Misattributed biospheric carbon sink to the Three-North Program in the Taklamakan Desert may lead to an impractical policy: A commentary Authors: Tian Gao, Jiaojun Zhu, Xiao Zheng, Lining Song, Yirong Sun, Dexiong Teng, Xinhua Zhou Published: 2026 Afforestation is a widely accepted practice to build terrestrial carbon sinks, but its applications are limited by climatic conditions (1, 2). Recently, Noor et al. (2026) demonstrate that ecological restoration (China’s Three-North Protective Forest Program, TNP) is transforming hyperarid environment into a carbon sink, providing an encouraging projection for carbon sink built up through afforestation, and extrapolating it to the entire Taklamakan Desert (3). However, given extremely limited effective water to plants in the region, potential ecohydrological processes derived from nonfield data could easily misinterpreted real field cases. Hydrothermal conditions are the fundamental constraint, but these are not adequately addressed by Noor et al. (3). Based on precipitation, wet season (Jul–Sep) and dry season (Dec–Feb) are defined for analysis. However, the Taklamakan Desert features hot, dry summers, and cold, dryer winters, with annual precipitation less than 80 mm, while annual potential evaporation more than 2,500 mm; i.e., this hyperarid region experiences a sole “dry season” year-round without moist seasons. The defined dry season is exactly the mid of winter (nongrowing season), with an average temperature of ca. −5 °C, when plant activity ceases at all. Therefore, the comparison of vegetation activity between the dry and wet seasons has no physiological basis. Additionally, given the huge summer evaporation potential (4, 5), the precipitation is apparently insufficient to support plant growth. Furthermore, the authors attributed the summer decline in atmospheric CO2 to regional afforestation. However, such declines are a well-known seasonality driven by widespread vegetation growth outside this desert across the Northern Hemisphere. Due to the low afforestation covers, vegetation contribution is locally limited. Observed 3-ppm (3) decline falls within 4 to 6 ppm seasonal fluctuations of background atmospheric CO2 (6, 7), making it baseless to be inferred as the results from the Taklamakan afforestation. Afforestation can build carbon sinks, but extrapolating its potential of 58.7 Mt CO2 y−1 into the entire Taklimakan Desert is unrealistic (Fig. 1). Regional evaporation leaves little rainfall available for summer plant uptake, and almost all of artificial vegetation relies on irrigation. Sustaining large-scale vegetation has to persistently pump groundwater. Hydrological evidence indicates a long-term decline of 8.6 mm y−1 in regional groundwater (8). Therefore, achieving carbon sinks would depend on large-scale water-diversion projects. Moreover, arid ecosystems exhibit low productivity and stability, and climate warming-induced drought may further cause vegetation decline and even shift the region to carbon sources. So, the carbon budget and afforestation cost-effectiveness should be reasonably evaluated. True-color Sentinel-2 satellite images of the Taklamakan Desert from June to August 2025. The green areas are vegetation, including both natural and planted vegetation. These areas are in the peripheral ecotone surrounding the desert, being very different from desert main area in climate and soil conditions, particularly in water effective availability. Note that afforestation was implemented in peripheral ecotone surrounding the Taklamakan Desert (Fig. 1), primarily aiming to control desertification expansion. Antidesertification is successful (9, 10), but the investment along with water resource consumption should not be overlooked. Extrapolating this investment over the entire desert is impractical. In practice, biospheric carbon sink potential derived from the ecotone absolutely cannot be extrapolated inward to the entire Taklamakan Desert, even outward to entire China. Pursuing maximal carbon sink capacity through afforestation in the Taklamakan Desert can mislead the public awareness of the intended objectives of TNP, and potentially lead to an impractical policy.