Profitability of Nonprofit and For-Profit Ambulatory Surgery Centers Authors: Elizabeth Plummer, Kahler Doyle, Ge Bai Published: 2026 ABSTRACT This economic evaluation examines the financial performance of ambulatory surgery centers in Pennsylvania in 2024. Introduction Ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) are facilities that primarily provide outpatient surgical procedures to patients not requiring an overnight stay. As services continue to shift from hospital-based settings to outpatient facilities, ASCs will play an increasingly important role in patient care.1,2,3 However, little is known about their financial performance because, unlike hospitals, the Medicare program does not require ASCs to submit cost reports. Using data from Pennsylvania—where ASCs must disclose annual financial and operational information to state agencies—we conducted an academic study to examine ASCs’ financial performance and provide financial measures separately for nonprofit and for-profit ASCs. Methods For this economic evaluation, we obtained financial and operational information for 2024 (most recent year available) from the Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council and the Pennsylvania Department of Health for all ASCs in Pennsylvania reporting complete data (eMethods in Supplement 1).4 We compared patient volume, specialty, system affiliation, net patient revenue, profit margin, and other key operational and financial metrics between nonprofit and for-profit ASCs. No human participants were involved, so IRB approval was not sought. This study followed the CHEERS guideline for economic evaluations. We plotted kernel density functions of profit margins for nonprofit and for-profit ASCs to compare the full distributions by ownership type. Differences between distributions were evaluated using the 2-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. We also examined the distribution of profit margins by ASC system affiliation. We calculated P values from 2-sided Wilcoxon tests or tests of differences in proportion between for-profit and nonprofit ASCs. Statistical significance was determined by P < .05. SAS, version 9.4 (SAS Institute, Inc) was used for statistical analysis. Results Among 257 ASCs reporting complete data, 204 (79.4%) were for-profit and 53 (20.6%) were nonprofit. ASCs exhibited remarkably high profitability in 2024, with 14 nonprofit facilities (26.4%) reporting margins above 51% and 49 for-profit ASCs (24.0%) reporting margins above 29% (Table). Nonprofit ASCs accounted for 51.5% of net income while representing only 20.6% of facilities, 32.2% of patient volume, and 35.8% of patient revenues. Nonprofit ASCs were larger (median [IQR] visits: 4598 [2953-6786] vs 3613 [2002-6215]; median net patient revenue: $8 480 000 [$4 428 000-$17 540 000] vs $4 739 000 [$2 228 500-$8 461 500]; P < .001), with median (IQR) full-time employment double that of for-profit ASCs (27.0 [12.0-45.0] vs 13.5 [7.0-23.5] workers; P < .001). Nonprofit ASCs also had significantly higher median [IQR] per-visit net patient revenue ($1721 [$1226-$3311] vs $1297 [$701-$2120]; P < .001), per-visit net income ($592 [$128-$1326] vs $197 [$43-$404]; P < .001), and profit margin (37.8% [7.9%-51.4%] vs 16.4% [6.4%-28.9%]; P < .001). Table. Comparison of ASC Operational and Financial Characteristics by Ownership TypeCharacteristicNonprofit (n = 53)For-profit (n = 204)Test for differenceaAll ASCs combined Total visits, No. (row %)b,c437 803 (32.2)922 873 (67.8)NA Total net patient revenue, $ (row %)b,d714 985 000 (35.8)1 283 364 000 (64.2)NA Total net income, $ (row %)b,e291 306 000 (51.5)274 050 000 (48.5)NAOperational characteristics, median (IQR), No. Visits4598 (2953-6786)3613 (2002-6215).049 Full-time stafff27.0 (12.0-45.0)13.5 (7.0-23.5)<.001 Part-time staff17.0 (8.0-61.0)16.5 (7.0-31.5).10Urban, No. (%)40 (75.5)166 (81.4).34Health system affiliation, No. (%)g50 (94.3)55 (27.0)<.001Top health systems (No. of ASCs owned)UPMC (11), Penn Medicine (6), Geisinger (5), Highmark Health (5), Jefferson Health (5)SCA Health (7), Tenet Health (5), UPMC (5)NAMultispecialty, No. (%)h33 (62.3)61 (29.9)<.001Reported specialties, median (IQR), No.h6.0 (1-8)1.0 (1-4)<.001Top 5 most-cited specialties (No. [%])Gastroenterology (39 [73.6]), orthopedic (31 [58.5]), ophthalmology (27 [50.9]), urology (26 [49.1]), dermatology (26 [49.1])Ophthalmology (77 [37.7]), gastroenterology (69 [33.8]), dermatology (66 [32.4]), pain management (66 [32.4]), orthopedic (60 [29.4])NAFinancial characteristics Net patient revenue, median (IQR), $8 480 000 (4 428 000-17 540 000)4 739 000 (2 228 500-8 461 500)<.001 Net patient revenue per visit, median (IQR), $1721 (1226-3311)1297 (701-2120).003 Net income, median (IQR), $3 334 000 (399 000-7 377 000)701 500 (51 500-1 870 000)<.001 Net income per visit, median (IQR), $592 (128-1326)197 (43-404)<.001 Profit margin, median (IQR), %i37.8 (7.9-51.4)16.4 (6.4-28.9)<.001 Medicare, median (IQR), %j23.6 (16.6-32.0)31.9 (20.3-48.2)<.001 Medicaid, median (IQR), %k3.4 (1.8-6.1)1.6 (0-4.8)<.001 Uncompensated care, median (IQR), %l0.5 (0.0-1.0)0.0 (0-0.1).001Abbreviations: ASC, ambulatory surgical center; NA, not applicable; UPMC, The University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. a P values from 2-sided Wilcoxon tests (medians) or tests of differences in proportions between for-profit and nonprofit ASCs. b Total visits are the number of visits to an ASC, summed across all ASCs (separately by profit status). The same methodology applies to total net patient revenue and total net income. c Visits are measured as the number of visits to the ASC during the year (or number of procedures, if greater). d Net patient revenue is revenue for patient care only. e Net income is net patient revenue minus operating expenses, plus nonoperating income. f Measured as the number of workers, not full-time equivalent. Full-time staff are workers who perform duties for 30 hours or more per week. g Health system is defined as a group of health care organizations that are jointly owned or managed, including hospitals, ASCs, and/or insurance plans. Nonsystem ASCs include independent ASCs (not associated with a larger organization or a for-profit investor) and investor-owned ASCs (owned by a group of shareholders or investors). h Specialties are measured by an ASC reporting at least 1 physician on staff in the following 18 distinct fields: cardiology; dental; dermatology; endocrinology; ear, nose, and throat; gastroenterology; nephrology; neurology; obstetrics and gynecology; ophthalmology; orthopedic; pain management; podiatry; pulmonology; radiology; thoracic; urology; and vascular. ASCs are classified as multispecialty if they report more than 2 specialties. i Profit margin is the ratio of total income to total revenue (ie, measures income from all sources). j Medicare percentage is the percentage of net patient revenues from Medicare. k Medicaid percentage is the percentage of net patient revenues from the state’s Medicaid program (known as Medical Assistance). l Uncompensated care percentage is the dollar value of uncompensated care (including both bad debt and charity care), as a percentage of net patient revenue. Uncompensated care is initially reported as charges and converted to dollar values using an ASC’s cost to charge or revenue to charge ratios. Comparison of ASC Operational and Financial Characteristics by Ownership Type Abbreviations: ASC, ambulatory surgical center; NA, not applicable; UPMC, The University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. P values from 2-sided Wilcoxon tests (medians) or tests of differences in proportions between for-profit and nonprofit ASCs. Total visits are the number of visits to an ASC, summed across all ASCs (separately by profit status). The same methodology applies to total net patient revenue and total net income. Visits are measured as the number of visits to the ASC during the year (or number of procedures, if greater). Net patient revenue is revenue for patient care only. Net income is net patient revenue minus operating expenses, plus nonoperating income. Measured as the number of workers, not full-time equivalent. Full-time staff are workers who perform duties for 30 hours or more per week. Health system is defined as a group of health care organizations that are jointly owned or managed, including hospitals, ASCs, and/or insurance plans. Nonsystem ASCs include independent ASCs (not associated with a larger organization or a for-profit investor) and investor-owned ASCs (owned by a group of shareholders or investors). Specialties are measured by an ASC reporting at least 1 physician on staff in the following 18 distinct fields: cardiology; dental; dermatology; endocrinology; ear, nose, and throat; gastroenterology; nephrology; neurology; obstetrics and gynecology; ophthalmology; orthopedic; pain management; podiatry; pulmonology; radiology; thoracic; urology; and vascular. ASCs are classified as multispecialty if they report more than 2 specialties. Profit margin is the ratio of total income to total revenue (ie, measures income from all sources). Medicare percentage is the percentage of net patient revenues from Medicare. Medicaid percentage is the percentage of net patient revenues from the state’s Medicaid program (known as Medical Assistance). Uncompensated care percentage is the dollar value of uncompensated care (including both bad debt and charity care), as a percentage of net patient revenue. Uncompensated care is initially reported as charges and converted to dollar values using an ASC’s cost to charge or revenue to charge ratios. Nonprofit ASCs were overwhelmingly system-owned (50 [94.3%]), while 55 for-profit ASCs (27.0%) were system-owned. Both nonprofit (40 [75.5%]) and for-profit (166 [81.4%]) ASCs were predominantly located in urban areas. Thirty-three nonprofit (62.3%) and 61 for-profit (29.9%) ASCs were multispecialty. Nonprofit ASCs’ most commonly reported specialty was gastroenterology (39 [73.6%]); ophthalmology (77 [37.7%]) was the most common among for-profit ASCs. Medicare payments accounted for a median (IQR) of 23.6% (16.6%-32.0%) and 31.9% (20.3%-48.2%) of revenues for nonprofit and for-profit ASCs, respectively. Both groups incurred low Medicaid payments and negligible uncompensated care. Profit margin distributions differed significantly between nonprofit and for-profit ASCs (2-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, D = 0.408; P < .001) (Figure). Nonprofit ASCs exhibited a profit margin distribution shifted toward higher values relative to for-profit ASCs. Kernel Density Estimation of Ambulatory Surgical Center Profit Margins, by Ownership Type The continuous curves map the estimated probability density functions for nonprofit and for-profit ambulatory surgical centers. Kernel density estimates were calculated using the full sample. For graphical presentation, the x-axis was limited to the 1st and 99th percentiles of the profit margin distribution to improve visualization. Because 94.3% of nonprofit ASCs were system-owned vs only 27.0% of for-profit ASCs, we also plotted distributions for 3 groups: nonprofit ASCs, for-profit ASCs affiliated with a health system, and for-profit ASCs not health-system-affiliated. The distribution of profit margins for nonprofit ASCs remained shifted toward higher values than either for-profit subgroup, regardless of health system affiliation. The 2 for-profit subgroup distributions were not statistically distinguishable from each other. Discussion Using a unique data source from Pennsylvania, we conducted the first empirical study on ASCs’ financial characteristics, addressing an important evidence gap created by the lack of ASC financial disclosure to federal agencies. We documented the strong profitability of ASCs and identified higher profitability and larger size among nonprofit ASCs. Although nonprofit ASCs represented only one-fifth of facilities and one-third of patient volume, they accounted for more than half of total net income in Pennsylvania’s ASC market and exhibited significantly higher profit margins than for-profit ASCs, while continuing to maintain their tax-exempt status. Nearly all nonprofit ASCs were system-owned, whereas fewer than one-third of for-profit ASCs were system-affiliated. Facility-level financial measures derived from Medicare cost reports, particularly balance-sheet measures, may be less reliable for system-affiliated ASCs. We examined income statement measures (ie, facility-level revenues and expenses), which are less likely to be affected by system affiliation. Nevertheless, measurement error may be greater among nonprofit ASCs because they are more commonly system affiliated. Recent policy activities—such as Medicare’s phasing out of the Inpatient-Only list, expansion of covered ASC procedures, introduction of site-neutral payments, and state reforms to Certificate of Need laws—highlight ASCs’ growing role in US health care.5,6,7,8,9 As health systems continue to grow and pursue site-of-care optimization, and self-insured employers and other cost-conscious purchasers increasingly seek lower-cost-of-care options, expansion of ASCs is likely to continue.10 This trend has important implications for public programs’ payment policies, market competition, and the operating efficiency of health care facilities.