Learner-Educator Co-creation of Student Assessment in Health Professional Education Courses: A Scoping Review Authors: Laura A. Killam, Christina Godfrey, Mercedes Lock, Renée Gordon, Amanda Ross‐White, Marian Luctkar‐Flude Published: 2026 ABSTRACT BackgroundCo-creation means engaging learners in working collaboratively to make decisions about course planning, implementation, or student assessment. Involving students in these decisions potentially enhances learning. When co-creation is part of assessment, it may reach more learners but may also pose pragmatic challenges. In this review, we focused on co-creation of assessment that may occur at any time during a health professional course. Systematic examination of learner-educator co-creation is needed to inform how educators can engage strategically in co-creation with healthcare students.ObjectivesThe objective of this scoping review was to examine strategies for collaborative learner-educator decision-making during the design, implementation, or evaluation of student assessment in health professional education.Search MethodsSearches were conducted until August 1, 2024, in six databases with no date limitation (MEDLINE, Embase, Education Source Complete, CINAHL, ERIC and APA PsycInfo). Reference lists of included full-text papers and papers close to meeting inclusion criteria were manually searched, along with publications by conference abstract authors.Selection CriteriaWe included all papers focused on how learners and educators share decision making regarding student assessment during a health professional course. Information about co-creation that occurs outside of a course or is not related to student assessment was excluded.Data Collection and AnalysisStandard procedures for reviewing and summarizing data according to JBI methodology were used. Two reviewers independently screened documents and extracted data. Data about paper characteristics, where co-creation occurs, decisions that are co-created, process descriptions, and author conclusions were extracted and summarized.Main ResultsWe screened 11,517 titles and abstracts, then 341 full-text reports for eligibility. In total, we identified 27 reports published between 1980 and 2025 that describe 25 unique courses where co-creation of assessment has been reported in the literature.Co-creation of assessment was reported in nursing, social work, medicine, health services navigation, paramedicine, pharmacy, occupational therapy and dental technology disciplines, at the undergraduate, graduate, and postgraduate levels. Most courses where co-creation occurred were mandatory. Reports spanned various years of study. Many assessment decisions were made together, predominantly assessment instructions and grading criteria. Diverse ways of co-creating with different levels of student influence over decisions were reported. The most reported strategy for co-creation was discussion during class time or in individual meetings. A wide range of benefits and ways to support co-creation were reported. Barriers, disadvantages, and future considerations were also reported.ConclusionsThis review identifies and synthesizes existing examples of co-creation of assessment that have been integrated into health professional education. While it was mainly portrayed positively across included literature, there remains a lack of rigorous and diverse research in this area. The interventions identified in this review are diverse and highly contextual, limiting generalizability. Our findings provide a preliminary list of reported cases of co-creation of assessment and highlight contextual influences on implementation. Implementation processes need to be described in more detail to promote replication. Future research is needed to explore educator and student experiences, evaluate learning outcomes, and evaluate applicability across contexts to support evidence-informed practice. Co-creation of assessment offers a promising yet under-researched approach to creating more collaborative and authentic assessment strategies. It warrants thoughtful, context-specific application, research, and reporting in the literature. Background The Problem There is growing interest in inclusive and empowering ways of teaching in health professional education. Teacher-directed approaches in education where knowledge is transmitted from experts to passive students such as through lecture and memorizing textbooks may create excessive cognitive load and be ineffective for preparing learners for applied tasks in health professional education (Salari et al., 2018; Spicer et al., 2018), particularly when they are overused or fail to engage learners. Educational reformers throughout history have advocated for learner-engaged approaches to education where the goal is to develop learner metacognition through involving learners more actively in knowledge discovery and problem-solving (Dewey, 1938; Freire, 1973; Giroux, 2020; Thomas, 2022). Several approaches for actively engaging learners in their education have been integrated into health professional education. For example, collaborative problem-solving may occur during clinical placements, simulation, or other interactive teaching strategies. Another approach is to engage learners as partners in decision-making in areas such as curriculum, content, learning activities, and assessment. For health professional learners, shared decision making with patients, interprofessional teams, and other key persons following graduation has been argued to be a critical skill needed for patient-centered care (Cribb et al., 2017). Cribb et al. (2017) argued that for medical graduates to be prepared to make joint decisions about how to solve healthcare problems with key persons after graduation, it is important to embed opportunities to learn how to co-create during their education. The term co-creation is used in a variety of ways to describe shared decision making with different parties. In healthcare, co-creation has involved patients, healthcare professionals, and other key persons in collaborative problem-solving (Cribb et al., 2017). Working with others who are more knowledgeable than the learner in an interactive way is theorized to enhance learner development (Vygotsky, 1978). For example, nursing and midwifery learners have been found to gain confidence, improve relationships, and develop their skills when they work with service users and carers to make decisions (O'Connor et al., 2021). Similarly, in both nursing and educational contexts, co-creation has been described as a transformative practice that repositions learners as partners in knowledge construction (Cook-Sather et al., 2019; Dyson, 2018). However, this type of collaboration often occurs in a clinical context, where placement experiences vary widely and it is not possible to guarantee that learners will have the opportunity to co-create. In contrast, embedding co-creation into courses is an equitable strategy that enables educators to intentionally design opportunities for collaborative decision-making that are consistently available to all learners. However, health professional education is often regulated by external accreditation processes, which prioritize quality assurance, define competencies, and establish measurable outcomes, while at the same time inadvertently limiting flexibility and innovation (Burdick & Dhillon, 2020; Frenk et al., 2010). As Frenk et al. (2010) explain, while these systems aim to ensure quality and accountability they lead to standardized, rigid, and outdated curricula that contribute to a mismatch between graduate competencies and real-world health priorities. This problem further underscores the need for more adaptive, evidence-based participatory pedagogical approaches like learner-educator co-creation in health professional education. Learner-educator co-creation may occur during course planning, discussions, activities, and assessment. The intent of sharing decision-making power with learners is to engage them in reflection, develop critical thinking skills, and improve learner preparation for practice (Dyson, 2018; Killam, et al., 2023). Other benefits of active learner participation in designing courses may include improved relationships, enhanced learner confidence, more depth in learning, improved academic performance, and development of collaboration skills (Bovill, 2020a, 2020b; Bovill & Bulley, 2011; Doyle et al., 2020; Ha & Pepin, 2017). Co-creation also promotes a shift from hierarchical teacher-student dynamics toward relational pedagogies rooted in trust, respect, reciprocity, and shared responsibility (Cook-Sather, 2014; Cook-Sather et al., 2019). These benefits are particularly important for graduates of health professional programs who need to be equipped to be both clinically competent and function effectively within teams. Further, co-creation has been described as mutually beneficial for both learners and educators as new insights into pedagogy are gained (Cook-Sather, 2014; Dyson, 2018; Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024). Health professional learners face emotional challenges and a recent scoping review identified co-creation as a reported strategy to positively influence learner well-being in multiple ways (Suliman et al., 2025). However, learner-educator co-creation may be pragmatically challenging within a course due to the time-consuming nature of participative pedagogy and uncertainty about how to involve learners in curriculum decisions (Bovill & Bulley, 2011). Concerns have also been raised about the scalability and sustainability of leveraging the potential of partnerships with learners (Barradell & Bell, 2021). There remains a need to balance the pressures of industrialized education with the benefits of discursive teaching strategies in health professional education in a way that is feasible. There are also concerns about equitable access to these partnership opportunities. Unfortunately, opportunities for learner educator co-creation during formal education are often limited to small groups of volunteers (Bovill, 2020b; Suliman et al., 2025). For example, learners may work outside of a course context to co-create curriculum or work on research projects. When co-creation opportunities occur outside of coursework, it does not reach all learners in a program, and often, already socially privileged learners are the ones who benefit (Bovill, 2020b; Mercer-Mapstone & Bovill, 2020). Typically, these partnership opportunities are offered to learners who are already highly engaged in their education and can afford to participate (Mercer-Mapstone & Bovill, 2020). Some learners may not be able to access extracurricular activities (e.g., learners who need to work in order to pay for their education and may therefore not have the time to volunteer). Purposeful action is therefore needed to ensure that all learners enrolled in a program have the opportunity to co-create with educators (Mercer-Mapstone & Bovill, 2020). One way to achieve the goal of reaching all learners in a course is to embed opportunities for co-creation into assessment practices. Integrating co-creation into assessments provides a structured and equitable opportunity for all learners to participate regardless of their ability to engage in extracurricular or voluntary initiatives. Embedding co-creation in assessment also aligns with calls for more authentic, participatory approaches to assessment that build learners’ evaluative judgment and readiness for collaborative professional practice (Killam, Camargo-Plazas et al., 2024). This strategy also enhances the preparedness of health professional graduates for real-world practice by developing collaborative decision-making skills through simulating it in the formal curriculum. Although co-creation in any aspect of education may also be beneficial, we focused this review on assessment co-creation because of the complex, high-stakes, and regulated nature of assessment in health professional education. In addition, health professional courses may enroll large numbers of students and meaningful co-creation is reportedly difficult with larger groups (Suliman et al., 2025). Despite discourse around the benefits of co-creation, little is known about how co-creation has been used in the context of assessment within health professional education. Therefore, the focus of this review was learner-educator co-creation of assessment during courses in health professional education. Definitions For the purposes of this review,• Learners were students enrolled in a course in an academic context.• Educators were people employed by an academic institution to design and facilitate course(s). They held a position of power over learners’ course grades or progression through the program (including on a pass/fail basis). In the literature, educators were also called teachers, instructors, professors, tutors, or faculty.• Co-creation was defined as engaging learners as partners during decision-making in an interactive way (Bovill, 2020a, 2020b; Killam, Lock, et al., 2023). While it overlaps with the goals of other forms of active learning, co-creation emphasizes learner empowerment and involves a deeper interaction between parties during decision-making (Bovill, 2020a, 2020b; Martens et al., 2019).• Assessment within a course was defined as a process whereby a learner’s knowledge or skills were inferred through analysis of evidence. During assessment, learner work is used to evaluate, measure, and document learner progress or skills in a way that helps to determine if a learner will pass a course. Assessment decisions may include, but are not limited to, planning course outcomes or assessment learning outcomes, instructions, due dates, grading criteria, and/or deciding on final grades.• Co-creation of assessment was the active involvement of learners in decision making about one or more decisions in relation to planning or completing assessments. It involved sharing control over these decisions with students. In higher education literature, there are several overlapping terms used to refer to co-creation of assessment, such as co-assessment, co-design, co-construction, coproduction, and consensus grading.• Health professional disciplines were defined according to international standards (International Labour Organization, 2012). These professions included medical doctors, nursing, midwifery, complementary medicine, paramedical practitioners, dentistry, pharmacy, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, respiratory therapy, dieticians, nutritionists, audiologists, speech therapists, optometrists, and other allied health programs. For example, we included social work and counseling as allied health disciplines since they are recognized for contributions to health and social care systems (Ashcroft et al., 2024; Micallef Marmara & Kemer, 2023).• Health professional education included academic coursework in a program that prepares learners to practice in any health profession. These programs included, but were not limited to, any academic undergraduate or graduate health professions program pre- or post-licensure. It also included programs that prepared learners to practice in any of the listed professions in countries where licensure is not required.• Courses were units of teaching that lasted a pre-determined length of time, were led by educator(s), and had a fixed list of registered learners. This list may be any size. Learners needed to complete courses to earn academic credits that counted towards earning educational credentials (e.g., a degree). • Learners were students enrolled in a course in an academic context. • Learners were students enrolled in a course in an academic context. • Educators were people employed by an academic institution to design and facilitate course(s). They held a position of power over learners’ course grades or progression through the program (including on a pass/fail basis). In the literature, educators were also called teachers, instructors, professors, tutors, or faculty. • Educators were people employed by an academic institution to design and facilitate course(s). They held a position of power over learners’ course grades or progression through the program (including on a pass/fail basis). In the literature, educators were also called teachers, instructors, professors, tutors, or faculty. • Co-creation was defined as engaging learners as partners during decision-making in an interactive way (Bovill, 2020a, 2020b; Killam, Lock, et al., 2023). While it overlaps with the goals of other forms of active learning, co-creation emphasizes learner empowerment and involves a deeper interaction between parties during decision-making (Bovill, 2020a, 2020b; Martens et al., 2019). • Co-creation was defined as engaging learners as partners during decision-making in an interactive way (Bovill, 2020a, 2020b; Killam, Lock, et al., 2023). While it overlaps with the goals of other forms of active learning, co-creation emphasizes learner empowerment and involves a deeper interaction between parties during decision-making (Bovill, 2020a, 2020b; Martens et al., 2019). • Assessment within a course was defined as a process whereby a learner’s knowledge or skills were inferred through analysis of evidence. During assessment, learner work is used to evaluate, measure, and document learner progress or skills in a way that helps to determine if a learner will pass a course. Assessment decisions may include, but are not limited to, planning course outcomes or assessment learning outcomes, instructions, due dates, grading criteria, and/or deciding on final grades. • Assessment within a course was defined as a process whereby a learner’s knowledge or skills were inferred through analysis of evidence. During assessment, learner work is used to evaluate, measure, and document learner progress or skills in a way that helps to determine if a learner will pass a course. Assessment decisions may include, but are not limited to, planning course outcomes or assessment learning outcomes, instructions, due dates, grading criteria, and/or deciding on final grades. • Co-creation of assessment was the active involvement of learners in decision making about one or more decisions in relation to planning or completing assessments. It involved sharing control over these decisions with students. In higher education literature, there are several overlapping terms used to refer to co-creation of assessment, such as co-assessment, co-design, co-construction, coproduction, and consensus grading. • Co-creation of assessment was the active involvement of learners in decision making about one or more decisions in relation to planning or completing assessments. It involved sharing control over these decisions with students. In higher education literature, there are several overlapping terms used to refer to co-creation of assessment, such as co-assessment, co-design, co-construction, coproduction, and consensus grading. • Health professional disciplines were defined according to international standards (International Labour Organization, 2012). These professions included medical doctors, nursing, midwifery, complementary medicine, paramedical practitioners, dentistry, pharmacy, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, respiratory therapy, dieticians, nutritionists, audiologists, speech therapists, optometrists, and other allied health programs. For example, we included social work and counseling as allied health disciplines since they are recognized for contributions to health and social care systems (Ashcroft et al., 2024; Micallef Marmara & Kemer, 2023). • Health professional disciplines were defined according to international standards (International Labour Organization, 2012). These professions included medical doctors, nursing, midwifery, complementary medicine, paramedical practitioners, dentistry, pharmacy, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, respiratory therapy, dieticians, nutritionists, audiologists, speech therapists, optometrists, and other allied health programs. For example, we included social work and counseling as allied health disciplines since they are recognized for contributions to health and social care systems (Ashcroft et al., 2024; Micallef Marmara & Kemer, 2023). • Health professional education included academic coursework in a program that prepares learners to practice in any health profession. These programs included, but were not limited to, any academic undergraduate or graduate health professions program pre- or post-licensure. It also included programs that prepared learners to practice in any of the listed professions in countries where licensure is not required. • Health professional education included academic coursework in a program that prepares learners to practice in any health profession. These programs included, but were not limited to, any academic undergraduate or graduate health professions program pre- or post-licensure. It also included programs that prepared learners to practice in any of the listed professions in countries where licensure is not required. • Courses were units of teaching that lasted a pre-determined length of time, were led by educator(s), and had a fixed list of registered learners. This list may be any size. Learners needed to complete courses to earn academic credits that counted towards earning educational credentials (e.g., a degree). • Courses were units of teaching that lasted a pre-determined length of time, were led by educator(s), and had a fixed list of registered learners. This list may be any size. Learners needed to complete courses to earn academic credits that counted towards earning educational credentials (e.g., a degree). Learner-Educator Co-Creation of Assessment Conceptual clarity about what co-creation involves is complicated by the many terms used to describe it, ambiguity in how it is defined, and overlapping and inconsistently defined terminology in existing literature (Martens et al., 2019). Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation was used in this review to differentiate co-creation from less active forms of learner participation in assessment design. In this review, we included Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) top four levels of learner participation where learner influence was limited to specific areas of a course that were pre-defined by the educator (level 5) or selected by learners (level 6) to where learners partnered with educators in negotiating curriculum (level 7) or were in control over decision-making (level 8) (Bovill & Bulley, 2011). We excluded the lower levels of learner participation on this ladder where educators remained in control over planned curriculum (level 1), portrayed a false sense that learners can influence decisions (level 2), or limited choices to a pre-defined set of prescribed options (levels 3 and 4). Martens et al. (2019) also conceptualized co-creation as falling on the upper end of this ladder since learners have more influence on decision-making during co-creation than in other forms of participation. Suliman et al. (2025) refer to involvement in design without interaction with educators as ‘pseudo-partnerships,’ further highlighting the need for conceptual precision in this review. During co-creation, educators do more than listen to student feedback; they focus on empowerment and partnership with learners by including them in decision-making at a level that is appropriate for the course context and learner readiness (Bovill & Bulley, 2011; Killam, Lock, et al., 2023). The key differentiating feature of papers that were included was the active involvement of learners in influencing or substantially shaping decisions about learner assessment, since it is a critical aspect of health professional education, influencing learner progression, licensure, and career opportunities that is uniquely high-stakes and highly influenced by power dynamics. In health professional education co-creation of assessment has been used in course contexts, as illustrated by examples such as: (a) creating simulations with undergraduate nursing and occupational therapy master’s learners (Killam & Luctkar-Flude, 2021; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022; MacKenzie et al., 2018), (b) determining limited undergraduate nursing exam design characteristics (Killam, Luctkar-Flude, et al., 2022), (c) teaching qualitative research at the graduate level (Abboud et al., 2017), and (d) determining postgraduate nursing learner oral viva grades (Henderson et al., 2022). Despite the use of co-creation of assessment in health professional education, ambiguity exists in how educators engage learners in co-creation within the physical or virtual classroom. A beginning understanding of principles to guide equity-centered learner-educator co-creation have been proposed, but the authors indicate that they require refinement based on existing evidence, disciplinary context, and awareness of pragmatic limitations (Killam, Lock, et al., 2023). These principles were derived based on reflections on practice and literature and include: prioritizing equity, reflecting on values, negotiating power-sharing, engaging in active and honest dialogue, integrating choice and flexibility, building respectful relationships, and promoting a psychologically safer environment (Killam, Lock, et al., 2023). Reflecting on examples of how co-creation of assessment has occurred, what decisions were made together, and how those decisions were made is an important step for educators considering co-creation of assessment in their own contexts. Co-creating assessment activities during a course can be intentionally designed to mitigate potential unintended harm arising from power dynamics (Killam, Camargo-Plazas et al., 2024; Killam, et al., 2023). The relationship between learners and educators during a course is influenced by the power educators hold over grades. This hierarchical structure leads to an imbalance, where learners may feel personally at risk when redefining traditional roles (Könings et al., 2021). In contrast, co-creation in informal or clinical settings may evolve more organically and feel less constrained by grading-related power dynamics. Unfortunately, informal or clinical opportunities may reach only a few students. When embedded in a course, co-creation can reach all learners, but learners may experience vulnerability during learner-educator co-creation of assessment during a course since a productive experience involving honest feedback could mean exposing their limitations or possibly offending their educator (Johnson et al., 2020), which may cause learners to avoid critical dialogue (Könings et al., 2021). Learners may therefore want to conceal these thoughts to protect their grades, which typically reflect learner progression through programs and thereby influence scholarships. Without careful planning, decision-making processes could also inadvertently lead to feelings of exclusion and disadvantage for already marginalized students (Killam, et al., 2023). Educators may also face challenges in implementing co-creation, particularly when assessment is involved. These challenges could include discomfort with power-sharing, fear of unpredictable outcomes, and skepticism about the value of learner input (Könings et al., 2021). These tensions may be heightened in the context of assessment, where educators are responsible for grading accuracy and fairness. Other potentially negative consequences of learner-educator co-creation of assessment need to be identified to help educators decide if co-creation is an appropriate tool for their context. The Need for This Review More evidence about learner-educator co-creation of assessments in course contexts is needed to inform educational practices. Learner-educator co-creation in health care contexts may serve to support quality education through enhancing how education meets learner needs, which may support United Nations (2015) Sustainable Development Goal 4 (quality education; United Nations, 2015). Learner-educator co-creation may also be a strategy to help develop learner teamwork, complex problem-solving, and advocacy skills (Blau & Shamir-Inbal, 2017; Dyson, 2018), which are necessary to develop during health professional education to promote a workforce capable of addressing global health challenges, such as advocating for United Nations (2015) Sustainable Development Goal 3 (good health and well-being). In this review we have chosen to focus on co-creation related to learner assessment because in higher education literature (1) co-creation outside of a course has been criticized for failing to be accessible to all learners in a program (Bovill, 2020b; Mercer-Mapstone & Bovill, 2020), (2) co-creation within a course that is not part of assessment may also fail to reach all learners in the course, (3) the stakes for learners are higher during assessment, (4) co-creation of assessment may be complicated by potential learner vulnerability, and (5) the feasibility of co-creation related to assessments remains unknown. A preliminary search of MEDLINE, the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Epistemonikos, and JBI Evidence Synthesis was conducted in July 2023. We were unable to identify any published or ongoing scoping reviews about co-creation of assessment in the context of health professional education. A discussion on existing reviews that cover some aspects of this topic can be found in our protocol (Killam, Egan, et al., 2024). Most of the findings in these reviews focused on co-creation outside of a course context and findings specific to co-creation of assessments were not captured. At that time there were no known systematic reviews or scoping reviews that described strategies for learner-educator co-creation of assessment in health professional education. Owing to the broad nature of our research questions, a scoping review was needed to understand how learner-educator co-creation of assessment is implemented, investigated, and reported in the literature. Objectives The objectives of this scoping review were to answer the following question: What has been reported in the literature about learner-educator co-creation of assessment in health professional education? More specifically, we aimed to identify:(1) Where is learner-educator co-creation of assessment occurring? (e.g., which disciplines, course types, level of learner, year of study)(2) What course assessment decisions are influenced or being made together? (i.e., assessment instructions and/or grades)(3) How much influence do learners have on decision-making? (i.e., where does it fall on Bovill and Bulley’s ladder of participation)(4) How do learners and educators go about making decisions together? (i.e., discussion or voting, with a whole class or portion of the class)(5) What are the perceived facilitators, barriers, disadvantages, benefits, and/or future considerations reported by the authors? (1) Where is learner-educator co-creation of assessment occurring? (e.g., which disciplines, course types, level of learner, year of study) (1) Where is learner-educator co-creation of assessment occurring? (e.g., which disciplines, course types, level of learner, year of study) (2) What course assessment decisions are influenced or being made together? (i.e., assessment instructions and/or grades) (2) What course assessment decisions are influenced or being made together? (i.e., assessment instructions and/or grades) (3) How much influence do learners have on decision-making? (i.e., where does it fall on Bovill and Bulley’s ladder of participation) (3) How much influence do learners have on decision-making? (i.e., where does it fall on Bovill and Bulley’s ladder of participation) (4) How do learners and educators go about making decisions together? (i.e., discussion or voting, with a whole class or portion of the class) (4) How do learners and educators go about making decisions together? (i.e., discussion or voting, with a whole class or portion of the class) (5) What are the perceived facilitators, barriers, disadvantages, benefits, and/or future considerations reported by the authors? (5) What are the perceived facilitators, barriers, disadvantages, benefits, and/or future considerations reported by the authors? Methods Inclusion Criteria We included peer-reviewed and other publications produced globally that outlined how learner-educator co-creation of assessment has been used in health professional education. Participants (Role and Discipline) Perspectives of both learners and course educators were included in this review. Reports could detail the perspectives of one or both participant types. Partners in learner-educator co-creation needed to include both learner(s) and educator(s). Co-creation with others was excluded unless the learner and course educator were both also part of the co-creation process. To be included, participants needed to be from health professional disciplines, meaning that they were from any program that prepares them for practice. Reports with mixed disciplines in the same course were also included. Participants who were co-creating in hospital or other service provider settings were excluded. In addition, coursework that was part of obtaining a degree in pure sciences (i.e., biology) was excluded. We excluded veterinarian professional education since their practice is with animals. Concept (Co-Creation of Assessment) Learner-educator co-creation of any aspect of student assessment during a course was the concept of interest for this scoping review. To be classified as co-creation, the report needed to describe an effort to share power with learners during any assessment-related decision-making process in an interactive way. Learners must also have explicit control or substantial influence over assessment decisions to be classified as at or above level 5 on Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation. Where the level on the ladder was unclear, we included the study if there was an indication that it was most likely level 5 or above based on article wording. The kinds of decisions that learners and educators collaborated on could be limited to prescribed areas of the assessment, as long as the choices that learners had were not predetermined. Learner-educator co-creation during a course could range from influencing one decision about course assessments to making many decisions together. Any situation where an educator invited current learners to substantially influence assessment decisions through collaboration with them, which is traditionally only made by an educator, was included. To be included, a major focus of the report must be on learner-educator co-creation of assessment. To be considered a major focus of the report, co-creation must be evident in the abstract. We did not consider reports for full-text review if they did not refer to co-creation in the abstract. During the search, a broad definition of co-creation as interactive shared decision making was used. The term “co-creation” is often misused (Bovill, 2020b), which means that a definition or description is essential to ensure that co-creation is interactive and not simply an act of seeking learner input on a decision. Any article that used the terms co-creation, co-design, co-production, co-construction, consensus grading, or other related terms alongside a definition or description of the process was included. To be included, learner-educator co-creation must relate to any aspect of learner assessment during the course. Evaluation is another term that was included when it referred to making a value judgment about learner work that led to a grade. There are many kinds of assessment, which may be labeled as objective (sometimes called traditional), performance-based, and/or authentic assessment. All types of assessment may involve co-creation and were therefore included in this review. Articles were included if they discussed co-creation of assessment and answered RQ1 and RQ2 in a way that was separate from content in the article related to other interventions or forms of co-creation. Specifically, in some cases, findings related to co-creation of assessment were embedded within broader discussions of co-creation or other student empowerment initiatives. We only included articles where the content related to co-creation of assessment could be clearly identified and meaningfully extracted to address our review questions. Publications that say they engaged in collaborative decision making but did not describe or define how decisions were made were excluded. Publications about co-construction of knowledge or content curation that did not address course assessment decisions were excluded. Self-assessment in the absence of written or verbal dialogue with an educator was also excluded. Articles about providing feedback, mentorship, or guidance were also excluded unless co-creation was used in these processes. Context (During a Course) The context of the review was academic course assessment. Learner-educator co-creation must have occurred during the time learners were registered in a mandatory or elective course of any size. Decisions they co-created must have impacted the course that students were registered in. Reports that described co-creation at a curriculum level or where learners volunteered for co-creation opportunities outside of a course context were excluded because their involvement impacts future learners (not themselves). Publications about co-design of educational materials (such as mobile applications or simulations) were excluded unless it occurred during a course for use in that same course. Co-creation in a placement or clinical context was also excluded since collaboration is understood as a natural part of these placements and is not the focus of this review. We excluded hospital-based training programs for similar reasons. In addition, learners working as co-researchers outside of a course context were excluded. Publications that referred to co-creation in a variety of contexts were only included if the use of co-creation in an academic course context was clearly distinguished from clinical and other contexts. If the source provided general guidance for learner-educator co-creation but did not refer to it in the context of a specific course, it was excluded. Types of Sources We included peer-reviewed reports published globally, as well as dissertations and editorials, discussion papers or commentaries published in peer-reviewed journals, as well as publicly available conference proceedings, white papers and reports on websites of reputable organizations. We excluded conference abstracts, posters, study protocols, social media posts, and opinions published outside of peer-reviewed journals. Study protocols, poster presentations, and conference abstracts were excluded because they did not provide adequate data to answer the research questions. We excluded other types of evidence due to feasibility. Without these sources, we already needed to screen a high number of indexed sources due to the broad range of terms we are using to identify co-creation. A previous review about learners as partners in health professional education, which was limited to qualitative research, noted that they needed to limit their search due to the impractical nature of screening high volumes of literature, which they stated may detract from the meaningfulness of a review’s findings (Barradell & Bell, 2021). In addition, during preliminary searches of Google and known blog posts, the data from these sources was limited in the quality of data that would answer the research questions. Searching for gray literature may also present challenges related to search methods, replicability, and resource intensity (Adams et al., 2016). To promote transparency and feasibility, we focused our search strategy on sources that were most relevant, accessible, and feasible to identify. Methodology This scoping review was conducted in accordance with standard procedures for conducting and reporting scoping reviews using the JBI methodology (Peters et al., 2020, 2021; Pollock et al., 2023), and our protocol was published in March 2024 (Killam, Egan, et al., 2024). JBI methodology was chosen since it is a rigorous and well-recognized approach for scoping reviews that was developed to address broad questions and synthesize the state of knowledge in topics relevant to health professions. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses extension for scoping review (PRISMA-ScR) checklist (Tricco et al., 2018) and relevant sections of the Methodological expectations of Campbell Collaboration intervention reviews (The Methods Coordinating Group of the Campbell Collaboration, 2017) were used to guide the reporting of the review. Search Strategy The search strategy was designed by an information specialist (ARW) and the lead author (LK) to locate published information. A three-step search strategy was utilized in this review: (1) the initial search to identify keywords, (2) a full search of all databases, and (3) a review of relevant reference lists and publications by conference abstract authors. First, an initial limited search of JBI, Cochrane, MEDLINE (Ovid), Scopus and Education Source (EBSCOhost) was undertaken to identify articles on the topic. Then, the words contained in the titles and abstracts of relevant articles, and the index terms used to describe the articles, were used to develop a full search strategy for MEDLINE and Education Source. This search strategy, including all identified keywords and index terms, was adapted for each included database (see Appendix 1). The databases searched included MEDLINE (via OVID, 1946–present), CINAHL (via EBSCOhost, 1981–present), Embase (via Ovid, 1947–present), Education Source (via EBSCOhost, 1929–present), ERIC (via EBSCOhost, 1966–present), and APA PsycInfo (via OVID, 1806–present). Each database was searched from the date of inception. Databases were last searched on August 1, 2024. The reference list of all included sources, as well as existing reviews and relevant reports related to co-creation of assessment identified during full text screening, was screened for additional papers. We also hand-searched the authors of conference abstracts excluded during full-text review by identifying a list of their publications online, reviewing titles, and importing on-topic records into Covidence. We contacted Dr. Bovill, Dr. Napan, and Dr. Thompson for assistance locating some of their work. We also hand searched The Journal of Educational Innovation, Partnership, and Change in July 2024, which is a non-indexed journal focused on learner-educator partnerships. We used the journal-specific search feature to search Teaching and Learning Together in Higher Education using a modified search strategy on July 12, 2025, and imported 20 results into Covidence for screening. We also conducted forward searching of included studies in July 2025. Papers published in any language were included if they were identified during the English-language search. No limitation on the date of publication was used. Gray literature searches were restricted to dissertations indexed by the respective databases and websites of referenced organizations. Evidence Selection Following the search, all identified citations were exported and uploaded into Covidence (Veritas Health Innovation). Duplicates were removed using Covidence and verified by the lead author. Following a pilot test, titles and abstracts were screened by two independent reviewers (LK, ML, RG, or FC) in Covidence for assessment against the inclusion criteria for the review. Reviewers were guided by an inclusion criteria summary document (Appendix 2). LK screened all papers except the ones she co-authored. Full-text review was also assessed within Covidence by two independent reviewers (LK, ML, RG, or FC). Again, LK screened all papers except ones she co-authored. Reviewers were guided by a hierarchy of reasons for exclusion (See Appendix 3). For example, all articles were assessed for the concept of co-creation prior to being assessed for the participants in co-creation. EndNote 20 (Clarivate Analytics) was used by individual reviewers to make notes on their articles. Any disagreements that arose between reviewers at each stage of the selection process were resolved through discussion. Additional reviewer(s) were involved in these discussions as needed (CG and/or MLF). Authors of reports were contacted to request missing or additional data, where necessary and possible. Quality Appraisal We had planned to conduct a quality appraisal of included studies. However, quality appraisal was not completed as it is not a requirement in a scoping review and should only be completed when there is a rationale for doing so (Levac et al., 2010; Peters et al., 2021; Pollock et al., 2021). In a scoping review, data pertaining to the impact of interventions is not synthesized, and claims regarding the effectiveness of interventions are not made. Therefore, quality appraisal or discussion of the risk of bias is generally not recommended (Peters et al., 2021; Tricco et al., 2018). Data Extraction Data were extracted from reports included in the scoping review by two or more independent reviewers using a Covidence data extraction tool developed by the reviewers. The lead author extracted data from all included sources except the ones she co-authored. Consensus was checked by the lead author and verified by a second reviewer as needed. Disagreements between reviewers and items that were difficult to decipher in articles were resolved through discussion or with an additional reviewer. The data extracted included specific details about the participants, concept, context, study methods and key findings relevant to the review questions. As per the protocol, the data extraction tool was piloted by the lead author and modified during the review to include additional items necessary for the characteristics of the included reports table, as well as a free-text question for items to discuss that were unclear to the extractor. Data Analysis During data extraction, data were summarized in Covidence through simple deductive data categorization and basic inductive content analysis. Deductive data categorization involved selecting one or more multiple-choice options from pre-determined lists during data extraction. Comments or report quotations were added to support these selections. Selection lists were developed by the research team as part of the protocol (Killam, Egan, et al., 2024) and expanded to include more options and questions based on preliminary data extraction. For example, we added a selected response question for which assessment decisions were co-created to enable us to create an accurate bar chart. The options for this question were inductively created during preliminary data extraction then used during a second round of extraction to ensure data were complete. Basic inductive content analysis was done to summarize qualitative data pertaining to interventions presented in each report, reasons for co-creation (part of RQ1), which assessment decisions were being made together (RQ2), and overall author conclusions (RQ5) (Peters et al., 2021; Pollock et al., 2023). Quotations were extracted alongside codes used to summarize data extraction by two independent reviewers. Both summaries were reviewed again during consensus, collapsed, and re-checked by data extractors for completeness and accuracy. Differing interpretations were resolved through discussion. Reinterpretation of evidence was avoided to the extent possible (Pollock et al., 2023). However, inferences were sometimes made about whether courses were mandatory (part of RQ1), which assessment decisions were being made (RQ2), whether all learners were required to participate, and what strategies were used to promote feasibility (part of RQ4). In several papers, it was challenging to identify the answer to RQ3. When a paper included a definition of co-creation that referred to interactive decision-making, but no process description, it met our inclusion criteria. Where possible, we used the wording of the article to interpret how much influence learners had on decision-making. Where the level of influence was unclear, we categorized it as Level 5 on Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation when creating charts. Consensus data were exported from Covidence and managed in Microsoft Excel, to create charts and assist with counting categorized data. Narrative data were copied and edited in Microsoft Word to create summary tables to answer each research question. Then, LK collapsed data through coding similar narrative descriptions from tables and grouping data into categories, which were checked by a second reviewer. Adobe Illustrator was used to refine charts and create figures. Data Presentation Data are displayed in tabular form, charts, and accompanied by a narrative summary to answer each research question. Results Search Results Figure 1 outlines a PRISMA flow diagram for the search, which was last updated on August 1, 2024. Citations from electronic databases, hand searches, and forward searches were imported into Covidence. In total, 1,894 citations were added to title and abstract screening based on hand searching reference list of included reports, literature reviews, as well as general guidance papers that referred to examples. We also hand searched the authors of conference abstracts. In addition, we imported all 243 publications from The Journal of Educational Innovation, Partnership, and Change published prior to August 2024 and 20 publications from Teaching and Learning Together in Higher Education. We also conducted forward searching of included studies in July 2025, which yielded 89 additional records. After excluding duplicates, the title and abstract of 11,517 reports were screened for eligibility. During this review, 11,173 citations were deemed irrelevant.Figure 1.PRISMA diagram.Note. We screened both studies and non-research papers since there is limited literature in this area. The term ‘reports’ in this figure refers to studies as well as non-research papers. Companion papers are groups of multiple papers that described the same course and approach to co-creation of assessment in similar ways, which are counted as one report in this review. PRISMA diagram. Note. We screened both studies and non-research papers since there is limited literature in this area. The term ‘reports’ in this figure refers to studies as well as non-research papers. Companion papers are groups of multiple papers that described the same course and approach to co-creation of assessment in similar ways, which are counted as one report in this review. Excluded Reports We sought 344 reports, but three could not be located. We retrieved and assessed 341 full-text reports for eligibility and contacted authors for clarification as needed. In 10 cases, responses confirmed the exclusion of the report. In 1 case, the response resulted in the inclusion of the report. Non-responses from 7 authors resulted in team discussions to make the best possible decision about article inclusion based on available data, 1 of which was included. Of these, 314 reports were excluded because they were: off-topic (n = 10), the wrong evidence type (n = 11), not about co-creation (n = 78), did not involve learners and educators in co-creation (n = 20), co-creation was not about assessment (n = 76), co-creation did not occur during the course learners were currently registered in (n = 59), did not include health professional students (n = 54), or were about a course that was planned to occur in the future (n = 1). We excluded 4 books consisting of different reports of co-creation after reviewing the table of contents and importing each chapter individually into Covidence for assessment. Likewise, one referenced website with a list of case studies was excluded after hand searching these cases. Appendix 4 describes reasons for the exclusion of a selection of reports that were debated for inclusion or close to meeting the criteria. The full list of reasons for the exclusion of sources at full-text review that did not meet the criteria, as well as attempts to contact authors, is reported in Appendix 5. Included Reports We included 30 papers published between 1980 and 2025, which described 27 distinct reports including three pairs of companion papers. Companion papers were treated as the same report since they describe the same course and approach to assessment co-creation in similar ways where: (1) negotiation was embedded in a task-based syllabus (Martyn, 2000; Martyn & Husain, 1993), (2) Academic Co-Creative Inquiry was used for course co-creation within limitations (Napan, 2009; Napan et al., 2020), and (3) student and tutor consensus was used during grading (Thompson, Houston, & Dansie, 2017; 2017b). In addition, the same course involving co-creation of assessment was described in two separate research reports about consensus marking of online oral vivas (Henderson et al., 2021, 2022) as well as a non-research and research report about co-creation of virtual simulations as an assignment (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022). There were also two reports that described multiple courses. Therefore, 25 unique descriptions of courses involving co-creation of assessment are described in this review. Table 1 provides an overview of the main characteristics of included reports, including the aim, date, design (if applicable), sample or perspective represented (in non-research articles), context, intervention, and declarations. Key characteristics are also presented in Figure 2. Only two authorship teams included students as co-authors (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022).Table 1.Characteristics of Included ReportsSourceCountryAimStudy Date(s)DesignSampleCourse contextIntervention(s)Declarations Fox and West (1983) USADescribe and evaluate learning contracts.Not reportedQuantitative, pre-post survey and educator observation.Medicine.Introduction to clinical medicine.Learning contracts.None.92 students in a self-directed course section.49 1st and 46 2nd year students.Ethical approval not explicit. Hardigan (1994) USADetermine if students view contract grading as effective.1993 and 1994Quantitative, survey.Pharmacy.Communication.Learning contracts.None.61 students from two spring cohorts.Year 3.Ethical approval not explicit. Huff and McNown Johnson (1998) USAExplore strategies to empower students.1997Quantitative, quasi-experimental.Social work.Foundational graduate course.Learning contracts, formative feedback from students to educators, and narrative evaluations.None.46 students in two groups: 22 (experimental) and 24 (comparison).Year 1.Ethical approval not explicit. Waddell and Stephens (2000) USADescribe processes.Not reportedQuality improvement.Nursing.Leadership.Nominal group process and learning contracts.None.16 students.16 students.Ethical approval not explicit. Limin (2005) ChinaDescribe use and effectiveness.2003Quality improvement.Nursing.Nursing psychology.Learning contracts.None.142 students from 2 programs.142 students.Ethical approval not explicit. Phillips and Napan (2016) NZCritical reflection on tensions.2013Qualitative action research, poststructuralist critical reflexive analysis.Social work.Advanced principles and theory.Academic co-creative inquiry, which involves course co-creation.External funding.The author (educator) and 69 students.Year 3.No reported conflicts of interest.69 students.Ethical approval not explicit.Thompson, Houston, & Dansie (2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017)AustraliaEvaluate perceptions.2015Quantitative, survey that was part of a larger study.Paramedicine.Capstone course.Consensus grading of simulation performance.None.90 students.Year 3 (final year).Ethical approval obtained.94 students. Esambe (2018) South AfricaExplore the intervention.2015Qualitative, diffractive methodology.Dental technology.Research writing.Dialogical formative feedback during the completion of research proposals.Internal funding.14 students and 2 educators.Exit-level.No reported conflicts of interest.14 students.Ethical approval not explicit. MacKenzie et al. (2018) CanadaOutline guidance and impacts.Not reportedQualitative.Occupational therapy.Neurorehabilitation.Simulation co-construction, delivery, and debrief.None.8 students.Graduate.Ethical approval explicitly not required.8 senior students. Thompson et al. (2020) AustraliaEvaluate perceptions.Several years after 2015Quantitative, survey.Paramedicine.Fundamentals of paramedic practice.Consensus grading of simulation performance.None.88 students.Year 1.Ethical approval obtained.100 students. Henderson et al. (2021) AustraliaExplore student perceptions.Not reportedQualitative research using pre-existing data.Nursing.Capstone emergency nursing.Online viva and consensus marking approach.None.13 students.50 students.Ethical approval obtained.Postgraduate. Henderson et al. (2022) AustraliaCompare consensus marking to traditional assessor judgement and explore perceptions.Not reportedConvergent mixed-methods parallel research design.Nursing.Capstone emergency nursing.Oral vivas graded through assessor judgement compared to consensus marking.None.46 students.56 students.Ethical approval obtained.Postgraduate. Thompson et al. (2024) AustraliaEvaluate assessment pedagogy.Not reportedExplanatory sequential mixed methods design.Paramedicine.Resuscitation training.Consensus grading of simulation performance.None.Phase 1: Score comparison.Phase 1: 84 students.84 students.Ethical approval obtained.Phase 2: Survey.Phase 2: 77 students and 7 assessors.Final year undergraduate. Killam, Akerlind, et al. (2024) CanadaExplore differences in students’ experiences.2021-2023Qualitative research, phenomenography.Navigation and nursing.Empowerment and service navigation.Learner-educator co-creation of virtual simulation experience assignments.External funding.Co-authors included one learner.32 students.Year 3 nursing.Year 1 navigation.No reported conflicts of interest.82 learners: 22 navigation and 60 nursing students.Ethical approval obtained.Non-research reportsSourceCountryAimCo-creation datePerspective representedDisciplineCourse contextIntervention(s)Declarations Hengesbach (1980) USADescribe a course that applies adult education principles.Not reportedEducatorNursingReligion.Course redesign including learning contracts.None.Undergraduate elective.15 students. Martenson and Schwab (1993) GermanyDescribe reasons for contract learning.1991Both student and educatorMedicineMultiple courses.Learning contracts.None.Size not explicit. Owen-Mills (1996) NZDescribe how dialect is established.Dates not reportedEducatorNursingFirst-year undergraduate.Transformative curriculum with several strategies including negotiated assessment.None.Topic and size not explicit.Martyn (2000) and Martyn and Husain (1993)PakistanAdvocate for interventions.Dates not reportedEducatorNursingEnglish.A task-based syllabus and syllabus negotiation.None.Second-year undergraduate.15 learners.Napan (2009) and Napan et al. (2020)NZDescribe an innovative method for teaching in a hierarchical system.2006, 2007, and 2009Both student and educatorMultiple social practice practitioners (i.e., social work).Spirituality.Academic Co-creative inquiry (ACCI), involving course co-creation within limitations and learning contracts.None.Explore synergies between pedagogies.Unclear, between 2004 and 2016Graduate.Culturally responsive pedagogy.Positionality included creation of ACCI.7-15 students per delivery. Napan (2012) NZReflect on collaborative inquiry-based course delivery.2011EducatorMultiple social practice practitioners (i.e., social work).Reflecting on practice.ACCI, involving course co-creation, co-teaching, and respectful interviewing.None.Graduate elective.Learning contracts.Positionality included creation of ACCI.12 students. Hawkins (2015) USAEncourage educators to mentor students.Dates not reportedEducatorNursingWriting.Co-authorship with students during an independent study elective.None.Undergraduate independent study elective.Size not explicit. Napan (2016) NZDescribe how course-based ACCI develops practical wisdom.2015EducatorSocial workManagement and leadership in social services.ACCI involving course co-creation within limitations, learning contracts, peer- and self- reflection.None.Graduate.Positionality emphasized social justice, creativity, and practical wisdom.Year 2 (final year of a condensed program) Abboud et al. (2017) USADescribe a teaching method.Dates not reportedEducatorSeveral. The course is in the school of nursing.Research.A learner-centered and learner-driven course.None.Graduate elective.Size not explicit. Killam and Luctkar-Flude (2021) CanadaDescribe interventions.2019 and 2020EducatorNursingFamily assessment.Virtual simulation creation and gamification to encourage learner-educator co-creation.None.Year 1 undergraduate.About 70 learners in 2019; number not explicit in 2020.Killam, McAuliffe, et al. (2022). Co-authors included students.CanadaDescribe the process used to co-create a course assignment.2021Both student and educatorNavigation and nursingEmpowerment and service navigation.Interprofessional collaboration to co-create virtual online poverty simulation experiences for use in current and future courses.None.Year 3 nursing.Year 1 navigation.82 learners: 22 in navigation and 60 in nursing. Killam, Luctkar-Flude, and Tyerman (2024) CanadaDescribe an inclusive approach to integrating e-learning modules.Dates not reported.EducatorNursingSocial justice.Asynchronous e-modules with subsequent debriefing and reflection assignments.None.Year 3 undergraduate.Class size 60 to 70 per delivery. Killam et al. (in press) CanadaExplore negotiated grading.2018 and 2019EducatorNursing (and business)Undergraduate.Negotiated grading.None.Note. Under declarations, “none” means there was no reported funding or conflicts of interest. Ethical approval was not discussed in any non-research report. Sources with multiple citations in column 1 were treated as companion papers (i.e., the same report) since they describe the same course and approach to assessment co-creation. Data were extracted from both reports and combined in the tables. This table is ordered by publication date.Figure 2.Report characteristicsNote. Non-research reports refer to descriptions of innovations, concepts, or reflections where primary data were not collected. Quality improvement reports describe practical changes to improve teaching, which may involve some data collection but do not involve formal research methodologies or systematic analysis. Table 1.Characteristics of Included ReportsSourceCountryAimStudy Date(s)DesignSampleCourse contextIntervention(s)Declarations Fox and West (1983) USADescribe and evaluate learning contracts.Not reportedQuantitative, pre-post survey and educator observation.Medicine.Introduction to clinical medicine.Learning contracts.None.92 students in a self-directed course section.49 1st and 46 2nd year students.Ethical approval not explicit. Hardigan (1994) USADetermine if students view contract grading as effective.1993 and 1994Quantitative, survey.Pharmacy.Communication.Learning contracts.None.61 students from two spring cohorts.Year 3.Ethical approval not explicit. Huff and McNown Johnson (1998) USAExplore strategies to empower students.1997Quantitative, quasi-experimental.Social work.Foundational graduate course.Learning contracts, formative feedback from students to educators, and narrative evaluations.None.46 students in two groups: 22 (experimental) and 24 (comparison).Year 1.Ethical approval not explicit. Waddell and Stephens (2000) USADescribe processes.Not reportedQuality improvement.Nursing.Leadership.Nominal group process and learning contracts.None.16 students.16 students.Ethical approval not explicit. Limin (2005) ChinaDescribe use and effectiveness.2003Quality improvement.Nursing.Nursing psychology.Learning contracts.None.142 students from 2 programs.142 students.Ethical approval not explicit. Phillips and Napan (2016) NZCritical reflection on tensions.2013Qualitative action research, poststructuralist critical reflexive analysis.Social work.Advanced principles and theory.Academic co-creative inquiry, which involves course co-creation.External funding.The author (educator) and 69 students.Year 3.No reported conflicts of interest.69 students.Ethical approval not explicit.Thompson, Houston, & Dansie (2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017)AustraliaEvaluate perceptions.2015Quantitative, survey that was part of a larger study.Paramedicine.Capstone course.Consensus grading of simulation performance.None.90 students.Year 3 (final year).Ethical approval obtained.94 students. Esambe (2018) South AfricaExplore the intervention.2015Qualitative, diffractive methodology.Dental technology.Research writing.Dialogical formative feedback during the completion of research proposals.Internal funding.14 students and 2 educators.Exit-level.No reported conflicts of interest.14 students.Ethical approval not explicit. MacKenzie et al. (2018) CanadaOutline guidance and impacts.Not reportedQualitative.Occupational therapy.Neurorehabilitation.Simulation co-construction, delivery, and debrief.None.8 students.Graduate.Ethical approval explicitly not required.8 senior students. Thompson et al. (2020) AustraliaEvaluate perceptions.Several years after 2015Quantitative, survey.Paramedicine.Fundamentals of paramedic practice.Consensus grading of simulation performance.None.88 students.Year 1.Ethical approval obtained.100 students. Henderson et al. (2021) AustraliaExplore student perceptions.Not reportedQualitative research using pre-existing data.Nursing.Capstone emergency nursing.Online viva and consensus marking approach.None.13 students.50 students.Ethical approval obtained.Postgraduate. Henderson et al. (2022) AustraliaCompare consensus marking to traditional assessor judgement and explore perceptions.Not reportedConvergent mixed-methods parallel research design.Nursing.Capstone emergency nursing.Oral vivas graded through assessor judgement compared to consensus marking.None.46 students.56 students.Ethical approval obtained.Postgraduate. Thompson et al. (2024) AustraliaEvaluate assessment pedagogy.Not reportedExplanatory sequential mixed methods design.Paramedicine.Resuscitation training.Consensus grading of simulation performance.None.Phase 1: Score comparison.Phase 1: 84 students.84 students.Ethical approval obtained.Phase 2: Survey.Phase 2: 77 students and 7 assessors.Final year undergraduate. Killam, Akerlind, et al. (2024) CanadaExplore differences in students’ experiences.2021-2023Qualitative research, phenomenography.Navigation and nursing.Empowerment and service navigation.Learner-educator co-creation of virtual simulation experience assignments.External funding.Co-authors included one learner.32 students.Year 3 nursing.Year 1 navigation.No reported conflicts of interest.82 learners: 22 navigation and 60 nursing students.Ethical approval obtained.Non-research reportsSourceCountryAimCo-creation datePerspective representedDisciplineCourse contextIntervention(s)Declarations Hengesbach (1980) USADescribe a course that applies adult education principles.Not reportedEducatorNursingReligion.Course redesign including learning contracts.None.Undergraduate elective.15 students. Martenson and Schwab (1993) GermanyDescribe reasons for contract learning.1991Both student and educatorMedicineMultiple courses.Learning contracts.None.Size not explicit. Owen-Mills (1996) NZDescribe how dialect is established.Dates not reportedEducatorNursingFirst-year undergraduate.Transformative curriculum with several strategies including negotiated assessment.None.Topic and size not explicit.Martyn (2000) and Martyn and Husain (1993)PakistanAdvocate for interventions.Dates not reportedEducatorNursingEnglish.A task-based syllabus and syllabus negotiation.None.Second-year undergraduate.15 learners.Napan (2009) and Napan et al. (2020)NZDescribe an innovative method for teaching in a hierarchical system.2006, 2007, and 2009Both student and educatorMultiple social practice practitioners (i.e., social work).Spirituality.Academic Co-creative inquiry (ACCI), involving course co-creation within limitations and learning contracts.None.Explore synergies between pedagogies.Unclear, between 2004 and 2016Graduate.Culturally responsive pedagogy.Positionality included creation of ACCI.7-15 students per delivery. Napan (2012) NZReflect on collaborative inquiry-based course delivery.2011EducatorMultiple social practice practitioners (i.e., social work).Reflecting on practice.ACCI, involving course co-creation, co-teaching, and respectful interviewing.None.Graduate elective.Learning contracts.Positionality included creation of ACCI.12 students. Hawkins (2015) USAEncourage educators to mentor students.Dates not reportedEducatorNursingWriting.Co-authorship with students during an independent study elective.None.Undergraduate independent study elective.Size not explicit. Napan (2016) NZDescribe how course-based ACCI develops practical wisdom.2015EducatorSocial workManagement and leadership in social services.ACCI involving course co-creation within limitations, learning contracts, peer- and self- reflection.None.Graduate.Positionality emphasized social justice, creativity, and practical wisdom.Year 2 (final year of a condensed program) Abboud et al. (2017) USADescribe a teaching method.Dates not reportedEducatorSeveral. The course is in the school of nursing.Research.A learner-centered and learner-driven course.None.Graduate elective.Size not explicit. Killam and Luctkar-Flude (2021) CanadaDescribe interventions.2019 and 2020EducatorNursingFamily assessment.Virtual simulation creation and gamification to encourage learner-educator co-creation.None.Year 1 undergraduate.About 70 learners in 2019; number not explicit in 2020.Killam, McAuliffe, et al. (2022). Co-authors included students.CanadaDescribe the process used to co-create a course assignment.2021Both student and educatorNavigation and nursingEmpowerment and service navigation.Interprofessional collaboration to co-create virtual online poverty simulation experiences for use in current and future courses.None.Year 3 nursing.Year 1 navigation.82 learners: 22 in navigation and 60 in nursing. Killam, Luctkar-Flude, and Tyerman (2024) CanadaDescribe an inclusive approach to integrating e-learning modules.Dates not reported.EducatorNursingSocial justice.Asynchronous e-modules with subsequent debriefing and reflection assignments.None.Year 3 undergraduate.Class size 60 to 70 per delivery. Killam et al. (in press) CanadaExplore negotiated grading.2018 and 2019EducatorNursing (and business)Undergraduate.Negotiated grading.None.Note. Under declarations, “none” means there was no reported funding or conflicts of interest. Ethical approval was not discussed in any non-research report. Sources with multiple citations in column 1 were treated as companion papers (i.e., the same report) since they describe the same course and approach to assessment co-creation. Data were extracted from both reports and combined in the tables. This table is ordered by publication date. Characteristics of Included Reports Note. Under declarations, “none” means there was no reported funding or conflicts of interest. Ethical approval was not discussed in any non-research report. Sources with multiple citations in column 1 were treated as companion papers (i.e., the same report) since they describe the same course and approach to assessment co-creation. Data were extracted from both reports and combined in the tables. This table is ordered by publication date. Report characteristics Note. Non-research reports refer to descriptions of innovations, concepts, or reflections where primary data were not collected. Quality improvement reports describe practical changes to improve teaching, which may involve some data collection but do not involve formal research methodologies or systematic analysis. Description of Reports Country Included reports originated from 8 countries. Close to half (n = 13 of 27 reports) originated from North America; 6 were from Canada and 7 were from the United States. A total of 10 reports originated from Oceania, with 5 from New Zealand and 5 from Australia. The remaining 4 reports originated from Germany in Europe, Pakistan and China in Asia and South Africa. Aims and Interventions Co-creation of assessment was the main focus of 15 of 27 reports that included the following examples:• Learning contracts (i.e., negotiated agreements between students and educators used to collaboratively plan individualized assignments) (n = 4)• Learning contracts alongside other course changes or processes (n = 4)• Grading together (n = 5), and• Completion of assignments (n = 2) • Learning contracts (i.e., negotiated agreements between students and educators used to collaboratively plan individualized assignments) (n = 4) • Learning contracts (i.e., negotiated agreements between students and educators used to collaboratively plan individualized assignments) (n = 4) • Learning contracts alongside other course changes or processes (n = 4) • Learning contracts alongside other course changes or processes (n = 4) • Grading together (n = 5), and • Grading together (n = 5), and • Completion of assignments (n = 2) • Completion of assignments (n = 2) In 12 other reports, co-creation of assessment during courses was discussed as a strategy to support course co-creation (n = 3), simulation development (n = 3), and a variety of other initiatives. Co-creation of assessment was a major focus in 21 reports, whereas 6 reports focused on other interventions but answered RQ1 and RQ2 and were therefore included. Design In health professional education, approximately half of the existing evidence pertaining to co-creation of student assessment is from non-research sources (n = 13 of 27 reports), such as innovation papers or educator reflections. All of these non-research reports included educator perspectives of co-creation, and four included both learner and educator perspectives. Waddell and Stephens (2000) and Limin (2005) were considered quality improvement. These authors summarized data collected from students about learning contract use in nursing courses but did not conduct formal research. Of the 12 included research reports, 5 were quantitative studies, 5 were qualitative studies, and two used mixed methods. All research reports included student participants; three studies integrated the perspective of one, two or seven educators. All 5 quantitative researchers collected data using questionnaires; Fox and West (1983) also collected educator observations. The number of participants in quantitative studies varied from 46 graduate social worker students to 92 medical students. Qualitative researchers collected data using class recordings, course assignments, educator field notes, focus groups, interviews, open-ended surveys, participant observation, and self-reflection. The number of participants in qualitative studies ranged from 13 postgraduate students to author reflections and observations of 69 undergraduate students during a course. In the two mixed methods studies, interviews, student scores, and questionnaires were used to collect data from 46 nursing students in a course. Assessment Co-Creation The main findings from this review are summarized in Tables 2 through 5 and Figure 3 through 10.Table 2.Courses Where Co-Creation of Assessment OccurredCourse focusProgramDisciplineClass sizePurpose of Co-creationAssessment descriptionAssessment decisions Nursing (n = 11 courses) 1) Advanced qualitative research (Abboud et al., 2017)Graduate elective; various doctoral and post-doctoral years of study welcome.Several disciplines. The course is in the school of nursing.Not explicit.To meet unique needs of diverse students.Assignments are individualized and may include various types of research writing activities.Planning: Assessment instructions, grading criteria, and pass/fail vs. letter grade.Evaluation: Ongoing critique and feedback. 2) Comparative religion (Hengesbach, 1980)Undergraduate elective course; details not explicit.Nursing15.To enable self-direction, commitment, and ownership over learning using adult learning principles.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes, instructions, format, and grading criteria. 3) Unclear course focus (Owen-Mills, 1996)A first-year course that is likely mandatory in an undergraduate program.NursingNot explicit.To transform education, empower students, and produce graduates who can transform health care systems.Self/peer/educator evaluation worth 40% of the course grade.Planning: Grading criteria, weighting of assignments, and evaluation form design. 4) Leadership (Waddell & Stephens, 2000)An undergraduate course that is likely mandatory; details not explicit.Nursing16To individualize the course to meet the unique and diverse needs of adult learners.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes, instructions, format, and grading criteria. 5) Professional communication for nursing education and management (Martyn, 2000; Martyn & Husain, 1993)A second-year mandatory English course in an undergraduate program.Nursing15To meet students’ unique needs and produce leaders who are competent and confident in English communication.Public speaking and writing projects.Planning: Assessment focus, instructions, and format. 6) Nursing psychology (Limin, 2005)A mandatory undergraduate course; year not reported. After fundamental courses.Nursing142 (unclear if it is the Same class)To increase autonomy, independence, lifelong learning skills, confidence in self-directed learning, interest and engagement. To address challenges in past course delivery.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning objectives, instructions, format, due dates, and grading criteria. 7) Independent study to promote scholarly writing (Hawkins, 2015)Undergraduate independent study elective course; details not explicit.NursingNot explicit.To mentor students in writing while increasing scholarly productivity in an ethical way.Manuscript co-authorship (for publication after the course ends).Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, partnership expectations, communication modalities, and due dates.Completion: Assignment completion. 8) Emergency nursing capstone course (Henderson et al., 2021, 2022)Likely mandatory; postgraduate program; details not explicit.Nursing50–56.To prepare students for real-world reflection, self-evaluation, and lifelong learning by developing evaluative judgement.Oral viva grading using consensus marking compared to traditional grading. Oral vivas involved simulation.Evaluation: Performance feedback and final grades. 9a) family assessment (Killam & Luctkar-Flude, 2021)A first-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.NursingAbout 70 in 2019; number not explicit for 2020.To promote student engagement and invite students to create needed simulations.Simulation development as an option to earn 5% of the course grade.Completion: Assignment completion. 9b) family assessment (Killam et al. (in press))A first-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Nursing79To empower students, reduce fear, and build real-world skills and address dissatisfaction with traditional grading systems and student focus on grades.Not reported. Authors report it was essay writing.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, grading criteria.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades. 10a) social justice (Killam, Luctkar-Flude, & Tyerman, 2024)A third-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Nursing60 to 70 per delivery.To role-model anti-oppression and improve learning by reducing barriers, promoting accessibility, and focusing on authentic learning.Module debriefing and written reflection assignments.Planning: Assessment instructions, format, grading criteria, choices, and the syllabus. 10b) social justice and empowerment (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022)A third-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Nursing60 in one delivery. Other deliveries are not explicit.To empower students, shape their values, and prepare them to impact real-world change. To enrich learning, improve equity, develop critical thinking and self-assessment skills, and improve simulation relevance.Interprofessional virtual simulation creation and implementation.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, weighting, due dates, grading criteria, group assignment, and template creation.Completion: Assignment completion.Evaluation: Performance feedback. 11) Nursing research (Killam et al. (in press))A fourth-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Nursing52To empower students, reduce fear, and build real-world skills. Dissatisfaction with traditional grading systems and student focus on grades.Not reported. Authors indicate it was research writing and presentations.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, format, due dates, weighting, grading criteria.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades. Social and human services ( n = 6 courses) 1) human behavior in the social environment, a foundational course. (Huff & McNown Johnson, 1998)A first-year mandatory graduate course.Social work53To teach empowerment by empowering students. To guide them to focus on learning (not grades).Learning contracts supported by narrative evaluations. Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes, format, grading criteria, and weighting of assignments.Evaluation: Performance feedback. 2) Spirituality and social practice (Napan, 2009; Napan et al., 2020)A graduate course; details not explicit.Transdisciplinary including social work, counseling, and other social practice disciplines.7-15 students per delivery.To personalize prescribed outcomes and focus customized assignments within a non-authoritarian co-created course. To suit needs within limitations of accredited programs.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of assignments that were as creative as possible. Must have a written component and one presentation.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, format, and grading criteria.Evaluation: Final grades. 3) reflecting on practice (Napan, 2012)A masters-level elective; year not reported.Social workers, counselors, and other social practice practitioners.12 students.To support flexibility, scaffolding, and course co-creation. To balance self-direction with educator guidance. To personalize assessment to meet student interests.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized inquiry-based projects.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, format, number, due dates, weighting, and grading criteria. 4) management and leadership in social services (Napan, 2016)A mandatory second-year graduate course in a compressed 3-year program.Social work28 students.To personalize prescribed outcomes, balance flexibility with structure, and enable relevance. To encourage creativity, critical thinking, investment, practical wisdom and deep engagement.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized inquiry-based projects.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, format, due dates, and grading criteria. 5) Advanced social work principles and theory (Phillips & Napan, 2016)A third-year undergraduate course that is likely mandatory.Social work69To prepare students for real-world collaboration and make assignments meaningful.Learning contracts, which supported a variety of student-chosen assignments and assessment criteria.Planning: Assessment focus, instructions, format, due dates, and grading criteria. 6) service access and navigation (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022)A mandatory second semester postgraduate certificate course.Health services navigation22 in one delivery. Other deliveries are not explicit.To empower students, shape their values, and prepare them to impact real-world change. To enrich learning, improve equity, develop critical thinking and self-assessment skills, and improve simulation relevance.Interprofessional virtual simulation creation and implementation.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, weighting, due dates, grading criteria, group assignment, and template creation.Completion: Assignment completion.Evaluation: Performance feedback. Medicine and other Allied health ( n = 8 courses) 1) introduction to clinical medicine course with a focus on gerontology (Fox & West, 1983)An undergraduate course that is likely mandatory as part of first year. Second-year students were also surveyed.Medicine49 year 1 and 46 year 2 students. Unclear if it was separate deliveries.To promote self-directed lifelong learning.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes, instructions, format, and grading criteria. 2) A couple of courses; topic not specified (Martenson & Schwab, 1993)Multiple courses that were likely mandatory; details not explicit.MedicineNot explicit.To promote learning through mutual commitment.Learning contracts were used to plan course objectives and content with an entire class (not individual students).Planning: Course outcomes. 3) communication (Hardigan, 1994)A third-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.PharmacyNot explicitTo empower learners, foster mutual planning, clarify objectives, and shift student focus away from memorization. To enhance learning through relevance and self-directedness.Learning contracts were used but the contents of the contract were not reported.Planning: Unclear but it included assessment learning outcomes, and grading criteria. 4) research methodology (Esambe, 2018)A mandatory exit-level undergraduate course.Dental technology14To teach in a difficult setting where writing is not a priority, the project causes apprehension, and retention and equity are concerns.Research proposal writing.Evaluation: Performance feedback.Completion: Implementing formative feedback. 5) Neurorehabilitation (MacKenzie et al., 2018)A graduate course for senior students that was likely mandatory.Occupational therapy8To promote self-regulated and transferrable learning.Simulation creation and implementation.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes.Completion: Assignment completion including simulation design decisions.Evaluation: Performance feedback. 6) Capstone course with a focus on transition to practice (Thompson, Houston, & Dansie, 2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017)A third-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Paramedicine94To rebalance outcome-focused grading and reward learning, manage a competitive culture, and develop necessary real-world reflection, critical thinking, judgement, and self-assessment skills.Simulation performance.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades. 7) Fundamentals in paramedicine (Thompson et al., 2020)A first-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Paramedicine100To develop critical appraisal, critical thinking, reflection, evaluative judgement, and self-regulation. To mitigate challenges with traditional competency-based assessment. To reduce power-tensions and views punitive grading, enable high-quality feedback, and reflect real-world practice.Simulation performance.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades. 8) resuscitation training (Thompson et al., 2024)A final year undergraduate course that was likely mandatory.Paramedicine84To prepare students for future practice and reflect real-world expectations. Current pedagogies were inadequate.Simulation performance.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades.Note. There are 25 courses. Multiple reports described the same course, and some reports described multiple courses. This table was ordered by discipline and publication date.Table 3.How Co-creation of Assessment is OccurringCourse focusLevel a FrameworkInteraction methodsStrategies supporting co-creationParticipation Nursing ( n = 11 courses) 1) Advanced qualitative research (Abboud et al., 2017)5Student-centered education within a course that is informed by Marxism.Discussion during individual meetings.Co-teaching, co-learning, consensus over content and processes. Resource library co-creation, participatory meetings, reflection, collaboration, debriefing, and collegial support.All learners must participate. 2) Comparative religion (Hengesbach, 1980)5Adult education principles (andragogy) and Knowles learning contract guidance.Discussion during class time as a large group and in two smaller groups.Worksheets, filmstrips, and choices in a prior assignment. Choice of course topics based on interest. Peer review encouraged.All learners must participate. 3) Unclear course focus (Owen-Mills, 1996)7Philosophy of caring in a critical social paradigm.In-class discussion, educator refinement after class, presentation back to students, then consensus verification.Group building exercises, weekly free discussions across all courses, expressing caring during feedback, and clinical tutorials.Participated in four groups. Individual participation levels not reported. 4) Leadership (Waddell & Stephens, 2000)5Adult learning and Knowles model for learning contracts.Discussion during class, voting via nominal group process, consensus, and document submission.Course content decided through nominal group process. Students select feasible activities. Learning contracts to plan assignments.All learners must participate. 5) Professional communication (Martyn, 2000; Martyn & Husain, 1993)5Group process and self-directed learning. Negotiation in curriculum.Discussion during meetings and individual feedback.Syllabus negotiation with students and nursing professionals began in advance of the course.All learners must participate in some aspects, but others are optional. 6) Nursing psychology (Limin, 2005)Unable to tellTeacher-led, student-centered teaching. Individualized, self-directed, and lifelong learning. Active inquiry-based approaches.Includes negotiation and discussion likely during class and a meeting.Learners prepare a draft of the plan prior to negotiation.All learners must participate. 7) Independent study to promote scholarly writing (Hawkins, 2015)7Heinrich’s guidance for writing partnerships.Individual meetings, email and asynchronous work on the manuscript.Mutually setting expectations via a partnership agreement. Examples, worksheets and guiding documents.All learners may choose to participate or not. 8) Emergency nursing capstone course (Henderson et al., 2021, 2022)5Assessment as learning, authentic assessment and evaluative judgement.Discussion during individual meetings that were guided by a rubric until reaching consensus.Instructions and rubrics were externally reviewed for clarity and fairness.All learners must participate. 9a) family assessment (Killam & Luctkar-Flude, 2021)5Not reported.Discussion during meetings for feedback and guidance.Simulation based education and gamification. Learners had other options to earn grades.All learners may choose to participate or not. 9b) family assessment (Killam et al. (in press))7Social constructivism and principles for co-creation.In-class discussion with collaborative document editing. Peer and educator written feedback prior to grade negotiation by email or in person meetings.Post-class educator refinement prior to further in-class discussion. Resubmission of work if desired after receiving feedback.All learners may choose to participate or not in rubric creation. All learners participated in requesting grades. 10a) social justice (Killam, Luctkar-Flude, & Tyerman, 2024)5Universal design for learning.In-class discussion, email, anonymous discussion board, and an open-ended survey.Beginning with a draft syllabus with broad expectations. Time for reflection after class. Overall assignment structure.All learners may choose to participate or not. 10b) social justice/empowerment (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022)5 and 7Constructivist learning theories. Progressive and democratic education. Principles to guide co-creation. Authentic assessment.Discussion with the class and groups during and after class, collaborative document editing, an anonymous discussion board, email, and open-ended surveys.Interprofessional group work, reflective journaling, guide documents, and a co-created template. Optional submission of script(s) prior to simulation filming. Opportunities to renegotiate expectations.All learners may choose to participate or not. 11) Nursing research (Killam et al. (in press))7Social constructivism and principles for co-creation.In-class discussion and collaborative document editing. Written feedback then discussion during individual meetings or via email to reach consensus. Optional grade negotiation form.Post-class educator refinement prior to further in-class discussion. Resubmission of work if desired after receiving feedback.All learners may choose to participate or not in rubric creation. All learners participated in requesting grades. Social and human services ( n = 6 courses) 1) human behavior, a foundational course. (Huff & McNown Johnson, 1998)5Philosophy of empowerment, social work principles, and Knowles guidance for learning contracts.Students submitted suggestions (likely in writing) and received feedback. Discussion during individual meetings to discuss progress.Formative feedback from students about course format and delivery. Narrative evaluations from the instructor about progress in meetings at midterm and in writing at the end of the course.Students in the experimental group must participate. 2) Spirituality and social practice (Napan, 2009; Napan et al., 2020)6Academic Co-creative inquiry (ACCI) informed by the research method of cooperative inquiry and continuous feedback from students. Alignment with cultural pedagogies.Discussions during class, reaching consensus, and email responses within 24 hours.Invitation letter. Welcoming ceremony. Learning contracts to plan assignments. Course co-creation, self- and peer-assessment. Culturally responsive pedagogy, practices, and space. Focus on collaborative learning and relationship-building. Course closure celebration.Students choose to participate at the onset of the course; if agreed than all must participate. 3) reflecting on practice (Napan, 2012)6ACCI. Narrative interviewing. Principles of purpose and meaning, curiosity, participation, co-creation, mutuality and reciprocity, feedback and contextuality.In-class student presentations and discussions.Respectful interviewing. Welcome letter. Course co-creation, self and peer-assessment. Posting decisions online. Learning contracts to plan assignments. Feedback from professionals.All learners must participate. 4) management in social services (Napan, 2016)6ACCI based on adult learning principles, whole people learning, choice theory, critical reflection, and cooperative inquiry. Embeds context, trust, relevance, choice, flow, integration, and integrity.Discussions during class, in-class activities, anonymous comment box.Course introductions, clear boundaries for co-creation. Course co-creation, self and peer-reflections. Learning contracts to plan assignments. Structure for learning contracts.All learners must participate. 5) Advanced social work principles and theory (Phillips & Napan, 2016)6Inquiry-based learning and dialogic principles.Discussion, negotiation, and written submissions. Group presentations.Co-design of course process, rules of conduct, and teaching methods. Co-learning, feedback surveys, peer and self-assessment.All learners must participate. 6) service access/navigation (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022)5 and 7Constructivist learning theories. Progressive and democratic education. Principles to guide co-creation.Discussion with the class and groups during and after class, collaborative document editing, an anonymous electronic discussion board, email, and open-ended surveys.Interprofessional group work, reflective journaling, guide documents, and a co-created template. Optional submission of script(s) prior to simulation filming. Opportunities to renegotiate expectations.All learners may choose to participate or not. Medicine and other Allied health ( n = 8 courses) 1) introduction to clinical medicine course with a focus on gerontology (Fox & West, 1983)5Self-directed learning. Knowles contract learning method.Class discussion to explain the contract. Back and forth feedback on draft contracts.Restricted topics to gerontology to promote feasibility. In-class discussion of contracts with peers who have similar contracts.All learners must participate. 2) A couple of courses; topic not specified (Martenson & Schwab, 1993)Unable to tellLearning psychology.Discussion likely during class time.The contract was between the teacher and an entire class (not individual students). Problem-based learning, mid-course evaluation.Unclear. 3) communication (Hardigan, 1994)Unable to tellSelf-directed learning and adult learning characteristics.Not reported.Not reported.All learners must participate. 4) research methodology (Esambe, 2018)Unable to tellDialogical approach to feedback, work by Freire stressing the importance of dialogue.In-class discussion, online asynchronous group discussions, individual meetings, and joint document editing.Involved support persons as needed.Unclear but it is likely that all learners participated. 5) Neurorehabilitation (MacKenzie et al., 2018)5Self-regulated learning, Cook’s instructional design guidance, and other educational frameworks.Not reported.Multiple perspective debriefing, multiple role preparation, observation, peer interaction, layered debriefing process with reflection, and video recordings.Unclear but it is likely that all learners must participate. 6) Capstone course; transition to practice (Thompson, Houston, & Dansie, 2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017)5Sustainable assessment and assessment for learning.Discussion during class, extensive feedback, two-way conversations, and reaching consensus.Discussions about performance were guided by a rubric. Withholding educator assessment until self-assessments are complete.All learners must participate. 7) Fundamentals in paramedicine (Thompson et al., 2020)5Paramedic reflective practice principles and real-world practice expectations.Discussion prior to self-assessment, student-led performance critique based on criterion, and two-way discourse to reach consensus.Withholding educator assessment until self-assessments are complete.All learners must participate. 8) resuscitation training (Thompson et al., 2024)5Authentic and sustainable assessment, entrustment decisions, and Ottawa criteria for assessment practice.Grading discussion guided by a scoring framework likely during a meeting.Self-assessment based on a framework prior to discussion. Withholding educator assessment until self-assessments are complete.All learners must participate.acourses were classified according to Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation at one or more levels.Note. There are 25 courses. Multiple reports described the same course, and some reports described multiple courses. For companion papers (i.e., those that reported on the same course and approach to assessment co-creation) data were extracted from both reports and combined. This table was ordered by discipline and publication date to match Table 2.Table 4.Abbreviated Author Conclusions About Impacts and LessonsResearch and quality improvement reportsSourceAssignment descriptionFacilitatorsBarriersBenefitsDisadvantagesFuture considerations Fox and West (1983) Level 5: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Not reported.Student anxiety (higher at the beginning than the end).Achieved goals.Not reported.Increase self-directed learning.Unfamiliarity. a Developed and reinforced lifelong learning.Apply in clinical.Once familiar anxiety decreased, skills refined, and enthusiasm grew.Develop a systematic approach. Hardigan (1994) Learning contracts, details not reported.Recognize student uniqueness.May not suit memorization-heavy courses.Positive student response; concerns resolved; goals achieved.Initial confusion, disbelief, uncertainty.Recommended for this course, not all.Aligned with course content; meaningful, useful, and effective.Level unclear.Promoted clarity, equity, empowerment, and personal growth.Hesitancy to determine personal evaluation criteria.Continue in this course.Less competition, anxiety.More strategies needed. Huff and McNown Johnson (1998) Level 5: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects. Supported by narrative evaluations.Not reported.Scheduling meetings was challenging.Positive student response to learning contracts.Initial anxiety.Provide options, feedback, and grading clarity.Address anxiety and listen.Difficulty objectively grading diverse assignments.Monitor dynamics.Initial student anxiety.Eager for individualized feedback during narrative evaluations.Ensure fairness and flexibility.Scheduling.Foster creativity, questioning, and self-challenge.Resist deciding for students. Waddell and Stephens (2000) Level 5: Nominal group process and learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Bloom’s taxonomy action verbs. a Sharing power may feel uncomfortable for educators. a Empowering, customizable, and fosters lifelong learning and responsibility.Not reported.Strategies are useful in education and also potentially in other contexts (i.e., staff development).Inclusive design shifts power to students and values adult learners.Appropriate, feasible and manageable.Course content themes emerged over the years even though each delivery is individualized.Course content changes from term to term. a Solved heterogeneity challenges. b Additional benefits. Limin (2005) Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Alignment with curriculum, course, and learner needs.Learner readiness, interest, time limits, and unexpected events.High student approval, engagement, learning, and performance.High demands on teacher technical skills, organization, expertise, and preparation.Educators should be mindful of and respond to potential challenges and barriers.Humanistic, collaborative environment.Built professional identity, ethics, and social responsibility.Continuous guidance from instructors and peers.Personalized learning.Unable to determine the level.Use of appropriate and diverse assessment methods.Success depends on educator preparedness and student readiness and engagement.Overcomes traditional method limitations.Encourages reflection, collaboration, innovation, efficiency, autonomy, flexibility, lifelong learning.Educator skills, organization, and psychological readiness. b Additional benefits. Phillips and Napan (2016) Level 5 and 6: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Integrating self- and peer assessment with co-learning.Neoliberalism opposes co-creation.Shifts students from consumers to active participants.Tensions between top-down and bottom-up efforts.Reflexive sensitivity is essential.Sharing control.System tensions, contradictions.Welcomes diverse voices in assessment.Student resistance.Effective process, flexibility.Promotes responsibility for one’s own learning.System change is required to reduce tension.Ongoing educator reflection.Context-specific barriers.Voices who oppose dialogue are marginalized.Skilled facilitation, preparation, transparency, and context awareness.Pressure to pass students or meet targets. a Reflects real-world tensions of social work.Need to co-create while remaining critically aware of tensions.Focus on process not outputs.Exhaustion from opposing neoliberalism.Some voices dominate discussions.Thompson, Houston, & Dansie (2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017)Level 5: Consensus grading of simulation performance.A simple and intuitive approach. a Limited time to explain the process.Valued by educators and embraced by students.A few students were unhappy with being unable to earn grades by chance, which educators did not see as a disadvantage.Viewed as sustainable.Active engagement and critical reflection.Promoted learning, self-assessment, fairness, critical thinking.Prepares for real-world.Recommended for use.Aligns grades with capabilities. b Additional benefits. Esambe (2018) Research proposal writing.Acknowledge limiting factors (i.e., students’ lack of experience in the topic).Student apathy and different content value perceptions.Improved understanding, communication, clarity, and writing.Not reported.Recommends moving away from formal and linear ways of giving feedback.Difficult content.Active, collaborative feedback improved perceived value.Level unclear.Use multiple student engagement strategies.Grade-focused students.Educator professional development.System priorities.Identified contextual barriers and supports.Limited educator support, training, or resources.Built real-world skills via critical conversations. MacKenzie et al. (2018) Level 5: Simulation creation and implementation.Educator responsiveness to learner needs.Student unfamiliarity with simulation design.Valuable learning experience.Not reported.Unable to separate from other content discussed.Enhanced performance, confidence, and self-reflection.Feedback availability.Student openness to challenge themselves.Need for educator adaptability.Understanding case requirements.Mentioned that the findings are informative for future co-creation.Greater self-regulation.Learner-centered. Thompson et al. (2020) Level 5: Consensus grading of simulation performance.Not reported.Not reported.Positive attitude; fair and effective for learning.Not reported.Apply across the program.Supports future practice, reflection, thinking.Suitable for novices. a Preferred by tutors.Appropriate for beginning students.Authentic, empowering, and sustainable. b Additional benefits. Henderson et al. (2021) Level 5: Oral viva consensus grading.Not reported.Indistinct from other content.Valued reflective, two-way dialogue and learning.Looking for tutor judgement and inability to self-evaluate may be barriers or disadvantages. a Democratic summative assessment is possible, ongoing evaluation is needed. a Shifted power dynamics, authentic discussions.Fair, non-punitive, and collegial experience.Promoted reflection, self-evaluation, and evaluative judgement. Henderson et al. (2022) Oral viva grading using a consensus marking approach compared to traditional educator grading.Not reported.Not reported.Reduced hierarchy, anxiety, and stress.Increased anxiety for one person.Not reported.Enhanced satisfaction, authenticity, learning, accountability, self-assessment, and student voice.Immediate feedback.Level unclear.Learner-centered, empowering.Built motivation, evaluative judgement, and lifelong learning. b Additional benefits. Thompson et al. (2024) Level 5: Consensus grading of simulation performance.Student willingness to recieve and process critical feedback.Grade-seeking behaviour.Preferred method.Two students felt it was unfair as expectations were high and it impacted their confidence. These concerns were related to fear over lost grades.Transferable approach to grading.Empowered educators; constructive feedback.Personalized, context-rich, two-way discussion.Enhanced reflection, learning, and scores.Calibration between judgements.Assessed metacognition and observed skills.Perceived credible, valid, and reproducible. b Additional benefits.Killam, Akerlind, et al. (2024) Co-authors included one learner.Level 5 and 7: Virtual simulation assignment co-creation.Recognized need.Concerns over scalability. a Improved inclusion, equity, accessibility, learning.The newness of co-creation and course changes cause periods of confusion.Use a framework to explain the process and outcomes of co-creation.Student self-assessment skills and will to speak up.Strong educator support, guidance.Clear communication and input-seeking.Empowered students, fostered ownership.Monitoring for confusion.Reduced stress.Openness to working together.Built transferable skills and confidence.Organizational support.Mutual growth.Scaffolding opportunities across a curriculum. b Additional benefits.Non-research reportsSourceAssignment descriptionFacilitatorsBarriersBenefitsDisadvantagesFuture considerations Hengesbach (1980) Level 5: Learning contracts used to plan individualized projects.Not reported.Not reported.Not reported.Not reported.Not reported. Martenson and Schwab (1993) Learning contracts to plan course objectives and content with an entire class (not individual students).Clear and detailed steps.Reluctance.Practical approach.Unclear or unrealistic plans.Learning contracts should be used and can be made with the entire class instead of individual students.Positive impact on communication, confidence, and self-responsibility.Supports learning psychology.Unable to determine the level.Educator preparation and understanding of learning contracts.Educator fear of losing. Authority or control.Fosters collegiality, self-confidence, understanding.Educators may have difficulty making contracts meaningful.Builds negotiation, collaboration, and team-work skills. b Additional benefits. Owen-Mills (1996) Level 7: Self, peer, and educator evaluation worth 40% of the grade.Not reported.Indistinct from other content.Empowerment.Not reported.Not reported.Experiences may influence future practice. a Martyn (2000) and Martyn and Husain (1993)Level 5: Public speaking and writing projects.Perceived need, acceptance.Increased need to manage and facilitate negotiations.Manageable, practical, and customized.Not reported.Process syllabus is practical.Student maturity, prior skills.Negotiated agreements suit any course.Respect for diversity.Feelings of fear.Fostered experiential learning, pride, and engagement.Commitment and planning.Enhanced autonomy, communication, collaboration, leadership skills.Context shapes negotiation principles and processes, which will need refinement for other contexts.Working within institutional limitations.Built confidence, competence, self-management.A flexible syllabus.Viewing students as inferior or less capable.Created a valuable, memorable, enjoyable course.Institutional culture, collaboration.Institutional rules.Enabled collaboration.The process is essential for creating relevant courses. b Additional facilitators. b Additional benefits.Napan (2009) and Napan et al. (2020)Level 6: Learning contracts to plan a variety of projects with a written component that were as creative as possible.Providing a template.Institutional hierarchies.Heard student voices.Indistinct from other content.Students desire customization in other courses. a Built trust, respect.Fostered inclusivity, creativity, flexibility, and accessibility.Required constant educator accessibility via email.Promoted engagement, honesty, openness, and skill growth.Facilitated progress tracking, support.Elements may scale, but the process is most suited to smaller classes. a Maintained rigour.Course outcomes are typically predetermined.Produced high-quality, practice-relevant, assignments and feedback processes. b Additional benefits. Napan (2012) Level 6: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Flexible course delivery and assessment.Accreditation limits flexibility in course outcomes and assessment criteria.Focus on learning.Requires engagement in class discussions, meaning attendance should be mandated.Not reported.Students placed high expectations on themselves.Trust, mutual appreciation, multi-source feedback.Difficulty being critical of students who are trying their best.Flexibility to meet student needs.Post decisions to aid recall.Concern over rare instances of cheating.Overwhelmingly positive student feedback. Hawkins (2015) Level 7: Manuscript co-authorship (for publication after the course ends).Student interest.Concerns: Student commitment, vulnerability, unfamiliarity with processes.Co-authored publications.Not all manuscripts published. a Not reported.Pass/fail grading via negotiated contract.Improved writing skills.Embed choice.Increased faculty scholarly productivity.Evidence-based planning.Poor planning leads to burdensome co-authorship with minimal contributions.Clear expectations, and planning tools.Revisions may be discouraging.Coaching and encouragement. Napan (2016) Level 6: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Clear expectations; negotiable vs. non-negotiable outlined.Initial confusion and uncertainty, a which were resolved through clear expectations, support, and trust-building.Personalized learning.Not reported.Explore in other academic settings.Built relationships and discovered relevance during class activities. a Promoted clarity, trust, agency, honesty, peer support.Structured flexibility with high choice.Linked learning goals, passions, and real-life contexts.Ongoing reflection on principles. a Increased motivation, creativity, deep engagement, and quality.Appreciative, transformative, creative, and personalized learning environment. a Fostered fear-free, diverse, impactful, and inspirational learning.Expand reflection on impacts.Developed practical wisdom for lifelong learning. a b Additional benefits. Abboud et al. (2017) Level 5: Assignments are individualized.Not reported.Indistinct from other content.Indistinct from other content.Indistinct from other content.Not reported. Killam and Luctkar-Flude (2021) Level 5: Option for simulation co-creation to earn 5% of a course grade.Making co-creation a choice.Not reported.Improved student understanding.Not reported.Unable to separate from other content discussed.Quality simulation development for future classes.Killam, McAuliffe, et al. (2022). a Co-authors included students.Level 7: Interprofessional simulation experiences.Organizational structure and detailed guidance in live documents. a Indistinct from other content.Enriched learning experience.Students may become overwhelmed. a Co-creation is recommended for future use. Killam, Luctkar-Flude et al. (2024) Level 5: Module debriefing and reflection assignments.Technology.Oppressive educational structures. a Feasible and liberating.Not reported.Increase weighting.Board marking guide.Flexibility, choice and accessibility. a Integrating flexibility.Options will differ with each course. Killam et al. (in press) Level 7: Negotiated grading of assignments.Clear plan to guide students.Not scalable to large classes.Valuable process, shifted power.Time intensive process.Continued use with efficiency improvements.Student input in multiple stages.Resistance from others.Built real-world skills: Self-advocacy, self-assessment, communication.Not feasible in large classes; adapt elements for scale.Ongoing guidance, communication.Use in only one class.Promoted reflection, engagement, self-directed learning.Discussions may delay feedback in large classes.Reduce meeting time.Clarify terminology.Trusting relationships.Unfamiliar to students.Learning through feedback and role modeling.Plan for resistance.High instructor workload.Meaningful links with course content.Terminology may confuse students and academics.Provide clear structure.Shared values. b Additional benefits.Excessive change may overwhelm studentsScaffolded across a curriculum.Contextual constraints may exist. b Additional considerations.aImplied: Required interpretation.bExtensive benefits reported; to promote readability, clarity, and comparability, only key or most frequently reported benefits are summarized in this table. A full version is available in Appendix 6.Note. Data were only extracted if a connection to assessment co-creation could be identified. Reports where we were unable to separate data from other content discussed co-creation in a way that was integrated with other interventions. Sources with multiple citations in column 1 were treated as companion papers (i.e., the same report) since they describe the same course and approach to assessment co-creation. Data were extracted from both reports and combined in the tables. This table is ordered by publication date.Table 5.Reported Limitations and GapsResearch and quality improvement reportsSourceAimDesignLimitationsGapsFox and West (1983), USADescribe and evaluate learning contracts.Quantitative, pre-post survey and educator observation.Not reported.Investigate learning contract use in more areas of medical education.92 students.Hardigan (1994), USADetermine if students view contract grading as effective.Quantitative, survey.Not reported.Test impacts on class performance.61 students from two cohorts.Explore why students do not want learning contracts in all courses.Huff and McNown Johnson (1998), USAExplore strategies to empower students.Quantitative, quasi-experimental with multiple interventions.Small sample.Employ a randomized study design.Potential selection bias.Conduct a study with the same instructor for both sections.Non-random group assignment.Measure impacts on learning and practice.Researcher-developed questionnaire.Potential social desirability in responses.Study interventions separately to test effectiveness.Untested instrument with no neutral option, potentially reducing differences between groups.46 students in two groups: 22 (experimental) and 24 (comparison).Measures student perceptions.Different instructors across sections.Esambe (2018), South AfricaExplore dialogical formative feedback.Qualitative, diffractive methodology.Small sample.Explore in other departments and universities.Focus groups and draft papers with comments.Unable to generalize.Leverage both qualitative and quantitative approaches.14 students and 2 educators.Methods prevented in-depth exploration of learning.Explore depth of learning.MacKenzie et al. (2018), CanadaOutline guidance and impacts for simulation co-construction.Qualitative.Small homogenous sample.Conduct larger studies.Instructor field notes and a student-completed open-ended survey.Reliance on qualitative methods.Leverage both qualitative and quantitative approaches.8 students.Findings are context specific and not generalizable.Test effectiveness in other contexts.Thompson et al. (2020), AustraliaEvaluate perceptions of consensus grading.Quantitative, survey.Small scale study with a single cohort.Unable to separate.88 students.Not generalizable.Henderson et al. (2021), AustraliaExplore student perceptions of online vivas and consensus marking.Qualitative research using pre-existing data.Small sample.Compare consensus marking and educator assessment.Simple open-ended questions were asked during data collection.Explore impacts on learner-educator relationships and resulting anxiety.Recordings of answers to open-ended questions asked for quality assurance purposes.Explore how different learning preferences impact experiences and outcomes (i.e., satisfaction, self-evaluation, and changes in future practice).Findings are context specific and not generalizable.Investigate educator perspectives.13 students.Reliance on student perceptions, which may contain assumptions about assessment.Study other disciplines.Henderson et al. (2022), AustraliaCompare consensus marking to traditional assessor judgement and explore perceptions.Convergent mixed-methods parallel research design.Reliance on a one group, non-randomised design.Identify strategies to engage students in dialogue.Semi-structured interviews (n = 13) after both oral vivas were graded.Inability to draw conclusions as exposure to the first oral viva may have impacted outcomes.Validated questionnaires.Risk of pressure to participate and bias since a researcher was also the educator.Conduct a larger randomized controlled trial testing different strategies to develop self-assessment skills.46 students.Thompson et al. (2024), AustraliaEvaluate assessment pedagogy.Explanatory sequential mixed methods design.Single-site, convenience sample, unblinded, no control.Explore equivalence criteria.Phase 1: Score comparison; 84 students.Did not assess perceptions of Ottawa equivalence criteria.Long-term retesting.Phase 2: Survey; 77 students and 7 assessors.Killam, Akerlind, et al. (2024), Co-authors included one learner. CanadaExplore differences in students’ experience of assignment co-creation.Qualitative research, phenomenography.Findings are context specific and not generalizable.Explore interventions to facilitate understanding of co-creation.5-Question open-ended survey and reflective journals written during the course.Reliance on written responses where probing for depth cannot occur.Identify strategies to help students reach higher levels of understanding.Compare depth in written versus interview responses.32 students.Exclusive focus on student perceptions.Explore educator perspectives.Non-research reportsSourceAimPerspectiveLimitationsGapsOwen-Mills (1996), NZDescribe how dialect is established in a transformative curriculum.EducatorThe paper is subjective, and perceptions may change.Not reported.Martyn (2000) and Martyn and Husain (1993), PakistanAdvocate for a task-based syllabus and syllabus negotiation.EducatorNo negotiation process can be replicated due to contextual factors.Test and refine principles and processes in other contexts.Explore the impact of changes in administrative structures on the process.Killam and Luctkar-Flude (2021), CanadaDescribe virtual simulation creation and gamification to encourage co-creation.EducatorNot reported.Research about simulation co-creation is needed.Napan (2012), NZReflect on collaborative inquiry-based course delivery.EducatorNot reported.Test strategies in other course contexts.Napan (2016), NZDescribe how course-based co-creation develops practical wisdom.EducatorNot reported.Explore in other academic settings.Expand reflection on impacts.Killam and Luctkar-Flude (2021), CanadaDescribe virtual simulation creation and gamification to encourage learner-educator co-creation.EducatorNot reported.Evaluate replacement of clinical hours.Explore co-creation of virtual simulations.Killam, McAuliffe, et al. (2022), CanadaDescribe the process used to co-create an assignment.Both student and educatorNot reported.Explore diverse student experiences.Killam, Luctkar-Flude et al. (2024), CanadaDescribe an inclusive approach to integrating e-learning modules.EducatorNot reported.Explore diverse student experiences with highly interactive courses.Conduct experimental studies to test impacts on learning outcomes.Refine the process based on student feedback.Killam et al. (in press), CanadaExplore negotiated grading.EducatorNo objective data collection, reflection-based, and did not test effectiveness.Develop conceptual clarity and refine terminology.Explore student and educator experiences with different ways of negotiating grades.Identify ways to mitigate resistance.Measure outcomes and test various approaches.Note. Limitations and gaps were not reported in Waddell and Stephens (2000), Limin (2005), Phillips and Napan (2016), or Thompson, Houston, & Dansie (2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017).Note. Limitations and gaps were not reported in Hengesbach (1980), Martenson and Schwab (1993), Napan (2009) and Napan et al. (2020), Hawkins (2015), and Abboud et al. (2017).Figure 3.Co-created assessment types reported by course discipline and levelFigure 4.Co-created decisions reported by phase of assessment and assignment typeNote. The inner circle illustrates the assessment phase, the middle circle shows the specific elements within this phase that were shared, and the outer circle identifies the types of assessments where co-creation occurred. As illustrated, shared decision-making was most frequently reported during the assessment planning phase.Figure 5.Co-created assessment decisions reported by course level and disciplineNote. Figure 5 is ordered according to a typical sequencing of events. However, assessment was often an iterative and non-linear process meaning that these decisions did not necessarily happen in this order.Figure 6.Levels of learner influence by course discipline and course level.Note. Levels of learner influence are based on Bovill and Bulley's (2011) ladder of participation. Courses with multiple levels of participation were counted at the highest level. *Courses that could not be placed are counted at level 5. Figure 7.Levels of learner influence by assessment phase.Note. Levels of learner influence are based on Bovill and Bulley's (2011) ladder of participation. Courses with multiple levels of participation were counted at the highest level. *Courses that could not be placed are counted at level 5. Figure 8.Choice in participation by level of learner influence.Note: Levels of learner influence are based on Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participationFigure 9.Interaction methods used during co-creation by level of learner influence.Note. Levels of Learner Influence are based on Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation. This figure is based on data from 23 courses. Interaction methods were unclear in Hardigan (1994) and MacKenzie et al. (2018). 2 courses could not be placed at a level and are counted at level 5. 2 courses had multiple levels of participation and were counted at the highest level. Table 2.Courses Where Co-Creation of Assessment OccurredCourse focusProgramDisciplineClass sizePurpose of Co-creationAssessment descriptionAssessment decisions Nursing (n = 11 courses) 1) Advanced qualitative research (Abboud et al., 2017)Graduate elective; various doctoral and post-doctoral years of study welcome.Several disciplines. The course is in the school of nursing.Not explicit.To meet unique needs of diverse students.Assignments are individualized and may include various types of research writing activities.Planning: Assessment instructions, grading criteria, and pass/fail vs. letter grade.Evaluation: Ongoing critique and feedback. 2) Comparative religion (Hengesbach, 1980)Undergraduate elective course; details not explicit.Nursing15.To enable self-direction, commitment, and ownership over learning using adult learning principles.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes, instructions, format, and grading criteria. 3) Unclear course focus (Owen-Mills, 1996)A first-year course that is likely mandatory in an undergraduate program.NursingNot explicit.To transform education, empower students, and produce graduates who can transform health care systems.Self/peer/educator evaluation worth 40% of the course grade.Planning: Grading criteria, weighting of assignments, and evaluation form design. 4) Leadership (Waddell & Stephens, 2000)An undergraduate course that is likely mandatory; details not explicit.Nursing16To individualize the course to meet the unique and diverse needs of adult learners.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes, instructions, format, and grading criteria. 5) Professional communication for nursing education and management (Martyn, 2000; Martyn & Husain, 1993)A second-year mandatory English course in an undergraduate program.Nursing15To meet students’ unique needs and produce leaders who are competent and confident in English communication.Public speaking and writing projects.Planning: Assessment focus, instructions, and format. 6) Nursing psychology (Limin, 2005)A mandatory undergraduate course; year not reported. After fundamental courses.Nursing142 (unclear if it is the Same class)To increase autonomy, independence, lifelong learning skills, confidence in self-directed learning, interest and engagement. To address challenges in past course delivery.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning objectives, instructions, format, due dates, and grading criteria. 7) Independent study to promote scholarly writing (Hawkins, 2015)Undergraduate independent study elective course; details not explicit.NursingNot explicit.To mentor students in writing while increasing scholarly productivity in an ethical way.Manuscript co-authorship (for publication after the course ends).Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, partnership expectations, communication modalities, and due dates.Completion: Assignment completion. 8) Emergency nursing capstone course (Henderson et al., 2021, 2022)Likely mandatory; postgraduate program; details not explicit.Nursing50–56.To prepare students for real-world reflection, self-evaluation, and lifelong learning by developing evaluative judgement.Oral viva grading using consensus marking compared to traditional grading. Oral vivas involved simulation.Evaluation: Performance feedback and final grades. 9a) family assessment (Killam & Luctkar-Flude, 2021)A first-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.NursingAbout 70 in 2019; number not explicit for 2020.To promote student engagement and invite students to create needed simulations.Simulation development as an option to earn 5% of the course grade.Completion: Assignment completion. 9b) family assessment (Killam et al. (in press))A first-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Nursing79To empower students, reduce fear, and build real-world skills and address dissatisfaction with traditional grading systems and student focus on grades.Not reported. Authors report it was essay writing.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, grading criteria.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades. 10a) social justice (Killam, Luctkar-Flude, & Tyerman, 2024)A third-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Nursing60 to 70 per delivery.To role-model anti-oppression and improve learning by reducing barriers, promoting accessibility, and focusing on authentic learning.Module debriefing and written reflection assignments.Planning: Assessment instructions, format, grading criteria, choices, and the syllabus. 10b) social justice and empowerment (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022)A third-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Nursing60 in one delivery. Other deliveries are not explicit.To empower students, shape their values, and prepare them to impact real-world change. To enrich learning, improve equity, develop critical thinking and self-assessment skills, and improve simulation relevance.Interprofessional virtual simulation creation and implementation.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, weighting, due dates, grading criteria, group assignment, and template creation.Completion: Assignment completion.Evaluation: Performance feedback. 11) Nursing research (Killam et al. (in press))A fourth-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Nursing52To empower students, reduce fear, and build real-world skills. Dissatisfaction with traditional grading systems and student focus on grades.Not reported. Authors indicate it was research writing and presentations.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, format, due dates, weighting, grading criteria.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades. Social and human services ( n = 6 courses) 1) human behavior in the social environment, a foundational course. (Huff & McNown Johnson, 1998)A first-year mandatory graduate course.Social work53To teach empowerment by empowering students. To guide them to focus on learning (not grades).Learning contracts supported by narrative evaluations. Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes, format, grading criteria, and weighting of assignments.Evaluation: Performance feedback. 2) Spirituality and social practice (Napan, 2009; Napan et al., 2020)A graduate course; details not explicit.Transdisciplinary including social work, counseling, and other social practice disciplines.7-15 students per delivery.To personalize prescribed outcomes and focus customized assignments within a non-authoritarian co-created course. To suit needs within limitations of accredited programs.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of assignments that were as creative as possible. Must have a written component and one presentation.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, format, and grading criteria.Evaluation: Final grades. 3) reflecting on practice (Napan, 2012)A masters-level elective; year not reported.Social workers, counselors, and other social practice practitioners.12 students.To support flexibility, scaffolding, and course co-creation. To balance self-direction with educator guidance. To personalize assessment to meet student interests.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized inquiry-based projects.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, format, number, due dates, weighting, and grading criteria. 4) management and leadership in social services (Napan, 2016)A mandatory second-year graduate course in a compressed 3-year program.Social work28 students.To personalize prescribed outcomes, balance flexibility with structure, and enable relevance. To encourage creativity, critical thinking, investment, practical wisdom and deep engagement.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized inquiry-based projects.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, format, due dates, and grading criteria. 5) Advanced social work principles and theory (Phillips & Napan, 2016)A third-year undergraduate course that is likely mandatory.Social work69To prepare students for real-world collaboration and make assignments meaningful.Learning contracts, which supported a variety of student-chosen assignments and assessment criteria.Planning: Assessment focus, instructions, format, due dates, and grading criteria. 6) service access and navigation (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022)A mandatory second semester postgraduate certificate course.Health services navigation22 in one delivery. Other deliveries are not explicit.To empower students, shape their values, and prepare them to impact real-world change. To enrich learning, improve equity, develop critical thinking and self-assessment skills, and improve simulation relevance.Interprofessional virtual simulation creation and implementation.Planning: Assignment focus, instructions, weighting, due dates, grading criteria, group assignment, and template creation.Completion: Assignment completion.Evaluation: Performance feedback. Medicine and other Allied health ( n = 8 courses) 1) introduction to clinical medicine course with a focus on gerontology (Fox & West, 1983)An undergraduate course that is likely mandatory as part of first year. Second-year students were also surveyed.Medicine49 year 1 and 46 year 2 students. Unclear if it was separate deliveries.To promote self-directed lifelong learning.Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes, instructions, format, and grading criteria. 2) A couple of courses; topic not specified (Martenson & Schwab, 1993)Multiple courses that were likely mandatory; details not explicit.MedicineNot explicit.To promote learning through mutual commitment.Learning contracts were used to plan course objectives and content with an entire class (not individual students).Planning: Course outcomes. 3) communication (Hardigan, 1994)A third-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.PharmacyNot explicitTo empower learners, foster mutual planning, clarify objectives, and shift student focus away from memorization. To enhance learning through relevance and self-directedness.Learning contracts were used but the contents of the contract were not reported.Planning: Unclear but it included assessment learning outcomes, and grading criteria. 4) research methodology (Esambe, 2018)A mandatory exit-level undergraduate course.Dental technology14To teach in a difficult setting where writing is not a priority, the project causes apprehension, and retention and equity are concerns.Research proposal writing.Evaluation: Performance feedback.Completion: Implementing formative feedback. 5) Neurorehabilitation (MacKenzie et al., 2018)A graduate course for senior students that was likely mandatory.Occupational therapy8To promote self-regulated and transferrable learning.Simulation creation and implementation.Planning: Assessment learning outcomes.Completion: Assignment completion including simulation design decisions.Evaluation: Performance feedback. 6) Capstone course with a focus on transition to practice (Thompson, Houston, & Dansie, 2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017)A third-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Paramedicine94To rebalance outcome-focused grading and reward learning, manage a competitive culture, and develop necessary real-world reflection, critical thinking, judgement, and self-assessment skills.Simulation performance.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades. 7) Fundamentals in paramedicine (Thompson et al., 2020)A first-year mandatory course in an undergraduate program.Paramedicine100To develop critical appraisal, critical thinking, reflection, evaluative judgement, and self-regulation. To mitigate challenges with traditional competency-based assessment. To reduce power-tensions and views punitive grading, enable high-quality feedback, and reflect real-world practice.Simulation performance.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades. 8) resuscitation training (Thompson et al., 2024)A final year undergraduate course that was likely mandatory.Paramedicine84To prepare students for future practice and reflect real-world expectations. Current pedagogies were inadequate.Simulation performance.Evaluation: Performance feedback, and final grades.Note. There are 25 courses. Multiple reports described the same course, and some reports described multiple courses. This table was ordered by discipline and publication date. Courses Where Co-Creation of Assessment Occurred Note. There are 25 courses. Multiple reports described the same course, and some reports described multiple courses. This table was ordered by discipline and publication date. Table 3.How Co-creation of Assessment is OccurringCourse focusLevel a FrameworkInteraction methodsStrategies supporting co-creationParticipation Nursing ( n = 11 courses) 1) Advanced qualitative research (Abboud et al., 2017)5Student-centered education within a course that is informed by Marxism.Discussion during individual meetings.Co-teaching, co-learning, consensus over content and processes. Resource library co-creation, participatory meetings, reflection, collaboration, debriefing, and collegial support.All learners must participate. 2) Comparative religion (Hengesbach, 1980)5Adult education principles (andragogy) and Knowles learning contract guidance.Discussion during class time as a large group and in two smaller groups.Worksheets, filmstrips, and choices in a prior assignment. Choice of course topics based on interest. Peer review encouraged.All learners must participate. 3) Unclear course focus (Owen-Mills, 1996)7Philosophy of caring in a critical social paradigm.In-class discussion, educator refinement after class, presentation back to students, then consensus verification.Group building exercises, weekly free discussions across all courses, expressing caring during feedback, and clinical tutorials.Participated in four groups. Individual participation levels not reported. 4) Leadership (Waddell & Stephens, 2000)5Adult learning and Knowles model for learning contracts.Discussion during class, voting via nominal group process, consensus, and document submission.Course content decided through nominal group process. Students select feasible activities. Learning contracts to plan assignments.All learners must participate. 5) Professional communication (Martyn, 2000; Martyn & Husain, 1993)5Group process and self-directed learning. Negotiation in curriculum.Discussion during meetings and individual feedback.Syllabus negotiation with students and nursing professionals began in advance of the course.All learners must participate in some aspects, but others are optional. 6) Nursing psychology (Limin, 2005)Unable to tellTeacher-led, student-centered teaching. Individualized, self-directed, and lifelong learning. Active inquiry-based approaches.Includes negotiation and discussion likely during class and a meeting.Learners prepare a draft of the plan prior to negotiation.All learners must participate. 7) Independent study to promote scholarly writing (Hawkins, 2015)7Heinrich’s guidance for writing partnerships.Individual meetings, email and asynchronous work on the manuscript.Mutually setting expectations via a partnership agreement. Examples, worksheets and guiding documents.All learners may choose to participate or not. 8) Emergency nursing capstone course (Henderson et al., 2021, 2022)5Assessment as learning, authentic assessment and evaluative judgement.Discussion during individual meetings that were guided by a rubric until reaching consensus.Instructions and rubrics were externally reviewed for clarity and fairness.All learners must participate. 9a) family assessment (Killam & Luctkar-Flude, 2021)5Not reported.Discussion during meetings for feedback and guidance.Simulation based education and gamification. Learners had other options to earn grades.All learners may choose to participate or not. 9b) family assessment (Killam et al. (in press))7Social constructivism and principles for co-creation.In-class discussion with collaborative document editing. Peer and educator written feedback prior to grade negotiation by email or in person meetings.Post-class educator refinement prior to further in-class discussion. Resubmission of work if desired after receiving feedback.All learners may choose to participate or not in rubric creation. All learners participated in requesting grades. 10a) social justice (Killam, Luctkar-Flude, & Tyerman, 2024)5Universal design for learning.In-class discussion, email, anonymous discussion board, and an open-ended survey.Beginning with a draft syllabus with broad expectations. Time for reflection after class. Overall assignment structure.All learners may choose to participate or not. 10b) social justice/empowerment (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022)5 and 7Constructivist learning theories. Progressive and democratic education. Principles to guide co-creation. Authentic assessment.Discussion with the class and groups during and after class, collaborative document editing, an anonymous discussion board, email, and open-ended surveys.Interprofessional group work, reflective journaling, guide documents, and a co-created template. Optional submission of script(s) prior to simulation filming. Opportunities to renegotiate expectations.All learners may choose to participate or not. 11) Nursing research (Killam et al. (in press))7Social constructivism and principles for co-creation.In-class discussion and collaborative document editing. Written feedback then discussion during individual meetings or via email to reach consensus. Optional grade negotiation form.Post-class educator refinement prior to further in-class discussion. Resubmission of work if desired after receiving feedback.All learners may choose to participate or not in rubric creation. All learners participated in requesting grades. Social and human services ( n = 6 courses) 1) human behavior, a foundational course. (Huff & McNown Johnson, 1998)5Philosophy of empowerment, social work principles, and Knowles guidance for learning contracts.Students submitted suggestions (likely in writing) and received feedback. Discussion during individual meetings to discuss progress.Formative feedback from students about course format and delivery. Narrative evaluations from the instructor about progress in meetings at midterm and in writing at the end of the course.Students in the experimental group must participate. 2) Spirituality and social practice (Napan, 2009; Napan et al., 2020)6Academic Co-creative inquiry (ACCI) informed by the research method of cooperative inquiry and continuous feedback from students. Alignment with cultural pedagogies.Discussions during class, reaching consensus, and email responses within 24 hours.Invitation letter. Welcoming ceremony. Learning contracts to plan assignments. Course co-creation, self- and peer-assessment. Culturally responsive pedagogy, practices, and space. Focus on collaborative learning and relationship-building. Course closure celebration.Students choose to participate at the onset of the course; if agreed than all must participate. 3) reflecting on practice (Napan, 2012)6ACCI. Narrative interviewing. Principles of purpose and meaning, curiosity, participation, co-creation, mutuality and reciprocity, feedback and contextuality.In-class student presentations and discussions.Respectful interviewing. Welcome letter. Course co-creation, self and peer-assessment. Posting decisions online. Learning contracts to plan assignments. Feedback from professionals.All learners must participate. 4) management in social services (Napan, 2016)6ACCI based on adult learning principles, whole people learning, choice theory, critical reflection, and cooperative inquiry. Embeds context, trust, relevance, choice, flow, integration, and integrity.Discussions during class, in-class activities, anonymous comment box.Course introductions, clear boundaries for co-creation. Course co-creation, self and peer-reflections. Learning contracts to plan assignments. Structure for learning contracts.All learners must participate. 5) Advanced social work principles and theory (Phillips & Napan, 2016)6Inquiry-based learning and dialogic principles.Discussion, negotiation, and written submissions. Group presentations.Co-design of course process, rules of conduct, and teaching methods. Co-learning, feedback surveys, peer and self-assessment.All learners must participate. 6) service access/navigation (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024; Killam, McAuliffe, et al., 2022)5 and 7Constructivist learning theories. Progressive and democratic education. Principles to guide co-creation.Discussion with the class and groups during and after class, collaborative document editing, an anonymous electronic discussion board, email, and open-ended surveys.Interprofessional group work, reflective journaling, guide documents, and a co-created template. Optional submission of script(s) prior to simulation filming. Opportunities to renegotiate expectations.All learners may choose to participate or not. Medicine and other Allied health ( n = 8 courses) 1) introduction to clinical medicine course with a focus on gerontology (Fox & West, 1983)5Self-directed learning. Knowles contract learning method.Class discussion to explain the contract. Back and forth feedback on draft contracts.Restricted topics to gerontology to promote feasibility. In-class discussion of contracts with peers who have similar contracts.All learners must participate. 2) A couple of courses; topic not specified (Martenson & Schwab, 1993)Unable to tellLearning psychology.Discussion likely during class time.The contract was between the teacher and an entire class (not individual students). Problem-based learning, mid-course evaluation.Unclear. 3) communication (Hardigan, 1994)Unable to tellSelf-directed learning and adult learning characteristics.Not reported.Not reported.All learners must participate. 4) research methodology (Esambe, 2018)Unable to tellDialogical approach to feedback, work by Freire stressing the importance of dialogue.In-class discussion, online asynchronous group discussions, individual meetings, and joint document editing.Involved support persons as needed.Unclear but it is likely that all learners participated. 5) Neurorehabilitation (MacKenzie et al., 2018)5Self-regulated learning, Cook’s instructional design guidance, and other educational frameworks.Not reported.Multiple perspective debriefing, multiple role preparation, observation, peer interaction, layered debriefing process with reflection, and video recordings.Unclear but it is likely that all learners must participate. 6) Capstone course; transition to practice (Thompson, Houston, & Dansie, 2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017)5Sustainable assessment and assessment for learning.Discussion during class, extensive feedback, two-way conversations, and reaching consensus.Discussions about performance were guided by a rubric. Withholding educator assessment until self-assessments are complete.All learners must participate. 7) Fundamentals in paramedicine (Thompson et al., 2020)5Paramedic reflective practice principles and real-world practice expectations.Discussion prior to self-assessment, student-led performance critique based on criterion, and two-way discourse to reach consensus.Withholding educator assessment until self-assessments are complete.All learners must participate. 8) resuscitation training (Thompson et al., 2024)5Authentic and sustainable assessment, entrustment decisions, and Ottawa criteria for assessment practice.Grading discussion guided by a scoring framework likely during a meeting.Self-assessment based on a framework prior to discussion. Withholding educator assessment until self-assessments are complete.All learners must participate.acourses were classified according to Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation at one or more levels.Note. There are 25 courses. Multiple reports described the same course, and some reports described multiple courses. For companion papers (i.e., those that reported on the same course and approach to assessment co-creation) data were extracted from both reports and combined. This table was ordered by discipline and publication date to match Table 2. How Co-creation of Assessment is Occurring acourses were classified according to Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation at one or more levels. Note. There are 25 courses. Multiple reports described the same course, and some reports described multiple courses. For companion papers (i.e., those that reported on the same course and approach to assessment co-creation) data were extracted from both reports and combined. This table was ordered by discipline and publication date to match Table 2. Table 4.Abbreviated Author Conclusions About Impacts and LessonsResearch and quality improvement reportsSourceAssignment descriptionFacilitatorsBarriersBenefitsDisadvantagesFuture considerations Fox and West (1983) Level 5: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Not reported.Student anxiety (higher at the beginning than the end).Achieved goals.Not reported.Increase self-directed learning.Unfamiliarity. a Developed and reinforced lifelong learning.Apply in clinical.Once familiar anxiety decreased, skills refined, and enthusiasm grew.Develop a systematic approach. Hardigan (1994) Learning contracts, details not reported.Recognize student uniqueness.May not suit memorization-heavy courses.Positive student response; concerns resolved; goals achieved.Initial confusion, disbelief, uncertainty.Recommended for this course, not all.Aligned with course content; meaningful, useful, and effective.Level unclear.Promoted clarity, equity, empowerment, and personal growth.Hesitancy to determine personal evaluation criteria.Continue in this course.Less competition, anxiety.More strategies needed. Huff and McNown Johnson (1998) Level 5: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects. Supported by narrative evaluations.Not reported.Scheduling meetings was challenging.Positive student response to learning contracts.Initial anxiety.Provide options, feedback, and grading clarity.Address anxiety and listen.Difficulty objectively grading diverse assignments.Monitor dynamics.Initial student anxiety.Eager for individualized feedback during narrative evaluations.Ensure fairness and flexibility.Scheduling.Foster creativity, questioning, and self-challenge.Resist deciding for students. Waddell and Stephens (2000) Level 5: Nominal group process and learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Bloom’s taxonomy action verbs. a Sharing power may feel uncomfortable for educators. a Empowering, customizable, and fosters lifelong learning and responsibility.Not reported.Strategies are useful in education and also potentially in other contexts (i.e., staff development).Inclusive design shifts power to students and values adult learners.Appropriate, feasible and manageable.Course content themes emerged over the years even though each delivery is individualized.Course content changes from term to term. a Solved heterogeneity challenges. b Additional benefits. Limin (2005) Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Alignment with curriculum, course, and learner needs.Learner readiness, interest, time limits, and unexpected events.High student approval, engagement, learning, and performance.High demands on teacher technical skills, organization, expertise, and preparation.Educators should be mindful of and respond to potential challenges and barriers.Humanistic, collaborative environment.Built professional identity, ethics, and social responsibility.Continuous guidance from instructors and peers.Personalized learning.Unable to determine the level.Use of appropriate and diverse assessment methods.Success depends on educator preparedness and student readiness and engagement.Overcomes traditional method limitations.Encourages reflection, collaboration, innovation, efficiency, autonomy, flexibility, lifelong learning.Educator skills, organization, and psychological readiness. b Additional benefits. Phillips and Napan (2016) Level 5 and 6: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Integrating self- and peer assessment with co-learning.Neoliberalism opposes co-creation.Shifts students from consumers to active participants.Tensions between top-down and bottom-up efforts.Reflexive sensitivity is essential.Sharing control.System tensions, contradictions.Welcomes diverse voices in assessment.Student resistance.Effective process, flexibility.Promotes responsibility for one’s own learning.System change is required to reduce tension.Ongoing educator reflection.Context-specific barriers.Voices who oppose dialogue are marginalized.Skilled facilitation, preparation, transparency, and context awareness.Pressure to pass students or meet targets. a Reflects real-world tensions of social work.Need to co-create while remaining critically aware of tensions.Focus on process not outputs.Exhaustion from opposing neoliberalism.Some voices dominate discussions.Thompson, Houston, & Dansie (2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017)Level 5: Consensus grading of simulation performance.A simple and intuitive approach. a Limited time to explain the process.Valued by educators and embraced by students.A few students were unhappy with being unable to earn grades by chance, which educators did not see as a disadvantage.Viewed as sustainable.Active engagement and critical reflection.Promoted learning, self-assessment, fairness, critical thinking.Prepares for real-world.Recommended for use.Aligns grades with capabilities. b Additional benefits. Esambe (2018) Research proposal writing.Acknowledge limiting factors (i.e., students’ lack of experience in the topic).Student apathy and different content value perceptions.Improved understanding, communication, clarity, and writing.Not reported.Recommends moving away from formal and linear ways of giving feedback.Difficult content.Active, collaborative feedback improved perceived value.Level unclear.Use multiple student engagement strategies.Grade-focused students.Educator professional development.System priorities.Identified contextual barriers and supports.Limited educator support, training, or resources.Built real-world skills via critical conversations. MacKenzie et al. (2018) Level 5: Simulation creation and implementation.Educator responsiveness to learner needs.Student unfamiliarity with simulation design.Valuable learning experience.Not reported.Unable to separate from other content discussed.Enhanced performance, confidence, and self-reflection.Feedback availability.Student openness to challenge themselves.Need for educator adaptability.Understanding case requirements.Mentioned that the findings are informative for future co-creation.Greater self-regulation.Learner-centered. Thompson et al. (2020) Level 5: Consensus grading of simulation performance.Not reported.Not reported.Positive attitude; fair and effective for learning.Not reported.Apply across the program.Supports future practice, reflection, thinking.Suitable for novices. a Preferred by tutors.Appropriate for beginning students.Authentic, empowering, and sustainable. b Additional benefits. Henderson et al. (2021) Level 5: Oral viva consensus grading.Not reported.Indistinct from other content.Valued reflective, two-way dialogue and learning.Looking for tutor judgement and inability to self-evaluate may be barriers or disadvantages. a Democratic summative assessment is possible, ongoing evaluation is needed. a Shifted power dynamics, authentic discussions.Fair, non-punitive, and collegial experience.Promoted reflection, self-evaluation, and evaluative judgement. Henderson et al. (2022) Oral viva grading using a consensus marking approach compared to traditional educator grading.Not reported.Not reported.Reduced hierarchy, anxiety, and stress.Increased anxiety for one person.Not reported.Enhanced satisfaction, authenticity, learning, accountability, self-assessment, and student voice.Immediate feedback.Level unclear.Learner-centered, empowering.Built motivation, evaluative judgement, and lifelong learning. b Additional benefits. Thompson et al. (2024) Level 5: Consensus grading of simulation performance.Student willingness to recieve and process critical feedback.Grade-seeking behaviour.Preferred method.Two students felt it was unfair as expectations were high and it impacted their confidence. These concerns were related to fear over lost grades.Transferable approach to grading.Empowered educators; constructive feedback.Personalized, context-rich, two-way discussion.Enhanced reflection, learning, and scores.Calibration between judgements.Assessed metacognition and observed skills.Perceived credible, valid, and reproducible. b Additional benefits.Killam, Akerlind, et al. (2024) Co-authors included one learner.Level 5 and 7: Virtual simulation assignment co-creation.Recognized need.Concerns over scalability. a Improved inclusion, equity, accessibility, learning.The newness of co-creation and course changes cause periods of confusion.Use a framework to explain the process and outcomes of co-creation.Student self-assessment skills and will to speak up.Strong educator support, guidance.Clear communication and input-seeking.Empowered students, fostered ownership.Monitoring for confusion.Reduced stress.Openness to working together.Built transferable skills and confidence.Organizational support.Mutual growth.Scaffolding opportunities across a curriculum. b Additional benefits.Non-research reportsSourceAssignment descriptionFacilitatorsBarriersBenefitsDisadvantagesFuture considerations Hengesbach (1980) Level 5: Learning contracts used to plan individualized projects.Not reported.Not reported.Not reported.Not reported.Not reported. Martenson and Schwab (1993) Learning contracts to plan course objectives and content with an entire class (not individual students).Clear and detailed steps.Reluctance.Practical approach.Unclear or unrealistic plans.Learning contracts should be used and can be made with the entire class instead of individual students.Positive impact on communication, confidence, and self-responsibility.Supports learning psychology.Unable to determine the level.Educator preparation and understanding of learning contracts.Educator fear of losing. Authority or control.Fosters collegiality, self-confidence, understanding.Educators may have difficulty making contracts meaningful.Builds negotiation, collaboration, and team-work skills. b Additional benefits. Owen-Mills (1996) Level 7: Self, peer, and educator evaluation worth 40% of the grade.Not reported.Indistinct from other content.Empowerment.Not reported.Not reported.Experiences may influence future practice. a Martyn (2000) and Martyn and Husain (1993)Level 5: Public speaking and writing projects.Perceived need, acceptance.Increased need to manage and facilitate negotiations.Manageable, practical, and customized.Not reported.Process syllabus is practical.Student maturity, prior skills.Negotiated agreements suit any course.Respect for diversity.Feelings of fear.Fostered experiential learning, pride, and engagement.Commitment and planning.Enhanced autonomy, communication, collaboration, leadership skills.Context shapes negotiation principles and processes, which will need refinement for other contexts.Working within institutional limitations.Built confidence, competence, self-management.A flexible syllabus.Viewing students as inferior or less capable.Created a valuable, memorable, enjoyable course.Institutional culture, collaboration.Institutional rules.Enabled collaboration.The process is essential for creating relevant courses. b Additional facilitators. b Additional benefits.Napan (2009) and Napan et al. (2020)Level 6: Learning contracts to plan a variety of projects with a written component that were as creative as possible.Providing a template.Institutional hierarchies.Heard student voices.Indistinct from other content.Students desire customization in other courses. a Built trust, respect.Fostered inclusivity, creativity, flexibility, and accessibility.Required constant educator accessibility via email.Promoted engagement, honesty, openness, and skill growth.Facilitated progress tracking, support.Elements may scale, but the process is most suited to smaller classes. a Maintained rigour.Course outcomes are typically predetermined.Produced high-quality, practice-relevant, assignments and feedback processes. b Additional benefits. Napan (2012) Level 6: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Flexible course delivery and assessment.Accreditation limits flexibility in course outcomes and assessment criteria.Focus on learning.Requires engagement in class discussions, meaning attendance should be mandated.Not reported.Students placed high expectations on themselves.Trust, mutual appreciation, multi-source feedback.Difficulty being critical of students who are trying their best.Flexibility to meet student needs.Post decisions to aid recall.Concern over rare instances of cheating.Overwhelmingly positive student feedback. Hawkins (2015) Level 7: Manuscript co-authorship (for publication after the course ends).Student interest.Concerns: Student commitment, vulnerability, unfamiliarity with processes.Co-authored publications.Not all manuscripts published. a Not reported.Pass/fail grading via negotiated contract.Improved writing skills.Embed choice.Increased faculty scholarly productivity.Evidence-based planning.Poor planning leads to burdensome co-authorship with minimal contributions.Clear expectations, and planning tools.Revisions may be discouraging.Coaching and encouragement. Napan (2016) Level 6: Learning contracts to plan individualized projects.Clear expectations; negotiable vs. non-negotiable outlined.Initial confusion and uncertainty, a which were resolved through clear expectations, support, and trust-building.Personalized learning.Not reported.Explore in other academic settings.Built relationships and discovered relevance during class activities. a Promoted clarity, trust, agency, honesty, peer support.Structured flexibility with high choice.Linked learning goals, passions, and real-life contexts.Ongoing reflection on principles. a Increased motivation, creativity, deep engagement, and quality.Appreciative, transformative, creative, and personalized learning environment. a Fostered fear-free, diverse, impactful, and inspirational learning.Expand reflection on impacts.Developed practical wisdom for lifelong learning. a b Additional benefits. Abboud et al. (2017) Level 5: Assignments are individualized.Not reported.Indistinct from other content.Indistinct from other content.Indistinct from other content.Not reported. Killam and Luctkar-Flude (2021) Level 5: Option for simulation co-creation to earn 5% of a course grade.Making co-creation a choice.Not reported.Improved student understanding.Not reported.Unable to separate from other content discussed.Quality simulation development for future classes.Killam, McAuliffe, et al. (2022). a Co-authors included students.Level 7: Interprofessional simulation experiences.Organizational structure and detailed guidance in live documents. a Indistinct from other content.Enriched learning experience.Students may become overwhelmed. a Co-creation is recommended for future use. Killam, Luctkar-Flude et al. (2024) Level 5: Module debriefing and reflection assignments.Technology.Oppressive educational structures. a Feasible and liberating.Not reported.Increase weighting.Board marking guide.Flexibility, choice and accessibility. a Integrating flexibility.Options will differ with each course. Killam et al. (in press) Level 7: Negotiated grading of assignments.Clear plan to guide students.Not scalable to large classes.Valuable process, shifted power.Time intensive process.Continued use with efficiency improvements.Student input in multiple stages.Resistance from others.Built real-world skills: Self-advocacy, self-assessment, communication.Not feasible in large classes; adapt elements for scale.Ongoing guidance, communication.Use in only one class.Promoted reflection, engagement, self-directed learning.Discussions may delay feedback in large classes.Reduce meeting time.Clarify terminology.Trusting relationships.Unfamiliar to students.Learning through feedback and role modeling.Plan for resistance.High instructor workload.Meaningful links with course content.Terminology may confuse students and academics.Provide clear structure.Shared values. b Additional benefits.Excessive change may overwhelm studentsScaffolded across a curriculum.Contextual constraints may exist. b Additional considerations.aImplied: Required interpretation.bExtensive benefits reported; to promote readability, clarity, and comparability, only key or most frequently reported benefits are summarized in this table. A full version is available in Appendix 6.Note. Data were only extracted if a connection to assessment co-creation could be identified. Reports where we were unable to separate data from other content discussed co-creation in a way that was integrated with other interventions. Sources with multiple citations in column 1 were treated as companion papers (i.e., the same report) since they describe the same course and approach to assessment co-creation. Data were extracted from both reports and combined in the tables. This table is ordered by publication date. Abbreviated Author Conclusions About Impacts and Lessons aImplied: Required interpretation. bExtensive benefits reported; to promote readability, clarity, and comparability, only key or most frequently reported benefits are summarized in this table. A full version is available in Appendix 6. Note. Data were only extracted if a connection to assessment co-creation could be identified. Reports where we were unable to separate data from other content discussed co-creation in a way that was integrated with other interventions. Sources with multiple citations in column 1 were treated as companion papers (i.e., the same report) since they describe the same course and approach to assessment co-creation. Data were extracted from both reports and combined in the tables. This table is ordered by publication date. Table 5.Reported Limitations and GapsResearch and quality improvement reportsSourceAimDesignLimitationsGapsFox and West (1983), USADescribe and evaluate learning contracts.Quantitative, pre-post survey and educator observation.Not reported.Investigate learning contract use in more areas of medical education.92 students.Hardigan (1994), USADetermine if students view contract grading as effective.Quantitative, survey.Not reported.Test impacts on class performance.61 students from two cohorts.Explore why students do not want learning contracts in all courses.Huff and McNown Johnson (1998), USAExplore strategies to empower students.Quantitative, quasi-experimental with multiple interventions.Small sample.Employ a randomized study design.Potential selection bias.Conduct a study with the same instructor for both sections.Non-random group assignment.Measure impacts on learning and practice.Researcher-developed questionnaire.Potential social desirability in responses.Study interventions separately to test effectiveness.Untested instrument with no neutral option, potentially reducing differences between groups.46 students in two groups: 22 (experimental) and 24 (comparison).Measures student perceptions.Different instructors across sections.Esambe (2018), South AfricaExplore dialogical formative feedback.Qualitative, diffractive methodology.Small sample.Explore in other departments and universities.Focus groups and draft papers with comments.Unable to generalize.Leverage both qualitative and quantitative approaches.14 students and 2 educators.Methods prevented in-depth exploration of learning.Explore depth of learning.MacKenzie et al. (2018), CanadaOutline guidance and impacts for simulation co-construction.Qualitative.Small homogenous sample.Conduct larger studies.Instructor field notes and a student-completed open-ended survey.Reliance on qualitative methods.Leverage both qualitative and quantitative approaches.8 students.Findings are context specific and not generalizable.Test effectiveness in other contexts.Thompson et al. (2020), AustraliaEvaluate perceptions of consensus grading.Quantitative, survey.Small scale study with a single cohort.Unable to separate.88 students.Not generalizable.Henderson et al. (2021), AustraliaExplore student perceptions of online vivas and consensus marking.Qualitative research using pre-existing data.Small sample.Compare consensus marking and educator assessment.Simple open-ended questions were asked during data collection.Explore impacts on learner-educator relationships and resulting anxiety.Recordings of answers to open-ended questions asked for quality assurance purposes.Explore how different learning preferences impact experiences and outcomes (i.e., satisfaction, self-evaluation, and changes in future practice).Findings are context specific and not generalizable.Investigate educator perspectives.13 students.Reliance on student perceptions, which may contain assumptions about assessment.Study other disciplines.Henderson et al. (2022), AustraliaCompare consensus marking to traditional assessor judgement and explore perceptions.Convergent mixed-methods parallel research design.Reliance on a one group, non-randomised design.Identify strategies to engage students in dialogue.Semi-structured interviews (n = 13) after both oral vivas were graded.Inability to draw conclusions as exposure to the first oral viva may have impacted outcomes.Validated questionnaires.Risk of pressure to participate and bias since a researcher was also the educator.Conduct a larger randomized controlled trial testing different strategies to develop self-assessment skills.46 students.Thompson et al. (2024), AustraliaEvaluate assessment pedagogy.Explanatory sequential mixed methods design.Single-site, convenience sample, unblinded, no control.Explore equivalence criteria.Phase 1: Score comparison; 84 students.Did not assess perceptions of Ottawa equivalence criteria.Long-term retesting.Phase 2: Survey; 77 students and 7 assessors.Killam, Akerlind, et al. (2024), Co-authors included one learner. CanadaExplore differences in students’ experience of assignment co-creation.Qualitative research, phenomenography.Findings are context specific and not generalizable.Explore interventions to facilitate understanding of co-creation.5-Question open-ended survey and reflective journals written during the course.Reliance on written responses where probing for depth cannot occur.Identify strategies to help students reach higher levels of understanding.Compare depth in written versus interview responses.32 students.Exclusive focus on student perceptions.Explore educator perspectives.Non-research reportsSourceAimPerspectiveLimitationsGapsOwen-Mills (1996), NZDescribe how dialect is established in a transformative curriculum.EducatorThe paper is subjective, and perceptions may change.Not reported.Martyn (2000) and Martyn and Husain (1993), PakistanAdvocate for a task-based syllabus and syllabus negotiation.EducatorNo negotiation process can be replicated due to contextual factors.Test and refine principles and processes in other contexts.Explore the impact of changes in administrative structures on the process.Killam and Luctkar-Flude (2021), CanadaDescribe virtual simulation creation and gamification to encourage co-creation.EducatorNot reported.Research about simulation co-creation is needed.Napan (2012), NZReflect on collaborative inquiry-based course delivery.EducatorNot reported.Test strategies in other course contexts.Napan (2016), NZDescribe how course-based co-creation develops practical wisdom.EducatorNot reported.Explore in other academic settings.Expand reflection on impacts.Killam and Luctkar-Flude (2021), CanadaDescribe virtual simulation creation and gamification to encourage learner-educator co-creation.EducatorNot reported.Evaluate replacement of clinical hours.Explore co-creation of virtual simulations.Killam, McAuliffe, et al. (2022), CanadaDescribe the process used to co-create an assignment.Both student and educatorNot reported.Explore diverse student experiences.Killam, Luctkar-Flude et al. (2024), CanadaDescribe an inclusive approach to integrating e-learning modules.EducatorNot reported.Explore diverse student experiences with highly interactive courses.Conduct experimental studies to test impacts on learning outcomes.Refine the process based on student feedback.Killam et al. (in press), CanadaExplore negotiated grading.EducatorNo objective data collection, reflection-based, and did not test effectiveness.Develop conceptual clarity and refine terminology.Explore student and educator experiences with different ways of negotiating grades.Identify ways to mitigate resistance.Measure outcomes and test various approaches.Note. Limitations and gaps were not reported in Waddell and Stephens (2000), Limin (2005), Phillips and Napan (2016), or Thompson, Houston, & Dansie (2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017).Note. Limitations and gaps were not reported in Hengesbach (1980), Martenson and Schwab (1993), Napan (2009) and Napan et al. (2020), Hawkins (2015), and Abboud et al. (2017). Reported Limitations and Gaps Note. Limitations and gaps were not reported in Waddell and Stephens (2000), Limin (2005), Phillips and Napan (2016), or Thompson, Houston, & Dansie (2017, Thompson, Houston, Dansie, Rayner et al., 2017). Note. Limitations and gaps were not reported in Hengesbach (1980), Martenson and Schwab (1993), Napan (2009) and Napan et al. (2020), Hawkins (2015), and Abboud et al. (2017). Co-created assessment types reported by course discipline and level Co-created decisions reported by phase of assessment and assignment type Note. The inner circle illustrates the assessment phase, the middle circle shows the specific elements within this phase that were shared, and the outer circle identifies the types of assessments where co-creation occurred. As illustrated, shared decision-making was most frequently reported during the assessment planning phase. Co-created assessment decisions reported by course level and discipline Note. Figure 5 is ordered according to a typical sequencing of events. However, assessment was often an iterative and non-linear process meaning that these decisions did not necessarily happen in this order. Levels of learner influence by course discipline and course level. Note. Levels of learner influence are based on Bovill and Bulley's (2011) ladder of participation. Courses with multiple levels of participation were counted at the highest level. *Courses that could not be placed are counted at level 5. Levels of learner influence by assessment phase. Note. Levels of learner influence are based on Bovill and Bulley's (2011) ladder of participation. Courses with multiple levels of participation were counted at the highest level. *Courses that could not be placed are counted at level 5. Choice in participation by level of learner influence. Note: Levels of learner influence are based on Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation Interaction methods used during co-creation by level of learner influence. Note. Levels of Learner Influence are based on Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation. This figure is based on data from 23 courses. Interaction methods were unclear in Hardigan (1994) and MacKenzie et al. (2018). 2 courses could not be placed at a level and are counted at level 5. 2 courses had multiple levels of participation and were counted at the highest level. Where Co-creation of Assessment Is Occurring (Question 1) Table 2 summarizes 25 courses in which co-creation of assessment was reported including the disciplines involved, reasons for it, and assessment decisions made together. Data were extracted from 27 included reports, which included three pairs of companion papers that described the same course and use of assessment co-creation. In addition, 2 reports described multiple courses. In one case, the report referenced multiple courses but did not provide sufficient detail to distinguish them clearly, so it was counted as a single course in this review (Martenson & Schwab, 1993). Two reports described separate assignments in the same course and were therefore counted as one course (with parts a and b in the table). Co-creation of assessment was reported across courses representing diverse disciplines and academic levels. Courses included the following disciplines: Nursing (n = 11), Social Work (n = 3), Paramedicine (n = 3), Medicine (n = 2), Health Services Navigation (n = 1), Pharmacy (n = 1), Occupational Therapy (n = 1), Dental Technology (n = 1), and multiple disciplines in the same course (n = 3). Co-creation of assessment was reported in courses at undergraduate (n = 16 of 25 courses), graduate (n = 6), and postgraduate (n = 2) levels, with one course at an unspecified level. Most courses were mandatory (n = 11) or likely mandatory (n = 10). Some (n = 4) courses were electives. Courses spanned various years of study, from first-year (n = 6), second-year (n = 2), third-year (n = 4), fourth-year (n = 1), or senior or exit level (n = 3), and multiple or unspecified levels (n = 9). Educators engaged students in co-creation for a variety of reasons. They wanted to promote learning, personalize courses around learners’ unique needs and interests, make assignments more meaningful, balance flexibility with structure required by accreditation, foster mutual planning, and clarify objectives. Co-creation of assessment was viewed as a tool to enhance how educator feedback is received and implemented in difficult teaching contexts. Co-creation of assessment was also used to empower students, improve equity, support self-direction, self-regulation, and shift learner focus from grades to authentic learning. Through co-creation educators hoped to give students more autonomy and promote independence. It was used to prepare students for real-world practice and collaboration by promoting transferable skills such as critical thinking, reflection, evaluative judgment, and self-assessment. Additional goals included producing graduates capable of leading change in healthcare systems, addressing inequities through anti-oppression and accessibility practices, mentoring students in writing and communication, and managing competitive cultures or dissatisfaction with traditional grading. Partnering with students in writing also aimed to simultaneously help educators be productive in an ethical way. In addition, co-creation of assessment was used to address challenges in prior course delivery, enhance engagement, commitment, promote lifelong learning, and build student confidence. Commonly co-created assignments involved learning contracts (n = 11), writing (n = 8), and aspects of simulation (n = 8), which were reported across all included disciplinary categories as well as at both undergraduate and graduate or postgraduate levels of education (Figure 3). More specifically, written assignments were used to develop skills in research, scholarly writing, and reflection. Learning contracts were used to plan a variety of individualized projects or to plan course objectives and content with an entire class (not individual students). Aspects of simulation creation, implementation, and/or performance evaluation were co-created to develop transferable skills. In addition, co-created assignments included presentations, module debriefing and reflection, self/peer/educator evaluation processes, and other student-driven assignment types. What Assessment Decisions Are Being Made Together (Question 2) The final column in Table 2 and Figure 4 summarizes the different types of assessment planning (n = 20), completion (n = 6), and student evaluation (n = 12) decisions that were co-created by course. Only 4 courses engaged students in all three phases of assessment (although not always in the same assignment) and all 6 instances of co-created assignment completion also engaged learners in assignment planning or student evaluation. Across disciplines, co-creation of assessment was reported in all phases. Planning emerged as the most common co-created aspect of assessment, followed by evaluation and then completion. In nursing, 10 of 11 courses included the planning stage with about half (n = 5 of 11) including evaluation and 3 involving co-completion. All 6 courses in social and human services included students in planning, with 2 including evaluation and 1 including completion. In medicine and other allied health (n = 8 courses), students were most commonly included in evaluation (n = 5), followed by planning (n = 4), and completion (n = 2). When examined by course level, co-creation of assessment was also reported in all phases of assessment. Undergraduate students were most often involved in planning assessments (n = 12 of 16) and less often involved in co-completion (n = 4 of 16) or co-evaluation (n = 7 of 16) of assessments. All 6 reports of co-creation of assessment with graduate students included assessment planning, with one report including all three phases of assessment and three including evaluation. Both reports with postgraduate students included co-evaluation with one course including students in all three phases of assessment. The course at an unspecified level included co-creation during the planning phase. Course outcomes were co-created in only one course where co-creation occurred with the entire class and not individual students (Martenson & Schwab, 1993). In the remaining courses, learners and educators engaged in co-creation of assessment during the course to plan in a variety of ways. The most common co-created aspects of planning included deciding on grading criteria or the evidence needed to show learning (n = 16), and assessment instructions or plan (n = 15). In 12 courses co-creation was used to plan the assessment format (i.e., written, presentation, or other). Students were also included in co-creating assessment learning outcomes (n = 7), the focus of the assignment to meet pre-determined assessment learning outcomes (n = 10), due dates (n = 8), weighting of assignments (i.e., how much each is worth) (n = 6), and more. During assignment implementation, co-creation involved completing the assignment together in 5 courses. And in another course learners worked with educators to address formative feedback derived from peers, the writing center, and educators (Esambe, 2018), which we counted as co-completion. Co-created learner evaluation included generation of performance feedback in 11 courses and deciding on final grades together in 6 courses. How Much Influence Learners Have (Question 3) The 25 courses were classified according to Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation at one or more levels (see Table 3). Multiple levels of participation were evident in 3 courses based on different student understandings of co-creation (Killam, Akerlind, et al., 2024) or where different assignments were described in separate reports (Killam & Luctkar-Flude, 2021; Killam et al. (in press)) and are counted at the highest level in this review. The lowest level of participation, level 5, was the most common (n = 11) where learners had control over prescribed areas of assessment. In addition, 4 courses could not be placed at a specific level but based on article wording they were likely at or above level 5 and are counted at level 5 in this review. There were 4 courses that contained level 6 participation where students had the option to chose what areas to change (i.e., they designed a project to achieve prescribed learning outcomes). Lastly, 6 courses contained level 7 participation where there was a partnership, and students worked with educators to negotiate assessment. Figure 6 shows the level of influence according to Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation by course discipline and course level. In nursing, co-creation was either at level 5 or 7, with reports of undergraduate, graduate, and postgraduate courses at level 5. Almost all instances of Level 7 co-creation reported in this review occurred in undergraduate nursing courses (n = 5). The one postgraduate navigation course with Level 7 co-creation occurred in collaboration with a nursing course. In social work, one graduate course was at level 5 and another 4 courses were at level 6. All courses in Medicine and other allied health contained level 5 participation. The level of influence based on the phase of assessment is shown in Figure 7. While planning is the most frequently reported phase across all levels of participation, when co-creation reached level 7 a higher proportion of reports involved assignment completion or student evaluation. How Learners Influence Decisions (Question 4) A summary of how co-creation was implemented in health professional courses is presented in Table 3. Assessment co-creation design was guided by various frameworks across the 25 unique courses, which are grouped into one of three overlapping categories based on the main emphasis in reports: fostering self-direction and autonomy, educational design to promote learning, and/or real-world application. Together, all categories of frameworks guiding co-creation highlight a common aim of equipping learners with the skills, mindset, and confidence needed for lifelong learning and competent professional practice. Learner-centered frameworks to foster self-direction and autonomy were evident in 7 courses. For example, leveraging adult learning principles, including Knowles guidance for learning contracts, meant aligning assessment with learner goals, promoting autonomy, and enabling independent learning. Educators in these courses empowered students to set goals, plan, and take responsibility for their own learning. Educational design frameworks to promote learning were the most common category, observed in 12 courses. These courses used frameworks such as learning psychology, inquiry-based learning, constructivism, or instructional design to scaffold learning, encourage reflection, inform dialogue, and promote metacognition. According to learning psychology, effective learning requires new knowledge to be connected to prior understanding, individualized pacing, learner autonomy, and a supportive environment for interaction and feedback. Through inquiry-based learning the educator’s role shifts from a knowledge provider to a facilitator. Constructivist and progressive education philosophies also emphasize learner-centeredness, critical thinking, and interaction between learners and educators in different and sometimes emancipatory ways. Instructional design theories were also used to emphasize the need to be deliberate, inclusive, and reflective when structuring courses. Real-world application was a closely related category, emphasizing preparation for professional practice or authentic tasks as part of educational design. This category was evident in 6 courses focused on preparing learners for future professional challenges and bridging classroom learning with real-world expectations. For example, assessment-focused frameworks included assessment as learning, authentic assessment, or sustainable assessment, which share a common goal of developing learner evaluative judgement. Evaluative judgement refers to the capacity to self-assess and assess the performance of others. Assessment as learning emphasizes scaffolded skill-building. Authentic assessment also involves scaffolding with an emphasis on aligning assessment with real-world tasks and contexts. Likewise, sustainable assessment emphasizes the need to equip learners with the skills to face future challenges. All 3 of these assessment frameworks aim to build real-world transferrable skills that are essential for lifelong learning and professional practice. Learner participation in co-creation was either required or optional (See Figure 8). All learners were required to participate in co-creation in 14 courses, most of which were at level 5 on Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation. In 4 courses, all learners had a choice if they wanted to participate in co-creation or not. In 2 courses, all learners must participate in some aspects of co-creation, but others were optional. In one course, learners chose to participate at the onset of the course and if all of the students agreed, then all of them participated (Napan, 2009). In 4 courses, it was unclear if participation was mandated or optional. Interaction methods are summarized in Figure 9. At all levels, both synchronous and asynchronous interaction methods were used, and, in most courses (n = 13 of 18), multiple interaction strategies were used (ranging from 2 to 7 strategies). Discussion was used as a strategy for interaction with students across all reports where interaction methods were reported (n = 18 of 18 courses). Across reports, verbal discussions occurred with an entire class, again, after educator refinement of plans based on class discussions, during individual meetings, during class time with smaller groups of students, and/or in groups during class time. Discussion also occurred through anonymous online discussion boards during classes and asynchronous online group discussion boards. Other strategies used to co-create assessment included a range of approaches, such as reaching consensus. Of note, the way in which this agreement took place varied across the cited literature and uses other strategies such as discussion, forms, or email to reach an agreement. In addition, educators used open-ended surveys to gather input, email communication, document submission, or editing live documents together synchronously or asynchronously. Additional methods involved providing written constructive feedback before grade requests, exchanging feedback on draft work, and holding meetings by request rather than with each student. Other techniques included voting during the nominal group process, distributing an invitation letter, offering an anonymous comment box, and facilitating student-led performance critiques with a guide (i.e., rubric). Reported Impacts and Lessons (Question 5) Table 4 and Figure 10 summarizes reported facilitators, barriers, benefits, disadvantages, and future considerations for learner-educator co-creation of assessment.Figure 10.Reported Impacts and Lessons Learned Reported Impacts and Lessons Learned Facilitators Facilitators that made it more possible for co-creation of assessment to occur were reported in 19 of 27 reports. These facilitators included student factors, educator skills and preparation, process design and clarity, institutional alignment, and collaborative relationships. Student factors identified in 7 reports included engagement through multiple strategies, openness to self-challenge, willingness to receive and process critical feedback, and ability to self-assess, speak up, and collaborate. Additional influences were perceived need and acceptance, maturity, motivation, prior skill building, shared commitment, interest, and development of shared values. Educator skills and preparation, extracted from 8 reports, included strong planning, organization, design, and facilitation skills, psychological readiness and responsiveness to learner needs, respect for diverse expertise, commitment to shared goals, flexibility and ongoing reflection. The most common facilitator identified across 16 reports was clear and flexible process design. It was critical to establish transparent expectations, structured yet adaptable guidance, and intuitive processes to support student engagement. Helpful strategies included planning for multiple engagement methods, leveraging technology such as anonymous online discussion boards and collaborative online document editing, providing clear templates and planning tools to reduce confusion, offering detailed guidance, integrating diverse assessment methods, ongoing communication, in-class activities, monitoring for confusion, and negotiating flexible syllabi that balanced structure with student choice. These approaches supported clarity, encouraged student engagement, and allowed processes to adapt to varying learner experience levels. Institutional alignment, identified in 4 reports, involved ensuring fit with curriculum and learner needs, scaffolding within the program, and securing organizational support while remaining aware of contextual limitations. Relationship-building and collaboration were facilitators described across 9 reports. Creating a humanistic, collaborative environment that recognized student uniqueness, built trust and mutual appreciation, encouraged openness to working together, and fostered supportive relationships with continuous guidance and feedback supported co-creation efforts. Barriers Barriers specific to co-creation of assessment were described in 19 of 27 reports and were framed as factors that limited or prevented co-creation from occurring. These barriers may be context-specific and related to emotional factors, cognitive challenges, workload and logistical issues, program limitations, and difficulties with participation. Emotional factors were identified in 8 reports and included student anxiety, fear, confusion, discouragement from revisions, apathy, or grade-focused attitudes. Likewise, cognitive challenges described in 7 reports included unfamiliarity with processes, terminology confusion, differing perceptions of content value, content difficulty, and limited readiness or preparedness among students and educators. These emotional and cognitive challenges were often reduced or resolved over time. Workload and logistical issues hindering co-creation of assessment were described in 12 reports and related to high educator demands, limited time, systemic pressures, inadequate support/resources, scheduling, and scalability challenges. It was also described as a misfit with memorization-heavy courses. Similarly, program limitations were identified in 4 reports due to institutional rules, fixed outcomes, and accreditation requirements that restrict flexibility. In addition, difficulties with participation stemmed from power imbalances, educator discomfort with sharing control, educator difficulty critiquing students who were trying their best, student reluctance, hierarchical norms, and concerns around mitigating cheating in 5 reports. Disadvantages Disadvantages specific to co-creation of assessment were closely related to barriers experienced, but positioned as negative outcomes of co-creation, and reported in 14 of 27 reports. Disadvantages related to emotional challenges, workload and logistical barriers, as well as participation challenges. Emotional challenges (n = 8) such as initial confusion, disbelief, uncertainty, hesitancy, or anxiety were predominantly described as temporary disadvantages, which may occur initially and/or when expectations change. Confusion was also attributed to terminology as well as the uniqueness of co-creation of assessment. Another concern was the potential for learners to become overwhelmed, particularly if too much change occurred. The root cause was sometimes identified as fear over the inability to earn grades by chance. Authors identified that these concerns may be resolved during the co-creation process or limited to a few students. Processes were also reported as time intensive, leading to workload and logistical concerns in 6 reports. Co-creation of assessment placed high demands on educator skills, organization, expertise, and preparation. Scheduling may be difficult when meetings are required and large class size may delay feedback. Concern was also raised around potential for unclear or unrealistic plans and objectively grading diverse assignments. When poorly planned, co-creation was reported to become burdensome, and learners contributed minimally. Careful planning was therefore identified as essential to balance workload with making the process meaningful. Participation challenges, though only surfaced in 4 reports, included resistance, reliance on participation, and the impact of power dynamics in the classroom. Resistance originated from students or other educators, and a perception that co-creation of assessment meant students ‘doing the educator’s job’. One author suggested that class attendance should be mandated since a student who did not attend classes struggled to understand the process. During discussions, power dynamics meant that inevitably some voices may dominate, and the voices of those who oppose dialogue may be marginalized or excluded. Mitigating these participation challenges requires careful planning. Taken together, 21 reports identified emotional and/or cognitive challenges (n = 15), process, workload, and logistical issues (n = 14), participation obstacles (n = 8), and program limitations (n = 4) as disadvantages or barriers. Benefits Benefits of assessment co-creation were outlined in most reports (n = 25 of 27), highlighting that it was an overall valuable experience. Benefits included process improvements, creation of a supportive and collegial learning environment, educator benefits, learner empowerment and equity, general learning gains, specific skill development, as well as personal growth and lifelong learning. Process improvements from working with students identified in 20 reports included flexibility, meaningful choices, personalization, and shifting power dynamics in feasible ways. Co-creation incorporated student voices, promoted autonomy, clearly communicated negotiable elements of assessment, and led to manageable customized assignments. Reflective two-way dialogue, immediate feedback, active student involvement in the process, and detailed feedback enhanced student satisfaction, clarity, fairness, understanding, and engagement while aligning assessment with learning needs, curriculum and real-world practice. The process fostered clarity, relevance, and efficiency. It also supported active collaboration between students and educators, was suitable for a wide range of learners, and enhanced the perceived credibility and authenticity of assessment. Co-creation fostered a supportive and collegial learning environment (n = 6) characterized by trust, respect, support, authentic dialogue, and mutual understanding. Relationship-building and growing familiarity with the process reduced hierarchy, anxiety, stress, and fear while building motivation, pride, and enthusiasm for learning. Learners held themselves to high standards, which further contributed to building a positive environment. The process promoted meaningful engagement, reflection, and collaboration with educators and peers. This environment led to an enjoyable, and memorable learning experience that leveraged contributors’ strengths and supported real-world relevance. Educator benefits included professional growth and scholarly gains (n = 8), such as professional development, compensating for limited facilities, co-authored publications, and increased research productivity. Co-creation supported quality resource and simulation development, addressed learner diversity, and empowered educators by enhancing credibility and allowing them to leverage their expertise. Educators preferred consensus grading over traditional methods. Co-creation fostered empowerment and equity (n = 13 reports) through authentic discussions, inclusivity, shifting power to students, valuing diverse voices, recognizing learners as adults, and promoting ownership of learning. Learner-centered approaches enhanced accessibility, reduced competition and anxiety, and encouraged social responsibility and authentic engagement. Learning was a major outcome of co-creation of assessment in 22 reports. Authors reported general learning gains in 17 reports, including authentic and practice-relevant learning, enriched course content, improved understanding, insights into performance, competence, and higher-quality academic results/performance. Learning resulted from practical and customized assignments, clarified objectives, deeper reflection, meaningful feedback, role modeling, increased motivation, deep learner engagement, and stronger links between learning outcomes and real-world application. This learning led to goal attainment, a sense of accomplishment, high approval from students, and unexpected learning. In addition, specific skill development (n = 15 reports), included growth in cognitive skills such as reasoning, problem-solving, metacognition, creative thinking, lateral thinking, and critical thinking. Additional transferable skills developed included communication, collaboration, team-work, self-assessment, self-advocacy, and negotiation skills, as well as improved writing and co-authorship abilities. Critical conversations during co-creation fostered real-world skills, leadership abilities, and reflection. Closely related, personal growth and lifelong learning benefits emerged across 16 reports and centered around developing readiness for professional practice. Benefits of co-creation in this category included components of independent lifelong learning such as autonomy, self-responsibility, self-direction, self-management, accountability, professional identity, practical wisdom, reflective practice, and evaluative judgment. In addition, learners grew their confidence in areas such as self-advocacy and self-regulated learning. Overall, co-creation promoted ownership of learning, preparing students for real-world practice and supporting ongoing personal and professional development. Future Considerations Ideas to improve future co-creation of assessment efforts were identified in 21 of 27 reports. Future considerations across the reports emphasized the need to continue or adapt approaches for future use (n = 14) and broaden application to other contexts such as more courses in a program, clinical, and professional development settings (n = 6). In addition, educators can support student engagement in co-created assessment through clear guidance, flexible options, feedback, addressing anxiety, ensuring fairness, monitoring group dynamics, and using structured frameworks with scaffolded, team-based strategies to empower learners while responding to potential challenges and barriers (n = 4). Educators also need to engage in ongoing reflection and evaluation to develop guiding principles and refine processes for diverse contexts (n = 4), and address system and cultural change (n = 2). Gaps in the Literature Limitations and research gaps reported in the literature are summarized in Table 5 alongside each report’s aims and designs. Among the research studies, 8 reports explicitly acknowledged limitations due to small, homogeneous, convenience, or single site samples, which limits generalizability. In some cases, different instructors or researcher involvement as educator posed a risk of bias or pressure to participate. In addition, designs were limited by non-randomized, single-group designs without controls, making it difficult to infer causation. Findings relied on student perceptions, risking social desirability bias, and did not capture educator perspectives. At times, data collection was based on untested or limited instruments (e.g., no neutral option, simple open-ended questions). Some data collection methods prevented in-depth exploration, limiting the ability to draw conclusions. Findings, particularly from qualitative studies, were also context-specific, making results hard to apply broadly. Three non-research reports noted limitations in relation to the report being based on subjective interpretations that may change, the inability to replicate any context-specific syllabus negotiation process, and the reflection-based nature of the report with no objective data collection. Authors of 16 reports noted a need for research related to (1) perspective exploration, (2) strategy refinement, (3) outcome identification, and (4) improved methodologies. Authors of 6 reports called for future research to build a more complete understanding of co-creation from multiple perspectives, including educator perspectives (n = 4) as well as different and diverse student experiences (n = 4). Hardigan (1994) identified that it would also be interesting to explore why students who liked using learning contracts did not want to use them in all courses. Strategy refinement to improve how co-creation of assessment is implemented was called for in 11 reports. Researchers need to explore principles, strategies, and processes in multiple and diverse contexts to further develop pedagogy (n = 7). For example, researchers need to test ways to communicate what co-creation of assessment involves clearly to help students understand it (n = 2) and explore approaches to engage students in feedback dialogue that develop their evaluative judgment (Henderson et al., 2022). In addition, to facilitate implementation, researchers should identify ways to mitigate resistance from other educators to sharing power with students through co-creation (Killam et al. (in press)). Likewise, exploring the impact of changes in administrative structures on the process may offer interesting insights into the contexts where co-creation of assessment may flourish (Martyn & Husain, 1993). Outcome-oriented research was identified as a need in 6 reports to identify student and instructional impacts of co-created assessment. Researchers should investigate and compare the impact of different approaches to assessment co-creation and grading methods. For example, outcomes needing further investigation included student satisfaction, learner-educator relationships, classroom performance, depth in learning, future practice, anxiety, and self-assessment skills. Authors of 7 reports also called for improved methodologies in future research that leverages both qualitative and quantitative approaches (n = 2), includes larger studies (n = 3), and longitudinal designs. Outcome testing should involve randomized experimental studies (n = 3). When comparing courses with and without co-creation it would be ideal to have the same instructor teaching the experimental and control groups (Huff & McNown Johnson, 1998). Discussion Summary of Main Results We identified 27 distinct reports published between 1980 and 2025 that describe 25 unique courses where co-creation of assessment was reported in health professional educational settings, highlighting that there is insufficient research in this area. Included reports originated from 8 different countries, with most coming from North America; the global south was underrepresented. Despite a geographic imbalance in the literature, this finding supports the international applicability of co-creation of assessment in health professional education. While there may be a global interest in co-creation of assessment, a lack of representation across countries and languages in our findings underscores the need for more research across diverse educational and cultural contexts. Co-creation of assessment has been reported in both mandatory and elective undergraduate, graduate, and postgraduate health professional education courses in 8 disciplines: nursing, social work, medicine, health services navigation, paramedicine, pharmacy, occupational therapy and dental technology as well as multidisciplinary courses. This reporting across diverse course types and disciplines indicates that co-creation of assessment has potential in a variety of contexts for a variety of learners. Co-created assessments included learning contracts, writing assignments, simulation, presentations, and more. Many assessment decisions were made together, predominantly during the planning stage when determining grading criteria and instructions. In most situations, learners had control over prescribed areas of assessment (RQ3), with higher levels of partnership with students noted in nursing and social service courses. The reported diversity across approaches to co-creation points to the contextual nature of co-creation, which educators should consider when choosing how to approach co-creating with learners in their context. Discussion during and outside of class time was the most common way educators engaged learners in making decisions (RQ4). This finding may be because without some form of dialogue, co-creation efforts may be pseudo-partnerships (Suliman et al., 2025), which would fall lower on Bovill and Bulley's (2011) ladder of participation and would have been excluded from this review. Educators typically used multiple synchronous and asynchronous interaction strategies. Courses with higher levels of partnership also tended to offer more methods of interaction. Multiple engagement strategies support equitable participation (Dyson, 2018; Killam, Lock, et al., 2023) and are therefore recommended. Overall, reports were highly positive. Many benefits and ways to support co-creation were described, but no attempt was made in this review to draw conclusions about the benefits of co-creation. Barriers, disadvantages, and ways to make co-creation more successful were also reported across all levels of learner influence. These findings are primarily intended to promote educator reflection while planning for co-creation of assessment. The highly contextual nature of co-creation may explain conflicting reports. For example, some authors noted initial confusion as a temporary challenge that was resolved as students engaged in the process. However, others reported confusion without indicating if it diminished over time, presenting it as a lasting disadvantage. Confusion may relate to contextual factors such as how new co-creation is to students and how clearly the process is communicated to them. In another example, some authors position co-creation as feasible and practical whereas others note practical challenges with its implementation. Authors who experienced practical challenges indicated that improved planning could help to mitigate them. Additional factors that may have impacted their experience include class size, level of learner, and availability of support and resources. Potential Biases in the Review Process To reduce potential sources of bias, this review was designed to capture all dates and broad co-creation terminology in multiple databases. However, to ensure feasibility, we did not conduct comprehensive searches for non-English language publications or systematically search grey literature. Thus, this review may be subject to publication bias. We attempted to minimize this bias by hand searching the reference lists of included studies and relevant reviews, as well as screening organizational reports and websites referenced in included publications. Bias may have been introduced due to different interpretations of article content or inclusion criteria. At times, reports were difficult to understand. We attempted to mitigate this concern by ensuring all reports were reviewed by two or more team members and resolving conflicts through discussion. We involved a third and sometimes fourth reviewer in these conversations as needed and described any key reports that were challenging to interpret or close to meeting the inclusion criteria in Appendix 4. It was also challenging and sometimes seemed artificial to separate co-creation of assessment from other kinds of co-creation occurring in a course. We attempted to mitigate this concern by reporting strategies that supported co-creation of assessment in Table 3. Likewise, we excluded co-creation occurring within clinical placement settings to support the feasibility of this review, as they would have been captured by Barradell and Bell’s (2021) review. However, some of the reports we excluded were outside of the timeframe covered in their review and may have contributed to this review. We also restricted this review to co-creation of assessment in health professional education. Many reports (n = 54) were excluded for not being in health professional education, meaning that these reports may have described assessment co-creation in higher education contexts that could be transferable to health professional education. Agreements and Disagreements With Other Reviews Our findings are mainly consistent with 5 other recent reviews on co-creation in health professional education (Abbonizio et al., 2024; Ambrosetti et al., 2025; Barradell & Bell, 2021; O'Connor et al., 2021; Suliman et al., 2025). Together, recent reviews of co-creation in health professions education highlight disciplinary and geographical variation in existing literature. Barradell and Bell (2021) found that most qualitative reports of students as partners were from North America and focused on medicine. Another recent scoping review, which examined curriculum co-design, similarly reported a dominance of medical studies in Western contexts, particularly the USA and the UK (Abbonizio et al., 2024). In contrast, Suliman et al. (2025) located most of their literature about wellness outcomes because of co-creation in Europe, again mainly in medicine. O’Connor et al. (2021) focused specifically on nursing and midwifery, with most studies based in the UK. We found that most papers were from North America and Oceania, but unlike others, only 2 originated in medicine and nursing was the most represented profession. These differences are likely attributed to our narrower focus on co-creation of assessment during a course as well as multiple included reports from the same author in these regions. Geographical patterns across reviews suggest that research from the Global South is notably underrepresented. Overall patterns may also reflect both global publication trends and our use of English-language search terms and databases. Only two reports in our review were explicitly co-authored with students. Barradell and Bell (2021) also found low rates of co-authorship, acknowledging that it may be owing to challenges inherent in involving students as co-authors. However, Abbonizio et al. (2024) identified that 13 of the 21 included papers in their review were co-authored with students, suggesting that co-authorship remains possible. Mercer-Mapstone (2020) advocates for a more consistent and concerted effort to include learners as co-authors in papers about co-creation, which remains an area where future reviews or studies could improve. Our review includes student co-authors, which serves as a study strength. In Abbonizio et al.’s (2024) review students were positioned as agents for change where students were empowered to change education or partners where they collaborated with educators to co-create outputs. Studies in our review rarely positioned students at the forefront of driving educational change, but there was a strong emphasis on learner empowerment in some reports. While transforming education was sometimes cited as a goal in some reports, the main focus of co-creation of assessment was on a partnership with learners to improve the educational experience and prepare them for real-world practice. Our review surfaced reports of similar outcomes related to learner well-being as identified by Suliman et al. (2025), namely positive emotions, engagement, positive relationships, meaning, and accomplishment. Our review surfaced more reports of accomplishment-related outcomes (i.e., increased autonomy, evaluative judgment, and confidence in professional abilities) and fewer reports of specific emotional responses such as gratitude, pride, or reduced stress. These differences may reflect our narrower focus on assessment co-creation, variation in how data were analyzed, or our inclusion of non-research reports. Still, our findings reinforce that assessment co-creation can meaningfully support learner well-being. Our review also echoes findings that the ways learner-educator co-creation is occurring are diverse and reports are mostly positive (Barradell & Bell, 2021; Matthews et al., 2019; O’Connor et al., 2021). The highly contextual and diverse ways in which co-creation is occurring are not surprising given the wider educational discourse around customizable education. Our review adds depth to the findings of previous reviews by offering clear examples of starting points into co-creation of assessment, namely learning contracts in the planning phase and writing assignments or simulation in one or more phases of assessment. In addition, our review confirms Barradell and Bell’s (2021) finding that challenges reported during co-creation related to logistics, time commitment, limited support from colleagues or institutions, shifting roles, and difficulty building trust. We did not find reports expressing concern around future translation or single disciplinary perspectives during co-creation of assessment as they did in their review. However, their finding that the literature contains infrequent mention of challenges with co-creation of assessment is surprising since co-creation has previously been identified as challenging (Bovill et al., 2016), and health professional programs are highly regulated and content-heavy. Authors publishing about co-creation may be advocates for it and therefore less likely to focus on describing these challenges. Despite limited depth in reports of disadvantages and barriers, 20 reports in our review identified challenges such as initial confusion, terminology, feedback delays, resistance, concern over marginalization of student voices, and maintaining objectivity in grading diverse work, which adds to existing literature. Some of these challenges may be specific to co-creation of assessment and not experienced with co-creation of curriculum or learning. Our findings also support the conclusion from Abbonizio et al. (2024) and O’Connor et al. (2021) that overall, descriptions of learner-educator partnerships are lacking in depth across the literature. We agree with them that more research is needed to refine pedagogy and evaluate the outcomes of co-creation. Limitations Our scoping review has limitations. First, this review was limited to health professional education, meaning it did not capture the ways in which co-creation of assessment is implemented in other higher education settings. While we acknowledge that principles of co-creation may be transferable from other domains, our focus on health professions education was intentional to ensure contextual relevance. This field is influenced by distinct regulatory and competency-based constraints that may impact how co-creation of assessment is implemented. As a result, this review does not capture the full range of theoretical or conceptual frameworks on co-creation emerging from broader higher education literature. Second, despite our efforts to be inclusive, this review may not have captured all the ways in which co-creation of assessment is reported. One contributing factor is the wide variety of ways it may have been described. In addition, to make the review feasible, we only examined articles where there was an indication that co-creation was occurring in the abstract. It remains possible that co-creation of assessment was integrated into papers but was not evident in abstracts, as it was not the focus of the report. To maintain feasibility, we limited our grey literature search to known or referenced websites, meaning that all possible websites were not captured in our search. We also did not track website screening separate from other sources in Covidence, limiting our ability to report on specific numbers of websites screened. Likewise, we also did not conduct a separate search for dissertations, conference proceedings, grey literature, or government reports. Third, it was often difficult to place reports on Bovill and Bulley’s (2011) ladder of participation due to insufficient detail. Therefore, we made our best efforts to include reports that most likely met our definition of co-creation but may have missed some. Lastly, this scoping review was labour-intensive and may have been impacted by investigator fatigue when reading difficult-to-decipher reports. Authors’ Conclusions Implications for Educational Practice Overall, co-creation of assessment was portrayed positively across included literature. Still, these findings cannot be generalized, meaning that educators should not change their practice without first reflecting on the contextual appropriateness of co-creation. While our findings show that co-creation has been used in many contexts, we cannot make any claims about where it should be used. Educators who are interested in trying co-creation of assessment in their courses are encouraged to use the findings of this review to generate ideas appropriate for their contexts. We identified diverse approaches to co-created assessment in this review; however, learning contracts, written assignments, and simulation as well as planning assignments and grading together were frequently reported and represented across all disciplinary categories. These strategies may therefore serve as a starting point for educators to consider feasible and context-appropriate ways to engage learners in co-creation of assessment in health professional education. Implications for Research Co-creation of assessment remains an understudied intervention in health professional education. Most identified studies explored student perspectives; research exploring educator perspectives of co-creation is lacking across the reports included in this review, thereby leaving a critical gap in understanding how educators approach decision-making and manage institutional or accreditation-related constraints. However, the overall limited available research, diversity of interventions, and highly contextual nature of co-creation also points to the need to conduct further research on student experiences with context-specific forms of assessment co-creation. There remains a need for both qualitative and quantitative studies in this area to identify how co-creation of assessment impacts learning, engagement, and evaluative judgement. Qualitative studies should include a more in-depth examination of educator and diverse student experiences with co-creation. Quantitative studies are also needed to measure the impact of co-creation on quantifiable learning outcomes. Researchers should also isolate the impact of different assessment co-creation decisions (e.g., deciding on grading criteria vs. grades) and specific strategies for co-creation (e.g., individual meetings vs. back and forth written feedback) to enable educators to make informed decisions about what and how they are co-creating. Several reports in this review included co-creation of assessment as a component of a larger pedagogy or process. It would therefore be interesting to examine whether co-creation is more effective when used as part of an overall strategy or if it can be effective when used in isolation. Likewise, examining how the type or depth of assessment co-creation influences the benefits and barriers experienced could yield meaningful insights. Given the paucity of literature in this area, a systematic review of evidence across higher education contexts may be needed, but to keep it manageable, we recommend examining qualitative and quantitative evidence in separate reviews. Reviews that incorporate specific searches to locate non-English literature may also help to uncover reports not captured in our review. Final Message Co-creation of assessment, though complex and context-specific, offers an opportunity for inclusive, meaningful, and authentic assessment practices in health professional education. While implementation challenges remain, this review identifies promising examples of educational practices and directions for future research. Moving forward, educators are encouraged to implement, test, and report co-created assessment innovations. Scholars must explore how to implement co-creation of assessment in a way that upholds the rigorous academic standards in health professional contexts while enabling evidence-informed innovative assessment design that prepares learners for health professional practice. Supplemental Material Supplemental Material - Learner-Educator Co-creation of Student Assessment in Health Professional Education Courses: A Scoping Review Supplemental Material for Learner-Educator Co-creation of Student Assessment in Health Professional Education Courses: A Scoping Review by Laura A. Killam, Christina Godfrey, Mercedes Lock, Renée Gordon, Amanda Ross‐White, Marian Luctkar‐Flude in Campbell Systematic Reviews