Increased Accuracy of Acetabular Cup Positioning with an Automatic Impaction Device in Total Hip Arthroplasty Authors: Hyeongmin Song, Chan Young Lee, Taek-Rim Yoon, Kyung-Soon Park Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundTraditionally, cementless total hip arthroplasty (THA) has been primarily performed using a manual technique involving a hammer and an impactor. During cup insertion into the acetabulum, the manual technique may cause temporary limitations in visualization, discrepancies in the applied force, and imbalances in the force vector. Recently, automatic impaction devices have been developed and adopted for cup insertion. The purpose of this study was to compare the accuracy of cup positioning in primary THA between the manual technique and the use of an automatic impaction device.MethodsA total of 67 hips that underwent primary THA were retrospectively evaluated: 36 hips using the manual technique and 31 hips using an automatic impaction device. The accuracy of acetabular cup positioning between the 2 groups was compared using the Lewinnek safe zone, which indicates accurate cup placement, based on postoperative measurements of cup anteversion and inclination angle. Six methods for measuring anteversion were applied in this study. In addition, the incidence of acetabular screw augmentation and the occurrence of intraoperative and postoperative complications up to 1 year after surgery were assessed.ResultsThe proportion of cases positioned within the Lewinnek safe zone was higher in the automatic group than in the manual group across all measurement methods. Regarding postoperative complications, 1 episode of dislocation occurred in the manual group, but the difference between the groups was not statistically significant.ConclusionsAn automatic impaction device can improve the accuracy of THA cup positioning compared with the manual technique.Keywords: Total hip arthroplasty, Acetabular cup, Automatic impaction device Traditionally, cementless total hip arthroplasty (THA) has been primarily performed using a manual technique involving a hammer and an impactor1) (Fig. 1A). Even with the manual technique, no major complications have been reported, and generally favorable outcomes have been achieved.1) However, during cup insertion into the acetabulum, the manual technique may cause temporary limitations in visualization, discrepancies in the applied force, and imbalances in the force vector.2) These factors can result in variations in cup positioning and stability, particularly in achieving the targeted anteversion and inclination angles. Such issues may be more pronounced among less experienced orthopedic surgeons, as it is difficult to maintain consistent force and direction during cup insertion. Surgical instrumentation for acetabular cup insertion in total hip arthroplasty. (A) Manual hammer and impactor. (B) Automatic impaction device. Recently, automatic impaction devices have been developed and adopted for acetabular cup insertion, replacing the traditional manual technique3) (Fig. 1B). Using these devices, consistent force and direction can be maintained throughout the cup insertion process.4) Acetabular cup positioning in primary THA is closely related to postoperative complications, including dislocation, impingement, accelerated polyethylene wear, and component loosening.5,6,7,8,9,10,11) Dislocation is the second most common cause of revision surgery after primary THA, and inaccurate acetabular cup positioning is a major risk factor for dislocation.5,12,13) It remains unclear whether the manual technique or the automatic impaction device provides greater accuracy in acetabular cup insertion. Therefore, this study was designed to compare the accuracy of acetabular cup positioning in primary THA between the manual technique and the automatic impaction device by asking the following research questions: (1) Is there a difference in the accuracy of acetabular cup positioning between the manual technique and the automatic impaction device? and (2) Is there a difference in the rate of intraoperative and postoperative complications when using the automatic impaction device compared with the manual technique? We hypothesized that the automatic impaction device that can provide consistent force and direction would position the acetabular cup within the Lewinnek safe zone more accurately than the manual technique. METHODS The retrospective study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Chonnam National University Hwasun Hospital (IRB No. CNUHH-2025-212). This study was conducted as a retrospective study, and the requirement for informed consent was waived by the Institutional Review Board. Study Design Patients who underwent THA at a tertiary hospital were retrospectively evaluated. From May 2009 to March 2023, a total of 77 patients who underwent primary THA with the PINNACLE 1-mm press-fit cementless cup (DePuy Synthes), performed by a single surgeon with specialized training in hip surgery (KSP), were initially identified. There were no restrictions on underlying disease or preoperative diagnosis, and cases included osteoarthritis, osteonecrosis, femoral neck fractures, and sequelae of developmental dysplasia of the hip. Patients were excluded if they underwent revision or conversion from bipolar hemiarthroplasty to THA. In addition, 10 cases that used other surgical approaches, including the direct anterior, posterolateral, or posterior approaches, were excluded, as this study included only patients who underwent THA using the anterolateral approach.14) Based on these inclusion and exclusion criteria, a total of 67 cases were included in the study. The first 36 hips were assigned to the manual group, undergoing surgery with the manual technique, while the remaining 31 hips, operated using the automatic impaction device, were assigned to the automatic group. Two researchers (HS and CYL) reviewed the electronic medical record for each case and measured the anteversion and inclination angles of the cup on 1-month postoperative radiographs. There are 6 established methods for measuring radiographic cup anteversion on plain radiographs. Using each method, the proportion of cups positioned within the Lewinnek safe zone was compared between the 2 groups. In this study, placement of the acetabular cup within the targeted Lewinnek safe zone was considered indicative of high accuracy. The accuracy of cup positioning, the incidence of acetabular screw augmentation, and the occurrence of intraoperative and postoperative complications up to 1 year after surgery were compared between the 2 groups. Intraoperative complications included intraoperative acetabular fracture and femoral fracture, whereas postoperative complications included dislocation, periprosthetic fracture, infection, hematoma, deep vein thrombosis, and pulmonary thromboembolism. Surgical Method Apart from the impaction process, there were no procedural differences between the 2 groups. In the manual technique, the cup was attached to an impactor and inserted by the surgeon through direct hammering, whereas with the automatic impaction device, the cup was connected to an insertion handle and implanted using an automated system (Fig. 2). In this study, the KINCISE system (DePuy Synthes) was used. Unlike the manual technique, the automatic impaction device can provide a consistent direction and magnitude of force to the same location, enabling co-linear impaction, whereas variability during manual impaction may result in off-axis strikes.2,3) Intraoperative scenes of acetabular cup insertion using the manual technique and the automatic impaction device. (A) Manual technique. (B) Automatic impaction device. The intraoperative target angles were identical in both groups, with a target anteversion of 15° and a target inclination angle of 40°. Acetabular screw augmentation was additionally performed when adequate press-fit fixation was uncertain. There were no differences between the 2 groups in the subsequent steps, including femoral component placement, liner and head insertion, and stem reduction after full seating of the cup. Radiologic Evaluation A standardized protocol was used to acquire 2 types of radiographs for radiological evaluation: anteroposterior (AP) hip radiographs and cross-table lateral radiographs. The acetabular component anteversion was measured using multiple established methods, including those described by Liaw et al.,15) Lewinnek et al.,6) Widmer,16) Hassan et al.,17) and Ackland et al.18) on AP radiographs, and the Woo and Morrey19) method on cross-table lateral radiographs.20) All images were digitally archived and managed using a picture archiving and communication system (PACS). Acetabular anteversion and inclination angle21) were measured on plain radiographs, as illustrated in Figs. 3 and 4, respectively. Measurements were performed independently by 2 orthopedic surgeons (HS and CYL). Each surgeon measured the values twice at separate time points, and the mean of the 2 measurements was used for analysis. Measurement of acetabular anteversion on anteroposterior (A-E) and lateral (F) plain radiographs. (A) The method of Liaw et al.15) version: sin‒1 tan α. (B) The method of Lewinnek et al.6) version: arcsin (b / a). (C) Widmer’s method.16) version: arcsin (b / r): 48.05 × (b / r) – 0.3 (if 0.2 < b /r < 0.6). (D) The method of Hassan et al.17) version: arcsin [(h / a) / √(c / a – c2 / a2)]. (E) The method of Ackland et al.18) version: arcsin [2× / 2√ (2ay – y2)]. (F) The method of Woo and Morrey19) version: the angle between the acetabular opening and a perpendicular line drawn from the table (β angle). Measurement of acetabular inclination angle on an anteroposterior plain radiograph. Cup inclination is the angle between the ischial tuberosity line and the acetabular opening (γ angle). Data Analyses All data were managed and analyzed using Microsoft Excel and IBM SPSS statistical software version 25.0 (IBM Corp.). Continuous variables were analyzed using the t-test or Mann-Whitney U-test, as appropriate. Categorical variables were evaluated with Fisher’s exact test. A p-value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. RESULTS Preoperative demographic characteristics of both groups are summarized in Table 1. There were no significant differences in age, sex, operative side, body mass index, and American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) classification between the manual and automatic groups. The distribution of preoperative diagnoses differed between the 2 groups; however, this difference was not statistically significant. Table 1Demographic DataVariableManual (n = 36)Automatic (n = 31)p-valueAge (yr)59.4 (34–83)65.8 (34–71)0.072Sex0.332Male25 (69.4)18 (58.1)Female11 (30.6)13 (41.9)Operative side0.310Left13 (36.1)15 (48.4)Right23 (63.9)16 (51.6)Body mass index (kg/m2)22.3 (16.6–31.4)24.9 (18.6–33.3)0.214Preoperative diagnosis0.105Osteoarthritis7 (19.4)13 (41.9)Osteonecrosis18 (50.0)13 (41.9)Femoral neck fracture11 (30.6)5 (16.1)ASA classification1.6 (1–3)2.2 (1–4)0.056Values are presented as mean (range) or number (%).ASA: American Society of Anesthesiologists. Demographic Data Values are presented as mean (range) or number (%). ASA: American Society of Anesthesiologists. The mean values of postoperative radiographic anteversion and inclination angle for each measurement method are summarized in Table 2. Differences were observed between the 2 groups, and except for the Woo and Morrey method, the automatic group demonstrated smaller standard deviations. Table 2Postoperative Acetabular Cup Anteversion and Inclination AngleAcetabular positionManual (n = 36)Automatic (n = 31)p-valueAnteversion (Liaw, °)14.95 ± 5.5311.85 ± 3.320.009Anteversion (Lewinnek, °)14.83 ± 5.2711.67 ± 3.320.006Anteversion (Widmer, °)24.07 ± 6.7219.63 ± 4.260.003Anteversion (Hassan, °)19.46 ± 6.9315.63 ± 4.490.012Anteversion (Ackland, °)20.58 ± 6.2716.46 ± 4.820.005Anteversion (Woo and Morrey, °)23.65 ± 8.1619.39 ± 9.170.116Inclination angle (°)34.83 ± 5.5138.61 ± 4.500.004Values are presented as mean ± standard deviation. Postoperative Acetabular Cup Anteversion and Inclination Angle Values are presented as mean ± standard deviation. The proportions of cases positioned within the Lewinnek safe zone in the 2 groups are summarized in Table 3 and Fig. 5. As shown in the table and figure, the automatic group was positioned within the Lewinnek safe zone more frequently than the manual group. Post hoc power analysis demonstrated adequate statistical power (> 0.8) for all measurement methods except the Woo and Morrey method, which showed relatively lower power. Regarding postoperative complications, 1 episode of dislocation occurred in the manual group, but the difference was not statistically significant. Similar findings were observed for acetabular screw augmentation and intraoperative complications (Table 4). Table 3The Percentages of Cases within the Lewinnek Safe ZoneManual (n = 36)Automatic (n = 31)p-valueLewinnek safe zone (anteversion: 5°–25°, inclination angle: 30°–50°)Liaw25 (69.4)31 (100.0)0.001Lewinnek26 (72.2)31 (100.0)0.001Widmer18 (50.0)27 (87.1)0.002Hassan25 (69.4)30 (96.8)0.004Ackland22 (61.1)30 (96.8)0.001Woo and Morrey15 (41.7)22 (71.0)0.026Values are presented as number (%). The Percentages of Cases within the Lewinnek Safe Zone Values are presented as number (%). The distribution of acetabular cup positioning within Lewinnek safe zone. Red boxes indicate the Lewinnek safe zone. Table 4Acetabular Screw Augmentation and Intraoperative/Postoperative ComplicationsManual (n = 36)Automatic (n = 31)p-valueAcetabular screw augmentation2 (5.6)00.495Intraoperative complications001.000Postoperative complications (total)10Dislocation1 (2.8)01.000Values are presented as number (%). Acetabular Screw Augmentation and Intraoperative/Postoperative Complications Values are presented as number (%). DISCUSSION In this study, the automatic group demonstrated a higher proportion of cases positioned within the targeted Lewinnek safe zone, indicating greater accuracy. Moreover, except for the Woo and Morrey method, the automatic group showed smaller standard deviations across the other anteversion measurement methods as well as in inclination angle measurements. Together with the more concentrated clustering of cups within the Lewinnek safe zone observed in Fig. 5, these findings collectively indicate that the automatic group demonstrated superior precision. There are 3 types of anteversion: radiographic, anatomic, and operative.21) Among these, radiographic anteversion is widely used due to its cost-effectiveness and accessibility, as postoperative x-rays are routinely available. Postoperative computed tomography (CT) is not routinely performed in our hospital. Measurements of cup orientation on plain radiographs, particularly anteversion, may be affected by factors such as pelvic tilt and patient positioning. Although CT-based assessment would have provided more accurate measurements, these data were unavailable in this study. Therefore, because postoperative pain may affect patient positioning during radiographic acquisition, radiographs obtained 1 month after surgery were used for analysis, and only appropriately positioned AP and lateral radiographs were included. As previously noted, 6 methods are commonly used to measure anteversion; however, their comparative accuracy remains controversial. Some studies have reported that the Woo and Morrey method is less reliable because it does not account for spinal deformity or pelvic tilt, whereas the Liaw method is considered the most accurate.20,22) Because no universally accepted standard currently exists for radiographic anteversion measurement on plain radiographs, and because measured anteversion may vary according to pelvic tilt and other positional factors, all 6 radiographic measurement methods were used in this study in an attempt to minimize measurement bias and improve the robustness of the radiographic assessment. The clinical significance of acetabular component positioning in THA has been widely investigated. A notable contribution came from Lewinnek et al.6) in 1978, who established a radiographic safe zone for acetabular position, specifying an anteversion of 15° (± 10°) and an inclination angle of 40° (± 10°).6) Their findings demonstrated an association between anterior dislocations in THA and increased cup anteversion, which has since been corroborated by multiple subsequent studies.6) Cup placement outside the Lewinnek safe zone has been associated with higher rates of dislocation.6) Dislocation is the second most common reason for revision after primary THA, and as dislocations increase in frequency, the likelihood of undergoing revision THA also rises.5,12,13) Therefore, positioning of the acetabular cup within the Lewinnek safe zone was targeted during surgery. While manual techniques have traditionally yielded excellent outcomes in primary THA, the introduction of the automatic impaction device holds promise for improving operative efficiency and reducing surgeon workload.1,23) However, the potential advantages of the automatic impaction device over the manual technique have not been thoroughly investigated. In the present study, the automatic impaction device positioned the acetabular cup within the targeted Lewinnek safe zone more accurately during cup placement, resulting in a higher proportion of cases meeting this target compared with the manual technique. This improved accuracy may be attributable to the temporary visual limitations, variability in applied force, and inconsistencies in force vectors that are inherent to manual impaction. Therefore, the use of an automatic impaction device may reduce inter-surgeon variability, and its benefits could be particularly valuable for less experienced surgeons. In this study, cases performed between 2009 and 2023 were included, representing a relatively long study period. Because the automatic impaction device was introduced more recently, the manual group consisted predominantly of cases performed earlier than those in the automatic group. The inclusion period became prolonged because only cases using a single implant system were included in order to minimize confounding factors. Although all procedures were performed by the same surgeon, the potential influence of the surgeon’s learning curve over time cannot be completely excluded. However, the surgeon had performed more than 200 hip surgeries annually since 2008, and there were no substantial changes in surgical technique, instrumentation, or perioperative environment during the study period. Therefore, the influence of temporal bias related to surgeon experience or perioperative factors was considered minimal. This study had several limitations. First, because it was conducted as a retrospective study, it is subject to inherent selection and information biases, and unmeasured confounding factors could not be fully controlled. Second, the study included a relatively small cohort of 67 cases. Although no significant differences in complication rates were observed between the 2 groups, the small sample size may have limited the statistical power of the analysis. In addition, marginal differences in age and ASA classification were observed between the groups in Table 1. However, because this study focused primarily on the device effect based on radiographic findings rather than differences in clinical outcomes, the influence of these baseline differences was considered minimal. Third, the study was performed at a single center; therefore, the results may not be generalizable to other surgeons using different implants or surgical approaches. Fourth, long-term follow-up was not available. Additional cases and further studies involving other surgical approaches or techniques are needed. Despite these limitations, this study has notable strengths. First, potential confounding factors were minimized by using a single surgeon, a single implant system, and a single surgical approach. Second, this study provides a novel comparison of the accuracy of the manual technique and the automatic impaction device, which has not been previously investigated. The use of an automatic impaction device can improve the accuracy and precision of acetabular cup positioning in primary THA compared with the manual technique. By providing consistent force and direction during cup insertion, automatic impaction devices may facilitate more reliable achievement of the surgeon’s intended anteversion and inclination angles, reduce inter-surgeon variability, and offer particular benefits for less experienced surgeons. Footnotes CONFLICT OF INTEREST: No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported. References