Academic performance and college students’ subjective well-being Authors: Qianqian Zhai, Qian Li, Shoaib Ahmed Wagan Published: 2026 ABSTRACT Academic performance stands as a pivotal metric for schools in evaluating the proficiency of students, and it serves as a targeted objective for students to strive for. Based on the survey data of 327 undergraduate students, this paper empirically examines the association between college students’ academic performance and their subjective well-being. The results show that the average subjective well-being of college students is situated in the lower mid-range, with an observable tendency toward decline over time. The subjective well-being of college students is associated with both their absolute and relative grade point average (GPA). Specifically, the higher the GPA, the stronger students’ subjective well-being. However, students’ subjective well-being will be significantly reduced if their GPA is ranked lower. The association between academic performance and college students’ subjective well-being exhibits heterogeneity across gender, grade and place of origin. Specifically, the association between academic performance and subjective well-being is more pronounced among females and low-grade students than that of males and high-grade students, but dose not significantly differ by place of origin. We additionally find several other factors that affect students’ subjective well-being: joining school clubs, liking their majors, being extroverted and maintaining good health also significantly improves students’ subjective well-being. Given the cross-sectional design and single-institution sample, these findings should be interpreted as associational rather than causal. Introduction Within educational frameworks, fostering students’ subjective well-being is a paramount objective, complementing traditional goals centered on academic learning (1). Students’ subjective well-being has recently emerged as a critical issue due to its wide-reaching benefits for better performance in school and later as adults (2). However, our survey conducted in this research reveals that the overall level of subjective well-being among Chinese college students is suboptimal, situated in the lower middle tier, which is consistent with the survey results of German middle school students (3). In general, students in China outperformed in their subjects but suffered from a low level of well-being (4, 5). An expanding corpus of research indicates a downward trend in subjective well-being and a concurrent rise in mental health issues among the youth in recent decades (6), especially after the COVID-19 pandemic (7). The subjective well-being of students serves as the cornerstone for their learning and holistic development. Those with diminished subjective well-being are more susceptible to psychological maladies, including anxiety, boredom and depression (8–10). Therefore, it is of great practical significance to improve college students’ subjective well-being. The key to improving college students’ subjective well-being lies in identifying its determinants. Subjective well-being is intricately tied to an individual’s living environment. School is the context in which children and adolescents pass almost one-third of their waking time, and it is the primary setting of social and emotional experiences as well as exposure to adverse events such as struggles with learning, peer rejection, bullying, and poor relationships with teachers (1, 11). As a consequence, schools play a privileged role in influencing their overall well-being (12). For college students, school remains the main context of life and learning, with learning being their principal endeavor. It follows that academic performance is inextricably linked to subjective well-being. Academic performance is an important reference index for college students indicated by awards, success in taking the postgraduate entrance examination to ensure postgraduate education, and study abroad, and it determines their future academic trajectories and employment (13). Research on middle school students has consistently shown that academic performance can significantly affect their subjective well-being (11, 14, 15). However, the academic content, competitive pressure, and living environment differ markedly between college and middle school students, particularly since the outbreak of COVID-19 pandemic and its profound impact on educational systems. The extent to which academic performance is related to college students’ subjective well-being remains to be further studied. A further gap in the literature concerns how academic performance is conceptualized. Most existing studies treat academic performance as an absolute metric, typically measured by GPA. However, in competitive educational environments, students do not evaluate their performance in isolation. Few studies have distinguished between absolute and relative academic performance when examining their associations with subjective well-being, leaving the independent role of class ranking largely unexplored. Another notable limitation of existing research is the lack of systematic heterogeneity analysis. The association between academic performance and subjective well-being may not be uniform across student subgroups. Factors such as gender, grade level, and place of origin could moderate this relationship, yet prior studies have often treated student populations as homogeneous. Understanding these subgroup differences is crucial for designing targeted mental health interventions. Moreover, as recent research on Chinese university students has emphasized, studies should move beyond a single GPA-well-being association and consider a more ecological context that includes learning motivation, time management, classroom participation, self-regulation, institutional support, family background, and peer influence (16). This broader perspective helps identify which student subgroups are most vulnerable to performance-related distress and informs the design of more effective, context-sensitive interventions. Thus, this study intends to take college students as the research object to explore the association between academic performance and their subjective well-being. The possible innovations of this study lie in the following. First, while existing research has largely focused on middle school students, we examine college students – a population whose academic environment, competitive pressures, and living context differ markedly from younger students. Second, beyond confirming the positive association between absolute academic performance (GPA) and well-being, we explicitly distinguish relative performance (GPA ranking) and demonstrate that ranking exerts an independent effect on well-being beyond raw GPA. Third, we systematically examine heterogeneity across gender, grade level, and place of origin, revealing that the well-being of female, lower-grade, and urban-origin students is more sensitive to academic performance. Fourth, our data were collected in October 2022, a period when COVID-19 restrictions were still actively shaping Chinese university life, providing a timely snapshot of student well-being under unique stressors. Literature review Subjective well-being encompasses a spectrum of pleasurable emotions that individuals experience, stemming from their perceptions of contentment and security. A multitude of factors impinge upon subjective well-being, with health widely acknowledged as the predominant influence (17–19). In addition, previous studies have also pointed out that exercise (20), digital disability (21) and information involvement (22) also significantly affect individuals’ subjective well-being. These studies mainly focus on adults or employees. In recent years, students’ subjective well-being has attracted the attention of scholars. Students’ subjective well-being is classified into six dimensions: academic, psychological, self, physical, social and spiritual (4). Some scholars have designed an indicator system to measure students’ subjective well-being and analyzed the current situation and trends (1, 11, 23). Others have delved into the effects of various factors on students’ subjective well-being, including information processing style (24), school alienation (12), study major (25), mindfulness training (26), mathematics performance (27), physical activity (28), concerts (14) and family capital (29). However, the research mainly focuses on middle school students or primary school students, with relatively little attention paid to college students. In terms of the relationship between academic performance and students’ subjective well-being, most studies have reported a positive association. For example, Morinaj and Hascher’s (12) longitudinal study of secondarly school students found that academic performance positively predicted subjective well-being over a one-year interval. Wu et al. (30) examined bidirectional relationships among Chinese middle school students and found that both present- and future-oriented subjective well-being were associated with later academic performance. However, these findings should be interpreted with caution due to several contextual factors. First, most of these studies focused on middle school or primary school students, whose academic environment, competitive pressure, and developmental stage differ substantially from college students. Second, the measures of subjective well-being varied across studies, ranging from single-item self-reports to multi-dimensional scales, which may affect the observed strength of associations. Third, the majority of existing research employed cross-sectional designs, which cannot establish temporal order or rule out reverse causality – it is equally plausible that students with higher subjective well-being perform better academically rather than the reverse. Notably, a few studies have found no stable correlation between academic performance and students’ subjective well-being (31, 32). This inconsistency may reflect differences in sample characteristics: studies reporting null findings often involved college students or used different subjective well-being measures, whereas positive associations were more consistently found in younger populations. For instance, research on medical students has produced mixed results. Hagemeier et al. (33) found that medical students’ subjective well-being was negatively associated with the number of weekly examinations but positively associated with fall semester GPA. Monrad et al. (8) examined medical students and found that those with poorer well-being had lower Step 1 examination scores; however, after adjusting for Medical College Admission Test scores and cumulative GPA, the association was no longer significant. This suggests that academic aptitude and prior performance may confound the relationship between well-being and high-stakes exam outcomes, highlighting the importance of controlling for baseline academic ability – a consideration often overlooked in studies on this topic. Taken together, the existing literature has three major limitations that motivate the present study. First, the evidence base is heavily skewed toward middle school and primary school populations, with limited research on college students despite their distinct academic and developmental contexts. Second, few studies have distinguished between absolute academic performance (GPA) and relative performance (GPA ranking), leaving the independent role of social comparison largely unexplored. Third, systematic heterogeneity analyses across gender, grade level, and place of origin are lacking, which is particularly important given that the association between academic performance and well-being may vary across student subgroups. The present study addresses these gaps by focusing on college students, distinguishing absolute from relative performance, and examining heterogeneity across key demographic dimensions. Conceptual framework Subjective well-being refers to individuals’ cognitive and affective evaluations of their lives, encompassing life satisfaction (34). In the context of higher education, understanding the determinants of college students’ subjective well-being is of paramount importance, as it is closely linked to their academic engagement, mental health, and long-term development (1, 2). Among the various factors that shape students’ subjective well-being, academic performance stands out as a particularly salient one, given the central role that academic achievement plays in the educational system, especially in China. Several theoretical perspectives help explain why academic performance may exert a significant influence on college students’ subjective well-being. We focus on two complementary frameworks. First, Self-Determination Theory (SDT) (35) provides a well-established lens for understanding how absolute academic performance (GPA) may relate to well-being. SDT posits that the satisfaction of three basic psychological needs – autonomy, competence, and relatedness – is essential for intrinsic motivation and psychological wellness. In the academic context, high GPA can be interpreted as a marker of competence, one of the core needs in SDT. When students perceive that they are academically competent, their sense of mastery and effectiveness is enhanced, which in turn fosters greater well-being. Conversely, persistent academic difficulties may frustrate the need for competence, leading to diminished well-being (36). SDT has been extensively validated across educational settings and offers a parsimonious, empirically grounded explanation for the link between academic performance and well-being. Second, Social Comparison Theory (37) explains why relative academic performance (GPA ranking) may be associated with well-being independently of absolute GPA. This theory suggests that individuals evaluate their own abilities and opinions by comparing themselves with others. In academic settings, students frequently engage in upward or downward comparisons with their peers regarding grades and rankings. Students with favorable class rankings may experience greater self-esteem and positive affect, while those with lower relative performance may suffer from feelings of inadequacy, anxiety, and diminished well-being. This comparative process is particularly pronounced in competitive educational environments, where academic standing is highly visible and socially consequential (38, 39). Notably, lower academic ranking may evoke not only social comparison effects but also shame, threats to perceived competence, and fear of negative evaluation from parents, teachers, and peers (40). Conversely, psychological resources such as self-compassion may help students process academic setbacks without an excessively sharp decline in well-being, a perspective that enriches the theoretical understanding of why some students are more resilient to low relative standing than others. In addition to these two primary frameworks, we acknowledge Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Theory (41) as a broader motivational backdrop: academic performance can fulfill esteem and self-actualization needs, which may contribute to well-being (42, 43). However, SDT and Social Comparison Theory provide more direct and empirically testable mechanisms for the specific associations examined in this study. We also acknowledge the Mindsponge Theory (44) as a complementary lens that emphasizes how individuals selectively absorb and process external information – such as academic feedback, parental expectations, and peer performance – within their sociocultural contexts. According to this theory, positive academic outcomes are more likely to be internalized as affirming one’s self-concept when they are perceived as beneficial or aligned with existing value systems, thereby enhancing well-being. Conversely, poor academic performance may be filtered as a threat to self-identity, leading to psychological distress (45, 46). However, we recognize that Mindsponge Theory is relatively recent and has not yet accumulated extensive independent empirical validation in the field of public health. Therefore, we use it here primarily as an illustrative framework to contextualize our findings within the broader information-processing perspective, rather than as a load-bearing theoretical pillar. Future research may further test its applicability in educational well-being studies. In the Chinese context, the emphasis on academic performance is deeply embedded in the cultural and institutional fabric. Confucian heritage places a strong emphasis on educational achievement as a means of social mobility and family honor (29). Parents, teachers, and society at large often view academic success as a primary indicator of a student’s potential and worth. Consequently, students may internalize these external expectations, making their academic performance a critical determinant of their self-esteem and emotional well-being. Moreover, the highly competitive nature of the education system, exacerbated by the phenomenon of “involution” (neijuan) – a situation where excessive competition leads to diminishing returns – intensifies the psychological stakes associated with academic performance (47, 48). Based on the above theoretical frameworks, we posit that both absolute and relative academic performance matter for college students’ subjective well-being. Absolute performance, as measured by GPA, reflects an individual’s objective level of achievement, which directly contributes to feelings of competence and self-worth. Relative performance, as captured by class rank, operates through social comparison mechanisms and may have an independent effect on well-being, particularly in competitive academic environments (consistent with Social Comparison Theory). Thus, we propose the following hypotheses: Hypothesis 1: College students’ academic performance (GPA) is positively associated with their subjective well-being. The higher the GPA, the stronger the subjective well-being. Hypothesis 2: College students’ relative academic performance (class ranking) is associated with their subjective well-being. Specifically, students with lower class rankings tend to report lower subjective well-being compared to those with higher rankings. Methodology Data The data used in this study come from the survey conducted by the research team in October 2022 with undergraduates at Beijing Technology and Business University. The questionnaire content included three parts: students’ basic characteristics, academic performance and individual cognition. We first designed a questionnaire around the research topic and conducted a preliminary survey at Beijing Technology and Business University. Based on the feedback from the survey, we revised and improved the questionnaire. After the formal questionnaire was designed, an electronic link was generated using the QuestionStar platform (a professional company that conducts online survey) and distributed through course group chats, WeChat Moments, and similar channels, encouraging current undergraduates of Beijing Technology and Business University to voluntarily and without compensation complete the survey. A total of 422 responses were collected through this online survey. For the purposes of this study, after excluding observations with missing data on key variables (i.e., the variables selected for the model) and invalid responses (e.g., implausible values such as age greater than 50 or negative GPA), 398 valid responses were retained, yielding a valid response rate of 94.3%. Since freshmen have no GPA, 71 freshman observations were excluded from the empirical analysis, resulting in a final analytical sample of 327 students. As shown in Figure 1, among these 327 students, sophomores, juniors, and seniors accounted for 48.62, 28.44, and 22.94%, respectively. In terms of academic fields, 58.41% were from the humanities and social sciences, and 41.59% were from the natural sciences. Additional sample characteristics are presented in Table 1. Sample selection. Table 1Variable definition and descriptive statistics.Variable namesVariable definitionMinMaxMeanDependent variable Subjective well-beingSelf-rated subjective well-being (1–10 points)1106.875Independent variable of interest Academic performanceGPA of last academic year1.504.323.402Control variables GradeSophomore = 1, junior = 2, senior = 3131.743 AgeAge of college students (years)182620.177 GenderMale = 1, female = 0010.401 Major typeMajor in social science = 1, major in science and engineering = 0010.584 PostClass-cadre = 1, not class-cadre = 0010.462 Place of originUrban = 1, rural = 0010.636 Family incomeFrom extremely low to extremely high, assign values 1–5 in turn152.899 Living expenses1,000 yuan/month or below = 1, (1,000, 1,500 yuan/month) = 2, (1,500, 2000 yuan/month) = 3, (2000, 2,500 yuan/month) = 4, Above 2,500 yuan/month = 5152.963 School club membershipNumber of school clubs joined051.101 Major preferenceFrom extremely unlike to extremely like, assign values 1–5 in turn153.459 Academic pressureFrom extremely low to extremely high, assign values 1–5 in turn153.431 PersonalityFrom extremely introversion to extremely extroversion, assign values 1–5 in turn153.080 HealthSelf-rated physical health (1–10 points)1106.954 Variable definition and descriptive statistics. Variables The dependent variable is college students’ subjective well-being. Although single-item measures cannot fully capture the multi-dimensional nature of subjective well-being, they have been widely used in large-scale educational surveys and researches. With references to previous researches (49–51), during the survey, students were asked to score their own subjective well-being, with values ranging from 1 to 10 as integers. The survey results showed that the average score of college students’ subjective well-being is 6.875, and the overall level of subjective well-being was not high. As shown in Figure 2, a total of 35.78% of the participants had a low level of subjective well-being, scoring less than or equal to 6 points. Only 37.61% of college students had a subjective well-being score of more than or equal to 8 points. In terms of grades, the sophomore students’ subjective well-being was the strongest, with an average score of 7.019. The junior and senior students’ subjective well-being was similar, with average scores of 6.667 and 6.827, respectively. In terms of gender, the average subjective well-being score of females was 6.934, higher than that of males (6.786), indicating that females had stronger subjective well-being than males, which is consistent with the findings of Raccanello et al. (1). Students’ subjective well-being. The independent variable of interest is college students’ academic performance. College students’ academic performance was measured by their GPA for the previous academic year, which is highly objective and representative. During the survey, students were asked to fill in the GPA of the previous academic year truthfully, and the value range was 0 ~ 5. While GPA was self-reported, students were assured of complete anonymity and were not required to provide identifying information, which encourages truthful responses. The survey results showed that the average GPA of participants was 3.402, which is above average (Figure 3) and closely related to the current “involution” social environment. The maximum GPA of college students is 4.32, the minimum is 1.50, and a few students failed in the exam. Kernel density estimation of students’ academic performance. With reference to existing studies (29, 52–54), variables such as participants’ year in school, age, gender, major, post, place of origin, family income, monthly living expenses, club participation in school, academic pressure, personality and health were also introduced to control the impact of other potential factors on their subjective well-being. See Table 1 for details of each variable. Model Since the subjective well-being of college students is assigned an integer of 1 ~ 10 from low to high, which belongs to an ordered variable, an ordered probit model (hereinafter referred to as Oprobit) is built. With reference to Wooldridge (55), the specific form of the model is as follows: In Equation 1, SWBi∗ represents the latent variable of college students’ subjective well-being, and Performancei represents college students’ academic performance in the last academic year. Controli represents a series of control variables that may affect students’ subjective well-being. α , β1 and φ represent the parameters to be estimated. εi represents the residual disturbance term and is assumed to follow the standard normal distribution. The relationship between the observed value SWBi and its latent variable SWBi∗ is as follows: In Equation 2, SWBi represents college students’ subjective well-being. C1 ~ C9 indicate cut points. When SWBi∗