Running Assessed Maximal Oxygen Uptake Increases with Participant Classification Framework Tier in Overall Cross-Country Skiing Performance: A Systematic Review with Meta-regressions Authors: Steven E Morton, Laura J Forrest, Mykolas Kavaliauskas, Chris Easton, Kurt Rumley, Tom W Macpherson Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundPrevious research in cross-country skiing (XCS), frequently emphasises the importance of maximal oxygen uptake (VO2Max) and individual studies have correlated XCS performance with VO2Max. However, meta-regression analyses with multiple studies have not previously been conducted.ObjectiveThe aim of this study was to conduct meta-analyses of VO2Max data, in relation to XCS performance using retrospective participant classification framework (PCF) scoring.MethodsElectronic databases were searched, up to November 2024, using Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. Data were extracted from the included studies (n = 78), with participant groups separated by exercise mode and sex, and retrospectively scored using the PCF. Random effects meta-regressions with sub-grouping were conducted, to calculate pooled mean values by PCF tier, standard error, and 95% confidence intervals.ResultsSufficient data were only present for inferential analysis of running based protocols. VO2Max values generally increased with PCF tier in males and females for both absolute (Male: R2 = 0.80; Female: R2 = 0.66) and relative to total body mass values (Male: R2 = 0.41; Female: R2 = 0.69).ConclusionPerformance prediction is multifaceted, particularly within XCS where numerous physiological parameters are compounded by multiple skiing techniques. These findings emphasise the importance of VO2Max in XCS to develop performance across the participation spectrum. Even within ‘elite’ athletes, this remains true, possibly reflecting a lack of homogeneity of VO2Max values within this sub-population. The values presented within this study may represent useful benchmark values for talent identification and performance development purposes. Key Points The performance classification framework is a useful tool to address incompatibilities in prior research. The performance classification framework is a useful tool to address incompatibilities in prior research. Maximal oxygen uptake (VO2Max) increases across all cross-country skiing performance tiers, reinforcing the role of aerobic capacity as a critical determinant of success in XCS. Maximal oxygen uptake (VO2Max) increases across all cross-country skiing performance tiers, reinforcing the role of aerobic capacity as a critical determinant of success in XCS. A lack of skiing-specific data and inconsistencies in defining and measuring VO2Max highlight the need for future research to refine these metrics in the context of sport-specific techniques. A lack of skiing-specific data and inconsistencies in defining and measuring VO2Max highlight the need for future research to refine these metrics in the context of sport-specific techniques. Introduction Cross-country skiing (XCS), also known as Nordic skiing, requires individuals to complete hilly and undulating courses as fast as possible. Sprint event distances ranging between 1.2 and 1.8 km, distance events up to 50 km and classic long distance events > 50 km [1, 2]. Even during sprint events, multiple high intensity heats (approximately three minutes) with limited recovery time (as little as 15 min), demands a high level of endurance, amongst several other determining factors [3–6]. The key physiological factors influencing endurance performance have been broadly categorised into three components: ‘performance oxygen uptake’ (O2)/aerobic (including maximal oxygen uptake (O2Max)), ‘performance O2 deficit’/anaerobic, and gross mechanical efficiency [7]. Importantly, fractional utilisation of O2Max at distinct physiological points, such as the so called ‘lactate thresholds’, across different skiing techniques, and, total buffering capacity, are also important contributory components of endurance performance that are outside the focus of this review [7]. For in depth deconstruction of the broader physiological components of XCS performance, we direct readers to several excellent previously published articles [3–6]. Among these factors, O2Max is frequently studied and reported in XCS research, with athletes achieving some of the highest O2Max values of any sport [1, 8–10]; and is often considered among performance predictive variables [11–15]. It is therefore a measure highly valued by athletes and coaches. This apparent predictive quality somewhat contrasts to other endurance sports, such as distance running, whereby whilst O2Max is important, and does separate ‘good’ from ‘elite’ runners [16–20], the performance predictive quality of O2Max is reduced when a group of homogenous elite runners are considered [18, 21]. Thus, other physiological, biomechanical, psychological and/or other external factors (e.g. race pacing tactics) become more distinguishing factors where O2Max homogeneity exists [16, 20]. Given that XCS is also an endurance-based sport, it is interesting that O2Max is reportedly so differentiating for performance outcomes, seemingly even at the highest levels of performance [22]. Despite the volume of O2Max data, meta-analyses and meta-regressions of O2Max, in relation to XCS performance, have proven elusive, likely owing to various methodological challenges and incongruities [1, 3, 9]. As XCS research commonly utilises relatively small sample sizes, inferences from individual studies may be restricted by such limitations. Consequently, there is justification to collate data across studies, in order to evaluate findings across a range of performance standards with increased population sizes. Furthermore, understanding of current benchmarks for physiological variables across a range of performance levels, may provide valuable insights into the talent identification and development of XCS athletes. The recently published Participant Classification Framework (PCF) [23] presents potential opportunities to overcome some of the reported challenges concerning athletic performance definitions across differing studies. Therefore, the purpose of this review was to conduct meta-regressions of O2Max data, in relation to XCS performance standards using retrospective PCF scoring. Methods Systematic Search Methodology A systematic search of research literature was conducted up to November 2024, using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) statement as guidance [24]. Five academic electronic databases were searched (SPORTDiscus, PubMed, Web of Science, MEDLINE, and Scopus), using key words. Search terms encompassed appropriate ski sports combined with terms for physiological testing and performance prediction. Search terms were combined using Boolean logic, specifically keywords were combined within terms using the ‘OR’ operator and the three search terms were combined using the ‘AND’ operator. The final search phrase was "cross-country skiing" OR “cross-country skier” OR “Nordic combined skiing” OR “Nordic combined skier” OR “winter biathlon” OR “winter biathlete” AND “O2 Max” OR “O2 Peak” OR “maximal aerobic*” OR “maximal oxygen*” OR endurance* OR “graded exercise test” OR “maximal anaerobic*” OR “power” OR “critical power” OR “W’” OR “strength” OR “dynamomet*” OR “maximal accumulated oxygen deficit” OR “haematocrit” OR “haemoglobin” OR “lactate” OR “blood acid base” OR “aerobic fitness” OR “anaerobic threshold” OR “W Prime” OR “max* O2” OR “cardio* fitness” OR “body composition” OR “body-fat*” OR “maximal-speed*” OR “maximal-velocity” OR “maximal-intens*” OR “maximal-effort*” OR “time to exhaustion” OR “time-trial” OR “3 min all-out” AND predict* OR perform*. Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria Studies were included if reported participants were healthy and fully abled bodied cross-country skiers, competing in sprint and/or distance events for recognised Winter Olympic events and aged between 16 and 40 years old. Studies also needed to report a O2Max variable, either in relative (mL.kg.min−1) or absolute terms (mL.min−1) from a graded exercise test, sufficient information to classify participants according to the PCF and statistical measures of central tendencies. The following exclusion criteria hierarchy was used to select articles for review and analysis: Full article unavailable or not in English language. Full article unavailable or not in English language. Non-empirical study (i.e. review, case-study, survey, opinion piece). Non-empirical study (i.e. review, case-study, survey, opinion piece). Participants outside the target age demographic (< 16 or > 40 years). Participants outside the target age demographic (< 16 or > 40 years). Investigated a specialist population (e.g. para-athletes, return from injury or illness, mental health). Investigated a specialist population (e.g. para-athletes, return from injury or illness, mental health). Lacked a required O2Max variable. Lacked a required O2Max variable. Lacked sufficient details for PCF assessment. Lacked sufficient details for PCF assessment. Did not separate data (e.g. males from females or winter biathletes from XCS athletes). Did not separate data (e.g. males from females or winter biathletes from XCS athletes). Lacked other necessary statistical detail (e.g. sample size). Lacked other necessary statistical detail (e.g. sample size). Utilised a time-trial based assessment method for O2Max. Utilised a time-trial based assessment method for O2Max. Did not include competitors in typical Winter Olympic/World Cup XCS events. Did not include competitors in typical Winter Olympic/World Cup XCS events. Duplicate participant data already included from other studies. Duplicate participant data already included from other studies. Study Screening and Selection Following literature searching, studies were initially screened by titles and abstracts for relevance by two authors (SM & TM), using the defined exclusion criteria. Consensus was reached by discussion, where disagreements occurred (n = 10, at the title and abstract level) (Fig. 1). Identified texts were accessed, in full, and screened a second time for inclusion. Studies identified for data extraction were assigned a PCF tier using the PCF flow-diagram (Fig. 2) by the same two authors. Again, consensus was reached following discussion for both study inclusion and PCF scoring, where disagreements occurred (inclusion: n = 5; PCF scoring: n = 4, at the full text level). Systematic review study screening process. PCF, Participant Classification Framework; O2Max, Maximal Oxygen Uptake Participant classification framework decision making flow diagram. FIS, International Skiing Federation; XCS, Cross-Country Skiing Performance Definitions In undertaking this review, specific information from the original framework [23] was adjusted for application to XCS (Table 1). Where International Skiing Federation (FIS) points were reported, these were checked against a FIS point threshold, calculated using the fourth FIS season point lists (2020/2021–2023/2024 seasons). The FIS point system is a snow sport specific metric used to rank overall on-snow performance over a calendar year [25]. Individuals were removed from calculations if they had competed in less than five events, due to adjustments made to their FIS points. Remaining athletes’ data were used to produce a combined FIS point average, before sorting all records in ascending order. The individual in 20th position for males and females was identified and their averaged FIS points recorded for each year. The four annual average FIS point values were then again averaged, producing a grand mean FIS point score for 20th position. The variance for each year to the grand mean was calculated and expressed as a percentage. This variance was averaged across the four years and then added to the grand mean. Finally, the resulting number was rounded up to the nearest whole number, to account for season-to-season variability and provide leniency in the calculation. This process was completed for the tier 4/3 boundary using the individual in 300th position, as per PCF recommendations (Table 2). Participants were considered tier 5 (‘World-Class’) if reported as previously finishing in the top 20 of a World Cup, Winter Olympic or World Championship race. Participants were considered tier 4 if they were described as competing internationally or for their national team, tier 3 if they were described as ‘national level’ athletes or descriptors to this effect, tier 2 if described as ‘developmental athletes’, ‘regional competitors’ or descriptors to this effect, and tier 1 if reported as ‘recreational’ or otherwise trained but not identifying as XCS specific athletes (Fig. 2). Table 1Recommended application of a participant classification framework for cross-country skiingTierClassification criteriaTier 5: World classOlympic/World Championship/Overall World Cup medallistWithin the top 20 of a recently published FIS point listCombined FIS point total below acknowledged value for 20th position (i.e. currently suggested as being < 25 for males and < 31 for females)Maximal/near maximal training, typically ~ 750–950 h/year (see Holmberg [1])Exceptional skill-level achievedOlympic/World Championship/Overall World Cup medallistTier 4: Elite/international levelCompeting at the international level (i.e. on a national team)Within the top 300 of a recently published FIS point listCombined FIS point total below acknowledged value for 300th position (i.e. currently suggested as being 25–70 for males and 31–111 for females)Maximal/near maximal training, typically ~ 750–950 h/year (see Holmberg [1])Highly proficient in skills requiredTier 3: Highly trained/national levelCompeting at a recognised national levelNational Collegiate Athletic Association Division I athletesCompleting structured and periodised training at ~ 80% typical age norms (see Karlsson et al. [26])Developing proficiency in skills required to perform sportTier 2: Trained/developmentalCompeting at a local/regional levelNational Collegiate Athletic Association Division II and III athletesRegular training ~ 3 times/week, with purpose to competeIdentify as a cross-country skierLimited skill developmentTier 1: Recreationally activeMeet World Health Organization minimum activity guidelines: Adults aged 18–64 years old completing at least 150 to 300 min moderate-intensity activity or 75–150 min of vigorous-intensity activity a week, plus muscle-strengthening activities 2 or more days a week (see Bull et al. [157])May participate in multiple sports/forms of activityTier 0: SedentaryDo not meet minimum activity guidelinesOccasional physical activity (e.g. walking to work, gardening or other domestic activities) Recommended application of a participant classification framework for cross-country skiing Table 2Calculations for PCF Tiers 3/4/5 FIS combined point thresholdsCombined FIS Points ( )GΔ≅ (%)XG + XG ΔThreshold (Combined FIS Points)MalesSeason 20–21 [20th]24.311.3Season 21–22 [20th]25.014.8Season 22–23 [20th]20.27.2Season 23–24 [20th]17.718.9Grand Mean (G)21.813.124.6 < 25Season 20–21 [300th]69.62.5Season 21–22 [300th]65.73.2Season 22–23 [300th]66.91.4Season 23–24 [300th]69.32.1Grand Mean (G)67.92.369.4 > 25 but < 70FemalesSeason 20–21 [20th]33.120.7Season 21–22 [20th]25.37.8Season 22–23 [20th]27.50.1Season 23–24 [20th]23.913.0Grand Mean (G)27.510.430.2 < 31Season 20–21 [300th]106.61.4Season 21–22 [300th]95.29.5Season 22–23 [300th]105.60.4Season 23–24 [300th]113.27.7Grand Mean (G)105.14.7110.1 > 31 but < 111FIS, International Skiing Federation; PCF, Participant Classification Framework; , Mean Average; G, Grand Mean Average; GΔ, Difference to Grand Mean. Combined FIS Points = (FISDist + FISSpr) ÷ 2 Calculations for PCF Tiers 3/4/5 FIS combined point thresholds Males Season 20–21 [20th] Females Season 20–21 [20th] FIS, International Skiing Federation; PCF, Participant Classification Framework; , Mean Average; G, Grand Mean Average; GΔ, Difference to Grand Mean. Combined FIS Points = (FISDist + FISSpr) ÷ 2 O2Max Inclusion Reported O2Max values were eligible for inclusion if reported as absolute values (L.min−1) or relative to whole body mass (mL.min−1.kg−1). Studies reporting O2Peak with supporting primary O2Max criteria (i.e., O2 plateau despite further increase in work) were considered to represent a mode specific O2Max and were therefore included. Intervention studies including multiple assessments of O2Max at different times, were combined using appropriate calculations, as described in the Cochrane guidelines, to avoid double counting [27]. Data Extraction and Statistical Analysis Data were extracted directly from article tables, text or by digitisation of figures (PlotDigitizer, v3.1.4, Automeris LLC, TX, USA), by a single author (SM). Axis ends and data were digitised using the closest centre point. Where overlapping data made individual datum centre points unclear, these were estimated using any visual point of reference available. Random effects meta-analyses with meta-regressions and sub-grouping were conducted using Comprehensive Meta-Analysis (v.4.0, Biostat Inc., NJ, USA). Data were separated by exercise modality or skiing technique and by participant sex. Subsequent data were sub-grouped by the attributed PCF tier. Uncertainty in the pooled effects was expressed at 95% confidence intervals [28]. A 95% prediction interval was derived to quantify the expected range of true exponents for 95% of similar future studies [29]. Between-estimate heterogeneity was quantified using the tau statistic (τ)—a standard deviation which describes the typical variability in the mean size exponent between studies [30]. Meta-regressions were used to explain the variance of the pooled O2Max by using the τ and r2 values. Sufficient data were only available to conduct detailed sub-group regression analysis on studies which measured O2Max using running based protocols. Results Search Results A total of 2338 studies were retrieved through database searches. A further 14 studies were found through reference list scanning (2352 total studies). Of this total, 1288 studies were excluded as duplicates and 751 studies were excluded for irrelevancy after screening titles and abstracts. A total of 313 studies were accessed in full for further review, and 78 studies were deemed to meet the inclusion criteria and were selected for data extraction and analysis (Fig. 1). Key information and outcome measures for each of the included studies is summarised in Table 3. Table 3Summary of studies reporting maximal oxygen uptake as part of a study focussing on cross-country skiing. Data reported as mean ± standard deviation (SD)Study (year)n = Sex (m/f)Spr/dist/ bothAge (years)PCF (1–5)Participant descriptionO2Max (mL.kg−1.min−1)O2Max (L.min−1)Protocol descriptionInstrumentationCalculation methodAlsobrook and Heil [31]10MNR24 ± 72‘Ranged from 3 subjectsamong the top collegiate57.4 ± 4.14.24 ± 0.49DP on SkiErg (WB); Continuous ramp. Start: M = 40 W, F = 30 W;Modified Concept 2 rowing ergometer;‘Sample interval for computed5F26 ± 62skiers in the USA to weekend citizen racers’43.2 ± 4.72.51 ± 0.31Power Increased: M = 20 W, F = 15 W every minuteTrueMax 2400 metabolic systemO2 values was 20 s’Andersson and McGawley [32]11MNRNRa2‘Junior athletes, national and/or international standard’67.2 ± 2.6NRDS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.0–12.0 km.h−1 and 3.0° − 4.0° incline. incline increased until 9.0° (rate NR) after which, speed increased by 0.4 km.h−1 every minuteRodby motorised treadmill; PRO-Ski C2 roller skis; AMIS 2001 model C metabolic system‘Highest 30 s moving average was used to calculate O2Max’10FNRa54.7 ± 3.5NRAndersson et al. [33]11MBoth24 ± 44‘Swedish male cross-country competing at a national or international level’NR5.10 ± 0.50DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 9.0 km.h−1 and 7.0° incline. Speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 45 sRodby motorised treadmill; Pro-Ski C2 roller skis; AMIS 2001 model C metabolic system‘Average of the three highest consecutive 10 s O2 values was defined as O2Max’NR4.90 ± 0.50DP on Treadmill; Continuous rampStart: 21.0 km.h−1 and 1.0° incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteAndersson et al. [34]10MBoth25 ± 44‘Competed in sprint and distance races at national and/or international level’62.2 ± 6.0NRDS on Treadmill; Specifics NRRodby motorised treadmill;Pro-Ski C2 roller skis;NR59.8 ± 6.0NRDP on Treadmill; Specifics NRAMIS 2001 model Cmetabolic systemBerg et al. [35]13MNR24 ± 44‘Participation in World Cup races or other high ranked FIS races in the 2015/2016 season’75.5 ± 4.2NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individual speed (RPE = 12) incline NR. Speed increased by 1 km.h−1 each minuteForcelink motorised treadmill (RUN); Modified Concept 2 SkiErg ‘seated with ‘middle dampe setting’ (DP); Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system with mixing chamber r‘O2 Peak was reported as the mean of the three highest 10 s values during the last minute of the test’b55.1 ± 6.1NRDP on SkiErg (UB); Continuous ramp. Start: Individual power (RPE = 12). Power increased 20 W. min−112MNA26 ± 31‘Physically activecontrols’57.2 ± 6.4NRRunning on Treadmill; As above35.8 ± 4.6NRDP on SkiErg (UB); As aboveBergh [22]5MDistcNRa5‘Olympic and/or WorldChampions or medalist’83.8 ± 6.46.54 ± 0.48Running on Treadmill; Uphill on amotorised treadmill. Specifics NRIndeterminate motorisedtreadmill; 100-200 lNR34MNRa4‘Less successfulinternational competitors’79.6 ± 3.45.50 ± 0.39Douglas bags; gas contentmeasured by MGA200mass spectrometer; volumemeasured by indeterminate spirometerNRa4‘No Olympic Games or World Championship medallists, but Swedish National Champions’71.2 ± 4.33.75 ± 0.259F9FNRa3‘Less successful skiers’68.4 ± 2.73.82 ± 0.38Bilodeau et al. [36]10MDistc21 ± 23‘Members of the Pierre-Harvey National Cross-Country Skiing Centre’77.6 ± 1.2NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: 5.5 km.h−1 and 3.0° incline. Speed increased by 1.1 km.h−1Indeterminate motorised treadmill; SMI Inc SkiErg; Applied ElectrochemistryNR10FDistc21 ± 2362.7 ± 1.7NReach 2 min until 13.0 km.h−1 after which, incline increased by 1.8° every 2 minopen-circuit gas content analyser; Flesch Type Hewlett-Packard pneumotachometer with mixing chamber10MDistc21 ± 2361.8 ± 4.0NRDP SkiErg (WB); Continuous ramp. Start: 1.4 kg load. Flywheel target cadence of 400 RPM throughout10FDistc21 ± 2347.6 ± 2.2NRLoad increased by 0.2 kg every 2 minBinek et al. [37]10MNR22 ± 34‘Polish national team’65.7 ± 7.3NRRunning on Treadmill; Incremental test. Start: 6.0 km.h−1 and 0.0% incline. Speed increased by 2.0 km.h−1 each 3 min until 14.0 km.h−1 after which, incline increased by 2.0% every 2 minIndeterminate motorised treadmill; Jaeger Oxycon metabolic systemNR6F24 ± 3453.8 ± 5.0NRBjörklund et al. [38]6MNR28 ± 45‘Participated in FIS World Cup race within 12 months including 3 Olympic and World Championship medallists’73.0 ± 3.05.60 ± 0.60DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 11.0 km.h−1 (PCF 5) or 10 km.h−1 (PCF 3) and 4.0° incline. Incline increased by 1.0 each minute until 11.0 after which, speed increased by0.3 km.h−1 every 30 sRodby treadmill; Pro-Ski C2 roller skis; AMIS 2001 model C metabolic system‘Three highest values measured with a sampling durationof 10 s were averaged to calculate O2Max’6MNR35 ± 43‘Previous national/international experience but not participated in a FIS World Cup race within 12 months’61.0 ± 5.04.90 ± 0.40Bolger et al[39]4MNR28 ± 35FIS Points: 4 ± 481.7 ± 4.0NRRunning; Specifics NRSpecifics NRNR5FNR26 ± 45FIS Points: 8 ± 571.0 ± 3.9NRBucher et al. [40]17MNR22 ± 43‘Ten athletes were described as elite and 29 as highly trained’d,e70.1 ± 4.5NRDS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: M = 8.6 km.h−1, F = 6.8 km.h−1 and 9° incline. Speed increased by 0.4km.h−1 every minute for the first three minutes (M = 0.5 km.h−1 for the firsttwo minutes). Speed then increasedevery 30 sIndeterminate motorised treadmill; Indeterminate roller-skis; 100L Douglasbag; AEI Technologies O2 (S-3A/I) and CO2 (CD-3A)analysers; Hugo SachsElektronik dry gas meter‘O2max was defined as the highest O2 measured in one bag, meeting the criteria of a filling time of > 25 s and an increase in O2 from the previous bag of < 150 mL min−1’10FNR22 ± 4358.8 ± 4.4NRBucher et al[41]16MNR19 ± 33‘Required to compete atnational level with 5 yearsminimum of ski specifictraining’62.2 ± 6.9NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (specifics NR) and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteIndeterminate motorised treadmill; Cortex Metalyzer 3b metabolic system‘Average of the 3 highest 10 s consecutive measurements determined O2Max’Carlsson et al. [42]12MDist24 ± 43FISDist Points: 122 ± 5870.3 ± 4.25.34 ± 0.34DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 11.0 km.h−1 and 4.0° incline. Incline increased by 1.0° each minute until 10.0° after which, speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 sOJK-2 motorised treadmill; Pro-Ski C2 roller skis; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system‘O2Max was defined as the highest mean O2 during a period of 20 s’Carlsson et al. [13]8MSpr25 ± 53FISSpr Points: 96 ± 27NR5.57 ± 0.52DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 11.0 km.h−1 and 4.0° incline. Incline increased by 1.0° each minute until 10.0° after which, speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 sOJK-2 motorised treadmill; Pro-Ski C2 roller skis; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system‘O2Max was defined as the highest mean O2 during a 60 s period’Carlsson et al. [14]10FBoth25 ± 34FISDist Points: 93 ± 2863.0 ± 3.04.00 ± 0.30DS on Treadmill; Continuous rampHP Cosmos Saturn‘O2Max was defined as the highest mean O2 during a 60 s period’FISSpr Points: 116 ± 60Start: 10.9 km.h−1 and 2.4° incline. Speed increased by 0.1 km.h−1 and incline increased by 0.4° every 30 s450/300rs motorised treadmill; Pro-Ski C2 roller skis; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic systemCarlsson et al. [43]24MNR21 ± 34‘Competing at the national and international levels’71.5 ± 6.45.39 ± 0.57DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start:10.0 km.h−1 and 3.0° incline (lower ranking skiers: n = 8)/11.0 km.h−1 and 4.0° incline (higher ranking skiers: n = 16). Incline increased by 1.0° each minute until10.0° after which, speed increased by0.5 km.h−1 every 60 s (lower ranking skiers)/30 s (higher ranking skiers)OJK-2 or Rodby RL3500 motorised treadmillc; Pro-Ski C2 roller skis; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system‘O2Max was defined as the highest mean O2 during a 60 s period’Danielsen et al. [44]9FNR24 ± 5‘Norwegian national-level’NR5.45 ± 0.64Running on Treadmill: Specifics NRIndeterminate motrisedtreadmill; Jaeger OxyconPro metabolic systemNRDrzazga et al. [45]6MNR23 ± 34‘Polish national team’64.0 ± 5.94.68 ± 0.55Running on Treadmill: Continuous ramp. Start: 6.0 km.h−1 and 0%incline. Speed increased by 2.0 km.h−1 every 3 min until 14.0 km.h−1 afterwhich, incline increased by 2.5%every three minutesIndeterminate motorised treadmill; Jager Oxycon metabolic systemNREvertsen et al. [46]11MDistcNRa3‘Competing at national and international junior level’73.0 ± 4.0NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Speed NR and 3.0° incline. Speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 sWoodway motorised treadmill; Jager EOS- Sprint metabolic system‘Calculated the O2 as averages over 30 s intervals’9FDistc358.0 ± 2.0NRFabre et al. [47]7MNR21 ± 53f‘Regional to national class’67.4 ± 7.8NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 5.0 km.h−1 and 0.0% incline. Subsequent 1-min stages at 7.0, 9.0, 10.5, and 12.0 km.h−1 and 0.0% incline after which, incline increased by 2% every minuteS2500 HEF Techmachine motorised treadmill;Swenor Carbonfibre roller- skis; Sigma Sport BC800 speedometer; Cosmed K4b2 metabolic systemNR64.4 ± 8.4NRDS Roller-Ski (3 km asphalt road course); Start: 5.0 km.h−1, 8.0° incline, 1134 m altitude. Speed increased by 1.0 km.−1 every minute by bicycleGejl et al. [48]10MBoth25 ± 44‘Participated in national and/or international competitions’64.9 ± 4.15.10 ± 0.50DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 9.0 km.h−1 and 7.0° incline. Speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 45 sIndeterminate motorised treadmill; Indeterminate roller-skis; AMIS 2001 model C metabolic system‘Average of the three highest 10 s consecutive values was defined as O2Max’62.5 ± 4.25.00 ± 0.50DP on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 21.0 km.h−1 and 1.0° incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteGrasaas et al. [49]12MNR25 ± 34FIS Points 68 ± 2771.4 ± 3.45.50 ± 0.60V2 on Treadmillc; Continuous ramp. Start: 15.8 km.h−1 and 5.0% incline. Speed increased by 2.2 km.h−1 until 20.2 km.h−1 after which speed increased by 1.1 km.h−1 every minuteBonte Technology motorised treadmill; Startex Start Skating 80 roller-skis; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic systemO2 measured every 10 s, the average of the three highest Consecutive values determined the O2Peak’bHaymes andDickinson [50]10MDistc23 ± 24‘United States ski team’NR5.34 ± 0.44Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed between 12.0–15.0 km.h−1 with a target HR of 160 b min−1. Start incline NR. Incline increased by 4% after two minutes then by 2% every two minutesIndeterminate motorised treadmill; Meteorological balloons; Godart rapox O2 analyser; Capnograph CO2 analyser; Volumes measured by Parkinson Cowan CD4 gas meter‘Analysed for the final three to four minutes of the run’10FDistc20 ± 44NR3.44 ± 0.36Hegge et al. [51]16MNR24 ± 44‘Participated at national and international level’71.5 ± 3.8NRV2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 16.0 km.h−1 and 5.0% incline. Speed increased by 2 km.h−1 until20.0 km.h−1 after which speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteBonte Technology motorised treadmill; Startex Start Skating 80 roller-skis; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system‘Average of the three highest 10 s consecutive measurements determined O2Peak’bHegge et al[52]8MNR20 ± 23FIS Points: 128 ± 4873.9 ± 5.3NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (specifics NR) and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteIndeterminant motorised treadmill; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system with mixing chamber‘Two highest consecutive 10 s O2 values were defined as O2Peak’b8FNR23 ± 33FIS Points: 131 ± 3662.0 ± 1.5NRHegge et al[53]10MNR21 ± 43FIS Points: 99 ± 2173.4 ± 4.8NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (specifics NR) and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteIndeterminant motorised treadmill; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system with mixing chamber‘Two highest consecutive 10 s O2 values were defined as O2Peak’b10FNR23 ± 44FIS Points: 99 ± 2665.4 ± 4.7NRHoff et al. [54]15FDistc18 ± 02‘Competing at regional level’55.3 ± 1.33.30 ± 0.10Running on Treadmill; Discontinuous incremental. Start: Individualised speed at ~ 60% O2Max based on previous laboratory testing, and 6° incline. 5 min stages with 20 s BLa sampling. Speed increased 1.0 km.h−1every stageIndeterminant motorised treadmill; Jager Ergo Oxyscreen metabolic systemNRHolmberg et al. [55]7MNR27 ± 35‘Included five World Championship and/or Olympic medallists’NR6.23 ± 0.47DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 11.5 km.h−1 and 4° incline.Incline increased by 1° every minuteSpectra Refox motorised treadmill; AMIS 2001 metabolic system with mixing chamber; Pro-Ski C2 roller-skis (DS & DP)‘Average of the three highest 10 s consecutive Measurements was used’6.00 ± 0.42Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Speed NR and 4.5° incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute5.36 ± 0.28DP on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 15.0 km.h−1 and 2° incline. Incline increased by 0.5° every minuteIngjer [11]6MDistc27 ± 35‘All among best on world cup list and won World Cup races’85.6 ± 1.66.38 ± 0.27Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (specifics NR) and 10.5% inclineIndeterminant motorised treadmill; Douglas bag; Beckman E2 Oxygen analyser; Beckman IR215A Carbon Dioxide analyser;NR6FDistc23 ± 2570.1 ± 1.84.28 ± 0.257MDistc24 ± 34‘Participating in international races and World Cup races’81.5 ± 2.15.94 ± 0.39Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute6FDistc23 ± 2470.6 ± 3.53.84 ± 0.2313MDistc23 ± 24‘Occasionally participating in World Cup races, earning none or only a few World Cup points’79.4 ± 2.95.74 ± 0.3013FDistc23 ± 1464.2 ± 1.93.84 ± 0.21Ingjer andMaher [56]35MDistc26 ± NR4‘Participated in international competitions (World Cup)’82.1 ± 2.76.02 ± 0.04Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (specifics NR) and 12° incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteIndeterminant motorisedtreadmill; Douglas bag;Beckman E2 Oxygenanalyser; BeckmanIR215A Carbon Dioxideanalyser; Wilhelm RitterKG wet gas meterNRJohansen et al[57]14 gMNR22 ± 23‘National level’71.4 ± 1.95.51 ± 0.27Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: F = 8.0 km.h-1, M = 10.0 km.h−1 and 6.0% incline. Incline raised to 7.0–10.0% within 2 min “depending on the subjects’ fitness”. Speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 sRodby RL25000E motorised treadmill (DP); Woodway PPS55 motorised treadmill (RUN); Swenor wheel type 2 Fibreglass roller-skis; SensorMedics 229 metabolic system with mixing chamber‘Defined as the mean of the highest two consecutive 20 s measurements of O2’57.9 ± 2.74.47 ± 0.34DP on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Speed 2.0–4.0 km.h−1 below 80% of expected HRMax, determined by submaximal testing, and 4.0% incline. Incline increased by 0.5% until 80% expected HRMax reached after which, speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 sJohansen et al. [58]12MNR24 ± 23‘National level’72.8 ± 5.5NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 8.0–12.0 km.h−1 (specifics NR) and 6.0% incline. Incline increased 1.0% every 30 s until 8.0% after which, speed increased by 0.5 km.h-1 every 30 sWoodway PPS55 motorised treadmill (RUN); Cortex Metalyzer II metabolic system‘Measurement every 10 s. Mean of the three highest consecutive O2 measurements were used’9MNRNAg3NR5.11 ± 0.069hFNR27 ± 1362.3 ± 1.14.34 ± 0.29Klusiewicz and Cempa [59]2MNR32 ± 54‘Polish national team’58.2 ± 1.6NRRunning on Treadmill; Incremental. Start: F = 10.0 km.h-1, M = 12.0 km.h-1 and 1.5% incline. 5 min stages. Speed increased by 2.0 km.h-1 each stage until F = 16.0 km.h-1, M = 18.0 km.h-1. After which, incline increased by 1.5% each stageIndeterminate motorised treadmill; SensorMedics Vmax29 metabolic systemNR4FNR23 ± 2455.7 ± 3.9NRKravitz et al.[60]9MNA29 ± 81‘Recruited from community health clubs, faculty staff members and students’49.9 ± 7.53.90 ± 0.70Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individual speed (specifics NR), “level running” (0.0% incline). Speed increased by 1.6 km.h-1 until “a predetermined self-selected jogging pace” reached after which, incline increased by 1% every minuteQuinton Q65 motorised treadmill; Jaeger Ergo- oxyscreen metabolic system‘Recorded every 30 s’9F29 ± 81Recruited from community health clubs, faculty staff members and students’44.6 ± 3.72.60 ± 0.30Lindinger et al. [61]12MNR23 ± 24i‘Members of the Swedish Junior and Swedish National team’73.1 ± 4.5NRDS on Treadmill; Specifics NRRodby motorised treadmill; AMIS 2001 metabolic Indeterminate roller-skis; systemNRLosnegard et al. [62]6MNR21 ± 33‘All top30(F)/70(M)/15(J)c inNorwegian NationalChampionships –Experimental Group’67.3 ± 5.1NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: M = 10.0 km.h-1, F = 8.0 km.h-1 and 10.5% incline. Speedincreased each minute (speed NR)Rodby motorised treadmill (V1); Woodway motorised treadmill (RUN); Swenorwith Type 1 Wheels rollerskis; Jager Oxycon Prometabolic system‘Highest oxygen value averaged over 1 min wasconsidered asO2Max’3FNR21 ± 5361.5 ± 1.1NR5MNR21 ± 33‘Control Group’69.5 ± 4.7NR3FNR23 ± 2357.9 ± 2.8NR63MFNRNR21 ± 321 ± 533‘Experimental Group’64.6 ± 5.156.8 ± 1.6NRNRV1 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: M = 10.8 km.h-1, F = 9.0 km.h-1and 5–6° incline. Incline increased 1°every minute until 8° after which, speed increased by 0.9 km.h-1 everyminute5MNR21 ± 33‘Control Group’68.4 ± 6.1NR3FNR23 ± 2353.1 ± 3.0NRLosnegard et al. [63]14MNR24 ± 34‘One World Cup winner, 6 skiers with top 30 results in World Cup races’71.8 ± 3.55.66 ± 0.40V1 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.8 km.h-1 and 6° inclineIncline increased 1° every minute until 8° after which, speed increased by 0.9 km.h-1 every minuteRodby motorised treadmill; Swenor Skate roller-skis; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system‘Highest mean values over 1 min was taken as O2Max’71.5 ± 3.35.65 ± 0.50V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.8 km.h-1 and 6° inclineIncline increased 1° every minute until 8° after which, speed increased by 0.9 km.h-1 every minuteLundgren et al[8]17MNR23 ± NR4‘Competing at national orinternational level’77.8 ± 9.35.80 ± 0.31Running on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Speed NR and 10.5%incline. Speed increased 1.0 km.h−1every minuteWoodway motorisedtreadmill; Jager Oxyconpro metabolic system withmixing chamber‘Mean of thethree highestconsecutive 10 swas used todetermineO2Max’Mahood et al[12]13MNR20 ± 33‘All NCAA Division Iathletes’66.7 ± 4.6NRVarious Skate Skiing Techniques inField; ‘most used the V2 techniqueuntil the final uphill section, whenthey switched to the V1 technique…’;3 km course, 2 km ‘relatively flat’final kilometre at 10–15% incline. 0–1km ‘below race pace’, 1–2 km ‘racepace’, 2–3 km ‘all-out effort tovolitional exhaustion. None of thesubjects completed the entire 3 km…’Pro-Ski inc. R2 Roadskaterroller-skis; Aerosport KB1-C metabolic systemNRMognoni et al[64]7MNR20 ± 33‘At least 4-years history of active competition at a national level’65.9 ± 2.0NRRunning on Treadmill with Poles (alt1000 m); Incremental protocol. Start:M = 7.5 km.h−, F = 7.0 km.h−1 and 0°incline. Incline increased by 2° every 3 min until 4°. Speed then increased by 0.5 km.h−1 for 3 minafter which, incline increased by 2°every 3 minIndeterminate motorisedtreadmill; MedgraphicsCPX/D Systems metabolicsystem‘Linearregressions werecomputedbetween HR andO2 for eachsubject’7F22 ± 3358.1 ± 4.2NRMyakinchenko et al. [65]27MNR25 ± 54‘Russian national teamFIS Point Range: 7–202’77.1 ± 4.1NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Speed 6.0 km.h−1 and 0%incline. Incline increased to 16%within 45 s after which, speed increased to 9.0 km.h−1 for 30 s and then further to M = 12.0 km.h−1, F = 11.0 km.h−1Fitness Master Fitnex motorised treadmill;Cortex Metalyzer 3Bmetabolic system‘Highest 30 s O2 value wasrecorded asO2Max’27F24 ± 34‘Russian national teamFIS Point Range: 6–201’66.1 ± 3.5NRMyakinchenko et al. [66]14MNR27 ± 44‘Russian national teamFIS Point Range: 2–45’79.4 ± 3.5NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Speed 6.0 km.h−1 and 0%incline. Incline increased to 16%within 45 s after which, speed increased to 9.0 km.h−1 for 30 s and then further to M = 12.0 km.h1, F = 11.0 km.h−1Specifics NRNRMygind et al[67]18MDistc24 ± NR4‘All Danish national teamfor 1987 World Cup’66.3 ± 1.84.92 ± 0.13DP SkiErg (WB); Start: 162 WPower increased by 15 W every 2minutes until 192 W after which,participants instructed to ski ‘flat out’Bespoke ‘multipurpose’ergometer; Jaeger ErgoOxyscreen metabolicsystem‘O2Max wasmeasured overthe last 2 min’Ng et al. [68]43MDistc31 ± 42‘Entrants of the Wintergreen race series’56.6 ± 5.74.30 ± 0.50Running on Treadmill; Specifics NRIndeterminant motorised treadmill; Douglas bags; Beckman E-2 O2 analyser;Godart Capnograph CO2 analyserNRNybäck et al. [69]5MNR22 ± 33‘Competing at a national level’71.5 ± 4.75.23 ± 0.40DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.0–12.0 km.h-1 “depending on the sex, age and skiing ability” (Further specifics NR) and 3° incline. Incline increased by 1° every minute until 9° after which, speed increased by 0.4 km.h-1Rodby motorised treadmill; Pro-ski C2 roller-skis; Cortex Metamax 3B metabolic system‘O2Max was accepted as the highest 30 s mean value’3F21 ± 1358.4 ± 2.53.69 ± 0.47Østerås et al. [70]13FNR23 ± 44FIS Points: 107 ± 2564.9 ± 4.2NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (specifics NR) and 10.5% incline. Speed increased 1 km.h-1 every minuteIndeterminant motorised treadmill; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system‘Average of the three highest 10 s consecutive measurements determined O2MaxRud et al. [71]8MNR24 ± 72j‘Healthy recreational cross-country skiers’66 ± 4.74.90 ± 0.40Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Specifics NR except duration was 4–6 minIndeterminant motorised treadmill (RUN); Modified Concept 2 RowErg; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic systemNR60 ± 3.94.50 ± 0.40DP SkiErg (WB); Continuous ramp. Specifics NR except duration was 4–6 minSandbakk et al. [72]8MSpr26 ± 24FIS Points: 50 ± 12NR5.80 ± 0.50Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 9.0 km.h-1 and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.1 km.h-1 every minute8F24 ± 24FIS Points: 49 ± 14NR3.60 ± 0.408M26 ± 24FIS Points: 50 ± 1262.2 ± 1.85.20 ± 0.40DP on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 14.0 km.h-1 and 5% incline. Speed increased by 1.1 km.h-1 every minuteWoodway motorised treadmill (RUN); Bonte motorised treadmill (DP); Pro-ski roller-skis with standard wheels (DP); Oxycon pro metabolic system‘Averages of the three consecutive 10 s intervals associated with the highest values designated as maximal values.’8F24 ± 24FIS Points: 49 ± 1453.6 ± 3.03.20 ± 0.20Sandbakk et al[73]7MBoth24 ± 34FISDist Points: 67 ± 2670.6 ± 4.15.40 ± 0.55V2 on Treadmill; Continuous rampStart 16.0 km.h−1 and 5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 everyminuteBonte motorised treadmill;Swenor roller-skis with standard wheels; Oxyconpro metabolic system‘Average ofthe three highest consecutive 10 svaluesdesignated asO2Peak’bFISSpr Points: 80 ± 18Sandbakk et al. [74]8MSpr26 ± 24FIS Points: 50 ± 1269.5 ± 3.75.77 ± 0.49V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: M = 15.8 km.h−1, F = 14.0km.h−1 (and 5% incline. Speedincreased by 2.2 km.h−1 every minutefor the first 2 min after which,speed increased by 1.1 km.h−1 everyminuteBonte Technologymotorised treadmill; Swenor roller-skis withstandard wheels; JagerOxycon pro metabolicsystem‘Average ofthe three highest consecutive 10 svalues wasdefined asO2Max’8F24 ± 24FIS Points: 49 ± 1460.8 ± 3.83.64 ± 0.43Sandbakk et al. [75]12MSpr25 ± 34FIS Points: 44 ± 4070.0 ± 2.75.74 ± 0.52V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 15.8 km.h−1 and 5% incline. Speed increased by 2.2 km.h−1 everyminute for the first 2 min after which, speed increased by 1.1 km.h−1 every minuteBonte Technology motorised treadmill; Swenor roller-skis withstandard wheels; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system‘Average ofthe three highest consecutive 10 svalues designated as O2Peak’bSandbakk et al. [4]8MSpr26 ± 45FIS Points: 23 ± 1270.6 ± 3.25.88 ± 0.40V2 on Treadmill; Continuous rampStart: 15.8 km.h−1 and 5% incline. Speed increased by 2.2 km.h−1 everyminute for the first 2 min after which, speed increased by 1.1 km.h−1 every minuteBonte Technologymotorised treadmill; Swenor roller-skis withstandard wheels; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system‘Average ofthe three highest 10 s consecutivemeasurements determined O2Peak’b8M25 ± 23FIS Points: 101 ± 4665.8 ± 3.45.44 ± 0.43Sandbakk et al[76]12MNR26 ± 63FIS Points: 76 ± 2173.0 ± 3.6NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Individual speed(specifics NR), and incline 10.5%Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 everyminuteIndeterminate motorisedtreadmill; Cortex Metamax3 metabolic system‘Averages ofthreeconsecutive 10 sintervals withhighest valuesdeterminingmaximalvalues.’Sandbakk et al[77]9MNR18 ± 02‘Junior elite athletes’69.3 ± 5.8NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Individual speed(specifics NR) and 10.5% inclineSpeed increased 0.5–1.0 km.h−1 “everytime the participant attained O2 thatwas stable during a 30 s period”Rodby RL2500 Emotorised treadmill; JaegerOxycon pro metabolicsystem with mixingchamber‘Average ofthe three highest10 s consecutivemeasurementsdeterminedO2Max’Schmitt et al[78]7MNR23 ± 34‘French national team’69.3 ± 3.6NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous‘incremental with ramp phase’. Start:8.0 km.h−1, 2.0% incline and 1150 maltitude. Speed increased to 9.0 km.h−1after 3 min. Incline increased by2.0% every 3 min until 6%incline, after which speed increased to10.0 km.h−1 until ventilatory threshold(VT). After VT, incline increased each minute (rate NRk) until 16%Indeterminant motorisedtreadmill; MGCDiagnostics Ultima Cardio2® metabolic system‘Highest 30 saverage value’5F23 ± 4458.9 ± 2.5NRSkattebo et al. [79]18FNR18 ± 3 l2‘All top 30 in Norwegiannational cup. 3 participated in JuniorWorld Championship -Experimental Group’59.8 ± 4.43.64 ± 0.08Running on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: 7.0 km.h−1 and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1every minuteWoodway Desmo-Evomotorised treadmill; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolicsystem‘O2Max was taken as thehighest averageO2 over 60 s’14F17 ± 3 l2‘Control Group’57.9 ± 2.63.47 ± 0.12Skattebo et al. [80]6MBoth25 ± 35FISDist Points: 16 ± 1285.0 ± 3.46.38 ± 0.42Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.0 km.h−1 and 6° incline. Speed increased 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 sRodby motorised treadmill; Swenor roller-skis; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic systemHighest continuous O2 during a 60 s period was defined as O2Peak’kSolli et al. [81]8MNR20 ± 23FIS Points: 165 ± 8268.1 ± 5.35.28 ± 0.49Running on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Individualised speed (85-90% of predicted VO2Max) and incline 10.5%. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1every minuteRodby 2500E motorisedtreadmill; Jaeger Oxyconpro metabolic system‘O2Max wasdefined as thehighest averageof 2 consecutive30 smeasurements’m6F21 ± 33FIS Points: 153 ± 4463.1 ± 5.23.85 ± 0.29Solli et al. [82]6MNR22 ± 24‘All competed at thenational and internationallevels’68.9 ± 2.95.55 ± 0.40Running on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Individualised speed (85-90% of predicted O2Max) and incline 6°. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1every minuteRodby 2500E motorisedtreadmill; Jaeger Oxyconpro metabolic system‘O2Max wasdefined as thehighest averageof 2 consecutive30 smeasurements’m6F20 ± 2460.1 ± 3.33.71 ± 0.40Stadheim et al. [83]10MNR20 ± 33‘Compete in the Norwegian National Cross-Country Skiing Cup’69.3 ± 3.1NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.0 km.h−1 and 10.5° incline. Speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 sWoodway motorised treadmill (RUN); Thoraxtrainer Elite Poling Ergometer (DP); JaegerOxycon pro metabolicsystem;‘Average of the two highest (30 s)measurements’n63.2 ± 4.7NRDP SkiErg (WB); Specifics NRStadheim et al. [84]13MNR22 ± 33‘Compete in the Norwegian National Cross-Country Skiing Cup’72.6 ± 5.7NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.0 km.h−1 and 10.5° incline. Speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 sWoodway motorised treadmill (RUN); Thoraxtrainer Elite Poling Ergometer (DP); JaegerOxycon pro metabolicsystem;‘Average of the two highest (30 s)measurements’n62.9 ± 6.8NRDP SkiErg (WB); Continuous ramp. Start: 15.0 km−1. Speed increased by0.5 km.h−1 every 30 sStöggl et al[85]14MSpr22 ± 55‘Nine skiers with top-20rankings in World Cup.’NR5.20 ± 0.50DS on Treadmill; Specifics NRIndeterminate motorisedtreadmill; Indeterminateroller-skis; AMIS 2001metabolic system;NRStöggl et al. [86]12MSpr22 ± 54‘Austrian national team’64.6 ± 6.04.88 ± 0.59DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 11.3 km.h−1 and 4.0° incline. Incline increased by 0.8° every 30 s until 9.6° after which speed increased by 0.4 km.h−1 (Rate NR: ‘gradually’)Pomer motorised treadmill; Pro-ski C2 roller-skis; Cosmed K4b2 metabolic system‘Maximal men value of 10 successive breaths’Stöggl et al[87]16MSpr26 ± 54‘7 national and 9international standard’67.6 ± 5.4NRoDS on Treadmill; Specifics NRRodby motorised treadmill;Pro-ski C2 roller-skis;AMIS 2001 model Cmetabolic systemNRSunde et al. [88]12MNR19 ± 12‘Well trained fromNorwegian high schoolsand local highperformance competitiveskiers’72.2 ± 5.15.22 ± 0.63Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 8.0–12.0 km.h−1 (specificsNR) and 6% incline. Incline increasedby 1% every 30 s until 8.0% afterwhich, speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1every 30 sWoodway PPS 55 sport motorised treadmill;Cortex Metalyzer IImetabolic system withmixing chamberNR16FNR18 ± 1253.8 ± 4.43.54 ± 0.39Sylta et al. [89]16MNR26 ± 34‘Norwegian national team28 medal winners injunior or senior levels(specifics NR)’79.8 ± 5.06.20 ± 0.50Running on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Individualised speed (85-90% of predicted VO2Max) and 3°incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteWoodway ELG motorisedtreadmill; various Jaegermetabolic systems (JaegerEOS Sprint 1989–2002 and Jaeger Oxycon pro thereafter)NR13FNR24 ± 4470.3 ± 5.04.30 ± 0.30Sylta et al. [90]12MNR25 ± 34‘Norwegian national team80.9 ± 3.76.10 ± 0.46Running on Treadmill; Specifics NRSpecifics NRNR12FNR24 ± 4410 medal winners (sexspecifics NR)’70.9 ± 4.64.30 ± 0.32Talsnes et al. [91]33MNR19 ± 33‘National level. FISPoints: 202 ± 91’70.8 ± 4.75.05 ± 0.56Running on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: 9.0 km.h−1 and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1every minuteRodby RL 2500 motorisedtreadmill (RUN); Rodby RL 3500E motorisedtreadmill (V2); IDT Sportsroller-skis with ‘category2’ wheels; Jaeger Oxyconpro metabolic system‘Average of thetwo highest consecutive 30 smeasurements’68.1 ± 5.24.89 ± 0.66V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 14.0 km.h−1 and 5% incline. Speed increased by 2.0 km.h−1 each minute until 20.0 km.h−1 after which,speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 everyminuteTønnessen et al[92]17MDist28 ± 45‘Olympic medallist’84.3 ± 5.26.42 ± 0.64Running on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Individualised speed (85-90% of predicted O2Max). Inclinespecifics NR. Speed increased by 1.0km.h−1 every minuteWoodway ELG motorisedtreadmill; various Jaegermetabolic systems withmixing chamber (JaegerEOS Sprint 1989–2002 andJaeger Oxycon prothereafter)‘Highestaverage of twoconsecutive 30 smeasurements’10FDist28 ± 5572.6 ± 5.14.27 ± 0.307MSpr26 ± 4577.9 ± 2.96.27 ± 0.555FSpr29 ± 8568.6 ± 3.74.28 ± 0.418MDist26 ± 34‘Olympic non-medallist’82.0 ± 2.26.31 ± 0.3112FDist25 ± 4469.4 ± 2.74.16 ± 0.376MSpr30 ± 4478.5 ± 3.66.34 ± 0.498FSpr25 ± 4468.6 ± 4.14.18 ± 0.36Tortu et al. [93]19MNR20 ± 33‘National Team athletes’68.3 ± 6.8NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 8.0 km.h−1 and NRincline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1every minuteIndeterminate motorised treadmill; Cosmed K5metabolic system‘Most excellent15 s O2 value obtained duringthe incrementaltest wasconsidered asO2Max’17F19 ± 2359.0 ± 5.6NRTorvik et al[94]24MNR20 ± 43‘Competed at the nationallevel’71.4 ± 3.1NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Speed specifics NR and10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteRodby RL 2500Emotorised treadmill; JaegerOxycon pro metabolic system‘Mean of thethree highestconsecutive 10 s measurementsof O2 at eachstage wasdesignated asO2peak’bTorvik et al. [95]8MNR22 ± 13FIS Points: 120 ± 4469.4 ± 5.1NRDS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.0 km.h−1 and 7.0% inclineIncline increased by 1.0% everyminuteRodby 3500ML motorised treadmill; SwenorFiberglass roller-skis with‘standard resistance wheel2’; Jaeger Oxycon prometabolic system withmixing chamber‘Measuredevery 10 s andevery minute ofthe test, whileO2 wascalculated bythe averagethree valuesclosest (last 30 s)to every stepchange.’65.3 ± 6.7NRDP on Treadmill; Continuous rampStart: 10.0 km.h−1 and 7.0% inclineIncline increased by 1.0% everyminuteUndebakke etal. [96]12MNR26 ± 44FIS Points: 66 ± 774.5 ± 4.15.80 ± 0.40Running on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Individualised speed(RPE 12) based on submaximalstages, and 10.5% incline. Speedincreased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minuteForcelink BV motorisedtreadmill (DS and RUN);Modified Concept 2SkiErg ‘seated with‘damper setting 5’ (DP);IDT Sports classic roller-skis with category 2wheels; Jager Oxycon prometabolic system‘Averageof the threehighestconsecutive 10 srecordingsduring thelast minutedeterminedO2Peak’b75.9 ± 5.35.87 ± 0.40DS on Treadmill; Continuous rampStart: Individualised speed (RPE 12)based on submaximal stages, and12.0% incline. Speed increased by1.0 km.h−1 every minute54.8 ± 6.24.24 ± 0.40DP SkiErg (UB); Continuous rampStart: Individualised power (RPE 12)based on submaximal stages. Power increased by 20 W min−1Vergès et al. [97]10MNR19 ± 23‘National level’73.7 ± 4.25.23 ± 0.49Running on Treadmill; bContinuous incremental. Start: 9.0 km.h−1 and0.0% incline. Incline increased by2.0% every 3 min, except each4th step in which speed increased by 0.7–1.1 km.h−1Indeterminant motorised treadmill; Brainwaremetabolic systemNRVergès et al[98]7MNR18 ± 13‘National level’NR4.05 ± 0.90Running on Treadmill; Continuousincremental; Speed and inclineadjusted to 70%, 80%, 90% HRMax(based on previous testing) each 6minutes. Thereafter, incline increasedby 2% every 2 minIndeterminant motorisedtreadmill (Running);Marwe Skating 610 roller-skis with high resistance;Brainware metabolicsystem (Running); JaegerOxycon Mobile (Roller-skiing)‘O2 wasobtained byaveraging thelast minutebeforeexhaustion’NR3.98 ± 0.75Roller-skiing on tarred road withvaried techniques; Discontinuous 4km loops at 70%, 80%, 90% HRMax(based on previous testing) and‘maximum speed’, separated by 10minutesWalther et al.p[99]10MBothNRa5"Classified as world-class(Tier 5) according toperformance caliberclassification by McKayet al.…" FISComb: 6 ± 981.6 ± 3.86.02 ± 0.50Running on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Individualised speed(specifics NR) and 10.5% inclineSpeed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 everyminuteIndeterminant motorisedtreadmill; Inditerminantmetabolic systemNR7FBothNRa571.3 ± 4.44.46 ± 0.30Wang et al. [100]12MNR21 ± 23‘2 national players [sic] and 4 reserve national players’77.9 ± 1.2NRRunning on Treadmill; Start: 2.7 km.h−1 and 10% incline. Speed increased by 1.3–1.5 km.h−1 andincline by 2% every two minutesIndeterminant motorised treadmill; COSMED; Quark CPET metabolicsystemNRWisløff et al. [101]8FNR19 ± 12‘Competitive cross-country skiers… recruited from a secondary school’NR3.60 ± 0.40Running on Treadmill; Start 9.0 km.h−1 and 3° incline. Speed increased by1.0 km.h−1 every minute until ‘close toexhaustion’ followed bysupramaximal intensity stage ~ threeminutesChallenger LE5000 motorised treadmill; Jaeger EOS Sprint metabolicsystemNRZhu et al. [102]5MNR3‘Competitive at nationallevel’63.3 ± 6.5NRRunning on Treadmill; Continuousramp. Start: Individualised speed(specifics NR) and 10.5% inclineSpeed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 everyminuteRodby RL 1700 motorisedtreadmill; Indeterminatemetabolic system‘Three highest10 s successiveresults wereaveraged toobtain O2max’Both, Known to be competing in both sprint and distance disciplines; Dist, Distance competing athlete; DP, Double Poling; DS, Diagonal Stride; F, Female; FIS, International Skiing Federation; FISComb, Known to be a combined measure of sprint and distance point scores; FISDist Distance specific point score; FISSpr, Sprint specific point score; M, Male; n = , Number of participants; NCAA, National Collegiate Athletic Association; NR, Not Recorded; PCF, Participant Classification Framework tier; RPE, Rating of Perceived Exertion; Spr, Sprint athlete; UB, Upper Body; O2Max, Maximal Oxygen Uptake; O2Peak, Maximal Oxygen Uptake for Modality - see footnotes; WB, Whole BodyaValue not reported, but contextual indication that all participants were above the exclusion criterion age, i.e. > 16 years old; bRefers to assessment of O2 plateau, therefore considered a mode-specific O2Max; cBased on the date preceding sprint events; dNumbers of each performance level not separated by sex; eUnclear why so many participants data were excluded, 39 recruited but only 27 reported and 3 exclusion explanations provided; fNational skiing federation points reported for each individual; gData could only be separated for certain individuals, specific individual ages were not known to report here but all participants > 16 years old; hStudy recruited two females who did not complete the protocol, leaving exclusively male data; iRatio of junior and senior members unknown, but assumed majority senior due to reported mean age and range (20–26 years), therefore considered representative of PCF tier 4; jDescribed as recreational (‘PCF 1’) but also stated to identify as a cross-country skier (‘PCF 2’), therefore PCF 2 applied; kRate of 2% min−1 assumed as a continuation of the previously described stated for the running protocol procedures; oData were reported as 5.20 ± 0.50 but due to the same participant descriptors as Stöggl et al. [85], this was considered a duplicate sample and not considered in analyses. Study included here for relative O2Max data; pSenior season data included; p > 16 years old Summary of studies reporting maximal oxygen uptake as part of a study focussing on cross-country skiing. Data reported as mean ± standard deviation (SD) ‘Ranged from 3 subjects among the top collegiate DP on Treadmill; Continuous ramp Start: 21.0 km.h−1 and 1.0° incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Rodby motorised treadmill; Pro-Ski C2 roller skis; AMIS 2001 model C metabolic system ‘Physically active controls’ ‘Olympic and/or World Champions or medalist’ Running on Treadmill; Uphill on a motorised treadmill. Specifics NR Indeterminate motorised treadmill; 100-200 l ‘Less successful international competitors’ Douglas bags; gas content measured by MGA200 mass spectrometer; volume measured by indeterminate spirometer Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 5.5 km.h−1 and 3.0° incline. Speed increased by 1.1 km.h−1 DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 11.0 km.h−1 (PCF 5) or 10 km.h−1 (PCF 3) and 4.0° incline. Incline increased by 1.0 each minute until 11.0 after which, speed increased by 0.3 km.h−1 every 30 s ‘Three highest values measured with a sampling duration of 10 s were averaged to calculate O2Max’ Bolger et al [39] DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: M = 8.6 km.h−1, F = 6.8 km.h−1 and 9° incline. Speed increased by 0.4 km.h−1 every minute for the first three minutes (M = 0.5 km.h−1 for the first two minutes). Speed then increased every 30 s Indeterminate motorised treadmill; Indeterminate roller-skis; 100L Douglas bag; AEI Technologies O2 (S-3A/I) and CO2 (CD-3A) analysers; Hugo Sachs Elektronik dry gas meter Bucher et al [41] ‘Required to compete at national level with 5 years minimum of ski specific training’ DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start:10.0 km.h−1 and 3.0° incline (lower ranking skiers: n = 8)/11.0 km.h−1 and 4.0° incline (higher ranking skiers: n = 16). Incline increased by 1.0° each minute until 10.0° after which, speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 60 s (lower ranking skiers)/30 s (higher ranking skiers) ‘Norwegian national- level’ Indeterminate motrised treadmill; Jaeger Oxycon Pro metabolic system Running on Treadmill: Continuous ramp. Start: 6.0 km.h−1 and 0% incline. Speed increased by 2.0 km.h−1 every 3 min until 14.0 km.h−1 after which, incline increased by 2.5% every three minutes S2500 HEF Techmachine motorised treadmill; Swenor Carbonfibre roller- skis; Sigma Sport BC800 speedometer; Cosmed K4b2 metabolic system Haymes and Dickinson [50] V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 16.0 km.h−1 and 5.0% incline. Speed increased by 2 km.h−1 until 20.0 km.h−1 after which speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Hegge et al [52] Hegge et al [53] Running on Treadmill; Discontinuous incremental. Start: Individualised speed at ~ 60% O2Max based on previous laboratory testing, and 6° incline. 5 min stages with 20 s BLa sampling. Speed increased 1.0 km.h−1 every stage Ingjer and Maher [56] Indeterminant motorised treadmill; Douglas bag; Beckman E2 Oxygen analyser; Beckman IR215A Carbon Dioxide analyser; Wilhelm Ritter KG wet gas meter Johansen et al [57] ‘All top 30(F)/70(M)/15(J)c in Norwegian National Championships – Experimental Group’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: M = 10.0 km.h-1, F = 8.0 km.h-1 and 10.5% incline. Speed increased each minute (speed NR) Rodby motorised treadmill (V1); Woodway motorised treadmill (RUN); Swenor with Type 1 Wheels roller skis; Jager Oxycon Pro metabolic system ‘Highest oxygen value averaged over 1 min was considered as O2Max’ 6 3 M F NR NR 21 ± 3 21 ± 5 3 3 64.6 ± 5.1 56.8 ± 1.6 NR NR V1 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: M = 10.8 km.h-1, F = 9.0 km.h-1 and 5–6° incline. Incline increased 1° every minute until 8° after which, speed increased by 0.9 km.h-1 every minute V1 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.8 km.h-1 and 6° incline Incline increased 1° every minute until 8° after which, speed increased by 0.9 km.h-1 every minute V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.8 km.h-1 and 6° incline Incline increased 1° every minute until 8° after which, speed increased by 0.9 km.h-1 every minute Lundgren et al [8] ‘Competing at national or international level’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Speed NR and 10.5% incline. Speed increased 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Woodway motorised treadmill; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system with mixing chamber ‘Mean of the three highest consecutive 10 s was used to determine O2Max’ Mahood et al [12] ‘All NCAA Division I athletes’ Various Skate Skiing Techniques in Field; ‘most used the V2 technique until the final uphill section, when they switched to the V1 technique…’; 3 km course, 2 km ‘relatively flat’ final kilometre at 10–15% incline. 0–1 km ‘below race pace’, 1–2 km ‘race pace’, 2–3 km ‘all-out effort to volitional exhaustion. None of the subjects completed the entire 3 km…’ Pro-Ski inc. R2 Roadskater roller-skis; Aerosport KB1- C metabolic system Mognoni et al [64] Running on Treadmill with Poles (alt 1000 m); Incremental protocol. Start: M = 7.5 km.h−, F = 7.0 km.h−1 and 0° incline. Incline increased by 2° every 3 min until 4°. Speed then increased by 0.5 km.h−1 for 3 min after which, incline increased by 2° every 3 min Indeterminate motorised treadmill; Medgraphics CPX/D Systems metabolic system ‘Linear regressions were computed between HR and O2 for each subject’ ‘Russian national team FIS Point Range: 7–202’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Speed 6.0 km.h−1 and 0% incline. Incline increased to 16% within 45 s after which, speed increased to 9.0 km.h−1 for 30 s and then further to M = 12.0 km.h−1, F = 11.0 km.h−1 Fitness Master Fitnex motorised treadmill; Cortex Metalyzer 3B metabolic system ‘Highest 30 s O2 value was recorded as O2Max’ ‘Russian national team FIS Point Range: 6–201’ ‘Russian national team FIS Point Range: 2–45’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Speed 6.0 km.h−1 and 0% incline. Incline increased to 16% within 45 s after which, speed increased to 9.0 km.h−1 for 30 s and then further to M = 12.0 km.h1, F = 11.0 km.h−1 Mygind et al [67] ‘All Danish national team for 1987 World Cup’ DP SkiErg (WB); Start: 162 W Power increased by 15 W every 2 minutes until 192 W after which, participants instructed to ski ‘flat out’ Bespoke ‘multipurpose’ ergometer; Jaeger Ergo Oxyscreen metabolic system ‘O2Max was measured over the last 2 min’ Indeterminant motorised treadmill; Douglas bags; Beckman E-2 O2 analyser; Godart Capnograph CO2 analyser Sandbakk et al [73] V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp Start 16.0 km.h−1 and 5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Bonte motorised treadmill; Swenor roller-skis with standard wheels; Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘Average of the three highest consecutive 10 s values designated as O2Peak’b V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: M = 15.8 km.h−1, F = 14.0 km.h−1 (and 5% incline. Speed increased by 2.2 km.h−1 every minute for the first 2 min after which, speed increased by 1.1 km.h−1 every minute Bonte Technology motorised treadmill; Swenor roller-skis with standard wheels; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘Average of the three highest consecutive 10 s values was defined as O2Max’ V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 15.8 km.h−1 and 5% incline. Speed increased by 2.2 km.h−1 every minute for the first 2 min after which, speed increased by 1.1 km.h−1 every minute Bonte Technology motorised treadmill; Swenor roller-skis with standard wheels; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘Average of the three highest consecutive 10 s values designated as O2Peak’b V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp Start: 15.8 km.h−1 and 5% incline. Speed increased by 2.2 km.h−1 every minute for the first 2 min after which, speed increased by 1.1 km.h−1 every minute Bonte Technology motorised treadmill; Swenor roller-skis with standard wheels; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘Average of the three highest 10 s consecutive measurements determined O2Peak’b Sandbakk et al [76] Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individual speed (specifics NR), and incline 10.5% Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Indeterminate motorised treadmill; Cortex Metamax 3 metabolic system ‘Averages of three consecutive 10 s intervals with highest values determining maximal values.’ Sandbakk et al [77] Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individual speed (specifics NR) and 10.5% incline Speed increased 0.5–1.0 km.h−1 “every time the participant attained O2 that was stable during a 30 s period” Rodby RL2500 E motorised treadmill; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system with mixing chamber ‘Average of the three highest 10 s consecutive measurements determined O2Max’ Schmitt et al [78] Running on Treadmill; Continuous ‘incremental with ramp phase’. Start: 8.0 km.h−1, 2.0% incline and 1150 m altitude. Speed increased to 9.0 km.h−1 after 3 min. Incline increased by 2.0% every 3 min until 6% incline, after which speed increased to 10.0 km.h−1 until ventilatory threshold (VT). After VT, incline increased each minute (rate NRk) until 16% Indeterminant motorised treadmill; MGC Diagnostics Ultima Cardio 2® metabolic system ‘Highest 30 s average value’ ‘All top 30 in Norwegian national cup. 3 participated in Junior World Championship - Experimental Group’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 7.0 km.h−1 and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Woodway Desmo-Evo motorised treadmill; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘O2Max was taken as the highest average O2 over 60 s’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (85- 90% of predicted VO2Max) and incline 10.5%. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Rodby 2500E motorised treadmill; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘O2Max was defined as the highest average of 2 consecutive 30 s measurements’m ‘All competed at the national and international levels’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (85- 90% of predicted O2Max) and incline 6°. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Rodby 2500E motorised treadmill; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘O2Max was defined as the highest average of 2 consecutive 30 s measurements’m Woodway motorised treadmill (RUN); Thoraxtrainer Elite Poling Ergometer (DP); Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system; ‘Average of the two highest (30 s) measurements’n Woodway motorised treadmill (RUN); Thoraxtrainer Elite Poling Ergometer (DP); Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system; ‘Average of the two highest (30 s) measurements’n DP SkiErg (WB); Continuous ramp. Start: 15.0 km−1. Speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 s Stöggl et al [85] ‘Nine skiers with top-20 rankings in World Cup.’ Indeterminate motorised treadmill; Indeterminate roller-skis; AMIS 2001 metabolic system; Stöggl et al [87] ‘7 national and 9 international standard’ Rodby motorised treadmill; Pro-ski C2 roller-skis; AMIS 2001 model C metabolic system ‘Well trained from Norwegian high schools and local high performance competitive skiers’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 8.0–12.0 km.h−1 (specifics NR) and 6% incline. Incline increased by 1% every 30 s until 8.0% after which, speed increased by 0.5 km.h−1 every 30 s Woodway PPS 55 sport motorised treadmill; Cortex Metalyzer II metabolic system with mixing chamber ‘Norwegian national team 28 medal winners in junior or senior levels (specifics NR)’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (85- 90% of predicted VO2Max) and 3° incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Woodway ELG motorised treadmill; various Jaeger metabolic systems (Jaeger EOS Sprint 1989–2002 and Jaeger Oxycon pro thereafter) 10 medal winners (sex specifics NR)’ ‘National level. FIS Points: 202 ± 91’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 9.0 km.h−1 and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Rodby RL 2500 motorised treadmill (RUN); Rodby RL 3500E motorised treadmill (V2); IDT Sports roller-skis with ‘category 2’ wheels; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘Average of the two highest consecutive 30 s measurements’ V2 on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 14.0 km.h−1 and 5% incline. Speed increased by 2.0 km.h−1 each minute until 20.0 km.h−1 after which, speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Tønnessen et al [92] Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (85- 90% of predicted O2Max). Incline specifics NR. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Woodway ELG motorised treadmill; various Jaeger metabolic systems with mixing chamber (Jaeger EOS Sprint 1989–2002 and Jaeger Oxycon pro thereafter) ‘Highest average of two consecutive 30 s measurements’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 8.0 km.h−1 and NR incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Indeterminate motorised treadmill; Cosmed K5 metabolic system ‘Most excellent 15 s O2 value obtained during the incremental test was considered as O2Max’ Torvik et al [94] ‘Competed at the national level’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Speed specifics NR and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Rodby RL 2500E motorised treadmill; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘Mean of the three highest consecutive 10 s measurements of O2 at each stage was designated as O2peak’b DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: 10.0 km.h−1 and 7.0% incline Incline increased by 1.0% every minute Rodby 3500ML motorised treadmill; Swenor Fiberglass roller-skis with ‘standard resistance wheel 2’; Jaeger Oxycon pro metabolic system with mixing chamber ‘Measured every 10 s and every minute of the test, while O2 was calculated by the average three values closest (last 30 s) to every step change.’ DP on Treadmill; Continuous ramp Start: 10.0 km.h−1 and 7.0% incline Incline increased by 1.0% every minute Undebakke et al. [96] Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (RPE 12) based on submaximal stages, and 10.5% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Forcelink BV motorised treadmill (DS and RUN); Modified Concept 2 SkiErg ‘seated with ‘damper setting 5’ (DP); IDT Sports classic roller- skis with category 2 wheels; Jager Oxycon pro metabolic system ‘Average of the three highest consecutive 10 s recordings during the last minute determined O2Peak’b DS on Treadmill; Continuous ramp Start: Individualised speed (RPE 12) based on submaximal stages, and 12.0% incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute DP SkiErg (UB); Continuous ramp Start: Individualised power (RPE 12) based on submaximal stages. Power increased by 20 W min−1 Running on Treadmill; bContinuous incremental. Start: 9.0 km.h−1 and 0.0% incline. Incline increased by 2.0% every 3 min, except each 4th step in which speed increased by 0.7–1.1 km.h−1 Indeterminant motorised treadmill; Brainware metabolic system Vergès et al [98] Running on Treadmill; Continuous incremental; Speed and incline adjusted to 70%, 80%, 90% HRMax (based on previous testing) each 6 minutes. Thereafter, incline increased by 2% every 2 min Indeterminant motorised treadmill (Running); Marwe Skating 610 roller- skis with high resistance; Brainware metabolic system (Running); Jaeger Oxycon Mobile (Roller- skiing) ‘O2 was obtained by averaging the last minute before exhaustion’ Roller-skiing on tarred road with varied techniques; Discontinuous 4 km loops at 70%, 80%, 90% HRMax (based on previous testing) and ‘maximum speed’, separated by 10 minutes Walther et al.p [99] "Classified as world-class (Tier 5) according to performance caliber classification by McKay et al.…" FISComb: 6 ± 9 Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (specifics NR) and 10.5% incline Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Indeterminant motorised treadmill; Inditerminant metabolic system Running on Treadmill; Start: 2.7 km.h−1 and 10% incline. Speed increased by 1.3–1.5 km.h−1 and incline by 2% every two minutes Indeterminant motorised treadmill; COSMED; Quark CPET metabolic system Running on Treadmill; Start 9.0 km.h−1 and 3° incline. Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute until ‘close to exhaustion’ followed by supramaximal intensity stage ~ three minutes Challenger LE5000 motorised treadmill; Jaeger EOS Sprint metabolic system ‘Competitive at national level’ Running on Treadmill; Continuous ramp. Start: Individualised speed (specifics NR) and 10.5% incline Speed increased by 1.0 km.h−1 every minute Rodby RL 1700 motorised treadmill; Indeterminate metabolic system ‘Three highest 10 s successive results were averaged to obtain O2max’ Both, Known to be competing in both sprint and distance disciplines; Dist, Distance competing athlete; DP, Double Poling; DS, Diagonal Stride; F, Female; FIS, International Skiing Federation; FISComb, Known to be a combined measure of sprint and distance point scores; FISDist Distance specific point score; FISSpr, Sprint specific point score; M, Male; n = , Number of participants; NCAA, National Collegiate Athletic Association; NR, Not Recorded; PCF, Participant Classification Framework tier; RPE, Rating of Perceived Exertion; Spr, Sprint athlete; UB, Upper Body; O2Max, Maximal Oxygen Uptake; O2Peak, Maximal Oxygen Uptake for Modality - see footnotes; WB, Whole Body aValue not reported, but contextual indication that all participants were above the exclusion criterion age, i.e. > 16 years old; bRefers to assessment of O2 plateau, therefore considered a mode-specific O2Max; cBased on the date preceding sprint events; dNumbers of each performance level not separated by sex; eUnclear why so many participants data were excluded, 39 recruited but only 27 reported and 3 exclusion explanations provided; fNational skiing federation points reported for each individual; gData could only be separated for certain individuals, specific individual ages were not known to report here but all participants > 16 years old; hStudy recruited two females who did not complete the protocol, leaving exclusively male data; iRatio of junior and senior members unknown, but assumed majority senior due to reported mean age and range (20–26 years), therefore considered representative of PCF tier 4; jDescribed as recreational (‘PCF 1’) but also stated to identify as a cross-country skier (‘PCF 2’), therefore PCF 2 applied; kRate of 2% min−1 assumed as a continuation of the previously described stated for the running protocol procedures; oData were reported as 5.20 ± 0.50 but due to the same participant descriptors as Stöggl et al. [85], this was considered a duplicate sample and not considered in analyses. Study included here for relative O2Max data; pSenior season data included; p > 16 years old Descriptive Study Details Data for 1392 participants (Male (M): n = 990, Approximate Mean Age: 24 years; Female (F): 402, Approximate Mean Age: 22 years) were extracted. A total of 1667 data samples (Male (M): n = 1229, 73.7%, Female (F): n = 438, 26.3%) were recorded across all of the included studies. Studies were separated by exercise mode or skiing technique to determine O2Max resulting in 52 studies for running (Total: n = 1040; M: n = 684, 65.8%; F: n = 356, 34.2%), 18 studies for Diagonal Stride (DS) on a treadmill (Total: n = 234; M: n = 201, 85.9%; F: n = 33, 14.1%), 1 study for DS in the field (Total: n = 7; M: n = 7, 100.0%), 8 studies for Double Poling (DP) on a treadmill (Total: n = 86; M: n = 68, 79.1%; F: n = 18, 20.9%), 6 studies for DP on a Ski Ergometer (Unrestricted) (Total: n = 84; M: n = 69, 82.1%; F: n = 15, 17.9%), 2 studies for DP on a Ski Ergometer (Upper Body Only) (Total: n = 37; M: n = 37, 100%), 2 studies for V1 (skate skiing technique [103]) on a treadmill (Total: n = 33; M: n = 25, 75.8%; F: n = 8, 24.2%), 8 studies for V2 (skate skiing technique [103]) on a treadmill (Total: n = 126; M: n = 118, 93.7%; F: n = 8, 6.3%), and 2 studies using a variety of skiing techniques in the same trial (Total: n = 20; M: n = 20, 100%). Eight studies [36, 56–58, 67, 79, 94, 100] reported multiple assessment points using the same technique, as part of their research design (longitudinal and/or cross-over intervention design), requiring data to be combined [27]. Relative O2Max: Treadmill Running Of the 47 studies measuring relative O2Max values from treadmill running protocol in male participants, 52 groups of data were extracted and separated by PCF score. PCF explained 42% of variance in O2Max (τ = 6.51, R2 = 0.42) and group means increased with PCF (Fig. 3; τ2 = 42.4). Of the 26 studies measuring relative O2Max in females using a treadmill running protocol, 34 groups of data were extracted and separated by PCF score. PCF explained 70% of variance in O2Max (τ = 5.36, R2 = 0.80) and group means increased with PCF (Fig. 4; τ2 = 28.7). Male relative maximal oxygen uptake data for included studies, sub-grouped by participant classification framework. PCF, Participant Classification Framework; O2Max, Maximal Oxygen Uptake Female relative maximal oxygen uptake data for included studies, sub-grouped by participant classification framework. PCF, Participant Classification Framework; O2Max, Maximal Oxygen Uptake Absolute O2Max: Treadmill Running Of the 26 included studies measuring absolute O2Max value in males using a treadmill running protocol, 32 groups of data were extracted and separated by PCF score. PCF explained 80% of variance in O2Max (τ = 0.59, R2 = 0.80) and group means increased with PCF (Fig. 5; τ2 = 0.35). Of the 16 included studies measuring absolute O2Max in females using a treadmill running protocol, 23 groups of data were extracted and separated by PCF score. PCF explained 66% of variance in O2Max (τ = 0.34, R2 = 0.66) and group means increased with PCF, with the exception of tier 4. (Fig. 6; τ2 = 0.12). Male absolute maximal oxygen uptake data for included studies, sub-grouped by participant classification framework. PCF, Participant Classification Framework; O2Max, Maximal Oxygen Uptake Female absolute maximal oxygen uptake data for included studies, sub-grouped by participant classification framework. PCF, Participant Classification Framework; O2Max, Maximal Oxygen Uptake Benchmark O2Max Values Pooled group analysis of each PCF tier produced key values that may be considered benchmark O2Max values and are summarised in Table 4 and Fig. 7. Table 4Key data for relative and absolute O2Max benchmarking using running-based incremental exercise tests separated by Participant Classification Framework tier and sexPCF TierPooled MeanMinMaxSE ( ±)95% CIPooled MeanMinMaxSE ( ±)95% CIMale Relative (mL·kg−1·min−1)Female Relative (mL kg-1 min-1)World Class (5)82.877.985.63.779.1, 93.570.768.672.61.567.8, 73.6Elite (4)75.458.282.11.273.1, 77.865.253.871.20.863.6, 66.9National (3)70.862.277.91.168.6, 73.061.457.968.41.059.4, 63.3Development (2)65.956.672.22.660.7, 71.056.753.859.81.553.7, 59.7Recreational (1)53.749.957.23.846.2, 61.244.644.644.64.535.8, 53.4Male Absolute (mL min−1)Female Relative (mL min−1)World Class (5)6.336.026.540.126.09, 6.574.324.274.460.124.09, 4.56Elite (4)5.875.346.340.085.35, 6.403.923.444.300.073.78, 4.06National (3)5.184.055.510.114.97, 5.394.023.824.340.133.75, 4.28Development (2)4.754.305.220.164.44, 5.073.503.303.640.103.32, 3.69Recreational (1)3.903.903.900.343.24, 4.562.602.602.600.102.16, 3.04CI, Confidence Interval; Max., Maximum; Min., Minimum; PCF, Participant Classification Framework; SE, Standard Error; O2Max, Maximal Oxygen Uptake Key data for relative and absolute O2Max benchmarking using running-based incremental exercise tests separated by Participant Classification Framework tier and sex CI, Confidence Interval; Max., Maximum; Min., Minimum; PCF, Participant Classification Framework; SE, Standard Error; O2Max, Maximal Oxygen Uptake Summary statistics for participant classification framework subgroup mean averages. A: Maximal oxygen uptake relative to body mass. B: Percentage differences of mean maximal oxygen uptake relative to body mass between males and females. C: Absolute maximal oxygen uptake. D: Percentage differences of absolute maximal oxygen uptake between males and females. • = Males • = Females Discussion Overview This review is the first to systematically group data with retrospective use of a PCF, to quantify relationships between O2Max and XCS using meta-regressions. Results established both absolute and relative O2Max running measures, tend to increase with each PCF tier in males and females. The tier-wise trend was most evident in relative measurements. These findings provide a quantitative description of O2Max across performance strata, and contribute empirical context to the prominent emphasis that O2Max has traditionally received within XCS. Athlete Classification Performance classification was a central challenge to interpreting O2Max values across the performance spectrum. Studies varied considerably in their descriptions of participants and athletes (e.g. national-team status, level of competition, or general “elite” labels). Attempting to standardise athlete performance definitions, this study retrospectively applied an amended PCF (Table 1). The original framework provides broad definitions but with flexibility to enhance applicability [23]. This flexibility is not necessarily a weaknesses of the PCF, but rather demonstrates the complexity of the challenge it attempts to address. Thresholds of FIS points based on 20th and 300th position, were calculated to assign PCF tiers 3–5 to studies reporting this value. Owing to FIS point reporting inconsistencies, ‘overall performance’ was evaluated by averaging sprint and distance points (Table 2). These values offer guidance for prospective studies using the PCF, preferably alongside confirmatory quantitative data [104]. Introduced in 1994, FIS points were initially a single score reflecting distance performance. Separate sprint points were introduced in 2000, with the majority of athletes competing in both disciplines [3]. Therefore, studies since 2000, reporting single FIS point values, may represent sprint, distance or combined values similar to the approach taken in this study. Despite these options, it often remains unclear which discipline is reported [39, 49, 52, 53]. Where quantitative competitive information was absent, classification relied on the contextual qualitative details [33, 43, 47]. Although classification in this review followed a structured, independent and blinded decision process, residual uncertainty could not be entirely eliminated. These issues underscore that classification represents a reporting limitation of the available literature rather than an evaluative judgement on individual studies, many of which were not designed with performance-tier comparison as a primary purpose. It is also important to recognise variations in international standards across different countries. Klusiewicz and Cempa [59], and Drzazga et al. [45], both described their participants as ‘members of the Polish National Team’. A qualifying quantitative descriptor might have suggested these studies be considered more representative of national level athletes. Yet, in the absence of a quantitative description, the description of ‘National Team’ status was inferred as an international standard of performance, although seemingly far below the international average standard. This variation of national standards, teamed with a comparative lack of female data, likely explains the observed slight drop in pooled average absolute O2Max for tier 4 females compared with tier 3. The tier 3 average was calculated from just three studies [22, 58, 81]. One group of female participants in Bergh’s [22] study were scored as tier 4. In this case, it was inferred that despite not winning international medals, they had likely competed, still representing a tier 4 standard. The described ‘less successful’ athletes were then considered representative of tier 3, using the prior group as a reference standard, although these participants may have equally been representative of tier 4, also. The participants of the study by Johansen et al. [58] were more unambiguously described as being ‘national level’, whilst Solli et al. [81] reported FIS points aligning with tier 3 based on the thresholds put forward by this study. Of the 24 participants, 9 were represented within the Johansen et al. [58] study, containing Norwegian athletes, who likely represent the extreme highs of each performance tier, based on the nation’s historical success in XCS. In more contemporary studies reporting pre-assigned PCF tiers, these too should not be regarded as self-evident. Researchers should avoid split tier reporting (i.e. between PCF Tier 2/3) and identify a single, most representative tier. For example, Holsbrekken et al. [105], reported their participants as: “…highly trained and elite XC skiers that regularly participated in national and international races, while the recreational XC skiers should be classified as trained and highly trained.” It is unclear which PCF tier is the most appropriate, as the language implies the competitive group included tier 3 and tier 4 athletes, without quantifying the numbers of each. Likewise, the ‘recreational’ group (itself a tier 1 descriptor) could represent tier 2 or tier 3 participants, with use of the phrases ‘trained’ and ‘highly trained’. Another example of ambiguous PCF reporting is provided within Staunton et al. [106]. Their study compared a group of cyclists with a group of cross-country skiers, stating: “These participants represent tier 4 and tier 5 level athletes according to the sports participant classification framework.” Similar to Holsbrekken et al. [105], no details were provided about the distribution of athletes across tiers or sports. Such ambiguity undermines the PCF’s purpose of standardised classification. For this reason, these studies were excluded from this study. Future studies should prioritise clarity to maintain the framework’s usefulness. Defining and Calculating O2Max Defining O2Max and O2Peak remains complex due to varied criteria, calculation methods and interpretations. O2Max is often considered the limit of aerobic capacity, characterised by a O2 plateau despite increasing workload [16, 106, 107]. This is typically supported by secondary criteria; respiratory quotient > 1.10, blood lactate > 8.0 mmol·L, heart rate (HR) near HRMax, and maximal or near-maximal rating of perceived exertion [108, 109], though the widespread accuracy of these are debated [110–112]. A O2 plateau was the accepted definition for the purpose of this study [16]. However, it must be acknowledged that the presence of O2 plateau during incremental testing, is not guaranteed nor universally identifiable [113]. Consequently, O2Peak, the highest value recorded during testing, is often reported. Although this may equal O2Max, O2Peak suggests a limit either could not be reached or could not be confirmed [110, 114]. To address this, supramaximal verification bouts have been proposed to confirm the presence of a plateau [110, 115]. However, universal use of verification bouts, and the abandonment of O2Peak, is also controversial [114–121]. An alternative rationale for using O2Peak, common in XCS is measurement variances across exercise modes and the total recruited muscle mass [1]. Studies measuring O2 using DP report lower ‘maximal’ values [34, 55, 72]. For example, when comparing tier 5 athletes, DP O2 values (5.36 L·min−1) were lower than those reported during DS (6.23 L·min−1) and running (6.00 L·min−1) modalities [55]. This phenomenon is even clearer in lesser trained individuals [57]. However, this convention can render such O2Peak designation indistinguishable from the former justification of O2Peak, representing an unconfirmed O2Max. For this study, studies reporting O2Peak with reference to a plateau were considered representative of a ‘mode specific’ O2Max and therefore relevant for inclusion [4, 36, 50, 52–54, 74, 76, 81, 95, 97]. In contrast, if only secondary criteria were reported, these were not considered sufficient to overrule the original study definition and were excluded [6, 122–140]. It is recommended that O2Max be used in cases where a O2 limit has been verified [109, 110], whilst O2Peak remains relevant if a limit is unverified [114, 116, 117]. To account for the important consideration of muscle mass, reporting mode specific O2Max (i.e. O2MaxDP, O2MaxSkiErg, O2MaxV2, etc.) may reduce ambiguities when comparing across exercise modes or skiing techniques [114, 115]. In addition to challenges associated with defining O2Max and O2Peak, calculation differences and reporting oversights may induce discrepancies when comparing values [104, 141]. Reducing the number of breaths or time used to calculate averages, increases calculated O2Max by as much as 10% in untrained individuals [141]. To account for this, Martin-Rincon et al. [141] suggested conversion equations, to standardise values from different calculation approaches. However, these equations require agreed reporting standards, currently not sufficiently present for the analyses carried out in this study. Furthermore, these equations have not been verified for use within populations with exceptionally high O2Max (i.e. tier 5 XCS athletes with substantially > 60 mL·kg−1·min−1). Nevertheless, such variances should be considered and may explain some variability observed in certain tiers. O2Max in XCS The worth of enhanced O2Max for endurance performance is not a subject of debate. Clearly, athletes wishing to compete at the highest sporting level must demonstrate elevated values compared to an ‘average’ individual. Predictably then, the findings of this study demonstrate O2Max increases with PCF tier in male and female cross-country skiers across heterogeneous performance standards. Interestingly, the findings of this study suggest O2Max continues to distinguish ‘successful’ (Tier 5) from ‘less successful’ (Tier 4) internationally competitive XCS athletes [11, 22], which is not always the case in other endurance sports [16, 18]. Such an observation potentially highlights why O2Max is so highly regarded within XCS. Mahood et al. [12] found large correlations between O2Max and ranking (r = 0.66, p < 0.05) and very large correlations between O2Max and simulated 10 km time-trial performance (r = 0.74, p < 0.05). Additionally, Carlsson et al. reported very large correlations between O2Max and sprint performance, measured by race speed in males (r = 0.86, p = 0.0069) [13] and FIS points in females (r = 0.81, p = 0.0043) [14]. These observations align with established exercise physiology principles: enhanced oxidative phosphorylation increases O2, delaying increasing anaerobic contributions and consequently fatigue, thereby improving performance [7, 16]. However, examining individual data reported in the data published by Carlsson et al. [14], suggests this study was not as homogenous as the term ‘elite’ may lead some to infer. Digitisation of these data and the thresholds set in this study, suggest one participant would have qualified as PCF Tier 5 (< 31 FIS points), four participants PCF tier 4 (< 111 FIS points), and five as PCF tier 3 (> 111 FIS points). Therefore, the finding that VO2Max correlated with performance is unsurprising, demonstrating the limitation of drawing conclusions on the basis of single studies. The O2Max values of tiers 4 and 5 encompass the full spectrum of international XCS competition standards. A systematic review investigating the benchmarking of female cycling performance suggested even broader distribution of O2Max in their highest two performance levels [142]. In a process not dissimilar to this study, performance level 4 individuals (n = 13) averaged 52.6 ± 3.8 mL·kg⁻1·min⁻1 and 3.10 ± 0.30 L·min⁻1, whilst performance level 5 individuals (n = 11) averaged 61.4 ± 3.4 mL·kg⁻1·min⁻1, and 3.60 ± 0.20 L·min⁻1 respectively. This demonstrates that O2Max is typically higher in XCS than cycling, possibly owing to the importance of aerobic capacity in XCS and the aforementioned differences in muscle mass recruitment [143, 144]. Despite Decroix et al. [142] employing similar procedures to this study, their definitions for performance level were broader than those incorporated in this study. Performance level 4 individuals were described as ‘highly trained, well trained, endurance trained and highly trained competitive’ more aligned with the descriptors of PCF tier 3 in this study, whilst performance level 5 individuals were simply broadly described as ‘professional cyclists’, more aligned with the descriptors combining PCF tier 4 and 5 in this study. These discrepancies in performance definitions, make comparisons across sports challenging. In a study of ‘world-class’ cyclists, males recorded O2Max values of 71.3 ± 4.2 mL·kg⁻1·min⁻1 and 5.02 ± 0.36 L·min⁻1 [145], demonstrating an apparent alignment to values reported in XCS for PCF tier 4. Whilst these O2Max values for the cyclist population may have been classified as ‘elite’ (PCF tier 4) using benchmarks predating the PCF [146], the group included ‘world class’, such as World Championship podium finishers, more aligned with PCF tier 5, This suggests XCS athletes possess higher O2Max values. In the same study [145], ‘amateur competitive cyclists’ (PCF tier 3) showed very similar O2Max values (69.5 ± 5.0 mL·kg⁻1·min⁻1, 4.86 ± 0.43 L·min⁻1), to those of the PCF tier 5 group. While limited to a single representative study, this example suggests that O2Max variability in XCS is broader compared to more nuanced differences between PCF tiers in male cycling. In addition, Sandbakk et al. [4] compared a range of physiological variables between more homogenous populations, world class (PCF Tier 5) and nationally competing (PCF Tier 3) athletes. Results demonstrated clear relationships between O2Peak and performance when comparing groups (Tier 3 vs. Tier 5) (p < 0.05), but no significant relationships within-groups (p > 0.05). Supporting this, Tønnessen et al. (2015) [92] found statistically non-significant differences between mean O2Max of medallists and non-medallists in both distance and sprint XCS events, for males and females, giving brief mention to working economy and fractional utilisation of O2Max as being other factors determining performance. Differences in distance events were described as ‘moderate’, whilst differences for sprint events were described as ‘trivial’. Pooled data from the appraised literature in this study demonstrate the importance of O2Max to distinguish differences in PCF tiers, even at tiers 4 and 5, but further empirical evidence may be required in XCS to be confident of this finding [92]. Individual athlete case studies were excluded owing to the lack of central tendency statistics necessary for subgroup regression analyses undertaken in this study [147–149]. Formenti et al. [147], did not report O2Max values and would subsequently have been excluded under criterion 5. Hladnick et al. [148] reported a O2Max value of 63.2 mL·kg−1·min−1 in a Slovenian national cross-country team member (PCF tier 4), whilst Talsnes et al. [149] reported O2Max values of 5.59 L·min−1 and 79.9 mL·min−1·kg−1 in an athlete classified as PCF tier 5. Both of these case studies used the G3 skate technique. Furthermore, Norwegian Bjørn Dæhlie’s reputed O2Max has been reported as ~ 96.0 mL·min−1, but owing to the non-peer reviewed sources of this value, these data were also not included. The observed trend of O2Max increasing with PCF tier was constant across both relative (Fig. 7A) and absolute measurements (Fig. 7C) in males. However, whilst females also demonstrated this trend in relative measures (Fig. 7A), this was not as obviously consistent in absolute measures (Fig. 7C). This supports the assertion that body mass of international (PCF tier 4) and world-class (PCF tier 5) female athletes is a contributory factor to performance success [150–152]. A caveat to this point is the number of studies [22, 58, 81] and relatively low combined sample size (n = 24), contributing to the PCF tier 3 subgroup mean. Johansen et al. [58] reported values of three national level female athletes at three distinct time points, combined here to produce a sample size of 9. One participant reported an absolute value > 5.00 L·min−1, during their second repeat assessment, elevating the average for this study. Despite the study explicitly reporting their participants as being ‘national level’ (PCF tier 3) it is possible this individual transitioned to international standard during the course of the study, which may have resulted in an inflated PCF tier 3 subgroup average. The findings of this study also highlighted sex differences between male and female athletes. Female relative O2Max differences ranged between 13–17% lower, whilst absolute values were between 22 and 33% lower. The relative values recorded in this study agree with a recent study by Solli et al. [152], reporting females as typically demonstrating between 10 and 27% lower values. However, whilst overlapping, the range of absolute values reported in this study are slightly lower than those of Solli et al. [152] who reported a range between 30 and 63%. This slight divergence is possibly explained by the present study only focussing on running as a testing modality and only investigating cross-country skiers. Solli et al. [152] meanwhile, included ‘O2Peak’ values from protocols including diagonal stride and double polling, as well as the G2 and G3 skate techniques. Furthermore, Solli et al. [152] included data for a broader range of Nordic skiers, such as biathletes and ski mountaineers, as well as cross-country skiing athletes, potentially impacting direct transferability across these studies. Practical Application For academic assessments of XCS studies, the amended PCF (Table 1) may serve as a guide for future researchers [23]. Additionally, The findings of this study may inform various performance-related practices. While long-term athletic development is complex and often involves exceptions (e.g., late vs. early developers), endurance performance maturation remains critical for XCS success. The PCF tiers align with key athletic development stages, ranging from recreationally active tier 1 individuals to world-class medallists at tier 5. Coaches may find the reported values valuable for evaluating their athletes' performance potential. For instance, an athlete with a significantly lower-than-expected O2Max for their development phase is unlikely to achieve competitiveness without substantial progress, which may be challenging to attain efficiently. Thus, the O2Max benchmarks outlined by PCF tier may assist in talent identification, talent transfer from other sports, and athlete selection criteria when used alongside other metrics [153, 154]. Limitations This study is not without limitations. Firstly, insufficient data were identified across sufficient PCF tiers to meaningfully analyse XCS specific techniques. Despite this, previous research suggests O2Max values between running and DS skiing to be comparable [136]. Running is still a test modality widely used within XCS due to its practical advantages over skiing techniques (i.e. ski treadmills are very expensive). Therefore, the findings in this study remain practically relevant. Secondly, to broaden the inclusion of data, this study included all O2Max data irrespective of calculation method, potentially influencing the comparability of studies [106, 115]. Finally, this study did not find sufficient data to allow segregation of data by distance or sprint categories, and therefore the findings of this study are representative of overall XCS performance, with further specific consideration of sprint and distance demands required in the future. Future Directions Comparable to many areas of sports science [155, 156], females are currently under-represented in XCS research (see Sect. "Descriptive Study Details"). Future studies should consider increased female representation, or exclusive female representation to address knowledge gaps. Although outside the scope of this review, other populations, such as para-athletes, are also likely to be under-represented. Consideration as to the most effective techniques to assess para-athlete performance may be considered by future researchers. This review demonstrates some considerations that need to be given to PCF scoring in XCS, such as the alignment of the FIS point system with the PCF. However, as FIS are changeable from year to year, the points of those in 20th and 300th position will continually fluctuate. As such, the numbers in this study are presented as a guide and may require future updates, or discipline specific considerations. Most XCS research has been conducted using running. This is unsurprising, owing to the later development of treadmills that safely support roller-skiing, and the wealth of data that exists for running tests. Transitioning to more externally valid methods of assessment, such as roller-skiing, has been debated [80, 136]. Nevertheless, given the continuing increasing accessibility of alternatives (e.g. Double Poling Ski Ergometers), the number of studies utilising “ski-specific” performance assessments are likely to increase. Future research should continue to investigate these XCS specific movements to assess sport-specific applications. Conclusions Re-examining previous data suggests the current heterogeneity even within the international standard (elite and world-class) XCS athletes may explain some of the emphasis placed on the importance of O2Max throughout XCS research. Nevertheless, this study provides clear evidence of the importance of O2Max to XCS performance, often a differentiating factor between performance tiers and therefore should be a particular focus of those working with and developing XCS athletes. Acknowledgements The authors wish to acknowledge and thank the library services of the universities of the authors included in this study for their support in locating additional sources used in the production of this review. Author contributions SM conceived of the idea for this review with input from TM, LF, MK, CE and KR. SM and TM were responsible for data analysis. SM wrote the first draft of the manuscript. TM, LF, MK, CE and KR revised and co-authored subsequent revisions. All the named authors, read and approved the final version of the manuscript. Funding The authors have no funding to declare. Availability of Data and Materials Data available on request to the corresponding author. Declarations Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate Not applicable. Competing interests The authors of this study have no conflicts of interest to declare. Footnotes Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement Data available on request to the corresponding author.