Monte Carlo modeling of the formation and organization of ion channel clustering Authors: Nicolae Moise, Seth H. Weinberg Published: 2026 ABSTRACT The spatial organization of ion channels on cell membranes critically influences many key physiological processes, such as cardiac and neuronal excitability and cellular signaling, yet the mechanisms governing channel clustering remain poorly understood. In this study, we present a stochastic computational framework that models the dynamic organization of ion channels through Monte Carlo simulations incorporating membrane insertion, removal, channel-channel interactions, and diffusion processes. Our model reveals several fundamental principles of membrane domain formation. In single-channel systems, we demonstrate a biphasic relationship between interaction energy and cluster size, with optimal clustering occurring at intermediate interaction strengths, suggesting that excessively strong interactions can impede cluster growth by restricting channel mobility. In two-channel systems, we find that the interplay between homotypic and heterotypic interactions determines whether channels form mixed or segregated clusters, with asymmetric clustering behaviors emerging when homotypic interaction strengths differ between channel types. Simulations of three-channel systems demonstrate emergent organizational principles leading to hierarchical clustering patterns and specialized domain formation. These findings generate testable predictions about how channel density, trafficking dynamics, and interaction energies collectively alter ion channel spatial organization, in the setting of both physiological function and pathophysiological conditions. Introduction Ion channels are critical regulators of cellular signaling, in excitable cells, such as neurons and cardiac myocytes, and non-excitable cells, including immune cells, fibroblasts, cancer cells, pancreatic β-cells, pituitary cells, vascular and pulmonary endothelial cells, amongst nearly all other cell types [1–7]. As such, ion channels are ubiquitous drivers of physiological processes and the spatial organization of ion channels on cellular membranes plays a critical role in many key physiological processes such as electrical excitation, synaptic transmission, muscle contraction, proliferation, cytokine and hormone secretion, etc. A single ion channel type rarely if ever functions in isolation. Rather, multiple ion channel and transporter/exchanger proteins work in concert to perform a specific physiological function, highlighting the necessity for channel co-regulation and coordination. Ion channels typically form clusters of varying density, and indeed emerging research, including our own, highlights that clusters of multiple different channel types co-localize at distinct locations within cells, often specialized ultrastructural niches [8–22]. These clusters can include single channel types (homotypic clusters) or multiple channel types (heterotypic clusters), with emerging evidence suggesting that the precise organization of these clusters significantly influences cellular physiology under both normal and pathological conditions [23–26]. Despite the importance of ion channel clustering, the fundamental mechanisms that govern their formation, maintenance, and regulation remain poorly understood. While experimental approaches using super-resolution microscopy have revealed increasingly detailed snapshots of channel organization [21,27], these techniques are limited in their ability to capture the dynamic processes that lead to cluster formation. Additionally, the multitude of potential interactions, including channel-channel, channel-lipid, and channel-cytoskeleton interactions, creates a complex system that is difficult to dissect experimentally. The formation and maintenance of these multi-channel clusters is complex, involving co-regulated protein trafficking, recycling, scaffolding, diffusion, and protein binding. While many models of ion channel function (e.g., gating kinetics) exist [28–30], there are very few to consider channel clustering structure. Computational modeling offers a powerful complementary approach to understand the principles governing ion channel organization. Prior models of membrane-protein organization have focused on cytoskeletal regulation of clustering based on principles of thermodynamical and/or mechanical equilibrium [31,32], for example, illustrating how active actin dynamics regulate clustering of lipid-anchored proteins at the membrane [33]. These studies thus consider an “intracellular-centric” perspective on protein clustering regulation. In contrast, “membrane-centric” modeling studies have often focused on membrane lipid-protein interactions, for example, all-atom Molecular Dynamics simulations demonstrating the role of lipid structure in supporting protein clustering [34]. Yet, these simulations are limited in the spatial and temporal scope due to computational constraints. By simplifying these membrane-protein and protein-protein interactions to thermodynamical energy constraints and intracellular regulation to probabilistic protein trafficking, our proposed model can simulate a wide range of conditions and scales in both space and time. To address these gaps, in this study, we develop a novel stochastic computational framework that simulates the dynamic organization of ion channels on the cell membrane. The Monte Carlo approach incorporates four key processes that influence channel spatial organization: membrane removal, membrane insertion, channel-channel interactions, and diffusion. Critically, our model allows for the systematic investigation of how channel clustering is influenced by factors such as channel density, trafficking rates, and interaction energies between similar or different channel types. We previously illustrated the clustering model framework as a single proof-of-concept to predict altered multi-channel spatial organization in the setting of a loss of expression channel mutation [23]. In this study, we perform a systematic study of the clustering model to explore how the balance between trafficking dynamics and interaction energies shapes cluster formation for channel types, revealing non-intuitive relationships between these parameters and clustering outcomes. We extend the model to investigate systems with multiple channel types, illuminating how competition between homotypic and heterotypic interactions leads to complex spatial patterning. Finally, we characterize emergent properties in three-channel systems that demonstrate how selective affinities between different channel types could organize the membrane into functionally specialized domains. By providing a quantitative framework for understanding ion channel organization, our model generates testable predictions about how alterations in channel properties or cellular conditions might affect membrane organization and, consequently, cellular function. These insights have potential implications for understanding channelopathies and other disorders in which disrupted channel organization contributes to disease pathophysiology. Materials and methods Model formulation In the channel clustering model, individual ion channels are represented by pixels on a 2D grid lattice, with dimensions Nx x Ny and pixel size Δx x Δx (where we have assumed equal grid spacing). In this study, we define Nx=Ny=100 and Δx=10nm, based on realistic ion channel size [25], such that we simulate a membrane patch of 1 μm x 1 μm. For all conditions investigated, channel dynamics are described by four stochastic processes: channel insertion, channel removal, channel-channel interactions, and channel diffusion. Simulations are performed by a Monte Carlo method, described as follows: Channel seeding and iteration First, for channel type i, for i=1,2,...,Nchan, where Nchan is the number of channel types in the membrane, channels are randomly seeded on the membrane lattice, with probability pseed,i. Then, Ntime iterations are performed that evolve channel location and insertion to/removal from the membrane: For each iteration n, for n=1,2,...,Ntime, a random pixel (x,y) is selected. Channel insertion and removal. If the pixel is ‘unoccupied,’ i.e., there is no channel present, then channel type i is inserted into the membrane with probability pinsert,i. If the selected pixel is ‘occupied,’ i.e., there is a channel present, then the channel is removed from the membrane with probability premove,i. For the case of individual channel insertion/removal, we can define the relationship between the expected number of type i channels on the (n + 1)th iteration Ni(n+1) and the number of free membrane pixels Nmem(n) and type i channels on the nth iteration Ni(n): Accounting for (i) the number of free membrane pixels Nmem(n)=NxNy−∑i=1NchanNi(n), (ii) at steady-state Ni*≈Ni(n)≈Ni(n+1), and (iii) defining the steady-state membrane fraction of channel type i as fchan,i=Ni*/(NxNy), the general relationships for the steady-state membrane fractions fchan,i are given by: which can be solved as a Nchan x Nchan linear system. For the case of a single channel, this simplifies to fchan,1=pinsert,1/(pinsert,1+premove,1). We note that for all simulations, the initial seeding probability is set equal to the steady-state fraction, i.e., pseed,i=fchan,i, to mitigate initial transient behavior in the model. Further, we define model parameters such that an increase in trafficking rate results in both more frequent channel removal and insertion in a manner that maintains the steady-state fraction fchan. Specifically, we define the removal probability premove as proportional to the channel trafficking rate rtraffic (where premove=rtrafficδt and δt=1 is a nominal time step), and subsequently pinsert is defined from premove and fchan from Eq (2). Channel-channel interactions and channel diffusion. If the pixel selected is occupied but not removed, then the channel may move to one of its Nmove unoccupied neighbors, based on both channel-channel interactions and diffusion. Specifically, the probability of movement to an unoccupied neighboring pixel is determined from a Boltzmann distribution based on the thermodynamic energy differences between the current channel position and the possible unoccupied neighbors. As described further below, movements with negative energy differences are more energetically favorable and thus have a higher probability. For a channel type i, we define the homotypic channel-channel interaction energy Hccii and heterotypic interaction energy Hccij for i≠j. Note that it is convenient to define these values as elements in a symmetric matrix, since Hccij=Hccji. Additionally, we define an energy term Hdiff,i associated with membrane diffusion that depends on the channel diffusion probability pdiff,i. We define the relationship between Hdiff,i and pdiff,i below, but clarify here that these have an inverse relationship, i.e., higher diffusion probability is more energetically favorable, and thus smaller Hdiff,i. We define the energy of the current position as H0 by summing over all values of Hcc for both homotypic and heterotypic channel-channel interactions in the Moore neighborhood of the selected channel. We repeat this process to calculate the energy Hm associated with the channel moving to each of the m=1,2,...,Nmove unoccupied neighbors (i.e., we calculate the energy if the channel moved each of the possible unoccupied positions). From these values, we calculate the energy difference for each m possible, ΔHm,i=Hm+Hdiff,i−H0. Finally, the channel of type i moves to unoccupied neighbor m with probability given by the Boltzmann distribution: where k is the Boltzmann constant, T is the thermodynamic temperature, and we define the probability of the (Nmove+1)th ‘move’ as the channel not moving, which by definition has no energy difference and thus ΔHNmove+1,i=0. Note that we define Hcc terms in units of kT, such that it is not necessary to introduce an additional value for parameter T. The channel either moves to unoccupied neighbor m or does not move based on these probabilities. This complete process is then iterated for a specified number of time points, each time selecting a new random pixel. Time is specified in terms of Monte Carlo Steps (MCS), where one MCS corresponds to NxNy iterations, such that each pixel is selected on average once per MCS. Connection between diffusion model parameters and biophysical measurements. The energy associated with diffusion Hdiff,i is related to the channel membrane diffusion probability pdiff,i and coefficient Dchan,i as follows: First, the probability of a channel moving to one of its unoccupied neighbors solely due to diffusion (and not channel-channel interactions) is defined as pdiff,i=Dchan,iΔt/4Δx2, where Δt is the time step (in physical units of time) and Δx is the spatial grid size (in physical units of distance). This probability is limited to values ≤1/8, with 1/8 corresponding with a channel guaranteed to move to one of its 8 Moore neighbors. While this probability definition is convenient for a random walk model of pure diffusion, it is not consistent with the channel-channel interaction energy framework. Thus, we need to define the energy associated with diffusion Hdiff,i to be consistent with the value of pdiff,i. Specifically, we define the relationship pdiff,i=exp(−Hdiff,i)/(8exp(−Hdiff,i)+1) based on the Boltzmann distribution described above, from which we can define Hdiff,i=−ln(pdiff,i/(1−8pdiff,i)). For all simulations and channel types, we define pdiff,i=1/9, which corresponds with Hdiff,i=0, consistent with the channel being equally likely to move to one of its 8 neighbors or not move, which also conveniently defines the energy associated with channels interacting with free membrane as 0, such that negative (positive) Hcc describes channel-channel interactions more (less) energetically favorable than free membrane. Note that for this study, we present results in normalized time and distance (i.e., in MCS and pixels, respectively), but the modeling framework can be naturally generalized based on physical channel dimensions and diffusion coefficients. Thus, collectively, the parameters for channel insertion, removal, and diffusion probabilities and channel-channel interaction terms define the model. Model analysis Unless otherwise specified, simulations were run for 10,000 MCS. Clusters were defined as groups of at least 3 channels, sharing adjacent pixel connections, utilizing the binary connected component (bwconncomp) function in the Image Processing Toolbox in MATLAB. Cluster mean and standard deviation measurements were calculated by taking the mean over the final 5,000 MCS. For simulations with two channel types, the nearest neighbor distribution between channel type 1 and 2, is calculated by the pairwise distance (pdist2 function in MATLAB) between all possible combinations of channels of type 1 and 2. Simulation code is provided as S1 Code. Results Dynamics of single channel type clustering We first modeled the minimal system containing a single channel type (Nchan = 1) to investigate ion channel dynamics on the cell membrane for parameters that result in robust clustering (Fig 1A, S1 Video). After initial random seeding (MCS = 1), small clusters began to form through diffusion-mediated aggregation (MCS = 10). By intermediate time points (MCS = 500), more substantial clustering emerged with significant variability in cluster size. In the later stages (MCS = 5000), the system approached a steady state characterized by a stable distribution of cluster sizes, though individual clusters continued to undergo dynamic remodeling through trafficking events and diffusion. Throughout this temporal evolution, the Monte Carlo approach generated variability in cluster morphology and spatial distribution, reflecting the inherent randomness of clustering processes at the cell membrane. The total number of clusters initially decreases, while mean cluster size increases, in time, reflecting initial cluster formation, with both measures reaching steady-states with small fluctuations (Fig 1B, 1C). Temporal evolution of single channel type clustering. (A) Spatial distribution of a single channel type on a 100 x 100 (1 μm x 1 μm) membrane grid shown at four time points (1, 10, 500, and 5000 Monte Carlo steps [MCS]). (B) The total number of clusters and (C) mean cluster size (black), with +/- 1 standard deviation (grey) are shown as functions of time. The simulation demonstrates the progression from an initially random distribution to the formation of small clusters, followed by cluster growth and eventual establishment of a dynamic steady state. Parameters: channel fraction (fchan) = 0.2, trafficking rate (rtraffic) = 0.0005, and homotypic interaction energy (Hcc) = -1. The effects of varying trafficking rates and interaction energies on channel clustering are illustrated in Fig 2. As the trafficking rate (rtraffic) decreased, more stable and larger clusters formed due to the reduced turnover of channels. Interestingly, the relationship between interaction energy (Hcc) and cluster size was non-monotonic, with the largest clusters observed at Hcc=−1, such that the largest and most stable channel clusters when combining slow trafficking rates and intermediate interaction energy of Hcc=−1. Effects of trafficking rate and interaction energy on single channel clustering. Clusters for a single channel type with varying trafficking rates (rtraffic, rows) and homotypic interaction energies (Hcc, columns). Channel fraction (fchan) = 0.2. Lower trafficking rates consistently promote larger clusters, while the optimum clustering occurs at Hcc=−1, with reduced cluster sizes at both more and less negative interaction energies. To quantitatively assess how these parameters affect clustering behavior, we systematically varied channel fraction (fchan), trafficking rate (rtraffic), and homotypic interaction energy (Hcc) (Fig 3). Notably, the mean cluster size exhibited a biphasic relationship with interaction energy, with a peak occurring near Hcc=−1. This non-monotonic behavior suggests that while moderately negative interaction energies are necessary to promote clustering, excessively strong interactions constrain channel mobility and limit cluster growth. As shown in Fig 2, increased trafficking rates reduce cluster size. Additionally, higher channel fractions, such that there are more channels on the membrane, also generally increased cluster size. These relationships highlight the complex interplay between channel density, interaction strength, and membrane turnover in determining the steady-state organization of membrane channels. Quantitative analysis of clustering parameters for a single channel type. Mean cluster size is shown as a function of channel fraction (fchan), trafficking rate (rtraffic), and homotypic interaction energy (Hcc). Two-channel system: Competition between homotypic and heterotypic interactions We next considered a membrane with two distinct channel types (Nchan=2), incorporating both homotypic (Hcc11, Hcc22) and heterotypic (Hcc12) interactions. Fig 4 shows the spatial organization of two channel types (red for type 1, blue for type 2) under conditions where both channel types had equal fractions and trafficking rates, while the interaction energies were systematically varied. When homotypic interactions were equivalent for both channel types (Hcc11=Hcc22), the spatial patterns were primarily determined by the heterotypic interaction energy (Hcc12). For stronger homotypic interaction energy (Hcc11=Hcc22=−2), heterotypic interactions result in a spatial organization of either adjacent or more segregated clusters (S2 Video). For weaker homotypic interaction energies (Hcc11=Hcc22=−1 or -0.5), more negative heterotypic energies promoted the formation of mixed clusters containing both channel types (S3 Video), while more positive heterotypic energies led to segregation of the two channel populations into distinct clusters. Two-channel clustering with equal homotypic interaction energies. Spatial distributions of two channel types (type 1 in red, type 2 in blue) with equal channel fractions (fchan=0.1) and trafficking rates (rtraffic=0.0005). Each panel represents a different combination of homotypic (Hcc11=Hcc22, rows) and heterotypic (Hcc12, columns) interaction energies. More negative heterotypic energies promote mixed clustering, while more positive values lead to channel segregation. We next quantify the relationship between interaction energies and clustering size for two channel types with equal homotypic interaction energies (Fig 5). The top panels show the mean cluster size for the individual channel types (averages of both channel type, as the two types have identical properties), while the bottom panels display the mean size of clusters containing all channel types. Consistent with the single channel simulations, the largest cluster sizes occur for homotypic interaction energies near -1 (yellow lines), and similarly, slower trafficking results in larger clusters. As the heterotypic interaction energy (Hcc12) transitioned from positive to negative values, corresponding with the increase in mixed cluster formation, there is both a decrease in individual cluster size and an increase in total cluster size, particularly when homotypic interactions were also favorable (negative Hcc11 and Hcc22 values near -1). Interestingly, this transition point from segregated to mixed clustering generally occurs for heterotypic interaction energies near Hcc12=−0.5, i.e., half as strong as the optimal homotypic interaction energy, although this transition is more gradual and appears to be influenced by the relative strengths of homotypic versus heterotypic interactions. Two-channel clustering with varying interaction energies. Mean cluster size as a function of heterotypic interaction energy (Hcc12) for different homotypic interaction energies (Hcc11=Hcc22=Hccii, different lines). Top row: Mean cluster size for clusters containing only individual channel types. Bottom row: Mean cluster size for clusters containing any channel type. Channel fraction fchan for both types was fixed at 0.1. We next illustrate the possible complexity of channel organization for cases in which the homotypic interactions differ between channel types (Fig 6). We find that for conditions in which one channel type exhibited stronger homotypic interactions than the other (Hcc11