Genome-wide association study and evolutionary analysis of the CrRLK1L family reveal BnCrRLK1L1_5 as a positive regulator of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum resistance in Brassica napus Authors: Tongyu Fu, Rong Zuo, Jie Liu, Zetao Bai, Cong Zhou, Junyan Huang, Li Ren, Yueying Liu, Fan Liu, Chaobo Tong, Li Xu, Lijiang Liu, Shengyi Liu Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundSclerotinia stem rot, caused by the necrotrophic pathogen Sclerotinia sclerotiorum (S. sclerotiorum), poses a significant threat to rapeseed (Brassica napus), resulting in substantial yield losses and economic damage worldwide. While receptor-like kinases, particularly the Catharanthus roseus RLK1-like (CrRLK1L) family, are known to play vital roles in plant immunity and development, their specific functions in B. napus defense against S. sclerotiorum and their evolutionary dynamics remain largely unexplored.ResultsThrough a GWAS, we identified BnCrRLK1L1_5, a CrRLK1L family member, as a candidate gene conferring resistance to S. sclerotiorum. To understand its evolutionary context, genome-wide and phylogenetic analyses of the CrRLK1L family across three Brassica species were performed, revealing significant diversification driven by whole-genome duplications and gene loss. Nevertheless, key functional domains, such as the malectin-like and kinase domains, remained highly conserved. Further analysis of cis-elements and the identification of six BnCrRLK1L1 paralogs in B. napus suggested potential functional redundancy and broad roles in mediating stress responses. Transcriptomic analysis revealed that the expression of BnCrRLK1L1_5 was strongly induced in resistant genotypes upon inoculation. Functional characterization using fer-4, a mutant of the Arabidopsis ortholog FERONIA (FER), showed enhanced susceptibility to S. sclerotiorum. Furthermore, complementation with BnCrRLK1L1_5 in the fer-4 background restored resistance to levels exceeding the wild-type, indicating functional conservation between BnCrRLK1L1_5 and FER. Co-expression of BnCrRLK1L1_5 with BAX in N. benthamiana leaves significantly reduced necrosis and ion leakage, suggesting that BnCrRLK1L1_5 functions as a suppressor of cell death. Moreover, protein-protein interaction network analysis predicted interactions between BnCrRLK1L1_5 and key partners, including BnCrRLK1L1_4, PTM9, RALF23, and Ferritin 4. These findings suggest that BnCrRLK1L1_5 modulates resistance through regulating cell wall integrity, oxidative stress, and immune signaling.ConclusionsTogether, this study elucidates the dynamic evolution of the CrRLK1L family and establishes BnCrRLK1L1_5 as a key regulator of resistance against S. sclerotiorum. The potential mechanisms involving immune signaling and cell death regulation provide valuable insights for improving disease resistance in rapeseed and other crops.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12870-026-08872-5.Keywords: CrRLK1L, FER, Sclerotinia sclerotiorum, GWAS, Brassica napus Background The Catharanthus roseus receptor-like kinase 1-like (CrRLK1L) family is a prominent subfamily of the RLK superfamily that regulates key developmental processes and mediates responses to diverse stress conditions [1]. The CrRLK1L family was first identified in Catharanthus roseus and is characterized by an N-terminal extracellular domain, a single transmembrane helix, and a C-terminal kinase tail [2]. This structure allows CrRLK1L proteins to function as signal transducers at the plasma membrane, perceiving external signals through interactions between the extracellular malectin-like domain and RALF peptides [3]. In Arabidopsis thaliana, the 17 identified CrRLK1L members are grouped into 10 clades, each with distinct functions in regulating diverse biological processes [4]. Among them, CrRLK1L1, also known as FERONIA (FER), exhibits ubiquitous expression in vegetative and reproductive organs and plays a multifaceted role from growth to immunity [5–7]. It has been implicated in diverse developmental processes, including root hair elongation [8], flowering time [9], pollen tube growth [10], and seed development [11]. FER also participates in abiotic stress responses such as cold, heat, drought, and salinity [7]. It regulates cell growth and stress responses by modulating the balance of ROS and hormone homeostasis, particularly auxin, jasmonic acid, brassinosteroids, ethylene, and salicylic acid [12]. Most of all, FER plays a dual role in plant immunity. It positively regulates basal immune responses by forming receptor complexes with PRRs [13]. For example, overexpression of the extracellular malectin-like domain of TaFER enhanced resistance to Fusarium graminearum [14]. Moreover, FER attenuates bacterial virulence efficiency. It mediates resistance to Pseudomonas syringae by suppressing JA and coronatine through the phosphorylation and destabilization of MYC2 [15]. However, this pathway can be exploited by pathogens. RALF23 binds FER to stabilize MYC2 or to block immune complexes, thereby suppressing plant defense and promoting infection [13, 15]. Brassica napus L. is a major global oilseed crop used in food, feed, and biofuel production [16]. As an allotetraploid species (AACC) that emerged from the natural crossing between Brassica rapa (AA) and Brassica oleracea (CC), B. napus exhibits a complex genome [17]. However, it faces numerous biotic stresses, among which Sclerotinia stem rot caused by the necrotrophic pathogen S. sclerotiorum is a major threat [18]. This pathogen infects multiple tissues and persists in soil as sclerotia for years, resulting in yield and quality losses worldwide. To date, no B. napus accession possesses complete immunity to S. sclerotiorum. Despite the identification of various resistance-associated QTLs, the isolation of a single gene conferring complete resistance remains lacking [19–23]. It implicates the complexity of resistance mechanisms and poses significant challenges for breeding efforts. Recent advances in genomics, especially GWAS, have been utilized to explore candidate resistant QTLs; only a few genes have been functionally validated. For example, BnaA07.MKK9 enhanced Sclerotinia stem rot resistance by promoting H2O2 accumulation and hypersensitive response [24], while BnaA07.WRKY40 regulated downstream defense-related genes in response to S. sclerotiorum infection [25]. Considering the devastating impact of Sclerotinia stem rot, the limited number of resistance genes identified so far has significantly hindered progress in breeding for resistance. In this study, we integrated GWAS with functional genomics to identify BnCrRLK1L1_5 as a critical enhancer of resistance to S. sclerotiorum. Using a natural population of 180 B. napus accessions, BnCrRLK1L1_5 was identified as a candidate gene associated with stem rot resistance. Then, the study investigated the functional role of BnCrRLK1L1_5 by complementing the corresponding Arabidopsis mutant fer-4. Furthermore, we performed a comprehensive genome-wide analysis of the CrRLK1L family in rapeseed, including phylogenetic and synteny analyses, gene structure and motif characterization, cis-element prediction, expression profiling, and protein-protein interaction networks. Together, this study investigated the functional and evolutionary roles of CrRLK1L genes, offering novel insights into the molecular basis of immunity against S. sclerotiorum in B. napus. It will also uncover new resistance genes, broadening the genetic resources available for combating S. sclerotiorum. Materials and methods Plant materials and fungal pathogens The natural populations employed for GWAS consisted of 180 B. napus accessions, including spring, winter, and semi-winter types of rapeseed oil, all cultivated under natural conditions in our laboratory’s Yangluo experimental field in Wuhan, Hubei Province (Table S1). A. thaliana wild-type and the fer-4 mutant were maintained in our laboratory and grown in a controlled greenhouse at 22 °C, under a 16 h light/8 h dark photoperiod. The S. sclerotiorum isolate 1980 was propagated on PDA at 24 °C, and its mycelium was subsequently used for further inoculation. Stem and leaf inoculation with S. sclerotiorum Stem inoculation was conducted on 180 natural accessions of B. napus grown in the field during the peak flowering stage of the majority of the population. Each accession was planted in three replicated plots, with ten plants per replicate. Mycelial plugs of S. sclerotiorum were prepared by punching 8 mm discs from the actively growing edge of fungal cultures. A hole of the same diameter was pre-drilled into the stem of each plant, and the 8 mm mycelial plug was placed at the wound site. Then the inoculated stem was wrapped with plastic film to maintain moisture and promote infection. Each plot received three sets of inoculated plants, and lesion size was measured at 17 days post-inoculation [26]. The average lesion size from the three replicates was used as the phenotypic value for GWAS analysis. Leaf inoculation was performed on B. napus cultivars ZS11 and ZY821 grown in the field during the wintering period. An 8 mm mycelial agar disc was placed at the leaf center. The size of each lesion was determined by measuring two perpendicular diameters and calculated as the mean of these values at 24 and 42 h after inoculation. Subsequently, the final “average lesion size” for each specific accession was calculated as the statistical mean of the lesion sizes across all replicates. Similarly, Arabidopsis wild-type and fer-4 mutant were inoculated using a 2 mm mycelial plug on each leaf collected from eight-week-old plants. Lesion size was measured and calculated using the same method at 42 h after inoculation. Each accession was inoculated in three replicated plots, with ten leaves per replicate. The average lesion size from the three replicates served as the phenotypic value. Statistical significance was assessed using Student’s t-test. GWAS in a natural population We conducted GWAS on a collection of 180 B. napus accessions, utilizing whole-genome resequencing data previously generated in our laboratory [27]. The Illumina HiSeq XTen platform was used for sequencing, followed by the alignment against the B. napus Darmor-bzh reference assembly (version 5.0). SNPs with a MAF < 0.05 were filtered out, resulting in 2,797,642 high-quality SNPs for GWAS analysis. The GWAS was implemented using both MLM and GLM. A significance cutoff of p < 1.8 × 10⁻⁸ was adopted in this study, corresponding to a Bonferroni correction (0.05/total number of SNPs) [28]. LDBlockShow was employed to generate heatmaps representing linkage disequilibrium and haplotype blocks in specific regions [29]. Box-and-whisker plots of phenotypic differences among haplotypes were generated based on significant SNPs via a two-tailed Student’s t-test. Genetic complementation assays in Arabidopsis The complementation vector was constructed for transformation into Arabidopsis to validate the candidate gene. The genomic sequence of BnCrRLK1L1_5 was amplified from B. napus cv. ZY821 via PCR (primers in Table S2) and inserted into the pBI121 under the control of its native promoter. The constructed vector was then electroporated into Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain GV3101. Arabidopsis mutant (fer-4) was transformed using the floral dip method. After selection on kanamycin-containing medium and confirmation by PCR, homozygous T₂ lines were used for leaf inoculation. Subcellular localization, cell death, and ion leakage measurement in Nicotiana benthamiana The pBI121-mCherry vector carrying BnCrRLK1L1_5 (primers in Table S2) was transformed into A. tumefaciens GV3101. For transient expression assays, bacteria were resuspended to a final OD600 of 0.5 in a solution of 10 mM MgCl₂, 10 mM MES (pH 5.6), and 100 µM acetosyringone. The bacterial suspensions were infiltrated into the 4- to 6-week-old N. benthamiana leaves using a needleless syringe [30]. Subcellular localization of BnCrRLK1L1_5 was visualized by detecting mCherry fluorescence using confocal laser scanning microscopy after 48 h. To assess cell death induction or inhibition, the BnCrRLK1L1_5 construct, control vectors, and BAX were expressed in N. benthamiana leaves as described above. Cell death symptoms were monitored visually and documented 3 days post-infiltration. Leaf discs with a diameter of 1 cm were prepared from both inoculated and uninoculated N. benthamiana leaves using a sterile cork borer. The leaf discs were immediately immersed in 20 mL of sterile distilled water and incubated for 30 min. Initial electrical conductivity (EC1) of the samples and the blank control (EC0) was measured using an OHAUS STARTER 300 C conductivity meter. Subsequently, the samples were boiled for 30 min to achieve complete electrolyte release, then cooled to room temperature (25 °C). The total electrical conductivity (EC2) was then measured. The leakage percentage was calculated using the equation: (EC1−EC0) / (EC2−EC0) × 100% [31]. Identification of CrRLK1L family members in three Brassica species Sequences of the 17 A. thaliana (Columbia_TAIR10.1) CrRLK1L members were acquired from TAIR. The genome and protein data of B. napus (Darmor-bzh_v5), B. oleracea (JZS_v2), and B. rapa (Chiifu_v4.1) were retrieved from BnaOmics (https://bnaomics.ocri-genomics.net/) [32]. The A. thaliana CrRLK1L amino acid sequences were employed as query probes to screen for homologous genes in three Brassica species. All CrRLK1L protein kinases are defined by a conserved architecture comprising a malectin-like domain and a kinase domain. Domain structures of the 17 Arabidopsis CrRLK1L proteins were analyzed using Pfam, which confirmed that all of them contain the malectin-like domain (Pfam ID: PF12819). Notably, ATCrRLK1L14 (AT5G39020) included the Pkinase domain (Pfam ID: PF00069), whereas the remaining 16 members contained the Pk_Tyr_Ser-Thr domain (Pfam ID: PF07714). Therefore, candidate CrRLK1L members were characterized by the malectin-like domain (PF12819) in combination with either the Pk_Tyr_Ser-Thr domain (PF07714) or the Pkinase domain (PF00069). All candidate protein sequences were further verified using Pfam to confirm the presence of complete domain structures. Chromosomal distribution, phylogeny, and synteny analysis Chromosomal loci were identified using genome annotation files in GFF format and visualized with TBtools [33]. Phylogenetic relationships were established using the Neighbor-Joining method in MEGA 11 under default parameters, following the alignment of amino acid sequences from Arabidopsis and the three Brassica species [34]. The online server iTOL (https://itol.embl.de/) was utilized to display and annotate the constructed tree. Additionally, to further investigate the evolutionary conservation and genomic synteny of CrRLK1L genes, collinearity analysis was conducted using MCScanX with default parameters [35]. Gene structure, conserved motif, cis-elements analysis, and PPI network of BnCrRLK1L genes The exon-intron organization of BnCrRLK1L genes was analyzed using the B. napus genome annotation files (GFF). Conserved motifs were identified via the MEME Suite server, while functional domains were examined using the NCBI Conserved Domain Database. The PlantCARE online tool was utilized to analyze the 2 kb genomic region upstream of the start codon for each BnCrRLK1L gene (http://bioinformatics.psb.ugent.be/webtools/plantcare/html) [36]. All the data were visualized using TBtools [33]. The PPI network of the CrRLK1L family in B. napus was constructed from STRING data [37] and visualized in Cytoscape [38]. Putative interacting genes were further evaluated through GO enrichment analysis using the BnaOmics platform [32]. Transcriptomic profiling and qRT-PCR validation Transcriptome data upon S. sclerotiorum inoculation were generated by RNA-seq in B. napus cv. ZS11 and ZY821 at 24 h post-inoculation in this study. Additionally, transcriptomic data covering 31 distinct tissues of the ZS11 cultivar were obtained from BnTIR (http://yanglaboratory.hzau.edu.cn/BnTIR) [39]. To maintain consistency with the data format retrieved from the BnTIR database, the expression levels of all analyzed genes were normalized and evaluated using TPM values. Expression profiles were visualized as heatmaps using TPM values through the ImageGP online server (https://www.bic.ac.cn/ImageGP/). Results Identification of BnCrRLK1L1_5 as a candidate gene associated with resistance to S. sclerotiorum To investigate genes potentially regulating resistance to S. sclerotiorum, a GWAS was conducted using 180 B. napus accessions. A total of 2,797,642 SNPs with a MAF > 0.05 were analyzed using the MLM and GLM based on the average lesion size. Manhattan plots highlighted a genomic region significantly associated with resistance, spanning 36.006–36.012 Mb on chromosome C07 (Fig. 1A and Fig. S1). Within this 6-kb region, the most significant SNPs were in strong LD with BnaC07g32280D, which encodes a CrRLK1L family receptor-like kinase (Fig. 1B). Two major haplotype groups were identified by focusing on seven statistically significant missense SNPs in the candidate gene, comprising 45 (Hap1) and 114 (Hap2) accessions, respectively (Fig. 1C). Accessions in Hap2 exhibited significantly shorter lesion sizes than those in Hap1. The results suggest that BnaC07g32280D (a homolog of AtCrRLK1L1, also known as FER) is a strong candidate gene contributing to Sclerotinia stem rot resistance in B. napus. Discovery of the S. sclerotiorum resistance candidate gene BnaC07g32280D by GWAS. A Manhattan plot of the association analysis by MLM. Each point represents an SNP. The horizontal line indicates the genome-wide significance threshold (p = 1.787 × 10–8). B Location Manhattan plot and linkage disequilibrium (LD) heatmap of the candidate region (36.006–36.012 Mb) on C07. Red dots above the cutoff line represent significantly associated SNPs. C Structure and SNP variations of BnaC07g32280D and the necrosis size associated with the identified haplotypes. Data was analyzed via Student’s t-test (***, p < 0.001) Identification and chromosomal distribution of CrRLK1L family in B. napus To better characterize the gene identified by GWAS, a comprehensive genome-wide survey of the CrRLK1L family was performed in B. napus. Using 17 Arabidopsis CrRLK1L members as reference sequences, we identified 48 distinct CrRLK1L members in B. napus, including 23 in the A subgenome and 25 in the C subgenome (Table S3). These genes were unevenly distributed across 18 chromosomes, excluding A05 (Fig. S2 and Table S4). Chromosomes A04, C03, and C04 each carried five CrRLK1L genes, while A06 and C07 each carried four genes. The remaining chromosomes contained one to three CrRLK1L genes. These genes were named based on phylogenetic relationships with Arabidopsis orthologs. The gene BnaC07g32280D identified by GWAS in this study was an ortholog of AtCrRLK1L1 (FER). Our results revealed six orthologous copies in B. napus, all showing high sequence similarity with FER (Fig. S3). Accordingly, BnaC07g32280D was named BnCrRLK1L1_5. Phenotype of S. sclerotiorum resistance and the expression profiling of BnCrRLK1L1 Representative accessions representing the two haplotypes were subjected to leaf inoculation assays. The resistant genotype (Hap2) exhibited significantly delayed symptom development compared with the susceptible genotype (Hap1) at both 24 and 42 h post-inoculation (hpi) (Fig. 2A). Quantification of lesion size confirmed that Hap2 accessions developed significantly smaller necrotic lesions than Hap1 (Fig. 2B), validating the association with Hap2 and the enhanced S. sclerotiorum resistance. Phenotype and expression profiling of BnCrRLK1L1 homologs in representative two haplotypes. A Disease symptoms on leaves of two haplotypes, including ZS11 (Hap1) and ZY821 (Hap2) at 24 and 42 h post-inoculation (hpi). B Quantification of lesion sizes at 24 and 42 hpi. C Expression patterns of BnCrRLK1L1s in ZS11 and ZY821 at 24 hpi. D Distribution of SNP variant types in the six BnCrRLK1L1 gene loci. Different colored segments represent different SNP annotation categories. Data was analyzed via Student’s t-test: ns, no significance; *, p < 0.05; **, p < 0.01; ***, p < 0.001 To identify the causal gene among the homologs, the expression patterns of the six BnCrRLK1L1 copies were examined upon S. sclerotiorum inoculation. Of these, four genes were differentially expressed between the two haplotypes. BnCrRLK1L1_4 and BnCrRLK1L1_5 shared similar expression patterns. Their transcripts were barely detectable in Hap1 but were strongly and rapidly induced upon inoculation in Hap2 (Fig. 2C). Furthermore, analysis of sequence variations within the genomic regions of the six BnCrRLK1L1 genes revealed that BnCrRLK1L1_5 (62 SNPs) and BnCrRLK1L1_6 (84 SNPs) exhibited a higher degree of overall polymorphism than the other homologs (Fig. 2D). Notably, BnCrRLK1L1_5 harbored the highest number of upstream regulatory variants (20 SNPs) and a large number of missense mutations (10 SNPs), suggesting potential functional variation (Fig. 2D). Combined with its inducible expression pattern, these features implicate BnCrRLK1L1_5 as the causal candidate gene. BnCrRLK1L1_5 enhances resistance to stem rot and inhibits BAX-induced cell death Since BnCrRLK1L1_5 is an ortholog of the Arabidopsis receptor kinase FERONIA (FER), the loss-of-function mutant fer-4 was inoculated with S. sclerotiorum to assess resistance. The fer-4 mutant displayed significantly expanded lesions compared with the wild-type upon inoculation with S. sclerotiorum (Fig. S4 and Fig. 3A-B), indicating that FER is putatively required for basal resistance against this pathogen. A construct carrying the full gene sequence of BnCrRLK1L1_5 (haplotype from ZY821) with its native promoter was transformed into the fer-4 mutant for complementation (Fig. S5 and Fig. S6). The transgenic plants exhibited significantly reduced disease symptoms and restored resistance to levels exceeding the wild-type, indicating that BnCrRLK1L1_5 can compensate for the loss of resistance in the fer-4 mutant (Fig. 3A-B). These results support a pivotal role for BnCrRLK1L1_5 in positively regulating immunity against S. sclerotiorum. BnCrRLK1L1_5 enhances resistance to S. sclerotiorum and suppresses BAX-induced cell death. A Phenotype of Arabidopsis WT, fer-4 mutant, and BnCrRLK1L1_5 complementation line at 48 h post-inoculation (hpi). B Statistical analysis of lesion sizes at 48 hpi. C Subcellular localization of BnCrRLK1L1_5-mCherry fusion protein in Nicotiana benthamiana. D Leaf necrosis identification at 5 days post-infiltration (dpi) using a transient expression system in N. benthamiana. E Measurement of ion leakage at 3 dpi in N. benthamiana. Distinct letters denote statistically significant differences (p < 0.05) Subcellular localization studies in N. benthamiana leaves showed that BnCrRLK1L1_5-mCherry fusion protein localized on the cell membrane (Fig. 3C). Furthermore, the co-expression of BnCrRLK1L1_5 with BAX significantly alleviated leaf necrosis, indicating that BnCrRLK1L1_5 inhibits BAX-triggered cell death (Fig. 3D). The rate of ion leakage was also significantly reduced in co-expressed N. benthamiana leaves, further supporting the result that BnCrRLK1L1_5 inhibited cell death (Fig. 3E). The results suggest that BnCrRLK1L1_5 contributes to resistance, likely by suppressing pathogen-associated cell death. Phylogenetic and syntenic relationship of the CrRLK1L family To explore the evolutionary relationship within the CrRLK1L family, an unrooted phylogenetic tree was generated from 114 amino acid sequences, including 17 CrRLK1L proteins from (A) thaliana, 25 from (B) rapa, 24 from B. oleracea, and 48 from B. napus (Table S5). These proteins were classified into seven distinct clades based on phylogenetic relationships (Fig. 4A). Clade V, with 23 members, was identified as the largest cluster, containing CrRLK1L12 to 15. Clade III and VI each contained 21 members, including CrRLK1L4/5/9 and CrRLK1L1/2/3, respectively. Most AtCrRLK1L genes had 2–6 orthologs in B. napus, distributed across both the A and C subgenomes. This expansion reflects the whole-genome duplication events in Brassica. However, specific evolutionary divergence was observed. For example, AtRLK1L9/11/14/15 each had only one ortholog, whereas AtRLK1L13 had seven orthologs. The phylogenetic analysis also revealed the loss of AtCrRLK1L2/12 orthologs in Brassica species, suggesting gene loss events during evolution. Within clade VI, the candidate gene BnCrRLK1L1_5 and its paralog BnCrRLK1L1_3 both clustered tightly with AtCrRLK1L1. While BnCrRLK1L1_3 showed slightly higher sequence similarity, the close phylogenetic relationship of BnCrRLK1L1_5 within this specific subclade suggested a shared evolutionary lineage and potential functional conservation. Phylogenetic and syntenic analyses of the CrRLK1L family in Arabidopsis and Brassica species. A Phylogenetic tree generated with MEGA 11, showing seven distinct clades (indicated by different colors). B Syntenic relationships of the CrRLK1L family indicate the syntenic gene pairs within Arabidopsis and Brassica species. Gray lines denote syntenic blocks. Colored lines trace specific syntenic relationships: green for (A) thaliana, (B) rapa, and the B. napus A subgenome; purple for (A) thaliana, (B) oleracea, and the B. napus C subgenome; and orange for pairs between the A and C subgenomes of B. napus Syntenic analysis highlighted the conservation of CrRLK1L genes between Arabidopsis and the Brassica crops (Fig. 4B and Table S5). However, the synteny between (A) thaliana and Brassica genomes appeared fragmented, reflecting extensive chromosomal rearrangements during the evolution of Brassica species. Furthermore, a one-to-one syntenic relationship was revealed between the (B) napus A subgenome and B. rapa chromosomes, and between the B. napus C subgenome and B. oleracea chromosomes, confirming the allopolyploid origin and genomic stability in B. napus. Analyses of gene structure, conserved domain, and protein motif in BnCrRLK1L proteins To explore the structural diversity of the BnCrRLK1L proteins, we examined the exon-intron organization, conserved domains, and protein motifs of the 48 BnCrRLK1L proteins (Fig. 5). Gene structure analysis revealed that almost half of the family members lacked introns, and about one-third contained a single intron. All CrRLK1L family members feature conserved malectin-like and protein kinase domains. Conserved domain analysis confirmed that all BnCrRLK1L proteins share the standard structure of receptor-like kinases. Specifically, they feature tandem N-terminal malectin (PF11721) or malectin-like (PF12819) domains, followed by a transmembrane helix, and C-terminal kinase domain including Pkinase (PF00069) and Pk_Tyr_Ser-Thr (PF07714). Analysis of conserved motifs in the BnCrRLK1L proteins revealed 9–10 motifs across the family, with some motifs repeated in certain genes and other motifs absent in specific members (Table S6). For example, motifs 3 and 7 were absent in some genes, while motif 8 was absent in the group V members. Phylogenetic relationships and structural characterization of CrRLK1L members in B. napus and Arabidopsis. A phylogenetic tree is generated based on the sequences of AtCrRLK1L and BnCrRLK1L. A Exon-intron organization. The UTRs and exons are represented by light green and light yellow boxes, respectively, while introns are represented by black lines. B Functional domains. Malectin-like (PF12819) and malectin (PF11721) domains are shown in red and pink, respectively; kinase domains including Pkinase (PF00069) and STKc-IRAK (PF07714) are marked in yellow. Corresponding Pfam accessions are listed in Table S3. C Distribution of conserved motifs, with each motif represented by a distinct color. Detailed motif sequences are provided in Table S6 Spatiotemporal expression pattern of BnCrRLK1L genes Based on RNA-seq data from 18 tissues at different developmental stages, BnCrRLK1L genes exhibiting distinct expression profiles were classified into four clades (Fig. 6). The green clade, including BnCrRLK1L13/14/16, showed predominantly expression in leaves, and the genes in the blue clade were highly expressed in seeds and siliques. The gold clade, including BnCrRLK1L3/4/5, displayed a pollen-specific expression. The red clade, including BnCrRLK1L1/7/17, exhibited ubiquitous expression across most tissues. Within this clade, BnCrRLK1L1 genes showed varied expression patterns. The candidate BnCrRLK1L1_5 exhibited high expression levels in most tissues but relatively low transcript levels in seeds, pollen, and stems. Overall, the similar expression patterns of different BnCrRLK1L paralogs suggest conserved functional roles across the gene family. Tissue-specific expression profiles of the BnCrRLK1L gene family. The heatmap displays the expression levels (log2-transformed TPM values) of BnCrRLK1L genes. The four phylogenetic clades are distinguished by different colors. The tested tissues include root, L_stem (lower_stem_peel), M_stem (middle_stem_peel), U_stem (upper_stem_peel), cotyledon, leaf (7, 14, and 41 days old), filament, petal, pollen, sepal, seed (14, 40, and 64 days after flowering), and silique (12, 36, and 60 days after flowering). Relative transcript abundance is indicated by the color scale, ranging from blue (low) to red (high) Cis-elements analysis of BnCrRLK1L genes To understand the transcriptional regulation mechanisms of BnCrRLK1L genes, cis-regulatory elements were analyzed in the promoters (Table S7). The analysis showed that core promoter and enhancer region elements accounted for approximately 79% of all predicted cis-elements (Fig. 7A and Fig. S7). The remaining elements were mainly associated with hormonal response, stress, and developmental processes. About 8% of hormone-responsive cis-elements were enriched. Among them, MeJA-responsive elements were the most significantly enriched, followed by ABA-responsive elements (Fig. 7B). The enrichment of MeJA-responsive elements reflects an evolutionary adaptation of these genes for defense against necrotrophic pathogens. Moreover, multiple environmental stress-responsive elements were also identified, including light, anaerobic conditions, drought, low temperature, defense, and wounding (Fig. 7C). This indicates that the expression of BnCrRLK1L is putatively regulated by environmental stimuli. In addition, a smaller proportion of cis-elements was associated with various developmental processes, including meristem activity, circadian regulation, endosperm expression, flavonoid biosynthesis, seed regulation, and cell cycle control (Fig. 7D), indicating the diverse roles in development. Distribution and functional classification of cis-elements in BnCrRLK1L promoters. A Overall distribution of all identified cis-elements. B-D Number and categorization of cis-elements associated with hormone responses (B), biotic and abiotic stress responses (C), and developmental processes (D) PPI network of BnCrRLK1L members To explore potential interaction partners, a PPI network for BnCrRLK1L members was generated using the STRING database (Fig. 8A and Table S8). The resulting network of B. napus comprised 190 nodes and 930 edges, with two major clusters suggesting divergent signaling roles within the family. Among the 190 nodes, 14 represented query BnCrRLK1L proteins, which act as hubs connecting to numerous interacting partners. Prediction of PPI network for BnCrRLK1L members. A Global PPI network constructed using STRING. The yellow nodes represent the query BnCrRLK1L protein, and the green nodes indicate interacting proteins. The gray lines represent predicted interactions. B A specific subnetwork for BnCrRLK1L1_5. PTM9, protein methyltransferases 9; RALF23, RAPID ALKALINIZATION FACTOR 23; FER4, ferritin 4. C GO classification of the potential interacting proteins A focused subnetwork concentrated on BnCrRLK1L1_5 was identified (Fig. 8B). This subnetwork contained crucial nodes, including its paralog BnCrRLK1L1_4, the peptide ligand RALF23 (Rapid Alkalinization Factor 23), PTM9 (Protein Methyltransferase 9), and FER4 (Ferritin 4). BnCrRLK1L1_4 not only physically interacts with BnCrRLK1L1_5 but also shares a highly similar expression pattern (Fig. 2C), indicating that they may cooperate in S. sclerotiorum resistance. However, the possibility of functional redundancy cannot be ruled out. Moreover, the receptor-like protein RALF23 was also identified in this subnetwork, implicating its conserved role in RALF-triggered immunity. GO enrichment analysis of the interaction partners provided insights into the cellular mechanisms of BnCrRLK1L proteins. Functional annotation based on GO enrichment indicated that the interacting proteins were significantly associated with biological processes, molecular functions, and cellular components (Fig. 8C and Table S9). Biological process terms were primarily associated with cellular processes such as the organization of cellular components, cytoskeleton dynamics, and actin filament assembly. Analysis of molecular function revealed a significant enrichment in binding-related activities, particularly cytoskeletal protein binding, nucleotide binding, and ATP binding. For cellular components, the analysis reveals a significant enrichment in membrane-related categories, including the cell periphery and integral membrane components. These results suggest that BnCrRLK1L proteins may be important for cell membrane integrity and intracellular signaling, processes closely linked to plant defense responses. Discussion BnCrRLK1L1_5 enhances resistance to S. sclerotiorum in B. napus Our study highlights the significance of the CrRLK1L receptor-like kinase family in crop immunity. FER has been widely reported to regulate broad-spectrum immunity in the model plant Arabidopsis [1]. However, understanding its homologous functions in polyploid crops like B. napus is challenging due to extensive gene family expansion and functional redundancy [17]. Although Hap1 is broadly distributed across susceptible accessions, the highly resistant Hap2 allele is relatively rare. The strong pathogen-induced transcriptional activation of Hap2 suggests an efficient and rapid immune response mechanism. The low frequency of this advantageous allele in the examined population indicates that it has largely escaped extensive selection during the historical domestication of rapeseed [39]. However, large-scale haplotype identification and association analysis in germplasm resources are necessary to evaluate the application potential of Hap2 in breeding populations and to develop molecular markers for assisted selection. Furthermore, the biological significance of BnCrRLK1L1_5 is strongly reinforced by its functional conservation. Previous studies have established that FER acts as a crucial positive regulator against necrotrophs, including S. sclerotiorum and Botrytis cinerea [40]. Our heterologous expression data demonstrated that BnCrRLK1L1_5 not only fully rescued the susceptibility of the Arabidopsis fer-4 mutant but also conferred resistance levels surpassing those of the wild-type. The enhanced resistance may result from the potent immune signaling of the naturally selected Hap2 allele in B. napus. Additionally, it is also possible that sequence divergence protects BnCrRLK1L1_5 from the S. sclerotiorum effectors that normally hijack the native Arabidopsis FER [41]. While its role in conferring basal resistance is clear, future comparative studies are required to elucidate how specific sequence variations between Hap1 and Hap2 alter this protective kinase function. Potential mechanism of BnCrRLK1L1_5-mediated defense against S. sclerotiorum Cell death plays a versatile role during the interplay between plants and pathogens. On one hand, cell death is part of the plant’s defense strategy to restrict pathogen spread and to confer resistance against biotrophic pathogens [42]. However, necrotrophic pathogens such as S. sclerotiorum exploit cell death to facilitate infection and colonization by secreting effectors that degrade plant cell walls and induce additional cell death [43, 44]. Accordingly, suppression of excessive cell death represents an effective resistance strategy for necrotrophic pathogens [45]. In this study, co-expression of BnCrRLK1L1_5 with BAX in N. benthamiana leaves significantly reduced necrosis and ion leakage, suggesting that BnCrRLK1L1_5 functions as a suppressor of cell death. Previous studies have shown that suppression of necrotic cell death is a known strategy confering resistance to S. sclerotiorum. Overexpression of AtMLO2 and BnMLO2_2 in Arabidopsis reduced lesion sizes and cell death following S. sclerotiorum infection [46]. Similarly, FER has been demonstrated to modulate immune responses through RALF-mediated signaling, and fer loss-of-function mutants exhibit enhanced cell death and altered defense responses [3, 47]. A recent study demonstrated that RALF22, a peptide involved in cell wall remodeling, inhibits ROS bursts, thereby positively regulating the resistance to S. sclerotiorum [40]. Together, the results suggest that the resistance conferred by BnCrRLK1L1_5 is achieved by suppressing necrotic cell death. PPI network analysis further provided insights into the potential molecular mechanisms. BnCrRLK1L1_5 was found to interact with several important proteins. RALF23 is a well-characterized FER ligand that regulates immune signaling and cell wall remodeling [13], suggesting that BnCrRLK1L1_5 may participate in peptide-mediated signaling at the cell surface. Ferritin 4, which is involved in ion homeostasis, may regulate oxidative stress during pathogen attack [48]. By promoting Ferritin stability or accumulation, BnCrRLK1L1_5 could alleviate cell death, thereby restricting the infection of the necrotrophic pathogen S. sclerotiorum. Moreover, BnCrRLK1L1_4 shared similar expression patterns with BnCrRLK1L1_5 upon S. sclerotiorum inoculation, raising the possibility that these two genes act together or redundantly to modulate resistance to S. sclerotiorum. These interactions support a model about how BnCrRLK1L1_5 may contribute to resistance by modulating cell wall integrity, oxidative stress, and immune signaling. Evolutionary dynamics and functional redundancy of the CrRLK1L family Despite the extensive characterization of the CrRLK1L family in various plant species, a systematic genome-wide analysis in B. napus remains lacking [49–55]. As an allopolyploid species derived from hybridization between B. rapa and B. oleracea, B. napus provides an opportunity to investigate gene family expansion and functional divergence following polyploidization [17, 56]. Phylogenetic and synteny analyses suggest that the CrRLK1L family has undergone extensive expansion and diversification across Brassica species. Although the total number of CrRLK1L genes in B. napus approximates the combined numbers found in its progenitor species, differential retention of orthologs between the A and C subgenomes indicates asymmetric gene loss and chromosomal rearrangement following polyploidization [57]. Despite diversification, the CrRLK1L family exhibited significant evolutionary conservation, particularly within key functional domains, including the malectin-like and kinase domains [58]. The functional complementation of Arabidopsis fer-4 by BnCrRLK1L1_5 in this study provides experimental evidence for the conservation of CrRLK1L1 function across species. Moreover, the presence of six copies of the BnCrRLK1L1 genes in B. napus suggests specialized roles in different tissues or developmental stages. Interestingly, BnCrRLK1L1_5 and BnCrRLK1L1_4 not only share high sequence identity with FER but also exhibit co-expression patterns and potentially interact with each other. The findings support the hypothesis that these paralogs may act cooperatively or redundantly in conferring resistance to S. sclerotiorum. Such functional redundancy may enhance the robustness of defense responses against necrotrophic pathogens and contribute to adaptive evolution of disease resistance in polyploid crops [59]. Conclusion We identified BnCrRLK1L1_5 as a key positive regulator of resistance to S. sclerotiorum, potentially acting through suppression of host cell death. The study highlights the potential for manipulating the CrRLK1L family to improve disease resistance in Brassica crops. Further studies are needed to elucidate the exact molecular function of BnCrRLK1L1_5 and its homologous genes, especially BnCrRLK1L1_4, which regulates defense response to S. sclerotiorum inoculation in B. napus. Supplementary Information Supplementary Material 1. Supplementary Material 2. Acknowledgements Not applicable. Abbreviations Genome-wide association studies Receptor-like kinase Rapid alkalinization factor Reactive oxygen species Ppattern recognition receptors Single nucleotide polymorphism Potato dextrose agar Minimum allele frequency Mixed linear model General linear model General feature format Protein-protein interaction Gene ontology Transcripts per Million Authors’ contributions T.F. and L.X. wrote the main manuscript text, T.F. prepared the figures. T.F., C.Z., R.Z., J.L., Z.B., and J.H. performed the experiments and analyzed the data. F.L., L.R., Y.L., C.T., L.L., and S.L. contributed to project administration and supervision. All authors reviewed the manuscript. Funding This work was supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China (2023YFF1000700), the Agricultural Science and Technology Innovation Program (ASTIP) (CAAS-CSIAF-202402), and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (32370693). Data availability The datasets generated and/or analysed during the current study are available on request. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate Not applicable. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1. Supplementary Material 2. Data Availability Statement The datasets generated and/or analysed during the current study are available on request.