Is infraocclusion always caused by ankylosis? Current perspectives on primary molar ankylosis: A systematic review Authors: Masatoshi Otsugu, Hamada Masakazu, Fumikazu Tojo, Kazuhiko Nakano Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Ankylosed primary molars are relatively common during the mixed dentition period; however, ankylosis does not always coincide with infraocclusion. This systematic review assessed the clinical evidence regarding ankylosis of primary molars, including its etiology, diagnosis, and management, and discussed whether infraocclusion is primarily caused by ankylosis or instead reflects a broader disturbance of tooth eruption. A literature search was conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines across three databases (PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science) on 25 April 2025 and updated on 3 July 2026. The risk of bias and methodological quality of the included studies were assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute critical appraisal tools. Fourteen studies met the inclusion criteria. The person-level prevalence of infraoccluded primary molars, used as a surrogate for ankylosis, ranged from 1.3% to 24.8%. Histopathological and clinical studies indicated that not all infraoccluded primary molars exhibited evidence of ankylosis. Treatment strategies varied according to the severity of infraocclusion and the presence or absence of permanent successors. The available evidence remains limited and insufficient to determine the temporal and causal relationship between ankylosis and infraocclusion. Further epidemiological, histopathological, and treatment-related studies are needed. Introduction Dental ankylosis is defined as an eruptive abnormality characterized by the direct fusion of cementum to alveolar bone [1], [2]. As root resorption progresses, the cementum may be resorbed and replaced by alveolar bone, resulting in direct continuity between bone and dentin, a characteristic feature of replacement resorption [1], [2]. It prevents normal development and eruption of the involved tooth and, consequently, the supporting alveolar bone growth [3]. An ankylosed tooth remains static despite continued eruption of the adjacent teeth, resulting in infraocclusion [4]. Although permanent teeth are rarely affected by ankylosis, ankylosed primary molars are relatively common during the mixed dentition period [3], [5]. Infraocclusion of primary molars is a dental anomaly characterized by the affected tooth being positioned below the occlusal plane of the adjacent teeth [5]. Historically, infraocclusion has been regarded as a clinical manifestation primarily caused by ankylosis [6]. However, ankylosis is not always identified histopathologically following the extraction of infraoccluded teeth, and conversely, histologically confirmed ankylosis does not invariably lead to infraocclusion [7]. Moreover, once complete ankylosis is established, spontaneous correction of infraocclusion is unlikely, and the severity and progression of infraocclusion may also be influenced by multiple factors, including craniofacial growth [8], hypodontia [2], and genetic predisposition [5]. Therefore, the conventional concept equating infraocclusion with ankylosis may require reconsideration, and a more comprehensive understanding of the underlying pathophysiology is warranted. Comprehensive research on primary molar ankylosis remains limited [9]. Although case reports and small observational studies have described its diagnosis, clinical presentation, and natural course, systematic evaluations of clinical outcomes and management strategies remain scarce. Most previous studies have focused on epidemiology, patterns of infraocclusion, and effects on adjacent teeth and permanent successors, whereas evidence regarding treatment approaches remains limited. Therefore, this systematic review aimed to synthesize the available literature on ankylosis of primary molars, with particular emphasis on clinical evidence related to its etiology, diagnosis, and management. It also addresses the key question of whether infraocclusion is primarily caused by ankylosis or instead reflects a broader disturbance of tooth eruption. Materials and methods Protocol and registration This systematic review was reported in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA 2020) guidelines [10]. The review protocol was established by the authors before the literature search but was not prospectively registered or publicly available. A literature search was conducted across three electronic databases (PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science) on 25 April 2025 using the following search terms: “ankylosis” AND “primary tooth” and “ankylosis” AND “deciduous tooth”. The results from both search strategies were combined before duplicate removal. The literature search was updated on 3 July 2026 before resubmission using the same search strategy. This systematic review was not prospectively registered, and no prespecified protocol was publicly available. During manuscript revision, the eligibility criteria were clarified to better reflect the review question, and all potentially eligible studies were reassessed using the clarified criteria. Review question This systematic review aimed to synthesize the current evidence regarding primary molar ankylosis. To comprehensively address this objective, the review was structured into three predefined domains: (1) epidemiology, including the prevalence and diagnostic characteristics of primary molar ankylosis; (2) histopathology, including histopathological findings and the etiology of ankylosis; and (3) treatment and prognosis, including the natural history, clinical consequences, and effectiveness of treatment strategies. Based on these predefined domains, the literature search strategy and eligibility criteria were developed. Because the review question focused on primary molar ankylosis and its relationship with infraocclusion, the electronic search strategy was intentionally designed using ankylosis-related terminology rather than all infraocclusion-related terms. This approach was intended to identify evidence addressing ankylosis while allowing evaluation of its relationship with infraocclusion. Eligibility criteria The following inclusion criteria were used to select publications: studies published in English, studies involving ankylosis of primary molars, and studies that provided epidemiological, histological, or clinical follow-up data related to ankylosis of primary molars. The review was limited to English-language publications because English was the working language of the review team, allowing consistent screening and interpretation of the included studies. The following exclusion criteria were applied: reviews, comments, editorials, and case reports; studies for which references were not available; studies written in languages other than English; and studies not involving ankylosis of primary teeth. Observational studies, including cohort, cross-sectional, and case-series studies, were eligible. Case reports were excluded because the objective of the review was to synthesize evidence from observational studies with more representative populations. Case reports were considered only for hypothesis generation in the Discussion and were not included in the systematic synthesis. Titles, abstracts, and publication types were screened simultaneously before full-text assessment. Studies were eligible regardless of the participants’ age, provided that they investigated ankylosed primary molars. Histological studies involving retained primary teeth in adults were included because such studies provided unique histopathological evidence that could not be obtained from exfoliated primary teeth during childhood. The presence or absence of permanent successors was extracted when reported and considered during the interpretation of treatment outcomes. Studies involving children with craniofacial anomalies (e.g., cleft lip and/or palate) or syndromic conditions were excluded. When multiple publications were based on the same study population, the most comprehensive study relevant to the review question was included to avoid duplication of data. Reports for which the full text could not be obtained were excluded. Study selection One of the authors (M.H.) collected records from PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science and removed duplicates using EndNote 21 software (Clarivate Analytics, Toronto, Canada). A manual review was subsequently performed to remove additional duplicates not initially identified by the software. Two reviewers (M.O. and F.T.) then independently screened the titles and abstracts of the collected studies for relevance. The same reviewers (M.O. and F.T.) subsequently performed full-text screening of the studies included from the previous step. Disagreements between the reviewers were resolved through discussion. Data extraction and evidence synthesis Data extraction was independently performed by one reviewer (M.O.) using a standardized data extraction form developed for this review. The extracted data were subsequently checked by a second reviewer (F.T.), and discrepancies were resolved through discussion. The following items were extracted from all included studies: author and year of publication, country, study design, participants’ age, sample size, study objective, analysis methods, presence or absence of follow-up, and intervention type (if applicable). In addition, the following items were extracted from each predefined domain: ・Epidemiology domain: diagnostic criteria, prevalence, age at which infraocclusion was most frequently detected, common site, severity, number of affected teeth, and other findings. ・Histopathology domain: diagnostic criteria, prevalence of premolar agenesis, histological findings, and clinical findings. ・Treatment and prognosis domain: diagnostic criteria, duration of follow-up, intervention and prognosis, and additional findings. The extracted data were synthesized descriptively and organized according to the three predefined review domains (epidemiology, histopathology, and treatment/prognosis). Because of the substantial clinical and methodological heterogeneity among the included studies, including differences in study design, diagnostic criteria, study objectives, and reported outcomes, a formal meta-analysis was considered inappropriate. Therefore, the findings were synthesized narratively according to the three predefined review domains. Risk of bias and methodological quality The risk of bias and methodological quality of the included studies were assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) critical appraisal tools [11]. The appropriate JBI critical appraisal checklist (for prevalence studies, cross-sectional studies, case series, or cohort studies) was selected based on each included study’s design and primary objective before quality assessment. Each item was rated as “yes,” “no,” “unclear,” or “not applicable.” In accordance with JBI guidance [12], no overall quality score was calculated because the checklists are intended to support critical appraisal rather than generate summary scores. Methodological quality was independently assessed by two reviewers (M.O. and F.T.). Any disagreements were resolved through discussion until consensus was reached. Results Study selection The study selection process is summarized in Fig. 1. In total, 1147 records were identified through database searching, including 513 from PubMed, 463 from Scopus, and 171 from Web of Science. Of these, 682 records (308 from PubMed, 248 from Scopus, and 126 from Web of Science) were retrieved using the search term “ankylosis” AND “primary tooth,” whereas 465 records (205 from PubMed, 215 from Scopus, and 45 from Web of Science) were retrieved using “ankylosis” AND “deciduous tooth.” After duplicate removal, 411 records were screened by title, abstract, and article type, and 391 were excluded. Subsequently, 20 reports were assessed for eligibility through full-text review. Three reports could not be retrieved. Following full-text assessment, three reports were excluded for the following reasons: duplicate population (n = 1), craniofacial anomalies or syndromic population (n = 1), and non-English publication (n = 1). Finally, 14 studies met all inclusion and exclusion criteria and were included in the narrative synthesis.Fig. 1Records identified through database searching. (accessed on 25 April 2025 and updated on 3 July 2026). Searches were performed using the terms "ankylosis" AND "primary tooth" and "ankylosis" AND "deciduous tooth" in each database. The results from both search strategies were combined before duplicate removal. Records identified through database searching. (accessed on 25 April 2025 and updated on 3 July 2026). Searches were performed using the terms "ankylosis" AND "primary tooth" and "ankylosis" AND "deciduous tooth" in each database. The results from both search strategies were combined before duplicate removal. Characteristics of included studies The main characteristics of the 14 included studies [2], [3], [5], [6], [7], [8], [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] are summarized in Table 1. The studies were published between 1973 and 2026 and were conducted in the United Kingdom, the United States, Sweden, Israel, Italy, Saudi Arabia, Romania, and Turkey. Four studies were case series [2], [7], [16], [17], seven used a cross-sectional design [3], [5], [6], [13], [18], [19], [20], and three included a longitudinal observation component [8], [14], [15]. Participants ranged in age from 3 to 29 years, although the majority were children in the mixed dentition stage. Sample sizes ranged from 15 to 8452 participants. Larger sample sizes were observed in epidemiological cross-sectional studies, whereas longitudinal investigations generally included smaller cohorts. Regarding the clinical question categories, seven studies addressed epidemiology, followed by three on treatment, two on prognosis, and two on etiology. Diagnostic methods in the included studies consisted of oral findings, radiography, and model analysis, used alone or in combination [2], [3], [5], [7], [8], [13], [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20]. Only two early studies included histological examination of tissue following extraction [6], [7]. Follow-up periods were reported in only five studies (two case series and three cohort studies), ranging from 16 months to 8 years [2], [8], [14], [15], [16], whereas the remaining studies did not include follow-up [3], [5], [6], [7], [13], [17], [18], [19], [20]. In addition, tooth extraction was performed in six studies [2], [6], [7], [14], [15], [16], and orthodontic treatment was included in only one study [16].Table 1Summary of clinical evidence on primary molar ankylosis.Author (Year) [Ref.]CountryDesignAgeaSampleCQ categoryAnalysisFollow-upInterventionDarling and Levers (1973) [7]UKCa5–29 years50 pts / 108 pmEtM, RG, HiNAExtMesser and Cline et al. (1980) [2]USCa3–12 years107 pts / 263 pmTrOF, RG4–6 yearsExtKurol (1981) [5]SECr3–12 years1059 ptsEpiOFNANoneKoyoumdjisky-Kaye and Steigman (1982) [13]ILCr3–13 years1530 pts / 8250 pmEpiMNANoneKurol and Magnusson (1984) [6]SECr3–17 years58 pts / 102 pmEtHiNAExtKurol and Koch (1985) [14]SECo8.1–13.0 years15 pts / 46 pmTrOF, M, RG1.5–4.5 yearsExtKurol and Olson (1991) [15]SECo6.1–16.3 years68 pts / 143 pmPrOF, RG8 yearsExtLeonardi et al. (2005) [8]ITCo8.5 vs 9.0 years28 pts / 56 pmPrOF, RG16–19 monthsNoneSilvestrini Biavati et al. (2011) [3]ITCr5–15 years512 ptsEpiM, RGNANoneShalish et al. (2014) [16]ILCa7–14 years25 ptsTrM, RG1.5–3.0 yearsExt, OrthoAlshaya et al. (2022) [17]SACr4–12 years542 ptsEpiRGNANoneEşian et al. (2022) [18]ROCr6–12 years150 ptsEpiOF, RGNANoneÇege and Akal (2026) [19]TRCr7–11 years8452 ptsEpiRGNANoneDevrim et al. (2026) [20]TRCr5–12 years3012 ptsEpiOD, RGNANoneUK: United Kingdom, US: United States, SE: Sweden, IL: Israel, IT: Italy, SA: Saudi Arabia, RO: Romania, TR: TurkeyCa: case series, Cr: cross-sectional, Co: cohortpts: patients, pm: primary molarsCQ: clinical question, Et: etiology, Ep: epidemiology, Tr: treatment, Pr: prognosisM: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographs, Hi: histologyNA: not applicableExt: extraction, Ortho: orthodontic treatmentaAge is presented as a range or as a comparison. Table 1Summary of clinical evidence on primary molar ankylosis.Author (Year) [Ref.]CountryDesignAgeaSampleCQ categoryAnalysisFollow-upInterventionDarling and Levers (1973) [7]UKCa5–29 years50 pts / 108 pmEtM, RG, HiNAExtMesser and Cline et al. (1980) [2]USCa3–12 years107 pts / 263 pmTrOF, RG4–6 yearsExtKurol (1981) [5]SECr3–12 years1059 ptsEpiOFNANoneKoyoumdjisky-Kaye and Steigman (1982) [13]ILCr3–13 years1530 pts / 8250 pmEpiMNANoneKurol and Magnusson (1984) [6]SECr3–17 years58 pts / 102 pmEtHiNAExtKurol and Koch (1985) [14]SECo8.1–13.0 years15 pts / 46 pmTrOF, M, RG1.5–4.5 yearsExtKurol and Olson (1991) [15]SECo6.1–16.3 years68 pts / 143 pmPrOF, RG8 yearsExtLeonardi et al. (2005) [8]ITCo8.5 vs 9.0 years28 pts / 56 pmPrOF, RG16–19 monthsNoneSilvestrini Biavati et al. (2011) [3]ITCr5–15 years512 ptsEpiM, RGNANoneShalish et al. (2014) [16]ILCa7–14 years25 ptsTrM, RG1.5–3.0 yearsExt, OrthoAlshaya et al. (2022) [17]SACr4–12 years542 ptsEpiRGNANoneEşian et al. (2022) [18]ROCr6–12 years150 ptsEpiOF, RGNANoneÇege and Akal (2026) [19]TRCr7–11 years8452 ptsEpiRGNANoneDevrim et al. (2026) [20]TRCr5–12 years3012 ptsEpiOD, RGNANoneUK: United Kingdom, US: United States, SE: Sweden, IL: Israel, IT: Italy, SA: Saudi Arabia, RO: Romania, TR: TurkeyCa: case series, Cr: cross-sectional, Co: cohortpts: patients, pm: primary molarsCQ: clinical question, Et: etiology, Ep: epidemiology, Tr: treatment, Pr: prognosisM: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographs, Hi: histologyNA: not applicableExt: extraction, Ortho: orthodontic treatmentaAge is presented as a range or as a comparison. Summary of clinical evidence on primary molar ankylosis. UK: United Kingdom, US: United States, SE: Sweden, IL: Israel, IT: Italy, SA: Saudi Arabia, RO: Romania, TR: Turkey Ca: case series, Cr: cross-sectional, Co: cohort pts: patients, pm: primary molars CQ: clinical question, Et: etiology, Ep: epidemiology, Tr: treatment, Pr: prognosis M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographs, Hi: histology NA: not applicable Ext: extraction, Ortho: orthodontic treatment Age is presented as a range or as a comparison. Epidemiology including diagnostic criteria, prevalence, and clinical characteristics of primary molar ankylosis Table 2 summarizes the studies included in the epidemiology domain, including diagnostic criteria, prevalence, and clinical characteristics [3], [5], [13], [17], [18], [19], [20]. Among the included epidemiological studies, most diagnosed infraocclusion rather than confirmed ankylosis. Therefore, the reported prevalence primarily reflects infraocclusion used as a surrogate for ankylosis. Diagnostic criteria varied among studies and were primarily based on the degree of infraocclusion relative to the occlusal plane or adjacent teeth, typically defined as 0.5–1.0 mm or more below the occlusal level [3], [5], [13], [20]. The reported prevalence ranged from 1.3% to 24.8% at the person level and from 2.7% to 8.8% at the tooth level [3], [5], [13], [17], [18], [19], [20]. The highest reported prevalence was generally observed between 6 and 10 years of age [3], [5], [13], [17], [18], [19], [20]. Ankylosis occurred more frequently in mandibular primary molars, with the mandibular first primary molar generally more commonly involved than the mandibular second primary molar [3], [5], [13], [18], [20]. Most cases were classified as mild infraocclusion, with fewer moderate and severe cases reported [3], [13], [17], [19], [20]. The number of affected teeth varied among individuals, with one or two teeth most commonly involved, whereas involvement of more than three teeth was less frequent [3], [5], [13], [17], [18], [19].Table 2Studies included in the epidemiology domain.Author (Year) [Ref.]Diagnostic criteriaPrevalenceof IoAge (years)Common siteSeverityNumber ofaffected teethOther findingsKurol (1981) [5]≥ 1.0 mm below occlusal plane (OF)8.9%(2.7%)8–9LD > LE > UD > UENo left–right differenceNA1: 52.1%2: 27.7%> 3: 20.2%A familial tendency was found.Koyoumdjisky-Kaye and Steigman (1982) [13]> 0.5 mm below occlusal level of adjacent teeth (M)24.8%(8.8%)8–10LD > LE > UD > UEMi: 85.4%Mo: 12.1%Se: 2.5%1: 41.2%2: 39.6%> 3: 19.3%The severity of Io increased with age.Silvestrini Biavati et al. (2011) [3]≥ 1.0 mm below occlusal plane (M)6.6%8–10LD, LE > UD, UELE + UE > LD + UD1–2 mm: 60.2%2.5–4.0 mm: 28.4%4.5–9.0 mm: 6.8%1: 20.6%2: 32.4%> 3: 47.1%No sex-related difference was observed.Alshaya et al. (2022) [17]Brearley and McKibben classification (RG)7.4%9.2 ± 3.8LE > LD > UD > UEMi: 75%Mo: 23.5%Se: 1.5%1: 50.0%2: 42.5%≥ 3: 7.5%Io was associated with hypodontia, supernumerary teeth, and radix entomolaris.Eşian et al. (2022) [18]> 0.0 mm below occlusal plane and neighboring teeth (RG)12%6–9LD > LE > UD< 1 mm: 56.7%> 1 mm: 43.3%1: 33.3%2: 66.7%44.4% of patients had no permanent successors.20% of IPM show signs of delayed exfoliation.Çege and Akal (2026) [19]Brearley and McKibben classification (RG)3.6%9LE > LD > UE > UDMi: 49.5%Mo: 29.8%Se: 20.7%1: 58.7%2: 27.9%3: 6.6%> 4: 6.9%10.3% of IPM had no permanent successors.Dens invaginatus (33.1%) and hypodontia (32.5%) were the most common in patients.Devrim et al. (2026) [20]・≥ 1.0 mm below occlusal plane (OF, RG)・Percussion sound・periodontalligament space1.3%9–10LD > LE > UD > UEMi: 55.8%Mo: 34.9%Se: 9.3%Not specifiedThere were no associations between the severity of infraocclusion and periodontal health.M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographsPrevalence: person-level (tooth-level)Severity: tooth-levelNumber of affected teeth: person-levelAge: age at which infraocclusion was most frequently detectedLD: lower first primary molar, LE: lower second primary molar, UD: upper first primary molar, UE: upper second primary molarMi: mild, Mo: moderate, Se: severeNA: not applicable, Io: infraocclusion, IPM: infraoccluded primary molars Table 2Studies included in the epidemiology domain.Author (Year) [Ref.]Diagnostic criteriaPrevalenceof IoAge (years)Common siteSeverityNumber ofaffected teethOther findingsKurol (1981) [5]≥ 1.0 mm below occlusal plane (OF)8.9%(2.7%)8–9LD > LE > UD > UENo left–right differenceNA1: 52.1%2: 27.7%> 3: 20.2%A familial tendency was found.Koyoumdjisky-Kaye and Steigman (1982) [13]> 0.5 mm below occlusal level of adjacent teeth (M)24.8%(8.8%)8–10LD > LE > UD > UEMi: 85.4%Mo: 12.1%Se: 2.5%1: 41.2%2: 39.6%> 3: 19.3%The severity of Io increased with age.Silvestrini Biavati et al. (2011) [3]≥ 1.0 mm below occlusal plane (M)6.6%8–10LD, LE > UD, UELE + UE > LD + UD1–2 mm: 60.2%2.5–4.0 mm: 28.4%4.5–9.0 mm: 6.8%1: 20.6%2: 32.4%> 3: 47.1%No sex-related difference was observed.Alshaya et al. (2022) [17]Brearley and McKibben classification (RG)7.4%9.2 ± 3.8LE > LD > UD > UEMi: 75%Mo: 23.5%Se: 1.5%1: 50.0%2: 42.5%≥ 3: 7.5%Io was associated with hypodontia, supernumerary teeth, and radix entomolaris.Eşian et al. (2022) [18]> 0.0 mm below occlusal plane and neighboring teeth (RG)12%6–9LD > LE > UD< 1 mm: 56.7%> 1 mm: 43.3%1: 33.3%2: 66.7%44.4% of patients had no permanent successors.20% of IPM show signs of delayed exfoliation.Çege and Akal (2026) [19]Brearley and McKibben classification (RG)3.6%9LE > LD > UE > UDMi: 49.5%Mo: 29.8%Se: 20.7%1: 58.7%2: 27.9%3: 6.6%> 4: 6.9%10.3% of IPM had no permanent successors.Dens invaginatus (33.1%) and hypodontia (32.5%) were the most common in patients.Devrim et al. (2026) [20]・≥ 1.0 mm below occlusal plane (OF, RG)・Percussion sound・periodontalligament space1.3%9–10LD > LE > UD > UEMi: 55.8%Mo: 34.9%Se: 9.3%Not specifiedThere were no associations between the severity of infraocclusion and periodontal health.M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographsPrevalence: person-level (tooth-level)Severity: tooth-levelNumber of affected teeth: person-levelAge: age at which infraocclusion was most frequently detectedLD: lower first primary molar, LE: lower second primary molar, UD: upper first primary molar, UE: upper second primary molarMi: mild, Mo: moderate, Se: severeNA: not applicable, Io: infraocclusion, IPM: infraoccluded primary molars Studies included in the epidemiology domain. M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographs Prevalence: person-level (tooth-level) Severity: tooth-level Number of affected teeth: person-level Age: age at which infraocclusion was most frequently detected LD: lower first primary molar, LE: lower second primary molar, UD: upper first primary molar, UE: upper second primary molar Mi: mild, Mo: moderate, Se: severe NA: not applicable, Io: infraocclusion, IPM: infraoccluded primary molars Etiological and histological findings of ankylosed primary molars Table 3 summarizes the studies included in the histopathology domain, including proposed etiological factors and histological findings [6], [7]. Histopathological studies provided direct confirmation of ankylosis through microscopic examination of extracted teeth [6], [7]. Premolar agenesis was reported in 19.4%–22.6% of infraoccluded primary molars in these studies [6], [7]. Histopathological examination of infraoccluded primary molars demonstrated direct continuity between alveolar bone and dentin following root resorption, together with areas of dentin resorption accompanied by subsequent deposition of bone or bone-like tissue [6], [7]. These changes frequently involved the inner root surface and, in some cases, were limited to the apical third of the root [6], [7]. However, not all infraoccluded primary molars necessarily exhibited ankylosis [6], [7]. Clinically, affected teeth typically produced a solid sound upon percussion, lacked mobility, and were associated with increased vertical positional loss [6], [7]. In some cases, attrition, caries, or restorations were observed, and a small proportion of clinically normal primary molars were found to be ankylosed upon histological examination [7].Table 3Studies included in the histopathology domain.Author (Year) [Ref.]Diagnostic criteriaPremolar agenesisaHistological findingsClinical findingsDarling and Levers (1973) [7]Bone tissue directly deposited within dentin on histological examination19.4%・98% of IPM showed areas of dentinal resorption with subsequent deposition of bone tissue into the resorbed areas, in direct continuity with the dentin.・9% of clinically normal primary molars were also ankylosed.・In 53.7% of IPM, attrition, restoration, or caries were observed.・An increase in the degree of infraocclusion from 0.5 to 2.0 mm was observed in four teeth between 9 and 10 years of age.Kurol and Magnusson (1984) [6]Direct contact between root dentin and bone tissue on histological examination22.6%・79.1% of IPM with permanent successors and 85.7% of those without permanent successors showed histological signs of ankylosis.・Ankylosis was observed along the inner root surface, often within a 1- to 2-mm area of the apical third of the root, especially in younger children.・All IPM produced a solid sound on percussion and lacked vibration.・37.8% of IPM showed a thicker buccal alveolar bone crest and more pronounced vertical positional loss.IPM: infraoccluded primary molarsatooth-level Table 3Studies included in the histopathology domain.Author (Year) [Ref.]Diagnostic criteriaPremolar agenesisaHistological findingsClinical findingsDarling and Levers (1973) [7]Bone tissue directly deposited within dentin on histological examination19.4%・98% of IPM showed areas of dentinal resorption with subsequent deposition of bone tissue into the resorbed areas, in direct continuity with the dentin.・9% of clinically normal primary molars were also ankylosed.・In 53.7% of IPM, attrition, restoration, or caries were observed.・An increase in the degree of infraocclusion from 0.5 to 2.0 mm was observed in four teeth between 9 and 10 years of age.Kurol and Magnusson (1984) [6]Direct contact between root dentin and bone tissue on histological examination22.6%・79.1% of IPM with permanent successors and 85.7% of those without permanent successors showed histological signs of ankylosis.・Ankylosis was observed along the inner root surface, often within a 1- to 2-mm area of the apical third of the root, especially in younger children.・All IPM produced a solid sound on percussion and lacked vibration.・37.8% of IPM showed a thicker buccal alveolar bone crest and more pronounced vertical positional loss.IPM: infraoccluded primary molarsatooth-level Studies included in the histopathology domain. IPM: infraoccluded primary molars tooth-level Treatment and prognosis of ankylosed or infraoccluded primary molars The management strategies and prognostic outcomes of ankylosed primary molars are summarized in Table 4a, Table 4b [2], [8], [14], [15], [16]. Most treatment studies diagnosed ankylosis clinically based on infraocclusion together with percussion, mobility, and radiographic findings, whereas histological confirmation was generally unavailable. Mildly infraoccluded teeth, especially mandibular first primary molars, usually exfoliated on schedule with minimal residual root fragments [2]. A conservative approach for mildly affected cases was often recommended when permanent successors were present [14], [15]. In non-extracted cases, progression of infraocclusion was observed in a proportion of teeth, but all exfoliated within the normal timeframe [14], [15]. Extraction was generally performed in more severely affected cases [14], [15]. Findings regarding treatment outcomes after extraction varied across studies. One study reported gradual space loss following extraction [14], whereas others found no consistent increase in residual root fragments or alveolar bone loss compared with non-extraction [2], [15]. Mandibular second primary molars were more prone to leaving root fragments if not carefully managed, and reduced alveolar bone support for the successor premolars was reported in some untreated severe cases [2].Table 4aStudies included in the treatment and prognosis domain.Author(Year) [Ref.]Diagnostic criteriaFollow-upIntervention and prognosisAdditional findingsMesser and Cline (1980) [2]・≥ 1 mm below expected occlusal plane (OF, RG)・Mobility during manual rocking movement (OF)4–6 years・Most LD exfoliated on schedule and left no residual root fragments, whereas LE was less prone to exfoliation and tended to leave residual root fragments. None of the UD and UE extracted early left root fragments.・Failure to perform timely extraction in severe cases resulted in reduced alveolar bone support for the premolar.・LD was only slightly affected, whereas most LE showed progressive development of more severe Io.・Hypoplasia and/or hypomineralization were found in 39.1% of L4 and 22.2% of L5.・Coronal rotation in 90.4% of L4 (control: 11%)・Space inadequacy in 30% of L5 (control: 8%)Kurol and Koch (1985) [14]・Mobility on percussion (OF)・Sharp, clear sound on percussion (OF)・Distance from IPM to a plane extending from mesiobuccal cusp of permanent molar to central incisor edge (M, RG)until eruption of successors・No differences were observed in the frequency of residual primary root remnants between extraction and non-extraction.・Extraction cases exhibited gradual space loss, with a higher frequency (93.3%) than non-extraction cases (40.0%).・43.5% of non-extraction cases showed progression in the degree of Io.・All non-extracted IPM exfoliated within the normal timeframe.・No differences in marginal alveolar bone height were observed between extraction and non-extraction after eruption of the successors.Kurol and Olson (1991) [15]Unclear8 years・Two extraction cases exhibited mesial alveolar bone loss of the first permanent molar amounting to 3–4 mm.・No differences were observed in the distribution of root residuals between extraction and non-extraction.・IPM did not constitute a general risk for future alveolar bone loss mesial to the first permanent molars.・Observation until normal exfoliation and eruption of successors was recommended.M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographsLD: lower first primary molar, LE: lower second primary molar, UD: upper first primary molar, UE: upper second primary molarL4: lower first premolar, L5: lower second premolarIo: infraocclusion, IPM: infraoccluded primary molarsTable 4bStudies included in the treatment and prognosis domain (continued).Author(Year)Diagnostic criteriaFollow-upIntervention and prognosisAdditional findingsLeonardi et al. (2005) [8]> 1 mm below occlusal plane of neighboring teeth (OF, RG)16–19 months・Anterior mandibular growth rotation was observed in subjects with IPM.・High levels of alveolar bone turnover and remodeling in anteriorly rotating mandibles may influence the clinical expression of Io.Shalish et al. (2014) [16]> 5 mm of vertical discrepancy measured from mesial marginal ridge of permanent first molar (M, RG)1.5–3.0 years・Space regaining using removable plates (72% of cases) or fixed appliances (28%), surgical extraction of the obstructing primary molar in all cases, immediate insertion of a space maintainer following extraction, and 3–6 months of follow-up were performed.・Approximately 95% of impacted premolars erupted.・Severe IPM were found more frequently in LE and UE than in LD and UD.・In all cases, the crowns of adjacent teeth were severely inclined and space loss was present.・20% of patients had no permanent successors.・Agenesis of permanent teeth, including premolars, small maxillary lateral incisors, and palatally displaced canines, was frequently observed in deep IPM.M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographsLD: lower first primary molar, LE: lower second primary molar, UD: upper first primary molar, UE: upper second primary molarIo: infraocclusion, IPM: infraoccluded primary molars Table 4aStudies included in the treatment and prognosis domain.Author(Year) [Ref.]Diagnostic criteriaFollow-upIntervention and prognosisAdditional findingsMesser and Cline (1980) [2]・≥ 1 mm below expected occlusal plane (OF, RG)・Mobility during manual rocking movement (OF)4–6 years・Most LD exfoliated on schedule and left no residual root fragments, whereas LE was less prone to exfoliation and tended to leave residual root fragments. None of the UD and UE extracted early left root fragments.・Failure to perform timely extraction in severe cases resulted in reduced alveolar bone support for the premolar.・LD was only slightly affected, whereas most LE showed progressive development of more severe Io.・Hypoplasia and/or hypomineralization were found in 39.1% of L4 and 22.2% of L5.・Coronal rotation in 90.4% of L4 (control: 11%)・Space inadequacy in 30% of L5 (control: 8%)Kurol and Koch (1985) [14]・Mobility on percussion (OF)・Sharp, clear sound on percussion (OF)・Distance from IPM to a plane extending from mesiobuccal cusp of permanent molar to central incisor edge (M, RG)until eruption of successors・No differences were observed in the frequency of residual primary root remnants between extraction and non-extraction.・Extraction cases exhibited gradual space loss, with a higher frequency (93.3%) than non-extraction cases (40.0%).・43.5% of non-extraction cases showed progression in the degree of Io.・All non-extracted IPM exfoliated within the normal timeframe.・No differences in marginal alveolar bone height were observed between extraction and non-extraction after eruption of the successors.Kurol and Olson (1991) [15]Unclear8 years・Two extraction cases exhibited mesial alveolar bone loss of the first permanent molar amounting to 3–4 mm.・No differences were observed in the distribution of root residuals between extraction and non-extraction.・IPM did not constitute a general risk for future alveolar bone loss mesial to the first permanent molars.・Observation until normal exfoliation and eruption of successors was recommended.M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographsLD: lower first primary molar, LE: lower second primary molar, UD: upper first primary molar, UE: upper second primary molarL4: lower first premolar, L5: lower second premolarIo: infraocclusion, IPM: infraoccluded primary molars Studies included in the treatment and prognosis domain. M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographs LD: lower first primary molar, LE: lower second primary molar, UD: upper first primary molar, UE: upper second primary molar L4: lower first premolar, L5: lower second premolar Io: infraocclusion, IPM: infraoccluded primary molars Table 4bStudies included in the treatment and prognosis domain (continued).Author(Year)Diagnostic criteriaFollow-upIntervention and prognosisAdditional findingsLeonardi et al. (2005) [8]> 1 mm below occlusal plane of neighboring teeth (OF, RG)16–19 months・Anterior mandibular growth rotation was observed in subjects with IPM.・High levels of alveolar bone turnover and remodeling in anteriorly rotating mandibles may influence the clinical expression of Io.Shalish et al. (2014) [16]> 5 mm of vertical discrepancy measured from mesial marginal ridge of permanent first molar (M, RG)1.5–3.0 years・Space regaining using removable plates (72% of cases) or fixed appliances (28%), surgical extraction of the obstructing primary molar in all cases, immediate insertion of a space maintainer following extraction, and 3–6 months of follow-up were performed.・Approximately 95% of impacted premolars erupted.・Severe IPM were found more frequently in LE and UE than in LD and UD.・In all cases, the crowns of adjacent teeth were severely inclined and space loss was present.・20% of patients had no permanent successors.・Agenesis of permanent teeth, including premolars, small maxillary lateral incisors, and palatally displaced canines, was frequently observed in deep IPM.M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographsLD: lower first primary molar, LE: lower second primary molar, UD: upper first primary molar, UE: upper second primary molarIo: infraocclusion, IPM: infraoccluded primary molars Studies included in the treatment and prognosis domain (continued). M: models, OF: oral findings, RG: radiographs LD: lower first primary molar, LE: lower second primary molar, UD: upper first primary molar, UE: upper second primary molar Io: infraocclusion, IPM: infraoccluded primary molars In cases with severe infraocclusion or significant space loss, combined treatment involving space regaining with removable or fixed appliances, surgical extraction of infraoccluded primary molars, and immediate space maintenance was associated with spontaneous eruption of impacted premolars in approximately 95% of reported cases [8], [16]. Severe infraocclusion occurred more frequently in lower second and upper primary molars and was sometimes associated with adjacent tooth tipping, anterior mandibular rotation, and alveolar bone remodeling [2], [8], [16]. Agenesis of permanent teeth and other dental anomalies were reported in a subset of patients with deep infraocclusion [8], [16]. Risk of bias and quality assessment using JBI critical appraisal tools The results of the quality assessment using the JBI critical appraisal tools are summarized in Fig. 2. Most studies used standardized diagnostic criteria, although reporting of participant characteristics varied across study designs. However, in the prevalence studies, all studies identified infraocclusion rather than histologically or surgically confirmed ankylosis and therefore did not meet the criterion for valid identification of ankylosis. One cross-sectional study provided limited information regarding participant characteristics. Among the case series, consecutive inclusion, complete inclusion, and demographic reporting were often insufficiently described. Similarly, cohort studies seldom reported potential confounding factors or strategies used to address them.Fig. 2Results of the quality assessment using the JBI critical appraisal tools. Results of the quality assessment using the JBI critical appraisal tools. Discussion In this systematic review, 14 studies fulfilled all inclusion and exclusion criteria and were included in the narrative synthesis. These studies were categorized as epidemiological, etiological, or prognostic. This systematic review integrates evidence across these three research domains to provide a comprehensive interpretation of the relationship between ankylosis and infraocclusion in primary molars and summarizes the currently available diagnostic criteria (Table 1–4). Although the primary focus of this review was primary molar ankylosis, the relationship between ankylosis and infraocclusion was a prespecified component of the review question. Accordingly, the findings regarding infraocclusion should be interpreted in the context of evidence identified through this ankylosis-focused review. Prevalence and diagnosis of “ankylosed” or “infraoccluded” primary molars In the seven epidemiological articles included in this systematic review, the diagnostic criteria for primary molar ankylosis were mainly based on the tooth being more than 0.5 mm or 1.0 mm below the occlusal plane, as assessed by study models, oral findings, and radiographs [3], [5], [13], [20]. The Brearley and McKibben classification is a long-established standard, and its definition of “mild” closely corresponds to the diagnostic criteria described above [21]. However, these findings should be interpreted with caution because the prevalence studies primarily evaluated infraocclusion rather than histologically confirmed ankylosis. In addition, the sample sizes of these studies varied widely, ranging from 150 to 8452 participants [3], [5], [13], [17], [18], [19], [20]. In the Israeli study, the reported prevalence was very high (24.8%), with significant differences observed among ethnic groups [13]. By contrast, in the study in Turkey, the reported prevalence was very low (1.3%), based on multiple strict criteria [20]. However, the other studies reported prevalence rates of approximately 5%–15% at the person level. Therefore, based on the diagnostic criteria used in these seven studies, the reported prevalence likely reflected the prevalence of infraocclusion in primary molars rather than the true prevalence of ankylosis and was comparable to the prevalence reported in recent systematic reviews of infraoccluded primary molars [22]. Association between ankylosis and infraocclusion based on pathological evidence There has been very little new histological evidence regarding ankylosis over the past few decades. Darling and Levers reported that 98% of infraoccluded primary molars exhibited areas of dentinal resorption followed by the deposition of bone or bone-like tissue in direct continuity with the dentin on histological examination [7]. These histopathological findings are consistent with replacement resorption associated with ankylosis [7]. In addition, Kurol and Magnusson reported that more than 80% of infraoccluded primary molars were diagnosed as ankylosed based on histological findings [6]. However, the presence of infraocclusion does not necessarily indicate ankylosis [6], [7]. The following discussion incorporates additional mechanistic and developmental evidence that was not included in the systematic review. This evidence is presented solely to provide biological context and generate hypotheses for future research. Ankylosis has been described as a transient phenomenon occurring at specific stages of root resorption, with ankylosed areas subsequently undergoing resorption and resolution [23]. By contrast, this interpretation does not adequately explain cases in which ankylosed areas are observed in the absence of root resorption. Such findings suggest that infraocclusion may also arise from factors other than ankylosis. Previous studies have suggested that infraocclusion may represent a clinical manifestation of increased occlusal force following eruption of the first molar [24], mandibular growth characteristics [8], [25], and eruption disturbances, including eruption timing mismatch and weak eruptive force [6], [26], [27]. These multiple developmental and biomechanical factors may also help explain the age at which infraocclusion was most frequently detected (8–10 years) and the predominance in the mandible observed in the epidemiological studies included in this systematic review. Furthermore, teeth that become infraoccluded due to non-ankylotic factors may develop increasing discrepancies in occlusal and alveolar relationships over time [6], potentially leading to secondary ankylosis through altered mechanical and biological environments. However, ankylosis may occur focally, and histological sectioning may fail to detect small ankylosed areas. Moreover, because the available histopathological evidence was derived from selected extracted teeth, the reported histological proportions should be interpreted as observations from these samples rather than estimates applicable to all infraoccluded primary molars. Therefore, the absence of histologically identified ankylosis should not be interpreted as definitive evidence that ankylosis was completely absent. Consequently, the relationship between infraocclusion and ankylosis should be interpreted with caution, and further well-designed histopathological studies are needed to clarify this association. On the other hand, Darling and Levers reported that ankylosis can be present even in clinically normal primary molars in approximately 9% of cases [7]. Recent transcriptomic analyses have suggested that infraocclusion may represent a molecular phenotype associated with ankylosis, characterized by inflammatory pathways and epithelial cell dysregulation, whereas non-infraocclusion may represent a temporary absence of ankylosis [28]. However, this interpretation may not fully account for the clinical heterogeneity of infraocclusion, which is likely influenced by multiple developmental and biomechanical factors. Therefore, the presence of ankylosis in clinically normal primary molars suggests that ankylosis per se is not synonymous with infraocclusion, but rather a latent condition that may or may not become clinically apparent depending on growth-related factors. In the clinical diagnosis of ankylosis, in addition to findings of infraocclusion, the percussion sound test is considered one of the simplest methods for diagnosing ankylosed primary molars and provides relatively reliable diagnostic results [6], [29]. However, percussion changes reportedly occur only when at least 20% of the root surface is ankylosed [30]. In addition, mobility evaluation is also helpful because loss of mobility in infraoccluded teeth occurs when more than 10% of the root becomes ankylosed [30]. On the other hand, limited diagnostic accuracy has been reported not only for two-dimensional dental imaging [29], [31] but also for three-dimensional cone-beam computed tomography [32]. Therefore, the most useful clinical approach for diagnosing ankylosis is likely the combined assessment of percussion sound and tooth mobility together with longitudinal radiographic observation, regardless of the presence or absence of infraocclusion. Nevertheless, the histopathological evidence included in this systematic review was derived from only two relatively small studies of extracted teeth published several decades ago, with limited reporting identified by the JBI critical appraisal. Because extraction is generally performed in more severely affected teeth, selection bias cannot be excluded, and these findings may not be generalizable to all infraoccluded primary molars. Clinical course and management of infraoccluded primary molars Management of infraoccluded primary molars has long been debated, particularly regarding the indication for extraction [2], [14], [15], [21], [33]. The available evidence does not demonstrate a clear superiority of either extraction or conservative management in teeth with permanent successors because treatment outcomes have been inconsistent across predominantly observational studies. Based on the currently available evidence, mild infraocclusion is generally considered suitable for observation, whereas severe infraocclusion associated with progressive space loss, tipping of adjacent teeth, or occlusal disturbance may warrant extraction with appropriate space maintenance [2], [14], [15], [21], [33]. This is broadly consistent with the Brearley and McKibben classification [21]. Brearley and McKibben proposed a severity-based classification of infraocclusion that links the degree of infraocclusion with clinical management [21]. Mild infraocclusion is generally managed by observation, whereas severe infraocclusion associated with progressive space loss, tipping of adjacent teeth, or occlusal disturbance may require extraction with appropriate space maintenance [21]. Although recent studies have questioned whether infraocclusion is always attributable to ankylosis, the findings of the present review are broadly consistent with this severity-based management approach when determining treatment strategies for infraoccluded primary molars with permanent successors. Consistent with this classification, conservative management remains a viable option for mild to moderate infraocclusion, and a clear superiority of extraction has not been demonstrated in a recent systematic review [34]. On the other hand, several studies have reported a relatively high frequency of missing permanent successors in infraoccluded primary molars [6], [7], [16], [18], [19]. For example, successor agenesis has been observed in approximately 30% of infraoccluded primary molars, compared with only 0.66%–3.62% in the general population [35]. In the present review, the proportion of infraoccluded primary molars without permanent successors ranged from approximately 10%–25%, which is considerably higher than the reported prevalence of premolar agenesis in the general population [6], [7], [19]. These findings suggest a possible association between infraocclusion and developmental anomalies such as agenesis. In cases of infraoccluded primary molars without permanent successors, treatment planning should extend beyond management of the infraoccluded tooth itself and adopt a comprehensive, long-term perspective, including orthodontic space closure, prosthetic rehabilitation, or implant placement [4], [33], [36]. When significant malocclusion is absent, preservation of the infraoccluded primary molar may be considered whenever possible. In the absence of ankylosis, continued monitoring is generally appropriate; by contrast, when ankylosis is present, management should be tailored according to the severity of infraocclusion and the number of affected teeth, including options such as periodic monitoring, occlusal build-up to maintain function, orthodontic space closure following extraction, or implant-based rehabilitation [4], [33], [36]. Implant-based rehabilitation should generally be considered only after completion of craniofacial growth. Preservation of infraoccluded primary molars may also contribute to maintenance of alveolar bone volume, which could be advantageous for future implant placement [37]. Regardless of the selected approach, regular follow-up is essential to monitor the progression of ankylosis and associated occlusal or alveolar changes. Nevertheless, the treatment recommendations discussed above should be regarded as conditional because they were derived predominantly from observational studies with low-certainty evidence, many of which provided limited information regarding potential confounding factors identified by the JBI critical appraisal. Hypothetical conceptual framework possibly related to ankylosis and infraocclusion Based on the findings of this systematic review, together with additional mechanistic literature, we propose a hypothetical conceptual framework illustrating possible relationships between ankylosis and infraocclusion in primary molars (Fig. 3). Infraocclusion has traditionally been attributed primarily to ankylosis [5], [7], [21]. However, accumulating evidence suggests that additional factors, including occlusal forces, eruption disturbances, and craniofacial growth characteristics, may also contribute to its clinical manifestation. As shown in Table 4, Messer and Cline reported that mandibular second primary molars exhibited more severe infraocclusion than first primary molars [2]. The mandibular second primary molar plays a central role in masticatory function and is exposed to substantial occlusal forces, which may occasionally exceed the adaptive capacity of the periodontal ligament [38]. Such mechanical loading has been suggested to contribute to periodontal ligament breakdown and may be involved in the development of ankylosis [24]. In addition, Shalish et al. reported that agenesis of permanent successors, particularly premolars, was more frequently observed in cases with severe infraocclusion [16]. Given that second premolars show a relatively high prevalence of agenesis in the general population [35], the absence of a permanent successor may reduce eruptive and resorptive stimuli acting on the primary molar, thereby delaying exfoliation and increasing susceptibility to infraocclusion [39]. Nevertheless, the evidence linking occlusal forces and eruption disturbances to infraocclusion remains limited, and further investigation is required.Fig. 3Hypothetical conceptual framework illustrating possible relationships between infraocclusion and ankylosis. This framework integrates the findings of this systematic review with additional mechanistic literature to provide biological context and generate hypotheses for future research. It should not be interpreted as demonstrating established causal or temporal relationships. Hypothetical conceptual framework illustrating possible relationships between infraocclusion and ankylosis. This framework integrates the findings of this systematic review with additional mechanistic literature to provide biological context and generate hypotheses for future research. It should not be interpreted as demonstrating established causal or temporal relationships. Regarding mandibular growth patterns, the limited available evidence presents inconsistent findings [8], [25]. Some studies, including those by Leonardi et al., have suggested that anterior (counterclockwise) growth rotation is associated with more stable occlusal relationships and reduced vertical discrepancies, possibly because of increased alveolar bone turnover and remodeling activity [8]. These characteristics may influence occlusal contact patterns and eruption dynamics of successor teeth [6], [26], [27]. By contrast, Lanteri et al. reported that posterior (clockwise) mandibular rotation is associated with increased vertical dimensions and reduced occlusal contact, which may predispose individuals to infraocclusion [25]. However, the causal relationship between growth pattern and infraocclusion remains unclear, and the association observed in previous studies may reflect shared developmental factors rather than direct causation. Indeed, familial aggregation of ankylosis and infraocclusion has been reported [5], [16], suggesting a possible genetic contribution, potentially mediated through craniofacial growth characteristics. Taken together, these findings suggest that ankylosis and infraocclusion should not necessarily be regarded as synonymous conditions. Instead, multiple mechanical, developmental, and genetic factors may contribute to their complex relationship, the temporal and causal direction of which remains uncertain. The hypothetical framework presented in Fig. 3 is intended to summarize these possible relationships and generate hypotheses for future research rather than to depict established causal pathways. Limitations This systematic review has several limitations. Most included studies were case series or observational in design, which limits the ability to draw causal inferences. In cross-sectional and cohort studies, confounders and strategies used to address them were seldom reported. In addition, because the electronic search was intentionally focused on ankylosis-related terminology, studies describing infraocclusion without explicit reference to ankylosis may not have been comprehensively identified, although manual reference-list screening was performed to minimize this risk. Furthermore, diagnostic criteria for ankylosis and infraocclusion were not standardized across studies, which may have contributed to heterogeneity in the findings. Future studies incorporating standardized diagnostic criteria, histopathological validation of ankylosis, and large-scale epidemiological designs are warranted. Another important limitation relates to the stage at which ankylosis is identified. Most included studies focused on ankylosed or infraoccluded primary molars after complete eruption. Although ankylosis is generally considered to occur after eruption, it may also develop during the early stages of eruption, thereby mimicking a primary eruption disturbance in some cases [2], [21], [40]. In addition, teeth affected by eruption disturbances, such as primary failure of eruption or odontogenic lesions (e.g., odontomas or dentigerous cysts), are initially non-ankylosed; however, prolonged absence of eruption and functional loading may predispose these teeth to secondary ankylosis over time [41]. These observations suggest the possibility that ankylosis may not always represent the initiating factor, but occur as a secondary event in the progression of eruption disturbances. Moreover, cases of ankylosis in unerupted primary molars have been reported [42], indicating that ankylosis may arise earlier than traditionally assumed. Taken together, these findings suggest that the relationship between ankylosis and infraocclusion may be more complex than the conventional unidirectional model and may involve multiple contributing factors, as illustrated in Fig. 3. Further investigation into the temporal and causal relationships between ankylosis, infraocclusion, and eruption disturbances is required. Scoping reviews incorporating case reports of impacted primary teeth, in addition to infraocclusion, may provide valuable insights into the developmental sequence of these conditions. Conclusion The available evidence regarding ankylosis of primary molars remains limited, heterogeneous, and derived predominantly from observational studies. Consequently, the temporal and causal relationship between ankylosis and infraocclusion cannot yet be established. Nevertheless, our systematic review led to the following findings: ・Epidemiological studies on ankylosed primary molars have mainly reported the frequency of infraoccluded primary molars used as a surrogate for ankylosis, with an overall prevalence of 1.3–24.8% at the person level and 2.7–8.8% at the tooth level, although reported prevalence varied substantially among populations. ・To diagnose infraocclusion, oral findings, radiographs, and model analysis are used alone or in combination. A position more than 0.5 or 1.0 mm below the occlusal plane or Brearley and McKibben classification is commonly used as the diagnostic criterion for infraocclusion. ・Although most infraoccluded primary molars exhibited ankylosis, the presence of infraocclusion does not necessarily indicate ankylosis on histological examination. In addition, ankylosis can be present even in clinically normal primary molars. ・Based on the currently available evidence, conservative management may be considered for mild to moderate infraocclusion, whereas extraction with appropriate space management may be warranted in selected severe cases. In cases with successor agenesis, treatment planning should adopt a comprehensive, long-term perspective, including orthodontic space closure, prosthetic rehabilitation, or implant placement after completion of craniofacial growth. ・The available findings suggest that multiple developmental and biomechanical factors may contribute to the complex relationship between ankylosis and infraocclusion. Whether ankylosis represents a primary event or develops secondarily under different developmental conditions remains uncertain. This review synthesizes the currently available evidence across epidemiology, histopathology, and clinical management while highlighting the uncertain relationship between ankylosis and infraocclusion. By distinguishing established observations from hypothesis-generating concepts, it may facilitate future mechanistic and longitudinal research. Ethical approval Not required. Declaration of Generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in the writing process During the preparation of this work, the authors used ChatGPT in order to improve the language and readability of the text. After using this tool, the authors reviewed and edited the content as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the publication. Patient consent Not required. Declaration of Competing Interest The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.