Comparative Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Intrapulpal Crushed Ice and Intrapulpal Local Anesthesia during Pulpectomy in Primary Molars Authors: Snehal D Jagtap, Nupur Ninawe, Ritesh R Kalaskar, Nidhi Sharma, Utkarsha S Kadam Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractAims and backgroundThis study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of intrapulpal crushed ice compared to intrapulpal lidocaine as a supplementary anesthetic during pulpectomy in primary second molars of children aged 5–10 years. The goal was to assess whether crushed ice could serve as a less painful, effective alternative to intrapulpal local anesthesia when the inferior alveolar nerve block (IANB) alone is insufficient in cases of symptomatic irreversible pulpitis.Materials and methodsA randomized controlled clinical trial was conducted among 52 children fulfilling the inclusion criteria: Frankl Behavior Rating of 3 or 4, vital pulp with bleeding on exposure, and requiring supplementary anesthesia following IANB. Participants were randomly assigned using concealed envelopes to group I (intrapulpal lidocaine, 0.2–0.5 mL under pressure) or group II (intrapulpal crushed ice, placed in the pulp chamber for 3–5 minutes at −4 to 0°C). Pain perception was assessed at access opening and during biomechanical preparation using a visual analog scale (VAS) by the child and a sound, eye, motor (SEM) score by a blinded dentist. Procedure duration was recorded, and cases requiring additional anesthesia were noted.ResultsThe correlation between VAS and SEM scores was not uniform across groups and assessment stages. A statistically significant positive correlation was observed during access opening in Group II and during biomechanical preparation in Group I, whereas the correlations at the other assessment stages were not statistically significant.ConclusionIntrapulpal cryotherapy using crushed ice may be a safe, child-friendly, and effective alternative to intrapulpal lidocaine, providing acceptable pain control with improved behavioral outcomes and clinical efficiency.Clinical significanceThis alternative technique helps avoid the pain of intrapulpal anesthesia while providing effective pain control with a positive impact on the child's experience, making it a more child-friendly option.How to cite this articleJagtap SD, Ninawe N, Kalaskar RR, et al. Comparative Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Intrapulpal Crushed Ice and Intrapulpal Local Anesthesia during Pulpectomy in Primary Molars. Int J Clin Pediatr Dent 2026;19(8):1017–1022.Keywords: Intrapulpal anesthesia, Intrapulpal cryotherapy, Pain perception, Pediatric dentistry, Pulpectomy Introduction Effective behavior management is essential in pediatric dentistry to build a positive dentist-patient relationship and ensure successful treatment outcomes. Children's behavior is closely linked to pain perception, which can influence the success of dental procedures.1 While pain is a common reason for seeking dental care, it can also be a major deterrent, especially in children. Local anesthesia is often required to manage pain, but, ironically, its administration can cause discomfort, making effective pain management strategies crucial for a smooth dental experience.2 Pulpectomy is a common procedure in pediatric dentistry, often requiring an inferior alveolar nerve block (IANB) for mandibular teeth. However, IANB has a high failure rate (44–81%) in cases of symptomatic irreversible pulpitis (SIP), as noted by Bigby et al.,3 making additional anesthesia necessary. Intrapulpal lidocaine injection is frequently used as a supplement, but, as Malamed states, it can itself be painful.4 This creates a challenge in pain management, where the methods used to alleviate pain may cause additional discomfort for the patient. Cryotherapy involves the application of cold to a localized area to produce a cooling effect that can reduce pain perception and minimize discomfort during dental procedures.5 Research shows that it slows down nerve conduction and reduces inflammation, swelling, cellular activity, and local blood flow, providing physiological relief. This also provides psychological relief by distracting patients from focusing on their pain.6 Cryotherapy has been used to treat sprains, wounds, fractures, bruises, insect stings, and other injuries.7 Although less common in dentistry, ice as a topical agent has been proven effective in multiple studies. Lakshmanan and Ravindran8 and Padmanabh et al.9 concluded that cryotherapy is a highly effective, noninvasive alternative for reducing pain perception during local anesthesia injections in children. However, its effectiveness as a supplementary anesthetic during pulpectomy procedures has not yet been studied. Thus, the present study was planned to evaluate and compare the effectiveness of intrapulpal crushed ice and intrapulpal local anesthesia during the pulpectomy procedure. Materials and Methods This prospective, two-arm, open-label, randomized controlled clinical trial was conducted at a dental institute following ethical approval from the Institutional Review Board. Informed consent was obtained from parents or guardians before treatment. Based on data from a previously published study,8 a sample size of 52 was determined with 99% power using a power analysis. Children aged 5–10 years were recruited and underwent an initial clinical examination. The inclusion criteria were: Frankl Behavior Rating Scale scores of 3 or 4. Frankl Behavior Rating Scale scores of 3 or 4. Teeth with symptomatic irreversible pulpitis (SIP) requiring endodontic treatment of the second primary molar. Teeth with symptomatic irreversible pulpitis (SIP) requiring endodontic treatment of the second primary molar. Need for supplementary anesthesia following an IANB. Need for supplementary anesthesia following an IANB. Presence of vital teeth exhibiting active bleeding on access opening. Presence of vital teeth exhibiting active bleeding on access opening. Parental or guardian consent for participation. Parental or guardian consent for participation. The exclusion criteria included: Frankl Behavior Rating Scale scores of 1 or 2. Frankl Behavior Rating Scale scores of 1 or 2. Teeth unresponsive to traditional vitality tests. Teeth unresponsive to traditional vitality tests. Teeth achieving adequate anesthesia with IANB alone, not requiring supplementary anesthesia (these were excluded from the study). Teeth achieving adequate anesthesia with IANB alone, not requiring supplementary anesthesia (these were excluded from the study). Teeth with acute or chronic apical abscess/periodontitis (positive percussion test)/necrotic pulp, with or without sinus tract formation. Teeth with acute or chronic apical abscess/periodontitis (positive percussion test)/necrotic pulp, with or without sinus tract formation. Special health care needs. Special health care needs. Medical conditions or recent intake (within 48 hours) of analgesics, steroids, or antibiotics. Medical conditions or recent intake (within 48 hours) of analgesics, steroids, or antibiotics. Based on the above-mentioned criteria, selected children received a standard IANB using a self-aspirating 27-gauge needle, with 2 mL of 2% lidocaine hydrochloride containing epinephrine (1:80,000) at a rate of 1 mL per minute. Anesthesia success was confirmed after 15 minutes based on subjective signs, such as lip numbness. Mechanical debridement was then initiated. If the patient experienced pain, supplementary anesthesia was required, and the patient was included in the study. Using the concealed-envelope technique, participants were randomly assigned to one of two groups: Group I (intrapulpal anesthesia, IANB-L) (Fig. 1): Following caries removal and initial pulp exposure, 0.2–0.5 mL of 2% lidocaine with 1:80,000 epinephrine was administered directly into the pulp under pressure using a cotton pellet stoppering technique to ensure adequate buildup. Group I—intrapulpal anesthesia, IANB-L Group II (intrapulpal crushed ice, IANB-C) (Fig. 2): After caries removal, when a thin layer of dentin remained or there was a pinpoint pulp exposure, and additionally after deroofing the pulp chamber if required, crushed ice was placed in the cavity for 3–5 minutes. The ice temperature was maintained between −4 and 0°C, measured using a thermocouple to prevent frostbite. Group II—intrapulpal crushed ice, IANB-C It was found that, unlike intrapulpal anesthesia, crushed ice was more soothing and less painful, with patients adapting to the cold within minutes. Teeth that did not require supplementary anesthesia during mechanical debridement were excluded from the study. The biomechanical preparation of the selected tooth was completed (Fig. 3A) and temporarily sealed with zinc oxide eugenol (ZOE) cement. The remaining endodontic treatment, obturation (Fig. 3B), and postobturation restoration (POR) (Fig. 3C) were completed 1 week later. Pulpectomy procedure: (A) Biomechanical preparation; (B) Obturation; (C) Postobturative restoration Children's response to pain was assessed using a visual analog scale (VAS) immediately during access opening and biomechanical preparation (Fig. 4). Participants were trained beforehand to indicate their pain intensity using the VAS. Additionally, an independent dentist recorded the sound, eye, motor (SEM) score at the same time intervals. The duration of the procedure, from mechanical debridement to the completion of biomechanical preparation, was also recorded. Evaluation of children's response to pain using the VAS score Teeth from group I or group II that required additional anesthesia during treatment, or those that continued to experience pain after supplementary anesthesia, received intrapulpal injections if necessary and were recorded as failures in the final analysis. Results The study involved 52 children (21 male, 31 female) aged between 5 and 10 years, with an average age of 7 ± 1.9 years. Comparison of VAS scores between group I and group II at various treatment stages revealed no statistically significant difference in pain perception, suggesting comparable efficacy of both techniques as supplementary anesthesia. Notably, group II exhibited higher VAS scores during access opening, whereas group I recorded higher scores during biomechanical preparation (Table 1). Table 1:Comparison of the VAS score between the two groups Interval Group I (Mean ± SD) Group II (Mean ± SD) p-value Access opening3.08 ± 0.953.15 ± 1.070.762During BMP2.85 ± 0.992.39 ± 0.770.418BMP, biomechanical preparation; SD, standard deviation. Mann–Whitney test Comparison of the VAS score between the two groups BMP, biomechanical preparation; SD, standard deviation. Mann–Whitney test The comparison of SEM scale scores between group I and group II during access opening revealed no statistically significant differences across all individual parameters—sound (p = 0.724, eye (p = 1.000), and motor (p = 0.724). The total SEM score was slightly higher in group II than in group I, but the difference was not statistically significant (Table 2). Table 2:Comparison of the SEM scale score between the two groups Variable Group I Group II p-value Mean ± SD Mean ± SD Access opening Sound2.54 ± 0.522.69 ± 0.750.724 Eye2.54 ± 0.522.62 ± 0.771.000 Motor2.23 ± 0.732.15 ± 0.900.724 Total7.31 ± 1.497.46 ± 2.150.920During BMP Sound2.23 ± 0.601.85 ± 0.560.169 Eye2.15 ± 0.691.77 ± 0.600.204 Motor1.77 ± 0.831.23 ± 0.440.125 Total6.15 ± 1.954.85 ± 1.350.072BMP, biomechanical preparation; SD, standard deviation. Mann–Whitney test Comparison of the SEM scale score between the two groups BMP, biomechanical preparation; SD, standard deviation. Mann–Whitney test During biomechanical preparation (BMP), the SEM scores were consistently lower in group II across all parameters: sound, eye, and motor. Also, group II showed a notably lower total SEM score than group I; however, this difference did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.072) (Table 2). These findings suggest a trend toward reduced pain-related responses in group II, particularly during BMP, although the differences were not statistically significant. The correlation between VAS and SEM scores was evaluated using the Spearman rank correlation test. During access opening, there was a high correlation between the two scales in group II. During BMP, there was a moderate correlation between the two scales in group I. These findings suggest that the subjective (VAS) and objective (SEM) measures of pain perception are more strongly aligned in group II during access opening and in group I during BMP (Table 3). Table 3:Correlation between VAS and SEM in each group Interval Group I Group II Access openingr = 0.355; p = 0.235r = 0.651; p = 0.016*During BMPr = 0.564; p = 0.045*r = 0.467; p = 0.108BMP, biomechanical preparation. Spearman rank correlation test. *Indicates a significant correlation at p ≤ 0.05 Correlation between VAS and SEM in each group BMP, biomechanical preparation. Spearman rank correlation test. *Indicates a significant correlation at p ≤ 0.05 The time required to complete the procedures was compared between the two groups using the Mann–Whitney test. During access opening, both group I and group II required the same amount of time, with no difference observed (p = 1.000). For biomechanical preparation, group II required slightly less time (6.77 ± 0.60 minutes) than group I (7.08 ± 0.64 minutes), but the difference was not statistically significant (Table 4). Table 4:Comparison of the time required between the two groups Interval Group I Group II p-value Mean ± SD (minute) Mean ± SD (minute) Access opening1.000.001.000.001.000Completion of BMP7.080.646.770.600.287BMP, biomechanical preparation; SD, standard deviation. Mann–Whitney test Comparison of the time required between the two groups BMP, biomechanical preparation; SD, standard deviation. Mann–Whitney test Discussion In cases of symptomatic irreversible pulpitis (SIP), the presence of pulpal inflammation significantly compromises the success of conventional anesthesia, with studies reporting up to an eightfold reduction in efficacy.10 Byers et al.11 observed that inflammation induces the sprouting of nerve fibers within the pulp and surrounding periapical tissues, leading to exaggerated pain responses such as allodynia and hyperalgesia. As a result, patients with SIP often require supplementary anesthetic techniques to achieve adequate pain control. Although intrapulpal lidocaine is a routinely used method for this purpose, it is frequently associated with sharp pain upon administration due to the high-pressure injection into confined pulp tissue.12 This presents a clinical challenge in pediatric dentistry, where pain perception can influence behavior and treatment outcomes. To address this, the present study was undertaken to evaluate and compare the efficacy of intrapulpal crushed ice—an approach utilizing cryotherapy—and intrapulpal lidocaine as supplementary pain management strategies during pulpectomy in children. Cryotherapy, recognized for its analgesic and anti-inflammatory properties, could offer a less painful yet equally effective alternative. Cryotherapy has already shown potential in minimizing injection-related discomfort in children.8,9,13 Vera et al.14 reported a notable decrease in external root surface temperature when cold saline was applied using negative apical pressure. In a subsequent clinical trial, they further demonstrated that saline cooled to 4°C significantly reduced postoperative pain in patients with symptomatic apical periodontitis. Supporting this, Goodis et al.15 observed that cooling the tooth reduced pulpal blood flow and, in some cases, completely blocked pain sensation. Moreover, lowering the temperature of the pulp may inhibit neurotransmitter release from nerve endings, enhancing its pain-relieving effect. However, its specific application intrapulpally during endodontic procedures had not been explored before this investigation, underscoring the relevance and novelty of the present research. Although pain scores (VAS and SEM scale) between the groups were statistically similar, patient behavior and clinical feedback favored group II. Children receiving intrapulpal crushed ice often reacted positively, even playfully, during application. In contrast, patients in group I demonstrated more discomfort during intrapulpal injection, likely due to the pressure and sharp pain associated with lidocaine administration. These findings suggest that while both methods are effective, crushed ice may offer better overall patient acceptance, particularly in pediatric settings. Fernández et al.16 concluded that cryoanesthesia using dry ice spray is an effective supplementary technique to enhance the success of IANB during endodontic treatment of mandibular molars with irreversible pulpitis. Koteeswaran et al.17 concluded that the use of Endo-Ice followed by intrapulpal ice stick application significantly reduces pain during pulp extirpation in mandibular molars with symptomatic irreversible pulpitis. The cold group showed pain reduction comparable to the articaine group. The present study used crushed ice intrapulpally, allowing better tissue contact and prolonged action, thereby potentially offering superior pain control and patient comfort. Oh et al.,18 in their study on cryoconservation of human teeth for future tooth banking, observed enamel fractures in 4 out of 16 teeth, although hardness testing showed no significant differences. It is important to note that the cryoconservation temperatures used in their study ranged from −130 to −196°C, which are far more extreme than those applied in the present study; therefore, the present study does not consider such variables as those evaluated by Oh et al. The observed reduction in time for biomechanical preparation in group II, although not statistically significant, suggests a potential clinical advantage of cryotherapy in improving procedural efficiency. The cold application may have led to localized vasoconstriction, resulting in reduced pulpal bleeding, which likely facilitated easier pulp extirpation and better visibility during instrumentation. This cleaner operative field may have contributed to smoother and quicker biomechanical preparation. Moreover, as this is the first study to evaluate the effect of cryotherapy on procedural time, these findings cannot be directly compared with previous literature. However, they provide valuable preliminary insight into the possible efficiency-related benefits of using cryotherapy as an adjunct in endodontic procedures. The present study employed both the VAS and SEM scales, with the VAS being simple and effective for self-reporting by children and the SEM scale, used by the dentist, providing an objective behavioral assessment. A positive correlation between the two was found, supporting their combined reliability in evaluating pain perception. Fernández et al.16 used the Heft-Parker Modified Visual Analog Scale (HPVAS), while Koteeswaran et al.17 utilized the standard VAS for pain analysis. In contrast, our study incorporated both child- and dentist-based assessments, enhancing the overall reliability and comprehensiveness of pain evaluation. Future studies can be planned with a larger sample size to generalize the results and determine the actual duration of pain relief provided by the ice group during clinical procedures. Conclusion Both methods were equally effective based on VAS and SEM scores; however, the cryotherapy group demonstrated better patient acceptance and behavior. It also enabled slightly quicker biomechanical preparation and improved clinical visibility. The positive correlation between the VAS and SEM scales supports their combined use in pediatric pain assessment. Overall, intrapulpal cryotherapy emerges as a safe, effective, and child-friendly alternative. Clinical Significance Intrapulpal anesthesia, though effective, is often associated with sharp pain that can negatively affect a child's behavior and cooperation during treatment. The use of crushed ice as a supplementary technique provides a novel, nonpharmacological alternative that helps avoid this painful injection experience. It ensures adequate pain control during pulpectomy while improving the comfort and acceptance of the child. By reducing anxiety and enhancing cooperation, this method has a positive impact on the overall treatment experience. Moreover, it is safe, efficient, and easy to implement in routine clinical practice. Therefore, intrapulpal cryotherapy with crushed ice may serve as a child-friendly substitute for intrapulpal local anesthesia. Ethics Approval This study was reviewed and approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee (IEC), Government Dental College & Hospital, Nagpur, Maharashtra, India (EC Registration Number: EC/NEW/INST/2024/4160). The committee is located at Government Medical College Campus, Medical Square, Nagpur − 440003, Maharashtra, India. Ethical approval for the study was granted under Approval Reference Number IEC/GDCHN/121/2024 on 21 July 2024. The study was conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the Institutional Ethics Committee and the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki. Ethical approval was obtained before the commencement of the study. Clinical Trial Registration This study was prospectively registered with the Clinical Trials Registry − India (CTRI). The trial was prospectively registered under CTRI/2024/06/068337 on 05 June 2024, prior to participant enrollment. The CTRI Acknowledgment Number for the study is REF/2024/05/084445. Acknowledgment None. Author Contributions Snehal D Jagtap: Conceptualization, methodology, investigation, data curation, formal analysis, visualization, writing − original draft. Nupur Ninawe: Methodology, supervision, validation, writing − review & editing. Ritesh R Kalaskar: Conceptualization, supervision, project administration, writing − review & editing. Nidhi Sharma: Data curation, formal analysis, validation, writing − review & editing. Utkarsha S Kadam: Investigation, resources, visualization, writing − review & editing. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work. AI Use Declaration The authors declare that no artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted technology was used in the conception, design, data collection, data analysis, interpretation of results, writing, or preparation of this manuscript. The authors take full responsibility for the accuracy, integrity, and originality of the work. Orcid Snehal D Jagtap https://orcid.org/0009-0008-9164-0869 Nupur Ninawe https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1403-4634 Ritesh R Kalaskar https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7403-3364 Nidhi Sharma https://orcid.org/0009-0000-7725-6475 Utkarsha S Kadam https://orcid.org/0009-0001-1990-7492 Footnotes Source of support: Nil Conflict of interest: None Patient informed consent: Written informed consent was obtained from the parents/legal guardians of all participating children prior to their inclusion in the study. Data Availability Statement The datasets generated and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The datasets generated and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.