Impact of emotional competence on clinical reasoning: a scoping review Authors: Louise Joly, Alexandra Nunes de Sousa, Marjorie Bardiau, Valérie Dory, Marie Bayot, Anne-Laure Lenoir Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractObjectivesGiven the role of emotions in reasoning, we hypothesised that emotional competence (EC), defined as the ability to identify, understand, express, regulate and use emotions, would increase the quality of physician’s clinical reasoning (CR). The objectives of this study were to map the existing literature on the impact of EC on physician’s CR and to identify any literature gaps.DesignThis study is a scoping review.Data sourcesWe included articles from Medline (via Ovid), Embase and Psychinfo and articles found manually, with no limitations in terms of publication date or location.Eligibility criteriaInclusion criteria were all physicians and medical students and articles focusing on one or more dimensions of EC (based on the model of Mikolajczak et al) and of CR (based on the framework of Young et al). We excluded non-research articles and articles concerning other health professionals, physicians’ psychiatric disorders or the impact of emotions on well-being, instrument-handling skills or students’ academic learning.Data extraction and synthesisData were extracted by two independent reviewers. Results were summarised using descriptive analyses and a narrative synthesis.ResultsAfter removing duplicates, we identified 12 046 articles. Following a review of their titles and abstracts, we assessed 268 articles for eligibility and included 98 in the scoping review. Most studies examined the effects of emotional regulation strategies, empathy and global EC scores on clinical performance. Positive effects of EC on uncertainty management and intuitive reasoning have been well documented, as have its effects on diagnostic and therapeutic performance and the development of CR in the context of life-threatening situations. A smaller number of studies suggest a favourable impact on clinical performance in the surgical context and on the quality of prescriptions. The impact of EC on diagnostic and therapeutic performance outside emergency and intraoperative contexts and on patient outcomes remains uncertain. The effects of EC on CR were most evident under conditions of high acute stress, likely due to the increased cognitive load associated with such conditions.ConclusionsEC has been found to have a positive impact on CR mainly when dealing with uncertainty and life-threatening emergencies. Stress regulation and the resulting reduction in cognitive load appear to be a key modulator of EC’s impact on CR. Further research should focus on the impact of EC on diagnostic and therapeutic performance outside emergency conditions and on patient outcomes. STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY To the best of our knowledge, this is the first scoping review focusing on the impact of EC on CR, which is an important topic for undergraduate and postgraduate medical education and in continuing professional development. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first scoping review focusing on the impact of EC on CR, which is an important topic for undergraduate and postgraduate medical education and in continuing professional development. We explored CR in its broadest sense to provide a wide overview of the impact of EC on CR. We explored CR in its broadest sense to provide a wide overview of the impact of EC on CR. Due to the multi-dimensional nature of both CR and EC, the literature is heterogeneous. Due to the multi-dimensional nature of both CR and EC, the literature is heterogeneous. Some articles mentioned ill-defined concepts related to CR or EC; this rendered the selection and synthesis of articles challenging. Some articles mentioned ill-defined concepts related to CR or EC; this rendered the selection and synthesis of articles challenging. We were unable to locate one full text. We were unable to locate one full text. Introduction Rationale Clinical reasoning (CR) is a critical skill for physicians.1 Previous research drawing on cognitive psychology has set out to describe how CR works.1 2 It is commonly conceptualised through dual-process theory, which differentiates between a fast, intuitive process (type 1) and a slower, analytical process (type 2).1 2 Cognitive and emotional biases can affect CR and impact patient care.137 Although enhancing the quality of CR is crucial, few interventions have proved effective.13 4 811 Debiasing strategies have shown limited effectiveness.91214 Forcing physicians to engage in analytical reasoning can be useful; however, it may lack feasibility, as intuitive reasoning, commonly used by experts, is more cognitively efficient and capable of incorporating information that solely analytical approaches may overlook.9 10 12 14 15 The most credible strategy to date involves increasing physicians’ knowledge base, but this may not always be feasible with the ever-increasing amount of knowledge to learn.9 15 One potential novel approach to improving CR is to leverage the key role that emotions play in reasoning and decision-making.21618 Emotions influence how working memory functions and whether or not individuals recall events and knowledge; they modulate cognitive load and can improve or disrupt reasoning.23 8 11 16 1926 Emotions could therefore have either a positive or detrimental impact on CR. We hypothesised that the way in which physicians manage their emotions may be pivotal in determining whether these emotions ultimately help or hinder their CR. Could improving physicians’ emotional competence (EC), that is, their ability to effectively identify, understand, use, regulate and express their own emotions (intra-personal EC) or the emotions of others (inter-personal EC),1624 2729 enhance the quality of their CR? To help answer this question, we set out to map and describe the existing literature on the impact of EC on CR in a scoping review. Objectives The primary objective of this scoping review was to summarise current knowledge on the impact of EC on CR among physicians and medical students, both in real and virtual contexts. We also aimed to describe (1) the type and scope of available literature, (2) the different methods used to examine the relationship between EC and CR and (3) the trend of publication numbers over time. Methods The following section is presented according to the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Manual for Evidence Synthesis30 and the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Scoping Review (PRISMA-ScR) checklist.31 Protocol and registration The protocol was registered on the Open Science Framework (OSF) platform (https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/GM7YD) and published.15 Eligibility criteria Table 1 provides an overview of our inclusion and exclusion criteria, which we discussed in further detail in the article reporting our protocol.15 As permitted in scoping reviews, we modified one exclusion criterion, that is, the context of research.32 While reviewing retrieved abstracts, we identified several relevant articles that were based on clinical vignettes rather than real, simulated or virtual patients. As the literature supports the use of clinical vignettes to assess CR,33 34 we decided to remove this exclusion criterion. We also added two exclusion criteria to clarify our selection process: protocol articles were excluded, as well as articles only exploring the impact of EC on instrument handling during surgical procedures. Table 1Inclusion and exclusion criteria.Inclusion criteriaExclusion criteriaParticipantsPhysiciansMedical studentsResidentsArticles including physicians and other healthcare professionals if results were pooled across professional groups with no subgroup dataConceptEC as described in Mikolaczak’s framework that includes five components: emotion identification, regulation, expression, use and understanding.CR according to the categorisation of Young et al141: reasoning skills, performance, process, outcome of reasoning, context and goals of reasoning.Impact of emotions on well-being Impact of emotions on students’ academic success, independently of CRImpact of psychiatric disorders on CRArticles only considering the impact of EC on instrument-handling skills during surgical procedures.ContextAll contexts, including clinical vignettesNo limitations on geographic location or publication dates/Type of resourcesPrimary and secondary research articles in French and EnglishNarrative reviewsExpert opinionCommentaries and editorialsProtocolsCR, clinical reasoning; EC, emotional competence. Inclusion and exclusion criteria. CR, clinical reasoning; EC, emotional competence. In accordance with the protocol, we included search terms referring both to EC as an overarching construct and to each of the five components described by Mikolajczak et al. The related framework distinguishes five emotional skills (understanding, expression, regulation, identification and use of emotions), both intrapersonal and interpersonal, each comprising three levels: (1) the individual’s knowledge of emotional processes, (2) their ability to apply this knowledge in a given situation and (3) their natural propensity to behave in accordance with this knowledge.2729 Although the terms ‘emotional intelligence’ and ‘emotional competence’ are often used interchangeably in the literature, EC more specifically refers to the latter two levels, whereas emotional intelligence refers to all three levels.2729 Gut feeling and empathy were considered, as they include several core EC. Empathy encompasses the identification, understanding and use of interpersonal emotions.35 36 Gut feeling is defined as the ability to identify, use and understand one’s own emotions (and to a lesser extent, the emotions of the patient), often triggered by subtle or non-specific clinical cues, that generate a sense of alarm or reassurance about a patient’s prognosis.37 38 Information sources Three bibliographic databases were identified for the literature search: MEDLINE (via Ovid), Psychinfo and Scopus (via Elsevier). However, Scopus generated numerous irrelevant publications. Scopus was therefore replaced by Embase, which is more specific to the medical field and entails record types more specific to our eligibility criteria.39 Additional references were hand-searched in the bibliography of selected articles. The grey literature was explored through Open Grey. All databases were explored from their creation date to the 31 December 2024. The literature was first explored on 3 March 2023 and a re-run phase was performed on 7 January 2025. Search strategy The full electronic search strategy for Medline can be found in the online supplemental file 2. Selection of sources of evidence Articles were imported into the Covidence software (Covidence systematic review software, Veritas Health Innovation, Melbourne, Australia), and duplicates were removed. Title, abstract and full-text screening of the entire database were performed independently by LJ and AS based on eligibility criteria. In cases of conflict, consensus was sought between reviewers. A third reviewer (VD) resolved the remaining conflicts. If the exact content of the article could not be fully understood, it was included for full-text review. One article could not be retrieved.40 Agreement between reviewers was tested using the first 25 articles during the title and abstract selection phase. A Cohen’s kappa coefficient of 0.92 was found. To test the robustness of this result and eliminate the risk of a result obtained by chance, we confirmed this level of agreement on the next 25 articles (0.90). Data charting and data items Data were extracted using an Excel form, which was pre-tested by the two reviewers during a pilot phase carried out on the first 10 articles. Based on JBI guidelines for scoping reviews, each reviewer analysed five articles, which were checked by the other reviewer.30 Discrepancies were discussed until consensus was reached and the extraction form was refined (see online supplemental file 3). For the remaining articles, each reviewer analysed half of the articles and cross-checked the other half. No critical appraisal of sources of evidence was conducted. Synthesis of the results To facilitate data analysis, we grouped individual EC and CR outcomes of retrieved studies into categories. To describe the scope of the available literature, we computed frequencies of study designs, population, context, EC outcomes examined, CR outcomes examined and the measurement instruments used for EC and CR. We also cross-tabulated the EC and CR outcomes to help identify gaps in the literature. To examine trends over time of interest in this topic, we displayed the number of publications by year in a diagram. We then synthesised results narratively to describe the main findings from the identified publications. Results Selection of sources of evidence Figure 1 presents the PRISMA-ScR flow chart. PRISMA-ScR flow chart. PRISMA-ScR, Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Scoping Review. Characteristics and results of individual sources of evidence Due to the large number of retrieved articles, characteristics (country, date, study design, population, objectives, measurement instruments and identified categories of EC and CR) and main outcome data of individual studies according to review objectives are presented in the online supplemental file 4. Synthesis of the results Type of available literature Table 2 presents the type of available literature. Of the 98 included articles, 10 were literature reviews. Of the 88 primary sources, 70 reported non-interventional studies. Most articles examined CR in contact with real patients. The most commonly examined CR outcome was clinical performance outside the operating room. In terms of EC, 13 used global scores of EC, while 59 assessed specific emotion regulation strategies. 27 articles explored empathy, and 20 assessed gut feeling. The vast majority of studies have been conducted in Western cultures. Table 2Types of available literature.Number of articlesStudy designsNon-interventional study70 (71.5 %)Interventional study—non randomised9 (9.2 %)Interventional study—randomised7 (7.1 %)Systematic review9 (9.2 %)Scoping review1 (1 %)Mixed method (non-interventional and interventional)2 (2 %)PopulationPhysician (specialist)32 (32.7 %)Physician (specialist resident)24 (24.5 %)Physician (general practitioner)24 (24.5%)Physician (general practitioner resident)5 (5.1 %)Physician (not specified)9 (9.2%)Physician (resident, not specified)2 (2%)Medical students22 (22.4%)Context in which the impact of EC on CR has been studiedFace-to-face—Real patients64 (65.3 %)Face-to-face—Simulated patients11 (11.2 %)Face-to-face—Mannikin7 (7.1%)Clinical vignettes7 (7.1 %)Virtual patients2 (2 %)CR-related categoryClinical performance outside operating room*48 (49%)Clinical performance in the operating room†14 (14.3%)CR learning17 (17.4 %)Uncertainty management23 (23.5 %)Intuitive reasoning19 (19.3 %)Prescriptions8 (8.2 %)Patient’s related outcomes (including medical errors)33 (33.7 %)EC-related categoryEmotional regulation strategies59 (60.2 %)Empathy‡27 (27.6 %)Gut feeling§20 (20.4 %)Global scores of EC13 (13.3 %)Emotional identification3 (3%)Geographical areaEurope (including UK)46 (47%)North America40 (41%)Asia6 (6%)Oceania (Australia only)5 (5%)Multinational1 (1%)*History taking, physical examination, diagnostic, prognostic, therapeutic reasoning and decision making outside of the operating room. †Surgical planning, stages of surgery, diagnostic, therapeutic and prognostic reasoning during surgery and intraoperative decision-making.‡Identifying, understanding and using the emotions of others.§Identifying, understanding and using emotions in relation to patient prognosis.CR, clinical reasoning; EC, emotional competence. Types of available literature. History taking, physical examination, diagnostic, prognostic, therapeutic reasoning and decision making outside of the operating room. Surgical planning, stages of surgery, diagnostic, therapeutic and prognostic reasoning during surgery and intraoperative decision-making. Identifying, understanding and using the emotions of others. Identifying, understanding and using emotions in relation to patient prognosis. CR, clinical reasoning; EC, emotional competence. Evolution of publications over time Figure 2 shows how interest in the subject has increased over time, particularly since the 2000s. Evolution of publications over time. Measurement instruments for EC and CR Table 3 presents the different instruments used to measure CR and EC retrieved in primary sources. The most commonly used methods to assess CR were external observations, interviews, and focus groups. EC, on the other hand, was primarily evaluated using self-administered questionnaires, mostly based on Likert-scale items. A compiled record of the standardised measurement scales used across the included articles is available in the online supplemental file 5. Table 3Measurement instruments for CR and EC in primary sources.CRMeasurement instrument for CRNumber of articlesSituational assessments with external evaluation (OSCEs, structured exams, etc.)20Semi-structured interviews, focus groups32Self-reported questionnaires22Data extracted from medical records8External evaluation by supervisors during ward rounds in daily practice4Think-aloud methods2Video or audio recording with retrospective analysis2External evaluation by patients1Case resolution using written vignettes5Measure of time needed to complete a clinical vignette1Written case reports (participants write case reports, which are then evaluated for the presence or absence of specific themes)1Objective measures of patient outcomes through questionnaires or additional diagnostic test results5ECMeasurement instrument for ECNumber of articlesSelf-reported questionnaires52Semi-structured interviews and focus groups35Physiological measures (heart rate, heart rate variability, skin conductance, salivary or hair cortisol levels)5External evaluation by peers or patients4Data extracted from registries or health records (the presence or absence of gut feeling during encounter)1Video or audio recording with retrospective analysis1Written case reports (participants write case reports, which are then evaluated for the presence or absence of specific themes)1Objective measurement of facial expressions using software1Implementation of a checklist forcing the use of emotion identification1Think-aloud methods1CR, clinical reasoning; EC, emotional competence; OSCE, Objective Structured Clinical Examination. Measurement instruments for CR and EC in primary sources. CR, clinical reasoning; EC, emotional competence; OSCE, Objective Structured Clinical Examination. Summary of knowledge on the impact of emotional competence on clinical reasoning The synthesis of results is structured into two main sections. The first outlines the relationships identified in the literature between the categories of CR and those of EC. For each CR category, the corresponding EC categories explored in relation to it are presented, allowing for the identification of potential gaps in the literature. The second section examines factors discussed in the literature that may moderate the interactions between CR and EC, providing a basis for generating new hypotheses for future research. Section 1: Description of the links between categories of CR and EC Table 4 describes the links established between conceptual categories of EC and CR with the type of methodology used and references. Table 4Links established between conceptual categories of EC and CR with the type of methodology used and references.CategoryClinical performance outside of operating roomClinical performance inside the operating roomDevelopment of CRIntuitive reasoningUncertainty managementPrescriptionsPatients’ outcomesHistory taking and clinical examinationDiagnostic, therapeutic, prognostic performanceMedical knowledgeEmotion regulationNI50 86SR25 79 81MM80I/non-RCT72 73 82 83I/RCT74 84NI557578 85SR25 89I/non-RCT90 91I/RCT92 93NI9498NI117SR25 113NI5985 96 114118SR25NI117122SR79 81I/RCT60 74 133 135I/non-RCT72 73 125MM49 80NI5575 77 94 103 104 106 116 126132 134Emotion identificationNI59NI59EmpathySR41 53 61, I/RCT60, I/non-RCT54NI4450 5557 59 62SR61NI45 46 55 58 62NI4446NI63 107 108 117NI59 117NI117 122 123SR53 61I/RCT60 133NI106124 128130Gut feelingSR64, NI3763 6571SR25 64NI3738 58 63 6569 71 107SR25 64NI3738 58 6769 71 108NI108NI70 71 112Global scores of ECNI50SR61MM49NI47 51 52SR41NI42 43 47 48ScR87SR61NI88SR61CR, clinical reasoning; EC, emotional competence; I/non-RCT, interventional study, non-RCT; I/RCT, interventional study, RCT; MM, mixed method; NI, non-interventional; ScR, scoping review; SR, systematic review. Links established between conceptual categories of EC and CR with the type of methodology used and references. CR, clinical reasoning; EC, emotional competence; I/non-RCT, interventional study, non-RCT; I/RCT, interventional study, RCT; MM, mixed method; NI, non-interventional; ScR, scoping review; SR, systematic review. Clinical performance Because the definition of clinical performance varied across contexts, we distinguished between performance in the operating room and outside of it (see table 2). Outside the operating room As presented in table 2, based on the different outcomes found in the articles, we defined clinical performance outside of the operating room as the quality of history taking and clinical examination, quality of medical knowledge and diagnostic and/or therapeutic quality, as well as prognostic performance. The effect of EC as measured by global scores remains unclear. On the one hand, higher scores of EC were positively associated with the Medical Knowledge component of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) examination.4143 In particular, two specific components of global EC scores—emotionality and self-control—were positively associated with the acquisition of knowledge and critical thinking, respectively.42 On the other hand, other studies showed no added value of EC (global scores or empathy) over medical knowledge.4448 Global scores of EC were also examined in relation to diagnostic and therapeutic performance. In life-threatening situations, residents showing a high level of EC had higher diagnostic and therapeutic performance than those with a lower level of EC.49 Outside of an emergency context, the evidence of a relationship between global EC scores and diagnostic or therapeutic performance is inconsistent.4347 5052 Empathy, based on evidence predominantly drawn from studies involving student samples, did not appear to be a predictive factor for the quality of clinical examination or diagnostic and therapeutic performance.414446 50 53 54 An association was observed only when evaluation criteria incorporated interpersonal interactions with patients or the medical team alongside the technical aspects of the examination.4553 5558 However, it was associated with better self-perceived quality of history taking and a better understanding of patients’ symptoms.555962 Many studies found that physicians’ gut feelings had a high predictive value for reaching the correct diagnosis (detection of severe illnesses, suicidal risk or child abuse)376369 and determining prognosis, with gut feelings sometimes outperforming clinical scores in predicting patient mortality/morbidity.70 71 Emotional regulation was linked to faster and higher-quality diagnoses, more appropriate therapeutic actions, an improved sense of self-efficacy and an increased perception of clinical performance as rated by peers in emergency situations.497278 In non-emergency settings, emotion regulation has been associated with a greater sense of self-efficacy in diagnostic and therapeutic tasks55 79 80; however, its actual impact on performance remains uncertain.2550 74 8185 Evidence showed, nevertheless, that when medical students regulated their emotions by distancing themselves from their emotions (emotional avoidance), their anxiety increased and their performance decreased as measured on an Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE), a standardised assessment used to evaluate clinical examination and communication skills in healthcare training.86 Inside the operating room Based on the different outcomes found in the literature, clinical performance in the operating room was defined as surgical planning, stages of surgery, diagnostic, therapeutic and prognostic reasoning during surgery as well as intraoperative decision-making. We found no direct evidence that global scores of EC directly and positively influence non-technical skills training in surgeons.87 88 However, we identified clear evidence of their effectiveness in enhancing decision-making.61 The role of EC in surgical training has been discussed and deemed sufficiently relevant to warrant greater integration into training programmes.61 87 88 Programmes to train physicians in emotional regulation showed positive effects on perceived stress, confidence and the ability to manage pressure.8993 Although some studies reported improvements in surgical decision-making and non-technical skills,89 90 92 93 others found no significant impact on performance.91 The multifactorial nature of the evaluation scales, which included communication and leadership dimensions, complicates efforts to isolate the specific influence of emotion regulation on intraoperative CR. Functional and dysfunctional emotion regulation strategies during surgery were reported in the literature. Functional strategies that promote adaptive behaviour and effective decision-making16 include anticipation, relaxation techniques, positive self-talk, cognitive reframing, seeking help and team communication.259498 Dysfunctional strategies that reduce emotional discomfort in the short term while impairing the quality of decision-making16 include silence and expressions of stress through shouting.259498 Development of clinical reasoning in learners A positive effect of empathy on the quality of history taking and clinical examination learning has been suggested, but from a highly heterogeneous body of literature, preventing any clear conclusion.53 62 Global EC scores have been explored as predictors of CR development in residents. One study found that high EC at the start of residency did not predict better clinical performance by year’s end, whereas another showed that high EC at the end of the year correlated with stronger performance.48 99 Thus, a low initial EC does not preclude progress, provided residents are exposed to meaningful clinical and life experiences.49 99 These experiences influence both EC and clinical performance, with clinical exposure shown to be a stronger predictor than EC scores.84 Poor stress regulation abilities have been inversely correlated with the ability to learn new skills, establish a differential diagnosis and determine treatment in students facing emergency situations—especially when their clinical experience is limited.49 75 78 83 As a result, the ability to regulate perceived stress was lower in medical students and newly qualified physicians compared with more experienced practitioners.78 83 However, the evidence linking emotional regulation and the development of CR is scant outside of emergency situations.62 100 Studies based on reaching a diagnosis in clinical vignettes showed that students with stronger emotional regulation reported more positive emotions, but this did not necessarily improve diagnostic performance learning.62 100 101 Interestingly, mild stress during diagnostic tasks was linked to better performance.101 Emotional regulation also contributed to managing the negative emotions caused by diagnostic errors, with rationalisation being the primary strategy supporting improvements in CR.102 103 One study sought to support students’ learning of diagnostic accuracy by implementing an analytical reasoning checklist that included an item on identifying one’s emotions.82 The checklist proved effective, but the study design did not allow the specific effect of this component of the checklist to be isolated from the rest of the checklist.82 Qualitative findings suggest that supervising students’ CR helped tutors to identify and use their emotions, particularly in recognising the role of gut feeling and becoming more aware of their own emotional responses in their own CR.104 105 The supervision process enhanced supervisors’ self-monitoring of their psychological needs and supported the development of their metacognitive skills,106 although emotional aspects were still rarely discussed during supervision.63 105 One study found that when students had better emotional regulation, they were more receptive to feedback about their CR, which could potentially improve their CR in the future.104 Intuitive reasoning Intuitive reasoning has been mostly studied through the lens of gut feeling. Many studies have described gut feelings and their predictive value in a variety of clinical situations (see above).2537 38 58 6369 71 107 It can directly inform a diagnostic, therapeutic or prognostic orientation or trigger analytical reasoning aimed at rationalising it.25 65 69 110 111 The use of gut feeling increases with time pressure, uncertainty level and empathy.64 69 109 110 112 Uncertainty management Tolerance of uncertainty mainly depends on emotional regulation, which enables physicians to work with provisional, intuition-based, gut-feeling-guided hypotheses and maintain cognitive flexibility in dynamic or ambiguous clinical situations.2537 38 58 64 6769 71 85 109 When uncertainty becomes unmanageable, it can trigger anxiety related to fear of litigation, loss of control in the event of an error or difficulty coping with unpredictable clinical outcomes.59 85 113 114 116 Physicians thus attempt to down-regulate this emotion by using strategies such as discussing uncertainty with colleagues (mostly novice physicians) or patients (mostly experienced physicians) or searching for practical solutions (time delay, therapeutic testing, safety netting and reducing uncertainty through testing).113 115 Some of these strategies can contribute to overtreatment and the overprescription of diagnostic testing.116118 Prescriptions Physicians’ ability to regulate negative emotions, such as anxiety or irritation in response to patient demands, may contribute to reducing inappropriate prescriptions including of antibiotics, antidepressants, opioids and unnecessary diagnostic tests.25117121 No significant correlation was found between physician empathy and the volume or quality of prescriptions.117 122 123 Patients’ outcomes When patients were treated by physicians with higher global scores of EC or empathy, they were more satisfied with care and displayed fewer symptoms of anxiety and depression.61 124 A gut feeling is a valuable predictor of patient outcomes and can also guide certain therapeutic decisions, such as whether or not to perform a caesarean section during labour.70 71 112 Emotional regulation and empathy were associated with increased physicians’ sense of self-efficacy in patient management, especially in emergency situations.4955 7275 79 80 104 116 125 Self-efficacy was itself associated with significantly fewer adverse effects in patients.126 They were also associated with a better understanding of patients’ symptoms and needs.5360 80 106 127129 However, this did not translate into clinical improvement for the patient, such as pain reduction or improved function of an operated limb.130 Limited evidence was found concerning the direct impact of emotional regulation on patient outcomes. Obstetricians exhibiting greater emotional regulation (eg, lower anxiety and more reflective coping) were associated on one hand with fewer operative deliveries, a trend towards more spontaneous births and on the other hand with increased risks of postpartum haemorrhage and chorioamnionitis.131 132 Poor stress regulation was also associated with an increased risk of intraoperative adverse events.94 Emotional regulation based on mindfulness did not show any conclusive effect on medical errors.81 103 133 134 The role of emotion avoidance has been examined in connection with patient outcomes, and its role remains ambiguous. It may help manage life-threatening emergencies by limiting the influence of caregivers’ emotions, though this remains unproven. However, in ethically complex therapeutic decisions, it may hinder judgement and potentially harm patients.77 135 Section 2: Factors moderating the interaction between EC and CR Various factors may modulate the impact of EC on CR: clinical and life experience, work context, burnout and sense of self-efficacy. Clinical and life experience were mentioned as factors promoting both the development of EC and CR in residents.48 49 75 83 99 A correlation between the acquisition of high levels of CE and CR performance was identified after 1 year of practice.48 99 Two studies examined the role of burnout as a moderating factor between EC and clinical performance. Although a lower level of EC was linked to a lower level of burnout risk,52 133 burnout was not associated with a lower level of clinical performance.52 133 Physicians with a stronger sense of self-efficacy in managing clinical cases tend to have higher EC.497375 77 126 Self-efficacy is also associated with a lower risk of adverse patient outcomes.126 The work context appears to be a major influencing factor in the relationship between EC and CR. We identified three distinct contexts, each marked by specific stressors that directly affect cognitive load and modulate the relationship between EC and CR.78 83 Emergency and intraoperative settings are associated with acute stress stemming from the patient’s condition, leading to high cognitive demands.49 75 78 94 95 97 98 The surgical environment adds interpersonal stress due to its hierarchical structure and potential for conflict.135 In contrast, non-urgent, non-surgical contexts are characterised by chronic stress, mostly arising from interactions with patients and teams, as well as from the uncertainty surrounding diagnosis, treatment and prognosis.5480 85 113 114 118121 127 In medical emergencies, the literature is consistent and robust, showing a positive impact of EC on diagnostic and therapeutic performance.497275 131 132 Similarly, in intraoperative contexts, EC appears to enhance CR performance, although many CR outcome measures include leadership components, limiting our ability to isolate the specific effect of EC.878998 Outside of emergency and surgical contexts, the literature is abundant but methodologically heterogeneous, precluding firm conclusions about the role of EC in CR.2537 38 54 5860 63 Discussion Summary of evidence The impact of EC on CR has attracted particular interest over the past decade, mostly in Western countries. The available literature is primarily composed of non-interventional studies, relying on semi-structured interviews, self-reported questionnaires or external evaluations. Most of these studies have examined the effects of emotional regulation, empathy and global EC scores on clinical performance. The evidence suggests that EC positively affects multiple dimensions of CR. The most consistent evidence supports the role of high global EC scores and emotion regulation abilities in life-threatening emergencies, where they clearly enhance both diagnostic and therapeutic CR, as well as CR development. A substantial and consistent body of literature also supports the role of gut feeling and emotional regulation in managing uncertainty, prognostic reasoning and intuitive decision-making. A positive impact of emotional regulation and global scores of EC on intraoperative CR were also reported. Emotional regulation may also positively influence prescribing practices, although evidence remains limited. We identified three major gaps in the literature. The first one concerns the effects of EC on diagnostic and therapeutic CR and CR learning in non-urgent, non-surgical settings, environments in which most physicians practice. The evidence in those contexts remains fragmented and uncertain. The second one concerns the effects of EC on patient outcomes. There is still little evidence showing that EC could enhance healthcare quality for patients. We nonetheless found some encouraging findings, such as a reduction in patients’ anxiety and depressive symptoms. The third gap in the literature concerns the lack of data from non-Western countries. The cultural context strongly shapes CE by influencing, namely, how emotions are expressed, perceived, interpreted and regulated, with potential direct implications for CR.16 Our findings also point to additional directions for future research. In particular, analysis of the factors influencing the interaction between EC and CR revealed three major areas of interest. The first is about the correlation observed between CR development and a high level of CE. Correlation is not causation, and further studies are needed to examine whether there is a causal link between EC and CR development. The second focuses on the identified association between a high level of EC, increased self-efficacy and reduced patients’ adverse events. These findings suggest that high EC may enhance self-efficacy, which in turn could reduce clinical risks. However, again, a causal relationship has yet to be established. The third highlighted research pathway arises from the recognition that work context is a major moderating factor since contexts differ in terms of the nature of stress involved. This could explain the observed difference between well-documented effects of EC on diagnostic and therapeutic CR in life-threatening, urgent contexts and their poorly described effects on the same dimensions of CR in non-surgical and non-emergency contexts. This gives rise to three hypotheses. The first hypothesis supports the fact that the link between EC and CR is moderated by the level of acute stress. The higher the level of acute stress, the greater the effect of EC on CR, likely by helping individuals to manage their cognitive load. This is congruent with the literature on cognitive load.161921 136 137 The second hypothesis is of a methodological nature: it may be easier to identify the impact of EC on CR in highly demanding contexts involving critical medical conditions. In emergency settings, clinical priorities are more explicitly defined, particularly the preservation of vital functions.137 138 Therapeutic interventions are typically guided by well-established decision algorithms, which facilitate the assessment of the appropriateness of clinical decisions.137 138 Furthermore, diagnostic reasoning is primarily focused on identifying the immediate causes of an acute event, thereby narrowing the range of possible hypotheses and enabling a more rapid clinical approach.137 138 This contrasts with non-urgent clinical settings, where decisions unfold over a longer period of time and notions of accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment are more ambiguous.139 As a result, EC may influence CR in non-surgical and non-urgent practice to the same extent as in emergency settings, but current assessment tools may lack the sensitivity or precision required to capture this effect. The third hypothesis is based on the assumption that the impact of intra- and interpersonal EC on CR may actually differ. Intrapersonal EC (EC in relation to one’s own emotions) may play a more critical role in ensuring diagnostic and therapeutic accuracy under acute stress related to diagnostic and therapeutic decision-making. In contrast, interpersonal EC (EC related to the emotions of others) may be more relevant in managing interactions with patients, families and the healthcare team. While they may have less direct influence on diagnostic and therapeutic quality outside of acute stress situations, they likely contribute more to coping with the chronic stress associated with ongoing interpersonal dynamics, such as those encountered in non-urgent outpatient care. Further research should focus on the effects of EC on diagnostic and therapeutic CR as well as its development in non-urgent care settings. The challenge is to define what is considered sound CR in these contexts and to develop the right instruments to assess diagnostic and therapeutic quality. Limitations The identified literature displays significant heterogeneity, particularly regarding the evaluation criteria used in studies. Some used concepts such as ‘professionalism’, ‘self-efficacy’ or ‘psychological characteristics’ that appeared ill-defined in some articles, rendering data interpretation and synthesis challenging. Many studies also relied on self-administered questionnaires, which introduce bias in the assessment of one’s own abilities, whether they relate to EC or CR.140 Heterogeneity in study samples constitutes an important limitation of the current evidence base, as studies variably include students, residents and/or practicing physicians, either examined separately or aggregated, thereby limiting fine-grained comparisons across those populations; however, the overall patterns of association between EC and CR remained broadly consistent across these groups, and we explicitly indicated when findings relied predominantly on student samples to avoid overgeneralisation. Some relevant publications may not have been identified, particularly those related to patient outcomes, as our search strategy may have overlooked studies focused on specific clinical conditions or outcomes. Including such a wide range of pathology-specific endpoints would have significantly broadened the scope of the review beyond its intended focus. Conclusions This scoping review highlights that the literature on the impact of EC on CR is heterogeneous and largely based on non-interventional methods mainly exploring the effect of emotional regulation, empathy and global EC scores on clinical performance. ECs appear to enhance CR particularly in life-threatening emergency management, where they likely help in managing stress and cognitive load, in uncertainty management and in intuitive reasoning. Evidence for these outcomes is relatively consistent. However, their impact in non-urgent care remains unclear, possibly due to methodological limitations. Further research is needed to clarify the role of EC on CR in those contexts by using outcomes able to address their specific complexity. Supplementary material