Multifactorial Non-union After First Metatarsophalangeal Arthrodesis Revised With Structural Iliac Crest Autograft: A Case Report and Comprehensive Literature Review Authors: Georgios Renieris, Natalia Renieri, Athanasios Georgokostas Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractIntroduction:First metatarsophalangeal (MTP-I) arthrodesis is a reliable procedure for end-stage hallux rigidus and selected complex first-ray deformities. Non-union is uncommon but clinically important, particularly when associated with pain, osteolysis, implant fatigue, and loss of correction. Revision is challenging because failure is usually multifactorial rather than the consequence of an isolated implant problem.Case Report:A 62-year-old woman with a 45 pack-year smoking history underwent MTP-I arthrodesis for advanced hallux rigidus with hallux varus and associated lesser-toe deformity. The index procedure used cup-and-cone joint preparation and dorsal plate fixation. Radiographs at 3 months showed maintained alignment but incomplete consolidation. Progressive pain and swelling developed during weight-bearing, and at 6 months radiographs demonstrated dorsal plate breakage. Computed tomography (CT) confirmed established pseudarthrosis with osteolysis involving the base of the proximal phalanx. Before revision, white blood cell count, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, and C-reactive protein were normal; intraoperative cultures obtained during revision were negative. Revision included removal of failed hardware, complete debridement of fibrous pseudarthrosis and sclerotic bone, insertion of a tricortical iliac crest autograft to restore length and bone stock, interfragmentary compression screw fixation, stronger revision dorsal plating, correction of the second-ray deformity, and prolonged post-operative protection. Smoking cessation was achieved after revision.Outcome:The post-operative course was uncomplicated. At 3 months, the patient walked in regular footwear without pain or swelling. CT at 6 months demonstrated graft incorporation, bridging trabecular bone and stable fixation. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society hallux metatarsophalangeal-interphalangeal score improved from 29/100 before revision (pain 0, function 29, and alignment 0) to 85/100 after revision (pain 30, function 40, and alignment 15).Conclusion:Failed MTP-I arthrodesis should be analyzed systematically through biological, mechanical, and whole-forefoot factors. Structural autografting, compression-based revision fixation, correction of associated deformity, and individualized protection can achieve union even after plate breakage and established pseudarthrosis. Learning Point of the Article: This case shows that failure of first metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis may result from combined biological, mechanical, and biomechanical factors rather than a single isolated cause. In a heavy smoker with painful pseudarthrosis, osteolysis, and dorsal plate breakage, revision with debridement, structural tricortical iliac crest autografting, compression screw fixation, revision dorsal plating, correction of associated lesser-ray deformity, and prolonged protection achieved computed tomography-confirmed union and improved the AOFAS-HMI score Introduction First metatarsophalangeal (MTP) arthrodesis is a standard procedure for end-stage hallux rigidus and a reconstructive option in severe deformity, inflammatory arthritis, neuromuscular disease, and failed forefoot surgery [1]. Although union rates are high, non-union can cause pain, swelling, transfer metatarsalgia, implant fatigue, and loss of correction [2,3]. Revision is challenging because bone loss, osteolysis, sclerosis, shortening, malalignment, scarring and failed implants may coexist [3,4]. This case illustrates a multifactorial failed MTP-I fusion treated by biological, mechanical and whole-forefoot reconstruction, followed by a focused literature review and revision framework. Case Report Patient information and initial presentation A 62-year-old woman presented with progressive right MTP-I pain, stiffness and walking limitation after failed conservative treatment. Examination showed advanced hallux rigidus with hallux varus and second-toe varus/claw deformity. Weight-bearing radiographs confirmed end-stage MTP-I arthritis (Fig. 1). Pre-operative weight-bearing anteroposterior and lateral radiographs demonstrating advanced hallux rigidus with hallux varus deformity and associated second- and third-toe deformity. Intraoperative fluoroscopy following primary first metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis performed using cup-and-cone preparation and low-profile dorsal plate fixation. She had a 45 pack-year smoking history. Distal pulses were palpable and arterial duplex ultrasonography was normal. MTP-I arthrodesis was recommended. Index arthrodesis and early post-operative course The index procedure used cup-and-cone preparation and low-profile dorsal plate fixation. Intraoperative alignment was considered satisfactory, with dorsiflexion relative to the floor and neutral transverse alignment relative to the second ray. Postoperatively, she remained non-weight-bearing for 4 weeks before progressive loading. At 3 months, alignment and fixation were maintained, but osseous consolidation was incomplete; retrospectively, dorsiflexion appeared slightly greater than ideal. Diagnosis of failure At 4 months, weight-bearing pain and swelling increased. Radiographs were initially inconclusive, but at 6 months showed dorsal plate fracture and persistent fusion line. Computed tomography (CT) confirmed pseudarthrosis, absent bridging trabecular bone, and proximal phalangeal osteolysis (Fig 2). There were no clinical signs of infection; white blood cell, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, and C-reactive protein were normal. Symptomatic aseptic non-union with implant fatigue failure was diagnosed. Failure of primary arthrodesis. Computed tomography – 3D reconstruction demonstrating established pseudarthrosis with plate breakage. Failure analysis Failure was considered multifactorial. Persistent smoking was the main modifiable biological risk. CT showed local biological failure with pseudarthrosis, sclerosis, and osteolysis. Plate fracture was interpreted as the endpoint of micromotion and cyclic loading, not the primary cause. Subtle sagittal malposition and untreated second-ray deformity may have increased forefoot loading. Revision surgical technique Revision was performed through the previous dorsal approach. Failed hardware was removed, fibrous pseudarthrosis and sclerotic margins were excised, intraoperative cultures were obtained, and all non-viable bone was debrided to bleeding cancellous surfaces. Cultures were negative. Because compression alone would have shortened the first ray, a tricortical iliac crest graft of approximately 1.8 × 1.2 cm was used to restore length and bone stock. Fixation used an interfragmentary compression screw and a stronger dorsal revision plate. The second-ray deformity was corrected with subcapital second metatarsal osteotomy and proximal interphalangeal arthrodesis stabilized by K-wire to improve forefoot balance. A conservative post-operative protocol was used: Eight weeks non-weight-bearing in a boot followed by gradual loading. Smoking cessation was achieved and maintained during healing. Outcome and follow-up Recovery was uncomplicated. At 3 months, she walked fully weight-bearing in normal footwear without pain or swelling, and radiographs showed maintained alignment with progressive graft incorporation (Fig. 3). Revision arthrodesis. Serial post-operative anteroposterior and lateral radiographs, immediate post-operative; 3-month post-operative and 6-month post-operative radiographs demonstrating maintenance of alignment and progressive graft incorporation. At 6 months, CT showed bridging trabecular bone, graft incorporation, closure of the fusion gap, and stable fixation without recurrent osteolysis (Fig. 4). At 1 year, she remained asymptomatic in regular footwear. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society hallux metatarsophalangeal-interphalangeal score improved from 29/100 to 85/100 (Table 1). Six-month post-operative computed tomography demonstrating graft incorporation, bridging trabecular bone across the arthrodesis site, closure of the previous fusion gap and stable implant position. Table 1Clinical timelineTime pointClinical eventInterpretationPre-operativeAdvanced hallux rigidus with hallux varus and second-/third-toe deformity; 45 pack-year smoker; normal arterial duplex.Complex forefoot deformity with major modifiable biological risk factor.Index surgeryFirst MTP arthrodesis using cup-and-cone preparation and low-profile dorsal plate fixation.Primary fusion with standard preparation and plate fixation.4 weeksNon-weight-bearing followed by progressive weight-bearing.Routine primary rehabilitation protocol.3 monthsAlignment maintained; fixation intact; complete osseous consolidation not evident.Delayed or incomplete early fusion.4 monthsIncreasing pain and swelling during weight-bearing.Symptomatic mechanical activity at the fusion site suspected.6 monthsRadiographs demonstrated dorsal plate breakage; CT confirmed pseudarthrosis, absent bridging bone and proximal phalangeal osteolysis. WBC, ESR and CRP were normal before revision.Aseptic symptomatic non-union with implant fatigue failure suspected.RevisionHardware removal, pseudarthrosis debridement, tricortical iliac crest graft, compression screw, stronger dorsal revision plate, second-ray correction and intraoperative cultures.Biology, length, compression, fixation stability and forefoot loading addressed; intraoperative cultures were negative.Post-revisionEight weeks non-weight-bearing; smoking cessation maintained.Risk-adjusted protection and host optimization.3 months after revisionFull weight-bearing in regular footwear without pain or swelling.Clinical recovery.6 months after revisionCT-confirmed graft incorporation, bridging trabecular bone and stable fixation; pain-free walking in regular footwear; AOFAS-HMI improved from 29/100 to 85/100.Radiographic union with major clinical and functional improvement. CT: Computed tomography, WBC: White blood cell, ESR: Erythrocyte sedimentation rate, CRP: C-reactive protein, MTP: Metatarsophalangeal, AOFAS-HMI: American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society hallux metatarsophalangeal-interphalangeal score Clinical timeline CT: Computed tomography, WBC: White blood cell, ESR: Erythrocyte sedimentation rate, CRP: C-reactive protein, MTP: Metatarsophalangeal, AOFAS-HMI: American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society hallux metatarsophalangeal-interphalangeal score Patient perspective and functional assessment The patient reported resolution of weight-bearing pain and swelling, return to regular footwear, and improved walking tolerance. Discussion Why this case is more than an isolated hardware failure Plate breakage should not be treated as a diagnosis. It is usually the visible endpoint of an unhealed fusion exposed to repetitive loading. Implant exchange alone may miss the underlying causes: Impaired biology, insufficient compression, bone loss, malalignment, premature loading, or adjacent-ray pathology. Here, incomplete consolidation preceded symptoms, and symptoms preceded radiographic plate failure. CT then confirmed pseudarthrosis and osteolysis, supporting biological failure and micromotion before fatigue fracture. Biological risk: Smoking and host factors Smoking is a major modifiable risk factor for impaired osseous healing through vasoconstriction, reduced tissue oxygenation, impaired osteoblast activity, diminished collagen synthesis, and reduced angiogenesis [5,6]. Even when MTP-I-specific studies vary, broader foot-and-ankle fusion data support cessation before elective arthrodesis. Normal pulses and duplex findings reduced concern for major arterial disease but did not exclude smoking-related microvascular or cellular impairment. Local biology and joint preparation Fusion requires cartilage and sclerotic bone removal, viable cancellous surfaces, and stable contact. Cup-and-cone preparation preserves bone stock and assists alignment, whereas planar cuts may improve cancellous apposition and compression [7,8,9,10]. In revision, the specific preparation method is less important than complete debridement to bleeding bone. In this case, excision of fibrous tissue and sclerosis converted an inactive pseudarthrosis into a viable graft bed. Fixation and compression in revision arthrodesis Stable fixation and compression are central to MTP-I fusion. Evidence generally supports constructs combining compression with dorsal plating, particularly in revisions or biologically compromised patients [11,12]. The revised construct used an interfragmentary compression screw and stronger dorsal plate to compress the graft interfaces and resist bending during rollover. Structural grafting: Restoring biology, bone stock and length Revision often involves bone loss, osteolysis, shortening and sclerosis. When compression would shorten the first ray, structural grafting is required. Tricortical iliac crest autograft provides support and osteogenic, osteoconductive and osteoinductive properties [13]. CT-confirmed incorporation and bridging trabeculation showed that the graft served both structural and biological roles. Forefoot biomechanics and second-ray deformity MTP-I arthrodesis should be assessed within the whole forefoot. Adjacent lesser-ray deformity may alter rollover mechanics and plantar pressure, although direct causality cannot be proven from a single case. Correcting the second-ray deformity was intended to improve balance and reduce abnormal loading across the revised first ray. Post-operative protection Although early protected weight-bearing may be safe after selected primary fusions [14,15], this evidence should not be applied uncritically to high-risk revisions. Smoking history, pseudarthrosis, bone loss, and structural grafting justified 8 weeks of non-weight-bearing before gradual loading. Proposed revision framework On the basis of the present case and the available literature, failed MTP-I arthrodesis should be assessed using a structured framework. The surgeon should determine whether failure is symptomatic, confirm non-union with CT when radiographs are equivocal, exclude infection, evaluate host biology, assess bone loss and first-ray length, analyze fixation and alignment, identify adjacent-ray deformity, and individualize the post-operative protocol. Revision should be designed to restore both biology and mechanics (Table 2). Table 2Failure analysis and revision responseProblem identifiedEvidence in the present caseRevision responseHost biological risk45 pack-year smoking history and continued smoking after primary surgery.Smoking cessation after revision and prolonged protection.Local biological failureCT-confirmed pseudarthrosis, sclerosis and osteolysis.Excision of fibrous tissue and sclerotic bone to bleeding cancellous surfaces.Structural bone lossOsteolysis involving the base of the proximal phalanx.Tricortical iliac crest graft to restore bone stock and length.Mechanical instabilityPersistent symptoms followed by dorsal plate breakage.Interfragmentary compression screw and stronger dorsal revision plate.Possible sagittal malpositionRetrospective concern for excessive dorsiflexion.Realignment during graft insertion and revision fixation.Adjacent forefoot deformitySecond-ray varus/claw-toe deformity.Second metatarsal osteotomy and PIP arthrodesis.Rehabilitation riskPrimary protocol used 4 weeks non-weight-bearing; delayed consolidation became evident.Eight weeks non-weight-bearing after revision before gradual loading.Need for objective union assessmentRadiographs were initially inconclusive.CT used to confirm both non-union and later union.Infection as differential diagnosisNo clinical infection; pre-revision WBC, ESR, and CRP were normal; no intraoperative purulence; intraoperative cultures negative.Single-stage aseptic revision rather than staged septic reconstruction.Functional impairmentPre-revision AOFAS-HMI 29/100 (pain 0, function 29, alignment 0).Post-revision improvement to 85/100 (pain 30, function 40, alignment 15). CT: Computed tomography, WBC: White blood cell, ESR: Erythrocyte sedimentation rate, CRP: C-reactive protein, MTP: Metatarsophalangeal, AOFAS-HMI: American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society hallux metatarsophalangeal-interphalangeal score, PIP: Proximal interphalangeal Failure analysis and revision response CT: Computed tomography, WBC: White blood cell, ESR: Erythrocyte sedimentation rate, CRP: C-reactive protein, MTP: Metatarsophalangeal, AOFAS-HMI: American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society hallux metatarsophalangeal-interphalangeal score, PIP: Proximal interphalangeal Comparison with published revision literature Literature on failed MTP-I arthrodesis is limited. Takács and Swierstra used inlay grafting for pseudoarthrosis, supporting biological augmentation and stable graft-host contact [16]. Larger revision cohorts by Waizy et al. and Gaudin et al. show that revision is clinically important and carries higher complication risk than primary fusion [4,17]. Saccomanno and Bitterman treated infected non-union with staged revision, antibiotic spacer placement, and tricortical iliac crest autograft [18]. Their report supports structural grafting but differs because infection required staging. In the present aseptic case, normal inflammatory markers, absence of purulence, and negative cultures supported single-stage revision. Malunion is another failure mode. Hirao et al. used CT-based planning and a custom guide for malunited pronation deformity after MTP-I arthrodesis, emphasizing three-dimensional alignment assessment [19]. In this case, suspected excessive dorsiflexion prompted careful sagittal restoration during grafting and fixation. For recalcitrant non-union with hostile biology, Kaiser and Levin reported medial femoral condyle free-flap reconstruction [20]. By contrast, this case united with non-vascularized tricortical iliac crest autograft because infection was excluded, macrovascular supply was preserved, bone loss was reconstructable and stable compression fixation was achievable. Salvage arthrodesis after failed MTP-I arthroplasty also informs bone-loss reconstruction. Mao et al., Yurteri et al., Johnson et al. and Adamson et al. highlight strategies including structural grafting, custom implants and length maintenance when bone stock is compromised [21,22,23,24] (Table 3). Table 3Selected literature relevant to failed or revised first MTP arthrodesis and salvage reconstructionAuthor/yearType of problemRevision or salvage strategyRelevance to present casePrat et al., 2023 [10]Revision-first MTP arthrodesis cohort.Revision arthrodesis with variable techniques.Demonstrates that revision first MTP fusion has higher complication risk than primary fusion.Takács and Swierstra, 2011 [16]Pseudoarthrosis after failed MTP-1 arthrodesis.Inlay bone grafting technique for repair.Directly supports graft-based revision for failed first MTP fusion.Gaudin et al., 2018 [17]Multicenter series of 158 revision procedures after first MTP arthrodesis.Revision for hardware problems, non-union, malunion, and related complications.Shows that revision after first MTP fusion is not negligible and may address more than one failure mechanism.Saccomanno and Bitterman, 2023 [18]Infected non-union after first MTP arthrodesis.Staged revision with antibiotic spacer and tricortical iliac crest autograft.Closest comparator for structural iliac crest autograft in failed fusion, although infected and staged.Hirao et al., 2014 [19]Malunited pronation deformity after first MTP arthrodesis.3D-CT planning, custom guide, deformity correction and re-fusion.Highlights the importance of three-dimensional alignment analysis in revision.Kaiser and Levin, 2023 [20]Persistent/recalcitrant osseous non-union of the first MTP joint.Medial femoral condyle free flap.Represents advanced vascularized biological salvage when local biology is severely compromised.Mao et al., 2020 [21]Failed first MTP arthroplasty.Systematic review of salvage arthrodesis with or without structural graft.Supports the role of salvage arthrodesis in bone-loss revision settings.Yurteri et al., 2024 [22]Failed first MTP total arthroplasty.Arthrodesis using iliac crest autograft.Contemporary series supporting iliac crest grafting in revision first MTP reconstruction.Johnson et al., 2023 [23]Osseous defects in revision first MTP fusion.Custom three-dimensional printed implant.Modern comparator for reconstructing bone loss and first-ray length when standard grafting is insufficient.Adamson et al., 2021 [24]Failed first MTP arthroplasty with bone loss preventing fixation.Arthrodesis using allograft struts without hardware.Demonstrates the centrality of length and position restoration when fixation options are limited by bone loss. Selected literature relevant to failed or revised first MTP arthrodesis and salvage reconstruction This case was distinct because aseptic failed primary arthrodesis occurred in a heavy smoker with CT-confirmed pseudarthrosis, osteolysis, and plate fatigue and second-ray deformity. Union was achieved without staged infection treatment, vascularized bone transfer, or arthroplasty conversion by combining debridement to viable bone, structural autograft, compression, enhanced fixation, adjacent deformity correction, smoking cessation, and prolonged protection. Revision series support a whole-forefoot, stepwise escalation approach (Table 4). Gaudin et al. identified revision indications beyond hardware problems, including non-union, malunion, metatarsalgia, claw-toe deformity, and interphalangeal disorders [17]. Takács, Swierstra, and Malhotra et al. support graft-based repair and length-preserving bone-block arthrodesis [16,25], whereas Kaiser and Levin represent escalation to vascularized bone for rare hostile non-unions [20] (Table 4). Table 4Revision series and case-series evidence supporting the reconstruction strategyStudyDesign/populationMain contributionRelevance to present caseTakacs and Swierstra, 2011 [16]Technical note/case series of 26 patients with pseudoarthrosis after failed MTP-1 arthrodesis.Described a turnaround inlay graft bridging the pseudoarthrosis, with fixation and protected heel weight-bearing.Directly supports graft-based biological reconstruction for established first MTP pseudarthrosis.Gaudin et al., 2018 [17]Multicenter study of 158 revision procedures after first MTP arthrodesis.Showed that revision indications include hardware discomfort, non-union, malunion, metatarsalgia/claw-toe deformity, and IP-joint disorders.Supports analyzing failed fusion as a spectrum of mechanical, alignment, and adjacent-ray problems rather than only broken hardware.Kaiser and Levin, 2023 [20]Level IV preliminary case series for persistent osseous non-union of the first MTP joint.Reported medial femoral condyle free-flap reconstruction as a vascularized biological salvage option.Defines the upper end of biological escalation for recalcitrant non-union; the present case achieved union without vascularized transfer.Malhotra et al., 2015 [25]Retrospective case series: 24 patients/25 feet undergoing interposition bone-block arthrodesis.Used non-vascularized tricortical autologous iliac crest graft to maintain first-ray length in failed hallux MTP surgery.Strongly supports the use of structural iliac crest autograft when bone loss or shortening would make simple compression inadequate. MTP-1: First metatarsophalangeal Revision series and case-series evidence supporting the reconstruction strategy MTP-1: First metatarsophalangeal Conclusion Non-union after MTP-I arthrodesis is usually multifactorial. Revision should restore viable bone surfaces, bone stock, first-ray length, alignment, compression, and fixation stability while correcting modifiable host and biomechanical risk factors. In the present case, successful union was achieved after pseudarthrosis excision, structural tricortical iliac crest autografting, compression screw fixation, revision dorsal plating, smoking cessation, correction of associated second-ray deformity and prolonged post-operative protection. Clinical Message Revision should not be limited to hardware exchange. Surgeons should systematically assess infection, biological risk factors, bone loss, fixation stability, alignment, post-operative loading and adjacent forefoot deformity. In high-risk cases, successful revision may require structural autografting, stable compression fixation, deformity correction, and smoking cessation and prolonged protected weight-bearing. Conflict of Interest: Nil Source of Support: Nil Consent: The authors confirm that informed consent was obtained from the patient for publication of this article