School-Based Educational Interventions for Improving Knowledge of Back Health, Ergonomics and Postural Behaviour of School Children Aged 4-18 Years: A Best Evidence Systematic Review Authors: Josette Bettany-Saltikov, Robert Mcsherry, Roongtip Duangkaew, Gokulakannan Kandasamy, Garikoitz Aristegui Racero, Paul van Schaik, Julie Hogg, Mona Salman, Fiona McPherson Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundMusculoskeletal and back health of school aged children is a global health problem, with evidence that the prevalence of these problems is increasing. Many modern school systems require children to assume sedentary positions for extended periods of time, and the increasing use of classroom-based technology adds to the number of hours seated. With the incidence of musculoskeletal pain reported not only in adult populations but increasingly in young people, an understanding of spinal health and posture may be essential for students.ObjectivesThe main objective for conducting this review was to conduct a best evidence systematic review. This means we only included the highest quality papers on the effectiveness of school-based education programs on back health for improving knowledge of back health, ergonomics and postural behaviour in school children aged 4-18 years.Search MethodsWe searched the following 21 electronic databases from inception till the 20th January 2023: AMED (EBSCOhost), APA PsycINFO (EBSCOhost), Best Evidence Medical Education (BEME) (EBSCOhost), British Education Index (EBSCOhost), CINAHL (EBSCOhost), Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (Wiley), EMBASE (Ovid), ERIC (EBSCOhost), EThOS (British Library), Europe PMC (Europepmc.org), GoogleScholar. Health Technology Assessment (HTA) (INAHTA), Health Management Information Consortium (HMIC) (Ovid), MEDLINE (EBSCOhost), PEDro (pedro.org.au), ProQuest Dissertations & Theses (Proquest), ProQuest Nursing and Allied Health Database (ProQuest), SCOPUS (Elsevier), SportDISCUS (EBSCOhost), Web of Science (Arts and Humanities Citation Index, Science Citation Index Expanded, Social Sciences Citation Index, Emerging Sources Citation Index, Conference Proceedings Citation Index – Science, Conference Proceedings Citation Index – Social Sciences and Humanities; Clarivate), ZEToC (British Library). Selection Criteria PopulationThe population eligible for the review included all children and young people between 4 and 18 years of age, attending school. Exclusion criteria: Children under 4 years of age and adults over 18 years of age; chronic disease or conditions or co-morbidities.InterventionStudies needed to meet the following criteria to be included: any formal educational school-based programme that included back health, ergonomics and postural behaviour that was designed to support the educational performance of students’ knowledge of posture and ergonomics within an educational establishment. We excluded physical activity or exercise only interventions.ComparisonIncluded studies were required to have a control group that represented either business-as-usual (no intervention), or a wait-list design.OutcomesWe included studies that examined back care knowledge, knowledge of back care ergonomics, back care behaviours and knowledge of back posture.Types of Research DesignThis was a Best Evidence Systematic Review and only research papers scoring a “good” or “excellent “on the Downs and Black (1998) risk-of-bias form were included. The following research designs were included: randomised controlled trials (RCTs), cluster randomised controlled trials (CRCT) and quasi-randomised controlled trials (QRCTs). We included prospective non-randomised studies (NRSs) with a control group because it was anticipated that very few RCTs would be found. Controlled before-after studies (CBAs), interrupted time series (ITS) studies as well as controlled studies that were non-randomised and included a pre- and post-test were also eligible for inclusion.Data Collection and AnalysisTitles and abstracts were screened in duplicate. Full texts of studies with seemingly relevant abstracts were retrieved and assessed for eligibility using the pre-specified inclusion criteria. Full texts were also screened in duplicate. Studies were classified as either included or excluded. Two authors independently extracted data from relevant studies.Main Results1,327 potentially relevant papers were found through the searches of the academic databases, while no studies were identified through searches of grey literature and reference lists. After removing 1,256 articles which did not meet the inclusion criteria, 71 studies remained for screening. 37 articles were excluded based on screening the titles and abstracts. This left 34 articles for further examination of full texts. After the full texts had been read, these 34 studies continued to the quality assessment/risk of bias stage using the Downs and Black ROB form. Only two papers scored 20 or over (i.e. good or excellent) and were included in this systematic review. As the outcomes of the two studies differed, it was not possible to conduct a meta-analysis. Therefore, a narrative synthesis was conducted. Each of these studies showed statistically significant improvements on knowledge and behaviour, in the short term (3-8 months) though these need to be interpreted in light of concerns regarding risk of bias.Authors ConclusionsDespite the comprehensive search of electronic databases, grey literature, hand searching, journals and reference lists of included studies, we only found two ‘good’ quality studies (scoring 20-25). No studies achieved an “excellent” score, that provided “excellent” evidence, on the effectiveness of school-based education programs on back health for improving knowledge of back health, ergonomics and postural behaviour in school children aged 4-18 years. This highlights the urgent need for high-quality studies to be conducted to assess the effects of these programmes due to the importance of ergonomics and posture in the activities of daily living of school children.Keywords: back health, educational intervention, school based, knowledge of back health, knowledge of ergonomics, knowledge of postural behaviour, best evidence, systematic review Background Description of the Problem, Condition, or Issue Musculoskeletal and back Health of school aged children is a global health problem with evidence that the prevalence of these problems is increasing (Pavithra & Anand, 2013; Weiguang et al., 2011). As Dugan (2018) states that “many modern school systems require children to assume sedentary positions for extended periods of time, and the increasing use of classroom-based technology adds to the number of hours seated. With the incidence of musculoskeletal pain reported not only in adult populations but increasingly in young people, an understanding of spinal health and posture may be essential for students. Posture is the attitude assumed by the body either when it is stationary or when it is moving. It is attained because of the coordinated action of various muscles working to maintain stability (Dena, 1957). Poor posture is the result of musculoskeletal distortion in the neck and lower and upper back. Most people think of poor posture as simply slumping over, but this is not necessarily the case. Further due to the variety of body types, incorrect posture differs from person to person. One person’s proper posture can be an incorrect posture for someone else and vice versa. Posture holds the body upright against gravity while standing, sitting or lying down. The ideal “normal” erect posture is one in which the line of gravity (the vertical line drawn through the body’s centre of gravity) runs when viewed from each side. In layman`s terms this means that good posture (Carolyn et al., 2017) is the position which is attained when the joints are not bent or twisted, and the spine is aligned. Maintaining good posture involves training one`s body to move and function where the least strain is placed on the bones, joints and soft tissues. Poor posture can result in numerous health problems such as tight neck muscles, muscle soreness, pain (shoulder, neck and back and arms), headaches, poor circulation, physical and mental stress as well as poor sleep. To prevent the health problems mentioned above, it is important to “fit” any work or school environment to the user’s needs (correct ergonomics) (Pavithra & Anand, 2013). Ergonomics aims to increase efficiency and productivity by reducing discomfort. A sound understanding of ergonomics by students can help prevent school place injuries by adjusting the tools (for example desk, chair, computer screen) to the user, putting an emphasis on proper posture to reduce the impact of repetitive movements or the potential for straining muscles and joints. The use of computers together with the rapidly changing technology in modern schools has greatly increased the need for ergonomics. Desks, chairs, monitors, keyboards and lighting all need to be assessed when creating a work or school space, whether it is at the office, at home or at school. It is important to study ergonomics because faulty ergonomics has been known to cause musculoskeletal aches and pains (Sellschop et al., 2018). Ergonomic assessment, especially in schoolchildren, is gaining ground as the activities and the postures used to perform those activities could be one of the reasons for the high prevalence of pain in this young population, which may lead to chronic pain in adulthood (Pavithra & Anand, 2013; Weiguang et al., 2011). The International Association for the Study of Pain defines pain as “an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with real or potential tissue injury or described as caused by this injury or whose presence is revealed by visible and/or audible behaviour manifestations”. Recent population-based studies conducted in a range of countries have reported point, one-year, and lifetime prevalence rates of back pain in adult populations of up to 52%, 84%, and 91%, respectively (Steele et al., 2006). However, spinal pain is an issue across the lifespan, not just in adulthood. Cross-sectional surveys conducted in different countries with children and adolescents between the ages of 8 and 16 years of age variably report one-month prevalence rates of up to 39%, and lifetime prevalence rates of back pain up to 69.3% (Kovacs Francisco et al., 2003; Niels et al., 2001; Watson Kath et al., 2002). Although posture as well as movement may not appear to be directly relevant in the context of schooling, in western Europe most courses are either dedicated to improving the brain or the body (Dugan, 2018). Within school settings, the latter are usually considered to be secondary to the former. As Dugan (2018) states “There is, evidence to suggest that the body and brain are inextricably linked, and that physical health is valuable if not essential for educational pursuits; this can be demonstrated by links between body and memory retrieval (e.g. Katinka et al., 2005), logical concept acquisition (Fischer & Brugger, 2011) as well as emotional and personality factors (e.g. Hallee & Stephen, 2004), all of which come into play in the classroom”. The causes of back pain in youth are challenging and difficult to diagnose and as briefly mentioned above have been theorised to include; mechanical back shape, incorrect posture while using technology (game consoles, computers, Gameboys, iPad, iPhone) and carrying heavy back packs, improper lifting techniques, and incorrect posture during prolonged sitting and standing, together with a lack of back care knowledge and the lack of opportunity to move around frequently (in standing, sitting). These issues may be exacerbated by the educational environment because of inadequate or unavailable school lockers, ill-fitting school furniture and the changing structure of the school day which provides fewer opportunities for movement (Bettany-Saltikov et al., 2008; Cardon et al., 2004; Feingold & Jacobs, 2002; Legg & Cruz, 2004; Sheldon, 1994). Dugan (2018) further suggests that because of the significance of the human body in learning, studies have looked at all the above causes that could potentially impact how students’ bodies function in educational settings. Interventions have also been conducted helping students discriminate between healthy and poor postures, reminding them to sit properly at their desks and computer workstations and modifying their physical habits and routines. Historically, educating children and youth about the importance of back health and posture was an important element of the physical education national curriculum in many countries but was overlooked during the 1980’s when heart health became a greater priority (Tinning, 2001). The high prevalence rates of back pain in children and adolescents, as well as the predictive value of adolescent spinal pain for spinal pain in adults, have caused several authors to advocate for, and implement, spinal health interventions in the school setting. Cardon et al. (2004) further suggest that guidelines to support teachers made a difference to the back health of school children and strongly recommend that guidelines are formulated. Back care knowledge among children, parents and teachers has also been reported to be very poor (Arghavani et al., 2014). This is further compounded by the lack of media coverage and governmental structured programs to help to inform youth (Bettany-Saltikov et al., 2008; Cardon et al., 2004). This has subsequently resulted in not only children but also parents and teachers being unaware of the prevalence and risk factors of musculoskeletal pain and disorders (Hashemi et al., 2012), resulting in the increase of poor back health behaviours routinely being undertaken in schools (Salminen Jouko et al., 1995). Numerous authors have also suggested that poor posture, ergonomics and body use in childhood may cause a further increase in these issues in future years (Harreby et al., 1996). It is generally assumed that as “young people are more flexible and adaptive learners than adults this may make childhood the best time to effect postural change and undo the physical harm modern lifestyles can inflict while at the same time setting up young people for healthy body use as adults. If this is true to any degree, elementary schools may be the best opportunity to introduce important concepts about healthy posture to learners” (Dugan, 2018, p. 643). To summarise, the patterns, disciplines and habits, whether correct or incorrect, that are learnt during children`s school years have an influence on the possible development of back pathology in the future. Many authors consider that the appearance and development of back pain among teenagers is a risk factor for back pain in adults (Harreby et al., 1996) with the risk increasing the more pain one has suffered during adolescence (Lise, Charlotte, & Kyvik Kirsten, 2006; Lise, Charlotte, Ohm, et al., 2006). The Intervention School environment interventions are strongly supported by the World Health Organisation (WHO) framework for Health Promoting Schools (Vivian et al., 2006). Indeed school-based education interventions for improving knowledge of back health and postural behaviour have been used in numerous countries worldwide to improve children’s and adolescents’ knowledge of back health, postural awareness and behaviour (Dugan, 2018). Back health educational programs aim to decrease the risk of spinal, back and other musculoskeletal problems which may lead to disability and musculoskeletal pain both in the present and in the future (Arghavani et al., 2014; Hashemi et al., 2012). Whilst numerous school-based education programmes have been implemented to reduce smoking, decrease alcohol consumption and teenage pregnancies, increase physical activity and healthy eating, and prevent obesity in children and youth, educational programmes teaching children and youth about the importance of back health, posture and ergonomics, together with ways of preventing back pain, have not received as much attention. There is currently no standard school-based educational program for improving knowledge of back health, ergonomics and postural behaviour of school children. These programs are designed to support students’ academic success in educational establishments. Educational establishments, or schools are broadly defined as institutions dedicated to education. These interventions generally engage school children in some form of active learning that cognitively and physically engages them in learning to improve knowledge, ergonomics and postural behaviour (Dugan, 2018). The programs described in the literature vary from country to country as well as within countries. The contents of the education back health programs have included lectures or lectures with actual demonstrations, practical sessions, workshops, individual lessons, class group lessons, curriculum lessons, posters, hands-on learning as well as educational modules. These studies have varied in their aims, the teachers teaching the intervention, the duration and intensity of the interventions as well as the content and strategies of the programs. These are discussed in turn below. Aims of the Educational Programs The aims of the programs are varied and have included all the following: to decrease the prevalence of back pain, to improve body mechanics and improve posture while performing various tasks, to improve the safety as well as methods of wearing a backpack, to teach acceptable sitting postures, safe lifting techniques and sports injury prevention procedures, to train students to make appropriate and safe decisions regarding the use of their bodies in order to prevent the onset of back pain as well as to improve students’ knowledge of back care principles (Steele et al., 2006). Teachers of Back Health Programs Steele et al.'s (2006) systematic review on school-based interventions for spinal pain reported that the teachers of these back-health education programs are diverse and have included all of the following: the classroom teacher, physical therapists, occupational therapists, physical education teachers as well as physical therapy students. Duration and Intensity of These Program The duration and intensity of these programs have varied widely. They range from one 30 min session, one 60 min session, 6 one-hour sessions over 6 weeks, one session with an unspecified duration, 11 sessions over 8 weeks (total 19 hours), 3 sessions of unspecified duration, and 3 years duration with no intensity specified (Steele et al., 2006). Content of the Back-Health Programs The reported content of these programs (Steele et al., 2006) have included the following: principles of Swedish back school, anatomy, physiology, spinal care principles and exercises, how to choose, lift and wear backpacks safely, how to recognise when a backpack is too heavy, exercises combined with behavioural intention and self-monitoring, biomechanics and risk factors for injury as well as how to incorporate this knowledge into everyday life using lifting techniques. Strategies for the Delivery of These Programs The strategies for the delivery of these programs have included a variety of approaches. Cardon et al.'s (2004) back health program has included teacher and parent involvement, and posters in the classroom or have been included within the curriculum where guided self-discovery and active hands-on methods were used. Goodgold and Nielsen (2003) used a whole-school approach with teacher and parent involvement, posters in the classroom and inclusion in the curriculum of the following: lecture, worksheets, demonstration, hands-on activity. In the Goodgold and Nielsen (2003) study, the strategies for the delivery of these programs were altered slightly to cater to a younger age group. Mendez Francisco and Antonia (2001) used teacher and parent involvement whilst also including posters in the classroom. The program was included in the curriculum as lectures, demonstrations, and practice. Robertson and Lee (1990) included the information in the Curriculum only and comprised of lectures, worksheets, games, demonstrations and practice whilst Schwartz & Jacobs (1992) strategy was included in the curriculum only: and comprised a lecture, demonstration and practice. Sheldon’s (1994) strategy was also only included in the curriculum and comprised a lecture and demonstration practice. Lastly, Spence et al.’s (1984) strategy was also only included within the curriculum and comprised a lecture, demonstration OR guided self-discovery. How the Intervention Might Work Many schools have traditionally held a “transmissionist” or “instructionist” model in which a teacher or lecturer ‘transmits’ information to pupils, for instance giving a lecture or presentation. In contrast, Vygotsky’s theory promotes learning contexts in which pupils play an active role in learning. The roles of the teacher and pupil are therefore shifted, as a teacher collaborates with his or her pupils to help facilitate meaning construction in their pupils. Further when an educational intervention is planned for children, for optimal learning to occur, children taking part need to have a greater reliance on so-called ‘hands-on’ learning, or learning by doing (Hartman Beth et al., 2000). Hartman Beth et al. (2000) focused on the effect of learning by doing versus learning by demonstration. These authors stated that children who had participated in a ‘hands-on’ project had a significantly greater amount of recall of the task than children who only had a demonstration. The children who were taught in the ‘hands-on’ condition also had a greater memory recall of the process. The results of this study appear to support the idea that ‘hands-on’ learning is more effective than verbal instruction for fostering retention and recall of the steps or the procedures of a skill in children. Furthermore, a contemporary theoretical framework called the dual-process model Wendy et al. (2016) was recently developed for interventions that improve children’s physical health at school. The model draws on various theories and other models, including the elaboration likelihood model (Petty & Cacioppo, 1986) and social cognitive theory (Bonell et al., 2013). Behaviour change is promoted through an automatic pathway to target habits and a reflective pathway to target knowledge, attitude and self-efficacy. Methods include the provision of rewards and positive reinforcement for habits, active learning and advance organisers for knowledge, and mere exposure and positive reinforcement for attitude and goal setting, monitoring and feedback for self-efficacy. Why it is Important to do This Review Research in this area has to date not received much attention. As (Dugan, 2018) states and as already stated above “most modern school systems require children to assume sedentary positions for extended periods of time, the increasing use of classroom-based technology adds to the number of hours seated” (Dugan, 2018). With the incidence of musculoskeletal pain reported not only in adult populations but increasingly in young people, knowing whether back health educational programs are effective on spinal health, ergonomics and posture is a very important consideration for all stakeholders: pupils, teachers, parents, researchers as well as clinicians. Dugan’s (2018) recent systematic review on the diverse range of posture interventions used within primary schools suggests that “although approaches to promoting postural health in primary schools vary, studies could be compared in terms of their impetus (e.g. low back pain in students, increasing classroom technology as well as aims and methodologies). Trends in the literature include delivery by posture experts (as opposed to homeroom teachers), examination of both sitting and moving postures in children and the impact of computer use on musculoskeletal heath. Much of the literature however relied largely on self-report data and assessment instruments were wide-ranging”. Steele et al. (2006) in another systematic review evaluating the effectiveness of school-based interventions on spinal pain was published 20 years ago. Twelve papers were included in that review with all papers receiving a “weak” quality rating. The result of the systematic review indicated that educational school-based back health interventions may be effective in increasing spinal care knowledge and decreasing the prevalence of spinal pain. However, overall, as the evidence was weak the results were inconclusive regarding spinal care behaviours. A more recent systematic review in a related area by Bonell et al. (2013) looked at other school-based educational interventions but did not include educational interventions to improve back health knowledge and posture. Bonell et al. (2013), concluded, however, that whilst there is definitely the potential for school environment interventions to promote young people’s health, the evidence base is far from definitive. Completing such an educational programme may help children improve their knowledge and develop an understanding of the importance of postural, ergonomic, and spinal back-health education for the prevention of back pain at a young age as well as later in adulthood. As stated previously the causes of LBP in youth are challenging and difficult to diagnose and have been theorised to include a lack of back care knowledge together with lack of knowledge regarding the best way of dealing with associated back problems. All the following: poor mechanical back shape, incorrect posture while using technology (game consoles, computers, Gameboys, iPhone), carrying heavy back packs, improper lifting techniques, incorrect posture during prolonged sitting and standing, lack of back care knowledge and the lack of opportunity to move around frequently (in standing, sitting) which may interfere with the educational environment. Inadequate or unavailable school lockers and ill-fitting school furniture have also been implicated (Bettany-Saltikov et al., 2008; Cardon et al., 2004; Feingold & Jacobs, 2002; Legg & Cruz, 2004; Sheldon, 1994). Therefore, as research in this area is still controversial, a systematic review conducted with state-of-the-art, high-quality Campbell Collaboration methodology is urgently needed to provide all stakeholders (“parents, children, teachers, researchers and clinicians) with the latest evidence to help inform policy and practice in this area of public health. Objectives The main objective for conducting this review was to conduct a Best Evidence Systematic Review. Only the highest-quality papers or best evidence on the effectiveness of school-based education programs on back health for improving knowledge of back health, ergonomics and postural behaviour in school children aged 4-18 years were included. The review seeks to gather, summarise and integrate the best empirical research on the review question so as to help people understand the evidence: for school children and adolescents aged 4-18 how effective are back care educational programs as compared with no back-care education for improving knowledge regarding ergonomics and posture as well as postural behavior? Methods The protocol for this study can be found here: Bettany-Saltikov J, McSherry R, van Schaik P, Kandasamy G, Hogg J, Whittaker V, Racero GA, Arnell T. PROTOCOL: School-based education programmes for improving knowledge of back health, ergonomics and postural behaviour of school children aged 4-18: A Systematic review. Campbell Syst Rev. 2019 Jul 13;15(1-2):e1014. doi: 10.1002/cl2.1014. PMID: 37131478; PMCID: PMC8356490. Criteria for Considering Studies for This Review Types of Study In this study we included the following research designs; randomised controlled trials (RCTs), cluster randomised controlled trials and quasi-randomised controlled trials (QRCTs). If a study was a well-controlled RCT, then the experimental groups were assumed to be equal at the start of the study. Prospective non-randomised studies (NRSs) with a control group were also included because it was anticipated that very few RCTs would be found. These included controlled before-after studies (CBAs) and interrupted time series (ITS) studies. Controlled studies that were nonrandomised were required to have a pre and post-test. The studies needed to include, at least, a treatment and a control group. Only studies of the highest quality that scored “good” or “excellent quality” quality as assessed by the Downs and Black (1998), risk-of-bias form were included. Retrospective studies as well as qualitative studies were excluded. We also excluded narrative and other types of non-systematic reviews (e.g. critical reviews, overviews, state-of-the-art reviews), clinical practice guidelines, evidence summaries, critically appraised topics, clinical paths, consumer information sheets, best practice information sheets, technical reports, and other evidence-based pieces. Type of Participant We included all children and young people between 4 and 18 years of age, attending school. Exclusion criteria were children under 4 years of age and adults over 18 years of age, chronic disease or conditions or co-morbidities. We excluded studies in which all subjects in the sample presented with pain, spinal diseases or surgical vertebral treatments. Types of Intervention The intervention of interest in this systematic review was any formal educational school-based program that included back health, ergonomics and postural behavior that was designed to support the academic success of students’ knowledge of posture and ergonomics within an educational establishment. Educational establishments, or schools are broadly defined as institutions dedicated to education. To be eligible, the interventions must have engaged school children in some form of active learning that cognitively and physically engages them in learning to improve their knowledge of ergonomics and postural behavior. The contents (lectures or lectures with actual demonstrations and practice, workshops, individual lessons, class group lessons, curriculum lessons, educational modules), length (hours, days, weeks, months, years) and manner of delivery (face to face, face to face with complementary materials, group and individual practical participation, observations) of the program may have varied in each of the studies to be included, as there is no standard school-based educational program for improving knowledge of back health, ergonomics and postural behaviour of school children. We planned to exclude physical activity or exercise only interventions. The control condition needed to include “usual” health and physical education programs provided by schools or no educational school program on back health and posture interventions. Studies comparing the effects of back health education programs to another type of back health intervention, were excluded. Types of Outcome Measure Primary Outcomes To the researchers’ knowledge there is no consensus regarding indicators for outcome measurement in the evaluation of educational and health promotion programs. While a change in a health outcome is the overall goal of most programs, often such changes may not occur within the evaluation timeframe, and intermediate endpoints must also be measured to gauge effectiveness. Intermediate endpoints often evaluated after the implementation of a health promotion program are the level of knowledge regarding the health issue, and the frequency in which relevant health behaviors are undertaken. The construction and administration of the outcome measures are typically developed by primary study authors. There may, however, be the occasional paper where these measures are both standardized and validated. Most measures of self-report appear to be undertaken by the youth themselves. We included studies that examined at least one of the following outcome measures. 1. Back care knowledge 1. Back care knowledge 2. Knowledge of back care ergonomics 2. Knowledge of back care ergonomics 3. Back care behaviors 3. Back care behaviors 4. Knowledge of back postural outcomes (primary and secondary) 4. Knowledge of back postural outcomes (primary and secondary) Any outcomes not mentioned above that were related to postural behavioral change were included. We intended to include studies that used validated outcome measures that related to the knowledge and/or understanding of all the above using the results of surveys, actual measurements, and other validated specific questionnaires. Secondary Outcomes Secondary outcomes included any adverse effects, for example pain or stiffness or other adverse effects reported in the included studies. If adverse effects were reported that were not listed here, we would have still reported them in our review. Duration of Follow-Up We evaluated any educational programs where pupils were followed up for 6 months, one year and 2 years. Types of Setting Settings included any educational setting and excluded any studies undertaken at a university (greater than 18 years of age) level or any kindergarten educational setting that taught children aged under 4 years. Search Methods for Identification of Studies We conducted a very comprehensive search that included 21 different health and education databases as seen below. Electronic Searches We developed a comprehensive search strategy consisting of relevant terms based on the PICOT elements of the review question. All the searches were conducted from inception till 20th January 2023 and we searched the following electronic databases: AMED (EBSCOhost), APA PsycINFO (EBSCOhost), Best Evidence Medical Education (BEME) (EBSCOhost), British Education Index (EBSCOhost), CINAHL (EBSCOhost), Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (Wiley), EMBASE (Ovid), ERIC (EBSCOhost), EThOS (British Library), Europe PMC (Europepmc.org), Google Scholar. Health Technology Assessment (HTA) (INAHTA), Health Management Information Consortium (HMIC) (Ovid), MEDLINE (EBSCOhost), PEDro (pedro.org.au), ProQuest Dissertations & Theses (Proquest), ProQuest Nursing and Allied Health Database (ProQuest), SCOPUS (Elsevier), SportDISCUS (EBSCOhost), Web of Science (Arts and Humanities Citation Index, Science Citation Index Expanded, Social Sciences Citation Index, Emerging Sources Citation Index, Conference Proceedings Citation Index – Science, Conference Proceedings Citation Index – Social Sciences and Humanities; Clarivate), ZEToC (British Library). Searching Other Resources We complemented our search with a thorough examination of reference lists of identified studies, and we contacted experts in the field to identify any on-going or unpublished studies. We also searched trial registries (ICTRP) for on-going studies. The following strategies were also used: • Screening the reference lists of all relevant papers • Screening the reference lists of all relevant papers • Searching the main electronic sources of ongoing trials, • Searching the main electronic sources of ongoing trials, • Searching the grey literature, including conference proceedings and PhD theses completed since 1980. Dissertation and theses were searched via EThOS and ProQuest Dissertations & Theses (Proquest). • Searching the grey literature, including conference proceedings and PhD theses completed since 1980. Dissertation and theses were searched via EThOS and ProQuest Dissertations & Theses (Proquest). • Contacting investigators and authors in this field for information on unpublished or incomplete trials. To do this we obtained the email address of the main author from their research paper and asked them whether they had any more information on unpublished or incomplete trials • Contacting investigators and authors in this field for information on unpublished or incomplete trials. To do this we obtained the email address of the main author from their research paper and asked them whether they had any more information on unpublished or incomplete trials • The information specialist who is also one of the authors (JH) at our university conducted an advanced search on Google Scholar using all the following words: education programs, knowledge, back health, ergonomics, postural, behaviour, school children. The exact phrase: “school-based” was used and could occur anywhere in the article (on 17 January 2023). As Google Scholar defaults to ranking by relevance, the Information specialist suggested that the search could be conducted and the screening stopped when the results reached several pages in a row with nothing relevant found. • The information specialist who is also one of the authors (JH) at our university conducted an advanced search on Google Scholar using all the following words: education programs, knowledge, back health, ergonomics, postural, behaviour, school children. The exact phrase: “school-based” was used and could occur anywhere in the article (on 17 January 2023). As Google Scholar defaults to ranking by relevance, the Information specialist suggested that the search could be conducted and the screening stopped when the results reached several pages in a row with nothing relevant found. All searches included non-English language literature. Government publications or those of international organisations were not specifically targeted during searches, so that could be acknowledged as a limitation. However, the HMIC (His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Service) database was searched, and this incorporates Department of Health official publications. The search strategy aimed to find both published and unpublished studies. A three-step search strategy was utilized in this review. An initial limited search of MEDLINE and CINAHL was undertaken, followed by the analysis of the text words contained in the title and abstract, and of the index terms used to describe the article. A second search using all identified keywords and index terms was then undertaken across all included databases. Thirdly, the reference list of all identified reports and articles was searched for additional studies. There was no restriction by date of publication. Specific conferences were not targeted during the searches, but conference proceedings were identified through database searches that indexed this type of publication, such as Web of Science and SCOPUS. Journals • European Spine Journal. • European Spine Journal. • Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies. • Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies. • Physical Therapy in Sport. • Physical Therapy in Sport. • Physiotherapy. • Physiotherapy. • Spine. • Spine. A copy of the CINAHL search strategy as well as the additional 20 search strategies in different databases are included in the Appendix (3). The names of each database and numbers of papers found in each database can be seen in Table 1 below. Table 1Names of Databases and Numbers of Papers Found in Each DatabaseNo of DatabasesName of DatabaseSearch resultsIncludedIncluded after duplicates taken out1EMBASE622532Scopus20339133CENTRAL241004HTA0005Australian education indexNo subscriptionNot searchedNot searched6ZETOC25937Google scholar5922568Proquest dissertation1109Best evidence medical education00010Europe PubMed central2610011CAB healthNo subscriptionNot searchedNot searched12Ethos10013CINAHL299314MEDLINE104272715AMED66216PsycINFO144217SportDiscus204118ERIC71019HMIC00020Web of knowledge19326821PEDro65022Proquest nursing and allied health104323British education index400132720571 Names of Databases and Numbers of Papers Found in Each Database Data Collection and Analysis Selection of Studies Two authors independently screened the search outputs and abstracts for relevant studies. Full texts of studies with seemingly relevant abstracts were retrieved and assessed for eligibility using the pre-specified inclusion criteria. Studies were classified as either included, excluded, awaiting assessment, or on-going. Two authors independently extracted data from relevant studies. In the case of differences in the extracted data, the authors discussed these to reach a consensus. If unresolved, these were discussed with a third author. In the case of missing data, we contacted the original study author for clarification. A data selection form was first developed on the basis of the inclusion criteria and then piloted and tested for both intra-observer and inter-observer reliability by two review authors, who then independently screened the search results by reading titles and abstracts. Potentially relevant studies were obtained in full text and once again they were independently assessed for inclusion by two review authors, who resolved disagreement through discussion. A third review author was contacted if disagreements persisted. If a review author was also the author of a paper, another review author who has not authored any of the papers undertook the selection. Data Extraction and Management Two authors (JBS and RMcs) independently extracted the data from the results section of the two included study. Any disagreements were referred to a third author (GK). For the Gallardo study which was written in Spanish one of the authors GAR who is Spanish, translated, collected and extracted the data from the Gallardo paper. Assessment of Risk of Bias in Included Studies The quality assessment or risk of bias for both randomised studies and NRSs was assessed using the criteria from the Downs and Black checklist, as outlined in Appendix 2. Originally, we had stated that we would use both the Downs and Black form as well as the Furlan critical appraisal form, but we found it too complicated to combine the two. We therefore only used the Downs and Black criteria. The Downs and Black Checklist (D) is a tool used to critically appraise the quality of quantitative (randomised and non-randomised) research studies. It assesses five key areas: study quality, external validity, study bias, confounding and selection bias, and the power of the study. Results Results of the Search The PRISMA flow diagram (Figure 1) below shows the number of papers identified in the search for literature, included and excluded in the study selection process. 1,327 possibly relevant papers were found through the searches of the 21 academic databases, as well as searches through the grey literature and reference lists. After removing 1,256 duplicates, 71 remained for screening. 37 articles were excluded based on screening the titles and abstracts. This left 34 articles for further examination of full texts. After reading the full texts, all the 34 studies continued to the quality assessment stage. We conducted a Best Evidence Synthesis using the Downs and Black risk of bias form which quantifies the quality of a paper by using an overall mark based on the individual grade of each question as well as for each section. If a paper was marked as having 14 points or under it was classed as a poor paper; 15-19 points was considered fair, good was considered to be between 20-25 points and excellent is 26-28 points. For the purposes of this study only the best evidence was included i.e. only 2 papers that achieved a score of 20 or over (good and excellent) were retained and included within this review, whilst papers that received a score of 19 and under (n = 32) were exluded. PRISMA Flow Diagram Assessment of Risk of Bias of the Studies Left After Reading the Full Papers and Assessing the Methodological Quality (34) [2nd Screening and Evaluation] The Risk of bias assessments of the studies that were methodologically appraised using the Downs and Black ROB form can be seen below (Tables 2 and 3). The colouring indicates the following: red indicates the studies were poor quality and got a score of 14 or under with a (high risk of bias); The yellow-coloured studies indicate that studies achieved a score from 16-19. This corresponded to a fair grade with a medium risk of bias. Two studies scored 20 points or over (i.e. good) and are highlighted in green indicating a low risk of bias. These 2 studies were included in this Best evidence systematic review. Details of the full and detailed ROB assessment forms for the 34 studies can be seen below in Table 4. Table 2Characteristics of Studies Excluded After Reading the Full Paper (Table Below). This as Based on whether the Eligibility Criteria were Met or NotID paperPurposeCountry of originStudy designParticipantsInterventionOutcomesReason for Exclusio1 Brzek & Plinta (2016) The study aimed to evaluate the postures of children participating in the program “I take care of my spine” compared to a group of children without diagnosed postural defects and not participating in the program.PolandComparative longitudinal studyGroup a had 144 children aged 7 to 9 with good postures during a screening at a school using the “I take care of my spine” curriculum. The control group had 222 children of similar age from schools without the curriculum.The “I take care of my spine” initiative by brzek is designed to prevent postural defects in children by encouraging exercises that support healthy movement. The program demonstrated notable enhancements in posture, with evaluations performed prior to commencement, after 9-10 months, and after one year for children in group B.Posturometric parameters changed positively in the main group and negatively in the control group. The postural prevention program reduced school bag weight for children significantly.WI2 Conti et al. (2009) Intervention to prevent back pain in school childrenEuropean journal of Physical and Health educationSpainStratified randomisation, sampling to select schools137 school children between 10-12 years6 1-h sessions (4 theoretical and 1 practical took place over 4 weeks.Improved awareness that school bags are a risk factor for bacl [painWI3 Galmes Panade and Vidal Conti (2022) To investigate the effects of postural education program (PEP) on daily life habits in school childrenSpainSchools chosen by convenience sampling.253 primary school children aged between 10-12 years were randomly allocated to experimental or control groupA 16-week online intervention consisting of 2 questionnairesIndividual postural variables not improved after interventionWI4 Rodiguez Garcia et al. (2013) To evaluate the effect of a physical education program on LBPSpainRandomisation to two different groups41 elementary and 43 secondary school childrenMean age 13 years oldA organised exercise program every 2 weeks over 32 weeksExperimental group showed decrease in back pain frequency while control group showed an incereaseWOWI5. Kędra et al. (2021) To analyse the association between LBP and physical activityPolandSystematic reviewSample size of 9 included studies and 75,233 total subjectsModerate evidence for relationship between low back pain and physical activityWT6 Liller (2003) Teaching tips: How much does that backpack weight? Report from a lessonUSAPre-post design and presentationUpper elementary and lower middle school pupilsThe students developed and presented recommendations on how to carry a backpack safelyBack-pack safetyWT7 Ahlqwist et al. (2008) Assessed the effects of two treatments on health perception, pain, and physical functioning in children and adolescents with LBP over timeSwedenRCTForty-five children and adolescents were randomised into one of 2 treatment groups for 12 weeks.Group 1 received personalized physical therapy, an exercise regimen, a standardized self-training program, and back education. Group 2 received only the self-training program and back education without any personalized therapy.Perception of health, pain, and physical functioning over timeWI8 NeJhaddadgar et al. (2022) Nmpact of an education program on the school backpack carrying habits of adolescent students.IranGroup based RCTThe study sample included 138 adolescent students aged 12 to 16 from four schools, randomly assigned to either the experimental group (N = 69) or the control group (N = 69).The experimental group participated in a 6-week education program comprising 6 sessions, while the control group did not receive any educational intervention.Participants completed a questionnaire during the pre-test and again three months after the intervention.Outcomes: (1) carry minimal items, (2) use a backpack on both shoulders, (3) use lockers or equivalent storage. After 3 months, the experimental group exhibited significant improvement in healthy habits (P = .001), whereas the control group demonstrated no significant change.WO9 Mendez Francisco & Antonia (2001) Postural hygiene program to prevent LBP.SpainComparative studyThe participants in this study were 106 third-grade (9-year-old) students.The program included 11 sessions. The teacher attended the placebo group sessions. No intervention was used with the control group.Level of knowledge and motor skillsWO10 Fanucchi (2007) It also aimed to assess its effectiveness in mitigating physical risk factors associated with childhood low back pain and enhancing overall well-being.S. AfricaRCT72, 12–13-year-old children, who had complained of low back pain in the past three months.The experimental group completed eight exercise classes of 40-45 minutes duration over eight weeks conducted by a physiotherapist, whilst the control group received no interventionThe primary outcome measured was intensity of pain. Secondary outcomes included the prevalence of pain over a three-month period, childhood physical risk factors associated with LBP, and overall sense of well-being.WO11 Heiser (2014) This study evaluated whether physical educators could improve 5th grade students’ understanding of back pain prevention by including back care principles in their regular curriculum. The study also investigated the long-term retention of this information.USA thesisComparative group studyThe participants were 135 students in three public elementary schools.The education group outperformed the control group on both the written knowledge test and the practical assessment. No significant differences in written knowledge scores/mean score gains on the practical assessment among the three instructional groups.Improvement in BPP knowledge and back care practice over the control group.WI12 Ciccarelli et al. (2016) This study aimed to assess musculoskeletal treatment for children and adolescents in Perth due to technology use, including service frequency, duration, treatment types, and costs.AustraliaSurvey (cross sectional study)Data from 101 pupils showed the common musculoskeletal complaints treated among children and adolescents. Over the last year, about 1,445 children received treatment, with one-third of chiropractors treating more than 31 children each.Most common treatments were soft tissue release, mobilisation, flexibility and conditioning exercises, soft tissue massage and kinesio-taping. Verbal education about healthy use of technology was provided by most clinicians (88%), with some inconsistent recommendations.(i) The number of children/adolescents treated for musculoskeletal issues due to technology use; (ii) frequency and duration of these services; (iii) nature of treatments administered. Treatment costs were also calculated.WI13 Ritter & De Souza (2015) To assess the immediate and sustained impact of the elementary school postural program on the execution, generalization, and perception of daily school activities.BrazilRCT61 subjects (14-15 years old)The postural program included 20 sessions over a 10-week period. In each session, participants discussed and practiced routine actions that typically occurred at schoolsPostural knowledge and behaviourWI14 Santos et al. (2017) To assess short/medium-term effects ofposture education program (PEP) for elementary school students on theoretical knowledge/posture during ADLsBrazilPre-post38 students (aged 8–12 years)Each 90-min class, held weekly, covered spine structures, curvatures, and functions, as well as ADLs like standing, walking, carrying a backpack, picking up objects, sitting, chewing, and lying down.Posture during ADLs and the theoretical knowledge about spine and body postureWT15 Shinn et al. (2002) Assessing whether a training session on body mechanics and computer ergonomics improves students’ knowledge.USAPre-post designSeventy-three male and forty-four female sixth-grade studentsLecture and demonstration on proper seat height, keyboard and mouse positioning, VDT height adjustment, and glare reduction techniques.Ergonomically correct computer workstationsWRD16 Springett & Wise (2007) To evaluate the impact of educating adolescents in ways of looking after their backs to reduce the incidence of back-pain, and carrying method of ergonomically designed schoolbagsUKPre-post682 year 7 schoolchildren, aged 11 to 12 yearsEducational leaflet containing a range of back care informationStudents’ awareness of the importance of looking after their backs, and achieving positive back-healthWRDWO17 Williams & Jacobs (2002) To determine if an educational intervention would increase both the children’s and their parents’ knowledge of ergonomically correct setup of a computer workstation and computer useUSAPre-post study design6 school children (average age = 12 .7 years) and their parentsThe intervention was based on a healthy computing checklist the intervention included spoken instructions and demonstration regarding posture, workstation setup, and rest breaks.Knowledge of ergonomically correct setup of a computer workstation and computer useWI AND WO18 Miñana-Signes & Monfort-Pañego (2016) To analyse the relationship between the level of back care knowledge and physical activity practiceSpainCross sectional576 adolescents aged 13-18 yearsSelf-reported questionnaire on health back care and LBPHigh school students have a low level of level of specific knowledgeOn health back care and LBPWRD19 Belcher et al. (2014) This study aimed to investigate whether physical educators could enhance knowledge of back pain prevention by incorporating back care principles into their standard curriculum.USA2 group-controlled studyThe participants were 135 students in three public elementary schools.The education group performed better on the written Knowledge test and on the practical assessment as compared to the control group that did not experience the instructional treatment.Improvement in BPP knowledge and back care in the control group.WO20 Schwartz & Jacobs (1992) A body basics cognitive approach to body mechanicsUSAThis study was conducted using 110 third grade students in San Antonio, Texas, and 31 students grades 1-6No control groups were employed, and all subjects received the same educational program.Change in knowledge concerning safety and the backWI21 Skaggs et al. (2006) The purpose was to see what factors influence the prevalence of back pain in middle school children, with particular attention to the weight of children’s backpacks availability of school lockersUSAPopulation based studyA population-based sample of 1540 children ages 11-14 years in a large metropolitan area was studied.A questionnaire was used to determine presence and severity of back pain, availability of lockers, backpack use, use of 1 or 2 straps to carry backpack, activity limitations due to back pain, and use of pain medication for back pain.Gender, age, weight of the child, and weight of his or her backpack were recorded as well as presence/absence of back painWO22 Robertson Helen & Lee Vicki (1990) Investigated some of the effects of back care educationAustraliaPre-post studyStudents aged from 10 to 12 yearsThree lessons structured to teach acceptable sitting posture, safe lifting techniques and sports injury preventionSitting postures and lifting skillWT23 Sawyer & Penman (2011) To evaluate the effectiveness of an educational session to promote awareness of the principles of ergonomics relating to computer useAustraliaPre-post study55 schoolchildrenThe 2-h session covered computer-related disorders, warning signs, ergonomic principles, software, a practical demo, summary, and evaluation.Awareness of the principles of ergonomics relating to computer useWT24 Hill & Keating (2015) To determine whether education and daily exercise affect LBP episodes in children compared to education aloneNew ZealandProspectivre multi-cluster RCT708 children age 8-11Children in the exercise group were taught 4 spinal movements for daily practice. Both groups had education that emphasised back awareness.Regular exercise and education reduced LBP more than education aloneWP25 Mendez Francisco & Antonia (2001) To improve the level of knowledge & motor skills and thereby avert the development of painful symptoms.Spain.The participantsThe program included 11 sessions.The teacher attended the placebo group sessions. No intervention was used with the control group.Improved health knowledge and habits more efficiently than those restricted to the mere transmission of information. [WI26 Jordá Llona et al. (2014) The aim off this study was to show a Juvenile back school (JBS) programme and its results in the hospital.SpainProspective observational studyA total of 139 patients referred to a Juvenile back school for advice due to pain, deformity or back asymmetry, were includedA scale with a survey completed in the first session and 3 months after finishing the programImprovement in posture and painWP27 Park & Kim (2011) This study examined the effects of spinal health educational programs.South KoreaA non-equivalent control-group pretest–post-test design was used.88 fifth-grade elementary school children. Three groups were compared: a Web-based group, a traditional face-to-face and a control group.The changes of spinal health practices were not significantly differentSpinal health education program as effective as traditional face-to-face instruction.WI28 Syazwan et al. (2011) To assess a multidisciplinary ergonomic education program to reduce musculoskeletal issues by lowering schoolbag weight and improving sitting posture.MalaysiaBefore and after study designChildren aged 8 and 11 years attending two schools within the central region of Malaysia.Students who received ergonomic intervention showed improvements in sitting posture and reduced schoolbag weight compared to controls.Reduction in musculoskeletal painWT29 Springett & Wise, 2007 This paper evaluated the impact of teaching adolescents practical methods for back care on their use and carrying techniques of ergonomically designed schoolbags to reduce back pain.USAPost-only designThe population group of year 7 schoolchildren, aged 11 to 12 years, (682) attending three main secondary education schools in West Sussex during September 2004.A leaflet with back care information was made for year 7 students aged 11 to 12 and given to 682 students in three secondary schools in West Sussex in September 2004. Feedback from one class in each school (81 students total) evaluated its impact.Ensuring good posture and preventing back pain.WT30 Szilagyi et al. (2021) Objective: To assess and improve back care knowledge and spine disease preventionRomaniaConvenience sample102 (mean age: 6 years) children were examined at baseline, and 48 (23 boys, 25 girls) were chosen for the program.Theoretical and exercise program with home materialBack care knowledge and habitual postureWO31 Menor-Rodriguez et al., 2022 Effect of postural interventions to modify postural hygiene habits in school childrenSpainCheck if randomised?479 students between 6-12 years oldA pictorial questionnaire was used from the PERSEO and ENKID studiesImprovement in postural hygieneDecrease in no of hours watching TVImprovement in way books were carried increase in use of wheeled backpacks.32 Rodriguez Garcia et al. (2013) To evaluate the efficacy of a 32 week physical education programme on LBP in school childrenSpainRandom assignment to intervention and control group41 elementary school children mean age 10 years and 42 secondary school children 13Structured physical education programme twice weekly for 32 weeksDecrease in pain frequency and in intervention group and increase in control groupWO33 Jones et al. (2004) To provide evidence of prevalence and consequences of recurrent LBP in children from NW EnglandUKCS survey with experimental and control group41 elementary school children 500 boys and 251 girls aged between 10-16 years of ageStructured physical education programme twice weekly for 32 weeks.Prevalance -average lifetime was 40%Intervention subjects -LBP frequency decreased and in control group it increased.WO34 Ciccarelli et al. (2016) To determine knowledge and practice of back care in 1st grade children after an intervention for back careAustraliaQuasi-experimental study with pre test and post test71 1st grade students.Postural education program containing theory and exerciseKnowledge and theory of back careEstimated costsWI35 Minghelli et al. (2021) Compare 2 back postural education programs on ergonomic knowledge and painPortugalComparison of 2 different intervention groups153 pupils aged 10-16 years oldDivided into 2 intervention samples3 theoretical and practical sessions lasting 45min and and at intervals of 1 week.A longer, more frequent, and personalized program shows different effects compared to a shorter, less frequent, and collective program with the same content.WO36 Mantilla Toloza et al. (2021) The objective was to determine the knowledge and practice of back care in first-grade school children after applying an educational intervention for back care.Quasi experimental study with pre-test and post-Knowledge and practices for back care were evaluated before and after of the intervention.Sample of 71 first grade school studentsA 5 week program of physical education for back care was developed in the intervention group,Knowledge and practice of back careW)37 Ismail (2010) Effectiveness of 2 ergonomics intervention programs in reducing ergonomic risk factorsMalaysiaComparative group229 children from 7th grade (8 years) and 5th grade (11 yearsGroup 1 ergonomically designed furniture group 2 exercise and postural education program. Group 3 controlSignificant reduction in RULA SCORE and bag weight in intervention groupErgonmic quizWO**Please note that 2 full text screening assessments were conducted as follows: one based on reading the full papers and evaluated to check if they met the PICOT criteria. The 2nd evaluation comprised the papers that DID meet the PICOT criteria that were consequently evaluated for risk of bias.Key WP = wrong population; WI = wrong intervention; WC = wrong comparative group; WT = wrong type of research design; WO = wrong outcomes. Characteristics of Studies Excluded After Reading the Full Paper (Table Below). This as Based on whether the Eligibility Criteria were Met or Not **Please note that 2 full text screening assessments were conducted as follows: one based on reading the full papers and evaluated to check if they met the PICOT criteria. The 2nd evaluation comprised the papers that DID meet the PICOT criteria that were consequently evaluated for risk of bias. Key WP = wrong population; WI = wrong intervention; WC = wrong comparative group; WT = wrong type of research design; WO = wrong outcomes. Table 3Risk of Bias in the 34 Studies Left After Reading the Full Papers (Appendix 1)Out of the 34 studies remaining after reading the 71 full papers and assessing the Risk of Bias, only two studies achieved a score of GOOD (20-25) or over. These studies are depicted in the table below (Tables 4 and 5) with green colouring.Nine studies achieved a score of under 14 points and were, therefore classed as poor studies as per the D&B criteria (this means they had high bias). This is depicted in the table below (Tables 4 and 5) with red square and colouring.23 studies achieved a score of between 15-19 and were classed as fair studies according to the criteria of Downs and black form. This is depicted in the table below with a yellow squareTable 2 shows the scores obtained for each question in each section for each paper are shown:9 studies scored poor under 14 points.23 studies scored fair (between 15-19)2 studies scored good (20 marks or over).0 studies scored excellent (26-28 points)Total = 34 studies Risk of Bias in the 34 Studies Left After Reading the Full Papers (Appendix 1) Table 4Scores for the Assessment of Papers Using the ROB Downs and Black Criteria (2nd Screening/Evaluation)No.AuthorQ11Q1111222345678a8b910Total for Reporting111213Ext Validity 0/31415161718Int validity 0/5192021222324IV total 0/6PA 0/2Total scoreQuality1 Akbari-Chehrehbargh et al. (2020) 111101100017/1258%0000/30%001012/540%0000000/60%0/20%9/2832%Poor2 Balague et al. (1996) 110201000117/1258%1113/3100%001012/540%1100103/650%2/2100%17/2861%Fair3 Bartone et al. (2015) 111201011019/1275%1113/3100%111014/580%1000001/617%0/20%17/2861%Fair4 Candotti et al. (2011) 111201101019/1275%1113/3100%111014/580%1011014/667%2/2100%22/2879%Good5 Cardon et al., 2000 1112111011010/1283%0011/333%111014/580%1110014/667%0/20%19/2868%Fair6 Cardon et al. (2002) 111201101008/1267%0112/367%111014/580%1110003/650%2/2100%19/2868%Fair7 Cardon et al. (2002) 111101101007/1258%1012/367%111014/580%1110014/667%0/20%17/2861%Fair8 Cardon et al., 2002 110101000004/1233%0000/30%001012/540%0000000/60%2/2100%8/2829%Poor9 Cardoso et al. (2014) 111201000017/1258%0000/30%011114/580%1120004/667%0/20%15/2854%Fair10 Conti et al. (2009) 111101100017/1258%1113/3100%111115/5100%1110003/650%0/20%18/2864%Fair11 Dockrill et al. (2010) 1112011101110/1283%0000/30%101114/580%0000011/617%0/20%15/2854%Fair12 Dolphens et al. (2011) 111101100118/1267%0000/30%011114/580%1110014/667%0/20%16/2857%Fair13 Dullien et al. (2018) 111201100018/1267%1113/3100%001113/560%1100002/633%2/2100%18/2864%Fair14 Foltran et al. (2012) 111101110118/1267%1113/3100%111115/5100%1110003/650%0/20%19/2868%Fair1 Gallardo et al. (2013) 1112011011110/1283%0011/333%111115/5100%1110014/667%2/2100%22/2879%Good16 Geldhof et al. (2006) 110101100117/1258%1113/3100%111115/5100%1110003/650%0/20%18/2864%Fair17 Geldhof et al. (2007) 110101111119/1275%0000/30%011013/560%1110003/650%0/20%15/2854%Fair18 Goodgold & Nielsen (2003) 111101000016/1250%0101/333%101114/580%1100002/633%0/20%13/2846%Poor19 Habybabady et al. (2012) 110101100016/1250%1001/333%001012/540%0110002/633%2/2100%13/2846%Poor20 Jacobs et al. (2013) 110100100015/1242%0000/30%001113/560%0000000/60%0/20%8/2829%Poor21 Kovacs et al. (2011) 111001100016/1250%1113/3100%001113/560%1110002/650%2/2100%18/2864%Fair22 Miñana-Signes & Monfort-Pañego (2016) 111101100017/1258%1113/3100%001113/560%1111004/667%0/20%17/2861%Fair23 Minana-signes et al. (2019) 111201101019/1275%1113/3100%001113/560%1100002/633%0/20%19/2868%Fair24 Ritter & De Souza (2015) 110201100017/1258%0011/333%111115/5100%1100002/633%2/2100%17/2861%Fair25 Robertson Helen & Lee Vicki (1990) 100210001005/1242%1113/3100%110114/580%1100002/633%0/20%14/2850%Poor26 Robbins et al. (2009) 111201001119/1275%0011/333%111115/5100%1110014/667%0/20%19/2868%Fair27 Santos et al. (2017) 111201100119/1275%0112/367%111115/5100%1100002/633%1/250%19/2868%Fair28 Sawyer & Penman (2011) 110201000005/1242%0011/333%110114/580%1100002/633%0/20%12/2843%Poor29 Schwartz & Jacobs (1992) 110201001017/1258%0011/333%111115/5100%1100002/633%0/20%15/2854%Fair30 Sellchop et al. (2018) 110201100118/1267%0011/333%111115/5100%1111116/6100%0/20%20/2871%Fair31 Sellshop et al. (2015) 110201100017/1258%0011/333%111115/5100%1111105/683%2/2100%20/2871%Fair32 Sheldon (1994) 011201100017/1267%1113/3100%001113/560%1010002/633%0/20%15/2854%Fair33 Torras Bernáldez et al. (2023) 110200000004/1233%0011/333%110114/580%1100002/633%0/20%11/2839%Poor34 Williams & Jacobs (2002) 110101000004/1233%0000/30%001012/540%0000000/60%0/20%6/2821%Poor Scores for the Assessment of Papers Using the ROB Downs and Black Criteria (2nd Screening/Evaluation) Results of the assessment of the risk of bias in the two included studies The risk of bias for both randomised studies and NRSs was assessed using the criteria from the Downs and Black checklist, as outlined in the supplementary materials Appendix 2 (Table 5). Table 6 shows the risk of bias assessments for the two included studies. Table 5Downs and Black Risk of Bias Assessment for the Two Included StudiesDowns and black risk of bias assessment for the two included studiesCandottiGallardo1. ReportingYes/No/PartiallyScoreScore 1. Is the objective of the study clear?Yes = 1, No = 011 2. Are the main outcomes clearly described in the introduction or methods?Yes = 1, No = 011 3. Are characteristics of the patients included in the study clearly described?Yes = 1, No = 011 4. Are the interventions clearly described?Yes = 1, No = 022 5. Are the distributions of principal confounders in each group of subjects clearly described?Yes = 2, Partially = 1, No = 000 6. Are the main findings of the study clearly described?Yes = 1, No = 011 7. Does the study estimate random variability in data for main outcomes?Yes = 1, No = 011 8a. Have all the important adverse events consequential to the intervention been reported?Yes = 1, No = 000 8b. Were the screening criteria for study eligibility specifiedYes = 1, No = 011 9. Have characteristics of children lost to follow-up been described?Yes = 1, No = 001 10. Have actual probability values been reported for the main outcomes, except probability <0.001?Yes = 1, No = 011Total for reporting9/12 (75%)10/12(83%)2. External validityYes/No/UnclearScore (%) 11. Were subjects who were asked to participate in the study representative of the entire population recruited?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 010 12. Were those subjects who were prepared to participate representative of the recruited population?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 010 13. Were staff, places, and facilities where students were taught representative of the teaching most received?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 011Total for external validity3/3 (100%)1/3 (33%)3. Internal validity- biasNo/UnclearYes 14. Was an attempt made to blind study subjects to the intervention?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 011 15. Was an attempt made to blind those measuring the main outcomes?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 011 16. If any of the results of the study were based on data dredging was this made clear?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 011 17. Was the time period between intervention and outcome the same for intervention and control groups or adjusted for?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 001 18. Were the statistical tests used to assess the main outcomes appropriate?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 011Total for internal validity- biasYes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 04/55/5 (100%)4. Internal validity-confounding (selection bias)Yes/No/UnclearScore 19. Was compliance with the interventions reliable?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 011 20. Were main outcome measures used accurate? (Valid and reliable)Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 001 21. Were patients in different intervention groups recruited from the same population?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 011 22. Were study subjects in different intervention groups recruited over the same period of time?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 010 23. Were study subjects randomized to intervention groups?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 000 24. Was there adequate adjustment for confounding in the analyses from which main findings were drawn?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 000 25. Were losses of patients to follow-up taken into account?Yes = 1, No = 0,Unclear = 000Total for internal validity selection bias3/73/7Section 5. Power analysis 26. power analysisYes = 2, No = 0,Unclear = 122Total score22/28 (79%)22/28 (79%)Downs and black risk of bias classificationGood qualityGood quality Downs and Black Risk of Bias Assessment for the Two Included Studies Table 6Characteristics of the Two Included Studies Candotti et al. (2011) Gallardo et al. (2013) Citation and yearCandotti, C. T., Nunes, S. E. B., Noll, M., Freitas, K. D., & Macedo, C. H. (2011). Efeitos de um programa de educação postural para crianças e adolescentes após oito meses de seu término. Revista Paulista de Pediatria, 29, 577-583.M.I. Gallardo Vidal, R. Rodríguez Barrientos, A. Borda Olivas,Evaluación de la efectividad de una intervención educativa para disminuir el peso de la mochila escolar en los alumnos de 3.° y 4.° de educación primaria, Fisioterapia, Volume 35, issue 2, 2013 58-65,PurposeTo evaluate the effects of a postural education program (PEP) for children and adolescents eight months after its completionThe purpose was to have them limit backpack weight to no more than 10-15% of the total weight of the student and avoid some of the spinal cord overload and therefore one of the risk factors of suffering back pain.Country of origin and locationBrazilSpain location: Public schools in Alcobendas andSan Sebastian de los Reyes.Study designDesign: A randomised control trial with repeated measures design over 8 months. A validated questionnaire was filled out by each subject before the educational programme, and a week and three monthsDesign: Randomized controlled clinical trial.Participants34 children, were assigned to a control group (CG) or to an experimental group (EG).A total of 357 children,Ages10-13 years old8 to 10 yearsInterventionOnly the EG participated in the PEP, but all the subjects were evaluated before, during and eight months after finishing the PEP.Comparative interventionComparative group did not receive any interventionComparative group did not receive any interventionOutcomesThe evaluation utilized three distinct methods: (1) analyzing static posture through photographic documentation; (2) assessing dynamic posture by recording the performance of routine activities; and (3) completing a questionnaire aimed at evaluating theoretical understanding of spinal function.Main outcomes: children and their school backpacks were weighed prior to the educational intervention, immediately after and at three months of the educational intervention.Time point/s of measurementsEvaluated before, during and 8 months after finishing PEPChildren + school backpacks weighed, prior to intervention, immediately after and three months afterSynthesis methodThree nonparametric tests evaluated differences between groups and time points for children and adolescents: Mann-Whitney U test compared control and experimental groups at baseline.Wilcoxon signed-rank test compared baseline, post-intervention, and follow-up scores.Chi-square test assessed frequency of postural changes over time. These tests were applied to ADL circuit scores and questionnaire results with a significance level of 0.05.At the primary endpoint, children in the intervention group carried backpacks that were on average over 1 kg lighter than those in the control group, a difference considered meaningful. At the end of the intervention and again 3 months later, the average weight difference was around 2.28 kg and 2.24 kg, respectively (P < .001). Additionally, children who received the intervention were about three times more likely to carry backpacks without excessive weight at both time points (RR = 2.63 and 2.96).ResultsWhen evaluated immediately after completion, the PEP had a positive effect posture of EAs and on knowledge about the spine. The positive effect of the PEP was reduced eight months after its completion. (P < 0.001)Regarding the study primary endpoint, average weight of the backpack, the difference between the two groups was greater than 1 kg (difference considered relevant) both at the end of the intervention (difference of means (SD) = 2.28 kg) and at 3 months of it (SD = 2.24 kg) (P = 0.001).ConclusionsThe authors suggest that that awareness of the importance of good posture during EAs was not effectively incorporated into the habits of the studied group.This work shows that classroom educational orientation provided by a physiotherapist can lead to a reduction in the weight of backpacks carried by 8–10-year-old schoolchildren.Quality appraisal/ROB scoreQuality according to D&B good 22Low risk of biasQuality according to D&B goodLow risk of bias 22 Characteristics of the Two Included Studies Populations in the Two Interventions The sample size of the two papers can be seen in Figure 2 below. The Candotti et al. (2011) paper was a small study and only included 34 school children whilst the Gallardo study (2013) included 353 children. Populations in the Two Interventions Interventions Used in the Two Included Studies The intervention for the Condotti study comprised a postural education program whereas the postural education program in Gallardo`s study focused on teaching the pupils how to wear backpacks safely and carry loads that would not result in injury. For both studies the comparative intervention groups did not receive any postural education program (Tables 7 and 8 below). Table 7Candotti’s study intervention (2012)Stages of the experiment and topics addressed in each lesson of the Adapted Postural Education Program (PEP) 1. Introduction and pre-intervention assessment (baseline photo and questionnaire). 2. Pre-intervention assessment (videotaping) 3. The objectives of postural education. The curves of the spine in the sitting position 4. Postural compensation mechanisms. Standing and walking properly 5. Structure and function of the intervertebral discs. Sitting and standing up properly 6. Spinal overload: Onset of disc herniation. Squatting, picking up, and lifting objects properly 7. Spinal overload: Painful slipped discs. Rotation and bending of the spine 8. The ideal position for sleep and pillow height. Lying down and getting up properly 9. The muscles and posture – the erector spinae muscles, abdominal muscles, and hip flexors 10. Theoretical review – a review of the content of the PEP 11 Post-intervention, assessment (photo and administration of questionnaire) 12. Post-intervention assessment (videotaping) Eight months later - follow-up (photo, administration of questionnaire, videotaping) Candotti’s study intervention (2012) Table 8Gallardo’s InterventionThe requirements that the school backpack needed to meet were as follows:Size capacity and characteristics that a school backpack must meet.How to carry a school backpack properly: Adjustment, positioning and back position when walking,How to use a wheeled backpack: Handle adjustment, upper limb placement and ways of pushing and pullingHow to select and properly pack the schoolbooks in the backpack Gallardo’s Intervention Gallardo`s (2013) educational intervention focused on ways of carrying the backpack together with calculating the ideal load each student needed to carry based on their weight (Tables 9–12). Table 11Outcome 1Evaluation of the effective difference in backpack weight between the 2 groupsControl (86)Intervention (271)Difference of means (CI 95%)p-valueMean and SDMeans and SDBackpack weight at the end of the intervention5.89 ± 1.393.60 ± 1.162.28 (1.98-2.58)<0.001Backpack weight 3 months F/U6.08 ± 1.343.83 ± 1.472.24 (1.89-2.59)<0.001 Outcome 1 Table 12Outcome 2Evaluation of the excessive weight of the backpack (>15% of body weight) in the experimental and control groupExcessive weight categoryControl 86Intervention (271)Relative risk (95% CI)N = (%)N = (%)(%)Excessive weight at the start of the interventionNo27 (31.4)224 (82.7)2.63 (1.92-3.62)Excessive weight 3 months after the end of the interventionNo24 (27.9)2.24 (1.89-2.59)2.96 2.10-4.18) Outcome 2 Table 9Means and standard deviations of knowledge and behaviour in the control and intervention group in children.GroupChildrenBaseline a Post-intervention b Follow-up c P-valueControl4.8 ± 3.15.2 ± 2.15.0 ± 1.7NS (a vs b)NS (a vs c)NS (b vs c)Experimental4.7 ± 2.710.9 ± 1.68.0 ± 1.9p = 0.001 (a VS b)p = 0.045 (a VS c)p = 0.038 (b VS c)p = 0.32P = Paper did not include thisP = paper did not include thisNS = no significant differences.a = baseline.b = post-intervention.c = follow-up. Means and standard deviations of knowledge and behaviour in the control and intervention group in children. NS = no significant differences. a = baseline. b = post-intervention. c = follow-up. Table 10Mean and Standard Deviation of Knowledge and Behavior in the Control and Intervention Group in AdolescentsGroupAdolescentsBaseline a Post-intervention b Follow-up c P-valueControl6.5 ± 1.76.6 ± 1.96.8 ± 1.8NS (a vs b)NS (a vs c)NS (b vs c)Experimental6.6 ± 1.812.4 ± 3.310.1 ± 2.0p = 0.001 (a vs b);p = 0.041 (a vs c);p = 0.042 (b vs c)p = 0.85P = paper did not include thisP = paper did not include thisNS = no significant differences.a = baseline.b = post-intervention.c = follow-up. Mean and Standard Deviation of Knowledge and Behavior in the Control and Intervention Group in Adolescents NS = no significant differences. a = baseline. b = post-intervention. c = follow-up. Discussion of the Outcomes of Each Study Candotti’s Outcomes (2012) The questionnaire in this study measured the theoretical knowledge of the spine, with a top score of 18. The study reported control versus intervention group comparisons. Control group scores for knowledge and behaviour showed no significant change over time. Experimental groups improved significantly after the intervention, and while scores dropped slightly at follow-up, they remained above baseline levels. Gallardo’s Outcomes (2013) Theory Underlying Intervention The intervention is based on the premise that heavy backpacks can cause back pain in children. Numerous research papers show, that carrying more than 10–15% of a child’s body weight can affect spinal health and cause pain. The study aimed to reduce backpack weight through an educational session. In the intervention group, a researcher measured students’ backpack and body weight at three points: before, immediately after, and three months after the session. During the session, students learned to carry only necessary school items, and their backpacks were reweighed afterward. In the control group, measurements were taken only at the start and after three months, with no educational session. All measurements were done consistently to ensure accuracy. Main Measurements Outcomes 1. Average weight of backpack- The Difference between the two groups was greater than 1 kg both at the end of the intervention (difference of means = 2.28 kg) and also 3 months after completion (2.24 kg). 1. Average weight of backpack- The Difference between the two groups was greater than 1 kg both at the end of the intervention (difference of means = 2.28 kg) and also 3 months after completion (2.24 kg). 2. Excess weight in the backpack children and school backpacks were weighed, prior to educational intervention, immediately after and at three months after the educational intervention.- Children who had the intervention were approximately 3 times more likely to not to carry excess weight in their backpacks both at the end of the intervention and 3 months later. 2. Excess weight in the backpack children and school backpacks were weighed, prior to educational intervention, immediately after and at three months after the educational intervention.- Children who had the intervention were approximately 3 times more likely to not to carry excess weight in their backpacks both at the end of the intervention and 3 months later. - Children who had the intervention were approximately 3 times more likely to not to carry excess weight in their backpacks both at the end of the intervention and 3 months later. - Children who had the intervention were approximately 3 times more likely to not to carry excess weight in their backpacks both at the end of the intervention and 3 months later. Outcome 3: Clinical Relevance of the Results at the End of the Intervention (in Brief) Relative Risk Reduction (163.3%) This means that the intervention reduced the chance of carrying too heavy backpacks by a very large percentage compared to the control group This means that the intervention reduced the chance of carrying too heavy backpacks by a very large percentage compared to the control group • Absolute risk reduction (51.3%): Out of every 100 children, about 51 benefited by stopping the habit of carrying too heavy a backpack. • Absolute risk reduction (51.3%): Out of every 100 children, about 51 benefited by stopping the habit of carrying too heavy a backpack. • Number needed to treat (NNT = 2): For every 2 children who receive the intervention, 1 child stops carrying excessive weight. This shows the intervention works very effectively. • Number needed to treat (NNT = 2): For every 2 children who receive the intervention, 1 child stops carrying excessive weight. This shows the intervention works very effectively. • 62% of children benefited: Overall, 62% of the children who took part in the intervention ended up carrying lighter backpacks. • 62% of children benefited: Overall, 62% of the children who took part in the intervention ended up carrying lighter backpacks. Collective Summary of What the Two Intervention Studies Showed In summary this systematic review comprised of the following two studies: The Candotti et al. (2011) study focused on a postural education program and demonstrated significant improvements in knowledge and behaviour related to back health. The Gallardo et al. (2013) assessed backpack weight management and reported that students who received the intervention were significantly less likely to carry excessive backpack weight Both studies showed that educational interventions improved students’ knowledge about ergonomics and posture, but the effects faded over time. This review highlights the need for high-quality research and standardized educational programs to address back health and ergonomics in schools effectively. In summary, both studies demonstrated short-term improvement. Overall Discussion Summary of Main Results This systematic review investigated the effectiveness of educational interventions developed to improve knowledge regarding ergonomics and posture, as well as postural behaviour in children aged 4-18 years including primary, secondary and sixth form students (ages 16-18 years). The comprehensive search strategy retrieved 1327 articles that could potentially answer the research question of this review. After sifting the titles and abstracts of the identified papers based on the inclusion criteria (PICOT), the authors identified 71 potentially relevant articles. A total of 37 papers were excluded as detailed in Table 1 and the PRISMA flow chart Figure 1. The remaining 34 papers were then assessed for risk of bias (ROB) using the Downs and Black, (1998) checklist. This checklist was designed to evaluate the methodological quality of both randomised and non-randomised studies (a copy of this form can be found in Table 5). No studies achieved excellent (scores 26-28) but the two included studies were found to have ‘good’ scores (20-25). The results from the two included studies indicated that at three months after the interventions, both interventions were effective compared to the control group. Discussion of the Risk of Bias in the Two Included Papers The risk of bias table can be found above in Table 5 above. Reporting of Papers Both studies scored 22/28 on the Downs and Black form, indicating a lower risk of bias and classification as good papers. Although both studies received the same final score, they achieved different scores for various sections of the assessment. In the initial part of the assessment, the reporting of the papers was evaluated. The Candotti paper scored 9/12 points (75%), while the Gallardo paper scored 10/12 points (83%). Overall, the Gallardo paper had the highest score with the lowest bias in the reporting section. External Validity Both included studies achieved a perfect score of 3/3 (100%) for external validity. This finding suggests that the results of both studies could be generalized to the population from which the study subjects were drawn. Internal Validity - Confounding Bias Candotti et al. (2011) scored 4/5 (80%) points in this section, whereas Gallardo et al. (2013) scored 5/5 points (100%). This indicates high internal validity for both authors, though the Candotti et al. (2011) paper was not as well designed as the one by Gallardo et al. (2013) To adequately control confounding bias, data collection must include all factors related to both treatment choice and the outcome of interest. Internal Validity (Selection Bias) Both papers scored 3.7 points (43%) in this section. None of the papers scored highly here. To adequately control for selection bias, data collection must include all factors related to why certain students participated in a study and others did not. Internal Validity (Confounding Bias) The next item, also internal validity, refers to how well the study was executed. Both papers scored 3/7 points (42%) for confounding bias, suggesting that improvements are necessary in this area. The authors believe that there are potentially confounding variables present which are interfering with the study’s ability to truly separate out the effect of the intervention and thus the reported impact of the intervention may be over/underestimated. Power analysis Both studies conducted a power analysis and scored 22 points (79%) each. Power Calculations “Power” is the probability of avoiding a type II error in a comparative study. A type II error occurs when the false null hypothesis is not rejected, indicating no effect or difference despite its existence. Small sample sizes result in lower power and increase type II error risk, potentially suggesting ineffective interventions when they are effective, thus biasing results. The 2 included studies scored high on power analysis. However, other studies may not have been published and therefore not reviewed here, because of their low statistical power, non-significant results and small effect sizes. Therefore, the effect size of the reviewed studies could be an overestimate of the true effect. Overall, whilst both studies scored well and were classed as good-quality studies on the overall Downs and Black risk of bias forms, the Candotti (75%) paper lost points in the reporting section which means this could be improved. The Gallardo’s paper scored 83% in this section. Furthermore, all papers scored very highly 3/3 for external validity which means that the results of the papers have very good generalisability. The internal validity for the overall bias for both papers scored highly with Candotti scoring 4/5 whilst the other paper scored 5/5. We found the Downs and Black RoB form relatively easy to understand and fill in. The large number of questions assessing each aspect of the quality appraisal and risk of bias makes it easier than other forms (which may have only half the number of questions) to identify where and for what reason each paper lost points in the evaluation. Limitations of the Review Processes The main limitation of our review in our opinion were the number of authors involved. When conducting the selection as well as the evaluation of the quality of studies, our group was split into 3 groups of 2 assessors to make sure the assessments were as rigorous and valid as possible. However, problems arose for a couple of the papers when the overall value for the ROB assessment between the pairs differed by several points. We believe this was due to the fact that one pair of assessors had much more experience in critiquing papers than the other pair. Another way to view this is that the assessors were not sufficiently well trained in making the assessments prior to doing so. Another limitation is the fact that Government publications or those of international organisations were not specifically targeted during searches. However, the HMIC database was searched, and this database incorporates Department of Health official publications. Additionally, Government information was not identified because the likelihood of finding references that would use the included study designs was limited. It is also important to remember that the latest searches were conducted in 2023 and there may well be published papers since that time that might be eligible for inclusion. Furthermore, although comprehensive, sensitive and robust, it is possible that our search strategy failed to identify additional references. Agreements and Disagreements With Other Studies or Reviews The primary distinction between this systematic review and others in the field lies in its best-evidence synthesis approach, which included only the highest quality papers, not just in terms of the level of evidence but also as to how well each RCT was operationalised. In contrast, other systematic reviews considered all papers meeting the inclusion criteria, including those of poor and fair quality. The systematic reviews by Minana-Signes et al. (2021) and Anyachukwu et al. (2024) were the most comparable to this one, as they only included randomized control trials (RCTs). While RCTs are generally regarded as providing the highest quality evidence, these trials may suffer from flaws in their operationalization and execution. Futhermore, whilst in our review we searched through 21 databases for relevant papers from inception till 2023, the AnyaChukwu et al. (2024) systematic review included only 5 databases, and the search was conducted between the years 2000-2022. The PEDRO scale was used to assess the quality of papers in this review. AnyaChukwu et al. (2024) found 8 studies that met their criteria whilst the Minana-Signes et al. (2021) review included 7 databases and reported finding 6 RCT’s. AnyaChukwu et al.’s (2024) review only included papers in English whereas Minana-Signes’s et al. (2021) review reported studies in both English and Spanish. Our own review included papers in five languages. With regards to the outcomes, those reported in the other two reviews were similar to the ones reported in our review, but both also included pain as an outcome, which was not investigated in our own review. Furthermore, Minana-Signes’s et al.'s (2021) review had a focus on student-centred approaches, which neither our own review nor Anyachukwu et al.’s (2024) included. Our systematic review included many of the same research papers as the two other reviews, but we excluded a number of these papers, at the risk-of-bias stage, if they had not scored 20 points or higher. We used the Black and Downs risk of Bias form with 28 questions (see Appendix 2), whilst Minana-Signes et al. (2021) and Anyachukwu et al. (2024) used the PEDro scale with 10 questions. We found the Black and Downs assessment was more discriminating than the PEDro scale. For instance, the Habybabady et al. (2012) paper scored 6/10 (60%) in the other two reviews but only 13/28 (46%) in ours. So, in our review this was classified as a “poor study” and excluded. This suggests the need to compare the two different critical appraisal forms in this research area to understand where the score differences occurred. Having said this, the association between the overall PEDro and Downs and Black critical appraisal form was evaluated by L’Aubut et al. (2013), who found moderately high correlation scores but in a study on acquired brain injury (r = 0.71, p < 0.01); this indicates a significant relationship between these two quality assessment tools for the assessment of acquired brain injury. Despite the positive correlation, however, B&D may produce relatively low scores and PEDro relatively high scores. Finally, similar to our own review, both Anyachukwu et al. (2024) as well as Minana-Signes et al. (2021) concluded that Back Health Educational interventions were effective and needed to be implemented for school children. It is acknowledged that completing risk-of-bias forms is subjective, as scores depend not only on assessors’ interpretations but also on their knowledge and experience in research methodology. In our review, each paper was independently evaluated by two pairs of scorers who then reached a consensus. Despite this method, final scores varied significantly in a couple of papers. For example, one pair scored an RCT at 22 points, while another scored it at 14 points, showing an 8-point difference. A strength of our review was using two independent sets of assessors for risk of bias, ensuring a comprehensive and rigorous evaluation. However, comparing different studies remains challenging due to the various quality appraisal/risk of bias forms. To our knowledge little is known as to how the PEDro scale and the Downs and Black compare in the evaluation of back health education papers as both were developed to assess clinical papers and not education research. Authors’ Conclusions Implications for Practice and Policy This systematic review aimed to answer the following question: “For school children and adolescents aged 4-18 how effective are back care educational programs as compared to no back-care education for improving knowledge regarding ergonomics and posture as well as postural behavior?” This review found “good” evidence from 2 RCT’s of what the educational program impacts are, of implementing this approach, such as improved knowledge regarding ergonomics and posture as well as postural behavior in school children. The Gallardo study also provided evidence that the children carried bags that were of much less weight after their intervention. Whilst many authors and programs have provided evidence of the effectiveness in terms of knowledge regarding ergonomics, and postural behavior, these studies were excluded from this best evidence synthesis review due to being of poor or fair quality. The inclusion of the 2 studies by Candotti and Gallardo demonstrate that in the short term (3-8 months) postural education programs appear to be effective in improving knowledge of back health posture, ergonomics and behaviour; however, because we could only include 2 good papers, both of which suffered from problems of selection bias and confounding bias, and no excellent papers, we are unable to make firm conclusions and recommendations for policy and practice. The results suggest that implementing postural and ergonomic educational programs in primary/secondary schools significantly and positively impacts children’s knowledge of back health. Further studies are needed to evaluate different approaches to educating children about back health, including the latest technology and computer applications, such as those available on smartphones and tablets. Implications for Research As stated above, future studies need to rigorously investigate the impact of back health educational interventions on knowledge related to back health, ergonomics, and posture, utilizing high-quality research designs. It is imperative that these studies encompass children across the complete age spectrum from 4-18 years, including those in kindergarten, primary and secondary schools, as well as sixth-form colleges. The studies we included only comprised children aged 10-13. Systematic reviews should incorporate well-conducted randomised controlled trials (RCTs), which are regarded as the gold standard for evaluating interventions. However, it is essential that these RCTs are conducted and operationalised at the highest level. This is because we found that several of the RCT papers did not score highly on the Downs and Black risk-of-bias (ROB) form. Furthermore, authors need to possess a comprehensive understanding of research designs and methodology to accurately assess research papers and exclude non-randomized studies due to their lower evidence quality. Implementing blinded research to mitigate performance bias is recommended, though challenging within school settings. Furthermore, considering the limitations of ROB forms, only one form designed for assessing the quality of educational interventions was found. Therefore, most systematic reviews in this domain rely heavily on critical appraisal or risk of bias forms intended for clinical health research papers, potentially leading to errors. Supplemental Material Supplemental Material - School-Based Educational Interventions for Improving Knowledge of Back Health, Ergonomics and Postural Behaviour of School Children Aged 4-18 Years: A Best Evidence Systematic Review Supplemental Material for School-Based Educational Interventions for Improving Knowledge of Back Health, Ergonomics and Postural Behaviour of School Children Aged 4-18 Years: A Best Evidence Systematic Review by Weiyao Yang in Campbell Systematic Reviews. Author Contributions: Substantial contributions to conception and design: Josette Bettany-Saltikov, Robert Mcsherry, Paul van Schaik and Gok Kandasamy. Study search and selection: Julie Hogg, Josette Bettany-Saltikov, Roongtip Duangkaew, Gok Kandasamy, Paul van Schaik, and Fiona Mcpherson. Methodological assessment: Josette Bettany-Saltikov, Roongtip Duangkaew, Robert Mcsherry, Gok Kandasamy, Garikotz Aristegui, Paul van Schaik, Fiona Mcpherson and Mona Salman. Acquisition/abstraction of data: Josette Bettany-Saltikov, Roongtip Duangkaew, Gok Kandasamy, Garikotz Aristegui, Robert Mcsherry, Paul van Schaik, Fiona Mcpherson. Data analysis: Josette Bettany-Saltikov, Gok Kandasamy, Robert Mcsherry, Paul van Schaik. Interpretation of data: Josette Bettany-Saltikov, Gok Kandasamy, Robert Mcsherry. Drafting of the article: Josette Bettany-Saltikov, Robert Mcsherry Mona Salman, Gok Kandasamy. Critical revision for important intellectual content: Josette Bettany-Saltikov, Robert Mcsherry, Roongtip Duangkaew, Gok Kandasamy, Mona Salman. Information retrieval expertise. Julie Hogg. Who is responsible for the below areas? Please list their names: Content: Bettany-Saltikov J,Rob Mcsherry, Roongtip Duangkaew, Gok Kandasamy, Paul van Schaik, Mona Salman. Systematic review methods: Bettany-Saltikov J, Rob Mcsherry, Roongtip Duangkaew, Fiona Mcpherson, Mona Salman. Statistical analysis: Van-Schaik P. Information retrieval: Julie Hogg, Roongtip Duangkaew, Fiona Mcpherson, Mona Salman Funding: The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. Plans for updating this review: The review will be updated every 2-3 years. JBS, GK, RMSs and RD will be responsible Differences Between Protocol and Review: In the protocol we had stated that we would use the Downs and Black (1998) risk of bias form together with the criteria recommended by the Cochrane back review group (Higgins et al., 2011). Unfortunately, when we tried to do this the process became much too complicated and we therefore decided to only use the Back and Downs form. Furthermore, in the protocol we had stated that physical activity or exercise only interventions would be excluded. This was modified slightly to exclude any study that comprised an intervention that included exercises or physical activity. We decided to focus on the educational (teaching and learning) aspects of the intervention. Supplemental Material: Supplemental material for this article is available online. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplemental Material - School-Based Educational Interventions for Improving Knowledge of Back Health, Ergonomics and Postural Behaviour of School Children Aged 4-18 Years: A Best Evidence Systematic Review Supplemental Material for School-Based Educational Interventions for Improving Knowledge of Back Health, Ergonomics and Postural Behaviour of School Children Aged 4-18 Years: A Best Evidence Systematic Review by Weiyao Yang in Campbell Systematic Reviews.