The Missing, the Unidentified, and Representational Obligations to the Dead in the United States of America Authors: Nicole R. Jackson, Laura J. Tafe Published: 2026 ABSTRACT ABSTRACTThousands of human remains lie unidentified in Medical Examiners' and Coroners' Offices across the United States of America. Determining identity is the first step in bringing closure to grieving families and communities and, in certain cases, moving towards justice. While many distance themselves from death, forensic specialists, including forensic photographers and artists, dive in, focusing intently on every detail to recapitulate the deceased's story. Forensic sketches serve a dual purpose—identification and remembrance. They have been used for over a century to help identify deceased bodies and connect them to their remaining loved ones. Common external characteristics are combined with accentuated distinguishing features to bring the body back to life in a recognizable form. Preserving human dignity, acting with respect and non‐maleficence, and contributing to justice are central in these postmortem proceedings. This comprehensive review explores the gravity of the silent mass disaster of unidentified human remains in the United States of America, the disparities that exist between the missing and the recovered and identified, and sheds light on the early introduction of artificial intelligence into the field of forensic identification. The dead cannot cry out for justice. It is a duty of the living to do so for them.Lois McMaster Bujold [1] The dead cannot cry out for justice. It is a duty of the living to do so for them. Introduction Modern technological advances are being adopted into forensic evaluations. Some examples include the use of 3D printing to reconstruct the skulls of unidentified individuals for use by forensic artists in their rendering of facial features [2], the integration of augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR) to create detailed, immersive recreations of crime scenes and, ultimately, support the forensic pathologist during autopsy examinations [2, 3, 4]. As artificial intelligence (AI) finds its footing within healthcare and forensics, it is being used to varying degrees to generate or enhance forensic sketches, and its implementation must be done with caution. Forensic professionals are given a snapshot of an individual's life at the time of examination. Death investigation often starts where the body or remains are found, and forensic photographers are among the first present to document the visual story of the death [3, 5]. Through photographic documentation of the scene and autopsy examination, clues are gathered that provide further insight into how that person lived. Documented at autopsy are identifying marks on the body such as tattoos, scars, limb amputations, deformities, moles and birthmarks, and body piercings and jewelry. Additionally, an inventory is taken at the time of intake and examination of clothing and accessories. When identity is unknown, forensic sketches can be created as part of the arsenal of postmortem identification methods, which include visual identification by next of kin and scientific methods such as fingerprint and DNA analysis [6, 7]. Through the review of these items, the forensic artist attempts to revive the dead, creating life‐like drawings of potentially disfigured or decomposed bodies so that they are non‐traumatizing and recognizable by family and loved ones, aiding in identification. Phenotypically male bodies are overrepresented in medicolegal death investigation cases, as men are most often both the perpetrators and targets of physical violence and are more likely to have traumatic deaths [8, 9]. The overwhelming presence of these bodies within Medical Examiners' and Coroners' Offices can mask a concerning but barely visible trend—some female‐identified and gender nonconforming individuals are often overrepresented as targets of this violence, resulting in their silent disappearances and deaths. These crises have rarely been studied in the forensic literature and, when they are, it is typically in isolation rather than together as a shared experience of societal neglect. Herein, the missing, murdered, and unidentified in the United States of America (USA) are examined, with attention given to special minority populations, and the obligations forensic specialists have to preserving their image and spirit are investigated. The Missing and Unidentified Termed the “silent mass disaster” [10, 11], despite being a known, longstanding problem, granular data on unidentified deceased bodies in the USA and internationally is overall lacking [6]. Every year, over half a million people go missing in the USA [12]. While a majority are found alive, many are not. In one study by Paulozzi and colleagues, on average, there were over 400 unidentified deceased people annually in the USA between 1979 and 2004 [13]. Currently, at over 15,000 individuals, more are housed as unidentified remains than there are total full‐time equivalent employees within Medical Examiners' and Coroners' Offices (n = 10,930), with DNA evidence collected for identification purposes for less than half of these individuals [14, 15]. The Federal Bureau of Investigation's National Crime Information Center (NCIC)'s Missing Person and Unidentified Person Files [16] and the National Institute of Justice's National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs) [17] are the two leading national databases used to help identify people. The NCIC is managed by professionals (e.g., law enforcement) and focuses on more acute events, while both professionals (e.g., law enforcement, medicolegal death workers, forensic specialists) and the public (e.g., families, volunteers) can enter information into NamUs, which centers on cold cases. Given the different sources of data input and varying factors influencing the missing and the unidentified, there are discrepancies between these important databases. Special attention is warranted for two populations whose overrepresentation in the missing can be traced back to the colonization of the Americas—those of Indigenous and African descent. With shared histories of generational trauma and compromised social determinants of health, it is unsurprising that those whose land was violently stolen to build America and who were violently stolen from their land to build America are overrepresented in these numbers (Table 1) [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26]. TABLE 1Indigenous and Black communities' parallel experiences in the United States of America contributing to missing and murdered statistics as compared to the White community.American Indian or Alaska NativeBlack or African AmericanWhiteOrigin of traumaColonizationChattel slaveryNot applicableMajor displacement eventsForced federal removals and relocationsRedlining, gentrification, urban renewal projectsNot applicablePercent of the US population [18]2.1%13.5%72.3%Women's personal experience of violence in lifetime [19]84.3%Not specified49.7%Law enforcement issuesUnder‐enforcement from jurisdictional complexity, over‐policing, physical brutalityOver‐policing, physical brutalityPhysical brutalityIncarceration rates [20]1045 per 100,0001218 per 100,000231 per 100,000Ratio of poverty population to total population [21]1.91.60.7Percent of females with intimate partner violence history [22]46%43.7%34.6%Percent of total human trafficking [23]Not specified31.69%20.11%Percent of sex trafficking victims [23]Not specified40%22.17%Percent of labor trafficking victims [23]Not specified9.52%1.59%Rates as murder victims [24]250 (1.3), 4.2 per 100,00011,060 (55.8), 21.3 per 100,0008070 (40.8), 3.2 per 100,000Percent of victims of ancestry‐based hate crimes [25]2.70%48.50%15.70%Life expectancy [26]70.1 years74 years78.4 years Indigenous and Black communities' parallel experiences in the United States of America contributing to missing and murdered statistics as compared to the White community. Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls Originating with the colonization of the Americas, Indigenous women have been targets of violent objectification and sexualization, including being taken from their communities and forced into the transatlantic sex slave trade [27, 28]. Missing and Murdered Indigenous Persons (MMIP) is a term encompassing the public health crisis of those identified as American Indian/Alaska Native (AIAN) who disproportionately become missing persons and/or homicide victims. While historically this discussion has focused on women and girls (MMIWG), it has grown to encompass all, including those identified as male or Two‐Spirit [29, 30]. The extent of the MMIP across the USA is a crisis affecting all locations where Indigenous populations reside, including reservations, rural, suburban, and urban areas, and it has sustained negative effects on survivors [27, 30, 31, 32, 33]. Like the silent disaster of unidentified bodies in the USA, this is a silent crisis, with many outside of Indigenous communities unaware of its presence [34]. Only representing 2.1% of the USA population [26], those identified as Indigenous die from homicidal means at a rate approaching 10 times the national average, depending on location [27]. Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) National Violent Death Reporting System reveals that between 2003 and 2020, there were 2959 reported homicides of those identified as AIAN in the USA, with a majority occurring in “urban” locations (54.2%), with victims commonly between the ages of 18 and 44 years [30]. While this crisis is widespread across the country, there are marked geographic differences. The states with the highest cases of missing Indigenous women are Oklahoma, Alaska, New Mexico, California, and Arizona [27, 33], while the cities with the highest number of cases are Seattle, Washington (n = 45), Albuquerque, New Mexico (n = 37), Anchorage, Alaska (n = 31), Tucson, Arizona (n = 31), and Billings, Montana (n = 29) [33]. Interestingly, there is an association between MMIWG and fracking and drilling sites, attributed to changes in local demographics, including a high concentration of largely non‐Indigenous men working these jobs [27]. Many complicating factors have been identified related to MMIP. Data quality and completeness are issues due to several factors. Those of Indigenous descent are commonly racially misclassified, leading to underestimation of their contribution to the category of homicide victims in this country [35, 36, 37]. Due to the relatively small population size of American Indians and Alaska Natives, statistics for this group have historically been aggregated and placed in the “other” race category, preventing discrete analysis relevant to these communities [26, 38]. Regarding data, local law enforcement underutilizes NamUs, resulting in a falsely low number of cases compared to the NCIC missing persons database, which reports several thousand additional active cases [27]. Missing and Murdered African American Women and Girls Similar to MMIP, missing and murdered Black women in the USA have been described as a public health crisis with staggering statistics only recently garnering attention and resources [39]. Black women consistently have the highest homicide rates among women in the USA, worsened in many states since the turn of the century, and not uncommonly the victims are unmarried young adults [40]. In recent years, nearly 100,000 Black women and girls go missing in the USA annually, representing greater than one‐third of reported cases—over double their representation (13.5%) [26, 41, 42]. Research led by Rijt explored the influence of race and gender on the likelihood of a missing child being recovered using high‐quality data from the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services from 2007 to 2010 [43]. In analyzing 31,232 children, they found that while there was no significant difference in the chance of recovery based on gender, Black children both go missing longer and are less likely to be recovered than their peers of other races. Additional data is provided by recently formed local and regional groups and focused studies. In 2021, Minnesota became the first state to create a task force to investigate its Missing and Murdered African American Women (MMAAW) crisis [44]. In their 2022 report to the state legislature, they emphasize the erasure of the Black community from discussions on missing and murdered people in the USA and the disproportionate violence this subset of the population experiences, with Black female Minnesotans accounting for 7% of the state population but 40% of domestic violence victims and being three times more likely to be murdered as compared to White women who account for approximately 40% of the state's population. In the same year as Minnesota's inaugural task force report, Chicago, Illinois, a city that is nearly 30% Black, nearly 30% Hispanic, and nearly 30% White, created a similar task force, but focused on all women [45]. In their 2024 report, they similarly highlighted the disproportionate violence experienced by their Black female residents, who represent 15.4% of Chicagoans. Significant and relevant findings from their report include a recent increase in Black females as criminal sexual assault victims from 47.5% to 52.0% of all victims and their overrepresentation in missing person cases (26.7%) and as female homicide victims in 2023 (72.1%). The reasons underlying these disparities are complex and related to a national history of systemic racism and sexism, with their extension into education, financial stability, security, and safety [41, 46, 47]. Black youth are often overrepresented in foster care, owing to over‐policing of their communities and harsher sentences for their caregivers. As a community, they commonly have less access to quality resources and are more hesitant to utilize law enforcement as a resource when in need due to a history of harassment, assault, and death [48, 49]. Tragically, fatal intimate partner violence, worse in the perinatal period [50], is on par with other racial groups as a common cause of death for this group [40]. The Missing White Woman Syndrome Within forensic pathology, “vulnerable populations” is a term used to describe groups that are at increased risk of exposure to neglect, trauma, or other violence due to an intrinsic characteristic or identity, thereby resulting in their death. Commonly discussed within the context of pregnant individuals, those with disabilities, and the extremities of age, this label extends to the missing and unidentified. Within the criminal justice and human rights systems, this term applies to groups whose experiences of harm are less likely to be taken seriously or to result in appropriate repercussions [51]. Disparities exist between groups who receive public attention when missing: White women in the USA are consistently reported and publicly broadcast as missing at higher rates and with more rapidity, including deployment of resources, and are identified sooner than other groups [52, 53]. Contrary to what is shown in the news media, nationally, Indigenous and Black girls and women are overrepresented in trafficking, violence, and neglect, with their subsequent absences from society and deaths less likely to be reported, publicized, and thoroughly investigated, and their remains less likely to be identified (Table 1) [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 54, 55, 56, 57]. This disparity is not limited to interracial dynamics, as, even within the Black community, Black women's deaths are less likely to receive media attention as compared to those of Black men [48]. Humanizing the Dead and Contributing to Justice Dignity, from the Latin root “dignitas”, evokes connotations of basic value or worth and consequent respectful treatment accorded to a group. This moralized concept of dignity, as it applies to humans, referred to as “fundamental inherent human dignity” (FIHD), is foundational to human rights, as is being recognized and identified as human [58]. FIHD does not die at death, but is preserved through the actions of others—the living. The chain of events initiated by a person's death depends on the location of and circumstances around that death. Guiding all postmortem proceedings, including medicolegal death investigation, are three major questions asked with every death: Who died, how, and why did they die? Commonly, all three questions are readily answered. However, in a small fraction of cases, one‐to‐all is unknown or undetermined. With a keen eye and attention to detail, these artists can accomplish a great deal with such limited information. The pressure lies in making unique features stand out and appropriately compensating for injuries and postmortem decomposition changes so that just one person can recognize the constructed image. Artists deftly draw attention to what is present rather than absent, generating leads to answers and providing closure to those left wondering in the unknown [59]. It is very easy and common for the media, society, and even clinicians to reduce the deceased to their cause of death. Those last minutes of life can overshadow years of memories. Not only are the deceased forgotten, but often, so are those left living with the loss and picking up the pieces of their lives [60]. Confident ascertainment of identity is necessary to inform the remaining family so that planning for final arrangements can begin and to complete the death certificate, which allows for the transfer of assets. Additionally, identification aids in criminal proceedings. Until the time of identification, family members are left in the unknown, where fear, anxiety, and ambiguous grief reside and fester, which can insidiously or overtly erode their quality of life. Recurrent questions of whether their loved one is safe or in danger, alive or dead, can plague the mind [60]. The practice of forensic specialists often intersects with that of the criminal justice system—two systems tasked with treating people fairly and equally. Justice for victims, which includes their families and communities, can only be served once their identities are known. As the courts are obligated to ensure procedural equality across the spectrum of the accused, so are forensic professionals entrusted with appropriately representing deaths and lives across the spectrum of the deceased. The artist's focus on skin color, hair texture, clothing choice, and body is done to discriminate the unique from the common, not for prejudice or bias. Central to their mission is preserving the humanity and dignity of the deceased, regardless of identity or social status. One beauty in working with death is the privilege of seeing people in their most vulnerable state, directly facing the ultimate inability to act or speak for oneself, and using that as fuel to surmount vicarious trauma and continue, case after case, in an effort to bring justice to the community and closure for the bereaved. Use of Technology and Artificial Intelligence From its inception, AI has been fraught with ethical dilemmas and challenges, prompting the formation of its own emerging, interdisciplinary field—AI ethics [61]. Created with binary algorithms, machine learning and AI‐generated images are lagging behind in many communities. AI involvement in the creation of human images tends toward homogenization—the opposite of what is sought in traditional forensic sketches. Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Minorities When discussing mortality, all statistics are derived from the death certificate—a document that tracks important information for vital statistics, including the decedent's name, age, race, ethnicity, and pregnancy status, in addition to the cause and manner of death. Absent from this document is a catchment system for sexual orientation and gender identity (SOGI) status [62]. While it is well documented that SOGI minorities are a vulnerable population more likely to be subject to harassment, intimidation, and violence, exact data is lacking on the causes of death of members of this community [63, 64, 65]. Unique are those identifying as transgender and gender non‐conforming. Even ascribing “John” or “Jane Doe” to unidentified remains can have deleterious consequences. Inherent in this labeling is a forced binary, leading to postmortem erasure of their identity. In situations where family and law enforcement might use a “dead name” to aid in identification, forensic artists counterbalance efforts by depicting the individual through the eyes of their community. Solving, Not Exacerbating, the Problem For SOGI minorities, particularly nonbinary and transgender individuals, and communities of color, AI use would potentially exacerbate the postmortem identification gap, thus creating harm [66, 67]. In recognition of the threat of homogenization of individuals by AI, guidelines are emerging that address concerns of minority populations. One example is the Indigenous Protocol and Artificial Intelligence Position Paper, developed by Indigenous communities in North America, New Zealand, Australia, and the Pacific, that addresses concerns over data sovereignty and the protection of their cultures [68]. While identity currently remains a challenge for AI algorithms, these tools are skilled at analyzing large datasets and recognizing subtle patterns; in other words, they are skilled in observation and therefore have the potential to become a powerful assistive technology for forensic scientists. In one pilot study using publicly available AI tools (ChatGPT‐4, Claude, and Gemini), investigators evaluated the ability of these tools to analyze 30 images of crime scenes and rated their performance against 10 forensic experts. Not surprisingly, the AI tools performed well with some tasks (accuracy of observation, comprehensiveness, and time to analysis), but several limitations were also obvious (missed contextual clues of critical evidence, often crime scene‐dependent context, misidentification of objects, and unfounded conclusions) and study participants especially noted the risk of confirmation bias if relying too heavily on AI analysis prior to their own assessment of a scene [69]. The adoption of AI carries potential risks and benefits, and the implementation of such tools requires thoughtful design and rigorous validation prior to implementation so as to avoid harm. Starting from existing principles and guidelines for AI ethics and adoption, Stacey and colleagues propose a responsible AI framework (RAIF) for forensic science organizations [70]. The proposed RAIF is based on the following principles: explainability, trust, safety, fairness, ethical integrity, and responsibility. The framework is comprised of a three‐part protocol to guide the development, piloting, iterative revision, implementation, and retrospective analysis of AI tools and protocols into forensic work. The RAIF principles allow for each project to be considered in the context of ethical implications and cultural perspectives. However, it is important to reemphasize that these AI tools will only be successful because of human input into their design, validation, application, and interpretation, thereby supporting and complementing, but not replacing, the work of forensic scientists. Importantly, regardless of identity, AI cannot accurately address the emotional side of humanity [71]. Ethical considerations, as well as the human eye and touch, remain vital to evaluating crime scenes, constructing forensic sketches, and delivering justice. Ethics Statement The authors have nothing to report. Consent The authors have nothing to report. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare no conflicts of interest.