Bibliometric and visualization analysis of non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia [2014–2025] Authors: Yu Che, Lei Chen, Shenghua Yi, Mochi Guo, Jiaqi Liu, Yulong Wang Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundNon-intubated thoracic anaesthesia (NITA) is an emerging anaesthetic approach that integrates spontaneous breathing general anaesthesia with regional blockade. By avoiding tracheal intubation, NITA effectively reduces anaesthesia-related complications and significantly curtails anaesthetic consumption. Evidence indicates that this technique lowers the incidence of postoperative pulmonary complications, facilitates immediate airway clearance, permits early ambulation, improves early postoperative comfort, and shortens hospital stay, thereby accelerating patient recovery. The growing adoption of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) has heightened interest in NITA across various thoracic procedures. This bibliometric study aims to systematically map the global research landscape, identify hotspots, and delineate evolutionary trends of NITA literature from 2014 to 2025.MethodsThis study applies bibliometric and visualisation methods to systematically map the NITA literature indexed in the Web of Science Core Collection (WOSCC) from January 2014 to June 2025. Relevant articles were retrieved and screened to identify research hotspots, trends, and principal findings. Data processing, network mapping, and graphical presentation were carried out with VOSviewer, CiteSpace, Scimago Graphica, and Excel 365.ResultsThe bibliometric dataset comprised 141 articles published between January 2014 and June 2025. Annual output rose steadily from 2014, peaked in 2022, and then declined in 2023–2024. Collaborative-network indicators placed China first in both publication count and total citations. The Journal of Thoracic Disease contributed the largest number of papers. Jianxing He emerged as the most prolific and highly cited author; the single most referenced article is “Nonintubated video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery under epidural anaesthesia compared with conventional anesthetic option: a randomized control study” by Liu et al. [2015]. Keyword co-occurrence analysis shows that the intersection of NITA with thoracic surgical procedures (VATS, lobectomy, anatomical resection) and anaesthetic techniques (regional blockade, preservation of spontaneous ventilation) constitutes the dominant research theme; studies integrating NITA with VATS currently represent the most active subfield.ConclusionsThis study presents the first comprehensive bibliometric visualisation of NITA research, providing an intuitive overview of its hotspots, trends, and prospects. The findings will offer scholars a valuable reference for identifying priority topics and potential collaborators, and will clearly point the way for future NITA research.Keywords: Non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia (NITA), video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS), VOSviewer, CiteSpace, visual analysis Highlight box Key findings • Bibliometric analysis identified 141 non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia (NITA) publications [2014–2025], with China dominating (59.6% of output) and Guangzhou Medical University leading institutional contributions. • Research hotspots evolved from early feasibility/safety validation to enhanced recovery after surgery integration, outcome assessment, and meta-analyses, with video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) lobectomy remaining the primary surgical context. • Author collaboration networks reveal concentrated productivity within Chinese institutions, while Italy functions as the principal international bridge linking European, North American, and Asian research. What is known and what is new? • NITA reduces intubation-related complications and facilitates early recovery when integrated with VATS; however, standardized protocols and high-risk population data remain limited. • This study presents the first comprehensive bibliometric visualization of NITA research, objectively mapping the field’s transition from technical feasibility studies to evidence-based outcome optimization. What is the implication, and what should change now? • International multicentre collaborations (particularly with European and North American centres) must be prioritized to enhance generalizability beyond current single-centre, Chinese-dominated evidence. • Future research should focus on rigorous multicentre randomized controlled trials in high-risk populations (elderly >75 years, American Society of Anaesthesiologists III–IV), standardized conversion criteria with validated physiological thresholds, and accredited training curricula to ensure safe dissemination. Introduction Non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia (NITA) avoids tracheal intubation while preserving spontaneous ventilation. It combines regional anaesthesia (epidural, paravertebral or intercostal block) with sedation, maintaining oxygenation via supraglottic airway or high-flow nasal oxygen (1). With the evolution of minimally invasive thoracic surgical techniques, NITA has evolved into an established and integral component of modern thoracic anaesthetic practice. Although conventional endobronchial general anaesthesia with one-lung ventilation provides reliable lung isolation and controlled mechanical ventilation, it is associated with airway trauma, ventilator-induced lung injury, and other anaesthesia-related morbidities (2). NITA can mitigate the aforementioned risks to some extent (3). In a comparative cohort study, Wu et al. (4) reported a lower incidence of pulmonary complications (5.6% vs. 12.5%) and post-operative nausea and vomiting (2.8% vs. 4.2%) in patients undergoing NITA compared to those receiving tracheal intubation. Enhanced recovery metrics are also superior: mean length of stay was 3.66±1.56 days after NITA compared with 5.52±2.12 days following intubated general anaesthesia (P<0.001), and overall morbidity was likewise reduced (5). These advantages extend to high-risk populations: a recent non-inferiority study demonstrated that spontaneous ventilation video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) in octogenarian non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients (>80 years) provides comparable long-term oncological outcomes (overall and disease-free survival) to mechanical ventilation, with significantly shorter post-anaesthesia care unit (PACU) stays and resuscitation times (6,7). Recently, NITA has been integrated into VATS (8). Several series have demonstrated significantly lower complication rates and faster recovery in patients undergoing VATS lobectomy or segmentectomy for lung cancer under NITA compared to standard general anaesthesia (9-11). Despite its proven efficacy, NITA still presents significant challenges. Preserving spontaneous ventilation increases susceptibility to surgically induced coughing, mediastinal shift, and vagal reflexes (12). Intraoperative hypercapnia and hypoxaemia remain critical concerns: Chiang and Lin reported a 2–11% conversion rate to tracheal intubation, with 14–33% of conversions attributed to hypercapnia or hypoxaemia (13). Consequently, high-flow nasal oxygen and supraglottic airway devices are routinely utilized to enhance patient safety (14,15). Furthermore, precise indications and contraindications for NITA require further definition, particularly for complex procedures or patients with severe comorbidities. Achieving an optimal balance between adequate anaesthetic depth and sustained spontaneous ventilation remains a key area of ongoing research (13). By integrating mathematical and statistical models, bibliometrics quantitatively and qualitatively dissects the spatiotemporal distribution of publications, author-institution collaboration networks, and co-words or co-citation relationships, thereby providing an objective lens for delineating disciplinary evolution and forecasting emerging trends (16). The recent, successful deployment of tools such as CiteSpace and VOSviewer in thoracic surgery (17), oncology (18), and rheumatology (19) has further corroborated the robustness and visual clarity of this approach when handling large-scale, heterogeneous bibliographic data. Despite the rapid expansion of NITA-related research over the past decade, a dedicated bibliometric analysis of this field remains absent. To address this gap, the present study will apply a bibliometric framework to the Web of Science Core Collection (WOSCC) [2014–2025] to map the developmental trajectory, research hotspots, and evolutionary trends of NITA literature, thereby offering a structured reference for future research and multidisciplinary collaborations. We present this article in accordance with the BIBLIO reporting checklist (available at https://jtd.amegroups.com/article/view/10.21037/jtd-2026-1-0353/rc). Methods Data collection The analysis used Clarivate Analytics’ WOSCC as the sole data source, and its rigorous journal-selection criteria and comprehensive citation index are widely recognised as the bibliometric gold standard (20). The search strategy employed the following query: TS = ((“tubeless” OR “non-intubat*” OR “spontaneous ventilation”) AND (“thorac*” OR “lung*”) AND (“anesthes*”)). Notably, while surgical procedures (e.g., VATS, lobectomy) appear in the retrieved literature as the clinical context for NITA, the mandatory inclusion of anaesthesia-specific search terms ensures that this analysis specifically targets perioperative anaesthetic management rather than surgical techniques. Records were limited to original Articles and Reviews written in English and published between 1 January 2014 and 30 June 2025. Review articles were deliberately retained as primary objects of bibliometric analysis, given their established role as knowledge-synthesis nodes and citation-network hubs within emerging interdisciplinary fields such as NITA. This timeframe reflects methodological necessity rather than arbitrary exclusion; pre-2014 foundational reports (e.g., Chen et al., 2011; Hung et al., 2013) (2,21) lacked standardized anaesthesia-specific terminology in titles, abstracts, or keywords, rendering them inaccessible to reproducible bibliometric retrieval algorithms despite their historical significance. After duplicate removal and data cleaning, 141 eligible publications with their complete bibliographic details and cited references were exported in both TXT and CSV formats, ensuring exhaustive and unbiased downstream analyses (Figure 1). Detailed process for literature screening. Data analysis and visualisation Microsoft Excel 2019 was used for data collation and summary of bibliographic information. VOSviewer (version 1.6.20) was used to construct and visualise author collaboration networks, country-level collaboration networks, and keyword co-occurrence networks. The software represents research entities as nodes and their relationships as edges; node size reflects the number of items; colours denote distinct clusters; and edge thickness indicates the strength of similarity or association between items (22). CiteSpace (version 6.4.R1 advanced), developed by Prof. Chaomei Chen of Drexel University, is a visualisation tool dedicated to co-citation analysis and research-front detection. In this study, CiteSpace was employed to identify research hotspots, keyword co-occurrence networks, and document co-citation patterns within NITA. Timeline and dual-map overlay visualisations were used to delineate the intellectual development and pivotal turning points of the domain. Cluster validity was assessed by means of the silhouette metric (S>0.5 indicates well-separated clusters) and modularity (Q>0.3 denotes a significant clustering structure) (23). Figure 1 presents the search strategy and screening workflow of this study. Results Annual publications and citation trends From 2014 to 2025, the WOSCC database contained 141 NITA-related publications. Their annual counts and citations are shown in Figure 2A. The field produced its first papers in 2014, followed by a step-wise increase. In 2016, 13 articles attracted 681 citations (22% of the decade’s total). After 2017, the annual output entered a plateau (10–25 papers per year), yet citation impact remained high (352 in 2018 and 213 in 2020). Both publication numbers and citations began to decline from 2023 onward. Temporal trends in NITA research [2014–2025]. (A) Annual publication output and yearly citation count for NITA-related research. (B) Temporal distribution of study designs in NITA literature. NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia; RCT, randomized controlled trial. Study design analysis reveals a parallel temporal evolution (Table 1, Figure 2B). While descriptive case series dominated early (44.4% in 2014–2016), comparative cohort studies became prevalent from 2017 onwards (54–59% across middle and late periods). Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) emerged in 2017 but remained sparse (9.2% overall), with only single-centre studies reported in 2024–2025. Table 1Distribution and temporal evolution of study designs in NITA literature [2014–2025]Study designTotalEarly period [2014–2016]Middle period [2017–2021]Latest period [2022–2025]Peak year(s) [n]Case series/reports31 (21.99)8 (44.44)13 (21.67)10 (15.87)2016, 2018, 2022 [4]Cohort studies75 (53.19)6 (33.33)32 (53.33)37 (58.73)2022, 2023 [12]RCTs13 (9.22)0 (0.00)8 (13.33)5 (7.94)2020, 2022 [3]Meta-analyses10 (7.09)2 (11.11)5 (8.33)3 (4.76)2016, 2019, 2021 [2]Reviews12 (8.51)2 (11.11)2 (3.33)8 (12.70)2022 [5]Total1411860632022 [25]Data are presented as number (%) or number. NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia; RCT, randomized controlled trial. Distribution and temporal evolution of study designs in NITA literature [2014–2025] Data are presented as number (%) or number. NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia; RCT, randomized controlled trial. To identify the countries that contribute most prominently to the NITA field, we analysed the output of 27 nations. Figure 3A shows that productive countries are concentrated in the Northern Hemisphere, with visible academic links among Asia, Europe, and North America. Figure 3B visualises these data (VOSviewer): node size reflects the number of publications (Np), edge thickness indicates bilateral collaboration frequency, and node colour denotes distinct clusters. The distribution is clearly uneven, with the majority of papers originating from a limited number of countries. China occupies the central position and maintains strong collaborative ties with Italy, the United States, Germany, Japan, and several other nations. Country/region analysis of NITA-related research. (A) Geographic distribution generated in Scimago Graphica: dot size indicates the Np, dot colour denotes cluster assignment, and line thickness represents collaboration intensity. (B) Collaboration-network map produced in VOSviewer: node colour identifies cluster membership, and node size corresponds to publication output. Country-level collaboration networks follow standard bibliometric practice where publications from Taiwanese institutions are aggregated under China, consistent with Table 2 classification. NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia; Np, number of publications. To ascertain the most productive countries, we examined the top 5 publishing nations (Table 2). China dominates the field with 84 publications, accounting for 59.57% of the total output, and also ranks first in total citations. Italy occupies second place with 24 papers and 424 citations, achieving the highest citations-per-paper ratio (17.67) among the leading countries. Table 2Top 5 countries in NITARankCountryPublicationCitationsAverage citations/publicationsCentrality1China841,35716.150.292Italy2442417.670.423South Korea1016716.70.274USA8597.380.025Germany8739.130.02Country-level classifications followed standard international bibliometric practice; publications originating from Taiwanese institutions were aggregated under “China”. NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia. Top 5 countries in NITA Country-level classifications followed standard international bibliometric practice; publications originating from Taiwanese institutions were aggregated under “China”. NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia. Distribution of authors and research institutions Price’s law, derived by Price in 1963 from Lotka’s distribution, states that within a given research domain, half of all papers are produced by a subset of highly productive authors whose size approximates the square root of the total author population m=0.749×nmax), where nmax is the output of the most prolific author and m is the minimum count defining the “elite” group (24). Applying this formula to the present dataset, we set the core-author threshold at ≥4 publications, identifying 41 investigators who together contributed 72 papers (51.06% of the total), thereby satisfying Price’s 50% criterion and indicating the emergence of a stable, high-productivity collaborative network within the NITA field. Table 3 lists the 10 most productive authors in the NITA field. Between 1 January 2014 and 30 June 2025, Jianxing He led with 28 publications accruing 702 citations (mean 25.07 citations per paper), followed by Jun Liu with 20 papers and 505 citations (mean 25.25 citations per paper). Both authors are affiliated with The First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University and have collaborated extensively; their joint output focuses on the clinical translation and precision management of respiratory diseases, particularly lung cancer, constituting a systematic research programme. Table 3Top 10 authors in NITARankAuthorAffiliationsH-indexDocumentsCitationsAvg. C/P1Jianxing HeThe First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou Institute of Respiratory Disease & China State Key Laboratory of Respiratory Disease, China442870225.072Jun LiuThe First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou Institute of Respiratory Disease, China State Key Laboratory of Respiratory Disease, National Clinical Research Centre for Respiratory Disease, China222050525.253Hengrui LiangThe First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, China421217014.174Long JiangThe First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, China231119417.645Jin-Shing ChenNational Taiwan University Hospital and National Taiwan University College of Medicine, China641126023.646Wenlong ShaoThe First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou Institute of Respiratory Disease, China State Key Laboratory of Respiratory Disease, China371042942.907Qinglong DongThe First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, State Key Laboratory of Respiratory Disease, National Centre for Clinical Trials on Respiratory Diseases, China; Department of Thoracic Surgery, Nottingham City Hospital, Nottingham, UK26927830.898Wenhua LiangThe First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, State Key Laboratory of Respiratory Disease, National Clinical Research Centre for Respiratory Disease, Guangzhou Institute of Respiratory Health, China50914816.449Ya-Jung ChengNational Taiwan University Hospital and National Taiwan University College of Medicine, National Taiwan University Cancer Centre, China20921924.3310Lixia LiangThe First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou Research Institute of Respiratory Disease, China State Key Laboratory of Respiratory Disease, National Centre for Clinical Trials on Respiratory Diseases, The First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, China36820525.63Avg. C/P, average citations/publications; NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia. Top 10 authors in NITA Avg. C/P, average citations/publications; NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia. Author co-occurrence analysis with VOSviewer included 641 authors, 41 of whom met the threshold. Each node represents an author, node size indicates publication count, and edges denote co-authorship ties. As shown in Figure 4A, distinct clusters correspond to collaborative groups: Jianxing He, Wei Wang, Jun Liu, Hui Liu, Hengrui Liang, Wenhua Liang, and Hanyu Yang form a dense network; Lixia Liang, Fei Cui, Qinglong Dong, Shuben Li, Eugenio Pompeo, Hanzhang Chen, Diego Gonzalez-Rivas, Wenlong Shao, Weiqiang Yin, and Xin Zhang constitute a second cluster; Long Jiang and Lan Lan create a smaller partnership; Manling Wang, Ya-Jung Cheng, Jin-Shing Chen, Hsao-Hsun Hsu, and Ming-Hui Hung compose a fourth collaborative unit. In Figure 4B, temporal colouring reveals that nodes for Eugenio Pompeo, Hengrui Liang, Wenhua Liang, and Hsau Haun are shifted toward the recent end of the spectrum, indicating that their active research period is recent and underscoring the topical relevance of these groups. Collaboration networks among authors and institutions in the NITA field. (A) VOSviewer co-occurrence cluster map of authors. (B) VOSviewer temporal-overlay co-occurrence cluster map of authors. (C) VOSviewer co-occurrence cluster map of institutions. (D) VOSviewer temporal-overlay co-occurrence cluster map of institutions. (A-D) VOSviewer maps: node size indicates publication count; colours denote clusters (as in Figure 3). NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia. Institutional co-occurrence was also generated with VOSviewer, applying Price’s threshold of ≥4 publications. Figure 4C reveals three clusters reflecting close inter-institutional collaboration. Cluster 1 comprises State Key Laboratory of Respiratory Disease, Gorizia University Hospital, Guangzhou Institute of Respiratory Disease, Guangzhou Medical University, National Clinical Research Centre for Respiratory Disease, and University of Rome Tor Vergata; cluster 2 includes Kunming University of Science and Technology, National Taiwan University, National Taiwan University Hospital, Taipei Veterans General Hospital, University of Szeged, and University of Turin; cluster 3 is represented solely by Southern Medical University. In the temporal-overlay map (Figure 4D), nodes for Kunming University of Science and Technology and University of Szeged are shifted toward the recent end of the colour scale, indicating that their relevant outputs are concentrated in the most recent period and thus occupy a temporally advanced position within the research timeline. Table 4 indicates that Guangzhou Medical University leads institutional output with 36 publications, followed by Guangzhou Institute of Respiratory Disease with 15 papers. Hospital Universitario A Coruña (Spain) exhibits the highest citation impact, achieving 334 citations across five articles and a corresponding per-paper citation rate of 66.80. The University of Rome Tor Vergata ranks second in this metric, with a mean citation count of 42.60 per publication. Table 4Top 10 organizations in NITARankOrganizationsDocumentsCitationsAvg. C/PCentrality1Guangzhou Medical University (China)3675120.860.342Guangzhou Institute of Respiratory Disease (China)1542228.130.173China State Key Laboratory of Respiratory Disease (China)1333125.460.174National Taiwan University (China)1225521.250.025National Taiwan University Hospital (China)11275250.026Hospital Universitario A Coruña (Spain)533466.800.027National Clinical Research Centre For Respiratory Disease (China)519639.200.018University of Szeged (Hungary)5418.200.089University of Rome Tor Vergata (Italy)521342.600.0110Southern Medical University (China)45413.500.02Avg. C/P, average citations/publications; NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia. Top 10 organizations in NITA Avg. C/P, average citations/publications; NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia. Distribution of journals A total of 141 articles published in 49 journals were retained for analysis. As shown in Table 5, the most productive outlet was the Journal of Thoracic Disease (36 articles, 25.53%), followed by Frontiers in Surgery (13 articles, 9.22%) and the European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (10 articles, 7.09%). In terms of co-cited sources, the Journal of Thoracic Disease was the most frequently cited [number of citations (Nc) =524], followed by the Annals of Thoracic Surgery (Nc =471) and the European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (Nc =418). Notably, five of the journals with the highest Np count also ranked among the top 10 co-cited journals. Table 5Top 10 journals and co-cited journals concerning NITARankJournalCo-cited journalSourceNpIF [2025]JCRCo-cited sourceNcIF [2025]JCR1 Journal of Thoracic Disease 362.1Q2 Journal of Thoracic Disease 5242.1Q22 Frontiers in Surgery 131.8Q2 Annals of Thoracic Surgery 4713.6Q13 European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery 103.0Q2 European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery 4183.0Q24 BMC Anesthesiology 92.6Q2 Annals of Translational Medicine 2563.8Q35 Journal of Clinical Medicine 62.99Q1 Anaesthesia and Analgesia 1474.6Q16 Annals of Translational Medicine 63.8Q3 Anesthesiology 1429.1Q17 Translational Lung Cancer Research 44Q2 Interactive Cardiovascular and Thoracic Surgery 1261.6Q38 Journal of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anaesthesia 31.67Q2 Annals of Surgery 12314.4Q19 Interactive Cardiovascular and Thoracic Surgery 31.6Q3 Journal of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anaesthesia 1021.67Q210 Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery 36Q1 Chest 819.5Q1IF, impact factor; JCR, journal citation reports; NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia; Nc, number of citations; Np, number of publications. Top 10 journals and co-cited journals concerning NITA IF, impact factor; JCR, journal citation reports; NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia; Nc, number of citations; Np, number of publications. Figure 5A maps the co-cited journal sets that each contribute ≥20 citing articles, displaying their inter-citation links and clustering. Four colour-coded journal groups emerged. The red cluster centres on perioperative anaesthetic care in thoracic surgery, emphasising anaesthetic management and pain control. The blue cluster focuses on operative techniques and surgical approaches. The green cluster addresses pulmonary pathophysiology and respiratory management, encompassing lung and airway diseases, ventilatory physiology, pathology, and the indications for spontaneous-breathing anaesthesia in these patients. The yellow cluster corresponds to cardio-thoracic oncology, concentrating on lung cancer biology and its perioperative implications, including cellular and molecular mechanisms, genetics, and evolving therapeutic strategies derived from clinical trials. These delineations enable researchers to pinpoint dominant research fronts and to select the most appropriate journals for disseminating future work. Analysis of NITA-related journals. (A) VOSviewer co-citation network of journals contributing ≥20 articles, node colour denotes cluster membership, and node size reflects citation frequency. (B) Dual-map overlay: citing journals (left) and cited journals (right) are linked by coloured trajectories indicating citation flows. NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia. Dual-map overlay analysis clearly delineates cross-journal thematic distribution, citation-path evolution, and shifting research foci (Figure 5B) (25,26). The left-hand journal taxonomy represents citing sources, whereas the right-hand taxonomy denotes cited sources. Coloured citation trajectories that originate from the citing map and terminate in the cited map visually expose the contextual logic of inter-journal citation flows (25). Citing journals cluster predominantly within dentistry, dermatology, and surgery, defining the research front. Cited journals cluster chiefly within health, nursing, and medicine, constituting the intellectual base of the field. Keyword analysis Keywords condense the core content of articles and thus serve as indicators of research hotspots and emerging frontiers in NITA. The 20 most frequently occurring keywords are confined predominantly to thoracic surgery and anaesthesia. Table 6 lists these terms in descending order of frequency. “VATS” heads the list (72 occurrences), followed by “anaesthesia” (56 occurrences). High counts are also recorded for “lobectomy” (52 occurrences), “resection” (46 occurrences), and “thoracic surgery” (44 occurrences), signalling that these domains constitute the prevailing foci of NITA-related investigation. Table 6Top 20 keywords in terms of frequency of occurrence and the corresponding total link strengthRankKeywordsOccurrencesTotal link strength1VATS723742Anaesthesia562703Lobectomy523034Resection462625Thoracic surgery442626Feasibility352317Lung cancer311778Epidural-anaesthesia301879Spontaneous ventilation2916010Thoracoscopic surgery219511Regional anaesthesia1911312Awake1810913Management189714Safety169915Non-intubated158916Non-intubated VATS156917Meta-analysis1410118Vagal block148919Surgery135520Experience1287VATS, video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery. Top 20 keywords in terms of frequency of occurrence and the corresponding total link strength VATS, video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery. The keyword co-occurrence network generated in VOSviewer is presented in Figure 6A. Edges between nodes indicate co-occurrence relationships, and three main clusters were identified. The red cluster comprises terms related to pulmonary pathology (lung cancer, pneumothorax), thoracic procedures (lobectomy), and the corresponding anaesthetic approach (tubeless, non-intubated). The blue cluster encompasses perioperative outcomes (complications, safety, mortality) and pathobiological research (interstitial lung disease). The green cluster focuses on operative aspects of VATS (thoracoscopic surgery) and its ancillary techniques (one-lung ventilation, laryngeal mask airway, vagal block). Keyword-based analysis of NITA-related literature. (A) VOSviewer collaboration network of keywords (frequency ≥5). Node colour identifies cluster assignment; node size reflects occurrence frequency. (B) Keywords timeline visualisation. Each horizontal strip represents a cluster; lower numbers denote larger clusters (#0 = largest). Node size indicates co-citation frequency, inter-node links show co-citation ties, and node position along the axis marks the year of first co-citation. (C) Keywords burst-detection plot. (D) Keywords clusters generated by similarity: #0 mediastinal tumour, #1 ERAS, #2 awake surgery, #3 interstitial lung disease, #4 VATS, #5 pleural effusion, #6 mechanical ventilation, #7 non-intubated VATS, #8 non-intubated anaesthesia, #9 myasthenia gravis, #10 non-intubated thoracoscopic surgery. ERAS, enhanced recovery after surgery; NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia; VATS, video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery. The CiteSpace timeline view displays the most frequently emerging keywords for each cluster over time (Figure 6B). The earliest and largest cluster is #0 “non-small-cell lung cancer”. Initial keywords included “thoracic surgery” and “lobectomy”, whereas “non-intubated thoracic surgery” and “one-lung ventilation” represent more recent foci. Another early, large cluster is #1 “intercostal nerve block”, within this domain, “paravertebral block” and “mediastinal tumour” are likewise emerging frontiers. Notably, several clusters—#3 “double-lumen tube”, #5 “empyema”, #6 “opioid-related complications”, and #7 “coexisting pulmonary disease”—continue to accrue associated keywords, indicating that NITA research remains active and is continuously expanding into new areas. Based on the keywords co-citation network, we performed burst-detection analysis and identified the two most strongly bursting terms. As shown in Figure 6C, the blue horizontal axis represents the timeline, and the red segments superimposed on it indicate the burst periods, specifying start year, end year, and duration. Notably, “spontaneous pneumothorax” (burst strength 4.09) exhibited the strongest citation surge, followed by “epidural anaesthesia” (3.52). Highly cited reference analysis Table 7 lists the ten most-cited articles. The highest-cited paper is “Nonintubated video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery under epidural anaesthesia compared with conventional anesthetic option: a randomized control study” (Liu et al., 2015) (10), which employed a randomised controlled design to demonstrate that epidural anaesthesia is a feasible and effective option for non-intubated VATS. Ranked second is “Non-intubated video-assisted thoracoscopic lung resections: the future of thoracic surgery?” (Gonzalez-Rivas et al., 2016) (27). This review concluded that non-intubated VATS significantly shortens hospital stay, reduces post-operative pain and complications, and achieves surgical efficacy comparable to conventional approaches, while emphasising that wider adoption still requires refinement of anaesthetic technique and operative workflow. Table 7Top 10 highly cited referencesRankArticle titleSource titleAuthorsYearCitedDoi1Nonintubated video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery under epidural anaesthesia compared with conventional anesthetic option: a randomized control study Surgical Innovation Liu et al.20153210.1177/15533506145316622Non-intubated video-assisted thoracoscopic lung resections: the future of thoracic surgery? European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery Gonzalez-Rivas et al.20162410.1093/ejcts/ezv1363Comparison of non-intubated versus intubated video-assisted thoracoscopic lobectomy for lung cancer Journal of Thoracic Disease AlGhamdi et al.20181810.21037/jtd.2018.06.1634The impact of non-intubated versus intubated anaesthesia on early outcomes of video-assisted thoracoscopic anatomical resection in non-small-cell lung cancer: a propensity score matching analysis European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery Liu et al.20161810.1093/ejcts/ezw1605Non-intubated spontaneous ventilation in video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery: a meta-analysis European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery Wen et al.20201610.1093/ejcts/ezz2796Nonintubated thoracoscopic anatomical segmentectomy for lung tumors The Annals of Thoracic Surgery Hung et al.20131410.1016/j.athoracsur.2013.05.0657Nonintubated thoracoscopic surgery for lung tumor: seven years’ experience with 1,025 patients The Annals of Thoracic Surgery Hung et al.20191410.1016/j.athoracsur.2019.01.0138Guidelines for enhanced recovery after lung surgery: recommendations of the Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS®) Society and the European Society of Thoracic Surgeons (ESTS) European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery Batchelor et al.20191310.1093/ejcts/ezy3019Feasibility and safety of nonintubated thoracoscopic lobectomy for geriatric lung cancer patients The Annals of Thoracic Surgery Wu et al.20131310.1016/j.athoracsur.2012.10.08210Nonintubated thoracoscopic lobectomy for lung cancer Annals of Surgery Chen et al.20111310.1097/SLA.0b013e31822ed19b Top 10 highly cited references Co-citation analysis quantifies the frequency with which pairs of articles are cited together, thereby revealing latent relationships among studies (28). Networks were generated in CiteSpace; authors and years of burst articles whose co-citation frequency increased abruptly are indicated in Figure 7. Eleven clusters, colour-coded according to inter-document relatedness, were identified. The largest and most NITA-relevant cluster is #1 “awake non-intubated VAT”. On the timeline, the earliest thematic strand is #3 “non-intubated video-assisted thoracoscopic lung resection”, which subsequently evolved into #6 “tubeless VAT” and #11 “colorectal lung metastasectomy”. Around 2021, the volume of co-cited documents expanded, giving rise to #1 “awake non-intubated VAT” and #6 “invasive technique”. During the current year, these strands have merged into the emergent cluster #7 “advance”. Analysis of NITA-related references. (A) Reference co-citation network generated in CiteSpace; node size is proportional to co-citation frequency, and purple shading indicates high centrality, marking intellectual key nodes. (B) Clustering of references by similarity yields the following main clusters: #1 awake non-intubated VATS, #3 non-intubated video-assisted thoracoscopic lung resection, #5 tubeless VATS, #6 invasive technique, and #11 colorectal lung metastasectomy. NITA, non-intubated thoracic anaesthesia; VATS, video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery. Figure 8 displays the 25 references with the strongest citation bursts. The earliest high-impact paper was “Nonintubated thoracoscopic lobectomy for lung cancer” by Chen et al. [2011] (2), which achieved a burst magnitude of 6.95 and maintained a burst period from 2014 to 2016. Subsequently, “Nonintubated thoracoscopic anatomical segmentectomy for lung tumors” by Hung et al. [2013] (21), with a burst magnitude of 5.21, remained highly cited between 2014 and 2018, acting as a pivotal bridge that linked successive research phases and provided a foundation for later studies. Overall, citation bursts in the NITA field began in 2014 and have remained prominent; thereafter, the majority of highly cited burst articles concentrate on thoracic surgery and cardiovascular medicine subspecialties. The 25 references with the strongest citation bursts. Discussion CiteSpace 6.4.R1 Advanced, VOSviewer version 1.6.20, Scimago Graphica 1.0.43, and Python 3.13.2 were used to analyse the 141 NITA-related articles retrieved from WOSCC [2014–2025], enabling assessment of the field’s temporal and spatial distribution, author contributions, core papers, research hotspots, and emerging frontiers. General distribution Citation data for NITA-related publications from 2014 to 2025 (Figure 2A) reveal distinct chronological phases. In 2014, four papers received 166 citations, indicating an incipient stage. The citation count dropped sharply to 15 in 2015, reflecting the publication of only one paper that had not yet accumulated references. Both output and citations peaked in 2016: 13 articles attracted 681 citations, accounting for 22% of the decade’s total. This surge is attributable to highly cited papers published that year by Gonzalez-Rivas et al. (27) (160 citations) and Liu et al. (29) (107 citations). The former offered the first systematic appraisal of non-intubated anaesthesia during VATS and proposed that the technique could define the future of thoracic surgery, whereas the latter compared early outcomes of NITA vs. conventional intubated anaesthesia for non-small-cell lung cancer resections performed via VATS, further delineating the advantages of the approach. These publications mark the field’s transition from purely theoretical groundwork to clinical application. From 2017 to 2023, annual citations remained high [159–352], indicating sustained interest in the field. The marked decline in citations in 2024–2025 (16 and 1, respectively) is attributable to the recent publication date of articles in this interval; many papers have yet to be indexed. Citation counts are expected to increase over the next three to five years. While the sharp citation decline in 2024–2025 reflects recency, the publication decline from 2023 onwards may alternatively indicate field maturation, integration into standardized perioperative protocols, or terminological stabilization. The temporal shift in study designs (Table 1, Figure 2B) provides context for these publication trends. The field matured from feasibility demonstrations (case series) to comparative effectiveness research (cohort studies), yet the disappearance of RCTs after 2022 suggests a stabilization phase where large randomized trials are not keeping pace with clinical adoption. Country-level analysis (Figure 3, Table 2) shows that China leads with 84 publications, representing 59.57% of the total and far exceeding Italy (24 articles, 17.02%) and South Korea (10 articles, 7.09%), confirming China as the dominant contributor. However, Italy’s citations-per-paper (17.67) slightly surpasses that of China (16.15), indicating a higher average impact. Centrality analysis further reveals that Italy’s betweenness centrality (0.42) is markedly higher than China’s (0.29), positioning Italy as the principal “bridge” that links European, North American, and Asian research networks. Although the United States and Germany publish fewer papers, their work targets niche technical aspects: US studies emphasise integration of NITA with enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) protocols, whereas German research focuses on respiratory management in elderly patients. The collaboration map (Figure 3) includes more than 20 countries, yet inter-country ties remain loose; only China-Italy and China-South Korea display pronounced co-authorship, while most nations conduct isolated investigations, underscoring a paucity of genuine multicentre international research within the NITA field. Notably, while surgical multicentre studies of non-intubated techniques have been reported [e.g., Pompeo et al., 2019, ESTS Working Group (30); Elkhouly et al., 2022 (31)], these were not captured by our anaesthesia-focused search strategy due to disciplinary indexing differences. Institutional collaboration analysis (Figure 4, Table 4) shows that Guangzhou Medical University and its affiliated units (Guangzhou Institute of Respiratory Disease, State Key Laboratory of Respiratory Disease, etc.) dominate the field, having published 64 papers (45.4% of the total) and garnered 1,504 citations. Their output focuses on comparative assessments of respiratory function in NITA patients, optimisation of anaesthetic protocols, and technical innovations, thereby providing a robust theoretical and clinical foundation for the specialty. Conversely, Hospital Universitario A Coruña (Spain) contributes only five papers but achieves the highest citations-per-paper ratio (66.80), indicating exceptional research quality. Content analysis reveals that this centre concentrates on the application of NITA in complex thoracic procedures such as pleural empyema, pleural effusion, and pulmonary tumours. The concentration of publications at Guangzhou Medical University (25.5%) and Chinese institutions (59.6%) reflects technical leadership but introduces generalisability concerns. Patient selection criteria and perioperative protocols in these single-centre studies may differ from Western practice patterns, and the limited international multicentre collaboration (Figures 3A,4C) concentrates intellectual risk. Validation across diverse healthcare systems remains needed. The author-collaboration network (Figure 4, Table 3) further corroborates Chinese dominance: eight of the ten most prolific authors are from China and affiliated with Guangzhou Medical University and its subsidiaries. Among them, Jianxing He (H-index =44; 702 citations) is the most influential investigator, his group concentrating on the utility of NITA in lobectomy and lung cancer therapy. Table 5 shows that core outlets for NITA research are concentrated in thoracic surgery and anaesthesiology literature. Journal of Thoracic Disease leads with 36 publications and, with 524 co-citations, being the most frequently cited source, indicating its role as a key publication venue for NITA research. Thoracic-surgery journals such as Frontiers in Surgery (13 articles) and European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery (10 articles), together with anaesthesia titles BMC Anesthesiology (9 articles) and Anesthesiology (142 co-citations), form the main publication arena. Impact analysis reveals that 20 % of the top 10 journals occupy Q1 [e.g., Journal of Clinical Medicine impact factor (IF) =2.99; Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery IF =6.0] and 50% Q2, with a mean IF of 2.96, indicating that NITA research is carried primarily in medium to high-impact outlets, ensuring recognised quality. Co-citation counts are highest for leading periodicals Anesthesiology (IF =9.1, Q1) and Chest (IF =9.5, Q1), confirming close integration with frontier theory in anaesthesiology and thoracic medicine. Among the ten most-co-cited journals, seven are surgery-focused (Journal of Thoracic Disease, Annals of Thoracic Surgery, European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery, etc.) and one is medicine-focused (Annals of Translational Medicine), aligning with the dual-map overlay shown in Figure 5B. Hotspots and frontiers Keyword co-occurrence analysis (Figure 6, Table 6) revealed that “VATS” (72 occurrences), “anaesthesia” (56 occurrences), “lobectomy” (52 occurrences), and “resection” (46 occurrences) are the most frequent terms, confirming that NITA is principally employed during thoracoscopic lobectomy and oncological resection. High counts for “feasibility”, “safety”, “regional anaesthesia”, “spontaneous ventilation”, and “awake” further indicate sustained attention to the technical applicability and safety profile of NITA, as well as to its integration with regional block and the preservation of spontaneous ventilation. Notably, while NITA encompasses heterogeneous technical strategies—from purely awake epidural techniques to sedation with supraglottic airways and high-flow nasal oxygen—these variants naturally segregated within the bibliometric networks (e.g., “laryngeal mask airway” in the green cluster versus “awake” in early temporal clusters), validating our approach of capturing unified thematic evolution rather than imposing prespecified subtyping. According to established criteria for CiteSpace clustering, the modularity index (Q) and mean silhouette score (S) are used to evaluate the validity of the resulting maps: Q>0.3 indicates a statistically significant clustering structure, while S>0.5 suggests that the clusters are rational, and S>0.7 implies they are both efficient and highly convincing. The keyword-cluster map shown in Figure 6D meets these benchmarks (Q=0.52, S=0.79), demonstrating a robust and meaningful structure. The dominant clusters—#1 awake non-intubated VAT, #3 non-intubated video-assisted thoracoscopic lung resection, #5 tubeless VAT, and #6 invasive technique—confirm that NITA is principally applied within the VATS paradigm and reflect an academic emphasis on reducing surgical and anaesthetic invasiveness. The prominent positioning of “epidural anaesthesia” and “vagal block” underscores the pivotal role of regional anaesthesia in NITA, particularly the use of epidural blockade and vagal nerve block to suppress cough reflexes and maintain intraoperative oxygenation. Analysis of highly cited documents (Figure 8, Table 7) corroborates the identified research hotspots. The ten most-cited papers were published predominantly between 2015 and 2020, and most are comparative studies of NITA versus conventional intubated anaesthesia during VATS. Liu et al. [2015] (10) first used a randomised controlled design to demonstrate the advantages of NITA over standard anaesthesia in VATS procedures. Gonzalez-Rivas et al. [2016] (27) systematically summarised the technical essentials of NITA and predicted that it would become the future direction of thoracic surgery. Batchelor et al. [2019] (32) included NITA in ERAS guidelines, signifying authoritative consensus endorsement. These high-impact articles constitute the intellectual foundation of the NITA field and continue to guide subsequent research toward deeper dimensions. The keyword temporal-overlay map (Figure 6B) reveals a recent surge in the frequency of “meta-analysis”, “enhanced recovery after surgery”, and “outcome”, indicating that the field has moved beyond initial technical validation toward evidence-based synthesis and perioperative outcome evaluation. This shift reflects the maturation of NITA research, with the central question now evolving from “is it feasible?” to “how can it be delivered more safely and efficiently?”. Drivers of NITA success The rapid expansion of NITA and its rising academic visibility result from mechanisms spanning physiological, pharmacological, and interdisciplinary domains. While the bibliometric patterns identify where and when research concentrated, the following explanations of why these patterns emerged represent clinical expert interpretation intended to contextualize the quantitative findings. Physiological basis NITA preserves spontaneous ventilation, unlike conventional intubated anaesthesia. Maintaining negative intrathoracic pressure throughout surgery keeps mechanics closer to the physiological state and avoids barotrauma, volutrauma, and atelectasis associated with positive-pressure ventilation (33). The high co-occurrence of “spontaneous ventilation” and “feasibility” mirrors academic acceptance of this lung-protective effect. Well-cited studies from China and Italy (10,34) confirm more stable intraoperative oxygenation and shorter extubation times in NITA cohorts. Second, although traditional thoracic anaesthesia employs sedative analgesic agents to attenuate perioperative stress, endotracheal intubation and surgical trauma still trigger pronounced sympathetic activation and marked haemodynamic fluctuations, posing a major threat to patients with concomitant cardiovascular disease (35). By eliminating airway instrumentation, NITA, especially when combined with regional blockade, provides effective analgesia while simultaneously blunting the surgical stress response, thereby maintaining a more stable haemodynamic profile (36). Third, NITA permits a marked reduction in sedative, analgesic, and muscle-relaxant consumption, thereby lessening hepato-renal burden and minimising central nervous system and neuromuscular depression. This facilitates rapid awakening and early mobilisation, aligning closely with ERAS principles (37). The rising frequency of keywords such as “enhanced recovery after surgery” and “awake” reflects growing recognition of this advantage within the academic community. Advances in anaesthetic techniques The feasibility of NITA is contingent upon parallel progress in regional anaesthesia. The persistent high frequency of “epidural anaesthesia”, “regional anaesthesia”, and “vagal block” underscores the pivotal role of loco-regional techniques. The advent of ultrasound-guided visualisation has enabled more accurate delivery of intercostal, paravertebral, and vagal blocks, providing precise intraoperative analgesia and reflex control (e.g., cough suppression) while reducing systemic drug exposure and enhancing safety (38). Table 3 shows that leading authors such as Jianxing He and Jun Liu are affiliated with Guangzhou Medical University, an institution whose preeminence in the field coincides with its systematic application and innovation of ultrasound-guided regional blocks. Consequently, block techniques that minimise patient impact and facilitate surgical conditions are likely to constitute a future direction for NITA. Additionally, NITA mandates meticulous titration of respiratory rate, tidal volume, end-tidal CO2, and depth of sedation rather than deep general anaesthesia (1). The availability of ultra-short-acting, controllable agents such as propofol and remifentanil has therefore been instrumental in accelerating clinical adoption. Future research is likely to focus on novel hypnotics with minimal respiratory depression and specific reversal agents, exemplified by remimazolam, thereby further enhancing the safety and controllability of NITA. Interdisciplinary collaboration The emergence of NITA has depended on concurrent advances by anaesthetists and thoracic surgeons. As shown in Figure 2A, annual output increased sharply after 2015, while keywords such as “VATS”, “lobectomy”, and “resection” displayed strong co-occurrence. During the same period, single-port VATS and sub-lobar resection gained popularity, illustrating parallel technical progress: VATS reduced surgical trauma, whereas NITA lessened the systemic impact of anaesthesia, together driving the operative approach toward greater minimal invasiveness. By minimising systemic drug exposure, reducing pulmonary complications, and facilitating early recovery, NITA aligns seamlessly with the ERAS philosophy in thoracic surgery. The frequent citation of the ERAS guidelines published by Batchelor et al. (32) (Table 7) signals that NITA has progressed from early technical exploration to guideline-level recommendation, heralding its transition toward a more mature phase of development. Formation of an academic community The convergence of a dedicated academic community has accelerated the dissemination of NITA. Tables 2,3 highlight a high-output group of authors affiliated with Guangzhou Medical University and its affiliated hospitals; their extensive collaborative networks (Figure 4) have generated a substantial volume of high-quality publications in recent years. This closely integrated research network not only facilitates rapid knowledge diffusion but also, through international collaborations (Figure 3), enables the transfer of expertise to multiple countries across Asian and European countries, fostering the emergence of additional technical hubs worldwide (e.g., Italy and Spain). Moreover, keyword clustering and burst-detection analyses (Figure 6) reveal that NITA research has shifted from early exploratory terms such as “feasibility” and “safety” to higher-level evidence concepts, “outcome”, “meta-analysis”, and “enhanced recovery after surgery”, indicating increasing field maturity. The majority of highly cited articles (Table 7) appeared between 2015 and 2019, coinciding with the period of technical expansion, and these papers continue to supply the theoretical framework and methodological basis for subsequent investigations. Limitations and challenges Despite the advantages outlined above, our data also highlight several limitations and challenges. First, both geographical and institutional distributions are heavily skewed: China, especially Guangzhou Medical University and its affiliated hospitals, dominates the field (Tables 2,4). While such concentration accelerates internal knowledge transfer, it risks generating a narrow research perspective and limiting the generalisability of findings. Conversely, although European and North American outputs are modest, Italian publications achieve a higher average impact, suggesting a more cautious stance toward NITA that may reflect inter-regional differences in anaesthetic practice patterns. Second, the hierarchy of evidence remains sub-optimal. Although highly cited reports include randomised controlled trials and meta-analyses (10,39), observational and single-centre descriptive studies still predominate. Notably, while surgical multicentre studies exist in the literature [e.g., Pompeo et al., 2019 (30); Elkhouly et al., 2022 (31)], these were not captured by our anaesthesia-focused search strategy due to disciplinary indexing differences, highlighting the fragmented nature of NITA reporting across specialties. Future work should prioritise rigorously designed multicentre RCTs with longer follow-up, focusing on hard long-term end-points such as tumour-specific events, overall survival, and major complications. Additionally, the restriction to WOSCC may have excluded relevant publications indexed in Scopus or PubMed. Third, technical standardisation and structured training remain inadequate. The frequent appearance of “regional anaesthesia”, “nerve block”, and “epidural anaesthesia” reflects heterogeneous anaesthetic techniques currently employed for non-intubated thoracic procedures, yet no universally accepted procedural protocol or comprehensive training curriculum exists. Moreover, recurring terms such as “management” and “complication” underscore the need for anaesthetists to undertake meticulous preoperative evaluation and intraoperative decision-making, while the potential for emergency conversion to tracheal intubation demands rapid response skills. These factors may limit the widespread dissemination of NITA. Finally, patient selection criteria require further refinement. Most studies have enrolled adults aged 18–65 years with a body mass index (BMI) ≤30 kg/m2 and American Society of Anaesthesiologists (ASA) physical status classification I–III. Although isolated reports suggest that NITA may offer unique advantages in lung or combined heart–lung transplantation, its safety and efficacy in higher risk cohorts (extreme age, obesity, significant cardiac or pulmonary dysfunction, difficult airway, extensive pleural adhesions) remain insufficiently documented and demand prospective validation. Future directions Based on the present findings, future NITA research should pursue five strategic objectives: Foster international multicentre collaboration, particularly with leading European and North American institutions, to improve global generalisability; Foster international multicentre collaboration, particularly with leading European and North American institutions, to improve global generalisability; Conduct high-level clinical trials, especially multicentre randomised controlled studies in high-risk populations (elderly >75 years, ASA III–IV, severe pulmonary dysfunction) with long-term outcome endpoints; This remains urgent: only single-centre RCTs in 2024–2025 (40), with multicentre trials in high-risk populations still lacking, despite the technique’s continued clinical use; Conduct high-level clinical trials, especially multicentre randomised controlled studies in high-risk populations (elderly >75 years, ASA III–IV, severe pulmonary dysfunction) with long-term outcome endpoints; This remains urgent: only single-centre RCTs in 2024–2025 (40), with multicentre trials in high-risk populations still lacking, despite the technique’s continued clinical use; Develop consensus protocols including standardized conversion criteria with validated physiological thresholds and accredited training curricula to standardise technique and facilitate safe dissemination; Develop consensus protocols including standardized conversion criteria with validated physiological thresholds and accredited training curricula to standardise technique and facilitate safe dissemination; Extend NITA to complex procedures and high-risk populations, refining absolute and relative indications; Extend NITA to complex procedures and high-risk populations, refining absolute and relative indications; Integrate artificial-intelligence algorithms and dynamic ultrasound-guided blocks for real-time intraoperative monitoring and intelligent titration; Integrate artificial-intelligence algorithms and dynamic ultrasound-guided blocks for real-time intraoperative monitoring and intelligent titration; Conduct cost-effectiveness analyses comparing NITA versus intubated anaesthesia in terms of hospital costs, length of stay, and patient-reported outcomes. Conduct cost-effectiveness analyses comparing NITA versus intubated anaesthesia in terms of hospital costs, length of stay, and patient-reported outcomes. Conclusions This study mapped 141 NITA publications from 2014 to 2025 using bibliometric methods. China produced the majority of research, with Guangzhou Medical University and its affiliated institutions as the most productive contributors. The field has evolved from early feasibility and safety reports to comparative cohort studies and meta-analyses, with VATS lobectomy remaining the dominant surgical context. Nevertheless, the current evidence is still limited by single-centre designs and geographical concentration. Future efforts should focus on multicentre randomised controlled trials in high-risk populations, standardised protocols, and broader international collaboration to support the safe dissemination of NITA. Supplementary The article’s supplementary files as Acknowledgments The authors thank all colleagues who contributed to data analysis and interpretation. Ethical Statement: The authors are accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved. Footnotes Reporting Checklist: The authors have completed the BIBLIO reporting checklist. Available at https://jtd.amegroups.com/article/view/10.21037/jtd-2026-1-0353/rc Funding: This work was supported by the Shaoxing Health Science and Technology Program (No. 2023SKY028). Conflicts of Interest: All authors have completed the ICMJE uniform disclosure form (available at https://jtd.amegroups.com/article/view/10.21037/jtd-2026-1-0353/coif). All authors report that this work was supported by the Shaoxing Health Science and Technology Program (No. 2023SKY028). The authors have no other conflicts of interest to declare. References Available at https://jtd.amegroups.com/article/view/10.21037/jtd-2026-1-0353/prf Supplementary Materials The article’s supplementary files as