Ontogeny of postgenital leaf sheath fusion in Commelina erecta L. (Commelinaceae) Authors: Arthur K. Chan, Michael J. Scanlon, Gladys F. A. Melo-de-Pinna Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Main conclusion Commelina erecta L. leaf sheaths fuse postgenitally without KN1 ortholog expression, indicating a distinct molecular mechanism for sheath fusion in Commelinaceae, contrasting it from sheath formation in Poaceae.AbstractLeaf sheaths are common structures within monocotyledonous, being open or closed depending on the separation of their margins. In Commelinaceae, a family of monocotyledonous plants with simple leaves and alternate phyllotaxy, their sheaths are closed. In Poaceae, which often have open sheaths, there has been evidence of KNOX genes affecting the fusion in sheaths in this family. The present study, therefore, investigated the nature of the sheath fusion and the expression of KN1 ortholog at the leaf sheaths in Commelina erecta L. Samples of the shoot apex and leaf primordia were subjected to scanning electron microscopy and optical microscopy techniques with serial sections in paraffin. Samples of apical meristems from specimens of C. erecta were also subjected to in situ hybridization to verify the expression of KNOX within its leaves, with the probe sequence established by degenerate RT-PCR. The anatomical analysis revealed that sheaths of C. erecta undergo post-genital fusion. In situ hybridizations in C. erecta revealed no expression of KN1 ortholog at the region of the fused sheath margins. The post-genital fusion indicates, therefore, the previous separation of the sheath margins, which, associated with lack of expression of KN1 at this region, suggests a distinct molecular mechanism of leaf fusion in Commelinaceae, contrasting it from sheath formation in Poaceae.Graphic abstract Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00425-026-05029-4. Introduction Leaf development in angiosperms is complex and depends on the interactions of genetic regulators and the actions of phytohormones, such as auxin, cytokinin, and gibberellin, that modulate their morphology and anatomy (Melo-de-Pinna & Cruz 2020). In monocotyledons, the leaves are usually subdivided into a distal lamina and a basal sheath, a structure that protects the shoot apical meristem (SAM) (Esau 1965; Faden 1998). The leaf sheath has been the subject of phylogenetic and ontogenetic studies in recent years focusing on the molecular development of its margins (Richardson & Hake 2018; Richardson et al. 2021b). Regarding this theme, a notable case can be found in Commelinaceae, a family of herbaceous and perennial monocotyledonous plants, sometimes epiphytic, described as having simple leaves with smooth margins, alternate distichous or spiral phyllotaxy, an absence of ligules, often involute vernation and closed tubular sheaths (Faden 1998). Many species of Commelinaceae present in the leaf sheaths a line of trichomes parallel to the stem axis, occurring in the region opposite to the leaf blade, sometimes extending to their respective internodes (Saunders 1922). This paper postulated that the line of hairs located in the sheath of these species is signaling the region of the fused margins, thus being a likely marker of the marginal domain in this region. Fusions in plant organs can be postgenital, occurring after an initial separation of the organs, or congenital, never having had a previous separation between them; in some plants postgenital fusion predominates in the apical positions of the plant, whereas congenital fusion prevails in the basal portion (Verbeke 1992; Sokoloff et al. 2018). However, it is still unknown what type of fusion occurs in the sheaths of Commelinaceae. The closed sheath morphology in the Commelinaceae contrasts with those found in Poaceae, which generally develop an open sheath whose margins typically overlap, but exhibit no fusion (Esau 1965; Dahlgren et al. 1985; Richardson & Hake 2018). The leaf primordia of Poaceae are ring-shaped, in such a way that they are inserted into the stem axis by a circular base called the “disc of insertion” (Sharman 1942). The delimitation of sheath margins is, therefore, necessary for their future separation to occur. It is known that in Zea mays the delimitation of these regions depends on the transport of auxin, as detected by the expression of SPARSE INFLORESCENCE1 (SPI1), and auxin biosynthetic gene that is expressed at the edge of the two future margins (Johnston et al., 2015; Richardson & Hake 2018). The influence of this auxin on the leaf sheath was also tested by applying an auxin inhibitor to Zea mays L. individuals grown in growth medium (Scanlon 2003). Under these conditions, the sheath of the fourth plastochron was unable to separate its margins and developed into a tubular shape, presenting a comparable morphology as the fused leaf sheaths of Commelinaceae. Application of an auxin inhibitor in Zea mays also resulted in the ectopic accumulation of KN1, belonging to the KNOX class 1 gene family, in the closed sheaths, precisely in the region where the two margins would be defined (Scanlon 2003). Class 1 KNOX proteins promote indeterminacy in the SAM and expanding internodes, but are down-regulated in newly initiated leaf primordia (reviewed in Tsuda & Hake 2016). The ectopic presence of KN1 in the overlapping sheaths of Zea mays, on the other hand, raised the hypothesis that they are also responsible in this species for the determination and separation of the left and right margins (Scanlon 2003). This data raises questions as to the organ-specific expression of KN1 orthologs in Commelinaceae, specifically whether or not there is KNOX accumulation at the site of sheath margin fusion. Assuming that the molecular regulatory system remains conserved between Poaceae and Commelinaceae, the regulation of leaf primordia development by these genes could bring a better understanding of the developmental process of the fusion of their sheath margins in Commelinaceae, in addition to the role of KNOX ortholog in this process. However, it is still not known how this gene are expressed in the meristems of Commelinaceae; investigations are complicated by the lack of a sequenced genome. Thus, the present study combines anatomical analyses with cell/tissue-specific investigations of gene expression during the development of closed sheath margins within Commelina erecta L. Materials and methods Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) The formation of the sheath margins of Commelina erecta L. was investigated by Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM). Samples of leaf primordia of Commelina erecta L. were subjected to dehydration in an increasing alcoholic series (70% ethanol, 85% ethanol, 90% ethanol, and twice in 100% ethanol) at 2 h intervals. They were then dried at the critical point of CO2, mounted on stubs and covered with gold for 2 min and subsequently examined under SEM (Silveira 1989). The observation was made using a Zeiss Microscope (DSM 940), belonging to the Electron Microscopy Laboratory of the Institute of Biosciences of the University of São Paulo. Light microscopy Samples of vegetative shoot apices of 3–5 individuals of each species were fixed in FAA 50% (formalin, ethanol 50% and acetic acid) subjected to an ascending butanol series, then transferred to mineral oil and embedded in Paraplast Plus®, following the methodology described by Johansen (1940). The samples were cross-sectioned at a thickness of 10 μm, in a rotary microtome, subsequently deparaffinized and stained with Astra Blue 1% and Safranin 50%, and then mounted on permanent slides in Entellan™ (Ruzin 1999). The photographic record was made using the IM50 Image Digitization System, coupled to the Leica DMLB microscope of the Plant Anatomy Laboratory of the Institute of Biosciences of the University of São Paulo. Sample preparation for in situ hybridization (Strable & Satterlee 2021) Samples of apical meristems from Commelina erecta L. individuals were subjected to in situ hybridization to verify the expression and anatomical position of orthologs of KN1 in the sheaths of Commelinaceae (Strable & Satterlee 2021). The stem tips of C. erecta were cut and fixed in FAA 3.7% (Formalin, Ethanol 3.7%, Acetic Acid) with the vials in a container with ice, followed by an ethanol series at 4ºC, under gentle agitation, and left overnight. The material was transferred to Paraplast Plus® inside an oven at 60ºC, where it remained for 3 days, with the paraplast being renewed twice a day. The day before in situ hybridization, the incorporated material of C. erecta was sectioned with 10 µm slices following the methodology of Ruzin (1999), with the paraplast tapes extended on Probe-On-Plus slides with the application of water treated with DEPC (diethyl dicarbonate). Gene cloning and probe preparation RNA from C. erecta was extracted and subsequently reverse-transcribed into complementary DNA (cDNA). Fragments of KN1 homologue were then isolated by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Due to the lack of sequenced genomes in Commelinaceae, the probe sequence was established by degenerate RT-PCR at an alignment temperature of 40 °C, based on conserved regions of these genes in species closest to Commelina with sequenced genomes (Ji et al 2010), with members of Musa and Zingiber (Order Zingiberales) being the closest sequences available. All reactions were prepared with 1 μl of cDNA and 9 μl of master mix and 1.5 μl for each primer diluted 1/10 (adding 3 μl for the forward and reverse primers), totaling 18 μl for the entire reaction. The designed primers can be found in Table 1. Table 1Nucleotide sequences of the designed primers of KN1, with positions containing variable nucleotides marked with the IUPAC degenerate nucleotide codePrimerSequencesKN1 FWDGGTSAARTWCAGGGARGAGCKN1 REVCKCKTCCKYTGRTTKATGAACC Table 1Nucleotide sequences of the designed primers of KN1, with positions containing variable nucleotides marked with the IUPAC degenerate nucleotide codePrimerSequencesKN1 FWDGGTSAARTWCAGGGARGAGCKN1 REVCKCKTCCKYTGRTTKATGAACC Nucleotide sequences of the designed primers of KN1, with positions containing variable nucleotides marked with the IUPAC degenerate nucleotide code Phylogenetic analysis The acquired sequences from the probe of the ortholog of KN1 of C. erecta (available at Online Resource 1) had its protein sequence translated, and was compared with protein sequences recorded from members of the KNOX gene family, obtained through BLASTN searches in NCBI (Table 2). These sequences were then aligned by the ClustalW1.4 algorithm, and visualized through the Bioedit software (Hall 1999). The same sequences were then analyzed phylogenetically through the maximum likelihood criterion, with the selection of models and phylogenetic analyses performed through the IQTREE program (Trifinopoulos et al. 2016), and visualized with iTol software (Letunic and Bork 2024). Table 2KN1 orthologs used for the alignment and phylogenetic analysisOrthologSpeciesFamilyOrderGenbank accession numberAaKN1Asparagus asparagoidesAsparagaceaeAsparagalesBAM08928.1AtKNAT1Arabidopsis thalianaBrassicaceaeBrassicalesAAM45030.1CpKN1Cucurbita pepoCucurbitaceaeCucurbitalesXP_023536402.1BpKNOX3Brachypodium distachyonPoaceaePoalesXP_010230586.1OsKN1Oryza sativaPoaceaePoalesNP_001389174.1OsOSH1Oryza sativaPoaceaePoalesABF98653.1PhKN1Panicum halliiPoaceaePoalesXP_025795239.1TaKN1Triticum aestivumPoaceaePoalesXP_044368246.1ZmKN1Zea maysPoaceaePoalesONM08817.1TlKN1Typha latifoliaTyphaceaePoalesXP_072989408.1CiKN1Canna indicaCannaceaeZingiberalesWOK92258.1MaKN1Musa acuminataMusaceaeZingiberalesXP_009411331.3ZoKN1Zingiber officinaleZingiberaceaeZingiberalesXP_042444176.1 Table 2KN1 orthologs used for the alignment and phylogenetic analysisOrthologSpeciesFamilyOrderGenbank accession numberAaKN1Asparagus asparagoidesAsparagaceaeAsparagalesBAM08928.1AtKNAT1Arabidopsis thalianaBrassicaceaeBrassicalesAAM45030.1CpKN1Cucurbita pepoCucurbitaceaeCucurbitalesXP_023536402.1BpKNOX3Brachypodium distachyonPoaceaePoalesXP_010230586.1OsKN1Oryza sativaPoaceaePoalesNP_001389174.1OsOSH1Oryza sativaPoaceaePoalesABF98653.1PhKN1Panicum halliiPoaceaePoalesXP_025795239.1TaKN1Triticum aestivumPoaceaePoalesXP_044368246.1ZmKN1Zea maysPoaceaePoalesONM08817.1TlKN1Typha latifoliaTyphaceaePoalesXP_072989408.1CiKN1Canna indicaCannaceaeZingiberalesWOK92258.1MaKN1Musa acuminataMusaceaeZingiberalesXP_009411331.3ZoKN1Zingiber officinaleZingiberaceaeZingiberalesXP_042444176.1 KN1 orthologs used for the alignment and phylogenetic analysis In situ hybridization The procedure for In situ hybridization is based on Jackson (1992) and Juarez et al. (2004), described below: the slides transported to a metal support were deparaffinized in histoclear solution, followed by a descending ethanol series, application of PBS (NaCl and Na2HPO4) and an ascending ethanol series. The material was then stored in an airtight container with a little ethanol at the bottom. After preparation, the KN1 probe was then diluted, denatured at 80 °C, cooled on ice, and briefly centrifuged. The processed probe was then added to the hybridization solution (NaCl, Tris–HCl, sodium phosphate, EDTA, formamide, dextran sulfate, Denhardt's solution, and nonspecific tRNA), and the mixture was spread on the slides. The slides were then adhered in pairs and stored inside a box with formamide, remaining overnight at 50 °C. The next day, the slides were subjected to a series of washes with NTE buffer, saline-sodium citrate buffer (SSC), Roche Blocking Solution, and BSA/Triton-X 100 solution, when the anti-digoxigenin antibody was subsequently added to the material. After two hours, the slides were washed with TBS and TN buffers and left overnight. Once the staining was sufficiently clear, the slides were washed with TE (Tris–HCl and EDTA), rapidly dehydrated with an ethanol series, washed in histoclear, dried and mounted with Permount. The images were analyzed and taken with a Leica DMLB optical microscope. Results Sheath formation During later stages of the leaf primordia in C. erecta, the sheaths develop free margins (Fig. 1), around the fourth to fifth plastochron. This is evident by the fact that the margins of the sheath are demarcated from the leaf blade by the presence of clefts delimiting the future auricles, characteristic of the species. Earlier stages of leaf primordia development, from the third to fourth plastochron, show a little expansion of the sheath, but pronounced growth of the leaf blade and internode, revealing that the sheath expands later in relation to these regions (Fig. 1). Cross sections at the apex of the fused portion of the sheath of C. erecta (Fig. 2) reveal a histological transition of the epidermis of the two margins in contact: initially separated, the two epidermis layers come into contact, undergo cellular changes as indicated by the presence of elongated, intervening cells that will eventually become part of the mesophyll.Fig. 1Stages of development of the Commelina erecta sheath. A Adult plant. B An overview of the adult leaf. Lm – Limb. Sh – sheath. C–D. Initiation and primary morphogenesis, with the region of the constitutive base marked by the arrow. E Stage of expansion of the leaf blade, still without the expanded sheath. F-G. Stage of expansion of the sheath, with free margins; with the upper portion of the sheath delimited by the presence of the region of formation of the future auricle, marked by the arrow. H. Adult leaf, with the presence of the closed sheath and auricles (arrow)Fig. 2Commelina erecta sheath in primordium at the fifth plastochron, undergoing the process of postgenital fusion revealed in serial transverse sections of the stem apical region. A Region of fused margins marked by the arrow. B Region of the sheath with free margins. C–E Transition between free and fused portion of the sheath. F–G. Region with fused margins Stages of development of the Commelina erecta sheath. A Adult plant. B An overview of the adult leaf. Lm – Limb. Sh – sheath. C–D. Initiation and primary morphogenesis, with the region of the constitutive base marked by the arrow. E Stage of expansion of the leaf blade, still without the expanded sheath. F-G. Stage of expansion of the sheath, with free margins; with the upper portion of the sheath delimited by the presence of the region of formation of the future auricle, marked by the arrow. H. Adult leaf, with the presence of the closed sheath and auricles (arrow) Commelina erecta sheath in primordium at the fifth plastochron, undergoing the process of postgenital fusion revealed in serial transverse sections of the stem apical region. A Region of fused margins marked by the arrow. B Region of the sheath with free margins. C–E Transition between free and fused portion of the sheath. F–G. Region with fused margins Gene orthology Candidate C. erecta ortholog of KN1, CeKN1, was isolated using degenerate PCR (Table 1). Alignments of the C. erecta KN1 ortholog with the corresponding sequenced genes (available, respectively, at Online Resources 2 and 3) revealed the presence of conserved regions in all genes, thus indicating the phylogenetic proximity of the obtained sequences with the respective gene families. Phylogenetic likelihood analyses showed that the CeKN1 ortholog is phylogenetically close to the other genes (most significantly KN1) within the KNOX Class 1 family in a selected range of angiosperms (Fig. 3A). In particular, significant sequence conservation is found in KN1 orthologs from the Zingiberales (Musa acuminata and Zingiber officinalis). These findings are in phylogenetic agreement, since Zingiberales is the sister group of Commelinales, which includes C. erecta.Fig. 3Phylogenetic KNOX tree obtained through maximum likelihood analysis of protein sequences obtained from Commelina erecta with the cl osest sequences available. Root positioned in Arabidopsis thaliana KNAT1 Phylogenetic KNOX tree obtained through maximum likelihood analysis of protein sequences obtained from Commelina erecta with the cl osest sequences available. Root positioned in Arabidopsis thaliana KNAT1 In situ hybridization of KN1 homolog in C. erecta Transverse sections of C. erecta do not reveal accumulation of CeKN1 transcripts in the region of the fused margins of the sheath nor in other portions of the leaf primordium. In contrast, CeKN1 expression was detected only in the apical and axillary meristems extending to the first internodes (Fig. 4), but with a clear absence of transcript accumulation in the region of the leaf primordial disc of insertion.Fig. 4In situ hybridization of the KN1 ortholog of C. erecta, observed in transverse sections of the SAM. Region of the fused margins of the sheath marked with an arrow In situ hybridization of the KN1 ortholog of C. erecta, observed in transverse sections of the SAM. Region of the fused margins of the sheath marked with an arrow On the other hand, CeKN1 was expressed along the stem axis as a peripheral ring in the cortex region. This ring can be observed up to the fourth internode region. Right in the region of the leaf insertion disc, this ring is found exactly below the forming larks. CeKN1 is also strongly expressed in the stem pith, in procambium cells. In situ hybridization images also reveal that CeKN1 is also expressed in floral meristems, in addition to being present in the central region of the developing vascular system (Fig. 5).Fig. 5In situ hybridization of the C. erecta KN1 ortholog, observed in transverse serial sections of the inflorescence, revealing the expression of KN1 at the floral meristems and developing vascular system In situ hybridization of the C. erecta KN1 ortholog, observed in transverse serial sections of the inflorescence, revealing the expression of KN1 at the floral meristems and developing vascular system Discussion Leaf sheathes in Commelina erecta develop by postgenital fusion The presence of leaf primordia in which the two margins of the sheath are separated (Fig. 1) indicates a process of postgenital fusion in Commelinaceae. This reveals that there was redifferentiation of the cells in the region where the margins of the sheath overlap into parenchyma cells, which are supported by the presence of histological changes in the epidermal cells at the site of fusion (Fig. 2). The existence of postgenital fusion, therefore, implies the existence of the process of margin separation, which delimit the region of the marginal domain of the leaf. CeKN1 expression delimits vascular and meristematic domains and reveals distinct mechanisms of sheath fusion in Commelina erecta Class 1 KNOX genes accumulate in the SAM, reproductive meristems and non-elongating internodes, but generally not in developing leaf primordia, where they are down-regulated. They are responsible for meristem indeterminacy and maintenance (Tsuda & Hake 2016). In fact, overexpression of these genes in a variety of angiosperm species examined can result in the formation of new adventitious meristems, for example, in tobacco leaves (Srinivasan et al. 2011). In this sense, the absence of ectopic accumulation of CeKN1 in the fused margins of leaf sheaths in C. erecta is expected regarding the usual expression of the KNOX family. Furthermore, the accumulation of KN1 in C. erecta is extremely similar to that obtained in results from members of Poaceae such as Zea mays, occurring in the SAM and growing stem, but absent in leaf primordial founder cells at the SAM periphery (Smith et al. 1992; Jackson et al., 1994). In reproductive stages, ZmKN1 accumulates in floral meristems and in the procambium of developing pedicels. This accumulation pattern, together with the phylogenetic analysis of the probe sequence (Fig. 1), indicate that our CeKN1 gene candidate does indeed comprise a KNOX ortholog. The fact that the CeKN1 ortholog accumulates in the procambium regions can be assessed by comparing the images obtained with the expression already described for the organization of the vascular system in Commelinaceae (Vita et al. 2019). While the peripheral ring of CeKN1 in the cortex region (Fig. 2) corresponds to the region where the stem bundles are formed in the internodal region and the external vascular plexuses in the node region, delimited by the pericycle, the marking of the central portion corresponds to the region of the central bundles. These results indicate that the native accumulation of CeKN1 may be delimiting the regions of the vascular system, which could reveal the role of this gene in the formation of this system. This marked accumulation of CeKN1 transcripts in vascular tissue and its role in the formation of this system are also consistent with the expression pattern of other KNOX family genes, such as STM, KNAT1 and POTH1, which are known to mark procambial regions in several species of monocotyledons and eudicotyledons (Lincoln et al. 1994; Rosin et al. 2003; Tioni et al. 2003). KNOX genes are also known to affect the development of the vascular system, as reported through mutant experiments, such as KN1 in Zea mays (Poaceae) leaves and KNAT1 in Arabidopsis thaliana (Brassicaceae) inflorescences (Veit et al. 1990; Woerlen et al. 2017). Future analyses in other members of Commelinaceae may clarify whether this pattern is conserved for other members of the family, which may bring further insight regarding the role of KNOX genes in vascular development. Considering the association between KNOX gene expression and the vascular system, the presence in C. erecta of a continuous central cylinder of CeKN1 accumulation, with an absence of expression at internal region, is consistent with the interpretations of stele by Tomescu (2021) that argues that, in Tracheophytes, there is a duality in the concept of stele, being defined both by the provascular region by the presence of endoderm, and by the procambium. According to this perspective, even medullary parenchymatic regions present in stems have a vascular origin. Thus, the expression of CeKN1 also corroborates this interpretation of the stele. Although KNOX genes are mostly known to act in meristem indeterminacy, homologues of Class 1 KNOX genes are implicated in sheath development in grasses and can also affect the shape of leaf margins and, in some eudicots, the formation of compound leaves (Satterlee et al. 2020; Hareven et al. 1996; Janssen et al. 1998; Bharathan et al. 2002). For example, in compound leaves of Cardamine hirsuta, KNOX transcripts accumulation occurs in leaf primordia, whereas in Solanum lycopersicum ectopic expression of KNOX genes can lead to the subdivision of super-compound leaflets, determining the formation of simple or compound leaves (Haraven et al. 1996; Hay & Tsiantis 2006). In the current model for sheath development in the Poaceae, it is assumed that KN1 orthologs are correlated with the separation of the lower margins of the sheath, as evidenced by the ectopic expression of KN1 within the fused margins of limbs affected by auxin transport inhibitors (Scanlon 2003). On the other hand, the results of C. erecta show that fused sheaths can develop completely closed even in the absence of KN1 accumulations in the fused region of their margins. Furthermore, the fact that the development of fused sheath margins in this species occurs through postgenital fusion (Fig. 1) reveals the occurrence of its margin separation in C. erecta. Thus, postgenital fusion associated with the absence of KN1 in the sheath indicates a distinct molecular mechanism of fusion in C. erecta from that responsible for the formation of fused sheaths in Zea mays treated under auxin transport inhibition. Instead, postgenital fusions are known to be determined by genes such as CRINKLY4 in Zea mays leaves, and FIDDLEHEAD in the leaves and flowers of Arabidopsis thaliana. These genes are involved in redifferentiation of the epidermis from the fusion regions of developing organs or in changing the permeability of the inter-epidermal contact (Lolle et al. 1998; Sieber et al. 2000; Phillips et al. 2020). However, it is currently unknown which genes are responsible for the postgenital fusion of the leaf sheaths in Commelinaceae. A transcriptome analysis of sheath regions at different stages of fusion may shed light on the mechanisms regulating postgenital fusion in this family. However, the details of how KNOX genes are actually involved in the process of opening the Commelinaceae sheath margins and their relationship with auxins remain open due to the possibility of the action of other members of the gene class other than CeKN1. Furthermore, a comparison of the regulatory systems of KNOX and auxins between Z. mays and S. lycopersicum regarding the formation of leaf margins reveals changes in the regulation between KNOX and auxin signaling proteins, being specific even within clades (Wang et al. 2005; Richardson et al. 2021a), thus indicating the possibility that this relationship is not conserved between Poaceae and Commelinaceae, which belong to distinct orders. Future investigations are needed to clarify exactly how KNOX gene regulation occurs in Commelinaceae. Supplementary Information Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.Supplementary file1 (PDF 1367 KB)Supplementary file2 (XLS 7 KB) Supplementary file1 (PDF 1367 KB) Supplementary file2 (XLS 7 KB)