Radiographic and clinical factors associated with open reduction in pediatric supracondylar humerus fractures Authors: Emre Kocazeybek, Mehmet Ersin, Yasin Doğan, Furkan Savran, Abdülhamid Tatlı, Mehmet Ekinci Published: 2026 ABSTRACT BACKGROUNDThe aim of this study was to evaluate demographic and radiographic factors associated with the likelihood of open reduction in pediatric supracondylar humerus fractures (SCHF).METHODSA total of 294 pediatric patients with SCHFs treated operatively between 2016 and 2025 were retrospectively reviewed. Patients were divided into two groups: Open reduction (OR, n=128) and closed reduction (CR, n=166). Demographic variables, including age, sex, side of injury, and surgeon experience, were recorded. Radiographic parameters assessed on preoperative anteroposterior and lateral elbow radiographs included fracture type, displacement direction, rotational deformity, diaphyseal involvement, coronal fracture pattern, sagittal fracture pattern, and coronal alignment. Variables with p<0.05 in univariate analysis were included in a multivariable logistic regression model using a backward stepwise method.RESULTSThe mean age was significantly higher in the OR group compared to the CR group (6.94±2.85 vs. 5.58±2.64 years, p<0.001). Flexion-type fractures were more frequent in the OR group (24.2% vs. 10.2%, p=0.012). Posterolateral displacement and rotational deformity were also significantly associated with open reduction. Coronal alignment differed significantly between groups, with varus and valgus malalignment more common in the OR group (p=0.003). Multivariable logistic regression analysis identified increasing age (OR=1.127, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.029–1.236; p=0.010), flexion-type fractures (OR=1.807, 95% CI: 1.261–2.590; p=0.001), and posterolateral displacement (OR=1.39, 95% CI: 1.010–1.926; p=0.043) as independent predictors of open reduction. In contrast, neutral coronal alignment was associated with a lower likelihood of open reduction (OR=0.681, 95% CI: 0.510–0.909; p=0.009).CONCLUSIONSeveral demographic and fracture-related characteristics were independently associated with the likelihood of open reduction in pediatric SCHFs. Among these, fracture-related characteristics, particularly displacement pattern and coronal alignment, showed the strongest associations with open reduction. Recognition of these associated factors may assist preoperative planning and help surgeons anticipate technically challenging reductions. INTRODUCTION Supracondylar humerus fractures (SCHFs) represent one of the most common elbow injuries in the pediatric population and account for a substantial proportion of pediatric orthopedic trauma.[1] These injuries most commonly occur following a fall onto an outstretched hand, typically resulting in extension-type fractures, whereas flexion-type injuries are relatively uncommon and are often associated with direct trauma to the elbow.[2,3] The primary goal of treatment is to achieve and maintain anatomical reduction to restore alignment and prevent long-term complications such as malunion, neurovascular compromise, and functional limitation. Closed reduction and percutaneous pinning (CRPP) is widely accepted as the standard treatment for displaced SCHFs.[4] However, in certain cases, satisfactory reduction cannot be achieved or maintained with closed techniques, necessitating conversion to open reduction.[5] Open reduction is generally associated with increased soft-tissue dissection, longer operative time, and a potentially higher risk of complications.[6] Therefore, identifying factors that may predict the need for open reduction is of considerable clinical importance for preoperative planning and surgical decision-making. A considerable number of studies have investigated predictors of open reduction in pediatric SCHFs. Various quantitative and qualitative parameters have been reported in the literature, including clinical, demographic, and radiographic factors.[7-11] Among these, fracture displacement pattern, rotational deformity, and instability have been suggested to influence the difficulty of achieving and maintaining closed reduction (CR).[12] However, despite the growing body of evidence, the findings remain heterogeneous, and no clear consensus has been established regarding which radiographic features reliably predict the need for open reduction. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the demographic and radiographic factors associated with the need for open reduction in pediatric SCHFs. We hypothesized that increasing fracture instability as reflected by radiographic features and fracture patterns would be associated with a higher likelihood of requiring open reduction. MATERIALS AND METHODS Patients and Study Design This retrospective study included pediatric patients with SCHFs who underwent either CRPP or open reduction between January 2016 and December 2025. The study protocol was approved by the institutional review board (IRB approval no: 9-2026), and all procedures were conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the Declaration of Helsinki. Demographic characteristics, clinical data, fracture classification, and radiographic findings were obtained from hospital databases and patient charts. Radiographic evaluations were performed using images retrieved from the picture archiving and communication system. The inclusion criteria for this study were as follows: (1) Pediatric patients diagnosed with SCHFs treated with either CRPP or open reduction, including Gartland type III extension and flexion-type fractures and (2) availability of adequate preoperative and postoperative radiographs, including anteroposterior and lateral views, suitable for measurement and evaluation. The exclusion criteria were (1) patients managed nonoperatively, (2) delayed surgery due to external referral or medical reasons, (3) history of prior trauma or surgery involving the affected elbow, (4) inadequate radiographic quality for accurate measurements, and (5) neurovascular injuries requiring immediate open reduction. A total of 574 pediatric patients with SCHFs were initially assessed for eligibility. Of these, 280 patients were excluded for the following reasons: Conservative (nonoperative) management (n=215), Gartland type II fractures (n=45), neurovascular injury requiring immediate open reduction (n=5), delayed surgery due to external referral or medical reasons (n=7), and insufficient radiographic or demographic data (n=8). After applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 294 patients who underwent operative treatment were included in the study. These patients were divided into two groups based on the surgical technique: Group I consisted of patients treated with open reduction (n=128) and Group II included those treated with CRPP (n=166) (Fig. 1). Flow diagram of the study. Surgical Technique and Postoperative Management All operations were carried out under general anesthesia with the patient in the supine position. Intravenous cefazolin (30 mg/kg) was administered preoperatively for antibiotic prophylaxis. Fracture reductions and fixations were performed under fluoroscopic guidance. CR was attempted as the initial treatment in all cases. Gentle longitudinal traction was first applied to restore coronal alignment, followed by rotational correction according to the direction of fracture displacement. Sagittal alignment was then achieved by elbow flexion for extension-type fractures or extension for flexion-type fractures. The elbow was maintained in hyperflexion and pronation (Jones position), and reduction was assessed fluoroscopically using anteroposterior and lateral views. Acceptable reduction was defined as restoration of coronal alignment without residual varus or valgus malalignment on the anteroposterior view and satisfactory sagittal alignment, with the anterior humeral line intersecting the middle third of the capitellum on the lateral view. If acceptable reduction could not be achieved or maintained after several attempts at gentle manipulation or if persistent varus or valgus malalignment, rotational deformity, or failure of the anterior humeral line to intersect the middle third of the capitellum remained, conversion to open reduction was performed. Once satisfactory alignment was obtained, fracture fixation was completed using percutaneous Kirschner wires. In our institution, open reduction was typically carried out using medial, lateral or combined approaches, depending on fracture characteristics and surgeon choice. Following open reduction, fixation was again performed with percutaneous Kirschner wires under fluoroscopic control. Postoperatively, the extremity was immobilized in a long-arm splint with the elbow maintained at approximately 90° of flexion. Patients were followed in the outpatient clinic with regular wound care, clinical assessment, and radiographic evaluation. The long-arm splint was removed at approximately the 4th postoperative week, and gradual elbow range-of-motion exercises were initiated. In the absence of delayed union or other complications, Kirschner wires were removed at the 5th postoperative week in the outpatient setting. Outcome Measurements Demographic and radiological parameters Demographic data, including patient age, sex, side of injury, and the operating surgeon’s level of experience, were obtained retrospectively from hospital records and operative reports. Surgeon experience was categorized based on years of clinical practice. The operating surgeon’s experience was stratified into three categories according to years of clinical practice: ≤5 years, 5–10 years, and >10 years. Radiographic parameters were assessed on preoperative anteroposterior and lateral elbow radiographs, including fracture type (extension or flexion), diaphyseal involvement, rotational deformity, and the direction of fracture displacement. Displacement patterns were categorized as posterior (without coronal translation), posteromedial (posterior and medial translation), posterolateral (posterior and lateral translation), or anterior (flexion type), according to the classification of Novais et al.[13] Coronal plane fracture patterns were classified as high transverse, low transverse, medial oblique, or lateral oblique, whereas sagittal plane fracture types were categorized as high or low as originally defined by Bahk et al.[14] Coronal alignment was further assessed on anteroposterior radiographs and categorized as varus, valgus, or neutral. These coronal plane assessments were performed in accordance with previously described methods.[7,14] Radiographic measurements were independently performed by two senior orthopedic trauma surgeons who were blinded to the treatment allocation (open or CR). Interobserver reliability was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). Statistical analysis Statistical analyses were performed using IBM Statistical Package for the Social Sciences Statistics (Version 27.0; IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). The normality of continuous variables was assessed using the Kolmogorov–Smirnov test. Continuous variables were presented as mean±standard deviation and compared using the independent samples t-test or Mann–Whitney U test, as appropriate. Categorical variables were expressed as frequencies and percentages and analyzed using the Chi-square test or Fisher’s exact test. Radiographic measurements were independently performed by two senior orthopedic trauma surgeons who were blinded to the treatment allocation (open or CR). Interobserver reliability was assessed using ICCs based on a two-way mixed-effects model with absolute agreement. The ICCs for the evaluations made by the two observers demonstrated values of 0.83 or higher across all radiographic measurements, indicating good interobserver reliability. Variables found to be significant in univariate analyses (p<0.05) were entered into a multivariable logistic regression model using a backward stepwise (likelihood ratio) method to identify independent predictors of open reduction. Given the presence of multiple correlated categorical subgroups (e.g., displacement patterns and coronal alignment), the stepwise approach was used to reduce potential collinearity and identify the most relevant independent variables. Results were reported as odds ratios (ORs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). A p<0.05 was considered statistically significant. RESULTS A total of 294 patients were included in the study, comprising 128 patients in the open reduction (OR) group and 166 patients in the CR group. The mean age was significantly higher in the OR group compared to the CR group (6.94±2.85 vs. 5.58±2.64 years, p<0.001). There was no significant difference between the groups in terms of side of injury, with right-sided involvement observed in 64 patients (52.9%) in the OR group and 82 patients (50.0%) in the CR group (p=0.91). Similarly, sex distribution was comparable between the groups, with females accounting for 34.4% of the OR group and 36.7% of the CR group (p=0.74). The distribution of operating surgeon experience did not differ significantly between the groups (p=0.251). Surgeons with more than 10 years of experience performed the majority of procedures in both groups (53.1% in OR vs. 40.4% in CR) (Table 1). Table 1Demographic characteristics of the patientAge (years) Mean±SD6.94±2.855.58±2.64p<0.001Min-Max(1.5–13)(1–14)Side (%) Right (R)64 (52.9)82 (50)p=0.91 Left (L)64 (47.1)84 (50)Sex (%) Female44 (34.4)61 (36.7)p=0.74 Male88 (65.6)105 (63.3)Operating surgeon (%)Experience (years) (%) ≤532 (25)53 (31.9)p=0.251 5–1028 (21.9)46 (27.7) ≥10 years68 (53.1)67 (40.4)OR: Open reduction; CR: Closed reduction; SD: Standard deviation. Demographic characteristics of the patient OR: Open reduction; CR: Closed reduction; SD: Standard deviation. Radiographic evaluation revealed significant differences between the groups in terms of fracture type, displacement pattern, rotational deformity, and coronal alignment. Flexion-type fractures were significantly more common in the OR group compared to the CR group (24.2% vs. 10.2%, p=0.012). The distribution of displacement patterns differed significantly between the groups (p<0.001). Posterolateral and anterior displacements were more frequently observed in the OR group, whereas posterior and posteromedial displacements predominated in the CR group. Rotational deformity was significantly more frequent in the OR group compared to the CR group (75% vs. 59%, p=0.038). Diaphyseal involvement tended to be more common in the OR group (25.8% vs. 19.3%); however, this difference was not statistically significant (p=0.183). Coronal fracture pattern and sagittal fracture pattern were comparable between the groups (p=0.075 and p=0.363, respectively). In contrast, coronal alignment differed significantly between the groups (p=0.003), with varus and valgus malalignment observed more frequently in the OR group while neutral alignment predominated in the CR group. Variables identified as significant in the univariate analyses (p<0.05) were entered into a multivariable logistic regression model, and a backward stepwise (likelihood ratio) method was applied to obtain the final model (Table 2). The results of this analysis are summarized in Table 3. Multivariable logistic regression analysis demonstrated that increasing age was significantly associated with a higher likelihood of open reduction (OR=1.127, 95% CI: 1.029–1.236, p=0.010). Similarly, flexion-type fractures were identified as an independent predictor of open reduction, showing increased odds compared to extension-type fractures (OR=1.807, 95% CI: 1.261–2.590, p=0.001). Posterolateral displacement was also significantly associated with a greater likelihood of requiring open reduction (OR=1.39, 95% CI: 1.010–1.926, p=0.043). In contrast, neutral coronal alignment was associated with reduced odds of open reduction, indicating a protective effect (OR=0.681, 95% CI: 0.510–0.909, p=0.009). Table 2Comparison of radiographic parameters between groupsGroup 1 (OR) (n=128) (%)Group 2 (CR) (n=166) (%)pFracture type Extension97 (75.8)149 (89.2)p=0.012 Flexion31 (24.2)17 (10.2)Displacement pattern Anterior27 (21.1)14 (8.4)p<0.001 Posterior27 (21.1)70 (42..2) Posterolateral41 (32)26 (15.7) Posteromedial33 (25.8)56 (33.7)Rotation Present96 (75)98 (59)p=0.038 Absent32 (25)68(41)Diaphyseal ınvolvement Present33 (25.8)32 (19.3)p=0.183 Absent95 (74.2)134 (80.7)Coronal fracture pattern High transverse2330p=0.075 Low transverse72108 Medial oblique1612 Lateral oblique1716Sagittal fracture pattern Low66 (51.6)101 (60.8)p=0.363 High62 (48.4)65 (39.2)Coronal alignment Varus43 (33.6)39 (23.5)p=0.003 Neutral36 (28.1)78 (47) Valgus49 (38.3)49 (29.5)OR: Open reduction; CR: Closed reduction Comparison of radiographic parameters between groups OR: Open reduction; CR: Closed reduction Table 3Results of backward stepwise (likelihood ratio) logistic regression analysis. Only the final step of the model is presented for clarityVariableBSEOR95% CIpAge0.1200.0471.1271.029–1.2360.010Flexion type0.5920.1841.8071.261–2.5900.001Posterolateral displacement0.3330.1651.391.010–1.9260.043Neutral alignment−0.3840.1480.6810.510–0.9090.009SE: Standard error; OR: Odds Ratio; CI: Confidence interval Results of backward stepwise (likelihood ratio) logistic regression analysis. Only the final step of the model is presented for clarity SE: Standard error; OR: Odds Ratio; CI: Confidence interval DISCUSSION In the present study, patient- and fracture-related factors associated with the need for open reduction in pediatric SCHFs were systematically evaluated. It was demonstrated that increasing age, flexion-type fractures, and posterolateral displacement were independently associated with a higher likelihood of open reduction, whereas neutral coronal alignment was found to exert a protective effect. Furthermore, although certain variables, including rotational deformity and displacement characteristics, were found to be significant in univariate analyses, these associations did not persist following multivariable adjustment. Taken together, these findings suggest that the requirement for open reduction is influenced by a complex interplay of patient-specific and radiographic factors rather than a single determinant. In this context, numerous studies have investigated factors associated with the need for open reduction in pediatric SCHFs, identifying a broad range of potential risk factors. Among patient-related variables, age has emerged as a frequently discussed factor; however, the findings regarding its influence on open reduction remain controversial. Oguzkaya et al.[9] reported that increasing age was an independent predictor of failed CR, demonstrating that each 1-year increase in age was associated with approximately a 40% increase in risk (OR≈1.40, p≈0.01). In contrast, Thirakulpakdi et al.[15] reported that patients younger than 8 years of age had a higher likelihood of requiring open reduction, suggesting an inverse relationship between age and reduction success. These conflicting findings indicate that the effect of age may not be linear and could vary depending on fracture characteristics and study populations. In the present study, increasing age emerged as an independent predictor of open reduction, with each additional year associated with a higher likelihood of requiring open reduction, suggesting that older children may experience greater reduction difficulty. Beyond patient-related variables, fracture-specific characteristics have been shown to play a critical role in determining the need for open reduction. Among these, fracture type was identified as one of the most important determinants. Flexion-type fractures have been widely reported in the literature to be associated with a higher likelihood of open reduction, largely due to their inherent instability. In a recent study, Kolac et al.[11] demonstrated that flexion-type fractures were significantly more common in the open reduction group than in the CR group, indicating a strong association between fracture configuration and the need for open reduction. Similarly, Oguzkaya et al.[9] reported that flexion-type fracture configuration was an independent predictor of failed CR (OR=2.644, 95% CI: 1.085–6.440; p=0.032). Furthermore, Latario et al.[10] demonstrated that flexion-type injuries increased the risk of conversion to open reduction more than tenfold (relative risk =10.2). However, recent meta-analytic evidence has yielded more heterogeneous findings, suggesting that although extension-type Gartland IV fractures are strongly associated with open reduction, flexion-type injuries may not independently predict the need for open reduction (OR=2.354, p=0.251). Consistent with several previous studies, flexion-type fractures remained an independent predictor of open reduction in our cohort (OR=1.807), further supporting the concept that fracture instability plays a major role in reduction difficulty. The direction of fracture displacement is another important factor that may significantly influence reduction success and the likelihood of open reduction. The direction of fracture displacement is another important factor that may significantly influence reduction success and the likelihood of open reduction. In this context, previous studies have suggested that lateral displacement patterns, particularly those corresponding to posterolateral translation, are associated with increased reduction difficulty and a higher likelihood of open reduction. Wang et al.[16] reported that distal fragment displacement toward the radial side was an independent risk factor for failed CR, indirectly supporting the clinical importance of posterolateral displacement patterns. More directly, Ondina et al.[4] demonstrated that posterolateral displacement was present in 65.9% of patients who required open reduction and identified it as a key factor associated with conversion to open reduction. In addition, a recent meta-analysis by Transtrum et al.[8] demonstrated that medially displaced fractures were significantly less likely to require open reduction (OR=0.35; 95% CI: 0.15–0.78; p=0.011), indirectly supporting the notion that lateral and posterolateral displacement patterns are associated with an increased risk of open reduction. Consistent with these studies, posterolateral displacement was identified as a factor associated with an increased likelihood of open reduction in our study, with a 1.39-fold higher risk of requiring open reduction. When fracture patterns were considered in our study, both flexion- and extension-type fractures, particularly those with posterolateral displacement corresponding to Gartland type IIIb injuries, were more frequently managed with open reduction, likely due to their inherently unstable nature. These findings further emphasize that instability plays a key role in determining the need for open reduction and should be carefully considered during preoperative planning.[17] In addition, the experience level of the operating surgeon was evaluated to determine whether it influenced the choice between open and CR; however, no significant association was found. This observation is consistent with findings from a recent meta-analysis suggesting that fracture characteristics rather than surgeon-related factors primarily dictate the need for open reduction.[8] Although the decision to proceed with open reduction is ultimately made intraoperatively, it is primarily based on the inability to achieve or maintain an acceptable reduction despite appropriate CR maneuvers. Therefore, the need for open reduction represents a clinically meaningful surrogate of reduction difficulty rather than surgeon preference alone. Nevertheless, surgeon-related factors and intraoperative judgment may still have contributed to the final treatment decision. Accordingly, our findings should be interpreted as identifying fracture characteristics associated with an increased likelihood of open reduction rather than absolute indications for conversion. Among the evaluated variables, coronal fracture alignment emerged as a key independent factor influencing the likelihood of open reduction. In our analysis, preoperative neutral coronal alignment (neither varus nor valgus) was associated with a lower likelihood of requiring open reduction (OR=0.681, 95% CI: 0.510–0.909; p=0.009). This finding indicates that fractures without coronal malalignment are more likely to be successfully managed with CR. Similarly, the importance of coronal alignment has been emphasized in the literature. Colak et al.[7] demonstrated that varus fracture orientation was significantly associated with an increased likelihood of open reduction (OR=3.848, 95% CI: 1.506–9.831; p=0.005). Taken together, these findings highlight that coronal malalignment, particularly varus deformity, increases fracture instability and the likelihood of requiring open reduction. This study has several limitations that should be acknowledged. First, due to its retrospective design, the study is inherently subject to selection and information bias. Second, certain potentially relevant variables, such as injury mechanism severity and soft tissue status, could not be fully evaluated due to limitations in the available records. Furthermore, patients with associated neurovascular injuries were excluded to obtain a more homogeneous study cohort. Consequently, our findings may not be generalizable to patients with more severe injury patterns, and a degree of selection bias cannot be excluded. Third, although radiographic measurements were performed by two experienced trauma surgeons and demonstrated good interobserver reliability, measurement-related variability cannot be completely excluded. Furthermore, although the operating surgeon’s level of experience was evaluated, procedures performed within the study period were conducted by multiple surgeons, which may have introduced heterogeneity in reduction techniques. Variations in surgical experience, technical approach, and individual thresholds for conversion to open reduction may have influenced intraoperative decision-making and introduced potential bias. Finally, as this was a single-center study, the generalizability of the findings may be limited. Nevertheless, the relatively large sample size, the balanced distribution of patients between groups, and the comprehensive assessment of both demographic and radiographic variables strengthen the validity and robustness of our findings. CONCLUSION Several patient and fracture-related characteristics were found to be independently associated with the likelihood of open reduction in pediatric SCHFs. Increasing age, flexion-type fractures, and posterolateral displacement were independently associated with a higher likelihood of open reduction, whereas neutral coronal alignment was associated with a lower likelihood of requiring open reduction. Among these, fracture-related characteristics, particularly those reflecting fracture instability and displacement pattern, showed the strongest associations with open reduction. Recognition of these associated factors may assist preoperative planning and help surgeons anticipate technically challenging reductions.