Comparative health risk assessment of occupational dust exposure in industrial sectors using multiple models and monte carlo simulation Authors: Zahra Ordudari, Farzaneh Mohammadi, Reza Esmaeili Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Dust, a common pollutant resulting from industrial activities, poses significant risks to workers across various sectors, including agriculture, mining, and manufacturing. Dust risk assessments are vital for implementing preventive measures and improving air quality in workplaces. This study aims to identify the most suitable technique for evaluating dust exposure risk among workers in the wood, textile, food, and livestock industries. A cross-sectional descriptive-analytical study was conducted to assess dust exposure risks in the wood, textile, food, and livestock industries using three risk assessment approaches: qualitative, quantitative, and semi-quantitative methods. These methods were compared, and the Monte Carlo Simulation was used to model non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risks. The highest dust concentration was in the food industry, while the textile sector had the lowest. Dust levels in the textile and food industries exceeded safe limits. US-EPA assessment showed adverse health effects in all industries, with significant carcinogenic risks in the wood, food, and livestock sectors. The SQRA method categorized risks as very high in textile, low in food, and negligible in wood and livestock, while the ICMM method classified risks as intolerable in all industries. A significant correlation was found between risk scores and dust concentrations (P < 0.05). Chemical exposure risks in the studied industries were found to be intolerable, with adverse health effects. The results highlight the critical need for interventions to control dust exposure and mitigate health risks in these sectors. Introduction Industrial development enhances employment and socio-economic conditions but also increases air pollution, with dust being a major concern for workers1. Dust refers to solid particles of various sizes, shapes, and densities2. generated through natural or mechanical processes such as processing, crushing, grinding, or explosive activities involving organic and inorganic materials. Its health effects depend on particle type, size, and deposition in the respiratory system3. Occupational exposure to dust is common in industries like agriculture4, mining (miners, team leaders, drill operators, and locomotive drivers)5, ferrous metal foundries6, welding, livestock and poultry farming, chemical and food industries, stonemasonry, textile production3, brick and tile manufacturing4, and woodworking. Dust may be mineral, metallic, or organic2. Airborne dust forms during activities such as rock movement, crushing, and shaping. Both short- and long-term exposure can cause acute or chronic respiratory illnesses7,8. If dust contains toxic metals like lead, mercury, nickel, chromium, or cadmium, it can cause pulmonary fibrosis and respiratory distress9. Crystalline silica dust can deeply penetrate the lungs, leading to coughing, phlegm, shortness of breath, asthma, lung damage, tuberculosis, kidney disease, arthritis, lung cancer, COPD, bronchitis, pneumoconiosis, silicosis10, cardiovascular diseases, and even death11,12. In addition, wheat stands as the cornerstone cereal grain in the food and bakery industries13. However, it’s important to note that wheat flour harbors at least 40 allergens, which can provoke adverse health effects in workers and trigger allergic cross-reactivity14. In the UK and Norway, exposure to grain and flour dust ranks as the second most frequently reported cause of occupational asthma13. Within the baking and milling sectors, measurements of total flour dust have shown remarkable variability, ranging from just a few milligrams to over 400 mg/m³ during peak exposure13. Also, wood dust, a complex mixture of organic and inorganic particles, encompasses wood fragments, toxic chemicals, minerals and metals, and microorganisms such as bacterial and fungal spores15,16. In 1995, the International Agency for Research on Cancer classified hardwood dust as a Group 1 human carcinogen. Seven years later, dust from certain softwood species also fell into this category17. Beyond its potential link to lung cancer, wood dust exposure can lead to headaches, lung function impairments, itchy eyes, runny nose, genotoxicity, and hepatotoxicity18. On the one hand, raw cotton dust particles with an aerodynamic diameter less than 15 microns in the textile industry penetrate nasal passages and are deposited in the tracheobronchial tract or lung. Inhalable cotton dust primarily triggers lower airway reactions, while larger particles (40 microns or more) predominantly affect the upper airways19. These reactions can manifest as respiratory symptoms, including irritation of the upper and lower respiratory tracts, characterized by a runny nose, chronic cough, shortness of breath or wheezing, and chest tightness20. Exposure to organic dust may also lead to various allergic or immunotoxic diseases, such as hypersensitivity pneumonitis(HP), organic dust toxic syndrome(ODTS), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease(COPD), and asthma21,22. Also, respirable dust is also generated throughout various poultry production and breeding processes, exposing industry operators to the aforementioned pollutants and putting their health at risk23. It is estimated that several hundred million people worldwide may be exposed to organic dust during their work. In the United States alone, in 2000, approximately 0.5 million workers were occupationally exposed to grain dust, and 0.8 million to cotton dust24. In India, recent estimates suggest that more than 20 million people employed in intensive livestock production may be exposed to organic dust25. Based on aerodynamic diameter, dust is categorized as inhalable, thoracic, and respirable9. Inhalable particles (< 100 μm) enter through the nose or mouth, thoracic particles (< 10 μm) pass through the larynx, and respirable particles (< 4 μm) reach deep into the airways. “Total dust” includes particles between inhalable and thoracic sizes2. Total suspended particulates (TSP) consist of particles up to 100 μm, PM10 (< 10 μm), and PM2.5 (< 2.5 μm)3. These fine particles can enter the bloodstream10, affecting the lungs and heart, potentially causing irregular heartbeat, asthma, and reduced lung function11. According to the International Labour Organization, work-related deaths are attributed to respiratory diseases (21%), cancer (34%), accidents (25%), cardiovascular diseases (15%), and other factors (5%). The World Health Organization estimates that particulate matter exposure causes around three million deaths annually Due to the high risk of occupational respiratory diseases, the National Commission for Occupational Safety and Health reduced the permissible exposure limit for respirable crystalline silica from 0.2 mg/m³ to 0.1 mg/m³ in 2004. However, evidence indicates that even lower concentrations can lead to silicosis with prolonged exposure11. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has established a permissible exposure limit (PEL) of 5 mg/m³ for inhalable dust (8-hour TWA). In contrast, The American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) recommends lower exposure limits: <3 mg/m³ for inhalable dust, < 10 mg/m³ for respirable dust, and < 0.025 mg/m³ for crystalline silica26,27. A study on the textile industry’s spinning process found that the average total dust concentration over one hour was 233 µg/Nm³ (max: 478.1 µg/Nm³, min: 0.005 µg/Nm³), exceeding Indonesia’s regulatory limit of 230 µg/Nm³3. Similarly, Golbabaei et al. measured an average respirable dust concentration of 4.9 mg/m³ among poultry industry workers23. Given the adverse effects of dust on workers across various industries, the implementation of management programs, including health risk assessments, is crucial in industrial settings. Health risk assessments for chemicals and dust help organizations choose and apply appropriate control measures to eliminate or reduce pollutant emissions28. These assessments describe the adverse health effects of chemical exposure, a process practiced globally by organizations29. Risk assessments can be carried out qualitatively, using risk matrices, or quantitatively, using mathematical models30. One semi-quantitative method that has recently gained attention is the Semi-Quantitative Risk Assessment (SQRA) method31. Several studies have introduced quantitative health risk assessment techniques, such as the US-EPA-based methods28,32. Assessing and controlling dust and chemical hazards are vital for monitoring and implementing preventive measures to improve air quality in dust-laden work environments33. Monte Carlo simulation is the most widely recommended probabilistic risk analysis method, as per the National Academy of Sciences and the United States Environmental Protection Agency, for quantifying variability, uncertainty and finally achieving a quantitative risk assessment34. For instance, Mahmoudian et al. assessed the health risks of wood dust exposure using the Singapore Risk Assessment (SORA) method, finding a moderate risk that could lead to long-term harm35. Similarly, Duan et al. (2023) reported the time-weighted average concentrations of silica dust in a ferrous metal foundry during various processes, ranging from 0.8 to 83.52 mg/m³. Their risk assessment using the International Council on Mining and Metals (ICMM) method revealed that 100% of jobs involved silica dust exposure, with “unacceptable” risk levels in 59 foundries, leading to pneumoconiosis6. Despite extensive research on dust exposure, no study has comprehensively assessed risks across multiple industries (especially industries whose dust potentially leads to illness) or identified the most suitable assessment method for specific occupations. The selected industries were intentionally chosen to represent distinct categories of occupational dust exposure with differing physicochemical and toxicological characteristics. Flour dust in the food industry is primarily biological and allergenic in nature; wood dust in carpentry workshops consists of organic particulate matter with established carcinogenic potential; and mineral dust exposure in stone-related activities is predominantly siliceous, associated with fibrotic and carcinogenic respiratory outcomes4,20. By including these heterogeneous exposure scenarios, the study aimed to evaluate the performance and consistency of different health risk assessment models across dust types with varying intrinsic toxicities. The applied models (US-EPA, SQRA, and ICMM) were not chemically calibrated for specific dust composition but were implemented according to their standardized methodological frameworks, allowing comparative evaluation of their structural sensitivity to exposure magnitude and hazard classification across diverse industrial contexts. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate and simulation health risks associated with respirable dust exposure in the wood, textile, food, and livestock industries. The findings provide managers with a better understanding of industry-specific dust-related health hazards, facilitating informed decision-making and improved risk management. Methods Study design This cross-sectional descriptive-analytical study was conducted on 80 workers across various industries in Isfahan, including the food industry (grain mill and packaging workers), textile industry (weavers), wood industry (sawmill workers), and poultry industry (egg collectors). The study aimed to assess the chemical risks associated with respirable dust exposure in different occupations and industries and to compare the outcomes of three chemical risk assessment methods based on the following steps: i.Collection and analysis of dust samples from the air in the industries and occupations under study.ii.Evaluation of chemical risk associated with dust exposure using the quantitative method based on the US-EPA model in the studied industries and occupations.iii.Assessment of chemical risk using the semi-quantitative SQRA method in the studied industries and occupations.iv.Evaluation of chemical risk using the qualitative method of the International Council on Mining and Metals (ICMM) for the air in the industries and occupations under study.v.Comparison of the findings from the four methods with the measured dust concentrations to determine the most suitable approach for dust risk assessment in the industries and occupations under study.vi.Modeling the risk of dust exposure in the studied industries using the Monte Carlo simulation. i.Collection and analysis of dust samples from the air in the industries and occupations under study. Collection and analysis of dust samples from the air in the industries and occupations under study. ii.Evaluation of chemical risk associated with dust exposure using the quantitative method based on the US-EPA model in the studied industries and occupations. Evaluation of chemical risk associated with dust exposure using the quantitative method based on the US-EPA model in the studied industries and occupations. iii.Assessment of chemical risk using the semi-quantitative SQRA method in the studied industries and occupations. Assessment of chemical risk using the semi-quantitative SQRA method in the studied industries and occupations. iv.Evaluation of chemical risk using the qualitative method of the International Council on Mining and Metals (ICMM) for the air in the industries and occupations under study. Evaluation of chemical risk using the qualitative method of the International Council on Mining and Metals (ICMM) for the air in the industries and occupations under study. v.Comparison of the findings from the four methods with the measured dust concentrations to determine the most suitable approach for dust risk assessment in the industries and occupations under study. Comparison of the findings from the four methods with the measured dust concentrations to determine the most suitable approach for dust risk assessment in the industries and occupations under study. vi.Modeling the risk of dust exposure in the studied industries using the Monte Carlo simulation. Modeling the risk of dust exposure in the studied industries using the Monte Carlo simulation. Sampling and analysis of respirable dust Respirable dust measurement and analysis followed the NIOSH 0600 method36. Sampling was conducted at a height of 1.5 m using an SKC Universal 44XR air sampling pump (USA) at a flow rate of 2.5 L/min. Polyvinyl chloride filters (37 mm, 5-µm pore size, SKC, USA) were mounted on a backup pad within a three-piece cassette (Whatman Grade QM-A, 37 mm, UK) (Whatman Grade QM-A, 37 mm; Whatman, Midstone, UK) equipped with a respirable cyclone. Cotton dust concentration was measured using a vertical elutriator (Sierra Instruments Inc., Carmel Valley, CA) following OSHA standards. This device collects particles with an aerodynamic equivalent diameter cutoff of ~ 15 μm at a flow rate of 7.4 ± 0.2 L/min in the breathing zone (1.6 m above ground). Dust samples were collected on 37-mm polyvinyl chloride filters with a 5-µm pore size37. Filters were weighed before and after sampling using an electronic balance (Mettler Toledo, AG245, Switzerland) with a precision of 0.01 mg. The pump flow rate was calibrated before and after sampling using an air flow calibrator (Drycal, Mesa Labs Bios Defender 510-H, USA). Mass concentration was calculated by dividing the measured weight by the sampled air volume, determined from the flow rate and sampling duration38. The collected samples from various industries were then sent to the laboratory for further analysis. A total of 160 personal respirable dust samples were collected across the four industries (40 per industry). Each sample was obtained over a full-shift duration to reflect time-weighted average exposure conditions. Sampling was conducted under normal operational circumstances without modification of production processes. Environmental conditions, including workshop ventilation status and seasonal climate characteristics, were documented during monitoring to ensure representativeness of routine exposure scenarios. All samples were collected within the breathing zone of workers using calibrated personal sampling pumps, in accordance with the NIOSH 0600 protocol. All exposure measurements and subsequent risk calculations in this study were based exclusively on respirable dust fraction (PM₄), as determined using the NIOSH 0600 method. Inhalable dust fraction was not considered in this study due to differences in sampling methodology and health impact pathways. Chemical risk assessment of dust Method 1: US-EPA based health risk assessment method This risk assessment method has been proposed by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US-EPA) to evaluate the health risks associated with chemical exposure to human health39. The method follows the guidelines set by the US-EPA as outlined below40. In this risk assessment approach, the first step involves calculating the average daily dose of dust exposure (EC) according to the following equation:\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:EC=\frac{C\times\:ET\times\:EF\times\:ED}{AT}$$\end{document} Where HQ is Hazard quotient for non-carcinogenic risk of substances; EC is Average daily exposure dose in milligrams per cubic meter; RfD is Reference concentration (mg/m³) for PM2.5 (respirable particles), equal to 0.005 mg/m³41; C is Dust concentration under evaluation in milligrams per cubic meter; ET is Exposure time in hours per day; EF is Exposure frequency in days per year; ED is Exposure duration in years; AT is Average exposure time in hours, which for non-carcinogenic effects is calculated as AT = ED x 365 × 24, and for carcinogenic effects as AT = 70 × 365 × 24 = 631,200. Then, to calculate the non-carcinogenic risk of the compounds, the hazard quotient (HQ) for dust must be calculated using the following equation:1\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:HQ=\:\frac{EC}{RfD}$$\end{document} In this method, if the HQ for non-carcinogenic substances is greater than 1, the worker is at risk of adverse health effects. If it is less than 1, the health risk is lower42. To calculate the lifetime carcinogenic risk (CR) in this method, the following equation should be used:\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:\mathrm{C}\mathrm{R}=EC\times\:\:\mathrm{I}\mathrm{U}\mathrm{R}$$\end{document} IUR: Inhalation Unit Risk (mg per cubic meter) (PM2.5 particles equal to 0.000008 mg per cubic meter). In this method, the carcinogenic risk (CR) of substances can be evaluated in three categories: If CR is less than 10− 6, the carcinogenic risk is negligible.If CR is between 10− 4 and 10− 6, the carcinogenic risk should be considered.If CR is greater than 10− 4, the carcinogenic risk should be strongly considered. If CR is less than 10− 6, the carcinogenic risk is negligible. If CR is less than 10− 6, the carcinogenic risk is negligible. If CR is between 10− 4 and 10− 6, the carcinogenic risk should be considered. If CR is between 10− 4 and 10− 6, the carcinogenic risk should be considered. If CR is greater than 10− 4, the carcinogenic risk should be strongly considered. If CR is greater than 10− 4, the carcinogenic risk should be strongly considered. Method 2: semi-quantitative risk assessment The semi-quantitative health risk assessment technique for chemicals (SQRA) was introduced by the Singapore Institute of Safety and Occupational Health. This method systematically identifies chemical hazards, evaluates exposure or the potential for exposure, determines the level of risk, and prioritizes risk communication actions. The steps for performing this method are as follows. In this method, two factors are significant: hazard rate (HR) and exposure rate (ER). The hazard rate (HR) can be determined using information related to the acute toxicity values of substances, including LD50 and LC50 indices for compounds, as outlined in Table 131. Table 1Acute toxicity degrees.Risk FactorLD50 absorbed orally in rats (mg/kg)LD50 absorbed through the skin in rabbits or rats (mg/kg)LC50 absorbed through the respiratory system in rats (mg/lit) for gas and steam exposure over a four-hour periodLC50 absorbed through the respiratory system in rats (mg/lit) for airborne particles22000<2000<20<5<3200 < LD50 < 2000400 < LD50 < 20002 < LC50 < 201 < Lc50 < 5425 < LD50 < 20050 < LD50 < 4000.5 < LD50 < 20.25 < LD50 < 15< 25< 50< 0.5< 0.25 Table 1Acute toxicity degrees.Risk FactorLD50 absorbed orally in rats (mg/kg)LD50 absorbed through the skin in rabbits or rats (mg/kg)LC50 absorbed through the respiratory system in rats (mg/lit) for gas and steam exposure over a four-hour periodLC50 absorbed through the respiratory system in rats (mg/lit) for airborne particles22000<2000<20<5<3200 < LD50 < 2000400 < LD50 < 20002 < LC50 < 201 < Lc50 < 5425 < LD50 < 20050 < LD50 < 4000.5 < LD50 < 20.25 < LD50 < 15< 25< 50< 0.5< 0.25 Acute toxicity degrees. In this method, to calculate the exposure rate factor (ER), the time-weighted average weekly exposure is first determined using the formula below when air monitoring results are available:\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:\mathrm{E}=\frac{\mathrm{F}\times\:\mathrm{D}\times\:\mathrm{M}}{\mathrm{W}}$$\end{document} Where E is Weekly exposure (ppm or mg/m³); F is Frequency of exposure per week (number of times per week); D is Average duration of each exposure (hours); M is Magnitude of exposure (ppm or mg/m³); W is Average weekly working hours (40 h). The calculated E value from the above equation is then compared with permissible exposure limits, and the ER value is determined based on Table 2 and Table 3. Table 2Exposure rate calculation method.Exposure rate (ER) \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:\raisebox{1ex}{$\mathrm{E}$}\!\left/\:\!\raisebox{-1ex}{$\mathrm{O}\mathrm{E}\mathrm{L}$}\right.$$\end{document} 1< 0.120.1–0.530.5–141–252≤ Table 2Exposure rate calculation method.Exposure rate (ER) \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:\raisebox{1ex}{$\mathrm{E}$}\!\left/\:\!\raisebox{-1ex}{$\mathrm{O}\mathrm{E}\mathrm{L}$}\right.$$\end{document} 1< 0.120.1–0.530.5–141–252≤ Exposure rate calculation method. Table 3Occupational exposure limits for dust based on the latest permissible exposure limits handbook of Iran.Type of IndustryType of DustOccupational Exposure Limit (mg/m³)WoodSoftwood Dust5Food IndustryGrain Dust4TextileRaw Cotton Dust0.1Livestock and PoultryUnspecified Dust3 Table 3Occupational exposure limits for dust based on the latest permissible exposure limits handbook of Iran.Type of IndustryType of DustOccupational Exposure Limit (mg/m³)WoodSoftwood Dust5Food IndustryGrain Dust4TextileRaw Cotton Dust0.1Livestock and PoultryUnspecified Dust3 Occupational exposure limits for dust based on the latest permissible exposure limits handbook of Iran. Finally, the risk score for exposure to each compound can be calculated using the following equation. Based on the calculated risk score, the risk rank can be determined using Table 4, :\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:R=\sqrt{HR\times\:ER}$$\end{document} Table 4Method for determining risk rank.Risk scoreRankingRisk RateNecessary actions0–1.7NegligibleNEnd of evaluation,reassessment every 5years1.7–2.8LowLNon-continuous airsampling, reassessmentevery 5 year2.8–3.5MediumMContinuous air sampling,reassessment every 4years3.5–4.5HighHCompletion ofengineering controls,air sampling, personalprotective equipment4.5–5Very highVHCompletion ofengineering controls,air sampling, personalprotective equipment,setting emergencyprocedures Table 4Method for determining risk rank.Risk scoreRankingRisk RateNecessary actions0–1.7NegligibleNEnd of evaluation,reassessment every 5years1.7–2.8LowLNon-continuous airsampling, reassessmentevery 5 year2.8–3.5MediumMContinuous air sampling,reassessment every 4years3.5–4.5HighHCompletion ofengineering controls,air sampling, personalprotective equipment4.5–5Very highVHCompletion ofengineering controls,air sampling, personalprotective equipment,setting emergencyprocedures Method for determining risk rank. End of evaluation, reassessment every 5 years Non-continuous air sampling, reassessment every 5 year Continuous air sampling, reassessment every 4 years Completion of engineering controls, air sampling, personal protective equipment Completion of engineering controls, air sampling, personal protective equipment, setting emergency procedures Method 3: international council on mining and metals (ICMM) model The model introduced by the International Council on Mining and Metals (ICMM) comprehensively considers factors such as potential health outcomes, exposure probability, and exposure duration. It determines risk levels using either the quantitative allocation method or the matrix method. The quantitative allocation method is used when occupational disease risk monitoring results are unavailable, while the matrix method is applied when such monitoring results are present43. In this method, the risk level is calculated using the following formula44:\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$${\mathrm{RR}}\,=\,{\mathrm{C}} \times {\mathrm{PrE}} \times {\mathrm{PeE}} \times {\mathrm{U}}$$\end{document} Where RR is Risk Rank; C is Frequency; PrE is Probability of Exposure; PeE is Duration of Exposure; U is Uncertainty Factor (as per Table 5). Table 5ICMM risk criteria scoring table.Risk CriteriaDescriptionScore PrE Low3Medium6High10 PeE Once a year0.5Few times a year1Short periods multiple times a month2Between 2 and 8 h per shift continuously6More than 8 h10 C Exposure at this level is unlikely to result in harm1Reversible health effects that are not life-threatening15Adverse health effects that are permanent but do not significantly impact quality of life or life expectancy. Effects that may be slightly limiting or disabling, potentially resulting in job or lifestyle changes.50Adverse health effects that are generally permanent and can result in a significant reduction in quality of life or life expectancy. Chronic exposure usually leads to permanent physical or mental disability or a long-term limiting illness.100 U Certain1Uncertain2Very uncertain3 RR Acceptable riskBelow 20Potential risk20–70High risk70–200Very high risk200–400UnacceptableAbove 400 Table 5ICMM risk criteria scoring table.Risk CriteriaDescriptionScore PrE Low3Medium6High10 PeE Once a year0.5Few times a year1Short periods multiple times a month2Between 2 and 8 h per shift continuously6More than 8 h10 C Exposure at this level is unlikely to result in harm1Reversible health effects that are not life-threatening15Adverse health effects that are permanent but do not significantly impact quality of life or life expectancy. Effects that may be slightly limiting or disabling, potentially resulting in job or lifestyle changes.50Adverse health effects that are generally permanent and can result in a significant reduction in quality of life or life expectancy. Chronic exposure usually leads to permanent physical or mental disability or a long-term limiting illness.100 U Certain1Uncertain2Very uncertain3 RR Acceptable riskBelow 20Potential risk20–70High risk70–200Very high risk200–400UnacceptableAbove 400 ICMM risk criteria scoring table. Monte carlo simulation In this study, Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) was used for health risk assessment modeling. MCS is a mathematical technique that estimates the probable outcomes of uncertain events by generating random numbers based on the probability distribution of each variable with inherent uncertainty45. The results are then recalculated across the distribution of the variables. For this study, 10,000 data points were generated to explore potential outcomes. RStudio software (version 2022.02.2) and the Monte Carlo package (version 1.06) were used for MCS calculations46. The first step in this method was to determine the statistical distributions of the input parameters, for which the fitdistrplus package (version 1.1-8) in RStudio was used. Table 6 presents the statistical distributions for the input variables. Based on these distributions, 10,000 data points were generated using R software. The generated data were then used to calculate the carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic risks of the respirable dust. The selection of probability distributions for Monte Carlo simulation inputs (Table 6) was based on the statistical characteristics of the variables and established practices in exposure assessment studies. Lognormal distributions were assigned to exposure-related variables such as contaminant concentration, as environmental and occupational exposure data typically exhibit right-skewed behavior. Parameters with approximately symmetric variability were modeled using normal distributions. In cases where limited data were available, uniform or triangular distributions were applied based on minimum, maximum, and most likely values. These assumptions are consistent with previous risk assessment studies and widely accepted modeling approaches. The probability distributions assigned to input variables were selected based on their statistical properties and common practices in occupational exposure modeling. Lognormal distributions were used for exposure-related variables such as respirable dust concentration, reflecting their typically right-skewed distribution. Other parameters, including physiological and exposure factors, were modeled using normal, uniform, or triangular distributions depending on data availability. Monte Carlo simulations were performed using 10,000 iterations to ensure stability and convergence of the output estimates. Table 6Statistical distributions for the input variables.ParameterUnitDiscriptionDistributionCWmg/m3wood industryWeibull (α = 1.8059 β = 4.5736)BW_wKgwood industryLognormal (3P) (σ = 0.80101 µ = 2.1112 γ = 61.044)IRm3/hrwood industry(0.0325 × BW + 0.6045)/24EThr/daywood industryUniform (5–7)EFday/yearwood industryUniform (270–312)EDYearwood industrypoint (30)CFoodmg/m3food industryBeta (α1 = 0.88964 α2 = 0.81897a = 2.4 b = 18.6)BWFoodKgfood industryLognormal (3P) (σ = 0.82303 µ = 1.9196 γ = 63.923Ctextilemg/m3textile industryWeibull (3P)(α = 1.484 β = 1.4655 γ = 0.03172)BWtextileKgtextile industryGamma (3P)(α = 3.0546 β = 4.749 γ = 61.294)Cconmg/m3livestock and poultry industryLognormal (3P)(σ = 0.14696 µ = 2.3172 γ=-7.3448)BWconKglivestock and poultry industryLognormal (3P)(σ = 0.49825 µ = 2.4988 γ = 58.759ATDayall industrypoint (ED*365)LTDayall industrypoint (70*365) Table 6Statistical distributions for the input variables.ParameterUnitDiscriptionDistributionCWmg/m3wood industryWeibull (α = 1.8059 β = 4.5736)BW_wKgwood industryLognormal (3P) (σ = 0.80101 µ = 2.1112 γ = 61.044)IRm3/hrwood industry(0.0325 × BW + 0.6045)/24EThr/daywood industryUniform (5–7)EFday/yearwood industryUniform (270–312)EDYearwood industrypoint (30)CFoodmg/m3food industryBeta (α1 = 0.88964 α2 = 0.81897a = 2.4 b = 18.6)BWFoodKgfood industryLognormal (3P) (σ = 0.82303 µ = 1.9196 γ = 63.923Ctextilemg/m3textile industryWeibull (3P)(α = 1.484 β = 1.4655 γ = 0.03172)BWtextileKgtextile industryGamma (3P)(α = 3.0546 β = 4.749 γ = 61.294)Cconmg/m3livestock and poultry industryLognormal (3P)(σ = 0.14696 µ = 2.3172 γ=-7.3448)BWconKglivestock and poultry industryLognormal (3P)(σ = 0.49825 µ = 2.4988 γ = 58.759ATDayall industrypoint (ED*365)LTDayall industrypoint (70*365) Statistical distributions for the input variables. Beta (α1 = 0.88964 α2 = 0.81897 a = 2.4 b = 18.6) Data analysis Data analysis was conducted using SPSS software (version 25). For the evaluation of quantitative variables, the mean and standard deviation were calculated using descriptive statistical tests. In this study, a one-sample t-test was applied to determine whether the mean measured concentrations and corresponding risk scores significantly differed from established reference values, including occupational exposure limits (OELs) and method-specific acceptable risk thresholds. Results The demographic characteristics of the participants, including height, weight, duration, frequency, exposure time, and the concentration of respirable dust in the air, are presented in Table 7. Table 7Mean demographic characteristics, duration, time, and frequency of exposure in the studied industries.ParameterMean ± SD Height (cm) 175.53 ± 6 Weight (kg) Wood industries72.05 ± 8.17Food industries73.40 ± 6.31Textile industries75.80 ± 5.07Livestock and poultry72.50 ± 7.09 Age (years) 36 ± 2 Duration of exposure (years) Wood industries10.65 ± 4.49Food industries10.90 ± 4.38Textile industries10.90 ± 5.68Livestock and poultry11.70 ± 5.50 Frequency of exposure (days·year -1 ) Wood industries299.30 ± 16.04Food industries301.15 ± 14.84Textile industries303.15 ± 14.74Livestock and poultry305.35 ± 12.34 Exposure time (h·day -1 ) Wood industries6.35 ± 0.81Food industries6.30 ± 0.86Textile industries6.30 ± 0.86Livestock and poultry6.05 ± 0.88 Table 7Mean demographic characteristics, duration, time, and frequency of exposure in the studied industries.ParameterMean ± SD Height (cm) 175.53 ± 6 Weight (kg) Wood industries72.05 ± 8.17Food industries73.40 ± 6.31Textile industries75.80 ± 5.07Livestock and poultry72.50 ± 7.09 Age (years) 36 ± 2 Duration of exposure (years) Wood industries10.65 ± 4.49Food industries10.90 ± 4.38Textile industries10.90 ± 5.68Livestock and poultry11.70 ± 5.50 Frequency of exposure (days·year -1 ) Wood industries299.30 ± 16.04Food industries301.15 ± 14.84Textile industries303.15 ± 14.74Livestock and poultry305.35 ± 12.34 Exposure time (h·day -1 ) Wood industries6.35 ± 0.81Food industries6.30 ± 0.86Textile industries6.30 ± 0.86Livestock and poultry6.05 ± 0.88 Mean demographic characteristics, duration, time, and frequency of exposure in the studied industries. Table 8 presents the dust concentration across the studied industries. The highest respirable dust concentration was recorded in the food industry, whereas the lowest concentration was observed in the textile industry. Table 8Maximum, time-weighted average, and minimum concentration of respirable dust in the studied industries.IndustryMinimum Concentration (mg/m³)TWA Concentration (mg/m³)Maximum Concentration (mg/m³)Standard DeviationWood1.304.097.101.94Food2.4010.8318.604.91Textile0.101.364.100.91Livestock & Poultry0.302.916.601.55 Table 8Maximum, time-weighted average, and minimum concentration of respirable dust in the studied industries.IndustryMinimum Concentration (mg/m³)TWA Concentration (mg/m³)Maximum Concentration (mg/m³)Standard DeviationWood1.304.097.101.94Food2.4010.8318.604.91Textile0.101.364.100.91Livestock & Poultry0.302.916.601.55 Maximum, time-weighted average, and minimum concentration of respirable dust in the studied industries. The results of the toxicological risk assessment for respirable dust exposure across different industries are presented in Table 9. It should be noted that the statistical analysis presented in Table 9 is based on comparison with predefined benchmark values rather than direct comparison between variables. The one-sample t-test was used to evaluate whether the estimated risk scores and measured concentrations significantly deviate from acceptable or permissible limits. This approach aligns with the risk assessment framework, where deviations from regulatory thresholds are of primary importance. The rationale for using this test is based on the fact that risk interpretation in occupational health is inherently benchmark-driven, where both exposure levels and risk scores are evaluated against predefined regulatory or guideline values rather than compared between independent groups. Therefore, the one-sample t-test was considered appropriate for assessing whether observed values deviate significantly from these reference standards. According to the findings, the average carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic risk scores assessed using Method 1 indicate potential adverse health effects in all industries. Specifically, the carcinogenic risk in the textile industry requires attention, while in the wood, food, and livestock & poultry industries, it is a significant concern. Based on the toxicological risk assessment using Method 2, the average risk level was negligible in the wood and livestock & poultry industries, indicating no need for further risk evaluation, with measurements required only once every five years. In the food industry, the risk level was low, suggesting no need for continued sampling, with periodic evaluations every five years. However, in the textile industry, the risk level was classified as very high, requiring immediate sampling, engineering controls, personal protective equipment, and urgent corrective actions. The results of the toxicological risk assessment using Method 3 indicated that the measured risk levels in all studied industries were intolerable. The time-weighted average (TWA) concentrations of respirable dust in the food and textile industries exceeded the permissible limits, while in the wood and livestock & poultry industries, the concentrations were below the permissible limits. As shown in Table 9, respirable dust was evaluated and ranked using all three methods. Further analysis compared the risk scores obtained from the three toxicological risk assessment methods with the TWA concentrations of respirable dust in the studied industries. A one-sample t-test revealed a significant difference between the mean risk scores from all methods and the TWA concentrations in the studied industries (P-value < 0.05). However, the significance of the difference in non-carcinogenic risk scores between Method 1 and Method 3 was lower in the livestock & poultry industry compared to the other industries and methods. Table 9Average respirable dust concentration, comparison with occupational exposure standard, risk score determination, and comparison of three studied methods across different industries.IndustryWoodFoodTextileLivestock and Poultry Time-Weighted Average Respirable Dust Concentration (mg/m³) 4.09 ± 1.9410.83 ± 4.911.36 ± 0.912.91 ± 1.55 Occupational Exposure Limit (mg/m³) 540.13 USEPA-Based Method Non-Carcinogenic RiskMean Risk Score (Mean ± SD)178.49 ± 88.96472.78 ± 234.0759.55 ± 41.1756.92 ± 42.18Mean Risk LevelAdverse health effectsAdverse health effectsAdverse health effectsAdverse health effectsP value0.001<0.001<0.001<0.001