Application of [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET/CT to Assess Molecular Calcification and Glucose Metabolism in Thyroid Cartilage Authors: Niloofaralsadat Motamedi, Shashi Bhushan Singh, Miraziz Ismoilov, Saira K Niazi, Bimash B Shrestha, Malia Ahmed, Om H Gandhi, Thomas J Werner, Drew A Torigian, Abass Alavi, Mona-Elisabeth Revheim Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractObjectiveThyroid cartilage calcification and glucose metabolism may vary with age and gender. This study investigated the role of [18F]-sodium fluoride ([18F]NaF) and 2-[18F]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose ([18F]FDG) PET/CT in evaluating of physiological molecular calcification and glucose metabolism of thyroid cartilage with age.MethodsThis retrospective study analyzed [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET/CT images from the CAMONA study (NCT01724749). Regions of interest were placed around the thyroid cartilage on CT images using OsiriX software. The mean standardized uptake value (SUVmean) was measured for [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET/CT images. Pearson correlation coefficients were calculated to evaluate the effects of aging on [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG in the thyroid cartilage.ResultsA total of 127 healthy subjects (65 females and 62 males) with a mean age of 48.46 ± 14.13 (range 21–75) years for [18F]NaF PET/CT and 114 healthy subjects (52 females and 62 males) with a mean age of 49.05 ± 14.29 (range 22–75) years for [18F]FDG PET/CT were included. A significant positive correlation was observed between age and SUVmean of [18F]NaF in the thyroid cartilage (r = 0.18, p = 0.04), indicating that molecular calcification of this cartilage increases with aging. However, the correlation between age and SUVmean of [18F]FDG in the thyroid cartilage was not statistically significant (r = -0.09, p = 0.31).ConclusionThis study presents a novel methodology for the determination of molecular calcification and glucose metabolism of laryngeal cartilage using [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET/CT. Molecular calcification of thyroid cartilage increase with age, whereas glucose metabolism did not show a statistically significant correlation with age.Keywords: positron emission tomography (PET), thyroid cartilage, calcification, glucose metabolism, aging, [18F]NaF, [18F]FDG Introduction The thyroid cartilage (TC) is the largest among the nine cartilages in the larynx and is composed of two plates that meet in the center. It also has superior and inferior horns, which are key landmarks for airway and laryngeal procedures. 1 The progressive process of calcification in the thyroid cartilage, beginning in adolescence and increasing with age, is fully developed in individuals over 70 years.2,3 Positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET/CT) with [18F]-sodium fluoride ([18F]NaF) can measure both blood flow and osteoblast activity in bone and soft tissue. 4 [18F]NaF is well-known for its bone-seeking properties, with high skeletal uptake and quick blood clearance from the circulation following intravenous infusion.5,6 Extraosseous tissues have also shown [18F]NaF uptake in previous studies.7,8 Such accumulation of [18F]NaF has been documented in several settings as a sign of soft tissue calcification.9-11 Physiological calcification tends to build up in tissues such as the choroid plexus, pineal gland, and habenula over a person’s lifetime.12-14 Among the respiratory tract organs, a case report described tracheobronchial tree calcifications as detected on [18F]NaF PET/CT in a 75-year-old woman. 8 However, no attempts have been made to study the calcification of thyroid cartilage using [18F]NaF PET/CT. Explaining the link between [18F]NaF uptake and age in thyroid cartilage will require understanding its underlying physiology. 2-[18F]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose ([18F]FDG) is a radioactive tracer that is becoming increasingly useful in the diagnosis and monitoring of inflammatory diseases, as well as in determining the presence, stage, and biologic behavior of tumors.15,16 However, the uptake of [18F]FDG is an indicator of glucose metabolism not only in inflammatory and cancerous tissues but also in healthy tissues such as the lung, myocardium, liver, spleen, bone marrow, and cartilage. 5 Several studies have reported that [18F]FDG uptake imaged by PET/CT in healthy tissues before or during treatment is linked to different factors, including possible treatment-related adverse events.17,18 The process of aging and the presence of degenerative diseases have a significant impact on cartilage within the human body. 19 This distinction pertains to the differentiation between the degenerative processes associated with the natural aging of adult cartilage and the alterations that transpire during skeletal growth. The phenomenon of age-related degradation in cartilage, such as those found in the costal, nasal septal, laryngeal, and tracheobronchial regions, has been documented in diverse mammalian species. 19 The pathogenesis of degenerative joint disease proposes that articular cartilage experiences senescent alterations akin to those observed in extra-articular cartilage. The process of localized calcification and endochondral ossification in costal cartilage with advancing age has been documented. Fibrillation, which is distinguished by the presence of minute irregularities on the surface of cartilage, serves as an initial indication of cartilage deterioration in the context of aging and degenerative processes. 19 While significant research has been performed on the use of various anatomical locations for determining an individual’s age, such as in rib cartilage, which becomes more calcified with age, there is relatively little literature on the use of the thyroid cartilage for age estimation.20-22 The thyroid cartilage gradually calcifies as individuals age. 23 Previous studies on age estimation from laryngeal cartilage calcification have reported contradictory results, with some finding a significant correlation between age and laryngeal cartilage calcification and others finding it to be an unreliable method. 24 Further research on different population groups is needed to better understand laryngeal cartilage calcification in relation to age. Because [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET/CT are routinely acquired for oncologic and some cardiovascular indications, characterizing the normal age-related calcification and glucose metabolism of the thyroid cartilage on these examinations may aid the interpretation of incidental laryngeal findings and inform approaches to age estimation. This study aims to achieve two objectives: 1) to develop a method for measuring the molecular calcification and glucose metabolism of thyroid cartilage and 2) to examine the correlation between aging and the molecular calcification and glucose metabolism of this cartilage. Materials and Methods Subjects This retrospective cross-sectional study examined a total of 139 healthy subjects from the study known as “Cardiovascular Molecular Calcification Assessed by [18F]NaF PET/CT (CAMONA)” (NCT01724749). The CAMONA study recruited subjects from 2012 to 2016. The study was approved by the Danish National Committee on Health Research Ethics. All subjects gave written consent, and the Declaration of Helsinki was met. To enroll healthy patients in the CAMONA study, the exclusion criteria were the presence of malignancy, immunodeficiency syndromes, autoimmune disease, alcohol abuse, any symptoms suggesting cardiovascular disease, illicit drug use, pregnancy, or any prescription medication. Due to technical issues (incomplete data sets and insufficient image quality), 12 subjects from the [18F]NaF group and 25 subjects from the [18F]FDG group were excluded from further analysis. PET/CT Imaging All participants underwent whole-body [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET/CT acquisition on two different days within two weeks. In brief, [18F]NaF PET/CT imaging was performed 90 minutes after the injection of 2.2 MBq/kg of [18F]NaF with 2.5 min/bed. After fasting overnight for at least 8 hours and confirming serum glucose concentration < 8 mmol/L, [18F]FDG PET/CT imaging was performed 180 minutes after the injection of 4 MBq/kg of [18F]FDG with 3.5 min/bed. The following scanners with compatible full-body spatial resolutions were used for image acquisition: GE Discovery RX, STE, and 690/710 imaging systems (General Electric Healthcare, Milwaukee, WI, USA). PET was adjusted for attenuation, scatter, scanner dead time, and random coincidences. For attenuation correction and anatomical alignment, low-dose CT imaging (140 kVp, 30-110mA, noise index 25, 0.8 seconds per rotation, slice thickness 3.75 mm) was performed. Image Processing A trained physician, who was blinded to the subjects’ demographics and clinical history, manually placed regions of interest (ROI) around the thyroid cartilage in each axial slice using a DICOM viewer (OsiriX MD Software; Pixmeo SARL, Bernex, Switzerland) (Figure 1). The mean standardized uptake value (SUVmean) was calculated from the ROI in each axial slice. Each subject’s SUVmean was given as the average value of all voxels measured within all ROIs placed on thyroid cartilage combined. SUVmean was selected rather than SUVmax because it reflects the average tracer activity across the entire delineated cartilage and therefore provides a more representative measure of the diffuse physiological calcification and glucose metabolism of the structure, whereas SUVmax reflects only the single highest-activity voxel and is more susceptible to image noise and statistical variability. Regions of interest placed around the thyroid cartilage in axial slices during segmentation Data Analysis Pearson correlation coefficient was calculated to test for association between SUVmean and age for both [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET. A p-value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant. For visualization, scatterplots and exploratory univariable linear regressions were used. Results A total of 127 subjects (65 females and 62 males) with a mean age of 48.46 ± 14.13 (range 21–75) years for [18F]NaF PET/CT and a total of 114 healthy subjects (52 females and 62 males) with a mean age of 49.05 ± 14.29 (range 22–75) years for [18F]FDG PET/CT were identified. Physiological molecular calcification and glucose metabolism of thyroid cartilage were measured with [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET/CT, respectively. The study showed that age was positively correlated with SUVmean of [18F]NaF in the thyroid cartilage in a mixed-gender group (r = 0.18, p = 0.04) and that the correlation was not significant with [18F]FDG uptake in a mixed-gender group (r = -0.09, p = 0.31). When the subjects were divided based on gender, a significant positive correlation was observed in females (r = 0.28, p = 0.023) for the [18F]NaF uptake. Although a positive trend was observed in the male group, the correlation was not significant (r = 0.13, p = 0.32) (Table 1) (Figure 2). For the [18F]FDG uptake, a significant negative correlation was observed in males (r = -0.31, p = 0.01), but the correlation was not significant in females (r = 0.07, p = 0.63) (Table 2) (Figure 3). Table 1.Pearson Correlation Between [18F]NaF Uptake in Thyroid Cartilage and Age for Different GroupsGroupPearson correlation coefficient (r)P-valueMixed-Gender0.180.04Female0.280.023Male0.130.32 Pearson Correlation Between [18F]NaF Uptake in Thyroid Cartilage and Age for Different Groups Scatterplots illustrating the relationships between [18F]NaF uptake and age in different gender groups: (A) mixed-gender, (B) female, and (C) male Table 2.Pearson Correlation Between [18F]FDG Uptake in Thyroid Cartilage and Age for Different GroupsGroupPearson correlation coefficient (r)P-valueMixed-Gender-0.090.31Female0.070.63Male-0.310.01 Pearson Correlation Between [18F]FDG Uptake in Thyroid Cartilage and Age for Different Groups Scatterplots illustrating the relationships between [18F]FDG uptake and age in different gender groups: (A) mixed-gender, (B) female, and (C) male Discussion Aging involves functional processes and anatomical changes that do not represent disease in elderly asymptomatic patients, including cartilage calcification. Aging is associated with a wide range of metabolic changes, including alterations in glucose metabolism and metabolic rate. Our study presents a novel methodology for the non-invasive quantification of molecular calcification and glucose metabolism of laryngeal cartilage using [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET/CT. To our knowledge, this is the first study to assess the effects of aging on the uptake of [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG in the thyroid cartilage. Several studies have discussed changes in calcification and glucose metabolism in thyroid cartilage based on CT and PET1,2,25,26; however, none of them have used PET/CT imaging. In the current study, we found a significant positive correlation between age and SUVmean of [18F]NaF uptake in the thyroid cartilage in a mixed-gender group, indicating an increase in molecular calcification of this cartilage with aging. Moreover, [18F]NaF uptake in our study demonstrated a significant positive correlation in females. Although the male group showed an upward tendency, the correlation was non-significant. However, [18F]FDG metabolism of this cartilage did not show a statistically significant correlation with age. The study’s findings are significant as they suggest that [18F]NaF PET/CT imaging can be used to measure molecular calcification in the thyroid cartilage. Calcification of the thyroid cartilage is a process that occurs as a part of normal aging, where the cartilage undergoes mineralization and hardening. 27 Our study demonstrated a significant positive correlation between age and [18F]NaF uptake in females. Although the male group demonstrated a positive trend, the correlation was non-significant, and the underlying reasons are not clear. Available findings in the literature suggest that there may be differences in the calcification of the thyroid cartilage in females and males. Studies have investigated these potential differences with varying results. One study has found that there is a lower prevalence and degree of calcification in females compared to males, 27 while another has found no significant difference between the two genders. 2 One possible explanation for these discrepancies may be differences in the age and health status of the study participants. 2 For example, some studies may have included older individuals with more advanced stages of calcification, which could skew the results towards one gender. Similarly, there could be hormonal factors (for example, effects of sex hormones) impacting the degree of cartilage calcification among females and males. 28 The reaction of cartilage to estrogen administration has been studied. 29 Although researchers have identified sex hormone receptors for 17β-estradiol, progesterone, and testosterone in human chondrocytes, as well as in immortalized chondrocyte cell lines, there is still limited understanding of how sex hormones affect cartilage metabolism. 28 Understanding the exact mechanism by which hormonal factors may affect the calcification of thyroid cartilage will require further investigation. Shehu et al examined the normal molecular calcification of the costal cartilage in relation to age and sex using [18F]NaF PET/CT in the CAMONA subjects, similar to our study. 22 Both sexes had an age-related increase in calcification using [18F]NaF PET/CT measures, but only men had a substantial age-related increase in calcification when they performed CT measures. 22 This highlights that although the calcification of cartilage is age-related, there is a possibility that the calcification pattern of cartilage in females and males may vary depending on the type/location of cartilage studied. For example, costal cartilage, which is probably more prone to damage and calcification in males, may have resulted in this finding. Overall, while there is some evidence to suggest that there may be differences in the calcification of the thyroid cartilage between females and males, the exact nature of these differences remains unclear. Further research is needed to better understand the underlying mechanisms and potential implications of these gender differences. It is worth noting that the [18F]FDG metabolism of the thyroid cartilage did not exhibit a statistically significant correlation with age in the mixed-gender group. After separating the subjects into groups based on gender, a significant negative correlation for [18F]FDG uptake was seen in the male group but not in the female group. From a clinical standpoint, [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG PET/CT are already widely performed for oncologic, inflammatory, and cardiovascular indications, so the thyroid cartilage can be evaluated opportunistically from existing acquisitions without additional cost, scanning time, or radiation exposure to the patient. Establishing reference patterns of physiological, age-related calcification and glucose metabolism in the thyroid cartilage may help readers avoid misinterpreting incidental laryngeal uptake on such examinations as pathology, and may complement existing computed tomography- and autopsy-based approaches to forensic age estimation. Although PET/CT is not available in every center, these observations are intended not to introduce a new dedicated examination but to add value to scans that are already being obtained. Our study has some limitations. Firstly, the sample size was relatively small. Additionally, while the study showed promising results, there are limitations to the methodology and delineation of the ROIs. For example, adjacent tissues near the cartilage, like thyroid tissue, could also have radiotracer uptake, making it difficult to completely exclude overlapping radiotracer uptake in the cartilage of interest. Given the study’s limitations, future studies with larger sample sizes and more diverse populations may be needed to confirm these findings. Conclusion Our findings indicate that increasing age is associated with an increase in [18F]NaF uptake in the thyroid cartilage in the mixed-gender and female groups, and with a significant decrease in [18F]FDG uptake in the male group. These data support a potential role for [18F]NaF and [18F]FDG in assessing molecular calcification and glucose metabolism in thyroid cartilage. The ability to determine age-related trends in these processes may aid the interpretation of incidental thyroid cartilage uptake on PET/CT performed for other indications and may complement existing methods of laryngeal age estimation, while the gender-specific variations observed warrant consideration in future work. Extending this methodology to other cartilaginous structures throughout the body may further our understanding of age-related changes and gender-related differences in cartilage physiology. Footnotes Funding: The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. ORCID iDs Shashi Bhushan Singh https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5536-0869 Mona-Elisabeth Revheim https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3300-7420 Ethical Considerations The Danish National Committee on Health Research Ethics approved the “Cardiovascular Molecular Calcification Assessed by [18F]NaF PET/CT (CAMONA)” study (NCT01724749). Consent to Participate All participants gave written, informed consent, and the Declaration of Helsinki was met. Consent for Publication Informed consent for publication was provided by the participants. Data Availability Statement Data can be made available by requesting the corresponding author.* References Associated Data Data Availability Statement Data can be made available by requesting the corresponding author.*