Research on supporting mechanism and application of new ductile thin spraying technology in coal mine roadway Authors: Ruijie Wang, Rui Wu, Jinhai Xu, Huaiguo Wu, Keke Wang Published: 2026 ABSTRACT The safety and stability of the roadway is the fundamental guarantee for safe, green, high-yield and efficient production in coal mines, and the surface support of the roadway surrounding rock is crucial for the stability and effectiveness of the entire roadway support system. However, currently most coal mines use traditional shotcrete technology for surface protection, which has disadvantages such as poor ductileness, easy detachment and cracking, high transportation and labor costs, environmental pollution and high rebound; Only a few mines have adopted the new ductile thin spraying technology, but the support mechanism, applicable conditions, and application effects are still unclear and in the stage of engineering experience. This article first provides a detailed theoretical analysis of the support mechanism of ductile thin spray coatings, including surface protection and cooperative support. Secondly, numerical simulations and comparative analysis were conducted using finite difference software FLAC3D and discrete element software 3DEC to study the effectiveness of new ductile thin spray materials and traditional sprayed concrete materials in roadway support. The simulation results show that ductile thin spray materials are more conducive to improving the stress environment of shallow rock layers in roadway surrounding rock, enhancing the bearing capacity of roadway surrounding rock itself, suppressing the displacement and sliding of loose rock blocks between anchor rods, optimizing the stress state of the entire support system, and greatly ensuring the stability of the roadway support system. They are particularly suitable for application in two types of coal rock roadways: “poor quality+medium hard rock/hard rock” and “general quality+soft rock/medium hard rock”. Finally, the new ductile thin spraying technology was industrially tested in the bottom extraction roadway of Changping Coal Mine. The on-site measurement results showed that the technology effectively controlled the overall deformation of the roadway surrounding rock, improved the stress state of the roadway support components, and had good application effects. The research results of this article have good reference and guidance significance for the understanding of the importance of roadway surrounding rock surface support and the promotion and application of new ductile thin spraying technology. Introduction In recent years, with the layout and planning of the national energy strategy, China’s coal resources have been further integrated and optimized, resulting in a large number of “safe, green, high-yield and high-efficiency” large-scale mines. Obviously, the rapid excavation and safe stability of roadways are the fundamental guarantees for the safe and efficient production of coal mines1–3. As of now, with the vigorous promotion and popularization of anchor net cable support technology in most coal mines in China, the overall support problem of coal mine roadways has been basically solved and improved. However, the problem of timely sealing and surface protection of roadway surrounding rock has become increasingly prominent. Relevant research results show that the following problems exist in the timely sealing of surrounding rock of coal mine roadway for surface protection4–10:, As a result, the metal mesh can not closely fit with the surrounding rock surface, so that some of the surrounding rock is in a two-way stress state, which can not play a real active support role, and can not effectively control the harmful deformation of the roadway surrounding rock at the initial stage. At the same time, the mesh laying process increases the labor intensity, and restricts the roadway excavation speed to a certain extent; (2) For the traditional shotcrete surface protection, due to the low ductileness of the shotcrete layer, poor adhesion with the surrounding rock, and easy to fall off and crack, the concrete shotcrete layer has poor water separation effect, large thickness, large amount, large auxiliary transportation volume, high rebound rate, and large dust in the operating environment, which are contrary to the production concept of “green, safe, high-yield and efficient”. Therefore, based on the above outstanding problems, continue to seek and research a new type of surface protection and support material that can replace the traditional metal mesh or concrete shotcrete, which is green, energy efficient and has better comprehensive performance. In recent years, extensive research and practical results have shown that a new type of ductile thin spray material (TSL) specifically used for sealing and protecting the surface of coal mine roadway surrounding rock in countries such as Canada and Australia has a good effect on protecting the surface of roadway surrounding rock. Compared with traditional surface protection technologies (metal mesh and concrete spraying), TSL has the following main advantages: (1) good ductileness, strong adhesion with surrounding rock, and can better adapt to the uneven surface of roadway surrounding rock, while not easily cracking or falling off. It can truly play an active supporting role in sealing and protecting the surrounding rock in a timely manner. TSL has good surface protection effect and can effectively solve problems such as gas leakage, weathering of surrounding rock, and rusting of supporting components in coal mine roadway; (2) The ductile thin spray coating on the surface of the surrounding rock in the roadway can form a good cooperative support effect with components such as anchor cables, allowing the pre stress of the anchor cables to fully diffuse, improving the stress environment on the surface of the roadway surrounding rock, enhancing the bearing capacity of the surrounding rock itself, and improving the stability of the support system; (3) The ductileness thin spray coating has a small thickness, low usage, low labor intensity and auxiliary transportation volume, a green and environmentally friendly working environment, no rebound, and fast construction speed. Numerous domestic and foreign researchers have conducted extensive research on the new ductileness thin spray technology and achieved a series of results. Representative scholars include: In the study of mechanical properties and failure modes of thin sprayed materials, Dube11 believes that the important mechanism by which thin spray coatings play a supporting role is to promote the interlocking between rock blocks and improve their own bearing capacity; Shan et al.13, compared the strength and support effect of samples reinforced with thin spray coating and metal mesh, and the results showed that thin spray coating can improve the load-bearing capacity and surface damage resistance of the samples; Zhang Nong et al.17, conducted tensile and block bearing capacity tests on sprayed flexible film materials, indicating that sprayed film materials have the characteristics of fast bearing response, large deformation capacity, and strong block bearing capacity. At the same time, combined with the characteristics of coal mine roadway engineering and the mechanical properties of sprayed flexible film, their application principles and applicable conditions were pointed out; Gunner and Tananat18,19 used a combination of two-dimensional discrete element software PFC2D and experimental methods to study the mechanical properties and mechanism of thin spray coatings, providing a new approach for the research of thin spray coatings; Taesang20 and Lee21 studied the thermal insulation and water barrier effects of thin spray coatings on cement concrete through numerical simulations. The existing research lacks systematic comparative analysis of the ductile thin spray material and the traditional concrete shotcrete under the same conditions, especially the quantitative comparison from the perspective of improving the surrounding rock stress environment and optimizing the stress state of supporting components. In the research on the cooperation of thin spray coatings as a part of the support system, Kuijpers et al.12, believe that the support performance of thin spray coatings is mainly reflected in their role as a part of the entire support system, working together with other support components; Wei Qun et al.22,23, used the two-dimensional discrete element software UDEC to simulate the support effect of spray film under anchor rod support system. The results showed that the bonding performance between spray film and rock mass is very important, which is the key to the spray film’s surface support effect. At the same time, they pointed out that the spray film and anchor rod play a cooperative support role, greatly reducing the subsidence of the roof rock coatings and improving the bearing capacity of the roadway roof. Most researches focus on the material properties or two-dimensional simplified simulation, and the research on the cooperative support mechanism of thin spray coatings and anchor (cable) under three-dimensional conditions is insufficient. In the field application and performance test research of thin spray technology, Archibald and Katsabanis14,15 conducted extensive experimental research on the support effect of thin spray coatings under dynamic pressure under different support methods, the results showed that the performance of thin spray coatings was not inferior to other support methods; Dong Shan et al.16, summarized the main functions of thin spray flexible film in roadway support, including adhesive effect, diaphragm effect, and penetration reinforcement effect. The existing industrial test and effect evaluation of thin spray coatings are not systematic and quantitative enough, and lack of long-term monitoring data support. To sum up, the existing research has not yet formed a clear consensus on the cooperative mechanism of the ductile thin spray coatings in roadway support, especially the comparison effect with the traditional shotcrete under the framework of three-dimensional numerical simulation. Therefore, this paper aims to deeply study the support mechanism of ductile thin spray coatings and its advantages over traditional shotcrete through detailed theoretical analysis, three-dimensional finite difference (FLAC3D) and discrete element (3DEC) numerical simulation, and verify its application effect through field industrial test, so as to clarify its application conditions and engineering value. Engineering background Geological conditions The sixth panel of Changping Coal Mine, located in Shanxi Province, mainly mines No.3 coal seam. Due to the low strength, high gas content, poor coal permeability and rapid gas drainage attenuation of No.3 coal seam within the mine field, the gas drainage effect of this coal seam is not ideal. To solve the problem of gas drainage and accelerate the connection of mining and excavation working faces, the comprehensive mining working face adopts the bottom drainage roadway for gas drainage. The design length of the north roadway of gangue removal in panel 6 is 1530 m. The normal section has a clear width of 4.8 m and a clear height of 3.2 m. The north lane of gangue removal in panel 6 is located between K6 limestone and K7 fine sandstone. The K7 sandstone is high. The rock stratum between K6 limestone and K7 sandstone is sandy mudstone with a thickness of about 3.0 m. The design height of the bottom drainage roadway is 3.2 m, and the roadway is driven along the K6 roof. Therefore, it is necessary to break the K7 sandstone of the roof with a height of about 0.2 m. Above the K7 sandstone is a 3 m thick sandy mudstone layer, as shown in Fig. 1. Fig. 1Schematic diagram of the location of the bottom drainage roadway. Schematic diagram of the location of the bottom drainage roadway. Existing problems Due to the thickness change of K7 fine-grained sandstone, roadwaying disturbance, roadway crossing structure, layer crossing and other factors, it is easy to dig through and expose the sandy mudstone above K7 sandstone in some areas, and even in some areas, the top of K7 sandstone can not be found after passing structure or layer crossing. The top plate is directly sandy mudstone, which is unstable, and is prone to weathering, deformation and damage, and gradually expand the broken area of surrounding rock to the deep stable surrounding rock. So, the roadway gradually converges and deforms, and even local collapse and roof fall occur, resulting in the need for multiple repairs of the roadway, and even serious personal safety accidents. Although the traditional shotcrete can play a certain role in preventing the weathering of the surrounding rock of the roadway, there are problems such as large pollution, large material consumption, high transportation and labor costs, high rebound rate, unstable quality, easy to fall off and crack, etc. in the shotcrete operation process, and the construction speed is slow, which is difficult to meet the requirements of rapid roadway excavation and timely closure of the roadway. Therefore, to solve the above problems, this article proposes a new ductileness thin spraying technology based on green environmental protection and high-performance surface protection materials. Mechanism of the supporting effect of ductile thin spray technology A large number of engineering practices and research results have shown11,12,16,17,24–27 that ductile thin spray coatings play two main roles in coal mine roadway support according to their main functions, namely, surface protection of roadway surrounding rock and cooperative support with anchor cables. The former mainly reflects the closed anti weathering, anti gas or goaf gas leakage, and anti rust function of the ductile thin spray coating on the surface of the surrounding rock of the roadway, while the latter mainly reflects its timely and active support for the shallow surrounding rock of the roadway, and the formation of a systematic support system from the surface to the inside with anchor cables in space. Mechanism of surface protection A thin spray coating with good ductileness and bonding strength can form a continuous and complete “physical diaphragm” on the surface of the roadway surrounding rock, as shown in Fig. 2, tightly wrapping the loose blocks on the surface of the roadway surrounding rock and the nearby intact rock blocks together. The ductile thin spray coating can not only prevent and suppress the movement and sliding of loose rock blocks in the shallow part of the roadway surrounding rock, but also form a “physical diaphragm” on the surface of the surrounding rock, blocking the entry of moisture and gas from the air into the cracks of the surrounding rock. The protective effect of ductile thin spray coating largely depends on the shear strength, tensile strength, and bonding strength between the coating and the surrounding rock surface. The protective effect of the ductile thin spray coating generally goes through several main processes from the beginning to failure (as shown in Fig. 3): (1) In the static bearing stage, the thin spray coating is tightly adhered to the surface of the surrounding rock, and the coating at the gap between the stable surrounding rock and the loose surrounding rock mainly bears the combined effect of shear and tension. At this time, the coating is in the elastic stage and there is no damage phenomenon; (2) In the debonding stage, when the gravity of the loose surrounding rock exceeds the bonding force between the coating and the surface of the surrounding rock, the coating begins to slowly detach from the surface of the surrounding rock, generally expanding from the boundary between stable and loose surrounding rock to both sides. The detached coating mainly bears tensile action; (3) During the tensile bearing stage, as the debonding process continues, the detachment of the coating gradually stops when it extends to the point where the support component is subjected to force (near the anchor cable tray). At this point, the detached coating mainly bears the tensile action between the support component and the loose surrounding rock at the point of force application; (4) During the tensile failure stage, when the applied force exceeds the tensile strength of the coating itself, the coating gradually undergoes tensile failure until the entire coating fractures and falls off, ultimately leading to failure. From this, it can be seen that the protective effect of the ductile thin spray coating mainly has two failure modes, namely tensile shear failure and adhesive failure failure, as shown in Fig. 4. Fig. 2Schematic diagram of thin spraying coating for surface protection. Schematic diagram of thin spraying coating for surface protection. Fig. 3Schematic diagram of thin spraying coating process. Schematic diagram of thin spraying coating process. Fig. 4Failure mode diagram of thin spraying coating. Failure mode diagram of thin spraying coating. Cooperative support mechanism In addition to providing surface protection for the surrounding rock of the roadway, the ductile thin spray coating can also interact with supporting components such as anchor rods and cables to improve the stress environment of the surrounding rock and construct the entire support system of the roadway. The principle diagram of the cooperative support effect of the ductile thin spray coating is shown in Fig. 5. After the initial support of the roadway excavation, a certain thickness (10–50 mm) of ductile thin spray coating with high compressive, tensile, and shear strength forms a closed “physical protective layer” on the surface of the roadway surrounding rock in a timely manner (as shown in the yellow part in the Fig. 5). On the one hand, this protective layer can prevent the weathering and damage of air and moisture in the roadway to the shallow surrounding rock, suppress and limit the displacement and sliding of loose blocks between anchor rods (cables); On the other hand, the discontinuous and unstable “point line support” formed by the original anchor rods, anchor cables and other supporting components on the surface of the roadway can be converted into continuous and stable “surface support”, so as to form a continuous overall structure on the surface of the roadway surrounding rock, thereby improving the stress environment of the shallow surrounding rock. At the same time, connect the relatively isolated compressive stress zone formed by the anchor rod of the shallow surrounding rock (as shown in the green part of the Fig. 5) into a relatively continuous compressive stress zone, and then deform together with the “bearing layer” of this compressive stress zone under the pressure of the surrounding rock, so that the surface surrounding rock of the roadway and the shallow surrounding rock form a continuous deformation bearing structure in space. Finally, use the “anchoring layer” formed by the anchor cable in the deep surrounding rock (as shown in the blue part of the Fig. 5) to suspend the previous continuous bearing structure in the stable rock layer in the deep part. At this time, the “physical protection layer”, “shallow bearing layer” and “deep anchoring layer” of the roadway surrounding rock can jointly form a complete “surface to interior” structure. The continuous effective compressive stress zone (as shown in the red box inside the Fig. 5) forms a relatively stable and reliable cooperative support system in space. This greatly increases the stability and effectiveness of the entire roadway support system. Fig. 5Schematic diagram of thin spraying coating cooperative support. Schematic diagram of thin spraying coating cooperative support. Simulation of the support effect of ductile thin spray coatings Simulation of surface protection Establishment of numerical model To better demonstrate the surface protection effect of ductile thin spray material in roadway support and study the applicable conditions of this new material (i.e. which type of coal and rock roadway is suitable), FLAC3D software was used for numerical simulation. The model size is 40 × 5 × 30 m, with horizontal displacement limited by the boundaries around the model, vertical displacement limited by the bottom of the model, and a uniformly distributed load of 2.5 × 104 × 600 = 15 MPa equivalent to the gravity of 500 m thick overlying rock applied to the top of the model. The numerical calculation model diagram is shown in Fig. 6. Fig. 6Calculation model Diagram. Calculation model Diagram. The Hoek Brown constitutive model is used for the rock mass material, the Concrete constitutive model is used for the spray layer material, and the Cable element is used for the support components. Among them, the rock mass quality considers three types: poor quality, average quality, and good quality. The rock hardness considers three types: soft rock, medium hard rock, and hard rock. Referring to the research data in the literature28, the corresponding values of GSI, UCS, material constant mi, and rock intact Young’s modulus Ei are detailed in Table 1. The mechanical properties of ductile thin spray materials and shotcrete materials are shown in Table 2. Basis for selection of relevant parameters in the model: the rock mechanics parameters used in this model are based on the results of on-site geological survey and indoor rock mechanics test, and are calibrated by comparing with the published literature data of similar engineering geological conditions28, ensuring the rationality of model parameter setting. The roadway section size and support parameters in the simulation are strictly based on the site design of Changping Coal Mine. GSI, UCS, mi and Ei values in Table 1 refer to the rock mass parameter estimation method based on Hoek Brown criterion in reference28 and are comprehensively determined in combination with the core test data of Changping Coal Mine. In Table 2, the bond strength, cohesion and other parameters of TSL and surrounding rock are determined according to the results of pull-out test and shear test on the thin spray material specimen used in the laboratory. Table 1Calculation Parameters.Rock mass quality(GSI)Rock hardnessUniaxial compressive strength(UCS)/MPaRock intact Young’s modulus(Ei)/GPaRock material constant(mi)Poor qualityGSI = 30soft20178medium hard502212hard803016General qualityGSI = 50soft20178medium hard502212hard803016Good qualityGSI = 70soft20178medium hard502212hard803016 Table 1Calculation Parameters.Rock mass quality(GSI)Rock hardnessUniaxial compressive strength(UCS)/MPaRock intact Young’s modulus(Ei)/GPaRock material constant(mi)Poor qualityGSI = 30soft20178medium hard502212hard803016General qualityGSI = 50soft20178medium hard502212hard803016Good qualityGSI = 70soft20178medium hard502212hard803016 Calculation Parameters. Poor quality GSI = 30 General quality GSI = 50 Good quality GSI = 70 Table 2Mechanical properties of surface protection materials.Surface protection materialsTSLConcreteThickness(mm)100100Bulk modulus (GPa)0.247.2Shear modulus (GPa)0.226.6Cohesion (MPa)52Tension (MPa)31Bond strength with rock (MPa)2.50.5 Table 2Mechanical properties of surface protection materials.Surface protection materialsTSLConcreteThickness(mm)100100Bulk modulus (GPa)0.247.2Shear modulus (GPa)0.226.6Cohesion (MPa)52Tension (MPa)31Bond strength with rock (MPa)2.50.5 Mechanical properties of surface protection materials. Simulation result analysis Tensile strength: This indicator can evaluate the degree of damage to the surface rock layers of the roadway surrounding rock (the smaller the range of surrounding rock with a tensile strength of 0 MPa, the better). Tensile strength: This indicator can evaluate the degree of damage to the surface rock layers of the roadway surrounding rock (the smaller the range of surrounding rock with a tensile strength of 0 MPa, the better). Tensile strength: This indicator can evaluate the degree of damage to the surface rock layers of the roadway surrounding rock (the smaller the range of surrounding rock with a tensile strength of 0 MPa, the better). Figures 7, 8 and 9 show the distribution cloud maps of the tensile strength of the surrounding rock when the roadway is excavated under different rock mass conditions and the surface support is made of ductile thin spray material and shotcrete material, respectively. According to the simulation results, for poor quality rock masses, when the surrounding rock is soft, the surface protection effect of sprayed concrete material is better than that of ductile thin sprayed material. Among them, under the latter surface protection support, the roof and surrounding rock surfaces of the roadway show a tensile strength of 0 MPa; For high-quality rock masses, regardless of the hardness of the surrounding rock, the surface protection effect of shotcrete materials is superior to that of ductile thin shotcrete materials. Among them, under the surface support of the latter, the range of surface rock layers with a tensile strength of 0 MPa in the roadway is significantly larger than that of the former; In other cases, the surface protection effect of ductile thin sprayed materials is better than that of sprayed concrete materials. Fig. 7Cloud map of tensile strength distribution of surrounding rock in poor quality rock mass roadway. Cloud map of tensile strength distribution of surrounding rock in poor quality rock mass roadway. Fig. 8Cloud map of tensile strength distribution of surrounding rock in general quality rock mass roadway. Cloud map of tensile strength distribution of surrounding rock in general quality rock mass roadway. Fig. 9Cloud map of tensile strength distribution of surrounding rock in high quality rock mass roadway. Cloud map of tensile strength distribution of surrounding rock in high quality rock mass roadway. (2) Maximum principal stress: This indicator can evaluate the stress state of the rock layers on the surface of the roadway surrounding rock (the greater the compressive stress, the better) and the bearing capacity of the deep rock layers (the smaller the distance between the peak position and the free face of the roadway, the better). (2) Maximum principal stress: This indicator can evaluate the stress state of the rock layers on the surface of the roadway surrounding rock (the greater the compressive stress, the better) and the bearing capacity of the deep rock layers (the smaller the distance between the peak position and the free face of the roadway, the better). Maximum principal stress: This indicator can evaluate the stress state of the rock layers on the surface of the roadway surrounding rock (the greater the compressive stress, the better) and the bearing capacity of the deep rock layers (the smaller the distance between the peak position and the free face of the roadway, the better). Figures 10, 11 and 12 show the maximum principal stress distribution cloud maps of the surrounding rock when the roadway is excavated under different rock mass conditions and the protective surface support is made of ductile thin spray material and shotcrete material, respectively. For poor quality rock masses, when the surrounding rock is soft, the surface protection effect of shotcrete material is better than that of ductile thin shotcrete material. The maximum principal stress peak of the former is 6.0 m away from the top plate, with a magnitude of 19.3 MPa, and the latter is 8.5 m away from the top plate, with a magnitude of 18.5 MPa. Moreover, the compressive stress of the surface surrounding rock (top plate and two sides) is higher in the former (average 5.0 MPa) than in the latter (average 2.0 MPa); For high-quality rock masses, when the surrounding rock hardness is medium hard rock and hard rock, the surface protection effect of shotcrete material is better than that of ductile thin shotcrete material. Among them, for medium hard rock, the maximum principal stress peak of the former is 1.5 m away from the top plate, with a size of 22 MPa, and the latter is 1.8 m away from the top plate, with a size of 20 MPa. Moreover, the compressive stress of the surface surrounding rock (top plate and two sides) is higher in the former (average 7.5 MPa) than in the latter (average 6.7 MPa). For hard rock, the maximum principal stress peak of the former is 1.6 m away from the top plate, with a size of 19.8 MPa, and the latter is 2.0 m away from the top plate, with a size of 19.4 MPa. Moreover, the compressive stress of the surface surrounding rock (top plate and two sides) is higher in the former (average 9.0 MPa are greater than the latter (average 8.8 MPa); In other cases, the surface protection effect of ductile thin sprayed materials is better than that of sprayed concrete materials. Fig. 10Cloud map of maximum principal stress distribution of surrounding rock in poor quality rock mass roadway. Cloud map of maximum principal stress distribution of surrounding rock in poor quality rock mass roadway. Fig. 11Cloud map of maximum principal stress distribution of surrounding rock in general quality rock mass roadway. Cloud map of maximum principal stress distribution of surrounding rock in general quality rock mass roadway. Fig. 12Cloud map of maximum principal stress distribution of surrounding rock in high quality rock mass roadway. Cloud map of maximum principal stress distribution of surrounding rock in high quality rock mass roadway. (3) Plastic zone: This indicator can evaluate the overall failure range of the roadway surrounding rock (the smaller the plastic zone range of the surrounding rock, the better). (3) Plastic zone: This indicator can evaluate the overall failure range of the roadway surrounding rock (the smaller the plastic zone range of the surrounding rock, the better). Plastic zone: This indicator can evaluate the overall failure range of the roadway surrounding rock (the smaller the plastic zone range of the surrounding rock, the better). Figures 13, 14 and 15 show the plastic deformation distribution of the surrounding rock after excavation of the roadway under different rock mass conditions, using ductile thin spray material and shotcrete material for surface support. For poor quality rock masses, when the surrounding rock is soft, the surface protection effect of shotcrete material is better than that of ductile thin shotcrete material. Among them, the plastic zone range of the surrounding rock in the roadway is smaller under the surface protection of the former than that of the latter; For high-quality rock masses, when the surrounding rock hardness is medium hard rock or hard rock, the surface protection effect of shotcrete material is better than that of ductile thin shotcrete material. Among them, under the surface protection support of the former, the plastic zone range of the surrounding rock in the roadway is significantly smaller than that of the latter. When the surrounding rock hardness is soft rock, the surface protection effect of the two is almost the same (the plastic zone range of the surrounding rock is the same); In other cases, the surface protection effect of ductile thin sprayed materials is better than that of sprayed concrete materials. Fig. 13Cloud map of plastic zone distribution of surrounding rock in poor quality rock mass roadway. Cloud map of plastic zone distribution of surrounding rock in poor quality rock mass roadway. Fig. 14Cloud map of plastic zone distribution of surrounding rock in general quality rock mass roadway. Cloud map of plastic zone distribution of surrounding rock in general quality rock mass roadway. Fig. 15Cloud map of plastic zone distribution of surrounding rock in high quality rock mass roadway. Cloud map of plastic zone distribution of surrounding rock in high quality rock mass roadway. From the above, it can be concluded that when sprayed materials can be used for surface protection and support in roadways, ductile thin sprayed materials are more suitable for the two types of rock mass roadways: “poor quality + medium hard rock / hard rock” and “general quality + soft rock / medium hard rock”. This is consistent with their mechanical properties of large deformation adaptability and strong ductileness sealing. Simulation of cooperative support action Establishment of numerical model To better present and demonstrate the cooperative support effect of ductile thin spray coating with supporting components (anchor rods, cables) in roadway support, the bonding block model29,30 and mixed anchor rod components in 3DEC software were used to simulate the failure characteristics of roadway surrounding rock and the stress characteristics of supporting components, respectively. The numerical model size is 15 × 4 × 12 m (length × width × height), and the boundary conditions of the model are: applying vertical downward stress on the upper boundary of the model to simulate the load of the overlying rock layer; The displacement of the model along the horizontal direction is limited; Limit its vertical and horizontal displacement at the bottom boundary of the model. The cross-sectional shape of the roadway is rectangular, with dimensions of 5.0 × 4 m and a burial depth of 600 m. The surrounding rock of the roadway is sandy mudstone with developed joints and fissures, which is prone to weathering. Table 3 summarizes the micro mechanical properties of blocks and contacts in the BBM model of sandy mudstone. The values of these attributes can be obtained through uniaxial tensile and compression tests and parameter calibration of BBM samples. The mechanical properties of the surface protection materials are shown in Table 2, the mechanical properties of the support components are shown in Table 4, and the numerical model is shown in Fig. 16. In the model, the length of bolt is 2.4 m, the spacing between rows is 1.0 m × 0.8 m, and the preload is 60KN; the length of cable is 4.3 m, the spacing between rows is 1.5 m × 1.6 m, and the preload is 200KN. Table 3Elastic Block and Contact Mechanical Properties used in the Model.Block PropertiesYoung’s Modulus2.2 GPaPoisson’s Ratio0.20Density2600 kg/m3Contact PropertiesNormal Stiffness80 GPaShear Stiffness40 GPaFriction Angle30°Dilation Angle5°Peak Tensile StrengthVariable – from Gaussian distributionMean value = 1.0 MPa, std. dev.=0.02 MPaResidual Tensile Strength0Peak Cohesive Strength2.5 MPaResidual Cohesive Strength2.5 × tensile strengthElastic Boundary Block PropertiesYoung’s Modulus1.5 GPaPoison’s Ratio0.25 Table 3Elastic Block and Contact Mechanical Properties used in the Model.Block PropertiesYoung’s Modulus2.2 GPaPoisson’s Ratio0.20Density2600 kg/m3Contact PropertiesNormal Stiffness80 GPaShear Stiffness40 GPaFriction Angle30°Dilation Angle5°Peak Tensile StrengthVariable – from Gaussian distributionMean value = 1.0 MPa, std. dev.=0.02 MPaResidual Tensile Strength0Peak Cohesive Strength2.5 MPaResidual Cohesive Strength2.5 × tensile strengthElastic Boundary Block PropertiesYoung’s Modulus1.5 GPaPoison’s Ratio0.25 Elastic Block and Contact Mechanical Properties used in the Model. Variable – from Gaussian distribution Mean value = 1.0 MPa, std. dev.=0.02 MPa Table 4Support components properties.Support componentsboltcableArea (m2)314e-6380e-6Young’s modulus (Pa)2e112e11Bond stiffness (N/m/m)3e82e8Bond strength (N/m)8e58e5Axial strain limit (m/m)0.10.2Axial strength (N)1.88e53.61e5Dowel stiffness (N/m)1e78e6Dowel strength (N)1.4e51.9e5Dowel strain limit (m/m)0.20.2 Table 4Support components properties.Support componentsboltcableArea (m2)314e-6380e-6Young’s modulus (Pa)2e112e11Bond stiffness (N/m/m)3e82e8Bond strength (N/m)8e58e5Axial strain limit (m/m)0.10.2Axial strength (N)1.88e53.61e5Dowel stiffness (N/m)1e78e6Dowel strength (N)1.4e51.9e5Dowel strain limit (m/m)0.20.2 Support components properties. Fig. 16Numerical model diagram. Numerical model diagram. Simulation result analysis Displacement field analysis Displacement field analysis Displacement field analysis Figures 17 and 18 show the horizontal and vertical displacement cloud maps of the roadway under three working conditions, namely, only under the support of anchor cables, under the action of anchor cables and shotcrete materials, and under the action of anchor cables and ductile thin shotcrete materials, respectively. Figure 19 shows the sealed bonding between the protective material and the surrounding rock on the surface of the roadway. From Figs. 17 and 18, it can be seen that the maximum displacement of the two sides of the roadway under three working conditions is 305 mm, 142 mm, and 126 mm, respectively, and the maximum subsidence of the roof is 92 mm, 70 mm, and 58 mm, respectively. It can be seen that under the action of the surface protection material, the overall displacement of the roadway is reduced, but the ductile thin sprayed material is significantly better than the sprayed concrete material in controlling the overall deformation of the roadway. As shown in Fig. 19, the adhesion between the sprayed concrete material and the surrounding rock on the surface of the roadway is poor (there is obvious delamination in the red circle in the Fig. 19), and the sealing effect is not good. On the other hand, the ductile thin sprayed material is closely adhered to the surrounding rock on the surface of the roadway, and the sealing effect is good. Furthermore, the combination of ductile thin spray materials and anchor rods can enhance the overall integrity of fractured rock masses and reduce the risk of collapse of locally loose blocks. Fig. 17Cloud chart of horizontal displacement of roadway(unit: m). Cloud chart of horizontal displacement of roadway(unit: m). Fig. 18Cloud chart of vertical displacement of roadway(unit: m). Cloud chart of vertical displacement of roadway(unit: m). Fig. 19Bonding state of surface protection material and surrounding rock. Bonding state of surface protection material and surrounding rock. (2) Force analysis of supporting components (2) Force analysis of supporting components Force analysis of supporting components Figures 20 and 21 show the fracture situation and force diagram of the roadway support components (anchor rods and cables) under three different working conditions. From Figs. 20 and 21, it can be seen that in the roadway support system, when only anchor cables are used, two anchor cables on the leftmost side of the roof are sheared and broken, and six anchor cables are sheared and broken (blue segment in the Fig. 20). Moreover, the average axial force value of all anchor cables is very large, and the force is extremely uneven; When there are anchor cables and sprayed concrete, one anchor cable on the leftmost side of the roof is sheared and broken, three anchor cables are sheared and broken, and three anchor cables on both sides are stretched and broken (yellow segment in the Fig. 20). Moreover, the average axial force value of all anchor cables is relatively large, and the force is uneven; When there are anchor cables and ductile thin spray materials, only 2 anchor rods on the roof undergo shear fracture, and the average axial force value of all anchor cables is relatively small, with relatively uniform force distribution. Therefore, in terms of the force state of the roadway anchor cables, ductile thin sprayed materials are more conducive to improving the force state of the anchor cables than sprayed concrete materials, fully exerting the timely active support effect of the anchor cables, better coordinating with the anchor cables for support, and more conducive to ensuring the reliability and stability of the entire support system of the roadway. Fig. 20Breaking condition of support components. Breaking condition of support components. Fig. 21Axial force of support components (unit: N). Axial force of support components (unit: N). (3) Analysis of surrounding rock fragmentation (3) Analysis of surrounding rock fragmentation Analysis of surrounding rock fragmentation Figure 22 shows the distribution of rock fragmentation zones in the roadway under three different working conditions. From Fig. 22, it can be seen that when only anchor cables are used in the roadway, the range of rock fragmentation in the roadway is the largest, and the number of loose blocks (loss of bonding between blocks) is 262; When there are anchor cables and sprayed concrete in the roadway, the range of the surrounding rock fragmentation zone is second, and the number of loose blocks is 200; When there are anchor cables and ductile thin sprayed materials in the roadway, the range of rock fragmentation in the roadway is the smallest, and the number of loose blocks is 139. From this, it can be seen that the timely surface protection effect of the ductile thin spray material and the synergistic support effect with the anchor cable are the best, jointly suppressing the separation and displacement of loose blocks in the shallow surrounding rock of the roadway, greatly improving the bearing capacity of the surrounding rock itself, and ensuring the overall stability of the roadway. Fig. 22Distribution of roadway surrounding rock fracture zone. Distribution of roadway surrounding rock fracture zone. Based on the above simulation results, it can be concluded that considering the overall deformation of the surrounding rock in the roadway, the force state of the supporting components, and the range of the rock fragmentation zone, the control effect of the ductile thin spray coating on the deformation of the surrounding rock in the roadway and the improvement of the stability of the roadway support system are significantly better than those of the concrete spray layer, further demonstrating its good collaborative support effect. Engineering applications Based on the theoretical and numerical simulation analysis results in the previous section, a new type of ductile thin spray material with better performance should be preferred for roadway surface protection materials. Therefore, based on the specific geological conditions of the Liupan area of Changping Coal Mine in Shanxi Province (see Chap. 2 for details), the new ductileness thin spraying technology will be industrially tested in its bottom extraction roadway. Construction technical scheme Spraying materials Composition and proportion of spraying materials Composition and proportion of spraying materials Composition and proportion of spraying materials The total length of the experimental roadway is 800 m, with a designed spray layer thickness of 10–15 mm. Among them, the spraying material is composed of two components A and B, wherein component A is composed of water-borne emulsion resin with a solid content of more than 55%, which is packaged in plastic barrels with a weight of 25 kg; component B is composed of a mixture of inorganic mineral powder materials, which is packaged in moisture-proof packaging bags with a weight of 25 kg. On site, it is mixed in accordance with the solid ratio of 1:1 and constructed by special spraying equipment. And the spraying materials mainly have the following characteristics: inorganic composite materials, no volatile harmful substances (in compliance with environmental requirements); High tensile strength, large deformation, strong adhesion, fast hardening, and excellent sealing performance; The reaction temperature is low, less than 30 ℃. The main performance parameters of the material are shown in Table 5. Table 5Performance parameters of spraying materials.Product featuresPerformance parameterSurface drying time (min) <60Complete hardening time (min) <4Ultimate tensile strength (MPa) >2.5Maximum elongation (%) >30Flame retardancyAbsolute flame retardant Table 5Performance parameters of spraying materials.Product featuresPerformance parameterSurface drying time (min) <60Complete hardening time (min) <4Ultimate tensile strength (MPa) >2.5Maximum elongation (%) >30Flame retardancyAbsolute flame retardant Performance parameters of spraying materials. (2) Indoor test data of spraying materials (2) Indoor test data of spraying materials Indoor test data of spraying materials The compressive strength of traditional shotcrete materials is generally 25 MPa, and they are brittle materials, and the compression deformation is only 0.0% to 0.08%. Under the impact of dynamic pressure, they are easy to break and collapse, and then lose their mechanical properties. The ductile thin spraying material not only has high compressive strength, but also can adapt to the impact of uneven dynamic pressure under the shaft. Under the pressure work, the greater the deformation, the higher the strength. It can reach about 20 MPa at about 20% deformation and more than 30 MPa at 50% deformation, and it is not completely broken. Figure 23 shows the curve of the compressive strength value of the material under different compression deformation. Figure 24 is the deformation diagram of the compression test block under different compression deformation. Fig. 23Compressive strength value under different compression deformation. Compressive strength value under different compression deformation. Fig. 24Deformation diagram under different compression deformation. Deformation diagram under different compression deformation. The tensile strength of the traditional shotcrete material (C20 strength) is about 1 MPa, and the tensile deformation is less than 0.01%. Under the influence of uneven dynamic pressure of roadway, the material is easy to be damaged by tension. The shotcrete layer is cracked and voided. The ductile thin spraying material has the characteristics of high tensile strength and large tensile deformation. Its tensile strength curve under different tensile deformation is shown in Fig. 25, and the deformation before and after tensile deformation is shown in Fig. 26. Fig. 25Tensile strength value under different compression deformation. Tensile strength value under different compression deformation. Fig. 26Deformation diagram before and after stretching. Deformation diagram before and after stretching. The ductile thin spraying material has strong ductileness, absolute flame retardant and antistatic properties, and meets the coal safety standard (MT113-1995). The spraying effect is good. The relevant test photos are shown in Fig. 27. The flash point, maximum reaction temperature, curing time and surface resistance of the thin spraying material in the flame-retardant performance have been tested professionally, and the test results are shown in Table 6. Fig. 27Material properties test char. Material properties test char. Table 6Test results of flame retardancy of thin spraying materials.No.Inspection itemTechnical requirementsInspection resultConclusion1Flash point(°C)Component A≥ 100 and above the maximum reaction temperatureNot detectedQualifiedComponent B/2Maximum reaction temperature(°C)≤ 14032Qualified3Curing timeSurface dry time(h)≤ 20.2QualifiedActual dry time(h)≤ 60.64Flame retardant propertiescombustion test of alcohol blowtorchAverage value of flaming combustion time(s)≤ 3.000QualifiedAverage value of flameless combustion time(s)≤ 10.002.92Average flame spread length(mm)≤ 28022Alcohol lamp combustion testAverage value of flaming combustion time(s)≤ 6.000Average value of flameless combustion time(s)≤ 20.002.27Average flame spread length(mm)≤ 250185Surface resistanceAverage value of upper surface resistance(Ω)≤ 3.0 × 1085.9 × 107QualifiedAverage value of lower surface resistance(Ω)6.3 × 107 Table 6Test results of flame retardancy of thin spraying materials.No.Inspection itemTechnical requirementsInspection resultConclusion1Flash point(°C)Component A≥ 100 and above the maximum reaction temperatureNot detectedQualifiedComponent B/2Maximum reaction temperature(°C)≤ 14032Qualified3Curing timeSurface dry time(h)≤ 20.2QualifiedActual dry time(h)≤ 60.64Flame retardant propertiescombustion test of alcohol blowtorchAverage value of flaming combustion time(s)≤ 3.000QualifiedAverage value of flameless combustion time(s)≤ 10.002.92Average flame spread length(mm)≤ 28022Alcohol lamp combustion testAverage value of flaming combustion time(s)≤ 6.000Average value of flameless combustion time(s)≤ 20.002.27Average flame spread length(mm)≤ 250185Surface resistanceAverage value of upper surface resistance(Ω)≤ 3.0 × 1085.9 × 107QualifiedAverage value of lower surface resistance(Ω)6.3 × 107 Test results of flame retardancy of thin spraying materials. Supporting spraying equipment The technology is equipped with a special pneumatic spraying pump. The spraying pressure is controlled at 0.4-0.6 MPa. The spray gun is 0.8–1.2 m away from the rock surface. The thickness of each layer is about 3–5 mm until the total design thickness is 10–15 mm. The relevant physical drawings of the supporting equipment are shown in Fig. 28. The performance parameters of the spraying pump are shown in Table 7. Fig. 28Schematic diagram of physical equipment. Schematic diagram of physical equipment. Table 7Performance parameters of special spray pump for ductile thin spraying material.ProjectUnitValueOutput pressureMPa1.8Spraying construction delivery distancem≥ 20Spray paint flowL/min≥ 12Gas consumptionm3/ min≤ 4Sound power leveldB≤ 90Equipment sizemm1500*400*1000(L*W*H)Equipment weightkg120 Table 7Performance parameters of special spray pump for ductile thin spraying material.ProjectUnitValueOutput pressureMPa1.8Spraying construction delivery distancem≥ 20Spray paint flowL/min≥ 12Gas consumptionm3/ min≤ 4Sound power leveldB≤ 90Equipment sizemm1500*400*1000(L*W*H)Equipment weightkg120 Performance parameters of special spray pump for ductile thin spraying material. Construction technology The on-site construction process flow chart of spraying materials is shown in Fig. 29: Fig. 29Site construction process flow chart. Site construction process flow chart. The process flow is as follows:Equipment preparationThe equipment is in place and leveled, the pump head is slightly lower, the high-pressure air duct is connected, and each joint is checked to ensure that there is no air leakage. Pumping test pumpStart the pump after adding water and mixing, observe the effect of water and atomization, fully open the air valve test equipment and air pressure state. MixturePrepare according to A: B = 1:1 (weight ratio), add component A (liquid material) first, and then slowly add component B (powder material), stir slowly for 2 ~ 3 min until it is uniform and flowing, and avoid over stirring until it is thick. Spraying and punchingStart atomization after the discharge is normal, the spraying distance is 1 ~ 2 m, and the thickness of the single layer is about 5 mm. Adopt a straight line or spiral spraying, follow the principle of “overall first and then local”, and the anchor net can be sprayed near but free from sagging; Cracks or pipe holes shall be blocked before spraying. Each bin shall be sprayed within 10 min. Construction rhythmThe single spraying area is 5 ~ 8 m ², taking 5 ~ 10 min, and the efficiency is about 1 ~ 2 m ²/min. Each shift shall complete at least 10 linear meters to ensure continuous operation. Device movementThe pipeline is about 10 m long, the equipment is portable and easy to move, the position is adjusted with the progress, and the materials are stacked nearby. Cleaning and maintenanceClean the mixing bin after spraying 3–4 groups of materials; After the completion of construction, thoroughly clean the mixing paddle, bin body, gun head and pipeline, repeatedly wash with clean water and compressed air, and the gun head needs to be disassembled and cleaned. Fill the air inlet of the pneumatic motor with oil for lubrication.ClosingClean up the site and carry out civilized construction. Equipment preparationThe equipment is in place and leveled, the pump head is slightly lower, the high-pressure air duct is connected, and each joint is checked to ensure that there is no air leakage. Equipment preparation The equipment is in place and leveled, the pump head is slightly lower, the high-pressure air duct is connected, and each joint is checked to ensure that there is no air leakage. Pumping test pumpStart the pump after adding water and mixing, observe the effect of water and atomization, fully open the air valve test equipment and air pressure state. Pumping test pump Start the pump after adding water and mixing, observe the effect of water and atomization, fully open the air valve test equipment and air pressure state. MixturePrepare according to A: B = 1:1 (weight ratio), add component A (liquid material) first, and then slowly add component B (powder material), stir slowly for 2 ~ 3 min until it is uniform and flowing, and avoid over stirring until it is thick. Mixture Prepare according to A: B = 1:1 (weight ratio), add component A (liquid material) first, and then slowly add component B (powder material), stir slowly for 2 ~ 3 min until it is uniform and flowing, and avoid over stirring until it is thick. Spraying and punchingStart atomization after the discharge is normal, the spraying distance is 1 ~ 2 m, and the thickness of the single layer is about 5 mm. Adopt a straight line or spiral spraying, follow the principle of “overall first and then local”, and the anchor net can be sprayed near but free from sagging; Cracks or pipe holes shall be blocked before spraying. Each bin shall be sprayed within 10 min. Spraying and punching Start atomization after the discharge is normal, the spraying distance is 1 ~ 2 m, and the thickness of the single layer is about 5 mm. Adopt a straight line or spiral spraying, follow the principle of “overall first and then local”, and the anchor net can be sprayed near but free from sagging; Cracks or pipe holes shall be blocked before spraying. Each bin shall be sprayed within 10 min. Construction rhythmThe single spraying area is 5 ~ 8 m ², taking 5 ~ 10 min, and the efficiency is about 1 ~ 2 m ²/min. Each shift shall complete at least 10 linear meters to ensure continuous operation. Construction rhythm The single spraying area is 5 ~ 8 m ², taking 5 ~ 10 min, and the efficiency is about 1 ~ 2 m ²/min. Each shift shall complete at least 10 linear meters to ensure continuous operation. Device movementThe pipeline is about 10 m long, the equipment is portable and easy to move, the position is adjusted with the progress, and the materials are stacked nearby. Device movement The pipeline is about 10 m long, the equipment is portable and easy to move, the position is adjusted with the progress, and the materials are stacked nearby. Cleaning and maintenanceClean the mixing bin after spraying 3–4 groups of materials; After the completion of construction, thoroughly clean the mixing paddle, bin body, gun head and pipeline, repeatedly wash with clean water and compressed air, and the gun head needs to be disassembled and cleaned. Fill the air inlet of the pneumatic motor with oil for lubrication. Cleaning and maintenance Clean the mixing bin after spraying 3–4 groups of materials; After the completion of construction, thoroughly clean the mixing paddle, bin body, gun head and pipeline, repeatedly wash with clean water and compressed air, and the gun head needs to be disassembled and cleaned. Fill the air inlet of the pneumatic motor with oil for lubrication. ClosingClean up the site and carry out civilized construction. Closing Clean up the site and carry out civilized construction. Construction quality evaluation Mine pressure monitoring scheme To verify the rationality and correctness of the new ductileness thin spraying technology, mining pressure observation and support effect evaluation were conducted on the experimental roadway. Monitoring method of roadway surface displacement Monitoring method of roadway surface displacement Monitoring method of roadway surface displacement The cross-point method is used to install the roadway displacement monitoring section, as shown in Fig. 30. Drill φ 30 mm and 400 mm deep holes vertically in the middle of the top and bottom plates and horizontally on both sides, and drive φ 32 mm and 400 mm deep wooden piles into the holes. Bent measuring nails shall be installed at the ends of top plate and upper side wooden piles, and flat headed measuring nails shall be installed at the ends of bottom plate and lower side wooden piles. The two monitoring sections are 0.6 ~ 1.0 m apart along the axial direction of the roadway. Observation method: tension the measuring line between the two side nails C and D, tension the steel tape between a and B, and measure and read the AO and ab values; Tension the measuring rope between a and B, tension the steel tape between C and D, and measure and read the CO and CD values; The measurement accuracy is required to be 1 mm and estimated to be 0.5 mm; the leather tape is used to measure the distance between the monitoring section and the heading face. The measurement frequency is: within 50 m from the working face, it is observed once a day, and 1 ~ 2 times a week at other times. Fig. 30Roadway surface monitoring displacement section. Roadway surface monitoring displacement section. (2)Quality monitoring method of bolt and cable (2)Quality monitoring method of bolt and cable Quality monitoring method of bolt and cable CMW 3.7 bolt nondestructive tester is used to monitor the stress of the bolt (cable) in the test roadway area, which provides a basis for the later evaluation of the effect of spraying support. The device diagram of CMW 3.7 anchor nondestructive tester is shown in Fig. 31. Fig. 31CMW 3.7 bolt elastic wave nondestructive testing instrument. CMW 3.7 bolt elastic wave nondestructive testing instrument. (3)Station layout (3)Station layout Station layout The layout of the mining pressure measurement station is shown in Fig. 32. To facilitate analysis and comparison, the mining pressure data from A3 and B3 measurement stations were selected for comparison. Fig. 32Schematic diagram of station layout. Schematic diagram of station layout. Analysis of mine pressure monitoring results Observation of surface displacement in roadways Observation of surface displacement in roadways Observation of surface displacement in roadways The deformation curve of the surrounding rock is shown in Fig. 33, and the statistical table of the deformation of the roadway surrounding rock is shown in Table 8. From the observation results, it can be seen that the overall deformation of the surrounding rock in the unpainted area is significantly greater than that in the sprayed area. Among them, the subsidence of the roadway roof is 32 mm and 17 mm respectively, the two sides move closer by 280 mm and 75 mm respectively, and the bottom bulge is 64 mm and 33 mm respectively. Combined with the geological conditions of the roadway (see Sect. 2 for details), monitoring station B3 (unspraying area) is located in the area where the roadway crosses the structure, and the roof lithology is mainly unstable sandy mudstone, which is the main reason for the convergence of its two sides (280 mm) is much larger than that of A3 spraying area (81 mm). The ductile thin spray sealed the rock surface in time, effectively inhibited the weathering and deliquescence of the weak rock mass, and thus significantly controlled the deformation. It can be seen that the ductileness thin spraying technology has a good control effect on the overall deformation of the roadway surrounding rock. Table 8Statistical table of roadway surrounding rock deformation.Monitoring station NoRoof Subsidence / mmIndentation of two sides / mmFloor heave / mmA3188133B33228064 Table 8Statistical table of roadway surrounding rock deformation.Monitoring station NoRoof Subsidence / mmIndentation of two sides / mmFloor heave / mmA3188133B33228064 Statistical table of roadway surrounding rock deformation. Fig. 33Deformation curve of surrounding rock of roadway. Deformation curve of surrounding rock of roadway. (2)Observation of the force state of roadway support components (2)Observation of the force state of roadway support components Observation of the force state of roadway support components The statistical table of axial force of supporting components is shown in Table 9. According to the force state of the supporting components, it can be seen that the axial force values of the anchor cable in the unpainted area are generally large, and the stress is uneven (the axial forces of each component vary greatly); The axial force value of the anchor cable in the spraying area is relatively small, and the force is relatively uniform (with small differences in axial force among various components), further indicating that the ductile thin spraying material has good ductileness and adaptability to large deformation when the roadway is disturbed by mining stress, and can absorb some energy, thereby achieving the goal of reducing the peak load of the anchor cable. Table 9Statistical table of axial force of supporting components.Monitoring station NoSupport component NoRoofcable/KNRoofbolt/KNSidebolt/KNA3131013813423201451423315140138B3136817216823851901853375180174 Table 9Statistical table of axial force of supporting components.Monitoring station NoSupport component NoRoofcable/KNRoofbolt/KNSidebolt/KNA3131013813423201451423315140138B3136817216823851901853375180174 Statistical table of axial force of supporting components. (3)Site construction effect (3)Site construction effect Site construction effect In order to more intuitively compare the spraying effect and quality of the sprayed area and the non-sprayed area of the roadway, the field spraying effect of each part of the roadway is compared. See Fig. 34 , 35, 36 for details. Fig. 34Deformation curve of surrounding rock of roadway. Deformation curve of surrounding rock of roadway. Fig. 35Comparison drawing before and after roadway side spraying. Comparison drawing before and after roadway side spraying. Fig. 36Comparison drawing before and after roof spraying. Comparison drawing before and after roof spraying. From the mine pressure monitoring data and the field construction effect, it can be seen that the ductile thin spraying coating has great benefits for the control effect of roadway surrounding rock deformation and the improvement of the stability of roadway support system. Comparison of economic and social benefits Economic benefits Economic benefits Economic benefits The direct economic cost comparison table of the new ductileness thin spraying technology compared to traditional spraying technology is shown in Table 10. Table 10Direct Economic Cost Comparison Table.Cost accounting itemsTraditional spraying costCost of new ductile thin spray materialRemarksRoadway section parametersthe length * width is 5.5 * 3.5 m, and the circumference is 12.5 m1. The cost of spraying materials is 12,000 yuan/ton.2. The cost of traditional concrete spraying materials is calculated based on the general cost of spraying materials for roadway design, which is 390 RMB/m ³ (referring to the cost accounting of spraying materials in various mines of Jinmei Group).Comparison of spray thickness100 mm10 mmComparison of material coststhe material used per linear meter is 1.25 m ³, and based on 2.35 t/m ³ of concrete, the material used is approximately 2.9 tons, with a material cost of approximately 487.5 RMB per linear metereach linear meter uses 0.125 m ³ of material, approximately 0.12 tons of material, and the material cost is 1440 RMBComparison of labor costs for spray painting constructioneach shift requires 3–5 people, with a cost of 5 * 300 RMB per person, totaling 1500RMB, each shift can construct 5 linear meters, and the labor cost for spraying construction is 300 RMB/linear metereach shift consists of 2 people, with a cost of 2 * 300 RMB per person, a total of 600 RMB, each shift can construct 10 linear meters, and the labor cost for spraying is 60 RMB per linear meterComparison of material transportation costseach shift consists of 5 people and an additional forklift, with a cost of approximately 2000 RMB, it can transport 12 vehicles of materials and calculate the rebound by 10%, which is enough for one shift to spray 5 m, therefore, the shipping cost per linear meter of material is 400 RMBthe transportation cost is calculated at one twenty fourth of the traditional construction method, which is about 6 RMB per linear meter.Comparison of total cost per linear meter1187.5 RMB1506 RMBCost required for 500 m test length594,000 RMB753,000 RMBComparison of spraying schedule50 day25 dayComparison of material costs for a test length of 500 m1450 tons of spraying material are required to be consumed, the material cost is about 226,000 RMB60 tons of spraying material are required to be consumed(no rebound), the material cost is about 720,000 RMBComparison of labor costs for a test length of 500 m368,000 RMB33,000 RMB The direct economic and technological comparison between traditional spraying equipment and new ductileness thin spraying equipment has not been considered, in addition, the unit price of traditional shotcrete materials (390 RMB/m ³) and the unit price of labor and transportation in the table refer to the average cost accounting price of shotcrete materials of Mines under Jincheng Coal Group in 2025. Table 10Direct Economic Cost Comparison Table.Cost accounting itemsTraditional spraying costCost of new ductile thin spray materialRemarksRoadway section parametersthe length * width is 5.5 * 3.5 m, and the circumference is 12.5 m1. The cost of spraying materials is 12,000 yuan/ton.2. The cost of traditional concrete spraying materials is calculated based on the general cost of spraying materials for roadway design, which is 390 RMB/m ³ (referring to the cost accounting of spraying materials in various mines of Jinmei Group).Comparison of spray thickness100 mm10 mmComparison of material coststhe material used per linear meter is 1.25 m ³, and based on 2.35 t/m ³ of concrete, the material used is approximately 2.9 tons, with a material cost of approximately 487.5 RMB per linear metereach linear meter uses 0.125 m ³ of material, approximately 0.12 tons of material, and the material cost is 1440 RMBComparison of labor costs for spray painting constructioneach shift requires 3–5 people, with a cost of 5 * 300 RMB per person, totaling 1500RMB, each shift can construct 5 linear meters, and the labor cost for spraying construction is 300 RMB/linear metereach shift consists of 2 people, with a cost of 2 * 300 RMB per person, a total of 600 RMB, each shift can construct 10 linear meters, and the labor cost for spraying is 60 RMB per linear meterComparison of material transportation costseach shift consists of 5 people and an additional forklift, with a cost of approximately 2000 RMB, it can transport 12 vehicles of materials and calculate the rebound by 10%, which is enough for one shift to spray 5 m, therefore, the shipping cost per linear meter of material is 400 RMBthe transportation cost is calculated at one twenty fourth of the traditional construction method, which is about 6 RMB per linear meter.Comparison of total cost per linear meter1187.5 RMB1506 RMBCost required for 500 m test length594,000 RMB753,000 RMBComparison of spraying schedule50 day25 dayComparison of material costs for a test length of 500 m1450 tons of spraying material are required to be consumed, the material cost is about 226,000 RMB60 tons of spraying material are required to be consumed(no rebound), the material cost is about 720,000 RMBComparison of labor costs for a test length of 500 m368,000 RMB33,000 RMB The direct economic and technological comparison between traditional spraying equipment and new ductileness thin spraying equipment has not been considered, in addition, the unit price of traditional shotcrete materials (390 RMB/m ³) and the unit price of labor and transportation in the table refer to the average cost accounting price of shotcrete materials of Mines under Jincheng Coal Group in 2025. Direct Economic Cost Comparison Table. 1. The cost of spraying materials is 12,000 yuan/ton. 2. The cost of traditional concrete spraying materials is calculated based on the general cost of spraying materials for roadway design, which is 390 RMB/m ³ (referring to the cost accounting of spraying materials in various mines of Jinmei Group). The direct economic and technological comparison between traditional spraying equipment and new ductileness thin spraying equipment has not been considered, in addition, the unit price of traditional shotcrete materials (390 RMB/m ³) and the unit price of labor and transportation in the table refer to the average cost accounting price of shotcrete materials of Mines under Jincheng Coal Group in 2025. From the table, it can be seen that although traditional spraying technology has certain advantages in material costs, it cannot be compared with the new ductileness thin spraying technology in specific construction environments, labor costs, material consumption, transportation, and other aspects. Overall, traditional spraying technology does not have an economic advantage. (2)Social benefits① It can work in parallel with roadway excavation: shorten the support time of each cycle by about 2 h, and improve the excavation efficiency by 15% -20%. The new ductile thin spraying technology has a short curing time (usually reaching the initial strength within 30 min), supports spraying while driving, avoids the bottleneck that the traditional shotcreting needs to wait more than 8 h to continue driving, and significantly improves the continuity of operation.② Construction environment friendly: the dust concentration in the construction site is reduced to below 10 mg/m ³, and the measured value of some projects can be controlled at 8 mg/m ³, which is far lower than the standard of 20 mg/m ³ in the national code for the construction of green mines, meeting the requirements of environment-friendly construction in the mining area.③ It is conducive to improving the gas drainage efficiency of the bottom drainage roadway: the tightness of the roadway surface is improved, and it is estimated that the gas drainage efficiency of the drainage roadway can be increased by about 9% to 35%. Because the spray layer is firmly bonded with the surrounding rock and has strong deformation adaptability, the gas escape channel is reduced, and the hole sealing quality and drainage concentration are improved.④ Improving the effectiveness of roadway anchor mesh support: effectively controlling the deformation of surrounding rock, significantly improving the reliability of roadway support, thereby greatly reducing the possibility of roof collapse accidents in anchor mesh support and improving the safety of workers’ working environment. (2)Social benefits① It can work in parallel with roadway excavation: shorten the support time of each cycle by about 2 h, and improve the excavation efficiency by 15% -20%. The new ductile thin spraying technology has a short curing time (usually reaching the initial strength within 30 min), supports spraying while driving, avoids the bottleneck that the traditional shotcreting needs to wait more than 8 h to continue driving, and significantly improves the continuity of operation.② Construction environment friendly: the dust concentration in the construction site is reduced to below 10 mg/m ³, and the measured value of some projects can be controlled at 8 mg/m ³, which is far lower than the standard of 20 mg/m ³ in the national code for the construction of green mines, meeting the requirements of environment-friendly construction in the mining area.③ It is conducive to improving the gas drainage efficiency of the bottom drainage roadway: the tightness of the roadway surface is improved, and it is estimated that the gas drainage efficiency of the drainage roadway can be increased by about 9% to 35%. Because the spray layer is firmly bonded with the surrounding rock and has strong deformation adaptability, the gas escape channel is reduced, and the hole sealing quality and drainage concentration are improved.④ Improving the effectiveness of roadway anchor mesh support: effectively controlling the deformation of surrounding rock, significantly improving the reliability of roadway support, thereby greatly reducing the possibility of roof collapse accidents in anchor mesh support and improving the safety of workers’ working environment. Social benefits① It can work in parallel with roadway excavation: shorten the support time of each cycle by about 2 h, and improve the excavation efficiency by 15% -20%. The new ductile thin spraying technology has a short curing time (usually reaching the initial strength within 30 min), supports spraying while driving, avoids the bottleneck that the traditional shotcreting needs to wait more than 8 h to continue driving, and significantly improves the continuity of operation.② Construction environment friendly: the dust concentration in the construction site is reduced to below 10 mg/m ³, and the measured value of some projects can be controlled at 8 mg/m ³, which is far lower than the standard of 20 mg/m ³ in the national code for the construction of green mines, meeting the requirements of environment-friendly construction in the mining area.③ It is conducive to improving the gas drainage efficiency of the bottom drainage roadway: the tightness of the roadway surface is improved, and it is estimated that the gas drainage efficiency of the drainage roadway can be increased by about 9% to 35%. Because the spray layer is firmly bonded with the surrounding rock and has strong deformation adaptability, the gas escape channel is reduced, and the hole sealing quality and drainage concentration are improved.④ Improving the effectiveness of roadway anchor mesh support: effectively controlling the deformation of surrounding rock, significantly improving the reliability of roadway support, thereby greatly reducing the possibility of roof collapse accidents in anchor mesh support and improving the safety of workers’ working environment. ① It can work in parallel with roadway excavation: shorten the support time of each cycle by about 2 h, and improve the excavation efficiency by 15% -20%. The new ductile thin spraying technology has a short curing time (usually reaching the initial strength within 30 min), supports spraying while driving, avoids the bottleneck that the traditional shotcreting needs to wait more than 8 h to continue driving, and significantly improves the continuity of operation. It can work in parallel with roadway excavation: shorten the support time of each cycle by about 2 h, and improve the excavation efficiency by 15% -20%. The new ductile thin spraying technology has a short curing time (usually reaching the initial strength within 30 min), supports spraying while driving, avoids the bottleneck that the traditional shotcreting needs to wait more than 8 h to continue driving, and significantly improves the continuity of operation. ② Construction environment friendly: the dust concentration in the construction site is reduced to below 10 mg/m ³, and the measured value of some projects can be controlled at 8 mg/m ³, which is far lower than the standard of 20 mg/m ³ in the national code for the construction of green mines, meeting the requirements of environment-friendly construction in the mining area. Construction environment friendly: the dust concentration in the construction site is reduced to below 10 mg/m ³, and the measured value of some projects can be controlled at 8 mg/m ³, which is far lower than the standard of 20 mg/m ³ in the national code for the construction of green mines, meeting the requirements of environment-friendly construction in the mining area. ③ It is conducive to improving the gas drainage efficiency of the bottom drainage roadway: the tightness of the roadway surface is improved, and it is estimated that the gas drainage efficiency of the drainage roadway can be increased by about 9% to 35%. Because the spray layer is firmly bonded with the surrounding rock and has strong deformation adaptability, the gas escape channel is reduced, and the hole sealing quality and drainage concentration are improved. It is conducive to improving the gas drainage efficiency of the bottom drainage roadway: the tightness of the roadway surface is improved, and it is estimated that the gas drainage efficiency of the drainage roadway can be increased by about 9% to 35%. Because the spray layer is firmly bonded with the surrounding rock and has strong deformation adaptability, the gas escape channel is reduced, and the hole sealing quality and drainage concentration are improved. ④ Improving the effectiveness of roadway anchor mesh support: effectively controlling the deformation of surrounding rock, significantly improving the reliability of roadway support, thereby greatly reducing the possibility of roof collapse accidents in anchor mesh support and improving the safety of workers’ working environment. Improving the effectiveness of roadway anchor mesh support: effectively controlling the deformation of surrounding rock, significantly improving the reliability of roadway support, thereby greatly reducing the possibility of roof collapse accidents in anchor mesh support and improving the safety of workers’ working environment. By adopting this technology, the surface protection efficiency of the roadway is higher and faster than traditional spray anchor support. At the same time, it significantly improves the excavation speed of the bottom pumping roadway, effectively alleviates the problem of mining connection, and is conducive to achieving high production and efficiency in the mine. From this, it can be seen that the industrial application effect of the new ductile thin spraying technology is good, which verifies the correctness of the technical support mechanism. At the same time, the new ductile thin spraying material replaces the traditional shotcrete material, which can greatly reduce the cost of underground transportation and labor, and is conducive to the rapid excavation of roadways; Moreover, it greatly improves the working environment of underground shotcrete, and the material itself is green and environmentally friendly, in line with the production concept of “safe, green, high-yield and high-efficiency” in mines. It can also effectively solve the problems of gas leakage in coal mine roadways, easy weathering of surrounding rocks, and rusting of supporting components. Moreover, the economic and social benefits are far greater than traditional shotcrete technology, and it has great promotion and application value. Conclusion This paper points out the problems in timely sealing and surface support of coal mine roadway surrounding rock, compares the advantages and disadvantages of roadway surrounding rock surface protection materials, and briefly summarizes the research progress and current shortcomings of domestic and foreign scholars on ductile thin spray materials. On the basis of analyzing the main problems and engineering geological conditions of the bottom extraction roadway in Changping Coal Mine, a new type of ductile thin spraying technology was proposed, and the main supporting mechanisms of the ductile thin spraying coating, namely surface protection and cooperative support, were theoretically analyzed in detail. Numerical simulations and comparative analysis were conducted using finite difference software FLAC3D and discrete element software 3DEC to investigate the effectiveness of new ductileness thin spray materials and traditional shotcrete materials in roadway support. The simulation results show that ductile thin spray materials are more conducive to improving the stress environment of shallow rock layers in roadway surrounding rock, enhancing the bearing capacity of roadway surrounding rock itself, suppressing the displacement and sliding of loose rock blocks between anchor cable, optimizing the force state of the entire support system, and greatly ensuring the stability of the roadway support system. They are particularly suitable for application in two types of coal rock roadways: “poor quality+medium hard rock/hard rock” and “general quality+soft rock/medium hard rock”. The new ductileness thin spraying technology was tested industrially and the spraying support effect was evaluated in the bottom extraction roadway of the Liupan area of Changping Coal Mine. The on-site measured mining pressure data shows that the new surface protection technology effectively controls the overall deformation of the roadway surrounding rock and improves the stability of the support system. The industrial application effect is good, significant economic and social benefits, further verifying the rationality and correctness of the new ductileness thin spraying technology. This paper points out the problems in timely sealing and surface support of coal mine roadway surrounding rock, compares the advantages and disadvantages of roadway surrounding rock surface protection materials, and briefly summarizes the research progress and current shortcomings of domestic and foreign scholars on ductile thin spray materials. This paper points out the problems in timely sealing and surface support of coal mine roadway surrounding rock, compares the advantages and disadvantages of roadway surrounding rock surface protection materials, and briefly summarizes the research progress and current shortcomings of domestic and foreign scholars on ductile thin spray materials. On the basis of analyzing the main problems and engineering geological conditions of the bottom extraction roadway in Changping Coal Mine, a new type of ductile thin spraying technology was proposed, and the main supporting mechanisms of the ductile thin spraying coating, namely surface protection and cooperative support, were theoretically analyzed in detail. On the basis of analyzing the main problems and engineering geological conditions of the bottom extraction roadway in Changping Coal Mine, a new type of ductile thin spraying technology was proposed, and the main supporting mechanisms of the ductile thin spraying coating, namely surface protection and cooperative support, were theoretically analyzed in detail. Numerical simulations and comparative analysis were conducted using finite difference software FLAC3D and discrete element software 3DEC to investigate the effectiveness of new ductileness thin spray materials and traditional shotcrete materials in roadway support. The simulation results show that ductile thin spray materials are more conducive to improving the stress environment of shallow rock layers in roadway surrounding rock, enhancing the bearing capacity of roadway surrounding rock itself, suppressing the displacement and sliding of loose rock blocks between anchor cable, optimizing the force state of the entire support system, and greatly ensuring the stability of the roadway support system. They are particularly suitable for application in two types of coal rock roadways: “poor quality+medium hard rock/hard rock” and “general quality+soft rock/medium hard rock”. Numerical simulations and comparative analysis were conducted using finite difference software FLAC3D and discrete element software 3DEC to investigate the effectiveness of new ductileness thin spray materials and traditional shotcrete materials in roadway support. The simulation results show that ductile thin spray materials are more conducive to improving the stress environment of shallow rock layers in roadway surrounding rock, enhancing the bearing capacity of roadway surrounding rock itself, suppressing the displacement and sliding of loose rock blocks between anchor cable, optimizing the force state of the entire support system, and greatly ensuring the stability of the roadway support system. They are particularly suitable for application in two types of coal rock roadways: “poor quality+medium hard rock/hard rock” and “general quality+soft rock/medium hard rock”. The new ductileness thin spraying technology was tested industrially and the spraying support effect was evaluated in the bottom extraction roadway of the Liupan area of Changping Coal Mine. The on-site measured mining pressure data shows that the new surface protection technology effectively controls the overall deformation of the roadway surrounding rock and improves the stability of the support system. The industrial application effect is good, significant economic and social benefits, further verifying the rationality and correctness of the new ductileness thin spraying technology. The new ductileness thin spraying technology was tested industrially and the spraying support effect was evaluated in the bottom extraction roadway of the Liupan area of Changping Coal Mine. The on-site measured mining pressure data shows that the new surface protection technology effectively controls the overall deformation of the roadway surrounding rock and improves the stability of the support system. The industrial application effect is good, significant economic and social benefits, further verifying the rationality and correctness of the new ductileness thin spraying technology.