The Interpretation of Radium (Frederick Soddy, 1909) ========================================================== FREDERICK SODDY. The University, Glasgow, November ■, 1908. PREFACE TO THE THIRD EDITION IN revising this book and bringing it up to date, I have made it conform to what I should have said if I had been lecturing this year instead of four years ago. The statements of the original edition stand with hardly any serious modification, and this is, perhaps, the best possible answer to any mis- givings that it aroused, that the time had not yet arrived for the full acceptance of the new views on atomic disintegration, and the unreserved statement viii PREFACE TO THE THIRD EDITION of all the logical consequences that the science of radioactivity has rendered necessary. I have taken the opportunity of including the latest and most complete data available, and many new discoveries and developments, in so far as, among those who have devoted themselves to the subject, there is a general consensus of opinion that the evidence is good. The original lectures dealt almost entirely with radium and the other members of the uranium series. But the thorium series, since the technical production of the new radioactive substances, mesothorium and radiothorium, now has a con- siderable and growing importance. A new final chapter has therefore been added, including this series and that of actinium, in the hope of affording those who wish to pursue the subject further a comprehensive glimpse of the whole field of radio- activity. F. S. The University, Glasgow, August, 1 91 2. CONTENTS CHAPTER I PAGI The new science of radioactivity — Its discovery — The four ex- perimental effects of radioactivity — The rays of radioactive substances — The continuous emission of energy from the radio-elements — The arresting feature of radioactivity • . i CHAPTER II Mme Curie's discovery of radium — Radioactivity an atomic property — Its unalterability — The radioactivity of thorium — Pitchblende — Quantity of radium in pitchblende — The inter- national radium standard — The smallest quantity of radium that can be detected — Experiments with pure radium bromide — Doctrine of energy — Energy evolved by radium compared with that from the burning of coal — Source of cosmical energy — A quotation from Professor Tait — Radium and the •* physically impossible" 16 CHAPTER III The radiations of the radio-elements — a-, /S-, and y-rays — Test of penetrating power — Experiments with the penetrating /9- and y-rays — The non-penetrating a-rays — Experiment to show the absorption of a-rays by air — Physical nature of radiations — Necessity for an ether — Corpuscular and wave radiations — a- and jS- rays due to the expulsion of particles — Can a single a- par tide be detected? — The spinthariscope — Counting the a particles expelled by radium 39 IX x CONTENTS CHAPTER IV PACT The £ rays — Their deviability by a magnet — The nature of the 0-particle — Analogy to cathode-rays or " Radiant Matter " — The electron — Velocity of the 3-rays — The nature of the a-particle — Its velocity — Its power of passing through atoms of matter in its path — Scattering of a-particles — Method of rendering the track of rays visible — a-Particles might be expelled without their being detectable • . • . . 66 CHAPTER V From where does the energy of radium come ? — The two alterna- tives and their consequences — The internal energy of matter — Atomic disintegration — Disintegration in cascade — The successive outbursts of energy from otherwise impalpable quantities of matter — The emanation of radium — Its proper- ties — Experiments with the emanation — Its condensation by liquid air — The infinitesimal quantity of the emanation from radium — The chemical nature and atomic weight of the emanation— The energy evolved by the emanation — The decay of the emanation and its reproduction by radium — The facts, not the theories, of radioactivity are revolutionary — Unalterability of radioactive changes — Evanescent products of radioactive change — All products equally knowable whether short-lived or long 93 CHAPTER VI The connection of the a-particle with radioactive changes — The a-particle and helium — Accumulation of helium in geological time — Discovery of helium in the sun and on the earth — Its connection with radioactivity — Production of helium from radium — Its production from uranium and thorium — Proof that the a-particle is an atom of helium — The nature of the first change of radium — Radioactive " recoil " . . . .128 CONTENTS xi PAGB CHAPTER VII Atomic disintegration and the periodic law — Questions of nomen- clature — Definition of the chemist's atom — Difference between atoms and chemical compounds — The insufficiency of chemical methods in many radioactive problems — The relation of radio- activity to the electrical theory of matter — Hypotheses or mental pictures — The two possible pictures of atomic dis- integration — Sudden explosive character of the disintegration — Law of radioactive changes— Chance of disintegration — Average life of a disintegrating atom — Its expectation of life — The "how," not the "why," of atomic disintegration ex- plained — Determination of the period of average life of atoms — Primary radio-elements and ephemeral transition-forms — Radioactive equilibrium — Average life of radium — The total energy evolved in the complete disintegration of radium . . 145 CHAPTER VIII How is it there is any radium left? — The parent of radium — Fixity of ratio between the quantity of uranium and radium in all minerals — Period of average life of uranium — Relation of uranium to radium — An analogy to the Glasgow water- supply system — Age of pitchblende — Radioactivity of uranium — Uranium X, Uranium I., and Uranium II. — Uranium not - the direct parent of radium — Growth of radium by uranium — Intermediate transition forms of long life — Ionium, the direct parent of radium — The stately procession of elementary evolution 168 CHAPTER IX The subsequent changes of radium — The induced or excited radioactivity — The active deposit of radium — The disintegra- tion of the emanation — Radium A, B, C— Experiments with the active deposit — Radium A gives only a-rays and has a very short life — Radium B gives no rays— Radium C gives xii CONTENTS PAGl a-, £-, and y-rays — The emanation only gives a-rays — The later slow changes of radium — Radium D, E, and F — Polonium — Its identity with radium F — The last disintegra- tion — What is the ultimate product ? 190 CHAPTER X Ratio of quantities of polonium and radium in minerals — Table of the ratio of the quantities of all the products of uranium — Difficulty of concentrating many of the long-lived products of uranium— Increase of activity of radium with time — Radioactivity a physical measure of value or rarity — The currency metals and their rarity— Are they changing like radium ? — Physical necessity for rarity of a changing element — One aspect of the ultimate nature of matter — A quotation from Clerk Maxwell— Evolution of the elements denied — Similarity of all the atoms of the same element — The atom a complex and perfect piece of mechanism — Professor Schuster's analogy — The atom true to its character at dissolu- tion — Similarity in the velocity of all a particles expelled from a radio-element — The more stable the radio-element the slower the a-rays expelled from it — Survival of the fittest or most stable atoms — Universality of the conception of evolution to the material universe, animate and inanimate • • • 210 CHAPTER XI Why is radium unique among the elements? — Its rate of change only makes it remarkable — Uranium is more wonderful than radium — The energy stored up in a pound of uranium — Transmutation is the key to the internal energy of matter — The futility of ancient alchemy — The consequences if trans- mutation were possible — Primitive man and the art of kind- ling fire — Modern man and the problem of transmutation — Cosmical evolution and atomic disintegration — Radioactivity and geology — Quantity of radium in the earth's crust — The earth probably not a cooling globe — The geological age and the incandescent age — Ancient mythology and radioactivity — The serpent " Ouroboros " — The " Philosopher's Stone " and CONTENTS xiii PAGB the " Elixir of Life"— The * Fall of Man » and the "Ascent of Man " — The great extension in the possible duration of past time — Radium and the struggle for existence — Existence as a struggle for physical energy — The new prospect • . . 230 CHAPTER XII The thorium disintegration series — Source and radioactivity of thorium compounds — Mesothorium and radiothorium — Varia- tion of radioactivity of thorium compounds with time — Analogy between the thorium and uranium series — Meso- thorium and its changes of activity with time — Its chemical resemblance to radium — Abundance of the raw material of mesothorium — The thorium emanation — Experiments with radiothorium — Thorium A — The actinium disintegration series — The question of the origin of actinium — Its great scarcity — Multiple atomic disintegration — The actinium emanation — Actinium A — The unsolved riddle of matter .... 256 Index 279 «■ LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS FIG. :} :} 1. Becquerel's uranium radiograph of an aluminium' medallion ... 2. Welsbach mantle, taken by the rays from the thorium contained in it . . 3. Photograph and radiograph of a piece of pitch- blende (Sir William Crookes) 4. Photograph of silk tassel electrified by friction 5. The same discharged by the rays of radium 6. Radium writing on a photographic plate 7. Box of compasses taken by 7-rays of radium 8. Diagram of coated flask and radium-covered dish for showing a-rays . . 9. Photograph of the same apparatus . 10. Diagram of Spinthariscope of Sir William Crookes . . ... 11. Photograph of the Spinthariscope . 12. Photograph of the electro-magnet for deviating the 0-rays . . ... 13. Diagram of magnetic deviation of 0-rays 14. Diagram of Crookes' tube to show magnetic devia- tion of cathode-rays 15. Diagram of Strutt's radium clock 16. Photograph of radium clock 17. Photograph of tube containing willemite 18. Photograph of the same tube by its own light when containing radium emanation 19. Diagram of apparatus for showing the condensa- tion of the radium emanation 20. Diagram of the first disintegration of radium To face 10 91 » >1 »» 20 44 . 49 To face 49 60 To face 49 66 68 • 75 . 82 To face 66 » 108 . 112 . 129 XV XVI LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS nc. 21. Photograph of the spectrum-tube in which the pro-' duction of helium from radium emanation was observed . ... 22. Photograph by Dr. Giesel of the spectrum of helium produced from radium 23. Photograph of apparatus for detecting and measur- ing helium produced from uranium and thor- ium . . . ... 24. Diagram showing the first change of radium 25. Diagram for the first disintegration of uranium 26. Diagram of the uranium-radium disintegration series (initial changes) . ... 27. Diagram of the first four disintegrations of radium 28. Diagram of apparatus for obtaining the active deposit of radium . ... 29. Photograph of the same apparatus 30. Diagram of the later disintegrations of radium 31. Diagram of the complete uranium disintegration 32. Diagram of the complete thorium disintegration scries • • • 33. Diagram of the complete actinium disintegration series • • • • PACT To f oca 137 138 142 181 188 194 196 To face 196 204 209 262 *73 • •••••• # • • • • •«*<• •• • • ■ • - # » • • • • • • • • _ • THE INTERPRETATION OF RADIUM CHAPTER 1. The new science of radioactivity— Its discovery — The four experi- mental effects of radioactivity — The rays of radioactive substances — The continuous emission of energy from the radio-elements — The arresting feature of radioactivity. ONE of the main duties of science is the corre- lation of phenomena, apparently disconnected and even contradictory. For example, chemistry teaches us to regard under one aspect, as various types of combustion or oxidation, the burning of a candle, the rusting of metals, the physiological process of respiration, and the explosion of gun- powder. In each process there is the one common fact that oxygen enters into new chemical com- binations. Similarly to the physicist, the fall of the traditional apple of Newton, the revolution of the earth and planets round the sun, the appari- tions of comets, and the ebb and flow of the tides B • • • • * „ f 2 THE NE W SCIENCE are all phases of the universal law of gravitation A race ignorant of the nature of combustion or of the law of gravitation, and ignorant of the need of such generalisations, could not be considered to have advanced far along the paths of scientific discovery. The phenomena with which I am con- cerned in these lectures belong to the newly-born science of radioactivity and to the spontaneous disintegration of elements which the study of radio- activity has revealed to us. It is a natural inquiry to ask — To what most nearly are these new pheno- mena correlated? Is it possible to give, by the help of an analogy to familiar phenomena, any correct idea of the nature of this new phenomenon " Radioactivity " ? The answer may surprise those who hold to the adage that there is nothing new under the sun. Frankly, it is not possible, because in these latest developments science has broken fundamentally new ground, and has delved one distinct step further down into the foundations of knowledge. During the century which has just closed there occurred, it is true, at an ever-increasing rate, a ceaseless extension of our knowledge of the nature of matter upon which physical science is largely based. Yet this advance was for the most part an expansion rather than a deepening. It was con- cerned with what may be termed atomic and THE NE W SCIENCE 3 molecular architecture, the external qualities of atoms and the construction and study of com- plexes built of atoms — that is to say, molecules. As buildings are built of bricks, so compounds can nowadays be built up out of atoms. The atoms are to the chemist and physicist what bricks are to the architect — the units supplied ready-made to a certain limited number of standard specifications and dimensions capable of an endless variety of combinations and arrangements, each with its own peculiarities and external relationships. The century which has just begun has seen the first definite and considerable step taken into the ultimate nature of these units of matter or atoms, which is in one sense not merely an extension of existing knowledge or principles, but a radically new departure. Radioactivity is a new primary science owing allegiance neither to physics nor chemistry, as these sciences were understood before its advent, because it is concerned with a know- ledge of the elementary atoms themselves of a character so fundamental and intimate that the old laws of physics and chemistry, concerned almost wholly with external relationships, do not suffice. This first step has indeed emphasised how super- ficial our knowledge of matter has really been. If one were to demonstrate to an architect that the bricks he habitually and properly employs in 4 THE NE W SCIENCE his constructions were under other circumstances capable of entirely different uses — let us say, for illustration, that they could with effect be employed as an explosive incomparably more powerful in its activities than dynamite — the surprise of the archi- tect would be no greater than the surprise of the chemist at the new and undreamt of possibilities of matter demonstrated by the mere existence of such an element as radium. ^ In this first lecture our attention will be mainly directed to the one outstanding feature in connec- tion with radium, and the property of radioactivity which it exhibits to an extraordinary degree, in which the whole range of its remarkable features are epitomised. \The radioactive substances evolve a perennial supply of energy from year to year without stimulus and without exhaustion^ It would be idle to deny with regard to this that physical science was taken completely by surprise. Had any one twelve years ago ventured to predict radium he would have been told simply that such a thing was not only wildly improbable, but actually opposed to all the' established principles of the science of matter and energy. So drastic an innovation was, it is true, unanticipated. Radium, however, is an undisputed fact to-day, and there is no question which would have triumphed in the THE NE W SCIENCE 5 conflict, had its existence conflicted with the estab- lished principles of science. Natural conservatism and dislike of innovation appear in the ranks of science more strongly than most people are aware. Indeed, science is no exception. There was, however, never the slightest ground for assuming that because the new facts were startling and un- expected they must necessarily conflict with older knowledge. That would be to pay science a poor compliment. Some of the new facts we shall discuss in the lectures appeared at first, and may even yet appear to you, almost incredible, but that is only on account of the entire newness of the whole region to which they belong. Into this region the older chemistry and physics have, as we have seen, never before penetrated. It is not until we begin to apply to the new facts the estab- lished principles of science, which have served so well of old, that their full significance gradually becomes evident. Keep in mind that our know- ledge of nature is always of necessity partial, and is bounded in all directions by certain inevitable but too often forgotten limitations connected, for example, with the briefness of human life and the physical impossibility of pursuing investigations except under conditions where the life of the in- vestigator can be maintained. The laws and prin- 6 THE NEW SCIENCE ciples of physical science, old and new, are alike subject to these perpetual limitations, and are necessarily only true within these limits. From this point of view there is nothing in the many surprising properties of radium which conflicts with a single established principle of older science. Physics and chemistry remain almost unchanged where they were, and radioactivity, so far as it is concerned with the correctness of their principles, has, as a matter of fact, given to the old laws and theories a fuller and truer significance than they had before. The extension of the old theories which has been rendered necessary has not been revolutionary in any destructive sense. It is wonderful how accommodating a true theory is to new truth, apparently of a diametrically opposite character, and this not in any sense of mere ingenuity of explanation, but in a manner that arrests the investigator, and is his sign that he is on safe ground. It may seem a paradox, but from the first the best proof of the newer views, to my mind, was in the completeness with which the strange, newly-won knowledge of radioactivity harmonised with the old views of the chemist about atoms and elements. On the other hand this gratifying harmony, where conflict might have been expected, is not a surrender. On every hand new vistas of thought are opening out. We see THE NEW SCIENCE 7 the simple and direct answer to many problems before deemed ^insoluble. We recognise now causes at work y its own T - i EFFECTS OF RADIOACTIVITY n darker than under the thicker portions, thus causing the head of the figure to be clearly apparent in the photograph. Although the radioactive process is itself without analogy in science, the main effects which it produces can almost all be more or less nearly imitated, and were all more or less perfectly studied prior to its discovery. The main effects of radio- activity with which we are most concerned are four. Firstly then, radioactive substances affect a photographic plate in the same manner as light and many other agencies. Secondly, they excite phos- phorescence or fluorescence in certain substances when brought in their neighbourhood. Thirdly, radioactive bodies cause the air and other gases to lose the insulating power they normally possess and to become partial conductors of electricity. In consequence, any electrified object has its elec- tricity rapidly discharged in the neighbourhood of a radioactive substance. But the same effect is produced by X-rays, by incandescent bodies, and even by a lighted match. The instrument em- ployed to detect this effect is the gold-leaf electro- scope, the first and simplest electrical instrument to be invented, and for this purpose capable of so great refinement that it affords the most delicate and sensitive test it is possible to employ in 12 RAYS OF RADIOACTIVE SUBSTANCES the detection of radioactivity. Lastly, radioactive bodies generate heat, as does coal or any other substance burning. The photographic action and the discharge of electricity from insulated charged bodies are clearly shown by radioactive substances even in the form in which they occur in Nature, as all unsuspected they have been handled and ex- amined by men for centuries. Hence you will understand how it is that the discovery of radio- activity could not under any circumstances have been indefinitely delayed. But only the more power- fully radioactive substances, like radium, give ap- preciable phosphorescence or heat effects. In the naturally occurring radioactive substances these effects are far too small to be readily detectable. Exact physical experiments have demonstrated that all these effects of radioactivity owe their origin to the fact that the radioactive substances emit "rays." These rays are invisible to the un- aided eye it is true. In this they resemble Rontgen's X-rays. There are three different types of rays given out by the radioactive substances, which are known respectively as the a-, ,S-, and y-rays. Each will require detailed future considera- tion. But they all bear less resemblance to light than to the recently discovered types of rays, of which the X-rays of Rontgen are typical, produced RAYS OF RADIOACTIVE SUBSTANCES 13 when an electric current is forced by powerful appli-* ances to traverse a nearly vacuous space, a path which it much prefers not to take if it can avoid it. The first effects of most new things are old. Motor-cars and railways do the old work of horses. In commercial life a really new effect is generally valueless until it has ceased to be new, as many inventors know to their cost. In scientific dis- covery a new effect does not usually proclaim itself from the housetops. It often needs new instru- ments and the way must first be paved for its dis- covery, while old effects are generally recognised first. It is natural that the first effects of radio- activity to be discovered should be those more or less familiar, But for the development to perfec- tion of that marvellous thing, the photographic plate, radioactivity would not have been discovered in the way it was, and we should still be without one of the readiest methods of detecting it. But for the work on the conduction of electricity through gases immediately following the discovery of the X-rays, the only other method of detecting radioactivity in the natural state would be unknown, and therefore also in all probability radioactivity itself. On the other hand, if radioactive substances exhibit any entirely new kind of properties — and it is quite possible that they do — it is very likely that their very novelty would delay their discovery. 14 ARRESTING FEATURE OF RADIOACTIVITY Why then, you may ask, if all of the effects of radioactivity are shown in other ways do I insist that radioactivity is a phenomenon unparalleled in science ? The distinctive feature of radioactivity is not, however, so much in the rays the radioactive substances emit, though we shall find upon a closer examination that these are distinctive and most remarkable. The main interest of the new pro- perty consists in the spontaneous and continuous emission of energy of which the rays are but one manifestation. \ Heat and light may be obtained in numerous ways, but it is a new thing to find it being given out by a substance, as it is by radium, year in, year out, without apparent intermission or dimi- nution, and without the substance being in any apparent way consumed or altered. This was the arresting fact. The radioactive substances appar- ently were performing the scientifically impossible feat of evolving a store of energy presumably out of nothing. N So long as radioactivity was known only on the scale and in the degree exhibited by uranium, it was perhaps possible to explain away this aspect of the question because of the minute- ness of the amount of energy involved and the difficulty of proving that it was not in some way derived from the surroundings. But the work of M. and Mme. Curie, by their discovery of radium, made the world familiar with an element over a ARRESTING FEATURE OF RADIOACTIVITY 15 million times as radioactive as uranium. In this case the energy evolved is great enough to produce effects which are obvious to all and which cannot be explained away. In a strictly scientific sense there is no difference of principle between the radio- activity of radium and that of uranium. The difference is one of degree only, but it is so great that radium, though, as we shall come to see, not so wonderful in reality as uranium, rapidly acquired a monopoly of public interest and attention. CHAPTER II. Mme. Curie's discovery of radium — Radioactivity an atomic property — Its unalterability — The radioactivity of thorium— Pitchblende- Quantity of radium in pitchblende — The International Radium Standard — The smallest quantity of radium that can be detected — Experiments with pure radium bromide — Doctrine of energy — Energy evolved by radium compared with- that from the burning of coal— Source of cosmical energy— A quotation from Professor Tait— Radium and the " physically impossible." IT is worth while to stop to consider the starting-point of Mme. Curie's discovery. Chemistry analyses all known substances into their component constituents or elements, all of which are fundamentally different, the one from the other, and inconvertible the one into the other. Uranium is such an element, gold, silver, lead, and many of the common metals are others, but uranium is dis- tinguished by having relatively the heaviest of all known atoms. The atom is the minimum unit quantity of an element. The relative atomic weight of an element is one of its most important characteristics, and as a first approximation the atom of hydrogen is chosen as the standard and is assigned unit value. For exact work it is more convenient to choose oxygen as the standard, with 16 MME. CURIES FIRST STEP 17 the value 16. On this basis the atomic weight of hydrogen becomes i # oo8, and that of uranium 238*5. Now radioactivity is an intrinsic property of the element uranium, and therefore of the atom of uranium. This Mme. Curie first recognised, and it formed the starting-point of her work. In the case of uranium, the element itself and all its various compounds are radioactive, and the radioactivity of each compound is conditioned simply by the relative amount of uranium it contains. It does not matter where the uranium comes from— it is always to the same degree radioactive. Non-radioactive uranium is unknown. Not only so, but it is absolutely im- possible really to affect the radioactivity of uranium or any other of the radioactive elements in the slightest degree. In this the process is utterly unlike any other process previously known in Nature. Radioactivity is part and parcel of the very nature of the element which possesses the property, and therefore of the atom or unit quantity of the element. The attempts that have been made artificially to alter or to stop the radioactivity of an element have met with signal failure. This is still an impossible feat — a thing modern science cannot do — and yet, as we shall come to see quite clearly in the sequel, a thing which science must do if mankind is to realise to the full the destiny these discoveries have for the first time unveiled. There 1 8 THORIUM is another still impossible feat, to the accomplish- ment of which all the appliances of modern science have been directed in vain, as well as all the utmost power of man from the earliest time. It is trans- mutation, or the conversion of one element into another. Radioactivity is the one process going on in matter we cannot influence or stop, while trans- mutation is the one process in matter we have so far signally failed to effect. The juxtaposition of radioactivity and transmutation is not a fanciful one, because it will appear, as we proceed, that the two processes are most intimately connected. Radioactivity being a property of the element uranium, it was natural to ask whether uranium alone of all the eighty elements known possessed it. This was the starting-point of Mme. Curies illustrious researches in the subject. She found only one other element among those known which possessed the property — the element thorium, which, at one time rare and little known, has come into industrial prominence of recent years in the manufacture of the Welsbach incandescent gas mantle, 1 of which it forms the main constituent. To the electrical test — the power of discharging 1 The cause of the action of the gas-mantle in generating light is quite unconnected with the property of radioactivity. THORIUM 1 9 >h- a gold-leaf electroscope — thorium preparations are ice of about the same degree of radioactivity as ost uranium ; but to the photographic plate thorium ns- is far less active than uranium, owing to the fact nto that the type of rays which affect the photographic plate most strongly are not those with most effect in on the electroscope. The radioactivity of thorium ms- is a fact which can be beautifully demonstrated by ave any one acquainted with the process of photo- tion graphy. An incandescent mantle, after burning off :iful the fibre, is cut open and pressed as flat as that possible on a card. A photographic plate, which 1. has first been wrapped in a light-tight envelope, is laid upon the flat mantle, and the whole is lent left undisturbed for a fortnight or longer. On jutn developing the plate it will be found that an image 5 sed of the mantle has been formed on the plate in the r ie's dark by the rays from the thorium contained in mnd the mantle. Any one can do this simple experi- hich ment for himself. iuiflf Fig- 2 (facing p. io) shows the result I obtained jtie with a very thin piece of aluminium foil between t be the film and the mantle. The foil, while quite gas opaque, allows the a- as well as the £-rays to go ien t through. Paper would stop the a-rays entirely. jfaff The radioactivity of thorium, though producing the same general effects as that of uranium, differs jhtI5 from it entirely in detail. Indeed, by a few simple 20 PITCHBLENDE tests on the radioactivity, any one of the radio- active elements can be recognised and distinguished far more quickly and certainly than by any of the other chemical or spectroscopic tests, even when present in very minute quantities. In the his- torical development of the views now held in radioactivity thorium played a leading part. But, as it is quite foreign to my intention to give any- thing approaching a detailed systematic account of the subject, and as radium lends itself more readily to experimental demonstrations, I shall confine myself primarily to the properties of the latter substance. Although uranium and thorium were the only two known elements possessing radioactivity, Mme. Curie found that the natural minerals containing uranium are more radioactive than can be accounted for by the uranium present. Certain minerals, called pitchblende, particularly the variety from the celebrated Joachimsthal mine in Austria, con- tain often more than 50 per cent of uranium in the form of uranium oxide. The radioactivity of pitchblende to the photographic plate is beautifully shown by two photographs of Sir W. Crookes (Fig. 3). The lower figure shows the polished face of a piece of pitchblende photographed in the ordinary way by daylight. The upper figure Sir William Crookes" igurt is t daylight phatogrj PITCHBLENDE 21 was taken by placing the polished face of the mineral on a photographic film wrapped in light- tight paper. The lighter portions of the figure indicate where the plate has been acted on by the rays from the radioactive matter in the pitchblende. Some pitchblendes are from three to four times as radioactive as pure uranium oxide. This could only be the case, Mme. Curie correctly argued, if there existed in the minerals one or more unknown elements more powerfully radioactive than uranium. By the ordinary process of chemical analysis it is easy to separate out the various constituent ele- ments in pitchblende. There are a great number of elements in pitchblende, though most of them are present in very small amount. A fact that will be found significant later is that lead is always present in important quantity. Mme. Curie found that of the elements so separated two in particular, the bismuth and the barium, were strongly radio- active. Now ordinary bismuth and barium are not at all radioactive, and the radioactivity of these elements, when separated from pitchblende, is really due to the presence of two new elements in minute amount mixed with them. The one associated with bismuth was discovered first by Mme. Curie and named Polonium^ after her native country. Its consideration is more profitably delayed till later. The other, which was discovered very soon after- 22 QUANTITY OF RADIUM IN PITCHBLENDE wards, is associated with the barium and is Radium. The exact quantity of radium in pitchblende and other uranium minerals is a fact of considerable importance. There is one part of the element radium for every three million two hundred thousand parts of the element uranium in pitchblende. The pitchblende may be of any degree of richness, from only a few per cent, to over 50 per cent of uranium. But of even the richest pitchblendes between 100 and 200 tons would be needed to produce an ounce of pure radium. The compound usually sold, radium bromide, contains, if pure, 58*5 per cent, of radium. But what it lacks in quantity radium makes up for in quality — that is to say, in radio- activity. It is like the myriad of roses we are told go to make a single drop of the real attar, which is almost priceless. The radium that is extracted is a million times more radioactive than the mineral, and several million times more than pure uranium itself. Conversely, just as you can buy quite a large bottle of rose-water for a small sum, so quantity is not the only consideration to be taken into account in the buying of radium preparations. A very small quantity of radium is sufficient to confer on a large quantity of an inactive salt many of its own peculiar properties. Particularly is this the case with the property of glowing visibly in the dark. Weak radium preparations, which contain usually barium, QUANTITY OF RADIUM RECOGNISABLE 23 shine by themselves in the dark more strongly even than the pure radium salts, owing to a phos- phorescent action of the barium salts, although they may hardly contain enough radium to affect an X-ray screen through a piece of metal. If you mix a very minute quantity of radium with a quantity of a very highly phosphorescent body, like sulphide of zinc, it will shine in the dark so brilliantly that an inexperienced person might well be deceived into believing that it must contain a large quantity of radium. So great has become the need that radium preparations should be of definitely ascertainable quality that in 19 10 an International Radium Standards Committee was formed, with the result that there is now pre- served in Paris an International Radium Standard prepared by Mme. Curie, and consisting of a tube containing twenty-two milligrams of the most care- fully purified radium chloride. This standard is to form the basis for the preparation of secondary standards to be supplied to the official testing institutions of the various countries, and henceforth there should be as much definiteness about the milligram of radium as there is about a pound of tea. It is an interesting digression to consider here the smallest absolute quantity of radium which can be detected and identified with certainty in the laboratory. One fifty-millionth of a milligram, or 24 EXPERIMENTS WITH RADIUM one three-thousand-millionth of a grain of radium is quite easy to recognise, whilst with special care one-tenth of this amount could probably be detected. This is far less than could be detected in the case of any non-radioactive element by any method known, not excluding even the spectroscope. If the half of a grain of pure radium bromide, which is in this room to-night, were divided equally among every human being at present alive in the world, and one such portion were returned to us, it would prove sufficient for detection and identification by means of a gold-leaf electroscope with the greatest ease.' With half a grain of a pure radium com- pound the main effects of radioactivity, which in the case of uranium or thorium would either be too feeble to show or would require the use of incon- veniently delicate instruments, can be shown in a striking and convincing manner to you all in the simplest possible way. Of the small amount of radium bromide, which by a labour of love certain chemists have succeeded in extracting from pitchblende, I am fortunate to possess about a grain, or sixty-five milligrams. Half of this quantity, which I shall use for most of my lecture experiments, is contained in a small ebonite capsule. The other half is dissolved in water and not brought into this lecture-room, but kept in the laboratory half a mile away. With the ■ • • • •• • • - • • • • • •. • • • EXPERIMENTS WITH RADIUM 25 room dark the radium in the capsule is hardly visible to you, because the rays do not of them- selves affect the unaided eye, but if I bring some crystals of the fluorescent substance, barium platino- cyanide, near to it, you will see that the crystals shine out at once with a beautiful green light. An ordinary X-ray fluorescent screen, which is simply a piece of card painted over with the same fluorescent substance in the form of powder, is very convenient for these experiments. When thin pieces of metal foil are placed between the radiuip and the crystals you see their brightness is only slightly reduced, while several shillings can be interposed one above the other without altogether stopping the rays from the radium. Those in the front will see the crystals still shining faintly, although the rays from the radium have first to traverse more than half an inch of solid silver before reaching the crystals. The electrical effect oi radioactivity can be shown in a very rough and simple way with this, comparatively speaking, large quantity of radium. A silk tassel is stroked with a rubber tobacco-pouch and so electrified. All the threads then repel one another and stand out as you see (Fig. 4). The moment the radium is brought near the threads collapse at once (Fig. 5). Lastly, the photographic action of the rays is seen in the photograph (Fig. 6, facing p. 44) which was obtained by slowly writing, with a small tube con- 26 VALUE OF RADIUM taining a small fraction of a grain of radium bromide as if it were a pencil, over a photographic plate wrapped in black paper, and then developing the plate without exposure to light. By the aid of delicate thermometers it could also be shown that this small quantity of radium is always a few degrees hotter than the surrounding air. The one fact about radium, which every one is aware of, is its tremendous cost. When you con- sider that even of the best ore several hundred- weights must be worked up to obtain the small quantity here exhibited, you can understand that the price is necessarily very high. The price rose rapidly from about 8s. the milligram for radium bromide in 1903 to about £\$ the milligram in 191 2, and even at the latter price very inferior preparations have found a ready sale. We shall see, as we proceed, that from its very nature any strongly radioactive body like radium must always be excessively rare. Indeed, in the degree of radioactivity we have a scientific standard of rarity, and therefore of "value." There are un- fortunately some fields of scientific investigation, of which radioactivity is one, which cannot be thoroughly explored without continuous and con- siderable expenditure. The old boast of science, that some of her grandest discoveries were made with very simple apparatus, largely built up of wire A SCIENTIFIC MONOPOLY 27 and sealing-wax, costing little or nothing, does not apply to any of the discoveries with which we are now concerned. The investigations of Mme. Curie naturally have cost many thousands of pounds, pro- vided in part by the Austrian Government and the Rothschilds. This radium we are using to-night we owe to the work of a German chemist, Dr. Giesel, who undertook its extraction on a large scale in the early days when the raw material was to be obtained in the market, and who very unselfishly distributed much of the radium he prepared among workers in all parts of the world. To-day the Austrian Govern- ment, who hold the monopoly of the Joachimsthal mine, do not allow the ore to be exported, and there is a great dearth of the raw material. Even those who have borne the heat and burden of the day, who have given the waste raw material its value, and who have discovered the very methods of extraction, are unable any longer to obtain the raw material for their researches. A monopoly in scientific research is an unfortunate innovation, but such, alas ! so limited is the supply of radium, exists to-day. The Royal Society recently obtained, as a privilege, a thousand pounds' worth of the raw material, but it produced less than fifty milligrams of radium. To-night it is not my intention to. take you through the various phases of the new properties 28 DOCTRINE OF ENERG Y of radium. We have to face squarely the great general question which its simple existence has demanded of physical science. Last century will remain for ever memorable on account of the de- velopment and establishment of the great doctrine of energy. Those were great days for physical science in Scotland, for that doctrine, which lies at the root of all modern industry and enterprise, took its rise largely in Scotland, and was developed by Tait, of Edinburgh, and Lord Kelvin, of Glasgow. For a full account of these stirring developments you should read Tait's Recent Advances in Physical Science, which, in spite of the fact that it is now over thirty years old, still continues fresh and inspiring. The first law, that of the conservation of energy, states that energy is a real entity, and has a real existence no less than matter, and no more than matter can energy be created or destroyed, although the forms it may assume are legion. The second law, that of the availability of energy, is sufficiently accurately stated for present purposes by saying that the same energy is available for useful work but once. To obtain useful work from any source of stored- up or potential energy, it is necessary to transform it into new forms which are kinetic, and by which some- thing is made to move. As motion is invariably attended by friction or similar processes, ultimately the energy passes into heat. It is said to be de- DOCTRINE OF ENERGY 29 graded into low-grade or waste energy, for although all forms of energy tend, after assuming the kinetic form, to turn into heat, the transformation of the waste heat so produced back into useful forms can- not be practically effected. The conversion is not altogether impossible, but requires for its accom- plishment the degradation of more fresh energy than is gained, and so is practically out of the question. The practical aspect of the question may be summed up by saying that if you want useful energy you must pay for it like any other commodity, and the value of the energy, though not the energy itself, is destroyed by use. The up-to-date street car driven by the electric motor, which has displaced the old horse-tram, although it has not the same obvious incentive to locomotion as its predecessor, nevertheless does not go by itself. It requires energy or power, which is bought arid sold and has a value as strictly as the oats and hay which energised the now emancipated horse. The driving power of the machinery of the modern world is often mysterious, but the laws of energy state that nothing goes by itself, and our experience, in spite of all the perpetual motion machines which inventors have claimed to have constructed, bore this doctrine out, until we came face to face with radium. Nothing goes by itself in Nature,' except apparently radium and the radioactive substances. That is why, in 30 DOCTRINE OF ENERGY radioactivity, science has broken fundamentally new ground. I cannot too plainly insist that available energy, though immaterial and intangible, has a definite and real physical existence. Were it not so, coal would not be the very expensive commodity it unfortu- nately is rapidly becoming. No one burns coal for the sake of polluting the atmosphere, but simply and solely because it gives out during combustion a certain amount of energy as light or heat. Last century civilisation may be said to have attained its majority and to have entered upon the control of an inheritance of energy stored up by the sun in fuel during the long ages of the past, and now it is dissipating that inheritance as quickly as it can. With the lightheartedness and irresponsibility of youth, it is taking no thought of the future, but confidently assumes that the supply of natural energy, upon which at every turn it is now entirely dependent, will continue indefinitely. Well! if it does not do so, new stores of energy cannot be created to order, and there will be an end to the age of energy in which we are living, and to civili- sation as we have come to understand it. Energy is susceptible of exact measurement and, though it exists in many varieties, all forms of energy can be most readily and completely con- ENERGY EVOLVED BY RADIUM 31 verted into heat and measured as such. The energy given out by radium, although it is in nature new, is no exception to this rule. Practically the whole of the energy is transformed into heat when the radium is kept in a leaden vessel, so that the rays are absorbed in the surrounding metal. The actual amount of heat given out, for instance, by this small quantity on the table is, of course, very small, but in comparison with the quantity of sub- stance producing it, it is very great indeed. Exact experiments have proved that 1 gram ( = 1 5*4 grains) of radium gives out 133 calories per hour. The amount of heat evolved by any quantity of radium in three-quarters of an hour is as much as is required to raise a quantity of water equal in weight to the radium from the freezing-point to the boiling- point Radium bromide, if it is pure, consists roughly of three-fifths by weight of the element radium and two-fifths of the element bromine. Half a grain of radium bromide thus evolves two and a half calories every hour. This specimen of half a grain of radium bromide has been in my possession for nine years, and the outpouring of energy has been going on ceaselessly day and night at a steady rate. A simple calculation shows that in this time about 200,000 calories have been evolved. To obtain an idea of what this means consider the amount of energy given out in the burning of coal. A weight of coal equal to the weight of this radium 3 2 ENERG Y E VOL VED BY RADIUM bromide would give out during complete combustion only about 250 calories, so that this radium has evolved in nine years 800 times the energy obtain- able from the same weight of coal. I have chosen coal for the comparison because the combustion of carbon furnishes the modern world with its main supply of energy. During the last nine years this radium has given hundreds of times as much energy as could be obtained from an equal weight of any other kind of substance in any way known. Coal is no longer coal when it is burnt and consumed. Gun- powder and dynamite, once they have exploded and evolved their stored-up energy, disappear as such, and there remain incombustible and non-explosive solids and gases, out of which no more energy can be drawn. But this radium is as active as ever. So far, careful measurements have failed to detect the least diminution in the radioactivity of radium with time. Rather it increases steadily, rapidly in the first month and slowly for the first few years after preparation, for certain profound reasons we shall have to go into subsequently. In the face of a new fact of this character it is obvious that this doctrine of energy, which we thought so well founded, requires further considera- tion. Based as it has always been on the results of our experience and the practical impossibility of COSMIC A L ENERGY 33 achieving perpetual motion of any kind, it is con- fronted with a natural example, going on apparently for an unlimited space of time under our very eyes, which not only does not come to a stop, but which cannot be stopped by any means whatever. Now, although the doctrine of energy accords well enough with our terrestrial experiences, the student of the physical sciences has only to turn his thoughts from the laboratory to the heavens to see there, in the larger laboratory of Nature, an example of practical perpetual motion on the grandest and most majestic scale. What, for ex- ample, is the source of the apparently inexhaustible supply of energy from the sun, upon the receipt of a minute and insignificant fraction of which life on this planet absolutely depends for its continued existence from year to year? This is a question which has been frequently asked and only im- perfectly answered by physical science. It has been the custom vaguely to connect the appar- ently ehdless and inexhaustible outpourings of energy going on everywhere in the universe with its vast scale and dimensions. In the background there has always been the tacit assumption that the supply of fresh energy is only apparently inexhaustible, and that in some remote future a time will at length arrive when the supplies of fresh energy are exhausted and all things 34 QUOTATION FROM PROFESSOR TAIT will come to a stop and remain at rest for ever. We have applied the teachings of the laboratory, our knowledge of the laws of energy and its conservation, and the impossibility of perpetual motion, without modification to the cosmos, only making allowance for its enormous scale. Astronomers, if one may judge from recent utterances, still continue to regard cosmical evolu- tion as proceeding on these old conventional lines. That is, they seem to regard it still as only a question of time before the sun and planets cool down to a dead uniform temperature. In former days this point of view was the only possible one. A hot body radiating heat and light into space, even when all possible sources of energy, such as the accretion of meteorites, shrinkage, etc., have been allowed for, must ultimately radiate away its energy. The same is still true but with a differ- ence. Thus Professor Tait, in his Recent Advances in Physical Science (1876), says (p. 169) : ' " If we were to trace the state of affairs back, instead of to ten millions, to a hundred millions of years, we should find that (if the earth then existed at all) if that collocation of matter which we call the earth was then actually formed, and if the physical laws which at present hold have been in operation during that hundred million years, then the surface i QUOTATION FROM PROFESSOR TAIT 35 of the earth would undoubtedly have been liquid and at a high white heat, so that it would have been utterly incompatible with the existence of life of any kind such as we can conceive from what we are acquainted with. Thus we can say at once to geologists, that granting this premiss — that physical laws have remained as they now are, and that we know of all the physical laws which have been operating during that time — we cannot give more scope for their speculations than about ten or (say at most) fifteen millions of years. " But I dare say many of you are acquainted with the speculations of Lyell and others, especially of Darwin, who tell us that even for a comparatively brief portion of recent geological history three hundred millions of years will not suffice. " We say, so much the worse for geology as at present understood by its chief authorities, for, as you will presently see, physical considerations from various independent points of view render it utterly impossible that more than ten or fifteen millions of years can be granted.' Again (p. 154): "Take (in mass equal to the sun's mass) the most energetic chemicals known to us, and in proper proportion for giving the greatest amount of heat by actual chemical combination, and, so far as we yet know their properties, we cannot see the means of supplying the sun's present 36 NEW STORES OF NATURAL ENERGY waste for even 5000 years. . . . This question is totally unanswerable, unless there be chemical agencies at work in the sun of a far more power- ful order than anything that we meet with on the earths surface." I do not quote these utterances with any wish to revive the old controversy between geologists and physicists, long since tacitly abandoned by both sides mutually as barren and unprofitable, but because of their present extraordinary aptness. To-day, science has come to know, by means of radioactivity, of agencies at work on the earth s surface of a far more powerful order than anything that was known in the time of Professor Tait. The discovery of radioactivity and the revelation it has given of unsuspected stores of energy in Nature available for cosmical purposes, of necessity put the whole question of the evolution, the past history and the future destiny of the universe in a new light. This is one of the conclusions of clearly general interest which follow from the recent discoveries. There is nothing of the vast scale and dimensions of the universe about this tiny scrap of radium. Yet it is giving out energy at a rate, relative to its mass, which no sun or star is doing. Suppose, for example, our sun, instead of being composed of the THE INDIFFERENCE OF RADIUM 37 materials it is, which we know by the spectroscope are practically the same as those of the earth, were made of pure radium. Provided only that every part of its mass gave out energy at the rate this radium on the table is doing, there would then be no difficulty in accounting for its outpourings of energy. Rather, the light and heat that would be given out from such a sun would be of the order of a million times greater than they actually are. On another count also one's thoughts almost uncon- sciously revert from radium to the transcendental phenomena of the larger universe, for in no other phenomena are we so reduced to the position of onlookers, powerless alike to influence or control. All the powerful resources of the modern labora- tory — extremes of heat and cold, and of pressure, violent chemical reagents, the action of powerful explosives and the most intense electrical dis- charges — do not affect the radioactivity of radium or the rate at which it works in the slightest degree. It draws its supplies of energy from an hitherto unknown source and obeys as yet un- discovered laws. There is something sublime about its aloofness from and its indifference to its external environment. It seems to claim lineage with the worlds beyond us, fed with the same inexhaustible fires, urged by the same un- controllable mechanicism which keeps the great 38 "PHYSICAL IMPOSSIBILITY" suns alight in the heavens over endless periods of time. This tiny speck of matter we can hold in our hands exhibits in perfect miniature many ancient mysteries, forgotten almost in their familiarity, or mistakenly and too easily dismissed as belonging and appropriate to the infinitely great dimensions of the universe. The "physical im- possibility" of one era becomes the commonplace of the next, and in the controversy between the geologists and the physicists we have a good illustration that no theory can claim a universal application. It is of necessity partial, and bounded on all sides by the unknown and unexplored. It is rarely proved false, so surely and truly are the foundations of modern science laid, but it is liable at any moment to be restricted in its appli- cation to the particular cases for which it was formulated and found not to apply in new spheres at the time of its inception unsuspected. As we shall see, the law of the conservation of energy is not necessarily controverted by any of the new facts with reference to radium, but prior to these discoveries our knowledge of the avail- able sources of energy in Nature has been partial and superficial to a degree. CHAPTER III. The radiations of the radio-elements — a-, p- t and 7-rays — Test of penetrating power — Experiments with the penetrating P~ and 7-rays — The non-penetrating a-rays — Experiment to show the absorption of a-rays by air — Physical nature of radiations — Neces- sity for an ether — Corpuscular and wave radiations — a- and 0-rays due to the expulsion of particles — Can a single a-particle be de- tected? — The spinthariscope—Counting the a-partides expelled by radium. IN the previous lectures we have considered the bare fact that radium and the radioactive sub- stances are continually evolving from themselves a perennial supply of energy, and the fundamentally new ground which this discovery opens up in physical science. To-night our inquiries will be directed to one special portion of the subject, namely, the nature of the rays emitted by the radioactive elements, by means of which, or rather of the effects of which, the property was first discovered. These rays themselves, apart from their effects, we have hitherto scarcely considered, but they play an essential part in the theoretical scheme by which the activity of the radio-elements is now inter- preted. The tracing back of the main effects of radio- 39 40 RAYS OF RADIOACTIVE SUBSTANCES activity, photographic, fluorescent, electrical, and thermal, to definite radiations emitted by the radio- elements came very early in the subject, but it must not be forgotten that such tracing back is of the es- sence of the discovery. Too frequently it is wrongly assumed without such evidence that any substance capable of simulating one or other of the various effects of radioactivity is therefore a radioactive substance. Naturally, the exact study of the new radiations has been mainly the work of physicists. They have succeeded, not only in clearly analysing into distinct classes the complex radiations involved and distinguishing the part played by each alone, but also they have advanced very far towards a solution of the real nature of each class of radiation emitted. Much of this latter work, however, is based upon reasoning of too specialised and in- tricate character for general presentation, and as these lectures are intended primarily for the general public, and not for trained physicists, I propose con- centrating attention for the most part on the con- clusions which are universally accepted and of the greatest general interest. Although the reasoning is difficult, the chief conclusions are very simple and easily followed, and they fit in with the general scheme of the cause and nature of radioactivity in a way which makes the whole subject clearer and more easily visualised. o-, P-, AND y-RAYS 41 The first analysis of the complex radiations emitted by each of the radio-elements — uranium, thorium, and radium — was done by Rutherford, and much of the work we are considering is his, and has called forth in their highest degree his well- known experimental genius and energy. He classed the rays into three main types, the a-, fl-, and y-, distinguished from one another by enormous differences in their power of penetrating matter. I may say at once that the a-rays of radium, for instance, are readily distinguishable in penetrating power from the a-rays of uranium, and the latter again from those of thorium. Moreover, the a-rays of radium are themselves complex and consist of no less than four separate types readily distin- guished. The same is true of the f$- and y-rays of radium, which are themselves complex and recognisably different from the /3- and y-rays of uranium or thorium. But the differences between the a-rays as a class, for example, are small and unimportant relatively compared to the enormous difference between any a-ray and any )8-ray or y-ray. The most penetrating a-ray known is not much more than twice as penetrating as the least penetrating known, whereas the /8-rays as a class may be considered to be approximately a hun- dred times more penetrating than the a-, and the y-rays a hundred times more penetrating than 42 PENETRATION TEST the P-. Again, the kind of matter penetrated, although it has a certain influence which may be different for different types of rays, is only of secondary importance. For these rays, like the new X-rays, and unlike light, are absorbed by matter roughly in proportion to its density, and quite independently of its optical qualities of trans- parency and opacity. The first result of these re- searches was to bring into prominence the a-class of rays, which at first sight are of apparently little importance, and to diminish relatively the impor- tance of the fl-class of rays which had been operative in the photographic effects hitherto mainly studied. For the a-rays are completely absorbed by very thin screens — even by a sheet of thin paper, or by three inches of ordinary gaseous air, — and they pro- duce but little action on the photographic plate in comparison with the £-rays, which are able to pass through a visiting card or piece of tinfoil with ease. To the electrical test — the discharge, for example, of an electrified silk tassel or electroscope — the a-rays are immensely more effective than the P- and y-rays together, and from this fact Rutherford con- cluded, and the conclusion has been wholly borne out by subsequent developments, that the energy possessed by these feebly penetrating, and not at first sight very striking, a-rays is always immensely greater than that of the other two types taken EXPERIMENTS WITH )3- AND y-RAYS 43 together. In fact, the ft- and y-rays at most possess but a few per cent of the total energy of radiation, and therefore are in this fundamental respect rela- tively of less consequence than the previously neglected a-class. Although less suited to lecture experiments than the other more penetrating types, the a-class have proved far the most instructive and important in the theory of radioactive change. The small capsule in which my radium is con- tained is closed by a thin sheet of mica, which effectively stops all the a-rays, so that in working with the capsule only the fi- and y-rays are opera- tive. The platinocyanide salts fluoresce most brilliantly under the j8-rays. On interposing suc- cessive thicknesses of thin copper or aluminium foil the fluorescence is weakened, very rapidly at first, but a point is soon reached when the feeble fluor- escence remaining is not much further weakened by additional thicknesses of foil. This is because the j8-rays have all been absorbed, and there re- main only the relatively feeble but extraordinarily penetrating y-rays. These y-rays are always very feeble, and comparatively unimportant, but their chief interest lies in the fact that they are by fai the most penetrating type of radiation at present known. If the capsule is completely closed in a box of steel; half an inch thick, and a platino- 44 y-RAYS cyanide crystal laid on the top, those in front can readily see that the crystal still fluoresces, and stops the moment it is taken away from the radium. Through a pile of twelve shillings, or pennies, the effect can still be observed, while by means of a sensitive gold-leaf electroscope it can readily be shown that some of the rays still penetrate a foot thickness of solid iron, or six inches of lead. The rays from radium are not well adapted for the taking of radiographs of the kind produced by X-rays. The j8-rays are hardly sufficiently pene- trating for this purpose, so that the flesh as well as the bones of the hand, for example, casts a heavy shadow. The y-rays, on the other hand, are far too penetrating, and the bones hardly cast a shadow at all. The picture (Fig. 7), however, is a good example of a radium radiograph taken by the y-rays of radium. A small box of compasses with the lid shut was placed on a table. Over it, film down, was placed an X-ray plate wrapped in a light- tight envelope. On the floor beneath, at a distance of twenty-five inches from the plate, was placed one-tenth of a grain of pure radium bromide sealed up in a tiny glass tube. The radium was placed between the poles of an electro-magnet, as recom- mended by Mme. Curie, to deflect away the j8-rays which tend to blur the distinctness of the picture. In this way the y-rays of radium were Fie. 6. Wrilten liy Radium in the Dark. idiograph by R. Kill Cromhie, Esq., Journal eftht Rtntgtn Society, Dec, 1906.) Fill. 7. Closed Box of Compasses lakell w y-RA YS 45 alone used. The exposure was five days. It will be seen that the shadow cast by the wooden box is scarcely noticeable, while even the metal compasses and fastenings of the box by no means entirely stop the rays. The metal parts appear in the negative only slightly darker than the unprotected portions of the plate. The negative was reduced and intensified before reproduction. At first the y-rays appeared to be a secondary radiation produced by and accompanying the /3-rays, much as X-rays are produced by and accompany cathode-rays. The /3- and y-rays seemed always to go together, any variation of the /3-rays being accompanied by a similar variation of the y-rays. This is now known, however, not to be invariably the case, and the opinion is gaining ground that the /3- and y-rays are not necessarily connected. The real nature of the y-rays is at present an open ques- tion as rival views are in the field, and as the rays are not of primary importance at the present time we may, with these experiments and remarks, dismiss the subject and pass on to the more detailed con- sideration of the two more important types of rays. Before proceeding to show experiments with the a -rays, it is necessary to touch on certain considera- tions which come into play on account of their very great absorption in passing through matter. In the first place, radioactivity is a mass or volume 46 a-RA YS phenomenon. That is to say, every part, not the surface only but the inner portions also, of a radium salt, for example, is giving out a-, /3- and y-rays. All these rays are absorbed by the sub- stance itself very considerably, for the salts of radium are dense or heavy. But this absorption naturally does not affect the more penetrating rays nearly so much as the feebly penetrating a-rays. That part of the latter, generated inside the salt, does not escape at all. Only a very thin surface film contributes to the a-radiation. The conse- quence is that whereas, with the small quantities of radium that we have to work with, the strength of the penetrating rays is more or less proportional to the quantity of radium employed, with the a-rays this is no longer the case. The weight of the substance is less important than the amount of sur- face exposed. A very small quantity, say a milli- gram, of radium bromide, spread out as a thin film on a large plate, will give out immensely more a-rays than the same quantity in the form of a small crystal. In order to free the /8- and y-rays from the a-rays, or the y-rays from the /8-rays, it suffices to interpose screens of successively increasing thick- ness until the more easily stopped type is completely absorbed. But it is not possible so easily to eliminate by physical methods the /8- and y-rays from the a-rays in order to leave the latter by themselves. For practical purposes, however, this result can be *-RA YS 47 achieved very simply. If we take a very minute quantity of a radium salt spread over a very large area, the /8- and y-rays from so small a quantity will be so feeble as to be practically negligible, whereas the a-rays under these circumstances will reach their greatest intensity. For practical pur- poses a thin film of pure radium salt can be used to give a-rays by themselves, essentially free from £- and y-rays. Such a thin film I have prepared for these ex- periments. On this shallow platinum dish, about a square inch in area, 1 have evaporated down a solution containing about a milligram of pure radium bromide, and the dish, with its precious film open to the air, is carefully preserved when not in use in a special tube containing a desiccating agent to keep it dry, so that without undue risk of loss I can work .with a bare film of radium salt and show you the a-rays. Over the bare film I bring the electri- fied silk tassel. It collapses instantly, in fact, much faster than it does when brought over the whole thirty milligrams of radium bromide contained in the mica-covered capsule. The a-rays from one milligram of radium produce more electrical effect than the £- and y-rays from thirty milligrams. Now I cover the bare film of radium with a single sheet of thin writing-paper, which stops the a-rays com- pletely, the j8- and y-rays scarcely at all. You 48 EXPERIMENTS WITH a,RAYS observe the tassel remains now charged as if the radium were absent. The £- and y-rays from so small a quantity hardly appreciably discharge it. But if I displace the paper ever so slightly and expose a tiny part of the bare surface, the tassel instantly collapses. From these experiments, and the fact that it was the fashion at the time to cover radioactive substances when experimenting with them, you will have no difficulty in understanding how it was that these feebly penetrating but in- tensely powerful a-rays remained at first neglected and almost unknown. I now have to show you a very striking experi- ment indeed, suggested by some profound investi- gations of Professor Bragg in Adelaide, on the a-rays, to which we shall again have occasion to refer. So readily are these a-rays stopped that a few inches of air suffice entirely to absorb them. But the a-rays show this remarkable peculiarity not exhibited by any other type known. Each individual a-ray of any one homogeneous type travels exactly the same distance in an absorbing medium, and is stopped sharply and completely when a certain thickness of matter has been penetrated. The con- sequence is that if we work with a homogeneous beam of a-rays, just without the distance of com- plete absorption, there is absolutely no effect, while Kit:. 9. Apparatus lo show Aliwirpiiun of (i-kiiv-i liy Air. Fie. II. The Spinthariscope of Sir William Cruokes ABSORPTION OF a-RA YS BY AIR 49 just within there is a very large effect. I have said that the a-rays derived from radium are complex, consisting of four different types, each with a definite " range," as it is termed, or distance, it will travel in any given absorbing medium. For the Fig. 8. purposes of this experiment, however, it is neces- sary to consider only the most penetrating type, which Bragg found could travel in air at atmo- spheric pressure and ordinary temperature, 71 millimeters (or just under three inches) and no more. Now this flask (Figs. 8 and 9) is a little more than six inches in diameter, and it has been coated on the B I 50 ABSORPTION OF *RA YS BY AIR upper hemisphere of the inside surface with a phos- phorescent film of zinc sulphide. For these a-rays the usual phosphorescers (e.g. the platinocyanides, willemite, etc.), employed for the fi- and y-rays, are far less sensitive than crystallised zinc sulphide, or, as it is called, Sidot's hexagonal blende. The coated flask is arranged so that I can plunge my platinum dish with its bare radium film upward inside the flask and hold it centrally by a cork. In the dark, the flask being full of air, you observe hardly any glow. The three inches of air surrounding the radium film on all sides suffices completely to stop all the a-rays, and the £- and y-rays, from so small a quantity of radium, produce only a negligible effect on the zinc sulphide. But I have connected the flask to an air-pump and can pump out the air. At the very first stroke of the pump the whole globe flashes into luminescence, and as I continue pumping the glow gets stronger and fairly illuminates the im- mediate neighbourhood with its soft white light. I now readmit the air, and the glow disappears as suddenly as it came. So that you see with some- what carefully designed arrangements, and keeping in mind the peculiar properties of these a-rays which physicists have exactly worked out, it is possible even from a minute amount of pure radium bromide to obtain quite a fair amount of light, whereas the same quantity of radium less cunningly NATURE OF RADIATION 51 disposed would give very little effect. Radium compounds are usually preserved in sealed tubes so as to prevent them absorbing moisture from the atmosphere. Under these circumstances the effects produced by these a-rays are not ob- served. Problems connected with the real physical nature of radiation are, it is well recognised, among the most fundamental in physics, and they involve more deeply perhaps than any others the great under- lying metaphysical relationships between the external world of physical fact and the subjective mental processes by which we attempt to visualise these facts and obtain some sort of a reasonable explana- tion of them. Take, for example, the great problem that is always before us of the real nature of light. Is there anything more difficult of mental com- prehension? The difficulties are not minimised but rather increased by the very definite view we take to-day of energy as a separate entity having a real physical existence. Contemplate for a moment, if you can, the origin of the energy which impels every moving thing in earth or sea or sky. With the exception of a very small and practically negligible movement contri- buted by the tides and by volcanic agencies, and, it must not be forgotten, by the radioactive substances 52 THE ETHER themselves, all things which move do so directly or indirectly by virtue of the energy reaching this earth as radiations in the form of the sun's light and heat. Great masses move hither and thither here because of happenings at some time past, re- mote or recent, 90 millions of miles away in the sun. Inevitably, when we begin to contemplate radiation phenomena, we are driven to inquire into the medium filling the outer void of space by virtue of which this immaterial, but vital entity — energy — reaches us from far distant worlds. It is true we call it ether, and try to give to it all sorts of material, or pseudo-material, characteristics. Lord Kelvin seems to have spent a large part of his leisure time trying as it were to dematerialise matter into ether, that is, trying by all sorts of mechanically ingenious arrangements and analogy from material models — the only possible models our minds can yet grasp — to obtain a possible construction which would simu- late the elusive but all-pervading ether. Others, on the well-known principle that topsy-turvydom, if only consistent and all-embracing enough, results finally in a system no less logical and rational than the original one, have given to the ether inconceiv- ably great density, and to the atoms of matter the character of holes or voids in it. The necessity for the existence of a universal all-pervading medium, or ether, capable of transmitting energy, no one in THE ETHER 53 these days of wireless telegraphy would deny, but on the question of its real nature opinion is as divided as it well could be. The tendency, however, in modern physics to- day is rather to derive and explain material pheno- mena from the properties of the ether than to attempt to construct an ether on a material or pseudo-material model. As yet, however, we know little about the properties of the ether itself. One definite thing we do know, for certain, and have known for a very long time, namely the velocity at which influences are transmitted across the ether. It is 185,000 miles a second, the speed of light So far as we yet know, all influences that are transmitted by the ether travel at this one definite velocity. Not only light, but also the electro- magnetic radiations employed in wireless tele- graphy, the magnetic storms, as they are termed, which reach us from the sun, and also, we believe, the X-rays, travel through the ether at this one definite speed. The great mind of Newton two centuries ago appreciated to the full the fundamental difficulty in the explanation of radiation, and proposed the only way of escape from the more modern doctrine of an ether which, so far as I know, has ever been put forward. 54 CORPUSCULAR RADIATION Light, on the Newtonian hypothesis, consisted in the emission from the glowing body of exces- sively minute material particles or corpuscles travel- ling with immense velocity. This corpuscular theory, so far as light is concerned, failed when subjected to a closer examination, and gave way to the present undulatory theory that light consists in a transverse vibration of the ether, the existence of which, it was beginning to be recognised, was as great a necessity for the transmission of gravita- tional, magnetic, and other forms of energy which reach us from outer space as it was for the trans- mission of radiation itself. Though proved wrong so far as light is concerned, this idea of corpuscular radiation, strangely enough, will rank as one of the most suggestive flashes of Newton's genius, for it, in fact, anticipated by two centuries the march of experimental discovery. To-day, thanks to radioactivity, science has been enriched by the discovery of a-, £-, and y-rays, and two, at least, out of these types, the a- and the j8-rays, are not, like light, vibrations of the ether, but consist of the emission of excessively minute material particles (atoms and corpuscles) travelling with immense velocity. This is one of two chief main lines of evidence that radioactivity is an accompanying manifestation of "atomic disintegration." Into this aspect of the matter, however, I do not WA VE THEOR Y OF LIGHT 55 propose entering to-night Its consideration is more conveniently deferred. It is sufficient to say that the a- and £-rays, or, as I shall henceforth also refer to them, a- and j8-par tides, comprise the lighter fragments, as it were, of the disintegrating atoms of the radioactive substance. In ordinary circumstances radium appears to be expelling both a- and ^-particles together, but this as we shall come to see is due to the fact that several successive disintegrations are occurring, and the effect is a composite one. The nature of * r ay to the next, such a reservoir would be an extremely small one, and for periods such as we are considering its effect on the flow would be practically negligible. It would be quite otherwise if one or more reservoirs as large as Milngavie — if one or more intermediate substances as long-lived as radium — existed in the series. I well remember one fact told me by the engineer in charge of the mag- nificent scheme of waterworks, supplying the mines at Kalgurli, in Western Australia, from a source near the coast across three hundred miles of desert There are several intermediate reservoirs on the way. The plant installed is capable of pumping five million gallons of water daily, and yet it took a period of many weeks since pumping operations began before the water appeared in Kalgurli. When uranium is carefully purified from all other substances one can be sure that one starts with all the intermediate reservoirs empty, that is, with none of the intermediate substances present. Water is flowing steadily from the source all the time, as the 1 86 INTERMEDIATE PRODUCTS disintegration of uranium is always going on. We have been watching and waiting seven years at the radium reservoir — strictly speaking, at the one beyond radium, since the emanation of radium, not radium itself, is actually employed for the test. But the flow has not reached there yet and the radium reservoir remains practically as empty as at the start. But there is no doubt it will come, and there is good reason to expect that some of us, at least, will be still alive when it arrives. It is not beyond the resources of mathematics to find out a good deal about these intermediate reservoirs. The present results indicate that if there is but one long-lived intermediate body between uranium and radium, then its period of average life must be at least 100,000 years, that is, forty times that of radium itself. On our analogy, then, between Loch Katrine and Milngavie, there must exist a reservoir of forty times the capacity of Milngavie, provided there is only one. There may be several. Several small ones would be much more effective than one large one. Since the equilibrium quantity to which an intermediate body accumulates is proportional to its period of average life, then if there is only one intermediate parent of radium between radium and uranium, there must be forty times as much of it in minerals con- taining radium as there is of radium itself. THE DIRECT PARENT OF RADIUM 187 This leads me to the next step. The failure to detect a production of radium from uranium merely foreshadowed the discovery of one or more intermediate substances of long period of life. Boltwood in America has, however, actually succeeded in isolating one from minerals contain- ing radium, and this one proves to be the direct parent of radium. Whether there are others it remains to be seen. The one found possesses the property of producing radium directly from itself by disintegration, and it has been called Ionium. It expels a-rays during its dis- integration into radium, and these a-rays possess a relatively low velocity. Their range is very little more than one inch of air. Chemically, ionium resembles thorium so completely that the two substances, if mixed, cannot be separated. This gives the means of separating the new body from minerals. Some thorium is added and separated by the well-known methods of chemical analysis. It is then purified as com- pletely as possible. The parent of radium is not separated from the thorium by this treatment, although all other substances are. The chemical resemblance between the two substances is analogous to that between radium and barium or polonium and bismuth, and does not signify any genetic connection between the substances. 1 88 THE PRODUCT OF URANIUM The disintegration series thus reads : — 0-0 Uranium I. Uranium II. Uranium X. Ionium Radium. Emanation. 8,000,000,000 2,000,000 35*5 days. 200,000 2,500 56 days, years. years (?) years (?) years. Fig. 26. as far as we have yet considered it. In the centre is placed the known or presumed atomic weights of the various bodies. It is to be noticed that a gap still remains between uranium X and the parent of radium. As the mass of the ^-particle is practically negligible, the product of uranium X should still have an atomic weight of 230, so that there are presumably no more changes in which a-particles are expelled. There is little doubt that the gap will soon be filled up. All that it is required now is to prove that uranium X is the parent of ionium. A long research, which involved the repeated separa- tion of the uranium X from a hundredweight of pure uranium nitrate, failed to establish this, doubt- less on account of the very long period of ionium. Indeed, it is possible to say now that to command success, and settle the question definitely, half a ton of uranium nitrate would probably be required. The reason for this is, as already explained, the enormous period of ionium by comparison with that of uranium X, which an indirect estimate, to be later considered, indicates to be about 200,000 years. ELEMENTAR Y E VOL UT10N 1 89 So far t then, as we have inquired, uranium, uranium X, the parent of radium, radium, and the emanation represent respectively the starting-point and the four successive stopping-stations in the long journey of continuous devolution from the heaviest and most complex atom known into less heavy and complex atoms which is going on around us, or, to preserve our original analogy, the source and four successive intermediate reservoirs in the flow of elementary evolution. " All things flow " was one of the dogmas of ancient philosophy, and in this, as in many others, the ancients guessed truer than they knew. Instead of four stopping-stations or inter- mediate reservoirs in this stately procession of elements disclosed by radioactivity, there are already known no less than eleven, starting from the element uranium, but for our present purposes of illustration these four will suffice. But this new transformation scene on which the curtain of the twentieth century has been rung up, beginning as it has done with the transformation of the most fundamental and permanent of the existences which physical science has recognised in the past, extends beyond physical science and transfigures with new light some of the most fundamental and permanent ideas which in one form or another are deep-rcoted in the world's philosophies. CHAPTER IX. The subsequent changes of radium — The induced or excited radio- activity — The active deposit of radium — The disintegration of the emanation — Radium A, B, C — Experiments with the active deposit — Radium A gives only a-rays and has a very short life — Radium B gives no rays — Radium C gives a-, /3-, and y-rays — The emanation only gives a-rays — The later slow changes of radium — Radium D, E, and F — Polonium — Its identity with radium F — The last disintegration— What is the ultimate product? WE have attempted to trace radium to its source. It remains to follow through its disintegration briefly to the end. This was a task to which Rutherford particularly devoted himself, after the main principles of atomic disintegration had become familiar, with the consequence that, with the exception of a lacuna here and there still to be supplied, our knowledge of the whole process from the start to finish is now tolerably complete. In addition, some new considerations have trans- pired which concern us nearly in the broad general application of the principles of atomic disintegration, so that for this reason, if for no other, the work claims our attention. Most of you who have read at all in the subject will be aware of one mysterious and extraordinary 190 SUBSEQUENT CHANGES OF RADIUM 191 power possessed by radium, which I have hitherto carefully avoided all mention of, not wanting to have too many irons in the fire at once. Radium possesses the power of endowing with some of its own radioactivity neighbouring objects. Thorium, which is very like radium in many ways, particularly in giving a gaseous emanation (which, however, has the very short period of average life of only a little over a minute), also possesses a similar power. The phenomenon was discovered by the Curies for radium and termed " induced radio- activity," and for thorium simultaneously by Rutherford and termed "excited radioactivity." With the explanation of the property the original names have largely fallen into disuse. We shall, as usual, confine ourselves to the case of radium. Any object left in the immediate neighbourhood of a radium salt becomes radioactive, but after it is removed the radioactivity decays away rapidly and almost completely, abnormally at first, but subse- quently in a geometrical progression with the time, with a half-value period of about thirty minutes. The temporary activity so " induced " consists of a-, £-, and y- rays. The activity exists as an invisible film or deposit over the surface of the object rendered radioactive, for, by sand -papering, the activity can be rubbed off and then is found on the sand-paper. It is now customary in con- iQ2 ACTIVE DEPOSIT OF HADIUM sequence to refer to it as the " active deposit of radium." This power is, strictly speaking, not a property of radium itself, for if the radium is contained in a completely closed vessel — it does not matter how thin-walled so long as it is air-tight — no radio- activity whatever is produced outside. The first step in understanding the nature of the phenomenon consisted in tracing it to the action of the emanation of radium. In the ordinary condition the emanation is always diffusing away to some extent from radium salts unless they are contained in air-tight vessels. The "active deposit " is the product of the disin- tegration of the emanation. Just as radium cannot exist without continuously producing the emanation, so in turn the emanation cannot exist without con- tinuously producing this active deposit. In any vessel containing radium emanation this body is being continuously deposited on the walls of the vessel, so that if the emanation is at any time blown out, the active deposit remains behind. Radium expels one a-particle and changes into the emanation. The emanation expels a second a-par- ticle and changes back again into a solid, or at least into a non-gaseous form of matter, the first of the " active deposit " group. The latter in turn expels more <*- and also £- particles, and so the course of successive disintegrations goes on. In the active deposit itself at least three changes follow one ACTIVE DEPOSIT OF RADIUM 193 another with great rapidity, so that the analysis of them proved a complicated task. You know that if a moisture-laden atmosphere is sufficiently chilled, the vapour of water condenses directly into the solid form, and a snowstorm results. Something of this kind is always happen- ing in an atmosphere containing the radium emanation. Every second two out of every million of the atoms of emanation disintegrate, expelling a-particles and leaving a solid residue, so that there is a sort of continuous snowstorm silently going on covering every available surface with this invisible, unweighable, but intensely radioactive deposit. Unlike snow, however, the particles of this active deposit are charged with positive electricity, so that if two surfaces are provided, one charged nega- tively and the other positively, the deposit is attracted almost entirely to the negatively charged surface. The other surface repels the particles and so does not get coated. By making the negatively charged surface very small the active deposit can be almost entirely concentrated upon it. This enables me to show you more effectively the pro- duction of the active deposit from the emanation and some of its chief properties. The separation of the non-volatile product of a volatile parent or emanation by this use of a negatively charged sur- face is a very simple operation, much more so than o i 9 4 RADIUM A, £, AND C when the parent substance is non-volatile and the recoil of the product is used to effect its separation and concentration on a negatively charged surface, as discussed on p. 144. It would take us too long and too far if we attempted first to study these properties, and then tried from them to deduce their explanation. It must suffice if I give you first the explanation of the facts according to the theory of atomic dis- integration and then illustrate as many of the points in it as possible experimentally. I have said that after the disintegration of the emanation at least three successive disintegrations, following one another rapidly, occur. The bodies produced are referred to as Radium A, Radium B, Radium C, in order to avoid the necessity of inventing a host of new names for bodies having such fleeting existence (Fig. 27). Radium. Emanation. Radium A. Radium B. Radium C. * „ ' Active deposit of rapid change. 2,500 years. 5*6 days. 4*3 3 8 '5 2 8'i minutes. minutes. minutes. Fig. 27. As before, the presumed atomic weights are placed inside the circles corresponding with the successive products. The periods of average life RADIUM A % B, AND C 195 are placed below. The symbol 08) here and throughout indicates that £-rays are expelled, but that they are not the normal penetrating £-rays, but rays akin to the cathode-rays in their low pene- trating power and low velocity. They only come into evidence in special experiments, and are not of great general importance. The first body produced from the emanation, radium A, changes with great rapidity with a period of average life of 4/3 min- utes, expelling an a-particle. The body radium B resulting undergoes a change which was at first thought to be entirely "rayless." Neither a- nor £-rays of the ordinary kind can be detected, although a very feebly penetrating £-ray is produced, which we need not further consider. The period of this substance is 38*5 minutes. The body pro- duced, radium C, changes, expelling both a- and £- particles and 7- rays also. The period is 28*1 minutes. It is probable that this change is complex, and that the &• and y-rays are given off in a separate change to that in which the a-rays result. The point is still being investigated, and need not further concern us now. We started our description of the rays of radium with the statement that they consisted of a-, £-, and y-rays. One of the most interesting points of the above scheme is to show that the fi- and y-rays do not come from radium itself, any more than they 196 RADIUM A, £, AND C do from uranium itself, but from the later products. It is loose, but convenient, to talk of the P- and y-rays of radium. Really we mean the 0- and y-rays of radium C. The emanation, like radium itself, gives only a-rays. The whole of the £-rays result in the later changes of the active deposit. Fig. 28. We have seen that, freshly prepared from solution, radium salts give only a- rays. The £- and 7-rays make their appearance only after the subsequent products have accumulated. On the table there is a small glass vessel silvered internally (Figs. 28 and 29) containing the emana- Fm. 29. Apparatus fur obtaining the Active Deposit of Kadiun EXPERIMENTS WITH THE ACTIVE DEPOSIT 197 tion from half a grain of radium bromide. It is arranged so that steel knitting-needles can be inserted into the emanation and withdrawn through a glass tube held in a cork. The needle is con- nected to the negative pole of the electric supply and the silver coating to the positive pole. If only the point of the needle is made to project beyond the glass tube, the whole of the active deposit can be concentrated on the point. Some hours before this lecture a needle — we will call it No. 1 — was so inserted, and by now its point should be coated to its maximum degree of radioactivity with the products of the disintegration of the emanation. After some hours the products all arrive at the state of radioactive equilibrium, in which the quantity is at its maximum for all the products, radium A, radium B, and radium C, as much of each changing as is produced from the emanation. The disintegrations all going on together, the wire should give a-, £-, and y-rays, the j8- and y-rays being as intense as those given from the half-grain of radium bromide from which the emanation was derived. Now I withdraw No. 1 needle from the emanation, and with the room darkened we will examine its active deposit. To detect the o-rays we will use a glass translucent screen, thinly coated with phos- phorescent zinc sulphide on one side. I bring the point of the needle gradually near the coated side 198 EXPERIMENTS WITH THE ACTIVE DEPOSIT of the screen. As soon as it comes within a distance of three inches the screen lights up, and when the point is only a little distance removed from the screen a most brilliant phosphorescence is produced. Now if I interpose between the wire and the screen a single sheet of paper, the effect practically entirely ceases. The a-radiations pro- ducing this effect come both from radium A and from radium C. To detect the /J-rays we will use an ordinary cardboard X-ray screen of barium platinocyanide. Bringing the needle behind the screen, so that the rays have to penetrate the cardboard, you observe the screen lights up as brightly as with half a grain of radium bromide itself. In the dark I happened actually to touch the back of the screen with the active needle-point, and in so doing some of the active deposit has been transferred to the back of the screen. You can see where the back of the screen was touched, because this spot still glows though the needle has been removed. If now the needle is again presented to the back of the X-ray screen with thin pieces of metal foil interposed, you see that the rays are only slightly stopped by having to traverse the foil. When a piece of thick lead sheet is interposed, a faint luminosity on the screen still remains produced by the y-rays. In fact the active needle-point gives EXPERIMENTS WITH THE ACTIVE DEPOSIT 199 all the penetrating rays given by half a grain of radium bromide. It is now several minutes since the needle was removed from the emanation. If we now again examine the a-rays you will notice they already are very perceptibly less intense than at first. Practically all the radium A, of which the period of average life is only 4*3 minutes, has already disintegrated, and in consequence the a-rays now come only from the radium C, and are only half as intense as at first. Now if, instead of exposing the needle to the emanation for some hours so as to allow all the successive products time to be produced, we expose it to the emanation for a very short time, say for five minutes by the watch, we shall get quite a different set of effects. Here is a new needle, we will call it No. 2. Before putting it in I will test it with the screen to show you that at present it is an ordinary needle, not at all radioactive. We will let it stay in the emanation, connected to the negative pole as before, for five minutes and withdraw it, and test its a-rays immediately, exactly as before. You observe that it is already giving a-rays abundantly. Comparing it with No. 1, the two are now very similar in their a-ray-giving power, No. 1 being only slightly the better. The a-rays from No. 2 come entirely from radium A, 200 EXPERIMENTS WITH THE ACTIVE DEPOSIT for there has not yet been time for any appre- ciable quantity of radium C to be formed The a-rays from No. i come entirely from radium C, and this radiation has not yet had time appre- ciably to decay. Let us, however, test their 0-rays. You observe that No. 2 gives no 0-rays worth considering, whereas No. 1 still gives i8-rays in practically undiminished intensity. Radium A gives no j8-rays, and as there is no appreciable quantity of radium C formed there yet, the con- sequence is that No. 2 wire gives no #-rays. I can show you at this stage a very striking experiment with another needle, No. 3, which has been in the emanation a few minutes. I take it out and draw the point once through a piece of emery - cloth and expose the latter to the zinc sulphide screen. You observe that a single rub has removed a large part of the active deposit from the needle and transferred it to the emery- cloth, so that the latter makes the screen glow almost as brilliantly as the needles themselves. Now we will contrast the decay of the activity of the needles Nos. 1 and 2. The activity due to radium A by itself decays very rapidly, half disappearing every three minutes. The con- sequence is, if we now again test the a-rays of No. 2, we shall find they have already nearly EXPERIMENTS WITH THE ACTIVE DEPOSIT 201 disappeared, whereas No. 1 still continues to give a-rays at about the same strength as it did when last examined. In ten minutes the a-rays of No. 2 practically disappear. It is thus not difficult to give you a certain amount of experimental evidence in favour of the conclusion that the first change of the active deposit is a very rapid one in which a-, but no j8-rays are expelled, and that this is followed by a less rapid change in which both a- and j8-rays are expelled. It is more difficult to give you in a lecture satisfactory evidence of the exist- ence of radium B, a body not itself giving rays, intermediate between the first and second changes in which rays are expelled. If we examine care- fully the decay of the a- and j8-rays of wire No. 1, in which at first all these products co-existed in equilibrium, we shall find, as already shown, that for the first half-hour after removal from the emanation the /8-rays suffer hardly any change and then quite definitely the decay begins. In the next half-hour the jS-rays decay to one half their original intensity, and the decay then goes on at this rate regularly and continuously to the end. After two hours they are only a few per cent of what they originally were, and in three or four hours they can no longer be detected. The initial pause before decay begins is due to the quantity of radium C being maintained, in 202 THE RAYS FROM THE EMANATION spite of the fact that it is disintegrating all the time, expelling a- and jS-rays, by the disintegra- tion of radium B. The latter continues to supply new radium C to replace that disappearing for the first half-hour or so after the needle is re- moved from the emanation. Exactly the same pause occurs in the decay of the a-rays. As we saw with No. i, within a very few minutes after the needle was removed from the emanation the a-rays had decayed very perceptibly, owing to the dis- appearance of the a-ray-giving radium A. Then, however, no further change occurred. It is now about half an hour since No. i was first tested, and the a-activity is about the same as it was when last tested twenty minutes ago. The a-rays of No. 2 have now almost completely disappeared. If we continued to examine No. i, we should find, from now on, a rapid decay of both a- and £-rays at the same rate, so that at the end of the lecture both will be much enfeebled, and by midnight both will have ceased so far as we could tell by these rough methods. Now that we have finished with the emanation used in the preceding experiments, it is an interesting experiment to show that itself it gives no j8-rays. If we blow the emanation out into a U-tube of thin glass cooled in liquid air, it THE LATER SLOW CHANGES OF RADIUM 203 is condensed in the cold tube. The tube can then be sealed up to prevent the emanation from escaping. The tube contains some phosphorescent zinc sulphide and glows brightly owing to the a-rays from the emanation inside. But if we hold the tube against the X-ray screen, you can see that no penetrating rays come from the tube. The emanation itself gives no £-rays, only a-rays. By the end of the lecture, however, sufficient radium C will probably have been formed inside the tube to give an appreciable j8-radiation. Owing to the existence of the intermediate body radium B, there occurs a similar pause in the growth of /8-rays from the emanation to that which, as we have seen, occurs in their decay, after the emanation is taken away. But in two or three hours the £-rays from all the needles will have decayed, and that from the sealed U-tube will have reached a maximum. This finishes this subject and brings us to the next. What happens to radium C when it disinte- grates ? Is this the real or only the apparent end of the process ? It is, in fact, a very long way from the end. Madame Curie discovered that the rapid and almost complete decay of the active deposit, at the end of a few hours after removal from the emanation, is not in fact quite complete. A very small residual radioactivity remains and per- 204 XADIUM A E, AND F sists for years. The series of changes have now entered on a stage which is as slow as the previous ones were rapid. The next change requires almost as many years as the last required minutes for com- pletion. The effect of these further changes is in consequence extremely small, but they last a very long time. Continuing our diagram where it last ended at radium C, the next stage is represented in Fig. 30. 1 1 *°)—+l 2#ol-^f a/ol— »r 206I Radium C. Radium D. Radium E. Radium F. Radium G. (Polonium.) (Lead?) Active deposit of slow change. 28*1 24 7*5 days. 202 days, minutes. years (?) Fig. 30. The body produced from radium C, radium D, has a period of many years. It is too early yet to state it exactly. One recent estimate makes it twenty- four years. No very important rays are given in its change. 0-rays, however, result from the body pro- duced from it, which changes rapidly again with a period of only a few days. We shall pass over these intermediate changes and consider the last known change of the series, that of radium F, which has a period of average life of 202 days, in which an a-particle is expelled. Radium F is the polonium POLONIUM 205 of Madame Curie, having been separated by her from pitchblende first before she discovered radium. A digression may here conveniently be made on what is known about polonium, before its connec- tion with radium is considered. Chemically it re- sembles bismuth, and was separated first from pitchblende in association with the bismuth con- tained in the mineral. Its radioactivity, which consists entirely of a-rays, slowly and completely decays, so that a few years after it has been pre- pared, the most intensely active preparations of it lose practically all their activity. The work was carried on by Marckwald in Germany, who dis- covered new and simple methods of extracting polonium from the mineral and worked up many tons of pitchblende for this substance. His careful chemical investigations of the nature of the body made it clear that it was quite as nearly allied in chemical nature to the element tellurium as to bis- muth, and he first proposed the name "radio- tellurium " for it, which, however, with the elucidation of its identity with polonium, has fallen into disuse. He proved that there is far less polonium in the mineral even than radium. In a ton of mineral there is less than a thousandth part of a grain of polonium, but the radioactivity is correspondingly intense, and greatly exceeds, so far as the a-radiation io6 POLONIUM is concerned, that of pure radium itself. The period of average life, 202 days, is deduced by direct observation from the rate of decay of the radio- activity. Returning now to the consideration of radium C, we saw that after its activity had decayed there existed still a residual activity which is very feeble. This steadily increases with time, and consists both of a- and £-rays, which, however, increase at dif- ferent rates. The a-rays are due to polonium, or radium F. These go on increasing for the first two years and then a maximum is reached, the amount of the radium F formed being in equilibrium. The jS-rays, however, reach a maximum much more quickly. The j8-ray product (radium E) having a much shorter period, equilibrium is reached in a few weeks. If at any time the active matter is subjected to the chemical processes worked out by Marckwald for the separation of polonium, the a-ray body radium F can be separated from the other products, and its activity then decays away completely at exactly the same rate as in the case of polonium. Moreover, it shows the property of being volatile at a temperature of a bright red heat, which is the basis of one of the methods originally used by Madame Curie in separating polonium from the bismuth in pitchblende. This is merely WHAT IS THE ULTIMATE PRODUCT '? 207 a sketch of the evidence in favour of regarding polonium as the last radioactive substance produced in the disintegration of uranium. One more step remains to be discussed, and then this long story of continuous transformation is at an end. What is the ultimate product ? When radium F or polonium expels its a-particle, what is produced ? The estimated atomic weight of polonium is 210*5, which is deduced by subtracting from the atomic weight of uranium (238*5) the weight of the seven atoms of helium known to be expelled in the form of a-particles. This agrees well with its chemical nature, for there is a vacant place in the periodic table for an element, the next heavier than bismuth (atomic weight, 208*5), and this element would be chemically analogous to tellurium. The expulsion of an a-particle would further reduce the atomic weight four units, leaving a residue of atomic weight 206*5. What is it ? Now, if this is really the final product and not merely a very slowly changing substance, the forma- tion of which in proportion to the degree of slow- ness of the change would be difficult experimentally to detect, then it follows that the ultimate product must accumulate in quantity indefinitely with time in the minerals containing the elements of the uranium-radium series, and must therefore be a well-known common element. There seems to be 208 LEAD IN RADIUM MINERALS only a possible choice of two such elements. Lead has the atomic weight of 207*1, and bismuth, 208 # o. The next known element is thallium (204), and then comes mercury (200). For long it has looked as if lead would prove to be the ultimate product. It must be remembered that the atomic weight of helium is not very accu- rately known, and is probably a little below, rather, than above, 4. So that the atomic weight of lead, 207*1, agrees fairly well with the estimate 206*5, ob- tained by subtracting from the atomic weight of radium 226*5, the weight of the five a-particles, or helium atoms, known to be expelled. Lead is found in all the common minerals containing uranium in considerable quantity, and there is some evidence that the older the geological formation from which the mineral is obtained, the greater the percentage of lead present. Recently a uranium mineral, autunite, has been found containing no chemically detectable quantity of lead. But then the same mineral contains only an excessively minute trace of helium, and less than its full equilibrium amount of radium. There is every reason to believe that its formation as a mineral has occurred in quite recent times. This question is still unsettled. We may rest assured that the patient application of the methods which have already resulted in the brilliant solution of many problems in radioactivity, at first apparently DISINTEGRATION SERIES OF URANIUM 209 insoluble except by researches extending over im- possible periods of time, will cause this last strong- hold to capitulate. The only method of settling it is to study the change of polonium, separated from enormous quantities of pitchblende, by the aid of the spectroscope, and on this task Mme. Curie and her colleagues have for long been engaged Uranium I. Uranium II. Uranium X. Ionium. Radium. 8,000,000.000 2,000,000 35- 5 days. 200.000 2,500 years. years (?) years (?) years. Emanation. Radium A. Radium B. Radium C. Active deposit of rapid change. 56 days. 4*3 38'5 ? 81 minutes. minutes. minutes. {ft •ft** fno\— *QllOj< Radium D. Radium E. Radium F. Radium G. (Polonium.) (Lead?) v_ f ' Active deposit of slow change. 24 years (?) 7*25 days. 202 days. Fio. 31. Fig. 31 shows, so far as it is at present known, the complete disintegration series of uranium, p CHAPTER X. Ratio of quantities of polonium and radium in minerals — Table of the ratio of the quantities of all the products of uranium — Difficulty of concentrating many of the long-lived products of uranium — Increase of activity of radium with time — Radioactivity a physical measure of value or rarity — The currency metals and their rarity — Are they changing like radium ? — Physical necessity for rarity of a changing element — One aspect of the ultimate nature of matter — A quota- tion from Clerk Maxwell — Evolution of the elements denied — Similarity of all the atoms of the same element — The atom a complex and perfect piece of mechanism — Professor Schuster's analogy — The atom true to its character at dissolution — Similarity in the velocity of all a particles expelled from a radio -element — The more stable the radio -element the slower the a-rays expelled from it — Survival of the fittest or most stable atoms— Universality of the conception of evolution to the material universe, animate and inanimate. • • * FROM the law, which has already been found so useful, we can calculate the ratio of the quantities of radium and polonium that exist together in a mineral from their periods of average life. The period of average life of radium is 4500 times that of polonium, so that there must be 4500 times more radium than polonium in minerals. A good pitchblende contains about an ounce of radium in 150 tons. The same quantity of polonium would therefore be contained in about 700,000 tons. The whole output of the Joachimsthal mine per annum, reckoned as 15 tons, contains about one hundredth 210 THE LA W OF PROPORTIONALITY 21 I of a grain of polonium. This is borne out by MarckwalcTs experiments, already referred to. Let us apply the law not only to radium and polonium, but to the whole list of known transition- forms existing as products of uranium. In the table this has been done. The first column gives the name of the substance, the second its period of average life, and the third its relative quantity in minerals, the quantity of uranium being considered 1,000,000,000. If these numbers are taken to refer throughout to milligrams ( i milligram is about ^ of a grain), then since 1,000,000,000 milligrams is roughly a ton, the quantities refer to an amount of mineral containing one ton of the element uranium. TABLE. Period. Uranium I, 8,000,000,000 years. Uranium II, 2,000,000 years (?). Uranium X .. Ionium Radium Emanation .. Radium A Radium B Radium C .. Radium D Radium E Radium F (Polonium) 35-5 days. 200,000 years (?). 2,500 years. 5*6 days. 4*3 minutes. 38*5 minutes. 28*1 minutes. 24 years. 7 '5 davs - 202 days. Quantity. 1,000,000,000 mg. (=1 ton). 250 grams (?). One eightieth mg. 25 grams (?). 312-5 mg. One five-hundredth mg. One millionth mg. Nine millionths mg. Seven millionths mg. 3mg. One four-thousandth mg. One fourteenth mg. 212 DIFFICULTY OF These respective quantities in the last column emit a similar number of a-particles per second in the six cases where a-particles are expelled at all, and so produce similar radioactive effects. This is an illustration of the compensating principle I spoke of earlier, that the quantity of a radioactive sub- stance divided by its life, not the quantity only, gives a measure of its radioactive effects. It can readily be calculated that the actual amount of radium A used in our experiments, which produced powerful and striking effects on the phosphorescent screen, was much below one ten-millionth of a milligram, or below one thousand-millionth of a grain. For it was derived from 30 mg., i.e. half a grain of radium bromide. Yet while it lasts it comes into evidence through the energy of the a-particles expelled in its rapid disintegration no less than any of the other products. The table brings out clearly that radium is but one of many radioactive substances in uranium minerals, which would be of value if they could be extracted. Uranium II, ionium and radium D, all possess sufficiently extended periods of life to repay recovery. Ionium gives only very feebly penetrating a-rays, and so would not be so generally useful as radium, whereas uranium II and radium D both, being followed by short-lived products which give £-rays, would be of great general utility. The SEPARATING RADIO-ELEMENTS 213 reason which has precluded the practical separation of these substances in the past is a general one, which undoubtedly is of the highest philosophical significance in the chemistry of these new ephemeral elements. They all so closely resemble one or other of the known elements that the separation is impossible. The resemblance between radium and barium is of great practical utility, because these two elements, though very closely alike in chemical nature, can be separated from each other after they have first been separated from every other element. Taking them in order, uranium II cannot yet be separated from uranium I, ionium cannot be separ- ated from thorium, nor radium D from lead. Lead, as has been stated, is almost always present in considerable quantity in uranium minerals, and so usually is thorium, but to a much more variable extent. Hence, though it is easy to separate radium D from the mineral with the lead, it is at present useless practically, as it cannot be con- centrated from the lead. By choosing suitable minerals like secondary pitchblendes, which do not contain ponderable quantities of thorium, intensely active preparations of ionium can however be separated. It is at present the only one in the uranium series likely to become useful, and its lack of penetrating rays is a serious drawback. Polonium, with its period of less than a year and 214 INCREASE OF ACTIVITY its absence of penetrating rays, hardly repays ex- traction, except for purely scientific investigations. There is, however, another disintegration series, that of thorium, which offers a better chance of providing an efficient substitute for radium, and this series will therefore be briefly considered in the concluding chapter. The increase of the radioactivity of radium after it is prepared is due to the steady growth of the products undergoing further disintegration. As we know, when freshly prepared from solution, the activity of radium is due solely to its own disintegration and consists of a-rays. After four weeks the first four products accumulate to their equilibrium, and the activity now consists of a-, /8-, and 7-rays, the a-rays being four times as great as initially. It is not difficult to see that the later slow changes must also cause a very slow further continuous increase of all these types of rays. There is reason to believe that the change of radium C is double, two /8-particles and one a-particle being expelled in the double change, but that is not yet settled. These considerations are embodied in the following table giving an analysis of the total radioactivity of a radium preparation, kept in a sealed vessel so that none of the products escape, at different periods since preparation : — OF RADIUM WITH AGE 215 a- PARTICLES. 0-PARTICLBS. I. Freshly prepared. 1 (due to radium itself ) o II. After one month. 4(1 due to radium) 1 or 2 (1 due to emanation) (due to Ra C) (1 due to radium A) (1 due to radium C) III. After a century. 5 (as in II and 1 due 2 or 3 to radium F) (1 due to Ra E 2 ) The idea, which is a necessary consequence of the atomic disintegration theory, that fixed definite relationships must exist between the quantities of elements formed from one another — for example, between uranium, radium, and polonium — forms the first indication that physical laws may exist regulat- ing the relative abundance and scarcity of elements in Nature. Gold and platinum, for example, are valuable or rare metals, and we do not know why. Radioactive bodies like radium are rare because of the rapidity with which they are changing. The degree of radioactivity of an element being pro- portional to the rate at which it is changing, it follows that radioactive elements are scarce and valuable in proportion to their radioactivity. In this case degree of radioactivity is a physical measure of value or rarity. It is, for example, so far as we can see, an impossibility that an element like radium will ever be found in greater abundance in any minerals than in those already known. 216 A PHYSICAL MEASURE OF RARITY Naturally, in the consideration of some of these questions of general interest upon which we are now entering, we are, be it said, in sharp contrast to almost everything we have dealt with in the subject up to now, frankly speculating. But it is helpful and legitimate to speculate upon how far, if at all, the process of atomic disintegration, dis- covered for the radio-elements, applies to the case of elements not radioactive, of which there is as yet no positive evidence that they are changing at all. The workers in radioactivity have within their province explored thoroughly the process of atomic disintegration. They have made clear the laws it follows, they have measured the rates at which it occurs, and they have established what may be termed its inevitableness or independence from all known influences. But there is no reason why the process should be limited in its scope to the some- what special phenomena which led to its discovery. It is, for example, natural to inquire whether the scarcity of elements like gold is fixed by the opera- tion of similar physical laws to those which regulate the rarity of radium. The race has grown used from the earliest times to the idea that gold is a metal possessing a certain fixed degree of value, enabling it to be used safely for the purposes of currency and exchange. It is no exaggeration to i THE GOLD CURRENCY 217 say that the whole social machinery of the Western world would be dislocated if gold altered violently in its degree of rarity — if, for example, in some hitherto unpenetrated fastness of the globe a moun- tain of gold came to be discovered. Is there not at least a strong presumption that this is really as contrary to the operation of natural law as the dis- covery of a mountain of pure radium would be ? It may, I think, be taken for granted that an element changing more rapidly than uranium, for example, — that is with a period of average life of less than 8,000,000,000 years — is not likely to be much more plentiful in nature than uranium, and therefore that all the common elements — lead, copper, iron, oxygen, silicon, etc. etc. — have periods of average life of many thousands of millions of years. So far, the traditional view that the elements are permanent and unchanging is substantially correct. At the same time, we cannot but recognise that inevitably the effects of atomic disintegration, too slow to be other- wise detectable, would result in the accumulation of the more stable and longest-lived elements at the expense of the others, resulting in some sort of equilibrium in which the relative abundance of the elements was proportional to their respective periods of average life. For example, the ratio between the relative abundance of gold and silver 2iS RELATIVE ABUNDANCE OF ELEMENTS is roughly but pretty certainly known, owing to these metals being employed for currency purposes from the earliest times. It is at least a possible view to take that the elements gold and silver belong to the same disintegration series, both changing very slowly, but the gold many times more rapidly than the silver. Obviously we are only at the beginning. But already it cannot be gainsaid that the interest and importance of this process of atomic disintegration is not confined to radioactivity only or even to physical science. It extends into almost every region of thought. This is the chief reason, and must be my excuse for being so bold as to attempt to bring before a general audience so much of the, in one sense, highly technical discoveries of radioactivity. It would be a pity if mere technicalities and strange words barred the progress of ideas and their application to everyday thought. Otherwise the scientific discoverer would, so far as his own times were concerned, labour half in vain, and worse, the accurate and complete application of his work to other fields of thought would be delayed by erro- neous and partial ideas, mere half-truths, springing up in their place. I now propose considering briefly another ques- tion of general philosophical interest in connection THE NATURE OF ATOMS 219 with the recent advances of physical science. Naturally the discoveries in radioactivity have not been made without influencing considerably our ideas on the ultimate nature of atoms. In some points older conceptions have had to be modified, while in others these conceptions have been strangely confirmed. It has always been a matter for remark, considering the myriads of individual atoms which go to make up the smallest perceptible quantity of matter, that there are so few different kinds. The number of atoms which go to make up this world, for example, would run into at least fifty-four figures, yet among them all there are less than a hundred different varieties. Moreover, it has come to be regarded as one of the greatest philosophical generalisations of physical science that all the atoms of one kind, that is to say of one element, are exactly and completely similar in character. There is, for example, not the shadow of distinction between gold found in the Klondyke, in Australia, or in S. Africa. Not only so, but we have learned from the spectroscope that this similarity of nature extends throughout the whole universe. In this connection," both to set forth the idea and to illustrate the deductions which have been drawn from it, I cannot do better than to quote a celebrated utterance of Clerk Maxwell to the British Association in 1873. I may remark 220 A QUOTATION FROM CLERK MAXWELL that Clerk Maxwell throughout used the word molecule in the sense of "atom" as this word is employed by the chemist, and throughout these lectures. "In the heavens we discover by their light, and by their light alone, stars so far distant from each other that no material thing can ever have passed from one to another ; and yet this light, which is to us the sole evidence of the existence of these distant worlds, tells us also that each of them is built up of molecules of the same kinds as those which we find on earth. A molecule of hydrogen, for example, whether in Sirius or in Arcturus, executes its vibrations in precisely the same time. " Each molecule therefore throughout the uni- verse bears impressed upon it the stamp of a metric system as distinctly as does the metre of the Archives at Paris, or the double royal cubit of the temple of Karnac. "No theory of evolution can be formed to account for the similarity of molecules, for evolu- tion necessarily implies continuous change, and the molecule is incapable of growth or decay, of generation or destruction. " None of the processes of Nature, since the time when Nature began, have produced the slightest difference in the properties of any mole- cule. We are therefore unable to ascribe either the existence of the molecules or the identity of FOUNDATION-STONES OF THE UNIVERSE 221 their properties to any of the causes which we call natural. " On the other hand, the exact equality of each molecule to all the others of the same kind gives it, as Sir John Herschel has well said, the essential character of a manufactured article, and precludes the idea of its being eternal and self-existent. " Thus we have been led, along a strictly scien- tific path, very near to the point at which science must stop ; not that science is debarred from study- ing the internal mechanism of a molecule which she cannot take to pieces, any more than from investigating an organism which she cannot put together. But in tracing back the history of matter, Science is arrested when she assures herself, on the one hand, that the molecule has been made, and on the other, that it has not been made by any of the processes we call natural. "Science is incompetent to reason upon the creation of matter itself out of nothing. We have reached the utmost limits of our thinking faculties when we have admitted that because matter cannot be eternal and self-existent it must have been created. " You will admit that, in the light of all that has transpired in the thirty-five years since Maxwell used these words, science has advanced far. The concluding words of the address are even more striking from this point of view. 222 COMPLEXITY OF ATOMS " Natural causes, as we know, are at work, which tend to modify, if they do not at length destroy, all the arrangements and dimensions of the earth and the whole solar system. But though in the course of ages catastrophes have occurred and may yet occur in the heavens, though ancient systems may be dissolved and new systems evolved out of their ruins, the molecules out of which these systems are built — the foundation-stones of the material universe — remain unbroken and unworn." Before we dwell upon the modifications that have been made in this point of view, let us rather con- sider the chief basis of the argument, namely, that all the atoms of any one element are exactly alike. On this fundamental question the evidence to-day is far more complete and striking than it was in 1873, an d we believe more firmly than ever in the absolute similarity of all the atoms of the same element. We no longer regard the atom as a simple thing. On the contrary, we now look upon it as an almost infinitely complex piece of mechanism. The late Professor Rowland, of Baltimore, once made the remark that a grand piano must be a very simple piece of mechanism compared with an atom of iron. For in the spectrum of iron there is an almost innumerable wealth of separate bright lines, each one of which corresponds to a sharp definite period of vibration of the iron atom. Instead of AND THEIR SIMILARITY 223 the hundred-odd sound vibrations which a grand piano can emit, the single iron atom appears to emit many thousands of definite light vibrations. Two pianos would be regarded as in perfect tune together when there was a comparatively rough approximation of period between the various notes. Whereas by the spectroscope a difference in " tune " or period in the vibrations emitted by different atoms of only one part in many millions would be easily detectable, and no such variation exists. In a similar vein Professor Schuster, referring to the broad teachings of the spectroscope, has compared the atoms of the same element to an innumerable number of clocks all wound and regulated to go at the same period. If all these clocks were set at the same time, not one of them would vary by a single second even after many days. No clockmaker could make such clocks. Yet these almost infinitely complicated pieces of mechanism we call atoms are turned out by Nature with such undeviating accu- racy and fidelity that in all the myriads in existence there are less than a hundred different kinds known. We can, however, from the point of view of recent researches in radioactivity, push this idea even one step further, to the case of atoms actually in the condition of breaking up. We have seen that it is a property of the a-rays to possess a 224 VELOCITIES OF THE a PARTICLES very sharp and definite range. In a beam of homogeneous o-rays passing through a homoge- neous absorbing medium the number of a-particles suffers little or no diminution until the extreme end of the path is reached, and then they cease altogether. Just without the extreme range, there is absolutely no effect perceptible, while just within this range, the effect, per small element of path, is at the maximum. Every a-particle expelled from the radio-element in the same change travels exactly the same distance before it ceases to be detectable, and, as Rutherford has shown by direct measurement of the magnetic and electric devia- tion, is expelled at the same velocity. In the table following, the approximate initial velocities of the a-particles from the changes in the uranium series have been collected, together with their " ranges " or distances in millimetres they will penetrate in air at 15 C. and 760 mm. of mercury pressure. Velocity a-PARTICLE FROM (miles per secor id). Range. Uranium I ... • • ■ 8,8oo • • • 25 Uranium II * • • • ■ • 9>3°° • • * i 29 Ionium • • ■ • • 9,400 • • • 1 3«> Radium » • • * • 9,600 • • • 33 Emanation . • • • • * 10,400 • • • 42 Radium A t • • • • • 10,900 a • • 47'S Radium C • ■ • • • 1 2,400 ■ • • 1 69-5 Radium F • • • • • 10,200 * • • 377 The atom thus retains its role of a perfect MATERIAL EVOLUTION 225 piece of mechanism even up to and during the moment of its dissolution. So exactly alike are all the atoms of the same radioactive element, that when the break-up occurs the velocity with which the fragments of the atom, or a-particles, are ex- pelled is exactly the same in each case. We may liken the disintegration of an element to the burst- ing of shells, in which the fragments of the different shells all are expelled with the same velocity. Certainly no shells ever constructed would answer this requirement. Truly, in the words of Sir John Herschel, thfe atom bears the essential character of a manufactured article, but of a degree of per- fection humanly unattainable. But with regard to the process of manufacture and of the cause of this undeviating fidelity to a few types, what a revolution of thought has taken place in the last few years ! The evolution, or rather devolution, of matter, its continuous change, the generation and destruction of atoms — all of the things which seemed impossible in Clerk Max- well's day — we know to be going on before our eyes. It is true the processes call for periods of time so vast, even in the most favourable cases, that the physicist of a generation ago would have dismissed them as physically inconceivable. Yet these periods are to-day actually determined by direct measurement in the laboratory. Q 226 CONNECTION BETWEEN PERIOD Before leaving this question a very interesting development may be mentioned, which has resulted in a connection being established between the ranges or velocities of the various types of «-rays, and the periods of life of the atoms from which they are derived. As a general rule — not, it is true, entirely without exceptions, but possibly the exceptions may prove to be only apparent — the more rapidly a radioactive substance disintegrates, or the shorter its period of average life, the greater is the velocity with which the a-particle is expelled from the atom, and the greater therefore is the range of the a-particle. Thus, the most stable radio-elements, uranium and thorium, give a-rays having the lowest ranges, and the low range of the a-rays of ionium is additional evidence that its period must be very long. The greatest ranges occur in the short-lived " active deposit" products. The very long ranges of the a-rays of radium C (69*5 mm.), and of the corres- ponding thorium C (86 mm.), is generally explained by the supposition that the real atoms giving these rays have periods of the order of only a millionth of a second, and therefore that it is impossible to separate them from their parents, which thus appear to be giving rays which in reality come from their products. Two actual cases of such a sequence will be considered in the last chapter. Latterly, this generalisation has been put into stricter form by the AND RANGE OF a-RAYS 227 discovery that if the logarithm of the period is plotted against the logarithm of the range or of the velocity, straight lines result for each of the three known disintegration series. The three straight lines are parallel to but not identical with one another. The reason for this is still obscure. Some mathe- matical connection exists between the two quantities, and that is all that can yet be said. On the other hand, it has been found possible to calculate some of the unknown periods — like that of ionium, so estimated at 200,000 years, for example — from the ranges of the a-rays by means of this relation. For long it was known that uranium was exceptional in that it appeared to give out two a-particles per atom disintegrating instead of one, as in all other cases. A very careful investigation revealed the fact that the ranges of these two sets of a-particles were not exactly alike. One set, those from uranium I, presumably, have a range of 25 mm., and the other set, those from its shorter- lived product, uranium II, presumably, a range of 29 mm. The period corresponding with 29 mm. of range is, in the uranium series, two million years, and this is the main evidence for believing that such a product, uranium II as it is called, exists, and that it has so far not been separated from uranium because of the identity of the chemical properties of the two elements. 228 MATERIAL EVOLUTION Instead of regarding the hundred or less ele- ments which exist to-day as manufactured, created, once for all time, we rather regard them as existing because they have survived. All other forms less stable than those we recognise as elements have been weeded out. Over sufficiently great periods of time the rarity or abundance of an element must be controlled by its degree of instability or stability. Probably for every stable atom many unstable ones could be, even are being, formed. But only the stable forms can accumu- late in quantity and become known to us as ordinary chemical elements. We have seen that the rarest of such in all probability must have a period of thousands of millions of years, while for the more common elements, if they are chang- ing at all, periods of billions of years may be anticipated. At first glance only, the material universe gives the impression of a permanent and finished creation. In reality the now familiar remorseless operation of slow, continuous change moulds even "the foundation-stones" themselves. By this last step the doctrine of evolution has become universal, embracing alike the animate and inanimate worlds. But whereas in the former slight changes of environment effect the profoundest modifications, in the latter the controlling factors still remain MATERIAL EVOLUTION 229 absolutely unknown. By the spectroscope a partial material survey of the whole universe has been rendered possible, and what we find is every- where an essential similarity of composition. For example, there is no evidence that in the sun or stars large quantities of elements unknown to us exist. The reason why some atoms are stable and others are not is a mystery we have not yet begun to probe. Yet this question, to us only of academic interest and possibly some- what remote at that, will, as we shall soon come to see, be one of life and death to the inheritors of our civilisation. CHAPTER XI. Why is radium unique among the elements ? — Its rate of change only makes it remarkable — Uranium is more wonderful than radium — The energy stored up in a pound of uranium — Transmutation is the key to the internal energy of matter — The futility of ancient alchemy — The consequences if transmutation were possible — Primitive man and the art of kindling fire — Modern man and the problem of transmutation — Cosmical evolution and atomic dis- integration — Radioactivity and geology — Quantity of radium in the earth's crust — The earth probably not a cooling globe — The geological age and the incandescent age — Ancient mythology and radioactivity — The serpent "Ouroboros" — The "Philosopher's Stone " and the u Elixir of Life "—The " Fall of Man " and the " Ascent of Man " — The great extension in the possible duration of past time — Radium and the struggle for existence — Existence as a struggle for physical energy — The new prospect. • THIS interpretation of radium is drawing to a close, but perhaps the more generally interesting part of it remains to be dealt with. We have steadily followed out the idea of atomic disintegration to its logical conclusions, so far as they can at present be drawn, and we have found it able to account for all the surprising discoveries that have been made in radioactivity, and capable of predicting many, and perhaps even 230 WHY RADIUM IS UNIQUE 231 more unexpected, new ones. Let us from the point of vantage we have gained return to the starting - point of our inquiries and see what a profound change has come over it since the riddle has been read. Radium, a new element, giving out light and heat like Aladdin's lamp, apparently defying the law of the conservation of energy, and raising questions in physical science which seemed unanswerable, is no longer the radium we know. But although its mystery has vanished, its significance and importance have vastly gained At first we were compelled to regard it as unique, dowered with potentialities and exhibiting pecu- liarities which raised it far above the ordinary run of common matter. The matter was the mere vehicle of ultra- material powers. If we now ask, why is radium so unique among the elements, the answer is not because it is dowered with any ex- ceptional potentialities or because it contains any abnormal store of internal energy which other elements do not possess, but simply and solely because it is changing comparatively rapidly, whereas the elements before known are either changing not at all or so slowly that the change has been unperceived. At first sight this might seem an anti-climax. Yet it is not so. The truer view is that this one element has clothed with its own dignity the whole empire of common 232 WHY RADIUM IS UNIQUE matter. The aspect which matter has presented to us in the past is but a consummate disguise, con- cealing latent energies and hidden activities beneath an hitherto impenetrable mask. The ultra-material potentialities of radium are the common possession of all that world to which in our ignorance we used to refer as mere inanimate matter. This is the weightiest lesson the existence of radium has taught us, and it remains to consider the easy but remorseless reasoning by which the conclusion is arrived at. Two considerations will make the matter clear. In the first place, the radioactivity of radium at any moment is, strictly speaking, not a property of the mass of the radium at all, although it is proportional to the mass. The whole of the new set of properties is contributed by a very small fraction of the whole, namely, the part which is actually disintegrating at the moment of observa- tion. The whole of the rest of the radium is as quiescent and inactive as any other non -radioactive element. In its whole chemical nature it is an ordinary element. The new properties are not contributed at all by the main part of the matter, but only by the minute fraction actually at the moment disintegrating. THE ENERG Y IN URANIUM 233 Let us next compare and contrast radium with its first product, the emanation, and with its original parent, uranium. Uranium on the one hand, and the emanation on the other, represent, compared with radium, diametrically opposed extremes. Uranium is changing so slowly that it will last for thousands of millions of years, the emanation so rapidly that it lasts only a few weeks, while radium is intermediate with a period of average life of two thousand five hundred years. We have seen that in many ways the emanation is far more wonderful than radium, as the rate its energy is given out is relatively far greater. But this is compensated for by the far shorter time its activity lasts. Also, if we compared uranium with radium, we should say at once that radium is far more wonderful than the uranium, whereas in reality it is not so, as the uranium, changing almost infinitely more slowly, lasts almost infinitely longer. The arresting character of radium is to be ascribed solely to the rate at which it happens to be disintegrating. The common element uranium, well known to chemists for a century before its radioactivity was suspected, is in reality even more wonderful. It is only very feebly radioactive, and therefore is changing excessively slowly, but it changes, we believe, into radium, 234 THE ENERG Y IN URANIUM expelling several a-particles and so evolving large amounts of energy in the process. Uranium is a heavier element than radium, and the relative weights of the two atoms, which is a measure of their complexity, is as 238 is to 226. This bottle contains about a pound of an oxide of uranium which contains about seven-eighths of its weight of the element uranium. In the course of the next few thousand million years, so far as we can tell, it will change, producing over thirteen ounces of radium, and, in that change into radium alone, energy is given out, as radioactive energy, aggre- gating of itself an enormous total, while the radium produced will also change, giving out a further enormous aggregate quantity of energy. So that uranium, since it produces radium, con- tains all the energy contained in a but slightly smaller quantity of radium and more. It may be estimated that uranium evolves during com- plete disintegration some thirteen per cent, more energy than is evolved from the same weight of radium. But what are we to say about the other heavy elements — lead, bismuth, mercury, gold, platinum, etc. — although their atoms are not quite so heavy as uranium or radium, and although none of them, so far as we yet know, are disintegrating at all ? Is this enormous internal store of energy confined to the radioactive elements, that is to THE INTERNAL ENERGY OF ALL MATTER 235 the few which, however slowly, are actually chang- ing? Not at all, in all probability. Regarded merely as chemical elements between radioactive elements and non-radioactive elements, there exists so complete a parallelism that we cannot regard the radioactive elements as peculiar in possessing this internal store of energy, but only as peculiar in evolving it at a perceptible rate. Radium especially is so completely analogous in its whole chemical nature, and even in the character of its spectrum, to the non-radioactive elements, barium, strontium, and calcium, that chemists at once placed radium in the same family as these latter, and the value of its atomic weight confirms the arrangement in the manner required by the Periodic Law. It appears rather that this in- ternal store of energy we learned of for the first time in connection with radium is possessed to greater or lesser degree by all elements in common and is part and parcel of their internal structure. Let us, however, for the sake of conciseness, leave out of account altogether the non-radioactive elements, of which as yet we know nothing cer- tainly. At least we cannot escape from the conclusion that the particular element uranium has relatively more energy stored up within it 236 USEFUL AND USELESS ENERGY even than radium. Uranium is a comparatively common element. The world's output per year is to be reckoned in tens of tons. I have already referred to the total amount of energy evolved by radium during the course of its complete change. It is about 360,000 times as much energy as is evolved from the same weight of coal in burning. The energy evolved from uranium would be some thirteen per cent, greater than from the same weight of radium. This bottle contains about one pound of uranium oxide, and therefore about fourteen ounces of uranium. Its value is about £1. Is it not wonderful to reflect that in this little bottle there lies asleep and waiting to be evolved the energy of at least one hundred and sixty tons of coal ? The energy in a ton of uranium would be sufficient to light London for a year. The store of energy in uranium would be worth a thousand times as much as theuranium itself, if only it were under our control and could be harnessed to do the world's work in the same way as the energy in coal has been harnessed and controlled. There is, it is true, plenty of energy in the world which is practically valueless. The energy of the tides and of the waste heat from steam fall into this category as useless and low-grade energy. But the internal energy of uranium is not of this kind. The difficulty is of quite another character. THE PROBLEM OF TRANSMUTATION 237 As we have seen, we cannot yet artificially ac- celerate or influence the rate of disintegration of an element, and therefore the energy in uranium, which requires a thousand million years to be evolved, is practically valueless. On the other hand, to increase the natural rate, and to break down uranium or any other element artificially, is simply transmutation. If we could accomplish the one so we could the other. These two great problems, at once the oldest and the newest in science, are one. Transmutation of the elements carries with it the power to unlock the internal energy of matter, and the unlocking of the internal stores of energy in matter would, strangely enough, be infinitely the most important and valuable con- sequence of transmutation. Let us consider in the light of present knowledge the problem of transmutation, and see what the attempt of the alchemist involved. To build up an ounce of a heavy element like gold from a lighter element like silver would require in all probability the expenditure of the energy of some hundreds of tons of coal, so that the ounce of gold would be dearly bought. On the other hand, if it were possible artificially to disintegrate an element with a heavier atom than gold and produce gold from it, so great an amount of energy would probably be 238 THE PROBLEM OF TRANSMUTATION evolved that the gold in comparison would be of little account. The energy would be far more valuable than the gold. Although we are as ignor- ant as ever of how to set about transmutation, it cannot be denied that the knowledge recently gained constitutes a very great help towards a proper understanding of the problem and its ulti- mate accomplishment. We see clearly the magnitude of the task and the insufficiency of even the most powerful of the means at our disposal in a way not before appreciated, and we have now a clear per- ception of the tremendous issues at stake. Looking backwards at the great things science has already accomplished, and at the steady growth in power and fruitfulness of scientific method, it can scarcely be doubted that one day we shall come to break down and build up elements in the laboratory as we now break down and build up compounds, and the pulses of the world will then throb with a new source of strength as immeasurably re- moved from any we at present control as they in turn are from the natural resources of the human savage. It is, indeed, a strange situation we are confronted with. The first step in the long, upward journey out of barbarism to civilisation which man has ac- complished appears to have been the art of kindling THE ART OF KINDLING FIRE 239 fire. Those savage races who remain ignorant of this art are regarded as on the very lowest plane. The art of kindling fire is the first step towards the control and utilisation of those natural stores of energy on which civilisation even now absolutely depends. Primitive man existed entirely on the day-to-day supply of sunlight for his vital energy, before he learned how to kindle fire for himself. One can imagine before this occurred that he became acquainted with fire and its properties from naturally occurring conflagrations. With reference to the newly recognised internal stores of energy in matter we stand to-day where primitive man first stood with regard to the energy liberated by fire. We are aware of its existence solely from the naturally occurring manifestations in radioactivity. At the climax of that civilisation the first step of which was taken in forgotten ages by primitive man, and just when it is becoming apparent that its ever-increasing needs cannot in- definitely be borne by the existing supplies of energy, possibilities of an entirely new material civilisation are dawning with respect to which we find ourselves still on the lowest plane— that of on- lookers with no power to interfere. The energy which we require for our very existence, and which Nature supplies us with but grudgingly and in none too generous measure for our needs, is in 2 4 o KEY TO THE NEW STORES OF ENERGY reality locked up in immense stores in the matter all around us, but the power to control and use it is not yet ours. What sources of energy we can and do use and control, we now regard as but the merest leavings of Nature's primary supplies. The very existence of the latter till now have remained unknown and unsuspected. When we have learned how to transmute the elements at will the one into the other, then, and not till then, will the key to this hidden treasure-house of Nature be in our hands. At present we have no hint of how even to begin the quest. The question has frequently been discussed whether transmutation, so impossible to us, is not actually going on under the transcendental condi- tions obtaining in the sun and the stars. We have seen that it is actually going on in the world under our eyes in a few special cases and at a very slow rate. The possibility now under consideration, how- ever, is rather that it may be going on universally or at least much more generally, and at a much more rapid rate under celestial than under terrestrial con- ditions. From the new point of view it may be said at once that if it were so, many of the difficulties previously experienced in accounting for the enor- mous and incessant dissipation of energy throughout the universe would disappear. WORLD- CUE All AG INFLUENCES 241 Last century has wrought a great change in scientific thought as to the nature of the gigantic forces which have moulded the world to its present form and which regulated the march of events throughout the universe. At one time it was cus- tomary to regard the evolution of the globe as the result of a succession in the past times of mighty cataclysms and catastrophes beside which the erup- tions of a Krakatoa or Petee would be insignificant. Now, however, we regard the main process of moulding as due rather to ever-present, continuous, and irresistible actions, which, though operating so slowly that over short periods of time their effect is imperceptible, yet in the epochs of the cosmical calendar effected changes so great and complete that the present features of the globe are but a passing incident of a continually shifting scene. Into the arena of these silent world-creating and destroying influences and processes has entered a new-comer — "Radioactivity" — and it has not re- quired long before it has come to be recognised that in the discovery of radioactivity, or rather of the sub-atomic powers and processes of which radio- activity is merely the outward and visible manifesta- tion, we have penetrated one of Natures innermost secrets. Whether or no the processes of continuous atomic disintegration bulk largely in the scheme 242 ULTIMATE SOURCE OF COSMICAL ENERGY of cosmical evolution, at least it cannot be gain- said that these processes are at once powerful enough and slow enough to furnish a sufficient and satisfactory explanation of the origin of those perennial outpourings of energy by virtue of which the universe to-day is a going concern rather than a cold, lifeless collocation of extinct worlds. Slow, irresistible, incessant, unalterable, so apparently feeble that it has been reserved to the genera- tion in which we live to discover, the processes of radioactivity, when translated in terms of a more extended scale of space and time, appear already as though they well may be the ultimate controlling factors of physical evolution. For slow processes of this kind do the effective work of Nature, and the occasional intermittent displays of Plutonic activity correspond merely to the creaking now and again of an otherwise silent mechanism that never stops. It is one of the most pleasing features of this new work that geologists have been among the very first to recognise the applicability and importance of it in their science. I am not competent to deal adequately with or discuss the geological problems that it has raised. But this story would be incom- plete if I did not refer, though it must be but briefly, to the labours of Professor Strutt who initiated RADIUM IN ROCKS 243 the movement and to those of Professor Joly who has carried it on. These workers carried out careful analyses of the representative rocks in the earth's crust for the amount of radium they con- tained Absolutely, the quantity of radium in com- mon rocks is* of course very small, although with the refined methods now at the disposal of investigators it is quite measurable. The important fact which has transpired, however, is that the rocks examined contain on the average much larger quantities of radium, and therefore necessarily of its original parent uranium, than might be expected. The amount of heat which finds its way in a given time from the interior of the globe to the surface and thence outwards into external space has long been accurately known. Strutt concluded that if there existed only a comparatively thin crust of rocks less than fifty miles thick of the same composition, as regards the content of radium, as the average of those he examined, the radium in them would supply the whole of the heat lost by the globe to outer space. He concluded that the surface rocks must form such a thin crust, and that the interior of the globe must be an entirely different kind of material, free from the presence of radium. Other- wise the world would be much hotter inside than is known to be the case. So far then as the earth is concerned, a quantity of radium less than in all probability actually exists would supply all the heat *44 RADIOACTIVITY lost to outer space. So that there is no difficulty in accounting for the necessary source of heat to main- tain the existing conditions of temperature on the earth over a period of past time as long as the uranium which produces the radium lasts, that is to say, for a period of thousands of millions of years. Professor Joly in his interesting work, " Radio- activity and Geology," has considered in detail some of the consequences of the existence of radioactive materials in the earth. One of the specific instances is the effect of the radium in the rocks of the Simplon Tunnel in producing the unexpectedly high tempera- tures there encountered. From a radioactive analysis of these rocks he came to the conclusion that without undue assumptions it is possible to explain the differ- ences in the temperature of the rocks encountered in boring the tunnel by the differences in their radium content. The presence in the rock of a proportion amounting to a few million millionths of radium above the normal quantity very nearly wrecked the whole enterprise. From the importance of radio- activity in this instance, of a tunnel a few miles long bored through a mountain, some idea may be obtained of the significance of the new discoveries in the general problem of the thermal condition of the interior of the globe. Since Strutt's original work, it has been established that not only radium, AND GEOLOGY 245 but all the other radioactive materials, including the whole thorium disintegration series, must contribute an important quantity of heat, so that his estimate of a crust only fifty miles thick is in reality too great, and a much thinner crust would suffice. Joly has had the courage to push the argument to its logical conclusion, and has supposed that the radio- active materials are not confined to a thin surface crust, but are equally distributed throughout the globe in much the same proportions as they are in the crust If this is so, there is no escape from the conclusion that the interior of the earth, so far from gradually parting with its heat and cooling down, must actually be getting steadily hotter. The heat generated within, even after the lapse of hundreds of millions of years, would scarcely appreciably escape from the surface, for, as Lord Kelvin deduced, the central core of the earth must be almost insulated thermally from the surface, owing to the low con- ductivity of the rocks composing the crust. He assumes throughout an average composition of the globe of two parts of radium per million million, which is considerably below the average he found for the rocks of the crust, and he calculates that in the course of a hundred million years this minute quantity will produce a rise of the temperature of the central core of no less than i,8oo° C. Unless, therefore, this heat is utilised in some unknown 246 THE GEOLOGICAL AND way, or the disintegration of the radio-elements is prevented by the high temperature and pressure, the ultimate fate of the globe must be very much as depicted in the Biblical tradition. Sooner or later the crust must succumb to the ever increasing pressure within, and the earth must become again, what it is supposed once to have been, a vastly swollen globe of incandescent gas. As Joly remarks, there is no evidence that this has not already occurred more than once, nor assurance that it will not recur. So far as physical science yet can deduce, the accumulation of thermal energy within a world containing elements undergoing atomic disintegra- tion during the " geological age" must alternate with a state of things which might be termed " the incandescent age," in which this accumulated energy is dissipated by radiation. This periodic cycle of changes must continue until the elements in question have disintegrated — that is, over a period which radioactive measurements indicate is of the order of tens or hundreds of thousands of millions of years. During the incandescent age the loss of heat by radiation, which increases according to the fourth power of the temperature, is immensely greater than could be supplied even by atomic disintegration. Thus, if the known laws hold, it is certain that the present loss of heat of the sun cannot be supplied by the presence of radium. For this to be the case a very large part of the sun's mass must consist of THE INCANDESCENT AGES 247 uranium, and this we know from the spectroscope is very improbable. Still, it is by no means to be concluded that the heat of the sun and stars is not in the first place of internal rather than, as has been the custom to regard it, of external origin. As soon as sufficient of the heat energy of the sun has been radiated away for a solid crust to form, the poor thermal conductivity of this crust at once reduces the radiation loss to a negligible figure again, a fresh geological age is inaugurated, and again the heat accumulates within. This view, that the elements contain within themselves the energy from which Nature obtains her primary supplies, and that in cosmical time "geological age" and " incandescent age " alternate as the night and day, however imperfect it may still be, is at least more in harmony with existing knowledge than the older conventional view that the universe was wound up once for all in the beginning like a clock to go for a certain time, for the most part quietly and unevent- fully, pursuing its allotted path towards ultimate physical stagnation and death. But what a picture it conjures up of life and of the precariousness of its tenure — from its lowest beginnings to its highest evolution, not a permanent accomplishment, but a process to be inaugurated and consummated afresh, if at all, between the ending and beginning of each new cosmical day ! 248 COSMIC AL EVOLUTION To escape from this conclusion it is necessary to suppose that atomic disintegration is cosmically not the inevitable uncontrollable process it has hitherto been proved to be under all laboratory conditions, but that under conditions of pressure and tempera- ture, such as exist in the inferior of a world, it may either be stopped altogether, or compensated for by unknown complementary processes of atomic syn- thesis in which energy is taken up. Be that as it may, our outlook on the physical universe has been permanently altered. We are no longer the inhabitants of a universe slowly dying from the physical exhaustion of its energy, but of a universe which has in the internal energy of its material components the means to rejuvenate itself perennially over immense periods of time, inter- mittently and catastrophically, which is the first possibility that presents itself, or continuously and in orderly fashion, if there exist compensating phenomena still outside the ken of science. The world probably being of much greater antiquity than physical science has thought to be possible, it is interesting and harmless to speculate whether man has shared with the world its more remote history. In this connection it is curious how strangely some of the old myths and legends about matter and man appear in the light of the recent knowledge. OLD LEGENDS RECALLED 249 Consider, for example, the ancient mystic symbol of matter, known as Ouroboros — " the tail devourer " — which was a serpent, coiled into a circle with the head devouring the tail, and bearing the central motto, "The whole is one." This symbolises evolution ; moreover, it is evolution of matter — the very latest aspect of evolution — the existence of which was strenuously denied by Clerk Maxwell and others of only last century. The idea which arises in one's mind as the most attractive and consistent explanation of the universe in the light of present knowledge is, perhaps, that matter is breaking down and its energy being evolved and degraded in one part of a cycle of evolution, and in another part, still unknown to us, the matter is being again built up with the utilisation of the waste energy If one wished to symbolise such an idea, in what better way could it be done than by the ancient tail- devouring serpent ? Some of the beliefs and legends which have come down to us from antiquity are so universal and deep-rooted that we are accustomed to consider them almost as old as the race itself. One is tempted to inquire how far the unsuspected apt- ness of some of these beliefs and sayings to the point of view so recently disclosed is the result of mere chance or coincidence, and how far it may be evidence of a wholly unknown and unsuspected 250 THE ELIXIR OF LIFE ancient civilisation of which all other relic has dis- appeared It is curious to reflect, for example, upon the remarkable legend of the philosophers stone, one of the oldest and most universal beliefs, the origin of which, however far back we penetrate into the records of the past, we do not probably trace to its real source. The philosopher's stone was accredited the power not only of transmuting the metals, but of acting as the elixir of life. Now, whatever the origin of this apparently meaningless jumble of ideas may have been, it is really a perfect and but very slightly allegorical expression of the actual present views we hold to-day. It does not require much effort of the imagination to see in energy the life of the physical universe, and the key to the primary fountains of the physical life of the universe to-day is known to be transmuta- tion. Is then this old association of the power of transmutation with the elixir of life merely a coincidence ? I prefer to believe it may be an echo from one of many previous epochs in the unre- corded history of the world, of an age of men which have trod before the road we are treading to-day, in a past possibly so remote that even the very atoms of its civilisation literally have had time to disintegrate. Let us give the imagination a moment's further free scope in this direction, however, before closing. THE FALL AND ASCENT OF MAN 351 What if this point of view that has now suggested itself is true, and we may trust ourselves to the slender foundation afforded by the traditions and superstitions which have been handed down to us from a prehistoric time ? Can we not read into them some justification for the belief that some former forgotten race of men attained not only to the knowledge we have so recently won, but also to the power that is not yet ours ? Science has reconstructed the story of the past as one of a con- tinuous Ascent of Man to the present-day level of his powers. In face of the circumstantial evidence existing of this steady upward progress of the race, the traditional view of the Fall of Man from a higher former state has come to be more and more difficult to understand. From our new standpoint the two points of view are by no means so irrecon- cilable as they appeared. A race which could transmute matter would have little need to earn its bread by the sweat of its brow. If we can judge from what our engineers accomplish with their comparatively restricted supplies of energy, such a race could transform a desert continent, thaw the frozen poles, and make the whole world one smiling Garden of Eden. Possibly they could explore the outer realms of space, emigrating to more favour- able worlds as the superfluous to-day emigrate to more favourable continents. The legend of the 252 THE NEW PROSPECT Fall of Man, possibly, may be all that has survived of such a time before, for some unknown reason, the whole world was plunged back again under the undisputed sway of Nature, to begin once more its upward toilsome journey through the ages. The vistas of new thought which have opened out in all directions in the physical sciences, to which man is merely incidental and external, must in turn react powerfully upon those departments of thought in which man is central and supreme. We find our- selves in consequence of the progress of physical science at the pinnacle of one ascent of civilisation, taking the first step upwards out on to the lowest plane of the next. Above us still rises indefinitely the ascent to physical power — far beyond the dreams of mortals in any previous system of philosophy. These possibilities of a newer order of things, of a more exalted material destiny than any which have been foretold, are not the promise of another world. They exist in this, to be fought and struggled for in the old familiar way, to be wrung from the grip of Nature, as all our achievements and civilisation have, in the past, been wrung by the labour of the collective brain of mankind guiding, directing, and multiplying the individual's puny power. This is the message of hope and inspiration to the race which radium has contributed to the great problems of existence. No attempt at presentation of this THE NEW PROSPECT 253 new subject could be considered complete which did not, however imperfectly, suggest something of this side. It is fitting to attempt to see how far purely physical considerations will take us in delimiting the major controlling influences which regulate our existence. Surveying the long chequered, but on the whole continuous, ascent of man from primeval conditions to the summit of his present-day powers, what has it all been at bottom but a fight with Nature for energy — for that ordinary physical energy of which we have said so much ? Physical science sums up accurately in that one generalisation the most funda- mental aspect of life in the sense already defined. Of course life depends also on a continual supply of matter as well as on a continual supply of energy, but the struggle for physical energy is probably the more fundamental and general aspect of existence in all its forms. The same matter, the same chemical elements, serve the purposes of life over and over again, but the supply of fresh energy must be con- tinuous. By the law of the availability of energy, which, whether universal or not, applies universally within our own experience, the transformations of energy which occur in Nature are invariably in the one direction, the more available forms pass- ing into the waste and useless unavailable kind, and this process, so far as we yet know, is never reversed. I 254 THE NEW PROSPECT The same energy is available but once The struggle for existence is at the bottom a continuous struggle for fresh physical energy. This is as far as the knowledge available last century went What is now the case? Th 233-7. 259. 260, 266 — Average life of, 162, 174 — Production of helium from, 138-40 — and radium. Connection be- tween, 173-88 Uranium I and II, 180, 212, 226, 260, 268 — X, 179-82, 188, 259 and ionium, Connection between, 188 Vacua, High, 72, 74 Value, Gold, physical explanation to account for the unchang- ing. 217 — of radium, 25, 26, 215 Velocities, Ultra-material, 88 Velocity of cathode-ray particle, 81 — of light, 53, 81 Visible, Making the paths of rays, 90-1 Volume of helium in minerals, 135 — emanation in equilibrium with radium, 114, 165 W Wave theory of light, 55 Wkytlaw-Gray, R. t 118 Willemite, 50, 74, 76, 108, 109, 112 Wilson, C. T. R., 89 Writing by radium, 25 X-rays, 9, 42, 44, 53, 109 Z Zinc sulphide, 50, no, 197, 269, 271, 275, 278 BILLING AND SONS, LTD., PRINTERS, GUILDFORD 13 RETURN CIRCULATION DEPARTMENT TO—* 202 Main Library LOAN PERIOD 1 HOME USE 2 : 3 4 5 < b AU tOOKS MAY If RECALLED AFTER 7 DAYS Rofftowols md Roclioroos inoy do ntodo 4 ooys prior fo fno ooo oofo* looks may bo ionowod by coiling 442-3409 DUE AS STAMPED B&O W MAR 011994 * ,1^3-1 FORM NO. DD6 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY BERKELEY, CA 94720 et U.C. BERKELEY LIBRARIES C021A00A0?