Management strategies for loosened knots during cardiac surgery Authors: Tingting Tao, Firyuza Husanova, Xiaofan Chen, Junnan Zheng, Yiming Ni Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundSuturing and knot-tying during cardiac surgery remain challenging. Unexpectedly loosened knots are particularly stressful and can lead to poor outcomes if not properly handled.Methods and resultsHerein, we describe four simple yet practical techniques to address unexpectedly loosened knots or paravalvular leaks caused by them during cardiac surgery.ConclusionsThese techniques offer cardiac surgeons alternatives for managing unexpectedly loosened knots and their associated complications. By avoiding reintervention, we believe these techniques are highly beneficial in intraoperative emergencies.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13019-026-04100-1.Keywords: Surgical Knots, Cardiac Surgery, Suture Techniques, Knot loosening, Manually tied knots Background Knots can occasionally loosen unexpectedly, particularly when suturing at awkward angles and when visibility or depth perception is limited [1], especially during cardiac valve replacement surgery. A loosened knot can be a potential obstacle and may require reintervention, which adds additional time and leads to severe consequences such as pledgets falling into the cardiac cavity, increasing the risk of cerebrovascular accidents [1–2]. Knotting on the annulus remains a major challenge that may result in complications such as paravalvular leaks (PVLs) [3–4]. However, reviews and reports on immediate and effective strategies for managing a loosened knot during cardiac surgery are scarce. Therefore, we describe a series of techniques for addressing this issue in emergency situations. Techniques This study was reviewed and approved by the Research Ethics Committees of the First Affiliated Hospital of Zhejiang University School of Medicine, under the Reference Number IIT20240740A. The need for individual informed consent was waived by the ethics committee due to the study’s retrospective nature. All the procedures were performed under principles of the local law and the Declaration of Helsinki. The following four practical and convenient surgical techniques can be performed when a loosened knot on the annulus is encountered during cardiac surgery. Line drawings are presented to provide details regarding the key steps of these techniques. The titanium clip method Typically, approximately 5–6 knots are tied on the sewing ring. If a knot loosens, particularly the first or second knot (Fig. 1A), then the stitches should be continuously wound several times using a wire hook, followed by the application of one or two medium-sized of titanium clips either on the knot below or on the bottom, to secure the loosened knot and fix it in place (Fig. 1B). We have performed this method, which we refer to as the titanium clip method, during surgery (Fig. 1C). An insightful and vivid visualization of this technique is provided in Additional file 1. (A) the blue box shows the loosened knot, particularly the first or second knot. (B) The line drawing demonstrates after continuously wound several times using a wire hook, clipping a medium-sized of titanium clip and securing the loosened knot in place. (C) The blue arrow indicates that the loosened knot intertwined with the wire hook PVL repair technique A loosened knot often leads to stitch-wide leakage, which can be addressed using techniques for repairing PVLs. Our team has summarized a series of techniques for managing various sizes of PVLs, including the supravalvular repair method (Fig. 2A), folding-type sealing method (Fig. 2B), complex supravalvular and subvalvular repair method (Fig. 2C), and pericardium patch repair method (Fig. 2D). These techniques have been published in the Journal of Cardiac Surgery [5–6]. Surgeons can select the most appropriate technique based on the PVL diameter and specific clinical situations. (A-D) The line drawings show four techniques for managing various sizes PVLs Direct suturing of the polyester fabric of the sewing ring If a knot cannot be tightened during surgery, especially during minimally invasive surgery, then surgeons can use an additional stitch to suture directly onto the polyester fabric of the sewing ring (Fig. 3A). Ensure that the stitch is made through the polyester fabric rather than attempting to tie another knot adjacent to the loosened knot. (A) The line drawing shows using an additional stitch to suture directly onto the polyester fabric of the sewing ring. (B) The line drawing shows skipping one knot from the loosened knot and suturing with another stitch Skipping and suturing with another stitch If a knot cannot be tightened during surgery, specifically the first knot, then surgeons can place an additional stitch while skipping one or two knots from the loosened knot (Fig. 3B). Suturing the loosened knot directly with the subsequent knot will pull the loosened knot further and fail to tighten it; therefore, one or two knots should be skipped before suturing to allow tightening. Discussion Loosened knots are highly undesirable events for surgeons. Nowadays, self-tying devices are commonly used, which bring great convenience to operation [7]. However, cardiac surgeries, such as valve replacement surgeries, often involve awkward angles and require many knots. Therefore, loosened knots are inevitable whether manual tying or using knot instruments, especially some complex procedures. Such incidents necessitate additional operative time for reintervention, considerably prolonging the intraoperative cardiopulmonary bypass time, thereby increasing the risk of complications. Moreover, undetected or inadequately addressed loosened knots can most commonly lead to PVLs and affect long-term postoperative outcomes [8]. Thus, we comprehensively propose these techniques as emergency solutions to prevent more serious consequences. Originally, we summarized these simple yet practical techniques for surgeons to manage the unexpectedly loosened knots in emergencies. However, we must acknowledge that the potential risk of clip displacement does exist. Thus, we treat these techniques as emergency management. And the device is not designed for tightening a knot indeed, if surgeons adhere to the principle can only abandon this method. In addition, several other issues remain to be discussed. These emergency techniques are based on our clinical experience, currently lacking the evidence regarding methodological rigor and safety validation, nevertheless they have been applied in clinical practice and achieved satisfactory results. We suggest that surgeons select the most suitable alternative techniques based on the specific intraoperative conditions. These techniques can be used during both general open-heart and minimally invasive surgeries, and we believe they can save considerable time and reduce unnecessary complications. Conclusion These techniques offer cardiac surgeons some simple yet practical alternatives for managing unexpectedly loosened knots and their associated complications. By avoiding reintervention, we believe these techniques are highly beneficial in intraoperative emergencies. Supplementary Information Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material. Supplementary Material 1: Video 1 The video shows the process of the titanium-clips method. Acknowledgements not applicable. Author contributions All authors contributed to the study conception and design. Material preparation and the first drafting were performed by Tingting Tao. Data collection was performed by Firyuza Husanova. Analysis and draft revision were performed by Xiaofan Chen and Junnan Zheng. Yiming Ni provided the idea of this technique. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Funding This work is supported by the Science Technology Department of Zhejiang Province (Grant No. 2024C03026 and No. 2023C03087). Data availability All data and materials of this article are available online. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate The need for individual informed consent was waived by the ethics committee due to the study’s retrospective nature. All the procedures were performed under principles of the local law and the Declaration of Helsinki. Consent for publication All authors have consent for publication. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Tingting Tao and Firyuza Husanova contributed equally. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1: Video 1 The video shows the process of the titanium-clips method. Data Availability Statement All data and materials of this article are available online.