From Ritual to Screen: Documenting Tabuik as Intangible Cultural Heritage Authors: Ananda Putriani, Sumiyadi Sumiyadi, Tedi Permadi, Halimah Halimah, Vereki Martiano, Nurmalinda Zari, Jamilah Aljah Siompu, Munyika Sibanda, Munyika Sibanda, Ananda Putriani, Libra Dui Putra Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Intangible cultural heritage (ICH) plays a crucial role in sustaining cultural identity, collective memory, and social continuity; however, existing studies have predominantly focused on preservation efforts and heritage policies, with limited attention to how documentation itself contributes to the construction of cultural meaning. This study examines the documentation of the Tabuik tradition in Pariaman, West Sumatra, as a process of cultural representation and meaning-making. Employing a qualitative autoethnographic approach, data were collected through participant observation, interactions with cultural practitioners, focus group discussions, and the development of a documentary narrative entitled Tabuik Manusia: Dari Asal Menuju Melepaskan. The data were analyzed using thematic analysis to identify patterns of representation and narrative construction within the documentation process. The findings reveal that documenting Tabuik extends beyond the technical recording of ritual activities and functions as an interpretive practice through which cultural meanings are selected, negotiated, and reconstructed. Four major themes emerged from the analysis: origin and loss as an existential foundation, silenced grief in adolescent experience, intergenerational expectations and identity negotiation, and responsibility as an embodied practice in ritual and everyday life. These themes demonstrate how ritual symbolism is translated into visual and narrative forms that connect collective cultural memory with contemporary personal experiences. The study argues that cultural documentation should be understood not merely as a preservation mechanism but as an epistemological and representational practice that actively shapes cultural understanding. By transforming ritual experiences into mediated narratives, documentation contributes to both the safeguarding of intangible cultural heritage and the ongoing production of cultural meaning, thereby highlighting the significance of reflexive and context-sensitive documentation in ensuring the relevance and sustainability of cultural heritage in contemporary society. Introduction Intangible cultural heritage (ICH) plays a crucial role in sustaining collective identity, cultural memory, and social continuity across societies worldwide ( Harrison, 2013; Kirshenblatt-Gimblett, 2004; Kuutma, 2009; Smith, 2006; UNESCO, 2003). It encompasses practices, rituals, and cultural expressions transmitted across generations, serving as key markers of cultural diversity and social cohesion ( UNESCO, 2003). Within contemporary heritage studies, ICH is no longer understood as static inheritance, but rather as a dynamic social process that is continuously reconstructed in response to changing socio-cultural contexts ( Akagawa & Smith, 2019; Harrison, 2013). Recent studies also highlight that research on intangible cultural heritage has expanded significantly across disciplines, reflecting its growing importance in contemporary cultural discourse ( Hu et al., 2024; Pérez-Gandarillas, 2024). However, amid accelerating processes of globalization and modernization, many traditional cultural practices face significant threats to their sustainability ( Logan, 2012; Silverman & Ruggles, 2007). These challenges not only risk the disappearance of cultural practices but also undermine the systems of meaning and identity embedded within them. Therefore, safeguarding intangible cultural heritage has become a central concern in contemporary cultural and heritage studies ( Kurin, 2004). Rituals, as a fundamental component of intangible cultural heritage, function not only as symbolic practices but also as mechanisms for transmitting values, knowledge, and cultural identity across generations ( Bell, 2009; Turner, 1969). In recent years, scholarly attention has increasingly focused on the role of rituals within cultural heritage contexts, particularly in relation to community participation, cultural experience, and sustainability ( Hu et al., 2024). At the same time, rapid technological advancement has positioned cultural documentation as an essential strategy for ensuring the continuity of these practices. Documentation is no longer understood as a passive process of recording, but rather as an active and interpretive practice involving the selection, interpretation, and representation of cultural values ( Giaccardi, 2012). Empirical studies indicate that digital technologies and visual documentation significantly contribute to the preservation and dissemination of intangible cultural heritage, while also transforming how cultural practices are accessed and understood ( Dou et al., 2018; Ioannides et al., 2021; Zabulis et al., 2021). Despite the growing attention to safeguarding intangible cultural heritage, existing studies suggest that documentation and preservation efforts continue to face conceptual limitations. Much of the research remains focused on identifying and describing cultural practices, without critically examining how documentation processes shape cultural meaning itself ( Akagawa & Smith, 2019; Kurin, 2004). Furthermore, cultural documentation is often treated as a neutral technical activity, whereas in practice it involves processes of selection, interpretation, and representation that influence how culture is understood and communicated ( Giaccardi, 2012). From a cultural studies perspective, representation is not merely a reflection of reality but a process through which meaning is constructed through language, symbols, and media ( Hall, 1997). Therefore, this study adopts a cultural representation perspective, which views documentation as a meaning-making process rather than a neutral recording activity. In addition, recent developments in digital technology have introduced new challenges regarding how cultural practices can be represented without losing their social context and symbolic meanings ( Ioannides et al., 2021; Pandey & Kumar, 2020). While digital documentation enables wider access and preservation, it also raises critical questions about authenticity, interpretation, and the transformation of cultural practices in mediated forms. While previous studies have extensively examined preservation and policy aspects of intangible cultural heritage, limited attention has been given to how documentation practices actively construct cultural meaning through narrative and visual representation. This gap is particularly evident in studies focusing on local ritual traditions within contemporary socio-cultural transformations. Consequently, a significant research gap remains in examining cultural documentation not merely as a preservation tool, but as a process that constructs cultural representation and meaning within contemporary contexts. In the Indonesian context, one form of intangible cultural heritage that continues to be practiced is the Tabuik tradition in Pariaman, West Sumatra. This annual ritual, performed during the month of Muharram, commemorates the historical events of Karbala and has evolved into a local cultural practice ( Asril, 2018; Dalmenda & Elian, 2017). Beyond its religious dimension, Tabuik functions as a medium for preserving cultural identity and collective memory within the community, reflecting the interrelationship between adat (customary practices) and religion in Minangkabau society ( Dalmenda & Elian, 2017). From a heritage perspective, such rituals serve not only as inherited traditions but also as dynamic practices that are continuously reinterpreted within changing social contexts ( Harrison, 2013; Smith, 2006). Based on this background, this study aims to analyze how the Tabuik tradition is documented as intangible cultural heritage within a contemporary societal context. Specifically, it examines documentation as a practice that involves processes of selection, interpretation, and narrative construction. This study seeks to explore how elements of the Tabuik ritual are translated into visual and narrative forms, and how these processes contribute to the preservation and understanding of cultural meaning. This study offers a conceptual contribution by positioning cultural documentation as an interpretive and epistemological practice, rather than merely a technical activity of preservation. By integrating perspectives from heritage studies, ritual theory, and visual culture, this research highlights that documentation actively shapes cultural meaning, narratives, and representation. Furthermore, this study provides an empirical contribution through an analysis of the Tabuik tradition as a dynamic local cultural practice, thereby extending existing scholarship on the relationship between ritual, documentation, and cultural representation in contemporary society. Literature review Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH) Intangible cultural heritage is a key concept in contemporary cultural studies, referring to practices, representations, expressions, knowledge, and skills that are recognized by communities as part of their cultural heritage ( UNESCO, 2003). Unlike tangible cultural heritage, intangible cultural heritage is dynamic in nature and is continuously recreated by communities in response to their environment, social interactions, and historical experiences. Therefore, it should not be understood merely as a set of traditions passively inherited, but rather as living cultural practices that continuously evolve within changing social contexts ( Blake, 2015; Kurin, 2004). Recent studies also emphasize that intangible cultural heritage should be understood as a living and adaptive system that is continuously negotiated within contemporary societies ( Bortolotto, 2010; Hu et al., 2024; Pérez-Gandarillas, 2024; Su et al., 2019). In the development of academic scholarship, intangible cultural heritage is no longer viewed solely as an object of preservation, but as a social construction that involves processes of interpretation, negotiation, and representation ( Bortolotto, 2010; Harrison, 2013; Smith, 2006). This perspective highlights that what is defined as “heritage” is not neutral; rather, it is shaped through power relations, cultural policies, and specific social and political interests. In this sense, heritage is actively produced through discourse and practice, rather than simply inherited from the past ( Smith, 2006). Consequently, safeguarding intangible cultural heritage is not only concerned with maintaining the continuity of cultural practices, but also with how cultural meanings are produced, mediated, and represented across different contexts ( Akagawa & Smith, 2019). Recent empirical research further shows that heritage practices are increasingly influenced by global cultural dynamics, digital transformation, and interdisciplinary approaches ( Chen et al., 2022; Hu et al., 2024). Furthermore, in the context of globalization and modernization, intangible cultural heritage faces a range of challenges, including shifting social values, the commodification of culture, and changes in the functions of rituals within society ( Akagawa & Smith, 2019; Kurin, 2004; Logan, 2012). Contemporary studies also indicate that digital transformation and globalization processes significantly affect how cultural heritage is preserved and transmitted, often leading to reinterpretation and hybridization of cultural practices ( Ioannides et al., 2021; Qiu et al., 2022; Zabulis et al., 2021). On the one hand, preservation efforts are increasingly important for ensuring cultural sustainability; on the other hand, these processes may also transform the original meanings and functions of cultural practices. This tension reflects the complex relationship between preservation and transformation in contemporary heritage practices ( Blake, 2015). Therefore, the study of intangible cultural heritage cannot be separated from an analysis of dynamics of change, adaptation, and processes of cultural representation in contemporary societies. Cultural documentation Cultural documentation constitutes a crucial aspect of efforts to safeguard intangible cultural heritage, particularly in the face of social change and technological development. In contemporary scholarship, documentation is no longer understood as a passive process of recording; rather, it is regarded as an active practice that plays a significant role in organizing, storing, and transmitting cultural knowledge to future generations ( Cameron & Kenderdine, 2007; Khan et al., 2018; Kurin, 2004). This is especially important given that intangible cultural heritage is inherently non-material and heavily dependent on social practices and collective memory, making it vulnerable to transformation or even disappearance in the absence of systematic documentation ( Kurin, 2004). Recent studies further emphasize that documentation practices are central to sustaining cultural continuity, particularly in rapidly changing societies ( Hu et al., 2024; Su et al., 2019). With the advancement of digital technologies, cultural documentation practices have undergone significant transformation through processes such as digitization, database development, and cultural information systems. Studies suggest that digital documentation enables broader storage and dissemination of cultural knowledge; however, it also introduces challenges related to representation, interpretation, and cultural context ( Dou et al., 2018; Ioannides et al., 2021). In addition, research indicates that digital technologies not only preserve cultural heritage but also reshape how it is accessed, experienced, and interpreted by wider audiences ( Bekele et al., 2021; Rahaman et al., 2019; Zabulis et al., 2021). In this context, documentation functions not only as a tool for preservation but also as a medium that mediates the relationship between culture, technology, and society. Furthermore, a number of studies emphasize that cultural documentation is not neutral, as it inherently involves processes of selection, interpretation, and the construction of cultural representation ( Giaccardi, 2012)vv. Documentation, particularly in visual and digital forms, plays a significant role in shaping how cultural practices are understood and represented within broader contexts. From a contemporary perspective, digital documentation also raises critical questions regarding authenticity, ownership, and the transformation of cultural meaning in mediated environments ( Jones, 2017; Pandey & Kumar, 2020; Zabulis et al., 2021). Therefore, the documentation of intangible cultural heritage is not solely concerned with preservation, but also with the production of meaning and cultural representation in contemporary society. Representation and visual culture Cultural representation constitutes a significant aspect in the study of cultural heritage, particularly in understanding how cultural practices are produced, interpreted, and communicated across various social contexts. From a cultural studies perspective, representation is not understood as a neutral reflection of reality; rather, it is a process of meaning construction through language, symbols, and media ( Hall, 1997). Therefore, any form of cultural documentation, especially those based on visual media, inherently involves processes of selection and interpretation that shape how a culture is understood by broader audiences. Recent studies further highlight that representation plays a crucial role in shaping public understanding of cultural heritage, particularly in mediated and digital contexts ( Smith & Waterton, 2009; Waterton & Smith, 2010; Waterton & Watson, 2015). Within the context of visual culture, media such as documentary film, photography, and digital platforms play a crucial role in representing cultural practices. Visual representation functions not only as a tool of documentation but also as a medium that constructs cultural narratives and meanings through specific visual choices, narrative structures, and perspectives ( Pink, 2013)vv. Empirical research in visual and digital heritage studies suggests that media technologies significantly influence how cultural experiences are framed, accessed, and interpreted by audiences ( Champion, 2020; Ioannides et al., 2021; Rahaman et al., 2019). In addition, studies in visual anthropology and media research emphasize that images and visual narratives are not neutral representations but are embedded within cultural, political, and epistemological frameworks ( Banks, 2018; Banks & Ruby, 2011). Consequently, visual documentation cannot be separated from interpretation, as every cultural representation is inevitably influenced by the perspective of its creator. Furthermore, in contemporary studies, cultural representation through visual media is closely linked to issues of authenticity, power, and the construction of cultural identity. Several studies indicate that representation processes can reinforce, transform, or even simplify particular cultural meanings, depending on how such cultures are selected and presented ( Rose, 2016). In addition, recent scholarship highlights that digital and visual representations may reshape cultural meanings through processes of mediation, recontextualization, and audience interaction ( Bekele et al., 2021; Jones, 2017; Zabulis et al., 2021). In the context of intangible cultural heritage, this becomes especially significant, as visual documentation not only records cultural practices but also contributes to shaping collective understandings of those practices. Thus, the study of cultural documentation cannot be detached from an analysis of visual representation as a process of meaning-making within contemporary society. Methodology This study employs a qualitative approach with an autoethnographic perspective to analyze the documentation of the Tabuik tradition as a practice of representing intangible cultural heritage. A qualitative approach is adopted as it allows for an in-depth exploration of meanings, experiences, and social processes within specific cultural contexts ( Creswell, 2014). Meanwhile, autoethnography is utilized as a reflective approach that connects the researcher’s personal experience with broader cultural analysis, enabling a more contextualized understanding of cultural representation practices ( Ellis et al., 2011). The study is conducted in Pariaman City, West Sumatra, which serves as the central location for the Tabuik tradition. Data are collected through direct observation of the Tabuik ritual sequence, particularly the Maambiak Tanah and Buang Laut processions. In addition, data are obtained through interactions with cultural actors, including traditional elders (Tuo Tabuik) and youth who actively participate in the social practices surrounding the ritual. One of the primary data sources in this study is the development of a documentary storyline entitled Tabuik Manusia: Dari Asal Menuju Melepaskan, which is constructed based on field observations, focus group discussions (FGDs), and the researcher’s reflective experiences throughout the documentation process. The study involved 36 individuals as sources of research data: 30 senior high school students who participated in focus group discussions (FGDs) and 6 tradition bearers/practitioners. Nine of the 30 student participants provided personal narratives that were selected for thematic coding in relation to the themes developed for the documentary film. These nine students are a subset of the 30 FGD participants and are therefore not counted as an additional participant group. Tables 1– 3 summarize the participant composition, selection strategy, and analytical structure of the study. As shown in Table 1, the research involved 36 participants, comprising 30 senior high school students who participated in the focus group discussions (FGDs) and six tradition bearers/practitioners—including two Tuo Tabuik, one Maambiak Tanah diver, one elder woman involved in the tradition, one gandang tasa practitioner, and one ninik mamak—who served as cultural informants and provided contextual knowledge of the Tabuik tradition. Participants were purposively selected based on their direct involvement in, familiarity with, or cultural expertise regarding the Tabuik ritual. Each participant contributed information for approximately 20–30 minutes through a combination of structured and unstructured questions, allowing the researcher to obtain comparable information across participants while also providing sufficient flexibility for participants to elaborate on their personal experiences, interpretations, and cultural knowledge. The structured questions focused on participants’ experiences and understanding of Tabuik practices, while the unstructured questions enabled follow-up exploration of issues emerging during the discussions and interactions. From the 30 student FGD participants, nine students were further selected for thematic coding because their personal narratives provided sufficiently detailed and relevant accounts for the development of the documentary themes concerning cultural representation and intergenerational meaning-making. As presented in Tables 2 and 3, these nine students consisted of four males and five females, aged 15–17 years, with seven students in Grade X and two in Grade XI, representing two public senior high schools in Pariaman: four students from SMA Negeri 1 Pariaman and five from SMA Negeri 2 Pariaman. The six tradition bearers/practitioners were analyzed as cultural informants rather than as part of the nine-student narrative subset. This participant structure enabled the study to combine broader collective perspectives from the student FGDs, detailed personal narratives from the selected nine students, and contextual cultural knowledge from. Table 1. Composition of research participants. CharacteristicsCategoryNumber PercentageParticipant GroupStudent FGD participants3083.3%Tradition bearers/practitioners616.7%Student FGD ParticipantsStudents participating in the FGD30100%Students contributing personal narratives used in thematic coding930.0%Other FGD participants2170.0%Tradition Bearers/ PractitionersTuo Tabuik233.3%Maambiak Tanah diver116.7%Elder woman involved in the tradition116.7%Gandang tasa practitioner116.7%Ninik mamak116.7%Total Research ParticipantsAll participants36100% Note: Percentage calculated within the 30 student FGD participants. Percentage calculated within the 6 tradition bearers/practitioners. Composition of research participants. Note: Percentage calculated within the 30 student FGD participants. Percentage calculated within the 6 tradition bearers/practitioners. Table 2. Demographic characteristics of student participants included in thematic coding.CharacteristicsCategoryNumber PercentageGenderMale444.4%Female555.6%Age15–17 years9100%Grade LevelGrade X (First Year)777.8%Grade XI (Second Year)222.2%SchoolSMA Negeri 1 Pariaman444.4%SMA Negeri 2 Pariaman555.6%Educational BackgroundSenior High School Student9100% Note: N = 9. These nine students were drawn from the larger group of 30 FGD participants. They were the students whose personal narratives were used in the thematic coding for the documentary themes. The age range is reported as 15–17 years for the participating Grade X–XI students. Demographic characteristics of student participants included in thematic coding. Note: N = 9. These nine students were drawn from the larger group of 30 FGD participants. They were the students whose personal narratives were used in the thematic coding for the documentary themes. The age range is reported as 15–17 years for the participating Grade X–XI students. Table 3. Composition of the nine student participants by school and grade.SchoolParticipantsGrade XGrade XI TotalSMA Negeri 1 Pariaman1, 2, 3, 4314SMA Negeri 2 Pariaman5, 6, 7, 8, 9415Total—729 Note: Grade XI participants were B (SMA Negeri 1 Pariaman) and A (SMA Negeri 2 Pariaman); the remaining seven students were in Grade X. Composition of the nine student participants by school and grade. Note: Grade XI participants were B (SMA Negeri 1 Pariaman) and A (SMA Negeri 2 Pariaman); the remaining seven students were in Grade X. Prior to participation, all participants provided verbal informed consent. Verbal consent was considered more appropriate than written consent because the study was conducted in a community-based cultural setting where interactions were informal and rooted in local customary practices. Some participants, particularly traditional elders, were more comfortable providing oral agreement rather than signing formal documents. Before data collection, participants were informed about the objectives of the study, the use of visual documentation, the voluntary nature of their participation, and their right to withdraw at any stage without consequence. To protect participant privacy, all names were replaced with pseudonyms and identifying information was removed or anonymized during data analysis and publication. This storyline is positioned as qualitative data that represents processes of selection, interpretation, and meaning construction within cultural documentation practices. Within the autoethnographic framework, the researcher acts as both the primary instrument and an active participant directly involved in the documentation process. The researcher’s position is inherently reflective, acknowledging that personal experiences, background, and engagement shape the interpretation of the data. This approach emphasizes the importance of reflexivity in qualitative research, defined as a critical awareness of the researcher’s positionality in the production of knowledge ( Ellis et al., 2011) Ellis. To enhance data credibility, this study employs source triangulation by comparing observational data, field notes, and insights obtained from discussions with cultural practitioners. Triangulation is used to ensure interpretive consistency and to strengthen the validity of the findings in qualitative research ( Creswell, 2014). Data analysis is conducted using thematic analysis by identifying patterns of cultural representation within the documentation process of the Tabuik ritual. The analytical process includes coding, theme development, and interpretation of meanings. This approach enables the researcher to uncover underlying structures of meaning within the data and to understand how ritual elements are translated into visual and narrative forms ( Braun & Clarke, 2006). Thus, the analysis extends beyond mere data description to examine the construction of cultural representation within documentation practices. Findings The four themes presented below are interpreted as illustrative narrative cases rather than generalized patterns across all participants. They were developed through thematic analysis of nine student narratives selected from the broader group of 30 FGD participants. Each vignette foregrounds a particular relationship between an individual experience, the symbolic structure of the Tabuik ritual, and the documentary choices through which these elements were connected. Origin and loss as an existential foundation Participant 1’s narrative illustrates how the Maambiak Tanah procession can become a symbolic framework through which personal experiences of origin and loss are interpreted. This symbolic meaning becomes particularly significant when connected to the personal experience of the character Participant 1, who undergoes the loss of a father figure as the foundation of his existence. The interrelation between ritual symbolism and personal experience suggests that loss is not solely an individual emotional condition but is mediated through cultural symbolic systems. This is reflected in Participant 1’s statement that he felt “lost since his father’s passing,” indicating that the experience of loss is not only emotional but also existential in nature. In this context, the earth as a symbol of origin does not merely signify the beginning of life but also embodies notions of separation and human limitation. Furthermore, these findings demonstrate that the experience of loss within personal narratives can be understood as part of a broader structure of meaning embedded in cultural practices. The Tabuik ritual provides a symbolic framework that enables individuals like Participant 1 to interpret loss as part of the cycle of life, rather than as a fragmented or isolated experience. Thus, personal experience does not stand alone but is interconnected with collective narratives transmitted through cultural traditions. Within the process of documentation, these symbolic meanings undergo transformation through the construction of visual narratives. The Maambiak Tanah procession is not only documented as a ritual event but is also represented as a metaphor for Participant 1’s experience of loss. This narrative choice demonstrates that documentation is not neutral; rather, it actively shapes the relationship between collective memory and individual experience. Thus, the relationship between origin and loss emerges as a thematic foundation that reveals the intersection of ritual, personal experience, and visual representation. These findings affirm that cultural documentation does not merely record cultural practices but also contributes to constructing an existential understanding of life, loss, and meaning within contemporary society. Silenced grief in adolescent experience Participant 2’s narrative provides an illustrative case of how grief may be experienced privately and articulated indirectly rather than through explicit public emotional expression. Participant 2 stated that he had “never truly been able to accept the loss,” suggesting an unresolved experience that remained largely internal. This account is interpreted not as evidence that all adolescents experience grief in the same way, but as a situated narrative demonstrating how personal loss may be negotiated through silence, withdrawal, and private reflection. In this context, the grief experienced by Participant 2 and other adolescents is not solely individual but is also shaped by social and cultural norms that regulate how emotions are expressed. Consequently, grief does not emerge as a shared collective experience but rather as a personal experience that is endured silently. Furthermore, the findings indicate that private spaces such as bedrooms, beaches, and other personal environments become significant sites for the expression of grief. Within these spaces, individuals like Participant 2 have the freedom to reflect on their experiences of loss without social pressure. This suggests that grief does not disappear but instead transforms into a more reflective and introspective experience. In the process of documentation, this silenced grief is not represented in a dramatic manner but through subtle visual approaches and contemplative narrative structures. The decision to avoid explicit emotional displays becomes a representational strategy that reinforces the understanding of grief as a complex experience that cannot always be directly expressed. Thus, documentation does not merely capture grief but actively shapes how it is interpreted by the audience. These findings affirm that grief in adolescence is not merely an emotional response to loss but constitutes a social and cultural experience shaped by norms, spatial contexts, and representational processes. Therefore, silenced grief can be understood as an alternative form of expression that reflects the interplay between individual experience, social structures, and practices of cultural documentation. Intergenerational expectations and identity negotiation Participant 3’s narrative illustrates of this study indicate that adolescent life in this context is closely shaped by intergenerational expectations, particularly those originating from parents and the surrounding social environment. These expectations are associated with educational choices, career paths, and life trajectories considered ideal. In many cases, adolescents are confronted with pressures to follow predetermined paths that do not necessarily align with their personal interests or aspirations. This is reflected in the experience of the character Participant 3, who states that she feels “obliged to follow choices that have already been determined, even though they are not what I want,” revealing a tension between individual agency and familial expectations. In this context, adolescent identity is not formed autonomously but emerges through a process of negotiation between personal desires and the social structures that shape them. The pressure to fulfill family expectations can be understood as part of a social mechanism through which values, norms, and aspirations are transmitted across generations. This conflict is also evident in other characters who experience uncertainty in making life decisions, positioned between personal aspirations and strong familial demands. These findings become increasingly significant when connected to the cultural practice of Tabuik, which also involves the intergenerational transmission of values and roles. The involvement of traditional leaders (Tuo Tabuik) in preserving and continuing the ritual reflects how culture is sustained through robust social structures. In this regard, a parallel can be drawn between the transmission of cultural values within the Tabuik ritual and the transmission of expectations in adolescent life, both of which require the continuity of values across generations. In the process of documentation, the tension between expectations and identity is represented through narratives that implicitly depict the characters’ internal conflicts. Rather than presenting explicit resistance, the representation emphasizes reflection and meaning-making processes undertaken by the characters. This demonstrates that documentation is not merely a neutral recording of social reality but actively constructs narratives about how individuals negotiate their identities within the context of social and cultural pressures. Thus, these findings affirm that intergenerational expectations constitute a significant factor in shaping adolescent experiences and identities. The process of identity negotiation occurs not only at the individual level but is also embedded within broader social structures and cultural practices. Therefore, cultural documentation functions as a medium that not only represents these tensions but also reveals the dynamic relationship between individuals, families, and culture within contemporary society. Responsibility as an embodied practice in ritual and everyday life The narrative of Participant 3 also provides an illustrative case of responsibility, within this context, is not merely understood as a normative concept but as a practice enacted through the body and everyday activities. In the Tabuik tradition, responsibility is manifested through the physical engagement of community members, including the construction of the Tabuik, collective labor, and participation in ritual processes. In this sense, responsibility functions not only as a social obligation but also as a lived cultural practice transmitted across generations. This dimension of responsibility as an embodied practice is also reflected in adolescent life, particularly in the experience of Participant 3, who actively contributes to the family economy through trading activities. Participant 3 expresses that he “must continue to carry out his responsibilities, even when circumstances are not always easy,” indicating that responsibility is not merely a matter of choice but an integral part of self-formation and maturation. In this context, responsibility emerges as a concrete experience enacted through action rather than as an abstract value. The relationship between ritual practice and everyday life reveals a parallel between responsibility in cultural contexts and responsibility in personal life. While in the Tabuik ritual responsibility is realized through collective labor and devotion to tradition, in adolescent life it takes the form of effort, work, and personal sacrifice. Thus, responsibility can be understood as a practice that connects individuals to their communities while bridging the present with cultural heritage. In the process of documentation, this dimension of responsibility is represented through visualizations that emphasize movement, labor, and bodily engagement. Such representations do not merely present final outcomes but also foreground the processes and dynamics involved. This demonstrates that documentation plays an active role in presenting responsibility as an embodied practice one that is physically experienced and enacted rather than merely symbolically represented. These findings affirm that responsibility operates as a practice that connects ritual, everyday life, and processes of cultural representation. Responsibility is not only transmitted as a value but is enacted through concrete actions that shape both individual and collective experiences. Therefore, cultural documentation does not merely record these practices but also reveals how responsibility is lived as part of cultural continuity in contemporary society. Discussion This study argues that the documentation of intangible cultural heritage should not be understood as a neutral act of representation, but as a cultural practice that actively constructs meaning through processes of selection, interpretation, and visual narration. This perspective aligns with previous scholarship that positions heritage as something continuously produced through social practices and representational frameworks ( Harrison, 2013; Smith, 2006). In the context of the Tabuik tradition, documentation does not merely record ritual sequences as cultural events, but operates as a site of meaning-making that connects ritual symbolism with subjective experiences such as loss, identity, and responsibility. In this sense, documentation functions as a mediating practice that bridges collective memory and personal experience in contemporary society ( Hall, 1997). Furthermore, the findings support the conceptualization of intangible cultural heritage as a dynamic and continuously recreated process, as emphasized in the UNESCO Convention ( UNESCO, 2003). Rather than serving solely as a preservation tool, documentation becomes part of the ongoing reconstruction of cultural meaning. This aligns with the view that heritage depends on evolving social practices and interpretations ( Kurin, 2004). Thus, the documentation of Tabuik can be understood as an act of cultural actualization, where ritual meanings are not only maintained but also rearticulated through visual and narrative forms. From a representation perspective, meaning is not inherent but produced through representational practices ( Hall, 1997). The documentation of Tabuik therefore cannot be treated as an objective reflection of cultural reality, but as an interpretive process shaped by narrative decisions, visual framing, and contextual positioning. The selection of scenes and the construction of narrative structures demonstrate that documentation actively shapes how culture is understood rather than simply presenting it. Importantly, the findings also reveal that cultural representation is not static but open to continuous reinterpretation. The Tabuik ritual, traditionally rooted in religious and historical meanings, undergoes a shift when represented through visual narratives that connect it to contemporary youth experiences. This indicates that documentation does not merely reproduce existing meanings but generates new interpretive possibilities relevant to present social contexts. The themes of silenced grief, identity negotiation, and responsibility as embodied practice further demonstrate that individual experiences are inseparable from broader social and cultural structures. Experiences such as loss, familial expectations, and responsibility are shaped through complex social relations ( Giddens, 1991; Hall, 1996). In this study, grief is internalized rather than publicly expressed, reflecting social norms governing emotional expression, while intergenerational expectations reveal identity as a negotiated process rather than an autonomous formation. Meanwhile, responsibility emerges not only as a symbolic value but as an embodied practice enacted in everyday life. This study contributes conceptually by repositioning cultural documentation as an epistemological practice rather than a passive archival process. Unlike conventional approaches that treat documentation as a recording tool, this research demonstrates that documentation actively constructs relationships between ritual, personal experience, and social meaning through visual narratives. It also extends intangible cultural heritage studies by integrating autoethnographic and visual documentation perspectives, offering a more reflexive understanding of how subjectivity shapes cultural representation. Finally, these findings have important implications for heritage studies and documentary practices. An interpretive approach to documentation enables cultural heritage to remain dynamic and meaningful across generations, rather than fixed and static ( UNESCO, 2003). Moreover, documentation can be understood as a dialogical space that connects tradition and modernity, collective memory and individual experience. This suggests that reflexive and context-sensitive documentation practices are essential for sustaining intangible cultural heritage in increasingly complex contemporary societies. Conclusion This study argues that the documentation of intangible cultural heritage cannot be understood as a neutral process, but rather as a cultural practice that actively constructs meaning through visual representation and narrative. In the context of the Tabuik tradition, documentation functions as a mediating space that connects ritual symbolism with personal experiences, including loss, identity, and responsibility in adolescent life. These findings demonstrate that cultural meaning is not statically inherited but continuously negotiated and reconstructed through documentation practices in contemporary society. The main contribution of this research lies in positioning cultural documentation as both an interpretative and epistemological practice that shapes how culture is understood and represented. By integrating autoethnographic perspectives with visual documentation, this study not only expands the field of intangible cultural heritage studies but also offers a more reflexive approach to understanding the relationship between ritual, individual experience, and the production of cultural meaning. More broadly, this study suggests that a reflective and context-sensitive approach to documentation can serve as a crucial strategy for sustaining intangible cultural heritage amid ongoing social change. Therefore, cultural documentation should not be viewed merely as a tool for preservation, but as a cultural practice that enables heritage to remain dynamic, relevant, and meaningful for present and future generations. AI Declaration statetment During the preparation of this manuscript, AI-assisted tools were used solely for language improvement, grammar checking, literature exploration, and reference support. All processes of data interpretation, analysis, argument development, and the originality of the work were conducted independently by the author. The author fully reviewed and verified all content and takes complete responsibility for the final version of the manuscript. No further comments. APPROVED Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? Partly If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? Not applicable Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? No source data required Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? Partly Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? Partly Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? No Reviewer Expertise: Heritage management, Museology, Records and Archives Management, Archaeology I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard. Summary: This autoethnographic study examines documentation of the Tabuik ritual (Pariaman, West Sumatra) as an interpretive, meaning-making practice rather than neutral recording, built around a documentary project ("Tabuik Manusia"). Thematic analysis yields four themes which are; origin/loss, silenced adolescent grief, intergenerational identity negotiation, and responsibility as embodied practice, each linking ritual symbolism to an individual's personal narrative. The theoretical framing (Hall's representation theory, Smith/Harrison on heritage as social construction) is well-integrated and the paper makes a genuine conceptual contribution to ICH documentation studies. Points that must be addressed: Clarify participant status and data provenance. State explicitly whether "Participant 1/2/3" and "Queen" are real research informants and clarify why naming is inconsistent (numbered vs. named). Specify whether quoted statements are verbatim interview data or dramatized/scripted documentary lines. This is the single most important fix as it determines whether the findings section is being presented as empirical or creative-interpretive work. Add methodological detail for replicability: number of participants, selection criteria, fieldwork duration, number of FGDs and their composition. Correct the Rahaman et al. (2019) citation; it does not support the claims it's attached to; replace with an appropriate heritage/digital-documentation source. It is a likely hallucinated/mis attached citation which requires correction before indexing can be considered sound. Broaden the evidentiary base per theme or explicitly frame the findings as illustrative case vignettes rather than generalized patterns, to better match the single-quote-per-theme structure. Clean up editing artifacts: "(Giaccardi, 2012)vv" (×2) and "(Ellis et al., 2011) Ellis." Add a Limitations section addressing the small/unclear sample and the researcher's dual role as both documentarian and analyst. Clarify participant status and data provenance. State explicitly whether "Participant 1/2/3" and "Queen" are real research informants and clarify why naming is inconsistent (numbered vs. named). Specify whether quoted statements are verbatim interview data or dramatized/scripted documentary lines. This is the single most important fix as it determines whether the findings section is being presented as empirical or creative-interpretive work. Clarify participant status and data provenance. State explicitly whether "Participant 1/2/3" and "Queen" are real research informants and clarify why naming is inconsistent (numbered vs. named). Specify whether quoted statements are verbatim interview data or dramatized/scripted documentary lines. This is the single most important fix as it determines whether the findings section is being presented as empirical or creative-interpretive work. Add methodological detail for replicability: number of participants, selection criteria, fieldwork duration, number of FGDs and their composition. Add methodological detail for replicability: number of participants, selection criteria, fieldwork duration, number of FGDs and their composition. Correct the Rahaman et al. (2019) citation; it does not support the claims it's attached to; replace with an appropriate heritage/digital-documentation source. It is a likely hallucinated/mis attached citation which requires correction before indexing can be considered sound. Correct the Rahaman et al. (2019) citation; it does not support the claims it's attached to; replace with an appropriate heritage/digital-documentation source. It is a likely hallucinated/mis attached citation which requires correction before indexing can be considered sound. Broaden the evidentiary base per theme or explicitly frame the findings as illustrative case vignettes rather than generalized patterns, to better match the single-quote-per-theme structure. Broaden the evidentiary base per theme or explicitly frame the findings as illustrative case vignettes rather than generalized patterns, to better match the single-quote-per-theme structure. Clean up editing artifacts: "(Giaccardi, 2012)vv" (×2) and "(Ellis et al., 2011) Ellis." Clean up editing artifacts: "(Giaccardi, 2012)vv" (×2) and "(Ellis et al., 2011) Ellis." Add a Limitations section addressing the small/unclear sample and the researcher's dual role as both documentarian and analyst. Add a Limitations section addressing the small/unclear sample and the researcher's dual role as both documentarian and analyst. Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? Partly If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? Not applicable Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? No source data required Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? Partly Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? Partly Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? No Reviewer Expertise: Heritage management, Museology, Records and Archives Management, Archaeology I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard, however I have significant reservations, as outlined above. Response to Reviewer We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful and constructive comments. We have thoroughly revised the manuscript in response to all of the points raised. The revisions have particularly clarified the participant status and data provenance, strengthened the methodological description, corrected the citation issue, reframed the findings as illustrative narrative cases rather than generalized patterns, removed the identified editing artifacts, and added a limitations section addressing the scope of the study and the researcher’s dual role. Our detailed responses are provided below. Comment 1. Clarify participant status and data provenance. Reviewer comment: State explicitly whether “Participant 1/2/3” and “Queen” are real research informants and clarify why naming is inconsistent (numbered vs. named). Specify whether quoted statements are verbatim interview data or dramatized/scripted documentary lines. This is the single most important fix as it determines whether the findings section is being presented as empirical or creative-interpretive work. Response: Thank you for highlighting this important issue. We have clarified the status and provenance of the participants and the narrative data in the revised manuscript. The study involved 36 individuals as sources of research data, consisting of 30 senior high school students who participated in FGDs and six tradition bearers/practitioners. Nine of the 30 student participants were subsequently selected for thematic coding because their personal narratives were sufficiently detailed and relevant to the documentary themes. These nine students are a subset of the 30 FGD participants and are not an additional participant group. We have also clarified that “Participant 1,” “Participant 2,” and “Participant 3” refer to anonymized student participants whose personal narratives were used as illustrative cases in the findings. The use of numbered labels is intended to protect participant confidentiality and maintain consistency with the ethical procedures described in the methodology. We have further clarified that the findings are not intended to present these narratives as generalized representations of all adolescents or Tabuik participants. The quoted statements in the findings are derived from participants’ personal narratives and are presented as part of the qualitative interpretation of their experiences. At the same time, we have clarified the distinction between participants’ narrative accounts and the subsequent documentary construction. The documentary storyline represents an interpretive and creative transformation of the field data rather than a claim that every narrative element appearing in the documentary is a verbatim statement from participants. These clarifications have been incorporated into the Methodology and Findings sections. The revised methodology now explicitly describes the participant structure, selection process, anonymization, and the role of the documentary storyline in the analytical process. Comment 2. Add methodological detail for replicability. Reviewer comment: Provide the number of participants, selection criteria, fieldwork duration, number of FGDs, and their composition. Response: We appreciate this suggestion and have substantially expanded the Methodology section. The revised manuscript now specifies that the study involved 36 participants, comprising 30 senior high school students participating in FGDs and six tradition bearers/practitioners. The six tradition bearers consisted of two Tuo Tabuik, one Maambiak Tanah diver, one elder woman involved in the tradition, one gandang tasa practitioner, and one ninik mamak. We have also clarified the selection criteria. Participants were purposively selected based on their direct involvement in, familiarity with, or cultural expertise regarding the Tabuik ritual. The revised manuscript further explains that nine students were selected from the 30 FGD participants for thematic coding because their personal narratives provided sufficiently detailed and relevant accounts for the development of the documentary themes. In addition, Tables 1–3 have been added/revised to provide greater transparency regarding participant composition, demographic characteristics, school affiliation, and the analytical structure of the participant group. We also clarify the approximate duration of participant interactions, which was 20–30 minutes, and distinguish the student narrative subset from the broader FGD group. Comment 3. Correct the Rahaman et al. (2019) citation. Reviewer comment: The citation does not support the claims to which it is attached. Replace it with an appropriate heritage/digital-documentation source. Response: Thank you for identifying this citation problem. We have reviewed the relevant discussion and corrected the citation. The unsupported/mis attached citation has been removed from the relevant argument and replaced with references that more directly support the discussion of visual representation, digital heritage, and cultural documentation. The revised literature review now relies on more appropriate sources, including Ioannides et al. (2021), Bekele et al. (2021), Zabulis et al. (2021), and other relevant heritage and visual-culture scholarship. We have also carefully checked the references and in-text citations throughout the manuscript to reduce the possibility of citation misalignment. Comment 4. Broaden the evidentiary base per theme or explicitly frame the findings as illustrative case vignettes. Reviewer comment: The findings should either be supported by a broader evidentiary base or explicitly framed as illustrative case vignettes rather than generalized patterns. Response: We agree with the reviewer’s concern and have revised the framing of the Findings section accordingly. Rather than presenting the four themes as generalized patterns applicable to all participants, we now explicitly identify them as illustrative narrative cases developed through thematic analysis of nine student narratives selected from the broader group of 30 FGD participants. A clarification has been added at the beginning of the Findings section stating that the four themes are interpreted as illustrative narrative cases rather than generalized patterns across all participants. Each vignette is therefore intended to foreground a particular relationship between an individual experience, the symbolic structure of the Tabuik ritual, and the documentary choices through which these elements were connected. We have also revised the language within individual findings to avoid overgeneralization. For example, the discussion of Participant 2 explicitly states that the account should not be interpreted as evidence that all adolescents' experience grief in the same way, but rather as a situated narrative demonstrating how personal loss may be negotiated through silence, withdrawal, and private reflection. This revised framing is consistent with the study’s qualitative autoethnographic and interpretive orientation and better reflects the evidentiary scope of the data. Comment 5. Clean up editing artifacts. Reviewer comment: Remove “(Giaccardi, 2012)vv” (×2) and “(Ellis et al., 2011) Ellis.” Response: Thank you for pointing out these editorial errors. We have carefully proofread the manuscript and removed the identified editing artifacts, including the duplicated “vv” following the Giaccardi (2012) citation and the erroneous duplication associated with Ellis et al. (2011). The relevant citations and surrounding sentences have also been checked for consistency and grammatical accuracy. Comment 6. Add a Limitations section. Reviewer comment: Add a Limitations section addressing the small/unclear sample and the researcher’s dual role as both documentarian and analyst. Response: We agree with the reviewer and have added a dedicated Limitations section to explicitly acknowledge the scope and methodological limitations of the study. The revised section clarifies that the study is interpretive and case-oriented, and therefore does not seek statistical or broad empirical generalization. It also acknowledges the researcher’s dual role as documentarian and analyst within the autoethnographic framework. In particular, the limitations section explains that the interpretation of participants’ narratives and the transformation of those narratives into documentary forms are inevitably influenced by the researcher’s positionality, selection of scenes, narrative framing, and representational decisions. We acknowledge that this dual role may introduce interpretive subjectivity, although reflexivity and source triangulation were employed to strengthen the credibility of the analysis. The revised Limitations section also clarifies that the nine student narratives used for thematic coding represent a selected subset of the broader participant group and should therefore be understood as illustrative rather than representative of all adolescents or Tabuik practitioners. We believe that these revisions provide a clearer alignment between the study’s methodological design, evidentiary scope, and interpretive claims. We sincerely appreciate the reviewer’s detailed comments, which have helped us improve the methodological transparency, evidentiary framing, and overall clarity of the manuscript. We believe that the revised manuscript now more clearly distinguishes empirical participant narratives from documentary interpretation and appropriately positions the findings as illustrative cases within an autoethnographic and interpretive framework. We hope that the revisions adequately address the reviewer’s concerns and improve the manuscript’s suitability for further consideration. This manuscript is well structured, clearly written, and addresses an important issue in the field of intangible cultural heritage. The study makes a meaningful contribution by moving beyond the conventional perspective of cultural documentation as merely a preservation tool and instead conceptualizing documentation as an epistemological and representational practice that actively constructs cultural meaning. This perspective provides an original theoretical contribution to the literature on intangible cultural heritage, cultural representation, and memory studies. The integration of an autoethnographic approach with thematic analysis is appropriate for addressing the research objectives and offers rich insights into how the Tabuik tradition is interpreted, negotiated, and communicated through documentary media. The identification of the four thematic dimensions strengthens the analytical depth of the study and demonstrates the complex relationship between ritual, identity, collective memory, and contemporary cultural experience. Overall, this article has the potential to make a significant contribution to the development of theory and scholarship in cultural heritage studies, visual anthropology, cultural documentation, and related interdisciplinary fields. The manuscript is scientifically sound, methodologically appropriate, and suitable for publication. I therefore recommend Approved. Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature? Yes If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate? Yes Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility? No source data required Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound? Yes Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results? Yes Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others? Yes Reviewer Expertise: culture, linguistics, gender studies, and toponymy. My review was conducted primarily from these disciplinary perspectives. I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard.