Momentum-Space Path Integral Approach to Non-Hermitian Symmetry Breaking Authors: Zhuo-Ting Cai, Wei Chen Published: 2026 ABSTRACT A quantum-classical correspondence for non-Hermitian symmetry breaking has recently been established using coordinate-space path integrals, providing a semiclassical understanding of spectral transitions at the level of individual eigenstates. Here we develop its dual formulation in momentum space by constructing the corresponding trace formula and quantization condition. We show that the real or complex nature of individual eigenvalues is determined by the symmetry properties of the associated semiclassical orbits, as in the coordinate-space path-integral approach. Moreover, we demonstrate that the topology of semiclassical orbits determines the natural formulation of the quantization condition: the coordinate- and momentum-space formulations are equivalent for contractible periodic orbits in phase space, whereas for noncontractible orbits, the quantization condition along the winding direction remains valid, but its dual form must be corrected by a boundary term. In particular, real-space-winding and Brillouin-zone-winding orbits naturally select coordinate- and momentum-space quantization, respectively. As a nontrivial application, we investigate the boundary-induced spectral transition of Bloch oscillations in a finite non-Hermitian lattice, where Bloch-oscillation orbits winding across the Brillouin zone preserve the relevant symmetry and yield real energy levels, whereas boundary-reflected orbits form symmetry-related pairs and give rise to complex-conjugate eigenvalues. Our work completes the quantum-classical correspondence framework for non-Hermitian symmetry breaking, extending its applicability to a broader class of non-Hermitian problems. 1. Introduction Conventional quantum mechanics is built on Hermitian Hamiltonians, which ensure real spectra and unitary time evolution. However, many physical systems are not perfectly isolated: they exchange particles or energy with their environments and exhibit gain or dissipation effects. In many cases, non-Hermitian effective Hamiltonians provide a natural description of these phenomena and have been widely researched in optics [1,2,3], acoustics [4,5,6], and condensed-matter physics [7,8,9,10,11,12]. The studies have revealed a variety of intriguing phenomena, including exceptional points [13,14,15,16], non-Hermitian skin effects [17,18,19,20,21,22], unconventional topological phases [23,24,25,26], and momentum-gapped dispersions [27,28]. Many of these phenomena are closely related to the spectral properties of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians [29,30,31], which are central to non-Hermitian physics. Among various concepts in non-Hermitian physics, pseudo-Hermiticity [32,33,34] has attracted considerable attention. It imposes a symmetry constraint on non-Hermitian Hamiltonians that can give rise to entirely real energy spectra. More precisely, eigenenergies are real for eigenstates that are invariant under the pseudo-Hermiticity operation, whereas eigenstates that break this symmetry are associated with complex-conjugate eigenvalue pairs. While the mathematical foundations of pseudo-Hermiticity are well established [35,36] and spontaneous breaking of pseudo-Hermiticity symmetry has been experimentally observed [37,38,39,40,41,42], a universal mechanism governing these phenomena at the level of individual eigenstates across both symmetry-preserving and symmetry-broken regimes has remained elusive for a long time. In a recent work [43], we addressed this problem by establishing a quantum–classical correspondence principle for non-Hermitian symmetry breaking. By generalizing the Gutzwiller trace formula and the associated quantization condition to the complex domain via coordinate-space path integrals, we revealed a correspondence between the energy spectrum and complex classical orbits. This correspondence allows the real or complex character of individual eigenenergies to be understood from the symmetry properties of the underlying semiclassical orbits. Specifically, real eigenenergies are associated with self-symmetric orbits, whereas complex-conjugate eigenvalue pairs originate from symmetry-related pairs of orbits. Given that our previous work was formulated in terms of coordinate-space path integrals, a natural question arises: whether an analogous quantum–classical correspondence can be established via momentum-space path integrals and whether the two formulations provide equivalent descriptions for generic non-Hermitian systems. In this work, we establish the quantum-classical correspondence principle for non-Hermitian symmetry breaking using a momentum-space path-integral approach. We generalize the trace formula and quantization condition to momentum space and interpret whether individual eigenvalues are real or complex in terms of the symmetry properties of their corresponding semiclassical orbits. By comparing the quantization conditions formulated in two dual representations, we clarify their respective regimes of validity. For contractible periodic orbits without phase-space winding, the two formulations are equivalent. For noncontractible winding orbits, the winding direction determines which formulation is globally well defined in its conventional form: real-space winding is naturally described in coordinate space, whereas Brillouin-zone winding is naturally described in momentum space. In either case, the dual formulation requires the corresponding boundary term to recover the same quantization condition. As a nontrivial example where the momentum-space formulation is essential, we investigate the boundary-induced real-to-complex spectral transition of Bloch oscillations in a finite non-Hermitian lattice. The semiclassical orbits traversing the Brillouin zone preserve the corresponding symmetry and yield real energies after quantization, whereas boundary-reflected orbits break this symmetry and form symmetry-related pairs, resulting in complex-conjugate energy pairs. The spectra predicted by our theory agree well with exact diagonalization results, confirming the validity of this framework. Our work provides a comprehensive semiclassical framework for non-Hermitian symmetry breaking and extends its applicability to a broader class of systems. 2. Quantum-Classical Correspondence from Momentum-Space Path Integral In this section, we establish the quantum-classical correspondence of non-Hermitian symmetry breaking through a momentum-space path integral, instead of the previous coordinate-space approach [43]. The main steps of our analysis are as follows: First, we develop the momentum-space path-integral framework and establish the correspondence between the quantum η-pseudo-Hermiticity and the associated classical Sη symmetry. Next, we derive the extended non-Hermitian Gutzwiller trace formula in momentum space and the corresponding quantization condition. We will compare it with its coordinate-space counterpart, clarifying their relation and respective domains of applicability. Furthermore, we relate the symmetry of semiclassical orbits to the real-or-complex nature of the quantized energy levels. As a starting point, we consider a generic non-Hermitian system governed by the Hamiltonian H(x^,p^). Here, x^ and p^ denote the canonical position and momentum operators, respectively. In this work, we restrict our discussion to systems that satisfy the condition of η-pseudo-Hermiticity [32], which we refer to as η-pseudo-Hermitian symmetry (η-PHS). This fundamental symmetry requires the existence of a Hermitian, invertible operator η (i.e., η=η†) such that the Hamiltonian satisfies(1)ηHη−1=H†. Following the same principle as the coordinate-space construction [43], we begin with the propagator in the momentum representation,(2)G(pf,pi;t)=〈pf|e−iHt|pi〉.For the subsequent analysis, we adopt a biorthogonal momentum basis and analytically continue the semiclassical phase-space variables to the complex domain. The action of η on the coordinate and momentum operators is denoted by x^η=ηx^η−1,p^η=ηp^η−1, and its corresponding action on the propagator is obtained through Gη(pf,pi;t)=〈pf|e−iH(x^η,p^η)t|pi〉, with its physical interpretation specified in concrete examples. As shown in Appendix A.1, the η-PHS (1) imposes the following constraint on the propagator(3)Gη(pf,pi;t)=G∗(pi∗,pf∗;−t∗). We next express the propagator in terms of the momentum-space path integral, which takes the form(4)G(pf,pi;t)=∫pipfD[ξ]expi∫0t−xp˙−H(x,p)dt′, where ξ(t′)={x(t′),p(t′)} denotes a phase-space orbit satisfying p(0)=pi and p(t)=pf. In this representation, Equation (3) becomes(5)∫pipfD[ξ]ei∫0t[−xp˙−H(xη,pη)]dt′=∫pipfD[ξ]ei∫0t[−xp˙−H∗(x∗,p∗)]dt′, where xη=xη(x,p) and pη=pη(x,p) denote the classical variables induced by the η transformation. Here, x and p are c numbers which are analytically continued to complex phase space, and H(x,p) denotes the corresponding classical Hamiltonian. Since Equation (5) holds for arbitrary pi, pf, and t, the semiclassical Hamiltonian is required to satisfy the following constraint, referred to as the Sη symmetry:(6)Sη:H(xη,pη)=H∗(x∗,p∗),This is shown in Appendix A.2. The symmetry agrees with the result obtained through the coordinate-space path integral approach [43]. Having established the correspondence between the quantum η-PHS and the classical Sη symmetry, we next relate the semiclassical orbits to the quantum energy spectrum. This is achieved through the trace formula in momentum space and the resulting quantization condition. In deriving the trace formula and throughout the subsequent discussion, we restrict our analysis to one-dimensional systems. A higher-dimensional momentum-space trace formula can, in principle, be constructed in analogy with the multidimensional coordinate-space trace formula [44]. We begin with the trace of the Green operator, G(E)=Tr(H−E)−1, whose poles determine the eigenenergies. Using the biorthogonal momentum basis, it can be written as(7)G(E)=i∫dteiEt∫dpi〈pi|e−iHt|pi〉.Substituting Equation (4), we obtain the momentum-space path-integral representation(8)G(E)=i∫dteiEt∫dpi∫pipiD[ξ]ei∫0t−xp˙−H(x,p)dt′.The boundary condition p(0)=p(t)=pi imposed by the trace selects closed orbits in momentum space. For a periodic Brillouin zone, however, closed orbits are defined modulo the reciprocal-lattice period 2π such that p(t)=p(0)+2πw, where w∈Z is the winding number. Equation (8) represents a path integral over all phase-space orbits ξ starting and ending at pi during a propagation time t. We evaluate these three integrations sequentially using the saddle-point approximation (SPA), as in the coordinate-space approach [43]. First, we apply the SPA to the functional integral over ξ. The variation of the momentum-space action Sp[x,p;t]=∫0t[−xp˙−H(x,p)]dt′ with respect to the phase-space path ξ(t′)={x(t′),p(t′)} yields the complex canonical equations x˙=∂H/∂p,p˙=−∂H/∂x. Second, applying the SPA to the integral over pi imposes x(t)=x(0), implying that the classical orbits are periodic in the complex phase space. Finally, the saddle point of the time integral is determined by ∂Sp(t)+Et/∂t=0. This condition fixes the orbit to the energy shell, H(x(t′),p(t′))=E, and the saddle-point value of t is the period T(E), which is generally complex. As shown in Appendix A.3, after three steps of SPAs, the trace formula can be expressed in terms of contour integrals along all periodic orbits O as(9)G(E)=iT(E)expi−∮Oxdp−2πμ1−expi−∮Oxdp−2πμ, where T(E) is the periodicity of the orbit for a given energy E, and −4μ defines the Maslov index. Equation (9) is the dual form of the Gutzwiller trace formula in coordinate space. The poles of Equation (9) yield the momentum-space quantization condition(10)−∮Oxdp=2π(n+μ),n∈Z.The corresponding coordinate-space quantization condition is [43](11)∮Opdx=2π(n+μ),n∈Z.We now compare the momentum- and coordinate-space quantization conditions. For contractible periodic orbits satisfying p(0)=p(T),x(0)=x(T), the two quantization conditions are equivalent because(12)∮pdx=∮−xdp+pxp(0),x(0)p(T),x(T)=∮−xdp.For non-contractible periodic orbits, however, either p(T)≠p(0) or x(T)≠x(0), so the boundary term no longer vanishes. As an example, consider a Brillouin-zone-winding orbit with p(T)=p(0)+2π,x(T)=x(0). The two contour integrals are then related by(13)∮pdx=∮−xdp+pxp(0),x(0)p(T),x(T)=∮−xdp+2πx(0).The contractible and noncontractible periodic orbits mentioned above can be distinguished by their phase-space winding numbers. Specifically, this contractibility is characterized by the real-space winding number wx=1Lx∮dx=x(T)−x(0)Lx and the momentum-space winding number wp=12π∮dp=p(T)−p(0)2π, where Lx denotes the spatial period of the system. When x(T)=x(0) and p(T)=p(0), the vanishing of both wx and wp implies a contractible orbit, whereas a nonzero value in either wx or wp indicates a noncontractible orbit. Equation (13) shows that the two contour integrals differ by a boundary term that explicitly depends on the starting point along the winding orbit. This apparent discrepancy reflects the global topology of momentum space. For a Brillouin-zone-winding orbit, the contour integral −∮xdp is globally well defined. By contrast, since p cannot be chosen as a globally single-valued variable on the momentum cylinder, the bare contour integral ∮pdx is not globally well defined. When the orbit crosses the chosen Brillouin-zone boundary, a boundary term −2πx(0) arises from the global topology of momentum space. Once this term is included, the coordinate- and momentum-space formulations yield the same quantization condition, naturally expressed in the momentum-space form of Equation (10). A detailed derivation of this result is provided in Appendix A.4. An analogous argument applies to real-space-winding orbits, with the roles of coordinate and momentum interchanged. In this case, the coordinate-space quantization condition Equation (11) provides the globally well-defined rule, consistent with the examples discussed in Ref. [43]. Having identified the appropriate quantization condition for each type of periodic orbit, we next establish the quantum-classical correspondence in momentum-space formulation, relating the real or complex character of individual energy levels to the symmetry properties of the corresponding orbits. As shown in Appendix A.5, if a periodic orbit O1(t) with energy E and period T is a solution of Hamilton’s canonical equations, O2(t)=ξη(O1∗(±t)) is also a solution of the equations, with energy E∗ and period T∗. Moreover, the contour integrals of two orbits satisfy(14)∮O2(t∗)−x2(t∗)dp2(t∗)=∮O1(t)−x1(t)dp1(t)∗. Together with the quantization condition, these symmetry relations provide a classification of nondegenerate levels according to the symmetry of the semiclassical orbit:When two orbits O1 and O2 describe the same orbit, i.e., the orbit is Sη symmetric, the quantized energy is real.When O1 and O2 are distinct but related by Sη, they form an Sη-related orbit pair, and their quantized energies occur as complex-conjugate pairs, En2=En1∗. When two orbits O1 and O2 describe the same orbit, i.e., the orbit is Sη symmetric, the quantized energy is real. When two orbits O1 and O2 describe the same orbit, i.e., the orbit is Sη symmetric, the quantized energy is real. When O1 and O2 are distinct but related by Sη, they form an Sη-related orbit pair, and their quantized energies occur as complex-conjugate pairs, En2=En1∗. When O1 and O2 are distinct but related by Sη, they form an Sη-related orbit pair, and their quantized energies occur as complex-conjugate pairs, En2=En1∗. This establishes the quantum-classical correspondence in the momentum-space formulation, consistent with its coordinate-space counterpart. Combined with the coordinate-space formulation, it completes the quantum-classical correspondence framework for non-Hermitian symmetry and spectral properties, as summarized in Figure 1. 3. Boundary-Induced Real-to-Complex Transition of Bloch Oscillations In Ref. [43], we applied the coordinate-space quantization condition to several examples, thereby demonstrating its validity. Here we consider the boundary-induced real-to-complex transition of Bloch oscillations. Because a particle undergoing Bloch oscillations winds around the Brillouin zone in momentum space, the conventional coordinate-space formulation requires an additional boundary term, whereas the momentum-space formulation is globally well defined in its natural form. It therefore provides an ideal test of the momentum-space quantization condition. We begin with Bloch oscillations in a one-dimensional lattice (with the lattice constant set to unity), whose band dispersion h(p) is periodic in the Brillouin zone. The Hamiltonian reads(15)H=h(p^)+Fx^, where F is a uniform external force. We first focus on the bulk Bloch motion and neglect boundary effects; boundary reflections in finite lattices will be incorporated later in a concrete example. The corresponding classical Hamiltonian is H(x,p)=h(p)+Fx, from which Hamilton’s equations follow:(16)x˙=∂H∂p=∂h(p)∂p,p˙=−∂H∂x=−F.For the initial conditions p(0)=p0 and x(0)=[E−h(p0)]/F, the solution of Equation (16) yields(17)p(t)=p0−Ft,x(t)=E−hp(t)F, where x(0) is expressed in terms of p0 and the energy E through the relation E=h(p0)+Fx0. Equation (17) shows that the momentum evolves uniformly and winds across the Brillouin zone during the Bloch period T=2π/F. Since the band dispersion is periodic, h(p+2π) = h(p), the coordinate also satisfies x(t+T)=x(t), exhibiting Bloch oscillation in complex coordinate space. Having obtained the orbits of Bloch oscillations, we can determine the quantized energies by applying the momentum-space quantization condition Equation (10). To elucidate the relation between the quantized energy levels and the band dispersion, we expand h(p) as a Fourier series,(18)h(p)=h0+∑ℓ=1∞aℓcosℓp+bℓsinℓp, where the Fourier coefficients are generally complex in a non-Hermitian system. Substituting the orbit in Equation (17) and the Fourier expansion in Equation (18) into the contour integral in Equation (10), we obtain(19)−∮xdp=1F∫p0−2πp0E−h(p)dp=2πFE−h0, where we have used the fact that all nonzero Fourier harmonics in Equation (18) vanish upon integration over the Brillouin zone. The resulting quantized energies are(20)En=h0+Fn, where the Maslov index is taken to be μ=0 since the orbit encounters neither turning points nor reflections in momentum space. The results show that the detailed form of the band dispersion enters the quantized spectrum only through the constant offset h0. Having established the semiclassical description of Bloch oscillations for a general dispersion, we turn to a concrete model:(21)H(x^,p^)=2it0sinp^+Fx^, where t0 characterizes the magnitude of the imaginary dispersion. For clarity, we take t0>0 and F>0 and consider a finite lattice bounded by x=0 and x=L. We further assume that L is sufficiently large to permit the existence of bulk semiclassical orbits that can complete a full Bloch oscillation before reaching either boundary. For complex-valued momentum, we restrict our discussion to the first Brillouin zone, defined by −π≤Rep≤π. The Hamiltonian obeys the time-reversal T constraint(22)H∗(x^,−p^)=H(x^,p^), or T-PHS in the standard pseudo-Hermitian notation (1), where T denotes matrix transposition. As shown in Figure 2a, the eigenenergies of this Hamiltonian are complex in the upper and lower parts of the spectrum, whereas they remain real in the central spectral region. This spectral structure can be understood within the semiclassical framework. The corresponding classical symmetry ST is expressed as(23)H(x,−p)=H∗(x∗,p∗), which yields the ST-symmetric pairs of orbits denoted as O1(t)={x(t),p(t)} and O2(t)=x∗(−t),−p∗(−t). Physically, the semiclassical orbits fall into two classes: bulk orbits that complete a full Bloch oscillation, and boundary-reflected orbits for which the Bloch oscillation is interrupted by the boundary. For bulk orbits O, the semiclassical solution is(24)x(t)=1FE−2it0sin(Ft),p(t)=π−Ft, where the initial momentum is taken as p0=π. For a real energy E, this orbit O satisfies ST symmetry, i.e.,(25)x∗(−t)=x(t),−p∗(−t)=p(t)(mod2π), as shown in Figure 2b. Note that for real time t, the Bloch oscillation occurs along the imaginary coordinate axis, in contrast to the conventional Hermitian counterpart. Applying the momentum-space quantization condition (10) to this orbit yields real energy levels En=Fn, as shown by the purple points in Figure 2a. The eigenenergies obtained from the quantization condition agree well with the numerical diagonalization results, confirming the validity of our theory. The physical interpretation of these energy levels is that, for a particle undergoing a Brillouin-zone winding, the gain and loss effects induced by the imaginary dispersion h(p)=2it0sinp compensate each other over one period, thereby ensuring that the corresponding eigenvalue remains real. This mechanism is analogous to that in the PT-symmetric double-well model [43], where high-energy orbits explore both gain and loss regions in coordinate space so that the two effects compensate over one period. However, once the particle is reflected by the boundary during the Bloch oscillation, it can no longer complete a full winding around the Brillouin zone. Instead, the motion is confined to only part of the Brillouin zone so that the gain and loss accumulated along the trajectory are no longer balanced. Consequently, the boundary-reflected orbit O1, subject to the loss, breaks the ST symmetry, while its ST-symmetric partner O2 experiences the corresponding gain. They are represented by the red dashed and blue solid trajectories, respectively, in Figure 2c. We first identify the boundary-reflected orbits and then apply the quantization condition to them. Since the force F creates a linear potential gradient across the system, the boundary-reflected orbits localized near the two boundaries naturally correspond to the two ends of the energy spectrum, as confirmed in Figure 2a. On the original real-time contour, however, Equation (24) shows that the Bloch oscillation proceeds along the imaginary coordinate axis, obscuring the role of the real-space boundaries. While this description suffices for Bloch-oscillation orbits, it is inadequate for boundary-reflected ones. To capture the boundary effect, one should analytically continue the time contour into the complex plane, where the propagator naturally selects the dominant orbits. This continuation allows orbits to reach and reflect from the boundary during the Bloch oscillation, giving rise to the two boundary-reflected orbits O1 and O2. It should be noted that the boundary-reflected orbits and the Bloch orbits are complex saddle-point trajectories, which are distinct from the ordinary real-time and -space trajectories in Hermitian systems. From the path-integral perspective, both complete Bloch-oscillation and boundary-reflected orbits contribute to the propagator. The key is whether boundary-reflected orbits remain an exponentially small correction to the bulk Bloch oscillations, or instead become the dominant contribution that dictates the spectrum. As shown in Appendix B, this distinction can be identified by examining the contributions of the Bloch-oscillation orbit O and boundary-reflected orbit O2 to the propagator. In the momentum-space path integral, an orbit with energy E contributes a factor exp(−i∫xdp), whose magnitude is given by exp−i∫xdp=expIm∫xdp. Therefore, a negative Im∫xdp suppresses the orbit contribution, whereas a positive value enhances it. Here, for Bloch-oscillation orbits winding across the whole Brillouin zone, we have Im∮Oxdp=0. Consequently, the boundary-reflected orbit remains exponentially suppressed when Im∮O2xdp<0, and the complete Bloch oscillation remains the dominant trajectory. Conversely, when Im∮O2xdp>0, the contribution of the boundary-reflected orbit is enhanced and becomes the dominant one governing the semiclassical quantization. For concreteness, we focus on the left boundary in the following discussion. By evaluating the semiclassical weight of O2, we find that the boundary-reflected contribution is suppressed for large positive E, where the center of the Bloch-oscillation orbit nc=E/F lies far from the left boundary. As E decreases, the orbit becomes closer to the left boundary and correspondingly, the boundary-reflected contribution gradually increases. When the energy decreases below the critical value Ecl, determined by(26)−Im∮O2x(Ecl,p)dp=Im∮O2p(Ecl,x)dx=0, the boundary-reflected orbits become the dominant semiclassical contributions governing the quantized energy levels. Mathematically, this transition condition corresponds to an anti-Stokes crossover. The solution of Equation (26) yields(27)Ecl≈3.018t0.In this energy regime, the eigenenergies in the lower and upper halves of the complex-energy plane are governed by the orbits O1 and O2 respectively, shown in Appendix B:(28)∮O1pdx=2πn+34,ImE<0,∮O2pdx=2πn+34,ImE>0.Here, the phase correction 2π×3/4=3π/2 in the quantization condition consists of a phase shift π from reflection at the hard boundary and a phase shift π/2 from the smooth turning point generated by the linear potential. A detailed discussion about Maslov phase can be found in Ref. [45]. Since all boundary-reflected orbits are contractible, the equivalence relation in Equation (12) has been used. The eigenvalues associated with the right-boundary-reflected orbits can be obtained by an analogous analysis. As shown in Figure 2a, the spectra obtained from the quantization conditions agree well with the numerical solutions of the eigenvalue equation, supporting the validity of the present semiclassical description. 4. Conclusions In summary, we establish a quantum–classical correspondence for non-Hermitian symmetry breaking based on the momentum-space path-integral formulation. We derive the corresponding trace formula and quantization conditions, providing an essential complement to the real-space path-integral approach and extending the applicability of the theoretical framework to a broader class of non-Hermitian systems. Furthermore, we demonstrate that orbit topology determines the natural formulation of semiclassical quantization. For contractible periodic orbits in phase space, the coordinate- and momentum-space quantization conditions are directly equivalent. For noncontractible winding orbits, the winding direction determines which condition is globally well defined in its conventional form: real-space and Brillouin-zone winding naturally select coordinate- and momentum-space quantization, respectively. The dual formulation requires an additional boundary term to recover the same quantization condition. Finally, we demonstrate the validity of our theory by studying the boundary-induced real-to-complex transition of Bloch oscillations in a finite non-Hermitian lattice.