Exploring the matrilineal ancestry of swamp buffaloes ( Bubalus bubalis ) in Sijunjung Regency, West Sumatra, through partial cytochrome-b sequencing Authors: Muhammad Ridho, Muhammad Cahyadi, Ahmad Pramono, Widya Pintaka Bayu Putra, Hartati Hartati, Eko Handiwirawan, Aprisal Aprisal, Afdal Yulius, Rasiravathanahalli Kaveriyappan Govindarajan, Muhammad Indra Maulana Published: 2025 ABSTRACT Background:Buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis) are a significant livestock in Indonesia, with approximately 36% (201,060 heads) of their breeding populations located on Sumatera Island, including Sijunjung Regency.Aim:This study aimed to ascertain the matrilineal lineage of swamp buffaloes in Sijunjung Regency, Indonesia, using the mitochondrial cytochrome b (Cyt-b) region.Methods:Blood samples were obtained from 23 adult female swamp buffaloes for DNA extraction and analysis. A total of 906 bp of bubaline Cyt-b amplicons was amplified for forward sequencing. Six bioinformatics programs (BioEdit, DNAsp, MEGA, STRUCTURE, BEAST, and R) were used for sequence alignment, haplotype diversity estimation, phylogenetic tree construction, pairwise genetic distance calculations, and genetic admixture analysis.Results:Seventeen mutation sites were identified in the Cyt-b region. Consequently, four haplotypes (H) of Cyt-b were identified: H1 (56%), H2 (22%), H3 (17%), and H4 (5%). The haplotype diversity (Hd) and nucleotide diversity (pi) for the partial Cyt-b analyzed were 0.645 ± 0.081 and 0.003 ± 0.001, respectively. Phylogenetic tree analysis indicated that the swamp buffaloes in Sijunjung Regency were classified within Haplogroup 1 and exhibited close genetic ties to buffaloes from South Asia (Bangladesh), Southeast Asia (Thailand, Laos, Vietnam, Philippines), and East Asia (Taiwan, China). No evidence of genetic introgression from Indian and Pakistani buffaloes was found in the studied population.Conclusion:The matrilineal origin of buffaloes in Sijunjung Regency may be traced back to the southeastern Chinese buffalo (Lineage A) via two migration routes: the land-bridge (China - IndoChina - Malaya Peninsula - Sumatra) and the insular pathway (China - Taiwan - Philippines - Borneo - Sumatra). Introduction Buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) is a significant livestock species in Indonesia, which is used for both draught work and meat and milk production. In 2024, the buffalo population in Indonesia was recorded at 556,794 heads, with a total carcass production of 17,361.50 tons (Kementan, 2024). Currently, the Indonesian Ministry of Agriculture has officially registered nine swamp buffalo breeds as AnGR, namely, Gayo, Simeulue, Kuntu, Pampangan, South Kalimantan Kalang, East Kalimantan Kalang, Toraya, Moa, and Sumbawa (Prihandini et al., 2023). Additionally, the riverine buffalo breed Silangit has also been recognized as an AnGR in Indonesia. Among these, four buffalo breeds (Gayo, Simeulue, Kuntu, Pampangan) are bred on Sumatra Island. West Sumatra Province, on Sumatra Island, has a swamp buffalo population of 30,913 heads as of 2023. Sijunjung Regency is one of the regions in West Sumatra where buffalo breeding occurs, although it is experiencing a decline in population (Rias et al., 2020; Syaiful et al., 2020). Generally, female swamp buffaloes aged 6 years in Sijunjung Regency have an average body length of 109.50 ± 3.25 cm, a chest girth of 180.04 ± 4.05 cm, a withers height of 116.70 ± 3.28 cm, a hip height of 115.00 ± 1.91 cm, a rump width of 44.10 ± 0.74 cm, and a body weight of 327.58 ± 17.61 kg (Jesti, 2019). As a local livestock species, studying the origin lineage of swamp buffalo in Sijunjung Regency for genetic conservation and future breeding programs. In mammals, the origin of maternal lineage can be predicted through the diversity of the cytochrome b (Cyt-b) region (Tobe et al., 2010). Cyt-b is a gene that plays a role in electron transport within the respiratory chain. It serves as a target for evolutionary analysis and species identification, which is particularly beneficial for comparing species within the same genus or family (Bruford et al.,2003). Besides, the Cyt-b gene has been used mostly for studying the evolution and genetic relationships of mammals, including buffalo (Yue et al.,2013; Sukri et al., 2014; Rusdin et al.,2020; Sun et al.,2020; Saputra et al.,2021). In this study, the partial sequences of Cyt-b were used to identify the substitution pattern and haplotype diversity of Indonesian swamp buffalo, which are important for the genetic inventory, buffalo preservation, and improvement of the genetic potency of the buffalo population in Indonesia. Materials and Methods Animals and the research site A total of 23 female swamp buffaloes were used for the study. These animals are kept by the farmers in the Villager Beeding Center at Jorong Koto Lamo Village, Muaro Takuang Urban Village, Kamang Baru District, Sijunjung Regency, West Sumatera Province of Indonesia (Fig. 1). This area is located at latitude 0˚ 18′ 43″–1˚ 41′ 46″ S and longitude 100˚ 37′ 40″–101˚ 30′ 52″ E with 500–1,000 m asl. In general, this place has 21˚C–37˚C of air temperature, 60%–100% of relative humidity, and 13.61 mm/d of rainfall. A swamp buffalo herd at Sijunjung Regency, West Sumatra Province, Indonesia. Management of the animals The swamp buffaloes in this study were managed by the farmers under an extensive management system. The buffaloes grazed around the river from the morning (08.00 am) in the evening (17.00 pm). In addition, Brachiaria decumbens is the most common field grass around the river. However, no concentrate was given to the buffalo herds. Natural mating was managed in the buffalo herds. Regular health examination and medical treatment were performed every month. DNA extraction and amplification A total of 23 blood samples of swamp buffalo were collected from jugular veins using venoject and vacutainer tubes containing ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid. DNA extraction was performed using the Genomic DNA Extraction Kit (Geneaid, Taiwan) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. In this study, approximately 21.26 µl/ng of DNA concentration (λ260/280) and 1.31 of DNA purity were obtained from the DNA extraction analysis. The Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) reaction was carried out at a total volume of 30 µl containing 9 µl of DNA template, 0.6 µl of each primer (10 pmol), 15 µl of PCR mastermix (Bioline, USA), and 4.8 µl of nuclease-free water. A primer pair of Forward: 5’-CAT TCA TTG ACC TCC CTG CT-3’and Reverse: 5’-GCC GGA ACA TCA TAC TTC GT-3’ (Rusdin et al.,2020) was used to amplify the bubaline Cyt-b region (GenBank: AY702618) along 906 bp from 14,579th–15,484thnucleotide. The PCR program was run with one cycle of pre-denaturation at 94˚C for 5 minutes, and followed by 37 cycles of denaturation at 94˚C at 30 seconds, annealing at 59.4˚C at 30 seconds, extension at 72˚C at 30 seconds, and final extension at 72˚C at 5 minutes. The DNA was visualized by electrophoresis at 100 V for 30 minutes using 1% agarose, which was stained with FluoroSafe DNA Staining (1st Base, Singapore) above a UV Transilluminator machine (UVITEC, UK). According to the primer pair used, 906 bp of amplification was successfully amplified using 1% agarose gel (Fig. 2). Amplicons of bubaline Cyt-b along 906 bp at 1% agarose gel. Line 1–9 = represented DNA samples; M = DNA ladder 100 bp. Sequencing and analysis of data A forward sequencing analysis was executed for each amplicon by Apical Scientific (Malaysia). Sequence alignment analysis was performed using the BioEdit package (Hall, 2011). The DnaSP package (Librado and Rozas, 2009) was used to obtain the haplotype diversity (Hd) and nucleotide diversity (pi) values. An Neighbor-Joining tree was constructed with the Tajima-Nei model (10,000 × bootstrap replications) using the MEGA package (Hall, 2013). Therefore, 60 sequence references of bubaline Cyt-b were included in the phylogenetic tree (Table 1). Subsequently, the STRUCTURE package (Earl and vonHoldt, 2012) was used to determine the genetic admixture of buffaloes. The HKY+G5+F model (Hasegawa et al., 1985) was chosen to estimate the genetic divergence time of Asian buffalo because it describes the substitution pattern the best based on the Find Best DNA/Protein Models tool (Nei and Kumar, 2000) in MEGA 11 (Tamura et al., 2021). Subsequently, the BEAST package (Bouckaert et al., 2019; Bouckaert, 2022) was used with the Strict Clock model (Douglas et al., 2021). Furthermore, a Calibrated Yule model (Heled and Drummond, 2012) was constructed to show clear diverging points of every included species. The posterior tree file generated by BEAST was summarized using TreeAnnotator (Heled and Bouckaert, 2013) to produce a maximum clade credibility tree, with mean node heights and posterior probabilities assigned to each clade. Subsequently, the summarized tree performance and convergence were evaluated using Tracer v1.7.2, confirming that the analysis achieved reliable sampling of the posterior with Effective Sample Size values well above 200 for all key parameters, including clock rate and tree topology. For the BEAST analysis result, we added stratigraphy information with R software version 4.4.2. Table 1.Sequence reference of bubaline Cyt-b region*.NoGenBankOriginReferenceNoGenBankOriginReference1JF946519Pakistan H1 Saif et al. (2012)31KR010168Vietnam H1 Zhang et al. (2016)2JF946520Pakistan H2 Saif et al. (2012)32KR010072Vietnam H2 Zhang et al. (2016)3JF946521Pakistan H3 Saif et al. (2012)33KR010076Vietnam H3 Zhang et al. (2016)4JF946522Pakistan H4 Saif et al. (2012)34KR010167Vietnam H4 Zhang et al. (2016)5JF946523Pakistan H5 Saif et al. (2012)35KR010104Vietnam H5 Zhang et al. (2016)6JF946524Pakistan H6 Saif et al. (2012)36KR010164Vietnam H6 Zhang et al. (2016)7FJ467720China H1 Lei et al. (2011)37KR010122Vietnam H7 Zhang et al. (2016)8FJ467715China H2 Lei et al. (2011)38KR010044Taiwan H1 Zhang et al. (2016)9FJ467648China H3 Lei et al. (2011)39KR010057Taiwan H2 Zhang et al. (2016)10FJ467649China H4 Lei et al. (2011)40KR010045Taiwan H3 Zhang et al. (2016)11FJ467658China H5 Lei et al. (2011)41KR009986Thailand H1 Zhang et al. (2016)12FJ467660China H6 Lei et al. (2011)42KR010032Thailand H2 Zhang et al. (2016)13FJ467678China H7 Lei et al. (2011)43KR009992Thailand H3 Zhang et al. (2016)14FJ467686China H8 Lei et al. (2011)44KR010003Thailand H4 Zhang et al. (2016)15FJ467700China H9 Lei et al. (2011)45KR009988Thailand H5 Zhang et al. (2016)16FJ467701China H10 Lei et al. (2011)46KR009947Nepal H1 Zhang et al. (2016)17FJ467709China H11 Lei et al. (2011)47KR009944Nepal H2 Zhang et al. (2016)18FJ467710China H12 Lei et al. (2011)48KR009848Laos H1 Zhang et al. (2016)19FJ467712China H13 Lei et al. (2011)49KR009858Laos H2 Zhang et al. (2016)20FJ467713China H14 Lei et al. (2011)50KR009849Laos H3 Zhang et al. (2016)21FJ467714China H15 Lei et al. (2011)51KR009082Bangladesh H1 Zhang et al. (2016)22FJ467722China H16 Lei et al. (2011)52KR009079Bangladesh H2 Zhang et al. (2016)23FJ467724China H17 Lei et al. (2011)53KR009069Bangladesh H3 Zhang et al. (2016)24FJ467726China H18 Lei et al. (2011)54KR009113Bangladesh H4 Zhang et al. (2016)25FJ467728China H19 Lei et al. (2011)55KR009116Bangladesh H5 Zhang et al. (2016)26FJ467730China H20 Lei et al. (2011)56OQ460476Philippine H1 Cailipan et al. (2023)27EF409940India H1 Kumar et al. (2007)57OQ460410Philippine H2 Cailipan et al. (2023)28EF409942India H2 Kumar et al. (2007)58OQ460454Philippine H3 Cailipan et al. (2023)29EF409941India H3 Kumar et al. (2007)59OQ460415Philippine H4 Cailipan et al. (2023)30EF409939India H4 Kumar et al. (2007)60OQ460419Philippine H5 Cailipan et al. (2023)*Haplotype groups of each sequence reference based on the method of Saputra et al. (2021). Sequence reference of bubaline Cyt-b region*. *Haplotype groups of each sequence reference based on the method of Saputra et al. (2021). Ethical approval This research was approved by the Animal Ethics Committee of the National Research and Innovation Agency (approval issue no: 150/KE.02/SK/07/2023). Results Haplotype diversity Seventeen polymorphic sites were identified within the partial Cyt-b region of the buffaloes examined, which exhibited four distinct haplotypes of sequence variation (Table 2). A total of 16 polymorphic sites were observed in the H4 animal, as indicated in Table 2. Mostly, mutation sites occurred in the H4 animal (15 sites). Therefore, the haplotype diversity (Hd) and nucleotide diversity (pi) values for the Cyt-b region in the studied animals were recorded as 0.645 ± 0.081 and 0.003 ± 0.001, respectively (Table 3). Furthermore, a positive value for Fu’s Fs statistic and a negative value for Tajima’s D test were found in the Cyt-b region of the buffaloes under investigation. Table 2.Mutation site detection in each haplotype of swamp buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis) at Sijunjung Regency, West Sumatra, Indonesia.Haplotype (GenBank) NNucleotide position (GenBank: AY702618.1)1111111111111111144444444444444444688888999999999995367880011122233452315707068167026H1 (LC878289)13CCACTATAAAGACTCTAH2 (LC878290)5CTACTATAAAGACTCTAH3 (LC878291)4TCACTATAAAGACTCTAH4 (LC878292)1TCGGATATTGAGGGAGTN = number of animals. Mutation site detection in each haplotype of swamp buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis) at Sijunjung Regency, West Sumatra, Indonesia. N = number of animals. Table 3.Genetic diversity in the partial Cyt-b region of swamp buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) at Sijunjung Regency, Indonesia.ParametersValueNumber of sequences23Number of sites838Number of polymorphic sites identified17Number of haplotypes identified4Haplotype diversity (Hd)0.645 ± 0.081Nucleotide diversity (pi)0.003 ± 0.001Fu’s Fs2.240Tajima’s D test−2.047 Genetic diversity in the partial Cyt-b region of swamp buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) at Sijunjung Regency, Indonesia. Phylogenetic tree and genetic admixture The phylogenetic tree analysis indicated that the Sijunjung buffaloes were categorized within the Haplogroup 1 cluster (Fig. 3). Overall, the Sijunjung buffaloes exhibited a genetic composition similar to that of buffaloes from China, the Southeast region, Taiwan, and the Philippines, as demonstrated by STRUCTURE analysis (Fig. 4). Nevertheless, the Asian wild buffaloes were classified within the Haplogroup 1 cluster, showing similarity to the Sijunjung buffaloes. Based on the sequence of the Cyt-b region, the Sijunjung buffaloes were related to Haplogroup 1 buffaloes from China (Fig. 5). However, the genetic flow of Haplogroup 3 buffalo was not detected among Southeast Asian buffaloes, including those from Sijunjung. Additionally, the frequency of Haplogroup 1 buffaloes in Taiwan and the Philippines was higher than that in Thailand and Vietnam. Neighbor-joining tree (10,000 × bootstrap replications) among Cyt-b haplotypes of swamp buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis) from Sijunjung Regency and Asia. The genetic admixture of the Cyt-b region in Asian buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis) is characterized in haplogroups 1 (blue and yellow), 2 (red) and 3 (green). Haplogroup map and genetic flow analysis of the Cyt-b haplogroup in Asian buffalo. Genetic divergence The genetic divergence analysis of Asian swamp buffaloes (Fig. 6) revealed that Haplotype 3 (riverine lineage) was an old cluster that existed during the early Calabrian period (1.8–0.8 mya). Haplotype 2 and Haplotype 1 were established during the last Calabrian period. Therefore, B. bubalis has been separated from Bubalus quarlesi since the last Gelasian period (2.6–1.80 mya). Interestingly, B. bubalis and Bubalus depressicornis have been separated since the middle of Tortonian (Neogene) period (11.6–7.2 mya). It can be predicted that the buffaloes migrated to the Sijunjung from 0.2 to 0.8 mya or during the middle of the Pleistocene period. Genetic divergence time of the Cyt-b haplogroup in Asian buffalo. Discussion The bubaline Cyt-b region in this study has several polymorphic sites. Rusdin et al. (2020) obtained nine polymorphic sites and 10 haplotypes for the Cyt-b region of Indonesian swamp buffaloes with a similar primer pair. However, Sukri et al. (2014) obtained 61 polymorphic sites and 16 haplotypes for Cyt-b region in Indonesian swamp buffaloes using a universal Cyt-b primer pair (L14841 and H15149). Sun et al. (2020) obtained 22–46 polymorphic sites in the Cyt-b region of Chinese swamp buffaloes with 9–6 haplotypes of sequence variation. Thus, the polymorphic sites in those buffaloes were found with a primer pair for 1,161 bp of amplicon length that is 15,617th–418th (circular) based on sequence reference (GenBank: AY702618.1). Subsequently, Zhang et al. (2016) identified 46 haplotypes and 59 polymorphic sites in the full Cyt-b region of the Chinese buffalo population. Several studies have obtained similar Hd and pi values in the bubaline Cyt-b region with this study. Sun et al. (2020) reported similar findings in swamp buffaloes in Southwest China and North IndoChina regions, with Hd and pi values of 0.697 ± 0.016 and 0.003 ± 0.006, respectively. However, Yue et al. (2013) obtained a Hd value of 0.663 ± 0.101 for buffalo in Henan-China and a pi value of 0.003 ± 0.002 for buffalo in Southwestern China, which is similar to the present study. Furthermore, Zhang et al. (2016) reported similar results in the Cyt-b region of the Chinese buffalo population with the Hd and pi values of 0.637 and 0.003, respectively. The Hd value for the Cyt-b region in Indonesian buffalo was 0.659 (Rusdin et al.,2020), which is close to this study. According to Falconer and Mackay (1996), migration, selection, and inbreeding/crossbreeding can cause the genetic diversity of livestock. Nei and Kumar (2000) stated that the Hd > 0.50 is categorized as high and Hd < 0.50 as low. The pi value had three categories: low (0.01–0.04), moderate (0.05–0.07), and high (0.08–0.10). The negative value of Tajima’s D test in this study indicates an excess of low-frequency polymorphism relative to expectation (Ashfaq et al.,2014). Joshi et al. (2013) obtained a positive Fu’s Fs value in the D-loop region of Indian buffaloes, which is similar to the results of the present study. The positive Fu’s Fs statistic indicated that the investigated buffalo population was under a population bottleneck. Hence, the negative Tajima’s D value and positive Fu’s Fs value can indicate that the actual polymorphism frequency is lower than expected (Aminisarteshnizi et al.,2024). Yue et al. (2013) previously identified three lineages (haplogroups) in Chinese buffaloes: Lineage A (swamp buffalo from the southeastern region), Lineage B1 (swamp buffalo from the central region), and Lineage B2 (Southwestern region/riverine lineage). Thus, the Lineage A Chinese buffaloes had a close genetic relationship with the Philippine and Thailand populations. Lineage A swamp buffaloes are distributed in Vietnam, Laos, Thailand, Taiwan, the Philippines, China, and Indonesia. Lineage B swamp buffaloes are not distributed in Indonesia (Cailipan et al.,2023). This argument supports this current finding that no Haplogroup 2 (Lineage B1) was observed in the Sijunjung population of Indonesia. Genetically, the buffaloes in South Asia are typical of riverine buffalo, and those in China and Southeast Asia are typical of swamp buffalo (Saif et al.,2012). In this study, a specific Cyt-b sequence, namely H4, was found in one sample of Sijunjung buffalo. Four swamp buffalo breeds (Gayo, Simeulue, Kuntu, and Pampangan) were kept on Sumatra Island and could have migrated to Sijunjung by human trade activity. Hence, the H4 buffalo may represent different matrilineal lineages of Sumatran buffalo. During the Pleistocene era, buffaloes migrated to Indonesia through the Philippines and the Taiwan archipelagoes, known as the insular route (Tougard, 2001). Despite this, Bird et al. (2005) and De De Vos et al. (2007) argued that a migration route to Indonesia through ancient corridors via IndoChina and the Malaya Peninsula is known as the land-bridge route. Priyono et al. (2024) argued that the migration of buffalo through the insular route contains the various bubaline species in the Philippines (Bubalus mindorensis and Bubalus cebuensis) and the Wallacea region of Sulawesi (B. depressicornis and B. quarlesi). Borneo Island can be a part of the land-bridge and insular routes for buffalo migration. However, based on the mitochondrial D-loop region, the genetic admixture of the Bornean swamp buffaloes is related to the Fuling Chinese buffalo (Suhardi et al., 2023). The Cyt-b region is confirmed to cluster the Fuling buffalo in Lineage B2 (Yue et al., 2013). The haplogroup map in this study reveals a high frequency of buffalo with Haplogroup 1 in the insular route. Therefore, we argued that the haplotype 1 buffaloes can migrate across Borneo to Sumatra. In this study, swamp buffalo migrated to Sijunjung multiple times through the Indo-China region between 0.2 and 0.8 mya. This period coincides with the era of significant glacial-interglacial fluctuations during the Quaternary. In the early Pleistocene, around 2.6 mya, alterations in the Earth's orbital patterns, influenced by Milankovitch cycles, led to temperature variations on Earth every 41,000 years (41 My) to 800 My, subsequently shifting to a cycle of every 100 My. These temperature changes resulted in the formation and melting of ice sheets in the Northern Hemisphere approximately every 1,000 years (Bintanja and Van De Wal, 2008; Sosdian and Rosenthal, 2009; Woodruff, 2010). Such fluctuations have caused substantial changes in global sea levels, with Sundaland and Sahul experiencing the most pronounced changes (Hall, 2012). During the last glacial maximum around 0.015 Mya, a vast savanna corridor was estimated to have existed from Indo-China to Java (Heaney, 1991; Bird et al., 2005). During each glacial period, this savanna corridor facilitated the movement of buffalo across the Sunda Shelf from China to Sumatra Island via land bridges and insular routes during interglacial periods, until the Sunda Shelf began to submerge and some areas became fragmented. These periodic oscillations have resulted in extensive genetic maternal introgression in the contemporary population of swamp buffalo. These findings highlight the significance of Sijunjung buffaloes as a potential reservoir of unique genetic resources with, important implications for livestock conservation and genetic management. Study limitations Studies that investigate the origin of an organism using mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequences only reflect the evolutionary history of the maternal lineage and do not capture the entire biparental history of an organism. Despite this, genetic drift in small populations can lead to loss of mtDNA diversity, making it difficult to differentiate between individuals. Presently, next-generation sequencing can be performed to obtain the full mtDNA region of an organism and to accurately discriminate among individuals. Furthermore, in-depth study involving nuclear gene information with whole-genome sequencing can provide an accurate phylogenetic tree among individuals. Despite this, no Bornean buffalo samples in this study cannot completely explain the haplotype distribution in the migration routes. Conclusion The early investigation revealed that the swamp buffaloes in the Sijunjung Regency of Indonesia share a close genetic connection with the Chinese buffaloes from the Southeastern region (Lineage A), with genetic exchange occurring through land-bridge and insular pathways over the past 0.2–0.8 million years ago. A comprehensive study that includes various Indonesian swamp buffalo breeds is essential to accurately determine the origins of the swamp buffalo in Sijunjung.