Unanswered Questions About Microscopic Hematuria With Tubulopathy Authors: Guy H. Neild, D. Deren Oygar, Ahmet Behlul, Salahi Ataçi, Meral Yükseliş, Simge Özadalı, Fezile Ozdemir, Hasan Hüseyin Kazan, Daniel P. Gale, Cemal Gurkan Published: 2026 To the Editor: We read with great interest that Riella et al.1 found pathogenic heterozygous variants of COL4A3, COL4A4, or COL4A5 in only a third of their US cohort with clinical features of thin glomerular basement membrane glomerular disease. Their results resonate with accumulating observations of kidney diseases in Cyprus. We have reported predicted-pathogenic COL4A variants in just 7 of 55 families (13%) with an apparent dominant inheritance pattern of chronic kidney disease.2 This concurs with another report from Cyprus in which only 28% of microscopic hematuria families carried pathogenic COL4 variants.3 Reviewing the detailed clinical features in a Cyprus cohort of 20 families without overt COL4 mutations, each with multiple affected members, we find that microscopic hematuria was detected at least once in 76% of affected individuals and hypertension was universal and easily controlled with 1 to 2 drugs. Little or no proteinuria (< 1 g/d) was typical in chronic kidney disease grades 1 to 3, and chronic kidney disease 5 occurred in a quarter of those aged >50 years at a median of 62.8 (range: 36−86) years. Therefore, these families have features of both glomerular and tubular disease and resemble so-called “hypertensive nephropathy.” Furthermore, pathogenic variants in other (non-COL4) Mendelian glomerulopathy genes (e.g., WT1, INF2, PAX2, etc.) are also absent in these families. In addition, they do not carry mutations in autosomal dominant tubulopathy genes, including UMOD and HNF1B. However, approximately half of these affected family members carry 1 of 3 common missense variants (COL4A4: p.G545A and p. G999E, and COL4A3: p.G43R). Although these are not predicted to be overtly pathogenic, one can speculate that they somehow predispose to the phenotype; COL4 genes are expressed in a subset of tubules, as well as in glomeruli.4 Other, yet-to-be defined, genomic factors may be operative, as well as modifying environmental “hits” such as diabetes mellitus, which is common in Cyprus.