught to ny attention. Or there voro reports directly froc tiw Kilitnry Nodical Aerdory which also were sent to tho Amy Kodical Inspector. 2092 12 IttVSi-StM-3-Dcsacr-JF Court I Did you sot the roports in other ways? i >jy i atnto with regard to the question of tho President there «„ report. ohout «ort «hlch hod orLon within nr flcl? of ccpotonco r* Arsy '.xdlcal Inspector. Q. I then cono to your connections to other flolds. First of nil to -he Vnffon SS at hone. Did you know or did you hare cay official contact with the Axnod Forces Institute for Research In tho Ahnenerbe? A. -Jo, I did not even know that institute. \ Q, Did you know tho Hyclonic Institute of the 7nffon SS under Pro- fossor ISragcrral^? A, I only know that Institute hy none because boforo wo wore trans¬ ferred froa 3orlln, I pncaod by tho Institute nt Zchlondorf. I have no- rcr been In:ldo. I did not hrvo any contacts with it. Q. Did you know tho dopnrtaont for Typhus and Pod oar eh in tho Concentration Cenp Buchonwald? A. ?o. Q. :;crc you youroolf over In tho Concentration Cr'tp Buchonwald? A. ro. q, !Wj »a we V- one of tho -.o.t lhphrtn.it nuo.tlon. for you In thtc trial. Or. tho ba.l. of an entry In the Dins Blojr, It ha. boon stated that Profoosor Dior, tha Director of tha SrtOcov In.titnto for Tjphu. rnd nr. 3crnhord Scheldt, nf tha .airy ::odlcal iMpodtornto had visited tho 3nchcnvali Canaontmtlau Oca®. Did you ardor .uch a rlsitt K 'Jo. Q. ’Jea this visit, reportod to you? A. So. Only froi tha d-cunont. riant tho Dine Diary I hnro found out "bout it horo In Fuember-;. Q. L-Ul you ploa.o oxplaln that to u= - hn» this oan ho poa.lhlo 2893 12 ?c^>S^-8~i-Losscr-£P CflUTt I thrt till* wrs ot brought to /NV knovlo' ~o7 *, I cannot explain that boenuoo I don't know tho reneono for this visit. Only tho pooplo ooncorr.od, Scheldt and Eier, can jive you nny isfornation about thrt, or porhaps ny Chiof of Staff. Q. Veil, wo shall question then r.s witnesses. According to this 3lsj Dl"ry which I hr.ro alrondy sontinnod, by order of tho Supreme Cornrnd of tho Amy, tho sshrinj Varies, tho Robert IToch Institute, end the ftrphus rad Virus Heserrch Inetituto at Erdcow, ore rllojod to hovo been ordered to produco yellow fovor vaccine. How according to tho entries in tho 2>inj Diary, a ro-oxrcination of tho yollov foror vaccino took pl.-.co ct Buchonwald. It is stated also frnr. Kr.-kow, What do you know about it2 12 7cV;i-9-l-P^-'=oha3-JP Court I i. Yith rojard t« tho question for tho ordor of producing such a % ool r-j. I n«o-jno that that crqr have boon the caaa boemso under condi¬ tions in Africa such a ^r.ccinc won necessary for us. Q. "ere you trying to find a yollow fever vaccino? A. Co, it was only a quostior. of producing It. It was tho pro- coduro to produce ouch a vaccino which was ciaplifiod; it was oely a technical production in tho laboratory of tho instltuto; tho woll known Poltlor vaccine. x Tho ^inj Diary also nonti'-nod tho fr.ct that ohipaents of lice, which had been Infacted with typhus, vero eont to 3uchcnwald in ordor to infoct pooplo at 3uchonwnld do you know anything about that procodure? K Ho. q. I's, .President, in this concoction and in ordor to clarify tho • tato of affaire, I shall subr.it Ittcuncnt EA--13, in Document Book Hmdlooor 11 on pr^o 33 and I want to preoent it as Exhibit 9. It In an affidavit by tho dofondant Dr. Eovon. At tho tine Dr. Hovon was in tho concentration esq? Buchcnwnld, ns you rry know and ho has personal kno*r- lod,;o of tho shijocots of lico and to this question ho ft-toe, rad I road: ■Tho aM{cant of lico, nontionod in tho Dine Dinry and in tho tosticony of tho vitnonoos Dr. Kogan and lirchhoinor, cano fro= Dr. Kruua Lvov. I know this for certain bccruso I infornod Dr. Haas that tho lico had boon destroyod. ■I can therefore nffirr., fror. -y own knovlodirc that the otatenonto of tho witnesses Dr. Ko^n rad Kirchhcircr - Dr, Kogan was not yot with Dr. Din,; at that tl-.c - that tho lico ohipaocts oono frr-r. tho CSC-: Ins¬ titute at Cracow are besod on a nicconcoption." I requort th-t this affidavit bo accepted as cvidonco, na exhibit 9. In tho Dirv Diary, tho Voigol vaccine is frequently nantionod* because r Iso the other vaccines which arc r.or.ti^ncd in the diary frequently were used for re—cxar.inntion; I wont to ask yau i: this was also tho 2895 12 ?oVK-*KF-9-W:aofcaa-JP Cwirt I c*-jo with roscrd to tho Voigol wccinot ^lrofidy In 1939 during tho c«ipaign in Poland, tho eany hr.d ite own tynkys research instituto at Crooow and it produced tho typhus YACeicOa wnicr. was trieon fron lico according to tho ^oi^ol nothod. This mccino hM rlready for nany yoars toforo teen testod In othor countries nnd it had proved itself* a 2095 (a) 12 T cV ^s-wi^:^-‘-J p Court I n hod not only been to.tod »* *»- «. in «porlnont. on ^ hut ^cnorally it hod boon — “ " ichcc e. a. » « fr-dnoin *“• ltt ““ “ 4 thor ° M romon for sculled r^.lnn.lon ,. « ho. boon- -died hero. M. ™v el: o hod t» rocofSlMd In nmy f.oldn. q. Whore did Bnchonviild obtain thin rneolnol A. I cannot any that. « «— — » *° ^ W * If th0 tfaffon SS wonted «o obtain thl. m.cln. for 'it. unit. * <»« then It on, dol irorod to the naln «dl«l «* of the Wfen M. A* dollvorod in the «, voy V other ^nclo. end If the office „ f ,ho lfoffon SS wonted to here .one of thl. mcclno, they prohnhly „ w tore turned to the nnln nodlc-1 T'» « 3orlln - Q, I on now enalnc f the txtln auction. to the action of the typhu. dloontolon* for thl. I - ^ « *» ^ ^ IT. K«. Before wo po.. on to the next exhibit. »tn T u hf/o the wltne*. .tote *. *. *to. - ™ - * l » office r-ioney he * mooted nt the tine, which nceordln, to Dr. Enron thcao lleo .hijnont* crr.o to the corp. ^ aao, You hro herd the quctlon. vitnosc; < taw Dr. Hvsl t o typhuo.rcoeorch inotltute w the n»e of Bc&rlne which teword the end of 1«3 hod Been e.tohlUhed nt , m . The institution hod nothing V. do -•> ° *•" ^ 0 . for no X M *. — wo. -» n r, her of the Vohntocht end what clTlllnn - tuney «. M. -uperlor ^ , - — *“ ,, X oenr-ot ... X al~yo —— » to he on industrial onto. price. 3? 33. 22LY3: 12 ?cb-j;-9-2-PEP-i:cchfiZ>-JP Court I Ojt lx. President, thoro will bo witaossoB hoard with rognrd to this quOBtion. At I it .-.tod, this fvLlo.Tcd typhus ca.Scrcncc which you will find in Locanont Book 12 roquirco dotnilod explanation. lie • Prosidont, it io >oarer.t Book 12, pego 36, Purthoir.oro, tho Prosocutioj. in oormoction with thin cfiostion hno sulr.ittod on "Xfidrvit fron tho ifoll-kr.ovn Kopo Dictoch# This Ik.eunont 'Bo. 1413 was subsequently Buhr.ittod nnd I do not Icv-v its exhibit nenbor by tho x 2896 (a) 12 Fob. 47 -K-9->PO*- Hoohan Court So. 1 Prjsjcaticn. I therefore request ttot you reed ir. Paragraph 6 wh*-t is stated .b^ut i. 'iscussijn of Kapo Diotsch. “IV.ore are two docuasnts about tliis alleged discuss! n, pa ; ... one cf the Dinr D1 thy an. th* affidavit by Dietsch. The prooccuti.t December, 1941, I was in the Hearlquartors - ty~t was How Year’s Eve. I ccnr.ot statu with certainty if I was tit the Headquarters «. the 29th. Q. I j aokini tbc qu-sti «r. in vie.. A the 2nd entry >n Pa e 1 of the Din/; Diary, where it is slat- in rd.r to test typhus vaccine, tin Concontrat Coop Buchuiwald has been chosen. It is t state who Selected the Conccntroti Cwap Duchjnwild, but with coneldoratixi to the fact that y.u are allcg* to have been present at a discussion of December 29th, I would lik^ to doturmino if it is -t least clear that on the second of January you coul* r. t p.ssi?ly fv.ve been at Berlin x»ni it was impossible for y-u to take part in any confei-uncc. A. Or. January 2nd I was Certainly not in Berlin. 2S91 12 :-.b- -J.-IC-l-iitnabick C.urh I I r. "it ycu V st w ur 'J'J-fn If such a conference whic:. Jr senta'..red in the Ding Diary under t!:o dateline of the 2?th of December l?iil aetirli.* df t'.:* plnce . I^fc tba s cirds oi ersone -ndwiih the sr.je contents? ... I heard the first ti.e c. r tt r -fter I had been arrested .and I heard of it in the iiterro;;' or. center it (/norursui towards^ ho end of Sept«bor 1‘ 4$. There the iaterro .'tor road 'O re excerpts fros n document X which, '8 far ~s I know not/, con'-axnid several things which ar scLso sectioned in the ‘/in. Diary. Ir. general it dealt x.itht»:pcrijj:ntr in tne 3uetonwr.ld Concer.tr'tion "“'ip# I at-.ted that I only got to know the nmw of Buchentald .".'ter tho c ipitulat an, and t the ease ti>c that 1 ad sever visited Buchonwald, and that ..it t »Mch h“d taken place thoru T»wre unknown to no* Thon tho in- t rro. - tor o-l t -at. It was superfluous for V dor.; th .. tx.cr.vc.. they had a phot r .aii ren ouchcm Id *fh„ru I wai ?. r. be- other rlth t. j ..ic'isfuchrer and Conti; furth. earc,tbo7 had j r cord fres tchonrold which 1 was alleged to h Vc t igntd. I thon I'opUod tc t..-. lnt«rrof.ator t h t this was .iot correct, and then said .hat ttoeocbcuBjata t._-r- air. - d> on th. n~y, and that thbj would.be presented to a. at the v.ry 1* • : i on .. m following day* Howuvor, this n-vor hupp-'fi-d “-fid iT*r iinco th.cc difficult d-y® in s»olit ry confinu.xnt,— P.. cKiKZY: li tao ir: >m 1 pL.rtsc, first h_ isked ni.4 vhothei* or not the -act- - toe' piece on the 29th Of December l?lil ind now wo have listurxd for five ndrmtos to tr*. first tipj ho hu-rd - j .m t the Booting and *rta t hnppono< to hin ~n -ho rr.a going to present . - tith documents and so forth. I think it ir :i qu: to i- .at.rial and i * - if ,vj ould confine hinsclf to directly answer pactions v.. would get-long *®:ch faster. d'.. _ : ay it plt'&: tho frisuncl, I believe th th. pros. out!on ns .. 1 oi.ly cLvotud s. ._rl hours to tur - ct, but several •' ys, sy reading all possible accusations. 12 -b-. -J.'-lC-Z-UL.’.ouck C'-urt I ’ . ;7. l 3ZTx Counsel any proceed with the ex aiiwtion. 3. ; 3 y "a-. ’cite) :lc-r:. m e t .phuc unfortunately ronehod with us in th \.-rs l?L-2 and U 3 . That it pi'ye:' a pj-iicular part is-Iso shown by the d-tcs-i.lch are not ’.mown t - -a zx.\. :ut the lectures' ith tv aldcf of t.i-. ,Ln.r 1 staff, wt.r-., fore _fl_. ■ ihink it was in January or ; -rch 1912, .alreati; 10,000 - nd s vor~ hundr- c-: s oi typhus had b_.n registered, 13 CO of tber. - 03 V-TO f -tal. .md 1 as U ttbL, t • stato - t is ti > if 1 reported to OeR-r.aloberst Haider the total number of ta.e ens.s as they had occurred, only .a.nut the :n=b-r which had bcienxcached during the pruvi'us few conths. 12 7.b- nr.buc -- .curt I rae cbfi preventive. j-.'Bure? did have * vaccine which ve -r- pr .'xciB«, ouraUvwS. Hoirevor, <• r.oro or* lir-dtcd in its production, r C'U rj*..number o. 35,0^) portxo: pcraor.th, and it nay be that it is the nuaber of boconoer 19U1. I had fcivon the order th-t the production of this vaccine be increased r.t all casta. I can r aeebor for certain that I had dircusstona -went tnr.t cud v 1 uct at ho.*. -no Iso tl.it 1 probably have discussed ituLth Conti, and I rw quite ou. t 1 discussed it with OUdJBoistor. •- I did this for r. certair. purpose and vith a curtain plan a..d I have to uaphasito ir. this respect that I, i .szy odical Inspector, or even if I had already be-n t:.e ch-of of the Vehroadit odical Service, which I was not nt tint t: to, ! did not have any of: iclcl in_ uonco on the ci* linn coctor, I am of the opinio, th.t \t the ti-c. -no qu.-t.on o first to do scribe the danger at home of U\.r typhus situation t .ie front, wlach typhus n iy\t cause; and secondly, to rise . x lnt out tc t. -a t t tie dole-ring procedure bet.?oonbia .re o' op.rat_ooa -utdttu hOBolan*' had not bocr. obstructed t sufficient nr yet or th-*t it had only oe-n e: . blirhed to qdto an insufficient ox- tont; ant th .t durint th- »int r period the ch nce3K.ru 7-ry slight th'.t tho construct on Ceuld be inprovod. Secondly, in n; opiuiai., 1 ;v. pointed out that w. h-d r. v.accino but onlj in such a li.-is -wtont ta t a. w_r suable te riv anyt- inj to the p-oplo at haie ...cyt for c . sliyt xr «.x- ti .-is| and thirdly, I oclicve that I have ask -1 fivf-ssor jilekr. st-r .. - ail praviour experiments >y -*e to rbt-in infar.ation : to how uctu 'j. t. cth- r typhus vaccine could bo used — which was rat mo fret lie: but fre c _c'..r — by l-rafessor Otto at Fr.nkfurt, by tho it.bort Koch Institute. ,ia ..r in, and *1 by the Ichring rkr . arburg, that actually bchr Lear me I had net succeeded in obtaining ny • . • inf r ti r. t.ut it, vh-.c in g-a.ral this v-ccine was being us-d and h effective it was. I era. re ±r that Oil victor — I don't kn» if it war in Iwcombcr I 9 ^ 12 7oW:-JB-U-l^Paity-JP Cosrt I ^r.d I hr.vc certainly rooauBondod to tho nor. with whoa 1 discus sod this problcn under consideration of tho situation ns it oxistod with us to do . everything ir. ordor to now obtain this so fnr prcviously-1 r. eking orpo- rioaco end to fain additional infoxention. la ny opinion, this could not wT.ua o rry difficulties at p!1 bccauso in tho civili : soctor nt that tire good opportunities existed to carry out this test in nrcnj^ In tho Z~.st or In other regions vhoro tho ior.,;cr existed and t< toot tho natter. 0. STow I vnnt to coao back to tho question whleh*iow has to ho put in such a way. Did you participate in any discussion with tho circlo of persons re it in stated in tho Dir.r Diary? % ro. Diyou aitond n conforonco which ronchod a resolution that* ns tho Pro so cut ion h~s intorprotod it, tho typhus rosonrch was to ho continued by c-nyln: out oxp.rinonto on hurra beings by infocting healthy pooplo? A . Fes Q* ’. r oo tho vaccination of concentration crip ian-tos or prlconoro frr c* icontratioa cvrps discussod nt nil in tho conforoncoo? a. ro. Q. In tho c oroo of such a discussion was your c ntnet to inoti- tutos of the Vrffon-SS, was it the suh.ioct of tho dlncunsiono? A. !Io. Q. If I nadorot-nd T' u correctly, y< ur t-sh was fulfillod whon you printed out tho seriousness of the situation in tho Dost to tho Hono- l.-r.d ~r.' when you pointed out to the that tho arry ty no.-ns of its institutes and its vaccines was unable t*- ~ivo nay of it to the Hoa&Lamf? \ Toe. Q# -o y^u !ci r v thr.t pnr^Taj'fc 6 r »f the ccc^nd do cur.on t ronti/‘DG tho fret that Dr. Dine is alleged V- hnv nttor.dcd this circle of persons which, is not nenti'-nod in tho Ding Diary itsolf7 Have you discussod this quest!- r. ray .tine with Dr. Ding? 2902 12 7 ; b-»I—0?-l 1-2-Pu t ty—JP Co-3-t : ■*. ro. Is the KC'::d Dlotsch dneunont Profoseor Rose has boon nentionod. Did 7''U discuss tola question with Mel A. I hftTO novor diocuasod It with bin at any tlno. 0, ;rn*r -a - procaution ne Defonao & unsol, I would llko to p.sJc you tho follovin,; question: "111 y< u pie- o ror.d tho loot contonco of tho first entry which states; "Since nnlrrl oxporinar.t it>aa nrit porait o aufficiort cvrlur.tlon, tho expori-onte ;uat bo carried out 03 hun.-n boingo. Tov let ur. neeur.c that this atntcncnt h~.fi been cn'c In jnur dlGcnsoiono ir thla wry. Hnv would you hwo lntorprctod it? A. If I ror.fi over tho scntonco nnd I dr. r.ot ’-now anything about tho incidents ne they hnvo been proaentofi by tho Pr< so cut Ion, 00 thoy nro atntofi In the dneunont horo, I would not find anything at nil which would cause no V. bo ahochcfi boenuao I would n.asuno that tho word "ox- pcrir.cr.t*, which noro and r-.ro aofna to nn unfortunate word — fco cololy at.-toa that tho ucas export".out nnfi tho n~.no uoo of bnnnn boingo r.uat t'o place in order to finally roach tho clarification nbut ltB offoo- tlvanoaa r.c r. yrovontativo on tho wholo which waa ntlll lacking, and I can jy lnt ou* la thio roapect that In an artlclo by Gohclnrat Otto, who In 193C dlBCoworcfi thla vaccine nnd wlv~ wrltco In this artlclo; Bio '..’olgl vacclno which. in bci - ,. produced la Krrkov, la Chinn and ntlll in cono othor city, has -lxo 'y pr-ved itaolf for r.rny yo~rs even on a l~rgo-ccAlo use 03 hu-.m boir-ge. ”ie e v yolfc rncclno hod provofi itself cffoctlvo ir. laboratory oxperi -onts and ir. export’.onts nr. v-.inrle. Bio practlcnl experience tr n lar~o extent lo atill lucking. That w-.s wrltton In on artlclo w .ich oncoa fro- the onfi of 1942 or tho first part of 19*13. w the following fror you in this connection; it is possiblo th-t r. vox duo of this kind ^alsn provos itself in rolr.tivoly largo indi- sridunl onperinents with threo or four hur.drod pooplo. Does this indivi¬ dual esporirent not offer proof of tho fact that it cannot possibly bo dangerous in a large-scale ospc.riror.t? ^ I havo not understood tho 1 rr L port of your question, I norm the circusstanco that n raccino when it fb nppliod to throo or four hundred pooplo in a singlo orporlient, dooa it not nffor proof and lOi.iti* ati r n of tho fret th-t it con be appliod on a lar -70 ocaloT A, Yen, this Quito applies with ro^aris to its corrpatibili but wo ust with every voccino difforor.tir.to botwcon the of foots and its C'npatibilit;*, Vlth reg-rd t tho c-r-patibility, ir. rjy opinion no doubt oxlntc< r;y.mro with regard t« tho o/y: yolk voccinc, but pooplo havo difforcr.t rjact'.'as to these vaccines, end if sonot Ins of this kind is t' bo introduce.” with tho Vohrr.rrcht whoro alllions of -ooplo -ro affoctod — t'T Ohr. rpic, until 1943 noro than ono million pooplo had nlroady Kc:: raccir.ntod with tho "foigl vaccine, md thin was otill bo in,- cxetlnuod, 'lllions wore boicj vaccir.-tcd with it, ord after nil, nillinns would have t< bo vaccinated wit v this r.cw vaccir.o. Thon I ncod a noro pooltivo and noro strblo basis frop a lar.qo-scnlo oxporlr.cnt which has to include at lorat one thousand poo-lo. How di y u do it with the Arr-y hodical Inspectorate in othor eases? d* Jirst of all, as vo di" it with the Rchrschutz vncolno, wo first of till nr.de - snail expert cat with ton pooplo in tho aendony, or first of all several do ton nay have beer, includod, and thon after tho ,-ood compatibility and tho hamlossnoso of the vaccine had been deton inod, a troop experiment was nado with a certain unit, and thon it was ox-.ctly obeervod first hov cany pooplo were unable to per for- duty for how long or booms: of what explications, and then aftorwerds '.t wre do tor:'-inod 2S04 12 -our t I by the expert by neon* of cxaninatlon* vhet tho proventotivc situation vns is tho body of the porson as e result of the vnecinetion, ~nd vhoa this roault also was•satisfactory besides tho rosr'.t* of the oncpatibllity, then before it v»s introduced, I roTortod to ny nilitnry cor.-and or s nV-ut it, and then I vouched for tho fact that tho pooplo v-uld not bee . .c sick through ray C'r.plic-'tior.a arising fro.". tHo vncci- r.ation 290-i (a) 12 y Q ,-F-l 1-4-Pu t ty-JP Court I rad thr.t nn lrvrailxatloa would bo achieved within the tino Units which til these vaccines hnvo, l r ov, how do J'U explain tho fr.ct that ct tho bejinn ins of 19.12 the oxjcrl-ioots v.ro carriod out in Suehcnwald of which yoviihnvo hoard horo? A « Veil* first of all, I r.ust asstr'O that this was dono nfc it has boon nlitcd* Ho wo 7 or, I nc not in a position t*JuS$o that in any way beenuao i &» lv >t hove any basis for it, ' 2905 12 Fob 47 -"-S.;- 12 -l-Lv.Ricl 8 C'urt Nc.. 1 In itsolf, th-r- c.nnot bo any doubt that Infections xrcro ..ccut.ll 7 cc.uacd? Or, on the basis of tl prosonontlcn of cvidonco dc yen 1 . "o imy objection to that? «s for as I know, ^ * "o not rocoivod any positivo bnsisfor it so f-r. r. You boliove tkx t you c nnot nako my judguent? .. Ho, I c n only nako r.saunptionBj thoy aro not always good to uso, ^ n. In tie affidavit of Bclcchowaky, docui:ont nuubor 484, which i. exhibit 91 of tlo ?resocution, docunont book 12, pa-o 64, you will find tl'.o following entry: •".•.ra graph 4: in tho chiof comitteo of tlis dopnrtr.iunt"—and I odd "block 45, Due. onw: Id" --"tl o following persons aro located: ”Dr. '-cndlcs r, Inapoc tcr-Qonural of tho -odioal Scrvico of tlo Wciruacht. "Dr. Conti, ^’r. Poppondick, r.nd :*• Qonekon On tlis nr -called Chiof C 0 nittoo, pornons v/ero inrtructod by ; cU , -'r. F. opondick, and Dr. Oonzkon*. Do yru ’new anytl irr: about sue*, cl i-f ccanittoc ? ... In connection wit! t in I c n only rope t tl .t I do not Jmow tl.o Buchonwc.ld C 0 ncontr..tlon Co p, th .t I do net 1: ov tho Inntitut for typhus hos-arcl at -vcl orwald, nd t! t I 1 v- r.ov-r had my contact with it. *1 r.fore, I c.r.not h;.vo been a uotibor of my superior cc , of w; icl I 1 VO never oven ho a rd, DH. «EL7S: Ilt.y it pK. so thv Tribunal, eftor f o conclusion of t is co'.iplox, I would like to present tl o following documents: Firc-tt cf 11, I would Ilk- to present ..n affidavit by Profossor • r jit-r. it is document 15A-25; it is located in ny document book c p e 38, end I present it s Exhibit 10 to tl u rribunnl, iCF.jTZY: With r-spoct to tlo affidavit of Reiter, tlo pro- soonlcn reservos tlo right spocificaily in this caoo to c 11 tho witness :md subject bin to cross-oxaoinaticn- 1 o is right hore 12 ?av»-r-ia-a-3fioi»-ap Court I t - -ucrotorj In jail; or. ns on alternative* wo reserve the richt to 6ulr.it o erees-affidavit It<* Hoitcl 1 * Sr. ordor that thoro bo no nla- understanding X v- uld like to have it understood that the prosecution reserves such a rijht Ath respect to any of the affidr.vits boin G sub- nit tod, end that it will not bo necessary for no to nnko that reservation on oacli occasion* ^ TIC PSSSIflEH: Tho prosooution nay hnvo tho rifiht to oithor coll the affiant as a witness or to put in another affidavit nr stotonont by tho witness* 31. lELCDl 1 ohly wnnt to point out that Profocsor Heitor has (•newerod the question that ho nrticlpntod In any conforonco. ns it lo e-.tod in tho Dine Diary, on tho 39th of Doconbor, 1941s Ho has stated in this connections "X have not participated in any conference with this ,rr,up of .croons deal in- with this subject." Ho further statos that discussions about typhus did take plaoo, but not in tho way as stated in tho diary. I therefore request that this dneunont bo accepted ns — IB. ::cHJ13ri Unlcrpr.Wc): I n* thrt dofon.o cruBMl bo dlroot- oi V. road ir.it or -ploto nffldnvlt Into tho record. Ho hn. noroly pnrApbrued cortnln portion, of It. It 1 . qnlto npr-nront, on rondlng tho nfflterlt c r .hole, th-.t Sol ter hln.olf o4r.lt. thrt ho 414 ntton4 n nootlnc on or rhout tho dr.to nontlonoi In tho Wnfi Blnrjr. Ho coo. on to .oto thr.t thoro vo, rr.o tn6!c-tl-n thr.t thoro nltft-. Be .cplclou. exporinonts enrriod nut. I think it only fair that this affidavit bo road into tho record, since ho is offering it. IS KCSI3EOTJ Tho suggestion of tho Prosecution is appropriate. Tnc entire exhibit will bo road into tho record. HU 13L3X "I. Professor Dr. Heitor, have been waxnod that I will ho cuhjoct to pum^ont If 1 nnho a frl.o nffldnvlt. I 4.o!nro under noth thr.t ny to.tinony cnrro.rrnd. tr tho truth md vn. eivon in ordor to bo subr.ittcd in ovidcnco to Military ^-ibunal 2907 12 Job-fr-o43-3-Doniol*-JP Court I X, 1'uornbor,-, Palace of Justice. 'Tko defense counsel of Professor Dr. Hftr-dloscr, Dr. Otto 'Joltoi fart carted to sc the entry in tbo diary of the Section for typhus n B d Virus I’xscrrch of tho*»affcn SS. Buchcnvald, of 29 Docoubor 1941, as follows*, and I quote: ■Conference of Kodicol Inspector, Gcneraloborstabsartt Profossor Dr. BmUosor. ■Belch Eorlth Loader, Stoto Socrotcry, SS Grupooofuobror Dr. Conti. ■President Profossor Hoi tor, Rot. a Ho.olth Offico. x • ■President Profossor Gildtr.oistor, of tho Hobort Xoch Institute, Pujich I-.otitutlon for Conb-.tting Contagious Diseases. ■SS Ctradertonfuchrex Locturor Dr. lirugovsky of tho Hygiono Inotituto of tho TfoffoB SS in Berlin. ■Tho conclusion was rcochod that It is nooossory to tost the con- pntnblllty raift effectiveness of typhus v-ccir.es node fron chicken vitollino sacs. Since nalnal oxperinonts do not pornlt ndoqunto evaluation, oTpert-ents nuct bo conducted on hmnn beings." 2nd of quotation. ■in nr.cvor to tho quostion of vhotbor I particioc 3& in this cor.fo- ronco, I declare to tho boot of ny knowlodgo and boliof: ■I did not ^rticirnto in a conforcnco with this group of porcons and with this result. ■I cb uld like to add, b 7 way of explanation, that tho typhus pmblcn and tho ian-jor thrc-tor.lnc S' 0"U.c4 .orlau. concorn at tho ond of 194 . =*- all nuthorltlo. hovln.;: aay rcepanolilllW for public hoclth. Accordir^ to ny rocollcctloc, I participated In one aactlag at the cad af 1941 ar the hcglaalag of 19-13 .hich dealt- *lth the typhue vnccino situation. ■? i t vaa ono of tho custor.nry nooting* in tho Reich Ministry of tho interior designed to enlighten the head of tho Health Section on n specific question. In general it cm bo said that Dr. Conti, vbo called those sooting* and presidod over then, reached his " “ 2908 12 TcV^-3V-13-1-1>ci1o1b-JP Court I decision indoposdontly• on the Wi. of tfco reports unde to bin according U, tho leadership principle.' "In addition to Dr. Conti, Dr. Gildcr.oistor of the Robort Koch Institute -ad Dr. Llndoc were prosent at the rooting on tho typhus vaccine situation, as far ns I can recall. I cannot ronorbor that Profossor Hnndlosor.or any special SS representative attended. ^At thin Booting Professor Ooldenoistor Cere an orientation report to tho Roich Health Loader, Dr. Conti, ccphaslxlng the ossontial difference betvoon the t;phus vaccine produced In Lvov and Cracov by tho Voicl nothod rnd the vrcclno produced at tho Robert Koch Institute in Berlin under tho direction of Professor Oildcnoistor, according to tho nothod of Gohoinrnt Dr. Otto of Tmnhfurt-nn^Caln. Thoro follovod a discussion in which tho offoct of the tostod voccino produced by tho OKH Institute in Crr.cov and Lvov vas particularly roengnisod, vhilo tho offoct of tho Otto vaccine vas roportod as boing not so certain. •fho confcrcnco vas broken off by Dr. c ontl with tho ronark that ho would dlscuoo this question in tho future with Professor Dr. Glldonoiotor nlono.. ■I did not attend any othor discussion of this subjoct. Tho entry in tho so-called diary, of the Sect!'-. for Typhus and Virus Roooorch con therefore not rofor to. the abovo-nontionod dlscuoo ion. ■In the ncoti-ir which. I nontiW, no conclusion was reached, no giver, in tho entry. This is especially true of the following sentence: •Since oninnl o.vpcri~onts do no* permit adequate evaluation, exponents nust bo conducted on hur-or beings.’ sjfor was anything aaid at thio discussion of transferring oxperinonto dt h typhus vaccine to the SS; that is, to the Hygiene Institute of tho Vnffen SS. Tor did I hear anything later on about the Soction for Typhus cad Virus Research, nor of the none Dr. Ding.’ 3909 12 cb-4-S£-13-6-Daniol*-JP Court I ■Hurabor^t 24 Jonurry 1*47. SignOds Prnfoc«nr Dr- Bolter. "The oboYO -ffidurit vrs eignod on 24 Ja&unry 1947 poraonnlly in ny prcflonco by Profoaenr ?>r. Bolter." TH3 KESim^: «u) Tribunal will now rocosa until 1:30 o'clock. (A recess vns tokor. until 1330 hours.) % 2910 12 Fab 47-«-DJQ-l*— 1-Beard- (^K) COURT I C0RR^C7£D COPY TH2 .-LjRSH^L: The Tribunal la again m cecalor, Trt£ RRZSIDZST; <%t this time the Tribunal ca$i:*oa to cnnounco that at tho*cloae of tho aoaalon ton Arrow aftornoon thu Tribunal will bo In rcooaa until 9;0 Tuesday nornlng. Thla la done on account of confllcta with ol.hor Tribunals, ao tha rocoaa at tho ond of tho aoaalon tone rrov aftornoon will bo until 9:*0 o'dock Tu08day nornlng. % Tho Counsol nay prooood. DR. UZLTZ: .uiothor docunont on tho subject, Tsubmit an affidavit of Doctor Gontkon. Ha- 26, Docunont Book 2, pago 41. I offer thlc Docunont as Exhibit 11. It oo.atalna tho atatonont of tho dofondant, Dootor Contkon, that ho did not belong to any connlttoo auoh as Bnlaohowsky oontionod, and no such oonnlttoo existed. I ask hat this bo aoooptod aa £xhlblt 11 . Thuro are tho sano atateaonts In tho nffldavlt for Doctor Poppondlck. Thla la Docunont Hir-27, In Docunont Book 2, page 42. It also soys, "I never bolongod to a oonmittuo or control oonnlttoo and I do not know of -ny such o.^nralttoo or o-ntral connlttoo. - I ask that this bo accoptod as Sxhlblt 12 . Tho third participant In this connlttoo was ProfosJor ;stijfute did not moan thoro t»’*l 12 Feb 47-Board-(.-*£) COURT I was any official connection with the Krakow institute I aok that this Document bo accoptod ae 2xhlbit 1*. Finally I submit a Document from Professor, Doctor otto, who has several tlaos boon mentioned by the lofendont on the witness stand. Ho Is tho Inventor of the Typhus vaccine from ohlokon eg 0 's. Tho essential point of this affidavit Is to prove that In 1941, the Typhus vnoolno produoed from tho Intestines of lloo, according to tho 'Jolgl method, is produo- ad at OKH Institute in Krakow, and was tho boat vacolno at that tlmo and did not roqulro 2911a 12 Fc , -rutry-^-DJO-13-&-3cor4 C;ur: So. 1 ~xy orporioxntr.tion. I subr.it tnis nffid-srit, H>-44, o* Sxhiblt 14, This rffib rit is In Docunoat 3ook 3, which unfortunately hns not yot boon trans¬ lated and is not yet avail blc. T13 P^clTJETT: Till? affidavit of Doctor Otto, where is It Doctor Holto? 33. SSXfflt It is in Document 3ook 3 veiefc is not yot available. It will to Sxniblt 14 and 1U-.*; 14-;. is a spoclr.l reprint fron n .lodicnl Journal which the .'.of on.Ant Profossor Ehndloscr nontioned. ^ 3. KeF-^ZT: Ibo Prosecution, of course, roserves the rl£ht to otjoot to tho adalssablllty of this document vhon it is available in Srv;litn. I hove not toon it. IKS PFZSirCTT: Tho whiiisabillty of eho document will not to considorod until it is boforo tho Tribunal and cxanlncd by tho Prosecution. DA. J3LTSI Kr. Prosidont, tho docaaont is nvnilablo only tho translation is not yot ready. T:3 PSESMGi I undentin'. t.vt. but it is not available to tho Tri- ouaal nor to tho Prosocution, ns I uni ox stand it, nt this tluo. 2X. nUl. ?nsn, I nsk th't t..is nu-eor oc reserved for this docunout. DT 33. HZLTSI * Profossor Smdloscr, you nontioxwd thv n/uoo, Oildonolstor, with vnoa ym hrd discussion* nt tho oni of 1941 eonoorzdn. Typhus vnccincn: is that truoT L Yos. Professor Oil .ouoii-tor is Iso r-ontionod in tho Din.; diary scvoml ti_os in the jrof r 1942 r.s bavin: visited 3uchonvr.l 4 ., and 3loclt 46. In ordor to clrxlfy this, I ask you li ‘ Profossor OilAoaoistor ov;r toll you of those oxp.crliionts in 3uchor.vrai, in', tho aothods uood in DocfconwnldT A So, n-vor. i Doctor ro.ou, in his tostiuony, oasortod thoro wns a connection be¬ tween tho Typhus r.nl Virus ro-tonrch r.t 3uchonvald ur*. tho Kllitnry Kedical -iC -do-y. 3o assorted thnt because Doctor Din was ct tho ouotir. of tho consulting r:odnli»ts in Ihy 1943, and -ado a speech in which ho sold tint tuvre *jr.s connection between Duchc av ail and the Solitary Hodicnl .xndory, 2912 12 Jv..rurj>-j-rj>l»-2JQrI C-urfc So. 1 -111 y a _ loi.eo cl-'X up this er.ttarT - 3*tvocn tho Military fcxlieal _crij;: wjfi tho nootinro, thoro wna ’air oac connection; that 1., tho -codcry ando lt« rooac available for tho -octin,;. nothin,; also. . : Did you hoard Doctor Diw'« spooch a* tfca hcndc-y in hr.y 191*3? - tei* v^aoch va« tfvon to tho e.TOup of ^r,^oncet, ru-d I did not .articipato in this ^rou;., ^ l Vfco it reportod to jr,ut a I hoard that in tho diocuaoiin w.-.ich follovod, rr.itod on ot*. Jootion, tut that not roportod to co nt that ti::o. 2913 12 Feb-A-'AA-lA-l-HLakley (?L) Court No. I r H.~ did you not Icar of it privately either? A.- No. Q.- To cplain furtter a connection between Block 46 at Buchomald and tho Military ifcdical Academy, Dr. Kogcn referred to tho wntry in tho Ding diary nhich speaks of the control, tho testing of the blood conser¬ ves. I dll read you only one of the total of three on trios. "22 Septem¬ ber *43« Test of blood Bonn preserves. 16 January >44: on behalf of tho Military it-dical Academy, 18 ampules of blood serum wore tested on 18 ex¬ perimental subjects. 17 February «44: records of v»st^ sent off." Then ttoro is another such entry on tho 25th of January '4*. aid in tho 22nd of May '44. Can you say anything about this, that is, about tho fact that tho Military Medical Academy sera blood soma to Buchertwald to bo testod on huaan beings thoro? A.- No, I can my nothing about that. I did not know of the ovont or tho reasons for it. DR. KdLTX: lir. President, at this joint 1 should liko to sutmit tho affidavit of Prof. Fr. Konred Lang as HA-38 in Document Book 2, pa go 56. Dr. Lang,whoa I askod for an affidavit as the* only request I ind to make of him, answored the following: "I, Konred Long, herewith staU> under oath the following facto which I km* freo personal knowledge: Tho scrum conserves produced by tho Amy Medical Accdvny »ro supplied to the ana? froe 1941on and later also tho navy and tho naff on SS. All physicians using it wore instructed to report about th. therapeutic success, the compatibility, are! posaiblo incidence so that experiences could be collected. Therefore, a qu-ction- ncire was attached to each ampule. . hen filled c*ut, it had to be returned to the Military 'fcdicnl Academy directly. In addition to that, soao uni¬ versity clinics, municipal hospitals and arc? hospitals currently received •tnoulvs for scientific testing ard research. Also, all medical offficos - 2914 - 12 Fob-A-'JU-U-l-31akle7 (FL) Court Ko. I ■hich »cru supposed to collect their o*r. oxpcrionccs before application on a large scale received cspulea for uxporloental purposes. X - 2914 a - 12 Feb-*- iiA-lA-2-Blfikluy (FL) C eurt Ho. I "The unitary Medical Agadeay did not cemission the Laffer. SS to test serin conserves on prisoners. The entry in the Ding Diary that serin conserves were to be tested upon request of the Military 2-edical A cade ay and again that in the examination findings were to oe *nt away I can only e.plain by stating that all offices which used serin conser¬ ves were generally instructed to report on success, compatibility, and possible incidence. The Military Medical Academy never received any reporte rtiich allowed that they aemnated from concentration camps. I learned from conversations that the SS carried out on Its own initiative the development of blood conserves and blood substitutes. "The good compatibility and din-ability of the serum conserves pro¬ duced by the ."Aiitary Medical Academy was proved by 1941 and documented in scientific publications. From ths oany thousards of reports, one did not learn of a single case which showed permanont damago to health or n fatality caused by these sorua conserves. "I have real, ti^ one pa^e of this aifidavit carofully and signed it with my own hand..." and so ferth. It Is certified by a notary on tho 15th of January 1947. I ask that this accoptod as Exhibit 15. Q.- Son, I ccuo to tho individual casos whoro it must oe uxaminod ae to what your connection was as tho chiof of the ..ohraacht Jtodical Ser¬ vice with tho research conducted in tho branches of tho ..ohraacht. Tho Individual branchos of tho ..ohraacht , as wc know, had their oun research institutes. You have spoken about this already. You have said that these wore primrily ^iccific experiments. Mill you ploaso toll no briofly w*at your powers wore on tho basis of the decree of 1942 in tho field o 1 research which uo have not yet aontic.icd? A.- It is no*bora sot down precisely. Even after 1944 thoro was never any authorization or influence from me as chief of the ’..'ohraacht Medical Service on the specific fields of research of tho Luftwaffe and - 2915 - 12 Pcb-A— IAA-14-2-Blakiuy (FL) Court So. I the navy. Thoso noro fields which "ere specifically connected -rith those branches of tho ..chroacht and wore thus autooatically el Inina tod froa ay duties, vhich - 2915 a - 12 7©b 47-XJUA_14_3-Blakl'ey (MSS) Court So. - • • vera to coordlnata the joint field* of Work. I can, therefore, only BB 7 that I was neither lnforned about the work of theae tranchea of the Mahrmacht nor did I hare any supervision or other influence on thli work. % q But now it hae teen shewn that the Luftwaffe, for example, carried on research which one cannot call specific luftvaffo problems, for example, the typhus question. Shat is your viewpoint on thds question? A Scientific medical research Is a subject which "Is not subject to military orders. It was never the intention and under the decree of '44 It would not hare resulted that the chief of tho *ehmacht Medical Service was tc prevent work's being dono In general flolds of rosorach by anyone Interested and capablo: that ho was to bo eliminated by an ordor that ho could not do It; that all othors could do it. My assignment of '*4 is to bm interpreted to mean that ur— noccoasnry duplication, where It is absolutely dear, and tho uso of porsonnol and materials unnecessarily, aro to bo aroldod as far no nooolblo. I vos to consult tho nodical chiefs of tho various branchos of tho b’ohrmacht and thoir scientific consultants and find vhothor and how wc could contrailto tho matter. ^ If I understand you correctly, you did not havo tho duty in such a caeo of coordinating but you could havo coordinated if It had boon oxpodiont for this flold of research. X First, if I had learned of it and, socond, if according to my information I had had tho impression that this was unnecessary duplication, then 1 would havo tried to prevent this duplication. 14 Did you l«.*rn of the typhus research which the air force carried en? A Ho. I* I must point cut tc you that in the typhus document book 2916 12 Tob 47-A_MAL_14_3-Blaklcy (MSD) Court > 0 . 1 exports jets are sentioncd, conducted by Prof. Haagon, Strasbourg, on bohelf of tho air force and the Beich Scsoarch Connell. Do you rcaaabor that* A Tot. Q Plcaso take this dscsncnt and look at Pago 77 In this docueont book. 2916 A 12 Fob-i-RAA-lWi-Glakloy (MJ) Court 1 That is Docunont :©-306, Exhibit 296 of the prosecution. It is a letter fron Prof. P.oso to Prof. Haagon. A. Sfty I os k for the page again? o, Pago 77, Page 7U fn tbo English document book. The Prosecu¬ tion believes that they sco in this lettor a connection with ytxi, as srdof of the ffohrracht Medical Sorvico, to the typhus research in Stmss- bourgh. ’’That do yea have to say about that? A. It says hero that tho inspector of tho radical sorvico of % tho air force is to approach tho chief of tho Tfohmacht Modical Sorvico with tho re^uost to have typhus vaccinos produced for tho •rforaaoht. I can only say that tho application nado to tho inspoctor was not roallzod. It did not couo to ay attention as tho chiof of tho TTohnaacht Modi col Sorvico. This suggostion to vaccinate tho wholo Eastarn Front is now to no. -2917- i2?ob 4“-A-7T>15-l-Coak S.jri So- 1 ft y c u vlll find la tho b'-cSc bo fori you -a v^o 75, c d;cu.iont, 2?o. 137, 29S, ;ci3 7§ 1 - tho fctlloh Book* 3»at i« ea application -f Jycfosoor ----or v tho Dirqctcr of tho University r.t Strasbourg with roforo^o% to flvo roao-rci nMlps-onta. Do 7^1 kna. tho 3 - rosorrch resilient s? i That la on jrgo SO? * so, rnao 79. • /. Uo, I do not iOCKi til030 r«si0IXBtO> r ’.111 you ploaso look la tho doauriont book on pneo 74. ibis is pocuront !lo. 370, 2 rhiblt 292 of tho Proaocutien. Thla is -a affidavit of tho dofordant, Rudolf Brandt, vhloh Bmolt cavo '- r tho Prcsoouti'-n. Xdode with X orroriEonta la tho coacor.tr-.tl 3 a cmp !l~.tzuoilo»< Tho defendant, rvo Just road fix. Mr affidavit ., 0 . 37C I qurto: "Tr.is prra raph -f r? affidavit d' 4 s r.ot jivo r.ctunl frots. I cana-t cite my c:r.croio fret whloh could eorr.borato tho minion. On tho b-.nlo of tho iatorrofiat-r'a atataunt I as.-urcl that this c'incljod with th- actual fret." I ask that this affidavit ba accoptod as nhibit fr. IS. :-, niaco t:.o 7r-socuti'c haa dm^aod tho charge of hij» altltudo uXynL «r. 3 , wo cr a t.' th^ cold ox. jrl c.ts. oro ccld oxaoriror.ts eoaduetol -r /-ur authority? ”03, cold exaorlronts woro c endue tod by the tolled Schxl in *>• J haii. 29 I 0 12 rob .;7-*--7C-15-2-Cock Court !'• 1 -Toss cold exporir-ents coneomod too adaptation to cold in too nountains for ivumtain troops. ;»s far as I know thay wsro carried out oxcluaivoly on - AT _ -a soldiors. I did not boccto aware that any of tha- sufforod any ior: fr*i tho orporirxinta. -i Hr. Proaidont, in t^is connection, I afcould liko to subdt Docunont :r. 17 - This la an oxcorpt frc;i ra^jasay concerning investigations on olr.ptr.tlon to coll. pocunoat, EL 29, It la in docucent book 3, docunont HA 49, which ia in doexBiont book 3, and la net yot r.Tallatlo to too Tribunal. Shis article which u-3 writtoa b7 Dr. Drier, too has boon ~ontlO-*>d fcovorcl tlnoa huro, concerns *ho ox;oriienta in the U untain PhysiclOt'ia-1 Inatituto at tho £runtaln Uodieal School at St. Johann, which *-t uador tho dofondant, Profoaacr Hr.aUoaor, and contains an oxrct description of hen thoao oxpori"onta wore o undue tod, and it atatoc that tfcoy uoro ccnductod on our own pooplo, our own ooldlora. *;ith tho cuatcrary roaorvation, I aak that this art 1 cl3, which tho author rwntioned in an affidavit by Dr. Kra=or, I aak that It bo ouhittod aa Exhibit !Ic. 1?. Mow tho Droaocution haa oroaontod on oxoorpt frx: tho report of too rooting ccncominc winter dtotrosa and diotrooa at coa er. tto 26th and 27th of Octotor, 1942, lr. ltobors* I sh-.ll haro you ohown too docuunt book on tho oolu oxporinonts. it is D'Ommt Ho. 401, exhibit 93 of tho rr socution, and in Docunoat gook 3, pago *. You will find thoro r. liat of too participants in this cootlrg. Ia this :eotlng* Dr. Kraner free. st. J Shaun* a —— WS :?^3IDSrrs -hat waa tho mnbor, ?loaso, tho nunbor cf tho document? DP.. 172.73: Decuront 401, Exhibit 93, prgo 79. It la r. Proeocutlon Docunont, yturncnor, Document Sock Mo. 3, aafio 79. BTD2. 1*3L3: Did you over rocoivo a report o:. too locturo cf rrcfoeeor Holzlochnor tt this nootlng? Ho. a ?ollcwino this nootlng thoro soans to have boon contact botwoen Dr. Kr-cior, as tho officer of tho Amy Mountain Modical School and Dr. Daschor, tho woll 'am a oxaorinqntor at Dachau. aa anything rorortod to you or did you loarn 2919 yob 47-A-?J0-15-3-Cock •-.thins of this contoot? It wna not roy-artai tc no olthar offlc-ily, or unofficiftliy, my connection hot*»on Krrz or mi Hoscbor. n r -3 tho connection to two 3 n tha /jry llcdintnln Jlodicftl School ad tha Crs^lv.-i 30 r -t Dachftu roymtod to you? So, i*sfl I should llico t-> ary tfcrt I m crnrincoi that tha vary strict C^nzi Officer ox* tta I'ount-.in Uodic-1 School nt St. Johann would cortoinly ;-.to ro^ort-4 that to the Amy Medical Inspectorate. o :Cr. Trosidont, I rhculd 11 to to sub:dt on affidavit of Dr. Xrmor end rito of Dr. Schcoffor. Dr. Xrmor soyt tho following, rad i quoto. That la X ryjcvxont HA 37, docur-ont beck 2, pneo K. Dr. scya tho fullawl-i: •I rjtondoi ns ri rojjrosontfttlTo th-* riountrln Uodicnl School tl.o ooaforoaco on tha ^bloi-s of 1 aw torporr.taros which was hold in Nurnbort; In tho fr.ll of 1042. I llstonol to tho locturo by rrofossor Hclnlochnor and tho ra/ffka rn .io luring tho diucunsica by Dr. anchor. On uy wry b-ck to st. Johrum, I hftTpoaol to sh-.ro until Ijialch, tho cai^xtraont with Dr. Roochor. Only oneo Dr. Dnschor :;ontlonad briofly his axporliionta nad doscrlbod tha. in tho .'oli-wirvi w-yj 1. .Irporirontal subjocts: Tti oy woro hardoood orl.lnds sontoncoo tc dor.th »:.c had volunto.rod for tho Dachau ox.-orii^nts to bo glvon lifo end liborty i*.Tine prosed threuflh tho oxnorinont. 2. St-xirir'onts: Tho arranGor-onto for tho scientifically oonductod ax*orlnonts \r s cueh that tho oa-orir.ont.-l Jubjoctc sural va if yosnlblo. 2. Results: As lifo-nrosarrim; aoasuro for yoc ylc who 'save boon axposod ic lew ta/or-turcc, - hat bath of ap toxI: r.toly 50 1c>,/rco3 is .'.vat fo-oiblo. To whet an axtont tLa doneri^ti n by Sasebor io in accordance with tho ono Jv-.a by bin and rrofaac r Holxloahcar at tho oenforonoo, or wunt boy :vd it, I c\a r.o lotv,or rucoll. 1 - -oil calculated contrast to thoso ox-orL-onie with hx.m beings, which •7 solLaoarators and i c^pcsol, .and which, as fax nB I know, woro novor ai>-rovod •7 tho .jiy I-odlcftl Inspect3r~to altaor, I cutllc&i for Dr. Roschor tho minor - »V0, in 3t. J.-hgpp, h r£ »i tho ox;xirLaauts cancorninA -tdjustr.or.t to ~nd hc-j wo :v.d :-.a3o yropprr.ti czs for thcxi with 'M -—.1 axyorir^nts. 2520 12 ?ot 47-V.-JT C-15-4— Cook Court - 0iu7 R^® ild 1 1 ° 4 '- ra free 3ocuiant !>o. 1519-25 thr.t Dr. R-schor pictured thoso 4j 0 ra -s :*_ia on rj id that ho clftlr-od that i dosiroi to ccooor-.to with hin. ; pointed out I aont this docuront to Dr. Hmr-or t >t St. Johann. •Xn St. Johann, wo conduct®! oxpcrlronts ns to tho adjustment to cold usias 5UTJC1V03 f'S.i. soldiers of tho jury Mountain Mod to School as axnorlLoatnl subjects, ns doscribod la the attached study tafera free tho Clinical TTookly P071CW." That Is tho document which I sutelttod. * 2921 12 -Gross 0 urt I »2von -ftcr Dr. Rnacher's 1-ttor cl 12 fov-rsb-r 191*2, nc further c-nnoction .ltr. Dr. .tascbcr cr a collatorsti rx with I>i—which could havo boon arranged only thr.ufh th- -xay : cdical Inspectorate, vns accomplished. -3 far as I rcs-ob-r tort letter me never ^ar.st/-r-c'. •The lurt:»j: collatomtiun watch Ur. H-schor wanted was a uppoewd to consist of Dr. Rase ho r torr-ving scientific A^cilr-r. anc. tools fro-. the institution ,t 5t. Johan.i. I particularly rut- bor that ho asked whether it. J?4ht a. feasible to *nlco avrliable e Haldane apparatus tor the analysis of respiratory jjascs. "he loan cf any appliances fr ur institute would'hr.vc nocossitctod i written request irax Dr. Raschtr lexica ic.rl t; oe eutrittod for decision to the .jvo' ideal Inspectorate. Such an lie tion of Dr. Rnsehor, as far ns I Know, rv.vcr readied St. Johann wncr-upcr. it w-s necessary t. -.id c r_,>ort to tho .juy 1 otJic.nl Inspector* to. ncith.r .if I cutnit a r-. rt -.b ut the Nurntorg ceaf-jxnco to th. ..ray rad cal insjxct rate. °1 intonwed Dr. Seh-~f-r, whi at th*t tine was ay ccrrvjid-r, i n the conversation with Dr. P.nscher a .Vi his letter t a-. ’’In ccncluai n I would like a *in t emphasise th-t at notirao any collaboration between Dr. RascL-.r a..J t»v unt-.ln fhyai> logical institute c thj ..rty Uiuntair. cdicnl School, hlch I c c-uctud, w?a x<-ugi;'- ~b ut boc.auoo »u di< : n.i* d sire it ner -fply tor it." I ask to-t this .dfidavit bc.-ccepted as Exhibit 18. The next -xhibit is the dfidrvit of Dr. Schaefer, the Ckxanneiing Olficor of tile . udic'.l School - Hocunont :u-J*2 - Docufv-nt Bo .k II, pa&e 66. ’1R. ‘ Cri.JfE'.t This drcur_nt vp-~rs cn pa.'c 66 -f ’ -ndlcser IXcu.wnt Book II. Fr s.cuti-n rbjects t its adsisaibility n the sr unds to t it is at sworn to r. r cji-tlfl. ! before c H.t-ry .vblic r r. Kcltc -s ttofense c unsel. •fc. hlLTifj I do mt kn w whether r. IcHnnoy h~.s soon tills Certiflento of the *J tary /.ncoloch en the ri^inai, rhe aiiidcvit is certified cs follows i ■I certified hore-t this document. ft oath was a&sinistored in so f-r a ir r.pjoars in this str-.tc.t-nt, n r is thcro anythin; 'miah indicates that the certifyir.i -uthority had tl~ right t< ac-inistcr an .nth, let ale no that irv- was - c : mistered. 0 have offeree several dccuacnts'w’.icb wero cortifivjd in exactly tnc srau aanr..r Which ix.ru objected to an’ e/ccludtd cn the saao grounds I m new urging t th. Tribunal. DS. NSLTEi It is correct that tils dc-cxsMnt is n t s*-rn. The heading -bow, this d :cu..kjnt roads: ".’.ffi davit". It c itinucs, "Up.n t»to request of Dr. Nolte, Defense Counsel ef f.« farter 'ucneraloburstabsarst Prof. Hind loser, I -r.k. the followin', st tJi-ni?" Tht is, in goner* 1, according to rules valid in fr-ro-ny sufficient I .signatc the d'.cuo_nt s r.n vit. If tho C.urt wishes that * further ox. rose r t'tea-nt bo raado in this f.ru "I herewith docl-.ru up n..oth" tb-n I .*bk that this drcuuuni bexcoptod tempo¬ rarily one’ that a special statcoont frer Or, Schaefer is submitted l*tcr that he hrs nndo this strtea.nt exprjssly as .an affidavit. THn S.'.ioITYT* Tho Tribunal will.xcopt th. exhibit pr vioionally subject t c it ooit.r 1-ter shewn that tiv. atat-v-nt was sir rn tc er w s -.da in liou .f .atb under pucaltios of f-lse sr.^arin, r o-r^^ry. -*t ary be .-aark-d "jr- visi nelly *' dttod". !lf.. iMLTEt To- drcxrent reads ns .ell.ws? JJCG: That is the exhibit n t-b-r -tf this d-cunurt? DR. HE1TS: exhibit 19, D.cumont Ljck II, p\gc 66. Dr. Sch-ofcr lakes tiu f ;1 lowing statoKonti "1. The «rxy ' .untain Lo 'ic-1 Sc.i .1, w'rjch I cc»a4J, -was OJroctly Mberdinato to the CJCK/.i'ry tceicr l Inspoct-'ratc. ?r a its oegirming 2923 jp y b- - > >co C urt I Cerurilcb_ret=bscrst Prcf i nr. Haadloacr na -r^y i^dlcil Inspector until iit v'S r.pointed Cnief of tnc cchiricht . cclicnl Service. "2. lie cat-oliahed this school ?jji 1 t 1#; the Tribunal bio exhibit nurib-jra of theso dccurents which have alrea y boon add ttod, it will bo convenient. y\. KSLCEi Mo. 2£2. As I bare alraa.v said, Daca-unt Book 13. q In addition to the report already aontxeaod., rhleh you did net knew, there is also Dccuren. NO 372, r.n affidr.vit fron the tofWiicnt Ibi.olf Brandt, wto soys that in a’diUon to Xnrl Bran\t an’ tho oMur .ereonj nenclonod, Smdloscr an’ tostock mist have k:own cf tU'.? fxporicnnts. I thoreforo ask you, !i:' you learn of any Lee 6 Gas axpari^jnts such as wore tho oubloet of tho Prosocuiion's case horo? A Jfc® Or<. KELTEi !tr. Prosi tort, in this connection I suLait an affi 'avit fron Pr. Rudolf Brandt, r«ocuiv>nt i' Bocuuont “-ok 2, pag® 3, as drJidit 22. to-Velf "randt s.ysi "In ry affi-nvit date.! Hi Ooto’ er 195.6 (Docun;nt 10-372) I tortifio • t n ail.- knwlo -a of tho LOST Cdustar l) jas .aporl- nonts on hurrn subjects. ibo lost prra T.iph subsequent to this tpstinory reads as fellows: • In addition to Karl Braadt an’ the other persons nontiorwd above, Han'loser and tcstcck roust have had knu rled o of -hose experiaents.* 2B29 12 ?eb. U7^-T>.l?-2-i-UMer Court Ho. 1 ■Concorairv" this I dadaro tto following "I# etc tenant In this case is a -nro assucntion which I pronounced only in reply to a correspond q -ostion of the interrogator. I car. d no factual data for this assumption. I te^e never had ary associations, neither official nor privrte, with Professor Bandloso:-,* I ask that this affidavit ho accosted ns SUhihit 22. Q Professor Han J l-Ser, in the various counts of tiio^in.’ictoir.t it is royoato 1 y said, an*, a/nin in tho Iv:st Onu torments, that your responsi¬ bility oan bo do Mood froa too fact that tho experirvonte *^ro oon&otad in the interests of tho HbwU. T shoal' lita to ask y u to «oy whether any exporlaonta conhictod hero of which it is said they were on bohfllf of tho Wohnaicht, rvjcossarily had ary connection with tho agencies of tho Kohnaoht as insti_ftto.-s or as participants? / 2930 12 Feb 47- Z5H-13-1- He eh an- (AX) oooaf i A. I ojb considering what example one should give. C n o oust realize that, for example, lr the whole flold of coamunloaOlo diaoasos th*c the Wofcrsiobt particularly during the war was espeolally. interested; but these are fields where oven under normal circumstances and especially ucaer the living conditions, which beoaco constantly worso duMng such a large war, tho wholo state Is equally Interested. As I have already said, that not only the rosouoh workers of the 'iehrmacht woie Interested, but every research verkor who conscientiously took an Interest In such things - arid I should like to add that fornerly the '/etrnaoht was predom¬ inately interested In the thingo and problons dealing with wounds, but in this war that was changed completely. Through the air raids, winch had oxlcted for yea-s and wore constant¬ ly increasing, which or.e could compare with a heavy barrage, of gun-fire on the civilian population, the doctors at homo were equally interested in wour.de, injuries, and burns as the doctors at tho front, so that llr.-ly one oan say not only In the field of Internal medicine and the flold of oora- cuniontlvo diseases, but also in tho entire floict cf Injuries the interest was definitely a common or.e and one onn no lon¬ ger spoolfy WohrmROht interest. Q. You taho as an example opldeulca.-. 'diioh aro probab¬ ly especially convincing, but I should like to come buck to your statement of till* morning where you spooouaont HA-5-A In Do cum on t 5ook No.l, page 29. This shows that tho duty of the eodloal offlocrs in tho roar areas was to care for tho civilian population and tho Prlsonors of 'far. I offer this Doounont as Exhibit No. 24. I offor tho affidavit of Qonoralarrt Dr. tfaltor ponnor, HA-6, eoouaont 3ook No. 2, Pago 4. It contains a gonoral presentation of tho observations of Qonoralarrt Dr. Ponnor of tho dofondant Handlosor. I do not want to offor that In this connection, but I should like to oorao book to tho letter. Tho reason why I oonticn it .* f is tho fact that Dr. Ponnor points out that Professor Handlosor Issued orders corresponding to humane treatment and dealing with tho uodloal caro to bo given tho population of tho oocuplod terri¬ tories. With tho approval of tho Prosecution, I should llko to offor this Docuaont as Exhibit 25 without roadlng It. and now I havo two special Documents of tho Swedish Colonel, Dr. v. Erlach - Ha- 7 in Document 3ook 2, Pago 7. This Document I should not like to road In Its entirety, but only insofar' ns it contains the question, which wo havo dealt with, tho treatment given tho Prlsonors of War and Professor Handlosor 1 s connection with this natter. Dr. v. Erlach, who was chairman of tho Kodlcal- Cocci 8- 29*2 ?.2 Fe'J 47-i3»-18-a-Heahan-(aJC) XAJRT 1 elon In Goraany frca Hie suaner of 1940 until the lato fall of 1944, jcnew conditions in Germany. Ho Units his tostio- ony 29 •'2a 12 ?eb 47- £5ri- 18 - 3-haohan- C AX ) COURT I alnco ho doals with throe nationalities and not the Russians. Ho says: ■Tne medical care gl\on to the prisoner! of war Is Ger- B ,m Prisoner of Var Camps and. hospitals for prisoners of y»r can generally bo celled good. The offocts of the p u-tlc- A lpatlon and use of 'enemy doctors 1 for taking caro of tho P07' s w \s particularly beneficial. Cooperation between tho Gorman crop doctors and tho enemy doctors was ^ratifying In gonoral. In tho course of the war, tho Sermon comp doctors and tho onony doctors was gratifying In gonoral. In the oourse of tho war, tho Gorman crop doctors wenv professionally used also outsldo tho comps to take caro of cho civilian populat¬ ion. and had, tho-oforo, booonc ovorburdoned with work to auoh on exto.ot that tne prioonors of war wore in nor.v casos almost exclusively in tho caro of enemy doctors. •Until tho onu, thoro wjre ol .nr difloronoos in the .nodical caro given to tho prison.*.'! of var In tho varlouo 3orvloo Commands. This olrcuasta*!.'. » l .-ajiy 3.novci how very ouch dopendad also In this case on the personal lty of the nodical, officer l.n charge of such a command, and of his assistant handling mattors concornlr.g Prlsonors of far. Deficiencies obsorvod w.?ro regularly comunlrntod to tho ropro3ontatlVGs of the Armed Forces High Com- nd, the prisoner of war organization, to tho medical Inspectorate, as well as to a representative of tho Foreign Office, at tho closing mooting of tho mixed commission. Tho medical Inspectorate, which subsequently became the Medical Services of the Arced Forces, often 2_33 12 ?eb 4?-.W?-18-la-Keehar-fcAX) COURT I issued special lnstruotlor.8 to the nodical officers In charge of Service Connande during tho tlno until the next ncoting of tho nixed commission, In order to remove tho doflcloncios vhloh had boon orltlclzod at tho closing mooting. ■It must, therefore, bo stated that Goneraloborsti- 3 arrt Prof. Dr. Handlosor omitted nothing to lmprovo the medical care of the prisoners of rfar during tho rforld War - 19*9 - 1945.■ Then It goes on to say: The second question: "Did the medical care -considering tho possibilities existing In Gomany - correspond to tho provisions of tho Genova convention and to tho principles of generally practiced nodical treatment of human beings?" The answer: '.vs soon no the provisions of t*K Geneva Convention had boooac Known to all Oernan gene 1 os concerned, the -fodloil oaro In Germany corresponded In general with tho principles of the Geneva Convention. "The chairman of the nixed medical oocalsalons wore able to state that good will prevailed and that efforts voro made to observe the provisions of the Genova Convention. “The Gonoraloborsta'oaartt Prof. Dr. Handlosor always favored a .nodical - humane treatment of the Prisoners of •far. ^0 a coneequonoo of the development of tho war In the -iroctlon of a 1 total w>ir' in particular, however after • risonera of ./ar questions ease under Himmler's Jurisdlc- -lon In J u ly 1944, the fate of Prisoners of 'far became scr. si durably worse also In its nodical - human aspects. This applied in particular to members of enemy air forces. The x-raying of Prisoners of Har was United to a nini.-.un owing 29 "*4 12 Fab 47--JMM-Keohan-(420 COURT I M the shortage of x-ray flU.a, lr. the samo way, tho supply of tho Prisoners of War with artificial tooth broke down progosalvcly. •But I would like to state uxpllcltly that this (••.Tid¬ ed turn for tho worse in the faio of tho Prisoners o£ Vnr eccurrod completely outside Gonoraloborstabsarrt Professor Dr. Handlosor's Jurisdiction.■ ' 29*4a 12 ?ub-v-J?-l3-2a-iLchan C'-urt I I will not road the Answer tc Ifurfc.r t'areo, because it c-nc^rns the personality of Dr. -mdlcs-rj I will dc f.rt Inter, Vith reference t this . D>cuiont, I effor this atqtenant cl fTefoSSor Dr. v. Erlnch as Exhibit "o. 26 Tffi P.l SIDEHT* The Tribunal will n*w b_ in recess. (j, r-ecss was taken.) a * 2?35 iL rub 47—A-3JG-20-1—Putty-(«K) OtfJnT I TKi .iARShAL: Tha Tribunal ia again In ness.™. 3R. .I2LT2: I now want to offer to tha Tribunal Documont An. H.V-i€ in document beck No. 2 on page ?0, and * of fur • t >m m r 27. This ia an answer to tho questions to Oolcn.i rr-nuier ac huoo'.'.acht In Zurich, a phy«loirx vfii: /.nows conditions ir. Goruar.y -.s a rusult of bio ofx'lclal. task. If tha J-rcauoutlon dees r.ov put *«y epanlal emphasis o.n * ic, I dc r.ot want to' read «..* anotors, because in general tha an-vers contain tha aaao .'ud^.jpt vbiob was -uw j>;pros3- ad by Dr. vor. Srloofc and which I have alroaiy presorted. Tha only chirg ci importun-: u. •• t. bo 1: ;;uo3._cn ::;ur.ber 2 that tho oodlcul owe wan In avoordanoo with tho Ik nova oon- vcr.tlnr. and '.ntsrra'ota? lav that human audicnl trontoont was gtvun. "ir. any ( as long r.r I worked ir. -Vaiuany us ofcairaan of r. nod 106?. commission -rco June, 1C40 to 13^2." In this casa i-ieo T. would like to lutor cn road tho character Judgment of Professor -xi that to when ?.‘3l086or Hondlosor 1? »ot or. th-. vet.:;* stand ...•.ynoro I new offer this document as ikhibit k? /u.S nqusas vuat It bo admit to 1 lr. evidence. 31 PR. HELT2; C* I rofcvt-cr Kundlf -«r, J sa now handing to you document be 3.t number 10 abxit su^ ran alio arpi-rlaonti. In tl.ls book In page 94 y.u *.iii find Dormant v:iioh Is oor.tair.od In doaunont book aumbor 10, ah hi bit 2*1. C.a this document .io. 472 on page 94 there Is ^ affidxv.lt by or. Ftaofior. Da. X2L/2: It Is cr. po^o 96 of tn « rng.'.isb deouaont book. Because cf paragraph 7 of this affidavit, the Prasoout- ior. has presented It In tho accusation oi.d In tha case against Hinilosor, and paragraph 7 statos: 2~/*6 12 Fab 47-ir-DJ(j-2p-l“?uity-( aX) COUaT I ■Whan tho sulfanllaalde experiment started, I vae told by Profoasor Oo'ofcardt, =jr military and xedloal auporlor, that those experiments were oarrlad out by order of the Chief of the Medical Office of the Wehnnaoht and tho Ghlof of the Medical Offlco of tho State." Q. Did you aa Chiof of tho Kohrcacht Moilca^ Sorvlco or In any other capacity glvo auch an ordor to Professor Gobhardt, or dld»you paa3 It on froa a higher agency, accord¬ ing to which the experiments carried out by 29*6a 1 z r- , .rarry-i-rj>2^-s-putt7 C-urt i'o. 1 - r# Qc’:fc«'-rdt, Oborsouaor and Tiaeh^r vcro ordered? i B3. 293? 12 Feb ,7-«-PKP-21-l-3oard-(.,X) COURT I V .ay It please the Tribunal, I ac now presenting two affidavits by Dr. Gobhardt and Dr. Fischer. This la H r-8, In Doouaur.t Book 2, pogo^l2, and I offer it as Sxhlbit 28i Dr. Fritz Flachor states In this affidavit: "I ha/e signed an affidavit which in the preaont trial has been submitted as evidence by the Prosocutlon. 0 In paragraph 7 of this affi¬ davit It is stated, and then follows what I have Just read. .»nd, I contlnuo with the affidavit of Fischer^ "This affidavit originated under circumstances which I an going to explain In detail when I shall be questioned on the wit¬ ness stand. In reply to Professor Dr. Handloser's Defense Counsel, I declare that It Is not oorrect to oay In the affidavit Professor Dr. Gobhardt had told ao that the 4 experiments aust be perforaed by order of the ohlef of the Medical office of the .»rnod Foroos. Nor did I mako suoh a statement. I oust eaphaslzo In this connection that the interrogation took place In the English language, and that tho above affidavit datod 21st ootober 19-46, represents a summary of a long Interrogation record. This summary, which was drawn up by combers of the Prosecution Stiff, was submit¬ ted to ce ready for signature. !•, cysolf, don't raastor the English languago sufficiently well to have ayself noted this nl8understandlr.g, but since I have, ;aysolf, no knowledge of such in order cf the ohlef of tho Medical Sorvlcos of the .*rcod Forcos, Professor Dr. Handlosor, I hereby rectify Item seven of ay affidavit, dated 21 October 19-16. ■ I request that this Dooucent oo‘ adaltted as Exhibit 26 . In the affidavit, H.r-9, Document 3ook 2, Page 14, which I u. presenting as Sxhlbit 29, Dr. Gobhardt has stated the 29 T 3 12 Fob rKr- 21- i- 3 card-( ) XUriT X following: "It Is not true that 1 ovor told Dr. Frits Fischer that those experiments wore being carried out by ordor of tho Chief of the hodloal Office of the tfohrsacht. In tela connection Dr. •Flachor must have nade a mistake, or the affidavit dated 21 October 1946 must have been baaed upen a nlsunderstanding of the facts glvon bv Dr. Frits Fischer. At any rate, I as not aware of any suoh order from the Chief of tho Kodlcal Service of the Vohrmaoht, Profoasor % Dr. Handloaer. Ilor did I dlsouse It with Professor Dr. Hand- losor before tho beginning of this experiment. The uxporlaonts for testing the aulfsnanldos wore oarrlod out on Hitler's and Hlnalor's orders, upon dlreot instructions from the Soloh Phyalolan SS and Police, Dr. Oravlts." 29*8a 12 Fobi 47 -..-21-2-PKP- d.ert do. 1 I roqueat tret this af fi_rvit be admitted as rb-hibit 29. Tht »'s Professor (hibhardt's conn-ctlrns to you? ... Pr.fcsaor Gw’ohardt *.-v-r rec-ivo '.ny invitati n to ctt.n'. it. Did you ev.r f-.ve r.y official contact with nurslm: hocao at H’henlychun? A. I did not h-.ve any official contact; hrsicvor, I aust st.atu h-re that the f-LI s in inci/ent occur re' : It ar.y probably h've Va in tlx> ye-r rf 1942 ahon C-nti or Gebhardt, I do not ivaunber -x c*ly "ny aaro, c-j^j to o.. xno in ny fficj it Berlin, nd they requested to enter the humtoriun «f srm. rurrixv h ne at i.oh-nlychen. I would not be spending cy tine to nuch in ray oth.r way, lout after the nun h:d au&cateC Dr. hrldaann, since he had eon in th; i.urrteriur.; they r.ls» cxei^r-i. it doain le th t 1 , :s a successor, would clso -.iter th- roup. I had no cause not to c.ply with tlv request, :n there x'.s n» caur- for aijr objection on oy part, . . uid you participate in ny Section of the Kui-toriurj, tliis c-j»dUce? «. I two not p-rticip-t i* ir. any discuss! -n not h-vu I ever r-c-ive-' an invitati n t. atteu ouch a c-nf.r.nce. Q. The Prosecution has atrte her-, in c-nn-ction with tho Confi.renco of -.r.cultin physicians in 1944, has described H -h^nlychen here as the center of th. jo. Can yeu state -nythin in c nn-cti n witn it? .. Y~s, I c-n =rk- the following st tenant: I cann. t un'erst'ixi this ipini-r. ‘—cause orior to th. war Hohenlych-n was a well kn un h spit l Center which, ,-a f r -o I kn w, w?-s 'Is well kn:wn utsitt- ->f GcmaQjr, ' r. wh-re fr n "11 circl_s if the popul ti :n, patients were accepte ' there. «r. 1 , wh. r. a v. all, 3 -r was r ctic. . in sp.cial fields, an- whore special confidence hi;- -ine ’ in tills field. As f r 38 I C-n r -ea-.r n* fr noj a-nory, I can state 293*5 1 2 Fe'o. Ll ~k~Zh~y-7S^- 3c-“ rc J.urt :.»• I th“.t ?•_ had an uxc o llont aurjicnl s~Mcl. - .llat, but trwy ooiieVe' they could ,*.ly + helped at K h-nlych-n. Thia applioe ala a ta L ‘uriw8 jccurr«-d in sp>rta, sapeclnlly injuries to the joints of the kn-oa. Ar. , ' 1 .ut thu center of the SS, I understand :ny institution which works . strictly recording to the politic.” 1 practice f the SS, but which i$ not r. hospital with three hun.h-ed civilian y tier.ts ir n LI class-s A the papulation, rv’. with three an.' f.ur hundred w ended an. aick soldiers a? the Luhnnacht, :.ni furthu'raore on d/itixir 1 three hun'r- injure! an’ aick patients -f thu aff-n-3S ..r« lccatw .. hh*t I want t- sr.y is, th t according to the whole c.natell ti r., I la not fine ny cause to &eo that th-n.spital at H-henlychen ar.s the center .f t!>* SS. In -rdvr to aok- this at~teaer.t caapl-tu, I .nly •ant to re.: hur- that 1 h ve »»-n Hah-nlycncn f >r thu first tiao; that I hav. vicito' SeVer~.l at-.tiona there or. the occasion of th- Cunforonoc A the „ nsultln. Physicians in Iday 1944.. 294C 12 Feb r-J P-22-1- 31 nkloy- (*eC) COURT I The facilities thoro, especially those for the sub¬ sequent treatment of severe Injuries and where arms and logs wore again rostered to activity, were so Impressive to no that later In 164-. I sent ay son there. Ho had boon aoveroly injured In the Caucasus and was sovoroly hanporod In breathing because of four of five operations in his chest. I also brought hin to Hohenl ychen buoaueo, I have Ator on rope-tod, I could not have round any bettor Institution for V that purpose; and I roally would had quite a numbor of hospitals at ay disposal for ny son. Q. *hy was Hohonlychon selected for the conforonco in Hay 1944? .». It was selected for the following reasons. Tha previous conferences took plnco In the Military Medical Academy at 3orlln; also the conference of May, 194*. Ever after the air attaoks on Berlin In the fall of 194*, which increased to an enormous -xtent every nonth, the Military Medical .icad-tyr had sufforod some sort of danago In every¬ one of the air attaoks. After the rovoro attacks In the aiddlo of Fooruary and In March and In .,prll cf the year 1944 the Academy had bojn damaged tc such an extent that It could not be utillxod at all ..ny more. In addition to this, because of the constant air alarms, oven If no actual attaoks were taking plnco, there would have bo-n no possib¬ ility In Sorlin or in Its vicinity to hold any mooting thoro whore after all two hundred to throe hundred physicians had t- be billoted there for a period of two days. Therefore, I was confronted by the problem when I come to Berlin on one occasion in .*>rll of actually net knowing where I should go for this conferenco whoso preliminary work had .already been concluded, at that tine Prof. Gobh-irdt 2941 12 Feb 47-A-JP-22-1—Eiacley-(AK) COURT I offerel Hohenlyohen to ne; and I really was very glad to accept this offer which later on was confirmed by the Reich8fuehrer. Hohenlychen was about ninety Kilometers * from Berlin; and around the vicinity there, not only in the vicinity of the hospital but throu-ihout the region, no bomb had ever been dropped; and we actually were able undisturbedly to carry on the conference from the 16h to the 22nd. That was the only re-son why this conference took place at Hohenlychen. 2941a 12 Feb 4?-A-JP-*22-2~Blakley-(AX) COURT I Q. At the conference at Hohonlyohen In 1944 how many reports were presented^ A. Outside of the printed report, 168. q. How many of these were by 38 physicians? A. Three. Q. On Page 96 of the document book you will find NO- 619 about the meeting and conference at Hoher.lyohen. This la Exhibit 2*6. About this list of the participants Dr. Fischer states in one of his affidavits that tho lists contained In Document 619 are representative lists of all these who participated in all four conferences. Is that correct? A. No. In this case it was forty. In this caso Fischer Is mistaken. Tho participants in the four conferences voro only In part tho same; and probably it should not be a representative list but lists of thoso prosent. Q. I think that it should be a representative list; that thoso participants actually roprooent tho conspirators in their entlroty who regularly attended the conferences of tho consulting physicians. Perhaps Dr. Fischer has not meant it In this way; out that is tho vay in which It was p.-osentod hero. a. Yell, this is completely out of tho question because the participants in thoso conferoncos which took place participated for tho following reasons. Tho Wohrmacht bronchos wore able to express tholr wish os toward the sub¬ jects Co bo discussed as well as those w ho woro working tho spoochos. Thon these pooplo who had to be there were soiocted by mo either because they were to glvo *». speech or because they ver- told to participate in discussions or because they wore specialists in tho particular field. 2942 12 ?ob 47--JP-22-2-EIakley-(AO COUAT I Of tho number which resulted then there wore those who had to participate In an official capacity. There were a certain nunbor of nodical offloors from the nodical Inspectorate of the tfehrnaoht branohos. ttl*n It was determined how many persons could still be accoenodatedf ; and this number was divldod into army. Vehrmacht, Luftwaffe, the toff on 33, the labor sorvloe; and then it was left to the branches of tho Wohrmaoht to send whom they wantod to the plaoos which % wore put at their disposal . 2 3 4 2 a 12 Feb 47-A- JP- 22- B- Pu tty- (AK J COURT I Therefore, regular members vfere only those who had southing In particular to do with It In tboir official capacity or with regard to their skill. q. Now, let us refer again to the experiments at Havonsbruck. It has been determined that you did not have anything to do with the beginning and the execution of theao experiments of Prof. Qobhardt and Dr. Fischer. 71th rogard to these oxporlmonts which were oarrlod out at Ravonsbruok, were there any lectures held by Prof. Dr. Gobhardt and Dr. naoher on tho Invitation of tho conferonco In Kay 194* at the Military Hodlcal Academy? Did you attend tho spooohos by Prof. Gobhardt? A. I assume yes. Q. You say you are making on assumption. Don't you know that for cortaln? A. Yea. I really oannot romembor the spoooh any more. However, It Is actually Impossible that I should not have boon thoro because In the oourso of that oonferenco tho first day I mado an official and rather long addross. I oponed the oonforenoo and then built the fraoovork of tho specialist group for surgery; and thon tho working soaslon of tho surgory groups cooaoncod. In this conference about six or seven locturps wore given on sulfanlllcldo expo-d^ents; and I aesumo for cortaln that I attended. I cannot remombor tho addross; I oannot remember any details. It may bo that after I came from ray opening speech thon I occuplod rayself with all the oth^r questions. I can only say one thing. It did not have an effect on me to the extent that I was especially Impressed or that he should have given mo any cause to reach some conclusions. 294.7 12 Fabr. U7-’-23-l-?FP-Cook (IL) Court So. 1 Q Then I cannot actually address any further question to you with «n objective content. Therefore, I ct. only «*sk you questions -ftcr you h-’ve received knowledge here of wh’t has been add here. How do you explain the fact that this lecture did not c->us« -ny oartlcular re¬ action of yourself, la there* any plausible explanation for that? * Yes, there la only one expiration, that the lecture according to It's fara-tlon and after the description cf the courso of the A redlcsl treasures caused the lsoresslon that they had been done in accordance with the rules of the nedlc »1 profession. X Q If aftor the ccncluslon of every locture a discussion took place, ■ore you present at the dlsousslona? » Tes, I «o quite certain of that. Q Did anybody make objections then with reference to the lectures by Oebh-rdt -nd Flschor? * As I gather free the report of Dr. Sohwelss, speaking on the subjoct Immediately aftcrw»rts, and -t the conclusion of the sulfana- llalde loctures there were about six or seven, to which those of Oibh-rdt and Fischer also belonged, about six or sc von people spoke in tns courso of the discussion. Q Did r.ot any cueplaint reach you subsequently through official channels or any voice of opposition? A Neither after the lecture, not In the recess which was called, nor during the lunch which was also taken In the 'cadesy or In the course of the day or the following day or -ny othir tlno nobody -pprorehed bo In *ny »»y, who expressed th-t he had the Impression tht something wijust was being done here which would cll for oppo¬ sition. Q H«d the lecture by Gebh»r*H and Fiacher been submitted to you before the conference? A No, that would h pvc been screwh.-t difficult because in the first h.^lf of the month of 'J- y, 19U3, I carried out Inspections In Italy, 'rrece «nd Crete, and then I returned to Berlin and I stayed there for - 29LU - 12 Febr. b?-*-&-l-ffP4ook (IL) Court Ho. 1 * very short period of tire and then I went by pl*ne to the head¬ quarters, »nd I snly returned to Berlin - very short tine before the conference, but even In the course of =y very brief stsy In Berlin, where I certainly •eked tho working staff of the conference If ev;ry- • thing w»s going In order, because It w's r»ther difficult to organise sore thing of this kind, and If ttere were »ny special questions, nothing w.-s brought to ay attention, -«ny oc«pl»lnt "bout the lectures »nd about the course of the coeing conference. Q kjy it please the Tribunal, with regard to this complex, I request te present the following document, first of »11 affidavit by Frofessor Dr. Frey, Document H5-10, Document Book 2, page 16, which I offer as Ejdilbit Ho. 30, Professor Prey's answer to the question: " 's f»r *s tho field of sulfonamide cxoorlrents rod exporlronts with bone, nusclo «nd norvo regeneration, *s well «s bone transplant¬ ation, Is concerned, can you say fron your tedlcal Inspoctor, ordered experiments In contradic¬ tion to "11 recognized nodical nod scientific methods?" *Se answer reds w follcwst "I know Prof. Dr. Hndloaor in his edacity -8 Chief of the kehrnacht Mrdloal Service -nd Arry ttJdlcal Inspector. I do not know »nd have never heard, th-t he or any of his offices carried out or ordered ary experiments In contradiction to recognized radical ond scientific net hod a. According to sy knowledge of the character of Prof. Dr. H«ndloscr I cannot Imagine that he erdered or even cpproved of such experlrcnta.'' I now request tht this affldrvit be *adttod as Exhibit No. 30, ’nd a further affidavit of the av» Professor, in which Dr. Frey de»la with the irpresslons during the lecture by Dr. Gebh*rdt «nd Dr.Fischer, -nd states here: "In the lectures of Gebh-’rdt rod Fischer, which Is nenticned In this letter of 2? ef January, 19li3 is contained - report pbout the result of - 29L5 - 12 ?ebr. Ii7- *-23-2 -PKP-Cook (IL) Coart Ho. 1 series of exoerinents which »« cerrfsd out simultaneously on hua-'n beings. This series concluded and after the series had been coapleted * repetition of the series was out of the question. In the lecture in question we discussed people who had been condemned to de»th end that experiments on concentration crap inmates were carried out ’gainst their will was not exoressed. So far as I know I personally o-intain the point of view th-t such experioants on he»lthy people 29U5 a 18 fab 47~^?K?-2.'*-^CQok-C4X) COURT I with tho Intention to cause symptoms of diseases on thorn and to test tholr therapeutic Influence would be prohibited by thv ethical rules, -nd that theory must be dlcppproved. 8 • I want to point out expressly that the next aontenco Is an objective subsequent opinion by Professor Frey, and ho does not state any fact. A MR. KoHANEf: This document which has JuBt boon road is not in tho document book and I must object tout's being offered until I have an opportunity to look at it and soo what It Is. THE PRESIDENT: I was going to ask counsol If tho docu¬ ment oan bo found In the document book. DR. NELTB: It Is contained In doounont book Wo. \ vhloh has not booomo available ao yet. The sano 2946 12 rc'o 47-A-JP-2' T -lR-Cocfc~ vAK) COURT I applies to tho document HA 43, which I have Just offered, And It la an affidavit by Dr. Professor Randoralf and I request that both documonts bo admitted with tho reservation that the documents will later on be presented to you and the prosecution and that .they can then object to then. i.R. McHAHSY: The Prosecution has no objection to his roservlng an exhibit number in sequence and no particular* objection to his now reading tho affidavit. However, I would like to havo It clearly urdorstood that It Is incumbent upon Dr. ilelto to re-offer thoso documents at a later stage when vo havo tho translations* before us, tocauso otherwise the bur- don Is on the Prosooutlon to koop a check on thoso documents provisionally admitted and wo aro going to lose track of them. THE PRESIDENT: I wao going to suggest if counsol has the doouaonts ho could offor now in his document book, thoy should be offorod first and these documents rosorvod until the doounent is preparod and given to the Frosooutlon, and Cno Tribunal. Is counsel advised as to whm this Document Book Ho. 3 will probably be prepared-/ DR. H2LTB: I was told It would be ready by this morning but I guess It was not completed. In the document book there are only four documents. It contains on additional four documents, and perhaps it would be appropriate to admit them, because otherwise the complex of the question ^uld be Impaired. THE PRESIDENT: Counsel may offer them provisionally If he desires and reserve the nu :ber, but It must be read again when the documents are again offered as exhibits. DR. NELT3: Yes, Your Honor. Professor Randeralf states at the third working session 2947 12 Feb 4?- < fr-J?‘-e*-la-0ook-(A:<) COURT I of che consulting specialist physicians from the 24th to the 26th of Hay, 194*, in connection with the leotures by Fischer and Gebhardt, I have not participated in the disous- slon, but after hearing th* lecture with regard to injuries sustained by bullet wounds, this leotuie didn't have anything to do with lectures by Gebhardt and Fischer, who are complete¬ ly unknown to mo. 2S47a 12 Feb »7-A-Ji2*-2arCooic-(«£) SCUiiT I iiy lecture was completely Independent from the report by Gebhardt and Fischer. It vas supported by experlenceo vhloh I myself had gained by dissecting the corpses of German soldier who had died lr. ba\tle, and *fcioh were supported by studying world literature. I have not made any remarks in the discussions to Gebhardt and Fischer. 2948 12 Fob 47— A- Ail— 24- 1 -Gro 5 S- COURT I ■I can't remember In detail my core the lectures by Oobfaardt and Fischer but as far as I remember It could not be seen by roports from Gobhardt and Fischer that experiments on concentration camp prisoners had been carried out. The consulting specialists physicians have discussed the modlcal experiences at this conference. In All combats, and In all hospitals at home In order to gain new methods of treating voundod and alok soldiers, as a result of this conferenco of the consulting physicians the now oodlonl experiences wore changed by the Arm/ Medical Inspectorate to dlrectlvos nnd through those medical directives It was posslblo to bring these experiences to the young physicians who voro used in tho hospitals at tho front and were unable to attend theso conferences. DR. NSLTB: I roquost to provisionally admit this dooumont a Exhibit 2. I now oorao to tho Dooumont Book about the Sea Water Experiments. That Is Document Booh V and the affid-.v.'*. by Dr. BooKer-Freyseng, HO-448, which Is not contain. in this Document joofc. The exhibit number of the Bo Oku r- F<*« y no. lg affidavit oannot be determined yet. The exhibit nu-iber of .10-449, that is the affidavit oy Profoosor Schroeder, and this will be exhibit 10. This will be exhibit n. This book I am holding to you does not contain any documents with tho exception of Document SO-449 which mentions your name direct¬ ly. In the affidavit of Profoosor Schroeder, HO-449, which la exhibit l*Q by Professor Becked-Froysong certain statements -To contained which might give cause to tho conclusion as If you had been In some way connected with the son water exper¬ iments or in the very least that you hid knowledge of them, '/ill you please make . statement with regard to tho assumption 2949 12 Fob 47-a-AK- 24-2-Gres8- COURT I that has been expressed by the tvo other defendants? a. In connection with this I can only aay that I have heard of the sea water experiments hero In Nurnberg. Before they wore completely unknown to bo. DR. .iiLTZ: kny 1* pleAae the Tribunal, I therefore request that the affidavit by Professor Schroedor, Document 3ook II, page *0, document HA-22, bo admittod as Sxhlblt aa. Profosaor Schrooder states here under paragraph 2 - ■Under Ko. 81 said that Professor Dr. Handloaer know about the medical resoorch experiments carried out by tho Luftwaffe. I have to add thu following In that connection: ■a) Xy testimony rofers only to the time of ny tour of duty as Chief of the Luftwaffe Modloal Service from 1 January 1944 on. About the procedures before that tlno I am In no position to oako any statements. “b) Luftwaffe rosonrch was not subordinated to tho Chief of th- Vohrnacht hod leal Servloo; It v R8 not among tho "common" tasks of the Yohrmaoht Medical Service. ’hat is why a report to the Chief of the tohrmnoht .'.eulc.Yl Servloo was not considered. ■c) When tho Luftwaffe handed out rooearoh ni-slgnmonts about strictly aviation medicine fields, the consont of tho Chief of tho tfohrtaaohi Hodloal Service was not necessary. Tho Chief of the Luftwaffe Medical Service could on his own responsibility carry out research In his .aviation medical research Institute without inforcing the Chief of the Johr- ■acht Medical Service. The information concerning research assignments given to third persons was connected with the assignment given to Professor Dr. Brandt in 194.a, to guide tho whole research vers In order to avoid duplication of work. After that time 2950 12 Feb *»7- A- AX- T - Gro s s- CCURT I all proposed research assignments had to be reported to the office of the Reich Commissioner, Office for Science and Research. .This was done In the following aonnor: Copies of che letter sent to the mop assigned the research Job wore sent to the Office for Science and Research (Professor Ros¬ tock); an additional copy went to the Chlof of the Vahrmaaht i.edical Scrvlco for his lnfornatlon. Those reports contained no lnfornatlon about place, methods of execution of such rosearch, assignments, nor wore any possibly oontbmplated experiments on human beings r.entloned In them. ■d) As for as the sea water experiments (No. 5 of my af¬ fidavit of 15 October 1946), It becomes evident from Document No. 17? that no representative of the Chief of the tfohraacht Nodical scrvlco or the Army Nodical Inspootorato participated In the preliminary conference on 19 Ray 1944; It further becomes evident from the distribution list that this record was not submitted to the Chief of the .ohrmaoht Medical Scrvlco. Nor was a copy of tho letter whloh was sent to tho Ralchsfuehrer S3 Himmler, bearing my signature, forwardod to the Chief of the ‘fehrmacht nodical Service. No research assignment was lss.od In this matter." I roquest that this doci'_«nt bo admitted as exhibit fT. Dr. Becker-Freyseng states In Document HA-2*- TH£ PRESIDENT: Before entering upon any further docu¬ ments the Tribunal will recess until 09*0 tomorrow rornlng. (The Tribunal adjourned until 1* February 1947 at C9*0 hours.) 2951 im 13 FaW>-i~l--LJG-?c>ster--J? (tart I Official Transcript of tfco ^ericnn KUitnry Tribunal in the natter of tho United Stotos of An crier., against trrl Brandt, ot al.< defendants, sitting at Bamberg, ^enany, on 13 7otruary 1947, ;9#>, Justice 3onls prosiding. TES KJ2SSAL: Persons in tho Court Hnoo will ploaso find their neats. She Honorable, tho'judges of KUitnry Trigonal 1. mitary Tribunal 1 is now in sostion* God snvo tho Unitod States of Xnerlca =nd this honorablo Tribunal. Tvoro will bo order in tho courtrooc. TEE EGSIXlTl Mr. Marshal, will you ascertain that the defendants oro nil present in court. IS KA3SULI Kay it please your Honor, all defendant, are present with tho oxeoptir.n of the Defendant Obcrhausor who is absent with a continuation of her rocont lllnoae. rs ranOSi Tho Socrotoxy-eonornl .111 nolo for tho rooord tho oroocnco of oil tho dofondont. .ovo tho Befondnnt Oborhou.or, tho Dofondnnt Ohorbnuoor loin* otoont on noonunt of lllnooo according to n d-otor'o oortlflcto vhlch I vlll hood to tho Soorotnry-Oonornl. (Cortlflcoto hondod to Scerotory). rn.ro HX-fcWO y It plor.o tho Tribunal, I -rat to roho o roqoo.t font tho Dofor-daat ludnlf Brandt ho r^-lttol f. he nhoont fr.c tho curtronr: oftor tho rocoo. thl. ror-lnc for oooh « period of tin. until It ho. he on dotorr.lnod h, a oodles «»lh-tl-n by tho prioon phy.lclon t>.-t ho 1. Ohio to P-rtlolpjJ^ay^xooc ooool'-no. In W opinion Hodolf nrondt I. .id. and. 'hcoordinn to'Shn.^tono -hloh I hnro tho opportunity to oboorve. bo 1. 1= ny opinionK^roly HI. Ho only «o»<*. 50 irllo^rn. nod ho It barely nhlo to over, folio- the proceeding. El. rental crpnelty 1. deteriorate free, drf V. dry. 00 that It hocono. Ccurt I 13 -“--b U7-i' - 1-2 - LX - Feel«• questionable to ^ if th- defense can even be consluded in a professional atoncr. I, therefore, request, ard I would te grateful, that an oxasdna- ticn 07 the orison physician bo ordered so that I will obtain full clarity as to whether tho Defendant Rudolf Brandt is still able to Attend tho ccurtrcoc sessions. THE PRESIDEfTt Counsel should ,iake his application in writing so that tho -iatt~r will bocono a oattor of record. C.uno«l vill proparo an application and haai it to the Tribunal at any prior to tho .mming recjM. The r.attor will then b« considered. DR. iUUF.UJKi Thank you voiy uuch. ER. NKJTfitx Fay it please thu Tribunal, at the end of yesterday Afternoon's session I hid started to r_.td tho affidavit of Dr. Becker^ Frvyson, with regard to tho copl-nt cf questions regarding son-water orpcrl or.ts. The affidavit which I r resented before of Professor Uchroodar, as you will recall, refers to the tino of 1 July 19Uu until Jjiuary 1SU5 when Frefossor Schroudor beconc -odical Oflicor Inspoctor oX the Luftwaffe. Dr. Freyoeng previously belonged to tho edical Ins, octornte of tho * which is toh ibit 01 and in this affidavit tho following is st*ted under Ko. 61 ■Hsndlrsur, .as Inspector of the chmacht wdical Service, nod to bo fully '.cquaintod with tho reSoarch work don-, by arry, Navy, and Luftwaffe. .0 had orders to ropert to these gontle-nn cn all research oasignenants -f tho scientists working f r us, so that duplication of ■or’: ;i*r£t be avuidud." In connection with this, vT. Beckor-Freys^ hoc iinn the 1 lowing affidavit which I shall offer and present as D--cu.:ont Ha 23. It is contained on pago 32 of Document Book II. It will have Exhibit S . 3k. In his affidavit. Dr. k-ckor-rreyseng stotts the foil wing« - 295 >- C art I 13 Feb hi-.. - 1-3 - LJG - Foster ■Im interprutctioc which tho Frr-secuticn gave this part of :ay affidavit praipts ir. rder tc avoid aisundcrst-vndi-ig *nd wrong conclusions, upon r«,u»t of the Defense Counsel cf Professor Handlosor, to Tflka the f.Hawing explanation* ■ 1 . The cextents gif He. 6 of the affidavit wo naver too subject of the questioning in the previous interrogations. ..hon the interrogator, in too presence of Hr. HcHaney, gav. e an relish copy of the affidavit to sign, which was supp-acd tc boa suenary cf the interactions aid which had been fornulntod by the ft*< secution, 1 told hin especially in r-spect to S-s. 5 and 6, that because of the genoral'fcrelation cf these sections I bad tc rake explanations. *r. JcHaney told :» that I oould nake explanations later. *horoupon 1 signed. I was not sivun ary opportunity later to explain He. 6 of the affidavit. the question -f Fr fosser Dr. Handler's jurisdiction as Chief „f the -ohr-jocht -edical Sorvico concerning the ros-arch work dono by the Luftwaffe, l state* ■a) -ms- arch psrferjsd by the Luftwaffe was net subordinate to tta Chief :f tho Vehruncht -sdical Service, it was not anong the "joint" t alks X the wehrnacht .odical Sorvice. lh-refere no report was nado tc tho -hiof f the ..ohr . cht .medical Sorvico. "b) Ho.. 6 dodls nly with the ariod after the Office for Scionoo and .tesearch had boon established urrfor Professor *orl Brandt. At this period -oust eisUnguieh bota.oon the r-s-arch dciu in the L’af twaffo's cwn institutes. Only concerning the l itver report was ...do to Professor Rostock, conflicting ■ f sending a copy of tho research aasignsonts b- Profosscff Rcst.ck and V- the Chief f the ehraacht ftodinsl Service. This research assisnoent, h-wevor, did not contain my information about tho DothMs to bo applied. ■c) The sea water oxperir-ents w.ro n t the result of a research -asignaont. Thercf-ro the Chi-f .f the -*r»cht *. ical Survica cad r. t recaLvo any copy. - 295 ^- Court I 13 Fab U7-H - 1 -L - LJj - Fcafcor * 2 . The wcrds: |n andl.. acr, aa Inspector of the Lohmacht Kedlcal Service, had to bo fully acquainted with the research work deno by Ar.y, Navy, a.id Luftwaffe,' in this general fora are inqorroct. They ref^r t- the foil-wins sontenco and are reant to express what I hr-.ra said above under Nr. 1. -295^- 13 Fob-ii-kAA-2-l-Lesscr Court 2*o. 1 n 3. Moreover wh».n I spok- of Eandloscr, I did not -xan Prof.Dr. Bandloser personally but his office, which, accordingly to the contents, of the copies of research assignaents sent it fron the end of 19h3 on, would hardly have any reSsen to subait such things to the Chief of the TTchreacht hodical Service hissclf, but only to the suctie.n chief in charge.* I request to adait this affidavit as Exhibit 3lj. SIEGFRIED HANDL06ER - (Hosuacd) DIEEC? EXIUIKaTIGK - (Cont'd.) BY DR. MILTS: Q Uny it please the Tribunal, I have only a brief question with regard to the bon. and suscle regeneration and the transplanta¬ tions. The Docusent Book does not sention the none of Handlosv-r and his offic- so that I went only to ask if he knows anything about thu experiments which wer. carried out at the Kav>.nsbrucck Concentration Crop, or if he received any reports about then? A No. Q On the occasion of the conference of the Consulting Physi¬ cians did you hear any lecture on this sublet? A No. This subject was not discussed at any conference. Q The question of the exp-riaenta within the fr-.acwork of hepatitus rcsoorch aust be considered ns concluded by tho interroga¬ tion of Prof. Dr. Gutieit and your testiaony, as far as it night contribute* to the gerv.rcl clarification in this ease, hay it please the Tribunal, in this connection I only want to refer to Docuaont NO-371. This is again an af idavit of the Defendant Rudolf Brandt, which states the following: “Hondloser and Schrouder also aust have infora-d about th- fact that Haagen and Dcho-n were physicians in the Amy Kedic .1 Service and th-_ Robert Koch Institute.” -2556- 13 Feb Ii7-fc-MAA-2-l-Lcs3 cr-{GJ)- Court So. 1 This affidavit is Lxhibit 186 of th- Prosecution. In connection with this I subait an affidavit by the Defendant Rudolf Brandtj Doc®cnt HA-11. It is on page 17 of Documant Book No. 2, and Brandt states the following: % “In ny affidavit of 11 October 19L6 I aentioned a Dr. DohiJen and described his as "A doctor of the A ray kedicol Service and of the Robert Koch Institute.' ^ * -2956-d- i3 7ob4>4IiJr-2~2-IC88or-0P (hurt I ■la this connection I doclaro that I f nyaclf, did ant uso this for¬ mulation but that it was suggested to no by tho Prosecution. I did act kaow Dr. Dohcon porsonally and I do not roeollcct having known whore ho vnrkod* want his function# woro, and to whnn ho won subordinated. ■If I said in this affidavit: 'Hendlosor nust have boon inf.irncd about that it was a noro ossunption. I cer.not cito an* facts which prom tc or suGgost that Prof, Dr. Hendlosor know of ouch things. 1 I roquoat that this affidavit bo adnittod ns Exhibit 35. I now cono to a point of tho indlctacat which was not*pontninod in tho original indictacnt. VI thin its presontntion tho Prosocution has proaentod Docunont Book 11 about tho Polygnl Srporinoats. In this Socvciont Book tho w:o of tho Dofondnnt Handle ««'. or one of his offlcoo is not ncnti'.nod oithor. Hnwavor, in tho c^ui so of his prooontatior. the prosecutor has dainod that tho Dofond-nt Eondlosor was connoctod with tho poctir. rooonreh. In tho session of 2 January 1947, tho pro- socutor stated tho fallowing with rofcronco to Siovors ‘Diary, "Tho Ahnonerbo, ■ That was Jbaunont Ko. 3546-FS and I quo to: "2 S3 Hnuptfltumfuohror Dr. Pb ctnor. " In connection with this, according to tho record, tho Prosecution undo tho followin- remark, and I qunto: ■&o Rosca-ch Institute was subordinated to the Defendant Handlo.or- - to which fact bo had already referred pr^- viously in tho crurso of tho trial. I c: now asking you, was an institute tc with tho nano of Instituto for Oorcen Snstom Ro soar ah at ,.rnkow — was this instituto subordinated to you? Ay It was aovor subordinated to no. q, Do you know this instituto? A. Bo. q. Since the Prosecution apparently wanted to prove a connection of Prof. Eandlosor here with tho Ahncuorbo Instituto, a part of tho S3, I barb asked the Defendant Siovors V> dctominc hero if, and in what place ir. this 3iory tho nnro of tho Defendant Handles or apporxs and if ho hod 2557 13 7cV*WlLir-2-2-Lo«Bcr-J? C^crt I caj ooatact with th« Ahnonorbc and with this for Sostorn Seaorrch. I cn now offering Ibcaaont KAr-15 on pa<* 25 of Bocunent 3ooSc So. 2. I request that 2957 (n) 13 Fee -i7— —-2-3-Ioascr C.urt ID. 1 it \c axdttc 1 a® Sxhiiit 36. Dr. - lfJra. Silvers 3tct,_e tha f II ninj : "The .rcsccutien su’idttc * v £icr/ '.J'-rxncr’c' (-'cuvcnt 3>b>-*S) in .ri .crco. ■C aeomin Ux c -.•.cfcixlant rX. Dr. Han .loser, I state cate '.rically tint there was no c nnccti n or ccllal retien * ebrcer. ilia an! rus, c.* tlx .'Moos t *Jiich I * .1 engod, either -fficially er . rivatcly; 1 'iD net kn it .r Ilanloscr pore'nelly .ri-r t this trial. "Since tL ncao .rf. Dr. San/lx^DT a. . errs in tw. iiffsrait lecca in c'lary, I c.nai ler it iy -utc t s~vs that nr. c nncctim r collal oration sit. .r ;f. Dr. Kantlcecr roaultc ’ in dth-r cere. "1) Lntrys 2 February 19UU-* Cnforencc Tilth .r-foee r Kirt In trab ur. : influenza vaccinatin by .r »• i’aa .n. Influenza vaccinati n, aucccoa- Itolly ccrriatl ut in cantoir&I h^Atol *y iref. Rasrcn ms reject,.’ iref. ••nloser : r uri in the ohnaccht. *:c. rt r-ejioate for su .-isal n tc tho adciafuchrcr SS. itativn by Dr. Sievars: .r.f, ilirt til this with tl: _ re. ark vr,t he c. ns lie re i tide natter r_r; clynlficant an:’., c r.tr _ r. t: Hr.m’ios-r, he was ef the ini.n tbit this vaccinati n shoul’. ’ c intr. 'nee.*, at least ir. t'.c CS. Tiatis -.Thy he --a':.*, f r a r_. art IT ;irf. Uaa.on f r the .ur.cso 'f su' tUsien to the *ic sfuchrer 3S. "2) Intr;: 3 February ltfdi. c jiforcncc ir. Str~~' ur with *r '. *..c or, • c :-.r acht bi 1 iatj ur nr; rt f their institute requests'.. i\r rcc xxn'c ., thor f:r- lotto* . C. issi-n-r Qcooral .r f. Dr. ran t tier v i-c. ..cs.r in t. ' u nTrie’ • s i alar letter is t. s_ne t *r . Vxullcear. b'.taticn by Dr. Siovars: .ref. .e'er, heal :i tV r “i 1 ;y cj >1 Cr.i^ •' the -- .rt .ont f Di 1 : ~j in the '.Jmener'e.' •- .cr.ti »' -specially in re ar * vest!-ns c nee min re. lacc-cntr, that he vza very .rxh interest.. in <- n nc.it bi.ic-iets which were i!iscuseo 1 at that tfcx. s rca. .nsi'.lc loader 13 Fo’. C-jrt 1 • t!~ '-iclc iata be ahculd like tc ,~t in t-uch rith !scn in shew undoratant- fcS a nrc likely tc hoi;; hia ,;l^na. He c nst’.ero: oayooially auited the r^fintionc:! ntxa eixl tra f tie e-ini.n thr.t it :d fct he r.'vanterc'us. L - 2 ^ 5 ?- 13 ?«£. U7-?-rvTD-3-l*eohan Co'art Ho, 1 if at tho tine Professor !4jyer, tho head of the Department of Biolory in tho ~:ich Research Council, should also approach thin. It was docidod tlat ho r.idrooa e letter to Professor r rondt through u in ord_r to enable us that the like letter b7 Frofosssr ’ ’ey or nay be added, "Profossor Kondlosor wr.s so completely unknown to no that I w-.., unable to give any information about lxlaj iir.t is thj reason why Professor Feb or asked m to inquir at Professor :teyer. As far as I reneabor, no such letter, hewovor, was ever written, x "Cn 2 January tho prosoou.ion oitou. vhen reading the docuuor.t book nbou h-oost&t "Polyyal", froo ty dir.ry («hnjn..rbe) cn-i quotation of tho 26th and 31at ’lay 19U., rojardin', a conferonco with Dr. Orauer of the Reich Rosoarch Council and with Dr, Flootnerj ‘ Pootino rosoc.rch at the institute for Qoratn Scat Rosocrch in Cracow, "Tho Prosecutor doscrl’ood this quotation as vory lntoro :tln , boo uso this Institute was under tho defend.'.nt H ndlosor, This v-nt-.y thoroforo provos V.vt Ik was faniliar .. 1 th t!-> spoly.al* "-ttor. "Thi institute for Oojrvan Fast Roso.vra'.a r Cracow »ras connected with th. Reich Rosoerch Co'UKil rad with rofossor ibis an, the Chief of the T)upar< -at for Inorganic Chemistry mxS !" atrodu-lstry of th- Reich Rosor.rch Council, Its aanajor an:, at the sreio tiro, Thiosnon’s and th. Reich Rusearoh Council’s deputy, was Dr. Piotsch, 'Frofos3or Sandiesmr definitely had nothing to do with this Institute, r»r did I ever hoar iis mas in connection with it. This Instituto was not under tho OK"-' either, 'It is quite apparent that this is one of th anrgr confusions cr con- * true tod artefacts of the prosecution trying to -stablish a connection of F oplo and facts where actually none existed," I now request that the affidavit bo a±ittod as Exhibit ” 0 , 36, ind, finally, the prosecution in excess of the ireiiefcoent ha? offered Docu.u--nts Ho. 1308 are* Ho. 1309 about tho question of bacteriological warfare -2560- 13 ?cb-i f-JJZD-5-2^tcohaxr-JP Court I Those doecncnts cro not contained In any do cm act books and I shall in r. few r.inutoa £ivc you the exhibit numbers. Those Arcuncnta also do not cation Is. Hacdlosor'e s*=0| hwerer, a nodical officer is nentioned horo as Stabsarzt Dr. Ellers, who had sovarnl functions and anone othor things ho had the work of the Amy Kolical Inspoctorato wf th tho Kilitnry l.cdicel Acrdccy with the Weapons and Amanent Offico 1*0, 9. Tho docur.onts -ro Prosocution Ibchibite 2?o. 325 and Ifo. 326. In connoction with this I should liko to ask you tho following quostion; who was or who is Profoscor Uliovo? ^ ", When in January, 1941 I stated in ny offico as Amy J.'cdiwd Ino- poctor I not noon.: tho nodical officors of tho Amy Inspoctorato, Prof. Dr. Eliovc. *~o was personally known to no fron tho yoor 1922 whon I was ctudyinc at tho Ililitory Modical Clinic at Ciooscn when I was assigned thero as Stabsarzt. At that tino, ho was a nodical practitionor at tho oano clinic t< which I belonged. Sinco tho yoar of 1922 I did not ooo hin aorir. until tho yoar 1941. At tho outbroak of tho war, ho hud boon called into tho Amy Hodical Inspoctorato by ny prodocoosor, Dr. Waldnonn nnd thoro ho wr.s to deal with tho nodical aspocto of br.ctorioio,-lcnl wjfaro. Q* To whon was Profoscor Kliovo subordinate? A. In hit nodical actlvitios and ac nodical officer, ho was sub¬ ordinate to no r.s tho Amy J.cdical Inspoctor and in his actlvitios no no¬ dical consultant and advisor nnd specialist, ho was subordinate to tho nrranoat Offico to the Dopartr-.ant VauPruf 9 whoro ho also rocoivod ncsi^nconts. Q. Was tho hoad of this offico in tho Vau Pruf, Colonel Hirsch? " Tos. * v . '/hat were the asai^nsents which Profoscor Eliovo had to carry "•it in this position? . -irat of ell, Profoa3or Eliovc had all tho publications end Professional literature of the foreign countries and he had to evaluate 2961 13 ?eb-:^4Z>-3-3-c:oobaa-v’P v ourt I th«c and use thee In order to find out, as far as this was at all possible, vhet work as being done in this field by the foreign powers and what point of riow they nalntained in each case, what intentions and conclusions could bo drawn*fron it and what prorentivc no a. our on could bo trie on against such potential coasuros. 2961 (a) 13 Fob. U7-!*-AH>-3-3-^eeban Cc-!rt :- 15 rob K -4-« l >-8lnahadc-JP Court I Q. ro you know tho opinions of the chiefs of the Goman leadership vith roerrd to banter iologica warfare? I know that tho Tuohror repeatedly did not only erpross, 'but that ho also ordered, that active hacteflogical warfare would ho conplo- toly out of quostion for tho Goman kokmacat. On ono occasion it was also statod that tho TuoSror had nadc a statorcat to tho offoct that tho prcreative work should only ho carvlcd out to a very lir.itod extent bocnvso he did not approvo of tho whole nnttor. Q. ^d what was tho point of vlow of Koitcl. 3rauchlto<* and Holder? Ao yield -.juohal Koitol and ny suporior, Brauchltsch and with tho chief of tho General Staff Holder, this question was never discussed. However, I c»n recall that tho Ouartomastor Gonoral, General Vu^cr, dioatw-oC f-w Buhj«ct wttn no on ono occoslo*. ar.d Ho ookod nc if tni» was a natter which would cause us a lot of worry in tho circunstancos rnd thon I infomod hin to tho offoct that in tho lltoraturo, this work was constantly holnc nontioned; that I, on tho other hand, aintninod tho personal point of view that wo nood not worry about it, and whon ho askod no why not, I replied fron tho nodica point of riow tho drnjor was so Groat for ovorybody who night enca^o in this tn>o of wnrfaro for his own territory aau for his own troops, I aveye had tho inprosslon that our ililitory loadors wore not la favor of this ontiro typo of a bactorio- lo,-ica warfare as a woryon, and that they did not hnvo a vory favorablo attitudo on tho subject. I can aso rccffibcr thrt cn ono occasion I wont with Kliavo*to the now chi of of tho Sonora Staff, Zoisslor, who was to bo infomod about everything end what wo were working on; that wo reported to hin and that Zoisalcr showod vory littlo intorcst. and ho showod »o littlo intorost that I actuaiy folt sorry for Elicrc on that occasion. q. 2Hd yau know that Prof. Blcoo rccoivod an acsi.Tnont in that field' ", I uust state tho following in that oonnoction; In Juno or July of 1943 I, in c? capacity rs chief of tho Vohmncht c.a Sorvico, re¬ ceived a letter with tho letterhead Reich Research Council, Coralssionor of Plenipotentiary for Cancer Research. Shore I was invited to attend a con¬ ference 2964 13 ?ob-J4-KAir-4-3~2iusbuck-JP Court I i3 Berlin at a certain date. 1 then vent to Berlin, accordingly, coninc :ron the ruchrcr's he-adquartors. and elnce we wore to d.' to., cancer re¬ search I had also '■ nlons ny consulting turcoon, Bo.toOc. The conference took place In nooo's office, end besides hin tho following person, were present. tfini.torial Diri-Tcnt Schunnnn. the Vete¬ rinary Genoml Achtor and* one or two norc con. but I cenrot roc«nber tho onact nunber anyrmre. ». Blono opened .he conference .Ito » .tatwnt the. U* 41.eu..ion te he eheut tactortoloslcal .erfere and the. ho hod received or. ncisc noet ty Belch Ihrehel Swrinj V. err r, out preventive to* end to put It on . hrondor hclto He .lto ...ted the. ty virtue of thl. order ho .no ... Mklnc «, end tho order * -lto hnvo ...ted that he ... to eetlvoly Include htMOlf, tut I to net realtor the. erectly nnynoro-thorofnro, he ... nrictos a. to . 11.0 hln tone hrlcf report, .tout toe .tote, of the dofonec .ert end el to .tout toe tori, end report. »h!oh « hnd received nVut tho work which was bo ins dor.o Abroad, : to. the flr.t .no to telco too .tend, end then 1 .toted thnt flr.t ef nil thl. did net fell W»l» V field of crpetonee. end .oeendly. I did net hnvo toe nuttorlty «. dl.cue. rich tor.: .hlch hnd hoon dene In toe rilltory field end to * »«“ 1 31 eh tor end lUMd »«« — «■"«* * ltt> °» Blone .her. told ton., of curto he eMOd quite under.tend our point of vie. end that no. he vuld hnvo to nrico n return Journey, .hleh tould ef c.er .0 tnko eor.o tine. Thl. to. re^rettohlo tcceu.e he elec hnd teen inferred te the affect that et certoln place, .trend to mere... In too toric tolch .on terns done In thl. fluid eeald te dote -mod. 2965 13 ?cb-d*4Ui-i-Wrincbuckh-JP Court I I cm also rcnc-.bor thr.t ho nodo the stateeont thr.t ho actually In¬ tended to also in cl ado tho Ccmiu prose in ordor to point out to tho nnsoos tho lrrgo denser which nirfit or iso in tho eircunstanoos. Tnon, na tho only sto.tenant which I nndo during thr.t conforonco, I stated to Bioco that in ny opinion I had to warn hi.- of carry in,- out thr.t intontion nt this % tiro pr.d evon nt n lntor poriod of tlno, oocnuso now, in tho yo»x 1943, as a result of tho air attacks and as a rosv.lt of tho fonr of phosphorus which really plryod a najor part with tho pooplo, and as a result tho incidor.ts during tho first half yoar in 1943 whore rJ.roady thcro was oono err os*, which could ho folt in tho pooplo, that they shotu^bo protoctod irre thoso nov foars undor all drcunstanccs. rurthemaro, tho wholo problai was not suitahlo for discussion in the daily press. Blono acknow¬ ledged thr.t rnd then he hroko off tho anloronco. ”ow, what did you do on your part with rogord to your nllitary superiors? A. ?ror ny offico I Innodiatoly established oontact by tolophono with Tlold ".iarshal Koitol, and I broifly roportod tho courto of tho conforonco to hie, roe. I reported to hln what I had told ^lono. Then ho briofly oaid over tho tolophono, "I agroo with you, hut sinco tho Hoi oh Korshol to includod, send no a writ tor. report about this innodlatcly so thr.t I 'fill hr .70 that in hand I did that, Vhon, aftor i'co tlno, nb'.ut oight or ton drya noy hr.vo passed, I told hln onco r. ro that in ny opinion thoro was no urgent nocoasity nt nil end that it was not epprnpriato to follow this nou procoduro, 1 hr.* the ieprosaion that ho agroc with no. Hfwovor, a short tlno afterwords I rocoivod nr. ordor which read awroxinatcly as follows: Tho notch !Inrahnl has cocidod in tho natter of bactoriologicrl wnrfnro that tho ropxosontntivcs of tho Vohmacht which nttondod tho conforonco in June, nro to give tho nocossary inforration to Dr. 31onc who is acting on ry orders. I sout this lottor to tho Airy Hodical Inspoctorr.to for conpllenco with iloitol* s order, and with that the whole incident was corplotcd for no. 2966 1? 7cV*:-4L^-4-^inabticfc-JP 0 >art I it lrrgo ir.torrals then I f^und rut frr-n ZIIcto tbet asido fran the ... r-fcrcncco which t'."k plr.ee at Ant Office 9 and which to-k placo at vor;; l-r-o intorrola* that nothing -f particular tapertanco haa happened tboro. 2967 13 Court I 0 . 2-70 you spoken with Dr. 51ncc onco acre afterwards, or hnvo you enrr — pc o dod with hi= oa this natter? A. I hr.vo not corresponded with Bloao on this r^xttor aor did I hnro nay discussion with bin after Juno. I .» bin o^nin oaco noro. That WM rftor Janucry 1945, or it nay b- plotoly interrupted. I can only siy that wo of tho Amy fron the vory r.ooont of tho di*i eaal of *iold Marshal 3ranchitsch in a prnctlcol sonoo did not hnvo a Coanandoa in-Chiof at all onynoro.. whilo, for ox«t>1o, tho Luftuaffo was roprosontod by Snoring, tho lfavy by Itaodor and Dounl tr. tho SS by Hlonlor, and nil of thoso brmchos had vory poworful roprooon- tativos In th/>oo non. In tho cr.so of tho Amy tho pffico of tho Cuwndor-in-Chiof hod boon torn into sorornl pioccs and now various loodors had obtrxinod control "vor tho difforont pLccos. '*hilo I roportod in dotnil to Brnuchitcch nt locst '»nco in ti" wo ok 3 and I could toko oil ny ■uggostiono and fcaro V hin — • I knew personally that ho quito openly errod for his sick and injured soldiors and was vory such interested in tho Kodicnl Sorvico — such imodiato possibility of exorcising any influence ended for no as •‘my Kodicrl Inspector, and ell ny ir.fluor.co onduf. toward the end of 19-11. that tino on, I had to turn ovor ny *u«;-ostior. to tho Quar toman tor --cnoraij end 2970 13 Joh-K-SS- 5-4-Putty -JP >urt I I do not tev.w In what fora or to wfar.t extent ho bmu^it thoso natters to tho hnowlcd^o of tho Tuchror. \ On tho occasion of tho conversation which you had with Hitler, did you discuss research questions? J- So. Q* Vhnt was your oontact and what was your relationship? I rlsltod tho Hclchofuohror-So on ouo occasion at the tino he was alroady Corccndor-1>-Chlof of tho rcurro airy. That was In August 1944. I Tioltod ’:ln at hie hoadquartore In order to uwl to a discussion vhoro tho distribution of physicians was dlecussod^ Tho questlro wao dlsaussod how roplaccrents could bo pro cur od for the oxnjr units. OthorwioO: X did not hero any other contacts with Hl'nlor. Officially, ar.d personally? K I did not haro any porsonal contacto with hln at all. 2971 13 Fob 17-:-?JC-6 -i-3o axd C?irt Ko. 1 :fcrt ccnfcts ill you havo with GoariaG? A In tho wintor of 19-13 I rorortod to GooriaG together with tho ModicrJ. Chief cf tho luftwaffo and tho !>.vy, ct his Hoadquortors in tho ItaJinctor Hoido, irhoro in tho and, wo else discusaod tho question that tho iddical officorn would hp.vo tc bo oqaally distributed} that coordination with ro'.ard to tho tiro factor should ho .j^o hotwo^ tho front and tho facrolr.nl. 1 .t that ti:a, ho str.tol that ho h-i ho-xd fiat wscx»n nodical officoro woro still at tho front whoa they ahoull bo at fecejo, end olnilrr mtior. That was tho only discussion which I had with 2oich®'arshall Goorinf. ^ - I now want to rofor onco ovoro to HiJiJor. Did you ovor a.ttond n X locturo by Hi:j lor? Yoa, I attended it in tho yo-x lSd3. Tho CarnuJor in Chi of of tho nosorvo ±xny, hi* none was Brxn, tc.othor with tho Axry Cerno Aroa Coitjwdors, hr4 boon ordorod to r.tts.vl a sorios of locturos at Bad Schachon oa Lako Cacataneo. I was also < rlorod to at tort as 1 Nodical I natter. 1 only rant to cay this in erdor tc hevo tho record cc^ploto. y I Interrupt you r. rdmito. GonorAl TWylor, in hlo bi„ oponinc sooch h-rs rlan discussed rotted trrinln-. unslor tho TV.zl 3ystoi., or. paco 101 , nad ho hr.s rt~.tol thet tho s-.lrit hnd loon apollod. Yru Just .ontlcnod e tho ctruoilu 'v.r.lrat this influence tho universltiur whoro it kao not •>:dy the ACtlvo -iilltAry •.todied Corps, but All through tho otulonts who waro t. toc.'.io rocorvo rolic-J officer;.. In this connection, I would liko tr know how tho 0-.IO s.-o \ with tho r.otlvo dlilitAry Corps which w.o „ivon a: aolAl trninin;; 1 .* thoy roro undor tho lnfluonoo of nr.tiovl socirlien, tad ra Co \or-l Taylor st-tol, thr.t tho spirit of tho studoatc w-s prooaol .-*•0 to r. voir lew I070I. Ho s id that tho lovol hAl sunk in r. torriblo Annor. Cm you toll -o Anythin, About tho directives mfi with tho spirit •fit;-, which yu w-ntoi tc fill the stu'.ont IIodio -1 Cor c? Until tho vory l-.ot rax oat, in rcsarlmoo with ur tr-Jiti n -’f ono ‘.un’.rod rjjd fifty yo-re, wo oduc-to" .-ur youth, m*. wo h vo net difforod thoso -Id rrlacip~ls -no lotr.. Cm y-u iro un my ’roof -f th-t yet? I at. thinkin: of tho words : -lch you r.'.'xosto* t- thoeo ooplo on 8-ccIaI occ-ai'ne, r.t tho tiro of thoir r- -tica. 237 >- 7 13 ?ob “'-•7-: :-?JC—5—3—3orr* Ccurt So* I A Yos, I ces 6lTo you on axerplo. *faoa our -cti7o ropleccnonts, wfcon In tboir ontiroty, yiasod tfcrcuch our K&litery Kedicel zcedory, whon nftor thoy liatlnculshol thanaolrow at »ho front nhoro thoy had toon oncnsod In co:-bnt iporetiona, thon oithor tho Cccrv-jadin.^ Officer of tho Acedauy or xhonovor I wee in Borlin, I poreonelly aworo then in. And, thoy el30 rocoirod e certificate at th-.t ti:* which oe*teinod a cortein r-otto accordin;; to whet ycu wrjxtod to have ttoci oducetod, m3 thic r..tto was lainteinal until tho ond tfc. wer, end rs lon^ an ceniidatod fer s^>ilcr*l officers woro tola. treinod. Tto -cti. of Hijnoaretoa str.toa: "Dovout yair life to tho sodleid acia&co cal cenooatreto ell your work in celnloc ymticel oz/orionco in uodicino# X ^opoebor tho practical wordi ./horooror Ioyo to huxr.a toin^a exist thoro you will elao Xii4 lovo to the uod.cel profooalon. Humanity end tho :iodicr.l :rofo83ioa cannot bo aoperetod frc*» oech other. 'Jork conatently in ordor to bocoiu e phyalcien eni with c firr. cherector cad with lovo to huaen })1 bgSi .Vowor aoo anything olso in e petiant then ti aufforinG follow hurra fcoiiv uha. y-u heYo to holp. Try to undoratend tho alr.plo aoldior in auch away ea if you had crown up tocothor with hir: hoc-uao all of uo ero coanoctod with tho a-rx> feto." 1 'fill you now continuo tho tho doacrlptlcn of ell tho concopto end ell tho iafluonooa which wea bjlnr, oxorciaod by tho ?erty? 7rr. r'KIDET: Bofcro tho ’Titnoaa prrcooloc with tho ce»o of this ox* 1 ration, tho Cnurt will bo in roccsa. If Doctor Kaufman cen trine up the applicetitn for tho oxcuain^ of tho doforrient Dudolf Brealt I con aoo Mil duriiv tho rocoas if tho Socret'-ry Gonorel will rofor hia to xx>. (A rocoaa w-xa tokon) 13 r-b. -7 -L'-6-l-Pk?- Cook C urt No. 1 Il'ulSHnL: The Tribune 1 is a-ain in session. 7HJ Th- Tribunal h.e received th- “pplicrti i Rod 'If Brandt tr.rouh his counsel to be -xcusoc fr» th- s-ssion. The Tribunal will c..rsi.'-r th t arttor in it's rder durlnr th. nx>n rec..es. Counsel ar.y proceed, BY D?.. NLLTE: % Q. Professor, I put ay Inst question to whether any further -nterferoncos task place frt thj party, or rather tlx xrly creacies, r.ni I an referring to interference in y-ur so ho re of activity? A. In this co.mectijn I shuild .sorely like to a nti-n th t ar. -.tteopt was aoe- to interieru with the us- of C-th-iic nurses in jut hosbit’ 1. Repeatedly, it ms dumndod thrt these nurses bn Jicaicsod, end ih.y be substituted rj nurs-s fr-o the Red Cross :r the National Socialist nursing association. Dp until the end f the war I succoedcd in orevonting th-t procedure. Those people wore excellent in oorfer-dng their work, tnd I was sure rny substitute ■ ouL. h.vu been .. change f r the xorsw. Apart fr.«a th-.t, those nurses from tho start b-d bean s.« devoted to their .ubius -nd behaved in such :n eXieanlary a'.nxxr townrd -ur patients tb“t it would It v. constituted a Tert injustice •. einoiss then. An! in this commotion too, I should like to ecnhrsize that I -n ny -*n initi-tive probably would not have succeeded in doing thot if it •ron't in this c a- too that I had th- holp of Prolesnor Karl 3rn<’t r.;rinot these int-rfotvnces . f the p;-rty. He used all of his influence in sc-ins tbit theiK nurses remained in our hospitals :.n thereby defended us r.-ainst the attacks of the party. Q. VI.en sulxlttinr documents, 1 sb 11 suonit a few affidavits in th*t c mecti.n. N.w, di ’ jr u -vur attend any l*r t -o sc lie m rty neotinfc, for inctrnce, tl.e lj;n;b-r. party Rr LLy? a. il , rt n- ti_le . t *.U. Q. :.ltn wn -a f the c-o-dofanknts x-' y- u no c nr.ecti>n wh“.t«ouVer, th t is t- sr.y, “5 f-r s tixre wet cry ffici'-l c nnec'ion. *.e hive already -.-.1 r._. the-; .nr* shell repe~t th-a a rein, but I n-w want t- fir ut with •r.x. -f th-Se - -f.n'-nts y.u h' I n. e nt ct wh ts-v.r, ariv.tely r -ffici.ally? . 1 . "ntil ny -rrivr.l in Kurno^r- I h'd r. contact of -rv- ffici 1 'r -2975- 13 F-h. LI - M -S-2-PB*- Cook Court !ia. 1 personal rxztar. with th. f .ll^iln^ *_»olv. fcontl^atni '-Its, laif:, 3-ckor- fr-yolr--, “ui’oLf 3rrndt, Ho von, PAmgr, Si-v-rs, OKrhnu&.r, Popposv’ick, Schr.-Ur, 3reck, nr. Eonbor.. Q. During the st..t-ic.nts er.Cc by th. Chi-fCounsel h- a-r.ti'rw on prgd 96 of th- tx. nscript nJ sp-'ka -bout tb- participation .f th. Gv-rarn physici-ns in th- exc-ss-a of «?ril, 1933, nnJ h- apu.ko -bout th- coab.-ting 3 f the old phyeicinns• -ssoci-ti n. '.ho corps of th- .xui’ic'l 'lfic-rs, as I s-^d be for- nt n-t nanli xud in rry of th-.a- st-'t-nentt,. Tho aili^crv o.iysici*na ..n th- th-r hand -.ust be c.-nsi-cr-d ; n rt -f th- G-man physicians ■h: were -ctiv. in ailit-ry a-rvic- r.:’. you r- th- r- or-eant tiv-, th t is, as Amy Jicrtic 1 Inspector, f-r th- ray ohysicions, ’.nd Iflt-r os Shi-f of th. tt-hraacht I/w’.i© 1 Sorvic. v-u cr- th- r-pr-s-nt'tiv- f >r 11 physicians in th or»j-‘ t rc-s. In 7 -ur c/.p city a r-pr-s-nt tlv- I shoulJ lik- to r.sk you: i.huthwr th- .-liit. ry physici'-sis individually x '-r. thoir or.tir-ty •>* rticij>nt-ri in 'ny vr.y in th- -xc-oc-s *oich took pl'C© on th- 1st .f April, 1933, ■* Hhetlxir t:-.-y pcrticlo t- in ny ’icy ir. th- c oaV tin,: .f ti>- ol! physicians ^rgmiz-.tions. - 237 &- 13 Fob. a Cress C-Jurt So. 1 A. I law of iv* cess and no cose rts ever mentioned cither before the \ar nor iuriiL' the entire bar. Q. Tiv.t is to sty, the 'Itdicel Officers Corps ha., nothing to do r.iih these political instances? A. Ho. % Q. Cener 1 Tnylor, in his> opening speech, on p=go 9d, sne.'ks .-'out, and I quote: "The Prostitution of Corasr. Uecicine under :ational Socialism". Are, in this connection, ne aentioneo the principles of medicine to reViorel - socialist population policy. And on p.ge 99, 1 quote: "The entire public health polity ol the Third Rjich MS put in line iiith this pronouncement of principles". a.v' on pflfco 100, I quote: "AU Ceram physlcims wore reorganised through an orgnnic'.tion derivod Iron tlie Reich Physici: ns Chamber." Although military physicians were not aentioned in particular hore I .-»uot ask you, since thu assertion *'& rv.de tret til physici-ns ».c»o included, noro aortic 1 officers of the ‘.ohrr.iql.t includoa nd hid cblig. tions to chide by then? A. No. Q. Durinc the ox* ain tlon -nd rerdift, ol cfiidovitc thore *as much tr.lk • ojut the or nizntioi., its purpose, nd &> nint of tho uoetings of tho consulting ehysloi'ns nd I shill rosist fro putting any further questions to you ibout the prop r tion, conduct, nd results of Ukis^ noetingo. i>inco, hosovor, thin count is coiinocto.’ with tho question of conspiracy I should like to ivo ou •n opportunity to deiino your position with r.leiMncu to the importancu oi those codings. A. In susaorizing, 1 c nsfV the following in th t connection: These nuttings origintod iron n«rv necessity. Thoy -.or- ordered to tk^ pL'Co publicly. Or. swry occasion I o*du application to .uy ailitcry su^urior and trio, to ,xpl“ir. tho necessity for these mootings. On th t occasion I gave * survey of «h t I considered to b- cost urgent problems. Th-n the oi lit ry :; -rior ueeiJ whether such . Quoting c*n t ko pliCv or not, becuiae th t wco 3 In, ttrt dit.jcndcl on jilit ry situation nd the intontion of ..Jlit'ry 1- C^r-hio. i:- lU _re* c.s laic, down '.nd discussion ot. rted when- these prebieas nuiv discussed. The rvsults of the so meetings "fro corvil*-^ in -2977- 13 F-b. 47 -*-9-2-?KP- Gross Cairt Ho. 1 directive8 for the benefit ol physicians in general, southing that was publicly distribute-! casrjg *11 physicians; As soon ' s there wes a possibility those printed reports -or- Sunt out to various agendas and medic' 1 officers - sent out to *11 physicians in order thit they _ry servo as r basis for srincioal assures ?nd for th. information free older physici ns to younrer physicirna. I ra convinced thrt cv-ry physician, and every non-physician, who hr a an opportunity nl takoa ar. opportunity to try to get insight into tho*j mooting reports, will too be cceplet-ly convinced that thur-in the Seriou* work in the scientific field of ell the German physicians is Id'! down, opinions that »ore represented by leading 'uthcritiou from 'll territories of Gem.-.ny. I refer you to xy spe.ch-s uhlch I ar.de or. those occasions and which always constitute*! a review of t.io prat y«'r, • nc! at the same time a survoy of tho ■ork to be done durirg th. period to corn. And, I st-'nd up to every one of the •ordo which wore pronounce on these occasions. The Prosecution submitted one of those apcochos a a a document. In spite of gr-at.-st efforts I, not oven up to now, could have found anything in thet speech which in any way Justifies tho Severe chargo th-t thcBw meetings wer- expression and a typical jxjmolo oi a conspir cy of Goman physicicns in order to cosait war crises and crimes rg. inst * I hur. nity. In conclusion I should lil - to say th t 1 hopo th t hei^ nt this pL-.co these Quoting reports wiLL become document and mark atone for the serious, dutiful, awl almost superhua-n work which th Gera n soldiers performed during this long *n- s-verw w.~r. Aw!, ' a the words of Kippocrrter were mentioned here p-pe* twt’ly I should like to uaphr.site th t the Gervn pnysici ns not cnly »uru lully ware of these, namely th. words "Primea non nocure", but at all times they endeavored to help ’w. to cure whenever they could. And there is nothing furth.r I h ve to say. Dr.. ,‘elLTe: Hr. ?r-sie.nt, th t brings =- 1° tk- end of "V ox-nin tion of th. iefundant .nd in subst-.nti'tior. of the -.ords which th- defendant " pronounc-d at the on- I should Lik- to pres-nt affidavit HA-2 which deals with the n_c ssity it'. *rjrpos- of th- consulting physic inns. Ton will find th* t on o fe 5 of Document 3ook I *n it will become Exhibit 37. 1 further suoiit to you dv rt cl the a— ting cl consulting ohysicians on th- 17th of 11-y 1944 which took pi: c- at Hahenlychcn. This will o-ccrj, document HA-2-A, -297S- 13 Pcb. 47 -iL- 9-3-PIi?- Gross Court So. 1 exhibit 38 an.' it con oc found ir. the annax of Doci»nt Book 1. Th_ chert is to show tr._ Tribunal th«. extent of the work th t rs done within th-&o two days rv 2 the IdttJ of l»ctur«-3 th t were given.Further rvor_, that for the lu-Jors of this cutting rvl the individual paritci-xants it was L-nossibU to listen to a part of the:*, lectures - that -'ll hd to confine thoosclves to their own field. In conclusion I refer to tbo lr.~ady suhaitted .flit'.vit of Gen Arzt Pernor, HA-6 which will becoa- inhibit 26 :ni th- af/idrvit of Prof. R ndercth HA-43, exhibit 32. I finally sucait as KA-1, and exhibit 40, an eXerpt froa the Jud,$a.nt of the Intern'tior.~ 1 liilitary Tribunal, rep rcling the question of conspir'cy ■ n' crijin'I organisations. Thi^ is not rn evidential docuaent. I *orel> ask you to I k. notic- of it. “ 2975 - 13 ? oWW tUrlD—1—Lo s s cr—JP Court I JUEGS SBBlirC* Sr. Sol to, hero J'U identified EA-32 by any exhibit r.urbor? IE, i'iZL~: HA-32? JUICE 533111": Yob. jE* IELY2 I I believe H32 w«a not yot emitted. Tnis ia in 0 ,000 Sook So. 2. Ih'cur.cnt HA-32 la nn affidavit of tho 3cnodictino Abbey, Karla Leach, Xoblonx. It was net yot autoittod. TH2 PH3SII8OT; Vi 11 you plonao giro no once noro tho nunbora of tvn 8 o oxhibita? You proceeded a little too fiat for no to note then no you fiovo then, beginning with Exhibit EA-2? m. HU?St HAr-2 ia in Do cur. cm t 3<>ok So. 1, pn^o 5. It ia offerod „ 8 Exhibit 37. Docun-mt HA-2n, in ^client Book So. 1, con bo found in tho Annex. It ia offered aa Exhibit 30. I nov offer r.o Exhibit 39 nn affidavit of Gcnsralrxt Juedocke. who openk. nV.ut tho inportonce of the ncotin,^ of the conaultin.: phyaiciana. Thi. Document HA-51 con bo found in Docunont 3eok So. 3 and la therefore not nvnilnblo to tho Tribunal. A. I arid thi. nomine Went Book So. 3 i. available in the Soman text but a trrnalntion ha. not yot beer, unvoted. Therefore thi. document i. bom* aubnittod with tho re.ervation that it will later bo aupplonented by ita English tmr.alation. I aa* you to accept it aa :*ibit 39. Tl.cn the Lr, cun cat M «»t *” »■ * n * * " excerpt, froa the Jud. T .ont of the International XiliU-jr Tribunal dated 30 Soptor.bor end 1 Octobor 19 i6. Tr - PBSJ2ET: Owniol. It H not noeo.sniy V offor thet ns on MU. a- Trlbunel vill toko jtf! 1* -ties tf It If M lion V. It in your Dncuwmt >■ » »<"* »* h " v0 ro ° xMU * to bo introduced aa an exhibit. HU 3C, It -111 here no exhibit number. to Tribunal «U1 ro- -rbor the, they n*od the Prosecution to put tho printed report, of to posting. of the MW phy.lcln-.. nt ny disposed. Fro.ecutlon did thr.t -ery kindly. in eceordenso with the section, of the Trlbunel I eskod to reed. copy, end MU. M. " f «— ^ toi r ° iX ' rt “* * trentotlon. of the copies of these report, here not yot been node end I 29 SO 13 7ob4WOV-lO-&-LosBOXwJP Court I liko to to nblo to subnit those o^corpts *b evidence as soon as tta, coco tack v. BO. It oey to possible to do that «hon I presont ny short dncmcntcry evidence, SlBsOly. I should like v. »* tho KWh Tribunal to help no In tho natter of ay 1tao.se,, Setaidt-Sruckon on' Hnrilohon. tltor-a* tho :> r.hol toid no a fov day% on", «d .qnvo no « lottor free Ml* It »onld onporx thr.t those Itns.so. «ro hero. I hove not jot hod on opportunity M .poo* to those Itnoseos. I «• told that thoj oro rot hero at all. iftor the conclusion of crosa oroMnotl-n I should like to ho*r tho.o t„ 1tno.se. in tho ccortreor. -end I should 111- " a too Tribunal to find out on tholr part vhoro those wltnossos nro. ~r; BOSXSS^t VU1 tho Cocrctary General or.dcm" • to ascertain tho vhoror.tftuts of tho two wltnossos r.cntionod by cun.ol for tho Do- fondant Handloscr dur'jn: tho iv*or. rocons? BU mOt Tn-nic yu Tory r.uch. M that brings no to tho end of ry cxrc:iar.tlon of tho Defendant Handlosor. TOMB sn Sr. Sol to. on February 12 *» roforor-co -a. undo to a Dr. Bra. of Laval. The Tribunal put a question to tho dofondont eor.comIns tho Identity and offlolal etntu. of tho footer, to vMch eono con oral nicer vac .plv* V ~ »—» *» *>” * thaw that Kaos »a. a civilian connected 1th eooo eort of olvlllon rosorxeh institute. I believe that at that tine y-u eftod to the Tribe r.-l that hoforo J-u concluded y-ur oa. J-u -uld ho nhlo to rive u. f~- thor infori-tl-n. either thr-.-h a Itnos. or hj of.-ld-nvlts. of tho enact and precise nature, or.d It 111 ho jour purpose .*o *luo hoforo ,o„ Close your cr.ec to do that, I sur»;oso? 3U HZLS2* Icb. jraop ffi®. tohi the curse of tho exsrinatlon of this dofoc d-nt tho defendant ha. referred sovurrl tine, to tho foot that In certain -.tor. lr.vol 1 .-v certain doolslons. tho defendant Bnrl Drondt succoec full, ir.torcodod for hln ond 1 * no. directing this queetl-n to tho 1 t- r.css: mth Hoc did Karl Brandt In oroodel 2981 13 7c 'r-; lAi-10-&-Lo 6 G exv-JP C^nrt 2 aa- S3: •TV.9lr.tlr.-z vac vrhted. I don't holioro tho translation wra quito correct. Tho .jivon ns *ral«od objdc'lon". I think that tho Jui,~o 2981 (a) 1C 7 . b-£ W. 1'Jr -lG-o-I-3 3 *cr—Jr Court I to ’mow at what r,^ency Prof. 3randt stgjportod you? ITT 'Z'Z.~2SS~. Yes. lhat could only have boor, do no at any agency which had nry influence* I sujposo that in Party affairs it would have been Bornena c::ccnt for the Fuchror as for as I can judge it, and if "o were cncerr.cd with nilitary affairs I think ho would hare ir.torvcr.od with tho * Fuehrer end spoken to bin, • JUDGE sssznt fcr.otbin* vas said about Ir. Handlosor he in.- ur.tod, evor. casmndod, to rid his organisation «.f catholic r-ursos end to supplant then with nurses tokos fron tho SS organization, and tart Karl Brandt sup¬ ported hie ir. Ills viow to rotnin tho catholic nursos. With whon did Xorl 3r-r.dt intcrcodo ir. 7our support? TS VXSJSSS: I nay soy that "SS Sisters 1 is not corroct. It ie "2 T G— Fntifttnl Socialist Sisters." It was a rational Socialist I'ursin,- Associa¬ tion which has really- nothin,- to do with S3. I cannot r y in this spocinl caso in vh’ t nmnor 3rmdt C'-uli -ivo no support. During onothor oxrsii- notion I thiJc a docur.cr.t was nutnitted uhoro sor.obocly conflmcd th-.t Brandt trie*, t interrono in favor of tho catholic sictorc. How ho ronlly did that, Frof. Brnndt would hnvo to stato hinsolf* I oonnot .*ivo you ny details about it. I only know its effocto. JUH02 S23U3SQS What did y u undorstnnd was tho sphoro of Dr. Karl Brandt's authority or influonco, oithor In nilitrry nodical nattors or in Poxty no died cat tors? err MlZ’ZSSl Wo wore then sot concomod With an;.- authority but it vas r-thor r. siturtion where Prof. 3rmdt had tho possibility which ho ueod to .'.oution ouch anniotioe and uorrice to tho Fuehrer by way of conversation, in ordor tr oountoivb.-la.ioo to a cortoin extent tho things which wore triod fron another side. Wo voro not then concomod with nny authority but, as I said beforo, it was a possibility t bring those nat¬ ters V. tho attention of tho Fuehrer and inforo hie about theso things fr^r. ’-cr point of viow. JUDS3 SES1H5: Will y u state ag-ln who had a onflictin,- point of view with teat of yours in ro.-y\rd V- these natters—vh-.t persons or ngcncioe either in the yrroraaont or in tho party? 2S81 13 Feb ii7-'l - 11-1 - LvQ - feebaa a. his care to ry knowledge through a liaison can between the Party Chancellery and the OX.'. He was present at that tico during dis¬ cussions regarding these student cccpanies and was with the OKA freo whom he received thase directives and when he had to influence him, but ho was the liaison nan between toe Part. Jhancollory and the OK.. IKS .RESH32T: Has counsel for the Defendant Handlcser any further questions? D?.. HKLTEj Ko, thank you, not at the =i C.irt I 13 Feb k7-H - 11-2- LJG -cahan technical cr.ttars? *. Yea, teat say wall be correct. Could a situation arise ir. question- f rilitary competency that a superior had th- right tc issue directives to a subordinate , nho was not directly tuberoinatc- to him? A. Tea, that happened too. 3. .hat influ.nc- did those relationships hiv - the superiors - in relationship to r.sponsibility; is it correct that who-9t;r issued an ordor had tc assure responsibility for whatever he ordered and that whovor carried out the order hart to -ssxrre responsibility for what ho ans doing? A. That is correct. Q. Then, I should like to ask a question with reference to nnothc sphere; fer xhat r asen .-as tho participation of the -affon SS nocossnry during tho re-tin* of tho consulting physicians? •v. Tho .nffun 3°, over sinco tho bopinning of the war, was particl- . "tin,. with the .ohnracht and ca .itted to the ..dhmacht and in an ever irervasin amount the entiro services, Including tho modi cal oorvico, had tc -otabllsh con acts, of co rso, fighting should • to shoulder with other branenos . iyir. with ‘.ho sa-iu diroctl os. That is why it tr\z nuceosary *r.it -.von i .. ti- ., «hon there wore only a few divisions chitted, that tec so iecicrl i fleers hud contactWl'Jl tho entire londor- ship and received kn .locito end re} is about the principles, which " re valid for tho entire sysa.v and that is in jarticular reference t o y i-r-o. •A. ihmk you, I have n. fur char qu-_3tions. •r.. cHJtBTs 1 -oulcl like to have the r-ccrd shew that tec question- r.ich have just bevr. put to the witness, huv« been put by Dr. Fleming for tha Defendant -;ru cwsky. .'.-a rFSSiiSkTi Tho record will seshevr. ... >r.fense C: unsol fur Defendant Gerhard & 06 Q.) -23 Cwrt I 13 F-j U7 - A - 11-3 - LJ3 - Heahsa *• .d truss, did you kr.tr the IX-fendant Rosa befor-. the 8th of :iay, 15U5? *»• YwS. * •}. Did you it any tic*. speak tc the Uefendwt ftose about any of tho counts as charjud by the Fr-Socuticn before eay 3th, 19L5 or did ycu have n^r written or other cot. urdeeti ns directly cr indirectly with hi*.'? A. Ho. ' Did ycu at any ti:» see the r*.fendar.t Rose j: irticipata in any cenfwronccs w.-.;ra the counts as charged in the indie too nt wore discussed ;r ropertod? a. No. •1. .ip xt fro; whether the date r thu ccnt--nte of tho conferences, jontionud in tho Dir\> Dicry of tho 29th cf D-icc-toor, 1/Ll, oro correct or not, I should like you U toll wh.tn.r the Defendant Rosa at any ti * took art in c typhus taotln* where y^u er SvCroV.jy cf St~M Centi .ttor.icd too? A. No. ... Is the Dof6ndant R^se, as fur as you know; or rather was tho Befondant Rose considered as a specialist for typhus vaccino? A. He, Res. in She first instance w~s a troop hygienist. A. bid you as.; the Defendant Res-* to *i v-j you j ccinsal about the investigation of tho typhus vaccine.? a. He. i. Is it corr-.ct to say, i. a assume accordingly, that Rcso was r. t censu.tod by ycu in typhus v-acoino ratters, bc-causi he was n^t a socialist in ti; .t field, although u, yourself, -s Chief of the •lehr, cent -cdical Service, would have, had tho possibility tc ask hit'. haJ u rooted to do 30 ? f>.s, that is cc r_ct. -M.se did net belong tc the cont-.r, which I would hr.vu turned to in r^k,ard to these qu-stiens. Co- rt I 13 ?Jb U7-h - 11-U - LX * ifeebaa And n»w another question; you w^r* already speaking -.bout the taala -f tho consulting physicians with tho axr_e <2 forces. I should li 5 : you to .s. Shcy vwro n/.turrlly retired fre-o different nrrto if Qcr rny rnd the principle vre rlvrye followed thrt they Vo i-aeKnod to each rry ,roues thrt were in the sr;.e hoje territ.r*, bo you hive to con¬ sider thrt. rnd if yvu rls> ccnsicer *. - difference of rink it could v e ouitw -»*ai.le that tn older md roco. # defondrn. Kotc furin,- the entire ~rr vr® tho consulting hv rT ie- ni.t rnd trooicrl t*dicrl e^ert with the hedicrl Inonectorrto. or rrthor. with the chief of the hedicnl Service A the Luft-r/f^. In this cr-rcity h< into contact with you rnd verier, of ycur office. Vould y-U olorso eay S^othiru- r .out the vcy he considered ^terirlly and -rofcssionrlly Vy y-u rad your r«e ncy7 a. Hose vns considered es *n exirc ely experienced s’ooclrlist in his field, vv o caoMned *rer.t scientific tacvlcc-o with oncticrl rVilitlos. : knowledge k. e always considered to he very high, roscected. His strtcr entr were rlwryt to the noint end cs^ecirlly criticrl. .v_r Verc the i.iliUry authorities end treks; thrt ! V Ar.>th«r aueetion. Vcrc C-urt So. 1 12 Job ,7-fc-ia-a-iEI-5ix«iucic ta soy, tka executive authorities pas' the vowr -if co~-.end of r consulting scientist who hrr beccr.e Goncrdnrrt of the reserve, lnecsplirnco with ouch thrt -tc valid fcxv. t, expect with MV ran vhc holds such c rrnk; tha t is to spy, itn active Ceotrpli rctl A. At first, I h»re to si y thrt . .c f ;enord '-ositloa of dl senerde vf^s the sr-io. There m s no difference rt dl. that you ere rodly referrin,: to ire tho authorities rad the pw*r of cc.^rnd *+.ich he hr/ inf. in thrt con¬ nection I hrve to sty thrt the consulting nhyslcirr-s hr/ m> *>ovor of cofTinnd it* no nuthonity to issuo orr.ors. In nd ition, I hrve *o sry thrt iJ r.n ectivo Osnordcrrt was c Cvnsultizx Jhycicier. the oucstion of whether he wrs r.ctive or not rctivs plrys no tart rt dl. It is the nosition which counts, nr during the entire '/or there wrs no aeesosity to ,;ive »ny c ccid *:ower of eotuenr t* these consulting -.hysicl/ns. v Do y-u rericatcr thrt durin.: the cutunn of 19«t*i he ST v»,ntod to intr-ducc ';roce«6in..s *vnlnst rrofessor Hose bvcr.ust *f trvi son, since rro- fosor ?.oso held, lectures in tho noutrrl countries r’rrcnd, Svitrorlnnd nw Turkey, wherein ho described tho nro^-ross in detrll which wrs :udc in Qerr.wiy in the field of coobnt of ty-ihus aid arlnrid *. Ycc, I roauiher thrt. ^ Do you further kn-w th> t .-refesn-r Hose exdrinod hie rttltude by Bcyln£ thrt record in.* t, his opinion the results of nodicrl reoerrch in vro i wull rs in -.o-co should lore* it the entiro society, Just in the snno wry rs the indlvidud physician vee otli^od to C-ke no difference ir. his wtrk bo- tveen friend or foe? A. Yes, I knov th; t. v Did you knov vhc*. ccnsoottor.e«s rrofessor Hose hrd to expect roeulti fr ls hie ettitudo, end did you cover tin with the nuth.rity of your n^ncy. Yes, I did thr.t in n^reer.ent with tho aedied chief of tho Luftvcff ~- f-r cs I rejeabor. v Vhr.t v^uld rrofess-r Hose heve hed to exccct hrd he not Iclr ccverc y;u end his sujeriors rt the eirforce? A. he valid hrve to eroeet thrt sece uoliticrl roer-surce would bo trker Court So. 1 I? Je> -;7-ii-12-3-*»M:inetttek t;n iut hirj. Of c-ursc I cannot sey vfapt kind of r.e*surc. v ny inst aucstion. *ou were tettifj'ic. - : earlier th't you attended the keortitic noctins in Bresleu in the ye-r of 1944. Ues Professor Rose there? A. Sc. IE. 5EirZ: Think y.u. kr. president, I h/vc no further ouestions. A XHL pSZSXXES 3; I vyuld like to ti.vite Ur. Solto, attorney for the de¬ fendant Handloser, thrt I hr.ve hec tone inf-r.-ptior. Jurt hinded to oe thr-t X the witnesses, Dr. Uolf.-oxv Schoidt-Br ceken turf Hmo Kortleten, rro not now ftvrilr'le in "uernter,:. Counsel ni«;ht ineuire p.t the Defense Information Center cn.'. nossi.ly oltria core lnfomptlon then I have available here. Cho r.'itunol will now r«*ese until 1:30 o'clock this rfternocn. (A recoss vrs taken until 1330 h«Airs.) -25S9- n -eb I*7-t-FjC-l>l-putty -ourt I CORRECTS COPY ATTERiPOK 3ES3I0K (The hearing reconvened at 1330 hours, 13 February 19!tf.) "HE LARSHAL: The tribunal is again in session. THE PRESIDE?”: In regard to ‘he application of Defendant Rudolf Brandt for an excuse, the Tribunal directs that tho Secretary-General inform the commander of the prison that he should instruct t*e prison surgeon to examine the defendant, Rudolf Brandt, concerning his phy¬ sical condition and report tc the Tribunal so that the Tribunal thon nay doton-ino its future action. As tho Tribunal rill not be in session after thi- aft moon until Tuesday morning, there will be adoquate time for the examination and the roport. Tho defendant, Rudolf Brandt, my bo excused from attendance at the roquest of his Counsel for this aftomoon session. Is thoro any furthor cross-oxom nation of dofondant Hsndloser by enj' Dofonae Counsel? T.jere bolng nono, tho Prosecution my cross- oxanino. SIB3FRI2) HaJDLGSER - Rocunod CROSS 2LJ X-.TIOH 3T IR. VC HAKEY: ‘R. 1C EAKET: lay it ploaso the Tribunal: Q Qeneral, as I understand it, you admit that by virtue of your position as army physician and aimy medical Inspector, you had complete cormar.d end control over tho AraQr kedical Service, the Sanitaotsdienst and tho Sanitaetswe3cn, is that right? A los. I was the hoap'<7( t\e_ mod foal, system of tho army and the Av: ^ superior of the entire medical personnel. < rxi that control covered the period January 19Ul, to September, 19to? ’ , 7 • \ v V / . A Yes. \ . : _ 1 , ' / i I take it, therefore, asSuae responsibility for -H official activities of the J-dical Service durinr that period? 2990 13 ?eb Ii7-A-?JC-13-1-Putty Court I A I have already stated that I do not have any doubts about the fact that I havo to bear the responsibility for whatever I have ordored through a general order or by aoans of a decree. 3 'ihat was this institute for typhus and virus research at Lemberg % which you testified was under the control of the OKH? % 2990 A 13 Fob 47—..-FTC—13—2—rutty Court B°. 1 Yos. It was subordinated to the KOdicnl Inspectorate of the Rich Caxanl of tho A*cy. * '..'oil, was that tho vaccine production plant of tho Bohrlnv ’Parks at La. tor;? *»• As far os I or. infoit»d rf tho Institute of tho QBH at Krakow or at Lor.'-orp dil not hovo anythinc to do with tJ-o instituto for the Bohrlnc ’dorks. In any oaso, I havo not boon infcri-sd of anythin olso. . Did this Instituto for Typhus and 7lrus Hosoarch at lo:.bor_ for ^ tho OKK produce typhus vaccino? A 7hoy producod tho well-known typhus vaccino fra: tho intostinos cf lico occorcUnc to tho Total =othcd. *. Tfafior whoso oontrr.l and Jurisdicb.on was tho vaooino production plant of tho Bohrin Torts? A I cannot say that exactly. I only know ono thin- about tho Bohrln '■'orkM, that tho necfl of Dr. Bane was i-intlonod in that cnnoctlan. •. Did tho typhus instituto of tho OKH at Laibor'j und at Krakow So any rosonrch work on tho officacy of typhus vacolnos, or vcs tholr work oLr...ly roatrictod to vaccino production? A Tho :;ol 1 Vaccino which was produced by tho Instituto 2it*l alrocdy oxiotol oovoral year* uforo tho outbroke of th* war, ■»! os I have already st-t&i in yostordry*s sosolon, it Mas produced on a lor o-scalo in vcri.ua c cun trios, and it wan tootol in various countri-s with ro^ord to its offoctivonoss n‘ its oa;patlUlity. Thoroforo, a tostia. of thio vaccino wns not nocossarry nnyiroro. *. ‘tall, your answer tkoro is, than, that thoso hr. typfcua instituto of tho OXH restrict®; thoir aotlritloo to vac&lno productl :n, is that rl ht? Yos. I do not know what othor possibility c-n ’jo soon bo3idos production, JC ” usa typhus Instituto at Krakow or at Lor bor , as far as I krrw, triod *• flal yot another vaccino. First of ail, it was tho task to carry nit and • ncroaso with all cssiblo roans tho production of tho vaccina, and as far as I rXxr ‘ r » ^ has also nedo oxrorirxints .1 anlUals in orlur to Vo able to cut “ - --- ore onto, o of tlK vaccino and thus to obtain a larpor amount. 2991 13 -'Ob hl-^Skk -lii-l-Beard (?X) Court I 3 Did you ever visit tha Institute GKH at Lenberg? A In 1939 I visited the Institute at Krakow, and in 19U1 or 19U2 I have also visited the Institute at Lemberg. On the occasion of the visit to Lemberg I also'talked to Dr. ‘••eigl, himself, who was the man who had introduced the vaccine. 3 In ot!.er words, ^eigl was working at ienberg in 1911 when you visited thero? A A las, ne was working in the the Institute. Q •too was the Conrar.der of the Institute? A Prof. Dr. Kyer, a high staff medical officer who had received special training in this procedure. Q He was also the Coacanding Officer of the Institute at Krakow; is that right? A Yos. 3 Kow, General, . ou testified on direct examination that after being appointed Chief of the l.odical Servico of tho nohre&cht on 28 July 19U2, it was one of your dutios to provide uniform and coordinated measuros in tho field of Health Guidaneo, research, and combating of opidoalcs, and all medical neasuros which retired a unifonr. ruling among the uehrmncht; is that right? A A uniform coordination and coordination was one of ry nss5gn- ronts or measures. Q »r.l that applied to the fiold of health ’uidanca, research, the combating of opidnnics, ar.d all medical measuros which required a uniform ruling; io that right? A A similar text is contained in my official instructions, as to the performance of my duties. 3 *'-nd your tasks also covered tho evaluation of nodical experiences •nd medical ratters of tho recruiting system, of tho - >lforo and main¬ tenance of prisoners of war? A Yes, hit I want to point out that what you arc reading nor, ’• -* is from the official instructions for cy duties of tho year 19hii. 2992 13 Fob-ii7—?JC-U*-2-3 mM Court I Q Jfow, General, I want you to pay close attention to ay questions and T,- will get along a little faster. The first question I put to you was, your tasks after you were first appointed on 28 July 191*2, and I asked you with nj3poct to that, if it was not your duty to provide uni¬ form and coordinated erasures in the field of health guidance research, ar.d the combating of opideaics, and all nodical measures which required uniform ruling. Ziow, give me an answer, yos or no? «. A .lie docrco of 19l*2, this Js not contained — i (Interposing) General, wo all understand it is ftot in the decree of 19U2, or I would not to asking you the question. The fact is there was a service regulation issued on 28 July 1?1*2, which tho Prosecution has not yet put into cvidonco, and I aa asking you aono questions about your duties os contained in that scrvico regulation, and I will ask you to give in answer now to the ;uostion I put to you. A x ho tasks of tho Chiof of tho Wchmacht lodical Sorvice generally roforrod to, what you have cantior.ad, tho coordination of those — also in view of those soctions of tho nedical aorvico which could not be coordinated at all. Q nd that covored health guidanco, did it not? A .'oil, this quostion is vory difficult to answor. *..'hon I issuod an order, then ttut Indlcatod alroady that by sooo noans I shall soo that those r.oasuro3 aro carried out. Q And your tasks in tho field of having coordinated treasures also coverod the :ocbating of cpidoaics; did it not? lea. Q A nc i scientific research? A les, scientific research has boon ropoatodly discussed horo, and it has toon described, and it ha3 boen statod now this has to be under¬ stood. Jbw. or.o must differentiate on the subject. Q 'nd the service regulations of 23 July 1922, also stated that it Tfas y c ' dr Joo to have coordinated the evaluation of nodical experiments • • nodical natters of the recruiting systenj did it not? 2993 13 *eb U7-^-:^>lii-3-3oard (?JC) Court I A That nay bo, yes. Q And it also covered the welfare and maintenance of prisoners of war; did it not? A Yes. % Q I tor, General, as you have already observed, the dutios which I have Just been interrogating you about, which wore contained in the serv¬ ice regulations of 23 July 191*2, issued to you by Field Uarshal Keitel, are soma of the sane dutios t^at are contained in the servico regulations of 7 August l?!!. v A I an not able to confirm that because I have personally asked for this servico regulation, and as far as I aa Info mod, qy Dofonso Counsel has tried to, by ell means, to uroduco this regulation in tho official A ray coasunications of 1912, and in tho Any guidance shoots. Thoy havo boon repoatodly requestod and ro tore unable to find any our- vico regulations contained in than. *oH, uonoral, wo are mutually distrossod that you do not hnvo thon in front of you, but in spite of that, I an going to ask you a few r,oro questions about it. It aust bo a natter of considorablo Information, chich you have, since you wore operating 'under that service regulation for a littlo more then two yoars. I have had placed bofsrc you tho aor- vico regulations of 7 August 1911; that is Docuocnt lio. 0227, Prosecu¬ tion's Exhibit 6, and I Just briefly want to „o ovor it with you, to boo exactly hot; nuch difference there vas bot*.;oon thoso service regulations of 23 July l?ii2, which you do not have, and thoso servico regulations which you do tavo of 7 August l?l*k. 1 --. KELTS: ilr, President, nay it ploaao tho Tribunal, I request ruling or the Tribunal, if it is admissible, that tho servico regula¬ tions of 1911 are present in tho so.-vico regulations of 191*2, if tha s:rvico regulations of 1912 are not given to the defendant. If there is 3 con P ar ison to be drawn between thoso two servico regulations, thon ho, -c dofandant cannot support himself on that alone, iihat the Prosocution - reading to him is contained in the service rerulations of 19hL. but 299h 13 ?eb li7-~--*A-lii-3-3eard (PJC) Court I he aust also be given the opportunity to exa&ino that and to point out the practical differences, which perhaps 299h A 13 ?eb U7-A-3Jl-JM-Boani (FJC) Court I cannot be recognized from thj text ale no, especially with regard to the authority. 1 ?., *£ HA KEY: If the Tribunal pleases, I must object to having the cross examination in to rr up tod in this Banner. I have nothing elso to say about Dr. Ifolto's objections on this part. Thoro cortainly can¬ not fco ’ny objections to ry putting these questions to the witness. THE PRESIDE IT; Tho Counsel for tho defendant nay interposo my objection that ha dosiros to intorposo. Tho Tribunal will r.sk tho Proso- cution If it has available tho regulations of 19U2, % which havo boon roforred to? UP.. ’£ FAXZT: do not, your Honor. 7ii2 rRSSIDaT: If tho ritr.oc? is unfamiliar with tho regulations th -1 aro not boforo him, ho asy any so, but tho objection as medo by the Dofcruft) Counsel rill bo overruled. 5Y I?.. 1C HAMEIt Q Sonora 1 , I did not toll you that wo had the so sorvico regulations, rxi If 70 U juapod to that conclusion by soao of tho quo3tions I put to you, >rhy that is your own responsibility on tho tootimony that you ero about to give. In any ovont, wo ore interested in knowing what wao in those sorrlco regulations of 23 July 191:2. Lot *c look at tho ono of 7 August 1911, which is before youj look undor Part 2 whoro it snys "Duties". *ho first paragraph roads: "Tho Chiof of tho Ledicai Sorvico of the T/ohrnacht ia the advi3«-r of tho Ch'af of tho High Conrwid of the >Tohr- macht and of its health guidance." -as that snao paragraph in the regu¬ lations of 23 July 191*2? I cannot tell you that* I cannot remcober tho oxact teat of tho sorvico regulations. 13 ?o=ru-r;'-i-3JG-l5-L-3lttJaey Court Jo. 1 4 Souornl, wo uaiorstand thet you couldn’t «it down nnd dictate this sorvico regulation of 23 July 13li2; but isn't It & fact th> t you wore tho adviser of Keitel after 2o JUly 19 L 2 on nodical questions? Isn’t that rl : dit' A Toe, that is correct. •i Isn't that all that this first Taro.Th.ph says? A Tho fir3t .xtra,T .nh states; "The chief of tho nodical sorvlco Is tno advisor of tho chief of tho OK J In all questl ns poitninin,; to tho ser.'lca of the '..ohrancht nni the o.hor or,/mirations. ■ That Is tho text ns It is Arondy contained in the sorvlco regulation of 193no. Is that rl.fct? A Since a si.ilir .crcgroph is also contcinod in the ro.ul: tion for tao spec ini consultant of tho OW it is proa: bio that it in providod for in tho similar text in tho rotation of 1942. s Y.ry well, lot's look at Pura,;r .ph 2 . That sr.ys: "Tno chief of tflo nodical ervicos of tho Vahr.xvcht will direct the total nodical oorvicos of cr»o -ohr.cent as fares the special fiold is concornod with ro,: rd or tho .dlit ry loot rue ti 70S of the cnivf of tho hi.fc coenml of the ar.iod force end the . Onoral rUcs of t..o ?-ohr«r's co.-roisnioncr ,\«n>rnl or r.edicrl an d health do. art.-nt." 2 tnt s'.w yum. rnph wt c in tho norvlco regulation of 2u July 19-2, vtss't it? - I u unr'.le to ivo you an exact statement ->n that. v VU too sang r»vrph in subftunco in tho sorvlco rerul-tion of July 1.42? .. I ernnot so;- how .c.ny r.ra.T'.yhs wero contained in tho scrvico re¬ flation; how they were ordered; and vhat they contained individually. .. Gon-ral, doesn't the FUohr.r decroo Itself require ym to toko cert instructions in tho v-ecil field fron Karl 3r nc.tJ Isn't he autho>- i:.i to intervene In a responsible naanor by that decree? A Li the directive by tho Fuehrer of 19*.2, ns far ns I enow, it is 2996 v. 13 ?cbruc-r^-2JG-15-S-3lrJcloy C urt St. 1 ctstcd that tho .ronsrol connisaioaar of the FUohror Is authorised to docido that so has to bo Informed about fusdu-.or.tel tillage fro.: the ox: y nodical aarvico; that ho la authorised to include tinsolf; that ho io cllovod to int-rveso. that ia vhnt l\ cor.ti.in_d is the Fuehrer doc roc wild, wo hrve hero. . Lot *8 ,.o oa to too third psrr-.-rr.ri. General, rho first part roadat ■jho c-’.iof of tho nodical aervicoa of the tfehrn&cht will infora^thc Fup!>- ror's co:-.laeloncr .“ca_rcl ..;out aajor over.to in tno fiold of tho nodical aervicoa of t'.:o Vohrsmcht." Ct-t waa required y tho tarvico rculr.tion of 2e July 1942, wnac't it? A 1 cannot as}’ that with Cvit'inty. It ia po»alblo thrt thia atato- _ent ia contained ia r;y -o.iory fro., perhaps thia ro .illation. It io quito :: oo ai lo that tho text ori-lcr.tos fro.i thia, Slat ia tho dircctivo of 1944. ^ Voror.'t you required by the fuehrer docroo of 2 S July 1942 to rv.-ort to 3ror.dt on basic or fundamental event at A Voll, I would have to oak you to hr. ad ovor thu docroc to :.w>. I cannot ot .to that vitk-.ut it. i 3ut, General, you've eoor. thia docroc I .'juoaa a doron tinea already; uni you ope rat od und^r it for about four yours. Did you ua r. nnttor of fact report to Lori Drnndt on fundnnontal events in tho nodical eorvico after 2 o July of '42? Can you tell ua about that! - J:out sat tor a pertaining to the nodical fiold I cannot ro:>o:-bor any apoeifio cate. They >^e *u: port or nid with vohlclos or nlrplnnoa. Let 'a o on to too next p*ra.i-ph, rarn^-.ph 3 . It anya: "You will re.resent the Voursscht to t-.c civilian authorities in uutunl .wdical affairs mi will protect their interests in connection -dth tho health -ensures of the civilian ndnioistrutivo cuthoritloa. ■ ‘fi’.an't that contained i.. aubstaacc in tho service regulation of 26 July 19 L 2? _ I csnr.ot any th t. It ia understood that t..c t *Y. of the chief Of the nodical aorvicc toward the civilian minorities is. I would llku to 2997 13 7oirwu^->-IW0- *-15 >-3lr±lcy Court Ho. 1 Buy that It Is a certainty. ; 3ut yiu would like to scy that It was coatr-iaed ir. tkcro? In that rl^t? A I cr-oaot say thr.t. I have to stato n^aln thr.t It is after c Ion/; % *t_o hero when wo discussed theso questions for the first tiuo la tho dli>- cusslor. aid out basic docuu^nts waled I would like to hivo. I cr-w hero without cay docu^-ats nt ell: end then I requested tho Fuehrer Aocroo of lS4d. If thero wore oay addition:.! explanations for it or not, I person¬ ally stated on the subject t.o.t aoaothl'h^ could still bo jsyoilnblo in vrltlr,. I know for cert .In ..w.t Dr. ITclto cm obtained tho nrcjr ro.pu- lctloa naoet; but I cna re-e-Acr ween he told us that thero Is nothin,-: on U.e subject C-ntninod In it. I told hi:; that I would road It over .ysolf perhaps sinco he was unr.blo to find It. actually, It was not lintod in tee table of cor.t«nts; cad I havo looked thread: tho nhoots for tills SOTticulr.r shwot. Then tho re Is the further doea-ontary sheet about ,"onorol s.y co:. .ur.icr.tions. pr. Kelte obtained t.ils shoet alto, and nothin.-was c:nt: laod In It. So thr.t I .yself bocaae suspicious. ffion Dr. Hclto vroto to so.jobody else cal he received Uo information that thio aist bo contained in tho cr.y ro-ul- tions, either on shoot o A. 3. or C. 3>on wo n,»in road over tho arjy shoet of re.,-ulr.tions; rad wo dl not find anything vhntooover in Parts A, 3, cad C. ^ ITow, General, this Is all very sed that you hnvon't boon able to find .11 these docu.-jr.t3 that you'd liko to hnvo; but both tho dofonuo and the .riaooutlen a.-o labor in.. under so.^e of those sr-io ifficultios. I SB Just try!:, to ,.ot a little infcrmctlon fro., y/u -ere a out whrt you woro do in. ,.g cnief of the :.cdicd serricos of the 'ahnxcct; and I assu-oo thr.t tiace you cold th-t Jo: for t* out four yeexs, you hr.ro bo.;« vr^c rocollr- cctloc about v_-.t you wore doin, an’, went you wore -up^ored to do. One of tee questions is Just ox-ctly what chan.:es took piece after this eervico -elation of 7 Au .uot 1944. I hare a very vr^-uj suspicion tijit your duties and y ur _ overs woron't broadened to any substantif-l ^xtont r.t all: and I r— nov try ir. to find out vhcroln lies the dlffcronco betveon your duties 1 } Fcbru. r;OOJG-l7-U-31ul©r Court So. i and rvr^nBi'^llitioB ns of 25 July 1942 and as of 7 Auuot 1944. Sow, If you dtn't ~cv rad can't toll ua *e t thcao differoncos were, will you Just f ;o thocd red state ri,it now tint you don't Know, «md thor. wo can aovo on to ao-.c other topic. * A I nave already stntod hero that It 1 b elor.rly Indicated T>y tho Fuehrer dccrcaa that the anin dlfforonco Hot in th-t I was ranted nn authority to Ibbuo orders; and the sooond le n bc^ .ration of tho previous .eraonol u.:lon hotwoon tea :.eiic:l inspector. X •v Sow, GwUBcnl, wo understand tr.ls separation; and I'u of tr.u opinion that that was really t.:c rots>n that this aocool Fuehrer docroo was lafiucd end that that was au. at ant lolly tao only roason; hut yni any that in add¬ ition you .-ot so o pawor to ls*vu» ordoro. I sup oso .that la contalnod In Fort I of t .Is Bcrvico ro, ulr tlor.. Vlll you look >xt th» t nnd toll ub h... r~i.: t..is r.ddlti onnl power was ,lvcn to you? _ It la stated under ITuJber I In tno last sontonco of Farr-ya h 1 of tho -Uo..ror decree: "Ho is authorised to issue order# In all spoclflc qu.stims within his flold of co:.potcnco. ■ In the docroo undor Articlo 2 In tr.e "crvlco retaliation approvod by tho juohror it Is nt- tod undor Parr— r.-.jfc 2, II, "Ibo authority who, accordin, to Butwyaph 1, that lo, is the authority in question, also refers to the nrpy nodical i.-.s-octor, tho cnlef of tho navy aedic.il ocrvlco. too cnlof of tuo .icdical ocrvico of tho Luftwaffe, t..o ohlef of the nodical sorvlcc of t-;o 'Jaffen SS. '-nd tho — lieA c.lvfs of tho or.ruolsaiiJnc and services o~ loy.>d within tho fr.-n o- wtrh of the Ue-ir. cat, w.illo t«'.ogr oro act in.; In thv area of cortand of tho •Cnnxicht#" Therefore, that la la F:xa.T: _ih 2 the explanation of tho .ut.nrity .Ivon In Fnrsfir.Vi. 1 of tho Fuehrer decree. 1 ? Fob !.7W.-F'C-l6-l-Cook C-jurt I Q You didn't have any porer to issue orders to Hippko and Schrooder byforo 7 August, 19UU, is that what you want to say? A Before 19UU I did not have authority to issuo orders. Q Boforo 7 August, 19UL? % A Xus. Q A'oll did you have any power to issuo general instructions which •.rould bo binding upon Hippko and -chroodor? ^ A After tho docroo of 19UU I was ablo to do that. Q .«o are not talking about the period new after tho seYvica regu¬ lation and the Fuehrer Deere- of 7 August, 19UU. aro both agroed that fron and nftor that tiao you could issuo orders. 1 an non inquiring about your authority before that '-imo, and I askod you if you could issuo gor.oral Instructions to Hippko and Schroodor which would bo binding on thoc? a In tho fiold of notorial coordination and fron tho noconsity which nroso for a sinplo caso within the fcxlicol Sorrico and its coordi¬ nation, I was ablo to issuo on order in cases of this kind, bocauso othor- wiso I would have boon unable to carry out such a coordination. Hwrovor, thj branches of tho ••chrsacht ar.d the i-edical Chiofs woro ablo to object to those orders and I did not hav: the authority to issuo diroctivoa, authority to i 33 Uu those diructivos in tho fom of an order, and that is what is the noin thing in the military fiold. Q ~'j foro August 19UU you diu have power to issuo diroctivoa, but you sey you lid not have power to issue ordors, i 6 that right? « "os, that is correct. Q Could you go to Eoitol and have hin pass down an order for you to Kippk- end Cchroodor? A Yas, to a certain extent Keitel was able to issuo such c diroctivo. * .3 i 3 also tb. caso with ragard to mutual erasures, like, for oxaxplo, •h protecting of troops against the winter and sinilar cases. * o understand your special field. General, and nobody is insisting : u -.id the power to issue an order to Hippko having nothing to do with 3000 13 Fob L 7-^-r 'C-l6-l-~ook Court I the nodical service of vour so-called special field. mj aro Just linit- ing ourselves to the special fiold. Ikrn, doctor, Hippke has testified before another 3000 A 13 Feb u7-^-?jC-l£-2-Cook Court I Tribunal hero and ho was -la reading free the Znglish transcripts, of tho 7 February, 19h7, in the action “United States vs. Srhard Milch", pogo 765, Hippka was aakod: ■Tfaat was your official connection with General Oborstebsarzt Hand¬ les or of tto Lodical Haporteent of tho Tehraecht?" And Hippko replied: "'.ihon tho lodical Dopart&jnt of tho T/ohraacht --as created it was sought to coatdno all questions that concornod any of the throo brrnchos of the Arqy, and ho was ny auporior as Modi cal Oonaral. x Kandlosor who had previously boon on an equal basis with na as nodical inspector for tho any, new when ho also took on the new task, ho bocauo ry sujwrior." And then tho further qxastion was put to Hippko: •Coll could to givo you orders? uhat do you noan by tho word "superior"? And X know you will be surprised to hoar that Hippko ansircrodi "Yos, ho could givo bo orders and establish a policy." ?fcxf, was Hippko not tailing tto oxact truth whon ho said you could iss* orders to hin? lou know Hippko went out on the 1st of January, 19Uj, and that was seven months before this second Fuohror decroo wns issued. Tihat do you have to say about Hippko's testimony? A In connoction with his tost loony 1 want to say that if Hippko clains that I had authority to iS3'io orders and If he has described no superior, then I an ur.nbln to understand that, bocaON then it would hrr> boon conpletoly unnecessary' to expressly denand in 1?UU that I bo given authority to issue orders in a particular aanr.or, and «dniral Doonita would still t«j able to r.rcrtor this exactly, that in accordance -..'ith cy previous experiences, I could anly recall carry out ny assignments if I •3 to tccoen his superior, and tho Gross «dairal, in spito of all efforts by heitol, disapproved this, and with a lot of difficulty in 19Ui, to finally succocdod in obtaining for i*? the authority to issuo orders. AH of this ~uld have boon unnecessary' if 1 had been given authority to issuo ord rs already in 19U2 3001 13 Feb i»7—'?jC-l6-2-Cooic Court I Q Soli it still would have boon noccssary bacauso you loft your job as Arny Nodical Inspectorate, you know, so that it is quite natural they would issuo a new sorrice regulation. uaa there any difforonoo betwoon tho Aray * 3001 A 13 Fob 2i7-A-F jC-l£-3-Coo:-: Court I Medical Inspector and the Chiof of tho l^dical Sorvico of tha kray? A Ko, but between tho Arty Uodicol Inspector and tho Chief of tho •chroacht Medical SorriCo. Q “het wns the difforenpo? A Tho -nay Medical Inspector was tho hoad of the kray Uadical Ser¬ vice. Q Gonoral I understand, at least I think I understand, thcy«wcrc both heads of their respective medical services, but I am curious to know why there was this verbal dif’oronco between tho Chi dr of tho Medi¬ cal Service of the Luftwaffe, and tha Arrjy Medical Inspectors. Is thoro any reason for this or is it Just old practice? A The Arty liodical Inspector, whose off ico was already in oxiatonco before tho Luftwaffe was established, has always had this title, bocouso tho arny was organized ir. this manner. It was organizod to the extent that nil of the branches had thoir o>m inspector. There was an Inspector of the Infantry, of tho Artillory, and also an Army liodical Inspector. t. the course of tho years this could not bo changed in spito of the title, although the titlo did not apply. Q .'ith ruspoct to your nodical duties as Chiof of the .-lodiool Servico of the •Johraacht, was Karl Brandt your tochnical superior? A I hivo already stated yo3tordf>Y or tho d->y befora th-t Hrandt was not ay superior. 3 '-oil why did you nalcc such a statement in your affidavit, Gonoral? •or> you ir.pos >d upon by one of those interrogators? A I have also statod hare in tha brief history of ay life, as I h‘.v_ called it here, thi3 containod nmy nistakos, end in tho and and also sac- part of the draft .-hen it was presented to me, it contained - following sentence: "Professor 3rar.dt was ay military and ay nodical :U F rior", that is approximately what was stated there, . Ihy 11* you put :>rl Smelt up at tho top, unloss ho was in fact your superior in toohnlcal attora. •'hat did you :*it hi:, on tho chart at all for? BoOauso It cannot to c'elno! and Vocnuso I war.to', to a-.'id statins that I had not had any contact at all withTrofossor Brandt v ocauso aftor i'll tho e.ntacts are stated in tho Tuohror Docroo and 1 lid r.'t want to /lafio hie noxt to :.o cr tooldo m. That is purely tochnical question. 13 F’-b-A-.J?-17-1-C-ross Court I Q. «n.rcl, ersn't rTofcsscr r--r.it yw superior rlth r.s ,_ct to r.ll duti-s . utl£ud in thv First ?i*.hr..r \c:vo? A. Ir. tU irat Decree, as f.r .-.s I k.:on, it is stated.... * General, r„ knew *hat^ tie Docroo states. I ac asking jau to draw a cone usion. Isn't it true, wit.i respect tc .our functions n'tlin-d in this First Tua&rar IXcrvt, tbit Karl 3r. ndt c-.r superior? *• I ‘"Vc rlrays r .ept. A ’• *- ‘-mbH jfnur super! r, wxtly »;vt r . . id ho hivo to yea? >. I turned it his »h-norcr I b-liuvoc th-t I snculd report a •* so^ciln incident . :.*to t - .: a. dice1 fields tc hi.. and th?t I should bring it t-. hie kiy.vl_c'> 'ccause 1 nfsuc_d tirt this j. ulc suusjbcw roach the oars ci tlio F .ir,r. uld b<. Bter np rcjnrx >«.. r. to b. ini r-.d by c s;Sccialii in tn t 2U1 , cr if it Wore to be.9 lunoc* tt ir. by a^ci-.lists in th-t field b.c”iso i : -ro to b- r^p. rted by lay. u. tiv. wh. 1- * in r*.y In. ..n r ’ * • ' /vjn^vor *. in en CftrguOoy position rit rd t trwapMt ti n £ ;• :ur v.funded I turned t. i md -shod hi ix yusrAw to ft.lp tntBoae •. ay, f r oxaaple. By furnishing us r. squ-dren o 1 -.irer-ft -Men rters h d at its s woi i > : -i. i. isn't tutiliaati.tor 111 tnd ,.rtnn.l n c.aojn pr blew of “ill br-.ne ..a .1 -Ju Vehraacht? Yos. i* • Mt£or«| it is true t tor i : si thin r indie fcion? •*. l'cs. «. — »d th » o as of tiu. ? 20 July 192 * 2 ? •»• Yws. !> c ' Gon-ral, will y u ...1 uc rh- in s.r.-ny i. rutl.r 0X1 "ilitcjrj sciencw and research lr. ..r.„r 1? *• .»? - a lit-ry codic-1 science? !• -wi* run. rch. 3CCb 13 17-2- rocs Court I A. In cy field? Sell, there sc: quit: n rarbar of speci-Iistc. • ° us ‘- "• * minute, ger.aral, I a... -,.«jre sre probably a lot of peoole *ho bad v.ra irucruatioa about typhus, -k ct.. rs had nore infor-r.ticn about epid&nic jaundice, -d othur ^Oj.le he aid sore infons :tior. 'bout fev«;r. cut, I ask you who In Qor^-ny was hotter informed than you ,.crs on iho general picture of ailit ry aodiccl science and research? ... If you spoilt aoout gon.r 1 a-ttors in tlv field of military medical sci-nct as f r - r tho *chrmcht rras concerned, then I believe that I ea quite U ^ ' r ' od ' ‘ o*eVcr, I not oxcopt t.-c spdeial ar'nch-s o research and zxc’ic i rs of tho Ixftw'Afu mv! C. vy of which, to at-t. briefly, I do ot h vo slic;htuat lie:. 1 . I iuvorstr-ad ^rhapa oo .-u* dot a veil infona.d ns o.turs on tho r.?_*rc. probleus ulilch porta n exclusively to tho Lu: .cvy. °» you up.nk of calling together tho udtoal chiefs of tU _hrn.-cl.4br nch In -n effort to avoid duplication e. i.s. irch.,W»n du you do « ... I til 't in tiic n 1 of -_r did it with regard tot lie laocul ion.-* f r -s this refers to ty diuo, par:-typhus, am' chloiva. I hnvo f.rt .r Ir-ctcd coordination of t u Scientific b.n u conference which dealt •• ral vac :nation -gainst tfrsontory. ..side of that I ca.-u.ot n> nny oWa r prude case in that connection. ton you give us the dates or. which ..cu c llod tie c - t toge¬ ther? ..r. not only audical Chiefs Mfe _ro spdcl 1 dV son, .ith r-G- tc -1 ri- I b.licve that t.is :.- 3 in lr'.Jj bec .urc Sci.ro.d.r had *— Prior to t..at tirto 1-fi.a -r.d combatcing aniarir » as cecr-in .it ^ut nny conf_n.ic k Oe*. wdic-1 chiefs xrras , as In 1 9l2, u_*»in..‘nv of 151 . 3 , bec-use the inosculations were c-r~ivd cut in ^Cj 1 . t ,,f * 1% » ? * vi'4# -• bat oeut th, typhus? T- 't i: .ot a typhus v.accin t on. wc e -y typhus tbtn wc .an uost State bar t you 8 typhus, shat wo y*o 13 ?cb-^-v*F-17-3-Gross Court I cill fleckfi-bur, srhlch wens typhus. Q. I U 101 .fat I understood you to etito th-.t you called tc. jttvr uodioil chiefs tht branches to coordinate vcceimtiim against isalaria. You -o.iticrod eo.xhing else a%a * thought you ae'r.t flockfiebcr. «• I believe tut I hrv. said typhus, . - hue, nod e . J3U eg fcy iioid, is th-t rl^ht? ... I 1 . vc amt whit you describe, is tyheoid. 3* Gon.nl, whr.t ws tA- Scientific S n"tc of the cdicix 3wr.icos of tr.. Mhra»cht? A. The. 5-ciJHtiIic S.r. tc ic in i. stitution which v: is first est/.bliehed in 1895 end .• cs. scr&.ra «t th-.t ©art. ? y.ointcd by the -inporor nod, Bubocquentl}, by the heads of t!*- So.-rn..nt. It had n certain niVoor of regular onb-rt ind of irrwgulir o .ra r.:o t .. »*srw tn_ loading scientific p-rsomlitios ir. C.mny in the --die-.! f i-.ld, -.A also a nuUbor o. oldor r.nd ospuciil 7 x ; xrlenced end .lao spucvlly trained active neuicil oliicera and If on- of those r-,- lar or other neuters left, th_n the ._uy edio 1 | ctor, vdio was in c . r'_ of th. Scientific S n-.te, i ouccossor wio su ecter to the h-id of t..e St-U rrlio found th t one rs ip ointud . v_iter of the Scientific Scr. ic. You wore Irusldont of tfi-.t boi'y, -r-n't you? ... I ’resident of S-i-.iti c L ante, Just Ilk- 11 wy pr-d.c- sir. c‘. icl 1895. .• An : you havathat rnsidenoy by virtue of bein_, -a’lO' ’odlc 1 Ins¬ pector or Chief of tin. iitdicnl S-rvic-s of t.o -ohnsicht? ... I h'.iJ th. s (residency in .1 c-.pre t> -r .xmy ft.dicil Inspector and * 1; Scientific S int-, rosined 'a ent'blinha-nt of the .my until tlic -nd “• t vu intended t unort i din cht Scientific Sen to -• r, -■* ,-osult of tht h-ypem.. s ci t*.e ir which cim. bout s s jcdily it s n*ol. tc carry th-.t out. V v. continued to be Jrusidou^ager 7 August 19.C*, didr 1 you? 13 "ob-\.—Jr-i?-ii-Oross Ccvrt t Tbo S-a to vs not celled sir.co tl;e ;/2'x 19ii2. Q- 7hr>t * h -“ t I =s*ced you. I asked you if it isn't - fact that J-OU continued -.0 bo President of the Scientific Senate of hh_ ’.bdical Strvicos c: thi. .w hn s no h t -fte .• 7 August 19a.'. as it states in the Scrrico Regulation. ... ..c, t.ur- is sorfcthiu', KTonj. here In t.._ Service Regulation tr.o Senate of the cfcmrebt •..dical S~rvic» l: a2.r.-.ny included here. HcrOTCr, it was r ~V'-r establish^- but it ratal n.d t-e .. 'G report >ack in 19^3? A I cannot toll you that. Tho ro^rts offorod car* imr 1*., « • , • a B A lute the, after the loot*,. I that because 1 13 -’ob Ii7--ST-19-3-*oldt (FJC) Court I of this re son I nado an innovation in 19Ui that the -•aost inportent par*, sanely, the directors, should bo separately printed in the form of a little booklet, that they should bo given priority, because it took an oxtrencly long tin<* during the war to have these roports printed, because quito a niabor of copies were noodod, and it had lrondy bocono very difficult with regard to the printing facilities. THH rESSIDSbT: Tho Tribunal is about to rocoss. Tho witnoss, tho Defendant Handlosor, boing undor cross axnaimtion, will not bo allowed to cormunicnte with any person ur.‘ :.l his cross oxaaination i3 finished. Tho Tribunal >111 bo in rocoss• (A rocoss was taken.) 13 F cb U7-A-JF-20-l-~itzgortld (?JC) Court I 7HS MBSK&L: Tho "ribrnal is again ir. session. Q General, do you want the Tribunal to beliovo that no onj on your staff checked into tho qualifications of Dr. &ing as a typhus ex¬ pert before it was approval that ho deliver this lecture at tho mooting of the consulting physicians in Ucy, 19 h 3 ? A I cannot make any Judrpent on that question. Tho working staff, in gcnoral, probably thought that tiioy were tied to the suggestions of the '•fehrmicht Lrcnchos. Q In other words, they ebd-cated their Judgment to tho Waffen-6S that Dr. Ding ms a typhus export >nd that he had some words of inportnneo to oocuny tho time of such can as Schrdbor, Rose and Eyor? Is that right7 A If I personally rccoivod those suggestions, I would only hsvo raised on objoction if thoro voro any occasion to do so. Q Let 3» put a hypotbotic*■ 1 quostion to you. Doctor. Lot us sup- pos in April, 19k3, you wore porsonrlly arranging tho program for tho oooting of tho consulting p^ysici n s i n Ley 1?L3, -nd that you had des¬ ignated typhus and typhus vaccinos as ono of tho natters to bo diacussod -nd that the Yaffon-CS suggested tho nas» of Dr. Ding. You have nlroaly testified you had never ho-rd of Dr. Ding. I am asking you what you "ould have dono with rospect to including Dr. Ding on tho program to lecture on typhus under those conditions? •v I would have dono tho sa= thing I did with reference to other 3ugrc3tio::s by tho S3 or suggestion; by other tranches of tho Sehraacht when I diu not know all the r-ntleeen. I would have to rely upon their suggestion. This was not ay task, i did not havo time to investigate * he 0^9 of the individual suggested. 1 was only interested in gotting ■ loading people for these loctures to which I attached particular im¬ portance. I had to have enough confidence in the medical chief of tho •-v.rr.acht branches to know the;.- would put people at ny disposal who would vo the purpose well. That is all I can say. ‘ 1 7fouid ILRo to investigate your failure to read this report by 3016 13 ••b U7-A-JP-20-l-Fit*flB»ld (FJC) Court I Eln> , OB t ..... rr- that, tot .you -» net interaatad in the 9-' to Whu. vaccl* produced fro= T 3016 k 13 Feb U7-A-JP-21-l-OaTUgher (FJC) Court I A No, that i.3 not right. According to aj opinion ever since 1?U3 I received information about the vaccine situations, and I can say that so far as I an concerned, and so far as I had anything to do with the natter, the entire typhus cosplex W3s postponed. For the center of gravity and all the work was based on the delousing, That was a basical change which was of great importance. Q Now you recall having read Dings' report here in Humberg on egg yoke vaccine, and its effectiveness was really the c^re of the prob¬ lem he was dealing with, and ir. this report he compared the effective¬ ness of egg yo!» vaccines to the better known Corgi's vaccino, and I think also vaccine developed from rabbit lungs, Tou were not interested in that natter, is that right? A Certainly I was intorosted in these quostionc. 1 ronoabor that through various ways I tried to gain various information on tho typhus question, and among othors I road an articlo which appoared in tho pross which ’■-•as a long article on roasuros of ability of leadership at homo, which was contemplated in order to protect against typhus, and this articlo — this egg yoke question was also mentioned. Then discussions •.ore carried on with Ur. Eyer as to whether we should oxtond the difforont vaccine procedure, and, Vr. Eyor also dealt with tho question whether ve could not use rabbit lungs, o: Jog lungs in a nuch more productive nwnnor. Apart from that -r. Eyor increased his production in such a manner, which '■as groatly to sty satisfaction; that considering tho progross wo nado in tho program of dolousing, these questions, \*hich you have Just .nentionod, vorc not of such a primary interest as you tried to oxpross hero. Q General, I am not tryini to oxpros3 anything. I am asking you -out your interest ir. those matters. I suppose you know where Eyor rut his information and tho effoctivonoss of thsso dog lung and rabbit -•®* vaccinoa, don't you? Eo got that from Buchornrald, didn't ho? A I car. r.ot say, but I am sure that it was contained in literature, •M. 3017 IS 'Ob U 7-^-JP-2H-Gallagher (FJC) Jourt I Q *11 right. Shore did they tost the so dog lung and rabbit lung vaccines; ir. other wards, where did Syer get his info motion if he did not get it froa Bochersrald? 13 Fob U7-WP-21-2-3al^ JC ' Govt I X iou w. forgot «.t II-*- 9 * *° w m . - 1 - - “ f *“ *“• * ? »» hlelf aw. h..led <~U~. «•» * » * “» in. -. -n X only *« -t tb. —* * - ..;.*«- th. i—> ° f *• *«• aM —" ourda ' musing progra., and considering tho typ.ua action, a. it P-allod „ »«, tut -as tho socord half of X, « -uXd nut «od to rcao * tut, and «. actually proved thia. I - «■»» ««* *" ^olna, not only orfieidly alao paraonally, tut uo am no- .coins to thin*, in a r.troapaction, and at that tlno X .« «- 130 °‘' h0r -ay nroud, and X loohod at the thins. I- * vary different point of vWI , a, 1 . tho caao bora to-, tharofora, tho altuaUon i» different. q -ho -oo your hy cl uniat on the ataff o,. .hon you roXlodX X That tos Loctur-r 3r. Dlolcart. Q Tilll you spoil that? X F-I-C-K-A-R-Cf 3ickort. Q X,u did not anmor ay pravlou. location. .horo in lamany to your ^ did ho carry out any ro.oarch on tho oXrootl-onca. of Xus and r-.hhit Xus vaccines; In foot, on any vaccina, do you Ot * -oil, x only nc that tho *art Koch Xnatifoto horo that vaccine, the Bohrins ., ani pWhXy Uao Xnatituto far ^rinoataX therapy in Fradfnrt, and if you -ouXd he hind ancush to road the article nhlch waa autalttod by ny dafenao coed of e docent at.-eh ... a -t hy on. of tho ddcat _purts c. typhuo =» - - --cc,,, nanoly. ‘ M Otto of crardefurt, thin X - aura that you ..odd bo onli.*tanod about thia conplor Ration regarding dee and rahhita, and you idll t» cor wod about th= cubjoct. *» -a "itton in a papor M am could understand it, -icb -a c - — —• Sut " ■“" Bl •fOttWlcodgo Journal, ond I think it if wrlttan 111 3 ' C -' * ‘ ra * ^ 1 t- -nd edict 3 *°“‘ »• • it ” tton - * 55 Mt * 3019 13 Fob li7-*-J?-21-2-Gnllagfrar (FJC) Court I subjectively rritton report, and it is not a report made fey e general nodical specialist of Frrnkfurt, but cede bj* an expert, and 1 think this report would snorer all your questions. Q. Gehelsrat Otto, as I rdfcall it, was attached to the iUnistry of Interior, is that right? A. Ko, this Ceheir-rat Otto was always the president, or at least for -any years, of the Institute for firrerioental Therapy in Frankfurt. Q. And did you rely on his advice on this typhus question? % A. He was sy adviser, and it was his task to do that. He had so much knowledge and ability that I could roly on hin in the sane way I could rely previously on Schreiber. 3039 i 13 Fob l*7-A-JP-22-l-Eayx»s (FJC) Court I Q That do you mean, "roly previously on Schroibor?" JL I roar, that on the basis of Schreiber's knowledge and work and his efforts, I could roly upon ovoryt:*ing ho suggested or whatovor ho gave ao for :uy information. Considering the extent of ny work, I vns not in o position at oil to road everything aysolf, and that cort'inly rus not ny task. I bad tfreso tilings reported to rsc by ay department chiefs, and I then had to draw ay own conclusions and sometimes asked questions if I thought it was nocoss'.ry. x 4 Tioll, I understand that, Qonoral, but the way you phraaod your -.naror, it night lead sor-ebody to oli.vo that you quit relying on Schroibor and strrtod rolling on Otto, and that is not tho case, is it? Schroibor was working with you up until tho ond of tho war, wasn't ho? A f.s, but Schr^ib>jr did not ect as sy ircodiato advisor in ay aic.'nity until tha und of tho war. Schroibor was with =»a in tho army at the front until l?!i2. Ko was at tho liodical Inspectorate until 1?1*3, and t].on ho wont to tho Acadoc^, shore ho hoadod a scientific group, nd of course ho reroved himself froa ao to : certain oxtont. I had, of course, an opportunity to collaborate with him, but he was not my isncdi .to collabor tor rnyaero. Q -cs it not tho piirpcse of tr.oso mootings of coneulting physi¬ cians to establish a besis for th issuance of cod‘c 1 directives? A les. 3 j ji* 1, I understood that you n.vor were r r.-r.ber of tho Roich Bose arch council; is that right? A Yus, that is right, 3 "id you aver attccpt to become a nesbar? A 1 spoke to ?iald karshal Keitel about that whan tho Roich Re¬ search Council was created. I asked hie whether it 'ould not be right th. uohraacht was represented there. Ho at that tins was of tho sane oainion and made that application. Ho repeated it at a later date, tut th. application r~-3 ra^oct-d. Th reason was given th th- individual ox i xj rt departments were all covered by experts, that Field Marshal Keitel 3020 13 ?ob U7-A-Jf-22-2-H^T..a (FJC) Court I -a a noabor of tbo Prosidial Council, and that, in addition, tho President reserved tho right "honour any basic question gang .up trhich particularly concerned ailitary awdiciw to call upon tho $S Hd'jn~cht Hylicnl Sorrico in such a case and uso his advic:. That, fcoir.ver, never happon-.d. q OoBoral, I think that is a voxy clear picture of ho* thJso mem¬ bers of the .Reich Research Council operated. They vare representatives X of tho other medical services, T.-crun'i they? A I person* lly? q -Tho noabors of tho Reich Reeo rch Council wore appointod to the Reich Research Council in a sort of representative capacity for socw other nodical agencies, such -s tho Airy Lodical lnsp.ctor-.to, weren't they? A There was no representativo. The An*r Hedioal Sorrico had no representative on tho Rich Rose rch Council. Q ffho res Schroiber? . A Schreibor ms a nodical officer who had tho export doprrtnont — I should not o-ll it a dopartrwntj he was a plenipotentiary for tho . combatting of opid«ics. That was o task which had nothing to do rfith his position as nodic-1 officer. In this position he bad no relation to do whatsoever and was not dopondjnt upon bj or the trsy. Q Toll, now, Gonoral, do you want to go back, then and chango that unfortunate werd that you used oeraent aco when you said you xrgod your appointment of th- Prosidi-l Council of tho Reich Research Council on th. ground that you -.rould then b. tho representative of the “ohrsacht? Isn't that rrhat you said? A Xcs. Schruifcor was not a repr-santativo of the -ohrmacht. Schroibor entered the Council as an expert on the very spaci'l field of hygiene. I certainly did not fit into any position as a plenipo¬ tentiary or in n expert department. I ~b only interested in seeing to it th t if s or. a thing like that ras created that the Iodic?! Service 1 ould bo represent _d? 3021 13 Fob l7-k-22-y^T-^m (?«) Court I A ^ o 4A ban w~ Mi f ^presentation, « « <£& > h ? Ciso. Q AKlpu want the Corn* to believe Schroibcr worked in the Roich Roso-.rch Council with his loft hand and in the -my Nodical Inspectorate uith his right hand and that th. ono did not know what tho othor was doingi is that right? ^ A I would not like to load you to believe tint. The first part is a fact. Whatever happened in too second part, nanaly, >tho knowledge of tlio right or tho loft hand — a nan cannot cut fciasolf into two ports, but sene personalities oan koop thoso two things apart quite ruU. ? or Schroiber this no doubt noant n recognition of his efforts 0 38 rn export, being incorporated into tho* Roich Research Council ns a roprosontr.tivo for tho coobatting of opidor.ics. Ho emphasized that, r.d h. folt Masolf rather elovatod tl«rough his now position. q koll, now, wasn't Schroibcr, ao a natter of fact, tho roprosen- tativo for tho Amy U*licrl Inspoctorato on too *eich Keso-rch Council? A No. q Did Cchreibor not report to you concerning his activitios ao a Q«:.;bor of the Roich Rosoarch Council? A 2 to. Q How did it cooj about that Schroib-r was appointed to inborn ship on the Roich Re search Council? Did you rooonoond hla? A No. Schroibor one day cane to sae, very nuch ploasod with hie- solf, and ho told a; that ho had received o request to tako over this position. Bo asked whether he would have to infont his chi..- first, sfld in reply I told hia that I authorized him tc accept this position in tho Roich Research Council -nd that, if n.cossary, 1 vould holp him in his n.:dical sphere if it should cocaa about that he could not quite - nasu his work. *tet is what happened. Q Didn't you exploit his work In the Reich Research Council which ho p-rfonwd them? hasn't he really doing tho s=» work in tho Raich Ro- 3- arch Council that h. was doing -s -n officer La the Artsy liodioal xn- -3022- sp.ctoratc? 13 ?eb l» 7 -A-J« 2 -<*-fiayne 8 (FJC) Court I A I received no insist whatsoever into his assisrxants or hia tasks during the tire that Schreibor was in the Raich Research Council. Q Is it not a fact that the kray Medical Inspectorate or some other appropriate arny nodical agency represented officer associated with the a ray for aeobershlp in the Reich Research Council as their representative? k I don't know that. 3 Did you or any agancy subordinate to you ever reco'.ve reports on scientific research froc the Reich Resoarch Council? A According to ay fmoeiladge, no. Q How rere the results achieved by the Reich Research Council applied in a practical nanner in the nodical field if you did not re- eeive any reports? A I don't know whether Schrcibcr had an;* possibility or used ary possibility of corounicsting directly with the hygienist and thoro- by recoived soce rotor LI, or whether ho used the natoriol which ho recoived as cor.* ar.der of tho scientific ~oup, I cannot say. At any rate, no authority, no assigmonts, cz.ec fron no officially. } .ell, do you want this Tribunal to believe th>.t the Reich Re¬ search Council insofar os it investigated nodical and scientific preto- e less was working in sane sort of a vacuuc and that tho results they' achieved did not cone to anybody'3 attention? After all, thoy wore not of any use to tho Reich Research Council itself. A Well, 1 don't know how fer tho Reich Resoarch Council pro¬ gressed with its intended work. There were aany institutions which were thrown up, but you never heard anything further from then. I can only say that I personally received nothing; nothing caoe through wy hands which iapressed c" in any -y, nd I an referring to any portio- ui-r point or files regarding toe nodical research which was sent by the Reich Research Council to ne. I don't know whether the Council had or any othor such channel through a special organisation or a newspaper 3023 13 Feb U7-A-Jr-22-l«?ayr.e* (F*3§) Court I •Mob this agency could publish Its roty but I don't render anything like that. 3023 A 15 ?o- -5 7 .-FJC -23 -l-!&i;nor3 tc- i r. Co*irt !Jc. 1 I -*cii;v, then ths Schroibor liia't rpond nucb tlno on his work with tho Hitch E«so*r«h Council, sinco thoy didn't pr^luco anythin^ thct you knew anythin abcut? Schroibor was very industrious. Vhothor any rosults woro nohloved, I cannot say, If thoy .ust have re for rod to axyorionces which he nrotiously rnthorol in tho at. y llodicol Sorvlco, or sccr» sun^orizinr, iafometien about uilltary afti civilian er.yorioncos. At tho o-raont I cannot rocolloct any specific ca-o. A * Nc», wasn't Schroi'or, as e practical riattor, subordinated to you in all his official activltos, incladin. rhatovor ho did within tho fra-owerk of tho notch RosorxeL C xjrxll? For Mr acti~it" ir. the noich Rosoarch Crur.cll, as I roroatodly doclarod hero, Schroi' >r was crrviotoly indoyorvlar.t of no and tho Hohrracht. ' Su^rcso you loci iou that Cutroit would be ::oro usoful tc tho Any on tho Rolch Research C'a:ncil than Schroibor; couldn't you have subatitutol >:tnolt for Cchroilor? A 111 . ■ o How lid Schroibor divido hit ti-u, with rosvoot to Mr. work on tho Bolch Rooiarch Z uncil and as an offlcor in tho Ary liolieal Ins; octorato? I cannot ray that. Schroibor was no Ion .or In tho Ar:y Modi cal In- i.ootorato, whoa ho oatoroi tho Rolch Rosoorcl; Council, and how ho divide! hlo ti n a.- a quosti.-n that ho had to docldo with hlo caranlor, who woo hlo Oi~ori *r. r . Cunoral, I want to h-nl you Doca-ar.t Vi. JJO-1-590; ay bo vo err. riot a littlo ’ it '-•jttor Hoc about what tho so follows it the r.olch r.oso-rch C u-.cil frr.. tho any — hew thoy woro appointed and who thoy woro ro.rosonti&yt :a. ::c HAHST: I Cffor this as lYesocution Uhl' it Ho. -550, for ldontifi- Wlcn. (c^ntisuin ) Conoral, rill ye-., road aloud thio lottor fra. Frern to “--rit: , da to'. 9 Soytar.bor 19-527 ”'25. "Cn 20 Au ust 19-52, I ortnod 52 -ontlonon thr u.Jh Azny OrInar.co zn of thj Roich ?.03oarch C-mncil. in tho field of aranont. ":o'c. the further any 'ranchos, I havo tc yrcyoso: 302 * 13 Feb li7-A-PJC-23-2-Sa|»o«»ieia Court I • d) presiding Council. Jiinsfi Sessgtax^ of Slain Cpoli and Processor Brandt are ner.bers of the presiding council, it seems to follow to call the Chief of *he Kedical Service of the Anny-Ger.eral- Oborstabsarat Prof. Dr. Bandlooor - also into the presiding council, in compliance with the decreo of the Fuehrer concerning the lodicnl and Health Service, dated 28 July 19U2 (Reich - Law - Publication07/h2). "(2) Reich Research Council. It ssc-as to me to be necessary to adopt the natter 'killtor/ l^dicino' after (e) Luftraffe’es a special fiold of research for tho consulting board of aanagora. "I requost to call Oborstarzt Dr. Schreibor, Chief of dop rtnent *th tho Amy !M!«1 Xnspoctorat., e. . m»bor of u» Roooorch Cornell in the field of :ilit r/ Modicino. "I assure that if necessity should nriso, individu.il experts in social fiolde, for instance, veterinary service, protection against opidanics w* poison gas, nutritional chemistry, Textiles could be assigned to tho Reich Research Council without giving a nominal quota¬ tion at tho pros-nt. "(3) Consulting board of manf-fora. I roquost to ©all Profasoor Dr. Loos fron tho Toctaieol ColloEO *» Eorlin, ,» an *pert for tho Amy Into tho consul tine boon! of aonagors. If tho consulting board of Pro¬ fessor Loos should door It nscosscr/ to how, an Amy Offioor osslsnod, I shill note suggestions." Signed "Front.” q Did you confer with Frcre about the nppointaont of those aim to the Roich Rosoarcli Council? A In sy opinion, discussions of that question -.rent through Xoitol, ti*n to tho Chief of General lohmacht Office, Roinecko, who was exactly informed -bout that matter, -'hothor it was from there transferred to From, I cannot judjo. From had nothing to do with no as Chief of Tohroccfat ilodicnl Services. He only had something to do with no in ny ^ capacity as Axay medical Inspectorate. The Chief of the ^ohrmcht ilodi- cal Sorvicos ns tied to tho OKS, which was. tiad to the higher agency. I have said before that 1 havo discussed this question with Keitel and 13 Fob L7-A-?j >23-3- Kuprerst cic Court I u it » reject, x =--J= »««* «* W. »■ ■«« thot orls i M t»d froa fctt* or 3oi»,^a. K— ■*“ « lay I say soeothing olso? In addition. 3025 a 13 Feb li7-d-S2E-23->Suppar»tein (FJC) Court I it «y, hom, .t to top. "0,-ier A—-t * 13 a* tot 1. of delin': vith it. q wm, Ganorol, sonant to Court to boliova tot toytppolntod to» subordinate. or you to to Role* Eoaoaroh mi«M* — la* you about It or atone you your V.em In to *»ttor? 1 -ath .0- ■aubardlnato." you arobtbly naan Sohroibor, don't you? It says hora, -bout Schra!,ar, tot to r. .ur^tod a. nonbor for the fiold of BilitJry aodicln-. Q Very roll, do you ton to .V rt MM.X, «• " roprosontod or. the Roich Boscoroh Co well? K Military Uodlcliw wsa not rjjrtaontcd .-t all.- 1-tar. , 0 '™ coroly rooponalblo for the spcciM Mi of co-bat of cpiuomics. q X>b asking you again, did r.<« or Xoitol or Roinocko or any one of thorn Mk you your opinion bafor. Sohroibor on. rooounor.dod for appoint- oont to the Roich Rosoareh lo’acil7 A I cannot wy that. now. Tint ra la. Suptobor 1«. H 1. roaUy improbably tot a nodical offioor la, ny ofrioo vould havo boon disposed of -.rithout ny knowHdgo. q I ahouli thin* » too. Kchroibor b;co=a a nanbar af tr.a Reich Research Council? A Ihj ohango of the Reich Research Council taok pl'co about tho end of 1?U2, but I third: 1 heard h,;v that in 1?U3, thj Reich Research Council reactivated itself in 1SU3 ir. nnr fona but I'n not quito sure whathar that's correct. 3027 13 Fob U7-FjC-2!->I>s*-r Court I 5 0 moral, you she on «*SlU -0=0>7 on sooa points and conpl.-to l,o-= of nanory on others. K>r you insist =t groat long* that Sohroibor m not appointed to the cl(> Hcsosrck Council on tho b-sis of this lottor -.-hid, I have Just out before you. lot you cannot toll no -•bon M bco-sue s nanbor of tho «oich Research Council. i I csnnot 21.0 you tho enact dotes. 1 -.ss'soo it ms in the year 1*3. I only tar that on. day duo h_ nos in Berlin ho c-no to v roes end told no that ho received thnt request. 1 cs^uno that ny ChioT of Stiff, ufco rill appear hoi. os . '•» * «« sphoro of nork to do, could toll you . little nor. -bout this .Ubjoot .-.id probably glvo you non. exact dotes. I csnnot do tint. 5 And this letter does not indies to to you that tho tray had conploto control cor the ro.-DV.tion of its any officer, in tin Solch .Toaoorch Council? A In th. first letter it says — fro. the further ronark "bronchos" I .eve to on,™,. .... It say. I he. to .... I banco that .one request x ., „de - that soswbody redo a request; than there is a nan rationed a, coning free a technical high school. I can only iuaglna that thoro . , Mrt of a request and'that this res tho reply rith roforonco to the 80 officers that aro nentionod boro. a Lot us pcss on, Oonoral. lour attorney asked you vhethor or net you over gained any infection concerning tho fnoosing uxporiiaonts carried cut by tarcknr, Kolxloohnor rnd dink,. 6. yea deny that you over rocoivod SowulodiN on that erttar? A I snid no. q An a result of th- Hasten, Crnfiign w»H. you very nuoh inter- isUd in "Cold* ?robL-=3? A *os. q isn't that vhy you sent array offioors to the luftraffa Confarenco in October 15-2? A Of course tho interest in cold problna ™ of an inportant nature. I do not knee =ho assignee th». Fro. Hay until th. and of October 3025 13 Feb UT-A-EBS-Zii-Z-Icsscr (?JC) Court I I was with 'aadquartors ir. tfco Ukraine and I balijVu that the chief probably telephoned = , other or how many people re should send, and be nay have nado sono proposal, ar.d I think I rouid have told hia on that occasion B Yos, I an in fifil ncrocacnt. Send somebody there.” It ia quite a aattor of coixso that wo send soma of the peopl- who knew son.thing shout cold because thoy wore intuxvabed in it. Q moII, having sent then, you then iandlatoly lost intorort in the problem, 1 suppose? X A !.'o, I did not lose interest. At some period of tioo somebody probably reported to no whether sonething particular had happonod or rrhethor there woro any particular results or not, "h*t could be oxploltod by us. But at that tieo it was not .Mentioned that anything in partic¬ ular had occurred, nor was it said that any particular revolutionary results were achieved. At any rate, - cannot recollect anything like .. t to have happonod. I should merely like to point out thet my inter¬ ests in cold problems, that is theso sphere problems, that is tha co- callod earth-bound cold, that is, .oraal height or as it referred to soldiers in mountain troops. That was something that was discusnod with us during various mootings, at first during 19U2, something that wan discussed to a great extent and vory exact directives wore contained in these reports of theso meetings. You will find them in 19l*2 #nd you vi 11 find then in 19U3. Haturolly wo wore interested in oold problem and it is quite a matter of course that whor.over we v;oro invited by the Luftwaffe '. :t -..-a would send our experts there and this is something that is one everywhere, not only in t Aray and in the fiold of medicine, ’ut lr, technical fiolds as well. 3029 13 Fab U7-*-J?-2li-la-I«sssr (FJC) Court I Q sell, I thought that ras probably correct, -cnoral; r.o'.i I want to put it to you that Kolzoefaner had cade a very recarkablo dis¬ covery ar.4 one which - ar sum ca^-e to your attention. Holzloehner and Rascher had round out that this passive warm bath was an extrecely effcc- tvo vray of reviving persons fror. shook duo to long exposure to cold, a treatment which had been first discovered by a Russian in the 19th century but had beer, forgotten so:.choc. Hasn't this a natter r«*rk- cble enough so that Schreiber -ho was at this cseting, oY one of the -any other ore;’ doctors rfco veje dorm there, .rould perhaps call to your attention, after tho extru io cold you lad suffered in Russia the previous rintor? A 1 said already beforo that at all tiaaiwo voro interested In ' cold problaas and as you say, very correctly cainly because of this torriblo Trintor of 19U1 and 19U2, We already Ir.or boforo that and V.aro ora regulations up to the tn*r and porhaps during tho first war, no.nely that people '•••ho wore froaon 3hould not bo renraraod vory quickly, Evon beforo that vo included in our regulations that or.o should concentrate on ltr.fanaing onri cortain fores of rcr/arcing voro doacribod. If ve arrcy people Mho Umw frontal territory and Russia, WO not so impressed »y this irarn bath, as you nontionod it, as you say think v;o wo, it is probably for tho reason that the ontiro Eastern Front Just had no hot baths at thoir disposal and that plays quite s big role regarding tho inprossio:. :ny nr* invention cay hovo taado on us. Q -oil, rxrr, jo rural, lot aa put it to you this ray. *>id you r.a’:o any changes ir. tho basic dir ;tive3 concerning the manning aftor stuck fron exposure to cold afte- this Uiftrraffe Conferonco or aftor tho cor.foror.ee in Docor.ber 19L27 A If one would look through the reports of tho neotings ar.d the ir stlvoa it is quito possible that saa place, 2 can't tell you exactly r although I roed th± , saws thing is a-id a * -ara or :»t baths in regard to freezing- You yourself brought to our knowledge, through = doc-rvar.t, that in Docccbar 19U2 Bolxloeteor spoke about his rewarding questions during a coating. -3030- 13 Fab l~-L- j: -2Ji-2a-Lossor (FJC) Court I h' held* That was reported to 300 or U00 goct l o a ar. who transferred that information to the front end I -a sure that later or. new directives contained th.- weir: bath too. i I an auro it did, too. General, That is tho roason I nskod you bocausa I t^LrJc that thera is no doubt that groat importance was attached to the results of this oxperirint ir. ^acheu b7 Raschor, Holz- loohnor r-nd Pinto. I no;.* want to ask if you didn't actually hear Holalooh- nor sneak In Ooconbar 19h2 Qt th masting or consulting physicians at tho Military Lo Heal Acedesy? A I cannot recollect that and must say once noro that is 3or.o- thing that ros dona within tlw various expert branches. I an euro you will 80 ^ that those expert brenc’.os doalt with thoeo suggestions th*n- solvos. e < ..'oil, thon, to . it it to you, Gonoral, this soooch by Hole looh¬ nor is roportod in our Dociront Jr 722 , Prosecution exhibit U35* and it goes or. you taro a vary short synopsis hero of his raport but ha does rivo clinical observation in cases of death* resulting fron cold and I find that you nado sooo consents at this cold aossion on page 51 of tho ori ,inal Report. It roads: •liandlosor stresses th- extraordinary inportanco of education -'Iso in combatting cold offsets and 'ppccls to all nodical officers, in their capacity as loaders of th. health •service, to sao it that through over repeated explanations each individual is taught to observe tho nocossary proeaution&ry measuR^s." A Lay I ask you i thorp it is stated that i3 in refor-nco to tho lecture by Holzloohnor? It soema to ba within tho framework of tho cold problem. Q Gonoral, I rill put tho Goman tc you so that you can soo for -ourself. General, let us rc-d th. little suscary of the speech by Holzloohncr because the Tribunal doas not have this docunoni before it. -t reads: "Stebserst Professor Holslcahnar: "Prevention 'nd Treatment of Freezing. ' 3031 13 Fob I.7-»--J?-2li“2c-lcs3or (FJC) Court I In case of frooains in vntor of a tonocraturo be lor- 150 bio lo gical, countcr-aca auroa aro practically in affective, whothor in the caso of huaan boinga or -.ninela. H«an being* aucctnb to reflectory rigidity. 13 ?cb h7-A-JF-2i*-3a-Lo8sor (FJC) Court I increase or blood sugar, and acidosis, at an oarlior stago and to a groafcor extent than animals. At a rectal toeporaturo of bo low 30° undor such conditions of distress at sea auricular flutter regularly sots in; at under 26 ° hoart-failuro froquontly occurs in human boings. (Oroz^-oxjrtion dua to unequal distribution of blood, incrcasad rosistanco rnd increased viscosity). Troatoant with drugs is scnsoloas and^as r.o effect, -n tho ca30 of hisaar.-baings bast results are also achiovod with hot baths. Tho foam-suit w s developed as a prophylaxis sgninst freezing in water bolow 15°." I'cr:, General after th-.t little axamarj of tho talk by Holzloohnor thjro tjoxxj several other lectures on freezing problems rnd then at tho end .to have the gentleman »ho wide sor. coszaonts on thoso locturoa, wo find "rrong them Srocor, Ifr. Hippko, the am who comissionod thoso ax- porinente, and Jarisch and 3uochnor. Her .: I want to ask you if this docu- rent rofroshes your rocolloction ao that you can toll us whether or not you hoed this report by Holzloohnor. 3032 13 'ob U7-^-?jC-25-l-iicoh2n Court I A -os, after reading what I have in my hand, now it is cuito possible that I listened to this locturo. At tho saae tiro, it is a proof that I hivo not as ^jod memory as you assured, because I already had this Docieont in ny hands once before hero in Ihirnberg; you onco govo it to ca and I forgot about it. Q "or., did Holzloohnor dcscribo clinical ob3arvtions in^h.*t death resulting from cold hinan beings in thi3 locturo which you hoard? A I c.-nnot toll you that. x Q Does it not say so in your own report hor ? A It says hero that Holzloe’mcr bolongod to tho Luftvaffo and as far os I •..-as inforrod lat r, Holzloohnor had gainod large experiences fron his acrvico at t!» Atlantic Coast. I an suro that iras oo no thing that •.a ftontlonod during his lecture. Ho had on oaorgcncy sea station nonr tho Atlantic Coast and near that thoro ms a hospital whore ho tro"tud those frozon pcoplo who had boon rescued fron tho soa. Thoro was no 03080 to suspect anything special bohind this. Q . .ns it apparent to you that ha carriod out oxporiraonts on human beings? A Ko. Q ^oll. General, kj hnvo hoard soew testimony horo about tho talk Holzlo-hnor g-.vo In -'umberg t to months before this and as 1 rocall, thoro was acre indignation in this mooting in October, 19U2, bccau3o all thoso gentlccen nolizcd what had happened; aro you tolling na that no rumor of this soaped up fros Uumbarg to Berlin in two months, so whon tho 3 ar t o nan gave the sane talk, you gcntlaaon wore in coaplato ignorance about tho fact that those axp:riaonts had been carriod out on living hiraar. beings in a concentration escp? A How far any discussions or ary particular impressions were noted la "urr.berg, I cannot say. At any rate, I nover hoard anything about 13 ?cb l7--Sy-25-2-Moahan (?JC) Court I any discussions or any ckscline. I could irall iaagino that if I would hold ; lecture anynhoro and if afterward I gained the inprossion that tfcora was sor.,- kind of unclarification, or sone one night call too • nuch attention, -.nd if Wo aonths Tatar, I was holding the soao lecture -.c another placo, I would naturally chango ay locturo and I would drat* ay conclusions fron what I had loomed previously. I an sure that this vail night have boon the casa horo. At any reto after reading this oxcorpt, if a fov pages aro aissing horo and if scoobody d^os not look t tho pagOB oxcctly, ho oust assure that (bo nan noted dorm horo as Handloaor spoke imodiatoly after tho locturo of Holzloohnor. X boliovo that tho roport of the rooting itsolf lill show you that botr:o..n tho lecture of Holzloohnor and tho discussion, there wore c for othor locturcs and you -ill havo to adnit that considering tho fact th -1 wo wore npprooch- In-i t. inter again, because this rooting took plac; in Docoabcr 1?U2, my ruaarka did not r .for so nuch to Profossor Holzloohnor's locturo, but it wm corely a r joinder that wo it nfced to do everything and in that way .*nr.te3h 13 ?ob ii7— jC-2>-3—-chan Court I Q I supposo tho Tribunal wishes to adjourn at this point, i night say it is not tho dosire of the Prosecution to hanper oithor tho Defendant Handlosor or Dr. lijlto, his counsol, in th- continued prepar¬ ation of their cos-. In view of tho feet that ro ara nor; .adjournin': .'or ‘ period of four days, I would bo rilling to porait Dr. Nolto to confer with his client, if Dr. *^olto will st to for the record th l ho rill in no aonnor, shape or forr. discuss with his client tho setters about rhich .. has rlr.sdy boon interrogat-d, or ir. ay '~V co eh hie on sub Joe.: which cou up. I don't near. b - that to bar hin fron discuss¬ ing • ny of the subject, which I rd.ll interrogate hin about, that is typhus or -nything lik. that, but if ho wants to iicouss with Dr. Bandlosor tho question of aor.e witnesses, further affidavits or matters of that charac¬ ter, 1 i.ill b. lliir..; to lot him do it on tho basis of th. understanding that ho will not ir. any r-y influcnco the vritnoss. V.'Z rRJS2)2:.7: The Tribunal inquires of counsel "or D-fondant Kandloocr whether he doces it important ao consult with his client during those d ,*s of recess, th.- Tribtr.nl stating tint if he does fool th* th-t is important, tho Tribunal *111 consent relying upon Dr. holto ts confom with thoso principlos of profession-1 ethics to rhich ho should confirm rr.djr the circa st t.c.3. DP.. :~ZL7Z: Yx. President, 1 Monk *-r. dcH'noy very kindly for hie suggestion "nd I thank you for the confidence r hich you place 13 -’eb L7-A-FJC-2$-j ; fooh an Court I ip. to and I cm assure you that I shall caaply with the professional ethics of our profession and I shall only ipcak to ny client about questions, which have nothing to do with the complex of questions that r-ro the subject of cross-oxaainetion. TKZ FltSSIDEIfT: The counsol for Defendant Hendlosor nay talk 'dth his witness during the rocoss. A The Tribunal nail bo in rocoss until 9:30 o'clock Tuosday morning. % (Tho Tribunal recessed at 1652 hours.) 16 Pob. U 7—; .IS—l-i-5lckley C-urt )Io* 1 Official Transcript of the .easi-lean !tllitary Tribunal in the nattar of the Unite! States of -verier., ar.ainst Xarl 5rundt, ot al, defendants, sittin. at Hardier*, Germany, on 13 February 191*7, 0930-1630, Justice Seals presiding. THE 1 iJSH.it Persons in the Court Boon will please find thoir seats. The Honorable, the Ju of Military Tribunal 1, Military Tribunal 1 is new in session. Oo! save the United States ol .jaerica and this honorable Tribunal. Ttiero will bo order in the Court. THE PHBSIIEHTi !x. Marshal* have you ascortainu ' tho dofondonts ore rll in C jurt? THE ’..RSH.-Lt May it please your Honors, aU defendants uro present ir. tho Court Roca. THE I.TESIDBHT* The Secretary Ooneral will note for tho record tho prosor.co of all the defendants in Court. Couno-il aay procoed with t^ cress uxaninaticn of tho witness. It;. Ho&JCI* it plenso tho Court. SIEGFRIED HeKDiJlS-l - #ino' ca>SS ~X. TIUTI.iS (Continued) -r . C tMTt q r^n-ral, lan't the utilicrtion ! .ct.rlal and personnel In tho field f «.««* r^-rch a c-v m |.rS*» * «H branches -f the ~>chr- 3 AMf i will report tho . sUon, on rol. Isn't tho utUinati n of vxtorlrl on' pert-mul in Ww field ,f sedical research a comma prolix of -11 br nch-s ef tho obrrwcht, requlrin a c?or’lnut..’ and planned Lr.y’ti.n? .. The -ywsti-n nlv^r o nfr nto d -so. *hot-~r it confronted y u r not, wasn't the utillsnti in t ik. ii-li cf ’Icul research a c-wa-vn , r - f the ehraacht? was Istri'utcd in such a way as ms practicn .1 Institutions an n vr.ci.s; and the Constant r-quirs.- which they ha’ were settled automatically acearlln t 18 Feb. U7-i'/-i.TD-l-2-51dcloy Court 1’ th o dmaa* 3 , which I did not have in ny hands. a Get*rel, ycuOl recall that tbo ?u:hror Decree of July 19U2 vostc you with Jurisdiction ov^r prohla:.s oonceroin. the utilisation of raptorial and ; oraonnal* You rvswrd_-jr that? Yea, it was th. material and personal coot 'irationj and the roaec for thia «a that at a central v-ffico for reasons of economy tho stronrth of tho individual branches of tho .ahmaoht was t bo 'is tribute! accc^r in¬ to tho aizo *nd the roquirenonta of the individual branches. q Tioll, now, GvrurU, wo ur. -stand that; but wo are tryin' to rivo acno content to those encrai -rds "material" and "personnel"; and I'm askin- you if tho utilization of aatorinl and personnel ir. tho fiold of no !i cal risoarch wasn't a co ;an rc';l~r., roquirin c ordination, which foli wi« in y ur Jurisdiction und-r the oor« cf July 19U2. i. I car. nly say that in raotico — and tint is tho roost important this question did not yvjn oo=o up ir. sy-staff and within my field, of c -ap - tonoo. Kothirv- was over aul -ittod to no with ropard to tha istributlon of mtorial or pcraonnal where I woui l have had to make a decision because th.ro wore 'ifferont 'ifficultioo ir. this respect and that is tho neat lap j tone. q General, y u'll rnor: r that Ira', part of your spo« eh to the consul air. physicians nt tho sootla h,l! fra 30 !;ov,-r.bor to 3 Dooonbor 19) X Yoa. That was Ducus*nt fo-922, .rcsecution Exhibit 13 $. In that speech. 0 ti. r 1 , ycu said in p“-rt that "it is not a luostion >f narchin sej^r t.-l*- m. 1 'uattlin .7 tc other, Vat narchin- xurf br.ttlin: must bo -done in unison ft— tho Wimdn? in nil fields. ,.s result, aa cone, ms tho military eaotv, •Vhracht nodical service, and with it the chief of tie nodical turviers rt the Tfehrmcht; case into -oin . .Jet 'nly ir. n-tt rs of r-"somel and aatoid ••von as far as this is pcssi-lo in view of special Ctrl's and special task* which must be consider©:, but also with tto view to nsdical, scientific u u cation and raswtrrh, ur ,a4 ir §> • «■*♦• n.. .Hoal s-rvico mat toil .til be a urdfi-: i on: 15 Pal. h 7-.7D-1~3-Elakl ,y Court 2fc. 1 A 103. n Aren't y u sayin thro, G-ii^r-1, that the coordination of scien¬ tific research was ore f y ur jobs ns chief cf the no leal service cf the Tfehrcacht? Tos, itvr as infill tto fiidls where this was roruirod and noccss'.i 1 Oonorr.l, i' yiu have any interest in tho treat sont of wcun.’s can? by fcao cf v-.rieu3 ty ; «3? A Of ccurso I was interested# A tl hat research war V>n , to ycur !m wle Ige, on this o.uestior.? % A In the Tehrsacht vo --.1 t.ro Soparr.to They wore tho nili- tary fiol'. ibout the uso cf churdcrd warfare aronts ->n 1 th: ;nc 'lord fiol 1 ft * th. treat Kin t f injuries sustalrv'. boc.uso of such che-lcal events. ncoor !• in ly. thcro w^ro tiro separato r.. ulations. Thors w-.a ono regulation which referred to thj military usoj an’, t ro was ore r.-rulation v;hich roforro.'. to tho troatmnt. Those war,: tho arsy r .illations Nuubor 395 and a printo I rar-u- laticn Jhtior 396, That vis th) nodical ro ailati.n. Durln:: tho war it wan completely ropr- ’ucod on two or throe occasions. I hav. always shown a opeci interest in this service ro ulatdon# In connection with this tho noat ir\]'W •* sis was plaoi *r. tho quucticn of th- V.uminv churdcrd warfare aconts, naixd lost aaj an! as far as I can r • \ r th '‘irst crl! ‘ar, tills was a fi.>l 1 f spooial int -post, ret nly *.rith us tut als? in all ccnxntrios, q 7!oil.- di ’ you know of any as uxpurirwnts carriod out on hunan beings? (W Xos. •Vo hr : a la 1 crater;', an institute in tho sealery .hieh hs l nlwuy had th-! a3si rsxint and which vns .alsc ivon tho aosi. asont by mo to try finally to fin’, -a very practionbi) rofhod of tr atn.ntj as wo call (it, to fiti 1 a lacoutoai nation procoiirv $ nr. 1 this assi nix nt as voiy soalo':sly aarri A out. It finally rosultsl in tho fact that in th, courso of tho yonr 1?U3 wo fo y a know mything about the experi¬ ments of Bickenbach? % Aw Mo# Did you have an fiicer by ths n os -t "irth, V.-i-r-t-h, working jn gaa problems in the -odic.'-l inspectorate* ^ I cannot rcanber tho na^>- .irth at all. 2. Shy I thought y.u .v-r\» calling ..irth here trustify in your behalf? a. I hevo not hai called h-re. ■*. "no ncr-i is ..irth. a. Yus, ..irth. 1 r.ve r. t had -irth c«dlod hero. 4. Mid you d n't know hit:? a. Of course I know hit. I hav- fcn wn hire f r years. Ho was a socialist n tho ttlltaxy Medical acodony. 4. That io what I as trying to ,ct at. 18111 yuu toll us whnt ..irth was and wh ;t ha di- 't A. ulrth 5. a a student f 'Ivri and -irth was the successor if vunsch wh bed wrkod m chuidcal warfarv - into fer r.ny ytars and who hod written books which can bo found my bock st.ro .b-ut chondcal warfare a ency. .irth * a th_> heed t t - Fhartrx .logical Institute Do artriont in the kSlitory radical Acadtr-y in whoso Held he duhlt. a ten tr..r thir s with the s-rvicu rogulnti n *..c 396 which h s been ...entlon-d Nrf r". Be had -on as3i nod by tgr pred-cuss.r, Dr; u.ildmim, <■ lnpm-vo tfio doc-.:.train at ten drugs and durin, tho entire ti-c which I held ffico I have kept or. workin n this ud tl ntx > nt. .lully ir. y.ur pinion, Jirth would probably be infemod n all ra re;: xch ir. Gcr vy, wouldn't ha? a. I hr.ve n with all -eh in Qeraaqp but-1 said th. t he was head S tho Institute at Borlin and that h- was special consultant in tho field, that he was sp-cial consultant fr the ohr-..cht, or the .jay, ir. tho field f chordcal warfare agents. C.urt I io F-b U7-! -2-2- LJj * Gr?3S doll, h« v .s or ( tuj sb auth-rity -n g -s i>rcfclur_-, was ha n t'. I wculd r. t c_ll hi to- first auth rity but it rnthor is my pinion that tot. first auth rity v.uii bo his tuach.r, tho »-lI Jen. wn Frciosscr rluri. • O uh. 1 t is .irth's fir. t na y u Jen w? ... .v . I assao tot his first nr. o begins with " I think on ju3 ccasion I ruad «. •irta, but 1 au n t euro. A Did you icr. w if ..irth ov-r w-rk-d with Bickontich? X a. N-, I c um t toil y u th t. .lirth is too an wh- roc. .n id t; Xarl Brandt exp-riaonta for too decoctasiinaticn of w-tor poiacr .’ with 1 st, isn't ho? a. I havu road th ? a-ro fer tn- first tico in too d-cui-nt toich y:u havu pr-auntod n-ru. T u.t . .s in D .cuaoiit . 0-1 *t o-evti n jehibit Uh6, f.-r idonti- •ti.r.. X ■ win r. o-fcor th t cewsnt c ntoined too par irajfc which r. ;i as fill.Tsi thiru s-ri-s f ox K -rir.-nts w-r- c.irriod ut with too ■. .oat f too 1 st r too -vhixiatio* j 1 -at, in .cc. rcanco with au -s‘i n rv.do by 0 or xtt Dr. *irth at to- c.nfuroncu li Dsc^bur l U» vito .v-ich 0 so r Sr an t.» . . ut .n c ncontratir. ecu.;: in: -3, w.r-n't tooy 3-nural? *. I cannot ;iv- you in -i r. at all ib ut that. I do not ka w -jvtoin* v ut too sussi n, which is nastl :.t, :> t c-.n I toll y u too raaoctuj f:r it. o. r ^ it s- . j 'i x . lit lo strand to t no i tiio . flicors ii. tht «av:y .oiieal Ins.---ct.rato v . \ bo r-c nr«.r. In,. -xj-.riu;. nt® .*ii r - i-contration ca.i in_tos uni-so h- know that *h»t. ,-rat-tire was approve, by his su^ri’rs? 1 cr.rv, t Ju *„a if i. Irth asda this suggestion that such riuwnts bn carrl.xl H n o t/j -.n ttinu c -., p.rs ns. I d*»n't kn w •nythinT a.i..ut th-t. 4. I -us Juot asfcin. y u if j u uldn't fin- it str ^o that an C .st I 13 F~ kl-.L - 2-3 - JQ _ Grcaa *my fficor w old su^.-st r pcrttcivato in uxauriir.ts n co'ncantraticn ooap iiez'.tus aildss be knaw that bis an* orlor* had n bj-ct: - it. .. uldnt y u find it atran* if hu did that? irsfcsa r «irth c* int havu o u licv.d that I w. ulc agree to this because wo haae nsvor diacuaaad this qoosti n -t any tine. Q. Did yiu kn.w D_&i*n? ... I know D.hi-^n v,ry alijbtl. . Icinr. -ri>«r bin bucats* in ont» f ur . ujtin.8 bo gntw a very (P '• lecturo - it epidoaic Jaurvuico. I ean rwaxjbur that .-n the ccaei.n t - .-Mating which 1 attended whon 1 wwlc-;ajd all the pcoplo attuning. X oetad r.. £ then, " r- aro y u rldn ilf r.: Outaalt tcld me "That is sWoaarat D.hnon." I did n t hTa or- pobMoal c atcot with i . ». i car. nly rcoetdber hin .-caus- hu v/«. an oxfcullunt loetr . ab.ut the Jauntica and ah ut tho littlu inci-unt with :• xi.it. 4 a I recall y u tastifiot •- t y u kn i b^on'e ux. -riauhtc in 3 oha-.cncua-n r. c r.contrati r. ca=p inmates, is that c rivet -v. Xos. «. y.tt call . . Drealoa c nfoxvnco n Jaundice in 19bU? «. ..hun I ,-n-. U.u c.-nferutco in 19LU * at-trt, and th .t ia c.n- tsined in v penin* a.i roaa, thfc I had Iran r era >* haptctltls acioatlate, r_ .-rdluai *f w rking in U.u .uhrr.^ht r civilian cur.t^r, .Cfitin in l. fc in r. -r t ivo Uon tho ,. (J rtur.it y i oxchuivu th-ir -urluncws and, ab v u ili, t cent ra f.io cultures uhich tfcuy hnd i-c vv-r- , t c , 1J»«a t then, old y u .ttorii t;.vi .'oalva c nfur«nco? ... Xus. n’t y i .n.w .f tho c .rati n f Ha,<«r that tte rin,; «3 m included ftitrdt and DJaaen and' also I ta w that ,6; oddly batr-on Ha on and b h=on difficult! os existed, jhably a Is. in tho confcrunce oi the duinan S ci..ty f r Internal Ajdicim. (fc tuber 19U3 in Vienna, it wr.o n t the Military c nferorce. F^r this reason it waa -dtfc;ut cny '-ubt a 3uccoss n the part f Schrei «rao if r.e succeeded by -wans f this w rkin r up pr ceduro l nxaavu theso difficultly that axio tod. -3Cd^- 18 Fcbru.-ry-J4-OJG-3-I-- euitent cf th. nodical insp-ct.rrte or the -edicol inspect.r, (this wr.s Cutsc r tl.-.y went t; ;-y scientific .epartsent in -no a. lied inspectorate, without V * In? lirwctly inf-rrze: -1 cut it. Gutcult hiasulf has rupcatcdly powriwl 1 r . rind tc r.-j »n . large seal- r’rut the cpidesdc Jrundico. Cf ccurco, thrt ••a hio nrt.T -1 duty bocauao th- prc.Lea played c ;>art- h-»/ repc. - Xroa Drhaon 1 rust answer in the negc . D. you kr. w cf any Cxy-ri- 1-vino- with .iumdic*? - 3 •.•11, Cji-rrl, in vl* .f th- testimony cf Gotaeit th t jaunlico t.a v-iicd prcfclen cf orjor prcccrticns, and in fiarth-r vita-, of his toatiacry li Febnn. ry-ii-3J&-3-2-K arrem C.urt Ho. 1 it was n.t ' a-.ricua disease, her dc . 1 ex p l a i n the fact that nc experiment* *«ro carried cut cn fcarua beings t.c determine whether in fret you had isolat r. Jaundice vine? .. I can only explain this through the f.ct that r-scarch was still way and that .»t the Breslau Conference, v-ith the- utmost variety cf scientl 3 present, on*, cf the scientists still disputed with the ether if this was the cause at -U. Ion tell you further th: t 1 lid net even know anything a» u*. the f-.ot, tr. t I r-s never tol , that Gutzeit had carried out an experiment _n himself. I can explain the fact in the nay thr-t h'J n^t yet succeeded in fi the virus, There wcr. only assumptions and scet>of the scientists Relieved they had feu.-., it. H wtvtr, tho feet had not jut boon established, 1 Well, but General, aa 0 rly rs the jiiile ef 19A3 Gr*witx was stating that it vac neCersary t hotfe adzrl to can virus . -t f the importance of the pri-l— he;, is it thot n. experiments were carried c cn human beings? .. 1 cenn-t tell ycu anythin* r! -t it. Heftov.r, I believe th't Grndtx opinion was n-.t decisive for :e btco-s., without . ny doubt, he hod handled scce pro blue .j which Were net rlpo for discussion y.t, while we, in tho *..uhr- aecht, naintjinei the pcir.t ef vies that on a should be very careful in all th.Se cccuo. , General, ycu trv testified th*t ycu ctt-jiJei the O-etinfi of tho con¬ sulting physidnns t the Hit y, . . /. Yos. C Ycu have alsc te-tifi.J th/- yau h.ard the report by G/ehnnit in- Kir eh .r -t the Buetinc- I? th't ri t.t? .. I have su ted th't it c r. fc« snicei that I attir.iod this confer coco. r t I Xsai : u if yo" fc *>»■ r ,-rt t.; Celi-.-it -nd MacheT at. t} ia c.Alng? . .. i assus-- sc, y^-s. • • -11, -ie ycu r^ .ed.er whethe. ycu heard it? Did it aeko any ijaprerr :n you? .. i:_, I —-i—t re- ■ r that 't - I :u« »• *• i y»« *hfft 1 hr.vu net 16 ? cbruc rj'-ii-D JG->- 3 -Ktr re* C-urt Sc. 1 sh'-'n "JIT oped cl Interest In these roperta cr that they did not ackv cny _ci '1 inpreasion because, otherwise, 1 w»Ld bo able tc rcuoab-r then. Q . ell, v. 3 r,«t it =«de deer i.. this report that they had perfern-d a- perlacnts cr. concentration cjx inset cs? Ih =7 :pinion, ra f?r rs I ., it has beer, stated here that prison* era wh- had boon cenitsn-d to lie ml these »hc hod been perdenod were ccr.cer od. Q hell, General, yiu ea» these tcr.ai, these Polish wco-n mhc cane fc-ro testify, fell sr* to • tl ir icjs war- aifcllstad. Vill ycu tell the Tri’ „h\t yc«- third: cl iut sulfenctldo cxpe;-i~c:.ts ct rt-.vcnabNucck? Dc you think they »crc ril ri .ht? .. I c*.n only r-p»- t ' "in that in the lecture cert-inly the subject of ccncontrnticn ci»p prisoners w-.s n:t concerned. It tea net discussed boettuso enc cr th. ether -f the words wvoli her- roarinod ir. sy noncry. I m quite certain thet oq fcaaX t oners sees incus?.. I. 1 fcavo ae-.n the idish wocu s tto« subsequent result. However I cannot atrte x-ctly wh’.t u-s d:;i> to thoa mi the ocplnnr.ticn was net lvc ;• Or. Aboccador here. Hu has lvca* a dispwsis » if 1 «*« to tdl : vtnt I think r.b-ut these xporl^-nt. then I aurt -.sk ycu th-t 1 c r. postpone* *.i.;s ot t "jiTtnln^ »*« you hn.vo fmat su&oatei. - GonamI, =y zagliah tronr.Ir.ti n r--v!s »t..o • cr trv oa f iiu'-cti.nr *.’a :r.3 -jyono." I cna ... c or. u -.o by tint nn.o v-ndc =*c acontrati -a crnp" - •’e.acontraticn crop priss-nors" ssjpo ^oatl'-aod at '*- 11 . r von- HO 11. I think if tio bed pr v:d huro thee tkoro was -a sbjoction this Tory iacturo that y u a uli c croniontly he to boor, utsido tho r ~ • . that ti.-a. 2 n I put t ;• u thr.t at this ee:*, nootiiy ia liry 1943 t-s.ro vas hjocti a by Air dofpnd-r. ?. soj ta 3i.^*s rop.rt Ifpkus ox -oriisjuts aai a* — v- schraib-r wta c hair.au f tha -o.. sp'ko. Y u oay ;vu waro u.t tboro but . u -lea kava tostifiai cn 5Ma at-a. thr.t y;u hoard •. . . A X. I rad a t nly i -_ut it hao nlro-dy ropoetadl? boon atetoi :.oro -ad it ha* * 1 -' boon flo.n b> tho incus tf-loh naro prooontod hora,M;'-t this we* t\ caforonco - Ik dif-’.raat : -jcleli-'t cr j'a, *; ’ that tho individual epoelaLifft rr • a had iaSi-ilual sv.otia^a and tv- it r Li haro boon O'- ijilotol^ l«w»st plnco at tho . .. tine. i hero otetod u.*Sar at’: a verl u* ooaci as \jtj that I 1 *. r. t attend t‘a. c nforonoo f tho nioniot Cfrru vuaontk Bohralbor he* n' t told sb ab t s »3*a ' mtl . boro. Dobhnrdt'o loo- vo t L .Ilr.co la lar*o eullt.-i-. eftor I bed :lv-n thu zoning »;:©&oh s j fr-ftow rh f oargory. "too -.ctari 1 1c 1 h:\_ioai3t aixicialioto hoi: a onforonco by thaioolYor at U;or pleca. i c-.a l. royoat too ...to that 1 vaa n t jrosont. • 1 amoral, I e. a t -rocont 1 wru-»t iro i:. tho -blob "rial Utt 1 thirl: if anythin? ur._r al happen.,: : . than end :vct particularly if -nybidy waa ..illJ «1 1 • tiioro i thi hat :!:■ that I * uld ka~r ah .t i*. up boro twt i m: ovjr. ; u vj .uld, and 1 a: a~ ia. y u if it is.-'t a bit str-aa-o that '•'hon rp -rtaat Uhj ^ ro LJ ts u; in a -i-tin^ f an inatituti . f -4.1oh ycu \!lc-l :_.a wh r.tton’od. n -'oil. In t^jr rr^Tlo, r.s r result f the oriaonta r GolkarSt, no m s ileal lafltruoti -3 uoro Issui!, is that rioW i ' r~. - P. "oro a’: ut 10 iocturoc an£ . - rj- J.tr r* tho subfkJija-at lioeucsl no wuro auinrris. . - .rr: f V.._. poforrol t- tha results aohlorol by Gubhnnlt. 'Shat lfr•* tho aotual roar a f too lfuro.aoo c t at :..o .o ;lo a., ul. ku.v what tho rosuT varo with ros'r! t t - » ;o nil eh- o^oeinXlvts* That tine not elwn _ jtU a, ; Jti7o, but vary froquontl: in thor ->rtl>lx.3 tho *uo8tioa ru^int . that n lor&o nusber f .kysl class utsilo ths c-uutry wo o t bo Given ola* if/ t^at thj ioal.ra f “.:*-. :./iio 1 sorric- oa‘ tho c aaultihc jhyfliciaao v,7 o c natostly on! r.t all t -or *r i , t find r - lu'.l?:. t -11 tho oation still rccnlsrt 3?oa, ir. War t holy all t undo . * Ooooraly that liakos tdiat wo arc ab ut tho sa - tUa&< Oil tho . - :* ::olic-i i-.arsctr-to Iro-o isotrustl rx n, 1 -eo -f -a?or t- tho phy.-ici .. rkir-6 i- flail etnti-.- that in o-.-o coboo f oh ck luo t* n-olrnaoi I TO t c 11 ,* u eh ull tysa« tho -ntlcnt In tho r 11 --in. :>- ior or..l tho.- •Itli-.: tho iu-r f treat oat? Di th- irr.y ll-'ic-l Iax-oct-rate lamia t>.t Ida*. .« iaotpuoti no t r. t? L Toe. Flrot t all th&y ato t Insfer t»l eoo idly it in ala. c aforoaoo ft', o. :ibu1U.w phyoioinne. * i oako’ y u if t . oo I atpucti ,i8 c acoraiai, tho trunt: e:it f wual p lafluoacol -y tho talk z oobh-x-t an- yiwlvtf* , . . : n’t a-spo w thoj -or. c*';.-', .'ar t a r iiz —--r. th-;- chan o! r w-ron't th;y chanKoJ? .» : - • «41itlm t: tho .-rovi u» r r.sult was ala -llol—thoso po- -:lts .hich hal to-u achiorol by tho -Inrjcsi r. -305C- Jeb 47-1C-4-4-L>> ? 3or :cirt r&. i \ 'oil, prod roll what a: a: led to the instructions which you gave to field oiical officers on tnatlos infections or rounde? i To# instructions begin - '.ho following, ith a abort review. There it-.* about I, 2, , 4, 6-1/2 -la., hero about the osperiuoata which were ;orrl©l out ~J GeCharit ad then fron the nest lecture axe the results of If on* tides, -hen application, then the 11 deal result*, an. then it states .o followln. rules aro to a a-ie_ for the praxis. Thorofare what i.aa tool. oi hoxo not., tha itebo-* t..a; the lerolo^iont of a: inflaiaation oounoi A canal causes o:_ the. internal and ortomul cannot he rovontoi by tho xornal ad ox.oraal application of uulfcuad oa. Chon it statea about tho X .fla.-ati'a tho ic. ortar.t part cf tMi that also in this coso of vorninj, al to to iesuo'i to tho iurgoonn outsllo that tho ox orlaonto hal eh-fl'n that • .07 couli not aoioly *.o oni cn thoco Ifona-lloa but that they uould ro:alr. aintain thoir cur iccl troat* art. Th! a a o very ln-portent point at only In scco oasee they should a‘..‘ eul'm.a Mao. -3051- lc Feb-Vp-l-PinabUCfc OOurt ;■>. 1 . General, would your orfiSLr.lzr.tion, your staff. sbJco such nd*itionr :* -.ediol instructions without invest!,• tin precisoly 'fen*, had been done durln t.:e course of cx-.-.eriuontB upon ocich those now Ine!ructions wo.o i sod? _h. t's a proto;- important .roblc_, isn't itT e- That would not be the tosh of uy staff, but it would be tho task of the specialists, and tne reason for tnis conference and everything thct h - icon r.owly diaoOYcrol since l ?-3 was th-t sovornl dozen loading ecionti co. d read and that they cou d consul, about thoso instruct!cu which voro issued hore. Neither I nor uor-*liy peop-lo of zy rtuff participated dur'.y t-is conference, but tho procedure was thr. t on the very l.’.t day boforo thir opting w niabunied, h:o 12 or 1 different specialist groups wmouncod ti text if wflesv instruct! :uj. *nd i:. t..ia cr< c it w« *o be asked once niro if thero vut ony furta-r ^iscuosio.-i, and if not, then these inotructi'nn v. accopted. rhojr vero printed os quickly or r,o slowly ns this co Id bo dono, cA then tcoy were oent to the front. .. Veil tto, Gou.r , I take it th.*t these speclnliots group0 lnvcutl- Cutsd ;..c conditions of tho oxj- rlaonts which vme rooortod on with tyc t c-ro; ia ih..t rlgr.tT .. Tes. Unturraly pu will have considered in thi t r socct under whn -lie 1 foms; thr.t lo, in t-.is case br.ct.ri?lo,;ic-d forns or ourgie 1 forut . iio 03 -ri. — r.ta .. oon : -Tied out: •• is :o any, now the renelLr. wor. c-.i-vcd cm be aeon by the cose histories end ...o person who iuio c. rriod thot out will fxowm tho questions hero w..icn w v ro put to hia, bocauoo r.ftoj -11, c nuaber of physicirns nro V-* : lv.iys of the s u. opinion. 7~er. various questions were ut.r^d and the;’ v\.ro discussed and we also .. vo instructions with vrrious t..i.. o that were .ot added end >&oro pooplo -ere racing wh-.t procedure s~ mid be followod, nd tiu t, re r result of th .iacuasions wc saw a bi.; ndrantago. ... Sostocic was a -ouber of 12. rurjlc. 1 group, v sr.'t he? Ho >»o . .•inarilj concerned with this sulf nilfu-ide problem? .J 1 j." up v_re interested in tee culfo nnni do expcrinjnta ■— robi ... Veil, w-;o r.e a -e-ber of this group of specialists which inv roi - 3052 - 1£ r: Court 3c. i. ▼cry carefully these reports bocau they were goir£ to issuo nodical instructions based on those reports, and they wonted to ho sure that their . in-tructions wrv ri,^it end that the reports were correct: and now I idr- you v.a Hostock r. her of t..io specialist croup? — Toe. • .. l>o you reueuber jyocuaoat vy-Z^J, prosecution Exhibit 283, ''-ich ir af:id it it of Dr. Din,; telling about hio nee tin,, with Hrugovsky .iad Schroibe t the liltary S.odicol .icadooy at th-. ond of 19h2 on ,«b bun* odo.r.? -i. So. ... that is ,ms odo_v? x ... 3 t« edeco is n disc;jjo w.-.ic-; is caus.d by wounds and Injuries, vuor.ovor a curtain typo if rims, rh ir. this case they are bnctoria, aro intro dac od into the wound, rue word odo^-. can bo translated into C~r/.::-., vlu: certain swollin. , since this diaonso is c..- motorized by ; swoliirv, ca t tno lu—« tlu> by for^itl ir. of ,71* vhlc.i is caused by those bnotorl Then it is cr.llod ;pi burn or e ui*\. It it or.o of the ;>ost foarod cor>- •lic■ ttons which wo c find in th- field kftorir.Jurioo nml the mortality r .tc >i such eO >1 e Id terrlfyir»;ly -oi«£». rurtaerhcrc, this disoano is v.-r often ohuraetorlz.d by the fact that tho surgeon lo forcod, In order t- try to save the life of tho cfflictod person, 1 .e n s to c< rry out very lcr,:o upat-tims, or perhaps he ar.s to anputnto o lihb frou tho Joint of tho hi; of ihc nliouldor. ,. That will bo sufficient, I think. Gone ml, how, did you h'.vo a & edona oerun in Gumrcny? ... 7es. . Did it over cone to y ur attention th-1 soldiers treated with f,r.o -dc-a sena. died suddenly after app'-rent re cup. ration? — Tea. ..a far ae I know this enno froa tho fields of professor hil: If • ..y success was to be nchioved at all with this ,.i.b 6erun it 2nd t) bo i*.-n rc. -atedly in v.r; 1 r c do .s, and 8-nobody finally had the idea th: huso f- tclities V. ic- co-id ..ot -e properly oil inch ed.-h- >rha s be tr bech to tne ueaol co_.-oor.vuts which were contained in tco sonr.. -3C53- 16 rob-;.-6gS-5-3-gis$bac k : C -art ^3. 1. ... taia £ac odea.* w? ■ ts to~ic of me of :»ur conferences at the .ilitnry fcodicil .Lcr-dc-y, was it n't? Didn't you havo r report V cmoulti aysiclana on tala to-ic «t one of your laotia. 3? — ky predecessor directed tao fir3t confcronco during the :>rot unr. 5. t v. i.. 1940 . It vat hold by Dr. ifaldnr.nn after th» cr ipoi (l -n in Pol :.( a been completed and clren’y mo of the i-nin locturoo v s ,-iven about th , b roblo... Svcr since that ti ~ tao ijportcnco of this problen hno alwny bucr. discussed vita rc : r.rd to f ;.s odona. .. Veil, lot's (O back to t. is Sis.; affidavit, Socuacnt ! ? 0-2S7. Pr>- ecut 1 Zzaiblt 2*3. T3U have ioscribod this r s odora roblo Junt clout t..e 0 -.e way t-.t Sr. Sic, di-. It roods: "at tao o.-.i of 19 U 2 I too* •> rt *. a conference ir. tAc ..Hilary Doctors' ac ac.y in 3orlin. “Tao t pic of iscucs! a vr tao ftclity of . .0 bur:, soru. 0:1 wounded. vitondantB, J-aer-l Sv. Profeusor Scaroibor. SD ?rl .ndlor S..nor."l Professor jlru.yovoky, a A-'ic 1 officer w..o v s unknown to _o vao v a n our,:eon, aysolf an ooctlo le or it fifth Cer.tr Institution ! . Berlin for ?l,-tin, Epldo'.lcn. Mil■ n» w..... ; a a v, already .wntl-ned... ■ nd fcrarovsk; nvo reports of soldi .rs v. hid r.eoived . ;.s odc:r. uoru- in ..i h quantities, up to I 5 CO cubic continetere, and -ours ;.ften/. Jds, fter couple to recup. ration died miAdorl without any visible reason. «.ru. ovsky ourpeoted that the phonol content br u. .t cbout tao fated rooult of t.u oor.ooli • t'of the separate inject! In the presonco of t..w other .rontloaen, i!ru,ovcJ qr cou ended no to trkc pn*t i out:.cane ic. with paoaol in r. concentration ca p '.rod to doscribo the rosu? in detail, oir.ee neither I nor ::ru,-ovck> ever nrv n «■ no of death thrcu.ch .Jionol.» 0, S'.d Schrelbor over tell you anythin.* about that? ... So. ... Scaroibor didn't te.l you very _uea about twytalar. did ho? „. Schroib^r reported Very nuen to a, rad I ft .v. worked to .ether wit! ~i~ for -any years. . 3 yj do-s i. pen ho sever told y- about these little disagree incident r of kiliia. of concent rat i-n era ica. tcc by Dr. Din.-? lb ?->-:-3ZS-5-4-Eincincj: 3-uri .1. ... I do not know the reasons :ich Schroiher hud for doinr th t. I also .' i not know to vh-.t extent SchrelToor vus informed*. .. rid'you know of Keitel'a order ter,t tho Yohrrccht wi to Ivo 3thin, to do witn ox. orir.cats on oiaa bcin-E? la this for.;, • do not know anythin,: eh oat it in the forn in vh.’rh it h i. boon ot-ted in o .u lace h-r... I err. only any that thin wr.e ex. *>1 oint of view of t..o ’to hr . o cht red -i.r t perhaps Keitel brou/£t this up one. tin . t bouc place but I- do not know it in the connection in Miich it i-in boo:: mentioned hero. .. Wh-.t do you n_-.. tix.t '■ 1309. Prosooution Ec'ii’ol 325, w..ie. is a ao orru-ix - fooeor plo..o corner i blolo leal vnrfaro rad proponed oxporihenta or. .'nr/ beings, dated 23 February 19~h. *hlo;a h- • nr ortod that ho h-.d until now .,.lo no ox-a: ta in tne field of humn uodlolno, 2 h \ neccoa-ry rad ho plans to take tue_. .. mv institute ur.d v r his control io bain.-; built boot Pooon 1.. v^icr. bi'la-icnl weapons nro to b_ ntu.’iod tux touted. ?iold jkira.-l Xeltol bus Ivox the poniiauion to build. Roiciv fuehror SS and OcneraLarst Frofocsor 3rradt neve osBurod hi:: of vast au;ro 3:' roqucit of Field Xnrehnl Keitel tho ar.ai forcea arc not to have a r c .onoi'.le share in tnc oxpjriaonts air.ee oxporlaor.r* will nlro be conduo' on hx .u: tclr-a «• «b»t •» Xtit-i • *-o sr 3C55- c* - - - 1 - ... 1 1. Ti.it la ruito ;:sci • . w :• ’ifcusc. • i: T. rol rc, I cannot iv: ;*.-u - . - • •• c i fct ic tot Koitcl, wh o too t - , . ti r. -i:\-3 *.rh ilc . \ aro .i.t -"•* ha - Usuo' :r. . r _*• \. . c_cn u-i'cr I:io c ,:U 1 X10 . u*tici ate iii v uj 7 li a e: lain Uc.t Jena.- a\ .o.mc r.i* yao 'i.ln't? .. I can a* lain this i.i L.ic t ..t ..-ltd •• .. In ;’L . -Uirur 1 arterc, t:_ t : I.’g ho r s tint he fcovr L • ■- ec:ic ■■■■'- t In t o r-r'o rxt-ra-— e.at tU cjrclc n dw I'--er'a ic p- • lac very end r ’ fi&ly -’l ajt varic-.:, ... . j ten t in a - v ."v. ' non ' at u: . Fac;Jcr'o v - ••• ’~c' -i not cc_._ t U»6 lowAot) : .c:. lc. r.vc .ut 'iiotisB, : x .r. i . c vith iv r.i’vl—: net ••o, n c ;s- LV t. -.t l.» c .v..cti n -1 r ei* t r. v l r .ach k* crticl.cte in t.o. , <- »:.•. r3T? 7 u ct c.-uf ... sJcian T -Jc ccc cf t..c c r --c. *-7 .. • I n t r-Ce.iv -i . . •• tv^.urc nn-ct.. a ' ~ ~ i..;_ ldt. rC d ’.ti. ' .. re - c .U-Cii :: z ir-o't y u in char a: a ..attar fee:, X L.. atu a urn.. ci.r- 1 . c L-;cti .i '... i led •onr.rr.ro? A * t v s n fc ij raoi-i,— it, * at it rio U- -*al n:-eat i a oi . 'led i : rcL countries : ciX ct n h.-.’ ' .ca acJjlcv * - feel’., cat vl. fm-ti.r t vc *- o-i : .vac. t - , c '. :.cn an^ quest* :ia trrr . .... -. 1-5 cher e f nai: A . etna •_ tell ycu that. - - . Central Vetarinar^, jp. • 3 i- he * nly then zr So, at. .. Mo 3 oo&list f id!. ; IU; hi . . 3i»!n* t y a 5a; t r.t 1 : -•its u -u v. ‘ .in 3? * •• t ' c. :.l_ * iCtciM'2 ;•? .0.. . u t t -t th. wli; *.ith Il4:c rcsw.it. H trev ., . n t ins ~cu r rii .u. :za tl- iv . I . -vw ncvwr ’laouaoa: the im-oti 8U .~ c ‘" -i 1* :ic'.l warTci’c cx,.< % . Vital u 3 rl - . I. • or o 2 . ccrtrXi «*.. ..do ^ o enuoo dloar, • • < :i •m;. c -I! rwj.ct th-.- *t „;l .r.t w t.ic I-’ tvl K,d the - \ lilt ry ...’lcltw u.ilwii. . . r 6o:a*ol' . -? lo. ivll.V.. •, tQVO sal' t Js c lwtwl, ut f th. •fi.et.. u : .r ro, m' I c -il.*. lin. tie t r: ..*-tv Jr;’ r.t riwa wit 1. ut r_i c 1 t t -thw-r, -xfr.li, t 1 - ' ’ aly c eun - . ; . . - rutrri-« vi c. •; ric Vw its a nnlllhls. yru • c.y a.y ~*1.0 e -11*' ut n * On s? , ' ’ -i t ha v aaythia .. ■- ... r.qu ctuyi. •4fll • acri; : -a c..-/—J,i . v , t li U-. -• r : "^n;" ie - • cotrothj . ~ .. . ..itcnti a ,f ctiti.1 - •. r Ur s she will i«: : 4 ri .. ita *■: 1 JerJ vcu-f-.rc . '. , Ul * tJ.w r- rl u .or.. u —it t, , ■ - - C.'Sw, ill :.«T I vs It -> u4- r-tia , n- , .-rIV! s c .12 ■ - It. .-O - r u --ita tliw a ri. . Gur.rji - - --- - -- V C zr . :* . 1 v.rl - r it ruich is “s' straiten 44 . Very well, Ooocral, LoBtf.t'rtS rare r;-iuc*n ,:i f fti v-ccia s in Go may? . - ' -Cv- Frr as it *t\s the c . .• c . r r. •. . ... -7.0 .S3 Oi Uir.t I have zls: he r* ._ •r.* rcc-lv . i c - I ’ ' . . : , a -:-C. ...I .. r.i --v .. ;xnt I caan t r-:-i : r . .r r N , L. v fever tl i.sti .1 in Oor-xny ns ..!> lisc a a ,v. t- rrrilv r_: ' it Oy 1-jc-’ a art r* L n ;.o the coil ai .n i: . IKx', General, - a Jcv . Br'.t-rt K cl. Institute nLv r ‘rcL. ; ;11 lev r vaccines? .. t: t j ’v. ruitc . a v Q .ex:. the Tyv.ua :u\ Virus Ji-atiaut. .1 the IK at Or c ./ . , j •-»' >-u r '..it ii.-.t y u : v : -. c . ~ca :i tl- : . t -raluf; ct-.rc t.£o vac cLie? • • '-as live virus use ~i t o- v7 . r_(t. tr stv._ t';a -it . t.e 1 r lua i tiv i t very "• r — .niter, '.at fc.-re v„ njv.-* — vfr r .‘eh is L-.j i_. i ur re vliich v. nr- just lisc_ c--.. really . ut v _\n Lit- the fir- ’dth r.. ari V the fact -an c-n suTf-r ny a. - c 'r Lie vaccine, . .ell, Ttli-i .r?a t:,. r *-• . :D_ria t- test thiovcci c? - r.-U cana t tdl . - t‘ ' c - . . . n , x -rLich ha * air- > .. . i :c • , er_ - uc. a-_r r. re' s . _. . .-a .i- it. I ca.ai - . 1 Li Ir y a recall tfc : it . vi ,:i ;■ l-’ary, ~.,ic - c I cr.-.rv t ss^' 1 ;- na Tezstna *. it. Hcwcvtr, I =n noitbcr c sdral ;ist r : baeorl legist. Ic.-.. fctat C5 Smcwloij - is eUwomol, e t unicrstan! . r.-.i. which is ccataino.'. in th- -ir.. Dicr_ • ^ Q And y u never hear.*. raiytijia. e. .:\t t'^ro ex. -ri.;onts at johenrrai with those ycll-w fever vnccinos? ' •• • *. 'Jr. Select ain't t-U u? .. Bey n . Ar. \fi\ is -r. Sch d *t ? .. Sclteidt W - •; . hygienist . ; . :.r. y ' c . wont tfcr.ujh Ui- Trench ce-.,=i : *. .t. U. ; .xi’.ic'l Ins. -c - r r.„ in l?h2 wl-.cn I . ecu. led :y effic- in the Ar y .. Heel Ins; ect r-.t*. ;\t orlin r undor no until ..c li . He narcr re. rt-i enytdn. t / e* nt this? A * r • 0 Is he ti;. sm:e Scheldt . u cr c.J' a ha* t fc-stif ? A res. TBS .. LSHEOT* The C urt will bo in r-ccss f r a f ov . :»at<. (.. recess wrs todron) 3C59- Court I 18 Feb L7- - 5-1 - LJG - Karr t r-3 ImHSULs The Tribunal is c in ia s.ssi n. BY :S. VcPJSSZ i -4. General ,;: -cti . f j in th -t to . ti - viion frphtt* started t *d With us, t •< winter r l&l r 15 .2, I ru-n ttonti n t t,.; civilian .«:•, n I 4.i:.k it « u C nti, f tho ler..<* 1 OfluS I i .rial rs. -vr.ir. o: v • X r. Ur tho nun’. -r f fifty r rsj j«-r c«nt in that c nn.cti n. ..t * - t U * I liv ;dy stated in C -rureol t Uiu ti o tfvs,r. I .1 r.U r. v t»a nothin: tn t 1 taV-vr n sr - I 1 r.'t kn ' what it n r.ally - 1 • ut - Qi .t 1 ha n thin t c!l rith ■a C'.nfaronco in any >tty in c nn.cti n *-4th c nC.ntrati n ca s r tho ut j f in :t ;s r tho :so f any * th s *hi h d. 1 - 1 -_ fr u the n-s Vl yc a f r, and I c-r. .aly t\ -at th-t h-ro. «. ..oil, Qacoral, since y u .:.:.ti n. this s* t*. *-r.t at 0. ,-arsol Jet's f-ut it bof ro the n . This i: ^canent KU # 712 vhich w_. £f«r os r; Sxhi it fa* . o: . • hat at .*-nt y u :du in C erur 3, an 1 1 it? ... "-Sj in 0 ctmrsol 1 v. - vach :t — L -- , 5 t-rr. t v s.:.. J this st *.-^xnt -n-.r. it rv : Ct- C art I 1& . ; -i u7-> - 9-2 - LJj - Zarr v "iv3c-tvin t the statement - * - intorr sting *njricaa fficer, I was su^p-.s-d t. hero attended a acotin* in 19hl, at which Hoitor, C ntti n nd 'xu_ -sky sjto pr-s-nt, -ni t h su .st-i. tho c-rryir. ut f typhus research n hunsn tin s. I conn t r-c licet tho date, -l-'ce .and particip:nts, n r the c;ore- f each an..tin b-ccus- f t‘~ ’ V y^'-rs that hr.vo passed and the n’-c.r us i n cice n ts th t h ore ecu rcrn. rr.ph 5* *. "..s f x as th- typhus r hi- ic c r.c.m-d, it a.y h.v_ -on tho i 11 wir.-i f r .‘ccti.n f the kn , ry effective tyjhui , in& t- tho th r rr f. «hieh /.-s dor fr n lie-, draped far behind tho actu.-l d-ocn-'x, despite an increase. Ty■. hus vaccine was .Js r lucod in th- *• -rt * ch Institute, thr u. h cultures in chicken - 3 j ita dependable uffidency, . , iuntty pr-vod. lo . B qu -to ,.r tootica f.r tho c hat ar-as, is well cs f r tho z no f tho int.rl r r. irjt t,.hus, it . c_no n^cusc .ry t cl .rify tho valuo -f this rcc:ino at tho offfUest ,5.r-nt. It is t -r-f re quite . .ssiblo th t in th- o i-rst '' r. c nf. r^.c- hr. -Ini «3ky ii ht hr.vo boon aaai_r.ud t c .rry .n stu i-« • t r. 1^1 t-sta, w ut aa u, . .ti ility md oflicionc; . r. "Thu , ur. s- was t. rrivo at r. iir.-.l c i.clusi n whutho • ho vxeins pr .ucud by th- x b-.rt X.ch Institute s *. oqurUly -f icl-r.t .nd c uld bo usud in (he .ohr.wcht ar. in V .i.is x- x n U.o oasU.rn - r at v:.'th •i c nai . .. r s .act f success. 0 K y u cji't 'Mi •• * u ,urticij iU;’ in such a .jeetir. *t i oro? I 8-J.d t .-t I c n soy n thin ut tho ti-._- it t k \-\cc and I havu --Ir.-.dy t tific ' h *- - t, ..ctur .lly, c nf-r-nc-s t :: . 1 c- r- ut tho typhus oni . rr •*t Q>aru»ol ukod - car-ctly idiothcr it c .ui ’r't — ssibl- that It's, -k-n t i'xu, -.ski' ai/1 that such a c ni-r-rco h\ t.k-n ,lace 1 t 1 - hix. ‘that I .3 luit- S- * t k ji. Co. "hot I *as c nc-rr.-d C art I IS li7- { - 9-3- L«X» - Sr-rr r with - I spclc. . ut it .f ri- '..as "h. t.-tin* f thu chickon <*_s vaccine n •- sufficient noriier f -rs os in a c«,rt_in vicinity; that is, within on oron whore spotted tvJius or already ccurr j ’ r tf.ru was trinont dar -r oxistiit;. X “ - - - - -lC- 3 -I^co.r -- * • X • a tonc-rsif! t*zfc!i vr.^c_;;r.;_ :c >f vcn as i;~ca, • ' I • s- t:-' '-o ■ ti-t :-.bo lr*u. :> c'_7 loft tl^is crj£-.;v::cc - ;u- 2 "uchcn-rl -n* cam. >ufc t*.. 3 .s :-33 vrccx:-.r.C;. ••. or • -c ' • pc . iris, n.aoi’ llit* t ->? I cm «rl“ 3=7 :Iro.w fox. ?Mc *-"3 r •. _ . ’=0 caul' r.>C "isriVlr oread r ~r-clao •\-fcc t > v *•,-:' / 3 .. flTCthln- t: r t il; - - - rt ■ ■ rn r v - Ji'na to 6I.0 s *1 *icr but 0; •• fcrci - c-untn. 3 :: 3 :\v. -r -f v=ccln-a, 2 , 3 , .* • - - eti . ... ... --f >poi n oounfcrlca ' • . . . CW6.8 lit 'cr *a7 tl^ru -\;i\. still c o i- ibid .m vi t*o• Tiio -a ouxtv .' '.Ti-- aflit-.ti.ic s.. -. ? • rone .-, v* . . _ -1- . . iocusoi >::c. Fwiv' 3 I ‘ 3 .. Mff-i \«l»r. this c>ri)in“ti'.j v-cox-V.x i:o -a i.i. r)*; ‘., u t * -I--. * - t *.«. aro 1' .3. ~ut ■ ■ -t —c t’vt ouVj.ofc • vr cv.xd- ,-.fc io.*. iv sir ' c in -tt.n i.:.sfc • u ; >v- • inti--.? I cr.nt tell • v t.-.- , I • v t ro- - •* c*- : n- ; “ lfcl ' u - 10 '- s t,,!: rl“oc i*.r- *t *a . - .ufi ••-.iw.a “ »..ct it is qui c i .raill- . \ c. t..-t I 0 v.l* .ol- * cl1 * ' u cl ~ c-w cud c'r.forcnci xl 7 a: n*>t • - *tOTlfl!, ■ . 0 - - . . p , c t- i esret ' - :o. S, O . ^vq;i -id: —ji* r.lris’.. 3“t other • it:-. 1 ‘ pel ... ^ »i k - • • i* . ' * w “ ' “ - — - - - ^ • - Wkv Xi. U # .V J Sv. ar C^P^Xii Ml • «• • - 3 * L 4 id T i.rtu; fJFgb Y7-* ¥~ L rc^ilcall in " -r.* :,v • I tlar. . ‘tiv. :.15 ; 3»- 1: , -on'- *' tUvr. .c - -re ^- 30 - ,r 1 •'*; 1 4 I e“.r. ,:wi* - the. • . v , * •— r - • '~-a£ . ce-c^rr-e re .it.. ~!:ur? ' 1. I . 3nt“5t»- • t'l • ~t ' ,1 *ter 52. .. 1 m c^aXex-waow i'.'tw. t I *oii, fc -1 0 r-i'...p —a Fr.ai'c.tt ~ 1 tLi. ': t :_-1 cue* - .- r c xi; 1 . r-1 r * ±Ts*cl±\ *n ■it i. f > , ru-l.e 1: I -t ul' , - r-4.lv’ t 1 *• •*■1 -306c- :; _ c c cr '- "it *"cll he —a -rr St'i-e. : 1* •-'•lf.l, Y~o, r-, th. ?.».r tr— *'inic< -s' '-rtw.-s i •>r the. l-ct , , N ?•>•»* * N -• t O v 1^ t*.w rwc tair i % l. r n..r . *-• 308 ?r lnflOwas- — c Mr to Le e va j • . Sv t c I : - *1 • •* * • • « -.3 "lth itr.i v-r v - v-ov. «. or i^ .y. " * I r w: . :• _r c . ;*- * r.-y fi-.it'-ct -; -11 but" • JU - * » | i ^ » - : mV t ot ..ir i. •. * i 3067-r 3 "V' <7-• -r -Il-l- in ’Suck or* Kc. 1 . t. Oil ._!.ji3t r r ? rcsi .nt f tho “r'>crt 1'rcl Institute, .m't he? ... '--a, Oil .c: -let .r - rcei ant pf the “cbort Kech Institute Vr . *t. t] u •• - v ..rt Sr cl Institute v..s «uv r '.inr.to *. tr ti o inlets- rf Interior, -s it nrt? ... YL»a, I *-^liov tc im-w t] t on it -„c jo *-oici inetitut it i uo t Y vo ’-cn ax rin-to tr tie rt oich *!inis rv rf tt» Intor- : I v-.'t kne v wfcr.t t) eitu ti n r ? - of with o< rt in- ty. I 1-; ,;-r in cinol th c tfco 4i *>ort Xrcl Inatituto V 3 tlo r-conc f vUcl tho Hold . inietry «f Interior :: c use v.*» on it noo'c ny cruneol n any n ttor. I think th .t is hr I n lwnye unlopat it. . 1 n tti r Ctnti i U a • n in oY'.tzo cf tlo ort tool* In«tituto in ti inirtr;' f Xrtori.r? h. Yea, I w. ui: any t: fe wit! c rt inby •* on it xr • . .tele) i • . : n »t !• ■ wl t the situation ■ r bef* ro ti t wit) c o n ! 1 " v- 61 - y ? rt. • ‘ , ■ ‘ t Syph.ui, pr 1 • .’’.cti rf typhus v .rcir.s, t: . offioionc; 1 typhus - rcinec? . . ; rntr.cfc with Cmtl w~a n r r t' prwa.rt thv r. -or- re oltu* tim r - t: wlnt r 'f 19'il 10*2, • when 1 uy' n' t! - • " • ttr v eel--. : Olf r this vr.ee ino, > * f - tl r v. ccl. ,f ri le! e ;vj mtc r. pw.-J*nnca l'-tor *.n . ->eir.■ Mention.:. 1 ru wr-.. * nc ctceaptl> r. t r. <-.t thfct t*. a • , - : ‘ ’ , ispufc. , La , t: .t yru '.j ir. £ r. crhforoncp vJ v! lc queati'u rf tiu ifflcLonpy «* « 7 < Ik v.ccino v c 3063 - Jdi'-l-''- SU-ft-Z- Cdyrf #?'/ : ,!e ” !,rf -<^ »l-ro it v, , uc , - .. . . ■*• - c j ox>,ri. s.ntn v ’’1 Irvo tCb ° ' ° Wt W t™, • “—•".» «1. : . tlr!0 r: vo I fir.i.l c c t . “ 0R 0 - h *-70 =c 1„ e nf jroneo in 1 r -o cir- W * 1 - •. * • ■ t *«»,„ two '"'' »-+» , * Si ^ Bc6l , ’ SK C ' s * n't loicw, , it ant siu,: in e o A x* in « U ' 6 *" -CJS “ ns ; t: •’ • - ^- c;. . t; f x ■, , ►*r * • * „ " : » !:- <• un or ul . «, , leM „ « . , r . n g t; . ..ccinu crj.o? 1 £ •'• * r !rl; - ■'■<• ., tlo .1- ‘.ucti n r V ccinu r ; ' ' ■ ’ « - "*•- 7 ■ - Ileal Inpwotcr, I ° ^ ^ ■ 3 -*» n- , Pr „ ......... ' «*. * • Mkdu •.. :c :o f /0 t: .:r 'l,vct,,. fc «, ” hln ' ?ltU6 ° “* ««* « 1 t cy. X, u) - , IWS# „ . * 1 ”' ntUt0 ‘* ° uc; •• f » »*««■ cf Oohninrc.t ott. fa l>nfc- ■ ’ ■ • « « ■■ :■ r guot UlM " l r 01 - v r U'-ct r . r t f root. ' tl -°’ •■-» :iroctiv« rto-rlin.: t . , rt tn T aM ;:ic! ^ : ’ ««* : r tf 194 S; B t fa - until U 6 ri «uol institutions wl „ r. ■ •>• HP or S_ ; rt . ,, r „r .1 C aw X C. cl. c no , m O „ ltl “ v - colr -o quo at li ns :.c tloy t} u 1 tt fit t' . -1 t ir • . r - i r k * 0l - v. .Odin- oi-ntot 1 ' • : — a- V..CC1... c rtr-i, . : i - * ~ « typhcc » « vor:- hi ,. -,1m, fa loci, r;- Oifitic : pr hl« v, I ,! ul- K htSs lt 1# .. .. - -nt 1 tut «..r, „ Ul. , t Uon a. ,.. r: „ P r . jnc -. - 3069 - It F.b ,7-:-£ -11-:- nr&XQk CrVTt r . 1 ccnMW _ . ■ --- * '"’“' nt u -= pr. ' . • • « ' :i c 1 - . , • « ptotor- fr :• ••' ' «, to. ;lfcu 6 c. of tU 0 ». . Sr-V ■- - ?« »-» ' 0 ** I .. fv„m « - -- ' , . . f . .. .. v„ r n tli -■ ut tU R ' c.6 -crtourij -• -* * , I *> Institute n si oir pi 'oti X v BJO tjr. 1 • ' _ . .. , V in’ . r; : »"= > n . m \x 61 - rc w c.oitr. l • on T « riVl - - - e 5 .V r ^ury vXtl ev ^ Srr.tvn « , ,, .. .. r fua? nc: i: f r tU c;vili:r. ojc if V ^ n * a,t :or al r* •« —’•«• * " ‘ er-t; :y to « , -to tototW : ' r > 3 “ C.,..r,r ttt r.. .«v t < ■-• l ' Kr - m 1 -' 6: - n ' , ' nti ■" *r i ... It -- r.f t: -r , r. v rd:-,- v r «r t TOW lr -il t: . .. . . x ro< In- c* M-mu Z - »./« - tLto * « ■ - ■ ■ - r ' • " ' yr u woron’6 C -urt 5 — 1 16 -,7-ii-U-lc-IK.--it: "=’*'• ralyla* .Lraly cn th,.. t». .«««.. -». •“« «* y “ *“ *' try *" -«t vrcclna tt cuctl a, tyto* vrcciac -w-^acti-at A . Mil, vu received e-.r.ethin. fr_n th* lehr In.- v.rkc. rr--V.Uy - Gahalnret Ott. fllvarad #«tUK f r tha *=. t«rit ry » f« « »“ ” r '- du=«d than. It t. that tha Sot. • *-ch Iht.ltuto irttrarat. "• tha teat ka.va azalea. thara vote tha Saachaiacha Sam-. V .rtf. !W «» here It order t •* .due* vrceir.ee — A v BvB i t you ien-v whether y-u ,:-t vecclr.*e fr,-. the'. >r r. tl 1 u c ' 1 that. 1. a ,.aaitmty. “y,u 6 a't vrat thl. MM th ' 1 ! hMtaa. nailcal .fficar la tha Vahnaeht hlfa't to- vhara ha -r. ttt.ln: V vpccltce, d. y-u? .. i jua, ar ah th-aa .,-aaclat fr «hara tha Vahmraht nay have ra- aatrah thalr vacclaa. - lahrlrv: ' rhc. aajrt. tha h tart t«h laatltuta - I a t .ay that vith cartetaty ua.aa. I t-a't ha- It. ..teat rah It. oat,city -r-fuctl a, : f .«■« think It v,. tet lax. fhea tha la.tltata I r hx.ar aaatr 1 tharrey la rrttkfur. -a th. yta, «fi - racclvaf -ar dy.aat.ry vracl at tha Eyrtoaa :a.tltut. -f th. Lalvar.lt:- -f iarllr. vhlch vra 2.1.., la aifltl.a. at th. aal'. Vra «c at tha a.hrlv ' ar/. otha- v, Cl... C*» fr.-. th. Srach.lacha Sar , Lark., raf I h.a't think I t r,;.t aas- tt 1 . Iha.a vara tha kWh. *M Oar. tU,ah t- «».. «M» < the Vpfcrnrcht, raft thrt, Is fret, did doliv*r. Vary vll. 31 y.u raaalv. ar.r.uctl.r. mart, fran th-.a e acaracV , v . i nea't .a. 1 ML fer -.a- -ff». «» *" =u " hr, ‘ ..hat ar ha *». h.Va nth. .«t the -rr.ar tad h. iwt hrva oarrloh •» ■«« « ra.naaf.aBca ,a .xf« t. ..a vhath.r fallvarla. *ku t. and. to th. a.-cf.f axtaut* :h... varaa't ay affrlr.. I-r thrt cur-.ta I hrf ry c.Ur.t nr. x. rtd -.y ex .*rte. v hall a... It hr. trh.a » a rr.hr !•« * « "> <»* t!l ' fl , . „ vr verv wdi taev cxrctly vhrt th- ty^hn Is thrt y.u, .r rt lerst y-ur -...c*, •>— r fuctl -s eieurtl.a ws. Ica't thrt ri.ihti ^ m th. .ahrrcht taa.tr: ar.irLly ta««ll!,a -cl r t . , Sj o. chant tt. all-rtl-a of tyaha. vroolaa.I DJf aayhi'.V c . C'-urt 5 . 1 ic 7c'. tr .1 th: tl . It .» first fr IM» - -t first Oter.trhorr.t tier, Chle vr ,h« tin.: tor.t 1.. .h he receiver certrlh renue.t. ft- e.rtrl. urrt. of the ft* he .11 c.ted the . .«C*«W to the heed. M h^r. W to (ifflcuiti.c a* th« the fth, k»i lancet rote to* -« Ur, or rcthvr. fell )Mi. !>-«' -• rW W Inoocetorcte .or treferred It to the Chief -f the ™rr,oh. .uric,a Serv,- MU vhcre « received r«orto , * * »« rod rtl ft* n. wu thrt -.erl.d -f tit. «hrt 1.. IM »v3 », -til 19 -. tft ft H.dic, Iconvct rrto vro in ch»r. - i th/.t h,u. thrt vro y.u to h th lottroce.. T.u «ro the Ar y H.dic,1 Inncet -rr te ft, » -« ■«. -* P «rc hi. • Chief * the Vchr-,,. hciicrl Service# S.v, l»n't it true th:t . v * r ' °" oU " hod the o.ver «, c-otr-1 th- all Ctttl.n tychu. vnccloe to «-«*> *. Vhot V. meed V.0 .tly - .Oh * ducod vccclo. ft» xrrt.v rod Lather.:. I thick w tnhehly received revert, frod the ther ffleet, ■n-ft .he. err. ft - ^t ... ready, rod the. a c,n,rl. » » ,to tott the heed tod. thee It vr. m.crted. cc.erdlc: t. thrt need. V. dllo't -sly hove t. cere f.r the ft-at «ny tut rl. f r the hen. I cros-t ,.ive y » «* * *— - h,e tut . -r,dIcily «• lccIdeate recurred lot th., 1. vhy fttftU =• hud t he -rde. vh.ch -hr* exteeded te c 1.x. jr.uertut. i *-» r» ‘hot. , ceoern, : don't tolak y-u —red the cue., lee. I eked, y.u ■ l. O, . f.ct that"yu , «— — -« ' »“ ““ .... t.ver -ver to. hll-Cl o -f to— vrccioe. ty — ——’ ' t.„ d,h Ift.tltuto, lootttute .f the «K r, ftrk v. the — - nnyh .ey el.o-didn't y u r -he .f r-ur . the never t. m - that tTJ'nus Vr-ccinto nr-.ftioti.nl «• ' r -• •• t ' r -ct thrt v.. hrd o-rtUin,; * *> ^ th th A. S j, m. l a r.uttn t .- 16 Feb U7-h - 12-1 - LJj - x'-tty *. All ri. at, let 1 3 a. lit it u. . Did you haw complete control ever the ell-cati-B as between tr.. varl tranches of the ..ehr-acht? A. *as. ..hoover fl^rJced cn that ;ad a list where stock and derand % could e c. -red, and according to the size cf the branch ci the ..ehraacht or, ainli', accrrUr. t the ur .xr.cy -f the eecand, he allocated however he cculd, it it v< a£ . possible, to tfie larger extent cf the w^son.'., If not., a little leas. I think that Qborstabaarat Schrddt could tell you - re about it than I could, whe uaa actually working Inthat office. jenara . . and allocation of tychus vaccines as but .eon t:ui .dlitary ar.d civilian .i outers xas a ,.roblo= vhich fell aquarol; v.ithin the fuehrer 5ac.ee f -uly, 191*2, ; isn't St? A. C to core fer ac» -*ms r.uods. I h.d nc author 11; itch the civilian sect.r, no duties J allocation. «11 I had to a was co.rdi- hr acht. Ir. Conti was native la the clvi sector. % . T.-.it«a right, and Dr. irondt was standing between y u and Dr. C .sti t cc. t .t t.tn s y u ,.t whet needed insofar ns that was possible, unnn't ;-? a. l oe. For t.«» .ersoresol an* 4 .-lerid qturti.n, yes. I don't know her the a ,ujBti.n of vcc . tne *.r • . .-d any flscua- ai no th hi n :t v esinos. H . -a it n .t 'r;o * .' certain r- .n hy.lonists hold t-he vlon thtt the ui tctivotwsa 1 ty.hus • iccinoe c.ui n t U» ustablishod in advance *hv.:u. i n rai->C -i, -ri.-ur.ta ucr-use r. t forty .vrcoSt f t.»- twin.-Is n iv* V. » •- - ■ • .•Ist-arxca and «ii *» t . *t cick -lth-url. artificial 1 / Inf* >c tod* A. E «not S '. that. '* .. * fr .-hure y u t sh a uf-i-nco. but it Jp s.^thiu a. social that •t ociy c .ris* n in t . r rs -. 5 . ,. . . , • .cd Ter? Pry. »ify fr »iu a a., t t i: his ii n ;u x irlrntfite .-r- n^c-ojary in typhus just as in .-lari-. C;urt I 16 Fob L7-. - 12-2 - LX - hi tty Dr you r-:-3ur that? Ko. I cannot r.-u bur t t. .. jftli, *.hit is y ur i-inicn in tiw itu.-, r d-. y-u h. - ne? D- ycu :oUov- that it i3 rwcoaatxy t; vx—ri on, .n iwa —in s -\s diatteiuishci fra. antaala ts c-i-• ini th* offvctivwfciaa .f itf.-huc vaccinia? ^ .. I c-t. -nly acgr the iA. - L. in that connection *n tha practical co.-. ito-nt r an v. 11 -bio . ut not tosto* vaccina with hu ..n V jin ,a and vith hinan boln.a t a lar c extent. They w-ra tc bo inreul .t-d with a nOcino, the -fioct f ahich - as twsUd t. •; aufiicior.t uld be deno. ..ith rofereno. to r.-ccinu o^ori'vmtc cn h *Wel» : • » * ith referonoo to the rttcoaaity -f th*t with -.-.f -r-nc- t. the limitation r-- i^xd ic.: , «noh utap technical concerto which ao a ..r-r-qidaito duAaO a let f kn *l»d,u nd which cannot V* -cne amy nth , jr.ral i-hrac-e where tho c-n-r.l odical nan could not osijly Ju ' -, and l sh ul: have t. sk you t, h-*r rui «x. :-t un that qu-oti n cactus* I . n t in ' ; citi.n t. i - .ny Ju're, -nt n that. : m , Sutural, y u -dt t a extru > c necessity -xuci.d to Ut V co':- ir. in. "inter A$Jil-*u2. lot iurf-r a- it in y.ur *.n at .want h.;x th-t this chicken v.-.cciu 15 Job 47- A - ? j C -12-la-Bitt7 Csurt So. 1 sufficiently proved. You >c on to say that to previio eioquato arotoction isv tho ccnbat aroes as aoll e- Tor the Zono of interior against typhus, it boctTO noeossary to clarify tho valuo o this Taeciao at tho oarlioft r.ccont, and thin you soy that it 1 .-. or to yocsibl* that : iru ;ovrkr ai -it have boja aoaitnol to carry out “hone stu’i . * \ Fa* just "hat Ud yon do :o a.U. liah tho offoctlvanoss of this a; yolk vaacino? An! I !ont -n’. to - or you tull . . cl ut ccr:pet ability ts. X to la or i . that 7 r.r 0 corriod out to doboruino aj offootivanoar. or thi- 0 . yolk me : A I fccTj alr^clj :a;i ./.at for . ol — a— I cannot toll you for how lonfc — oal I boliovo Z In Cborurso 1, too, tho roport cono clone that this vaccina ha, boon cocuitA! ani had roved itoolf to bo loo’. and won coin, pro c&o ontonfc. That was or.o roport. 7..0 othor fact was the* *..’j hr.d dociiol to frao ouranlvoa f.or. v-.cci .uc. rji such *.ad «• n subatituto rotert and ec.^o:. . u .ana, *1 Hoi lit' 1 farcoS , . 1 j fioloualna Is not in laauo Jioro. You havin't pot told aa n •oats that ’..oro corriod cat to iotor .ino tho offoctlvonosc of this obl yolk v-aoinu. That ccorinonts woro c-rriol out? Xat did thoy So? How 111 tho7 dotorrlao that tho o yolk vaccine wan or 7.-3 not offootivo? A I is'n't e-tablin'. a y of.* .ctlv.no-?- at all. I :orol cold that t thoulc ;o used 'ractleall- , -ol this ir r.ot -r. -ri:.ont, hot it lo -r.ly a use an in tho c.aro of a dree froc rhiefc In yractlco can bo coon ihothor it Is offjotiv^ or uhotbar it ie not effective. fcayoal that 1 had '< !ntorocfc at all. ’ n-jv-r initiated any u yuririontn nor vac 1 inform*' abewt any onporirunts. Jr. 2-/uT '/■it tiiJn in itself was a vary positivj ido of tho affair, a r f'w onyori- : about thab, t:-ic -sn*t a junction 1 dealt with. 4 do: iral, you 3 -ay hoiu that tlui .urpou —You say first that * * --.’oro, .uito possible that ; • - * • a.<» or oonfaroocn nr. *- r .■ ’ ht havo jot < 1 - i a.. to c.arr;' :a n.ociao r.-o.-.t orollol t-sts, a - - t . ooc^tahillty .*yj officio ay of this ty-hus v-ceina on - 3076 - - ?ob 47-A-j;C-i2-Zc-?atty Court No. !• bolngr. Iho ourposo was to errlvo r.t a fl n~j cow-luslon whotbor tho —ccinu produced by tho Robert loch Institute "-.3 oioquatoly officiant could to used in tho *7ohxwicht and i= tha typfaua areas of the 3'atorn -rant with a consider'bio prospect of ccoss. I nc asking you whether or r.ot A-i ~rs over dotorr-inod whotbor tho ZB yolk 7r.eeico was suitablo for uso by tho "ohrv'.cht. Did you over -rriv. fit any conclusion on that? A I wcwld osauno fren tho start that typhus vaecirw free chic Icon ^ AA wos us.d to a sr-ollor ox:oat. Fro:, fifuroa of production *ron Trankfurt, for lnstonco, it can to neon that they olroady'ioliTorod to to rdlit-ry -ad ciTlllon sldcv. Share was no largo ccrr-itaont or that rucc. and I think it actually lac happened at r.a^.tlr.j an. saao uhoro. Cocothin* wan published about that in tho ‘rose, and I think sera* c-x^aoivo article a poo-*c.i a: a latar ir.t: acout it. i rr. quito sure that I oai Schroibor, too, -ad tho i.-;;ro3oiou that tho question ai' tho offootivo- noss of tho o&s yolk toco loo could bo acsiuad as having boon conflraod. '.bothor and how far vo wuro caLaj 1 boaauso of that and wo ;.-oro natiefiod, I -on't knoi/, boc-.UBo i: i. rat^xkabij chat all rose xch work in foreign -’Ojntiioa a- •'* "obo erf franco, R ... a rrd '"or.-any always roarchad for C-urt l . 1 lo c-iSK-rutty E different v/cciac. Shit is the rcM-avhjr the- oneetir.n couldn't hrv* .-c! yet fiarlly c aelucef tut f r :.c it w» c-seiudod iasofrr re vithin the fra vxlc -f vhr.t vn» evciltUc this veccine c.ul tc use.-'. rnd I didn't vrnt t ieniv ray thin*; a-re thin theft. ... Aftdhov rein vi a it det_r\ined thrt this v. ccinc ceuld. to ucod! K ..id y-u rrrivu rt thf t JvL&ontl a. Schreiter geet hive received i/« hind -f trterirl *-» thrt '.r to .u-.jr hedierl Inspect in te. I -r.ly r«t» >ter th: t I w o told that thio v.ccir % vto rll ri^ht. ^ . r.d vhsn 'ure y.u t-Id tiu tl I on'% y.u hive rny 1 dec -hen y u decided thrt wo -Very v. kj i her/ vith e.v yvl* vaccina uee? A . I .-.ectl.n It ves x.f.uced, I tcnti.n it wt used. t< Ml 4n- cretsin,; tenure. I r.wnti n re.-rts arna rt.ut it fr.r. eitterr. Urrit-rieo vhsre it vr. used pr-.hr.fcly. ‘-hit the extent w c I d.n't hn.v lec uso C*to Still -rites in 19-2 thrt it hasn't yet c«en '.r -Ved to r li>r.:e •Ci l®, Vat ! ust r s oin nantion ceUu.ic. rnd you cin't Wh h* nvry frx. thrt locruoo •-..rein we the nev dcci«i'« t •-1 W tt* thio -ther .r-ce.uro. Cur in¬ stitutes. -vrhrnc, c-ulr. hive teen ir.utcd rnd c.cctr yd in Cnc.v rnd U-tr Then vu v.uld h vc teen left vith r thin.; *hr.t is vhy - p.ncontrrted cn f hio nr-e vhich d.ow* a.t oxelfcd.o tho - co lillty that I -at hi : ..r $-eke t. hi , tut I h*d. r- -.ore nrl or official rc~ e 1 /itl .r.a with kin. v *ad y:u can't tell this ^ri.unrl vf rny specific inotrr.co in which y ,u received. « reT.rt cn the efficiency f the y-lk vr.ccincT Ycu kn.v a. rjedrl ins trace where doer incut e were :^do r In vhich thl« ocr J-lk vr cine vro tec ted. io that rltfktt U. : C.ulm't tell y-u anythin* .f that nr-ture ti the -/.-.cat. v All y-u icr. .v if thrt it Vf. r very l:«crtrnt nrohlcr. ft the er.d ’ll 19,1 tut c.-ehfv the r.blo.: cee-.ed. t» ovr»r»t« rnd ynx don't kn v h-v it vra rec-lved, io thrt ri.ht? A. r-. *he 'r-Ui- didn't even rrto. In cy nlni'.n, tho ir-ducti n this vrccinc *m ir.cre.acd. Ihrt U why v« didn't have to *lvc nythin- r.v, a f tho racein, thrt U 1 n>d t. uc which in lteolf helW uo caPwRtirll". . , d.iti -a, there vr. the rueoti.n f ttX urin o it ccrtrinly didn't evnOO- rattf. It r.«oced syct.-rticclly rnd. I ah.tild like t r-->ei t . ncc -i-.ro thrt it la c -itur- eretnc.*if-: f y *>.aiti n rnd ry trUcc end n r.icunde— a tux. la.; -f the tra« -f V c.llil -t.ro if y-u think thrt I c.uld. .tive y ouch loteiled inf-mtl.n. I !i-«. thrt if. f lnctr ace. y u net these tl.ae t. tho exert. Sctoitt. vh. icr hycieniet end who v,rW -n thce ou.sti.ns, he v-ulc. to *Uo t- heln y-u ,v«r thio vrcuur: of Mention. • -nly :e-.ert vb*t I hrva rlrecdy ctr ted. „ tell. c> Ur c.8 y-u y.urrelf ko-v, y u crJir..t tell this Trihur.i * the nr -tic:: -f the efficiency f -*•- v-lk -»'•» « lv "‘ thcr ' ly y-ur -x lra:-ti -a al-ut J .>1 usin.-T ^ l*v doutt ty the use. - 30 ^ 9 - Ccart 3-. 1 15 Ic- ->3 rilSIDiST: IrLoral lr. r-«e«r uitil uc-thlrty .'elveic. (A rcc-st vca trices ustil 1250 fc ure.) X - 13 Fob. U7-^-ABW3-l^Blakl«jr Court VCm 1 s> THE 'ARSFALl Persons lr. th; Court Roco rill plcasa find thoir seats. Tho Tribunal is again in session. DR. FIZZC-TH-i Attorney Flo.-rdng for Dr. Kauftaam and tha defendant Rndalf Brandt. HBy it picaso tho Tribunal, the defondant Rudolf Brandt re¬ quests that h* be excuud fro - .', the Court >oon after tho recess in duo con¬ sideration of his physical condition. ^ T.~ ~R~~Z~£'SU That is tho physical condition of dofond-.nt Brandt X today > Counsel? DR. F12 l?Ti Thj defendant Rudolf Br ndt has recently requested that ho bo -xa^in-d by tho urison radical officer. The prison nodical officer has det.rainjd that Sutolf Brandt is in a bad gor. ml physical conditionj and oth-r things ho has ordor-d that ho bo given additional food and also has ordered that ho rost. Rudolf Rrandt fools very rtuch exhaust 'd by this o>min.:*3 ao sion and th.refor j requests that he bo excused imodintcly follov in* tho afternoon recoss. THE .RESIDENT: Tho Tribunal has boforo it no bools upon which to oxouao tlw defendant Rudolf Brandt. The Tribunal will requoat the prison physician to make another examination of tho defend.nt Brandt aft.tr tho session today and r.port to th Tribunal W.3 findings on tho uattorj but at this ti - the Tribunal has no justl-ioatlon upon which to excuso tho defend¬ ant Brandt from attendance. ttll tho Secretary General roquust tho prison physician to rate.- another ex-vi nation of dafondint Brandt after tho closo of the session today? Tho prison physician should report to this Court con- oar ring his findings as to the p^y^ioal condition of defendant Brnndt and give Us opinion as to whether or not tho defendant Brandt's physical condition is such that he should be excused from attendance upon tho trial tomorrow subsequent period. v SE S F RI DD SUBHDS22 - Resumed ©OSS mid:iATIO!I (Continued) ~ :r. ::oauEi« Q General, do you roaucbar aqy specific steps which you took in the I _T-S1- i.3 Fob. - TD-d3-2-0lalcl ey Court lio# 1 latter part of 19ul with respect to th: typhus problem? A In the latter half of l?2il? I have already said that the lattor half of 19hl would have been the period of idmj when the cases of typhus began to spread# Q Did you ever suggest placing the production of typhus vaccines in ti» hands of tho pharmaceutical industry? A If this qaa at tho very beginning, 1 cannot say. Howover, I am of the opinion that, for example, tho foundation of the Behring Institute at L^iberg was caused by tho necessity of producing noro typhus vacoinc. I cannot to nonbor axactlyj but I can still rciaonfrqr that tho question was dio- % cussed with r jgard to tho industry# I was thinking first of all of tho Bohrlng "forks at 'larburg and that vo should request tho:a to inoroaso their production. That is the only thing I can say on tho subject, Q ell, 1 ts ut oca at ja-1323 to you. Doctor. This is thu letter you wroto to Conti, isn*t it, on i October, rather than on 10 ftovenbor 19hl? A Yos, that la quite posaibl . • '!cHA?r.T: '.h rrosocutlon cff.rs this as Prosocution Exhibit 1x52 for identification# Q YTlll ywx pl .aso read this letter aloud, G<>noral? A "Tc th Reich B alth Leader, for infomation of tho Roioh Minister cf th. Interior, 9- rlin, th- Govurnn.nt of tho Government General, at Cracow, tbs JtaLeh Health Office# Institute for Typhus and Virus Roso-.rch, Crooow# "Sov ral officos, rtioulirly in tb-i Gevorrr :jnt General, havo apparently exp.ri.ncad an increasing Aroni for typhus vaccine during tho past few months. At any.rate tv C~r. has rp-.at dly boon aokad for typhus vaccine# On account of tho roquircr-ants of tho OXE itself, this request could ba not only in part. As far a it ispossibl to judge th. development of tha '3'ic, it is to bo oxpoctri that tho demand will contiruo to exist in th future. It is thorofer- su ostri tc place production of the typhus vaccina ir. .nds of f • - 0 - - pharmaceutical industry. The airy, ”, although probably on a 3 —Her seal., would bo consid.red a customer." Q Ton'll notice from tee attachment that this letter was passed -3 2 F *. L7-A-.-.7r-13—3-5lakl oy C art !c, 1 • ilor.- ly Conti to thi Robert Koch Institute, wasn't it? A I'ia " eich 'in is ter of th: Interior requested it to to roturaod by th* Robert Koch Institute. 3 That noons that it*undoubtedly ca^o to the attention of Gildq- j is tor, didn't it? A Yos, C lid:.sister was tt resident of the Robert Koch In3tltuto. Q Did thi3 letter in any way refresh your recollection oflbut any reacting in Doc-.br -f 'Ll with Gildcetdstur and Reitor ‘ one or nine typhus vaccines? x A Ih't only refreshes :y xxcory to th: extent that before I knew of tho decur ent I had nnsrarsd ir. r:ply to your question that 3 cculd faintly r . -Voor — and I was thinkia.: of ta. B hrin’ orks first of all — that tho question had arisen that the oirilian industry was to bo included* and this fact has bojn confiriod by this doc -jnt. h t Conti did afterwards with this lot*, ir —.s net within =y sph.ro of influence. If it has been asnur.jd that the Rob art Koch Institute .-.t th; institute and ; rof. f-ild- roister was tho person subordinated to Coati uho advised bin, th r. this would be quit: -.n ordinary yroceiiro nnd then tho stato scer tr.ry ir. th: Reich ?lnistry of thu ’ rlor shc-iid p.se :n such a lofct r frou th. OKH to such a subordinate or consulting .gjney. J You don't knot what was don.i c-'ccorninc your su go3tien that tho phar -.ooutical Industry be ( -;in production of a typhus ra< ine? -3C83- su- -s-i -n -rt the IS 7o" • L7 -. - C-r S3 C art 1- • 1 -■ •; * n*t kn -• -ii-.t -.-as d c-.m. ii-. ; ur » * her . ;c tical in’.ua r;- \c in -h. r hseti r. f r. vaccine, t.-yhus vaccine? A. .'ell, I nl. -cat t s v U-.-fc -i.i.er the .r 'ucti a us incr-asc.' :r that iho Institute f the Civilian -.ct r at Lcr:'cr , r f he industry liiich lias already ^ccn . . , . ... , X '\r s I Pii e* lc - -. cr, is * .utc r.t Le:;c.r has r uccd rr:ci.»c Irt. he intcSt*n-s f li^c la Us. vr cine fr.: ichen t . ... cf -r., this ia the f it ,* tie r.quas v - • - t their -X -vi.u at the e; rlr. i*c?!« in Ltt&on In the . i*. Jsicti-a ef .'ei 1 vccciaot * : oanmrt ull . n th t at Forte; a they have nly ,'r !ue% ' .ia v.< c.'./.v -r : chicken - s ’ ut I atr.V. I tli u ht they v-rc .r <:cl tl:; that in the v.ry * a innin .-i l vaccine, : eereaia, tint io aJy an . ti .i n y ; art, - ; r c n c d .. r i. .7ns '.Vci 1 ti rJcLa • r.t .i-.c v in th- Ci;: j Institute at Lo:.i<. 1 , Cn he ccaai c T visit in Ui saner f l?lil I haw s. .n hit; ■' -l'.".! institute .in.' I have tall;- ,o .. am’ icrxnr th't ho .>a.’ \c:n i:r. f r uiu a i n . rl ' . i. e. I teat to ,iut an User , - 1321 , TItis is . ao Irceecntl n ontification. Ooncral, tide ic • • -in. 'at a sL ;i- litU- c ver I VUa- -/.ic'. ;«keo sxnti.n f -. : . -tia- . -c. -r 1/ I - i.-mir. - ... s c a! and third . - c. It s-.vo u; at thL e pi "2. )T: .... Str.te Institute frp ir ariiantol Thera. 7 Frankfurt / :.ain° - Institute un'-r Ock-iaiv.t Ctte? . r Gchc: Of -3 net have a 1-tter as call i-. , I- :*a aait Just a .inutc. General, *11 fini cut tthst tho 18 - e’ . 47 J-UTt .» • 1 14-i-rX?- Gr cs recent is firit. "Inci.o^i fir. c y .! n-t-s A . c-afer-nce which t 4c .il'Cu hor- un 29 .-cosher 1941. I request y.u roi rt uh*t quantities A typhus scrua can - r ice in y ur institute >r n r.th, T. ill x. avail'..>1- f r the civil! r. ul ti n. FuiV'xr.r-r., is this v ccin- ir-. f char.;r will it x eh r > n t h w nush? "In * itiin, I w-ul w-ciato >ur e;;, -r ti n v.ith the Institute f^r r.c* i us -vis- o-o •?.. xrt Rich.' Berlin l -r the ;or -3- f eot listen.: a t-st ieth. i r ty .-.us v ccin-, n. au'xait sra. t x." % Th-r. *- a-- "-h.-t c y f tte.se rir.ut-s f this n-etin.' w.r. c-nt la. ti iwrfc eh Institute, t tb- G Tgrn»nt £rur 1 in Cr os, ta first the .rjyHu'lerl Ins -ct rt., which « ul - t v ur ffic-, t th- Behrin rla t the 2. ... F-rUn, n t Lr. C r.ti. . xe this little * cunent 7 • .v obsne svfrtob .* ur r-c.il.-*: n at iiu Be tin f 29 1 r 1941? ♦ •• • . T.u c n s-c ti. t r r r.tly w a a-etln ? a. . - ... r.*.r. y th- n ae : J r^t : rrt i-r. Scfc ltz? .. T-0. . ."ul. .rl' urv 1 a Sch. It" . 0 nr«t '.a rrt Lr. Mlvltl ..~t Cull.', r t.r in th. Arty i: 1 -ct r tu. . - 11 r t r n \-h t? ... He u s in th- 0 . rtr-r.t 1 r Scientific K-'.lth L- -rrhi r te Isj c «. v. n rk- ir. th. Jr ni: ti r.l — rt-u-nt. KnieV.r, 1 ennn-t c t t r . i r-r, to w s - lln litb - ic 1 ortturs. I, thcrefsr, 1th - • -raid >. U - uith tyhus, f.r a-:. L-? .. :..t .x r.r.iVv. . ... hrii 1 - -v.rvhir. 1th Q-nsur*>8 i Itn xi nc-. H. -r n. ic 1 :i:.r vh te r.-c-ive -r-vi us *t . . i_ y.u -v-r h - ny cunt, ct wit ... I h ! th- aea» c.ntict uith Ida s I h: tu the uthur fifty re.lic'l IS • . , jri .. .nicer: - - - \% -- * — ic_i r_t .. 50 -r 15, I i rJl •- • ’*' 7 ». .. 5C. *„ ?r r Dr. Ku-’Ick.? D j y-« 1» " • ® • r .... - * J ' , ... K-u- -i—s-k--? .... -r a-..- :;. 1 . V t. . 3r r w, 3-u-u-r-. - -r.-n? . I u .3 w r. cna * • • . u U :a El.* II*- a ID-•“••• « • - c hi . - •hyaioi n wha . ,U- v icl Xmh I 1 • H- .. nr.? ... 1 kn * *. aw lur r. >. rlu n ,-r: . —: • • - • thBv.ic . fci -i ay ftf ’y -v- • • - *--* f i • • " it a.'t - ut D^-nits aooo toy. jut, la at r.tL*. I - & lr. K - • u *. little it rn: ut tj OU r.ort f 49 t—~r 19U -=•«. It -. th.ru mu W* J. I h r ' l t - no f «“ «• I think r.u nlU tU. it inl.r-ctlr.., il . • r.T.rh ».« «=»/. ul lh “ .•• •.: :. -x- t This wiU. •>- — • . / . eh. - : 10-1521, i.Vi * - • * - •* i » . _ . • , ^ omunt IC-131 f>, ;; c lir t • * t‘, .eh. •? . . : : , . • ' ■* Th nk y-tt. laU will - fr n L% f.r i, , . . -ui-likut.ru-. tl.it 1-, ■> tk M *4 | 13 r - .47 -fc-L t^L~?KP- Gr-ss - rt 1 sill Irvc it before it. Itetu.' ierlin, U Jenur-ry 1942. Muoemn u-_ .ri. in-.tinr iron th- Reich :inistcT7 of th- Int-ri-r sirno ’ey Dr. Bicbor, you t-l‘ us cbcut this cemin^, reals is follows: “On 29 -/eCejb-r 1941 n c^nf-r-nce t.rfc nl".cc t th. Reich Ministry -f th- Intori -r c-rccrnin. the ’.-vwi.Tajnt -f n typhus v-.ccine in which, ~si>*- fr . tho un’.-rsi xv-I, th. f-ll.*in t k nr t: a »Fr.’. th- Institute 4 Infectious Dis-.ses 'Hubert K ch': Vico Pr-sj ont Dr. iLuooist-r. X "ir i the Sovornini jr 4 the Sjrurm-nt &-r.er* 1: Dr. Sui'icko Me ’. R-t. Dr, imrr.-nn, ;r ; th- .ray ’ic“l Dervic-: 01-rst s-rst Dr. Sci 1 ■Fr a th- \y . F r :-n In ustry, B-:: In rks D-.'-rtaunt: ■Direct,r 2ita Hwua*an Dr. Dcardts "The c nf-r-nce h th- f 11 *in r-suits: r.J r • ucti .n c nt-r is t u -r-ct- in th. C *»mr..nt G-n-r 1, : cittc- 11* t L-ri r , which is t -v-1 .> r. nti-ty.:huo v.cclno r.ccjr'infi t r„ .1 ; Beth 7h- .)£• ucti cont-r is t -r-ct- n\ -oUvU. ;• the 3ohrin .r3:s, Th- -hranefct fc-.s -e-n sk-.'., n’ h s ir.'ic tv. its -illir. r-ss, t 1 o. ?r f-ss.r ei 1 t is^-s-l f r trlnln f -raonnol, ■|U» ir> i r ;a,.-tc. Th- v-rn rs ! th- G-v-rie-nt G-n-r*l ..ill furnish saw oil in : r.-B*. Tho B-brin rks will s-.cur. the n-ciss-.ry vCd-. ert? rj. 1 ce th- require:’ r -rs f r this ith the Reich Office I r • r 1. -r ucti ah til e uili u in the sh rt-st .ssi’.'le tir- o th t its c.\-V.city • iU e t h. equivalent f th’t 4 th- -xistir, ii-rrr cht Institute (Kr-.kr.u .. -V-1 H..: is t ■- «rijnril7 t th. ills; b l ft 16 *0-0 47-;.-i C -art 1 .lc vr.ccino *.;tich is pr.sortly oir. : prcluco'- >y *;hc 3 chrin;- .rrks fr.'r: chicken o.ys, s* -.11 *;o tostcl f'r its effectiveness in n .xpcri -nt. ir r c: is purp- s« Or. sennits qill c nt*.ct 0 '>orstum- bauifuol'ror -»r. Mrirrvaky. c. I;' tMs 3chrin * -“-rkc vr.ccino is prevoi*. t' ho offoctivo the pr ’.uctl'n cr.p-city C) y olrin "fries in -:r'ur - sVr.ll ^ osson- :ir..ly incror.co'. Ho Jolrirv- rr!:c -Jill V.ross .n r./plicr.tir n Bntho v,icJ iniatry f tic Intorirr f- r r. .ri-rity cortifipr.to fer tho aocruln ; f tho require , c -ntin mfca, n l ph.ee tl o nocosscry rr .oia <rtificr.ti.. . product ir n r tfcphua vr.ccino c tlw or1 ' inatit- uCo ahr.ll u incror.sc... . ott s f'r. toatir ty hue vr.ocinu ah 11 *'o lovol^pod v) ic) '.ill n.-Jcu at tu Cm* fcr 1 prrci’jlc. Hu 'Johrin. • " r’-s :.ru sor.'ir. . ropr^aunt-fcivo tr tie 0 vorn- Ocnor 1 n 6 J.nu.rry lf-iC c t! t pr-;': rr.ti- r.e c n be initir.tod l nc'.i tuly f r tlu pr luofcl r - f t pirn v.cclnc recrrlir* • tr tl-o »1 1 tl- . Si 7i w ‘ Wi>or iris tori • Ir t ~ r in, 2b Occo : «r 19*: 1. J -i’ 1, or tl io r.fPwC’ • ur roe liocti r in zny vrr.y . ut r. • r.tton'.o". r.n tie erzu. •*. . • • - y< ur aubcr.tinntu, Schi lr, p ;-t t •• u •ut tl la '*.outin~? •. -* t tMs x.tin? .. A - s • • c:.:.-= t.il *• * tl t * t :• J1, •} • • r c -Ur. : s very r. r- 1 j» it ’/or r - V t:_! rjiyt' in in r S. ct #} _c‘. il'. 1 v, c..vri . y ir.tervcnti - r wild* rrul.'. '?.n, r.ytl i: ir pr rtlcul r * si '.c fr i th. frct tl t r.n in- 16 r~ -r -15-2-Srjxrr c in-t n . l in t'«. prc 'uctirn rf v-.eeinc v:.s t be r.ifcc .• l ore, oil, 1 »" like tr ut t t it ory 1 k- • ri. n: 6t in , p rtloul.jl; ?- rr. rr.pl 2 :r.'. tl r.fc is th t l>r. ' eky, •.?] rr.s rut C t: c : v-tin , r i- o cent etc', sc thr.t >. c uil erjry rut o:.. < ri :,nts t t»r In. tl o effectiveness rf t'r. i ;*• l!c vr.ee inc, ?r- bio rt id r.u h o lr *.y * ittoH t t: a -ri'-ur.. 1 r; .c very lrp rt -it rr. rno in rt ir; • u t*o$o in- • * ' “illonoietor, i v rno, rc.r rent .ti*., fr . • ur f ico -n‘ po'pl fr- >Ur n - r!:a r. t th~.t testa v- ul • . •• e nrb r..;?r ront.-.Mv.. fr — . ’ r : : Oil erneittor r-.s xp isoly f . n viiiT aoc- : n . ho : \t.j ! vc, *■. r. t ! *vir r r 1 c- 11 v r-t r f Ca rr-t . ‘ ' rcco ,:b.r? t t’. it c. ifi voncu, yes. . vo ao. smot: In • ”• tl r then tfco • • , tl In * 1 " ft t: ''t . • - rlivT or.trier in tl © *'in • V-. rl;* r.a 6 Jrjiu n; 1 r- l-.r.C 1 p ries trr.s \ m '.vri.-r rl-:. h 31 p^rs. nc r...-o tr•.uni=v:: , . -it! t' cl 1 ’T.cciro fr y rr inr ituto .t Or k-w; 35 p-rv ns Prccocn 0 x, Oil‘oi ulster 'On; 35 . ; rn r_tl tl , v ccir- “-hrir. * • s*rr.l ,; nr.'.o f c- rrco by the 4 .rLr * •• ur ; r tl -r p.rs ns ritl ti er Iv-hrin.:; • • :* u uxpl «r. 51 t *-y G J.inu ry h: r .ci -1 Vr.eeino 1 13 ?c*' 47 -. -S r C- urt -> . I fr r. r ur institute t CrrJtrr, th* o - vr.ccin- or *.ucof. by tlo "v.) rir. ' v rks Ji - ddl r vr.eein- r.n. ..n inf-cti n rr tori -1 frrn Herbert A-ch institute unless tl t ncutin^ bctvfion •- u, CV ntl/ lil'o: deter rn' :.ru~. v/s]~- t"k pL.ee? ... 0 t cf.n bo oxdf.irud v ry si-pl;-. -it! re t tic fold v-cclne, I cm »nly r-p«r t -nee re t’ t tfcu .oi l v-.cc^.'O wr.e • Is tribute Sr r. 1 rp_ nu b.r -f pL-.cos as n r tl - instltuto :..i: •; w s oat lisle/, in 1939; tl* t, f r o fjjplo^tfco ” in Moil- : .1 i>Oi6 f tie Y/ . tl it; tl t, in ; n, It -lar etr.tvw in tl is 1 tt-r t: t it 1 s b-on ;:rovi-uoly fur- : t v ri ua pl.-.c-s .\n r r. resile t t: < c . t it \ir.s r. ft vory 1 ffloult tr r’;t in f is oi -1 v-ccino. ••• rjvyf.in r,b ut - *oerco ^5Jr.ur 1943 o rn- ia tvpl.us? • • , ’U tf rw tl • t r.ltl ] '. Uk.. t« toll ;• u v.::* aucK I c*nri t etr.to tl“fc 1 1 --u. • • fcyp- U\z v.ccino n r nc ln ur t •( icsu,’ t: tlo v ri'ua in'.ivi Iml ’ r ncrus f tl- obrrv.cl tt ’"it rnl- t * u jCur f tlo .ohmr.clt .l< 1 “,HCg rr t' r rr In r.o/.i-.r.l ru?pl;* • frico? . I olio Vi tl t I Lr.vo ..ir ; ?rvi ual;- ntlr 1 tl. t ’lat- rf-ti n v a wit: tie -u*ic:J. Incpuctr to n tl t tonrr.la ! - > fVW - iefcrlbuticn ^iof f t: . olri: cl t ?!o*icr.l Sor- xi r* • , , in :• cu unfc 1318. 'ills . — a •• • r ill *iblo. t: * *i.rt 7 cl Institute t tl “del -inlet r f tfe 1 r. It r t 21 nu r* 19-13: .>hu r v. c- Ip r t f 31 -cc * -r 1? 2. r . r: - 1 is rv s' -os ---j . »• C vrt . - .. 1 'Bo Ciur f tl c. el rr:..c! t l.ciicc... Vrvico, .;pprc re! o *. wit! c. -- r 11 J'-nu -ry 19^3 — ctpy end'so'. -- tc tie &evom*wnt emC iniustri-l f'.cfcxc ocnai Ij . • v, O.n-.r. 1, .1 In’t y u ..lc. exorcise r c ::tr 1 ver the ;»r 1 - uc;ii.n f typlua vc.cc in- z istm luiaho.’. fr • tl o llic.6i*n rf typhus vaccine? • I f tl u Plo n uy at. ff in r or tc o i f r.V. -• ic quito p sex* Is. r..\ I cr. n« t r..y rxythin • ; *c .Vut it r.t tl o :.unt. • : :..ll tint in " cuixmt .1 , acuticn 1'it 306 - it v c ■ vo: r n *.xt: e r.c.rnir r ito.l fov r re- - r* r .r ’>y K nt t ->r. V o * it i t-* • r.ls< r. c py t< ' . : .rr Or p ft "ilie x? . i 1 y . . U . . .. r . 1 : r: .. looial n ..a t» -t 11: : r v ciiju Jiuf-.ciuri:v: pi nt c.JT.ft yet * o : -c..ur. tl I'li-f f tl w . o.'.ic. 1 Service f tie ulri.cht, wlr " t tc ecilo . ' ut the precur j f vrccinos, l...a r - t y_t „ ko . ir. tie - .tter. "c-jsn't tl: c r tl.or in’.ic to 15 ; -7-—-S -15-5-Iv riv v C ure 1 ti t r'u ! s :u. c-ntr 1 -.r j rr .ucticn cf typfcus v.-.ccinus? % Co rt I IS Fob U7-* - 16-1 - LJC- - ---. Something -Is- is involved with regard to this aocuaont. This is - r_qu_3t to establish c. new place of production and to obtain 3 largo mount of personnel end aatorfcal in order to establish n«.w production foe ill tins. I con only say wi'-h r-* rd to this, that such a r-quest has r~v_r re-chud ry hands and i aacu_>- that sore body from the luftwaffo, or perhaps rro:.ossor Rose, could iv_ you rare infe-ation 3bout it b^bauso you hate also Seen fr:. tha docu.'unt that no reply os ever received by the Chi-f of the 'ahraacht Medical S-rvic«. -e w-r« never so impolite that wo did not give any answer for ncnths to Utters which ware received. C«u can only say that this request referring to the establishment of such -n institute or th* extension of ouch an institute n-v«r reached ny hands -nd that is why I n-v-r , -v_ any reply. rtoil but the pcint is they h~d to -;.t your permission to establish now faciliti-s, didn't they? /v. It ay only b- n this case t at all now constructions and all new facilltiaa rvqcir-d the approval of the OK and that I, In :ay capacity as thj ef of the .tohr’.acht ..die?.} S.rvico, -as ;lso included, in connection with tills I want toat-.to th'-t I con'd not «ive any .-pproval of that kind becausu I did r/ t have ny funds. 1 d to sub It thorn to tho OK,, and obtain tn-ir approval. . 7. Uhat about the production facilities it Duchcnwald—they didn't start until 1Vu3 — I dcr.'t suppo o you r.now anything about tho production f vaccine th-re, do you? i. a~v .r n_ .:-d of an. vacci:.- . roduced by the -ffor.-S^? A. I We h- rd for tbu first ti-a r a typhus v ccire produced by • \j .affer.-S3 in the y.ar lyui, whoa I was vaccinated in the prison camp .3 Eibli. g with this vaccine. ... ;• u -.' or . ign ranee :f the sach-nwuld rL ntr and vaccine production ir. h. f Ce of your critical inCrJstf ith typhus probljes and year p-rsonai control ov_r allocation? * C:urt I 13 ~-b W-n - 16-2 -IJ3- L-sscp I can only explain it tc th. fact that I did not know the nas* of Buchcarrald at all, and if ary vaccina b the. affen-SS h:,d r-ached .ay hands, or if I h .d -var heard f such a vaccina of tho '.affon-S^, which is net ir.pcssitlOj. t-icn I wauli irtadiat-ly hav- brought it into connection with thu Hygi-nic Institute of the .nffen-S*. I hre nov^r entered this institute but in ary case I Jenax of its existence* Q. Hut General, in Jcnuaiy 191:3* the Re -rt Koch Institute ^cognizes an erdor fro a ycu that they ere to quit allocating vaccines tc any of th- branches of the •ohzaaaoht and have to channel '-vorythlng through you. How do you naan to toll tfco ribunal that the typhus vaccina produc¬ tion station of the -ffen-SS at Duchurtwald could do what they wanted to do ith th.ir production -- you had no control ever that and never board of it — is that right? a. I can only j ;r thfct if such cn order, because of the delivery, was issued by the Chi-f cf tho .uhr. acht -cdic .1 Service, then this- was only sent to a Certain distribution ruvi the -ffon-S° was also included in it. That probably war directed by tho Chi.f of tho Medical Service *f—£fco fan-SS, Dr. Oonzkon, bvc- 's- his isttors fere always kept voiy • anurallyj if, md how Ion this -rccinu «J produced with tho affon-SS, I etna t tall you. Perhaps Pr, Schddt cm give you r.ore information about ms with thu -iadic 1 Inspectorate. J «ysol: only - r -d It for «:e first tLv. in 1 ?Ia5, Q. uorviral, hot oosaiblo interest could the 3S h.vo in testing tv.oo ogg yoLk -.-.coines on its on initiative in Buchenwuld without your op rt a tile xry edicol Inspect r ind tho support of Conti as Socrotary f 3.ate f r Health? - k * ~ h0 SS • aintair.-d Its cwn field, .s I hv- already previously tescrlixid. The fact could r.; - hava r- nlnod hidden bare that this sector voral decusocts ‘ - f r t •.: jStabllshaeat of a wholu series of scientific - rc " institutes ar/i . wh: .e na i -r cf approvals by ag'.-nci-s for that . vs never found cut earthing about then. 1 beva repeatedly Court I 15 rab 1*7-- - '- 6 — 2 - LJ3 - ^-ussor £' -ted *- t it ws not possible f?r 30 to gain any insight into the chcr- -cwr -ad the systaa ard tfco intentions of the SS end tberefro it is not surprising that this was else the case in that field. I cannot say viat the purpose of tho S° was but I nssu-o that cm. of the reasons was Mat they wnr.tjd t. b & L-dependont and they wanted to bo independent of arynllocation throu.h hj sc that - would not be able to say "You rdll get very little now, or nothing." Tfc t is enc -xpl-n.-.tion. I cannot state anything further -_n the sublet. « *n: r SS troc$s W -"‘3 the . .. rin; eC ( >yolk vac ir.l would be in the field un* talkjc t. . about it and nobody recoivcd my ri-rs Xrot o. C urt I 15 -D k~-n - lfi-li- LJ~- - L£cS£?. -A Insofar as Buch-nrold is ccncorr.cd, I can say that I h-v,. hoard the name n-nticnad fcr the first tii - after the capitulation. __ c-.. "Eiz I have no further qixstions. TH3 F?.ESTr2'7: Any r^-dircct ersnination of this witness by defenso counsel? RS-ror,.- re.-..Tier BY DA. I^iTS: -*• r rcfos3ar J -r. hcHanuy r.as askvd ycu b^ut the. report and tho l-c;uro which Dr. Eclsloohrwr p ve at the .ting :f tho Cexulting Fhyaiciana in DtCwofc.r 1 :2. It ra one f nu croua l-ct.urco in this field. !<■ I -ant to ask you once n.ro if you know *ith certainty that you have . r this lecture by Dr. Hdsloohnar? ... .cccriin.- t thw ontira situation 1 nu t ansr„r this question ir. the a f fir ..-.tiro because th.i-cturo .f Hcl-lcehnor tack place flnongst a whole 0Jri.»8 -f l.ctj.-^c ebout fr. .win.; ar.d this rating tork place -t .a.0 a ir.t _r. it v fro;. tho 31th cT JicVwrber until the 3rd of DcceSbap, and for «. it : .3 the- * .pertant or cik of tho 3.oat important , ...r^Xoro in ny opening speech -nd .Iso in tho discussions, I n- vo ir-ct-d and or.j.:J-d to tht:.i and hw. . .rn.d the:, that they woro ° 60 •" » * in 0» course tfthe winter, that wo should again 4.1 into such a situ tl ,;,.i - r 2. ■*° r toi3 r *aon, uni buc:.u3- ?f th. ir,pcrtunco cf tho prtblaa, i consider l * certain that x hav. ttiended thj ,cturo. is --17-i-PE?- ?.in- :uck ; art . l H . Cviii: i* Is - c—n fr.j the 1 -ctur* th t uiocri&nts wore c-rri-j'. .ut -n hua-.n ’-win s? I ::rsi t rv--a ~r tr.* 1 . star* .x-.ctly -Rjnar*, ut .ihen I look t the p.;. rt then it eh -s whet I h v- -lr-- 7 r-vi usly st t , th t r*s_:rch wna .jiA'C"rri-: -ut .n nirr Is r. -r. :vnn ’_i: s, ' r. t the r,rtici->-.nts w>n * ,r* iaf vrnu'. t. - cert'in ,xtr.t th-rc c-nr.-t h v ’-..on '■ny ' u‘ t, nne ;x»rhnp® this i. s >jun a-r.ti.n. in th fdl.‘ l.ctur* th t H. 1:1 hn>r h s colloctoi'. hia ux,:cricnoo ir. etod sec uoir, -noies r.' th*.t sea t th. Atlrntic^Caast. . 'liuTsJ rv 7 u s-.y t th. I ctur* h t c nv-y th- in.'i-asi.n to th ilatervr w: . Jen... K«lzl jehner th-.t he h hio _x. -riq-nta n dl-ta ■h r. 1 lln i;.t th a-- n' ah. h '-r. turn * v-r t- hie f.r trontn-nt- at. UbHUUV: If th* Tri'jUirl 1 * t , I f.'t think it is noas-ry t> 1 -.-. th- nitrvaa jit th t uch. i. 1 , h* tak* th- witix-aa .iruct question •v.v. hia nn enepwr *...ic:. I think u a un erst r - . . f ur, n I think ti la quit* 1 . r p-r f -r Id . th-r. t r.ot t- the :-ttr th ur y he has • .iv it n' . ut >1 r a In th uth .t this vitn-as th t hu ’i 'n't utter. DE. . 1 X 12 : i:~.y it lur.sa th Tri un l, I h th* 1 *. r.uaJ.n th-t in tft. c.urse f th- ir.Urr ti n iy i;r. JicKn-y th -1 this r 'l*.-i h n t boon -X’l.ir- na cl. irly a I n.ul like t h v* .t cl rili* 1 r th. un .erst n in,*. t th. tri jut.-.I — RSSXD2 C uns*l, th. 7n‘un 1 overrules th- n. I a . 1.7 -r c .. ilr. ; a oh 'in y u rt 1 th- t.-atie r," 1 ho f raer ■Jen.r 1. .rat a-rat id . v, which th- 1 ttr v* ir. th- c ura* S th* 2-ilch • trl 1. I • r. t h v f Sts r J Rt ti r. wr th* rc.r’ of th teatia ny. «a ir .a I c r. r . r Oen-r 1 ratr S rt .. th-t 7 u h • .*n hie ou *ri r uh.n h. ..-a ... ic 1 inc- *c: r f th Lttftwiffo; th~t . In the •«ro. : 1912 >r the : rvi • r- -1 ti -n hcc«; <».•' lot':, ir. c rjwcti . -it!; it, is th* n r’ "su.xjrior" • .-.fine ith r* r t th* Chief f th* '...hr-- ckt U* ic 1 S*rvic? .. r : - r.« • In th* Uag V u ur Chi-f it th* wehra - : 1 Survico nn 18 »c' . 47 -«-17-2-?'3- Hir.- icl: v -art . 1 n’r.-n Hi; >kc w.s Ohi-f I *-h- H-lc 1 C~rvicc i th. Luftwaffe, was there any c-.ue. - ■ 'w-Je.r. the ia'r- asi.n with Dr. Hi' kv th't ho i.ns y ur su’ .r .irate? ... , a I ‘ -ii-v- th t if Hi.>yfc. h' be-n &k- t the tine, r if s.a-b.'y h t. L'. nla th t I . a his su .ri r, then ho a il‘ h v- refute.: this 1 -u^ly n* cl- rly. . pr o :-n : -• - ■ 1490 — tty it >1.* o- the jribm'.l, I r. - ka *.h eX-.ct ..v.r i r.a-.'r-r. It is • Utter which the Jhiof f th. scy .rrcta-nt n Riiof J th- R-s-rv. ,.r.jy r Uress.* t3 Rg£ch Harahr-l *U«ri . It -.is k u-e.. r. f y ur -ntry int the c incil af th* i-ich .use rch Council, r. the su >ati r. t ait Dr. Schrvibcr int th- ..eich tUiSw-.rch - u. oil. _ • it -I th- Tri' un 1, t.is cuacnt .0-1490 is exhibit 45-. • . .U-r-8 t the f r.—r Obvrotr .a-ret Dr. ochr.i')-r h‘ ‘ in c-rt In wt; —r. :r.- li is.n officer f th- rt r.ay U* *ic 1 Inn.'ect r u t th- Uich ..oB~-rc:. - .'incil r. trr.t h- h b.r. cu oetw by ♦ y u f.r this . eitin; is that c rr-ct? «. ..t this ti I c re; t .* ctly -scri * the inci -nt • ay- r*. a it courr-! -t U. t M -. In ny c a*. t- :a wr.s in cc r nc- with wloh f the J :t r.-r-in-Shi-f f th- .Us rv- «.-ay, th t th- Lekrancht oh ul 'o r- T-Sente i:. lhif .. ... h-t I :.t t kaw is, e: tb. xs.qu.rto which ' r- e .-.fin- in the r : -- r 19 :. i M\ • la tf* V V er. Kelt*: :.r. . r si t, this ie ah in by th-- letter f 21 Oct -r 1942 which w-5 1 a zxfleOt * • ., ;- m. v-r, h's n t . In the lytt r 1 th. 1 : 1 .: r th- Guwrni Ivhrrr.cht Cffic. t Tr i.ss r a r. 1 a-r, f 21 Oct -r 1942, : II »ir. * is at* t- :, -i; 2 qu t. fi - nt-y-i "T\. .i^icr. rah 1 t 1 ... ... is •.. r T- “ f irti.-.r -xt.nsi n ... Uicb e» r 11". At -I a ski:. u — Dr. S^hr-i -r, »h3, ; - kn wr. v. ^ th- U .^issi n-r f th r-ich ?.-s- rch C ur.cil f r the ? . .«nr f 1 a- 3 , . - . ra -t - ? ;• u ft-r tr ie is- r v* 1? ... . , i re.. . ntan uaiy r. inf ra- a- th t ti- Ifer - .r. r. r -3=3?- 0 1? 3tf: jourt 1 :r. "C HSIJ3?: If tho ^tribunal plor.so, i don't think this is tho propor i=a to rrguo tho intorprot-tion of loeuDosfcs, tat i just *nt to st-to that the -xcorpt frau tho letter hich has Just boon road t; Dr. IJolto cortainly -cnatitatoo as ro Joe tic:. on t:.o pert of tho Roich 2osoarck Council to tho iiilnatloa of Sckroih.r by tho Ar-V Helical las ootr-.to. ?.o lottor which I road co.-.cor.-; itsolf o.yy i .h .ha aypoi ; .one of Hacdloaor. It is r ^rccnal lottor to Hanllosar stating that ho hits aot t.or. appoint©! tc tho prooldlsQ, council of tho so&j-rch council -.3 ho wntod o 0, and that's -.11 it 3tya. It rs-Jcoo ao poforoaoc t. Gchro’ or -.-s' it can't to torturod-ta tho c ii.-y that Sehroibor and the other rocccaonlatlocs ..-.do by Trooha uoro turned dona by Gearin'. -r. Ur* Proeldont, 1 bollovo th-t 1 • roo ant it.. :: r . KoHn that I car. lonv- tho int-rfrotation and judging of thio lottor to you. it is ol--tly - osplicltlv f t the Roic . !>rshr.l fiuvla'tentnUy dio-^provoi furthor e.tonal n :? the R.'.el. Hjcsarol. C vr.oil. - Tltnooa, t: hr.& aakol you t\. f& quostioa; is sjot the coil-cti :: .f -at-rlal .or re;:--.rch pur? ooi a task which -c ccanon to all braaceo: h . ho .• ao 7 ; . tho doaroo of 19*2, poreonnol »ad : c c. :. ,~-ii. ...ti.:., , -..-i -sxno* nakia you, lid this ^rrc.xol a:— ur.t orinl r.j.'l;-:—r.t of oeorii.-.ti e:. aloe ref or tc tho aoiio-J. ffleers which w rs bo aoaip.;ei roe.arch jobs? A : at is aot g? ocific ally -u>::tionoi as any pl-.co there hao n-vor cor. • " >ooial Jincuaalai a that ou'-jjct, - I uaat to a-, y. if, as Chief of tho Wrr.-.cht Nodical Sorvloo, ♦ • roso-^oh, « old r oa -oit; Chief .of th i/ohzwaoht ^ : sSic-l .:er-lco ;• •: s'- rule hava lad a io -xtiout ilk- with tho Vohmacht biic-1 l-.£ act r? Di’ v-u Have - >cl a Ce—rtr.ut, for :^lo:;co - - iNrasoarch? k ", 1 had - man th.ro t k c-; - :. ileal, aciontific r.d fT . : - . ataravor to do With rch. - ■ - yw. Aftor hmcj lid •/u ava nay fueds all;tt-d i*=s roso-rch? • • r-'fft 1 a : ndthiag -r thtt kind cnao : . fund; —.11-. r r r~r ci rll, but th- n *-.a f’s t i- teRr-elfaa tJso usr,cht. q star f Dr. Gatfeirtt rod Tiachor : ; -rcoucitl _ :r-._ .V t>i tl- 7-11 . — I b_ ; ur p-a-len — you l.-vo atf.tid ir- oca.icti vie, nil - :j - rl-j •' -ttended ill not cljcct s: *oi?le-.lly t. tin at :.—ol -.«o .. Ir f.na r r^bk-rdt r.ad 3r. yiachor, r.fc lo-.r. noth! . r - violin *> -t thr.t aubjoct. hv- - t .o' i- c-v la sovaml vn;- s, o*t lor •j u ir.z,t it, tkoao s' did .. t c-.ao cposilio i.-toroat, .? v t:.w >r.:-cj ;:.4 nz .t-.wl, t : rtll t j .*rao:^ .: proaont did : •. Jjet t: than ao taa;- rlrj-dy *»captod tfcftt f’C't “-a ar.turrCL; - ... 1 : ..ic-i oxporlaan a. • , i “.akin; a M .Ml .i„ q.jtMia; is f-.oro :. it yot “.nittor 5 aci Uity wkieh ?:. •;. ;-.ur r.oiu -1 n'-untor-jnti n -ad your ;'-.lluro t Vo «*sr -.c?i •? -JICX^- Court I 15 jb U7-» - 13-1- J3 - Putty .oil, this could only bo in y cun person. That I did not under¬ stand in that way. <• ..ell, net only you but else the others. I new want to ask you In tho fcrailstjcn of the iocturo r Went Proftaaor Gobhnrdt stated, could thuvo ..anythin, contain-d :.r. it as f-r na tho ntnn-r f tho .xtcutlen - ccnc_m.i, which vight sh.v. th .t y..u xid the otaurs — a. Th-1 is What ■ h to roj oatodly s. :t%.d h-r.., th .t in qy opinion th. f r.ulr.ticn end tho desertptlon and th. explanations w.r. preaonted N in such a .n.r tn t n< r ioons I r cbj.cticns .xiatod. 4. ih-rof ro, there *.a tho third pcasibility that son,thins 'which i.;>t hx ol' -rt-d fra. th. rd.nr.ry -Jght have been ;ru8ontod, but t at the ann.r in ••'ii<'h it •-.a -r-Sor.tjd conv-yod the ir.pr.ssicn with tno Uatoxtora th .t thia wsa n t 'ra, . r. a. r.. .t ia qui ; r.oai \», -a. Th- rv-.sec t.r -S r. • suntioiud h .ct riol.-rtc.l wirf.aro onco ncro, end ho has r . : n tfcich te-. alao tavaanted ta Professor t, • to Btato r no- ivoly tho r.i.raca to P-cv.wr.t 133? which in itaolf r a not pr-sont-d tlcn n .i quoation he* i rcUouin* santcaoo la - interpreted, Cn pea 1 t file rk r - jO, r.i : Tttutot "Tho ..uhroecht by r.quost T jon.rel Field --irahal .1 lc n.t t xticipat- in r.tpcnsibl. -,ur..r in the jr erir.onts o .c .'ioj oxperinonta w:uid also be cerr'.d out on hu-.an bo in s. !l r os this r r-ul-.ti. a at el that an o-d.r r i8 issued in that r cticn by u lt.1T ho. j •%. - i.-. did . 11 - _ -• :rk? ... . his ncr t - OUxtoL it.r rped-list? -- Ib tVi r.t o. xt .r.t . , bo h cto to co -ith tho 'fcdical Inspectorate? ... aJ medical TXic.r, bo* firat cf all, belonged t: the icdical Court I 15 Feb J»7-A - 15-2 - LJj - Putty Inspectorate organisationally, and then h- was a good g-r.-ral hygienist, a. s tha h-od r an investigatiiv; ffico in S.mny, and he -as net fully occupied tr.orc, and h- was also occupied with ether patters. t. I only want to dotag^dn; hare who was his superior with regards to tho work. •v. That was .. ..'.pen s Gflico tco ..r ar-nt Office 9. 3. In the crcac-exarinati-n th- D cu--i.t I.T-1'J has b--r. hetMod to you. It was not paresontod t you, but it wan used os blsife for your : rat r a jctioood the na* of rfcf.sser ..!rth, and h. nna sv.t-d Uir.t Dr. .Irth bed su: .. t- d th t -/p iaer-os should be onrriod out on c:ncontration cae? in.- t .3 t Neuen-pusaen, that you rust h.vc had Jennie 0 e f th-... 1 would liku U r-’ l y-u tr. r.unt.nc. wi*ich has glvon the reason for this c,u-sti.n ir. D;cu «t lf ;s tl&rd s-ri-t f -xperinenta was dis¬ cussed with the r-pr-cont-etivo f the "l-st" gr.ui according t' the sug¬ gestion which (Wsterst Dr. n the cession f ti-.o discussion with tii- fleloh Ccaalssloher n tha Uth Ducvter, 1-eu." This is a sontonco suitable t ivo c. urs- t til* corie.’.uc ;n th 1 irth slid that this • ; oriental s,ri.s o', old be ctxriad ut uf-oucn;i-rrva cr nt any other c c-ntr ti.r. c _ a. .• , he dij n t c z' th t with ary oth.r r .rd, s. ‘'.urvfure, it is nly a conclusion fren tho --..sur-s vtoich Pr-si.’-nt Konrich drew fr . the ciscusai n ,n th- feurth f -ectnber, a til 1 /• . i.TSi :i--y it ploato tho Tr -er.-l, * shill have tho frefsssor, lhVit, d id * - tr s-cuticn r*-s t kn. r- ifc.ut the afliduvit, then ho cii : - .-*43 45l a -5 i 'Itn-su .t or,- tire. .. « th* typhus question -.* hi-- st d than. 4. .as c y lk vaccin- »?r.viy pr.ducod at tout ti*w? ... -. 3 . 4. Bor if u i v« olf-ctir - ccln a In v ri us typos, will it bo wron* t discuss to- r.r. rch ... r tc- V. . twin? instead «£ li-rtin. tl a t the rr ucti r. .f r ecir..n? A. it is o iTOct ith - . . f th3 t.vigl /accine r.-lch -as o;.c-i ant, t. v - re ucti n c ulu n.t bu raised v-r a curtain aarunt, and with the - y~.»>. vaccine *o hu4 difficulty in cb- t-.inii the e- • s : tcause *ve v v *uld havj needed hundreds i th-.usands if ... ...r. Idy . 1 tc 1 ' k fra setting which ctuld bu produced a -wily. i* s ia ~jy fr tcv. ir .at pr.bKn f tryir. t raise th^ “ f vaccines? C urt I 13 X\2» L7-a. l6-o- LX - Putty — that Is to- s tilin'. ... I -maa that tocdocn.--nts which the Prcs.cution has presented ive s*-. -d in toe ccerso .f ry cir-ct . In-.ticni “I hid t -%rr. th, pcaplo ith xj Ih 3 to tell then th.t I c.uld n t furnish tv rxy vaccina fTor. Cracow." ... is stated there. ent tin n those c.cu”A, that is, if y:u r-copnize the . _r c’-'Jly, t...r. y u Bust przduco a ro and % then y u intend t ' fchrnh the it. cstry. I, therefore, in toaso docunjr.ta *hich 2uvo >o-n s«l ttad aid toich I assuvw y u confirm completely — A. 4 -s, - — "* :« •'-< racxnizu .os carrot ted ay, that I have to :-i : 7 tho qu.flti.Tj3 n -i y ur v cry uni yrur urging f .r an inc o.oao in tho p.'tfaction f vaccine, -a tus :v,an to- n cwssity f toe kncwl- od a hew c-v.ril ;• tefirid-inl poi-ntist* actually eccupiud thwnaolvco in s.Ivin t.Js r Is.? ... *t -a n thin: * with -ach vto_r. • • • ■’ -' f • -a y .r \ ; r uv’ ils fror. tow ti cunont about tv- 'iocuso 1.n / 2 "-c. b-.r 1 :,1 x. t n this diy thu typhus research pr blwc tos discussed? » . t 2 b the vaccina situation. • 1 " -•'-« ciai i ' to t . s.c'nd c j'.r-nCw to k piftCO r. t;- 2 to 1 !>.cc b-r, , in .-.icfc 7 u did n.t incuse anything Tfith te - cjrc -- f tno pe.pl- oanti-:n-"4 in tow bin 5 diary? ... . s, i n vu at ukI th.t c.torlj*. : • . quosti ns. - it » ■ . c .. 2 “SITS 7 : -ributv 1 has :• c-i*.--d _ c„rtific.a. fr r. Captain • * i ini^r. It ul. b- advisable tl; ■ the D-fonaaA, duaelf r--.net, be urin i... b : .no. f this aft.rnz.n. }1Z~ 14 Feb U7-~ - 15-5 - LJl - Putty Defendant Rudolf Bramt sill, ther-fere, be -reused frea attendance in Court for tho balance f this nftomaon. The Secrctajy-Gcn-ral will file the certificate rcc-iv-c fr:.a Dr. Sus3ell. The Tribunal will now bo in recess f r .few ninutes. (A recess woa taken.) 16 Fc'J If 3r r. t h :. v rJ.lv. : M-.eolf f S - Dr:cuco r.ntcl ;.L cJh* is r^Jaunt f(*r tl I.P «if . 3EE PRESIDE 7: H.o Sooxv t.ary 3oiu?..l vill n to- fr r tl o rvc r'. tlvo ounce tU lufun ijit -u 6 Rrsnv'.t purei r.t c, . n oxcuau. Oic n .uit . r. .1 sop V a \%juix .“cu;c *. .a .. wi . " 11 trill au.t:cn tic t itroae , • ul u.iv'I.r, r. cf tl o lofon:\- A .^t . n 1 acr. , as, t» E ST3RIK0: *l-c wltnuaa will ».icg Us rt 5 t hnU n' ’.o mvnra, r«.,Je tin • ..rs*r • o : 1 cwu r 'v Oil, ul ililtb;- 0 .rci-nt, ’-1 t I ri 1 a >oi k tho .jure cruttl -n vl. 1 rritll i ' n ( * 1.0 WitnoPO rep t^ . ti e t: .) Je>-2 iEBRl G: Y* u . y e . ... jlLZC? ~C ’JP.WX0. 3Y UR. 'I'.Li .. »'ltnoaa, tn ul j ... ?..Ul I’UoPl'leP • 1 1? n. c :urt I 18 ?«b U7-.v- 21-1- LJ3 - Karr.-w h. In particular I v._-t t. s!< you iai.it thj p sitlon .f tho Chief of tho .ichr -cht Radical S-rvic* was and he?, the w.rk and activity was carried - - .ncy frea the year i 1 .2 until the end -f tho war. I have shewn you the decrees f 2Tt July 19U2 and th. dcc:cc f 191&, together with the official'rogulati n, in r - sk j u t refresh j ur ry. •%t first I should lik* y u tc uvrror tho qjeati.n, r. tfta basis of the :oereo of 28 .oi.est 19h2, d. y u 'on h ~ this cocret cv-o ab cut or.3 I roan this dce.ee f l?h2? a* Tho creation of th* jctrj t ..or. acht ^.d'c .] S.rvicc, as caused by the difficulti r. f tho sir.t r f 1 fcl end 1 l&, •. • , . ,2, there woro ur or.t c'o anti fr tho «r y uhich wont tc the Savy and ..ir Forces in or ,r to bt'in .nodical officers. *.ro .-.-inly c ncorr.od with wp-rt Ad wel i-s in winter. «• n cw wso this CS'ISO .f tho cr ati r. oxpr.fCvd in the cLcroo? “• - basic t u ht in tho decree vus t u.. th; .viilablo personnel •>rd ant.orinl and us tr. ; in a lamed fashion. l.-.at is, at pl;cos whoro they were ^st ur -.ntiy r_* oirod. tdict is called, , 'th : : • rsnnel C - rdi nation"? “• *ea, that is ri ht. • .rs *nol that, for instance, was at cno ujhirvcht branch tsc.s to ho tt-incf. it,' to •, th; r ...hr-, cht branch which JK' dod tnt -1 r; re urgently. r.i Chief f tho -'htvneht ’{oriicnl S.rvic.? "• a !1 to. necic-J. tisles which occurred rf-.ult no •usly with all 4-hrnacht. bronchos w_ro t- b. r r!;:d u:.n by ,r.j control --ency and this "-o in rdor tc s-.tc p-rsoonel. '*• n-L'. " ci c :: speak f mutual r " c acurnia-.. tne entire ar-.i • rc.s? : r instance, affairs f F by i c-_ rhich cccurroc i'.- rr und ar_.ps _ni nrry :r ps .and T_r - r:i ~ 3 ~o in both cases? *• * Cr Active casur^c, -.1 ria prophylaxis, rr;tcctivo vaccinations Court I 18 Feb U7-k -21-2 - LJj - Xarrcw againat tho various epidemics od, finally, xclc:l cduc Hctt do y-u understand tho dccr__ f 15^2, bearing in oind the point cf view the cr.cti-n f t new c.-.rcy? .-> c it an .avency which, it tho noaont cf its cri-d nation, had a vory definite sphare f effectiveness? That is tc 3ry, alnsst nutcr-. tic ally c _-c under ths authority of the chief cf tho a- arc?? that wasn't to- c so at cl?. •- a, re concerned with Hvj quostion tc build up this a-oncy and only r r .'.I;-- • ._! • ith t.j task after tho oth-r. x Did the chief i this a^ncy hav* a spec! fchorlty which, in the isLlitary raj*, ru can deal note as an authority to issue ccomnds? a. Ho, ha hod no cilitaxy authority t. is n. In oho official rc .ulnti n, slich is not availafcl her., It » s .a-pr-ssud that he had the rlght f directives? *• The difforonco is that a nu/ori r naturally has auth rity to issu- r ers. But y u c r. r. / Jc : to® rl nt . ;ivin ,*i r^ctl vos nh .re thoro is not a rdfitixshi? f su, ri r an:: subcrc'inato and, them- i re, r. mth rlty tc is-uo c . - 31 ^ 5 - 13 r-. • 7-..-S -22-1-“ esu r C rt Be. 1 r . m -ill u pi r.eo it clc r t• tl . :-i 1 . -Y; un 1 1 w this r:.s fcx-rclso.; r. . r ticoi t:I _c* or.. 1 S3 - *■: ±-f f the i'.olicr.l Service t' r I.- t: - pr M- r ’• icl J . ? It w:-.r vr tr.sk c o it el-..r - j*. -1 f rccs *r id es vl t- % jy u r c r.-ccsa- ry . ' oj l. . t * o c i.vincu' a’, wen rvur y tlat tloy c «1Z c per ;o r. S’ - c *•! r. ~ ' o :V tv. *'y '.ircvc- cirr.a n. c rforoncos. r .. Mew, if sue! ta*k c ul n ' -.it ricn’.ly , v ; c u: ' . x ? A., r nd on nrt w t ir, ;i -r. ~r rr r ' rr.r.ch o? - . v ir c n ‘>o v r ■ i-s t-n lone ice rl*ick i- I r o f * .. 'fl u . ttitul-a t v re u: crat i ! V/ trlrin kit. o iri-" t, r . r. tv.il, . nri-r- f - r . -«• r ;• c rtr rt t- ti e ton'ency p • ‘ pcnchus •• : ri • tr, Ml: • : to 1 v : : . t - • t % i with • • 2 , -net ns i t fr ; t". - eifc- . • I crul • rol to T* r i Cii r _hi' *:.ckt I . • . •• ; N ; . : : - • - ' ' r t! -ir 18 IV. 47-..-S -22-2-Lcss-r c urt y . 1 c p.rr.61m up t-' tl o present zz. •_ r. . ..11 V.ic: 1 rfficus 6 eoitinuu working* lr. v . t» : . 1 ? t!« w .o - i'i-rs. fcurir. 61 c ur:_ f J r.u ry x 1 t.fc fit: uprono Cc::*- txi'.vr >t tl u 8 vy pr tcstin*, in p liic n r s, tl: t ti c Chief cf si. * clr:-.c!t -o’.ic 1 1-r c u a 1 . s! rl. *. 1 ir vy rio'ici.l rff- ic^.ra x wialV. thou .. • na' y r. ..1 tv:.: tl u rolc.tiincl.ip t; tlx, T. ffon-SS, tl.-.t is, tl o i..lic;.l s-rvico if tl o itff or.-SS? A. Just li ;tlo .c tlo tl* r .Vi xv. clt 'r .nc:,?; tho Cl iof r.f tl o Toll-.clt nolle 1 service w s tl u aup-rix ‘1* t! o :ffon-S£. _ • oroV. wit; tlo entire ..S', n-CG. Wo wero r.lwpyae concern*.vitl tl .c« * r.r.cKe tile! vwi-«s c u.ittc-’. wittl tic -1 r.v .cl t, tl t is t< fi •: t.:r fr nt tr ps. r. SI rtly, 1 v v ul y'» os ri c .V .vl tl cl ip < f t: o Cl iof tf 61‘v. ..ohrui.cl t ’Vlicr.l Corvi-.o ; -! iofc ft!,- c lie: 1 Sorvicoa »f * reus r-rnnbi-oa? Iry'te ioflno it. ... On tl . at rc\ -tl r T ocro. , ;hu Cl lof f tl Tohpn.-.cht ‘c .lc 1 Services v c olov-to,. ..’.-rvo ;1 o t..r -1 i>.fr »T 61 o "oC- . 1 r rvi- r - f tho jr.tlsi 3 r r.c! lo 1 t< -op: sc it tl . in fr r.t cf tl o civil- ; - • • . • ■ - tl r. ru, 1 , is. tU 6: si: 6 c rlin.-.t li ;.vtu .1 pr ' lo:;s cad . - r tl,.e t..sic l.o t’. j ri.-lt t -ivan," irtictiv-s. \ On tl, s run t: cf or f 1C .1 •• .3 tlo rcoor. r- atm in tho -!r..c’.t : T : r. tlo ffon-Si 6't'cho.l upr n? - A. K< . . - ■ -* • . . . eictc. V ntr.l cl ifif : , 1 • , r.v pi r: .cist * f . . ; , : r r r iatr- ticn cl-rl: . : Ter t~pi£ts. '32-o-~. sscr ie rob : CcurC 1T< a c-* w Di*. fcbo Cl I of if CI-^ obrnccbt Sorvicoo h-.vo uiy •jo.-jib in erlcr to c^crcir r- -crcl ::’r!:? ... “e. -c b. nr i.o .ns tif.tov. r. c crul- n't oxpuiu*. r.nytbin;; rn tb t. • ", '.e tbo Cliof -f tLo cb.xvr.cbt --o'.ici.l Services, this Prcf- 0 3 2 ' r *v.n lcsc-P, in !ia prsitim r.s C] i.,f ; f tbo •clrv.cl't oC.- icc.l S.-rvico2, in r.n iflucnti.1 :r.'. atr' n .ys. ti-n? . . . s cnly . • id v \ tr ovol poll, . :• i: _ ; z'.y : bl n’ tl o influonco x $id Prrfoaaor in>s.r nc ’/u'C b-.I? Ho inflv.onco errelate* ir. 1 a p r ti r. r.r .r.-.y "otUc. 1 In¬ spect r , t! •, r n ct ol r. .cb.t v r neb. ", ^ ycu n w ».-l- t: r, in 12 .r., r. 'lei 1 r. i'ir.tl n w.a r.tc tb^j *cr«v? ... Yea, tl-t.ro w.a rfficir.l « julr ti r, ' ut It is net r.ttr.oh- J c* l i.ro. . you, d r tur tic. cffloir.l ro u: iti net , ’ wrfco?. in thr.t iffico, writ 2^1 perl ut it. Host *f Ml wo .n inter etui in tl qv.otl r. rtf ivr rcb •' icb I icntlonoft *>of ro. In tl t rfflclr.1 re vl-.ti . -nti n rr.lc cf r 4 -rci, roa crcl r - : :* - rd It! ro r* tc tfco "obr- r.:.cl t •-r.'.ncbep? ... In tl is ffio - , : * ■ th.ru wna nr auc! rv nti n * ac »e V. la 7 lnt tr.s cnly nont- i'ns,' in tic jivt ' .cJ.-.i t.-iu ti n. . b. n •• . . y a. Ho r i* id . • t - - : v rl -Vt i i: r. cticn After tl. ifici 1 r- pii-ti^n -f il : : 2 ? r. • v,.r ccrri *. IS F-* - 7-.. -r -22—i— ss.r C urt He . 1 A. Ye 3 1 .uri. 19 -. 5 . 1 -u fcU C. .. v f ,* SI.a ohrst c! t I'-odic 1 £orvice 3 o ai cffici 1 trip t’ I- ly .sx , cc«r',in* t< r.y 1 U'JO, i-‘.sp>-C5-1 inst 11 r ; -r 5 n . . rco. It ly w..e c!r..c>i -istrie5, •- ^upro: u C. m w. c .’oil— c! t C 47: xn'-tir, m' -1 c j.'lc 1 fic-r i:. cl r «, in cc r - nee. vitl t* fc, 1 *. /. r: cl t fincti ns. H c 12 t er.y : . v.e c - r ^ . . Yu a, r. ti.«. vory : . Di. ?r fu S' r » n .1 r r 6 n - -l • r; c«C *n inetittt o f f tt e o!-n melt t Hr: .r.c>-r" a. He, ..cc ;• In t *1 1 "C, n . . ;«.a f ttc X n-Si ci lottlbh sitl r-c-..rol f f- r is : t*. . .• -io. -ne .tutu f r foasrr llru . - v.s!:y? ... I I-:-. \ w r ti - il) 6 5 i fcU t rr . .f. or.-CI. . *1’. ; u .r. ny ci. U t; tut- f r illt:.ry Eciunco :xi tco-rcl^, v • tl in u .-toior-r'ie? » it, T nnv. v 1 r t * * n “ * * % - . •• r ”ru •rrrel"’? n .. I rxj f r : ? ly iorv. K. t< \tt-r 1 *. p r5c • f 1 it: qv ti J.r f tr- r p . , ' ' lj : us r.c. rcl. , v Yu '.iccrrs- ••j'.l hi;.? ... I • t s..y cl. t. . -i ; In * -r, Di-a ■? . It is n:-n t: b ic lion . .u, - 3113 - 1' FtAni^*^^BJG-^1-Klnebuck n art 1-. 1 Q I cs sur > th-.t ycu repeatedly spoke tc Professor Handlescr. During such conversations, bo they official cr private conversations, was ft any tiae the ncao cf 3ucken«&14 ccnticnod? A It ns never stationed during say such conversation cr conversations. \ i Vero ycu *t rny tire in r concentration cie?? ... E.fcro the cc-pitula&cr. never; only r.ft.r tho capitulation, as an inssto. 1 Dc you fcn:n the aicr.cy cf the i.eich Hcsccrch Council? .. Y.s, I knew c that but : t'tc.kncv any details about it. Q Ycur .agency chief cf tho i.ohrsr.cht U-dical S rviceo, did they have nn X ffici-1 contact with the Reich r.esw*rch Council? /. So, •- hr', n; official cent:-?. Cn tho contrary the Chief, l.ehrnacht .{'.ileal Services, was cl the opinion that he .act-oily should heve '.denied tc . -oh Boa :i! Just ■ the civil! r bclcn£od to it, but th< offer*.® ho .e cn thtt score vore reject. . D. ycu fcn-w Canur nitre! Dr. Schrcib.r? .. Yco, I knew hi-.. " ’.hat position did ho hr! '.? .. Ho, -t that tint, wes dcparttcntal chi _f in the ny 1 -die’ 1 Inapoct- :-t., :ct-.rto.ent i. r oci-nco rat res. rch guidance. ..ft.r that he boc-Jic - .. odor cf •-iuc'.ti.r.-l r up ; nit hi . bho iliury Ufldloal ..ca-i-.y, *nd r.xinr.tcly at tho sacc ti w ho v: a plcnipctcnti rry cf the hoi eh Research C.unc'.i for the coo-t cf cpi'tscics. . ;:leni; ctor.ti-r;- f the Reich I.osoarch Council for the ccaV.t cf i .-vie.*, t-s h. subordinated tc Frcf.sscr Kanulroor? .. Sc, n hr : oorresacndooce with hin under hi* cm lottorhoad and us.nl '•is c*ri rintoi oovelcpes. ; Ti.vi -i.ncy ;hi.f, Am-cht -leal Service?, lid this - vney roe civ*) rta on r-sv.rch n:rtc and assi-Trs-nts? - , . ■ i y - n whether this v ? the cast ever since the be.ainnin'*; th^t ? I'o., r r a other that only erne int_ effect later? 3111- -OJG-23-2-: ttnRhu ck .V, . k ..cccrdin- tc ny reccllccticn -his case into effect - little Inter. I icr.'t r- o=l-or rrc definite subject, tut I think star-tine froa 1%3 this ary fc'Vu cl :.e intc -ffcct. r . IhTt it as ycur position r-s chief cf staff cf the l.chrnocht Nodical Service? % In the eld cfficid retail: ticn it wes lcid down thr-t I had to represent the chief :f the chmecht ^odicel Services. Q That is to scy, you were the representative. h.uld you *leusc describe the practical ccurso cf ic?lin with natters within ycur -’tncy; acil thet ra?y hr.V- arrived which y:u had tc distriluto end which then :>ont tc Professor Hfuilcsor? .. She. roil was delivered tc th j re. istretien office. The ordinary anil w.i cpjtai there -nl r -istero.. Sccr.t tturs, t.; secret nrtt.ro, i.-ero mod by Ihen the anil ues diotrituted tc the various -x rts. Fort .r then r .re nerfc-d u. . by cur little stiff and the ether pert •ire w.rkcd upon by the experts cn the rrr.S. fcrcos bronchos. Then, whonover § It was n.ccoarry iiscuaoi.ns woro hold about these letters end everythin • ms prep-red t. re. th t the 1 ertent aattera cr.ne tc the sijnr.turc cf the chief :f th-. chraacht de licrl Services. Q I 'a lotstod in atobUahlng l "° following thing. th-novor anil cv* t. ytu -nd to the 1 .pr.-ta-nt-l chi-fa, rh-t nrs actually preoente 1 tc the cl.i-f f th- uhrr-rcht foiled Sc:-/ices cf that a-il end who decided vrtr.t wr.a ‘ tc pr.seated tc h-i? .. li'turrliy only the ~ct import-at thin s could tc nroaentui tc tho chi.f cf .cnrciacht .l.licrl S r*.i = ;r, '.a the .---rta.nt 1 chi.fc hr.l the took t. .erst pr.scnt the in,:rttnt c.*tors t: n’ th.~n I in tern .cciiod wh't , Ken *. “3 the situ ti.-r. :hx Fr'-racr Handles.r was net in B rlin, hut ' • a!. Te cutsiie? .. if there Were ur «nt r. tters I .vric a telcph.nic r rt tc hiic cr he -• up and cc.-rissi-nd se tc M with important tasks. User. : - dly courier \i_-ir *vck and forth 2 . th't th’- ia:ort,mt letters c ul 1 1 s • rutry-..-OJG-23-3-ninibuck i urt i te 5c.1t cut cni cent brek. Loss isportent setters, bee vor, ^er« kept in Berlin u tc the tin- cf his prcs-r.ee, were prep-red sr th.it ho could then .-'ice i % ! cisi n ‘ si-n his nine. The s;-celled cu r«nt cutters r.erc- dealt with in the Lnay helical Inspectorate or in cur little stff -n' wore then signed by at *.7 order.- • i.ra Professor Hrr.Ucscr frequently ir, Berlin? .. No, he aoetly st-yoi ct tho hor-lqucrters. Only occasionally did ho cc.;_ tc ?.rlin for just r tea :rya. 4 ' itn-st, I su’rnittvJ tc ycu the affidavit cf Frcf.aaor H.indicaur which X he auhedttod tc th; Tri-unci rbcut the werkir./; 'ctivity md the sphere cf the terk in the l-vicrahip .f the ..my rr* chrnncht, rnd I raked ycu tc rend tho vrt which referred tc th-- ’.tahxsaeht Medical Servicer. 1 ok- y tc invosti- te it. £, «a n:t to lest ayadf in tee jre-t devil a, 1 should like to :sk ycu whether y u can s*y under y-ur erth that th- description of Yrcfoaaer Hand¬ le «-r vhich ref-ra U. the r .cecy cf the chief «i ohmncht Hedic.il S«.rvictn in true in' correct? .. 1 hove reel the stftencnta »ith r«. t c re, end I cm only confirm th.xu Q D. ; u t: nk th-t th- .raters which rr. subject cf this trial, matters i.Uch ycu kn w -cc riiny u their contents, nro iapertmt waters if th-y h- ,ci-' tv . su J ct cf • re,: rt cr my letter which c- .-o into your agency? i. Yus, r.c '.u* t. .honever ny experiments ner- cr.i-rod and whenever any ecurr n it would bev n ainantly important affair. ; Ceui: y.u sry rith cert:inty ‘hit such e r-r rt, such letters, never “v.-e ; resented? .. It w's neV-.r : r- -Mated tc ao. 3 Did ycu pcrh'ps rocoivo knrwlod/c th-t i cert-in art ter wr.a scu.tines -it with by dreunv cation cf ycur p^rsen end reported iaac liatuly tc Pr. *■•••• 1 t-r? .. ..' , th't n-v r era. t: ay fcn.iludce, end if th't hie happened, then I thinr » Z siciliy you w-.uld have tc knew -bout declaims, rcjxrts and letter -3116- IE ?C rurrv- l.urt lie. i which «cre isr-.ert-nt oncu *h sc th t th-y h'd to be presented t- Ircf-sscr * H-'r.HoBor? Yea, thtr: required cf nc, I never hr.d th- inpressien that rrc- f.as.r KcwUcs-r intcnticnclly end k i. »i_. ly lid net infcr.a ae. o Cn the 1 st :f Septcor-r 194/. ■- nc* sottlencnt cf th- rruncy chief cf -hrar.cht Helical Services emu r.V.ut, ehrt t.s the intention which ley be¬ hind the creation cf this nc.« agency? .. It t s the- difficulty cf the verk. It nado it appe-r necessary tc croetc c deer r-l*ti nship cf superiority and tc arrive *t r. cnoral authority tc issue erdura. * Did the r -cncy cn their wn initiative rite eur>sticns rh ut this new a-ttlc'i-nt cf the .latter? Yes, these sur ns ’ ere re-do ty uc. Th> cenf : re very len* ni todicus *nd I think that the my »o 3 jo it n w c lstituteo the twel¬ fth or thirteenth ir-ft. Ihoso crafts hr_. to be present.1 tc the bchror.cht tranches, t< the a SS, t. the Cctrdssicner Gcner*l, tc the OK , epor- -ticnal oteff end t . tho Chief, OJf , end wer Iso mfbrdttcd t; the chief of C». t 'i ’ h.*t is ‘ efrr. ycu n-w as the decree cf 19 U. including tho official r l ti n, is it s.rethiii* th t ir-fesacr Han 11-sor streve fer as chief, .ehr. .-.cht Helical Services? .. Kc, unf-rtun.tdy not. ; Vh t nor- the rlsjivir.-a mi the cbj.cti.na which led to r. chcn-e? .. The Leftw. ffe ur.igrstmlinrly cc:,.r t.-i. Tho SS rwdo the eld well k~n licit cticns with referjnco tc their pmta :n:l units whicn were aub: r- iinrtel to th: hehrcrcht, rnd sinca cth-ndso they wore net cencomvd r.t nil, '■is net interested ir. the furth-r details. *ho ..ncy suhiitt d a different -raft, -r.d thj N'-.vy aalo the str r.- cbjecti-r.s and did n.t wrnt U rliew *- d i.f cf the ’ -hraacht Jodicrl S rvicos nny ri +.t cf superiority and as ittl- a * sri'-’le uthcrity. , this situ-ticn, these r-j-ctin: rttitules cr r-ther, --re they : v r_=3«j In the finrl tact? IS retru-’ry-.'.— DJG-23-5-Sia4budc C urt :.*c. I .. Ycr-, hcuvir k.xws the story can well recc-nizo these points. The clear dlivn- c r.ccpts .f xo-.rirr -- 4 subordinate wore left cut. The herd aub.rdinr.ticn is r.:t acr.ticr.ui - single tine. Iv th r, it is nmticnod nee. Th t is cr-y v.ith the r.cdicnl — with the ohroftcht Chief of llodicrl Services ; %rs n*llyj thrt is, hia aulcjdir.rticn under the Chief of C1C . In addition the -jcrcssicn technical authority is used, rod furth.racre, those technical cuth- rdtics arc Unite! t: the sciiccl chiefs but net to pocplo whe were subordinated tc th-cu 1 hat is t; say, the Chief cf the ohrr-acht Nodical Services cculd, fer instance, issue ar. erder t- the ..ray dodic-l Inspector acccrdin. te Figure tut he couldn't issuo an crier t.- 'ny arny tvuc physician er any 1 ter cschdcn 1 ceruse he is not ncnticned un ler this author¬ ity cf iasui.a: directives. - 3115 - IS “. o-l- -ty Court I 4* Yrv - authority to c . rt'crs in ox fy that paint? L. . cr :• r.,-. t cticn v 5 limited The nj.t to iaau- .r i *: „•; .nc; si r % . i injnrticunlr t. t it is not 188U5VJ-' '-a r. n-tUr cf ooursu “.a it u cl- biro been in a easo r.i tionahip ration Sb«r.i . t t!«w footnote n pago 1 is it io cit- . ~n th.ro * .oil, U.ul-: you please r --.Z it? ... Y.8, ' - L'Oinj, t- r • it: 1 : ta .; «c f tnN r- ul .. ». thuro btlAV-.'. t t - Ux. cht, jry, .: vy, ia t - , th. unitt of th- -.iton-SS rut r ..vt^t t ’.- c’ir -cht in t . unit* ’ . rg* nlsatima cor.-ltt-c* >*ithin j-fic» -tion i: - pro.r .; . vtur cph.r.r l r. -..at.. .iJjr r-.Oully - »r- t. - i.itro- uc. * iit t: v^cy* j, h t v-a th. ir.t.n w ns h th lunctiona n# -r. laid •cm ia ft- t-rt? ... ..rt n j .r-«t • ■ . p rttioi » th. * hraaoiit l .-ic l >.ivi;c.c li.in uu. .Uat r r k *ar lai. down r.t til t oy Xa-.uro I lie r.i . h j th. d »:. ■ Di - - 'rt;~nt chi.. *.. jacif lurry t\ t cc r i. t Co u 0 1* -n ‘11 th. t rati r t‘ .in ih. r-oy - ii ore ;cc *no laid down tit r_v i: . in th- c-s.. . t.u .jr y o'.'ic l Inso-ctrr «v. only it".- th. irciplin-r; position of i Di- - -i. or 1 -i cr. .vi-t. r ; f ii-ii* 4 * r.is < s i. *. t-vor ia &-at i.u- viidcr Ill. t *. - purer to a y .t a« nl;. ‘ r - . The ri.,h. »1 In b-.V i 7i. ,h, ri .it i iu>ct..a *.•: tv. riint t iisue i .. xzto r nine: -' • . - -Tr n.tv, th ri; ;i * . x..ting p-.pi- in .’ii.l'-r positions v- r . ;• rr:.-* *. t,<. Clu.f f t - cat . ±c3l i~rvic-s, = :/ finally ■k-E. _ ic-il e.rvic.s i- -3U9- 13 .-2-Patty C^urt I which c-.iccr.i_ all th- hr.,-.cM or—r-.-s -x rfcicn c alc: be settle* by the Lui r * __et 3 .-.£c pic be . • h - 'ncuml, I • sure, ia irWreBtc in r t c : __ un erst ur: '- r : - - l ... ... ~ccotOjv t. pin! n, trt he* to b_ un orate lit .r~ily, quite lit.r .11*'. It Lera &rvire. 0 •’l *lfy t- . int cticelly? r r.B th. :ur.ari itr-lf , thlo -Jpr.osl n * .? .» t ri- • • t • . _.r -c!it Op.r«ticml -ri.r v ul h .• ' •• very c; -r c r.eo t, c nc -t » c* 1: u i. r. . s ~.ny a. 1 r ul-tions, ■i'-- n * t . r roe* :irt io, t a n t : ~' n 1 c - v -- “ tlur v rior* Ki l. J .n 1 -rcut, th-n ti.r. Oati n *. ul n t fc-.Vu t xxat ■ *r. vitw • rtt : r t-cnnic superior, s n C-. rd: t-y f.-t lt.i r.'.r.nco t th- M-’ic-l •i 1 'n •Ik.cU ire .- W ul-* Q| .r ©rs c •:i bo lrca U ko -r. c rc-m •' ’ • Sorriest, r if *- « - • - < . r icht br- : 11 in: ■ uch -nd In r _ • L cl-r-__j ta*t p lnt, : .ul t. ...tv ul th- altunti n i.. IX n fcr-n.-h ..-r tent r ul r.'iu. t r » . t itrcli *. ..Az r -r in t.clinic 1 tr.f.cra? -• h- ti le i* t.-,_ ehrr.set c‘ S rvic-r e> ul n . n tie wn C. IX the Ch “ - r hr- -ney, - -.1 Just : -i !•- 22 -b— .- 2 . -3-rutty G-nrfc I Kr. ll-. ~ -c-1 chief of ary cocr-a’ ~f the .^2cd Force? fr'acch. La the case f refusal :f bcyonca ;f an error, the Chi.I. tho chmacht Ic-Hcal Servicesvui:. have t.*.»port this *-ttcal chief tc his 1- a- iate super r in -r.tr t eras. a auniShr-r.t, a punishaent which would bo Cet-u:- . the rwocyoncc f . t chnic 1 pc . thiss tuition aloha Ulfieolt this cl cr-cticc. hroacht brenehas oyer ecus to . • -- " at?a. c — I than:: it is n „ • Tof » 1 •* . b^t i a-ver c-.:e t. a rub a • the reSearcr. institutes. .. Di - rvi't-:nship, t’.i. ; car. rel-ti.nshlp t. the 1 odicr.l U..~ric. tt too .af/on-St chan «:t dl t r u the Docn. of •&? • • I ' il r: ' -- -■ thoso units unlch cciwittod ot th r r.t* n t in practice was the «In? whip f the e Steal S.i-vlc. f the • ifen-SS? ... I alroa y sal- th t th- tfXen-Sb war n.t v.ry intorosto , an' in ■ ~ • Ua ■ r-ters in ur w rkin tt f. I r - .a- x. ~. ent that t. l n t f.-ll • rJcin ttaf w*e built up, it : k quite • •• : • r -Putty C urt I ' J-x icftt o ical Services, f.r inst-ncc,th. xeical wolf ire oitf err., the r .tt:r - v lunt r- serein;, t.v. c.ntr Idali^ with notic'd s upply of ill kin's, p-rtly ..-ic-l natters c «ora-*. »-iw ... pr.scntr-=f-crr systca, but tr.:t it s -t n that wo a fa is lost ct a i't.r >.to ttcaus. to. rxt.n.r-of- % *-.r v.it. -. -nt v.r In the or t. the. rt.s,rve .xt^. Th. fvrtb.r up-builc'ing dist-Tt. ;y fact that tX - -nci.s irtthrhtchtt ha' to* in eonst:.nt t uch w-r. -vwt-tc fr - B-rlin, an finally urs.lvca ha t ^rccuato cur v ncy to Thuringia in torunry, 2%. TX "ifficult lin.r i n m’ ti. if ieviti-s ir. t-L.nh nin ... a. . any c nrxeti n with thuBt . a flnoics c ..pLtoly i: p fb h •tryin t ex. f rt un’c' m-.ictth ry* tvi.; t otr.vit.ware's the heart f ".r iny fr • its v r. ur c rn.rs, an-, i r .. ..all th. tia. n-w hcopitnls ha t. cr.'.tw a.-, a.-.rclu * f r, -a in iti r. t that, .... t care r r ' ' a because all ..* Genaany ha 1 boo at c war territory. .K- AAI . T: Iha IW - cs until nine-thirty -'deck t •• • r. nr. xTX ~r'“ * urn. wtii 1 1?1.7 0?3C h urs.) - 3122 - C.urt S-. i IS 7<-t ‘.7-X-l-l-ZEX-rvSttr Official transcript -»f the American kllitery Tribunal in the matter of tho United States .i Anericc e<'claBt horl Brrxdt, et rl, defendant#, Bitting at Suernbcr*, Geraany, or. 19 Jetruaxy 19-17, 0920, Justice Beals orcaidin,'. Z~L KARSHALt Pers-nt la tho eourtr^M will *ilec#e find their eerto. The Honorable, the Juf• A tlu letter thrt • • • •— • * 3i«:o y u Just aeati.ecd. t C-urt Bo. 1 19 Fee -i7-h-l-3-ia«-Foeter v It een fce Boon froa that th*-t it vna one of the- tpokc of the Chief of the Wohrweht nedlefl Service# to diatrihute rsrterinle. Thrt includes vaccines. a. Ye■. On the strangle of that do you law* the cities vhere oroductlons case froa, that ie, the factories! a. Yob, they cre lcnovn to the Chief i.edicrl Suo^ly Offico. Q, Do you knov vhethcr rs no; thcBo suoiliert, eyccotin,; privato indue- try or erny institutes, that ia, Crcc.>, there v C re any SS ir.otitutoe? s a. I te-v nothin/: of that. this right -f distribution rnC the rtli ti*-nohln 'f the oumlierc t the Chief Pedicel Suo-Jly Office- contained the authority to control the oun- oilers, tr _-1 la to say, the feet xUtl vo ,niy hre to check ;n the production, the esour.t of the *n. TT^UCti C-.urt Kv. 1 IS Tub -.7~.:-2-l-L3i-3fccr<‘ I esk whether yju, y-ureelf, vr representrtlvoB >f y uro were rctiv in this Vvtrk. I- r iastincc, 1.5. rrrben c.uld send oe.nlo there ia wder U c.ntrol h v they vest about pr-ducir,; viccines? a. Ho, ve had no rir-ht of e-attvl. 5., I ur.r.oretrSid you c-rruetiy if I say thrt these ncreures of ,;rir in* the vrcclnoe in order to distribute then Justly is one of the tyoicrl ci-sos which the Chief ,f the Uhrsaefct Keller1 Services hrd; nrrely, to dis¬ tribute this v.'ccinv mutually f-,r rll ' ehraacht branches? a. Yes, this coaceot is ouite c-rr.ct. X C^, D,es this nranor of your activity relrtc rt all to the research aystens? a. S., this vis a ..gi euro of tu.nly. >ith reference te a oueoti-a which the irooecutor presented hero yesterday during th- er-«s (nomination, I have to cek you: The Chief ef th Vohrorcht Xcdical Services as such. did. he hive ray authority with re for one. t , the lastrllr ti -a «f v-rics f or ty hue vaccines? a. Basically, no. Hero v« were als c-ncornsd with the cutstion f t ruleroo ,f personnel and the urgency*of getting -(torirl rad thooo wore the' things thrt vt were oopr-rcho f. eb.ut by tho fir-o. Vher.ever wo had ray oor t-nx-el rvnilrtlc OBong .the? otdiccl personnel, v. c uld, of course, role.- , the- rr.' ’"O could soon.r any urgency r-.cu.st on tho orrt of the Industrie v Veil, then, is it orrect t j sr s v thrt you - thrt is, tho Chief f Uchrcrcht i.ecicrl Service* - had a decisl-n >vcr the Ouostion when euch r fret ry wi e t. be orocted, but thrt y^u aly had to be listunod t slnro cedlcrl service cu«eti,ns wore touched u-t*? A. He hrd m ri-*t .f ruth rity rnd ho did net have to be heard under rll circumstances, ’-hen the firms wished, they ceuld do these thin * — their vt. initletivo, but they needed >ur resistance . rA th.y ur a sis trace end- w t c.uld >oae-r their wishes. ^ Cvull this >r .ccduic extend t institutes la the framework £ the V-.hr oacht branches? Shat v juld have been o circucvcntion bdcausc the Vehrnrcht trrncc Court So. 1 15 Jot 4?-K-2-2-Sat-3«arc wore rocily independent. Shey hr', their ova contla-->nt of raterini. «v. la r B-^cirl cr.ac tho setter sce.so to J»ve toon different. It vrs lrif c.vn ia c letter on the * rt 4 the hedicnl Ineocctorcte «.f the air for th*t In the ccse 4 rc inetitute vfaic.'. belonged to this brunch 4 tho Chief the Vehr rcht *.edical Services bit. to be heard. Sir. you over heir of any such .r^ceruru7 .•v. I reenter a • concrete cite. I u eaerJcin,- r.t-ut this snecirl caso. ^ a. Ho, I do a t rc^e^ter such an application. Of c urce, when the % Wehraacht needed .ur assistance, then, -f c.urec, thoy approached us. You ,etn only that? a. Yes, -sly that. Sid y.-u attend the aeetin^s of the consult in,; Physlcirno? a. Yes, I attended thoc in 19-.2, in the soring 4 19*3, and the svrir- 4 19 ^,. v In jfey IS-3 n lecture was held by Dr. Din^ with rcforcnco to tjrohur Did you lifter, tj this lecture? a. So, I did not heir it and I d not knw his nr^e. I hivo no inagl- nnti.n about it whatsoever. During that speech an incident occurred, hrofoss'ir B -so uttered o alsgivings ond I r. asking you, do you know officially or Personally, I nerr during the recesses or during the evenings or whenever the participant* grthorcc, that any such protect vf o aa* o ty rr-fecc r Bose? a. So thin,: ever tcear.c ka.vn t. xae at ut that urotsst. ^ D. yj U know whether irofusoor Kaa^loser directly roocived ary r.v-.r at «ut thrt? a. S-, I know nothin,- rt-ut it. "orin.- thnt sc.se seating did JA i listen t. tho lecture 4 rr fuse • Gchhardt and Fischer? It v* a a lecture at ut special orwri wsti! with ref. eacw to sul-hr ail«;:idc. a. I did a.t listen to that lector, beerur. I -r* tntcrccto.' in iectu regarding ceychictry C-urt S% 1 IS Job •,7-k-2-3-2Si-5eer<‘ v y-u ever gain ery knovlc :e -ffieirl -r unofficially f this lecture vfcick attracted attention? «• Bo, nothing is known to r.e -f thtt.. didn't ^r.fcse.r Kand-l^ecr o ».nJc tv you tfter this lecture and dis- cuss this :irttor with you?* a. JIo, that vps n,t the case.. \* 3' y-u know vhether froc any side corrolaints «cre ot\o with your • a agency etout the contents f this lecture? A. So, according t i uy knowledge no such cocolaints were nado. X ■e* 3o y.u still ro:.i iter what the situation was in the Horticul Ineoeo- tornto during the middle of Kay, that is, shortly tefCrc these locturcs? a. Yes, the situatl>n vrs very tense. In January v t hid those losses Stalingrad and in Anril ve hrd severe losses near Tunis. Vc c mid - I r.onr, * the nodical Service of the on*.ire- behrr.ncht considerable physicians were- lor According t- ny recollection ve lost 400 in Stalingrad and about ."00-?60 in Airier end ve ha: ,Tect worry ib.ut getting substitutes for then. Vo had t. take physicians awry fr the- civilian sootvr if ve wanted then. So that vns a tine of great v.rry f-r the Chief of the Vehrnrcht AediCfl Services? A. *e8, no doubt. Cv. And, his tine was taken u*» to a c-nsideTetle degree in order to car through "oaaures which would lend t the dealing with these enurgoncy eltur- tions. ’-ere the oanuccriote .t the lectures shown t the Chief .f the Wchr- nacht itudlcrl Services - the ,-nuscriots -f the loctur. c during there neetln A. j., that vrs nit the cite. „ Ver- they oresented. t. hit: rftervrrds? A. 2? -, they w c r n »t resented t. fci“ rfte-rv»rds. x. Vfc . worked -n these lectures? a. "hit beloved t- the Departr-c-nt i Science end «cplth at tho hedic* Inspectorate and they hit t t rert eff rts t get all thaso nanuscrlH ;fter the lectures '-ere held. ■v Sow, ,ni. final cueSti js. J.r rjzy years you v.re a c-i=l S.rvic- ir. .ns sph-re f -rh iv_ cr _ro t the ..r..y .I’iciJ Insp ct r-t- -n his st-.l. hvl n x:o_rt > r th, quest* :nc which jay have c rx. up? ... Yc3, t:. •_ is c rr-ct. ;• h-.T-v-r i t :curr„-r>. *• 6 - ■ t .. rle, -r. these rep; rts cent to hie v.-. Colei, t . .jry edical . ar -ct r r r. th.y rent t the jiiijj f th- uhrs-.cht j'‘ 1- i Service? ... The r.. rts *-nt t. th. •; j-f Statt / the .jry - 'ic l Inspectorate, o CM.. : Staff £ the - r oh lc . . . rtiv-r u-ati ns. : : tl witness, n It . Be c ° i n-, the r a.cuti I *N ar or _jr t-w “.tr..ss. C.ff»Si. . .. e.. c ? "... .i-lDT: t . -itinaa, y u h -_ i -i‘_ . r, . r c*. xaninati ;i that t ! >c " ' - :• r -r ~ ir ' • i.jrv * -r« ■ , -a' 41'll, TO r f rth. I! c I 'X y u — heur qovrtl i . . k iv. 3130 15 Feb- -J. -3-2-c :< Court I . : > tint liroct examination th-.ttho besia re-s .n fer the S\jOir..r -civ. f I?i2 t prcc*rvc porenncl an; - t.rialV — " v I nsk - u tc repent th_rp-.fti,n nee icrc? i. Darlai. c urso £ ur xr..ct .x aaati n by 'cf_ns. counsel you hv . * -la _ <« t tfc- r.-.= n '-..i - isavneo efthc Fuehrer -cr... f 2fi July 19ii2, v-s t preserve pers nncl - -t- -I-2 byway r pr -r c rdlnstii » ’ « nterlal -n puraenncl^n t)i- riel-’ u ^ r-c.-rc; •• c • n pr -e- . 11 r. nch«o . the ..ohr.vxht, which r.quire! - ct r.iiv^. : aa- pLuut.* * cti n? ... Ir. tho ’scree ~t 19h2, *. *aci- r^.ul ti n f rue.arch un« n t rxinti nc • at ni m tJv, twice i r the C ... ttc .ohnacht lbt!ionl Service. C .nsequuntly, v. cl n t - i.. .. Isn't it Ir..., bt r, - . ... b-iru. p-rf r.--. ’ r.r..r. p_rs n.;*l nit.’ _ t-r;-.i t -r- at in uoo’ in th- c urs- tC :v, what v.r it — y ...» isn't it true, that r i exist . I c r'in-'i... the - r> r tn-t y-uwul n.t hive - ulicneJ n £ • . o .1 c-rry ut th- b-«ic porp ao f this cro , that is, t -u-. -rw. ,>wr# nocl m »t_ri-l? - T :r : cot r is r l i! r - fuel. • ni , .ul* h'v. ix-on hi is ro ul-tl a j Ipls/i, r lnoii . su. J.ct i f iciil JX. el-.tl .s i. . • • ■ f ' h uhrrohtw " 8 «*« «1X. r i c ul' 1 net ew c ..ctu. nith r • , • ’ " - ; -r hrve -ii . -cJliLi. r •. th . -»rpy u ’ic :1 Inspect rstu tt ,1c 1», tzl £ r th t purp.c-, nad didn't hn i:. £~rt • cc- : -Uah c r in^.n i fclv. iwlc-i .search to the l-.ct eayve * :r u 1 *- " • ‘ r -‘ u * t , . tin c.-nsciti... physiolcas vt the -in-.ry ’irl^c-Viy? •r - ic'd icadwgr thisw.-a 'unit with , Insect rs i th_ th-r ehmmsht tr-r.chcs T.^ r - invite! t the8^ _^ot. 3151 » ?cb-'w:—3-3-C-. k C urt I but y V. C l- ;t ell it a rc^ulr.tivn f the- c-.r.lncti n -f rus-:ircl!. .. uil n:w H-ntloser did in fret h v. the. focilitius 'f tlw ..roy __-\Lc -1 Ir.rp-.ct r~tc r.t nil is t'-I, dv* h- n .t? A. Y-S, fc- Id. .. b - ifcwW ^ incorrect - fncttltto* tt nia «1opo»r -e Cni-.f ftht -hr.".cht -dic‘1 S-rvicoS .re sj-.11? .t 1 -rt f your quoiti n? ^ s r.i-* it v ul ■ fcw Inc r. -Ct 3. — th* t the Chl-f f the liidic-il Sjrvic-o I th- ohn 1 v lUi it, in £K f.-.r '£ Dsiic'.l reSo^rch is c nc-rm.', ia " » "h 3 !irvn ‘iisor h • til f::cilitiu Sew y u £ i , D ct r, t:. : » - ohi-I f the -'xi-'icrl Service of the chrrr.cht - v « irv, tcetifU* -r., Dct r, <-1. th- Chi-f th. .v‘ior-1 Scrvico r t: - vhRveht roc-iv.-* r-a-'-rcb •'crifr. -nts fr * the r-nchca of . h '-ir-cfc-' ct tor i bol 11 «- ? Si* y» u hoar e.u-rti r.. ... I c-.i! : t r y tii- t r.r.i.i . 1 / rt rtin, fr a 19 .3, e ’pi-o f th; rop rts f the ohrrv-.cht br-ae:cc b vt r.s. .rc ; -relents « -re oent to th. Chi-f f ... -hnrtcht lIc- 1 S-nic. . r '-a nckn,vl--‘jJ*.nt. ,. • - • : - *ont t tho Cffic- .f th- Chief f the o ic-1 S.rrtcc f tho .vtr-cit? ... This >r-3 tu v lunt-rily wif.-.-ut Li Mkt ! f r by the. Chief f tl . .hrr. cht 1 c i - rvico. , ctor, »ht £!» jurp.s- f Mrw‘\-.a- * thos. re. rt: • ror^'rch ; rfc? ... : • • • 3132 1 ? k C.urt I t X svtcunt € Science -r.' arch rtth th- Cenaissi n~r r;_r._ral, rxk* thoy nr. t.l th.natives that i u -r_ -in_ a r_p r*. ibis t the C.or.isai r-.r Gcrural, it -r.yb. - 'vis*- ‘1 t the Chivf f the uhnnoht. <. *ioal £ .rvicc rc-caivu - cpy t • •. *. h vas this C -rdasi a-r _n r-.l y u r^f-r t ? ... TV C- rUsi r._r Qu»,r.l f r . . * ie-1 -n. Hcilth Service, irolcac Bran t. ^ .. D r’ •- -ny r.- rtf n •_ leal wqvrijtent ... I :n*t • ' -out th-t? I nly k: v i'j ut thtac. c i.o that I n-.nti r~ yoe*. .riay. Th-n . v. v ul-' st t- that i- the c urt. f y ur .fici -1 ’uti.a : u rwvcr V.cax ctrart f any :x'ic-i . • - i -Rte n huu*n • -in r in c r.ccntrati’ cnr.pc? ... n ne„-fc~ll. .. D n r, if I un -ret' j u c rrcctly, :hcn r. Holtc nr. a int.rr ati y U in c nn.cti.r. vith y ur bi .r .leal i-r.r.1*. y u first chief f tfc. 8toff t ttu . I S-rvic-- t t - Ini that is, fr n the let f Cct - 19llt, il 1 S. r 19!*2, isn't that c-r:cct? ... 1 ur : ir_w - r- n’t ui r it, r the 1st f Oct bur 19hl* until tV 31 f ..’V ust, 19L-2, I me Thie, - - Staff rith th. Vic 1 inspector af the Luft U-... viz ■ . ic l Inapoct r c£ the Luftn&ffc at that ti A ct.r? ... O ncralot.ratabr rxt Hi rt. If in y .ur capacity as Chiif f St af. t Hippk-, I -.scu - y ur uti. ..r si.il-r t th sc as Chiu.' f St-Xf t Han^acr ir. his capacity a a Chi-f -f th- /id Servlet cfh, ...xrc t, in that anythin th t Hip^W w ul have h ' t. -i.Vc r, y • ” '*1 h/. *-1- f. '»’■ tw.-.f 3133 — .. -“•‘I *• - - . • • I ' quit s-,'.r., ’ cr.uc -11 ftlcl. f'ct^r, I Uj I • :n*t I-“V- , ° ^ "A cl: '* Inti _ 1 a Tr 53 . 76 PC, Dr . It r_;'5rt >f r!;c Sc- rt •i xcL ".'a ti *a -< m t: t -tc. t? the Swcx’ctei- ; t-.t * *• • *.• t ^ .M •»/’« • I • ii, !?-:a— 1 UP " . “wPS u l\ .* lli“ 61 ' 50". ' X*? I !v.'w Si ‘Xcixnoc 1 “b!: * 3u 15 re . 3 i'rboV. a --.rnt or. , cc tele.-.' ..ic .:u • - • it: C'-. P ' • •' , •• •- c * itc •"cp . t: ■. - . -' tt the 6-c. , 4-0 C3UP0C f • .iol r r - • .’’J Pi>'onti c—. 3 . i-.x.-.-.x u rd8- 3 \C Jf«s POr-t hoi Sr zZo, Ch t:-w SI . /.ctur. . in t*..-. -ntv.3!-.- :? c c COTi’-.r (* £t ?f the: ;• cnt.il :: : i. i) vre x. 1 * r 3 * r. ,-.t rrevi 3 ; k t ‘m c: -T, n tl.“t r 11 *. - c^a.Pu.-.c» n . ->ti n “'totiu’o wra ti n fialsvpc v-. :n o »■ 1 r. 1 r 1. - c.ro -. 1 - . :• - r*. X -r 11 - r , ,m - - 7 , * c 1 • ‘ -n invc • .iCvrs, • ’ r. rrceetioo ,-vr- * 0 iU VI-V 5 f t*x t -1 -COO- t--.ee 1:. fvrs'r.c r:co:;t ■ \-,r 3237 15 ?eb ;r-H> c -l-.e Court 1 r 2 r.'I 122 -T: 111 counsel plena- Identify l-ineelf for the record? kisser sn xnoxos jY D3. .3L3B: (Counsel for tuo Defendant SanAlOser.) v. 3i0 prolocutor jU3t acid th t just in the field of rose rch :y coordinating various research offices one c uld save -^.inly personnel; nay I at/, you aa ecieatiat ie tnore e field here one c uld not save personnel:by -ay of coordin--.tion :>-.d I neon the field of research? A If aonot-.lcj has to rerult fro- research, then research h o to nave freedom and one only hoe to oxc~An<;e results. X - In order to ive you on eracole, for last aco. if five parsons are c^rrirv; on rusearon *-ork about very icr;ort. nt robloo, thon you Thin.-: th:t it t.a tue cxpcdlont ttak of the leader of suoh n rooc-.rch ey .to.: to a. vo on« re o re- '-arkor, ir. pl.vco of these five, vho would work n t.’.ia problc- nlaaolf? A 3*0 londor could only do that :oa convinced that tho four ot.;oro arc not qualified. Since research workers lwuys v.ink tnoy ro the eeot, it would probably bo very difficult to declare objectively • ; o the beet one la. 3:o toco, d uc-tion, tno prosecutor bellvos that Frofeanor Eandloaor, oinco he -to art? in«j>ect>r, hi* two officoc: tho bo- collod C-iof of tho lehmncnt ..-deal Service and Arty Kedical Insooctorato in ordur to deal vita hi a t eke. Is it correct that everyone of tho nvccncios krd t..cir own circle of t skat A That is correct. Ii it corr ct that -von if thoro vat the crnbimition of ono pit con doinfe two joba, ns it • ae the caao h-rc. that tho Chief of tho ...ruwsht i-^-dic..1 Service could sake uso of tho personnel, arterial, <-*.3., of *.iO Arjy TnapoctOtnw for the of cho lo raicht h-llcul Scr icol A 50t- of these activities h d to be difforontiatod. -•.ere tacre independent chiefs of staff for both of tneso e£0ncio3? ’ 19 ?cb l.-HD-5-a-iw^.B SiUTt 1 L Toe, a. turally. Bid nit tioso c..icfo of st ff see to It that the interests of t.:o t'.’o i£03cics -ore divided fro_ one ’-Other? ^ Tea. they sav that c very clear dlvifion -a codo end tho terreney of both up to c cor*:in point voro contrary to onch r^orey. > Toe, you said that ycst.ricy- -hi I Correct if I «y thcro vr* evon tension between thceo two n encies workln.; in tho UBO building? A Tea you ccn call tho- offlciri tensions ovon If thoy did aot. h '.vo any personal effect. -OW. r.t too end, I o..ould lllco to ash you with r3*orcncv to hr. hardy 1 o question; is It truo that ? W vent to tho uoctlnc r.t tho -vlntlon kialatry la y ur capacity r.s C-.ief of st ff of Axllcrl Sorvico of tno Air ?orco? Ton, rant is v.iurc too tension vas on power end authority; as I ■ re. i not tho c..lof ay loader. But, 7 u vero still pr ctlcelly thtf c..lof rood you were not with Professor E.adlas.r elaco ho only cane froa tho yjt T-or.-lus 19 ?cb Oilirt 1 1 Too, naturally. 311 not tncso chiefs of at ff oco to it that t.ic later*sta of t:.- f/o ,:orxicB -crc divided fro one .-ffiOthcr? Yea. they igv that u very clear dlvieioa tad. o cad tho toadoooy of both up t« b cortrln ^oiat v.ro contrary to onofa n^erxy. . Yo». you acid tl-.t yect*ricy. -o 2 Correct if I acy thoro - a ever, tcadoa hetwoca taoio tvo r ::.cioa world:..: in tho mbo buildinc? i Y-b you cc— call then offici i tonniona evon if tMoy did not h vo any ticraoar.1 effect. Sov. r.t Uo end, I a-ould like to calc you with roforcnc. to ;;r. Hardy *d ^uoati^a; ia it tnxo t-.r.t ;nu -cat to tho ucotinc nt tbo _vi .tioc idolatry i:. your capacity r.t Chiof of St ff of .Idler 1 Servlco of tao Air ?orco? 1 Yob. tnat io where tao tor-cion v C « on ?ovcr und authority; aa I vr.o uot the c-.iof : ry longer. 3ut. y u voro Btill pn-ctically t.:o c..iof na& you were not yjt vor-ia*. with FrofoBoor E-xdloaer ci:xo ho only er-e froa tho 19 - - - 17 -J.-S -la-=K?- 1 l^h-r. - 1 rt 2«-. 1 jjfcraixio t th- -n -f S--«t«i>-r in . -r t- strrt bis ffico; is th t correct ... I-s, th t is c rr-ct, :.s f r -.. th. ^.rs.r. ->f Prjfgaa r HsnCl.'Swr is : neuno ’; bat I 4 virtJjr - lr.- .y " -rk- t th- now -ffic-. . r:r tlw -ir>;a- I tnirir..— ... I ': 1 s r. t tmin.ayc.ir r tsrs n’ succ-ss-re. . .»i ‘ y a inf-r ?r loss r Kartil.s-r “ ut this r. tt-r '.t th- .viiti.n liinistry? . , a r*. inly n t - r. t t *01. This -.-s just • a ttor A which cv,_ U ' su ’ -nly n' th-n 'i oz.'7’~ r- '. KRAUSS: (- ur.-l : r D-i- r. Knk « st ck.) % . itnusa, 7 -u 3t*t- th t th- in ivi'u-l -fjv.cht r nchci r-e-iv-' c 'i».s f th- r-n-'rcb -3sL-n--r.tc, which tf.-y h -liv.r. -r ratbor s-nt thua t th. „hiof f ih. :.«hra-.cht ic-1 S-rvic- a th t tho ri inti f thwoo r-3-arch - ssi ni-r.ts w-.c :-r.t tj th- U rtr.-nt .1 Sci-nc- n. l.-c-crc'. hitn-ss, I or. r-*. shin; y.u is it r. t r. f“ct th t th- rijinr.l I my rca--» < jai nr-nts *«nt t. th- r-c. xch v rk-r c nc-ra.' -.n th t th-D-. *rto-nt f f oci-r.c- r.n R-a-rch -nly r-c-iv- »y si the- * ssi .v.-:;to; r. w is it th-.t y.u h v- lff-r.nt kn ..L- - th n th t? ... I oust c rr-ct ay at t-c-r.tr th ’ I . - r.; *h ■ rr * * th<- ri ir. 1 w o cortoir.ly s-nt t th »~n c.r.c-rn-:, th- a-.n t wh a th. tv l ri r.aoi iw ; this v- ru. th t th- - -trta-nt its-lf r-c-iv- * - o.py n' r-c-iv. * nr. th.r. .. Thanh ym, I h v - r. - iurth-r quvoti.n*. 8T DR. UnsJii (- - « to*. . ./.-..r-Fr-yrir. .) . hit axis, v u a* to -: : th t uri: > ttfcln -ri ' i ti - tt w-r- CM-f t .t -h i= 1 2n» -ct r -f Uu. Air F rco, -i. t uod fr j first .< Oct • -r, 19U until th- ?lst f «u unt in 1912; 1 will a •" --ok . «b . vs i- . :*ly su'-.r ir. to t y u ir. y ur y-siti.r.? ... Ih-r. *-r- W - .r:«.wt - rt . . , * , ’r.r let- c r£t Li-V rr.-.m *n th thutu vr.s an in - vacant r.u;' f rz Cists, ti.r. >:-s a static ffjap r.: - r- istr ti n r.uc n-. 1 thd:J: t IS. 11. 33 /* I 19 . .17 "-.h r.. --urt ; . l Q. :,”r. t pjaiti ft i. Uw H-fs-r. nt -r. Baekcp-Fr-ysin 1-1 t th.t ti with th*. Insect r f th. Air F.rc_. ... Dr. —fr -ysin waa th- * vis ry c imacl f r avir.ti n r.. Q. An rtaonva «x>rt f r rvinti n.m icir..? . ... I think it -as St s rzt Pr,i.rs r Ant ni th t nr: with th- U.’ic 1 D-.'-rt-a-r.t, q, I n» c '.cl: t. tiio c nfur^nce f H Sv .t.^ .r, 1 / 1 /; i y u . . ; nr. B-'h:-i : ./• ' - - r? ^ ... N , certainly n.t, »lncw ray infara ti wsa rwfusw to 1 bl •• tic th t I c ul. apeak t hi*", at. x Q. Yiu »-.y th t 7 u kn« n thin ’ ut hi h ItituV -xpcrLc-nto, which tturg c-rri ut >y Dr. P.-.ochr n - . R '-r ? ... , I h n k: .L.: - f th t -t *11. Q. Li 'n't 7r fvit r Hi • ku U.11 y.-a ? rythinr r* -ut th t? a. K , ?r i-itB.r . k~ t L - n t: in ut it. Q. :. , ■ vi« ry c unouX 1 r Avi ti h ■ '.-‘ici:. , c-r. 7 u ny 1- t.. a f r -ciai n r ;i tur», r i ' !. pr-o-r.t ary r-. rtc t ;• u ut th. -Xvcuti-n f nr such •js.^rfaunts in Dichr.u? a. ’ .. «. ..3-i .. ;: It M • r ! >’ ur i ' !t qu-cti n, ’ut I ill r~^ t tr. t I n-v-r r-c-iv- ouch r-p rto n* such » tt, .. ir. jck :-1 r jnin . Q, ;.a, Witn-oe, th *- i» ^ rr-ct, *ut it c ill' ' poaaihlA.that y .u T. r *o autltth. ’.y k- 7 f • r. • rt -r l.ctur.? n. th t to n t c-rr-ct. s c. Md anythin V«c aj kajm t •-* a 1 -x • * -> ich v»or* r. ?r -f oo r K-tel vtekr in th- c nc-ntr-ti n ui th *.. url-. t -.-tin/ in 191^; -r- ru t. t, in c _i i t >chm? .. . . * '. 3ut u . r - -.ft v S.ni .r. ? 3- V f Z O H - . sera nly .resent ' . -..is . otin : a:.- c csnltir. iys - cions? .. -\it that -ccurrc ’ .nch later, -•at I noon tills accfcinj in Jtanfjcr . '-ere v r --ant? , I was net. * <; lid y U b. cak tc Ki.,.k; o’ ui- thin questien re !i 1~1 diner .-.tv’, -rjsohor, r li*. ill ; i:o s.caJc t: j u? .. il , nevuv, ,;- 3 the nr -v - f Jtaechcr over c iti nc•- - r : J av r T j 1 t.. id .1 ..oet 4 Jir..lin« : t;.. • o inn inj f the rrr I • o i u n r.r.y bp i •‘it- r: *'t 1 : r . t!:o *’ £ Frcn^irfc t .*x; ortauittal cl-iof with • .t :r 13 t 17f^ I a c i-y “.”iti aal -axir.ti n :n.. ent-r. .' tl* i 2 -.-6-3-Fci .t C apt 1 anlvsi aity an! ~c n Anate * as - 3 -cturer. Then y v r;cru ulthin th: «. 2 e : -ificc tf *r f cao r Irmlcscr ft-.-.: 1 ? 2*0 tc i:Ui? ZwS, t’v-fc is crrrcct. «; -:v-t ; rsiti^ns 'A* y u h 1 -’. js t.'ej Ary iacx!loal Ins -cct.r.-.tc? I was a liyci^nist in tlu .'a-. _ Inspect-rate an 2 r«u;i 1 c la tba As.«rtaeat f Science on£ OtJ Qui. a n co. fl ..let was y-er 'c.arbxnt? ’cerrtcoot .X • Q TT.uld y.-.u -lease ictura te the TriT anal ycur a; her a • f v.r!: .-s a hy .ic.iiat in that tier.'art .cat. A I he, t Ital vith .-11 qiuati ns vile!; referre. t the a. here of y;l nc. -* r instance, :xaurlch.it , ky i.ne acC* . Vatl no, cl. thin o ftr.t f c' 1 »e'ics, then the cqai; v.:«t • the 'aetcrl i leal t a tiny otafcl ntdTiC q wrti ns in tbo s-.h-r have t- :sal with q-Jcrfti ns : tr loir.. .;.'’rio n_r- X- r * -.viciiJj, X * '/rich there were s. .ci 1 :*e.. rt i'. -hat was tl l . rolr.tl. nahi. . .- A artaent t the institutes f tho Ar.;; ai*.: th- ther ..'ohr.iacht ’-tm c us? ^ A he hr-', a fer inctitut_s t. .v j .It’ rhich no ixrc .... c-nnect P r inatmocj tho Military . .'.ic-i , Virus Eocoaroh in Cr*c *. i . ti c .a- .. 1 in a. J . J: V.nn, P. './ar t-.arc any •ffici l relay i.ns!d t* institute l* UV.iSS.-n ' ’ *’afr-r. SS? [ flirt • 0 ••:. i. .. . a it. . the aXX.n Sh? h Ut Z '; '. t ! :..y it. • 1 u . .an y u h- ' - - '*r:ce • fich J c . - eti.no t.. that instdtati « *• u ka-V . r feaa r ru '.r..w . \t rat ccrsi a ■ - a. .re -xx c ntact 'xtrsan .r /era r re. awly ur agency? IS ?C .' 7- - —,-6-L—F_l!t Curl .1 - jnEI'cr £ SC f r--ti ns • stf lvumt--' t. tjj r.r.y at the. fr at, rui' th-ref r; questi na nr ccnsi nnlly v’dch c ac-rn •‘•Iv.se ic r R , tlvt ir, a qu*ti.n n urir amt, c -tat f i ’.udcs, h usin , -tc. These vcrc tin- saaa quosti.ns qhioh c nc_rr~ us, t , rn ’ that was nl- c ncomu'. idth units f the 3. : - su'.- r ’inato t the ar.gr. n D- / u hr. rr tk. Institute ; r illt-ry Science nith tlw .Jm-ncr 1 ? .. ' , I ' n't ever. hn*ir the r vzto, .c. ^ B y u koss t:*c Institut r Virus :t.Z Ty. hus Icsenrck at hucivcn- wOd? " u that n;3' suck .institute adotci. Q U v what ms tta sitaati re .r'-.v- tho qucfltl n af t; ’res—ty. inis a articular . ;rt in the c . T k i-calos7 Tlir.t is nc f tlw - 1/1’- • wl,iQh Coals *.dth C nferoiWiS rej-r’in t-» ©o (v.-sti ns, r ‘.iC y u ..uroclf 0 • • Coal vitli sue! cnforcncce? '*' ^ .^.un*. that tine -..v .;cnomlI-, ha; re at c noon rojnr'..tl:c vr.ee’ .r c. - n. . i «»r m lust., vat-, Ty .ui Institute -.t 4rnc. . which • * . i oxn vaccines £ r us. -tit in r..Vdticn,.i. .» * . v hor ■fohnacl.t 'ranehec. re© tv ll relatively : /': • carlncy rice ’ far lir, . rcc-.lv-'*. d ac Ir stat lnstltaU I r c^ -riir.-.t-l them . at Frr.nhf.. - - .i, *.• t t»: J - t - •- r u. u .. t cuffic- - r nil * • • • : - r “ ‘ c : 're'Tient cca •» :ir. I# Fob 47-: :-S'. -7-1-rit z ycraL urt Nc. i_ c only used vaccines which r:re known to us to *‘o offoctlvo. In pite 0 / ti o cnornor.ry sltur.t?.on, wo nojoctcd •* vrccino v?5 ich v,t. 3 rxt rocc.~nir.od to 0 sufficiently # effective cn t!:o basis of a state It sticrtioru ftoro was ?n£ vacclno v! ich can fro:.: tho 3ohrin'- Varies. 'i. /hat w r.a the su*'st;-nco of tHa vaccino? A. It tcj r cMchon-o.'s vacelno. brother procoduro vc.s carried * uc and tho cntiro or.* rye w.;e uoo '.. Tcc uro of .tho i^so of tho on- .irc onbryo, tfcoro is o Irrsor . cunt of vrccino available, if •Ms vaccino had boor. valid, w would I \ s Vrewfr.t about an incror.o- 4 % A production. Uhtf: rtur r *; .ly , -! t u-.t r.. cfcr. cr.so, *. Uo I urulor I you oorrectiy *d\on you cay tho Behring orbs : .'rr ; ur- l.rd ont typhus v. ccinc froa chickon or a to tho -riy? • Yss . .. In tils crat you r« I tho offer of delivery 'ocr.uoo tho ty- hue vaccino was not cffoctivo? . . Ko, not sufficiently off low ?j,d you fi»i S) - -/out' ' rni' t; 1 : 0 OU |) 8 ol, ifc.Ii now 11 o'clock. fto Tribunal will •• 3 in rocors for r. c’rrt t o. ♦ ® • - 1 "• ricorr for fl^t n inut s. (A -iort rr.cj-c • ? ~rJ:rn) C-urt 3.. 1 15 ,-7-h-6 -l-£5t-3e arc. TES KAft S ? , « Li *hc Tribunal Is r.;«in in session. Ary it 'ilor.so Y ur K.na-, the 'ofextent Rudolf 3r«ct, having tom excused ty the Trlbunnl, ie e.seat f.r the talcnee A the day. Thi rR3S 131111 *heSecret:ry Gcr.orrl •'ill n-te for the rce^-c* the ab¬ sence A the defendant Rudolf Brandt f 'mrsurnt t excuse In order thrt he r.py testify tef-.ro Tribunal 2. The counsel rocy r>r >ceed. a 3Y DR. SCiu.IDTx • v Mtnets, before the recess you said thr t the^ty^hus danger pt the cad A 19<1 led to the consideration of increasing the r.roductlcn of typhus % vaccine. Du y.u icn.v vhxt rr.fccscr Knndluscr, es Arjy Medical Inspector, did rt this tiae -a this set*er? a. Yes, i-r.fots'ir Knt'l.ser ti ir that industry should nr'/.uco r.ore vne- clno. He vrnted to lneito industry to >rod.ucc soro. • • -v. v Q t this the Industry -hich v ( « rirerdy producing typhus vrcclr.o? a. lirst it vr.t th« industry vhich *vc already nr o due in.: vcccino, and in addition other fret ries, if nossltlo, wro t. *:rcd.ueo vrocine. v Du you ’ b r fact c5. r in crcrr o.w. in. tlcn of “radio a^r. 2 w!12 br.v« t: is decu-umt alr«n to you s’- you wl-on v 1 ok v i r.t it be (maw r . f r quor. wV-na. Md you km tl. t this lacu i i«n took pl .co? • , cl Is t * 1 ; lb, * rsyr.olf i;’. not p .rtic- t in *.3 llacuaeirq since I r.o on luo.vo. .. .r-jv - s Dr. Sebolz? Dr. ^cl olz mb one f f y %roup nnd lr. tl ia c- cu he represented r*o. t - « i • . n tier ? . . • '-••• will yen pi. c. l- k : 2 ? •• ~l ro ' I not hr.? c • - . 112 yen r ~ * . • • - vr.ccinc row prcducod * y tl i SuI.rin 'r'*s, which is *ucod fr- : cl ickon - c, is to ho tested for its effectiveness. ~ r r tlK^pwry r dr. .Dost, its will ct in t ucl with tie £S O''or- IS rv- '-7- "-S’-S-2-Ccok Ccu;-.'c. 1 sturr;'j:.nnfuoLror, r. ru • vaky. '.4 he w. a D$sinita? . . ->r. knifcz v:.a . rw n :: c. >. J rin ~6rks in -• r'jurr, - a . f r a 1 \cr.r\; j.„ « .s*lr. clo.rv p:.rontly tils Mrlr. ; vo.cfcino r.s S' - tc . inttituto. .. .£ tl . .. ye; ir s: . v.-.ul : • ateniaLed ycu? . o’, vn« c_h o iv.'.uc ; t . any tyyion© institute.* , % -on»t you s: • Ma . 'slvuft rieo to my o.ue- piciicn 1 I. t tl.uao lii 1 tt ; 7- * wn r'non;s n V.w: n ‘ oinyo? • . ■ -’c, net :it . 11 . • ‘ ’ id V..v w ti. ro ir i rkod soerot?" •_ , it is an ?*:• In;;-, If . . . aews notfcxnr t.e r.ia * ■■ t Ju . • .: , f. r j i:*. tr “at the idor. 1 I t 2 v* * r r . e :n col vrlfcl _-uol nwr.ld t3:uro? • xi f r !•” BUspiel . • . lUscuosi n ir. v _ rt, , , , , v ' - ■ s r, tie r;_ .v - '".t: ncicl. inistry in ^ djitLrir r.-L. t il _r^ vr.a ..lror.’:? rr’ : • i r r, Pl'cf.cr r ..’cit^r, Sr.-to -~civt ;*y Ccnfci, - n r 3152 »rtl. r.nu v ?o*; -7-s -5-3-C-cl: CrU! t rc, 1 sc fcrtt, Iripor p.rs-T lici-s P -ticip .tcd? .. D; t Is very unlikely. Such r’liecuafflcn or '.iscussions 1 .VC \-n pr.p.*.P 0 d fer na c ir.tfcor cf covjeo, aT invitations ro issUod few {1.-78 '2c.frro V-V.. ‘Kn tfr-ro would rev -r twr Ir.p rfc-nt 'laeuasicna cf i p'rt-r.t people vie hr A r. -re .t dor.l rf rork r 6 tMa ti ;o. Xfc«ro would n-v r *x tve • auch -diaouasi na on the arc .0 U.y. sirs -13-1-":. lc 19 So' 47-/.-S Court * : c. 1 V "\ q. It would hr.vc b.cn ?f£tl*3lc t: .t t-..c weeks cr cno vrock ':ofcrv. thero wt.s set 10 discussion cf i. diix'-r.r.t jrcv.p rf poopio . « Tj- t la quite poo a 1 ‘; la , yes. >ut 16 T7c ul 1 pro:..' ly h. vo ’>ien i.;p-ssiMo cn the sr-.c dr.y? ... i'oa, I ernsidor t! r.t irepr arlMc.. .. ycu knew t! t -ir fosser H..rv’lcs~r trek pr.rt in rdllfforont :iecuasi:r. end v.ith .* Ir.r-r nut.r f pojplo n thu typhus question durln tMa tl:*.? x ... Ye. I nor.il a cror.ee, — ti t t!.ru we.> liacuaaitna with In- ;iviaur.la, yes, but r. cinforonco? ... Ho. q. ..’ould ycu l :.vo 1 . oec.'.sa■ r. go knew 1. . * Prefers, r *. ndloaor participated In auch .'.lacu:*a> r. cr cenfuror.co? ... I wt ul'.*. ourt&lnly : . lo . . h. ' ey I or.y oithor '3ofcro cr .ft rrarla v .out tJo results, yew ' Jopc.rtaont prnjr.bly 1 d to ' o infer..od of the rerultr? T. I would t lor. at fcr.vo le. :• t 11 vo ex¬ ploited the results. :\vs the. nono 3uchenw:.l * : ■ ■ r. jiythl : tc 7 u, did you OVon r fcl r. :. 'UohonwrlJ in c< r-.csi'n witl typhui roi r.rch, r tho iv.a quocti :6 ;.ll? • A^ r *TII !t!. uhv.t! „r X tween tie Ole Institute in Cracow :nd •!. u oncontr..6ien p _ , r Vi-l ua ns-'rc!., t! • ;*c • s .ny c r?.. cti :.? ... Sv.ro wc.s nc c-nr.ecfcio!;. . • • , it s n st: to., t: -.t i 3 : : ; i:ek 46, th. t ■ l'l vr.ee ino in 1643 wee froqrenfcly issued f r vc.coinr.fcic «8j i « -ro lid Buchenwc.il ~et t: is v. ccino? BucTanwnld ocn hevo oht.-lnod t; is vr.eeino : rly :r:: tho SS ■— ic:.l store. The vc.ccino distri'iutod wr.s r.s fcllrws: It wr.a 3154 • -Tt A.* 1 astribwtov*. t tie izkdlvi - : 1 - ^cnokce rt the Jr?/ cht, * ici istrf'utc,. t' - rrupp. 'Ha -i-::* odifer.l Inspcetcrr.to ad not fcrotr, fr - «" -pr roeolvo.’. tte f '.U • • ■•--* «• - !vs ' ! ' 1 * rfncfc; rf th0 dr.* eM. ':ru : - u ov r In -’ - r ^ • N Toff# • ill yru twH »L..t tl.6cee.ti •• ; N •P° nod * Ilimins f liv.j, I a i cno ey ny gotten ffllof . . , •. ,.« TWfo.afr -c! roi'jor, tfcrt tr.ro wr-a t. apoel.-J. M 3 • „ 4to _ , <:i ..'-lc . r< :• ..a KPup ««? « tl ro:.t '« r»- r v.r.'-.r OV lr :-.r. o. •- W>* «* yolfc-w *«»>» '" c “ n0 tea to v . produe-O. i 0 to lr, f 5 * rofu.ocr 3jM lA err.er« te» „ cae .4 « -- tftc, «t «•» ' ' nus 1 'i»r of diffloultlo.. »o vooolm f tr* proiucoi » t : --t_-r-p..rly n 3uMo, -n _w- r not »t Mo. It , , t: orally o.trfry ' - " *>« • "• fcr0 ooiartcp. f .'.rotor. •• ... tr . s.t v 3 to r r.eolnr.ta tl-o troop. r tt . .pot 'tilnrS lit* r v . v * ' « ’ ho • ~ : i:r- v. . frlc-. Y-r» « n- - - iffldultio. ' v.t Mu s-lv'illlty r tho v.-.cclao 'v Aovloln ,:i foror.t not!-' r : : C » ' ; ' 1 ” • fs . . cttil - i .. O. 'f ao SS-J-r* to rr;* . ct tt jf ru •*»- • i‘ . c ir * • ? .n V- 5 ..-O ct.;. i. - «:»cir.l ivir'.cr.n rf tic SS #*W t) i • xntimc. fn* .r • ; tr 7 t r. S3 -rrvn nc.-j : n t: lc su-j.ct' .-n*. 'CC'Ti¬ ce '*.,coiv. vs t tV n Air -\ • * ... # -r , .1* t i:v.-.*h vc - . r.;* H c TTv-rt r * .r.kor. tr *tc *rrr t wf c \-.rr-C’:* \ff.6pc * tf.l; nr.s s- t -p, md -c • • fS totlior.l ffieevs r»-,.ro r. tr* lt w s ?-1 t'P, n rc n,,t ».t r. f tx 19 Ft': 47->S -10-3- < Icy C' ur t 1 * . 1 fou £S icc.l officers t \>lcr, : 3 rl\.cs r -y r c^mst r..tou 3 is vc.ccin- pnckin. . c ' 1 is p:.ckirc, —l:o 1 ’a* 1 u *11 tho vr.ccin^ with lin, r.ir r_.pul^a cnZ 8201 I c t: it « c tc "ic -irs lv_ •. It w.\s c. Iry prtduct. *1. ivcn tt 8 c l r • x. ; r u plcr.sc cscrl* o wlr.t tils w.'.a? ... Tho vr.ccino W'.o fcr :.rly pr.cho£. : n t-rt tu')o, r. r;lr.sa tnbo. . t t!., ’ Stci or tils -It.as ttj.s t! - *vy vr.ccino. -lc rlr.os hcJ t< *jo capoci .ily tixoJ, tho vrccinc r .s i:opfc in r. V..CUUT.. It V r Vo.;- *. .fflcttl■ t no: ills . pulo vlt'. >‘vt infoct- inr feho vr.ocino . Few, Prcfocorr 3yor ■ . r la ;I s’, po r luck. If I uv; r .l;c,-uoo t< .~t pi tho V.cclno • r in tho ’ c:.y f tho due!:. L*. tho noc! f V. c‘ ‘ w -1 r v: r -n -r apocl-.l tonaicn. If no fll ' xlo eponod fcttoaiatoly without ’.ruckin it nil « c <1 ’ put into it raid the vc.co- • ino w.-.e lirsrl -1 y with tho .-iycoc f Cl.* ns tf" Ich wuro ir. tl o «-nh!:cp, r«;. tl o i fic\ltics ic) 1 •! or.ictoC w.ro thus lv . :;iy ti e. Vaccine still ! unclor r^fri irct. ;r.. Th.nbf c. It 1 .* tc *jo 19 Fab. 7-iWE-10-43aoy Court Ho. 1 flown to «fric^* , Itoto purpose, of tto visit not to tost tto vaccine, but to denonatrato these nnpulcs? A Tto purpose of ttovi.it was to detonstrato those anpuos end the toctoic of opening irrotoc? A Th CUT was craeticaiiy «. .Vs*, only a for people doing cleaning up sc. ,rU-on th reads, and sc forth, .and on ingdry wo loomed . that tto innate3 pore bin- toed ftr «». linie we Were MM »“'• froo tto point of law -f :-’d,n , '■ *t th, hitch .ns, tto or throe of tto stoltors, tto aerugo syst®, cad that was the end tf «>e visit, -hen we loft re saw a Urge group of concentration esnp lnastus nnrcMro in. They were rtn~inr and wnro accccpnnied by r^utr. ergans. O Thjn what was tto inproesim you got there in Bucherwald? 19 Fob. U7-M-#.TD-ao-2a-»felcy Court Sfc. 1 A Itad tho ir.prosd.on that it was a big barracks and trca the peisi' of view of the hypicnists it was extroeely clean, and nado a vory clear im¬ pression. Q Bow, you want hono, that is to Berlin? A Yea. q And Tfhat did you report? X I reported to -• option clef, Profo.sor Sohrolbor «h»t I hove 1 reported hero. Q In thu talk with Dr. Ding, I assur* that you talked with hin? A Yes. q Did you not discuss what case mo deno in those roor-s in which . dooonstratod tho nnpulos? A So, th»t , it is two. I imuirod about tho «<*« in tho o.iEp bacr.uso I had s --on an*- other barracks, and ho ahwad no th,.su things as I hr.vo reported. q to, in the Din. Diary *hloh ho. booh suhnlttod to tho IWbunal, U-.cro 1. an entry about this visit ahloh^ou and Dr. Syor ntd. to Buchan.,..' cn February 6, 19U, but It ==y. raottin: else too, nuocly, n unnber of vaccinations vdth yollo. fever <® pirforted beginning .dth the 9th of F and lasting for several aonths, on! the yellov fever vneoin. used for 00=, frea the OSS Institute In Or-.ore, did Professor Dyer or the :to*»a m=pootor-.te ever get an assiuuraent to tost the vaccine* S,, end that vculd havo boun quite superfluous, because tho off of tho vaccin-i w ro known. C art I 19 rub U7-: - 11-1 - IJj - has .. But it was n_; b * did It happen th .t the Csncontr.ti n Case It c.uld n:t*'.v. c x. fr os, because -..o did n- t i30Uw axgr yullcw fever vaccine at =* . ?he vaccine was locked in a special re¬ frigerator Vx.d was n.t used. It ~i ht have bu-n possible th t in tho cxip the as^sula, ittid; uu tad • penad nt that tirre, was m.- V vr.cci- natl nr. Of c -T-u, we did n t t.-lo it along with us when "e‘* > ft , it «u useless X r ur hod be* . Statist niy explanation V tr.-t I can thiiuc f. Hew .\ny ees i -a such an a pul- c aueutf a. VtJ* ouch cn raipulu iu c-r. vneoimio fifty to uixty pe-plo. ». Nr Jf yfli L-ft o. - / tho pen aqnil. s th re whur. you left* it wjuld nr. -w bven p sainl* t iosuj thos f r accir.ati na? .v. r * j nti :. .in the D • nt. •• » I ...ru -r» .b-vt rixty. But i- y.u a-- j»y ir. the v.Coinati:na? . a. Kthu.-o t s n. r. L3 a f• r it. Q. New, wiln-oc, is itn tr-o t -t thio vaccine"was c plutely .vuvleao ar.i viccir. ti na with It had n of: cf: nhateuuvar, -s ,dally in Comauqr? a, as I h-.vu nlr-ady said, this vaccine w-a obs-lutely haraloao, - v.jr .a; h .rsXul ti. n sn 11 r. v ccir-.s. % .. ~icr. r. ,r.uc .i -ie fr t.? - T. t is qviU i. vsniblo. W. w, f «.r u-turned t Berlin, 1c y u re fr fosa r “uhdl r.r? i r. t. rv - Jv ; r. Did : u r«j> r. t M. >ut =Wo • W .r 1 n P'*V i/« .1 ..7 .. - , .y i n t. r_,' rt t hla* I r«p rUC t t Cr*.-f and i_. t *• c * . icuol pr co -ro. But, rnbf lieva that this affair, which jr u huvt described, 5 s -thin which Gchruibur -- nld hnv«. had t rep rt t Fr foster K&ndl 5 or? -ire C.'JTt I 1? .'_b U7- - 11-2 - LJ3 - r.4Cbsr. S , that ius quite a suberdinate atur, *hich ha took e re f thr.x.h hi3 s-cti n chief. In Conclusion, i should lik- * ask ycu about a *r. did y u knew pr.fess-r Kiiove? * *. Yes, * know hi . «*. where did Fr.foss r Kli^vo w rk? Profess r Kliova worked at the >af onset, at th*. ^rdnandt Office and ho also had a certai n ccntact :dth the Medic \1 *napect rata. Q. What did iia w rk on? rt . no tr i*ud in tr.u field f c -•'.ter xeasuros - ainst tho so-called bictoriulr ical wurfaro, 4 . H u d j u kn that thoy wore c unter b» wires? Ho told c« about it nd ho air ys said tn .t they w*re working cnly n oovntor tu suroa. Per ox-r.plo, there "ao a Puohrer r-.cr that nly dofonao r.oarores were t tu workod n. ^ .. Y-u acy a no :ative -rdor t- .t only d«fensu n.asurvs wore to bo worked on? a. ll « rk could be d m t w acteri l leal an' dvoly, th-ro tt-o pr.hibiti n inat " .st.ri 1 -ic 1 wtrfaro. D- y u havo tho conviction th t that r .o rlehtj that thoy noro w rking - nuantitioa f .-irarorw 3-ru_. hr.' b-or. a.: inist.r,.., tfc .r w r< -*alho *.nu si* ck i. n tho p tionts h: * hen 1 c ntents? a. , • H ' c ntonta *-8 osnti ned as pten 1- .. D j a kr. 71 vfaathar f r ^ ' industries r«i v*. tho ph-n-1 contents fr a tho .;.n;rem. serua? a. i.n, I kn w cb .t that, especially since ftench fir-j pr .:ucod this Borun with ut ch-.n 1 , but industry sUnsibly ciuld n'-t w rk with .t phenol sinso they did nt have or. u. h traino-d p^rs nn«l during the ear ZrZGl C urt I 1? i’cb U7-. - 11-4 - - ---ihaa an-: there was th-.ref-r. dnn_xr f c.ntaainati n by bacteria. •i. '-s .on^rono a frequent c lie:.ti n in w unds? Yus, It waa q^oito frequent in the field, t* Must one therefore say that the pr blen f preventln « rone, Xr -a the .tdical, as veil na fr s tho niUtary p.int of view, can bo called oxtranuly lapartant? a. -03, anb mat a a;* ao. ^ h. Zo ardin, tho aepuloa with yoILv fev-r scruu, y a said bof ro that tho a pul.a which hr/ been op .d wore loft behind in Buchonwald; you a aid bof ro y ur r.utoot difficult! tr.uro wer.. in at rin ani koupin this a-rxi. .. u y u tell tS j Tribunal hew 1 n , in ur pini n, the auru.. c„uld be k«-.:t in the --wpulo? .v. ih't depends n li they ’.jro handled; and if they wero iunediatol- oltiood and put ir. froeair. tcoporwir, they si ht be kept nu day. Q» 1 aa thinkin of tr.o a^jului which y.u left behind in Buobonraldj wore thoy cl Bud i^.ueuiaUjV after they vuro pen-d r wero they laid to no side? a. Thoy *uro lyii r. tho table. %• at. ib ut d 1 1 n were they Jyin th-re? 4 1 cannot a ; . : i la tiao r-xi half an hdnr at tho n st. wall, rntneas, y u apeko f paaait .gurus o .inst bocterlel ic :l .arfaro and y u ad.' th .t ur » enta h id r jp. s-ted hot Russia was propnrln frar. activu irfaro with p is^n? •• , - dii n.t .ear that. t vrccir.iti.na. was it oust afliy in •.r.o -tr y bef r v tho . on-.r .1 ir.tr “ncti n f a new vaccine first t. tort •■a effect t h j vaodho n - 5 ill t up f pers no and eb. vo all .ho reactions ir. r ’ur *. kr. w what the c.riiUi'lily f U.c vaccine *,tb? • if it wax -c’.ually a type f vaccine this sis d re n •v luntears, ■ ...b-.vs £ the -ary and nasb-rs .X the llilitsry .^dical -vcac.ry, hat ia students. 1 ? r-c- -J. -12-1- _1 t C urt I .. ul! y u c-nsi cr it e roX-M r iir.aponsibl. if such = n.w vr.ccino wcr. us..-:, rcijin. ,r. th« st-.t»:,nts by th. cr hicin. firi -b ut cupv tioility, wite ut V-stia v.ccin. in nqy i n - s.. r.ll ir .up? “* ' n ‘‘ 6r; ’ ul - ' c P- r * . r -'ucc' it. If it*-ui r.- # ai kmiMi iir= * h r - a ' biilt y h '' ? r v - ■» I W-WW "*t c nr 1 r r, Mt ifcCMBory, In thar c's-a, yos. A ~^ * °* Thank 7*u. I b.-.y- r. further cuccti ns. ?• . ..":T| le th.rc any further cj pgrint tl n f tiii« rdtn-c& .y any r’cfonsc o nn»tl7 Thera -civ. nr.,, . - . Drcu iJ# C«0S5 X. 1*QTIC:‘ . *• ltacM * ot oil - r i -• - i ur pait. n ir. tU a. *ictl •• • -rvctiy aub.r ir.-tc.'.? A. I v.-r. Ilroctlj :••• : -aaar fichroibcr. .. ~n' »n 'i ;• uhivb r-Ln n • ? • '' • • . eltor nr. ... Pootsoh , . phanaciat, “r. Iftfcnn , : . , .. itb butv-cen ;n.-ra »1*0 ~.r,' • i? thtrv antn - h - *- • l i n poet r-.tv., 19U0 -*• - - r bl - ' * ' t.vrhue vneeinue v. ch fa «f . i rt f c nf.ct • rr i cbT’et-r? - ’ " 1 s_r? “c it "roqr^nt • : , : rc- r S' i r zng r;.zT. K ^ rf i - . n chit f, . ■ r - wsccfcl chu: c . C> r,B8 r Icc.r fur r. *. rt r.- •ir-.otl’- tv at-*-:. i tbjs c .-n, - CC-.V: . -*iji j - :t-n r-& rti-ij, ^r,-ctly • 16 . 15 Fob— —Jr—12-2—*' .1 t C urt I t H~-n I r_r? ... L’cT rcur.-.tcly 1 0 a. t Ur. u. >.to rhan Fr f..ss.r Sehrcibcr left the .a-;* . ic -1 Inspect ntc, ant! I . nt thin bore. “ it that cv. pr. j-.oly bo 5 urv’ in the record. -• 0 *•-' -'-r when Schroibor 1^'t -X ..rry -’c-iccl L.spcctcrr.to? •». Mo, I -l n *. re. -racr tbs p-r. A .. .hy i ha le’.vo? 0 y.ul.uw? ... Fr r Schreit^r • - .'icor f Instruct! n Or up "C" ■>f tJv. ’ illi-ry o licil ..c- ’vuy, ti:t he iucr *„ - ,-wbtr cf the Reich Berreh C.uncil. i. That ’ oen't oocu t. leal jnaptoet-r-.to, if ho biccsc instruct r -f the iiit-r c Me-? .. - ;.. * .5 it? ... i r, t.. s. r - qilt l - c . . ilii-:-- oiical ;»cr.*'eny In •-1 f trn» instructs nr . . :• ■■ J Inapoebcmtc, etc it n t? * Xes, -*v ietru., att . v tore r 8chroi!--rr c n t Ivootty un or tho ” " "c ..yin 1 • s - loopootcr*to« J. Is-.', ii trv. t. . cv '• : -3 :n ' kw n 1' the pini-.n that ani.'-'l oxpjT entr.ti n rita t’-'"3..r T r- „ *>aci r bec-ur.. f tv. I ct that r ’ ' ^ x . : so? •“ : 1 ~ ! -n. f r . - ’.ri:. a r r * c* inihe atn$o - f-r osperisental *--r tn V «v •» used. .• , - • a ? rop-.rb, 1 r ' * - pd-'-ivr. r-s hil» qr certai* • .1 x.rtr V t -;.i .’.I o-?.rL ., 1 . L n 4 , , : " i'ncls .in rasist-.noj t. : ..r y.u ewe-rin that v M-wc •a * • f ▲ J C urt I • , rc : r_ r ts Bb -it it, r roa c Tty rtLei in n. ’ic'i j am - .Is? I tUate-j, in rsy pini n, it * truo, :: testing * ... . t th-.t : ? teats c*n . cn' ct. • r. - i - 1 : - r.ll. > n't 1 rv. anawcr&’tha questJ n. Istt r .. n »'ith typhus ic . i wilablo? Hi tm* cr yes r r. • I t* n t to • f this ; I . Tlvn if tl; ’-.f... -nt .rl r . : ..-pr-rs. • sue". r« plni n t thi Fribunr.l, .. to w'thot ho a as ttldn \ it? r.. viso£tlu Tritwftol th"t he th ..t it nr pr b-.ni, a recuse r. t x;<-ri tnt n totiitn ocin s , : 'IT ,'i •>? It Is » * ; pl-.i •« Ur ; t; h vi or >. -i entr us* :«c c n'uci n huoan jo 1 u*s« * i: ■- —i2-i--?ci' C VsTt . 1 ■ - . u lav- rfccth-r certain _ri. .:jV 2 antwls hive resistance t t; ins? Is it eust-.uary t...it ftcu t ;v v? •* i-tinca i s—'in' tfc.oo * . ac mindc c ncuii. '—tJscra arc : - tL„3 cith ut -x.in -Jifoctc • ith t -:us, Skips : ncrc sc:. tovcratrreo^Ut - r Ms r ac . i r . n ' ..r are tcicn t oliuinctc sue.'-. inaccuracies. '! Criticise -en lcvoll. : it the erori-xnt.-.l iicth-'u: .X the institute at Pranld * .. In'.us try a nctiico qute-i nc* t. esc testwe satoy'x, sircc induatr, . % itself crllc ' the vaccine t ' iriiiic -lx staU institute aai*. Eat it res 0 Toctivo > wo thcref re reject- *. it. This was the vaccine tlict I : xntl.no'. oC.*.re. " • -- 1 * y 4 . enti rv. a thin .V i iMs 1 o'.rin ./erico, tli- vaccine 2 Wfed b;- their institute at nr/ur. ' .in c ir a the o-i'-ryo in r. chicko •’ ’ °~* *ou weren't o-^oldn, a! at thair total ;-r?OucU:n, waro yeu? They. 'id r >uco vccaincs level .cl'j> n tio 0 j 15:, i '.n't they? .. Tea, U.-rt ore tw oti V hioti In tlw first .lnco the c_':r/c is us>:.. Then a r or ntit; of vaccine is sL-taiuc.*, \In tho 0 c .'^acc the eabry is n t use.:. Is u 0 footivo bet a a&allcr quantity, j uno.! nly this latter ty.o idthrut the uao r Era L.'.ryr n tlx * asia ; J>. roc .cn'iti n X th- state in- BtitutC. > ' tao i... rcssi h with U.v Tri*. inol tleit the «r.y Ix.licnl Ins ;ct rr.V. nr.s rojcctin ill ,f the ty. hur •* r _. That Vs a t true, is it? " 1,1 i- net say that. I &.; u t. t th-re r.-orc t-.t. v eoinoc r ■ r - • ri»« tno vaccine tra quit- an? another uwin;* the -* n tr._ ' isis X thin v;.ini< n, which was c nsieJorod —' . r-'cctiv., -n ’a;! net use it. Cl 3 y u ko - an r.--e: vver. Hc^on? — YeSe i*r> hi-.. : up: . i -I2-2a-?d *t : hcl‘. the sane ini r. th - y v !iu -• ut this ty Inis vaccine ' - • . t trite letter ;.e it. yeu kanr anythin;; =T Wet? »■ • i4 •!: • >4ir.t c nt-.cts i ! y*u bar- wit Hr. cr.? .. I n c ntnets •'ith A = . =11. I^t bin n e cersi n oinec I tea a hyricniot. i !c; •• that .. —5 a .rafeso r ct 8tr sm’iut . n . . 'r.r v.-ccLxa, 'l'ji't y.u? '•*“»« ftc W.S at the n ' ri " oh Institute he rr.r. wr.'riiy n the rime fid’. Wfia't y a kanr U it vacclno c:: rlacaitc* \c vneoin- ox. crlitfnte, aft-r h. loTt the * rt * cl* Institute at Straaalur,-? a n . Q Vvu have aev.r ' con ta Straw'wr s-t Idji? “ . 0 . Jii: ycu usually -.tun t. hoc. tin c r ttu, c noultin sicir.no f tho an:,-? I ittui.a few txct'jva, a a t all i then. Q '"rich noa ‘iO y u at ben;’.? .. I can-, t say f r curt^.:. * «t . ary iv «hich o;.cific --♦in fi : attcalc i.~rc wore sh ut Bw* t «iioc«. flsi. y«u raaotfjsr taideh «r.co y u at^nflpd? J printer that I 1 ’ . . *» 3 neotin at E hoa-luochon. ■..'ell, !i ■ J U att a 01 at J... idH&zy and •here ;-:v were • rhin;? » i n t ‘11 f ticn. • . j ro-.cci f t.h Ino-ect. rat c vil r * • •• r I ir n 12:3 *d 7 . Tri'- 1 ’ 1 c.. mtll -•3S 1 clcc!:. U r •--- - taken 1330 hours.) IS y,b -A-~C-L4-1- car C'vrt Jr. 1 ZI3 URSSAL: Sfcs. 7rlbu:.a2 is a_ai : in sossi .. T!. S2D2: (C uriscl - r thi -lofoadant Forte Oborhausor). Fr. .rosidor.t, th lofoudant Dr. Fort a Oborhausor askfl in vi rli::. It ia *uito pas ibio that i attoaHofl :.:r noitio., at lo*ot i .a: »to Cttaafitf id looturos. 1 I q::.-ao y u attorned ;hi lootur.o = .'.ocralu. hyclor.lc pr>bluao? A P at ray ho. 1 c ulln't toll ; that f r oort-ia. '.'oil, ’ll y u ttcuaily ntto: ’ tho .x,otl:cJ rhoro th- aurcocna -.oro hcldii* rtth? A , : * - wost t phys - late. * D • J P :riU' re « -r at t: at no .tin- in at the Hyyionio i t at D at - Dir /* ;„ tall: hi; ox'xjrinQnts? • : - by Dr. Di-. at any ti .. ' H &,.t Dia^ ' ' I ca* t r_ . t r iir.t. -S 7-t 17-A-3JC--.-.-B- ; urt If • 1 A no, I eona t toll.ycu that, o Do 7-u *hr.t Ding Wnfl dolao? A I only Sr: a that ho bol-n^od t: tho crllr.bcmt rs of Prsfosaor firugcwaky. ^ D ru i’.» that ho w-a working in Buohonwald -ftor you first acit hia? A H-, I didn't kn w that. ^ Hew naay tima did you soo bin Ir.tor? Did yen h-vo froquor.t cont-.cta with hie? «. i A !!3, I only .oot hie ^a cao ~r tvs occasions r.t tho nest. I hod no ;xor- wanoX centreta with hir. at all. x o Di’. y u hr.vo my c strata with Krug'vsky? A Yob, in a- for nr. hygienic problems v so alcco port -.f tho "nffon-ss v\b out rdluatcd undor tho Aj-ry. I royrrtod r.b-ut that bofTo. % H v frcquontly di'. y u fcwa c ntr.ct with Jirufrvafcy? A Vary rarely, only toloph nod u-.ybo onoo 'r t.rico q yoar. At any r.to, vory, vary, ror-ly. *\ Did y u «.v,r c nault with hie c nc oral as syjbua yr-bla-a? A »•, a do you kn~w that thoy had a 'fc'pfcno producing oatabliaheont r.t Buchonwold? A 1 to, I only ruo 1 that tut horo. *1 I suynoa j y u know !>r. ‘blgl? A A ?r foon.'r "olid* Yor I saw hi : :r.co who.: ho vial tod Crrc.v. \ as a att-r f f-ct, wasn't ho u rkin* f r the. Ary, Or. /oigl? A Preface r "oi 1 was working os a baotorl le^at in th. instltuto f*r I T7?huc 2ocoareh in Sr-c:v r La-.burs* Tho natkrds ho usod f r tho -reduction - V'.ccir.a: woe takon ror l us. - 'foil, but ho was att-chod to an-' wrkiag f*r tho /.my, won't ho ir. v.‘ 13-12? .. Yo», ho w-.s o eivilioa -uplcyoo, : t speak * Ar^., tho Amy trJo hie available t- the, 3cbring •'Tried now plant at -■ • -r. -idn't thoy? : r , tho Qohmacht nado hir: available, rs I arid bofTo, fer the iaati- ■ ~ a Typhus v-ccinnti a -reduction .* tho industry, that is to cay, P±r! _ •• jk s , only in rdor to incrons a or eduction cad in era or to toaoh than ?f 31t. 19 ?— C-14- r -3ocr- C .-JPt V . 1 I the, tochnic? uhlch ho -orol no '. n That Is vhnt I soil, tco /xny ntdo "old ar-Alablo to tho HohrinG "arks »> they o"uld start - TrrJucin^ 7 lent at Ixmborg; that is ri;.ht isn't it? A Yos. o Then did this ;r luctl-x plant at^xiborg boi.in its cjornti ns? "hon *il it actually got 1st: Typhus vacclno .r luction? A I boliovo no pr-ducti :: f any rsx unt cr;x> p.t-rut siaco tho technical insbnllati as bx uiht ab ut sclq toohmccu. difficulties, since no cctual ^ ;r luotica eculd c:ao ub'ut. At any rat , 2 aover hoard that no rocoivod ■ 7 Typhus v-flcinor froi ti:o:. for tho pur;*so of tho Amy. * • Don't you roaabor, r ighly, Aon thoy actually bognn opor-.tlcns? t-u rccanbor that tho plant hadn't boon built at tho first Tart :f 1941. Nov, n't y -a roar thoso details. n s j said boforo, It was bocauso wo didn't know whuthir it was doliv-r-d to us by the Behring 'forks. I only knew that no substantial quantities case fron t hare which wo woro to uso. 3 If you ft t my foil vaccine free th j Bohriny rks, you certainly kn-jw it caao fron that plant in La&berg bocauso that was the only place they woro producin' tho 0 I 7 I v.ccino, oxcopt in the two CKH Institutosj is that right? A I didn't quite unuratand that. q I said if you rot any foi^l vaccino fror. tho Bohring ’V’orks or any¬ thin- 0 I 30 you ten-* it had to 00:00 fron th? Behring "forks in Leiibarf? buoauso thoro wan only three places in all of Goraary ai^ I think in all of Europe prottadn? the *oigl vuccinoj ©no of then was the OEK Institute'at Cracow, tho OJ'H Institute at Loraberg, and th Sshrl&g 'forks at Lonbarg, three places? A That 13 quite correct, but I had 1 * list at all about tho amounts of vacoin or th? way th vr.Ccina wr.c produce . It ms not ny task, you soo. Tha vaccine was distributed by tho min aodicol supply office. 7 q in tho jdioal Inspectorate only ©alt rith tho question of whether sonebo'y will rot « vaccina or net, but net that kind 0 :' vaccine they wore to otj so, I know n ‘•lin-f about tho ■uacunt of vaccines. I f only know hat amounts ware available th. b'3ic rf the list which I rocciv, d from tho Chief Ilodic.al Supply 19 : b. hi-. l-».TD-U*-2a-Boerd Co-art So. 1 q yi-I you cntrcl tfr:- allocation of lyphas vaccines for the chrmcht* 1th reference to the vaccines which wo roceivod ourselves, it was distributed by us to the various /ehrracht branches acccrdinr to tho size cf tho opid/adc, and tho a.cunt cf people that wore there. Arc you referring to an iirroatination of vaccine, osybo I don't understand you ccrroctly. Q No, I should think tijoro would have been a central agency in Oermny which vac advised about tho production of vaccine, who vasproiucing it and how nuch« I should else think that this . ;:on lict. l'rca Frcfts 3 cr Syer since otherwise I or tho Medical Intj tern? * would have i .. raed about thet situation or «c would have been as* .jrsission. 1 -xplained that before, sc the vaccir. of the CKK cannot bo included. in th ? case there only roaains the Behring Corks in Leribcrg. It nay bo the Bt-hrin-: corks in Marburg fer instance had scce lico. I den't knew about that. 3173 1? ? >r- • r: -..-DcG-i5-2-Cock G'-rt 1 'i -.her. did the Echrift; lories . Lusters ret th-ir lice fro:-, from .. i -i when hw c^-.e cv-r fres dyer's I- -tituto? .. _ dt-.'t lexer tfept. Lice ore ell cv-r the world. -ne only hat tc -iv»• lice suck cn any typhus diseased porson in order tc ret such lice, thet is ill thet i3 r.eccssery. * q Thit say tc true, vitness, tut suppose you tall us hew srny places In Cerarny rare in the business cf cultivttin C typhus infected Uce? „ '..nerevsr typhus occurred. •; :Jo»., ltn-ss, Jtu aren't suggesting tc c° around and look fer typhus * inf^ctad lice, re you, I r.ox. thet we should get lice and feed then typhus infuctvd .I::d, tt. * isn't the wey tc do that. In ether words, hew liany places in Ownerny ner. actually cultivating typhus inl'ect^d lice, riny place besides Iho CKH in Krejeew, the CliH in Lei .rj, rnJ the B.hrinr berks in Lcctcrj. Those rr- the or. y three .-Irccs, isn't that ri ht? • • „ Yes, they arc the criy plocos whero lice w„ro cultivated, tut you can alnays build up such a breeding place rhero you went to. Q He* I tnink you told 'Jnn-owciy's attorney that the typhus vaccine situ.ticn ta3 so critical in the letter part of 1941, that you only had ,.r.ce;h coins tc innoculcta doctors nr.i nurs-s and other people who were ir, vor; expose! places, is that rieht? . k Y*.s, th:.t is correct. I , therefore, assume that typhus vaccine 'list have buon allocated vdth considerable cere, is that rieht? .. Y\ , according to the Cv-v.ds of thv individual 1 chraucht brrnchos, who naturally had to c denends. lidn't kn » -rythir.r eteut the ?itu._cn. 3174 19 V--~-.\-13-I--C k Ccurt I .. r instance, if the alien SS sai-. then, "wc nee-' 100 litr..c", y. u just a-.': b*ck in j or chair an scidj C&uh, *ivc then 100 litres," and shipped it .ff t Gonz:-xn -v-r here - ’-i'r.'t .r.y n.ay .attention tcwhnt he >3.1 with it, is t'.v ri t ht? % h-.-v.v-r, the ehroacht ir-cioh* aeon-led 2 cert-in a .3 unt ;I "X" v.-.ccinc then we tri--' t fin* ut whether w- hod = sufficient asunt f vrccine and we istr ' th. vnccioo ir. nee rdanco with what was available. - •iccri- butw it t tha c.'ic'i Supply O'ficc f that chraneht Branch an' that con¬ clude 1 cur 1 .'.ak. ' ;• it neat, I interested in ;• . rin. h * Dr. Din;; n the 5th f January, 1?L2, six •‘ays aft r th. eetin; < n te 29th f December 1$>’:1, at which } ur -tan Sch le ^tten u iv.:‘ btained a suf.'iciwnt ar. ur.t f till vaccine t f tart ar. - p..L.-nt, urln to. c urae I ehich he artificially iniected a substantial r up f pc pic? ... If V- 1 ,r_ c r.curn^ 1th t - ei 1 vaccine it must h-vc c r ;a th- rin a.’ic.al supply office :r .. Ui- .affon SS. .hen this ccurrcd ve c ulrtlT kn w occaua*i v;_ i'r.'t ( :n » »h-r. th. chi... x ic 1 supply f.'ice delivered twe- vacciixs 1 their r up i hr nofc.s. .• .'• '-his vaccine xcopt trout U •, lid they? •ind ■ u ‘i 'n»t h v .. ugh t inn dilate the fcr dps? Ten c ul dust give it t ctcrs an’ nurses, c ul n't yeu? Hew ycxtoll .x y u doliv-rad a subrtnn- ticl on.ur.t -f this vaccine t. the SS in j-riin -n-' then! r t nb ut it? ... e-rsu.. that thu SS in the very itx way ul use that vaccine 'S it -ran ' e -3j t: th-r hm-.cht ranchos, t’ ~t is t say, ivc it t the . r- - : 'I r ;r e:.,l. a i • . rt: . r typhus vaccine Into in 19-1, »!uit y.u • -> ut r-‘yi-t. t>-.. ri-unti r.? ... ?iu ara,- .. Heal Ii , in ustry in the pr .•ucticn f vaccines. _ er.ti n, that acf .ro. .. Didn't y.u fill * that siteti novtty carefully. ; in i o. a evst .xr f thx. phar actratlcri industry toe? 3175 asr.'t the .any C urt I a. Ek in ustr; uf t tir.t .t bvicurly 1» n -roat interest in pr . . £ T?eeina, an it is a mtt&r ■' c ursc that this wns - quca- ti.n - '-rosin as : r l..'us try, ?.n the ^reduction T the typhus v'ccinc is very uxpenaivo, ... thit c ul fcr.v. b,en t: - rur.a.n why ir. ustry was n-t very intcr-ste ’ in tnis ustt^r. a. ‘ hy ’ . * s..r. * y ur nan Sch lz t this /...tin, .r. Dcc^.: cr 29, 19L1? . .. • • r. .r s cut r. ft didn't send hln r~. .. itl , '.cisaunt by Cr'Koltc c nc-rhiny a ntetirv .-1 in the : «nistry i - - rl.r r. t ho 2Vth D.ce;ib-r 19l»l # at xhich typhus .r 'ucti r. on ' typr.v- v .cc r. tostin was ur. .-r lacuoo\on, in* that t.i- r.prec.nt tivc . j Boh it, an-' y j w. re h;j i o iitc su r wh t pur»> s*. ns Seh lz Os»nt t tlile ;*at\.v ? C-urt 5-. 1 19 Jet -.7-A-16-1 -SW-Malojr *. I he vo el ready said that I dldn': send this can there tut that thie nan repreaontad.ee during ty vacation. Of course. I didn't send hia to that acetic. I vean't there to do that. q, Vhat vra the tLray dole* there? Vhy were they interested? A. According to that invttrtl-n I think vo are concerned with on invi¬ tation of tho Belch Minister A the Interior, and circlea interested in tho jroduction of ty-ihus vrcclnct vere invited, anon* then the'Vay Medical In- aoectcrate, vh-te representative Dr. Scholr vea. v D-yiu reccnbcr having received cay report on this aeetlrwT? Vhat trrnaptrod there? A. I have already said that I vat infuroed abeut thla nootlnc by Dr. Scholt tut I den't reuentor tho report ltaelf. It la very iopmbablo that I roa.d It aytclf. v Vltneaa, prra,:raoh B in there arya Stfaethln* ftbeut toatln,: thoao o*v yolk vaccinoe end acne body hr a to aeo Mruovky about Denalts, didn't acnobody have O' nothin.: to a ay ab ut that? A. I cmn-t reaonbor theae detalle. I aa auro he nuct have rsoortad that to ac. Vc are very concerned with a Dr. Denalts, vho vas representative of the Industry end who vas to ri.lt Dr. Kru*ovsky. but vo arc nbt concerned vlth a nenbSr of the Medical Inspectorate. q, Vltneaa, to «ot it rather narrovly nuv, tho vhole Purpose of con- tactln,: Kru^vsky va. to teat thi. o*; yolk vaccine, of vhich you vero afraid. You had. confidence .nly in tho Voi.:l vaccine. I think the array as a vhole ha ,ycc.t Intorost In the «*,: Y<>lk vecclnc produced by the 3ohrlnk Vorka at Harburs and by tho Robert £-ch Institute in Berlin. »ov, didn't they toll y,u about that? A. they told ne that the Bchrln,: v.rke, r.e before. Insisted that thio vaccine vhich vc refused because A its late-effectiveness, had been uroved successful after their investigation and fr^ that, in ay opinion, the note in this d.cuncnt can bo explained, vhere It says that any other party vhich vr.e not Interested, like Industry, vould. have to test this vaccine. ^ •witness, you see it is not ouite so slnolo because only tlx days 3177 C-urt S-. 1 15 Ieb 47-A-16-2-SH.-KB1: y later, JefiOArv 6, 1S-2, Dr. Din.: in ruchecn Id started te-stin.: this e« yolk vrccinc. -hat vrs the vh -It uurn-oe star tin,: the ex^crincnto in Suchenvnld -n livir_- hunan be In.;*, during the course of which several hundreds «.f then vre killed; thrt vro the very pnrp-se -f the Buchenvrld exnerlnents to toot this -k.’ y-lk vaccine. ! r— suA;«sti*« t y<-u the- aray was very nuch inter¬ ested in the teet in.: -f this vreeir nod thrt you very voll knew they wore •r-in.: t. toot it ft 3uohenvcld. Isn’t that true? A. So. I oust deny thrt very energetically. I underotrod thie note no x I arid tof.ru by kn-vlc#: th /1 this lo '.eroly in Investigation ef the vaccine in r.n cniuel oxoeri :«nt. I r.i not convinced 1 1 nil that any ouch vaccination .a the hu;:en heir. v.uli brink about r reoult which vr.s of any value, for in thio case, f-r no car. novor laltete tho bi-,l-. s -icol ccndltlcna which nonly t the hu-an beings oo that t. *et a tlul^lcnl cxneri:.-ont the reoult, in iy .pinl-r., v.uld to of n. value at all. D. * understand y -u t. state the tyohus oxoorlrionte -n huoan bwin^o ere -f n. valueT A. According t :;y -oini n they rre ct lo. ot f n- lno-rtance. I cannot enlrin f.sy i.. rtmeo ot all. Vere-crlly, I think they rre ef n value. v I r.: cure that It will to .f intorost t. Dr. Din*. H v, lot’o «<. tr.ck t y ur visit t Buchon’-rld In February 19*3. Just exactly whey, okain, did you there with Dr. Ayer? a. Initially I arid I stated thrt the oueeti n wuo to send n coaalceion ,f ohyolclcno there t show thou h-v the -typhus vaccina vr.s proonrod and In .rder t show then h-w the difflcultioa which urcvj.ilod uo t that aunont, aracly t diae-lvo the dry vaccine, wore evorc.:vo. This CoonlssioB f oicinna, as It wrs >r -vldcd, vtro t vrcclnrtc tho tr.-.oo rikbt tJierp lu Africa, because the transo-rt f 3178 19 Feb :7-A- AA-16-la-Kalcsr Court ; ! o. 1 the vaccine by ordinary channels, that is by aedical supply office, war iir-ossible since the vaccine is to perishable and can too easily be destroyed and i*. could not be preserved under freezing degrees. f, That is yellow fever vaccine new, and not typhus? A ’Jo, that was yellow /ever. Q And wJy did you go to Wei.-..*, is that where you went to visit to .Teiitar? A I tias told that this was to be presented in the vicinity of beimar, where tho SS was. 3e were to be fetched there by the SS and then sent to the place whero this presentation iaa to take oiaco. Q You were Just scoins the So doctors in TTeinar, is that right? A I don't quite get you. TFould you lease repoat? Q I say, you were soeing only t!e SS doctors of tliis Cc-idasion in ‘/oicar? A Yes. Wo wero to presont this dissolution of tho vaccine to tho SS physicians at i'oisar. Q What SS doctors were on tlds C omission that was going to Worth Africa? What wero thoir nar.cs? A I cnly rcoeuher the naac of Dr. Ding. Witness, are you tollin'. : mission t on n Cofic-icr. tliat waa ;.oi;y to be flown to ,!orth Africa to vaccinate save- troopr with yollow fever vaccine? A I do not know whether Dr. D .ay vco to do that, but I a. smio that tlicso fen.* physician# who si- that ..v* -o *-rc:U: other piyeicioiu: in order for i to racticc this nfmner :f vaoc^na .. There were only a row pk.-ricians ssed t at. I wouldn' t arsuoo t.^t only these f an pStysioions voro t' fl; :c Africa. I an sure tlrro aart avo beer. r.orc than that. at wore, the aaacs of 5000 of these other SS doctor 3 ? A I regret I can't rnadnbor any of tJi-_ other naoos. ~at is unfortunate. Ard ow nan; were thero? A Five to six, I think. High ranking doctors? 3179 I ' 1? rcb . ~-k~. AA-l€-2a-.-2lo7 Court :;o. 1 k She gcntlaxn rerc dr.ss.l ir. v.dtc coats, and jl oouldD't tell. ..!>crc or-j this da_ itra.i.n carried out? said it in ar. one. kxi of the baa . TJw exup • itself consists of a iw=r- :r ci barroetw such ante- roou a tool; ms erected ..ilr presont book • . . Tids ms in BuchciroCd c itself, it vasn't ir. .foiuar? 7 TC nor : - *-chtd oa fro . oar, os I raid 19 ?ob-3SH-16-lb-; >.1 ; - C'-.urt I.’:. 1 * “- rv * irlv-r. t* >xchor-.~*. 11 , -al t!.ia .rosjct'.tion occurrol ir. Bucijn«“.ld itsolf. *1 ? ®»° i14 "' u tr-v -1 free to t-t to BucLaauLi, did y u . • • • l-erllr. ;r c> a fm. Ir'.crw? A », I c m 7rc- 3crlin. 1 HMT9 11 Hr. 3yj» e- -a fro? Or. ly-r :•*• bean in Berlin boforo. ^ 'i *••’• -11 7 u 4: durla: thla lor astrr.tlon, I rtrc-».«r a-r-othing It % ' • 36 it? is thf.t rlfht? /. th-*/ la i:t aulto Ti.lit. I • : . ,t!_ ; t- bo flU-i, «nd -lt.rfrr.t tho ttl© V’ c. be. t r~l 1 ,c-.uao n thu llctlj 7i ; . Lvofl, Zr. tho M O r i: Trxolnp Vottloa it ccysi A'.!!:’ h jpona t t:.o (.Iom in 5:3, a lac a •. tjc — 1 •vo i-Mkir.s thla "Vi-rj-.l •-> Volta*, o t'.-.-.t v. mich liatljguinhod o-'-ti—a -■ . . 1.1 fr... r. •ni;t 1^. 61: j o wifctf ii' n •.. >, •* .*> .r tol . ivu «■?. ;/.• uu i: •• * f "V * ■ • . I», , “W. *\| l A f •otr-.tol to • c;* -J; thj Jl- i ~ -0 It; 1c t‘:~.t : .-t y u -..-a tTvi ur-l - J i'.COe *J . . :r ^llovj? -..’.I t. .. 133 . 1 VO It laa*t i." • • * c^on tho % -ulo, . . jr. ■•3 nttar S tao Uoa luti n f tto- sal .. i - t, - it la 19 Feb 1:7- a - LJG - lieehan n, aell, you tau ht the SS cen firs*., then tl:e whole thin was dropped ani yc did not do arythin .acre. Is that ri ht? a. iO merely trained the S3 physicians and then preserved the vaccine in rder tc be able t- use \t at a iver. tine. «. fcitn&as, did you not see the typhus experimental station when you wore in Buchenreld? a, ri o, I already said that i did net know that such a station was there. «•. Dr. Din did not tell you that he was c:.rryin~ or. a typhus experi¬ ment although you woro in Buchenwuid. Is that ri.ht? a. Ho did not tell o anythin about it. Ycu know they had an experiment . edn cn the vuiy doy y u were there; they wore testin «4o4dla and bethyleno 91uo in the Bohrin.; Works, lou w^ro actually familiar with those dru s, were you not? a. Ho, I know nothin about that. *cu never hoard f Akridin and !ethylene Blue? • iu «ero concornod with ..ethylene Slue, which is somethin.. which wo used in uedioino f;r vanp years, but I cann.t kn.-w for what purpose it was used tr.oro. F r decades it as ijed in laboratories for oolorini; purposes, akridin is a yallca-colorad x unt arri I do not know what It is used for. It absolutely did not ccr.com qy sphere ~f icrk. Haw Ion; were j u ir. the ruc'.v -Id Carp? ‘ a. I already said that i stayed Mt.ro f r ab ut n- and no-half • hours. .. los, I recall you sai:: y a sav a r-up cf happy, -ll-fed * rkors •'■urchin . ack tc the camp sin ir. . a. -e3, *• saw a column, -wiich marched past as ne went out bain acccr:pini.d by a harmonica r so ethir. . d. Did they act like happy bo> 6ccuts? •v. That I could act jud o. -!• Kc»* ycu apparently don't kr. t anythin about these .-ellow fever vaccine testa that Dr. Din carriod cut frr y a in Bachonwald, cla you? Court I 19 r =b 1:7 - A - 17-2 - LJ3- ^eebaa .i. ^ already said that Dr. Din die n t io any yellow fever testing f r us. %• y u s c-. -ed the ;:-ssibility that ho kept four or five of those ar.pul=s f vaccine after y*u h- fce-r. th.re and he ci ht h vc conducted so::-j tests •' his ..wn 4th these. Is tout ri.ht? «. This pcssioility exists. ft 4. .* 011 , I want t.< dor castrate it t y.u that thi.ro is nc such possibility, litr.jc:, y u • .r ts.ro n Kibruiry 8th, lvi-3. titr^ss, lock «n ; i u nine. *. Yos. Soo thoro r-.oro it says Fbbrcay 3, 19U3* "•'isit f Gsjrstabsnrzt Dr. ajcT tree, the Institc o for onetted F„ver ant Virus Roaaurch of tho OKH in Oralcow and ^joratabsartt Dr. Sch-.i It fr *rcy *o . 571 ? a. ios. 4. ^ Fa „ 5 f the . r,: rt, under j; . Ill, you will find an r/ ' r 0 - " » • - *7 i" « .-ntic ii ind conferas with tho :-y in the Din . . I n nr .ok y u t. .1 k at tho • ■ r f ur visits. Bend then a air., it say 3 cn the nth f February, 19U3« «7isit f the clinical - .tier, by (fcorstebaarat Dr. Btft and ft-rst ±s :r=t Dr. Scheldt." and -n tho 2Uth of ut vst and 3rd f September anc the 29th f Soptorf>er. iou alwaya find the dosi. nation visit by these various visiters. Fren toe use cf tho word usually used in aUltuy chamois, e* ycu say what 3185 Court I / 19 Fob 1*7—w - 17-5 - LJ3 - _ohea tho basic difference is whether you consider srnethif. as a visit r ar. inspection? '*• Tha (jxjrossi-r. "inspection" is only usud when oau is c ncamoc with f-icial rolctionahiis -sf subordinates ond sup_ri;rs. If sciiobidy visits with ut axor official s urco, that is t. say there can be no official rolati nshlp between tho visitor and tho tne -hat is b:in • visited. %. I r.-.vu no fttrt-.er questions. 3166 C.urt S-. i IS 7cfc -;7-j,-18-l-iSK-7elftt —(C.unacl for the defendant ..ru,-v S ky): ._r. President, I ask y u t Jvreit e that I c -ulf ask another f c v ouesti r.s a the fcpeio of the ou.oti as out ty the or eccut -r. YHh rJiSIZillC: C unosl -ay ccvd* * Swisher iz^.zsszzca rT US. ILLsUs v itR.oe, y.u hi vo st» ted thi t the toctia,; -f tjnhus vaccines r. hur.cn teic,:# vrs f a- value. *>tt y .u ever v.r : with tythuel A, 3-. X V In that cice y ur Ju* w-at at ut the value f the tyohuo csnerlacnto •• lo r. t derive/, -a the hails f y ur .v& o c rs .ad oratricnce vith tyohuo vlruoeo Mf tjrofcus v; ec.ir.esl *. S. v Y u or id y.urswlf thi t the toctla: noth 4 the ty-.huo vicolr.cs :.n the talul which v*r« carried. ut by the instituto it Frankfurt n KMn wire -artly rtticke: :y industry. Have y.u ray rers-n t believe thrt this Inter¬ ference -a the tert i the Industry vre ur. fc *uctificdl .e. I have a reis-a t. Cellcvg that - veil, y.u no, thlo lc r scientific oueotl a Vhlch hit a t yet :-cr. s,:.e/. Thrt It vfc* *. oryo la tho d cusor.t that o c kind ,f a unified testis: atth ft vw t =e defined. Vi, rt nay rrto, topt t the itati lariitl rtl n because thrt, f r us, v fD the nr.-jer ruth rity. Witness, d. y.u'ka •• ^..ther the tr*:hut virus in the enro f the cnl- vrn trin-s r'. ut e diseice vhlch In *ver" »ry cm *-c c- '.nrrci' t <• d.lstrse of o hunca to in-: 7 "• She typhus virus has a such effect. v Thea v.uldn't ae have t- sey thrt the Uotia f tyohus vi.oclaec a hu.rr. beln.,6 vts a-t vith ut vrluc rt that la td.diti.n t oyucrinents on caiv.lc, •CT'erlnentG on hunrn tela,-B had t to carried thr u,;h If there vro raj' latent 1 a t. or duce certrin tyohus vaccines ia the rroy and In eacce In tho ccse f hundreds f th-usmr.s f jc.oie? Vw hid another sefe^uard, ae-ely, cve'ry s Idler vc« vrcclnrted rurelnst ty-hus vea registered la his ony t..k end It c uld be seen vith vhat 3167 C urt Sw. 1 IS Jet -.7-A-l 6-2-IH-.-?el oa ever let . hie cpbu hie? r;*. On the heals -f th« cr-e«. hie? cry ne could ettebliah vhich vpecinc -r-v t d t- >e th« totter or the v.. r8e . t thick that thie is r. r-cthud vhich vc carried thr u h end*which led us, I cure, t * v rhi* ceth.d, co d-u;t, ia c :eth-c vhich -ne v uld have edited in c.r^el ti-.we -ut didn't it tp>c ca oxtro^rdiccxily loc,; tir.e unti£ r.r.e c uld receive ueetU rcoulte? a* That ie correct, v v lht CPBt f « vr^eccy vhich y-u hrve nentlcnod w.on't it^cea- tcry t. sec t<, it that -a« c .uld Jui ro r.e euickly *s r».eelclo vhrt vrecin.o v^re i valid or tcctl.a la .rdor t. rv-ld. hrvin.* t vr.ccicate hundreds red th-uerr.de f o.Idlers vith Unuccble vreeinoa? *• r ~ euveti aa the iacue r.t ctrka vne t' d.ocido Mother no vre- la a little =.rv affective • • Vo, art £ ->r duct ion, vvrv nly lnt*ri.ct«d in nr d.ucin ; re 3uch -f it ea n cai fc le. It io r. t o lio.rtrnt t te-v vhetUr no veecine ie c little bettor then the thor. • v ’h*n ualu.- t. io • th I Uc?ir. , vror.'t thorc / 'nr.-vr r.t nly f- ueo vrcclnvs vhich “-ore r little Ivoe effective thra th.rc, tut rlo t ueo vrcclcco vhich h*d a .r t.eti t vi lu. vfc<.t c »vorT A. I! . Vo tested th-.ee vaccines ia ml al ojcjerinentc rn.' no c uld nover ccy in cuch c c*a« that .no v.uld receive c vcccir.e vhich *tb f n value rt ell. ... D- y u y a. I hrve a further rueatl ne. SHn r:--aS:3£_“: sy -th-r cxeular.ti.n f this vitae* hy defeneo c'unsel? Has the -;r-B.cuti n pc*' further puteti na? She v «- =uS6 - t y ; u excused. D.cB ctucsul f r defca -cat HVadl dc-air. thrt the vittese Hertl."-cn 1 * 0 -urt 3z, 1 is - 7 -^- 18 - 3 -iak-rcif.t e*ll«&! The Hershel vlll roaa.s the vitheae Eras Kwtlcter.. Eic:s :--A3TL.;3*: , f Vltr. t se, t. -k the stand ir/ testified. rs f'.ll.va; JEDG& SI13r.I2.0j rlease b^lr uc yvor ri,;ht heat'. rad he 6 v%tt., ro*>cptln.' eftcr at: I «v*-cr ~y S-d, the a? 1 x.ty esi Cr.r.iseicct, thrt I ''ll! #-5rrk the *mre truth end vlll vitfcfc.ld. «j (. a-V a.thlrv;. •'The vita'll! Tenanted tfco -rth.) W3J* Sl-a&JSSi V-u he seated. TEL .-3i5I"i.T: 3*»f ir.cfcodln,: vitk the cxi--init! c -f this witness X thv Tritunel vin -c e in rocee*. (* recess v ts teken.) 31S9 t Court o. 1 rd TKZ The Tribunal is -f-ir. r. session. , i-. ic-3 your Honors', the defendant. Korta Vfc.rh-us-r hvint. been i r it. 1 ® * • sr -• 7: V •ocrotery . 1 .note for the r.c.rd that defondant h-r,-. Oberh-ue »■ h-.s boor, -xcus cl for the ta-neo of the nTUrctoon. ry Oun.nl will Jilo the ' rtific Th- Counsel any procard with . .. r *:•. B’ Pi. - 12 1 . it:.. 6, will you . . • ou- -. x -i. H-ns -rtl:Obxn. Q. Uun and share r tti.'. WS H'xlo ... SJle. r •. 1 I. d • l. ;i ; c '.DO u.3 :n H ilu ou S r.d .i.d - dielac in Trsibur*, Brels ga: . , .1 entered tho Any of . posts -s aodloal officer, and Z was *,ro... . . f in ehrroo or- trie Intern 2 -'ficnl • jetior i.. - .cat c; - 1 in Stuttg'rt, r.nd ry 1937, I trrr.if.xr <1 to tin .»my .die 2 Insp-otor- — w -r » * , « to. Originally J • • • -r are of in nddltios. to basic pcstioas; organisation l questions in the rici.r r -r , ruch c trai :i,_ of the aon-ec :.ic^Lon officers and tho .sen, :-.cir H . th .t tlvj -r. r. ,1 i he ho: it-.ls -r.d with the units in the field, .dicnl unite i t tha field, -r,d in addition h--d to obt-in nodical oqu' enfc •. .. in charge of , -'-in-l Urtr.aa.nts, nd-*o-forth. .. third r.-. p ; in c.;* rgc of l or- r.i: tlon 1 >. r. :\: of . Fin-.ll;*, :‘.-..ro s nnoincr .rou, ir oh : of t.:. n nation o' r.d»ni th die- r.-lc Did the org-nii tiou 1 • n: include - orKlng nut r .Ions for th, n_ off led Of th* ■: t it ; . eh*. ifcdloal Services? • *. «»• • • , -i.-d in .rtr.tang tnis iro intrusted in the intfirprota- tien of tho inctructi-nc of 1 ; . jg this «» published or it and th. Prosecution i: v ry vn.- f.dc bee-use the p» u rs of defundan «\ndlor..r . s to h-ve .... r^u. ;„d by tnis regulation. I do not rant to Ir£urrupt about the. deer j of 19U2; the instructions, it c-~. about, nr,.- it '.-.a >fritter. <>_ cause tho interpretation Is of ep oiol inport nee* 31?1 i 19 Feb. i.7 -*-21-1-??:?- Cook Court 1 A. The instructions bad quite a long nistoiy v during the wnr. It C..C. about that in the nature of the thin; thr t tho d^velofrants for the .min- of the war the ry.dicr.1 service of the -rjy, n- no dou t eiso of the other branchoo of tho . not -ii-ve aay super flu »n and efttorials. conai crablo lack in important fields. To give r. example - at the beginning jf ' : 3 v-ry lei - - - jk -f tr* ined nodical personnel, but also u. tbu XioU of n * r . ■ t scarcity. T .v an ojcraplo - 0 i srtunt poop of ntdionl instructs hr.c not b W :. . .t Up t th- .. ir-olr. of th .t « in doe*. fields .’i ■ not ^Vwn exist, x-r y o.*v.r..tuP * 1 dir.,- t-j, n. ^buV nc-s v r- 1 chin end oth r t -a. -.or... r t -n • . r •*. *fc : _ i ..i. of th r thu nofcd for r.ll of those thin, •: personnel ros. sudd* ly. : , atdeh •.».s th. lor est branch th tohrasvcHt, this v.s Boat urgent, but in = na ou'.t oi'iL-r. . orcov r cv.tvri-.la fir'dunliy - wfficionr. in Joil Tfc The tv. mt.o ..it r.iy th, civil!-. r. x r .. Still 1 SU 11 :, but 1 - ~irv iti: th r. sc rev, nt. industry V a r.ot a : o in - r. v 1 y short ti .. a f thu t.vhra-.eht, bqt c.lso • » f : i3. -.V \-r W.nt '-r- Ir ■ difficult! t th- b- -ir.r.ir..* of tho war • r t d- 1 of r ol-cURcnt l:i th- n-iTleal ruppli-r for the r. ry for - c.rv.in unity to bv civili-.r. poanl-tii:;. Th-j- tl _ it .. r y for or. Ud. Q. £xcur . ., th •. . , :• th position >f th- Chivf ;f th- ..-hratcht 'rvic- w b ar- t.d by the ..-cr-- of > • *,pi olein e ly It t >bk so Ion , you •is- s~ -kin A th- scarcity in 1939? . aver* v s^tsur- or ;-r and i rovii ion, mt then r- jslly t:.v L.r. -r tiu nor ltst-d th- norv uryoat thu n—d bcecau end the norv Rvc-setry t curtain unification wr.s nor- n-cvss'jy tlso bc-caus- the bnnehus of thu chraecht -i. r.ct ch_ck upon one =r.oth-r nd did not knod v nhuthur on- br nch >f thu . ouuncht, for -Xf—'l-, h~.. oru-r-d sor- rx<’icrl 3192 Feb. LI U-2-PKT- Cook Court No. l oquipcont than another, Inon there «-. E - necscit;- f t - central r-tulr.ti >n ir. th. br'ncfKO of the '..ehr=ncht, but :.or.c of the br-r.ci.os of th- V,chraacht 'ir^.d such . r-.-ui.-ti,.:.. Thor. wor or: - 1.- two reasons for this. On- r. is ;>rob“-bly th-.t - eh branch of th- '..ehro.- cht f- -.r-o th- cr-.ntdon A •« cent. * , -s ... r- -f .ctiviti -j noul restrict. ! ti.-..r. ir...ividu 1 r rresee& ir. the Fttohror'• Fccree^-hlch contain n preaatle vhich assumed that the c - rdinati .r. in the field f Personnel aeterl’ls vte the nin thin,;. The- Fuehrer's Decree i-lc contained, nuch li toti.n .f taper tint instruct! .r.s c-ncerr.ir.: the fcrffen SS. It sold that t-lj Chief vf the Vehrrucht Medical Service In fctaic "Uetti.r.s the Medical Se vice >i the ‘faffon SS could act only vith the *>revl uo r'l^r.vcl >f the Medi¬ cal Chief f the Wcffon SS t ■ give an;-' .rders. This in effect neant n previous u roo.-.ont and -r.e *y er that in effect, rs far re the ether -ranches f the Vohroacht tro c ncornod, this v;s the situation fron the v« tv, inning. Generally it crr.e «,r.ly t. orders issued ly the Chief "f the Veto cicht Medical S« rvicc »*on there had ceer. urvliulnary discussions -n tide oueetl.ne tetter, th.se c.ncerned. This vholo solution v, o t, a certain extent c c-;or—ise t- r. ouitc c-r.sif.sretie extent and this comronlso io oxnrecred in the fact that the -fficinl instructions, vhich I helocd to dra« uo, v v rw relatively ;rlef and. v t re also in relatively general terns. First it stated, that the holder .f the .ffico, that is, the future Chief of the Vohnareht Medical Service in Vuhrr-acht natters, vis under the Chief -f th< High C.-t-and .f the 'lehrnacht, vhich rraent that the' Chief of the Vohrnacht Modlrcl Service vec under three authorities, under the Chief of the High C nand .f the Vehnaeht f -r V-.hr xcht ouesti.ns, unde-r the' Chief of the Gone Staff f.r cuestions c.nceruin. the field ersy, under th. Conm-ndar of the £<» serve vfc- vts General -Ursarzt Fr.hr:, ct that tir.e, for cuestions conccr In.; the reserve er.cy. The -fficiul instructions in general forn then said that the Chief .f the Vehrnacht Medical Service vie to direct end canape' the Vahmacht Medical S-rvle- in rraestl-n* c ne.-rx.lng the VaUrnaeht hrrncr. 3195 C Sc. 1 19 ?oi> •i7-A-22-2-£3C-Ki,l-y Jointly, cai I ney oerhc ;s, if this it desired, Int the cuestion f vt ouch «:cr.:rel ouettixs vure ft that ti~:e. rri-nrily, rs hr e been renept. ceid, it ie th' cuesti.n of co-rdim tin.; r-rterinlc cud 'cro naol, then the question -f volunteer nurses, cou'.-ftin,: eoidenics, r.nd x.-rhuos hoenitole fr ai.il: r cucsti-r.s, vh'^ch suvin,: _-.^r6.:.r.cl end r.otdriale could he effects 'ey the coord lent ion, end la which sinlificrti-n ec.\ild to effected. v *J-V, ay I intervene h«re to sueeJe -f oidcnic central, which ie es-.ocir.lly interesting here, r.vt thrt ::enn thrt rcscrrelxvps under the Chief f Vchrorcht Kediccl Sorvioc - the? thrt vne ..no .f the dutioo? A. As ftr (s : re-.o dvr, thie must!on vlryeft no role et nil £t that tine. Iho pueeti-ne which n.odod c . .rt-iar ti .n vxrt -.ers.nntl rad ai-leriilt I thin* I ecn recull thrt the cu-i*l-n -f returre'r vt 6 n.t .entioacd rt all in theoi instructions, “hit ie indicated rlo tiy the clreu stance that we hr d rec^niSed this cv.rdinati.n f-r cuite different rone no and that thee instruct! .no v« r<- .f suite n -ei.errl ture rnd cuito trltf and did not • ir.t. details rt nil. Z. thrt extent this ruoctlun woo certainly not In t r. f -r«,Tound, cortcinly n-t tut meh. V : -v, will you -.ioneo try vhu ,r whnt vro under the Chief of the Wo hr.', cht .-.t-.icrl Service? S.tfclft renlly, /side fr a hie -va otrff, which, Cf c uroo, vnf und«r hi .. Ch^re vi a really suh-rflnr te relnti' nofcl*> . entioned in the i otructi.nc. It v LS uly said thrt the Chief ,f the VehMrcht Hodlcnl StrvJ in ^enerrl *^int puestions "it :• cct .n he half the Chi-f -f the' Kl£h C< rnd .r the i/ehr. cht rn rive in;?ructi .ns t the* rtc.'icrl Chief -f the acd cd breaches .f the Vchrrxcht, n t riero in the rctual sense. hut direct!* Tr.-r- wre c freeuent distinct!x in ivru r«vul:-ti.r.s between orders rod instructi iob. This is a ,;cs*rcl v *d, a excrete tern which vrs Just in r CtSt. ... Ihen the Chief -f the Uohr-r cht Kadical Service directed, ns y« snii, in ,;cnercl the Medical S.rvio. cc^-hItv t». n.* U- okr which wore rir nixed ns J-int ones end whirl, h- hnc. tekcn7 A. 'feS 31 * Court S-. i 19 Fed •.?-A-22-c-Z3.-ii»l y v Secondly, he did ant have cry *>ov.r t. issue ordere in thie con¬ nection - he e uld norely Iseue instructions? A. SwB. ... and you express this oath rity cs the exorCBol >n of * re.Tuli.tian h-t «d on r^rocr-ict, nrcli Annry r-rcenent? A. Yec, thet is fcov it in -ffeet, that there vp.b first agroeeent «.fi this vea n.cesarry because in' the strict sense there vne net oc.vcr t issue -rdorc and the Chief ,f the Vohroacht hafiicrl Service di$. a >t have , cuth-rity, nay uoane t essert hie ruth .rity and if ve *ere t. av>ift thot -pooBition to inttructi.no ,r feiluro t- f>U« instruct! ns. it vns acre, orcctically to sit d-va nr,uni a table ■• hand n£ «r« an tetlo rue tijM. to thot after the Instruction# wore itsued, the vark vuld tegin i cedittciy. v SUV, b concrete cuectl.n. Vt the defendant Kandloaer, ns Chief the Vokrnecht Xediccl Service. in chrr,;. of the research inttitutoo of the Wuhrsncht rnd the Wpffon SS? A. Sot aeowdiv t the inetructi -ns, nothin,- vr.o under hi-.. The roaenreh institutes, I think thrt retained undvr the chief of the various trinoh-o A the Lehrnneht. v Uov, hov C uld the Chief -f the Vwhrr-iCht J.odicnl Service, in orde tv roclixe hie duties, obtain any c.ncreto t. cio f r hit > •Hi ». f " Uil •ff ice? A. I hove already described thrt in “*rt. In .rdor t ho able t * ,rk, he needed natericl fr._ the vrri.ut tranche A the Vehrnrcht rnd \ instruct 1.ns -raided that the :rrxches ,f the Vohmncht hnd the duty * tters which affected nil hrrncU-s of the ’Mir.^e not anything soacificnlly cel-n.in to the Luftwaffe or the Kcvy, "hich concerned this narticul-r trench A the VrtnuwUt, 3? «•<«• vMch ^ 1 fcct«,d ell v r—= .f ‘v- Wv^trb* '*• a ”~ H v *‘ y * ?1?7 15 F«b L7- n - 23- 1 - LJG - Koohan .. H * That is the relaticn t the ^ricsl Service f the ..affon S3, y u spoke f tho basic rustricti.r.3 in the ducrce -f 23 July 1-U2; 7no thin expressed c re cncrotoly Later n? a. Thu instructions, as far as I recall, contained a passa o which I beliv-va even r.strict^* tho r r In f toe Fuehrer's : «crec; the Fuehrer's ecrou speaks only f the .;aff«n SS, but 1 believe that those instructions contained a p.ssa e etneomin to. units f th. uffen SS under tho Ahrracht r s Athin liku that and the r. anizaticns att„chod to the ..ohr aeht, such s the hoich L-h r Service, r x tho OT or 3. nothin - like that, .vs fir as I roc-.'. , t .re vas such . passa e In these instruc- tions f 19U2. .. H in iver t uko a cle-r . ictun. f tfc. rclati ns botwcon 19ii2 and Soptuub^r 1, 1>.. , t icrea cncorni: th ,i«.hr.;icht • -j'iical S,rvico an tv. ccc nil f.'iciil instructions; 1 will ask yut Uk.tthj cluoroo an-', the instruct! na f 1 st, l'lili, which I have '.ir.- y ivoa y . -his 1 S u ouaant i> . 287 anJ Exhil-it Ko, 6 r the Pr socution. o rill -. clear picturo if you wii dice:- tho individual j rts f ■ otructi ns in.' toll us, as far as you can r. . bar wh instruct! ns f 19..2 s-.i-!, t rill be cl«.*.rly oh- n h st. n v.e .aiti a I the ^hi.f f the ..ohr.-ccht >Ltlcel Service .tus *n i 3 U2 »r. h - it van t to ucc rlin t tho cloCreo • First, I b.li^vu 1 sy ir. . ' . . it is t take f .r this extended ox . - r. * te x -i a l Defendants Brandt and Hondo . sever-J th*»r fitnesses. It fb rape,titi uo or*! t-.lcin up ti. inc f tr.e Tribunal. I think wo > ah-cUid sh.rtgn uj in ti n - . ate it as brief as p.ssiblc. • -H2 .-.-iSIDS:”* I an suri't.. t tho c unsui f r tho ufondont Hondl s G.s.3 n.e =ant t rnst/j r^y ti c -.nd it 3^cs t -c the tostir.-ny of tho witness 3 r-ith^r cnli nt.rlr- •».- rn rh ;t. Trr-'uly ext^ndln. this ^xa-in * it nay pree-ed. r-155 / C urt I 19 Fwb U7-a - 23-2 - LJj - i~ehm 3Y DE. rSLIE: Briefly c ~ent r» each Individual part an, pcinfc - ut the differences. a. first, . rnally, tho, rugulatl ns f 19fcl are nuoh Ion -r, throe and am half typewritten p as, ailc the r. ulati no f l 'b? were hardly :.re than ino • o. In fi uro no t- -re is s nothin now as ». ainst tho ra, ulation « f 19U2, that is the ratter f .vsciolinary M n. It «s -t define who is un'lor tho Chiof f th« lobe eht -dic.l S^rvicj and I ccnsidor this sontonC'j -roly r. p por with, ut any radical effect. In the Regulation f 19 <2 , vo als had r. suj-ivis ry uth rity f the Chief f tho lohrucht nodical Sundco, no real inspection ri ht in tho narr * ssnso. Q. II v, c -ncrotoly, ray I ask y u the queoti n f the pwo that KO spoke f bof r, us rdors, Instruct! r.3 and dir cti.no, as oxproorod in I - 2? rt . This rs ul ti n is Slot':, uishod fr tr tho first; it r. IctV’or speaks f instructions but aith rity acc i in-: t l> .l f tho fuehrer looroo. ibis Fuehrer .c . i says that in technic 1 n i' 1 , colors can be i ilo Jnet 1 r -li 2 . 2199 15 Fco. A7 -w>L-^PK?- ifccfctn. C^oit Bo. i Q« "'.hct does this paser t» issue '.ora urn? .. -: _/ aUic 1 Xicli; fivld f th rvic , -rv.:„ in ailitar 7 -.t. ,r?. Civ t is cl- r a thu - ..’.ir.-l *.rvico is ilitat -hr.V '/.t . j .1 ttors, whi ^ -t th t IMot :: vri as ->r >kno oi the :lei 1 v.ttvTc in th. r*.'’ic."l service '-r- licit.: t th fi^ I : in ; hich tu f th. '..ohrw.cht icnl • r Khich :i.- jointly. Plots- t .11 x...t... i • ale . - -i task, it la - tPi.d in tnia aorvic- r« ul-ti n; th t it '.^s n t c :.t .. v 1 uth rlty? Ur’-r IT, ‘.a . .1 ,i i.\ r.. -til 1 ih’t i.’i- r- J-int -r .. luti.s. :u first rv ul ti n t t, . hurt io quit- n. l .r u; tin. Thw -.Ut.. itities il scientific . . ic 1 Lnslitut . ...i . vthwr . ic 1 iicotitutl.ns I th. o.. T .-us f th ...hrr ej.t m' f th- ■ 2-3 n th i . t th first v rai but I auat ooy There So r. t. L* i na r.in ti .. Ur., it *-?o ir. tUCfciuX >f t.;v Ulic-l S«rvicv, t«r. : th Chlttf » • n r the Vohns oht, but ji . .. o’-y vr. .. : I l ... ’ic i Urvic-, a; ^rr.ntly tids . .••' r. sin . i . il. vi , it WJSt Cff.rf * ■ k- thwS* thir. e cl. r ir. . r. ;1 - r.c. WO » Court,. 1 A ' 15 f/--.. >^£-2 3—lb-ED-iie - fcjiw „ in ttw Bltt-u lt-dicra Service, it is - ratter of course ttant vb.ro thorn is s position of subcrdln-tion, this is cle-rly -s:.r..T.i i. Th-.t .-.s ilsoys cl-srly exposed in th. service r.;»l-.tions, which I rtssafcor. In the re$ul tirns top th. *V, tor cxcpio, the t sks of the il=y IfcdlMl Inspjotomto nro mntionod in on. point -at it it • imadi-.tely listed w\c is urior hia, .ho a. lie si officers, the r.on- MtaM officers, the non, etc. I tave seen the* in thet for,-, in nnny such rogulitlons snd there i. opooisl refta-.ti.-n .bout renhs whore th-.t is cL .nindd specific rllj. Q. K , I vy Trh.ro U i not sp.Cificrvlly r id th .t th-ro is - relationship f tu. .-ricr and subordinate, thin tht.ro is no author ty to issue crdorc in Goncr r .l? A. Th-.t i? ry opinion. q, ll0Tf cac could hr.to to 1 ciali3d euthcriti s Issued veur it ipf 1 Institutes r.d BChdo 1-s, *tO., rnd t!u.rc it orys gain th. . -ffon SS; i.v about th. TTnffon '3 ".cccrding tc this re,ol lion? A. Hir. it r-ys it thi hott in ii>U f*otn.tc that tho Uhr.r.cht cludis cmly tlu units und.r c':- * hr. • cht, tho units of the •• rfcii 88 * Cj. th it re - ■ ins th- r uo? .v. in offoct it r siftai . 1 Uc not kne* whothor tho Kftffen SS, -a far as its unit • .r. unuer thu • -hr .-cht, 1 V inetitu Q. Will y.u picneu lock nt 11, U-A, idwro it soy s th-.t other c -i.. of trw Chief of thu !i.dical S.rvl -a of thu ..ohm-.cht will 'oc in thi 3U»d1 scientific , unifora aoasuros in the I •» research nd tho eotfwttins ef cpid -Hoe -nd all acdioil nsrrt»r.»s rf ’eh require - wrffor.: ruling v.i 04 . tlu* -obrr e'-tt V »• * ls<» '»• 10J,?? 2301 C-urt So. 1 13 7«ifc -17-A-23-1 c-ZEK-Ke ehi-n A. So, It wr.s not included in 19-.2 in this f'-rn? ^ Kay one conclude tkit irxz the let of Scotoabcr 1944 the Chief 'f the WehraaCht Kudieel Service not -nly c uld ccahrt coidcaics but els; in edr.it 1 .n e.uld intervene la the rv oarch v-rk carried on ty the individual branches -f the Vehmach^? A. Chet teens euite inpr-fcetl« to aefre tho situation. 7 or exrr.'.i if the Luftvrffc- planned tee research which affected only that trench f Vohmacht ... ^ v. So, no, I a can -nly if these ere things which affected the ccm interestt for cxenole, henititit eoidi .ica, which yrh kmv, or tyohus. 1 this research n ouesti.n which can te uniforuly ro^ulrtcdl Sc, the ur.lf.rr. r^-ulrti r. of research vculd r.it serve tho r.chicv nent of fr.v.ratlc rcsulto. In :y cpir.icn -no cun isouo rselfnnor.ts on rc- search end >nc cm cay vc ere not sitiofiod with tho dru,; or thrt corur., t: that vhlch vc fc. vo is not sufficient rnd •Uf.vest thrt thoee things ho i:v>r tut nuch cannot he done eontrr.Uy. A roetrrch worker, who receives ouch r su^estion, will first hive to try f,r hi.sslf the aothods which he will t- coao to r result. Porhras ho will take two r three vr-n#' oaths, vv.ich - .t Iced t. the rl. In ry opini a this txt-:nlo shows ovon to r lryr.an t resoxrch csnn.t tc bridled In this fora tut -ust have a certain froedor.. .. Vill y ax ? 1 «» sc toll us under tho rest of tho recil'tions, esnee*. under III, vhi*t differences tb«re nro at against the regulations of 1942T A. 1 was c ntfined in 19-2 reerdinr tj tho sane sense end *crhr Under tho se:tc- wording. Sc. 2 ia now, conolotcly now. So. 3 vac contain in part in e slilar f-r in the roulntl n of 19t2, rc#:fxdin the rcstrl o.ver of inspectl n. I believe thrt this was expressed in r similar t with the sr c restriction in 19-^. tut it ie nuito new that the Chief of kehrr.-cht Medical Service is t. have the authority to issue rdeve •» tb- so.t in the field i :.odicnl service if those nre necessary f^r the rcr • f.f cn e er,;er.cy rnd do a t disejee with fundamental orders *f thi-'trnnci of the b«hrnr.cht. that is also any cover to issue orders on the sx-:t. t‘is rl,;ht ioh in itself contains^ two auch str.n limitations vhlch I would not h? Vehrnacht. 19 Feb. 47 -424-1-30- F-.l.'t C-ort 1 Q. loa IT I ask yxi h« j-s the regulation ->r 1944 in the -.ciaive .points JiTIer fr-n tfk. regoUti a of 1 % 2 , plcosu c -11 v- thri la f n r's. Sx-. it up. «. TJ>- wB£-nti:0. rtr re ...re -He' .script! n f the fields if *jrk, r. Halt- u.r t- issu. r‘.r;, .x th- Jirtt re isliti^n apak- -»nly j' instruct! -na; c.rt-.i:. inflnunct r. th -. ir t.,.;.tr t. physicians, Gener L.r=t, n’ Cert .in .x^r t. istjo .jv-ra -n the so^t ’urin. inspect! in c-s- if eri-r, Tho*- r- the. »ss<.n;i.'l points, in ay ^pini-n. N m Cenc.rnir. r.s-.rch I aust ak sh* quw8ti>n, in wh-t^r.y w.o th- ct‘ic 1 service : the *, -If-r. SS ..t : 19.2 ■ r. it_r 1944 under th. chit: jf the lehmacht n. .ic'l o-rvicc? A. It MBS rut : . I VUUttt See 'IJJF sub T ’if;' ti n ir this r« ulnti ~ry‘ n ■* nly . I . t r ... .r t 1 Y ]?..?, at it i r. t xist, '.a it ar.yc iv. lnatructi ns : t obroocht, :-rnin th. unit* \ ffer. SS tn -r th- .ehraacht. Ti.-re wn* na ti a. :t- c-ul 3-rely iciue i istrueti -a. Th.r. Were sl iil-r rvl c r.-.r,: th. rancht . : •.‘ r . i .. J 'ir. .tc 7:.. o) iof : '■ • : o thee os ri nt here under cath. Kot t r^p-.r.t tC.u ui -lr.aticn f this .ritn-S3 n c nmiltirv; physi¬ cians, I shew the witn-os .rtL.ben Hi 13 Exhibit 8 , D cucer.t Bo k 1 , Ft 0 32, and I Mk you, witness, have y.u r-t . this state:-- nt f Iv fens r Hniv.loeer? •. I have road thO wh lo d cu nt b k, but Id n t knw frer. tho nuaher *hioh no it is. x. It sny 3 *Tho instituti n f nsultin^ physicians." T-a. Ics, I r-ad that n». .. Con v u c nfirn tho c ntents f thiV.affidavit? .1. Yes, fully. .. Ar.d finally 1 hav« given y u Z cua-ct H% 2, Exhibit 37, Dccuracnt 3205 C.-urfc I Yj PVbruaiy U7- ft - 2U- 2a - LJj _ Foldt 3 -k 1, c>- 5 an: fall win. arI ask y u t. r_i~ it, the stit.mer.ts about necessity and purple f the rcetir. - f the c nsultin. specialists, that is, the AOtlxt s f the c nsultin socialists. Have y u read this stato- B-nt ? ft. las. }. Can y u c*nflr= tho c.jTeCtr.eSS these statements fr n y:ur -wn kn^!< o? ft. I c-j. c .nfirn it fr = ry jto kr. wlad o. ^ Than in c ndusi-n I shod' nly like t ask y u, what is y ur pini r. of Profess r Han-'1 ser, and in particular, hi^ attitude n nodical othioo? ft* In ^ affidavit f tho 13th X December, nhich hie just boon montionec’, I speke n this question and I ; int-d ut that It Xoss. r Hindi-a er raa always j-rl-arily interested in the -utstandin nodical achiovocent an c n uct .f his . icol ffic-rs. Perhaps I nay undorlino this by s jin. that, f r ex olo, h_ -sat sharply f.pp sod t: hiving tho rank nsaea -f tho radical cfficare chair'kd. Tho i 'physician", '..rzt“ is always inclulod in the nr. ir. tho Oaraan arny, « bs.irzt. Goneralorat. iff rts were ado t chnnw those narws, t soy "Captain" instead ,f »8tabeirst" r "it. C-olcnol" ir.sWad f "Cfejrfoldarit." He al «ays .pp sed such efforts b.cauoo he was f the pini n that cur titlo was t sh-w primarily ur capacity as a ct.r. I have sold m ha' a supc.*- l r Qi .. , | JiiMlj ■ u.- «n i!»l i". • >1 UtCiB nao n m ir-., ,«•«/• f n ♦htjv.r *nd Hi , as n 3206 Coart No. 1 19 Feb. -;.-r.d-2i.-lt-?o Idt super’or, weighed his decisions su carefully. I hive knomi Professor Handlos^r for thirteen or fourteen years. I was in close contact 7,1 ’ h ftir ‘ for y-~ r: > p nd I believe that I ea in a position to pass judgrtnt cn his personality. I can only say that in view o his oxciaplary re die '1 attitude, it is oy firs convioticn tii t any medically ethically inicrlsaiblo oicpjrisfcr.te could nit have been im*n to his. He wculd hive ond-.r^crud the whole air of J is life as piysician, -ml his whole atfitud wculd have had to bo champed suddenly. But that does not happen at his -ge. Th-refro I believe that ia ro h'd learned of such\hingo ho wculd have objoct-d a far as h*. h portunity. * Dn. N 2 LTE: I thank you. l ;« vo no further questions to this witnoSE BY THE HiESIDEl.T: Q. Witnees, were tho ary regulations of tho Gorar.n any published in print-d fora prior to 1S39? “• 1 q«i*« understand wnat regulations y u scan. If I sight ack y u to ex,-lair a little? 1 . There -re certain ro K as published, I assuoo, or issued by tho proper ntharlty cf tho sovora:x>nt for ^v„ry amy. In tho Stnt.s they arc called the ..my Regulations. I do net know what they nro null A in Gcr.-r.ni-, but in t lu Uhit_d States t ey >ro printod in a berk f ,ary Regulations, gcmr-l I n c valuing thj nenberc of tho .a-racd * s there liar to that printed in Tcrrvny i;r the bcr._fit and inctrurtiin of tho Gcrnon ..my? “* Y ’ 3 » ^Gul-ti ns cf “v. Z.rr-n nrcy cxisfcud — always . existed in a Tinted r m, cr at rt rd vagr-jj^d fora, and v.vru not publish-.! b" tho 3207 S-urt E . 1 IS ?e- 47-A-24-lc-«aC»rold? saveresent, tut thoy v e r<- issued ty the fcl^fc cocnnad, that is, the Vor Hini try, jr 1^:1 sally; later, ty the hi,* cceaaad of the Vobrsacht fer the Vehr- naci.t os- ty the hi<;b eoanatd \f the cr;;y f,r the amy an.*, they vere 61 ,-sed, ia scseral, aee.riis^ to the ei r *slflessee, usually ty tho cengender in Ohio. e -f tho trench if th^ Vohrnacbt, but is this care ty tho ctoaarv'.er in chief the arrjy. v Vhat vero these re^ulatlsxu called? Vhct vr-s the- titlo of the: ? A. h« titles varied. There era a lar»;o sinter ,f regulations. S-a tf thea vere still tci*- vtrked -a. J.r oxanale — v vor-; th*.a« r->,^ilati x.s &cwr essettled ^nd irlatcd la cno Tuluao? 3209 Court Fa. I 19 F-b. *z,:-r--ld A. They wore too cxtonsivo for that, 7her«. ware unny huhdrodr of regulations, but they v.re it. a soocir .1 folaor with n index giving tho tifcl~s of the various r-gelations. Q. Uhftfe as the mm, the ?orxric group n-at, of these regulations? A. -? r. . *:..r .1 ' r.y -re Any Service tU/ulationr., H--r-8 Vorschrtften, EDV, Jin a* so ad so. Then there wat the Title givin; the contents of thes- spec!, c rc G ulntiona, r-nk -nd suy.rior relationships in th- .iny, and disciplinary penalties. Thoac .as a n-dic war regulation or instruction boo/, for nor.-coraicsiori-d officers -nd so forth. x r»c jroo know of -.ny onj print In which th-:e things w.re -11 -ascnoled nd bound toother? A. Ho. As f r os I know, th-.ru is no such book. Q. As to tho authority of c!;- Chiefs of the Wsta diOfll S-rvicc, under tho ord.r of XU2, would ho hr.ve authority to crcor the Oenior surgeon nodical officer of r. rogluent or of a brig-ado to -ako a ro.sort to his upon tho health conditions of th*t organisation? •.!'* •. v. ic:. . The Chief of tho Judical Twhrr.-o S rvico, in this c r If v. t -d -o know sonothin? bout a specific re,:irunt, would pr.su;i b-j ’r. VC urn-d to tn- r~uic 1 c-iiof of that branch of th- 7.ehr--cat sked hit for the n.eosr- ry infomatlc H. was r.aily in no position to eo so. Kc was r.ot ly th superior of thio rc^injnt'l doctor ir. thffl base. 4. Tht ord-.-rs could h. h v. issued? Tou said ho cculd have issued cc^j ortV.re to so-vj adainistratlva eh. Do you noon Infantry, rtill-ry. or tank corps? A. A -di.c-.l officer cmiT not »rtvc ori.rs to troopo at all. Ha could only give orders In nis specialised T\ Id, *ud t! at, is *.ho field o.' u-jdicino. i'w -ould issue diroctiv s on the =oet favorable trc-at:>:-nt of pneucoain, but hu c*>uld not rive th. troops any dir ct ord_rs. ..rJy the military ccu md. r. could do that. If he had a wish, ?2C9 Court b'r . 1 1? Fcb.-A-HD-25-2-pitt S or Id lx; the radical respect, «.f fee tin- t'-v_ troopr, he hid to ask for -n ord< r . " r *- troqp cocnander. E to aek tho chief of tho hi^h cosuiind of tho 1 ahrrr.eht, or s -rqy cdic.a; inspector, he rould have to zb.: the Ca-rmwkr of the ?-.c .ci-o :.rq;, ol G.mny. Ho r.uuld issue’ the ord.r. That ie th, re-.sen th a :v.c- jcgulitione always any bo is * " of his In pica lou o' the radical service. Q. Tho Chi_f could isF-je, I und rstard, r. directivo that h.rc-f. r prv-.u;:onLa would bi. tr. a d .n a certain vay, ro fhnt a eorthln vnrinty of splint should Nj .attached to euro a broken log. That would bo t directive, -xuld it? Inrtructiono w-.re not i:. i in th. c connection. Adviao was river.. :?-> certain aotbed of tr- t.at at jrosorlb J for tho dee tor. The n-in thin r th t nr i: vke ».a djj wiKth.r one doctoj* prcforr.d onu drur and -aotbw doctor prof rx\.d nnette.; drug, t^a up to the doctnr. J. It would be i recooan tatirji, no. : coiTon* A. A r«cot: nd.tion, adviso, .-.a. Crurt I 19 Fob L7-* - 25-la - LX - Fitz orald ..-at Would bo the effect .f such a reccrrindati cn upon tho officers t- whoci !t na directed? hey a uld uso their wn Jud nent in applyin it or w. uld they follow it? a. Iqu naan tho radical officers? *. y o3. Tho radical fftcers kr^w that what tho hi -h u r nodical officers told then in this respect was too fruit of medical and scientific experiorveo f tho latest years. Tn^refcre, they welc -red such directive cr advice, and enerally, nc d ubt, f llcwed it. They were^n t so limited. If T think —bout proicdnla, f r exrr.ple, various modern methods of treat- X ■ant were reported in this bi.klot and cv spared with one ahothew. Tho *- Dodical officer had tho u mrantee that he was advised according to tho host radical knowlod c. Q. * directive, thon, c uld bo lisn. ordoi by a nodical officer of a ro; inont, bri ado :r division, if ir. his jud-oent, tho directive was not corroct, vis not siuni in principle? ", He had that liberty. In th:t case he prooably wruld have con¬ sulted the others. Did tho uudiool direct.r have auth rity tc direct or rder, whatever it should be cal.ud, ro inental sur. eons to rake report# to him at monthly intervals about the health of their OOOBAndfl? rt. T r.ore was n. spocial instruction noodod f ir this in tho medical aervice. Tc-jre was quite a C of ini report sysioa. Every c nth a report win nade by every unit ibeut the S'.iu :f health. This was done auto¬ matically. i. nh. required that th so rep-rts bu made? ..as th-t in these airy ro-Tilaticns wo ■entioned? I believe tr..t t r.t- was sot dwn in the re illations, but it is poesiblo that there wore individual Tiers. K., I Just rer.aibor the rt illations. Thera was a ro ulation abiut r.ip rts f r the nrtjy which settled this question in detail. 2211 C-urt I 19 Vjt U7- k 25-2R - LX - Fits>rald ^ It t r~ Chief cf tho Service desired, cuickly, • C jrtdn r ~ V ' up:n a curtain dirision, oculd h. send ^ “ * that division t rep-rt t. tin innate* upon in thit divisi n? A . The Chief of the aehroacht -n^ical Serv.'.ce? a . He. He could not. It waul’ have be«n f r hl ,v ” ppP tho nodical chief t the branch t «» -hn^htj c.net-mod. * doubt have he, bettor connection.. - basic pi-incipio. in such .hint* .ere, os Ur as I saw it, that the Chief of Use ehmacht WM Service -on ho ashed i r infr-ti n, did not r, ■ *• placos, hut t -.00 superi r f the judical ,ffi.:or fr a - si he .anted inforaation. . e. Ton naan the -litas, snperior, n t »« nucical office, do a. Ho. I SB afraid to haw cl sunder. ta_d e.sch other. I undorst tho quusti-n t.ba thlsi If tha Chief -f tho iJaxaoht -.olc.a 3or wonted to how inf emotion, to shoe «U “ - « **’ to the person fr = -, ho wanted inflation .r thr uh chanreisf Q. Teu understood i. c reCt*. hut I «» n.t understand you, I think. m PJHSIDn. the tribun-1 rill «*«“ 9 °° C ’ CW t i:i rrcw’E:rnin. . (The, -rit’mnl V— ■■■» W l’ * f» hU, “- > 2212 MICROCOPY