Introducing diabetes emotional well-being into routine consultations for adults with type 1 diabetes Authors: Ruth Harris, Sarah Sims, Mette Due-Christensen, Vibeke Stenov, Ruth Abrams, Clara Fabian-Therond, Shalini Ahuja, Siobhan O’Connor, Iliatha Papachristou Nadal, Megan Peck, Jane Speight, Richard I G Holt, Jackie Sturt, D-Stress Study Group Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractAims/hypothesisDiabetes distress affects approximately 40% of adults with type 1 diabetes and is associated with impaired self-care, but is rarely assessed or addressed in routine care. The D-Stress study aims to develop an innovative care pathway to manage diabetes distress. A core component seeks to integrate comprehensive distress assessment with discussion into routine consultations. This rapid realist review examined how, why and in what contexts diabetes distress assessment and discussion might work to assess, manage and reduce diabetes distress among adults with type 1 diabetes.MethodsFollowing guidance for rapid realist reviews, we synthesised evidence from 35 documents identified via expert-led searches and stakeholder consultation. Data were analysed to develop programme theories explaining how the intervention might operate in clinical practice.ResultsEight programme theories were generated. Key mechanisms include: (1) embedding emotional health in routine care; (2) comprehensive assessment and interpretation for timely support; (3) facilitating self-reflection and priority setting; (4) maintaining continuity through regular emotional health discussions; (5) supporting healthcare professionals to personalise consultations; (6) clarifying care pathways and expectations; (7) normalising emotional responses to type 1 diabetes; and (8) promoting person-centred, collaborative consultations. Evidence indicated that validated type 1 diabetes assessments with structured dialogue can normalise emotional responses and promote person-centred care. Critical contextual factors include sufficient consultation time, staff training and clear referral pathways.Conclusions/interpretationComprehensive assessment with discussion may address a gap in diabetes care by integrating emotional health into routine consultations. The programme theories developed here suggest that diabetes distress assessment and discussion may reduce risk of escalation of distress, empower adults with type 1 diabetes and strengthen therapeutic relationships. These findings will guide the realist process evaluation of the D-Stress pathway, highlighting contextual considerations essential for implementation.Graphical abstract Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1007/s44357-026-00010-w.Keywords: Diabetes distress, Realist process evaluation, Realist review, Routine consultation, Type 1 diabetes Introduction Diabetes distress is the emotional burden associated with living with and managing diabetes, including worries, feelings of overwhelm, frustration, isolation and perceived inadequacy in managing diabetes [1]. It is associated with impaired self-care behaviours, sub-optimal glycaemic levels and lower quality of life [2, 3]. Without appropriate assessment and support, diabetes distress can contribute to acute complications (e.g. hypoglycaemia and diabetic ketoacidosis) and long-term complications (e.g. nephropathy) [4, 5]. Diabetes distress is distinct from depression or general psychological distress and is highly prevalent, affecting around 40% of adults with type 1 diabetes [6]. Recent evidence suggests that diabetes distress is even more widespread, with up to 80% of adults with diabetes reporting at least one problem area that could contribute to diabetes distress (e.g. management difficulties, worrying about complications, hypoglycaemia, financial worries and technology challenges) [7]. Despite this high prevalence, diabetes distress is rarely assessed and managed in routine diabetes care [7, 8]. Prolonged distress can lead to diabetes burnout — a state of emotional and physical exhaustion that reduces engagement with diabetes care and self-management [5] and is associated with increased healthcare costs [9, 10]. Reducing diabetes distress improves diabetes self-management, enhances quality of life, increases healthcare engagement and helps to mitigate rising health costs [6, 9]. This significant gap in diabetes care has prompted recent funding calls by the US National Institutes of Health and the UK National Institute for Health and Care Research and Diabetes UK to commission research into diabetes distress. One of these commissioned research projects, the D-Stress study (https://fundingawards.nihr.ac.uk/award/NIHR205441), is developing and integrating an innovative care pathway to manage diabetes distress in adults with type 1 diabetes in the UK National Health Service. Although diabetes distress is also widespread in adults with type 2 diabetes, this 5-year programme of study focuses only on adults with type 1 diabetes, as the contextual factors surrounding the sources and drivers of distress and the prevalence and stability of distress are recognised to be different [6]. The differences in management strategies between the two types of diabetes are also likely to impact the experience of diabetes distress [11]. Furthermore, type 2 diabetes-specific distress is often related to lifestyle changes and stigma surrounding preventability, complex medical intensification (e.g. transitioning to insulin) and health inequalities (e.g. lack of access to diabetes technology) [12, 13]. One component of the D-Stress care pathway, which is called ‘Enhanced Usual Care’ in the D-Stress study, seeks to address this unmet need by detecting, assessing and discussing diabetes distress within routine diabetes clinic appointments. The aim is to reduce the risk of escalation of distress over time among those with sub-threshold levels of diabetes distress on the assessment tool being used and to refer those with higher distress to targeted support. Clinical diabetes guidelines emphasise the critical need to integrate assessment of diabetes distress into care using a validated patient-reported outcome measure (PROM) of diabetes distress [14]. Several diabetes distress assessment tools exist. These were developed and validated for the twin purposes of enhancing clinical care and as a research tool. Their use in research, to evaluate interventions and determine the prevalence of diabetes distress, has been far more widespread than in clinical care. Limited evidence exists for their use as a clinical tool to support emotional-focused discussions on living with diabetes. The T1‑Diabetes Distress Assessment System (T1‑DDAS) [15] was selected for use in the D-Stress study because it is the most recent, validated and type‑1‑specific measure, published in 2024, and designed explicitly to capture both overall intensity and distinct sources of diabetes distress in adults with type 1 diabetes. It includes an 8‑item CORE scale capturing the overall intensity of diabetes‑related distress, along with 10 SOURCE scales assessing specific contributors to distress. The aim of this rapid realist review was to develop programme theories explaining how and why introducing comprehensive assessment and discussion of diabetes distress into routine consultations may help to address the emotional burden of living with type 1 diabetes, reduce risk of escalation and identify when additional support is needed. This type 1 diabetes rapid realist review was conducted as part of the funded D‑Stress programme to inform the timely co-adaptation of the intervention, with its theories intended for testing in a subsequent realist process evaluation. A realist review of diabetes distress assessment and discussion for people living with type 2 diabetes is published in a separate paper in Metabologia [16]. Methods A rapid realist review methodology was selected for several reasons. First, the diabetes distress assessment and discussion intervention is seen as a complex, social intervention that may be delivered differently by different healthcare professionals (HCPs), in different clinic settings and received in varying ways by different people. Second, development of evidence-based context–mechanism–outcome configurations (CMOCs) would contribute a theoretical framework to support a realist process evaluation for a subsequent main trial, which had a fixed time schedule. Evidence-informed guidance for conducting rapid realist reviews was followed [17] and quality and publication standards in realist reviewing were upheld [18, 19]. Definitions of how realist terms were used in this review [20] are provided in Table 1. A flow diagram for the realist review process is provided in Fig. 1. Table 1Definitions of realist terms and how they were used in this rapid realist reviewRealist termDefinitionProgramme theorySpecifies what is supposed to be done in an intervention or provision of service (theory of action) and how and why that is expected to work (theory of change)Wong et al. [20]Context (C)The ‘backdrop’ of programmes and research… broadly understood as any condition that triggers and/or modifies the behaviour of a mechanismJagosh et al. [21]Mechanism (M)…underlying entities, processes or structures which operate in particular contexts to generate outcomes of interest. Astbury et al. [22]Outcome (O)The result of the interaction between a mechanism and its triggering contextGreenhalgh et al. [23]RetroductionRetroduction refers to the identification of hidden causal forces that lie behind identified patterns or changes in those patterns… Retroduction uses both inductive and deductive logic, as well as insights or hunches. It involves thinking through what causal powers might be at work in producing observed patterns or changes in patterns. It is underpinned by a belief that an understanding of causation cannot be achieved using only observable evidence. Retroductive theorising requires that inquirers use their common sense, intelligence, expertise, and informed imagination to build and test theories about underpinning causal processesGreenhalgh et al. [24] Definitions of realist terms and how they were used in this rapid realist review Specifies what is supposed to be done in an intervention or provision of service (theory of action) and how and why that is expected to work (theory of change) Wong et al. [20] The ‘backdrop’ of programmes and research… broadly understood as any condition that triggers and/or modifies the behaviour of a mechanism Jagosh et al. [21] The result of the interaction between a mechanism and its triggering context Greenhalgh et al. [23] Retroduction refers to the identification of hidden causal forces that lie behind identified patterns or changes in those patterns… Retroduction uses both inductive and deductive logic, as well as insights or hunches. It involves thinking through what causal powers might be at work in producing observed patterns or changes in patterns. It is underpinned by a belief that an understanding of causation cannot be achieved using only observable evidence. Retroductive theorising requires that inquirers use their common sense, intelligence, expertise, and informed imagination to build and test theories about underpinning causal processes Greenhalgh et al. [24] Flowchart of the rapid realist review process The scope of the review focused only on literature related to: (1) adults with type 1 diabetes; and (2) specific interventions under investigation in the D-Stress study, alongside the key psychosocial theories underpinning them. Thus, the research question identified for the review was: what aspects of comprehensive assessment of diabetes distress and discussion of emotional well-being in routine clinic consultations work, for whom, in what circumstances and why? The review was undertaken using a three-stage literature searching process, incorporating stakeholder consultation throughout. Stakeholders included programme architects, adults with type 1 diabetes, diabetes practitioners and methodological experts. As an evidence review of secondary sources we did not consider sex and gender in the review design. Stage 1: literature relating directly to diabetes distress assessment and discussion interventions An exhaustive search was not undertaken in order to streamline and accelerate the search process, as per rapid realist review guidelines [17]. Instead, all study investigators, the majority of whom have expertise in diabetes distress, were asked to identify relevant articles and documents that they thought should be included in the review. Inclusion criteria were that papers must discuss type 1 diabetes, be relevant to assessing or addressing diabetes distress in routine management or highlight evidence of any associated context, outcome or mechanism. Any type of published or unpublished document was potentially applicable, including empirical research studies, literature reviews and grey literature, such as best practice guidance, presentations and discussion pieces. Conventional quality appraisal methods were not applied, but instead, each study was assessed for its ‘fitness for purpose’ by examining its relevance and rigour [25]. In keeping with realist approaches, the focus was not on study design, but on whether the study offered credible, trustworthy insights that contributed to theory development [20, 26]. The lead reviewer (RH) read all papers and other members of the team divided the papers between them as second reviewers, so that every paper was read and discussed by two researchers. A bespoke data extraction sheet was created, and this was completed by every researcher for each paper read. Salient details about each paper were recorded on the data extraction sheet to identify elements that could help to answer the research question. For excluded papers, reasons for exclusion were also recorded. Researchers met to discuss inclusion and exclusion to ensure that agreement was reached. The researchers independently compiled a list of initial programme theories based on the papers they had read to produce eight overarching programme theories and their associated CMOCs. CMOCs can be described as specific and individual causal explanations of how an intervention produces outcomes in practice (Table 1). On the advice of a member of the review advisory group, these CMOCs were re-worded as ‘if–then-because’ statements, to allow for testable theory building. An if–then-because statement is a structured way of expressing a proposed causal explanation in realist research, which defines the ‘if’ as the relevant context or condition, the ‘then’ as the expected outcome and the ‘because’ as the underlying mechanism that explains why the outcome is likely to occur in that context. These configurations were rarely made explicit in the papers, limiting their applicability. Furthermore, most papers did not examine a specific intervention. Therefore, retroductive analysis and reasoning were used to interpret how outcomes may have been generated by mechanisms in particular contexts. Nineteen ‘if–then-because’ statements were identified from the eight theories (Table 2). Table 2Preliminary CMOCs for the D-Stress diabetes distress assessment and discussion interventionCMOC numberCMOC description1If the use of comprehensive diabetes distress assessment and conversation within a clinic indicates that HCPs are expected to review diabetes distress self-assessment scores and ask about emotional health, then the HCP will review the assessment score and ask every person with type 1 diabetes about their emotional health during their consultation time because it raises awareness that assessing and managing emotional issues is an expected part of the HCP role in diabetes care2If a validated self-assessment tool is used to assess diabetes distress prior to the consultation, then the HCP can ask the person with type 1 diabetes questions about emotional aspects of diabetes and explore reasons for their distress, because they are aware of the person with type 1 diabetes’ level of diabetes distress and the scores for specific sources of distress3If the person with type 1 diabetes undertakes the diabetes distress assessment before their clinic appointment, then they are more prepared to talk about their feelings, emotions and concerns about having diabetes in the consultation, which focuses the discussion on actual patient need because the person with type 1 diabetes has had the opportunity to think about how they are feeling before their appointment and is expecting to discuss this with the HCP during the appointment4If the person with type 1 diabetes is not aware that diabetes distress is a normal response to having type 1 diabetes and they complete the diabetes distress assessment then they are more likely to come to their consultation prepared to talk how their feelings about diabetes are influencing aspects of their life and how they manage their condition because diabetes distress assessment prompts them to consider and helps them make sense of how they are feeling about living with type 1 diabetes5If the clinic appointment is restricted to a short time and discussion of physical health checks is considered more important or the clinic is running late, then the HCP may not ask the person with type 1 diabetes questions about their emotional health because they may think that these discussions are not a priority or that there is not enough time, as they think these conversations can take longer6If regular, comprehensive assessment is carried out for all people with type 1 diabetes using a validated self-assessment tool, then low, moderate and high levels of diabetes distress will be identified and addressed either through support from the diabetes team or through referral for additional support, because use of a validated tool for assessment of diabetes distress will give both the person with type 1 diabetes and the HCPs information about the person with type 1 diabetes’ level and source of distress so that they can take action to address it7If a HCP receives education in how to use, interpret and discuss a diabetes distress score with a person with type 1 diabetes, as well as training in processes for subsequent action, then accurate assessment of diabetes distress and suitable actions based on this score will be implemented and the person with type 1 diabetes’ informed preferences will be considered, because the HCP will be knowledgeable about diabetes distress and confident to support person with type 1 diabetes to talk about diabetes distress and participate in the consultation8If a diabetes service has clear referral pathways and timely availability of specialist services, then HCPs will feel more confident about having conversations about diabetes distress, because they trust that appropriate help is available and feel confident that they can refer individuals who show high levels of diabetes distress to suitable specialist services9If a person with type 1 diabetes finds it difficult to reflect on their emotional health and raise these feelings in a consultation, then diabetes distress assessment can help them to prepare for the consultation, decide what they want to discuss in the consultation and feel empowered to talk about what is important to them, because the comprehensive focus on diabetes distress encourages the person with type 1 diabetes to recognise how they are feeling and understand how this may affect their day-to-day life10If clinic appointments are time restricted and a short version of a diabetes distress assessment can be used, then it is more likely that a person with type 1 diabetes will have a diabetes distress assessment, although this may not be as accurate as a long version of the assessment, because there can be variation between individual subscales of diabetes distress11If emotional well-being is discussed and followed up at each appointment, then the person with type 1 diabetes is more likely to feel comfortable talking about diabetes distress, because talking about diabetes distress becomes normalised as part of a diabetes consultation12If the HCP has received training, and the clinic record keeping enables availability of accurate content of previous consultations and diabetes distress assessment scores, then the HCP can be open, kind and positive and support the person with type 1 diabetes to feel comfortable talking about emotional and psychosocial issues, because the HCP feels prepared and confident to talk about the issues raised by the person with type 1 diabetes and is aware of their previous diabetes distress assessments13If the person with type 1 diabetes sees a different member of the diabetes team at each appointment, then diabetes distress assessment and discussion ensures that a conversation about diabetes distress is part of the appointment, irrespective of who they see, and ongoing issues are followed up because the regularity of the discussion at each appointment, structured by diabetes distress assessment, promotes continuity of care14If HCP members of the diabetes team do not have a psychology background then diabetes distress assessment and discussion intervention supports them to facilitate and tailor the conversation about emotional issues and well-being to better meet the needs of the person with type 1 diabetes and conveys that the HCP cares about how the person with type 1 diabetes is feeling; the diabetes distress assessment and discussion supports the HCP to feel more prepared and confident to have the conversation, because diabetes distress assessment provides a structured guide for HCPs to start an open conversation15If a person with type 1 diabetes is unclear about what to expect in their diabetes care, then comprehensive diabetes distress assessment and conversation can help them to manage the emotional and social challenges and be reassured that there is a plan for their care, because diabetes distress assessment and discussion provides a clear pathway of what to expect, which helps them to anticipate the emotional and social responses to life with the condition16If a person with type 1 diabetes has feelings of shame, stigma and powerlessness (i.e. feeling unable to cope) associated with diabetes and diabetes distress assessment and discussion routinely flags up the importance of emotional health for people with type 1 diabetes and acknowledges that a diagnosis of type 1 diabetes has a significant psychological impact that makes it more difficult to self-manage, then the person with type 1 diabetes feels more able and comfortable discussing their emotional health during a consultation, because their feelings are normalised as part of their experience and the person with type 1 diabetes feels understood, listened to and ‘seen.’17If HCPs use the comprehensive assessment of diabetes distress to guide the conversation using more open questions then the person with type 1 diabetes will feel able to direct the content of the discussion to issues that are important to them, because the person with type 1 diabetes feels empowered to direct the conversation on a more equal, person-centred basis18If the HCP feels appropriately skilled to actively listen, then the consultation becomes more person-centred with increased satisfaction for both the person with type 1 diabetes and the HCP, because the person with type 1 diabetes feels more autonomy and responsibility in the discussion to talk about what matters to them19If the HCP is worried about not having enough time to spend with the person with type 1 diabetes because consultation time is short or the clinic is running behind time, then they may not enable the person with type 1 diabetes to say everything they want to talk about, because the HCP is distracted, may not be actively listening or may be reluctant to have conversations that may take longer that the time available or that may be left incomplete or unresolved Preliminary CMOCs for the D-Stress diabetes distress assessment and discussion intervention The team met regularly throughout this process to explore the theories and statements, and all queries were discussed until agreement was reached. Engaging key stakeholders during the process helped us to validate the findings and identify any gaps in the literature. Realist approaches recommend this step, as understanding stakeholders’ insights about the intervention and its intended purpose is vital for explaining how it might work [27]. To operationalise this, we presented stakeholders with the emerging theories and their supporting statements and asked them to reflect on how well they resonated with their own experiences of delivering, receiving or designing the intervention (i.e. whether they felt plausible and whether any mechanisms or contextual factors were missing). Stakeholders were also invited to comment on the clarity of the theory descriptions and identify any requiring refinement. The overall feedback from stakeholders was that the eight theories and 19 if–then-because statements accurately captured the generative mechanisms of the intervention. Some small changes were made to clarify the theory descriptions, but no new theories were identified. Stage 2: literature relating to the psychological and social theories underpinning diabetes distress assessment and discussion We aimed to identify whether there were any randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of diabetes distress-related interventions for people with type 1 diabetes based on the same psychological and social theories underpinning diabetes distress assessment and discussion, self-determination theory and the biopsychosocial model. We accessed a Covidence database developed for a systematic review [28] underpinning the EASD Diabetes Distress Clinical Guidelines to identify any similar type 1 diabetes distress interventions also underpinned by these psychological and social theories. Stage 3: realist reviews exploring interventions outside of diabetes distress based on self-determination theory and the biopsychosocial model A third and final stage of searching was undertaken to identify any realist reviews or realist evaluations exploring interventions outside of diabetes distress based on self-determination theory and the biopsychosocial model. This approach of looking outside of the scope of the intervention under study is well supported in realist approaches and helps to avoid narrow interpretations [27, 29]. Expert advice was sought from library and information sciences specialists around generating relevant search terms and four electronic databases were searched on 24 February 2025 using the strategies highlighted in Electronic Supplementary Material (ESM) Box 1. This search also included terms to identify psychological theories underpinning interventions relevant to other aspects of the D-Stress study. Salient details about each included paper identified in stages 2 and 3 were recorded on the data extraction sheet and initial theories and statements in these papers were explored as in stage 1. Although some supporting evidence for the initial theories identified in stage 1 were found in stage 3, no new theories or statements were identified. All the included papers were re-read to explore whether any specific if–then-because statements could be identified within each theory. These statements were again circulated among the study stakeholders and modifications were made, where required. These statements helped to articulate tentative casual pathways to be refined in the subsequent realist process evaluation. Results A total of 35 papers were included across all three search stages. At stage 1, 48 papers were identified: 34 were included [1, 4, 7, 30–60] and 14 were excluded for not being relevant [8, 61–73]. In stage 2, 39 papers were screened but none provided relevant evidence. In stage 3, 77 papers were identified and 61 were excluded at title and abstract screening for not being a realist review, evaluation or synthesis; 16 full-text papers were assessed, one of which was included [74] and 15 of which were excluded for not including comparable interventions to diabetes distress assessment and discussion. A brief description of each paper is provided in ESM Table 1, and these comprised: published research articles (n = 23); an unpublished working research article (n = 1); assessment scales (n = 5); PowerPoint presentations (n = 2); reviews (n = 2); and discussion pieces or guidelines (n = 2). The papers referred to work undertaken primarily in Denmark (n = 10), followed by the UK (n = 9), the USA (n = 7) and Australia (n = 5). The papers were published between 2009 and 2026. The eight programme theories are presented below and the 19 if–then-because statements summarised in Table 2. These provide insights into how comprehensive assessment and discussion of diabetes distress into routine care appointments might be expected to work and why. Programme theory 1: embedding emotional health in routine care Seventeen papers addressed the programme theory that diabetes distress assessment and discussion raises the expectation that routine diabetes care will address emotional health [7, 30, 38, 39, 41–46, 51, 52, 54, 55, 58, 60, 74]. Many diabetes clinics are very busy, and time constraints of consultations means that there is a tendency for issues about blood glucose management and physical checks (e.g. blood pressure, foot pulse) to take priority. Furthermore, HCPs often consider diabetes distress to be a mental health condition that should be managed outside regular diabetes care by specialist mental health practitioners. This programme theory focuses on the idea that the comprehensive assessment and discussion of diabetes distress within routine care demonstrates to staff and the person with type 1 diabetes that addressing emotional health is an important part of usual, holistic care that should occur at every consultation. This expectation gives HCPs the confidence to address these issues and validates the belief that HCPs are often best placed to provide support for diabetes distress. Assessment and discussion of diabetes distress within routine care increases the expectation to talk about emotional responses and mental health and normalises its importance for both people with diabetes and HCPs. Having sufficient time to discuss feelings and assess distress is important and may result in improved consultation experiences for people with type 1 diabetes. Where healthcare organisations and diabetes services support or require comprehensive assessment and discussion of diabetes distress, this consolidates the expectation that addressing emotional health and well-being is part of routine diabetes care. Programme theory 2: comprehensive assessment and interpretation for timely support Fourteen papers and five assessment scales addressed this programme theory [7, 30, 31, 38, 39, 42, 43, 46, 48, 50, 52–58, 60, 74]. Regular (often annual) assessment of diabetes distress using a validated self-assessment tool (e.g. T1-DDAS scale) provides a comprehensive assessment of overall diabetes distress to indicate when a person with type 1 diabetes requires support from the diabetes team or specialist emotional and mental health support. This is combined with a clinical review of the total and sub-scale (source) scores to interpret their meaning and how they compare with previous distress scores. This helps the diabetes team to give the right level of support, from discussing management strategies for low levels of distress to further assessment or ongoing follow-up, or specialist referral for moderate-to-high levels of distress. Subscales of diabetes distress scores provide a detailed understanding of how distress is experienced to enable more targeted advice and intervention. Regular assessment of diabetes distress for all clinic attendees enables consistency to ensure that everyone who has distress is identified, thus enabling timely support to reduce distress and ensure no-one is missed. Having a clear and agreed upon process for each team member’s role in assessing distress supports consistency in capturing all people with type 1 diabetes with high distress and provides a comprehensive and complete referral for specialist help. Adequate recording of diabetes distress scores (e.g. electronic record) ensures that assessment history is captured and that no elevated score is overlooked. Timely intervention for elevated distress requires having clear referral pathways and available specialist services to which clinicians can refer. Education and training to increase HCP knowledge of the use and interpretation of distress scores, discussion with the person with type 1 diabetes and processes for subsequent action support the implementation of agreed processes. Training may need to be repeated to support new practices to become embedded into and sustained within usual practice. Programme theory 3: facilitating self-reflection and priority setting Seventeen papers addressed the programme theory that comprehensive assessment and discussion enables people with type 1 diabetes to recognise how they are feeling and to identify what they want to talk about during their clinic consultation, highlighting the importance of their self-awareness in addressing diabetes distress [1, 4, 30, 34–38, 45, 51–55, 58–60]. Some people with type 1 diabetes find it difficult to reflect on their emotional health and well-being or to raise how they are feeling in a diabetes clinic consultation. Comprehensive assessment of diabetes distress encourages people with type 1 diabetes to self-reflect and recognise how they are feeling, recognise the range of feelings they are experiencing and acknowledge the impact that diabetes has on their emotional well-being and day-to-day life. By recognising the connection between biopsychosocial aspects of diabetes, the person with type 1 diabetes can become more aware of how thoughts, feelings and behaviours affect self-management and understand their feelings and reactions, which may help them to be better prepared for future experiences and issues. This self-reflection can help people with type 1 diabetes to explore their own values, support them to make decisions related to self-management and improve their communication with HCPs. Completing a validated diabetes distress assessment tool before a clinic appointment can help people with type 1 diabetes to prepare for the appointment and decide what they want to discuss with the HCP. This preparation may increase patients’ confidence and help them to feel empowered to raise their priorities for discussion, encouraging feelings of self-compassion about when self-management routines do not appear to work and enabling patients to make changes to how they self-manage their condition. This priority setting supports the content of the consultation to be more person-centred. Assessment scores can act as a starting point to open clinical conversation to address often hidden or less talked about micro-dynamics that contribute to diabetes distress, supporting recognition and articulation of feelings of isolation, exclusion, loneliness and shame to enable these to be shared and addressed. Sufficient time in a consultation and the knowledge, skills and confidence of the HCP are important contexts. Programme theory 4: maintaining continuity through regular emotional health discussions Eleven papers provided evidence of how regular discussion of diabetes distress in routine consultations can enable continuity of care [30, 34, 35, 38, 40, 45, 51, 54, 58, 60, 74]. Regular discussion of the emotional response and experience of having type 1 diabetes legitimises diabetes distress as an important issue that influences how people live with diabetes. This regularity of discussion, structured by an intervention and informed by a structured diabetes distress PROM, supports continuity of care. The person with type 1 diabetes feels that conversations are part of a process irrespective of who they see in the consultation. This also means that they do not have to start from scratch at each appointment and that ongoing issues will be followed up. This continuity enables a safe and trusting interaction and relationship between the HCP and people with type 1 diabetes, which is important, so the person with type 1 diabetes feels comfortable talking about diabetes distress. HCPs feeling prepared and confident to talk about emotional and psychosocial issues is an important context to enable them to be open, kind and positive. This is helpful for clinic services with a high turnover of staff and resulting low continuity of consulting staff. Good record keeping of the matters discussed in a consultation (e.g. electronic record) is important so that HCPs are aware of what was discussed previously and can follow up on issues, reinforcing continuity of care. Programme theory 5: supporting HCPs to personalise consultations Seventeen papers highlighted how comprehensive diabetes distress assessment and discussion guides can support HCPs to tailor the clinic conversation to the person with type 1 diabetes’ own issues and needs [7, 30, 33, 35, 37, 38, 42, 45–47, 51–54, 58, 60, 74]. Providing a structured guide gives HCPs a conversation starter for an open conversation about emotional well-being during a clinical consultation so that they are able to give the person with type 1 diabetes the opportunity to express and process the biomedical, emotional, psychological and social aspects of diabetes that are relevant to them. Receiving diabetes distress scores before seeing the person with type 1 diabetes in the clinic can increase the HCP’s understanding of their emotional status and awareness of their priorities to be covered in the appointment. This leads to a consultation that is tailored to the person with type 1 diabetes and that better meets their needs, which can result in increased satisfaction. HCPs conveying the message that they care about how the person is feeling (not only about their physiological test results) strengthens the relationship, rapport and trust between HCPs and the person with type 1 diabetes. This pathway supports HCPs without a psychology background to facilitate a conversation about emotional and psychological issues and adapt to patient needs related to their everyday life, enhancing the therapeutic interaction between the person with type 1 diabetes and the HCP and further supporting a more open dialogue. Programme theory 6: clarifying care pathways and expectations Five papers addressed how diabetes distress assessment and discussion can signpost and clarify what can be expected from diabetes care [34–37, 60]. These studies provide evidence from the development of consultation tools for use in people with type 1 diabetes during the first year following diagnosis. These tools provide a clear pathway for what a person with type 1 diabetes can expect, helping them to anticipate emotional and social responses to life with diabetes and to be reassured that there is a plan for their care. If HCPs are trained in delivering structured guidance and people with type 1 diabetes receive consistent follow-up, then this guidance and signposting can help them to manage the emotional and social challenges more effectively. Programme theory 7: normalising emotional responses to type 1 diabetes Fifteen papers addressed how the use of a diabetes distress assessment with conversation in the clinic recognises that there is an emotional toll to living with diabetes that is experienced by many [1, 30, 32, 34, 35, 37, 38, 45, 49, 52–55, 58, 60]. This acknowledgement that living with type 1 diabetes has a significant psychological impact, which in turn influences self-management of all aspects of diabetes, helps to legitimise the importance of diabetes distress and emotional support as a routine part of care and follow-up. Routinely flagging the importance of emotional health in type 1 diabetes care encourages the person with type 1 diabetes to feel that it is normal to feel the way they do and appropriate to seek help when they need to. Normalising thoughts and feelings helps to reframe challenges and focus on solutions to adapting to life with diabetes. HCPs being open to talk about diabetes distress helps to share the burdensome nature of living with and managing diabetes, which is a key facilitator to allow people with type 1 diabetes to feel more supported in discussing concerns and may also ameliorate any guilt, shame and negativity about difficulty in self-management. This also helps HCPs to provide guidance, support and appropriate referral where needed. Programme theory 8: promoting person-centred, collaborative consultations Nine papers addressed how comprehensive assessment-directed conversation can promote person-centred care [30, 34, 35, 38, 44, 46, 51, 52, 54]. Typically, there is a hierarchical model of interaction between people with type 1 diabetes and HCPs during a clinic consultation, with HCPs tending to spend a large amount of time talking and providing people with type 1 diabetes with information and guidance. Diabetes distress assessment and discussion require a more balanced conversation, in which HCPs spend less time delivering information and problem solving and more time actively listening and exploring people with type 1 diabetes’ experiences to enable person-centred care. In these interactions, HCPs use open-ended questions and pay more attention to their body language, such as ensuring that they face the person with type 1 diabetes directly and turn away from computer screens. Common concerns are that HCPs may not feel appropriately skilled to undertake such discussions or may worry about the limited time available to spend with people with type 1 diabetes and the fear that addressing such concerns will increase visit time. However, many HCPs find these types of discussion more satisfying in relation to delivering person-centred, personalised care. Discussion This rapid realist review developed programme theories explaining how and why introducing comprehensive assessment and discussion of diabetes distress into routine consultations may help to address the emotional burden of living with diabetes, reduce risk of escalation and identify when additional support is needed. Evidence about assessment and psychosocial support interventions and their role in supporting emotional well-being in routine consultations was synthesised to identify the mechanisms through which comprehensive assessment and discussion may influence diabetes care outcomes. Although each theory is distinct, there was some overlap and interaction between them [23, 75]. This is common for complex interventions, which rarely work in a linear way. Several programme theories were supported, although the strength of evidence varied. In line with realist principles, the strength of evidence did not refer to a quantitative rating but the extent to which empirical findings from diverse study types consistently supported, refined or challenged a given programme theory. Evidence was judged as stronger where multiple, methodologically varied studies offered coherent support for the same causal explanation, and weaker where evidence was sparse or insufficiently detailed to illuminate theory. Stronger evidence related to the value of regular, comprehensive distress assessment as a resource for both HCPs and people with diabetes informing person-centred conversations and guiding advice and support. There was also substantial evidence that diabetes distress assessment and discussion can normalise diabetes distress, reassuring people with diabetes that emotional challenges are a legitimate and expected part of routine care. The findings emphasise the importance of sufficient consultation time and of HCPs being skilled and confident in asking about emotional well-being and responding supportively. Some theories, such as the role of signposting and clarifying expectations of diabetes care were supported by less evidence. However, this does not necessarily indicate that these mechanisms have a reduced impact on addressing diabetes distress but that existing studies have not examined them in sufficient depth. A notable finding of this review was that the stage 2 search, which focused on identifying evidence from RCTs, yielded no eligible papers. This suggests that theory‑driven trials examining emotional well-being assessment in diabetes care are rare, and that mechanisms are often implied rather than explicitly articulated or tested, highlighting the need for research that makes causal processes explicit and that empirically examines how and why distress assessment influences outcomes. This absence strengthened the rationale for adopting a realist approach, as retroductive reasoning was required to develop and refine programme theories in an area in which mechanisms were under‑specified. Future work, including the D‑Stress feasibility study, will be essential in addressing this gap by testing these programme theories in clinical practice and identifying which mechanisms operate, for whom and in what contexts. It is possible that some theories will not be supported in clinical practice or that alternate theories will emerge. This consideration of context and local implementation factors, which may include equity, diversity and inclusion as well as limited economic resources, is imperative to understand how to integrate diabetes distress assessment across clinical services. Interventions for adults with moderate-to-high diabetes distress often identify emotional regulation as a key pathway for reducing distress [76]. From an emotion-regulation framework, distress develops when the emotional demands of diabetes exceed a person’s capacity to identify, interpret, organise and adjust their diabetes-related emotions effectively. Burnout may therefore stem less from the demands of diabetes per se and more from how individuals respond to them [4, 77]. The if–then-because statements identified in this review consistently highlight emotional expression as a desirable outcome of care. Although comprehensive diabetes distress assessment alone may not significantly improve emotional regulation, it may serve as a catalyst by normalising emotional responses, prompting acknowledgement and disclosure and encouraging supported exploration. Assessment and discussion may therefore be necessary, although not sufficient, steps towards reducing diabetes distress by encouraging emotional disclosure enabled through person-centred questions and active listening. A future realist process evaluation will explore whether diabetes distress assessment and discussion improve emotional regulation skills and reduce the risk of escalation of diabetes distress. Strengths and limitations An important strength of this review is the realist approach, which enabled the generation of causal explanations for how comprehensive assessment with discussion may work. Few included studies evaluated specific interventions or articulated causal pathways, so theories were generated through retroductive theorising and iteratively synthesising evidence and insights. These programme theories will be refined in a realist process evaluation of the D-Stress care pathway alongside a feasibility study and main trial, supported by ongoing stakeholder consultation. As per rapid realist review guidance, the search was not exhaustive; instead, expert input guided identification of key literature. Some relevant evidence may therefore have been missed. All included papers were from high-income countries, such as the UK, Australia and Denmark, limiting generalisability. Evidence about diabetes distress among minoritised and global populations is scarce, emphasising the need to test these theories in more diverse populations. Conclusions This realist review provides detailed theories of how diabetes distress assessment and discussion may work in clinic consultations, although these require testing in practice. Variation is likely, given diversity among individuals and clinical settings. Understanding this complexity will strengthen our understanding of its effectiveness and how individual needs, experiences and contextual factors shape outcomes [78]. Future research should examine how contexts, mechanisms and outcomes interact in real-world settings and assess both the short- and long-term effectiveness and sustainability of comprehensive assessment of diabetes distress and discussion of emotional well-being in routine care. Supplementary Information Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material. Supplementary file1 (PDF 237 KB) Acknowledgements We would like to thank all stakeholders in the ‘Optimising the Delivery of Diabetes Distress-Informed Care for its Prevention, Detection and Management in Adults with Type 1 Diabetes: A Hybrid Effectiveness-Implementation Programme (D-Stress)’ study, including all of the PPI group, co-adaption group, clinicians and Expert Reference Group. Members of the D-Stress study group included Jennifer Mohammadi (Florence Nightingale Faculty of Nursing, Midwifery and Palliative Care, King’s College London, London, UK); Joerg Huber (School of Education, Sport and Health, University of Brighton, Brighton, UK); Gary Hickey (Faculty of Medicine, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK); Kate Hardenberg (Diabetes & Endocrinology, Royal United Hospitals Bath NHS Foundation Trust, Bath, UK); Francesca Fiorentino (Clinical Trials Research, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK); Lawrence Fisher (Family & Community Medicine, University of California, San Francisco (UCSF), San Francisco, CA, USA); Jennifer Halliday (School of Psychology, Institute for Health Transformation, Deakin University, Geelong, Victoria, Australia); and Ramzi Ajjan (Clinical and Population Science, Leeds Institute of Cardiovascular and Metabolic Medicine, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK). Abbreviations Context–mechanism–outcome configuration Healthcare professional Patient-reported outcome measure Randomised controlled trial Author contributions RH, SS, MD-C, VS, SA, RIGH and JS contributed to the conception and design of the review. RH undertook the analysis, interpretation of data and drafted the article. SS, MD-C, VS, RA, CF-T and SO’C contributed to the analysis and interpretation of data. All authors critically reviewed the manuscript and approved the final version. Ruth Harris is the guarantor of this work. Funding This project was funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Programme Grants for Applied Research (PGfAR) and Diabetes UK (NIHR205441). The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NIHR, Diabetes UK or the Department of Health and Social Care. SO'C is supported through an NIHR Development and Skills Enhancement Award (NIHR305124). Data availability All data and materials referenced in this manuscript are derived from previously published studies that are publicly available through the original sources. Code availability All analyses were qualitative and based on previously published literature. Declarations Conflict of interest Richard IG Holt has received honoraria for speaker engagements from Boehringer-Ingelheim, Eli Lilly, Encore, Liberum, Novo Nordisk and ROVI Pharma. Competing interests RIGH and JSp are the co-chairs, and JSt is a panel member, of the 2026 EASD evidence-based clinical practice guideline for assessing and managing diabetes distress among adults with type 1 diabetes and type 2 diabetes. The authors declare that there are no other relationships or activities that might bias, or be perceived to bias, their work. Footnotes Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Contributor Information Ruth Harris, Email: ruth.harris@kcl.ac.uk. D-Stress Study Group: Jennifer Mohammadi, Joerg Huber, Gary Hickey, Kate Hardenberg, Francesca Fiorentino, Lawrence Fisher, Jennifer Halliday, and Ramzi Ajjan References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary file1 (PDF 237 KB) Data Availability Statement All data and materials referenced in this manuscript are derived from previously published studies that are publicly available through the original sources. All analyses were qualitative and based on previously published literature.