Effectiveness of drying in digestive endoscope reprocessing: Systematic review on residual droplets and microorganisms Authors: Chengyi Han, Yanyan Chen, Yan Chen, Yangyi Li, Xuesong Jiang, Qing Song Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Background and study aimsDespite endoscope reprocessing, residual droplets remain in digestive endoscope working channels. Inadequate drying of digestive endoscope working channels may promote microbial reproduction, increasing risk of infection among patients. This review was designed to summarize the current status of digestive endoscope and assess effectiveness of drying methods in preventing residual droplets and microorganisms in digestive endoscope.MethodsPubMed, Web of Science, and EMBASE up until 2025 were searched to identify eligible articles focused on methods of digestive endoscope drying and the status of endoscope drying. The revised JBI quality assessment tool was used to determine the quality of each included article by two independent reviewers.ResultsThis review included 16 articles; six focused on residual droplets, six evaluated microbial growth, and four assessed both residual droplets and microbial growth following different digestive endoscope drying methods. Compared to the single drying method, the combination of novel automated drying techniques and guideline-recommended conventional drying methods reported lower levels of residual fluid and microbial growth in endoscope channels.ConclusionsAutomated drying, particularly with drying cabinets, reduces residual moisture and microbial contamination on digestive endoscopes more effectively than manual drying, warranting its inclusion in standard reprocessing protocols. Introduction Despite rigorous implementation of endoscopic reprocessing guidelines 1 2 3 4 , endoscope-transmitted outbreaks caused by waterborne pathogens and multidrug-resistant organisms (MDROs) remain prevalent globally 5 6 . This persistent issue is closely linked to inherent characteristics of digestive endoscopes—indispensable tools for diagnosis and treatment of gastrointestinal diseases 7 . Their intricate internal lumens and specialized materials present substantial challenges to standardized cleaning, disinfection, and subsequent reprocessing steps. Inadequate drying not only facilitates microbial proliferation but also promotes biofilm formation via residual moisture, directly elevating risk of healthcare-associated infections (HAIs) 8 . Notably, several recent studies have focused on optimizing performance of endoscopic drying processes; however, discrepancies and ambiguities persist regarding efficacy of different drying methodologies for achieving effective drying of flexible endoscopic lumens—a critical step in preventing pathogen colonization. This underscores the urgent need to refine endoscopic drying protocols within reprocessing workflows. Although a prior systematic review 9 evaluated impact of drying on residual droplets, microbial contamination, and biofilm formation during gastrointestinal endoscope reprocessing, it failed to yield a robust consensus conclusion and meta-analysis due to the inclusion of limited studies. With growing emphasis on gastrointestinal endoscope-associated infection control, the drying step has attracted increasing attention, alongside emergence of various drying technologies 10 11 12 . However, stability and efficacy of these drying approaches remain to be further validated. Accordingly, this systematically review synthesizes the literature related to endoscopic drying to provide evidence-based support for optimization of drying procedures in endoscopic reprocessing and thereby mitigate the burden of associated HAIs. Methods Data source and searches Focusing on studies published in English until November 17, 2025, two researchers (CY.H. and YY.C.) independently conducted a systematic search in PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science by using a combination of search terms related to endoscope ("endoscop*" OR "colonoscop*" OR "rectoscop*" OR “endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography” OR “ERCP”) and dry ("dry" OR "drying"). We did not obtain gray literature or unpublished research to inform this manuscript. To complement our database, the reference lists of included articles were also searched. This study was conducted in accordance with the preferred reporting guidelines for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA) 13 . Study selection We included studies: 1) that reported the procedure for drying in endoscope reprocessing or the particular drying intervention methods; 2) that reported effectiveness of endoscope drying or data to calculate (residual droplets, microbial growth, and biofilm formation); and 3) prospective, retrospective, observational, comparative, or randomized studies. Where multiple articles reported the same investigation, the one giving more complete details or with the largest sample size was included, but when different aspects or subgroups of the same survey were separately reported in different articles, they were selected. We excluded studies that: 1) were reviews, editorials, guidelines, or letters to the editor; 2) were abstracts without full-text articles; 3) and that were case reports of related infections due to insufficient endoscope drying. After removing duplicates articles, the two researchers (CY.H. and YY.C.) independently evaluated the retrieved studies to identify those that were relevant. Disagreements were resolved by consensus or by discussion with a third researcher (Y.C.). Data extraction Information on first author, published year, study design, country, drying methods, measurement methods of outcome, sample size, and number of endoscopes with residual fluid and bacterial contamination was independently extracted by two reviewers (CY.H. and XS.J.) for each included study. Then, the data were analyzed and summarized, and inconsistent opinions were discussed with a third author (Y.C.) to reach an agreement. Quality assessment Two reviewers (CY.H. and Q.S.) evaluated the quality of the included studies using the revised Joanna Briggs Institute literature quality assessment tools 14 15 16 . The total score was categorized as high, moderate, and low quality, respectively. If reviewer scores differed, they discussed them until consensus was reached. Statistical analysis All potentially relevant studies were systematically managed using EndNote software. Given substantial heterogeneity in both endoscope drying protocols and outcome measurement methodologies across the included studies, a meta-analysis was not feasible in the review. Thus, this systematic review solely adopted a descriptive analytical approach. Results Literature search and study characteristics Of the 4,672 potentially relevant studies identified through the database search, 16 articles 10 11 12 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 were included in the review ( Fig. 1 ). Detailed characteristics of the eligible studies are presented in Table 1 . Geographically, eight studies were conducted in the United States, three in France, and one each in the Netherlands, Canada, Germany, and Algeria. Methodologically, among the 16 included studies, 12 were quasi-experimental studies, three were cross-sectional studies, and one was a randomized controlled trial (RCT), with sample sizes ranging from three to 560. Regarding outcome measures reported in the 16 reviewed articles, six focused on residual droplets, six evaluated microbial growth, and four assessed both residual droplets and microbial growth following different digestive endoscope drying methods. Flow diagram of study selection 13 Table 1 Characteristics of included studies First author (year)CountryStudy designIntervention methodsSample sizeOutcomes and measurementJBI scoreAER, automated endoscope reprocessor; FADS, forced-air drying system; JBI, Joanna Briggs Institute; PSI, pounds per square inch; SCHE, AS300 Hysis semi-automated endoscope cabinetOfstead (2024)United StatesQuasi-experimental study(1) Alcohol flush and a 3-minute air purge cycle (AER alcohol and air purge cycles)(2) 10-minute FADS cycle(1) 42(1) 42Drying (droplet detection cards)9Michael (2025)GermanyRandomized controlled trial study(1) Standard endoscope washer-disinfector(2) Shorter standard endoscope washer-disinfector and PlasmaTYPHOON(1) 30(2) 30 Residual fluid (laboratory scale) Bacterial contamination 9Kwakman (2023)NetherlandsQuasi-experimental study(1) Post-decontamination(2) Post-drying (PlasmaTYPHOON)(1) 280(2) 280Drying (Cobalt chloride paper tests and borescope inspections) Bacterial contamination9Nerandzic (2023)United StatesQuasi-experimental study(1) Alcohol flush(2) Forced air(1) 3(2) 3 P. aeruginosa 9Perumpail (2019)United StatesQuasi-experimental study(1) AER and standard storage cabinet(2) AER and automated drying and storage cabinet (1) 30 (2) 30 (1) 15 (2) 15 Residual fluid (laboratory scale) P. aeruginosa 9Yassin (2023)United StatesQuasi-experimental study(1) AER (alcohol flush and a 3-minute air flush)(2) AER (alcohol flush and a 10-minute air flush)(1) 77(2) 77Residual fluid (laboratory scale)moisture visually and with moisture detection paper9Ofstead (2018)United StatesCross-sectional studyAER (alcohol flushing and 1 min air flushing) and medical-grade forced air drying for 10 min45Residual fluid (test strips)6Barakat (2019)United StatesQuasi-experimental study(1) AER (alcohol flushing and 1 min air flushing) and Manual forced air drying for 10 min (2) AER (alcohol flushing and 1 min in air flushing) and automated drying for 5 min (3) AER (alcohol flushing and 1 min air flushing) and automated drying for 10 min (1) 5 (2) 5 (3) 5 Droplets9Thaker (2018)United StatesCross-sectional study(1) Manual forced-air drying at room temperature(2) Medical air for more than 2 min in each port97Moisture/fluid9Saliou (2015)FranceQuasi-experimental study(1) In a clean, dry, dedicated cupboard(2) In an AS300 Hysis SCHE(1) 60(2) 69Endoscope contamination levels (< 25 cfu)9Hassaine-Lahfa (2017)AlgeriaQuasi-experimental study(1) Without drying the material after sterilization(2) Drying endoscope channels with compressed air after sterilization(1) 100(2) 200Candida sp. isolates 9Nerandzic (2021)United StatesQuasi-experimental study(1) 15 PSI (simultaneous drying of all channels via adapters)(2) 15 PSI (independent drying of each channel via a rubber-tipped nozzle)3Residual fluid (inspections)9Grandval (2013)FranceQuasi-experimental study(1) Storage cabinets for heat-sensitive endoscopes(2) Clean, dry, dedicated cupboard without morning disinfection(3) Clean, dry, dedicated cupboard with morning disinfection(1) 41(2) 41(3) 41Endoscope contamination levels9Pineau (2008)FranceQuasi-experimental study(1) inside the drying cabinet(2) outside the drying cabinet(1) 15(2)15Bacterial contamination9Alfa (1991)CanadaQuasi-experimental study (1) AER (2) AER and 10 min of drying (1) 15(2) 19Bacterial contamination9Barakat (2018)United StatesCross-sectional studyAlcohol flush and forced air drying for 10 min97Droplets8 Table 1 Characteristics of included studies Residual fluid Table 2 synthesizes efficacy of various drying methodologies in eliminating residual droplets and fluid within endoscopic instrument channels. Nine peer-reviewed studies 10 12 22 23 24 25 26 28 29 have documented persistence of residual droplets in endoscopes after strict standard reprocessing protocols. Table 2 Evaluation of effects of different drying methods on residual fluid in endoscopic working channels. First author (year)Drying methodsMeasurement of residual fluidEndoscopy of residual fluid (n1)Total endoscopy (n)n1/n (%)AER, automated endoscope reprocessor; FADS, forced-air drying system.Ofstead (2024)AER (Alcohol flush and a 3-minute air purge cycle)Droplet detection cards4242100AER and 10-minute FADS (Turbulent Fluid Flow Dryer) cycle0420Michael (2025)Standard endoscope washer-disinfectorLaboratory scale273090Shorter standard endoscope washer-disinfector and PlasmaTYPHOON (fast automated drying method)0300Kwakman (2023)Post-decontaminationCobalt chloride paper tests and borescope inspectionsNot done140-Post-drying (PlasmaTYPHOON)01400Perumpail (2019)AER and Standard storage cabinetCobalt chloride paper3030100AER and Automated drying and storage cabinet0300Yassin (2023)AER (alcohol flush and a 3-minute air flush)Visual inspection, manual detection (tactile sensation on gloved hand) of droplets, and cobalt chloride moisture detection paper7777100AER (alcohol flush and a 10-minute air flush)377748.05Ofstead (2018)AER (alcohol flushing and 1-min air flushing) and medical-grade forced air drying for 10 minTest strips224549Barakat (2019)AER (alcohol flushing and 1 min air flushing) and manual forced air drying for 10 minSteriCam borescope55100AER (alcohol flushing and 1min in air flushing) and automated drying for 5 min4580AER (alcohol flushing and 1 min air flushing) and automated drying for 10 min050Thaker (2018)Manual forced-air drying at room temperature (Medical air for more than 2 min in each port)SteriCam Inspection Scope8978.25Barakat (2018)Alcohol flush and forced air drying for 10 minSteriCam borescope296846.2 Table 2 Evaluation of effects of different drying methods on residual fluid in endoscopic working channels. Ofstead et al. 29 compared three endoscopic drying strategies-standard automated endoscope reprocessor (AER) alcohol flush/air purge cycles and a dedicated forced-air drying system (FADS), finding that 100% of endoscopes (42/42) remained wet post-AER, whereas FADS eliminated all residual fluid (100% dry, 42/42), as confirmed by droplet detection cards, visual inspection, and borescopy; these results were replicated in subsequent independent trials. A novel drying method (ND), which incorporates both PlasmaTYPHOON system and shortened endoscope washer-disinfector processing (EWD), was shown to result in significantly fewer residual water droplets in endoscope channels compared with standard EWD (90% dry vs. 0% dry, respectively); drying time for ND was significantly shorter than that for EWD in endoscope channels (5 min 59 s vs. 16 min 4 s) 10 . Following the 2.5-minute drying cycle of the PlasmaTYPHOON system, no retained fluid was detected in any of the 140 evaluated endoscopes, as confirmed by both cobalt chloride paper testing and borescopic inspection 12 . Storage cabinet type also significantly impacted residual moisture: Standard storage cabinets were associated with persistent internal fluid at 24 hours post-processing, whereas automated drying and storage cabinets achieved complete dryness within 1 hour 26 . Despite adjunctive use of an alcohol flush and a standard drying cycle, all stripped endoscopes remained grossly wet following high-level disinfection with a 3-minute air flush 28 . In stark contrast, a prolonged 10-minute air flush successfully dried biopsy/suction channels but failed to eliminate moisture from air/water channels, with 37 of 77 evaluated endoscopes (48.1%) still exhibiting evidence of retained moisture 28 . In a separate investigation, residual fluid was observed inside 22 of 45 endoscope channels (49%) following 24 to 48 hours of storage; these endoscopes had been processed using AER followed by 10 minutes of medical-grade forced-air drying 23 . Experimental findings further demonstrated that, when five endoscope tips were evaluated immediately after compressed air drying, manual drying resulted in a significantly higher number of visible fluid droplets (4.55 ± 6.14 droplets) compared with automated device-assisted drying for either 5 minutes (0.83 ± 1.29 droplets; P = 0.007) or 10 minutes (0 ± 0 droplets; P = 0.001) 25 . Notably, no droplets were detected on any endoscope tip following 72 hours of storage, regardless of which of the three drying methods was initially employed 25 . In a single-center study, Thaker et al. 24 performed 97 evaluations on 59 endoscopes at their institutional facility. Specifically, when gastroscopes and colonoscopes were stored without additional compressed air drying, visible water droplets were detected in eight of 23 gastrointestinal endoscope assessments (35%). In contrast, no such droplets were observed following implementation of a minimum of 2 minutes of additional compressed air drying prior to storage. Furthermore, residual droplets were identified on three endoscopes that had been stored vertically in a ventilated cabinet for a 30-hour period 24 . Small residual fluid droplets were visualized in working channels of 29 of 68 endoscopes (42.6%) following alcohol flushing and 10-minute forced-air drying 22 . Microbial contamination Table 3 synthesizes impacts of diverse drying methodologies on microbial contamination within endoscopic instrument channels. Ten published studies have documented persistent microbial contamination in endoscopes after standard reprocessing protocols 10 12 17 18 19 20 21 23 26 27 . Specifically, ND resulted in significantly lower bacterial contamination rates in endoscope channels than EWD following 14 days of storage (47% vs. 20%, respectively) 10 . In one investigation, 121 of 140 (86.4%; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 81%-92%) channel samples collected immediately post-decontamination exhibited growth of inoculated microorganisms; this rate decreased substantially to 47 of 140 (33.6%; 95% CI 26%-41%) in samples obtained after drying 12 . Forced-air drying was found to markedly reduce baseline contamination levels and suppress subsequent microbial proliferation in non-alcohol-flushed endoscope channels following 48 hours of ambient storage 27 . Furthermore, flushing with 30% to 70% isopropyl alcohol (IPA) exhibited superior antimicrobial efficacy against Pseudomonas aeruginosa , with no microbial regrowth detected; this contrasted sharply with flushing using sterile diluent, which was associated with a 4 log 10 colony-forming units (CFU) rebound in bacterial load. For air/water channels, complete visual dryness was sufficient to eliminate P. aeruginosa regrowth and no additional benefit was observed with extended forced-air drying durations 27 . Additional evidence indicated a positive relationship between IPA concentration and drying time in suction/instrument channel systems; specifically, mean drying time with 70% IPA was three times longer than that with water 27 . Table 3 Evaluation of effects of different drying methods on microorganisms in endoscopic working channels. First author (year)Intervention methodsMeasurement of outcomesEndoscopy of bacterial contamination (n1)Total endoscopy (n)n1/n (%)AER, automated endoscope reprocessor; SCHE, AS300 Hysis semi-automated endoscope cabinet.Michae (2025)Standard endoscope washer-disinfectorBacterial contamination143046.67Shorter standard endoscope washer-disinfector and PlasmaTYPHOON (fast automated drying method)63020Kwakman (2023)Post-decontaminationBacterial contamination12114086.43Post-drying (PlasmaTYPHOON)4714033.57Nerandzic (2023)Alcohol flush P. aeruginosa 030Forced air33100Perumpail (2019)AER and Standard storage cabinet P. aeruginosa 1515100AER and Automated drying and storage cabinet1156.67Ofstead (2018)AER (alcohol flushing and 1 min air flushing) and medical-grade forced air drying for 10 minBacterial contamination324571.11Saliou (2015)Clean, dry, dedicated cupboardBacterial contamination276045AS300 Hysis SCHE96913.04Hassaine-Lahfa (2017)Without drying the material after sterilizationCandida sp. isolates 2510025Drying the endoscope’s channels with compressed air after sterilization92004.5Grandval (2013)Storage cabinets for heat-sensitive endoscopesBacterial contamination0410Clean, dry, dedicated cupboard without morning disinfection54112.2Clean, dry, dedicated cupboard with morning disinfection54112.2Pineau (2008)Outside the drying cabinetBacterial contamination1515100Inside the drying cabinet1515100Alfa (1991)AERBacterial contamination61540AER and additional drying for 10 min0190 Table 3 Evaluation of effects of different drying methods on microorganisms in endoscopic working channels. With respect to storage cabinet type, standard cabinets supported mean hourly microbial growth rates of 8.1×10 6 , 8.3×10 6 , and 7.0×10 6 CFU for bronchoscopes, colonoscopes, and duodenoscopes, respectively 26 . In stark contrast, automated cabinets yielded mean hourly net reductions in CFUs of −28.4 ( P = 0.02), −38.5 ( P = 0.01), and −200.2 ( P = 0.02) for the same three endoscope types 26 . Notably, no microorganisms were recovered from bronchoscopes or colonoscopes following 31 days of storage in automated cabinets, with only a single CFU detected from duodenoscopes under identical conditions. In a multicenter study across three American hospitals, microbial growth was detected in 32 of 45 endoscopes (71%) following 24 to 48 hours of storage; these endoscopes had been processed using AER (incorporating alcohol flushing and 1-minute air flushing) followed by 10 minutes of medical-grade forced-air drying 23 . Regarding storage environment efficacy, 45.0% (27/60) of programmed microbiological tests on gastrointestinal endoscopes stored in clean, dry, dedicated cupboards showed contamination levels exceeding the target threshold, compared with only 13% of tests (9/69) on endoscopes stored in AS300 Hysis semi-automated endoscope cabinets (SCHE) 20 . A separate study identified 34 strains of Candida sp., accounting for 11.33% of the total samples analyzed; the number of isolated strains decreased significantly in the second and third years (9/200 samples) following implementation of post-sterilization compressed air drying of endoscope channels, compared with the first year (25/100 samples) when this step was not performed 21 . After 72 hours of storage, 100% of 41 endoscopes sampled from SCHE maintained contamination levels consistent with the target (< 5 CFUs per endoscope), whereas only 88% of endoscopes stored in cupboards (with or without daily morning disinfection) met this standard 19 . Consistent with these findings, endoscopes stored in dedicated drying and storage cabinets exhibited microbial contamination levels that were not only lower than the initial bacterial inoculum but also continued to decrease substantially over time 18 . In contrast, endoscopes stored outside of such dedicated cabinets maintained stable microbial counts or even demonstrated significant increases. Finally, following 48 hours of post-disinfection storage, 40% of duodenoscopes (6/15) processed with standard AER were found to be contaminated; no contaminated duodenoscopes were observed in the group processed with AER followed by an additional 10 minutes of forced-air drying 17 . Discussion This review revealed that digestive endoscopes still had residual droplets and microbial growth after routine reprocessing and drying from existing guidelines, but we found that automatic AER plus automatic drying device or automated drying and storage cabinet were obviously better than AER plus manual drying and use of a drying cabinet once again reduced residue of droplets and growth of microorganisms. Drying constitutes an indispensable step in the reprocessing workflow for digestive endoscopes and its efficacy is closely correlated with multiple variables—most notably, type of drying equipment employed and duration of the drying cycle. Inadequate drying of endoscopes creates a favorable microenvironment for microbial colonization and proliferation, thereby elevating risk of iatrogenic cross-infection among patients 30 . Our review revealed that single drying methods could not arrive desired drying effectiveness for endoscope, but an additional new drying device (automatic technique) or automated drying and storage cabinet were good drying means. Four studies 10 26 28 29 indicated that all the digestive endoscopes still had residual fluid observed in the channel after AER. Two studies 10 12 reported that additional PlasmaTYPHOON (laminar and turbulent airflows) could achieve no residual fluid in endoscopes channel and another study also observed a similar situation using an additional 10-minute FADS (Turbulent Fluid Flow Dryer) 29 and automated drying and storage cabinet 26 after routine reprocessing and drying. One study indicated that AER plus automatic drying for 5 or 10 minutes was significantly better than AER plus manual drying for 10 minutes in preventing residual droplets 25 . Six published studies 10 12 17 19 20 26 reported lower microbial contamination in an additional new drying device (automatic technique) or automated drying and storage cabinet compared with standard reprocessing protocols. Two studies 10 12 were used to reported additional PlasmaTYPHOON following routine reprocessing and drying and four studies were applied to another additional drying device 17 19 20 26 , whereas one study 23 reported 71.11% microbial contamination in AER plus drying for 10 minutes. High microbial growth is likely due to the more stringent flush-brush-flush method used to obtain and process samples in this study because flush-only methods are considered inadequate 31 32 . Alcohol flush has the potential to reduce endoscope contamination and use of wet contaminated endoscopes and, therefore, risk of patient infection 27 . However, alcohol might increase drying time due to potentially fixed effects 33 34 , although flushing is performed with reduced concentrations. Thus, new additional drying techniques are beneficial for endoscopic drying. This review synthesizes the current evidence base pertaining to drying methodologies for digestive endoscopes and evaluates their efficacy in mitigating residual moisture and inhibiting microbial persistence—ultimately aiming to provide empirical support for optimization of drying protocols in gastrointestinal endoscopy practice. Several potential limitations of this systematic review warrant acknowledgment. The review incorporated a heterogeneous study design mix, encompassing RCTs, quasi-experimental studies, and cross-sectional studies. Although RCTs represent the gold standard for evaluating intervention efficacy, quasi-experimental and cross-sectional designs are inherently prone to confounding biases, which may constrain causal inferences that can be drawn from the synthesized data. Furthermore, meta-analysis was deemed infeasible for this review, owing to substantial heterogeneity across included studies—specifically, marked variability in drying methodologies tested and outcome metrics used to quantify drying efficacy. In addition, the review did not analyze the pressure factor of forced-air drying, despite observations that higher pressure tended to correlate with shorter average drying times for flexible endoscopes 11 ; this gap stems from the paucity of dedicated studies investigating the impact of pressure on drying efficacy. Conclusions Routine reprocessing and drying are insufficient to eliminate residual moisture and microbial contamination from digestive endoscopes. Automated drying—using either an integrated automatic drying device or a dedicated drying cabinet—is markedly more effective than manual drying, with drying cabinets achieving the greatest reduction. These findings support incorporating automated drying into standard endoscope reprocessing protocols.