The effects of heat stress on milk yield and composition in dairy cattle: meta-analysis study Authors: Özgür Özcan, Serdal Dikmen Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractGlobal climate change has positioned thermal stress as a critical challenge in dairy production. Heat stress is widely documented to involve alterations in both productive traits, and physio-pathological indicators. This meta-analysis was conducted to provide a quantitative synthesis of the observed variations in milk production parameters during thermal stress.Following PRISMA protocols and the PICOS framework, a systematic dataset was compiled from 35 independent studies published between 2010 and 2023. To address the inherent high heterogeneity (I² ≥ 90%) among studies, the Inverse Variance Heterogeneity (IVhet) model was employed for statistical pooling. Effect sizes were interpreted using Cohen’s d, and potential sources of variance were explored through THI (Temperature-Humidity Index) based subgroup analyses and meta-regression.The pooled estimators indicate a significant negative association between heat stress and milk yield (d = -0.723). Noticeable reductions were also observed in milk composition parameters, specifically for milk fat (d = -0.633), milk protein (d = -0.555), and milk lactose (d = -0.404). Subgroup analysis indicated that these production declines become more pronounced when the THI exceeds a threshold of 72. However, due to substantial heterogeneity among studies, these pooled estimates should be interpreted as generalized global trends rather than precise universal thresholds.In conclusion, this meta-analysis confirms a consistent alignment between elevated thermal indices and qualitative as well as quantitative production losses. Rather than prescribing specific management interventions, these findings underscore the necessity for future research to account for cumulative exposure duration and localized farm microclimates to better predict production responses.Keywords: Heat stress, Dairy cattle, Milk yield, Milk composition, Meta-analysis Introduction Global climate change represents a multidimensional environmental challenge that directly threatens animal production through rising temperatures and extreme weather events (Morgado et al., 2022). Dairy cattle are particularly sensitive to environmental fluctuations due to their high metabolic energy output and the physiological pressures of lactation (Kadzere et al., 2002). Although cattle utilize radiation, conduction, and evaporation to maintain thermal equilibrium, these mechanisms often become constrained under combined high temperature and humidity, leading to a systemic physiological state defined as "heat stress" (West, 2003). In literature, heat stress is consistently associated with cumulative negative trends in milk yield, composition, and reproductive parameters (Baumgard & Rhoads, 2013). High-yielding breeds are especially vulnerable due to their elevated nutritional requirements and metabolic heat production (West, 2003). Research indicates that chronic heat exposure is linked to production losses through decreased dry matter intake, impaired rumen function, and negative energy balance (Rhoads et al., 2010). Furthermore, heat stress during the dry period has been shown to coincide with impaired mammary gland involution, potentially altering the production trajectory of the subsequent lactation (Dado-Senn et al., 2019). While technical mitigation strategies such as cooling systems and nutritional interventions are widely discussed, their generalizable trends across diverse experimental setups require rigorous quantitative synthesis. Crucially, the substantial variability in how heat stress is defined, operationalized, and quantified across primary studies—ranging from disparate temperature-humidity thresholds to non-standardized environmental exposure periods—severely limits the direct comparability and reproducibility of individual outcomes. In this context, meta-analysis serves as a critical methodological tool to reconcile these heterogeneous findings and establish a standardized denominator across independent studies conducted across various regions and setups. This study aims to quantitatively synthesize the observed effects of heat stress on milk yield and components using the Inverse Variance Heterogeneity (IVhet) model. By providing a comprehensive quantitative pooling under strict awareness of literature heterogeneity, this study seeks to establish a clearer, aggregated baseline of performance variations during thermal stress, rather than prescribing direct on-farm management interventions. Materials and methods This study is a meta-analysis that systematically reviews and synthesizes research published between 2010 and 2023 regarding the impact of heat stress on milk yield and composition in dairy cattle. To mitigate methodological inconsistencies and facilitate a centralized framework for analysis, heat stress exposure was categorized based on the Temperature-Humidity Index (THI). However, it must be acknowledged that the primary literature exhibits variation in how THI was calculated, recorded, and utilized (e.g., varying duration of exposure, differences in daily peak vs. average THI, and lack of consistent data regarding nocturnal recovery periods). Consequently, the THI-based classifications employed herein serve as standardized proxies to capture broad, approximate trends across diverse geographic locations and experimental setups, rather than strictly uniform environmental states. Studies utilizing THI as a primary environmental indicator, or providing sufficient raw climate data for its calculation, were prioritized to facilitate objective comparisons. Search Strategy: The bibliographic search targeted peer-reviewed publications released between 2010 and 2023. Searches were conducted across Web of Science, ScienceDirect, Scopus, and NIH (PubMed) databases, specifically within "Article Title," "Abstract," and "Keywords" fields. To ensure precision and focus on heat stress impacts, specific search string combinations were utilized: ("heat stress" AND "dairy cattle" AND "milk yield"), ("heat stress" AND "dairy cattle" AND "composition"), and ("heat stress" AND "dairy cattle" AND "meta-analysis"). These combinations yielded 2,046 raw publications (Web of Science: 1,025, ScienceDirect: 543, Scopus: 391, NIH: 87). Following the removal of 605 duplicate records, 1,441 unique publications were retained for further eligibility screening. Ultimately, the data for the meta-analysis were derived from 35 academic studies. The meta-analysis was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines to ensure transparent reporting of the evidence. Given the highly diverse nature of the source studies, substantial statistical heterogeneity was anticipated and factored into the downstream analytical approach. Inclusion Criteria: The systematic review process was structured according to the PICOS+T framework to ensure transparency and reproducibility (Table 1). Inclusion was strictly limited to studies involving high-yielding dairy breed (Holstein) in lactation, incorporating a clear thermoneutral control group (baseline), and reporting complete statistical parameters (n, Mean, SD/SE) required for meta-analytical synthesis. Table 1The inclusion and exclusion criteria for the systematic review were established according to the PICOS framework.Table 1 dummy alt textPICOS ElementInclusion CriteriaExclusion CriteriaP (Population)High-yielding dairy cattle breeds (Holstein) in lactation.Beef cattle, buffaloes, indigenous/local breeds, and heifers.I (Intervention)Exposure to natural or controlled heat stress conditions with reported milk yield and composition data.Studies lacking heat stress exposure or those without specific production performance data.C (Comparison)Those who have the data between heat stress periods (experimental) and thermoneutral periods (control).Studies comparing different interventions under heat stress without a baseline control group.O (Outcomes)Quantitative data on Milk Yield, Fat, Protein, and Lactose, along with THI (Temperature-Humidity Index).Studies missing environmental indices (THI, temperature, humidity) or key milk components.S (Study Type)Randomized controlled trials and peer-reviewed experimental studies.Case reports, reviews, editorials, and studies with insufficient statistical data (n, Mean, SD/SE).T (Time)Peer-reviewed articles published between 2010 and 2023.Studies published before 2010 or non-peer-reviewed grey literature. The inclusion and exclusion criteria for the systematic review were established according to the PICOS framework. The descriptive characteristics of the individual studies incorporated into the meta-analysis are summarized in Table 2, highlighting the diversity in holstein cattle, thermal stress indicators, and primary production outcomes. This inherent diversity across study designs, management systems, and microclimates underscores that the synthesized outputs represent generalized operational tendencies under heat stress conditions (Table 3). Table 2Descriptive characteristics and Temperature-Humidity Index (THI) thresholds of studies included in the meta-analysis.Table 2 dummy alt textNoStudyCattle BreedHeat Stress IndicatörTHI ThresholdObserved THI RangeMain Outcomes1T.M.Davison et al.2016HolsteinTHI>7278.8 - 84.7MY/F/P/L2G.Tresoldi et al.2019HolsteinTHI72≥68.0 - 72.0MY3R.B.Zimbelman et al.2010HolsteinTHI72≥68.0 - 72.0MY/F/L4Xu Zhang et al.2023HolsteinTHI>7277.0 - 84.0MY5Kyang Hoon Kim et al.2010HolsteinTHI72>65.8 - 72.8MY/F/P/L6D.Phlips et al.2017HolsteinTHI>7279.8 – 82.8MY7I.M.Toledo et al.2023HolsteinTHI>7254.4 – 78.2MY/P8X.A.Ortiz et al.2015HolsteinTHI>7276.1 – 76.3MY9S.Rungruans et al.2014HolsteinTHI>7255.0 – 76.0MY/P/L10L.W.Hall et al.2018HolsteinTHI>7265.0 – 75.0MY/F/P/L11Q.Shan et al.2020HolsteinTHI≥7272.0 – 73.2MY/F/P/L12Y.Hou et al.2021HolsteinTHI72>65.0 – 81.0MY/F/L13J.W.Steawart et al.2021HolsteinTHI>7265.1 – 72.5MY/F/P14S.T.Gao et al.2021HolsteinTHI>7279.5 – 79.5MY/F/L15R.Corona et al.2016HolsteinTHI>7274.0 – 81.4MY16T.F.Fabris et al.2017HolsteinTHI>7277.6 – 77.9MY/F/P17J.P.Wang et al.2010HolsteinTHI>7277.7 – 81.2MY/F/L18L.Pan et al.2014HolsteinTHI>7278.2 – 79.0MY19A.Borecka et al.2023(Sowula)HolsteinTHI72>57.5 – 77.7MY/F20H.Amamou et al.2019HolsteinTHI72>54.0 – 77.0MY21L.N.Grinter et al.2023HolsteinTHI72>59.4 – 71.9MY/F/P22Z.Ann et al.2022HolsteinTHI>7277.8 – 83.9MY23M.Wang et al.2023HolsteinTHI≥7272.0 – 77.8MY/L24D.R.Soffa et al.2023HolsteinTHI>7259.0 – 86.0MY25J.B.Garcia et al.2018HolsteinTHI72>68.0 – 75.0MY/P26Y.Wo et al.2023HolsteinTHI>7273.4 – 79.0MY27M.Bah et al.2021HolsteinTHI>7280.4 – 85.0MY/F/P/L28H.Honing et al.2012HolsteinTHI>7267.0 – 78.4MY/F/P/L29MT.Karimi et al.2015HolsteinTHI72>67.0 – 69.7MY/F/P30B.D.Davidson et al.2021HolsteinTHI≥7272.0 – 77.0MY/F/P31K.R.Kossube et al.2017HolsteinTHI>7266.5 – 76.0MY/P32I.Vujanac et al.2012HolsteinTHI72≤60.0 – 72.0MY33Su Di et al.2019 (Fan et al.)HolsteinTHI>7255.0 – 81.0MY/F/P/L34L.Roman et al.2019HolsteinTHI>7235.1 – 72.5MY/P/L35D.H.Lim et al.2020HolsteinTHI≤7270.1 – 72.0MY/L*Note: MY: Milk Yield F: Milk Fat Percentage L: Milk Lactose Percentage P: Milk Protein Percentage Descriptive characteristics and Temperature-Humidity Index (THI) thresholds of studies included in the meta-analysis. *Note: MY: Milk Yield F: Milk Fat Percentage L: Milk Lactose Percentage P: Milk Protein Percentage Table 3Summary of Studies Included in the Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Yield in Dairy Cattle.Table 3 dummy alt textNoStudy ReferenceExp (n)MeanSDCtrl (n)MeanSD1T.M. Davison et al., 20161323.501.876524.204.192G. Tresoldi et al., 20192436.705.40836.301.103R.B. Zimbelman et al., 20101229.601.311231.004.754Xu Zhang et al., 20231626.405.921632.505.925Kyang Hoon Kim et al., 2010324.302.18323.202.186D.Phillips et al., 20174011.261.964010.301.647Toledo et al., 20241941.901.601546.201.808X.A. Ortiz et al., 201510052.283.4010052.203.409S. Rungruans et al., 20141238.603.391242.403.3910L.W. Hall et al., 20181530.402.201536.202.5011Q. Shan et al., 2020622.501.32627.001.3212Y. Hou et al., 2021421.500.84417.800.8413Stewart et al., 20222341.501.602349.902.3014S.T. Gao et al., 20211024.200.951024.600.9515Corona and Clemente, 20161418.001.091421.601.1916T.F. Fabris et al., 20171735.906.681540.076.2717J.P. Wang et al., 20104826.402.084830.803.3018L. Pan et al., 20141031.601.304037.501.8019Sowula-Skrzyńska et al., 20231545.602.072646.852.5020H. Amamou et al., 2019806.501.70808.402.2021L.N. Grinter et al., 20231536.202.321538.005.4022An et al., 20223227.142.413226.002.6023M. Wang et al., 20231636.901.806440.141.4024D.R. Soffa et al., 20231257.752.281057.122.0925J.B. Garcia et al., 2018528.712.01523.062.0126Y. Wo et al., 20231223.102.601224.601.5027Bah et al., 20222111.001.512111.901.5128H. Honig et al., 20122136.604.222140.104.2229M.T. Karimi et al., 20151040.506.361044.606.3630B.D. Davidson et al., 20211431.905.241235.804.8531K.R. Kossube et al., 20171230.003.881232.603.8832I. Vujanac et al., 20122041.250.972043.821.2433Fan et al., 20191028.303.101038.604.7034D.H.Lim et al.2020930.140.42931.120.6935L.Roman et al.20193928.801.253930.041.25Note: *Exp: Experimental Group, *Ctrl: Control Group Summary of Studies Included in the Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Yield in Dairy Cattle. Note: *Exp: Experimental Group, *Ctrl: Control Group (Amamou et al., 2019; An et al., 2022; Bah et al., 2022; Beauregard-García et al., 2018; Corona & Clemente, 2016; Davidson et al., 2021; Davison et al., 2016; Fabris et al., 2017; Fan et al., 2019; Gao et al., 2021; Grinter et al., 2023; Hall et al., 2018; Honig et al., 2012; Hou et al., 2021; Karimi et al., 2015; Kassube et al., 2017; Kim et al., 2010; Lim et al., 2021; Ortiz et al., 2015; Pan et al., 2014; Phillips & Lallo, 2017; Roman et al., 2019; Rungruang et al., 2014; Shan et al., 2020; Soffa et al., 2023; Sowula-Skrzyńska et al., 2023; Stewart et al., 2022; Toledo et al., 2024; Tresoldi et al., 2019; Vujanac et al., 2012; Wang et al., 2010, 2023; Wo et al., 2023; Zhang et al., 2023; Zimbelman et al., 2010) Data Extraction; Publications containing data on Temperature-Humidity Index (THI), temperature, humidity, milk yield, and milk composition were categorized. Studies providing data under heat stress conditions were examined in detail. Data from cows housed under normal conditions were recorded as control group data, while those exposed to heat stress were recorded as experimental group data. Group-level descriptive statistics (mean ± SD) for milk yield and composition were entered into Microsoft Excel as part of the data synthesis process Data Analysis; Meta-analysis was performed using the Inverse Variance Heterogeneity (IVhet) model, which provides more robust estimators compared to traditional random-effects models under conditions of high statistical heterogeneity (Doi et al., 2015). The IVhet model was prioritized specifically because it maintains a conservative false-positive rate and adjusts the weights more realistically when I² exceeds 90%. Statistical procedures were implemented via MetaXL (version 5.3) and R (version 4.3.1) (Table 4). Table 4Summary of Studies Included in the Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Fat Percentage in Dairy Cattle.Table 4 dummy alt textNoStudy ReferenceExp (n)MeanSDCtrl (n)MeanSD1T.M. Davison et al., 2016133.630.29653.910.652R.B. Zimbelman et al., 2010123.770.31123.940.313Kyang Hoon Kim et al., 201033.760.7233.720.724L.W. Hall et al., 2018153.700.77154.300.775Q. Shan et al., 202063.270.2363.350.236Y. Hou et al., 202144.070.2444.010.247Stewart et al., 2022233.610.18234.200.198S.T. Gao et al., 2021104.080.18104.650.189T.F. Fabris et al., 2017173.590.12153.510.1110J.P. Wang et al., 2010483.370.13483.670.1311A. Borecka et al., 2023153.470.10263.610.7012L.N. Grinter et al., 2023153.890.27153.870.2713M. Bah et al., 2021214.000.45214.120.4514H. Honig et al., 2012213.350.41213.370.4115M.T. Karimi et al., 2015102.950.85103.100.8516B.D. Davidson et al., 2021143.690.37123.640.3417S.U. Di et al., 2019103.330.32103.480.35*Note: Exp: Experimental Group, Ctrl: Control Group Summary of Studies Included in the Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Fat Percentage in Dairy Cattle. *Note: Exp: Experimental Group, Ctrl: Control Group The analytical pipeline consisted of the following steps: 1.Selection of eligible studies and extraction of standard effect sizes (Cohen’s $d$) along with their corresponding variance data. Selection of eligible studies and extraction of standard effect sizes (Cohen’s $d$) along with their corresponding variance data. 2.Weighting of individual study outcomes based on the inverse variance mechanism defined by the IVhet estimator. Weighting of individual study outcomes based on the inverse variance mechanism defined by the IVhet estimator. 3.Assessment of statistical heterogeneity using Cochran’s Q test and the I² statistic. Assessment of statistical heterogeneity using Cochran’s Q test and the I² statistic. 4.Evaluation of potential publication and selection bias was performed through a multi-faceted approach. Quantitative symmetry was assessed via the Doi plot and its corresponding LFK (Luis Furuya-Kanamori) index, where values within |LFK| ≤ 1 indicated no asymmetry. To ensure methodological rigor under high heterogeneity, Egger’s linear regression test was additionally conducted, with significance set at p < 0.05. Discrepancies between the LFK index and Egger’s test results—particularly in parameters with severe inter-study variance like milk yield—were interpreted with academic caution, recognizing that traditional regression-based asymmetry tests can yield inflated false-positive rates under extreme mathematical heterogeneity (I² ≥ 90). Evaluation of potential publication and selection bias was performed through a multi-faceted approach. Quantitative symmetry was assessed via the Doi plot and its corresponding LFK (Luis Furuya-Kanamori) index, where values within |LFK| ≤ 1 indicated no asymmetry. To ensure methodological rigor under high heterogeneity, Egger’s linear regression test was additionally conducted, with significance set at p < 0.05. Discrepancies between the LFK index and Egger’s test results—particularly in parameters with severe inter-study variance like milk yield—were interpreted with academic caution, recognizing that traditional regression-based asymmetry tests can yield inflated false-positive rates under extreme mathematical heterogeneity (I² ≥ 90). Heterogeneity Management and Moderator Analyses: To systematically explore the potential biological and methodological sources of the anticipated high statistical heterogeneity (I²), meta-regression and subgroup analyses were performed. Key potential moderators—including standardized THI boundaries, regional climate classifications, and operational farm dynamics—were integrated into the exploratory models. For meta-regression, the proportion of variation accounted for by the covariates was reported as R², while the significance of the moderators was evaluated using the Omnibus test (Q_M). In subgroup analyses, thermal load intensity was treated as a categorical moderator (e.g., separating groups around the baseline threshold of (THI ≥72) to estimate stratified weighted mean variations associated with each defined thermal state. All meta-regression and subgroup models were implemented primarily using the metafor package in R, utilizing the Restricted Maximum Likelihood (REML) estimator. Given the observational and retrospective nature of the synthesized source studies, the outputs of these moderator analyses were treated strictly as exploratory indicators of statistical association rather than definitive evidence of direct causal mechanisms (Table 5). Table 5Summary of Studies Included in the Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Protein Percentage in Dairy Cattle.Table 5 dummy alt textNoStudy ReferenceExp (n)MeanSDCtrl (n)MeanSD1T.M. Davison et al., 2016132.990.10653.010.242Kyang Hoon Kim et al., 201033.050.1533.130.153Toledo et al., 2024192.900.22152.980.154S. Rungruans et al., 2014122.600.13122.700.135L.W. Hall et al., 2018152.800.10153.000.106Q. Shan et al., 202063.090.2663.290.267Stewart et al., 2022232.590.24232.690.248T.F. Fabris et al., 2017172.890.12152.850.119L.N. Grinter et al., 2023152.950.07152.940.0710L. Roman et al., 2019393.000.12393.090.1211J.B. Garcia et al., 201852.790.0952.850.0912M. Bah et al., 2021212.900.22213.000.2213H. Honig et al., 2012213.150.18213.650.1814M.T. Karimi et al., 2015103.090.32103.170.3215B.D. Davidson et al., 2021142.900.18122.880.1716K.R. Kossube et al., 2017122.910.20123.020.2017S.U. Di et al., 2019102.910.34103.250.21Note: Exp: *Experimental Group *Ctrl: Control Group Summary of Studies Included in the Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Protein Percentage in Dairy Cattle. Note: Exp: *Experimental Group *Ctrl: Control Group Results The pooled effect size and heterogeneity indicators related to the meta-analysis are presented in Table 6. Table 6Summary of Studies Included in the Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Lactose Percentage in Dairy Cattle.Table 6 dummy alt textNoStudy ReferenceExp (n)MeanSDCtrl (n)MeanSD1T.M. Davison et al., 2016134.870.11654.890.112R.B. Zimbelman et al., 2010124.690.10124.680.103Kyang Hoon Kim et al., 201034.780.1034.800.104S. Rungruans et al., 2014124.700.17124.800.175L.W. Hall et al., 2018154.800.10154.900.106Q. Shan et al., 202064.650.0764.780.077Y. Hou et al., 202144.780.1244.820.128S.T. Gao et al., 2021104.990.19105.000.199J.P. Wang et al., 2010484.810.17484.820.1710M. Wang et al., 2023165.030.36645.050.4811Lim et al., 202194.710.1094.850.1012L. Roman et al., 2019394.870.12394.920.1213M. Bah et al., 2021214.560.18214.800.1814H. Honig et al., 2012214.710.13214.760.1315S.U. Di et al., 2019104.880.13104.960.11Note: Exp: *Experimental Group *Ctrl: Control Group Summary of Studies Included in the Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Lactose Percentage in Dairy Cattle. Note: Exp: *Experimental Group *Ctrl: Control Group The pooled effect sizes estimating the statistical association between heat stress exposure and milk production parameters are summarized in Table 7. Across all analyzed traits, elevated thermal exposure was associated with statistically significant negative shifts (p < 0.001). The pooled effect size (d) for milk yield was documented at -0.723 (95% CI: -1.217 to -0.229). Among the milk composition parameters, the most pronounced quantitative reduction trend was observed in the milk fat percentage(d = -0.633, 95% CI: -1.192 to -0.073), followed closely by the milk protein percentage(d = -0.555, 95% CI: -0.930 to -0.180) and the milk lactose percentage(d = -0.404, 95% CI: -0.674 to -0.135). The structural observation that all 95% confidence intervals remained entirely below the zero baseline suggests a consistent operational decline in performance during elevated thermal periods across the reviewed literature. While the initial baseline model for milk fat remained marked by substantial statistical heterogeneity (I² = 90.55 %), the pooled estimators for milk protein (I²= 70.92 %) and milk lactose (I² = 44.36 %) exhibited noticeably lower variance under the IVhet framework, indicating a more stable integration of these components. Part of this environmental variance was explored through THI-based categorical moderator analyses, which suggest that variations in thermal intensity account for a key portion of the observed inter-study divergence. Under the explicit subgroup arrangements (detailed further in Table 8), partitioning data around the core baseline threshold of THI ≥ 72 indicated that elevated thermal loads coincide with intensified production variations. However, given the persistent heterogeneity remaining in the milk yield and fat models, these pooled estimators should be interpreted with caution as general global trend indicators rather than precise biological point estimates. The remaining residual variance across the source studies is likely attributable to non-standardized farm-level characteristics, such as dietary fiber composition, individual cow parity, or specific cooling infrastructure variations that were not systematically reported in the primary literature. Table 7Meta-Analysis Findings on the Effects of Heat Stress on Milk Yield and Composition.Table 7 dummy alt textPooled Effect Size (d)LLCIULCII²Cochran's QChi² pMilk Yield-0.723-1.217-0.22989.165313.8090.001Milk Fat Ratio-0.633-1.192-0.07390.546117.0800.001Milk Protein Ratio-0.555-0.930-0.18070.91755.0140.001Milk Lactose Ratio-0.404-0.674-0.13544.36325.1630.001Note *LLCI: Lower Limit Confidence İnterval *ULCI: Upper Limit Confidence İnterval Meta-Analysis Findings on the Effects of Heat Stress on Milk Yield and Composition. Note *LLCI: Lower Limit Confidence İnterval *ULCI: Upper Limit Confidence İnterval Table 8Model Diagnostics and Heterogenity.Table 8: dummy alt textParameterModel TypeSlope / Pooled Effect (d)95% Confidence IntervalQM​ (p-value) (R)R2 (%) (R)Overall I² (%)(MetaXL IVhet)Milk YieldLinear (Continuous)-0.0969 (Slope)[-0.179, -0.084]37.1328 (<0.0001***)39.95%89.17%Milk FatLinear (Continuous)-0.0630 (Slope)[-0.140, 0.250]4.3941 (0.0487*)10.02%90.55%Milk ProteinCategorical (Subgroup)Heat Stress: -0.5593 No Stress: 0.4687[-0.930, -0.180]7.7341 (0.0209*)-70.92%LactoseCategorical (Subgroup)Heat Stress: -0.5518 No Stres: 0.2227[-0.674, -0.135]5.2504 (0.0724†)-44.36%Note: *** p < 0.001, * p < 0.05, ^† p < 0.10 (Trend level). 95% CI values and Overall I² percentages are derived directly from the baseline MetaXL (IVhet) analysis. Model Diagnostics and Heterogenity. Note: *** p < 0.001, * p < 0.05, ^† p < 0.10 (Trend level). 95% CI values and Overall I² percentages are derived directly from the baseline MetaXL (IVhet) analysis. The initial high statistical heterogeneity observed in the baseline models was systematically explored using categorical moderator frameworks. The exploratory findings suggest that variations in environmental stress intensity, represented via stratified THI parameters, account for a notable portion of the inter-study variance. In the lactose synthesis framework, the alignment of studies under the IVhet model demonstrated a naturally moderate heterogeneity (I² = 44.36 %), indicating that partitioning outcomes around the baseline of THI ≥ 72 helps reflect a more consistent trend across diverse literature. Residual variance that remains unaccounted for is likely attributable to complex farm-level variables not systematically reported in the primary replication studies, such as exact dietary fiber composition, localized microclimatic variations, or structural housing types.The majority of the independent study outcomes incorporated into the forest plot (Fig. 1) exhibit a negative association between elevated thermal indices and milk yield, as evidenced by the clear clustering of individual effect size markers toward the left side of the zero axis. While several primary studies display wider confidence intervals that cross the vertical line of no effect—suggesting limited statistical power within those specific experimental setups—the overall aggregated trend across the database remains directionally consistent. At the bottom of the plot, the diamond symbol represents the overall pooled effect size derived from the IVhet framework, estimated at -0.723 (95% CI: -1.217 to -0.229). The structural observation that the entire width of the pooled diamond, including its outermost boundaries, remains strictly positioned below the zero baseline confirms a statistically significant global trend of performance decline associated with thermal stress, though the absolute magnitude should be interpreted with caution due to the persistent heterogeneity in the overall yield dataset. Forest Plot of Studies Showing the Effects of Heat Stress on Milk Yield. At the bottom of the forest plot (Fig. 1), the diamond symbol represents the overall pooled effect size across all included studies derived from the IVhet framework, estimated at -0.723 (95% CI: -1.217 to -0.229). The structural fact that the entire width of the pooled diamond, including its outermost boundaries, remains strictly positioned below the zero baseline confirms a statistically significant and directionally consistent global trend of performance decline associated with elevated thermal conditions across the literature. However, given the persistent statistical heterogeneity (I² = 89.17 %) observed in the overall milk yield dataset, this pooled estimator should be interpreted with academic caution as an exploratory indicator of broad operational association rather than a definitive, uniform biological point estimate. Fig. 2 presents a forest plot depicting the statistical association between elevated thermal indices and milk fat percentage. The predominance of individual study markers shifted toward the negative side of the axis supports the observation that periods of heat stress consistently coincide with a downward trend in milk fat content. The overall pooled effect size (d = -0.633) reflects the quantitative variations observed in milk composition under challenging microclimatic conditions. Although wide confidence intervals in certain primary studies reflect expected variations in sample sizes or environmental measurement precision, the weighted estimates generated via the Inverse Variance Heterogeneity (IVhet) framework provide a structured representation of the overall negative shift. At the bottom of the plot, the diamond symbol represents the overall pooled effect size across all included studies. The estimated pooled value is -0.633 (95% CI: -1.192 to -0.073). The structural observation that the entire confidence interval, including its upper boundary, remains strictly below the zero line confirms a statistically significant global trend of decline in milk fat percentage during elevated thermal periods. Furthermore, the substantial level of statistical heterogeneity detected (Cochran’s Q = 117.08; p < 0.001; I² = 90.55 %) justifies the prioritization of the IVhet model from a methodological standpoint, ensuring more conservative weights and enhancing the statistical stability of the pooled trends derived through this robust approach. Forest Plot from Meta-Analysis Showing the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Fat Percentage. Fig. 3 visually presents the individual effect sizes (Cohen’s d) and 95% confidence intervals derived from the primary studies investigating the statistical association between environmental heat stress and milk protein percentage. The majority of the included study outcomes reported negative effect sizes, providing directionally consistent evidence that milk protein content exhibits a downward trend during periods of elevated thermal conditions. This systematic trend is clearly illustrated by the clustering of individual effect size markers toward the left side of the zero axis. Forest Plot from Meta-Analysis Showing the Effects of Heat Stress on Milk Protein Percentage. However, a few independent trials—notably those by Fabris et al. and Davidson et al.—reported positive point estimates, highlighting the presence of inherent biological, environmental, or methodological heterogeneity within the overall meta-analytic dataset. The pooled estimate for the protein percentage(d = -0.555) aligns with broader physiological discussions regarding altered nitrogen utilization and mammary synthetic variations under thermal load. At the bottom of the plot, the diamond symbol represents the overall pooled effect size across all included studies estimated via the Inverse Variance Heterogeneity (IVhet) framework. This global pooled value was documented at -0.555 (95% CI: -0.930 to -0.180). Since the entire width of this pooled interval lies strictly below the zero line of no effect, the dataset confirms a statistically significant and systematic global trend of lower milk protein percentages associated with elevated thermal stress periods. Fig. 4 visually presents the individual effect sizes (Cohen’s d) and 95% confidence intervals from the primary studies evaluating the statistical association between environmental heat stress and milk lactose percentage. The clustering of the majority of study markers on the left side of the zero axis indicates a predominantly negative trend, suggesting that periods of elevated thermal exposure consistently coincide with a downward shift in lactose levels. At the bottom of the plot, the diamond symbol represents the overall pooled effect size derived via the Inverse Variance Heterogeneity (IVhet) framework, documented at -0.404 (95% CI: -0.674 to -0.135). Forest Plot from Meta-Analysis Showing the Effects of Heat Stress on Milk Lactose Percentage. The structural fact that the entire width of the pooled confidence interval remains strictly positioned below the zero baseline confirms the statistical significance of these aggregated findings, supporting a directionally consistent global trend of lower milk lactose concentrations during elevated thermal states. This exploratory result aligns with broader physiological perspectives suggesting that, alongside alterations in major milk solids like fat and protein, elevated thermal indices reflect a noticeable variation in lactose dynamics—a component critical for maintaining the osmotic balance and volume of milk secretion. Assessment of publication bias To evaluate the robustness and validity of the synthesized outcomes across all performance and compositional traits, publication bias was systematically assessed using the Doi plot and the Luis Furuya-Kanamori (LFK) index framework. Unlike traditional funnel plots and Egger’s tests, which often exhibit inflated false-positive rates under high baseline heterogeneity, the LFK index provides a more robust, quantifiably stable measure of publication asymmetry. However, in accordance with reviewer suggestions to more rigorously evaluate potential reporting biases, results from Egger’s regression test were also integrated into the assessment. While borderline significance was observed in Egger’s test, this mathematical deviation is primarily attributed to the inherent high heterogeneity and diverse sample sizes among the primary studies rather than true publication bias. Consequently, while the synthesized findings possess high scientific validity, the pooled effect sizes are interpreted with academic caution, acknowledging the operational diversity within the literature. Fig. 5 presents the Doi plot evaluating publication bias and directional asymmetry specifically for the milk yield dataset. The assessment of publication and selection bias, conducted to verify the mathematical robustness of the meta-analytic findings, was based on a dual approach combining the Doi plot, the Luis Furuya-Kanamori (LFK) index, and Egger’s linear regression test. The computed LFK index for milk yield was -0.87, which falls strictly within the conventional threshold of statistical symmetry |LFK| ≤1 indicating no publication asymmetry based on this estimator. This quantitative finding is visually complemented by the relatively balanced distribution of the main body of the Doi curve around the central axis. However, to ensure maximum methodological rigor under conditions of high statistical heterogeneity, Egger’s linear regression test was simultaneously evaluated. In contrast to the LFK output, Egger’s test revealed a statistically significant asymmetrical trend (p = 0.0223). This methodological discrepancy between the two symmetry indicators is interpreted with necessary academic caution; traditional regression-based frameworks like Egger’s test are highly prone to artificial inflation of false-positive asymmetry errors when analyzing datasets marked by intense inter-study variance (I² = 89.17%). Consequently, while the visual structure of the Doi plot supports a reasonable representation of the synthesized literature relative to standard deviation scores, the pooled effect sizes are treated as global trend indicators rather than absolute biological points. This comprehensive, multi-faceted validation highlights the structural reliability of the aggregated dataset while remaining transparent about the mathematical limitations inherent in asymmetry testing under high heterogeneity. Publication Bias Plot of Studies Examining the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Yield. Fig. 6 illustrates the Doi plot generated to evaluate potential publication bias and directional dataset asymmetry for the milk fat percentage framework. The calculated Luis Furuya-Kanamori (LFK) index for this structural model was -0.81, falling securely within the standardized boundaries of mathematical symmetry |LFK| ≤1. This metric confirms no publication asymmetry for the milk fat parameter, a finding visually supported by the cohesive, balanced distribution of the independent study replication points along both arms of the Doi plot curve.As established within the comprehensive validation design (Table 9), Egger’s linear regression test was evaluated alongside the LFK index to ensure analytical triangulation under substantial inter-study variance (I²= 90.55). In the case of the milk fat percentage dataset, Egger’s regression yielded no statistically significant deviation (p = 0.9289), demonstrating complete directional alignment with the symmetry reported by the LFK index. The operational consensus between both the regression-based and visual-quantitative estimators provides strong evidence that the aggregated database is free from severe selective publication distortions. Publication Bias Plot of Studies Examining the Effects of Heat Stress on Milk Fat Percentage. Table 9Egger’s Linear Regression and Doi Plot LFK İndex Metrics.Table 9 dummy alt textRegression Coefficient (b)LCIHCIpLFK İndexMilk Yield0.3485-0.49181.18890.0223-0,87(no asymmetry)Milk Fat Percentage-0.7779-2.72591.17010.9289-0,81(no asymmetry)Milk Protein Percentage0.4549-1.14412.05390.3213-0,96(no asymmetryMilk Lactose Percentage0.3653-0.44331.17390.0970-1,94(minor asymmetry)*Note: LLCI = Lower Limit Confidence Interval; ULCI = Upper Limit Confidence Interval. Statistical significance for Egger’s regression is defined at p < 0.05. Egger’s Linear Regression and Doi Plot LFK İndex Metrics. *Note: LLCI = Lower Limit Confidence Interval; ULCI = Upper Limit Confidence Interval. Statistical significance for Egger’s regression is defined at p < 0.05. The operational consensus between both the regression-based and visual-quantitative estimators provides strong evidence that the aggregated database is free from severe selective publication distortions. However, given the high statistical heterogeneity native to the baseline model, these integrated outcomes continue to be interpreted with academic caution as broad global trend indicators reflecting wide operational variations in field conditions rather than a single, uniform biophysical endpoint. Fig. 7 presents the Doi plot mapping potential publication bias and directional dataset asymmetry for the milk protein percentage synthesis. The computed Luis Furuya-Kanamori (LFK) index for this parameter was documented at -0.96, establishing a position strictly within the standardized criteria for statistical symmetry |LFK| ≤1. This metric indicates no publication asymmetry for the milk protein dataset, an operational outcome visually validated by the highly symmetrical, roof-like distribution of the individual study data points flanking the central peak of the Doi plot curve. In accordance with the rigorous dual-validation framework summarized in Table 9, Egger’s linear regression test was concurrently examined to cross-verify these visual-quantitative indicators under moderate-to-high variance conditions (I² = 70.92 %). Egger’s regression test yielded no statistically significant deviation (p = 0.3213), demonstrating a clear directional consensus with the LFK index output. Publication Bias Plot of Studies Examining the Effects of Heat Stress on Milk Protein Percentage. The structural agreement between both independent estimators indicates that the pooled trends for milk protein percentage are highly reliable and free from meaningful selective reporting distortions across the compiled literature. While this mathematical consensus strengthens the statistical integrity of the pooled findings, the remaining variance is still interpreted with standard academic caution, associating residual study-to-study fluctuations with undocumented operational variations in field management rather than a rigid biophysical constant. Fig. 8 illustrates the Doi plot mapping potential publication bias and directional asymmetry for the milk lactose percentage meta-analytic framework. The computed Luis Furuya-Kanamori (LFK) index for the lactose dataset was documented at -1.94, which falls within the conventional boundaries defining minor statistical asymmetry |LFK| ≤1. This visual indicator reflects a slight over-representation of independent study replications along the left arm of the axis, shifting the peak marginally away from perfect baseline symmetry.To achieve complete diagnostic triangulation under the multi-faceted validation design (Table 9), Egger’s linear regression test was concurrently interpreted alongside this visual-quantitative framework. Crucially, Egger’s regression test revealed no statistically significant asymmetrical deviation (p = 0.0970), demonstrating a strong methodological consensus with the broader symmetry profile. This analytical alignment between the regression framework and the visual-quantitative index indicates that the minor structural variance captured by the LFK index does not compromise the overall statistical validity of the dataset. Consequently, the compiled literature for the milk lactose percentagecan be considered free from severe selective reporting or publication distortions, confirming that the aggregated estimators derived via the IVhet framework represent a robust and scientifically reliable global trend across the synthesized studies. Publication Bias Plot of Studies Examining the Effect of Heat Stress on Milk Lactose Percentage. Egger’s regression test analysis To complement the visual and quantitative evidence derived from the Doi plots, Egger’s linear regression test was performed across all evaluated parameters, with the comprehensive results summarized in Table 9. The obtained regression parameters generally support the absence of widespread, severe publication bias, though distinct variations were observed among the traits. Notably, for the milk yield parameter, Egger’s test revealed a statistically significant asymmetrical deviation (p = 0.0223, b = 0.3485). This directional asymmetry stands in contrast to the stable symmetry indicated by the LFK index (-0.87). This specific methodological divergence is interpreted with academic caution; regression-based tests are highly prone to generating false-positive asymmetry errors in meta-analytic datasets characterized by high inter-study variance (I² = 89.17%), meaning this result likely reflects the intense heterogeneity of field management variables rather than true selective reporting practices. Conversely, for milk fat percentage (p = 0.9289), milk protein percentage (p = 0.3213), and milk lactose percentage (p = 0.0970), the computed p-values remained safely above the conventional significance threshold (p > 0.05). For these composition traits, the lack of significant regression slopes indicates that the individual study effect sizes are distributed independently of their standard errors. These linear diagnostics align robustly with the corresponding LFK index classifications—confirming "no asymmetry" for both fat and protein, and only "minor asymmetry" for lactose that does not compromise overall statistical validity. Taken together, the triangulation of both visual-quantitative and regression-based diagnostic methods demonstrates a reasonably balanced operational distribution across the compiled literature, reinforcing the methodological soundness and structural reliability of the pooled effect estimators. Discussion Methodological considerations The present study utilized the Inverse Variance Heterogeneity (IVhet) model to map the global operational association between elevated thermal environments and dairy cattle production parameters. Meta-analytic designs in livestock sciences consistently confront extreme statistical heterogeneity (I² ≥ 90%),which fundamentally violates the underlying mathematical assumptions of traditional fixed- or random-effects frameworks. As established by Doi et al. (2015), conventional random-effects models inherently experience a flawed overestimation of confidence intervals when handling severe inter-study variance, compromising the reliability of pooled indicators (Doi et al., 2015). By contrast, the IVhet framework optimizes statistical weight distribution based on a quasi-likelihood approach, ensuring highly conservative and reliable pooled estimators without artificially inflating the true precision limits(Doi et al., 2017). While the Restricted Maximum Likelihood (REML) estimator within the R metafor package was deployed to conduct exploratory secondary meta-regressions and categorical subgroup partitions, prioritizing the IVhet model for the primary pooling serves as a core methodological strength of this study. This robust dual-estimator architecture provides a statistically resilient framework capable of synthesizing real-world field variance into a highly reliable global trend. Interpretation of thermal stress and production trends The pooled effect size (d = -0.723, p < 0.001) documents a statistically significant and substantial negative shift in milk yield associated with elevated environmental temperatures. Rather than representing an isolated biological fluctuation, this directionally consistent decline aligns with extensive literature detailing systemic metabolic and homeostatic adjustments in high-yielding dairy cows exposed to thermal loads (Bah et al., 2022; Toledo et al., 2024; Zhang et al., 2023). Physiologically, these aggregated variations coincide with two primary concurrent pathways. First, elevated ambient thermal metrics prompt a substantial downregulation of dry matter intake as an immediate adaptive response to minimize internal metabolic heat production. Second, modern high-yielding breeds undergo an altered nutrient partitioning framework during thermal stress; instead of directing volatile fatty acids and glucose efficiently toward mammary epithelial tissue for galactopoiesis, a substantial portion of net energy is redistributed to peripheral tissues to facilitate thermoregulation and evaporative coolingn (Bernabucci et al., 2010; Chen et al., 2024). Additionally, these systematic outcomes align with evidence that thermal load disrupts structural mammary gland dynamics and cell proliferation pathways, compromising the long-term synthetic capacity of the secretory tissue (Dado-Senn et al., 2019). These global meta-analytic outputs reflect regional baseline trends documented within challenging Mediterranean climates. For instance, production data from Turkey indicate localized yield reductions ranging from 10% to 25% when environmental conditions compromise the cows' thermo-neutral zones (Alkoyak & Çetin, 2016). Furthermore, Dinçel and Dikmen (2013) demonstrated that elevated nighttime thermal indices compound daytime exposure by preventing necessary nocturnal physiological cooling and metabolic recovery.(Dinçel & Dikmen, 2013). The steady quantitative decay captured across our synthesized database echoes the linear performance declines noted under localized index augmentations(Bernabucci et al., 2010), reinforcing the validity of the global aggregated slope. Categorical thresholds and comprehensive limitations A core contribution of this multi-trait synthesis is the structural evaluation of standardized index boundaries via categorical moderator analysis. Partitioning outcomes around the core threshold baseline (THI > 72) revealed an intensified shift in performance variations; this alignment closely mirrors primary literature reporting a severe production drop with an effect size of d = -2.17 under extreme microclimatic loads (Kulaz & Ser, 2021). While establishing these aggregated operational boundaries provides valuable contextual intelligence regarding broad thermal limits, these thresholds must be interpreted with strict academic caution rather than treated as precise biological point metrics. To ensure scientific transparency, the core limitations of this synthesis are formally consolidated across three primary structural dimensions: High Trait-Specific Heterogeneity: Substantial statistical heterogeneity persists within the baseline milk yield (I²=89.17%) and milk fat (I²=90.55%) models. While the outlier-resilient IVhet framework accommodates this variance to provide reliable pooled estimators, this high residual variance underscores that the operational impacts of thermal load are heavily influenced by local management factors. Conversely, the variance in milk protein (I²=70.92%) and milk lactose (I²=44.36%) models stabilized at more moderate levels, reflecting distinct stabilization patterns across different biological traits. Variability in Heat Stress Operationalization: As highlighted by the extreme variability across the 35 included replication studies, the absence of a standardized global reporting index limits direct comparability. Individual trials vary significantly in their exposure lengths, daily thermal durations, and baseline microclimatic measurements, which inherently limits the consistency of absolute pooled estimates. Inherent Boundaries of THI Metrics: While the Temperature-Humidity Index (THI) serves as a highly practical macro-environmental proxy, it is structurally limited in its capacity to capture the multi-dimensional complexity of thermal stress responses. A standard THI configuration fails to account for microclimatic fluctuations inside housing structures, individual animal resilience factors (such as parity or stage of lactation), and the compounding influences of wind velocity and solar radiation exposure. Crucially, this macro-level index cannot capture key temporal dynamics, including the exact duration of daily exposure, the presence of nocturnal cooling recovery periods, and the cumulative physiological stress experienced by dairy cows over consecutive days of elevated thermal load. Consequently, the pooled estimators reflect approximate trend indicators rather than uniform, time-dependent biological endpoints. Future primary trials must implement highly standardized reporting frameworks—incorporating precise descriptions of dietary fiber physics, cooling infrastructure specifications, and comprehensive microclimatic metrics—to clarify the residual variance currently left unexplained in global syntheses. Conclusion This meta-analysis synthesized data from 35 independent replication studies to evaluate the global statistical association between environmental thermal parameters and dairy cattle production traits. Our aggregated findings indicate that elevated Temperature-Humidity Index (THI) values coincide with statistically significant downward variations in both milk yield and macro-component quality. These observed performance declines appear particularly pronounced across database records representing high-yielding breeds such as Holsteins, reinforcing the relevance of systematic microclimatic monitoring within dairy production systems. The relationship between elevated thermal exposure and milk composition was quantified across the synthesized literature. The observed negative shift in milk fat percentage aligns with wider physiological variations regarding systemic disruptions in lipid dynamics under thermal load. Concurrently, the pooled effect size for milk protein percentage (d = -0.555) reflects a directionally consistent global trend of lower protein content under elevated THI conditions—a variation frequently associated with cellular stress responses and altered nitrogen utilization in primary trials. These integrated findings highlight ambient thermal intensity as a practical risk proxy associated with variations in milk quality, confirming that the baseline configuration (THI > 72) serves as a reliable macro-environmental marker for broad, approximate production transitions.While establishing these global trends provides valuable contextual intelligence regarding broad thermal limits, the high trait-specific heterogeneity (I²= 89.17 % for milk yield and I² = 90.55% for milk fat) underscores that these thresholds reflect approximate regional baseline shifts rather than uniform biological point metrics. Conversely, the stabilization of variance at more moderate levels for milk protein (I² = 70.92%) and lactose (I² = 44.36%) models indicates distinct stabilization patterns across different biological traits under high thermal loads. Future meta-analytic updates should prioritize high-granularity moderator analyses to systematically investigate the interactive dynamics between standardized THI thresholds, parity levels, and breed-specific climate resilience. Furthermore, cross-referencing global meta-analytic trends with emerging transcriptomic and proteomic datasets at the mammary tissue level will be essential to further clarify the molecular variations underlying altered milk protein dynamics. In conclusion, while the observed variance underscores the extreme biological complexity of heat-stress responses, the consistency of the threshold-based trends provides a robust basis for understanding broad production declines. Future efforts must focus on standardizing microclimatic and physiological reporting markers to further refine these performance variation estimates. CRediT authorship contribution statement Özgür Özcan: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Formal analysis, Data curation. Serdal Dikmen: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Supervision, Software, Methodology, Conceptualization. Declaration of competing interest The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest. References