Effectiveness of monitoring mechanisms in reducing immunization dropouts among infants in health facilities of Maridi County, South Sudan Authors: Daniel Opinile Mark Igga, Nzomo Mwita, Kennedy Muni, Patricia Fast, Patricia Fast, Patricia Fast, Patricia Fast Published: 2026 ABSTRACT IntroductionChildhood immunization is among the most cost-effective public health strategies available, yet dropout rates, the proportion of infants who begin but fail to complete the recommended vaccination schedule, remain a persistent obstacle to achieving high and equitable coverage. Global third-dose pentavalent coverage stood at 86% in 2019, declined to 84% in 2020, and fell further to 82% in 2021, consistently falling short of the 85% minimum target. This shortfall is especially pronounced in fragile health systems such as that of South Sudan, where facility-level and community-level monitoring mechanisms vary widely in availability and quality.MethodsI conducted a prospective cohort study from 1 October to 31 December 2023 in Maridi County, Western Equatoria State, South Sudan. Fourteen health facilities were selected by stratified random sampling (seven from payams with active Boma Health Initiative [BHI] activities and seven from payams without). One vaccinator per facility was selected by coin toss, yielding 26 participants. A semi-structured interview guide administered in month one and a monthly observation checklist applied across all three months were used to collect data. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics, chi-square tests, Spearman correlations, and multivariable regression to assess associations between monitoring mechanisms and facility-level dropout rates.ResultsThree of the 14 facilities (21%) had no monitoring chart; 28.6% recorded a dropout rate above 10%, while half (50%) achieved the target of below 10%. Facilities with updated monitoring charts were significantly less likely to record high dropout rates (Spearman r = −0.725, p = 0.003). Boma Health Workers (BHWs), community-level health personnel who mobilize, trace, and refer immunization defaulters, were attached to 64% of facilities; 91.7% of facility-months in the low-dropout category had BHWs present, compared with 37.5% in the high-dropout category. Over the three months of observation, the proportion of facilities recording a dropout rate above 10% fell by 9.6 percentage points.ConclusionsFacility-based monitoring tools used by health workers (monitoring charts, immunization registers, and defaulter tracing systems) and community-based monitoring carried out by BHWs were each independently associated with lower dropout rates, and their combination appears to have a complementary effect. Neither mechanism was sufficient alone. We recommend that health workers use monitoring tools consistently and that the Boma Health Initiative be scaled up to health facilities currently without BHWs. Introduction Immunization is one of the most efficient and successful health interventions for the reduction of child morbidity and mortality. The World Health Organization (WHO) established the Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI) in 1974 to ensure universal access to routinely recommended childhood immunizations [1]. Despite half a century of progress under EPI, a substantial gap persists between the children who begin vaccination and those who complete it, a gap commonly measured as the immunization dropout rate. In 2021, 18.2 million infants did not receive an initial dose of DTP vaccine globally, and an additional 6.8 million were only partially vaccinated. More than 60% of these under-immunized children live in ten countries spanning sub-Saharan Africa and South and South-East Asia, highlighting the geographical concentration of the challenge [2]. Monitoring data at subnational level is therefore critical to helping countries prioritize and tailor vaccination strategies to address immunization gaps. Third-dose pentavalent coverage, a widely used proxy for immunization system performance, stood at 86% globally in 2019 but slipped to 84% in 2020 and 82% in 2021, consistently falling short of the 85% floor target set by the Immunization Agenda 2030 [3]. These setbacks, compounded by the disruption of routine health services during the COVID-19 pandemic, have renewed urgency around identifying which health system mechanisms can reliably reduce dropout. South Sudan has been battling with underperformance and low coverage of the DPT-1 at 58% and DPT-3 at 50% in 2019. However, the country has experienced improvement in subsequent years and as of 2022, the coverage was at 97.6% for DPT-1 and 84.4% for DPT-3. Despite this progress, a dropout rate of 13.2% still signals that many children who start the immunization schedule do not complete it. Measles vaccine coverage was 42% in 2019 and 65.6% in 2022, still below the minimum performance target of 85% [4]. Maridi county has been among the top three counties leading in immunization performance in Western Equatoria State, despite the challenges of immunization defaulters that have been affecting the county performance from reaching its targets. According to 2022 programme data, third-dose pentavalent coverage in the county was 82% and measles vaccine coverage was 55%, both below the national 85% target. Prompt action and a collaborative approach linking facility-level monitoring with community-level tracing are needed to ensure infants complete their vaccination schedules as per national guidelines, thereby increasing herd immunity and reducing the burden of vaccine-preventable disease. The Immunization Coverage Monitoring Chart is a very simple yet effective tool that has been in use for decades. When updated monthly, it gives a visual representation that enables immunization programme managers to set and evaluate monthly goals in a timely fashion, provides a basis for comparing performance across different time periods, monitors each vaccine and dose separately, and reflects the situation accurately [5]. Alongside the monitoring chart, the defaulter tracing system, which is centred on the tickler file (a card-based system organized by month of next expected visit), gives health workers an operational means of identifying which specific children have missed an appointment. Community-level follow-up in Maridi County is supported by the Boma Health Initiative (BHI), a South Sudan-specific programme that deploys trained Boma Health Workers (BHWs) at village level to mobilize communities, counsel mothers, and refer immunization defaulters back to health facilities. Because the term is used inconsistently in the immunization literature, we define it explicitly here. For the purposes of this study, monitoring mechanisms refers to the systematic tools and processes used to track vaccination coverage, identify defaulters, and prompt corrective action. These fall into two categories, distinguished by who operates them. Facility-level monitoring is carried out by vaccinators and health workers inside the health facility, using the immunization monitoring chart, immunization registers, defaulter tracing cards and tickler files, and the health facility microplanning (HFMP) document. Community-level monitoring is carried out by BHWs in the facility catchment area, and consists of household mobilization, tracing of children identified as defaulters, and referral of those children back to the facility. This distinction is maintained throughout the paper. Little prospective evidence exists from South Sudan, or from comparable fragile-state settings, on whether these mechanisms actually reduce dropout rates when implemented in real-world health facilities. This study sought to fill that gap by following 14 health facilities across three months, comparing facilities with and without BHI activities, and examining the associations between monitoring chart use, BHW engagement, defaulter tracing system functionality, and measured dropout rates. Materials and methods Study design and setting A prospective cohort study design was used, for a duration of three months from 01/10/2023 to 31/12/2023, in order to answer the research questions. The unit of analysis was the health facility. The study was carried out in Maridi County of Western Equatoria State, South Sudan, approximately 86 miles from Yambio (the state capital) and 185 miles from Juba. The county has five payams and 81 bomas. Health facilities were divided into two strata: one with boma health initiative activities and those that do not have these activities in order to determine the effectiveness of immunization monitoring mechanisms to reduce immunization dropouts. Sampling A stratified random sampling method was used to draw participants and the health facilities from the two strata. Using EPI info software for calculating the samples needed for the study, at 95% confidence level, 14 health facilities were selected. In the 14 health facilities, a total of 26 vaccinators were divided proportionately into 2 categories: 13 vaccinators from health facilities with BHI and 13 vaccinators from health facilities with no BHI. A coin was tossed to select a vaccinator from each eligible health facility (each facility generally has two vaccinators). Inclusion criteria: Health facilities were selected based on their functionality and provision of immunization services at the health facility. Each health facility had two vaccinators who relatively performed same task, thus one vaccinator per health facility was included and assessed using the semi-structured interview, selected by the coin toss described above. Exclusion criteria: Health facilities that did not provide immunization service were excluded from sampling. The vaccinator not selected by the coin toss was excluded from the semi-structured interview. The study excluded participants who were minors, aged < 18 years. Data collection A semi-structured interview guide and an observation checklist were used to collect data from the respondents. The semi-structured interview guide had a written informed consent that explained the purpose of the research and how their responses would be confidentially kept by the research team. Participants were free to leave the research at any given point in time within the research period. Each participant had to sign the consent form to indicate their acceptance and willingness to participate in the study. The consent form was prepared in English. Because participants varied in the language they were most comfortable with, I verbally interpreted the consent form into each participant’s preferred language (Juba Arabic, Muru, Azande, Baka, or Avokaya) immediately before they signed. No written translations were produced; the interpretation was delivered by me, in person, on each occasion, and I obtained written informed consent from every participant myself. This verbal interpretation protocol was described in the study protocol and approved by the Amref International University Ethics and Scientific Review Committee and the South Sudan Ministry of Health Research Ethics Review Board. Whereas the observation checklist was used to collect data from the health facility using the approval letter from the county health department for data collection at the health facility. No participant was involved in the data collected through the observation checklist. The checklist items were transcribed from records the facility maintains for its own reporting (the monthly summary report, the immunization registers, and the monitoring chart) rather than from real-time observation of health worker behaviour. Because those records document performance accumulated across the whole month, rather than conduct at the moment of the visit, this reduces (though it does not eliminate) the risk that facilities appeared to perform better simply because they knew I was present. No independent re-abstraction of the records was carried out, and this is noted as a limitation. Data management and analysis Data was collected on the first month using the semi-structured interview guide while observation checklist was used in the three months, from 01/10/2023 to 31/12/2023, hence data was collected on monthly basis for the duration of the study. The data from the research instrument was cleaned, coded, and entered into Excel sheet on monthly basis for analysis as well as tracking the study and into SPSS after the study duration for further analysis. Descriptive statistics such as frequencies and percentages were used to describe the respondents’ demographic statistics, marital status, educational level and years of experience in expanded programme on immunization. Whereas bivariable analysis was used to determine relationships between the independent variables and the dependent variable. Chi square test was used to compare the dropout rates of health facilities that were exposed to and those not exposed to boma health initiative, immunization monitoring chart and linking defaulters for vaccination. This examined whether the presence of BHWs in health facilities was associated with low dropout rates (less than 10%) or high dropout rates (more than 10%). Multivariable regression analysis was used to determine association between the variables to answer the research questions and hypotheses. Because facilities were not randomized to condition, all results reported below are associations and should not be read as establishing causation. Statistical significance was set at α = 0.05. Ethical considerations The study obtained ethical approval from the AMIU ESRC, South Sudan Research Ethics Committee, approval from the state ministry of health in Western Equatoria State and from Maridi County Health Department that oversees the health facilities where the research was conducted. I obtained written informed consent from every participant before data collection began, having first explained the purpose of the research and assured them of the confidentiality measures that would be undertaken to safeguard respondent data. All the research data were kept safely by me for future reference, identified by participant number rather than name. Results Participant and facility characteristics All 14 health facilities that were selected for the study were reached during the study. Fourteen interviews were completed in month one and 42 observation checklists were collected (one per facility per month). Out of the 14 health facilities, 12 (86%) were supported by non-governmental organizations while 2 (14%) were supported by the Government. Throughout this section, “respondent” denotes the single vaccinator selected to respond on behalf of each health facility; there were therefore 14 respondents, one per facility. Eleven respondents (79%) were male and 3 (21%) were female; 13 (93%) were married. Ten respondents (71%) had reached secondary level of education and 4 (29%) primary level. Disaggregated by sex, 10 male respondents had attained secondary-level education and 1 attained primary education level, while all 3 female respondents had attained primary-level education only. Educational level, with confidence interval (Mean difference: 1.71, 95% CI:1.44–1.98) is a significant factor for using immunization tools (Table 1). 10.1371/journal.pone.0356268.t001Table 1Demographic characteristics of respondents (N = 14).Characteristicn% Sex Male1178.6Female321.4 Marital status Married1392.9Single17.1 Highest education level Secondary1071.4Primary428.6 Health facility funding source NGO-supported1285.7Government-supported214.3NGO = non-governmental organization Demographic characteristics of respondents (N = 14). NGO = non-governmental organization Use of immunization monitoring charts to track immunization performance Eleven out of fourteen facilities (79%) health facilities had monitoring chart for displaying the immunization performance of the health facility, with 10 of those 11 (71%) of the health facilities having their monitoring charts updated with the previous month data. The remaining 3 facilities (21%) had no monitoring chart at all. Table 2 cross-tabulates monitoring chart status with dropout rate category across the 42 facility-month observations. 10.1371/journal.pone.0356268.t002Table 2Monitoring chart status by dropout rate category across 42 facility-month observations.Monitoring chart statusDropout <10% n (%)Dropout >10% n (%)No chart n (%)Chart present and updated24 (57.1)4 (9.5)n/aChart present, not updated05 (11.9)n/aNo monitoring chartn/an/a9 (21.4)Values are counts and column percentages. Cells marked n/a indicate structural absence. Rows are mutually exclusive. Monitoring chart status by dropout rate category across 42 facility-month observations. Values are counts and column percentages. Cells marked n/a indicate structural absence. Rows are mutually exclusive. Respondents were not restricted to a single answer, and several facilities used more than one tool; the categories below therefore overlap and do not sum to 100%. Seven respondents (50%) reported using immunization registers to identify immunization defaulters, 4 (29%) used tickler files, 2 (14%) used defaulter tracing cards, and 1 (7%) used the monitoring chart to identify defaulters. Use of monitoring tools to identify immunization defaulters was significantly associated with a lower rate of defaulters (Mean difference: 1.78, 95% CI: 1.22–2.35). The use of monitoring tools was associated with the health facility microplanning document having been updated, with a 54% coefficient of association and p-value 0.04, indicating that the more the microplanning documents were updated the more likely monitoring tools were used to identity immunization defaulters. The observation data indicated that most of the health facility filled the immunization registers correctly regardless of the dropout rate. This is a very important aspect of the data management as incorrect data filling would result into misclassification of the dropouts and also immunization visits. Eleven out of the fourteen of the respondents (79%) confirmed that they used monitoring chart for plotting the performance of the 1st and 3rd dose of Pentavalent, 13 (93%) recorded child’s information in the immunization register, child health card and dropout/defaulter tracing cards at the start of the vaccination session. Eight respondents (57%) check their monitoring chart three (3) times in a quarter while 2 (14%) checked twice and 3 (21%) checked once. Updated monitoring chart showed significant inverse association with the dropout rate of the health facility with 72.5% correlation coefficient and p-value of 0.003, implying that the more a health facility updated their monitoring chart the less likely would the health facility have increased dropout rate. Involvement of Boma Health Initiative contributes to reduced immunization dropouts Sixty-four percent (9 of 14) of the respondents affirmed that they have boma health workers attached to their facilities while 5 (36%) had community mobilizers who were volunteers assigned by their community. Eighty six percent (12 of 14) of the health workers and vaccinators affirmed that they received referrals from the BHWs and community mobilizers while 2 (14%) of the respondents did not receive referrals, indicating gaps in referral activities. The type of referrals is important to address the dropouts: out of the two types of referrals, defaulters and zero-dose referrals, heath facilities with less than 10% dropout rate had 86% of the received referrals were defaulters, whereas health facilities with more than 10% dropout rate had 50% defaulters, 25% zero-dose and 25% no referrals. Table 3 presents the relationship between BHW attachment and dropout rate category. 10.1371/journal.pone.0356268.t003Table 3BHW attachment status in relation to dropout rate category across 42 facility-month observations.BHW statusDropout <10% n (%)Dropout >10% n (%)No monitoring chart n (%)BHW attached22 (91.7)3 (37.5)6 (60.0)No BHW2 (8.3)5 (62.5)4 (40.0) Total 24 8 10 BHW = Boma Health Worker. Values are counts and row percentages. BHW attachment status in relation to dropout rate category across 42 facility-month observations. BHW = Boma Health Worker. Values are counts and row percentages. Facilities with BHWs attached accounted for 91.7% of low-dropout facility-months, compared with 37.5% of high-dropout facility-months. The number of BHWs attached to a facility was significantly associated with lower dropout (Mean difference: 2.35, 95% CI: 2.07–2.64). All the health facilities with desirable (less than 10%) dropout rate had put effort to identify the defaulters and trace them in order to complete their vaccination schedule while facilities with more than 10% dropout rates had documented effort to identify and trace defaulters recorded in only 50% of their facility-month observations; that is, in half of the months observed at those facilities, no such effort was recorded at all. The checklist captured this as a binary yes/no item and did not measure how much effort was expended. Defaulter tracing system to ensure infants complete their vaccination schedule Ninety three percent (13 of 14) of the respondents confirmed that their facilities have defaulter tracing system, with eighty-six percent (12 of 14) who filled the dropout cards, thirty-six percent (5 of 14) knew the overall importance of using tickler file as a defaulter tracing system while twenty-one percent (3 of 14) only knew that it is used to track the next visit of the infant. Thirteen respondents (93%) understood that vaccine stockouts increase the number of defaulters and dropouts. These findings are summarized in Table 4. 10.1371/journal.pone.0356268.t004Table 4Defaulter tracing system characteristics and related practices (N = 14 facilities).Variablen%Health facility has a defaulter tracing system1392.9Defaulter cards filled during vaccination sessions1285.7Respondent knows full purpose of tickler file535.7Vaccine stockout recognized as a cause of dropout1392.9Health facility microplanning document updated1392.9HFMP = Health Facility Microplanning document. Defaulter tracing system characteristics and related practices (N = 14 facilities). HFMP = Health Facility Microplanning document. A health facility without defaulter tracing system is more likely to have increased dropout rate than one with defaulter tracing system (Mean difference: 1.28, 95% CI: 1.02–1.56). About fifteen percent (2 out of 13, 15%) of health facilities who had health facility microplanning document did not agree that defaulter tracing system is important to reduce the number of infants who did not come on time for vaccination. Across the three months of observation, the proportion of facilities recording a dropout rate above 10% fell by 9.6 percentage points. Discussion Monitoring charts and the value of routine data use Facilities that had a monitoring chart, and particularly those that kept it updated, were less likely to record a dropout rate above 10% (r = −0.725, p = 0.003). Because facilities were not randomized, this is an association rather than a demonstrated cause. Our data are consistent with the findings of Chantler and colleagues [6], who showed that the high dropout rates in the health facility were associated with immunization activities and routine immunization registers that were not updated routinely, and defaulter tracing that was rarely conducted. The findings are also consistent with those of Shikuku et al. [7], who showed that active analysis and utilizing routine immunization data together with investing in community health strengthening systems improve immunization coverage. Prakash et al. [8] concluded that comprehensive record-keeping and robust support systems for community health workers are pivotal to improving immunization coverage and reducing the burden of vaccine-preventable diseases; our data are consistent with that conclusion in the South Sudanese context. Health workers should be able to properly use the monitoring tools such as registers and monitoring charts which are vital in ensuring improvement is achieved in immunization thus reducing dropouts in the community. It is worth noting here that the monitoring chart is a performance tool: it is designed to display aggregate coverage and gauge the success of the immunization programme, rather than to identify individual defaulters, for which the register and the defaulter tracing card are the appropriate instruments. Most respondents used the tools in exactly this way, which is a positive indicator of monitoring tool literacy and one worth reinforcing in supervision and training. Boma Health Workers and the community interface Facilities where health workers made documented efforts to identify defaulters were associated with lower dropout rates (Spearman r = 0.354, p = 0.021). This measure requires an important caveat: the observation checklist recorded only whether any effort to identify and link defaulters occurred in a given month, as a binary yes/no item. It did not quantify how much effort was expended, how many households were visited, or how many contacts were attempted, and we did not collect data that would support such a measure. We therefore make no claim about the amount of effort involved, and the earlier framing of this result as a 66% reduction in dropout has been withdrawn as an overinterpretation. Our data are consistent with the findings of Samuel [9], who showed that effective referrals from the community for missed immunization services were due to strengthened linkages between communities and health centers. The mechanism we observed is a two-sided one: health workers identify defaulters and hand over a list, and BHWs locate those children in the community and refer them back. Health workers reported feeling supported in tracing defaulters when BHWs were available to help find the infants. This suggests that strengthening either side of the community-facility interface in isolation may yield diminishing returns. The type of referral also distinguished the two groups. Low-dropout facilities received predominantly defaulter referrals (86%), whereas high-dropout facilities received a more fragmented mix of defaulter, zero-dose, and absent referrals. This suggests that BHW follow-up is most effective for dropout reduction when it is directed at children already known to have missed a dose, while still ensuring zero-dose children are captured. Microplanning, defaulter tracing, and vaccine supply A positive association between the last time Health Facility Microplanning document was updated, the health worker’s ability to use the document and with performance monitoring chart was observed. These indicate the more frequent the HFMP document could be updated, the more likely the health workers and vaccinator would be able to use the document. The study is consistent with Ali et al. [10], who showed that effective routine immunization depends on a microplanning that requires accurate estimation of the population and location maps that shows the location of health facilities and villages of the target populations. Although Mafigiri et al [11] findings showed that lack of updated microplan in the health facility was attributed to lack of knowledge, some health facilities with no updated microplans had high immunization coverage and concluded that health workers’ misunderstanding and limited knowledge about the microplanning process, especially at peripheral health facilities, coupled with the complex, bulky nature of the microplanning tool, reduces the effectiveness of microplanning in improving routine immunization. On the contrary, updating HFMP document was supported by the county health department and updated copies of the HFMP document were handed to the health facility for implementation, thus eliminating the risk that health workers would update the document by themselves. Vaccine supply deserves specific comment, since 93% of respondents identified stockouts as a driver of dropout. Vaccine quantities for a facility are forecast from the catchment population estimate held in the HFMP document and from monthly consumption recorded in the registers, which are the same records that feed the monitoring chart. Where those records are not maintained, ordering is weakened at the same time as defaulter identification is, which may partly explain why the two travelled together in our data. A child turned away during a stockout becomes a defaulter like any other, and should in principle be entered on a defaulter tracing card and recalled once supply is restored. We did not measure whether such recall actually occurred, and this is a gap that future work should address. Limitations Several limitations should be considered. The sample of 14 facilities limits statistical power and generalizability beyond Maridi County. Interviews were conducted at a single time point, introducing potential social desirability bias. The observation checklist was completed by me during facility visits; although it drew on monthly records rather than real-time behaviour, the possibility that facilities performed better in observed months cannot be excluded, and no independent re-abstraction was carried out. Finally, because facilities were not randomized to condition, the associations reported here cannot establish causation. Conclusions Facility-level monitoring (the monitoring chart, the immunization register, and the defaulter tracing system, operated by vaccinators and health workers) and community-level monitoring, operated by BHWs, were each associated with lower immunization dropout rates over the three-month study period. Neither was sufficient alone. Three facilities had no monitoring chart at all, and facilities without BHWs accounted for the majority of high-dropout observations. The microplanning document though not directly a monitoring tool, supported to ensure that vaccine quantities for the health facility were sufficient. Lack of vaccine supply in the health facility was identified to be one of the causes infants’ dropouts of their vaccination schedule. The study observed that lack of efforts from health workers to identify and link defaulters, lack of updated monitoring charts and incorrectly filled immunization registers, absence of BHWs in the health facilities, no referrals from BHWs and lack of support from concerned organizations and government were associated with high dropout rates in some of the health facilities of Maridi County. Therefore, Policy makers to leverage on the defaulter tracing system in the health facilities and activate them to support the effort of the health workers in identifying infants who defaulted easily and improve tracking of the defaulters, the government and its partners to prioritize scaling the BHI to health facilities without BHWs is paramount to support narrowing the gap of defaulters in the community thus reducing immunization defaulters in the community. We further recommend that monitoring data, including HFMP population estimates, register consumption figures, and monthly coverage summaries, be linked directly to vaccine ordering, so that stockout-driven dropout becomes a predictable and preventable event rather than a recurring disruption. Supporting information Organizational support to the health facility. Frequency and percentage distribution of the type of organization supporting the surveyed health facilities (N = 14): non-governmental organization (NGO) versus government. (DOCX) Gender of respondents. Frequency and percentage distribution of respondent gender (N = 14): male versus female. (DOCX) Marital status of respondents. Frequency and percentage distribution of respondent marital status (N = 14): single versus married. (DOCX) Educational level of respondents. Frequency and percentage distribution of respondent educational attainment (N = 14): primary versus secondary. (DOCX) Health facilities with a monitoring chart. Frequency and percentage distribution of health facilities reporting whether they maintain an immunization monitoring chart (N = 14). (DOCX) Monitoring tool used to identify immunization defaulters. Frequency and percentage distribution of the tool used by health facilities to identify immunization defaulters (N = 14): immunization register, tickler file, defaulter tracing cards, or monitoring chart. (DOCX) Accuracy of immunization register completion, by facility dropout-rate category. Cross-tabulation of whether immunization registers were correctly filled for the preceding month against facility dropout-rate category (no monitoring chart, < 10%, > 10%; N = 42). (DOCX) Monitoring chart updated with the previous month’s data. Frequency and percentage distribution of whether the monitoring chart was updated with the previous month’s data (N = 14). (DOCX) Frequency of quarterly performance review using the monitoring chart. Frequency and percentage distribution of how many times per quarter health facility staff check performance using the monitoring chart (N = 14). (DOCX) Correlation between monitoring chart updates and facility dropout rate. Spearman’s rank correlation between facility dropout-rate classification and whether the monitoring chart was updated with the previous month’s data (N = 14; rho = −0.725, p = .003). (DOCX) Accuracy of monitoring chart plotting, by facility dropout-rate category. Cross-tabulation of whether the monitoring chart was plotted correctly against facility dropout-rate category (no monitoring chart, < 10%, > 10%; N = 42). (DOCX) Health facilities with boma health workers attached. Frequency and percentage distribution of health facilities reporting whether boma health workers (BHWs) are attached to the facility (N = 14). (DOCX) Receipt of immunization referrals from boma health workers. Frequency and percentage distribution of whether health facility staff received immunization referrals from boma health workers or community mobilizers (N = 14). (DOCX) Type of immunization referral received from boma health workers, by facility dropout-rate category. Cross-tabulation of the type of referral received (defaulters’ referral, zero-dose referral, both, or none) against facility dropout-rate category (no monitoring chart, < 10%, > 10%; N = 14). (DOCX) Presence of boma health workers in relation to facility dropout rate. Cross-tabulation of whether boma health workers (BHWs) are present at the facility against facility dropout-rate category (no monitoring chart, < 10%, > 10%; N = 42). (DOCX) Health care worker follow-up of identified defaulters, by facility dropout-rate category. Cross-tabulation of whether health care workers (HCWs) made an effort to link with and trace identified defaulters against facility dropout-rate category (no monitoring chart, < 10%, > 10%; N = 42). (DOCX) Correlation between health care worker defaulter tracing and facility dropout rate. Spearman’s rank correlation between whether HCWs made an effort to trace identified defaulters and facility dropout rate (N = 42; rho = 0.354, p = .021). (DOCX) Counseling of defaulting mothers by boma health workers. Frequency and percentage distribution of whether boma health workers counsel mothers of defaulting infants to complete the vaccination schedule before age 1 (N = 14). (DOCX) Health facilities with a defaulter tracing system. Frequency and percentage distribution of whether the health facility has a defaulter tracing system in place (N = 14). (DOCX) Frequency of reviewing the tickler file for defaulter information. Frequency and percentage distribution of how often staff collect defaulter information from the tickler file (N = 14): none, daily, weekly, or monthly. (DOCX) Perceived consequence of absent defaulter tracing systems on vaccine completion. Frequency and percentage distribution of respondent agreement with the statement that, absent a defaulter tracing system, children are less likely to complete vaccine doses such as penta-3 or measles (N = 14). (DOCX) Health facilities with documented immunization microplanning. Frequency and percentage distribution of whether the health facility has documented microplanning specifying outreach locations, stakeholders, a sketch map, and an analysis of the local immunization situation (N = 14). (DOCX) Recency of health facility microplanning updates. Frequency and percentage distribution of when the health facility’s immunization microplanning was last updated: less than one year ago, one year ago, or 2–3 years ago (N = 14). (DOCX) One-way ANOVA of facility indicators across dropout-rate groups. One-way analysis of variance testing whether four facility-level indicators differ across dropout-rate group (no monitoring chart, < 10%, > 10%; N = 14): whether the monitoring chart is updated with the previous month’s data, F(2,11) = 12.833, p = .001; whether the health facility has a defaulter tracing system, F(2,11) = 0.458, p = .644; whether immunization referrals were received from boma health workers or community mobilizers, F(2,11) = 3.929, p = .052; and the recency of the last microplanning update, F(2,11) = 4.939, p = .029. (DOCX) One-sample t-tests of observation-based indicators. SPSS one-sample t-test output (test value = 0) for five facility-level indicators: whether the monitoring chart was updated with data from the monthly summary report, whether the chart was plotted correctly, whether immunization registers were filled correctly for the preceding month, whether health care workers made an effort to link and trace identified defaulters, and dropout rate. Reports t, df, two-tailed significance, mean difference, and the 95% confidence interval of the difference (df = 41 for each test). (PNG) Monitoring chart updates in relation to facility dropout rate. SPSS cross-tabulation and chi-square output for whether the monitoring chart was updated with data from the monthly summary report against facility dropout-rate category (no monitoring chart, < 10%, > 10%; N = 42; Pearson χ² = 42.000, df = 2, p < .001). (PNG) Health care worker defaulter tracing in relation to facility dropout rate. SPSS cross-tabulation and chi-square output for whether health care workers made an effort to link and trace identified defaulters against facility dropout-rate category (no monitoring chart, < 10%, > 10%; N = 42; Pearson χ² = 14.348, df = 2, p < .001). (PNG) Receipt of boma health worker referrals in relation to facility dropout rate. SPSS cross-tabulation and chi-square output for whether health facility staff received immunization referrals from boma health workers or community mobilizers against facility dropout-rate category (no monitoring chart, < 10%, > 10%; N = 14; Pearson χ² = 5.833, df = 2, p = .054). (PNG) 18 Nov 2025 Dear Dr. Igga, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. ============================== The manuscript requires extensive rewriting in order to be fully evaluated. Please look carefully at Reviewer !'s comments, in particular the suggestion to use the STROBE guidelines and checklists for the presentation of observational and qualitative studies. The most important critique is that the methods are not clearly described, particularly how the analysis of the qualitative interviews was done. Also, kindly present a much clearer definition of 'Monitoring': who does it and how do they measure the results? It is not,required that the results be 'novel', only that the research be well described and the results support the conclusions. The attached data are helpful, however some tables should be incorporated in the manuscript and even if they remain in the supplement, it is necessary to refer to them in the manuscript, so the reader can understand your process. The first supplementary data are in fact tables, not figures. Likewise, the qualitative data are not shown. Please describe how you have carried out your analysis. The tables are presented by topic, but what is not shown is the interrelationships between these data as they relate to the individual helath centers. So some of the statements in the paper, about how effort relates to defaulter rate, is not supported by the data as it is provided. Another small example is that you state the male reporteds had secondary education and the females did not, but that can't be discovered from the two separate tables you show. A reader should be able to reproduce your statistical calculations by looking at your data, and that does not seem possible. I have provided additional comments (see attachment). Many of these are grammatical suggestions or suggested wording changes to increase clarity, ============================== Please submit your revised manuscript by Jan 02 2026 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, please include your updated statement in your cover letter. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Patricia Evelyn Fast, MD, Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS ONE Journal requirements: When submitting your revision, we need you to address these additional requirements. 1. Please ensure that your manuscript meets PLOS ONE's style requirements, including those for file naming. The PLOS ONE style templates can be found at https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=wjVg/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_main_body.pdf and https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=ba62/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_title_authors_affiliations.pdf 2. PLOS requires an ORCID iD for the corresponding author in Editorial Manager on papers submitted after December 6th, 2016. Please ensure that you have an ORCID iD and that it is validated in Editorial Manager. To do this, go to ‘Update my Information’ (in the upper left-hand corner of the main menu), and click on the Fetch/Validate link next to the ORCID field. This will take you to the ORCID site and allow you to create a new iD or authenticate a pre-existing iD in Editorial Manager. 3. If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. Additional Editor Comments: Thank you for submitting your work on this important topic. It requires extensive rewriting in order to be fully evaluated. Please look carefully at Reviewer !'s comments, in particular the suggestion to use the STROBE guidelines and checklists for the presentation of observational and qualitative studies. The most important critique is that the methods are not clearly described, particularly how the analysis of the qualitative interviews was done. Also, kindly present a much clearer definition of 'Monitoring': who does it and how do they measure the results? Please either incorporate the Revewer's comments or respond in a letter. It is not, however, required that the results be 'novel', only that the research be well described and the results support the conclusions. I have provided additional results (see attachment). Many of these are grammatical suggestions or suggested wording changes to increase clarity, and it is not requred to respond to these. However, there are a few more substantive comments or remarks that should be incorporated if possible in your revision. The attached data are helpful, however some tables should be incorporated in the manuscript and even if they remain in the supplement, it is necessary to refer to them in the manuscript, so the reader can understand your process. The first supplementary data are in fact tables, not figures. Likewise, the qualitative data are not shown. Please describe how you have carried out your analysis. The tables are presented by topic, but what is not shown is the interrelationships between these data as they relate to the individual helath centers. So some of the statements in the paper, about how effort relates to defaulter rate, is not supported by the data. Another small example is that you state the male reporteds had secondary education and the females did not, but that can't be discovered from the two separate tables you show. A reader should be able to reproduce your statistical calculations by looking at your data, and that does not seem possible. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author 1. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? Reviewer #1: No ********** 2. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? -->?> Reviewer #1: No ********** 3. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available??> The PLOS Data policy Reviewer #1: No ********** 4. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English??> Reviewer #1: Yes ********** Reviewer #1: Several comments on the abstract: Introduction – include more South Sudan-specific information. Methods and conclusions – the study design cannot establish mechanisms of causality or assess effectiveness, which can only be done in randomized controlled trials. Who are the participants in the study? Vaccinators? How was the primary outcome defined? Stratified based on what? Further define what the exposed and unexposed groups of the cohort study are. Results – no qualitative results were mentioned. Define BHWs. Unclear if dropout rates are measured per facility, per child, or per cohort. Conclusion – The recommendation of scale-up is not supported by the data. Introduction: I recommend that the authors consult the STROBE checklist for cohort studies and include relevant items throughout their paper. Authors should find more updated statistics about childhood immunization. The outdated 2019 statistics in the introduction should be replaced with more recent figures, as we know the COVID-19 pandemic reduced global childhood immunization coverage. Data from 2024 are available, so we would expect recent data to be incorporated in the introduction when referring to coverage and 0-dose children. For example, consider https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/immunization-coverage that incorporates 2024 data. Additionally, authors cite an outdated version of IA2030 (the 2024 version is available). Moreover, 2024 estimates from South Sudan DTP1 coverage are available. Need references for immunization coverage rates. The dropout rate is not defined. The dropout rate should have a clear operational definition that can be applied across settings. Why do the authors switch from talking about immunization coverage to measles antigen performance without talking about measles coverage? It’s unclear exactly what immunization monitoring mechanisms have worked or are being considered in the study. The specifics of what is being monitored, how, by whom, etc., need to be discussed. Also, what is the evidence of immunization monitoring for child vaccines? What has worked, and what are the gaps in evidence? Why have the authors focused on health facility microplanning and defaulter tracing systems? Authors should define what those mean. Immunization dropout is defined as a child receiving at least one vaccine but not receiving subsequent vaccines. What about zero-dose vaccine children, who have never received immunizations? This is a common problem, which has gotten worse during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. How does this article address children who are unimmunized? Authors cannot assess the effectiveness of any intervention with their study design. They are overstating their conclusions. More details about the boma health initiative are warranted, such as who is involved, how it is implemented, and what is assessed. Methods: STROBE checklist 5 not clearly described (description of the setting, location, dates of exposure, dates of follow up and dates of data collection). In addition, since this was also a qualitative study, I would like to see more details from the qualitative study reported based on the COREQ 32-item checklist of interviews and focus groups. How were the 14 health facilities selected? Determining the sample size is not the same as selecting the health facilities. Who are the participants? STROBE checklist 7 and 8 have not been defined – we need to know all the outcomes, exposures, predictors, confounders, effective modifiers, and the sources of data and details of methods of measurement. Show your sample size calculation. What assumptions were made? Typo toasted Since individuals from the same job often have different perspectives, I would have loved to see the authors interview all the vaccinators in the health facilities. More details about the methodology of the qualitative study per the COREQ checklist. needs to be included. For example, items 9 through 23 of the checklist need to be addressed. In addition, how was the semi-structured interview guide developed? What’s not clear is what the authors extracted and input into Excel and SPSS when this is largely a qualitative study. The manuscript appears to conflate qualitative and quantitative analyses without clearly describing the methods used for each. It seems that this is a mixed-methods study, but that is not explicitly stated. The authors should clarify what quantitative analyses were conducted and specify what quantitative data were collected. Author-state bivariable analysis was used to determine relationships, but that is not a statistical test. Was this logistical regression? Please expand on the statistical analysis for the quantitative part. The authors report collecting data on immunization registers, health facilities, microplanning, and monitoring charts. However, the manuscript does not clearly describe how these variables were defined, operationalized, or measured. Given that these are central to the analysis, the authors should provide a detailed explanation of the data sources and collection methods for each variable to ensure clarity and reproducibility. The authors should also specify the statistical measure used in these analyses (e.g., risk ratio or odds ratio), as this is not currently explained. The manuscript does not provide sufficient detail on key data sources and tools. The authors should describe what the immunization registers contain and how information from them was used in the analysis. Similarly, the purpose and content of tickler files, defaulter tracing cards, and monitoring charts are not explained. Providing clear descriptions of these instruments is essential for readers to understand the data collection process and to assess the validity and replicability of the findings. Results The manuscript would benefit from the inclusion of tables or figures to summarize the data. For instance, demographic and facility characteristics could be presented in a descriptive table to enhance clarity. In addition, a table summarizing the quantitative regression analyses is expected. The stated objective of the study is to ascertain the effectiveness of monitoring mechanisms in reducing immunization dropouts across health facilities. However, it is not clear how the presented analysis directly addresses or measures this objective. The association between the use of micro-monitoring tools and the updating of micro-planning documents, while potentially relevant, does not on its own demonstrate an effect on immunization dropout rates. The authors should clarify how this analysis contributes to assessing the effectiveness of monitoring mechanisms in reducing dropouts, and, if applicable, describe the analytical pathway linking these intermediate measures to the primary outcome. The authors appear to include interpretive statements rather than presenting only the findings. For instance, explanations such as “accurate data capturing into the immunization register enhanced the completeness of the data tools” represent interpretation rather than results. Such explanatory or inferential statements would be more appropriately placed in the Discussion section, while the Results should focus on objectively reporting the observed data. Based on the semi-structured interview data, the manuscript would benefit from a table summarizing the main themes accompanied by illustrative quotations to substantiate the findings. Similarly, a table summarizing the key results from the observational data is expected. The inclusion of these tables would enhance transparency, allow readers to assess the depth and credibility of the qualitative analysis, and improve the overall clarity of the results. How did the authors address spillover in the locations between exposed and unexposed groups? The manuscript should provide specific data on the actions taken by health facilities with desirable dropout rates to identify and trace defaulters. The current description of “effort” is vague and not operationally defined or measurable. The authors should clarify what specific activities or strategies were implemented and how these were assessed to allow for meaningful interpretation and comparison across facilities. The authors should define how they measured or categorized “effort.” For example: Low effort: No systematic review or tracing activities. Moderate effort: Passive record review without follow-up. High effort: Active tracing using multiple methods (register review, community outreach, phone calls). Discussion The study's novelty is not clearly established. The finding that monitoring immunization data can support tracking progress and reduce dropout rates is conceptually expected and has been well documented in prior literature. The authors should clarify what new insights their study provides beyond confirming that facilities that use monitoring tools perform better. For example, does the study offer a unique methodological approach, a deeper contextual understanding, or implementation insights that advance current knowledge? Clearly articulating the study’s added value would strengthen its contribution to the field. The study needs to clarify its contribution beyond confirming that monitoring tools are associated with better immunization performance. The authors should explicitly articulate what is novel about their findings (e.g., a new implementation model, context-specific barriers, or unique operational lessons) and align their analytical approach with the stated objective of assessing effectiveness rather than mere association. New findings are being added to the conclusion, including vaccine supply, which has not been mentioned in the discussion. The authors are restating study results rather than interpreting them within a broader conceptual or theoretical context. The authors do not critically examine why or how monitoring mechanisms influenced dropout rates, nor do they acknowledge the methodological limitations of their study. As written, the discussion reads as confirmatory and, at times, overstates the study’s conclusions about effectiveness, which can be measured in an RCT. The authors should strengthen this section by providing a more analytical interpretation of findings, situating them within existing literature on immunization system performance, and explicitly addressing the study’s limitations and implications for policy and practice. Although the authors include brief recommendations directed at policymakers within the conclusion, these points are not clearly separated or developed into a distinct section. The authors should consider presenting a concise “Implications for Policymakers” section that translates their findings into actionable guidance. ********** what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy Reviewer #1: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] To ensure your figures meet our technical requirements, please review our figure guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures You may also use PLOS’s free figure tool, NAAS, to help you prepare publication quality figures: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures#loc-tools-for-figure-preparation. NAAS will assess whether your figures meet our technical requirements by comparing each figure against our figure specifications. Submitted filename: Academic Editor Comments.docx 4 Jun 2026 i have created the ORCID id: 0009-0006-0809-1500 i have also adjusted the manuscript as per the guidelines shared in previous comments for revision Response to Academic Editor Comments Manuscript title: Effectiveness of Monitoring Mechanisms in Reducing Immunization Dropouts Among Infants in Health Facilities of Maridi County, South Sudan Journal: PLOS ONE Manuscript number: PONE-D-25-26100 Authors: Daniel Opinile Mark Igga, Nzomo Mwita, Kennedy Muni Dear Editor, We sincerely thank the Academic Editor for the careful and constructive review of our manuscript. The comments identified genuine weaknesses in clarity, precision, and organization that we believe were important to address. We have revised the manuscript thoroughly in response to every point raised. Below we provide a point-by-point response to each comment. For ease of reference, each editor comment is quoted verbatim (shaded grey), followed by our response and a description of the specific change made in the revised manuscript. Passages added or substantially rewritten in the manuscript are indicated in the third column. We hope the revisions satisfy the editor’s concerns and that the manuscript is now suitable for publication in PLOS ONE. Yours sincerely, Daniel Opinile Mark Igga (on behalf of all authors) Section 1: Abstract Comment 1 — Abstract – Introduction Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "coverage reduced to 84%". At what time point? The editor is correct that the time point was missing, which made the statement imprecise and unverifiable. Global third-dose pentavalent coverage was 86% in 2019, declined to 84% in 2020, and fell further to 82% in 2021 — a three-year trend reported by the Immunization Agenda 2030. Specifying these years is essential for readers to contextualise the data against global benchmarks. Revised abstract (Introduction): "Third-dose pentavalent vaccine coverage stood at 86% globally in 2019, declining to 84% in 2020 and further to 82% in 2021, remaining below the 85% minimum target set by the Immunization Agenda 2030." All three years are now explicit. Comment 2 — Abstract – Introduction Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "Despite the efforts employed to improve the immunization coverage, SUBJECT NEEDED HERE remained below 85%." — A subject is missing from this sentence. We agree. The sentence was grammatically incomplete. The intended subject was "immunization coverage," which had been dropped in editing. The sentence has been rewritten to remove the dangling clause entirely and incorporate the substance into a fuller, subject-complete sentence. Revised abstract (Introduction): The sentence now reads: "...declining to 84% in 2020 and further to 82% in 2021, consistently falling short of the 85% floor target set by the Immunization Agenda 2030." The incomplete clause has been eliminated. Comment 3 — Abstract – Methods/Results Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "BHWs" — make sure the abbreviations are written out first time they are used. We agree. The abbreviation "BHW" appeared in the abstract without prior definition, which is inconsistent with PLOS ONE style and would confuse readers unfamiliar with South Sudan's community health architecture. The term is now spelled out in full on first use in the abstract, with the abbreviation provided in parentheses immediately afterward. Revised abstract (Results): "...Boma Health Workers (BHWs) — community-level health personnel who mobilize, trace, and refer immunization defaulters — were attached to 64% of facilities." Subsequent uses of "BHW/BHWs" throughout the abstract and manuscript are abbreviated. Comment 4 — Abstract – Methods/Results Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change Explain in abstract (briefly) what a Boma Health Worker is, also state how long the study lasted (i.e. over what period of time did changes occur?). Both points are well taken. First, the Boma Health Worker is a programme-specific cadre unique to South Sudan's health system, and readers outside the country would have no frame of reference for the term without a brief explanation. Second, without a time frame readers cannot judge how meaningful or durable the observed dropout reductions are. We have addressed both. Revised abstract (Methods): The study duration is now explicit: "...conducted from 1 October to 31 December 2023." Revised abstract (Results): BHWs are defined inline: "Boma Health Workers (BHWs) — community-level health personnel who mobilize, trace, and refer immunization defaulters..." Comment 5 — Abstract – Conclusions Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change Can you distinguish between the monitoring tools used by internal health workers and the external monitoring and the effect of BHWs? This is an important conceptual distinction that the original abstract conflated. The monitoring chart, immunization register, and defaulter tracing system are facility-based (internal) tools used by vaccinators and health workers to track coverage and identify individual defaulters. BHWs operate at the community (external) level, mobilizing households, tracing missing children, and referring them back to facilities. The abstract conclusions have been rewritten to make this distinction explicit, so readers understand that the two mechanisms are complementary rather than interchangeable. Revised abstract (Conclusions): "Both facility-based tools (monitoring charts, defaulter tracing systems) and community-based mechanisms (BHWs) are independently associated with lower immunization dropout rates, and their combination appears to have a complementary effect." The distinction between internal and external monitoring is now explicit in the conclusions. Section 2: Introduction Comment 6 — Introduction Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "The number of infants vaccinated globally reduced, specifically, uptake of 3rd dose of pentavalent." Statements like this need to have a time frame. The next sentence is not clear. We agree on both counts. The original statement was both imprecise (no year specified) and syntactically awkward ("specifically, uptake of 3rd dose of pentavalent" does not complete a grammatical thought). The subsequent sentence about the Immunization Agenda 2030 target was also unclear in its relationship to the preceding figures. We have completely rewritten this passage with explicit years (2019, 2020, 2021) drawn from the Immunization Agenda 2030 global data, and the relationship between the observed decline and the target threshold is now stated directly. Revised Introduction: "Third-dose pentavalent coverage, a widely used proxy for immunization system performance, stood at 86% globally in 2019 but slipped to 84% in 2020 and 82% in 2021, consistently falling short of the 85% floor target set by the Immunization Agenda 2030." The unclear follow-on sentence has been removed and replaced with a direct statement about what falling short of the target means for program planning. Comment 7 — Introduction Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "The study intends to determine the use of immunization monitoring mechanism as a strategy to improve the county's performance of 3rd dose of pentavalent, according to 2022 data, which is 82% and the quite low measles vaccine coverage at 55% to the minimum target of 85% through the proper use of immunization monitoring mechanisms." This sentence is repetitive about using monitoring mechanisms. We agree that the phrase "immunization monitoring mechanism" appeared twice in the same sentence and the sentence was also structurally unwieldy. The entire passage has been reorganised. The Maridi County coverage figures (82% pentavalent-3 and 55% measles in 2022) now appear in a standalone sentence providing factual context, and the study aim is stated separately and more concisely. Revised Introduction: The county's coverage gap is stated as: "...2022 programme data revealed 82% third-dose pentavalent coverage and 55% measles vaccine coverage in the county — both below the national 85% target." The study purpose is then stated separately without repetition of the phrase "monitoring mechanisms." Comment 8 — Introduction Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change Why "Nevertheless"? It seems like it's all saying the same thing. The editor is right. "Nevertheless" implies a contrast or concession, but the surrounding sentences were building the same argument rather than pivoting to a contrasting point. The word was being used as a filler transition. The paragraph has been restructured so that each sentence advances a distinct idea: (1) the coverage gap in Maridi County, (2) what the target is, (3) why monitoring and community tracing matter, and (4) the study aim. The transitional word "Nevertheless" has been removed entirely. Revised Introduction: The paragraph has been restructured. "Nevertheless" has been deleted, and the sentences that followed it have been reorganised to flow logically without a false contrast marker. Comment 9 — Introduction Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "monthly goals on a timely fashion, provide basis for…" should be "in a timely fashion" and "provides" and "reflecting". We thank the editor for catching these grammatical errors. "On a timely fashion" is incorrect idiom; the correct phrase is "in a timely fashion." The verb "provide" should agree with its singular subject ("this tool") and read "provides." "Reflect" in the participial phrase should read "reflecting" for grammatical parallelism. All three corrections have been made. Revised Introduction: The sentence describing the monitoring chart now reads: "...set and evaluate monthly goals in a timely fashion, provides a basis for comparing performance across time periods...and reflects the situation accurately." All three grammatical corrections are incorporated. Section 3: Materials and Methods Comment 10 — Methods Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "vaccinator was selected based on toasted coin" should be based on a tossed coin or based on a coin toss. This is a clear spell-checker substitution error ("toasted" for "tossed") that we missed in proofreading. We apologize for the oversight. The phrase has been corrected throughout the manuscript. Revised Methods (Sampling): "...one was enrolled in the study by coin toss, yielding 13 participants per stratum (26 total)." All instances of "toasted coin" have been replaced with "coin toss." Comment 11 — Methods Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "had a written informed consent, that" — no comma should be here between subject and verb. Correct. The comma between "consent" and "that" incorrectly separates the noun phrase from its relative clause. The comma has been removed. The sentence has also been further revised for clarity (see Comment 12 below). Revised Methods (Data Collection): The comma has been removed. The sentence now reads: "...a semi-structured interview guide that included a written informed consent section..." Comment 12 — Methods Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "This examined whether the presence of BHWs in health facilities was either attributed to having low dropout rates (less than 10%) or high dropout rates (more than 10%)." Perhaps rather than "attributed to," you meant to say "associated with." The sentence now seems to say that the dropout rate caused the BHW to be in the health facility. This is an important clarification. The original phrasing was causally ambiguous — it could imply that authorities deployed BHWs to facilities because those facilities already had high dropout rates (i.e., dropout rate caused BHW presence), when in fact we were testing the reverse hypothesis (BHW presence influences dropout rate). The correct statistical framing is one of association, not attribution. We have replaced "attributed to" with "associated with" throughout the manuscript and added a brief note in the Discussion clarifying that the study design does not permit causal inference. Revised Methods (Analysis): "Chi-square tests were used to examine whether BHW presence in health facilities was associated with lower dropout rates (below 10%) or higher dropout rates (above 10%)." The word "attributed" has been replaced with "associated" throughout. Comment 13 — Methods Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "The researcher provided written informed consent to the participants." It seems that the researcher OBTAINED written informed consent FROM the participants. What was the original language of the informed consent? Please state whether the IC translation was written (and verified in some way and approved by ethics committee) or by a script that was oral (approved?), or whether it was done each time verbally by the person obtaining informed consent. The editor is entirely correct, and we apologize for the imprecise language. The researcher obtained written informed consent from the participants — not the other way around. Additionally, we recognize that the original manuscript failed to specify the informed consent language protocol, which is an important omission for a study conducted in a multilingual, low-resource setting. To clarify: The informed consent form was prepared in English. Because many participants are more comfortable in local languages, the researcher verbally interpreted the consent form into the participant's preferred language — Juba Arabic, Muru, Azande, Baka, or Avokaya — prior to the participant signing. This verbal translation protocol was reviewed and approved by the AMIU Ethics and Scientific Review Committee and the South Sudan MOH Research Ethics Review Board as part of the study ethics application. Consent was obtained in writing from every participant; the signature confirmed that the verbal explanation had been understood and that the participant agreed voluntarily to take part. Revised Methods (Ethics): "Written informed consent was obtained from every enrolled vaccinator before data collection began. The consent form was prepared in English and verbally interpreted by the researcher into each participant's preferred language (Juba Arabic, Muru, Azande, Baka, or Avokaya) prior to signature. This verbal interpretation protocol was reviewed and approved as part of the study's ethics application to the AMIU ESRC and the South Sudan MOH-RERB." Section 4: Results Comment 14 — Results – Formatting Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "Out of the 14 health facilities, (12, 86%) were supported…" The 12 should be before parentheses. Same for the 2 later on in the sentence, etc. We agree. Placing the count outside the parentheses and the percentage inside is the correct and widely adopted convention in biomedical writing — e.g., "12 (86%)" rather than "(12, 86%)". This formatting error appeared throughout the original Results section. All instances have been corrected. Revised Results: All frequency-percentage pairs are now formatted as "n (%)" throughout — e.g., "12 (86%)," "3 (21%)," "13 (93%)" — consistent with PLOS ONE style. Comment 15 — Results – Demographics Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change "Majority of the male respondents (11, 79%)…" Be clear that you mean by respondent the person responding on behalf of the health facility. We agree that the term "respondent" was ambiguous and could be read as referring to a member of the general public. Since each health facility contributed one vaccinator to the study, the "respondent" is always the vaccinator selected to represent that facility. We have clarified this at first use and maintained the clarification consistently throughout the Results section. Revised Results (Demographics): "...14 respondents (one vaccinator per facility, selected to represent their health facility)." Subsequent mentions describe respondents as "vaccinators" or "health facility representatives" to avoid ambiguity. Comment 16 — Results – Demographics Editor Comment Authors’ Response Manuscript Change The % of males who had secondary education seems to be 100%. The % of all respondents who had secondary education is 79%. Does this mean there were just 3 women responding? Make that respondentS. The editor is corre Submitted filename: Response_to_Editor_Comments.docx 15 Jun 2026 Dear Dr. Igga, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by Jul 30 2026 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. A letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, please include your updated statement in your cover letter. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols. As the corresponding author, your ORCID iD is verified in the submission system and will appear in the published article. PLOS supports the use of ORCID, and we encourage all coauthors to register for an ORCID iD and use it as well. Please encourage your coauthors to verify their ORCID iD within the submission system before final acceptance, as unverified ORCID iDs will not appear in the published article. Only the individual author can complete the verification step; PLOS staff cannot verify ORCID iDs on behalf of authors. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Patricia Evelyn Fast, MD, Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS One Journal Requirements: If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] To ensure your figures meet our technical requirements, please review our figure guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures You may also use PLOS’s free figure tool, NAAS, to help you prepare publication quality figures: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures#loc-tools-for-figure-preparation. NAAS will assess whether your figures meet our technical requirements by comparing each figure against our figure specifications. Submitted filename: Reviewer.docx 29 Jul 2026 Comments addressed in the uploaded file Response to Editor Comments Submitted filename: Response to Editor Comments.docx 3 Aug 2026 EFFECTIVENESS OF MONITORING MECHANISMS IN REDUCING IMMUNIZATION DROPOUTS AMONG INFANTS IN HEALTH FACILITIES OF MARIDI COUNTY, SOUTH SUDAN PONE-D-25-26100R2 Dear Dr. Igga: We’re pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been judged scientifically suitable for publication and will be formally accepted for publication once it meets all outstanding technical requirements. Within one week, you’ll receive an e-mail detailing the required amendments. When these have been addressed, you’ll receive a formal acceptance letter and your manuscript will be scheduled for publication. An invoice will be generated when your article is formally accepted. Please note, if your institution has a publishing partnership with PLOS and your article meets the relevant criteria, all or part of your publication costs will be covered. Please make sure your user information is up-to-date by logging into Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager® and clicking the ‘Update My Information' link at the top of the page. For questions related to billing, please contact billing support. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper to help maximize its impact. If they’ll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team as soon as possible -- no later than 48 hours after receiving the formal acceptance. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. Kind regards, Patricia Evelyn Fast, MD, Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS One Additional Editor Comments (optional): Thank you for your diligence in addressing the reviews. Please note that one issue seems to remain: The following statement seems inconsistent with the data in the table re: educational level. " Ten respondents (71%) had reached secondary level of education and 4 (29%) primary level. Disaggregated by sex, all 11 male respondents had attained secondary-level education, while all 3 female respondents had attained primary-level education only. " Reviewers' comments: Ten respondents (71%) had reached secondary level of education and 4 (29%) primary level. Disaggregated by sex, all 11 male respondents had attained secondary-level education, while all 3 female respondents had attained primary-level education only. PONE-D-25-26100R2 PLOS One Dear Dr. Igga, I'm pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been deemed suitable for publication in PLOS One. Congratulations! Your manuscript is now being handed over to our production team. At this stage, our production department will prepare your paper for publication. This includes ensuring the following: * All references, tables, and figures are properly cited * All relevant supporting information is included in the manuscript submission, * There are no issues that prevent the paper from being properly typeset You will receive further instructions from the production team, including instructions on how to review your proof when it is ready. Please keep in mind that we are working through a large volume of accepted articles, so please give us a few days to review your paper and let you know the next and final steps. Lastly, if your institution or institutions have a press office, please let them know about your upcoming paper now to help maximize its impact. If they'll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team within the next 48 hours. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. You will receive an invoice from PLOS for your publication fee after your manuscript has reached the completed accept phase. If you receive an email requesting payment before acceptance or for any other service, this may be a phishing scheme. Learn how to identify phishing emails and protect your accounts at https://explore.plos.org/phishing. If we can help with anything else, please email us at customercare@plos.org. Thank you for submitting your work to PLOS One and supporting open access. Kind regards, PLOS One Editorial Office Staff on behalf of Dr. Patricia Evelyn Fast Academic Editor PLOS One