Beyond the price tag: a scoping review of the determinants of informal payments in health systems and strategies for curbing them Authors: Faride Sadat Jalali, Najmeh Bordbar, Mohadeseh Ghanbari-Jahromi, Mohsen Bayati Published: 2026 ABSTRACT BackgroundInformal payments (IPs) remain a persistent challenge across health systems worldwide and may undermine equity, transparency, and public trust in healthcare delivery. Despite a growing body of research, evidence regarding the determinants of IPs and the strategies proposed to address them remains fragmented and lacks a comprehensive synthesis. This scoping review aimed to: (1) map and synthesize existing evidence on the key determinants of IPs in health systems globally; and (2) identify, categorize, and summarize the range of strategies proposed to curb them.MethodsFollowing the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology, we conducted a systematic search across five databases—PubMed, Web of Science, Scopus, ProQuest, and ScienceDirect—from database inception through January 2025. Two reviewers independently screened all records against predefined eligibility criteria. Data from the included studies were extracted using a standardized form and thematically analyzed.ResultsThis review synthesized evidence from 68 studies. Determinants of IPs were categorized into five interconnected levels: (1) patient-level factors (e.g., fear of poor-quality care, desire for faster services, and limited knowledge); (2) structural/contextual factors (e.g., underfunding, weak regulation, and type of service); (3) provider-level factors (e.g., low salaries and shortages of supplies); (4) cultural/ethical factors (e.g., norms of gratitude and social acceptance of informal payments); and (5) organizational-level factors (e.g., corruption and lack of accountability). Proposed interventions were grouped into five strategic categories: patient empowerment (education and patient-rights mechanisms); cultural-normative strategies (shifting social norms and fostering trust); financial strategies (improving provider remuneration, formalizing payments, and expanding insurance coverage); structural strategies (strengthening health systems and improving service accessibility); and governance and regulatory strategies (legal frameworks, oversight mechanisms, and sanctions). An analytical framework was developed to illustrate the mechanisms of action and key contextual considerations associated with each strategy, highlighting that implementation processes and outcomes are highly context dependent.ConclusionsIPs are a multifactorial phenomenon rooted in systemic weaknesses, economic incentives, and sociocultural norms. Isolated interventions are unlikely to be effective. Addressing IPs requires integrated, multi-pronged strategies that reduce financial pressures on providers, strengthen governance and transparency, improve service quality and accessibility, empower patients, and reshape cultural norms. This review provides a foundational evidence map to support the design of context-sensitive, system-level policies aimed at reducing and ultimately eliminating informal payments. Future research should evaluate the effectiveness and sustainability of interventions across diverse health system contexts, particularly in underrepresented settings, and further examine the institutional and contextual factors that perpetuate informal payment practices.Clinical trial numberNot applicable.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12913-026-14846-y. Background Informal payments (IPs) remain a persistent challenge across many health systems worldwide and have attracted increasing attention in health policy and health systems research [1]. Although the forms, drivers, and social meanings of these payments vary across contexts, IPs are widely recognized as practices that may undermine equity, transparency, accountability, and public trust in healthcare systems [2]. Existing evidence suggests that these practices are shaped by broader structural and governance-related factors, including resource constraints, weak regulatory oversight, and asymmetries in power and information between patients and providers. Despite the expanding body of research on IPs, important conceptual and contextual differences continue to complicate their interpretation and comparison across settings [3]. Informal payments (IPs) were defined as cash or in-kind contributions made by patients or their families outside formal payment mechanisms or approved tariffs for services to which they were officially entitled [4]. These payments take multiple forms, including cash payments for services that are formally free of charge, in-kind contributions offered in exchange for preferential treatment, and unofficial charges for essential medicines or supplies [5]. Their consequences are substantial, as they may expose households to catastrophic health expenditures, distort provider incentives, and divert resources away from formal health financing mechanisms [3, 6, 7]. Beyond their financial implications, IPs are embedded within broader sociocultural norms and often reflect governance weaknesses and structural dysfunctions within health systems [8, 9]. At the same time, their conceptual boundaries remain fluid. Practices described as “under-the-table payments,” “envelope payments,” or “gratuities” may exist along a continuum ranging from voluntary expressions of appreciation to coercive or implicitly expected payments associated with access to care, service quality, or timeliness of treatment [10, 11]. This conceptual variability further complicates cross-country comparisons and has important implications for both policy design and the interpretation of evidence [8]. IPs have been documented across a wide range of health systems, although reported prevalence varies considerably by country, type of service, and measurement approach, with estimates ranging from 2% to 80% in the reviewed literature [12]. Cross-national studies indicate that IPs remain prevalent in several Central and Eastern European countries, including Hungary, Bulgaria, and Ukraine, as well as across the EU-27 region [13, 14]. Similar practices have also been reported in countries such as Greece and Iran, alongside findings from comparative analyses conducted across multiple health systems [15–17]. Broader evidence syntheses and regional studies suggest that informal payments are driven by common structural and governance-related factors, although their manifestations and intensity differ across contexts [5, 9, 18]. In contrast, evidence from high-income countries such as the United States, the United Kingdom, and Canada appears relatively limited and less explicit in the literature. This may reflect both lower reported prevalence and differences in conceptual framing, terminology, measurement, and reporting practices [9]. Micro-level studies have highlighted the socioeconomic and cultural factors that shape patients’ decisions to provide or accept informal payments [5]. Qualitative research conducted across diverse settings has identified multiple drivers of IPs and proposed context-specific interventions to reduce these practices [10, 19, 20]. At the macro level, studies have demonstrated that structural reforms—such as market liberalization, privatization, and financial sector development—may reduce both the prevalence and frequency of informal payments [20]. More recent conceptual and policy-oriented research suggests that power imbalances, weak accountability mechanisms, and governance failures contribute to the persistence of these practices [21]. Complementary evidence from mixed-methods and participatory studies, including research conducted in Tanzania, further highlights the importance of engaging frontline health workers in identifying feasible and context-sensitive policy responses [22]. Despite this growing body of literature, the evidence remains fragmented and dispersed across different analytical perspectives, including policy recommendations, structural determinants, theoretical frameworks, and context-specific intervention designs. To date, no comprehensive synthesis has systematically mapped the multilevel determinants of IPs and linked them to the range of strategies proposed or implemented to address them. Such a synthesis is essential for informing holistic and evidence-informed policy responses. To address this gap, we conducted a scoping review with two objectives: [1] to map and synthesize the existing evidence on the key determinants of informal payments across health systems globally; and [2] to identify, categorize, and summarize the range of strategies, interventions, and policy approaches proposed in the literature to curb these payments. By integrating these findings, this review aims to provide a foundational resource for researchers and policymakers seeking to design context-sensitive, system-level interventions that promote equity, trust, and sustainability within health systems. Materials and methods This study employed a scoping review methodology based on the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) framework [23]. A five-stage process was undertaken to systematically identify, chart, and synthesize the existing evidence on the determinants of informal payments in health systems and the strategies proposed to address them. In this review, Informal payments (IPs) were defined as cash or in-kind contributions made by patients or their families outside formal payment mechanisms or approved tariffs for services to which they were officially entitled. This operational definition informed the eligibility criteria for study inclusion and was applied consistently throughout the screening and data extraction processes. The review began with the formulation of a central research question designed to guide all stages of the study: “What are the key determinants of informal payments in health systems, and what strategies have been proposed to reduce them?” This overarching question served as the foundation for identifying and synthesizing relevant evidence across diverse settings. To further structure the review, a specific research question was developed using the PCC framework (Population, Concept, and Context). The population included all healthcare facilities, the concept encompassed factors influencing informal payments and strategies aimed at reducing them, and the context covered health systems across all countries worldwide. To enhance methodological transparency, the eligibility criteria were organized according to the PCC framework (Table 1). Table 1Eligibility criteria based on the PCC frameworkComponentDescriptionPopulationAll health system actors involved in informal payment practices, including healthcare providers, health facilities, and patients involved in such practicesConcept(1) Factors, drivers, or determinants associated with informal payments; (2) strategies, interventions, or policy measures aimed at reducing or managing informal paymentsContextAll health system settings across countries, without restriction by income level, geographic region, or level of care Table 1Eligibility criteria based on the PCC frameworkComponentDescriptionPopulationAll health system actors involved in informal payment practices, including healthcare providers, health facilities, and patients involved in such practicesConcept(1) Factors, drivers, or determinants associated with informal payments; (2) strategies, interventions, or policy measures aimed at reducing or managing informal paymentsContextAll health system settings across countries, without restriction by income level, geographic region, or level of care Eligibility criteria based on the PCC framework To identify relevant literature, a systematic search was conducted across five electronic databases: PubMed, Web of Science, Scopus, ProQuest, and ScienceDirect. The search covered publications from database inception through January 2025. To ensure comprehensive coverage, two complementary search strategies were developed: the first focused on the informal nature of payments, while the second addressed the financial or payment-related dimension. Keywords within each strategy were combined using the “OR” operator, and the two strategies were subsequently linked using the “AND” operator to identify studies addressing both the informal and financial dimensions of payments within health systems. Detailed descriptions of the search strategies, including database-specific adaptations, are presented in Table 2 and Table S1 (Appendix). To improve the specificity and relevance of retrieved records, the search strategy primarily relied on title-based search terms. This approach was adopted because of the heterogeneous terminology used to describe informal payments in the literature and to facilitate the efficient identification of highly relevant studies while maintaining the feasibility of the screening process. Table 2The search strategyDatabases: PubMed, ISI Web of Science, Scopus, ProQuest, Science DirectLimits: English LanguageDate: from database inception to January 2025Strategy: #1 AND #2# 1Informal OR “Under-the-Counter” OR “Under-the-table” OR envelope OR “In kind” OR Gifts OR Illicit OR Solicited OR Gratuities OR Illegal OR Unofficial OR Bribes OR Gratitude OR Unauthorized OR Grey OR Gratuity# 2Payment OR Cost OR Expenditure OR “Out-of-pocket” OR Spend OR Expenses OR OOP OR Fees Table 2The search strategyDatabases: PubMed, ISI Web of Science, Scopus, ProQuest, Science DirectLimits: English LanguageDate: from database inception to January 2025Strategy: #1 AND #2# 1Informal OR “Under-the-Counter” OR “Under-the-table” OR envelope OR “In kind” OR Gifts OR Illicit OR Solicited OR Gratuities OR Illegal OR Unofficial OR Bribes OR Gratitude OR Unauthorized OR Grey OR Gratuity# 2Payment OR Cost OR Expenditure OR “Out-of-pocket” OR Spend OR Expenses OR OOP OR Fees The search strategy In this phase, predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria were applied to guide study selection. In accordance with the PCC framework (Table 1), studies were included if they examined factors associated with informal payments—such as economic, sociocultural, institutional, or governance-related determinants—or reported strategies, interventions, or policy measures aimed at reducing informal payments across any healthcare setting or country context. Eligible studies included original quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods research published in English, with full texts available for data extraction. Studies were excluded if they lacked a rigorous peer-review process or were categorized as book reviews, theoretical papers, review articles, or letters to the editor. Studies that did not explicitly address the determinants of informal payments or failed to report strategies or interventions aimed at reducing them were also excluded. The retrieved records were independently screened by two reviewers in three sequential stages: title screening, abstract screening, and full-text review. Any disagreements were resolved through discussion, and unresolved cases were referred to a third reviewer for final adjudication. Screening was conducted using EndNote version 21, which was used for reference management, organization of retrieved records, and removal of duplicate studies prior to screening. Data were extracted using a standardized form developed in Microsoft Excel 2019 in accordance with the predefined research objectives. The extraction form captured key information, including the first author, article title, publication year, study setting, participant characteristics, determinants of informal payments, and strategies proposed to reduce them. In this review, any payments reported in the included studies that occurred outside formal payment channels or official tariffs were considered informal payments, consistent with the operational definition adopted in the study. Data extraction was independently performed by two reviewers, and the extracted data were subsequently verified by a third reviewer to ensure accuracy and consistency. Consistent with scoping review methodology, no formal critical appraisal of the included studies was undertaken. However, studies with substantial reporting limitations or publication concerns (e.g., retracted articles or non-peer-reviewed sources) were excluded during the full-text review stage to ensure adequate quality and completeness of the extracted data. In the final stage, the findings were compiled, summarized, and reported. One researcher conducted a comprehensive review of all included studies and prepared detailed analytical notes. To enhance the reliability of the synthesis, a second researcher independently reviewed the analysis and verified the findings. Relevant data were then systematically entered into the extraction form according to the predefined information categories. This collaborative approach helped ensure that the data were accurately captured and consistently organized, thereby providing a robust foundation for subsequent synthesis and interpretation. Results The initial search identified 1,702 records. After the removal of 718 duplicates, 984 unique records remained for title screening. Following title screening, 809 records were excluded due to irrelevance. The abstracts of the remaining 175 records were then assessed for eligibility, leading to the exclusion of 64 studies. Subsequently, 111 full-text articles were retrieved and evaluated against the predefined inclusion criteria. Of these, 43 articles were excluded for the following reasons: failure to report determinants or interventions related to informal payments (n = 18), not meeting the predefined PCC-based inclusion criteria (n = 9), insufficient information for data extraction—including retracted publications, duplicate datasets, and overlapping reports (n = 14)—and unavailability of the full text (n = 2). Ultimately, 68 studies met all eligibility criteria and were included in the final scoping review for data extraction and synthesis (Fig. 1). Fig. 1PRISMA flow diagram for the systematic review process. * Insufficient information refers to studies with inadequate detail for data extraction, including retracted publications, duplicate datasets, and overlapping reports PRISMA flow diagram for the systematic review process. * Insufficient information refers to studies with inadequate detail for data extraction, including retracted publications, duplicate datasets, and overlapping reports Table 3 synthesizes the diverse determinants of informal payments (IPs) within health systems, categorizing them into five interconnected thematic levels based on the scoping review findings. Table 3Determinants of informal payments in health systemsThemeFactorsRefFrequencyPatient Individual-Level FactorsAgeYounger Age[14, 16, 17, 24, 25]5Older Age[26–31]6Household SizeNuclear households[14, 24, 27, 30]4Larger households[32]1Marital status (more in married patients)[33]1Employment StatusEmployed patients[14, 16, 29, 30, 34]5Unemployed patients[31, 32, 35]3Financial difficulties[14, 33, 36, 37, 38]5Patient’s desire for faster care[17, 28, 29, 39–50]15Patient’s fear of poor quality[18, 28, 29, 33, 39, 40, 43–46, 49–56]18Desire to get better attention[52]1Socioeconomic status[8, 36, 53, 57, 58]5Lack of patient knowledge of free services[17, 29, 38, 42, 51, 55, 59–61]9ResidencyRural residents[26, 35, 62]3Urban residents/ capital city[8, 16, 31, 32, 47, 56, 63–65]9Residence in the surrounding cities of the hospital[66]1Health Insurance (Protective effect due to better bargaining power and more awareness of their entitlements. More in Social versus private health insurance)[24, 26, 30, 32, 55, 56, 62, 67, 68]9Frequent healthcare users[69]1Health Status (more in chronic illnesses or poor health)[24, 26, 27, 32]4Education levelMore in lower-educated patients[24, 26, 64]3More highly educated patients[16, 27, 28, 34, 45, 56, 63, 66, 70]9SexBeing male[16, 24, 45]3Being female[17, 27, 28, 31, 63]5Income LevelHigh income[27, 28, 30, 32, 45, 54, 62, 65, 66, 68, 69, 71, 72]13Low income[16, 25, 31, 64, 70]5Low Satisfaction with Public Services[42]1Occupation (more likely in entrepreneurs, disabled persons, public/private sector employees, and retirees)[17, 28]2Recommendations from other patients[28]1Historical experience (more in patients who have had previous hospital visits or higher out-of-pocket payments in the past)[55]1Distrusted by physicians[64]1Communication skills (Poor communication between physicians and patients)[64]1Structural and Contextual FactorsInstitutional Asymmetry between formal and informal institutions[14, 25, 31, 70]4Lack of Financial Resources (lower health expenditures as a percentage of GDP)[8, 14, 16, 40, 43, 46, 49, 57, 73, 74]10Lower quality of government[14, 18, 31, 35, 54, 75]6Health System Performance (with higher death rates)[14, 18]2The stage of regional economic development[37]1Lack of long-term healthcare resources[37, 42, 43, 51, 55, 71]6The deteriorating condition of healthcare facilities[37]1Few consequences for soliciting fees in public-sector facilities[40, 59, 73]3Less oversight[38, 42–44, 49, 59, 75, 76]8Service Type (more in surgical procedures, inpatient care, diagnostics/investigations, pregnant women, dental and emergency services, acute illness/ medications/consumables/ cesarean sections compared to vaginal births)[17, 26, 32, 34, 47, 48, 50, 58, 60, 62, 65, 66, 67]13Location of care (higher in specialized care, and elite medical staff were concentrated)[26, 55, 63, 71]4lack of clarity in charging guidelines/ Weak Regulation,/ Lack of Automated Payment Systems instead of cash[17, 40, 43, 44, 56, 63, 73–76]10Sector TypePublic and social security institution[8, 33, 35]3Private sector[56, 62, 63, 66, 67]5Tariff-related Factors (Low/irrational tariffs)[46, 56]2Healthcare resource allocation (The unequal distribution of medical resources)[68]1Overcrowding of health centers[71]1Understaffing of health centers[71]1Provider Level FactorsCrowding-out effect of monetary incentives on intrinsic motivation[77]1Positive impact on individual doctor responsiveness[77]1Greater carryover effect on follow-up interactions[77]1Financial problems[36, 42, 44, 78]4Low salaries and wages[29, 37–42, 44, 49–51, 57, 59, 61, 72, 74, 75, 78]18Salary Delays[49, 59]2Have a higher standard of living[78]1Market-orientation[78]1Referral method[36, 63]2Family pressure[59]1Compensating for supply shortages (e.g., gloves, Sterilization tools)/ irregular supply of commodities[38, 47, 61, 75, 76]5Physician specialty (more in General surgeons, ophthalmologists, urologists, and otolaryngologists)[62, 66]2Moral Factors, such as the dilution of professional morals, reputation, and retaliation from patients and poorly motivated public servants[46, 49, 54]3Self-indulgence and greed[29]1Cultural and Ethical FactorsThe personality traits, moral conscience, and professional ethics of physicians[36]1The personality traits, moral conscience, and professional ethics of hospital staff[36]1Express gratitude for medical care.[28, 29, 33, 37, 38, 39, 42, 44, 45, 46, 49, 50, 51, 53, 56, 57, 58, 61, 71, 73–75]22To create a close connection with the physician for future treatment[37]1Social Norms & Acceptance/Positive Attitudes Toward IP[69, 70, 72]3Lower Trust in public authorities[18, 25, 69]3Organizational-Level FactorsCollusion Among Senior Staff[59]1Corruption[16, 18, 35, 41, 53, 59, 65]7Lack of Accountability[59, 73]2Job Security (in the public sector)[41]1Working Conditions (heavy workloads and lack of job specifications)[41, 43]2 Table 3Determinants of informal payments in health systemsThemeFactorsRefFrequencyPatient Individual-Level FactorsAgeYounger Age[14, 16, 17, 24, 25]5Older Age[26–31]6Household SizeNuclear households[14, 24, 27, 30]4Larger households[32]1Marital status (more in married patients)[33]1Employment StatusEmployed patients[14, 16, 29, 30, 34]5Unemployed patients[31, 32, 35]3Financial difficulties[14, 33, 36, 37, 38]5Patient’s desire for faster care[17, 28, 29, 39–50]15Patient’s fear of poor quality[18, 28, 29, 33, 39, 40, 43–46, 49–56]18Desire to get better attention[52]1Socioeconomic status[8, 36, 53, 57, 58]5Lack of patient knowledge of free services[17, 29, 38, 42, 51, 55, 59–61]9ResidencyRural residents[26, 35, 62]3Urban residents/ capital city[8, 16, 31, 32, 47, 56, 63–65]9Residence in the surrounding cities of the hospital[66]1Health Insurance (Protective effect due to better bargaining power and more awareness of their entitlements. More in Social versus private health insurance)[24, 26, 30, 32, 55, 56, 62, 67, 68]9Frequent healthcare users[69]1Health Status (more in chronic illnesses or poor health)[24, 26, 27, 32]4Education levelMore in lower-educated patients[24, 26, 64]3More highly educated patients[16, 27, 28, 34, 45, 56, 63, 66, 70]9SexBeing male[16, 24, 45]3Being female[17, 27, 28, 31, 63]5Income LevelHigh income[27, 28, 30, 32, 45, 54, 62, 65, 66, 68, 69, 71, 72]13Low income[16, 25, 31, 64, 70]5Low Satisfaction with Public Services[42]1Occupation (more likely in entrepreneurs, disabled persons, public/private sector employees, and retirees)[17, 28]2Recommendations from other patients[28]1Historical experience (more in patients who have had previous hospital visits or higher out-of-pocket payments in the past)[55]1Distrusted by physicians[64]1Communication skills (Poor communication between physicians and patients)[64]1Structural and Contextual FactorsInstitutional Asymmetry between formal and informal institutions[14, 25, 31, 70]4Lack of Financial Resources (lower health expenditures as a percentage of GDP)[8, 14, 16, 40, 43, 46, 49, 57, 73, 74]10Lower quality of government[14, 18, 31, 35, 54, 75]6Health System Performance (with higher death rates)[14, 18]2The stage of regional economic development[37]1Lack of long-term healthcare resources[37, 42, 43, 51, 55, 71]6The deteriorating condition of healthcare facilities[37]1Few consequences for soliciting fees in public-sector facilities[40, 59, 73]3Less oversight[38, 42–44, 49, 59, 75, 76]8Service Type (more in surgical procedures, inpatient care, diagnostics/investigations, pregnant women, dental and emergency services, acute illness/ medications/consumables/ cesarean sections compared to vaginal births)[17, 26, 32, 34, 47, 48, 50, 58, 60, 62, 65, 66, 67]13Location of care (higher in specialized care, and elite medical staff were concentrated)[26, 55, 63, 71]4lack of clarity in charging guidelines/ Weak Regulation,/ Lack of Automated Payment Systems instead of cash[17, 40, 43, 44, 56, 63, 73–76]10Sector TypePublic and social security institution[8, 33, 35]3Private sector[56, 62, 63, 66, 67]5Tariff-related Factors (Low/irrational tariffs)[46, 56]2Healthcare resource allocation (The unequal distribution of medical resources)[68]1Overcrowding of health centers[71]1Understaffing of health centers[71]1Provider Level FactorsCrowding-out effect of monetary incentives on intrinsic motivation[77]1Positive impact on individual doctor responsiveness[77]1Greater carryover effect on follow-up interactions[77]1Financial problems[36, 42, 44, 78]4Low salaries and wages[29, 37–42, 44, 49–51, 57, 59, 61, 72, 74, 75, 78]18Salary Delays[49, 59]2Have a higher standard of living[78]1Market-orientation[78]1Referral method[36, 63]2Family pressure[59]1Compensating for supply shortages (e.g., gloves, Sterilization tools)/ irregular supply of commodities[38, 47, 61, 75, 76]5Physician specialty (more in General surgeons, ophthalmologists, urologists, and otolaryngologists)[62, 66]2Moral Factors, such as the dilution of professional morals, reputation, and retaliation from patients and poorly motivated public servants[46, 49, 54]3Self-indulgence and greed[29]1Cultural and Ethical FactorsThe personality traits, moral conscience, and professional ethics of physicians[36]1The personality traits, moral conscience, and professional ethics of hospital staff[36]1Express gratitude for medical care.[28, 29, 33, 37, 38, 39, 42, 44, 45, 46, 49, 50, 51, 53, 56, 57, 58, 61, 71, 73–75]22To create a close connection with the physician for future treatment[37]1Social Norms & Acceptance/Positive Attitudes Toward IP[69, 70, 72]3Lower Trust in public authorities[18, 25, 69]3Organizational-Level FactorsCollusion Among Senior Staff[59]1Corruption[16, 18, 35, 41, 53, 59, 65]7Lack of Accountability[59, 73]2Job Security (in the public sector)[41]1Working Conditions (heavy workloads and lack of job specifications)[41, 43]2 Determinants of informal payments in health systems The most extensively documented category is patient individual-level factors, which encompasses a wide range of demographic, socioeconomic, and psychosocial variables. Notably, fear of poor-quality care (frequency: 18) and the desire for faster access to care (frequency: 15) are the most frequently reported psychological drivers. Demographic determinants show heterogeneous associations: IPs are linked to both higher and lower income levels, varying levels of education, and mixed evidence regarding sex differences. Other important factors include limited awareness of entitlements to free services, health insurance status (which is generally protective), and place of residence. At the structural and contextual level, systemic weaknesses emerge as key drivers. These include insufficient health financing, weak regulatory frameworks, unclear charging guidelines, and inadequate oversight mechanisms. The type of service is also a strong predictor of IPs, with surgical, inpatient, and emergency services showing the strongest associations. Provider-level factors are primarily driven by economic pressures, with low salaries and wages being the most frequently cited determinant across the entire review. Additional factors include efforts to compensate for supply shortages and various motivational and ethical considerations among providers. Cultural and ethical factors highlight the normative dimension of IPs. The most commonly reported factor in this category is the perception of informal payments as a form of gratitude for care, illustrating how social norms may normalize or legitimize such practices. Acceptance of IPs within social norms and lower trust in public institutions further reinforce their persistence. Finally, organizational-level factors reflect institutional weaknesses, with corruption identified as the most frequently reported issue, followed by lack of accountability. Overall, this multi-level classification demonstrates that informal payments are a complex, multifactorial phenomenon, requiring comprehensive strategies that address all contributing dimensions simultaneously. Table 4 categorizes and synthesizes the broad range of strategies and interventions proposed in the literature to curb informal payments (IPs) in health systems. These interventions are organized into five main conceptual categories, each addressing a key dimension of the problem. The relative frequency (%) of each strategy, presented in the final column, reflects its prominence and level of attention in the reviewed studies. Table 4Proposed interventions to curb informal payments in health systemsIntervention CategoryStrategy FocusSuggested InterventionFrequency %Patient EmpowermentAwareness & Educationclarification of patients’ entitlements [14, 30, 38, 46, 55, 56, 59]public awareness campaigns about the negative effects of informal payments on equity and access to healthcare [16, 22, 32, 35, 36, 40, 41, 46, 47, 59, 61–63, 65, 66, 71, 73, 74, 79, 80]Comprehensive Patient Education [54, 81–83]treatment information transparency [37, 45, 55, 65]communication skills training [64]69.6%Rights & Accountabilityformalized patient rights procedures [34, 38, 48, 59, 79]Establishing transparent complaint channels [34, 48, 63, 64, 80]17.4%Cultural-NormativeShifting Social Normscampaigns to distinguish gifts from bribes [14, 16, 40, 41]de-normalization of gratitude payments [36]Shifting Social Norms through Targeted Campaigns & Public Discourse [18, 32, 46, 48]Engaging Religious Leaders and Institutions [79]21.7%Fostering Social Contracteducational campaigns on the link between tax payments and healthcare funding [14, 35]Building Trust between patients and physicians through Systemic Performance [41, 64]8.7%Quality & InfrastructureEnhancing service quality & infrastructure [14, 18, 24, 41, 62, 83, 84]15.2%Payment Systems ModernizationPayment reforms (like electronic or insurance-only transactions) [14, 22]4.3%Addressing Specific ConcernsAddressing Gender Disparities in Informal Payments [16]Addressing Patient Fears of Retaliation [63]4.3%FinancialSystemic FinancingIncreasing Health Funding and Systemic Investment in Healthcare [14, 38, 40, 46, 47, 72, 73]Rationalizing Tariff Structures [30, 44, 46, 56, 62, 80]23.9%Provider IncentivesImproving Formal Remuneration [35, 36, 48, 49, 73]Raising base Physicians’ Salaries [34, 37, 41, 44, 46, 50, 54, 59, 61, 81–83]Fee-for-service models [35, 38]Implementing performance-based pay [22, 35, 49, 67, 74, 80]Alternative Payment Models like Capitation [56]45.7%Formalizing PaymentsFormalizing Informal Payments and gifts in kind [18, 33, 34, 37, 49, 63, 67, 75, 81, 82, 85]Creating Channels for Voluntary Contributions [41, 66, 72]Paid Afternoon Clinics in public hospitals [34]Formalizing co-payments [37, 50, 84]Ensuring Fee Exemptions for the poor and vulnerable Groups [41, 49, 84, 85]37.0%TransparencyTransparency in Fee Structures [16, 38, 59, 74]Transparency in Regulation [74, 84]Simplification of Payment Systems [73]10.9%StructuralEquity & FinancingTargeted Redistribution Mechanisms (24)2.2%System StrengtheningDirect Facility Financing [22, 41, 61, 71]Systemic Supply-Side Strengthening [65, 67]Expanding Service Access [14, 18, 47]Reducing Wait Times [14, 56]Ensuring Fair Geographic Distribution of Services [44]Streamlining Administrative Procedures [48]21.7%Health InsuranceExpanding and strengthening health insurance coverage (SHI/PHI/UHC) [24, 30, 32, 34, 35, 37, 41, 44, 48, 50, 55, 56, 62, 66, 68, 80]Reforming Health Insurance to reduce out-of-pocket payments [55, 66, 68, 71]Defining an Essential Health Services/Benefits Package [46, 63]Reforming Health Financing [16, 41]Inclusion of Specific Services in UHC (family planning services, supplies) [38, 67, 79]47.8%Private Sector & ModelsEncouraging Regulated Private Sector Involvement & Market Competition (e.g., by introducing private healthcare facilities and insurance) [33, 35, 54, 55, 68, 84]Implementing a Gatekeeping Referral System & Family Physician Programs [44, 56, 63]17.4%Digitalization & SystemsImplementing Electronic Health Records [17] [79]2.2%Governance & RegulatoryTransparency & AccountabilityEnhancing Transparency & Accountability in the health sector [14, 40, 41, 46, 48, 49, 64, 71, 82, 83]Improve Trust in public authorities by enhancing transparency and accountability in healthcare systems [18, 41]Enhancing Transparency in System Governance (e.g., Procurement, Distribution) [18, 82]26.1%Systemic ReformsSystemic Governance Reforms [40, 73]4.3%Legal & SanctionsComprehensive Legal and Regulatory frameworks [33, 35, 36, 44, 46, 47, 49, 50, 61, 65, 68, 74, 75, 80, 82, 85]Banning Informal Payments [54, 55, 66, 81]Applying rigorous sanctions (e.g., fines, dismissal, revoke licenses) [16, 40, 45, 46, 55, 56, 62, 65, 71, 73, 75, 79, 80]63.0%Oversight & MonitoringStakeholder Engagement in policy design [40, 45, 73]Provider Ethics Training & Sensitization [44, 59, 71, 79, 80]Peer Monitoring [22, 59]Periodic internal assessments [35]Hotlines for reporting [22, 56]Oversight by Neutral/Independent Organizations [79]Public Shaming (e.g., Naming Offenders) [79]Establishing Community Oversight Mechanisms [49]23.9%Systemic GovernanceRegulating or Banning Dual Practice (Part-Time Practice/ both public and private sectors) [67, 79]Separation of Purchaser & Provider (via Insurance) [79]Integrating Professional Ethics into University Curriculum [79]Facilitating Internal Dialogue & Staff Forums [61]Cross-Sectoral Improvement of Governance & Corruption Reduction [35]Address the unequal distribution of IP among health workers [50]13.0% Table 4Proposed interventions to curb informal payments in health systemsIntervention CategoryStrategy FocusSuggested InterventionFrequency %Patient EmpowermentAwareness & Educationclarification of patients’ entitlements [14, 30, 38, 46, 55, 56, 59]public awareness campaigns about the negative effects of informal payments on equity and access to healthcare [16, 22, 32, 35, 36, 40, 41, 46, 47, 59, 61–63, 65, 66, 71, 73, 74, 79, 80]Comprehensive Patient Education [54, 81–83]treatment information transparency [37, 45, 55, 65]communication skills training [64]69.6%Rights & Accountabilityformalized patient rights procedures [34, 38, 48, 59, 79]Establishing transparent complaint channels [34, 48, 63, 64, 80]17.4%Cultural-NormativeShifting Social Normscampaigns to distinguish gifts from bribes [14, 16, 40, 41]de-normalization of gratitude payments [36]Shifting Social Norms through Targeted Campaigns & Public Discourse [18, 32, 46, 48]Engaging Religious Leaders and Institutions [79]21.7%Fostering Social Contracteducational campaigns on the link between tax payments and healthcare funding [14, 35]Building Trust between patients and physicians through Systemic Performance [41, 64]8.7%Quality & InfrastructureEnhancing service quality & infrastructure [14, 18, 24, 41, 62, 83, 84]15.2%Payment Systems ModernizationPayment reforms (like electronic or insurance-only transactions) [14, 22]4.3%Addressing Specific ConcernsAddressing Gender Disparities in Informal Payments [16]Addressing Patient Fears of Retaliation [63]4.3%FinancialSystemic FinancingIncreasing Health Funding and Systemic Investment in Healthcare [14, 38, 40, 46, 47, 72, 73]Rationalizing Tariff Structures [30, 44, 46, 56, 62, 80]23.9%Provider IncentivesImproving Formal Remuneration [35, 36, 48, 49, 73]Raising base Physicians’ Salaries [34, 37, 41, 44, 46, 50, 54, 59, 61, 81–83]Fee-for-service models [35, 38]Implementing performance-based pay [22, 35, 49, 67, 74, 80]Alternative Payment Models like Capitation [56]45.7%Formalizing PaymentsFormalizing Informal Payments and gifts in kind [18, 33, 34, 37, 49, 63, 67, 75, 81, 82, 85]Creating Channels for Voluntary Contributions [41, 66, 72]Paid Afternoon Clinics in public hospitals [34]Formalizing co-payments [37, 50, 84]Ensuring Fee Exemptions for the poor and vulnerable Groups [41, 49, 84, 85]37.0%TransparencyTransparency in Fee Structures [16, 38, 59, 74]Transparency in Regulation [74, 84]Simplification of Payment Systems [73]10.9%StructuralEquity & FinancingTargeted Redistribution Mechanisms (24)2.2%System StrengtheningDirect Facility Financing [22, 41, 61, 71]Systemic Supply-Side Strengthening [65, 67]Expanding Service Access [14, 18, 47]Reducing Wait Times [14, 56]Ensuring Fair Geographic Distribution of Services [44]Streamlining Administrative Procedures [48]21.7%Health InsuranceExpanding and strengthening health insurance coverage (SHI/PHI/UHC) [24, 30, 32, 34, 35, 37, 41, 44, 48, 50, 55, 56, 62, 66, 68, 80]Reforming Health Insurance to reduce out-of-pocket payments [55, 66, 68, 71]Defining an Essential Health Services/Benefits Package [46, 63]Reforming Health Financing [16, 41]Inclusion of Specific Services in UHC (family planning services, supplies) [38, 67, 79]47.8%Private Sector & ModelsEncouraging Regulated Private Sector Involvement & Market Competition (e.g., by introducing private healthcare facilities and insurance) [33, 35, 54, 55, 68, 84]Implementing a Gatekeeping Referral System & Family Physician Programs [44, 56, 63]17.4%Digitalization & SystemsImplementing Electronic Health Records [17] [79]2.2%Governance & RegulatoryTransparency & AccountabilityEnhancing Transparency & Accountability in the health sector [14, 40, 41, 46, 48, 49, 64, 71, 82, 83]Improve Trust in public authorities by enhancing transparency and accountability in healthcare systems [18, 41]Enhancing Transparency in System Governance (e.g., Procurement, Distribution) [18, 82]26.1%Systemic ReformsSystemic Governance Reforms [40, 73]4.3%Legal & SanctionsComprehensive Legal and Regulatory frameworks [33, 35, 36, 44, 46, 47, 49, 50, 61, 65, 68, 74, 75, 80, 82, 85]Banning Informal Payments [54, 55, 66, 81]Applying rigorous sanctions (e.g., fines, dismissal, revoke licenses) [16, 40, 45, 46, 55, 56, 62, 65, 71, 73, 75, 79, 80]63.0%Oversight & MonitoringStakeholder Engagement in policy design [40, 45, 73]Provider Ethics Training & Sensitization [44, 59, 71, 79, 80]Peer Monitoring [22, 59]Periodic internal assessments [35]Hotlines for reporting [22, 56]Oversight by Neutral/Independent Organizations [79]Public Shaming (e.g., Naming Offenders) [79]Establishing Community Oversight Mechanisms [49]23.9%Systemic GovernanceRegulating or Banning Dual Practice (Part-Time Practice/ both public and private sectors) [67, 79]Separation of Purchaser & Provider (via Insurance) [79]Integrating Professional Ethics into University Curriculum [79]Facilitating Internal Dialogue & Staff Forums [61]Cross-Sectoral Improvement of Governance & Corruption Reduction [35]Address the unequal distribution of IP among health workers [50]13.0% Proposed interventions to curb informal payments in health systems clarification of patients’ entitlements [14, 30, 38, 46, 55, 56, 59] public awareness campaigns about the negative effects of informal payments on equity and access to healthcare [16, 22, 32, 35, 36, 40, 41, 46, 47, 59, 61–63, 65, 66, 71, 73, 74, 79, 80] Comprehensive Patient Education [54, 81–83] treatment information transparency [37, 45, 55, 65] communication skills training [64] formalized patient rights procedures [34, 38, 48, 59, 79] Establishing transparent complaint channels [34, 48, 63, 64, 80] campaigns to distinguish gifts from bribes [14, 16, 40, 41] de-normalization of gratitude payments [36] Shifting Social Norms through Targeted Campaigns & Public Discourse [18, 32, 46, 48] Engaging Religious Leaders and Institutions [79] educational campaigns on the link between tax payments and healthcare funding [14, 35] Building Trust between patients and physicians through Systemic Performance [41, 64] Addressing Gender Disparities in Informal Payments [16] Addressing Patient Fears of Retaliation [63] Increasing Health Funding and Systemic Investment in Healthcare [14, 38, 40, 46, 47, 72, 73] Rationalizing Tariff Structures [30, 44, 46, 56, 62, 80] Improving Formal Remuneration [35, 36, 48, 49, 73] Raising base Physicians’ Salaries [34, 37, 41, 44, 46, 50, 54, 59, 61, 81–83] Fee-for-service models [35, 38] Implementing performance-based pay [22, 35, 49, 67, 74, 80] Alternative Payment Models like Capitation [56] Formalizing Informal Payments and gifts in kind [18, 33, 34, 37, 49, 63, 67, 75, 81, 82, 85] Creating Channels for Voluntary Contributions [41, 66, 72] Paid Afternoon Clinics in public hospitals [34] Formalizing co-payments [37, 50, 84] Ensuring Fee Exemptions for the poor and vulnerable Groups [41, 49, 84, 85] Transparency in Fee Structures [16, 38, 59, 74] Transparency in Regulation [74, 84] Simplification of Payment Systems [73] Direct Facility Financing [22, 41, 61, 71] Systemic Supply-Side Strengthening [65, 67] Expanding Service Access [14, 18, 47] Reducing Wait Times [14, 56] Ensuring Fair Geographic Distribution of Services [44] Streamlining Administrative Procedures [48] Expanding and strengthening health insurance coverage (SHI/PHI/UHC) [24, 30, 32, 34, 35, 37, 41, 44, 48, 50, 55, 56, 62, 66, 68, 80] Reforming Health Insurance to reduce out-of-pocket payments [55, 66, 68, 71] Defining an Essential Health Services/Benefits Package [46, 63] Reforming Health Financing [16, 41] Inclusion of Specific Services in UHC (family planning services, supplies) [38, 67, 79] Encouraging Regulated Private Sector Involvement & Market Competition (e.g., by introducing private healthcare facilities and insurance) [33, 35, 54, 55, 68, 84] Implementing a Gatekeeping Referral System & Family Physician Programs [44, 56, 63] Enhancing Transparency & Accountability in the health sector [14, 40, 41, 46, 48, 49, 64, 71, 82, 83] Improve Trust in public authorities by enhancing transparency and accountability in healthcare systems [18, 41] Enhancing Transparency in System Governance (e.g., Procurement, Distribution) [18, 82] Comprehensive Legal and Regulatory frameworks [33, 35, 36, 44, 46, 47, 49, 50, 61, 65, 68, 74, 75, 80, 82, 85] Banning Informal Payments [54, 55, 66, 81] Applying rigorous sanctions (e.g., fines, dismissal, revoke licenses) [16, 40, 45, 46, 55, 56, 62, 65, 71, 73, 75, 79, 80] Stakeholder Engagement in policy design [40, 45, 73] Provider Ethics Training & Sensitization [44, 59, 71, 79, 80] Peer Monitoring [22, 59] Periodic internal assessments [35] Hotlines for reporting [22, 56] Oversight by Neutral/Independent Organizations [79] Public Shaming (e.g., Naming Offenders) [79] Establishing Community Oversight Mechanisms [49] Regulating or Banning Dual Practice (Part-Time Practice/ both public and private sectors) [67, 79] Separation of Purchaser & Provider (via Insurance) [79] Integrating Professional Ethics into University Curriculum [79] Facilitating Internal Dialogue & Staff Forums [61] Cross-Sectoral Improvement of Governance & Corruption Reduction [35] Address the unequal distribution of IP among health workers [50] Patient empowerment This is the most frequently cited intervention category and focuses on reducing information asymmetry while strengthening patients’ autonomy and decision-making capacity. The primary strategy is awareness and education (69.6% of interventions within this category), which includes clarifying patient entitlements, conducting public awareness campaigns on the negative consequences of IPs for equity and access, and improving communication skills. A secondary strategy is the establishment of formal patient rights and accountability mechanisms (17.4%), such as transparent complaint and grievance systems. Cultural–normative interventions This category addresses the social and ethical norms that sustain IPs. The most frequently reported strategy is shifting social norms (21.7%), which includes campaigns to distinguish gifts from bribes, de-normalize gratitude payments, and engage religious and community leaders. Additional strategies include strengthening the social contract (8.7%) and improving service quality and infrastructure (15.2%) as foundational measures to reduce the perceived need for informal payments. Financial interventions This category focuses on economic incentives. The most prominent strategy is providing provider incentives (45.7%), including increasing base salaries, introducing performance-based payment systems, and implementing alternative provider payment models. Another key strategy is formalizing payments (37.0%), aimed at channeling informal transactions into transparent and regulated systems. Additional approaches include systemic financing reforms (23.9%) and improving financial transparency and payment simplification (10.9%). Structural interventions These strategies target macro-level health system design. The most frequently cited intervention is expanding and strengthening health insurance coverage (47.8%), aimed at reducing out-of-pocket payments and uncertainty regarding entitlements. Other strategies include health system strengthening (21.7%), such as direct facility financing and expanding service availability, and reforms involving private sector engagement and new service delivery models (17.4%), including the implementation of gatekeeping and referral systems. Governance and regulatory interventions This category focuses on legal frameworks, oversight, and accountability mechanisms. The most frequently cited and emphatic strategy is establishing comprehensive legal and regulatory frameworks with sanctions (63.0%), including clear legislation, explicit bans on IPs, and strict enforcement mechanisms. Other strategies include enhancing transparency and accountability (26.1%), strengthening oversight and monitoring systems (23.9%), and broader governance reforms (13.0%), such as regulating or restricting dual practice between public and private sectors. Overall, this classification highlights that a single-dimensional approach is insufficient to address informal payments. Effective policy responses require a coherent combination of interventions targeting provider financial incentives, structural weaknesses in the health system, governance and accountability gaps, patient awareness and behavior, and entrenched sociocultural norms. Rather than providing a simple catalogue of proposed interventions, Table 5 synthesizes the mechanisms of action and key contextual considerations associated with the strategies outlined in Table 4. This analytical framework illustrates how different interventions are theorized to influence informal payments and identifies the contextual conditions that may facilitate or hinder their implementation. Accordingly, the table is intended to inform the design of context-sensitive and multi-component policy responses, rather than to assess the effectiveness of specific interventions in reducing informal payments. Table 5Mechanisms of action and contextual considerations for interventions to curb informal paymentIntervention CategoryStrategy FocusMechanism of ActionContext / ConsiderationsPatient EmpowermentAwareness & EducationReduces information asymmetry and patient uncertainty across all interventions.Empowers patients to identify/refuse unauthorized charges and assert their rights.Reshapes social norms that normalize informal payments.Mitigates the “physician agency problem” by improving communication and Trust.Requires credible sources, accessible channels, and culturally sensitive, long-term strategies.Crucial for vulnerable groups.Messages must be specific and context-aware.Must be part of a broader, long-term strategy.Rights & AccountabilityCreates formal accountability channels, deterring providers by increasing the perceived risk of detection and sanction.Empowers patients to report violations safely.Systems must be well-publicized, easy to use, reliable, and actionable.Protection from retaliation and guaranteed anonymity are essential for the functionality and credibility of these services.Cultural-NormativeShifting Social NormsAims to reshape the social norms and attitudes that normalize informal payments. Directly challenges the belief that payments are necessary for adequate care and delegitimizes them by distinguishing them from voluntary gifts: Leverages moral authority and social pressure to create a powerful, conscience-based deterrent.Requires long-term, culturally sensitive strategies, especially in contexts with strong “gift-giving” traditions. Campaigns must be persistent, employ trusted messengers (including religious leaders), and be tailored to specific demographics. Effectiveness in religiously homogeneous societies hinges on collaboration with credible, independent institutions.Fostering Social ContractReinforces the concept of formal taxation as a legitimate source of funding for quality healthcare. Aims to foster a sense of collective responsibility and strengthen the social contract, thereby reducing public tolerance for informal payments that undermine the formal system.Effectiveness is highly contingent on government credibility in actually delivering quality public services in return for tax revenue. It may be ineffective or counterproductive in settings with low Trust in government or poor perceived service quality.Quality & InfrastructureReduces the fundamental “demand” for informal payments by ensuring the formal system is functional and provides an acceptable quality of care, removing the patient’s need to pay for basics or better treatment.A foundational intervention requiring significant and sustained investment. Credibility is key; visible improvements build Trust in the formal system and undermine the rationale for IP.Payment Systems ModernizationReduces the use of cash, creating an auditable transaction trail and limiting opportunities for on-the-spot informal cash requests. Increases transparency and formalizes financial flows.Requires robust technological infrastructure and public adoption. It can face resistance from those who benefit from the opacity of cash transactions.FinancialSystemic FinancingAddresses the root cause of provider motivation for informal payments by ensuring the system can provide adequate salaries and operational resources, reducing the financial pressure that justifies soliciting extra payments. Rationalizing tariffs closes the fundamental pricing “gap” that creates a financial rationale for informal top-up payments.Requires strong political commitment and sustainable macroeconomic policies. This is necessary but often insufficient on its own; it must be coupled with governance reforms and normative shifts. It is essential to maintain a continuous process to keep pace with inflation and changing costs.Provider IncentivesReduces the primary economic incentive to seek informal payments by providing adequate and legitimate income. Aligns provider incentives with formal system goals by directly linking a portion of income to measurable performance or official revenue, thereby mitigating the principal-agent problem.Must be significant, sustainable, and fairly distributed. Performance-based models require robust and transparent monitoring to avoid perverse incentives (e.g., overtreatment, patient selection). Strategic targeting of salary increases to the most vulnerable staff groups can be highly effective.Formalizing PaymentsReplaces uncertain, unofficial “under-the-table” payments with transparent, official channels. Modifies provider expectations by providing a legitimate source of extra income, potentially “crowding out” informal ones. Creates a clear, legal avenue for patients who wish to pay for additional services or express gratitude, thereby redirecting funds that might otherwise be allocated to informal arrangements.High Implementation Risk: Requires strong oversight to prevent formal AND informal payments from coexisting (dual burden). Public Resistance: May face backlash if not communicated carefully. Ethical Complexity: Must be strictly managed to avoid creating a two-tier system. Critical for acceptance: must deliver tangible quality improvements.Co-payments & EquityIntroduces a modest, official patient co-payment to generate revenue and signal the value of services, potentially undermining the rationale for informal payments. Targeted exemptions are designed to shield the most disadvantaged from all financial barriers, both formal and informal. Thereby preserving equitable access.The critical success factor is the design and implementation of the exemption system. Evidence suggests that exemption mechanisms are often poorly targeted and implemented. Effectiveness is contingent upon establishing robust, transparent, and reliable identification systems for low-income populations.Transparency & SimplificationEliminates information asymmetry by mandating the clear publication of all official costs, making them predictable and reducing the opportunity for providers to demand extra fees illicitly. Reduces the complexity and administrative burden for patients, diminishing the perceived necessity or relative convenience of resorting to informal payments to navigate a convoluted system.Requires simple/accessible communication of official fees, as well as active monitoring/enforcement. Particularly crucial in systems with intricate co-payment schemes, multi-layered insurance, or complex exemption procedures.Performance-Based & Alternative ModelsFundamentally re-aligns provider financial incentives by directly linking income to the delivery of officially monitored services or outcomes. Incentivizes providers to prioritize official duties and recorded activities over informal, off-the-books transactions.A critical caveat is that these models can unintentionally encourage undesirable behaviors if poorly designed. Implementation is highly dependent on the establishment of robust, transparent, and fair monitoring systems to ensure the maintenance of care quality and safeguard against gaming the incentives.StructuralEquity & FinancingProvides direct financial support to vulnerable patients, enabling them to access formal care and reducing the need for informal care.Requires precise targeting and sufficient transfer amounts to be effective.System StrengtheningImproves job satisfaction and enables effective service delivery by ensuring consistent availability of essential inputs (drugs, equipment, staff), thereby removing the primary justification and need for both soliciting and making IPs to bridge resource gaps.Undercuts key incentives for IP by expanding service availability, improving efficiency, and reducing patient competition, as well as the need to pay for expedited care or navigate bureaucratic bottlenecks. Diminishes providers’ leverage to demand IP by reducing geographic monopolies and increasing patient choice.A foundational intervention requiring reliable supply chains, predictable funding, and robust management to address the core drivers of IP. Crucial for systemic integrity.Particularly critical in underserved areas. Requires significant investment in infrastructure, workforce, and process optimization to be effective. Crucial in systems with significant bureaucratic bottlenecks.Health InsuranceReduces out-of-pocket expenditures and the need for informal “discounts” by providing formal financial protection, streamlining financing, and eliminating cash transactions for covered services, thereby reducing both the demand for and opportunity for IP. Removes the primary financial incentive for IP for targeted services by eliminating their out-of-pocket costs. Reduces ambiguity about entitlements, limiting providers’ opportunities to solicit IP for services that should be covered.Requires sustainable financing, strong governance to prevent internal corruption, and careful design to ensure equity and timely provider reimbursements. A foundational, long-term strategy contingent on political will and administrative efficiency. Must be explicitly equity-oriented to protect people with low incomes and establish a clear normative standard.Private Sector & ModelsReduces overcrowding in public facilities and the perceived need for IP by providing formal alternatives, thereby increasing competition and improving overall service quality. A higher share of private financing may be associated with lower informal payments by establishing formal channels for accessing enhanced services.Reduces direct, unregulated financial interactions with specialists—a common source of IP—by channeling and controlling access through primary care, thereby lowering OOP expenditures and the incentive to pay for shortcuts.Carries a high risk of exacerbating inequity. Requires strong state regulation to ensure quality, prevent corruption, and mitigate the adverse welfare effects of higher formal costs. Policymakers must exercise extreme caution to avoid over-reliance that compromises equitable access.Requires a strong, respected, and well-functioning primary care level. Challenges entrenched the interests of specialists, and it is crucial for overall system efficiency.Digitalization & SystemsCreates an auditable, transparent trail of care, reducing opportunities to solicit IP for undocumented or expedited services.Creates an auditable, transparent trail of care, reducing opportunities to solicit IP for undocumented or expedited services.Governance & RegulatoryTransparency & AccountabilityCreates a less permissive environment for IP by making corrupt actions riskier and more complex to conceal through systemic increases in transparency, accountability, and the rule of law.A slow, cross-sectoral process that is foundational for sustaining gains and targeting root institutional causes. Requires a strong political will to open opaque processes and depends on effective independent auditing bodies and freedom of information mechanisms.Systemic ReformsAddresses the root institutional and governance deficiencies that enable a culture of impunity around informal payments.A broad, foundational approach that requires long-term political commitment and cross-sectoral coordination.Legal & SanctionsCreates a credible deterrent by establishing explicit legal prohibitions, increasing the risk of detection (via audits, hotlines), and enforcing meaningful penalties—Leverages professional ethics to delegitimize IP.Effectiveness hinges on legal precision, consistent enforcement, and strong institutional commitment. Requires dedicated monitoring resources and ensuring reporter anonymity. Credibility is paramount.Oversight & MonitoringEnsures policies are practical and gain buy-in. Reinforces ethical obligations to prevent normalization of IP. Creates internal and external accountability through peer pressure, independent audits, and social deterrents, increasing the perceived risk of detection.Training must be practical and context-specific. Mechanisms depend on workplace culture and the genuine independence of supervising bodies. Public shaming raises ethical/legal concerns and requires a clear legal framework.Systemic GovernanceEliminates conflicts of interest from dual practice. Removes opportunities for direct cash payments via a financial intermediary. Instills a service-oriented professional identity. Addresses staff grievances and systemic inequities to reduce justification for IP. Increases overall public Trust.Requires vigorous enforcement and competitive public sector salaries. A long-term, generational investment for cultural change. Highly dependent on supportive management. A foundational approach for a sustainable, ethical environment. Requires understanding of pay disparities. Table 5Mechanisms of action and contextual considerations for interventions to curb informal paymentIntervention CategoryStrategy FocusMechanism of ActionContext / ConsiderationsPatient EmpowermentAwareness & EducationReduces information asymmetry and patient uncertainty across all interventions.Empowers patients to identify/refuse unauthorized charges and assert their rights.Reshapes social norms that normalize informal payments.Mitigates the “physician agency problem” by improving communication and Trust.Requires credible sources, accessible channels, and culturally sensitive, long-term strategies.Crucial for vulnerable groups.Messages must be specific and context-aware.Must be part of a broader, long-term strategy.Rights & AccountabilityCreates formal accountability channels, deterring providers by increasing the perceived risk of detection and sanction.Empowers patients to report violations safely.Systems must be well-publicized, easy to use, reliable, and actionable.Protection from retaliation and guaranteed anonymity are essential for the functionality and credibility of these services.Cultural-NormativeShifting Social NormsAims to reshape the social norms and attitudes that normalize informal payments. Directly challenges the belief that payments are necessary for adequate care and delegitimizes them by distinguishing them from voluntary gifts: Leverages moral authority and social pressure to create a powerful, conscience-based deterrent.Requires long-term, culturally sensitive strategies, especially in contexts with strong “gift-giving” traditions. Campaigns must be persistent, employ trusted messengers (including religious leaders), and be tailored to specific demographics. Effectiveness in religiously homogeneous societies hinges on collaboration with credible, independent institutions.Fostering Social ContractReinforces the concept of formal taxation as a legitimate source of funding for quality healthcare. Aims to foster a sense of collective responsibility and strengthen the social contract, thereby reducing public tolerance for informal payments that undermine the formal system.Effectiveness is highly contingent on government credibility in actually delivering quality public services in return for tax revenue. It may be ineffective or counterproductive in settings with low Trust in government or poor perceived service quality.Quality & InfrastructureReduces the fundamental “demand” for informal payments by ensuring the formal system is functional and provides an acceptable quality of care, removing the patient’s need to pay for basics or better treatment.A foundational intervention requiring significant and sustained investment. Credibility is key; visible improvements build Trust in the formal system and undermine the rationale for IP.Payment Systems ModernizationReduces the use of cash, creating an auditable transaction trail and limiting opportunities for on-the-spot informal cash requests. Increases transparency and formalizes financial flows.Requires robust technological infrastructure and public adoption. It can face resistance from those who benefit from the opacity of cash transactions.FinancialSystemic FinancingAddresses the root cause of provider motivation for informal payments by ensuring the system can provide adequate salaries and operational resources, reducing the financial pressure that justifies soliciting extra payments. Rationalizing tariffs closes the fundamental pricing “gap” that creates a financial rationale for informal top-up payments.Requires strong political commitment and sustainable macroeconomic policies. This is necessary but often insufficient on its own; it must be coupled with governance reforms and normative shifts. It is essential to maintain a continuous process to keep pace with inflation and changing costs.Provider IncentivesReduces the primary economic incentive to seek informal payments by providing adequate and legitimate income. Aligns provider incentives with formal system goals by directly linking a portion of income to measurable performance or official revenue, thereby mitigating the principal-agent problem.Must be significant, sustainable, and fairly distributed. Performance-based models require robust and transparent monitoring to avoid perverse incentives (e.g., overtreatment, patient selection). Strategic targeting of salary increases to the most vulnerable staff groups can be highly effective.Formalizing PaymentsReplaces uncertain, unofficial “under-the-table” payments with transparent, official channels. Modifies provider expectations by providing a legitimate source of extra income, potentially “crowding out” informal ones. Creates a clear, legal avenue for patients who wish to pay for additional services or express gratitude, thereby redirecting funds that might otherwise be allocated to informal arrangements.High Implementation Risk: Requires strong oversight to prevent formal AND informal payments from coexisting (dual burden). Public Resistance: May face backlash if not communicated carefully. Ethical Complexity: Must be strictly managed to avoid creating a two-tier system. Critical for acceptance: must deliver tangible quality improvements.Co-payments & EquityIntroduces a modest, official patient co-payment to generate revenue and signal the value of services, potentially undermining the rationale for informal payments. Targeted exemptions are designed to shield the most disadvantaged from all financial barriers, both formal and informal. Thereby preserving equitable access.The critical success factor is the design and implementation of the exemption system. Evidence suggests that exemption mechanisms are often poorly targeted and implemented. Effectiveness is contingent upon establishing robust, transparent, and reliable identification systems for low-income populations.Transparency & SimplificationEliminates information asymmetry by mandating the clear publication of all official costs, making them predictable and reducing the opportunity for providers to demand extra fees illicitly. Reduces the complexity and administrative burden for patients, diminishing the perceived necessity or relative convenience of resorting to informal payments to navigate a convoluted system.Requires simple/accessible communication of official fees, as well as active monitoring/enforcement. Particularly crucial in systems with intricate co-payment schemes, multi-layered insurance, or complex exemption procedures.Performance-Based & Alternative ModelsFundamentally re-aligns provider financial incentives by directly linking income to the delivery of officially monitored services or outcomes. Incentivizes providers to prioritize official duties and recorded activities over informal, off-the-books transactions.A critical caveat is that these models can unintentionally encourage undesirable behaviors if poorly designed. Implementation is highly dependent on the establishment of robust, transparent, and fair monitoring systems to ensure the maintenance of care quality and safeguard against gaming the incentives.StructuralEquity & FinancingProvides direct financial support to vulnerable patients, enabling them to access formal care and reducing the need for informal care.Requires precise targeting and sufficient transfer amounts to be effective.System StrengtheningImproves job satisfaction and enables effective service delivery by ensuring consistent availability of essential inputs (drugs, equipment, staff), thereby removing the primary justification and need for both soliciting and making IPs to bridge resource gaps.Undercuts key incentives for IP by expanding service availability, improving efficiency, and reducing patient competition, as well as the need to pay for expedited care or navigate bureaucratic bottlenecks. Diminishes providers’ leverage to demand IP by reducing geographic monopolies and increasing patient choice.A foundational intervention requiring reliable supply chains, predictable funding, and robust management to address the core drivers of IP. Crucial for systemic integrity.Particularly critical in underserved areas. Requires significant investment in infrastructure, workforce, and process optimization to be effective. Crucial in systems with significant bureaucratic bottlenecks.Health InsuranceReduces out-of-pocket expenditures and the need for informal “discounts” by providing formal financial protection, streamlining financing, and eliminating cash transactions for covered services, thereby reducing both the demand for and opportunity for IP. Removes the primary financial incentive for IP for targeted services by eliminating their out-of-pocket costs. Reduces ambiguity about entitlements, limiting providers’ opportunities to solicit IP for services that should be covered.Requires sustainable financing, strong governance to prevent internal corruption, and careful design to ensure equity and timely provider reimbursements. A foundational, long-term strategy contingent on political will and administrative efficiency. Must be explicitly equity-oriented to protect people with low incomes and establish a clear normative standard.Private Sector & ModelsReduces overcrowding in public facilities and the perceived need for IP by providing formal alternatives, thereby increasing competition and improving overall service quality. A higher share of private financing may be associated with lower informal payments by establishing formal channels for accessing enhanced services.Reduces direct, unregulated financial interactions with specialists—a common source of IP—by channeling and controlling access through primary care, thereby lowering OOP expenditures and the incentive to pay for shortcuts.Carries a high risk of exacerbating inequity. Requires strong state regulation to ensure quality, prevent corruption, and mitigate the adverse welfare effects of higher formal costs. Policymakers must exercise extreme caution to avoid over-reliance that compromises equitable access.Requires a strong, respected, and well-functioning primary care level. Challenges entrenched the interests of specialists, and it is crucial for overall system efficiency.Digitalization & SystemsCreates an auditable, transparent trail of care, reducing opportunities to solicit IP for undocumented or expedited services.Creates an auditable, transparent trail of care, reducing opportunities to solicit IP for undocumented or expedited services.Governance & RegulatoryTransparency & AccountabilityCreates a less permissive environment for IP by making corrupt actions riskier and more complex to conceal through systemic increases in transparency, accountability, and the rule of law.A slow, cross-sectoral process that is foundational for sustaining gains and targeting root institutional causes. Requires a strong political will to open opaque processes and depends on effective independent auditing bodies and freedom of information mechanisms.Systemic ReformsAddresses the root institutional and governance deficiencies that enable a culture of impunity around informal payments.A broad, foundational approach that requires long-term political commitment and cross-sectoral coordination.Legal & SanctionsCreates a credible deterrent by establishing explicit legal prohibitions, increasing the risk of detection (via audits, hotlines), and enforcing meaningful penalties—Leverages professional ethics to delegitimize IP.Effectiveness hinges on legal precision, consistent enforcement, and strong institutional commitment. Requires dedicated monitoring resources and ensuring reporter anonymity. Credibility is paramount.Oversight & MonitoringEnsures policies are practical and gain buy-in. Reinforces ethical obligations to prevent normalization of IP. Creates internal and external accountability through peer pressure, independent audits, and social deterrents, increasing the perceived risk of detection.Training must be practical and context-specific. Mechanisms depend on workplace culture and the genuine independence of supervising bodies. Public shaming raises ethical/legal concerns and requires a clear legal framework.Systemic GovernanceEliminates conflicts of interest from dual practice. Removes opportunities for direct cash payments via a financial intermediary. Instills a service-oriented professional identity. Addresses staff grievances and systemic inequities to reduce justification for IP. Increases overall public Trust.Requires vigorous enforcement and competitive public sector salaries. A long-term, generational investment for cultural change. Highly dependent on supportive management. A foundational approach for a sustainable, ethical environment. Requires understanding of pay disparities. Mechanisms of action and contextual considerations for interventions to curb informal payment Reduces information asymmetry and patient uncertainty across all interventions. Empowers patients to identify/refuse unauthorized charges and assert their rights. Reshapes social norms that normalize informal payments. Mitigates the “physician agency problem” by improving communication and Trust. Requires credible sources, accessible channels, and culturally sensitive, long-term strategies. Crucial for vulnerable groups. Messages must be specific and context-aware. Must be part of a broader, long-term strategy. Creates formal accountability channels, deterring providers by increasing the perceived risk of detection and sanction. Empowers patients to report violations safely. Systems must be well-publicized, easy to use, reliable, and actionable. Protection from retaliation and guaranteed anonymity are essential for the functionality and credibility of these services. Introduces a modest, official patient co-payment to generate revenue and signal the value of services, potentially undermining the rationale for informal payments. Targeted exemptions are designed to shield the most disadvantaged from all financial barriers , both formal and informal. Thereby preserving equitable access. Improves job satisfaction and enables effective service delivery by ensuring consistent availability of essential inputs (drugs, equipment, staff), thereby removing the primary justification and need for both soliciting and making IPs to bridge resource gaps. Undercuts key incentives for IP by expanding service availability, improving efficiency, and reducing patient competition, as well as the need to pay for expedited care or navigate bureaucratic bottlenecks. Diminishes providers’ leverage to demand IP by reducing geographic monopolies and increasing patient choice. A foundational intervention requiring reliable supply chains, predictable funding, and robust management to address the core drivers of IP. Crucial for systemic integrity. Particularly critical in underserved areas. Requires significant investment in infrastructure, workforce, and process optimization to be effective. Crucial in systems with significant bureaucratic bottlenecks. Reduces overcrowding in public facilities and the perceived need for IP by providing formal alternatives, thereby increasing competition and improving overall service quality. A higher share of private financing may be associated with lower informal payments by establishing formal channels for accessing enhanced services. Reduces direct, unregulated financial interactions with specialists—a common source of IP—by channeling and controlling access through primary care, thereby lowering OOP expenditures and the incentive to pay for shortcuts. Carries a high risk of exacerbating inequity. Requires strong state regulation to ensure quality, prevent corruption, and mitigate the adverse welfare effects of higher formal costs. Policymakers must exercise extreme caution to avoid over-reliance that compromises equitable access. Requires a strong, respected, and well-functioning primary care level. Challenges entrenched the interests of specialists, and it is crucial for overall system efficiency. To further clarify the relationship between identified determinants and corresponding intervention strategies, a conceptual mapping is presented in Fig. 2. Fig. 2Conceptual mapping of determinants of informal payments, underlying mechanisms, and corresponding intervention strategies, showing how these relationships operate across different levels of the health system Conceptual mapping of determinants of informal payments, underlying mechanisms, and corresponding intervention strategies, showing how these relationships operate across different levels of the health system Discussion This scoping review demonstrates that informal payments in health systems are complex and multidimensional phenomena arising from the interaction of patient behaviors, provider incentives, organizational arrangements, sociocultural norms, and broader governance structures. At the patient level, factors such as fear of receiving poor-quality care, expectations of expedited services, and limited awareness of entitlements underscore the importance of patient empowerment. Educational interventions, transparent information regarding service coverage and costs, and accessible communication channels may reduce the perceived necessity of informal payments and strengthen patients’ ability to navigate health systems effectively. Consistent with this interpretation, previous studies have shown that education, income, and other individual characteristics are significantly associated with both the prevalence and magnitude of informal payments [86, 87]. At the provider and organizational levels, low and inadequate remuneration, resource constraints, and weak oversight mechanisms create structural incentives that sustain informal payments. These findings suggest that interventions focused solely on patient education are insufficient to address the problem. Instead, system-level reforms—including formalizing payment mechanisms, expanding health insurance coverage, introducing performance-based remuneration systems, and strengthening transparency and accountability—are required to address the underlying economic and institutional drivers. Evidence from cross-national research by Incaltarau et al., covering 117 countries, supports this conclusion by demonstrating that institutional deficiencies are among the most important determinants of informal payments in health systems [35]. Moreover, informal payments are more prevalent in contexts characterized by low institutional trust and a misalignment between formal regulations and informal practices, highlighting the need to strengthen institutional frameworks as a central policy priority [25]. Cultural and ethical norms further contribute to the persistence of informal payments. Practices such as gift-giving and the social acceptance of unofficial payments can normalize these transactions and blur the boundary between gratitude and coercion. Accordingly, community-engaged interventions that promote professional ethics, strengthen social accountability, and foster trust between patients and providers are essential components of comprehensive prevention strategies. Review studies emphasize culturally oriented approaches, including increasing public awareness of insurance-covered services, medicines, cost-sharing limits, and available generic alternatives; informing patients about formal complaint and compensation mechanisms; and challenging the perception that informal payments are necessary to obtain quality care by reinforcing confidence in adequate public-sector remuneration [19, 44]. Importantly, no single determinant or intervention operates in isolation. Rather, informal payments emerge from a dynamic system in which financial pressures on providers are reinforced by weak governance structures, normalized through cultural narratives, and sustained by gaps in patient knowledge and information asymmetries. Therefore, the literature consistently highlights the need for multi-level strategies that simultaneously address patient empowerment, provider incentives, financial arrangements, governance capacity, and sociocultural norms. However, the effectiveness of these interventions is highly context dependent, as variations in social values, institutional capacity, and health system design shape both implementation processes and outcomes. Overall, this review underscores that informal payments cannot be effectively addressed through fragmented or isolated measures. Instead, integrated, system-wide approaches are essential to promote transparency, equity, and sustainability in health systems. Future research should move beyond descriptive analyses toward rigorous evaluation of intervention packages across diverse settings, with greater attention to underlying contextual mechanisms and long-term effects on health system performance and public trust. The conceptual mapping presented in Fig. 2 further clarifies the relationships between determinants of informal payments and corresponding intervention strategies. It illustrates how different strategies operate through distinct mechanisms to address underlying drivers at multiple levels of the health system, while also highlighting cross-cutting effects across categories. This underscores that effective policy responses require strong alignment between identified determinants and targeted interventions, supporting the need for integrated, multi-level approaches rather than isolated measures. Notably, several strategies simultaneously address multiple determinants, reinforcing the importance of coordinated policy design and implementation. Limitations This review has several limitations. Restricting the search to English-language publications may have excluded relevant non-English evidence, particularly from high-prevalence settings. The geographical coverage is uneven, with underrepresentation of some high-income countries, while evidence is concentrated in Eastern Europe, Central Asia, parts of Africa, and Asia, where informal payments are more frequently reported or differently conceptualized. As a scoping review, no formal quality appraisal was conducted, limiting assessment of methodological rigor and introducing potential variability bias. Differences in definitions and conceptualization of informal payments across studies also complicated the synthesis. Grey literature may have been missed, and restricting the search to studies up to January 2025 may have excluded recent evidence. In addition, title-based searching, while increasing specificity, may have reduced sensitivity and led to the omission of relevant studies. Although data extraction and synthesis were independently conducted within the research team, the absence of external reviewers may have introduced interpretive bias. Finally, the review mapped strategies and mechanisms rather than assessing their effectiveness, so it cannot determine which interventions are most effective or sustainable, highlighting a key gap for future research. Despite these limitations, the study provides a comprehensive synthesis and a structured framework to inform policy and future research on informal payments in health systems. Conclusions This scoping review synthesizes evidence from 68 studies and demonstrates that informal payments (IPs) are a multifactorial phenomenon shaped by interconnected determinants at patient, structural-contextual, provider, cultural-ethical, and organizational levels. Correspondingly, effective responses encompass patient empowerment, cultural-normative change, financial reforms, structural improvements, and strengthened governance mechanisms. No single intervention is sufficient, as IPs persist due to systemic interdependencies that require integrated, multi-level strategies. Contextual sensitivity is essential, given that the effectiveness of interventions depends on institutional capacity, sociocultural values, and health system design. Overall, reducing and ultimately eliminating IPs requires comprehensive policy approaches that promote transparency, equity, and trust in health systems. However, evidence on the comparative effectiveness and long-term sustainability of interventions remains limited, particularly in underrepresented settings. Future research should therefore focus on evaluating which interventions or combinations are most effective across different contexts, while further exploring the institutional and sociocultural mechanisms that sustain informal payment practices. Supplementary Information Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material. Supplementary Material 1 Supplementary Material 1