Clinician Perspectives on Barriers and Facilitators to Abdominal Organ Transplant Access Authors: Norine W. Chan, Carl Mhina, Whitney Welsh, Maia Anderson, Yee Lu, Ali Herman, Darrel Cleere, Constance Mobley, Rhiannon Reed, Lisa M. McElroy Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Key PointsQuestionWhat do clinicians and staff involved in the transplant selection process perceive to be barriers and facilitators to equitable organ transplant access?FindingsIn this qualitative study of 52 clinicians and staff at 3 large transplant centers, dominant barriers to equitable transplant access included costs of care, process navigation difficulty, and workflow inefficiencies. Facilitators included promotion of patient literacy, patient engagement, and clinician commitment.MeaningThese findings suggest that transplant centers can implement systems-level interventions that build on patient-level programs to improve transplant access through leveraging facilitators to patient access and optimizing barrier mitigation. Introduction Transplant is a lifesaving treatment for patients with end-stage organ disease, but most patients in the US referred for solid organ transplant are not placed on a transplant waiting list, with long-standing disparities among racial and ethnic minoritized groups and socially deprived groups.1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19 A large volume of scientific research has focused on improving equity in access to abdominal transplant. However, most interventions have focused on patient-level factors, such as education and caregiving.20,21,22,23 Within transplant centers, the candidacy determination process involves medical, surgical, and psychosocial evaluations. A multidisciplinary selection committee with representatives from medicine, surgery, social work, and nursing makes the final eligibility determination, based on distinct perspectives on risks and resiliencies of the evaluated patients. These transplant team members therefore hold unique insight into factors that hinder or facilitate transplant access.21 By building on qualitative stakeholder studies in other specialties,24,25,26,27,28,29,30 we sought to understand clinician and staff perspectives on factors influencing access to abdominal organ transplant. Additionally, we explored how barriers and facilitators during the selection process can inform interventions to reduce disparities in transplant access. Methods Study Design and Participants We conducted a qualitative descriptive study in accordance with the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ) guidelines31 using semistructured interviews of transplant clinicians and staff at 3 US transplant centers (Duke University, Durham, North Carolina; Houston Methodist, Houston, Texas; and University of Michigan, Ann Arbor) (eMethods in Supplement 1). Clinicians and staff (eg, physicians, nurse coordinators, financial coordinators, social workers, psychologists, and administrators) involved in the kidney, liver, pancreas, or intestine transplant programs at each institution were eligible for participation. Recruitment and Data Collection Study approval was obtained from the participating centers’ institutional review boards prior to recruitment. Participants were purposively recruited via email.32 A sample size of at least 15 stakeholders from each center was chosen based on data saturation literature.33 The semistructured interview guide was informed by the Practical, Robust Implementation and Sustainability Model (PRISM) conceptual framework and a literature review on the transplant selection process and equity in transplant access (eMethods in Supplement 1).2,34,35 Trained team members not associated with the transplant selection process conducted interviews between September 1, 2022, and August 25, 2023. Interviews lasted 30 to 45 minutes and were conducted via videoconferencing with no other persons present. Verbal consent was obtained at the start of each interview, and all interviews were recorded and transcribed with the participants’ permission. Data Analysis After data collection was complete, 2 analysts (including the principal investigator [C.M. and L.M.M.]) reviewed a sample of the transcripts and developed an a priori codebook derived from the interview guide. Thematic analysis was applied to analyze the data in a multistage deductive and inductive approach using NVivo software, version 14 (QSR International Pty Ltd).36 The analysts piloted the codebook by independently coding 1 transcript from each site. Discrepancies in coding were resolved through discussion, and edits were made to the codebook in an iterative fashion with transcripts recoded as needed. Intercoder agreement was assessed on 14% of the transcripts to ensure reliability of code application. After the codebook was finalized, one analyst (C.M.) coded the remainder of the text. Coding frequency tables and narrative summaries were then generated, and findings were shared with the participating centers. Results The study population included 52 clinicians and staff (24 physicians [46.2%], 18 transplant coordinators [34.6%], 3 dieticians [5.8%], 3 social workers [5.8%], 2 transplant referral intake specialists [3.8%], and 2 pharmacists [3.8%]) (Table 1). Our analysis identified 11 themes related to transplant access reflecting 6 barriers and 5 facilitators. Representative quotations are presented in Table 2. Table 1. Characteristics of Interview ParticipantsRolesNo. (%) of participants (N = 52)aCenter 1Center 2Center 3Coordinator Liver2 (3.8)2 (3.8)3 (5.8) Kidney3 (5.8)2 (3.8)3 (5.8) Financial1 (1.9)1 (1.9)1 (1.9)Surgeon2 (3.8)5 (9.6)2 (3.8)Hepatologist2 (3.8)2 (3.8)2 (3.8)Nephrologist2 (3.8)5 (9.6)2 (3.8)Pharmacist1 (1.9)0 1 (1.9)Dietician1 (1.9)1 (1.9)1 (1.9)Social worker1 (1.9)1 (1.9)1 (1.9)Referral intake specialist1 (1.9)1 (1.9)0 a Center 1 included 16 participants; center 2, 20; and center 3, 16. Characteristics of Interview Participants Center 1 included 16 participants; center 2, 20; and center 3, 16. Table 2. Representative Quotations of Identified ThemesThemeQuotation (transplant center role) Barriers to access Inadequate caregiver resourcesSo, I think some of the barriers that we run into with caregivers, especially in these historically marginalized communities, is driver’s license, you have to drive to be a good caregiver. And if you either don’t have a license, not legally at least, or aren’t comfortable driving. (Pretransplant coordinator)The emphasis placed on psychosocial factors, which may differ from patients, and cause inequities. So, for example, the internal policies of requiring 2 caregivers, that may not be available to everyone out there. The amount of, let’s see, influence put on the level of caregiving, or the assessment of the level; the competency of the caregivers. (Kidney transplant surgeon)…In some cases, just making it to appointments, just having somebody to transport patients to appointments, and get some of the testing that’s needed can be a significant challenge for some patients, just because their needed caregivers are not financially comfortable, they may not have transportation, and then that makes it difficult as opposed to the person whose immediate caregivers have access to transportation. (Liver transplant surgeon)Transplant is really resource intensive for patients and hospitals and so you have to come in with a degree of sophistication in how to navigate that and how to figure out all this stuff of how to get to the transplant center and what you have to do. And you have to have people that are willing to do that for you, and if you’ve got family that have to work and they don’t have flexible jobs, that’s really hard and that can make it really challenging for some of our patients to find people who can help them. (Transplant hepatologist)Costs of care and financial strainMedicaid patients—and when I say that, I mean they don’t have Medicare and Medicaid. So, that patient that is strictly a Medicaid patient, their income for an individual is less than $1000 a month. Every time they come to a clinic appointment, it’s $13 for parking. And depending on where they live, it’s the gas to get here. (Senior financial coordinator)Still, in terms of the financial aspect, unfortunately even those who do have medical insurance, there is the patient responsibility portion, the copays, however you wanna put it, and unfortunately for some patients, even that having insurance, whatever is their portion to pay is still significant to them. (Transplant hepatologist)They’re living on fixed incomes and many times when I go to set someone up, they’re telling me, well, I can’t come until after the first of the month when I get my check. (Liver transplant coordinator)For example, the most recent roadblock we had was not having a Medicaid coverage at all. Not taking any Medicaid. We’ve fixed that and we’re on the verge of getting another Medicaid contract, so I think that helps with our, again, our patients that financially are underinsured or have no insurance coverage at all. (Liver transplant social worker)Difficulty with transplant process navigationIf we’re reaching out to them and asking them for things and we’re just not getting that return communication because it just looks like a pattern that that’s how it’s going to be after transplant. We look at those patterns pretty close to be like this is showing us that. You are showing us that you are not going to be able to do this. You’re not doing this pre transplant. This looks to us like you are not going to do that post transplant. So, we don’t have a minimum set criteria for how much they’re communicating with us. But if they are not communicating with us when we’re communicating with them, it’s an issue. (Kidney transplant coordinator)So, in terms of language barriers, obviously those that are English speaking they have an advantage because they are able to understand what’s being communicated to them. Those that are non-English speaking, sometimes they bring family members, or we will access interpreter services in order to interpret for us but sometimes you can tell that it’s a little frustrating for some patients and so they don’t—well, I don’t know 100% but they probably don’t say or ask all that they really wanna express because they have to have that secondhand person that’s interpreting the information for them. (Liver transplant coordinator)In general, understanding why certain populations have an inherent distrust toward the healthcare system, and I think that if we realistically try to address that, I think that will be the first step in removing some of these barriers. (Transplant hepatologist)How can I include you on a video visit with medical psychology when you have a flip phone? How can I reach you and ask you to do that when you don’t have internet access? How can I tell you that if I wanna get you there or whatever, and your son has a computer and an Apple phone, but you can’t read, it’s not gonna work? (Kidney transplant coordinator)Sometimes not knowing fully what the transplant process entails and just not wanting to proceed with it could be another factor [affecting access]. Because when we see patients in the hospital and we bring up transplant, some patients do not want to hear about it because they feel like it’s a major surgery and they do not want to go through it. (Transplant hepatologist)Transplant clinician biasAnd I think that we don’t, for whatever reason, for some people we don’t think about, or their physicians aren’t thinking about that, or if they’re making judgment calls about like, well, they don’t have a lot of social support resources or they’re in and out of employment, and making judgment calls about them based upon their social determinants of health that may not be accurate in terms of if they would be a transplant candidate. (Transplant hepatologist)[They] might make an assumption that like, oh yeah, this person is not a good candidate because of X, Y or Z, when in fact, we might be able to fix some of those things or work on some of those things or get access to resources, because the transplant center does have quite a number of resources that aren’t often readily available elsewhere. (Transplant hepatologist)[On an “ideal” transplant candidate] They’re listening. They’re calm. They’re polite. They want to take care of themselves. They have a positive attitude more than anything. So, for the most part, I haven’t had any patients that were difficult in recent history. (Referral intake specialist)I do have some personal unsettling issues about how patients are put on the transplant list. And when I say that, I’m saying because we take our bias to that table. (Kidney transplant coordinator)Family support, transportation, those things are huge barriers for our patients, and I find that in the 22 years that I’ve done this, it tends to be like the alcoholics, unfortunately, who don’t have that. (Kidney transplant coordinator)Workflow inefficiencies and variabilityIf I had a preference, I would love to check in with them in the middle of the year. But there are so many patients, we’re constantly getting new ones and it’s impossible. But if I had my ideal scenario, I would but I can’t. (Kidney transplant coordinator)I have patients that call me and they’re mad. I haven’t heard from you in three months. So, what’s going on. And I’m like nothing. We’re waiting for organ offers. I don’t have the time to call you and update and see what’s going on. (Kidney transplant coordinator)The most tedious will be when we have insurance that are small companies and they are difficult to deal with and you have to do all this work around it and get special pricing agreements and go back and forth, back and forth and that just prolongs the approval, prolongs the health, for us to be able to start with the evaluation and help the patient, especially when the patient is really, really sick. (Financial coordinator)I think that things can be better or more efficient if the process can be simplified a little for us to be able to tackle our work sooner. (Financial coordinator)Social and environmental drivers of transplant accessI’ve said this time and time again, we transplant old, white men. And with them, there’s almost an expectation of, “Well, I’ve done all this. I’ve gotten here, you have to transplant me.” (Liver transplant coordinator)[On who has difficulty accessing transplant] Anybody whose skin is browner than mine, basically. And poor people. I think poor people have almost more, the working poor have a harder time. (Pretransplant liver coordinator)The disparities are real evident. It’s the have and the have nots. It’s always been. It’s always going to be about are you able to be able to get to the care that you need? So, we not only have economic status, we have rural areas. We have race. We have all of these things. And there has always been a disparity among those groups that…. You live in rural areas. Your race, you don’t have enough income. Your insurance that you have… (Financial coordinator)Where a lot of our other patients, if you have a smaller support system, or you really are having some financial issues, and you’re having trouble getting your meds, which is impacting your adherence, or you don’t have a car, and so it’s keeping you from being able to get back and forth, these are all the things that’s kind of like it’s stopped them previously from being able to do stuff. (Kidney transplant coordinator) Facilitators to access Patient engagement and interactionThe more face-to-face interaction that you have with these patients, I think the easier it is to take care of them, and to trust, and all that stuff. So, something face-to-face would be very nice. If we had a teleporter, that’d be great. (Liver transplant coordinator)I like interacting with you. If you’re talking back to me, I can get from you how much of this you’re absorbing. Whereas if I’m sending you a message, I don’t know when you’re going to see it, how much of that you’re, actually, paying attention to. (Kidney transplant coordinator)I have a lower to moderate threshold for compliance now (1) because I’ve just had such a large population of it. But (2) they’re not as likely to do as well after transplant because it’s such a lifestyle change. It’s such a big commitment. So, if they can’t even do the basics to get through pre, they likely aren’t going to do well post because nobody is going to handhold them through it. There has to be a lot of independence and autonomy. So, I have ended a lot of patients but I have also had a lot of patients come back with the list of things that they need to get done and they do better the second time around. (Kidney transplant coordinator)That electronic piece is good for us. It ain’t good for them but it’s really not good for us to work with them because we can’t see emotion. We can’t see anxiety. We can’t do anything—you can’t do anything through electronics. You can hear agitation, angst on a telephone. (Kidney transplant coordinator)Strong patient support systemsWe try to just make sure that they have the support that they need to be successful after transplant, so we just have to make sure that they have a really solid caregiving plan. (Pretransplant kidney coordinator)Making sure that we’re educating people and educating directly to patients and also directly to their caregivers and to physicians so that patients and their caregivers can also advocate for a transplant appointment if they feel like it might be necessary and they say, hey, I heard about this on the news or whatever and I think that this might be something that’s good for my mom or my dad or my sister or whatever, that they can feel empowered to do that and to get that connection into the transplant center. (Transplant hepatologist)So, I don’t think I’ve ever met the perfect candidate, but a good candidate would be someone who comes before starting dialysis who is not very sick yet, preferably does not have diabetes as their primary disease or comorbidity, but our patients who do well have polycystic kidney disease, for example. So, depending on the disease they have, and a strong family support to undergo this procedure and bandwidth to endure any complications that may happen. (Transplant nephrologist)But I think sometimes those caregivers who are working those hourly jobs or who have very few PTO [personal time off] hours, maybe allowing them still to do their job to save the time for transplant. And so, kind of giving some grace to those patients of like, “Okay. Your caregiver’s not here with you, but have them call me,” sort of thing. We can confirm it via phone. (Kidney and liver transplant social worker)I would say getting more objective data into the literature about how some of these psychosocial factors—for example, having a second caregiver, or having a car—how those things actually impact a transplant outcome, because I think there are no clear guidelines on that. (Kidney and liver transplant surgeon)Transplant clinician commitment to patient successI have seen everybody that I have worked with so far going above and beyond to try to accommodate and help patients that have limited resources. In every single way we can, until we can no longer do anything about it, because it’s out of our control. Yes, I do believe that. (Financial coordinator)As far as the most rewarding part, I would have to say when I’m on call and I get to call patients in because we have an organ for them. (Pretransplant kidney coordinator)So again, not knowing exactly how we have our referral system, but I would like other members of the team, or other disciplinaries of our team to…. And I know it’s hard, because everybody’s overworked and maybe some are underpaid, or everyone… I don’t know. But to not just cite from a piece of paper, but actually take a deeper dive into the patients and understand where they’re coming from and then, hopefully become their better advocate and a little bit of sometimes, solutions, outside of the box with savings and distance, and all this stuff. (Transplant nephrologist)As long as people communicate with us, we communicate with them. We have great social workers. Our social workers are really good at problem solving. And they’ve definitely helped people. ‘Cause patients think, “I don’t wanna be a burden. I don’t wanna do this.” And it’s like, well, we have to help you form a way to ask for help. You have to ask for help at this point. If you don’t have anybody who’s hovering over you, trying to take care of things for you, then we have to help you find a way to ask for help. And I think that our social work team does a really good job of helping patients to problem solve. (Referral intake specialist)Promotion of patient literacy and capacityI think there is a direct correlation. Usually, folks that we get into contact with easily on the pre side, you can get in contact with easily on the post side for follow up appointments, labs, things like that. Generally, they continue to carry that on. (Kidney transplant coordinator)Our clinic ended up getting iPads to make interpreter services more available. We don’t—we try to not let people fail because they have low health literacy. (Pretransplant kidney coordinator)On the access to transplantation, there is definitely a lot of work that’s been put in place to help individual patients navigate what are the potential needs that they may have and see if they can overcome some of those needs. (Transplant nephrologist)And so, they did institute an education class that I think has been somewhat helpful in terms of just making sure that everyone sort of hears the same thing. Everyone’s kind of in the room together and there is opportunity for people to hear the full scope of discussion about transplant. (Transplant hepatologist)So, when we do have the uninsured patients, we advise them on how they can possibly purchase insurance through the marketplace. We also work with getting them set up with the hospital’s financial assistance program to help cover the balances that they may owe on their marketplace plan or even on their commercial insurance plan. (Senior financial coordinator)Community-based outreach and educationI think having access and outreach and visibility in communities that don’t typically have that. I think that’s part of it. I think knowing people who have gone through it and are doing well is huge. (Liver transplant coordinator)We’ve tried to make our service more accessible to the community by doing outreach and reaching out to those communities that have been underserved in the past. (Liver transplant social worker)We’re also doing a lot more outreach, in regards to targeting these areas where there may be patients that are not being referred like they should be, and hence meeting up with primary care physicians and gastroenterologists in the area and educating them about early diagnosis and early referral, is what we’ve been working on. (Transplant hepatologist)We have had multiple outreach locations where providers actually go into the community to see new evaluation patients and sometimes patients who are waiting sometimes post, like chronic post not acute post patients. And so that was designed and intended to be a presence in those communities to reduce the travel that patients need to do, to sort of strengthen our relationship with community providers because they feel like we’re making the effort to come to their community. So, I think that’s certainly one of the biggest ways that we have tried to bridge any sort of barrier that might be geographic. (Kidney transplant social worker)They were able to have some meetings with community members and patients could come and they would have a round table discussion where people could ask questions to the provider and to the coordinators and the social workers about process, which seemed to be helpful. (Clinical pharmacist) Representative Quotations of Identified Themes Barriers to Access Inadequate Caregiver Resources (Barrier 1) Inadequacy of patient caregiver resources was noted as a barrier to transplant. The influence put on the level of caregiving, competency of the caregivers, and degree of sophistication of the patient and their caregiver were all cited as contributors to inequitable access. Several clinicians reported magnification of these challenges for patients from racial and ethnic minoritized or socially deprived communities. The resource-intensive nature of the transplant process was implicated as creating an interplay between caregiver support and patients’ ultimate candidacy for transplant. Costs of Care and Financial Strain (Barrier 2) The affordability of transplant evaluation was cited as a common barrier to access, including costs such as gas and parking. Clinicians frequently noted the misalignment between patients’ financial resources and the demands of the evaluation process. Examples were provided of patients whose insurance would cover 100% of their transplant procedure-related care, but none of the associated lodging or travel costs. Similarly, patients insured through Medicaid were sometimes forced to seek care at a center farther from home due to different practices in Medicaid coverage acceptability. Affordability was viewed as a compounding factor to barriers such as inadequate caregiver resources (ie, barrier 1). Difficulty With Transplant Process Navigation (Barrier 3) Patient-level difficulty with transplant process navigation was perceived as a significant barrier to access, intersecting with education, language, and perceived cultural barriers or personal mistrust. Center-level contributors included the complexity of the process and varying levels of navigational support. One clinician described the importance of reciprocal communication as a proxy for posttransplant patient success; however, they simultaneously acknowledged that there are no “minimum set criteria for how much [the patients] are communicating with us.” Clinicians noted that patients sometimes struggled with not knowing fully what the transplant process entails or understanding the circumstances of their eligibility. Patient-level challenges to process navigation were therefore exacerbated by center-level variations in information delivery and education. Transplant Clinician Bias (Barrier 4) Clinicians noted the influence of personal bias as a barrier to equitable access. Most clinicians had clear perspectives on their ideal transplant candidate, which influenced their perceptions of good and bad candidates. Clinicians described “[making] judgment calls about [patients] based upon their social determinants of health” compounded by lack of time, high patient loads, and inadequate access to resources for social support. Clinicians generally believed themselves to be better equipped to aid patients with whom they could reliably communicate (barrier 3). Furthermore, the concept of patient adherence was often stated but inconsistently described. This typically related to alcohol use, medication adherence, dialysis records, and overall attitude and was a major consideration when evaluating the likelihood of patient posttransplant success. Workflow Inefficiencies and Variability (Barrier 5) Clinicians across all centers, particularly transplant coordinators, shared common frustrations with inefficiencies in their workflow, including the large volume of work in the setting of unbalanced patient caseloads and communication difficulties. The resultant inability to devote attention to patients struggling with process navigation related closely to clinician bias (ie, barrier 4) and evoked cognitive dissonance for coordinators. There was also acknowledgment of unique communication-related challenges for geographically isolated patient populations. Despite recognition of inequities in the evaluation process, clinicians believed they were unable to mitigate patient circumstances, given their overwhelming baseline burden of work. Social and Environmental Drivers of Transplant Access (Barrier 6) Demographic variables and social determinants of health, such as patient sex, race, ethnicity, rurality, and socioeconomic status, were cited as foundational patient-level factors compounding other barriers. Even with adequate insurance or caregiver support, a background with low socioeconomic status was often cited as prohibitive to patient approval for transplant. Logistical challenges were also frequently discussed regarding transportation availability, distance to the transplant center, and lodging arrangements. Social and environmental drivers consistently interacted with workflow inefficiency (barrier 5), patient navigation (barrier 3), and costs of care (barrier 2) to contribute to access inequities. Facilitators to Access Patient Engagement and Interaction (Facilitator 1) Transplant coordinators affirmed that telephone-based or face-to-face interactions with patients were critical to success, allowing them to counteract the challenges of workflow inefficiencies (barrier 5). Patients’ level of engagement with the process was also a noted facilitator given that “nobody is going to handhold them through [the process].” Coordinators noted greater synergy with patients who demonstrated agency, finding that they “come back with the list of things they need to get done and they do better the second time around.” Independence and autonomy were positively associated with process navigation and associated with better outcomes. Strong Patient Support Systems (Facilitator 2) In parallel to the barrier theme of inadequate caregiver resources (ie, barrier 1), clinicians identified strong patient support systems as a notable facilitator. Having the bandwidth to endure any complications through caregiver support was a stated aspect of a good transplant candidate. Clinicians proposed that augmenting existing support systems could involve giving some grace to patients whose caregivers could not be present at every appointment. One clinician suggested data-driven investigation of how center policies, such as a second caregiver, “actually impact transplant outcomes.” Clinicians recognized strong patient support systems as a vital source of patient advocacy whose presence could be facilitated by the center itself. Transplant Clinician Commitment to Patient Success (Facilitator 3) Individual clinician efforts to promote patient success were noted as a key facilitator to patient access. Clinicians described needing to think outside of the box or problem solve to get their patients to transplant. Social workers and coordinators were repeatedly acknowledged as critical in these roles, and coordinators described immense joy when notifying a patient about an organ acceptance. The personal reward of communicating this news was a clear positive influence in promoting coordinator advocacy. The degree of clinician commitment to their patients acted as a driving force in ultimate approval for the transplant waiting list, particularly for patients from racial and ethnic minoritized backgrounds. Promotion of Patient Literacy and Capacity (Facilitator 4) Clinicians described the positive impact of center-level measures to promote patient capacity to mitigate challenges with process navigation (barrier 3). There was recognition that center efforts to address financial, health, and linguistic literacy could significantly improve a patient’s chances of being approved for transplant. Examples of facilitating interventions offered by clinicians included technology-based tools to improve communication, enhance patients’ health and financial literacy, and increase awareness of the transplant evaluation process. These solutions acknowledge that center-led programs to amplify patient capacity can exponentially improve overall care access. Community-Based Outreach and Education (Facilitator 5) Community outreach to racial and ethnic minoritized patient communities was described as a requisite need to facilitate access to transplant. Clinicians noted that having multiple team members meet with historically marginalized communities and provide education and support was transformative in bridging geographic barriers. Improving outreach and accessibility efforts were proposed solutions to build stronger relationships between racial and ethnic minoritized communities and the transplant center. It was also suggested this benefit could be amplified when transplant recipients themselves become advocates for others in the community seeking transplant evaluation, facilitating a positive cycle of trust. Discussion Despite long-standing evidence of disparate transplant access for racial and ethnic minoritized and socially deprived patient groups, the existing literature primarily focuses on overcoming patient-level barriers.16,21,23,37 Barriers to health care access, however, must be understood intersectionally through individual, environmental, structural, and systemic determinants of health.6,38,39,40,41,42 Prior stakeholder-informed research has focused on living donor, liver, and cardiac transplant.43,44,45,46,47,48,49 Our multicenter study examined transplant clinician and staff perspectives regarding equitable access across abdominal organ transplants, revealing themes about how transplant center–level processes create barriers or facilitators for patients. Using PRISM as our conceptual framework34,35 allowed us to focus on implementation considerations and evaluable metrics for success (Table 3).50,51 Identification of facilitators highlighted opportunities for transplant centers to address unmet health-related social needs (HRSN) and increase patients’ exposure to facilitating environments. The multilevel nature of our study’s themes—encompassing patients, clinicians, and health care systems—supports designing interventions across multiple levels of influence within the transplant center ecosystem (Box).41,52,53 Table 3. Mapping of Barriers, Facilitators, Proposed Interventions, and Metrics of Success Using the PRISM FrameworkIntervention tierBarriers addressedFacilitators leveragedPRISM domainsProposed interventionProposed metrics of successPatient-facing (education, literacy, navigation)3 (Process navigation); 5 (workflow inefficiencies)4 (Patient literacy and capacity)Intervention (patient perspective), recipients (patient characteristics)Culturally congruent education materials; interpreter technology; financial-assistance navigation; technology-based process navigation tools; provision of devices and internet access support for digital inaccessibilityReach: proportion of eligible minoritized patients engaged relative to overall population and proportion of eligible patients receiving and/or using device or platform Effectiveness: evaluation completion rate and time from referral to evaluation, referral, and/or waitlisting disparity ratio Implementation: consistency of communication frequency and/or cadence Maintenance: continued use of tools at established time intervals.Patient-facing (support systems)1 (Caregiver resources); 2 (financial strain)2 (Strong patient support systems)Recipients (patient characteristics), external environmentMultidisciplinary care teams for longitudinal support to socially vulnerable patientsEffectiveness: change in completed evaluation steps; patient activation or self-reported health scoreMaintenance: sustained caseload coverage post pilotClinician-facing4 (Clinician bias); 5 (workflow inefficiencies)3 (Clinician commitment to patient success)Intervention (organizational perspective), recipients (staff characteristics)Workforce diversification; bias-focused education on community-informed care and HRSN; center-level incentives tied to national payment models; and objective clinical decision support tools to mitigate subjectivityAdoption: proportion of staff completing trainingEffectiveness: stratified posttransplant outcomes by race and other identities; before-and-after transplant bias-awareness measuresClinician–patient interaction3 (Process navigation); 5 (workflow inefficiencies)1 (Patient engagement and interaction)Intervention (patient plus organizational perspective), implementation and sustainability infrastructureTechnology-assisted communication platforms and provision of devices and internet access support for digital inaccessibilityReach: proportion of eligible patients receiving or using device or platform Implementation: consistency of communication frequency and/or cadenceMaintenance: continued use of tools at established time intervalsCenterwide and policy1 (Caregiver resources); 2 (financial strain); 6 (SDOH)5 (Community-based outreach)External environment, implementation and sustainability infrastructureInstitutional partnerships with community-based organizations; transplant houses; and catchment-area HRSN assessmentReach: proportion of catchment-area minoritized population engagedEffectiveness: center-level referral- and donation-rate disparity trendsMaintenance: sustained partnership beyond funding cycleCommunity-centered4 (Clinician bias); 6 (SDOH)5 (Community-based outreach)Recipients (community plus patient perspective), external environmentCABs; CBPR-based co-design of education and outreach interventions; community health worker programs; and hiring diverse research staff representative of minoritized populations being servedReach: representativeness of engaged community relative to catchment demographic characteristics; proportion of catchment-area minoritized population engagedAdoption: number of community partners and/or CAB members retained over timeEffectiveness: measures of before-and-after community knowledge or trust screening and/or education uptakeAbbreviations: CAB, community advisory board; CBPR, community-based participatory research; HRSN, health-related social needs; PRISM, Practical, Robust Implementation and Sustainability Model; SDOH, social determinants of health. Mapping of Barriers, Facilitators, Proposed Interventions, and Metrics of Success Using the PRISM Framework Abbreviations: CAB, community advisory board; CBPR, community-based participatory research; HRSN, health-related social needs; PRISM, Practical, Robust Implementation and Sustainability Model; SDOH, social determinants of health. Proposed Multilevel Strategies to Improve Equity in Transplant Access From Identified Facilitators in Stakeholder Interviews: Promotion of Patient Literacy and Capacity Enhanced technology and written materials to support interpreter services Enhanced technology and written materials to support interpreter services Comprehensive patient education classes on transplant process (“transplant schools”) Comprehensive patient education classes on transplant process (“transplant schools”) Financial assistance programs for payment coverage and insurance advice Financial assistance programs for payment coverage and insurance advice Transplant Clinician Commitment to Patient Success Increased workforce diversification Increased workforce diversification Diversity, equity, and inclusion and implicit bias training Diversity, equity, and inclusion and implicit bias training Investment in material, financial, and human resources to support patient-clinician relationship Investment in material, financial, and human resources to support patient-clinician relationship Community-Based Outreach and Education Transplant education programs directed toward religious centers, dialysis units, satellite clinics, community gathering spaces Transplant education programs directed toward religious centers, dialysis units, satellite clinics, community gathering spaces Social and local media advertising to circulate culturally congruent educational materials Social and local media advertising to circulate culturally congruent educational materials Longitudinal partnership programs between patients with end-stage organ disease and community organ donors and recipients Longitudinal partnership programs between patients with end-stage organ disease and community organ donors and recipients Recommendations at the Transplant Center Level: Use of Clinical and Social Determinants of Health Data to Quantify Patients’ Psychosocial Risk Develop decision-making support tools to standardize transplant evaluation and selection processes Develop decision-making support tools to standardize transplant evaluation and selection processes Undergo extensive policy review at the level of the transplant center to review potential exclusionary policies Undergo extensive policy review at the level of the transplant center to review potential exclusionary policies Allocation of funds toward culturally congruent and inclusive signage, education materials, interpreter services Allocation of funds toward culturally congruent and inclusive signage, education materials, interpreter services Develop posttransplant transitional and recovery facilities Develop posttransplant transitional and recovery facilities Cosponsorship of community-based organizations, support networks, and social services for patients with end-stage organ disease and transplant Cosponsorship of community-based organizations, support networks, and social services for patients with end-stage organ disease and transplant Use of community advisory boards and community-based participatory research to center and engage voices of key community partners Use of community advisory boards and community-based participatory research to center and engage voices of key community partners Patient-Facing Interventions Promotion of patient literacy was an identified facilitator in transplant access (ie, facilitator 4). Clinicians described how technology to support interpreter services, patient education classes, and financial assistance programs empowered patients to gain proficiency in driving various aspects of their care. Creative communication mechanisms can build on this success through advertising and circulation of culturally congruent, on-demand educational materials to mitigate shortages of language services. Such strategies have demonstrated success in tailored education programs such as the National Minority Organ-Tissue Transplant Education Program,54 Infórmate,55 and Your Path to Transplant.56 There is also particular benefit to capacity building for patients with conditions placing them at risk for subjective evaluations of psychosocial suitability.57 The emergence in this study of workflow inefficiencies as a barrier (ie, barrier 5) is a less well-documented but notable area for improvement—particularly given the role transplant coordinators play as advocates for patients.58 Although they are the frontline contacts for patients, coordinators lack the available time to appropriately address the range of issues encountered by their assigned patients. This is consistent with studies of clinical coordinators highlighting the impact of time hunger and resource limitations on patient care outcomes.23,58 Technology-based process navigation and formation of multidisciplinary teams (social workers, transplant coordinators, and financial coordinators) primarily tasked with longitudinal communication with socially vulnerable patients are potential lower-cost accessible solutions to these workflow challenges. Technology-enabled solutions have shown great promise in improving education and access in kidney transplant59,60; these tools can be centralized and disseminated by transplant centers to provide tailored navigation without increasing existing workloads on staff. Clinician-Facing and Clinician-Patient Interventions Clinician commitment to patient success (ie, facilitator 3) can also be leveraged in the development of center-level interventions. Clinicians described how workforce diversification and additional resource provision were all beneficial to addressing bias (ie, barrier 4). These efforts can be coupled with transplant center–level commitment to objective data collection, clinical decision support, and patient-level resources to minimize clinician and staff subjectivity, particularly pertaining to biased perceptions of ideal or nonideal candidacy.61 Clinicians’ intrinsic motivation can be encouraged through implementation of meaningful center-level incentives coupled with national policy efforts compensating centers caring for patients with greater HRSN, as recently proposed by the Increasing Organ Transplant Access Model.62 Centers can devote resources to clinician-based education programs about community-informed care practices that focus on the HRSN of the at-risk communities serviced by the transplant center.63 These education programs can also leverage the benefits of community-based outreach (ie, facilitator 5) to facilitate partnerships that incentivize clinicians to become leaders in community-oriented programs. Patient-clinician interaction (ie, facilitator 1) was perceived as essential to transplant access. Coordinators reported that interactions were most fruitful in person, but even a telephone or a video call was more helpful than an electronic-based message. Rather than relying solely on patient messaging portals, transplant centers can invest in robust technology-assisted platforms that keep communication interactive and accessible. PHONE-CONNECT, a hospital-based initiative in Canada, demonstrated success in promoting postdischarge communication through providing smartphones to marginalized and vulnerable patients in the emergency department during the COVID-19 pandemic.64,65 Transplant centers could create similar programs that provide technological access support to patients experiencing digital inaccessibility, enabling them to amplify their capacity and engagement (facilitator 4). Centerwide Interventions and Policies The transplant center represents a hub that can formalize disparate interventions into a cohesive, sustainable operation committed to equity in transplant access. Centerwide initiatives such as culturally tailored programs and navigation assistance have been shown to demystify the transplant process, increase familiarity and trust in the process, and offer a business case for the center through increased transplant referrals and revenue.22,66,67,68 Existing programs, including the Northwestern Medicine African American Transplant Access Program69 and Hispanic Kidney Transplant Program66 are notable examples of such centerwide interventions. Transplant houses, as a further example, can facilitate communal support and accommodations for patients traveling for their care.70 Employment of clinicians and staff who represent populations within center catchment areas can also aid in design and execution of culturally congruent interventions to increase transplant access, engender patient trust, and ensure sustainability.71 Community-Centered Interventions Studies have demonstrated that institutional collaboration with community-based organizations leads to improved patient outcomes and reduced health care spending, particularly in areas of social work coordination, workforce staffing, and cross-sector sponsorship of patient-centered engagement projects.72,73 These efforts can be aided with detailed assessment of the transplant center’s catchment area, the referral population’s HRSN, and community asset mapping. Transplant center engagement can fortify center-community relationships in spaces such as religious centers, dialysis units, and community centers. The center can amplify community-based outreach efforts (facilitator 5) through incorporation of community-based participatory research approaches that position community members as key partners in the intervention design process. Community-based participatory research has been shown to promote equal partnership with community members in codevelopment of institution-led interventions and has exhibited success in both centering community voices and reducing disparities in chronic disease.74,75 Community advisory boards (CABs) and community health workers are vital to operationalizing this type of center-community partnership. CABs have been used to inform research goals related to structural racism in chronic kidney disease and the Johns Hopkins Faith-Based Alliance for Kidney Health and Transplant Equity effectively utilized CABs to guide development of religiously congruent educational materials for living donor kidney transplant.76,77 Limitations We acknowledge the following limitations of this study. We included perspectives from 3 transplant centers, which limits generalizability. We did not interview patients, as our focus was on organizational characteristics and team members with agency to influence transplant center–level interventions, and we acknowledge that these perspectives were not represented in our analysis. Our goal in performing a qualitative study was to generate hypotheses for future areas of exploration and report findings for future testing even if they are not currently in practice. Although an iterative approach was used in our thematic analysis, certain perspectives may have been given insufficient attention, or the influence of other emergent themes underestimated. Finally, our study did not distinguish among organ, clinical indication, or transplant phase, given the challenges of discerning this information through stakeholder interviews alone. This merits further analysis of phase- and organ-specific influences on transplant access, which will be elucidated through future focus group analyses. Conclusions In this multicenter qualitative study, we identified an opportunity to integrate multilevel factors impacting transplant access and design center-driven interventions to improve patient access without negating the policy, regulatory, and pragmatic constraints of modern transplant practice. Leveraging data to understand dominant characteristics within catchment areas, develop decision support tools, and standardize the evaluation and selection processes are feasible solutions to improve transplant access and reduce barriers.49 Review and revision of historically exclusionary policies, flexible evaluation options, and enhanced education can help patients build agency early in the process. Although multilevel interventions in transplant remain in nascent stages, longitudinal support is known to improve the likelihood of transplant and reduce inequities in marginalized populations.41,78 These changes will necessitate a paradigm shift and costly redesign of transplant center operations—but the implications for patient equity are immeasurable.