Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in assessing medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Authors: Melanie Potter, Anthony Smith Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackground:Medial Collateral Ligament (MCL) and Medial Meniscus (MM) injuries are common medial knee pathologies. While MRI and arthroscopy are gold-standard diagnostic modalities, they are costly, invasive, and often delayed. Ultrasound is fast, inexpensive, and non-invasive, with growing use clinically, particularly point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS). This systematic review and meta-analysis aims were to evaluate ultrasound’s diagnostic performance for MCL and MM injuries, both as standalone modalities and initial screening tools.Methods:A systematic search of PubMed, Cochrane, Embase, CINAHL, and Google Scholar identified studies between 1st October 2014 and 31st October 2024. Fourteen studies (1,259 patients) met inclusion criteria. Methodological quality was assessed using validated tools.Results:Overall risk of bias was low, with moderate certainty of evidence for MCL and low certainty for MM injuries. Nine studies (713 patients) evaluated MCL injuries. Bivariate meta-analysis showed pooled sensitivity 0.83 (95% CI: 0.76–0.88), specificity 0.96 (95% CI: 0.91–0.98), diagnostic odds ratio (DOR) 117.8, and area under the SROC curve (AUC) 0.90. Heterogeneity was minimal (I2 = 0%). Twelve studies (969 patients) evaluated MM injuries, with pooled sensitivity 0.85 (95% CI: 0.82–0.88), specificity 0.89 (95% CI: 0.81–0.94), DOR 45, and AUC 0.88. Heterogeneity was low for sensitivity but substantial for specificity (I2 = 70.6%).Conclusions:Ultrasound demonstrated high specificity for MCL and moderate sensitivity for MM injuries. It may serve as a valuable modality for MCL injuries in POCUS settings and as an initial screening tool for MM injuries. As POCUS utilisation expands, it may support diagnostic pathways.Keywords: medial collateral ligament, medial meniscus, knee injuries, ultrasound, magnetic resonance imaging Supplementary File 1 - Databases’ search strategies PubMed search Title “Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in assessing medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries? A systematic review and meta-analysis.” PIRD framework - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Index test – ultrasound. - Index test – ultrasound. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. Search strategy pubmed Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[Mesh] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[Mesh] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[Mesh] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] Tiab-terms [ti = title, ab = abstract] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] Tiab-terms [ti = title, ab = abstract] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] Truncation - Use of “ ”- Use of * Truncation - Use of “ ” - Use of “ ” - Use of * - Use of * Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab]#5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Filters/limits applied - Adults- Humans- 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024)- English Language- Full text Filters/limits applied - Adults - Adults - Humans - Humans - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - English Language - English Language - Full text - Full text Embase search Title “Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in assessing medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries? A systematic review and meta-analysis.” PIRD framework - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Index test – ultrasound. - Index test – ultrasound. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. Search strategy embase F)Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Medial Meniscus”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injury”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasound/dia” [MeSH] Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Medial Meniscus”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injury”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasound/dia” [MeSH] #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Medial Meniscus”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injury”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasound/dia” [MeSH] G)Tiab-terms #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] Tiab-terms #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] H) Truncation - Use of “ ”- Use of * Truncation - Use of “ ” - Use of “ ” - Use of * - Use of * I) Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Medial Meniscus”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasound/dia”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab]#5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Medial Meniscus”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasound/dia”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 J) Filters/limits applied - Adults- Humans- 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024)- English Language- Full text Filters/limits applied - Adults - Adults - Humans - Humans - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - English Language - English Language - Full text - Full text Cinahl ultimate search Title “Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in assessing medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries? A systematic review and meta-analysis.” PIRD framework - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Index test – ultrasound. - Index test – ultrasound. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. Search strategy cinahl ultimate K)Cinahl ultimate MeSH terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial” [MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries” [MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography” [MeSH] Cinahl ultimate MeSH terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial” [MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries” [MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography” [MeSH] #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial” [MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries” [MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography” [MeSH] L)Tiab-terms (ti = title, ab = abstract) #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] Tiab-terms (ti = title, ab = abstract) #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] M) Truncation - Use of “ ”- Use of * Truncation - Use of “ ” - Use of “ ” - Use of * - Use of * N) Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab]#5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 O) Filters/limits applied - Adults- Humans- 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024)- English Language- Full text Filters/limits applied - Adults - Adults - Humans - Humans - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - English Language - English Language - Full text - Full text Cochrane search Title “Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in assessing medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries? A systematic review and meta-analysis.” PIRD framework - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Index test – ultrasound. - Index test – ultrasound. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. Search strategy pubMed P)Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH ]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[MeSH]” Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH ]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[MeSH]” #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH ]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[MeSH]” Q)Tiab-terms (ti = title, ab = abstract) #1 medial collateral ligament“medial ligament* collateral” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuries“injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab]#4 ultrasound“ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab] Tiab-terms (ti = title, ab = abstract) #1 medial collateral ligament“medial ligament* collateral” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuries“injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab]#4 ultrasound“ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial ligament* collateral” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuries“injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab]#4 ultrasound“ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab] R) Truncation - Use of “ ”- Use of * Truncation - Use of “ ” - Use of “ ” - Use of * - Use of * S) Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR “injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR “ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab]#5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR “injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR “ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab] #5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 T) Filters/limits applied - Adults- Humans- 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024)- English Language- Full text Filters/limits applied - Adults - Adults - Humans - Humans - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - English Language - English Language - Full text - Full text Supplementary File 2 – Inclusion and exclusion criteria InclusionExclusionEmpirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of symptomatic medial meniscus and MCL injuries. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of ACL, PCL, LCL or lateral meniscus injuries only. Published between 1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024. Published pre-1st October 2014. Cross-sectional (cohort) studies, diagnostic accuracy comparative studies. Case control studies. Humans. Animal/Cadaver studies. Adults. Study Population of less than 20. English Language. Review Studies. Full text. Duplicate Studies. Must include TP, FP, TN, FN information. Missing TP, FP, TN, FN information. Reference standard of arthroscopy and/or MRI. No reference standard included or different from arthroscopy and/or MRI. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of symptomatic medial meniscus and MCL injuries. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of symptomatic medial meniscus and MCL injuries. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of ACL, PCL, LCL or lateral meniscus injuries only. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of ACL, PCL, LCL or lateral meniscus injuries only. Published between 1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024. Published between 1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024. Published pre-1st October 2014. Published pre-1st October 2014. Cross-sectional (cohort) studies, diagnostic accuracy comparative studies. Cross-sectional (cohort) studies, diagnostic accuracy comparative studies. Case control studies. Case control studies. Humans. Humans. Animal/Cadaver studies. Animal/Cadaver studies. Adults. Adults. Study Population of less than 20. Study Population of less than 20. English Language. English Language. Review Studies. Review Studies. Full text. Full text. Duplicate Studies. Duplicate Studies. Must include TP, FP, TN, FN information. Must include TP, FP, TN, FN information. Missing TP, FP, TN, FN information. Missing TP, FP, TN, FN information. Reference standard of arthroscopy and/or MRI. Reference standard of arthroscopy and/or MRI. No reference standard included or different from arthroscopy and/or MRI. No reference standard included or different from arthroscopy and/or MRI. Supplementary File 3 - Excluded articles from final search process/review Inclusion & Exclusion Numbers from Final Process for Inclusion within ReviewSOURCEINCLUDEDEXCLUDEDTOTALEmbase4610Pubmed1910Google Scholar549Other4711Total142640 Inclusion & Exclusion Numbers from Final Process for Inclusion within Review Excluded Articles’ Details & Reasons for ExclusionNo.AuthorsTitleYearJournalReason for Exclusion1.Artul S, Khazin F, Hakim J, Habib G.Ultrasonographic findings in a large series of patients with knee pain.2014Journal of Clinical Imaging ScienceNon-DTA study/no reference standard included, such as MRI or arthroscopy.2.Kijowski R, Roemer F, Englund M, Tiderius CJ, Swärd P, Frobell RB.Imaging following acute knee trauma2014Osteoarthritis and CartilageReview study.3.Nogueira-Barbosa MH, Gregio-Junior E, Lorenzato MM, Guermazi A, Roemer FW, Chagas-Neto FA, Crema MD.Ultrasound assessment of medial meniscal extrusion: a validation study using MRI as reference standard.2015American Journal of RoentgenologyOnly measuring meniscal extrusion, no evidence of injury or tear.4.Artul S, Jabaly-Habib H, Artoul F, Habib GThe association between Baker’s cyst and medial meniscal tear in patients with symptomatic knee using ultrasonography.2015Clinical ImagingNon-DTA study/no reference standard included, such as MRI or arthroscopy.5.Akatsu Y, Yamaguchi S, Mukoyama S, Morikawa T, Yamaguchi T, Tsuchiya K, Iwasaki J, Akagi R, Muramatsu Y, Katsuragi J, Fukawa T.Accuracy of high-resolution ultrasound in the detection of meniscal tears and determination of the visible area of menisci.2015JBJSSubjects = cadavers.6.Singh B, Pawar KN, Kachewar S, Ghule SS, Lakhkar DLEvaluation of knee joint by ultrasound and MRI.2016Journal of Dental and Medical SciencesPoor/limited methodology, with no inclusion or exclusion criteria included, no information on who completed or assessed the images.7.Ghosh N, Kruse D, Subeh M, Lahham S, Fox JC.Comparing point-of-care-ultrasound (POCUS) to MRI for the diagnosis of medial compartment knee injuries.2017Journal of Medical UltrasoundOnly 9 subjects included within study, and as <20 subjects included, excluded as per inclusion/criteria.8.Diermeier T, Achtnich A, Imhoff AB, Wörtler K, Petersen W.Meniscal extrusion in ultrasound as a new diagnostic tool for evaluation of medial meniscus function.2017Orthopaedic Journal of Sports MedicineStudy based on non-symptomatic subjects.9.Liao CL, Yu CW, Cheng YH, Wang TG.Is Ultrasound Reliable for the Diagnosis of Knee Medial Collateral Ligament Injury?2017Rehabilitation Practice and ScienceVery limited statistical information provided, including no sensitivity, specificity or accuracy data.10.Abram SG, Beard DJ, Price AJ, BASK Meniscal Working Group.National consensus on the definition, investigation, and classification of meniscal lesions of the knee.2018The KneeReview study.11.Mostafa HA, Abou Elfotuh AM, Alsakka MM.MRI versus ultrasound in diagnosis of meniscal tear in knee joint.2019The Egyptian Journal of Hospital Medicine.Doesn’t include any statistical information/break down on medial meniscal tears, including sensitivity, specificity, accuracy etc – puts all information together including lateral and medial meniscal tears. Authors contacted by email requesting whether information available – no response to request.12.Chiba D, Sasaki E, Ota S, Maeda S, Sugiyama D, Nakaji S, Ishibashi Y.US detection of medial meniscus extrusion can predict the risk of developing radiographic knee osteoarthritis: a 5-year cohort study.2020European RadiologyNo reference standard of MRI or arthroscopy utilised.13.Reisner JH, Franco JM, Hollman JH, Johnson AC, Sellon JL, Finnoff JT.Ultrasound assessment of weight-bearing and non–weight-bearing meniscal extrusion: a reliability study.2020PM&RNon-DTA study/no reference standard included, such as MRI or arthroscopy.14.El Sheikh H, Faheem M, Abdelmoeim A.Role of ultrasonographic examination of the knee in evaluation of meniscal injury in correlation with magnetic resonance imaging.2020Benha Medical JournalLimited methodology included – no information on who completed ultrasound or MRI, no information on order of imaging, no information on whether blinding occurred, no information on flow and timing of index or reference standard.15.Abuomira IE, Ahmed YA, Elshahat MT.Comparison between ultrasonography and MRI in diagnosis of knee joint meniscal injuries.2021Al-Azhar Assiut Medical JournalExtremely limited methodology+++.16.Jokela MA, Mäkinen TJ, Koivikko MP, Lindahl JM, Halinen J, Lindahl J.Treatment of medial-sided injuries in patients with early bicruciate ligament reconstruction for knee dislocation.2021Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, ArthroscopyNo diagnostic ultrasound included within study, was based on findings based on stress radiographs and MRI.17.Sundararajan SR, Ramakanth R, Sethuraman AS, Kannan M, Rajasekaran S.Correlation of factors affecting correction of meniscal extrusion and outcome after medial meniscus root repair.2022Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma SurgeryScreening of MRI used only, no diagnostic ultrasound included within study.18.Oo WM, Linklater JM, Bennell KL, Daniel MS, Pryke D, Wang X, Yu SP, Deveza L, Duong V, Hunter DJ.Reliability and convergent construct validity of quantitative ultrasound for synovitis, meniscal extrusion, and osteophyte in knee osteoarthritis with MRI.2022Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine.Only included information on medial extrusion and patients with knee pain, no history of injury/trauma. Study based on diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound v MRI in diagnosing osteoarthritis, such as medial extrusion.19.Chiba D, Sasaki T, Ishibashi YGreater medial meniscus extrusion seen on ultrasonography indicates the risk of MRI-detected complete medial meniscus posterior root tear in a Japanese population with knee pain.2022Scientific ReportsAll subjects without any history of injury/trauma, study based on degenerative medial meniscal pathology/osteoarthritis, rather than medial meniscal tears.20.Falkowski AL, Jacobson JA, Cresswell M, Bedi A, Kalia V, Zhang B.Medial Meniscal Extrusion Evaluation with Weight-Bearing Ultrasound.2022The Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine.No clear history of injury within inclusion, study focusing on medial extrusion including normal, degenerative meniscal and tears. No clear information included on DTA of ultrasound v MRI regarding sensitivity, specificity or accuracy data.21.Maheshwari M, Yadav PK, Jain S, Batham IK, Gupta A, Swaika S.Imaging of Knee Joint Pathologies: A Comparative Study of Ultrasound and Magnetic Resonance Imaging.2022Journal of Medical SciencesNo methodology included within study.22.Gayathri Mohanan DU, Job S.Sonological evaluation of medial knee injuries and its comparison with magnetic resonance imaging findings: A study.2022International Journal of OrthopaedicsDuplicate study – but published with different title and in different Journal.23.Wasilczyk C.The Value of Ultrasound Diagnostic Imaging of Meniscal Knee Injuries Verified by Experimental and Arthroscopic Investigations.2023DiagnosticsSubjects = Cadavers.24.VS SR, Jinu CK.Diagnostic Accuracy of Ultrasound in the Evaluation of Collateral Ligaments and Meniscal Injuries of Knee in Comparison with Magnetic Resonance Imaging.2023RGUHS Journal of Medical SciencesLimited methodology included – no information on who completed ultrasound or MRI, no information on order of imaging, no information on whether blinding occurred, no information on flow and timing of index or reference standard.25.Uusimaa AP, Kemppainen A, Nevalainen MT.Medial meniscus extrusion is associated with meniscus tears in US and MRI: A case control study.2024Journal of Clinical UltrasoundCase study26.Kanayama T, Nakase J, Ishida Y, Yanatori Y, Takemoto N, Demura S.Identifying unstable ramp lesions using ultrasonography.2024Journal of Medical UltrasonicsNon-DTA study, no clear information on including no sensitivity, specificity or accuracy data. Excluded Articles’ Details & Reasons for Exclusion Supplementary File 4 – Study characteristics Supplementary File 5 – Medial collateral ligament injuries – plots MCL Specificity Forest Plot MCL Sensitivity Forest Plot MCL DOR Forest Plot MCL Accuracy Forest Plot MCL PPV Forest Plot MCL NPV Forest Plot MCL Specificity Funnel Plot MCL Sensitivity Funnel Plot MCL SROC Curve Based on REML Bivariate Modelling Supplementary File 6 – Medial meniscus injuries – plots MM Specificity Forest Plot MM Sensitivity Forest Plot MM DOR Forest Plot MM Accuracy Forest Plot MM PPV Forest Plot MM NPV Forest Plot MM Specificity Funnel Plot MM Sensitivity Funnel Plot MM SROC Curve Based on REML Bivariate Modelling Background Medial knee injuries account for over 40% of knee injuries (1), with the Medial Collateral Ligament (MCL), and Medial Meniscus (MM), amongst the most injured (1, 2). Both structures play important roles in stability, shock-absorption, and load bearing (3, 4, 5). They have similar mechanisms of injury, including valgus force, external rotation, and sudden changes in direction (4, 6, 7). Whilst the majority of MCL injuries are isolated, 78% of Grade III injuries have associated structural injury (6). However, due to MCL’s healing potential (2), conservative management is normally indicated (8), unless there is significant valgus alignment, fracture avulsion, severe Grade III injury or multiple structural injuries (4, 6, 8). Grade III MCL injury specifically increases risk of MM tears to 32%, more common in older populations (9), split into horizontal, complex, flap, radial, root, and vertical (3, 11). Horizontal, complex and flap tears are typically degenerative, found in older populations, and treated conservatively. In contrast, vertical injuries are associated with younger populations, are twice as common medially, occur alongside multi-ligamentous injuries (10), and are frequently treated surgically. Therefore, the type and severity of injury guides management, with diagnosis traditionally completed with examination, followed by MRI. However, ultrasonography holds many advantages over MRI (3, 5), including being accessible, inexpensive, and allowing dynamic assessment (1, 12). Recently nearly 20% of patients in England missed recommended diagnostic waiting targets (13), and whilst demand increases, the workforce has not kept pace (14). These delays adversely affect disadvantaged groups, contributing to poor outcomes, and health inequalities (14-16). The King’s Fund (14) discussed the need for innovation, advocating Point-of-care Ultrasound (POCUS), typically performed as an extension to physical examination. Moreover, POCUS’ adoption reflects a shift toward more immediate, resource-conscious diagnostic strategies (17). Previous systematic reviews of diagnostic ultrasound in MM injury found diagnostic accuracy to be high (18) or good (19, 20). However, moderate to significant heterogeneity was found, with low subject numbers, and the latter reviews included pooled data on both medial and lateral meniscus injuries. Further, to the authors’ knowledge, there have been no recent systematic reviews on MM injury and regarding MCL imaging, only one, contemporary review (1). This review included only two studies on diagnostic ultrasound, which showed low sensitivity and high specificity. These gaps, alongside the growing clinical use of POCUS, and recommendations for regular updates (14, 21), highlight the need for a more current and comprehensive synthesis. Therefore, this review’s aims and objectives were to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound for MCL and MM injuries, both as standalone modalities and initial screening tools, and to inform evidence-based guidance on its role within diagnostic pathways, with implications for improving access, efficiency, and equity of care. Methods Design and search strategy This study’s design was a systematic review and meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy (DTA), conducted according to a registered protocol (PROSPERO CRD420250656377), in line with PRISMA-DTA guidelines. PubMed, Cochrane, Embase, CINAHL and Google Scholar were systematically searched with support from an information specialist to ensure rigour (22-24). These databases were chosen for their recognised standards of precision, recall and reproducibility (22). Embase provides high sensitivity and retrieval yield, considered essential for medically oriented searches, whilst PubMed provides additional biomedical content and complementary indexing (22, 25-28). CINAHL was selected for subject-specific coverage of nursing, biomedicine, and allied health (26). Whilst Google Scholar has lower precision, recall and lacks transparency (22), it adds value when combined with highly sensitive databases, by capturing grey literature (25). Firstly, a research question was formulated, utilising PIRD (Population, Index Test, Reference Test, and Diagnosis of Interest) framework, due to the inclusion of DTA study designs (28). This allowed the formulation of key words and concepts (29). Subsequently, each databases’ thesaurus was searched for matching index terms, within Medical subject headings (MeSH) and keywords or synonym terms, to increase number of studies retrieved (29). Secondly, free-text keywords were searched within the title and abstract, in addition to their corresponding thesaurus terminology (28), and finally, truncation was used, to narrow the search results to relevant articles (28). Subsequently, search terms and strategies were saved (Supplementary File 1 – Databases’ Search Strategies.docx), limited to 10 years (1st October 2014 to 31st October 2024) to stay contemporary (30), and with 82% of POCUS studies, published within this period (31). Moreover, both empirical and grey studies were included, to produce broad, objective, and comprehensive results (32, 33). Study selection and data extraction Titles and abstracts were screened against the study’s inclusion and exclusion criteria (Supplementary File 2 – Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria.docx), to ascertain eligibility. DTA cross-sectional (cohort) and comparative studies were included, to allow direct comparison of tests. Studies with less than 20 subjects, were excluded, in keeping with previous systematic review (20). Further, studies were only included if they reported sufficient data to construct 2×2 contingency tables (true positives, false positives, false negatives, true negatives), to allow statistical analysis. All processes were performed by two independent reviewers, and where disagreements occurred, were resolved by discussion, according to the guidelines of PRISMA (23). Decisions made were recorded, including how many studies were excluded and the reasons why (Supplementary File 3 – Excluded Studies.docx), to enable the PRISMA flowchart to be completed (Figure 1) (23). Subsequently, following full-text critical review, a final list of included studies were agreed (23). All relevant information and data were extracted from those articles, including key variables, research design, participants, year of publication and results (Table 1 in Supplementary File 4 – Study Characteristics.docx). PRISMA Flowchart. Table S1.Study characteristics of studies analysing diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound for Medial Collateral Ligament (MCL) & Medial Meniscus (MM) InjuryNo.Reference (Year)Study DesignStudy SettingSamplingSubject No.Mean Age (Years)Age range (Years)MaleFemaleAcute/ Chronic?ProbePositioningDTA of MCL/MM?Reference TestIndex Test(s)1Ahmadi et al. (2022)Prospective cross-sectionalEmergency Department (ED)Convenience25025n/a21733Acute (3 days from injury)Linear Probe 5-12 MHzProne 20-30 degrees knee flexion & hip external rotationMCLMRIUSS2Ahmadi et al. (2022)Prospective cross-sectionalEmergency Department (ED)Convenience5535n/a3817Acute (<5/7 post injury)Linear Probe 5-12 MHzSupine - knee flexion 15-90 degreesMedial MeniscusMRIUSS3Ahmadi et al. (2024)Prospective cross-sectionalEmergency Department (ED)Convenience1572515-519463Acute (<5/7 post injury)Linear Probe 5-12 MHzSupine - knee flexion 90 degreesMedial MeniscusArthroscopyUSS MRI4Singh et al. (2021)Prospective cross-sectionalHospital - RadiologyConvenience10333n/a7825UnknownLinear Probe 4-13 MHzSupine - knee flexion & hip external rotation for AHMM Prone - knee extended for PHMMMCL & Medial MeniscusMRIUSS5Muresan et al. (2017)Prospective longitudinal comparative studyMedical Centre (Radiology/ orthopaedics/ Rehab)Convenience452918-363015UnknownLinear Probe 5-13 MHzSupine - extension & varying knee flexionMedial MeniscusArthroscopyUSS MRI6Singh et al. (2018)Prospective cross-sectionalHospital - RadiologyConvenience60n/a15-654218UnknownLinear Probe 7-18 MHzSupine - knee flexion 20-30 degreesMCL & Medial MeniscusMRIUSS7Elshimy et al. (2023)Observational cross-sectional comparative studyHospital - RadiologyConvenience603318-604515UnknownLinear Probe 9-15 MHzSupine MCL and supine/prone for MMMCL & Medial MeniscusArthroscopyUSS MRI8Mohanan et al. (2023)Prospective cross-sectionalHospital – (Radiology/Orthopaedics)Convenience60n/a18-604416Acute & Chronic (majority 1 - 4/52 post injury)Linear Probe 5-6MhzSupine - hip in external rotationMCL & Medial MeniscusMRIUSS9Khalaf et al. (2020)Prospective cross-sectionalHospital - RadiologyConvenience503519-563020UnknownLinear Probe 11 MHzSupine - knee flexion & hip external rotation for AHMM Prone - knee extended for PHMMMCL & Medial MeniscusArthroscopy/MRIUSS10Hussain et al. (2019)**Prospective cross-sectionalHospital - RadiologyConvenience303318-57219UnknownLinear Probe 12 MHzSupine & proneMCL & Medial MeniscusMRIUSS11Ali et al. (2021)*Prospective cross-sectionalHospital - RadiologyConvenience404315-691822UnknownLinear Probe 7-11 MHZ)SupineMCL*MRIUSS12Elkholy et al. (2022)Prospective cross-sectionalHospital - RadiologyConvenience403715-602812Acute & chronic (exact timescale post injury/pain, not known)Linear Probe 7-10 MHzSupine - knee flexion 30-90 degrees flexion & hip external rotation for AHMM Prone - knee 20 degrees flexion for PHMMMedial MeniscusMRIUSS13Mir et al. (2021)Prospective cross-sectionalHospital - radiologyConvenience603621-304812Acute trauma as majority sporting or RTA but unclear of time to enrolmentLinear Probe 7-15MHzSupine with knee in flexionMCL & Medial MeniscusMRIUSS14Awan et al. (2024)Retrospective analysisCommunityConvenience24938Unknown136113UnknownLinear Probe 12-17MHzUnknownMedial MeniscusMRIUSS* Study’s data only on MCL included.**Study’s results of AHMM & PHMM combined for overall MM results.DTA = diagnostic test accuracy, USS = ultrasound scan, MRI = Magnetic Resonance Imaging, n/a = not applicable, AHMM = anterior horn medial meniscus, PHMM = posterior horn medial meniscus. Study characteristics of studies analysing diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound for Medial Collateral Ligament (MCL) & Medial Meniscus (MM) Injury * Study’s data only on MCL included. **Study’s results of AHMM & PHMM combined for overall MM results. DTA = diagnostic test accuracy, USS = ultrasound scan, MRI = Magnetic Resonance Imaging, n/a = not applicable, AHMM = anterior horn medial meniscus, PHMM = posterior horn medial meniscus. Study quality assessment DTA studies evaluate and compare precision of tests, however, they frequently exhibit methodological flaws (34). Therefore, quality assessment tools to critically evaluate findings, were used. These were the updated Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (QUADAS-2) tool (29, 34, 35), and QUADAS-C tool, which serves as an extension of QUADAS-2, specifically developed to assess the risk of bias and the accuracy of tests, employing rigorous methodologies and thorough piloting (34). These instruments evaluated the quality of the studies included by examining risk of bias and addressing applicability concerns across four specific domains, namely, patient selection, the index test, the reference standard, and flow and timing. Whilst QUADAS tools enabled risk of bias to be assessed for individual studies, they do not offer conclusions regarding overall body of evidence (36). Therefore, the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach was used (37). The GRADE approach focuses on how certain an effect estimate, reflects the true effect, and is sufficient to support a particular recommendation (38). GRADE represents a formal, rigorous, and transparent systematic methodology (39). Statistical analysis A meta-analysis was undertaken to synthesise evidence on the diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound for detecting MCL and MM injury. Given the variability in reported sensitivity and specificity across individual studies, a pooled analysis was necessary to obtain a more precise estimate to explore potential heterogeneity in test performance. This approach aimed to provide clinically meaningful evidence regarding the reliability of ultrasound diagnostic capabilities across diverse study populations and settings. DTA measures deemed appropriate to denote accuracy, were sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, positive and negative predictive values (PPV and NPV), and diagnostic odds ratio (DOR), in line with previous reviews (1, 18-20). All statistical analyses were conducted using R software (version 4.5.1), following the framework described by Shim et al. (40), outlining robust workflows for DTA meta-analysis. Univariate meta-analysis was performed using the meta package to estimate pooled sensitivity, specificity, DOR accuracy, PPV and NPV, applying logit transformation to stabilise variance and using random-effects models with DerSimonian-Laird estimators. Forest plots were generated to visualise individual study estimates alongside pooled values. For bivariate meta-analysis, the mada package was employed to fit a random-effects model via the Reitsma function (41), producing summary receiver operating characteristic (SROC) curves with confidence and prediction regions, and assessing the correlation between logit-transformed sensitivity and specificity. Heterogeneity was quantified using I2 and τ2 statistics, and funnel plots, Egger’s tests and Berg tests were used, to evaluate publication bias and the presence of small-study effects. Results Study selection From 1,077 records, 40 studies were screened for eligibility, demonstrated in PRISMA flow diagram and decision tree (Figure 1). Following full text review, 26 studies were excluded (Supplementary File 3 – Excluded Studies.docx). Therefore, fourteen studies were included in the study (42-55). Study characteristics A total of 1,259 subjects were included, with weighted mean age 33.5 years (SD +/- 4.99), including 69% males. The studies’ shared aims were to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in detecting MCL (42, 45, 47, 48-52, 54) and MM (43-51, 53-55) injuries. These were measured using reference standards of arthroscopy (44, 46, 48), MRI (42, 43, 45, 47, 49, 51-55), or combination of arthroscopy/MRI (50). Most testing was completed in emergency departments (42-44) utilising POCUS, or more traditional ultrasound machines in radiology (45-54), with clinician’s experience ranging from four hours to more than 5 years. Probe frequency varied, with the majority utilising linear probes of 5-12/13 MHz (42-46) or 7-12MHz (50-52). Four studies used higher frequency linear probes of 7-18MHz, 7-15MHz and 12-17MHz respectively (47, 48, 54, 55), and one, low frequency of 5-6MHz (49). Furthermore, positioning of MCL was supine, with knee flexion and hip external rotation (42, 45, 47-52, 54). Similarly, MM was done in supine positioning, (43, 44, 47, 49, 52, 54) or both prone and supine positioning (45, 46, 48, 50-53). Interestingly, only three studies used the dynamic capabilities of ultrasound (48, 50, 51). Quality assessment A comprehensive overview of the risk of bias and applicability concerns was completed, illustrated in Figures 2 and 3. Overall, risk of bias was considered low, with eight studies (57%) exhibiting low risk, four (29%) unclear, and two studies (14%) high risk. Regarding applicability concerns, most studies also demonstrated low risk (71%), with four studies (29%) showing unclear concerns, and none indicating high concerns. MCL injuries had moderate certainly of evidence and MM injuries, low certainty of evidence (Figure 4). Populations across the studies were similar, typically of predominant male gender and younger cohorts, therefore, this review’s recommendations may be limited to these populations. Regarding MM injuries, there appeared more inconsistency and reduced precision of results across the studies, reflected in the wider 95% CIs, and presence of outliers, which was reflected in the lower certainty of evidence. QUADAS-2 - Risk of bias and applicability concerns graph. Review authors’ judgements about each domain presented as percentages across included studies. QUADAS-2/C - Risk of bias and applicability concerns summary. Review authors’ judgements about each domain for each included study. GRADE Results. Meta analysis of MCL injuries Nine studies (713 patients) evaluating MCL injuries were included. Study designs varied in imaging protocols, operator experience, and threshold definitions. Univariate meta-analysis was performed yielding a pooled sensitivity of 0.85 (95% CI: 0.80–0.90), specificity of 0.99 (95% CI: 0.91–1.00), and DOR of 89.97 (95% CI: 42.62–189.93) (Figures 5–7). Additional pooled metrics were calculated, for accuracy 0.94 (95% CI: 0.91–0.97), PPV 0.97 (95% CI: 0.77–1.00), and NPV 0.95 (95% CI: 0.90–0.98) (Supplementary File 5 – MCL Plots.docx). These univariate estimates do not account for threshold effects or the inherent correlation between sensitivity and specificity. Thus, further meta-analysis was undertaken to obtain more precise estimates, to provide clinically meaningful evidence, across diverse study populations and settings. MCL sensitivity forest plot. MCL DOR forest plot. MCL specificity forest plot. A bivariate random-effects meta-analysis yielded summary estimates of sensitivity 0.83 (95% CI: 0.76–0.88), specificity 0.96 (95% CI: 0.91–0.98), Diagnostic Odds Ratio (DOR) 117.8 (95% CI: 65.44–212.04), and area under the SROC curve (AUC) 0.90 (95% CI: 0.86–0.93). The SROC curve included confidence and prediction regions that visually reflected between-study variability (Figure 8). The AUC indicated strong diagnostic performance, with broad prediction regions suggesting dispersion in sensitivity and specificity across studies. Heterogeneity was initially assessed using univariate random-effects models. For sensitivity, τ2 = 0, χ2(8) = 3.64 (p = 0.8879), and I2 = 0%, indicated no detectable variability. For specificity, τ2 = 4.43, χ2(8) = 6.57 (p = 0.5839), and I2 = 0%, suggesting minimal heterogeneity. The elevated τ2 may reflect model sensitivity to ceiling effects, as several studies reported perfect specificity. Notably, Khalaf et al. (50) was a significant outlier, with perfect sensitivity and specificity, lying outside the 95% region of the SROC and contributing disproportionately to between-study variance. Overall, heterogeneity was low and visually consistent with the prediction region of the SROC curve, aside from this study. Funnel plots (Supplementary File 5 – MCL Plots.docx) showed no marked asymmetry. However, it is important to interpret these findings with caution, as Egger’s and Begg’s tests, commonly used to formally assess publication bias, were not conducted due to the limited number of studies. Consequently, the possibility of undetected publication bias cannot be entirely ruled out. Ultrasound demonstrated high accuracy for diagnosing MCL injuries. Despite some variability in study design and imaging protocols, the consistently high specificity and AUC support its utility for ruling in MCL injury in appropriate clinical settings. MCL SROC curve based on REML bivariate modelling. Meta analysis of MM injuries Twelve studies (969 patients) evaluating MM injuries were included. Study designs varied in imaging protocols, operator experience, and threshold definitions. Univariate meta-analysis was performed yielding pooled estimates for sensitivity 0.85 (95% CI: 0.82–0.88), specificity 0.91 (95% CI: 0.83–0.95), and diagnostic odds ratio (DOR) 40.51 (95% CI: 21.74–75.64) (Figures 9-11). Additional pooled metrics were calculated, for accuracy 0.88 (95% CI: 0.85–0.90), PPV 0.92 (95% CI: 0.86–0.95), and NPV 0.84 (95% CI: 0.77–0.89) (Supplementary File 6 – MM Plots.docx). MM sensitivity forest plot. MM DOR forest plot. MM specificity forest plot. Bivariate meta-analysis produced summary sensitivity 0.85 (95% CI: 0.82–0.88), specificity 0.89 (95% CI: 0.81–0.94), DOR 45.0 (95% CI: 18.5–109.6), and area under the SROC curve (AUC) 0.88 (95% CI: 0.85–0.91). The SROC curve showed a shaded confidence region and broader prediction region, reflecting moderate variability across studies (Figure 12). The AUC supports strong overall test performance across varying thresholds. Heterogeneity was initially assessed using univariate random-effects models. For sensitivity it was low (τ2 = 0; I2 = 0%) but substantial for specificity (τ2 = 0.8282; I2 = 70.6%), consistent with the dispersion seen in the SROC prediction region. Elkholy et al. (53) and Singh et al. (47) were identified as significant outliers, driven by low specificity and low sensitivity, respectively, likely contributing disproportionately to between-study heterogeneity. Funnel plot asymmetry was assessed upon visualisation of Funnel Plots (Supplementary File 6 – MM Plots.docx) and using Egger’s and Begg’s tests. For sensitivity, Egger’s test suggested marginal asymmetry (t = 2.01, p = 0.0722), while Begg’s test was non-significant (z = 0.82, p = 0.4106). For specificity, both tests indicated no asymmetry (Egger: t = 0.88, p = 0.3970; Begg: z = 0.00, p = 1.0000). Therefore, there was no compelling evidence of publication basis. Ultrasound demonstrated high diagnostic accuracy for MM injury. Despite heterogeneity, the consistently strong sensitivity and AUC, support its clinical utility, particularly for ruling out MM injury, in appropriate clinical settings. MM SROC curve based on REML bivariate modelling. Additional analysis The included studies offered limited insights into the anatomical location, grading, and classification of injuries. Mohanan et al. (49) addressed the grading of MCL injuries, indicating that diagnostic ultrasound successfully identified all Grade III MCL injuries, in comparison to MRI. Regarding anatomical location, Khalaf et al. (50) reported 71% of MM injuries were to the posterior horn and Hussein et al (51) 100%. The latter reported a sensitivity of 83.3% and specificity 100% of ultrasound compared to MRI. Regarding tear morphology, positive correlation was reported with arthroscopy, compared to ultrasound and MRI. However, bucket handle tears, often necessitating surgical intervention, were not detected by ultrasound (50, 53). These findings were also reflected in Awan et al. (55) study, with ultrasound having difficulty detecting radial and horizontal tears, suggesting that ultrasound may lack the ability to clearly classify type of tears, and may be more useful as an initial screening tool. Discussion Summary of evidence The medial collateral ligament (MCL) and medial meniscus (MM) are essential for knee stability and load transmission. While many injuries are managed conservatively, accurate diagnosis is crucial to prevent long-term dysfunction. Imaging enhances clinical evaluation, with MRI and arthroscopy considered gold standards. However, their cost, invasiveness, and wait times limit accessibility. Diagnostic ultrasound offers a dynamic, non-invasive, and cost-effective alternative, increasingly adopted in clinical practice, at first point of contact. This review found ultrasound to be highly effective for diagnosing MCL injuries, with pooled sensitivity of 83% (95% CI: 76–88) and specificity of 96% (95% CI: 91–98). The diagnostic odds ratio (DOR) of 117.8 and area under the SROC curve (AUC) of 0.90 reflect robust performance, particularly for ruling in pathology. Minimal heterogeneity (I2 = 0%) further supports robustness. To date, only one systematic review has assessed ultrasound for MCL injuries (1), reporting lower sensitivity (63–87%) and specificity (83–96%). The improved accuracy in this review reflects larger sample sizes, technological advances, and increased operator experience. For MM injuries, pooled sensitivity was 85% (95% CI: 82–88) and specificity 89% (95% CI: 81–94), with a DOR of 45 and AUC of 0.88. These findings suggest moderate diagnostic performance, particularly for ruling out pathology. Earlier reviews (18, 19, 20) reported sensitivity ranging from 77.5–88.8% and specificity from 83.3–90%, indicating this review shows slightly higher sensitivity and comparable specificity. However, substantial heterogeneity, particularly in specificity (I2 = 70.6%) and low certainty of evidence, should be considered when interpreting these findings. Although, ultrasound demonstrated strong diagnostic accuracy for MCL injuries and moderate for MM injuries, these results should be interpreted cautiously. Ultrasound is valuable in point-of-care settings, but MRI remains essential when high-grade MCL injury or complex, surgically relevant MM pathology is suspected. Thus, ultrasound should be considered a complementary or first-line screening tool, rather than a replacement for MRI in more severe or uncertain cases. Differences in diagnostic accuracy seen across studies, may be attributed to patient age, probe frequency, positioning, and operator experience. The two included studies (44, 46) with the youngest cohorts (20’s), had consistent high scores across sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy. Previously, Alizadeh et al. (56) found ultrasound accuracy exceeded 95% in patients under 30 but dropped significantly in older groups. Anatolia et al. (57) similarly reported better performance in patients under 35. Certainly, degenerative changes in older patients, such as hypoechoic tissue, joint space narrowing, and osteophyte formation, are likely to reduce visualisation and diagnostic yield (56, 57). Furthermore, both these studies (56, 57) incorporated prone positioning to assess the posterior horn of the MM, reporting improved sensitivity. Given that over 70% of load transmission occurs in the middle and posterior zones (58), with most tears occurring posteriorly (59), prone evaluation is critical. Rodriquez-Sanz et al. (60), using cadaveric models, demonstrated near-complete visualisation of the MM with supine and prone positioning. Despite previous studies advocating both supine and prone positioning, only 50% of the included studies used this approach. Further, within this review, only two studies (50, 51), discussed specific anatomical location of MM injury, both reporting that the posterior horn had the largest number of tears, 71% (50) and 100% (51) respectively. Akatsu et al. (61) also supported prone evaluation, however, noted ultrasound’s limitations in detecting tear morphology. This was in keeping with this review’s findings where bucket handle tears, which often necessitate surgical intervention, were not detected by ultrasound. Further, ultrasound was noted to have difficulty detecting radial and horizontal tears. Thus, ultrasound may lack the ability to clearly classify type of tears and may be more useful as an initial screening tool. Probe frequency was another key factor, demonstrated in the study with the lowest specificity, using the lowest frequency (49), in contrast to those using high-frequency probes, reporting specificity of 94.7–100% and accuracy above 96% (47, 48, 54). Similarly, the study with the highest MM diagnostic values, used one of the highest probe frequencies and had among the most experienced clinicians (48). Operator experience was equally important, with the lowest accuracy, correlating with clinicians receiving only four hours of training (43), highlighting the known steep learning curve novice clinicians’ experience (62-64). Strengths and limitations This is the first systematic review and meta-analysis focused solely on ultrasound’s diagnostic accuracy for MCL injuries and the most contemporary for MM injuries. It combines quantitative analysis with critical appraisal, offering clinically relevant insights. However, limitations exist, including the exclusion of non-English studies, which may introduce selection bias, and heterogeneity, which may limit generalisability. Additionally, the exclusion of Scopus and Web of Science databases may have reduced retrieval breadth, and limited citation tracking sensitivity. Finally, the strength of conclusions depends on the quality of included studies. Across both MCL and MM analyses, several studies and pooled DORs showed wide confidence intervals due to small sample sizes and limited data, meaning these estimates should be interpreted cautiously. While most included studies exhibited low risk of bias, the overall certainty of evidence warrants consideration. Conclusions This systematic review and meta-analysis demonstrates that diagnostic ultrasound offers high specificity for MCL injuries and moderate sensitivity for MM injuries. These findings support its use as a valuable modality for assessing MCL injuries in point of care and early assessment settings and as an effective screening tool for MM injuries. While MRI and arthroscopy remain the gold standards, ultrasound provides a non-invasive, cost-effective, and accessible alternative, particularly relevant in healthcare systems facing diagnostic backlogs. However, MRI remains essential with high-grade MCL injury due to potential concurrent injuries, or where complex, surgically relevant MM pathology is suspected. Variability in operator expertise, imaging technique, and study populations may also influence diagnostic performance, highlighting the need for consistent imaging standards and further research. Nevertheless, integrating ultrasound into diagnostic pathways may contribute to reduced delays, more efficient resource use, and improved accessibility. Acknowledgements: The authors would like to thank Liz Askew, the information and knowledge specialist, for support with the development of the database search strategy. Author’s Contributions: MP conceived and designed the study, conducted the literature search, led the quality assessment, data extraction and analysis, and drafted the manuscript. AS acted as an independent second reviewer, contributed to study design, quality assessment, data interpretation, and critically revised the manuscript. Both authors approved the final manuscript. Funding: This research received no external funding. Availability of Data and Material: All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files. Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate: No ethical approval was required, as no primary research was conducted. The authors declare no conflicts of interest. Consent for Publication: Not applicable. Competing Interests: The authors declare no competing interests. Declaration on the Use of AI: None. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary File 1 - Databases’ search strategies PubMed search Title “Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in assessing medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries? A systematic review and meta-analysis.” PIRD framework - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Index test – ultrasound. - Index test – ultrasound. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. Search strategy pubmed Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[Mesh] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[Mesh] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[Mesh] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] Tiab-terms [ti = title, ab = abstract] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] Tiab-terms [ti = title, ab = abstract] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] Truncation - Use of “ ”- Use of * Truncation - Use of “ ” - Use of “ ” - Use of * - Use of * Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab]#5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR “Diagnostic Imaging”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Filters/limits applied - Adults- Humans- 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024)- English Language- Full text Filters/limits applied - Adults - Adults - Humans - Humans - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - English Language - English Language - Full text - Full text Embase search Title “Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in assessing medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries? A systematic review and meta-analysis.” PIRD framework - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Index test – ultrasound. - Index test – ultrasound. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. Search strategy embase F)Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Medial Meniscus”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injury”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasound/dia” [MeSH] Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Medial Meniscus”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injury”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasound/dia” [MeSH] #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Medial Meniscus”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injury”[MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasound/dia” [MeSH] G)Tiab-terms #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] Tiab-terms #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] H) Truncation - Use of “ ”- Use of * Truncation - Use of “ ” - Use of “ ” - Use of * - Use of * I) Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Medial Meniscus”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasound/dia”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab]#5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Medial Meniscus”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasound/dia”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 J) Filters/limits applied - Adults- Humans- 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024)- English Language- Full text Filters/limits applied - Adults - Adults - Humans - Humans - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - English Language - English Language - Full text - Full text Cinahl ultimate search Title “Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in assessing medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries? A systematic review and meta-analysis.” PIRD framework - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Index test – ultrasound. - Index test – ultrasound. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. Search strategy cinahl ultimate K)Cinahl ultimate MeSH terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial” [MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries” [MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography” [MeSH] Cinahl ultimate MeSH terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial” [MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries” [MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography” [MeSH] #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial” [MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries” [MeSH]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography” [MeSH] L)Tiab-terms (ti = title, ab = abstract) #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] Tiab-terms (ti = title, ab = abstract) #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial collateral ligament*” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuriesinjur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab]#4 ultrasoundultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] M) Truncation - Use of “ ”- Use of * Truncation - Use of “ ” - Use of “ ” - Use of * - Use of * N) Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab]#5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee” [MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain* [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound [tiab] #5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 O) Filters/limits applied - Adults- Humans- 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024)- English Language- Full text Filters/limits applied - Adults - Adults - Humans - Humans - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - English Language - English Language - Full text - Full text Cochrane search Title “Diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound in assessing medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries? A systematic review and meta-analysis.” PIRD framework - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Population – Adults who have suffered medial meniscus or medial collateral ligament injuries. - Index test – ultrasound. - Index test – ultrasound. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Reference test – MRI and arthroscopy. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. - Diagnosis of Interest – medial collateral ligament and medial meniscus injuries. Search strategy pubMed P)Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH ]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[MeSH]” Me-SH Terms #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH ]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[MeSH]” #1 medial collateral ligament“Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH]#2 medial meniscus“Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH]#3 knee injuries“Knee Injuries”[MeSH ]#4 ultrasound“Ultrasonography”[MeSH]” Q)Tiab-terms (ti = title, ab = abstract) #1 medial collateral ligament“medial ligament* collateral” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuries“injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab]#4 ultrasound“ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab] Tiab-terms (ti = title, ab = abstract) #1 medial collateral ligament“medial ligament* collateral” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuries“injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab]#4 ultrasound“ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab] #1 medial collateral ligament“medial ligament* collateral” [tiab]#2 medial meniscus“medial menisc*” [tiab]#3 injuries“injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab]#4 ultrasound“ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab] R) Truncation - Use of “ ”- Use of * Truncation - Use of “ ” - Use of “ ” - Use of * - Use of * S) Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR “injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR “ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab]#5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 Combing MeSH and tiab into search blocks #1 medial collateral ligament “Medial Collateral Ligament, Knee”[MeSH] OR “medial collateral ligament*” [tiab] #2 medial meniscus “Menisci, Tibial”[MeSH] OR “medial menisc*” [tiab] #3 injury “Knee Injuries”[MeSH] OR “injur* or tear* or sprain* or strain*” [tiab] #4 ultrasound “Ultrasonography”[MeSH] OR “ultrasound or sonograph* or sonogram or ultrasonography* or pocus or point-of-care ultrasound or point of care ultrasound or bedside ultrasound” [tiab] #5 #1 OR #2 AND #3 AND #4 T) Filters/limits applied - Adults- Humans- 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024)- English Language- Full text Filters/limits applied - Adults - Adults - Humans - Humans - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - 10 years (1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024) - English Language - English Language - Full text - Full text Supplementary File 2 – Inclusion and exclusion criteria InclusionExclusionEmpirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of symptomatic medial meniscus and MCL injuries. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of ACL, PCL, LCL or lateral meniscus injuries only. Published between 1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024. Published pre-1st October 2014. Cross-sectional (cohort) studies, diagnostic accuracy comparative studies. Case control studies. Humans. Animal/Cadaver studies. Adults. Study Population of less than 20. English Language. Review Studies. Full text. Duplicate Studies. Must include TP, FP, TN, FN information. Missing TP, FP, TN, FN information. Reference standard of arthroscopy and/or MRI. No reference standard included or different from arthroscopy and/or MRI. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of symptomatic medial meniscus and MCL injuries. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of symptomatic medial meniscus and MCL injuries. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of ACL, PCL, LCL or lateral meniscus injuries only. Empirical and grey literature research relating to diagnostic ultrasound of ACL, PCL, LCL or lateral meniscus injuries only. Published between 1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024. Published between 1st October 2014 – 31st October 2024. Published pre-1st October 2014. Published pre-1st October 2014. Cross-sectional (cohort) studies, diagnostic accuracy comparative studies. Cross-sectional (cohort) studies, diagnostic accuracy comparative studies. Case control studies. Case control studies. Humans. Humans. Animal/Cadaver studies. Animal/Cadaver studies. Adults. Adults. Study Population of less than 20. Study Population of less than 20. English Language. English Language. Review Studies. Review Studies. Full text. Full text. Duplicate Studies. Duplicate Studies. Must include TP, FP, TN, FN information. Must include TP, FP, TN, FN information. Missing TP, FP, TN, FN information. Missing TP, FP, TN, FN information. Reference standard of arthroscopy and/or MRI. Reference standard of arthroscopy and/or MRI. No reference standard included or different from arthroscopy and/or MRI. No reference standard included or different from arthroscopy and/or MRI. Supplementary File 3 - Excluded articles from final search process/review Inclusion & Exclusion Numbers from Final Process for Inclusion within ReviewSOURCEINCLUDEDEXCLUDEDTOTALEmbase4610Pubmed1910Google Scholar549Other4711Total142640 Inclusion & Exclusion Numbers from Final Process for Inclusion within Review Excluded Articles’ Details & Reasons for ExclusionNo.AuthorsTitleYearJournalReason for Exclusion1.Artul S, Khazin F, Hakim J, Habib G.Ultrasonographic findings in a large series of patients with knee pain.2014Journal of Clinical Imaging ScienceNon-DTA study/no reference standard included, such as MRI or arthroscopy.2.Kijowski R, Roemer F, Englund M, Tiderius CJ, Swärd P, Frobell RB.Imaging following acute knee trauma2014Osteoarthritis and CartilageReview study.3.Nogueira-Barbosa MH, Gregio-Junior E, Lorenzato MM, Guermazi A, Roemer FW, Chagas-Neto FA, Crema MD.Ultrasound assessment of medial meniscal extrusion: a validation study using MRI as reference standard.2015American Journal of RoentgenologyOnly measuring meniscal extrusion, no evidence of injury or tear.4.Artul S, Jabaly-Habib H, Artoul F, Habib GThe association between Baker’s cyst and medial meniscal tear in patients with symptomatic knee using ultrasonography.2015Clinical ImagingNon-DTA study/no reference standard included, such as MRI or arthroscopy.5.Akatsu Y, Yamaguchi S, Mukoyama S, Morikawa T, Yamaguchi T, Tsuchiya K, Iwasaki J, Akagi R, Muramatsu Y, Katsuragi J, Fukawa T.Accuracy of high-resolution ultrasound in the detection of meniscal tears and determination of the visible area of menisci.2015JBJSSubjects = cadavers.6.Singh B, Pawar KN, Kachewar S, Ghule SS, Lakhkar DLEvaluation of knee joint by ultrasound and MRI.2016Journal of Dental and Medical SciencesPoor/limited methodology, with no inclusion or exclusion criteria included, no information on who completed or assessed the images.7.Ghosh N, Kruse D, Subeh M, Lahham S, Fox JC.Comparing point-of-care-ultrasound (POCUS) to MRI for the diagnosis of medial compartment knee injuries.2017Journal of Medical UltrasoundOnly 9 subjects included within study, and as <20 subjects included, excluded as per inclusion/criteria.8.Diermeier T, Achtnich A, Imhoff AB, Wörtler K, Petersen W.Meniscal extrusion in ultrasound as a new diagnostic tool for evaluation of medial meniscus function.2017Orthopaedic Journal of Sports MedicineStudy based on non-symptomatic subjects.9.Liao CL, Yu CW, Cheng YH, Wang TG.Is Ultrasound Reliable for the Diagnosis of Knee Medial Collateral Ligament Injury?2017Rehabilitation Practice and ScienceVery limited statistical information provided, including no sensitivity, specificity or accuracy data.10.Abram SG, Beard DJ, Price AJ, BASK Meniscal Working Group.National consensus on the definition, investigation, and classification of meniscal lesions of the knee.2018The KneeReview study.11.Mostafa HA, Abou Elfotuh AM, Alsakka MM.MRI versus ultrasound in diagnosis of meniscal tear in knee joint.2019The Egyptian Journal of Hospital Medicine.Doesn’t include any statistical information/break down on medial meniscal tears, including sensitivity, specificity, accuracy etc – puts all information together including lateral and medial meniscal tears. Authors contacted by email requesting whether information available – no response to request.12.Chiba D, Sasaki E, Ota S, Maeda S, Sugiyama D, Nakaji S, Ishibashi Y.US detection of medial meniscus extrusion can predict the risk of developing radiographic knee osteoarthritis: a 5-year cohort study.2020European RadiologyNo reference standard of MRI or arthroscopy utilised.13.Reisner JH, Franco JM, Hollman JH, Johnson AC, Sellon JL, Finnoff JT.Ultrasound assessment of weight-bearing and non–weight-bearing meniscal extrusion: a reliability study.2020PM&RNon-DTA study/no reference standard included, such as MRI or arthroscopy.14.El Sheikh H, Faheem M, Abdelmoeim A.Role of ultrasonographic examination of the knee in evaluation of meniscal injury in correlation with magnetic resonance imaging.2020Benha Medical JournalLimited methodology included – no information on who completed ultrasound or MRI, no information on order of imaging, no information on whether blinding occurred, no information on flow and timing of index or reference standard.15.Abuomira IE, Ahmed YA, Elshahat MT.Comparison between ultrasonography and MRI in diagnosis of knee joint meniscal injuries.2021Al-Azhar Assiut Medical JournalExtremely limited methodology+++.16.Jokela MA, Mäkinen TJ, Koivikko MP, Lindahl JM, Halinen J, Lindahl J.Treatment of medial-sided injuries in patients with early bicruciate ligament reconstruction for knee dislocation.2021Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, ArthroscopyNo diagnostic ultrasound included within study, was based on findings based on stress radiographs and MRI.17.Sundararajan SR, Ramakanth R, Sethuraman AS, Kannan M, Rajasekaran S.Correlation of factors affecting correction of meniscal extrusion and outcome after medial meniscus root repair.2022Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma SurgeryScreening of MRI used only, no diagnostic ultrasound included within study.18.Oo WM, Linklater JM, Bennell KL, Daniel MS, Pryke D, Wang X, Yu SP, Deveza L, Duong V, Hunter DJ.Reliability and convergent construct validity of quantitative ultrasound for synovitis, meniscal extrusion, and osteophyte in knee osteoarthritis with MRI.2022Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine.Only included information on medial extrusion and patients with knee pain, no history of injury/trauma. Study based on diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound v MRI in diagnosing osteoarthritis, such as medial extrusion.19.Chiba D, Sasaki T, Ishibashi YGreater medial meniscus extrusion seen on ultrasonography indicates the risk of MRI-detected complete medial meniscus posterior root tear in a Japanese population with knee pain.2022Scientific ReportsAll subjects without any history of injury/trauma, study based on degenerative medial meniscal pathology/osteoarthritis, rather than medial meniscal tears.20.Falkowski AL, Jacobson JA, Cresswell M, Bedi A, Kalia V, Zhang B.Medial Meniscal Extrusion Evaluation with Weight-Bearing Ultrasound.2022The Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine.No clear history of injury within inclusion, study focusing on medial extrusion including normal, degenerative meniscal and tears. No clear information included on DTA of ultrasound v MRI regarding sensitivity, specificity or accuracy data.21.Maheshwari M, Yadav PK, Jain S, Batham IK, Gupta A, Swaika S.Imaging of Knee Joint Pathologies: A Comparative Study of Ultrasound and Magnetic Resonance Imaging.2022Journal of Medical SciencesNo methodology included within study.22.Gayathri Mohanan DU, Job S.Sonological evaluation of medial knee injuries and its comparison with magnetic resonance imaging findings: A study.2022International Journal of OrthopaedicsDuplicate study – but published with different title and in different Journal.23.Wasilczyk C.The Value of Ultrasound Diagnostic Imaging of Meniscal Knee Injuries Verified by Experimental and Arthroscopic Investigations.2023DiagnosticsSubjects = Cadavers.24.VS SR, Jinu CK.Diagnostic Accuracy of Ultrasound in the Evaluation of Collateral Ligaments and Meniscal Injuries of Knee in Comparison with Magnetic Resonance Imaging.2023RGUHS Journal of Medical SciencesLimited methodology included – no information on who completed ultrasound or MRI, no information on order of imaging, no information on whether blinding occurred, no information on flow and timing of index or reference standard.25.Uusimaa AP, Kemppainen A, Nevalainen MT.Medial meniscus extrusion is associated with meniscus tears in US and MRI: A case control study.2024Journal of Clinical UltrasoundCase study26.Kanayama T, Nakase J, Ishida Y, Yanatori Y, Takemoto N, Demura S.Identifying unstable ramp lesions using ultrasonography.2024Journal of Medical UltrasonicsNon-DTA study, no clear information on including no sensitivity, specificity or accuracy data. Excluded Articles’ Details & Reasons for Exclusion Supplementary File 4 – Study characteristics Supplementary File 5 – Medial collateral ligament injuries – plots MCL Specificity Forest Plot MCL Sensitivity Forest Plot MCL DOR Forest Plot MCL Accuracy Forest Plot MCL PPV Forest Plot MCL NPV Forest Plot MCL Specificity Funnel Plot MCL Sensitivity Funnel Plot MCL SROC Curve Based on REML Bivariate Modelling Supplementary File 6 – Medial meniscus injuries – plots MM Specificity Forest Plot MM Sensitivity Forest Plot MM DOR Forest Plot MM Accuracy Forest Plot MM PPV Forest Plot MM NPV Forest Plot MM Specificity Funnel Plot MM Sensitivity Funnel Plot MM SROC Curve Based on REML Bivariate Modelling