Protocol for controlled gas-phase oxygen In-leakage in anaerobic bioreactors Authors: Shota Shimokawara, Toshinari Maeda Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Trace oxygen may enter the gas supply line of an anaerobic bioreactor and affect reactor operation. In this study, we describe a method to expose a defined oxygen concentration for gas-fed anaerobic bioreactors. H2, CO2 and premixed CO2/O2 gas were supplied using mass flow controllers, and the reactor inlet O2 concentration was adjusted from 0 to 10,000 ppm. Both stepwise and constant exposure tests were carried out. The reactor outlet O2 concentration was measured by gas chromatography to confirm the actual exposure condition in bioreactors.Because oxygen exposure is defined at the reactor inlet, stable exposure conditions can be applied regardless of oxygen consumption within the reactor.This protocol provides an approach for investigating trace oxygen responses in continuously operated anaerobic microbial cultures.•Defined inlet O2 concentrations can be generated by gas blending using mass flow controllers.•Oxygen exposure conditions can be monitored by outlet gas chromatography.•This method can be applied to stepwise and continuous oxygen exposure experiments. Subject areaEnvironmental ScienceMore specific subject areaAnaerobic cultivation, Gas fermentation, oxygen exposureName of your protocolControlled Gas-Phase Oxygen In-leakage in Anaerobic BioreactorsReagents/toolsCO2 cylinder (≥99.999 % (v/v))H2 cylinder (≥99.99 % (v/v))CO2/O2 premixed cylinder (O2: 100–50,000 ppm(v/v) in CO2)Mass flow controllers (H2: 0–50 mL/min, CO2: 0–20 mL/min, premix: 0–20 mL/min, control range: 2–100 % of full scale, accuracy: ±1.0 % of full scale)Gas chromatograph (GC-990, GL Sciences, Japan) configured with two analytical channels:Channel 1: Molecular Sieve 5A column (10 m × 0.25 mm × 30 μm) with Ar as the carrier gas, used for H2, O2, CH4 analysis.Channel 2: PORAPLOT Q column (10 m × 0.25 mm × 8 μm) with He as the carrier gas, used for CO2 analysis.Thermal conductivity detector (TCD).ORP electrode (Redox Fermprobe S8, Broadley James, USA)1000 mL Anaerobic bioreactor (BMZ02KP4, Biot, Japan)Soap film flowmeter (SF-1 U with Glass volume piping unit VP-1 U (0.2–10 mL/min), VP-2 U (2–100 mL/min), HORIBA, Japan)6.35 mm SUS 316 L Tubing (OD: 6.35 mm, wall: 1.0 mm, ID: 4.35 mm)3.18 mm SUS 316 L Tubing (OD: 3.18 mm, wall: 0.5 mm, ID: 2.18 mm)Experimental designMethanothermobacter thermautotrophicus DSM3590 was cultivated in a 1000 mL anaerobic jar fermenter at 60 °C, 600 rpm, and pH 7.0 according to the method of Martin et al. [1]. Oxygen exposure tests were conducted on a reactor that stabilized following 30 days of cultivation in pure H2 and CO2.Quantitative oxygen exposure tests were conducted by gradually introducing a known concentration CO2/O2 premixed gas into a CO2/H2 culture system using mass flow controllers.The response of microorganisms to oxygen exposure was measured as the methane production rate at the outlet of the reactor. Outlet gas composition and flow rate were quantified by gas chromatography and soap-film flowmeter. ORP was analyzed as a supplementary indicator of oxygen exposure.Trial registrationNot applicableEthicsNot applicableValue of the Protocol●It is possible to test the effects of short-term and long-term oxygen exposure on microorganisms.●Stable oxygen exposure conditions were provided for anaerobic bioreactors.●Oxygen exposure can be evaluated without being affected by oxygen consumption in the bioreactor. Subject areaEnvironmental ScienceMore specific subject areaAnaerobic cultivation, Gas fermentation, oxygen exposureName of your protocolControlled Gas-Phase Oxygen In-leakage in Anaerobic BioreactorsReagents/toolsCO2 cylinder (≥99.999 % (v/v))H2 cylinder (≥99.99 % (v/v))CO2/O2 premixed cylinder (O2: 100–50,000 ppm(v/v) in CO2)Mass flow controllers (H2: 0–50 mL/min, CO2: 0–20 mL/min, premix: 0–20 mL/min, control range: 2–100 % of full scale, accuracy: ±1.0 % of full scale)Gas chromatograph (GC-990, GL Sciences, Japan) configured with two analytical channels:Channel 1: Molecular Sieve 5A column (10 m × 0.25 mm × 30 μm) with Ar as the carrier gas, used for H2, O2, CH4 analysis.Channel 2: PORAPLOT Q column (10 m × 0.25 mm × 8 μm) with He as the carrier gas, used for CO2 analysis.Thermal conductivity detector (TCD).ORP electrode (Redox Fermprobe S8, Broadley James, USA)1000 mL Anaerobic bioreactor (BMZ02KP4, Biot, Japan)Soap film flowmeter (SF-1 U with Glass volume piping unit VP-1 U (0.2–10 mL/min), VP-2 U (2–100 mL/min), HORIBA, Japan)6.35 mm SUS 316 L Tubing (OD: 6.35 mm, wall: 1.0 mm, ID: 4.35 mm)3.18 mm SUS 316 L Tubing (OD: 3.18 mm, wall: 0.5 mm, ID: 2.18 mm)Experimental designMethanothermobacter thermautotrophicus DSM3590 was cultivated in a 1000 mL anaerobic jar fermenter at 60 °C, 600 rpm, and pH 7.0 according to the method of Martin et al. [1]. Oxygen exposure tests were conducted on a reactor that stabilized following 30 days of cultivation in pure H2 and CO2.Quantitative oxygen exposure tests were conducted by gradually introducing a known concentration CO2/O2 premixed gas into a CO2/H2 culture system using mass flow controllers.The response of microorganisms to oxygen exposure was measured as the methane production rate at the outlet of the reactor. Outlet gas composition and flow rate were quantified by gas chromatography and soap-film flowmeter. ORP was analyzed as a supplementary indicator of oxygen exposure.Trial registrationNot applicableEthicsNot applicableValue of the Protocol●It is possible to test the effects of short-term and long-term oxygen exposure on microorganisms.●Stable oxygen exposure conditions were provided for anaerobic bioreactors.●Oxygen exposure can be evaluated without being affected by oxygen consumption in the bioreactor. ●It is possible to test the effects of short-term and long-term oxygen exposure on microorganisms. It is possible to test the effects of short-term and long-term oxygen exposure on microorganisms. ●Stable oxygen exposure conditions were provided for anaerobic bioreactors. Stable oxygen exposure conditions were provided for anaerobic bioreactors. ●Oxygen exposure can be evaluated without being affected by oxygen consumption in the bioreactor. Oxygen exposure can be evaluated without being affected by oxygen consumption in the bioreactor. Background Batch culture experiments have been widely used to investigate oxygen exposure in anaerobic microorganisms [[2], [3], [4], [5]]. However, batch experiments are not sufficient for evaluating oxygen exposure events in continuously operated anaerobic bioreactors. Anaerobic bioreactors, particularly those operated over long periods, are likely to be exposed to continuous oxygen in-leakage. In batch culture tests, oxygen in the gas-phase is rapidly consumed by microorganisms. Consequently, it is difficult to establish a test environment where the system is constantly exposed to a fixed amount of oxygen. It is possible to reduce the impact of oxygen consumption by periodically replacing the gas phase. However, because the oxygen consumption rate of methanogens is relatively high, this can be significantly burdened in practical experiments. Although continuous oxygen exposure tests have recently been reported, reports are still limited [6]. Therefore, a method is needed that allows oxygen exposure to be defined under controlled conditions [7]. This protocol resolves these experimental challenges by continuously supplying a controlled amount of oxygen to anaerobic reactors. This could be a practical approach for evaluating microbial responses from controlled oxygen exposure. And it can be used for simulating oxygen in-leakage events in continuously operated anaerobic bioreactors. Description of protocol Purpose This protocol is intended for continuously operating anaerobic gas-fed bioreactors, for example, bio methanation using H2 and CO2 as gaseous substrates. The protocol should be initiated only after stable condition of the bioreactor has been established. Oxygen exposure is achieved by introducing a premixed CO2/O2 gas into the H2/CO2 feed gas. Experimental setup A simplified schematic diagram of the experimental setup is shown in Fig. 1. Experimental setup consists of an anaerobic bioreactor, gas supply lines, and gas analysis equipment.Fig. 1Schematic diagram of the experimental setup for controlled oxygen exposure in an anaerobic bioreactor.Fig 1 dummy alt text Schematic diagram of the experimental setup for controlled oxygen exposure in an anaerobic bioreactor. The bioreactor was operated under the conditions listed in Table 1. The reactor outlet gas was directed to the gas analyzer for measurement of CH4 and CO2 concentrations. Oxidation reduction potential (ORP) is recorded using an ORP electrode (Redox Fermprobe S8, Broadley James, USA). In this condition, bioreactor has been operated for 30 days until methane concentration and methane production rate at the reactor outlet reached stable values. Oxygen exposure experiments were initiated only after stable reactor performance had been confirmed.Table 1Bioreactor operating conditions.Table 1 dummy alt textParameterValueMicroorganismMethanothermobacter thermautotrophicus DSM3590(Leibniz Institute DSMZ, Braunschweig, Germany)Reactor typeStirred anaerobic bioreactor (BMZ02KP4, Biot, Japan)Total Reactor volume1000 mLWorking volume700 mLCultivation Temperature60 °CpH7.0Agitation speed600 rpmH2 flow rate40 mL/minCO2 flow rate10 mL/min Table 1Bioreactor operating conditions.Table 1 dummy alt textParameterValueMicroorganismMethanothermobacter thermautotrophicus DSM3590(Leibniz Institute DSMZ, Braunschweig, Germany)Reactor typeStirred anaerobic bioreactor (BMZ02KP4, Biot, Japan)Total Reactor volume1000 mLWorking volume700 mLCultivation Temperature60 °CpH7.0Agitation speed600 rpmH2 flow rate40 mL/minCO2 flow rate10 mL/min Bioreactor operating conditions. H2, CO2, and CO2/O2 premixed gas were supplied through mass flow controllers. The CO2/O2 premixed gas was used as an oxygen source, and inlet O2 concentrations were defined by adjusting the flow rates of CO2 and CO2/O2 gases. The gas supply lines were constructed from SUS316L tubing. The CO2/O2 premixed gas line was calibrated using a soap film flowmeter (SF-1 U, HORIBA, Japan) equipped with glass volume piping units (VP-1 U, HORIBA, Japan). Outlet gas composition was analyzed using gas chromatograph (GC-990, GL Sciences, Japan). O2, CH4, and CO2 concentrations were measured. The outlet gas was cooled to 10 °C and dried using a micro-GC dehumidifier (GL Sciences, Japan) before GC analysis. The inlet O2 concentration was calculated from the corrected flow rate of the CO2/O2 premixed gas using the following equation:Cin,O2=CpremixFpremixFH2+FCO2+Fpremix Cin, O2 is the inlet O2 setpoint, Cpremix is the O2 concentration in the premixed gas, and FH2, FCO2, and Fpremix are the respective gas flow rates. The H2 flow rate was fixed at 40 mL/min. The combined flow rate of pure CO2 and the CO2/O2 premixed gas was maintained at 10mL/min. Experimental procedure The inlet O2 setpoint was adjusted by replacing a portion of the pure CO2 gas with a CO2/O2 premixed gas. The total CO2 flow rate was kept constant, and the H2 flow rate was also kept constant under all experimental conditions. Therefore, the total gas flow rate remained constant throughout the experiments. During the oxygen exposure experiments, outlet CH4 and O2 concentrations were measured at 15-min intervals by gas chromatography (GC). The ORP was continuously monitored throughout the experiments. The outlet gas flow rate was measured using a soap-film flow meter. The CH4 production rate was calculated from the outlet CH4 concentration and the outlet gas flow rate. Immediately after changing the inlet O2 setpoint, a time lag occurred before the outlet gas composition reached the new setpoint because of the residual gas remaining in the reactor and gas lines. Therefore, the first GC measurement after each setpoint change was excluded from the data analysis. CO2/O2 premixed gas containing 50,000 ppm O2 was used for the short-term oxygen exposure tests. At the start of the experiment, the CO2/O2 premixed gas was introduced while the pure CO2 flow rate was reduced by the same amount to supply the desired inlet O2 setpoint. The inlet O2 concentration increased stepwise from 0 to 10,000 ppm in eight setpoints. Each condition was maintained for 1 h. During each O2 exposure condition, the outlet CH4 and O2 concentrations were measured four times at 15-min intervals, and the outlet gas flow rate was measured once. After the 1 h exposure at the highest O2 concentration, the flow rate of CO2/O2 premixed gas was set to 0 mL/min, and the inlet O2 setpoint was returned to 0 ppm. The outlet CH4 and O2 concentrations were then monitored for 36 h to evaluate reactor recovery. For the long-term oxygen exposure tests, a CO2/O2 premixed gas containing 10,000 ppm O2 was used. The inlet O2 concentration was set to 600, 1000, 1200 ppm, and each condition was maintained for 48 h. During the exposure period, the outlet CH4 and O2 concentrations and the ORP were monitored, and the outlet gas flow rate was measured at three representative times for each condition. The concentrations were applied sequentially in the order of 600, 1000, 1200 ppm. Even when CH4 was no longer detected in the GC during oxygen exposure, the inlet O2 concentration was maintained until the end of the 48-h exposure test, and the ORP and outlet gas composition continued to be monitored. Protocol validation Fig. 2 shows a representative result of the short-term oxygen exposure test using a 50,000 ppm O2/CO2 premixed gas. The inlet O2 setpoint was changed every 1 h, and the outlet O2 concentration followed each setpoint. Because oxygen was consumed within the reactor, the outlet O2 concentration remained lower than the inlet O2 setpoint. Except for the first measurement obtained 15 min after each setpoint change, the outlet O2 concentration reached a stable value for each inlet O2 setpoint. These results demonstrate that the protocol provided stable oxygen exposure conditions.Fig. 2Representative result of the short-term oxygen exposure protocol. Showing the inlet O2 setpoints and outlet O2 concentrations.Fig 2 dummy alt text Representative result of the short-term oxygen exposure protocol. Showing the inlet O2 setpoints and outlet O2 concentrations. Fig. 3(a) and 3(b) show results of the short-term oxygen exposure test. As the inlet O2 concentration was increased stepwise from 0 to 10,000 ppm, methane production decreased to 0 mL/min, while the ORP increased from −510 mV to −237 mV. After the inlet O2 setpoint was returned to 0 ppm following exposure to 10,000 ppm O2, methane production and ORP gradually recovered during the subsequent 36-h monitoring.Fig. 3Result of the short-term oxygen exposure test.Methane production rate during stepwise oxygen exposure and reactor recovery.Oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) during stepwise oxygen exposure and reactor recovery.Fig 3 dummy alt text Result of the short-term oxygen exposure test. Methane production rate during stepwise oxygen exposure and reactor recovery. Oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) during stepwise oxygen exposure and reactor recovery. Fig. 4(a), 4(b), and 4(c) show results of the long-term oxygen exposure test at inlet O2 concentrations of 600, 1000, 1200 ppm. At an inlet O2 concentration of 1000 ppm, methane production gradually decreased during the 48-h exposure period. At 1200 ppm, methane production decreased to 0 mL/min after approximately 24 h and remained undetectable until the end of the test period. These results demonstrate that the long-term oxygen exposure protocol allows reactor performance to be monitored under continuous oxygen exposure for up to 48 h.Fig. 4Results of the long-term oxygen exposure tests.Methane production rate during continuous exposure to 600 ppm inlet O2.Methane production rate during continuous exposure to 1000 ppm inlet O2.Methane production rate during continuous exposure to 1200 ppm inlet O2.Fig 4 dummy alt text Results of the long-term oxygen exposure tests. Methane production rate during continuous exposure to 600 ppm inlet O2. Methane production rate during continuous exposure to 1000 ppm inlet O2. Methane production rate during continuous exposure to 1200 ppm inlet O2. Limitations In this study, the short-term oxygen exposure test was performed at oxygen concentration of up to 10,000 ppm. The long-term oxygen exposure test was conducted at concentrations of up to 1200 ppm. Because the oxygen concentration that affects methanogenic activity is expected to vary depending on the microbial species and reactor operating conditions, preliminary oxygen exposure tests should be performed for each experimental system to determine an appropriate oxygen concentration range for evaluation. CRediT author statement Shota Shimokawara: Conceptualization, Methodology, Investigation, Validation, Formal analysis, Data curation, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing, Project administration. Toshinari Maeda: Supervision, Writing – review & editing. Supplementary material and/or additional information [OPTIONAL] None. Related research article None. Declaration of competing interest The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.