Optimizing oil productivity by immiscible CO2 and N2 injection comparison of the Asmari formation in southeastern Iraq Authors: Ahmed N. Al-Dujaili, Maaly S. Asad, Mustafa M. Hashim, Najah Saeed, Nurbol Tileuberdi, Zahraa Ayad Mahdi, Mohammed Thamer Jaafar, Sundus Hameed Mousa Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Gas injection is a fundamental process for hydrocarbon recovery, whereby gas is injected into the reservoir to maintain pressure and increase production of oil or gas. This study was conducted to investigate the optimization of gas injection, differentiating between the behavior of CO2 and N2, as a potential alternative to water in southern Iraqi fields (the Abu-Ghirab field, particularly) to overcome the water supply shortage as a result of climate change. Techlog, Petrel, and CMG software were utilized to examine the CO2 and N2 behaviour. The increased percentages (CO2 and N2 injection processes) in the oil production rate are 139.45 and 66.6%, respectively. The wells located near the fault section show the best water cut (approximately 18%) among all the wells. The water cut percentages are 520 and 380 for CO2 and N2 injection, respectively, pointing out that the water cut produced by the N2 injection process is higher than that of CO2 by percentage of 36.8. An acute increase in the gas-oil ratio by N2 injection (more than 40 times on average) could result. The wells far away from the fault region have the best performance of gas-oil ratio among all the wells. For the entire field, the oil production rate for the CO2 injection process shows a significant increase in both ultimate and maximum production compared to N2. This could be due to the specifications of crude oil. The sensitivity analysis of the results from CO2 injection for the Asmari formation in Abu-Ghirab for production/injection percentage and water cut shows that the water cut percentage will be acceptable during the first 9 years of the process, with concerns of economic issues due to increasing gas-oil ratio (GOR). Introduction The long-term development strategy for any formation in a specific oilfield aims to maintain sustainable oil production for the maximum duration while considering the uncertainties1. The development plan has to be sufficiently flexible to optimize recovery based on the assessment of new field data and ongoing studies2,3. The field life passes through three eras that represent the oil recovery stages4, including primary (formation pressure is sufficient to extract oil to the surface), secondary (injection of water or gas), and enhanced oil recovery (to extract oil trapped in the pores)5. CO2 injection began in the late 1950s and has garnered increasing attention over the years, particularly as concerns about greenhouse gas emissions, especially CO2, have grown6–8. The USA, with its high levels of CO2 emissions from fossil fuel combustion, has been a significant adopter of CO2 injection. CO2 is captured from various industrial sources and stored in deep geological formations like saline aquifers, depleted oil and gas fields, and coal beds in a process known as Carbon Capture Storage (CCS), aiming to reduce atmospheric CO2 emissions9,10. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA) in 2023, investments in oil and gas extraction were $239 billion. Saturation of oil with CO2 using a higher amount causes mass transfer between phases. Subsequently, leading to condensation of CO2 into the oil phase and vaporization of light and medium components of oil into the gas phase11. Phase diagrams are used to describe the different zones formed during the injection-vaporization process in the reservoir cross-section12 (Fig. 1). The relation between the vapor phase and pressure differs depending on the difference between the CO2 concentration and the critical point13. The volume of the vapor phase is inversely proportional to pressure when the concentration of CO2 is lower than the critical point. Moreover, the vapor phase volume is directly proportional to pressure when the CO2 concentration is above the critical point14.Fig. 1Various oil displacement methods by gas injection12. Various oil displacement methods by gas injection12. The affordability, availability, and anti-corrosivity of Nitrogen are more favourable than those of CO2 and natural gas15,16. N2 stops swelling in clay formations due to its ineffectual characteristics, obviating permeability deterioration, and keeps the rocks stable11. Various methods, including pure nitrogen, nitrogen foam, and nitrogen-water alternative injections that are tailored to different reservoir types for reservoir development17–19. The lower pressure demand to attain the mixture between the injected fluid and crude oil is known as the minimum miscibility pressure (MMP). Experiments, correlations, and the equation of state are the essential procedures to determine MMP20. Temperature and the oil and gas composition are the characteristics that affect MMP. Most correlations consider reservoir temperature, concentration of intermediate components, and the molecular weight of the heavy components21. The unfavourable water outputs, recognized in terms of water cut, in the hydrocarbon extraction process, continue to be one of the hardest factors to manage and overcome22. Many technologies have been studied over the last few years for the injection process in oil reservoirs23, among which injecting hydrocarbon gas, CO2, and N2 are the most promising for secondary and EOR recovery24. Gas has a much higher injectivity compared to water and supplies reservoirs with additional energy25. Gas also tends to affect swelling, oil viscosity, and reduced interfacial tension in miscible injection, which often causes more mobilized oil26. The primary objective of this study is to develop and comparatively evaluate the optimization of gas injection. The novelty of this study is that it represents the first study applied in the Iraqi fields, differentiating between the behaviour of CO2 and N2, as a potential alternative to water in southern Iraqi fields (the Abu-Ghirab field, particularly), to overcome the water supply shortage as a result of climate change. Geological settings The Abu-Ghirab oilfield is located in the Missan governorate, southeast Iraq, near the Iraqi-Iranian border27. It has an axial length of 30 km and a width of 5 km, with coordinates from 3,575,000 to 360,000 Northing lines and 71,000 to 73,500 Easting lines. This field has two domes (northern and southern) with a saddle zone28,29, as shown in Fig. 2.Fig. 2Left- Location of the Abu-Ghirab oilfield30, Right- Contour map of the field27. Left- Location of the Abu-Ghirab oilfield30, Right- Contour map of the field27. The Asmari is considered a heterogeneous, fractured distribution, and implementation of water control formation at a later stage of field development. It is recommended to adopt a cased hole perforation method for vertical and directional wells31. The reservoir consists of Cretaceous and Tertiary carbonate reservoirs within the transitional zone between the Zagros Mountains and the Arabian Plate32. Four sub-units of the Asmari formation in this field can be distinguished33: (A) Jeribe- Euphrates, which is composed mainly of dolomite with some limestone and anhydrite34. (B) Upper Kirkuk is limestone, dolomite, and some sandstone. (C) Buzurgan Member, containing sandstone with dolomite, limestone, and shale in the upper. (D) The Middle-Lower Kirkuk is generally composed of limestone, dolomite, and sandstone35 (Fig. 3).Fig. 3Geological column of Asmari Formation in the Abu-Ghirab oilfield36. Geological column of Asmari Formation in the Abu-Ghirab oilfield36. Figure 4 illustrates that the main reservoir units for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab oilfield are A, B, and C, where the sub-units B2 and B3 have higher effective porosity than the other units, and the sub-units B1, B2, and B3 have a high hydrocarbon volume. Generally, A unit represents the Jeribe-Euphrates formation related to the Miocene era. In contrast, unit B is the Upper-Kirkuk, and unit C represents the Middle-Lower Kirkuk, which are all related to the Oligocene era.Fig. 4Main reservoir units for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab oilfield (a) AG-X3; (b) AG-X7; (c) AG-X1336. Main reservoir units for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab oilfield (a) AG-X3; (b) AG-X7; (c) AG-X1336. Methodology Data The data from six wells were utilized (AG-X5, X9, X1, X7, X4, and X35), which include porosity, permeability, and water saturation logs using wireline and core data, PVT data for the field, and daily production of these wells. Analysis of core data reveals that the reservoir properties in Section B are significantly better than those in Section A. Section A has an average porosity of 0.088 and an average permeability of 10.74 mD., classifying it as a low-porosity, medium-to-low-permeability reservoir. Section B has an average porosity of 0.186% and an average permeability of 268.5 mD., classifying it as a medium-porosity, medium-to-high-permeability reservoir (Table 1). A 3-D geologic model was constructed for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab Field by the Petrel™ (Fig. 5).Table 1Formation reservoir property statistics (from core analysis) for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab oilfield. (Structurally, average).FormationAverage porosity (%)Average permeability (mD)Reservoir typeA19.0115.42Low porosity, medium permeabilityA26.8517.00Low porosity, medium permeabilityA39.724.50Low porosity, low permeabilityA8.8110.61Low porosity, medium to low permeabilityB113.630.50Mesoporous, MesopermeableB218.5122.14Mesoporous, high porosity and permeabilityB314.8114.92Mesoporous, MesopermeableB418.0494.5Mesoporous, high porosity and permeabilityB16.83268.5Mesoporous, medium-to-high permeabilityFig. 5Reservoir simulation setup, (a) Petrophysical properties according to the depth, (b) Relative permeability of oil and water saturation from Special core analysis (SCAL), (c) capillary pressure models from SCAL, (d) Initial conditions according to the well reports, (e) Relative permeability of gas and gas saturation, (f) Fluid properties from laboratory tests, (g) PVT data from core analysis, (h) Pressure and solution gas-oil ratio and oil formation volume factor, (i) Pressure and viscosity of oil and gas, and (j) Pressure and compressibility gas factor. Table 1Formation reservoir property statistics (from core analysis) for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab oilfield. (Structurally, average).FormationAverage porosity (%)Average permeability (mD)Reservoir typeA19.0115.42Low porosity, medium permeabilityA26.8517.00Low porosity, medium permeabilityA39.724.50Low porosity, low permeabilityA8.8110.61Low porosity, medium to low permeabilityB113.630.50Mesoporous, MesopermeableB218.5122.14Mesoporous, high porosity and permeabilityB314.8114.92Mesoporous, MesopermeableB418.0494.5Mesoporous, high porosity and permeabilityB16.83268.5Mesoporous, medium-to-high permeability Formation reservoir property statistics (from core analysis) for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab oilfield. (Structurally, average). Reservoir simulation setup, (a) Petrophysical properties according to the depth, (b) Relative permeability of oil and water saturation from Special core analysis (SCAL), (c) capillary pressure models from SCAL, (d) Initial conditions according to the well reports, (e) Relative permeability of gas and gas saturation, (f) Fluid properties from laboratory tests, (g) PVT data from core analysis, (h) Pressure and solution gas-oil ratio and oil formation volume factor, (i) Pressure and viscosity of oil and gas, and (j) Pressure and compressibility gas factor. Methods Geologic model by Petrel™ The Asmari Formation in the Abu-Ghirab field consists of three main zones (A, B, and C). In this model, the zones were subdivided into eight zones (three for A, four for B, and one for C). The geologic model was simulated to create the porosity, permeability, and water saturation models37. Geologic model by CMG™ The geologic model was transformed into the CMG TM to apply two scenarios: the first for Carbon dioxide and the second for Nitrogen. The injection rate for each well was 10 × 106 ft3/day with total injection rate equal to 80 × 106 ft3/day for the period between 2021 and 2036. The reservoir simulation setup was completed in Petrel™. Relative permeability curves, capillary pressure models, boundary conditions, and other properties are shown in Fig. 5. The eight injection wells were arranged as in Fig. 6. The data were simulated using IMEX (Implicit–Explicit Reservoir Simulator) in the SMG™, since PVT/EOS model was used for miscible gas injection, near-critical reservoirs, or compositionally sensitive cases, a black-oil approach yields overly simplistic and potentially inaccurate results, therefore there is no need for PVT/EOS model.Fig. 6The wells under study and injection wells in the CMG model. The wells under study and injection wells in the CMG model. Results and discussion After selecting the locations of the injection wells, as in Fig. 4, two scenarios were applied in the same procedure for CO2 and N2 injection for reservoir B in the Asmari formation. According to the available production data, the simulation process started in 2001 and stopped in 2021 for the primary recovery. The injection process began in 2021 and will continue until 2036 in two scenarios, first for CO2 injection and second for N2. Scenario 1- CO2 injection The injection process of CO2 through the eight wells shows different behaviour in oil production rates (Fig. 7). The wells on the flanks (X1 and X35) tended to have a higher production rate (over 5000 bbl/day) than the wells on the crest (X4, X5, and X7), while the well AG-X9, which is located near the fault section, shows the worst behaviour during the injection period with the less production rate at the end of the 2036.Fig. 7Oil production rates for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by CO2 injection (2021–2036). Oil production rates for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by CO2 injection (2021–2036). The comparison between the oil production rates for the wells under study for both primary recovery and CO2 injection periods indicates that the wells (X1 and X35) have the best performance in both periods. That refers to the good performance for CO2 injection when the wells are tending to the southwest near the fault region. This will be essential for the next drilling operations and for future development (Fig. 8).Fig. 8Oil production rate for all the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by CO2 injection (2021–2036). Oil production rate for all the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by CO2 injection (2021–2036). The water cut percentages for the wells (Fig. 9) illustrate that the well AG-X9, which is located near the fault section, shows the best water cut (approximately 0.18) among all the wells. In addition, the water cut increased later than the other wells (started in 2027). That is due to the well location near the fault region and on the flank of the field.Fig. 9Water cut for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by CO2 injection (2021–2036). Water cut for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by CO2 injection (2021–2036). Scenario 2- N2 injection The injection process of N2 through the eight wells shows different behaviour in oil production rates compared to CO2 injection (Fig. 10). The maximum oil production rate (5500 bbl/day) was achieved by only one well (AG-X1), while the rest showed low production rates with rapid decline during the injection period, reaching (on average) 750 bbl/day in 2036.Fig. 10Oil production rates for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by N2 injection (2021–2036). Oil production rates for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by N2 injection (2021–2036). The comparison between the oil production rates for the wells under study (for both primary recovery and N2 injection periods) shows the same results as in the CO2 injection process (Fig. 11).Fig. 11Oil production rate for all the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by N2 injection (2021–2036). Oil production rate for all the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by N2 injection (2021–2036). The water cut percentages for the wells (Fig. 12) indicate that well AG-X9 shows the best water cut (up to 0.45) among all the wells. The well AG-X35 increased the water cut later than the other wells (started in 2024). The gas-oil ratio for the wells indicates (Fig. 13) that well AG-X4 shows the best performance (increased rapidly by 2032 and over) among all the wells. At the well AG-X7, the maximum rate (approximately 1400 ft3/bbl in 2036) was the lowest compared to the other wells.Fig. 12Water cut for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by N2 injection (2021–2036).Fig. 13Gas oil ratio for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by N2 injection (2021–2036). Water cut for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by N2 injection (2021–2036). Gas oil ratio for the wells under study by primary recovery (2001–2021) and by N2 injection (2021–2036). Comparison between the two scenarios for the wells The comparison between the CO2 and N2 injections in the eight wells shows different behaviour in oil production rates, water cut, and gas-oil ratios. For the oil production rate, the injection process using CO2 shows better performance than the N2 injection (Fig. 11). The comparison between CO2 and N2 injections in the eight wells indicates that the CO2 injection has a better water cut performance and gas-oil ratio than the N2 injection (Figs. 14 and 15). It has been noticed that the wells (X7 and X35) have a lower water cut percentage than the other wells. which indicates that the southwestern part of the formation at the fault area behaves at the low limits of water cut.Fig. 14Comparison between the injection of CO2 and N2 for the oil production rates.Fig. 15Comparison between the injection of CO2 and N2 for the water cut. Comparison between the injection of CO2 and N2 for the oil production rates. Comparison between the injection of CO2 and N2 for the water cut. Comparison between the two scenarios for the field The comparison between the CO2 and N2 injections in the eight wells for the entire field shows different behaviour in oil production rates, water cut, and gas-oil ratios (Figs. 16 and 17). For the oil production rate, the CO2 injection process shows a significant increase in both ultimate production in 2036 and maximum production rate in 2025, compared to N2. This could be due to the specifications of crude oil (light oil at 45.15° API and viscosity at 2.31 Cp).Fig. 16Comparison between the injection of CO2 and N2 for the for the entire field for oil production rate, water cut, and gas-oil ratio.Fig. 17Comparison between the injection of CO2 and N2 for the gas-oil ratio. Comparison between the injection of CO2 and N2 for the for the entire field for oil production rate, water cut, and gas-oil ratio. Comparison between the injection of CO2 and N2 for the gas-oil ratio. The increased values for CO2 and N2 injections are shown in Table 2 and Fig. 18. The increased percentages (CO2 and N2 injection processes) in the oil production rate are 139.45 and 66.6%, respectively. An acute increase in the gas-oil ratio by N2 injection (more than 40 times on average) could result. The water cut percentages are 520 and 380 for CO2 and N2 injection, respectively, pointing out that the water cut produced by the N2 injection process is higher than that of CO2 by percentage of 36.8.Table 2Average values and percentages of primary and injection of CO2 and N2.SpecificationAverage value at primary during the period of studyAverage value for injection (ft3)CO2N2Oil production (bbl/day)734117,57812,230% Increase in oil production139.4566.6Gas oil ratio (GOR) ft3/bbl1802507800% Increase in Gas oil ratio394005FWater cut (fraction)0.10.480.62% increase in water cut380520Fig. 18A comparison of average oil production rate, water cut, and gas oil ratio by CO2 and N2 injection. Table 2Average values and percentages of primary and injection of CO2 and N2.SpecificationAverage value at primary during the period of studyAverage value for injection (ft3)CO2N2Oil production (bbl/day)734117,57812,230% Increase in oil production139.4566.6Gas oil ratio (GOR) ft3/bbl1802507800% Increase in Gas oil ratio394005FWater cut (fraction)0.10.480.62% increase in water cut380520 Average values and percentages of primary and injection of CO2 and N2. A comparison of average oil production rate, water cut, and gas oil ratio by CO2 and N2 injection. The physical properties comparison between CO2 and N2 injection can be explained as follows: The high solubility of CO2 in oil causes significant swelling and tends to extreme viscosity reduction, while the much lower solubility of N2 in oil results in minimal oil swelling and a low viscosity reduction. For CO2 injection, higher density and lower interfacial tension lead to an unfavourable mobility ratio, viscous fingering, and poor sweep in the Asmari heterogeneous reservoir. On the other hand, lower density and higher interfacial tension for N2 create a more favourable mobility ratio, which can suppress viscous fingering and improve macroscopic sweep. CO2 achieves miscibility at relatively low Minimum Miscibility Pressures (MMP), while N2 has a very high MMP, making miscibility unattainable under most reservoir conditions; displacement is typically immiscible. Experiences an early breakthrough for CO2 due to low IFT, and allows it to channel rapidly through large pores. Delayed breakthrough occurs in N2 due to high IFT, trapping gas in small pores. A diversity between CO2 and N2 in sensitivity to reservoir heterogeneity, when the CO2 is considered, is more sensitive to the heterogeneous reservoir than N2. As a result, CO₂ behaves as a strong solvent for mobilizing and displacing oil at the pore scale; on the other hand, N₂ is more efficient as an immiscible flooding (a pressure-maintaining agent). Sensitivity analysis According to Fig. 19, the sensitivity analysis of the results from CO2 injection for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab for the entire wells for production/injection percentage, production and injection, and water cut shows that the water cut percentage (Figs. 20 and 21) will be acceptable during the first nine years of the process, with concerns of economic issues due to increasing GOR (Fig. 15) and water cut.Fig. 19CO2 injection rates for the period (2021–2036) and Oil production rates for the period (2001–2036).Fig. 20Sensitivity analysis for production/injection percentage and water cut.Fig. 21Sensitivity analysis for oil production rates and water cut by CO2 and N2 injection processes for the period (2001–2036). CO2 injection rates for the period (2021–2036) and Oil production rates for the period (2001–2036). Sensitivity analysis for production/injection percentage and water cut. Sensitivity analysis for oil production rates and water cut by CO2 and N2 injection processes for the period (2001–2036). Economic analysis The Economic Evaluation characterizes the best growth option by expertise, data, and propositions with modern software to estimate profitability38. Economic indices are divided based on the time value. Discounted indicators, including Net Present Value (NPV), internal rate of return (IRR), and profit investment ratio, consider the time value of money, whereas non-discounted indicators (Breakeven Analysis, Sensitivity Analysis, and Exposure Point) do not39. In addition, the reduction in monetary value over time should be considered when evaluating returns. Net present value The NPV is the summation of discounted yearly cash flows related to the project40. NPV clarifies the present-time measure of the net benefits derived from a project. The general form of the NPV equation is:\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$NPV=\sum_{t=0}^{t}\frac{{NCF}_{t}}{{\left(1+r\right)}^{t}}$$\end{document}where; \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${NCF}_{t}$$\end{document}: Net cash flow at the end of year a, r: The discount rate, t: Number of the year a = 0,1,2…t. If the NPV at a certain discount rate is positive, the project is considered favourable. By comparing reciprocally exclusive projects, the NPV with the highest value should be chosen. A negative NPV indicates that the investment is not profitable. The economic analysis was evaluated according to the values in Table 3.Table 3The parameters of economic analysis.ItemValueCO2 Price $/ft30.001N2 Price $/ft30.0025Crude oil $/bbl60Cost of extraction and operational costs $/bbl10injection infrastructure costs, additional costs and taxes $/bbl10Cost of injection well $/well20,000,000Number of injections well6Injection duration time (years)16Additional supposed period by (AI) (years)8The discount rate0.1 Table 3The parameters of economic analysis.ItemValueCO2 Price $/ft30.001N2 Price $/ft30.0025Crude oil $/bbl60Cost of extraction and operational costs $/bbl10injection infrastructure costs, additional costs and taxes $/bbl10Cost of injection well $/well20,000,000Number of injections well6Injection duration time (years)16Additional supposed period by (AI) (years)8The discount rate0.1 The parameters of economic analysis. The Artificial Intelligence was used to estimate additional oil production by expansion of the injection period for another 8 years. According to Fig. 22, based on the values in Table 1 and the oil production rates in Fig. 20, it is obvious that CO2 injection will be better than N2 injection in both productivity and economic profits.Fig. 22Net profits by CO2 and N2 injection with other parameters used to evaluate. Net profits by CO2 and N2 injection with other parameters used to evaluate. Based on the results in Fig. 21, the artificial intelligence was used. A linear regression was fitted to years versus production according to the equation:\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$m= \frac{n \sum xy- \sum x \sum y }{n \sum {x}^{2}- {(\sum y )}^{2}}$$\end{document}where: m is the slope for Years versus Production relationship, n represents time step, which is here 4 years, x is the x value (year), y represents the production rate in bbl/day.\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$b= {y}^{-}-m {x}^{-}$$\end{document} The profit percentage relationship is unrealistic (negative) or approaches approximately 0% when continuously using linear regression. Instead, an exponential decay or the last two points were used to estimate years 16, 20, and 24. Figure 23 represents the regression relation of expected production and net profit percentage, including all periods and 16, 20, and 24 years.Fig. 23Regression relation of expected production and net profit percentage for all the periods, including 16, 20, and 24 years. Regression relation of expected production and net profit percentage for all the periods, including 16, 20, and 24 years. Table 4 shows the final results of the regression of production after 24 years of injection.Table 4Expected production and net profit percentage after 24 years of injection.YearsExpected production bbl% of net profit20301,6700.11%24302,000Nil Table 4Expected production and net profit percentage after 24 years of injection.YearsExpected production bbl% of net profit20301,6700.11%24302,000Nil Expected production and net profit percentage after 24 years of injection. Figure 24 illustrates that continuous CO2 injection in the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab field for 20 and 24 years will cause an acute drop in income, making it “maybe” useless if world inflation continues to rise due to recession and slow growth, and oil prices drop dramatically for any reason.Fig. 24Sensitivity analysis of CO2 injection in the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab field for 20 and 24 years. Sensitivity analysis of CO2 injection in the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab field for 20 and 24 years. Conclusions This study was conducted to investigate the optimization of gas injection, differentiating between the behaviour of CO2 and N2, as a potential alternative to water in southern Iraqi fields (the Abu-Ghirab field, particularly) to overcome the water supply shortage as a result of climate change. The results pointed out:The wells on the flanks tended to have a higher production rate (over 5000 bbl/day) than the wells on the crest, while the wells located near the fault section showed the worst behaviour during the injection period.A good performance for CO2 injection when the wells are tending to the southwest near the fault region for oil production rates, water cut, and gas-oil ratio. This will be essential for the next drilling operations and for future development.The increased percentages (CO2 and N2 injection processes) in the oil production rate are 139.45 and 66.6%, respectively. The wells located near the fault section show the best water cut (approximately 18%) among all the wells. The water cut percentages are 520 and 380 for CO2 and N2 injection, respectively, pointing out that the water cut produced by the N2 injection process is higher than that of CO2 by percentage of 36.8.An acute increase in the gas-oil ratio by N2 injection (more than 40 times on average) could result.For the entire field, the oil production rate for the CO2 injection process shows a significant increase in both ultimate production in 2036 and maximum production rate in 2025, compared to N2. This could be due to the specifications of crude oil (light oil at 45.15 API and viscosity at 2.31 Cp).The sensitivity analysis of the results from CO2 injection for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab for the entire wells for production/injection percentage, oil production, and injection rates, and water cut shows that the water cut percentage will be acceptable during the first nine years of the process, with concerns of economic issues due to increasing GOR.The economic analysis of the results indicates that CO2 injection was more profitable than N2, in terms of the price of supplied gas. For this reason, if the CO2 injection period extends by an additional eight years than the planned (with the current prices of CO2 and crude oil), the net profits will drop. That will be a critical sign due to recession and slow growth, and oil prices drop dramatically for any reason The wells on the flanks tended to have a higher production rate (over 5000 bbl/day) than the wells on the crest, while the wells located near the fault section showed the worst behaviour during the injection period. The wells on the flanks tended to have a higher production rate (over 5000 bbl/day) than the wells on the crest, while the wells located near the fault section showed the worst behaviour during the injection period. A good performance for CO2 injection when the wells are tending to the southwest near the fault region for oil production rates, water cut, and gas-oil ratio. This will be essential for the next drilling operations and for future development. A good performance for CO2 injection when the wells are tending to the southwest near the fault region for oil production rates, water cut, and gas-oil ratio. This will be essential for the next drilling operations and for future development. The increased percentages (CO2 and N2 injection processes) in the oil production rate are 139.45 and 66.6%, respectively. The wells located near the fault section show the best water cut (approximately 18%) among all the wells. The water cut percentages are 520 and 380 for CO2 and N2 injection, respectively, pointing out that the water cut produced by the N2 injection process is higher than that of CO2 by percentage of 36.8. The increased percentages (CO2 and N2 injection processes) in the oil production rate are 139.45 and 66.6%, respectively. The wells located near the fault section show the best water cut (approximately 18%) among all the wells. The water cut percentages are 520 and 380 for CO2 and N2 injection, respectively, pointing out that the water cut produced by the N2 injection process is higher than that of CO2 by percentage of 36.8. An acute increase in the gas-oil ratio by N2 injection (more than 40 times on average) could result. An acute increase in the gas-oil ratio by N2 injection (more than 40 times on average) could result. For the entire field, the oil production rate for the CO2 injection process shows a significant increase in both ultimate production in 2036 and maximum production rate in 2025, compared to N2. This could be due to the specifications of crude oil (light oil at 45.15 API and viscosity at 2.31 Cp). For the entire field, the oil production rate for the CO2 injection process shows a significant increase in both ultimate production in 2036 and maximum production rate in 2025, compared to N2. This could be due to the specifications of crude oil (light oil at 45.15 API and viscosity at 2.31 Cp). The sensitivity analysis of the results from CO2 injection for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab for the entire wells for production/injection percentage, oil production, and injection rates, and water cut shows that the water cut percentage will be acceptable during the first nine years of the process, with concerns of economic issues due to increasing GOR. The sensitivity analysis of the results from CO2 injection for the Asmari formation in the Abu-Ghirab for the entire wells for production/injection percentage, oil production, and injection rates, and water cut shows that the water cut percentage will be acceptable during the first nine years of the process, with concerns of economic issues due to increasing GOR. The economic analysis of the results indicates that CO2 injection was more profitable than N2, in terms of the price of supplied gas. For this reason, if the CO2 injection period extends by an additional eight years than the planned (with the current prices of CO2 and crude oil), the net profits will drop. That will be a critical sign due to recession and slow growth, and oil prices drop dramatically for any reason The economic analysis of the results indicates that CO2 injection was more profitable than N2, in terms of the price of supplied gas. For this reason, if the CO2 injection period extends by an additional eight years than the planned (with the current prices of CO2 and crude oil), the net profits will drop. That will be a critical sign due to recession and slow growth, and oil prices drop dramatically for any reason