A Collection of Esoteric Writings ======================================== T. Subba Row (1895) — Subba Row's theosophical writings — the great Indian theosophist's doctrinal legacy. Source: https://archive.org/details/collectionofesot00subbiala. Public domain. COLLECTION OF ESOTERIC WRITINGS OF T. SUBBA ROW, F.T.S., B A., 2 L. PUBLISHED FOR THE BOMBAY THEOSOPHICAL PUBLICATION FUND BY RAJARAM TOOKARAM. S^mfea^. PRIN-TEDAT *'THBTATt4-VlVPCaAKA" PUBSS. 11 iO. Price Re. 1-8. THE LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LOS ANGELES i THEOSOPHICAL BOOK CONCERN Krotona, Hollywood California Esoteric Writings by T. Siibba Roio. Pub- lished by The Theosophical Publishing House, Adyar, Madras, India. Price, cloth, $4.25. This revised and enlarged edition of T. Subba Row's Esoteric Writings will be wel- comed by students of the sacred writings of the East. The author was a valued member of the Theosophical Society in the early days and his unexpected death at the age of thirty- four was a great loss to the Society and a shock to its members. The present collection of his writings con- sists mainly of articles contributed to the Theosophist, and many of them are of a con- troversial nature, consisting largely of reviews of articles contributed to the magazine and discussions of occult subjects. Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2007 with funding from IVIicrosoft Corporation http://www.archive.org/details/collectionofesotOOsubbiala COLLECTION OF ESOTERIC WRITINGS OF T. SUBBA ROW, P.T.S.. B.A., B.L. PUBLISHED FOR THE BOMBAY TMEOSOPHtCAL PUBLICATION FUND BY RAJARAM TOOKARAM. ^fe®>-^\®^^- PRtStBt) AT " THB TaTVA-VIVBCHAKA " PRBSS. 1910. J'rice Re, IS. CONTENTS. ■S>fV/c^ /f/5 Pages. 1 A Sketch ot the Life of the late T. Subba Rao, B. A., B.L., F. T. S i— iv 2. The Twelve Signs of the Zodiac 1 — 13 3. The Aryan-Arhat Esoteric Tenents oo the Seven-fold Principle in Man ... ... ... ... ... 14 — 33 4. Appendix by Madame H. P. Blavateky 34 — 39 5. The Philosophy of Spirit 40—72 6. Esoteric Spiritaalidoi ... ... 72 — 83 7. A Personal and an Impersonal God ... 83 — 98 8. Will 98—102 9. Adwaita Philosophy 103 — 107 10. •'H- X" and G>>d Personal and Impersonal 107—108 11. In re Adwaita Philosophy 109 — H5 12. The Ahnora Swami upon Philosophy in general and our failings in particular... ... ... ... 115 jlg 13. The Swami of Alraora to his Opponents 118 130 14. Prakriti and Purusha 130 — 140 15. Shri Shankaraoharya's Date and Doctrine ... ... 14o 162 IC. Age of Lord Buddha's Death ... ... ... i(;2 165 17. Buddhism and Ancient Wisdom-Religion 166 — 167 18. The "Occult World" 167—173 19. Notes on Occult Philosophy 174 — 185 20. Thoughts of Kama-Loka 185—191 21. Nadigr.inthams and their Interpreters... ... ... 191 — 203 22. Places of Pilgrimage in India 204 — 213 23. The Virgin of the World 213 24. Correspondence — "The Virgin of the World" 226 233 25. BhagavadGita 234—240 26. The Idyl of the White Lotus 240 252 27. Notes on Hata-Yoga 253 255 28. Classification of •'Principles" ... 256 268 29. The Contstitution of the Microcosm ... ... ... 269 280 30. Re-Classification of Principles... ... ... ... 281 286 31. The Constitution of the Microcosm ... ... ... 287 298 82. The Bhagavad Gita and the Microcosmic Principles ... 299 308 83. The Forms of Vak 307—308 84. The Occultism of Southern India 309 325 85. A Ijetfer to Madame U. P. Blavatsky 316 86. Observation on "a letter to the Fellows of the London Lodge of the Theosophical Society, by the President and a Vice President of the Lodge" 317 356 PREFACE. Whilst presenting this little volame to the pnblic, vre cannot but pay dae tribute to the memory of one who had done such good service to the cause of Occult Science. The late lamented Mr. T. Subba Row, b.a., b.l., of the Madras University, was one of the highest Occultists of Southern India. We tried our utmost to collect as many facts relating to his life as we conld possibly get from his relatives and friends, to enable ns to write a short sketch of his life to go with this book. But, we regret to say, that our endeavours in this direction have been without fruit. We have, therefore, had no alternative but to reproduce the notice of his death taken by Col. H. S. Olcott, in the " Theo8ophist,*'in its place. Mr. Subba Row was a member of the Theosophical Society,and was highly respected not only by all its members, but also by Madame H. P. Blavatsky, for his great erudition and profici- ency in almost all the branches of Occult Science. Madame Blavatsky used always to consult him whenever there were diflficult and intricate problems to be solved. And we know she had, at one time, sent the manuscripts of her most valuable work, " The Secret Doctrine,*' to him for correction and alteration ; but he declined to undertake the work because he believed the world was not yet prepared to accept the disclosures of those secrets which had been, for good reason, hitherto kept within the knowledge of the sacred few. Mr. T. Subba Row had written no book on Occult Science, but he has left behind him a series of lectures and articles which he used every now and then to contribute to the " Theosophist, " and which display the real depth of his knowledge, and his worth as an Occultist. He, in the year 1887, at the Convention of the Theosophical Society, held at Adyar, Madras, gave a course of lectures to assist Theosophists and others in their study of the Philosophy of Bhagwad Gita. We all know how difficult to understand is the Philosophy of the Gita, notwithstanding the commentaries written thereon in Sanskrit as well as in many modern Eastern and even Western languages. The reason of this is obvious. Every- one acquainted with the description of the great war between the P^ndavas and the Kauravas knows that the Bhagwad Gita was preached by Bhagwan Shri» Krishna to his friend 11 and disciple Arjaa, becaase of the disinclination expressed by the latter to fight ou the battlefield. This description, as a matter of coarse, as there was no time to be lost, must have been recited in a short space of time, iu the form of A[>horisra8 in short sentences, conveying a deep hidden meaning. Shri Krishna knew that Arjun was able accurately to comprehend in all its fullness the significance of this teaching. Mr. Siibba Row has written a commentary on this Philosophy, and has done his best to make it as elucidative, consistent, and clear as possible. We have printed these lectures iu a separate book, and the readers will find on its stud)* what an amount of learning the lecturer must have had. These very lectures are conspicuous for the fact of having created between Mr. Snbba Row and Madame Blavatsky a difference of opinion regarding the Koshas (^rt) or principles of which the human being is formed. Tliis resulted iua written controversy between them, which the reader will fiud reprinted in this book. Though most of the articles reproduced here are of contro- versial character, the reader will find them of sterling worth and merit on account of the originality of thought displayed and the able treatment of the various points controverted. And, moreover, they teem with learned and useful suggestions for progress of the students of Occult Science. Those who had read and studied these articles in the various numbers of the " Theo- sophist, " as they appeared from time to time, had more than once requested us to reprint them in a collected form for the benefit to students of Occult learning. Besides these articles, we are in possession of several notes of a miscellaneous character, regarding the private instruc- tions given by Mr.T. Subba Row to the "chosen few "who had the good fortune to be in close contact with him. But we are sorry to say that they are incomplete, and were given by him only under the pledge of secrecy. It has, therefore, been thought desirable not to publish them. Mr. T. Subba Row had also made contributions to the local newspapers and maga- zines, but we think it unnecessary to reprint these, as they are solely on questions political and social. Here we cannot help thanking our respected brother, the Hon'ble Mr. Subramaniyar for the valuable help, pecuniary and otherwise, he has rendered us iu publishing some of our works. Bombay, Ut April 1895, T. T. A SKETCH OF THE LIFE OF THE LATE ' T. SUBBAROW, B.A.,B.L., F. T. S. Thb announcement, I am now compelled to make of the death of this brilliant yonng Indian mystical philosopher will shock the Theosophical reading public. Wherever our work has extended, ^tbere has his reputation spread. He was an intellectual phenomenon, and his mental history goes as far as anytliing conceivable to support the theory of palingenesis. The facts bearing upon the case, as I derived them from his venerable mother on the day of the cremation, will presently be given. When he last visited the Head- quarters, the first week in April last, the mysterious cutaneous disease to which he ultimately succumbed, had begun to show itself in an outbreak of boils. Neither he nor either of US dreamt that it was at all serious. But shortly after he had to keep to his room, then to his lounge, and he never went out again save once, when he was taken to a different house for change of air. In the beginning of June he sent me a touching request to come and see him, which of course, I did. He was a piteous sight : his body a mass of sores from crown to sole, and he not able to bear even a sheet over him, nor to lie in any comfortable position, not get sound sleep. He was depressed and despairing, and begged me to try if I could not help him a little by mesmerism. I did try with all my will, and it seemed with some success, for he began to mend from that evening, and at my third visit he and 1 thought he was convalescent, and so informed his unhappy family. But suddenly there came a relapse, his disease finished its course rapidly, and, on Tuesday, the 24th June, at 10 p. m., he expired, without a word or a sign to those about him. The last wordly business he attended to was to declare on the morning of 24th idem in the presence of his relatives and friends, among them, Dewan Bahadur P. Shrinivasa Rao, 11 that he had anthorized his wife to adopt a son after his death— there being no issue of his marriage. At noon on that day, he said his Gara called him to come, he was going to die, he was now about beginning his tdpas ( mystical invocations ), and he did not wish to be disturbed. From that time on, he spoke to no one. When he died, a great star fell from the firmament of Indian con- temporary thought. Between Subba Row, H. P. Blavatsky, Damodar and myself there was a close friendship. He was chiefly instrumental in having us invited to visit Madras in 188::^, and in inducing us to choose this city as the per- manent Head-quarters of the Theosophical Society. Subba Row was in confidential understanding with us about Damodar's mystical pilgrimage towards the North, and more than a year after the latter crossed into Tibet, he wrote him about himself and his plans. Subba Row told me of this long ago, and reverted to the subject the other day at one of my visits to his sick-bed. A dispute — due in a measure to third parties — which widened into a breach, arose between H. P. B. and himself about certain philosophical questions, bub to the last he spoke of her, to us alid to his family, in the old friendly way. When we last saw each other we had a long talk about esoteric philosophy, and he said that as soon as he could get out, he should come to Head-quarters and draft several metaphysical questions that he wished Mr. Fawcett to discuss with him in the Theosophiat. His interest in our movement was unabated to the last, he read the Theosophist regularly and was a subscriber to H. P. B.'s Lucifer. Our great Vedantin was of the Niyogi caste of the Smartha ( Advaita ) Brahmaus. He was born on the 6th July 1856. At the time of his death he was aged but nearly 34 years. His native country was the Godavery District on the Goromandal Coast of India ; his vernacular tongue the Telngu. His grandfather was the Sheristedar of the District, and his maternal uncle was Dewan ( Prime Minister ) to the Rajah of Pittapur. His father died when he was but six months' baby, and the nncle brought him up. He first attended the Goconada Hindu School, where he was not at all suspected of possessing any surprising talent. He passed his first Matriculation examination at the Hindu School, Goconada, then under the direction of Mr. J. Kenny. From thence he passed in 1872, into the Madras Presidency College, where his career was a brilliant one, and ended in his passing B. A. in 1876 as the first of the University in his class. In the latter part of the same year that astute satesman, Sir T. Madhava Row, then Dewan of Baroda, oflfered him the Registrarship of the High Court of that State, and Subba Row stopped there about a year, but then returned to Madras and prepared himself for and passed the B. L. examination, number 4 in the class. Having adopted the law as his profession, he served his apprenticeship under Messrs. Grant and Laing and was enrolled a Vakil ( Pleader ) of the High Court in the latter part of 1880. His practice became lucrative, and might have been made much more so had he given less attention to philosophy ; however, as he told me, he was drawn by an irresistible attraction. As an example of his extraordinary cleverness, his friends cite his successful passing of the examination in geology for the Statutory Civil Service in 1885, though it was a new subject to him, and he had had only a week for preparation. He leaves a young widow of 24 years, and an aged mother — herself a learned Brahman lady — who mourns ths loss of her great son, the pride of her soul, most bitterly. The cremation took place at 9 o'clock on the morning after his death. Our brother, Judge P. Sreeuivas Row, was with him at the last, and T. Vijiara- ghava Charlu saw him two hours before the event occurred. It is remarked above that T. Subba Row gave no early signs of possessing mystical knowledge : even Sir T. Madhava Row did not suspect it in him while he was serving under him at Baroda. I particularly questioned his mother on this point, and she told me that her son first talked metaphysics after forming a connection with the Founders of the Theo- sophical Society : a connection which began with a corres- iV pondence between himself and H. P. B. and Damodar, and became personal after oar meeting him, in 1882, at Madras. It was as though a storehouse of occult experience, long forgotten, had been suddenly opened to him ; recollection of his last preceding birth came in upon him ; he recognized his Guru, and thenceforward held intercourse with him and other Mahatmas; with some, personally at our Head-quarters. with others elsewhere and by correspondence. He told his mother that H. P. B. was a great Yogi, and that he had seen many strange phenomena in her presence. His stored up knowledge of Sanskrit literature came back to him, and his jTbrother-iu-law told me that if you would recite any verse of y jGita, Brahma-Hutras or Upanishads, he could at once tell you jwhence it was taken and in what connection employed. Those who had the fortune to hear his lectures on Bhagvad Gita before the T. S. Convention of 1886 at Adyar, can well believe this, so perfect seemed his mastery of that peerless work. For a man of his abilities, he left scarcely any monument the paper she contributed to these pages and the one-volume Report of his four Adyar Lectures being almost his entire literary remains. As a conversationalist he was most brilliant and interesting ; an afternoon's sitting with him was as edifying as the reading of a solid book. But this mystical side of his character he showed only to kindred souls. What may seem strange to some is the fact that, while he was obedient as a child to his mother in wordly afiairs, he was strangely reticent to her, as he was to all his relatives and t . ordinary acquaintances, about spiritual matters. His constant I answer to her importunities for occult instruction was that he " Dared not reveal any of the secrets entrusted to him by his Guru." He lived his occult life alone. That he was habitually so reserved, gives the more weight to the con- fidential statements he made to the members cf his own household. H. S. 0. The above, having been considered in family-council, was endorsed as follows :— "Read and found correct.— D. .T. R., Brother-in-Law of T. Subba Row. " —^Iheosophist. COLLECTION OF ESOTERIC WRITINGS OF T. SUBBA ROW, F.T^., B.A. B.L. THE TWELVE SIGNS OF THE ZODIAC, Thb division of the Zodiac into different signs dates from immemorial antiquity. It has acquired a world-wide celebrity and is to be found in the astrological systems of several nations. The invention of the Zodiac and its signs has been assigned to different nations by different antiquarians. It i» stated by some that, at first, there were only ten signs, that one of these signs was subsequently split up into two separate signs, and that a new sign was added to the number to render the esoteric significance of the division more profound and at the same time to conceal it more perfectly from the uniniti- ated public. It is very probable that the real philosophical conception of the division owes its origin to some particular nation, and the names given to the various signs might have been translated into the languages of other nations. The principal object of this article, however, is not to decide which nation had the honour of inventing the signs in question, but to indicate to some extent the real philosophical meaning in- volved therein and the way to discover the rest of the meaning which yet remains undisclosed. But from what is herein stated, an inference may fairly be drawn that, like so many other philosophical myths and allegories, the invention of the Zodiac and its signs owes its origin to ancient India. What then is the real origin of these signs, the philosophical conception which the Zodiac and its signs are intended to represent ? Do the various signs merely represent the shape or configuration of the different constellations included in the divisions, or, are they simply masks designed to veil some bidden meaning ? The former snpposition is altogether unten- able for two reasons, viz, : — I. The Hindoos were acquainted with the precession of equinoxes as may be easily seen from their works on Astro- nomy and from the almanacs published by Hindu astronomers. Consequently they were fally aware of the fact that the con- stellations in the various Zodiacal divisions were not fixed. They could not, therefore, have assigned particular shapes to these shifting groups of fixed stars with reference to the divi- sions of the Zodiac But the names indicating the Zodiacal signs have been allowed to remain unaltered. It is to be inferred, therefore, that the names given to the various signs have no connection whatever with the configurations of the constellations included in them. II. The names assigned to these signs by the ancient Sanskrit writers and their esoteric or literal meanings are as follows : — The names of the The esoteric literal signs. meanings. 1 Mesham Ram or Aries. 2 Rishabham Bnll or Taurus. Z Mithunam Twins or (rg/w/;««'(male and female), 4 Karkatakam Cancer or Crab. 5 Simham Lion or Leo. 6 Kanya Virgo* or Virgin. 7 Tula Libra or Balance. 8 Vrischikam Scorpion. 9 Dhanus Sagittarius or Archer. 10 Makaram Capricornns or Crocodile. 11 Kumbham Aquarias or Waterbearer. 12 Meenam Pisces or Fish. * Vir^-Scorpio, when none but the initiates knew there were 12 signs. Virgo-Scorpio was then followed (for the profane) by Sagittarius. At the middle or jnnction-point where now stands Libra and at the sign now called YirgOy two mystical signs were inserted which remained unintelKgible to the profane.— Ed. Tbbos. The figares of the constellations incladed in the signs at the time the division was first made do not at all resemble the shapes of the animals, reptiles and other objects denoted by the names given them- The truth of this assertion can be ascertained by examining the configurations of the various constellations. Unless the shape of the crocodile* or the crab is called up by the observer's imagination, there is very little change of the stars themselves suggesting to his idea that figure, upon the blue canopy of the starry firmament. If, then, the constellations have nothing to do with the origin of the names by which the Zodiacal divisions are in- ^iicated, we have to seek for some other source which might have given rise to these appelations. It becomes my object to unravel a portion of the mystery connected with these Zodiacal signs, as also to disclose a portion of the sublime conception of the ancient Hindu philosophy which gave rise to them. The signs of the Zodiac have more than one meaning. From one point of view they represent the different stages of creation up to the time the present material universe with the five elements came into phenomenal existence. As the author of **Isis Unveiled" has stated in the second volume of her admirable work, "the key should be turned Seven titnes^' to understand the whole philosophy underlying these signs. But I shall wind it only once and give the contents of the ^rst Chapter of the History of Creation. It is very fortunate that the Sanskrit names assigned to the various divisions by the Aryan philosophers contain within themselves the key to the solution of the problem. Those of my readers who have studied to some extent the ancient " Mantra" and the "Tantra Sastras" f of India, would have seen that very often Sanskrit words are made to convey a certain hidden meaning by means of certain well-known pre-arranged methods and a tacit con- vention, while their literal significance is something quite * This coastellation was never called OrocodUe by the Western ancient «6troQomen who described it as a horned goat and called it BO—Capriromufp —Ed. Thkos. t Works on Incantation and Magic. different from the implied meaning. The following are some of the rnles which may help an enquirer in ferreting out the deep significance of the ancient Sanskrit nomenclatnre nsed in the old Aryan myths and allegories:— 1. Find ont the synonyms of the word used which have other meanings. 2. Find out the numerical value of the letters compos- ing the word according to the methods given in ancient T&ntrik works. 3. Examine the ancient myths or allegories, if there *re any, which have any special c(mnection with the word in question. 4. Permute the different syllables composing the word and examine the new combinations that will thus be formed and their meanings, &c., &c. 1 shall now apply some of the above given rules to the names of the twelve signs of the Zodiac. I. Mesham. One of the synonyms of this word is Aja Now, Aja literally means that which has no birth and is applied to the Eternal Brahmam in certain portions of the Upanishads. So the first sign is intended to represent Parabrahmam, the self-exist- ent, eternal, self-sufficient cause of all. II. Rishabham, This word is nsed in several places in the Upanishads and the V6da to mean Pranava (Aum). Sankar&charya has so interpreted it in several portions of his commentary.* HI. Miihunam. As'the word plainly indicates, this sign is intended to represent the first androgyne, the Ardhanareesicara, the bisexual Sephira-Adam Kad- mon. IV. Karkatakam, "When the syllables are converted into the corresponding numbers according to the general * Example "Bishibhas;^— ChaQdasam Risbabhasya Pradhauasj;-£o. Tkxob. an Advaiti, I* look npon Jeev&tma as identical with Param- atma in its real essence when stripped of its fictitious attri- butes created by Agn^nam or Avidya — ignorance.) The Jeev^tma is correctly placed in the fifth sign counting from Mesham, as the fifth sign is the putrasthdnam or the son's house according to the rules of Hindu Astrology. The sign in question represents Jeev^tma — the son of Param^tma as it were. (I may also add that it represents the real Christ, the anointed pure spirit, though the missionaries may frown at this interpretation.)* I will only add here that unless the nature of this sign is fully comprehended it will be impossible to understand the real order of the next three signs and their full significance. The elements or entities that have mere- ly a potential existence in this sign become distinct, separate entities in the next three signs. Their union into a single entity leads to the destruction of the phenomenal universe,, and the recognition of the pure spirit, and their separation has the contrary effect. It leads to material earth-bound existence and brings into view the picture gallery of Avidya (Ignorance) or M&ya (Illusion). If the real orthography of the name by which the sign in question is indicated is pro- perly understood it will readily be seen that the next three signs are not what they ought to be. Kanya or Virgo and Vrischikam or Scorpio should form one single sign, and Tula must follow the said sign if it is at all necessary to have a separate sign of the name. But a separation between Kanya and Vrischikam was efiected by interposing the sign Tula between the two. The object of this separation will be under- stood on examining the meaning of the three signs. * Nevertheless it is » true one. The JiV'OtvfUi in the (Mieroeogm man) is the same spiritnal essence which animates the Macrocosm (universe), the dificrentiation, or specific difference between the two Jveatmai presenting itself but in the two states or conditions of the same and one Force. Hence "this son of Param&tma" is an eternal correlation of the Father-Cause, Parnsha manifesting himself as Brahma of the "golden egg" and becoming "Viradja — the universe. We are "all bom of Aditi from the water" (hymns of theMamtsX 632; and "Being was bom from not-being" {Rx&-Vedaj Mandala 1, Sbirth) according to the doctrines of the ancient Hindu philosophers. A Yogi mast thoroughly subjagate this power or force before he can at- tain Moksham. This force is, in fact, the great serpent of the Bible. Mairikdsahti .-—Literally, the force or power of letters or speech or music. The whole of the ancient Mantra Shastra has this force or power in all its manifestations for its subject.matter. The power of The Word which Jesus Christ speaks of is a manifestation of this Sakti. The influence of music is one of its ordinary manifestations. The power of the mirific inef- fable name is the crown of this Sakti. Modern science has but partly investigated the first, second and fifth of the forces or powers above-named, but it is altogether in the dark as regards the remaining powers. * Even the very name of Eanyd (Virgin) shows how all the ancient «soteric systems agreed in all their fundamental doctrines. The Eabalists and the Hermetic philosophers call the Astral Light the " heavenly or celes- tial Virgin." The Astral Light in its unity is the 7Ui. Hence the seven principles dilSused in every unity or the 6 and onb — two triangles and a crown — ^Ed. Theos. t As the Infinite differs from the Finite and the Unconditioned from the conditioned.— Bd. Theos. to earthly Adam, to Nara. As the emblem of Nara it is properly placed as the seventh sigD. VIII. Vrischikam. It is stated by ancient philosophers that the san when located in this Rasi or division is called by the name of Yisknu (see the 12th Skandba of Bhagavata). The sign is intended to represent Vishnu. Vishnu literally means that which is expanded'-'exp&uded as Viswam or Universe. Pro- perly speaking, Viswam itself is Vishnu (see Sanka- rach&rya's commentary on Vishnusahasranamam). I have already intimated that Vishnu represents the Swapndvastha or the Dreamy State. The sign in question properly signifies the Universe in thought or the universe in the divine conception. It is properly placed as the sign opposite to Rishabham or Pranava. Analysis from Pranava downwards leads to the Universe of Thought, and synthesis from the latter upwards leads to Pranava (Aum). We have now arrived at the ideal state of the universe previous to its coming into material existence. The expansion of the Beejam or primitive germ into the universe is only possible when the 36 "Tatwams"* are interposed between the Maya and Jeevatma. The dreamy «tate is induced through the instrumentality of these "Tat- wams." It is the existence of these Tatwams that brinsrs Hamsa into existence. The elimination of these Tatwams anarks the beginning of the synthesis towards Pranava and Brahmam and converts Ilamsa, into Sdham, As it is intended to represent the different stages of creation from Brahmam downwards to the material universe, the three signs Kanya, Tula, and Vrischikam are placed in the order in which they now stand as three separate signs. IX. Dhanus {Sagittarius). When represented in numbers, the name is equivalent to 9, and the division in question is the 9th division counting from Mesham. ' * 34 is three times 12, or 9 Tetniktis, or 12 Triads, the most sacred num- ber in the Eabalistic and Pythagoreaa numerals. — Sd.Tueos. 10 The sign, therefore, clearly indicates the ^Brakmds — the 9 ParajapatJs who assisted the Deminrgus in. constrncting the material nniverse. X. Makaram, There is some difficulty in interpreting this word ; nevertheless it contains within itself the cine to its correct interpretation. The letter Ma is- equivalent to number 5 and Kara means hand. Now in Sanskrit Tribhujam means a triangle, bhnjam or karam (both are synonymous) being understood to mean a side. So, Makaram or Pan- chakaram means a Pentagon .* Now, Makaram is the tenth sign and the term "Dasa- disa" is generally used by Sanskrit writers to de- note the faces or sides of the universe. The sign in question is intended to represent the faces of the universe and indicates that the figure of the universe is bounded by Pentagons. If we take the pen- tagons as regular pentagons (on the presumption or supposition that the universe is symmetrically con- structed) the figure of the material universe will, of course, be a Dodecahedron, the geometrical model imitated by the Demiurgus in constructing the material universe. If Tula was subsequently in- vented and if, instead of the three signs "Kanya,'* " Tula *' and *' Vrischikam," there had existed ♦ formerly only one sign combining in itself Kanya and Vrischikam, the sign now under consideration was the eighth sign under the old system, and it is a significant fact that Sanskrit writers generally speak also of "Ashtadisa" or eight faces bounding space. It is quite possible that the number of disa might have been altered from 8 to 10 when the • See the article in the August (1881) number "the Five-Pointed Star,." where we stated that the fire-pointed star or pentagram represented the fire limbs of man. — Ed. Tubos. 11 formerly existing Virgo-Scorpio waa split up into three separate signs. Again, Kara may be taken to represent the project- ing triangles of the five-pointed star. This figure may also be called a kind of regular pentagon (see, Todhunter's Spherical Trigonometry, p. 148). If this interpretation is accepted, the Rasi or sign in question represents the "Microcosm," But the " microcosm " or the world of thought \a really represented by Vrischikam. From an objec- tive point of view the " microcosm " is repre- sented by the human body, Makaram may be taken to represent simultaneously both the micro- cosm and the macrocosm, as external objects of perception. In connection with this sign I shall state herein a few important facts which I beg to submit for the consideration of those who are interested in examining the ancient occult sciences of India. It is generally held by the ancient philo- sophers that the macrocosm is similar to the microcosm in having a Sthoola Sarlram and a Sookshma Sariram. The visible universe is the Sthoola Sariram of Vis warn; the ancient philo- sophers held that as a substratum for this visible universe, there is another universe — perhaps we may call it the universe of Astral Light — the real universe of Noumena, the soul as it were of this visible universe. It is darkly hinted in certain passages of the VMa and the Upanishads that this hidden universe of Astral Light is to be represented by an Icosahedron. The connection between an Icosahedron and a Dodecahedron is something very peculiar and interesting though the figures seem to be so very dissimilar to each other. The connection may be understood by the undermentioned geometrical con- struction. Describe a Sphere about an Icosahedron; let perpendiculars be drawn from the centre of the Sphere on its faces and produced to meet the surface of the Sphere. Now, if the points of intersection be joined, a Dodecahedron is Ifir fori^eU withiD the Sphere. By a similar process an Icosa- hedron may be constracted from a Dodecahedron. (See Todhnnter's Spherical Trigonometry, p. 141, art. 193). The figure constrncted as above described will represent the universe of matter and the universe of Astral Light as they actually exist, I shall not now, however, proceed to show how the universe of Astral Light may be considered in the light of an Icosahedron. 1 shall only state here that this conception of the Aryan philosophers is not to be looked upon as mere "theological twaddle" or as the outcome of wild fancy. The real significance of the conception in question can, I believe, be explained by reference to the psychology and the physical science of the ancients. But I must stop here and proceed to consider the meaning of the remaining two signs. XL Kumbham {or AqtM?nu8). When represented by numbers, the word is equivalent to 14. It can be easily perceived, then, that the division in question is intended to represent the "Ghaturdasa Bhuva- nam" or the 14 lokams spoken of in Sanskrit books. XII, Mee?iam {or Pisces). This word again is represented by 5 when written in numbers and is evidently in- tended to convey the idea of PayichamahabhtUams or the 5 elements. The sign also suggests that water (not the ordinary water, but the universal solvent of the ancient alchemists,) is the most important amongst the said elements. I have now finished the task which I have set to myself in this article. My purpose is not to explain the ancient theory of creation itself, but to show the connection between that theory and the Zodiacal divisions. I have herein brought to light but a very small portion of the philosophy imbedded in these signs. The veil that was dexterously thrown over certain portions of the mystery connected with these signs by the ■ancient philosophers toill nemr be lifted up for the amuse' ment or edification oj the uninitiated public. 13 Now to sammarize the facts stated in this article, the con- tents of the first chapter of the history of this nniverse are a» follows : — (1). The Self-existent, eternal Brahmatn. (J). Pranava (Anm). (3). The androgyne Brahma, or the bisexaal Sephira- Adam Kadmon. (4), The Sacred Tetragram — the fonr matras of Pranava— the foar ayasthas — the fonr states of Brahma — the Scared Thdrakam. (5). The five Brahmas — the five Baddhas — representing in their totality the Jeevatma. (6). The astral light — the holy virgin— the six forces io nature. (7). The thirty-six Tatwams born of Avidya. (8). The universe in thought — the Swapna Avastha— the miscrocosm looked at from a subjective point of view. (9). The nine Prajapatis— the assistants of the Demiur- gus.* (10). The shape of the material universe in the mind of the Demiurgus — the Dodecahedron. (11). The fourteen lokams. (12). The five elements. The history of creation and of this world from its beginningN up to the present time is composed of Seven chapters. The I * Seventh chapter is not yet completed. / Tbiplioakb, Madras, lith September, 1881. * The nine Kabalistic Sephirotha emanated from Bephira, the Iflth, and the head Sephiroth are identical. Three trinities or triads with their emanative principle from the Pythagorean mystic Decad, the sum of aU which repre- sents the whole £otmo8:—E,D, Theos. THE ARYAN-ARHAT ESOTERIC TENEIfTS ON THE SEVENFOLD PRINCIPLE IN MAN* . . . Probably the Aryan (we shall for the present call it by that name) and the Chaldeo-Tibetan esoteric doctrines are fundamental ly identical and the secret doctrine of the Je- wish Kabalists merely an offshoot of these. Nothing, perhaps, can be more interesting now to a student of occult philosophy than a comparison between the two principal doctrines above mentioned. H. F. B.'s letter seems to indicate two divisions in the Chaldeo-Tibetan doctrine : (1) that of the so-called Lamaists; and (2) that of the so-called Arhats, (in Buddhism Arahat, or Rahats) which has been adopted by the Himalayan or Tibetan Brotherhood. "What is the distinction between these two systems ? Some of our ancient Brahmanical writers have left us accounts of the main doctrines of Buddhism and the religion and philosophy of the Arhats — the two branches of the Tibetan esoteric doctrine being so called by them. As these accounts generally appear in treatises of a polemical character, I cannot place much reliance upon them. It is now very difficult to say what was the real ancient Aryan doctrine. If an enquirer were to attempt to answer it by an. analysis and comparison of all the various systems of esotericism prevailing in India, he will soon be lost in a maze of obscurity and uncertainty. No comparison between our real Brahmanical and the Tibetan esoteric doctrines will be possible unless one ascertains the teachings of that so-called "Aryan doctrine," .... and fully comprehends the whole range of the ancient Aryan philosophy. Kapila's **Sankhya," Patanjali's " Yoga philosophy," the different systems of '*Saktaya" philosophy, the various Agamas and Tantrds are but branches of it. There is a doctrine though, which is their real foundation and which is sufficient to ex- plain the secrets of these various systems of philosophy and * Extracts from the letter of T. Sabbhft Bao to H. P. B.— Ed. 15 'harmonize their teachings. It probably existed long before the Yedas were compiled, and it was studied by oar ancient Rishis in connection with the Hindu scriptares. It is attri- ijuted to one mysterioos personage called Maha*. . . The Upanishads and such portions of the Vedas as are not chiefly devoted to the public ceremonials of the ancient Aryans are hardly intelligible without some knowledge of that doctrine. Even the real significance of the grand ceremonials referred to in the Vedas will not be perfectly apprehended without its light being thrown upon them . . The Vedas were perhaps compiled mainly for the use of the priests assisting at public ceremonies, but the grandest conclusions of our real secret doctrine are therein mentioned. I am informed by persons competent to judge of the matter, that the Vedas have a distinct dual meaning — one expressed by the literal sense of the words, the other indicated by the meter and the szvara which are, as it were, the life of the Vedas . . . Learned Pundits and philologists, of course, deny that Swara has any thing to do with philosophy or ancient esoteric doctrines. But the mysterious connection between Swara and light is one of its most profound secrets. Now it is extremely difficult to show whether the Tibetans derived their doctrine from the ancient Rishis of India, or the ancient Brahmans learned their occult science from the adepts of Tibet; or again whether the adepts of both countries pro- fessed originally the same doctrine and derived it from a common source, t If you were to go to the Sramana Bala- gula and question some of the Jain Pundits there about the authorship of the Vedas and the origin of the Brahmanical esoteric doctrine, they would probably tell you that the Vedas were composed by Rdhshasdst or Daityas and that the * The very little of the present chief of the Esoteric Himalayan Broth«r-> hood.— Ed. t See Appendix^ Note 1 — Ed. t A kind of demons — DevH.Eo, 16 Brahmans had derived their secret knowledge from them.* Da these assertions meaQ that the Yedas and the Brabmanical esoteric teachings had their origin in the lost Atlankis-^^the continent that once occupied a considerable portion of the •xpanse of the Southern and the Pacific oceans ? The asser-- tion in "lais Unveiled" that Sanskrit was the lanffaasre of the inhabitants of the said continent, may induce one to sup- pose that the Vedas had probably their origin there, — where- ever else might be the birth-place of the Aryan esotericism.f Bnt the real esoteric doctrine as well as the mystic allegori- cal philosophy of the Vedas were derived from another source again, whatever that source may be — perchance, from the divine inhabitants (gods) of the sacred Island which once existed in the sea that covered in days of old the sandy tract now called Gobi Desert. However that may be, the knowledge of the occult powers of nature possessed by the inhabitants of the lost Atlantis was learnt by the ancient adepts of India and was appended by them to the esoteric doctrine taught by the residents of the sacred Island. t The Tibetan adepts, however, have not accepted this addition to their esoteric doctrine. And, it is in this respect that one should expect to find a difierence between the two doctrines. § The Brabmanical occult doctrine probably contains every- thing that was taught about the powers of nature and their * And 80 would the Christian p&drl«. But they would nerer admit that iheir "fallen angles" were borrowed from the Eak»hdsas\ that their "DeTil" is the illegitimate son of Dewel — the Sinhalese female demon, or that the "War in Heaven" of the Apocalypse— thQ foundation of the Christian dogma of the **Fallen Angles" — was copied from the Hindu story about Siva hurling the T&rakasura-wVo rebelled against Brahma into Andhak^ra,— the Abode of Darkness, according to Brabmanical Shastrdt. — Ed. t Not necessarily.— See Appendix^ Note II. From rareMSS. just received we will shortly prove Sanskrit to have been spoken in J&va and adjacent islands from remote antiquity. — Ed, X A locality which is spoken of to this day by the Tibetans and called by them "Scham-bha-la" the Happy LanJ.— See Appendix, Note III. — Ed. $ To comprehend this passage fully, the reader must turn to Vol. I.f pp. 589-694, liit Unvtiled.—^\). ir hi«rs either in the mysterious Island of the North, or in the ^nally mysterions continent of the Sonth. And, if yoa mean to compare the Aryan and the Tibetan doctrines as regards their teachings abont the occult pov^ers of nature, you must beforehand examine all the classifications of these powers, their laws and manifestations and the real connotations of the various names assigned to them in the Aryan doctrine. Here are some of the classifications contained in the Brahmanical system : I. Classification of the occult powers as appertaining to Parabrahmam and exist- ing in the Macrocosm. II. do. do. as appertaining to man and existing in the Microcosm, III. do. do. for the purposes of Tdraka Yoga or Pranava Yoga. IV. do. do. for the purposes of Sdnkhya- Yoga (where they are, as it were, the inherent attributes of Prakriti). V. do. do, for the purposes of Hata Ydga. VI. do. do. for the purposes of Koula Agama, VII. do. do. for the purposes of Sdkta Agama, VIII. do. do. for the purposes of Siva Agama. IX. do. do. for the purposes of Sree- ckakram, (The Sreechakram referred to in "Isis Unveiled" is not the real esoteric Sreechakram of the ancient adepts of Aryavarta).* X. do. do. in Atharvana Veda, fc. ' Very truo. But who would be allowed (o give out tlio " real esoteric one"?— Ed. 18 . Id all these classifications, sobdivisions have been- mnlti'' plied indefioitely by conceiving new combinations of the Primary Powers in different proportions. Bat 1 most now drop this sabject and proceed to consider the article headed the ^*Fra-gment& of Occult Truth" (since embodied in "Esoteric Buddhism.") I have carefolly examined it, and find that the resnlts arrived at (in the Bnddhist doctrine) do not seem to differ mnch from the conclasious of oar Aryan philosophy, though our mode of stating the arguments may differ in form. I shall now discuss the question from my own stand-point, though following for facility of comparison and convenience of discus- sion the seqaence of classification of the seven-fold entities or Principles constituting man which is adopted in your article. The questions rais»ed for discussion are : (1) whether the cUs- embodied sjoiriU of human beings (as they are called by Spiritualists) appear in the stance-rooms and elsewhere; and (2) whether the manifestations taking place are produced wholly or partly through their agency. It is hardly possible to answer these two questions satisfac- torily unless the meaning intended to be conveyed by the expression '■^disembodied spirits oj human beings''' be accurate- ly defined. The words Spiritualism and Spirit are very misleading. Unless English writers in general, and Spiritual- ists in particular, first ascertain clearly the connotation they mean to assign to the word spirit there will be no end of confusion, and the real nature of these so-called spiritualistic phenomena and their modus occurrendi can never be clearly defined. Christian writers generally speak of only two entities in man — the body, and the soul or spirit (both seeming to mean the same thing to them). European philosophers generally speak of Bod^ and Mind^ and argue that soul or spirit cannot be anything else than mind- They are of opinion that any belief in Lingasariram* is entirely unphilosophical. These views are certainly incorrect, and are based oa * The Astral Body— so eaU«tU— Ed. 19 miwarranted assamptions as to the possibilities of nature, and on an imperfect understanding of its laws. I shall now examine (from the stand-point of the Brahmanical esoteric doctrine) the Spiritual constitution of man, the various entities or principles existing in him, and ascertain whether either of those entities entering into his composition can appear on earth after his death; and, if so, ttshat it is that so appears. Professor Tyndall in his Excellent papers on what he calls the "Germ Theory" monies to the following ooncinsions as the result of a series of well-planned experiments : — Even in a very small volume of space there are myriads of protoplas- mic germs floating in ether. If, for instance, say, — water (clear water^ is exposed to them and if they fall into it, some form of life or other will be evolved out of them. Now, what are the agencies for the bringing of this life into existence ? Evidently : — I. The watery which is the field, so to flay, for the growth of life. II. The protoplasmic germ, oat of which life or a living organism is to be evolved or developed. And, lastly — > III. The power, energy, force or tendency which springs into activity at the touch or combination of the protoplasmic germs and the water, and which evolves or develops life and its natural attributes. Similarly, there are three primary causes which bring the human being into existence. I shall call them for the pur- pose of discussion by the following names : — (1) Purabrakmam — The Universal Spirit. (2) SakfA (The crown of the astral light combining in itself all the powers of nature). (3) Prakriti, which in its original or primary shape is represented by Akasa (really, every form of matter is finally reducible to Akasa),* * The Tibetan esoteric Buddhist doctrine teaches that Prakriti is cosmie ■tatter, out of which all visible forms are proadced; and Akasa that same «oamic matter, — but gtill more subjective, its spirit, as it were, "PraArtti" Mug the body or tuhtatv^e, aud^Akasa-Sakti"" its soul or eaergy, — BD. 20 It is ordinarily stated that Prakriti or Akasa is the Kshet- ram or the basis which corresponds to water in the example we have taken ; Brahmam the germ^ and Sakti the power or energy that comes into existence at their anion or contact.' Bnt this is not the view which the Upaniskads take of the qnestion. According to them, Brahmam f is the Kshetram or basis, Akasa or Frakriti^ the germ or seed, and Sakti the power evolved by their union or contact. And this is the real scientific, philosophical mode of stating the case. Now, according to the adepts of ancient Aryavarta, seveif^ principles are evolved out of these three primary entities. Algebra teaches us that the number of combinations of n things taken one at a time, two at a time, three at a time and so ioxih=2n—\. Applying this formula to the present case, the number of entities evolved from different combinations of these three primary causes amounts to 23 — 1=8 — 1=7. As a general rule, whenever seven entities .are mentioned in the ancient occalt science of India, in any connection what- soever, you must sappose that those seven entities came into * Or, in other words, "Praleri%i Swabbdvdt or Akasa la — Space as the Tibetans have it ; Space filled with whatsoever substance or no substance at all ; i.e. with substance so imperceptible as to be only metaphysically con- ceivable. Brahmam^ then, would be the germ thrown into the soil of that field, and Sakci that mysterious energy or force which develops it, and which is called by the Buddhist Arahats of Tibet— FO-HAT. ''That which we calleci form (Rupa) is not different from that which we call space (SCknyata) . • Space is not different from Form. Form is the same as Space; Space is the same as form. And so with the other skandhas, whether vedana, or sanjua or sanskara or vijnana, they arc each the same as their opposite" . . , (Book of «m-fe»ny or the "Heart Sutra,". Chinese translation of the "Maha- Prajna-Paramita-Hridayft-Sutra." (Chapter on the "Avalokiteshwara," or the manifetted Buddha.') So that, the Aryan and Tabetan or Arhat doc* trines agree perfectly in substance, differing but in names given and the way of putting it. A distinction resulting from the fact that the Vodantin BrabmauB believe in Farabrahman, a deifio power impersonal though it may be, while the Buddhists entirely reject it. — Eo. t See A^pciidifit Note IV,- Ed. %% existence from three 'primary entities and that these three entities, again, are evolved oat of a single entity or Monad. To take a familiar example, the seven coloured raya in tha solar ray are evolved oat oi three 'primary coloured rays; and the three primary colours co-exist with the four secondary colours in the solar rays. Similarly, the three primary entitiea which brought man into existence co-exist in him with the four secondary entities which arose from different combinations of the three primary entities. Now these ^even entities which in their totality constitata man, are as follows : — I shall enumerate them in the order adopted in the "Fragments" as far as the two orders (the Brahmanical and the Tibetan) coincide : — Corresponding names in Esoteric Bnddhism. Prakriti. Stk'dlasariram ( Physical Body ). The entity evolved ^ out of the combina- / Sukshmasariram or LingasarU tion oi Prakriti and T ram (Astral Body). Sakti. ) Sakti. 1. 11. III. IV. V. VI. Kdmar'Apa (the Perisprit), The entity evolved "\ out oF the combina- ! -r ^ , ,t ^ c i tion of Brahmam, Ui^atrnd {Life-Soul), Sakti and Prakriti. J The entity evolved "\ out of the combina- / Physical Intelligence (or animal tion of Brahmam T soal). and Prakriti. J The entity evolved out of the combina- tion of 5ra/^;;,a7n^^P^"*^"^^^^*^«"^°«°<^«<<>''^°^)- and Sakti. Vll. Brahmam.- i The emanation from the Abso- \ LUTE, &c. (or pure spirit). 22 Before proceeding to examine the natnre of these seven entities, a few general explanations are indispensably ne- cessary. I. The secondary principles arising out of the combination of primary principles are quite different in their natnre from the entities out of whose combination they came into existence. The combinations in question are not of the nature of mere mechanical juxtapositions, as it were. They do not even correspond to chemical combinations. Consequently no valid inferences as regards the nature of the combinations in question can be drawn by analogy from the nature [variety?] of these combinations. II. The general proposition that when once a cause is removed its eflfect vanishes, is not universally applicable. Take, for instance, the following example : — if you once communicate a certain amount of momentum to a ball, velocity of a particular degree in a particular direction is the result. Now, the cause of this motion ceases to exist when the in- stantaneous sudden impact or blow which conveyed the momentum is completed ; but, according to the first Law of Mction, the ball will continue to move on for ever and ever with undiminished velocity in the same direction unless the said motion is altered, diminished, neutraliaed or counteracted by extraneous causes. Thus, if the ball stop, it will not be on account of the absence of the cause of its motion, but in con- sequence of the existence of extraneous causes which produce the said result. Again, take the instance of subjective phtnomena, • Now the presence of this ink-bottle before me is producing in me or in my mind a mental representation of its form, volume, colour and so forth. The bottle in question may be removed, but still its mental picture may continue to exist. Here, again, you see, the effect survives the cause. Moreover, the effect may at any subsequent time be called into conscious existence, whether the original cause be present or not. 23 ■ Now, in the case of the fifth principle above-mentioned— the entity that came into existence by the combination of Brahmam and Prakriti, — if the general proposition (in the "Fragments of Occult Truth") is correct, this principle which corresponds to the Physical intelligence must cease to exist whenever the Brahmam or the seventh principle should cease to exist for the particular individual; but the fact is certainly otherwise. The general proposition under consideration is ad- duced in the "Fragments" in support of the assertion that whenever the seventh principle ceases to exist for any parti- cular individual, the sixth principle also ceases to exist for him. The assertion is undoubtedly true though the mode of stating it and the reasons assigned for it are to my mind objectionable. It is said that in cases where tendencies of a man's mind are entirely material, and all spiritual aspirations and thoughts were altogether absent from his mind, the seventh principle leaves him either before or at the time of death, and the sixth principle disappears with it. Here, the very propo- sition that the tendencies of the particular individual's mind are entirely material, involves the assertion that there is no spiritual intelligence or spiritual Ega in bim. It shonld then have been said that, whenever spiritual intelligence ceases to exist in any particular individual, the seventh principle ceases to exist for that particular individual for all purposes. Of course, it does fly off anywhere. There can never be anything like a change of position in the case of Brahmam.* The assertion merely means that when there is no recognitioo ■whatever of Brahmam, or spirit^ or spiritual life, or spiritual consciousness, the seventh principle has ceased to exercise any influence or control over the individual's destinies. * Trne — from the ataodpoint of Aryan E»oterici*m, and the Upanishads; not quite so in the case of the Araliat or Tibetan esoteric doctrine>aud it i» only on this solitary point that the two teachings disagree, as far aa we know. The difference is very triEing though, resting, as it does, solely npoa the two various methods of viewing the one and th« same thing from two different aspects — See A^pewlix, Note XV. — Eo. 24 r shall now state what is meant (in the Aryan doctrine) by the seven principles above ennmerated. I. — Prakriti. This is the basis of Sthillasarlram and represents it in the above-mentioned classification. II. Prakriti and Sakti, — This is the Lingaaariram^ or astral body. III. Sakti. — This principle corresponds to yonr Kdmarupa. This power or force is placed by ancient occultists in the Ndbhichakram. This power can gather akdsa or prakriti and mould it into any desired shape. It has very great sympathy with the fifth principle, and can be made to act by its Influence or control. IV. Brakmam, Sakti, and Prakriti. — This again corresponds to your second principle, Jivtdmd. This power represents the universal life-principle which exists in nature. Its seat is the Andkatachakram (heart). It is a force or power which constitutes what is called Jiva^ or life. It is, as you say, indestructible, and its activity is merely transferred at the time of death to another set of atoms, to form another organ- ism. But it is not called Jivdtmd in our philosophy. The term Jwdtmd is generally applied by our philosophers to the seventh principle when it is distinguished from Para7ndtma or Parabrakmam.* V. Brakm and Prakriti. — This, in our Aryan philosophy, corresponds to your fifth principle, called the Physical iTitel" ligence. According to our philosophers, this is the entity in which what is called Mind has its seat or basis. This is the most difficult principle of all to explain, and the present discussion entirely turns upon the view we take of it. * The impersonal Parahrahmam thus being made to merge or separate itself into a jMr«onaZ**Jiv4tma" or the personal god of every human creature. This 18, again, a difference necessitated bj the Brahmanical-l)elie£ in a Gkni whether personal or impersonal, while the Baddhist Arahats, rejecting this idea entirely, recognise no deity apart from man. — Sec A^tndix, i^oto v.— Ed. Now, what ia mind ? It is a mysterions something which is considered to be the seat of conacionsneas— of sensations, emotions, volitions and thoughts. Psychological analysis shows it to be apparently a congeries of mental states, and possibilities of mental states, connected by what is called memory, and considered to have a distinct existence apart from any of its particnlar states or ideas. Now in what entity has this mysterions Something its potential or actual existence ? Memory and expectation which form, as it were, the real foundation of what is called tndimdualitf/, or Ahankdramy must have their seat of existence somewhere. Modern psychologists of Europe generally say that the mate- rial substance of 5/*a«w is the seat of mind; and that past subjective experiences^ which can be recalled by memory, and which in their totality constitute what is called indididualitt/^' exist therein in the shape of certain unintelligible mysterious' impressions and changes in the nerves and nerve-centres of the cerebral hemispheres. Consequently, they say, the mind — the individual mind — ^is destroyed when the body is destroyed j so there is no possible existence after death. But there are a few facts among those admitted by these philosophers which are sufficient for us to demolish their theory. In every portion of the human body, a constant change goes on without intermission. Every tissue, every muscular fibre and nerve-tube, and every ganglionic centre in the brain is undergoing an incessant change. In the course of a man's lifetime there may be a series of complete transform mations of the substance of his brain. Nevertheless the memory of his past mental states remains unaltered. There may be additions ot new subjective experiences and some mental states may be altogether forgotten, but no individual mental state is altered. The person's sense oj irtdimduaHty remains the same throughout these constant alterations in the brain substance.* It is able to survive all these changes, * This is also sound Buddhist philosophy, the transformation iu question beiug kauwn as the chaogc of the ska,ndhif. — £d. 2e and it cjin survive also the complete destruction of the mate- rial substance of the brain. This individuality arising from mental consciousness has its seat of existence, according to our philosophers, in an occult power or force which keeps a registry, as it were, of all our mental impressions. The power itself is indestructible, though by the operation of certain antagonistic causes its impressions may in course of time be effected, in part or wholly. I may mention in this connection that our philosophers have associated seven occult powers with the seven principles or entities above-mentioned. These seven occult powers in the microcosm correspond with, or are the counterparts of the occult powers in the macrocosm. The mental and spiritual consciousness of the individual becomes the general conscious- ness oi Brahmam when the barrier of individuality is wholly removed, and when the seven powers in the microcosm are placed en rapport with the seven powers in the macrocosm. There is nothing 'very strange in a power or force, or sakti carrying with it impressions of sensations, ideas, thoughts, or other subjective experiences. It is now a well-known fact, that an electric or magnetic current can convey in some mysterious manner impressions of sound or speech with all their individual peculiarities ; similarly, I can convey my thoughts to you by a transmission of energy or power. Now this fifth principle reptesents in our philosophy, the mind, or, to speak more correctly, the power or force above described, the impressions of the mental states therein, and notion of individuality or Ahankaram generated by their collective operation. This principle is called merely physical intelligence in the "Fragments." 1 do not know what is really meant by this expression. It mny be taken to mean that intelligence which exist in a very low state of development in the lower animals. Mind may exist in different stages of developmeut, from the very lowest forms of organic life, where 27 the signs of its existence or operation can hardly be distinctly realised, up to man, in whom it reaches its highest state of development. In fact, from the first appearance of life* ap to Tkureeya Avastka, or the state of Nirvana, the progress is, as it were continuous. We ascend from that principle up to the seventh by almost imperceptible gradations. Bat four stages are recognised in the progress where the change is of a peculiar kind, and is such as to arrest an observer's attention. These four stages are ai? follows : — (1) Where life (fourth principle) makes its appearance. (2) Where the existence of mind becomes perceptible in conjunction with life. (3) Where the highest state of mental abstraction ends, and spiritual consciousness commences. (4) Where spiritual consciousness disappears, leaving the seventh principle in a complete state of Nirvana^ or nakedness. According to our philosophers, the fifth principle under consideration is intended to represent the mind in every poS' sible state of development^ from the second stage up to the third stage, VI. Brahmam and Sakti. — This principle corresponds to your " spiritual intelligence." It is, in fact, Buddhi (I use the word Buddhi not in the ordinary sense, but in the sense in which it is used by our ancient philosophers^ ; in other words, it is the seat of Bddha or Atmabodha, One who has Atma-hudha in its completeness is a Buddha. Buddhists know very well ivhat this term signifies. This principle is described in the '* Fragments " as an entity coming into existence by the combination of Brahmxim and Prakriti. I do not again know * In the Aryan doctrine which blends Brahmam, Sakti, and Prakriti in one, it is the fourth principle, then ; in tlie Duadhist esotericism the second in combination with th^ first,— Bu, 28 in what particular sense the word Praki'iti is nscd in this con- nection. According? to onr philosophers it is an entity arising from the nnion of Brahm and Sakti. I have already explained the connotation attached by our philosophers to the words Prakriti and Sakti, I stated that Prakriti in its primary state is Akdsa.m If Akdsa be considered to be Sakti or Power,! then my statement as regards the ultimate state of Prakriti is likely to give rise to confusion and misapprehension unless I explain the distinction between Akasa and Sakti. Akdsa is not, properly speaking, the Crown of the Astral lights nor does it by itself constitute any of the six primary forces. But, generally speaking, whenever any phenomenal result is produced, Sakti acts in conjunction with Akdsa. And, more- over, Akdsa serves as a basis or Adhisthanum for the transmis- sion of force currents and for the formation or generation of force or power correlations.^ In Mantrasastra the letter " Ha *' represents Akdsa, and yon will find that this syllable enters into most of the sacred, formulae intended to be used in producing phenomenal results. * According to the Buddhists in Ak^sa lies that eternal, potential energy whose fanction it is to evolve all visible things out of itself. — Ed. ' '\ It was never so considered, as we have shawn it. Bat as the " Frag- mentjs" are written in English, a language lacking such an abundance of metaphysical terms to express every minute change of form, substance and state as found in the Sanskrit, it was deemed useless to confuse the Western reader nntrained in the methods of Eastenji expression more than necessaiy, with a too nice distinction of proper technical terms. As •' Prakriti in its primary state is 4^i€*a, and Sakti " is an ^tribute of *' A kasha," it becomes evident that for the uninitiated it is all one. Indeed, to speak of the ''Union of Brahmam and Prakriti " instead of "Brahmam and Sakti " is no worse than for a theist to write that " man has come into existence by the com- bination of spirit and matter," whereas, his words framed in orthodox shape, ought to read »* man as a living soul was created by the power ( or breath ) of God over matter" — Ed. X That is to say, the Ary4n AkSM h another word for Buddhist SPACE (iu its welapbysical meaning)— Bp« , 29 Bnt by itself it does not represent any Sakti. Yon may, if yoa please, call Sakti, an attribute of Akdsa. I do not think that as regards the nature of this principle there can, in reality, exist any difference of opinion between the Buddhist and Brahmanical philosophers. Bnddhist and Brahmanical initiates know very well that mysterious circular mirror composed of two hemispheres which reflects as it were the rays emanating from the "burn- ing bush" and the blazing star — the Spiritual sun shining in ChidakIsam. The spiritual impressions constituting this principle have their existence in an occult power associated with the entity in question. The successive incarnations of Buddha, in fact, mean the successive transfers of this mysterious power or the impressions thereon. The transfer is only possible when the Mahatma* who transfers it, has completely identified himself with his seventh principle, has annihilated his Ahankdiam^ and reduced it to ashes in Chidagnikundam and has succeeded in making his thoughts correspond with the eternal laws of nature and in becoming a co-worker with nature. Or to put the same thing in other words, when he has attained the state of Nirvdna, the co7idition of final negation, negation oj indivi- dual or separate existence.^ VII. Atma. — The emanation from the absolute ; corres- ponding to the seventh principle. As regards this entity there exists positively no real difference of opinion between the Tibetan Buddhist adepts and our ancient Eishis. We must now consider which of these entities can appear after the individual's death in stance-rooms and produce the so-called spiritualistic phenomena. Now, the assertion of the Spiritualists that the '^disembodi- ed spirits" of particular human beings appear in seance-rooms * The highest adept — Ed. ■(■ In the words of a gathd in the "Maha-pari-Nirvana Sfitra"— *' We reach a condition of licst," >^ Beyoud the Uroit oi an; bumaa knowledge''— £o. 30 aecessarily implies that the entity that so appears bears the stamp of some particular iudividnal's individuality. So, we have to ascertain beforehand in what entity or eutities individuality has its seat of existence. Apparently it exists in the person's particular formation of body, and in his subjective experiences, (called his mind in their totality). On the death of the individual his body is destroyed ; his lingasariram being decomposed, the power associated with it becomes mingled in the current of the corresponding power ia the macrocosm. Similarly, the third and fourth principles are mingled with their corresponding powers. These entities may again enter into the composition of other organisms. As these entities bear no impression of individuality, the Spiri- tualists have no right to say that the '^disembodied spirit" of the human being has appeared in the seance-room, whenever any of these entities may appear there. In tact, they have no means of ascertaining that they belonged to any particular individual. Therefore, we must only consider whether any of the last three entities appear in stance-rooms to amuse or to instruct Spiritualists. Let us take three particular examples of in- dividuals and see what becomes of these three principles after death. I. One in whom spiritual attachments have greater force than terrestrial attachments. II. One in whom spiritual aspirations do exist, but are merely of secondary importance to him, his terrestrial in- terests occupying the greater share of his attention. III. One in whom there exist no spiritual aspirations whatsoever, one whose spiritual Ego is dead or non-existent to his apprehension. We need not consider the case of a complete Adept in this connection. In the first two cases, according to our supposi- tion, spiritual and mental experiences exist together ; when spiritual consciousness exists, the existence of the seventh principle being recognised, it maintains its couaections with 31 the fifth and sixth principles. But the existence of terrestrial attachments creates the necessity of punarjanmam, the latter signifying the evolution of a new set of objective and sub- jective experiences, constituting a new combination of sur- rounding circumstances or, in other words, a new world. The period between death and the next subsequent birth is occupied with the preparation required for the evolution of these new experiences. During the period of incubation, as you call it, the spirit will never of its own accord appear in this world, nor can it so appear. There is a great law in this universe which consists in the reduction of subjective experience to objective phenomena and the evolution of the former from the latter. This ia otherwise called "cyclic necessity." Man is subjected to this law if he does not check and counterbalance the usual destiny or fate, and he can only escape its control by subduing all his ter- restrial attachments completely. The new combination of cir- cumstances under which he will then be placed may be better or worse than the terrestrial conditions under which he lived. But in his progress to a new world, you may be sure he will never turn around to have a look at his spiritualistic friends.* In the third of the above three cases there is, by our sup- position, no recognition of spiritual consciousness or of spirit. So they are non-existing so far as he is concerned. The case is similar to that of an organ or faculty which remains unused for a long time. It then practically ceases to exist. These entities, as it were, remain his or in his possession, when they are stamped with the stamp of recognition. When such is not the case, the whole of his individuality is centered in his fifth principle. And after death this fifth principle is the only representative of the individual in question. By itself it cannot evolve for itself a new set of objective experiences, or to say the same thing in other words, it has no • As M. A. (Oxon) will, see the Spiritualists have still less chance of having their claims recoguis'Jil by Brahmaaical than by Budtlhiat occultists. —Ed. 32 punarjanmam. It is sncb an entity that can appear in stance- rooms ; but it is absurd to call it a diseinbodied spirit* It is merely a power or force retaining the impressions of the thoughts or ideas of the individual into whose composition it originally entered. It sometimes summons to its aid the Kdmariipa power; and creates for itself some particular ethereal form (not necessairly human). Its tendencies of action will be similar to those of the in- dividual's mind when he was living. This entity maintains its existence so long as the impressions on the power associat- ed with the fifth principle remain intact. In course of time they are efiaced, and the power in question is then mixed up in the current of its correspondiug power in the Macrocosm, as the river loses itself in the sea. Entities like these may afford signs of there having been considerable intellectual power in the individuals to which they belonged ; because very high intellectual power may co-exist with utter absence of spiritual consciousness. But from this circumstance it cannot be argued that either the spirits or the spiritual Egos of deceased individuals appear in s^ance^rooms. There are some people in India who have thoroughly studied the nature of such entities ( called pisacham ). I do not know much about them experimentally, as I have never meddled with this disgusting, profitless, and dangerous branch of investigation. Your Spiritualists do not know what they are really doing. Their investigations are likely to result in course of time either in wicked sorcery or in the utter spiritual ruin of thousands of men and women.f The views I have herein expressed have been often illus- trated by our ancient writers by comparing the course of a man's life or existence to the orbital motion of a planet round • It is especially on this point that the Aryan abd Arahat doctrines quite agree, the teaching and argument that follow are, in evoiy respect, those of the Buddhist Himalayan Brotherhood.— El). \ We bharc entirely in this idea. —Ed. 33 the snn. Centripetal force is gpiritaal attraction and centri- fogal, terrestrial attraction. As the centripetal force increases in power in comparison with the centrifugal force, the planet approaches the sun — the individual reaches a higher plane of existence. If, on the other hand, the centrifugal force becomes greater than the centripetal force, the planet is removed to a greater distance from the sun, and moves in a new orbit at that distance — the individual comes to a lower level of exist- ence, These are illustrated in the first two instances I have noticed above. We have only to consider the two extreme cases. When the planet in its approach to the sun passes over the line where the centripetal and centrifugal forces completely neutralize each other and is only acted on by the centripetal force, it rushes towards the sun with a gradually increasing velocity and is finally mixed up with the mass of the sun's body. This is the case of complete Adept, Again, when the planet in its retreat from the sun reaches a point where the centrifugal force becomes all-powerful it flies off in a tangential direction from its orbit, and goes into the depths of void space. When it ceases to be under the control of the sun, it gradually gives np its generative heat and the creative energy that it originally derived from the Bun, and remains a cold mass of material particles wandering through space until the mass is completely decomposed into atoms. This cold mass is compared to the fifth principle nnder the conditions above noticed, and the heat, light, and energy that left it are compared to the sixth and seventh principles. Either after assuming a new orbit or in its course of divia- tion from the old orbit to the new, the planet can never go back to any point in its old orbit, as the various orbits lying in different planes never intersect each other. This figurative representation correctly explains the ancient Brahmanical theory on the subject. It is merely a branch of what is called the Great Law of the Universe by the ancient mystics • APPENDIX BY MADAME H. P. BLAVATSKY. Note I. In this connection it will be well to draw the reader's at- tention to the fact that the country called "Si-dzang" by the Chinese, and Tibet by "Western geographers, is mentioned in the oldest books preserved in the province of Fo-kien (the chief head-qnarters of the aborigines of China) — as the great seat of occult learning in the archaic ages. According to these records, it was inhabited by the 'Teachers of Light," the "Sons of Wisdom" and the "Brothers of the Sun." The Emperor Yu the "Great" (2207 B. C), a pious mystic, is credited with having obtained his occult wisdom and the sys- tem of theocracy established by him — for he was the first one to unite in China ecclesiastical power with temporal authority —from Si-dzang. That system was the same as with the old Egyptians and the Chaldees ; that which we know to have existed in the Brahmauical period in India, and to exist now in Tibet; namely, all the learning, power, the temporal as well as the secret wisdom were concentrated within the hierarchy of the priests and limited to their caste. Who were the abori- gines of Tibet is a question which no ethnographer is able to answer correctly at present. They practise the Bhon religion their sect is a pre — andanti — Buddhistic one, and they are to Le found mostly in the province of Kam — that is all that" is known of them. But even that would justify the supposition that they are the greatly degenerated descendants of mighty and wiee forefathers. Their ethnical type shows that they are not pure Turanians, and their rites — now those of sorcery, incantations, and nature-worship, remind one far more of the popular rites of the Babylonians, as found in the records preserved ou the excavi^ted cyliwd^rs, thau of the religious 35 practices of the Chinese — sect of Tao-sse — a reh'gion based npon pnre reason and spiritnality — as alleged by some. Generally, little or no differnce is made even by the Kye- lang missionaries who mix greatly with these people on the borders of British LahonI — and ongbt to know better — between the Bhons and the two rival Baddhist sects, the Yellow Caps and the Red Caps. The latter of these have opposed the reform of Tzong-ka-pa from the first and have always adhered to old Bnddhism so greatly mixed up now with the practices of the Bhons. Were onr Orientalists to know more of them, and compare the ancient Babylonian Bel or Baal worship with the rites of the Bhons, they would find an undeniable connection between the two. To begin an argu- ment here, proving the origin of the aborigines of Tibet as connected with one of the three great races which superseded each other in Babylonia, whether we call them the Akkatiians (invented by F. Lenormant,) or the primitive Turanians, Chaldees and Assyrians — is out of question. Be it as it may, there is reason to call the trans-Himalayan esoteric doctrine Chaldeo-Tibetan. And, when we remember that the V^das came — agreeably to all traditions — from the Maussorowar Lake in Tibet, and the Brahmins themselves from the far North, we are justified in looking ou the esoteric doctrines of every people who once had or still has it — as having proceeded from one and the same source: and, to thus call it the "Aryan-Chaldeo- Tibetau" doctrine, or Universal Wisdom Religion. "Seek for the Lost Word among the hierophants of Tartary, China and Tibet," was the advice of Swedenborg, the seer. Note IL Not necessarily — we say. The Vedas, Brahraanism, and along with these, Sanskrit, were importations into what we now regard as India* They were never indigenous to its soil. There was a time when the ancient nations of the West included under the generic name of India, many of the countries of Asia now classified under other names. There was an Upper, a Lower, and a Western India, even during m the comparatively late period of Alexander ; and Persia (Iran) is called Western India in some ancient classics. The countries now named Tibet, Mongolia, and Great Tartary •were considered by them as forming part of India. When wo say, therefore, that India has civilized the world and was the Alma Mater of the civilizations, arts and sciences of all other nations (Babylonia, and perhaps even Egypt, included) we mean archaic, pre-historic India, India of the time when the great Gobi was a sea, and the lost "Atlantis" formed part of an unbroken continent which began at the Himalayas and ran down over Southern India, Ceylon, Java, to far-away Tasmania. Note III. To ascertain such disputed questions, one has to look into and study well the Chinese sacred and historical records — a people whose era begins nearly 4,600 years back (2697 B. C). A people so accurate and by whom some of the most important inventions of modern Europe and its so much boasted modern science, were anticipated— such as the compass, gun-powder, porcelain, paper, printing, &c. — known, and practised thousands of years before these were rediscovered by the Europeans, ought to receive some trust for their records. And from Lao- tze down to Hiouen-Thsang their literature is filled with allusions and references to that island and the wisdom of the Himalayan adepts. In the Catena of Buddhist Scriptures from the Chinese by the Rev. Samuel Beal, there is a chapter "On the Tian-Ta'i School of Buddhism" (pp. 244-258) which our opponents ought to read. Translating the rules of that most celebrated and holy school and sect in China founded by Chin-che-K'hae, called Che-chay (the wise one) in the year 575 of our era, when coming to the sentence which reads; "That which relates to the one garment (seamless) worn by the Great Teachers of the Snowy Mountains, the school of the Haimavatas" (p. 256) the European translator places after the last sentence a sign of interrogation, as well he may. The statistics of the school of the "Haimayatas" or of our 37 Himalayan Brotherhood, are not to be found in the General Censns Records of India. Farther, Mr. Beal translates a Rale relating to "the great professors of the higher order who live in raoantain depths remote from men," the Aranyakds, or hermits. So, with respect to the traditions concerning this island, and apart from the (to them,) historical records of this preserved ia the Chinese and Tibetan Sacred Books: the legend is alive to this day among the people of Tibet. The fair Island is no more, bat the country where it once bloomed remains there still, and the spot is well-known to some of the "great teachers of the snowy mountains," however much convulsed and changed its topography by the awful cataclysm. Every seventh year, these teachers are believed to assemble in Sgham- Cha-lo, the "happy land.'' According to the general belief it is situated in the north-west of Tibet. Some place it within the unexplored central regions, inaccessible even to the fear- less nomadic tribes; others hem it in between the range of the Gangdisri Mountains and the northern edge of the Gobi Desert, South and North and the more populated regions of Khoondooz and Kashmir, of the Gya-Pheling (British India), and China, West and East, which affords to the curious mind a pretty large latitude to locate it in. Others still place it between Namur Nur and the Kuen-Lun Mountains — but one and all firmly believe in Scham-bha-la, and speak of it as a fertile, fairy-like land, once an island, now an oasis of incompa- rable beauty, the place of meeting of the inheritors of the esote- ric wisdom of the god-like inhabitants of the legendary Island. In connection with the archaic legend of the Asian Sea and the Atlantic Continent, is it not profitable to note a fact known to all modern geologists — that the Himalayan slopes afibrd geological proof, that the substance of those lofty peaks was once a part of an ocean floor ? Note IV. We have already pointed out that, in our opinion, the whole difference between Buddhistic and Vedautic philosophies was 38 that the former was a kind of Rationalistic Vedantisra, while the latter might be regarded as Transcendental Buddhism. If the Aryan esotericism applies the term Jtvdtmd to the seventh principle, the pnre and per se unconscious spirit — it is be- cause the Vedanta postulating three kinds of existence — (1) the paramdrthika, — {the true^ the only real one,) (2), the Tyavahdrika (the practical,) and (3) the pratibhasika (the apparent or illusory life) — makes the first life or Jiva the only truly existent one. Brahma or the one's self is its only representative in the universe, as it is the universal Life in toto, while the other two are but its "phenomenal appear- ance," imagined and created by ignorance, and complete illusions suggested to us by our blind senses. The Buddhists* on the other hand, deny either subjective or objective reality even to that one Self-Existence. Buddha declares that there is neither Creator nor an Absolute! Being. Buddhist ra- tionalism was ever too alive to the insuperable difficulty of admitting one absolute consciousness, as in the words of Flint — "wherever there is consciousness there is relation, and wherever there is relation there is dualism." The One Life is either *'mukta" (absolute and unconditioned) and can have no relation to anything nor to any one; or it is "Baddha" (bound and conditioned), and then it cannot be called the ABSOLUTE ; the limitation, moreover, necessitating another deity as powerful as the first to account for all the evil in this world. Hence, the Arahat secret doctrine on cosmogony admits but of one absolute, indestrnctible, eternal, and uncreat- ed UNCONSCIOUSNESS (so to translate), of an element (the word being used for want of a better term) absolutely independent of everything else in the universe; a something ever present or ubiquitous, a Presence which ever was, is and will be, whether there is a God, gods, or none; whether there is a universe, or no universe; existing during the eternal cycles of Maha Yugs, during the Pralayas ; as during the periods of Manvantara: and this is Space, the field for the operation of the eternal Forces and natural Law, the basis (as Mr. Siibba Row rightly calls it) upon which take place the eternal 3ft intercorrelations of Akftsa-Prakriti, guided by the nnconscions regnlar palsations of Sakti — the breath or power of a conscious deity, the theists would say, — the eternal energy of an eternal, unconscious Law, say the Buddhists. Space then, or "Fan, Bar-uang" (Maha Sunyata) or, as it is called by Lao-tze, the "Emptiness" is the nature of the Buddhist Absolute. (See Confncins' '*Praise of the Abyss.'"} The word jha^ then could never be applied by the Arahats to the Seventh Principle, since it is only through its correlation or contact with matter that Fohat (the Buddhisb active energy) can develop active conscious life; and that to the question "how can Unconscious- ness generate consciousness T* the answer would be "Was the seed which generated a Bacon or a Newton self-conscious?" Note V. To our European readers: Deceived by the phonetic similarity, it must not be thought that the name "Brahman" is identical in this connection with Brahma or Iswara — the personal God. The Upanishads — the Vedanta Scriptures — mention no such God and one would vainly seek in them any allusions to a conscious deity. The Brahmam, or Parabrahm, the absolute of the Vedantins, is neuter and unconscious, and has no connec- tion with the masculine Brahma of the Hindu Triad, or ■Trimurti. Some Orientalists rightly believe the name derived from the verb "Brih," to grow or increase^ and to be in this sense, the universal expansive force of nature^ the vivifying and spiritual principle, or power, spread throughout the universe and which in its collectivity is the one Absoluteness, the one Life and the only Reality, *'rHE PHILOSOPHY OF SPIRIT: The book bearing the above title, and professing to exponnd "the philosophy of spirit" contained in the Bhagaiatgita^ has already been introduced to the readers of the "Thesophist" by the review that appeared in the December nnfnber, and the author's reply thereto published in the copy of March. Con- Bidering the importance of the issues raised by the author's publication, and the two articles above referred to, I persuade myself that I shall be justified in sifting, with some minute- ness, the conclusions arrived at by the author regarding the authorship and philosophy of the Bhagavatgita and its esoteric basis or foundation. As the author has not merely published his own speculations regarding the subjects dealt with in that ancient work, but informs the public that his speculations are in perfect accordance with the ancient philosophy of Vyasa, 1 believe I have a right, as a Hindu, to object to the position taken by him, if, in my humble opinion, his views should be at variance with those of the orthodox pundits and the initiates of ancient Aryavarta, as much as with those of modern India. And I hope the learned gentleman will be good enough to excuse me, if, in this article, I may be under the painful necessity of dwelling longer on what 1 conceive to be the defects of his work than on its merits. Though the author does not seem to be a Spiritualist in the sense in which that term is used by the so-called modern professors of that name, still he has attempted to give a philosophical shape to their crude notions about "disembodied spirits"; and any intelligent and profitable discussion of the real points of difference between Theosophy and Spiritualism is only possible with writers like Mr. Oxley. In this article I shall first examine the author's theory about the real origin of sacred writings in general and of the Bhagavatgita in particular, and next, in his remarks, scattered throughout the book, about what he calls the Astro-Masonic basis of the said treatise, and his views about some of the doctrines therein expluiued. 41 At the ontset, it is necessary to apprehend correctly Mr. Oxley's opinions about the constitution of man and the progress of what the learned author is pleased to call •* life- principle " after death. The author recognizes the trinity of man, and names the three entities that constitute him — body, spirit and soul. He calls " Soul " the " inmost of all," " eternal, incorruptible, unchangeable and inseparable from the grand Life, called God," while describing " Spirit" as the *' inner or intermediate active agent which guides, propels and uses as its instrument the body, or that covering which is exterior to itself" (p. 221). From these explanations it is apparent that the author means by "soul" and " spirit " the same entities as are denoted by the two Sanskrit terms Atma (7th principle) and Sookskmasatiram^ or Lingasariram^ re- spectively. The author is at liberty to attach any connotations he pleases to these words, as no definite meaning has yet been attached to them by English writers. But 1 do not think he has used the word Spirit in the sense above indicated throughout his book ; for, he further says that there are 12 degrees or stages of ascent ( p. 40 ), which the life-principle in man has to pass through in its spiritual progress ; and we are also informed that, on reaching the 12th stage, man be- comes an angel. Further progress from angel-hood upwards or inwards is admitted, though the author does not undertake to describe it. He farther proceeds to say ( pp. 53, 56, 181, &c., ) that particular individuals are in some mysterious way connected with particular spiritual communities " receiving their life-influx" from them and imbibing their influence. And every human being will, in the course of his progress, become an angel of some particular description or other. Now I beg to submit, with all due respect to the author's guru^ that these views do not harmonize with the teachings of Vyasa and the other Rishis of ancient Aryavarta. The dif- ference between the doctrines of the ancient Aryan esoteric science and the propositions above laid down, will not be pro- perly appreciated unless the meaning attached by the author 6 42 to the word angel i» first ascertaitteil, Thong-h the said word is no-wbere defined ia his book, yefe from a foot-note in page &3, it can be easily seen that an angel means Derata. Those, who are aeqnainted with Sanskrit mythology, know very well that there are several classes of I>evata ; that these classes perish at the end of each Mantoantara* and that new classes or tribes {Ganants) come into existence at the beginning of every snbeeqnent Manwantara. It will also be seen, from the Hindu turanas and the Makabkarata itself, that neither the individnals of these various tribes, nor yet the tribes collectively, undergo any change, transmigration* or transla- tions into a higher state, or a higher plane of existence. No Hindn has ever heard of a Takska or Gandharva') becoming a Leva, and of a J)eva becoming a higher being. The really important difference, however, between the author's theory and the doctrines of the ancient Rishis, consists in the view taken of the various degress or " states-being*' in a man and their esoteric significance. The author's desire to find some reference to the 12 signs of the Zodiac in almost everything connected with the ancient Aryan religion and philosophy, has probably led him to the belief that there are 12 degrees in man corresponding to the 12 signs ot the Zodiac; and it would also, appear that such was his gurus teaching. The author, however, has no right, it seems to me, to import into the Aryan doctrine either his guru's teaching or his own fancies, unless he is in a position to show that they are in aiccordance with the teachings of the ancient Rishis. 1 shall now state what the Aryan doctrine really teaches as regards these states or degrees, as far, of course, as I am permitted to say in an article intended for publication. The 5ei-6/i-/o^rf classification in man was already prominently brought to the notice of the readers of the " Theosophist" in * The period oi Hegeneratton, or the active life ol the nnirerse between two Pralayat cr universal Desfcrnotion : the former being called the " day " and the latter the " night " of Brahma — En. t Yaksha, the earth-spirit or GDome; the Oandharva, akin to th« Christian cherub or singing teraph. There are, says Athana Fcda^XI, &, 2, ), 6,3"J3, Gaiidharvas in tbeir Loka. — Eir. 4* Hie article headed "Fragments of Occult Truth,"* and in a subseqaent article, referring to aad completing it, published in the January naraber of the said journal. f These sevea entities in man represent the 7 principles that constitute him. Bat the Rishis also recognized 16 stages of ascent — not 12 as the author has erroneously supposed — from Prithioi Tattram np to ** the eternal aad infinite monad" — the anfoides that overshadows every mao, the blaeing star at the end of Skoda- santum (end of the 16th stage of ascent). Busiris himself, when in hatnan form cus Krishni Dwypayana (!), spoke of Shodaidvttum,^ as may be seen from the many sacred writings attributed to Vyasa, From the stand-poiat of Aryaa phtlo* sophy, the author is right in saying that a man becomes perfect on reaching the 11th stage, but he ia wrong in saying that, on attaining the next higher step, he becomes an "angel" or Deva. The nature of the last 5 stages, spoken of by the ancient Rishis, is not clearly understood even by the ordinarif imtiate.X It is not surprising, then, that an author, like Mr. Oxley, who attempts to interpret the ancient Aryan doc- trine without knowing either the Sanskrit language, the Hindu systems of mythology, the Eastern modes of allegorizing spiri- tual truths, or the physiology and psychology as taught by the ancients, should have misunderstood the meaning of the 12th stage. No one, who correctly understands the meaning of the 8th Adhyaya (chapter) of the Bhagavatgita, and compares the original with the author's translation of the said chapter, wilJ be inclined to doubt the correctness of our assertion. In that chapter, Krishna, speaking of the future state of the human being after death, says that, generally speaking, "the life- printjiple" in man (the Karanasariram probably ?) assumes the shape and nature of that being or entity on whom, or on which, the human being concentrates his attention deeply. Therefore, and as it is not desirable for a human being to * "THEosPHIgT," October, 1881. \ <' Tbe Arjau-Arbat Esoteric Tenets on the SereQ-Fold Priaciple ia Man. ; Au iaitiat3 0l the pc«Iimin»r7 degrees. 44 contemplate aoy other spiritual entity or being than Krishna himself, he advises Arjuna to centre his thoughts in him. Bat, who is Krishna ? The Bhagavatgita does not leave as in any doubt about this question. In giving an account of his Vibhuti (as it is called in Sanskrit ) Krishna commences by saying " Ahamatma "* (I am Atma—the 7th principle in man). To use the author's phraseology, he is the " soul" — the inmost principle in man. The author admits this view in certain portions of his book, though, for the purpose of establishing the claims of Busiris to the authorship of the "Mahabharata," a diflferent interpretation would perhaps be necessary. And, in recommending the contemplation or Dhyan of one's own atma, Krishna points out two different modes of doing it, in the 9th, 12th and 13th Slokamihs of the chapter above mentioned. The author's translation of the 9th Slokam is enough to convince me that he has no defininte idea about the esoteric meaning therein found, and that he mistook the spiritual being or entity described in the said Slokam for his favourite angel. He translates the significant Sanskrit adjective — Furananit as if it meant ^The Ancient Angel,'* I shall be very happy indeed to learn in what Sanskrit Lexicon is this meaning given, or what are the Sanskrit words used in the Slokam that could ever suggest that idea of an "angel." From this instance of mis-transla- tion, as well as from other similar instances, which will be noticed further, I am justified in thinking that the author's theories were formed before he had carefully ascertained the esoteric meaning of the Bhagavatgita\ and that he simply attempted to find support for his individual speculation in it, and to identify modern Spiritualism (however advanced) with what he is pleased to call " Ancient Yogiuism" (P. 87). In fact, in the Slokatn, or verse in question, there is no re- ference whatsoever to any angel, Deva or God. The last five stages in the ladder of ascent have exactly the same meaning * The "I AM, That I am" of the Biblical Jehovah, the "I am who I AM," or Mazdao" of Ahuramazda in the Zeud Avcsta, &c. All tbeije are names for the 7tb principle in man,— Ed. 45 that is given by the esoteric Baddhism to the fonr celestial *' Dhyan-Baddhas" and " Adi-Baddha." Krishna significantly alludes to the Dhyan-Baddhas in the 9th and 10th Slokas, and speaks of "Adi-Baddha" — the state or condition represented by Pranava — in the succeeding verses.* While he applies the wore Purusha to these " Dhyan-Buddhas " he speaks of Adi-Buddhas, as if it were merely a state or condition.f The two expressions, Anusasitarum and Aditya-Varnam^ in the 9th verse may give the author a clue to the mystery connected with these *' Dhyan-Buddhas." I am not permitted to state in an article the views of the ancient Rishis concerning these 5 stages — the spiritual counterparts oithe 5 chambers of construe^ Hon above the King's chamber in the great Pyramid of Egypt — or the phliosophy underlying the Buddhist doctrine regard- ing these 5 Buddhas. Bat it is enough for my present pur- pose to state that these celestial " Dhyan-Buddhas" came into existence (according to Vyasa) before the last work of creation or evolution commenced, and consequently, before any Deva or Angel was evolved. Therefore, they are to be regarded as occupying a higher position (in a spiritual sense) than even Brahma, Vishnu and Ishwara, the three highest gods of the Hindu Pantheon — as they are the direct emanations of Paj-a- brahman. The author will understand my meaning clearly, when he examines the accounts of '* creation " given in the Hindu Puranas, and comes to comprehend what the ancient Rishis meant by Sanaha^ Sanandana^ Sanatkumara^ and declined : and in spite of repeated revivals at different epochs, every effort to restore it to the traditional pristine glory of the Golden Age has failed.* Now assuming that one section of the Brothers succeed in resuscitating their order on the old lines, what security can we have that, at best, it would be but a sprouting out from the decaying trunk of the old tree of knowledge : as is proved by the history of the past. The ancient Hindu, Brahminical, Buddhistic, Egyptain, Hebrew or Arabic, Christian and Mahomedan systems are mere variations from the same stock, and all of which were best at their beginnings. How comes it, that notwithstanding the more immediate presence, influence, and tutelage of the * We beg to be permitted to emphatically deny the statement. Neither the Theooophisl — i..e., ita editor nor any one of the Founders, has ever admitted anything of the sort about the "Oriental System," whatever some of its contribators may have remarked apon the sabject. If it has degenerated among its votaries in India (a fact due entirely to the cunning of its dead letter interpretation by the modern orthadox Brahmin who has lost the key to it) it flourishes as high as ever in the Himalayan retreats, in the ashrum of the initiated Brahmin, and in all the "pristine glory of the Golden Age."— Ed. 78 Brothers to the Indian popnlatious, that these confessedly have become degraded, and have lost their own spiritaality and power.* What other fate can befall us, as a Theosophical Society, if the very roots of onr life, as snch, draw their vitality from a decaying Tree, whose fraits, leaves, and branches are of "efflax" growth, and that of a descending order; inasmuch as it ignores the inmost "Law of Influx" from the Tree of Life of an inner causation ? All outgrowth in that direction must, of necessity, sooner or later exhaust their vitality. It is the new influx from the Grand Central Sun of all existences, that causes of the soul to rise to higher states and forms of consciousness; and by means of this, the newly evolved states therefrom, form a new series of a system — on an ascending scale which will never retrograde, as have done and do, the grades of a purely Planetary Cycle of incarnations, whose occultations shut out the direct light of Grand Eternal Sun. The teachings of 'Theosophy' appear to imply that there is latent power possessed of self-sufficient energy, sufficient in itself for the evolvement of a new species, without the inter- vention of a still higher power. For instance, can this alleged self-sufficient energy from an object without existing materials ? Can it create a thought * The "tutelage of the Brothers to the Indian popnlations" is a fancy based on a misconception. Ever since Buddhism with its esoteric in- terpretations of the Vedas and other sacred books was driven out of the country by the ambition and jealousy of the Brahmins, the trutht of eso- tericism began to fade out!of the memory of those populations until there now remains hardly one Brahmin in ten thousand who understands the Shastras at all. Hindus were degraded for the same reason that life and spirit have gone out of Christianity. The increase of wealth-bred sensuality, quenched spiritual tispiration and intuition, plugged the ears that once listened and shut the eyes that once saw the teachers. And at last by gradual deterioration of species, multiplications of war, and increased scarcity of food supply, the prime question became that of a struggle for life to the obliteration of spiritual yearnings. — T. S. R. 7d or an idea of a new form, absolutely independent of that which comes into the mind from the ideal realm of being from whence all germs are derived ?* It it were possible to sever the lines of the snbtile — but ex- ternally invisible — thread of life which extends from the Parent Tree of life in the midst of the universal Garden to the external circumference of its physical manifestation ; and to maintain such severed lives vitality ; then, I admit, the Law of Efflux would be an all-sufficient cause for the appear- ance and perpetuation of those new and higher forms of life which have been evolved and manifested at different epochs. If any order, — dependent solely on the traditional obser- vances of those who ages ago derived their light at first and second hand from the fountain of all light, — should deny us the privilege of using their stores of ancient experimental knowledge by interposing impractical barriers ; yet jao order can prevent our access to the Grand Fountain of Light and Love, where we may drink freely of the waters of Life.t Is not this better than being confined to partake of a descend- ing stream of wisdom which silts up its outlets with the stands of ages, — leaving a portion of its strength and power at every stage of its descent, until, at length, it is lost in the desert waste, where so many famish; and who cannot reach the purer water higher up the stream ? Nor is it so with those systems which are on the ascending plane and order. By virtue of their being ever subject to the direct energy of the * Most assuredly not. Both this neither proves existence of the one Atom, separated from and differentiated by, its unity from all other atoms, nor does it point to the necessity of one. At any rate, even our English Brother's '* one atom " or God can hardly create *' an object " without existent materials or matter, — T. S. R. ■j- The "Grand Fountain of Light and Love" is a very poetical meta- phor— and uo more, when applied to an unproved abstraction, Wc admit of such a fountain but not outside of, independent from, past, present and future humanity, (the crown of the evolution on our globe) every individual atom of which is a drop of thar. "Water of Life" the agglomera- tion of the drops of which forms that **one Fountain."— T. 8. B. ^0 Divine Solar ray, they have power to do that which other systems never coald accomplish. How can a system impart that which it admits it does not possess, viz., the dual states of adeptship ? Where there are no feminine adepts in the order, it mast ultimately yield to that dual power which is able to polarise and prepare both male and female atoms for the state in which they are fitted to be drawn up into the 'Celestial Marriage*. When intromitted into this state these wedded atoms act and re-act until every quality of their united being rotates and vibrates up and down the semn sides of the ray until becoming all radiant with light and heat in themselves, they are able to project the new born germs of a higher and purer life into the souls of those beneath them, who are drawn into the same state, and who, in their turn, may give out their several degrees of light and heat, and life to all around; and so on ad infinitum.* By these intermediates the mass of mankind receive the new order of life unconsciously according to their respective deeds, but the dual adepts will receive it consciously by direct influx. In order that new life-forms may be generated, the new life-force of a higher and purer order, must inflow into prepared atoms to receive the same both on this and other earths. * Again an unwarranted assertion whichever way we see it. There are * 'female" adepts in the Brotherhood, and of a rery high order. There- fore, there being such, in fact, the deductions drawn from a mistaken premise fall. And if onr opponent had in mind in writing the above sentence, something more abstract and vague than a more physical differ- ence of aexes, then he will allow me perhaps, to tell him that oar esoteric philosophy jprov^ that outside of the world of gross matter there is no snch difference, the latter itself occurring (even on our earth) as an acci- dent dne to gestation and not as a result of snch or another male or female germ. Even the Christian Bible, the youngest of the many attempts to religions philosophy, teaches him that in the resurrection the people "neither marry not are given in marriages". So that "Celestial marriage, whatever this may mean in modern Esotericism, appears to be but a figure of speech. Oar readers might also be benefited were they explained what it meant by a ♦•Dual Adept."— T. S. K. 81 How, except throngh the Diviae Solar state of a wedded pair, can this higher and purer life be generated ? With this in view, it can be seen that the 'Brothers' — with their celi- bate conditions of adeptship — cannot possibly beget a higher, or pnrer, order of life than their own;hecce it follows that a system, based on snch a principle, cannot perpetnate itself.* It is at the cnlmination of a seventh cycle — a symbol of the Celestial Snn-day— that another Ray is shot forth across the universal Earth, and those who are prepared to receive its inflaeuce, and give birth, or nltimation, to higher forms of life, upon the respective earths they inhabit, according to its degree of development in the series; for as so ably shown by the writer of "Fragments of Occnlt Truth," the varied earths of a system, all differ as to states of mental and spiritual deve- lopment; and yet not one could suffer deprivation of this Cyclic action from the 'Grand Sun,' without all the rest suffering from such loss to any specific member of the Solar family. Here comes in the distinction and ditierence between the guidance and teaching of the Planetary and Solar Guru. The one is the Forerunner, and prepares the way for the other; and it is the later one who leads his Chelas — both masculine and feminine — beyond the Tree of Knowledge, even to the Tree of Life itself.f ♦ Not necessarily. One critic seems to forget, — or perchance never know — that an adept has means of inbreathing, into his chosen '• chela " besides his own "high order of life," to nse his own expression, that of one still higher than himself, t. e., of the highest Bhodisatra living or dead, provided the parity of his own life permits to him the performance of the mysterioQS assimilation. But we can assure onr Brother, that without that "celibate" mode of life, against which he seems to protest 80 strongly, no adept could ever reach such a degree of power. Souls as well as spirits are sexless, and it is a great mistake to say that no "male monad" (?) can incarnate in a female body or vice versa. Mental and moral characteristics or idiosyncracies as met daily in life contradict the statement. It is owing to previous Karma that we discover so often masculine traits in weak female bodies and feminine tenderness and nervousness in strongmen. — T. S. B. ■j" Does our Brother, who speaks so often of the "Tree of Life," know itt real esoteric significance ? Let him prove it, by hinting at the grand mystery, and if he does show his knowledge — then verily will our Mabat> m»B he at his orders ! — T. 8. R. 11 82 It is the leaves of this Tree — the life-giving power which are to be given for the "healing of the nations/' and by this means the long-lost, and neglected ones, which the Occnlt system woald hopelessly consign to annihilation, are to be gathered up and nntilted by the great Economiser; so that there shall be nothing lost; and thas the fragments of the (apparently) long-lost Orb shall be collected and form a shin- ing San to enlighten the still denser darkness of the neither realms. In the above few hints, (for yonr space wonld not permit of more) 1 have shown a use for the elementals, reliquce, etc., etc., which Occult science does appear to recognise; and did your space permit I should be glad to show the necessity for these in the formation of earths, and sustenance of life-forms thereon, and the position they occupy in the Cosmos; but I content myself with this bare outline. Modern spiritualism, when viewed as an entirely new and diverse (from all that preceded) order of life, — which, instead of being the best at its beginning, commences at Zero, — is a factor which is overlooked in this respect by the Tlieosophist in its response to Mr. Terry, of Australia — (who is a personal .acquaintance of my own) and is hardly satisfactory to those who accept the higher aspects of a more advanced spiritualism. •Qccultists say that the only safe and right way in dealing with unseen forces, entities, intelligences, or whatever else, is according to their method: and that to seek for or allow 'Con- trols' to use the human organism, is wrong, if not positively dangerous to the morals of those who permit it; but to my •view, thexightor wrong of this depends upon the use we make of it, and we must not be forgetful, that this "Control- ling power and influence" sometimes comes with a resistless force and the sensitives are completely helpless to withstand.* * Exactly; «nd since la this mad inrash of eoDtrols the poor sensitive may at any time be knocked off his moral feet down the precipice of epiritaal degradation, why tamper with so dangerous a gift ? Adepts never encounter a "reeistlesa force," since adeptship means «ci/-control first and then coutrol Qver all forues of nature «zteraal to himself,— I. S. B. 83 Even the 'invocation' of spiritnal being?, if the modern practice of Seance-holding can be so called, which affords conditions for spiritual manifestations — is quite in conform- ity with the rituals and ceremonials of the ancient Indian system; as, for instance, the S'lma Veda says, *'Come, 0 Father, along with the spirits of our Father s^* If this practice was observed, and formed an integral part of religious wor- ship,— and if this was done under thegegis of the Church itself in far back ages; surely with oar increase of knowledge, and, we may hope, with improved morals, we may now safely engage in it with safety to both sides, provided the motives are pure and worthy. Are there not any adept "Brothers" of British or European extraction in sufficient sympathy with the efforts of their own countrymen to open up a direct correspondence with those who are striving to attain to a higher order of Life?t [A full reply is left over for a future article.] A PERSONAL AND AJf IMPERSONAL GOD. Vabious remarks that I have noticed in the Ari/a lead me to believe that, as is so commonly the case, differences in interpretations of terms, are leading to apparent antogonisma between persons whose views are in reality identical. Attacks are made on those who deny the existence of a personal God, and we are told that such persons^ even the believing in an Impersonal God, are in reality Atheists. ' We invita our brother's attention, in reference to this (jactation, to what Manu sayB (IV. 123, &;c.,) of this practice. The Santa Veda dealing with the Spirits of the dead, he saya that *'eveu the sonnd of it (the Sama Veda) is impure."— T.S. R. I This seems hardly a fair question. Our correspondent first assumes that our adepts are of an inferior order, and neither living nor capable ol showing a way to "a higher order of life," and then despairingly asks if there are no adepts to teach him. What talented beings there may be in. the "Solar" and "Planetary" orders — we cannot say, our experience having been confined to human adepts. But among these, we should certainly say that on the terms stated there is not one among our Brothers, whether of British or Asiatic extraction, who would volunteer fnr the service. ~T. S. R. 84 Now tliiB is simply, in my hamble opinion, a mistake, reanlting from differences in the significations attached by different persons to the terms Personal and Impersonal God. Let me at the ontset, however, explain, that I am not here seeking to defend the Thkosophist or yourself, you are quite able to defend yourself, and I am in no way empowdered or competent to express your views or those of the Himalayan Brotherhood whose representative you are, as to the nature of the First Cause — nor do I desire to enter into any controversy with any man; I desire to live in peace and brotherly love with all men; I have my own views, which satisfy my head and heart, in which I firmly believe, and which I hope all other men will respect in me; and I do not doubt that others who differ from me have equally seized the views that satisfy their heads and hearts, are equally justified in holding these and have an equal claim on me to respect these their views. Looking round the universe nothing so strongly impressed me, as the system of division of labour which pervades it. Practical results never spring from solitary causes; they are ever the resultants of the more or less divergent eSects of an inextricable plexus of diverse causes. It is from contrasts, that all the joys and beauties of the world arise; it is from the equilibrium of antagonistic forces that the Universe subsists. All progress springs from difference ; all evolution is the result of differentiation; as in the great, so in the spiritual; as in the visible so in the unseen universe. How, then, can men fail to see that differences of opinion on matters spiritual are parts of the necessary mechanism of the spiritual organism that everywhere underlies (as the bones underlie the flesh and skin) the physical or visible world ? How can they find fault with others for holding views different from their own? How fail to realise that those others are as truly working iu harmony with the pervading design or law of the All as themselves ? Night is as needful to oar mundane economy as dayj shall the night revile the day, for its glare, its noise, its heat, or the day reproach the night for its dusky stillness ? So then it is no spirit of finding fault with those who differ from me, but only in the hope of clearing away imaginary differences which being unreal work harm, not good as real differences do), 85 that I desire to say a tew words as to belief in a Personal Grod, in an Impersonal God and in No-God. Tne three beliefs are very different and pace our brethren of the Arya, who seem to think differently, the believer in an Impersonal God is not only no Atheist, but actually in many cases holds the exact tenets of the Upanishads. It is in the meaning of the word Person that the misconception originates. The Arya says, "By personal we understand the attribute of being an individual— the essence of personality is consciousness — the knowledge of the fact that I am." But this, if the writer will pardon my so saying, is really not a tenable position. Persona, or a mask, refers only to the mask of flesh and blood and bones and the associated powers that conceal, the spirit, soul or whatever it please? men to call that portion of the human entity which survives the dissolutions of the physical body. For materialists, who believe that with this latter the entire man perishes, it may be correct to say that the essence of personality is consciousness, but certainly, no Vedantist could ever say this if he really understood what personality signified. The essence of individuality is consciousness; it is the individuality which feels '• I am." not the personality^ which no more feels, of itselft I AM, than does the suit of clothes in which it is arrayed. Now there are many good men who believe in a Personal God, a radiant, glorified man, with bead and body and limbs; and they draw pictures of him (those who have haunted the galleries of Europe only know what glorious idealizations of the ''human form divine'* this belief has inspired), and they attribute to hira human feelings, anger^ repent- ance and the like, and they picture him to themselves, and love him as a veritable "Father who is in Heaven." But there are others (who can- not accept these conceptions which to them seem derogatory to the In- finite and absolute) who believe in an Impersonal God. They hold that God IS not a mere magnified man; that he has no form or persona, at any rate that we can conceive, that he is a spirit, all pervading, all sus- taining, neither liable to anger, repentance or change, and hence panic (having always known from all eternity what was right and therefore what he willed), always working through immutable laws. Many of these (but by no means all) hold further that he is not conscious or 86 intelUgeiit, in oua sense of the word, because both these terms imply duality, an entity to cognize and a thing to be cognized, whereas He is All in All and in Him, we and all things, move and live and have our being, bat still that He is All conscionsness and all intelligence. The believers therefore in an Impersonal God are some of them Theists, some Fanthesists, but can by no means tral/ be designated Atheists. Lastly there are the so-called Atheists, who say they believe in no God, Personal or Impersonal, who affirm that the universe is an infinite aggregation of substance, its undiCfereatiated condition, neither conscions nor intelligent, expanding and contracting by the inherent laws of its own being, and subject in accordance with these to alternate periods of day and night, activity and rest, who maintain that during such periods of activity in accordance still with these inherent laws, aH things human and divine differentiate out of, and are evolved from, this primal all-pervading substance, to disintegrate, once more, into it as the night of rest supervenes. These call themselves Atheists; and if there be such, they probably have the best right to assume the title, but I confess that I doubt whether even these are really Atheists. In t'ae first place, when they talk of laws, they overlook, it seems to me the fact, that a law postulates a law-giver — a will at any rate that has impressed a course of action — and so it seems to me that, admitting an inherent law, they cannot logically escape a will that orginated that law, and such a will in such a case must be what mankind understands as God. But in the second place, though they deny this primary will, they do not really deny all Gods. For thej say that in accordance witht the inherent laws, develop, not only all we see and know, but incredibly and iDConceiveably higher spiritual beings, who guide and direct all things in the visible universe, and to whose power and love are doe all the beauties and wonders of the world that so impress us with a sense of design.* So then, though they may call these, Dhyan Chohans or Elohim, these exalted spiritual beings are really their Gods, and they are * Reference is here made to the Tibetan Arhats— our Masters. — Ed. 87 Poljtbeists ratlier than Atheists. Only it must be remembered that tbesef their Gods, are neither infinite nor absolnte. They are finite; billions on billion of years as they subsist, they pass into non-txi stence (bat whether into non-being or not the holders of these tenets are not agreed) with the close of the great day, and they are conditioned by the eternal inherent law of the infinite substance one of whose deTelopments they are. Whi/, they have preferred finite and conditioned Gods to one Infinite and Absolute God is clear. On the former hypothesis, the origin of evil, the existence of sin and suffering offer no difficulty; the Gods do their best; but there are laws cf opposite polarity, of antagonistic, opposites, to which the universe owes its origin, and with it they themselves, which are above them and which they are powerless to control, although they can largely modify their results. They do their best, if there still remain misery and evil, it is becaase not being omnipotent, they cannot cnre without medicine, cannot make light apparent without darkness. Why, tooj they deny the primal Will as giving with to the so-called inherent laws is also clear. So bng as these are blind laws, self-existing, no one is responsible for all the sin and sorrow and suffering that these laws entail. But admit the will, then this as (exhypothese) Omnipo- tent becomes responsible for all the evil that evolves from its behests and could not therefore apparently be perfectly beneficent. Whichever way we turn, then there are difficulties. No solution of the fundament pro- blem of the universe that in all these thousands of thousands years the mind of man has been able evolve is altogether unimpeachable. Let us then each take the solution that best suits our mental and spiritual constitution, and let us leave our neighbours an equal freedom of choice ; let us never hesitate to state and defend our own views and oppose those other views that we think wrong, but let us do all this as we would defend our own and oppose our opponent's game at chess, with no more feeling against our opponents than we have agaiust an adversary at the noble game. Above all let us remember that in this present life, the high theoreti- cal questions of Personal, Impersonal, and No-God, are of less concern to us than our own everyday life about the right conduct of which no similar difficulties exist. 88 . That we shoald all try to love onr neighbours as oureelven, that we should forgive our eaemiea, that we sh'juld do good to those who do evil to 08, that we should value purity of life, truth and gooduess far above wealth or place or personal eujoyruent, — these are truths admitted ubiquft semper et ab omnibus, aud surely these furoiah a wide enough platform on which we can all, whether Brarahins, Christians, Theoso- phists, Aryans or what not, meet aal labour in one uuiverial being Brotherhood. H. X, I. Replied byT. Sobba Rao, b.a., b.l., f.t. s. A LETTER sisfned by " H. X." has appeared ia the Decetnber issue of the Tkeosophist uader the headiug aboveraentioned coataioiag some observations on "the Theoretical Questions of Personal, Irnpersooal, and No-God." Anything like an intelligent discossion of these questions i^ beset with almost insarmoantable difficulties; and it is not likely that any one, who has not exactly defined to himself what is knowable to man and what io unknowable, by a careful examination oi the nature of man and his latent powers, will ever be profited by devoting any portion of his time to speculations concerning these subjects. Jesus declared that nobody had ever seen the Father; Buddha was silent when he was questioned about the nature of the Absolute and the Infinite, and our Sankira- chariar said that all that was written on these questions only revealed the depth of human ignorance. But mankind have never ceased to speculate on these questions. Thousands of conflicting hypotheses have come into existence by reason of these speculations: disputants have never ceased quarrelling about them and the human race has divided itself into hundreds of warring sects on account of their differences of opinion in theoretical Metaphysics. If, as is stated by"H.X.," (Jifferences of opinion on matters "Spiritual" are inevitable, there must be an irrepressible desire in the human being to grapple desperately with the unknowable and unknown without knowing anything about the real capabilities of his own powers. 89 The generality of the public (at least in this conntry) are accustomed to associate every religions and social moveraeat with some particular belief regarding the subject under consideration. In their opinion every system of philosophy, science, or ethics which does not inculcate some particular doctrine with respect to the problems in question is necessarily imperfect. The importance of every religious movement, the usefulness of every association and the value of every philosophical system, is always estimated by them ia connection with such belief or doctrine. An association, like the Theosophical Society, composed of various religionists and established for the purposes of religious and scientific enquiry, is a novelty to them. Consequently, enquiries are constantly being made regarding the views of the founders of the Theoso- phical Society and our great Teachers of the Himavat about the questions under consideration. It is represented to them by some people that they are Nastikas. When the great mass of the people are unaccustomed to philosophical enquiry and precise mode« of thinking, the charge of Atheism is sufficient to lower in their estimation any particular in- dividual or association. When any man's Atheism is con- demned almost without hearing, no particular connotation hardly ever attached to the word; but it is associated with a large cluster of vices and deformities. It is highly desirable therefore to state to the public in clear language the doctrine of the Arhat philosophy regarding the problem in question and point out such misconceptions as are likely to arise from a perusal of the letter under review. Before proceeding further, I beg to inform my readers that in his letter "H- X.'* speaks of the Adwaita doctrine under the heading of impersonal God and introduces the Arhat doctrine under that of Atheism- It would have been better if he had referred to these two sys- tems of philosophy under their proper designations. The general public have not yet accepted any one difinitiou of the so-called impersonal God, and the word atheism, as above stated, conveys but a very vague idea. Without attempting, therefore, to ascertain the significance of the 12 -,. 90 same, I shall state the general principles of the Adwaita and the Arhat doctrines on the subject under consideratioo, and leave it to my readers to decide whether they indicate a belief in a personal or an imperaoncU God, or whether they amount to Atheism. I shall here request my readers (such of them at least as are not acquainted with the Cosmological theories of the Idealistic thinkers of Europe) to examine John Stuart Mill's Cosmological theory as explained in his examination of Sir William Hamilton's philosophy, before attempting to under- stand the Adwaita doctrine; and I beg to inform them before- hand that in explaining the main principles of the said doctrioe I am going to use, as far as it is convenient to do so, the phraseology adopted by English psychologists of the Idealistic School of thought In dealing with the phenomena of our present plane of existence Jehu Stuart Mill ultimately came to the conclusion that matter or the so-called external phenomena are but the creation of our mind; they are the mere appear- ances of a particular phase of our subjective self, and of our thouo'hts, volitions, sensations and emotions which in their totality constitute the basis of that Ego. Matter, then, is the permanent possibility of sensations; and the so-called Laws of matter are, properly speaking, the Laws which govern the succession and co-existence of our states of consciousness. Mill further holds that properly speaking there is no noumenal Ego. The very idea of a mind existing separately as an entity distinct from the states of consciousness which are supposed to inhere in it is in his opinion illusory, as the idea of an external object which is supposed to be perceived by our senses. Thns the ideas of mind and matter, of subject and object, of the E<'0 and external world are really evolved from the acroregation of our mental state which are the only realities so far as we are concerned. The chain of our mental states of consiousnesa is "a double-headed monster" according to Professor Bain, which has two distinct aspects, one objetive and the other subjective. 91 Mr. Mill baa paused here confessing that psychological analysis did not go any further, the mysterioas link which connects together the train of our states of conscionsness and gives rise to oor Ahankaram in this condition of existence, still remains an incomprehensible mystery to Western psychologists, though its existence is bnt dimly perceived in the subjective phenomena of memory and expectation. On the other hand, the great physicists of Europe are gradually coming to the conclusion* that mind is the product of matter, or that it is one of the attributes of matter in some of its conditions. It would appear, therefore, from the specu- lations of Western psychologists that matter is evolved from mind and that mind is evolved from matter. These two propositions are apparently irreconcilable. Mill and Tyndal have admitted that Western science is yet unaWe to go deeper into the question. Nor it is likely to solve the mystery here- after, unless it calls Eastern occult science to its aid and takes a more comprehensive view of the capabilities of the real subjective self of man and the various aspects of the great objective universe. The great Adwaitee philosophers of ancient Aryavarta have examined the relationship between subject and object in every condition of existence in this solar system in which this differentiation is presented. Just as a haman:being is composed of 7 principles, differentiated matter in the solar system exists in 7 different conditions. These different states of matter do not all come within the range of our present ob- jective conscionsness. But they can be objectively perceived by the spiritual Ego in man. To the liberated spiritual monad of man, or to the Dhyan Chohans, every thing that is material in every condition of matter is an object of perception. Further pragna, or the capacity of perception, exists in 7 different aspects corresponding to the 7 conditions of matter. Strictly speaking, there are bnt 6 states of matter, the so-called 7th state being the aspect of Cosmic matter in its original nn- differentiated condition. Similarly there are 6 states of * See Tyndall's Belfast Address.— S. B. 92 differentiated Pragna, the seventh state being a condition of perfect oaconscionsDess. By differentiated Pragna, I mean the condition in which Pragna is split np into various states of consciousness. Thus we have 6 states of consciousness, either objective or subjective, for the time being as the case may be, and a state of perfect unconsciousness which is the beginning and the end of all conceivable states of consciousness, corresponding to the states of differentiated matter and its original undifferentiated basis which is the beginning and the end of all Cosmic evolutions. It will be easily seen that the existence of consciousness is necessary for the differentiation between subject and object. Hence these two phases are presented in 6 different conditions, and in the last state there being no consciousness as above stated, the diffarentiatioa in question ceases to exist. The number of these various con- ditions is different in some systems of philosophy. But whatever may be the number of divisions, they all lie between perfect unconsciousness at one end of the line and our present state of consciousness or Bakipragna at the other end. To understand the real nature of these different states of consci- ousness, I shall request my readers to compare the conscious- ness of the ordinary man with the consciousness of the astral man, and again compare the latter with the consciousness of the spiritual Ego in man. In these three conditions the objective Universe is not the same. But the difference between the Ego and the non-Ego is common to all these condi- tions. Consequently, admitting the correctness of Mill's reasoning as regards the subject and object of our present plane of consciousness, the great Adwaitee thinkers of India have extended the same reasoning to other states of consciousness, and came to the conclusion that the various conditions of the Ego and the non-Ego were but the appearances of one and the same entity — the ultimate state of unconsciousness. This entity is neither matter nor spirit; it is neither Ego nor non- Ego; and it is neither object nor subject. In the language of Hindn philosophers it is the original and eternal combination of Purusha and Prakriti. As the Adwaitees hold that an ii 98 external object ia merely the prodnct of onr mental state, Prakriti is nothing more than illusion, and Pnrash ia the only reality; it is the one existence which remains eternal in this aaiverse of Ideals. This entity then is the Parabrahmam of the Adwaitees. Even if there were to be a personal God with any thing like a material upadhi (physical basis of whatever form), from the stand-point of an Ad waitee there will be as mach reason to doubt his nominal existence as there would be in the case of any other object. In their opinion conscious god cannot be the origin of the universe, as his Ego would be the effect of a previous cause, if the word coascious conveys but its ordinary meaning. They cannot admit that the grand total of all the states of consciousness in the universe is their deity, as these states are constantly changing and as Cosmic idealism ceases during Pralaya. There is only one permanent condition in the universe which is the state of perfect Uncon- sciousness, bare chidakasam in fact. When my readers once realize the fact that this grand uni- verse is in reality but a huge aggregation of various states of consciousness, they will not be surprised to find that the ultimate states of unconsciousness is considered as Parabrah- mam by the Adwaitees. The idea of a God, Deity, Iswar, or an impersonal God [if consciousness is one of his attributes] involves the idea of Ego in some shape or other, and as every conceivable Ego or non- Ego is evolved from this primitive element [I use this word for want of better one] the existence of an extra-cosmic god possessing such attributes prior to this condition is absolutely inconceivable. Though I have been speaking of this ele- ment as the condition of unconsciousness, it is, properly speak- ing, the chidakas%m or chinmatra of the Hindu philosophers which contains within itself the potentiality of every condi- tion of "Pragna," and which results as consciousness on the one hand and the objective universe on the other, by the operation of its latent chichakti (the power which generates thought). 94 Before proceeding to explain the definition of Pambrak- mam with which my last article closes, I beg to inform my readers that iu the opinion of AdwaiteeSy the Upanishads and the Brahmasutras fully snpport their views an the snbject. It is distinctly affirmed in the (Jpanishads that Parabrainarn which is bat the bare potentiality oi pragna,'* is not an aspect of pragna or ego in any shape and that it has neither life nor consciousness. "H. X." will be able to ascertain that such is really the case on examining the Micndakct and Mundiikya JJpaitishads. The Ifinguage used here and there in the Upa- nishads is apt to mislead one into the belief that such langu- age points to the existence of a conscious Iswar. But the necessity for such language will be perceived on examining the following remarks. From a close examination of Mill's Cosmologrcal theory as explained in my last article, it will be clearly seen that it will be extremely difficult to account satisfactorily for the genera- tion of conscious states in any human being from the stand- point of the said theory. It is generally stated that sensations arise in us from the action of the external objects around us : they are the effects of impressions made on our senses by the objective world in which we exist. This is simple enough to an ordinary mind, however diffiuulfc it may be to account for the transformation of a cerebral nerve-current into- a state of consciousness. But from the stand-point of Mill's theory we have no proof of the existence of any external object ; even the objective existence of our own senses is not a matter of certainty to us. How, then, are we to account for and explain the origin of out mental states, if they are the only entities existing in this world ? No explanation is really given by saying that one mental state gives rise to another mental state as may be shown to a certain extent by the operation of the so-called psychological "Laws of Association." Western psychology honestly admits that its analysis has not gone any further. ♦ The power or the capacity that gives rise to perception. 95 It may be inferred, however, from the said theory that there would be no reason for saying that a material Upadhi (basis) is necessary for the existence of mind or states of ■consciousness. As is already indicated in my last article, the Aryan psychologists have traced this current of mental states to its source — the eternal Chinmatra existing everywhere. When the time for evolution comes this germ of Pragna unfolds itself and results ultimately as Cosmic ideatisn. Cosmic ii entity, however that would be ncnie of either, but an Object /or itself ^ to which Kant's " i?ir!^ an sicA " degenerated under his treatment, is a jahanta«7n^ and lis recoj/nition a will-o'-the-w'/iisp in "philosopiy," Arthur Schopenhauer (Vol. I, p. 35,) edited in 1818, at a perioi when the km*wledge of Sanskrit in Europe was very meagre. Schopenhauer's **Objecttvation of Will " throws light upon the other side of the uaiverde. — L. A, S. 102 ,«D(I 4[va1ity, the vegetation of plants, and in the inorganic kingdom of nature, cryataliizutioa and every other original power which uiauifeats itself in physical and chemical phenomena, %a well as gravity, are some, tintig •outside of appearance and identical with what we find in ourselves and call — wiLiL. An intuitive recognition of the identity cf will in «I1 the phenomena separated by individuation is the source of justice, bene- volence, and love ; while from a non-recognition of its identity spring egotism, malice, evil and ignorance. This is the doctrine of the Vedantic «etdi/a (ignoranoe) that makes of Self an object distinct from Parabrahna, ■of Universal Will. Individual soul, physical self, are only imagined by ignorance and have no more reality and existence than the objects seea iu a dream. With Schopenhauer it also results from this original identity of will in all its phenomena, that the reward of the good and the punishment of the bad are not reserved to a future heaven or a futur« hell, but are ever present (the doctrine of Karma, when philoso- phically cotisidered and from its esoteric aspect). Of course the philoso- phy of Schopenhauer was radically at variauce with the systems of SchoUing, Hegel, Uerbart and other contemporaries, and even with that of Fichte, for a time his master, and whose philosophical system while studying uader him, he openly treated with the greatest contempt. But this detracts iu nothing from his own original and profoundly philoso- phical though often too pessimistic views. His doctrines are mostly interesting when compared with those of the Vedanta of ^'Sunkar- «h&'aJ. As to tarampada and Nirvana, both mean the same thing. From an objective point of view it is the condition of Pnrusba-Prakriti as above described; from the subjective — it is a state of parfect uuconscioasness resulting as bare Chidakasam. If the Swami is desirotts to learn more about the "Philosopher's stone** of "the votaries Of other Occult Philosophies," then wd may refer him to our foot-notes to the articles "QleanihgB from Bliphas Levi," published in the Jannary number of the Theo»ophist, and other sundry articles^ If the " other Occult Philosophies " are worthy of their name, then the doctrines taught in them must not differ save in the names given to identical things. Truth is but one, and of two different versions one must be necessarily false. We are not prepared to accept the interpreta- tion given of the world Aum^ since the above interpretation is not quite consistent with the doctrines of the Adwaitee Vedanta philosophy. We shall feel grateful, nevertheless, if the learned Swami can refer us to any great Adwaitee philosopher as an authority in support of his explanation^ No less puzzling are his curious ideas about our supposed meaning and views about the potentialities and nature of the human double. * MahaJt-tntwa corresponds to the spiritual Light, or the Sephira of the Jewish Kabalists. — Ed, t Literally — t}i» moit tacred pUcei, mexa* Nirvana or the condition of Molcsha — Ed. \ Satwaynna— the quality of passivity, or absence of any cause of disttirb- ance; Rajagitna — the quality of a9t;ivity, or that which induces to action; Tamguna — tha quality of ignorance, inactivity of mental and spiritual faculties atisiug from that ignorance— K