Experiences of Transgender and Gender Diverse Patients in Accessing Gender-Affirming Chest Masculinization: A Systematic Review and Qualitative Thematic Synthesis of the Literature Authors: Emma Lim, Justin Haas, Precious Adekoya, Sophia Hou, Kathleen Armstrong, Helene Retrouvey, Ammara Ghumman Published: 2026 ABSTRACT IntroductionThe objective of this review was to synthesize existing qualitative research regarding the experiences of transgender and gender diverse (TGD) individuals undergoing gender-affirming chest masculinization surgery, in order to identify critical barriers and facilitators which may affect access to and quality of care.MethodsWe searched eight electronic databases in August 2025 for qualitative results analyzing the experiences of TGD individuals undergoing chest masculinization. We included primary qualitative or mixed-methods studies published in English/French that involved trans masculine or gender-diverse individuals ≥12 years undergoing chest masculinization. Exclusion criteria included cisgender or trans feminine populations, nonsurgical or nongender-affirming care, absence of qualitative data, and nonpeer-reviewed literature. The Critical Appraisal Skills Programme checklist was used to appraise the quality of included studies. A thematic synthesis was conducted following Thomas and Harden.ResultsSixty studies met the inclusion criteria. Four analytical themes were identified: (1) charting a course, (2) interactions with providers, (3) surgical goal setting, and (4) adjusting to oneself.ConclusionTGD individuals face persistent structural and interpersonal barriers when accessing chest masculinization surgery. The domains identified in the present review form a patient experience-driven framework that healthcare stakeholders and providers can use to improve access to care. Healthcare providers should be aware that nonbinary and binary transgender patients may have varying surgical goals for chest masculinization. Introduction Chest masculinization surgery, colloquially referred to as “top” surgery, is a gender-affirming procedure that typically involves resection of glandular breast tissue. It is often the first or only surgical procedure that many transgender and gender-diverse (TGD) undergo1,2 and is the most commonly requested gender-affirming surgery requested, with demand increasing over recent years.1-3 Chest masculinization is associated with improved mental health outcomes, increased quality of life,4-6 and decreased gender dysphoria.7,8 Many TGD individuals face challenges accessing chest masculinization surgery. In a 2024 Canadian survey, all TGD patients undergoing gender-affirming surgery reported difficulty accessing care. 9 Barriers to care are often systemic, encompassing challenges like social stigma, safety, cost, lack of insurance coverage, and geographical inaccessibility.10-14 Significantly, these barriers have been linked to social difficulties, adverse health outcomes, and increased healthcare consumption.15-17 In response, some people may seek private care despite financial strain or choose to avoid medical systems entirely.4,18 Understanding patient experiences is essential in improving the quality and accessibility of gender-affirming care. However, research into the experiences of patients navigating chest masculinization remains limited. The current body of transgender literature often groups binary and nonbinary experiences under one umbrella, despite evidence of greater health disparities in nonbinary populations.18,19 Additionally, nonbinary patients face greater misunderstanding from primary care physicians and may have distinct transition and surgical goals.20,21 Thus far, no prior reviews have explored how TGD individuals interact with healthcare systems while accessing chest-masculinization surgery. The objective of this review was to synthesize existing qualitative research regarding the experiences of undergoing gender-affirming chest masculinization surgery, in order to identify critical barriers which may affect access to and quality of care. Methods Design We conducted a qualitative evidence synthesis following thematic synthesis methodology outlined by Thomas and Harden. 22 This protocol was registered on the Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (registration number: CRD420251113988) in line with the Cochrane guidelines and the Enhancing Transparency in Reporting the Synthesis of Qualitative Research framework.23,24 Selection Criteria We included primary studies with a qualitative component, including mixed-methods studies, that involved trans masculine or gender-diverse individuals aged ≥12 years seeking chest masculinization surgery and that were published in English or French. No date restrictions were applied. Exclusion criteria included cisgender or transfeminine populations, nongender-affirming or nonsurgical care, absence of qualitative data, nonprimary or nonpeer-reviewed literature (excluding grey literature), and non-English/French publications. Studies were also excluded if experiences of chest masculinization could not be separated from other forms of care. Search Strategy EMBASE, MEDLINE, Web of Science, SCOPUS, PsycINFO, Social Sciences Citation Index, CINAHL, and EBSCOhost LGBTQ+ Source were searched in August 2025. The search terms were developed using the Population, Exposure, Outcomes framework (Supplementary Material). 25 Given the previously described difficulties in locating qualitative studies, 22 we screened the reference lists of all included studies for additional research. Gray literature except university doctoral theses was excluded due to lack of peer-review. Screening All titles and abstracts were screened in duplicate using Covidence. 26 Discrepancies were resolved through discussion. Full texts were screened by three independent reviewers. Quality Appraisal The quality of included studies was assessed using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) checklist. 27 Quality assessment was used solely to inform confidence in our findings; it was not used to exclude studies.28,29 Data Analysis Data were extracted by three reviewers and included study characteristics and participant demographics. Primary data (eg, quotations, survey responses, field notes) were entered verbatim into NVivo15 for qualitative analysis (QSR International, MA, USA). Thematic synthesis was conducted by three independent reviewers following the three-step approach described by Thomas and Harden, which consists of three analytical stages: (1) line-by-line coding of primary study findings, (2) development of descriptive themes, and (3) generation of analytical themes. 22 The themes and subthemes derived from the main themes were summarized as text, with the writing of this publication representing the final analytic stage. 30 Themes were constructed as patterns of shared meaning, therefore the importance of a theme was not contingent on how frequently it occurred, but if it captured something of relevance to the research. Even themes which appeared infrequently across studies were considered analytically significant and considered for inclusion in our analysis. 30 Reflexivity Our research team includes individuals with diverse gender identities, sexualities, and backgrounds, including genderqueer/nonbinary, cisgender women, and cisgender men. Multiple authors identify as part of the LGBTQ2+/queer community. We acknowledge that qualitative research is inherently subjective, and our findings are shaped by our varied personal experiences. As described by Braun and Clarke (2022), our findings are inherently interpreted through the lens of the authors’ lived experiences. A continuous reflexive process was used throughout, including reflexive journaling and team-based reflexive discussion. 31 Results A total of 2201 records were identified, after de-duplication 1348 reccords were screened, and 396 underwent full-text screening. Of these, 60 studies met the inclusion criteria and were included in our qualitative synthesis.14,33-91 Reasons for exclusion are detailed in the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) flow diagram (Figure 1). 32 Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses 32 Flow Diagram. SSCI, Social Science Citation Index; CINAHL, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature. Study Characteristics Of the 60 studies which met inclusion criteria, 35 were qualitative,14,33-39,41,44-46,49-52,61-65,67,68,70,72,73,75-77,79,80,86-88,90 and 25 were mixed methods.40,42,43,47,48,53-60,66,69,71,74,78,81-85,89,91 Included studies were published between 2009 and 2025 with study participants recruited primarily from North America14,33,34,36,37,39-42,44-56,59-62,64,65,67,70,71,73,74,76-81,83-86,88 (n = 44), Europe36,43,44,60,62,69,70,76,88 (n = 9), Oceania58,60,62,90 (Australia) (n = 4), Asia33,73 (n = 2), South America 59 (n = 1), and Africa 67 (n = 1). Four studies recruited participants from the internet39,64,83,91 (Table 1). The quality of included studies is presented below (Table 2). Table 1.Characteristics of Included Studies.Authors (Year)CountrySampleAgeStudy DesignAnalytic StrategyRaner et al (2024) 14 Canadan = 108Transgender man (n = 37)Nonbinary (n = 71)25.54 ± 8.230.90 ± 9.6Cross-sectional surveyAgarwal and Dhillon (2023) 33 Indian = 222 and 26Semistructured interviewsInterpretive phenomenological analysisBauer et al (2009) 34 Canadan = 8518+Focus groupsGrounded theoryBell and Purkey (2019) 35 Canadan = 11Transgender man (n = 4)Transgender woman (n = 6)Gender diverse (n = 1)46.5 (range 24-64)Semistructured interviewsPhenomenological approachBjørnson and Sagbakken (2023) 36 Norwayn = 10 NRInterviewsSymbolic interactionismBoyer et al (2023) 37 USAn = 30 NRSemistructured interviewsContent analysisBridgwater et al (2024) 38 Canadan = 10Transgender man (n = 1)Transgender woman (n = 2)Gender diverse (n = 7)22.9 (range 18-34)Focus groups and semistructured interviewsQualitative descriptionCavic et al (2025) 39 Online250 videosNRTikTok videosReflexive thematic analysisChang et al (2023) 40 USAn = 182Male (n = 18)Female (n = 37)Transgender man (n = 35)Transgender woman (n = 51)Nonbinary (n = 28)Genderqueer (n = 2)Genderfluid (n = 1)Gender nonconforming (n = 2)Agender (n = 1)Other (n = 7)33.8 ± 12.1SurveyChristiano et al (2024) 41 USATransgender man (n = 53)30.3 ± 12.2Semistructured interviewsContent analysisCrabtree et al (2024) 42 USAn = 150Transgender man (n = 129)Transgender woman (n = 21)18.6Anonymous surveyPhenomenologyD'Angelo et al (2025) 43 USAn = 28Male (n = 9)Transgender man (n = 18)Nonbinary (n = 1)34.53 ± 8.11Semistructured interviewsReflexive thematic approachde Brouwer et al (2021) 44 EUn = 257Transgender man (n = 122)Transgender woman (n = 119)Nonbinary/other (n = 16) NRSurveyPhenomenologydel Mar Pastor Bravo and Linander (2024) 45 Sweden, Spainn = 34Transgender man (n = 22)Transgender woman (n = 6)Nonbinary (n = 6)15-26Semistructured interviewsAbductive approachDozier (2023) 46 USAn = 30Transgender man (n = 15)Male (n = 7)Nonbinary (n = 4)Other (n = 4)31 (range 21-61)Semistructured interviewsInductive thematic analysisDupasquier et al (2025) 47 Canadan = 21Transgender man (n = 9)Transgender woman (n = 7)Nonbinary/Agender/Genderqueer (n = 5)38.7 ± 12.4 (range 24-59)Focus groupsSocial constructionism and reflexive thematic analysisEl-Hadi et al (2018) 48 USA, Canadan = 32Transgender man (n = 12)Transgender woman (n = 20)36 (range 18-81)SurveyFerrin et al (2024) 49 USAn = 50Transgender man (n = 20)Nonbinary/Genderqueer/Gender nonconforming (n = 24)Agender (n = 3)Other (n = 3) NRSurveyInductive thematic analysisFrohard-Dourlent et al (2020) 50 Canadan = 35Transgender woman (n = 19)Transgender man (n = 13)Nonbinary (n = 8)24-69InterviewsThematic analysisGillani et al (2025) 51 USAn = 35Transgender man (n = 11)Transgender woman (n = 16)Nonbinary (n = 7)Other (n = 1)18-25 (n = 4)26-40 (n = 24)41-60 (n = 7)Focus groupsReflexive thematic analysisGoetz and Arcomano (2023) 52 USA, Canadan = 54Transgender man/trans masculine (n = 17)Transgender woman/transfeminine (n = 6)Nonbinary (n = 9)Transgender nonbinary (n = 3)Nonbinary trans masculine (n = 8)Nonbinary trans feminine (n = 3)Nonbinary genderqueer (n = 5)Trans masculine genderqueer (n = 1)Nonbinary genderfluid (n = 2)29 ± 9 (range 18-59)Semistructured interviewsHarry-Hernandez et al (2020) 53 USAn = 37Transgender man (n = 12)Transgender woman (n = 11)Nonbinary/genderqueer (n = 14)18-21 (n = 10)22-25 (n = 5)26-29 (n = 6)30–33 (n = 9)34–37 (n = 4)38+ (n = 6)Semistructured In-depth interviewsHoughtaling (2023) 54 USAn = 816-20Advisory groupHu et al (2023) 55 USAn = 67Nonbinary (assigned male at birth) (n = 57)Nonbinary (assigned female at birth) (n = 10)30.7 ± 11.3Retrospective chart reviewHu et al (2025) 56 USAn = 14Assigned female at birth (n = 9)Assigned male at birth (n = 5)32.5 (range 21-60)Semistructured interviewsInterpretive descriptionKatz-Wise et al (2017) 57 USAn = 16Transgender boy (n = 9)Transgender girl (n = 5)gender fluid (n = 1)Girlish boy (n = 1)7-18Semistructured interviewsGrounded theoryKloer et al (2023) 58 USAn = 246Transgender man (n = 56)Transgender woman(n = 80)Male (n = 17)Female (n = 31)gender nonconforming (n = 38)Genderqueer (n = 23)Agender (n = 1)42Survey and telephone interviewsThematic analysisLee et al (2019) 59 Australian = 10Transgender man (n = 4)Nonbinary (n = 6)18-36Semistructured interviewsExploratory inductive thematic analysisLerri et al (2025) 60 Braziln = 2026.5 (range 18−37)InterviewsContent analysisLittman (2021) 61 USA, Canada, Australia, UKn = 100Assigned female at birth (n = 69)Assigned male at birth (n = 31)29.2 ± 9.1SurveyMacCormick et al (2024) 62 Canadan = 21Transgender man (n = 11)Transgender woman (n = 3)Nonbinary/Genderqueer (n = 7)18-29 (n = 9)30-39 (n = 9)≥40 (n = 3)Semistructured interviewsQualitative description and phenomenologyMacDonald et al (2016) 63 North America, EU, and AustraliaTransgender man (n = 22)24-50Semistructured interviewsQualitative and interpretive description methodologyMakhoul et al (2023) 64 USAn = 3634 (range 25-51)Semistructured interviewsGrounded theory approachMartin and Coolhart (2022) 65 Onlinen = 10Transgender man (n = 6)Transgender woman (n = 3)Nonbinary (n = 1)39.7 ± 15.6 (range 24-69)Semistructured interviewsInterpretive phenomenologyMathis (2021) 66 USAn = 22Male (n = 9)Female (n = 8)Transgender woman (n = 3)Intersex (n = 1)Nonbinary (n = 1)19-72Semistructured interviewsTransformative paradigm, discursive aggression, and queer of color critiqueMcTernan et al (2020) 67 USAn = 776Transgender woman (n = 665)Nonbinary (n = 111)32.1 ± 8.7 (range 15-61)28.7 ± 9.8 (range 15-68)Semistructured interviewsNRMiller (2019) 68 South African = 6Transgender man (n = 4)Transgender woman (n = 2)30 ± 3.69 (range 26-35)Survey and retrospective chart reviewSocial constructionismMousavian et al (2024) 69 USAn = 15Transgender man (n = 5)Transgender woman (n = 6)Nonbinary (n = 4) NRSemistructured interviewsGrounded theoryNieder et al (2021) 70 Germanyn = 75Transgender man (n = 59)Transgender woman (n = 11)Nonbinary (n = 5)12-21SurveyCross-sectionalPipkin and Clarke (2024) 71 UKn = 6Man (n = 2)Transgender man (n = 2)Nonbinary (n = 2)23-41Focus groupsInductive thematic analysisPoudrier et al (2019) 72 USATransgender man (n = 58) NRSurveyCross-sectionalPuckett et al (2018) 73 USAn = 221Transgender man (n = 100)Transgender woman (n = 66)Nonbinary (n = 55)28.4Diaries/surveyGrounded theoryRaghuram (2024) 74 Indian = 4Transgender man (n = 1)Transgender woman (n = 2)Nonbinary (n = 1) NRSemistructured interviewsExploratory case studyRoller et al (2015) 75 USAn = 25Assigned male at birth (n = 5)Assigned female at birth (n = 20)21-64Semistructured interviewsGrounded theoryRoss et al (2024) 76 Amsterdamn = 2138.1Semistructured interviews and focus groupsThematic analysisRoss et al (2016) 77 Canadan = 10Transgender woman (n = 4)Transgender man (n = 1)Friends/Family (n = 3)Healthcare provider (n = 2)18-65Semistructured interviewsCase studySchafer et al (2024) 78 USAn = 302Nonbinary (n = 38)Transgender man (n = 264)28 ± 726 ± 8Retrospective survey studySlothouber (2024) 79 Canadan = 19Assigned female at birth (n = 14)Assigned male at birth (n = 5)Male (n = 1)Demiboy (n = 1)Female (n = 2)Transgender woman (n = 2)Nonbinary/Gender nonconforming/Genderqueer (n = 10)Genderqueer only (n = 3)33 (range 22-59)Semistructured interviewsInterpretive qualitative studyTrans and queer theoryFat studiesSmith et al (2022) 80 USAn = 15Transgender man (n = 7)Transgender woman (n = 4)Nonbinary (n = 4)NRSemistructured interviewsConsensual qualitative researchSood et al (2021) 81 USATransgender man (n = 2)16 and 17Case seriesSun et al (2025) 82 USAn = 59Nonbinary (n = 11)Transgender woman (n = 20)Transgender man (n = 24)Gender nonconforming (n = 1)Other (n = 3)24-40SurveySun et al (2025) 83 Online604 posts and comments NRReddit content analysisInductive thematic analysisTirrell et al (2023) 84 USAn = 10327SurveyTristani-Firouzi et al (2022) 85 USAn = 456Transgender man (n = 298)Nonbinary (n = 158)2827Anonymous surveyValente et al (2023) 86 USAn = 13Transgender woman (n = 5)Women (n = 3)Man (n = 2)Nonbinary (n = 2)Genderqueer (n = 1)31.3 ± 10.7 (range 18-52)Semistructured interviewsDescriptive phenomenologyValiquette (2024) 87 Canadan = 12Transgender man (n = 1)Transgender woman (n = 5)Trans masculine (n = 1)Nonbinary (n = 2)Genderfluid (n = 1)Genderqueer (n = 1)Genderqueer trans masculine nonbinary (n = 1)20-29 (n = 6)30-39 (n = 3)50+ (n = 1)Observation and interviewInstitutional ethnographyvon Vogelsang et al (2016) 88 Swedenn = 6NRSemistructured interviewsManifest qualitative content analysisWeixel et al (2025) 89 USAn = 50Transgender man (n = 45)Nonbinary (n = 4)Cisgender (n = 1)20.0 ± 2.32 (range 16-25)Chart review and surveyWindt et al (2026) 90 Australian = 9Transgender man (n = 5)Transgender woman (n = 2)Nonbinary (n = 1)Cisgender woman (n = 1)49.7 ± 11.5 (range 34-67)Semistructured interviewsExploratoryYang et al (2025) 91 OnlineNRNRReddit commentsWord cloud Characteristics of Included Studies. Table 2.Critical Appraisal Skills Programme Qualitative Studies Checklist.StudyClear Statement of Research Aims?Appropriate Qualitative Methodology?Appropriate Research Design?Appropriate Recruitment Strategy?Appropriate Data Collection?Adequate Consideration of Participant Researcher Relationship?Adequate Consideration of Ethical Issues?Data Analysis Sufficiently Rigorous?Clear Statement of Findings?Is the Research Valuable?Raner et al(2024) 14 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesAgarwal and Dhillon (2023) 33 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesBauer et al (2009) 34 yesyesyessomewhatyessomewhatyesyesyesyesBell and Purkey (2019) 35 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesBjørnson and Sagbakken (2023) 36 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesBoyer et al (2023) 37 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesBridgwater et al (2024) 38 yessomewhatsomewhatsomewhatsomewhatnoyessomewhatyesyesCavic et al (2025) 39 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesChang et al (2023) 40 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesChristiano et al (2024) 41 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesCrabtree et al (2024) 42 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesD'Angelo et al (2025) 43 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesde Brouwer et al (2021) 44 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesdel Mar Pastor Bravo and Linander (2024) 45 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesDozier (2023) 46 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesDupasquier et al (2025) 47 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesEl-Hadi et al (2018) 48 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesFerrin et al (2024) 49 yesnononononoyesnoyesyesFrohard-Dourlent et al (2020) 50 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesGillani et al (2025) 51 yessomewhatsomewhatyessomewhatnoyessomewhatyesyesGoetz and Arcomano (2023) 52 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesHarry-Hernandez et al (2020) 53 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesHoughtaling (2023) 54 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesHu et al (2023) 55 yessomewhatsomewhatsomewhatsomewhatnoyessomewhatyesyesHu et al (2025) 56 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesKatz-Wise et al (2017) 57 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesKloer et al (2023) 58 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesLee et al (2019) 59 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesLerri et al (2025) 60 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesLittman (2021) 61 somewhatsomewhatnonosomewhatnosomewhatnosomewhatsomewhatMacCormick et al (2024) 62 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesMacDonald et al (2016) 63 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesMakhoul et al (2023) 64 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesMartin and Coolhart (2022) 65 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesMathis (2021) 66 yesyesyesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesMcTernan et al (2020) 67 yesnononononoyesnoyesyesMiller (2019) 68 yesyesyesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesMousavian et al (2024) 69 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesNieder et al (2021) 70 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesPipkin and Clarke (2024) 71 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesPoudrier et al (2019) 72 yesnonoyesyessomewhatyessomewhatyesyesPuckett et al (2018) 73 yessomewhatsomewhatsomewhatsomewhatyessomewhatsomewhatsomewhatyesRaghuram (2024) 74 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesRoller et al (2015) 75 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesRoss et al (2024) 76 yesyesyesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesRoss et al (2016) 77 yesnonoyessomewhatnoyesnoyesyesSchafer et al (2024) 78 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesSlothouber (2024) 79 yessomewhatsomewhatsomewhatsomewhatnoyessomewhatyesyesSmith et al (2022) 80 yesnononononoyesnoyesyesSood et al (2021) 81 yesnononononoyessomewhatyesyesSun et al (2025) 82 yessomewhatsomewhatyessomewhatnoyessomewhatyesyesSun et al (2025) 83 yesnonoyesnonoyesnoyesyesTirrell et al (2023) 84 yesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesyesyesTristani-Firouzi et al (2022) 85 yessomewhatsomewhatsomewhatsomewhatnoyessomewhatyesyesValente et al (2023) 86 yesyesyesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesValiquette (2024) 87 yesyesyesyesyesyesyessomewhatyesyesvon Vogelsang et al (2016) 88 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesWeixel et al (2025) 89 yessomewhatyesyesyessomewhatyessomewhatyesyesWindt et al (2026) 90 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesYang et al (2025) 91 yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesNote: This checklist provides a structured method of appraising the methodological rigor and validity of qualitative research. Adapted from the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) Qualitative Checklist27 © CASP, licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/). Formatting was modified and wording was changed to present findings in chart format. NR, not reported. Critical Appraisal Skills Programme Qualitative Studies Checklist. Note: This checklist provides a structured method of appraising the methodological rigor and validity of qualitative research. Adapted from the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) Qualitative Checklist27 © CASP, licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/). Formatting was modified and wording was changed to present findings in chart format. NR, not reported. Charting a Course The analytical theme, charting a course, developed across three subthemes: confusion,14,37,46,48,51,52,62,64,73,80 financial strain,14,37-39,43,46,48,52,62,64,68,73,79,80,84,85,87,90,91 and community support.33,37,39,43,45-47,51,62,66,68,71,73,75,77,84,86 This theme appeared in 28 studies and was drawn from the experiences of at least 1358 patients as well as analysis of digital media (Table 3). Table 3.Themes and Subthemes.ThemeSubthemeParticipants (n)Articles (n)Articles1. Charting a CourseConfusion58210 14,37,46,48,51,52,62,64,73,80 Financial Strain119019 14,37-39,43,46,48,52,62,64,68,73,79,80,84,85,87,90,91 Community Support60717 33,37,39,43,45-47,51,62,66,68,71,73,75,77,84,86 Total:135828 14,33,37-39,43,45-48,51,52,62,64,66,68,71,73,75,77,79,80,84-87,90,91 2. Interacting with ProvidersNegative Experiences75721 14,34,35,37,38,40,43,45-47,51,52,54,59,62,64,69,77,80,81,87 Gatekeepers136126 14,35,38,45-48,50-52,54,55,57,62,63,71,73-75,80,84,85,87,88,90,91 Performing Transness127320 14,35,45,47,50-52,54,55,57,62,63,73,75,80,84,85,87,90,91 Protective Factors21912 38,41,47,50,59,62,65,69,77,80,86,88 Total:183538 14,34,35,37,38,40,41,43,45-48,50-52,54,55,57,59,62-65,69,71,73-75,77,80,81,84-88,90,91 3. Surgical goal setting55014 14,38,47-50,52,55,72,75,79,82,87,91 4. Adjusting to OneselfRelief66915 33,36,39,41,42,44,48,52,56,65,68,72,76,81,83 Unmet Expectations5938 42,44,52,56,66,70,76,83 Lifelong Process1132 52,82 Total82518 33,36,39,41,42,44,48,52,56,65,66,68,70,72,76,81-83 Themes and Subthemes. Confusion Study participants consistently reported uncertainty about where to start, how to locate surgeons, and how to navigate the insurance and referral processes when accessing gender-affirming care.14,37,46,48,51,52,62,64,73,80 “It wasn’t that the steps were overly difficult. Half the battle was figuring out what the steps were.” 62 Other challenges included unclear timelines for surgery approvals, denials, and short validity periods for funding, where something as small as missing a single form could delay surgery indefinitely. 69 Socioeconomic factors shaped the ability of patients to manage these barriers. 56 Financial Across studies, cost frequently arose as one of the most significant and persistent barriers to access.14,37-39,43,46,48,52,62,64,68,73,79,80,84,85,87,90,91 Indirect expenses such as parking and unpaid recovery time off work created substantial challenges. These were compounded for patients in rural settings, with some participants reported traveling hours for their appointments. 73 Participants described concerns related to two-tier healthcare systems, in which publicly funded care was perceived as inferior to private options. 68 Community Connections with people who had already transitioned helped participants navigate their own processes. Peer networks, online forums, and social media groups were frequently described as primary sources of information and support.33,37,45 Providers were identified using word-of-mouth recommendations, with positive and negative reputations circulating through informal networks. “It was like hunting down information and asking people different questions about their experiences with different surgeons and different procedures.” 51 Informal and formal navigators such as parents, friends, and specialized LGBTQ+ health centers provided important assistance. Patients relied on professional contacts with relevant expertise to appeal denials or secure coverage, for example. 46 Patients consistently reported smoother access to care when working within their support networks.33,37,39,43,45,62,86 Interactions with Providers The theme of Interactions with Providers was the most prevalent theme identified in the present review. This analytical theme developed across four subthemes: negative experiences,4,34,35,37,38,40,43,45-47,51,52,54,59,62,64,69,77,80,81,87 gatekeepers,14,35,38,45-48,50-52,54,55,57,62,63,71,73-75,80,84,85,87,88,90,91 performing transness,14,35,45,47,50-52,54,55,57,62,63,73,75,80,84,85,87,90,91 and protective factors.38,41,47,50,59,62,65,69,77,80,86,88 It appeared across 38 studies and drew on the experiences of at least 1835 participants as well as digital media (Table 3). Negative Experiences Across studies, healthcare encounters were marked by limited provider knowledge and avoidance when addressing trans-specific health concerns. This left many patients feeling dismissed or placed in the uncomfortable position of having to explain basic aspects of transgender care to their providers. Patients were often redirected to specialists because physicians were “not comfortable working with trans patients,” noting that even when information was offered, some providers “had no interest to learn.” 34 Being repeatedly “passed along” between providers disrupted continuity of care and, in many cases, created the ongoing fear that physicians would refuse to provide necessary care.34,38,54 Negative encounters ranged from invasive questioning to perceived or anticipated discrimination.40,62 Misgendering contributed to feelings of invisibility, frustration, and mistrust, particularly for racialized patients, and patients who were early in their transition. Experiences of trauma in healthcare settings shaped subsequent engagement with healthcare providers. Participants reported anticipating transphobia during routine appointments, which led them to avoid seeking medical care.38,42,55 The cumulative effect of this trauma was heightened vigilance and stress during healthcare interactions. Gatekeepers This theme illustrates the perception of healthcare providers as gatekeepers. Patients described a “power imbalance to deny or not deny.” 91 This was articulated as a loss of agency; transgender individuals did not feel capable of asserting themselves in assessments because they were afraid of being denied care. 50 Patients contrasted the lack of agency in these assessments with the autonomy afforded to cisgender individuals undergoing elective procedures, noting that transgender people are often treated as needing protection from their own decisions. 50 This fear led some patients to tell assessors what they wanted to hear, including altering information about themselves, such as sexual orientation and mental health, to avoid being deemed ineligible.47,90 This was based on the belief that many providers based approval for gender-affirming surgery on their own biased judgement, as opposed to following guidelines Performing Transness Study participants often described the need to perform a stereotypical or textbook version of transness in order to satisfy assessors. This was an active performance; participants practiced “fake interviews” with peers to ensure they said the “right things.”35,48,62 This experience was widely described as alienating and emotionally draining. Nonbinary patients frequently reported feeling pressured to conform to binary narratives in order to access surgery. 51 Many hid their identity to meet assessors’ expectations: “I had an expectation to play the system; resulted in me coming out as a trans male, despite that wasn’t how I identified so that I could get the surgery I needed.” 47 Nonbinary participants also critiqued the rigid expectation to present a “textbook” transgender narrative, which often forced them to compromise on their care goals. 54 “Many healthcare providers I encountered seem to have a view that trans people are ‘switching genders’ and still work within a binary system of male/female. I was very scared that I would not present as ‘male enough’ to qualify for surgery and funding.” 14 Protective Factors Within this broader pattern of deficit, patients also identified characteristics of positive interactions with healthcare providers. Healthcare providers’ knowledge and attitudes fundamentally shaped transgender patients’ capacity to move through healthcare systems. 86 Physicians who were “open-minded and happy to learn things to fill in their gaps” or who possessed strong medical knowledge coupled with cultural awareness were viewed as facilitating affirming and navigable care experiences.59,86 Similarly, positive surgical readiness assessments felt like nonconfrontational conversations, with positive surgical assessors described as communicative, accepting, and knowledgeable. Healthcare provider competence was observed to foster trust and enable smoother navigation of the care pathway. Surgical Goal Setting The analytical theme, Surgical Goal Setting, appeared in only 14 studies and drew from the experiences of 550 participants, in addition to digital media and forum posts.14,38,47-50,52,55,72,75,79,82,87,91 Surgical Goal Setting drew solely on studies from Canada and the USA (Table 3). There were distinct differences in surgical goals between binary transgender men and gender-diverse study participants. Binary transgender men predominantly pursued chest masculinization surgery with the goal of achieving a traditionally masculine chest, as one participant explained, “I wanted a chest to look like a normal cis male … Specifically for me that included smaller nipples and areolas.” 14 In contrast, gender diverse (or nonbinary) individuals demonstrated more variability in their surgical goals. While some wanted a flat chest, others aimed for an androgynous or flexible appearance that did not conform to traditional masculine or feminine ideals. Surgical goals were often driven by a desire to reduce dysphoria and to maintain a body congruent with a nonbinary identity rather than to conform to binary norms. 52 Some nonbinary individuals elected to partially conserve breast mass in order to present flexibly. 14 Nonbinary participants’ approaches to nipple sensation were also highly individualized. Some nonbinary participants valued the preservation of nipple sensation, while others opted for no nipples entirely.52,91 In contrast, binary transgender men often regarded the preservation or loss of nipple sensation as secondary to attaining the desired flat, masculine appearance. Some patients were hesitant to pursue surgery due to the anticipated challenges of meeting BMI cutoffs.79,82,90 Reduction mammaplasty was sometimes considered as an alternative or interim procedure to full chest masculinization surgery, particularly when social or logistical barriers limited access.38,47,75 Adjusting to Oneself This analytical theme captured how individuals responded to the aftermath of chest masculinization, and developed across three subthemes: relief,33,36,39,41,42,44,48,52,56,65,68,72,76,81,83 unmet expectations,42,44,52,56,66,70,76,83 and lifelong process.52,82 This theme appeared in 18 studies and drew on the experiences of 825 participants as well as digital media and forum posts (Table 3). Relief Study participants described the profound relief of no longer experiencing longstanding gender dysphoria.42,48 Beyond alleviating dysphoria, participants also described chest masculinization surgery as a turning point with, “all these things are opening up for me.” 76 Unmet Expectations Despite largely positive experiences, a small number of patients reported unmet expectations. Dissatisfaction often stemmed from esthetic outcomes or lack of postoperative support. 44 Participants whose surgical outcomes were disappointing reported continued bodily incongruence and dysphoria. Participants also described feeling lost when coordinating their follow-up appointments. Lifelong Process Finally, postoperative experiences were overwhelmingly positive, consistent with quantitative research demonstrating the benefits of gender-affirming surgery. 6 For many, surgery was not viewed as an endpoint but as part of an ongoing process of identity integration. 52 While some participants worried about surgical scars being noticeable markers, others expressed pride in their recovery and in visible signs of surgical transformation. Several patients also described a deepened sense of belonging within transgender communities. This belonging is outlined by one participant: “I’ll always be trans, right? There's no end point to that … my body's never going to be a normative one. And that's cool. That's beautiful.” 52 Discussion This systematic review and thematic synthesis explored the lived experiences of TGD individuals throughout the process of undergoing chest masculinization surgery (Figure 2). The experiences described in this review are intrinsically linked to marginalization. Intersectionality, a theoretical framework developed by Crenshaw in the 1980s, 92 provides a lens through which we interpret the compounding nature of the disadvantages experienced by TGD people as they navigate access to gender-affirming care.93,94 Similarly, minority stress theory posits that the chronic exposure to discrimination increases stress, leading to health disparities among marginalized populations.95-98 This was demonstrated in our findings, where the widespread lack of formal training for providers may compound the stress of seeking gender-affirming care, with each repeated negative experience priming an individual to be more harmed by a single interaction.99,100 Conceptual relationships among analytical themes shaping access to gender-affirming chest masculinization surgery. The area of each circle is proportional to the number of studies cited for each theme and subtheme. BMI, body mass index. Despite research showing that gender-affirming procedures improve quality of life, reduce gender incongruence, and are cost-effective, these procedures are subject to extensive debate and insurance denial rates remain high, which particularly affected participants from the USA.101,102 For context, the median costs for gender-affirming chest-surgery were $29,887 USD, according to a nationwide American survey by Das et al with 90.7% (n = 19,308) covered at least in part by private or public health insurance.103-104 In Canada, masculinizing chest surgery is currently covered nationwide, feminizing chest surgery is covered under limited conditions, while procedures like chest-contouring liposuction or reduction are rarely covered by government insurance.79,104,105 Chest masculinizing procedures are sometimes classified as “reconstructive” or “esthetic,” further affecting coverage. The theme of having to chart a course to access care was evident in the costs incurred. A critical finding of our synthesis is that transgender and nonbinary patients represent populations with often distinct surgical priorities. While transgender men generally sought a traditionally masculine appearance, the goals of gender diverse participants spanned a much wider spectrum. These observations were substantiated by Schafer et al., who found that nonbinary patients frequently request preservation of nipple-areola complexes, small breast mounds, or other androgynous features (such as removal of nipples entirely). 78 When seeking gender-affirming care, the burden of navigation is in and of itself a psychosocial stressor. Previous research has identified the lack of knowledgeable and willing providers as the most pervasive barrier to gender-affirming care, and the scarcity of trained providers results in patients approaching medical encounters with heightened vigilance and mistrust.106,107 This deficit has been recognized by physicians themselves, with many acknowledging a structural failure of medical curricula to equip them with the ability to manage transgender health. 108 Similarly, Mikulak et al record the accounts of providers which closely mirror the descriptive theme of negative experiences developed from accounts of patients, where providers report inadequate training, long waiting lists, and the absence of clear clinical guidelines as central barriers to their ability to provide care. 109 These deficits provide an explanation for the interpersonal strain observed in our synthesis. However, interactions with healthcare providers during the process of obtaining gender-affirming care are fundamentally distinct from interactions in other healthcare contexts. The perception of providers as gatekeepers creates a kind of anticipatory anxiety, where patients feel pressure to present a version of their gender identity that would be deemed acceptable to clinicians or funding bodies. They often concealed the presence or absence of mental health concerns or their sexual orientation to avoid being denied surgery. We note that this expectation to “perform” transness places exceptional emotional strain on nonbinary individuals whose identities do not fit established transformative frameworks. Training healthcare professionals on transgender health was identified as an area likely to be highly impactful across multiple contexts. 110 Patients across studies stressed that the responsibility for education should not have to fall to transgender patients. 50 We note that affirming provider interactions had a significant positive impact. When providers approached care with openness and competence, participants felt validated, informed, and empowered. Improving access therefore requires structural and educational reforms. Based on our findings, we recommend integrating transgender health education across medical training and continuing professional development, specifically with regards to interacting with transgender patients and with respect to the care pathway. As well, we recommend that surgical planning explicitly outline each patient's individual goals, rather than assuming a uniform or binary ideal chest outcome, in order to better support patient-centric care. Limitations Most included studies were conducted in high-income Western countries, limiting applicability to other contexts. CASP appraisal found several methodological limitations such as a lack of detail regarding recruitment strategies. 27 Many studies (n = 14 not at all, n = 20 somewhat) did not detail author positionality, which may further cisnormative assumptions. In addition, our study focuses on patient experiences and does not assess the experiences of healthcare providers themselves. Healthcare practitioners who provide gender-affirming care face substantial challenges, including lack of institutional resources, administrative and legal pressures, evolving standards of care, and threats to personal or professional safety. 111 These challenges may contribute to care environments where patient needs and provider well-being are at odds. Our current study assesses just one of the populations impacted by barriers to care. Future work assessing the perspectives of care providers is warranted to fully access to and delivery of gender-affirming care. Conclusion The experiences of TGD individuals accessing masculinizing chest surgery are determined by structural barriers, the interpersonal dynamics between patients and providers, and also by the diverse goals and identities of TGD individuals. Informed providers help TGD patients navigate the system; they are able to chart a course for their patients. The four analytical themes which emerged through our analysis identify persistent structural barriers to care but also highlight the resilience and resourcefulness of TGD patients. Supplemental Material sj-docx-1-psg-10.1177_22925503261477385 - Supplemental material for Experiences of Transgender and Gender Diverse Patients in Accessing Gender-Affirming Chest Masculinization: A Systematic Review and Qualitative Thematic Synthesis of the Literature Supplemental material, sj-docx-1-psg-10.1177_22925503261477385 for Experiences of Transgender and Gender Diverse Patients in Accessing Gender-Affirming Chest Masculinization: A Systematic Review and Qualitative Thematic Synthesis of the Literature by Emma Lim, Justin Haas, Precious Adekoya, Sophia Hou, Kathleen Armstrong, Helene Retrouvey and Ammara Ghumman in Plastic Surgery