Project Sign: Technical Report (February 1949) U.S. Air Force, Air Materiel Command, 1949 ======================================================================== PROVENANCE NOTE (Tower of Babel staging): The declassified February 1949 Project Sign technical report — the Air Force's first formal UFO study: the documentary origin of the government's flying-saucer file. Source: Internet Archive (https://archive.org/details/ProjectSIGN). This 1949 publication is in the public domain in the United States. ======================================================================== ttohnlftO* Rapcrt »>r TmDocnnsii'ABaa. objects PROJECT •SIGH* J g: -• is 6 JBCT *SBS9^ L. K. temttan k. B. teytraend. (SVojsct «o. 3-^} AppVOTVd tQ'l >i-W* «mW>*Cw TttfiBlCBl Division lQteUi««Do* Air Oat«l»X Cwud A^Ums D«t«t s Air Fvoa BW| Ikrtaa, Ohio Fafarimr I9i49 ^Ncussifieo’ 3-U750 AT 5 IhTTERVALSl .2 years. . • DOD Dii; 6800.10 . . ^. . yittas- J|fC •= 'v: * ^ . :*- '-? ^.*-'::«^.--rt. UNcw£s;r ;eo i d*9erlptlY« and aMlftioaX itudy of the unidentified aerial objeota, that have been reported both In the tfettod Statea and froB foreign oountrtea, la praaeoted. Indleidual oatea are deaortbed In brief fbrta» aa an appendix. Tha analjtloal treat»ant of bhe aubjaot la largely of a qnalltatlre and genarallaod nature. Hoiaeeer, detailed analyaet and detailed* reaulta ara preaentad* ahar# thla proeadure la poaal* ble a«^ Bill aialat In aatabllahlng tha validity or tenahlllty of an ovarall hypbtheala* Projaet •sign" U atlll largely aharaotarltad by tha oollaa- tlon of data, without aufflelairt infonoatlon to penal t definite, apeolfla aonelualona to be nade. lo definite evidence la yat ^vstlahle to eonfliwi ©r dlaprove the aotual axlatanoa of ualdeo- . tiflad flying objaota aa new and unknown typaa of alroraft. A Unitad nu^er of the Inoldenta have been Identified aa known ob* jaota. yNClASSIRED 3^11750 i- .Ml Project "Sign" w iD^tlctcd by the i^ifiliS^SSSoA DlYlelcn, Air Mct^lcl Oomaod, end CAClgned Pro jeet « wbe^ xa-504 €fi Jefitjcry l«4S» under authority of c Xetter fron.the Deputy Chief of Steff, ■eterlel. JJUT. .fhXe lottar is referenced 0/5, 05AP, 50 Decetfeer 1947» subject *Flying Dlshs. ' Aesietence In eAslyslng the reported provided by other DlTlilooe of Air lUterlel Co««d vlth JTe^inlosl Inetruetlone tI-2186, Addeodun to. sry ntt, aubJeetJ “Project 8lp»“ - Beelustlon of Itoldentlfled Flytoi^bjects*. AnsIysU of the reported Incldeote, es “ Mtro-phyilc 4 l ph«o*ene. le being eoooi^^llehed by Cmto Stete DnlversUy uadeP ccotruot with Air Us ter lei Cowssnd. i .p.ol.1 .tud, h.. »,?•. initiated Jh. B»d Projdot Id th. r.»t. p«.i- billty thst 10*0 of the oboerred objeots asy be speoe ahlps or sstellite Vehicles. ' ■' Keabere of the Scientific Adelsory Board to the Chief 'of Stuff* BSAF{ hove, slao supplied their eervloee.ln s ^onoultlng cepsolty. UNCLASSiFlED 5-U7S0 • . t < J^NCLAG^FiED TwtttcayvcTZcm ** - - -a»-C««fV7UJ.'r29.»*ir* Tht* p«tfW in written to present th# atetue of work n.ncow^ln-hnd on Project "31^-, to at«rlte the on aliitlatfa of oinlientlfleh werlal objeeta, to review ^e pot^da eoi reaaoninff tpplled In thw evnlnntlon of the data, and awt the peaulta'ao faj* obtained^l^B' the atudy of data available. It la not expeoted that tbla report can present a final ea- Uaate of the altuatloo regarding all f The data la atlll being atudlad by apeolallata - aatrophyaloa and pajohology. and fppther In for pat ^ letfted to enable peraonnel evaluating project to detePBine poaalble explanation# o'^ aoae the How aver, the pep^t will furnlah Inforaptlon on the preaeat state of the Ifiv watt get Ion to ataff peraonnel In this Headquartera and In higher eohelona, and to othept who are required to aaaasa the poialblllty of a threat to national ;;«urJty alghtlng of inch large nu*be* i of unidentified ^lylng ebjosta. vV r y S-ll7io 4 SnoURT Ti>6 reaulta of th^ «tudy In tM» p®pdrft on d»tft d<%Pl«d fpoa repopts or 845 domestic and thJpty (30) roralM Ineldanta. Data fpoia tb«a« looJdanta la balng. autearlsed, pepro- duaad and dlatrlbutad to pandas and individual a coopepatlnv In tbj ^alyala and a valuation. DlitHbutlon haa so far baan aeooaw pdahad on tha auvartaa of tdA inaldonta and nora aP« In prooaaa of rappoduottnn at thla ^ A aback list of ttaeia to ba not^d In rapoptlng Ineldanta haa baan prepaid and dlatplbutod to gova^bnant Invaatlgativa apanalaa. lHa data obtained In raporta paoalvad are studied in relation to na^ faatora auA as guided ■laalla paaaarcH activity, waathap and oth ar itBoapharlc sounding balloon launohinga, eoanartial and »lll- 4lfppaft fUsffte, r lights of algratopy birds, add other eon- alderatlons, to detepaloe poaaible estplanatlons for alghtlr^a. V.-.- poaalblllty that the objeeta are psally ualden- tifled.and unconventional type a of alroraft a teebnlaal analyala la made of scae of the reports to detemlae the aarodynaalo, pro- • pulsion, and oontrol features that would be required for the obisot / to per for® aa described in the reports. The objeota sighted bsve been grouped Into four olasaifioationa ae cording to configuration; 1. Hying disks, l.a., very low aepeot ratio aircraft. 8. Torpedo or clgsr shaped bodies with no wings or firs visible in flight. S. dpherlcO or balloon- shaped obi-ots. 4. Balls o.f light ^ The first thrde groups are capable of ai^t by serodyntnlo or aerostatic means 'and oan be propelled and controlled by' mthods imown to aaronsutlcsl designers. The fourth appears to ha vs no phyelcal for® attached, but the ®aans of support moy not have been seen by the observer. Apppoxloa tel percent of the Incidents Have been idsnbl- fled as conventionel sTlal obj-ots to the satisfaction of psraen- nel aasignsd to Project "Sign* In ^1# Comneni. • 2t Is expeoted, that a atudy of the Inoldenta 1 q relation to weather sj>d other at- woapherle sounding balloons will provide solutions for an e^iva-* lent number. Verbal atstements by an astpo-phyalelst at Ohio State thlverelty and by payebologlets of the Aero-Medical {laboratory of this Consnd, indloate tbe possibility of solving an sppreolsbls number of the •lgbtlnga_as a reault.of their Investtgatlcna, Bll®*- Instlon of Incidents with reasonably satlafaatory explasatlbhs will darlfy tbe probleic preamted by a project of thl# nature. ■UNCu.— s UNCU Tbe pesslbilit; tbit atnatt. of tba Inffldotiti r*pi*«d^nt — technlcftl dav^lepmebts fof in «dv«ne* of knowlad?* arollftbla to anginoart and aolantlatB of this coxmtry baa baan eoQaidarad. • Ho facta ara aaallaKLa to papeonnal at tbla Cobnand that tflll parnit, aa objective aacaaaisar.t of thla poaalbilitj. All Infor- aatlop ao far praaaotad on the poaslbla axiatenea of apaea ahlpa fpoB another planet or of alreraft propelled bj an advanoad type of atoolo power plant have been largely conjecture. Baaed on exparlenee vltb nuclear po«er plant retearch In thla country* the axlctenca on Sarth of auob eoglnea of asall enough alt# and weight to have ppvered the objecta daecrlbed la hi^ly l^sobable. Heporta of tjnldentlf led flying ebjeeta are net peculiar to . the p'^eaent blae« In* Booka of Cha^lea ft^rt" by Tiffany Tay« lor* publlabed In 1941 by Beary 8olte A Ce>* few Yortf* alnllar phenootna are deaerlbad ae baelng been tlthted during peat een« turlea. In the laat war* nuaeroua algbtlnge of "balla of In the air were reported by bonber ereva. * * * UNCLASSiFJED 1 UNCLASSIFIED ft^coiormATiov3 Future Activity on this project ihould be ecrrled on At the alntaiuB level neoeBcepy to record > eumoAPlsej end eveluAte the dAtA received on future reporta and to eoaplete the speelAllted inveitl^Ationa not In progreee. Vhen end if a aufftclent number of incident a are lolved to indloete that theee sight inga do nob repreeent a threat to the aeourlty of the net lob# the asaigoaent of Apeaial projeot atatua to the aotl-vity oould be temlnated. Future inveatigationa of reporta would then be handled on a routine baaia like any other Intelllgenee work. Reporting agenoiee should be la^reaeed vitb the neoeeelty for getting wore factual evideaoe on aigtatin^a* aueh aa photographs# phyaleal evidence, radar sSghtin<*e, and data on eiee end shape. Feraonnel elating aueh objects should engage the assletance of other#, when poaalble, to get no re definite data. For ex'ainple# military pilots should notify nal^borlag bases by radio of the preaenoe and dlrastion of flight of an unldanttfied object so that othei* observers# la fli|0t or on the ground, oould aaaist In its Identlficatlen. vll uncla ccinsD ? i > . >/ •S', Bi COICtUSIONS Ho doflnifce «od eoneluoly® o»ldence 1® y*t avilltblj *. would or dl*ppo»« the «xl®tonco of th®®^ uBldontifl ad ^object® AS rsol slpors^t of uniciiown snd unooav#ntlonsl «oof.l®ip1»tlon. It'xs uollltsly thAb posltlTo proof of ttwilp «*lst«no« will be ob* tAloed without ox sal ns fc Ion of tho ronoTna of erAshed objects. Proof of oon-exlatoroA la equally lapoesibla to obtain unless A resaonahls and conwlncln^^ •xplsnatlon la debeiTolned for eaeh Inoldant. Hany sittings by qualified and.appapenbly reliable wltneases besn reported. Howe qsr# each* Incident haw unaat Is factory features, such as shortoess of tlwe under observation, distance from observer, vagueness of description or photographs, Inconsls- tenclea betwesn individual observers, snd lack of descriptive debt, that prevents definite conclusions being drewn. Explanations, of some of the tndldSQts revealed the exlsbrnoe of simple and eaallj understandable causea, so wat there is the poaalblllty that enough incidents can be solwed to eliminate or grsstiy reduce ,the mystery asao elated with these occurrences. Evaluation of rsporta of unidentified objeobe Is a nsc»‘esary activity of nllltary Intelligence agencies. Such sightings are inevitable, anl under wartime eoodltions rapid and ccnvlnclng aolu* t lens of such ooourreooes /re neeeasary to mslnt sin morale b^* ' military and civilian personnel. In thle respect. It Is considered that the establlahnent of procedures and training of personnel is In Itself worth the effort expended on this project. t Approx Im At *ly 24S dondaf.io incfd<^nts hST^ b<%an PAvlewad, At t^A prns«nt tlmo. In AAOh Incident » th« obAcrvora have been Interrogated by Inveattjators and the results have bean analysed by technical personnel. ' * Condensed sumarlea have been prepared for the list of in- cidents In sufficient quantity to nslre the basic information easily available to Individuals or agencies having an authority or an intereat in the project. (3ee Appendix A). • ^ A detailed cheek Hat, eompiled by teehnl'eal personnel » in* dl eating the basic slemanta of loforBatlon. necessary for analy^i of the individual incldv. t, has been prepared and diatrlbutad to appropriate govenastant ai^eRolaa. In order to identify ordinary and oonventlooel objeota* that have probably been included Ih the list of reported incidents* graph! cal Betboda have bean applied, to as to present the baaXo data In such fora that overall faota, iapllait’in the grouped data, Bill be Bade epparant. (tea Appendix B>. The prepared graphical data ineludes: (a) Charts conceralag unidentified aerial objects, to indi- cate: 1. Type of ohjeet observed d. Vicinity la vbich particular type of*obJeet was ob* served . 9. DlrectioQ of flight (b) Looationa of guided Qleellea, reaeareb and related cant ere — (o) toeationa of alrlioee, airfields, both ailltary and cooiaarlial. (d) Locationa of radio beacon atationa (e) Xnovn or projected radar stations fro* vtal^ reports and asstatsace aay be derived . I * • (f) hateorologioal stations froB which balloon release data, radloaonde or theodolite readings Bay be obtained (g) fast, current^ and projected oeleatlal phenomena (b)* Plight path* of aigratory birds - 1 - a-imo f ( jSIrlED Patchologie>l Anal ye It • I A paT«hologt«al uiaXjsI* oC tha raported data la balng pra- oarad bj Aaro-^adloal Laboratopj, A.K.C., for the purpoaa of da- tarmlnlnp thoaa IncldanCa that are probably baaed upoa arrora of tha human mind and eenaea. A preUBlnary verbal report from the profeaalonal paychologlata Indloatea that a conalderable nuaber of mold ante can be explained aa ordinary oecurranoea that have bean miarapraaantad, aa tha reault of hwean errora. Thb. condition of "vortlyo", well known to alrpl^e pilota» as well aa others, la conalderod to bo an Important factor In Bome of the raportad Ineldanta. "Vertigo U daflnad from a nedlcal viewpoint by Wobatar*a Dictionary aa "Olatlnaaa or awlma- ln« of the head? a dlaturbanee In whl^ objeeta, tbou»5h atatTOnar^, appear to mjve In various dlractlona, and the peraon affected flnda It difficult to maintain an ereot poatve. It may, reault froa changes in the blood a«^ply of the brain or from dlseaae of the blood, aye a, ear a, atoaaob^or other organa. Aocaleratlons^ reaultlng fj^jalrplana maneuvera, togethr tlth space-orlantatlon dlffleultlaa at night In an airplane, duo to the lack of or atrangsneaa of visual referencea, makea a condition of "vertigo" more likely to ^pear .In p^racoael In night-flying aircraft than under more zioneal condition#. The fact that both pilot and oo-pllot may report .the aane lapresslcna la not completa proof of accuracy, ainco both Indlvlduala have axperlencad tho aama nansuvera and acceleratlona and 'have flawed the aame llghta and aurroundinga under the aame optical conditions (including the same wlndsbttd and canopy glass). A A loore complete dlousslon of psy^ologJcsl factors la expsetad to bs preidled in a futnro atatus report. ^Ita probably, sooa of the Incidents of fast, fal^y maneuvering "lights’ , rsported by both air and ground •observers, are the aesult of vertigo or optical illusions. « Strictly speaking, no englnearlng analjsls of an incident should be Initiated until the payobologlcal analysis hss been made and has shown that paycholcgloal factors cannot explain tha observation. i % ^Analvals" Specialist sspflc^s, supplementary to those of Air haterlsl Coonand technical offices, are being provided by a number of.egsn- elea. The Air Weather Service has reviewed the Hat of Inclderta and has provided the Information tf.et tt^nty-four of them coincide, both with reepaet to location and time, with the release of weather balloona. - 2 - a-ii'^so UNCLASSIFIED \ ^ UMCLASSIFIEQ The Ohio State hae dOQtraeted with Air Materiel CoBBand to 0 Uppl 7 aatronomical aervfeei In an effort to lientify netaorai planetolda and aaaoclated phenonana. Frofeeaor S}netc» ^ Ohio State Unlverait7 AatrO'Pbjalolat and bead of the Tblreraltj Ohfervatorj haa uodertaKen to review the tneldect auB'T'cry eheeta. Vhlle thia work hae not jet been oonpleted, Pro^eaacr’ H^nelr haa reported verbal Ij that be ia aattaf ted'that a number of the re- ported obaervationa repraaent aetro-phjaloal phenoTnena. Memberi of the Setentlfle Adviaorj Board Co the Chief of Sta^'f/ nSAP, irtio have provided oonaultant a^rvloea tn Project "Sign”, Include Br. Irvings LanpenilCj Chief, 'ieneral ^eotrio Reaearoh and Or. 0. B. Valley of NIT. A prellnlAarj type of iDtervlev haa been held between Dr. Lansmulv and peraonnel of Project "Sign? during early at age# of the project. It la Intended to eonault further with Dr. Langirulr in an effort to aupplenent present oacbnloal ef”orti toward iden- tifying the reported objeeta. Dr. 0. V. Valley haa diaplayed an active inCereat In Project "Sign”, to the extent of reviewing the reported incldenta and writing an overall type of analyala in which he groupa the vcrioua objeeta and then analyaea each group fren tt>e atandpoint of aoiah- tlfic feaalblllty. Thla analyala la provided at Appendix (C) to thla report. * s XnasBuch at varloua aurniaea have been advanced that aoite of the reported obaeT*vationa way have repreaented "apace ahSpa" or aatellLta veblclea, e apecial atudy has been initiated with the fUnd Corporation, under the Band* Project, to provide an analyala frow this Btandpelnt and alao to provide fundanental Inforrutlon, pertaining to the baaio design and per romance eharaoterlsti'ei that miaht diatinpuiah a poatible "apace ship."' Aa a preliitloary undertaking, the Band Project haa submitted a study by Dr. Lipp in which the poaaibllity is sxplorsd of^ any planat In the known unlvarae being In a physical end cultural position to allow the developnent and use of the "space ship”. Thla atudy has been prepared in the fom o”^ a report that la pre- aented es Appendix (D). # The Weather Bureau library of the Department of Cbansrce hat 'Supplied information on "ball lightning". Thla waa I'squeated be- oaMa of the belief by sooie persona that aone of the 0 ''servatlons aay have repreaented Sail lightning". It appears that the sub- ject of "ball li^toing" oooi^isa an undeterwlned status and authorltlea are not at all convinced that sue* a phenomena actually sxiata. The Federal Bureau of InveaiV'gatlon baa assisted Project "Sign" in a number of in stance a, both by Invaatlgstlons of the character and reliability of witnesses of Incidents and by providing other lavestigatlva services. ■UNCLASSiriED 5-117B0 ' t UNCLASSIFIED CQnild»r»tlona Affgctina AoalT^U tn d Etraluttloo OPgRATlCWAL . InAAiiuoh o th«r« !• a dletlftct posdlMUtT «>»At e nuab«r or^th« reported Incidants r«pr«8ARt doMstle proJjctA ^ *tp-«l*»Alfl«*d luture, tt>« ll*t of inoldont* hd# b»«d dubmlttod to hljd^op oebol^nd fdr potlow* Slnoo wodther bolloodd* blimp*, dlrplbno* of \iau*u*l or-ooaflgurdtlfiP.dnd ituldid laUallP* toot 0OIW of tho oboopvdtlono, oetlon hoo boon tokoo to obtain Inforwo- tton,,oono«pntB« ooho-iuloo ond m^^hti of ouob oroft froa tho opppoprioto ogoAoioo* Ift oonaoetlon with tbo popebologlcol otudlo# •stontl^e Invodtlfiotlona, oonoernlag tho ohoroctop and polloblllty of tho poportlns olta«i»M aodo. i ooftcda ppoportl^ of Inoldonto oppoor to bo pool olwoft, thou A of uaooaoontlonol ooaflsuratlon, la ordor to Invootlgoto tbo orodlblllty of tholr oalotoaoo tho following footers oust bo ooaoldorod in oay toohalool onolyols. ilroroft Vothod of Support (lift) VIbm Ihioelogt Lift (Vlnglood) Rotor ioginio*Bff«ot (potoblag eyllndop, oono or sphof^, sub- looted to polotl^o tponolotloool sir volooityl Aorostotlo (llRbtor-tbon-olr oroft) lotbod of Propul ol OB (Thrust) Propollor-poclproootlog onglno obabtaotlon Jot, roelcot, rosijot (utlllsJag convontlenol fuols ond oxldoatt or possibly stoalo ♦ ,w ■orodyhoalo (Imtoatysr Bffoot - ooollldtlag olrfolls 'doooloplas n«gotlTO drag (thrust) If oa otoalo oaorgy pooorod onglno oore OTsilsblo, a saoll maaa flow at a laPB» -aalootty •oali aeeoniplWh • and propulataa foraaa and tha large. •««*•«» expeadltura would bo of SCSAII la^ortsnoo. ^ , alto thot pros eatly would iMiN* poworplont for alpopoft* . 4 - S-U '?60 V UNCLASSIFIED! In^ddltloTk* B*miad aircraft would rc<)uir« an exeaaalva percent vel^t of ahieldlng for huaen proteotion, unleae conflgurA^ blona of extreaolf large slae were iiaed. If unabieided craft were In operatJ on* axlatlng detection means vould probably bave h' indicated Uteir pretence. Hdtallurglcal linltatione to date* Unit the rate of coq« eertlng the heat energy of the atonic aouree to useful propulsive work to Bu^ an Inaffectlve order of nagnltuds tbet such a power 97 s tea Is quite unlikely fron >he stendpoint of site and weight. Stability Aerodynaaie (both static and dynamic through the use of aerodynamic aurfaoea and val^t dlatrlbution) > Servo -aaohsnlaa (gyro or acceieroiceter - servomotor systen) Control , Movable surfacea in airflow or ^et ' Jet (flow control or svtvaling types). / Possible Spaoeiblps World knowledge* tecbniquea* and resources are considered to ba presently adequate for the developcaent of spaoesbips. 4 Dlstlnguiablng design and performance pa rase ter a are ax- pactad to te aupi'llad as a speoial study by the Rand Project. Probable Ra,tursl Pbenomena Aatrophysloal (Betsors* comets* planetoids* etc.) Astrephysieal analysts Is expected to be performed by personnel of Ohio State Uilverelty Research Pounds tl on. Eleotronagnvtle (ball lightning* St. Elno*s Fire, Pboa- ptaoreaesnoe* corona* etc.). • Ordnance Items ^ > While this analysis considers the reported objects largely froa the standpoint of aircraft with requirements for' spaed and subetsntlal duratlcn of flight and range* it Is entirely possible that tbs configurations reported In small sties could serve as very ussful ordnance items to take the place of (or supplement) such short-range weapons of gpoxnd (infantry) warfare as the trench iDortar* hand grenade* etc* The small aaucer-like, eplanlng* - 5 - S-11760 UNCLASSIFIED dlikt» r<»porte^lj undor daVAlopaezit by the Oapaan Soiantlate* H vlng aj^losiye edges 'ppeseed sir eatapulc, (perhaps In the tnsnn jetted by e trap aeohanlsa) eould possibly Aleo* sucH devioes eould helps ed by si rare strp^^* fomstlone* In suds osees* only rsn;e,and Halted flight duration would be seredynsBle sffioienoy of the design would litportanse* 1S3H with the aid of and launched by a eoo-> ,*p of elay pigeons pro* be ordnance articles, ft in at tasking enemy a modest speed, short required, ^toea the not be of very much lasuffloieat Infonsatlon for Bven Toaslbla or Rypothetloal Type Dotepalnation** Dlseredlted Reports erroneous (See Olaeuasloa* Fayoholo?rloal Errors) False kJTiTsiSTimiinFur nfi lOiJl tlons fhs estraae lack of data for eaoh of the been reported makes It presently Icuposslble to any of the reported craft with respect to dee! Technioal analysis suet be made by eensldsrlng prebabilitlea* which are erpeoted to. be proved when oomplete-data or physical speoiaens of al available. Ibdtsnttfled aerial objects appear follows t incidents that have accurately identify ^ end perfcraanca. possibllltlea and or ditsreved only r craft (crash) are to be grouped as (1) Plying disks (saucers) (8) Torpedo or Cigar Shaped Bodies (no wings or fins visible In fll^t) ^ (3) Spherical or &allcon^Shape Cbjeots( capable of hawsB|Pfc.. descending, ascending or travelling at hS^ apeed), (4) Balia of light (no apparent pbyvtcal form attached). Capable of msneuverlny, cllrblng.snd travelling at speed. The first tks*ee groups of objects are capable of flight through the atmosphere by means of aerodynamic and propulsion de- signs (to produce the required lift and thruet) that are readily conceivable by aerosnutlcal designers. The stsbilising and cen- tal features that would be required, while more obscure, could oeneelvably be provided. The question arises, however, as to idiether these oonflgurstlons would develop much speed and allow a sufficient duration of flight and adequate range to be of prac- tical tfss as aircraft. Plying Disks The disk or circular planfom has hot b*en used in represen- tative aircraft, either mllltery or. civilian, for the reason that tbs Induced drag, as det^mlnad by the Prandtl theory of rPft, would • 6 - unclassified S- 11750 f wi»Ci.,MoSiFI£0 *ppfti*«otTy hl^» Blne« th« ratio o^ • clr^ oular planforta la only 1.27, fixtensSon of th« Prandtl ttoory, h%a «leo shown that tho Aaxlma possible lift eo%fflelent to ^s expected frov sudi low scpect retlo planfoms should also *)e poor. In addition, the relatlvelj large aean serodyrianle chord would present difficult design problem, to achleTe static longi- tudinal atablJtty for airfoil seotlcns having a significant oftntar. of -presour a travel, or for airfoil aeetlona* of so-ealled stable type, vheo equipped vlth ailerons at the trailing edgb. In the vary lov aspaet ratio range, the Prandtl theory le probably very Inaceurate. Vlnd -tunnel tests of very lov aspect r ttliT lndleats-.nuoh.lssa Inducod drag In or ease than ax- psoted froa tbaory and also denonstrate very high maxlrnun lift coefficient aocos^anled by extronely bi^ atalllag angijht* Bov- ever, in generel the Induced drag of vary lov aepeot ratio wings is nuA larger than the Induced drag of convent lonal aircraft vlngc, s Condi tloo rtiieh vould adversely affect all perforcsanQS values In flight oondltlons which require tnedlun and hiph lift coef f ielenta . thua, porfomanoe in olinb, at altitude, and for leng*range eondltlone would be relatively poor, although high epead would be little affected. Iptvithetasdlng the predicted eerodynanio disadvantages of circulsr planfora wings, quite a nuaber of experlaeitsl efforts ' have been nade to use this conflgnretlon - and not all of then by peraone ignorant of aerodynasio fundaBsntsls . Bxperimental wind-tunnel w6Tk at tha BACA (iPbb) showed both naxinmn lift ce- efflolenta and ctall obaracterletlee such no re favorable than oeuld be anticipated. The problen of atetic longltudinel atebillty could peaalbly. be solved by tbe uee of a etable airfoil section of the reflexed trailing edge type with wing tip ailerons (perhaps float Inp) aero* dynanicslly independent of the wing. At supersonic speeds, irtiere the Induced drag la snail, the circular plsnfom offers the probability of reduced drag, oharaoterlitlc of low aspect rati© airfoils In the supersonic ranwe. Also tbe circulsr planforn presents s swept -bach leading edge (of vdplsble sweep along the epen), should result In a reduced effective Bach fwiber, with attendant reduced drag fop a certain Vupersbnlc apeed rang#. lo definite infonietlon hai been received on the method of nrodulslon uaed on flying dlska idilch )nve been sl^bed. However, beoause of distance factors Involved in the possible that either propellers or Jet propulsion could have been employed without being noted by the obserrvp. Fuse m*pedo or Clwer-Shaped Bo ■bll. th. Olg»p.op t«»rp.do-rti»p.c» bo^ P.prs.jnt. « form for the fueelage of an elrplane or the body of a guided islaslle • 7 - UNCLASSIFIED S -11750 ^■classified in n9itb«r e«»9.he«* l*t H a pM^ry ll^t^produoln^ $ut»- fAoe. BovaTor, an extanalcn of tba Prandtl tbaory of lift S^dl- Oft tea that a fuaelage of tbo^dlunaSona raportad by the Saatarn Alrllnea pilots Alted and Chllea in tha Montsoneryj Alahana* In- oldarvt oould support a load eoaparable to the walcbt of an air ora ft of this s'lae at flying apaeds In tha subsonic range. Tha Prandtl theory probably giaea eery eonserrstlve value a of naxlawn lift for bodies of this shape. Oerman experleoee Indicates that tha * maxlBum lift nay be teiee as Mah as that glvao by ttie theory. Although the oraft al^tod by Vhlted and CbHas was reported to be olthout vlnga and flns» It la poaalble that It oould have bean equipped with eztanalhle' vin^s for ta^e-off and landlng» contained vlthln the^ f uaala:;e in erulalng flight. This type of aircraft oexild also be partially supported in the take-off and landing condition by the vertical oodq>onent of the Jet thrust, if the landing and take-off took place with the fuselage axis, or the Jet strean direction in a vertical or nearly vartloal altitude. Ihe further posaiblllty that an extensible rotor, conoaalad wttbln the fuselage, could have heed used, would provide another nathod for landing and take-o'‘f that would sllow wlngleti fillet at very hl^ apaad. Sudu a deal an oould result * Ln s relatively large duration of flight and corraspoadlag range. While no stabilising fins sera apparent on the "flying fuse- lage" reported by «hlted and Cbllas, it la poasible that vanes within the Jet, operated by a gyrc-tarvo ays ten could have pro- vided atatio atabillty, longltudiaally, directionally and laterally. Tha saoie vanae could also have been used for acooffpllihing statls bslsfioe or trln, as well as oootrcl for maneuvering'. a The above dlacusslon regarding weight, controllability » sta- bility, mto. la not intended to r«preaent deductions regarding the exact nature of the torpedo or oigar-sbaped aircraft which were sighted by the airline pilots, Whited and Chll*s, and others. They are' msraly statements of possibilities, which are Intended to show that such an aircraft' oould support and control Itself oy eerodynanlc ireans. The propuleivc ayetem of this type of vehicle would appear tc be a Jet or rocket engine. Tha epeoiric fuel consumption of anginas to this type would be ratbar bl^. This, coupled with the fact that aerodynamic lift on such a body would be accompanied by high drag, placet a serious llaltstlon on the ran^{e of this air- craft for any particular gross weight. If this type of unidenti- fied aerial object baa extremely long ranie, it is probable that the method of propulsion la one which la far la advance of presently known engines. 4 Wound ObJeoti f Spheric el- and Balloon-3hsped Objects Spherlcaleor balloon«shaped objeote, are not usually considered *as efficient aircraft. lot only' would the drag of such bodies be high, but the energy expenditure that would be required to develop lift by aarodynanlc weans would be excessive. Tha only conceivable - 8 • UNCU::33/FIED S-tl750 % Ncussirieo Beaas of producing; lift for auch a otbrr than by a^roatatlc (alfipXa buoyancy) noana* voul’d by rotation of<-th« aphar* with translational notion r^latlva to th« air; or by Uaeharglny a atraam of air verttoally dp«n«ard. Aarodynamlc *lle})t could bo aeooopllahed vlth a rotating spbera« provided tho detailed deslii^ problena^ including atablllty and cwxtrol vapo worked out. The nothodai ualny a blcwar aystoa or Jota» would roqulra yolatlvdly gpoatop amounta of onorgy and whllo they could bo uaod for fllp>ta of vary abort ran;;e cad duration* would not ordinarily bo oon- sidored' as practical by aeronautical deal ;n era. The obvious oxplsnatlon for nost of the apfaerical ahppod objeota Is that they ar* vetooroloitloal or alBilar typo balloons. This* however, does not explain reports that Uioy travel st hl^ speed or nanouvor rapidly. It la possible that the novenent of ths object a was aone kind of an optical illuaion* or that noveiDent for a brief period due to a gas leak In the balloon was exaggerated by observers. ^lls of Ilaht ffo reasonable hypothesis of the true nature of balls of light such as that reported by Lt. Oormaa at Fargo. I. Dakota, haa been developed thet explains the behavior reported. The nost reason^ able sxplsnatlon la that the llghta were suspended froTt balloons, or other Beans of support, not visible at night, and the violent naaeuvera reported are due to Illusion. of Scientific PevelooBents In Advance of Xnovledge Conaideration haa bdan givea to tha poaalbillty that theae unidentified alroraft rapreaant acientlfio developieents beyond the level of knowledge attained In thia country. Since this la probaUy tha nost advanced of the Induatrlal natlona on the earthy and our Interest In scientific developnenta throughout tha world Is vory active, it wduld be necessary for any other sowtry to ooaduet raaaarob and developisant vork in extrene seorsey for any such projeet to have reached au^ an advanced state of developnant without a hint of its existence beooaing known here, ’(ha only nation on earth with extanalva teohaloal reaouroes ehl^ haa such rigid aaourlty* la the 0.8. S.R. An objective evaluation of tha ability of the Soviets to produce teehnioal developaers a so far in advacMs of tba peat of the world results in the conclusion that tha possibility Is axtrac^ly renot^. Most of the successful Soviet aeroaautloal developwents have been ypoduced by utillting ezpsrlanee of other nations, soae of tbea being very close copies, BO It^ is v*ry unlikely. 12 iat they bavfi..deve loped the propulsion «QdL. controldovlcea oeoessery to neke tba so objects perfom as described Another possibility Is that these aerial objeats are visitors fpoB another planet.^ Little Is known of the probabilities of ' f« on other planets, so there Is no basis on which to* Judge the p si- blllty that cl vlitsatlons far in adyars e of oura exist outald '. be earth. The oosknentary on this possibility by Dr. Jares Llpb of the Rand Project In Appendix o , Indi cates that thia solution of ths oyatery connected with the alibiing of unidentified flying — ^ — t««eUSSIFIED • 9 • S-U750 ft ^ .1 rir-ffASSIRED obj«ota < ■ 4^.«/^K^vi « , ^«Bdlo£ •llalnatlon of all othar eolutl^na or daflnlte proof of tha* wtQi a » uf » tiwa a ubj tbla poaiiblllty vlll not ba fvrthar evplorad, . Z±2M^2i:X - 10 • S*lV760 UNCLASSinED 4i«-u ^ DlstributloQ of IcLoidODt Suveot^loa: Air VAteriol Oosaand Aoro Hadieal L»ber0itorr (MCR8XD} V«Ath«^ Llftisoa (HCLAdS) Aoootroh 4od DovoXopaont (KRSOS) n«etronle Fl4no (KCRSBP} TeotuUoal tDteXllg«no4* Toefanleal daotions (ACI ) Othor Ae«Aol4« Dlrootorate of Intelllganoa, flq.» USAF (AFOIR) Offloo of VavoX ZatoXllgoaaa nolte or radio Inter faraaoe* Nor are there nanv Indl cations of ar^j net Ariel affects or physical daieege attributable to the obaerved of- Jeots. SuBpnapy -- PART 1 Thla report will .conaider melr.ly the reports '‘of Oroupa 1 sad d.' PART II..« ON POSSlBtS NXPLANATIONS OP THE RBPORT3 Section A — Nhat ean be deduced oorseralng the nature of a n AfPlejl , ^ 1 eot frya a e^aa^e alahtlBg ? Here, there are tvo problenss first, hoe much eoO'be deduced ooneemlng the nature of the objeeta froa geonetrlcal calculations alone; seoond, hoe nuoh more ean be dadueed If, in addition* it la asauned that the objects obey the laws of nature as #e Inoo theai. i Conoernlng the first problen, it can be stated that only ratios of lengths* and rates of obange of such ratios, can be acourstely determined. Thus, She rente and size of such ob* Jects cannot be determined: and it is notlceeble that reports of size of the obeoreed objects are widely at yariance. How- ever* anglesr such as the engle subtended by the object* ean . be observed, likewise there Is fair agreement among several observers that the diameter of the objects of Oroup 1 is about ten times thslr thickness. Although velocity* cannot be deter- mined* angular velocity oaa be. and In particular the flutter frequency could, tn principle* be determined. All that can be concluded abctit the rtn;a and size of tbe objects, from geometrical eonelderatlocs alone* Is: 1) from the fact that ea tins ted sizes vary so widely, the objects wnre actually either of different sizes, or sore Ukejy, that they were far enough from the observers eo thet binocular vision produced no atereesceplo effect; this only means that thay wars farther off than about thirty feet; S) slnot ebjeots were seen to dlseppear behind trees, bulldlnge, clouds, eto., they are- large cnou^ to be visible at the ranges of thoss recog** nlzable objects. How, It Is obviously of primp Inportanoe to estlmete the size end mass of Che obsArved objeete. This may be poeslble to tone extent if It Is permiaslble to assume that they obey the laws of physics. Sliwe the objects have not been observed UNCUSSIFIED®*“''®° UNO.ASSinED to opcdueo *nyp^y•loal «ff«ct*, than the ore fteee in whl'oh e eloud Avaporated along tbe traje-story. It la not cApta’n tbnt Wa laws of mAehanlse# for ljptance» eoulo oe eufflclent* But auppoiA that feaobanloel lava alone are auffiel«nt» then the folloili^ example la auffloleot proof that at loaet a length eould, In prlnolple* be deteniined: auppoee a simple pendulxjB were ahaArvad. auapended Irr the ekyj than after ob- serving Ita frs^enoy of ^eelllaVott* •• could deduce frov the lava of v'eiheinlca Ita precise lengtti* This suwati that aoaetblng could be deduced fro« the obeerved fluttirlng notion of soeie of the objects of Aasu&e that v« know the antpilar freouenoy end angular an«pij- tude of this fluttering motion (they ©an be measured. In PfiJ* olple from a »tlon picture). Then for purpoeea of caleulatloa aesume the ohjact. to be thirty feet In diameter, to as a normal aircraft vlng of 50- foot span, to be constructed of cDsterldl of tb» optimum vel^t-strengbh ratio and J •trueture of most efficient desl»i>._It is now possible to cal- o^ste how heavy the object muat be Mraly bo remain rigid ^ under the observed angulsr mot I op. let the for a oluralltr of*aseu»ed sites 1, 9, d,*S, Id* o2» ot • up to say 200 feet, end let calculated mass be plotted versus sesumed alts. The non-Unesr character of Irttllcabe an approximate upper limit to the sire of the object. If. In addition, U Is sssumed that the flutter to aerodynamic forces, It Is possible that more precise Informs- tier could be obtained. . The required sngulsr dart can probably vltneeaee moat reliably by the use of a demonstration model which esn be wade to oscillate or flutter In a knovr way. Sumary — PAHT 11 . Section A 4 *;eoiiiebrloal calculetlons alone cannot yield the else ©f objects observed fro.n a single atatlohj such cbservatlon tc- .^sthsr with fcha ass-J«ptlon t#et the ' aircraft, can be used to set resscnablc U*its of slaa. Section J — The, Linv s solid ebJsct b: meelMlltv of suppcrtipm and prope.l- , unuauaJ sit,o. s«. ob.«r*.r. h... obYiouij, 80 l.r.d With talk o'* rays. Jets, besma, spaom-sbipe, and the llks. It le well to eximlne what posalblUtles exist along This la alto Important In view of the conolualons of PART II , aeetlon A, of this report, / I^NCUSS/FIEO S- 11750 Ar». . .. ■ Uu'CLASSIFlED Method I -- Propuletcn and sxippont by tneana "raye" or "beftnia"7 *” ' • » ^ Hy "raye* or "bea«" are caeent either pure]y frleetro- na^^neblo radiation or <*la« radlatJon vh! Oh la largely eorpuaoular like catbode-raya or cosMle-rays oi^ oyclotren* beaiaa. s • Now» it la obvious that any davtae prooelled or supported by such means is funda'enn tally a reaction device. It Is fund* Sfoental in the theory o'* such deTio*a t>»t a given aaeunt of energy la'aost efficiently spent If the ji^mentua thrown back or down is large. *Thla naans that a lar^ assb should be given a snail acceleration -- a theore* wall uMerateod.by helicopter dealgnera. 5 . .l-v The b-— la given a Veigy high v^losity, consequently enomoua powsra* - greater than the total world's power *capaplty« would be need ^«^2 to support even the siaallest objeet by. au^ meant. ' Method •- Direct uee of Sarth'a Magnetic Field ; j s ' , ’lOT . One obeareer Uneidont 6d) nottoed a violent 'notion of hand-held cec^ess. If we assuiae from thla that the objeete . Produced e vagnetic field, comparable vttte the Earth's rieldj V namaly, 0.1 gauss, and that the obaerrer f*e rsflutbod electroieagnot la given byt .’V- Mg nl 8 su where R la the range o^ the object. ^ \ J e^As or rays mentioned do the contrary, a small nisg. ' vary high veloeity, consequently anemous powsrsk ni -. m For Instance, if R la c>io kilometer* aM the object la 10 TBetsra in diameter, than nl ^ 1 billion ampare- turns . ✓ Row, If the object we^ actually, only 10 meters away and were correspondingly smaller; :iamely> 10 cm in diameter, It would s . 1 / 11 ' r ecu Ire 10 ralUlon amps re •turns. These fiouras are a little In excess of what can be con- veniently done on the ground. They make it seen unlikely that the effect wee actually observed. !icw, the Earth's iaa.7netle field eould reset on such a coa^Tnet to produce not only a torque but also s force. This depends not dlreotJy^Oh the Earth's field Intensity but or Its Irregularity or gradient. This roroe Is obviously iclriUte since the change Ir. field over a distance of 10 meto£s (asBuaed dleneter of the object) la eoarcely mssaareable, moreover the gradient Is not predlotehle but chsngea due to local ore deposits. Thus, eva% if the effect were large enourh to use, It would still be unreliable and unpredictable. S-11760 UNCLASSIFIED I UNCLASSIFIED » M# thod III -- Support e^^ir» •lootHeolly charged object by oa’isJh'X to raove trana versa to* the Barth's magnetic field t A positively c'-arged body moving frcn west to east, or a nej»etlvely charged body moving from Bast to dest will experience anupward force due to the Barth's magnetic field. ♦ * * A sphere 10 meters dlareter moving at a speed of one kJlo- meter/seoond would experience an upward force of one pound at th4 if to A of & x 10 ifelt#e Tbit i% obviously rldloulous. Section P •-The anti gravity shield It has been proposed/ by various wrJtara, perhaps first by H. 0» Wells ► that It might be poaelbla to construct a means of sMeldln? a wssslve body from the Influence of gravity. ^ Such an oblaot would then float. Recently^ there appeared in the preao a notice that a prominent economist has offered to support re- search OR such an enterprise. Obviously, conservation of energy demarrls that consider abjs ener^T be given the supported object lb order- te place ahleld. However, this amount of energy le In no way prohibitive, aitl ''urthoraore It can be gotten be ok when tbe object lands. Aside ^ov the fact that we have no suggestfo.nt ks to how such a device Is to be mele, the various theories of genersl relativity all agree In asstainB that gravitational force and force due to acceleration are indistinguishable, aad from this sasumptloR the theories predict certain effects whleh are In fact observed. The assumption, therefore. Is probsbly correct, and a earoll.PT of It 1« .««.ntUUj th.t onl, bj lutna of «n .oeol.r- stlon can gravity bo counteracted. This, we can sucoossfully do 4n^iirioe by making an artificial sa&alllte, but this pre- •UMbly Is not shat has been observed. SuBsnart — PIHT 11, Section 6 dsvoral solid object finding lends Fart II. that noraal tcesns, of the type 0 be oospletei SecM^ unorthodox meana of supporting or px^pelXlng a hava baen considered, all tre impraotl cable. This I credence to tbe tentative proposed assui^tlon or ; the objects are ai^ported and propelled by soije or else that they are not sollda. ko discussion pf Part II, Section 9, can. In principle, of course, C — Possible causes iorts. niftaalflcatlcn I — Saturm^ te r i^str lal_ph»II^ga& 1. fhe observations may be lue to Some effect such as UNCLASSIFIED i • » DNCLAS?’’ 3-11760 y?35rsssiFiED A iorg**8oale, axoapJMnfc was raade at the time of Orson Wellea* "Heptlan" broadsest. Sor fHss. option II -- Maa^made teyr eat rial phenomena 1. The objects may be Bua^an ..Iroraft. If this were so» then the eonalderatlcTia of Sections A and 3 Indicate that we would have plenty to eorry ebout. It la the euthor*s opin* loa that only an accidental dieeoeerj of a deprae of novelty never before achieved could sufftee to explain eueh devices. It is doubtful whether a potential eneay would arouse our eurloalty In ao^idle a fashion. ClMeifl cation ITT -- Ratra terreatrlal obleeta I* Be teojs ? It Is noteworthy that the British physlolst ,lovell wpitiaa in ’’Physios Today* iseatlons the paiar discovery of a new daytime meteorite streen which reached Ita max Into durlni? June 1947, The reported objects lose little of their interest, however, if they ere of Reteorltle origin. 8. Anlaali : A]thou/h the objeots as described act more like aaleale than anything else, there are few reliable reports on extra-terrestrial aolwals. which can make such\obJeota es ere reported tlen it le most probeble that its development le rlr in edvanoe of eura. This argument can be supported on probeblllty arguments alore without recourse to astropomleel hypotheses* Sp.aoe Ships ? The followloi^ consider at lens pertain: a. 'Zf there is an extra terrestrial olvlllsstion b. 3uch a ciytllsetton observe that on Sarth wi now have atbnio bowbe and are feet d eve lop 1 nr rockets. In view of ths past history of mankind, theynhouli* be el*«rTDed> Te should, therefore, expect at this time above all to behold such vlsltattor.s. dlxMe the acts of neoklnd most easily observed from a distance are A-bomb explosions we sboxild expect come relation to obtain betwem the tioe of A-bomb explosions, the tioe at wbloh the space -whips are seen, aod the time re^rulred for such ahipa, to arrive from and return to home-base. PART llf — MCOiOIgPATleRb 1. The file should be continued. 2. A anteorologist should cos^ute the approximate energy 23 ->ii^<^‘^SSIF/E0 3-11760 -v^ .. t^NCLASS/FIED required to oTaporebe aa sue^. cloud as shown tn the Incident 86 photographs. Togather with an asrodyoABiolat ba sbouTd axanlns whether a ttetaorlte of unusual shape could wove as observed. 9. The oaloulatlons suggested In fart Il« Seotion A. should be estlsiated by an aerodTiiBnlolat with such changes as his siore detailed knowledge nay suggest. - 4« The masa-pajchologj studlea outlined In Part .II » Section C» Classlfleetlon I S should be carried out b;f a oos- petent staff of statiatlelans and Baaa-payebologlsts. Inter.vl owing agents should carry objsots or novlng pictures for oosaparlson with reporter's oe&orles. Thesa devices ahoald be properly designed by a paychologiat exper* lenoed In problens pertaining to aircraft nd desl^ of alr« craft -control aqulpaent to that he shall have aona graap of shat lb Is that la to be found out« Tf the Air force baa reason to b^ seriously Interested tn these reports. It should tske IflMdiste steps to Interrogsts tbw reporters nors. prs- slssly. 6. A person skilled In the optics of the eye end of the stfiosphsrs should Investigate tbs psrtloular point thst several reports agree In describing the ob jests as being about ten tines ss wide ss they ere tbiok; the point being to see if there is a plurality of actual sbapsa vhieh appear so» under oondltlons approachii^ Uniting reseluticn or detestable son- trast. UNCLASSlHti5 s-ii760 r APPRTDIX "D 13 DeooBber 1948 Al-1009 Brifndler Oeneral Putt Valtad Stataa Atp Force Direotor of ReeeArch eod DeveLopnent Office, Deputy Chief of Staff, Materiel MeaMngton 96, D. C. Deer Geaarel Putt: rioeae re^’cr to your letter of 18 Novenber 1948 relative to the flying object* probleie end to Mr, Cellb^U reply dated 84 Bov ember 1948, In paragraph (b) of tbe reply, Mr, Collboha promiaed (aneng other thl r«a) to aend a dleetfaaloc of the apeelel deal«a and performance ebaraotertatica that are believe bo dletlnguiah apace ahipe.* general terae, a deacrlptlon of the likelihood of a vie It from obKr aorlda aa an anglneerlng problem and aooe pointa regarding the uae of apece veblelea aa collared with deaerlptlcna of the flylne objeota. Mr, CcllbolMa will deliver copies to Colonel McCoy it Vrlaht-Fatteraon Air Baae during the AASD briefing there *ltMn the next fee days* A good beginning la to dlaQuae.scete poaetble pleeea of origlm of 'vlaltlng aptaa ehlpe. Aatronooere are largely in agreanant that only oAa maob^r of tba Solar ayetem (beiidea 1?arth) ean evppert higher forma of Ufa, It la tbe plaaet Hera. Even Mara appeara cult# desolate and Iz^ospltabla ao that a race veuli be more oooupled elth aurvlval than ee are on Barth. Raferenoe 1 gives adequate d^acrlptlona of cordltlona on the i varlcua plaefte «id aatellttea, A Quotation from Ref. 1 te^eretupe evtremae vbuld be raduoed. f ' S-11789 41 UNCLASSIFIED 4 trolled. Ae a second posalbllltyv evolution na; have developAd a being vho e«n withe tend the rlgore of the Kertlen ellcnate, -Or the race ae; have perished. "These posslbllltlee have been aufflelectly expanded In the paaudo-eolentifle literature to aaice further anpllfl* cation auperfluoua. However, there may exist some Interest- ing restrictions to the anatoay and physiology of s Martian. Harlty of the atncspbere, for exanpla, aay require a com- pletely altered respiratory systea for wara-blooded creatures, atrospherlc pressure is ouch below the vapor pressure *Ater at the body tesiperature of* the Individual, the*prooeas of breathing with our type of lungs beooaes, iaposalble. On Mars the critical pressure for a body teaparature of 98.tfV. occurs when a ooluan of the atmosphere contains one sixth the Mas of s similar colujmi on tba Sarth. Por a body tsaperature of 7?^. the critical aasa ratio .la reduced to about one twelfth,^ and at 80®P, to about one twdnty- fourth. These or} tied veluas are of the sane ord^r as th*' values astlnatad for the^Martlan ataosphere. Accordingly the anatomy and phys- iology of a Martian may be radically different free ours - but this Is all conjecture. "Wa do not know the origin of life, even on the Baj^th. le are unable to observe any algns of Intelligent Ilfs on Kars. .The reader nay fore Ms o«n opinion. If he believes that the life force is universal anl that Intelllrent beings may have once developed on Mara, he has only to imagine that they persisted for oowtless generations in s rare atmosphere which Is nearly devoid of oxygen and weter. and cn a planet where the nlghtesre much colder than our arctic winters. The ex- istence or Intelligent life on Mere is net Imposstblo but It is completely unproven." It Is not toe unredscnoble to go a step further and consider Venus es a possible hooafor Intelligent life, The atmoephere, to be sure, apparently cormle.ts mostly of oarbon dioxide vlth deep clouds of fonraldehyde droplets, snd there seems to be little or no water. Tet living erganlsme might develop In chem^al envlroments that are strange to us: the vegetable kingdom, ^for example, operates on a fundamen tally different energy cycle from Man. Bodies night be oonetnicted and operated with different chenlcela and other physical prlaolples than any of the oreatures we know. One thing is evident: fishes. Insects, and sianoala all nenufacture within their own bodies oonplox ehenleel oompouxsds that do not exist as minerals. To this extent, life Is self -sufficient and wight wall adapt Itaelf to any anvlronaant within 'certain limits of temperature (and slsa of creature). Venus has two handicaps relative to Mahs. Her mss, and gravity, are nearly as large aa for the Sarth (Mars la amaller) and her 3-11750 UNOJ^IFIED i • ^ UNCLASSIFIED oloudy fitroaphere would dlaocura^?^ astrouoBy. thence apae# traval. The remaining Solar pXar^ta are aueh podr proapects that they can be i^ored. In the neat few paragraph a. wa aha^l 'apeak of Uara. It should be ' understood that must of the r*ffieHfs apply equally well to Venus. • • , Various people have .suggested that an aiwanoed^raoe nay have been wlaltlng Barth fron Hare or Venus at Interwals fron decades to eons. Reports of objeets In the aky seem to hare been handed down tbrouj^ the generstions. Zf this were true, a race of auoh Vncwlodge and power would have, oatabllshed sona forn of direct Qontact. Tkray eould sea that Barthes inhabitants would be help* less to do Interplanetary ham. If afraid of carrying dlsaasea home, they would at leaat try to eemuntoate. It la hard to believe that any teeh*kloally aooompHahed raea would ooire hera, flaunt its ability in ■yatrrlcus waya and then aloply go away. To thla writer, lonr*ttmr praotloa o'* spade travel Inpliet advaraed engineering and solenoe, weapons and ways of thinking. It la not pleualble (as mny fiction writers do) to mix space ship a with broadswords. Fur the more, a rsoe whloh had enough Initiative to explore anon^ the planete would hardly be too timid to follow throush when the Job wee aoeowpliahed. One other hypotheale neede to be dl a ousted. It Is t*.st the Martians tree kept a long-term routine watoh on Barth and have bean alarMd by, the sight .of our A-bomb shots as evldertoe that we are warlike and on the threshold of apace travel. (Venus is elinlneted here beeeuse her cloudy atncephere would make suoh a survey Impractical). The ftrat flying objects were sighted in the Sprln* of 1947, after a total S atoslc bomb sx- ploslons, l.e. • Alenoserdo, Ulreshlma, Nagasaki, Crossrosda A and Crossroads 6. Of these, the flrat two were In positions to from Kars, the third was very doubtful (at tha edga of Earth's dleo In daylight) and the Is at two were on the wrong side of Rarth. It la likely that Vartlan astronomers, with their thin stmoephere, could build tolescopes big enou^^ to see A-homb explosions on *^srth. even thouqh we were 16b and 153 million miles away, respectively, on-*be AlMo.^^ordo and Hlro- shlaa dates. The weakest point In the hypotnesle is thst a flontlnusi, defensive watch of Berth for long periods o'* time (perhaps thousands of years) would be dull sport, and no race that even remr>tely resembled Ban would undertake It. We haven't even considered the Ides for Venus or Kura, for example. The sum airi substance of this -tlso'jsalon ts that If Martians are now visiting us without oontsot, It csn be assumed thst , they leva just ‘recently succeeded in space travel and that their civilisation would be practically abreast o'* ours. S-11750 29 UNCIASSIFIED / ®«CUSSJF1ED The chance that Liar an 9 , uiuer auch widely divergent oondS- tlona* 'would have a olvlllaatlcn raavvbllrg our own- la ex- treme I 7 remote. It la particularly uni lice I 7 that their’ elvlllcatlon would be wlthla a half century of our own state of advancement. Tet in the la at 50 ye are ire have just started to uae aircraft and In the c»xt SO years we will almost certainly start exploring epace. Thus It appeare that apnea travel from another point within the Solar* ayetem Is possible but very unlikely. Odda are at least a thousand* to-ooe against It. , This leaves the totality of planets of other stars in the lalaxy as possible eoureas. Many modern astronomers beltave that plenata are fairly normal and logical affairs in the life history oC a star (rathar than cataelyamle oddities) so that many plsnets osd bs expected to exist In apaee. * To narrow the field a little » some loose speolficatlona can be written for the star about which the home base planet would ' retolve. let us’ say that the star should bear a fanlly ra« semblance to the- 5un» whidi la s'. member of the so-called ''main- aequeoae" of stars, l.s«, wa eliminate white dwai^s, red giants _ic4 aupsrgianta. a description ttgae types, see refer* . ence Z, ohaptcr S. There Is no specific reason for making this assumption sxcapt to al^llfy ilseusalont wa ars still consldar* log tha majority of stars. Ksxt, truo variable stars can be ellmSnatsdj alnee conditions oi) a planet attached to a variable star would fluctuate too wildly to permit Ilfs. The number of stars deleted here la negligibly SMll. Reference 3, psj:ea T6 and 8S Indtcate that the sost oonmon types are too bright to be In nearby space umotleed. Lastly, ws shall omit binary or multiple stars, since the eondl* tlona for stable planet orbits are obscure In such oases. About a third O'* the atara are eliminated by this roa^rtctlon. As our beat .known aaspl* 0 ^ dpaoe we dan take a volume vlth the Sun at the center and a radius of 16 light years. A coapllation of the 47 known stars, Inoludlm the 3un« within this vcl urns Is given In reference 4, pawes 58 to S7. Tlimlnntlng aooordlrig to the above dtaouasloc: Three are white dwarfs, eight binaries aogount for 18 stars and two trinariea aeo.ount for. 6 more. Tbs renalnler, 22 stars, can be considered as eligible ^or habitable planets. ' 8-11750 UNCUs>SlFlED f LINCLASSIFIEDi _ Assuming th« •bo»«*Yoliw to-be tjploel, the oontente of eny^ TOlume oen be found by eerylng the number of etere proportionately with tbe Yolwe, or elth the redlua oubad, S. 22 x ' ' » where So la number of eligible stare and r ie the radlue of the volume In light year*. (TMs formula ahould only be used for radii greater thad 16 light yeara. For emallar eaaplee we call f^ I one known eligible star other than the Sun llaa within eljht light jeara)* Having -an eatlnato-of the number of uaeable etara, it la now 5!!!* II?! •• o**"ber of habitable planeta. We 5l Syetaii, and tbe gueao must dlet?lbutid^at Iir"^****"'^*' Intelligent life may not be randomly ??? 5^^* planeta, arranged In a fairly regular, progreetlon of orblta (flee referenced. Appendix 1) that lende orelence to rlllfi*? »eny atara have planeta« Of the nine planets, (one, Che Harth) la oompletely suitable for life. Pwo more (In adjioent orblta) 5II*.I*I*‘ ■!•••• t ia« haa axtremely rigorous living oondltlona and IlIVJ il an unsultabla atmeepbere. Viewed very broadly indeed, thl# oould Been that ea^ star would have a ear lee of plane te so epaoed IS?Ii.III' would have oorreot teigie rat urea, eorrect moisture oontent and atespbere to support ol villa ed life. Let ua ateuma that there la, -.bo the average, ooe habitable plenet per eligible there la no line of reaaonlag or evldenoe whlA can Indicate Whether life will actually develop on a pkanet where the condlCtona Ur'th may be unique ratbar than a randoB a^le. mia writer can only inject aone pereonal Intultlbo into the dliouaalon with the view that Ufa la not uni qua on ^rth, or even the randoB reault of a low probability, but la practically Inaeitable in the rl^t condltlona. Thl a la bo aay, tbe number of Inhabited planeta la e^tal^.to th^^e that are aultablel One Bore Item needs to be eonaldered. Knowing nothing at all a^ut other raoei, we suet aaauBe that Ibin la average aa to technical advanoenent, environmental dlffieultlaa, eto. That la, one hnlf of the other planeta are bhhlnd ua md have no epeoe travel end the other half are ahead and have various levels of apace travel. We can thus imagine that In our eai^le volume there era 11 races of beings who have begun apace explorattona. The formula on oure S ebova nn* UNCLASSiFiZD e UNCLASSiFIED To BUmArlso dl«eutslon thus fu*s th» ctXftOK^ ^ spBoa tMTalapa azlatlog at plaodta attaehad to iMl/^torlng atari la rar; RMoh graater than t}i« obaug^ apaco-travaling Kartlaaa. Ibo OQO eon ba vlavad klaoat aa a eartalnt 7 (if the aaauaiptlona ara aocaptad) » wharaat tba. oCb«* is verj allgbt Indaad. tn odder to ostlmata the relative ohattj^ea that visitor# Troft Sara or atar X oould cone to the Rarth and aet like "fljlng objaota"* soft# dlsousaloA of oharacteriatloa of space ahlpe la neoeaBarx. To handle the al^Xt case first* a. trip fsoa Mars to Sartb should be feasible using a rocket'^pover^ rahlole. Ones herSi the rocket vould* probably use sore fuel In alovlng doan for a lending thnh'lt did in initial takeoff* due to Barth's hlj^er gravltstional foroe* A rough aatlkste of one^vay perfomroe ean be found by sddlng the so-called "eaeape velocity" of Mars to that of the Barth plue the total energy ohanga {kinetic and potential) used In changing froB one planetary orbit to the otber* Tbeee are 5.1* 7.0* and 10.7 Biles per seepnd* respectively* giving e total required perforBanee of 20.8 »ilea per second for a one-way flight. Barring a suicide, nlasion, the vehicle aould have to land and repleniah or else carry a 100 ^ reserve for the trip hone. Let us assuBS the Martians have developed a nueXear, hydrogen* propelled vehicle ver- tically.' V (b)' Fuel resarvea. It it hard to see bow a sln.fla rocket ship could carry enough extra fuel to oake repeated deaoenta into the larth'e ataoepbers. .^e large ouaber of flying objects reported in quick auccesaion could. only aean a large aunber of visiting craft. two pos alb 111 ties thus are presented. First, a number oV space ships could have costa as a ;roup. This would only bs done If full* dress contact were to be eetabllebad. Second, nuaerous snail oraft . ai^t’dascand froB a Bptbar abip vhioh coaste around the Earth in a satellite orbit. BuV this could atao that ths smaller orsft would have tc be rooketa ef aAtAUlte perfomanoe, and to contain them the ssethor ship would have to be truly enonsoua. * (o) Appearance. A vertloally deacanding rocket might well V appear as a lualnoue disk to a person directly below. Obeervare sit distanre, howeva^ would! surely Identify the rooket for what it really is. niere ^uld p^bably be more reports of oblique views ttiikn of si^'On views. Ofjeoursa, the shape need not be typical of our ro'okstss ^t the exhaust should be easy to see. UNCl/wSiflED 5-11750- S-U’50 UNCLi^oSlFlED UNCLASSIFIED 01 * t*o tddltloaH gorwptl poMrlca mj be relevant to «p*4oe ehlpe ee "nylng ohjeote", Ibe dlstMbatloa of flylns objeote 1« 'peouller. to eay the leut. le fer as ttle writer knows, «ll iBC^- . dents have ooourred within ttie United dtates. whereas visiting. »psje- MA could he expeoted to'eoatter their visits oore or less unlforwy over the globe. The sea 11 area covered indies tee strongly that the ~tljixk^ objeots sre of ISarthly origin, whether physioal or pyehologto al The leek of purpose eppsrent In the various episodes is 'also pussllng. Only one aotlve oan be easlgnedt that the apaee-^nen are vfsellAB out" our defsnaae vltbont wanting to ba belligerent. Tf so, they nuat have been .satisfied long ago that we can't , oatob thee. It seees fruitless for thee to keep .repeating the saee eaperieent. Conclualonai s Although visits froe outer spaoe are selieved to be posalble, they are bslleved to ba very l^rooabie. particular, the aetlons attributed to the "flyl,ng obtests" reported during 1947 and 1948 seen tnoonsi stent with the requl resents for spaoe travel. Tery truly yours, * I^SLssp - ^ ■*^*^!?^"iarth, boon sod Planets*, by P.L.fhlppls. Harvard Books on. Aslronoey|^Bls1jlston,^im Ooldbor»c, Alter; Harvard Books on Aatrono^, BlsWstw,^1943^^ Stare", by Cambell and Jaochla, Hsr- «*rd Books on Astronoey, Hlaklston, 1945. . . _ 4. "The Milky lay", by Bok and Bok, Harvard Books on Astronoey, Blaklston^lB^.^^^ propertlos of Hydrogen Propellant at Hl^ Tswper atures. Data prdvldid to RAID by Dr. Altean. then at JPL. ^published, 6. "The Uas of Atoelo Power for Rockets", by R, Sorter, Ipp^dl* IV Second Quarterly Repert, RA-1S004. Douglas Aircraft Co., Inc., Project *^**^ 7. "Oalaxtei", by Shapley, Harlow; Harvard Books on Astronoey, Blaklston 1943. unclassified Ltr fr B«, Sftucer** mix Co."^fv*» 'rlc^«i Sr7t«n*0Mo AU^<>-«i k»Tat« l« Iftfarv'Uea tn >aslo laitcf* 01IAOS AKP ■uvx *iTAi: or VOftnC'iriATifU e/Fic«t4 ^ ^ptacb*r 19ij7 T3NU0-2S SlTBJaCTi •riTlng DUc" 4 TOi Ccwaandlf^ G^Mnkl Air Forces Kashington 25, D. c* ATTKi AC/a« ^«»r Ooftjral Ooorgo UcDon id » tki »iCh .C.»o Coiorwl H, y * 'Jrtwlng «»t a rocord bo kopt ©/ Kith rtgnatoroo a«d*tfaU; 2* Ihio draHa^ ; •opvod its furpost so CO Hi. VSG for off r*ctaJJi”ot.rA'So iror'lSit J*"’ invitod ttng aad Aceor.pli,hsonts t«s5d 5, fkroeraph U rod 6. 6, fbra,-rspA 1 am 7^^ 26, Hr^iritth 5 «d 10, 27, fOrajrcfb 12, f*60 2d, ftiragrsfftfl i 3 U, I^otcgrof* of Porobola UNCLASSIFIED 0-399112 »BD AT S YEAR iNTERVALfi OTEir-aiTER 12 YEAM. . X)OS> DIR^ 62£KI.10 UNCLASSIF c o P I 083ic Itr, dtd 24 Sup 47, to CC, H 4 tuoh, »obJ, si,e- £• 69, Ibe dcrUA VI fj, H. 1^6«» n T?, Of tho Kortan n Version,; Pago OroUng «f tho •Pnrabolt**, Th^do^ont aOp«ld_al*o bo m««,o*, Raea>«b • wolopr^nt Jttjcr Cor.or*! t. C* Cr^glo i \ ; ,r • 1. ConflrBdnt tb« r-^cor.t c-nvwatl<<» «f^« wwirfilfsflj — KaJot Coooral I.# C. CrAlei** 9 4i. . L ^ \ 'b DNOJ^SSIFIEQ Aia vAtiya. oowaxs nnis-r 3/ -rtcht m,a>cruri,o 24 B«pt 47 V$I7A9^33 •nylftg taac«rs* Cor--n'1la5 iin^rnl. Apnr Air •Wnjtja ** li Oftl ^rr«tA AT7SI t4 ra«a«nl«4 that tMa off tea 'Ae foratabcA cU^YAlUUa ftfofr.%‘.Un c«MtxolT»« ikUa^ae -rirl4« 5^waf tUrMt ilrhUjT ft At by r. ra4*r ttatlom I® Ja?®®. «itt iBClA-'ftt vai BtAtltaU bj f* CJv.rltt CArroil iarltfs ® tonftraftca i* *fU 0*® SchalgM « £f\6fl o.iUr>M by A.C. U«»«liwr, **3 r#j>f#tatiUU«. P« P . 6pt'*.sb»'y .i9A7« ruft TRj. ciin**.*^;Dl6C »» .*uti /«/ H.z.vtn . /»/ B,r;.r4r of *u ’* ,*' ^l’’* "■*'•’• 'in ^' Vfh >l t-->iu,; '.rfllt:.,, I?. Wl^HnJ Sy Off.-: ■ M -v., Ijuall nc«,:i .',v * r-;;*r.anf a fiyj ^.| .tU •'W.-K aU., >• 2t la fiirthfi- C.-*t ih •4.U? tii^ plotting or *u is lcrt:.| A^.orio*^. liwid*8t*. blit -Ml ■ or fit* ba tdiisod ao to ppo^^ U»o laflnon^a to BD AT 8 TEAR IK^T A APTKR 12 YEARS. fWCLASSiFIED Lt C/>\ InCorfloa ct AP7M ua) • HU WF, Kawlrswn 2J. » Saj.Un^r 1V«T • ^ * Ccr.-iadins Tr^itiir.:. Cc. ' . 't A o d, CvkstJU* * I / ’ tnnTTsLtUi l-crcsUb In d* ifil* P*‘ orC«r to pT9rid9 year Cor^i.-o«s • < 2 j;>U 3. t‘h«7i fhitoetatlrs Wd* rcteri-*d f bo eoTXO-^lotti If tn* «xtr% oot 1^ fo «t tho 04 ".« tl--« •»»* r'bnrr.'S ' i»» riia ^ AS i^outbls ts Cds r^dyt’^aibo Dtri’^tw, CoUocttoo CT av^*.n& or o-tdol £P^TZt DOWNGRArEU AT 3 Vj: wi jv- i'hvaTR» DBCUSSmSD AFTER lE YEARa ^ DODDlRftSOoaO UNQ-ASSI^^ OrfSCBSYbfRCI. OBaOS AMO ltf:o o^i'tccr.A opUon thU CcMM e» o . •siMPO* «f ih»i^ 0b>el*» 5. li U nc v mm nM W»%«- U3^*J?S Mc Md 4N0\^1947 >t)rlac Chl«f 9t tta%M ilr f^rP9 tubjMt ^ 9h9f%, d«M 19 rvfUMM 4«Ue« W 9«k«a t* *fpro 114 • *l%h t>« •UMtft«*tl«B "••vn ««a B«b«r !• M etll9m$ CM99M mt 7SK coiiwjR)i)ro emit B« U, |»C01 Chi*/ «f Za«*UlfM* prlmt*d irTi^blr la Kf ?SS£" 4« 1 %ri«f 4%<%Ms% VI Jjj. IW. *8/*M. r*cu4Uc OlMd W(* il^[«U 4 'tdi It It furtter Mac Mt «■ III* pUniM IftTlr U ftrth AMrita« it fUi% iteit iatUiatt. ^ut k la • fljriAC Am M iMd at. alat MifMte 4 Hdt tfAM W iT «U flylac Am ImIMM «r 4 M*. ~ aU«f«tM 4 tMt tr. C 4 TMU m« ^ ««« rv«gir *4 mcm 41 ^ •• w*> m nmuBiuo anwai ,, L^' H. >t. «^r ip«p.r «Up|iU(i e«U-» l. Hr Onr* lirttlUca Af f^ y CO Nt v 57 1 coiled HU 0 Pnoddy, vho U Cblet', Aosloletrotlvf* Reference Branch, Hall 8G>1 Records Hsoa^eveat Oieisloo, Ajr AjJ Offjre, B 9 L’SAf (extenslco 7^35)- APCAO-22. MjhS Snoddy Is trying to Utcate letter ircm C/S, USAF, dated 30 Dec Uk, subject; "Flying Dlscr". i« riAWfkttMWM Ur mr%m, Oklm S W vov* CkMr. *lr ■•fctMf lain- Ur f»••• nr--^ — ». 6. •*«i »i I, mUm nf^ ^ - 4 f^f ♦•ll**tt**» IftwrtV* >»>Tw •# ^ *•**••• ■■? _ _ _ ftkA flftVV r^Sjtrfw .^??y,,;!L:2r>n»ri><.> r.»-^ - r^*i- «uM terrlM. t>w »»•» . MTki^ Nfrri««* pwr¥«***» » _ . - ■ . «M »iy *'• _ •*'««■■ •r.TU.* Uftr^tU" • Ulbltt WUMOa'^ •••< 44* •kWh 4M 52i5 Miii^ Sryg. ;«> t M* 4^ I & s S £ » n 9 s m )H 19 196 19 fV T> c fr 9 iS M WT»(»9 . su Urf 1§ IS t««4i01-ft 4 Wi UB* ChiMt, iir WMtter Ihftbias^ 25» t» C* M4l fba fora mA is vltzMMi ^ itshtlsc* U 1mU«» 4 ft» 4 Mn«r af iBtmat. CftMt m to pMoibU «C ^ "EiMtUl UmM «r Urawiltfi* in Mford to rontiQ* ^saptU Ullm nicbta ia lsTit«4« $4 It y rsMfM y*t aofTOiypnionn# ta famrdaA y tho BMAquMrtora# Air Uatorloi CoMnd, attoatloB fOK tB cosiiiDiva anBULi ft XmUi Ua WB eaplsa f»r»l«haA» APOtt. BAT Bft ff«tMakl« ^^iqraya U» «Rlaf Mu« mwm Oalatsl 1^ BUM /«/ l« ft. CUn^n*a» Ooi* VftiT far a. ft. ftaCdr Moaol, VUf 0ki»f« IstaUMaBoa Dapt tU *uOc r > % Dr^BHK*d,irAWTICnS SSfUCTH) FRCH nOfBCT (sajta REPORT. ficuiaT ism %m «• eif» fMkoU&ityi fU. tr« S0» Sl« «» H. 41. 4i, 60. «», TO, 94, 9», 94, 9T, 99, lOl# l«a* lOS, 104, lU, 192, )», 140, H7, U9, M, 1T4, IM, Ito, 14T, W, 909, 904, 206, 216, 919, SM« s lUr 6 T 1 «« ^robftbUUyt ^4, 20, 29, 24 , 26, 2b, 26, 46, £0, CS, 6T, 62, 98, ICO, lU, 120, Ul, m, 120, 144, 162, 16;., 166, UT, Ifb, 192, 199, 202, 206, 220, 220, 240. I, V«ai^tr«04Ale4l tut •au#iU'»4 •t e^hw uplufttleBt 4, lullMtu «r •rdlmry tlrur^i It, 11, 22, 41, 42, 62, M, T2, 91, 22, 91, 91, 118, 114, lib, 124, lU. 126, 141, 14$, U6, 166, U7, 169, 160, 161, 162, 169, m, 1T8, m, 160, 122, 126, 190, 194, 196, 199, 196, 100, 201, 209, 210, m, 221, 286, 227, 289. ftaktU, fUr«4 «r fulllac to41««( _ _ |4, 6, 9, f, 9, 9, 12, U, 14, U, U, 26, 66, 66, 79, 100, lOT, 229, 109, 122, ITO, 111, 216. •« ■lM#ll4M«wi (fullMtleM, Mrertl ttrMntrt, 61H#, 999, 92, 122, m, 129, 149, IM, 621, 129, 214, 221, 181, 224. 2. te^ifUMAlMl, Ultlk BO Ufl4M>tteA UVlOOBt Lftok 4f 4vl4«B04 pruolttOot MylWMtloa* #99, 44^ 46, 47, 96, 67, T2, 99, 97, 98, 90, 99, llO, 117, 119, U9, 129, 127, 199, 149, 169, 177, 176, 191, 206 , 218, 212, 219, 222, 222. thUW «rr«r 44 t«Cfi» 4 t 4 64 OXplBMttMl n* 2. 10, 17, 21, »• 27, 40, 61, 12, 89, 91, 92, 94, 99, 71, 76, 19. 77, 79, 98, 106, lU, 122, 169, 161, 111, lU, 192, 199, 179, 179, 162, 199, 192, 907, 216, 229, 224, HI, 229, m, 224, Ml, 262, 246, 244, 164. . , 4 I i 4 i i 4