An Equity-Driven Analysis of the Implications of Attachment and Attachment Readiness Within Primary Care Healthcare Systems in Canada Authors: Akm Alamgir, Subrana Rahman, Saleema Allana, Rosanra Yoon, Kasia Filaber, Cliff Ledwos, Pema Yanzom, Faye Goldman, Michelle Naimer, Jennifer Rayner Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Background: The persistent challenge of not having a physician or nurse practitioner for ongoing care for millions of residents imposes a burden on the health economy in Canada and demands a shift in focus from mere system registry to the value-based concept of attachment readiness. With a hypothesis that true attachment is a function of attachment readiness, a relational process shaped by the intersection of patients’ preparation, providers’ capacity, and systemic support, this study aims to investigate the challenges of attachment-creating barriers to meaningful healthcare relationships. Methods: This sequential mixed-methods study was designed to integrate a comprehensive scoping review of academic librarian-guided databases, search engines, grey literature, and snowballing, followed by 360-degree qualitative interviews with experts, service providers, and clients. Qualitative data was analyzed by thematic coding to answer the research questions. Results: Attachment is a function of a multitude of factors from patients and physicians’ “attachment readiness” is a multilevel, process-oriented condition shaped by patient preparedness, provider capacity, and system design more than a single episodic event or individual attribute. Facilitators such as team-based care, patient navigation, culturally responsive outreach, and structured onboarding reinforce readiness as a system-enabled condition. However, persistent system-level barriers delay attachment among motivated patients (readiness decay), leading to frustration, disengagement, and reduced trust. Findings further suggest that attachment is constrained not only by physician supply but also by time-sensitive readiness conditions. Conclusions: This study suggests that attachment to primary care is one leg of a three-legged stool, upheld and sustained by the two others- equity and access. To facilitate true attachment and to move beyond fragmented care and reliance on high-cost emergency departments, Canadian healthcare policy must consider attachment readiness through standardizing onboarding (implementing uniform digital intake processes to reduce repetitive data entry and administrative friction), an equity lens for prioritizing vulnerability (refining centralized waitlist algorithms to account for clinical urgency and social determinants of health), and supporting provider capacity (providing financial and administrative incentives that recognize the labour involved in establishing new longitudinal relationships for patients with complex needs). 1. Background According to the Canadian Medical Association (CMA), approximately 6.5 million Canadians remain unattached to ongoing primary care, which is the essential front door to the healthcare system in Canada and foundational to accessing timely preventive care and chronic disease management [1]. This represents more than 15% of the population, indicating limited consistent access to primary care [2]. Certain groups, such as immigrants, low-income individuals, formerly incarcerated people, people with a history of opioid use, and those experiencing mental health challenges, are disproportionately less likely to have a regular primary care provider [3,4,5]. Patients who are not attached to a primary care provider often rely on walk-in clinics or emergency departments for both basic and preventive health services [6,7]. Canada ranks among the lowest in primary care attachment rates within the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries [8]. This lack of attachment to primary care providers limits access to healthcare and diminishes the quality of care, largely due to disruption in system navigation and fragmented care [9]. For residents without a consistent healthcare provider, it is a significant contributor to preventable health problems [9]. Those without a regular family doctor or nurse practitioner face substantial barriers to care. Research by Crooks, Agarwal, and Harrison [10] revealed that unattached individuals experience fragmented medical records, limited access to specialized care due to missing referrals, and the absence of a continuous doctor–patient relationship that fosters trust and communication [11]. Experiencing longer periods without attachment is associated with poorer health outcomes and higher healthcare costs, particularly among individuals with moderate-to-high comorbidities [9]. In Ontario, systemic issues, such as an ongoing severe shortage of family physicians and family health teams, compound these challenges. The Canadian Health Workforce Education, Training, and Distribution Study [12] reported a deficit of about 23,000 family doctors, with only 1700 new graduates entering the workforce each year, far below replacement levels. This shortage, along with underutilized internal training programs in Canada and an aging physician population, exacerbates the attachment gap. Primary care providers face increasing administrative burdens, outdated billing and remuneration models, and significant workforce challenges that impact both recruitment and retention. These structural challenges contribute to burnout and reduced capacity, thereby further straining access to primary care. Despite the need for more medical professionals, Ontario experiences significant brain waste, with many internationally educated professionals not hired and their skills going to waste [13]. This shortage of health professionals exacerbates the gap in healthcare access. Solo family medicine practices are overstretched and do not have the necessary resources and access to team-based care to manage the needs of complex patients experiencing multiple social, health, and structural vulnerabilities such as food insecurity, poverty, and complex co-occurring mental health or substance use challenges. Subsequently, solo family medicine practices are forced to maintain smaller rosters and selectively accept patients due to limited capacity and resources to adequately care for patients with severe, complex chronic conditions or substance use [10]. To address these challenges, governments at all levels have introduced multiple initiatives to enhance attachment to primary care. Ontario’s Primary Care Action Plan (2025–2029), a provincial government strategy, aims to connect approximately 2 million residents by creating and expanding interprofessional primary care teams [14]. Further, Ontario’s Healthcare Connect is a centralized waitlist for unattached patients awaiting attachment. Other provinces have implemented similar policies and programs. British Columbia’s provincial attachment system uses the Health Connect Registry and Provider Panel Registry to link patients and providers. Quebec’s Guichet d’accès à la première ligne (GAP) and GAMF, Nova Scotia’s Need a Family Practice Registry, Alberta’s Primary Care Networks and AlbertaFindADoctor.ca, Prince Edward Island’s Family Care Teams, and Newfoundland and Labrador’s Patient Connect NL all aim to improve equitable, longitudinal access to primary healthcare across jurisdictions. Problem Statement Despite these nationwide efforts, millions of Canadians remain unattached to a consistent primary care provider. Improving access requires more than just system capacity. The readiness of both patients and providers to engage in and sustain ongoing primary care relationships is crucial but underexplored. This study explores attachment readiness from both perspectives. This article informs strategies that streamline and strengthen the onboarding process for primary care attachment by integrating the perspectives of patients, providers, and the healthcare system to support equitable, sustainable, and person-centred care. Research Questions:What are the global concepts of “Attachment” and “Attachment Readiness” to primary care?What is the impact of attachment and attachment readiness (attaching prepared or not prepared patients) on the healthcare system (cost of non-attachment)?What are the challenges to and facilitators of attachment readiness? What are the global concepts of “Attachment” and “Attachment Readiness” to primary care? What are the global concepts of “Attachment” and “Attachment Readiness” to primary care? What is the impact of attachment and attachment readiness (attaching prepared or not prepared patients) on the healthcare system (cost of non-attachment)? What is the impact of attachment and attachment readiness (attaching prepared or not prepared patients) on the healthcare system (cost of non-attachment)? What are the challenges to and facilitators of attachment readiness? What are the challenges to and facilitators of attachment readiness? Specifically, this review seeks to clarify the global concepts of attachment and attachment readiness within primary care, examine the impact of attachment and non-attachment on health system outcomes, including the costs associated with unattached care, and explore the key challenges and facilitators that influence patients’ readiness to attach to a primary care provider. 2. Methodology This project employed a sequential approach [15]: a scoping review to generate foundational information, followed by interviews with patients and providers based on the information gathered during the scoping review, and, finally, validation by expert consultation. A scoping review was considered the most appropriate, given the novelty of the area of study and the scarcity of relevant articles, to capture anecdotal experiences and to define clinical attachment and differentiate it from other attachments. 2.1. Scoping Review This scoping review activity, conducted in September and October of 2025, followed an enhanced modelling [16] of the Arksey and O’Malley framework (2005) [17] and included peer-reviewed literature from databases, search engines such as Google Scholar, snowball searches of the references of other literature, and grey literature sources. PubMed, MEDLINE, ProQuest, ScienceDirect, and JSTOR databases were searched, following PRISMA-ScR guidance [18]. Grey literature searches were conducted through Google and other references. Databases, search terms and Boolean Operators were reviewed and guided by an academic librarian at Seneca College in Toronto. The search strategy details are available in Appendix B. The inclusion criteria required articles in English (published in English or with an English translation available) that examined the concepts of attachment to primary care and attachment readiness within primary healthcare systems in Canada or other countries with comparable health care systems. Considering the relative scarcity of relevant literature and rapidly changing strategies for health system reforms and attachment initiatives, articles published in the last 15 years were included. Exceptions were made for seminal articles or articles of high relevance and value. Studies were excluded from this review if they did not address tools or practices that were grounded in evidence, full texts were not available, and scientific rigour was not validated during quality checks by the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) checklist [19] (Figure 1). The conventional five-step strategy of scoping review practice (identifying the research questions, identifying relevant studies, selecting eligible studies, charting the data, and collating, summarizing, and reporting the results) was strengthened by adding four practice-based components. First, the PRISMA-ScR guidelines were incorporated to systematically screen, sort, and select relevant articles retrieved from databases. Second, Flicker and Nixon’s collaborative data analysis approach was adopted to minimize individual researcher bias and reduce variability in interpretations among researchers. Third, the traditional role of the principal investigator was shifted to an “insider–outsider” perspective, which helped limit the investigator’s influence on the data analysis process, to resolve disputes among researchers, and to triangulate findings [20]. Finally, the CASP checklist was integrated as a quality monitoring tool to ensure the rigour and credibility of the review process and its outcomes. Identified literature was manually screened for duplicates and for eligibility by one independent reviewer (P.Y.). Articles were then exported into MyBib (https://www.mybib.com/, accessed on 18 September 2025), a citation management website, to sort through relevant articles. Grey literature sources were assessed for relevance and credibility based on authoring organization, publication date, and alignment with the review’s focus on attachment. Specific sources include government reports and policy documents. A reflexive thematic approach was conducted on the extracted articles and included themes surrounding attachment and its impacts, facilitators, barriers, readiness, and other characteristics [21]. Reflexive thematic analysis positions researcher subjectivity as a valuable resource and views coding as inherently interpretive rather than fixed [22]. 2.2. Qualitative—Semi-Structured Interviews This study further employed a qualitative descriptive design using semi-structured, in-depth interviews to explore attachment readiness to primary care from the perspectives of 8 patients, two physicians from two private clinics, one physician from a community health centre and two project managers. A qualitative approach was selected to capture participants’ experiences, perceptions, and interpretations of attachment and onboarding processes within real-world primary care contexts [21]. 2.3. Participant Sampling and Recruitment This study used a purposive snowball sampling approach with intentional design to ensure heterogeneity and maximum variation [23]. This strategy was used to recruit participants with direct experience of primary care attachment processes. Sampling aimed to capture diverse perspectives from patients and providers relevant to attachment readiness. Sampling continued until information power was achieved, defined as the point at which additional interviews did not yield substantively new insights relevant to attachment readiness [24]. Patients were recruited through the Access Alliance Multicultural Healthcare Centre and were either randomly phoned or approached by staff or study team members, who provided information about the study. Patients were eligible to participate if they had recently sought attachment to a primary care provider or had experienced onboarding or intake processes related to primary care attachment. Providers were recruited via professional networks, organizational contacts, and email invitations. Primary healthcare providers and staff were eligible if they were involved in patient attachment, intake, onboarding, or panel management and practised in private primary care clinics, community health centres, or team-based primary care settings. Interested individuals were contacted directly by the research team. 2.4. Data Collection Data collection began between October 2025 and December 2025. Interviews were conducted by a trained qualitative researcher (P.Y.). An interview guide was developed based on the study objectives and existing literature on primary care attachment and attachment readiness. The guide included open-ended questions and probes exploring perceptions of readiness, administrative processes, barriers and facilitators, and suggestions for improvement. Interviews were conducted in person or virtually (by phone/video), depending on participants’ preferences and availability. Interviews lasted approximately 30–60 min and were audio-recorded with participant consent. Field notes were taken during and immediately after interviews to capture contextual details and initial analytic impressions. The thematic analysis was performed using an iterative, inductive approach, ensuring a reflexive process [21]. The analysis was conducted manually by one researcher (P.Y.), with codes being developed using the interview guide and discussions with the principal investigator. 3. Result 3.1. Scoping Review Findings: Characteristics of Included Studies After the removal of duplicates, the search yielded 86 studies. Once screening commenced, 38 were excluded, leaving 48 studies screened for eligibility. After 24 articles were excluded, 24 peer-reviewed literature articles remained (Figure 1). An additional 10 grey literature articles were identified. Most studies for both peer review (n = 14/24, 58%) and grey literature (n = 9/10, 90%) were based in Canada. Other articles from outside of Canada were in the context of other comparable health systems or discussed multiple countries (Figure 2). In particular, they were from Iran, the Netherlands, New Zealand, France, China, and Indonesia (n = 6/24, 25%). A summary table of themes is available in Appendix B. 3.1.1. Attachment and Influencing Factors Attachment in primary care refers to a provider’s responsibility for continuous, comprehensive patient care, with the linking process known as enrollment, empanelment, or rostering [25,26]. Terminology varies globally, with China using the Family Doctor System with “contracting,” the Netherlands using “registration,” some countries using gatekeeping models, and others relying on voluntary attachment [27,28]. Strong primary care access supports equitable, cost-effective outcomes through prevention and early treatment [29]. Attachment is influenced by factors such as patient awareness, trust in the healthcare system, life transitions, provider attitudes, and cultural preferences, including mistrust of general practitioners compared to specialists [10,30,31]. 3.1.2. Barriers and Facilitators to Attachment Attachment to primary care is shaped by a range of barriers and facilitators, particularly those related to the social determinants of health [32]. Factors such as immigration status, experiences of discrimination by service providers, and broader social and economic conditions can limit individuals’ ability or willingness to attach to a provider [33]. At the same time, membership in supportive communities can facilitate attachment by providing information, encouragement, and navigation support. Additional challenges, including a lack of knowledge about how to access primary care and logistical issues such as transportation, scheduling, and system complexity, further influence whether individuals can establish and maintain attachment [32,34]. 3.1.3. Characteristics of an Attachment-Ready Provider An attachment-ready primary healthcare provider is one who has the capacity, through appropriate panel size, staffing, and team composition, needed to take on new patients while ensuring availability, longitudinal care, and coordination across the patient’s healthcare journey [35]. Their team and infrastructure support continuity through tools such as EMR tracking, follow-up systems, proactive outreach, and care coordination. They also have efficient onboarding processes that enable understanding patients’ histories and contexts, insurance verification, timely scheduling, patient education, and clear communication of clinic policies [35]. Beyond operational readiness, these providers demonstrate a commitment to meeting diverse patient needs, including a willingness to accept patients regardless of background or disease complexity, even though they tend to prefer less complex cases [8]. They take accountability for ongoing, continuous care, are comfortable working within patient-panel and team-based care models, and are equipped to address social and clinical complexity. Additionally, they support improved access by offering care beyond regular office hours and aligning with remuneration models, such as capitation, that account for patient size and complexity [26]. 3.2. Findings from Qualitative Interviews The scoping review findings were reinforced through a qualitative approach, using semi-structured, in-depth interviews to explore attachment readiness to primary care from the perspectives of patients and primary healthcare providers. 3.2.1. Attachment Readiness from Patient, Provider, and System Perspectives Attachment readiness emerged across all interviews as a process rather than a single event, shaped by interactions among patient need, provider capacity, onboarding practices, and system-level supports. Findings from patients, physicians, onboarding staff, and program managers collectively illustrate how readiness is constructed, constrained, and supported at multiple points along the attachment pathway. 3.2.2. Patient Perspectives: Readiness Driven by Need, Experience, and Uncertainty From the patient perspective, attachment readiness was rooted in the recognition that episodic or fragmented care was insufficient to meet ongoing health needs. Patients described specific triggers that prompted them to seek attachment, including the need for routine cancer screening, persistent unmanaged pain, hypertension, mental health concerns, and delays in diagnostic follow-up. Prior reliance on walk-in clinics was commonly described as inadequate for continuity, reinforcing the need for a consistent primary care provider. Social and contextual experiences further shaped readiness. Patients described traumatic community events, legal and psychosocial challenges, and the COVID-19 pandemic as moments that clarified the importance of having an attached provider capable of understanding complex, intersecting needs. For these patients, readiness was not abstract but urgent and grounded in lived experience. Despite both patients’ and providers’ readiness, patients described system-level barriers that disrupted attachment. These included long waits for acceptance, delays in scheduling a first appointment, and repeated requests to restate information already provided in shared records, all of which extended onboarding time. While many patients felt personally prepared to complete registration and intake forms, their readiness was undermined by prolonged waiting periods between application and acceptance, as well as other barriers, including language and digital literacy (Table A1 in Appendix A). These barriers persisted for individuals when completing intake and registration forms and booking appointments online. The reported wait times ranged from one to seven months, during which patients experienced uncertainty, limited communication, and difficulty identifying whom to contact for updates. Inconsistent information from front-desk staff further contributed to frustration and, in some cases, regret over changing providers. These delays and ambiguities strained readiness despite patients’ motivation to attach. Patients also identified communication and system navigation as ongoing challenges even after attachment. Difficulty reaching clinics by phone, unanswered calls, long hold times, and confusion about follow-up care disrupted continuity of care. In some cases, patients were removed from clinic rosters after a prolonged absence, without a clear understanding of their status, resulting in re-registration and further destabilizing attachment. Despite these barriers, patients reported that attachment readiness was strengthened when onboarding staff and providers demonstrated empathy, patience, and preparedness. Reviewing medical histories in advance, facilitating interpreter support, allowing sufficient time during first visits, and addressing both physical and psychosocial concerns reinforced patients’ sense of being understood and supported. The first clinical encounter proved critical in solidifying readiness and attachment. Patients also highlighted the need for greater onboarding capacity, dedicated staff to manage intake and phone communication, and prioritization based on urgency or clinical need. 3.2.3. Physician Perspectives: Readiness Constrained by Capacity and Administrative Burden Physicians described attachment readiness as closely tied to clinic capacity, administrative workload, and the availability of support structures. In private community clinics, onboarding new patients was characterized as substantial, unpaid and often invisible work, encompassing chart creation, consent management, portal registration, medication reconciliation, and retrieval of external records. This work competed directly with clinical responsibilities and influenced decisions about accepting new patients. Physicians emphasized deliberate efforts to structure onboarding through meet-and-greet appointments, policy explanations, and repeated communication of expectations. However, reliance on voicemail and email disadvantaged patients with limited digital access, necessitating repeated explanations and increasing workload. Capacity limitations led many clinics to restrict acceptance to specific groups, such as children or family members of existing patients, highlighting ethical tensions between the desire to help and practical constraints. In community health centres and team-based models, readiness was shaped differently but remained constrained by system factors. Physicians reported limited real-time information on onboarding timelines, eligibility criteria, and capacity changes, which reduced their ability to provide clear guidance to patients. Staffing changes, such as leaves, could rapidly alter onboarding capacity, creating pauses that were difficult to communicate transparently. Across settings, physicians identified administrative overload as a persistent barrier. Even when supportive intake roles were introduced, workload shifted rather than disappeared, often without additional staffing. Bottlenecks during first visits—including insufficient buffer time, late arrivals, and missing records—further strained readiness and disrupted clinic flow. Physicians consistently noted that attachment readiness would improve when information was gathered, organized, and entered into electronic medical records prior to the physician encounter. From the onboarding staff’s perspective, attachment readiness began when patients recognized the need for a family doctor and submitted an application. Readiness was conceptualized as a process dependent on accurate assessment, eligibility screening, and completeness of information, rather than as a single step. Onboarding staff emphasized prioritization and fast-tracking those needing immediate care, while processing standard intake pathways. Otherwise, there may be a risk of “readiness decay” among patients, particularly if they are newcomers, refugees, or members of equity-deserving populations. Staff reported the need to repeat and rephrase questions to verify accuracy, particularly when language barriers, literacy challenges, or interpreter-mediated communication were present. Even English-speaking patients sometimes provided excessive or irrelevant documentation, increasing intake time. In cases involving illiteracy, staff relied on family members or children, further extending onboarding appointments. Onboarding staff acknowledged that repeating questions already captured on registration forms was necessary to ensure reliability for physician screening. Obtaining prior medical records with patient consent added further coordination demands. While most patients were described as cooperative, inconsistent or unclear responses delayed progression through onboarding and affected readiness. Onboarding staff suggested that earlier physician involvement and more structured registration forms could improve efficiency and reduce task repetition. However, they clarified that intake remained primarily administrative, with physicians assuming responsibility for detailed clinical questioning later in the attachment process. 3.2.4. Program Manager Perspectives: Readiness as a System-Enabled Condition Program managers framed attachment readiness as a system-supported, relational process contingent on the alignment of patient preparedness, provider capacity, and intermediary supports. In private clinic contexts, readiness was enhanced through attachment liaison roles, often staffed by registered nurses, who conducted early assessments, consolidated histories, completed preventive care tasks, and coordinated referrals prior to the first physician visit. These supports reduced physician burden and increased willingness to accept new patients. Within community health centre settings, readiness was described as emerging through holistic engagement and stabilization rather than discrete onboarding events. Roles such as holistic navigation counsellors supported patients with intersecting health and social needs, fostering continuity and trust before formal attachment. In this model, readiness is developed through sustained engagement rather than immediate physician attachment. Across both contexts, program managers emphasized the importance of intermediary roles, centralized intake mechanisms, standardized data collection, and structured communication. Readiness was consistently described not as an individual attribute but as an emergent outcome of coordinated systems that supported both patients and providers at the point of attachment. 3.3. Triangulated Results Below is a synthesis of the attachment efforts across Canada pilots and international models found in our scoping review and interviews (Table 1). Findings were consolidated separately to identify key characteristics including facilitators and barriers related to primary care attachment. These findings were then converged to develop and refine core themes. Interview findings further provided contextual insight that extended patterns identified in the literature. A full summary of these models is available in Appendix A. Conversely, the literature identifies facilitators that enhance readiness, including team-based primary care models, patient navigation supports, culturally responsive outreach, and structured onboarding processes. Collectively, these findings support the conceptualization of attachment readiness as a system-enabled condition that must be intentionally supported through coordinated policy, organizational design, and practice-level interventions. Our qualitative findings support these findings. Even when patients are motivated, informed, and willing to attach, prolonged waiting periods and lack of communication undermine their readiness. This aligns with evidence that unattached patients experience frustration, disengagement, and a breakdown in trust during prolonged attachment processes. Attachment is not solely constrained by physician supply but is also limited by readiness conditions that shape whether attachment efforts succeed or fail. Our interviews also highlighted readiness as time-sensitive, suggesting that attachment initiatives that do not account for delays risk losing prepared patients, a dimension less explicitly addressed in prior work. 4. Discussion This study and analysis were conducted using data on residents of Ontario; however, they have significant implications for equity-deserving populations, such as newcomers, refugees, and people without status. Across jurisdictions and health system models, attachment readiness emerges as a relational, process-oriented, and context-dependent construct. While attachment is widely defined as the formal enrollment or registration of patients with a primary care provider or team, the literature consistently indicates that attachment alone does not ensure effective or sustained primary care relationships. We tested the strategies against the context to move Canadian primary care policy from a “volume-based matching” model to an “equity-driven readiness” model that ensures sustainable longitudinal patient–provider relationships. Current centralized waiting lists (CWLs) often treat attachment as a binary administrative event (matched/unmatched). However, evidence shows that without readiness, these matches frequently fail, leading to:Patient Disengagement: Trust erodes during long wait times with zero communication.Provider Burnout: Excessive uncompensated administrative labour during onboarding.System Inequity: Marginalized populations face higher barriers to establishing stable care. Patient Disengagement: Trust erodes during long wait times with zero communication. Patient Disengagement: Trust erodes during long wait times with zero communication. Provider Burnout: Excessive uncompensated administrative labour during onboarding. Provider Burnout: Excessive uncompensated administrative labour during onboarding. System Inequity: Marginalized populations face higher barriers to establishing stable care. System Inequity: Marginalized populations face higher barriers to establishing stable care. The review further demonstrates that readiness is shaped by the interaction of patient-level factors (such as health literacy, trust, documentation, and logistical capacity), provider-level factors (including panel capacity, staffing, onboarding processes, and willingness to accept complex cases), and system-level conditions (such as workforce supply, centralized waiting-list design, and availability of team-based supports). Our interview findings corroborated the scoping review findings that patient readiness is influenced by health literacy, trust, documentation, and logistical capacity. These interrelated factors indicate that readiness cannot be reduced to a singular administrative act such as registration or waitlist placement. The review further highlights that attachment initiatives focused primarily on increasing capacity or accelerating patient–provider matching often overlook readiness-related barriers that undermine sustainability. Structural challenges—including workforce shortages, administrative fragmentation, inequities linked to social determinants of health, and inconsistent onboarding practices—continue to limit the effectiveness of attachment efforts with equity needs. Aligning with the existing literature, our findings underscore that policies aimed solely at increasing attachment numbers risk overlooking the foundational role of readiness. Integrating readiness assessments into centralized waitlist algorithms, standardizing electronic onboarding, and supporting providers with capacity-building resources are recommended to improve attachment rates, reduce wasteful disengagement, and advance equitable continuous primary care. Findings across patients, providers, onboarding staff, and program managers demonstrate that attachment readiness is a multi-level, process-oriented construct shaped by information flow, capacity, communication, and system design (Figure 3). Attachment is successful only when the three domains of readiness intersect simultaneously. At the patient level, the strategic priority is to enhance health literacy and build trust in the system through transparent communication. At the provider level, efforts need to focus on strengthening clinic infrastructure and reducing administrative burden, particularly through EMR optimization. At the system level, integrating intermediary “navigator” roles is essential to bridge the gap between patient registration and the first clinical encounter (Figure 3). While patients often arrive motivated and prepared, readiness is constrained by waiting periods, administrative complexity, and unclear communication. Providers and staff navigate competing demands and limited resources, while system-level supports play a critical role in enabling sustainable attachment. From all perspectives, attachment readiness is best understood as a shared condition arising from coordinated onboarding processes rather than from individual readiness alone. After analyzing all data, this study finds that effective policy and implementation need to clearly distinguish attachment readiness from attachment itself, recognizing readiness as a distinct construct across patients, providers, and systems rather than assuming that enrollment alone signals preparedness. Current policy metrics often treat attachment as complete once a patient is formally linked to a provider’s billing number; however, this is a lagging indicator that overlooks whether patients are functionally prepared to sustain a longitudinal care relationship. Our findings suggest that attachment must be preceded by readiness, understood as the patient’s capacity, confidence, and contextual ability to engage in ongoing primary care. As such, health systems should adopt Readiness Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) as leading indicators of successful attachment, including measures such as time from registration to intake completion and patient preparedness scores derived from pre-appointment surveys. Tracking readiness in this way would enable decision-makers to identify systemic bottlenecks, such as prolonged “in-between” stages, before these delays lead to failed or unstable attachments, particularly given that readiness is time-sensitive and may decay amid prolonged uncertainty during onboarding. To operationalize this shift (Table 2), readiness assessments should be embedded into centralized attachment mechanisms such as waiting lists and registries, with standardized data collected at intake and updated over time to improve prioritization and reduce mismatches. At the system level, investment in infrastructure is essential to support readiness across all actors, including interoperable data systems, adequate staffing, and sustained intermediary roles such as navigators and onboarding teams, with successful pilots scaled and replicated across similar organizations. Strengthening patient readiness further requires clear, multimodal communication and navigation support to ensure that information about processes, timelines, and requirements is accessible through both digital and non-digital channels. Provider and practice readiness should be reinforced through structured onboarding, team-based care models, reduced administrative burden, appropriate EMR access for interdisciplinary staff, and alignment of attachment targets with realistic capacity. Standardizing data collection, onboarding workflows, and feedback loops across initiatives enhances consistency and transparency, while ongoing research should continue to refine readiness concepts and tools and embed these measures into evaluations to better understand what drives success or failure. 4.1. Role of Digitalization and Scope of Using AI The above-mentioned options of a centralized intake and a culturally responsive attachment system can be ensured through credible digitalization and an AI platform. Currently, healthcare providers at different levels, such as Family Teams, Community Health Centres, and regional hospitals, use non-transferable EMRs (such as PSSuite) and digital communication or registration platforms (such as OceanMD). Data between these institutions are not transferable, causing clinical service disarray and an administrative burden when attaching new patients. Appropriate use of AI and transferable platforms for data collection and retention is required. 4.2. Limitations The articles that were included were in English only and excluded other languages and definitions that may have been relevant to attachment and primary care systems. Further methodological limitations include varied timeframes, geographic distribution, and reviewers. Timeframe limitations may have excluded relevant policy documents, although an approach prioritizing current literature was taken. Most of the included studies were conducted in Canada, therefore limiting the generalizability of these findings to other contexts and health systems. Further, the barriers and challenges to attachment identified in this review may not adequately reflect the experiences of underrepresented regions. While health systems mobilize to increase patient attachment to primary healthcare, there is a scarcity of studies on attachment readiness, which plays a vital role in successful patient attachment to primary healthcare providers. Moreover, as scoping reviews typically have two reviewers for screening and validation, some articles may not have been captured in this study, and inter-rater reliability was not present. Limitations also persisted in qualitative interviews, including limited geographic settings, which may reduce transferability to other jurisdictions. Given the small number of participants, not all views may be represented. Further, the proposed conceptual framework has not yet been prospectively validated in independent healthcare systems. 5. Conclusions This study contributes to the growing body of literature on primary care attachment by empirically examining attachment readiness from the perspectives of patients, physicians, onboarding staff, and program managers. The implications are more for newcomers, refugees, and other equity-deserving populations. Consistent with existing research, the findings demonstrate that attachment readiness is not a single event or an individual attribute but a multilevel, process-oriented condition, e.g., patients, providers, and the system design. Patients in this study were often motivated and willing to attend; however, readiness was undermined by prolonged waits, unclear communication, and administrative complexity. Providers expressed willingness to accept new patients but identified administrative burden, staffing constraints, and workflow pressures as key limits to readiness. At the system level, structured onboarding roles, centralized coordination, and team-based models emerged as critical facilitators of sustainable attachment, while fragmented processes and limited resources constrained effectiveness. Aligning with the literature, these findings underscore that policies aimed solely at increasing attachment numbers risk overlooking the foundational role of readiness. Attachment initiatives that fail to address readiness may lead to disengagement, inefficient use of resources, and inequitable access, particularly for patients with complex needs. This study reinforces the importance of reframing attachment as a system-enabled relationship rather than a simple administrative match. Embedding attachment readiness into policy design, onboarding processes, and primary care reform efforts is essential to advancing equitable, continuous, and sustainable primary healthcare. In conclusion, achieving equitable, sustainable, and effective primary care in Canada depends on fostering an “attachment-ready ecosystem”. By addressing the barriers identified in this research—ranging from systemic (administrative) burdens on physicians to logistical hurdles in intake—healthcare systems can ensure that, when a patient’s and provider’s needs are each identified, acknowledged, addressed, and finally linked through formal attachment, they are both prepared to sustain a continuous, high-quality healing relationship. By addressing the barriers identified in this research—ranging from systemic physician shortages to the logistical hurdles of intake—healthcare systems can ensure that when a patient and provider are finally linked, they are both prepared to sustain a continuous, high-quality healing relationship. 6. Recommendations for Next Steps: Operational Level To move beyond fragmented care and reliance on high-cost emergency departments, Canadian healthcare policy must evolve. Enhancing attachment requires:Ongoing “Realist Evaluation” for Sustainability: This current, more political, “rapid attachment” strategy has been promulgated as a heuristic decision-making tool to support the ailing residents, conducive to improving the public health system, productivity, and reducing the high burden on the healthcare system. The implementation was rapid and unsynchronized, requiring multi-level, complex evaluation matrices to ensure sustainability. Access Alliance and Alliance for Healthier Communities can jointly conduct this multi-metric evaluation going forward.Standardizing Onboarding: Implementing uniform digital intake processes to reduce repetitive data entry and administrative friction.Prioritizing Vulnerability: Refining centralized waitlist algorithms to account for clinical urgency and social determinants of health rather than simple chronological order.Supporting Provider Capacity: Providing financial and administrative incentives that recognize the labour involved in establishing new longitudinal relationships, particularly for patients with complex needs. Ongoing “Realist Evaluation” for Sustainability: This current, more political, “rapid attachment” strategy has been promulgated as a heuristic decision-making tool to support the ailing residents, conducive to improving the public health system, productivity, and reducing the high burden on the healthcare system. The implementation was rapid and unsynchronized, requiring multi-level, complex evaluation matrices to ensure sustainability. Access Alliance and Alliance for Healthier Communities can jointly conduct this multi-metric evaluation going forward. Ongoing “Realist Evaluation” for Sustainability: This current, more political, “rapid attachment” strategy has been promulgated as a heuristic decision-making tool to support the ailing residents, conducive to improving the public health system, productivity, and reducing the high burden on the healthcare system. The implementation was rapid and unsynchronized, requiring multi-level, complex evaluation matrices to ensure sustainability. Access Alliance and Alliance for Healthier Communities can jointly conduct this multi-metric evaluation going forward. Standardizing Onboarding: Implementing uniform digital intake processes to reduce repetitive data entry and administrative friction. Standardizing Onboarding: Implementing uniform digital intake processes to reduce repetitive data entry and administrative friction. Prioritizing Vulnerability: Refining centralized waitlist algorithms to account for clinical urgency and social determinants of health rather than simple chronological order. Prioritizing Vulnerability: Refining centralized waitlist algorithms to account for clinical urgency and social determinants of health rather than simple chronological order. Supporting Provider Capacity: Providing financial and administrative incentives that recognize the labour involved in establishing new longitudinal relationships, particularly for patients with complex needs. Supporting Provider Capacity: Providing financial and administrative incentives that recognize the labour involved in establishing new longitudinal relationships, particularly for patients with complex needs. 7. Recommendations for Next Steps: System Transformation Level Funding for evaluation for sustainability with redefined metrics: Implement “Readiness Indicators” (e.g., patient health literacy scores, clinic onboarding capacity) as distinct KPIs from raw enrollment data. This shift in the paradigm can ensure a transition from a quantity-based to a value-based framework. Funding for evaluation for sustainability with redefined metrics: Implement “Readiness Indicators” (e.g., patient health literacy scores, clinic onboarding capacity) as distinct KPIs from raw enrollment data. This shift in the paradigm can ensure a transition from a quantity-based to a value-based framework. Fund for intermediary roles: Institutionalize Primary Care Attachment Liaisons and Holistic Navigators to manage the “in-between” stage of the patient journey. Fund for intermediary roles: Institutionalize Primary Care Attachment Liaisons and Holistic Navigators to manage the “in-between” stage of the patient journey. Modified intake algorithm: Create a uniform, provincial digital onboarding protocol to reduce redundant data entry and unpaid physician labour. Modified intake algorithm: Create a uniform, provincial digital onboarding protocol to reduce redundant data entry and unpaid physician labour. Diligence to protect trust: Deploy automated, multimodal updates for patients on waiting lists to prevent “readiness decay” and loss of system confidence. Diligence to protect trust: Deploy automated, multimodal updates for patients on waiting lists to prevent “readiness decay” and loss of system confidence. 8. Recommendations for Next Steps: Future Validation Studies Future research should validate, as an implementation research agenda, the “Primary Care Attachment Readiness Scale for Newcomers and Equity-Deserving Residents” (PCARS-NER). The evaluation matrices can be: Success of attachment (e.g., #new clients, #longitudinal continuity, access utilization, etc.)Attachment readiness (e.g., awareness, administrative readiness, digital readiness, referral, follow-up, etc.)Readiness scoring model (e.g., high, medium, low, etc.)Policy-relevant system (e.g., %unattached, median wait time for attachment, %vulnerable attachment, 12-month sustainability, ER use among attached Vs. unattached, etc.). Future research should validate, as an implementation research agenda, the “Primary Care Attachment Readiness Scale for Newcomers and Equity-Deserving Residents” (PCARS-NER). The evaluation matrices can be: Success of attachment (e.g., #new clients, #longitudinal continuity, access utilization, etc.)Attachment readiness (e.g., awareness, administrative readiness, digital readiness, referral, follow-up, etc.)Readiness scoring model (e.g., high, medium, low, etc.)Policy-relevant system (e.g., %unattached, median wait time for attachment, %vulnerable attachment, 12-month sustainability, ER use among attached Vs. unattached, etc.). Success of attachment (e.g., #new clients, #longitudinal continuity, access utilization, etc.) Success of attachment (e.g., #new clients, #longitudinal continuity, access utilization, etc.) Attachment readiness (e.g., awareness, administrative readiness, digital readiness, referral, follow-up, etc.) Attachment readiness (e.g., awareness, administrative readiness, digital readiness, referral, follow-up, etc.) Readiness scoring model (e.g., high, medium, low, etc.) Readiness scoring model (e.g., high, medium, low, etc.) Policy-relevant system (e.g., %unattached, median wait time for attachment, %vulnerable attachment, 12-month sustainability, ER use among attached Vs. unattached, etc.). Policy-relevant system (e.g., %unattached, median wait time for attachment, %vulnerable attachment, 12-month sustainability, ER use among attached Vs. unattached, etc.). This follow-up research will be a longitudinal study with strong policy advocacy components. This follow-up research will be a longitudinal study with strong policy advocacy components.