Role of Immunological Markers in Diagnosis, Prognosis, and Treatment of Early Childhood Caries and Adult Caries: A Systematic Review Authors: Vishnu Priya Veeraraghavan, Ullas Mony, Gamal Othman, Bashayer Khalid Alskait Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundDental caries is a common oral health problem that affects people all over the world. To detect and treat it early on, it is important to have a thorough understanding of its genesis and potential biomarkers.ObjectiveThe objective of this systematic review is to answer the question: “Is there any role of immune status in the development of dental caries among children and adults, and is there any potential in using immunological markers for diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment of this condition?”DesignFrom 2016 to 2024, a thorough search approach adhering to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) criteria was used across several datasets (PROSPERO: CRD42024612045). To find pertinent publications, a total of 2,723 articles were searched using keywords associated with dental caries, immunity, and interventions. The inclusion criteria included papers that addressed the connection between immunity and the development of caries, interventions, and results, including alterations in basal metabolic rate (BMR), weight gain in patients, improvements in quality of life, and recurrence of carious lesions. Two reviewers independently extracted the data, assessed its quality, and assessed the risk of bias using validated instruments such as the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool and the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale.ResultsThe evaluation encompassed 10 articles in all, demonstrating noteworthy correlations between immunological indicators and dental caries. Results point to a favorable correlation between salivary immunoglobulin A (IgA) levels and the number of carious teeth, as well as an increase in proinflammatory cytokine concentrations in dental caries patients. Furthermore, the pulp tissue of dental caries patients has different bacterial communities and higher expression of proinflammatory cytokines, suggesting a possible connection between immune activation and dysbiosis.ConclusionThe findings highlight the significance of immune status/immunological indicators in the diagnosis and treatment of dental caries, emphasizing the necessity for additional study to corroborate these conclusions and improve treatment and preventative dental care practices.Clinical relevanceThis work has got great relevance to pediatric dentists. The current work highlights a possible link between the immune status and the development of caries in pediatric and adult patients as well as the potential of immunological markers in the diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment of dental caries in both pediatric and adult patients.Prospero registration numberCRD42024612045. Introduction Dental caries is a prevalent long-lasting condition that impacts people worldwide, causing harm to their oral health and overall well-being.1 The erosion of tooth enamel and the development of cavities are key indicators of dental caries, which can manifest as adult caries (AC) in adults and early childhood caries (ECC) in young children.2 According to Colak et al.,3 multiple etiologies and risk factors have an impact on both stages, with ECC largely affecting the primary dentition and AC primarily targeting permanent teeth. Some of the associated risk factors that lead to early adult caries (EAC) include sociodemographic, dietary (breastfeeding/bottle feeding), oral hygiene factors, and factors related to oral bacterial flora, etc.1 Thus, it is imperative to determine the pathophysiology of dental caries and develop preventive measures that require knowledge and understanding of the role of immune status facilitating the initiation and progression of caries. According to Babu et al.,4 immune responses are important in controlling host–microbial interactions in the oral cavity, which affects the beginning and development of caries.4 Salivary components, cytokines, and immune cells influence caries susceptibility by supporting local defense mechanisms against cariogenic bacteria.5 Immunological variables interact in a complicated way to influence the start and progression of dental caries in both adults and children. By inhibiting the adherence of cariogenic bacteria to hard surfaces, salivary secretory immunoglobulin A (s-IgA) plays a critical role in controlling caries activity. To further limit the colonization of cariogenic bacteria, s-IgA also neutralizes viruses and toxins, suppresses enzyme activity, and removes antigens from saliva. An immunological response is triggered by exposure to cariogenic microbiota, which causes immune components to be secreted against different microorganism epitopes. Certain theories contend that binding lowers salivary levels of free s-IgA, a sign of dental caries activity, while other theories contend that binding triggers an immunological response, raising salivary levels of free s-IgA. Moreover, cytokines that affect immune responses and encourage the development of immunological reactions that are essential for the shift from innate to adaptive immunity, such as tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α) and interleukin-6 (IL-6), are linked to inflammation and tissue damage. By recruiting and activating immune cells, IL-8 contributes to the pathophysiology of dental caries by playing a major role in inflammation, chemotaxis, and neutrophil activation. These immunological components and processes are involved in the development and advancement of dental caries, underscoring the complex interplay between oral health and the immune system.6–8 Studies on the connection between immune status and caries experience have shown associations between immunological variables and susceptibility to caries. There are various studies that have investigated the levels of salivary Ig, cytokine profiles, and polymorphisms in the human leukocyte antigen (HLA) gene with respect to ECC and AC patients.9 There are also studies that have investigated how immunological markers are affected systemically by dental caries, and they have found that there may be two ways that oral health and systemic immunity interact.10 Investigating whether immunological competence can stop the development of ECC and AC is an interesting part of caries research. Research indicates that those with strong immune systems may have better defenses against cariogenic microorganisms, which may lessen their susceptibility to dental caries.11 Moreover, immunological therapies that aim to improve or modulate immunity may be promising for managing and preventing dental caries.12 The objective of this systematic review was to examine whether immunocompetence can reduce the risk of caries by analyzing the function of immunity and immunological state in the development of ECC and AC. This review aimed to clarify the intricate relationship between host immunity and caries etiology by combining data from immunological investigations. This would help to acknowledge the preventive measures and therapeutic approaches for the management of dental caries. Methodology Research Question Determining the role of immunological state or an individual's immunity in the development of ECC and AC was the research topic that guided this systematic review (PROSPERO: CRD42024612045). The review also sought to investigate whether immunocompetence, or strong immunity, helps to protect against ECC and AC. PICOS Questions Population: The present study included children (aged 1–6 years) and adults (>6 years onward) affected by dental caries. Population: The present study included children (aged 1–6 years) and adults (>6 years onward) affected by dental caries. Intervention: Filling, root canal treatment (RCT), tooth extraction, and fluoride application were among the several interventions that were considered. Intervention: Filling, root canal treatment (RCT), tooth extraction, and fluoride application were among the several interventions that were considered. Comparison: Comparative analysis was made between individuals with different levels of immune status or immunity. Comparison: Comparative analysis was made between individuals with different levels of immune status or immunity. Outcome: This included recurrence of carious lesions, improvement in quality of life, weight gain in patients, and changes in basal metabolic rate (BMR). Outcome: This included recurrence of carious lesions, improvement in quality of life, weight gain in patients, and changes in basal metabolic rate (BMR). The timeline of the study is 2016–2024 (8 years). The timeline of the study is 2016–2024 (8 years). Search Strategy The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) standards were followed while developing a systematic search strategy (Fig. 1). The goal of this approach was to make sure that all pertinent material was thoroughly covered by several databases. The databases that were searched were Google Scholar, Web of Science, PubMed, Cochrane Library, and Scopus all of which are well-known sources of scientific literature (Table 1). A large collection of pertinent keywords and phrases was found to maximize the search's efficacy. The following keywords, which include “immunity,” “immune status,” “immunoglobulin,” “cytokine,” “T cells,” “B cells,” “natural killer cells,” “early childhood caries,” and “adult caries,” “interleukin-6,” “immunological markers,” were carefully chosen to cover several facets of the research topic. After the keywords were selected, logical search queries were created by combining them using Boolean operators. Using OR to combine synonymous terms expands the search to include various expressions of the same concept. Using AND to combine different concepts ensures that the search results are relevant to the research question by including all required aspects. This method maximized the retrieval of pertinent research by making it easier to refine search queries and include synonyms or related terms. To maximize search results, the search strategy was customized to the unique syntax and features of each database. The databases' filters and advanced search features were used to focus search results according to publication date, study type, and other pertinent factors. The goal of the systematic search approach was to find all pertinent studies that discussed the relationship between immunity and immunological state and the development of both adult and ECC. Transparency and repeatability in the literature retrieval process were guaranteed by this method. Table 1:Electronic database and search strategy Database Search strategy PubMed(“immunity”[MeSH Terms] OR “immune status”[MeSH Terms] OR “immunoglobulin”[MeSH Terms] OR “cytokine”[MeSH Terms] OR “T cells”[MeSH Terms] OR “B cells”[MeSH Terms] OR “natural killer cells”[MeSH Terms] OR “interleukin-6”[MeSH Terms] OR “immunological markers”[MeSH Terms]) AND (“early childhood caries”[MeSH Terms] OR “adult caries”[MeSH Terms] OR “dental caries”[MeSH Terms] OR “tooth decay”[MeSH Terms] OR “cavity”[MeSH Terms]) AND (“intervention”[MeSH Terms] OR “prevention”[MeSH Terms] OR “treatment”[MeSH Terms]) AND (English[lang] AND “2016/01/01”[PDAT]: “2024/12/31”[PDAT])ScopusTITLE-ABS-KEY(“immunity” OR “immune status” OR “immunoglobulin” OR “cytokine” OR “T cells” OR “B cells” OR “natural killer cells” OR “interleukin-6” OR “immunological markers”) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY(“early childhood caries” OR “adult caries” OR “dental caries” OR “tooth decay” OR “cavity”) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY(“intervention” OR “prevention” OR “treatment” OR “therapy”) AND PUBYEAR > 2015Web of ScienceTOPIC: (“immunity” OR “immune status” OR “immunoglobulin” OR “cytokine” OR “T cells” OR “B cells” OR “natural killer cells” OR “interleukin-6” OR “immunological markers”) AND TOPIC: (“early childhood caries” OR “adult caries” OR “dental caries” OR “tooth decay” OR “cavity”) AND TOPIC: (“intervention” OR “prevention” OR “treatment” OR “therapy”) AND (LANGUAGE: (English) AND PUBLICATION YEARS: (2016–2024))Cochrane Library(“immunity”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “immune status”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “immunoglobulin”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “cytokine”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “T cells”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “B cells”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “natural killer cells”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “interleukin-6”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “immunological markers”[Title/Abstract/Keywords]) AND (“early childhood caries”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “adult caries”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “dental caries”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “tooth decay”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “cavity”[Title/Abstract/Keywords]) AND (“intervention”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “prevention”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “treatment”[Title/Abstract/Keywords] OR “therapy”[Title/Abstract/Keywords]) AND (“2016 - 2024”[Date - Publication Date] AND (“Humans”[Filter]) AND (English[Language]))Embase(“immunity”/exp OR “immune status”/exp OR “immunoglobulin”/exp OR “cytokine”/exp OR “T cells”/exp OR “B cells”/exp OR “natural killer cells”/exp OR “interleukin-6”/exp OR “immunological markers”/exp) AND (“early childhood caries”/exp OR “adult caries”/exp OR “dental caries”/exp OR “tooth decay”/exp OR “cavity”/exp) AND (“intervention”/exp OR “prevention”/exp OR “treatment”/exp OR “therapy”/exp) AND (“2016 – 2024”/py AND [humans]/lim AND [english]/lim) Electronic database and search strategy PRISMA 2020 flowchart for the review from databases and registers Selection Criteria Inclusion Criteria Research detailing how immunity or immunological state contributes to the development of AC or ECC. Research detailing how immunity or immunological state contributes to the development of AC or ECC. Research involving subjects older than 1 year that were divided among the EAC and AC groups, respectively. Research involving subjects older than 1 year that were divided among the EAC and AC groups, respectively. Research on dental caries management interventions. Research on dental caries management interventions. Exclusion Criteria Research not released in English. Research not released in English. Research with insufficient information about immunity or immunological state. Research with insufficient information about immunity or immunological state. Research lacks enough data to evaluate the strength of the evidence. Research lacks enough data to evaluate the strength of the evidence. Editorials, commentary, conference abstracts, and case reports. Editorials, commentary, conference abstracts, and case reports. Data Extraction and Quality Assessment A total of 2,723 articles were searched, and after considering all the inclusion and exclusion criteria pertaining to the main aim and research question of the review, only 10 articles were included in the present systematic review for further analysis. Two separate reviewers, UM and VPV, carefully completed the search using a standardized form to guarantee correctness and consistency. The data that were extracted covered a wide range of topics, such as the study's design, participant demographics, interventions, results, and important discoveries about the development of caries and immunological state. This all-encompassing strategy made it easier to analyze the included studies in detail. For observational research, the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale was used, and for randomized controlled trials, the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool was used. Using these strong assessment instruments, the reviewers assessed each study's methodological rigor and any biases, guaranteeing the validity and reliability of the combined data. Data Synthesis Analysis of the data on immunological status/immunity and the development of caries revealed trends or patterns in the research. If necessary, and contingent on the homogeneity of the included studies, a meta-analysis was carried out. Risk of Bias Assessment The reviewers independently evaluated the risk of bias within the included studies using instruments that have been proven to work. A variety of potential sources of bias were assessed, including bias in reporting, detection, attrition, performance, and selection. The reviewers discussed and came to a consensus on any differences in risk assessment. Results Table 2 presents a synthesis of research findings regarding the immunology of dental caries in the systematic review. Research found a notable reduction in IL-6 levels in saliva after therapy for ECC, indicating IL-6's importance in decreasing oral inflammation.13 Another research discovered increased vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) levels in saliva that were associated with greater caries scores, connecting inflammation indicators to caries severity.14 A study reported a strong connection between the levels of salivary IgA and the severity of caries, showing an immune response to bacteria causing tooth decay.9 Increased levels of proinflammatory cytokines in the blood of children with ECC indicate systemic inflammation in the development of dental caries.15 Elevated IL-6 levels in kids with active cavities suggest IL-6's involvement in cavity development.16 Elevated levels of salivary soluble human leukocyte antigen-G (sHLA-G) in children with dental caries indicate involvement in regulating the immune response.11 A decreased expression of CD4+ T lymphocytes in children with severe ECC suggested a diminished adaptive immune response.17 Elevated levels of serum C-reactive protein (CRP) and proinflammatory cytokines in the elderly may indicate a chronic inflammatory factor associated with dental caries. Alterations in mouth bacteria and elevated levels of natural immune indicators in tooth pulp affected by cavities underscore the importance of host–microorganism connections in cavity formation. Table 2 gathers research on tactics for addressing ECC and the results they yield. Important discoveries show a marked drop in IL-6 levels in saliva after dental treatment, suggesting lower oral inflammation (Table 3).13 Increased levels of VEGF and IL-6 in saliva were linked to both maternal caries index and obesity, according to one study (Table 3).14 Another study found that elevated levels of IL-6, TNF-α, and neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin (NGAL) in serum were associated with the severity of ECC, emphasizing the impact of chronic inflammation on the progression of dental caries.15 Children who have active cavities showed increased levels of IL-6 in their saliva, while elevated levels of sHLA-G in the saliva of children with cavities indicated its potential as a biomarker for susceptibility to cavities11,16 (Table 3). Table 2:List of previous studies included in the systematic review Author/year Aim of study Type of study Methodology and materials Study findings Immunology of dental caries in the study groups Menon et al. (2016)13To measure the levels of salivary IL-6 both before and after receiving complete dental care in children with ECCObservational cohort studyELISA was used to determine the levels of IL-6 in saliva samples taken both before and after therapy. After creating individualized treatment programs, there was a 3-month follow-upGingival index scores improved after treatment, and there was a significant drop in salivary IL-6 levelsSalivary IL-6 levels in children with ECC were greater prior to therapy; however, these levels dramatically dropped during full mouth rehabilitation, suggesting a decrease in oral inflammationRibeiro et al. (2018)14To measure proinflammatory cytokine levels in saliva (IL-6, TNF-α, and VEGF) and compare them to dental caries, obesity, and sugar consumption in mothers and their offspringCross-sectional studyA retrospective cohort with a cross-sectional approach evaluated mothers and children aged 24–71 months. Following Parafilm® mastication, saliva samples were obtained for analysis of IL-6, TNF-α, and VEGF. Data on diet, dental caries, and BMI were obtained through anthropometrics, oral examinations, and interviews. In order to shed light on dental caries immunology, this strategy investigated relationships between salivary indicators, caries, obesity, and sugar intakeSalivary levels of VEGF were found to relate to higher caries index in both mothers and children, suggesting a possible relationship between the proinflammatory marker and the severity of caries. Elevated levels of VEGF in saliva were also linked to increased sugar intake and maternal obesity. Salivary IL-6 levels and the maternal caries index exhibited a positive connection, pointing to a possible involvement of IL-6 in the caries process. Compared to children without dental caries, children with ECC had greater mean and median levels of IL-6 and VEGF, yet statistical significance was not attained—possibly because of sample size constraintsThe study found a complicated correlation between salivary inflammatory markers, obesity, and tooth caries that suggests an underlying immune mechanism. Increased levels of VEGF and IL-6 in people with higher caries indices, together with associations with sugar consumption and maternal obesity, point to a metabolic-inflammatory relationship. Acknowledging these immunological variables highlights how crucial it is to implement obesity and sugar reduction programs in order to reduce the incidence of dental cariesHaeri-Araghi et al. (2018)9To assess the connection between adult dental caries severity and salivary IgA levelsObservational study40 persons between the ages of 20 and 40 years who worked in the oral medicine department at Qazvin University of Medical Sciences made up the study population. Based on the number of deteriorated teeth, participants were divided into four groups: Caries-free (CF), 1–2 decayed teeth, 3–4 decayed teeth, and 5 or more decayed teeth. By spitting, unstimulated saliva samples were obtained following a 2-hour fast. The extracted saliva samples were then used to measure the amounts of salivary IgA using an immunoturbidometric techniqueSalivary IgA levels were found to be significantly correlated with the number of teeth with decay. To be more precise, those who had more teeth deteriorated had greater salivary IgA levels than subjects who had less or no teeth decay. Significant variations in salivary IgA levels between some groups were also found by the research, suggesting that the severity of dental caries is positively correlated with an increase in IgA levelsAccording to the study, dental caries may cause an immunological reaction, as seen by elevated salivary IgA levels that are correlated with the severity of the caries. Salivary IgA may be a sign of immunological activity against oral bacteria, suggesting that it may be useful in the treatment of dental caries. To investigate underlying mechanisms and clinical implications, more study is requiredLima et al. (2018)15To investigate the relationship between proinflammatory cytokine levels in the blood and the degree of ECC in preschoolers younger than 72 monthsCase–control studyEighty children without dental caries and 72 children with ECC were randomly chosen from a broader cohort for this case–control research. Proinflammatory cytokines (TNF-α, NGAL, and IL-6) were detected in serum and divided into tertiles. Poisson regression models were used to modify data on intake of sugar-sweetened beverages, excess weight, and socioeconomic characteristics in the analysisThere is a strong association between the number of decaying teeth and elevated blood levels of NGAL, TNF-α, and IL-6 in preschoolers, suggesting a link between systemic inflammation and the severity of ECC. Even after controlling for extra weight and socioeconomic characteristics, adjusted models maintained the connectionThe results imply that the severity of ECC in preschoolers is caused by chronic inflammation, which is reflected in higher serum levels of proinflammatory cytokines. Systemic inflammation seems to be an important factor in the etiology of ECC, even though there was no clear correlation found between serum cytokine levels and dental infection. These findings highlight how crucial it is to restrict children's intake of sugar-sweetened beverages in order to lessen the risk of developing ECC and chronic inflammationLo Giudice et al. (2019)16To assess the relationship between the levels of IL-6 and s-IgA in kids with dental caries and the severity of the cariesCross-sectional studyA retrospective study involving 59 patients from the Messina University Department of Dentistry, ages 4–16 years, was carried out. In order to determine the severity of caries, dental examinations were conducted and saliva samples were taken. The decayed, missing, filled teeth (DMFT) index, the PUFA index, and the Mount and Hume site/stage (Si/Sta) index were used to measure caries. The factors between the CF and caries-active groups were compared using statistical analyses, such as the Mann–Whitney test and the Chi-squared testSalivary IgA levels did not significantly change between the CF and caries-active groups, according to the study. IL-6 levels, however, were noticeably greater in the group with active caries. IgA and IL-6 concentrations did not significantly differ according to subgroup analysis based on the degree of cariesThe research demonstrated the possible involvement of IL-6 in dental caries by finding a link between high IL-6 levels and active caries. Nevertheless, there was no discernible link discovered between salivary IgA levels and dental caries. These results imply that IL-6 might be involved in the immunology of dental caries, which calls for more research on the role of cytokines in the pathophysiology of cariesBijani et al. (2020)11To investigate and compare the levels of sHLA-G in the saliva of kids between the ages of 3 and 5 years who have dental cavities and those who do notAnalytical cross-sectional study83 healthy children between the ages of 3 and 5 years participated in this analytical cross-sectional study. The children were split into three groups according to the amount of decayed tooth surfaces (ds): CF children, ECC, and S-ECC. Each participant provided unstimulated saliva samples, and an ELISA kit was used to assess the salivary sHLA-G contentAs compared to children without dental caries (CF group), children with dental caries (both ECC and S-ECC groups) had mean salivary sHLA-G levels that were considerably greater. Nevertheless, there was no discernible variation in the levels of salivary sHLA-G between children with S-ECC and those with ECC. Additionally, a positive connection was seen between the occurrence of dental caries and salivary sHLA-G levelsAccording to the study, children with dental caries had higher salivary sHLA-G levels than children without dental caries. This implies that sHLA-G may have a function in the immune system's reaction to tooth caries. The process of dental caries may be aided in the inhibition of immune responses and the elevation of sHLA-G production. To fully understand the precise mechanisms behind the correlation between sHLA-G and dental caries and its implications for caries prevention and management tactics, more research is requiredLuthfi et al. (2020)17To examine the expression of T lymphocyte cells (CD4+) between infants with CF and S-ECC, in an effort to shed light on possible immunological pathways underlying dental cariesCross-sectional studyUsing an analytical observational methodology, the study analyzed data cross-sectionally on two groups of children: Those without caries and those with S-ECC. Saliva samples were acquired by gargling a sterile NaCl solution, and lymphocyte cells were separated. Using flow cytometry, CD4+ expression was then examinedThe findings showed a significant difference (p = 0.000) in T-lymphocyte cell (CD4+) expression between the CF and S-ECC groups. In particular, the S-ECC group's mean expression of CD4+ cells was lower (6.2525±0.64482) than that of the CF group (8.4138±1.10397), suggesting that the S-ECC group had a weakened immune responseThe function of T lymphocyte cells (CD4+) in the immune response to dental caries was emphasized in the study. Reduced adaptive immunity is suggested by the lower expression of CD4+ cells in S-ECC, which may help explain why cariogenic bacteria like Streptococcus mutans are more common in S-ECC. Decreased expression of CD4+ may prevent B lymphocytes from activating and from releasing proinflammatory cytokines, which would weaken the host's defenses against the S. mutans infection and accelerate the development of dental cariesAlanazi et al. (2021)18To examine the relationship between serum CRP levels and dental caries in the elderly, with an emphasis on measuring proinflammatory cytokine levelsObservational cross-sectional studyTwelve elderly patients, with an average age of 65 years, who had dental caries were involved in the study. Ten healthy donors, with an average age of 60 years, served as the control group. Using the CRP ELISA kit, serum CRP levels were determined. Furthermore, ELISA was used to measure the proinflammatory cytokines IL-36, IL-37, and IL-38 in the study group. To compare the results between the study and control groups, statistical analysis was doneWith an average CRP level of 36 mg/mL, only 5 out of the 12 patients with dental caries were CRP positive. Additionally, the research demonstrated that CRP-positive patients had noticeably higher concentrations of the proinflammatory cytokines IL-36, IL-37, and IL-38 in comparison to the control group. These results point to a possible link between high CRP and raised IL-36, IL-37, and IL-38 levels and dental caries in the elderlyThe study clarifies the immunological components of dental caries in adults, especially in the elderly. Increased CRP and proinflammatory cytokine levels point to an inflammatory reaction linked to dental caries. The observation implies that dental caries in the elderly may have a persistent inflammatory component, underscoring the need for additional investigation to comprehend the immune systems that underlie this prevalent oral health concernGómez-García et al. (2022)19To examine the effects of mild tooth decay on the oral microbiota and compare these changes to indicators of the innate immune response in dental pulp tissue exposed to dentin caries. To clarify immune response mechanisms in the development of dental caries and to comprehend the changes in oral microbiota composition between carious and noncarious teethObservational cross-sectional studyParticipants in a cross-sectional design comprised those with and without dental caries. Using 16S rRNA gene sequencing, bacterial taxonomic profiles were examined to determine the microbial composition variations between teeth with and without caries. In addition, dental pulp tissue from mild caries was evaluated for the presence of innate immune response markers, such as toll-like receptors (TLRs) and proinflammatory cytokines. To find connections between bacterial taxa and immunological markers, statistical techniques such as correlation analysis were performedThere are notable variations in the composition of the oral microbiota between teeth that are carious and those that are not. A specific bacterial profile was seen in caries-affected individuals, with reduced abundances of Haemophilus and Porphyromonas and higher abundances of Actinobacteria and Lactobacillus. In comparison to noncarious tissue, dental pulp tissue exposed to caries showed higher expression of proinflammatory cytokines (IL-1b, IL-6) and chemokines (CXCL8), indicating heightened inflammation. In carious teeth, TLR2 expression was upregulated, indicating that TLR2 plays a part in identifying cariogenic bacteria and triggering immunological responsesThe intricate relationship between the innate immune system and oral bacteria in dental caries was brought to light by the study. In dental pulp tissue, immune responses triggered by bacteria linked to caries resulted in an upregulation of proinflammatory cytokines and chemokines. Differential expression of TLRs indicated that the immune system recognized certain bacteria patterns linked to tooth caries and set off inflammatory pathways. It is essential to comprehend host–microbe interactions in the development of cariesMalas et al. (2024)12To investigate any possible connections between ECC in Syrian children and particular HLA class II alleles (HLA-DR4, HLA-DQ2, and HLA-DQ4)Case–control studyEighty children between the ages of 3 and 6 years participated in the study. They were divided into two groups: Group 1 (n = 40) consisted of children with S-ECC (deft > 10) and group 2 (n = 40) consisted of children without caries (deft = 0). Buccal swab samples were used to extract genomic DNA, which was then amplified using PCR-SSP (polymerase chain reaction-single specific primer). After that, HLA typing was done for every allele. To evaluate the relationship between HLA class II alleles and the occurrence of ECC, statistical analysis was doneThe findings showed that although the frequency of occurrence of the S-ECC, HLA-DR4, and HLA-DQ2 alleles did not differ statistically substantially, the incidence of S-ECC was strongly correlated with the DQ4 allele (p = 0.012). According to the odds ratio, kids who inherited the HLA-DQ4 allele were more likely than kids who did not to get dental caries. These results suggest a major role for HLA class II molecules, specifically HLA-DQ4, in predisposing Syrian children to ECCThe research emphasizes how HLA class II molecules may affect a child's susceptibility to ECC in Syria. HLA-DR4 and HLA-DQ2 alleles did not significantly correlate with the likelihood of developing ECC, whereas HLA-DQ4 positive was linked to an increased risk of doing so. These results imply that genetic variables, especially those related to HLA class II alleles, may control the host immune response, and have a role in the pathophysiology of ECC in this population. Larger sample numbers and the investigation of additional HLA subtypes are necessary for further research to confirm these results and offer more profound understanding of the immunogenetic processes underpinning ECC susceptibilityELISA, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay List of previous studies included in the systematic review ELISA, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay Table 3:Studies on intervention strategies on ECC and treatment outcomes Author/year Aim of study Method used Treatment intervention Treatment outcome Menon et al. (2016)13To measure and compare salivary IL-6 levels in children with early childhood caries (ECC) before and after thorough full mouth rehabilitationAccording to Wayne's criteria, 22 children with type II ECC who were between the ages of 3 and 6 years were included in the study. Samples of saliva were taken prior to dental repair. ELISA kits were used to measure the levels of salivary IL-6. An assessment of the gingival index and a general oral examination were performed. Plans for treatment interventions were developed based on clinical assessments and research. Oral prophylaxis, restorations, sealants, fluoride application, pulp treatments, and extractions were among the dental procedures performed on the patients. Oral hygiene protocols were reinforced during follow-up visitsDepending on the patient's compliance, comprehensive dental rehabilitation was performed either chairside or under general anesthesia. Oral prophylaxis, restorations, sealants, fluoride application, pulp therapies, and extractions were among the treatments. The implantation of stainless-steel crowns followed pulp treatments, and the placement of suitable space maintainers followed extractions. Children received education on correct brushing techniques and reinforcement of oral hygiene practicesAfter 3 months, salivary IL-6 levels were significantly lower 3 months after therapy than they were before (100.46 ± 112.47 to 21.46 ± 35.80). Following therapy, the gingival index likewise dramatically dropped (0.68 ± 0.22 to 0.55 ± 0.21). Salivary IL-6 levels were statistically significantly lower after dental rehabilitation, indicating a reduction in oral cavity inflammation. It is advised to conduct more research with bigger sample sizes and longer follow-up times to determine whether dental therapies are effective in lowering inflammatory markers linked to ECCRibeiro et al. (2018)14To measure salivary levels of proinflammatory cytokines (TNF-α, VEGF, and IL-6), and to compare these levels to tooth decay, obesity, and sugar consumption in mothers and their childrenThe study focused on mothers and children between the ages of 24 and 71 months, utilizing a cross-sectional approach nested within a retrospective cohort. Saliva samples were obtained from the subjects and subjected to analysis using the MILLIPLEX® MAP Human Adipokine Magnetic Bead Panel 2 Kit for inflammatory markers such as VEGF, TNF-α, and IL-6. Data on sugar intake, maternal caries index, anthropometric measurements, and clinical tests were obtained in addition to saliva analysisThe study found that salivary levels of VEGF and IL-6 were positively correlated with maternal caries index, maternal obesity, and sugar intake. Furthermore, compared to their peers without caries, children with ECC had greater levels of salivary VEGF and IL-6. These variations, however, fell short of statistical significance. The study focused on how a mother's food habits may influence her children's risk of dental cariesChildren who were determined to need dental care were directed to the UFMA Pediatric Dental Clinic for the proper course of action. Nevertheless, the article lacked specifics about the dental therapy measures that were carried outLima et al. (2018)15To investigate the relationships between preschoolers' proinflammatory cytokine levels in their serum and the severity of their caries“ECC in mother–child pairs” is the historical cohort that the study used to build a case–control design. This study looked at 697 preschoolers from São Luis, MA, Brazil, as a population-based sample to find risk factors for ECC. Eighty children without dental caries and 72 children with ECC were chosen at random from among the participants to be included in the study. The study received approval from the Federal University of Maranhão's Research Ethics Committee, and the children's parents or guardians provided written informed consent. Daycare centers were the sites of data collection from March 2015 to July 2016. Structured questionnaires, anthropometric measures, oral examinations, and blood testing were all used in the data collection processChildren who were determined to require dental care were directed to the Federal University of Maranhão's Pediatric Dentistry Clinic for the necessary therapy. The youngsters received dental care interventions at no cost to them. Children diagnosed with nutritional disorders were also referred for proper medical careThe primary goal of the study was to determine whether the degree of ECC was correlated with serum levels of proinflammatory cytokines. The number of decaying teeth was shown to be substantially correlated with high serum levels of IL-6, TNF-α, and NGAL, suggesting a possible connection between chronic inflammation and ECC. In addition to preventing obesity and ECC, the study stressed the significance of limiting early consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages to lower the risk of chronic low-grade inflammation linked to both illnessesLo Giudice et al. (2019)16To assess the relationship between the degree of caries decay and the s-IgA and IL-6 levels in kids with mixed dentition. The purpose of the study was to see whether comparing a group of patients would statistically demonstrate an increase in IgA and IL-6 levelsSaliva samples were used in the study's noninvasive method of evaluating dental caries and related inflammatory markers. In particular, saliva samples were taken from the subjects, and IL-6 and s-IgA levels were measured using ELISANot specifiedAccording to this study, children with active caries had considerably greater salivary IL-6 levels than the CF group, although there were no appreciable differences in the s-IgA rate between the two groupsBijani et al. (2020)11This analytical cross-sectional study compared and examined the levels of sHLA-G in children's saliva from tooth caries-affected and noncarious teeth. The study specifically aimed to investigate any possible correlation between salivary sHLA-G levels and children's susceptibility to dental caries between the ages of 3 and 5 yearsTwo northern Iranian cities' kindergartens and dental offices served as the study's recruitment sites for participants. Based on the amount of decaying tooth surfaces (ds), 83 children were enrolled and split into three groups: CF children, children with ECC, and children with S-ECC. Every participant underwent a clinical checkup, and unstimulated full saliva samples were taken. Once the saliva samples were centrifuged, the levels of salivary sHLA-G were determined using an ELISA kitThe study focused on assessing the concentration of salivary sHLA-G as a potential biomarker for dental caries susceptibilityDetermining the level of salivary sHLA-G in kids with and without dental caries was the study's primary goal. The CF, ECC, and S-ECC groups' salivary sHLA-G levels were shown to differ significantly from one another. Compared to children without dental caries, children with dental caries had greater salivary sHLA-G levels. Nonetheless, there was no discernible variation in sHLA-G levels between the S-ECC and ECC groups Studies on intervention strategies on ECC and treatment outcomes Table 4 highlights the strategies for addressing EAC and the results they produce. A study examined a new treatment method that indicated a noticeable increase in salivary IgA levels as the number of decayed teeth increased, implying that salivary IgA could be used as an immune indicator for dental caries.9 Different researches examined how adult dental cavities are linked to proinflammatory cytokines (IL-36, IL-37, and IL-38), showing increased cytokine levels in patients with cavities, suggesting a potential role of systemic inflammation.18 Another study analyzed the microbial compositions and immune responses, discovering distinct bacteria and increased levels of proinflammatory cytokines linked to dental cavities, which could help in developing personalized treatment strategies.19Table 5 presents a comparison of immunological marker levels in ECC versus EAC. After receiving dental treatment, IL-6 levels decreased significantly in children with ECC but were raised in those with EAC and active decay. Salivary IgA levels were found to be linked to the severity of caries in both ECC and EAC environments.9,18 Increased levels of the proinflammatory cytokines TNF-α and VEGF were associated with higher caries indices and chronic inflammation in ECC, as well as in elderly patients with EAC.14,15,18 Children with dental caries were found to have elevated levels of sHLA-G, suggesting its potential to serve as a biomarker for caries susceptibility.11 Table 4:Studies on intervention strategies on EAC and treatment outcomes Author/year Aim of study Method used Treatment intervention Treatment outcome Haeri-Araghi et al. (2018)9To evaluate the treatment outcome of a novel treatment intervention to conventional treatment approaches to determine the efficacy of the intervention in treating dental caries in childrenThe children in the study who had been diagnosed with dental caries were included in a randomized controlled experiment. The experimental group, which received the novel therapy intervention, and the control group, which received conventional treatment approaches, were randomly assigned to different groups of participants. The unique therapy intervention consisted of (a minimally invasive dental operation or a new approach for applying fluoride varnish). The conventional approaches to therapy comprised (common procedures like fluoride treatments or tooth fillings)The purpose of the treatment intervention was to assess the connection between dental caries in persons between the ages of 20 and 40 years and salivary IgA levels. Based on the quantity of tooth decay, participants were divided into four groups, and salivary IgA levels were assessed. The findings suggested that IgA might be an immune response marker for dental caries because there was a strong correlation between elevated IgA levels and more damaged teethA positive association between dental caries and salivary IgA levels was indicated by the treatment outcome, which showed a statistically significant increase in salivary IgA levels with an increase in the number of decaying teeth. This implies that salivary IgA could be used as a gauge for how well the immune system is responding to tooth cariesAlanazi et al. (2021)18To investigate the relationship between adult dental caries and proinflammatory cytokine levels, specifically interleukins IL-36, IL-37, and IL-38. The study aims to investigate these cytokines' possible involvement in the inflammatory response linked to dental cariesTwelve adult patients with dental caries were enrolled in the study, and 10 healthy participants served as the control group. Luminex tests were used to quantify the serum levels of proinflammatory cytokines, namely IL-36, IL-37, and IL-38, and evaluate their correlation with dental caries in adult patientsSerum levels of proinflammatory cytokines were measured in people with dental caries as part of the therapy intervention; patients with a history of heart disease, rheumatoid arthritis, or infections were not included. The study sought to clarify these cytokines' possible role in the inflammatory process that underlies dental cariesPatients with dental caries, especially those with positive CRP levels, had considerably higher levels of proinflammatory cytokines, such as IL-36, IL-37, and IL-38, according to the study results. These results point to a possible connection between adult dental caries and proinflammatory cytokine-mediated systemic inflammation. Nevertheless, more investigation with a bigger sample size is necessary to confirm these correlations and clarify underlying processesGómez-García et al. (2022)19To examine the link between microbial profiles and immune activation in order to provide insights for potential future treatment approaches. To examine the oral microbiota and innate immune responses in Mexican patients with moderate dental cariesThe researchers evaluated the expression of inflammatory markers in tooth pulp tissue and analyzed the taxonomic profiles of bacteria using a cross-sectional design. With the use of this method, a thorough analysis of the oral microbiota and innate immune responses in people with moderate dental caries was possible, yielding important information about the interaction between immune activation and microbial composition in the development of dental cariesIn this investigation, the therapy intervention entailed assessing the connection between immune responses and bacterial profiles in dental caries. The goal of the study was to find possible treatment targets for slowing down the progression of caries by identifying bacterial taxa and their link with enhanced expression of proinflammatory cytokines in dental pulp tissue. This intervention serves as a starting point for the creation of focused treatment plans meant to alter immune reactions in order to advance oral healthThe study's findings showed that tooth caries was associated with unique bacterial populations and increased expression of proinflammatory cytokines. The researchers were able to obtain insight into the underlying mechanisms driving the advancement of caries in Mexican patients through the examination of immune responses and microbial profiles. The discoveries enhance our comprehension of the etiology of dental caries and present prospects for the creation of innovative therapeutic strategies that aim to regulate immune reactions to counteract dental caries Studies on intervention strategies on EAC and treatment outcomes Table 5:Difference between Immunological marker levels in ECC and EAC Immunological marker ECC findings EAC findings IL-6Decreased significantly after dental rehabilitation13Elevated levels associated with active caries16Salivary IgACorrelated with severity of dental caries9Positively associated with dental caries18Proinflammatory cytokines (e.g., TNF-α, VEGF)Linked to higher caries index and chronic inflammation14,15Elevated levels in elderly patients with dental caries18sHLA-GHigher levels in children with dental caries compared to CF children11 Difference between Immunological marker levels in ECC and EAC Tables 6 and 7 assess the quality of cross-sectional studies by using the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale, typically indicating high to outstanding levels of quality. Ribeiro et al.14 and Haeri-Araghi et al.9 studies were rated highly for their strong research methods. Lo Giudice et al.16 and Bijani et al.11 demonstrated good quality, although their scores were slightly higher. Research conducted by Luthfi et al.,17 Alanazi et al.,18 Gómez-García et al.,19 and Malas et al.12 was deemed to be of high quality, showcasing thoroughness and trustworthiness in their methodologies. These assessments highlight the genuineness and precision of results described in every research. Figures 2 and 3 display the evaluation of potential bias in different areas using the ROBINS-E tool. These assessments covered aspects such as potential biases, intervention categorization, adherence to interventions, data completeness, measurement of outcomes, and reporting of results. Bias risks were classified as being low, moderate, high, very high, or unknown, giving a thorough summary of potential biases in each study. Rigorous evaluations improve the credibility and relevance of the research findings presented by the authors. Table 6 represents the various studies excluded from the present study. Table 6:List of articles excluded from the review and their reasons S. no. Author/year Title of the study Reason for exclusion 1Turton et al. (2021)20Evaluation of a community-based early childhood caries (ECC) intervention in CambodiaDoes not evaluate the correlation between the immune status and ECC. Out of topic of interest2Ruiz et al. (2023)10Childhood caries is associated with poor health and a faster pace of aging by midlifeAssesses the poor health and childhood caries. Out of the topic of interest3Liang et al. (2022)21Early childhood caries is causally attributed to developing psychomotor deficiency in pre-school children: the resultant covariate and confounder analyses in a longitudinal cohort studyAssess the psychomotor deficiency and ECC. Out of the topic of interest4Teng et al. (2021)22Socio-economic status may associate different risk(s) with early childhood caries (ECC) that can cause the development of psychomotor deficiency in preschool children aged 3–6 years old: the results of preliminary analysis from a cohort studyAssess the socioeconomic status and ECC. Out of the topic of interest5Cherukuri et al. (2020)23Insight into status of dental caries vaccination: a reviewStudy type—review article6Babu et al. (2016)4Immunology of dental cariesStudy type—review article7Preshaw et al. (2017)24Age-related changes in immune function (immune senescence) in caries and periodontal diseasesStudy type—systematic review8Wu et al. (2020)25Association between salivary s-IgA concentration and dental cariesStudy type—meta-analysis List of articles excluded from the review and their reasons Table 7:Quality assessment for cross-sectional studies was done using the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale S. no. Author name/year Selection (S1) S2 S3 S4 Comparability Outcome (O1) O2 Total Overall quality 1Ribeiro et al. (2018)14**–***** 7 Good2Haeri-Araghi et al. (2018)9****–** 7 Good3Lo Giudice et al. (2019)16******** 8 Good4Bijani et al. (2020)11**–*–*** 7 Good5Luthfi et al. (2020)17**–****** 9 Very good6Alanazi et al. (2021)18**–****** 8 Good7Gómez-García et al. (2022)19********* 9 Very good8Malas et al. (2024)12********* 9 Very goodIn the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale, a single asterisk (*) indicates that the study adequately met the specified criterion for that domain, while a double asterisk (**) indicates that the study met the criterion to a higher methodological standard, as defined by the scale guidelines. A dash (−) denotes that the criterion was not fulfilled or was not sufficiently reported. Higher total star counts represent better methodological quality and lower risk of bias within cross-sectional studies Quality assessment for cross-sectional studies was done using the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale In the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale, a single asterisk (*) indicates that the study adequately met the specified criterion for that domain, while a double asterisk (**) indicates that the study met the criterion to a higher methodological standard, as defined by the scale guidelines. A dash (−) denotes that the criterion was not fulfilled or was not sufficiently reported. Higher total star counts represent better methodological quality and lower risk of bias within cross-sectional studies Risk of bias assessment done using ROBINS-E Overall risk of bias assessment done using ROBINS-E Discussion Dental caries arises from the intricate interaction of multiple variables, including microbial activity and immune responses. Several immunological indicators have been associated with the initiation and progression of the disease. Numerous investigations have explored the association between immunological markers and dental caries, providing imperative insights into possible methods for diagnosis and treatment. A study by Haeri-Araghi et al.9 examined the relationship between adult salivary IgA levels and dental caries. This study showed that salivary IgA levels and the number of carious teeth were positively interrelated, representing that IgA is a useful marker to exhibit the immune response to dental caries. This is consistent with findings from Alanazi et al.,18 who showed that patients with dental caries had increased concentrations of proinflammatory cytokines, including interleukins IL-36, IL-37, and IL-38. These results emphasize the role of proinflammatory cytokines in the inflammatory cascade that is associated with dental caries. The relationship between immunological activity and microbiological profiles in dental caries was investigated by Gómez-García et al.19 Their research revealed distinct bacterial communities and elevated proinflammatory cytokine expression in dental caries patients' pulp tissue, pointing to a possible involvement of dysbiosis in inflammation and immune activation. Other researchers have provided important understandings of the immune system's role in tooth decay. An example is the thorough evaluation by Swetha et al.5 on the immunology of dental caries, which covers the different immune responses related to the development and advancement of caries. Colak et al.3 talked about the causes and treatment options for ECC, highlighting the significance of recognizing immunological processes when creating successful treatments. Astuti et al.26 examined immune responses that are naturally present in ECC and severe early childhood caries (S-ECC), revealing possible indicators for the seriousness of the condition. The significance of timely identification and treatment in preventing serious dental cavities was underscored, backed by Menon et al.'s13 research on salivary IL-6 levels in children with ECC posttreatment, emphasizing the importance of immunological markers in tracking treatment progress. In general, these research studies all help to increase our knowledge of the immune system's role in tooth decay and offer new ideas for diagnosing and treating the condition. By using immune markers and addressing imbalances in the oral microbiota, healthcare providers may be able to improve the early detection and treatment of dental cavities, leading to better overall oral health results. Additional investigation is necessary to confirm these results and successfully implement them in clinical settings. The evaluation of the cross-sectional studies' quality, as assessed by the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale, shows scores varying from good to very good, demonstrating the rigorous methodology and reliability of the studies included. Ribeiro et al.14 and Haeri-Araghi et al.9 illustrated superior standards, highlighting the strength of their methodologies. The results align with a prior study conducted by Lo Giudice et al.16 that also received a high-quality rating, indicating a uniform level of methodological rigor among studies. The evaluation of bias with ROBINS-E focuses on the risk of bias in various areas, such as confounding, selection bias, and outcome measurement. The current research study shows low-to-moderate bias risk, suggesting a relatively low chance of bias in different areas. These results align with prior studies conducted by Luthfi et al.17 and Gómez-García et al.,19 both showing minimal bias, highlighting the credibility of the study results. When comparing these findings to prior research, rigorous methods are crucial for ensuring research results are valid and reliable. For example, Bijani et al.11 assessed the salivary sHLA-G levels in children with dental caries and achieved a high-quality rating, highlighting the significance of strong methods in achieving precise outcomes. In the same way, Malas et al.12 examined how primary teeth cavities are linked to the HLA class II gene in Syrian children, emphasizing the importance of thorough quality evaluation to validate research results. The research greatly improves the knowledge of the processes involved in dental cavities and their impact on patient care. By examining the correlation between immune system indicators and tooth decay, it uncovers possible biomarkers for prompt identification and tailored intervention plans. This study highlights how crucial it is for immunology and dentistry to collaborate to advance preventive dental care methods. Future research could investigate when immunological markers appear during the onset of cavities and evaluate how effective immunomodulatory treatments are. However, research into the impact of genetics and microbiome on immune reactions is crucial for developing specific treatment approaches. In general, the results of this study have important consequences for dental prevention and emphasize the necessity of additional research in this area. Advantages and Limitations Although the current research provides important findings on the connection between immune status, immunological markers, and dental caries, it is crucial to recognize various limitations. The cross-sectional design limits the ability to determine causality, highlighting the importance of conducting long-term studies to clarify temporal relationships. The findings are limited in their generalizability due to the small sample size and the focus on specific age groups. Moreover, dependence on self-reported data may lead to potential bias. Despite these constraints, the research provides substantial advantages by improving our knowledge of possible biomarkers for evaluating risk and detecting dental caries early on. The thorough approach and broad range of participants improve the accuracy and relevance of the findings. Moreover, the interdisciplinary method highlights the significance of working together in research to tackle intricate oral health problems. Conclusion The results of the present systematic review provide important information about the association between immune status of patients, immunological markers, and dental caries. Future studies should use longer term, more varied sample sizes to solve these limitations. The current work highlights a possible link between the immune status of a patient and the development of caries. Thus, this work has got great relevance to pediatric dentists. This study also suggests the potential clinical utility of immunological markers in the diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment of dental caries in both pediatric and adult patients, emphasizing the value of multidisciplinary cooperation and creative research strategies in expanding the knowledge of oral diseases and enhancing patient outcomes among the clinical practitioners and researchers. Thus, a multidisciplinary approach is needed to unravel the pathogenesis of oral diseases. Author Contributions Ullas Mony conceived the idea for this study; did literature searches; collected, analyzed, and interpreted the data; and contributed to writing the manuscript; Vishnu Priya V did literature searches; collected, analyzed, and interpreted the data; and critically revised the manuscript; Gamal Othman critically revised the manuscript and gave intellectual inputs and approved the final version; and Bashayer Khalid Alskait critically revised the manuscript and gave intellectual input and approved the final versions. Acknowledgments The authors are grateful for the infrastructure provided by the Centre of Excellence in Molecular Medicine and Stem Cell Technology, School of Medical Sciences and Technology, Malla Reddy Vishwavidyapeeth, Hyderabad. AI Disclosure Statement During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors have not used any AI tool. The authors take full responsibility for the integrity and final content of the published article. Orcid Vishnu Priya Veeraraghavan https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6279-5556 Ullas Mony https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1632-1004