Waste-to-Biofuel Conversion: Hydrodeoxygenation of Frying Oil over NiMoS2/Al2O3 for the Production of Renewable Hydrocarbons Authors: Luanne Ester Monteiro Ferreira, Vinicius Rossa, Sancler Vasconcelos, Carolina Vieira Viêgas, Gisel Chenard Díaz, Winny Rego Cardoso, Thiago de Melo Lima, Yordanka Reyes Cruz, Donato Alexandre Gomes Aranda Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Renewable hydrocarbons were produced from soybean oil (SO) and frying oil (FO) through hydrotreatment over a commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. The effects of temperature (350, 360, and 370 °C), hydrogen pressure (50, 60, and 70 bar), and stirring speed (500, 650, and 800 rpm) were investigated through a 23 factorial design in a batch reactor operated for 5 h with 3 wt % catalyst loading. High catalytic activity was observed for both feedstocks, with XTG (triacylglyceride conversions) above 98% under most experimental conditions. The optimum condition (370 °C, 70 bar, and 800 rpm) resulted in hydrocarbon selectivity (SHC) above 97% and selectivity toward the green diesel range (C16–C22 n-paraffins) (SGD) reached 95.12%. Statistical analysis identified temperature as the most significant influential variable, followed by hydrogen pressure, whereas stirring speed showed no significant effect. The fitted models exhibited high predictive capability (R2 > 0.96). Catalyst reuse tests maintained conversions above 93%, although a gradual loss of activity possibly associated with coke formation was observed. The results demonstrate that commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalysts are effective for converting both refined and residual oils into SGD, highlighting the potential of frying oil as a low-cost feedstock for sustainable fuel production. Introduction The significant increase in global energy consumption and the intensive use of fossil fuels have intensified worldwide environmental concerns, particularly because of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, which contribute to global warming and accelerate climate change. In this context, the production of renewable fuels emerges as a promising alternative, especially when they are of the drop-in type, that is, chemically similar to fossil fuels, ensuring compatibility with existing infrastructure and engines. − Hydrotreatment of lipid feedstocks produces oxygen-free paraffinic renewable hydrocarbons, predominantly composed of n-paraffins in the diesel boiling range. When appropriate fuel properties are achieved, these hydrocarbons may be referred to as green diesel and can potentially be used as drop-in fuels. , To obtain a drop-in product, hydrotreating (HDT) processesincluding hydrodeoxygenation (HDO), hydrocracking, and hydrodesulfurization (HDS)are employed, many of which are adapted from well-established refinery technologies. , An important advantage is cost reduction, as existing units can process oils and fats with little or no modification. Oils and fats are mainly composed of triacylglycerides, which are molecules with a high oxygen content. During hydrotreating, these molecules are subjected to high temperatures and H2 pressure in the presence of metallic catalysts, which promotes deoxygenation reactions. , Initially, triacylglycerides are cleaved into free fatty acids (R–COOH) and glycerol via hydrogenolysis or hydrogen-assisted hydrolysis. Subsequently, the fatty acids undergo deoxygenation reactions, yielding linear hydrocarbons within the diesel boiling range through pathways such as decarbonylation, decarboxylation, and hydrodeoxygenation (Scheme (a)). In parallel, glycerol is hydrogenated and deoxygenated, resulting primarily in propane (Scheme (b)). ,,− Reaction Pathways for the Hydroprocessing of Triglycerides to Renewable Hydrocarbons in the Diesel Boiling Range: (a) Fatty Acids Undergo Deoxygenation via Decarboxylation, Decarbonylation, and HDO to Form n-paraffins, While (b) Glycerol Is Converted into Propane aR represents alkyl chains derived from fatty acids. R represents alkyl chains derived from fatty acids. In the direct decarboxylation and decarbonylation reactions (I and II), the carboxyl group is removed from the fatty acid, producing paraffinic hydrocarbons with one fewer carbon atom and releasing oxygen in the form of CO2, CO, and H2O, respectively. In the indirect decarbonylation route (III), oxygen removal occurs in the form of CO and H2O, also resulting in hydrocarbons with one fewer carbon atom. In contrast, in hydrodeoxygenation (IV), oxygen is removed exclusively as water, producing paraffinic hydrocarbons with the same number of carbon atoms as those of the original chain (Cn). ,,, Alternative technologies have been employed for the development of second-generation fuels, aiming at cost reduction, lower environmental impacts, higher efficiency, and the use of feedstocks that do not compete with the food industry. In this context, several sources can be utilized, including edible oils, nonedible oils, and FO, among other residual lipid sources. FO refers to fats and oils discarded after use in food processing, cooking, or frying, such as vegetable- and animal-derived oils or fats (soybean oil, corn oil, sunflower oil, lard, chicken fat, etc.). − After repeated use, fats and oils become unsuitable for consumption due to oxidation reactions, increased free fatty acid content, and the accumulation of solid residues. However, improper disposal may lead to issues, such as oxygen depletion in water bodies, unpleasant odors in the air, and pipe clogging. Furthermore, the mere degradation of these substances into harmless compounds at high cost is both environmentally and economically inefficient. , According to the 2023 report by the Clean Fuels Alliance America (LMC/Global Data), the global market for biofuels derived from FO has grown significantly, reaching a global supply of 3.7 billion gallons, with projections ranging from 5 to 10 billion gallons by 2030. Asia stands out as the main global supplier, with China leading exports since 2017. − In 2023, the United States imported approximately 1.4 million metric tons of FO from countries such as China, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and Chile, representing about US$ 1.66 billion. According to the report, in Latin America, Brazil is the largest exporter of FO, and in 2024, the Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock (MAPA) obtained approval from the United States for FO exports under the International Phytosanitary Certificate (CSIV). , It is important to note that when FO is used for biofuel production, it must meet specific standards related to acidity, moisture content, iodine value, among other parameters. However, pretreatment stepsgenerally aimed at removing suspended solids, water, and free fatty acids from the oilsare influenced by storage conditions. Food residues, nonhermetic containers, and high ambient temperatures may promote decomposition reactions in FO, leading to the formation of polymerization and oxidation products, as well as changes in yield after prolonged periods of improper storage. In addition, the additional costs associated with collection and pretreatment can be significant. Nevertheless, the effects of feedstock degradation occurring between collection, storage, and catalytic conversion remain insufficiently understood. , This study aims to evaluate the potential of frying oil as a feedstock for renewable hydrocarbon production through hydrodeoxygenation. Although sulfided NiMo catalysts are well-established in petroleum hydrotreating, − they are typically employed to process refinery streams containing relatively low concentrations of oxygenated compounds. In contrast, vegetable oils consist almost entirely of oxygenated triglycerides and free fatty acids, representing a substantially more challenging feedstock. Therefore, a key novelty of the present work is demonstrating that a commercial refinery NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst can efficiently convert feedstocks containing nearly 100 wt % oxygenated compounds into green diesel-range hydrocarbons without catalyst modification. This industrially relevant assessment is further strengthened by a systematic comparison between soybean oil and frying oil under identical operating conditions, the application of a statistically designed factorial approach, and the catalyst reuse evaluation. This contribution is supported by four complementary elements: (i) a rigorous side-by-side comparison of SO and FO under identical reaction conditions, enabling direct assessment of the effect of feedstock quality on catalytic performance; (ii) evaluation of the effects of temperature, hydrogen pressure, and stirring speed through a statistically designed factorial approach on triglyceride conversion (XTG), hydrocarbon selectivity (SHC), and green diesel selectivity (SGD); (iii) the use of a commercially available NiMoS2/γ-Al2O3 catalyst supplied by CENPES/PETROBRAS, widely employed in Brazilian refineries, demonstrating its applicability to biobased feedstocks without catalyst modification; and (iv) catalyst reuse and deactivation studies supported by postreaction characterization. Together, these aspects provide new insights into the use of an industrial hydrotreating catalyst for the production of renewable hydrocarbons from waste-derived feedstocks. Materials and Methods Feedstock and Catalyst The feedstocks used were commercial refined soybean oil (SO), purchased from a supermarket, and waste frying oil (FO) obtained after domestic frying operations. Both feedstocks were of Brazilian origin. Hydrogen gas (H2, 99.9% purity) was supplied by Air Products Brasil. The commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst was provided by the Leopoldo Américo Miguez de Mello Research, Development, and Innovation Center (CENPES/PETROBRAS) and is widely used in Brazil in petroleum hydrotreatment processes. Characterization of SO and FO The feedstocks were characterized in terms of their chemical, structural, and thermal properties by thermogravimetric analysis, gas chromatography (GC-FID), and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR). Thermogravimetric analysis was used to quantify the mass variation of the vegetable oils as a function of temperature increase. This analysis aims to evaluate the thermal stability of the samples, as well as to determine ash and moisture contents. The methodology consisted of weighing approximately 10 mg of sample in an alumina crucible and performing the thermal analysis over the temperature range of 20 to 800 °C, with a heating rate of 10 °C/min and an air flow of 100 mL/min. Thermogravimetric analyses were conducted using a PerkinElmer thermogravimetric analyzer, model Pyris 1 TGA. The oils were characterized by gas chromatography (GC-FID), following method EM 14105, and the acid value was determined according to ASTM D664. The free fatty acid profiles of SO and FO were determined by gas chromatography according to methodology EM 14103. The infrared absorption spectrum was obtained using a Shimadzu IRPrestige-21 spectrometer within the wavenumber range of 400 to 4000 cm–1. This technique was employed to identify and confirm functional groups, as well as to determine the degree of saturation and unsaturation of the vegetable oils. Catalyst Characterization For catalyst characterization, the following analyses were performed: hydrogen temperature-programmed reduction (TPR-H2), X-ray fluorescence, X-ray diffraction, and full textural analysis using the BET (Brunauer–Emmett–Teller) method. The catalyst was analyzed by temperature-programmed reduction (TPR-H2) using a Micromeritics Autochem 2920 instrument. Hydrogen consumption was monitored by a thermal conductivity detector (TCD). Reduction profiles were normalized considering the sample mass (80 mg) and the H2 signal intensity. The sample was previously weighed and introduced into a quartz reactor. Initially, a pretreatment was carried out at 150 °C, with a heating rate of 10 °C/min, for 1 h under a flow of 30 mL/min of argon (Ar). The TPR-H2 reduction of the sample was conducted under a flow of 30 mL/min of a mixture containing 2.5% H2/Ar, from room temperature up to 900 °C, with a heating rate of 10 °C/min. X-ray fluorescence (XRF) was used to determine the chemical composition of the catalysts after synthesis. The powdered sample was analyzed using a Rigaku Primini instrument equipped with a palladium X-ray source. X-ray diffraction (XRD) was employed to analyze crystallographic planes, as well as crystal dimensions and orientations. The instrument used was a Rigaku Miniflex II, equipped with a graphite monochromator and using CuKα radiation (30 kV, 15 mA). The analysis was performed over an angular range from 5° to 90°, with an increment of 0.05° every 2 s between points. Textural analysis was carried out to determine the specific surface area, pore volume, and pore size of the catalyst. The analyses were conducted using a Micromeritics Tristar 3000 Surface Area and Porosimetry Analyzer. The specific surface area was calculated using the BET (Brunauer–Emmett–Teller) method, while pore diameter and specific volume were determined using the BJH method from the adsorption/desorption isotherm. After weighing, the sample was subjected to thermal drying at 200 °C under vacuum (5 × 10–3 Torr) for 24 h, and subsequently cooled to room temperature for reweighing before analysis at −196 °C, thereby obtaining N2 sorption isotherms (adsorption/desorption) at different partial pressures of N2. Catalytic Tests Preliminary Catalytic Tests The experiments were carried out using SO and FO under four different reaction systems: (i) without catalyst, (ii) with alumina (Al2O3) as catalyst support, (iii) with catalyst reduced for 2 h, and (iv) with catalyst reduced for 4 h. The reactions were conducted in a high-pressure reactor using 40 g of oil and 3 wt % catalyst relative to the oil mass, under constant stirring at 800 rpm and H2 pressure of 70 bar for 5 h. Catalyst reduction was performed prior to the reaction under continuous H2 flow (99.9%) at a flow rate of 50 mL/min. The reduction process was conducted at 500 °C, maintaining the reduction time according to the experimental condition: 2 or 4 h. After reduction, the catalyst was immediately transferred to the reactor to avoid reoxidation before the start of the catalytic test. The experimental conditions were selected based on real operating conditions of the hydrodesulfurization (HDS) process employed in petroleum refineries for the removal of heteroatoms (S, N, and O) from aviation kerosene and diesel streams. Catalyst reduction was performed ex situ prior to reaction. Although in situ activation is generally preferred to avoid catalyst exposure to air, immediate transfer of the reduced catalyst to the reactor was adopted to minimize reoxidation effects. This procedural choice and its potential impact on the density of active NiMoS edge sites are acknowledged as a limitation of the present study. , All reactions were carried out in a stainless-steel autoclave reactor (Parr Instruments Inc., model 4848B), with a total volume of 300 mL, in a simple batch system, under a maximum operating pressure of 200 bar. The reactor was equipped with temperature and pressure controllers, a stirring system, and an external heating mantle. Statistical Experimental Design A 23 factorial experimental design (2 levels, 3 factors) was conducted by varying temperature (350–370 °C), hydrogen pressure (50–70 bar), and stirring rate (500–800 rpm) in order to investigate the influence of independent variables on triacylglyceride conversion and selectivity toward hydrocarbons and green diesel. Additionally, three central points were included for each factor, totaling 11 experiments (Tables and ). Experimental data were analyzed using Protimiza Experimental Design software (https://experimental-design.protimiza.com.br). 1Matrix of 23 Factorial Experimental Design with 3 Central Points to Investigate the Influence of Independent Variables on Hydrocarbons Selectivity (Dependent Variable)ReactionsTemperature (°C) X1PH2 (bar) X2Stirring (rpm) X31–1–1–121–1–13–11–1411–15–1–1161–117–111811190001000011000 Matrix of 23 Factorial Experimental Design with 3 Central Points to Investigate the Influence of Independent Variables on Hydrocarbons Selectivity (Dependent Variable) 2Real Values of the Levels Used in the Matrix of the Experimental Design 23 + 3 Central Points LevelsIndependent variables–101Temperature (°C), X1350360370PH2 (bar), X2506070Stirring (rpm), X3500650800 Real Values of the Levels Used in the Matrix of the Experimental Design 23 + 3 Central Points Thus, the hydroprocessing reactions of SO and FO were carried out for all possible combinations of factor levels obtained from the experimental design. Catalyst Reuse Study The methodology employed for the catalyst reuse experiments was adapted from the works of Rossa et al. (2017) and Díaz et al. (2025). , The experiments were conducted under the following conditions: 40 g of vegetable oil (SO and FO); 3 wt % of catalyst (NiMoS2/Al2O3) relative to the oil mass; temperature of 370 °C; constant hydrogen pressure of 70 bar; reaction time of 5 h; and magnetic stirring at 800 rpm. Prior to the reaction, the catalyst was activated under a hydrogen flow of 50 mL/min at 500 °C for 4 h. A total of five consecutive reaction cycles were performed. After each cycle, the catalyst was recovered by filtration, thoroughly washed with 50 mL of chloroform, 50 mL of isopropanol, and 50 mL of acetone, and subsequently calcined at 300 °C for 4 h using a heating rate of 10 °C/min. The regenerated catalyst was reused in the subsequent cycle, and fresh catalyst was added only to compensate for catalyst losses during recovery and handling. To compensate for unavoidable mechanical losses during catalyst recovery and handling, a proportional amount of fresh catalyst was added in each cycle to maintain the total catalyst loading constant at 3 wt % relative to the oil mass. The commercial catalyst was intentionally used in its presulfided form without continuous sulfur cofeeding to simulate the direct application of conventional refinery hydrotreating catalysts to sulfur-free renewable feedstocks. Although progressive sulfur depletion may occur under these conditions, the adopted strategy allows for an assessment of catalyst performance during the processing of sulfur-free renewable feedstocks. Characterization of Reaction Products Gas Chromatography-FID Gas chromatography coupled with a flame ionization detector (GC-FID) was employed to identify and quantify products in the liquid phase, including fatty acid methyl esters, hydrocarbons, fatty alcohols, wax esters, and free fatty acids. This technique was also used to evaluate the triacylglycerol conversion and product selectivity. Triacylglycerol conversion was quantified using an external standard method with modifications based on standard EN 14105. Product selectivity, in turn, was determined by using an external calibration method specifically adapted for this analysis. The analysis of triacylglycerol conversion was performed using a direct injector and a DB5-HT capillary column (30 m length, 0.32 mm internal diameter, and 0.10 μm film thickness, Agilent), with a stationary phase composed of polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) modified with 5% phenyl-polysiloxane. Operating conditions included an injection volume of 1 μL, helium (99.95%) as the carrier gas with a linear velocity of 92.3 cm/s, and a temperature program starting at 40 °C (1 min), followed by a heating rate of 15 °C/min up to 230 °C, then 7 °C/min up to 320 °C, and finally 30 °C/min up to 380 °C, held for 20 min. The detector temperature was set at 350 °C, and the total analysis time was 48.52 min. Component identification was performed by comparing the retention times of sample peaks with those of authentic standards, while quantification was carried out by external calibration. It is noteworthy that only the liquid fraction was analyzed, as the study focuses on its application in the production of renewable hydrocarbons in the green diesel and aviation biokerosene boiling ranges. Gaseous products were not directly analyzed; however, their mass was estimated by difference. Calibration curves for the oil samples were constructed using standard solutions with mass fractions of 0.50, 0.25, 0.10, 0.01, 0.001, and 0.0001. For each concentration, the area corresponding to the triacylglycerol region was determined. Sample preparation for these calibrations involved collecting 11 μL of sample, adding 22 μL of the derivatizing agent MSTFA, and allowing a waiting time of 30 min prior to dilution in 1 mL of a 1:1 hexane/isopropanol solution. Regression equations were then obtained for the triacylglycerol mass fractions in SO and FO. Conversion was calculated based on the initial and final molar fractions of triacylglycerols in each sample, according to Equation 1 XTG%=(wi−wfwi)×100 where X TG% is the triacylglycerol conversion (%); wi is the molar fraction of triacylglycerols at the beginning of the reaction; and wf is the molar fraction of triacylglycerols at the end of the reaction. Selectivity analysis was conducted using a split injector (split ratio 1:25) and the same DB5-HT column described above. Helium (99.95%) was used as the carrier gas with a linear velocity of 38 cm/s. The temperature program started at 50 °C, followed by heating at 4 °C/min up to 180 °C, then 5 °C/min up to 320 °C, and subsequently 30 °C/min up to 385 °C, maintained for 15 min. The detector temperature was set at 260 °C, and the total analysis time was 77.76 min. For the analysis, 13 μL of each sample was diluted in 1 mL of a hexane/isopropanol solution (1:1). Product selectivity was determined by calculating the relative area of each compound with respect to the total area of all identified products, as defined in Equation This approach enabled the evaluation of product distribution formed during the reaction, providing insights into catalytic behavior and process efficiency. 2 Si=AreaiAreaall products·100 where Si is the selectivity to product i; Areai is the peak area of compound i; and Areaall products is the sum of the peak areas of all formed products. This methodology was designed to determine the fatty acid composition of vegetable oils. For this purpose, 300 mg of each oil sample was weighed, and the following procedure was applied: initially, a saponification reaction was carried out by reacting the oils with 2 mL of a saturated potassium hydroxide solution (0.5 mol/L) in methanol, followed by an esterification step using 2 mL of a methanolic solution containing 5% hydrochloric acid. The reactions were conducted in a closed system at 75 °C using a water bath for 10 min. Subsequently, to separate the methylated fatty acids from other components, 2 mL of distilled water and 2 mL of analytical-grade hexane were added. The organic phase containing hexane was then transferred to the second stage. In the second stage, the produced methyl esters were analyzed using a Shimadzu gas chromatograph, model GC-2014, equipped with a flame ionization detector (FID), a split/splitless injector, and a Carbowax 20M capillary column with a polyethylene glycol stationary phase (30 m length, 0.25 mm internal diameter, and 0.25 μm film thickness). Hydrogen was used as the carrier gas with a linear velocity of 26.5 cm/s. The oven temperature program was defined as follows: 60 °C for 2 min; heating from 60 to 200 °C at 10 °C/min; then from 200 to 240 °C at 5 °C/min, with a final hold at 240 °C for 15 min. The injector temperature was maintained at 250 °C, the detector at 280 °C, and the injection volume was 1 μL. The identification of methyl esters was performed by comparing the retention times of each sample component with those of a mixture of 37 external standards of fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs), covering the range from C4:0 to C24:0, supplied by Sigma. The composition was determined by area normalization, comparing the relative percentage of each characteristic FAME peak with the total peak area in the chromatogram. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) SO and FO were characterized by Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR). Reaction products obtained from preliminary tests were also analyzed by FTIR in order to evaluate the removal of oxygenated functional groups from the molecules present in SO and FO. The analyses were carried out using a Shimadzu IR PRESTIGE-21 instrument. Spectra were recorded in the range of 4000 to 400 cm–1, with a resolution of 1 cm–1 and 64 scans per spectrum. Results and Discussion Feedstock Characterization Initially, the feedstocks (SO and FO) were characterized by thermal analysis in order to evaluate the thermal stability of the oils as well as their moisture and ash contents. Figure presents the thermogravimetric analysis curves of the vegetable oils SO and FO, while Table summarizes the main thermal events and mass loss (%), in addition to the moisture (%) and ash (%) contents of the vegetable oils. Thermogravimetric analysis (TG and DTG) of (a) soybean oil: SO; and (b) frying oil: FO. 3Main Thermal Events and Mass Loss (%), Moisture (%), and Ash (%) for Each of the Oils (SO and FO)EventTemperature range (°C)AssignmentMass loss (%) SOMass loss (%) FOI20–200Loss of physically adsorbed moisture0.740.46II201–383Decomposition of polyunsaturated fatty acid species68.0770.85III384–391Decomposition of monounsaturated fatty acid species11.5710.42IV392–588Decomposition of saturated fatty acids and heavy residues13.5214.58V>450Oxidation of residual species under air atmosphere, accompanied by oxygen uptake and peroxide formation5.723.25Total loss--99.6299.56Moisture--0.740.46Ash800 °CResidual inorganic content0.380.44 Main Thermal Events and Mass Loss (%), Moisture (%), and Ash (%) for Each of the Oils (SO and FO) Based on the TG/DTG data presented in Figure and Table , and supported by the specialized literature, the thermal events observed for each vegetable oil (SO and FO) were analyzed over the temperature range from 20 to 800 °C. Event I, observed between 20 and 200 °C, is attributed to moisture evaporation and is consistent with the moisture contents determined for SO (0.74%) and FO (0.46%). According to previous studies, the first major thermal decomposition stage (Event II) is mainly associated with the degradation of polyunsaturated fatty acid species, corresponding to the onset of triglyceride decomposition and representing the most important stage for assessing the thermal stability of edible oils. The second decomposition stage (Event III) has been attributed mainly to the thermal degradation of monounsaturated fatty acid species. During this process, cleavage of carbon–carbon double bonds may occur, promoting the formation of more saturated structures. The third decomposition stage (Event IV) is mainly associated with the decomposition of saturated fatty acid species, which exhibit higher thermal stability. During heating, triacylglycerides, which account for 96–98% of the composition of vegetable oils, generate volatile compounds that are continuously removed by the vapor produced. These products are mainly formed through thermal reactions involving unsaturated fatty acids. The initial stage of oxidation in vegetable oils is characterized by oxygen uptake along the fatty acid chains, resulting in the formation of oxidation products such as peroxides. This behavior can be observed as an apparent increase in sample mass, detected after 450 °C for all analyzed oils, defined as event V. Considering that the analyses were conducted under an oxidizing atmosphere, a slight mass gain was detected in the DTG curves, indicating that the thermal decomposition process involves both absorption and release of the oxidizing gas (compressed air). This phenomenon was observed for both oils in the range between 450 and 600 °C. , Finally, the ash content, measured at 800 °C, showed low values: 0.38% for SO and 0.44% for FO. These levels are considered insufficient to cause significant interference in the HDO process, particularly with regard to catalyst deactivation. Table presents the characterization results of SO and FO in terms of the chemical composition of triacylglycerides (TAGs), diacylglycerides (DAGs), monoacylglycerides (MAGs), and free fatty acids (FFAs), obtained by gas chromatography (GC-FID). 4Results of the Chemical Composition of Vegetable Oils (SO and FO) in Terms of Triacylglycerides (TAG), Diacylglycerides (DAG), Monoacylglycerides (MAG), Free Fatty Acids (FFA), and Acid IndexOilsTAG (%)DAG (%)MAG (%)FFA (%)Acid index (mg KOH g–1)SO98.300.560.260.880.01FO95.183.320.011.490.21 Results of the Chemical Composition of Vegetable Oils (SO and FO) in Terms of Triacylglycerides (TAG), Diacylglycerides (DAG), Monoacylglycerides (MAG), Free Fatty Acids (FFA), and Acid Index The amounts of TAG, DAG, MAG, and FFA directly influence the amount of H2 required for the HDO of vegetable oils, aiming at their conversion into hydrocarbons. − The greater the number of oxygenated groups and the degree of unsaturation of carbon–carbon bonds in vegetable oil chains, the higher the amount of H2 required to hydrolyze glycerol from TAG, DAG, and MAG; saturate double bonds in the carbon chains; and promote the removal of oxygenated groups from the molecules via hydrodeoxygenation. The acidity index indicates the amount of free FFA; therefore, the higher this index, the greater the concentration of these free fatty acids in vegetable oils. The free FFA profile was also determined by gas chromatography coupled with a flame ionization detector (GC-FID), as presented in Table . 5Profile of Vegetable Oils (SO and FO) in Terms of Free Fatty Acids (FFA) Fatty acids (%)CompositionSOFOLauric acid (C12:0)-0.04Myristic acid (C14:0)-0.01Pentadecanoic acid (C15:0)0.050.13Palmitoleic acid (C16:1)10.2012.47Heptadecanoic acid (C17:1)0.080.10Estearic acid (C18:0)0.070.07Oleic acid (C18:1)32.6832.73Linoleic acid (C18:2)50.5048.40Linolenic acid (C18:3)5.425.17Nanodecanoic acid (C19:0)0.140.03Eicosanoic acid (C20:3)0.030.47Eicosapentaenoic acid (C20:5)0.260.22Erucic acid (C22:1)--Docosadienoic acid (C22:2)0.05-Tricosanoic acid (C23:0)0.54-Lignoceric acid (C24:0)-0.15Saturated0.790.43Unsaturated99.2199.56Monounsaturated42.9645.30Dienounsaturated50.5548.40Trienounsaturated5.455.64Polyunsaturated0.250.22 Profile of Vegetable Oils (SO and FO) in Terms of Free Fatty Acids (FFA) In addition to the quantified glyceride and free fatty acid fractions, vegetable oils may naturally contain minor constituents such as sterols, tocopherols, phospholipids, pigments, and other unsaponifiable compounds. , However, the soybean oil (SO) employed in this study was a commercially refined edible oil. During industrial refining processesincluding degumming, neutralization, bleaching, and deodorizationmost of these minor constituents are removed, remaining only at trace levels that are generally considered negligible for hydroprocessing reactions. Consequently, the chemical composition of the refined SO is adequately represented by the quantified TAG, DAG, MAG, and FFA fractions. The frying oil (FO) used in this work was originally the same refined soybean oil and, therefore, had also undergone the same refining process. Nevertheless, repeated exposure to high temperatures during frying promotes oxidation, hydrolysis, and polymerization reactions, leading to the formation of small amounts of secondary oxidation products, including hydroperoxides, aldehydes, ketones, and other oxygenated species. Although these compounds were not quantified separately because of their very low concentrations, they may also undergo hydrodeoxygenation and secondary hydrocracking under the reaction conditions employed, contributing to the formation of lighter hydrocarbons. The absence of additional significant FTIR bands and the thermogravimetric behavior of both feedstocks indicate that these species, if present, occur only in minor amounts and, therefore, are not expected to significantly affect the overall interpretation of the catalytic results. On the basis of Table , a qualitative estimation of hydrogen demand can be inferred from the degree of unsaturation of the fatty acid profiles, suggesting a slightly higher hydrogen demand for SO compared to FO. The HDT route via HDO of oils and fats, with the addition of H2 from both fossil and renewable sources, is a widely studied technology for converting triacylglycerides, diacylglycerides, monoacylglycerides, and their respective fatty acids to hydrocarbons. This process enables the production of green paraffinic hydrocarbons, with carbon chain lengths equal to or one carbon unit shorter than those of the original fatty acid. ,,,,,− Figure shows the infrared spectra of SO and frying oil FO. Table lists the assignments of the main bands in the infrared spectra according to the reference literature. , Infrared spectra of soybean oil (SO) and frying oil (FO). 6Assignments of the Main Bands in the Infrared Spectra for the Raw Materials Soybean Oil (SO) and Frying Oil (FO)Wavenumbers (cm–1) SOFOAssignments of the main bands30073004Deformation of the bonds in the CH group29202914Stretching of the bonds present in the −CH2 and −CH3 groups28592847Stretching of the bonds present in the −CH2 and −CH3 groups17361742Vibration of the bonds in the CO esters group16521647Axial deformation of the CC bond-1561Stretching of the bonds present in the −CH2 and −CH3 groups14581462Angular deformation in the bonds of the CH2 group13741380Angular deformation in the bonds of the CH3 group12351235Vibration of the bonds in the −C–O esters group11561162Vibration of the bonds in the −C–O esters group10961096Vibration of the bonds in the −C–O–C– group908908Out-of-plane angular deformation of the RCHCH2 bonds721721Stretching of the bonds present in the −CH2 and −CH3 groups Assignments of the Main Bands in the Infrared Spectra for the Raw Materials Soybean Oil (SO) and Frying Oil (FO) The regions characteristic of triacylglycerides are identified by bands at 1740 cm–1, attributed to CO ester bond vibrations, and in the range of 1235–1096 cm–1, corresponding to −C–O– and −C–O–C– bond vibrations, typical of esters. These bands are assigned to triacylglycerides and their precursor esters linked to the glycerol molecule. Catalyst Characterization Figure presents the temperature-programmed reduction profile (TPR-H2) of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. TPR-H2 profile of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst and its deconvolution according to Díaz et al. (2024). The TPR profile of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst exhibited three peaks after deconvolution, similar to those reported by Rodríguez-Catellón (2008). Figure shows a peak at 426 °C associated with the reduction of weakly adsorbed sulfur on the support surface, representing the reduction of sulfur vacancies with the formation of the MoS2 phase. A second peak, at 542 °C, was attributed to the reduction of nickel sulfide species located at the edges of MoS2 layers, corresponding to the NiMoS phase, which is recognized for its high catalytic activity. The third peak, at 631 °C, is likely associated with the reduction of basal planes, indicative of bulk MoS2. − This H2-TPR analysis indicates the presence of sulfur/sulfide species in the catalyst both before and after hydrogen reduction. The qualitative and quantitative compositions of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst and the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst after 4 h of reduction followed by passivation were determined by X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analysis, as presented in Table . 7Chemical Composition of the Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst and after the Reduction Process for 4 h (50 mL min–1 H2 Flow for 4 h) and Passivation, Obtained by X-ray Fluorescence (XRF) According to Díaz et al. (2024) Chemical composition (%, m/m)CatalystAl2O3 MoO3 NiOSO3 NiMoS2/Al2O3 commercial 55.3334.907.462.29NiMoS2/Al2O3 reduced 4 h 55.3534.927.462.29 Chemical Composition of the Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst and after the Reduction Process for 4 h (50 mL min–1 H2 Flow for 4 h) and Passivation, Obtained by X-ray Fluorescence (XRF) According to Díaz et al. (2024) The qualitative and quantitative XRF analysis, presented in Table , confirmed the presence of Ni, Mo, and S derived from the catalyst precursors, as well as Al from the support. No significant variation in bulk sulfur content was observed after reduction and passivation. This behavior was expected and indicates that no appreciable loss of the main active components occurred during these treatments, supporting the effectiveness of the passivation procedure and the reliability of the characterization protocol employed. The atomic ratio Ni/(Ni+Mo), which is important for hydrotreatment performance, was approximately 0.20, a value within the effective range (0.20–0.40) for the conversion of triacylglycerides into hydrocarbons via HDO, as reported by Kubička (2010). Studies with alumina-supported NiMo catalysts have reported conversion and selectivity up to 100% at temperatures up to 280 °C, contact times up to 4 h, and hydrogen pressures of 35 bar. X-ray diffraction (XRD), shown in Figure , revealed the diffractograms of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst and those obtained after reduction for 2 and 4 h. X-ray diffractograms of the catalyst (a) commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3, (b) NiMoS2/Al2O3 reduced for 2 h, and (c) NiMoS2/Al2O3 reduced for 4 h. Figure (a) presents the characteristic X-ray diffraction (XRD) pattern of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. Figure (b) and (c) show the diffraction patterns of the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst after reduction for 2 and 4 h, respectively. A low-intensity peak associated with the monoclinic Mo3O phase was observed at 2θ ≈ 27°, while the MoS2 phase exhibited a diffraction peak at 2θ ≈ 36°. Peaks located at 2θ ≈ 34° and 50° are attributed to the NiMoS phase, and a diffraction signal corresponding to the NiS2 phase was detected at 2θ ≈ 54°. − The presence of these sulfur-containing phases indicates the incorporation of sulfide groups in the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst, as also evidenced by the TPR analysis (Figure ). All diffraction peaks observed for this catalytic material are in agreement with those reported in the literature, in which the authors identified crystalline phases using reference files from the JCPDS (Joint Committee on Powder Diffraction Standards) database. The specific surface area (determined by the BET method), total pore volume, and average pore diameter were obtained from N2 adsorption–desorption measurements. The corresponding values are summarized in Table . 8Textural Characteristics of Al2O3 Support, Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst, and NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst Reduced for 4 h CatalystSBET (m2 g–1)Vpores (cm3 g–1)Dpores (nm)Al2O3 1610.387.8NiMoS2/Al2O3 commercial 1040.093.3NiMoS2/Al2O3 reduced 4 h 840.2711.8aSBET: specific surface area (m2 g–1); Vpores: average pore volume (cm3 g–1); Dpores: average pore diameter. Textural Characteristics of Al2O3 Support, Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst, and NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst Reduced for 4 h SBET: specific surface area (m2 g–1); Vpores: average pore volume (cm3 g–1); Dpores: average pore diameter. Regarding the textural properties obtained by N2 adsorption/desorption (Table ), the Al2O3 support exhibited a specific surface area of 161 m2 g–1 and an average pore diameter of 7.8 nm, confirming its mesoporosity. After metal incorporation, the average pore diameter decreased to 3.3 nm without loss of mesoporosity, which is suitable for reactions involving large molecules such as triglycerides, as it improves diffusion pathways. For the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst, the surface area decreased from 104 to 84 m2 g–1 after 4 h of reduction; however, an increase in pore volume and average pore diameter was observed, which may enhance accessibility to active sites and improve interaction with sterically demanding substrates. These results are consistent with previous literature reports, including the study by Łaniecki et al. (2000). , Hydrodeoxygenation of Vegetable Oils via H2 and Catalytic Activity The hydrodeoxygenation reactions were carried out using SO and FO in order to evaluate the influence of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst on hydrocarbon selectivity. The evaluation was compared with control reactions without a catalyst and with the use of the support material alone. The impact of catalyst reduction time (activation for 2 and 4 h) on maximizing hydrocarbon selectivity was also investigated. The catalytic tests were conducted under the following conditions: 40 g of vegetable oil (SO or FO), 3 wt % of NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst relative to the oil mass, external hydrogen pressure of 70 bar, temperature of 370 °C, stirring at 800 rpm, for 5 h. For comparison, four different reactions were carried out with each oil: a control reaction without catalyst (RS0 for SO and RF0 for FO); a reaction using only the Al2O3 support (RS1/RF1); a reaction with NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst activated by reduction at 500 °C under H2 flow (99.9%) of 50 mL min–1 for 2 h (RS2h/RF2h); and a similar reaction with reduction for 4 h (RS4h/RF4h). The complete results are described in Tables and . 9Catalytic Tests Using Soybean Oil (SO) ReactionsConditionsRS0RS1RS2hRS4hPH2 (bar)70.0070.0070.0070.00Catalyst-Al2O3 NiMoS2/Al2O3 NiMoS2/Al2O3 Reduction time (h)--24Glycerol quantity94.5096.2598.3598.82SO conversion (%)97.5385.0988.0978.46Liquid products (%)2.4714.9111.9121.54 Functional groups Selectivity (%) Fatty acids (%)0.571.56-0.01Methyl esters (%)83.4180.8113.843.47Fatty alcohols (%)--0.860.22Wax (%)1.04-0.290.01Hidrocarbons (%)14.9917.6385.0196.30aRS0: control reaction without catalyst; RS1: reaction using only Al2O3 as support; RS2h: reactions using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst reduced at 500 °C with H2 flow (99.9%) of 50 mL/min for 2 h; RS4h: reactions using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst reduced at 500 °C with H2 flow (99.9%) of 50 mL/min for 4 h. Catalytic Tests Using Soybean Oil (SO) RS0: control reaction without catalyst; RS1: reaction using only Al2O3 as support; RS2h: reactions using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst reduced at 500 °C with H2 flow (99.9%) of 50 mL/min for 2 h; RS4h: reactions using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst reduced at 500 °C with H2 flow (99.9%) of 50 mL/min for 4 h. 10Catalytic Tests Using Frying Oil (FO) ReactionsConditionsRF0RF1RF2hRF4hPH2 (bar)70.0070.0070.0070.00Catalyst-Al2O3 NiMoS2/Al2O3 NiMoS2/Al2O3 Reduction time (h)--24Glycerol quantity96.2697.8598.6898.98FO conversion (%)82.6896.6885.9389.87Liquid products (%)17.323.3214.0710.13 Functional groups Selectivity (%) Fatty acids (%)1.761.090.000.00Methyl esters (%)78.7982.1217.631.50Fatty alcohols (%)0.000.672.110.21Wax (%)0.000.003.080.61Hidrocarbons (%)19.4516.1377.1797.68aRF0: control reaction without catalyst; RF1: reaction using only Al2O3 as support; RF2h: reactions using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst reduced at 500 °C with H2 flow (99.9%) of 50 mL/min for 2 h; RF4h: reactions using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst reduced at 500 °C with H2 flow (99.9%) of 50 mL/min for 4 h. Catalytic Tests Using Frying Oil (FO) RF0: control reaction without catalyst; RF1: reaction using only Al2O3 as support; RF2h: reactions using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst reduced at 500 °C with H2 flow (99.9%) of 50 mL/min for 2 h; RF4h: reactions using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst reduced at 500 °C with H2 flow (99.9%) of 50 mL/min for 4 h. The use of the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst reduced for 2 h promotes a significant increase (from ∼15% (SO) and ∼20% (FO) to ∼85% (SO) and ∼77% (FO)) in hydrocarbon selectivity during the HDO process of vegetable oils. Extending the reduction time to 4 h results in a further increase in selectivity, demonstrating the fundamental importance of the active metallic phase of the catalyst for process efficiency. The hydrocarbons produced span the carbon range from C7 to C24, with a predominance of C15, C16, C17, and C18 compounds, which correspond to green diesel. These compounds were quantified by gas chromatography with flame ionization detection (GC-FID) using an external standard method, with results expressed as selectivity percentages. In the HDT process of triacylglycerides, several simultaneous and consecutive reactions occur. Under hydrogen and high-temperature conditions, hydrogenolysis of triacylglycerides into fatty acids takes place, along with saturation of olefinic bonds and conversion of triacylglycerols to their corresponding fatty acids and propane. Subsequently, deoxygenation reactions involving fatty acids, methyl esters, fatty alcohols, and other oxygenated intermediates lead to the formation of hydrocarbons, while CO, CO2, H2O, propane, and light hydrocarbons are generated as byproducts through decarboxylation, decarbonylation, hydrodeoxygenation, hydrogenolysis, and secondary cracking pathways. , To gain further insight into the deoxygenation pathways operating during vegetable oil hydrotreatment, the relative abundance of Cn and Cn‑1 paraffins was evaluated from the GC-FID chromatograms of the most selective catalytic runs (RS4h and RF4h), as summarized in Table . In HDO, oxygen is removed as H2O while preserving the carbon chain length, leading primarily to the formation of C16 and C18 paraffins from C16 and C18 fatty acid derivatives present in the feedstocks. In contrast, decarboxylation and decarbonylation (DCO/DCO2) pathways remove one carbon atom as CO2 or CO, producing C15 and C17 paraffins. ,, Since the fatty acid profiles of both feedstocks are dominated by C16 and C18 fatty acids (Table ), the formation of C15 and C17 paraffins provides indirect evidence that oxygen removal occurred through decarboxylation and decarbonylation pathways, in which one carbon atom is released as CO2 or CO. 11Relative Contribution of Cn and Cn‑1 Paraffins Obtained from GC-FID Analysis of the Most Selective Catalytic RunsSampleC15 areaC16 areaC17 areaC18 area(C15+C17)/(C16+C18)RS4h10960433858672192624067370.303RF4h110998.3476295.9579431.624637040.235 Relative Contribution of Cn and Cn‑1 Paraffins Obtained from GC-FID Analysis of the Most Selective Catalytic Runs The calculated (C15+C17)/(C16+C18) ratios were 0.303 and 0.235 for SO (RS4h) and FO (RF4h), respectively. Since both values are significantly lower than unity, the results indicate that hydrodeoxygenation was the predominant deoxygenation pathway under the evaluated conditions. ,, The slightly lower ratio observed for FO may indicate a somewhat greater contribution of HDO relative to SO. However, the difference between the two feedstocks was relatively small, suggesting that both oils exhibited a similar dominant deoxygenation behavior under the investigated conditions. The feedstock characterization data presented in Table showed that FO contained a higher concentration of free fatty acids (1.49%) than SO (0.88%), reflecting the degradation reactions that occur during the repeated frying cycles. Nevertheless, only a modest variation in the (C15+C17)/(C16+C18) ratio was observed between the two feedstocks (0.235 for FO and 0.303 for SO). This result suggests that the differences in feedstock composition exerted only a limited influence on the relative contributions of HDO and DCO/DCO2 pathways under the hydrogen-rich conditions employed in this study. In both cases, the predominance of HDO is inferred from the higher relative abundance of C16+C18 paraffins. In addition, hydrocarbons lighter than the green diesel range (C5–C15) were detected in the product mixtures, indicating the occurrence of secondary hydrocracking reactions. As discussed later in the experimental design section, the formation of these lighter hydrocarbons became more pronounced at higher reaction temperatures, consistent with the enhanced cleavage of C–C bonds under more severe reaction conditions. The products from the control reactions and those with catalyst reduced for 2 and 4 h (RS0, RS2h, and RS4h, respectively), presented in Table , were further characterized by infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) and compared with the original SO, revealing chemical modifications resulting from the process, as illustrated in Figure . Infrared spectra of (a) soybean oil (SO) and the products of (b) control reaction (RS0), reactions performed with the catalyst (c) NiMoS2/Al2O3 reduced for 2 h (RS2h), and (d) NiMoS2/Al2O3 reduced for 4 h (RS4h). The most notable difference between the infrared spectrum of SO (a) and that of the RS4h product (d) is the absence of the characteristic ester carbonyl stretching band at 1750 cm–1 in spectrum (d). In spectrum (a), bands at 1200 cm–1, corresponding to C–C­(O)–O axial deformation in esters, and at approximately 1183 cm–1, likely associated with asymmetric stretching of the O–C–C bond, are observed. These bands are still present in spectra (b) and (c) but are no longer observed in spectrum (d), confirming the hydrodeoxygenation of the crude oil. All spectra exhibit absorption in the 3000–2800 cm–1 region, corresponding to C–H stretching vibrations, typically attributed to methylene (CH2) and methyl (CH3) groups, both in hydrocarbon chains and in oxygenated compounds such as fatty acids. A band at 1744 cm–1, possibly associated with carbonyl species or CO2 dissolved in the reaction medium, is observed in spectra (c) and (d), but not in the control reaction (b) nor in the original SO (a). This suggests the formation of CO2 through decarboxylation reactions. Although CO may also have been generated via decarbonylation, it was not detected in the FTIR spectra. At this stage, gaseous products were quantified only as mass percentages, as presented in Tables , , and . Their composition is likely a mixture of CO, CO2, C3H8, CH4, and H2O. To complement the spectroscopic evidence and provide a global validation of the catalytic system, representative mass balances were established for the most selective catalytic runs (RS4h and RF4h), as summarized in Table . Near-complete mass closure was achieved (99.50–100.00%), confirming excellent consistency between the quantified liquid products and the overall material balance. 12Representative Mass Balances for the Catalytic Hydrodeoxygenation of Soybean Oil and Frying Oil under Optimum ConditionsStreamRS4hRF4hInitial oil mass (g)40.2039.50Total liquid products (g)31.3435.50Gaseous products (g) 8.664.00Mass closure (%)99.50100.00aCalculated by difference because of the absence of direct gas-phase collection in the batch reactor configuration. Representative Mass Balances for the Catalytic Hydrodeoxygenation of Soybean Oil and Frying Oil under Optimum Conditions Calculated by difference because of the absence of direct gas-phase collection in the batch reactor configuration. Gaseous products were estimated by mass balance closure due to the absence of direct gas-phase collection in the batch reactor configuration. Gas formation is associated with decarboxylation and decarbonylation reactions (CO2 and CO formation), hydrogenolysis of the glycerol backbone (C3H8 formation), and secondary cracking reactions producing light hydrocarbons (C1–C4). ,, In addition, water is expected to be generated mainly through the hydrodeoxygenation pathway, in which oxygen is removed from fatty acids as H2O while preserving the carbon chain length of the corresponding hydrocarbons. ,, Although water was not quantified separately, since it condensed together with the liquid products, its formation is consistent with the predominance of deoxygenation pathways inferred from FTIR results and liquid-phase composition trends. The high mass closure suggests that major unaccounted losses were limited under the investigated conditions. Nevertheless, direct quantification of gaseous products, water formation, and coke deposition would be required for a rigorous assessment of material closure. To better understand the catalytic activity of NiMoS2/Al2O3 in the HDO process of vegetable oils, the catalyst used in the SO reactions was characterized after use in the RS4h reaction, as presented in Table . 13Textural Characteristics of NiMoS2/Al2O3 Reduced for 4 h and NiMoS2/Al2O3 after Reaction with 40 g of Soybean Oil at 370 °C, 70 bar of H2, 800 rpm, 3% (m/m) Catalyst for 5 h CatalystSBET (m2 g–1)Vpores (cm3 g–1)Dpores (nm)NiMoS2/Al2O3 reduced 4 h 840.2711.80NiMoS2/Al2O3 after first reaction 870.196.03aSBET: surface area (m2 g–1); Vpores: average pore volume (cm g–1); Dpores: average pore diameter (nm). Textural Characteristics of NiMoS2/Al2O3 Reduced for 4 h and NiMoS2/Al2O3 after Reaction with 40 g of Soybean Oil at 370 °C, 70 bar of H2, 800 rpm, 3% (m/m) Catalyst for 5 h SBET: surface area (m2 g–1); Vpores: average pore volume (cm g–1); Dpores: average pore diameter (nm). Figure (a) presents the typical X-ray diffraction (XRD) pattern of Al2O3 (cubic structure), with its main diffraction peaks observed at 2θ = 37°, 46°, and 67°, in agreement with the literature. The pattern shown in Figure (b) was previously discussed in Figure (b). In contrast, the diffractogram of the catalyst after the hydroprocessing reaction with SO, shown in Figure (c), reveals a decrease in the intensity of the peaks associated with the NiMoS and MoS2 phases, indicating a loss of crystallinity of the active phases. Additionally, the peaks at 2θ = 41° and 66° are attributed to carbonaceous phases and nickel aluminates, respectively. This suggests possible catalyst deactivation associated with the formation of nickel aluminate species and carbon deposition. − X-ray diffractograms of the catalyst (a) Al2O3, (b) NiMoS2/Al2O3 reduced for 4 h, and (c) NiMoS2/Al2O3 after reaction with 40 g of soybean oil at 370 °C, 70 bar of H2, 800 rpm, and 3% (w/w) catalyst for 5 h. The comparison between the XRD pattern of the support (Al2O3) and those of the fresh and used catalysts reveals that the diffraction peaks of the catalyst overlap with the main peaks of Al2O3. This overlap arises from the high concentration of active phases (NiMoS) impregnated on the support, suggesting that the active phase responsible for the HDO process is located on the catalyst surface. However, low metal dispersion favors the agglomeration of crystalline phases on the surface, which, in turn, attenuates or eliminates the main diffraction peaks of the Al2O3 support. High levels of crystallinity may negatively impact the catalytic activity and stability of the material at high temperatures. Table presents the results of the textural analysis of the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst after 4 h of reduction and after its first use in SO hydroprocessing. The NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst, reduced for 4 h and passivated prior to the reaction, exhibited a specific surface area of 84 m2 g–1. The textural analysis indicated an average pore diameter of 11.8 nm, classifying the material as predominantly mesoporous (2–50 nm), which is favorable for the diffusion and conversion of large molecules such as triacylglycerides. After the hydroprocessing reaction, the average pore diameter decreased to 6.03 nm, while still maintaining its mesoporous character. This reduction in pore volume and diameter suggests partial blockage, possibly due to the deposition of heavy intermediates or coke. Nevertheless, the catalyst may potentially be regenerated by recalcination followed by a new reduction step, enabling its reuse in HDO processes. The NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst used in this study was supplied by the Centro de Pesquisa, Desenvolvimento e Inovação Leopoldo Américo Miguez de Mello (CENPES) and was selected due to its commercial relevance and industrial applicability. This material is widely used in petroleum refineries for the hydrotreatment of diesel and aviation fuels, aiming at the removal of sulfur-, nitrogen-, and oxygen-containing compounds. The sulfiding step plays a fundamental role in catalytic performance, as sulfided catalysts exhibit higher activity compared to their nonsulfided counterparts. The importance of this step in increasing conversion and selectivity in hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) processes is well established in the literature. According to Li (2018), sulfided catalysts are generally more effective than nonsulfided ones in promoting the conversion of vegetable oils into hydrocarbons due to their higher catalytic activity. However, despite their superior performance, these catalysts may cause undesirable sulfur contamination in the final products as a result of sulfur leaching during the reaction. , To place the present results in the context of industrial operation and highlight the limitations associated with batch reactor studies, a brief comparison with typical continuous-flow hydrotreatment conditions is provided below. Although the batch experiments employed a catalyst/oil ratio of 3 wt % and a reaction time of 5 h, these conditions are more severe than those commonly encountered in industrial trickle-bed hydrotreatment units. , Commercial renewable diesel processes are typically operated continuously at WHSV values in the range of approximately 0.5–2.0 h–1 and with lower catalyst inventories relative to the feed. , Therefore, the present conditions should be regarded as laboratory-scale conditions for comparative evaluation of catalyst activity and selectivity, rather than direct industrial simulation. Statistical Experimental Design To investigate the influence of temperature, hydrogen pressure, and stirring speed on selectivity toward hydrocarbons (HCs) and green diesel (GD), a full factorial design (23) with three central points was employed. The central points allowed for the evaluation of the curvature of the response surface and the estimation of the experimental error. This design enabled a comprehensive analysis of both main effects and interactions, providing insights into how these variables affect selectivity individually and in combination. In this study, the HDO of SO was conducted using a commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst under different conditions of temperature (350, 360, and 370 °C), hydrogen pressure (50, 60, and 70 bar), and stirring speed (500, 650, and 800 rpm). The selectivities toward hydrocarbons and green diesel obtained in the hydrotreatment of SO and FO are presented in Tables and , respectively. 14Results Obtained from the 23 Full Factorial Experimental Design with the Addition of Three Central Points for the Hydrotreatment of Soybean Oil (SO), Using the Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst ReactionT (°C)P (bar)Stirring (rpm)XTG (%)SHC (%)SGD (%)SC5–C15 (%)SOthers (%)13505050099.3682.4977.974.5217.5123705050099.4496.2989.586.713.7133507050099.3991.9687.304.668.0443707050099.4897.2289.817.412.7853505080099.3375.2472.432.8124.7663705080099.4494.8985.289.615.1173507080099.4696.4091.065.343.60 8 370 70 800 99.50 97.91 93.74 4.17 2.09 93606065099.4892.3786.885.497.63103606065099.4894.1289.634.495.88113606065099.5091.2388.133.108.77aXTG: triacylglyceride conversion; SHC: selectivity toward liquid hydrocarbons; SGD (C16–C22): selectivity toward hydrocarbons in the green diesel (GD) range (C16–C22); SOthers: selectivity toward other products (a mixture of free fatty acids, fatty alcohols, methyl esters, and waxes). Results Obtained from the 23 Full Factorial Experimental Design with the Addition of Three Central Points for the Hydrotreatment of Soybean Oil (SO), Using the Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst XTG: triacylglyceride conversion; SHC: selectivity toward liquid hydrocarbons; SGD (C16–C22): selectivity toward hydrocarbons in the green diesel (GD) range (C16–C22); SOthers: selectivity toward other products (a mixture of free fatty acids, fatty alcohols, methyl esters, and waxes). 15Results Obtained from the 23 Full Factorial Experimental Design with the Addition of Three Central Points for the Hydrotreatment of Frying Oil (FO), Using the Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst ReactionT (°C)P (bar)Stirring (rpm)XTG (%)SHC (%)SGD (%)SC5–C15 (%)SOthers (%)13505050098.8482.2679.352.9117.7423705050098.9296.0690.965.103.9433507050098.8791.7388.683.058.2743707050098.9697.1591.195.962.8553505080098.8175.0173.811.2024.9963705080098.9294.6686.668.005.3473507080098.9496.1792.443.733.83 8 370 70 800 98.98 97.68 95.12 2.56 2.32 93606065098.9692.1486.585.567.86103606065098.9693.8988.285.616.11113606065098.9891.0089.511.499.11aXTG: triacylglyceride conversion; SHC: selectivity toward liquid hydrocarbons; SGD: selectivity toward hydrocarbons in the green diesel (GD) range (C16–C22); SC5–C15: selectivity toward hydrocarbons in the biojet fuel range (C5–C15) and lighter hydrocarbons; SOthers: selectivity toward other products (a mixture of free fatty acids, fatty alcohols, methyl esters, and waxes). Results Obtained from the 23 Full Factorial Experimental Design with the Addition of Three Central Points for the Hydrotreatment of Frying Oil (FO), Using the Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 Catalyst XTG: triacylglyceride conversion; SHC: selectivity toward liquid hydrocarbons; SGD: selectivity toward hydrocarbons in the green diesel (GD) range (C16–C22); SC5–C15: selectivity toward hydrocarbons in the biojet fuel range (C5–C15) and lighter hydrocarbons; SOthers: selectivity toward other products (a mixture of free fatty acids, fatty alcohols, methyl esters, and waxes). The analysis of Tables and shows that, in addition to the target hydrocarbons, the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst also promoted the conversion of SO and FO into byproducts such as free fatty acids, fatty alcohols, fatty acid esters (methyl esters), and wax esters. Both feedstocks exhibited high selectivity toward total hydrocarbons, with values exceeding 97% under the most favorable conditions (Experiment 8), along with high selectivity toward hydrocarbons in the green diesel range. These results indicate that FO is also a viable feedstock for green diesel production via hydrotreatment. Besides the hydrocarbons within the green diesel range (C16–C22), smaller amounts of C5–C15 compounds were also detected. These lighter products are attributed mainly to secondary hydrocracking reactions occurring at elevated temperatures. The increase in temperature enhances C–C bond cleavage and favors the formation of shorter-chain hydrocarbons, explaining the increase in SC5–C15 observed in some experiments conducted at 370 °C. , No significant formation of branched paraffins was observed in the chromatographic analyses. This behavior is consistent with the predominantly hydrogenation/deoxygenation character of sulfided NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalysts and with the limited bifunctional acidity of γ-Al2O3, which does not strongly promote skeletal isomerization. Consequently, the products obtained consisted predominantly of linear paraffins. , It is observed that higher temperature and hydrogen pressure conditions result in higher selectivities toward hydrocarbons and green diesel, indicating the predominance of deoxygenation pathways under more severe reaction conditions. The conversion of triacylglycerides (XTG, %) was also satisfactory for both oils, reaching 99.50% for the SO and 98.98% for the FO. To confirm which conditions of temperature, H2 pressure, and stirring speed led to higher selectivity toward hydrocarbons, a statistical analysis of the data was performed. Because triacylglyceride conversion (XTG, %) remained above 98% in all experiments and exhibited only a narrow variation range, it was not considered to be a suitable response for factorial modeling. Therefore, the statistical analysis focused on SHC and SGD, which showed a greater sensitivity to the operating variables and represented the main performance indicators of the process. Statistical AnalysisSO Based on the results of the experimental design for HDO reactions of SO (Table ), the relationship between the response variableshydrocarbon selectivity and C16–C22 hydrocarbon selectivityand the studied variablestemperature, H2 pressure, and stirring speedwas established. Among the models available in Design-Expert 9.06, the linear model, determined by the least-squares method, proved to be the most suitable for fitting the experimental dataset. Figure and Table present the estimated effects (Pareto chart) and regression coefficients (regression table) of the independent variables temperature (°C), stirring (rpm), and H2 pressure (bar) on hydrocarbon (HC) and SGD, considering the linear model, as well as the interactions between variables when NiMoS2/Al2O3 was used as the catalyst. Pareto diagram of the standardized effects for (a) selectivity to SHC hydrocarbons (%) and (b) selectivity to SGD green diesel and lubricants (%) using NiMoS2/Al2O3 as the catalyst. X1: temperature (°C); X2: H2 pressure (bar); and X3: stirring. 16Regression Analysis of Coefficients for (a) Hydrocarbon Selectivity and (b) Green Diesel Range Selectivity When Soybean Oil (SO) Was Hydrotreated in the Presence of the Commercial Catalyst, NiMoS2/Al2O3 NameCoefficientsStandard errorCalculated-t p-value (a) HDT SOHydrocarbon selectivity Mean91.830.64143.40<0.05Temperature, °C (X1)5.030.756.69<0.05Pressure of H2, bar (X2)4.320.755.76<0.05Stirring, rpm (X3)–0.440.75–0.580.59X1·X2–3.330.75–4.440.06X1·X30.260.750.350.74X2·X31.720.752.290.08 (b) HDT SO Green diesel range selectivity Mean86.530.62145.09<0.05Temperature, °C (X1)3.710.705.30<0.05Pressure of H2, bar (X2)4.580.706.55<0.05Stirring, rpm (X3)–0.270.70–0.380.72X1·X2–2.410.70–3.440.09X1·X30.180.700.250.81X2·X32.190.703.13<0.05 Regression Analysis of Coefficients for (a) Hydrocarbon Selectivity and (b) Green Diesel Range Selectivity When Soybean Oil (SO) Was Hydrotreated in the Presence of the Commercial Catalyst, NiMoS2/Al2O3 Based on the p-value criterion (≤0.05), an independent variable was considered significant in influencing hydrocarbon selectivity (%). In this study, temperature (X1) and hydrogen pressure (X2) were identified as significant factors, both exerting positive effects, with regression coefficients of 5.03 and 4.32, respectively. The sign of the coefficients indicates that positive values increase hydrocarbon selectivity, while negative values have a detrimental effect. Specifically, increasing temperature (350–370 °C) and hydrogen pressure (50–70 bar) favors the cleavage of oxygenated bonds and promotes hydrogenation by overcoming activation barriers. Additionally, higher hydrogen pressures stabilize reaction intermediates and increase hydrogen availability on the catalyst surface, thereby improving selectivity, although high temperatures may also lead to the formation of undesirable byproducts. − On the other hand, stirring speed did not show a statistically significant influence, suggesting that under the evaluated experimental conditions, the reaction rate was governed by kinetics rather than mass transfer limitations, since increased agitation minimizes diffusion constraints. ,, It is noteworthy that no significant interactions between the independent variables were observed regarding the hydrocarbon selectivity. Figure presents a Pareto diagram confirming that temperature and hydrogen pressure are the only statistically significant factors influencing the system. The results indicate that the simultaneous increase in temperature and gas pressure favors hydrocarbon selectivity, which is in agreement with expected trends. The validation of the models for HC and GD selectivity using the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst was performed through analysis of variance (ANOVA), as presented in Table , as well as through the F-distribution, with two F-tests conducted at this stage (Equation and Equation ). 17Results Obtained After Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) for the Response Variable: (a) Selectivity for Hydrocarbons, SHC (%) and (b) Selectivity to Green Diesel, SGD (%) Variation sourceSSFDMSF1Cal p-value (a) HDT SOhydrocarbon selectivity Regression446.50677.7517.2<0.05Residuals18.0444.5 F2 Cal Lack of fit13.8026.903.30.23Pure error4.2422.12 Total484.5310 R2 = 0.9628 Radj2=0.9070 (b) Selectivity of HDT SOgreen diesel Regression363.45660.5715.5<0.05Residuals15.6543.91 F2 Cal Lack of fit11.8625.933.10.24Pure error3.8021.89 Total379.1010 R2 = 0.9235 Radj2=0.8088 aSS: sum of squares; FD: freedom degrees; MS: mean squares. Results Obtained After Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) for the Response Variable: (a) Selectivity for Hydrocarbons, SHC (%) and (b) Selectivity to Green Diesel, SGD (%) SS: sum of squares; FD: freedom degrees; MS: mean squares. The values of F1 and F2 were calculated using Equation and Equation . • F1 Test: To evaluate the significance of the linear regression, the null hypothesis (H0)which assumes that all regression coefficients are equal to zero and that the slope of the fitted line is nullwas tested using the F1 test. For H0 to be rejected, the calculated F value (F1Cal, Equation ) must exceed the critical tabulated value (F1tab), and the p-value must be statistically significant (≤0.05). As shown in Table , the p-values for both models are below the predefined significance level (α = 0.05), indicating statistical relevance. Moreover, based on the critical F values reported by Rodrigues and Iemma (2014), the F1Cal value for the SHC (%) model is 17.2, approximately 2.8 times higher than F1tab (F1tab = F(6.4;0.05) = 6.16). A similar result is observed for the SGD (%) model, where F1Cal is 15.5, approximately 2.5 times higher than the critical value. Therefore, the null hypothesis can be rejected in both cases, confirming the existence of a significant linear relationship between the response variables (SHC (%) and SGD (%)) and the independent variables. 3 F1Cal(6,4)=MSRegressionMSResidual • F2 Test: To evaluate the goodness of fit of the models, the lack-of-fit F2 test was applied, in which model adequacy is confirmed when the calculated F2 value (F2Cal, Equation ) is lower than the tabulated value (F2tab), considering a 95% confidence level, and when the p-value is not statistically significant (>0.05). According to Table , the p-values for the SHC (%) and SGD (%) models are 0.23 and 0.24, respectively, both above the 0.05 threshold. Additionally, the calculated F2 values for the SHC and SGD models (3.3 and 3.1, respectively) are lower than the critical value (F2tab = F(2;2;0.05) = 19.00) reported by Rodrigues and Iemma (2014). These results indicate that the null hypothesisaccording to which the models adequately represent the datacannot be rejected, thus confirming a satisfactory model fit. 4 F2Cal(2,2)=MSLack of fitMSPure error Additionally, high coefficients of determination were obtained for SO hydrotreatment with R2 values of 0.9628 and 0.9235 for SHC and SGD, respectively. The corresponding adjusted coefficients ( Radj2 = 0.9070 and 0.8088) also remained high, indicating that the fitted models retained good explanatory power after accounting for the number of model terms. Combined with the nonsignificant lack-of-fit results (p > 0.05), these findings confirm the adequacy of the proposed models and their satisfactory predictive capability. The equations describing the responses for hydrocarbon selectivity (Y 1, SHC, %) and green diesel selectivity (Y 2, SGD, %) under SO hydrotreatment in the presence of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst are presented in Equation and Equation , respectively. 5 Y1=91.83+5.03x1+4.32x2−0.44x3−3.34x1x2+0.26x1x3+1.72x2x3 6 Y2=86.53+3.71x1+4.58x2−0.27x3−2.41x1x2+0.18x1x3+2.19x2x3 where: Y 1 = SHC (%), using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. Y 2 = SGD (%), using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. x 1 = temperature (°C); x 2 = H2 pressure (bar); x 3 = stirring (rpm). Figure presents the comparison between experimental and predicted results for (a) HC selectivity (%) and (b) GD selectivity (%), using NiMoS2/Al2O3 as the catalyst. Graph of experimental results versus the results obtained by the proposed model for (a) hydrocarbon selectivity (SHC, %) and (b) green diesel selectivity (SGD, %), when soybean oil (SO) was hydrotreated in the presence of the commercial catalyst NiMoS2/Al2O3. The dots represent the experimental results (●), and the results obtained from the linear statistical model are represented by the line (−). The closer the dots are to the line, the closer the experimental results are to the model’s results. In general, the experimental values of hydrocarbon and green diesel selectivity are closely distributed around the predicted lines, indicating good agreement with the model estimates. Subsequently, the effects of reaction parameters on the response variables were evaluated using two-dimensional response surface plots (Figure ), constructed from the model equations (Equation and Equation ). In these plots, green regions indicate the highest selectivities toward hydrocarbons and green diesel. 2D plots illustrating the selectivity to hydrocarbons (SHC, %) and green diesel (SGD, %) during the hydrotreatment of soybean oil (SO) using the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. (a) temperature vs H2 pressure for SHC; (b) temperature vs stirring speed for SHC; (c) H2 pressure vs stirring speed for SHC; (d) temperature vs H2 pressure for SGD; (e) temperature vs stirring speed for SGD; (f) H2 pressure vs stirring speed for SGD. Figure shows the effects of temperature, stirring speed, and H2 pressure on HC and GD selectivity. Consistent with the statistical analysis, temperature and H2 pressure were the dominant factors, whereas stirring speed exhibited only a minor individual effect within the investigated range. In Figure (b) and (e), higher temperatures (360–370 °C) increase selectivity regardless of stirring speed, indicating a more pronounced influence of stirring at elevated temperatures. Figures (c) and (f) show that at low H2 pressures (<54 bar), increasing stirring speed reduces selectivity; however, this effect is reversed at higher pressures, where both HC (>96%) and GD (>92%) selectivities are favored by higher stirring speeds (>700 rpm) and pressures (>68 bar). Figures (a) and (d) further confirm that high temperatures (∼370 °C), combined with high H2 pressures (>65 bar), enhance HDO performance, resulting in selectivities above 90%. Thus, the optimal conditions for maximizing hydrocarbon selectivity in the green diesel range were identified as 370 °C, 70 bar H2, and 800 rpm, as observed in Experiment 8 (Table ). Statistical AnalysisFO Table presents the experimental conditions and selectivities obtained for hydrocarbons and green diesel (GD), which were used as input data for the statistical analysis of FO hydrotreatment using the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. Figure and Table present the estimated effects (Pareto chart) and regression coefficients (regression table) of the independent variables (temperature (°C), H2 pressure (bar), and stirring speed (rpm)) on hydrocarbon selectivity (SHC, %) and green diesel selectivity (SGD, %), based on a linear model that also considers interactions between variables. These analyses were conducted for the hydrotreatment of FO using the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. Pareto diagram of the magnitudes of the standard effects for (a) hydrocarbon selectivity and (b) SGD when frying oil (FO) was hydrotreated in the presence of the commercial catalyst NiMoS2/Al2O3. 18Regression Analysis of Coefficients for (a) Hydrocarbon Selectivity and (b) SGD When Frying Oil (FO) Was Hydrotreated in the Presence of the Commercial Catalyst, NiMoS2/Al2O3 NameCoefficientsStandard errorCalculated-t p-value (a) HDT FOHydrocarbon selectivity Mean91.610.65141.897<0.05Temperature, °C (X1)5.050.766.67<0.05Pressure of H2, bar (X2)4.340.765.732<0.05Stirring, rpm (X3)–0.460.76–0.610.58X1·X2–3.310.76–4.380.08X1·X30.240.760.320.76X2·X31.700.762.250.09 (b) HDT FOGreen diesel selectivity Mean87.510.37236.22<0.05Temperature, °C (X1)3.710.438.53<0.05Pressure of H2, bar (X2)4.580.4310.55<0.05Stirring, rpm (X3)–0.270.43–0.620.57X1·X2–2.410.43–5.540.07X1·X30.180.430.400.70X2·X32.190.435.04<0.05 Regression Analysis of Coefficients for (a) Hydrocarbon Selectivity and (b) SGD When Frying Oil (FO) Was Hydrotreated in the Presence of the Commercial Catalyst, NiMoS2/Al2O3 The statistical analysis of FO hydrotreatment, based on p-values (significance threshold ≤ 0.05), revealed that temperature and H2 pressure significantly influenced hydrocarbon selectivity (SHC, %), while stirring had no significant effect. As shown in Table (a), both temperature and H2 pressure exhibited positive and statistically significant effects, with regression coefficients of 5.05 and 4.34, respectively. These values indicate that increasing temperature from 350 to 370 °C and H2 pressure from 50 to 70 bar increased hydrocarbon selectivity by 5.05 and 4.34 units, respectively. In contrast, stirring speed, when evaluated independently, showed no significant impact on SHC (%). Furthermore, interaction terms between independent variables were not statistically significant for hydrocarbon selectivity. These findings are corroborated by the Pareto chart (Figure a), confirming temperature and pressure as the dominant factors. Reaction 8 (Table ) reinforces this trend, showing that higher temperatures and H2 pressures are associated with higher SHC (%). Regarding SGD, a similar pattern was observed. As shown in Table (b) and Figure (b), temperature and H2 pressure were again significant and positive factors, with regression coefficients of 3.71 and 4.58, respectively. This indicates that increasing temperature from 350 to 370 °C and H2 pressure from 50 to 70 bar led to increases in GD selectivity of 3.71 and 4.58 units, respectively. Although stirring speed alone was not significant for GD selectivity, its interaction with H2 pressure showed a positive and statistically significant effect, with a regression coefficient of 2.19. This suggests that higher stirring levels, combined with high pressures, favor green diesel production, as evidenced by reaction 8 (Table ). Overall, the behavior observed for FO consistently reproduces that found for SO, as expected, considering that the used cooking oil in Brazil is predominantly derived from soybean oil. These findings highlight the central roles of temperature and hydrogen pressure in maximizing product selectivity during hydrodeoxygenation. The statistical validation of the predictive models for SHC and SGD during FO hydrotreatment over NiMoS2/Al2O3 was performed using ANOVA, as summarized in Table . This procedure included two F-tests based on the F-distribution (Equation and Equation ) to evaluate model significance and robustness. 19Statistical Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) for the Response Variables: (a) Selectivity for Hydrocarbons, SHC (%) and (b) Selectivity for Green Diesel, SGD (%) Variation sourceSSFDMSF1Cal p-value (a) HDT FOhydrocarbon selectivity Regression467.94677.9917.0<0.05Residuals18.3444.58 F2 Cal Lack of fit14.1027.053.30.23Pure error4.2422.12 Total486.2810 R2 = 0.9623 Radj2=0.9058 (b) HDT FOgreen diesel selectivity Regression363.45660.5740.0<0.05Residuals15.6543.91 F2 Cal Lack of fit11.8625.930.40.72Pure error3.8021.89 Total379.1010 R2 = 0.9837 Radj2=0.9592 aSS: sum of squares; FD: freedom degrees; MS: mean squares. Statistical Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) for the Response Variables: (a) Selectivity for Hydrocarbons, SHC (%) and (b) Selectivity for Green Diesel, SGD (%) SS: sum of squares; FD: freedom degrees; MS: mean squares. The comparison between calculated and critical F-values indicates that the statistical criteria for F1 and F2 are satisfied, confirming model adequacy under the evaluated conditions. Furthermore, high coefficients of determination were obtained for FO hydrotreatment with R2 values of 0.9623 for SHC and 0.9837 for SGD. The corresponding adjusted coefficients ( Radj2 = 0.9058 and 0.9592, respectively) also remained high, indicating that the models retained excellent explanatory power after correction for the number of fitted terms. Combined with the nonsignificant lack-of-fit results (p > 0.05), these findings confirm the adequacy and predictive capability of the proposed models. The mathematical models for SHC (Y 1) and SGD (Y 2) are presented in Equation and Equation , respectively. 7 Y1=91.61+5.05x1+4.34x2−0.46x3−3.31x1x2+0.24x1x3+1.70x2x3 8 Y2=87.51+3.71x1+4.58x2−0.27x3−2.41x1x2+0.18x1x3+2.19x2x3 where: Y 1 = SHC (%), using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst; Y 2 = SGD (%), using the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst; x 1 = temperature (°C); x 2 = H2 pressure (bar); x 3 = stirring (rpm). Figure presents the correlation plots between experimental data and model predictions for SHC(%) and SGD(%) during FO hydrotreatment using the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. Graphs comparing experimental data and values predicted by the proposed model for (a) hydrocarbon selectivity (SHC, %) and (b) green diesel selectivity (SGD, %) during the hydrotreatment of frying oil (FO) over the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. Experimental data points are represented by dots (●), while the predictions from the linear statistical model are indicated by the solid line (−). The proximity of the data points to the line reflects the degree of agreement between the experimental results and the model predictions. The comparison between experimental data and model predictions shows that the experimental points closely follow the proposed linear trends, indicating a good fit and a strong agreement between experimental results and predicted values. Based on the model equations (Equation and Equation ), two-dimensional response surface plots were constructed to illustrate the effects of the independent variablestemperature (350–370 °C), hydrogen pressure (50–70 bar), and stirring speed (500–800 rpm)on the dependent variables: hydrocarbon selectivity (SHC, %) and green diesel selectivity (SGD, %). These results, obtained from FO hydrotreatment over the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst, are presented in Figure . 2D graphical representations of hydrocarbon selectivity (SHC, %) and green diesel selectivity (SGD, %) during the hydrotreatment of frying oil (FO) in the presence of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. (a) Temperature vs H2 pressure for SHC; (b) temperature vs stirring speed for SHC; (c) H2 pressure vs stirring speed for SHC; (d) temperature vs H2 pressure for SGD; (e) temperature vs stirring speed for SGD; (f) H2 pressure vs stirring speed for SGD. The regions highlighted in green in Figure indicate the experimental conditions under which the highest selectivity values were achieved, particularly the combination of high temperature (≈ 370 °C), high hydrogen pressure (70 bar), and high stirring rate (800 rpm). Consistently, the contour plots (Figure ) demonstrate that temperature and H2 pressure are the most influential factors for both responses, as confirmed by the analysis of the coefficients of the fitted model, which exhibit the highest absolute values for these variables. Increasing temperature raises the kinetic energy of the system, promoting more frequent and more effective molecular collisions and, consequently, favoring hydrocarbon formation. In contrast, reducing H2 pressure hinders mass transfer and limits hydrogen availability at the catalyst active sites, negatively impacting deoxygenation rates. Although the stirring rate proved to be statistically less significant as an isolated factor, its interaction with H2 pressure positively affected green diesel selectivity, especially at higher temperatures. Figures (b), (e), (c), and (f) show that under low H2 pressures (<54 bar), increasing stirring tends to reduce the formation of desired products; however, this trend is reversed at higher pressures (>68 bar), where selectivity values above 96% for SHC and 92% for SGD were observed. Overall, the graphical analyses suggest that the optimal conditions to maximize hydrocarbon selectivity within the range of interest correspond to temperatures between 350–370 °C, an H2 pressure of 70 bar, and a stirring rate of 800 rpm, with experiment 8 (370 °C, 70 bar, 800 rpm) standing out as the most effective in terms of both selectivity and liquid product yield (Table ). It should be emphasized that the highest selectivities were obtained at the upper boundary of the investigated experimental domain (370 °C, 70 bar H2, and 800 rpm). Therefore, the true optimum may lie outside the evaluated range, and further studies employing response-surface methodologies with expanded operating windows are recommended. Comparison of Catalytic Performance with Literature Reports To further assess the performance of the commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst under the optimum conditions in this study (370 °C, 70 bar H2, and 800 rpm), a quantitative comparison was conducted with representative literature reports on the hydrodeoxygenation of vegetable oils and waste cooking oils using both sulfided NiMo-based catalysts and noble-metal catalysts. The comparison includes feedstock type, reaction conditions, conversion or yield, and selectivity toward diesel-range hydrocarbons (C16–C22), allowing the catalytic performance achieved in the present work to be positioned within the current state of the art. 20Comparison of Catalytic Performance in Hydrodeoxygenation of Waste OilsCatalystFeedstockT (°C)H2 (bar)Performance metric (%) SGD (%) Ref.Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 FO37070TAG conversion = 98.9895.12This work0.2-NiMoS2/Al2O3 WSBO 30040C15–C18 yield = 56.998.1Prangklang et al. (2023)Sulfided NiMo/Al2O3 WCO35070Oil conversion = 99.890.7Toba et al. (2011)2.4%Ru/NbOPO4 WCO35030Liquid yield = 7896Rosa et al. (2026)Ir-ReOx/SiO2 WCO18020Diesel-ranged alkane yield = 82 wt %98.7 Liu et al. (2018)aPerformance metrics vary among studies according to the methodology adopted by each author (e.g., feedstock conversion, hydrocarbon yield, or C15–C18 selectivity). Therefore, the table provides a comparative overview rather than a strict ranking of catalytic activity.bSGD denotes green diesel selectivity, defined as the selectivity toward liquid hydrocarbons in the green diesel range. Although most studies consider C16–C22 paraffins, some literature reports extend this range to C10–C20 hydrocarbons depending on the catalyst system and product classification criteria.cWSBO: waste soybean oil.dEstimated from reported product distributions, as green diesel selectivity was not explicitly provided in the original study. Comparison of Catalytic Performance in Hydrodeoxygenation of Waste Oils Performance metrics vary among studies according to the methodology adopted by each author (e.g., feedstock conversion, hydrocarbon yield, or C15–C18 selectivity). Therefore, the table provides a comparative overview rather than a strict ranking of catalytic activity. SGD denotes green diesel selectivity, defined as the selectivity toward liquid hydrocarbons in the green diesel range. Although most studies consider C16–C22 paraffins, some literature reports extend this range to C10–C20 hydrocarbons depending on the catalyst system and product classification criteria. WSBO: waste soybean oil. Estimated from reported product distributions, as green diesel selectivity was not explicitly provided in the original study. Direct quantitative comparison among studies should be interpreted with caution because different authors report catalytic performance using distinct metrics, including feedstock conversion, hydrocarbon yield, liquid yield, and diesel range selectivity. The commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst employed in this work achieved 98.98% TAG conversion and 95.12% SGD at 370 °C and 70 bar H2, representing a highly competitive performance among NiMo-based systems reported for waste-oil hydrodeoxygenation. Literature NiMo catalysts exhibit similarly high selectivity, although often accompanied by lower overall hydrocarbon yields. For instance, Prangklang et al. reported 98.1% SGD over 0.2-NiMoS2/Al2O3, corresponding to a C15–C18 hydrocarbon yield of 56.9%, indicating a trade-off between selectivity and total hydrocarbon production. In contrast, sulfided NiMo/Al2O3 reported by Toba et al. achieved nearly complete conversion (99.8%) but lower SGD (90.7%) compared to the present study. Noble-metal catalysts also show high activity but under more complex or less directly comparable conditions. Ru/NbOPO4 reaches 78 wt % liquid yield with 96% SGD; however, the reaction proceeds predominantly via a decarboxylation/decarbonylation (DCOx) pathway, which involves intrinsic carbon loss and affects the effective carbon efficiency of the process. In addition, Ir–ReOx/SiO2 achieves 82 wt % diesel-range alkane yields only after extended reaction times (18 h) and in the presence of impurity-containing feedstocks, indicating slower overall kinetics and sensitivity to catalyst deactivation. Overall, despite differences in feedstock quality, reaction conditions, reaction pathways, and performance metrics, the results demonstrate that the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst employed in this work provides an optimal balance between the TAG conversion and SGD. This performance places it within the upper range of reported catalytic systems for waste oil hydrodeoxygenation under industrially relevant conditions. Reuse Reuse experiments were carried out using the commercial catalyst NiMoS2/Al2O3 and vegetable oils (FO and SO) under the optimized conditions established in the experimental design (370 °C, 70 bar, 800 rpm, 5 h). At the end of each reaction cycle, the catalyst was separated from the reaction mixture by filtration and subjected to sequential washing with chloroform, isopropanol, and acetone. Subsequently, the catalyst was reused for four additional cycles under identical conditions. The results of these reuse experiments with the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst in the hydrotreatment of FO and SO are summarized in Table . 21Results of Reuse Experiments, Reusing NiMoS2/Al2O3 as a Catalyst; Conditions: 800 rpm; 3% Catalyst Relative to the Mass of (a) Frying Oil and (b) Soybean Oil; 370 °C; 5 h, 70 bar (a) FO (b) SO CycleXTG (%)SHC (%)SGD (%)SC5–C15 (%)XTG (%)SHC (%)SGD (%)SC5–C15 (%)199.0397.2292.737.2799.2397.2292.737.27294.4596.0693.206.7995.4897.0993.306.70393.2694.7792.487.5194.3796.1892.617.39493.4295.0186.9113.0893.9696.1587.0512.95593.8394.3984.3215.6794.3395.2684.4515.55aXTG (%): triacylglyceride conversion; SHC (%): hydrocarbon selectivity; SGD (%): green diesel selectivity; SC5–C15 (%): aviation biokerosene selectivity. Results of Reuse Experiments, Reusing NiMoS2/Al2O3 as a Catalyst; Conditions: 800 rpm; 3% Catalyst Relative to the Mass of (a) Frying Oil and (b) Soybean Oil; 370 °C; 5 h, 70 bar XTG (%): triacylglyceride conversion; SHC (%): hydrocarbon selectivity; SGD (%): green diesel selectivity; SC5–C15 (%): aviation biokerosene selectivity. Figure presents plots correlating the trends in triacylglycerol conversion and selectivities obtained with FO and SO (Table ) after each reuse experiment of the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. Triacylglyceride conversion behavior and selectivity to hydrocarbons (SHC, %), green diesel (SGD, %), and aviation biokerosene (SC5–C15, %) with (a) frying oil (FO) and (b) soybean oil (SO), reusing the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. The NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst exhibited high initial catalytic activity, achieving triglyceride conversions (XTG) of 99.03% for FO (Table (a) and Figure (a)) and 99.23% for SO (Table (b) and Figure (b)). Between the first and second cycles, a moderate decrease in conversion to approximately 95% was observed, followed by stabilization up to the fifth cycle with average values of 93.51% (FO) and 94.22% (SO). This initial deactivation pattern is likely associated with the restructuring of the active sulfided phase, partial desulfurization, accumulation of carbonaceous deposits, and/or other deactivation mechanisms. However, the available experimental evidence does not allow the individual contributions of each mechanism to be quantitatively distinguished. − The selectivity toward total hydrocarbons (SHC) remained high and consistent throughout the cycles, with average values of 95.49% (FO) and 96.38% (SO), suggesting the predominance of deoxygenation pathways and the partial preservation of the active Ni–Mo–S structure. However, from the third cycle onward, a decrease in SGD was observed, concomitant with an increase in the C5–C15 fraction (SC5–C15). This shift toward hydrocracking reactions may be associated with gradual changes in the physicochemical properties of the bifunctional system, a phenomenon also reported by Wei et al. (2025) and Carrasco Díaz et al. (2024). , From a mechanistic standpoint, the changes in product distribution and the loss of activity are likely associated with progressive modifications of the sulfided phase and partial pore blockage caused by the accumulation of carbonaceous species. Although these structural modifications affect the accessibility of active sites and the efficiency of hydrogenation and deoxygenation steps, the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst demonstrated robustness, exhibiting similar performance for both oils used. Thus, the system proves to be a promising catalyst, maintaining high performance and hydrocarbon selectivity, even after multiple reuse cycles. It should be emphasized that the catalyst was intentionally operated without sulfur cofeeding to simulate the processing of sulfur-free renewable feedstocks in conventional refinery infrastructure. Under these conditions, gradual desulfidation is expected and may contribute to the catalyst deactivation. Therefore, the observed performance reflects the catalyst robustness under realistic retrofit conditions rather than under continuously sulfided operations. Catalyst Characterization after Reuse Cycles To investigate the catalyst deactivation observed at the end of the reuse experiments in HDT reactions with FO and SO, the spent catalyst was subjected to comprehensive textural characterization, as presented in Table . 22Textural Characteristics of the Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 after Five Cycles of Reuse in Hydrotreating (HDT) Reactions with Frying Oil (FO) and Soybean Oil (SO) CatalystSBET (m2 g–1)Vpores (cm3 g–1)Dpores (nm)NiMoS2/Al2O3 reduced 840.2711.8NiMoS2/Al2O3 reuse FO 340.1120.4NiMoS2/Al2O3 reuse SO 310.1721.4aSBET: specific surface area (m2 g–1); Vpores (cm3 g–1): average pore volume; Dpores (nm): average pore diameter. Textural Characteristics of the Commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 after Five Cycles of Reuse in Hydrotreating (HDT) Reactions with Frying Oil (FO) and Soybean Oil (SO) SBET: specific surface area (m2 g–1); Vpores (cm3 g–1): average pore volume; Dpores (nm): average pore diameter. The textural characterization of the NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst after reaction revealed significant structural modifications that are consistent with deactivation phenomena commonly reported in hydrotreating processes, particularly pore blockage and the probable accumulation of carbonaceous deposits. According to the data in Table , the catalyst in its reduced form exhibited a high specific surface area (SBET = 84 m2 g–1) and pore volume (Vpore = 0.27 cm3 g–1). After reuse, a drastic reduction in these parameters was observed, with SBET values decreasing to 34 and 31 m2 g–1, and Vpore reduced to 0.11 and 0.17 cm3 g–1 for FO and SO feeds, respectively. This contraction suggests a significant loss of structural accessibility and the progressive coverage of active sites. − The apparent increase in average pore diameter, from 11.8 nm to approximately 20–21 nm (Table ), together with the reduction in surface area and pore volume, suggests significant alterations in the porous structure. Such changes are frequently associated with the accumulation of carbonaceous deposits and pore blockage in hydrotreating catalysts. According to the literature, these phenomena impose severe intraparticle diffusional limitations, restricting the mass transfer of bulky molecules. The combined textural changes observed in Table suggest that polymerization reactions involving oxygenated intermediates may contribute to the degradation of textural properties and the progressive loss of catalytic activity over successive cycles. Although direct quantification of the sulfur content by X-ray fluorescence (XRF) after reuse cycles was not reliable due to the limited sensitivity of the technique at very low sulfur concentrations, catalyst deactivation is strongly supported by the observed deterioration of textural properties (Table ) and catalytic performance (Table ). The loss of activity is consistent with the partial depletion and restructuring of the active NiMoS phase under sulfur-free reaction conditions. Previous studies on vegetable oil hydrotreatment have shown that oxygenated feeds promote sulfur loss from sulfided NiMo catalysts, leading to progressive deactivation when no external sulfiding agent is supplied, whereas continuous sulfur addition helps preserve catalytic activity. , In addition, the pronounced reduction in surface area and pore volume further supports the occurrence of structural modifications during reuse. Therefore, the observed deactivation is likely the result of multiple factors acting simultaneously. However, the present experimental evidence does not allow the relative contributions of each mechanism to be distinguished quantitatively. In addition to the probable accumulation of carbonaceous deposits and pore blockage, it should be considered that the ex situ reduction procedure adopted in this study may have allowed limited exposure of the catalyst to atmospheric oxygen during handling. Although rapid transfer to the reactor was employed to minimize this effect, partial reoxidation of the sulfided phase cannot be completely excluded and may also contribute to the progressive modification of active sites during reuse. Such morphological changes directly impacted process selectivity, as detailed in Table , where an increase in the formation of lighter fractions is observed at the expense of the green diesel. This shift in product distribution suggests that changes in the porous structure and in active site availability may not only contribute to catalyst deactivation but also promote secondary reactions such as cracking. Thus, the experimental results highlight a strong correlation between the preservation of the textural properties and the overall catalytic performance of the NiMoS2/Al2O3 system. Limitations and Future Perspectives The present study demonstrated the technical feasibility of producing renewable hydrocarbons from soybean oil and frying oil through hydrotreatment over a commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. Nevertheless, some limitations must be acknowledged. The experiments were conducted at laboratory scale, catalyst stability was evaluated over a limited number of reuse cycles, and no catalyst regeneration procedures were investigated. The absence of continuous sulfur supplementation during operation may lead to deviations in the sulfur chemical potential required to stabilize the NiMoS active phase, potentially resulting in progressive modifications of the sulfide structure during reuse. , Future work should focus on validating the process under continuous flow (trickle-bed) operation, improving catalyst regeneration strategies, investigating sulfur management approaches, and evaluating the influence of contaminants typically present in waste frying oils on catalyst deactivation and product quality. In addition, comprehensive characterization of spent catalysts using techniques such as thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and temperature-programmed oxidation (TPO) is recommended to quantify carbonaceous deposits and provide a more detailed understanding of catalyst deactivation mechanisms during reuse. Further characterization of fuel properties, including density, viscosity, cetane index, and cold flow behavior, is also necessary to assess the suitability of the obtained hydrocarbons as drop-in fuels. Although a fraction of the products was distributed within the C5–C15 range, the present work was primarily focused on renewable diesel production. Therefore, the suitability of these hydrocarbons for sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) applications cannot be established based on the current results. Dedicated fuel-property characterization and compliance assessment with aviation fuel specifications will be required in future investigations. Final Considerations This study demonstrated the feasibility of producing renewable hydrocarbons from soybean oil and frying oil through hydrotreatment over a commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalyst. Triacylglyceride conversions above 99% were achieved under the optimum conditions of 370 °C, 70 bar H2, and 800 rpm, yielding hydrocarbon selectivities above 97% and a maximum SGD of 95.12%. Statistical analysis identified temperature as the most influential operational variable, followed by hydrogen pressure, whereas stirring speed showed no significant effect on process performance. The comparable performance observed for frying oil highlights its potential as a low-cost and sustainable feedstock for renewable fuel production. Catalyst reuse experiments confirmed good stability, maintaining conversions above 93%, although progressive catalyst deactivation, probably associated with carbonaceous deposition and changes in product distribution. Overall, the results demonstrate that commercial NiMoS2/Al2O3 catalysts can efficiently convert waste lipids into diesel-range renewable hydrocarbons, supporting the valorization of waste cooking oils within circular bioeconomy strategies.