Communities of Practice in Emergency Mental Health Care for Involuntary Patients in Common Law Countries: A Scoping Review of Evidence Gaps Authors: Alan R Clough, Veronica Graham, Janet Catterall, Richard Stone Published: 2026 ABSTRACT BackgroundEmergency departments (EDs) play a critical role in managing individuals experiencing mental health crises who are involuntarily transported under mental health legislation. Although collaborative models such as co-responder teams and diversion services have shown operational benefits, their implementation is inconsistent and rarely embedded within systems that support sustained practice development. Communities of Practice (CoPs), which emphasise ongoing social learning and shared practice, may offer a framework to address this gap.ObjectiveTo map the scope of published research on involuntary mental health presentations to EDs and to assess whether the evidence supports the existence, implementation, or potential value of CoP approaches in this context.Eligibility Criteria and Information SourcesPeer-reviewed studies published in English from 2008 onwards were included if they examined responses to involuntary mental health presentations in EDs within common law countries (Australia, Canada, Aotearoa New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States). Searches were conducted in Medline, PubMed, Embase, PsycINFO, and Google Scholar, supplemented by targeted grey literature searches and an AI-assisted search tool.MethodsFollowing Joanna Briggs Institute scoping review methodology, studies were screened and selected by two independent reviewers. Data extraction and synthesis were conducted using a structured framework, with studies analysed for evidence of CoP-consistent elements such as collaborative learning, interagency communication, and shared practice development.ResultsSixty-five studies met inclusion criteria (40 quantitative retrospective, 11 quantitative prospective, 10 qualitative, and 4 mixed methods), predominantly from the United States (n=30) and Australia (n=23). Only one study explicitly evaluated a CoP, and no sustained CoP structures were identified. While many studies described collaborative practices consistent with CoP principles—such as interagency coordination, shared training, and improved communication—these were typically operational and episodic rather than embedded in ongoing systems of shared learning and practice development.ConclusionDespite the growth of research and the demonstrated benefits of collaborative service models, there is little evidence of formalised CoP approaches in emergency mental health care for involuntary patients. This absence suggests a gap in sustained collaborative learning mechanisms that may limit system level improvement. CoPs may offer a theoretically coherent framework to address this gap. Future research should examine the feasibility, implementation, and impact of CoPs, particularly through qualitative and mixed-methods approaches. Introduction Emergency departments (EDs) are critical points of care for individuals experiencing acute mental health crises, including those involuntarily transported from the community by police or ambulance services under mental health legislation,1,2 circumstances that involve some of the most vulnerable members of the community and require cohesive, collaborative responses from multidisciplinary teams.3,4 However, systemic fragmentation, role ambiguity, and inconsistent training across professional groups reportedly undermines the quality and safety of care provided in these high-stakes presentations,3–7 prompting the development of collaborative service models such as co-responder teams and liaison psychiatry services across common law jurisdictions including Canada, Australia, Aotearoa New Zealand (AoNZ), the United States (US) and the United Kingdom (UK).3,4 While these models have demonstrated promising outcomes such as reductions in involuntary detention, improved patient flow, and enhanced interagency coordination,3 evaluations consistently highlight systemic constraints that limit their sustainability and effectiveness, including variability in implementation, lack of standardised protocols, and inadequate integration of staff and service‑user perspectives.3,6,8 Absent from our preliminary scan of the literature is a systematic examination of “communities of practice” (CoPs) in these emergency contexts involving involuntary patients. CoPs are commonly understood as collaborative learning arrangements in which members of a multidisciplinary group engage in shared reflection, knowledge exchange, and the co-development of practice in response to real-world challenges,5,9 and are increasingly regarded as a promising, practice‑led approach to workforce development and service integration, particularly in emergency department settings characterised by high staff turnover, diverse professional cultures, and rapid, high‑stakes decision‑making.10–13 Given the acknowledged limitations of existing collaborative service models in embedding sustainable practice change, and the limited evidence examining structured collaborative learning mechanisms in emergency mental health responses, a scoping review was warranted. Preliminary searches of MEDLINE, the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, and JBI Evidence Synthesis identified no current or ongoing systematic or scoping reviews addressing the application or evaluation of CoPs in emergency psychiatric care involving involuntary patients, nor any relevant registered protocols, leading to registration of the present review with the Open Science Framework.14 Accordingly, this review aimed first to map the scope of peer-reviewed and relevant grey literature describing responses arising in emergency departments where involuntary transport for mental health care is authorised, incorporating both staff and consumer perspectives. Second, it aimed to identify and examine evidence supporting the potential use of CoPs to address challenges within the emergency care service ecosystem involving police, ambulance, and mental health services. Communities of practice (CoPs) are understood as policies and practices that bring together a community of people within a defined domain who meet or communicate regularly to promote shared learning, experience, and the development of skills and knowledge around common challenges.15 In the present context, the domain is state-authorised involuntary transport from the community to emergency departments for the management and treatment of mental health and behavioural disturbance. CoPs promote social learning and mutual understanding to address shared challenges that may not be fully captured by formal policy or guidelines, through processes that Lave and Wenger16 described as legitimate peripheral participation, whereby learning occurs through social embedding within a culture of practice.17,18 Such socially embedded learning can generate emergent effects that are difficult to prescribe in advance but may include enhanced interagency communication and improvements in the quality of interpersonal interactions that support more dignified, destigmatising patient experiences. CoPs are also characterised by relationships that promote accountability, cooperation, and collaborative problem‑solving, as articulated by White et al,19 and it was these characteristics and emergent properties that we sought to identify in the published literature as indicators of the actual use of CoPs in emergency mental health care contexts. We therefore sought published reports of these characteristics and properties as indications of actual use of CoPs. This review focuses on research conducted in English-speaking common-law countries, where health law systems are grounded in broadly comparable legal and human rights principles. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities entered into force in 2008,20 providing an ethically and legally coherent timeframe for examining emergency mental health responses involving involuntary care in these jurisdictions. Review Question Population, Concept and Context Utilising the Population, Concept, Context (PCC) framework recommended by the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) to structure the formulation of research questions,21,22 we determined the following elements for our investigation: Population Persons experiencing mental health crises who require urgent care, presenting involuntarily to emergency departments or similar acute care settings.Healthcare professionals and stakeholders involved in the care and management of this population. Persons experiencing mental health crises who require urgent care, presenting involuntarily to emergency departments or similar acute care settings. Persons experiencing mental health crises who require urgent care, presenting involuntarily to emergency departments or similar acute care settings. Healthcare professionals and stakeholders involved in the care and management of this population. Healthcare professionals and stakeholders involved in the care and management of this population. Concept The needs of individuals requiring urgent, involuntary mental health care.The use and impact of a CoP approach in emergency medicine to support these needs.Evaluation of policy literature and scientific evidence regarding the need for, or implementation of, a CoP approach in emergency care for patients experiencing mental health crises requiring urgent intervention. The needs of individuals requiring urgent, involuntary mental health care. The needs of individuals requiring urgent, involuntary mental health care. The use and impact of a CoP approach in emergency medicine to support these needs. The use and impact of a CoP approach in emergency medicine to support these needs. Evaluation of policy literature and scientific evidence regarding the need for, or implementation of, a CoP approach in emergency care for patients experiencing mental health crises requiring urgent intervention. Evaluation of policy literature and scientific evidence regarding the need for, or implementation of, a CoP approach in emergency care for patients experiencing mental health crises requiring urgent intervention. Studies that involved patients where a mental health crisis was not clearly described, or which did not explicitly state or clearly imply that transportation of the patient was involuntary, were excluded. Context Emergency care settings, specifically hospital EDs.The major common law, English-speaking countries with developed economies.Evidence published after the adoption of the UN CRPD20 in 2008 in response to which most signatory countries began to consider reforms of mental health and associated laws. Emergency care settings, specifically hospital EDs. Emergency care settings, specifically hospital EDs. The major common law, English-speaking countries with developed economies. The major common law, English-speaking countries with developed economies. Evidence published after the adoption of the UN CRPD20 in 2008 in response to which most signatory countries began to consider reforms of mental health and associated laws. Evidence published after the adoption of the UN CRPD20 in 2008 in response to which most signatory countries began to consider reforms of mental health and associated laws. We sought articles to address the following review question: Does the available published scientific evidence and policy literature support a “Community of Practice” (CoP) approach in emergency care for persons who, because of a mental health crisis, require urgent involuntary care? Inclusion Criteria Included were articles: Published in peer-reviewed journals;In English;Reporting on studies in the major common law countries of the Canada, Australia, AoNZ, the US and the UK;Concerning service response(s) to persons taken to EDs against their will; andPublished from 2008 to 2025, reflecting the adoption in many common law countries of the UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities (CRPD).20 Published in peer-reviewed journals; Published in peer-reviewed journals; In English; In English; Reporting on studies in the major common law countries of the Canada, Australia, AoNZ, the US and the UK; Reporting on studies in the major common law countries of the Canada, Australia, AoNZ, the US and the UK; Concerning service response(s) to persons taken to EDs against their will; and Concerning service response(s) to persons taken to EDs against their will; and Published from 2008 to 2025, reflecting the adoption in many common law countries of the UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities (CRPD).20 Published from 2008 to 2025, reflecting the adoption in many common law countries of the UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities (CRPD).20 Exclusion criteria Theoretical publications, commentaries, editorials and conference papers which did not report original research.Reports of studies primarily concerning voluntary presentations to facilities other than EDs or those providing urgent care.Studies in populations outside the specified common law countries.Studies published prior to 2008. Theoretical publications, commentaries, editorials and conference papers which did not report original research. Theoretical publications, commentaries, editorials and conference papers which did not report original research. Reports of studies primarily concerning voluntary presentations to facilities other than EDs or those providing urgent care. Reports of studies primarily concerning voluntary presentations to facilities other than EDs or those providing urgent care. Studies in populations outside the specified common law countries. Studies in populations outside the specified common law countries. Studies published prior to 2008. Studies published prior to 2008. Types of Sources To capture the scope of formal studies on the topic of involuntary transport, both quantitative and qualitative original research and all methodological approaches and study designs were considered. The websites of national Colleges of Emergency Medicine and Emergency Nursing in each jurisdiction were examined, where these existed, to source relevant guidelines for practice in the grey literature. Methods The review was conducted following the JBI methodology for scoping reviews and in accordance with an a priori protocol registered with OSF.14,23 Search Strategy The medical databases Medline, Pubmed, Embase and PsycINFO were searched for the period from 2008 to 2025, using combinations of keywords and database-specific subject headings supported by AI-supported pilot searches to optimise the conventional search.24 Full search strategies are provided in Appendix 1. EndNote version 20 was used to record the date, search and number of records retrieved for each search in each database. Google Scholar was also searched using simple keyword searches. Ranked by relevance, the first 100 records returned were examined and those that appeared to fit the inclusion criteria were evaluated. The AI-assisted search agent tool Undermind was used to discover relevant peer reviewed papers that may have been missed in the conventional database searches.25–27 Prompts and reports can be found in Appendix 2. Grey literature was also sought using a site-delimited Google search for the exact phrase “communities of practice” across the websites of a jurisdiction’s professional and policy authorities, namely the national College of Emergency Medicine and College of Emergency Nursing, where these existed. Evidence Selection All identified citations were imported into Zotero (version 7.0.15) reference management system and duplicates removed. Titles and abstracts were screened independently by two reviewers (VG and JC) against the inclusion criteria, followed by full-text assessment of potentially eligible studies. Disagreements at each stage were resolved through discussion and, where required, consultation with a third reviewer (AC). In addition to database searches, an AI-assisted search tool (Undermind) was used to identify potentially relevant studies not captured through conventional methods. Studies identified through this process were assessed against the same inclusion criteria. The final set of included studies comprised 65 peer-reviewed articles. The study selection process is summarised in the PRISMA flow diagram generated using an established tool (Figure 1).28 Figure 1Preferred PRISMA Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews (PRISMA) flow diagram of study selection process.The diagram illustrates the PRISMA flow of study selection. On the left, identification via databases and registers includes records from Embase (659), Medline (308), PubMed (379), PsycINFO (248), Google Scholar (68) and registers (0). Before screening, 1662 records were identified, with 683 duplicates removed. Screening involved 979 records, excluding 913, with 66 sought for retrieval and assessed for eligibility, excluding 11. Ten new studies were included, totaling 65 records. On the right, identification via AI-assisted search found 17 records, all sought for retrieval, with none not retrieved. Seventeen were assessed for eligibility, excluding 7. The process results in a final set of included studies comprising 65 peer-reviewed articles.PRISMA flow diagram showing study selection process with databases and AI-assisted search. Preferred PRISMA Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews (PRISMA) flow diagram of study selection process. Data Extraction A data extraction tool adapted from the Joanna Briggs Institute template was used (Appendix 3).23 Authors VG, JC and AC first piloted the tool with a convenience sample of the seed studies retrieved in pilot searches to ensure consistency of interpretation. Data were extracted independently by two reviewers (VG and JC). Extracted data included study characteristics (eg. authorship, year, country), study design, population, intervention, and outcomes. Studies were classified by methodological type as quantitative retrospective, quantitative prospective, qualitative, or mixed methods. Data Analysis and Presentation Extracted data were collated and analysed descriptively. Studies were first grouped by methodological type—quantitative retrospective, quantitative prospective, qualitative, and mixed methods—and summarised in Tables 1–4. The distribution of studies over time and by jurisdiction was also examined and is presented in Figures 2 and 3 respectively. Table 1Quantitative Retrospective Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency DepartmentsYear PublishedTitleAuthor(s)CountrySummary Description of StudyStudy PopulationInterventionOutcomes2025Eleven-Month Arrest Outcomes Among Three Crisis Response Models in MichiganSwanson et al29United StatesComparative - post-year arrest outcomes of mobile crisis teamsGeneral populationStreet triage/co-responder/PACERMobile crisis teams may divert future crisis service pathways away from 911, decreasing law enforcement involvement and arrest risk. Patients receiving crisis response services had fewer arrests per person, but only the mobile crisis group had a statistically significant reduced incidence rate of arrest compared to the law enforcement-only group, with non-significance in post- year arrest outcomes of co-response models.2024Civil Monetary Penalties Related to Violations of the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act Involving Patients Arriving or Departing with Law EnforcementAhmed et al30United StatesDescriptive - Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act related civil monetary penalty settlements involving patients arriving to or departing from the ED with law enforcementGeneral populationProvider fines and police transportProviders need more training to avoid violations of the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labour Act (EMTALA).2024Characteristics and outcomes of emergency department presentations brought in by police with and without an emergency examination authority: A state-wide cohort studyAlcock et al31AustraliaComparative - cohort - Characteristics and length of stay with and without involuntary orderGeneral populationPolice transportOver-represented among involuntary patients: mental health problems; from major cities; allocated more urgent on Australasian Triage Scale categories; and higher proportion of these not seen within time frame and experienced longer stay.2014Impact of boarding paediatric psychiatric patients on a medical wardClaudius et al32United StatesDescriptive - Study compared the psychiatric care provided to boarders in the medical ward versus those transferred to an affiliated psychiatric hospital. Calculated cost and number of medical beds for paediatric psychiatric patients - effect on psychiatric treatment over 18 monthsPaediatric patientsPsychiatric ward or medical ward admissionReduced chance of psychiatric treatment for those patients in the medical ward. 555 (50.1%) of 1108 patients on involuntary holds admitted to the paediatric medical unit. The majority (523 [94.2%]) were admitted for boarding because no psychiatric bed was available. Thirty-two (6.1%) patients admitted for isolated psychiatric reasons had counselling documented, and 105 (20.1%) received psychiatric medications. Patients admitted to an affiliated psychiatric hospital were significantly more likely to receive counselling and medications2023The association between the Police, Ambulance, Clinician Early Response model and involuntary detentions of people living with mental illness: A retrospective observational studyHeffernan et al11AustraliaComparative -PACER, police or ambulance as the exposures and rates of involuntary detentions (outcome)General populationStreet triage/co-responder/PACERPACER tri-response model was associated with lower rates of involuntary detentions compared to police and ambulance services with diversion of approximately half of patients from hospital.2022Health Service Outcomes After Implementation of an interdisciplinary Model of Care for the Management of Repeated Intentional Foreign Body Ingestion in Patients with Emotionally Unstable Personality DisorderHoey et al33AustraliaComparative - Pre-post use of Advanced Management Plans effect on subsequent admissionPatients with emotionally unstable/borderline personality disorderAdvanced management plansFor nine patients with 273 ED presentations), post-AMP decreases in presentations (9.8 to 7.0 per person-year); involuntary status (43%to 5%); average length of stay if admitted (1.5 to 1 day); and overall use of resources.2023Emergency examination authorities in Queensland, AustraliaClough et al34AustraliaDescriptive - Patterns of involuntary transport rates after legislative changeGeneral populationPolice transport legislationInvoluntary treatment recorded in psychiatric records before and after legislation change from the Mental Health Act to the Public Health Act.2022Characteristics and outcome of patients transported by police to emergency departments under section 351 of the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic)Ward et al35AustraliaDescriptive - cohort with police-ambulance co-responder treatment patterns of police transportGeneral populationPolice transport and police-ambulance co-response84% of encounters (368/438) patients were co-transported with ambulance. Suicide risk/intent accounted for 67%; abnormal behaviour without threat to self or others 21%. In ED, parenteral sedation was administered in 11%. Physical restraint was applied in 17.6%. Psychiatric admission was required in 23.5% (involuntary 14.4%). Most (67.8%) patients were discharged home. Eighteen patients (5.6%) accounted for 22% of all events.2022Predictors of Emergency Department service outcome for people brought in by police: A retrospective cohort studyWardrop et al36AustraliaComparative - cohort study of factors that predict length of stay >4 hours for people brought in by police at multiple sitesGeneral populationPolice transportAmong a cohort of involuntary patients: 79% were under 45 years of age; 67% were male; 22% identified Indigenous status; > half presented to EDs in major cities; 88% were Australian born. Length of stay ≥4 hours included higher priority triage categories, hospital transfer/admission, evening/night shift arrival, and non-descript diagnosis.2022Involuntary Psychiatric Hospitalization: How Patient Characteristics Affect Decision-MakingBhalla et al37United StatesComparative - mixed effects modelling patient involuntarily admitted to psychiatry versus those who were discharged from the emergency departmentGeneral populationInvoluntary hold for social determinantsPsychiatrists utilise involuntary psychiatric treatment for patients facing social determinants of health like homelessness and loneliness related to aggression, intoxication, police transport.2021Racial and ethnic disparities in emergency department restraint use: A multicentre retrospective analysisCarreras et al38United StatesComparative - ethnicity effect on use of restraintEthnic group focusUse of restraintBlack/African American and Hispanic patients under an involuntary hold experience higher rates of physical restraint in the ED compared to their White/Caucasian counterparts. Factors associated: male sex, Medicaid insurance, and a diagnosis of bipolar disorder or psychotic disorder. Patients with a primary care provider within the health system’s network were at lower risk of being physically restrained.2022Recent amendments to Queensland legislation make mental health presentations to hospital emergency departments more difficult to scrutiniseClough et al39AustraliaComparative - admission under Mental Health Ac pre-post involuntary transport legislation to Public Health ActGeneral populationPolice transport legislationMoving involuntary transport to the Public Health Act appears to have had the unintended effect of restricting the publicly available information about some emergency mental health presentations to Queensland hospital EDs - perhaps ~16% of the 6887 involuntary transports reported in police records were reported in emergency psychiatric reporting.2021Emergency department visits among patients transported by law enforcement officersRosen & Travers40United StatesDescriptive -Effect of rural location on involuntary transport ratesRural settingPolice transportMedian transport rate in rural counties, 291.1, was twice that of large metro counties, 145.1. Nearly 50% increase during the study period, highest in rural counties. Many transports were for mental Illness and involuntary commitments.2022The association between involuntary alcohol treatment and subsequent emergency department visits and hospitalizations: a Bayesian analysis of treated patients and matched controlsVuong et al41AustraliaComparative - Involuntary and voluntary treatment for alcohol dependence on subsequent emergency and hospital care for cohorts at two sitesGeneral populationMandated alcohol treatmentNo statistically significant difference in outcomes between the patients admitted for mandated alcohol treatment and control groups.2021Older adults on involuntary hold status in the emergency departmentChipi et al42United StatesComparative - older and younger involuntary hold patients, demographic and clinical variablesAdults>65 yearsInvoluntary hold in EDOlder people may be more likely to be subject to involuntary holds for non-mental health related reasons.2020Are pre-existing psychiatric disorders the only reason for involuntary holds in the emergency department?Lachner et al43United StatesComparative - involuntary patients with and without a formal diagnosisGeneral populationInvoluntary hold/transportMost involuntary patients had a pre-existing psychiatric disorder including substance use disorder. Suicidal ideation associated with pain accounted for half of those without a diagnosed disorder. Better addressing pain in the medically ill population may prevent hopelessness and helplessness that can lead to suicidal ideation.2020Discontinuing involuntary mental health holds for children: Does psychiatrist specialty matter? A pilot studySantillanes et al44United StatesComparative - logistic regression length of hold of children assessed by paediatric vs general psychiatristsPaediatric patientsPaediatric psychiatric evaluationHolds > 3 times as likely to be discontinued in patients evaluated by child and adolescent psychiatrists rather than general emergency psychiatrists.2020Gun-Related and Other Violent Crime After Involuntary Commitment and Short-Term Emergency HoldsSwanson et al45United StatesComparative - Short-term hold association with future arrest for violent crimeGeneral populationShort term holdsShort-term hold with or without commitment was associated with a significantly higher risk of future arrest for violent crime, although the study population had other violence risk factors unrelated to mental illness. Risk of gun-involved crime, specifically, was significantly higher in individuals following a short-term hold only, but not in those who were involuntarily committed and became ineligible to purchase or possess guns.2018Treatment and outcomes of patients presenting to an adult emergency department involuntarily with substance misuseHughes et al46AustraliaDescriptive - Involuntary patients with substance misuse outcomes (2002 to 2010)General populationInvoluntary hold in EDIntoxicated patients experienced longer lead time to assessment with 30% involuntary patients, and the minority received intervention or referral for substance misuse treatment.2020Involuntary patient length-of-stay at a suburban emergency departmentManiaci et al47United StatesDescriptive -Length of stay dependence on substance misuseGeneral populationStreamlining for substance misuseIncreased ED length of stay associated with alcohol use, urine drug test screening, and barbiturate use. Protocol development to help streamline ED evaluation of alcohol and drug use may improve ED length of stay in this patient population.2019Patients Threatening Harm to Others Evaluated in the ED under the Florida Involuntary Hold Act (Baker Act)Maniaci et al48United StatesDescriptive - Diagnosis and suicidality among patients threatening homicideGeneral populationInvoluntary hold75% of patients expressing homicidal threats also were suicidal.2019Patients on Involuntary Hold Status in the Emergency DepartmentRoy et al49United StatesDescriptive – compared involuntary patients who attempted suicide with those who did notGeneral populationInvoluntary holdMost common reason for involuntary hold status was suicidality (73.7%).2019Emergency Medical Services Use Among Patients Receiving Involuntary Psychiatric Holds and the Safety of an Out-of-Hospital Screening Protocol to “Medically Clear” Psychiatric Emergencies in the Field, 2011 to 2016Trivedi et al50United StatesComparative - proportion of the population requiring involuntary transport and psychiatric vs medical care requiredGeneral populationDiversion/direct transfer to inpatient psych facilityOf541731emergency services encounters and257625unique patients in Alameda County, 10% of encounters and 24% of unique patients accounted for involuntary holds. 41% of encounters were transported to stand alone psychiatric emergency service and only 0.3% required re-transport within 12 hours. Involuntary hold patients were younger, more likely to be male and uninsured, and 4% had more than 20 emergency service encounters (ten times more than those never held involuntarily).2017Frequent users of Mental Health Liaison Services within Emergency DepartmentsBeck et al51United KingdomDescriptive - cohort with frequent involuntary ED admissionGeneral populationMental health liaison serviceFrequent users: comprised a small proportion of clients (4.72%) responsible for nearly a quarter of all admissions (24.2%); and were more likely to be diagnosed with substance abuse, personality disorder and psychosis; to have higher number of care coordinators; and to have been involuntarily detained under the Mental Health Act.2017Delayed Access to Involuntary Mental Health ExaminationsBrennaman et al52United StatesComparative - delayed access to involuntary treatmentGeneral populationInvoluntary MH ExaminationDelayed access to involuntary treatment - mean duration of delay was 14.9 h. Significantly associated with longer delays were being male, increased age, and intoxication.2018Violent behaviour by emergency department patients with an involuntary hold statusDawson et al53United StatesComparative - Length of stay increased with violent behaviourGeneral populationInvoluntary hold in EDViolent patients had a longer ED length of stay than nonviolent patients (median, 376 min vs 655.5 min; P = 0.01). Violent patients were more likely to be readmitted to the ED.2017The role of ethnicity in pathways to emergency psychiatric services for clients with psychosisRotenberg et al54CanadaComparative - Effects of social networks and cohesion on emergency mental health care accessEthnic group focusPolice transportEthnic minority communities in Toronto access resources differently during crisis and may have unique experiences regarding individual level social networks and community level social cohesion.2017Involuntary Psychiatric Holds in Preadolescent ChildrenSantillanes et al55United StatesDescriptive - paediatric involuntary hold characteristics and outcomesPaediatric patientsPaediatric psychiatric evaluationPreadolescent patients (under 10 years old) on involuntary psychiatric holds seen in one urban ED over two-year period were three quarters male, with child protective services involvement; one third had a prior psychiatric hospitalisation; more than half were discharged.2017EMS Utilization Among Patients on Involuntary Psychiatric Holds in Alameda County, April 2014–2016Trivedi et al56United StatesDescriptive - ambulance transport diversion to psychiatric facilityGeneral populationDiversion/direct transfer to inpatient psych facilityExamined outcomes of field triage to ED or psychiatric unit. Involuntary hold patients tended to be younger and less likely to be insured. 41% were admitted to psychiatric facility, 59% to ED.2016Patients assessed by the liaison psychiatric team in the emergency department of a regional hospital in Canada -general characteristics and gender differencesJuhas et al57CanadaComparative -Factors leading to involuntary holdGeneral populationLiaison psychiatric teamPsychiatric antecedents and predisposing factors - levels of clinical insight and global function, specific sex differences, threats of harm to others led to involuntary hold.2016Too much detention? Street Triage and detentions under Section 136 Mental Health Act in the North-East of England: a descriptive study of the effects of a Street Triage interventionKeown et al58United KingdomComparative pre-post street triage effect on use of involuntary transportGeneral populationStreet triage or co-responder model and police transportStreet triage (co-responder 7 days a week from 10am to 3am) reduced annual rate of involuntary holds by 56% (78% in one jurisdiction) in the first year. Noted the ability to respond speedily, with the combined skills and confidence of police officers working jointly with mental health professionals, with appropriate and desirable early mental health intervention2016Mental Health Emergency Department Visits: 24 Hours and Counting, Characteristics Associated With Prolonged Length of StayLippert et al59United StatesDescriptive - diagnosis and length of stayGeneral populationInvoluntary hold/transportPatients with more severe disorders had increased rates of admission and transfer and longer lengths of stay - the most seriously ill had increased odds of ED lengths of stay > 24 hours, even when ultimately discharged.2016Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? An audit of records of involuntary detentionO’Connor et al60AustraliaDescriptive -Use of involuntary treatment orders by different professionsGeneral populationPolice transportMore than 10% of involuntary detention certificates were incomplete but police-issued certificates were more detailed and less likely to be non-compliant.2016Presentations by ambulance under the NSW Mental Health Act to an emergency department with a 24-hour mental health teamSkopek & Francis61AustraliaDescriptive - Use of Mental Health Act admission and length of stay patternsGeneral populationInvoluntary ambulance transport~50% discharged home; increased length of stay associated with complexity, sedation, number of clinical problems.2015Exceeding the Legal Time Limits for Involuntary Mental Health Examinations: A Study of Emergency Department DelaysBrennaman62United StatesComparative - logistic regression of wait times for specific variablesGeneral populationMaximum hours detention8.8% of participants waited longer than the 12-h maximum allowed by Florida law for transfer to an authorised facility.2015Lengths of stay for involuntarily held psychiatric patients in the ED are affected by both patient characteristics and medication useWilson et al63United StatesComparative - cohort study of diagnosis, sedation and length of stayGeneral populationInvoluntary holdLonger lengths of stay for involuntarily held psychiatric patients were associated with suicidal ideation and weekend presentation and lengthened by factors typically under the control of ED clinicians, such as use of calming medication.2014Characteristics and outcome of patients brought to an emergency department by police under the provisions (Section 10) of the Mental Health Act in Victoria, AustraliaAl-Khafaji a et al64AustraliaDescriptive - Patient diagnosis and behaviour with police transportGeneral populationPolice transportAmong 164 patients and 195 presentations: male 95(58%); median age 35 years; multiple presentations 18 (11%); 77% outside business hours. Reasons included: threat of self-harm alone 128 (65%); threat of harm to self and others 34 (17%); abnormal behaviour without threat of harm to self or others 17 (9%); threat of harm to others only 16(8%); and other 2 (1%). Physical restraint applied 5(2.5%); sedation 76 (39%); 132 (67%) discharged home.2012Trends in the use of Emergency Examination Orders in Queensland since the implementation of the Mental Health Intervention ProjectMeehan & Stedman65AustraliaDescriptive - Use of involuntary transport legislation over timeGeneral populationInvoluntary hold/transport and police transportIncreased use of involuntary transport by both police and ambulance 2002–10. Police continue to generate two-thirds of all EEOs completed.2011Involuntary psychiatric attendances at an Australasian emergency department: A comparison of police and health-care worker initiated presentationsLlewellin et al66AustraliaComparative - patients transported by police and ambulanceGeneral populationPolice transportNon-medical patients were more likely to be suicidal or make specific threats of violence, while patients on medical orders were more likely to exhibit psychotic or manic symptoms without overt manifestation of violence. Non-medically detained patients spent longer in ED (248 min vs 208 min) and were more likely to be discharged. The impact of these differences on ED workload was small. Streaming towards rapid discharge may be cost-effective.2011Characteristics of patients referred by police to a psychiatric hospitalMaharaj et al67AustraliaDescriptive - Violent or threatening patient behaviour with police transportGeneral populationPolice transport and seclusionPolice referrals compared to others exhibited violent and/or threatening behaviour - a likely explanation for the high rates of seclusion for patients referred by police in this study (30% vs. 12%). Table 2Quantitative Prospective Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency DepartmentsYear PublishedTitleAuthor(s)CountrySummary Description of StudyStudy PopulationInterventionAims - Outcomes - Notes2024Testing the Impact of a Law Enforcement–Operated Co-responder Program for Youths: A Quasi-Experimental ApproachChilds et al68United StatesComparative - Co-responder model effect on police-initiated transport and de-escalation and representation rates 12 monthsYouthStreet triage or co-responder model and police transportSignificantly lower likelihood of police officer–initiated involuntary commitment examinations; and involuntary commitment examination within 1 year. Eighty percent of co-response incidents (police officer and mental health professional) were deescalated, allowing the youth to remain in the community with a safety plan, whereas 17% of incidents with a police-only response ended with crisis de-escalation.2023Police, ambulance and psychiatric co-response versus usual care for mental health and suicide emergency callouts: A quasi-experimental studyEvery-Palmer et al69New ZealandComparative - cohort assessed for outcomes with or without co-responderGeneral populationStreet triage or co-responder model and police transportImmediate and 1-month outcomes of mental health emergency calls made to police and ambulance were compared according to whether they occurred on days with co-response availability. When co-responder was available ED admissions reduced by 13%. Use of force unchanged, few police detentions.2021Costs and Savings Associated with the Police Use of the interRAI Brief Mental Health ScreenerHoffman et al70CanadaComparative - Impact of police use of screening tool on involuntary referralGeneral populationPolice Use of the interRAI Brief Mental Health Screener & police transport6,727 assessments were completed with involuntary referrals decreasing by 30%, and voluntary referrals by 34%. Costs savings implied.2021Examining Proactive and Responsive Outcomes of a Dedicated-Responder TeamMorabito & Savage71United StatesComparative - logistic regression of co-responder model effect on involuntary treatmentGeneral populationStreet triage - co-responder - PACEROne-month dedicated Co-Responder car pilot programme collected data about all related encounters. Co-Response team assisted more people and enhanced service connection with potential flow on reduction of crisis.2020An Observational Study of Telemental Care Delivery and the Context for Involuntary Commitment for Mental Health Patients in a Group of Rural Emergency DepartmentsFairchild et al72USADescriptive - Rural telehealth, diagnosis, involuntary commitment, ED throughput and reimbursementRural populationTelehealthTelehealth reduces admission to psychiatric wards generally. Reduced involuntary admission can reduce costs. Youth under police transport were more likely to be female compared with the adult involuntary patients. Suicidal ideation is the main risk for involuntary transport, underscoring the need for immediate and intensive psychiatric care through telemental health in rural settings when someone is a clear danger to themselves or others.2019Improving Emergency Department Flow for Patients Requiring Involuntary Psychiatric HospitalizationBhalla & Danovitch73United StatesComparative - pre-post program’s impact on emergency department flow. Do not provide pre data or baseline.General populationCoP with training in involuntary holdsImpact of a community of practice to change training and policy. Preliminary report for first two phases staggered implementation at multiple sites; 133 providers trained and certified by the county to write a hold. 402 patients committed on pilot holds. At Phase 1 sites 225/333 (68%) patients placed on a hold transferred to psychiatric hospitals within 24 hours; no complaints related to the pilot or reports of inappropriate holds. Perceived success - county extended the initiative beyond 2 years.2019Do police–mental health co-responder programmes reduce emergency department presentations or simply delay the inevitable?Meehan et al74AustraliaDescriptive - Individuals seen by the co-responder team were followed for two weeks to monitor subsequent ED presentations and inpatient admissions.General populationStreet triage - co-responder - PACER82/122 people (67.2%) remained at their residence -followed-up for 2 weeks. During this time 10 (12.2%) presented to ED and 3 of these (3.7%) were subsequently admitted to hospital. 35/122 (28.7%) were transported to the emergency department (ED) and 5/122 (4.1%) were taken into custody by police.2014Effects of a Dedicated Regional Psychiatric Emergency Service on Boarding of Psychiatric Patients in Area Emergency DepartmentsZeller et al75United StatesDescriptive - cohort of 144 patientsGeneral populationAlameda Model of transferring patients from general hospital EDs to a regional psychiatric emergency servicePatient experience considered. Expedited transfers from local EDs, with an average transfer time of 1 hour 48 minutes, 80% reduction compared to state average. High discharge rate for transferred patients, lower admission to inpatient.2013Involuntary psychiatric admissions under the Mental Health Act 2007 (NSW): A comparative study of patients who were detained by ambulance officers and medical officers and accredited persons within a NSW Hospital EmergencyCutler et al76AustraliaComparative - Ambulance versus clinician effect on inpatient admissionGeneral populationAmbulance initiated transportAmbulance officer certification poorly predicts involuntary psychiatric admission.2011Aggressive behaviours in the psychiatric emergency serviceChaput et al77CanadaComparative -logistic regression of aggression dependence on substance use disorderGeneral populationAggressive patientsFactors associated with aggression - substance use important factor but rated differently by doctors and nurses. Few referrals specifically for SU. Rather, referring emergency department physicians appeared to focus on factors such as poor impulse control and suicidal ideation, which are observed in almost 50% of patients with alcohol dependence.2011Physical Restraints in the Emergency Department and Attendance at Subsequent Outpatient Psychiatric TreatmentCurrier et al78United StatesComparative -two-arm study of effect of restraint use on follow up treatment complianceGeneral population-patient experiencePhysical restraintPatient experience considered. 84% of patients in the unrestrained group attended their first outpatient psychiatric appointment, only 65% of restrained patients attended their first outpatient psychiatric appointment. Table 3Qualitative Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency DepartmentsYear PublishedTitleAuthor(s)CountrySummary Description of StudyStudy PopulationInterventionAims – Outcomes – Notes2023Involuntary Hospital Admission in the Treatment of People With Severe Substance Use DisorderDi Paola et al79CanadaCase-reports examined ability to consent during involuntary treatment for substance misuse disorderGeneral populationInvoluntary admission for substance misuse disorder and treatment consentPatient experience considered. Patients in their early 20s to mid-50s had a severe substance use disorder and required inpatient hospitalisation to stabilise. Admitted involuntarily to hospital for a brief period for safety and stabilisation, permitting withdrawal management and initiation of medications. Although patients were admitted involuntarily, they remained capable of consenting to treatment.2023Structural Racism in Behavioural Health Presentation and ManagementRainer et al80United StatesCase study of involuntary care and diagnosis of children and adolescentsEthnic group and paediatric focusInvoluntary care and diagnosisPathologising and criminalising Black children’s developmentally appropriate stress responsesDiagnostic disparities can compound into differential treatment and access to services beyond the health care domain.2024Clinicians’ experiences of caring for people brought in by police to the emergency department: A qualitative interpretive studyWardrop et al81AustraliaIn-depth, semi-structured interviews examined doctor and nurse perspectives of police transportGeneral populationPolice transportCommunication processes between police and health care staff and service outcomes (discharge location, custody, community, hospital admission) and length of stay. Current care delivery for patients transported by police to ED is unique and complex, often occurring in high traffic, resource-intensive areas. There is a need to strengthen structures and processes, to improve service outcomes.2020Patient and clinician experiences with an emergency department-based mental health liaison nurse service in a metropolitan settingWand et al82AustraliaSemi-structured interviews, thematic analysis of patient and staff perspectives on mental health liaison nursing (for a realistic evaluation)General populationMental health liaison nursing (MHLN)Patient experience considered. Mental health liaison nursing team established in the ED of a metropolitan hospital in New South Wales, Australia. Patient and staff interviews.2020Cairns Mental Health Co-Responder Project: Essential elements and challenges to programme implementationRobertson et al83AustraliaNine participating service providers completed semi-structured interviews focused on their knowledge and experience of the Cairns co-responder modelGeneral populationStreet triage - co-responder - PACERChallenges to project implementation included the following: initial concerns regarding client confidentiality, lack of an evaluation plan, and adequate project resourcing. Governance through a vigorous joint agency operation committee and adequate resourcing is imperative to the sustainability of this model.2018Patient perspectives of being detained under section 136 of the Mental Health Act: Findings from a qualitative study in LondonSondhi et al84United KingdomGrounded theory semi-structured interviews focused on patient experience of involuntary detention including police transportGeneral populationInvoluntary detention including police transportPatient experience considered. From mainly Caucasian female cohort - length of time and multiple assessment points, the importance of a positive professional-patient relationship (particularly with police officers), and the need for a supportive, therapeutic environment rather than a chaotic or clinical setting.2018Assistants in nursing working with mental health consumers in the emergency departmentGerace et al85AustraliaSemi-structured face-to-face (n = 23) or telephone (n = 1) interviews explored themes in Assistants in Nursing (AIN) self-perception and roleGeneral populationAIN available to continuously supervise people on mental health inpatient treatment orders.Patient experience considered. Interviews explored AIN role, practice, boundaries, image, learning through experience, and support. AINs were able to make meaningful contributions to patient trust, comfort and emotional state complementary to clinical treatment.2017Lived experience of involuntary transport under mental health legislationBradbury et al86AustraliaCross-sectional, qualitative research design using a social constructivist approach - all stakeholder experiences of involuntary transport incl. with policeGeneral populationPolice transportPatient experience considered. Lived experience of involuntary mental health transport from the perspectives of consumers, carers, mental health nurses, police officers, and ambulance paramedicspolice response was often too intense, even when the person was not violent, and carers struggled with having to call for emergency intervention. - Service providers were frustrated by lack of coordination, resource issues, delays at hospitals, and inadequate training.2015Patients with Mental Health Issues in the Emergency Department: The Relationship Between Coercion and Perceptions of Being Helped, Psychologically Hurt, and Physically HarmedHarrison et al87CanadaInterviews with 49 patients in an inpatient unit at a large general hospital explored patient perception of being helped or harmed during involuntary treatment.General populationInvoluntary transport and treatmentPatient experience considered. Roughly half of patients endorsed high levels of feeling helped, with the other half endorsing low levels. Additionally, perceptions of having control over coming to the emergency department were predictive of patients’ perceptions of being helped and psychologically hurt.2011Barriers to the operation of mental health legislation in Australian emergency departments: A qualitative analysisJelinek et al88AustraliaDeep interviews explored themes in barriers to using legislation - clinical staff perceptionGeneral populationInvoluntary transportMainly interviewed nurses, one doctor. Barriers to utilisation of mental health legislation in emergency departments - core themes were related to environment/resources, staff and patients. Table 4Mixed Methods Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency DepartmentsYear PublishedTitleAuthor(s)CountrySummary Description of StudyStudy PopulationInterventionAims – Outcomes – Notes2010A Controlled Before-and-After Evaluation of a Mobile Crisis Partnership Between Mental Health and Police Services in Nova ScotiaKisely et al89CanadaComparative - Controlled pre post one and two years follow up (all Co-response contacts and 724 call-to-door visits) with qualitative focus groups and interviews with service recipients, families, police officers, and health staff at baseline (53 participants) and 2 years afterward (31 participants)General populationStreet triage/co-responder and police transportAn increased use by people in crisis, families, and service partners (for example, from 464 to 1666 service recipients per year). Despite increased service use, time spent on-scene and call-to-door time were reduced. Supported by the qualitative results of focus groups and interviews.2023The Suicidal Patient in the Emergency Department Team-Based Learning ActivityAstemborski & Dimeo90United StatesComposite scale - attitudinal survey to assessment of team-based learning to recognise suicide risk - Likert scale and open questions.General populationTrainingTeam-based learning activity will help prepare residents and medical students to describe suicide risk, summarise the physician’s role, assess patient mental status, identify criteria for involuntary psychiatric hold, develop safe discharge plans for depressed patients and formulate plans for acutely intoxicated suicidal patients.2025“I was Able to Like, Kind of Breathe.” Baseline Perspectives and Lessons Learned from Participants of a Co-Response ProgramStauss et al91United StatesPerceptions of Co-response team encounters. Surveyed convenience sample (N=37) composite scales scored as mean (feelings during interactions, overall perceptions of team, and likelihood of seeking further treatment). Thematic analysis of interviews (N=15).General population-patient experienceStreet triage/co-responder and police transportPatient experience considered. Reported: (1) optimism about potential/actual changes in traditional policing outcomes (2) optimism about potential/actual changes in non-traditional policing outcomes and (3) pessimism about potential/actual changes to police authority and autonomy.2018Co-responding police–mental health programmes: Service user experiences and outcomes in a large urban centreLamanna et al92CanadaMixed-methods -Street triage/co-responder and police transport patient experience with comparative data from 2743 co-response vs 16226 police-only interactions. Thematic analysis of in-depth interviews explored patient experience.General population-patient experienceStreet triage/co-responder and police transportPatient experience considered. Rates of injury and arrest in co-responding team interactions at a large urban centre? Second, how do co-responding teams compare to police-only teams in response times, escorts to ED, and ED handover times? Third, how do service users experience corresponding and police-only team interactions? Figure 2Time trends in the number of publication outputs for 2008–2025.A bar graph showing the number of publications over different time periods from 2008 to 2025. The x-axis is labeled 'Year' with intervals: 2008-10, 2011-13, 2014-16, 2017-19, 2020-22 and 2023-25. The y-axis is labeled 'Number of Publications'. The data points are as follows: 2008-10 with 1 publication, 2011-13 with 7 publications, 2014-16 with 10 publications, 2017-19 with 16 publications, 2020-22 with 17 publications and 2023-25 with 14 publications. The graph shows an overall increasing trend with peaks in 2017-19 and 2020-22.Bar graph showing publication trends from 2008 to 2025, with peaks in 2017-19 and 2020-22. Figure 3Publications by region for 2008–2025.The pie chart illustrates the distribution of publications by region. The United States leads with 30 publications, followed by Australia with 23. Canada has 8 publications, the United Kingdom has 3 and Aotearoa New Zealand has 1. Each segment is labeled with the country name and the number of publications, providing a clear visual representation of the data distribution across these regions.Publication distribution: US 30, Australia 23, Canada 8, UK 3, NZ 1. Table 1Quantitative Retrospective Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency DepartmentsYear PublishedTitleAuthor(s)CountrySummary Description of StudyStudy PopulationInterventionOutcomes2025Eleven-Month Arrest Outcomes Among Three Crisis Response Models in MichiganSwanson et al29United StatesComparative - post-year arrest outcomes of mobile crisis teamsGeneral populationStreet triage/co-responder/PACERMobile crisis teams may divert future crisis service pathways away from 911, decreasing law enforcement involvement and arrest risk. Patients receiving crisis response services had fewer arrests per person, but only the mobile crisis group had a statistically significant reduced incidence rate of arrest compared to the law enforcement-only group, with non-significance in post- year arrest outcomes of co-response models.2024Civil Monetary Penalties Related to Violations of the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act Involving Patients Arriving or Departing with Law EnforcementAhmed et al30United StatesDescriptive - Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act related civil monetary penalty settlements involving patients arriving to or departing from the ED with law enforcementGeneral populationProvider fines and police transportProviders need more training to avoid violations of the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labour Act (EMTALA).2024Characteristics and outcomes of emergency department presentations brought in by police with and without an emergency examination authority: A state-wide cohort studyAlcock et al31AustraliaComparative - cohort - Characteristics and length of stay with and without involuntary orderGeneral populationPolice transportOver-represented among involuntary patients: mental health problems; from major cities; allocated more urgent on Australasian Triage Scale categories; and higher proportion of these not seen within time frame and experienced longer stay.2014Impact of boarding paediatric psychiatric patients on a medical wardClaudius et al32United StatesDescriptive - Study compared the psychiatric care provided to boarders in the medical ward versus those transferred to an affiliated psychiatric hospital. Calculated cost and number of medical beds for paediatric psychiatric patients - effect on psychiatric treatment over 18 monthsPaediatric patientsPsychiatric ward or medical ward admissionReduced chance of psychiatric treatment for those patients in the medical ward. 555 (50.1%) of 1108 patients on involuntary holds admitted to the paediatric medical unit. The majority (523 [94.2%]) were admitted for boarding because no psychiatric bed was available. Thirty-two (6.1%) patients admitted for isolated psychiatric reasons had counselling documented, and 105 (20.1%) received psychiatric medications. Patients admitted to an affiliated psychiatric hospital were significantly more likely to receive counselling and medications2023The association between the Police, Ambulance, Clinician Early Response model and involuntary detentions of people living with mental illness: A retrospective observational studyHeffernan et al11AustraliaComparative -PACER, police or ambulance as the exposures and rates of involuntary detentions (outcome)General populationStreet triage/co-responder/PACERPACER tri-response model was associated with lower rates of involuntary detentions compared to police and ambulance services with diversion of approximately half of patients from hospital.2022Health Service Outcomes After Implementation of an interdisciplinary Model of Care for the Management of Repeated Intentional Foreign Body Ingestion in Patients with Emotionally Unstable Personality DisorderHoey et al33AustraliaComparative - Pre-post use of Advanced Management Plans effect on subsequent admissionPatients with emotionally unstable/borderline personality disorderAdvanced management plansFor nine patients with 273 ED presentations), post-AMP decreases in presentations (9.8 to 7.0 per person-year); involuntary status (43%to 5%); average length of stay if admitted (1.5 to 1 day); and overall use of resources.2023Emergency examination authorities in Queensland, AustraliaClough et al34AustraliaDescriptive - Patterns of involuntary transport rates after legislative changeGeneral populationPolice transport legislationInvoluntary treatment recorded in psychiatric records before and after legislation change from the Mental Health Act to the Public Health Act.2022Characteristics and outcome of patients transported by police to emergency departments under section 351 of the Mental Health Act 2014 (Vic)Ward et al35AustraliaDescriptive - cohort with police-ambulance co-responder treatment patterns of police transportGeneral populationPolice transport and police-ambulance co-response84% of encounters (368/438) patients were co-transported with ambulance. Suicide risk/intent accounted for 67%; abnormal behaviour without threat to self or others 21%. In ED, parenteral sedation was administered in 11%. Physical restraint was applied in 17.6%. Psychiatric admission was required in 23.5% (involuntary 14.4%). Most (67.8%) patients were discharged home. Eighteen patients (5.6%) accounted for 22% of all events.2022Predictors of Emergency Department service outcome for people brought in by police: A retrospective cohort studyWardrop et al36AustraliaComparative - cohort study of factors that predict length of stay >4 hours for people brought in by police at multiple sitesGeneral populationPolice transportAmong a cohort of involuntary patients: 79% were under 45 years of age; 67% were male; 22% identified Indigenous status; > half presented to EDs in major cities; 88% were Australian born. Length of stay ≥4 hours included higher priority triage categories, hospital transfer/admission, evening/night shift arrival, and non-descript diagnosis.2022Involuntary Psychiatric Hospitalization: How Patient Characteristics Affect Decision-MakingBhalla et al37United StatesComparative - mixed effects modelling patient involuntarily admitted to psychiatry versus those who were discharged from the emergency departmentGeneral populationInvoluntary hold for social determinantsPsychiatrists utilise involuntary psychiatric treatment for patients facing social determinants of health like homelessness and loneliness related to aggression, intoxication, police transport.2021Racial and ethnic disparities in emergency department restraint use: A multicentre retrospective analysisCarreras et al38United StatesComparative - ethnicity effect on use of restraintEthnic group focusUse of restraintBlack/African American and Hispanic patients under an involuntary hold experience higher rates of physical restraint in the ED compared to their White/Caucasian counterparts. Factors associated: male sex, Medicaid insurance, and a diagnosis of bipolar disorder or psychotic disorder. Patients with a primary care provider within the health system’s network were at lower risk of being physically restrained.2022Recent amendments to Queensland legislation make mental health presentations to hospital emergency departments more difficult to scrutiniseClough et al39AustraliaComparative - admission under Mental Health Ac pre-post involuntary transport legislation to Public Health ActGeneral populationPolice transport legislationMoving involuntary transport to the Public Health Act appears to have had the unintended effect of restricting the publicly available information about some emergency mental health presentations to Queensland hospital EDs - perhaps ~16% of the 6887 involuntary transports reported in police records were reported in emergency psychiatric reporting.2021Emergency department visits among patients transported by law enforcement officersRosen & Travers40United StatesDescriptive -Effect of rural location on involuntary transport ratesRural settingPolice transportMedian transport rate in rural counties, 291.1, was twice that of large metro counties, 145.1. Nearly 50% increase during the study period, highest in rural counties. Many transports were for mental Illness and involuntary commitments.2022The association between involuntary alcohol treatment and subsequent emergency department visits and hospitalizations: a Bayesian analysis of treated patients and matched controlsVuong et al41AustraliaComparative - Involuntary and voluntary treatment for alcohol dependence on subsequent emergency and hospital care for cohorts at two sitesGeneral populationMandated alcohol treatmentNo statistically significant difference in outcomes between the patients admitted for mandated alcohol treatment and control groups.2021Older adults on involuntary hold status in the emergency departmentChipi et al42United StatesComparative - older and younger involuntary hold patients, demographic and clinical variablesAdults>65 yearsInvoluntary hold in EDOlder people may be more likely to be subject to involuntary holds for non-mental health related reasons.2020Are pre-existing psychiatric disorders the only reason for involuntary holds in the emergency department?Lachner et al43United StatesComparative - involuntary patients with and without a formal diagnosisGeneral populationInvoluntary hold/transportMost involuntary patients had a pre-existing psychiatric disorder including substance use disorder. Suicidal ideation associated with pain accounted for half of those without a diagnosed disorder. Better addressing pain in the medically ill population may prevent hopelessness and helplessness that can lead to suicidal ideation.2020Discontinuing involuntary mental health holds for children: Does psychiatrist specialty matter? A pilot studySantillanes et al44United StatesComparative - logistic regression length of hold of children assessed by paediatric vs general psychiatristsPaediatric patientsPaediatric psychiatric evaluationHolds > 3 times as likely to be discontinued in patients evaluated by child and adolescent psychiatrists rather than general emergency psychiatrists.2020Gun-Related and Other Violent Crime After Involuntary Commitment and Short-Term Emergency HoldsSwanson et al45United StatesComparative - Short-term hold association with future arrest for violent crimeGeneral populationShort term holdsShort-term hold with or without commitment was associated with a significantly higher risk of future arrest for violent crime, although the study population had other violence risk factors unrelated to mental illness. Risk of gun-involved crime, specifically, was significantly higher in individuals following a short-term hold only, but not in those who were involuntarily committed and became ineligible to purchase or possess guns.2018Treatment and outcomes of patients presenting to an adult emergency department involuntarily with substance misuseHughes et al46AustraliaDescriptive - Involuntary patients with substance misuse outcomes (2002 to 2010)General populationInvoluntary hold in EDIntoxicated patients experienced longer lead time to assessment with 30% involuntary patients, and the minority received intervention or referral for substance misuse treatment.2020Involuntary patient length-of-stay at a suburban emergency departmentManiaci et al47United StatesDescriptive -Length of stay dependence on substance misuseGeneral populationStreamlining for substance misuseIncreased ED length of stay associated with alcohol use, urine drug test screening, and barbiturate use. Protocol development to help streamline ED evaluation of alcohol and drug use may improve ED length of stay in this patient population.2019Patients Threatening Harm to Others Evaluated in the ED under the Florida Involuntary Hold Act (Baker Act)Maniaci et al48United StatesDescriptive - Diagnosis and suicidality among patients threatening homicideGeneral populationInvoluntary hold75% of patients expressing homicidal threats also were suicidal.2019Patients on Involuntary Hold Status in the Emergency DepartmentRoy et al49United StatesDescriptive – compared involuntary patients who attempted suicide with those who did notGeneral populationInvoluntary holdMost common reason for involuntary hold status was suicidality (73.7%).2019Emergency Medical Services Use Among Patients Receiving Involuntary Psychiatric Holds and the Safety of an Out-of-Hospital Screening Protocol to “Medically Clear” Psychiatric Emergencies in the Field, 2011 to 2016Trivedi et al50United StatesComparative - proportion of the population requiring involuntary transport and psychiatric vs medical care requiredGeneral populationDiversion/direct transfer to inpatient psych facilityOf541731emergency services encounters and257625unique patients in Alameda County, 10% of encounters and 24% of unique patients accounted for involuntary holds. 41% of encounters were transported to stand alone psychiatric emergency service and only 0.3% required re-transport within 12 hours. Involuntary hold patients were younger, more likely to be male and uninsured, and 4% had more than 20 emergency service encounters (ten times more than those never held involuntarily).2017Frequent users of Mental Health Liaison Services within Emergency DepartmentsBeck et al51United KingdomDescriptive - cohort with frequent involuntary ED admissionGeneral populationMental health liaison serviceFrequent users: comprised a small proportion of clients (4.72%) responsible for nearly a quarter of all admissions (24.2%); and were more likely to be diagnosed with substance abuse, personality disorder and psychosis; to have higher number of care coordinators; and to have been involuntarily detained under the Mental Health Act.2017Delayed Access to Involuntary Mental Health ExaminationsBrennaman et al52United StatesComparative - delayed access to involuntary treatmentGeneral populationInvoluntary MH ExaminationDelayed access to involuntary treatment - mean duration of delay was 14.9 h. Significantly associated with longer delays were being male, increased age, and intoxication.2018Violent behaviour by emergency department patients with an involuntary hold statusDawson et al53United StatesComparative - Length of stay increased with violent behaviourGeneral populationInvoluntary hold in EDViolent patients had a longer ED length of stay than nonviolent patients (median, 376 min vs 655.5 min; P = 0.01). Violent patients were more likely to be readmitted to the ED.2017The role of ethnicity in pathways to emergency psychiatric services for clients with psychosisRotenberg et al54CanadaComparative - Effects of social networks and cohesion on emergency mental health care accessEthnic group focusPolice transportEthnic minority communities in Toronto access resources differently during crisis and may have unique experiences regarding individual level social networks and community level social cohesion.2017Involuntary Psychiatric Holds in Preadolescent ChildrenSantillanes et al55United StatesDescriptive - paediatric involuntary hold characteristics and outcomesPaediatric patientsPaediatric psychiatric evaluationPreadolescent patients (under 10 years old) on involuntary psychiatric holds seen in one urban ED over two-year period were three quarters male, with child protective services involvement; one third had a prior psychiatric hospitalisation; more than half were discharged.2017EMS Utilization Among Patients on Involuntary Psychiatric Holds in Alameda County, April 2014–2016Trivedi et al56United StatesDescriptive - ambulance transport diversion to psychiatric facilityGeneral populationDiversion/direct transfer to inpatient psych facilityExamined outcomes of field triage to ED or psychiatric unit. Involuntary hold patients tended to be younger and less likely to be insured. 41% were admitted to psychiatric facility, 59% to ED.2016Patients assessed by the liaison psychiatric team in the emergency department of a regional hospital in Canada -general characteristics and gender differencesJuhas et al57CanadaComparative -Factors leading to involuntary holdGeneral populationLiaison psychiatric teamPsychiatric antecedents and predisposing factors - levels of clinical insight and global function, specific sex differences, threats of harm to others led to involuntary hold.2016Too much detention? Street Triage and detentions under Section 136 Mental Health Act in the North-East of England: a descriptive study of the effects of a Street Triage interventionKeown et al58United KingdomComparative pre-post street triage effect on use of involuntary transportGeneral populationStreet triage or co-responder model and police transportStreet triage (co-responder 7 days a week from 10am to 3am) reduced annual rate of involuntary holds by 56% (78% in one jurisdiction) in the first year. Noted the ability to respond speedily, with the combined skills and confidence of police officers working jointly with mental health professionals, with appropriate and desirable early mental health intervention2016Mental Health Emergency Department Visits: 24 Hours and Counting, Characteristics Associated With Prolonged Length of StayLippert et al59United StatesDescriptive - diagnosis and length of stayGeneral populationInvoluntary hold/transportPatients with more severe disorders had increased rates of admission and transfer and longer lengths of stay - the most seriously ill had increased odds of ED lengths of stay > 24 hours, even when ultimately discharged.2016Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? An audit of records of involuntary detentionO’Connor et al60AustraliaDescriptive -Use of involuntary treatment orders by different professionsGeneral populationPolice transportMore than 10% of involuntary detention certificates were incomplete but police-issued certificates were more detailed and less likely to be non-compliant.2016Presentations by ambulance under the NSW Mental Health Act to an emergency department with a 24-hour mental health teamSkopek & Francis61AustraliaDescriptive - Use of Mental Health Act admission and length of stay patternsGeneral populationInvoluntary ambulance transport~50% discharged home; increased length of stay associated with complexity, sedation, number of clinical problems.2015Exceeding the Legal Time Limits for Involuntary Mental Health Examinations: A Study of Emergency Department DelaysBrennaman62United StatesComparative - logistic regression of wait times for specific variablesGeneral populationMaximum hours detention8.8% of participants waited longer than the 12-h maximum allowed by Florida law for transfer to an authorised facility.2015Lengths of stay for involuntarily held psychiatric patients in the ED are affected by both patient characteristics and medication useWilson et al63United StatesComparative - cohort study of diagnosis, sedation and length of stayGeneral populationInvoluntary holdLonger lengths of stay for involuntarily held psychiatric patients were associated with suicidal ideation and weekend presentation and lengthened by factors typically under the control of ED clinicians, such as use of calming medication.2014Characteristics and outcome of patients brought to an emergency department by police under the provisions (Section 10) of the Mental Health Act in Victoria, AustraliaAl-Khafaji a et al64AustraliaDescriptive - Patient diagnosis and behaviour with police transportGeneral populationPolice transportAmong 164 patients and 195 presentations: male 95(58%); median age 35 years; multiple presentations 18 (11%); 77% outside business hours. Reasons included: threat of self-harm alone 128 (65%); threat of harm to self and others 34 (17%); abnormal behaviour without threat of harm to self or others 17 (9%); threat of harm to others only 16(8%); and other 2 (1%). Physical restraint applied 5(2.5%); sedation 76 (39%); 132 (67%) discharged home.2012Trends in the use of Emergency Examination Orders in Queensland since the implementation of the Mental Health Intervention ProjectMeehan & Stedman65AustraliaDescriptive - Use of involuntary transport legislation over timeGeneral populationInvoluntary hold/transport and police transportIncreased use of involuntary transport by both police and ambulance 2002–10. Police continue to generate two-thirds of all EEOs completed.2011Involuntary psychiatric attendances at an Australasian emergency department: A comparison of police and health-care worker initiated presentationsLlewellin et al66AustraliaComparative - patients transported by police and ambulanceGeneral populationPolice transportNon-medical patients were more likely to be suicidal or make specific threats of violence, while patients on medical orders were more likely to exhibit psychotic or manic symptoms without overt manifestation of violence. Non-medically detained patients spent longer in ED (248 min vs 208 min) and were more likely to be discharged. The impact of these differences on ED workload was small. Streaming towards rapid discharge may be cost-effective.2011Characteristics of patients referred by police to a psychiatric hospitalMaharaj et al67AustraliaDescriptive - Violent or threatening patient behaviour with police transportGeneral populationPolice transport and seclusionPolice referrals compared to others exhibited violent and/or threatening behaviour - a likely explanation for the high rates of seclusion for patients referred by police in this study (30% vs. 12%). Quantitative Retrospective Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency Departments Table 2Quantitative Prospective Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency DepartmentsYear PublishedTitleAuthor(s)CountrySummary Description of StudyStudy PopulationInterventionAims - Outcomes - Notes2024Testing the Impact of a Law Enforcement–Operated Co-responder Program for Youths: A Quasi-Experimental ApproachChilds et al68United StatesComparative - Co-responder model effect on police-initiated transport and de-escalation and representation rates 12 monthsYouthStreet triage or co-responder model and police transportSignificantly lower likelihood of police officer–initiated involuntary commitment examinations; and involuntary commitment examination within 1 year. Eighty percent of co-response incidents (police officer and mental health professional) were deescalated, allowing the youth to remain in the community with a safety plan, whereas 17% of incidents with a police-only response ended with crisis de-escalation.2023Police, ambulance and psychiatric co-response versus usual care for mental health and suicide emergency callouts: A quasi-experimental studyEvery-Palmer et al69New ZealandComparative - cohort assessed for outcomes with or without co-responderGeneral populationStreet triage or co-responder model and police transportImmediate and 1-month outcomes of mental health emergency calls made to police and ambulance were compared according to whether they occurred on days with co-response availability. When co-responder was available ED admissions reduced by 13%. Use of force unchanged, few police detentions.2021Costs and Savings Associated with the Police Use of the interRAI Brief Mental Health ScreenerHoffman et al70CanadaComparative - Impact of police use of screening tool on involuntary referralGeneral populationPolice Use of the interRAI Brief Mental Health Screener & police transport6,727 assessments were completed with involuntary referrals decreasing by 30%, and voluntary referrals by 34%. Costs savings implied.2021Examining Proactive and Responsive Outcomes of a Dedicated-Responder TeamMorabito & Savage71United StatesComparative - logistic regression of co-responder model effect on involuntary treatmentGeneral populationStreet triage - co-responder - PACEROne-month dedicated Co-Responder car pilot programme collected data about all related encounters. Co-Response team assisted more people and enhanced service connection with potential flow on reduction of crisis.2020An Observational Study of Telemental Care Delivery and the Context for Involuntary Commitment for Mental Health Patients in a Group of Rural Emergency DepartmentsFairchild et al72USADescriptive - Rural telehealth, diagnosis, involuntary commitment, ED throughput and reimbursementRural populationTelehealthTelehealth reduces admission to psychiatric wards generally. Reduced involuntary admission can reduce costs. Youth under police transport were more likely to be female compared with the adult involuntary patients. Suicidal ideation is the main risk for involuntary transport, underscoring the need for immediate and intensive psychiatric care through telemental health in rural settings when someone is a clear danger to themselves or others.2019Improving Emergency Department Flow for Patients Requiring Involuntary Psychiatric HospitalizationBhalla & Danovitch73United StatesComparative - pre-post program’s impact on emergency department flow. Do not provide pre data or baseline.General populationCoP with training in involuntary holdsImpact of a community of practice to change training and policy. Preliminary report for first two phases staggered implementation at multiple sites; 133 providers trained and certified by the county to write a hold. 402 patients committed on pilot holds. At Phase 1 sites 225/333 (68%) patients placed on a hold transferred to psychiatric hospitals within 24 hours; no complaints related to the pilot or reports of inappropriate holds. Perceived success - county extended the initiative beyond 2 years.2019Do police–mental health co-responder programmes reduce emergency department presentations or simply delay the inevitable?Meehan et al74AustraliaDescriptive - Individuals seen by the co-responder team were followed for two weeks to monitor subsequent ED presentations and inpatient admissions.General populationStreet triage - co-responder - PACER82/122 people (67.2%) remained at their residence -followed-up for 2 weeks. During this time 10 (12.2%) presented to ED and 3 of these (3.7%) were subsequently admitted to hospital. 35/122 (28.7%) were transported to the emergency department (ED) and 5/122 (4.1%) were taken into custody by police.2014Effects of a Dedicated Regional Psychiatric Emergency Service on Boarding of Psychiatric Patients in Area Emergency DepartmentsZeller et al75United StatesDescriptive - cohort of 144 patientsGeneral populationAlameda Model of transferring patients from general hospital EDs to a regional psychiatric emergency servicePatient experience considered. Expedited transfers from local EDs, with an average transfer time of 1 hour 48 minutes, 80% reduction compared to state average. High discharge rate for transferred patients, lower admission to inpatient.2013Involuntary psychiatric admissions under the Mental Health Act 2007 (NSW): A comparative study of patients who were detained by ambulance officers and medical officers and accredited persons within a NSW Hospital EmergencyCutler et al76AustraliaComparative - Ambulance versus clinician effect on inpatient admissionGeneral populationAmbulance initiated transportAmbulance officer certification poorly predicts involuntary psychiatric admission.2011Aggressive behaviours in the psychiatric emergency serviceChaput et al77CanadaComparative -logistic regression of aggression dependence on substance use disorderGeneral populationAggressive patientsFactors associated with aggression - substance use important factor but rated differently by doctors and nurses. Few referrals specifically for SU. Rather, referring emergency department physicians appeared to focus on factors such as poor impulse control and suicidal ideation, which are observed in almost 50% of patients with alcohol dependence.2011Physical Restraints in the Emergency Department and Attendance at Subsequent Outpatient Psychiatric TreatmentCurrier et al78United StatesComparative -two-arm study of effect of restraint use on follow up treatment complianceGeneral population-patient experiencePhysical restraintPatient experience considered. 84% of patients in the unrestrained group attended their first outpatient psychiatric appointment, only 65% of restrained patients attended their first outpatient psychiatric appointment. Quantitative Prospective Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency Departments Table 3Qualitative Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency DepartmentsYear PublishedTitleAuthor(s)CountrySummary Description of StudyStudy PopulationInterventionAims – Outcomes – Notes2023Involuntary Hospital Admission in the Treatment of People With Severe Substance Use DisorderDi Paola et al79CanadaCase-reports examined ability to consent during involuntary treatment for substance misuse disorderGeneral populationInvoluntary admission for substance misuse disorder and treatment consentPatient experience considered. Patients in their early 20s to mid-50s had a severe substance use disorder and required inpatient hospitalisation to stabilise. Admitted involuntarily to hospital for a brief period for safety and stabilisation, permitting withdrawal management and initiation of medications. Although patients were admitted involuntarily, they remained capable of consenting to treatment.2023Structural Racism in Behavioural Health Presentation and ManagementRainer et al80United StatesCase study of involuntary care and diagnosis of children and adolescentsEthnic group and paediatric focusInvoluntary care and diagnosisPathologising and criminalising Black children’s developmentally appropriate stress responsesDiagnostic disparities can compound into differential treatment and access to services beyond the health care domain.2024Clinicians’ experiences of caring for people brought in by police to the emergency department: A qualitative interpretive studyWardrop et al81AustraliaIn-depth, semi-structured interviews examined doctor and nurse perspectives of police transportGeneral populationPolice transportCommunication processes between police and health care staff and service outcomes (discharge location, custody, community, hospital admission) and length of stay. Current care delivery for patients transported by police to ED is unique and complex, often occurring in high traffic, resource-intensive areas. There is a need to strengthen structures and processes, to improve service outcomes.2020Patient and clinician experiences with an emergency department-based mental health liaison nurse service in a metropolitan settingWand et al82AustraliaSemi-structured interviews, thematic analysis of patient and staff perspectives on mental health liaison nursing (for a realistic evaluation)General populationMental health liaison nursing (MHLN)Patient experience considered. Mental health liaison nursing team established in the ED of a metropolitan hospital in New South Wales, Australia. Patient and staff interviews.2020Cairns Mental Health Co-Responder Project: Essential elements and challenges to programme implementationRobertson et al83AustraliaNine participating service providers completed semi-structured interviews focused on their knowledge and experience of the Cairns co-responder modelGeneral populationStreet triage - co-responder - PACERChallenges to project implementation included the following: initial concerns regarding client confidentiality, lack of an evaluation plan, and adequate project resourcing. Governance through a vigorous joint agency operation committee and adequate resourcing is imperative to the sustainability of this model.2018Patient perspectives of being detained under section 136 of the Mental Health Act: Findings from a qualitative study in LondonSondhi et al84United KingdomGrounded theory semi-structured interviews focused on patient experience of involuntary detention including police transportGeneral populationInvoluntary detention including police transportPatient experience considered. From mainly Caucasian female cohort - length of time and multiple assessment points, the importance of a positive professional-patient relationship (particularly with police officers), and the need for a supportive, therapeutic environment rather than a chaotic or clinical setting.2018Assistants in nursing working with mental health consumers in the emergency departmentGerace et al85AustraliaSemi-structured face-to-face (n = 23) or telephone (n = 1) interviews explored themes in Assistants in Nursing (AIN) self-perception and roleGeneral populationAIN available to continuously supervise people on mental health inpatient treatment orders.Patient experience considered. Interviews explored AIN role, practice, boundaries, image, learning through experience, and support. AINs were able to make meaningful contributions to patient trust, comfort and emotional state complementary to clinical treatment.2017Lived experience of involuntary transport under mental health legislationBradbury et al86AustraliaCross-sectional, qualitative research design using a social constructivist approach - all stakeholder experiences of involuntary transport incl. with policeGeneral populationPolice transportPatient experience considered. Lived experience of involuntary mental health transport from the perspectives of consumers, carers, mental health nurses, police officers, and ambulance paramedicspolice response was often too intense, even when the person was not violent, and carers struggled with having to call for emergency intervention. - Service providers were frustrated by lack of coordination, resource issues, delays at hospitals, and inadequate training.2015Patients with Mental Health Issues in the Emergency Department: The Relationship Between Coercion and Perceptions of Being Helped, Psychologically Hurt, and Physically HarmedHarrison et al87CanadaInterviews with 49 patients in an inpatient unit at a large general hospital explored patient perception of being helped or harmed during involuntary treatment.General populationInvoluntary transport and treatmentPatient experience considered. Roughly half of patients endorsed high levels of feeling helped, with the other half endorsing low levels. Additionally, perceptions of having control over coming to the emergency department were predictive of patients’ perceptions of being helped and psychologically hurt.2011Barriers to the operation of mental health legislation in Australian emergency departments: A qualitative analysisJelinek et al88AustraliaDeep interviews explored themes in barriers to using legislation - clinical staff perceptionGeneral populationInvoluntary transportMainly interviewed nurses, one doctor. Barriers to utilisation of mental health legislation in emergency departments - core themes were related to environment/resources, staff and patients. Qualitative Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency Departments Table 4Mixed Methods Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency DepartmentsYear PublishedTitleAuthor(s)CountrySummary Description of StudyStudy PopulationInterventionAims – Outcomes – Notes2010A Controlled Before-and-After Evaluation of a Mobile Crisis Partnership Between Mental Health and Police Services in Nova ScotiaKisely et al89CanadaComparative - Controlled pre post one and two years follow up (all Co-response contacts and 724 call-to-door visits) with qualitative focus groups and interviews with service recipients, families, police officers, and health staff at baseline (53 participants) and 2 years afterward (31 participants)General populationStreet triage/co-responder and police transportAn increased use by people in crisis, families, and service partners (for example, from 464 to 1666 service recipients per year). Despite increased service use, time spent on-scene and call-to-door time were reduced. Supported by the qualitative results of focus groups and interviews.2023The Suicidal Patient in the Emergency Department Team-Based Learning ActivityAstemborski & Dimeo90United StatesComposite scale - attitudinal survey to assessment of team-based learning to recognise suicide risk - Likert scale and open questions.General populationTrainingTeam-based learning activity will help prepare residents and medical students to describe suicide risk, summarise the physician’s role, assess patient mental status, identify criteria for involuntary psychiatric hold, develop safe discharge plans for depressed patients and formulate plans for acutely intoxicated suicidal patients.2025“I was Able to Like, Kind of Breathe.” Baseline Perspectives and Lessons Learned from Participants of a Co-Response ProgramStauss et al91United StatesPerceptions of Co-response team encounters. Surveyed convenience sample (N=37) composite scales scored as mean (feelings during interactions, overall perceptions of team, and likelihood of seeking further treatment). Thematic analysis of interviews (N=15).General population-patient experienceStreet triage/co-responder and police transportPatient experience considered. Reported: (1) optimism about potential/actual changes in traditional policing outcomes (2) optimism about potential/actual changes in non-traditional policing outcomes and (3) pessimism about potential/actual changes to police authority and autonomy.2018Co-responding police–mental health programmes: Service user experiences and outcomes in a large urban centreLamanna et al92CanadaMixed-methods -Street triage/co-responder and police transport patient experience with comparative data from 2743 co-response vs 16226 police-only interactions. Thematic analysis of in-depth interviews explored patient experience.General population-patient experienceStreet triage/co-responder and police transportPatient experience considered. Rates of injury and arrest in co-responding team interactions at a large urban centre? Second, how do co-responding teams compare to police-only teams in response times, escorts to ED, and ED handover times? Third, how do service users experience corresponding and police-only team interactions? Mixed Methods Studies Focused on Involuntary Transport and Admission to Hospital Emergency Departments Time trends in the number of publication outputs for 2008–2025. Publications by region for 2008–2025. In addition to descriptive summarisation, an interpretive analysis was undertaken to assess the extent to which the included studies demonstrated elements consistent with Communities of Practice (CoPs). For the purposes of this review, CoPs were understood as collaborative learning arrangements characterised by sustained interaction, shared knowledge exchange, and the co-development of practice within and across professional groups. A structured analytical framework was applied to each study to identify the presence of CoP-consistent elements, including: Interagency collaboration and coordination;Shared learning or training activities;Communication and information exchange across roles or services; andPractices supporting reflection, workforce development, or service improvement Interagency collaboration and coordination; Interagency collaboration and coordination; Shared learning or training activities; Shared learning or training activities; Communication and information exchange across roles or services; and Communication and information exchange across roles or services; and Practices supporting reflection, workforce development, or service improvement Practices supporting reflection, workforce development, or service improvement Studies were examined for explicit or implicit evidence of these elements and for any reported effects on processes or outcomes. Coding was conducted independently by two reviewers, with discrepancies resolved through discussion. Given that most included studies did not explicitly adopt a CoP framework, identification of CoP-consistent elements required interpretive judgement. The analysis therefore focused not only on the presence of collaborative practices, but also on whether these reflected sustained, system-level approaches to shared learning, as distinct from isolated or operational forms of collaboration. Findings are presented both descriptively by study type and thematically in relation to their relevance to CoP concepts, with emphasis on the extent to which existing evidence supports, approximates, or fails to demonstrate CoP-based approaches. Results The 65 peer-reviewed articles meeting inclusion criteria included: 40 quantitative retrospective studies (Table 1);11 quantitative prospective studies (Table 2);10 qualitative studies (Table 3); and4 mixed methods studies (Table 4). 40 quantitative retrospective studies (Table 1); 40 quantitative retrospective studies (Table 1); 11 quantitative prospective studies (Table 2); 11 quantitative prospective studies (Table 2); 10 qualitative studies (Table 3); and 10 qualitative studies (Table 3); and 4 mixed methods studies (Table 4). 4 mixed methods studies (Table 4). The 65 included studies are summarised by methodological type in Tables 1–4. Within each study type, findings are interpreted in relation to their relevance to collaborative practices consistent with CoPs, including interagency coordination, shared learning, and communication across services. Research Outputs Over Time and by Jurisdiction Figure 2 shows that the trend in the number of studies meeting inclusion criteria was for a steady increase over time, accelerating after 2014–2016. No publications were identified for 2008–9, whereas during the period from 2017 to 2022, inclusive, there was an average of seven publications per year, including eight in 2020, the largest number published in any calendar year. More studies may well have been published after June 2025 but not included in our review, making it likely that the overall trend for a steady increase in research output since 2008 has continued. Figure 3 shows that almost half of the publications included in our review came from the US (n=30), a third from Australia (n=23) with the remainder from Canada (n=8), the UK (n=3) and AoNZ (n=1). Quantitative Retrospective Studies (n=40) The quantitative retrospective studies all interrogated service system records such as clinical charts and hospital, police or ambulance electronic databases (Table 1). Twenty-two studies contained comparative elements while the remaining 18 were purely descriptive in nature. These studies primarily characterise service use and clinical outcomes providing only indirect insight into collaborative practices relevant to CoPs. Patient characteristics considered included: age; sex; diagnosis (particularly major psychiatric disorder, substance misuse disorder); intoxication; pain; and insurance status (a particular focus in the United States). Specific behaviours examined included suicidality and threats of harm to self or others.33,45,46,48,49,53,57 Individual studies considered homicidal intent,48 gun-related violence after involuntary admission,45 intentional foreign body ingestion,33 pain43, and effects of mandated alcohol treatment.41 Only three studies considered paediatric or adolescent minors,32,44,55 one specifically considered older adults42 and two considered ethnic minorities.38,54 Generally, the quantitative retrospective studies reported that most patients transported involuntarily are discharged home, with a small proportion of service users accounting for a disproportionate number of instances of involuntary transport. The US, Australian and UK studies found that around 5–10% of patients accounted for around one quarter of service use.31,35 The more commonly examined outcomes were length of stay31,32,36,38,44,46,47,53,59,61,63,66 use of seclusion67 or physical or chemical restraint,35,38,67 the proportion of involuntary patients discharged home without admission to hospital and frequency of involuntary admission to psychiatric ward or facility.31,35–37,44,50,56,59,61,66,67 Severity of disorder, night or weekend admission with lack of access to a mental health specialist, violence or the threat of violence occasioning sedation, and intoxication all increased wait-times and length of stay.36,45,46,50,52,53,64,66,67 Diversion directly to specialised psychiatric facilities was found to be feasible with favourable treatment outcomes where such services were available.11,50,56 Police co-responder models and field triage reduced involuntary detention, arrest rates29 and wait-times.58 Treatment by the appropriate mental health specialist and advanced care plans also reduced wait-times.41,44,62 A commonly recurring theme in the 40 studies was a focus on police transport.11,29–31,34,36,39,40,58,64–67 These studies generally reported that patients transported by police are more likely to be male,67 and to exhibit violent behaviour64 or suicidal ideation.35 Among six Australian studies altogether, two reported that police and ambulance transport episodes had increased over time in Queensland.34,65 Two studies compared patients transported by police with other involuntary patients, finding more frequent use of seclusion64 and greater length of stay36 in police-transported patients, both outcomes attributed to the nature of the behaviours (eg. suicidality, threats of violence) requiring police intervention. Police-issued records were found to be more detailed and compliant with regulations than for their ambulance or clinician counterparts.60 Quantitative Prospective Studies (n=11) As for the quantitative retrospective studies, the prospective studies interrogated service system records such as clinical charts and hospital, police or ambulance electronic databases (Table 2). Seven studies evaluated pre-post intervention effects,68–71,74,75,77 and one the effects of physical restraint on follow-up compliance.78 The remainder compared different patient group characteristics76 or exposure to treatment or intervention.72,73 These studies more frequently evaluate interventions, particularly co-responder and diversion models, and therefore provide more direct evidence of structured interagency collaboration. Five of the 11 prospective studies focused on street triage or diversion models.68–71,74 Childs and colleagues specifically examined effects on youth populations with compelling findings of 85% de-escalation with co-response compared to 17% for police-only responses, enabling young people to remain in the community with safety plans with reduced likelihood of further involuntary commitment within one year.68 Co-response models in AoNZ, the US and Australia supported rapid response, reduced involuntary transport and subsequent ED and mental health unit admissions and did not increase the use of force69 or the risk of re-presentation in the two weeks following initial contact.74 Morabito & Savage noted the co-responder approach extended reach by connecting individuals to services previously unknown to them, potentially, reducing the need for future calls.71 Hoffman and colleagues’ Canadian study also demonstrated that reduced police transport in the absence of co-response was achieved with the use of a screening tool supported by appropriate training.70 Five quantitative prospective studies considered a range of topics with a common theme of improving patient compliance and reducing involuntary transport. Topics covered included: the effects of regional specialist psychiatric services on boarding;75 aggression and substance use disorder;77 use of physical restraint;78 ambulance-initiated transport;76 and, telehealth in rural populations.72 Ambulance certified involuntary transport was found to be a poor predictor of psychiatric admission.76 Currier et al reported that experiencing physical restraint reduced the likelihood of patients attending their first outpatient psychiatric appointment78 Chaput et al observed that the decision to apply involuntary holds was most often determined by poor impulse control and suicidal ideation in the patient despite a patient’s untreated alcohol dependence.77 Zeller et al’s study of direct diversion to a psychiatric facility reduced wait times and admission to EDs, and improved patient experience.75 In a high-risk rural Canadian context, Fairchild et al reported a telemental health service was a cost-effective means to access immediate and intensive psychiatric care for suicide threat.72 Bhalla & Danovitch’s study, the only study to feature an evaluation of a CoP in our literature search and selection, found that after hospital-based clinicians were trained and certified to write a hold, two-thirds of patients committed on pilot holds were transferred to psychiatric hospitals within 24 hours, without distressing patients.73 Further evaluations of the appropriateness of holds and patient experience are pending at time of writing. Qualitative Studies (n=10) Of the ten qualitative studies included in our review six were carried out in Australia,81–83,85,86,88 two in Canada,79,87 one each in the US80 and the UK84 (Table 3). Eight of the ten qualitative studies employed interviews with patients and/or providers and there were two case studies79,80 (Table 3). One case study considered the potential benefits of brief, involuntary admission to stabilise substance use disorder79 and the other considered the potential consequences of pathologising Black children’s developmentally appropriate stress/distress that might compound differential treatment.80 These studies provide insight into relational, organisational, and experiential dimensions of care highlighting the importance of communication, trust, and shared understanding across roles. Two of eight qualitative studies, focused primarily on staff perceptions of an aspect of involuntary care, one exploring clinician perceptions of barriers to using mental health legislation in EDs88 and the other exploring “Assistants in Nursing” (AIN) self-perception.85 Jelinek et al highlighted that ED environment, resources, communication, relationships and staff understanding or ability to apply legislation were often beyond role descriptions for staff.88 Gerace et al explored the AIN role in supporting patient trust, comfort and emotional state.85 Both studies spoke to the need for professional supports like refresher training, formal supervision and debriefing—practices legitimising participation and collaboration in shared practice beyond the strict clinical role definition. Studies from the UK, Australia and Canada highlighted the importance of patient experience, citing positive professional-patient relationships, and the need for a therapeutic, structured treatment setting to support patients’ sense of autonomy and perception of being helped.84,86,87 Studies exploring challenges in police transport co-response models highlighted concerns for confidentiality, coordination,83 resourcing and training.86 Both patients and staff viewed mental health liaison nurses as supporting internal (eg. bed managers) and interagency (eg. referral services) communication and workflow in Jelinek et al’s Australian study.88 Mixed-Methods Studies (n=4) Four articles from Canada (n=2) and the US (n=2) employed mixed methods, and featured qualitative interviews of patient and/or provider perspectives with street triage or co-responder models with police as the focus89–92 (Table 4). The few mixed-methods studies were published recently, and—though more explicit about both measured efficacy and effects on patient experience—lacked robust designs and did not promote sophisticated practice responses to enhance system functionality. However, these studies offer partial integration of outcome and experiential data, providing limited but relevant insight into both effectiveness and collaborative processes without examining the development of sustained collaborative learning systems characteristic of CoPs. Synthesis Across all study types, collaborative practices, particularly interagency coordination, shared training, and co-response models, are not prominent and are typically inferred as operational or programmatic responses rather than as components of sustained systems of shared learning. While many studies report elements consistent with CoP principles, the deliberate establishment of ongoing, adaptive communities of practice is lacking. The current evidence base we depict here is characterised by repeated description of service challenges and interventions, with limited attention to how collaborative practice can be developed, embedded, and sustained over time. Discussion Research interest in the effectiveness and appropriateness of involuntary transport to EDs for patients requiring urgent mental health care has grown substantially since 2008. However, the evidence base remains heavily weighted towards quantitative analyses of routinely collected service data. These studies repeatedly characterise patterns of service use, patient characteristics, and system pressures, while providing limited insight into how collaborative practices are developed, sustained, or improved over time. Most of the 65 studies included in this review were published in the US (n=30) or Australia (n=23), with most (n=47) published from 2016 onwards. The vast majority have been quantitative studies (n=51, 40 retrospective and 11 prospective) interrogating service system records such as clinical charts and hospital, police or ambulance electronic databases. Fourteen were qualitative or mixed methods studies. Irrespective of study type the most common focus among the studies reviewed was the efficacy of police co-responder models. Other interventions, such as the role of an Assistant in Nursing, Mental Health Liaison Services or targeted training, have also been assessed. Patient experience was a topic in several quantitative prospective studies, and in most of the qualitative studies albeit, understandably, not as a primary topic in the quantitative retrospective studies. Topics that received little or no attention among the studies reviewed included sexuality, gender identity, neurodiversity and indigeneity. Studies specifically considering paediatric involuntary emergency mental health transport and treatment were few—all published in the US by one research group. Interventions that were effective in reducing overall transport to EDs and reducing wait times were co-responder models enabling street triage11,29,50,56,58,64,68,69,71,74 and direct transfer to psychiatric facilities.56,75 Co-response models generally reported no ill-effects or unintended outcomes on patients, and use of force, arrest rates and re-transport in the weeks following, where reported, were low.29,50,68 Though the benefits seem clear, such models pose policy and resourcing challenges due in large part to the complexity of interagency autonomy, communication, and cooperation.83,87 No studies examined in any detail the phenomenon of multiple episodes for the same individual. Studies from the US,50 UK51 and Australia35 reported that perhaps as few as 5% of patients account for around one fifth to one quarter of involuntary admissions to EDs. The imbalance in the evidence base reflects the underlying field rather than the authors’ editorial emphasis. Quantitative studies—often based on secondary analyses of system-generated data—predominate; whereas, qualitative and mixed-methods research is comparatively scarce. This imbalance is not unexpected, given the practical and ethical challenges of conducting qualitative research in acute mental health crisis settings, particularly involving involuntary patients. However, this gap has important implications, as understanding patient experience, interprofessional relationships, and the dynamics of collaborative practice is central to the development of CoP-based approaches. Evidence of Actual or Potential Use of CoP A Community of Practice (CoP) is typically defined as a group of people who share a common interest or domain and engage in ongoing interaction to share knowledge, solve problems, and improve practice related to that domain. According to seminal work by Wenger et al,15 a CoP involves three key elements: a shared domain of interest, a community of members who interact and build relationships around that domain, and a shared practice including resources, tools, experiences, and standards developed over time through collaboration and mutual engagement. CoPs emphasise continuous learning, collective problem-solving, identity formation within the group, and the development of a shared repertoire of knowledge and approaches relevant to their focus area. They often include members from different backgrounds who learn through social participation and exchange, moving beyond mere individual expertise to collective development of knowledge and practice. In the context of emergency and crisis response, many of the included studies examined elements consistent with CoP characteristics. These include elements which enhance and legitimise professional participation in shared processes, such as: collaboration among professionals from diverse services authorised by government to intervene (emergency services, police, ambulance, mental health teams); information and data sharing and knowledge exchange as a key enabler; shared training protocols and resources; interdisciplinary or interagency cooperation; and an emphasis on effective partnerships and communication. However, while the papers reviewed implicitly depict features of collaborative and integrated practice, they typically do not explicitly frame their work or findings in terms of a CoP. They tend rather to describe operational or procedural cooperation, protocols, or partnership models rather than highlighting the ongoing social learning, identity formation, mutual engagement, and development of shared repertoires that are the hallmark of the CoP notion. In other words, although the described interdisciplinary efforts and partnerships contain components of CoP theory, the studies lack evidence of a formal or intentional establishment of a CoP with its continuous, evolving knowledge-sharing and collective learning culture. For this scoping review, aiming to assess the presence or impact of CoPs in emergency mental health crisis contexts, these papers indicate promising collaborative elements but do not provide direct empirical support or conceptual framing confirming an actual CoP structure or process at work. This gap is a key finding of this review. Although a formal CoP around emergency services, involving police, ambulance, mental health, and hospital teams could offer a useful framework to enhance the collaboration, shared learning, and coordination required, the current literature only documents related but distinct phenomena such as interagency protocols, co-responder initiatives, and partnership-based approaches rather than explicitly identified or studied CoPs. While co-responder, and similar diversion models demonstrate measurable improvements in outcomes, they are typically implemented as discrete interventions rather than as components of sustained systems of shared learning. This distinction is important, as it may explain why successful models are not consistently embedded or scaled across settings. CoPs offer a framework for understanding how collaborative practice can be developed as an ongoing, adaptive process rather than a series of isolated initiatives. CoPs emphasise sustained social learning mechanisms and shared identity that can lead to deeper practice improvements beyond standard operational collaboration. None of the papers included in this review offer these elements. Limitations Although this scoping review employed a comprehensive search strategy across multiple databases and sources, several limitations should be acknowledged. First, while both peer-reviewed and grey literature sources were searched to inform contextual understanding, only peer-reviewed studies meeting the inclusion criteria were included in the final synthesis. Grey literature searches focused on emergency medicine discipline peak bodies where these existed in the jurisdictions but yielded no materials meeting inclusion criteria. It is nonetheless possible that relevant policy or practice-based insights were not captured from other source materials, eg. health department policies and programs in the jurisdictions. Second, the inclusion of studies identified through an AI-assisted search tool (Undermind) may have introduced selection bias. Although these studies were assessed against the same inclusion criteria as those identified through conventional database searches, the potential for systematic differences in retrieval cannot be entirely excluded. Third, the review was limited to English-language publications from five common law jurisdictions. While this provided a coherent legal and policy context, it limits the generalisability of findings to other health systems and legal frameworks, particularly in non-English speaking countries and countries where legal systems are based on an inquisitorial tradition. Fourth, consistent with scoping review methodology, no formal critical appraisal of included studies was undertaken. As a result, the review maps the extent and nature of the evidence rather than assessing the quality or strength of individual studies. Fifth, the analysis of CoP-consistent elements required interpretive judgement, as most included studies did not explicitly adopt a CoP framework. Although a structured analytical approach was used, the identification of CoP-relevant practices is necessarily subjective and may be influenced by the conceptual lens applied. Finally, the evidence base itself is characterised by a predominance of quantitative studies, many of which are based on secondary analyses of routinely collected data. This limits the depth of insight into patient experience, interprofessional relationships, and the social learning processes central to CoP development. The relative scarcity of qualitative and mixed-methods research in this field represents an important gap in the literature rather than a limitation of the review alone. Conclusion Research on involuntary mental health presentations to emergency departments has increased steadily since 2008 across common law jurisdictions, with a strong focus on service utilisation, patient characteristics, and the effectiveness of specific interventions. This evidence base is dominated by quantitative studies, many of which rely on secondary analyses of routinely collected data, and therefore provides limited insight into patient experience, interprofessional relationships, and the processes through which collaborative practice is developed and sustained. While a range of collaborative models—including co-responder approaches, diversion pathways, and liaison services—have demonstrated improvements in operational outcomes, these are typically implemented as discrete interventions rather than as components of sustained systems of shared learning. Across the literature, elements consistent with CoPs, such as interagency communication, shared training, and coordination, are frequently described but not conceptualised or evaluated as part of an ongoing, adaptive community of practice. The absence of explicitly defined or sustained CoP approaches represents a gap in the current evidence base. This gap is significant, as it suggests that existing models may lack the mechanisms required to support continuous learning, integration across services, and long-term improvement in practice. Addressing this gap will require research that moves beyond descriptive, quantitative studies to examine how collaborative practice is developed, embedded, and maintained over time. In particular, there is a need to balance the preponderance of quantitative studies with qualitative and mixed-methods research that captures patient experience, clinician perspectives, and the social and organisational dynamics that underpin effective collaboration. Communities of Practice offer a theoretically coherent framework for understanding and supporting these processes. However, their feasibility, implementation, and impact in the context of emergency mental health care for involuntary patients remain largely unexplored. Future research should therefore focus on the development and evaluation of CoP-based approaches, including their potential to improve patient experience, support workforce capability, and strengthen interagency coordination in this complex and enduring area of care.