How Patients' Inquiry Shapes Meaning in Primary Care Consultations: A Qualitative Study Using Own‐Point‐of‐View Video‐Stimulated Recall Authors: Louis‐Baptiste Jaunay, Anne‐Sophie Ivanoff, Corentin Philippot, Emmanuel Triby, Thierry Pelaccia Published: 2026 ABSTRACT ABSTRACTRationaleMedical consultations are collaborative encounters in which physicians and patients jointly address health concerns and make decisions. While most research has focused on physicians' clinical reasoning, decision‐making is increasingly viewed as a form of situated cognition, distributed across individuals and their interactions. However, the patient's perspective on how they make sense of their health problems remains underexamined.Aim and ObjectivesThe aim of this study was to investigate how patients experience and make sense of their health problems before and during a primary care consultation.MethodsWe conducted video‐stimulated recall interviews with patients after their consultations. Consultations were recorded from the patient's perspective using wearable camera glasses. Each interview comprised two parts: (a) an explicitation interview exploring the patient's experience and reasoning before the consultation, and (b) a video‐based stimulated recall to analyze their experience during the consultation. We performed an abductive thematic analysis using Dewey's theory of inquiry.ResultsTwelve interviews were analyzed. Patients engaged in an inquiry process before the consultation, involving the identification of a problematic situation, hypothesis generation and the exploration of potential actions and interactions. During the consultation, patients interpreted the physician's messages as confirmations, refinements or refutations of their own hypotheses. They attempted to infer the physician's reasoning and its underlying assumptions. Patients' acceptance and integration of medical explanations depended on the coherence between these explanations and the trajectory of their own inquiry.ConclusionPatients interpret the physician's messages in light of their own inquiry, which can be described according to John Dewey's pattern of inquiry. The physician's ability to recognize where the patient stands within their inquiry and to make clinical reasoning explicit appears central to knowledge sharing and decision‐making. These findings suggest new orientations for communication training in primary care, emphasizing physicians' capacity to identify and support patients' inquiry processes. Background Medical consultations are fundamentally oriented toward addressing the patient's health problems [1]. These problems may be raised by the physician (the doctor's agenda) or by the patient (the patient's agenda) [2]. Throughout the consultation, the interaction shapes and is shaped by the evolving reasoning processes of both the patient and the physician [3]. This is one pathway through which consultations can affect patients' health positively [4, 5] or negatively [6, 7]. Although many studies have examined physicians' clinical reasoning during consultations, recent approaches increasingly view decision‐making as arising from a situated, distributed process involving patients and physicians, the interactions between them and the context in which those interactions occur [8, 9, 10]. Knowledge thus emerges through exchanges of meaning and action, making knowledge sharing central to decision‐making—not as decontextualized information transfer, but as situated co‐construction between actors who make sense of the situation differently [11, 12, 13, 14]. However, one limitation identified in the patient‐centered care literature is its focus on discrete aspects of patient experience, such as reasons for consultation, and on outcomes such as satisfaction, rather than on experience as an unfolding process [15]. In response, calls have been made for a shift toward relationship‐centered care (RCC), which foregrounds interaction itself as an unfolding relational process through which patients' experiences are shaped [16]. Understanding their sense‐making may help clinicians align care with experiential knowledge and expectations, while recognizing patients' capacity to contribute to both the management of their health problems and patient safety [17]. Patients' experiences and sense‐making processes remain largely opaque because they involve substantial implicit and tacit activity [17, 18]. Their decisions—which are central to models of shared decision‐making—therefore cannot be regarded as entirely intentional or fully conscious [16]. Yet few studies have examined the patient's own process of making sense of their health problems during a consultation. The influence of this process is particularly salient in primary care, where patients typically make decisions that lead to appointments, shape their engagement during the consultation and influence their subsequent behaviors, including adherence. This study sought to answer the following question: How do patients experience and make sense of the health problems that lead them to seek primary care, before and during the consultation? Methods Theoretical Approach Because no single established framework fully captures how patients make sense of their health problems as an unfolding process, we adopted an abductive approach combining conceptualization and field observations [19, 20]. We sought to understand patients' experience of their health problems by drawing upon John Dewey's philosophy of experience [21]. According to Dewey, experience refers to the significance that emerges through interactions with the environment over time [22, 23]. When individuals identify a disruption in the continuity of experience, they engage in inquiry to transform a problematic situation into one sufficiently determinate to guide action. They generate hypotheses and examine their anticipated consequences, which shape the subsequent course of the interaction. Inquiry involves several partially overlapping phases: (1) identifying a problematic situation, (2) defining the problem, (3) developing hypotheses, (4) examining their consequences and (5) testing solutions through action [21]. This framework is currently widely used in the French‐speaking field of experience studies to analyze work activity and professional development, particularly in healthcare [24]. It is particularly well‐suited to examining how patients experience and make sense of their health problems because Dewey conceived his theory of inquiry as applicable to diverse problematic situations and as encompassing the active and passive, bodily and cognitive, episodic and prolonged, as well as implicit and explicit dimensions of experience. Previous studies have illustrated its value for studying patients' perspectives. [25, 26, 27, 28, 29]. Setting and Recruitment We conducted a multicenter qualitative study between March 2023 and September 2025 in France. We initially recruited general practitioners (GPs) through convenience sampling because participation required acceptance of video recording. The researcher was not familiar with the selected sites beforehand. Participating physicians provided written consent to be filmed during the consultation and identified patients willing to participate. As analysis progressed, patient recruitment was iteratively adjusted through purposive sampling to diversify participant profiles. Patients were eligible if they were aged 18 years or older, fluent in French, capable of providing informed consent and willing to wear camera glasses during the consultation and take part in an audio‐recorded interview. Recruitment continued until we judged the data sufficient to support the thematic analysis. We conducted and reported our research following the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ) checklist (see Appendix S1) [30]. Data Collection We collected data through interviews with patients after their consultation with a GP. The consultation was recorded from the patient's subjective perspective using a head‐mounted camera, allowing the reconstruction of the human natural field of view (Figure 1) [31]. Only the GP was filmed. The choice to use a subjective‐perspective recording via camera glasses (rather than by an external camera filming the patient and physician from an observer's point of view, as in video elicitation [32], for example) aimed to avoid participants' tendency to focus on the judgment of their own behavior [33]. Video and audio recording device during consultation: patient wearing camera glasses/image captured (GP). Prior to their appointment, patients provided written consent and were equipped with camera glasses to wear upon entering the GP's office. We conducted the interview in a dedicated enclosed area, immediately after the consultation or within 8 days, at the patient's convenience, in accordance with previous studies [34, 35, 36]. The interview comprised two parts. The first part aimed to explore the patients' experience of their health problems prior to the consultation, using the explicitation interview (EI) method [37]. This method guides participants to relive a specific past experience situated in time and space through open questions focused on their perceptions and actions [38, 39]. EI explores both the active and passive dimensions of patients' experience, enables detailed descriptions of mental and behavioral activity, makes implicit aspects of reasoning explicit and limits retrospective interpretations [23, 40]. It is considered by some authors to be the most appropriate interview method for exploring lived experience [41] and has yielded significant results in understanding patient experience across various conditions [42, 43, 44, 45, 46]. The second part of the interview focused on the experience during the consultation, using the video recording of the encounter (Figure 2). This recording supported the interview according to the method known as subjective re‐situ interview, derived from EI [33, 47, 48]. This video capture aimed to (a) act as a mnemonic trigger, stimulating the patient's re‐experiencing of the event, (b) provide a shared observable for both the patient and the researcher, allowing the latter to understand the context and (c) provide a video record of the physician's observable activity [33]. The video was paused at the patient's request, or whenever they reacted verbally or nonverbally, as well as when the researcher identified elements requiring exploration. Second part of the interview: subjective re‐situ interview about the experience during the consultation. Examples of interview prompts for each part of the interview are provided in Table 1. Table 1Interview guide.Part of the interviewFirstSecondAim of explorationExperience of health problems prior to the consultation Experience of health problems during the consultation Use of video as interview supportNoYesInterview methodExplicitation interview [37, 38, 39]Subjective re‐situ interview [33, 47, 48]Introductory prompt“I propose, if you agree, that we return to the moment when you decided to make an appointment”.“I propose, if you agree, that we watch the video together; as soon as something comes back to you from that moment, please tell me and I will pause the video”.Examples of interview prompts “What comes back to you from that moment?”“When you are in that situation, what do you do?”“What is happening for you at this moment?” “What is happening for you when the doctor says that?”“What goes through your mind at that moment?”“What are you trying to do when you say that?” John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Interview guide. “What comes back to you from that moment?”“When you are in that situation, what do you do?”“What is happening for you at this moment?” “What comes back to you from that moment?” “What comes back to you from that moment?” “When you are in that situation, what do you do?” “When you are in that situation, what do you do?” “What is happening for you at this moment?” “What is happening for you at this moment?” “What is happening for you when the doctor says that?”“What goes through your mind at that moment?”“What are you trying to do when you say that?” “What is happening for you when the doctor says that?” “What is happening for you when the doctor says that?” “What goes through your mind at that moment?” “What goes through your mind at that moment?” “What are you trying to do when you say that?” “What are you trying to do when you say that?” Interviews were audio‐recorded, fully transcribed, anonymized and sent to participants for feedback. The interview guide was refined iteratively. All interviews were conducted by L.‐B.J., who has qualitative research experience and formal EI training (Groupe de recherche sur l'Explicitation, GREX). Data Analysis Our research team consisted of a male GP with 10 years of practice and experience in conducting and supervising qualitative research and engaged in a PhD in educational science on the topic of this article (L.‐B.J.), a female GP with 15 years of practice and experience in conducting qualitative research (A.‐S.I.), a male GP resident involved in a medical doctoral thesis about patient experience (C.P.), a male professor of emergency medicine with 25 years of practice, holding a PhD in educational science (T.P.) and a male emeritus professor in education, former vice‐dean of the Faculty of Educational Sciences (E.T.). We conducted an abductive thematic analysis informed by the data and Dewey's theory of inquiry [19, 20]. During the interpretative phase, the emerging categories were examined in relation to Dewey's conceptualization of inquiry, allowing us to organize themes according to the temporal unfolding and phases of patients' inquiry while remaining grounded in participants' accounts. The interviews were first coded independently by L.‐B.J., A.‐S.I. and C.P., then analyzed with T.P. and E.T. to discuss interpretations. Disagreements about coding were discussed and revised until consensus was reached. Ethical Approval This project was reviewed and approved by the Ethics Committee for Research Integrity and Education in Health Professions of the International Francophone Society for Medical Education (SIFEM) on 22 March 2023. Results Participant Characteristics We conducted 12 interviews (Table 2). Patients ranged in age from 18 to 72 years; eight were women, and four were men. They had been followed by their respective GP for between 18 months and 10 years. The time elapsed between the initial appearance of the main reasons for consultation and the consultation itself ranged from 3 days to 50 years. Interviews ranged from 32 to 121 min, averaging 89 min. GPs ranged in age from 30 to 73 years; five were women, and five were men. They practiced in urban (n = 8) and rural (n = 2) settings and had between 2 and 49 years of clinical experience. Patients are identified by pseudonyms. Table 2Patient characteristics. N° (pseudonym)AgeSexMain activityMain reasons for consultationSymptom‐to‐consultation intervalInterview duration (min)P1 (Ann)72FRetiredHeadaches1.5 months45P2 (Tom)33MPublic sector managerLeg pain that appeared while running1 month52P3 (Eva)36FClerkRenewal of therapeutic part‐time work after cervical cancer2.5 years96P4 (Joy)56FDirectorObesity50 years121P5 (Liv)66FRetiredBurning sensation in the throat5 months120P6 (Max)61MChocolatierAntihypertensive prescription renewal and review of follow‐up blood test results10 years84P7 (Jim)66MRetiredFollow‐up after diverticulitis6 months32P8 (Zoe)18FStudentFever, fatigue, sore throat, muscle soreness, headache8 days98P9 (Yan)34MNotary clerkCystic fibrosis34 years87P10 (Emy)49FAccountantSick leave due to an employer conflict10 days121P11 (Sue)30FManagerSick leave renewal for work‐related psychological distress5 weeks89P12 (Noa)38FCareer transitionCough4 days118John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Patient characteristics. Themes Our analysis was informed by Dewey's theory of inquiry. Specifically, the two overarching themes represent the temporal unfolding of patients' inquiry before and during the consultation, whereas the subthemes reflect the dynamic and iterative process of inquiry described by Dewey: the identification and definition of a problematic situation, the generation of hypotheses and anticipation of their consequences, the testing of solutions through action and the construction of meaning through interactions (Table 3). Table 3Themes, subthemes and codes.ThemesSubthemesCodesExperience prior to the consultationIdentifying problems as disruptions in usual experiencePerception of unusual sensationsUncertainty and indeterminacyDesignation of problems as constraintsGenerating hypothesesFormulation of multiple hypothesesMobilization of experiential knowledgeDiagnostic/therapeutic self‐actionsAnticipation of consequencesInteractions to progress inquirySeeking external inputRevising hypotheses through current experienceDecision to consultExpectations for clarification and reliefExperience during the consultationInterpreting the physician's identification of problemsComparing a physician's assessment with one's ownDeciphering the physician's reasoningInferring physician's reasoning and underlying hypothesesMisunderstandingsClarificationsEmergence of knowledgeActivation of tacit experiential knowledgeIntegration with medical explanationsProjecting future evolution and recoveryJohn Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Themes, subthemes and codes. We observed that when consulting, patients were already engaged in an inquiry concerning their health problem: they had identified disruptions in their usual experience, constructed hypotheses grounded in experiential knowledge, explored actions or interactions (including that of making an appointment) and anticipated what the consultation might provide. During the consultation, patients interpreted the physician's reasoning through the lens of this prior inquiry. Their reception of the physician's messages depended on (1) how well these messages resonated with their ongoing inquiry and (2) how they interpreted the physician's reasoning and the underlying hypotheses. To illustrate these findings, we selected verbatim excerpts. Quotes from participant P8 (Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) are used to provide a narrative thread, while excerpts from other participants broaden the illustration of each code. The Experience Prior to the Consultation Identifying Problems as Disruptions in Usual Experience Patients described the beginning of their inquiry as emerging from a concrete situation in everyday life in which something disrupted the continuity of their usual experience. Rather than recognizing a health problem immediately, they first noticed bodily sensations, emotions or events that no longer fit with what they considered normal.I was coming back from university, and I felt like I was going to be sick, because I felt it in my body, I was starting to have a bit of muscle aches.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) I was coming back from university, and I felt like I was going to be sick, because I felt it in my body, I was starting to have a bit of muscle aches. A pain I had never felt before… At the time, I thought to myself, I don't know what this is, maybe it's… Given the area, I wasn't sure… It's 3 a.m., we'll see in 4 hours.(P2: Tom, 33, manager; running‐related leg pain) A pain I had never felt before… At the time, I thought to myself, I don't know what this is, maybe it's… Given the area, I wasn't sure… It's 3 a.m., we'll see in 4 hours. However, because these situations could not be immediately interpreted, they generated uncertainty and indeterminacy.In fact, I really felt fatigue, the beginning of a sore throat, and my body, I could hardly control it anymore […] I spent really 48 h without sleeping… I was sweating a lot because the fever was going up, it was going down.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) In fact, I really felt fatigue, the beginning of a sore throat, and my body, I could hardly control it anymore […] I spent really 48 h without sleeping… I was sweating a lot because the fever was going up, it was going down. I am just… stunned [reading the email] the first time, and it really hit me hard. […] I carried on with my day, but I wasn't okay, you know? I was physically there, but my mind wasn't. I feel trapped, stuck in this situation, and I have no idea how to get out.(P10: Emy, 49, accountant; work‐conflict‐related sick leave) I am just… stunned [reading the email] the first time, and it really hit me hard. […] I carried on with my day, but I wasn't okay, you know? I was physically there, but my mind wasn't. I feel trapped, stuck in this situation, and I have no idea how to get out. Patients framed their problems as constraints that disrupted their usual functioning and hindered their anticipated courses of action.Plus, it's my vacation week, so being sick during vacation… […] I have a lot of pain in my body, in my neck, I couldn't move my neck either. And in fact, the body pains prevented me from sleeping.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) Plus, it's my vacation week, so being sick during vacation… […] I have a lot of pain in my body, in my neck, I couldn't move my neck either. And in fact, the body pains prevented me from sleeping. On Sunday morning I couldn't get out of bed, which was difficult considering I have young children. And all day long it was coughing. I was coughing and coughing, and at night I couldn't sleep.(P12: Noa, 38, career transition; acute cough) On Sunday morning I couldn't get out of bed, which was difficult considering I have young children. And all day long it was coughing. I was coughing and coughing, and at night I couldn't sleep. Taken together, these accounts show that health problems appeared as disruptions in the continuity of patients' interactions with their environment. Patients initially experienced these disruptions without explicitly identifying their situation as problematic. This identification was intertwined with the development of explanatory hypotheses, as the following section shows. Generating Hypotheses Patients generated multiple competing hypotheses, each projecting a different interpretation of the situation together with its anticipated consequences and possible course of action. Rather than selecting a single explanation from the outset, they entertained several, sometimes contradictory, possibilities simultaneously.Because normally muscle aches are either that you've done sports, things like that, and I hadn't done sports this week. So I had no reason to have strong leg aches.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) Because normally muscle aches are either that you've done sports, things like that, and I hadn't done sports this week. So I had no reason to have strong leg aches. I start asking myself all these questions, what should I do? Should I call a lawyer? […] You think, but if, but if I leave, what will I do? And if I quit? What's going on with me? Well, you know, you make up all sorts of scenarios, all these different possibilities….(P10: Emy, 49, accountant; work‐conflict‐related sick leave) I start asking myself all these questions, what should I do? Should I call a lawyer? […] You think, but if, but if I leave, what will I do? And if I quit? What's going on with me? Well, you know, you make up all sorts of scenarios, all these different possibilities…. These accounts illustrate that some hypotheses were explicitly articulated, whereas others remained tacit. As patients developed hypotheses, experiential knowledge was spontaneously mobilized to enrich and assess their plausibility.When I was little, I often got sick, so I know a little bit about the beginnings of illness, I know that when my body is like that, it means I'm getting sick.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) When I was little, I often got sick, so I know a little bit about the beginnings of illness, I know that when my body is like that, it means I'm getting sick. But my father had cholesterol issues. It was panic mode. Overnight, everyone started eating grilled steaks. Because I was told not to put butter on anything anymore. It's something that kind of stuck with me, you know, I'd say. I'm not traumatized, but it's a childhood memory that came back to me.(P6: Max, 61, chocolatier; hypertension follow‐up) But my father had cholesterol issues. It was panic mode. Overnight, everyone started eating grilled steaks. Because I was told not to put butter on anything anymore. It's something that kind of stuck with me, you know, I'd say. I'm not traumatized, but it's a childhood memory that came back to me. We observed that, in addition to emerging from experiential knowledge, patients' hypotheses were connected to possible diagnostic and therapeutic actions that contributed to confirming, challenging or refining their understanding of the situation.So I took my temperature directly, but in the end it wasn't [exercise‐related soreness], it was a fever. […] I took my meds and tried to sleep, but it wasn't happening. So I just watched a movie.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) So I took my temperature directly, but in the end it wasn't [exercise‐related soreness], it was a fever. […] I took my meds and tried to sleep, but it wasn't happening. So I just watched a movie. I connected with my son, I mean, when [the salbutamol] opens his airways, so it should work the same way for adults. And I'm going to… self‐medicate, I'll do that to relieve my symptoms, just until the appointment, you know?(P12: Noa, 38, career transition; acute cough) I connected with my son, I mean, when [the salbutamol] opens his airways, so it should work the same way for adults. And I'm going to… self‐medicate, I'll do that to relieve my symptoms, just until the appointment, you know? As part of their ongoing sense‐making process, patients' hypotheses not only guided possible actions but also involved anticipating the consequences that different interpretations of their situation could lead to.I know I'm going for another two weeks, I'm going to be sick. I'm going to have to stay stuck at home, yeah.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) I know I'm going for another two weeks, I'm going to be sick. I'm going to have to stay stuck at home, yeah. So I thought to myself, oh no, that's it, I'm done for. My cholesterol has skyrocketed. And now they're going to put me on a diet. Anyway, you imagine all sorts of things.(P6: Max, 61, chocolatier; hypertension follow‐up) So I thought to myself, oh no, that's it, I'm done for. My cholesterol has skyrocketed. And now they're going to put me on a diet. Anyway, you imagine all sorts of things. Among these actions, patients engaged in interactions that shaped the ongoing process of making sense of their situation. Interactions to Progress Inquiry As the inquiry unfolded, interactions with digital tools or people in their social environment reshaped patients' hypotheses and subsequent decisions.ChatGPT I told it I had body aches, headache, fever of 39 since the day before, I explain a little bit about all that and I say ‘what do I have?’ and so it lists ‘meningitis, flu’, it marks the symptoms of each disease.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) ChatGPT I told it I had body aches, headache, fever of 39 since the day before, I explain a little bit about all that and I say ‘what do I have?’ and so it lists ‘meningitis, flu’, it marks the symptoms of each disease. When I talked to my little neighbor [a surgical student]. I told him about my knees because they are completely gone. He told me, ‘We won't operate on you like that; there's too much risk. You need to lose some weight’. He was kind of the trigger for all of this.(P4: Joy, 56, director; obesity) When I talked to my little neighbor [a surgical student]. I told him about my knees because they are completely gone. He told me, ‘We won't operate on you like that; there's too much risk. You need to lose some weight’. He was kind of the trigger for all of this. The hypotheses generated through these interactions were evaluated in relation to the ongoing experience, contributing to their refinement and subsequent decisions.At first I was a little stressed with the meningitis but I said to myself ‘I think that if I really had meningitis my neck wouldn't be like it is now’.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) The next day, I call the diet center to say, ‘Here it is. This is what's happening to me. I've gained weight’.(P4: Joy, 56, director; obesity) At first I was a little stressed with the meningitis but I said to myself ‘I think that if I really had meningitis my neck wouldn't be like it is now’. The next day, I call the diet center to say, ‘Here it is. This is what's happening to me. I've gained weight’. Among the interactions patients chose to initiate, consulting a GP could help advance an inquiry that was no longer progressing satisfactorily.This morning, I woke up really with an infected eye, we tried to move the appointment forward to today and so we came here.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) This morning, I woke up really with an infected eye, we tried to move the appointment forward to today and so we came here. If I had just limped, I wouldn't have said ‘I'm going to see the doctor immediately’. It's the fact of being so limited, I said to myself ‘it's not just a small twist or a muscle that's pulled too much’. I said to myself ‘it must be something else’.(P2: Tom, 33, manager; running‐related leg pain) If I had just limped, I wouldn't have said ‘I'm going to see the doctor immediately’. It's the fact of being so limited, I said to myself ‘it's not just a small twist or a muscle that's pulled too much’. I said to myself ‘it must be something else’. The prospect of the appointment with the GP generated expectations related to both decision‐making and relief, through a better understanding of the situation and opportunities for healing.See the doctor to perhaps see the evolution and is it… What medication am I going to be able to take maybe in addition to heal myself… Also it's a bit to reassure me to know a little more what I have to heal myself faster.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) See the doctor to perhaps see the evolution and is it… What medication am I going to be able to take maybe in addition to heal myself… Also it's a bit to reassure me to know a little more what I have to heal myself faster. Well it's especially to be able to have a… Something that stops the headaches… And to understand too. Because I thought it was a question of tension but it could be something else.(P1: Ann, 72, retired; persistent headaches) Well it's especially to be able to have a… Something that stops the headaches… And to understand too. Because I thought it was a question of tension but it could be something else. Overall, patients entered the consultation having already engaged in an inquiry shaped by their experiential knowledge, interactions and evolving hypotheses. The consultation represented a continuation of this process. The Experience During the Consultation Interpreting the Physician's Identification of Problems During the consultation, patients interpreted the physician's messages in light of their prior inquiry. They compared the physician's identification of the problem with the understanding they had progressively constructed before the consultation.GP [consultation record]: My thermometer says you've still got 38, though. P [interview]: I'm shocked. I really didn't think I had a fever, actually. 38 isn't that high, but it's still a fever. […] So I'm thinking, it still hasn't gone away, really(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) When I explain to her, she is surprised that the pain is still there, still almost as persistent.(P2: Tom, 33, manager; running‐related leg pain) GP [consultation record]: My thermometer says you've still got 38, though. P [interview]: I'm shocked. I really didn't think I had a fever, actually. 38 isn't that high, but it's still a fever. […] So I'm thinking, it still hasn't gone away, really When I explain to her, she is surprised that the pain is still there, still almost as persistent. Deciphering the Physician's Reasoning Patients gave meaning and coherence to the physician's communication; they tried to decipher the inquiry followed by the physician and infer the underlying hypotheses.There he explains a little bit about everything I could have. Although he doesn't really know, in relation to my symptoms, the possible viruses.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) There he explains a little bit about everything I could have. Although he doesn't really know, in relation to my symptoms, the possible viruses. Because in fact she more or less knows why I'm consulting too. As my health problems have had effects on my relationship with my partner, so she asked me if I was okay.(P3: Eva, 36, clerk; post‐cancer work adjustment) Because in fact she more or less knows why I'm consulting too. As my health problems have had effects on my relationship with my partner, so she asked me if I was okay. This sense‐making process could lead to misunderstandings when the physician did not make their reasoning explicit.Well, in fact, I didn't really understand why he was touching my stomach, knowing that I have a sore throat. Since I've already had symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome, I tell myself that maybe…(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) She makes me do an exercise. So you have to extend your hands in front… and close your eyes… Then I asked myself: ‘but why did she make me do that? Does she think I… Is it to check if I haven't been drinking alcohol?’(P1: Ann, 72, retired; persistent headaches) Well, in fact, I didn't really understand why he was touching my stomach, knowing that I have a sore throat. Since I've already had symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome, I tell myself that maybe… She makes me do an exercise. So you have to extend your hands in front… and close your eyes… Then I asked myself: ‘but why did she make me do that? Does she think I… Is it to check if I haven't been drinking alcohol?’ These misunderstandings were resolved when the physician clarified their reasoning. Patients evaluated the physician's hypotheses in light of their current experience.GP [consultation record]: Someone who has swollen glands, a persistent fever and is 18 years old, sometimes it's mononucleosis. It's a virus, you often catch it in adolescence. We drink from the same glass as someone… And that's going to give a sort of tonsillitis, sore throat, swollen glands, significant fatigue and a bit of a lingering fever. P [interview]: There, I also think about everything he says. It's really everything I have. […] Each symptom… I tell myself that it's good, I have mononucleosis.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) And then she told me you don't have a meningeal problem, and you don't have a neurological problem. So I understood that the whole thing about following her finger with my eyes and stretching out my arms or legs was to check for a neurological issue.(P1: Ann, 72, retired; persistent headaches) GP [consultation record]: Someone who has swollen glands, a persistent fever and is 18 years old, sometimes it's mononucleosis. It's a virus, you often catch it in adolescence. We drink from the same glass as someone… And that's going to give a sort of tonsillitis, sore throat, swollen glands, significant fatigue and a bit of a lingering fever. P [interview]: There, I also think about everything he says. It's really everything I have. […] Each symptom… I tell myself that it's good, I have mononucleosis. And then she told me you don't have a meningeal problem, and you don't have a neurological problem. So I understood that the whole thing about following her finger with my eyes and stretching out my arms or legs was to check for a neurological issue. Emergence of Knowledge The physician's messages brought previously tacit experiential knowledge into awareness by triggering memories of past experiences. In doing so, they could prompt comparisons that informed the evaluation of diagnostic hypotheses or elicit emotions associated with those experiences.So there I thought directly of one of my friends who had had that. It's the first thing I said to myself. […] He didn't necessarily come to class anymore because he was super tired. So, that… When I compare, I tell myself that I'm also very tired. So it's possible that it's that. […] And now, I did think about the fact that I'd drunk from someone's bottle. All those moments…(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) When she says to me ‘I'm looking’, indeed, the report of the second operation… I think of… When the surgeon told me… Made me come back and told me ‘Sorry… Finally we're going to have to do a hysterectomy’. There I think back to that and that's why… Tears started to well up.(P3: Eva, 36, clerk; post‐cancer work adjustment) So there I thought directly of one of my friends who had had that. It's the first thing I said to myself. […] He didn't necessarily come to class anymore because he was super tired. So, that… When I compare, I tell myself that I'm also very tired. So it's possible that it's that. […] And now, I did think about the fact that I'd drunk from someone's bottle. All those moments… When she says to me ‘I'm looking’, indeed, the report of the second operation… I think of… When the surgeon told me… Made me come back and told me ‘Sorry… Finally we're going to have to do a hysterectomy’. There I think back to that and that's why… Tears started to well up. During the consultation, patients' individual experiences could become integrated with general medical knowledge, thereby giving the situation greater coherence.Well that reassures me in fact. I tell myself that I might finally be able to be cured because after a week I'm a bit fed up of being sick.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) Then, when he said, um… 'maybe it's the stomach nerve,' Well, right away it clicked, you know? […] I told him, ‘Maybe that's it.’ And that's when I told him about losing my little cat, […] Now, is that all connected?(P5: Liv, 66, retired; persistent throat burning) Well that reassures me in fact. I tell myself that I might finally be able to be cured because after a week I'm a bit fed up of being sick. Then, when he said, um… 'maybe it's the stomach nerve,' Well, right away it clicked, you know? […] I told him, ‘Maybe that's it.’ And that's when I told him about losing my little cat, […] Now, is that all connected? As a result of the diagnostic interpretations, patients could anticipate possible trajectories of their health condition and consider possibilities for healing.Afterwards I know he told me that this disease was, he gave me the example of how it was a flu, but with much less intensity. So I know that the disease will evolve… I'm going to be able to eat better, drink better.(P8: Zoe, 18, student; acute febrile illness) When the problem is solved, yes, I will start to say to myself, now, I will be able to make a schedule do this, do that, because I will be sure of myself and that… I have the health to do it.(P5: Liv, 66, retired; persistent throat burning) Afterwards I know he told me that this disease was, he gave me the example of how it was a flu, but with much less intensity. So I know that the disease will evolve… I'm going to be able to eat better, drink better. When the problem is solved, yes, I will start to say to myself, now, I will be able to make a schedule do this, do that, because I will be sure of myself and that… I have the health to do it. Discussion This study examined how patients experience their health problems before and during a primary care consultation, drawing on John Dewey's theory of inquiry as an interpretative framework. It highlights the importance of patients' own inquiry in shaping meaning within primary care consultations. This inquiry began before the consultation, when disruptions in patients' usual experience prompted hypotheses, actions, interactions and expectations. At first, however, patients underwent this process rather than deliberately initiating it, and much of it remained implicit. Our results bring attention to the early stages of health‐problem emergence—identification and framing—which have received limited attention in the decision‐making literature, where problems are often treated as objective data to be obtained from patients [49]. Some studies support our findings by showing the importance of patients' ability to detect and name their problems [50], as well as the role of their engagement in interactions with relatives, health professionals or online resources in shaping how these problems are constructed [51]. During the consultation, their inquiry shaped how they received the physician's messages and assessed the physician's problem identification, reasoning and underlying hypotheses. When the physician's reasoning remained unexplained, misunderstandings could arise; when it was made explicit, patients could integrate medical explanations with previously tacit experiential knowledge and anticipate the evolution of their condition. Examining, from the patients' perspective, how the physician's messages became integrated with their experiential knowledge provides insights into processes of knowledge sharing [52] and negotiation of meaning [18]. These findings support reconsidering the central role assigned to physicians' decisions in models of clinical reasoning and shared decision‐making. From the patient's point of view, the GP's influence operates chiefly through the messages conveyed by the physician and the positions that these messages imply for the patient's inquiry. This may help explain how consultations influence adherence and contribute to therapeutic effects through interaction. Such effects may arise when consultations enable patients to become aware of previously tacit experiential knowledge and coherently relate medical knowledge to their own experience. Supporting the emergence of patients' tacit knowledge and their formulation of the problem appears to be a key clinical skill for shared understanding [18, 49, 53], yet it is only marginally addressed in competency frameworks [22]. Communication techniques derived from EI could help physicians support patients in becoming aware of and articulating their health problems, thereby informing both the patient's and the physician's inquiry [23]. This study reframes decision‐making not as the physician's reasoning supplemented by patient input, but as the coordination of the patient's and physician's interacting inquiry processes, consistent with RCC [16] and distributed cognition [10]. Which factors determine whether practical decisions stem more from the physician's or the patient's inquiry? Recent studies suggest that this influence depends on (1) who holds the relevant information (awareness and knowledge of the problem) and (2) who performs the action [54]. In primary care, patients typically initiate the consultation, possess crucial information through their experiential knowledge, and perform most of the actions outside of consultations. In this context, the physician's influence may lie less in their decisions or prescriptions than in how they support the patient's inquiry [4, 18]. These findings suggest that communication training should teach GPs to recognize and engage with patients' ongoing inquiry. Strengths and Limitations The strengths of this study lie in its theoretical framework and its original methods for eliciting patients' experience in real‐life situations while avoiding decontextualized declarative knowledge. Dewey's theory enabled us to analyze patients' inquiries without presupposing their underlying basis. The EI and video‐based stimulated recall enabled us to examine the ‘black box’ of patients' thoughts nested within the ‘black box’ of the consultation, providing insight into patients' actions and meaning‐making while bringing implicit dimensions of their experience to light. The limited number of participants may be considered a limitation of this study. However, purposive sampling produced diverse patient, physician and clinical problem profiles, and recurring patterns were identified across interviews. As with any abductive approach, data may be fitted to a theory. Dewey's framework should therefore be viewed as an interpretive lens rather than a comprehensive account of patient experience; it has nonetheless been productively applied across diverse contexts [24]. The experimental setup and video recording modified the consultations studied. However, most participants reported forgetting the camera glasses, consistent with previous findings [55] and possibly because the camera was unobtrusively embedded in the glasses. Conclusion and Implications The patient interprets the physician's messages through the lens of their ongoing inquiry, which can be described according to Dewey's inquiry framework. Our findings highlight the central role of physicians in recognizing where patients stand in their inquiry and in making their own reasoning explicit. When patients face an unclear situation, physicians can help them identify the problems, possible courses of action and their likely consequences. When patients seek to understand the problems identified, physicians can work with them to develop and discuss hypotheses, notably through diagnostic and therapeutic actions. By doing so, physicians help patients make sense of their situation in a more structured and actionable way, enabling them to integrate experiential and medical knowledge into a coherent understanding of their condition. Conversely, when physicians leave their reasoning implicit, misunderstandings may arise and disrupt the patients' inquiry. This study also demonstrates the value of combining EI with own‐point‐of‐view video to examine patients' tacit and situated activity. This method could be used to investigate multiple dimensions of patients' experience across diverse healthcare settings. In particular, it could support research into how clinicians' recognition and active support of patients' inquiry affect patients' understanding and subsequent actions. Funding The authors have nothing to report. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare no conflicts of interest. Supporting information Supporting File