Reply to Trinkle: The elastic field of an edge dislocation Authors: John P. Hirth, Jian Wang Published: 2026 The comments in ref. 1 do not apply to refs. 2 and 3 as we now show. The physical basis and analysis for the combined Volterra defect are the same in refs. 2 and 3, as demonstrated in ref. 4.The factor of 1/4 arises because the field in our equations 5 and 6 is nonlinearly partitioned into quadrants as explained in ref. 2 that analyzes the field from one quadrant. That is why equations 1–3 in ref. 1 are inapplicable. The correct stresses are those in equations 11–13, which do agree with the equilibrium equations.Equation 1 in ref. 2 is a Green’s function. A distribution of Green’s functions is equivalent to a displacement distribution and any set of displacements is given in either description. Equation 1 deals only with the asymmetrical ln y term, relevant for the Volterra field and the line force. Thus figure 3B in ref. 2 shows the displacements, or equivalently the Green’s function differential line forces dr, at a given r. The integral over θ and φ is a net force independent of r. This is exactly what we show is predicted by the M integral (5) and agrees with the shell theorem, dating back to Newton. We never argue that different halves of the field behave as opposite sign dislocations, contrary to ref. 1.There is no basis for equations 4 and 5 in ref. 1. Equations 17–19 in ref. 2 satisfy the equilibrium equations, but his (4, 5) do not, as he shows. More generally the LE limit does not apply, and his procedure applies linear-elastic (LE) analysis to a nonlinear result. Only equations 11–19 satisfy equilibrium in the SM case. For a general position, the nonlinear displacement u(x, y) is as given in ref. 2 for the Standard Model (SM). The LE value is given at a fixed y and displaced by δx. Thus, in ref. 1, the stress for (x, y) is treated as the stress at x+δx,y. Obviously this gives an incorrect result since the stress at a given r differs in the two cases.The full form of the ln displacement term is ln r, so on the original glide plane there is a term in uy∝ln x. This states that uy there diverges with x. This is nonphysical (6), never observed., and in disagreement with symmetry.Experimental HRTEM observations also support the SM. Also, in a remarkable analysis of the strain field for a silicon crystal containing a single dislocation (7), exact agreement with the SM model in ref. 2 and 3 was found. There the outer boundary R is of the order of mm, and the ln r term would be enormous, contrary to ref. 1, where the divergence is dismissed. as unimportant. The factor of 1/4 arises because the field in our equations 5 and 6 is nonlinearly partitioned into quadrants as explained in ref. 2 that analyzes the field from one quadrant. That is why equations 1–3 in ref. 1 are inapplicable. The correct stresses are those in equations 11–13, which do agree with the equilibrium equations. The factor of 1/4 arises because the field in our equations 5 and 6 is nonlinearly partitioned into quadrants as explained in ref. 2 that analyzes the field from one quadrant. That is why equations 1–3 in ref. 1 are inapplicable. The correct stresses are those in equations 11–13, which do agree with the equilibrium equations. Equation 1 in ref. 2 is a Green’s function. A distribution of Green’s functions is equivalent to a displacement distribution and any set of displacements is given in either description. Equation 1 deals only with the asymmetrical ln y term, relevant for the Volterra field and the line force. Thus figure 3B in ref. 2 shows the displacements, or equivalently the Green’s function differential line forces dr, at a given r. The integral over θ and φ is a net force independent of r. This is exactly what we show is predicted by the M integral (5) and agrees with the shell theorem, dating back to Newton. We never argue that different halves of the field behave as opposite sign dislocations, contrary to ref. 1. Equation 1 in ref. 2 is a Green’s function. A distribution of Green’s functions is equivalent to a displacement distribution and any set of displacements is given in either description. Equation 1 deals only with the asymmetrical ln y term, relevant for the Volterra field and the line force. Thus figure 3B in ref. 2 shows the displacements, or equivalently the Green’s function differential line forces dr, at a given r. The integral over θ and φ is a net force independent of r. This is exactly what we show is predicted by the M integral (5) and agrees with the shell theorem, dating back to Newton. We never argue that different halves of the field behave as opposite sign dislocations, contrary to ref. 1. There is no basis for equations 4 and 5 in ref. 1. Equations 17–19 in ref. 2 satisfy the equilibrium equations, but his (4, 5) do not, as he shows. More generally the LE limit does not apply, and his procedure applies linear-elastic (LE) analysis to a nonlinear result. Only equations 11–19 satisfy equilibrium in the SM case. For a general position, the nonlinear displacement u(x, y) is as given in ref. 2 for the Standard Model (SM). The LE value is given at a fixed y and displaced by δx. Thus, in ref. 1, the stress for (x, y) is treated as the stress at x+δx,y. Obviously this gives an incorrect result since the stress at a given r differs in the two cases. There is no basis for equations 4 and 5 in ref. 1. Equations 17–19 in ref. 2 satisfy the equilibrium equations, but his (4, 5) do not, as he shows. More generally the LE limit does not apply, and his procedure applies linear-elastic (LE) analysis to a nonlinear result. Only equations 11–19 satisfy equilibrium in the SM case. For a general position, the nonlinear displacement u(x, y) is as given in ref. 2 for the Standard Model (SM). The LE value is given at a fixed y and displaced by δx. Thus, in ref. 1, the stress for (x, y) is treated as the stress at x+δx,y. Obviously this gives an incorrect result since the stress at a given r differs in the two cases. The full form of the ln displacement term is ln r, so on the original glide plane there is a term in uy∝ln x. This states that uy there diverges with x. This is nonphysical (6), never observed., and in disagreement with symmetry. The full form of the ln displacement term is ln r, so on the original glide plane there is a term in uy∝ln x. This states that uy there diverges with x. This is nonphysical (6), never observed., and in disagreement with symmetry. Experimental HRTEM observations also support the SM. Also, in a remarkable analysis of the strain field for a silicon crystal containing a single dislocation (7), exact agreement with the SM model in ref. 2 and 3 was found. There the outer boundary R is of the order of mm, and the ln r term would be enormous, contrary to ref. 1, where the divergence is dismissed. as unimportant. Experimental HRTEM observations also support the SM. Also, in a remarkable analysis of the strain field for a silicon crystal containing a single dislocation (7), exact agreement with the SM model in ref. 2 and 3 was found. There the outer boundary R is of the order of mm, and the ln r term would be enormous, contrary to ref. 1, where the divergence is dismissed. as unimportant. Contrary to his final remarks, the qualitative picture is that the Volterra defect includes a ln r term as does a line force. Thus, with the correct prefactors in the equations selected, the difference between the two has no ln r term.