A Morality Based Target Audience Analysis and Quantum Open System Interaction Model for Propaganda Authors: Mustafa Canan Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Two people can view the same information but can take different actions. Most importantly, while thinking about moral and political issues, such as abortion, depending on the differences in the psychological systems, a perception of threat can arise. To exploit this aspect of the psychological systems, state and non-state actors make use of propaganda techniques to influence any target audience. Although the spread of disinformation is extensively studied in the information ecosystem, a model that represents the interactions between the schemata of the individuals and schemata of the perceptual stimuli has not been introduced. An interaction model is crucial to fathom the propaganda dynamics because while aiming to undermine the norms, values, and institutions in free societies, propaganda does not target the material objects or networks; it targets the psychological systems. Therefore, this research proposes to use the moral foundation theory (MFT) to define the system states of the interaction model for propaganda; doing so, the proposed model can represent the psychological systems of a target audience and schemata of the information stimuli with the same system states. This paper’s primary contribution is introducing an interaction model by capitalizing on a quantum open system model that captures the dynamics of two interacting systems in the information environment. The effects of non-selective measurement were studied by simulating a quantum open system-based cognitive model. 1. Introduction People categorize social phenomena, actions, and other-than-themselves with their psychological systems. These psychological systems support diverse interpretative frameworks such that the same phenomenon can be perceived as praiseworthy by person A and blameworthy by person B. The story of a former member of the Westboro Baptist Church (WBC), Megan Phelps-Roper [1], can demonstrate the effects of the changes in these psychological systems. Her grandfather is the founding pastor, and her mother was the spokesperson of the church. She grew up in an environment in which the doctrine of the WBC permeated every aspect of her life [1]. She had been very articulate about the church and its exclusivist doctrine. When the church members decided to promulgate their doctrine via social media, Megan became the face of the church on Twitter. She argues that Twitter and other social media platforms enable the evolution of individuals and societies in unprecedented ways [1]. She shares her discussions (with then-husband-to-be) concerning notions such as commandments and truth. During those discussions, he was choosing his words in such a way that Megan would see the commandment and truth notions through the lenses of humility, gentleness, and compassion. Switching perspectives allowed her to interpret the very same notions through different lenses; in return, exclusivist interpretations have transformed into an inclusivist understanding. Although leaving WBC means estrangement from her family, Megan left. Unfortunately, the changes in psychological systems via social media can lead to radicalism [2] or other social problems [3]. State and non-state actors actively shape the information sphere [4] and make use of propaganda techniques to encircle the information consumers in the information ecosystem [2,5,6,7,8,9,10]. These increased interactions involve the schemata of the individuals and schemata of the perceptual stimuli [11,12]. The state-of-the-art disinformation/fake-news/network studies, e.g., [13,14,15,16], do not address the interaction between perceptual stimuli and the cognitive dimension. While propaganda attempts to undermine the norms, values, and institutions in free societies, it does not target the material objects or networks; it targets the psychological systems that are utilized to perceive norms, values, and institutions. This study develops a mathematical model of information processing that can capture the mechanism and dynamics of information processing in the context of propaganda or in general information processing with one set of cognitive state representation that can be used for the cognitive system and the information stimuli. The purpose of this study is to explicate via simulation how non-selective elicitation affects the cognitive system’s state evolution with respect to the case of not having non-selective elicitation. 2. Moral Foundation Theory Two people can view the same information but can take different actions. For example, in the context of political issues such as abortion or same-sex marriage, with varying political preferences, the perception of threat can arise, and conflict can ensue. The problem here is not about being right or wrong; the problem is that individuals do not recognize the differences in the interpretative framework that are enabled while perceiving the same phenomena. A book, movie, blog, speech, and tweet all have associated narratives. Narratives and frames are embedded in the story schemata, which describe the contextual regularities [12] of stimuli. When people interact with the regularities in the stimuli, their schemata are modified. A modified schema will affect the information-seeking behavior of the individuals, who then can be inadvertently directed to confirmation bias and trapped in a filter bubble. For example, to counter a conservative filter-bubble concerning abortion, the left should understand the interpretative framework of the conservative right. Thinking about moral issues, e.g., same-sex marriage, is different than thinking about what to do during a long weekend. As a robust theoretical framework, MFT indicates that the human mind interprets social phenomena with five innate foundations: care/harm, fairness/cheating, loyalty/betrayal, authority/subversion, and purity/degradation; details are shown in Table 1 [17]. By using these five innate foundations, the degree of an individual’s political leanings can be expressed [18,19,20]. Haidt [20] argues that morality is innate and learned; morality results from adaptation processes that include psychological mechanisms. As a result, morality can be used to represent the schemata of a target audience and the schemata of the information stream with the same parameters. The five pillars of morality for two major political preferences exhibit different moral matrices [17] Figure 1. The moral matrix of the left is dominated by two of the five moral foundations; the right, social conservatives, have an equally weighted moral matrix [20]. Subsequent MFT studies introduced four categories concerning the patterns in moral pillars [21] Figure 2. The two new categories (liberation and religious left in Figure 2) elucidate the state of the moral mind of the individuals, who are typically categorized as moderates or bi-conceptual [22]. Although morality is innate, it is highly dependent on environmental influences [17,23]. MFT elucidates a framework in which one can study how the human mind is prepared to learn/adapt values and norms that are related to a diverse set of social problems [23]. MFT has commonalities with the construction of social reality [24]. For example, the left perceives the legalization of same-sex marriage as a way to reduce harm for the innocent victims and to increase fairness for everyone [21]; the right perceives same-sex marriage as a different cultural practice, an action against the authority of the church and an impure action [21]. Therefore, the two sides cannot fathom each other unless they comprehend the differences in their interpretative framework. The MFT can provide a unified framework to study the interaction between the human mind and perceptual stimuli in the information environment. An important product of the MFT is its dictionary [25,26,27]; the first MFT dictionary [28] had a limited number of words. Although the first dictionary had been used as the theoretical foundation for several voting prediction studies [21,29,30,31,32] and provided robust results, a newer MFT study [27] suggested a newer version of the dictionary [25], shown in Table 2, which is more comprehensive. MFT delineates characteristics of moral development, such as the construction of social reality, contextual learning/adaptation, being highly intuitive, and being dependent on environmental influences. Propaganda and Moral Foundation Theory MFT can ameliorate the models of information processing/in the information environment that include disinformation propaganda. In this work, four aspects of propaganda that connote the characteristics of the moral foundation theory are discussed. The first aspect: Morality is a product of the construction of social reality. Information connotes the reality [33] and includes disinformation [34]; as a result, taking the totality of information [35] into account is critical to capture the full threat vector of disinformation propaganda. For example, while focusing on the dissemination of disinformation and fake news or critical nodes in social networks, e.g., [13,14,15,16], the interactions that occur between perceptual stimuli and the cognitive dimension can be unheeded. These interactions are part of the construction of social reality, which delineates the perceptual adaptation processes, such as X becomes Y in context C [24]. Since disinformation propaganda aims to undermine the norms, values, and institutions in free societies, it targets the process of construction of reality; in return, cognitive representations of norms, values, and institutions change, and the magnitude of change should be accounted for in the threat vector of disinformation propaganda. The second aspect: Contextual learning and adaptation. Propaganda exploits cognitive peripheral routes, such as watching TV while doing other work, or skimming through updates in social media feeds [8,9,10] so that it can increase its interaction with the target audience [7]. These interactions involve the schemata of the individuals and regularities of the perceptual stimuli [11,12]. As a result, the changing schema of the individual constrains the action and perception of the individual, such as defining the other-than-self [36,37]. In the current information ecosystem, the reciprocal relationship between the user and the environment is augmented with more contextual effects [38]. This provides a perfect ontology for disinforming [38]; as a result, the freedom of choice is controlled, culture is directed, and the danger of being systemically disinformed becomes very real [11]. The third aspect: Morality is highly intuitive and influenced by the environment. Propaganda attempts to smear a specific interpretative framework for the concepts that are pertinent to social norms, values, and institutions [16,38,39]; in doing so, it can induce conflict and confusion concerning social issues. Propaganda standardizes ideas, reinforces prevailing stereotypes, and provides patterns of thought concerning all the aspects of social life. In doing so, propaganda attempts to codify social, political, and moral standards [6]. The distracting elements of the information ecosystem enact fast thinking; hence, the intuitive system controls the decisions [3,20], framing effects increase [40], and analytical reasoning can be hindered [20,22,41]. The fourth aspect: Propaganda cannot create something out of nothing; it must attach itself to a sentiment, an idea that exists in society [6]; it must be associated with a foundation that already exists in the minds of the constituents of the target audience. Propaganda must consist of fundamental psycho-sociological bases, such as pillars of MFT, because propaganda that conflicts with the accepted structure of a target audience would have no possibility of success [6]. 3. Human Mind and Stimuli Interaction The overlapping concept for propaganda, influence, social networks, disinformation, misinformation, and information warfare research is the human element. The models in this field mostly capitalized on the theoretical construct of classical probability theory (CPT). For example, a Bayesian model in this context is a monotonic accumulation model [42] with the constraints of the Bayesian model that has the property of the conjugate update [43]. Belief update in the Bayesian model in the context of propaganda/disinformation/influence operations is sequential and order-independent [43,44,45,46]. Modeling influence with a Bayesian approach not only ignores the order of the information received but also shows no sensitivity between having information one-by-one vs. receiving all at once [45]. Markov models of information sharing/opinion update/influence [47] can also be considered adaptive; however, there is no time sensitivity in the Markov models. A Markov model of influence follows an ergodic behavior and monotonically converges to a stationary distribution [43,48]. A pure quantum probability model (QPT) based model [49,50] can lose the coherence of the system transiently with intended interactions; for example, a decision-making entity elicits a judgment or a decision [50,51,52,53], or by gradually adapting to the environment [48,53]. Both the Markov and Bayesian modeling approaches aligned with the older propaganda/disinformation/influence [54] efforts in which the volume of information was not inflated and, hence, the target audience would monotonically absorb the evidence with the cues in the information stream. For contemporary propaganda/influence operation modeling, these modeling approaches fail to capture ambiguity/indeterminacy [55,56]. More importantly, Bayesian- or Markov-based models represent uncertainty in a way that it decreases as the evidence accumulates; if this is the case, which may not be all the time, the increase in ambiguity/confusion with more information cannot be captured by these CPT based models [44,53,55,56,57]. In the pure quantum model case, the problem is continuous oscillation because it does not consider the interaction element as a continuous dynamic, hence demonstrating indefinite oscillation. The modern-age propaganda is like a firehose [54]. Modern information/influence/propaganda operations are high-volume, repetitive, engagement-driven, and aim at inducing confusion along with persuasion [58,59]. Consequently, the new information ecosystem, in which humans are drawn into information, becomes the perfect habitat for these operations. People in this ecosystem may not know what to pay attention to. Information in the new ecosystems is too timely, which may entail spontaneous action [38]. Its repetitive, continuous stream with high volume of information generates an environment in which humans have very little time to think between perceptual stimuli [54,60,61,62]. This environment gives rise to fast thinking situations in which framing effects can increase [40]. In this environment, humans are exposed to an excessive amount of information, and hence the analytical reasoning processes can be hindered [20]. For example, a conflict can easily arise if the interlocutors use incompatible frames to understand a social phenomenon [22]. Therefore, a framework that can represent destabilization and engagement-timing that can account for judgement/choice/decision elicitation can capture features of modern-age information warfare. Hitherto research indicates that although QPT based models capture some of the shortcomings of CPT based models, using a pure quantum model also introduces modeling shortcomings. However, the quantum open system (QOS) modeling combines Markov and pure quantum models in one equation with single continuous probability distribution [43,48,51,52,53]. 3.1. Quantum Open System Modeling QPT is recognized as a comprehensive method in cognitive modeling [44,49,57]. Mathematical axioms of QPT ameliorate the puzzling experimental findings in cognitive science as they did for physics [63]. One of the peculiar contributions of the QPT is that it can capture different types of uncertainty [64], which may be characterized as either epistemic or ontic [48,51,53,56]. Epistemic uncertainty has to do with a lack of information and can be minimized through gathering additional information from the environment. Ontic uncertainty describes the uncertainty or indeterminacy experienced due to the superposition of the cognitive states that are based on possible outcomes [44]. Ontic uncertainty, indeterminacy can only be resolved through interaction with the environment, for example, eliciting (including non-selective measurement [65]) a category/judgment/decision. The distinctions between epistemic and ontic uncertainty are important for modeling propaganda, especially the ontic type of uncertainty that can allow one to address ambiguity/confusion that is internal to the target audience [51,53,56,61]. Depending on the situational constraints, quantum-like and classical dynamics interchangeably dominate human information processing. To represent the change in dynamics continuously with one single probability distribution, quantum open system (QOS) [66] has been adapted for use in decision modeling [48,51,53]. QOS can capture both the non-commutative relations between incongruent perspectives and interaction effects while also including classical Markovian dynamics. Furthermore, QOS can relate the dissipation and adaptation dynamics of the decision-making with a single probability distribution as a function of time [52]. 3.1.1. QOS Equation The quantum open system is an extension of the Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad (GKSL) equation (please see Appendix B and Appendix C for detailed derivation and proofs), also known as the Lindblad equation [51,67,68], shown in Equation (1).(1)ddtρt=−i·1−q·H,ρ+q·Lρ(2)Lρ=∑γij·Lij·ρ·Lij†−12Lij†·Lij,,ρ(3)Lij†·Lij,,ρ=Lij†·Lij,·ρ+ρ·Lij†·Lij,(4)H,ρ=H·ρ−ρ·H The Equation (1) is the QOS equation and is used to describe cognition and human decision making [48,51,53,69]. The first part of Equation (2) iH,ρ), represents the quantum component. The second part of the Equation (1), L(ρ)), represents the classical Markov component. The weighting parameter, q, in Equation (1) provides a means to weight which element (e.g., Markov or quantum) will dominate the system. For example, when q=0, it signifies that the system is in a fully quantum regime, which indicates a higher ontic uncertainty based on the model simulation; when q=1, quantum dynamics no longer take place, and the system model becomes Markovian. The quantum open system model begins with oscillatory behavior, and due to the interaction with the environment, the oscillation dissipates to a stationary distribution due to the classical dynamics, such as Markov models [67]. The challenge with using Equation (1) as it was used in earlier applications in evidence accumulation [48,51], and trust [53] is that it does not work as it is for the target audience analysis. The reason is that evidence accumulation and trust models in [48,51,53] are both one-dimensional quantum/Markov walks. The modeling assumption in these approaches is like a spatial quantum walk in which states are linearly ordered. If the same assumption is used for MFT pillars, the resulting order will be Care→Fairness→Loyalty→Authority→Purity. However, this is just an arbitrary order that can be found in the seminal MFT work [20,23]. This assumption would introduce a nearest-neighbor structure, which means that with this arbitrary order, some of the moral foundation pillars, cognitively, are assumed to be adjacent, resulting in a chain sequence behavior. 3.1.2. Building Hamiltonian The general Hamiltonian equation is:(5)H=π2·c·C+V0·diags In Equation (5) c(=35) [48] represents the coupling constant, C is the coupling matrix to determine the off-diagonal terms of the Hamiltonian, and s represents the information stream that determines the diagonal potential based on the MFT pillars of the information stream. V0(=500) [48] represents the potential depth, and cV0 (for a detail discussion for these two parameters please see Appendix D) determines the dynamics between adjacent pillars: transition vs. information stream strength. These two modeling parameters are modeling constants and do not approximate any human cognitive characteristics. The use of s as the potential of the attack Hamiltonian rests on the assumption that the relative frequency of moral framings in the information stream translates into the relative strength of the bias those framings attempt to impose on the audience’s cognitive system. This assumption is consistent with findings on the amplified diffusion and priming effects of moral-emotional language in social media in earlier studies. However, it should be noted that word frequency characterizes the content broadcast, not the content received/processed by a user or, in general, a target audience; hence its validation belongs to the future empirical study as discussed in Section 6. The numerical value choices for c and V0 are based on the 35 and 500, which are taken from [48]. In the case of chain approach, the coupling matrix will be:(6)Cchain=0100010100010100010100010 The chain sequence approach was the first Hamiltonian matrix built in this work. However, the Cchain in Equation (6) introduces an arbitrary adjacent coupling to the MFT pillars. In Equation (6), each column represents one MFT pillar (from left to right: Care→Fairness→Loyalty→Authority→Purity), and the off-diagonal 1 entries represent the transition possibility. A theoretically correct approach is to restructure the coupling matrix, C, in the Hamiltonian by using block foundations of the MFT pillars [17,19]. There are two blocks for MFT pillars, which are the individualizing foundation and the binding foundation. The individualizing foundation includes two pillars, which are Care and Fairness; the binding foundation includes three pillars, which are Loyalty, Authority, and Purity. With this approach, the coupling matrix becomes:(7)Cblock=01vvv10vvvvv010vv101vv010 In Equation (7) v represents the strength of coupling between the pillars in a block. For example, Care and Fairness in the individual foundation block coupled with a strength of v. This coupling strength v is between 0 and 1. When v=0, the coupling constant in Equation (7) becomes Cno-coupling; if v=1, the coupling between the pillars becomes fully coupled. This means that every pillar couples directly with the other pillars. However, there is no evidence in the MFT literature to support this super-coupling approach. Having a v value between 0 and 1 provides a coupling within the blocks of MFT. 3.1.3. Building Markov Intensity Matrix Building the Markov component of the QOS equation is similar to building the Hamiltonian. Choosing the Markov intensity matrix Kij without considering the individual/binding block constraint would mean that the classical component of the QOS results in alignment with the information stream schema quickly and under all conditions. In the model, the rate of arrival is expressed by λ; as a result, without the clustering constraint, the rate of change is:(8)λ·si where si in Equation (8) is the information stream. There are options for the information stream profiles for IRA; one is based on the words in the corpus and the other is based on the hashtags, which are shown in Equations (9) and (10) respectively. The details of this discussion are presented in Appendix A.(9)sprofile_words=0.30 0.15 0.18 0.15 0.22(10)sprofile_hashtags=0.08 0.12 0.30 0.25 0.25 By using the same block constraint used in Equations (6) and (7), the new intensity matrix will be:(11)Kij=λ·Cij·si Since Cblock in Equation (6) is symmetric, Cij=Cji, Kij·sj=Kji·si, K·s=0 is ensured and the stationary distribution will be still si. 3.1.4. Operationalizing K and H Matrices in QOS The QOS equation shown in Equation (1) requires adjustment to operationalize the K and H matrices. The density matrix, ρ, is a 5 × 5 matrix that represents the general cognitive system of the target audience with the pillars of the MFT. The diagonal entries pi represent the probability of a foundation pillar based on the target audience MFT category that is shown in Figure 1. In this work, a new super operator that acts on ρ is introduced to account for the defense mechanics of the target audience in the same equation. This new operator Ltotal is (please see Appendix B for details):(12)∂ρ∂t=Ltotal·ρ The super operator Ltotal is written as:(13)Ltotal=γ⏟attackweight·q·H⏟Quantumdynamics+1−q·Dattack⏟Maikov attackdynamics+1−γ⏞defenseweight·Ddefense⏟DefenseMarkov In Equation (13) there are two forces in action, which are attack and defense. The attack force dynamics can be quantum and classical Markov dynamics. Each of these dynamics represents the operators that can act on the cognitive system by considering the information stimuli. Quantum dynamics in the attack component in Equation (13) is similar to the fast thinking aspect, which is also known as system 1 [70], which derives the confusion when exposed to cues in an information stream. On the other hand, the Markov dynamics in the attack component in Equation (13) is akin to a more analytical slow-thinking system 2 [70]. The defense component in the super-operator Ltotal only includes classical Markov because of the assumption that defense mechanics requires more analytical reasoning and it will be slower, as assumed in system 2 [70]. The attack weight γ is between 0 and 1; the quantum vs. classical weight q is between 0 and 1 [48,51,53,69]. The hitherto Hamiltonian discussion in this work provides a sufficient construct to build the model; however, the K requires more discussion to distinguish the Kattack and Kdefense. Kattack Intensity Matrix In Equation (13) by following the discussion in [48,51,53,69], Dattack of the attack component can be written as:(14)Dattackρ=∑k≠jKkj·Lkj·ρ·Lkj†−12Lkj†Lkj,ρ The intensity matrix Kattack in Equation (14) is calculated as follows:(15)Kij=λ·Cij·sii≠j−∑k≠jλ·Ckj·ski=j Based on Equation (15), the off-diagonal elements are scaled by Cij, hence, the transition within a moral cluster (individual/binding) can occur at full rate because Cij=1. On the other hand, cross-cluster block transition rates will be weighted by v, where Cij=v. The intensity matrix of the attack component Kattack is a 5 × 5 Markov intensity matrix with a stationary distribution si, the chosen information stream. The state of this 5 × 5 Markov matrix is based on the pillars of the MFT. The attack dissipator in Equation (14) Dattack represents either analytical reasoning that derives accepting the information stream schema; or it represents the adaptation to the information environment. The diagonal elements of D(ρ) reproduce the classical master equation, which is dpdt=K·p, where p is a probability column vector. Including Kij in Equation (14) delivers the consistency of the dissipator factor to operate on all of the elements of the density matrix, not just the diagonal elements. Kdefense Intensity Matrix The defense intensity matrix is built in the same way as Kattack in terms of the cluster block matrix. The only difference between Kattack and Kdefense is that the stationary distribution in the defense intensity matrix is represented as p0, which is the prior distribution of the audience’s cognitive system based on the MFT pillars.(16)Kij=λ·Cij·p0i≠j−∑k≠jλ·Ckj·p0i=j By using Kdefense in Equation (16), the dissipater, Ddefense, is built as in Equation (14). 4. Simulation Analysis and Results The goal of the analysis is to use the QOS model to simulate the evolution of the cognitive system represented by ρ under different conditions that are characterized by q and γ values to understand the behavior of the target audience under different conditions. The parameter values that are used in this analysis are shown in Table 3. The text analysis, Appendix A, provides the quantitative characterization of the attack through si; the literature provides the characterization of the defenders and the prior distribution; and the simulation combines the two components in this work. The choice of these parameters is to analyze the interaction between a target audience with information stream at boundary conditions, e.g., fully quantum, minimal attack, and decision elicitation. There are two conditions in each analysis: control and treatment. A treatment condition in this simulation represents a group that, in an experiment, would be the group that is prompted to elicit a decision, choice, or judgment. The treatment condition represents the elicitation, which is a categorization of a phenomenon or a cue. The control condition in this simulation represents a group that would decide without eliciting a categorization or an intermediate judgment. The comparison between the control and treatment conditions via simulation is done to explicate how a categorization/intermediate judgment can affect the evolution of the cognitive state of a target audience. This state evolution is an important feature of the quantum models because prompting a confused target audience can be directed to a chosen outcome [61,71], if the amplitude of the confusion is tracked. When a target audience is exposed to an information stream for a long time, the dissipater dynamic dominates and off-diagonal terms of the density matrix become zero [53]. The logic of this elicitation is to replicate this adaptation process with forced categorization. The coherence is destroyed (ρ→diag(diag(ρ)), but the population is untouched. The elicitation acts on coherence (not on a single system state, which is one of the MFT pillars) such that an induced ambiguity can be used as an advantage to substantiate a firm understanding at the cognitive level. This process is also known as non-selective measurement [65]. An elicitation event, in the present interpretation, is any interaction situation that prompts a user to commit (even if it is inadvertently) to a moral framing of the cued phenomenon. This can be through participating in a poll, a reply or quote tweet in response to a solicitation, deciding whether to share or endorse, or reacting to content. The measurement is non-selective in nature because the model does not condition on which framing the user choose/commits; instead, the elicited ensemble is averaged over outcomes, corresponding to a population where an engagement is prompted but individual responses are not tracked. This is an interpretive correspondence, not an empirically established correspondence. The dataset records the tweet contents, not the interaction histories of exposed users; hence, its validation is part of the future empirical study. Thus, the elicitation is the act of categorization itself, averaged over all possible answers weighted by their probabilities. No single foundation is picked out; the whole superposition is collapsed into a classical mixture across all five pillars, with the population weights preserved. From the propaganda perspective, elicitation is the moment a propaganda feed prompts a reaction; for instance, these prompts can be share this, share this, which side are you on, which side are you on, react now, react now, who would you vote for in November. who would you vote for in November. The target audience is pushed to substantiate a moral framing of the cue; for example, is this cue a:Loyalty matter?Care matter?Authority matter? Loyalty matter? Loyalty matter? Care matter? Care matter? Authority matter? Authority matter? To sum up, the act of measurement in simulation captures the treatment condition; in the quantum model, the act of being forced to categorize a cue affects the ambiguity that is captured by the oscillation [61]. In addition to the parameters listed in Table 4, the initial cognitive state distribution of each group, two idealized, ensemble-level audience profiles derived from published moral foundations survey research; the scope and limits of this two-profile design are stated in Section 3. The two idealized p0 distributions are as follows:(17)p0 Conservative=0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20(18)p0 progressive=0.35 0.35 0.12 0.10 0.08 4.1. Pure Quantum Case #1 q=1, γ=1 In this condition, the behavior of the target audience was simulated for both of the information streams that are shown in Equations (9) and (10). Since q=1, in the attack component there is no Markov contribution and there is no defense mechanics involved because γ=1. Under these two conditions, the behavior of a target audience over time is dominated with full quantum dynamics. For the control condition in Figure 3 and Figure 4, both the conservative and progressive audiences demonstrate oscillating behavior in the model when they are exposed to the information streams that have different distributions. This oscillation represents the ontic type of uncertainty [48,51,53,56,61] that represents the confusion an individual in the target audience experiences due to the superposition/coherence of the cognitive states. Ontic type uncertainty describes the internal ambiguity that an individual experiences while processing any new information [53,55,56,60,61]. In this condition, there is no dissipating dynamics; as a result, until an elicitation is prompted for a categorization/decision, the coherence is not interrupted, as shown in Figure 5. The treatment condition simulates when an audience is prompted to elicit a categorization through a non-selective measurement process; within the model, it demonstrates different behavior than the control condition. The graphs in Figure 3 and Figure 4 demonstrate, in the model’s dynamics, that the introduced block coupling to avoid chain progress captures the progressive audience resistance to the binding stream, shown in Equation (10) (system stays in Care/Fairness domain). However, repeated elicitation and non-selective measurement manage to force some probability across the moral-family boundary into the binding foundations (Authority, Loyalty and Purity). This supports the idea that the individualizing/binding boundary introduces distinct vulnerabilities, and prompting is the mechanism that makes the breach possible. The sociological significance of the transition between foundations in the simulation analysis is worth elucidating. In MFT, the binding foundations, which are Loyalty, Authority, and Purity, are the parochial foundations [20,21]. The binding foundations are associated with group binding behavior that holds members together and draws a boundary that defines who is not in the group [23]. Empirical work in moral and political psychology has linked the binding foundations to out-group derogation, prejudicial attitudes, and support for exclusionary policy [18,21,23], and Purity-based framing has been associated with dehumanizing characterizations of out-groups [18,21,23,27,28]. The result of the analyzed Twitter data in Appendix A supports these framings. For example, the anti-Islamic and anti-immigrant content documented in Table A1 is constructed as Loyalty appeals with betrayal narratives and in-group solidarity. Purity appeals, for example, with an invasion metaphor. The elicitation-driven shift of probability across the individualizing/binding boundary in Figure 3 and Figure 4 represents, in the context of this theoretical work, how propaganda can weaponize/exploit/create boundary-drawing situations. It should be noted that the limit of this interpretation is as follows. Heightened binding-foundation does not constitute a discriminatory attitude, and the introduced coupling parameter v is a constant parameter in the model. As a result, this parameter is not an empirically tested/adjusted threshold of attitude change. What the introduced model identifies is a dynamic that describes susceptibility to us-vs.-them context that can be bolstered by the repeated elicitation. The comparison and testing between simulated state trajectories and measured attitudes remains an empirical question, addressed in the future-work research in Section 6. For a conservative target audience, the prior distribution, p0 shown in Equation (17), is uniform; as a result, a simulated conservative population experiences more oscillation compared with the progressive audience, a comparison shown in Figure 5. As can be seen in Figure 3, the breach between the two blocks is higher in Fairness with non-selective measurement after prompting to elicit. This is something that needs to be investigated further because of the nature of the quantum random walk that considers spatial priority (closer to the binding block) to Fairness. Figure 6 shows the final moral foundation probability distribution per pillar. The progressive audience in Figure 6 has become more aligned with the elicitation process. This simulation model indicates that although the information stream induces confusion, the elicitation determines the final non-kinetic effect. As discussed in [54], confusion is the goal for modern-age propaganda; however, substantiating an alignment between the information stream and the cognitive system is required to have an effect. For the simulated conservative target audience, eliciting also helps to align with the information stream MFT distribution. Figure 7 demonstrates how eliciting dynamics in the model improves the non-kinetic effects of propaganda. The total variation distance is calculated as:(19)TVDp,s=12∑i=1npi−si Both the conservative and progressive target audiences were affected by the information stream and got closer to the stream distribution when elicitation, non-selective measurement, occurs. 4.2. Pure Quantum Case #2 q=1, γ=0.01 In this set of conditions, although there is no Markov component for the attack, there is a heavy defense component which is Markovian. As can be seen in Figure 8, Figure 9 and Figure 10, the defense mechanics prevents oscillation and pulls the final distribution towards the prior distributions for both conditions. Regardless of the information stream type, hashtag or word, the defense mechanism prevails, and the target audience preserves its perspective. As shown in Figure 8 and Figure 9, elicitation expedites the stabilization and minimizes the confusion. As shown in Figure 11, eliciting when prompted, improved the defense efforts, and final MFT probability distribution per pillar remained at the prior distribution levels. 4.3. Pure Classical Case #1 q=0, γ=1 In this set of conditions, the developed model is tested for Markov dynamics of the attack component without having any defense resistance. The conservative group increased the probability distribution for the binding block MFT pillars shown in Figure 12; in both of the information stream cases, the target audience perspective adapts to the information stream distribution. For the progressive target audience, the same behavior is observed within the model simulation; for both of the information stream conditions, the MFT probability distribution adapts, as shown in Figure 13, to the stream’s distribution. Since there is no quantum contribution in the attack component, the treatment and control condition results are identical, as shown in Figure 14, and no oscillation has been seen in the model simulation. This shows the unique aspect of modeling human behavior with quantum dynamics. 4.4. Pure Classical Case #2 q=0, γ=0.01 In this set of conditions, what is tested is that the defense mechanism dominates the process and the only attack component is classical Markovian. As can be seen in Figure 15, Figure 16 and Figure 17, the system protects the prior distribution in all cases, and each target audience maintains its initial distribution regardless of the information stream. This is a checkpoint for the model’s defense mechanics, if that is consistent in terms of defending against a weak information exposure. 4.5. Full Quantum q=1 Balanced Attack and Defense γ=0.5 In this set of conditions, the attack component is dominated by the quantum dynamics, and the defense and attack components are equally weighted. Similar to the previous full quantum dynamic case, the non-selective elicitation serves the purpose of the propaganda. For example, as shown in Figure 18, elicitation helps to align the conservative prior to the stream, which is also conservative. However, as can be seen in Figure 19, the non-selective measurement, in the simulation model, changes the probability distribution in favor of the information stream. This simulation model indicates that the confusion element discussed in [54] is accentuated with the quantum model; when a target audience is confused, the subsequent prompted elicitation of a category in the form of non-selective measurement, within the model simulation, changes the outcome in favor of propaganda, which can also be seen in Figure 20 and Figure 21. 4.6. TVD Comparison for γ=0.5, q=[0.1−1.0] So far in the analysis section, different sets of conditions were used to show how the model captures different behaviors. The model captures the critical characteristic of human behavior that is consistent with the earlier research in quantum open system modeling. In this section, 10 different conditions, shown in Table 4, were used to test the total variation distance outcome with the information stream set to Hashtags. As shown in Equation (10), the distribution generates more conversion with the progressive perspective, and elicitation helps to change a progressive perspective to a conservative perspective. However, since the information stream is not in a big conflict as it is with the conservative distribution, other full quantum cases, elicitation does not help the information stream. Figure 22 shows a condition in which Markov attack dynamics are 20% more dominant than the quantum dynamics. As expected, relatively smaller oscillations for both treatment and control groups have been observed in the model simulation; however, due to the presence of quantum dynamics, elicitation in the simulation model, via non-selective measurement, pushes the progressive target audience towards the information stream distribution, and the target audience perspective becomes more aligned with the conservative perspective, all of which are within the simulation model. Figure 23 shows a balanced attack condition, and the sensitivity of the progressive group to non-selective elicitation is still higher compared with the conservative group. This is expected because the information stream is already conservative. The key observation for the conservative group is that non-selective elicitation allows the target audience to preserve the probability distribution within the binding block. Figure 24 shows a case in which quantum attack components are more dominant over the Markov attack component. Figure 24 demonstrates that in the case of having higher oscillation, the elicitation, in the simulated dynamics, helps the stream such that the progressive perspective becomes aligned with the conservative perspective. The non-selective measurement, in this simulation study, gives a boost to the intended effect of the information stream in the case of the progressive target audience more than the conservative target audience. For the conservative audience, the partial quantum attack, q<1, is more comprehensive than the fully quantum one q=1, because the classical channel keeps pushing while the pure quantum (dominated by Hamiltonian dynamics only) attack freezes at the maximum mixed point. Maximum quantumness is not maximum propaganda effectiveness for a uniform-prior audience. A propaganda operation using a highly coherent attack, which aims to generate/exploit ambiguity, can improve the intended outcome by prompting engagement more frequently and focusing earlier and altering prompting; each prompt collapses the ambiguity (off-diagonal elements become zero) before it can resolve back, pulling the audience toward the stream. High-frequency engagement/prompting can be a way to convert oscillatory destabilization into directional capture. 5. Conclusions This paper demonstrated that MFT can be used in an interaction model to represent a cognitive system and information stimuli. The model delivered in this research can be used to analyze the information interaction activities in the information environment; the effects of information interaction can be simulated with this model. The main drawback of the common approaches is that there is no unified framework to represent the schema of the target audience and the schema of the information stream with the same basis for the system states. Using the five-pillar psychological system of the moral foundation theory to represent the system states in the interaction introduces a framework to analyze and study adaptation, intuition, and environmental influences in a systemic way in the context of disinformation propaganda. The unique aspects of the model are as follows. First, the model accounts for both the quantum and classical dynamics. Second, the information stimuli, attack mechanics, defense mechanics, and the cognitive system are represented on a single common basis, the five-dimensional moral foundation state space. The introduced model supports an adjustable attack vector for an information stream and defense vector for the cognitive system. The model is capable of representing confusion (via coherence that captures ontic type uncertainty) of a target audience that is exposed to an information stream. As discussed, creating confusion is one of the characteristics of propaganda in the information age. The level of confusion can be adjusted by the parameters of the model, such as q,γ, v, λ. It should be noted that the model of this work predicts mechanisms and dynamics (in the simulation model), and more importantly, these mechanisms and dynamics have not been validated or tested against measured audience responses, within the simulation results of the model, and the Twitter data does not include information to use for this purpose. Consequently, the model developed in this study is an inference tool, not a source of statistical evidence about experimentally observed events. This inference tool is to elucidate mechanisms/dynamics when such cognitive dynamics could arise. Empirical validation of the mechanisms and dynamics remains a task for future research, which is discussed in Section 6. The mechanisms/dynamics identified in this paper can have implications outside the model and be summarized as follows. (1) The amplifying effect of non-selective elicitation implies that information-disseminating platforms’ features designed to prompt engagement can function as elicitation events as described in this model. (2) The word frequency analysis in Appendix A shows the most frequently used words in the Twitter data. However, from an information-processing and interaction perspective, the dynamics and mechanisms demonstrated in this model support a new perspective on the interaction model. This work argues that effective countering requires engagement at the level of generalizable framing, such as MFT, rather than vocabulary content. (3) A model of target-audience vulnerability certainly can be dual-use. For example, the same analysis that supports defense can inform targeting. These are stated as risks and mechanisms/dynamics, not as operational recommendations, because the simulation model predicts mechanism/dynamics and requires validation against measured audience responses. In the simulation model, recommendations for platform operators would require empirical evidence, which can be done with future research. The mechanisms/dynamics introduced in this work identify potential safeguards that are quantifiable in the parameters of the model. For example, interface contact that prompts deliberation before engagement would mean requiring an article to be opened before resharing. This can be considered as a possible design approach to reduce the frequency of elicitation events, and the results of this paper predict their simulated effect; for example, less frequent elicitation substantially weakened capture by the information stream. Designs that introduce a delay before response can be related to increased relative weight on the defense channel, under which the cognitive state relaxes toward the audience’s prior between exposures. It should be noted that these are mechanism/dynamics derived hypotheses about intervention, not validated recommendations. This study, within the model, demonstrates that the predicted simulation effects follow from the model; their real-world behavior is an empirical question belonging to future empirical work, and their implementation involves trade-offs between safeguarding and expression that require normative analysis beyond a modeling study. Without recognizing the psychological systems as a foundation to represent mental states of the individuals, the efforts to counter disinformation propaganda would not only fail but also carry the risk of inadvertently augmenting the intent of the disinformation propaganda. Since propaganda exploits the cognitive peripheral routes, an approach that is supported by MFT will ameliorate the design of the counter-disinformation operation with a comprehensive framework. Removing a node in a network or the content from the World Wide Web will not undo the impacts of the disinformation propaganda from the cognitive dimension. Moreover, ignoring this aspect means that individuals in free societies can become more vulnerable to threats in the information ecosystem. 6. Limitations and Future Research This study is a theoretical model-development study. The developed model has not been tested with any data. The developed model builds on previous open system modeling techniques [48] and introduces a new method to monitor the complete positivity of the ρ density matrix for cognitive modeling. The presented model includes the information stream, the attack-defense balance, and the quantum-classical balancing elements over the evolution. However, this has not been tested with any human subject experimentation. Therefore, the limits of the claim are at the theoretical level. The target audiences studied are likewise idealized, such as the conservative and progressive profiles, which are ensemble-level characterizations drawn from published MFT survey research, not populations measured from the platform data. The two-profile (conservative vs. progressive) design of the model abstracts away in-group heterogeneity and from any moral contexts specific to different communities, including ethnic-minority contexts, and no conclusion attaches to any individual user. It should be noted that the uniform profile extracted from MFT literature lies at the center of the moral foundation spectrum, hence, the design of the information stream in the model spans the moderate-to-skewed range rather than opposing ends. The Twitter data serves to extract the moral foundation profile of a real information stream. The data set does not contain any behavioral or demographic information about exposed users, as a result, it characterizes the stimulus rather than validating the model’s predicted responses in the simulation, for example, in the case of elicitation. A stated bridging assumption underlies the stimulus representation that the relative frequency of moral framings in the stream translates into the relative strength of the bias exerted on the cognitive dimension, on the other hand, word frequency characterizes the content of the broadcast, not the content received by the information processing entity. Appendix B establishes GKSL validity uniformly across the parameter conditions studied. In real-time information operations, the parameters vary in time; for example, stream strength changes with campaign dynamics, or the target audience’s defense strength varies as well. In such time-varying settings, validity is no longer guaranteed by a single theorem; in fact, it becomes a property of each evolution interval, and the Choi criterion (see Appendix C) introduced into the model is the instrument that extends the framework to that regime. This study makes no empirical claims about audience responses; however, the introduced Choi criterion, together with the introduced model, allows (as part of future empirical work) an empirical testing of a question, that is, “is target audience cognition under a continuous information stream Markovian, or is it history dependent, exhibiting phenomena such as inoculation?” This question can be tested with data because, in the case where CP violations are present, they become an indicator of memory effects [72,73]. Two extensions can be derived from the results of this study. (1) The vulnerability asymmetry reported here should be tested for symmetry. For example, exposing the conservative profile to a Care/Fairness-dominant stream would determine whether the observed sensitivity in the model simulation is a property of a mismatch between audience and stream or solely a property of an audience profile. (2) The metrics reported in this paper are total variation distance (TDV) and net shift. These metrics quantify only an audience’s shift toward the information stream distribution. These two metrics fail to distinguish other forms of displacement. For example, a state may move toward moral profiles that belong to neither the audience’s prior nor the profile of the information stream. Therefore, developing displacement measures that can separate alignment with the stream from such off-target displacement, and relating them to coherence-based measures of ambiguity/confusion, is the next step for this study.